The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About007-080-010r I I L I I I, L r ' r r r I I II r r' : I I ' I ' I ! , i I I I I ' I I _ r I I I_ r _ I r I I r , ' , I I , : r 1. r _. ..:. .....- : .. �.. u -LINDA S0 SA 06n3n� 1 ... .. ., _ � 0 07_ OS U 010... 1 A _ CE VARIANCE . I r f x . P 4,. I , : i I I y rN 1 1 , r l i r I r I ` r I r _ I i I I 'r r Ir: I w I r , r_ _I .,tk- r = LINDA.A. SOUSA 93-06 � - x- AP-0007-080-010 VARIANCE x _ - I r =+ Col t, Lunda A. Souza (Item determined to be categorically exempt from environmental review) Variance to the front yard setback to allow a garage 42 fest from road centerline on property zoned R-1 (Residential) located on the north side of El Paso roximatel 170 feet west of White Avenue at 2422 Et Paso Way, identified Way, 00 -080-010, Chea (SMH) The Commission waived the reading of the Staff Report. A video of the site was shown. Steve Hackney gave a .brief summary of the project. He saidthe applicant was informed at the final inspection the the variance would be required. hie said the County has to take some responsibility for not catching the violation at the foundation inspection time. Fla said there are physical constraints on the property limiting the placement of the garage. V Chairman Lambert stated that other garages and carports in the neighborhood do .not encroach into the setback. Commissioner Bergman asked if the garage Was built with building permits? Mr. Hackney said yes., Commissioner Lynch asked what part did the County play in the error? Mr. Hackney . -iid on Mrs. Souza's original map it indit ated a 50 ft.` setback ands the Building Department stamped the plan as requiring a 50 ft, setback. Commissioner Lynch asked if Mrs. Souza moved the garage into the setback and was not tagged' by Builoing? Mr. Hackney said this is correct. The hearing was opened to the public. Unda Souza submitted before and after pictures of the property. She said the violation was not caughf, until the final building inspection. She said tho 'kitchen was extended 8 ft. and this made the garage 8 ft into the setback area. f.; �� kiC7' TE: o i1�ING; ciarirfx5sro M� 1UTE5 L ''BR�iAiX 24y i 04 I X^iyM1yY/q MI 'i The hearing was closed. Commissioner Bergman said there was a 5 ft:. error in the width of the street to start with and a 3 . error on the property. He was in favor of granting this variance. ft rop�y Chairman Lambert was concerned with setting a precedence where there are no other encroachments in the neighborhood. She said the problem is the garage is already built. She said the Commission needs to discuss finding a solution for structures that are already built and how to abate the 'problem. Commissioner Lynch said the applicant submitted building plans and obtained building permits. He said one problem was the lack of information to the Building Department from the applicant that the plot plan was changed. Staff said the dimensions remained the same, that the error was in the setbacks, not the size of the garage. ;Commissioner Lynch said the applicant did move the structure on -,site diffet,ent from the plans spbmitted to the Building Department. He said where the setback was, not checked at the time the foundation was put in, he would vote in favor of the variance. He was concerned, however, with the intent, to build the garage other than how it was shown on the plans. It wasmoved by Commission Nelson, seconded by Commissioner Ferguson, and .; unanimously carried for approval,so, follows; A. Find that the proposed project is categorically exempt from provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act in accordance with Section 15305, Class 5 (a) of the California Public Resources Code; and B. Find that the strict application of thischapter (Government Code 65905 and 65906) deprives the property of privileges enjoyed by other property in the vicinity and under identical zoning classification because zoning allows for this use, does not create a health or safety problem; and other properties in the neighborhood have garages; and C. ,Approve the proposed Variance to allow the existing garage to remain on AP 007- 080-010 (Linda Souza). _ 'T'X P�.ANNZMG COMMISSAN hi�NUTES PEERt1ARX 7�4, 1994 r U rig ur. FILE NO.: 007-080-010 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING (�O ISSION STAFF FINDINGS - December 16, 1993 Linda Sousa APPLICANT: Gary G. Kerch O'VNER: Variance to the front yard setback to allow a REQUEST: from road center line 2 garage 42 feet2 feet from curb). 007-080-010 AP NO.: 0.19 ac SIZE: On the north side of El ]Paso Way, LOCATION: approximately 1701 west of White Avenue at 2422 El Paso Way, Chico. R-1 EXISTING ZONING: Zoned R-1 on April 5, 1985 by Ordinance ZONING HISTORY: #2474. SURROUNDING ZONING: silgtle axnily dwelling SURROUNDING LAND USE: Residential' GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION'. Low Density Residential California Government Code Sections code APPLICABLE REGULATION 65905 and 65906. Butte county through 24-52, 24- Sections 24-49 130 and 24-21.454. COMMENTS RECEIVED: Can meet this Department � s 'PublicWo3 : The project as proposed requirements- No Environmental_Healthx No requirements for this project. i Count Fire pe artment[CDFa tl°Pio Farre Dept. Objections." g1tof Chico: o°N0 Comment. °B Video recording taken of the sate. This is a request for a variance to allow a garaghewhi ih as 50 een built and encroaches into the front yard setback. e addition encroaches into requirement from road center line. eav g an existing setback of 1.2 feet this setback by eight (8) feet, from property fine. Commission must,.: a variance request., .the. P1ax�ni.rig 1en considering node deprives the determine 'whether strict applscataon of the zoning ro erties in the Of prvi�ges enjoyed by surrounding properties property classification. variance from the vicinity and under identical zoning abecause of terms of the zoning ordinance should be granted only including size, shape, special circumstances applicable i the propertyis discriminated State.. rah location or surroundings, the property topog p y► against by a given requirement of t n e lshall� be In subject� to such g variance g authorized will 'Law r,equi.res that anyent t with conditions as will assuretin thatthe tspec ial spriv privileges inwhichwhich not constitute a gran in the vicinity and z limitations upon other properties such property is situated. iv:Lsion with parcels of comparable The project site is located in a subd� on L that ear to have been Sl This is an older subdi owner f�thismprop er y has Substatil Y built 80-x40 years ago. The additions, and landscaping. improved this structure with hremodeling,sal (approximately 600 square feet The original structure was much smaller. attempted to P carpor t) . The present structure shows the vementsowner s A number o upgrade his house with internal/external �apar�e or carport. Because other houses on this street have either ► garage location of the garage most of the houses are these hamesfareentical dclocated where �siqnPthe subject property s new for many of arages outside the required kitchen is located• This places their g' setback° lied for a building permit to adO/remodel a in 1989, the owner app the .owner '' chen and add a garage to the structure. Due t kitchen Gatio�a air a kit oak tree directly behind the (new) The permit was large valley garage in trie front of the house. constructed the g lot plan indicated granted based upon theerrplotlepof the street to the front of the arage. a 50 ° setback from cen. ° depth. The BuildingDepartment it also showed the lot to be 134 the lot to be 122.5° in depth. The corrected this figure, indicating Department also indicated, by stamps on the plot plan, that a 501 setback from centerline of street was required. The owner proceedeLi to build the additions', including the garage. The result was the garage now encroaches eight (8) feet into the 500 setback. This addition passed inspections. Apparently the Building inspector was not aware that the foundation for the garage encroached into the 501 setback, The project was completed in 1992. The dilemma is that the subject property does not meet the physical criteria for special circumstances (size, shape, topography, location or surroundings) as given in California Government Code section 65906 allowing for a variance, yet the garage has been constructed after the applicant followed county building permit procedures and had his structure pass a number of inspections. The question as what are the proper findings to make in order, to determine the appropriate staff recommendation? section 65906 also says that any variance granted "shall not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the . . zone in which such property is si.tuated.B1 Also, this section states "A variance shall not be granted for a parcel of property which authorizesa use or activity which is not otherwise expressly authorized by the zone regulation governing the parcel of property."Granting a variance for this structure would not be giving the owner special privileges inconsistent with the zone or allowing the owner a privilege denied to his neighbors, in as much as other houses on the street have garages, and the zone allows for garages. I The purpose of a setback is to provide for the health and safety of the citizens. The existence of the garage does not appear to impede access 'or emergency services, obstruct pedestrian or bicycle traffic, or interfere with street traffic in any way. An automobile can be parked in the driveway and still leave room for public passage on the right-of-way. El Paso Way serves 16 residences from East Avenue to White Avenue. There is limited traffic on this street. The general appearance of the neighborhood is enhanced with 'this newer structure ( including landscaping) . Denial ' of the request for a variance will require removal of the garage. _ qu front 8 feet An alternative would he to require removal of the of the garage, leaving a 16 x'24 foot structure. However, this would leave the owner with a stiiucture which would not serve the purposes of a garage, that is, parking a standard size vehicle inside. Granting -the variance foe:° the garage would allow the applicant to enjoy the same use of'his property as enjoyed by other homeowners in the neighborhood. The proposed project is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act in accordance with Section 153051 Class 5(a) of the California Public resources Codec ti fK9 plahnls Department n PLIi,'�1 FVARIANCE,MSR 0 2 1993 , BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION Orowille, Cejifornle APPLICANT Read and follow instructions as set forth on attached,; sheet. 15 PP, one No. +�'r Applicant`s Name — _ p� Applicant's' Mailing Address, � � el -11 CG evt Applicant's Interest in property (Owner, lessee, other) -- Owner's Name and Address Contact Person for Project (if other than applicant) r Y Assessor's Parcel Number(s)oA /0 Present zoning "'. � Location and size of parcel(s).y,_�2 ` A/" llq Street address Directions fur travel to property (rural smd mountainous areas only) ..J _j Type of variance requested:, Lot area or building site Mobll� home size U. Lot width Parking requirements Front yard setbackLivestock requirements Side or rear yard setback y Sign requirements Other (specify) Oct D cri' ti n of proposed use and re• dons for variance°because of special circumstances (refer to Instruction No. 6 on attached sheet) CL 64 Description of existing land use , /dye'7L Existing/proposed sewage disposal method'— Proximity of ethod: Proximity -of pov t sndphone lines:' Water source: Proximity of water for fire fighting purposes (hydrants, ponds, etc,)— WI I I tc,)Will excavation or grading.be necessary? Cubic yards (estimate) List and describe any other related permits and other pcl appr,)vals required for this project, including those required by city, regional, State and Federal agenciesL is n$ M1i yuyµy:.' ° h IS aR�t'i'piGW �,.14.A •��1 PI n The following questions pertain only, to variances to the minimum parcel size required within the zoning district; IV1%fRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURCiS* (da�Wfy potentially significant environmental impacts associated with the variance. What project design features or s eolal` �:It.�w a p 1 P conditions of approval (mitigation measures) are proposed to alleviate potential environmental Impacts? ENVI90NMENTAL SETTING* Describe the project site as it exists before the project; including Information on topography, soil stability, plants and animals, and any cultural, historical or scenic _aspects, Describe any existing structures on the site, and the use of the -� structures: Describe the surrounding properties, including information on plants and animals and any cultural, historlcal or scenic aspects. Indicate the type of land use (residential, commercial, etc.), intensity of land use (single-family,apartments, shops, depart- h ment stores, etc.), and scale of development (height, frontage; setbaok, rear yard, etc.). 2, * Use separate sheet for longer responses., G La. Ce.. hereby declare under penalty of perjury that i have read and understand the instructions d that a foregoing statements are true, complptV andjorrect to the best of my knowledge and bel lef. Date °� /-� Applicant's signature rt 1 Date�� / C[,_ Property owner's signature Varlance number RequGs arlance to Location and size of parcel(s): located on, the., VERIFY A.P. t4umber(s) Zoning and Requirements ✓ Ownership Location Description Proof of Agency(if needed) cdples of Plot Plan 5S UJ Date Received �� $ i �� Receipt Number A-7 Application Taken By__�N _W Gi U U- C:) I IMST UCTIONS TO VARIANCE APPLICANTS 1. if applicant is plot` the owner, written authorization by theowneror other- proof of agency must be sub- mitted in order for tete applicant to legally sign the application. Application shall be corisidered void if not signed by the r• .ler or legal agent. 2. All items on application shall be filledin as completely as possible. If an item is' not applicable, please indicate by the term '"NA" 3. It is'lmportant that the applicant supply an accurate description of the location of the proposed project, including the following: a. Assessor's parcel number(s) (from the tax bills or Assessor's Maps). b. Street addresses (if available). C. Distances and directions to named streets, bodies of water or railroads, 4. Twenty (20) copies of a detailed plot plati of adequate scale to clearly show proposed buildings and i iprovements, folds «d to 81/2 x 11 inches, shall accompany and be made part of the "Application for Vari- ance". The plot plan snail include the -following information; a; A scaled drawing of the parcei(s) boundaries. b. Location and; dimensions of all existing and proposed improvements on the property, includ- ing buildings, driveways, parking areas, wells, septic tanks arid leach fields, C. Location and name of bordering streets, access roads, nearby crossroads, streams, bodies of water and railroads. d. North arrow and scale of drawing. S. The "Application foi riance" is subject to public hearings and approval by the Planning Commission. Any special conditions of approval shall be made a part of the approved "Variance" and shall be binding on the applicant. The procedures for County action on variance applications are stated in Chapter 24 of the Butte County Code: ti. VARIANCES from the terms of the zoning ordinance shall be granted only when, because of special circuWi,olces applicable to the property, including size, shape, topography, location or surroundings, the strict aprilea•tion of the zoning ordinance deprives such property of privileges enjoyed by other property in the virinity and under identical zoning classification. Any variance granted shall be subject to surh conditions as will assure that the adjustment thereby auth- orized shall not constitute a grant of ,pecial privileges inconsistent with the limitations upon other pro parties in the vicinity and zone in v)hioh such property is situated. Any such condition imposed upon Issuance of a variance must be, related to the use of the property for which the variance is requested. A variance shall not be granted for a parcel of property which authorizes a use or activity which Is not otherwise expressly authorized by the zone regulation governing the parcel of property. 7. Application fees as of_� � J9'Z-� ., �: I ,_.:. (date) are st(92�Z ,tees maybe paid In cash or by check made payable to "Treasurer of Butte County". ) B. Elefore submitting a variance application, applicant is requested to discuss with staff all questions about application requirements, County procedures, zoning provisions and "special circumstances". t4fC F , 12 va MMI. IGS 01 FACT Each zoning classification and laird use has an associated set of development standards which are specifiad io the Butte County Code. The Co4G also estab- lishes a procedure to grant variances from these standards whP.re unique circumstances exist to warrant relief from the strict application of these standards. A vari.arxce can ,be granted only U specific findings are made to indicate that unique circumstances do, in fact, exist. These specials ircumstances may include factors such a5 the size, shape, topography, location and surroundings of a piece if property. The courts have clearly indicated that variances are not intended to rewrite the County. Code and can only be granted if all the findings listed below are made. Further, the courts have indicated the actual, factual basis for these :'findings must be stated. NOTE TO APPLICANT. Please do NOT apply for a variance unless you can provide the necessary factual basis to 'grant the requested variance, .All necessary application fees are non- refundable. FINDINGS 1. The following exceptional or e4traord nary circumstances or conditions apply to the land, building or use in question which do not apply generally to other land, buildings or uses in the same district. ab Nor P&.elva- 2. The factg �that the granting of the variance is necessary for the preservation and enjoyment p ent of substantial ,:o ert rights is supported bythe following: r !lw C 6 �Z -, E,=C- 51VM 7Z A) 7- K /171*1 4r19R_ `16 I 3. The fact that the granting of the variance will not adversely affect the neighborhood or be detrimental to the, public health, safety or welfare or adversely affect proprrty or imr; r;ovAme•its in -he neighborhood is supported by the following, 154-4 CAS 9, � AN 6 6CL a 7" rE, y ALL OF THE ABOVE FINDINGS: MUST BE ISE, INCLUDING THE ST,ATMENT OF SPECIFIC FACM TO GRANT_A VOIANCE. 7777 452 EAST 8TH 'AVE �r `7 45Z Jr, b'1"li AVli:. d� �aH�ICO` CA 9592b CI1 TC0 , . CSA , 9S9`2fo L : 007 080 021 OpJ 5TAT6 IS :` A`CT I VE, L: 007 '.0130 007 000 STATUS: ACTIVE DIETER MELVIN L R� CLgRE 5. HEYL RAYMOND J & VERA L ^415 EL PASO WAY 58L9 WHITE AVE CHICO CA 95926 CHICO CA 95926 L: 007 080 022`000 STATUS: ACTTVC L:; 007 "0130 008.000 STATUS: ACTIVE ALVIS ELLIS M & LAURETA ENRIQUEZ CORNELIO P & TON! L (CB DVA) 578 WHITE AVE 2404 EL PASO 'WAY CHICO CA 95926 CHICO CA 95926 L: 007 080 052 000 STATUS: )CTIVE Lc 007 080 009 Opp STATUS: ACTIVE KOCH VERLE W & JUDY SALAS JORGE & JENNIFER DOYLE WARREN t 585 WHITE AVE 2414 EL PASO WAY CHICO CA 95926 CHICO CA 95926 L: 007 080 053 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 010.000 STATUS. ACTIVE TRABULUS 'NORMAN SS KERCH GARY GLENN ETAL 589 WHITE AVE 452 EAST 8TH AVE CHICO CA 95926 CHICO CA 959R6 L: 007 080 058-000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 011'000 STATUS: ACTIVE GREGORY ROBERT J & AGNES J SISAY FATU Y;' 581 WHITE AVE 2430 EL PASO WAY CHICO CA 95926 CHICO, CA 95926 L: 007 080 061 000 STATUS:"ACTIVE L: 007 080 012 000 STATUS: ACTIVE CARLILE MARY H BLAKE CURT I S F 8 1:+JR I EL; R 565 EAST AVE 918 PRIMROSE AVENUE CHICO CA 95926 SUNNYVALE CA 94086 L: 007 OBO 062 000' STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 013 000 STATUS: ACTIVE KINSLOW MICHAEL V STICKEL SUSAN YVONNE P 0 BOX 3884 RT' 2 BOX 234' CHICO CA '95927` CHICO CA 95926- L: 007 080 063 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080„ 015 000 F" `1: ACTIVE MULLIN JUANITA DAVERN GERALD, P '& LOIS RT 2 BOX 2418 1030 EATON RD ORLAND CA 95963 CHICO CA 95926 L: 007 080 064 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L 007,080 016 000 STATUS: ACTIVE WILKINSON LESLIE E & BEULAH M JT EVANS DEAN F & SUSAN A P 0 BOX 1328 2451 EL PA801WAY CHICO CA 95927 CHICO CA 95956 L: 007 080 065 000 STATUS: ACTIVE ' L: 007 080 017 000 STATUS: ACTIVE WILKINSON LESLIE E & BEULAH M TAMIETTI,PAUL D & DONNA C' P O BOX 1828 2445 EL PASO WAY CHICO CA 95987 CHICO CA 95926 L9' 007080 066 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 0118 000 STATUS: ACTIVE JAC088 DOUGLAS B & STEPHANIE A BERTONI FISHER CAROLYN 593 Er3T AVE 2437 EL PASO'' CHICO CA 95926 CH`IC0 CA 95926 Ll: 007 080 067,000 STATUS- ,ACTIVE L: 007 080 019 000' STATUS: ACTIVE KOCH GEORGE E & GWENDOLYN HERON BILLY R'& BARBARA JACKSON TR, HERON FAMILY TRUST $99 EAST AVE 9 DANA POINT ROAD CHICO CA 95926 CHICO CA 95988 L: 007 080 068 000 STATUS: ACTIVE Lt 007 080 020 000 STATUS: ACTIVE MALMQUIST JOHN W & VIRGINIA REV MFMT TR GRIFFIN ARNOLD R & VIVIAN MALMQUIST JOHN W & VIRGINIA TRU51*EE5 834 W 12TH AVE 2483 5L,PASO ,<rJAY CHICO CA 95926 CHICO CA 515926 I ifll'JVi J4 .l It) t,lvl!ll " IERCH GARY GLENN ETAL LINDA A.. SOU 8A 458 EAST 8TH AVE. 452. 8TH AUS. C CHICO' CA 9592.6 { CICO CA. 95926 , y L. 007 080 021 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007'08(0 007 000 STATUS: ACTIVE DIETER MELVIN'L & CLARE S` HFYL RAYMOND J & VERA L 588 WHITE AVE 2415 EL PASO WAY CHICO CA 95926 ' CHICO CA 5'5926 L: 1007 080 022 000 STATUSt ACTIVE L: 007''080 008 000 STATUS: ACTIVE ALVIS ELLIS Ih & LAURETA ENRIQUE2 CORNELIO P & TONI L (CIS DVA) 578 WHITE AVE 2404 EL PASO WAY CHICO CA 75926 CHICO "A 90926 L: 007 080 052 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 009 000 STATUS: ACTIVE KOCH 'jERLE W & JUDY„ SALAS JORGE & JENNIFER D,OYLE OARREN Q 585 WHITE AVE 2414 EL PASO WAY CHICO CA 95926 CHICO CA 95926 L: 007 080 053 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 A10 000 STATUS: ACTIVE TRA8ULUS NOROAN SS KERCH GARY GLENN ETAL . 589 WHITE AVE , 452 ;EAST 8TH AVE CHICO CA 95926 CHICO _ CA Y5926 L: 007 080 058 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L„ 007,080 011 000 STATUS: ACTIVE GREGORY ROBERT J &'ACNES J SISAY FATU Y 581 WHITE AVE 2430 CL PASO WAY CHICO CA 95926 CA 95926 L 007 080 061 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L; 007'080 018 000 STATUS: ACTIVE CARLILE'MARY H BLAKE CURTIS F & MURIEL q 565 EAST AVECHICO 918 PRIMROSE AVENUE CA 95926 ,SUNNYVALE CA 94086 L: 007 080 062 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 013 000 STATUS: ACTIVE KINSLOW'MICHAEL V STICKEL SUSAN YVONNE P 0 BOX 3384' RT 2 80X 234 CHICO CA 95927 CHICO CA 95926 L, 007 080,063 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 015 000 STATUS: ACTIVE MULLIN JUANITA DAVERN GERALD P & LOIS A 1 flJ30 EATON RDOR! RT 2 BOX 241E AND CA 95963 CHICO CA 95926 L: 007 000 064 0010' STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 016 000 STATUS: ACTIVE WILKINSON ;.ESLIE E & BEULAH M JT EVANS DEAN F & SUSAN A P 0 BOX 132.8 241 EL PASO WAY CHICO CA 95927 CHICO CA 95926 0 007 080 065 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 080 017 000 STATUS: ACTIVE WILKINSON LESLIE Z & BEULAH M TAMIETTI PAUL D,& DONNA C P O 'Box 1,189 2445 EL PASO WAY CHICO CA 95'92' I;HICO CA 95926 !1.: 007 OK 066 000 STATUS : " ACT IVE L: 007 080 010 000 STATUS: ACTIVE JACOBS DOUGLAS 8 & 'STEPHANIE A B5,RTUN'I FISHER CAROLYN J $93 EAST AVE 2487 EL PASO CHICO CA 95956 CHICO CA 95986 007 080 067 000 51`ATU8& ACTIVE L,,007 p80 0i9 000 STATUS: ACTIVEL: KOCH GEORGE E .& GWENDOLYN HERON BILLY R BARBARA JACKSON TR HERON FAMILY TRUST 599 EAST AVE 9 DANA PRINT ROAD CHICO CA 959816 CHICO CA 95928 L: 007 080 068 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 007 0801 020 000 STATUS: ACTIVE MALMQUIST JOHN W & 'VIRGINIA RLV MGMT TR GP.'!rFIN ARNOLD R & VIVIAtJ MALMOUIST.JOHN W & VIRGINIA TRUST5ES Stint to Sheet & No. PO., S ate & ZIP Coda Postage aortltiad Fea Spoolnl Delivery Fee Restrlalod Dollvor 'Fee Return ftocolpt Showing to Whom & Dete Dolivered rn '- Return Rsoalpt Showing to Whom, CD Dale, & Addreso of Delivory 7 TarAI Postage E[,` & F000 C? CO Postmark or Data M la a. POSTAGE TO COVER FIRST UASS POSTAGE, 'I I CERTIFIED rAICK H � AND HSES ARTICLE A ANY SELECTED OPTIONAL SERVICES (Goo front), ; a 'I. If you want this receipt postmarked, stick the gummed stub to the right of the return address 1 leaving the receipt attached and present the article at a.post office service window or hand It to 1 your, rural carrier (no extra charge). h 2. If you do not want this receipt postmarked, stick the `duritmod stub to the right of the return I address of the article, date, detach and retain the receipt, and mail the article. f 3. If you want a return receipt, write the, certified mall [lumber and your name and address on a o rn r return receipt card, Form 3611, and attach It to the IIrunt of the artlole by means of Ilse gummed ends 1f space permits, Otherwise, affix to the back of arfioip .ndorse front of artiole RETURN i RECEIPT REQtJF'S'6E D adjacent to the number. —, q. If ,you want delivery restricted to tha addrissoo, or to an authorized agent of the addressee, CD r L endorse RESTRICTED DELIVEi1V on the front of the article. i 6, Entor Foos tar the services requested In the appropriate spaces on the front oi this receipt. if r return mceipt Is requested, check the applicable blocks In item 1 of form 3611. !!! It 1 6, Save this rareipt and present it if you make Inquiry. *U'SARO. 1090.270=163 . 11 . � �K �.. •, , �t. �. � r ,.. r ' .. a .. . r rr A i i r n. i ( Y,�j rI lir. 1� a t�� '� Ix1 t Y i e• q i t . ,., It n,_ �, � �L r dt a ..,�, v� � t .�� a tED STATES POSTAL SERVI ` r�` la,E 7 Official Business j PENALTY -FOR PRIVATE. ,W USE TO,AVOIf� RAYMENTEl ��7FPOSTAGE, $300 f s . t 5 a Print your name, address and ZIP Code here COUNTY Or- BUTTr: PLANNING 7 0,(`Unty. coli r r)dvC OroviiieCA P 65-'01307 a07 -00 -Ola i Pr--'r,t_� UNITED. STATE., PQSTAI. SERVICE,, I p t0 j i Official Business i PENALTY'FQ.R PRIME A USE TO AUOIia.PAYMIENT E w o OF POSTAGg a r { 1 " , Print your name, address and ZIP Code here ICOUNTV OF BUTTE RAh,inir 1v DepArt4'iient County Center Drive 1, Oreviile, uA 9596"-3397 i Va r, 60 7- 0s0- 4/0 uOm • Complete items 3, and ao at b•uuu" y ��•. N i • p followinft' services If an extra ry •print your Hams and address, on the reverse of this form so that we can fee): 5 return this card to you. m ' Attach this form to the front of the mallpiece, or an the back If bpaco 1. ❑ Addressee's Address t!' ` does not permft; to -Write "Roturli Receipt Requested" On the mailpiece below the articio number, y 0 Restricted Delivery yt - h • The Return Receipt will show to Whom the artiala was delivered ane the date Consult postntester for fee. ee. ) ; 4 cc delivered, S. Article Addressed to: 4a, Article NumLtor s 7 7�Y t/✓t•nj n�j a} o l.InU0_ JC0fd,$0. 4b. Service Type W, ', L45,• O`ti Ave. Registered ❑Insured 0 ; r3 ,y / Certified 0 CUD ty t n �.i4 Q J�'i �^ j3tir' Receipt for a i w t� C ..d'y L7 Exp•^s lVlaii Mer Ise- u� 0 , M 7. Date of DA ry 6. J .19 n are Addre see 8, Addfesse ' , d Ian if r questec a g• and fee is pat' 1. 5. ign trite (Ager"t'° y P5 Form 3811, December 1991 u;s.GPu:tear-323402 ADOMES71C IRETURiII RECEIPT a SE111DER` I also wish to receive the • Complete items t and/or ^ for additional aorvlees, ' y complete Itemo 3, And 4t, a , following services Dor an extra Print your name and address on thb ravcrso of this form so that we can foe), :> ar return this card to you, w Pitaoh this form to the front of the mailpieoe, or on the hack it spoon 1 Addressee's Address '^ does net permit, a� Write "Return Recolpt Sequssted" an the mallplece holow the article numbnr. 2, 0 Restricted Delivery n• • 'Che Return rocaipt will show to whom the article we doliverad and the date � 1 C: delivered. _� gansuli postrnastar for fee. 41 F Article' Addressed to: 4a. Article Number b+` 6 3 % a a L o da., SU u sa_ 4b. Service Type E r r F( Regls'terod t d_ ut 5 r �h (jV EV7 u �' Certifiede�) �J £ N 01 (_turn Receipt fur c'i 1 ! (tJ < I 1 Express �;:chenslise Q d� 7. Date of e f erl�ryl �- 0 Address Addross I if r uestud � 5, ig 'cure (A 'dr se and Y G and fee is p ) �� M Si atu.e IAge r"" �. Pa Form 3Ei11, December mber 1991 *V.S.GPOt1002 393-402 DOMESTIC RETURN RECEIPT I I k a STICK POSTAGE STAMPS TO AntiULE TO COVER FIRST CLASS POSTAGE, 1 CERTIFIED MAIL FEE, AND CIIARGES FOR ANY SELECTED OPTIONAL akRVICE5 Inno frant6 " 1. If you want this Ucoipt nosttuatknil, stick file gummestun to the r,ght of the teturn eddurs leaving the receipt attataod and ru;anl the article et a post office service wardaw at hand it to i �,. your rural carrier Inn extra charge).. - -, ti 2. If you do not wart this receipt postmarked, gfick the pomafad spltr to the �ipht of the return address of the arpslp,rttota, detach Will rotate the receipt, and moil the article. rn 9, It you ,Wallin return rocaipt, write the certified mad numhor and gout nome and address an a elle return racelpt card, Farm 3511, and onach n to the front of the ar icls by means of the pmmnud ? ends if Space parR'tS, atherwioe, pffiz to back of articlo. Endnrsv hunt of ertiple RIETGRIV RECEIPT' fYRCXUESTEr dlsrant to ilii 0 t pembor„. a, It you iwdnt delivery tastrided pi the addressao, of to on ouihetiad apeot of the addrossea, co apdarso RC-STRICTED DELIVERY all the front of ilia article. 6, Enter has for the services roguustod in the appropriate spaegs on I64e bent at this receipt If return resaipt is requested, chock the applicable blacks in item i of Ft r„, 3011, E” 13. Save (Ills receipt sad prosom it if you make inquiry, ki_S. Ga): 1991—W-910 y ne, count PLANNING DIVISION 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - 0 OV`ILD E CALIFORNIA 95965.3397 TELEPHONE: (916)'536.7601 n. FAX: (916)538-7i65 March 7, 199 hnda Sousa 45?_ F. 8th Avenue Chico, CA 95926 CERTIFIED MAIL Ike: Variance, AP No. 007--080-110 Dear Ms. Sousa: We are ericicsing the original and one copy of your Variance dayso. 9 the. receipt ofph s must he signed and returned to this da,ries artrrlerlt within letter. We will then nave theta validated by the Chairman of the Butta County Planning Commission and the original will be retUrned to you `or your records. signed copies within OO d h nill result in the Please be aware thatfiailur� to return the sig p . r Veriar�ce becoming In�2�lid. Re-application to this departmr.nt w necessary. to proceed with the project. They Variance iF deemed granted when it has been signed by the applicant, with the• countersignature ,signature of the Chairman of the Planning Commission, and said Varla, rice is received by the applicant by registered mail. Should you have any questions regarding this iliatter, please contact Stephen Hackney of this office between 8:00 a.m. and 4:00p.m+, ",Monday through Thursday. Vely truly you; s, ar . 'Ho ri PI ng M na ec 1301:bd iz;,nclosure �¢pp Butte PLANNING DIUISI0N REPARTfNENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 7,COUN•tY CENTER DRIVE , OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 96008.0087 TELEPHONE! (916) 638.700.1 FAX! (918) 638.77E6 I`. February 24, 1.9 Linda A. Souse 452 E. S`s , t Avenue Chico, CA 9592 Re Variance, AP No. 007-080-010 ®ear nes Sousa., At 'the regular meeting of the Butte County Planning Commission held February 24., 1994, your reque yt for a Variance to the front yard sQtback to allow a garage 4.2 feet from road centerline on prop(-,'..rty zoned A-1 (Residential) located on the norRh'side of El Paso way, approximately 170 feet west of White Avenue. at 2422 EI Paso Way, Chico, CA, was approved. Should you desire to appeal any of the conditions it nosed by the Planning Commission, you must do so in writing with the appeal fee 1,)f $250.00, to the Clerk of the bu-jrd of Supervisors, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, .Callfornia, priow to 4:00 p,m. Monday,, March 7, 1994. If you do not appeal and if thare are no other appeals vvilthin the 8 -day appeal ;period, your Varianco will be issued after March 7, 1994. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office between 5:00 a.m, and 4,00 p.m., Monday through Thursday. Sincerely, Barry K. llogan Planning Manager YRW hr Thomas last Senor !Planner BKH fL:bd co�n PLAi1 NINO IVISIOrY DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT 6ERVICES 7`COUNTY CENTER DRIVE OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 96060.3397 TCLEPHONEI (918) 638,7601 FAX; (91(31638-7785 February 24, 1994 Ganda A. Sousa 452 E.8th Avenue Chico, CA '95926 Re Use Permit, AP No.. 007-080-010 Dear Ms. Sousa: At the regulra meeting of the Butte County Planning Commission held February 24, 1994, yoU request for a Variance to the front yard setback to allow a'gurage 42 feet from road centerline on property zoned R-1 (Presidential) located on -Cha north side of E' Paso Way, approxin ,stere 170 feet west of White Avenue at 2422 El Faso Way, Chico, CA, was appy,,) ved. Should you desire to appeal any of the conditions inti, osed by the Planning Commission, you mu''� do so in writing with the appeal fee of $250,010, to the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors, 25 County Center Drive, 0roville, California, prior to 4:00 P.M , Monday, March 7, 1904. If you do not appeal and if there arra no other appeals within the 8 -day appeal period, your Variance will be issued after March 7, 1994, Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office between 8:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m., Monday through Thursday. SinceMly, Barry K. Hogan Planning Manager Thomas Las S--ilor Planner BKH TL., bd d Fatu Sisay 2430 El Paso Way Chico,' CA 95926 County of Butte Office of Planning Department 7 County Center Drive ...Oro 'lle CA 95 C5 vi 9- 3397 Butte County Planning 'Commission Barry K. Hogan, Planning 'Manager: I am writing to respond to your announcement regarding the public hearing scheduled for 2/24!94 in order to discuss tre excemption for Linda A. Souza 'Variance to the front yard set back. As a home owner sharing boundries with the said address (2422 El Paso Way), I am writing to state my opposition to Unda's regiiest for an excemption. Some of my :reasons are as follows: First, I find the S feet projection of the garage into the street to 'be`too'noticeabily out of compliance to the rest of the neighborhood and the general stated county code. Secondly, because of its non conformity to the neighborhood, it is visually disturbing and does in effect block and binder my view from my property to the .rest of the street southof my home. Thirdly, granting an excemption to this variance, I believe will be setting a precedent that says its okay` for every property owner in this neighborhood' to initially ignore and violate the, county code for one, two to three years, after which retract, ;apply and simply receive an, exemption, It is possible that granting this exception might not have a l . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . m ra 77lie'� SU - -" - PLANNING DIVISION DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT S>rRWDES 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE • OROVILLE, CA,LIFORNIa 9s966.3397 TELEPHONE: (9161 538-7601 FAX: (916) 636.7785 January 20, -1994 Lin da A. Sousa 452 E. 8th Avenue Chico, CA 95926 Ike: Use Permit, AF 007-080-010 Dear Ms. Sousa a Variance to Enclosed is a copy of the Staff Findings concerning your ace lt�rline on prop rty zoned the front yard setback to allow a garage 42 feet from_road R-1 located on the north side of'E1 Paso Way, at 2422 El Taco Way, Chico. Aublic hearing has been set for February 24, 1994 at 9:00 aa.m e rMis mOroeet ngCalwill b held in the Board of Supervisors' Room, 25 County Center , r their authorized The Planning Commission recommends that the y applicant Commission ay representative be present at the hearing to respond to any questions contact the Planning have. In the event that no one will represent the applicant, p office prion to the I scheduled public hearing. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office between 8:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m.,, Monday through Thursday. Sincerely, Barry K Hogan Planning n Manager Steve Haclmey Associate Planner SMH:1r Enc. nares :' � ;... A� a t � ,. �L^ � f . yl' M?, l(.. n:it ;�4 i�� ; .�':, "1, I. jj� 04 El ;fir ��.�►, ,��,�� - � `, 2474 e� P r TIM ;t r BUTTE COUNTY ;PLANNING COMMISSION NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given by the Butte County Planning Commission that' public hearings will be held on Thursday, February 24, 1994, in the Butte County 'Board of SuPervisorsI Room, County Administration Center,; 25 County Center Drive, urovi.11e, California, regarding the following item at the following time: ITEM DETERMINED TO BE CATEGORICALLY EXEMPTFROM ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 9,:00 a.m. - Linda A. Souza variance to the 'front yard setback to allow a garage 42 feet from roadCenterline on property zoned R-1 (Residential) located on the north side of El Paso Way, approximately 170 feet west of White Avenue at 2422 El Paso Way, identified asAP007-080--03.0, Chico. (SMH) ITEM ON WHICH A NEGATIVE DECLARATION REGARDING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS HAS BEEN RECOMMENDED, 9:;00 a.m, Rosemary and Melvin Bodarke - Use Permit to allow a`horse arena, boarding and training of horses on, property zoned A-20 (Agricultural - 20 acre parcels) located at the end of Alberton Avenue, south of Chico' River Road, at 10176 Alberton' Avenue, identified as AP 039-140-013, Chico. (SAL) The above mentioned applications, maps, and Negative Declaration are on file and available for public viewing at 'L -he office of the Butte County Planning Department, 7 County Center Drive, nroville, California. If you challenge the above applications in court, you may be limited to raising only those is.ues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice or in Written correspondence delivered to the Planning Commission, at or prior to, the public hearing. BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION BARRY ''K HOGAN, PLANNING; MANAGER p p To be published In the Chico Enterprise Record on Thursday, January 20, 1994. ��) 4 rid a.: ir�,9ar4t rr0 [3rlaarCsra rxt 1=nvironmental Healti•► 61993 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT MAR 17 1993 PRE—APPLICATION REVIE`V FORM C�rrsrrtit�, Oalltarni i Oraville, California 0�0Ul',19i iHlrr j To ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH rf�il�4 fJl`dC�i 11CAi.li Al.T1i Date' MARCH 17 1993 MAR 1 ' 9 1993 CHIC., 0.1FORNIA RE: Pre -Application Review Information for. LINDA A. SOUSA #93-06 VARIANCE Enclosed is preliminary data our office has ,received or generated concerning the following project; vn�c�mun�rr mn A GARAGE AP 007- 080-0Z �� AG �- LOW SIDE AL 0 LOCATED'ON THE NORTH SIDZJ OF I;I, PASO WAY�'APROX. 170' WEST OF WHITE AVENUE AT 2422 EL PASO WAY, CHICO. ZONED R-1 Please indicate your ,response by checking the appropriate box. No requirements for ,this project. The project as proposed can meet this Departments requirements Suffioien;t proof has been given that the applicant can meet the following conditions approved euproject as proposed can/does riot meet the requirements of this department. A revision of the ;project will be necessary. The applicant has been contacted with this information. Signature: 'J ,,.,.►"'� ,aC' +ear.^`` -,; _... PLANNING DEPARTMENT April 8, 1993 i_ 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROI/IEEE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONE: (916) 538-7601 Linda A Sousa 452 E. 8th Ave Chico,CA 95926 RE: Variance AP#007-080-010 Dear Ms. SoWila. This is to notify you that we have received sufficient assurances from Butte County Environmental Health and Public Works Division that your project can meet their requirements This fulfills the Pre -Application review process. Pursuant to the Butte County' Planning Division Project Review Procedure Manual which states, 11Upon tentative approval of a land use permit or variance by the Environmental Health Department and Land Development Division, the applicant must submit o completed formal application, including any required changes from the original submittal_ and the balance of the fees within six (6) months of the tentative approval." No additional work shall. be performed on this project'until we have received the remainder of the application fee in ,the amount of $410.00 and, if any, required changes from the original submittal. Please submit the fee along with any required changes from the original submittal to the Butte County Planning Division no later I and than October 8th, 1993 or your. application will become void, in order to continue the project, you will be required to re -apply. Please make all checks payable to the Butte County Treasurer. Enclosed is a ,field 'marker for identification of the project. Please secure the ribbon in a conspicuous place on the site, preferably visible from the roadway. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact this office any weekday between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 "p.m Sincerely, B.A. KIRCHER_ Director of ZPla /'Larry PAIfiter Planning Technician - 4" i 1n�� M BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE Oroville, CA 95965-3397 (916)1538-7601 TO: , COUNTY: FIRE DEP,r/CDF ` DATE: APRIL 8, 1993 RE: PROJECT REVIEW ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION LINDA SOUSA-VARIANCE follow nEnclosed is preliminary data our office has received or generated concerning the g prcjcet: VARIANCE TO THE FRONT YARD SETBACK` TO ALLOW A GARAGE. AP#007-080-010 LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF EL PASO WAY, APPROX 170' WEST OF WHITE "AVE. AT 2422 'EL PASO WAY, CHICO. ZONED R-1_ 0.19AC. APPLICANTS ADDRESS: 452 E. 8TH AVE,CHICO CA 95926 916-893- 3115 . We " are making an assessment of possible environmental impacts and will be preparing an environmental' document, either a Negative Declaration, Negative Declaration with Mitigation Measures or an Environmental Impact Report (EIR). Please provide any factual statements, ideas for investigation, or opinions you can offer in your area of concern or .expertise that relate to either physical, social, or economic impacts that this project may generate. Please respond within 14 days of the above -noted date. If no response is generated by this inquiry, then it shall be assumed that there are no significant environmental impacts - which are potentiai from the projcet. We appreciate any assistance you can provide. Sincerely, Larry Painter Planning Technician Comments: 2�F1 __ `�- r�•e--' C 01 Does your agency wish to receive a copy of the environmental document (initial study for Negative Declaration (with or without Mitigation Measures) or EIR for this pro). Yes No 7 APR 1 41993 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION -1 7' COUNTY ' CENTER DRIVE NW CI TY of p QIVISIpNry Oroville, CA 95965-3397 PLA ' (916) 538-7601 TO: CITY OF CHICO DATE: APRIL 8 1993' R13. PROJECT REVIEW ElgiV'IRONME;NTAL EVALUATION LINDA ;SOUSA-VARIANCE Enclosed is preliminary data our office has received or generated concerning the following projcet: VARIANCE TO THE FROV1T YARD SETBACK TO ALLOW A GARAGE. AP#.007-080-010 LOCATED' ON THE NORTH` SIDE OF. EL PASO) WAY, ,APPROX' 170' WEST OF WHITE AVE. AT 2422 EL PASO WAY CHICO. ZONED R-1 0.19AC. APPLICANTS ADDRESS: 452 E. 8TH AVE,CHICO CA 95926 916-893- 3115, We are malting an assessment of possible environmental impacts and will be preparing an environmental document, either a Negative: Declaration, Negative Declaration with Mitigation Measures or an Environmental Impiact Report (EIR). Please provide any factual statements, ideas for investigation, or opinions you can offer in your area of concern or expertise that relate to either physical, social, or economic impacts that this . project may generate. Please respond within 14 days of the above -noted date. If no response is; generated by this inquiry, then it shall be assumed that there are no significant environmental impacts which are potential from the projcet. We appreciate any assistance you can provide. Sincerely, a� Larry Painter Planning Technician Comme , Does youe agency wish to receive a copy of the envi onmental document (initial study for Negative Declaration (with or without Mitigation Measures) or ETR for this project). Yes No w R ffl'z MAhL , M-1; {yd� 7722••�ty1, - - A f! tl i4� Tc h1 7.1 54 r n ��i v7 F.Jiz1 h"�'1 ci'#'�F�1 t % �>, � G�jtr {�r N�4r t JFh"tb� �:§ y aT •�'t.r v1 a at{ �� i.p �,'�itjuJ � ai {I"�'��,J.rnFt t f`r •', xJ� A r :'P,'F':.�kr+ a�'d 13� ��'� 1 �C�� F�6/ # 11 r J bu a1 It it+xa ry rlrf is {3 w *t Ti uµ11 ah1 ' 'yM ea."j S .,�r� 1 7� # 1 .., ! t .1 •i �i t � � X,Nj1 t IFy1 � tt' r ii' N h t ^� 1 ♦ C y a ' Y �,. '# � tlpt #I r i r R't'4 . �1; tn•44,*?a ; `t� s h:. � ti n I+t J�,� ;r T i ! ! � � ;kr � a �t f 1 &: "i�' h urW f ^r r �. a y ii 6# � hty�q.,+� r •. �� t.. } _ 0.1 c, i7 1 � lj vait r MgiEro 7��a ro) 1" ,t IMS 4 r ni?ti lr r 717 l y °fir fy kp F ,c Mr1 G `.. r r �4 drt'"tr?� i 5._ 11 4i. \r t vdn �iP'"_M '' t r •.. aR r 1 Rt T V o. >• f Ma+" 7 *`;r '1'X" 'mak' waM 4'"tJf'It •airy - r:� i 164.• a Y +yy l�t��t��J1 a ItV .ty '.x k{4 tl ;_IJfj t Ir: �,Jk {�^'�ti.. ;tpa krt t\'�I�S °,��k�''rrhl 1 " �,�..:�� f(rMk yd's y1 41,E t? . 1 rtn-ir�JhR c , ;'r 1 i r rl?�t� 1c T P t?4y4'Al4fyR ^ F iy wU} ;L f ' y� +fit) 4r'`• t SY ?y�c,,l kl�rh 2a: r Yi i i t t r t iN R rz., tahzlti41n r 1r '�iq '��',<itin�l '�` ,F =T T I+II::y�i��n R�1[:�4fr1ylly k�„j��'isr �' 11ri ��1 J"Jr9 ,: h.; x✓•4t R ',' .y.,. 4�r4*7�,i. 1r,pf 1 �.. _ Y } s i, 7�1 � � ny.4�ur'�.4�r 4 R ry t �, ^-ur�? `" z¢k p tti is � T 1i�1 i1u}+tart f t • t t�.., t , �.,t �f F J :: ; , 01 �Nro lynui7.lrrii it7.yro ri�9 1 dXy iz ��1� s •. f''t lr�yr r r rig i t a T. y i �t� qq x � J+.prj � �:ty;T 1+,.M%(rY�f hj a � af�,,,,•# rhu.b.rn.i-,�rfi IY,�/��x 1 i.;.�J?a7 �z�4 !1M r �rltri� <Jtrµ r 1 •.._r•^ z't r 41 �F' •k”, F�� Hx�'r-! i `r14 r k1.:1� �A Sa 4Ytft+N'u��,1 Z f�}i, i! � 4 e✓,17 � k,� ' ✓� .,r+3 P °'.a f. Ji tr dd 114141 r rv.h • � ,, �•t�� i. 'i'1 (I . b.� 1 �Y k.'��,'.`y.rit:)y 1. "+'h�.n f T�::•.,SJ� ��'v'l�y� L u � ..:r'}11 �lfyt� }r4r �_:" t i 4dyn,rt�t r ,. fi,{+?n. \ :t• � f r4;. Yi 'tn rr �I�r,- ^"StF�f �* —•,,>1 � ,�'� y 4r a '� T :�'R� � � r3e +r` a T `.,�! l 4rS k IF 3+'P f.,t a y � � 7k4a� t{ E. {{° !Gr' yUf In ' a *��J1 `" ifrp' $a. •. V t 3'. 1 � 1 r%rr ry5 Ilan 1 ,1�"7y )i yi 1��:4i to 4zy �. Xi r (Fyx-,.�{t) r411 y, Is1 jR �•1.f�rfa k�i Vdl (f `I Stl Vii. ty1: '4d1..,J rl k4 1 ry't ';' ,! iil "�Y r v ro'4i•k1y (1R A"."6' 1.� a a a 1i d tj, 1 A n f f d. alyl IIIJt t, 11 ha54 r r1 r r p; f r lrnl r p '1 't dv • 1'e_ r�'1:• T' ;Vial 51 s�7Y��fu •'�� i (,4 :ii�{I 4ir a -u al �f 11f�1 ,,(-f ��d �yr l',•y6rR u)t �)iJ 9q',�f 1,.1 .� f4'` r,a:•' ei ,^.fay l� �p i,, r�i' Iif..js.0 ly .l r, - ' y i� a v � '�, �z r a'' '{I - � Y4 � �. i a I r x Sr°; itJ rl�;i.1�.1 {I � ..i r},+ t. I h r r .•kp•, • r -c Y� ��: r ,•�'+, S gyp.. ker +1 ' T r?ai4 .v ro4..J.,�J R..�� i , < r G i1 a'ri9. d, i, u yyy� 1. h: 'tl. f ai DaSM� i1 ihi R a a'T l 1. I r hJ u 1 q tt�s °1 t ati! art �;. 1� cY$.T r MY rt� t . .. .... .. 'ror•. li.'r .u.Yr .....�".Lux •n.L..:y R i 'sA:' 1( fir{ 7;•: r�•i' t �!t I r J �e ti I ii�t� 4 .n 1 tlni�r' ..J. I �r t �•`j .*� • lt��K*r. t�� ='mom a��t l ztj ll /kR 7' 1 S,f 11 •. :4 t 1,1 P� dt r l 1. I r hJ u 1 q tt�s °1 t ati! art �;. 1� cY$.T r MY rt� t . .. .... .. 'ror•. li.'r .u.Yr .....�".Lux •n.L..:y R i 'sA:' 'e4 r ff r�•i' t �!t I r P+711�.xFw� f i C 4.r d l 1 If 4 � ..J. I .*� • lt��K*r. t�� ='mom a��t 'e4 r try 77 '4*,',-,',`,�,� T "M mall, 9,077 "A !Y"', WS1%, "vt cS. y i} I /. � q Arf 2 I :t: t' �!'. (Il 1 �I try 77 '4*,',-,',`,�,� T "M mall, 9,077 "A !Y"', WS1%, "vt cS. If 1 try 77 '4*,',-,',`,�,� T "M mall, 9,077 "A !Y"', WS1%, "vt cS. • r) ' , •(* ^7 F t ,'7 yR r t y l !;, j r1C ' i n •.. C l Ir n L! i a t y . y, 1 �''!.. 4Flr ;t '' t. •7�'ty'�Y �i t�' It :;, t tr jt.,F 1 [ .:�} j ,r r t � lfsr S �`�lrr. R} (�'IfJYQ;t ! ry yrlt�{F�, it Std," t, ytS � t• � I,' ,r •� t .!'t t j r e�,t t ! r ',+,.y..} ' 1 3`�i4ti L�+l+s r� lt�� tfi+�.i ��' �!,:,a'{r It 'r-, 1''• t ..`':X ,At'.'7r W �� r Q'. tt,� � f M. i t i.�• i �� 1 I ! !t o f ,i.,,. t r 1F i t t '3 ri r i{' f, t � t^I 7}) 7 r .. rr ! R 1• I s U ,t. r P� of f� 7 y , t '�, f } „ y„ rt rtv I�lr'1 ire I`� l 1..r M1� ,sk�.;•�- r , 4 t t• i_. y P •4 ({ 1! e v ,Li r ii ,.F 1 �. 4 i:' I Y I �j{ Ir ''r,'I r :• ,� n. f, •� t r �"'.y� I,i•�, 1 r Y7R . ' n L'l+r •�' ! .L 7i '+ xx J( >{•` 1 "' Rt Jr F!(�1 it !t' f �I�dl rt nit{dl ,r! tH It i vl 7' �. j`' tldt t n "y•��t tlr :I}J Jl jrfr�lll {�.41n j /fit fr I IFL SI t7 t + I` t (•:'L�ti,rr �iie�rr115 ;7. r' ' E - i S r it °L.; Ktr 1yl ti,111 II t X_i X11 1 N; ' 1 S:r y •• r , t+). i♦ �•� N is r i :A I ! Ir i !I I t {. "1 i a 't • F + :�+,! I y ti ! I I 4c dl. t ,t F i ,: 'J } L1 �L- t t A I' 1 it ! � I. • � :� I FI . i i j•'! f t n1j i r I i !( � 1'. eyF ' � 1 ' r P t ♦ , �!�' r t N r t, , I r r • r ' , r'I 'I '� I ••r I 1 t ''t r " i r •n , 1 rY t +,n i • r •. ♦ r I } 'I Ilt 't'. ttt 7 r♦i Z , F.II t,1 , ' Y Pl�nnlrl� b�p�rttnent MAR 0 3 1993