HomeMy WebLinkAbout022-170-059® 0
Pac Tell Cellular proposed Negative Declaration regarding env ronmental
impacts and Use Permit to allow a 163 foot cellular monopole antenna and 12 ft..
x 28 ft. equipment building on property zoned A-40 (Agricultural - 40 acre parcels)
located on the west side of State Highway 99, approximately 900 feet north of B
Street, identified as AP 022-170-059, Higgs. (CBS)
The Commission waived the reading of the Staff Findings.
Commir .ioner Lynch said this project is closer to Biggs than to Gridley.
Staff said the mistake was on the ,agenda, and that the mailing notices went to persons
residing in the Biggs area.
CommissionerMatson asked about Mr. Leland's letter objecting to the location? He
asked staff if the location was appropriate?
Staff said the letter has a validp oint. Staff said the Board of Supervisors _determined
that the type of use proposed could be considered through the Use Permit process. Staff
said if the Commission feels the use would be detrimental in this location then it is their
decision.
The hearing was opened to the public.
Ron Waddell, representative of Pac Tell Cellular, thanked staff for their hard work on
this project. He noted that the building being requested is 12 ft. x 28 €t. He said Pac
Tell agrees to the conditions: He said the pole will be 500 ft. from the :rayless property
and the tower will riot interfere with the farming operation. He said the light on the
tower will be a, FAA approved obstruction light and will not affect the neighbors.
C6=AIissioner Lambert discussed the power lines interfering with agricultural planes.
Waddell
said (height
f�t high tension wires are 150-200 ft.
high, He said
most utility power lines are 60 €hig
Commissioner Lambert said this tower would be 150 + feet high and could present a
problem to the agricultural planes.
Mr. Waddell said' that most areas have.- from 200-500 feet of buffer for agricultural
spraying.
Commissioner,
ssy asked there had been any contact with the property owners on
the east side of Highway 99?
.. Bt,7"L'x'E1 e ar 12, 199.,.
Mr. Waddell said the property was looked at. He said it was 150 feet to the field edges.
He said the owners were not contacted.
Commissioner Lynch realizes that 'they can not use the Federal towers, but asked if the
applicant had contacted the Southern Pacific Railroad for use of their towers.
Mr. Waddell had a map showing the tolerance ring in which they, could locate the tower
and the SPRR towers were outside of the ring.
Paul Satur, 190 B Street, Biggs, said he has been a commercial pilot. He said the
antenna would not restrict spraying to the north. He said there is sufficient buffer zone
to the east for the rice fields.
The hearing was closed.
Commissioner Lambert asked what had been discussed at the Board?
Staff said -the Board made the interpretation that 'this project could and should be
considered through the Use Permit process.
Commissioner ,Lynch was concerned with a 165 ft. tower in an agricultural area because
of the spraying and low flying planes.
Commissioner Nein he had no problems with the projiect. He said most of the
concerns have been addressed. He said the location is where it should be and not in
a residential area.
Commissioner Matson said if there are difficulties in the future, the Use Permit could
be pulled..
Commissioner Nelson said there are power lime towers traversing the valley and they .are
not a problem.
It was -ioved by Commissioner Lynch, seconded by Commissioner Lambert to deny the
project as folloNs:
A. Find that the requirements of CEQA have .been completed and considered in
making this decision; and
B, Bind that the proposed use of the property will' impair the integrity and icharacter
of the zone inwhich the land lies and that the use would be unreasonably,
incompatible with or .injurious to surrounding property or detrimereial to " the
health, safety, and general welfare of the persons residing or working in ; the
neighborhood or to the general health, welfare and safety of the County, because
it is an agricultural area and there is the potentiil for aerial spraying and it could
'i,
become an ave ation hazard; and
r. > tx 4 OU f !Y ,X TAT t�G Gc t` i�S J . 5� 1� FS Nti remb � ' � 2 , i.99 ?
C, Deny the Use Permit to allow the installation of a cellular telephone transmission
tower and accessory structure.
Commissioner Lambert said she shares some of the concerns with low flying planes for
agricultural 'spraying.
s..., AYES: Commissioner's ]Lambert and Lynch
NOES: Commissioners Nelson, Matson, and Chairman Gstrowslu
ABSENT: No one
ABSTAINED No one
The motion failed.
It was moved by Commissioner Nelson, seconded by Commissioner Matson, and carried
for . approval as follows:
A. Find that the requirements of CEQA Have been completed and considered in
making this decision and adopt a Negative Declaration regarding environmental
impacts; and
B. Find that the proposed use of the property will not impair the integrity and
character of the zone in which the land lies andthat the use would not be
unreasonably incompatible with or injurious to surrounding property; or detrimental
to the health, safety, and general welfare of the persons residing or working in the
neighborhood or to the general health, welfare and safety of the County, because
of the current agricultural spraying patterns and this proposal has been reviewed
by local and federal agencies and, they found no problem based on spraying
patterns that have occurred in the area; and
C. Grant the Use Permit to allow the installation of a cellular telephone transmission
tower and accessory structure subject to the following conditions:
L The tower shall` not 'exceed 200 ft. in height.
2 Antenna colors shall blend with the natural environment and be approved
by the Director of Planning or designee.
3.: Obtain all neces(aty building permits fiom the Building rng, Division of the
Butte County Department of Development Services.
'NXxv oomm,5sx<�N I �YtJ ' Noir zkrber X99
4
u
4
FILE NO.: 022-170-059
<;
BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
STAFF FINDINGS b September 16, 1992
APPLICANT:
Pac Tel Cellular
OWNER, „
Paul Satur
REQUEST:
Use Permit to allow the installation of a cellular
telephone transmission tower and associated
facilities as a public use
AP NO.:
022-170-059
SIZE:
60.5 acres
LOCATION:
Located on the west side, of Hwy.99
approximately 900' north of B St., Biggs
EXISTING ZONING:
A-40
ZONINGHISTORY:
Zoned A-40 on June 29, 1982 by Ord.* 2296
SURROUNDING ZONING:
A-40, A-5, SR -1
SURROUNDING LAND USE:
Agricultural
GElNIERA►L PLAN DESIGNATION:
Orchard and Field Crops
APPLICABLE REGULaaTIONS:
Butte County Code Sections 24-47
COMMENTS RECEIVED:
All commenting agencies had no, requirements for this project,
BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
STAFF FINDINGS - September 16, 1992
ANALYSIS
This is a Use Permit request to allow the installation of a 165' tall cellular telephone
transmission tower and an associated 336 squale foot equipment building. The site is located
on the west side of Hwy 99, approximately 900' north of B St,, near Biggs. Pao Tel Cellular has
made arrai-igements to lease a 60' by 60' portion of a 60+ acre walnut orchard. The tower will
be located near the northeast corner, of the orchard and will not interfere with the maintenance
of the orchard. Only three walnut trees will have to be removed to install the facility.
The tower is not located near any airport and 'is less than the 200' height that would require
a permit from the Federal Aviation Administration, This use permit is being heard as a public i
use n an Agricultural zone lased ,upon a determination by the Board of Supervisors made on
Sept. 22, 1992. It appears that the proposed use will be compatible with the surrounding land
uses and will not be detrimental to the neighborhood.
An initial study has been prepared and no significant impacts were identified. A Negative
Declaration is recommended
RECOMMENDATIONS:
aecision ana aaopt a n
B. Find that the proposed
the zone in which the lai
with or injurious to surrc
welfare of the persons r
welfare and safety of th
C. Grant a Use Permit to i
and accessory structure
1. The tower shall r
2. Antenna colors:s
Director of Plann
& Obtain all neces
County Developr
4. Applicant must
ordinances and i
ative ueclaration regarding environmental impacts; and
3 of the property will not impair the integrity and character of
lies and that the use would not be unreasonably incompatible
ding property or detrimental to the health, safety, and general
ding or working in the neighborhood or to the general health,
county, becaUse 'and
iw the installation of a cellular telephone transmission tower
ubject to the following conditions.,
exceed 200' in height,
I blend with the natural environment and be approved by the
of designee.
-y building permits from the Building Division of, the Butte
it Services Department.
) comply with all other applicable State and local statutes,
ulations.
2
APPLICATION FOR U PER IT
BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
APPLICANT: Head and follow instructions as set forth on attached sheet.
Applicant's name -PAC-TEL CE'LLULAFZ
Phone No.
Applicant's mailing address_J50 River Plaza Drive, Suite #400 Sacramen'i o, CA 95, 8�3
Applicant's interest In ;property (Owner, lessee, other) L e s s e e
Owner's name and address P a u l & Pau I i P e S a tuL, 1 9-0 Bt �,e , f3 4 ,, CA 95917
Contact person for project (if other than applicant)_ Mick Smith ( P a p, T e l Cellular
Assessor's parcel number(s) U22-170-059_ Presont zoning--L-4o
Local',)nand size ofparcel(s) North of Big -s East Hiohway and West of State; Highway 99,
5
Street address _ N / A
Directions for travel to property (rural and mountainous areas only);; Highway99 North past intersection
of Biggs East Highway approximatel
y 900' +/ to paved access driveway on..
west side of Highway 99.
-J Descr►ptio, of proposed development and use A 1$3' cellular monopole -and a 12X 28' radio
e uipment shelter (untanned_, prefabricated)
Description of existing land use _Wa1 nut_ rlr-jarrl
~° proposed scheduling/associated projects On issuance of Buildinq Permit
] e
Anticipated Increments; development singlePhase Construction r approximately 1 month
Building construction (state dimensions, square footage and materials used)
..,I
o.. a. Existingbuild;ngs 1500 +/-.sq. ft. single. family. residence
®°'
b. Proposed buildings,,_,._,_„
336 sq, ft. radio equipment shelter
.
Hazardous materials to be used (inflammebies, explosives or strong chemicals) 24 lead calcium sealed
batteries
Daily hours of operation N/A _ Numb,ir of employees N/A
Number of off-street parking spaces provided N/A
Existing/proposed sewage disposal method; N/A
:proximity of power and phone lines;
40' +/- to north from lease site
Distance to natural water course or storm drain; Pitch at shoulder 50' east
Anticipated on and off-site drainage Improvements; N/A
Water source; N/A
Proximity of water for fire fighting purposes (hydrants, ponds, etc.) N/A
Will excavation or grading be necessary? Cubic yards (estimate);--7� ma t ard a1, on1.y AC1 +Z
List anddescribe anyother rela t�.d permi(s and ot er,public approvals rpqu'reL,:.ar thisl project, Including those required,bi
city, regional, State and Federal agencies: PublicUtility MM-ss:,1nn, l= adr-Ta] r lnMmijaj r:a%LM
Commission'
IF RESIDEN-rIAL, ,include the r„imber of units; whether units are single or multi -story In height, schedule of unit sizes, and
type of household size expected. N/A
IF COMMERCIAL, indicate the type, whether nelghborhood, city or regionally oriented, s,quare.footage, of sales area, and
loading facilities. N/A'
IF INDUSTRIAL, indicate type, estimated employment per shift, and loading facilities. N/A
IF INSTITUTIONAi-, i'ndicate the major function, estimated employment, per shift,'estimated occupancy, loading facilities,
and community benefits to be derived from the project. N/A
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND MITIGAT)ON MEASURES*
Pte.
Identify potentially significant environmental Impacts associated %,Ith the use permit. What project design features or special
conditions of approval (mitigation measurers) are proposed to alleviate potential environmental Impacts?
This project will not have "a significant impact environmentally.
ham:
ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING*
Describe the, project site as it exists before the project, including information on topographv, sold stability, plants and an'i-
mals, and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects. Describe any existing structures on the site, and the use of the structures,
ry. Describe the surrounding properties, including information on plants and animals and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects.
11.. indicate the tyPe of land use (residential, commercial, etc.) Intensity of land use (single-family; apartments, shops, depart-
ment stores, etc.), and scale of development (height, frontage, setback, rear yard, etc.).
Use separate sheet for longer responses,
See "Attachment A"
hereby declare under penalty of perjury that I have read and understand the inst ' tions and that the for oing statements
are true,:complete and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
Date c3 2
Dat _[ Applicant's signature
Date- Property owner's signature
Use Permit Number
Request: Use oermit to allow
Location and sire of parcel(s)
q
Vi✓RI,FY;
W A.P. Number(s) Project Description
Ownership Zoning and Requirements
Proal of agency (it needed) Location Description
16 Copies of Plot Plan
LtJ.
{
U_ Date Received_ S_ Receipt Number
li.
�D Aphlicatton taken by
'r
-70,��,�
BCS
4
w
D
n
c
/y, r
{
i
-• ;r-y,C
77
L: 022 170 059 200 STATUS:
ACTIVE'
SATUR, .PAUL l&''PA'ULI'NE 'S CP
t '
190 B STREET
BIGGS CA 95917
L: ,022 170 033 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
KINGSLEY. BETTY MAE SS
21a B ST
B.IGGS- -- CA 95917
F
L:OJPP 170 009 000 OTAT110:'
ArTT'VE
SATUR PAUL & PAULINE S CP
190 B STREET
k]IGGS- CA 95917
L: 022 170 OSA OKAPI STATHS:
ArTTVF
SATUR PAUL &'PAULINE S CP
190 B"STREET
BIGGS CA 95917
L: OE2 170 030 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
BAYLES LIVING TRUST
BAYLES MELVA'& BONNIE TRS
P 0 BOX 536
BIGGS CA 95917
L: 022 170 041 000' STATUS:
ACTIVE
B•IGGS,UNIPIED'SCHOOL DISTRICT
P 0 BOX 397
BIGGS" CA 95917
L: 025 800 022 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
:'DOS'RIOS LAND COMPANY
P 0 BOX 536
BIGGS CA 95917
ii
x
cl
•� i
A
L; 022,'180 062 000 STATUS: ACTIVE
L; 022 180 084 000
STATUS: ACTIVE
gJALA BETTY
'
t MEYERMCYER ('ARMS INC
1
40 DAKOTA AVE
� P 0 BOX 67B
BIGGS CA 959.17
BIGGS CA 95917
L 022 180 082 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
La X22..^80 081.000
STATUS: ACTIVE
MATTOS A W'& HELEN ETAL
( HITCHCOCK CARL E & MARIA IT
'
MATT08 EUGENE
p 0 BOX 773
I 2901 HWY 99
'
BIGGS CA 9591'1
BIGGS CA 85917
'
;r
U: 022'180 083 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
. 022 160 055 000
STATUS: ACTIVE
BUTCHER NELDA L SSI
�. PECK WILLIAM H'& DOROTHY (CB—DVA)
Ce
10 DAKOTA AVENUE
168 DAKOTA'AVE
—
1
{
BIGGS CA 95917
BIGGS CA
95917
—
9' 00 STATUS,:
L� 022 170 p59'0�0
ACTIVE
L: 022 180 037`000
STATUS: ACTIVE
t
&
SATUR PAULNE S CP
f QUIST RUTH YVONNE SS`I
190 B STREET
134 DAKOTA AVE
C
BIGGS CA 95917
�r t,' BIGGS CA
9591'1 -
L: 022 170 060 000 5'TATUS:
S CP
ACTIVE
j L: 022 180 038 000,
STATUS: ACTIVE" �.
i
SATUR CAUL & PAULINE
BOWLEG HELENE
190 S STREET
P 0°BOX 125
BIGGS CA 9917
, BIGGS CA
95917.
L- 025 080 004 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
L. 022 180 017 000
STATUS: ACTIJE
SEELEY REV INTER VIVOS TR
WHEAT PHAN THI—'•
SEELEY HARRY A &'SHEILA A TRS
5750 MUSTANG LPI
336 PARK STREET
NORCO CF, 91760-2527
SAN LEANDRO CA
i
95477
L: 025 080 072 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
L; 022 180 058 000
STATUS: ACTIVE.
HANSE.N WILLIAM
EMMONS AN I TA -;GS
128 PRYDR AVE
7E DAKOTA
BIGGS CA 959 17
BIGGS CA
B
95917
1 s
L:Y02�F180 084 000 STATUS;
ACTIVE
000
r
STATUS: ACTIVE
ER
ADAMS2L160�065
UE
—p 0 BOX 678
BIGGS CA 95917
5{ DAKOTA (AVE
BIGGS CA
95917
L:'025 080 087 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
L:,022180 066 000
STATUS"ACTI~VE
BLAIR HAROLD K & JOAN L
ANTHONY BILLIE GENE
& DORIS
{
11 E BIGGS RD
3181 P.' f?AINER DR
BIGGS CA 95917
SAN JOSE CA
95127
L: 085 0B0 093 000 STATUS:
ACTIVE
L. 022 180 061 000
STATUS: ACTIVE
"
BRADY COLLEEN O
DEPT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS
�
MCCULLOUGH DALE A,&
RENECTA J'E'T 87058610
P 0 'BOX 864
32 DAKOTA AVENUE
GRIDLEY CA 95948
BIGGS CA
95917
i
022-.180-084
�+
Pac Tel Cellular
Attwl: Ml. r Smith
,
2150 River Plaza Dir,, Suite 400
aduramento, CA 95833
L: 02,2 180 010 000 STATUS: ACTIVE
�
LUND PETER & EVELYN PAM REVOCABLE TRUST
LUND 'PETER A & EVELYN C TRUSTEES
213 9 STREET
BIGGS CA 95917
L: 022 IE30 072 000 STATUS: ACTIVE
GREIN DAVID PHILIP &`CAROL'
P 0 SOY, 666
s BIGGS CA 95917
L. 022 180 7
p�J0G1a0 STATUS.; ACTIVE
1
MEYER EDGAR & LILLIAN L
P 0 B0X 678
i
7
aIGGS CA 95917
�' Y
I,
P 780 008 107
d Mail Receipt
ipt
No InSUrdil :r Cn:r=r�iyo Fruvidod
� M Do not use for Intermatioriol Mad
roti-Ir�ir li,'r (See Revern
San[ In
Pac Tel Ce11ua1r
Slmel h Na
2150 River. P1.
-
Dr., 04
Pa., alolo !ZIP Code
Sacramento, CA 95833
Poslarlo
�Cotttlled
4
RIO
Spacial Dauvery Fee
taoatrOod Dullvery l`acrl a ,
Pulurn tea ;agrr Showlnir
Ia Whom a pole pallvarad
noturn Neenlpt Shaw015 to Whom,
Data, & Addm,e at Delivery
TOTAL. Postago
& Foos
�`
$
Postmark at Dole
12/17/92
77
i
USE PERMIT
BIME COUNTY PIA1°dl®TING COMMISSION December 16, 1992
DATE: (Certified Mail Ree.)
X2-.5
PE WAIT NO.
022-170-059
,ASSESSOWS PARCEL NO.
Pursuant to the provisions of ;the Zoning Ordinance of the County of Butte and the
sp:-�;ial conditions set forth below: Pac 'fell Cellular is hereby granted a Use Permit in
ace(, dance with application filed: $/4/92 to allow a 163 foot cellular monopole antenna
and 12 x 28 £t. equipment building, on property zoned A-40 (Agricultu.ral - 40 acre
parcels) located .on the west side of State 1- ighway 99, approximately 900 feet north of
E Street, Biggs.
l: Failure to comply with the conditions specified herein as the basis for
approval of application and issuance of Permit, constitutes cause for tl e
revocation of said permit in accordance with the procedures set forth in the
Butte County Zoning !Ordinance, including Butte County Code Sec. 24-62,
2. Unless otherwise provided for in a special condition to this use permit, all
conditionsmust be completed by the Permittee within 12` r!:onths of the
delivery of the countersigned permit to the Permittee.
3. If any use for which a use permit has been granted is not established within
one yepy of the date of receipt of the countersigned permit by the
Permittee, theermit shall become null and void and reapplication and a
.
new permit shall be required to establish the use. '
4. The, terms and conditions of this permit shall run with the land and shall be
binding upon and be to the benefit of the heirs, legal representatives, : successors.
' s
and assigns of the Permittee. uccp
SPECIAL CONDITIONS:
1. The tower shall not exceed 200 ft. in height.
2. Antenna colors shall blend with the natural environment and be approved by the
Director of Planning or designee
3. Obtain all necessary building permits fxom the Building 'Division of the butte
County Department of Development Services.
4, Tower to be adequately lighted so the tower is visible to agricultural, aircraft.
Strobe lights are prohibited.
ioq
4
via
oun
a a
' - 4 Department of Development Services
^
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE-'OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95065-3397
TELEPHOIN''-: (916) 538-7601
November 23, 1992
,NL 4 E. Smith
Pac Tel, Cellular
2150 River Plaza Drive,, Suite 400
Sacramento, CA 95833'
CERTIFIED MAIL
Re: Use Permit, AP 022-170-059
Dear Mr. Smith:
We are enclosing the original and one copy of your conditional Use iPermit, No. 92-55
to allow a 163 foot cellular monopole auterina and a 12 x 28 ft. equipment building on
property zoned A-40 located' o a the west side of State Highway 99, Biggs. Both ' copies
must be signed and returned to this department within 30 days from the receipt; of this
letter ¢ We will then have them validated by the Chairman of the Butte Colinty Planniag
Commission ana the original will be returned to you for your records;
Please be aware -that failure to return the signed copies within 30 days will .result in the
use permit becoming invalid. Re-application to this department would then be necessary
to proceed with the project.
w The, Use Permit is deemed granted when this permit has been signed by the applicant,
with the counter signature of the Chairman of the Planning Commission, and said permit
a
is received by the applicant by registered mail.
Sho.11d you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office between
10:00 aan. and 3:00 p.m.
_
I
U
..�' Sins
O
- IU Q" C
'K�M cfi
Director of Flaluung,,'
IJ -07 D N
"ei M n
t
BAK•lr� g 9
C1Y w
llrr.JJ
8rici .0
4
0 � Cit�
.as+°YY_n ryy
t« I CL ,Vol
Aa00
m
H
�
�
rd
w
�4
-
WY)
0
r^.•,.
�i
..
w
v
c w
j
8
M
.
{UL �y�t
��
w
U, n
V7 M
N
F�
y
14Oi
Jr
y�1(rn
+qy
qi.
a t}
Til
O
,114
U2
C
�2t
GC E�
�L,d
tQi
'�i F�'I
N
C?
w
li
w
IC o
Td
(C G7
1
ttl
tq
I T
0.
IILL
0
to
1-
_..
.: r db � •�'• ��'Y„~«lam~ ti �r�1 '
•I A i'r Y. 3
i
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
7 COUNTY CENT;; R DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 96965-3397
TELEPHONE, (916) 538-7601 ,
November 12, 1992
Pac Tell Cellular
2150 River Plkia Drive; Suite 400
Sacranren'o, CA 95833
Re: Use Permit, AP 0224,170-059
ixentltmen:
At the regular meeting of the F>atte County Plag
Commission h�;iti �luverrber 12,
req ': otiv rhe; installation of -, cellular telephone'
1992 your r �xest far a Use Perrin4 to allow
as a public use on ,iroperty zoned' A-40
"
transmission tower and associatged fya,cYlitles roti ed subject to the followiaxg
located on the west' side of Highway 99, Biggs, way app J
conditions:
1. The tower shall not exceed 2,00 ft. in height.
2, .antenh���.a ,ior5shall ba ,nd with the
natural environmental and be approved by the
Director of Planning of designee.
_ 3, Obtarx 01i necessary building; permitsim the Building Division
of the Butte
County Devek�prent Services Department.
4:'17)wer to be adequate lightod so the tower is visible to agricultural aircraft.
Strobe lglzts,aare prohibited:
5a Applicar,,t must also comply with all other applicable State and local statutes,
ordinar yes, and ragulations
Should you dr, sire to appeal any of the conditions imposed luyhe Clerk ng Corpunissihe Board of
you must do so in writing with the .appeal fee of $516.00, to t
Y Califoirnia, 'prior to 5',00 p.m., Friday,
Supervisors, 75 County C,er,aer Drive, OrovLtle, r
November A, 1992.' 1f you do not appeal and if there arP, no other appeal
peal with' the
2.
8 -day appeal ,p
eriod, your use permit will be issued after Nuve ,
I
., :.1
2150 Hiver Plaza Drive
Suite 400 PAC O
Sacramento, CA 93833
(016) 646 3773 LAR
LL
A Pacific Taiesis Company
November 2, 1.992lglannlr tg 08"8t111111 Tnt
Mr. Craig Sanders
SOU 05 1992
Assistant Planner OrOV11101 0. atifovilia
Department of Planning
BUTTE COUNTY
7 County Center Drive
Oroville, CA 95965
R(- PacTel Cellular's 'Biggs Cell Site - Butte County Application Number 022-170-059
L - ;
Dear Craig:
II�
PacTel Cellular has applied for a TJse Permit to place a 163' monopoic tov a 12 x 28'
unmanned communications, equipment shelter at the above referenced site it, ,ce County.
Due to time constraints with the federal Comnnuinications Commission and our scheduled
Use Perini'. hearing date of November' 12, 1992, we would like to, request issuance of the
BuildinL; Permit on or before November 12, 1992, vend written confirmation on November
12, 1992, :approving the Use Permit,, pending the 8 -clay appeal period, if it is indeed
approved on that date.
PacTel. Cellular understands that early issuance of the Building Permit and written
notification of approval of the Use Permit on �;overnbe, 12, 1992, would not allow PacTel
Cellular to commence Con,truction at this Site until t.te appeal period has expired, in the
event it is not appealed:
Our request for early issuance of said pernlits is so that we may comply with California.
Public Utilities Commission filings, which mast include copies of ali permits required and
issued. , By allowhig early' issuance of said permits, we will be able to file our Advice Letter
on November 12, 1992, thus we can coirinnence construction at the end of the appeal period
to meet our FCC.; deadline.
Your assistance in this nnrtter is greatly appreciated, Should you have any comments or
questions, T may be rear hod at (916) 646-22:."'5,
Best re -ds,
-7X A/z�wx "I',
yi 11 6/1 1 1
T oinaid !C, Wa'; d .11 t �
Manager Real Estate
and Construction
,M
Post-lt band lax transmittal mecna 76'71
8 b
1! aT Peyc e%
70 `.
FvOm
Co;
ro:
—
Dept,
Phone c:,,;y
rox n _ _� M
FOX # *3
,tS
LEL,P,..7. D c3C K.A.TZNnLSON ppm,�9�g 2 9
ATTORNEYS AT LAWwJY"�
44 MONTGOMERY STREET
SUITE 1300.
SA.W IrRANOISCU, OALTFORNTA 09104
TEI.EPH0NE7 (416)989-9600
TELECOPIER:i41S) 969-2S27
NIQUAWo A. LIMAND, dR. ..
October 29, 1992
County of Butte
Department of Public Works
7 County Center Drive,
Oroville, California 95965
Re: PacTel ,Cellular Application; AP 022-170--059
Dear Sirs
This letter is written on behalf of Melva Bayles in her
capacity as trustee of the Bayles 1980 Family Trust in order to
protest the proposed use permit.
Melva Bayles and the Family Trust farm prunes on the land
adjoining the Satur's land to the north and farm prunes and rice
an land bordering the parcel to the east across Highway 99. Mrs..
Bayles lives near the proposed site -to the northwest.
Mrs. Baiyles's primary objection to the use permit is that
the height of the tower will interferewith agricultural
operations on her lands. Prune trees must occasionally be
sprayed with chemicals, and one frequently used method of
-applying the material is by helicopter. In addition, the
cultivation of rise and wild rice requires applications of seed,
fertilizer and chemicals by fixed wing aircraft. The existence
of high antenna in the area of the agricultural land would make
aer..al operations more difficult and hazardous.
The second objection is the detrimental effect that tower
illumination would have on Mrs. Bayless residence. 9,s a safety
precaution this tower may be illutina.ted with a strobe light at
the tope even though not required at this time. Ir he strobe ligh'r
would produce a brig), -it blinking light which is irritating to
local residents, particularly on cloudy nights.
The detrimental effects of locating a cellular antenna in
the area would be reduced or eliminated if PacTel could locate'
its t;,•ansmitter tG ar the existing tower: just north of Rio Bonito
Road NaZt of Highway 95. A, tower exists on that site already so
that eithr:r locating Pact."el's antenna on the tower or
-o•tistruc:ti.ng a neva antenna near the existing antenna would have
no detrimental effects on aviation or local residencesi
Si.�cer%ly,
Richard A, Leland, JrB,
R.AL1gs
cc: Me.lv a Bayles
I
pF{
q
J:
c
O
C
'a)
a
N
r
.c.
Q
N
>
O
.
,C
y
E
u
N
u
�
di
N
di
•
y
MM•1•1
W
C
p�p
N,
•C
N.
9
U.
d
CI
'N
sw
H
C
C d
Of
A
N.0.
Nr
M1
U
'41
N
r
r
4•
di
rt
p.
g
C.
C
4
O:
rz
{ '
iS4
m
�..I
c.
o
N
.p.
,
4
In
QLU
c
C.
r.
c.
V
Q
-p,
71
w
QI
m
N
,vp�
00
N
ti.
O N
„
0
h
w
a
C
wg
O
U
N
O
o
O
o
0. c
N
°Lac
a
w
oa
L
m
off
"J
J, Y
qy
5111,
cGI
�y
5n
N
N
N
•C Z
w
�
o
�
h
,c
Q
N
%1,{' •�
4•
e
°
",
i -I
U
i
x
st
x
x
1
o 0
N
d
a
yt.
°
c
vt°...,
HI
n
v
FA��
C
O
C 0
N Y
d
WW14•�
Wo
n4 14
7
m
i
t+1
�I
I
I
(
N
u
U N
v
N
d
.C.
41
:9 P14
'O
4
S
0,
�.,
u0i
1
•
c
p�rryy.
4�Wa-
Cyj�
.,.r•akk,
EENy
r.Ey•
t
rLd
7daNl
4Yc
duCy-
dro�rL•
41
r4
NA
Iv`.dC.�
bdEEa4�
d
1JOrnuim
3;4,O
4j
!yi
sNPAP
Id�NdiL.
LCup0
�hNN
�]y'
>mJ
u
OL,4j
t,0L
.'.-VH�Wy1 "�M��A�dqA91
rLro]-
�,
.FLaiGL
.YrdONd
Ud
A
tNE
d
.'.tl6NClqq
Vp
+{
..
�
'NuL77c
(,u to
'
LL
d
u d
9.
N d
p
d
NUm
VN
c
Id
d
0
VW
o
N
th
8y
wNp]UNa
irENENNad
RpM'
..
0 41 0
1N
1
y�,E>Gddb
zpppV'bryda
41
.
plNOd
d
.
.
rN
..
LN
O N'
rN
u
byN' LdO
c
tw4'NdydNp'`j .
XC
A
d0
N
C
L dN O
'yCa�dZ'1
�✓Lo:.
E
.00 O 0
p
C
0
ONN
ySEb>aY
rhdU
NN
..
t01
C`hN
,]>•
0
0U
:...
,f�♦
L
p
4
O O'd 4-
{NbyN;�
.
O'
0
U
4 9
U ..
.
OONc
:,.sH����y1],�
OV11}0.11d11
'tddrNb.l
.
r�N'EEEN
N'c"
GdVdyEaKrrOd 4d
Wc�JdcOFJ
r'
d
O
bNVdLO
r•
0 '
W in
c0.
CNu 0
N 4-
y N
d N 1;
S
U
t.
KI
a
N O1C
coO '�ry
L
dNbd
u0aL
A
AC a)d'Lsd
.OaIlj
N
E
N
�yrO+
r.;G�
Ou
10
CoU
wO
aqhH.110
0
.
®p;;
41
m
1NJ
CL
..HpD(�jI
Q
UO
.: .-� .N�N.
p
Un 6a�,d
E
uy
N 7
yroMXNN_•
�G
NJ�LdO:"
NNE
.
Fd`
0
L.
U
'v=
bIJ '
�O
dLU
O
O
Yr/Vrg1`i
y
N
4-
OS41>r
L O rd
ql
4J ONJJ
2
41
,c
L
O
U
N
O
N N
N -N
'rpLU
✓N
4 U
Od
U4'br"
dr
.r.a.]NIN111
N
Nv
y.
r
ca
NON
'�F`NqqV✓'/y
L
'n
N
d ro
.Noc
.
4u
dd
O
ww
U
wN
cn
O'�I
d NA] N
N p
C CL
':
CL m
4
4
?r®
QOd
4- 0 N
0 0 0a;1'0 NUA�rO,r'Er
O,N Qw-
Ceee���O
O 0. N
O v
U2
.
)-4
a
•
H
1i
N�
mmA
.`m
X vA
r m o
O L C
a
C
•AO r 0
Q m
F
/y
1� 1J
N
Lb i
a
S
H
o 7.r
r
o
A > In
iEEtl
ly Ir
4J
4^
c
U
a
�N
IU R r 4
N
'
N
`n
U. N N
N
4,
D. L .r C
>' a
E
L
La
'- u
a
n Yn :r
a s
m
4•
L
l•
a
15
.•
E@
r
it
41oi
p
S.
ao
'°
N,.
d a a L
ro-=Nva
•r U
�,
O
I
u
'w
o.
w
t
-
r.L
a
.ac.
41
.d
C
0 4
:.
4+
4^
o..
n..� u a.
N
^Y
a+ oar.
4,
a.
N
la...
a
"•
m
7
o
,R
U
N..
C aC
N
C
o 3 ro
a y
.p
r
.a
yyy�
.
y
U
p 'N
N
O
'
�: N 'p G
C..
Y
m V'
m
U
0
N'
H
a
L
il.l'
0U1
r.W
mN.
Q'O N
uO
a
o
o
b
a
y
O a
D a
A
,
O.
a a' L G A
C
;� p $:
}T
AN
a.
L
a
U
A
Vtl
V o
41 C
ro
v
E o. 41
,o
Lu u �.
a r,.m
m
]
o.
p E
m
W
O
y..
# a L
�.� a
L w o
. p.
L U
N
'a
ro
C
o
r
O
h..w..
a j
v Y 41
r
v
r
a
p
a1.
N
L
a
r
N. 4-
o
..
E a.e
,,,,yyy,
u
.'..* y.0
IY
`•: Lm
u m
*.
'+u.
u
r
'.
p•
41
=
wm.
N..m
;
IJ 4^N
y
+ V
a
U
C �E
'.
m
/�q
'M
V'
u�� m
N
C
p
O
" p
y
4
C,'.
!y+�� :•N' N
J,
G
D'
J+
C
F
a� y yC^
M, U
m' U
•Yip N
p
C n
p
C
C
C
C
p
yy
W
" 71 q"
A O
,�
m C
^ y U 7
Cp•U
r
rr•
r
r
C. .
Uw ,u�i
: cai
rm.
p OI b
r
VI
N
b pl'In
4
o 1N
a a N
AI
rm .«.
rro
N
14
Io
N F r• ��
p•,i. rN b
N
'b
.ma
�^
U
m
6�
G a U
U. mt 41 C
}�j
m N'C'
N. III
P.0
N
'o..
N
'.0O..
N4.
p,
6
'N
y�
�✓
Q.
o.a V u
LO.
0.
a
ar
P.
°y
p A
L. C C..
L
.c. ro
o
o
a
0
V.
4
o
L
w
L.
o Y. ;I'
L
o. A
C C
O > N.
L. J.
a
�mmm
aN
Nu`ar
r�
d
w
> t •r
a>
.0 a
a
t
m
.0
t m
.0 ro N .E .m
41
d 3
rw
o
F-
r
'.,,�
A
.C,
r
.0
c o }. N
r r-
r
r
r.
r ++ r•r E
N
!-
xI
f
f
a
U.
L
4-
>,
c E.L
yr
N
;'
o
or
oI•`n.'
N
No
o'
m
•p
D.:'O
Id
:�
�-
,a
w
'ow
C N L }I.
N L BVI
N
N
o r •D{•
C
a
oI.
U
4 U
u 4.
L
N
Y
0 O .
V
a.
!
mo
a
N.
y r -
b O
a
o b
p
4_
a C
,'p'
a"
,.
o
,a�
ved
O
u
o
Ir ��
o
y o L
�o F
O
A�
.. ro
c i+
'.E
ro
L F
o
m;
B
uI
E
'7
N
,d
F
O
A C> ro.
Il. o A
O'
'O
. tl
L
E
4N
a
N ro
m L
`
C
a m
1mr
01
U
O
U 7.
,N
((••
0 r ,L
O
}>�. �r
.W
.o
p
u
m
L.
a
p U
Cm
U
,D
O
C �r ni C
O. t•.
I^ a R
C C
4
N
L m
'%
r U
C
jjggAAtlO
C
.0
L'.
r. a
90
�'
01
D N m
I� G,
>'
a Y N
ymj O
N .r
a
r
C C
a •r
m
7
o
p L
U a
4
o
' 01
4-
o L
L 0
y
s.w
o> L
$-
O.
A 4,
rj
A
rd
E
N
a L
,
^
In N
y
L d
o
C
-w
C P.
m
L U
a
a
a� C
C
m .m
L.
.a
L
N. o
o
O O!
d
w
M D
O
u y..
yj
C'
a
a.•r
O
'Ih
3
C
0 o L. 'r,
0 C
1�
L
V d
d
u
k ro
U
L
0
yy
U.N
m
ul. >'
C
pj
C. i U U.
D.
.A
7 L
U 7
.�-
a.
J�. k+
a
L
F1'
7
.rC-.
«
C C
o>
O
Oro
%• C C
r'.•p
a
,q..
..
G.
S
a
�L
N
b a
'r M: s a
�t •o
Oro
aro
y 'aO
N
°
C
d
�'
N N
c c..
a m
N •o +�
!+
L
N ,,4.
L
7 0
u
N .�- {0 41
N N
N C
O
w
m
a
16-d
ai
N U r
0:.
'U
U
4^
,2
a,
L
L
o o
IyL
p
O
O
a r 9 o4.
•
r +m.
w a OL7.
b C..
N
C
Yt
O.
U G
ro m
a
y: W
> In
Y
'o,
O
s
m.. o
OI
G c
. O
il C
' L
D
.p p
N y
�ry
a s
O N.
p
G .N
0
a"
O G
p
0.
E
r
r N
4-
o OI
O.
4' 41
O C
o.M
a
C
IG
y+ a >i A
9
VI
a a
p N j..
J1 O
L
a
L
L C
'lO
u
°
r a
O. O.'
In
1� Ot
a O
m
In C m
E a
4- a
Dy
L N 'p
tl'O it
p• >1
F_. J,
d)
a
Lr.
A.I IIpp k^
m L O1A
y
N ,N M
a N
m
s
0 r u
4- a
.aC
4,,
p {{..
m .N
1IAln1
U
ata.
O1 7
`a
O a
L 7
L
'. a 01
Wro
OI. A A 'C n.
U U y
rr
tll L r
'O
4I I'
1. rN
a N
Y
m L
d C
N
:.
N a
N
a
N
a C.
U A�
C .r
m
.G
U1 4I
a N
m S
>
C
i 7'
4«
d N D',
t w m
U O i
.mC L
U O
Z •r 4
rr-•
C 7
N
>
O'O
.0
U 4«
�'a
H a
U O S o r
o
'.J o
W t E
O•
r
r
VFe
�
SWI
ro
.c
u
3I
ro
A
u
F.
ri.
Agra'
:
-- - d.
Alterations to the course or flow. of flood
-
X
The proposal will not significantly affect any flood control channels or
-
'_-waters? - - - -
watercourses...
Change In the amount of surface water in any -X.
The proposal. will not affect any-watercourse-
ny watercourse_water
waterbody?
-
- -
X -
The will not significantly affect surface water quality..
Discharge into surface waters, or in any
proposal
-
- - -
alterationofsurfacewater qualit.y,. including-
- - - -
but not limited to temperature-, dissolved oxygen.-
...
-
or turbidity?
S.
Alteration of the direction.: or rateof flow of ;
-_ X.
The propo4al will not affect the direction or flow of ground waters.. _
ground waters?..
:.. ---
h_. -
Change in the quantity or quality ofground
,-
X _
The proposal. will not directly affect any aquifer. •-
waters, either through direct additions ' orwithdrawals,
-
or through interception of an.
-
Caquifer
by cuts or excavamionsF
i.
Reductions, in the -amount of water otherwise _
-X
The project will not affect any public. water supply. - -
available for public water supplies?
Exposure of people -or property to water -related
X
The proposal will not expose people or, property to flooding.-
- --
- -
hazards such as flooding? -- --
-
4. -- PLANT LIFE. Will the proposalresultin substantial=
- - -- --
a.
Change in the diversity of species., or number of
_ X
The, proposalwillnot affect the diversity of plant life an site.. -'-
-
--
any species of plants (includingtrees, shrubs,
- _ -
-
grass, c ops, and aquatic plants;?
- -
- _ - b.:
Reduction. of the number - of -any unique, rare or
- X
T'ne site contains no rare plants.
endangered species of plants?
--
C.
Introduction of raw species of plants i to an
X
_ The proposal will not affectexisting. plant life..-
-
area, or in, a barrier to the normal replenishment- - -
- -
- --
_
_
of existing species?
- -
d.
Reductionin-_acreage -of any agricultural crop?
k
Seethe discussion -for item lg..
=,
5. ANIMAL
LIFE_ - Will the proposal -result insubstantial:--
-
Change in the diversity of _species, or cumbers _.
X.
- The proposal ,.will not significantly thediversity or number of animal life '
l ifeor habitat.
of any species of animals (birds, land animals -
-because the site does not support significant animal.
including reptiles,fish and shellfish,. benthic
_
_-
organisms or insects)?
-
b_ -
Reduction in the of any unique,- rare. or. -
X
Thesitecontains no rare animals.
_
- endangered species. of animals?,
- - - c- -
Introduction of new species of animals into an:.
X"-
Theproposalwill not affect._existing animal life.
-
- - -
_
' area,, or -- in - a barrier to the - migration ar
-
- - - - - - -
_
movement of animals?
-
- d. -
Deterioration. of existing fish or wildlife
_ X -
The site contains no significant wildlife habitat. _
habitat?
@. NOISE.
Willtheproposal result in substantial: - -
- - - `-
-
- X
The proposal will not result in a substantial. increase in noise created on .-
- a.
Increasesinexisting noise levels'? -
_
site or inthe vicinity. - - ---
b.
Exposure of people to severe noise levels?
X
The. proposal .will not expose people. to severe noise levels.
4`
[En� � ► Checklist � Evaluation ®f Environmental
�tn���f
X
The proposal will not result in a substantial increase in .light or glare
7,
LIGHT AND GLARE_- Will the proposal produce significant
-
created on-site or in the vicinity_ ._
-.
dight and glare?'
--
-_ - - - - -
X--
The proposal will not alter the land use in the area_ - - - `-
g_
LAND USE. Will the proposal result n a substantial
--
_ _
-`
-alteration ofthe present or'planned land use of:an_area' _
- -
g'_
'NATURAL --RESOURCES_ - Wi 11 the proposalresult in.
substantial:
X
?he proposal will not affect any natural resources_ ,
..a.. Increase in the rate- of use of any natural
.. resources?
K
The p.oposal willnotdeplete any natural resources.
_
- b_ Depletion of any non-renewable natural. resources?
10_
RISK OF UPSET- Will the proposal involve: -
- - Q
materials, nor is located _
a.- A risk of explosion or- release of. hazardous -_
X-
The proposal will not involve the .use of hazardous
close to. any facilities which -store or utilize such. materials_
-
substances (including, i:ut not limited to, oil,
pesticides,chemicals or radiation) in the event
-
- - -
- - of an accident or upset conditions?.
_
%.
Thepraposal will not affect any emergency services..
b_ -- - Possible interference with an emergency response
-
plan or emergency evacuation plan?
- - u -
significantly affect the population of the area. _
the proposal alter location.,. -
--
POPULATION. Will --distribution,
X
The proposal will not
- - -
distribution,:.density or growth rate of the human.
-_..
_.
-
--
_population? _
-
X-
The proposal. will not significantly affect he demand.
HOUSING_ Will, the proposal affect existing housing, or
- -
-
create a demandfor additional housing?
- 13.
TRANSPORTATION/CIRCULATION. Will the proposal result in-.
in- traffic in the.
X
The proposal will not represent an incremental increase
-- ..
a_ Generation of substantial additional vehicle
-
area.. - - - -
.
movement? -
- --
X -
-.
The proposal will not t affect parking because -:none is required for. the _
b.. = Effects on existing parking facilities, or.demand _,.
-
facility.
for new parking? -
- X-
The proposal will represent an increase incongestionand. maSntznance. _
c. Substantial impact on .existing transportation -
_not.
requirements on area roads.
systems? -
X -
-
The proposal will not alter the present pattern of circulation in the area_
d. = - Significant alterations to present patterns of
circulation or movement of people and/or goods?
less than 200' high,
- towaterborne, rail or air-traffic? ..
X
- The .tower site. is not :located near any airportandis _
is the threshold for a. Federal Aviation Administration permit. No
_:-- -_ -
e_ Alterations
_
- - - -
which.
- adverse impacts to air transportation are expected.
X
The proposal w+ll not result in an incremental increase in traffic and
-
Increase in t,�affic hazards to motor vehicles;-
f_ ---
related traffic hazards in the area. _
-.._:-.
bicyclists or-pedestria¢3?'
- 14_.
PUBLIC SER93CES. Will the proposal have an effect upon,
or result i.. a need for new or altered government services..-
in demand for fire
- - - - -
X
- The proposal will not result in an incremental increase
Fire protection? -_
-`-
protection" in the area...
X
The proposal will not result in an incremental increase in demand for police
-
- Police protection?
b. p
- protection in the area.:
Thepr=posal will not result in an incremental increase indemand fo schoo"[.
c Schools?
5 .
Environmental Checkilst w Evaiva#loll ®# Environmental
1
',l pact
-
- -
services in the area. - -
X
-
The proposal wi 11 not result in an incremental increase in demand for park
Pkrecreational facilities?
d. -ars or other - -
- _- - - - - - ' --
and recreation facilities in the area. _
- - --. - - - -
-_.Maintenance of pubTic facilities,. including
X
t - incremental increase. in the need for - -
The proposal will not result in an - -
roads and other facilities in the area.
-- - -_ - -
.roads?
--
maintenance of, public
X
The proposal willnot result inanincremental increase in demand for all
- f. - Other governmental services?
- -
other governmental services in the area_
-:-_ I5. - ENERGY. -Will the proposal result in,
- a. Use of substantial amounts of fuel or energy? -
X
The proposal will not utilize substantial fuel or -energy_ -
demand upon existing
X
The proposal will not -substantially ."increase the demand for energy -
nergy.sourcesof
-.b. Substantial increasein
sources ofenergy,. -or require the development of -
-
- - - -
-
new sources of energy? - -
- - - -.
-
- Io`. FUTILITIES_ Will: the proposal result in -a needfor new.. -
-
- -
_ 'systems, or- substantial alterations to the follOwing= - -
-
-
X
The proposal will not affect electrical power zr natural gas distribution
- a_ - Power or natural: gas?
- -
systems.. -
--
X -
The proposal will enhance the quality of cellular telephone service in the
.-
-b. -- Communications systems? -
- -
- -..-
area.
_
-
X
Thr proposal will not affect public water systems..
Water. availability?.- - -
-or
X
The proposal will have to meet the requirements of the Butte County
-d. Sewer septic. systems? - -
Environmental Health Dept.
X
The proposal does not need a permanent solution -for drainage.
e_ Storm water drainage?
-
X_
The proposal will not affect solidwaste disposal.
Solidwaste and disposaTT- -
- --17.-HU14AN.HEALTH. '-Will the proposal result in:
- =a. - Creation Of any health hazard d or potential hazard __
X -
The proposal will not create any health hazard. ;
(excluding mental health)?-
- -- hazard - -
X
The proposal will not expose people to any health hazard. - -
`b_ Exposure of people ta.potenti alhealth
- _
X
The proposal will result in a talltower-being located near a State Highway.
- the in the :�
a
AESTHETICS_ Will tproposal result In obstru
he th
The tower will be visible to all vehicles travelling. On Hwy. 99. It will not _j
g
e{ any scenic vista view open the public, will :
obscure. or interfere with any scenie view.. - ..
_ -proposal result in the creation of an aesthetica o l_y
-
- `offensive 'site open to the-publicview? -.
-
- -
X
The proposal will not: result in an incremental increase in: demand for park
_ 19_ RECREATION_ Will the proposal result in an impact upon the..
-and recreation facilities_ ._
'- - --...quality or quantity of exiy ing recreational opportunities?
._
-2G - ,- CULTURAL-.RESCUPCES_
-- - - - - --
X
:The proposal will not. affect ,archeological. sites_.
P P
a. - Will the proposal result in the al-tsration or
-
-
- d.atruction of a -prehistoric or historic
-
- - -
-:__ archaeological' site'
-- - - - Will the result in-adversr physical or _,-
X
The proposal will not affect historic sites.
b_ proposal
- - aesthetic effects to a prehistoric or historic
I - _ build -ng, structure or object?
DATA SHEET
f
A. Project Description
l_
Type of. Project: Use Permit
Wildlife Hab?tat: Small birds and animals common to valTey
_ _
-
-orchards. - -
2_
BriefDescrription: Use Permit to allow the installationof a cellular
-
Cultural Environments
telephone transmission tower and associatedfacilities_`-
3_
`
,Lornt-ion-:. Located on the west side of Hwy. 99 approximately
10_
Archaeological and Historical Resources:inthe area:- Low
sensiti:viey arca_ - - -
4..
-Proposed. Density of Development- N/A-
'+�.
-. Butte County general Pian: designation: .Orchard and Field Crops
5_
Amount of Impervious Surfacing: Minimal-
12_
Existing: Zoning: A-40.. --- _ _-
6.
Access and Nearest Public Road(s): Access to Hwy. 99 via a.private-13_
-
- Existing Land Use on-site: Walnut orchard-
_-
easement
7_
- -34.
Method of Sewage Disposal :. None -
_
Surrounding Area_
_-.
a_ Land Uses: Orchard uses -surround the property
`
-
-8_
-
- Source .of Water Supply: -None
- b. Zoning: A-40 - --. -
-
-
gem_ Plan Designatjoac OrchardandField Crops
-
-9-
>Proximity of Power Lines-. To property_ -
d_ Parcel Sizes: 40+ acres -_
e.. ,Population:- Limited--
10-
Potentialfor further land divisions. and development_ N/A
is_
Character of Site and. Area: Agricultural - -
&- -Environmental Setting
-
16_
.Nearest Urban .Asea: Biggs, approximately 3 miles -away
Physical. Environment: -
'17_
Relevant Spheres of Influence: N/A
Terrain..
I8.
Improvements Standards Urban Area: No
a_ general' Topographic Charactert Level valley.. land -
- - - --
b_ Slopes, - 0 to 2`.6 - -
19.
Fire Protection Service:
-
c_ ``Elevation- 100 feet abovesealevel.
d.
_
o. - Nearest County (State)_Fire Station: N/A
-
_
Limiting Factors: None
- -
b_ Water Avdilabilitya N/A. --- -
2a
-
_ Soils -
--a_
20.
'Schools in Area: -.N/A- -
_
Types and Char cteristicsc NIA -
-
- - -
--.Limit-Ing
Faezorsa None -
- - -
-
-.Natural: Hazards: of the Land
a_ Earthquake Zona: Moderate Earthquake Intensity zone VIII_
- -.
- b_ :Erosion Potential: Low
- - -'
c_ Landslide Potential_ None -
-.
d_ Fire Hazard: Unclassified - irrigated farmland--
- -
-
-. e_ Expansive. Soil Potential= Low
-
-
4_
Hydrology - - - - -
-
a_ - Surface later None._.
ground Hater- Abundant valley aqu;ifer:.-
-
c_ - Drainage Characteristics- The -pars,. i drains to the -
-
southwest
_.
-
- -
-:d. Annual' Rainfall (normal): ` 20 inches per year-
-
- -
e_ Limiting Factors: None
-
- 5..
- Visual/Scenic Qualityc Good.
-
- -
- 6_.
Acoustic Quality-- Good:.:
- - 7- -
Air Qualjtys G000, except during periods of ,stagnant valley air. _--
-
- - -
_ -
Biological Environments
8-_
-Vegetation: Walnut orchard
ENVIRONMENTAL
REFERENCE MATERIAL
1.
Butte County Planning Department. Earthquake and
Fault Activity MaD 11--1, Seismic Safety Element.
12.
Butte County Board of Supervisors.
Oroville, CA: CH2M Hill, 1977.
Agricultural Preserves Map, established by
-
Resolution No.. 67-1.78. Oroville, CA:
2.
Butte County Planning Department. Liquefaction
Butte County _Planning Department, 1987.
Potential Map 11-2,Seismic Safety element..
-
orov Ile, CA CH2M.H ll, 1977.
13.
National Flood Insurance Program. Flood
Insurance Rate maps. Federal Emergency -
3.
Butte Cosaty Planning department. Subsidence and
Management Agency, 1989.
Landslide Potential Map 111-1, Safety Element.
oroviller_CA. -CH2M Hill, 1977.
14.
VSGS Quad Maps, Biggs, Calif. I
i
4.
Butte county Planning Department,, Erosion.
15.
Soil Map, chico (1925)lOroville (1926)
Potential Map 11-1-2, Safety Element. Oroville, CA:
Area. United States Department of ,.-
CH2M Hill, 1977.
Agriculture.
5.
Butte County Planning Department, Expansive Soils
16.
Soil Survey of Chico (1925)fOroville
Map 311=3, Safety element'. oroville, CA: CH2M
(1926) Area. United States Department of
Hill, 1977.
Agriculture.
6.
Butte County Planning Department. Noise element
17.
Butte County Planning Department. Butte
Map IV -1, Scenic Highway element. Oroville, CA:
County Fire Protection Jurisdictions and
CH2M Hill, 1977.-
Facilities Map. Butte county fire
Department and California Department of
7.
Butte County Planning Department. -Scenic Highways
Forestry, 1989.
Map V-1, ''Scenic Hiahway Element_ Oroville, CA:
CH2M Hill, 1977: -_
8.
Butte county Planning Department. Natural Fire
Hazard classes: Map 111-4, Safety Element.
Oroville, CA: CH2M Hill, "1977.
9_
Butte County Planning Department. Archaeological
Sensitivity Map. Oroville, CA: James P. Manning,
1983.
30.
Butte County Planning Department. School. District
Map., orovlle, CA,
11.
- Northwestern District Department of Water
Resources. Chico Nitrate Study Map, Nitrate
g_
Concentration in Shallow Wells. The Resources
Agency, State of California, 1983.
�...
y .
boli.
"'- 77// 1' �jj
LAND U'F NATURAL WEALTH AN BEAU
- r `r
- Department of Develo ment SEridces
PLANNING LTEPARMENT
7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397
'7 TELEPHONE: (916) 538-7601
October 13, 1992'
M. E. -Smith
Tac Tell Cellular
2150 River Plaza Drive
Suite 400
Sacramento; CA. '95833
Re: Use Permit, AP 022-170-059
Dear Mr. Smith:
Enclosed is a copy of the Staff Findings concerning your application for a Use Permit
to allow a 163 foot cellular monopole antenna and associated facilities as a public use
property cated on the west side of FEghway 99, `Biggs:`
onzoned A•-4.0 to
A public hearing has been set for November 12, 1992 at 9:00 a.m. This meeting will be
:held in the Board of Supervisors' Room, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California.
The Planning Commission recommends that the applicant or their authorized
representative be present at the hearing to respond to any questions the Commission may
have. in the event that no one will represent the Applicant, please contact the; Planning
office 'prior to the scheduled public hearing.
Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office between
10:00 a.m. sand 3;00 p.m.
Sincerely,
B. A. Kircher
Director of Planning
r
Craig B. anders
Associate Planner
CBS:Ir
Eric.
FILE NO.: 022-170-053
BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION'
STAFF FINDINGS - September 16, 1932
APPLICANT:
Pao Tel Cellular
OWNER
- Paul Satur
REQUEST:
Use Permit to alfaw the installation of a cellular
telephone 'transmission tower and associated
facilities a s a public use
022-170-059
SIZE:
60.5 acres
LOCATION:
Located on the west side of Fiwy. 99
approximately 900' north of B St., Biggs
EXISTING ZONING:
A••40
ZONING HISTORY:
zoned A-40 on June 29, 1982 by I Ord. # .2296
SURROUNDING ZONING:
A-40 A-5, SR -1
SURROUNDING LAND USE:
Agricultural
GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION:
Orchard and Field Crops
APPLICABLE REGULATIONS:
Butte County Cade Sections 24-47
CCNN1ENTS BCEIVED:
All commenting agencies had no requirements for this project, -
i
1
BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
STAFF FUNDINGS September 16, 1992
ANALYSIS
This is a Use Permit request to allow the installation of a 165' tall cellular telephone
transmission tower and an associated 336 square foot equipment building. The site is located
_ on the west side.of Hwy 99, approximately, 900' north of B St., near Biggs: Pac Tel Cellular has
made arrangements to lease a 60', by 60' portion of a 60+ acre- walnut orchard. The tower will
be located near the northeast' corner of the orchard and will not interfere with the maintenance
Only three walnut trees will have
of the orchard.. On to be removed to install the facility..
The tower is not located near wy airport and is less than the 200' height that would require
a permit from the (Federal Aviation Administration. This use permit is being heard as a public
use in an Agricultural zone based upon a determination by the Pkoard of Supervisors made on
Sept. 22, 1992. It appears that the proposed use will be compatib�'4 with the surrounding land
uses and will not be detrimental to the neighborhood.
An initial study has been prepared and no significant impacts were identified: A Negative
Declaration is recommended
RECOMMENDATIONS
A. Find that the requirements of CEQA have been completed and considered in making this
decision and adopt a Negative Declaration regarding environmental impacts, and
B. Find
that the proposed use o
the p p f the property will not impair the integrity and character' of
zone in which the landlies and that the luse would not be unreasonably incompatible
with or injurious to surrounding property or detrimental to the health, safety, and general
I
welfare of the persons' residing or working in the neighborhood or to the general health,
welfare, and safety of the County, because : and
C. Grant a Use Permit to allow the installation of a cellular telephone transmission tower
and accessory structure subject to the following conditions:
1. The tower shall not xcea
d 200'0 in height.
t.
2 Antenna colors shall blend with the natural environment and be approved by the
Director of Planning of designee:
necessaryO�tain all building permits from the Building Division of the Butte
County Development Services Department.
4. Applicant must also comply with all other applicable State and local statutes,
ordinances and regulations.
2
�a
BUTTE E COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
Notice is hereby given by the Butte County Planning Commission that public hearings
will be held on Thursday, Novemrer 12, 1992, in the 'Butte County Board of Supervisors'
Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California,
regarding the ,following ,item at the , following time:
ITEM ON WHICH A NEGATIVE DECLARATION
_ REGARDING ENVIRONMENTAL INiPLQT HAS BEEN 'RECOMMENDED
9:00 a.m. Pac Tell Cellular - Use Permit to allowa 163 foot cellular monopole
antenna and 12 ft. x 18 ft. equipment building on property zoned A-40
(Agricultural 40 acre parcels) located on the west side of State Highway
99, approximately 900 ft. north of B Street, identified as : AP 022-170-059,
Gridley. (CBS)
The above mentioned application,, map and Negative Declaration are on file and
available for public viewing at the office of the Butte County Planning -Department, if
County Center Drive, Orovi'le, California. If you challenge the _above applications in
court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the
public hearing described in this notice or in written correspondence delivered to the
Planning Commission, at or prior to, the public hearing.
BU'I'TI'E COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
B. A. KIRCHER, DIRECTOR OF PLANNING
To be published on Friday, October 9, 1992 in the Gridley Herald.
--- LAND OF NATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY
Department: of Development Sex-vices
w PLANNING DEPARTMENT
7 COUNTY CE"TER DRIVE OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397'
TELEPHONE: (916) 538-7601
June 18, 1992:
pac Tell Cellular
Attn: N.E. Smith
2150pRiver Plaza Dr.
Suite 400
Sacramento, CA 95833
RE; Pre-Application Review
AP#022-180-084
,Gentlemen:•
This is to notify you that we have received sufficient assurances
from Bu'i'te County Environmental Health and Public Works Departments
that your project can meet their requirements.. This fulfills the
Pre-Application review process.
Pursuant to the Butte County Planning Department Project Review
Procedure Manual which states, "Upon tentative approval of a land
use permit or variance by the Environmental health Department and
Land DevelopmentDivision of the Department of Public Works, the
applicant must submit a completed formal application, including any
required changes from the original submittal and the balance of the
fees within six (6) months of the 'tentative approval." No
additional work shall be performed on this project until we have
received the remainder of the application fee in the amount of $780
and, if any, required changes from the original submittal.
Please submit the fee along with. any required changes ' from the
original submittal to the Butte County Planning' Department no later
than 12=18-92 or your. application will become void, and in order to
continue the project, you will be required tore-apply. Please
make all checks payable to the Butte County Treasurer.
Enclosed is a field marker for identification of the project.
Please secure the ribbon in a conspicuous place on the site,
preferably visible from the roadway.'
� 1
ffutte Count'
LAND OF NATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CkLIFORNIA 95955-3397
TELEPHONE: (916) 538-71301
June 8, 1992
Pac Tel Cellular
Attn M.E. Smith
2150 River Plaza: Drive
Suite 400
Sacramento, CA 95833
Re: Use Permit .AP#022-180-084
Dear Mr. Smith:'
We received your pre -application review request for the subject Use Permit.
The Butte County Public "Works and Environmental Health Departments have received
the information you submided. The Planning Department staff will also be reviewing
the application for any special conditions or modifications that are , appropriate.
It is the applicants responsibility to provide any additional Mation needed by Public
Works or Environmental' Health to meet their requirements.
- furtherinformation bas telephone
evaluation 266 and., Environmental Health at
Public Works
538-7281 forof the proposal and their
requirements.
Should you have any questions about the pre -application review, please contact this
office.
Sincerely,
E.A. KIRCHER
Director of Planning
Larry 'Painter
Planning Technician
BAK: LP: j1
Cp
Planning Departments
bl U 22 1 9,,l2 �f
B.UTTZ; BOUNTY PT�ANrtINCx DEPARTMENT JUN 15 1992 1'.
PRE. -APPLICATION REVIEW FORM
QCUVi{3;s `«�i�iiAPPIIEi
To: r � V r-0. r 1 rne' cj Date: June 8, 1992
RE: Pre -Application Review
information for:
Pac Tel Cellular
Attn: M.E. Smith
['7 2150 River Plaza Dr., Ste. 400
Sacramento CA 958:3
Enclosed is preliminary data. our 01A.Tice has received or. 'generated
concerning the follow=' 19 project. USE PERMIT to'allow• a 153 foot _
_cellular monopole and 12'XI.8' equipment-
buildingon property zoned A-40 '
(Agricultural, 40 acre parcels), ".orated- on the south side of Biggs, East
AP#022 180-084
Hiehway apnrox�mately J.150�vet of Hi
hwa 99, Gridley. —_
Please indicate y'Our response bn ' checking the appropriate box.
No requirements dor this project.
'Phe project: as proposed can meet this Departments
requirements. sufficient proof has been given that
the applicant car). meet the following conditions
approved
-------------
f"1 The project as proposed can/does not meet the
requirements of this 'department. A revision
be necessary. p , t
of �he �colhas-been n
x�tactedwththis��.nrormatign.p� can.
_✓`'
SnvironMental HeAlth
Signature:
71
JUN 0 8 1992
Ov
'' Q(gyVii (��l�t�rACdJf
pt
(t, , 6��9�6ia� ��►p�a��rrt�nfi ',
JINN 10 1392
BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT
PRE -APPLICATION REVIEW FORM
n
To: VU C Y VJOfr��}� Date: June 8, 1992
? RE: Pre -Application Review
information for:
Pac Tel Cellular
Attn:M. E. Smith
2150 River. Plaza Dr., Ste. 400
Sacramento, CA 95833
Enclosed is 'preliminary data our office has received or generated
concerning the following project: USE PERMIT to allow -a 163 foot T`
cellular monopole.•and 12°x18' ec(uiment building; on property zoned A-40> _
(Agricultural I , 40 acre arcel's) , located - on the sou:th side of Biggs East
Iii hwayy'anproximately 1.150 feet west of Highway 99, Gridley. AP#022-180-084
Pleas Ie indicate 'your' response by checking the appropriate box.
his project.
-
No requa.rements fort
The project as proposed can meet this Departments
fu�.l requirements.` Sufficient proof has been given that
the applicant can meet the following conditions
approved:
,The project as proposed can/does not meet the
requirements of this department. A revision.
of the project will be necessary. The applicant
'has been.contacted with this information'o
'Signal
;�;,
�"�'
�;C��J�e ��'�3
U ��
�"�'
UTTE COUNTY PLANNING COM1f SION
7 County Centnr Drive �9annfnc� I parlmdrrf
Orovill e, CA 95965-3397 AUG 12 1992
(916) 538-7601
Orovitfe, GaEOfornia
TO: Mosquito Abatement ])istrict DATE: 8-7-92
RE: PROJECT REVIEW Q
EN'VIROMIENTAL EVALUATION
Pac Tell Cellular
Revised. AP# 022-170-059
Enclosed is preliminary data our office has,received or generated
concerning the following project: Use Permit to allow a 163 ft. cellular
monopole and 12' x 18' equipment building located on the south side of Biggs _
East Hwy, approx. 1150 ft. west of Hwy. 99, Gridley.
We are making an assessment of possible environmental impacts and
will be preparing an environmental document, either a Negative
Declaration, Negative Declaration with Mitigation Measures or an
Environmental. Impact Report (EIR).
Please provide any factual statements, ideas for investigation,
you oro icyan offfer. in your area of concern or expertise
opinions
that relate to either physical, social, or ergonomic impacts that
this _project may generate.
Please respond within 14 days of the albove-noted date. 3f no
response is generated by thisinquiry, then it shall be assumed
that there are no significant environmental impacts which are
potential from the project.
We appreciate any assistance you can provide
Sincerely,
Larry Pa' er
Planning Technician
Comments: No foreseeable problem
Does your agency wish to receive a copy of the 'environmental
document (initial study for Negative Declaration (with or without
Mitigation Measures) or EIR fa this project)
Yes No
ir
,: tUTTE COUNTY PLANNING. COM1,�."JSION
7County Center Drive JUN 26 1992
oroville, CA 95965-A3397
a1'41oieCal�ifdrniarr�
(916),538-7601
JUL 2 3 1K2
DATE. 6-18-92
TO: County Tire Dept.
()Y0'V;gxG,:3ir''arip
RE: PROTECT REVIEW &
ENVIRONMENTAT., EVA.::XATiON
PAC TEL CELLULAR
ed is preliminary data our office has received or generated
co19a^ernilzg the following project: _ USE PERMIT to allow a 163 foot cellular _
_mon_opole and 12''x:18' equipment building 6n property coned A-40 (Agricu;ltura7 , 40
acx� arcels) located on the south side off Bi os East Hi hu�a a roxinnate1�1Z50
PAC TEL CELLULAR
feet west of Highway 99•, Gridley: AP#022-180'-084 Attn: M.E. Smith
j.. �-�•y0 O
21.5 River Plaza Dr, Suite 400
Sacramento, -CA 95833
We are makirxg, an assessment of possible environmental impacts and Will
be preparingon an envirmenttall doc document, either a Negative Declaration,
Negative Declaration i g Measures or an .Environmental
Impact Report (EIR).
Please provide any -factual statements, ideas for investigation, or
ea of opinions you cnoffer i your aconoma.r ar ccimpactsoncern Qthatpthissprojec at relate
to either.physical, may
p - yproject
generate
Please. respond within 14 days of the above -noted date. If no response
is 'generated by this inquiry, then it shall be assumed that there are
no significant environmental impacts which are potential ::nom the
project.
We ap reciate any assistan ce you. can provide
Sincerely,
CommeItS
------w���y"
zi ei, .z,;,
to receive a aca v of the an
*ritonmental docuMen
Does your agency w:.sh P. L L �- '� , tiG -on
'� or wi,:zou� �i'
• y i y - S" ive Declaration (wig•
(snit' a.. -stud for Ve at
Lieasures) or EIR for. this 'project}
r