Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout026-080-020a �: 6 t � � n � 1t ' f � . „ . A� t o x� a ., l t � . e ' 4 87-42. w. d'—,. —(j 3' R,O..TEC`Z' ��I�i���'� M`r 87.0_ 02 7E' Ezell Gospel Tabernacle represes3tativa applicant ADDRESS: -1592 Irwin Avenue f' Palermo,, CA 95968 . 533-2975 5Inc . pfR)NE: NTbrthern. District of CA,, Rentecostal church of God,. property owner 9 Citrus Heights, C_, 95621 7'605:.LaupPe Lane, ADDRESS:. pit® •"�� �ESCRZVT2K7 Use Permit to allow a ch -c, �n AR: -1 iofated at the northwest cornea of U er Palermo Road . on property zoned ----- 26—fl8 e_� 20 town/area: Palermo and. North VilI a Avenue identified as AP s tn) Ag -Residential )) ATE GENERAL p 19 Dr T_`-:tt�T][oN 5 0 CEIP r NUMBER: 9 3 8__ 2 — — FRE -App ,'M PAID � $�. � FINALAPP`S PMD': - -1 RECEIPT APZ:tTM ER PT�:ICATiON AC4'EETEDi' pERCENTAGE:. g ciaw POTION SI L TURES CAEC`KEB s MAILING L' ST PREPARES � ? hie=�rspaper: j NOTICES Publ c- _ triMSER: -� NMIS`hc. KkILED LW 'AL DESCRIpnoN PREPARED' PUB%iCATIOY 0TIcEWRITTEN DYSPF,AY AD PREPARED` p,s�rCATION: G R R DATE 0^ MspAPER. poLICATICx INITM 5TU?iY PREPARED FILED: Catega,-:cal Exemption E: VIRO D�IO'T .�-- FILED. Negative Declaration - FILED •C Negative, Mitigated . Envxormental Impact Report VIED;; Others 5°.ATECLEAR.0GROUSE, NUMBER: CATION OF ENV DETERMINATION F+PPLICANLI S� NOTiFI pjA,,,WIKG GoawKs4uis Iox HEARING(s):. BOARD OF SUPERVISORS HEARING(:): ADOPT RESOLUTION NUMBER' GPAs)! ADOPTED: ORDINANCE NUMBER dix A) � BICE OF DE:-ar.'INATION (Appen 'Ful 1 m(ti Cos'el Tabernacle gatIon measures re Proposed Ne at'ive to allow a church on 9a rd n env (ro Dec l ar g l or_a _l with g nmental Residential Mobile property zoned AR -MH -..l mpact and Home (Agr(culturale Permit, corner of UPPer Paler t acre parcels) AP 2S:.OSLO <mo Dodd and North Villacated at the Ptn), Paler Avenueidentified northwest nno . � (den t i f The Commission wa' ied as i ved the reading of the Staff` F(ndings. The hearing was opened to the pub Mr Drown tic, Pastor of the Ch to questioned Condition 7 urcho stated I1e has read turn lane off of` U for a left the staff states t PPer Pal Pr turn lane. Findings. he alternative mo Road was He stated that a protection 11 ve would be a right tunfeaneble, that Public Wort o he will Probably Install k's a tank. ' and that for fire Commissioner ,4 L.atnber� quest i oned i nsPecl: i on from the Health Cond i holdinglth De tion 2 for a wr~11 u tank with draft(n Pairtment and Condition g f under Permit and requirements. the asked g connections sufficient to I f thea or, a we 1 1 and e need to meet CDI fire Staff be coordinated.. flow stated ori l y If they are only going to have one well, Chairman Walter asked who takes care of Condition Staff "stated t 1p+ recam►nended his coria i t i on conic: ` mitigat(on. Staff _s from the geolo earthquake hazard ar stated that gical report of Public W ea there i f aaineone I s and whe i t Works uses. are codes in an that the Departk,ent The hearing was closed. Chairman Waal ter had no Problems with Commissioner the Project: d(scusser,i limiting access to N Staff stated Lambert. ort that this was h Villa. not aconcern Commissioner Lynch stated that publof :Public Works, (c Works aPPlicant on Condition 7 where ii; is s is workin an either/o w(th the. Ft was moved by Chair r condition. Carried for a ma°'i Walter, secondod b PProVal as foilbws y Commissioner Lynch A'. Find y and.. the requiremehts of c"onsidered and adopt lete a C:EGA have been co d and measures 'attac,hed; and Nega'tive� Declaration with mitigation �ibTTL COi1N�',r �>JAN1�i1:�`G CChltrtt� v R, Find that the proposed project as conditioned meets the requirements of` Butte County C%Je Sections 24-35, 43, and 47 spec i f i call y because it is a use consistent with the zone and compatible with the neighborhood, and C. Approve the proposed Use Permit to allow a 9,600 square foot church on AP 26-08-20 (portion) (Full Gospel Tabernacle) subject to the following conditions I. Install septic tank and leach lines per approved plait under permit and inspection from the Health Department. 2. Install well under permit and inspection from the Health Department;. 3. Beed 20 ft. radius returns at 'Intersection of Upper Palermo and North Villa 4. Construct 16 ft. of roadway on the north side of North Villa and 12 ft. of roadway on the south side of North Villa along entire property frontage Typlcal section to be 2" Type B AC and 8" Class 2 AB. 5. Department solution Public Works.. Drainage is acceptable to the olution to drainage shall not be directed' into roadside ditches. Any drainage plan shall be s ubm j tt:ed with the requisite-fees. All drainage facilities, required shall be installed. 6. Replace existing culvert with 1811 pipe. 7. Install a left turn lane at North Villa and Upper Palermo road if required by the Deparcment of Public Works or construct right turn lanes along Upper Palermo apt North Villa, S. Install a well and holding ,tank with drafting tonnections sufficient to meet CbF fire flow requirements 9. Meet the re-Au rements of the State Fire Marshal, 10i Foundabion and design shall be subjected to careful engineering analysis with respect to lateral for-ces I Ili Provide parking and landscaping in accordance with butte County Code Section 24-35 12. No sign or building shall be placed within the required setback .areas 12. Applicant mu4t also Comply with 811 other applicable State and locrl statutes, ordinances, and regulations, 11 T]a +udt'tviy, 1?i,A1Vt43G t11 ix8SJoN �iYI�UM t Selstcmtae�r 17 198 I r fr AYES: Cotrim i ss i avers Lambert, Lynch Peabody and Chairman NOES: No one titer ABSENT Commissioner Forbes ABSTAINED; No one Commissioner Peabody to ,just this asked i f the report Project or if it can be from the geoIocgist Was Staff stated the kept.for general geared i n rOrmat i on . aPPlioation Y do keep them for general a I identified as being information, but applicant Will be required to 9 in an area of sensitivit With each Provide the necessar Y� the Commissioner Y information. lettzr-in Ynch cornplimented the architect on of the site Plan map, his draWin e and. t B x7'E CONT" I'ly NG tnnr�l�zs5tat� Mir�c�r L r lsa� 'aptmb>+,,yi�,$ N FILE N0. AP 26-08-20 (ptn) BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING STAFF FINDINGS GO1�I.ISSION September 17, 19$7 APPLICANT; 014NER: Full Gospel Tabernacle: REQUEST; Pentecostal Church of God AF,NO.,• Use Permit to allow a church SIZE: AP 26-08-20 (ptn LOCATION': 10 acres At the northwest corner Palermo Road and A.'urth Vof 11 EXISTING Paler Aper ZONING; mo` �11a Avenue, ZONING HISTORY; AR-MNi I Zoned AR-,,,H_l SURROUNDING Feb- 28, 1984 2393 ZONING, Ord. SURROUNDINGAR-Mti-1 U, ,4R -MH -2 1/2 LA.N� USE: , A-5 Residential .SITE 1racant at low densities, HISTORY; _ olive orchards, GENERAL "LANbESIGNATIONs tJot applicable APPLICA$LE REGULATIONS: Agricultural-Residential COMMENTS RECEIVEb: Butte County Sections 24-85, Gas 47 9n�irOninenta.l FIea.lth; :r1+ !PProved plan under Install 2' Install permit and' ins sept fromthe and line, Department. 11 a well tinder inspection the leach Permit and > Health De per inspection from therttnent, ne 7artinent of Public Works: .r health a.ntersectlo__. n`` s Upper--P-,.1ermo 3 anvee-r'0 #t: radio d Nor.;a Villa s retrtrns gat alb 2+ Construct 16 zt BUTT , E COUNTY PLANNING STAFF FINDINGS - COh>r1ISSI0N September 17 1087 Of roadwa the south side the north side of Class 2 f North Villa. North Villa and roadside ditch aggregate base, Typical section to l2 ft. of roadway Traffic hes. 4. Re 3. Drainagebe 2f Glass B on data ,,;,,RY require place existing can not be directed and and Upper Paler q xre const cUlvert into mo Road, �1 n of left with �.$�� turn lane at Pipe. 5. De a ument of Forestr North Villa Minimum flow ,forwouldfirehas an 8" main at thee 1:'Water 000 galleins perpm Protection will ho Departmentach is 1,200 nttosectiOn of mute for 20 rnintztrequ.ired. Palermo North specifications •x,300 ft, away, Roo" and Paleres, OWID Villa U Palermo installed at t mo Honcut and hydrant meeting Closers however it xs pu r rmo Roads, he northwest g the Fire water main is beyond nknown to OWID ma corner o,i °wnisell and holden tank0 feet Of Chief Hohave a Water it lmesj, main Preferred to meet s'•te the bui If the that OWID be the fire flo lder, may ij1stall his Count used. w requirements, however --�' Sheri r�+1,he Would be an incre primary, existin ase Sri ca iU Pact on law g ,levels calls enforcement in patrols °f law for service which this W be needed enforcement„ Would take awa case vandalism which a during the In addition Y from easy access' re n;ore conctructio , an increase in xbil.ty t materials. 'because n.Phase due of a lack to thefts and ANALYSIS, of security and The p7:0pert3, has been famill residences Planned churci'h r thence„ now exit for rural to the residential uses, eonformit Property, i£ south and Condit' Y witle h sUrroundin conditioned West' Construction1of a ions tie land use g land Properly, can be a systems and intensity to and the General found in provide :for adequate capabilxt` Plan, Roads infrastructure res of the circulatioh roadsiThe din the vicinitysupport. ditches. are minimum standard and other arterials With the exceptionandard North is pp ' generally paved, With oh Villa 'Pavement of Upper ra Public Works.s aPProxirnate gene ally 12 to g kerma Road, Lincoln Palermo 12 ft. 1/Z sec re1.o) alongPgradx l7 1/z ft, wide; f wider Pavement l 18 re U t'iohends U i g North Villa rhe Department q ested that the the entire fronta to 28 ft iid ft. of frontage. public Mork only a ge• The Pius a frontage is ode Works does not FeelplY to 290 ft; of Plus has safely, i wouldUate• Road that improving their 480 ft. of West also Widening is .irv ng a portion of the. lido of the property airy di necessary , to handle a later U toto obtaintraffic GDF recommend roper on the In the event .that OWID mains be that the existing line s tmo re dtha and a h n Ydrant installed,. 1,000 Feet away, an 2 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS — September 17, 1987 independent water system is acceptable. The applicant has agreed to install a fire hydrant at the corner of Upper Palermo Road and Palermo Road where the OWID line is now stubbed off. The distance from the hydrant to the church would be approximately 1,200 feet, According to CDF, the hydrant would be too far away to maintain adocluate pressure and be of use in an emergency. The alternative is the Jnstallation of a well, holding tank, and drafting connection to meat'. the fire flow requirements. Additional input from CDF has been requested on this item prior to the September 17th hearing The two remaining issues addressed in the initial, study include provisions for drainage, and geologic hazards, A drainage solution will be provided which does not utilize existing roadside ditches. A geologic survey has been submitted indicating the maximum credible earthquake to be expected. has a magnitude of 6.5, The geologist recommends that All foundations be subjected to careful engineering analysis with respect to lateral forces Atid const high quality. ction should be of Butte County Code Section 24-35 states that 5% of the parking lot arra shall be landscaped. An additional 1.,607 square feet of landscaping will be required to meet this standard. It is suggested that landscaping bays be installed along both sides of the building to break up large expansives of parking spaces, A sign is located at the southeast property corner. It appears to project into the front yard building setback area. The sign will have to be relocated approximately 1 to 2 feet northwest._ RECOMMENDATIONS: A. ;Find that the requirements of CF.QA have been completed and consider and adopt a Negative Declaration With mitigation measures attached; and B. Find that the proposed P project as conditioned meets thee. requirements of Butte County Code Section 24-35, 43, and 47, specifically because and C. Approve the proposed Use Permit to allow a 9,600 square foot church on AP 26-08-20 (portion) (,Full Gospel Tabernacle) subject to the following conditionst 1, Install septic tank and leach Lines per approved plan under Permit and inspection from the Health Department. 2, Install well under permit andinspecti Department, on► from the Health i BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS - September 17, 1987 3 Deed 20 ft, radius returns at intersection and North Villa, of U peer Palermo 4. Construct 16 ft, of roadway on the north side of and 12 ft. of roadway on the south side of North Ville entire property frontage. T No�rh Villa along and 8" Class 2 AB, YP1.ca1 section to be 2" Type BAC, 5• Provide a solution to drainage which is nOCOPtable to the Department of Public Works...Drainage .into roadside ditches • Any drainage plan jj,t)t be di A11 drected With the requisite fees, g plan shall he submitted, shall be installed. rainage faclties required 6. Replace existing culvert with 18s, oipe, 7• .Installa left turn Road if required by the at North Villa and Upper Palermo construct tight hand turnelanesaalonn U of Public Works or Villa. g Peer Paletmo at North 8• Install a well and boldin sufficient to g tank with drafting connections meet CDF fire flow requirements. 91 Meet tht requirements of the State .Fire Marshal,, Foundation and design 1/J engineering analysis with r shall be subjected to espect to lateral forces, careful 11. Provide parking and landsca in County Code Section 24-35, R g in accordance with butte 12. NO sign or building shall be placed Within t' setback areas he required 13, Applicant must also Comply and local. statutes, ordinances, tandll other PPlicable State regulations. lJrtT lr Attachments to Cities and Commission! .Initial. Study Letter from Applicant of 8/1.2/87 Geologist Report Site plan Location Exhibit 4 �r w.. .BULL GOSPEL TABERNACLE 7582 Irwin Ave, Palermo, CA. 95968 (916) 533-2975 Duffe Co, Planning+ Cm0l, .August 12, 1987 A U G 1.4 1987 0rov1110, K>ONOMln Butte County Planning Commission 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA. 95965-3397 PE: Use Permit AP 26.08-20 (Portion) Log #87-04-X02-03 ATIN: Laura M. Tuttle In regards to the Mitigation Measures submitted to us, to be considered, we now address as follows: Suggested Mitigation Measures. 1) Submit a geological survey identifying the hazards to persons or property represented by the proximity of the 1975 epicenter. Completed and on file. 2) Provide a solution to drainage acceptable to the Dept. of Public Works which does not utilize the roadside ditches. We agree: Engineering calculations are now in progress to calculate the nee. to meet this requirement. 3) Replaceee existing culvert with 18" pipe. Lle 4) Limit construction activities to Monday thru Saturday 6:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. We agree to this mitigation measure to Heavy Equipment only. But, we would like to have the time extended to 8:00 p.m. Much of our work will be done by donated labor by men skilled in their, vnrious professions such as electrical, sheet rock, plumbing, etc:.. Such wutk would riot be any disturbance to those living by the site, 5) Outdoor Lighting be installed Below roof -line or on loaf stai�daY.ds and shield to minimize glare spillover. We agree, 6) Construct N. 'Villa to 16' on the North side and 12' on the South side. Typical section to be 2" type B, At, and 8" Class II Agregate base, Abid submitted to us by Robiv,8on Contruction on this 'road work is $20;000 minimum. It would work a tremendous burden upon our small. congregation. We would.like you to please consider widening Ni Villa 16' on the North side, 12' on the South side, and 50' beyond the second Entrance and Exit. 7) Deed 20' radius returns at the Intersection of Upper Palermo Rd, and North Villa. We�• 8) Install a Left turn lane at the Intersection of ►lr-j-;r Palermo Rd. and North Villa. Paragraph 13a, Page 7 under the discussion of Environmental Evaluation. This evaluation of the Arizona Dept. of Transportation, as they said, were made under worse case estimates. We have only (2)of tfamiheselies tha tratravel North on Upper Palermo Rd. to the end on Sunday Morning services. 1,qe have only (6) ,families that travel South on. Ur it Palermo Rd. and some of these attend on Sunday Morning and ,Sunday ghts, never midweek service. The bulk of our congregation are in the.z.:;,meciiate vicinityof the church site. The average church and ours is no exception, Never Ila,-, 100% participation Sunday Morning and is reduced 30% for Sunday Evening service and another 20% for mid -week service. We would consider a transition Right sane (Intersection Synometrical) off of Upper Palermo Rd. onto North Villa. This would take care of all going South on Upper Palermo Rd. from which the balk of the traffic will be flowing. 9) Extend O.W.I.D. lines and install a faire hydrant at the Southeast corner Of property. Ibis would create a tremendous burden upon our congregation. After checking with O.W.I.p. and the costs involved ($30,000 +), we woul� like to offer these alternatives: Since the Palermo Fire Dept. is only 6 blocks from the new church site; let us install a fire hydrant on the corner of Upper Palermo Rd. and hePalhydrant tomo Rd. ethethe chux church would1beapproximately now stubbed off. The distance from pp tely 1200 ft. or) We will have to install a water tank th.--it meets the specifications required by the Mitigation Measure as defined on Pg. 3, Paragraph 14a. of the Discussion of Environmental Evaluation sheet. 10) Submit the results of a Archaeological record search prepared by the Chico State University. Completed and on file. We hope this will be of help to you in determining and processing our application for a Used Permit, Please feel free to call if we can be of assistance in any way. We hope to hear from you soon. Respectively, Rev. Dave Brow,, Pastor PHILIP A. L.lWN Consulting Geologist 2646 Sari Verbena Way, Chico, Caiifom.oia 95926 (916) 343.9277 JUly V, 190' POVENTIAL SEISMIC HAZARD AT TIME NES SITE OF THE FULL GOSPEL TABS NAt',LE CHURCHy PALERMO CONCLUSIONS Ido evidencte o~F jan cacti ve fault viai5Found can or adjacent to the proposed site Of a new r_riur-ch building. Gr-ound shal inn 1s the pr i nci p- l potential aosi. mi c ho --r r-ci arlsi ng From a possi, 4l o nearby -Fi tt.rea e arthquaka# stronger, that which occurred in 075. Parameter -s c -F the tna;;imum cr-od bles oaar•tnqual<u% for the rogi;on, a`li3 adopted by Dt;�partment ri Tater Eetsourcos -For the teroville D'am, includo magnitudo 6� -:i, maximum hoi-izontal ccel r t t3. G n c).6 '9, ciuroi i, ol,l v, c�� and pr•odcami. namt pee" i od 0.4 oec. In order- to provido r-tmsonablo mitigation of, Potential seismic hazard, the +dundatioa and dosxgn of all hi.LJh-0r-cuj:)amcy st.rLtcturoa on the property shulald be zubjec'ted to Cal -0- ul enga:MV40j-ihQ an�lysi a with rospet:.t to lateral +Or r-0%, and construction ►aldol tl itl leo di, high (%. etl l ty INTliDDUCT,ON The proposed new site AP 26 -08 -try Parti an) Of Gospel`rabcrnacls ChurchC1 twa Pull Of Palermo s Corrie -r of South V sxt�txtod at Vill i �i the no end U rw•l,{'West 9n 71 a3T�l upper aad IW'ax er Assessor's a :t n >,�•�. Thi si t� SWI/4 t�rw1 r�. campr� the paster s- Parcel 20n third: of and is �ppra;•�i mat�I y .�, 1 �'t�t"a in size ,:",01 mi nor Y assessment Dopartmsr7t hY staff Of the Ca�.t 1 Wthe nLy Planning cane Ltsi has ath"t Patenti albecwus s�i smi a an inferred erred . ren � i �. � �.t 1 �.•; a•I. •!r 17 �� I� oat h i 1 �. s s in "he imm�a diate vi;c.in�:t. 5haai� Y:1 and because the 1 quake Was Iaca�tad loss than a �'�� ���tr�h Caltht one mi 1 e �rt_,rri the pt"a�aer•� Y requested that applicant _ Y. The i tight,. +yi n "sui�rni �� g the hazard .. geologic survey lr� pr�rsans onProximity Of the 5 p y represented h p�"a cr•L �p�. �'L�r'ii:�,'�*. n I��ctSt y the`Fer the Ch�trrh tar Jaye ret�ti.ne�i t~, r�F`aw►;a actingme '�a prepare, sp smi i~ hazard ��ssacz qtr, � report �,n d With C the Site, atontial Site, P'r"P&rfi'tti,nn cry thy.o rePtar`l i the Site and 5LC1 1 rrlth �1 udt�Ci surface examination parts ta•f the ...: � tJh Of �';•t�mi MM ah Of . _ di n0 area On LLtl y ��, 1 stili ec��,cap i � t�� �� ' .. C7 own 2 Y fan t o 'il Phot r� r r'�::t311�,� b WNW (black and Whi ts+y " gO Aorti. al Sur 1I; 6,1 w �iP1d'^ vsys Of aatCreirnc�nt7 photos .az ta�� �� 01 tr;�., getax 1 cod y,'tl"ri`UY"L'y I TOPOGRAPHY AND SOILS The pr"oiara aed church site is on escenti a,l l y--1 ovel t►rt�t,trrcl (average want slope a+ teas than I per coot) „ $oi;ls mapping With at al, 1174)shows that th o ;property lies within a unit mapped as .mAea Gometa a`O AMU variant Series, However, the Cometa Series has a brown 14yer", whereas the Agate variant Series has a roddi.sh-yellow surface layer; thus the site, entirely underlain by an orangi sh-prown pebbly loam, is in thio Agats variant Series, This toil: typically is 12 to .,�"�.0 inches deep over a hardpan ,r )'iris modoratel y -slow permeability, drains well, and hau only alight; erazion I a2ard (Smith A al 1974), GtML OG'y I The only geological unit on the site is terraco- gravel deposits +ormi.ng part A the upper member cap tho Laguna rorma- tion, thoQght to have been dohosi ted from 2.1 to 20 r r milli ran years ago 48usa.cca, 1982, p; Al).It is --a compact ��crir�lomerai: consisting o+ rounded pebbled not an an orange -brown to reddish matrix o+ poorl. yy-Gorhod, coarse rand, silt, and clay., A number o+ faults near the property Have boon mapped by Cather Workers. None passe, through or Immediately adjacent to the site; in addition, exomination of at tial photographs failed tea rOVWl MY Ovi&nce A NOW 00 or atlJai:;ent to thrix p'roporty. r An orderly discussion of the possible effects nearby faults .i s best done by r^efierr=nco to rn p Or which locations of faults F"trtd earthqualtie e+ f ecta are shown. Therefore 1 am enclosing �� copy of part , of the foal ermo 7.5-min quadrangle on which the -following features have beery plotted; they are discussed in turn, in the Paragraphs below. (1) Two inferred faults +rom map 11-1 Of the County General Plat (2) An infero-ed fault fr or'j Bus,:,cca with its loc" �Ation Slightly modified to 'fit MY field observations. CS, DQsacca' s interpretation of the position o•f the buried P""airih Green: linoj:Mont (point PC on map) (4) MY interpretation of the likely position (jfi the Prairie CrLt'Ok lineament between point PC and the northernq,ost location mapped by t)ept � Of Water Rei 5 rurces (1977). (5) Est i matecl l acati ort of the c p.i renter o°F the mai n 1975 earthgL(ako. (&) Locations of Oraur`td cr r ch ina that o carr ed durir t) the 197 1 eatrthqt .Ake ser-i es M Ynferrod +aulto Tfrom Map 11-i. The inferred Molts shown as tieing +r^ora map 11-1 of the County General plan►,erre scaled frrirrt townshi. fa l i, ries ( the pe4i'nci pt`tl lines of ref bronco on ("lap It-l) t:t the iar^go_r -,scale to0oGiraphie rrrp teirrl used) wr r rr., r lttith tho topography and the plot itsel,- show that neither inferred Exult crosse , the proposed site- 'the closer of thea two passe; about ft to the east of the zite. (.2) Inferred +aQlt (BLtsacca 19(32),. This fault is not directly exposed anywhere along its length. DUsacca inf�;rred i,ts oxistonco ava an fault because it, Separates markedly-4di+T.erent roc[., tyles and topographyce to the West are rolatively-gentle plains formed ,of geol ag c -'Vi l y -young gravels (L�:AgUna and yoOnger I erMlti ons) a whereas to the east are more --rugged hi 1 l ti made Of 900logically-ancient metamorphosed volcanic rocks � it�l't�C`ilca`tC)Ilt��t) Its Position as shown on the enclosed wrap is close to but not i denti cial with that shown by B%,tzac_ ca; it is based on the 10ct:tti ons and al. i gnoient of a number of features that I ,observed in field that el sewhG re arc= I• nown to be associated with f aW ts. pi ty � ,ample 7,�rhere x t crosses the north line Of Soot ion y a north -trending band of. grrYylsh-brown soil, 2C� to, 40 'ft wrtieo is bc.)unded on Uoth Sides by Orange -brown soil 1 C)C') ,ft +arthutr nor,thi is a broad sWal,03 cOntaihing a north -trending band a+ yr�_,en graso in 4 field cif othLtrWi V;e--brawn grass, indicating inter- rul tiOM of shallaw groundwater along a north -trending barrier, and' 900 ft north of that" apot'is another dis'.,nct nortl-t-trehdinc SWAI0. abuLh of the north gine o� Section 41the pt`,si,ti on of the �'ctul.t is kndr.c t +r,1 by swat s, sat,+dles;, Chang- in soil typos and changes in rock type. The fact that the fault has affected the gravel dopo&ts the upper member of the kaguna Formation shows that the fault, has been active more recently than the time the gravel Was deposited (2.0 million years ago). As is discussed in Section (41 beloww the California Department of Water Rezourcos (1979) has presonted signW cant evidence indicating that the "Prairie Creel. lineament fault _z cane" of which BusaCC&S fault is a part, should be convidcred a currently"active (cult zone. ,e At its closest approach to the pp - proposed church site, the fault lies 2400 f t to the east (2) Point PC. Busacna (1182) did not showy the location of the Prairie Greek lineament on his geological imap but tlid show the location in cross sections and discussed ovidonco for placing it whore he did. On a cross z4vion trending norrhoast from Memorial Park Cemotor-y; he identified an "approgimate projection of Prai ri.o Crook. 1 i r olmont/fault one" (19825 p. 170) » sealed from the cross section;; this, is point "PC" on the enclosed map. A lineament is a 1100 or Rapti, usually soon on atrial or satellite photographs, that results from alignment caf vi si file features, including vogetation, tonal chanoesp ri.dgosv saddlosh stroam bedsotc, A lineament can have a vari ot.y of geological M cruses Ouch as joints or chan9es in rocE.; typo), including +aul ts. The Prairie Creek lineament .% wl7 ch is discussed in rhol" ij dete`til in the ne;t sections is col -15i derecJ to be a ma `oto +at.tlt zone (Dopa. Waiter Resoiurces 1979) . rBusacca' s interpretation, which seems reasonable in lit �l�t o the detailed eoldgical m�+pping he did in the Oroville area, is based on the presence of a shallow„ strtb•tle told �a adest_+ar_ing "manacl ine") in the young Sedimentary rocE;:s east o+ point I=`Gg 1i placod the Projection o+ the lineament near the western base of the monocl i ne. 14', as seems reasonable, the Pral ri e Creete lineament passes not~thwcrd nt=�,►- poin`• PC., a 1 i kely position +or• it is a topographically -expressed lineament 7rtst to the east, e,rtending northward +rom Bt.ts�tCca s in+e► t ed +4�t�t11 near l-alc�� r w >. p %ion consists o+ 4w prominent Palermo. and The topogr`•�tphic �e;, reser. , north -trending segment o+ stream and several saddles. (4) Qharacor-i sti cs and l i k,el y' location 04' Prairie Creek; lineament, The Prairie Creel, l z nOament i s about 4a,r mY long, anal is at'we of three;, "lineament -fault cones" in thte ►"egi an, so~called because they consist o+ "ccymplets lands o•F discontinuousy intortwinod., steeply -dipping faultz" +ormed in ancient geological times Wept. Water PkesOul-ces 15`79)u The Cleve):arld Hill +F julty which moved in 19754 was 'a t^L Act'vat i on o+ One of thOtio ancient +cult t t7es tt;P�e Sw ii r1 Ravine lineament.) The Prairie Creek. lineament is coosiderod by D partment (1,11r Water Resources (1979, p6 7 ) to b8 capable of i,utwtro fault movement for these reasons. (1) South o+ Butte County, it merges with the Swain Rav nn 1inp+amont, which includes vho recently -active Cleveland Hill +aul t (2) Ground cracks developed d( ring the 1:9' 5 earthLjual;:e series formed a crude, b -°mi -1 any alignment that extended nail`th- northwest from the northernmost mapped end of the Prairie Creek: 'linoament. Celt the Limo oT the Departmont c•f Water Resources %•Ludy (19-79),, the faarthest-north paint to which tVie Prairie, Creek: lineament h d Meeh mapped was about T- 5 mi south Of Palermo (see' enclo-ed map); l fitter work by 8u-racca (1.982) p'rovxded strong evidence +or errtonding the lin.=amont 6 to 7 mi farther north. (.5) Small, varthquab:es have occurred, with their" opicontors aligned along the l i neiamont or its northerly Ox' te,nt'; ons The Prairie Crmsk lineament it covered by geolOtjically-yaung gravel and alluvial deposits north of Wyandotte Creo1; (about 2.1,55 mi south of Palermo) , and so its (--tact location north o+ Wyexh- dotto Creek: is ronJoctural., Ne�jverth,eless, then o is aonsider'"tble evidoncoi rug Arding its :,fir-;o].y position. (fit its �'7ort'he most mapped e,; tent, the Pra-ir: e Creel Ment has a trend of I\I17W.; this is close to the trend o+ the inferred fAult from map li--z of the C;eneral Plano which in turr5 is (over part of its extent) almost coincident with ct��ci~rt' inferred fault just east. of Palermo. T`gtsacca'�: +L-iult, the 10(7- — tion o4' which wa.:3 confirmed during field worn{. for this project" changes to 1 mrari�?-northerly trend,, its northward projection pasze5 very close to 8usacc � 5 Point PC and tees into the topographic lineament _gust to: the oast of point PC. It SNeams reasonable to as7;,ume that these 4eaturos• 1^1uzacca's inferred fault, « pcar'L'ions oaf the infertHed fault from mapT-�1, and the topographic lineament Just to the east of point PC-- are all el emerit,z o -F the F'rai r i r , CreM,: lineament fault ono, (5) Epicenter of the main 1975 earthquake The Hugu5t 1, 197Sw main asarthqual-,-o had a mkgni tUde of 5. 7; it was caused by ;i0ve%MU,-t along the Cleveland Hill •fault ( part of the Swain Ravine linoamont fault zone) . Th* fault stril-'OS (,tr(5?nds) north4 intersects 'the eatrth" ea %LLI� lFare RbOUt 4 mi east of Palermo4 and Ali ps ( i . inclined) ajnf (jegrees tawarci the west. The main oarthqual::e Occurred at a depth of 8. Irl 1.01) '%S. a mi) � aS w consequentL4 of the dip o+ the faulto the epicenter Ca point cin the su1rf4Ace 0X1rACtly Vibove the sprit whore the first bio-e.al• inq of a fault t ll,us pj. ,Acoj wt%s l or«=atotj nozil" Palermo ratl" er t114M "Car Cl evel and Hi l whir 1= �.rl 'f ince breal4ing occur 4 -40. Thus, although the epicenter was located OMIY 00 Mi north or northeast of the proposed church site, Measured irl Ct horizontal direction, the hypocenter (the point on the fault where lirst breaking occurs) was 5-5 Mi from the site, mOasurod in a vortical direction. A further factor to Consider is the precision with which the location of the epicenter is known. Published statements of the epi center location are Wical lY given to the nearest o.00i degree or Wo! minute 0+ latitude and longitude; such descrip- "o's "PlY a precision of less than 360 it (i.w,y a measure- ment of lat"de given to the nearest 0*001 degree indicates that the true location is kNlwn within a nor Ch -south distance of 56C) it (PlUs-dr-mlnus .j3 degroe) Such statements are misleading, The precision Q'I which epicenter locations art known deponds on a WOW Of Toctorzo among them the nUmbor of stations gat Which the earthquake Is recorded and the d'stalte frOM the stations to ths oypoconter. At the tjfnL� Of the maim earthquake, the number of stations was rel at 0011 and their average d'stInat from the hypocontoj� tended to be largo: Howovar, in the days following the main shock, I large number Of portable inztrQmwmtz Were brought into the immediate area no the aftershocks ; even Under these +avUrablo conditions, tha-baQ dotowminations mado of latitUdO and 1009itudo had standard errors 0+ about 0.5 Ism (Q, mi; Savage ot al. 1975)M E"Standard error" is a diNance within which 6B % of the avarzIes of a very large number of repeated moaGurements would fall ul Since it Was not possible to repeat the main earthquake shock in order to create a "vary large" nwmbor of repeated measurements, the precision statement can be reworded to state that we can be only 68 % certain that.the real epicenter Position lies within 0.0 mi N the Position that was calculated. To further complicate things,, the average poli tions calculated for the epicenter by different workers do not agro*k Two opicentor location, (Morriven 1975; Dupt. Water posourcos 1979) are shown on he enclosed map„ they are about 2000 Q Parts and each it anout 0.6 mi frost the Proposed church mitei In SUMfilary, t,%-:, UpiContor location of too 1975 main earth— quAko has an inheroot degoio of u0cortainty; thus a location shown on a map 0"Vt be understood to be only iappro�,,timate- t K)Groumd ctackingi F0110wing the IM earthquake, inv0stigatiOns in tho area Qatos 1975; Moohan 1975; Capp of all MY recorded slight damage to bridges and Public buildings in the vicinity of Vaj,rmo. WNW include tilt of abutment bearings and minor l0ttl0ment A WrOachez at Usel Rd, overhead, movement and sAMMOK of Pilo bong and abutmontz at the Upper Palermo Road crossing at Wandotto Croo, broken window at Oakdale Height, School, mod brokon glassy light fixtures$ and LOW plaster at Las Plumas High School. Ground cracking occurred north, south, and east of Pal ormo. Thee ground cracking and damage to buildings are attributable to ground shaking rather than to fault movement directly on each affected site, although Oopartment of Water Resoveaus (1979) has noted that the pattern of ground cracking south and north of Palermo has a regional trend that appears to form an extension of the Prairie Creek lineament north of its northernmost mapped ogtent. The pattern of ground cracking forms a zono broad enough that it cannot be used to attempt an enact location of the Prairie Creek lineament. SEISMIC HAZAKIO Because of concern over the Auburn dam; the 1975 earthquake triggered extensive Kudy by private and governmental organi- zatibne into the seismicity of the Siorran foothills. Con- clusions, summarized by Divisi"On A Minos and Geology 8taff (1979)4 are that a man imum arediOlo earthquake having a Magnitude of 60 should be considered posGiblo anywhere in the Foothills Fault System, DopartMent 0+ Water Wourcos (1179, N 71) concluded that (a) the potential +or future earthquakes and ground rupture in the Orovil,le area is greatest along the Swain Ravine 100=hto month and south a+ the part broken in 0750 and %) the Prairie Crook lineament fault one should be considor,od capable of tho samo kind of activity as occurred along the Swain A r Ravine lineament in 1975. The 8tttte County General Plan, prepared in NOVO(Abor and Docember xV6 (5esimic safe;cy, E'lemeot, p. It-,17), COnalude; that "the anticipated maximum ground shaking intensity t1r.ros &.1l 1 0� butte County is VIII on the Modified 118tc>alli scale; however, the intensity COUl d Ovary locally from VII to I X . A zummt: ry of historic and future potential earthgttakos from faults within rind close to BLVE.L•o CoLtn•ty (page 11-IS) includes these data.- Cleveland ata:Cleveland Hill faalt Maximum credible earthquake magnitude 6.4; estimated magimum intensity VIII; estimat° . ma:t:imum bedrock accelerwI-tion 0.43 0.6 g. Foothills shoar zone.. (Thim is a generali ed term that includos all of thO faults of the Orovil.le c`irea. ma:aiinttm credible Oarthquake magnitude '7. esti ma-Eed mit;a i it;Ltm i nten- sit-y IX; estimated mauxtimt:N bedrocl, acceleration 0.6 - 0.9 g Following the 1975 earthquake, a ConsLtlting hoard fear Earthquake Analysis recommemdod Wept, Wator F,esottrces, '197'7, p. 22S) that the ma:,i.mum crudiblo earthqutak:e (the "reanalysis earthquakell„ So named bocau�o the board was roanaly4;inq the seismic sa+cty of 01-Ovi l l e team) for the tgrovi l l e �.rea shOU l d be cohsidere,d LAG having theso cl arac eristicia di Stance to mi ) magnitude 6. Peak- Mari; ontal gtr•dund j*cCc`l els ati. on l�►6 g duration (shaking ,,ri).(.)5 g) "'tt sec predominant period 0.4 sec 141TIGATION Ground er• ll:;xrig is the principal seI srni c hazard to the p►"epese~d church site, I as shtawn by the seismic hi.stcar realcn� field examination of the �+rew~l; and analy�;.i� of Published tilegeological ma Publ. i shed ppirrl t + the region. EgOcauae the Proposed use of dea hi gh~crcetblp��n�Y St►•-l.tct�lre (Al chctrctl the site incltl br„calize of the a ) and pe'kl ntix-1 for a nearby earthtquak:cf higl-►rilr magn i tudl� than( that of 1975 It is import ant that And deli , of sti t.lctui es cn the Zltel the +Oundatizan L- be 8UbJected to careful ngi r►eeri r►g anL�l ysi s � esp�.3K�i: as I y With rr::�pcct to�. �; The I.SC4 of contservatl4�f? lateral forces, fOUNdatlla r analySi and F��n de igns a,.nd ,�jppricatjor•l of hi h� gtrlr--ring g L►u��l �. tyy constrUcti l„ 11 Practice, Should provide �"eascn�tbl e mi t,i t��t, br•► e�. patr nt:►.al gi^at,trid . Shaking, e�f•fedts► REFERENCES CITED L-rusacca, A. J. , 1982 Geologic I-li stare northeastern Sacramer7to Valley, and soil 0 vel opment, unpublished Ph. D. thesis„ "�ISCalifornia: (.lni v. of Calif. scale 1--62, .,5ryta. P. Plus append,cesand map, Depar trrrc,nt of Water Resources, he earthquake i nveSt1 gati ani;;, Cal ��F . TDe AUgust 10 1 1275., 01-ovi l l e : 0Z-78y Eby p. p ' Watol Resources cull. tai vi s� a-t of Mines and Geral ogy t seismic Staff, f, 1979,' Techtjjcrjl review 0+ and d Geology Safety Of the Auburn damsito.. Cal'i,-P. Sp0c. Pub, $4, 17 p. Div. !vlir7es Gates, ogys,, 197u, Geology Damage to bridgbridges..Cali f.. Di l,�y. Spec. Rept. 124, p. 91�'-9q.w v4 Mi.nez and Meehan, .F. 17, Clbservatiotns Of earthquake rpelate damage: Cal.1 ' IJi v. Mines and Geology Spec. d building Morr i tion, �'" Y . W. Jr. , et a], . 1�i7�y The segt.tence o+ August ;L S'7 » Gal ti Diva rol fines cart!rt uaf;e i°epi�. 1 N p. 147-151. arid C0010gy Spec. Rapp" J. S• , et al,., 197S,4 Observations Of Drov" "1 area, Cal iTornia» Cali+, Div. gM�nes artdUnd aC,ealt� the Spec. Dept 1211•, p.. u } Geology Smith, $.F, .4 est aS, 1974, Sail vec�0taquarter Gridley(=alermc)) 7.5-mintion mei p 'and nd tables,County, California... U.S. ! quadjzIngl rarest and Faa C r.. Service e('19� A-1), c=f1c ugl,s�l�e,1"`6. tion, t l�or'r� tliel� S P- r71us map:, Seale:± Philip A. Lydon Calif. Regi starod Geologist 4 144 flap r«s� f trite, lirloamerrte,, and l'e'i' fi t MAP OF FAULTS, LINEAMENTS, AND 1975 GFOUND BREAKS EXPLANATIOIu inferred fault, map xI-1, County General Flan B inferred fault, 'BUsacca 1982' appro>ti mate location of inferred extension of Prairie Creed:: lineament fault zones t from cross section in Busacca, 1952; PC p. 170 inferred extension of Prairie Creek lineament fault ,n gone,, this report car 0 _A2, location of main 1975 epi center; according to; Eli M Morrison et al. 1975 D Dept, Water Resoureee 079 p. location of reported ground cracking, Sapp 075 and Dept. Water Resources 1975 location of proposed site of Full Gospel Tabernacle church building Topography from USGS palei-mb 7 5—min qu�:dV"angle iiatjt;r ft2 Ccontour interval 5 +ti scale 1 inch; Compiled by P A. Lydon July 19137 n Lullu WbLjl .14 g. vt iRl hP OF FAULTS, LINEAMENTS, AND 1975 GROUINM BREAKS Compiled by JulY 1987 IF We See attached sheet for explanation Trailer WP tz it 4111 va -� AT'i" 01 Ouls well nR kt 141 "0 17 1 H. zz 6. 0 2000 feet -2-1 Viet OJO Prairie Cr Lineament Fault (i Zone Y1 t 116 122 Tj J LL. gutfo Co. Planning Com A.PPaLICATION FOR USE PERMIT MAR 241987 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION Orwyilleq Coufarak APPLICANT: Bead and follow instructions as set forth on attached sheet. Applicant's named rx/� %"�rsot" — pltu�rio 140. v y Applicant's mailing address �!ef/Ai I7 y" . e:�,, Znnary w�ar_�f,».. Applicant's Interest in property (Owner, lessee, other)��'= Owner's name and Contact person for project (If other than applicant)2Z-'z0, 0 !1.�e42 r- , ��'II—,o"A i.4" r"� ,x. ifs' `+Y:X2_9A'1 - Assessor's parcel numbersJ-4.–-, ,P/ T` Present zoning,. • `r �' -" Location and size of parcel(s) (',il= 62e -t– r~r, hko P11 &O, I zW}'J e 1� e-4 :°,l :°,l LLv, Street'address°`° Directions for travel to property (rural and mountainous areas only): *y". +e s o ed oescriptionof proposed development and use Description of existing land use r Proposed scheduling/associated projects x(41 �- Anticipated Incremental development e,dllr Building construction (state dimensions, square footage and materiels used) a, Existing buildings r b. Proposed bulldlrtgs - Hazardous materials to be used (inflammables, explosives or strong chemicals) Daily hours 0operationNumber of employees, Number of , 1-atreet parkilig spaces providr,d C .� bo r -J;.4 e `+? E=xisting proposed sewage diupusal Proximity of power and phone fines: Dls.snce to natural water course or storm drain:... �Z` - A - , , L Zf. AnUdipated on and off-site drainage improvementsx, W:, rw . F„ .114V14JJL1 r -f -- List and describe any other related permits and other public approvals required for this prodot, including those required by dityf roglonal, State and Federal agencies: ✓ " ' !' IF RESIDENTIAL, include the number of units, whether units are single or multi -story in height, schedule of unit sizes, and type of hausehold size expected. IF COMMERCIAL, indicate the type, whether neighborhood, city or regionally ort'entod, square footage of sales area, and loading facilities. Clwo t -el) IF INDUSTRIAL, Indicate type, estimated employment per shift, and loading facilities, T IFINSTITUTIONAL, NSTITUTI t NAL,Ibenefitsn be iidethe major rom function, estimated ernplol-ment per shift, estitttated ocnupency, loading facilities, and -.� ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES'* J Identify potentially significant environmental Impacts associated with the use permit. What project design features or special conditions of approval (mitlgatian measures) are proposed to alleviate potential environmental Impacts? 10 ENVIRONMENT AL, SETTING* Describe the project site as It exists before the project, thcl,iding information on frnpoyraphy, soil stability, plants and ant- Q mals, a.ntl any cult.: at, historical or scenic; aspects. Describe any existing structures an the site, and the use of the structures, J CL. Describe the surrounding properties, including Information an plants and animals and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects, CL Indicate the type of (and use (residential, commercial, etc.) intensity if land use (single-family, apartments, shops, depart - CC meat stores, etc.), and scale of development (height, frontage, setback, rear yard, etc,). Use separate sheet for longer responses, /wci,�; 7, — "�09sld -�4-)wr rr�Ji-aC &I ,I .7 I hereby declare under penalty of perjury that I have read and undarst nd the I118truc4ons and that the foreagIng.8tatemente , are true, complete and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief, Mata e2e .r.,xppilcant'8 signature Dater YL +? • /T�4, Property owner's signature ..74r".G Use Permit Number `+ w Request: Use permit to fellow "f Location and size of pf.roel(s).-....,,,._;: r VERIFY: _ A.P, Number(s) Project Description Z– Ownership , Zoning and acquirements .1Prnnf of Agency (if needed) Location Description 96 Copies of Plot plan 49 ILL CS ,,, f�,, Y� Gate Iaecekvea.� "1j (, , �Ci i G receipt Numtaer., U 0 Application taken by ... a`InnSnq t MAR 24,1987` r1�4 OrovilIN CaMigpda PENTECOSTAL CHURCH OF GOD L.. TtgCaUMINb' 'L-, 'A ••—• ' NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA, INC. IN CST{1'Efl co A�. 7605 Lauppe Lane Gurus Heights, Califvrni� 95621 0) 723-2467 $UPERINTENCIENT bt: p.i• 5iandridgc Noven1be'r 27t 1986 (916) 711.5217 Butte County P]anni:ng Commission oroville, California Gentl.menr Re: Authoritation for Applicant - Pastor Dave 'Brown to sign APPLICATION FOR USE PERMIT and APPLICABLE FORMS NECESSARY FOR OBTAINING A USE PFRMIT. reEsnml. pcicsend S.irtV'P. W-111% 009) 3604122 The Pentecostal Church Of God( Northern District of is California non-profit religious California0 Inc.; a corporation whose State', Corporat on Number is 1941970, and whose Federal Identfication Number is 94-11:22276. The Full Gospel Tabernacle (Pentecostal Church of Gadd is a sub-unit of the above stated corporation. The Senior pastor of the Full Gospel Tabernacles 7582 Irwin Street] Palermo, Ca is Reverend Dave Brown. Reverend Dave 13rown is hereby authorized by the Pentecostal Church of God, Northern District cf.:'' S�Ca�TAR19ta ges<rend H.L. Kodwtlo Application For Use Permit 'California, Inc. to sign the App (4161 729 M as well as applicable forms necessary for obtaining a, Use Permit on the prop=rty shown on the enclosed. APPLICATION FOR tJSE PERMIT You magi direct any questions egarding this letter to Robert L. Hardcastlej District Secretary & Treasurer for the above stated corporation at the phone number listed at the heading of this correspondence. Sincerely yours; R, L: RAR6'.,.ASTLZ District Secretary & Treasurer Ri-i; rh a compfile: palermo 26--08-20, etc. 26-08-53 etc -� 26-13-2-008, etc. Bon Buckley Steve Mzsso 7079 Irwin Ave. 5893 Skyline Dr. PaJermo,t CA 95968 Tom Sanders Bl Sobrante CA 94$.03 30011 2 Olive Hwy,. Ornville, CA 95966 26^0$-26 26-08-65 26••: 3-2-.11 j etc. Emery Shamblin Roderick MacLeod Don Armitage P -,O. Box 94 1.611 Feather River Blvd,. 2440 Baldwin Ave X''alermo, CA 95968 Oroville, CA 95965 Palermo, CA 95968 26-08-27 26-08-66 26-13-2-15 Loyd Dugger John Aughe wm Vairse 814 Ralph Ave. P.O. Box 153 . Manteca, CA 95336 Palermo, CA 95968 7127 Irwin Ave. P4ermo, GA 95968 26-08-29 26==08-E7, etc. 26-13'-3-Ol, etc. Jack Hopper Cliff Scheer Harold Balaz P.Q. Box 326 7087 Irwin Avenue � 25..1. N. Villa Palermo,, CA 95968 Palermo, CA 95968 Palermo, CA 95968 26-08-31 26-08-71, etc. 26-18-c3-03, etc. Mildred Hard Murel Mosby 7042 U Josephine Burns 7032 Fulton Avenue peer Palermo Rd. 2587 N. Villa n Palarttto, CA 95568 Palermo, CA 95968 Palermo, CA 95968 t 26-08-39 26-08-73 27w06--04 i Robert McFarlin Lester Orman Melvin Mosby One Galleria Twr 1022 Fulton Avenge 2671. Messz,na Avenue Ste. 265 Palermo, CA 95968 Palermo, CA 95968 Dallas, Texas 7524.0 26-08-00 26-08-74 27_06--51 James Ervin i Nina Smith Caro' P004 Box 401 2651 Messinc-1 Avenue I, Mainczno Palermo, CA 95968 Palermo, CA 95968 `v�„ Ful�erth Rd Qt Olws Landing, CA 95818 26-08-49 _ 26-13_2-fJ07_; etc. � � 27- 06-5 ; Harold Ewing Vmma, Chancellor 7046 2435 Nottl•t Villa J,�tY,es Horton 7049 Upper Palermo ,Rd Palermo,Fulton 9on Ave.�'i96F3 Palermo, CA 959 5 Palermo, CA 95968 J 26-08-48, etc. 2fi- 3-2-004 27-08r-39 G" can Taylor Walter HW .Juan Charles P•Q. Box 1.63 P.O. B0)1-42 1�rwii7 2591 es ' Palermo; CA 95568 Palextr,,�;, CA 95968 Villa Ave. alarm o CA 95968 Z6"08``46 ?6�a.-2:.n05 " 2708-63, ei::cz 'P.O.Oxley 1 Dc1%id Young � Henry Billington I�cin bile P. y O. Box 43 25,55 N. Villa Ave, I t�alermo, CA9596B.�a.!.ctx;mo, CA 95968 ? y x al.ermO CA 95968 26-98-47 26�-1.-2�-6A�i N Richard Bills c0di 'Pennock �.0. Box 63.9 P.Ok, Boit 388' p-481 843 053 RECEIPT AOR CESTIFIEri MAIL trLF1 Gospel Tabernacle lrxvin ,_Avenue Kr Palermo, 95968 Ui 5,.3.en"3Ri'�Ste _sf €lE +.• 0[9[87 i -,�" "`"'�'-„"'�`� •Q�..r--•-may`; -.,,. --� 14-1 d A611 PLANNING COMMISSION ? COUNTY CENTER DR'VE OROVILLU', CALIFORNIA 95965.3397 PHONE; 539•7601 October 9, 1987 Full Gospel Tabernacle 7582 Irwin Avenue Palermo, Ca. 9596.8 OFRTIFIEb MAIL Re; Use Permit, ALP 26-08-.20 (ptft) Gentlemen: Enclosed is your validated Use Permit No. 87-42 to allow p`rop4rty zoned AR -14H-1 Iodated at a church on Palermo Road and North Villa Aienue the northwest corner of U > Palermo. Peer Should you have any questions regarding this office between 1.0:00 a.m, and 5:00 � thy” matter, please contact. Sincerely..,, . A: K rcter Director of Planning ti BAIL; lr D'nc.M do; Department of Public Forks C2j Environmental Health Department of Forestry Inter-Departmental TO: Memorandum Butte County Assessor's Office FROM: Butte County Planning Department SUBJECT: Full GosPr=J. Tabernacle DATE: October 9 1987 Pursuant to Section 65863.5 0 Parcel identified as AP 26-08-20 f the Government Code, the fr�l+ Lwin iportion) , was: .� Rezone from to----_, tonin g district. Granted a variance to X:' Issued a~� conditional use Permit for a church, t USE PEI:MIT BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING Cf3KM I SS I ON October 9. 1987 DATE (Certified H( 1 Rea;') 'E37-4 PERMIT NO __6P :�6- 08- C pen ) T ASSESSDR IS PARCEL NICs. P_ctal Pursuant to the provi+slons of the Zoning Ordinance of the ;County of Butte and the s p- conditions set forth below: Fu`1 1 Gospel. Tabornacl e is hereb+, application filed. 3/24✓SZH-to eallow aUchurch se 1�ont in accordance with orated of the c?'.`^th�+aest co�wner o}+ U property zoned AR-MH-1!� Avenues Palermo. peer Palermio Road antl North Villa 'Failure to comply with the conditions specified fied herein as the basis for approval of applicatlon and issuance f Permit, o constitutes cause foe- the revoc$,tion of said parait 'In accordance with the procedures set forth In the Butte Count Zon I rag Enabl 'rncu Ord I trance,. y 2. Unless otherwise pa^ov i ded for In a tczond t I rn to a use p6rm i t ,: ali conditions must be completed by the months of the delivery of the counttzrsc'c'"m I tees within ' i permitteew t gna�. permit to the 3. If any use for Which'a use 'permit Inas been granted is not established within one year Of the date Of receipt of the coOntersigned permit iay the permittee' the permit Shale be came nu"Il and void and reapplication shall i_�e required be establish theusewto 8PECI CONDITIONS: 1. Install septic, tank and leach lines per approvedp lan Lander and inspection from the Health bepaartment permit 26 Install well under permit and. ItjSpec+ion from th Uepartment. e HealthDeed . 3, NorthV i 1 1 a 2t radius return at Intersection of Upper Palermo grail 4 Cohstrutt 16 feet of r -c ,"way Gtr the north side of Nraa"•th Villa and 1 feet of roadway on the south side of North Villa Along entire property frontage. TyOlca1 vection tai bo 2" Type B AG and 80 CIMss 2 ASS 5- Provide a solution to drsinage which Is acceoteble to the Department of Pub! is Works. Drainage shall not be directed Into i „- .... _ roadside d i bches . Any drainage Plan shall be sugrn i teed w 1 th the requisite fees All drainage facilities required quired shall be 6. Replace existing culvert with 18 pipe, i. Install a left 'turn lane at North Villa and Upper requ i red by the Department o f Pub 1 c 4iOrks Or const,r�,ci;r�ghpaharid turn lanes along Upper Palermo at. North Villa. �• Install a well and holding sufficient to meet CpF fire: flow requ i rements�raft i �� � � cnne��;t i ons 9: Meet the requirements of the State (ire Marshal 10.Foundation and design shall be subjected to careful engineering analysis with respect to lateral farces. g ring 11- provide parking and landscaping Code Section 24-35. tte County in accordance with gu areas. e. uire 12. No sign or building shall b Placed Within n the rE±q d setback 18: Applicant must also Comply with all other applicable State aid local statutes, Ordinances, and regulations. at id hereby declare under foregoing conditions, that theyalareOjn perjury a Jtuthetc� conditions read the Imposed upon the ons which were granting of this use permit$ and +:)gat I agi^ee to ab,i de folly by safci'condtions. ibTiiE tai Issuance Of this Use Pormlt does not waive requirement of g :' 9 ,, Department permit, before starting �+btatnin Dur�din and He�1th Lle artmen construction nor does it n�:,ive an other r y require Butte County p) artn 1 i7g Cotr,m J .sas i on Cha i r man CG pepar`tment of Public Works C 2 Health Oepartment Department of Forestry 0FFICIAL 0USINESS P'rlrtt your ,aSENQEO (NSTRUCTION9« ' ono below, � • .t:omplate items 1, 4 3, and 4 an a trovarat: ' i Attach to front of article If spacermita,' T � � w" „» ",,, ,... �.► " 001 N lrX.Qr-j . atherwM4 affix to buck of article. \ qtj r rC ♦ Endorsaarticle"ReturnfistelptRaq�le*tWd ' • pi„�1�f�iiNG CC�.MIS €OSd ad rteIt 1 to number. County enter Drive RETU�ttV' Orovilie, CA 95nfi5»4;��� TO ,� Ir (Ne m*of lirndear # f �.an�1\ 19 +,. tip tai AP 26 08� (ft:altl>tt�a._ . (N*,+And s� P.O. Box of W.P. N0.} 6pltrt,AVt,Suit 1,,,. /►� 198 (City4 State, end ZIP Code) Crcv to* Std, C It it tl �= a ess inrthe Rc FURR! T0• spaceton the- .- o�.•.a.w.�.paurnaa_aGtnrsWgg'!.prevent Inigcaraarom ' 'Seing returned.to you. The eaturrrrecelpt fee will'ooyide' yav-the nams of. the Person delivered to and the trate of deilvery. Faradditionai reel thefalirnvinp services are available CCnsuttposftTi - r for fees and shack box{es? 2or zerviee(s)-requested. 1' EX Show to whom, date and address of delivery. 2.. Q Restricted bat(very. 3. Article Addressed_ toi Full Gospel Tabernacle 7582 Irwin Avenue Pplermo, Ca.. 95968 +4: Tvoe of Service: Article Number - �istered Q Insured E certified A(waSrire ofaddreuea ragen: and DATE DECtvc �c7i. 5: Signeture — Addressee x 7 Date of De ery` £ E � YsrersWmAddress (OXLYlf rmWWed 4i d fee jvW) NEGATIVE DECLARATION REGARDING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT 1, NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the project described b plow has been reviewed pursuant to the provisions of the Californi,4 Environmental Quality Act of 1970 (Public Resources `Code 21.100, et„sea,) and a determination has been made that it will not have a s,IEnificant effect upon the environment. AP (ptn� Log 87=04-02.05 2 DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT Use Permit to allow a church 3: LOCATION OF PROJECT: At the northwest corner of 'Upper Palermo Road ,and North Villa Avenue, Palermo 4 NAME AND ADDRESS OF PROJECT APPLICANT Full Gospel, 'tabernacle 7582 Irwin Avenue Palermo, Ca, 95968 5 )MITIGATION MEASURES: See Attached 6. A copy of the initial study regarding the envi,ronmbnta,l effect of this proj( t is on file at 7 County Center Drive, Orovil.le. This study was: Adopted as presented. ❑ g Specific Adopted with Changes. Seci,��c modifications and supporting reasons are attached, 7. A public hearing on this Negative Decl.arat.ion was held by the decisionmaking body. Hearing Body Butte County Planning Commis aon' Date of Determination September 17, 1987 Determination: On the basis of the initial study of environmental impact, the information presented at hearings, comments received on the proposal and our own knowledge and independent research: We find the proposed project COULD NOT have a significant FRI effect on the environment, and a. NEGATIVE DBCLARAT?`ON is hereby adopted We f'i.ne that the project COULD have a significant effect on the environment but will not in this case because of ❑ attached mitigation measures described in item 5 above Which are by this reference made conditions of project approval: A Conditional NEGATIVE DECLARATION is hereby adopted,, Signature Carl. Walter, Chairman Butte County planning Commission Title Date P 535 012 864 r' RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL NO INSURANCE COVERAGE PROVIDED NOT FOR: INTERNATIONAL MAIL [Sem Reversef se"Villl Gospel Tabernacle Street and No. 7582 r °P.O., State and ZIP Code Palermo. Ca. 95958 Postage 5 CartifieaFee Spectat Delivery Fee Restricted Delivery Fee Return Receipt, Showing to whorn and Data Delivered Return receipt showing to wham, Date, And Address of Delivery TOTAL Postage and Fees g Postmark sr Date 5/28'/87 � •,�,�-tom •�:`;d-.� `f � 'Nell .a.a._ jY r,• .. AU ILANNING COMMISSION 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3397 September 28, 1987 'HONE; 536.760 Full Gospel Tabernacle 7582, Irwin Avenue Palermo, Ca. 95968 CERTIFIED MAIL Ret Vse Permit, AP 26-08-20 (ptn) Gentlemen: We are enclosing the Permit No, g original and one co 87-42 to allow e church on PY of Your conditional Use at the northwest corner of c property zoned AR-1fj-1 located Palermo. Both copies must bepper signedxando returned toad and o Villa Avenue,1 within 30 days from the receipt of this o this department them validated by the Chairman of the Butte County We will then have and the original wi11 be returned to Y tannin you for g Commission Please be Your records, aware that failure to returermn the days wi3.1 result in the use to signed copies within 30 ` Projects department would the itbecoming saryinvalid,proceedaPPication with the ' The Uspplicant is deemed the a granted when this permit has been signed Planning t' with the counter si nature g Commission, and said g of the Chairman o0 the registered mail, permit is received by the applicant by Should you have any questions t ' this office between 10:00 a, "egardng this matter; ple m. and 3t00 P.M. rise contact S�incere7,y B, A, Kircher Director of planning BAK1r '8nc . I OFPICIAl. BUSINESS' MIDER INS7RUCTION3 Print your name, address, and;4P Cod'b O W, I see below, �- A Camplsto hems 1, 2:3, and 4 of the,reverse.. o Attach to frim of article if sprico permits, iiE.h LTY FOR PRIYAYt othoivilsp sffutto hack of article. COUNTY OF BUTTE use sa ticle"Retu;Raeeipiegsted" .rPLANNING COMMISSION number. R'{ URN 7 County center Dave Orayill, CFS 9565-3�7 k TO �,�,� tNomu rrf Sottdorj;� r3' ..nrr�Ti-�—Cry'` TIP A, 26- 0+eo,S planning Com p [vu i 6No. noel &traUt, Apr, aito P O..Bo SEP 3: 1987 ;. Colfy., state, and ZIP Code) �"?royiiler Calitarnia 1, h ':� Z1. . fOtt Items -1 2.3 and �< Comp t,won -the o ••RET0" TQ" spfro o` Put Youc address tri th ravens thiv it rdr ide' 3 reverse Sioa- Failure io do this;Wltl p _ to being returned to You or.pnrdelivo d to attd 3t8of at the tottowtnB icesare, cu the name of" the detive _ tFnr additional fe ter Sof fe�s:attd chop t- avadablo. Consultpostm e w__etsl roquestod. doiiymir �� } Show ,hom,dataSndaddressOf' cato F -a Restricted: Qelfv9rY� 3. Article Addressed to - in at• e Pull Gospel Tabern 7582 Irvin Avenue Palermo, Ca... 95968 q cwe Number d. Type of servles d Registered. COded p 535 Ql2 864 IM: CeRifted L , Express a gntand Aiways obtaRnsignatu,e of addli estr- 9 QATEDEttVERED 5. Sl9naturo"Y AddrecsoQ a _ o X 6 Si9f aturc - AtOnt �Y. Dat Oelive ifrequeste A_ Addrg Address (©da /i, lig AIL W' ®r coun PLANNING COMMISSION 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3397 PHONEa 538.76U1 September 18, 1987 I Full Gospel Tabernacle 7582 Irwin Avenue Palermo, Ca. 95968 Re Use Permit, AP 26-08-20 (ptn) Gentlemen: At the regular meeting of the Butte County Planning Commission held September 17, 1987, your request for a Use Permit to allow a church on property zoned AR -MH -1 located at the northwest corner of Upper Palermo Road and North Villa Avenue, Palermo, was approved sub ect to the following conditions: j 1. Install septic tank and leach lineser approved pproved plan under. permit and inspection, from the Health Department. 2. Install well under permit and inspection. from the Health Department, 3: Deed 20 fto radius returns at intersection of Upper Palermo and. North Villa. 4, Construct 16 ft, of roadway on the north side of North Villa and 12 fte of roadway on the south side of North Villa along entire property frontage, Typical section to be 2" Type B AC and 8i1 Class 2 A8. 5. Provide a solution to drainage which is acceptable to the Dapartment of Public Vorks. Drainage shall not be directed into roadside ditches. Any drainage plan shall be submitted with the requisite fees. All drainage facilities required shall be installed. 6 Replace existing culvert with 18i1 pipe. I, Install a left turn .lane at North Villa and Upper Palermo Road if required by the Department of Public Works or construct right, hand turn lanes along Upper Palermo at. North Vi11a..