Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout028-170-028r`..,rt�,,,+-x-:'rtr,,, w.,.Y,.«--wa ..„>n5i..'4d,. Y .'nin':"'_'!`'.=,.•.�wa ":.w+"",r. ..,:.: K Yi k—'iu�.r+ "*,+r' .ip r Meq {.*d'<y�i :.' t. : , �(1 Yyu.r`�rit'i'e.i��i,�'r'lj.Ma't�,� .,._ .4 Mt�MIaW+ „ 1 1, ,.,'I��iL�iLytYllJ�m--�.-.T-: �� n�� -us�� r�,,,�w.,i,C+ysm`_»'F1��1•.�+34'IYri.�'T,7R"^t�»'<+'if�^ J' T"�'�' M��Pt�,n, - i , 17 I 4 1` v , r•f ar t r r t ; 1 f : t. I , I♦ 1 7r _., , �u. ar. .. .' � ':��'R7�1 36iA�itk�k`�Il�'1r`etu'-"4`e7:�i+rro�taxe�hiri'rt�Y"ara&i,�i@irb6�eidh�ah6e.��tiidlrrHta�kt�.rctiLiS�ei�aui�3re%61(les&sa16d`Yl�iilFeS'.+�NYo�l6itlhaUii$eit4t�N�id411� "' dillfirnr"rn'iligtl�n Y �'C'��1'!d�':SiiFsm&ItidtrGltlti�'wrS�,�J'avy'63r:au,awt44i�d:... _ Si.. t G7 26 \ 4 35 r. bd ! ". 25 25 3Q_,-_ cw, wn WE sr 3536"• _ I f - ,. 3 31 e•vr. - A-5 937 w. 1071 _ A M.R ;� jS — r. �' -*` � r. Y 3 } , •i\ \ - { � .1071 fp d ; -5 p , { ,s t �>w r 4. ,� :[. - - w 1 1071 937 r , „ .' : _ :. 1,1 �•.* may+` i�. - , .. !� " i � ! i ` .. ;_, \. �c •. , - , INDEX ''MAP' g '. : , _ , � . ` v 1'..' r.-, ', ., i 11 : .: u '. . / "1) •' '.MO'. .84LG .: � '. ,. yKi :moi ..-.:c ° ^., , ,y ,.. ' :+�., ,,.. .'., ! ^ .'... li •.iy'�1 ... 3" � '^ �: 7-':i ,r'. ,.��;. 4.s.x...,�4 � • awi-LIKE mw r7[ '8 11 , k r«.. Be II , 13 -77 .:::: , -,.. f r -.,'.z,- 1`o- . -' ,. ,. ,:- :. .. .,. , ..... n _,,,>., ,. ;., ' .,.. -:• �. ... ,.. .. ^, �.., �% d, r 7& y x A 'g :r i 1 /' 1, " [-: ';. w ; / / 1071 V Q A $ BUTTE COUNTY, CAUFORNIA - ZONING DISTRICT MAP r' r , rr` I0«� lu �'♦•f 1 !''�• .mak , l - 'A5 If ,11 r r 9071 . �, t rye 1 n " •. �1 Ip lr[t!• �i ��wr". t�t1 _...a.,.++' �� 1.7 I I 1 a, r • n to b to , ' � 1 { (tT z ', � ' i '-11 12, 11121-71 A-5 �1� rC•'v 937 1091 d� - t jl A-5 - 6 937 ----.., i - 12/ 1 1056. v:_.Ia 1 .i I9 ,�.-..,„,.,•..« ..,... r--.. ,... «,n,.� ...r,.. -.n: _ \ S G ., a: " I a1 ," «Y[T. , x., : •' � €�'.'-wN,r-+wa _. .. '�" - PgiP _tioyyipN _.64!0 _..�,♦ r' t, \' e :. .. rJ.wr., -,:,e •�+ r, ''` I. G. t ♦ ,,,,�"`�' \Yr- f r 4.5 N µ M -R yt F r � 1t �� iota -R M-R i' .: 6, ,dj 07t'( b ,, 056 1 ` _ r, LG4 /fy , 4w ow yW, r SCS '`Jfe, d ✓ r ,'; ✓ �•. �; t� ,f,, Ll. ; �, - `, , € ` BUTTE OU COUNTY CAL FORN A ZONING DISTRICT I MAP 937 , 1071. 'kr 1 ::: ', ,'1 ♦ '.� ,`, ri n C ,�' 1\r ,� ..e• .. „ \,.w ,, :, K:NMNG Wn0t011. r 9 10 ,; \ ,ar+ ' C` _11 12 ° 1217 ro mP— w�/ - �.. - ""'•.'�"".�.'' F j '.,, 14 IJ. 13IB aP o:lt Lr bnP ba[ et . w•�a..�%e' � � i ...�,—.,_»+....,r. �� i V`as»—_ yii� Df4 _, I / e , ' f C » I I A-5 y A t b3 jS A-5 937 f 4 107€ JM � w r^ �[ tt• , ✓ I4 _ J, 14 13 � 13 18 I3 I4 /r�g �d��C 16 18: i t 23 24 — -� 24 19 L.✓ w , ll p , 1i t P ..� t �� _ SANGOk 5NEEt G KIF IY. _ ' :.. - t�iieuw..,.,._,t�.�.a1tie�,..,zw:N„ar:...:,.: •'>�...._a�.'.sFe:b:»,�t::_.._e�:'..i<•�. : - .. - , t , r I'F�O EC's SUMMARY SFI�� �3-� ' Pita NO. Pern- t No. 1 McMa%n �`anay D',- -_ r ,(i�..c:7� zr�'-rum ppaicartt �. t las S 113 Blazeford Gulch Rd, (, Orovil l e, 'GA 95965 PRONE:: 589-4257, Same Property Owner, Address A -5 to AL3_" �,� -- �v'P� x I ,�.�z � PROJECT DESCRIPTION:` Rezone from -k-5 on ��art """'"`� modes of Swedes Flat Rd• ap rox located 1 1./2 miles east of Oroville-Bangor Highway O2$ -17O -G.. ? �� �.B � town/area Orovill.e M- identif;ed as AP Ag..-ResMap #i .� DATE Gene_ rat` Plan Designation - Pre -App Fee Pack Receipt No.: - 9-11-92 FPPlication A✓epted1275,4Rece:p No.:131.80 FinalAPP: Paid= Rezoning Petition signatures checked. Mailing List: P repaTed Noticesriaed Number: Mews: Public: -- Legal Description Prepared; 2 -- Publication -Publication Notice Written Display Ad Prepared .Newspaper Publication C P G B R Date of Pub.: Initial Study Prepared: ------------- Environmental Determination.: Categorical Exemption Nagative Declaration Mitigated Negative Declaration —" Environmental Impact Peport - Other State C3' ringhouse Number Notification. o€ Environmental Deterrunatic Apphcant/ReprEsentativa Planning Commission ,l �:,ring(s): ` Y fid" �• �, Roard of Supervisors' Hearing(s), Adopted: ResolutionNumber (GPA-.) v �'-J "fir "F 0 TT `` •-�ti..,-'-tiw,.� l Li 8 r..-� r_dub] is he rIn o Ric derat o McM��ir , Dutch rt�man's Club consi Randy Dan of a np rezone g (propos, egative decZarataon regarding dnvirortmental impact) 1-5 f'6 (agricultural,,, fiVe acre parcels to FR-- � recreatidhal ' 40 acre ) 40 fodth��l Parcels), approximately 846 drldo- located on both s'ic%es of Swedes Flat Road a pprokimate+�,�' 1 1/2 milks east of QrbVjlle-P,angor Highway, AF 028-tla 0281 028--320-003, 072-3. -016 and 018, orcville a ar (2545) (**06) MO`DIO,Ni S MOVE TO DEFY THE REQUEST FOR RE?ONE. ` S VOTE: 1 Y 2 Y 3 Y X 5 Y Unanimously` Oarried) w, i ��i WOuyM'J:«.G M1.lrt'1i7 �� ,176i`CirLw�w""t74 K Dutch av �n Snort c n' , ` 0:30 a.m. E .Y. -D � � b- prOpOSCd �1Qj 1 , ISS. regarding environmental impact and j e .one from A - (Agricultural 5 acre parcels) to FR -40 (Foothill Recreational m 40 aCM parcels) for property �' located on both sides of Swedes Flat Rottdt approximately 1.5 miles' east b,f Oro -Bangor ;highway, identified as AP 028`- 1.70-028, 028-320-003,,072-330-016 and 018, Oroville. ('Re 93-08) (CICS) The Commission waived the heading of the Staff Findings: Chairman Lynch said all the Commission was considering today was a rezone and not the intended use of the land: He asked people to address the rezone request only, The hearing was opened to the public. Virginia Berglund, representative of 'Dutch Ravine, said she was there to answer questions: Wilma Shirley, asked what the difference .was between A: R and FR -40 coning? She waned to know what was allowed icy � the FR zone? Staff explained the. 'FR zone. Staff said the A -R zoning designation is much more restrictive in the allowed uses and the uses requiring a Use Permit: Staff. said the FR zoning designations allows some commercial, uses with a Use Permit including recreational clubs. Commissioner Nelson said there will need to be an additional hearing to deal with a sports club. Staff said he was correct leis. Shirley said she signed the petifiblii against this project, but after farther, consideration was not necessarily against the rezone: Mr, Shu4ey said he Was in favor of the rezone. He said this 'rezone has the potential to increase tike tax rate and the potential to bring, in revenue. %lane Monsol said she was against this rezone. She submitted a pedf!.6p, with 159 vvho d iagree with the rezone. Sf6e suited, she was willing to take PAr; people ,,. p y p homes around the gun Shirle s name �pff of "the et�tion. She 6brnttted a map, of 1 :J7'iibUNTY P�,P,NNICfJt^.N1F'C3Jrt�4.'�' 3, V r„ n= �� f) 1 club. She said Swedes Flat Road will not take the traffic asso��iate She said the gun club is alread using hi r d with a bu§1119Ss, Y g high sower rifles on the property. She dodg ,Ywt fire area. She did not want ca. Permitco later. She said this is t , h want a rezone that will allow a. Use Pe � k . nmercial uses allowed in this area: She said the rdad-Is in very bad shape. She submitted pictures of the narrow road. Manfred Schiediclt Swedes Flat Road, said the County should take into cons . that people have been stopped from going under 40 acre parcels because of deer e fdert(t.on He said the deer herds are a major .consideration by Fish and Game, He said r.. herdg, i . g P he w no ,allowed to split his kind because of the deer,. He said •there �s no room ori. the t't11,td far emergency vehicles. He did not want out of fiwn traffic being br�bu lit into th Ile said he has grandchildren in direct view of tue g e tik,Oa poachers to his livestock. 1 club, He uvas into. with Robert Schiedick said his house is directly in line with the concerned because he has two children. He is concerned with hi club, high power said lie Jr,r, rifles bd11J& Med. He said a n club nest door will destroy his property values, Patricia Lipchak said she was concerned with erosion of the land b addin different livestock into the area. Y more told John Quinn said his land i's adjacent to China Wall Road i i and Game that his prop er could not be divided because of the cri was advisiWd by 1lailx P , A ty range. He said his roe tical winter',deer herid club is allowed. property �' would be useless if this zoning ,goes through and tj4e h a gdo Prank White said his concerns have becn covdred and he is againstthisro' P J ec,t. Torrianna Reedy said she has small children who walk to the school h»r s Mgt Road and it is a trafltic hazard now. She did not want an increa;�r:e;. � � i. ,"..�vede i said There are 15 children who use this road. .n tie traffic;, She by Stubbs said lie concurs, Lorain .A, Brown said her property adjoins the g!in club. She said fences ;have ahead been cut: She said she was against this protect because of the den dangerto lze _ Y g r clvldrei. )Richard Strelsky said there is only Mom for one car+ atinYe on Swedes He was agai'ast the projec"t: ; w des Mat load. Guth Holt; 1M -11n. AyLnc ,Fred Hol>; and Anthony p4lon%ba s were not present. tgoed cards to speaiC� but qty COCJl' '� ti4 ��:�u.rr.�....'... ..., ,. ws " , Par1i����G :.��IC1i�..l���S�x� lean Simard said the noise is verygad when people are shooting. Shooting she can even hear the eople at the nShe said during: §,k.4 is shooting it sounds life a war zone. She v, a club say. path She skid v��bcn ttl<xe gamst the project: Ery Knorzer said he would like to play a tape Jerry . l of the gun shots for the Cana.m $S101lx afford to repair bounty can not afford this rezone. P road. He said the County, 'cart- ,tot Michael Pierce, Chinese 'Wall. Road,, said a gun club is aaot an a r land. He said a comane°cial PP opri,�te lase, of lj1Xs rezone might gun club as not appropriate art this area. He said. tho is not app oprbatc: �Hepsaid there It ,is a way for the gun club to be est,tb�lish,ed l s no water storage in the area. He said, the jtztl reason to rezone this area. He was against the project. He said safety is a b' islxLe, He said; he talked to Mr. Snowden with Fish and G wants to take a closer look at this project.Ze asked' the C g ;tee and Mr. Snowden told h�axi lte request. ommssion to deny 11116 ',Prix. Knorzer said on November 21, 1992, some commtuiit3, members met an was in attendance. He said at this meeting, Mr. McMain stated hunted d Mr. F°tf domesticated. He said hogs were discussed as domestic animals, animas will fid said they did not need a permit or hunting license, and FishHand tGamelYlttl t .lass np jurisdiction, over diem. Mr. Krtorzer called Jim Snowden,e Fish and Game and Snowden said he would look at the whole aperataoax if requested b M16 COMInission. He said the Deer herd r4vge calls for no exotic animals to y the Plannitxg into the area. He was against the project. be introtlucl Virginia Berglund said they are not responsible for the traffic on Swedes M said there is no bunting, no animals being released, no hi at Road, She admitted the fence was bad. She said she was not responsible Power hersused. She, shooting lit the middle of the night. She said she opened the club on or people She said Mr. Pierce talked to them and then went to the Board oi` Suu ervisoy 192; C; She said Fish and Game issued a license for pheasant hwn She and Said after the complaint, the business stopped. g ad MS. Monson said she hears the shots. She said there is'. a lot trafuc. She did not believe these people were not being charged a shots tand a lot is i Shoot at this 16 years and Mr. McMa' hasfacility, She Said she feels sonl x mess Is still gomg on. She said she has been there y there. 6 months. Mri heariPierce He said the A -F. zo 'p : d to be a Use e.:. said if this rezonemisna asro ed there would still nee Permit there,would be no ne,Ad for a l`JSe Permit hearing He said it was the Commission° then ore restrictive. and should be n held ,and to preserve the peace `and trap uili of the area, s 'duty, q iy U'�TE; COt)gt'ypLANNCNOC7'-iSStJ * �� R Mrs. tyhva *� tjd she was here to discuss the rezone only, dens is potentially higher for AR-5 than k'It-4p Y 5h said she, the�i% lC llie Mr. Knorzer played the tape of the shooting noises. He said t because the Code Enforcement Officer ave lbir, his hearing was beita 111c1 Club and the neighbors do not agree, He said this business g McCain permission to operate the §'��',ts started. should never have ##4 Commissioner Nelson said the Commission is process' . a Use Permit for a gun club. Ing a rezone only, not,proedmdpt MS, Berglund said she was told to stopthe business and she did. Louis Brown wanted to know who .:mild pay' for road if • ' subsequently a Use Permit. this is approved and ;, The lcdring was closed. Cha rman Lynch said he was concerned with co mments from -Fish and G and w.h Game state,bents made in conflict with staff: tie su,;gested this heating might be continued, Comrt{issioner Ostrowski asked if Swedes Flat Road was �l Co unty Staff said ,es , Staff said Public 'Works is res onsib Road? discussion .on tl4wtt was �� formin P le for the road. Staff said i owners, at tL�at time, were not ing a dist, ct for n,aintainin n the past, g the road, but the pt'opel k, Chairman .Lynch said he would .like the a 'Code Enforcement questions and � n'ish &Game, offiicer .here to He said he would ask dsrcct questions and kcer hearing closed ii',, this is continued. Commissioner Lambert asked if this area will be considered ered in the Coun l' .� p ty Cr.,neral Plant Staff said there will be some changes in the area, Staff said tv" acre zoning to 40 acre parcels, ill probably gorglri ,,.�,, Commissioner Lambert talked about a motion to have People r P Present ;such as the Code to January 28 1993 member of Fish, and Gari e, and cont` , Bnforc,ement Officer She said ,` roue- this iie _ ' , e to Bear from Fish and GW ne mg closed Staff said Fish & G s e wat: lit " policies are to protect ;i.habitat for ;the deer trot to regulate ,�4 � shooting of the,�,deer, e . • i i — y Commissioner Lambert said FR-40is not a rbble problem. p m, but, a Use Permit would li# a Commissioner Nelson also had no problems with the F@-40 zoning, Statf said the AR -5 zoning gives people a false sense of being able to develop to S a�;re pare#tls. It was unanimously VecarriedCommisloner Lambert, seconded by Commissioner I�lelson, tttxd recommend approval as follows: A. Find that the requirements of CEQA have been completed and considered In. making this decisionand adopt a Negative Declaration regarding environmett;l impacts; and B. Find that the rezone conforms to the policies, including the text and map of the Butte County General Plan; and C. Recommend that the Board of Supervisors adapt an ordinance rezoning to 40, those properties identified as A& 028.170.028, 028.320-003 72-330-016 and 01.18 (Dutch Ravine Sportsman's Club). Chairman Lynch said the rezone is appropriate because it falls into the..averlay of the . DE0,r Herd Zone. He said it was not reasonable to use a zone tc� try to stop a use when: that zone is appropriate i ,. S-• ;. W,OUN�J.,140 n H FP u' <tt� [Y )FILE NO.: 93-08 T urrE COUNTY YLANNIP4G COMMISSION STAFF FINIDINGS - November 30, 1992 APPLICANT: Dutch Ravine Sportsman's Club OWNER: Same REQ TEST Rezone from A-5 to IiR-40 AP NO.: 028-170-028, 028-320-0031 072-330-016 018 SISI $40+ acres LOCATION- On both sides of Swedes Flet Road, approximately 1.5 miles east of C'rc .angor Highway. EXISTING ZONING: A-5 ZONING HISTORY.- Zoned A-5 on Jan. 27, 1970 by ORd', #1071 SUPROU1VDINCT ZONING: A-5 ,SLAROUNDING LAND USE: Open land and rural residential uses' siTE HISTORY: N/A GENERAL PLAN IDESIGNNVON: Agricilltural-Resiial APPLICABLE REGULATIONS:„ Butte County Code Sections 24-2�i 'tl�r � r 29, u 24"72; and 24.112.8, C M N FNTS RECEi D' Public Works: None ` II BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFI± I'XNDINGS - November 30, 1992 rite �enartm�nta " , No Fire Department objections:' l�nvironmental { health: "No objections to the rezone. Any lend divisions irtust tne'e e Butte County Subdivision Ordinance." 1jl Mosnuito Abatement• "No foreseeable problem:" ALYSIS oca is a request to rezone approximately 840 acres from located in the southeastern foothills of the- County on both sides of Si�►�ede�' i Tile, ft,tiiaet'ty is Oro-Bangor Highway. The current zoning is A-5 which was adopted i Flat B�tttj `oast of the current General Plan policies. The property P n 1970 antit e-dates 8 to 480 acres. The 22 contiguous parcels atreragE 79+ a�resb Y parcels of varying,, from In size.. This project will result in a zoning {hat is more consistt;nt with the General Plan ` oIJI. �s 1han the existing A-5 zone. The A-5 zone was adopted in 1970, 9 Years before p Plan adoption in 1979, and does not meet the conditional development crit " W f I the current !neral Agricultural Residential designation for parcels less than 20 acres, The c t "� the consistent with the General Plan and Ives roe urrent zortltl 10 not Potential, for their property and is further misleading b cause thesarea sense of de en"t�,�ent agricultural uses# For a zoning with a minimum parcel size less than 2U acres tot surto Flo for with the Agricultural Residential General Plan designation the followin crit beyl'sic,t�t Present, g arailUtit be 1. Compatible with neighboring agricultural all ctivities. 2.Evidence, of adequate water and sewage disposal cdj;,u tyi 3. Avatlabili of adequate firth protection, facilities. , 4 Adequately maintained approved road access with sufficient capacity .`a to sc,, r!j �Jr44 5. Reasonable accessibility to commercial services and schools. Criteria 3 z and 5 are clearly not Present and; Criteria 21s questionable. lilt! tonin , rs to consider are as follnvws: 1; cto 1. Existing parcel sizes in residential densities, 2. Slope 3, Soil conditions and water availability 2 N; K 77 inn II f )JUIrm,, couNry P LANNING COMr.,IISSI4N f 't'A_f+'' 1~INniNGS - November Vit?, 1992 4, Effects on u ad'acent J uses, , CI'O and wildlife habitat. P Production, livestock grazing, forestry; resource' ��r.titcction 5, Proximity to public roads and other public facilities 6, Distance from airports, railroads, and industrial uses, Existing utility and drainage facilities: 8 Potential: for surface cracking, landslides and erosion. 93 Effects ork noise, traffic flora and safeti,, water u general environmental quality: qua Mr qualli,ty, Wildlilro f►ai�j,�#t nod 10 Local desires. 1-14 potential .for, pest infect breeding. In addition to the listed,tonin g factors, it must also be noted that this pro er within a designa.td,, critical winter deer range 'where th Game are recommending P P tY i' lrffted g parcels of 40 acres or greater. = a Taepartrnonf' of, piro� and @ Ce,liforni The applicant has made it clear that their ultimate goal is it) e recreatvna facility on-site which will include a huntiz; ' clan . a rifle range, archery course and stabIish a com,rnericiil'itr` clubhouse or lodge, lc some camping► and RV clay ghod"tirtg c ,t e have a provisiv: 1, This �s tl ,, pvssp in pursuin ts l.V sliace�i w,ti�t a +G��of)",Fl1 re first stop g goal since the A tar this P Under the PR -40 � "S z [l creation use requires a use df use. � ar,�e d� "not se permit; The applicants were ,dread ung an outdoor `i."oI'itl quad, c ukar and clear hunting on site this season, 00we�ver, Y p t=Pared to iilovv 1� owners Prompted the 1?lanrung btvasion to ,instruct the r'o ort ► cvncc,rns from �4't'.jrtjyr zoning ty AM a use perraiit were obtained. P, P Yew ier to st, .i pt , fij Of he hunting club to be, the focus oft ' The Con1mission should nv hur�titl t�, lil project shall have no bdarin PP t a�1lo�S►'ifyt�e outdoor recreation `fac'" g on the outcome of a��furtures a rez°ne+ii nd ,a ipro+�,sla rtf tai uxty other 'than to give the property owner he mgjtt to Itt 1 use, Bused upon the General Plan polices and criteria at'td upon e t Po [ PP Vr;i`cSY" f it 5 i ^' fi"A Game policies the ;proposed coning is more . ', he Departni ? 0 SE SUMAMEND a p for thA 'at'ea than the P ry ria e A, Mod that: the, re .quixeMents of CEe this decisiion ,anJ ado ,t a . be ci mpleted label. tj iVegativDeclaratio_ rot}s�dere'd trip w n rr�gardIng elxvironmental ix ap t %s ►nd ;i �I{ 'UIS MHP); F r -site drainage improvements rn Describe i.xtici ated on and off Aescribe haw on-site and downstream dratrn e channels will 6G affected C,I'11D, MiIP): _ + Water stiurCet Proximit of water` for fire fighting y g g purposes (hydrants, ponds, etc,) _l�f,�r._ Will excavation, or grading be necessary? .. ,-Cubic - Cubic yard, (estimate)? .14�— List and describe and other related permits and other public approvals required for this ptOjN i r if leludinl those required by city, regional, State and Federal agenciem if residential, include the number of units, whether units are single or multi -story in height, PArbedule, of unit sixes, and type ofhousehofd size c1,pccted, if commercial, indicate thet'ype, Wi�ether neighborhood, city or regionally odertked, squad FfiUw of, C+ ;saiesarea, and loading facilr ,If industrial, indicate type, estimated pmployment per shift, and loading facilities, if instiltutional indicate the major function, estimated employment per shirt, estimated 09011)ancy, loading facilitits, and eomrminfty b+'nefits to -be derived from the project, ij NVtRONiAI_NTAL IMPA&SAND MIT DATION MtA6,UR"t~S' f� potentially ja(�,�f�, li iNhtlt pr4��1. d tsign Identify features orspec al conditions of aon at�a1A1 im' acts assocrated �vitit the rezone, � P (Mitigation measures are proposed to a$I0.via l pt�+ntial ) p p + cnvfronnictttaimpacts'� _ � - �..._,, s jrb_;�w�� I �I , r� I. - i _ �.0?-b- CyZA c COG 011 4,. _ t� ._. ? L -'0, - r f s. _ -->- --- La re liq —. _ . e L_:- 028- 370 027 000 STATUS: ACTIVE a U I N JOHN & BEVERLY` 1 L: 072 2303 058 000 STATUS: ACTIVE _R DELFINO ANTHONY 238 CUESTA DRIVE SD SAN FRPNCISCO CA 94680-- 2625 BAILHACHE - HEALDSBURG: CA 45448 L; 029 370 R&2 GE;7I_ 57ATU QUINN JOHNRS: ACTIVE L: 072 230 058 000 STATUS: ACTIVE w ' DELFINO ANTHONY _ 2387 CUESTA DRIVE - SO' SAN- FRANCISCO CA 9`4CO803 2625 BAYLHACHE - HEALCSBURC CA 95448 U 028'370 028 000; - ;STATUS: ACTIVE. BIGLANB DEVELOPMENT CORP L: 0.72 230028'000 STATUS: ACTIVEE, C/O WANG &- WANG` HOEGER GEORGE J' &ELAINE TRUST' NO'320'SEG 4 CHUNG HS'IA0 E RD BOEGER GEORGE J & ELAINE TRUSTEES 15TH FLOOR, KUANG'FU BLDG 3564 BOEGER LANE TAIPEI TAIWAN'106 SAN JOSE CA 95148' L:- 628 370 .028 000 STATUS: ACTIVE - -=` _RIUGLAND' _DEVELOPMENT CORP- L: 072 230:028 000 � STATUS: ACTIVE - Clt� WANG & WANC 1 =_ _ _ _ , _ �1 DLJr-Qr- or-unur- J at ELAINE TRUST - _-" NO 320 SEC'4 CHUNG HSIA©'E RD - D15TH HL'-rER GEORGE J & ELAINE TRUSTEES' 15T , H FLOOR KUANG'FU BLDG` 3564-BOEGER LANE TAIPEI TAIWAN:10'6 SAN. JOSE CA 95146:' L: 028 370 03.1000 STATUS': ACTIVE TOMPKINS VAL 'R ETAL � L: 07E230 038 000 STATUS: ACTIVE - TOMPKINS:GAR:E PIERCE MICHAEL V'SS P 0 BOX, 7E BRENTWOOD,. CA 94513 500 CHINESE WALL RD OROVILt,E CA 95466 L: :028 370' 038 000 S?fiTUS A:.T IVE TOMPKINS VAC 'U ETAL. -. L: 072 230 038 0130' STATUS: ACTIVE TOMPKINS GAR E PIERCE MICHAEL V SS P 0 BOX 72 BRENTWOOD CA 94513 500 CHINESE WALL RD " OROVILLE CA 95966 Lr 072`230 024 000' STATUS: ACTIVE OVERRTR .�r'_'- EET REUBEN E 8R BETTY JT L: 072`230 070 000_ STATUS: ACTIVE SIMARD GERARD & JEANNINE JT' 41681 CENTURION DRIVE - SANTA ROSA CA, 95403` 464 CHINESE WALL. RD GROVELLE rA 95966 L:. 072, 230"024 000 STATUS: ACTIVE OVEf2STREET REUBEN E BETTY L: 072 230'070 000 STATUS: ACTIVE .& JT vIMARD GERARD & .7EANNINE ?T 1681CENTURION DRIVE SANTA ROSH. CA 95403: 3 " 464 CHINESE: WALL RD _ "� OROVILLE- CA 95966 L: 072 230 027 000,1- STATUS:; ACTIVE U S A 4,KNORZER L: 072 230 071 000 STATUS- ACTIVE: i ERWIN T & KATHLEEN'S = 00000 459 CHINESE WALL RD OROVILLE CA 95§6o---- 59boL:` L:'072 230 027 000 STATUS:: ACTIVE, U S'A L: 072 230 071 000_ STATUS: ACTIVE KNORZER ERWIN T & KATHLEEN E 00000' 459 CHINESE 'WALL RD OROVILLE GA 95966 Lr 072 230.057 000 STATUS: ACTIVE VIAGOM--CABLEVISION OF Ni7RiHERN CALIF L' 072,230 042 030' STATUS: ACTIVE INC TAX"`DEPT BRAXTON:RICHARD L pr O; BO's 1r3 _ PLEA64NTON CA'945b6 _,__ P 0 BOX 2806 - ORQ'.VILLE CA 95965 L: 072 230--0557- x o STATL is -ACTIVE VIACOM CABLEVISIOWC. NORTHERN CALIF L; 072 230 042 000; STATUS: ACTIVE INC TAX DEPT _ BRAXTON RICHARD L pi G BOX 1'3' =-PLFgsANTO�[ CA 44566 P 0 BOX ,2806 - OROVILLE CA. 95,965 N -mm --= - 000 STATUS: ACTIv- f _ _F-� L: 028 870 014 - L: o28 37 008 000 STATUS: ACTIVE BUELER KAREN M GORMAN R=CHARS ,JlfrtARGAGE" P 1,196 MONTSOMERTY ST 38620 ADCOCK PACE OROVILLE CA 95965 FREMONT CA 94536 028;370 014 000 :STATUS: AGT:IVE - L: 028 370 009 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L; 13UELER;KAREN M GORMAN RICHARD' DI &. MARGARET P` - MQNTGOMERTY-'ST ' 38620 ADCOGK PLACE 1126 OROVILLE CA 95965 .-. FCA;94536 FREMONT 028 370 015 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 02B:370,009 000STATUS. ACTIVE L• SOLIS' IRIS 6 & DORIS M' _ 'ORMAN RICHARD: D & MARGARET. P ` 5369 OLD OLIVE HWY 39.722PLUMAS`WAY OROVILLE CR 95965 `_- FREMONT CA 94538 - 370 015 000 STATICS: ACTIVE 02B--370-,009 000- STATUS*. ACTIVE L: 028 SOLIS IRIS G & DORIS M GORMAN.RICHARD D &- MARGARET P 536.9 OLD OLIVE HWY CA 95965 39.722 PLUMAS, WAY' OROVILLE _ CA 94538 - FRaMONT' 0213 370.021 000 STATUS: ACTIVE € Li_ 028 370 010 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: MUNN WILLIAM C & 3ANEP L JT _ - GORMAN: `RICHARD D &: MARGARET 'P CREEK Rei = 1.4 SPRING 95966 39722:PLUMAS,WAY' OROVILLE K - CA 94538" 028 370 021: 000 STATUS;: ACTIVE � 0213`. 370 0:i0 000:STATUS: ACTIVE L: MUNN WILLIAM G & JAN L JT' L:, " GQRMAN-RICHARD"D &MARGARET P �- 14 SPRING I CREEK RD ;59722, PLUKAS WAY - QROVILLE CA 95966 FREMONT CA 4 STATUS: ACTIVE 370 024 000'^_� 028' 370' .011 000 STATt1Sa nrTI��E f `0213 .ofl JEWELL C WESLEY & BAR.,B"'." • C - L:, FAIRLEY DENNIS-rA.fiICM: &SHEILA LOIS _ RD 20 SloLDE5 FLAT CA.95966 137 TAMALPAIS ROAD OROVILLE; BERKELEY-' CA 94708 3`30 024 X00 STATUS: ACTIVE 026y 370 011 000 STATUS: ACTIVE. � L: 028 .. JEWELL C WESLEY '& BARBARA C L; FAIRLEY DENNIS PATRICK &SHEILA LOIS. 209 SWEDES FLAT RD 137 TAMALPAIS ROAD '' OROVILLE CA 95966 BERKELEY CA 94708 370 025 000' STATUS: ACTIVE �- L: 028 379 012 000 STATUS:. ACTIVEDERUSHIA L: 028 DONALD J JOHANSEN JAMES' L & SHIRLEY S JT s ` FLAT RD 24:3 SWEDES GA 95966 38B'RI.VERVIEW ARIVE OROVILLE OROVILLE CA 0546`5 370 025 000 STATUS: ACTIVE +M 'A'70 012;001a STATUS: ACTIVE. L: ��f28 DERLfSn A DONALD J JOHANSEN JAMES' L &; SHIRLEY S JT 243 SWEDrS FLAT RD CA 95966 38a- RIVERVIEW- DRIVE OROVILLE OROVILLE CA95965 02S 370 026 000 STATUS: ACTIVE _ L: 0213 370 013 000 STRIuS:° ACTIVE - L. • __ R10E GEORGE R.& WILMA J `- DELONG, JAMES 3 &, SUED 1564 FITZGERALD DR #134A 10950 MAGDALENA AVE PINOLE CA 94564 ' LOS ALTOS HILLS CA 94022 L 028' 370' 026 000 STATUS: ACTIVE 0213 013 000 STATUS':' ACTIVE - Fc,CE (5 Or R & i'1iLiie�. J L .370 DELONG JAMES -1 & SUE D _ .. _ 1564 FITZGERALD'DR n39A CA 94564 t: �LO�. ALTOS` HILLS Cdr_-- k �2g i7016 000 - ST�iU4 ALS L: Web 320 227 000 SIAiUS ACTIVE kit I HELi'tUTH MYRTS.,r:. ria HL. -SS 399E'=ACAPULCO DR ---- -` _-= 3680" LOCUST ST �: -NEI Fuses _ CA 94560 CAMPBELL CA 95008 Y L: 62$ 320 220-000 a IA i un-: -HUT L: 628 170 .16 000 � - STA : US r ACTIVE =- - —PAD I LLA 'MANUEL D & LUPE L F!---- HFrMUTff_MYRTL_ rANN S 36807CUS �, T "�T 3998 4CAPU CO D4 RK O CA 9z5 ds V NEWA _-VTI •- . _ _`.- _ _ to .- C -- L 228 3220 221 000 tmss- A t u.7. IAZTIVE L. X128 x:70; 111 600 STATUS: ACTIVE - --_ 14ARVFY ALFRED. i RUTH H E ETAL BALLS DONALD & GAIL FAMILY TRUST RALL4'DCNALD JACK & GA?L HELEE3 TRUSTEES' (j R Or BOX 648 = PO: SOX 250 F _ --- _ _ _- - - _. --FigGiGB�iBY = - —CFS 912 noZrttTmnnn rA 44Si3 L:' 028 1710 1117 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L 028;320 221 086STATUS: ACTIVE HARVEY 'ALFrRED' F &. #1L�TN _F:_ET^• R�3LLS DONALD & GAIL FAMILY TRUST _ _ RAI=LS DONALD JACK: L 'GAIL HELEN TRUSTEES' eT ncst .s PG Brix 8j0 RACE{ERBY '; CA X5972 BRENTWOOD CA 94513 L_. =L 17Y 11v" �T s.�saa: HL+_i TVE - L: 029,320 225 060 STAT`JS: ACTIVE _ uTr__T .S. RAYMnND T- 7R. COWLEY ROBERT GLBE�RT & ARDATH MAE "'"C��" P O BOX 94 P 0 JOX E68 Rt�CKERBY_ CA 9`9%2 CLOVIS' CA 93613 028 320 2a8 f8 C �- C�s�cv ^ t t8, 200 STATUS: ACTIVE L: STATUS: A =TIVE 00 -_- t`Yasvaa-�Iriu NRAYMOND i Ji f1t1F"onnEaT rLBr�_&: nRr;7wsrZ I - P" O, BOX 94 P' 0 BOX, 268 RAC.: ERH`r` c:H Y5V7 G �uvi5 CA 93b13 �.: 17[ i 1Q STP vrces- 'gas T"e4S ACTIVE L;: 026 320 _2,7y, AC_ - WEST ANNA CLAIRE E� VANS JACKS & "CURIA S JT 4980 E COLORADO PO.BOX 2581 OROt1ILLc: CA ?5965 LA5 VEGAS NJ 87104L 028' 11.70 119 008 STATUS:. ACTIVE Le' 022 320 229 000 STATUS: ACTIVE II WEST ANNA CLAIRE EVANS. JACK &:GLORTA S JT 25R1 4980 E COLORADO ORO!lILCE CAL95465 LAS VEGAS NV 891.04 _ �soa ,.., T L: 028 370 006 Sor�s� S=�TUS: ACTIVE L:- 022! _ 10" 188 oo STATUS: AC �.IVE GULF? BEN E Tnr+.+. A1Tf _ - - PCi�. LOVnn7s�c. a lam., - - - "If]:�JaOD ROBERT G.. 2363 N©£; O €UN: RD _- p' 0 BOX 1082, MARYSVILLE 'A' 95901 OROVILLE c ; L: 028 .,` `000 -ACTIVE- . .. ,ter0t8BSTATUS: ACTIV E _ - Ldei 5"470 ,096 000STRTUS : ACTIVE : PERlZBORN MICK £ULET BEN: CIG WOOD. ROBERT G _ -caaj nHrtrtcltV i Uig HU - — ?'_ Il RCTX 1582- R MARYStti`LE CP." `?901 ' OROVILLE CA 95965 _. 189 000 - STATUS: ACTIVE L: 028 37 s 67 000 STATUS: ACTIVE -' PERTZB3s�N :SICK:. r9RMAN RICHARD D � , ARBARET P _ C�'u WOOD ROBFAT Ci 23Ei3 HAMMONTGN'ry t 38620 ADCOCK PLACE r IARYSVILr E C=; 295901 FREMONT CA 9453b j LI 028 %'7fd 189' 000 "STA7`US:': ACTIVE v L '02G 870 007 060 STATUS: ACTIVE - ,.- 1 GORMAN RICHARD D & MARGARET P FF R; ZBORK MICK - m Q':y11661 ROBERT G 386�C0 ADC�JCK PLACE 8a6� HAMMONTON, RB -_ _ 6 EREMONT CA 94531 MA?YSVa:,LE CS9B- 8 3_a9 STATUS::� r- -��AC-IV- L: 028 170 131 000 STATUS: ACTIVE - Ot,`Ac.15 J W &': pEggy= I JT 7ERMINEL. AUGUSTINE JR, & Jr"titIGz.c COLLEEN-- C EEN F 0 BOX- 632 _ 5871.- VALLEY 1 EN WAY TRANOUILLITY CA 93668 - SACRAMENTO CA '95823 L; 028 170 04$ aa0CT! SACT1 va L a 92B 1.79' 131 990 STA } Ll cS _ ACTIVE,' Qt1AL! S J W &.. PEGPZY: TERMINEL AU13USTINE JR & JAWICE COLLEE^; 0 BOX 632 5871: VALLEY GLEN WAY' _ - TPANQUILLITY- CA 93668 = :SA RnrLpNTn, CA 95823 �� = STATUS: Saco 19 947 999rACTIVE`L: 028 170' 132 00� STATUS: ACTIVE _ EVANS WILLIS O ALMA D' JT 5111 MINERS` ;RANCH?` oD 'P 0 BOX 1969 OROVtLLE LA 95966EAn• Cl coz n.\" -A ra o_ ..i�f 1 2caa_ ..'STfTUSa - L: 928 170947 999 STATUS; ACTIVE J raRNELISOY L: "028 170` 132 009`T -ACTIVE ROY AL ETAL EVANS WILLIS 0 & ALMA' D JT �•••...�. �irtiVE.Q,T Cltf " - :C n pGX 1969 - OROVILLE `A;95966 CLEARLAKE - CA 45422 `133 070 949 999, STATUS; ACTIVE L: 028 179 600 STATUS;, ACTIVE �I TOVAR HERIBERTA & NARY M' GLOVER IRA E & EUNICE 859 SAN CARLOS GT P C BO 312 �. FREMONT '' CA; 94536 BANGOR CA 95914 L:- 928 170 949 900 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 928'170 133 000 STATUS -s ACTIVE .�-- TOVAR HERIBERTA & MARY M GLOVER IRAE &.El1NICE 857SAN' CARLOS- CT P 0 BOX 312 FREM04 CA` 9:``r526 BANGOR: CA 95914 028.179 O50 990 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 020'179 126 900 STATUS: ACTIVE MAHOO ARTHUR JAMES _ ---"f - - DEPT OF VETERANS AFFAIcr 24J54 KLIMA GARY E � 'K .TA J JT 269212782 HARRISON AVE 1318 SWEDES FLAT RD SAN`, MATE©` Ck,95503-19i0' GROV'ILLE` CA 95966 L: 028 179 950 990 STATUS:- ACTIVE L: 02B 170 126 900 STATUS: ACTIVE MAHOOD ARTHUR JAMES. f DEPT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS _ ,KLIMA GARY E & RITA J JT 269812782: 2084 HARRISON AVE 1318 SWEDES FLAT RD - SAR,,NATEO`.OROVILLE Cts 45593-1910':.. `~� � CA 95966 L,raci i�44 1000 STATUS:: ACTIVE JOHiiEl i Lt 928. 179 127 906 STATUS: ACTIVE OYCE L ETAL = r- KROLL DENNIS L & JUDY A JT --'- Ili /1:e7VtV [�CUIVA' M' 325' MAPLE: LN _ -=-Y -- PO BOX 89.1 ;. OROVILLE BANGOR CA 95914 L:= 02S 170'044 909 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 928 179 raj L90 STATUS: ACTIVE JOHNSON JOYCE L ETAL KROLL DENNIS'L & JUDY A JT HUSW LEONA hC 325 MAPLE,LPI } "20 BOX 291: ORv`vLLE -: `CA `95965 BANGOR CA 45914 L: 028 1.70 130' 990 STATUS:, ACTI:VE ry L: 928 1:70`:128 SILO STATUS: ACTIVE` MOORE WILLIAM T & DOLLIE ht STRELSKY RICHARD ETAL TC P O BOX 322 - 56 STONEY -OAKS BLVD BANGOR. CA__95914 OROVILLE CA 95966 L: 028 17pf =130 000 i, STATUS: ACTIVE MOORE Le 028 I79 128 090 STATUS:: ACTIVE WILLifiM. T &- DOLLIE M' STRELSKY RICHARD ETAL TE P O. BOX 322 50 <STONEY OAKS_ BLVD: - BANGOR _ -CA 95914 OROVILLE _ 'CA :95966: 028; 170 028 000 STATUS: AGTIVE_ Lt 028 17D' 070 000" STATUS: `ACTIVE KIHARA: RAE & PAU`.INE REVoCASILE iRll ETAL ;t BROWN LOUIE & LORAIN` ETAL TC' C/O INTRA PACIFIL COMMERCIAL INC,.' 9254 riAgISON AVE 94 STONEY `OAKS LOOP ORANGEADIS CA 95662 DROVILLE CA '95956. L: 028` 1'l.-28 000 STATUS: ACTIVE `` 8: 170 fb7D O00° STATUS: ACTIVE L: 0'2 KIHARA RAE & PAULINE REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL BROWN LOUIE. & LORAIN' E.TAL TG ` C/O INTRA PACIFICCOMMERCIAL: INC 9254 MADISON AVE 94 STONE.-Y'OAKS.LOOP- ORANGEVALE CA 956622 DROtJILLE CA- 9~966 L.:. 026`170 029 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 028" 1701 026 000'_STATUS: ACT LOUIE 'W & LORAIN` A GLOVER IRA E EUNICS 94 STONEY OAKS LOOP P DtBOX 312 GROVILLE CA 95966 BANGOR "- `CA, 95914 L: 028 170 097 000 STATUS-. ACTIVE L,: 028 17ff 026, 000 STATUS:: ACTIVE SILVA. DEBORAH J GLOVER IPL°:E & EUNICE DOMNICK DEBORAH J 1808 FOOTHILL KNOLLS DR P 0: BOX, 312 PLEASANTON CA 44566 ,. CA BANGOR 95914 L: 029 170 X329 000 6TATUS: ACTIVE L:' 928. T70 gr,5. 000 =.,v> STATUS:- ACTIVE _ HROW�l, LOUIE W & LORAIN A GRANTHAM: CHARLES W, � PALMA 94 STONEY OAKS LOOP 187 GARDENSIDE LANE -" OROVILLE CA 95966 - CUPERTING CA 95014 - L: 02Q 17fd' 097 010E STATUS: ACTIVE Lt 028 1743. X145 00ff STATUS'; ACTIVE w - SILVA DEBORAH J GRANTHAM CHARLES iri &PALMA: DOMNICK DEBORAH? J 7808 FOOTHILL Kr30LuS DR 1187 GARDENSIDE LANE '' PLEASANTON CA 94566 - CUPERTIN&:_ CR 95014 _ x1.70, L 026 !70'096 000 STATUS: ACTIVE _z L: 028: 046 000' SITA4 US: ACTIVE. cujr LF% —. MOXIE A & WILMA C .... OESSLER DONNA W` SS`r. P 0 BOX 219 - PO BOX. CA '95972 RACKERA.Y,."CA-55972 L: £2Q 170 69e 609 STAlus ALiI1?E _ L: 028' 170 046aay. StATU!- ,;CTIVE _ a SHiRLEY TiO�IE & MOESSLER DONN :. _. R _ 0 BOX ;R 19 Ei3 BOX:.- 133 � � RACKLRRY - RACKEF9Y CA 95972 -_ - L: 028 1170 X99 000 ACTIVE t `025, I 89 000,STATUS: ACTIVE SERCO INCSTATUS: MOESSLER, JOH &: DONNA WEEKS y� C/0 SAENGER DAVID M P 0 BOX 427 Poi, EOX.133- _. PARADISE CA 95967- ,'RACKERBY CA 95.972 _ L: 02B 1'70 099 000 STATUS: ACTIVE 8 17ff 089 0Fi0 STATUS- ACTIVE SEBCv INC MOESSL. R: JOHN & DONNA UEEKS T CIO SAENGER DAVID M - P O'BOX 427 PO BOX .133 - �` PRRADI&E CA 95967 RACKERBY C 95972- _` L: 028 1:70 100' 000 5TATUSs ACTIVE L: ff28 17,e ;090 -4300 STATUS: ACTIVE °_ BARRERAS -WILLIAM & `MANY °'3ALMINS ARTIS R: & RASMA I JT 1418 MARKET ST l' - $29 JUANA: Lt. 07P_ ESD 04__000 ST OR ACTIVE .. 072 To MANN, WILLTAN A :&. LETTIE J L: X11 000STATUS: ACTIVE BOEGER GEORGE i & ELAINE TRUST 356 CHINESE WALL RD ' - EOEGER GEORGE J & ELAINE TRUSTEES 3564 BOEGER LANE OROVILLE CA 95966` SAN JOSE CA 95148 _ —_ Lr 072 230 ?143:000 STATUS: ACTIVE L:: 072: 330 011 000 STATUS: ACTIVE MANTt WILLIAM. A & LET,TI J BOEGER'' GEORGE J & ELAINE TRUST 356 CHINESE WALL RD B05GER GEORGE J &`ELAINE TRUSTEES OROVILLE: CA '95966- 3564 $OEuER:LANE SAN JOSE GA 95145 Lr 972 330 001 000 STATUS: 'ACTIVE L. 072 330 012 000 STATUS: ACTIVE BUEGER GEORGE J & ELAINE TRUST MONTGOMERY MARION MAE SS BOEGER GEORGE x & ELAINE TRUSTEES 3564-BOEGEP_LANE 205 KINGS RD' S� CA 95148 BRISBANE T A 94005 L.,, $72 330'001 000 STATUS:' ACTIVE L: 072 330 012 000 STATUS: ACTIVE -, BOEGER GEORGE J &SLAIN- TRUST MONTGOMERY'MARION MAE SS BOEGER GEORGE J& ELAINE TRUSTEES ' 3564 BOEGER LANE 205 KINGS RD SAN JOSE CA.95148 BRISBANE CA 94005 Lt 072 330 002'600 STATUS: STATUS. ACTIVE - 072 330 013 000 STATUS': ACTIVE [ ARRIS JOHN K FAMILY -REVOCABLE TRUST _ETAL MONTGOMERY!°:Nt ZOr:' MAE SS COOK WILLIAM.H & MYRNA N JT - 2810=F REDDING: AVE 205 KINGS RD I SACRAMEWiV CA 95G20 r 3K SHADE CA 94005 L: 772J330 002 0010 STATUS: ArTiVE L: 072-330 01:3 000 STATUS: ACTIVE HARRIS JOHN K FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL MONTGOMERY MARION''MAE SS COOK WILLIAM H` & MYRNA N JT 2810-F REDDING AVE BOS Kir1G5 RD SACRAMENTO CA 95620' _- BRISBANE CR 94005 L:'. 072 330 004 000 STATUS:, ACTIVEr L: 072 330 014 000 STATUS: ACTIVE HARRIS JOHN K FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL- HARRIS'3OHN K FAM7LY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL COOK WILLIAM K.&.MYRNA N JT COOK WILLIAM'H & MY"uA N JT 2810-F REDDING AVE t _ 2810-F REDDING AVE SACRAMENTO - CA '95820` SACRAMENTO _ CA 9Lc20 L: 07E 333'004 000 STATUS:" ACTIVE L; 072 330 014 000 STATUS:ACTIVE HARRIS JOHV'K FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL HARRIS JOHN K' FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL COOK WILLIAM H & MYRNA N JT _ COOK WILLIAM H & MYRNA 'N_ JT 2810=F REDDING'AVE 2810-F REDDING AVE - SACRAMENTO CA; 951320 SACRAMENTO CA.95B20 L: 072 330 006 800 STATUS: ACTIVE ( L• 072 3_30:015 000' STATUS• -ACTIVE HARRIS JOHN K_ FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL. HARRIS JOHN K, FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL C0LK'�.ILL7AM H`& MYRNA N JT _ COOK WILLIAM H & MYRNA N JT 2810-r= REDDING AVE 2810-F REDDING AVE SACRAMENTO' - CA 95820 SACRAMENTO CA 95820 L: 072 Z-30 006 000 STATUS: ACTIVE" 072 330 01:5 000 STATUS: ACTIVE HARRIS JOHN K FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETALHARRIS JOHN _K'FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL II GDOK''WILLTAM H & MYRNA N JT COOK WILLIAM LI & MYRNA N JT -' firs -F ?-^LING AV 2810 -FF REDDING AVE SACRAMENTO` C^x5820 SACRAMENTO CA 95820 L:: 072' 330 008" 0STATUS:. CORVITN STEVEN CHARLES' & BARBARA ACTIVE L ETAL TG k L.:' 072 330 016 000 STATUS: ACTIVE KIHARA; RAE & PAULINE REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL - "- 8633 ROBINSuN RlrGE DR C/O INTRA PACIFIC COMMERCIAL INC LAS VEGAS - NV` 89117 9254 MADISON AVE ORANGEVALE CA 45662 Lr 072 330 008 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 072 330:016 000 STATUS: ACTIVE CORWIN STEVEN CHARLES. '& BARa'ARA L ETAL TC` KIHARA RAE & PAUL:INE REVOCP5LE TRUST ETAL A633` ROBINsba RIDGE DR` C/O INTRA PACIFIG CuririERL:AL lNC LAS VEGAS NI). 891.17 9254 MADISON'AVE r ORANGEVALE CA; 95662 WA EN AN RICHARD L RACHEt, P ill[ ARA R016,& Pr` UL IN[ €2C VOC. CULL 111URL L1 AL 4501.-ROXEJRY LANE 925§ MADISON AVC rtOI�ES.TO — - - =""x+530 OizANGEVALE CA 9566R_° L: 072: 330 017-0off STA'T'US: ACTIVE_ L:. 028 320 003000 STATUSi ACTIVE WAKEMA4 RICHARD'L & RACHEL A KINARA RAE 6 PAULINE REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL: - C/O INTRA PACIFIC COMMERCIAL I'NG 501 ROXBURY LANE 9254 MADISON AVE MODESTO CF. 95350 - ORANGEVALE CA 95662 Lt 072 330`;018 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 028 320 4311 000 - STATUS: ACTIVE KIHARA RE & PAULINE REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL. BIGLAND DEVELOPMENT CORP' C/& INTRA PACIFIC COMMERCIAL !NG, C/G-WANG & WANG 9254 MADISON AVE NO 320` SEC 4 CHUNG 'HSIAO E. RD ©RANGEVALE CA 9566'8 15TH FLOOR KUANG FU BLDG: TAIPEI TAF1Jt-14 106 ` L.: 072 330: 91& 0$43 STATUS:" ACTIVE L:` 028 3L$ 1111 006 STATUS" ACTIVE KIHARA RES PAULINE REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL BI `AND DEVELORMENT CORP' CIO INTRA 'PACIFIC COMMERCLAL ING CIO WANG WANG 9254 ,-AIDISON. AVE NO 320 SEC 4 CHUNG HSIAO E RD ORANSEVALE CA 35662 15TH FLOOR KUANG FIS'BLDG TAIPEI TAIWAN 106 L: 012: 330 91V 600 STATUS: ACTIVE L:' 028 320 012 000 STATUS:: ACTIVE HARRIS-JOHN'K FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL- BIGLAND DEVELOPMENT CORP --COOK-MIL i Tara° ,- a jTriN IV JT - -- - C10 WE?NG 8: WA ".G 8810-F< RENT AVE. NO 320 SEC 4 GH[1Nr HSIAO E RD SACRAMENTO CA 95820' 15TH- FLOOR KVANG 'FU BLDG x iAPEI eAItJ41t; 106 -;ts 072 330' 019'_000 STATUS:: ACTIVE L: 028:320 012 000 STATUS;: ACTIVE HARRIS JOHN K FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL BIGLAND DEVELOPMENT CORP COOK WILLIAM H & MYFfi:A' iV JT C/0' WHt '' :d ..ANG 2810-E REDDING AVE: NO 38E�`SEC _4 CHUNG; HSIAO` E RD SACRAMENTO CA,9x826; - 15TH FLOOR KUANG FU BLDG TAIPEI TAIWAN 106 L: 972 339 0241 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L: 028 320 216 000 STATUS: ACTIVE_ IiARRIS JOHN K FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST ETAL PADILLA MANUEL D & LUPE L ' COOK WILLIAM H & fitYF.NA N JT 2810_F REDD`ING:AVE 36807 LOCUST ST SACRAMENT@ CA 95820'- NEWARK CA 94560 L: 072,330F 020'000 STATUS: ACTIVE_ L: 028 320 2161000 STATUS: ACTIVE HARRIS JOHN 1K FAMILY REVOCABLE TRUST .ETAL PADILLA MANUEL D & LUPE:L COOK WILL.IAK H. 8c MYRNR N JT- 2810=F REDDING AVE 36ae7= Lb00ST 'ST SACRAMENTO' CA7 95820' NEWARK CA 94560 L: 028 320-218,000 STATUS: ACTIVE Bandy McNain. 113 Blazeford Gulch Road CAVA MELVIN L - Oroville, CA 95956 19388 LAKE CHABOT ROAD CASTRO VALLEY CA 94546 L:'028 320,218 080- STATUS: ACTIVE Randy.D.. >4LMain: CAVA MELVIN_ L ;I 113 Blazeford Gulch°Road OrQ°rille,; CA 95966 _ 1$386 LAKE CHABOT ROAD' CASTRO VALLEY CA 94546 -- _ L: 028 320'219 100 STATUS: ACTIVE . ORTH EDWARD R,& CYNTHIA LEE ETAL 14550 ATHERTON CIR MORGAN HILL CA 95037 L: 028 320 21.9 000 STATUS': ACTIVE ORTH EDWARD R & CYNTHIA LEE ETAL 14550 ATHERTON CIR _ MORGAN HILL CA 95037 - i ' 1 RESOLUTION 93-8 A: RF,'O =,UTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OI+'jjI , k 1 4•�. COUNTY OF BUTTE APPROVIN0 ,8ND ;RECOMMENI)IN(y O f O THE :BOARD ,OF SUPERVISO(2S THE ADOPTION,/ GENERAL PI:AIV AMI?�) I?MEi` T FROM PUBLIC T AGRICULTURAL RESIDE,,NTIAL )W3ER.EAS, a private husinesaL & L Surveying has ;petitioted 1he Butte County Planning Commission, through an appropriate application, to arrtjld the Butte County General Plan Land Use Element, for ii change from pubfit = � i .Agricultural ]Residential :for that property identified on 119hibit A-t, lttae�� 8� hereto ana the Butte County Planning Commission expanded that request l!+ include other surrounding properties similar in size, and WHEREAS, the proposed GeneralPlan Amendment hap 22 studied and reviewV ,d' by the Butte County Planning Conlmisilion and a puui 23 hearing held pursuant to law`, at which time all intere,�ted person s+ were heard, ate' WHEP1AS, the Butte County Planning Commission has revie%r and considered the contents of the environmental review study ertecltist (Exlit jWt 1, A-2 prepared on the amendment P !� pursuant to the Cal'rfor�tia Environmen 117 Quality Act; and WFIERVmR in. granting this rib,,'qutt� the Count?$ inteiil and i�urpofi ' i9 is 80,1ely to facilitate and promote the hi liest economic g usa of tltc i�o�t�se� p a �� ro ti's, p feet site in confarmaned with the goals and objectives of. ,the $Atte Cous'tty General Ilan; and WHBRgAS the. Butte County ' i Planning Commission finds the,, proposed amendment (Exhibit A-1) together with the other+ applicable Element r` y" 14 of the Butte County General Plan doeseomprisc an overall internally cotis'4lCll a1 whole, NOW, TT3ER;EFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT, 1. '116,03eneral Plan Amendment to Agriculttital `Residenft€tl,_04 shown ort the attached Exhibit A-1 is hereby incorporated hY referents. BE IT FUR.'THEM RESOLVED, the General Plan .Aneifds)161,11 derFribed herein is hereby recoM" mended for adoption by the Board of Supet,0401. d§1 as an amendment to the Butte County Generat Plan. ifl PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Bulla Bounty Piamlflg Commission on the Nth of June, 1993, by the following 'veto:' Z3 AWES; Commissioners Sessions,, Ferguson, Lambert, and Chairman Lynch 1 NOES: Commissioner Nelson ABSENT No one �8 .7 ABSTAINED. No one "✓ x YI V�," ; ROBERT L�'NC CdAIR 1 Butte County Planmrig C omrr is On. 2� �a ATTEST: Paula Si Leasure, Principal Planner 26 i 26 Ili It ,awi �' � � n n.♦ � ait� I " 99 { ' �'"E7,o,:fd,4��.G�.c+aeeiea:aowe; Vesear�eest®' atnr.� r�ar�rsv+r� , '� r i � .,��• �/ ��' SIM li i�ytglr�IM'✓�++MMb'A "� ,wr. � saw �w .,. !� � MR• ���r 767 2zs�i' ! ' ! i ✓J ' ` J , I i • (t r1 JY e kr n. ..w.k...r...-+x — T� -1 , l � � I `� tall `I j4 r MA/6V 1 �Ki 'j �ii�i • �� i , Z4 r 40 VI I iN CJO ! BU TE . COUNTY P��/�N NG:: �nMtu����;i�nti.'°.` � U,130 a.m. cAGa#ice regardutg en�virottmenia proposed,'i ingrrRvltt�:W - S acre parcels) to FIR-40 (Foothill ,Retand �,at� >�o��'0 ��"5 parcels} fox prorperty located on both si-&i of 5,.,, 'cr approximately 1.5 miles east Of Oro-)Bangor 7Eiig� odes FlaV`1,3�,S- 170-028,! dhway, I triii�"ed as 028.320.003, 072-330-016 aisd 018, �),ro+vine. �Fi1e g3-0$)' t ►�`) The Commission waived the reading Of `he Staff, windings: Chainnal, Lynch said ad cue Commission was considering t� today was a rezone , ofi L11e intended use o£ the land. He asked people to address the rezone ,re � quest o�. `.f'he .heaving was opened to the public. Virginia Berglund, representative of butch Racvine, said she w there questions. to ai► 3 Wilma Shirley asked what the difference was between A-R and wR41j zottir, y e want,,d to .Know what w,, s &IIj wed v7 the FR zo:ae`d g n��� Stair explained M ••str, ri,.Y hi the allowed uses" d theaff u este pui n zo g designation is much MO Gjuriing designations allows son, e conuneri;iagl uses w e a r Use Eaff said the, f kt recreational c)►.tis. rmit inclUdi GomrrIissln»;� r 5jn s;�d there will need to be an additional. hearing spurts club. g to deal vdfp A Stuff said he wo.s correct. Ms. Shirley said she signed the petitioa ag coainst this pro "ec _ consideration was not necessarily against the rezone,J 4 bt It after fUrtfrCgr W. Shirley said he was in favor of the rf,;zone„ Re said this rezone h to increase the tax rate and the potential ;to bran the potertta g� revenue, Diane Wilson sod she was against this rezone. She submitted a pedd'on with 59 people who disagree with the rezone. Sht:he was Shir',ey's name off of the petition. She subma tited ed aZnap Of the homes e,Njr. tic 1Vfr � o�u.nd the ifttfi ,¢. tUTT8 COUNTY PLANVI00 COI"MIS810N idx"'iUT'!rS a, u 1993 ak mg -MA -7 7 r4 0 i 1 cu b. She said S-Wedes Flat Rol ad will, not take the traffic y the said the club is alr; affic; assi[►ciated with a, &6gffiess. � ` ady using, bigh power rifle,,- ort the pro pert . <, giant a rezone that will allow a L7se IE'ermit consideration Pater. Sh1, said this &OV got fire area. She did :not want commercial uses ;allowed iii this arest. She snit ;s z� ,� Wil s in very bad shape. She submitted pictures of the narrow �cezati. , 1 the z����!j i. Manfred Schiedick, Swedes 1~lat Road, ;said the Count� should take int y that people have e��n stopped o consid, pped fra�n gohig under 40 acre n. 3e said the deer herds are major c. Paucels because, o£ deer" l`'s� J consideration by Fish &ad Game, He ;;aid h,6 ,W not allowed to split his land because of the deer. He said there is no .roams on thea rJ for eneraency vehicles. He did not: want out of town traffic being bxc►u.�ht into t'la� air,�a,, �e said he has grandchildren in direct viE;w of the poachers to his livestock, i. Burt club. e was c61,Wern.ed� ,g th Robert Schiedick said his House is directly!pi chub. in 'line with the > + < , � t concerned because he has two children. ,Ie is concerned with high poVW]Hez' lies hL'" i4 used, E; said a gun club next door will a�estroy Ids property valuer, Patricia Lipchak said she was concerned with erosion of the ► different HYOstock iaU) talc are,. laud by addirg Xn rd ad � John Quuui; said his la'and' � . is adjacent to China Wall Road, and his and Game that his l7roperty could not be divided .becatage of the ��ztical wiruas ede�r�a range: Tie said hispropertty would be useless if this zontttzg goes i`htoizgh anci lhezt <t' club is allowed. said his concei'ns have been covep,Cl and :lte is against klus project p j _ t. Frank White I AW Road and zt z w tides �' To and ReOdy said she has small children who walk to a`Jte .school; likts on S� s a traffic hazard now. She; diel not, want an increase ina► the tra�ic:t said there are 15 children who use this road, Say Stubbs said he ;concttrs, Urain A. Bi iwn said her <prope:rty adjoins ,;the b* club. Shd said fence been cut. Slie said she 'Wass agatust this projector t g her chiiidr`c:°because of the dan t have jdjt 4t Richard Strelsky said there is onljt carom for,.ane car .at a tirn;e on Swedes Flat a He was against the project. A.6a, gt Ruth Holt, Irene Ay(--ock, i"red foal , were ziot .,present, t, and r nt ,-any Palo mba signed cards to, spec ,,, of r 'w �k1T E CoUNIZY %LAID �.� . �V .L LV �. r2', Mi y,5 .� iTahtle, SY k II h-an Simard said the noise is very bad when people are shooting , +� Mooting she can even hear the people at the she stdd during, cet 1s shooting it sounds like a war zone. She was 's ag club tsthy pullShe said when1i-ere project. Lry Kanorzer said he would like to play a tape of the Merry Simard said the County can not afford this rezone. He said the to repair the road. he <,.ounty cul POt Michael Pierce, Chinese Wall Road said a 1aad. :He said a commercial gun club is not aPPrapriaten club is tii�tl appropriate use b'f. ffils rezone might be appropriate, but it is a way for the ea, He saitf j)�e Is notappropriate. He said there is no water storage . the Iare� b � estabhshed� ���1t Mason to rezone this area. He was against the project. He said safetHe y there i iso Ile said he talked to Ivlr: Snowden with Fish and h' a bag r�. wants to take a closer look at this project. He asked the i~� y Game and lvlr. Snowden told hh'�'� ,r request. �.Ommission to deny 11#4 Mr, Knorzer said on November 21, 199.2, some community Was in attendance. He said at this meeting, Mr. McMaidmbstated ers et a and Mr, f-€tifel domesticated: He said hogs were discussed as domestic s v%'i � P auiniais. Ile said Mr: MC&LOP) said dthey did not .need. a permit � • 1 Uns action over them. Mr. Knorzer -called �rmlcSnowdand Fish and Gane has Ilii` Game and' Snowden said he would Took :at the whole operation if questeden, Fish andby the Pl t[&9 Commission. He said the Deer herd range -calls for no exotic ani�ria' into the area. He was against the project. ls to be intr odvtc Virginia Berglund said they are not responsible for the traffic on Swedes FlatRoatl, 8fte, said there is no hunting, no animals 'hem released no hit*;h power rifles use LL g admitted the fence was bad. She said she was not responsible for poachers or e fl shooting in the middle of the night. She said she opened the club on She said Mr. Pierce talked to them and then went to the Board August 1p19r complained. She said Fish and Game issued a liCeiise for pheasant hunt She s sifter the complaint, the business stopped. g aid Ms. Monson said she hears the shots. She said there is a lot of shots and a traffic: She did not believe these peopleweire not being charged a Etre to shoot lot 6f facility, She said she feels this lyusi ess is still going on She said she ,has been�thehl 16 years and Mr. McMain has rimy been there 6 mouths.re Mr: fierce said if this rezone is approved there `would still need to be, hear .ng. He said the AM zoning is more restrietive and i should to tip field Use Permit p° rout hearing: He sa,d it was the Comm d And th n there would be no need for a Use Pe to preserve the .ace and h'angWlity taf the area, duty 1QNnaMxNC7TES, au.u, COUNTY pt.ADrNZNG � ld y C1 l I 1 -tl i6 q' i M'ru, Shirley said she was here to discuss the rezone only, She said she tboul;l"i` to de,i')Ill)y is potentially higher for AR-5 than ;FR-40. Mr. ed norzer Kla the tape f the shooting noises. He said this hearing was bent' r played because the Code Enforcement Officer gave Mr. McCain permission to operate t .e° AP9!ts' club and the neighbors, do not agree. He said this business should never haven stoerN, ted., Co;t missioner Nelson said the Commission 'is processiIlg, a rezone only, not proC6�?��I 'Use Permit for a gun club. Ms. Berglund said she was told to story the .business and she did. LOW Brown wantedto know who would pay for the road if this is approved 0nd vbsequently a Use Permit. 1. he hearing was closed. � .team ntsLynchmade a conflict with he was cern d with comments from Fish and Game anti Y4,0 He suggested this :hearing might be cozit bn'6,4 Commissioner Ostrowski asked ,if Swedes Flat Road was a County Road? Staff said yes. Staff said Public 'Works is responsible for the road, p Staff said in the p;> ,there was, a discussion an formin a distract for maintaining the road, but the pro' g owners, at that time, were not interested. ;L questions and Fish & Game. He said he o here to � o Chairman L � ch said he would like the a Code would Enforcement Officer ask direct questions and t:eeg th nearing. closed if this is continued., Commissioner Lambert asked if this area will be considered m' the County "General PUA update? Staff said there will be some chan acre zoning to 40 acre parcels. ges in the area. Staff said it will probably go frb:' - Commissioner Lambert talked about a riotion to have ,people present such as the CWo Enforcement Officer and a member of Fish and Game,, and condAue this hearing d6§-0 to January 28, 103, She said she would like to hear froth Fish and 'rYathe. Staff said Fish & Game policies arc, to protect habitat for the deer; not to i+egulatp;; h shooting of the deer. ;BUTTE Cott`l'..'„LFINN�NC�;GQNiMxZtJlt>,1�! I �. �1 r> w 777 1 r a O mmissioner Lainbert said 1~"R-40 is not a problem, but a Use Permit would Vpa ; problem: Commissoner Nelson also had no problems with the FR -40 zoning, Staff said the AIS, -5 zoning' gives people a false sense of being able to develop to J glee parcels. It was moved by Commissioner Lambert, seconded by Commissioner Nelsons R#d 'unanimously carried to recommend approval as follows: akin this decision A. Find Haat the requirements of CEQA have been completed and considead, JA making n and adopt a Negative Declaration regarding enviroauri'e'�� impacts; and L3. Find that the rezone conforms to the policies, including the text and map" of ill# Butte County General Plan; and C. Recommend that the- Board of Supervisors adopt an ordinance rezoning to Y111P 40, those properties identified as AP 028-170-028, 028-320=00:3, 72.330.016 and (Dutch Ravine Spr�rts'man s Club): Chairman Lynch sake _tht rezone is appropriate because it falls into the overlay of :tib Deer Herd Zone; He ;said it was not reasonable to use a zone to try to stop a. use V/10101that zone is appropriate. _ y-MBCJ.TTE, COUNTY PL1�23 r _ • ?M1 Fla¢. f aYY !'Y. L .. ..SON N1�NUTtrS �h .fsrlY N-SNG �CQN►1K .3 .. tt 1 s,o of 4 = 1 x 4+ d �l� ,� � '.� � Cl � CS� .a7 �1 • 14 �xli_ �� ��.� r � �� ,� �' u . 9 cov In Az S CL ro . n r r. r a� �+ z tifir 4 Y, g, .ti-` 'Lr Ci'(�ItJr PM,hoK~p tigP rd�i � ? MZ.. "i; U �iE +Ulild� i` 7tcn h Url- Y he a j $r•"xl G" t�� M1a I. E mai' ryc s`='x- :fury dfr+;.=j P►e+t s Y; fed h°aWfng tl,+ata Fsr 22 r^�"3��" -` hQVI�;Iti tit'fRcplj zx. ' "`,UI' t CIC r+ r, ITi�ah hc' "'pard �� ury>rr a:li+ba k• r�4 rilE*� 1'EaCfl i80 r 3Pia"Tjt9f{k 'r{yu,a rp "'r� btu tr+a`C^. 4ur CFilj}E�' r, y z ci%y Pttu�,.?ia�t} P�' �rY a te, -L .vrnejVtixr { ar�hfry f"y`'y,SRrulrJ ,i,, �I, 'ii�i.�v,f+-i1 L;r' [t C-1,4�d�iilE'`;''fr �.i'�trx' K�r`i iazv t�l0i -41s•?tr 1JEF "tt t"�7� + E 1l!„tkrCr!!e: t �':»t�$jJF.4fe z h$�J .,p 4 n t� 5 F , 4t1 r y� S� + t$ ,J. '�ja`i'r� �*'aE” •lr'A`= ' � !' W�ti '�y�t�, { N GG y +. 'i� i, rte. Yxt, arr r,�i s - r ♦ o ■ x.V rll yt r"r�. "n tL i'.L 3t. i y ��a, "°�' d' "rf'i, t £r�( •r: r h,tl,.' t. ''v '^e�- ro4." .FSE E r iP,C , -la �"t Yta �r "A. E fri�l7 y k, 1 L1L :}f fi.'e�r -moi 4y�' o} *4 k�'t; 6cti "It ijftT' y ��1 ��`t . +y r . I ti: r N ` S4- i. . O r �' ,- . `,' ! ., j l + `? �. y t{+ !!� w iaf7+3! cl3f 4ii 5 = ,s.a iNuL+ zr�e#rs"wuiJg9a +ri " pp , $ - '�> 'ia xdk:lPr�r a.P i 7hd - :1 • x;Y' ,. , . ruW E it rc' r ` L;En• r+R'� a 'drrt, "tji ti�tJ �. i'� J'�%;�ti ..i ,�`;; wpFt T iS"r,hr L,+^� *A 'v Wit, t err.- r7ult � r; 'emuw �Fa� C.P SOIj �iiP �1rSf_yf7 M� C� $ ¢ ^-(iylry l y i'; FNps. q7 ti,, I. t. !!Cry yy"` �Jrr� a r�_=k �1r'wekTlbt'!+ �� » . Aii��tErt5a' wv1;th yr' r bite' f?Re r •., a°Ital!f u °y�+iUllt xs Ua_ �tTf,1t ` »� al'?Gd �ir ti U C'r+i�' t bi a �* rJ ; F t f 41) �s x G { = = 'J,� i»cr 4' C y f R tx C2 wrE> r"� w � a r ant, on -4 .�f 2,' +u4: i �>;c: na`r« �� � ��.�ifeart�:#NiUi�('t��i �rLtrr' k� �i'!`"» uF`iY n fid- �rti e�� r{�� sdd- +. e'rd`+ e:. G�rsx tl� .;z rr Zt)L,., i .� r v q$ ii+aWi.+L�r' 2�L`S'LI� ..Y.. i ,, a W il��rftl "'�w;+ 0'"f, Sub t, ki i< st : a C' ,'l i..�.r,'�, T Yr`f►lEY eft. } U` ir�rs. �� k r � 1�,�KrC�+'� �; �W�"' '3}j �',. t' "y,'4' , }L�,.�'' �'- w ��i'^'�ui�v1�1°� yam`'' •% ,s ,14tl: alf +..L .w"r ay 1, e y yL ."S lr; ,rtl� P + L ax ,, » i 4k -.+i5, "- ,a yry A, •j1.,µ +y, iF k y t� ia"}� r.SdR' i d� tel � 4"s, u Adm"f h .fit s afic.r} [rr qq�`� ( i aka' "i?�"ear s�� U�PjjQc�. .r' $.w'"* iii « C+ h"-'{ ���� .M �..4,�a r - ,x t 'ii` �caR�➢r_ Efi' a r�Ly . � � mir�> f a wn � , 1 .4 }/.. j, In 4 �M11 �y > �� k yr. 4 Y V' i o n' i f.4 i ''. '.N 'FJ TII �. �'. �i' �5 /1 r l i'�'v Lrl �"LL yLtJ .•l�s"��_t ��� Lti�W'r�ti3; !12M 1 1 y 11AI nliS .:i C .0 '' It i 7 ,r�'. i t., .W � i �.� 1 ltAV# � ,lt x" ,• . a,:r+. _ ,. .1 in; ate. - -. - . o s.f ffirl4,0c`'a'i1'Jr?'r'+ �9b+ q��' ,'�E� 'C w1VSr1��` ry,� i3�{ ": '� r yyr7 ' i�1ft t1 ;U,s,i'te �' li�����I��� br#"4ipE�O i!"w� j iirnri{ i.r :Mr b+r117 �.,,1 4�� : i� i±t' 4tIL Y ,± X11'R1 1t �'ir k ki 7 iGih v F J �te 'CGU si,, 5, U, 9 � C girl; ���i; aQ t'G�U�+ra'!T��a,�'�,�tl .ries.r� he v'C��Amadt�4'�1r i�}h;;`j+ttfliyr"�i�arr Th,I �t a :itr i 1ts 0 ;SYe{ }«.� .yu rim' .1� Y tri i t �5 i Cl �ttgVOn Lt:r} °eti4 a %"w1 a `r�wte�, D �t s 7Cr rF1�te1 `V�' the urW �.1ite '�sY3?'ftt" " C� rrr L. ;+-t 1 L-��pt e i jm� w" ?xa 407,.' L c u41r=h`J,r�v. ZQ� r!',�j'Xf �f�� ��Pe .i� � �i�C.' i rx} x r� jt C t) p m t th t h u rr t' jv r +� 1 yr °° 7f�1 U S, ti � rWN 44. ZC��M C$k, P e a .� r~ i M w thi Y ��ad se i r r.� -Ct' ' ei 'S -n �, � ton- "615 j, I i7i >il:yn I `4t r L a - r v f t7f nr-@C((e?S rAn' j5�-s }= Gtr i,a �vr ! i^., r,e 't �? its v�j n'� tide.. i F7 Cfi itiY 4, -erl X11rr-►�_ encased'_ 7 zi rCtia�lsylenari tt� irif`r ��yy �+ r, i}X It }C Cl, YjN'"hi[rJtia�jt�Jst ° �ii`:1i1 �Yrj �FSr4,r�i"�� nCe� bid r rhe ?, {jnr+' i1r ,."tt j hrbi 4y r qtr rub. i e Sj7!r -tato ii h, t% c sazi�,uoU `C}" '� :�1 ^t + s bi err fi IJ 2 Lt U ' wok,?r' r ova, �3}:C cern rett6P t?� 1[)'ei"j` eCili yr°'+'fr tha }. 4tei`iprttl5ll� tes+deuce to C�PQYPt r. S ti �r U_. #1j'i7 E$`tv.. tti a,iUnelt'6 „r,E4,�,r NO �7E`Pliten@j7� � +�� � w viii;s -lay:, ;j6 iipCPk ri t ii Te4L>;i" ax L {xost ej' iY iCi C} 4 ��Ce is t'13Pi"," UJYs i!` 'IP` i L hre'Ft.dan �titi�, '�fyl fj'T+ w+i°P ". i3Orj 0- :1v':itjUC4Ut' irrt or i' ' "C, •hy n itC ;iC}r .F�E"a'E�whr 'rZ a Gii ara0 WZ-7 SUbM'itt$d d Y^L"YwI �$� 'they, �e t1eP CCir(" „tr " aP t. y �+ i4 _ L L ] j i3,, the. n o f�14 C' h A 4: F� rJ .� ar C' 4ii4 C tib cif .2. '`r L.i lrl� rC D �7t iii a Cr 'i`e n ?r 2ttk .P prop�an��`' 2 yC Z w + r CE .; nr e Y y yy n c GI�i1yy@Gt W r ile M6n y ;gym rtt h e C rr, r+ r0�:%t; Cia .j`i ter-" r r ..c 1J,C�'r:... 1 r+fLD.Ci%fUCyL��a "+rjntyt �5t- `{tt?`�ll�% �i5 r2i t'tten a31. +7.t"6J OT iJ+�it'- +"ai I'Cjh'riJ r 'F .a,. idnt`. ,t orY x ? � 'vrie a i' .rtdt ' ,,. �3Crfi I Q'h r •r7ie+1 ' a'; d tie .G11�U 'm ,jet! �t�lh Li tsL h �r.y g`- C+le int ,4t'4�!"Or, i' I7Gi ��' r i3idhaW!? 1Cii2 *irFS rtJi'annppe r ih'Y ifrU« {>`+?xjeCi A5 r - - ,a r t -he r vet t a x ti r t z a t D, 2 aS 'IC z :. � ,}r ,i,.�. x 5r r �ti, V i °jj,e sw S.OP�3a31'`�ctv�. x' t Lr �t i}i+ C, ,, ;L a r+f"t`'.. 1 it ,y �j y y K Y -'. t� Y Y 9 4 14-�Y" "ter, y� 73 +I r 1 4.yviiitie, 4i r- •i } ""' w +*c_ 1.. r.! ati i� 1"3 rie iz�^ Yis �rUCr r ¢ n y b s1: k' kie at�"i t �arf tri yY f rti «� ;r a lw.tr,:ri�" Yta 2cra„! °r4Szrtiit s r+ r s _• �r :;.t t 4'>:,Sl Ci � yy.',� j4 V 111 j4.'� l -c— 9 '..Yl r . rr1'ie'Gt'P:a«” "'��'r r) �-3'-�'ll,�7sE� rI �� ttrw r t v.P�. 114w,•1i`d Zs, 1: ir`?� r L y �y l i a y�� ty r.�^ ;ri U � '� t_., �J ii .�.J2„�jt1"�-g�etCti #�i +r"r3ti- `"r '�=s+ K h � l � � �;'; T tr : rt� . • s � 1.,:. L ; L .r r nx. N�, N i 3`d�rC!>rS 1 y4. L Ifn sr a•w. h+ ru a'r w'! k c"?.;,`r�lt�.�`%• �t x� 3r � a r"4i`+w�r �:, Ar t kit �(i�.✓,,� ty C, �, �+SY{� 1s P .'. '('' =a G ' i� M..'kl i ;:� � rj, �� w �. y ay � J � ',deit`tCe�S �� thin dile �i� s ,� r�4 rd� 11 ,s i -"ii "Y •.h�1yitf .i t'A .r�i};r a� r, t'�` '» w ,h Y �rCntEro! 9'�1L�' `Y? 4� r r:i i 'Yiry "�C i �. CE:'�Hr ik= 4 , e �w SiM �. 9'.', r jYl'� 7 ,+.��'iY,J�i�'1 and di Yii'e "w�rf r"WY3� Y�' i��. Lx3 9.r+wR tir '1 n i4 w"4 ! � o hd f u jj 4 F d:> ➢ � .,. `^ tj f'•p i+x• *,, An lmR�t�r � 't''i�. 'x:yMi ='� !, � t �; ir':r ''ti aL4 p .r q' , �' ly t 7 fpqFwlF9rlrlYah g „ f - r J17d?y('c,Efi ` , 'yhti c fieft. fl, CrF.i TAA ^it. 14l�� krd' nU4f Tr = c K a ri it « r Pr, CC Ul g A 1� Pfau 'C UJ. III,) 4aic 41af?cC.nfaaJ O� i�y)jw rk/CI.r Second )Free r' 1 d � a�U 7 Y d,ri tr ted tho s�1 f'TC} ) � T �''i1r� + Tett i{9'Bii )13i7A'a C,rr Ui �� �•jbmi,4tee F�"'7 GC+��WI')iC �1�Gc. wY ` ftC Y.tO »�. SJbra ! hi t vmt1 M'Offusloh,1*� �k ,»"'i Ya^ d U%¢_ auSe �,� wt0 CiUL' _ 11�1i1 r I �PrR'.� r ` f z t' pUbq $L ''-if'FGG �z Te..Sa, ^541i�Uey Y U It - . U (?GVJ 113L';` rSrS S�Qt `�e:vi`ci;l a)f? riitltai t(R� !L}' r „' •y � okPy ,� rr�f M!J f`* �50n+a.�.i.'Foes r,a 'lp�r?�'e; �„�ieear JL�i51'rJilier �t� a� irl' yf�U rp � ( ab a td =_:�” 'lG YrfP c �£a1z �Lo s� z at��y � { r E,,Fersndum on hunt wI'C VLtP'au , Co, x.�,' x�n j "9i; n U ;' _t � *Y es t > x*. n» k ' 1'twtc.M alCy+ (ai�U t 7 LJA, tw 5 y n A iA1:xi�._yyi'��: 4- . `,yr6> "�� w •3rJ kl � r� 1 �, F� y tJ �*1Jy .4 U L �aJ r' FJ fs i n,' katr9y r` 'turn 5 y� r � rr S1 '��•' :I Yr f � �� i d �;FZfffAUB x14 i?1tUti.!:�C+,tpw av i�c c":rl2+at.,ztfYNLt1 # i .:lie J rrUl ! 1 f n a rJ r• N G= t O ,v 1 rrfsk b tah4fr/ a j aCt�J ;�i° eiiln c.� t n 99 Y+i ''' " '' �'.�;4" arfd !)F1 41rsI"d�' My f .., i wret= att�' retnt"�LtrS . nvo, r'�d .� S f r r. i 'r 3 _ ! r#s 11a�5 ua':t' ;3Lt wx �) fly? .ti i i; ttic = p -fir C e i is i an +ar8d i' �j r loc ftGr.�lfrk_ rami£' %� t!�F1* fA))ffilcO t f s; qnt �'x€ l a'tic aA pr>�nCSc-e burr` r4 1 ; krj+ i'a"a '{tfr-r� P1� nUa"at`.t`S r' ail a`l r, n�Inc, tl"c moi`4 ^unpi'01 c " r _sear F1rx i a.4t 4 y '.aiY' fir,, ;rlpY1r n sa'y: /r+i.wI`ci'�0 "µ+r sa� iiSi''r_ 'S f� fiti✓a"a i' �.r r d <? , i"w F�zri�iJr* ca � E /1Y :FCA " U no t! p» a» :. F---' !' ,. y y. ,� ++ w �;W w;d i r r k•' {i ^ ttS t ` Y W . uf�FiJc ti F CiG G T'Cprii hF;H r`!:v Lir t'� LttU ' pp x 1 1 A4!"A is til Y4 ��M'i c+.Y •1J4 g �l a� �� �>� ;��& ,� � �;�.' ,, � � r , n t r ��. •Ids n� � ��:��� r���� ��r�r L e yI . �'x%i fyx. �tiCF1"C)Ci^ :tt'al, r�Cw L;ia �r",,g`ipc , r1d.3i Lit, ��liP ti tta� ..-.aM:9�'r•.rt .t +w i'•+'✓•+ —.,tl � ,. y, ,t w6r wr. h ��e`v�sal'-�. ���,q! `"µr° ._�•'r `y� 3,�..�Yw * 6 -"' w .t d jfi a"xCgcfhen: 'x ° s w Cn r3tl t1Ci ce tl3W)'tJ�'x�t4��'aW �cw �, Ertl•_ -� + - . rod �4 .1•tc." E1;"� :Lr + ,I'' *.i iJ�Yim4 i . t '�� � � `�7 +M +, rr« � r. s i hat ri' A x� f�,,i f�r'� � �:�cF� .. 'l .uti � w, VJp; � 4 y,�,a. ii Frii 1V MJt''. :1�C 4Wils /'' (bf�"� '� ft''�..r ze14 31Wrs itS, w .o .trt� Yry r » WO ti2llidr v ''' h° •,� y., „.s i s1� �,* i ��1't OB Y��j"�r�C'+�"gIY'� O'a' w'�b �_ 3�Jt>•Mi`l �, I pi! -i � h ari ,. y_. t[Er,,, i�.•if .... r c rtT I 41 dn� �".` it,, to ur�)x"Jr0^,X r 1 , tbi► A i?n a�{C�ni Ii 1 °i j . it -V M > i_, .0 a uA �* n nI ` x`�YY �')� "Y3G rv0 �, `4: ,} 1 na"= tr�'lv sl, zj I �I �' r r 4' ' "'amu h �.b t c DeVe v6 a x:� , 0ovlcas 01 LAW OFFICLS OF t 1992 o c' DAIVIBL 'V. BLACKSTOCK yet ali(ornia c 1440 LINCOLN, 8VITE 3 �rOV iTt°/ c OROVILLE; CALIFORNIA 95965 Fax Number (910) 534-0867 (916) 534-7144 ticet (016) October 15, 1992 Chico of Butte County Board of supervisors 25 County Center ,Drive OVOville, California 95965 RR: Dutch Ravine Sportsmen s Club, Ind. Dear Board Members' c Since my letter of October 8, 1992 1 have had the Opportunity to discuss the zonin Property in the Swedes Flat area gwith MembersSituatiof fon my client r s' would appeal that we do have a difference of opinionrasttoftha inte�:pretauion of certain uses allowed under the and 'therefore I would respectfully request that Werbeel zoning', placed an .the agenda to specifically obtain your boards' Tulin r`r Chapter 24 of the county code. g pursuant' As to setting a time; T woUld Simply request that it erg at your boards convenience, fully realizing and apprec your heavy schedule of hearings; etc. iating I presently have certain` trials and hearings set in the last two week of october, and commence a two week Jury on November 2 Therefore z would � request that this matter be scheduled on your regular meeting agenda at Some time at your Convenience in the latter part of iJoverk�er or December. ' Yours truly., Daniel V: Blackstock DVBJdkb f CC: William Farrel Betty Kircher aeff Madd6h. j---------------- kO LAW OFFICES, OF Develapmellx DANIEL V. BLA!CKSTO.CK OCT1 1.440 LINCOLN, SUITE 3 OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 96966 *0010, l Fax Number (916) 534.0867 (916) 534-7144 Chir.? office! (016) 9§&jP1 October 8 1992 Butte County Board of Supervisors 2.5 County Center Drive oroville, California 95965 RE; AP# 028-170--028, 028-•320-003, 072-330-016/ and 012-330-018, Property owned by the Dutch. Ravine Sportsmen's Club, a corporaf:f&)) [i Dear 'Board Members: Ravine Sportsmen's Club, Inc./ corporation. The corporation is the I represent the Dutch owner of the above-descra'" assessor parcels, which consist of approximately 842 acres, io the Swedes Flat area. The property has been used for hunting purposes, and to our, understanding has been leased for huntinq,, purposes and related uses for well over the past fifty years. This of Course is :not inconsistent with the history of other parcels of land nearby as well as throughout the county. The property is typical of the :foothill. area, i. a. , is not flat, W45 rather has substantial elevation differences and uo.,ald be described as hilly terrain; primarily covered by brush and wit'fg very few trees at this time. My clients' have conducted a mill r of activities on the property aimed at reducing possible fire' exposure, including the removal of brush. Unfortunately a number of misunderstandings have occurred relative to the activities of my client. One of the neighbors have contended that my client is in the process'of releasinq wild pigs and other animals that will in turn go ovdf? onto other peoples property leading to trespass, etc. This is° simply hot true, and at the present time such uses are simply ri beinq`undertaken: The misunderstanding probably relates to what would eventually like to do in the future if i economcally ,feasible Piease bear in mind that the animals tltesd the neighbors are talking about, i e., Wild pigs and mountain goats, sheep, etc. are very expensive: They would have to be controlled by internal fencing so that the animals could not bo` lost One of the misunderstandings that has arisen relates' the very name of my client. The individuals who ;incorporated J.r 1 i 4tt0 Courtty Board of Supervisors Ag: Dutch Ravine Sportsmenis Club ?Age 2 this corporation Picked the name Dutch Ravine S �7r TPc. even though they are not operating a huntizp^ Csmen, s all 4�le present time. This is simply the name of the club as such t hick happens to be t;,- ra7 Ins'Which happens fee title owner o�E -the he corporatiai does not Property. For well memberships or have d. Membership as Is the case:: with many "clubs".- As a result of the letter. that the ecororation r.ceived from the county, the corporation has modif1e th i has "tivities on the property so as to be consistent, with thezo nd past use, pending the outcomeg re , gtiect of their rezoning ni1f , We would respectfully submit that hunting r: state the question another way, that the use of hunting has never beenProperty per se, or �' 1Under zo for ifunting can be Precluded in this county under zoning'. Precluded, and is precluded pursuant to the Provisions of the Y � , g a tonere one can hunt.ouToamdekn4wladgeng the,Peeve Code in tern',', AS a nuisance in this County unless of cot rwz r been`classe�' Shooting unto the neighbors it were to invaj.ve, Only a nuisance brat is also apflatrOut tr spass toat Of uwhe is not neighbors would have full recourse to the courts. hich the Because of the misunderstandings relative to what has actually occurred e: the property, we wauld respectfully t eques?� Your permission to appear accusations by or►e othe owners of the surround Our board to mond to these, ;could lute the u g propexty, opportunity to set the record straight, and to ,point out that a number of other property err o area are ver su P Y weer, in the immed Ltd- Y supportive of our (efforts. The coY oration had previously sold chUckers , raised under their auspiceshtosVarious d bobwhite p quail course tier . be allowed to take them. We have the approvalwof allho of Cofrue.will o'Li activitaes fro.+.; Fish and Game, and it must be understood-tha't the birds, which are"in essence a livestock operation, are raise the Purposes of being eventually hunted on the d � c bv3aw, l} ,3r a e of ',zheto birds; ,,this twill ancludeepheasar5�..; bobwhite quail, an& chuckers ina ver q } property. Y well fly away frofri 'thit Those bi`''ds will have all been banded as required by Fish and Game who of course regulate this t , of course the birds themselves will e, hailceytheonaturalvit and de these 'birds in the area Y aid:*' when these birds are released,11nottall of chemawilnderstand'thet the people they have been sold to. be taken by n ,Butte County Board of Superxjisors ' RE Dutch. Ravine Sportsmen a Club Page 3 ' we' would respectfully suggest that Supervisors looks into this matter the when tl�e practically all of the Board of y will learn that hunting. They are Usedpforehuntingneitherrba are themselves or their licensees. usfld for ?�r . Pierce whothaspcomertyswne' You may very well hear shot guns, however we would rp�� plained: submit that fZom the distances involved it is ekd resp6l unllke]:y that he could hear a shotgun being g Y client + s' Property. g_ dis�.har ed p Y• Could would s p l falx not carry that far. we would suggest further the soundg from rtty some of these would s�,mpl People may be coMPlaining about aretthe Maybe eowrhiat neighbors and people hunting ori their .s in the process of actually compeir property. T their fending The core ratio property and in doing .so of course the of all of eliminatingt y are also d del�ious areas of brush which would fuel a range f which would dej:initely endanger the very people who are 5 -ire e Thank you in advance for your consideratian,o request to come before you to respond to the allegatio f our before You recently concerning our operations. respectfully request that all communications ns made Also x would the Dutch av�n Sportsmen s Cl b enc, from the county to that we can more readily respond to any of the ncoUnt me in order. Y con cerr��, YOUts truly, v+ r Daniel V. Blackstock OV13/dkb cCz Bett Kirshner tl , developman4 5ery cea MAY 2 6 1993 n Orovilio, Caii9ornia Z rte Corint y Board of Supervisors, You te probably aware that we at Dutch Club aInc, are disc Davi re request. enial ofnourpoeza �s q We feel that -the dissuehof�a use r zone taken up and gsyen much permit was We were repeatedly told weigthe ht in the decision and decided on was the rezone ay issue unfairly, to be discussed zoning we re n'lication that the quested was in line with t plan, further that the Property could he countyls into 5 acre parcels in an general permit Judged ed Y case: a not be divided j 9 by the Board Not only was the use to untruths and exaggerations. you chose to listen do not object also donoteratiorls. As usual, those who, Board of Supervisors wouldruleonpeak 0' an Had we known the agenda, we would have gathered our supporters issue not on the Y ve on Swedes Flat 'Roadpporters to appear, man of whom li The real purpose of 'thIs letter, however, to hunt in Ag zoning in Butte Count is the iti the Zone. Code Book of huntin Y• These is privilege Blackstock, informs us this is becauOur se at n° mention traditional American Y► Dan down a Privilege. There g is a Y the Galif. bout- of Fish & Game which law,- set are required' to obey- owners, animals,] and the hese laws also which all hunters environment. protect land In Butte County there are Licensed Pheasant huntinclubs, and farmers a.nd ranchers lease thosehuntinguri c These clubs charge lobs g for the rights done and would have privilege, just as w these clubs in A continued to do, e have Permits. g zoning in Butte county are operating` This opens the Y without use allowed commercial t�untinqueston: Why are t f S Portsmen s 5 privileges and Dutche clubs Privileges inlButte Cot` We feel this a 'ravine qu-stion of hunting' limits should be determinedoandgmoretoning clearloutside °f city by the Board of Supervisors: defih.ed to request a e the agenda we Mould like place 9 a to resolve the question If it is the determination of the Boar,d of Supervisors hunting clubs or charging a fee to hunt p visors allowed. al,l such clubs should is not down as we were,, and legally have to be c clubs in Eutte Count there is a. large number of such os.ed Us And to allow all other clubs to operate and not. us would seem to be t Of discrimination. he ver Y defini ton Sincerely, Randy McMa,.h and Virgin President ia Berglund ent Secretar Y Dutch Ravitle SPortsmen O s C QRa���i-��nc 0 _ 7y1 24-20 ZONING 24-20' (3) To obviate the menace to the public safety rogultmg , from the location of buildings, and uses of buildings and° of land, adjacent to streets and 'highways which are a'" part of the streets and highways element of the general plan of the county, or other thoroughfares, so that existing or prospective traffic circulation on said high= ways Will be facilitated: (c) It is expressly declared that all of the provisions of this chapter shall apply to all property within the unincorporated' territory of Butte County whether owned by private :persons, firms [or] corporations, or by the government of the United States of America, or any of its agencies, or by the State of g r California or any of its political subdivisions or a envies a by any county including the County of Butte, town or munici- pal corporation or any of its or their agencies, or by any district formed under the laws of the State of California. (d) The board of supervisors shall have the authority to decide any question involving the interpretation or application of any provision of this chapter. Said provisions of this chapter ., d the applications thereof shall be held to [be] the minimum x:a�.•�"n�ents necessary to promote the public health, safety 'onrl . ;,�nfr., a welfare. Except as specifically heroin provided, it is" llat iil tew),-x l b,yN this chapter to repeal, abrogate, annul or in ai',y way t� itr,p���11 ��° interfere with any existing piovision' of law or ordinances or any xulei rqulntinn or permit previously adopted or issued or which may, aha adopted or issued pursuant: to law relating to the use of buildings or premises, or "relating to the erection, constructinn, estANzhment, moving, alteration or enlargement of any building. improvement, r_or is it by this chapter to interfere with or abrogate or ,,nbik*l` any : easement, covenant or other agreement between parties ° or to ' annul or abrogate the public improvements emplaced and: paid, for by Property owners pursuant to previously adopted county plans; provided, however, that in cases in which this chapter imposes a greater restriction upon the erection, construction, Qstablishinent, moving, alteration or enlargement of buildings or the use of any 'such building or premises in said several districts or any of them, than is imposed or required by such existing provisions of 16w or ordinance, or by such rules, regu 240.3 Supp. 140. 6-0 w, Q1 '��'.. �. � k � •u[^"��.. fir= ,.,, T "'•1RCCTOR'S OFFICE DEPAR7MEN'I' ur U, -.V ,-, t V 7 COUNTY CENTER 013IVE •` ^ OROVILLE, CALII- TELEPHONE; (916) 53[1.7601 MEMORANDUM FAX; 196) 530.7785 TC Butte County Board of Supervisors F9614; Bill Farrel, Director of Development Service Craig Sanders, Project Planner s SUB LID, CT: Dutch Ravine SPOr•tsman's Club, Rezone, File g" DATE:3 0g February 26, 1593 - REQiJFST/RBCOMMFNnamrD Randy D. McMain Dutah Ray' Declaration regarding envronmentalm impacts and Rezone proposed (Agricultural - 5 acre parcels) to ;FR -40 (Footilill R from ,A r 0 acre parcels) located a 4 eatiana-�+ -- sides of Swedes Flat Road praximatGIV 840 acres , pproximatel located onot Oroville-Bangor Highway,y 1 1%2 miles east d', identified as AP 028-170+-028, 028-320-(�D�r 07z� 30-016 and 038, Oroville area. o Staff recommends the Board concur with the Plan. -I' C subject to the findings lz;sted in the report, g ommissian ' ` by Ordinance; p approve the request ANAL3C3ig_ This is a request to rezone a ro "r. 40: The r pi ximately 840 acres from A-5 to FRS Property is located in the southeastern foothills of th County on both sides of Swedes Flat Road east b£ Oxo-Ban.o7er Highway. The current zoning is A-5 which was ado t0 g the current General Plan Opted in 100 and. surrounded b policies. The property �s 22 co Y Parc-els of varying size fr pre -dates o _ ntiguous ;parcels average 79+ acres in size.° 480 acres. The / the Genera ct will result in a zoning that is More consi his pro e was adopted in 1970, nine years be s 5 stent zone 1 Plan olicies • � than the existing A.5 zone, adoption in 1g79 and does not meet the; c The A�5 zone fore the current General P1_ai' criteria of the Agr1 Rural Residential designation for than z0 acres. r parcel The current zoning a.s not consistent with the General Pian and grips property owners a false sense of dev Potential for ;heir property and is further miss eadin . elopmenl ecausd the MinskCYc area is nr.t suitable for a r�' Minimum g cultural uses. For a Parcel, sa ze less than 20 acres to zo`in'�ta%'� a Ag7: icultura:l. Residential. General Plan deS be consisten`'t � L e criteria must be with i, h Present: g Ation the fc.l:ldy,4419 1. Compatible witil neighboring agricultural ac 2 Evidence of adequate water t1viti,e'� 3: Availability of adequate fired sewage, disposal capilcity, Adequately maintained approved facilities, capacity to service area. proved road access Reasonable aGr �with 5 dssibility to commercial services a Cry, Feria 3 , 4 + and 5 are clearlyschof� �Stia.ionable. The zoningf not present and n actors to consider are f ll is `� + �1.,+ Existingas fold ovis S 24 Slope parcel sizes .in residential densa.zes 34 soil conditions and water availability 4. Effects on adjacent uses; crop p production; livestock e�raxi� Y, resource extraction and wildlife habitat. 5 Proximity to public reads and other , Public facilitid,4c �= Distance from airports, railr► ads and industrial us 7• Existing utility and drainage facilities $ Potential for surface cracking, ss, 9. Effects on noise traffic floia and safet es and erosii5n, qualitywildlife habitat and general envyronme • g Y, , water qual,Lty, a j,;- a,n Local desires. nt.al, c�ual�t�,r Potential for pest insect breeding, In that addition to the listed zoning factors 4t this property is located within a designated critical be gnote. reotimmend ng parcels of California Department of t� cad, WA mbar deet" range where the . kis'h and, G<�me aa'°t* 40 acres or greater., The 'applicant has made. it clear that 'their establish a commercial it recreational fac�iimate could incl a hunting club goals is to rifle range, archery course ` a sporting clayz ty ori-sits Wici: spaces with a central clubhouseaod shooting coursesy a in pursuing this lod e.; Y , Camping ,:enc( V .for goal since the A-5 g This is t2ie first possibly s this t. zone.. byte typo of does. ofie . � p Use. Under the ;1 R_40 zoriin riot have a proV.ision recreation use requiries' a use g an outcloox� t: ofimerc: The applicants were alrea permit,: chukar, and deer hunt.,ng on spte'paL-his as hlaw from nearby pheasant, qua�f.�.,,,; y property owners - Howeveri, concurs instruct the property owner to stpcmdinerialPh nnn Zoning and a use g Da vision to Permitgwere obtained, The Board s ng uric � � � `a the issue. of the hiintin club to )be the foous anti r p ax hould zirt 'alloV this is a rezone and approval.of tt+; .. + on the Outcome of a ure use ph is rajer t shil _w� ap'P Ca�,110 poi catioh fore "►h oui�doano g recreation facility other t�� {n to give tine property to apply for said use: criteria and upon the Departm rite tlof he Galiera:l Pawner the aright k'ish and Gafio po liCiesl, and p li.Cies tt�e Y 4 r f11I , Y T • .t ti Ip , , than the proposed toning is more appropriate :f'o>: the area, fy)xis project is not )Seen as a spot zoning because of the. phy8101 �1to of the propert1, the inconsistency of the A, zone ;Iltll eneral. plan, and the zoning will not confer speciai',p JVJ164LO -0 xe applicant. This entire area needs to be rezoned and tbd. b0fl- Td .recognized that fact when it directed staff to,review the A-6 MAW -f r consistency with the General Plan. « ' LANNxNG-cO.MMISSION ACTION: The Planning Commission Aheard lengthy testimony regarding t14r- project.' Most of the continents from the public centered on the'U99 of the pro)-perty for a hunting club and the negative impact#, *vould have on the area including noise, safety concerns, tract.€a19, road maintenance, the introduction of exotic game species/ 40 increased fire hazard. The Commission remanded members of 't,41e public the project before them is a rezone not a Use Permit fff a hunting club. The commission took an action recommending that •tbe Board approve the rezone. ALTERNATIVES •. . i4 <156 44o ert, 1; Deny the request and leave the zoning A:-5: This will f6CWS t112 j-ssue on what type of hunting activities are allowed In ^i n A-5 zone and possibly_ result in a request from the .td#,Vd fart an interpretation. C:ision• Given the policies the General Plan, no zoirefer :back to the Plarin��;nS" ommi p of 5+i'P4 2. Recommend a different zone a with a minimum parcel size less that 20 acres should J?e considered, with a 4o acre minimum being pi;eferred dud to c habitat concerns for the deer herd. This would leave the 40 or TM -40 zones. The A-40 zone would allow huntingdais& � outright and the TM -40 zone would have the same effect as thO M-40 zone whether or not the uses contemplated by *, g y property o*aver would be consistent with 10hunting'camps" 'tECommtNDATIONs : , Mt7TION ,Ay Find that the requirements of CEQA have been dompleted a)d considered in making this decision aitd adopt a Negative Declaration regarding environmental impactt and 13+ Find that the rezone conforms to the policies, including the text and map of the Butte County General Plan becausei, The PR -40 zone is listed as a zone that is consistent with`the Agricultural 'Residential General Plan_ designation while tha A-5zone is only conditionally consistent and that th.e conditions do not exist to support the A-5 zone °specifically"' �i JU,N ,� pr June 14, 1993 Dear Mr Farrell, ? I had a conversation this merixing with. Jeff', Madden, in regards to the Sportsmen's Club. He stI9qe$btd1jI compose 'a letter to you explaining' tour i.nte:ntions for the pro1,#erty. As far as I know it has been several month, singe any commercial hun..ti.ng or shooting has taken I—Lace on the property.. In order to convinc'B you of this °;fe are gain to take al.l the trap machines off the 'property, we will not apply for a pheasant club license for this Property, .,there will be no more game birds released and the gates to the property pro ort will remain locked .at all times except during entry and exiting. Anyone from your staff is welcome to come up and check at anytime. Tr the Property does ti ,+na y p Y not sell by the fall deer season, decide ' to bow :au:nt on the property and nay uncle " may rifle hu!/,),t. a I hope this moots your satisfaction and Ism sorry for. any inconveAlonce-welve caused you: Si core y; Randy b�ain� Pres. Ul'achRavine s ni is meis Club r„ C1 11 : Iy� fir• ,-, .. .,. ,. r. .. ......... .. ..:... :' 1 .� 1 -�--"' Fr Ufa - DIRECTOR'S oFFICF DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT 6V;1VI0E6 7 COUNTY CENTER Dnm - OROVILLC. CALIPC7ANIA DU90407 X TELEPHONE, 191 C) s3a.70C)1' PAX, 016) 630•1765 lune 14, 1993 'Twin Cities Rod and Gun k,.,ub, Inc. 07' Ainsley Avenue 1�uba City, CA 95901 Gentlemen. "thank you for your recent letter regarding the Dutch Ravine Sportsman Club. The Board of Supervisors have requested me to respond to your concerns, i first, let me clarify the Boards action. The Board determined not to + grant a rezonin{� from the current A-5 zone to the FR (Foothill-Recreation) zone. Had �he Board granted the requested zoning change, it would have then b.;en necessary for the Dutch Ravine Sportsmas Club to obtain a conditions) use permit to operate. That' Sportsman's discretionary decision by the Planning Commission, could have been appealed to the F,oard: At the Board hearingi strenuous objections by neighbors to the clUb evidenced the proposal was controversial and would continue to be soy Concerns expressed by neighbors at the hearing included increased usage of the narrow dirt road serving the area, hazards from stray bullets and nolse from shooting at the Dutdh Ravine: Sportsman's Club. In cases such as this, there are never easy answers, The County strives to achieve harmony among the different land uses existing or proposed In the area, Again, In this se, the Board elected not to make the requested zoning change. 'In making its decision on the rezoning request, the Board only expressed' concern as to the suitability of the hunting and clays club at this specific location proposed, given the proximity to residential uses. The Board did not address hunting in other locations at ali, nor was there any adverse discussion of hunting or firearms in general. The purpose of the rezoning''request by the Dutch Ravine Sportsman Club was to obtain a zoningdesignation within which the proposed year around corTmmerclal recreation facility could operate. The A-5 zone does not all(4 r for such uses, due to the generally small size of acreage involved, The A-10 ;s,t1d larger ag zones do allow for "hunting camps" which are understood to mean seasonal huhtii�'rg. It was for this reason that staff recommended to the sportsman club that they persue foothill Recreation zoning,, 1, • Twin Cities Find aril �b, Inc. June 14, `i9g3 Page 2 It has been pointed out in several letters to the Board that there are other hunting r camps within the existing A-5 zones in other arts of th although P e County. This may well. Ns established legallyare unaware o, their location. Such uses may have been p for to current zoning regulations, or may have simply been Introduced without the County's knowledge. On a reflective note, the conflict between the Dutch Flavine Sportsman's Club artcf t� Neighbors is a, result of a gradual change in 'land uses With the introduction of residences In 'the foothill region. These conflicts are in inevitab)I7 and as more ;arrei More people move into the countrysiG� conflicts andltmrtde, we will experience m ations' on traditional uses, including hunting and shooting. { 9 1'le hq a you reali' Thar these are not confli�;�s that the County has sought !yet when disagreements drt between neia!-��ars; the County' called upon to make the best decision it can. Thank you a ,`1 n for writing to us 1 hope that this answers at least some of your Y 9� ', pestions y r Sinc rely, Blil Farrel;_ ;1 Director of Devalopmer"t Services 1_ cc: Board of Supervisors i� 474 11 1 , 7� r cn r OMOW a, toVie, Cnl�,�nnla YJ a to e5r .! 'OF .Owl 4 ICT llir,Ot MW �OMS;14A,77- i y100 'y 1r .o. S cceM. o�'PoRr��7,�r, �x ,��•sp.� sT���.y s�l�kiv� cs�.�.�' �'i�, �-� � heh,OID n G-- A44 , lsftl �ald�.hclS ,!� PRtu�t� r�xt, c►��u�y Jttg�.tT' ; Wle "��-Z �/ft$!Z� �i �° ccG!9' ,9l �t.71.o,� 71 ��9-�"Z` ►�rt �¢ � ' 10 , ,F7 Sff . —y,A �1xttSS�,aya �4?tts�E� o ;. to tt s. LIGF- Mh 44447.41, .., � tr•�t1i� r�,tT Fu t, ev,7n�St I�E+�-1't �'1 7t, REZ„D�l t �-- 612 6 ,. -t ip OL 4 Rxo r U t ei tk � :S f� R.TS y�At�v1. � j r 0Ao,� o c "t y _ t o �i 4._ ��v?A IN 00 +J; ( r` App`71`' i April 11. 199 board of Supervisors of butte County -90 County Center Drive roville, CA 95965 - J Dear, sir/madam: 1` i' It 'never seeT,�s to fail that the selfish wily of • th6, :P,@,W overt idea the: desi:s.-es of the (many. How is it that, you, the g 'k� ' County Boa,rc Of SUJOLrvisc)rs, cin make aclEac si.ar► against the, Z�6,� JolVille,Sfsortsman,, s Club y in denying is re;.one application wh0-f i�)h 4ppl.ica.t;ion was approved .by the Plannil:ng commiss on, the Depart�iWnt, O fish and. Game, and Z4. other agencies? Yeu should welcome- () %4si,ne8t that brings, in nded} ed to dol'La,ra and is not detrSinie x �i tea the e. vi.tonment » HFve any of you Board rtemhers hectii two DutrllRavine? Ye" would find _ a, wholesome safe atmosphere for shooting 1 d hunting, of whicih ther4 are too few in californ;la, The 'Board shoul04 not let ` the few vojoes th- 4t obj ecti, to W41;10 Ravine b6comd another Bolinas in Marin Ootintyt i:e. the 111 A19,Y0 mine we cion+t need, or want you" mentality, As 'fixative Californians we have seen many changes in 50 torah liked and "' , houl,d na�� stop prngress,, some not, �,yut ,�e s Very', truly yours.., , I ,charl,es E. Finnel Charleizi R skrab�id 2`4 Fair Strera Pet41libia CA 908,2 (70") TO -0390 6AOVILtt, CALWA NIA APR W43 h� SOR Zl 9 i i #avcd and Dolma McDonald 18805 Artdmvier Dr. a lMagalia, CA 95954 r Dovelop�men May 24, 190:3 19l3I J U VII a �t Matte County � Board of ,3u rvisors OrGylilp CeIIfQ+tnia: 9.� County Center Drivf, .0roville, CA 95965 I Ac, Dutch Ravine Hunting & Sporting Clays Club j: Continue to be: amazed by the cap `.tier attitude in which the. Second Ante ndmel t is treA61d l>y liberal politicians aj1d the dominant liberal media. For some unknown reasot.:Pol # 61R04) modia and the public cannot seen! to grasp the threat to thein First Amendment °rights o { lre%dom of spet;ch by .attacking and otheiwise devaluing other Constitutional Aineridtni'� fif�a Tinse who seelc to replace our representative form of government with a socialisti0* ,bureaucracy tltatwould dominate all aspects of our Jives have, selected the easiest iarge.4 fid`#4 t11e right to bear arms. But the fact rermins, the dilution of tiny Constitutional Arrtenclf a'ei'? i will weaken onr Bill of Rights in itw entirety: ff those who would throw all the guns into the sea at? succesilful, their next target will 17 : lie the First Amendment. After All,, if it isn't fair or acceptable to own a gun, than it danif be fair or acceptable to speatc or write opposing opinions. To many this may sound 1ii?�Ei leap of logic, but',[ don't think so. Any reduction in :our personalfreedoms, no matter )�i� y slight; whether one finds that particulat fiededom personally distasteful or, not, greatly diminishos all the fte:e4oms guaranteM by our Constitution. The bias of the ;Board of Supervisors in denying hunting and commerciail use permits td' Dutch Ravine s just one more indicator of politicians taking it upon themselves to attach' Ill Constitutional rights. The Butte County Planning Commission, Department of IFisri & (kd ley and 24 other agencies have approved Dutch Ravine's rezone ;application; The Board Of Supervisors not only I.gnorod their adedce,, but they have di,rmriminated ai;a nst Dutch RallJt"�St and struck, a.nothe.4 blow to laur individual rights. In a County on tike verge of bankruptcy, the Board of Supervisoks has aifparenrly pia thdir personal bias before the needs of the public by potentially eliminating a. Ig x generating business that ,just: h;fppens to ezum its incor le through the sporting u5'e of guns. Ifit-. isn't personal bias, where is 'the, 6gie in Ignorilig the advice. of 24 agencies ai;d denyingl la, rezoning application From a new tax pnA cing business? I beg the 'goanj of Superuij' ibrs� l� ` reconsider their pasitibri, implement thd guidance of other guvernme�jt �q;encie;s; aril rant use ,permits to hutch Ravine. o �' Sincerel c� r ZONES REFERRING WO HtMr,, 'G OR SHOOTINGi ACTtNtX'T]CES A-10 through A-1'60 Agricultural Zones butte CouY�ty �.,ode :wMl Oections 24-075 through 24-84: hurting camps al.lowed. 1 C -V (Commercial Forestry) Zone, BCC Section 24°'111,, 160 ; Yr,e inInimum lot .size: hunting allowed. ?R-1 through FR"160, Foothill Recreational, Zones, BCC' Sectidns' Y4- 111.5- through 24-1-12A: hunting lodges allowed wlh use, pe L J�,.• M -R (Mountain or Recreation Subdivision -Residential) Z;oner #4y SecClon 24-123, minimum lot area 1/2. acre, hunting campe and 044 cslubzc allowed with use permit when located on Sites of not 1000 than d'iv'e (5) acres. A -C (Resource Conservation) Zone, BCC Section 24-1.47r rnihi uj4i, #t area, ten (,10) acres: hunting allowed. TM -1 through TM -160 (Timber Mourta n) Zones, BCC Section 24. . through 24-1d6: hunting camps; gun club.; and ranges al;awec''% its,« permit: ItPZ-160 (Timber Preserve Zona:) , BCC Section 24-1'q0: hunt allowed it co:npat .ble with use of the property for growjhq 124 harvesting timber. **Ndte The,above listiig is not necesoarily echaust14VG. t�liT.Udt ;:: t t�; �; SAMPLE LANGUAGE FO ` DUTCH RAVINE SPORTSMEN'S CLUB UTTtgl F; that "All uses of land within a 24-64 provides i` 1. Butte Count Code Section npertinent.9,,4-)rt zoned districtnot specif oY authorized or permitted by the regulations are prohibited.+ 2. The A-5 (Agricultural) Zone, Butte County Code Sectlerr - 72 does not specifically r. ecificall authorize or permit hunting oshJ6+."�, activities. The lack of such authorization' or permss3:6t� gig'nificant in vi6w of the fact that such activities APP— Opecifically referred to in a number of other zones. 3 Under the clear language of the Butte County d�6 r commercial hunting a.nd shooting aCttivities of the "type You h+ye proposed are prohibited. 4. Butte County Code Section 24 20 Subseotion d � s ' rl i � i ,in eminent �� �''� � i ( } prose, p part that The Board of Su ervisvr•s shall have ` JA authorityto decade any question involving the ihterpretatititi r,F application of any provision of this Chapter.$ 5. However, 'it is not proper to ' "inter ret p the zcih,,.,,�g -regulationsulations in the Butte County Code, where the meaning of brviszons as plain the language, is clear and unaMbiguots dj�,d there is no uncertainty or doubt of the intent of the Boar($ Supervisors in enacting it. 6 The 4oard of has delegated rtt me, Chief I Admihi tr ,t , e Section- 2=20. a�lM. Officer, rtrhe responsibility to determine if agenda requests tshd 4 be submitted to the Boardin this instance, for the reage.M,f stated al;ove, Z am decliningto lace ' p your ;request on the Boar"d/p agenda.' #tFitQJalt �rlvipSMciiusmpie2,ing) t 7I Dear Friends, As you have' Prob.6bll, heard by now, we Caere denied our 'it rezone by the D,Iil t t e County Hoard of Supervisor;l The orfici:als maintain there is no hunting or cottunerojal: use permiLt•ed in A-5 to A-160 zone. 'There are,, p1teasAilb aitd duct hunting clubs located in the valley o,C 13tit:e County zoned A-5 to 11-160, just as we are. We fork, as does our aUborney- that this is a discrinlin;lLory decision oft the part of the county. Ile worked'clorlel.y With the planning departnient, taking all the steps, Lhc advisod us to take. The planning -commission, j1he Depbr of Fi4di & Game along with .24 other? agencies approve,ci t our rezone t1�p13.caLion, The ':Board of Supervisdrs Vend, totally against Lite advice of their planners ail'd d'e jie(j' our rezone; YUet�ociearsld ttno, Land iscsUilj inat almost i,tlaitcialclL•rou ed b y 9 trouble,, idou.l.d, welcome a business that bring; in hooded 'Lax dotl&ffl and is not deLri.mental to the environment. Our busf;nktss' icesps wi1:h the rural atmosphere idea the counLy has paid bhoUsands of dollars to promote, We ,,it DuLch Ravine would like to cOhL,intte ofCering jtfou believe Dutch Ravine is ideally located in alt isolat a place i o shoos: acid 11unt 3n a saie envak�omtient: `�e�, area et: close onou h to o uia�i.nn celAbeto �Id y" - g p p to be cot'awei1.1 There are so .feta places left to legally, hu -11L an'd shoop We 110V -la large piece of property here, 'h We ave dev,-46ped a sporting clays course that sheets safety standards, Ii Otir OeXL step Was to, add a 3--D target archery Course sat now�Lu�fieitrouldil.ilcQuch as to takefurther cl"ays course 3 i - improVetttents as we are able. DUt VO need your ;support if VO are to c'ot L;,tnue to oppratiti, We feel. ;L�haL if' YOV write letters exprelisin;cg your "wish to ;;eep us open the 8uLte county Board oT Supervisors sand "the County" PItnning > epartment twill be i'orced to fairly interpret the zoning codes. In your lettersr Please ))king up the points fire have discussec1,' in Lhis letter and ti iy bLhee thoughts you tray have, " please address yobr 1e1,1LOtt to the 13uLte County Hoard of Sizperv"iqOris and 1,aLters Lo' Lhe Editor of the Mercury tieg,ister. (AddressvO to Pollo ) t We really need your support. Shooters and Hunters can no longer afford to be silent and watch as our Shooting and hunting rights slowly disappear. We hope each o ,. you will offer your support by writing`letterrs. !r Thank you. j Sincerely, Randy McMain and Virginia Berglund P.S. We are still open -to our Friends. ; Mercury Register Butte County Board o,, §Vr,�P9visor,t, p.oi Box 651 25 County Center Drive orovillet CA. 95955 Qrosrille, CA 95965 H\�Y ,r Ir..0 ,�~'s.should bo'j65 words or less; loner Ietiets' ' m.t• "ase condensed or"xetamed for condensation by'tt►'e , - not a co witk Ftease send us the ong�nal ( copy) address and plume numt=. :We do. j us ledw,'open leuers to a third party,; r~s vrrirten to tixher pnbtirahons. Verse ;ted libel r'r ,,o".ca=Cnts aren`t•printed. Letters sliRuld deal:with' iq• pot gmondides or religion. Letter ` kitm':Str ry, limit themselves to one published sub►ntission` i c . t. can be deliveted to the .Memory-Regiz0er • 2r;01, Stoond St,; or mailed to P.O. Boz 651, Oroville, ' ti ti.,/.//vN.i .. r'I.:Y :/P � .� y y1Y�4rr • Y `+. ry :; �. ♦main,. y Nw,ry.t it Bu 1 -� DIRECTOR'S or-FlcE DEPAIRTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICE 7 COUNTY CE'NTEn DRIVE - onOVILLE, CALIFORNIA.g$4-90,' �1h1197 TELEPI•IUNE: 1016) 538•7661 FAX- 191(1) 53B-7745 May 14, '1993 Dlane Nlonscri 00 Chinese Wall Road Oroville, CA 95966 ; Thank, you for your letter of April 23, 1993 .(�ocumenting what you b®lieVe are 'Illegall jCtIvIties occurrin at the Dutch Ravine S136rtsman's C � y g� club, l have also received calf of ooncern from other, neighbors. zs rJocument what tis a`h,Iail�� t'akir�c3 placer we are currently, t7vestigatirlg the matte,Y. Until that effort is conrludeil, it, will remain confidential as v 41 would Dot want to jeopordize'the investigallOri. 1 would discourd6e you from doing anything that could adversely affect th�j County's investigation, or in any Way jeopardize your,,self. HoWeVpr, if -'You have additional informati,)n substantiating aL zoning violation, feel free t6 send it to use Once our k' Urreht work is coholuded; a coW'se o '� action Will 6e deter mineci, Which ,�ii1l be d esigned to ensure compliance to the zolning ordi0ancO, We Will of course Iefi ydta know the results at a suitable time. t hope- this letter vVill assure you that we arb t:oncerned abort you and your ne ghbo?.* oorr1plami8and that we are actively )�ursunig them, Sincerely, rr William Farrel, Director of DovelOpment Services tr�tFrjl: I' l� ,gxvN 77" � } Apr, 11, 2 0 r 1 �,),O 3 Dear Rr. Farrel, Your r Of "l��arJ 13anQ� c�xui mended fMarch 17, 1993 r'e��tetiit .. wry �Ntt,; Overal options we axis discussing, pry pttrtyr one opH.0n ve are considering is to ask the Board' Of 'S�apervitim. for an interpretation of t1jo zoning code c fJ for liU6110ed huntling clubs. We know oi° s zninlicensed: Iaheasati{,, clubs how operating in A-5 to A-160. Though ,a X08t of li11e0e clubs may change areas frcm year .to dear, some stay in the same location for years,, We if these other that clubs are allowed to operate inf��el• onin You should not deny xis the right, to operate. Tri�refo�eq� VO consulted a prominent bay area attorney r`�gTh.eref lawsuit on the basis of discrimination„ And fry the Avidence 'we presented to him, he is ErR nn a contingency basis. We have also listed the p y option. taro ert c, e rr a real as another Bt b w.ittt the counties e:.t,remely limited alloy 0d i_w,s bee ear to any proposed uses 'We have F leader of some ole �tt]e nope of sellinq, We have also been contacted �`� a � the local. Asian cammi�nt; leasing the property y about pro ert to farm and raise animals. Also a northern Calif. off road Motcsrc.yc,le club has 4pproaohed, us with a"lease offer.' Regarding complaints and continued commercial use ,of the property, we ceased commercial use back to 0ct ber at your request. Rtxt Ve ha'v'e allowed otir friends to Use has noeJuriisdictionaover~pr vatetanonncoMMerdi t,e county sporting mmerciai hti,nf�ir,, r and shooting. _ 1V. V Ott is our intention to be legacy therefore we 'would, like to know in what tone ane- can have a hunt;ixlclub with our proposed uses? Also in which zone wbui;� a urge permit be regt1i.red for the above menti6htd o . ians? We hope this gives>_ yvu an, idea of our intended ftittt,re use of the property. So far We have' only acted o; the property with a rtaltbr, hi;listirzg Whether F;e act oft tlik Other Options would depend on the Board of Supe'rvj interpretation; R'�ndy McMa�i�n fires. butci`x Ravine Spor't8men's Club ��i ` i s1C:t ,1 .. nMF F.F."-� r^•�.« '�� , � Butte, U 4 7"- ,1,% T :DIRECTOR'S OFFICE MPNRTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SMVICES' 7 COUNTY CEN {'ER DRIVE OROVILLE, CALIFOANIII DI66M�07 7ELMIONGt (9161-538.760,1 FAX; 18161 5387766 i i II Mcirch 10, 1993 i :Ran(ly 'D. Mc Clain Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's Club 113 Blazeford Gulch Road. i Oroville, CA 95966 l Re: Rezone, File 93-08 Dear Mr. McMain: At the regular meetiog of the Butte County Board. of Supervisors held March 9;, 110,930 ,your request for. a Rezor,;e from A 5 to FR-40 on property located on both ,sidla -of Swedes Flat Road, approximately 11/2 miles east of Groville-Bangor Highway, icte�iF�%'Ped as AP 028-M-028, 028-320-0031 072-:330-016 and, 0181 Oroville, was dere ed, Should you have any questions regarding this matter) please contact this Departs ias tr f Verb' tryly yours, William :Farrel Development Services Director Far , n } �� ,r...�'y` •-r r� LAND O F N .- I ATURAL WCAIT11 AIIItY �}IAUT A DIRECTOR'S OFFICE DEPARTMENT of DF/ELOPIVIEIVT SERVICED 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE , OROVILLC, CALIFORNIA OG864r. ' 7 TELEPHONE, (016) 5�9.7gOf MEMORANDUM FAX. (910) U38-77% Tol Butte County Board, of. Supervisors Fb:1 13ill Farrel, Director of Development 'Services Craig Sanders, Project Planner i F� l5C�E3�7TCT Dutch Ravine Sportsman's Clu b, Rezone, File 93-08 IJATE February 26, 1993', r tESTIRECOMMENDATION: T.andv D. McM'ain, butch Ravine Sportsman Club - p'roposed j.�lei Declaration regarding environmental impacts and Rezone tro; (Agricultural - 5 acre parcels) to FR-40 (Footh .11 Recreationtii 40 acre parcels) located approximately 840 acres located on both sides of Swedes Flat Road, approximately a. 1/2 miles east O Orovi.11e-Bangor Highway, identified as AP 028-170-028, 0281-320_0031 072-330=016 and 018,,Orovillearea: staff recammonds the Board concur with the Planning commission 0" subject -to the findings listed in the :report, approve the regtJe'g by ordinance. ANAZY -IS t This is a rezone request to g � approximately 840 acres from A=5 to VA- 40, The property is located in the southeastern foothills of tf10 County on both sides of 'Suedes Flat Road east of Oro-Bangor Hrehdates he current General A-5 l hwhocii was. adopted in 1.970 ani g Y g ' p p licies. The property i surrounded by parcels of varying size, from s to 480 acres. The 22 contiguo'us parcels average 79+ acres in size. This project will result ih a zoning that is more consistent Vith the General Plan policies than the existing A-5 zone. The A-5 zorie was adopted in 1910, nine years before the current General Plan adoption in 1979, and does not meet the conditional development; criteria of the Agricultural Residential designation for parce.,ls less than 20 acres. The current zoning id not consistent with the General Plan and gives property owners a false sense of development potential for their property and 'is further misleading because tho ia.e tSl l �11 y r V'� 11 J 0 a da is "not suitable for a r cull' �I _ minimum parcel size less than 20 acresuses. I is For ,g " ultural Residential General Plan to be 'a zoning. a Criteria must be des cansistcant zoite t�r�.te present: gnatian the fob tt�I Ing 1• Compatible with neighboring agricultural activities., Evidence of adequate water and sewage tivties, 3. Availability of adequate tire g ,disposal capacity',' Y ;maintained approved facilities capacity to service area prayed road access wit-1 5• Reasonable accessibii.� Y sufficj�j�t -tY �o commercial services and schcio+.�f� r Criteria 31 4, and 5 are clearly questionable. The zoning factor,,o t present a-nd Criteria �Consi.der;` are as follows:` 1- Existin 3 slope g parcel sizes in residential densities. Soil conditions and water availability Effects on adjacent uses 4 .forestry'( resource extract an and wildl wildlife nab 54 Proximity -Eo production, livestock grazing, public roads and other 3., . D,istance from airports public faciltias, 7• Existing utility , railroads, and Indus trial uses. 8• Potential for surface drainage facilities. Effects on noise, traffic flow d safety, and erosion, i landslides quality( wildlife habitat and water �.o • Local desires'.quality, a'i general environmental quality, 11. Potential. for pest insect breeding, In addition to the listed tonin that this Property ,g factors- it Inust P Y is located *within a designated critical win deer range where the California Department of FIs o "'dame noted recommending parcels of 40 acres or h and Caine axe greater.: tor The applicant .has made it clear that their establish a commercial outdoor recreational f ultimate i g , a s orting clai1it� goal is, to could include ,a hunting Y shoo I range, archery course( and;s9.te which P spaces with a central Clubhouse or lPossibly b se bly some dam ting courser a in Pursuing this pang and RV for this t goal since the A-S zone doesThis 1s'the first step YPe of use; Under the FR--40 tonin not have a provision recreation `use requires a use permit, Zoning an outdoor commercia:1 Theapplicants were chukar,; and deer huntinreadY prepared to allota frOM nearbyon- ite this seasbh4 pheasant( quail, pro ert g P Y ownerspromptedHowever, conce,rne instruct the property owner to op ommercial hunt Plann1bg zoning and a use i g unt is inn i`a the issue of the huntln ire obtained. it p>oper g tub to be the focusoof tsh til not alloy �., this �soutco one and approval of this prof e5c shah have no kiear.� n' me of a future use permit a recreation facility other than; to pp dation for to aPPIY for said use. Sive the r an outdoor eased upon the GeneralrP an ner the right criteria aril upon the Department of Fish and dame policies anti.. policies th'e l ,r 't:opca ;ed ,zoh ng is More appropriate for the area t This project is not Seen as than the �5 f e Pize of the a spot zoning bcacause of the ri a;rp1, Property, the inconsistenc Yui General, Plan, and the -zoning will not confer h the a5 zonev,ith �7.. r the applicant. This entire area needs to be special ial privileldg �o recognized that fact wi;yen it directed staff toereview the the 1906 "d for consistency with the General plan. However, that e A-•5 Xone been delayed by the outcome of the However, hat at process JJe ne. PLANNING COMMISSTON AC7II. ON, The Planning cominissioh heard lengthy testimony ;project. Most of the cc,mments ;from the Y regarding of the property for a hunting club and the cnpentered on the t1§. i, Y gative impactsr Would have on the area includin noise safet cancer a road maintenance the introduction e exotic :increased fire hazard. The commission reminded ns trate Same species �1 public the project before members them I anot of t hunting club.. The Commission took an action recomUSe Permit So.r A Board approve the rezone. _ mending that t3l� ALTEI4NATrVFs • Deny the request and leave the zoning A- the issue on what t '_5: This will foCUq type of hunting activities are alloyed the A�-5 zone and pos81bly result in a request fro In for an interpretation. m the Board. Recommend a different Izo7:e Commission; and refer back to the p Given the POlioies Of the essGane lanninl , With a minimum Parcel -neral Plan, no zonihy considered,, with a 40 acre minimum that. acres should,b habJ,tat concerns for the deer herd. This would Preferred due to 40 or TM-„40 zones. The A-40 zone would allow, leave the Xx outright andthe TM-�40 z'onP would have the same' punting camp T'R4(► ane whether or ffeat not. L e � as the Property owrc��r would be' consistei tuaes Contemplated by th;o hunting campsh MOTxON RECOMMENDAT� Orifi z A. Find that the ,requirements , icolisidered in kE ,0,Ahave a e ,en completed arid ecr, e been Negative eclaratioi regarding environmental iiipacts andD rind that the rezone conforms to the text and map of the Butte County General �plan beca ciesincluding the A ricult ural Res us e: The FR-' Resident, 40 ;zone is listed as a zone that �s crnsistent with the A_ zorti'e is aril” General Plan designation While the conditions do not et to support ally consistent and that the pport the , -5 zone specifioally A` Com' IIE F Y'jMY�.,,T IS"�"R1�'i'YV�" CC7 TIVTy 00 'I31`,"r-rp 25 'COUNTY CENTJ~WDRIvE ° y OROVILLEo • e CALIFORNIA 95965=3380 Telephone; (916) 538.7631 e• Fax: (916) 538=7120 MEMSERS dte fqr;#OARD: .'C EN ti, mLAt�l<LAC; c,wM1N1orrrtv0rP1cCa � MFYEFZ JAI POLAN MARY" j(19 HOuX 8606 +OHLIN QF1.QMgs February 19, 199 Audy D. McMain L' UtCh Ravine Sportsmen's CILJ ` 113 Dlazeford Gulch Road CIMVille, CA: 95966 Re: Rezone, File 93M68 Dear Mr. McMain: ,f The Clerk of the Board of Su erva p 'sors set a public hearing date 10:00 a.m to consider for March your request for a rezone from A-5 to Fi'�;0 On both sides of Swedes Flat Road, identified as AP 028-170-028 0.16 for rich ' J.99 � " h � P ,rty �ocaf�d and 018, OrovilIe. �, 028=3 ~ • ti;13, 072 ( The meeting will be held in the Board Of Supervisors' Room, Center, 25 County Center Drive, OrovilIe: Cuui � � � y qty - tu�Y �r►rn�stratt�tt Should you have an questions re ardin y q regarding Department of 538-760 this shatter, please 1 between ]0.00 a.m. chin, h ., c t the Ylanr>ft; and 3:00 Very truly yours;. , JOhn S. Blackluk Chief Administrative Officer L 1�� i-Z.fR-^l:! '71 PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE oNCVILLE, CALIF C7pNIA,#§W-3397 TELEPHONE,, t916j 538-7801 January ,15, 1993 I. Randy D. Mwain Raa.ntl Ravim.e Sportsmen's Club 113 01azeford Gulch Road Oroville, CA .95966 Re: Rezone, File 93-08 Dear Mr. McIvain ►t the 'regular meeting of the Butte Countyplanning Your request for rezon0omm.ssl n'held Manu g from A-� to FR-40 for roe January 14 19010 Swedes Flat .Road identified as AP 028-170.02$, 028-320 Oroville, was :recommended for approval. property oc 072 on both sides' of 8 003, 072-330.016' and 011�, A report of this matter will be made to the Clerk of the Board to the provisions of Butte County of Supervisors. the rezone ordinance shall be deposited the Cle. on 8,1 Purse tit �stin�ated publishing fee df setting a public hearing, Clerk of the Board prior to the hoard Your rezone application has been reviewed and the estimated cos staff time is $7,00.00. Accordingly, We would request that you fort P $lOU.OQ to the clerk cf the Board 2.5, Co and our Cost of ublicaticsn and Y check fc�>' Payable to the Butte County Treasurer.ntY Center Drive, Oroville, Ca„ 95065, made Supervisors will be asked to set a public hearing. on receipt rt the monies the Boar 3 ,D ., y W t Should You have an _ J y questions regarding this matter, please contact this o 10:00 a.. and 3:00 p.m, ffice between Sinc el 'A.Orcher `r Director .of planning BA7 Jr cc: Clerk of the Board 100 ORRicvileHwv, ,t.,:. 'warms.■` --G roV�� o�h�� r ' O� yt .? ,.Olit)VIt.1.t� 162 rr..�. 1 Mt. f Rd. ` ad �a Alfiti)I'i'I' da Olive NURLI:TON 3`� Inc Cleo i Flu -p� abe ted ' y' oaa h h Plums ' Sao � °�° i� . s.+Z� P! . )Iit II,I�I: ,a Five ago` °x ��uAa 7tter�nalito '� s 6utrecity ,�It d•y��1i�, �;'i`�%.%G-.Elt:,� �,C, ; ° OUV I �/� ( c PRO3'E�i LrC1l !"TI[�NI r Hinhwnv �t r. ►$' T� e r 16 riAjterva l�r'• `^'"� I'�p�•y,��a � t�dYaNDOITk`a N 1°�°�1 / y�`r '' Qd= Qphir Road r V.' .i v /. }r as N� I 4N. Harfllllpn w S EaGt: ✓"--=�-5'rr �, .. j,4,,, U ' m C°� �a a. �) `°? { Vf` i+ lilhq`•. Hamilton ILI)h11'I! { a z ., �.. c v v < Road Ir o i.,, j ,�j 4 c; v 10 �►- r`'+ ¢.� .,rj � O Cr. ' ' -�' Swedes Flat Road ) I ARrA ` m' zo rssina a �, Pa v F [� L. c d p. .. yir c t Vance c Ave. w T cL ��'., , .x m r a �o� �hb� Roe o fl 0, /Z /j�UH/)CRY ... ,�v ,- East Weish ' ° Qd'e? �r _ rireilj l+C•°� Ntz 1 — +' Road 1 Rio Bonito '({i; Rd, — Palermo 9 v ti ' {c, w '4. 42 z � 1.'=' 3. Villa Ave °; Ittk .�` 11'°a �G Ug G Road '^ o" o , :�:u a`' 01 c uig �`' O f°' t N m + . +� rnit K . y ° it ca Walnut r... 3 ° c �P 1 , ° °✓ +� t3l� off' d. BigJs3;� �- .t ' J o -I s(p Daly .°AA A. 4� 0 �.�,s, Pant cg t= o° Hikson : (AIicE rai Av.N� p4 ' ' l r 6 ,Street Hwy. Avv yj� Allay Ranch Rd. a a o O (I1 i t�; aftotan No ation ker'A'A. v e �' Rd. Palm r.vc,,; ma Lone reoa r4 �� Avoca /gyp 1qt� .� tta t.ld �, r e tY,. w� N c3 ,��1 ( Q ad f JeX' rake Ave. Almonds?' frcle G nve• Has s tie ! ta�9g '� 6f`l� /'� e`3 Parris > Ave. Ranch Rd. o�d� ¢ South S O a N .Road �: Prude %Q o ,, . tQe�' Pv° o °2 Parks fI}�1' 0 Cc N D Ave, Steadman o, G inh '. 1554r u �' (JEnrilter Lane x a ¢ `^ 07 �,, �� ..�� i Rose Ln. Cox aoQ �0� m Via o aa ° Ord' Ranch Q'°Rd: } �Cqx c Hoss Land r13angorQat�'�bn�� prQ 'Verte% °�c1 +.aihur. 1t Mae�ccla father Rd, .r rv` r "`+ CL m I` Mlalod lane N Greek tr t) /BAri�7wiZ " 1 lusts"snn ,` Gni Iriv, 5r;lt 1:1 tai' d, .. , dley Road 3t n rj w b �,°Q�� h7rofi,ish � M 1L tjl.IUt rY?dnF.t r+ N y E+ Rd. .P. �r Colusa � d ROBINSON ,e c p c,, - Swain liil) � , Fii these Ave i� Oberst eyedersont YOC r nt,trylt r:. t CORNER c . 4 oy ro > � % � a ;i �yt n ti �, Central gHouse . _ y r� o 03 c ,d igidor�Q �fer W s ° West ¢ r t o Hoilfs O'Brien : _ Richards i St�� t �° bllvet �� Rd a w Kciih Do �i ' r s Road 4 �O.O' °' tj R1 O7 t n, PerersonAva. Nielson u v Cl dy m , W ' . ; + 19 i °tag �. a Ot�Q i Stoneh �U,a Dr,— ,c a W. Evans Wri ht r ` Ce tern, j{, �, Middle Honct t Road oc, i e 2Q T 5��� Qv « s or; > Reimer i Ev ns ... C, v=c 9� ,•,w 1t' �,, a,��u ..a+ o. K Wolf Road Road,aw ¢ Rd, a Honcut RoIONCUT ' �` ° �c/�� ti ultfarrd d n 3 t '^osd Reimer Road Jem Lower $d + 0 `�-. bn v . 4a•o o Cr b� na.�, °Fro .a, .. urner it p 1 r ,y✓`Sdnnvslone v� , qua ee,{ d o CDF F. Z� 3.r, .iu Whip pfe� F-, Campbell Qve. s tkQ.� CC STA,_ �o a '" °� t t0• or,kins Chandon Ma, E 'o " r t Igw 99 c ,., as �`Ct �y czvp i ��h +, b it +fitiL i3evan R oa urrf�iRd: Luckehe Lid. r�ONSo_ r . y ----r �.MetteerR Laurel n. �, �e �a LOMA RICA " a.. t i RiVlerar E o. m o C2mw�'.11t Chand et �{ ro t�'e ,, / e+� �'° ickie a °r virglntu Rd, e, _4 Ja �d f t,rn \ Cc ! .��. d. .�4 ... , n. Fr � Iowa r u.� k •S VICIK1;1Tf Y MAPF RANDY MCMAIN D.R,;`5.C. 'RE'ZONE. 02Si.1701-02-8+ 93--08, JAN f' 1$93 MEMORAMPUM FOR BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING CHMT,SS o"'oVUlp ION j il11#1ii% UtZON1110 PROPOSAL, SWEDE PLAT ROAD 10 gr)3 L'. WE VEORET TO E IMF YOU THAT WE ARE HEAS ING S SCHEDULED FOR 14 PIAN 19193, UNABLE TO ATTEND PROT-O tAL OF THE DUTCH RAVINE REGARDING THS; . SPORTSMAN Ci�THE REZONING, VE Wk; PURCHASED THE PP.QPERxy LOCATED IN DROV14BER OF iD�1. Al' 1329 SW PROMIRTY WAS FOR THE FRIARY REASON F SDE SLAT ROAD ENVI Ot11�ENT� R RETIREMENT PURPOSES OR PURCHASING THIS SUBU t AN FREE FROM THE NOISE � IN AN AGRICUL,TtrRA�, AND POLLUTION OF CONGESTED AREAB', THE AGRICU'LTU1tAL STATEMENT NO 'AHI"ED AND RECORDED IN WE SJOVED, COMPORT TO BUTTE COUNTY, GAVE US THE EFFECT THAT WE GU A DEG1{E O Al"D VEHICULAR POLLUTION, QHER �1*AN NQR.ifAE AG'�OSti) TO OPERAT I CANS . T " Nci 1 SE OOVPLICT THIS APPLICATION FOR REZONING APPEARS AL/PAR,�I Txls R8QUIRtMENT. RE IN S. THIS APPLICATION TO EXPAND OPERATIONS W. VEHICULAR TRAFFIC ON AN ROAD THAT WOULD ADD . WEEXEYDS ARE NOW SUF3JFCT TO CONSTANT �NEADY � C1 T1TE TRAFFIC. ROUGH" AT DEST,. FIRE AND XNCRUSED 4 � ONE OF THE MANY REASONS WE PURCHASED FACT THAT WILDLIFE WAS PLENTIFUL AND IT THIS PARCEL t ,:YS S AN, DEER WANDER THROUGH THE DAREAWAS NICE TO �'��, 'WILD t�1IL FTAi�PEN TO THE WLi�t,IFE DND Rt AILD VE11sOiJLATt TR sT RAED, WHAT NrTH THE INCREASE IN OUNFI i3E AND WHAT' WILL E',APPEN 0, THE ROAD'S 5 totr CtGH i4" EXP9 TED TO ''ENCCtJNT R QGCASIQNAI, � . AG1'iICULTURAL AREA, WE FEEL THAT AN EXPANSION TO HISUXFIJ�)ttLj) TO� 114 AN HAVE AN ADVERSE EFFECT Obi PROPS. MOPE OF THIS TYPE OF 1�TY VALHs OF ?�EzQNING. TNT WE DO ANIS COULD LED To SUPPO" r1 YUE USTriD JAE HERS RMINE.L 132D SWFDES BAORF'LA'T ROAD NG' CA 4^, i ~" PLT r TI C►�hl �I VAT 1" 3EP'�EI°iOER 27, F.M ; w We THE UNDERSIGN0 ARE AGAINST ,.rHE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGEON PARCELS 0 i428 -320-00S� $20 astlos i 201,75 acres; 072-33,0-01.6$ 2240 �r ' X13 072-SSit�°OI' 80C1�15 °ad's SEASONS FOR OPPOSITION INCLEIDE THE FOLL0WING ,1 r ME OR0,94I2ATION KNOWN AS"'O+.rrm RAVINE SPORTSMAN CLU3 INTENDS 'C0 ALLOa,I +.1, #MERCML. HUMIN[ ON THE AFOREMENTIONED PARCELS AFTER REZONING, THE CLU NO BE OUIREa TO VAP1ANTE5 THE NEIGW80RS SAFETY IN REGARD TO FIRE All s ENTAL SHOOTINOa IN AN A-2.0 ZONING• 2) SWEDES FLAT ROAD iCANNOT MNEILE THE EXTRA TRAFFIC SUCH A COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE WOULD BRING TO THE RCADj AND DUTCH RAVINE SPOaTSMANS CLUB WOULD A'YAI!'J NOT GFA REQUIRED TO MOIN'iAIN TflFj ROtrAD, SI 5#4 ED Nr 2 f�. (✓ac M ddre Is s Addptss`- z P: Nd' Name ar tc Add ss . Y��+wwrMw•a1Yu4Y � L � ,Y,+Y '-. .v *! /♦�jJ /A�Me t �r..V W f Y V' V .' rim -torr `%�O 'CiG✓ t c� f el3'i�s�+� t o est Address f 'rano ame - Addr� , t FEf I ON Po. Ly ryAT,5. nEEPryG'p,. 'i`gR G. 1p 199,2 TFG fWE THE UNDERSIGN"; ARE AGAINST 'THE PROP666-0 ZONIl!01 CHANGE Oil PARCELS!! 028-320-003r g O(`��2320 acres; 029-177-028, 2d; ° �. f'!t i�llrr�- .4Y ° 'iW.; wt•�,�.x.w°{'Y fel:. �rt�li`fii Ty'� i i'7 C.. Ptw'�if't;�S�G 711.° ,y PET red--.;j—!i ,a ,.i�wo•�, `+ S, pip t« !'1 0 L t t,! `tol,it. 1'>' !:)uret3f4l IVtrr r�e� SINEW: ; ,,rrw,a r, ►art ��t ►�� .° rr�C�, �; �r NC� � r lir. . i ►�►� w . t f1 mr two u. rtz,, }.t W , , - t w af�t:,Or.Sr,�» 5 Pt.rl� `y �fW."� �n,yi� r"��.r et�+hf"�?C. f�L� ai J E D� "'� t r , , � � , � ' a t k � �` �'� �' f�� 5 UL13 g ;rr t , "� t t Lc + S EXTRA TRAr SUCCjq w, 4t r 45 ROAD A">��ry�M°�ir,,fi 70 144vi`'A w �-t q ' 9 tos" 4 4v 940 Ad Xja y- ltd-fir R 2. �� I Cott - PETITION „. DATE; SEPTEMBER 27, 199� WE THE UNDERSIGNED ARE AGAINST THE PROPOSED BONING CHANGE,ON„P G�S o�OfiS, 324 does t 028--a 7a- 028 tot . J5 acres; 072- So'�ar LRI u } And 072-380-018, SG acres. � i 240 ,j,ap,o-j OUR .REASONS FOR OPPOSITION INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING.- 1) OLLOWING1i THE ORGAN]ZATICN KNOWN AS DUTCH RAVINE SPORTS (Or�rIERCIAL � SPORTSMAN C f UNTINU ON THE AFC,REMENTIONED PARCELS AFTER �REZONING, TO ALL O WOULD NOT BE REGUI P80 TO GUARANTEE THE NEI GHSORS � THE Ct.Uti f�CCIDEMAL SHOOTING' IN AN A-20 2ONING. �AI'ETY IN REGARD `fG FIRE Aflft 2' SWEDES FLAT ROAD CAVAOT HANDLE THE EXTRA TRAFFIC SUCH A COMMERCIAL ErlTERPRISE OrIDI1LD BRING tl THE ROAD, AND DUTCH RAVINE SPORTSMANS CLUB WOULb k)t tjt: 1�fOT' BE REQUIRED TO MAINTAIN THE ROAD, SI Gr4EO 15 dross ti Addrp s s .... �y d t ame -- Add r.� s s Stam ry Addraa �( �. Address Nam Address Address i �.. WE: SEPTEMBER 227, i P92 it "rIE THE UNOER8I6NED ARE AGAINST THE PROP088D ZONING L�2t —8,20-008, 520 arra s, ; CHANGE ON0�OP�~`9�St 4028-170-028, 201.75 41 24`0 and 072-X830-018, 80 acre+ rAIR REASONS Fog OPPOSITION INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING I THE ORGANIZATIONKNdIAI AS DUTCH RAVINE SPORTSMAN CLUB INTENDS TO ALLOW f)flMERwIAL HUNTII'40 ON THE PFOREMENTIONEI) PARCELS AFTER REZONING, THE CLUB WOULD NOT BE REOUIRED TO GUARANTEE THE NEIGHBORS SAFETY IN REGARD TO FIRE Alit) ABCIOEtITAL SHOOTINS IN AN A-20 ZONING, SWEDES FLAT ROAD CAV40-fr HANDLE THE EXTRA TRAPP,IC SUCH A COMMERCIAL !-.' ERPRI8E WOULD BRING TO THE ROAD, AND DUTCH RAVINE SPORT8MANS CLUB WOULD Ai..�61N NOT CE REQUIRED TO MAINTAIN THE ROAD 8S6NED - t.-' '� r.,; ;; . PETITION DATE: SEPTEMBER 27f 1992 We THE UNDERS161NED ARE AGAINST THC PROP09ED ?ONING CHANGE ON PARCELSI�;} 028-320-003, 370 acres-, 028-'176 -028, 20� -75 ;acres; 0?2-S;BN PAR, LS end 072-380-018, 80 acres. OUR REASON$ FOR OPPOSITION INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING: 1 i THE ORGANIZ'ATIC1 XNOIAN AS DUTCH RAVINE SPORTSMAN 'CLUB INTENDS TO ALLOW I !,�IMERCIAL NUINTIN5, ON THE AFOREMENTIONED PARCELS AFTER REZONING. THE CL'jtr WOULD NOT BE PEOUI RED TO GUARANTEE THE NEIGHBORS SAPEV IN REGARD TO FIRE olii {" iXIDENTAL SHOOTINO IN AN A-20 ZONING, 2) SWEDES PLAT ROAD CANNOT HANDLE THE EXTRA TRAFFIC SUCH A COMMERCIAL, rNTERPRISE WCULD BRING, TO THE ROAD, AND DUTCH RAVINE SPORTSMANS CLUB! WOUL& p'iVIIN' q0T BE REQUIRED TO MAINTAIN THE ROAD, 1 1- �, ti' -� t�ET1aI�IGN ff :+' 4 SEMMSFER 27, i 992 r q 44C THE UNDEFiS18NED ARE AGAINST tHE W#P3R, UXp0p1SE7G S 20a4cr11Ne�I CH4-N��O�E026-320-00$1 20 jLrlesg 0281783pN AARCS fir ` and 072 -330 -oleo 8 rr i e s . ,X417 13UR REASONS FOR OPPOSITION IhlC:LkipE THE FCLLCIW1NG� THE ORGANIZATION KNOU'N AS DUTCH RAVINE $PQRT$MAPd CLUB INTENDS 4ro Rt;LUW ��g'M,i.IERCJAL. HUNTI'sNO ON THE AFOREMENTIONED PARCELS AFTER REaLGNING,' THE' CLUD ,4ULD DICT BE UQUIRED TO SUAPANTEE THE NEIGHBogs S'Ai=E'rY YN REGARD TO ' ACSIDF14TAL SHOOT1,N'S IN AN A-�20 iCf tXNE, , IBE YPtfr 2) 51:"ECdE'S FLAl' PCAD CANNOT HANDLE THE E)(TRATRA17Flta SLiCH A COMMERCIAL t ' TEf PP 'SE GJCitll�C, EItrICI TO THE Rt Mi ANO DUTCH RAVINE- $PORTSMANS CLUB WOULD fW61N NIT BE REQUIRED 70 LAIWAIN THE ROAi), 0 4 E 0 t NameI Asrr j�.p �3/ Address ,�.,,12, -,. AX i � .et Nat Addros��"' , �- - '.,yJw�+hj��jw',(w�nVc+µa.+.+L}�--... •4�W 1�iG7 '�, ^�wr+s.1� IYsitdpW 1' t� 01 Y 1 .,.�. PLANNING DEeF'ARi`,'N5Ni y COUNTY GENTt a oRlv�. oa.�VILL�dALCFdJ�fll�i �!����-33417 `r.LEPHONE, (018) $34.1601 Anua-V'15, 1;993 1 Randy D lvlc?Vlain Duti:lt SportX meja's Ch bi 113 ',E-1=efbrd Gulch Road Groville (,*A 95966 Re Re., orae, File 9.3-08 Dear IN11% McM'ain: At the rgp)ar ineeting, of the Btttt,e Courtty Planning Commission held IAnuary 14,109,31f your request' far rezomlmg from, A-5 to FR -40 for property located on bath sada of Swedes Flat aRuacl, IdOvtfflied as AP 0028.170-028, 028-320-003, 0,80-016 and 01411 (�roville:, was Ireeommended for app.tov;al. A report of this itiatter wnll'be rna& to the Clerk of eae Board of Suipervisors. Ptitsit 0l to the vi,qzaras of Butte County Code Sect ori 24-28.1, an estimated putalislling the,rezone o,rdiliance shale be deposfited with the Cleric of the Board pri.ois to the 804t' setting a. ,pt'xMc hearing. Your re;wale application has been t'ev ewed aztd the e,SHmated, cost cit publication 01,I, staff firee is $'100.00. A,ccording.,lytr 'we would )'equest That you forward yoixr clteek, i't7�` 5100.00 to the, Clerk of th 13o, o,uj3;1f�, County Center Df-i�ve, i0tovillo.y Ca. QS965,. it ado p y " ty T> ewittrer." Upon receipt of the monies ,the Boaid 40 Supervsors will be asked to seta p%,61U! heari ig. y I p q �g f in f; this matters please �contttct Phis office bdw/661 Should oLt have, any questions rFr pa1�c 1f1.00 Alma sand x;00 m. X kreher Director bf Plat nir.►g l�Ai{ar cc, Cleric of the Beard r 'iiii.��'Lrr�t�� l .,. .�. „�t�,'• � ii�� � �i,.. ! 1 .... �I r���.. _..i� �. i4 .; .�. _. ��� ti._ � 4.�" �1 i lS� ti IS u� ., 5 u ' '_ .....•� ,;+�..y.�S... «. i 1 n '�l• _iI it '. *r � N 11 7 1 ,, 77. tic ' DIRECTOR'S OPFICE �-- DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMtN1'SEitVICr3 7 COUNTY CEN#R DnjVE . OROVILLE, 6ALI (iF1NIA IkJrn�iB- ? Q% TELEF'HONE2 19161 890,7001 d f RAXi (919) 538.11IJO SS \I b,,#iic�emher 21., 1.992 D. Monson §00 Chinese Wall Abad OtOviwl,le, CA 95966„ Deur Ms; 1'Vionsonz - 074W. l'c you for your letter dated October 10, 1992, Which our, w,,.ords zd'how it was recaivod on November 12, 1992 'V'our le• tet p� ' �srvides r:onsid.erable infoa-mata.on rela.t9.ve to the Dutch Rav;,Lne. OpOrt,gaftan f s Club and ;Z have referred It to JeffMadden for his r6Vievj. As We disF.ussed a number of the points tiaised 3.11 your letter '41ring tM meeting with the property ovi iers;, I will not try i'ro 2`e,spond ti irther herr s We would apprec Ote however, being notified. proznptZy alioot:Lnq begins so that a Codeniorcemcrri ef±icer cO visit the property. The Plah'n.Lng Commission is scheduled to hear the }:ezohinq requ16, btx on danua:rlr 14; 1991. Craic Sanders of tii4 planni;�,g Depa tment pre, ared'' the staff report recpr�nmohd' 7� abproval of the F�3N;;zone do the 'site, `�`}ou may wi.-h to ;call hirci Frith any questions. <1Si;tici�re ly i � i C William vat,tel, AZ.,cp D1t6'otor .oi`• Development Services h i I f 1 •'I�ih�Tsrl�i�elan�i:.�iriLir��,L.�:;'�,Ya�:�. �._ . ,,�..�I ......._ . � ,., �, x,14, , �� _ �� ,� ,�1: 1 09 tob*t .t A, 1M PILL FA09idi. Planning Dept County of Butte California) t;r, Farrel Sinr_e T met w t:h you on Monday i~lov R 9� have had t ftrfE� r , discussion ftrtirer,a F«rite to 1�t a�aja know rnv reiiectiops on ��ar witint>on.f you eall! rrn7°8ant wss firs Sparteman Club y R August 30th box ° t filed regarding Dofat# t vuine -the Noun is rce at Your office Pol IY44tt�a th i s, Michael PI' the matter was first re�Fe�rred b;� ., �a�,rd of 5u � �: yw,`y� ezlee!g,�� deerneo *pD,P,rt„ Ait that �e[t ypa P 9 ythe){80ar}dory{ ryegGyested� Fl ann Ing tc+��}a�Ma R V�4'i �1..T order t Yl'!'Ar?ML�i'J+R VYtUYf CSW/F"+y rA) a Step somowh- in Yi.1 �1Fti4'C :.i•.���17a'1 Pr to zo�nirg viOlations. wGa ver becau,5e of numerous error addressing the tease order of Sept. 23, it Was never , reptesentati9re5. ira9re proof ho Lis n however that ti.�rR signed for try cease- e, .P �s sign erected on r f did t`ecef j,e with i�. , ilrn a ger�olunel actually tem ararilY ciased the Club ori a, .s'ne t re club's entrance. SeP ovek ti9r bard signed by rilsR Sapplund, state that vi, � d This nr,�� t7��� a request nssued by the Caa�d Of 5u ervis n VCi1ttittary t�� �r Rar9ce closed". f ppestrrted tt`9+s errrf to Hr, Madden''��lttaberu��y xnd�Iyen�e��o��€q is Ph93tograph d,F this signed nate nmj. N014 you infor-In me on Novgmber 9th th_lt thy, normal pracedur� first fltheen normal r ceindeed the c$0 daYllettere"� .not Yet even rnaiied.:;���, Carri;, followed, anti the d�:y l a t t erg had then been fn,{a'day #r<r hada��R p promptly ,anal ita�i; �.��,:�Ap fOttOty s per the boatdls intention there 4"ho time ne-eded5toeelaen rsetfo, bath letter Ire old have been , s ' pa t nowR Inw� to you we must :,o:v trait until at least December 20th for the time to e����ir� �trd enfdreemetrt tihrou h the 0,A, could even be considered bxy the O.A, ehfarcement procedure "takes ti,nen. our And ydt� t l me bepartmen�fa attitud'k toward clutch g4j)fne Sportsman+ eve the' PlWing'be o ,fv4 olncessiue comprotrtise, And l `-i:eel this is a cath; ietol change,"� ? tti tulle-ff-otn the p. Sed, 1992, 5 anPIanni'ttg beet. o;�. fypk. �tctioh5 and wards esf- the Board of Su �,+�isord th:b On igctaberi, 10 neighbors, it with #eff Madden and at that trv{ae ;drily substar9tive item decLded was' that the delayed 3b day letter Out that tamewould 9 °6ng day. And yet l2 days later you tett me the defter has �� 2 .tra t�;y be sent-iktis,t ask why the constant delays? "these delays have left the r, C' 4.tfth aafeetirig af, corlplatettcy, to the e.ttertt that #n your meeting with t,> n o,f. Nov. 5th they a tnritt:ed to ha9aftrg bee n in buslnpss all a pheasants.along,gy aril to 'a re��)ljx � bn their part to continuo in. business into the f�,ture1 c'ommy Fi e;rtialluit' in 04 iJov. nth 9rbt9 told tna that the neigh;�cn s should meet with D,,R. .",� it: fat�t the club would, contact us, YOu feel tta should find' a tbmprtn �;atta� chem that wairld allose'then to continue In business without a xk� ane .comIz e ia pormltx We have had only the follauring euidenr_e of the, Clubis +c�ood;f ipn��,a Ir October ;seueral`'neighbgro called R.S,C,. aid requesters"`inf011AMAti p on dyer hunting, In each case vie, were tnD;d ta, bring 5bo,0Qglib i hDp ptv!4,�'4d r�,fl'e and ccrrtt: ahead to harm,! Yet on Novl, 9 they stated tit oir ..that 'rio toop h4'M7ting was done In they 19:'�easoni 0, fr:r you to the �1�j�':J�ules 5116 rN subrnittid to jou alongwith tlpe let4i, of inton't:ion from D kjO�X, on 61tf'q 14, in which rule 2$ Mates checkG� are to be�imadti ,iiut to t).R.C.G�, fi7r -trio f,trtiting. This titles list also goes tyre 'to 5tat:e in' its -i:mcluslan that r,Pl, . , 4►rr�r, firsts huntyrs get their deposit in )mmedlately ,as "'khere are a. litirittid arh(juO, kat big rims animals and game birds O"vallab'le anI; f,astiii 'Yoi. told me D,R.S,C, tisk, you on Novornber 6th. that doer hatrtt�fno WtPa111 h'alPe tsoar impossible in :91921 as ;tv Mow,,etcuro diger herd no lon;aot, migi'ateq} t$4to,ugh the ; ;id set aside 44:1- this O+ ipr4atian its the goneral plan r"E'r,ttisicin of 1'/,96, sr this to be cgmpl ertel y iiltc orrect r aEl we Ill the area have As 000 Marty qi t44 r th i e,. fall !,I our yards and f l e l ds, 3) ire., the letter, of intention del ivorif,tl to You by oo Sept,14, th4 letter staters that the Clint would b6 contacting the nvir�hbtws to t;-4, 11`$ o-cncerns, 60daya hia$ e elapsed and t;'n ttuch contact has bee?1 made witti Vag, of the contiguous neighbors to this ray Also the letter of intontlon that A caretal er r.+oul'd be inptrrriarre ft--?s�idttnce to prevont the use of property t access -"UrroundIng areas. tllo permanent aretaker it in etr��ptfb,i�� tc this rra;� tioet iJportantlyi, the letter of intentioi; states that the Oot'vo'i Q cat the property would be their Tlrst prioritYs and no such fanning has hater, bswr ed by tete ontiquovs; ooighbovs tall this day. Yet they haue contifigg'l in i si , Fp � r of intention #A4 u�r.,i Hess. � toed map rues sl�b,�i tttid to woo, with the letter, Sept.' 23rd. On this �m;e the Club ou'tl lnOd incorrectly their, property I ooOet r istaVonly ,(ricluding the Ogpger pat el)2 parcels owned by the MontrgOMOt'r= and a targe, psece of tite Waremari'pailcol, a5 Wol.I as another plkc6 of .propert:r P(A OMI contiguous with theirs, Is 6P5 the neap they glve to Minters to use, OU41ininq the' lend of other nea�hbors as %'heir owh? trach of the oelghbors mentivir� +I have Sg9ned a petition to, stop the i-2one 4plDcatloo, and noir' they must feo� even tore at risk from this iente;rftrizoi 4) A5 of ttdav tae are Informed by the State office that 0.13.3.C. has tit e cunt lied �rrt th the rule to disclose the 04 the D r c-orpora t i on, Vf ,,v iwounty has no 4ictitrous n .me statement on file, anti., 'Fish and Came has n , reed no ctmsraercial hero' ing to tl y?m. T'l:e apparent disregard 0,944, has fear° the rules and regulation "I bur we neighbors to believe they would' also di speciard any agreement tirade with gas wfi t ch is not enforceable by l twit, $i In the ept.23rcir issue of the Crroville Mere, Register handy Mf "'if , described as D,R-$-X• club presidents states that all hunting would rye` controlled with a,r gu l de I ead i ne the Iwai ters, so the neighbors treed not lX� conterned wath poosltle trespass's, I refer you to the Club Rule l}GPS. ,Cr. Sutmitted to you, q" dept. A with their let~ter, of intention., In it the i #ISt acid #23 clearl,r out IDtio ntan guided hunting procedures 6) In the Cc tob!er 7, issue of the Oo,oville Morcurx reg i sten i gusting ag* 4a fi"cm Ranoly Mciiai ra, h,T says Mat tht, nearost ne i ghboP is over a mile avjly, ' t)SVP had a crap df the area premared �-,x a professional ,Nivil engineer, ,arid It .tauti;5,��s one mlie and two milt ares arouil-i the club's Prot tei,t)" Where are gat loa t ` para ,els within oto mile. Approx, 80% of ';ht�s�', parcels" are ocdupfod� so tont4rvativoly McMair,. ig'hon*d the exl,!�tence 04 60 families In that one rh, to 7) 5i'nally`.r I Wer ,y YOU to the lettev from this a,V,SX,, Attorine?'et dated rat. e and rare i:�ed tsy your off ic !,on Oct* i;s„ In It the a`�torn6y sa-r, one neiobbar has, ctsntertded that h R. axC ' is in the pr�oc:ess a;t releaiain� wi id p10% and Miter b,rita'l s. l' Cate tit° o cel l y d'ttiry It v itig 'thade tri i s tatemen t 'at arty' t Ptiie t bof I do \1 y and tart�� rhri rr ,�r e ref t e confusion Y�,tr see from Atr u t ori the �" > i . brochures here trr3delY avaaf'4lable, from Orovhil l.Q's Huntington or9 (�G#r�ts rfttJ,r_,i to 1 ar:a# i ar7s I n Gr i dl ex. T"h i a brochure bas a r;ago that avo t ip., 1 e "on" the r rub Of 18 items available, the 'Firs» 1 ina reads "deer hunting", :PiCe second l ire °'w0d pig hunts"'ig" chid the third t ine "sRotic hunting",, evoll' rn the a.foromer,tloned club rules, 'Pubmitted to Yov on Sept, l.�l, ruIo 1119 oij,tl ii ppese,nce OfaWild rhogsd etc. +eras causetlSby theubmubtrshownaj-j rortfuslrjrr ayi fable � tAC'ttrr`'e j JV, � to the public adVto as least August. So "nDrea yo,4 te11 me 1'q0ra. Ott. haat ,.ire snoarks meet 03hth #tae G1ula's rjtpresen,:atrore . to nego#iaie vc"rr,e :oratprrnit,e With thettr.` las toll nip prr=ferabl e to ts�' i ng th-! issue to the Board; that if th;l t happens it ?,is k r i�c�e r�rrr a refezr vadum or grunters versus. County zoning rulett, You sa°ate that tA,e 8. r,"rld tA, prepared to terse this battle z hunters will, err, masse, des onrr to prr,#ot (herrrigI fi'ian;ito�t".� hs9t'i�*r � � stat,? r7 w' � lyeek"t,t+yrbriclnd �tlrrt��- 9 rrM.,I.��s, l n !e uerzeg no t r peti"!on% are 1"0 tirre hur i n e expect sa, f#?main �� s,Pr:rn� he saw a hr ra .er% of Sutt" count,', to be national and law ai?+irl'oo, citizens, citizens ur"+errlling to place innocent adjacent_ la,ndourner famtl ,Vs at risk by thra'rr cfnoice to t,;Pt. the 1(�Icvj they hunt safely «racy in, areas hpt,4,�,�riate to, high powered rifles, They respect the dangers involved,,,prriaapw ' ih�r� most, r0e haue far th in the rr abi l i t,, to see that an arra of th is ziz#" with1n rttapq? ox 2S"G+ ,fani,ies and their agriculture ar"imal3, rs rarifij; , the oxisting anf prcposed hurtrrag-. I Oriel the items a;oriamantioned in numbers 1-7 of txar� le##xr5 to cumulat-wj lY cc`Vin e us than the 0,R.S*C, owneiss are ynppofeseirraal, untruthf+A, and Tnzst imporltArttiv incoricerned 'dor the nerighbor,s rights as land .: ers, The";, are sgrioranfi. cif the i.r mf poopept ' line,,-,0 ve demarskr: ted by their su: sir a, d topo nnap * And the tact r s SherG has rrlrnplete lack of P709Mess ora 4011ti09 the property, though it las to be f"'O flr%. priority accor�d;tng to their letter Of intentions► We neighbor i5 have b�Oo trespass ,d bar twe�clrrb Ailld: aye PO C-Oniint''ing eui�,+e#ce th"af trezpa�� I,, rHt�t i�i'�iC+W d € we 'oe l at Sc�E Ti t A.*'i Y' PISX FROM THE CC""JTINUhp CWMERCIAL iai'?�t''i�'prirsC recur, and we �"ee, at r�E�� DA .*'Y 1-rLUS, IbC petrt"0riers, tlos, heighborsr ie,ei the character c-5 our agriczrl torr al' land lis b'e i g altered negatively b>, ftor p"esence of a cca,rrrercial hunt club in our midst. Scuedes z*la,f 'Rdad has r" bt sae a. hazard to'nauioatei, asset i .,R.S.i:. is tht prune contributor to this meneva:. 'f17e«o have brazen l Y i grmiNed the Count> cease ordpn i to the extent o4 telling >t � Pill laarrsli that toe cluta continues iri business even to this day, We detfiAn;j *lie° cease order issued to them on Sept, 28rd. of this Year be enforced by fhN � gunty Flapping at this t1the, irmledlately* Thank- You. Xj i?r�tne E4rnson �1 �. C. -` cc �'iiack lclntrlrf,i i.st, Cris 5upersaeisor 1 " ' ; Oroville MercatrY Register, Attr i Rust Longley R. Wakeman, $01 Roxbury Lane Mtidesto 95Si1 M. Pio toomeery, 215 drags Edd. Elrisbane 1�400 i 7fi� '6oe-�ele 1 tp Neff input, Dutch Ravine Sportmen's Club, inc, f 11.10-92, On September 23, 1992 we sent a ca , You because of our p of e warning lottd bo „'#° y position as secreta g a dre dd, :Ao 'Ravine Sportsmen's Club. The letter was inadvertentl a the previous owners because of the relatively property recent •s&10 of ibe recent trads. action. the assessor's ;computer •did notil re4loc f t"he On October 22, 1992-, we sent another warnin deleted) the Dutch Ravine Sportsmen'sClub letter to the secretary/agent of the incorporation. , IncInc, care of YOU #A These letters...:.. We understand that you will not allow an to be used on the ro ert Y guns other than shotgVjjp p p. y, and that the use of them will D limited to bird hunting and (clay pigeon shootiing-deleted).-fwl) disputed spa i:ng clay shotgun course. We agreed that that ��)@ sprung clay course is not unlawfull in and of itself but anIly ito onlt use is old to the public. 'Ycu.ag reed that the course wad family« be use at no charge, by the principles ars their txiends r ;........in the A-5 (Agricultural, Section 24-7u) zon to your property, e a'plicafs' i utte County ount o Code Sec`tll 6n 24-6 3.yt ��A11 uses of land within a zt�n , t specifically auithorized or e ; gt - p �r'. p rm_,tted by t, ace ilation� ,are rohiba ted Not onl have the cointnercial hunt.`nr (; and hunting related usos not been only authorized or permitted" but furthttr rowieio by the department of t)iese s eci; issue" has rea.firmed bur posia tion that 8,Lich c0htmercial hunt;%nq' operation' is not an allowed use in the A-j)' zone 1 14 ' 1 , i W This violation may be corrected bir either; (1) Terminating the commercial hunting operation, or by (2) Obtaining a rezone and use permit which would 0019 apprcpri.ate conditions on the commercial hunting use to Mid y t-p Its impact on the area. Unless the Violation is so corrected or rezoning and use p6tidIt , applications are being diligently pursued for that purpose,, -Ljr0 -"+ Dutch Ravines ,Sportmen's Club, Inc. may be held accountable .);A Court. in addition, any individual that helped create or maixYtj? ' the violation can be issued a citation to appear in Cmixt. w This ymmecl is aDeipartment can request that a Code Enforcement CfildOP Th csue citation (s) "when there is reasonable basig -110 1,-)el:ieve that the violation constitutes a threat to the health 9h4 safety of a�*r person or persons". You have 30 days to voluntarily comply with the a1b6V directions or to present an acceptable plan for abatement Or corrective actions to be taken by you. gothing in this letter should be con>trued that this is tj1 only course of action,thab can be used. The County of Butte don and may pursue any civil, criminal oradministrative rented^yt l. inc,iding requesting appropriate testraining orders from supd,elo court, that are deemed necessary or appropriate. to, gain complidA64 in this matter, i Ir , LAW OFFICES OF DANIEL V. BLACKSTOCK n/; j' .�1992, A 1440 LINCOLN, SUITE 3 OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 96906 31 ��O,Igt�wy Fax Number (1718) 634-060 (910) 534-7144 Chico of ido, (916) 841 • � i ) October 15,, 1992 AGENDA INFORN1MON Butte County Board of Supervisors "� V '� !� 0 25 County Center Drive arovil'le, Califohia .95965. RE': Dutch Ravine Sportsmen'sClub, rnc. Dear Board 'Members Since 'my letter ;of October 8 1992 I have had the opportunity to discuss the zoning -use situation on my client's property in the Swedes Flat area with members of your staff.' would appear, that we .do have a difference of opinion as to the interpretation of ceitain 'uses allowed under the present zonithy/ and therefore l would respectfully request that we be placed cif the agenda to specifically obtain your boards' ruling pursuant,� Chapter 24 of the county code. As to settin& a time, 1 would 'simply request that .3t '* At your boards' convenience, fully realizing and app,,c-iating ,your heavy schedule of hearings, etc. 1 presently have certain' trials and hearings set in the last two week of October, and commence a two week jury on November 2. Therefore T'would ;request that this matter be scheduled on your regular meeting agenda at some time at your convenience ;in the latter part of November, or December'. Yourd truly; Daniel V, Blackstock DVB/dkb dci. William Farrel Bet, -y Xitcher Jeff MaddenTfoa `reG�Af A�V�-� „ m. w�• i. �N va�u,�tax,� ?em iart.�L w� ti ,s k�#xehr �icRrsrr.En,s' y At �acdlem, E 44 ., 771 (41 LAW oFT'ICES DANiPL it. BLacxs oc OCTi�� 1 � 1992 7440 LTNool ni; SUITE s �rayal��j„ i ��,rnfa ORO VILLE; CALIFORNIA `96pG6 Far. Numba� (91r1,�„U�i67 (918) 559.7149 October 15 ChiEo , 92 of"da; (iia) e�!r`,44h� 1.9' X3utte County Board of Supervisors 25 County Center DrivecrovilleCalif... . a95965 RE; Du ch Ravine S partsmen's Clubr Inc. Sar Board Members: Since my letter of �Pportunzt � Octo�;er g, 1992 xopert ;y to discuss the tonin 1 have had the Property xn the Swedes Flat- g'u,,e situation on m V-Duld appear that 'we area with members y clientis interpretation of cextainauses allc>tvednce of o°f your staff. xt and therefore x pinion as thea a Would respectfull under the tci the agenda to spec ob . y rcgue,t that w rbeent �;Or��.Izgj Chapter 24 of the count y *ain Your boardso placed on y code. ruling pursuant As to settin at Your boards, g a txlne, I would sift i Your hea conJ6hience full Y realizing Y request: that it be trials and hearanls sethearthgs, etc. and a X Presently pprecza,•r�� commence a two g in the last two week of otobee`t;Ostain week Jury on November 2' , "eequest that this matter' be. Therefor a,nc agenda at some bine,. at i�chedu�,ed oh e r wonl�d November or DeCtijne your c.onvenie °ur rer u]ar meel�ing nye in the latter pare :of Yours trt11 h Laniel V $,iackstoc DVB/dkb ccs William � Farrel betty Kirc her ; Jett Madden i, Kj t1 i } LAW OFFICES OF di6M��C�i1#ltl�f11l '1 DANIEL V. BLACKSTOCK OCT I _1440 -LIN. OOLN, SUITE 8 OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 05005 ACOV�IIp, Calf�d�ti�� Fax Number (0A) 634-0867 (918) 'i34-7AA4 1 Chico utGcgs (016) So&141 Ootober 8, 1992 butte County Board of Supervisors 25 County Centex Drive Orov lle., California 959.65 RE: IiP# 028-170-028, 028-320-0030 072-330----016/ and 072-330-018,, Property owned by the Dutch Ravine sportsmen's Club, a coirporati&rx Deaf Board Members 1 represent the Dutch ;ravine Sportsmenfs Club, znc., At corporation. The do;rporation is the owner of the above-descri�,& assessor parcels, whicih consist c,)f approximately 842 acres, ih the !swedes Flat area. The prope:4;'ty has been used for Minting` purposes, and to of r un4erstanding has been Leased for iluntib(I ` purposes and related users for well over the past fifty years. This of course i's ,.not inconsistent with the history of other parcels of laird nearby a;. Well as throughout the It,property .'c�ountyThe hhJb foothill e1snot flat,. � � rater has substantial elevation, and be described as hilly terra.iin, primarily covered by brush and with very. few trees at this tite. My clients' have conducted a hutbtr,r of activities oil the p?:operty aimed. at reducing possibl.e fire exposure, including the removal of gush« unfortunately a number of' misunderstandings have ocd rr+ee.,relative to the activities of my client. one of the neighbct''g have contended that `my client is in the process t�f releasing wild pias and 6t:her animals that will in turn go' oyes onto other peoples propertjr leading to trespassj etc. Thir3 is simply not true:, and at the present time such uses aro simply hot being undertaken. The misu'nder'standing probably relates to whaf, my client would eventually like to do in the future: if economically f6asiblei, Plesise bear in mind that the animals thtit the neighbors are talking about, i.e., Wild pigs and mountain goats, sheep, otc. are very .6.,pensiv�e. They would have to be dontrolled byliiternal. fencing so that the animals could not, bd lost. One of the m;issunderstandings that has arisen relate.% to - the ve5;y name of my cliehti The individuals who incurpcixated s 7. �� Wtte count I Dutch Y Board of Supervisors I t.cre 2 r Ravine Spotsmen Is Clu+ corporation picked the name Dutch yfnc. even though they are not opera Ravine 3 the present time. portsmen+s Club; This is simply g a hunting club a,s such 'rl.�lich happens to be the fee titleyownerofe of the' l:llstance;, the corporation does notowne corporation plori 11mmbersh p as xs the case the Property. Fnr With many ,clubs#,., 'Ps Or have a As a result of the rVcpived from the count letters that the cor gictivities on the Y, the corporation h porat on has and property so as to be Consistent With their Past use, pendn the g h outcome of their re.tonin zon-iris P7e would respectfully submit that hunting g request. state t.11e question; another wa �Yuntiriofper se g has nnt�e. been Precluded the use of pro er ''or td Ranting ca h be y pxerluded in this county under t for provisions of the various codessUded � zoning• Pursuant to the of where: one c�-,n hunt . including the Penal Code as a nuisance "n. thcouritmY knowledge J4 - is has in terms. shoatinY unless of course been classed q unto tAe rieighbors+ it were to Only a nuisance but propertys alc-,o. That of involve: neighbors 'Would have fula flat l recourse to t' -es Course ,is not pass to the courts, which the Because of the + ctually occurred on the misunderstandin s ac g relative to Your pE-'emission' to a pro ert what ;has p Y� we would respectfully accusations b app befcre your board to' request Y one of the owners of the surrbundinpond to ' would like the o ty.,se pportunity to set the record straig property•; We at a number of other ,ght, and to Point out that area are ver}• supportive of ou; efforts, owners previously acid checkers in the minediat raised under: their auspices to 'various The•corporatior had ,_ pheasants and �oTheh e be allowed 4:o take theme ous pee le quail which ,'Were` activities f.,rom Fish We have thea p who of course will birds and Game; ani it approval of all, of our the, hich are .n essence a Most be understood t' sPurposes of being eventually operation that the obviously some of these birds y hunted on the are raised for bobwhite , which -ri 4M , {j. ?utfi�e County Board of Supervisors RE Dutch Ravine sportsmen's Club Rage 3 We would respectft�,ll sv Y ,gest that when supervisors looks izito this matter, they will learn that Practically all o; the the Bnax'a o huntin y properties in the area are used for 5• The are used for hunting either b themselves or their licensees. the �►pu may very well hear shotguns rd Pierce who hascon , otzi�ei"1. complained to submit that from the distances i a• .r . 1 at t `S- Department of Develde# 8e��es PLANNING D,PPARTMENT y COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - ,006VILLE, CAL IFOAN( A#5.3397 TELEPHONE: (91e) 53847901 December 8. 1992 �t andy D. MCMain: Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's Club 113 Blazeford Gulch Road Oroville, CA 95966 ate:; Rezone, File 93-08 .Dear Mr. McMain )Y nclosed is a copy of the Staff Findings concerning your application :for a rezoeoe ft'O A-5 to FR -40 for property located on both sides of Swedes Flat Road, identified U A, P 028470-028, 028-320-003, 072-380-016 & 028, Oroville, A public hearing has been set for January 14 190. at 10;30 a.m, The meeting Wl"It 'i held. In the Board of Supervisors Room, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville Cahfotg1 , 'The planning Commission recommends that the applicant pp ant or their authollmd have. t• g p • y q in the even that no one will represent the applicant, Cct the sior't r#ng� repre,,�,ntatrve be resent at the hearing #a respond to an questions the office pp cant, please contact the Plarfinr l . prior to .the scheduled public heading. ' ; p �1cP{I 10:00 4-14M4 and 3,00 an), regarding #hia matter lease contact this o JteE;tl Should you have an uesttons re Sincerely, A A, Kircher Director of Planning Craig B. Sanders As0ciatc Planner `C}3Silt! i NO � tlliir n \cti 0\1�0�� v yd �� ;t\'..�1 hit,, Harsc1.6 v' u h ::j� ��cHwY._e°`° Y o� Oroi:' ° z V �<'.8s,a hvato NWv.(�: �bZ .. am r0 dM d,� Oa01ivoteawn ," •.r`� n :1 'n Alltf't)I l'N o: -� a, S da a 1iun�rrt� Qta�k wat `�W c° - Phoenix Hill. ••�" � * �� � �cleek ftlJ S ake Nd` oaa ,ti p y Plu' gar a a / � l�r1s t j' ' 1tl ILUIJ t4 ,, C' Ave U� a _ (Therm lito ..,i �w'.i � � �ro c � tl��% c � )f, 11`1�'jl+ t` e" R63 - Lott., NF �$ ` 4a ! 11 "YYiW t i 1. F -� t#r�3rv�sv ,T 0�`�� m ' �y� �lUYflNlt�lili 2?67' �ba I-A(lerG°y Ophlto =,a lid sRtEo "1. sancon y iv d21�1 p S� r1N.Ft t`RYilY at ll�/ [�i►dr;do a 'g r. - I'd wedeso � ~A 11 77 Messina aFH oU3'P > Ave. adfVanRo o Welsh KE 5t Road o �� rRto Bonito t Rd, Pa1(rm0° 5. Villa Ave. `°; Ej\ \yK, lb ro mF r �-+ Toad o ° .ro • ::: ar °r c Louis a °mt gt s3= ¢ Walnut e'e.,�� 3 a Daly ,�q o i East r c c o� i tixson ' Ara Ranch Rtl `" yAlice •ti' AVe: t rai Av. o a ``� , std, Street Nw ,� akotao Notth y. atwn " kart-+�ti 2!; a q a b do t Vol . • a teld v Per '. Rd: m Ir,. i.i: Qi`j Ui" : IoneA4eC. a v Q ki AVOC Road d�&filter � t - ..: Hastin s °i Pal —" I cle (i d �> V �g ` fIj\ ! ° no ear' N Drake AVe: Alrhohd F& if ��+ > AW, Ranch Rd, ti ro ,.. , Parks; JJ O s ¢ Snuth� S a m� "' Gt 1 15a'"`` Fi 6 'c Steadma {- u ,. Ave, �� Jennifer x '-1 1 - Rbgb Ln Lane Cox ane tom dor n Qq ,Hili Ver In ._ Ord Ranch Rdt 4' (loss Lane • ;Banigor,,�,.�`�°�\ . c Ur je%} x? C7 _ t:e7t11%t Z e o v I'. r o-� c a �, Creek L7A'ectxld Prather rid. E- ivr r . a� ` Melod Lane y ti a, IiANGdtt sir/v Sc'ft Ir E m { d � ' f 'Joto Q . c ItV� 1 Grimley .Road �s rn 4 C � .Q ' rJ . o i i.°alIt7G3 .w y I Q s r ro Gtpols n. yighW�Y m,aal E r.,nrt r� t' 11eq'� rr•�� g N G Swain klili y rr ArcNe Anderson I •lbunr.AA1P IiOBINSO S � b �� st d 9Qa Little Ave :Ober ever ..�. uct � COl2tJEtt. c . c � ' a � ,�"�� fit, West � � c � Holli O'firlen TlRichards �� � �. Central � 5fiousa s. 7G � � � k �<n$' �,;�o� �� an Oliver a Rd m Keith , Road it y d d M Lill, i / r , ro y �g " Stone } ti,CL Pr}r rYn�+ve. Nlelsnn Cla dy m `° c- �Q�^� \��0� i,�,�•� ;� G Dr. a Vt. Evans wr+ ht " ce far\. addle I�oncUt Road b c� rossn+s/ Y Y• Reimer - w .. ire• d lop�� ro� n ����� , Wolf Rrihd Ins.- `r Fieimar Road Join i o °� °'m otiS. occ W. rUr S a u,�- � •& � 3 m L b � fld, � 2 Hant:ut Q o c r � ;+^ • ,. (land s e ° rr Laurer` a Road'v. �.'Q�° ---¢r. o urner qty p - sunnvstoba . �� w. a eX O o GDo. moaG►' fi.•�:�w �c? I:ftandoh Ade, ` ''°t r ��~� 7 .,, .✓ 7� .a STA. 190 36 m fti.. Rd +Nhipple a M to. oPklns Camp i Ave, , E % Glo g9 ,� ��`w el�nc� � `y4 „ 4 l�ra{{[d ' 9aVan R 0 urrislod, Luckehe Rd: �9_ �' `'°U �� �,� R1ea o LC1MQ 1tICa ";y � c Metteet (°Urel n: tR ivies a f L{ U .°el, 1 nF V. �a ° n vtrattito Rd: e� a Y ` a R m Rdme GMand er m Fru�t� lowa,:,6 Ick{o i�►o VICINITY MAP RrANOY MC-MAIN R .'S. C . KtZONC 0IS -176--®2.8+ �`���►?� y , I I Aeu .a OL W'sIiVG DI'VIS1QhI DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT sEHVIdkg 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE OHOVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95gg�" 407 TELEPHONE: (016) 530.7061 Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's Club FAX; (916) 639.770E ' Blateford Gulch Road October 1, 1992' Orovl,l:le, Ca 95955 Re: Hunting Club Ap 028-110-028, AP 028•.-320--003, AP 072-330-016 and AP 0012-330-018 Dear Ms Berglund During .our meeting this mornin hunting for Pheasants g You questioned 'whether or not CtVJ) the sub 'e r . t Quail, and Chukars wulild be an allowed use 0)) . J property. My initial response was that Clubs of th.i type are not uncommon on the agricultural land in the valleYj and that Agricultural Zones provide dor Hunting Clubs. Unfortunately the subject (Agricultural) Zane, which zone property ke the A�is locaed in an A-5 Zones has no provision for hunting Clubs. It would, there' and A1�,. zoning violation to have a Hunting Club on the subject pro bd including Pheasant fir, be t Quail or Chukar. P p We also discussed amending subject ;property from the rquested our A2pication for rezoning the (Foothill Residential) Zone, which Would, (Agricultural) to a b'R4tl consideration of a Ilse permit ;for a Recrcitl ovif al pacdllt ori,.> . property. As soon as �,�allowsthe Ycur transmittal requesting Y the received we Will continue processing the a ,.g the change in meantime, you are requested to cease use ppl�cat'In, .t.).ia commercial hunting and shootinge. °f the propertycs,r t.he. Zoning ordinance purposes Which are in violation m 5incerly� $.A. Xircher :planning Director cc : Code .>nforcment 1) l APPENDIX I COUNTY OF BUTTE 1 FNVIRONMENTfAL CHECKLIST FOm EVTION OF ENVIRONMENTAL .IMPA►CT Vgj,xqr ;No. 93-0F3' AP No. Q28-1:10-028 ' DEC i 1'! _PACKGRC�UND-i�av13lr� Gtaltvl„ 1. Name of proponent: butch Ravipe sportsmen's Club 2, Address of proponent and-epresentative (if applfcabla)i 113 fllazeford Gulch Roadt orovillot CA 9596E I* from A-5 do FA-40 an approRimatell 042 acres 3, pra.ient de:criptiant p� YES MAYBE NO . DISCUSSION07 E27VIRONMENTAI, _EVALUATIM' I MANDATORY FINDINGa OF SIGNIFICANCE i, Does the project have the potential to degrede the qualitythio proposal Mill not significa,htly degrade the environment, of the environment, substantially reduce the habitdt Of a: fish or wfldlife speclelt cause a fiah or wildli4s population to drop below self-sustaining levels, threaten to elim'ihate a plant or animal conmahity, reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plaht or animal or eliminate important exampios of major periods of California history or prehistory? 21 boas the project, have the potential to achieve 4hbrt-ter= X - This proposal will nbt impode long-term bfivirotnahtaj goals, b„ 't14 to the datrimept of long-term enviran,'cent goals? LA r7 term impact oh the enviropm9nt is one Which occurs aiively brief period of time while long ..aria •711 endure into the future.) 3. t,. t ,project have impacts- which are individually, ^f ehvironm proposal e 4igwifidaht cumulative impadt 6N ''he is ro osel will not have it Ito it cumulatively considerable? (A project may 1'14* t,4o or more soparnts resources where the impact tic' lout^%re i s ralatively small, but where the effect it a'at of those impacts on the it q, G1ro Set kava :nnviranmantal affiants whish will %.,. This propnsal will not have a significant adverse effect on homer beih'¢!J �- ;ahtial adve)u effects an human bein9st either $)Si'taatlyl" TZ7C. DE'":312M� ���CIOai On the basis of this initial evaluationt p e enviropmeht and a NsbAl#V bECL'ARATIat beWil a ii nftitiant'effact it;ihic nate "— y e o' osad ,c oat r'' tl htl. ytl I4fiaaht a x t saC find th+. traaospd roje•.t tOULb NOT have a stgnitieant qo ectyon t treat do the ehVironment, there , will h e b"daU# Vho IAlt find that to pr p h j CLAPM1ON Will fib propered. d0 • to tt'r, r ,feet. A NE(iATiVE DC MITtgATIbN MEASURES described on the attached sneer neve-:ti3it ttr. (` :. !JWt fihd the proposed 'project lAAV have a significatik piled? bn the ehviro��enti and an tHV1RONlIMUL 40W ROW is ra9 u,irhd,' toukty or suftt,/t]LAN m broAn SEiii� 0y t oA ct fiovembef. to, 092 Craig nd Reviewed by ,_ t' _ `y 777, c ..a. E�, f nvir���nlnrr�n�al Checklist ��Evalua#cru of Erwlwannnen#aM Impack _ IV. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS res MAYBE NO DISCUSSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL 1. EARTH, Will the proposal result in sigrifficanti a. Unstable earth conditions, orthanges in (geologic X-- The proposal Will not affect subsurface earth conditions, substructures? b. Disruption, displacement, rompsction ow __ X This proposal will not result in significant diaruptian, diapi drs�r nt+ ovorcovering of the soil? the prbpaged xoning' be compaction and ovFareovering of the aito,Wiol reducing the potential development of the site from AGN part:eio 0 91' parcels. C. Change in topography or graund surface relief - X The proposal will not affect topography becouso the building site fir 41.040Y feature0 level. • ii. Oestructian, Covering or modfficatioh Of any unique geologic or pt,ysicel features? X- The site has na unique physical features, a. Increase in Wind or water erosion of soils, The proposal Will not cause erosion, either on or off titel f. Chehgst Io deposition of erosion of beach sands, X The proposal will not effect the depotiti6n of soft or erosi6h' 0 Vly or changes in siltation, deposition ar erosion waterbody, Which mey modify the channel of a river Or stream or the bed of the ocean or hay bay, inlet o+ laket_ g, moss of prime agriculturally productive soils :i X,,,_ This proposal does hot: represent a significant loss of prlmd egridrrYtrt'Yal, uutsid« .1"i0dated urbih at-east adils. h. Enposure of, people or properly to goologic X All of•Hatte County is in a Moderato @arthquake intensity Zorit, V'it><�r' hazards• such as earthquakes, landslides* Construttton of buildings to Uniform Building Code standards for seldmfe '?gsso mutfolides, ground failure or similar hazarrlst �, es required through the building permit application, will provide eddifikata peotectioo to occupants inn-ease of seismic activity, Will the proposal result in substantial: ar Air, emissions er deterioration of amblent air: �r -X The Proposal Will not affect alr;huality.liauause the raxone will radudo`fri�a Jualityl pkehtial number of vehicle trips, b. The creation of objectionable addes, s+eoke or _ X the p'r,bposal will not ornate objeetionablo odors, smoke dr fumes, c, fumes Alteration of air movtmeht, moisture or �� temperature, or any cFahge in climate, 'i:ocally X .., The proposal will not affect the atmosphos°o, or ragionallyl NATER. Will the pro(Osal result in subitahtiAlt a. Changes in currsihi.6, or the course or direction ,+ -.. _ _ X _ The proposal will not affect .shy watercourse, of 'water mbvoments in either marihe or 'fresh wetersT h. Changes in absorption rates, drainage patterns, -- X -• `ihe pedrosal will hot result tis-an increase in surface' water runoff, or the rate and amount of surface runoff? ,. e, Read for off-site surface drainage improvements,__ X .. No oft Rita drainage tMprovements will bn raquit`ad., for this project, including vegetation rombval, dhahnklitation or, culvert tnstallationt d. Alterations to the course or fj6W of flood X .. The proposal will hot signifidently affect ahy fieed control chann'slsin or * watersY watercourses, t--_._-- -nvl--r Ero Checklist* Evaluation ofrrnnvia �y� +� -------------_:f t, Dict G, e. Clfange a ih Cha water body? moon€ of aUrface Harar to any f. wfil nLt� discharge into surface affect altetatto Waters, or in any Any watorcourse, n of surfate venter quality, including but not ilmited to terrpZtor q alit , in o Y ffect surface rr turbidity? L x-- Tho prdposgl Will not sighificentl t xYgrn rface 9. vector quaiity, ground bWaterst direction cr rete of flow of Alta attar of the dir h, � the propgsel Will Change in the quantity or —� 1 not affect the d waters, either throw h quality of kion or f1+iW of Withdrawals dr throw h grower X ground Waters, h direct g direct additions ur — `— ?hie proposal' Will not d aquifer by cuts b g interception of an irectly affect a r excaxatlonst any a i. quifar available in the amounk of water avafiebie for publir otherwise water sUPpl1e0 J` The prole Exposure of people ;tt will not of fest any public hate hazards such P ia or property to watar�Celetdd Y supply, h es flooding? a' PLA LYFE, _ `"-� X the proposal wi11 not oxposo --------_._ pill the pr000set r•ssult 1n substan#tags PeOp1e °r y� e, property to flooding, Change in the divarsity of s a, 'by species wt plants x p fids, or number of 'by s, crops, and aquatic trees, shrubs, " - x quatic Plahts)t —�-- The proposal Will not affect t b• Reductio horaa diversity df plant life o endangered ospa, tnumbers of e H site, ies be piAntstny unique, rare or d, Ihtroduetioh n si&e dofitaini f new. species of no.rere plant's, area, or fn a barrier -to the normal plants 'Into an of existing xpectest __ l repiehishment X 'fhara osal wt g1' not affect oktstfng p15nt ills, ih acreago of u' peduction a,*jX agrtr, Murat crop} P p S.AiYd—AL—L_7" €p, prnplft�l resuitr X hTrh+ni wtniglki e cd►uon6ll hot contain t, Will agriculturvi c}v s n su6stankiel: p end is presently Ul,6d 4,4r e° Lhenge in the diversity of :paCi,?s, or numfrera 4f shy spade's a 'ehimnis tbfrds, ,land anifnnls �_ iHfe nn t ir.diudtng reptiles, fish and shellf',ah; x organisms or thsects)t t benthic lie pr°p°sat ieiti )lot sign►fi°enti 11 he s y dhan�fo the diverift' b, Reductloh in the hgmbers of an u y or number of anfait+l endangarod species a y n'igue, rare or. P f aniawst � `, Iter f._�� -- x. -r' Introduction pf new species of a enteihs no rare animals, - The site c area, or fh a barrier to nfmals into an movement °f ahimbls1 the nfigratton ar "'` x The .Pro Dial � P W011 hot affect ekisting'uhimal life, d, habertorat eri of c 0 ih I. Wild) It's habitat? sfistin the site js jocakad in an bred d Provided to. bUtte county 6y ti esignated is a devalopiriont area' o DYSi, Ntll'the propdsat result 6f the bent of +�0 1'Cu y bis hitt lifornia Dapartmeht of n the gra g in subatantieil Pertme ,n in keepinfl With the tach and fi'amn�. A. increases in a fame, mmrndatidR, xfstin9 ifoise lavels} rt of i'i"sli a' d ✓ Proposed �olfkhio ha Use Pnrfoml Sion fa known tat the t siilieS This raftm'ercial ofttdoor fanflitlds h 6 lrllgting 61ut o' h re6reationnw this the Nofsr"issue cansitr, he a applicants grafi i ,to os batt ba bast addrdsfi,ed Nene 'toret. <tdp lowafd; Pi+ltcant in81'lwll, ;�, =y�� `1 . , ,kcklo # Ev�l�datian �t'` Enairgnmen��eil �h%�; � Environmental . Impact 4 b, Exposure of people to severe "Oise levels? an Use permit proposal. The proposal, wt 11 not oXpos4 people to severe 7, LIGHT ANll GLARE. Niil tN?a `al produce stgnl`ficent noise 1eve1's, light anp' gjar4�" —_ —)L_ The proposal Will hot result in a substantial increase propos Y1 attar tion Of the rasa"t or Janna created on site or in the vicinity, in light .or, 'p�Are _._PID LINE „ Will the p ,,pose? result ih d substanttai' p Planned land us of an areal x The proposal w111 not alter the land use in the a'.e, General plan lend Uso designation for the alta is Agr•{cultuwal Re¢{ogoutto 6A)Unty The proposed zoning is consistent With the Geteri le And a` Gene appropriate then t+;a existin zone Plan n is, I" ma'Ay rvPy 1 8, 11AttJRAL RF.54URC<5,. Wtl:t the proposal. result. {n General plan poticios, g beceuq,a it bat Is* refloete tho substentiaJt a. lhceease in the rate of use of cpy "atu,,el resources? _x The proposal will not affect any natural resoureos, b, Depletion Of shy non-renewable natural resqures7 10. NTSk OFUPSET, W{j1 the proposal involve# pieta _ The proposal will not de any natural resource's, a, A'risk of et los{on or release a haziv of ti aecida"hemicalsetb�o 'esus substances i not limited to, oil, "' k posticidds. cfremlcalI or radiation) {n the 'We"t. The ro osnt w{ti not involve tho Use of hazardous metei4811, not, is 10 fitRd p p y h store or utilize such makarials. P hditions7 cissa to en facilltios #yhi, b, Possible interference with an enter ge"cy rasiionse Plan or emergency evacuation pleht -- R The proposal will not affect a"V Amar enc POPULATiO#i, g Y services, Will the :proposal alteM lgn8titn, ���� distributiuno density or k' population? s{ y growth rate of the 'i,utnari The p isposa'l Well hot significantly affect the population of the'arae sbetepyffiP the piloposed density does not oxceed' that planned and 6eing devejoped 16) t�rli!s l2• HGUStNts, Will the proposal affect existing housi;� or ane", create a demand for Additional hous{ngtp i3k the proposal will he Will the ProposalrasuIt''Iht t sifigncdntly affect housing d Mandy , ANSPORTATloN/CIRCULATION �— —~ a, deneration of substantial additional vehicle movementt X,_:.. they proposal will not represent an incremental i e ee b. Effects on eXistin' area, hlr se in traffic f,ti lr for now parkingt g perking fdcilftiasr or demilhd The proposaC''*{11 not offer? or ~_ x p king because the with the part, „g requirements contained rlithin tlu to Chunky l001al lhavodeiiactiu ¢ 35. c. substantial Impact on existing transportation syskeMst The proposal will not rep re tl,alterations to present aeht an ihoroosa; i' requiremants on Area roads, h cohgestlon and patterns of Ma{nted''d�idM . sign{f{cant circulation or moVah:snt of people and/ori {#odds?" ` k Therp osal will hot alttsr, the P P pheaetit pattern of tirculatton in 'thb e, Alterations to watgrburhe, telt o r I r dir i:raffict `,,,� k r: The proposal w111 iqt e}{act r f. Intrsase In traffic hazards t6 ail on air traffic. biEyc'{st.f pr r+ motor vtkhicloa, P eatria"at - Proposal in a" ihtrame"tal incrldse {n traffid d"moi 14, 4OU StbylCEs, Will the arse. y proposal nolle an offset upoh, related traffic hazards in the qr result in,a nand for hew or,atlta red governmOnt The ro bsai will not result ices} p the area ) a, protection{ the ro osal W Fire p P ill not result , ratection in in an ihcrama,tal i'hcroase {n demand for iije;a the potahttal' density -allowed, by the xprie 1s be'fd g i0 8, reduced by a factor of B. If the land is further diVided. ihtA�Pe ,fire sprinkler system will be required at that time, b. Police Protection? � X The proposal will not result in an incremental increase in dpmantl W V lice Protection in thr area, o, Schools? X The, proposal Will not result in an incremental increase in daniatid ^1bt e' fool sarvices 1n the area, ' d. Aarks or other recreational facilities? _ X The proposal will not result in an incremental incroese 10 demand fors ;pork and recreation facilities in the area+ e, MAntehance of publi.t facilities; including roads? X The proposal will not result in an incremented JhCr66%Qr in the ih4W lRr maintenance of roads and other ubl facilities in the area, f+ Other bveeAmental serviceit 9 ._ _ X P A ! 1 increase fa demand 1'L'. ,411.., The proposal will not result in an}Increman a1 A other governmental services in the area, 15. MEW. hill the proposal result in. a, Use of "substantial amounts of fuel b" energy? „ X The proposal will not utilize substantial fuel or onargy. b. Substantial" increase in demand Upon oxfstiriy X.. That proposal will not substantially increasethedemand for onoFgy. sources of energy, or require the development of N4 j now sources of energyt C:' -Proposal or a head for new !LTsystems, r)r, uibstgntialalterationslto t the fnee,d fogt a. Po.ler or natural get? __, X. The prbposad will not affect electrical power or hatural gas disfff�.4it'i'on systems~ b. d6twunicati,ons systems? X : The prdposal Will not affect comanihic't'.ioh systems. \` c. Water availability? _ X_. The Proposal Will not affect public water systems, d. [@wer.or septfo' systems? X The proposal will have to meet the rhgdirements of the Butte' ddu'nt'y Envirobment6li1dalth bapt. e. Storm crater drainage,, ..r. X The proposal Willrhave to provide a - ermanent aolUtion for draltiagev f, Solid Waste and disposal? X -. The prbposbi,will not affect solid Waste diaposel. 17. : NUMAh_HEAL'TW,_ 'Wili the pi'opbsa'l result in a. Creation of any health hazard or potential haraild _r X . The proposal will hot: create anY health hazard; (recludinq mental health)? lir Exposure of peopir to potential health hazards? _ K..: The proposal Will hot exposdpeople to any health ha,-tard, 10. Attj`m tiLl. will the proposal result in the obstruction - ^�. X -, The proposal Will not result in an aesthetically offensive vfeW 'bad.fil s 'Of any scenfe Vista or view opah to the public) or Will the is consistent` With surebunding development+ proposal easylt in the creation of ah aesthetically ,C offen'slvo sfte open to the public view# `l 161. pECnEATI01i. Will the proposal result in eh iinpaCt upon the. ^a X. Tp p Y result it an incremental he proposal may ihcreaae demand for pdr d In deman quelityorqughtityofeXistingrpereatfohaiopportunitiest recriation facilities. 20. CULTURAL pESOUni:ES. a UM nroPoia? uyt in the aoteratidd � y- it lecated so a iiey subject e th, 1 `. dli i destructs 6 Prehistoric histori� p r oecut, SincThe OrbJectpfirty will hotndirdetl result in ohyi tsl 61sW p y y phYbical cfi.#d�&s ' archaeological site? L' : „ , i'on the bitr and Will' rudilca the potahtial future devrlupmant of the prdil;!`&kY► Environmental 66ecklist *,kEvalul tAon of JV64Bronme ntal Impact no survey is reconmended at this tifne. At such tiMa as a d`Av$li;.r'P1kpnt proposal is prosented,p an archaeological survey may be requited, b, Will the proposal result in adverse physical or "� %— The proposal will not affect historic uites. &bathetic effects to a prehistoric or, historic - building, structure or object? Cr boe► the proposal have the potential to causes _ :_, k The proposal will not effect cultural resources, physical change which would affect uhique ethnic _. cultural values? d, Will the proposal restrict egistiNg religious or ^ _ % - The proposal will not' affect religious resources, sacred uses within tate potential impact &rent S a � ! t 8 Environmental Checklist * Evaluatior► of En Wr®nmantal impact „ Iproieet. Doscritp ion '. ,Biological EnVironment.. . 1. Type of Project.- Ilazooe 0, Vegetation: Chaparral vegetation type a. Brief Description! Rezone from A-5 to FR -46 P. Habitat: Small birds and animal's iotnnoh to fo.-itj+jpIA, WildlWildl ;f. Location: Located .on both sides of 5WarJas Elat'Road, approximntaly Critical Winter habitat for the door hard, 1.5 miles e east of C ' Iro-Bangor Hwy. Bangor area Cultural Environment.-.. _ 41: Proposed Density of Development., The: zoningWill allow I dwelling 10, rrchaeologieel and iiistoricallRasourcas in the area: H'fgll•' unit per 40 &test sensitivity area. 5, Amount- of Impe"lous Surfacinor None proposed at this time, 11. Butte County General plan douignationi 'Agricultural RaSidAA' iql G. Access and Nearest public Road(s): The property Has frontage on Swedes 12: Existing zaningt h..5 Flat Hoed 7. Method of Sewage nisposal: Individual septic systems." 13`. Existing Land Uao on�sita: Open land.) hunting club 14. Surrounding Area: 8. Source of Neter Supply.-. Individual Wells... a, Land uses: Rural residential h parcel's to the eA'dt, 6,po g. Proximity of Potwar Lines: 70 property. land in other directions with limited rasidendas b. Zoning: ASS, 10, potential for further land divisions anis develo praontt The potential V4 Gan. Plan DoWigbetiont Agricultural Residentia r Grazing and opan Lands will okist tot- the Creation of aPP. rokimately 21 'parcels, d Parcel Siznst 0 to 100+ acres, predominately 464 AVO k« Enyiroiiinontal Setting e. population: Limited physics! Environment:. 15, Character of Site and Areal Very rural 1: Terrain 18. Nearest Urban Aroai Oroville4 approximately 10 miles pWj1y a. _ General Topographic Character:' HoWng foothill's „., 1�. Relevant Sphares of Influence: N/A b. Sia as• 5 to 2S*%, e, Elevaticnt 1200 to 1506 feet Above sea level, Is. Ioprovemahts:Standards Urban Arent No d. Limiting Factors• None 12, Pira protaction Servicat 2. 5oi13; it. Nuarest County (Stcte) Fire Station: N/A a, Types ;and Characieristicst N/A b. Nater- Availability: Eire tankers bnly, h. Limiting Factorst Nano '3: Natural Razards of the Land 26� 5choots in Arent Bangor Union Scheel Ofatridt acid Oi4bVille Eletn¢htary. a: Earth4ii0o Zonet tioderate Earthquake Intensity xohe Vill'v b. Erosion Potential: High to very high - c. Landsli'dn Potential: Low d, Fire Nazhrd;Nigh to weFy high n Expensive Soil potentials Law 4. hydrology. a. Surface Natert A Creek and a few ephemeral dPAiliages exist on tit b. Groun'-Neter.- unknown, potentially limited. c., braihite Characteristics; The area 'generally drains to the southwest d, Annual'hainfail (norami)s d0 to 35 inthes per year. o, Limiting Factors, Nohe 5. yi Virtual%Scenic Qualityt. Good. G. Acoustic Quality' Good, 1. stir Quality: Good, Environmental Checklist-* Evaluation of Environmental Impact ENVIRONMENTAL REFERENCE MATERIAL 1. Butte County ni Activ ty Ma11-De Seismic�SafetylemaEand Man g P lemenL-. 12. butte County ,Board of Supervisors: Fault orov lle, CA: CH2M Hill, 1977. AAoricultural.Preserves Mali, established. Resolution No. 67-178. Oroville,, CAS 2, Butte County 'Planning Depaitment. 1,1auefaction Butte County Planning Department:, 190Y. - potential Map 11-2, Seismic Safety element.. 13. National Flood Insurance Program. l CA: Cfi2M Hill 1977.. oroville, Insurance Rate mapg. Federal Emergerl(Sy 3. Butte County Planning department. Subsidence and Management Agency; 1989. Landslide Potential Map ill—I, Sa tv Elemznt. e . orovilley, CA• cmzm Hill, 1977. 14 USGS Quad Maps, Bangor Calif. 4 Butte County Planning Department. Erosion 15. Soil Mail, chico (1925)/Oroville t192 . Potential Map 111-2 Safety 'Element:, Oroville CA: Area. United States Department of CH2M Hill, 1977. Agriculture. 5. Butte County Planning Department. Expansive Soils 164 Soil Survev.of Chico (1925)/Oroville , 111-3, Safety element. oroville CA• CH2M (1926).Area.United States Departmp . n't• OfMd — Hill 1977. Agriculture. 6 Butte County Planning Department: Noise_ele'ment 17. Butte County Planning Department., Bute Jurisdictions Map TV -1, Scenic Hiahwav element. Oraville, CA: Counter Fire Protection dE CH2M Hill? 1977. cartment andMap�CaliforniaCahforniacounty Butte De. Det p'artment fir 7. Butte County Planning Department. Scenic Hic;hways Forestry, 1989: Map.V-1.Scenc Highway -'Element. Oroville, CAt- CH2M Hill, 1977." 8. aunty Planning Department. Butte County Butte Natural. Fire �# Map 111-4, Safety Element., Oroville, CA: CH2M Hill, 1977. 189. Butte County Planning Department. Archaeological Sensitivity Map. Oroville, CA* James P ,Manning, 1983: 10. Butte County planning Departs vont. Sn_hool District Mate. Oroville, CA 11.. Northwestern District Department of Water Resourced, Chico. Nittate Study Map: Mitrate Concentration_ in:Shallow.Welle. The Resources Agency, ,State of California, 1983. r I, C - .r r AANALY OA. Yr atex,Iai5 Cheniis(ry and Lighting Scienc t rdQ Accredited by Nrattotrril ittst, of Stttttdnrzls 6, Tech. rlttterican Assoc. cV illfotor Vehicle Adinitr, � H Certified by CnlifOrt in Departinent of I cnit/t Sc�r��tc s k ,,S' 4e� December 11, 1992 Sutte County Zoning Director of Development Services 7 County Center Drive proville, CA 94965 Attn: mr. 'w. Farrel I am Writing to inform you ,that as a land and homeowner adjacent to the proposed "tml Ravine Sports club" we object entirely to the formation and existence of same, 1 There are !IQ fences separating our property from the proposed hunting club undoubtedly our property will be trespassed upon; We MA no longer feel 5 9 walking on our own property due :to the possibility of stray +anti irresponsible gt►trlF` 2 The influx of so many non -locals into the neighborhood Will greatly increase lilla incidence of theft and hurglary, 3 The noise created by constant riflefgun ;fire is extremely objectionable and is rea l alone to refect the proposal.. The recent gunfire has been noticeable and X, undoubtedly increase to unacceptable levels, 4= Property and personal dilmage clue to stray bullets is inevitable. 5 ' The peace and ,quiet for which We purchased the property is violated: 6. etc and toy Traic on- odes eNally Hance problems have not beelat Road Will substan ' increase ' t ► with increased noise/deh�`ir�,. by the county, t addressed by the Sports Club tfC 7. Changing the ecological balance of tho animals in the' area by either shooting tlldttl introducing lcing animals to the area is sure to create problems, For exanlple shootige co otess will result in a hue increase o3- nnce and ,rabbits. COATINGS BUILDING M, RIALS t1olITINGDEVICp5 t4AIVnftt)OUSWAM; 8PtCTROSCOI' CHROMATOGRAPHY IvIICAOSCOPY • PHOTOMETATO's • txi b INS >;CTIO i MLLE AI30RATOhYAND 6FFrcg P.O. wk 8`]02 LOS ANGELUS OFFIr-Er ' P[MMtV VILtE, UA 9466,2 12304 SANTA MONICA BOUT- VARL) • SLgT#moi TEL W10) 65�;91STREET ri tAYVILLE, CA 94608 VL'Ir'.ST' LOS ANCELt8, CA 90026 rlit tSlo) 652 2979 VAX (510) 652.3085 TI?t (A) 826.8012 VAX (td) s26�jg u ,�,r IMMIWA LAW Orl`Iai';S OF _ 1992 3DANUM V, BLACKsTOCK�,. .gllfornla 1440 LINCOLN, SUITE s OROVIL r. e-kTj)?O"IA 95965 Fax Number (918) 534-0867 (918) 594.714 r'V chlco office, November 16, 1992 Butte COUbty Board of Supervisors 25 colnty Center Drive OrOville', CA 96965 iN RE: Dutch .Ravine Sportsmen's Club Inc._ 90a> Board Members: Your Board set our flatter for revieca and December 1, 1.992. discussion r dy, members of However, as a result of a conference that our your staff on November 6`, 1992,, 1 respectful Wa ti matter b taken Off calendar. Y reggegf My clients are proceeding to meet with the general arta Who have appeared before people in th the misunderstandings tkA�t have arisen,. We hope to eliminate I do continue to have disagreement with staff onone issue, As you are all members of ranchers ,in the c ounty will charge aware, ratan yont There may or may not be �� g people to hunt ori their land,.. Butte Count Y hunting lodges'« on the y has never interpreted this as a property involved, ' zoning sue and Mich o as the Penayed code oche laws to enforce hunt,i n 1s Y concept or use defined as commercialehtlntin �� J practices.; p There has never been a ih any other county in the Sacramento Valley to m g in this county, of Y krlow�:,..f�ge, We utill cont' .nue our efforts to amicably issue, and I join my clients in thanking you and your resolve' the �' ity of meeting and conferring on the issuesr irivolvfor the pportun ed, Very truly Yours; Daniel''v: Blackstock DAB%e j d , cc: William Farrel Betty Kircher aeff Madden p.vv n.uul. u1111-1 PLANNING CQM�IISSi(7�,1 i'+OTICE OF PUBLTC_TlEAR Notice is hereby given by the Butte County Planning Commission thift public ttl will be held on Thursday, January 14, 1993 in the Butte County Board of Supei4�Z�'!tl`�., :T 00 n, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, CagtiJ pegar6tng the following items at the following time: 9.00 a.m. �,aycon�unn „Q Meral Plan Amendment from Grazing, and culturaly e4���d parcelsj Located on the ;south side of Durham-Pentz R. pprox. 3 Ot} � st of Claris Road identified as AP 041-130-021, OrovMe area. (File ' ;Rosa _.Rogers - Use Permit for permanent second residetaee on pat`%!i, ty zoned A -R (Agricultural -Residential) located at 2554 Uak Knnlllapprox. 650, east of Lower Wyandotte Road, identified as AP 03, 17[��� OroVille area. RE A,RBIt tr T� - �--_ l • � •�rr� t t v r� U EULAR . G _ NVIItON11 E�7TAL ITvipACT irAS BIJ'EN RFrn7�+�+ ., T 10s3fl a.m. Rand u D. 'McMaiii Dutch Ravine S ortsman Cl w � ( Rezone from � (argcels) a ral, 5 ci' a acres Parcels) to FR -40 Foothill Recreational a5 P pprox. located on both sides of ,Swedes Flat Ra aPIA , g .g ` Yt + 02532 003 072-330-016 & 018 Orov le A x, (Fred as A 028.1�fpt , , � �e area. �Flle .�3-08� The above mentioned applications, ma s available for pubh,. vie�stng at the office of the Butteo and r Cove untyt1Plannin ate on f"jje aI4.(t g partmet�f County Center Drive, Oro gat California. Comments may be submitted in writing., X11 date. if You chane b �, y .e Weetu�g,bsted above or as Continued t g f. time Prior to the heat iijg or orallat to o ,a la r challenge the above applications in courtlimited' only those is;;ues you or someone else raised at the public h ting cribed ui yttl' . toa,si Y . notice or iai written correspondence detvered to the Plannin '� p Wic bearing. g Coninvssxon) at or ptri �a 11 to, the u B_Li TTE COUNTi' PLArYiYt1V(`' C IV A. KIRCH ER, Y �.._._., DCR�C7`QR- Off' PLAN�CT To be published in the CroviIle Mercury on Thtitsday, l"1ece.mb rr 10 1002; i f .......:..: n, LAW Ori"ICES OF 4 DANIEL Y, BLA,CKSTQCK J��nrinA 1440 LINCOLN, SUITE 5 OROVILLE} CALIFORNIA 061)65 Orouhe, Fax NuMhcr (pl(i) 634-b£G7 (916) 684-7144 dlilcb office: (916) 660, .111,1 November 7.6, ].992 ?butte Count Y. y Board of Supervisors 25 County Center Drive Drovi.11e, CA 96965 IN RE: Dutch Ravine sportsmen Dear Bnarsd Members: Club, Inc, December l set our matter for Your Boardour as �, review and clis .�. , members of your stdff on,Nvvemberr6sult of a conferenceuQs3,,.sn� that our matter b , 1992 h ld t�xf y 'takers off calendar. I respectfully MY clients are Proceeding to meet wve a general area who have ' the misunderstandigs that have arisen. eared you. We zth the people in -6�' n hops to elimina+. s; aff o I do continue to have disagreement with n one issue. As o members of ranchers in the count You are all aware There may or may not b will Charge many farmers y�fi y g People to hunt on their land Butte Count .. hunting lodges,, on the Prop n his i r 'Y 1, at OU PLANNING DIVISION , - AN , :7EPARTMENT OF MCLOPMENT $ERVICed 7 COUMYX UNICIA DRIVE . OROVILM 0ALIFOpNIA :6606:9M `TELEPHONE; 1010) 630,701 FAX, (910) 53ng705" MOvember 13, 1992 Dutch Ravine sportsmen's Club, Inc. ,Attn: Virginia Berglund, Secretary 113 Blazeford Gulch Road Oroville, CA 95966 Re. API 028-i70-028., 028-32p-oo3, o72-'' 3A -016j and 072-33.0-018,+ `per',.y owled by the Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's Cl, ., Linc. Dear Ms. Berglund: On September_ 23, _ 199'L,, a sent a copy of a warning letter to yds because of your position as secretary the Dutch 12avii lo Sportsmen's Club, Lnc (The letter was in?,Jvreitently addressed to theprevious owners because the asses80t's' COLputer did not yet reflect the recent sale of, the property t`I- your corporation.) Dip, October 22; 1992; we sent another warxti^ g let ter to the Dutch Ravine Sportsmen 18 Club, Inc., Care of you as the secretary of th corporation, These letters advised you that you were in violation atirn , of the Butze-County Code and to notify youtthat you could correct ttae violations by discontinuing the corpora -ion r s operation on t"he abdve-referenced properties On November 6, 1992, we held an intarmat conference. attended by Virginia Berglund, Secretary of the;Dutct Rgvine Sportsmen's Club Inc. , Daniel V. Blackstock; attorney for the COrporation and tt�e following county personnel.; williAm Parreli Directory DevolopmAnt" Madden Codep'nforcei�tent Officer,- and Heil. �.. Servides DP artment• tette Kircher; Plannz.ng Director; Jeff A.Labe; Assistant County Counsel. We Would.li.ke to 'thank you for thi steps the corporation. tapply o ail and limit Otis o era,dk, 4�, on the property a,nd oo apply r a rezoning thereof. he y pY! "that you have taken should help to a11.ev�iate concerns '-About thecorporation'zg p. p P y r p Y� .l Lead to a long term, operations oris on the prope and ho erull " w.� sol+.tion. 1 ,Butch Ravine sportsmenrs Cl Attn:ub, Inc, Attn: Virginia: Berglund, Secretary ,november 13, 1992 ?age _2_ We understand that you will not allow an to be used on the property, and that u e u the ns Other than shot U�.a limited to bird, hunting and cla shotguns wij clay course. You agreed that members igeon shooting on the s.o°:y Pq allowed to shoot clayers of the Public P at; pigeons and that Clayp will not confined to principals of the corporation, thee'families shootng wi l ,g friends. �,� e and However, it is our understanding that allowing members of the public to you intend to > , raised and released for hunting on the ro ext ceasAfij,,g Pay a fee to hunt. pheas�t�z and ektended pheasant hunting season. It :sour y during the regttl1" a commercial hunting operation is not an all I position that s 611 (Agricultural) ,zone (Butte County Code Section 24-72 a ase l the Your property. Butte County Code Section 24-64 ) pplicable �;'�,� '"All uses of land within a zoned district provides tha��' authorized or permitted by the regulations ars not sp, cifica l 1spe have the commercial hunting and hunt prohibitedfl 1�T`6, pecifically authorized or permitted 1+ t related uses not bei fu depa:�trnent has reaffirmed our position that is c review by thjg hunting operation is not an all o �aed. us a commercial, e in the A-5 zone,.. This violation flay be corrected by either commercial hunting operation or .(2) obtainin(l) terminating tif# with a permit allowing it, p g a rezone and xts impact on the neighborhood, appropriate ate condt�.ons to mitigato its" Unless the volai»ion is so corrected a citation may b i ~ . ! ` iy the corporation its offida s directors or agents or an one who has possession control I. an owners, interestY a issued �0..' access to the Y eielo premises '4i�d aided, abetted, advised or encoura o coh1tission of the 'violation of the Butte County Cod t , . g You to a y Y ich" letter citsh suc�fr, citation or ditat.oh8 ma this 1et,t be Issued thin days. after thy+ for failing to comply W31th Ph s noti e, Thus , violato neand 64 1 az`e oJ'attailed and limited as yb x have represented to wolUbtarily comply ws.th, tht above y f Your acti-vibe directions a d termnatedt2yy reiinaining commercial hunting or to present an acGeptble plan for abatement or corrective actions to be taken b Vartm66 dt can re uer Y you • However, q t that a Coda zrmmed at''lY issue ditation(5) if ��..:t Bn rcement officer bt,"eve that the Violation constitutes ae threat to t � health and, s&edty of any person or erson:s ... or to ro er„ n d,, Code Sectioh 41-2(c). P p n �Y" Butte County I?ROOF OF SERVICE BY 14A XL Z am over the age of 18 and not a party to this daugot I am employed in the County where the mailing occurred, 14 W business address is 1 County Center Drive. Orov lle, California. I served the foregoing 30 -Day Letter by enclosing a ttil copy in a sealed envelope and depositing said envelope in tfl United States mail with postage fully propaid on November 191 g 19.92, and addressed as followst, Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's Club, Inc. Attn Virginia Berglund, Secretary 113 Blazeford Gulch Road Oroville, CA 9596E I - declare Under penalty of perjury under the laws oft d 14 State ofl�Calif ornia that the foregoing is true and correctAnd 1 ? ; that t!"is declaration j in the City of oroville, CA was executed on: Date 20 ORIGINAL td BE + $IGNEb AND DATED 21 2'2 1 tip 261 2g `, �I Us, PrJSTAL SE VICE CERTIFICATE OF MAILING, MAY HE USED FOR DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL MAIL, DOES PROVIDE FOR INSURANCE-POSMkSTER� _. �pr"p,�1rJ► W4 V I V INQt'J— "7 GEaI - t l'! Com; G5 q Low'.,. ! w �� One piece of ordinary moil eddr?.oeea to:� L! if tse \urA �\-b 13, c6- *067a C- ukC)n Atrix tee hard In:#10MIlb or motor p041400 dill I post mark, Innulro of Postmaster 10*110011t loo, � m gar 1 I s Dear Members; I have good news for the 92-93 season. I finall a large piece of property A. the club. Y obtained At most of you know I was having troubles with the farmer that farmed the west side of the tracks last year. Mout Of you saw what he did to the cover on that sle iaell he is going to be farming all of the property this year and I couldn't see paying to lease a piece of that wouldn't have any cover, property I've entered into a partnership with Dale Berglund and weave recently purchased approximately 1,000 acres off Swede's Flat Va., south east of 0roville. DAlle will be running the RV park, fishing, swimming and gold panning part of the club, I'll have Complete control of the hunting and sporting clays part of the club. The property we've purchased isn't the best piece of proppet-Y there is for pheasant bunting but there are parts o,{ that is suitable for pheasant hunting and there is several thousand acres around it that is available for lease. Because' of the limited area for pheasant hunting I'm only going to sell 1,000 pheasants this year and I 'Will be charging per bird released. Past members Will get the first chance at the pheasant cards. The property is well suited for Bobwhite Quail and Chulcar hunting and I will have a large amount of these birds available. Besides the usual bird hunting we will have Wild Turkey, Deer> Wild Hog, Exotic Sheep and:Goats an'd Valley Quail hunting plus a very challetrging Sporting Clays course. We hope to have S g y p poriin Clays s course open eometime in on'their firste and I'm froundgaf Sportizigecial hCla.dsscount to all members' Y I look forward to seeing all of you and if you have any questions or would like to see the property please . me a ca11. give Sincerelyy fP jr mar. . "Pip gepartfrt a G 1992 October 26, 1992 G 0'!# X110: California Dutch Ravine S or ss s Club p t n 113 Blazer-Ordme GU1.(h, ,190ad. Oroville, CA 95906 Dept. of Development services Planning Dept. 7 County Ce,Atex Dr. Oroville, CA 95965 RE: Rezone, File on APO 028-170--026 Dear Ms. Kircher On reconsidering our a f Ravine Sportsmen T s Club hasadecidtion e� toe�z�37,in zoning for our {Llestt�tch n opE.rt,north of Swede l s> tt,. X20 to go ahead With the FR I a f; --;40 zoning 'Road and Of swedes Flat Rd. � for tr�e� j;r�itiperty south Thank you for your time and Sincerely, Virginia, Bezglut;d, Secretary j ,r i `i p la 7 .tia r mac,; UNTO O QUITO A BA�T�1. �r r� ren 17t�ilF�1�"0)t0vjj Lr./ ' StV LARKIN ROAD �����i 101S ,A, I11 � .! �+1,'fr, 4`�?]�NLt;, C1f J (51tCiVll�tF; A7.Ri4RT ONLAIMIN ROAi3 OROVILLR, CALIFORNIA 95965 JAWS A, 1'f tC1.4�t) 533<6438 rvA Mit' 342.7350 MAtS s�G)t PAX (916)53,1.9916 Butte County Planning Comms t�lmm�Dri►f7,:61# 7 Count g issi�n _.. County Center Drive, Oroville, Ca 95965 0 C T 2 9' Date-,. lOJ2.7I9z 'Co; Larry Painter) Planning Tech �IP04ti1la,C�t 0 NO;,; 0'28-170-028 { Applicant, Randy !`lchlain Pro, eet I)eacri 3tion i Rezone from A-5 to 1 tk-40 vGnditions and / or comments; 4< The I:o1j%ling comments regarding are offered as inforrrtatinn to g' disease vcc4orr and residents r.�f the area, PrUperty Owners and pests future a This atea has historically commonly called the �' ,produced .Aedes sierrensis ua.ter' holding the T eehole Mosquito. Tliis mosquito i, � d�j primary v'i'ctor df t1y , and other trees and which �' ,parasite N*h ch causes 80 is thki is subdiVided a.nd thereby ettcoura g hearkwotm. area gill result in an 11 increased risk Lar1Zi Les urban katlofi ijd this nC this disease. Tree davities that hold: Water especi�711 be drained b drilling y Oak tra _ nand, dirt or other g or notching the cavit �_es, Beed to water displacirtg mate' ::ia1, or filled t�fith �} "Chis U'64 includes areas tlia't are t Sl at includin " the Hector of 'Lyme 'Ilisea fe. yt t�abIta,t Edr ticks'' use could inert.ase thJ risk Any increased td residents: Otir.ing the tick sea disease traltp issiCn to f hossezal usually nctober thri, Jude), it is (thegabllee part L7.f ,, practice tick a,�loiru J E i`or ile year, and, t co- Procedures and r�:sidents to ,ten Za'r hed ticks t° per ociicAl ly chock 'peta i These ctatilMents ate consistent with trip i is tris t � s `. 5 , adopted1.. paf.ic�r rolled `�Guidelinea Ch, cklist dnd Sitgntlards for 1Jec . 1` roposed nevelopmentsl; r.�.vehtXtin zn P' for l If You hwie any ilueations regarding tiur' su t-Qcommendations ' f3ti0ns Or plefise feel tree to cbn'tact our os dice: Sincere Cl?/km pea g ion upervistr „ , •,..��'lltiti4iri�LL'L:�� �ta�,.., .1'. .: �t c.. �. �1l�li .7 i �I �t t'"''Jy .. v i 4UAk COUNTY COM14(SSAMM "" 7 County CeniCer j �aroville, CA9596!5 3 - 97 (916) X313-7601 I c..L4o A no-+e-a1 ? n 4- DAT,`.- 10-14-92 RE: PROJECT R,;,V IEW,, v- a sed ENVTRONMENTA L Rand D Y McMAIn 92µo8 ,ine closed is preliminary data our officAP�� 0 e,v -028 _ _has recceived Ancerning the following project"Rezoa�v` ?=r-xrxyt���p�tf,�a, ..,rtor,0^loaltadhFi�i�, �Aorth and south sides of Swedes Flat 'Rd. 4 'u, " PProx. 1 1/2 miles ease. of otd-V41,iio- T3angor Highway, Oroville. : _ -... Wo are making an asses suent of posbe preparing an environmental stble envirannental . Nimepacts dml Ioclaratiodocument, eitkej�, Negative wi�,h N[ztEnvironmental Impact Report (EIR) igatyariMeasure satoirvd i X Plea-td provide any factual , statements, ideas fog; zivest . car opinions you can offer in igation that relate to either phYs'c2clr sdcicil, oorceconemic�r�mp ctsit i this project may generate. at response eeisonednwith n 14 days of the above-note; date. If xto Please r generated by th i,s in i that there are no significant enTviroOrmPeht-al� i7npactslw be chsat' tec2 Potential from the project. re "We appreciate any as istanc;e you can proVide. . Sincerely, 4, POO a Larry Pa mer planning Technician Comments: , Doer yUu `v agen":Y wish to rdCeivo; a copy �nf the enviro 1atenta]. ,document (iMILal study for Npg�itive De , : . C1ara�.ion w3.t9z ar r�ra.t int 9 es) or EIIt dor thIs pra j ect ) Miti� anon Meas�ur Yes No Butte COuntY Board of Supervisors 2� `� � Count* Center Drive orovil.le California 95965 RE! Dutch Ravihs Spot tsmer,',`'s Club, Inc. Dear BoardMembers r - since my letter of October 8,, 1992 1 have had the opportunity to discuss the zonin Property in the Swedes Flat areagwith membrsoefan my clients would appear tha4-. we do have a difference Stafftl ft, interpretation t f OpinionOYr of certain uses allowed undOf the _ije and rY gth,ereforc.. J., would respectfully req resent that We z0hxh , thea �• p agenda, t o s ec11,�.c,,l y obtain rsrr youx lost � Chapter~ 24, of the county codei cis ruling pursuant t s to sc+tin a time 1 would siluply request that 1 at ,Your boards, convenience fully' rea,la.zi�g and it a kec- avy %� .,.Yhedule of hearings, ntc �` ralsYour eand' aa-i'ngs set in the, pxesentlyppaveyceriarr commence a t:wo week last two week of October ar�d jury an November 2, Therefore 1 request that this wo'ld. flatter he scheduled on your regular meet:ing;, agenda at some time at your convenience inthe November latter off: pecembor: part of Your. truly; ,I Daniel V. Blackstock i DVB/dk"b ' CC William Farrel Nett; 'Kircher aeff 24'adden �s �..)S(�7C+1��"r}YY1~•1"�5) ,' oVA► Vn a%" "}" �7`r, �{rc .�r l�YY1 „rL lzu C—i ����t✓��� 'fit 1��1�� _ D& o C. C.4 {t 5l �ji 1 Cr�►.�TI I Pw C� 4ts�� C�ti r:�i IIC. t t t to ra X411 1� , fII 1 y > ri►t i F`- c i1,t lr, Lt �: ' I "c ►ti��ci C 4r„'� 7`%,, . j. < f t i ,r`' L,, W OFFICES of IDANIti! 'V- BhACXsTwLK 1440 LINOOLNt SUITE 3 OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965' , Fax Nunber (916) 534-0867 (916) 5344144 October 8, 0111t y office; (Die) 8981)1 11 1992 Butte County board of Supervisors 25 County Center Drive oraville, California. 959`65 RE: AP# 028-110-028, 028-320-003, 072-330-016' and. 012-330-018, Property awned by the Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's Club, a carporatid pi Dear Board Nembers r x represent the Dutch Ravine Sportsmen,s Club, ince . c,o rporation. The corporation is the owner of the above-describad assessor plat els, which consist of approximately the Swedes F'! pit area. The has bier us 842 acres, in Property has been used for hunting purposes'.and to our `understanding has been leased � purposeG and related uses for well over the: or h+?nting This of course is not incoi�sistpnt with the historyfa ty other parcels of land nearby as well as throughout the count property 's typical of the foothill area i„e y• The rather has substantial elevatiOh differences and could benot at, *tit described as hilly terrain very few trees at this time. r'lmarily covered by brush and with � p of activities on the property a medmy lattredticin conducted a nulnbe�' r exposure, including the xemoval of brush. g possible fire bnfartunately a number of misunddr8tanding5 have occurred relative to the activities of my rlaent, ono of the neighbors have contended tYt,t my client is in the` releasin' Pigs property leading � . pxoces of , Onto other Peopless an other aclinatotresw `� in tarn o over e.impl.y not true. and at the present time such��u^�etc> ; This is' being undertaken. fine misunderstandin �`'s At simply hpt JMy client w0+,11d eventuall like to do g' the fut relates to wha"6 �' ' n the future it, economically feasible. r the Pl�.ase bear J. wind that the a iimals t'lrat goatseisheo�)o etc. ate very i.e:, wild pigs and McilZnta��., a, g y expensive z They Caould ' to lost'be controlled !,;y internal fencing so that the ani haV11 could not be . ma onE ofthe mi -t ,. understandings that bas arisen;relates td the very name of my client,The lhaividuals who incorporated y, q t41 13t1tte County Board of Supervisors Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's. Club gage 2 this corporation picked the name Dutch Ravine S o :the 01c. even though they are not operating a huntingrtsmenfs Club,/ which happens time. This is simply the name of tec or a5 such f.t to be the fee title owner of the corporation instance, the corporation does not Sell membersh' membership as is the case with many "Clubs". pz s or For cps or have a As a ,result of the letters that tiie cor o received from the county; the corporation has activities on the p ration has it ittehti With their and past use property so as to modified w Pending the outcome of the. th the zanx onjng request... We would respectfully submit that hizntin state the question another way, that the use of n per se or t hunting has never been Property Hunting can be precluded. in this count Y for precluded, and is precluded y under zoning. Provisions of the various codes includin,. pursuant to the Of where one can hunt. To my knowledge itthashe �neverbeenenal Code �C terx' as a nuisance in this county unless of course it were shooting unto the neighbors lasses property. That of coursed nvol^ve only a nuisance but is also aflat -out That to is neighbors would have full recourse to the courts, which the r Because of the misunderstandings relative to ectually occurred on the propert we what has: Your permission to a y% would respectful) appear before you r board to respond to�thes;t accusations by one of 'the owners of the surrc;. Would like the opportunity to set the record straghpropert poiht out that a ntinber cf other straight,, and to ` are"A are. ver supportive property owners in the �. pr vy pportive of our efforts. The corporation had�at'` ously sold chuckers ; raised ander their auspice Pheasants and bobWhite, quail wh:1c be allowed to take then. We haverthesa h were p of our F pec e activities from Fish ani Gamer and he approval of all birds, which. a be undWho o� course wyll re 1n essence a l vestsock operation�rstood that thd,; the purposes of being eventually hunted on the Obvio>xaly some of these birds, Which un 'will it , are r`i.� sed f yr premises. b oborhite ;quail,, and ahuckers may very, well include Property. Those birds W411 have all been yheasajit+ Fish and Game Who of coax=se regulate ate been d wa from 'this banded as re these course the birds thexnsE t required by ° type of tj;ea t:yr and lyes will enhance the nati�'ra 7 ese bias in the area x think that we can all tin when thesis supply off, birds are released, not all of then���vill bertakeh that the people they have been sold to, h y Al a D9tte County Board of Supervisors 10, Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's club '* page 3 Woul Supervisorselooks�into this matter, the twil when the Board of respectfully gghat Y ]. learn that Practically all of the properties in the area are uses! hunting. The are used for hunting either by the property oWne'r ' . g y � themselves or their licensees. Mr. Pierce who has complainba to rou may ver 1 m y well hear shotguns, however we would respectfully submit that from the distances involved it is exceedingly un,l.ikely that he could hear a shotgun being discharged from my, client's property;, We would suggest that the sound would situp not carry that far. We would further suggest that maybe wh same of these people mat may be complaining about are their own.: neighbors and people hunting on their pro ert is in the:,process Of actually completing the fencing ofrallaof their property g pro ert and �n dein so of course they are also eliminating various areas of brush which would fuel a range fire' which would definitely endanger thever complaining. Y people who are ,request to come you in advance for your consideration of our e befoj:e you to respond to the allegations made before you recently concerning our operations. Also I`would the Dutch Ravine S res ectfull re uest t"at all communications from the cwoul t p Y 4 Sportsmen's Y be sent to me in order, that we can more readily respond to an sof the count I ar s�nen s Club Inc . y s concern yours truly, Daniel V. Blackstock 7�VB J dkb ,i _ cc« Ji Betty `.Kirshner Bill; Farrell I; I RAY r oun DIRECTOR'S OFFICE DEPARTMENT OF VEVELOPMFINT SERVICES 7 COUNTY CENTER RRIVE • OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 9-690,,047 TELEPHONE, (0101 558.7801 FAX' (918) 63a-17135 qptember 23, 1992 14c . Virginia Berglund 11.3 Blazeford Gulch Road OroVille, CA 95966 ;RE Rezone Application and violation. AP#028-170-028, 028-320-003, 072-330-016and 072-330-018 Dear Ms. Berglund: The Butte County Department of .Development Services has receivdd' your letter dated September 14, 1952, regarding the Dutch Ravine Spott.smen's Club. After reViewIng the uses proposed for your 642, ,acre parcel located off Swedes Flat Road, we have conc]ucad th,a many of the proposed uses are not allowed within any of t - agricultural zones (A-5 through A-160). We are -Informing .1 'Yrou c this opinion sn that you may reconsider your<ckpplication fo.r rezoning; prior to proceeding further. Ther6 may be other t6hihc districts that would provide for your intended use such as this yk, (Foothill Recreational) district. Subject to obtaining approval Of a conditional use permit from the Planning Commission (or - Board of 8uperVisors upon appeal), the FR distract does allow, comme' your rcial Bunting lodges. You can easily amend applicat og" should you wish to follow this course. � This letter is, also to :inform you that the commercial hunting uses of Your property apparently now in progress] and uses such as commercial skeet or trap shooting' or at target range ate clearly �rico'nslsteh With the existing toning designation of ,Yourpropertc.Accordingly'You�arehereby requstedo immediately ease use of the property for commercial huntiti'g and shooting purposes which are in Violation of the zoning ordinanod .A notice of code V olat on is ,being sent under soparate coVer a Within the ,last week we have received several. verbal and writto�, complaints about the current and planned uses, Of your: pr,r�p A n'cimber of yoizt neighbors addressed the Board of SuperVi8ors today during the public comment period► generally objecting to dottherdial hunting on your property nota, and to ax>ty rezoning that would allow such to continue. UndOtbtedly, this getter will 1 i; _ 1►+ivei l mats - Coup ¢ � Coun of ;3 ppoa nir'� DP rim rit 1 SEP 1 9 o u we Zon nq epaptmtMv dru#1111 OP.Wornia, 4 bear site We w ri to to you now to infor SWir� you of the edGas Flat Road iri regard to the situation CUrrerrt. ton Dutch Rava,ne Sportsman's Ci"'a Dur 'first contact With :august 30th He met WithuLarry1Painterwas mand by yAlicha6 'L Pierce Cd our suspicion that the skeet. c1,ub/huntin l�ainte r confj rrrr Ation of OUr A -S zoning, g use was in viaa..= A colatingent of neighbor made Public comment at the :rvif,ors meeting, Sept. 1st: We exg�ressed our concerns � Board ofSup� oard at that time. Later Michael ,Pierce saw Mr. Painto_r { �xfices, a;nd iaas referred to the zoning code enforcement to tie in hip �,eff Madden. Michael lodged a complaint the r office'rr, He was told that day that within a Meek Mr. .tame day, Se t 1 Us regarding the legality of the Sportsmans Club wouldinform Ile waited 8 neighbors began too Call and rer�uest ini ortnat3on. days and then Thursday the loth s;r> t�'adden re`�hux-neCt one cal];.., to iy��, Si . chose property adz o,n,s the 800 acres in use for that ryard Ing area. Mr. gladden informed 14,r i Simard that the o neural hunt- Club had him out to the locatiot ,some time a o .rs of the Madden told the aolners to g r and at that time that Mr. iiadden; saw to gp alieau aid apply for the Problems,, u Mr. ���adden then to� permits �d Mr. Simard !� s much dens3,s,i ty of hoMo o idea.��� t�;dere was a in the area.:. �'�.:n a �. sadden had "no he wc,u`ld malke another tri. the club' week to 1 Q days' . Mr. sxmard was not assured tl,taE the ent. erprise would be closed 'down. At present time there are 13 day, tali ,the openint'� of deer season. TWo Of the neighbors. called R,��nr3y McMain�1 one �7f the +whets, and were offered the $SoO.00 a,,l season ht, o i�fe are concerned with the �.°ery c'roat hazards assocYat�`d`�lcage. hunting of game t�ith. h.tgh powered rifles. with tho There i;§ no ir�nce bei- >:4�ee n the a mardsF and the 800 dotes, and the awe " r 'E r�.� 1OW the hunting ' . _ � ttnW:Lll ±hg to g >:hstirahce against ,Eire and aocidents i�Y ill lace, and we �Ns�sr, not Jar frl:MMtb' A t� yaiar attention be directed to this s.:t Place, g. - have heard hi y n "� 'colo neighbors � � •� - tra.tio egttent] y :an the 8 U ecres t it�iir� the last5h Powerod ,riflog � week,. :1#41 wee ,t nderstai-Id ' ity the 8010 acres lieA in tho path bf the ritica winter range fo,r the deer; hunting is izl direct canf3 is".t to thee believe the tse dor 6e#ignatjon. Swede i s Vidt Road is ale4jjypurpose,of the a,1 nter ra,;!�ge ! ! ready showing Mdtked a` u.6e , aranY wi11 re dire furthcj ` g r care f t)za ;� x:hcrd"ed traffic is t .w ed to continue. Please contact Mr" or 14tt Sirriard at u. 1,38tl1, and het tis know the intentz orj�' of t i 820.. this s5 ti�c�t� on " 'aJ Tice tcy" 4�, L �ktlatz�.�U�'�'t��ix�rr.���. I pro.°cure fi it 1 0 Pr01 04 9earten it "# 1992 cl 1� p, �rpVr OJ PortIn Dutch .Ravine Sportt5men';s Club 113 Blazef'ord Gulc11, Road Oroville, Ca, 'Butte County Planning Department F,•t the request of, Craig Sanderso I submit the fb11Ci+,�irtg information regarding the operatibn and plans of Dutch Ravine Sprrtsmen's club. The area in which we 1,tave our hunting clan uis lo located aPprx mately 1.5 miles to of Orovil.le. is four large parcels connected together forming an 842 acre, piece. It is divided b,.jr Swedes Flat Road with aroxima 150 acres on the south side, the remainder on 'thenorthte �H side of Swedes Flat, Road. Itis our intention to offer a safe, supervised area in 'Which to hunt and shoot with clearly marked boundaries to protect other property owners From trespassers unsupervised, hunting and roaming. and Because of the short time we have owned the trt and the size, our improvements -40ncing ofandrbrush Clearing are barely startred, We intend to With these plans as our fj�.rst priority. progress The larger portion of the .property is to be left - for hunting;: fishing; and j?hotographic tundevelo� auxs. We plan. o clear the thick brush ir.1 order to reduce fir and encourage darlge"r. a natural environment for Wildli .e part of the propehis rt¢ ►ill be fenc9d and the houtidar es so hunters will. know, ex where ti ends, The access roads havo! sound at out !,ticks t.y Prevent uncut,horzed entr Eactl gates w�. r th ';ticks to Caretaker in s` ti ce to we p1ai� to have a permanent r'esidieice to insure nd� brie violaise.t OU property or uses our prod>erty to access sutrouzadin areas. Trespassing is g a in the clump�:n of pr'oL�1e�h fo.i; a1.1 of us as seen g garbage, old cars, and other,matseen w'e have foun i ori the property r s On the smaller Portion we have deValbped a 10 s . tatian sport �.ng clays course. This co-Orse isr intended to g� 4y ii T t ,provide members wpith a safe p]a'ce to tactics, skills and allows u.,to eValuace,a persons hunting s: habits. At each station,, s,tand> «c used which afety limit tk,te target area and, alb, sh',00�ing must o'er these gstands. All mezrdberrs usin a Are ac.frt) a� b q the course y a de, who may also tact as i trapper,. ,� e' are 'k aper. 7.hla�r' xCS nciia�ledgeable and halo' e;kperience wit't - s� f;'phLe Rulez, of the -ourse are printed otz the score each p,Errson gets each tune tlYey i t7me to s;ho�St�wRard '��`irxich An Unwilling to observe theruleof disregarYone ds 'the "; f of others aril], not be al:l owed to use our facilitie ;� sety � Th'ia locatioa't oF'the sporting 'cla;rs course was c'hoo. en wi1:h the sper.ific intent to Jsr,iai3O the shooting from neig'hbo+xa,,, E;txture plans include a ri,f le Lange and an archery rour�;ej: Targets on the archery rctursE� will be surrcu,nde� by tight g - g erally located,. in a corridox' through. bru�shW c�TheseTarElas Still als�b be su ervi� club f' P "fed af�icia,t,s and bo cezatra] l jr loca-�.ed by F'or the Convenience of the hunters, wie also plan to Oamp ng, RV facilities, ,ind -4,,1l:odge. The lodge y, 'have, serve as an office area land tSrovide a resting foto W� huers area We plan to contact our n:,igh}Sors and invite them to shard! their ideas and 'opinions:. WFC ha'Ve met a few nei a.nd most have had a o� ghbos p rLtive °v►.ett of our, operation. A major �� ;, ! 3ar concern to u9 all i.: p p y g o p danger and distructi�n cif x'o est We hope to $avtara g ` .�.. � shi ';� good wark�.n relation '4rith our neighbors. We V91,Cofne 'their sug5?�uf.;�.;s ,and a + •+ {.i:J' U 41 +art i r4 "'� �'t c � . f � 1' have attached seinech .i htSpCi will be Itelpfui. Included is a copy f5f the Club rules, a road' Map and a topographic map. Virginia. Ber6.`Iun.d, set.retary 'S 1 r. I \ - i. II"_u�5_, ,, ����. .• i as S7_. �11.��� `-lt ,4�` ' � ` n � f 1 . DUTCH RA'VIM SPORTSMEN'S CLUB� (916)-589-4257 Club Rules & Information 1. All, hunting;' reservations to be made at ,lease 24 hqOrd in advance. No shows will be charged for tVq;;Jbi.r:ds for each species of bird they have reservations for. Non guided deer hunters need not make reservations, The c:lU j,rill be open 6 days per week for pheasant, quail, and chukar hunting. Deer and Turkey hunters can hunt "I days per week during their respective seasons. We 'Vill be closed Tuesday's, Christmas and New years 2. I,'' hunters will check: in �.,t headquarters 'prior to huntintr, and sign the daily register. All hunters must cheCk in at headquarters aft iar 'hunting and sig;, out, even it no game is taken 3- All hunters and sporting ci.ays participants will sign and date a Participants Agreement before engaging in eithoe, sport. All hunters under the age of 18 must be. accompanied by an adult.. 4. Any hunter caught taking a bird and not reporting it at headquarters, will immediately lose all..A'untinq rights and forfeit the remaind�.r of his or her birds. 5 Any hunter shooting- a bird' that he doesn l t have a f pay tap individual bird price plus oie dollar"', card Sor wi:L]. a 6. There will be a limit: of 4 huntees per 40-bird card, jf•; 3 hunters per 20-bird card and 1-hunter per ltd 'bird card,rt, 7. There will be two �buftttnq periods each day, a inornf%g period beginning At, 8:00 and ending at noon and an aftotnooft period beginning n�t 1:00 and ending at 5.-00. These hu`ating periods' do not pertain to deer and turA.ey huri''ters They may hunt the legal hdurs designated their spat. 8 Bird cards alonq with a snap dif the ptopeity will be waiting for you oh the day Of your fir;:t hunt';. v J , 9 No' ihdividual under the , hfluence of an i, toxica°tjng b evera,e or drug will be permitted to hunb oar slxoat 'ott the premises. „ I 1Q' All pheasants released willbe 50% roosters and 509' and all members are 'hens. :rt:rtis legaa�PrOximat:ely :.x^pected to do o shoot hens so. 11. `there is no limit on the can be "takEn, but if number of pheasants you want for the da You have shot the numbthat him out of the field. Please leash Your number of bids dog and take 12. Pheasant. Bobwhite per bird released. Ouail and ChUkar will be , chargdd,, 13„ Any hunter usin and is nter,feriri with a dog that cannot to leave it h:nsistshoOther hunt e ers be controlled, n still usin ' will be asked Ing the dog, 14 All hunters except T,urce' article of Fluox`escent Oran ey hunters', mush d wear. vest; panta', etc. 9 while in the fielsome (hats A 25% deposit: -will hold until July 1st. Said depositYour bird card or under certain Said shall be refundedcards (to be determined Y on1 in by managemdff.j }1,, i� All hunting on the such a manner as is consistentsw J be coed Practices and not; in an uct;ed cause in ur Y fashion that will. hunting J Y to another individual or the potentially 17 • All Wild No _ pret�tises . ts within 7 days ofgconfirmingcthendatrequire refurdab] e but can be lie os $100 deposit transferred to Deposits aren + t 184 All rif,Le and another date, Pistol hunt,; are Guide fee' is included ire the guided burrs, be no guided if Ptcide. Bow hunts cah the price of. the anima ntr so You can deduct :$so prom you Fant to hunt l 19,'or the taking of Wi1.d hogs and Exot rifles .243 ,minimum, ics we powder 45 call recommend F% Pistols x 357 magnum minimunj, .'b . mum and bows shbuld be mini 15 mi r�imumpoll . 2d Mei;l�ocis o� talon i , Sbandin g Exotic.s ana Ws 1 d Hogs: choice is Yoltrs. or hunt out of a 04 veniclet t1j g, gree stands tine° �(, W�� take' Cdre �2 1 fief of field dressi.hg (unless 0 dress ) and YOU wish f],nsld fir all Your Own) hunts; getting aniina'1s out f the y ;t N - U \. It 4 �, .... , ,-7777 77 ,l 2z , ng Of their tchoicevyanday�i�hr 'cYear�c.e a� an exotic hied specie6i Putt the animal n the.'" pportunit ' ; • caurre"asIl Y to decided not to do sof"ol: missed +till be Y long hunt'.,bttt $50r9uides char e fee only.,, g d the 23. 130V hunters on a non -guided; hunt have days to take the animal ,ro of thein choice,r;u 3 euct�eetin taking Your animal in rt.his time days wi 1 you don i t . cost 5 y» a 'You $2� per da period a3ditfi�,�,�x�1 24. if ttoti Pied in ;advance the airpor tree of we will pick YOU char e. up at g Chico and Oroe vill» are.Just minutes .from the club. atrpri�b 25» Please mace all chec;ss Sportsmen's C paYa:ble to Dutch lub. Send checks Raine to rd.,OrOviller CA 9596.6 113 Bazeord Gulch f if You are serious about You g�• quality r hunti,t g1 T Your deposit in, boca su e number because+ there are a gg_st`. o£ big game animals and limited and they wil), 9eme birds go fast. available ,t. 'l r ;, 77777 el SEASON'S & 'BAG LIMIT S Dove ----------- Sept`.1 to state closing date! Pheasant------ October l to March 15 ---no .limit Bobwhite Quail -Sept. 15 to March 1.5 no limit Chuica'r-- Sept. 15 to March 15 no limit Va11ValleyQQuail-»--re Wild y,_w,--regular state season -state bag limit i Quail—regular Y gu'lar state fall, and spring season-- stat0i bag limit Deer-.------w----.regular state season -state bag limit ZONE D-3 Wild'Hog---A----Open year round Limit one per day Exotj.c Sheep & Goat. -open year round Sporting Clays, -open year round PRICES VOR THE 92,--93 SEA ;Old PHEA:>ANTS QUAIL CHUKAIT 1-9 birds $21eio- 1"9 birds $9ea, :1�9 biitr"dd'1.2ea. l' 1.0•- x?irds $185' 10 birds $85 10- birds i1.0 20- birds $32.0 20�- birds $140 20- birdtj 000 40 birds $600 40- birds $260 40- bitdg ;;360 DEED WILD TURKEY VALLEY $500 per person good $200 per bird nn--guli,de $75 pedk'oay per for bow & rifleseas on $50 per clay for guide person' $150 trophy fee ' for 2211 good for entire fall spread or better or ;spring season COXOTE WILr1 MUGS $50 peg day per_ $$32:6 -razorback rings Goats•'�ear person $ 0"0-russian hogs 8panish=-1390 All rifle anal pistol, hunts for exotics and Sheep: Lid hogs are guided hunts. Guide fee is Cor sicar���d�i0 included in the prise, 'deduc't $50 for ;non- Mouflon- --T. 00 -up guided bow' hunts Barbados-� 0$0 Four Horn-�00_u l DOVE - $30 per person per season i lDa1.1..........--..����00-up SPORTING CLA%S-,'x'15 per 50 bird rnd, i$25 per 100 bird rnd. fl TRAINEDddq andt�hand er-25 per half-day Dog boardiJk4 -$!;, :per day $160 per mantle �y Recrea %�tinaY Ven cle parking" $10 per day,. Day use --6010 PAhftihgi swimmir g, picknicki-nq -$5 pei `Vohj;cld k $... , � 9 ¢ l 1 1 son-�..tt°• 1 � ' lj� %�,�:.��„r `�,..,� G,79, ... �`` jo 0 � C ;a N, Ir, PLANNING DbIV1SI0N EEPAbThaCNT 0 DL'VELo0mvyT SEh'v("6g ' 7 COUNTY CE14TEFI DRIVE . O1i0VILLE, C 07 TELEPHONE, ALIf`�f�itJ(A• +�;i7` NE, IsiG)s3a.7061 _ Batch Ravine Sportsmen's Club 0 FAX' (oga) 638:770!; •. Blazeford Gulch Road October 1 Or°vil:le Ca 95965 r 1992 Re. Hunting Club AP 028-170-028, AP 028=-320-003 AP 072-330-016 and AP 0072-8301"018 Dear Ms. Berglund, During anPPi n h•ttn l. `' this a 4 ling you question6 �: o; - .'-lasants d cvtaa 4x1 a or :he subject Property. Quail, and Chukars � !lot, Cf� �� My in ti al L e8 r, ul'd be an al lowed. us`eG ,1'J type are not ung^orttmon on the dgr agricultural Wigs that Cl xbs ' and th t Ag�:ir �.�l, a��J' I t P ra.l land f this rw hones rovzdA g� n the �a11ey, for Hunt,., Um < A'11Aately, the h h Clubs, ---Vicultur<al) Zone which/ onproperty is in Zones has no located _ ate' provision for hunting C uhsrt wotal 20 zoning violation to ';have a. , d the efor q -?til' incl riding Pheasant t unt�ng Club on th • �Al We also discuss Quail. or Chu..ar. subject propatty sub 'ect propert ed amending gyour application ' t#>+„ y from the requested A20 (�!�gricu� t>r rezoning,� (Foothi.11 Residential) zone -hick conuideration of a Use pe would 1) to a &�4' if apgrov6d ,., property,. As soon as rMit for a Recreation �. 'aciZ:i dllo Ith' received we %, your transm t :a request xt y °n t f r ll continue processing ,g the Shan e1 meantime you are requested to cease use appl�.I�atig. g i, g the commercial huntingand shootincr ux °f the ern ife. the zoning Ordinance P Poses which are i ope�H�y klde in Vi°1rat1�11, �t Sincerl,y, B.A. Kircher Planning Director Code 8Af6rcm0hti Ali ;r �1 • Kr BN.�w . 1/q wr L} ,*JD 0 1`1ATURAL WC-ALTH AN46,i A5AUT PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - ORQVILLt, CALIFOW4,4§944'0397 TELEPHONE; (016) s3e•7001 .9�eptember 30, 1992 - Randy D. McMain 1.1.3 Rlazeford Gulch Rd. proville, CA 95966 i RE Rezone, File 93-08 on AP# 028-170-028 etr' Dear Mr: McMain: 'Chis ; to notify you tha4t we have received your application for a Re2onn from A-5 to+ 20, on property located on the north and south sides of Swedes Flat Rd, approx 1 1/1 miles east of Oroville-Bangor 'Highway, Oroville, identified as AP# 028-170-028 etc, ocential e �.>;t �n>tial study of p - mental consequences anticipated in connection wlfJI nviron. this protect tis bmng Oompleted by the r3utte County Planning Department and will M forwarded to your Should you have any, questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact this office: Sincerely 'B.A Kircher iDir ""tor of Planning Lisa ,Purvis Wilson Planning Technician BAK LPt�-t i l�t ` g r n �I/a%lf w tie ....sem . DIRECTOR'S OFFICE DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES' 7 COUNTY CENTLH DRIVE • ORIOVILLE, CALIFORNIA TELEPHONE: (916) 639.7601 FAX: 19161538-7785 Oept ember 23, 1992 140- Virginia Berglund t 112 Blazeford Gulch Road OWOV111e, CA 95956 '+» Rezone Application and Violation hP#026--170-028, 028-320-008, 072-930-015 and 072-3.1,0 V64r Ms. Be r(lutd t ��t',��a Esutte County' Department o Development Services :has r`eceive,c�,, 7-Atr letter dated September 14, 1992 regarding the D"dtch '!Za*,rine g 0p;�rtsmen's rrlui�. After, reviewing ' the uses 4W 'a parcel located off Swedes Fla Road, wephapesconclor youthh ZdAyl of the proposed uses :are riot allowed within any of the y �� �t;canc:Ll.tngt u, ral zones (A-5 through- A-16,0) Vle art e itf rirtf Yo u o inion so that you may reconsider your application orpraor to proceeding f further. ere a may be other zohi-tj r districts that would Provide for your intended .use such as she .r Qddt.hill Recteaf:ional) district. Subject to obtaining approval -, use p i.t from the Planningcommission Or' BoardGofdSuaerviso,rs upon appeal), thE, FR district p p cammercial huntitig lodges. You can easily amend mxsoas allow d should you wish t:o follow 'this course. your ai5p;l iccrxtia ;his "tattler is also to i,nflorm you that the commej;cia1 huntiric des of Your PtOPertY apparently re as�comriter'�c4an:y se keet or tapshotirig or now in �rtargetrrangeand uarIS such oBar1 r e with the existing A-5 zotihq designati YO -Air property. Accordingly, you are hereby requested to ion o Imedia�tely ease use of the property for commercial. hunting and s C7rat rig ptirpoSes wh' dh are, 1n violation "Of the zoning ordinancr�v .� �t�tc4 of code �►.` r � ' Jolatlon Is being sent under 8apara,te Cover w 'thi:lz the last woek We have received several. Verbal and writteli; CObPl.airits about t:he curten' and planned uses of our A number o �rOur ziel.ghbors a � y property. _ddres...ed the Board of Supervi`sor;;> today during the public comment 4.ridd commercial humin o , r j r generally objecting to g your property inow, and to any rezoning thai't wduld allow such to cantinue, Undoubtedly, this letter will y ki 11 ® yyyqyfy �� w � � / �/ 2 �7QV@lO�irl�►�( IR'iTl I��i9A �. t6unty, eitteri r� ;� SSP .319 �''' M -r tr ur parcel N4, Sept,<f29e or 11r . Farre 3 l y `THOS letter is to inform You of the situation on Swedes Flat 'Rac, ;,se s rrr�ately 6tl days ago a bus,,Aless Opened on Swedes°Flat ad,iac:ent t ,`�G1:up` M►'rel, Wa enclose a. brbH�hure from the Glub, They opened thii` Dutch Raving tsman s Club in violation of the ..4-b zoning For the acreage; their pat'ce x are 02,.,-320 Do$,, 32rj acres, 028-M-028, 201,-,15 acres; ti72-S3t1wOS6, ����� 4i— esj and 072-330.0:13, i7q acres;* Last week Dutch Ravin, $por*ts,-7an Club appl ied fog`' ,a ,coning change to A-261 : - � a Vibich world allow then to continue the enter risia p�, s p would stipulate f-isX mitigations D.R.SAC, tgoulidtbe forcedtoe �..� permit —vkR for aur safety, including 4nre and property insuranceq fencing, and tt iephene & water storage in case 04 a fire.) q# course, we oppose such a %&,A and we believe the aforer,..entioned mitigations are neces.sei*y frac aur fetY i* they are to continue ire business* kot%er concern is the intention of D*P.,S,C. to import non indioenaus speri!e "s the parcels, such AS L%beep, goats, wild briar and tethers, Tho,zii would be --leased to; later be hunted on tine property;. We believe this Is .� bad idea ti�*t c wld result in, escaped animals a?dangering the habitat and feeding of the dein+' other indigenous species.. Tho acreage 4s in the crltical winter range of twe deer, as Outlined ;by Butte County~ Osoj Swedes Plat Road is a conco,t,A, recOtving as it does so little �r ,a�t_rrance it is alread;e showing scans o4 de•torioration die to the traffic f;ur�r°ently a tease and De p . „. , �� Desist order is being prepared for b R S C through Ai0 s city zoning officoal Dill Farrel•, His li is 538-760tr 8:000 best time to c l r -PP s". We bel-erre the Club rira/ violatethe cease & desis{ order, to arty J olations you see occuH ng should be brought to his attention, As an adjacent property'ownerx you will be pati -fieri by the County rlgardir� tie proposed zone change within 6 months. t4antime hunting season starts ept,2t5th, aid we suggest you use caution wPten using your property as ,high"' Pa, r3rtci rifle shells may traVP ',� miles you require any further information, please contact Jean Simard a� (�' r 12510-1384, We will also be, addressing the Board of Supervisors Oct, .6th at IMAM- YOU are welcome to attend �• r_ �'ha�t'au, ,, °`dean Simard cane t. ons rx Iry K icier Pike 1'le1 kce a, car 8113 Farrel, Butte County PlaraninS Department'' r ,1r , e �Rr low Tr `Z"�5 t fte '/ Oaf; l.owj5 '4i's �� ..ems ��7.�+"d'(i/ � • Q.i" 70-029 r ase � ?� Mrs . 1�r•; , _ 4� Palma Grantham 2,41!V Gardenside Lang ';'ir rorty r no Cal 1 fora i s 95014 t,e:w Mr >♦ & Mrs, Grantham 1 L: a.2a Noessi er' . 13 Pikerby California 95 7 �'? 17fi- 046 $ C2C-170-089 Ms* Moessl erg d x & Eunice Glover * e,, 31 '��sjrgdr Cal Hornia, 95019 '.Por Mr. & mrs, (?lover �,Pr- ge & Elaln ,Poeger w5-49 Soeger Ln. �"a q Jose California 95140 eae Mr., Ax Mrs. Roege,w ;:a ani Montgomery ZJ'15 Kin-9, Pd St, i sbano California' 94005 -0-1 013 ti ��ear ads. Montgomery 5 C1 nl�osrburYRachel Lan� l�aKernan aaest Callfc+rnla 953�5ti C,Stfi Mrs. & kers Wakeman .. :�ai'res � Shirt;e� ��+�l7.ansen �� l�iueraiew br itle California 95965 5> Mr, & Mrs Johansen AL e &Cue t)eLong tr,"9$0 Magdelema Aire L?:�s Alto Hills California Ce'ar Hi�f & Mrs D#Lora Vii? c Lettie Mann �= Chlrrese Wall Rd C70v i l 1 e 95966 California 04 15e'w' mr+ & Mrs Man1` nCeverlY Ouinh �y ( U r 1 u �ryyA'�Al, a OT, Dellar 7,77 �I 4' 1Uhu"O'l tpad i)j a q Q' 4807,, L.ocuiA S ar Mr . Pad l I i a 9 !,am NcDonne11 .Ar 269 ,� OPOm O l e 95985 California i Mr. McDonnoll '.'W'Ohn Hassler Oa 1 1 1 or4n l a 95667 l r u "`°' ' < .1"op +danh� imt�m�nt #9 Dutch Ralri;n.e Sportsmen s Club :113 Blazeford Gulch Road groville, Ca Butte. County Planning Department At the request of Craig Sanders, I submit the following information .regard ng the operation and plane of Dutch Ravine Sportsmen's Club. The area in which we have our hunting club is JOCatecl approximately '15 miles southeast of Oroville. Tt is fou#r large parcels connected together torm,i.ncr an g42.acre, I piece. It is divided by Swedes Flat Road: with appxoxa.matej 160 acres on the south side, the remainder on the north, Side of 'Swedes Flat Road. It is our intention to offer a sale, supervised area in which to hunt and shoot,with clearly marred boundaries to protect other property ovilers from trespassers -anal unsupervised bunting and roaming. Because of the shod; time we haye owned the property and the size, our improvements of fencing and brush clearing are barely started. We intend to progress with these plans as our first priority. The larger portion of the property is to be ]eft undeveloped for huntir.,g, fishing; and photographic tours We'plan to clear the thick brush in order to reduce, fire danger and encourage a natural environment for wildlife. This part of the property will be fenced and the boundaries posted so hunters will knot exactly where our property ends: 'The access roads have sound gates with: �cica to prevent unauthorized entry. Futther we pian `-u-.,.Ihave a Caretaker in permanent resideftde to insure no one violates our property or uses our property to access surrounding areas: Trespassing is a problem for all of us as seen in the dumping of garbage, old carsr and other materials we have foUhdon the property, on the smaller portion we have developed a 10 station sporting clays course. This course is intended to i ;provide members With a safe place to pracice,hunting $kills and allow us to evaluate a persons gun--:safety, habits. At each station, stands are used which limit, the target area and all shooting dust occur 'from tYtese stands. All members using the course are accompanl6 by a guide, who may also act as a trapper. Those people axe knowledgeable and have experience with gut safety. Mules of the course are printed on the score card w]Yich each person gets each time they come to shoot., Anyone unwilling' to observe the rules, or disregards the safety of others will not be allowed to use our facilities. The location of the sporting clays course wac choosers with the specific intent to isolate the shooting -ftom neighbors Vuture plans include a rifle range and an archery course!: Targets on the archery course will be surrounded by tight bales of straw and will be generally located in a corridor through brush. These areas will also be supervised by club officials and, be centrally located. For the convenience of the hunters, we also plan to have camping, RV facilities, and a lodge-'The lodge may also serve ,as an office area and provide a restirig<<yarea for hunters. We plan n to contact our neighbors and invite thettl to share Wtheire lideas and opinions, We have met a few neighbors and most have had a positive view of our operation,, A major concern to us all is fire danger and distraction of proporty, We hope to have a good working rel,at:i'onsh iii with our neighbors, We WbIcome their I ha ,f attache6 some 1 'hope Dill be helpful# xneluded iz'i a copy, of the Club rulesr a road map and a topographic map. 'U'i;rgir�i.a l�e�gl.un.d t Sc��rotary DUTCli RAVINE SPORTSMEN'S CLUD (916)-589-4257"' Club Rules & informrttion Ali hunting reservations tj:) be made at least,' 2q %o�Axs in advance. No shows will be charged for taro birds for each species of bird they have reservations for. Non guided deer hunters need not erservations. The club'will be open 6 days wt fcrpe, quai1, and chukar hunting. Deer and Turkey hunters can Bunt 7 days per week during their respective seasons, We will be closed Tuesday's, ctnrist,mas and Nehw years. 2. All hunters will check in at headquarters prion to, hunting and sign the daily register. All hunters riust' check in at headquarters after hunting and sign if no game is taken. out, even 3. All hunter's and spotting p g cla s Y participants wi1:1 sign and date a Participants Agreement before engaging in either sport,: All hunters under the age of 18 must be aceompahiec by an adult. 4Any hunter ryaught taking a bird and not .reporting it at headquarters, will. immediately lose all hinting ri ghts and forfeit the remainder of his or her birdso Any pay g e a f 5, An.' hunter shooting a bird that:'I' unesn t ha'v, card for will a to individual bird price plus one d,alJ arra r �. There will be a limit, oper 40-,f 4 hunters .bird card, � r� hunters per 20-bird card and 1-hunter per 10 'bird card. 7 These Will he to ri hunting per3ods each day,, a morningl���� � 9 `, g period beginning at 8.00 and ending at noon and an afte.rnoo�` period beginning at. 1,:00 and ending at 5:00. These periods d-� - iot pertaih to deer and turkey hunters. ".Trey may hunt the legal hours designated their sport,, t3 13 L-eti c�ard'o along with u map o� the property V4-.1 .,., ti wa.i 1�ing' for yd`u on the day of your first ill ukit ti, , 9 No'ihdividual under the influence of all intoxicating beverage or drug evil be permittr I to Mint ox shoot an the premises. 1QAll Pheasants released will be a 50°t roosters and 50% Yrens. It is legalt:Q',IAni�tey and all members are expected to oot 'hens dorso. iJ. There is no Limit on the , can be takM�n, but i int mber of Pheasa,nt%s that You have shot the number of `birda YOU . toant ft�r the day, please .Leash your him da ottt of the field. g and take 12. Pheasaint Bobwhite Quail and c1au Per bird re,].eased. H;ar 'will be charged 1.3. Any hu.gter Using a dog that cannot be controlled, and is interfering with other hunters w3.1.1. be asked to leave if he insists an stili users,the dog, `�. All hunt(hrs except Turkey hunters, must; weG.r article of fluorescent so Orange while in the f me vest, pants, Etc.) field.;, (hats 1.5. A 25% deposit wi1.1 hold 1, until Ju]y l.st• y birdrd caox Said deposit shallrefunded only be under. ceri;ain circumstances (to be determined by managemejj.&)4 10• All hunting on the premises shall be conducted ill such a manner as is consistent with good huriti rg .' practices and not in any fashion that will potentially, cause nju�y to another individual or the premises 17. All Wild Hog and 9xotic hunts require a_ within 7 days of confirming the deposit date* Dbpo8$�00 refundable but can be transferred to t anotheridate. t A11 rifle and pistol hu;fits are Guide fisc is included to the guiddSj hunts. be non Prict. how .lunts `guided if you watch► so can the Price of tape. alli:mal You can deduct $50 from You want to huht, 1' 19, i:or the taking of Wild hogs and Bxotics We rifles 243 minimum, pistols :35 i magnum m nitnumYeblacicnd ,powder 45 cal, miri�imum and howb should be 450 minimum pull 2'i7• Methods of: taking Hxotics and Wild Ho" Standing, tree stands or hunt -out of aX4gvehicel:3ng, choice is yours. , the 21. We fates care of field: dressing unless to field dress }your own) and getting animalsyouttvaihh Pied far all guided hunts. e SEASON r S & BAG LIM:CT i S Dove"­!-­ ­--Sept. I to state closing date Pheasant:-_- W_--October I to March 15--no limit t-Sep;, i5' to March 15 no limit to March 15 no limit; Val.loy Quail--,-re1 ular state season-state I4ild q'ur.'}'6v--- reclular state fall limit and spring bald �fmit season- Deer.----,- Deer.----,-___-----:regular• state season-state bag ZONL D-3 � imit Wild 14og--.___---0 e,n year round limit one pe I;xotric Sbee P r day p & Goat-open year round Sporting Gays-open, year round PRICES FOR THE 92--93 SEASON PHEASANTS QIIAY'L CRUKAR 1-9 birds :�21ea .. 1_9 'birds $9e;j 10- birds $185 10- birds $'85 1-9 bird4§ f A20a . 20- birds $320 20- birds $140 X70-- birds $'600 40- 10- bird'g 20- birdo ;b birds $?,CSO 40- bi.rds� �y�a,0 WEER YLIA TO1tftTsY q A j $500 per pc'_rson,yoocl $200 per biro 1�` �"'-. no-guideYlILLEY � for bow & rifle seac;on $50 per day For guide $75 per dRy ,per :$150 trophy fee for 22" g spread or bobber good, for entire fall person or spring season COYOTE WILL) HOGS $50 per day pe;ri3XOTYCs-f£fa $325-rat0rbac7( m hunts r .person hogs $400-rust,ian hogs g Goats. Span p t AI.1 rifle atui p�.stol iaua2ts for exotics aril gild hogs ax1E► - ed Angora-_$3'§ She . �� de fee is. Includedp . hunts. I1UI1� , C''�io �iD.x' zncZui�eci an the 2'xce, 5 CoYisican�'y 21011...-» waded bow IjUnty Moxflo �.:. I3arbadas �»� AOvD -. • .$ P'pe 30 R a per season _� Four Bern $� 0Up 'rson SPORTING CI;Ai';5-$15 peer 50 bird rhd. $25 pear ,100 bird rnd: [ ' TRAINED dog a.nld hairit7l6r.- 25 Per hamonday Dog boarding-,$'6 Q-'$ per dal $160 th , Rdcteational #0hicie ptlxrldnq- $10 per da , Day use-gold y" x►arinitlg, swmmin Jr pielcnic""hg-$5 "vehicle per I r� t �fn'I. a ;". MI LL NO.: 93.08 Duvrt CLUN y P I=ANNiNtr COMMISSION S'PA "P FLNi Y,TNGS - November 30, 1992 /APPLICANT: Dutch Ravine Sportsman's Club O't%4'11'(IJTi Same RE, QUI+rST. Rezone from A-5 to FR -40 AP NO.: SIZE 028-170-028, 02&:!20-003; 072-330,0164 .01$ 840+ acres ` LOCATION; On both sides of approximate) Swedes Olaf ,:��rad, Y f.5 miles east of Oro=B44)$or Higi�way EXISTING �ZONINGi A-5 :'{JIVING -HISTORY» ZONING. -Y T Zoned A-5 on gran. 27' 1910 b ' Olid, �� I.t SURROUNDING A -S S►URR0UN1ji1NG LAND USE: ;SITE HISTORY: Opelp 'and and rural residential tares ' GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Agricultural-Residenfial APPLICABLE REGULATIONS: Butte County Code Sections 24.26 through 290 24-72, arid 24-112.8, COMMENTSRF[`rTC EM-. r` Public works: ' None 4 i r' I BUTi'E COUNTY PI ANNTIiiG COMMISSION STAI'F FINDINGS - NQvemb.30, 1992 )&_e a artme t: "No Fire Deifartmientobjections." nviro mental Health, No oby tions to the rezone. Any land divi �� " � sons CountySubdivision Ordinance." must meet Bette ,14�iosqu to Abatement: "No foresee e,'. ie problem." L 'This .is al request to rezone approximately 840 acres from A-5 to FR -40; The i , e' p6 t ty is B outheasbry,rn foothills of the County on bath sides of Svyedes Flat Rt ' , A-xst of '�c located te ang chkighway, The current zoning is A-5' which the current General Plan Policies. The property Was adopted in 1970 aricl;��clates 8 to 480 acres': The 22 Conti ovs is surrounded by parcels of varyinig s l ,r 1`a'oin parrc:els average 79+ acres in size. This project will result in a zoning �haf is more consistent with the General Planthe existing A-5 zone. The A-5 zone was adopted tin 1970, 9 years before the curp6l�� rent tet al Plan adoption in 1979, and does not meet the conditional development criteria Of the Agricultural Residential designation for 'parcels less than 20 acres. The current zontfi' fiat consistent with the General ]Plan and gives pro e potential for their roe property owners a false sense of dere ) Inciat uses. For a property, rty' and is further misleading because the area is not sYri�a for 6—r` zoning P with C the rAgricultural ' Residential t General Plan designation 1 size less than 20 acres to be ccafi�7>�tent present: the foll�w,ng criteria rtjw�>i W 11 Compatible with neighboring agrictitk &il activities. 2• Evidence of adequate water and „ ,d dispot al capacity: L, . Availability of adequate fire protection facilithlz 4dequatej'y ,maintained approved rr A access with suffi`ciTnt capacity' to service 5• :.Reasonable accessibility ` 'lity to commercial services and schools. Criteria 3, d, and 5 are clearly not present and Criteria is quCtst onabLe. The tonin . to cons,,ler .are as follows• g fCots 1, Existing parcel sixes in residential densities. 2. Slope Soil condition's and Water availability rr 1JI<J'I`M COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION TAFF FINDINGS - November 30, 1992 4, Effects on adjacent uses, crap production, livestock grazing, forestry, resource 6&#,0ion and wildlife habitat. L'roximity to public roads and other public facilities. 6, Distance from airports, railroads, and industrial uses: i, Existing utility and drainage facilities. $, Potential for surface -.racking, landslides and erosion. 9.; Effects on noise, traffic flow and safety, water quality, air quality, wildlife hafitlf and general environmental quality; 10. Local desires: 11. Potential for pest insect breeding. In addition to the listed zoning factors, it must also be noted t '` ` Gated that this property :is', �� within a designated critical winter deer range where the California Department of Eft ;gnd Came are recommending parcels of 40 acres or greater. The applicani has made it clear that their ultimate goal is to establish a commercibl (#tldoor -recreational facility un -site which will include a hunting club, a sporting clay shooting WA.Ose, arifle range, archery course, and possible some Vamping and RV spaces 'with 'd t;Wptral clubhouse or lodge. This is the first step. in pursuing this goal since the A 5 zone do#§ not have a proviso^ -ii, for this type of use, Under the FR -40 zoning an outdoor coirirlt0ia1 recreation use requires a use permit. The applicants were already prepared to allow ph,6A. sant, quail, chukar, and deer hunting on-site this season. However, concerns from nearby erty owners prompted the Planning Division to instruct the property owner to stop hunfttig "Until proper zoning and a use petniit were obtained. The Commission should not allow tfi� 1,ssue of the hunting club to be the' (acus ' of this application) this is a rezone and approval of this project shall have no+ bearing on the outcome of a future use permit applicatto y kr an outdoor recreation facility other than to give the property owner the right to apply tot ,said use, Based upon the 'OeneralPlan policies and criteria and upon the Department of 'Poli and Game policies the proposed zoning is more appropriate for the area than the A-5 zotl`. WECOMNIELO)ATIQNSI. A. Find that the requirements of CEQA have been completed and considered in Making' this decision and adopt a Negative Declaration regarding environmental impact§t and 3' _ .x Richvale Hwv: '162 Fp ~~ _ Q > )V \\ 62 -4 > up`� rot,��� o�b��j t °'�L �N'Y. O �,, °rb y� LN, ey , II14 V r 4 AIRF1011 ' Midget + t ;,I _ t II1' �: � ;�, � � � I w�. � Mt. Id l iy `r 'Ro��tpwn * ,:�i`�`51 1 74 •r�;11 ;•,I p ��+ a Rd, - Olive �, r' Creel, MI abe fid. 3 � ' t:i. v ilU�iL�CCihI Bl oadj , Lu m t t. Cr + plu -, Ba�go W rhnentx hili,,,,.-x� 9a� act Thermalito �. u. m b e O,, pc / Butte City ��,; '��q Hinhwav t�f �rS� � t'r Jt �fi' �� T�Ir�� ��,`' ' � �i�,. � 'r 162 r�1t:;rba 1 .'. 'Kv» >J geg°� w r VOT1t Fss 1. Rf�T�gT L64,4 iON Ophir srload o°� as �'^off V61- 2 W. Harnillan ` ast �cc I , �QD:Rd.E Hamilton WMIX Road ° i. I Q alt rr j. • �.` Vance C Avon AItT`A , ,t'1 w ` ,'tea essina d° �a•,yf otjn p rr 1' Swodes i^Inf .« . lioad .o t— ��x E ~ Rio i t Welsh _3 3 ' F;o 'o`�cv� GtWjs Road i D :N O �ohca �� r'�i++�/bRitt;liy _ _ ry to N '{ i Gi d: Pelotmo ° ad w� a� -1 enit Roan o ,o rCc Walnut r.. , m °c` 5� ViliaAvQ.. r3��• 'Ell, 17t ¢:� a::•+j,c� �» v ° tour< `u d Festv« Hixs Doty treet •� i, s I yAlice �� .-;• 1 ,Z v s� �i �Q d , akotao Hwy Ave: i t(� 9 At av Ranch Rd. raig Av,Q�lCIV` ° O a Ch Itort- Q t 4, t 1 t A fd th Rd,' Palm the WY N.'. 1.on 1 Woe = > Q a ti7� , -93 .1krry ( cn o Hastin t N rake Almond'I ircle G Ava. r,a { Q Avocado po : Farris °� > tEe ad,. Va, Mri �,t W Pryda Ave. R ch Rd., , o11 Roads ¢ South m ora. ° t to Ave. + Steadma Cr a,'� G<¢Q�'': 0 a �'�0� o � Parka'if}!1 'o Jennifer Lane S m ° Or Ranch Q'°Rd. Q� Cox c o --y :h111 i �i .e Bose Ln nos§ Lanr3 ask �Chiocedo Prather fid. ,E Bangor 1o�io p; 'Vorle ` iiy�lr . .J 0a 1 Just son .9 AIdv, Sell 91 Mi ° Iv ' Mood -Lane �'`� / � � � � gtisb OFf )est ?��•�� .9 11 iCoiusa d, 'dle � N cY, o � � r `-�...•.1,�, i � o ` ... Grr Y Road; ►— a o RiNighWay +itiiut t s r,+ttr;t a c Q� Droblsha At`cher Ande son + : ,yin+tf +,nhld+ t S S •' ° v Rd o till Ave I _t ° e / Ober oyer �4OG a, u d \ G �N � ". � D � Cb �E:�N'c cz > t � � � Swain Fll) r� c u Ido > (ter. 3 Wait< �"—_ W � o b o , ° :`103 �• 5� a Hollis a Richards is � Central SHouia x � e ,� • ; � -t.. > tr W — , O'grton m I N _ d kettt; �a Road § �4 1` Peter cnAve. fJlolsen �+ In d <m; roI a W. Evans Y I W ) % t Dlivoru 21 Reimer WN ht .. re ter • ».,�� �'� °�^� 9R\J:Qp� d gg n. tL ., a Htc ti eimct Haag Jem Middle Ftonco Road {� a p, ill, oto ac o ° 'q , o c a E Rd, t Honcut .. i� N�'iUY br ,p G� °. ;�,r�s� osen+s 11t;l( �Q� Rodd 3 tr n Q.ocr ro �. riritlshd o $ vvntpPie aL a Nl—f Iti= opki oo Urnej Campbell ,4v© _ Lotvert r rY �ksunddua','�*�,' d ora C`re �' v �d•.c n s`." b �� . rte r N �i t'Giow Chandon Ava. „-'� ;cyg� �'...�= a p CDF. �, LucitehP Rd: c Sy�Q, �� aptn f/..." /t� y � M/ ':,«.' STA, .p m 6 ' a 6 t « `g Metteer R Laurel h'. ° .... ' 4ia}iic' 9ovanR oa e. vYrti�ttdA E/, nil o`"' '�•lRivie(ff o v�c �..It 4 Rica_ `, r „ a e�e..e hbndt3r V +, °a \v �o LOMA AICA Rd. � .. , o- Fru�t� it ►'vn+:../ \. It 16 cc r \ to'nla kd. VICINITY MAF RtANbY MCMC IN D,R..S,C: Rte DISTRIBUTION L.,IST FOR COMMENTS RESORUCE MANAGEMENT j�Oqunty Public Works unty Environmental Health State Water Resourced' j t* 'eounty Building Department U.S. Forest Service eLy of Biggs _ U.S. S . Bureau of Land Mafia! a hent of Chico _ Butte County Mining -tee amity of Gridley? State Department of F�a�4 Game icity of Oroville California Native Plant #00.tety '�'Iown of Paradise ;State. Div.. Forestry- ritj'# ltd on Planning Department Craig Carter tate. Transportation Department Regional Water, Quays (i6pjjt7'ol Bd { r <---7tjC WATER SEWERS Outte Rc.hvale Sanitary• _. Oalifornia�Waterrict Service Co. r�.fjist North Burbank Pub. Util� Del Oro Water. Co, Skansen Sub. (CSA #21) O- WID Stirling City Sewer mai:4', Dist, Thermalito Irrilgati6h District Thermalito Irr'gr'lt o» trict ,,Other U r1ra —mits IRRIGATION' .WATER -G&&E North (Chaco) Biggs-TAT. GVidl,eyy Water 64.9trict PG&E South (Marysville) Butte. Water District !, P"acific Bell Durham Irrigation Distik 0t ;State TV Cable OWID Viacom TVCable Paradise. Irrigation DigtVCt Richvale irrigationgDio:7iot ZIL?E -PROtECTioN Table Mountain irri ai xldl) Dist 7 Zl Medio Fire Protection Dist. Thermalita Trrigat,on tpotrct f county Fire Department/CDF DRAINAGE DISTRICT 2403iDUITO.ABATEMENT DISTRICT Durham, Oroville or Butte County RECLAMATTOil DTSTRTC' POLICE: PROTECTION _ state Highway Pa- 1,91 ,` county Sheriff OTHER COMMITTEES/COMMIsS'TONS BCHOOL AIBTRICT RECREATION,rAfTLITXES Paradise Pines Architeot 'a n i ct Control committee k Dist, DurhamAAreaRRed, & Park � Butte 'County Farm Bureau, Vdath&park.Dis er River Rec, & Pakk Dist,Community Association; Paradise �:'se Rec. & Park D3.'st. Richvale Rec. & Park Dist. State Parks & Red Dept. f - "� fiuc, �d 611111112 ttf{r �'tr as X -A BUT Co 'Y P1aANN ,•- COMMIS q 2NG r q 7 County Center Drive • e 397 ,4 fi Orovllle CA 9S9G5-3 ' (91.5) 538-76011 +. TO: �(,l.l '(L C.AJ or rL-S DATE: 10-14.-92. RE; TRO,7mT REVIEW qtr .s dl. ENVIRONMENTAL preliminary a - - ' " .E..,VA 7 L�AJRandY D.`Pdfa tnclose.d 'is prelminarY data our office ceived � r genexa•�� doricerning' the following project> '" rom. A-.5 I2 - . .._ ��to �-�+0 �rfih and.south outh sides of Swedes Flat Rd. approx.' "1-'1/2 :miles east of n or Highway, 'Oroville. ; Y19 are making an assessment of possible env, rorunenta impact , -#W ll be preparing an environmental , docuMent either a Ne a6,tg: Dealar meet, Negative Declar.at on with Mitigation Measures o� ���� Eti�vironmental Impact Report (EIR) Please provide any fact, .Y , statements, ideas for invest3.gatioz aropinions you can offer in your azea of concern ore tuyr his relate to, either physical, social, or economic xmacttise project may regenerate -impacts thla cilli# t� a respond within 1� P � days of the above-,noted.date. .generated by thi a.n =f no 0.hat there * x��:r --�; gUity then it shall be as:: deed, :Pq' ficant environmental impacts which are; potential from the ; project. We appreciate any essist.ance you can provide., S.ncer�lyg " a Larry Pa er . 'Planning Technician Comments.*," - Does your agency vista to receive a copy of the enViroirimenta l docdment (initial study for Legative Declaration (with or without Mitigation Measures or E2R for this project) Yes NO r4 E COUNTY:PLANNINO COMM2S ' ,74 •. 7 County Center Drive ir Oroville, CA 95965=-3397 >' (916) 538-1601 tw o TO:bft DATE: 10-14-92 j �` e ,l116T oelik�f?ijkii�� RE: PROJECT REvlE�� ' H��r'xsd ENVIRC?1�iMENTAL WVAI,UAT'�;11()Jf Randy 1). McMainAVI a-U$ inclosed is preliminary data our office 2ias received or generat6d concerning the following project: _Rezone from A-5 to JM-40 located north and. south Bides of Swedes Flat Rd. approx,, 1 1/2 miles east of Orov�l�t� 2angox Highway, oroville. A We are making an assessment of possibleenvironmental impacts 61nd «gill bepreparing an environmental document, either a Negative Declaration, Legative Declaration with Mitigation Measures or ao Znvironmental Impact Report (EIR)_. Please provide any factual statements, ideas for .investigation; or opinions you can offer in your area of concern or expertise that relate to either physical, social, or economic impacts that this project may generate. 'lease respond within '14 duys of the above-noted elat ,r:ee. If no onse is p generated by this inquiry, then it shall be assumed that there are no significant environmental impacts which are ;potential from the project. 'We appreciate any assistance you can provide.. Sincerely, Enn try OCT15199 a P1a Hinga Technician DEPARTMENT Or 'FORE8TRY Comments,_ OUrTE COUNTY f Does your agency with to receive a copy of the environmental dodVinent (initial study for Negative JDeclaration (with or without .Mitigation`Measures) or El For this project) Yes No I �T zl� �'t�UNTY PLANNING COMMIES (9N , t'': Center Drive r ' tea:: a Or'024—M'e, CA 915965 .,338 7 538-7607. „- /1 i11'(Qnr1'f Yi �-u e-o-110-14-92 RE PROJECT REVIEW ENVIRONMENTAL EVAhI�A Randy. D. McMain,- ,-`93-08 .kz..: .... AP# 028-170-028 !closed is preliminary data our office 'liarreceived or genera' ! <:,dq%cernnc) the following projeGt. Rezone 'from A-S to XR-40 located- cv%" A n1rr.h and south sides of Sv.•addes Flat td._approx. 1 1/2' - hes wast of Oto ')'ep angor Highway, Orovil:le. ; Ve, are making an-assessment of possible environmental. impacts '11 ;be preparing an envirc.)nmental document, either ,a Negativa- Declaration, Ndgative Declaration with Mitigation Measures Orf**)) vironmental impact Report (EIA) �l.ease xarovide any :Factual statements, ideas for ix;vostigatior r r apiArion s you can off er in your area of co;.^cern or expertise that relate to either physical, social ax� a ;onomic impacts thA .s project may generate. 2lease respond withizi 14 days of theiL above-noted date. If; tJ � ^ ��13:YT CO_iJN7CX P PfTNO CONMISSIO rouziity'enter Drive Orovilllde, CA 95965-3397 ,t (9116) '-5381,7601 rt>a�l�t,Jo.r DATE: 9-30-92' RE' PROJECT REVIEW 6, ENVIRONMENTAL EVALt JtJ,,,9X t. Randy D. McMain 1, c ose API 020-170-028 0 d is preliminary data our office has received or ' genera�:��` a6ricerning the following project, Rezone from A -S to A-20 xocated..o�`�.�. , north and south sides of Swedes Flat Rd. approx. 1, 1/2 miles east of Oro 1,11-r f.nngor highway, Oroville We are making an assessmerr t of � ' possible environmental impacts RD be preparing an envJ' ,onmental document, either a rlegativd Declaration, Negative Declaration with Mitigation Measures or ail Envira.#Mental Impact Report ('ESR) .Please provide any factual statements, ideas for in'�restigatioiij or opinions you can offer in your area of concern old; s'�xpertise° that relate to either physical;, social, or economic 1',;impacts t)J this project may generate Please respond within 14 clays of the above -noted date. rf no, response is generated b this inquiry, quiry, then it shall be assumad that there are no significant environmental impacts Which are potential from the project. we appreciate any assistance you can provide. Sincerely, Larry Pa er-A Planning Technicialn - Comments _ ri` i eaco of the Y ( g a Y g4tti , e Dddlarationn Odithmort<ai Does our a el, With to recelV doc�tm�.nt a.nitial. ,stud for Ne 'v hoitt Litigation Measure) or XIR for this project) wit Yes Na lj' $CJTTE ,7OUNTYPLA,NNINd comm gSIOTT 7 County Center Drive DrON'ille, ' C <:.X5965-339'7 (93.6) TO: yL U i G7y]l��,rr At l ,Z/ed. DAM, 9-30-92 RE PROJECT REVIEW ENVIRONMENTAL EV Randy D. MOMain OY Mc,Main Enclosed is preli:ainary data our Office has P�received 208 g 4 concerning the fcsllow n r gendtAO Ing project: Rezone from A-5 north and south sided of Swedes Flat Rd a to A'20'1oca�ed oz.>xe nprox,. 1 1/2 mikes Bangor 1 Hi hwar east of.Orov�, g , OrOville, we are making an asSessment of possible environment Will be preparing an environmental document e• al impacts ar Declaration, an Declaration with Mitigation Meas Environmental Imgiact Report MIR). , ether a Negative utas or diy FleaseProvide, or opinions You can offer in our ar an factual stytenents, ideas for nvestigat.On Y that relate to ea.ther� physical, social, ea oorceeoern or' e this project ma Xpertsp� y generate. impacts 'that Please respond within 14 days of the above-noted, response is generated by this in tdate. If no that there are no sign"- y, then it shwa be Project. asstua ed potential from the proificant enviro ental iatpahal which are We appreciate any assistahte you can 'provide, Sincerely, Lar _ rY Pa er PlanningTechnician Comments: A/6 ALvE Does Your agency wish to receive a co document ' copy of the erivitontaental (Initial study for Legative Eeclaration (with or w'- gitfgstfon Mea`i;ures) or EO for this project) , xt��ut i=rivirohr�e�{at �Patth �` � ; Yes No Oct- 0 1 K . ... Orovl�� t Gni , F z; w) f TE Cb Ty T 4 L'N i'I+ANNIrIG COMMIS XOT, Cou�atX Center `Ar3:ve�" � .Oroville CA 9965 (j9x6) 5'38-7�601 r'�' ;°9992' DATE: 9-30-92 Pp9t� RE: PROJECT REVIE014. ENVI p , Randy D. McMain L1C7.c�aed is ;..kp# t12�170 028 preliminary data aur office has receiVed ot6 concerning the following project. Rezone from A-5 to A dU }�, • �r F t+c_°d bpi . ire hotth and south sides of Swedes flat Rd. a pprox. 1 1/2 .miles east of f, tangar Hi thwa .. _ a g Y� Oroviile � Weare making an assessment ofc Will be t Ecu ent, Gitenta,r r �.mpacatr� a1 ,preparing an environment, .,ocument� �'Yther r� r7,ega�ti�ie peclaration Negative Declaratiole. with Mif.a Ration Meas1f eg 'or' a .Environmental Impact; Report (BIR) . Please provide any factual statements, ideas for inv, ex opinions you can offer in stigation; your area of concern o. epi that relate to either physical, social, or economic : mcttpia- that Project ma;y generate. Please :respond within. 14 days of the above -rooted (jai response is generated by this inquiry, then it shalt,• I�'no Potentialthat eate from thesirgoojec�ant environmental 3m�,acts �hichgate- We appreciate any assistance YOU can provide:: ; Sincerely; Larry Pa�ie Planning Technician Comments No fore"seea"ble problems ... .. . Does your agency wish to ieceivo a co" m study for Ne .4jy Decof the environmental. g ive Delaration (With or Withouthitiatioocuent niMeasures) or 1~'>:R fo • ' r .his project), Yes No .. . _ T t 9 BUTTE CdUNTir PLANNING CaMMIS ++ 7 county b ety n 9 r Dr -ON Orovill5965339 Plahnlfittrn4rtf (91 38- ./�- , 1 O C92 DATES 9-30.92 RE: PROJECT REVIEW !� ENVIR01IME14TAL 0288-170--02 ,Bclosed s relim nor Randy Mc0 in AP8 � � . � '• 1 p fiJ .8. �' y data our office has received or gohdrd tod concerning the following project: Rezone from A-�5 t A-•20 1n�a�eci biz',. in xae�rth and south sides of Suedes Flat Rd. approxi 1 1/2 miles east o,� �ra�'s�.�,. Bangor Highway, Qrovi,ll,e, We are making an as of Posszble environmental Will be amental impacts Preparing an environmental document, e Declaration, Negative Declither a Negati�;g aration with Mitigation Measures or aq F'Vvironmental Impact Report (EIR). Please Provide an factual s P Y statements ideas fclr invest, or opinions you can Offer 1n your area of concern or e�cpertid: that relate to either physical, social, or Pcanomic impacts that this project may generate, Please respond within 14 days of the above -noted date. response is generated by this in xi If no' that there are no significant environmental impacts Potentialassuxrlec' potential from the project. Which ale We aPpreciate any assistance you can p .jvid;e. ince3, e1y', 0. 'alarry Pa .. er._ 73 �,anning Technic.�,�n - Comments a Does your agency 'wish to receive a co , d6v,-Ument i COPY of this environmental (ihitial study for Negative Declaration (With or withotz, ♦ ) r this project): Mite at, Measures or EiR fo �:es j�Cy C �j �% �"'; �t I E �- r L0 to III" .14/� z; a:, �Ie i•.. j�.r> �8,,, C*, 73 y fl =K72 ,f;- J IL57.rr 1s14.8D 1370.24As 12:1 18C�- y1Si'3.79 .Os AC <. ri` 1 ��► tS 91 � 19 g► I61 � 10 � I 20i•TSd1 W 4% 0,3 :C 18 VJ 4 i.v. L Lor 4 3 i' Lia �> tY Aa2tAC 4 39.14AC T r� �Ch,�fAC _. 5•G.99 `-� ' Y 5(7 a 49 40.05AC 40.0-3AC 4o.OGAC 39..41 AC ► ._ a 44 1a3' AC GR ERTY.R/S X48 4 J 7�0.+ FMW fi3l102 + y 3 ; 21 s1 51 N � ti r5 C) 189 C7 / 6 � IT4 18! ' fig. aro�ac gp �ao.ac E� O W 39.02AC ti t AC 3SLz9Ac 4u AC ^ C, ,; /// 103.91 �" �, p► 32 I 131 - PM 12Ia i 4r rt aaac. l8 "T�, Ac. 1 22 an .5Ae 3.ox sa 115 1tj1.7 �, .► r 161x1 ✓ e � I w 3T 29Ae TI � terra{ C'..'" AC � '� r � � t r O 1-91 � 9.d7A4• .. ,.; .. c.o 119 ti O b ld. 35AC2cz s z ., l2B 12 12 r�M' 68-13 40 AC IM � 0 169+ Rj547-3T 790 l4 n z y118 �. A1 15.15 Ac. - 40 AC "� 9 tits: 1324.2 aaez9 + Es v2 P A eu / _ 88,•23 1JR4.25 1 " 891 • r PA i )0 !!G 11 14.2 '! 1:58 i 1 l+1► 2 „ 122 /6C7 I 1 a to ^ I 1 ;1, e0 �, a ZQ ` 1' . • 9.81 / "O « �/ / 29 7f.23ACiR N too 2 io sYa 113 1 0 o a 'Q m 121 ' �►�5 - 3oa�ae y � M e � 143 23.22AC �+a 3a'!I{ Iq �+• a<o � &2 a �, N � 118.25 AC, 3 fasa i ,., a 114 ( 14 4 PM94-Si x391{� 3 41 j2 ►; --.✓ 40AC 0 M I2 129.79Ac 13 1t � T:S 19AI g •�� Q 4 fOA AC ,1 „ PM7MM AM J 3.-,M'8 IOAc R�110-J31 115 i 3 PM53-5 Fa f7n. of 6e6. s ►319.3► 3C1 1348.33 PM3 _._ aso,aa �1ss 1 4A« 10 110 !94 99 ' 1 9® ITr (7 N 110 �'� z fnaAc 17th /7/ - 25Ac. 15k., r ►.19 M 1, 40AC N�.. 4t7AC 40 AC 9.,;.g "-�,19.47R 19.08 , ( �3. t ssulc"; I pM l05 70 1 r Z°- - -� r f SFJ 1LE �N�. w>ra 787. s2o.os sfs 3rJ ,rj✓' \t4/.y� ±164)(► `� 165 - Ja39.ra w. 40AC. ld 44 18 � 40 AC 40' A.C. 41n.o9Ac 1 AO'Ll A._GOLD hfT._RD. t !_-• �i 43A4 7170 . 1 1RB z ► a� I 9Q 11 la7JAe . t PURPOSES ONLY ANI? �4 i ivor CDId3rlTvrE LNGaAL 100 149 41 r �, � A4 . .n , ?�. J , 1 40 ACS � 4 41"x41 40 Ac 1 1 15q o �- PM 98-18 151 1$0 1 / OX aC 'ti ... -• ' 1 7:93 A - , .'� -» «-• ,. ,.' 11.62 AC { C r I=I{i�Ie 10 t , j ,..., j�. r+15.5 855 �� 101 i "4 � � 10.0 9. «iO.dC. �?'r� 40 Ac "�T 153 O 'al0 AC` j �# O AC H, rJ j� BlistA Fv%f 67 Assessor's Mc h1 o, 2 aT 4, Ii County bF Butte', Calif. REVISED 7 t lC , .,.... __ - 11 11 .. ... . (:l YfCALC X_XNT ANA S•. e..N I i TICAL Materials Chemistry and, Science 7 Accredited b- 010 Nat onallnst, of 5tartdards �r G;;,•t; American Assoc, of rtilotor Mvele Admin. Certified by Phil `s � m 10 California Deparhrrerit of Health Services y- :)ecember 11, 1992 .. 1 i E B(Itte County Zoning DJrectorof Development Services % County Center Drive Croville, CA 94965 Attn: Mr. W Farrel I am writing to inform you that as a land and,homeowner adjacent to the proposed Ravine Sports Club" we object entirely to the f�rrnation and existence of same, `-- separating $ prgberty from the proposed hunting There are no fences se aratin our undoubtedly our property w11,1 be fres as&c u on, We cifk1i P p will no longer feel ate walking on our own property djae to the possibiliAt ty of stray and irresponsible gun, r 2. The influx of so ,;pan, incidence of theft andybulo}cals into the nerg;�borliogd_ will greatly increase tt The noise created by constant rifle/gun fire is extremely objectionable and is rens" alone to reject the proposal. The recent gun *1 i undoubtedly increase to unacceptable levels.g r►as been noticeable and V11 4. Property and personal damage due to stray ballets is inevitable, f: A The peace and quiet for which We purchased the property ;is violated, 6. Traffic on Swedes Flat Road will 8ubstantrally increase with increased noise i, , etc. and road maintenance problems have not been addressed by the Sports Clu(� by the county, y or introducing ecological balance of the animals in the area Or g g �. Chanin the ec mals to the by either shooting theme' g an area Is sure to create problems, For example shootirt coyotes will result in a huge increase of mice and rabbits, COATINGSBLIT DII�dG MATI??tIAI S LIGHTING 08VICP5 SPECTROSCOPY • CHROMATOGi:B AZAI11)0 ,`ts WiAST �`dY MICROSCOt?Y • PHOTOMBx ' � PI , ,� EMERMLLE I:ABORATORYAND iC7.� ,ME. 1✓LI�' iN$1 tC�'tO P,O, I30� 8702 BMBI2�trtLLP, C� t�) 664 LOS ANCE +LA'S O,E=RICE: �~.-. ., •1672'WA`I'TS $118ET + 8lt%IMYVILLE: Cll 94608 1 hod SANTA MONt A BUIL trAttb • St IITE"; TBL;dS1C7J 02-21974 FAX (51o1652,3g85 t WAST LOS ANOVI ts, CA 900 25 rl L (310) 826.8072 J �1 I