Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
034-270-116
February 9 1,980 irvironmahfal R v ovt G+�pt Cly ix'I:t r� of theoard of Supervit.mrs for the County of Butte,(�� 2 � ��� 25 County C rater Drive U rovillu , California 95965 qu tcs GcwnPy Da,'ir ,Ir Lor e a +Y■ {YCr$her{�que�/fit pad laiT},�.�t��opinion �f5r0,W, ,{(t��[ ie�y�{;oun�ty Cc�u�::�ex caz� kf 5 y1rI C:G i/4 .41v S:J tj'�U all' Y i'iO Subdivision Tii, ata a HT.'.ldy�j 011 the Procedures f01.3,t�t� oa PriOr to preSenting the ..)Ut;tt, County Board of 3upervi.sol.'s .—,tp to the Ph tx d the 4ouzl y 00un,1?0. rule that th�S n�at� l� art Vtr°t�t�iC�rt of any .rection of t;i��..�at er' 0 of t'hq But` e �o, , a) `L G=.rN gtr i #iJz�e r10 G t'011OWed O, r(-quze t tl,i tnt; � oo ej � , iry 'r 3 at t b t.. � - . . 41 tt ra~r tz�.x' m nta under the I rovi( ots ld feel that t:te tentative. mall of the Valley View �Qab�� `� ����1 shauld ac.)tr have beYcn suubmitted tri the Butt C+�ut�t visors cry it is in er5z i'? ,c t tlith the provisions of t1te rbuttcd of �uper.. out vac e. Chapter 26, Ceetj.or� 2C)•-4 f u: itte CoUrIty Code Spell In detail tk e :rteps rpt ceu;;ary for the x��nt n� of an o�»oe'ntic;x to tile Provision of Chapter 20 , �S of, 170 hour: fs K; �y� Y�y Pt�t�tr:try2 lCi ]�`tr f�.,, 5 5 rs 4}' r J �J W 1A/� i Sfi from tt e V911ey View Subdivider. 'q°C44 T1ON" could bo found In the reroord , ;�'iied `7*%try G U�ttY F i�k� , G :,�i(�rks e "t�'t;tt��1#' �r� �t'� t � + of 1 n� l' + yxXJt;t.o CrurJty' i:c�{3ca 0t`1 {t text�;rtr,l.�t r - {� + ,« Vdf y 5,11r�L ifiO `,s t O "thPl 1 r' a 7 length q } Section r . .1 . �»�;�.,��c'�.. " S:trG�L:� �, ,t�r Y Arr w ��,�,�1ri� �*. � Gti�~��' :�.•,� ,rrF3��a. ;66 ' s �k% t .7y„+ALT, NG �� " Ly�rl1- �jt ( � �,�i J.� ati�ti;hYYt 011011111 {i its t ;y^, aT«. r: r S7Tip t4,)rej jjjF,,Li q yryr$' 4 ty t t �y..In Parti P "It eetr, tr *ti{y � ,' #r *iz� AiL M.I Ie pN ` t Y S�A7d"� Y v r Y �y{ {+y t-� � 1 Y �.[ �j y� { !+� / f5 yMy l 4 i l S.L L .L «.; n'.{ S:l 4LM�4: A at Lj{N tn' tlt�7 �.r L�� »t.{t i' { VI. �; n G,+' 0+ �q ,r 1::A _,b' the 'F Jt rue t.a`Ct�'�tf'6 .tr1 "�e; 1�� "t4k:.'�ry,t t,fl•� 7.� '., YV vw. 4y K3 ti ( a� „sr ° T� !i It co"Ari 1. ` QF ii ry j 1, x" a. C>A�•�}7; tik ai r GL M,i. IL t l i ",i.E"±fi r+.J e"r t'i l,l i �' � r W It •V apt Wtv tkazt fila' .,rr)�.ttll �l.tr,t�)�t;tsu a �r ` r, c A `a 1; E 1(11, 'tX ,i. {;: f 'l q 'r .e :,� ,„t f r C „�t r t?• tr��. r thr{' s rll1 "tkw' n 2- { t as I'Arector of Pt.bl io fOrlts did not maks it Mandatory tb ��,�,� vfor u' ►.re s z>c et eXt.ent ons into trjjs Chapter 20 Artiole VT, their area the woj-d�njU, off', S eetl on 20.132 implies thftt they did I'lot"Wili ll dceission.r on. what was best: for 'theColAnty of o,:rttc. $11oul.d this developmer t be, vi; OrS should regi lire, ratir�r� be spprc vod', the Board of ataiaer- as a condition of W)proval, that streot ' provided to the south'arid 1�a t. Respectfully r Oalwal.e Avenue Orovi le, c l.ifOlmlla 95965 { {, ta��ax��t� C�laras�al, 4arl Nelson ::la,Y Castleberry i -�L �t�t•r����,yt i �1,„K Aa'�:} {n ;. ,: 1 . . , t.,� � yy�, _• <�AqM: �i't�w.wr«JwWA.+.'�swswra i lr,>•�M.e Rte 162, Men Co iurr `'!'R:lF7lc J'(AU,111„� Rte 162, OUt Co re; 162 Men Cu r Peak AO( APT mile- +. t)ctrriplion Peak AUT Hour , Pk, Md. AnnWi Rule post Description Hour MMo Annual All,Pnt ouk Pk. Mo. Awlu41 152.9 Co1Dos'Riot 75:21! Codora, South Jct, Ric, 45 .......... „.,, , „... •.• flo02a2d Wf«,,,Y............ 1,70111 I10 I�Stx1 7011 79.07 Bridge 11,18, i5i1 1!t'uKt Hirst "fi70 (:oanty Itoud 027, untie 4ity, taut Or ,,,, « ,» ,,,, , ... 1,500 , . LtyiA lb 21.Cdtl :'t1A+rt y„..„ Poonkiilnr Road , ..............IN1 1201,450 800 lJ0 IaOV I2U) 81.7 County Road i L iAJUO Nt111'4) TrA% el al 24 Fairbanks flood ,.<' 230 2,750 1,500 '. 8454 Cicnn County 210 2A 1,400 -0,00 fluae County' 0U 50,QM1 JV.Irrl , 311,74 Min4•xenia RoadX60 ... 1.000 b0 9w 750 6.V flichvide South Highway , »•.- � "1 110 1,400 750' 1,100 tKt W,OtMI. 47,IYllt �=' $holt Creek floatl' W„ ,, ....•.” »., .,... g.73 South Jct, Rte. 99,: 70 Hfl0 4�0 70 800 450 Riga}, North ,;,„1« , »..., i,; „ .,.. ,• ., . , , .,. ,., . , .., (Rrcuk,in DOW Al JJ,C11M), mm,A0 XrarShori CrtMkflrid8r ,;,;,, ,,,,,,,,, «.,..,........ , Illrcuk' in Route)- R9.13 %orth Jet. Rte rA, Ri(h4ale, Fas► ,;. ,.. DISTRICT 3 Xi .last ++uf (Actus County' 14.03 Oroville, Larkin Baud ,.., ,. ..,..�. 4rsrt -V 65 On Adler Springs IhghNdy Y) ]I,ixx1 i.lr!l, at (;ounty Ruud 4116 'ear 530 6: 0) t Jf 1 i 1lendocino `+ilcllat Forest 14:96 prosifle,12111 Street .„„ ,.,„. �..•' East uoundry .............. „.«..., ......,.. 72<) 93(10' . 7x200 41 M County Rood 344 North, ., .«....., ., L 34A1tt1t MAO rdl 850s 5 0 Vl4 4499 Cdont. Howl 3%$044,tc (to EU Creek) ««, .., ..N .,,„r, "”' ”' 1383 br9ville, let. R 70 ''IisJ 150 st} {'J711 70 1w, fi7(I Route, 139' Near W6 County R Yd3041 „ ,,.,. W '1'1•athrr Riirr Rnulstid r'd ''i�y1 t6'SM 1, filth ' (to Ston (Sotge fit-voirj ... „., ..W, „. ,,. . « Ifi� 70 7s11 6,50 t kt 0 2111YYt f.1 y , ,.,,«,. .. , �a (.o� tt Woad D. ..�. ,�, . .„ ,,,,,, .. , «.,,.Y., , 18.93. Lint�lu [tri u)rv4rd t tCn 1�AItt1 1h 1'><i 240 Ow 11 V5 15nC11iM!Nltha4v,�inxrdl l)aln ik 4rs: 0' i F t4't ht14 County Road F' «•2711 «i.fil)l1 l>ronlllc � 1 44.;111! 14 J,UU4!"•• it r/ ;ill 1111. Vd1 aldlh 3,•110 18.01 Chntlihti� Wind ( I t0l Is�52 vi illc.5, .,, J ,�1« , ,...9 4t 1 h1,iI1N1 �1` 4ndgt�l u rr 1 1 Ili 1 tl;tt 1 i CAI lt1 x1 r r+a1 i wt r>,k1 64t1�1 iw�/ �IJIltlti�1. 4111 a XAI f itrr I+:rd lidiu Hs„'Irh4ttdSltlKH ' .,,. ,..,461,11,,. ..R 171hi1 iNAK M'r _ 17U 4SCN1 , i Y.3'At i bsf: 2Si1(f 2,11x1 '.� ft; .1 CI'u1rAi lftlFAi�0t1,1«'Inuit'' - ..,.. low to Fffririnfs I x,^1Nl 2,1011 x Mtl+i1 C;Arunl} 11oa1 I! (A111i1rk ilml{t1 „ I'hXi 1lU10 ►U1 I l .'G Crnyon Drive ttt0 7 .3 � !lnttnl!• llnati k` , , ! ! (5t1 f k>0 1,44114 51� � �`� ' 214x6 ) (11101 It A knot ` Seto' 1511 f 3i1i1 I i01i Ir"ti "rr '6 O':0011m Noftijjm RIO Z �� �7JtY,) v 1 fa Irl -J.Srxl rt IlfrrJk to IDuilil :6 Vj Gclddni, Sotith Jcl. 111x" '45 d A f 151 24.19 hrlx„lawn;li,ud 25(Y) Y TR,4FFjr ! il.0/AIF,4 o Rte 162, But; post ll Prdk __ ADt P Ib Co Nour Pk. Mo, AnnAnnual anly' 4 oad 522 Mile• post re� ripllon s Peak o Cos -.pDAnrwdl A« Dos li;.;a Road ;, 76.29`, Calor r "odePk „ a. Nr,t'2000 , ' .1..7 ^«br7t1 (:ounfy [iwd 827 I10 1,500 700 Popnkinliq Road', 79,07 ,Uridge tlslit, I Ih0 7W N,..,•• Uuc ( ,NN 120 1150 800 INO 1hW 2924 Patrbanks Road N411Yi « !ry!{,•,•, 81.57 County Road P 2 , ISI I'M I'm nn W°` ' W I . vfl,l, � Nt«I�,''� rwr N,!•,•„r r 30,14 Road 210 n N I(A!.«,•1,850 .I,r,n,,,nnt � 1.041 110 11 00 750 5298 _Short Creek Rodd µ, Richvalc South i(ighwa Y W . 9w 750 � 120 leu n,rl.IfA ' I05 Va71 40 orf LcckRridga 977 Soulh jet Rie 99 RJf , n..«, (Rrcak n1,Roule) „«„ ([freak In:ltodle) - =,+„nir , R9,75 ti'art� jcP jlfv 019TF ICT 0 tlrchsala;'frt t Glenn Cosi n1y «,1 IG+1 "h!Xt0 J7M t)n Adler Springs Highway220 �t C.ounly'Road 405 \ear itendoclno Il W Qravfllr, larkin Road , 27(Ki ImI 2�txs VatipnaLjorest F=air UoUndrY .. 0,W 4rpj0 141% Qrovillt., 12th 5lresf Sw 4151 CountY Road ;106 \:orthG0 130 3 to Vw w � , S50 7211. bt%1ii �tj 444$ Cottnly Road 306 South 60 WO ain (lo Eli Creek) 432670' County Rau; JPs, 620 (t0, Stone C;orge Aesevosrl „« . ,••r, «...; . +0 M fi76V (�olrnty Rost C , 249 bs ti9 C001) Ihntd F`; n, 22fI J,OW; 2,hlil! N1 s-” let 1110, S ,, ., SIi 50 5,41Ni fiYj 7,400. 6,Og0: , t'r,lJ Wlll w'I'ehio S(rcm }7i1J,lr1(j: f 1,5rA)` X 21 1'cUlral ltrliahu�g i�pal �1),, 221i1f- 2,1(f') C& Ciwn Y, Owd ? 221 2,100 ;v r��41iC)~ Iio;lilr ,: f IIA IAw �><i4111tu' RiaUll 15�1� 1,154 I,dl� 7 ;7 (Rhgltsr 'artll jet, Nfi, 49 " I!W o Illrcukari Ilaule) .,.,,- # �. +o� ta�,�E�rAi5oo;n JCI. Ric 41,1-:1. f ' to?1S � 4 r r e I' r ,. J r , • • i � a r r ,�, 'hy. qt9 d � �,rr,i' > `a t t�•F,[� yr .,.�+ .,. lWrr�: r � to 'me. �w 1 t {r �9 +SIldin Cil " l .b, M td itay tl A wr t A Y ag,. ( rl,r� ¢+ xa n wl SlarTe. tpi rar . « ,' d as wA;' 5 f (� � NiI/.VIEW II r4 rMA ,ti .wv A •`g} � , al rtbtl tt.m j_,,,, �" RUCwa7itNf 1 � rr ��os;QUlpCy=} � ir�'tnr G I 1 ;".` r XI,Ma a arr• fine7l Nenth , � � tltl' itr W � � tr " ff. k } ; l A rYutF„ her � Xifit�i kr w�' � ��,t , n ►aa it ru i.,•r, GC $able. rr. ."i'', r `.. xX "'"rAa. .l-` .t , tt. bxt r, d4r.r e t �,,r AnAf6`i ♦;e. j 2 r I Y a 1 ?nr7rlr i 1u _r i if 1' r GUc ra nfrwr4reu111 ,,n ya��1 t"LUM((��t�eASbckx `M,t J /I Uu (� rrgr rrajf�nn �r x w f 7i•41t1 % ryrmthew . rtr_ rA 7 4 L yrt# 400 awa r`f tt lyo •.�� " � rkt! a .,t 3r K uul f• ,ra- � �. Ar�r nA t " 7ta uqi' r�'nr r 'aunt- I At •a cJt r` J ►aradtta }^ �.1- r(, 9 n L 1 �4M �'�_ jj11 S r im Cenlelrltla +/00uY anNaAr �Ge +"- lA 1 tl rrw _ r ry S,Ur � r AWSO w....�...,a • µ. kr• " 5 m elf r . y S Faradita rl �� t hF�" ti POOPlo in this sYre depend off-) ,73 rn ' OrOville for shopping. They - �' � �r ��' � Rn n 7!n •? C � t rr rw, r.>wra F t Must Mass the 'laC- to C�4� �C2: a•ywre `q Orova. ].le .' a ., wi010d �t t POPULATION r old � � ►thl7 � r � � ;. �� t.� - �I at 1 f ..,. y.n. I� _.., f � f '�' F h!t • K � Nt�,, � t 7 . r N, , ar dead i� ,i ♦ � tit? d th 11X7£ 9 � F I �4 wf "�' �+Q � rigtl b 61 • H� � '' 9 : >' • % .$' �b 4q =A,. r♦r La 15 �"�]. �,N�.Si _ "r_ y""'.+•-�.:���r t 1'a' tl�4• ,: tl�, �n h qv � d 4 i" rulA n �•+r ht t t � �.�_ rr s .a = 53 600-. r ► It y r } a Perko wT R Cie x � ,�.� � � krtll,��riq X33 Y n P wrrn�'J r'nr r +• 'Po 10 M le qtr', +� Q y i,'`.x �'I f,��^ °6 nit 17 iAtllenG1r i' ►� j `r 390600 600s� x7 ' 5 5 7 i as r: er to S ' feather 71 �a. by •r9; r � r t, yq� ppll '•xhltr � to l • :. to �tla ..... Y S3 w k � I � r• ' �. + I J n ¢ r °a k, fes' PF ....�' Miles 1�i7iyM0 N, ktr +Qj M sveu, ,a r ANA 1 lhtr 71 to v' Irr ^j` I �:. Mi '"{ eflewnLJM • Cljppt%k Cyt &aA z � r1 R7G „ g r ! MLt,, p,pL i 1 �R(thvile� ri !` i 1 f q . leS,,r ( + b `XI dy 7.rarw it r vw .h ZOOr' p1 '� tr It r d asri i KR. ' t. uiti�+t� � 7b'� ������' �' � '� „� ,°r ,+x •nrr ��wh. I'. "rt17 � � {7a+tdfef 1 p r �` 7 't� ' f !Y° 4 h .� �� = �!, y � Y � p ,'�, y � a�. A.5 Ufa d� r• I ; �a, � x � u'F tfi 'i 4 ��' M'• a 1 l,J L v*rte , b k• 7 . Y �. wD , X53 5 hA�tia 'r uty.8w,q." �,, wJr f r Ch9Renq! Y. ltfr r ..nl^' l INMItit4r iyy_ !r. �' 4Llit n )) w. ,rn a Ah t t bt r rrrt s t pa t ghKr Mttl a+e1 �il i I rr�erbr �� � r � '� '•w 1( t C1r�tp onvllla � ' �� • � 1 nr�r ' - r r n, � ��1' d 5 + 1� '}a Lw � .3 'q v ale tR �}, at 3 i s''tli, � 4 rr '�.� z � 1 `' �y� A ,� � es6h � }�p1{a • r J" r4 � tt t. r P krnr a•• •^'""„�•� "A n r �," r,, � & � l� � � , a 7 � 3 4 � A=a,r . ;, �� r Jnr dld�8 rwMiitt 7 r h, am , � �` .t Int. 3� � `'+� ti " 7 i ,� .A - ,,,y, . � t..�"ti' 2e � "• , .n " rw tr n w l E> , r r k', 5 • d4 } k v D Gh k aih T c I d 994 s a t`elgx X� r 1 Y !y o,T +lro 1� YI 7qd �1, r, � d •4V pp 6 uwwr „ t!A' r' Wait s Iyrl i! 1 f�ouRse r yv 5 A`+ t r s •' t Flarlh 1 9 h �v�, t k cA4, r0 r w r.,r•..r .r " ru.N,lS ,p rf t t.*rt r $l, Olo id1W9 t ' `ir:ttdand 4 b, A ltlrrl � i C 7� j � - : t w< " !t � ! r4,w Pr a rf ' 8 •1 a � 1 5 ,ly � ,, Xe �. ,'�s j a , +rB.a q �� _ is "•e I ;,,,.. 1 nr xy r � Alrthrijlt +t>a. �r* 'fig r.: �' r A � !s@ +,"Y •1, f a ra;,r+> � ' ' �5.� ar�"rr �+wWar+�"^ „ '�t�l�id��r�,I,na w�'"ir� 'I ' l1,'��r. " :. C Mh.. �� ;-. � � '►� �+� : g =5 'r.�a. �,•Ib � ', iit�ir .., .`� �`1� `a' `��IX �y� � � ', a n C Y• a lFuaa �;. t dr 4 Xl;#x L, t4 � .• ,�Ji�,lir'� .�,Gr • wr R � � �' :'A ♦ lL.�} It r-� v ., r,Yrt en ?r r > 4 'K ^kyr 4 Stowns N ;rut 1 .* , r » �Nt3VadY1It ` rF'� 5t 5I a+� re ,m ''• NH41uen •• 7rrr �+/ 9 7 ��..e ;; a' ph .A an .. vY Y r r r Ar ,, Rough -- :r i � it ' taxrnxun S " r ratf rr a `5 Aq �Jh '�� a Y %� 8" � • �i 1a II x � 4 r r r, � 1t R r: �R�tn 'Read► ��nsel ratl Kms.., l�M : �y ,� � ter aN alnw vtant u,AAr .,�- ''.� ,. •T4 �l d �' R a }rc� t Imbu hloant' o fi �:, r i"lal Pe f: carrµ• ., ► ' ,-w t! 71+Vp', ` t m $ 'All ant •Mv>rf.�' �..�.. � �ir�""_ IG � '�"1,� � � r� t, 1 aun�! �� 4�, r�!,fi - «•`,'""""" a**",.-! r fl"' ultr"al a n Ism 4 : x? + 444 i Airs lj r'et # t+.. A�o i - tY r Ir * hM . r ry$Y1��P-' t �; '��pi�Ay •,,, tt`C' �tN.. r +e,,.tiwr+r T�7e,r.,t ��dt Ma '� Yl blJild K3 % tcw d�% •a"� iAr,raa � F' d� h4 ��ik ..'1 w 8 nrAl r Ark. y,r rt t •rr�", yyyy .•. rtaitiK, ►' M 4ii1i � S'� sr qra "1,�. *, � � K m�� I..� r � � ,. r �f{ ' i , w vli {� � 't rint ,s. • 4,, :'(? + w�u' ytNb . h11W $idtta rrr--�, r. Pa+rtrrf� �/ rF 3 ;r'v itxla�, r 20 10791 Ca ysVilInj ,.lit xrtit�w'r;�'rir r e1" ter our, tt:*�t�plx,ar�e �o?iviw fes. yy f�1 t f�Fli ��13�'tJez�'%�di3�" i art�i�'�,x TLIO+ Zd a"r ta2�v r,"� :t r tory wco��y Or' the Tra fie "' . �� �,r,,mber lx.L�x?lct . drat 'JL��j `. ° �t1 :aG+i kr; a `` glzateP Fi fr 11eta NW t�7 �"�� .� ^ � � ` �� � 4 `�1.a �iOWn 1'Y �w�rl r'�'dYi tx h; r� h�:oar btFt k, ' t �k .l t' � tht: t a le.�"�tt�,^t� � ��ir: „ x+ of 80 , c��t�lu�eri to otar� otar� �r�uctiorz nt Burt th sUJx�,^oar of tak ohrtze coa�cr^s lri waa o�brt� �r��d di:�,1 rr e ar that, without .tx�a��ing al�7. ��kt ��f�� �t 01.11)�r �8 1IZA r t use one) a total Crf s regaraiyle h rsub-dli °3 feel r ,.< 1 2 hor�Ees (C sta.tist�os averas Veh.io]: ,, br, home) the boirj�., lad Into a, � u th.'e employeOs o:i` Gal "'r'��ns are t'� �t _l kaer o(' h posit -;here 'they can beoom� ��tr ,w goats tract,p goats for As yoQ see Piles ent7. on the >Jho cry ios that will b 2 I' i"x% d tc5 .r ii l ni th�,i l > it i15PI es that t;txe S<a' t}�-&]iti01M1 traf o t tEt propt i� skId dill be 5 e t? na ....ts to to handle a7. twra�k -02 after tyke sofa-��� irk s� c7ns ����lr�' jn t�ak��ra1 04Venue soktauter ant Sand fir;, or tta Ck!EP �, X have f O luted tht�t' tlae prosede�t 17;rat t:az�n Lane w r , , w1„V,110 Av rl1te �,,110u;7ck ttdve k en gra zF t Skiers Ell i., t!'xo ��i ��Id ` � k��,t�,�.r� 1.6 a�xd r a tru,c t c3 i xjxy� r�k.o Yoxs ado 44r�d m, �,ix)k �,�d ��car.r�:��� t�rabl.e:ts, L,k�e"�t�� ., y ,,, 1, r”, that the ,jdcj t�Onf tr�af'�� _ �narrt ���ders� by t,.". vt���a'stabr v i zrI '1401.11d ocart,� �, rpt d (� )ora t��E1 va e) y.5., a tion wid tl2(l an r rclu rr d still 11l �tE-cvulc.- 162 Lnter a Tlj�: tit l+e (,:01i,1lty,r tl:, t l� ver Win 11,1 r ro ont�al K k a trr ho, rc:t Oil one sub attd e rR thou -h they tyre umro that; �� �e���r pronosul at -a t1m0 PrOUsod In the; s;�,e x�re�. � srzb"d�v�:���ar1 i�ca xni oEt' utali` officesson�cksrAitrat� ,,. `,. }1,' t� *t xd °,t to �:� 1;? xYE rr 'tee �a`?iyEW 1 ' ii Cote a rc . to rn If r a.tion e st nd rfra ci raan tht t., tl e, ,sur "t h, t such � coda rpt' r.�r icon at the sa""to tirp�, � �caar� 00nsidOr all know,n ��g�e iapPr oo14te ;a x 'You'," 4F�p���'��Ae C;c"1 '� a "� ��`�tarF1C�iu �,*��vi�i%;?. �i�c'��i re�l.�tFrckr�.ihdeion' be`ro L' "° b►} ry yy rq j i rr45�,.A, �i.1i+.+.6i;�U iP4+1n N; 'has beer) sclleduled.. `car r�" esd 1 �, � Pubo o ZOO- - to ck so xs kr a pro ra'F n .��E 0r 6� 197 Sim"erg, k`ar�:� n Vii.... Robrart Btirry pockwo.,Lj. +._. Lynn T,,. !o ckwe i`.- Pt) OrovillOa" California 914965 October_ ' �. x.979 Earl Nelson$ Director of Iry irr�rr�tu�ntal �cc�va ew 1&-F C0LmtY Center Dr*vc 95 Oroville, Cs:�.ifovna.r.. ` 96?S LeGar, Concerned The Proposed C)-'Ikval "subs "visions axle a great conga cc to s Peasoaa.s Atta.cbed. is the petr:�t� ori that eis � been a i r�:�a� :tern fora many the tl,�o subdivisions. �" w <� .p g The Va�.ley '.r ew Subdivisa.on era our matin concern hnsa ; this LIMO however becauoa the Irap'Re ��e oxgt �'or t ..�.s sumain con Pro been presented ano. �z& feel it does not aderau�ation �;�,� answer co xnan subdivision �'ho I�et�tiOn st�tec' clearly x��,� c� the �=r:o,s�ans ori, Y aubc3 v sa r,n.� should, not tw3 acc�a�ite wi thout arae adequate %Ons rang the mat ,a.tions to alleviate problems caused by the -development, There are additional cons:i�d.erat.i ons the t na�ci. to be t,uc�a.e c� r,,, : cn. o *eTi , tr',r to be as succinct ac *ostijb1e rd floted, One exit on to Oakvale v0. �' lc�m �� aer�.es �f c��.�aesa Vi e11) J.s a hazard to l i 'e. f" cs, Valley Cook�"xssoc. str�.tioc that the "Pire lxa ennatill's Report by Unfortunately t1�.,1a.a x_a trra�; .her ",: sa is east side of Oa vale cx�.Gtly Last, pro�rdsed oritrannce ,it a fire on 'aha_ the subd�.va:,Sa.on. Athout; another ex�.t �'ar reg o o subs vis -Ion th2.is rsoula be,rous, a� �senta of the alone y cOU16 be -tromendou,s not to�rrent�� canboth ;r o. t rax�'I fire i-0- no d '.t dor to ho X t atta c; v� ut�.m the one road is bloclted, The . trattic coni ,tjoh ab I)ea 0 ianes would ,yeneratt=w� gfot' c irrowool be =bol evable .aorlaan;. t x D vehicles,every sci)001 bus r))voblovt, ti,1s ' Lthor tryint,; to. vialk, to a uho or °a,aeca t tr�r�;i.r ba ; a ano wThore would enjtr,:r�athe Subdivision�mUPto g 1.,R. stratus, t jj'�t era bus would on'�,y add. to fi:he c�on� eat�ra�x�ax dcIt trcon�'ua�nn.�the,���i4,n'�. This a.n` ,:# : a i r� stated ' 'Traff a prob exras c u5 ri 'ar c}a at- the the ntcrscetra ora or�rao aria tiab coxa antrane to. tn$.-: sb. u r�,zsaon. '�, earttar ua e, t✓lie ent�.re Ca .a.�'orx la V'�aothill a,r" o t �1ta tact tat b{ e nta l c art ua o arra sand: to new l o o b a; n,� tnSide d, to e �a a't�n 'b1�i.aan co;s ani Bait Asn : a.t cons de ed t;ha t e r �a ,,�th�.iba. e s a ,n taa a` x r od a tex must, a ut, r enn u7L]'i "( FCn 6n�1.3 C ti4Se �.J ofr tk^ x7 f C''d�. L�' 4" �'4a.li i be' ' a %i�xre onrr exit for the ro4idont of 60 .iaumec >ar��u� be a; ss 'a y precai)t;a.on, co to n The 0, d.I. U. water sut;r{ ly we now have will, be discontinued �i f and when. the subdivision r)ro ject belin.s The I)eVel.opers m vi' t not burd,on surroundings property owners in any wsy as a ro ault of their project, i, a., book -up Fees 'via j„e jjze tl.eir 1!Off site Costs” inolode such expenses but we want also to express cur concerns « Tnc 'need for perimet-ur fen`oine is stated in the 4ttaoJ, od, iotltion. however in raCard to ob i ldren short- outti,ng a.crops private prope;rby to school., the need., for fonaing Is uraxount;, , as the operz 0. ,.1.1). irrigation ditch runs throu< b those proporties. This ditch is of°ten, dangerously ia..i_o-h crj: acial,,ly for elementary school are ebildran. 'lease, it must be required that tkaa developr;x+:; f'enco the irra. ;ati,on O' -fob th,-t runs through the subdivi,tt .oz"� ;��o�)erty. D. sloes not require j)riva to pro j;e :qty ownrxls to, f'unco the irri=-ation ditch but certainly when.a subdiv1310 of ;gap homes is j�:cYoposed and strictly as a profit maki.ne vontur,o tale deve op- rirz, should be reu;i,red.. to tale the necessary ot;e ,,ia to sa.f'eguatd the 'Lives of the 'children who wifl live in tile subdivision. I know of a young who drowned .in this (Atch in this ureas fir. .K+Aaor on, General Unf 011.1 of of 0..'u ..r oaio on Ootobor 11j,- tb„,t fenci,np, the :i.rri.eati.ol ditch W'ou:lo be fine) all they xxrai;ta;i,re is that tine fence can b�.ck 15 feet from,, the top of the bank so that vehicles coul,c. be driven along, tiaa ditch for maintenance ,ur�aosas. This s;;apia nuita raasonab;lo; It teas been : U ,,,jested that a -mt en belt area ” le=od ,, lone tile. iiriat:ion rayl -ch ru n tnt,, throu h the .5ubd'.vision 3':ro ,epty would hole t4 solve` t4o :sbvoi-e dra5,xjs:--o problem;tn t';As area. ThP.s would be very coMOati,ble witki f encs llen the di t ah: This would M(,,) an',orrlitinsome 1ot,s, � azjc.�l along:` �i��V 61t r,6. obis uecryoase cierisity anj ad.,ied r reenary W, ul.d and to { ,,, beauty of, th© tZ ry , raixza. e a,. ��a t,ri,ct help s-o:l.ve M`:,n'y �arob].c:mio �.7.nd vfety. T1.1e lana bhw trowi+ondotxsl,{ in tine i +t o. x,+ t ncra,:, allows the dOv- 010 �a� .� y a ' h to allow, �� ter prat t 4e. do ,.ity of t" subdirviasiot . xxei pro ',� ly miti t�,a.t e, all taroblelr,1,; cau a.0 by the oubd vision and stiJI mako ,a tai of"t, 'i'he cievel.a:ur.-. are not i'rom Crovi l f e 4d 'are concox-hod �iboUt "o, conaerned about our; aro, . I :fit rmst be' sti�assed treat i l" Oone ;+ro 01,1Y, t ct n work .oiat wP,1 . Por a� �. invo i ced 1 1.� g oint tilint n.v0d � t6 be ronsiooreO is t;je 01 i i b d v 3'. s,io �•;1? ; k,o pouxat r t,t rr°.; ,+osec7 l;i o bJ rev�rx e« 't't o cjao, ; Kc;, t; yes; r: tsurnora to kac Count Would b:. J61 al , ' i000vor the 0r411nu+ e 'at obpl:.rxrts, ' i.f' not r*br`�xaate6 by the dovelcjiev,., #ejo U,,!,: d cost tl;se cunt) C� .enty not tri monti o ta�af w'i;c �rabl��a�s tJi :th noed.ocl ro��.c March 17, 1980 January': 2$, 1900' K-' VALLEY VTEW SUBDIVISION F IWDINGS 2 GR CERTIFICATION OF THE EN'VIRONMEN'TAL IMPACT REPORT .y d, I �w, TABLE OF CONTENTS Page , SUMMARY ® I. INTRODUCTION II. DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT -----_..„.. A. Location ---------------------------- B. - - Objectives Sought by F.T'c)posedProject�'-----`- C.. Description ofthe Projects T-echnical., - Economic & Environmental Characterist;IGs ------ 2 1. General Descri.ption--_.._-__------ 2. Surface,Drain Dr aosage - -_--- - - -- 3. S e�age Dsp al Methods 2 4• Solid Waste Disposal Method --;---_._ 5. Road Construction ------- ..__-�,: 8 _ 6. impervious Material. Covering Project Area-- 7. Square 4 Footage of Buildings - - - 4 8. Amount & Type" of Lighting inwProj ect4 9• Type & Construction of Perimeter Fenci.ng�- - 10. Amount 5 . & Type of Landscaping 1 l . Aes tlletic Des .gn of B ui ldil-igs & Prod ec t - - 1.2 'Utilities 13. Economic 'Cons.iderations _ - 5 __ 6 IxI. DESCRIPTION OF BN"VIRONMENTAL SETTING -- --_r_r-_-A. Topogra -- 7p B'oil ' Ty'es ?--_...-___.--_-�--___ -___ -_ 7 C. D. D. Surface - - - _ Drainage .. �, .--------------------- ',roximity; to Streams-�Chentels &~Flood- -.. 7. 7 E. 1s, �Tegetative Cope^ '1.0 F. mineral b'epos3.t: ---------_ - la G. Wildlife - ~ �' r _ H. _ Geological. T'c atures_.. i eismIcity - _ _ _-18 -- -:: J. .:.- _._,.._.-_..-- Arc haeolo ica1tor' c Sites w g i a 1 S a_ 14 : L. Gli.matES--___--.., .: land Uses 15 M. Populati,or N• Public Facilities & Uta�i-i'esyAyai" alai e - 0, - M - Project Accesses -•- _.. _ _ _ -_- ., 18 P _ Public Sentiment 19 , 19 .y d, I �w, i' IV. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT AND MITIGATION -----Y--------- 19 A. Environmental. Impact of Proposed_ Pro,jccL ---- 19 .. 1, Geology & Soils -"__-----,-_ ----_-_-_*� 2. Seismology ----------------- ------- .._...,�__. 2�� 3. Hydrology -------- -- - _-_-w _ 22 4. Vegetation -- - -----------2, 5. Wildlife -------------,_..__-___......._-__,__- _--_-__ . ___ -_. _ -__ -� 6. Schools------------------ 24 2'a -- _ - 7i Traffic ---" - - - -- �-- 26 8. Air Quality. 9 . Population Density & Land Use----,— 28, � 29 10. Water Quality & Availabil y -------------- 30 11. Noise - ------ --------------------------'--- 12. Energy Use & Resources --------- - 31 32 B. Adverse Environmental Effects Which ®Cannot - C. be Avoided Mitigation Measures Proposed to 32 `. Minimize Adverse Impacts ---------- .__.;"_., 33 Di Alternatives to Proposed Project ------ 34 F. The Relationship Between Local:Short-Term Uses of Man's Environment & the Maint'enan'ce Enhancement of Long -Term P'roductiw ty -"�-- E 35 F. Irreversible Environmental. Changes Involved in the Proposed Project 31 G. Growth Inducing Impact of the Pr, opos ed Prod ec't - - 36 ENERGY CONSERVATION ------ _..."._---------_- 36, APPENDICES, A. Map 3g V39, pcxnit�' Map G Tel tatie SuUdvision Map -- _.-- 40 D. Topographa. a'l. Quadrangle Map - _ . �, _ _ _ 41 E. Assessor's Parcel Map -� - G�2 F. _- - Archaeological Reporb, _�- ."_ - _-__--"_--___'� 43 G„ Average ;`Daily TrafficMap _ 47 H a Ma - - - . - _-- DramP ' 48 I. Chart - 'Drainage Sructures --"_ -� 49 J « ' ' • s & Persons Consulted Org Dinaion, - �„ L �' Cor�tiol 3o��'�� I,e-��er from S�L��e Water Quality M„ ... _ -. .. _ � � :, w ItitI' qql $tudy- Checklist 53 Y N. ;, Commends on l7ra $IR. and Responses - - SIlMN1ARY i C.Description of the projects Technical; Ek-:on-omic, And Environmental Characteristics 1. General. Description Valley view. Subd*vis.ion wi ll be t complete facility project designedand built in conformance with 'Butte County's lmprovempnt ;Standards for Subdivisions. The streets will be fully paved, 28 feet wide with native material: and/or paved gutters They will drain > into _:a rsurface drainage system consisting of _ underground conduit and concrete drainage inlets. Sewer- and water mai.la and .utility conduits will be situated under the roadway grid` will service individual lots totally underground from that, yroad' right -of way. Street lighting. and signs will be in plaaad accordance with Butte County requirements. The required and proposed improvements have been estimated to cost between $60(),000 and $700,000for the 1979 construction season. xnflaticn and rising construction costs wi ll obviously boost those estimates if the project is forestalled ,into subsequent construction seasons., ".' Surface Drainage The tentative proj ec° t map included -in this report as Appendix C also shows existing ground, contour lines, A completed project contour map would be nearly identical except in the area of roadways and driveways When the project is completed,' drainage from those parcels above t the streets will drain to the street rights-of"way, where it will be ,.olle cted into an underground storm drainage system. Parcels lower than the streets wi ,l continue to drain asthat partictt!ar location presently- does. The storm ciraiL syst m will consist of roadside gutters, concrete! collector boxes; ,and ie,—nforced. concrete pa.pes placed underground; This system will. disperse the collected c�rair�sge intoe two majox drainage ,swales curreiirly drai,rii.ng portions of the, project sate; the swat s which ,draari through Culverb '#237 and;Culvert X238 (See AppendiX H) .' At ntJ, point will water i=rom the storm dra%nage system be dt:tmped_ ,into, thrr Palermo Canal. Thirt percent of the ro`Oct ares. will c ' nu ` Y p p J ll o x e to dra5.n as i,t currently does. SI,xty pence It of the project area will drain to the most southwesterly corner; of the subdivision and pass under Dal. ale Avenue via Culvert #238 The remaining 1.0%' will' drain northerly along 0 e Avenue to CulVott C`rassing x237. 9 Type and Construction of Perimeter: Fencing, There is no perimeter fencing pros>osed. Aiso,. O.W.i.D, does not require fencing on either side of the existing open agricultural irrigation ditch traversing the project site. Individual lot owners, will undoubtedl y ins tail. ;fences of their own choosing as homes are built and occupied. 10. Amount and Type ,of Landscaping S ince plans do not exist to construct homes on the lots, neither, do plans exist to landscape lots upon completion of residences. Any landscaping will be done by homeowners. Within street rights-of-way and on vacant :Lots, all debris and slag resulting from improvement cons truc tion wi11 be removed as a part: of the construction contract. 11. Aesthetic Design 'of Buildingand Project J �l As stated above, the design of the homes that will be ;built within this subdivision llas not begun, in. that the developers of the subd:Lvision may not involve themselves in the construction of the houses., The: subdivision has been designed with a, uniqueness unlike most subdivisions in Butte County. Typical subdivision streets accomplish on y one purpose - theysimply provide access to one's "horde by the most inexpensIV and direct route. This results:. in most subd.vis, ion- homes being built in a :long;, rowoneither side of a sera ght and uninteresting street. Appendix C reveals that Valley View Subdi.visi.or has_been T,ai, out in a o as to manner p relief'to, the monotony 'oir barracks -type construction of; homes. The street design also', takes advantage of the natural contours of 'the project site rather than loo king do-wn into the yards and homes of res,cients and onto the bare roofs, most, of the homes Will be built having the privacy afforded by being at a higher elevation' Chari 'the' frontage street. 12, Util:�t�.es A11 to Gs within the 'subduis.aon will be -served undergraiind,' The following services Will, be 'supplied by ,the respective companies ,a� d°istricts: -5- i •� .r Pacific Gas & Ele Electricity` �;tric rGas Pacific Gas & Electric 1 Telephone pacific Telephone,,, Gable Television. Nor Cal. Cablevision rwater Uraville-Wyandotte Irrigatx.on District r� Sewer North Burbank Public Utility District All main and transmission lines will be colis'tructed Within the 'right-cif- roadway area, with service laterals stubbed to the be way line at each lot,. Meters, service boxes, etc., will the road right�of-�aay so that when the resp dences placed taithin are constructed,,, they can. tie to the various utilities at the ,r right-of-way line. r13: EconamLc C.onsideral.ions:. Due to the current escalation rate of property, r _ values in the Oxoville area, an accurate economic definition of the project is difficult to submit. However, estimates cal be -made; an current comparable- land values and building casts: On these, Uases, the following criteria will be used: value of Land$12,5'00 per lot t Value of Construction (homes) - $35 der square. foot :. 1 probable s,ze of homes - to be built 1425 square feet .1 Eighty subdiva.s on lots yield the f011o4�ing value. $ `00 000 ,,, 7:2 500 1 d x � 7. o tat `value of land (80 $: , ) � Tbtal:,value of conS.truction (8( 1425 _:k35) 41000,000 Total value of project $5,000,000 1 1 -g- i� J Using an assessed value of 25/ of the total Valia0 0$1,250,000,' X4.55 4100 assessed and an approa mate , Oounty tax.. rate of par value;: the property taxes xetur4ed to the Cou'nt'y` Mould be approxi,matelf $_5'& 5 per, year 0,3? x$''61,125 si:bgaoq,uoAt,to additional 0. annex ( 4 per, $100 assessed, value}.. atiox� to N.JLP.U. i DESCRIPTION OF;ENVIRONMMNTA!, SETTING A. Topography The project site consists of rolling foothill, type land. The property includes a low elevation of 480, and a high elevation of 610. One maj or Swale runs from the northeast corner of the parcel in a south/southwesterly direction, and eventual: y, 'atter leaving the project site crosses under Oakvale Avenue and drains into Wyman Ravine nearly one mile downstream.. On site, that swale has a maximum slope of IM about 0%. Slope on the overall site ranges up to . B. Soil, Types-. The soil coverrnathe pro ect site are entirely Aiken CD 3 clay loam as' designated on the U.S, Department, of Agriculture Sail Map. The soil is generally quite shallow 12 to 18 inches, with anticipated localized exceptions i_n the bottom of s�rales . Numerous rock outcrops were also noted., C, Surface Dr ainage The tentative project map included in this report as Appendix C also contains existing ground contours. These contours reveal= that the p;toj ect site i s c kized b;,r sma';ll, ephet feral: streams wh' h ultimately flow in es r7.y direction. These channels have a low to moderate gradient taxih a uiaxJLmum of 13%1. i Most d>lsc'l�axge ltcthe cin -site` channels i:s presenttly the, r�:Suit of direct store rLu1-off and has high peak. flows of short duration The is.rges t channel is the on one ° w 11 shows anyevidence of a sus tai,ned base flow,, However,. this flow is j calli:n , 'the stream more t. han minimal .at,d would not us of in.termitten�. The natural drainage pattern of the project site wa.s altered _ around the turn of the century, by construction of the Palermo Canal which traverses the site on a north to souCh course (See Appendix H) Since then the canal has collected the surface drainage from the areas to the east and, carried it to a point of overflow 700 feet southeast of the southeast corner of the = ect parcel. subject: p The spill from the overflow follows a natural drainage course to a 48 inch corrugated Imetal pipo, (culvert No. 241) crossing Oakvale Avenue 400 feet south of, Crane Avenue (See Appendix Z for existing rates of flow for Oakvale Avenue culvert crossings in the vicinity, of the pro' ec ) , Eighty percent of the project is currently drainedas descr;ibarl above. Tba t 20% of the site lying westerly of , the Canal drains via two natural swales running east to west; (See Appendices C & H). Surface drainage from, the northerly swalepasses under Oakvale Avenue through a ;30 inch corrugated metal pipe (Culvert #237, 'I Appendix H & 1). . Drainage from the southerly swale passes under Oaltvale Avenue through a 30 inch corrugated metal pipe' (Culvert #238, Appendix H,& Z) Culvert #239 °transports, drainage under Oakvale .Avenue from the major, swale traversing the project site. However, that porton w of the swale lying easterly of the Palermo Canal drains into that canal as discussed above.. Therefore, the culvert receives only that drainage flowing, into the swale from land lying. west of the � canal and from canal leakage. Leakage :f rom the Q.W. I D., canal in this area is substantial,. Zn fact, it is sof ficient to maintain a s toady stream flowing down this particular swaleri f Just below the point✓ in the swnle that receives the Banal leakage, a rock and mortar dam has been, constructed (apparently several t years ago), The ;clam, which is approximately thirty to forty feet Ni creates a small. and which �.s p probably six feet deep at the c f t e face o h clam. The ozld appears to o year .round. p pp overflow A residef ce has been Con t tucted immediately off' the face,of the clam on. the southerly sido. of the sz ale%, A wood deck° conneetS. the house to `the `top of the clam t�ritYi a differentI I "of no more than our. inches between the 'Ei tj 19h floor elevation of the house And the water surface: elevatiori of the pond, Evidence of c'ana�; overflara was vis ibl.e in this' area but information was not available or apparent regarding the. status of the dam and' residence during heavy, storm conditions." W 8.� -10- ' I7, Proximity to Streams, Channels and 1-'lood; Plains, `1.yhe s ubJ ect of streams and :channels,Jes discussed ab above under "Surface-Drainage". .J The project Site not lie s.ir to does any flood plains and is also outside the es t ably shed Lake Oroville "7nundation.Area" according to butte County nu,blic •inundation Works maps. •� This �.� would be El coded in the . �n reference t the area that event the dam Teta ning Lake bxovil le should be. destroyed,' There are, no aare pp nt surface springs on the ptraject site. E. Vegetative Cover The ve etation o g f the as a foothill oak-woodland ' subject area can be classified savannah of grassland. Scattered shrubs g - with scattered >open areas are a also present, No evidence was _found, of any rare or endangered species on the study area, either in field observation or in the course of research for this ro' ett, p J The. following vegetation 'List has been compiled on the basis of field observationublished p works and personal tommunications. It is not meant to be exhaustive, but to represent the main species which co;u.ld be expected in the area. PARTIAL ',VEGETATION LIST C ommbn Name scientific Name I M TilUe oak Quercus douglasij Scrub oak, Quercus dumos a bigger pine Pinus sabiniana Sour dock Rumex hymenosepalus s Ma antanit Arctostaphylos spp ' Poison oak Rhus divers i 1: :b Comm`on cat-tail Rypha lat-ifolia Rush Maiden-hair fern Jancus spp, Thistle Adiantum e-Arginaturn C'irciUM Yarrow at dersonii Wild' bu.cicwheat Achillea 7anulosa Golden yarrow Eriogontun spp, Common mullein Eriohyl'lum l.anatui Uea. c ,as um thaps us nnuel grasses (saveral� -- _ -10- j; F, Mineral Deposits There is no field evidenc reference to, deposits' sandian of minerals oroof the site, gravel on G Wildlife The _ study e ria s u ors pp a diversity o;G terrestrial animals as well as an abundance of bird species. A number o arboreal (tree -duelling) rodent species are = alsopresent,The grass and shrub habitat tends to favor anima] s �esociated 'with more open areas f-o,und in grasslands, includin g a number of small burrowin mammals: and insect s g / eed e�►.ting birds. Where vegetation on the site becomes more scrubby than usuall associated frith a grassland, rabbits, bush y -tits, and several other small birds are found, These areas folia e of relatively dense g provide excellent protective shelter for Wildlife- ild ife.Riparian Riparian area vegetation on the site , �s an important c`ontr.butor to the area's food chain CI, . serves as a faod su 1 r.. consumed directly by ;some species, or utilized, pa as breedings area for insects , re tiles a . hich consumed at Higher levels in themfood�cha nans are in turn No' evidence was found ol; any rare or ende,ngered species in the study area; either' in field observation j o research for r in the course Of this report. i' The following wildlife list has been compiled on the bas's field abservai:ionpuUl.ishcd of work8, and personal comma`°ic ons 7t is not meant to b;e exhaustive, but to represent the main species which could be expected i.n the are of Wild Ire ma he a,` Many other species Y present as vagrants, from tmeo as seasonal. travelers. time, ;or 11.-; I;® PARTIAL WILDLIFE LIST Common Name Scientific Name Mammals Black Taal Deer Odocoi.l.eus he,t:i r,nus Badger Taxidea taxus' Bobcat Lynx rufus 'Coyote Canis latrans California ground squirrel; Citellus beechcyi Red Fox Vulpes £uwa �9 Western gray squirrel Sciurus griseU8 Valley pocket, gopher Thomomys bottae Western harvest mouse Reithrodoatomys megalotI Deer mouse Peromyscus maniculatus Porcupine Ercfi'nizon dorsatum California mole Raccoon Scapanus latimanus Procyon lotor, Striped 'skunk Mephitis mephitis gingtail cat Bassariscus astutus -`Reptiles; S+Tesfern fence lizard Sceloporus. occidentalis Skink Eumece8 spp: Western NA iptail ° Cnemil dophorus tigri_s Rubber snake Charina bottae Racer Coluber constrictor ' Common Ming sna e Lampropeltis getUlus # " Garter snake Thamnophis sirtalis i r Wes tern rattlesnake ,` Crotalus viridi.s Birds t Turkey vulture Cathartes aura Sparrow ,hawk, Falco sparverius ;' XZ od-- tai ed hawk But J amaic ens is Sharp,,shinned hawk Accipiter stria tus Mountain quail, � �l Oreortyx pieta Mourning doge Zenaidujra macroura Band tailed pigeon Coltunba i asga.ata Owls �- Otu s spill, .Asio spp. Bubo s p0: Tyto `spp. -�n eclted heasant Rang n il Phasian us c o lchic us ' Rei - RI h Bald Eagle Wild turkey Halia.eetus jeU.CO Cephal4iS Vireos Meleagris gall.opavo Phainopepl_a Vireo spp Orange -crowned warbler Phainopepla ni ens Vermitrora Black -throated graywarbler Brewer's blackbird celata Dendroica_, �. ; lctechia Bullock's oriole Euphe,g'us c . y�tnocepha;lus icterus Blackheaded grosbeak Brown towhee cucu�ll�atus Hedymeles mO14n.ocephalus Purple finch P .pilo fuse's House finch Carpodacus Purpureus Lawrence'sgoldfinch Carpodacus mexicanus Greenbacked goldfinch S}?inus lawrcncei Spinus psal.Lr.i.a Chi Chipping sparrow Larks parrow Spi.zella pas s eri,na " Anna's hummingbird Chondestes, gran�macus Violet green swallow Woodpeckers Calypte antra Tachycneta thalassina. Western wood peewee Dendrocopus;, SPP, ContoPuus Purple martin sardidulus Progne s ubis CroYa ScrubCorvus J,ay brachyrhynchus Steller jay Aphelocoma rOeruleseens mape Cyanoclellow-billed i°tta s tell�ri Pica te-breasted nuthatciz muttalliWhi Sitta carolinensis Chickadee Bush. -tit Parus rufescens Titmouse PsOltriparus minimus House vixen Bewick Paras inornatus Troglo.dyteS t Caren ; aedoti Thzyoman.es ®. Western bluebird bewicki �1 Blue . raY g gna�c catch � � glia Polioptil.a caerulea H. Geologic Features M This,, his region is characterised b and `sedimenta.ry rocks which trolcanic j are intrudedybmetamorphosed and plutons of granitic origin;. 'lhe y several batho7.ithsi P road belt of n�el.a ' that lutons to proj ec'L a;� tis is,. situad in is ,l=ocated between the east aolcthe nd the Cent rel the granitic Va�,ley ;alluvium on the c�'" h os t � , y 'k t' The rock types found in the area are Mesozoic in ago or older. Bedrock material consists ,;of metamorphosed rocks which have been subjected to low-grade regional. metamorphism. These rocks contain about 60 percent hornblende and approximately 40 percent Mquartz, of any or all of the following minerals; epidote, :feldspar, clinozoisite and chlorite, with concentrations generally decreas in.g in the. order given., This rock usually appears massive, al ally rough schistose` ,structure, which is accentuated by weatheri.•ng, is not uncommon.. The rocks are considerably sheared, but by small faults and strongly" jointed as a result of deformation and intrusion. .joint systems- are quite pronounced and cause the exposed surface to appear blocky. Weathered outcrops occur at various locations on the propertybut predominate along the ridge area, Erosion on the property appears to, be minimal., with,sl.opes and �. channels presently stabilized. Mass movement activity appears to be negligible, being Limited to localized soil. creep that should present few problems to construction. Seismicity 1. prior to August 1: 1975 the Oro 1110,: area eras g , generally considered to be aa .n area, o£ low seismic ac<tiva ty, On that date; however, an 'earthquake measuring 6,. 2 on the Richter., Scale shook the Oroville area, causing considerable damage to some of the > old 'huildlugs in the area;„ princi:pal.l.y fthose of,, brick, block or, concrete construction, Chimneys fireplaces,, walls; And other, structures ,af, masonry cons tri oc ,4..on y were also damaged... Mast of the £game b'u.ildings weathered the earthquake. very well, "'the greatest- damage being, the 7.oss..o£ '' large windows.. ;Overall, the damage throughout the urea was,' s et at :several million dollars; which included Losse.; o£ merchandise from 8t- or` e shelves. Some minor personal injuries were reported, but there was, not loss 0£ 7.i£e Aftershocks; some of the Magnitude o£ 51 .0 on the kichter Scale, have,been felt periodically since, The epicenter for this large earthquake was determined to be between Oroville and Palermo, which would place it approximately 4 miles southwest of the project site. Since the August lst earthquake, the -entire California Foothill area is considered to be potential earthquake area and a new look is being taken at existing building. codes and safety precautions. J. Archaeological and Historical Sites in the Arra Members of the Department of Anthropology California State University, Chico, conducted a records search ,anal on-site inspection. They determined that no 'sites oz- archaeological importance exist on the project site (See Appendix, F). K. Climate Climatic data is not available for the immediate Valley View Subdivision area. However, an Oroville "weathei station occupies approximately the same elevation as the project site;. That station's, data can, be assumed to apply adequately to the subject development; Historically; precipitation averages around 35 inches per year occurring primarily as rain; but occasionally as snow. In the, period 1973 to i97n however, precipitation averaged about 29 :inches per year. (See Table l) . The mean annual temperature at the Orovillc station is 62,66F.; ' the highest recorded temperature is 112'5F. and the 1,owes t one is 24°F. The prevaili.n; winds are southerly in origin clueing ;most of the year'; but so e winds during the wI ter ;have a northerly origin. 'rThese fti.gures are for years 19737.976, Ml�3 9�No® f®IE TABLE 1 PRECIPITATION SU1�' (.Inches) OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 1973 -;1976 Jan Feb Mar AQr M�y_.% Jun%{ JTul* A. She Oct-k Nov"',' Dec' Monthly Max, 12.21; 10.65 7.27 2.31 . 23 .21 1,60 .56 1404 3.51 10.04 5.94 Mean 4.79 5.96 4.30 1.54 .14 .19' .54 .27 .49 2.56 4.12 3, 82 Monthly Min. 489' 2.35 .90 .1.2 .08 .16' .0 .0 .0 1.87 .86 2.61 TABLE 2 TEMPERATURE 'SUMMEIRY (F OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA, 1973.1976 Jan Feb Mar° Mia r�" June ,7u1%f A fe Oety',Noir' .� Dec_,e I431:ghest 73 - 71 79 90 101 107 ' 112 105 104 99 79 68'` Avg. Mix. 54.9` 59:7 62, 69. 1 65 6 91, 3 9`4.8 92.1 89.1 , 77.8 61,4 54.`9 Mean 46.1: 50.8 52.8 60.1 69`,9 76.5 79.6 77' 74.1 64.8. 52.4 47.0 Avg., Min: 37.3 41:.;8 43.5 46 55.7 61,7 64i 3 62014 59 51.7 43.4 39,''1 Lowest 24 29 30 34 36 45 52. 52 51, 37 32 27 Satirca; GlIrm ological Data,, U.S. pepartinent off° Commerce %)bans' not incidud value from 1976, " L. Land Uses ® The project site at present stands as. open land, without apparent specific use. Abandoned, ` dilapidated buildings on the site reveal that the parcel has'historical use as a re8idence. It most likely also hada soma form of agricultural application as indicated by the random inter- �! spersing of citrus and, predominantly, olive trues. The. project site is surrounded by land having several uses ® ranging from agricultural, to single -.family rosideintial, to �9 educational. At the time this report ,was bei ttg prepared, another single-family residential subdivision had been submitted to, .Butte County for tentative approval on. a 21.2 acre parcel situated on the west side of Oakvale Avenue, directly across the street from the project site. If approved, k , as tentatively submitted, it will contain 70 to 75 lots.; The remaining large, open parcels'in this general vicinity, having access to public. sewer facilities realistically have no other economically feasible_ use than that which is proposed for. this project. The soil depth and level of fertility does not provide the wherewithal to make agricultural enter- prises profitable.. M: Population t In 1975, the Butte County Planning Department conducted a special census. The following data was taken from that data, with the figures shown representing a 3,,1-s quare mile area literally s,arround' g the project site. The sample area is bounded on the north by State highway,162 (Olive; Highway) ; on, the ;south "by, Mt Ida Road;. on, ;the west by Foothill. Bou1evard, and an the east by the Qroville :Lateral q.W.I.D. drainage canal (Kelly! Ridge),. Toi:a1 single-famil hotts ti units 4b Y g 9 .. Total Vacant Units 22 To tal Ito us elzolds 4141 Hdu ehcsld1'opulation1.30" Population per lTousehold 3. Q5 Total Population 1397 OPopulation Under 18 Yrs .'' 471 ,(3016) Po u.lation 5 yrs. to ll rs elementary) 1,7�i (13%) p Y y C Popula,tiott 12 yrs . to ] 3' yrs . (Jr., High) 68 (5%) Population 14 yrs . to 18 yrs,. (Ha.gh) 125 (9%) Population over, 65 1,14 (87/0) Median Age 29:4 Male Population 709 (5r%) Female Population 686 (49%) To °determine what population trends N4111 resu:l,t from the subject project, the percentages shown above will be applied,. However, it ,should be noted that even data from this repre- epre-sentative area wall result in accurate projections due sentative.not to the fact that existing res;i,dents will not necessarily, have the same social characteristics as the people who would be a newly constructed subdivision home or buying a, purchasing newly developed subdivision lot on which to build their own, home. However, no other more accurate means of approximation exists. ` With, this probability noted, the following. projections are submitted based on said 1:975 census. Given: 80 subdivision lots All lots fully developed and sold Population per. household = 3'.051. Projection for Subdivisiofti., `total population244 Total elem.i school. age pd, pulataKon - 31 Total, Jr. High School age population - -- 12 t l Total kigh School age Popta.la;tion - 22 x Total popul ata.on under lS yrs . -- .. _ Total population over 65 yrs: ----,- --- 1:9.5 tionTotal Male Popul 124.4 Total Female population. 119 , 6 N. Politic Vac;ilities and Utilities Available 11 Utilit,es The project sate` as served U all utilities► ' E telephone - will. be, Electricityy Will be provi ed by P.G4& . , p provided by Pacific Tel:ophone, water will b,e distributed by btoville-'Wyandotte l r gstion Dxs' rice; sewer wiII be prove ded by North Burbank Publya Util rty District; attcl solid waste disposal will be hndl.ed by private contracts r � -18- 4 2. Community Services The Oalcvale Avenuearea is provided with police and fire protec=tion consist* ent with the rural. location. The Butte County Sherif f's Office regularly patrols the area; dire 1 protection is provided by ButteCounty, in c-ooporat-ion. with the California Division of Forestry. Other'serv;t,ep.s ayeprovi. e:d by fac ,liti_es located in Orovil,lt. : Education is provided by the OrovIlle Element _OVy School; District for .grades K through 8, and Orov'i lle Unioa� Hlgt-t School Distr.i.ct for grades 9 through121 . 0. Project Accesses The main arterial access to thi project is St ate 1� Highway 162 (:Olive Highway). . This Iiiiks the �Y ub j ec t area ® to the Urban facilities of Orovil'le; the :recreational facilities � of Dake Oroville and the mountain. areas above;, and the transportation facilities of the State Tlighway ;ystm, The project is situated :0--40 Mile youth of %zighway;'1629 gaining` access by aakva'l.e Avenue which fronts the proposed subdivi5 ion (See Append .x G for magi deuctl bing the most. rec��a� t Butte Count Public W. y Works and Cal Trans �'A�terage llaily Traffic Counts". P. Public Sentiment At a recent public Bearing concerning tho necessity of th.i s report, many. residents of the Orovl.le vi.c i.tzity -some neighbors of the pro,�ect and som.e''who , although they were not residents of the immediate area, were. apOarently concei;a ed in principle, - voiced concerns aver several elements of the project. Among the ms in_ paints raised were concerns regarding traffic; impacts on Ophir EIemen.tarSchool y (add acertt to R project' s.itc) , wildlife .and aesthetics, and. pos'siBle contamination of O.W.C.D. s Palertna Canal. IV,1. ENVIRONMENTAL, IMPACT AND MITTGATLON A i The Environmental Impact of • the Propos ed Pro j ec t 1 Geology and Soils Impact; Some s lopes in tile ' ro ` Ect construct' P J pn , area a:ange up to 13% Exc4 ati_on for roadways, axad driveways" may yield minor probleiias with" 1:60.k si:abil.ity, I�iilsl/ oes..— 1 w _ Mitig ation: Avoidance of oversteepoaed slopes in construction and utilization of proper enginaej;i.ng practices should minimize any such effects,," Impact: Ground rua ce during construction could produce geomorphic impaction is potentiated by , removal of vegetation during cons P.';LI Ion of roadway improve- mems driveways', an structures, as well as Uy the involved native soil disturbance. Mitigation:. Cons traction activity shouldbe, completed in one season, with; a revegetation program initiated for disturbed areas. The following revegetation specifications are exemplary of a mitigating plan: All areas disturbed by construction shall be revegetated. Seeding, or other planting shall be done as soon as possible and practical after construction is completed. Unless steep slopes,can.be roughened later; they should be seeded Immeadiately, while their surfaces are still loose. Proper planting bed preparation and planting is, extremel;y important. A minimum of 41' of topsoil shall be placed on sterilE areas, Cut ,slopes shall be scarified horizontally , prior to placing the topsoil. When seed is to be broadcast; the surfaces shall be roughened to provide a place for seed and fer'tili'zer to lodge and be covered by the action of rain ' in order to provide 'germination and "stand establishment; On Vet y critical areas,. sprigging, plugging or sodding' of plan ting. - materialsfolloraed by irr-igat'ion for establishment may bd des'i.rable. Such materials mins tl be p lamed firmly into moist. t� soil. Irrigate before planting on dry sites. areas other than those to be completely sodded _shall be mulched. A uniform mulch cover of weed-free straw, hay bar% or wood chips will be used. I f hay, or, straw, is us ec1, ' i t shall be spread over the: seeded , area at they rate Of on hundred pounds per` 100 s ft. Tt shall be applied 'byl hand. Toprevent removal of straw by wind; it sl�al:L be attached to ; the surface by "'punching"' or "tackii �4 th ,a spade, or 'by f i_l�,er nettiri . w 20- 'be Heavy j ute netting, l 2 to 2 inch mesh can used to, protect seeded slopes. The netting should, be properly stapled and anchored to the slope. Wood fiber mulch at 35 pounds ` per, lOQO sq.ft, may also be r used instead.of straw, if it s applied hydraulically. it can be either applied immediately following seeding and fertilizing ;or applied in a slurry with the weeds and ` fertilizer. This method is advantageous on, s,t..es where rocks or' terr;aan prevent preparing an adequate seedbed. Planting completed prior to autumn rains shall. be irrigated as 'necessary to maintain ,good growth. Planting materials: _ Lbs , Lbs. /1000 Acre S q.. F t . 1. Tegmar xn termed i.ate Wheatgras s or Arriba Western Wheatgrass or Luna ®; Pubescent Wheatgrass 25 .75 I�1 2. Durar Hard Fescue or Potomic Orchardgrass 10 ,50 3. White Dutch, clover or Ye17ow Sweet clover0 or Latina Caeer 'Mi.lkvetch lq .50 4. Sodding matpraal to be Kentucky B luegras s Fertilizer;; Use 16--20-0 or, another slow release ertilazer approved by the Engineer, applied at a rate o£ 250 pounds per acre CS'.7 pounds per 1000 sqt.) . The Owners shall make ` sLipp lemental. sprang ,applications as needed at a rade o 3.5 pounds ,per x.000_ sq:.t: Tl1e reveget'ation program; s�l,�►all be apart of the total pro3 ect ` undertaken by the Developers ,.21_ r f 2; .. Seismology Impact; Although no evidences of azx active' Fault on the site can be found, and no such evidence is 114plied n the Geological Literature dealing with the area, the of known faults to this rojcct- proximity p ., �� - prevents the ignoring of this impact. As a result of the August 1,, 1975 eaa:thquke in the O;avil e area, it must be considered that ea-thquakes of magnitude 6 (Richter) or greater can accux anywhere in the - foothills of the Sierra Nevada, even through the overall seismicity of Butte Co.unty is lora, Mitigation: S" g trcetures in this project should comply with the highest safety precautions for design and construction recommended for seismically acture areas., 3. Hydro I ipact The possibility exists that surface contaminants will be carried into Wyman Ravine and the O,W, g z. D irrigation on canal raith storm water, runoff. initial. , contaminants would be oa.ls and Phenols; ot3.'ginating from paving operations and construcr�:on cauipment,. Upon project completion, tyocal`contaminants would, be oil, products spired On the street and parking areas by automobiles, and nitrates and phenols from :�ertil.izers Used in the landscaped areas. _ gation: Roadway construction should be timed to be completed before the heavy 1 precipitation period beginsin D11bc1ec.re0il "; henals ori x:natin from pavi �� p g- g ng oera� Qns Operations as in conCentra,tion as the pavement ages.. Michael Messina of O.W.I.b, stated that they are not concerned that thle. Palezmo Canal irrigation ditch mightreceive con- tamnants frdm the completed project hocno sites. The ditch: is primax`il;y for lrr.gation purposes rather than domestic,Cxse,` anci, any resulting contamination would be tmo insigri,f cant to raarrant spec;i.fic mitigation. X22- Bird life, for the most part, will not be as affected by Oie project. Exceptions will be, ground nesting birds which ;ball prey to domestic cats. Native rodent populations would also be adversely affected, by the increase in domestic animals normally associated with new residential a�;eas. Sp, cies tolerant of residential life, such; as the English sparrow and house mouse would be, expected to locally increased Mitigation: Mitigation recommended measures the Vegetation chapter of this report should be reviewed.Residents should be made aware of, and encouraged to respect wildlife in the area. Domestica should not be allowed to roam the area om indiscriminately. Natural vegetation should be preserved to the fullest extent; revegetation: should be carried out on all d�s i uxbecl areas native possible extent., Where species native yeaetatonis not used,a substitute species such as Russian t' ive (Elaea nus angustifelia) should be,planted because of its desirability as a food and cover species for wildlife. 6: Schools xm` act: A develo meet of the type proposed is p p a ,signifi.caf t generator of school age populatiotiz. As discussed earlier the contribution by this project to the Oravill e r Elementary_.School Distract opula:t� on would be 31, students p" . Mitigation: The maximum allowable enrollment: at Ophit E"l zb4tary School, (K,-•6trh) is 3810. The 197879 enrollment was 330. The anticipated ated 1915-80 enrollment+ is 3806 r6r the 1978 79 <school year, there were 25 additional students in Or" s district over` and above hol 380 s tadent capacity; phi The extra 25 were bussed. to Wyandotte Schopl which had vacancies. Oroville Elementary School District Superintendent Harold" Corn states' that" the increase,;d excess., enrol merit" created by" the proposed development c�oulrl be m�ti " ated just t as it has been g ' .t in the past. Extra students would be transporue by bus to of:her schao s JL {:he dist~.xict that ire not at maximum einrolln�ent: - 25-- Corn said that on a whole, the Distract is experiencing a decrease in student population of 20 to 30 students per year. I (1-2%) , Ophix is the, only school, in the district faced with maximum en-oll.ment. Across the district there are 6or 7 clrRssroom facilities not in use for full class purposes. �I The District . can not , qual fy for State cons tr( got Z.on funds to ' be :applied to a new school, for tz.,p foothill a,„ea or for the e,)tpatsio.n. of existing facilities at Ophir si.ncc the district a' as a crhole can not show a maximum enrollment s tatis tic . S tate funds are available nn.ly to districts in which all facilites are at maximum enrollment. This proposed development will not create a now or unique problem for Ophix School. The Ophir, facility serves the foothill area which, within the last decade, has experienced one of the highest growth rates in Butte County. That growth will continue or. decline independent of i the status of Valley View Subdivision. As Long as there is a demand for housing in the foothill area, Ophir School, will be faced with its ,current situation - maximum enrollment: 7. Traffic rImpact:' The Butte County Environmental Review DepC1,rtrnent suggests t=hat a residential- development of the type Proposed,, when complete could generate 7 trips per day per dwelling unit. A trip is defined as a single vehicle movement f with either an origin or destination within the subject area. Eased on this ratio, the proposed, Valley View Subdivision Will. r generate an average of 5617 trips per day. As revealed in the earlier -discission, "Population", the median anticipated age of residents is 29.4. Thex;efore, the majority of the subdi.vision's households will, have members of the community's' working7force. Existing crita cad. peek hoar traffic condit.ons 'chat'` exist at the intersection of Highway 162 and 0alwale Avenue will `be amplified with the, addition of :the traffic generated by this development. Al$o, traffic p oblems could arise at the ntexsecticin of Oakval.e Avenue aad the only entrance to the subdivision.: 26- y® 560 tris per day generated by this projec Assuming all of theP (an assumption which, y�.�:1.ds maximum use Highway .x.62 dor access results ; although unrealistic) , the resulting contribution to 7"% tkxat roads average daily traffic volume is an additional. contribution to Oakvale Avenue's (ci'e, Appendix G). The. resulting average daily traffic volume between Highway 162 and the protect entrance would be 52% based on the above a'ssumptl oft rans s presently completing a Itigatlon Cal 'G:i reconstruction :design for the section of Highway l62 from 0 'oville Quincy Highway) to above the below the intersection at intersection of Ward Boulevard. TI - project wil'1. involve widening Highway 162 to provide full uninterrupted traffic Janes f or three involved inter- together with left turn pockets all g p The project will also involve an accelerati.un approach sections. and greater sight distance at the Orov I lle Quincy, �IS.ghway anter- s ec ti ori ,. Construction commencement is set for the summer Of 19800 �- Jim Swain, Cal Trans 'Project Design Engineer, >states that involving traf'f'ic s .gnals for t'he aUove-hated advanced planning intersections is not ]_n progress at this time, According be ng to Swain, traffic s� gnais would probably problein�contributi at this time. He did say, howevor, that rather than remeda.al after the idening project is bui lt, traffic signals might be ' , considered dor tk-ie,,future depending on the increase in average on traffic daily ;traffic;, effect on the rnew charnelzaticn plan the intersection. and accident occurrence at. mov.emeat, - Butte Co�rnty Publ,i.c' Works Department revealed at Preliminary they would condition: S ub divis 1.an App lit sat;:on hearings, that, approval of the project with the requirement to . tentative p construct- ,not only a publictoad approach at the entrance to, or►g the { the subdivision, but also to widen Oaltvale Avenue al r om O�cva tr ocf~ a ].eft turn lane f.. le p onta e andcons venueintothe pro, c.ct. When constructed,. the left turn lane gill permit uninterrupted sa, e turning 43,tuat7:on into flaw Oftraffic and also creato' a the s'uUdivisiott. be may introduced into the atmosphere here by Increased numbers of automobiles resulting from the proposed protect is:dependent upon a number of, interdependent factors, such as ambient tempeta•to.re, engine temperature , grade of fuel., the driver. type of trip (i.,e. > speed and number of s•tazts or stops) , size of eng, ne, condition of engine, year of manufac; tura and, distance traveled. Because of theseunknown variables, estimates of: pollutants generateduon Occupation --)f the P p fi�rod ec C are , best madcby using data based on average compos�,t� emission factors compiled by the California State Air ResourcC$ Board. According. to these calculations,a light-duty vel-icId will generate 43 19 - grams of pollutantser mile of travel: P The Zigure includes, in addition to hydrocarbons and oxides:, 36 grams of carbon dioxide, Assuming that each of 560daily, trips estimated for the project When I t is comp le he has an average 'length of 10 miles, it can be, calculated that the average daily pollutants, generated by the vehicles Would be some 242 UOQ grams, which is equivalent to approximately 530 pounds. Statistics are not available for existing automobile pollution accurrerlces in the East Greville y� area. , However, for purposes of comparison, the estimated composite emissions from gasoline dr iven mntar vehicles in the Sacramento County area is estimated:to be 969 tons day. per r Mitigation; NO mitigation measures are proposed o developer 'i yer W7,'L res pact forautomobile-caused air pollution. HoWe�rera it 'is note�h d that Signa .call, t progress P g ss has been madebythe State and Federal governments in this,field. The effect of traffic exhaust �. s not s ign:i_f'cant' at thin time because the meteorological conditions do nota llbw a C.o'ncentrati:on of pollut;an;ts to build to any significant level, Dust generated by Mid td ;cons truci ion activi ties will be mitigated to a large degree by the standar l practice of ,Using dater to control, Particulate matter as well as aiding in the cotpacti;on process Any on-site burning will be conducted under the , rov�is; the :Butte County7llrClx;l7g; orclinslZees'. ' P a_nns of 9. Population Density and Land Use lmpactc This, pro, ect would result in the location o,f, 8.0, lots on 29.9 cores: J3ased on 1,975 J3ui~te County census pal culata.rins estimating 3.•(l5 persons per` dwellin g. hs �d.evela p Haonleltiit meat �vouhd res t in the lQcat�,on 0, 24� p p � ' an By the time .nater reaches the channel of Wyman Ravine from the project area, it has received tribute ry contr ,b'utions from as '! IV 11,ighwciy at Heritage Itotd) . It far east ,as Kelly Ridge ((71i has traveled through numerous under-road culverts, received xunaEf :E:com thousands: of ,sciu��r..e feet of paved roadway, d iveway, and pa.r'Lsing 'tai: surfaces, ,and `been- polluted by the chemicals froim hundreds of lawn; and orchard fertilizers, p.esticide:y and herbicides. I:jz reality, even if, contaminants aou:ld each• Wyman Ravine from than development their percentagr , ;im',rease in. tot a. voluni,e. would be immeas urab Iie Trnpar.t;; The two units x4il1. placya gre4a•te demands' on the water ,,Ltp:pl.y system (Oroville-Wyandott;e Ira:ig;atioia, District) . I�Iitigat ion.: xhe proj ect cons tr.ucticyn will,. inV�o1'vei the extension of existing O.W.I.D, facilities in compl.i n.ce with that Districts standards and 'regairements. 'rh,i! qu."ll,•it�of 0,W.1.D. Is Seater is excellent 'kith the exception of some ttsrba d;i�t~y al1d that District has the resources to gi�intain that civa,li ty, The District is involved in. �n.gaing e�Ecarts o> repair and new construction to offset the effe�.ts' of area devel.,opment and future d:rou ht conditions. No moratoriums exist ar ars plantized far the future e concerning new hook.-ups . Nois tE: z xmpar_t.. Local arca naffse levels jaill increase: mbderately during construction of roadst+ays 'and str�xctures. After the Luiits ,ire Complete,' thE: nominal increase in area no levels will result from trafC:Ie noise and home (.;Lie. ! u Tvia;t,igation: Const:i:uction should 'be limited to i� those hours general l,' designated as ll otki ag hours' « This will prevent residen is Exam bei,nl, und��ly d sturUed during hours of sleep or, t artily relax, _:ion'. Txo ie tzse noise wil`L .n.at 'be s igni:Eicant7;y different than exi-5 Ling noise. Alsa, J.t is noted that rec eitt ame, ndmefttg to b ui l di•n Codes- as they affect c oix, ,v - ti .ial structures do address themselves to the auditory' env ron- ment, It; may be anticipated 't.hat residential s, truoturos of the immediate future' wild. cortai.more noise-recluci'ng f;at�tres than ', has been e case hea:etofore. i' §corm drainage collection system will transport it to a, discharge point, at a much faster rate than it would travel, via A surface runoff route. The, project, however, will not , disturb the present drainage patterns. 4. The net effect of this project will ncreast the population density of the site from zero to 244 people which will be a significant. increase for the area. 5. There will be an increased demand for pub I' services, i.e. fire and police protedtion, public transportation ' and health care facilities. 6 , There will be an increase in traffic flow as a result of the residential development. The primary impact will be on oakvs.le Aventle and State highway 162. This traffic ,ad flaw will have at),verse effect on ambient air quality,. 7 Tr:are drill be a change of aesthetic surroundings by the conversion of the present h"illside Ija.rcels into residential, lots', $. There will be an increased demand for utilities s uch asgas electricity, Y r,, and` Ovate C;. Mitigation Measures Proposed to Minmite Adverse Impacts 1, A. utilities within the protect Site will be under round, A draina e s s teshouldm be provided for any underground vault to facilitate access and tnaiGenatzce of utilities. J 2. A tree ,easement will: be established along a U' portion of the westerly, subdivision boundary to insure preyervati0o,of the existing mature trees,, . 3. Detailed mitigation neasures wero' discussed fuli - under indxvl.tlual the, Sect t� a.ans o C Ezlvironment 'al; impact of the pr 0pos ed Project" , � M ` i. .. D. Alternatives to the Proposed Project I., : No project: This al:ternativa would eliminate the impact on area residents who wish to see the parcel. remain undeveloped. This option could be accomplished' by a sale of the property: 2. D3LVision by Parcel. Map: The, existing owners or- ® the land could divide the project site intofourparcels by �l this means. This would reduce a number o£ impacts to a degree. This type of a division would create more of a rural atmosphere., This would also decrease the density from that proposed. Individuals purchasing the created, parcels would be under few controls, however, regardin, the quality of structures that - would be built, the roadway improvements other than a 20' wide gravel road could not be imposed b;• the Butte County Advisory Agency. Howwever, construction of ;sewer limes wouldnot'be __ economically feasible., 3., Planned Ares-Cluster. Zone: The PA.-C. Zone could be an alternative to the project. It' would allow greater reservation of open areas but would encompass more of a multi- family concept of development, The impacts on the area Would be reduced from those of 1.the proposed prof ect. In a P.A. --C. the residents own that portion of the structure forms the, ,which envelope of their living "space. Community ownership of non- living areas,is involved in the concept. Approval by the. Plahning Commission of a rezone of the area would be req;ui,retl. t 4.+ Reduction of living units: A reduction of impacts, would result, to a slight degree by reducing the ,number of lots in the d'errelopmont: However;, the off-site improvement tequi're- ments of the Butte County; Department of Public Works would t F remain, the same even though the" he prof ect size was ,:educed. This i would mean that any reduction would effect a subst:an.tial. i.ncrease in per-u,it-casts for` the .remainder of the development. Sub- stantial reductions would 'dest oy the projocts economic feasibility. -34- Y' E. The Relationship Between Local Short -Term Uses of Man's Environment and the Ma-intenance and Enhancement of Long --Term productivity In assessing the benefits of this at development ' p time . at this location as =opposed to long term maintenance of the status quo, certain consideration must be taken into account. These include the comparison of this 'Location with other loci -- tions suitable for this type of development, the development patterns of the area involved and theplanning, gnats of the area involved. Implementation of this project will substant;ial`Ly reduce the number of options available in the future, 'Rhe reduction in the number of available future options may result in a decrease in long- term productivity. However, the proposal will convert lands which have historically been used agriculturally - and recently not been used - to residential uses" The devel.cr�aers believe the project is justified now because of the market demand and because any other uses which might occur, in the , future may at that time be incompatible with surrounding land uses., The Proposed project is not out of rhythm with activities: ' now presently found 8L.Long Oakvale Avenue. Long term maintenance of the status quo is probably the most desirable future for 'the pro ec p J t espeQiall,y as far as tacit residents are concerned. However, currently adapted planning goals foresee low . -medium density residential develop- meat a.s imminent for property in the project area. To require the' owner of a large piece of property. to leave his lana in an undo eloped coadita.on p ' " s o Ghat l local residents may enjoy;; the . q continued maintenance of their own private park is ur,reali'st�c, especially in the light of current area develoPmen"t `patterns. Irreversible Environmental Changes Involved in' the } )?to used Pr " ec t p � 1. 'Chere to . _ l be an increase in storm water runoff with accompanying degrease in absorption rates.acally due to compaction and over -covering of the soil C�Nth impetv,1-Us .material. U A. Insulation and other protectLon from heat loss or heat gain to conserve fuel used to heat or cool, buildings, B Use of resource conserving forms of energy s uc1-. as solar energy for water and space heating, wind for opera`t7.ng pumps, falling water for generating electricity and 'heat pumps. C. Energy efficient building design including.,such features as orientation of structures to summer and 'winter sunlight to absorb winter solar heat and reflect or avoid summer solar heat: D. Measures to reduce energy consumption in transP'orta- tion such as 1.. Providing access to alternative means of transportation for people such as bus lines',, mass transit, Y bic:ycl,t_ 'lanes, pedestrian facilities, and car pooling. 2. Use of small cars rather than large cars where «' possible. 3. Use of alternative means" of shipping which, al],ow for energy Savings. E. Efficient lighting practices including use of indirect natural light, use of efficient lightin.g. fixtures and/or sources, establishment of reasonable li,ghti.ng criteria to prevent' over I illumination;, an rd minimum use of architectural or display lighting. F. Energy conserving construction practices. G. Use of energy conservation devices such as flywheels. H. Rate structures'which discourage unneczessary energy, conSumptione> I: Use of human or axtimal power ,where such Ltse is feasid�le. J Waste Beat recovery. Ki Recycling arLd use of recycled materials; ; -37- , a ,.: re,60j. Aid of sYc AMOR15 HILL w, hY4 kil+'Vat ' x or JL4 111 i L4reLalJb mvo � - 14 a !d�•! �a�,� �,%'.� R../ r{� Rc 11 IOWA ,� . 1i: (, l = a't pb17r bp0:-•awCNNbap4 u)1 , � Ly+v„ •''� L � � � B. ii''nJi,7 AVE S - r V•7 ;,�„ m„xu1AvaAlaa ftiT�tiGe $ AM n1. �.!I 4 ``a. y"�n � i P1frf Y�+�,�G wA 'i t 'u1 , t�� ♦ ib.� ,/1 - AHNowwJy N _ R. 7M11 uu C uN A. 1J .:ulrhi.No+ •••U rrti� ,u u ; u-•fa • / � _ 4Ttl i 1 ? , •• rf 1�:-...��� - � « irL.� � JUJr,�, 1« iv ^v � � a¢ • rq ^ Y ., 7., . � t cA r A'.Z9C � a.s. r?j ^' iy ri' ,�' ° � r N n, r, J.{ u,r� r av' : pti � QAr. �•+� 4r ^s' � � �' � A' � N li' ,. &l!„ .lata n>s; � �'Gy�j`� < - na eMq, • a h . 4 r 1` y ,. r • ,r- < a tti', , 1r .. ,••.,... Nal- �fj CJr 7h• .+a k F'^ y9r r. ttt 1?� a+�` t r < , ,« w ..;3 �'1 A'4 t � ,` � ,`b ^7' u,,• � � may« « d t ,vo $2' � fiRM nAylnE t7 t' . •t' R �. �':,4 4o- ' 1 1 !�� '” � :0.VW V, :.,.:•, f- ti{:.'i? '+C �« to 't •• ,r ur - :�� t`rr s� C1 E�! 821ryc { s f°A:J ��t K Fv + � :.r.%^'•` of : +v �� oa � � i (tSc ` ati •+ 1 I ,« �a ctrwry:r�n kQO 4, VaxtT � 4��r+� .i ,r,,,•. � r� 3M��y, JTTh \{ d JG� nb'#f • , :c' a;�', r ITS Y .. 4, �. a +r pL9� , y b t X., •��Yr��r9, l+^^ r, ':iJ +u 4Y,_:...,, i':. � -- ry'�'ntip-. N N: t _" Il aI' ,�, i `" 6 i� ',d _ � J• " j}+,�t �' tl'yti U U tj ^` 'Li 71:h ^"'"`. ' ..•." . ,� 9 r� �,� •' � „1Ts �� •' �^: ry�4 rr+ eN;ar,r ,� v V l:y N �tlr y ;,G t' 1 ,.InA � baa 'aN 4R d J rrly M M• Y J `"� 1 � i 3 ! Nt w rTTr, „u Tw'•A b� : • rr 1 . Tr, (d n 1, ,;�, � °.^ i„f 9 tf t bre �o tv1 naS•' n �� �• � r1d?� t �SCr'6 .T �/� H /� 1! Y«T«L,, rJ �4Y ` r':64 V - ` •i ". G T. fA Nit.+ f ,cQ /bjM /62 e�nt . =r"♦-`y ,NACJ.. u 1: er tr30j.. ,R �. Carl- ,.:Ycs,ft ". •^orf FAU i.. r ]'l ,' ,1:, y„ ;.,r .,. a�`a"^or a t ryhe r , tyv9 1 ,,"•rte%2~ � � �(j�� 'r r`` 'P1,10.11477 1114{ A J.. v Y TAr s' !f -. , aJ;xCi •.r yVr r , +' '�v Y'� N•R 4vs9 g1• J S� 1�7f u 144 �_,,r�•Au �. �1/R. tirwl {J � r: ,. ••.1411 5 Ll •r. --. n •rA ;f�,c ..ice: "r,i l Ih + If ,. ' ��'li � � � ,�t�=r f G,IM - tl rr tr lk'• .fr:b .s.-6.�.•a.�.r. �. Y,yT nstltr •rw,,, ' .3. ,i R 41 ,. =•ez° e r t 1 " ;: Avrwvc ,., � •r f •7tA-'�a��2` r lA �4w y. a r' n h �+'. •' r54N'Cv`.oUlhNi `J'tti i* R F^vl,treatr:.P ' S'r! p °. aYo 5 r r ,new�0t901 le to t 'T-1.1,te.•ax+ s{A" —.»_. ' •�:ia'� .s" ;' �" Jr>. .V9 t �a. ~Y' PasQ�li v r �r i'� a`\ IS 'J -"4tuu FNn.aA Ibbab}, n ,sn', .h''r IY " nv hay t• xr tl ,,sFar tr FtlSY J{ rt zrr fu. i c ! t t.f M1 " CT C �• i a lltl n i t :� n a.• g,.. 1 NINi4M 61.., h , S'' �r •. , pR . t i a% 1 ta R 4V y4 I Pb k .� ur 4 a, ryC rke , t "+• t K ^� ri k %U r" . F w" t T 1 F : 9:s,at D: too 6[ Rww CN a'te ovr 1 �J TS,V i�' 4 � JN v ^� ^ t•r ++tt µ, M4'N C: I `1LtJ v w �,$rFN » bT. rtl{y v I R] �.--- q CNO1C aJld 1. N `P A� K *< ra „ �'.• P55+Rf. / J w llry p , ,fon CL'vq 4 LY FR 1 .- Mly1a n ;A t` 4 'x r*T e .. 1R rbR W17k " Olot$Y ^.i'3i,:,::ti •' 1/+It �%Y F�A7fb ti1i� o eS(•� i~ u J. 'w w : oo a e �i 'Zi,{AS. � ,,? 'LW:4 tT �y rJ 1}t) 0 6.14 r... {A(1LL m r'4Y i r i r �?!to y0yM5 -11 ♦T• 5 1 C.. t!,{S ».a ,' 7{{!AF :Urfa 11u. _� r T s „� Na"•�t�f�.RY,.- i.2."' � ''`aa>;I.. tlrOVIL y. Ci '�� t.. AAALT 14'.944 ,•+r 1'� 'r kY4rYD s , .�..,. r f! { 4GL01 ', •4'Pfi {1JIG byf (}% tlb rat,Or., O Jr Nr%! )t `• �"".: bR 1i a, FAU J YG95'r a FJ itm 1 6v1 L1 a.� 4 ^� vbA�'Q4tC AYf.{.r 1 t /j G ,IF N.43 23`•fiWr I� tt,7Dt rP r1 a( 9g l Y 4 !]�17Y WYNONfi� NawtR»,.� y , R w � r- v h: no TraKa7Tvlw IYN . Pb p N �. 4. 1114, r � Y 0 ':'. V � •� w5.*nb ,r �4 ,sem tiv AQ$ �� , A ... h R i, A' A ". N R c� .�. •'. / r• L r it 4' ik SWI n Ndaa`NICCiLAI >tUY.' p.=giLf 'r, Aa1'apabv AVG' »'XMW p �" 1« 4310 anbtnLt.E BAN +�� .atl� Y. 4J J�., r,yy {,•rT HWYK0v1EV.71S i r c i•4AL1T"►4ttlrb.46 ? .. J''� `* ir, ..� I .,» ,�, J•. OCA j �4p I / d/�� ,.��/ �j �!tJagivaartnvts +:oluau�rarui� ' wV�W .m., ( •+' /� ,w H �I; @GAl tf r tAn 3_8l( aV.iONiJa — oxanVli.i�t Cn�VNgwntla 1mm®en r , , �--",—� ... ... �� ,-" ,- � -, , � , I _� ,.. � " , �!, :� ,.� " , F . - . ,�,, , � -, .I ,, Fit, 11. ., , , - , �,�-, ,� , �-, ': ,. , . , 6', . - � ", , - . '', � I, - I �-1- - - , -Ii` . I ll-� I ,Z " I . , , 14 . f, -, � —, - �',,, ,p,,- 11 I V�11.1 - I F11 , ,,, � ,�, ,,,-,; ,,,, 1 , , -�, , ,,, t i .. . . ,. , , . � . � 1, . , . � , , , �, 11 , , , , . : I 11 c � � I i,"� -I ; !�, . "� " q', i ,��,-,�, 1 . -� � � ,� , ., - I , � � '11; � , � �- I - , , - -- , , "i - , I i I . - . I 1 ff, . �1� I , , I � -�,,y, , ", � , " . , . I I , , , e " , , I -i �,, - , ,,�, - ,., I , - � , , I , � , , `� 'til �-; I il"', , 7-,l- - . �,� -��, , I I 1 - -1 '. I , . ,. I . I . � , . I - - i -e- - I , , , , � . I - �: I .k , � - - � . Foo - , I . 1. � - �- - . - �e � � F, , . , , ". I � I I �., , � I � ,, .�., ;�, , , , iT - - - i �� �, :' , , � I � . �, - I :ii . 11 -, 1; j I � . � � . 1. , 1. � , �. 1, I I - � , I "I I � - I. , , - - . � -_ � , , , . , . , - - , � , i, - I I I . .. .1.1 � I ,.".I � : �I �j , , , , 7-F; ,- v� �-I` " I , '�,"117 , ,"I., �. . " - . z , . - i I'- .11, I il - I .11 R111 'e.: .1 I',' lq- I . � ... � . I � . �, ,�, . � .1. . ; ! , "- � F � i � - � 1 11 i - � � � ,�� , - � ", .. - I I , I I I I I I - � . � , . . - :i ... , , " . . � , I . I . r, ,,��`�� i , " � I', "" , f :, �, �� � , i�. � r I .1 - " i" , 1, I ; I , I � I I � I � ii j * ,:�; , , � . � , �� .1 � I 1�1 �i ,. � I . - - I . ,-�. � . � , , " ,,, - " , , 4 --- . , , . � - '. -�.T, e, , . I , � o. � F -,-I, A- - " �� , , , : W . ,;, "I - ;,7 ,. I I " . - , '-�� " - �- I . . , , ,. I . � . . I - I � I I . , I � I , � , � 1-I, " *4 ............. f 11 , , I . � i � . . - , , . , , �, ,, . , , . , , , , . . ,,, - - . ,. � , . , , , ;- - - ii . � -1 1. I � � 'poo;, , vl� F,F ,,, , �1,67-;, i 1�';, Fr . I lf� �� - 1 ',�- _77771 11 I ,.,� ;�,�� 1:', �� � �, I 1� .. 11 "I' -.�,��111, I '. , �, , I �;": i; . ll:- � I, �l"i,. . I i", r� , ii: ;.,�:- , "''. - 11 "'l, �! .,. .� I ,i- , , I �, " I I � .;,,, -i- '', " : , I F 1 - �� V��', �,`, ':��!, ,;I 11� .� � ,.`;:', ,,;—� , ". , , '' ". I I, ,il� , - , , � Ill,, I . I I �., . " . ,- I'li-, 1 _F i,� ;:,t, ��-�,i. - , �, . 1, : I I _ - ,�� .. " . ,- " n, : c�_ I Iii; I / �', I� ., , , . �, 1'1� —:��,P , ,. I O I , . , .� ,. I : �,, i `� .F `.i:� ", " , I . ., - � , . "�� , ;,' 1 ��� �': I i, " , " ) I , , ", - , , j,,' I II� .I�-'�, " 1 t: i" �, I .'' , �j - ,,�� ". � .1 � ''� � 11, , � I , � , - "'. I I I , I , 'F ,. .. ",I � .� � , - -:-� � � ,� I ", � . ,.�l' , � : ,'� 'i � , ,, - . �'. , - i , . ,"�,, " . � . 1". -,I , �, 11, � , -'-,,�� . , I , - , I, :� "I', -l. . li� ,:i, t: I , ,'�, " - I � � . , ) , ,',. , �, i, I -, �' �) i ` ; ., h , , """ � , i - .1 ��; ,.. � . '., , I I, , ,: ,�, I 1-11 I I � , ��F'-�i . ,, f� -- � �- - � 'I 1; � ,-1; l',, 1: I 1�1 I., I.' , i -, �; , � I -: I I i) - .� I , "- . , ;� � , � �� . , ,,6. , I , , , '7 ",;, ,,� 1, , I.� , . 1� I , j, *, � , (�, -� 'I: I , I , , I I "I Ili', � i'. , " ". , � �. . . �, , '�:i � ,� F:,� ,,, I , ,� . - . �, .111 �,i,�.' ,--�, ,, 1. :- � ': I ,�� i� � ': � ,: , .11, , - " 11, " :1 " � I , - " -- � . � . . - -�, 1111�i�.,-r"�!� ,�,, - ,, I I ;�, F�� , I I , � �, � - , � -. �,,�", '. , '' I I fll'�;-; t �': : -, � I I . � � '' �:_' 1- � "i � '.. : � " I - �, ,,, , , I �,�� �, �l.ill� ��. i�- �� ,It � , , I ,.�I. llfi, �, � , -, I"' . - , ,:I,i . � -�,l , - , z , .1,1, , - .",''.- ,?,,� � , ", " �:� , . "'! I ,I, 4, I", � il, , , , , , - �,,, � , ", ,� , �' 1. , ,, - ,i ,,, , , ", , , , , .� ILI. il" ,,� , ,�, I . , , 11 . 'I: � ., ,, i, j ".�: � -1, 1 - - �, I ,", ��,,l -, � � ti � 'j, .1 . 'i-,', .- 'e I ,. ,,, ,"I'll !, ; ,,,, ".'e IM � , � , �'. ." � 11.1 I 1. , .. �. 11� .1i", . . ". . � '11 ,. � -, -, ,", - �- ,,, :: -. - - IL I. i", ,.; , �, - `� , , "I"i , i . , ,- -� , ,,I ,�' . � i 1. , , �e. , --, - . I � I � i, , - , . - "" ,", 5 -.��i , -- , i, I ... I . ,. - 'i � . , , - - , , - , ,� � " , , ". . ,�, , �'. " ',,e,�, , , . � " I � ,� ,,, " - ,,� ��, , , - ,. ,� - . � �, , ',� , , , ". � ,z; I.-, 'I� �, 17 ,, , �,� , ,,, � ,,,!,. � j-', ,�--�''-�i;".� . , " � -, , I � ; " ,�- � , , , , , ,�:� , " �, , Pei �,: ,�, � , , I 'i � , . , ", , 1, I I . � � I 0. , I ,< i, � ., , , �: , - - - ., � � ; -: 4 1 - , , . : . , .;� "' ,, �, : ... .... ., .. I i ,� :. , �, , ': , l, ` , -, � , �:1 - . " I , ".. ,� � �. ,��:� �,,� :, , , ;,:, ,e ,�:, .� i I , � I, � " . . . . , ., , � j, -, . ," , I ! .-e�`, I- ", -�, , ,, "n, � ,;,�, , A "", � ,:�. , � -e� I � , � - �, �, , . � , i � , , , - - " I, I,,, � I OIP, � .1.1 - � .1 ,.. I I - . � , - :,�. , �: :, i. . , e � �-- ;, . . -- , � , � 1, ,-,, �e,,- -� " � , ", � - � ,� � � � I . , - q , , �.,,-- � , , III, . 11 I � I., j -7;- 1,116 , , , I � 7 I I , - � , . � . , , : - , , , I I - � �. "I 4.1 F.�, . - - -� l� - �� ;: ',-. I �i �; �;", . ,I, �, . I - I: .. �': . i", i t, ev �, - , 1 . - . ,- " �� r,�' I; ,;, ... � . , "I' �1�1 ." I 1. I, Filt- 11 I . � F, - - , � "'! I 1�t, I 'Fi,� � ;,,,, , .1, � , , " ; , �. � � ,t,i ,� , 1�.,.,I, , '- , , � , �, ".: ,F$m i , , I , : I� ,:�. I , - � '�, , , �, , , Q , - I 'I I , �1 � �, -� , , -, il .. I - . . . - 1 I .1 . I , r , � " , -� F, , , � e":, � , ,�. -" , 1. J� � . , I 1, . ,i, o � �� ,;�,� , - � . � � �, - ", , ,;*., .1, 1, , �Tit .� - : 'It"'; �, :1. , � , � "" 'r N��, �.Iti. ,� �, , � i � . :,,� �!,; � t i ?.," ,,, , ; , . � �� , , � , I : , : ,, :1 " ; , 1�i " , e"i , .,I � ,,'-'�i 7, I "� - ,, ,,, :� . , ; : , ) . , " , -, I -'�� � e , , � e � . ;:�F ,, F, � , , ; � � �,,: I', , , ,, ,� �, , , , - , �,� I . ; :,v � '.� � " � , , , : , I . , , �j , � , , ", , , , - I , �'� I I 11, l I , , i, . � , ".., � , , V 1, ii), I , ,� . � I, I I , , - � . i, � � � , , F I 7.4, . X1 �, I 11 . � I I I I 11 I . I - 1. , � � , . � , ,� ,, , � . , .� � I 1�! !(�-. �'; :1. 1� , - , -�� �il,,, " , '. , - ,, , � . , , :� , , , - I, I "I . . " i I - . � - � ,� : �� ,; � , I i, I E�.�� :,. i� . i�, , ." . � . , I" I . 1 . , . , I , , ;, - :, , ." I " , , . ,� � : - :.! " ,�, , ,� ,,, il. ., . , . 11 , �, ; � ,,, � - � � , , , ��! 1�� . � :�.'I, � F , � � I� , . ,� , . �, ,; � -, , i ..� , "II ; ": . , ml I "I" . I.. ,'� I , I " , .1 - 1, , � ,� . ," , ,, , I , ... - F . - - . , . , . I � � ". . 1, I'e � .. � ;" E 'I �, I , , )"'I . � , - " , i , � 1, I , � : , ;' , I ., �-t , �� , i , I f ; � i , , i , , , 'j , ", " � , , �" - � .. .... � 1, i " . F� , ,ii C � "'i . 'e. " ., I 1. � ,,��.,� "I" - 1, - I ,. . ,,, , , ,.i � ,� - . , , , , � I , - . " . � ., F e I �i� Y , � ;,� I �-, , , I " 1, �, . � , , 'I " . " " -6i �, , , , -�:�, , � ,,� �: ; i . . , .i, - � � , � �� I �Fi, ," , '�,, i ;, ��! Fr ; , ` , I ", ; -, . * ; , � � , - 't - ,,� , , L �_, � , , .1, I 1, '- - , . �� , - � : I F;� I;, � , - - , , , , I - 11, I I , ,,, .- . � , : � . , � , , � , ,� : � , ` ' , �,, ,i, �,' � ;' -� A, ��� r I � ' � I , ,F� - , ; � � i , . � . , , I I � l, i � � , ,� - -;! I p , : ,,, 'll , 1. , �. I � . . I - I :, , � 11. " , 11 �- , 1, ii , I : , . I . I I , 1 I � �� , , � : r ,,; '. , I 11 I I "� � �. : !": " �, � -,'!t� , , � , i �� � � - F,i� , : j, ,,,I,' � � I;, , � , " , I �i �,' , ,i,4,: ,, ,� " . �, .- , , �; ,';F , � , .,�', o . I k�- , , � : ,F � 11 , 'i . -i; � ." ,� ,,�,,., I :; i ;,�-� i ,� I I , '. , . � , , , .. - ,I � I , , - , I , I , 'r ., i I , , oi , � , , � 1 ., " F ' ir " ' "' " � " s� i I F, : eI: " o , 14, , l'. i,; I " F , , , � , ,;. ,F,',,, � � , I - �, I �', . 1. I � , ,. I � j � iIi I . . I . . . j I d I I;,j I ; � � - ,� � I .. � , F , , �, , � " , , , , �, �, , "� . F, ", ", � 4, - ; � I �, , I , � � , �et . , ; , . , � � , , . , . , I,' ;� � �, . ., �1' � � � , I , , , , I , , � � � , ;� �1 , " , I I , , , ., - � ": . I'll, . . , i I , � - I I , I . - , , ; . . . � � - I 11 I I I � - - 1:1 . I - , I I . 1. , , ,, - . , ,� :" , , �� � S ,� '- � IF IF , " " , ,ii� � �, � � - , , , ,I , � , , " . : ,,� , , � . : , , ', � 1 , -� . . , . I � .I, I " � . , 11 . , I I � 11 I I I I 11 I I � , . , ., . � , I , 'I" ,�' � ,. , `4(lF, ", -, : ;� , :., `�� . t� , , � I � 11 . �,. , ... I , , " . I -, ,, - 1,� I � , I 1� ., 1, , . , P, ,. � . I � , . , I �, , . , I . . � . " .A � , , Ir, , i � .� I" , � ,;v . i , . �., � 0, tF, ,t, � . � I , ,� I I � , , , , I . . . . ,i !�j , �, - ,ae �iy , 'i " I � , " . � , . I,F, , ��, : il. , 7 �, . ,� � , , , �J, ", , %I : , " I 1. I , - . � � I I , r,, � . �:� : I � r�� I I, 1 . , � .. - . ,�e: " , ; I - � � - , � I ". - ,�, . , -, , , � I - , I, � , , , , , :1� � I- e - , 1, .. - � , , ": , , '. -, : , , �:� I � ,, I- , ; � - L i " , I , , I" , � I I .�� I I . ; i 1 � . 1, . � I� � 1; , " , I , , . , , , � � " , , , I" , , , , - �. I -i I,'- I .� ;, � . �. , � , . . - , ,� , , - . , I 11 -), . 11 . - , , - , � 1 . , " il�� � .1 11, 1, :� IF �� , % . ., �� I � ,,- , � � �i,' � : � , 1 , , , � , ii, ! � , 11 , � . , � . , . - , I, 'l��' ,I. , , J I , � � � ", ; , : - 7 , , , t ,- . . I " , , ,� , ,, I , , � , - : I - , ;, �, , :�,:, -, I!'� �!, " 6 �� , I I el , I I , , , � , 'I, , ,I , e , ",'. j � I . to, " I I , , - , ,,, I I ,� � � . , I . , , - , I! I i - I, ; � ,,, F I o - I I ,� I , � "i - �j , �' ., , , , ,; :: � I . , ."�x t . - l. , �� �� i,,��;,e �.� : , � -:, , . i ; � � . �, I � . � . 1, it 11 , . . � � � 11 1-1 �� O I ,I, , . � I �, . I I .1 , . . . " , i -1 , I� , , , I - , , ; � tl I 11 -, , - � el� , ,,� � ": I , " ,�� ', . . , . j, ; ,,-, , � : , V '. :,� . �, , , . , � , . I , I , ,; , , i� , - I - , " � - , � . , t�. � ". � " �,. � � � . ..... ;� - , 1. - e . . I ,,I ! , , , , . ,�, , . , � .1 ;.��., , ,� - ,� . I I I . , i, I , , , I . , I I . I -� 11 I , , , , � , P. � . I , I i , F , 1, I 1, , , , , �- , �, � - ,,, I 1� , , I ,� ", : . I .. . , " F e, , � " - , , , ;1 �; ,, ii", , . � � � , 1, I 11, , 1�,I � i �, e , q " , , ,,, ; -1 I � , I i � , , , '- ,, 1 i� i � - ,4, - , , " , -- , " , �: 7 , � � - . . I llv� FF � :,- �,il, .,,�l I , , , , . , ,;., . & I , IF , , , . �l . . .. I . . , . 0 , � c it, - ,,, I , I � I , , - - . I I 1, - � . , ;, 1, " � I'll "i I ;� , " � : F , "I. �� ID , , , - F , , ., " " ,Ill "�:� � 1 . It 1 � ii ` , , � -:iih �, "I . � �- - � I 11 I � le,,�,,- , I ,,,,- - -,-�,, � . Zj 1� I lF 1, " ;, , ,N , , I, i, :`� , - ,", , , . "" ,; I ,I � .1.i� 1, :1�1 ie� .- 11� I " . 11 � I - , �- � � I-i'iF,' ,;, - 1, � ,, �, � - -.t , -1 , ., - , , , �. I I 11 ,ep. �, '! � - , , �.. : � r ,! � i- � . . : � IF , ", : 11 �t, 1:i , ` J ., , v , I j�F: ��; ":,I:� , I , . " � . I "I '11iii, IF . . I .1 . � , � � , , ��. .. I ,,�, !1, �i: �� . , I , � - `.' , , t- � , - , ,, , , , , . , �4" 1 � , I jr ' ,, .... � ,�, !;, � I . � ., l, � I" '- I , F', j � i ,, ,,,� � &w' 'r . I . - I ,- " � 1 , .", , I , . - , , k I , , , , - )�, � � , ;. � - ., ti � , , , � � I I I , �. . - - -� � ;, i , : 'i,��,� - � !;; I I :, �;6,��,,,u -� " , ,t� I- J, - ,� ., . . I - . � I, 'I I , "i " . .1i I , "I . . I � " �, . 1 , : � �� ,- ; - , , �,!, " 11 .1 1% , " . - �, - -��,,,, � , , I � �� ;1 , , I .11 1�.�,� I , , - �, - I �� �- .i I . � I . I � � F,� . , 1, , , I I - - - �, -, " 'i � , , , - I 11 .. , t �� ,�l , - . . . � � i,, - � - .�, . : , ,�� � � ;"' �', � ., , , - �, i 2 - , v . " � �I, , il, 11, - I ,�, I I - . ", " . , �, I , , , I .� , " t, , ��'.�.� - � , it , '! � I � "", , , , ; " , - � ,. .1 " ,!",� , , , �� I C- " - , 1, , ,, �, - , , V� � : : " " 't - . I : - i�'. " �l; � - ," I . . ', , -, ,-Aii ,,, , , 1, , . I 1, - , , , , " ; 11 '� � ., , � I;, I , , " . I,, ., � � � , . h- , , , - � , �, ,# t ,,� �i% � ","', A I . ,Y � ". , , 1, , �, 1, � I , , �',' , - - .i,� . , , , i, I . � ", , " )'� . F Z;, ,� - X . � � I . . I I , (." . � I � � . .�, , ; -11 � : � ',,,�, I . ,� , ,, � .- , -,,� F, , - , . , , , . , �. - . - , � �� . 1 " �. : . � � I , � 11.1 , � .�, i!- � I - � - " , , - , I I I � , I - I I , , .. �� , I ,1,4� , , ,-' , �j' I , v . .'Il . . I i .p�t,, , I I � ,, � , , , I ��, �,� , � " � I , . , � � 1. . , � . � I I . �, " ., . � �' , - . , , � , . � �: I . I'. 11 � � , I 1�:- 1 1 I ,, � , '. � i4l:: 'N . � I I � , ,."� �` ", , - : � � , , , 01 .1 - ,l ,:, . it'i ,,.� � ., ,, , ., F I , ; 1i "" � , , , - �, , � �� ,,,I �,, -,'�; ��,, � � � `� " , , - , , - - 1. �,K -1 I .. . , , I ��.�, 51" T", ,,, Z - ,� .. , � . ,� ,- � : , ,, - i� ��,; ; ,� - � � :, �, .'� - , , � . � , , , � . � � -, , �;, 11, , :4 - . . I - - 1. ,; I �i,- � . , . . 1, � 1 � ,1 . , � 4 � .. " . ,,, I ril I � . I . ,�.�, , 11 , � , � ,, : ,� . �� � -,a, , , . ,,,� " I ,� , , .... , - , , I , , 4 -, " " �, I .� I . .1 :� ;1 , . . I 11 - '. "., . ..,: It . I , I I . .. �-, %;,T!7,V ic�, (41 , ;� � " � %, --.,, I 1� - � . I . , -F�:- , , " - , �. , I lik , , , " , I I � , , , , . r � , , , ie I ��F,,� , 4 1, , I . I : , "i, ,E : "; le� �i ,. , . , � , �' i"i . " I 1. . - I , --�, I 11 I -"� 11 i 1, � I ; ,, , , .;� , ,-,' � , � - � . . : . I "I , I I ,; , � � , ,F, , , ,�,,,- � ,I i , - , " , "" . 11 I'll - I I I I , � I I I .�r , I ,i, - Ti- 1�t P� 4 , ;i, � �, ,: , 4 " �., , . , � 3" �� . -11. - T, ,e,., . .1, " I 1. . ., . I ; �, m- e-J�4;1��r` "�"4' �'-- 77=1 -N, , - , :-. " � - �. 1, .�11 . ", . , , '. � t , � !, �' � . , � �F : ;1 11 . ., F ., " ,- " , . , , � �, I , I I , , F, , 7' -,, , ":!, , , ; , � , � . �r.','�;. 4; � I : , F� ". - il , :, �, � , -, .. , - .1 I �� - I . ;, : I , � - , , 4, i, ," .,��.; e.p - A IN I - � i , . -, . . - , , � , , � - I � I I, : �,"� ,I, F.-- �; " i, , , . I i, - , , I t '" I -I,', - 0 1, I I I �,� ��:�il I" - : ALZ i F.� . li� . :, . . � , - � . 1, lil,li*"' '� : 4! U, ��. , . 4 4� -� ,14� V . , �') , i . I -� , , 1, � 1, "!� ti,I5 ik� , �. I te � i0o : N'�'Af v , I , . I , � ,I I ... �, I , , , . , , 4,,'. ;,;h i�, � . i, , , tj� . 1�i� � " I" I 2 , 1111;I,;,�,, � ��. :-�� I ' � � tr i I t. , 11 I . , �� , , , ,,; , " ,;, . i ,it , , I p , s , - , , i, , t � i!��, , ; j � ,'�, � � �� � I I , " - . ,, , ", , , , , , , . " , . .� �-,, , , , , � go . - " ,,,,, ,,��-,,, I.- i,. 'I , , , ,� , ,,, 1 , �'-, , - " 111 "I I... "" , � ". ` , i ,,, ,� I �4 , 1 , - ... - q , , - ,�, ,-� - - F", - ! �, . I I- , - It, " , F, I" i ,, , � , " , ,�, - F! �- ,- ,, �, I i , I'll, . 11�%��- I : FY, �. ."; - ; � �, ;il, , I , ,if tI, , ". � �- � 1. IF 1,01 I i , , I 11 ��, � I . I - 1. --, I - , I '' � , . - , - , - I I : .� , i� , , 'I � I �,� ! . ��,,- .I , -.,, � , ',I '11,; l... � - ,-�` rl,� � " - I .1 - " e :�, , �, , , . i - ,. � f, I � �, t". , ,�t�,' " , � , PF �,.- - � � �� , - 11 - , ix , �, ,,"i $ ,,, ,5�11 I . I '�,ll- , � I ., A�:", 1 _ �, � , , . r,i; I ill i, 1';:� I I" , �: -- ii . o , �� , , , " , " , , I WK--, . t � I I.. .;.l ." -�,��W",,'r -,,�,, , " I -I L 11 li, i, .'', ,"; � I , � ,� : .1 , I ". � , I I i, �, 'I , �",.,, - , � ill, I, , !�, !, . , � � 1, 11 ,,� 1 . � I- - - ,- ., - F4 , T , ��yI��j,:� , `,��,i ... !; ;: , I i�-� i ,�A I � x�'�'� , I, .'' I ,I � I I , ,. , . 6, . , , . ", � . , � , , ,- IF, - - . - .� 1, , 'A - 10C .1 I ., . ,,':,�i� III , i . - � - ,- I 16, , . I, c . , . . , �, �, ; -,q'-I�f . .. ... ii* N it I ,, �:,�, .1 -, �,, , " , - -: F � ��, " � �. t'l I ", . I -,i J, � 'p,, "" - .1 . " le��; jtJX , :, . , ,.; ,,, , � I I I , ". " , , : .�F , I " '�, �Ij -%y 7N, A I �1' e,'11. ill I 1111!! �,,, - ". �� � ,,,�. , , ,� ,,fll� ' ly � - " . i� . . , I I -, ill - ,� -� �- I �1,1i. . - ; �I, - " I - , �� ,, . P� . ., ,� , -� , � , - ': , , " , " 4-, " ; - ,-, � , - � , I II " 11 I � ,!-Wl I , yeell � - � !" i j _. . , , . lt'4 . 7 �, ,,, I , - - , I !, I .. I - I I , .� , , ":: . � 1, ;� *�!r�' � ieT�" *'io , �, �� �� 11 I I X. ;ii iFIA I � . .` I I ),L,��, ", I . � . . . , , ,, , .1, 1 I I - 1: . � . i� , I I I �� I- ` " , , R- 7��-� .'�- - J- , � .- 1� F,441,,4� �! I" , , . ,,, : , I � "� ,1.,:�- :I, .IFF , j, , , 1 - F, 1. , �. " ,,, . ,,I, , ., I " � � � , , , . , ., , , , "� ", I , ,,I � I ;,�, �, i " , - , i " , 1, - .� ., ,,, " '� � -,4,, j��-- -1 'T,�,� ��:� I , I - . .. , ,. * i � : ., ,� � ". I : 4 . " � - -,��Ii��, -�"'111� , I . - ". l,'� -ji� �, --�.. �n , " � " 'i - 'N 'i : i ��,rt,e,, � jr - - - f, - - "' , I . - ��., , . , � ", , ., , , � - -�', ,, , I,' , � "' � ,,, '-, 1:11 � . F , ;, W .:a , 'I " , 7 1 I ,L, .,I, ��!, � V , , �; , , �,,F-, .01,?I�. , � , � � I , �," � .4- , . I - � IF - ,, P �f �, , 11, I - , �_ , � , I ,�,,,z -� , � i.11� , , �!��:; �,j ;iJ:.'� , , , � : I � !" I%. ,� ,,, , - � - . I I — ,. ,- - I 11 '. 1,- .1 1- - � -:�- ,;,"". : .. ,� �:z ", .11, , , � , , , " - , �.", , 't, ,I,. , , , '. ; k" �44'1 �l - t� -. � ,..� F� t, l� �,� � - � `F,'� ,Fit - "'. ,. �,,' � , ., , - . � ,� '. � -- I � � 11, ,, 7 ; . , -. ,,,, I':, , , I , -1 k�, I, , , - -- j� , - . ,.", I"11, `I�.!�:ly po'-,, ,� ��V!I`i4I �'W--',, , ',�", 1 Silk, I I , ,� � - � --Ij " � , , I , , ,1� �, " �;�, �-'.-,'� � , , , ,F, �� " ,- `� . . i, , :, - ' T . " I I 11, 1� I I I , � . . � , , I i " ', , - �� �: ,`,� 10 � . . - . , . . N . � . � ,� , i; � I , �1' . l� , .i , ... ;, � 11 � , IF I , 11 ", � - �� ff!, ;, - � . . . V 'II , - . -I� � '' . , - , ; " � " I . ,.,' : � ,� ,� , , e, If , . � - , ", F. - I . 6 , I, , , �. - ,,, , `54 ,, � . . � , .,� - , " " i, �, . - "i I � � I I., 111' � ,. � , , It � , � �! � I I . , I ; ,,�,,, i,�, I " , iik - � � �,, �`t , ;1'iii,, , . I ,.. ,,, q�, , - 1� , ., . i�', Al's : , ,� , , I , I , , �� � �, "! 1 , , , , � r"ll, I - N� , � I . I - . � " , , � . ,� "� ,li" 111- --, - - .� " �, , ; � p, , �, � , . I , . " � � I I - I �, . -` 1,�, - , , : �, ! " 2 . - !� - : , ;1 ;l Aii;*'INV� , " 4 � 4,-, li-.', , " , 4 :,- I � . - `��' . ', ,, � - - �, . �i " � ,� ,.�, - . , , � p"! , .l';.- , � ", 11, , , , ,; 1 :1 '. "�,.�� -,,: :�. . , . -: . ; , I ','.- ,�, ", I',' � " , . el. . , ,r;, e,� "","! ,, � , .� I I, It � I� ,; . . � , .�, �i,,: 'l .4 11' , , , . �,' " I !,7 I I � , iF, � , I ,; I �, � �i - - �'-. , . " .�I, t , , . , -, ;� , I". I , , ,,,, ,,, ��, � ,��T, - 7 �F, ,!Iel�fl�:; , , ��111'.,e. . - , . i 1. . :, ! � . 11, I i :" 'I! 0 q!i� � - , " .. , * � i, RX� . 1� �, . , '; , 'i ; , �, ill' I F, � , I�F, : I .��, I; - :-,I,i� , * , - 74� !I :-��',�:�: � , ��K, . - N�c k,f -,- �1; , �i,, :j i 4� - , i!. il ,�� " I I� - i I, 4 jt�; I, . �: , � : 4�- A , I f"e., , � , f , " , , " '� - , 7" ii�' - -. , A , I , , � F , 0 IF � , � I , , 11 � , . 4 4� � it.",- � j,i , " . . � - ". , -10", - - , �, M. ,� - -i t' ,f�, " "T , " L, I � , +11 , , ; , �, !� .:�l , , i-, , Ile: , ', , � 11�� t �. � , �qk 'l ie,N , , � , , I , , , - , L . �,;Z: � � I I . I , �.i. '.I �,il-- :: � � !,,� , " iF� ,� ,��;� , , i �,Q , . , , , ", , i t � ,: i e l� I " ", � � I �, ,.� . F, . , � , I �,P , � "I,- , '. , - , i , -, . i . , " , I , I ; � i .� - ;' i I e; ,Z. ,. � , , . ,� - �p - 4i, � --Vk' � :: I .- ; Ill "I'll ;,� ,�, 1�",; ," ' , I') , , � � � I" '. '� '. i' ' �Tii" : ' . I i. I I I , , "'. ,. . , . .� - , I- - ,;,�,']�, . I I 11 I I , ." . - � , . � - �� : %: i- ; 1 ;, " � , � 1� ,, , � .1 , I I . 11 � - - , I - - i. - fI '?,I'-" - , I I . ,4 .." � . ,I '-I 4'. : �it 94`4 I , ,,, ; ,--, i ', � � ": - I , ;,. , 'i" , - v ; . 1: '' ; i " , . , ,. . . . � '$?, -;iu, � "I �,x. , , . . I - . �c . - "I �� , �11 - , ,, I ul."� Ill 'I� , , � "!, - ,: ", �I� -, , I , , , f , �, , ;, ,- �, � � . 1, , I � F �% ;, . , , , , - , , . ��, � . , � I . t, I -,�. � le, �� � '; , :� . ,� . I 1, ,., I � . . ,: ,ii � , ,t�4'-f,j�' "i .'� .�W- 7 1�.- ".. , ,� . ,'. , I , � . , , i I � " I I 111� � , I � I, .. �; , �, , , , �� "; 1 i , , : � , ,,,, ,, !'� ; , � IF , , , , , , , . ,,, - . , � , � IF- � FI � ,� ,-1, `;". .� 1� . � " , , I . I� I , -,;,�., . I , , l, , .. , I , " '�,*' ,� -. 1�;� � � ,l - I -, , i i , - . , , , � . i, I, - I . , � I ", , I - - ,e"!,, : - :� , , , 1, i�. - , � � - , "� I I� I I - , , . � . . , � . 1; � " i,.� �j , ,, ,. - � L . ,,, : ,, � , � ,� � !�-� :) ; , �'� j. , , , , . , " I , j l, I, , , . � � , , , - ,. , , , ., �,. I7� � , iAI , , . " " ��, ", - , ,� � 11,111`4 - i ., �. , , , , I i , . �t�,,, , ; " :� �. � I I �; I , - . 1, , _:;, . I � , I .1� FF, - , � , , I- I I . I ': , ��i, ,Ij ", � ., , :, �' ,, ,, � I P`:� , ;,;� ,� , -, ,� � - -1 � -l" ., . , I , 1, I , , , � I o . , , , . " , � , ), i . , � " " ; -1, i, , , i; , , , ) " I .,- � . � ,; , i - ,.F,. � " , ,, I - '- I-Q�4, I , : ,,� "", r�- , � 'I -1 i , ,i , 111, , I , , ,v. A. I ,7- - I -,,,-,;, . - , , I �� �. .;, I , I , ,. , �ll , "I . , � " , , ; � , , I. i, i�,, ,, , I,) � o ,- , ". � I - - -�, , ,,'.� .� , I ,F� - V,jj%,- - I. �., I . ,., h". �,- ". . 0� �r �%,,� ., V� ,, * ,� �'�,, q� � � � 1 1 � : I ,� I I -, .: � , , � M , N , 1 '4 �, I v " , " - 'I �i; I Ii �11 ,� � .J-,�,, I `i' if, el . --- , i I �", , ., I I - �14 1 . " 4 " � , ". .'A " : � *`,- �k r, � i-', t N I �-. 0� , ,�,,,: , "", ,'I� - - 4 ` V Le,V,��,., �,,Fi, �, , , l I t, �� 1� 1� 1� �:. � " � � ,�, : 1�: "', - " '' - -F,�, �� ,.��`: '75ft�, , -,I- "' �� - i 1'�, 1�dll, I Ai� I I i �-,, , I , " I, - : , [ I , . ,�. 4, ��. F �,�,��,,�, , , , I I . , , , ""Oftil Im, � . , � - - , �:, 'I.: .1 r 1:e ., " 1: - I , I�;!,, . ; I y �)' �, - .�.% I �� ," , - 'i ,.�Z� - , : , �:11,10 '-,.I, ,,-J �,., ,; ,, , .. � -, �e , � iii �, �,� . , . - "N" " .V � ii' . 7 -�.. , . � ";-.;� . - ,�, , F. . , " � r'11� .F:- o i , i � 'p,j: � ,, . " , I , � , , . -.-'�, . " -.� � I I � , � � I I n, ', I - , , I , , ", �, , . ,.,-. � I ,,�- , , . , , ,� , " � I l, a I! ,, �, � I I I I ._ I I ,�,F, s I IF x , I , , 4 :01". Ir , , . , I . �,, ,,, , � . " , � X u 1, I I I I- I - ,� 1.�,�,!i,, , ": " ,, 'k-, I . . , i.�.!`., ;�F! .,:�,, '.1 11 � " . , - ;,,��` i:. ,;,-,, I - . :� ,;� , i", �,!�-, �Tl I , , ., l, , 1. 1. � . , . - � i, 11, n ,� � 1 , "; -:-.- " , - � - . I - , , , -1 :., ,, , , , , , ,;� ,, � ," -� , -': - : il . - � x I - , 1, k -� � I I',, , , 5.,, i � " :;': -,; 4 ".Ili - � �,:,( , I .I� 14'. III 11 1.� I, , - ,� ,ti,��,V,;"4 , ,,,,, , ,, I I i,jW, 'I � �, :11, I �ke � .�. - ,",I I - � , " , 0 I, .'If, �, i - F - - , All I I I . 1. 1,` : .� �� ' ". )i i�,,' . , ,' I ,,'�� , �, , , ' , ;, � k1 I "I , � , � , " . . . , 1. �� 'F- 1� -" " � � I , . , , - I I � - it - .1 ,�, I ., - . I .. , " , --'- - I ,i �� � - ,r , I ,� . " ll� -,,; - ., ., , . ,�,,�,� - , �� , e�,, � - ,! �, *.�. - - , , , , � , - " ��, : , , , 7 1 41 . , , , I , . , .. . . i - , , ,� -'. , 1: � , � - , , , . , " , ". lip C� , , '. .li � 1 1. , e " . , " , . , , I � - 4 - �, , ,� I '. . . , .4 1 1 �11 " ",:, i�, � F-1 , ,1� : �; , :!t �, , ,� t �, ., �1, ,, �:, I, , , ��: , . :, i, ,:,. I .1 � ." - - - q - 11.1 &-,-", I ( , - ":� , 1-1 11 , i � 1 %I 1 1 1 � � " ��: � i . 11 , F, .:,: i, , . I - , . , � 4F ,�-,,,� 'I , � :,� ; � i: 1�� �.. I I � , ,el,, , il . V I , f I #,, s , I � , F . I : il , I . ; , i�' I , , � K, ,�� �;, i "le. " � � . . I I I N;i 4, "Ill -4, �v I" �,Z� 4 W if , , ke , , , ;���,, I , J!" � , -,� , 6 0, , � I , � , , I , � , , �', , . " , " r , , , - -1 , , , � ,; ., , . . , 1, , "'i � i . " : , - ,� 11i ,� ,�I ... . . � � . . - I I 11 , � � t , , I , - , , 1� , I , -�; -:I� , , , , , , , - " � - 7� - ; --, ! \,��,,.. .4.�, � -,� I � � ,, � �W ��3- �, * , ; I - , : � : ,,, , - - ,,�I , , r i I I,, I, . � . ,�. � :1, ,,, I �. : .`,�-, . �� , I 1- . . ��t,, , :, ,,�,,-�' , it . 4" , . � I I ., `� . 32� �I , . l , �!, � ,z, ,, � .�ee : ; " i - , . , �, I, "."'. ", , , ': � , . - , " - :; i I . , - I � - N , , . - , �i : � '. :, � I I . � . , , , . � � . - , , , ,� "'i'll , . I IP , -, I lli;l .11 �" I I . , )'U, """Vi. , I I,, . - �' ' '� � , ,�� ,k :� - "i - ,.. , � . : , / . I � i , , -W , , . I � 71, . -.p -." .11, , . � I I, �, " - I . � , . , , . ,- - I I . , . - � . - I , , , � , , �, �, ,�, , e � .! , ,1, "I I I' , I", 1� , - , 1-i ; ; I ..� . i, .,I . � -- �, 1, . !, ;�� ;j.:� '. i, " , - - '.' ", K � . �� : �� � , i, I "I, .. �, ti-- ,� , .1 , , ,� I.,: �, , , � , 0 . - � ;; " , , , � 1 � :�' , " , � , � � ,� �- ,,� - , , �` � , � I ; , V � ��i�k, ,,,,!k' "� � I � , "� : -��:. ;, , 1 - �,, - �, \''._ , - I " �, , , , - , - � I , , ... . ... : ,c � I : ,, I. :1 - . , �' 1 - I, , t" -,r,�,' " �,��, .1 I , ,. . , ii,� i.. 1. ,! ,, .�' � I , , - .i" I , � , I-$ 44. - , - - .. ,� , �L , I I . I . ,j 1 -,,' , ., , ,i � , , ,, . : � � � " ? . � 1� Ai, �* �� , � -:, - e., � T ": -� � 'I;, , , , I " , i" "I,i , �.�l , . , , I � I . - ,��", I si�' ,"� - i� ,�� ". , )lI, � , . . , ���,,, , � I , , 4F , r , � ,�: , r, 's. - . . L . I.- . , I . F � I � I � I ; � , - , � I , � I -, ,. - - -i� I 1, �' , � �: i 1; , , ., , . - .,� � . ve- � �l,:: - ,,- . -, ,;-.. , "I ;'I ,. V� , � -r - " It " I 616h4wlI " i� i, � �� , I ,�, " , , � � � ': , � . , � " �, � � ;:,i ; ,,,�. ,, I . ,I, 1\ " �, - . , I i �:. - il � ,� I�i. " , ,. , " �", � . , lt+j� i i-;� , -,�,-N-,-��.,. ,-� Af k ;",. �, '. ���: '� " , � , : - ;. . - , � , � � , , - "`� ,�,�� �l�, . -r- . : , I. ; , , -1 , , 11 I , , , , ,;,,! ; ;� ,; � - . 11 - I , . - " . � -r"y , ,,; I I , , 1: ,:�� - : , - . ,r-,-5 '.. , ". � "I V V�� - . , ; . �, - -:4 -, �.�i :� Y : � i � 1, . � � , " , .1 . I I ,I I ,p 1- I " I , 1, , I I . 11, , .�, � ` I � , , - " � ",�� ll- 4, � , �� , FIi J��-:,%l�� !, ::: ", 11 �ii� , t: ,F - ��o� , ir, � I, , q . ",` I , � . , � � , � - . �Y i: . . , 1 I ,- ,, � ., .( : �� , I ti� , I . ,.. , j � ' � , , : �,., �� , I, I� ,, . , �I, , . , . , . 1. L; I I � 4. _,'L I �,,' , . , ,, , . , 1. I I",.,, , - . I . I , I . - , IF, , , , 7 io? i . I .,i)I �' I � ,F � I I �,F, I I ,'I . � . I - V " f � . . . " � I I , . : 1�. P- 1, I Fl� � I�% .r. �� i! I I - �, I. , , ; f - � .11 I el �, I � . I , , , �, 1.1! - . lij F I, - , i " ., , "' i " , - , i-, , �, , I , �, . , , ,� i� � . , , � - . ." I � � ... . , . , " :- , �: "" : ' ' .17 ,� 'C`�-'-If'ig; l� i' � .: -; .- - ' ` - ' � L' . , I , � � I - � 'l, " .? I , , �, , ., I 1. ". I I, ,, � , . :�, iF, N�, ", ), -. . � . . - j I . l' , -,"L , ,, . , ! � , I I � : , 1 , ".,� � , � e . I . 1,� . -.;,:,�,,., � I �.. �, 1� , I - , , �� -;, , ,��l , � I� � "-� I I -, �,.�11 low, �, - " 1. - ., ''. �. '... �, . , '..": �,!��' ;. .%- , 11 .1 , N .V-:� , '. - , I - :�,� w, ,�. " ,.: 3 ",140w1g&--- AIt, , , , � . '. 11 . 11 , ,� " J� , F.�- F� , VK "t , I, - IF, " � - ,:'AIII'll ,- , . �,:-, � .� I ", -�1�6.1,15��, I.. "" ,� , ,� 1, -", , . '-, , I ;, , �. , � , I ". J, � - ,�� .., , , . . I I I . il . ,� - ,, , , �.. I 11 ,� I 1: � F , . I .1, I , I , I" , . IF I , , , , , � , I I , , �i, I , .1 I'; . ,, , , t �11 1, � i 'd, � It 1;� - I I �,�it� �� I �, I " �il� � , : ,, . �. ", 1� ��k,i , Im , , �,, I4, �, . ; I , - , , , . , . - , , �: '. , l , . . I I I I " i� , I :,�. "I I ; , . I . . I j, . I I . I . , " I 1^11 � _-AF , �. I . � . .1 . ,., . , �, 4 ", � ,� . � I 1� , . , . , �-�-, 1�;(I 1,� I'll-, - I . -, I .. 1��q . " : ,�;, :� I �, I, . -te , , 11 I 4 IJA*,�,M,ft`l� , - I . I� ,.��!'; , " � . , � . �� - . 1. . - , 11 011, I I , '5 , V *0, �, I � ,, - .. . 1, 11 1: :::, �;: �: 11 � "'F�,'. -:;�-.. . . �, , , , �: � , , , 1: ,.i . �, 11 , " I �;�, I -� ,� �� II, I .e , , � - '� l�� i;,�, , � , � ".. ,- " � I I 1, � , I I - I . I, I ;11 , 1, e: � ,, ': : "; , ,,��:� e � , , 9- ", "-; T!, - I , �. , . t�;,:;-,I`Z�e�, �,, i I X�.,Illy If ", � � - 1". 11 I I � ,i ; , ,1 I I 11 - ,�, ; � ", -F� � . I I ,,31F � sl-� — , .,t� , , , ,��, ,:!J�e'�i�� "I - ", , .. ". , i . L � I 7 IST, ,. I ,� ;� F ,� ".�I.., �- �- , 1 ., , , � '', . .. . � �,-, I.- I , � , - , .: � �l , I : . "I . I I 1�, . : �,,�,, I I � �, ". `� 4 , , � � - , , V "'. I - - I I , I �LF 1 I :, ""41"I � . I I , i I-: ,I -, I �. . .1 10 I., . - j"` I � I -- �X II "01-AiIi,'Th�, �-4. � � : i".; +�,- " , "' 1: �. I " , I I . � I , , , � ,�, : , , , � I �,, - , " ', � ; , I � It il;_� , I � , " , " . I J� , . � , . . , IFE �ol v,)A . I, � ',. : , �4, , . , I . I ,�4 ,�'.. � , .., !,'�, � , 11 , �, . I I � , , ,, , . , � ,:, �,11 , ��,,.'. � I I � I " �. ..", X I." � � I ,��l .� , i4" ,, ;, � ; `F ., " ;", i, , , . ,, . I , , - 'i ,t i . 1, - , . , � , ,, � 1, I �* � , ,. :1 - , "" � - .� ,,, ,6� A"")., ,4:- . . .% f, I., I i V, III, I . I I, � � It :'rI': �,� I � � �- , I 'I � 11 I I , , t', - - . ., 1. ,� � �7 -� I ;11� I I I I , 'It, 11 . I L!� . I, ,, Vt " " 1,1�� "", : ,il", " I , : ' ,� L I � , , . .1 1. I ,;il I','- I 1,� e I ,i I I, �- 4" , I . I . . 11 - 1. I 1- ", , ��. . � : , '', . , � . . I ,',�,:, - . , . . ol "I sqkb ,-,q),l-o- , - � � .*:" ,, ,- '.. I . I " i -;. :�fl "'. � I ll� i, . - ,. , , .1,�, , I I I I � i". tl . .; . " , -, ";-,L - � � , , I A �-- -- " -i"'::, .x, * , - ;'Ir , .� I)� " �& , "l 1, . ,i I . , .. I N'�,' W%4 11v': - . - A . A k � , � I, . .., I . I - ,: :�t z,Y:jj, el, " ��, ,�,� , , ", "'I'- � �,� � ,-� - �- , , -It �,� � : �, I.-6: ,,� �-110,01�� ` � I .11 - �. ''Ii, "" , . I'll, . , . I . I ., - -'i-j; - ''. . .. I IV � , � ':,' "",�,- , . � - F., o I, - , f , , . ., -1111 4 I ,� , ,, , . �,, � , vi,FoiI ,�- ; ,';,� - , - I 1'�ei ,� " , � 1 I,4 14 , i.''; I- � , - �:� I 4 ". , ", :-* . 11I , , le 1� I . ,.;�,,. i, i'... . , 4, I ; I ." . - 1'�, I,- - , N '4, 1 Y-;�'�, . � ,�c . . � i.,;,:,. ., I ., . . - , � ,,, .:,. ,�� ";j . �:, '. l; . . " - , 6' ,, ," ,,'�J,�,e ,, , , , ,_ - , ' . I , - , 4 I . I . �,tl e-� , , . � - : . I 1: : ,lFA'2,�,Ji,4FWI'. � � 1, . - , � - . . I I . - . '� . . 1, : �, - , , � 1. , �. 1. I - , � � ., � � ';.I.,� ,' �F. I L.,, , , . � ' I, 1, � � - 'N. :?,x. " - " . - I '�V,'�,,,,iimo 441"IF1,NO) 1 - �-I�.;f, �:1 .1 1�1 1, " , : ." � I . I , -, - X, `4 � , . . i " �'', , ,:, I ;il':I�i .1 - , . I I, I, , ."I' �-. . i , �, '.e ,, , : �, , -,, ;Ill- �� :�t.� " . ;�L� �` - `-�' �i:� ' � .' ' � ", ''-�- : " , . , 1% " �, , i. �-,V I lai '11. � � .- , � , -,-'� . .7, - , ., - , , , , , , .1 i I r 1 , �, � , ,i , , .1- : ,,,, i" 1, ,, 11 G�. ,,�,,, ,-: . 11 I '..� :- :-i."i, ,� � - , '1�i;if�, , ;-, '- :�, iFF "' 'r � '. , � - - " , X1 ,, �, , , -, �. ,, �, - ,� , .1 ." - - I � " - e, - '11�,�, -, �, , " . ". -, . 1 �� . I -, 11 1 - �, , . �i I ,, .., ,., - 'I ,,L 1, 'it" 'i IF.'— 11 � ' ) ' ` . � �;- -i� , , � ,,, i, I . . I - , ,,, . - , , " - ,, , -, ;� . ..... I . � , . i , I; � . 1 4 ;,' " 1, 11, FF 1"' .: ui� .- " � ,� �,,- , ,,, , I 1� 1 � i !, - ; - � 1, - ,- I � 'I�L "I ' �,' ILI- ,1 . �:1 ,��, � I � I I I �,, --,I�Z,�, ,,, , " 1, � , - , ., Yi�- ,, , l�: �,� . ,') � , it , . I " � , , "� "' : 1, - , � 7 -: ,I'. - .1 I I , ,;, . � i , , ,� .... i, , ;;., I , t . . .... - - , ' i , 1� . 1, , ,� . . , - , " : � !, :� 1 -:: 1 j, �;. *.� ��Ii,�,, ,;..',i�', Ill ,.� ,.. I . �: I, .I� - ,; . , . , - . "., I . . -1� .11 - , ,-: ,' f". j ' ". �, F �ii' ,,;. , - - - .: � �,'� :,� � . , ... �. i,'';, "I; %� , � ,I ,--; , .. ,� �. I" , 4 1'oft,W�t z - , 1- ' , , , i� ,- I, -- -. -, , I ��'�- � � , � ,�`: �- , . ,,�lY I -1 , 1. 1- '�, "' ' ' �;'i''L''�. .. I I I , , �: � , , - fi.�, � . . � . I I �. _� j r, .. .'. . . - �,- -ti`,�.,%. ll"-..11�41 . �i': ", . - , \ 11� �,?' - . - " '' ". �, � ��- :-- � , ,;�� - ii�, -. t"; � I . , , -1- . '' �'. - �'. - 1,11 11 , i , �- " , ,.,� . , -,,lF �, . "" �� �i-` -� .,l,, �..,! %'i'!i''., i,� : �!.. . '. 't, I , ., Fi..� , , , Iii -illi: 17�1.1� 4;., .,.,, , � - ii Iie., " " I ,� - �;. ,i� - . � .- - A,� , , ,.. � ; , , e, " "i .�,�,�,I:�,� �, - -1 - %, i,;'I, I . , , . , , '. w '' ,'; �ii',4 ..''. -. I . �;Fl, " , , ,� I , ,�,�, ,,, � �F, I "I 11 il". .� ', I . , , . � , - �, ,( � �,!� � 1, I-', , , , ,., � ""i ,.-- ,jI I . , 1111,�, �! i I,, �, Z5 ill � 6 - " � , , - - , e,x. � �l , '- , 'I- �., ` , - " I � I . ,It , I � : w: �' , . .. I m "� 1. , ; - , I �'i,� ...... ., . ;. ,�, '. ,,,I � ��. ,� I� " � ill ! :; ��i :� - . j ', . -`.'i - .. - "4 , ,:. , , . " , . . -1 ,I , -�.,� ��; , �, � � � I , ,e 11 - 1. A , -, ,.� . � ;��. I - � I. �. , . I ,�A� I 11; ,,- ': ". . .1, !, 1 � 1 , �. , � - I ". 1. i �;, i -:1I 1 I .."'L. ll -411'51' e � I ; �" . � I'. ri, i. 1:1 I . , . i ... �. , �. ;: � �I��,�-f,e.. ; ��ii- : )� ,,,, � ;-, ", . .1 ,,;, . - � ml� rv�l.:P,Fri . , 11 �� �, ,,, I - I �, I . - � . , �, �, I � 't , v , - , � - 11 I �` ��, �� ., � ,� � ", I �, I ., � , -.1i :", ;�,�, ':i�! - � . ,I,, I .11 1`141-� I. � �- !�,'-i, , -,.,; �':. , 1 I,,. , � - ol : - . � �'; � ,',�, i . . IF, .. -FI . I .1- � , I - 11 ,F�-7,'I' , ,�.�.� I � i", 1- ;�, .- � 1; ,,, . 11 I : � �,�, � . � ,L ", _ ,, " � i", t, ". , ,i� , . ,� i:.�, ,��, � ,, - � ",!.,. : 1:. �, �,: �,., ,,., - �-� " . , � , I - [, , " ,.. I:,- - I I I - '. I . ' . I f - A� -,4!:; ��,,-Piit,� ", - , , !� F,,!4,' : �� F,�' ., . . . - � � , . I I . 11 I I , il , . 1,i1F I '' , ;i . �', � � -11 I . � ,. " I � , , I �, I � .I , ; .I - � .�. ',I� L �:I;I�-"_-- , I I I I . -' ��'.` " . , � - '; ,-' i.��, �,; � L' ��' �` . L . ;, ,!�, - �,- , I " I " I �1�1 - - 'Fe 1� 1,"P ,-'at" ��I,`-!,�"t � - p,.* # O`j,jAv, .";, 4., jl�,I, � �-'-,'irl W� y �:� .,;, ,, I I ''Il -,, " , � , . , .1 1: , I .�; , , , " , ,�l� .. 1 ,�. , I I. I, �, .. , � , " , I , . .. �T' ',. , I , , - , " �. , , . "" , ,-f , , ji 1 "" , '�', I , * ,,iei , , - L" , . � . " 6, , � - -)! . , , , , i,:��, Z t i", . � , , 7:, , , iF , , , ., - .i, . I I ". , , � � . , I , , I I � � , , . , � � , "", i - O I I 1� I I I 1, I. I ti ;- . �- I , e, ri�l , " 1j, � ,,, V I " 1 4 ,,, 1, 'e, l, "I , , , - , , '. �. . � . I I - -,,4 i . 1. ,; " :, ,,, . 1� , . � I 11 �. I I I � I t` �;�': , IF "'ll, � . .. ;, , ;- ... :1i f '11- .1 I� 11. ) �. . , � � �, �, � , , , - . 1 . - , ? ;,�e'L. ,);,. ; , , , , iI. ," . I , - . " - I I I . , � � . I . . . I , , . , �, �,i � -, "'i: I � �- , �.��,o. - li" ,i, � . - �; -, .. , . I ,, I "!, �. ". I I , : �� , : , ", . I - I � . . �� ., , . I i � I, ,�, ii, C e, , -4, � ,, I I - " � " , j, - I , "I , I , . I', 11 ''I , a :�,� , . � -� � � � " i " � �.; , , ,, , ,'�� "I ! , " 11 '911. . j : -, -f,�F L �': ,:�� '-�!�_ , �Lj.; ,�F . .� i� -i � ,,; :I �, � �,, ,, , ;,. . , , ., �'. �. ; iL"F: ". "I4, I, "'j; ,,.I i- � ,��,.. � , I I . � . ; I'- � , ,,-�', I , - 11.1. 1, ', ., �., , .; i. "" -� .� , , � �'. . ji ..... -:., - , � _:�-. ,� 11 � .;i 11�.I:v *z � - 11 , "'Wil ,, Y P"A i!,, ,,� 'Al'; �r '. ��:. �, "". ,:",:,:, , l, 1; . I IJ � . ,. 1, li�:I'rl 11, I ' � , "o, � , I :)�. � �� 'I '� �'� ' 1`� . " -: � 44.' - ' , I � , f , I 1:1 I � ,!. . , -, I, � I 11 - 1. 11 - - -- __Z" 1, I IF. � 7 "" "it'- ", � I ,l; , 'i I lw- :.. I i;I", , . -. .,:., ,i,el ,-i .,.,e-:1 ", �I�� �, - ,,, �': - :�,� , 1", """ ` ;# r, ��', - �,7 �,� � " .� , � � ,I � � , ", j - , , i" I -i", :3, , � �. , - 'i , . ":I .�'. I .: 11 1.-7, ,�I� " ,,�� -:''�,-,`,1`.i:`, ��' ,e� , " ", � ", 1:,Ii - F � :0,�:j�il- - 1,�- � t �i )11 I "', ;, _ �, ,, ,V "W. i 'it ;� ,I 1, 1.�,. i. , i, i�. , ]" , "'. - . , , , " �-'.�.-,- .1 :I�� ;, '. " . ., .. , . ,, -�-- :-l'.""'i� . '� ,i ', , 7��;,�';, !": " 1, � ,�-. � ,v- " " , �, ,,� -,,,, . -.,� ;. , - T.[�.J- .�eilj 1. . I 1�' 'e'"'��Iili:�-, '1�11 ". � ,, ;i t i , , 11 .. ir, , 'j,_ _ ,,i,,,., �'�, Z_,'_.� � �*'JV.4,1&��.' _"� � 1. I - '.,Fj ...... "�"i-e;-', . -..' I'll; � , , "'I - F- . , . -' - .� - I. 1. i- --�,, ,','o,,I �, , ,','.,�,�l - 3 , .,� -, , Ill.- ,,,, I7 F ., %�� - F it � , ��, �, , ; � - - , , ., :1 �L, , I � , ,j - ", - I � � . . -i I." 1'. � �'i'. " , ', , � I L .� � ... 1, 11 , F� ' .7 � - ..-i)(I'l , , . -11 '.1 - ., "P L � , :;F"", " � '), ,; I l�, , � - - ".�il, I F I k I � . 1."* I 1 .1 � �� ,, , - T ,-. ,� , ' ,.V -j , �: .-.�'. ", 1. I,, I - - , . '�j �, 4'4 j�jii�,, '#�j, �4'4' iii�" . - ,-F; 1.�- -.1. " ��, " , . - 4. .. , � . ,: - :11� ii, 'I , � I � ,, 'It , :1 I - I , , , ,- - ,, -i -, , %F� : ", F;� i , . ; � ,F,I. �, " I , I . : , �I. � - I ,�� , 7 " ,',';i j- .; I '..!,t, , , ; * 11, - j , ,-' , ',., "'. - . , , - , � . " - I I � 1 41' ' � - -� 'I"'" ' I , li ' " i' ; I - � ,� -� - . I " . ", � , ` , I , . 1� �� I ,� ,,�,,, ��". , , ii - i �",� ,-T'-,-�'; , - �� , . , , �� - �, , . � , ; "I , , I �e I , ,,�. , i'. , I 4!, , , , _ ,,)�'. � � 1_ ' ,',I, ,JL �' , 1; - ,, :, 7, "� 'F, f'.., 1.1 , F -ml ,% , �, �iL ,� r :.: , , , 11 I 1. , . . , �, , 1, 1. ', - n . , . , , I I , -, ;IiIi . . . . . . . . � I 11 L I. , I , " I , , , , - . 7 1. .1 ,.'Ili" I I "; I 11 . I I . " � F, , ,� I . , � � ;,I i, 11 I I . I 1.i .1 1i I � , .1 , F, L'; ": ',' � �'�" L ' , � � . .. - ,. ", 'i 1) , , , - -,, � - " , �'4- '- , � I I.Ir , . ' ' 11, t, ' , ; .1 .1 --I':' I,, , � , 1, "", . . '-,�, , 1;, -j !, ; �!I: j -. , . , " ,I,,,, , " : i , ,,, I �, �� lil!�'; ,, """: . , .�� ,; , 1. I -, �. - - -;�I,�,� ,. ,.� I ,:� ; , -, , � , . , - , . ;.� ,,, -�."'.,;", --;,-�.', � �.�_ - ,:, , , ;,i�,,-' I � , , � , '�if, � IF , -: .-1111- �L ".-, ol ��,,,;,.�, , � , e i -, - I If L:' 4 iF il-Ile" � , . -.� .1 , . - � " I ,� , . , -�--. : 11- , , , , � . . 1. ` . � ,,, ,f � i 1;1lf"i � � " , 1�,,, ,, ., . 'i;, I, I i , .1 I - ,I, I ,. I 11. ., - " - i, I - I I: ,,, 1 , , , .", , ,: � , -',�' , .., . - i,-,-' " ". i' I I ,, 11. ,� � I ; , 1. , . , " , . � . � , -, , - , , 4, - "I " !I -,' ie, , , ; - F,� �:, � , , ,, , I Pr , -1, "A, I �p -1 -0e - , i ,- -� IF 1 .tl,� , �;Ii 1.�,; , ,,,, '. ,,:,, 1 ,; 1 , i :1 . -'. , " . � I' . : : ii� , ,�. : i� . i , , ,- i" ... , . :. , , , .11�,., � ;�, 1�,- 11: " , , � "I �`eli ;, , , . ,� �',, � "I ,� - - , � � t'", � ,�e - �F : , - 11 � .. i. - - , , . � , : ti , , i" " , , , Ii ,,, � .; � � ; � - -, , . ,JVV 7'*Ii,,�, . i - , i,� � �,,, , ; ;." :- , , A '' j'' . I , � , i ', , " , , � � . I I - I 11 I 11 �, " , , �: - -L- I , , , 7", " , -, ,, � i I " : '-, I, ; - ; ".. ': _ " ;; ,, '. - - ,,, �!, . � I -�jl ��l' I , , .. 1,.- - 4, .. , 'j, - _,, � , .: ... 1," -i . , . . - I "-;, � , 111.1-L --__�I;,�"j ...... � __..,L��, i,_ �. _ : . -1, � .1. . � - -tz-, ,,.,- ,, _* L 'J, � - "', " , "-;� ,'-,�, W- #,�� ,,,�r -��- �,�-� �L,tii'�- ,'.��;; ... i`- -' � - 1, ii -I , 1, --- I ; , . � . , � � . � , , . , 1,.-�- - - , I ... I - - '. r --7- !�IIFIT,l��.iteir - I ,i � 1.7 �- -r, -,�qpj�i.-egr _ , - ,�=-,--,,� ,-'�- .11- -�7"rrp �, . . ,�qt-"," _ ,� �, ' , -- �---- - , " , I .. . �, ..,. ,�� )Ii�� i�, �:�" , , . , 1,1 I 11 � ,� , " ;. lb, -, ,, � -- , '1� ""I" ,;;-,., I,�, -,' I " ��"II � ,�J,� -��LP illilbF,11 , -11-, �, . 1, ,��-I , ,, �. ,. � - , I � I-) I ,, - 7, ` � _i,,� �,�,1"4( " " "I., ��,. . - -!�, � 1- --.�- ..", � -:� - - - 7 �' j .�! �-- --;"; , ".". 11-11 � Ki - .1. 41�, �,-- -*'.. �-`.- , -1. I Iil I I 11-�- , -�, . ., I I- .- .-t .., 'I - ,,, -1-1 � 1, ,,�. � ,-', 4�-,�-,,�,,!,�,��-,i.:i; -,-,.�-: _ "��'_ - - � .�,�-!,ii�l ,I i; �;,,'-3�.��,�ij.:�, ,� " I 'I _ ;, 4 -41 , - I ;��-, ,�, �2 �-� �, ,�,, , 11 ,� '--:2, -,- -1'-,N-�,� , , - i ,;,3, .1 , - . , I � ,#, , ,,-, � -- 4 p ; z �-i, 7 ,� , -� . I ., I , ,. .�, .�� �1, - 'i ,,�, - �,, e,��, - %i." - � , i , I � I , 1,; ;� : .� � e� T. t� �� �;,I,;.i: I I.. � ., . - .. ,,,, : ���,' ,t � , . , � " , , - , . �," ,, ;I , 'YA, ,� " i ", .; - _I 11 I , � . 11! -�,T,��,-��,'�' I �41I�- ,,, " I " " , , " - � . -4, , Z'i1i,- F? , , '' ;, 11�.I,1, I ,� "I - .1. �r " - "'. I ';,, I, , ,i" -, _, ,. - z't,pio � ,, " 1-1 1; - iL , : , I ILI 11.� , � IF; I , �, . , - �rk. i 'N'r ''.1 -k — , q,o .. I � �� 1.1, I � " , `I— ,I ,, - ,,,�l-�(i � �'. . ,4 �r, �, Y ., � i'e If.' , " , — ; .", e 1. , ,,., � ��",,�," �, I � � �, � ,. -��i I 1�.')", ,. : i.,ji, �113— A—I I ,:.� I 1. . ", ,;IF .. 1 .1 ,� ,, !" 'I, - . 'I , 1 ,, �-,��4,ete,::,—R � � ;- " - , I - �i Ilt� " ti F 4', ; , � � " I '. . .1 I 1", � . , , . � - - I I �.* ,. � . , , . ) , I., . ,,, ,, ,r�,; ..... : " ,. ,�� .1, . I,,.: -' 4 I 1, I - . . , I -1 �.- I I 11 , , i;i � I �, � ", "I , IF �. ".-I , I i i � . ;- - v� , , , �;: ,'ti��,I: , ,I , �;;��,� F , �:�, .1 ," �`:,,' "', ,;. 't, � ,, , i "' , � I ;11�11-.A!�', ) " . , � I, , , :_:, . � . ,� , � , � . .. , ,. i.-- . , ", 1, , �-, ,, , � , , - 11;1� " - ,,�i, , lj&,'�, -;��Jt fl�,�,-4�lilrl .:, I. , . ��, , , , , . I IF. - 1. , , .. wtv 4 - - �, , . � ... � , � i, 1, ,,� i,�,- '.;.- � �- :� . , I ,,;� , ",;, ; .; �, � � �r:, " ..� I : I ; I ,i- . . 'o! ... . ,7, � 1;. , F � -.1, ��: , �, ii� i . , L�, , ,� - I. �. t. I -� , �'�� , 1,�, �, � IF , I V,;� � ".0 "! ,��,;' I 1, � , 1"... ,,�I � , , , , W.-� T - .�: ,, - . !'r., - �, " �.- f'I , ;,,,I,,, ,-.' , - , ", " ,, ,;, "' � i - "... F, ;,��,,, 1, � Ii f� ','�, . � ji,,'�,'� 4'I'll , , i � ill! -;;-�, ,,I,� I ;1 , v,! ,, ,';i:�, �': �" ., ,, �' , .4 - , , , I ; �,,, . , r , " ,,';I� 'r � "I", I, ,';i . '))IV. `-I�k�4: '�II."���l��'l.�;:�'�W'��'1,?'t� !�;'�-_,�, , 1; I ".�, � , . . 1, � ,( , , ,,�r ,Fi;-�. , i" . , ''. it , �, � .. I L I I '� 4 � �,� 'I,*.,- , , �Ii ��'�"� I - "II 1, t '1,1- I,- .,. -.�,.,� -�, , ,. i� - .", T I.e�',,J, .�: .. - ` , - ,�,� -�� � " �,� � , � I 'I- '- i * ,te� I - ,4, : )o,t;!,- %���. " , I, �',p: I ,-,, �;, 1 1 � 11. .. . I i" ,.. , - I " , -� .�_ , , ,, ,� liji ,� ,sl-;;4�",�,, �m,' I, �,� 1�,;;,- ,III "ji Air"'I , $� 1 , , � : ,,�� , , I I i 1. I" , i. ,, ' �' � , , , , : i . , . , , ,. � 1, . ', , , "., il - il .:.,,�, l..', �[� IL,:, . , �. . , , - I ,�� - , , -� � l�, 1, � I .j'� , 'I ,,.L ,' . I"' - i, � ,, l% , 1 4. , ., . ". 1. 1, , 61�, e,fe L, FF ,-� -F. I , . .- I., � , -;ejL .. , I - ." � I r1i, , It , 1-:' ]]�L � � l,� .�', i, . , I � .. . , �", :,� " - - ; � I . I I 'I , :, � �il I , 5 � - 1, W ;`f'I:-�F, V1, ,-, � , k ,�-' �1�,-,.',l, �F ... !"-" ,I . . I ,[. �:, � , ., , ,4 ', ,A. ,,� �.,,-'iiw�,� , ,',,I, , 'I- ,:� , FI, �I "'i .� ll� I ., I - 4t �,,. �. Kle -il� ."."'It, I I '!I , ,�,�,; , , - � ,�, ", ., iY __�: - - � o',4 ,!� ;,, -. ��iI��,i--; I � *. I 'i, �, .�, ' ' , ,, ,,, I I I. -� .. . ..... I , � - "', , . �, , " ,�i,��, Y ','�.-;Ii- , .; ,"i, 1" �!�� � )�, ,, . - � �I - � , I � � t ,� I " , , , , � . , , , ' , �, i.1' ;1, 1,, , ,, � , . , 't. "I ' ` - -: Z " '.j' 1. - ,-"�� I lIL: , ,� . .11 - ,,,, . -)P ,-�.��, ","4 ,,,� , --, � I , ,,,,, , " ; "', ,-, -, I ,�, '. , , ,- � � �:, V", , � , -, o-' � , , , i, , ,� .' �4 �.; � I !, ' i� I ;, - . ., ", �� ,,' .4.1 -, . , ,)� '"' ' ' I � 1, ;, ,,I',,- " ,,� I 'i ,� I . -,I�,�, 1,�: - 11,11� --,I. le. .. , , I� �� 11 11 . - - , i � , ell, :', 11" ,&, , I � 1 , ".0 , , , � ., , , , , -, �,- � - .1 . I 1. I'll.1, - ���, � -.1 ,-�,,� , .. i" I . . i � � I d, , - � ,,, i ��� -� ,i�,�lj- , r., ", 1 ,I. � ,�..- - .. I ,;� , . L , - .1 -, . �. . i, '. - .-, , , � ��,� . ..� , . , , 'ce I .,. , , ""! , , I4 ,�14 4F , �, , " 1, 11;j � � �, k ", - , " 11.� ,,, I'll". ,� . , ,ll�. : ,I� �:�, ill; . , �,� ....... 7"�,;I, I4'- 1. ,,,�, l, ,; ,F� .l. , ; " ", , � � :��, Ill , , , " - ��, 11: 11 I � . . I . -, , l�'' , � �, . ': -, i I , .� , I , l - ''I'', I I ,,, - - -, ",I j* ;!,�--� FF , ;,� ,,i� , : �� , , , �, I - :11 1-1'� - - �- 1, , 1, , , .1 � , . I I , p � I .: .I I - , . ,�,�'� ... i- �' -si I 11 I F��, ;11.1 1; `,� '0�1`1. I I '-�, , - ,,, '��, � i, i , , , , . ,,� I - -i "', .: '. �.,,,-,.� �. i .I ,,, - . 11 ,�;b, I I .. - � .1,11". , I I , , , ,�,,,-,! F , . k,,W, !.; I 1. ,,, , I,,� , P ,,, ,,, : , , - 1,; ---, , - � ,�,'.- " - D'I.q OW �4.45i, , , "i "I -," � --�,, n - f�i',�.: - ,��,�111.:'-'. "I . .1, , 11 I , � I I , I , 1. 11 , , , , , -! , t , . � . FF � ,,, "'! , .., F;.; 1;� ,,- �' ; , I , I I 11� , �1, , Ii , ,, j. . " � ,-.F-� � I �, j:,,, -� �i,q ", ., � ,F-�,�, ,� x� ,,, ,;, : i " � 1 i I, , ,�, I , , I � i�,f, � �lj, �, , I ;t, ,. !. );"�,:-', -I I jil';;-, , I i, W, I ��.Il_, "I. , I , , ; V I , � -0�.,� ,,, ; � I ..... � � j ' I : ��L � --" . 1. :k I , ,,; "' �,,�.e.,.- 1 , I , ie � - ;� �� " � -i �,� i" ; ,, I It � �,��,, �-_11,7i �7� �., ", I t, 'It ��,kj, k" : , �,�,w *-$-2t � �, , t ,.v 51 , ', ,,,��, I � ,,, , I 1 i F, . IF , � ,� , ,ik,:iii'l ��'.4 , �;: , . JF�11 I I F. � " , -l- - � � , rj� I ,,,, - , , I T , . , �. I , ,��%AIOOV,i,ol 'vI;. . i", ��k�p IF. ,� .1 I 1, . 1'� I . ,�'.!, ,�. . ; �: r 1� P, ". " " � , " , .11 - i,�,,, �� - - I 9"O'iI Al 1111" I . . .I," I., 1, . ; �:� .1 . . - - I I . , . I" 1 I4� Ij , I,'ttw�-A,'J,-'A.-Ir�, ,� -� Iq � , -,�, 't .� " -� )2 " F � 1 �� " " I VT ' 71 -- -`I�e"�Il. ��; ,� , , - , "U, i , I� , I , I ; '� , l�'! ,� . `1 I i I I 41" l'. . ". . — . , �,4. �.6�4k��,,,—;�,,Zn� , 11 F� — ,- — j —,i�11-,�,:-,,,�.� ,,i,��`�II;,,:: " — . 11.11 � - ,, 1, , "'"'"i'l, — , , � � ". -'' i;, .I , , I _ , ,.— iii t'�,, ,, 1 '4A, I " , ",hj,� . - 1.11� , , , I '', ,- —. , � I'' 1-111-: .. . ��,,,��,11011ILe,1,11 .� , " , .l�� i,� ,I � —_� " 1 I - ii' �' 1 ' 141 e I i'l I - , . .. -� '. i . , , - , � ?. , -, lli� - 40i I I I . . . �� . �I, I , i--�,,:, n � "', - � I -4 ,W�,,j�!,,,_, �1, ,;- �,:,. ,,�, �_-- -�.i �,Ibil'.,A��� j,eli'"�. , 1, I ,,, . ; � , � ��. - � ll�- "K ,�;J�"-.4 �L,,� �, � ,; ",Z, �l'� i F' .." : , , �, - i . II " I ��tF � T .L . ... � . I , �� ,b��,, �- ii , . i , l, � ;1:1 . 1:. I i:; � "Ill "'i", i:t� , - 1� I , I , ... ... T� ,, , -, - . - � ... l, � . � l,� -.,;, �'. , - I I i- ; � II: � � j, -'n: � -111 . " " , , " I ""'i -I", "Fill 11 , 1� c.- - , � , , - - ," k, " �, ,�F. ., - ,,, I" 1�., -'(,.� ,, 'l,�. i: -" � , , , �4' � " � , -lI �, '. e, ,,-;., 'i", � ,:� IF, I .,�� , I.. �� -- -Fel--i. ,,, 1 u ,;"��-":i', , I���'�-, "', � ."� I� �1� e,il � ,- I ". - j " ite . , ". " � " , - � , � , ,, ', F�. . 7, - - , �': , I '. .. � ,I, - ,, :1 ,, e- , , L, . ;,�, � ,I ,, I I I -1, , � �. I I.- f , ; � 1 1�4.4` I , , , '. jtl� ".1 P I'll e, 11 � � jill, , , . , J., _�. F'.4, ', 1;FI -,"I".) NAFI.fl, .� . e .4, ,I . I , ", � , I il -� . . g�,��_ . ") 1� , - , . , 11 11 � 4 :1, 11 '---, ��-,. ;,11�i , , ; , I ,� F I I I 1 L, ,., , � i , , ;, l, .,� ", � �,F,�.,',�i, l-(.��, � ", , ". . e. ,. , - , , . - � , . f. - �, - I -I �, . , . . , . "I u , Ir \� 1� � ��" �, Ie',� ��' ': ' ,:�lr - -':t 11 I, .. .1 , �� - , , � - 1 , ,' , , IIOI�', e,� : � l: ', �,',�, � ,,,��, �;, ;, ,.� ";, � �� _I�L''FI,1�," - � "'t;- , - ,I " � . 111. � , 11 ...." ii- I . I � " , , . 11 ; , , , *; I �. - , 1. "I - � , , ." - ;,I,, _ ' �!" F� 1 ;'�`�� � �, I �. ; l� - I ;,F,, , I .1 , , , '' ,, �j,, - , �`, ,;i� -,L�',;',.1,1.�' I , , � I..", , 11 FF �, , r, I -, E 1�.Jl , I . ', ,, ,;,�,,�, ,� �LIlyj�; i e� � I' It �tI,;�, ,iiX, 1`1 1. I ",i.f1v "eh" I I ;11 I �- L 7 -: , -Ii,:,,X�P,�F'�- --,�,",. 11 - FO ,�,:�,'�I,.,�,��,I'..-� ,,,I� -_ 1, i " - � , I, - ,�, 1, , ,�:7,-- 'I, : it i 71�1�� I., .1 I, , I . I ''. - "I - - - - FI , V , - " _I " - e;'. , , " , .,,�, ��','17� , � , . , � , �Il , " ,�,f , I �11, �,,'� , �:: :i;, -, I � ,e�,, ;ji' � ,,, I: z� ,- I � � . l� ... , , � ,,.,,, , J', k , ,, IF ,%. " I 11 ti", , -01 ,�� �j� : ,:,-;� '. � II � ", ;", : ,, , ."". ", '. . 1-1 I'liF . ,ii. 'i , " , " , � , I' ,� , , - - ' "F1'4i.� " �,�'i ' ' . , , -L ---1.1- ., ,�i,tv'%-!.�Yi '4, ,*,, , j I , q` - � , � I ,i,:�:-, 11 �f! il , -�, :. � -,., 1� -�i-,'�,� �,�i�e�"i::��,jI ��-! , I , , , ", ,, � . ii.l� , - '�' � - I - I � . i "' 1, � . '�, , i� �,, "', . " F.I� "I - I I I�I'V,,'�I� . .1 � . ..... I I ,,,,, '. ,�,,� , ". ,I,� ",;, �", i, f, - - ,� I - " . . "'t-, ; , I I; ;1:,ilz" 1.11, f , , " 'L I I 11 "' ' ".;: " , 1;;� .. � ..e "." , . P", � � � I, 1; I b 'i , " �_- , " - � L. I I" t4l��,,I, ,'.i;�,), ''1,, ,,4 . ..... 1, . � ev,�.��, 11�, f,ei�",;,� II ', �� ii�, , , � �,�� , . .1 I I - I , ,..- I 11 I , I j. , -j� , - : - , , , , , 11 - ,,14 .. - 1, , ! 1� -1 'I, 1. - �'L I ; " , iei'l ,�`,,,[�. kl� � , 1, ,I� . ,�,ee ... �, -- li� . "Ill, 6iiii i :,�� 'll, . � - ��;� i: ; ,, I - " , I 1, . , , ,- ,.F1 it 11 11 "IR , . ,i:� r�,, 1, � : , L�� � �i,�::e, , ,i .... -P - , k- , ,11; I � I - ., IF � � 1 I .1 , I - � �,j, " � T 11 I - .I 0 - - , 7i� - , , , . - "� I I - �, "ll, � - ,:,� , "., , .., , -,�? ,� ',',.�; ,-", , ,- ;,��F�� . I - . �Fl 11 .��'J' 11""' � , � . , . , , , " , . I I ,�.j ,;":" ,,,, . . . . �11, � �1, t . , "I4 , ,� ,, '� ��Ii 1, I, i - :, " �,', 'I, � , " .1; �, , I , .. 1.11 � I I - � , A. - I , - , " I �L�l ��) � ,,- . I . I . .1 - 1'� 1;� � ' ,, Fl 1 �,J;F '�,, L' "I ...... 1, " ,� � - , �F - i,F,:l11 � -�, � " - I ... I ,. , , I'�`,N i'll 11� � I . " i" 11, ... I .- - ,,, - -i;�'. I " , , - " v,��, - ,��i-,, , �,� I , I .,�� ��, "� , � - - F; , - '. . ii, ,� , �,� ,, � - ` . "If " ',, , , e ", I; � t1i' 1';'� 4` . " � 11 � � , � l� � 1�1, ,,,l�O Ii"," � ,,,,i� !, I � ", I . 11"'.�, j. 1�7 i,j,�',' I F 11 t, � . ,. -f ( 1. I I.- 711, i ; iL 1' ,. , �:,-_,,ll�, � �j,�Ii,-, :�� � , ,� , �J � 11 IF, � ( '" . 1, I -1 - - - , , � I - ; I , " z"""! ; , I, ; "!:; (!, " i h. , ,Z' � I IF i" ',I , , , , Ill -�,�. , ,, !��;: j�, � �� , ': � 1, : : ,lili .,I'll, , I . . i, ;-, � '. I ,,, I I, , , " t , �o ,I� ;i". i1`011, ,� , M. F,�i.� �), �J�`. , 'I I— ,: � - � �i' , �', 11 �, , � 11 � I .1 1, - �. . � 11 11 � 11 'T I,- ' '1' ,j " - , " :,e.%*, 'A:;,l.,.'i, ,�'I. ve �.��, �', I l, "o., !,,I ", j �k i ill l ;h-1 . , I . ." , .1 ", --, .11 !� ",i -11il-11-1 11 1- , ,,,, - ..." '.1, . ... 41 I. -I -.j - , - / - - . - 7, ,� - . ,. , �, it. ". ': � , . �j" ,, , � I �' � '41, I ", , � � . . � . . �"., lie, -�i � I .,t,i IT- , , � I, i I , ,i ,,, I : I " I ,, . . . � , - , , . , ; " ,, I ij- 11, � ;,I I , ,, IF "�, ,. , �, it, ` -11C 1, iii, ,4 Kf. �, ,',' "'� - I I W . I - , ,I'. . , , .1�� TO ;, " , ,� ': :, 't �t- V�i.!; � - :,-, " , �,, , � � . , �� � ,.�,� : ,,4F �-;, :- I' Ill - - , . I . i., I , - "p 'L'. .,I 1,4 - "Ij �, �,J,, , " , ,,, ,,,,,, 'Fl"- , I., 1, � - , , �i i , � 11 I 't � I . �`i'4 Y,J,,t,5 , " ,, , . 'i , ., I , . I'll, �I I � i I tv. 1, `�' ,� �,',�,�F ", �, F, �, 1�7,i !,� � , I , , � ... . I �. �;, . , �, , . , , . �, 'i", , 1;, , , i� ,;, �;, �; ,, , � � . , , . 'i . : !I , " � , , � L, .,; �i- �� ��i� I ,� , . ��, - , :' -t. - -, , ,-.-1,1 I ," 1�1 "'i R ,� v�,Il;'��;�' J"Ji' 1 i' ;, , :'� � �� I�F i F,��I.��,Ii�,L :9V ,',!�"',�II��' -� ��IlI� � I I 0, I � FF, :�� � ;F � - , , , 11�1 ,, �. ," ," I , 11� ii�� I �� .. . , � ", ; �"-'--�. e-r,i, i�,F.'. -, ill - - � :�� ,� ,�t��;, ilit.�','Ivl �,;,F;,�� - " , I'll. , " ', F', I , , - , " , , , I , , , , I , � , - "I � I � �, `7 �1�7 " I I 1 `4 1 - ,� , - , I � I I I , , , I I il 'I ,,;I I � �, 11 �.* .� - 'it, - A ��t;, !-e, " I I I I I I I I � � " , , - , I , , - _ 1, lYi", " , ,� I 11 ,, ,,�,,6, :F�, !, "�', -"� - - ,� � , ,.� . �, , � ,� � � 'I, , , - ,F, . - ; `:,I�' ` V 11 , , ,, ,, � I , ,�, . .1 � � , 'Il, .� ,L", J.'ij . ,,.� _ , �,,,:,I, ,,, , �, ;tI�� , 'Fii -, � ,, " :; , .,,,� ,i-, 'I'll 1. ,,III 1� i; , , " `Fn , I , 'I o, I -, " � -,,� "t" ,4p �-�"�N;�. , � ,� 1-1- . I I I.. , I" �� � ". ;j, �� , � I , t, ' �l'�� � , , ill, ,�, , �'. � , I � �F, ,,,, , I ,i :'I - �" � � ,, ,,, ell, I :,,FI ," , I , & � , I 11 "'� -' elj:;��: '�,I' 'JI -til" .1 i l", I - - �, 1�',je��,_--,, I ' "I -j" ,, T-' - .. , -,--, ��, 1� -I� i - ,�� "',I, ,,,, 1�11, tj. .I " I'." 'I'l �4"j., , "'; , i ." , . - � , . , i), * I , , " , : i -i", ��,�, "'t , , � t" -;;,-, ', , ` F'- i��,, Ili a , 0� ,I� ;II( 1. 1� I I't,'; , . 'I, , , ,! , �. I . "I-,, , ., "".. � il. .. I 11.1e�l � " I Ill 1, �, , . I" - � , 'e, �� t .,Iq� � , , ,� . ,71�� - - I -I, , , "I � , �1 1,411L _�I, I I" , � �' :`;� � ,:,i;�,"'!",�"' , � 1. 1, t"', . 1;�-- 1". , �. - i It I , . . " li',I� ,-,"!�' I'V ll� ce-,, -I �- "I �,-,�J,I,4�11 '',"i . , , ,X - - - I ... . ... I. I'lu , . " " , , L 'i,,'ltt� , �, , , . , �� I . , 'i, , " -1 , I - F,!;�;',_-Ir , ,,I,, , 1, ��', ,�, ,,,�,,,j � , 1;,,F �� I F, F, , ,,,, �,� l, I . , 6`� I I,;,: � ". , I - ,,I , , , "i".. ,V , �,1,1, i1W, F"I", "' "' ""' , A'.'.1i. . '. 4 , -e ��i� "."I,., , - -1 � -, ,,, . , , I - , -" � ,� , � . - I , � F, �11 . 1pm, �:',,,, - - 1 ,, � l"It ", . ll, ".", " ,. .."', - I l-, - 1, 1, " 11 , J. ., ". :.I'. �. I , Il�! �`F' IiII �:4, ,� � -�,,, 1 e I, - I � ,z �, I " � 11'�: "". I � I ",'I , ". .1 v , 1;;J�11 ,I i , ,;, , �) F�, '- �,X f!l�,�;7,- ,�, ., ."; ,16","","', .,`Iii�... � �. , �. �' ,, , I, - , ;, I -, - ". . � 1, :� ". , I ll� , , , iq-i ", , 11 " .1 - , - . v ,,,,, , I ,,, ii. , F�,', 111-�--�tr�':�1,7r;7 -,'I i �,'� ,', IT', , ;i��l. , � rl-tll - , - �,, �",(Fl � 'f�'--_4. ,, `-�)� ,I l� �`�'ei�' I `,,� -,,�o�', " V,�Ii-i II')�" ��,;��' : � '-t-'�- �1� !!.i I, , � t , lo,�v L� il��,ie--- , , -1.', �I, � """ � .. .... f ,;J -Ft,;, , ,,,e,;�;�-, F�" " I V� ,,; -I, ,,, ,,� I IF � �ql ,,I I'll , , "�� .... .. ��,-,;;,Q, -, "" *� ... I '..'I" -le -- . 111�1111 i llell,�, , 1 � �.Iii,' �,. � - - ��, " I 1 1. �� , ,, A"I . ': - - , . - , I I I " , . , ,� t - 'ii: ,, -,, FI, � ,- ,, , I'. t, !,-, � i., � " dl,-�; . �,�; ,I, '-iro � . �� � , M, I . -v I 4 �'. %,� � I,, I � �, I � I ,�, " � �, ','I� . 1, i�V' ll:, -, ,,� , . .. ":I . , ,,,� , ,F,� � , i"t :" ,� :- ,,� ,, ` �� - �' I, ", 'i I. .... , - I ,;. . ":i.; �,.,4iij , , 'I" 1, I , , , � '. �".. , ,"! � � 1� , I �� !�-. i, � , , , , , " ;, h, -�� ,j;1.1 �� , � , �, . ,� 1; -:,;;. , I . , " i�, � ,,�?-, " ,;, , -, ��;F,-�I ", -le,,� :, .� ... ci' :, I,,,��,, Ylc,-�--, � �� i", ", : I ,;'. 1, %," , " . , I �: , - . i ,I,, 17�, 7 � I I 1 , � � � " - . , ,� , , , 1� I --- � F, ,�,�,7""I.It":!'. '�� �-Zil, ",ei�, �,�;,!� ��, I,; ,,, , . , , � . " "I 11, " ,�;,Vl�,�,;'�Ii.,, �, � � ,.I 1, � Fe � � . .. .... 1. ,. ,,j, , ,I,:."",� e, " IF , ii , - I I , ',I i I I t 1, -� R ", i ,, � , , , , . O ,,� - -, i ; p , -,; , . , � ,� lo ;- . , , � .. 4"".. "', ,, , I , I .1 1,1. 1111111 1, ", , - � . ,, I �.. ,� � 7. 1 _ ," .r, r. ,,.,,, ,� , :�� - , —I , I I - I I .. , � I � . I )"i I � , " � i. , I', , 1 � . � U ,�t � I � " `�i: k i"11, F " 'I .1, 11 ' lk., I- IF I 1.11 I " �'-,, ,: ,;� �': . . , :, ,& . �i,wfl!r I 11 iii'��, I: , : , ,� ,� e4li .�� ;:il - I I � - -, , I , \ J" F e�,�� I ��141"'- ` I� � ' '� I` I , 1. li 11, " . ,i. �' - IF �,ii� ;- � ,,,, :�� `i'�,'�� i� I ��,��l,"-`� �, � , Ij�,� �',l�Fi: : -,���: -�.'- " ��'�V F`1 ' � � ` Ir I I , � h, 1. , ,;�,"";L ,"i �lj'�� "�,: �,;'�' " " ' �', ,,"� ',�,� ir I -�, - 1'� , , , , , . � IF I ,'� , ,,,, -,11 I - - j" I "" � , ,i : I , ,.7 11 I I � , , - . � I �Y; �i , I � . '�11'.�', � - ,;I I - - "' I I'll 1�1 � 11;,�,��',F',Iiw� �, [ - . �i': I 1, !I I 1 1 I , I , .�j � �.-, . . , , ,-, , . �".,.���,,.",,.,,.��,,�'-',,,�'7�,�,�"",;�,�, , , �,-`l ,- - - � - 1i,,Jl,,;jII � ,I� - , � 1: . 1: �i� : ,�. .." - . I . . . ;�oe,;""'�?i� !.-I , 11 ll�l . I , - ';l',"��I�-�,F 1�,-�I, � `�-�'.��� , � -� ""! 1 �. i� � i-�� ,'!; F I �,�I, I , i ',�-�, � 1. ,� "' .,� �, . .il , - I .-.�i, �f;�. � ,j I , I- , , " , �:�'Pl, �., I l�', ;� ,� ", � 11. X,l , �' I I ,,, :: � 1� � - 11� V I .1 -,."j, , � F, ", i '' - "I Jlj,F� -1: � , 4"j, ""',,I .,',-i, ,;, 1w," �,�X'. I % -- ,, 'ji�, ,� 11. ', W." , , � �il i -,i,I,,��,�-"I ;� ,, I , A; - ,Il,i, �F 1`� L� - . I. . �, I � I,- , I 1 I - - , 1 , � - . � ., . , , F, ij��..11�. ,, .. , � 'i" , , ;, - , 1 . I � :.2 1 � I �11 I , , . I " I ', I, (,,', -,,Ll, ,) �� l,� i, ..I""":F[ I i" kill", ,.' 11 i I" I 1!� I, I'�. ,, �, � )ile . . ; ,;, . , � I., 1 �i , ��,' , � , � , I ", " . . "! I ,�, . r,,,,� � ���, i� �� �: , � F,;��.!,, "I", " �� ,, ", � , , 1�" ,, . . - , . , , .", I 11, . );',,� , I ''I'll" 1 Ii . I'll, 11 � , ,, - 'I �, � - ,I!,, ��',I, �� F �� . ', p, , �,l� � �', li, "ill," " " , 0,,,,:'II ;�T,�;' ' ,,, , F� I I � � . I , , I7 , . !� ,�. I,, , I , � , -, ,�11 , "11, ..; ,.I . . j,"ll I, - 'i" . � ,� 'Y , ., , ,,..I .... .. _- ., ,1 I'll, 1 , - , , � ,i I, ` - IV,"", �, ,.,;, .. .11.1 '1- � ", I � � `4 � 1� �', i - -- 11 . .11 I � .. '. " i �..;, �, , I ,� 11 - 44 . , ,, . --il �I I :,i �� . " 1, � ;I ,,, �, 1, � i%- v, 1 � . I I I I 1, I, �� 11, " I , ; I "I", . 11,� i. �, lt, i � ,t!!",�'!F,�'� �;"� "-` ��, �Jlp ItI,�",�P�l�""I-'��II "I'll 11. I 'li",- -' i ''-�-j""l "ii'Fi�1"', ,,,, I ,� ,, 111i, Ili I 11-11 "III'. -11 � , 1 r, � �' '"),.,'�'- ��41 'I" ' � "' �"' ' il I , , ", I - i I I - I , "I , ;,,�`� - - '. -:,., �r, � , � ; -Fj ,.� . � I I I � . , I"'��'�;I�f�`4, �, . ;�,�Iielp �,�� - � , ""). , 1, .1, F.", '. , , I'll 1111 1-.-, , --"'� z�f, , ,- ;,- �, " ., - , 1 4� �, , , f, 4, � .- -1t'.", 11. I �.� ,, 'I"', , , , �1, 11� , ,, ."I li, 1. il) . 1, "j", " 1� ,'I 11 11 , � , I - 1, , �� i,�; . 1 : - - i , ,,f , ;� " ,it . � I�, �, , I , j,ly - , ,�,,, , " ,I'�,,:t he�l , � 1;;.1 I . , ; ��� ". ��, , - , I � , I . � 11 .. ; - '14 R , , , 11 , " L ,, � "i., � , " 'l, " ,v '�',� ,�, 1k I -1111.,� 1 I',' ',, I - 1-1.1 ,4 eIr ': ,I , j - � I -1-1�� _ ""'Il ,, , 'J" 4F �, ,l, - � - � � li, ; � q: - i� : � �� � �.,i ,� i� I, L�, I " � ,., 90": I ,�, - "I " - , V , , ;;�� _ , . ,4 - , !,I, �;e :.. - iD , 1-1 FF', ; - " I - ,11 - 111.- 1.1-1- I "I.- . I , . � I W � I , , I, , 1"I", � "', 11 I .. L I t ". - ,'.,-,, - ."! �- , "i F ; ,. i2 :t � in -, , - , 7=-77, I I � il I -,:��, ,��, ,'IF I��i,,� .'�,,'r, - ""'; �,l,,�, F, �� I.- � - �� -, ,� , 11, I I I'. F; -' , . 11 �,� !"I ' O' " ��'- ' - 11 , .1--7 1 - . .. : ".I;�F �i,� 12, 1,�: �; iF� ,, � I � I -,,��.(' 0. �,e-;,,';�,,, ll'i� P:i�ji�,,'�i -; `i2.,`�X,i`,I� i Ili I 'k rig im� 41 iiill,iiiiii%, �- ", � - --.e i, -77 -��`-t�*�,ii 1:-,-i�j,�',.1,,?':�.,, �; -i ii, rl.;F If : �',"'L, ij��r;le�':ij; '��I'i`j, �' "I ; 1; . 11 i��-ijel � � ; - ,-A, rtw-'�;11 --, ", TQ, ,�,)7 �,` , �, I � - 1, '011 -7III�I-F, �� �.-"';,11&�i � , � . I - ,�e:��,, I� ", I �,�-l?�F;J.,�`. =��� s* ;aj "9 y%"p;�,���I;✓���(,;�""••'r'"'r�''"p�'v"�,�,,�• {�(,l{ (;.,,C..•�/�,',�'/jj(rN�� �' ,vIPT � �.�+ 7t� J�R'Y j ( I N'1y'iR � l'�, 1 y��r p {✓�� y•li ! � �tly "�'�, � �!: .F` � � , 7' .!'� ` r • v �' ���'. ' �r."+'t�� � Ii � %'lh Ak��-r `+ii„ ` .,'r `� �O i 1 y✓i� Af �' N�Y"�♦" Ir.'F� ��F..,�'� �'1�� '�..'�'<�` J A,�+� i4i Ila i '�• r''�' f•; '' I r ?..� ��h ti. � '/'�±'� h� � ;`.�, fr.=y1���krE,k,�k w 1��� `r�t .l k. • � � f i M��.�1�-`11 �.. � I . ' rr r+.. r.. , � r• .' r•l,iiAp / ,,✓✓•r`..�"i"'`°`I '�, ' � �1 .-_� x -Pa z�, o-"�i. ,qg„^�• e 1 ,. ►' 'y * fie, il`i'r� y, It/r�f(;�� F )d•.�i..t T� r+ +(55 . 4 67 MWA ,1 w aA+'� �y,�� r 'F+x �(''� 'rr +,'✓/'SE'ff t'Q + �-r "'w'y � (hl � /+ �yL'� ' d i �''� �r . ify0�,. '{ y .+.✓'"RAv'T. �'�r+-� j ?1� � + � y �?_..�.J ���:J . ��p�'+ 449 �.�+"�"/�; ','. :.,,/ J�( _'�. " � •� (` �.h� ��s+�?';041 6 '' `f'"' ;�,fK�'' (.��a"�.;r!^«�ir7- �;��G� '96^�!ss�,.' �{1�L�" J l ♦ ('""' �� ^�, �,r r •:�' -�L 1�4 " f♦ � h.6,F' •�a�.t.:-+,a.+4�.� ,-: W . � A���.•„y I+ .w " .:4 � j. e .. • '�"+ «. / � ,.. - *'!y :.s; '4 . ' �yj - Y , t9 II R d. (�y i y M. l .,♦ �ae �1'Y ' � �Q � ���' jfi� � I�� ti .,`w �♦ .. ,Z1�1'}��""'" `� ��""�y�. �4,aC. � �,,�.�., „, ! � i� 9 I +. ; •, `�t ?,�, i:.v. :1, 9c"1'y"�"�.-.� .r ell "i'>..,.; "e'i� ✓/ n ��v1 r~'n + `r' rb5�`.., i:;i h 1� �, x,7,1 C •. �Ii�„�° ..".. ,,,�«� q ti r� �(� � � T � � � � r q r✓ham✓� N �. E ! ..,,. �� • ,•, i J ':i �'•"� � `� 1 .w,. r s�1' s,,,. ';" I d1�1�� �( '. 4 ��. � ���F R� 7 q4 ��yr t f� l (, 4 S 47`. • X17 22 �y ��.:.` r-. +^a `' " e i ,,!,," � � ( Y � "' fid' � _ .� i' /- ' ✓+v ' i i r':•�i',y. .°�j�_..:�i����a,� \���ttf�' r .♦� '� �`•�i...y„yµ +•�>},',...�. s Lp {�, y r III J F}, r � Ems,""• M4i'�� ` �� ( �f'� ��C��% + tL,y 1� �1.h� �� .i `•-'ht.!^..'.�� f , \.. ~�` i� rl� �.,. k � �v.,,� � vy h ;,. ;i y P x . I '�" ��. � ''' "i•�e-,Y'W"'rA/'(j�'/✓��w1 Y,d. `4 `xvlh"",� 1 � � /' ...1"a ( � f �.' l hr r .;,yr-� v,,:...++V,1 e ✓ �*�� ��j(+1y� � ^^"w .,,s.M �+~ , � ti""'�'y ti"•„^...+�`_�� SS I,. ,`yM'� C '� /�•7}:_. :a n'xr„�•'' _ �+i".a.;",y.y,., ./ 1 f �, x w_...•-...« • •-.�...:.y` ''-ted . n" xy,u+ `rw a 4" .,':'�. rY'n I % f 1 ;„ FC ♦ �,\. 0 r '��`'uaa..,a- ,f. �" •�. � 'C� '•"'h.. � ti, kM 4 �w'k "`` pR3 � N /1 i v.: A `gy. `+. .A --r„^ U \ ,' �J ,.• ri � j�' S �,' "^v,� r/ .�, �� R. .w a '��. 1 ,„ �,,�,.� ri �(("�+r /',� x......1:'7: � � , �% ,�~`�� �, . ,,� `..�_.•.. • �;, 7 �y e � � � ��� All`�� ' ` '�-.»,-�yj'a.� �� 1�I� � +�;t n , �"`�r,,,j i �� I ✓ �. 3 �� " � p ✓� � �, } ��yy„w � .>.� �� r tl,+y. ..$jti °% �,::.�' ""„'"`` ,� ✓ ra'. l i b ✓, �> 1 +ankh ..�� I' ,.' ,f et�.��' �a , 4 � �+r✓, /fir +�,�",'�:,.�`�`';;,� r�,///",,."�'�,.'-�""'^�.�''e+s:.:1 � . � t)j "~••+.' � �, ��>� }�� Ci�„✓ ,�--, `°..,,, ..- YJ +� `�, �„ / 'y,• y ,4. � ��l IC � 2%' , `'�i, �` l\%�`+&..,.,����"'J, 4,, r” rw``5` `y '""y ,n •Y • � � 4:� • � ,i�' �'� '. rl"r 1, l(i i 1 +../ C `•* +`, '4.- ��,,>.) , 4aa i`.,w�TM" d �.i �` l; k ' � i� � ,"'�w�....'� >• "�.,,...«.'w,�,• � \� ,�r.,I �"�.�'-'''';i,�» •`'`i.: �7 ".1 r1, � i�,,.',....0 ""'�.r"7,.�� ��`� :. ?,�.,A' !ctti,.,.. ,.� . 0" ra i� ";'r" � �;,,, �, ,�.y.���1 (4�iyi �l =�'+'.;. ,� 7Kyc.� ✓F." � '; 1 ��:�vi-; � `m ,+� .� � t"`.." I� ♦"`���`r �_,v, U N`ITCIJ ST`A"I',�,5 _"�j ®I DI.,P RTMI) IIgotC?.F THS INTCRIOR GEOLOGICAL suRv w cAd _ 41' ,r � 7'' q�A��1RANG►,� L CATIOW, ' ��t'G',/���,J� ��+V �/ t ARCHAEOLOGICAL RECONNAISSANCIr OF T;II:E �rPROPOSED VALLEY VIEWSUBDIVISION LOCATED NEAR OROiILLE, BUTTE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA .,1 BY - peter M. Jensen California State University; Chico Introduction In order to evaluate the archaeological impacts of a proposed land subdivision protect known as the Valley View Subdivision located approximately 2 miles east of Oroville on the east side: of Oakvale Avenue, the firm of Cook .and Associates contracted, with the University Foundation of California State University, Chico for a records search and an -foot archaeological reconnaissance of the project area. Jahn Accordingly► on Friday, June 29, 1979, archaeologist r,zncanella of the Department of Anthropology, California, State University, Chico, conducted an intensive reconnaissance of the entire parcels The Valley View Subdivision parcel consists of approximately 30 acnes of foothill land located immediately The is, rotz— y the shape cast of Oroville Cal:i.fornia. parcel inverted Y'L" with a portion of •L•he property bordering r of an Oakvale AVenue. The proposed pr.ojeot wi11 involve �:bd visa on 80` lots with a min:i:mUm size o the 30 acres itato approximately X 110 feet. In adcliti.cn, the ,project will involve street of 80 age and construction and i=rovement as well. as storm dram "of sewage, disposal lane excavation. In cons deration tYie historic and/or prehistoric sites potential adverse impacts to wh h might e�rist ira thin, the boundaries of the pxop��rty'� the County.;of Butte required, that cultural retiourceS be considered the' Envi onmenta:l Impact Report bea.ng prepared for the project, r and hence the present archaeological reconnaiase, R i _44_ s Search. d115 ReC� Prior to going into,the field the archaeol.og;:cal records of District ? of the Soci6ty for California rc examined for any . existing rec;brdcd' ecords o y at Chico were A, g significant historic sites w that tie prehiet a:�C' ;and/or the No sites are currently recoa project area. acentra.reas immediate poject vicinity Or iznrnEdiately aJ fieldwork e 30�.l consists o� Vegetation within the -acre parc fe arcls dense grass, r abandoned or and:olive o�.ch , of potion oak and scattered oaks, dense concentrations the verfcLat manzanita. Although arl bushes, and the parcel examination of the entire surfaceof corer made sariiewhat difficult and time consuming it did not, the p an, acceptably thorough examination 0 and/or signi--Leant historic; i1se or evidence of prehistoric or.cupatiort, once the boundaries 'of the parcel were pointed Oroville, arch bUl-means out by jolene Blake of Blake Realty of the entire parcel b examining, ,� - y John Zancanella a nitiated ts north -south ane rgroundr of walking non-random. cover was ,paced app l0 metapart. The the 1 period.cally removed to expose other hole and da chessw rec�xarttined . rodent middens and es. dor possible inda.aat ions of subsurface resourc lwsults and Recommendations Non evidence of prohistorc or signifrant historic observed during -uh�. survey. use or occupation of the sr was Therefore, axckaeologica:l c., .arance is redomtended for the , ric roposed'subdivisioz. however, should pbe r�coyuntert�drdiaaing�the Mal 't or prehistoric .cultural, p"i or subseguert ' construczt�.on the development p � ec be in course of called qualified archaeologist should activties., au ate the adverse impacts mite �yiUnedateiy in order to properly g the cultural resources iitvolvec of the project against _45 ® f�P`N 1 yl°• t� SYCAMORE M" 14a°�I 40 49523 r _ �, 7 J Ir+� �, Lilt t49 hV0 'i1• i ,t17 r1 t�.r7•• ;, .. •.. °^ � '.. �i�� Yui •i 1�/+.'rO,r, to �qZ }+� tr xrf�" 4 n ,Jt ,�,• .iFA WN'j a • , 1 / ,. '`vY (J ar•. , +p ati�f # # 4 2-f13 of f R r 1 R R....p#..,-r..t��... R V u u U r-�e.ea�• r..u+es m w...W �atnsk«, t t �...�y• y U U .0 u 4 y tom, ,+ Ji J'' tly� � .I"I�' 1u1! u f tsh �y I. •Jr, p�?IY � ti�J �`•� L-_-_...•iu�M ^._.,,i. , 1 l., i >�y,(�b^ i�r i X310 .':-y� �, R ti/:� >.t lT t til t.,yy a., � ,/ t: , _ ,Yj '+• K y,+:� ti 1+Ilo`i tiY 1 '. � :. r `at�o� l,7 "T�y�.t.�� j � {,, ,' ,it`•,. �1? Yj „y,'t'� � . ';�N �,e sr'- ypl. '� "" I ftp/y 7 �c }�{i• °\� \stusro i w Yt its 1(341ilt P.; A�l ���, � T •, C�� i $27•a�Y.•. T r ; •� i � l��' caQ o^ na.� �• t1 ♦y » 1 a e� At: •!. a Ct.4.. IN ir.l1.1t t 1. , ry r :t{r,_. ptS i! w' „1•{�1 1 r/'�. t ti •� «�„yl �I :1♦� iw ` �/) -N+3 bj i '�41,��� � t t r.• •. ),` � �r 4°'�.a t�{ IvifY S_' 4 •Yr. F 2Y y w ,, •t, ,f I r y~ ° NP 1r i 4 r '^ ''i. f r l 1�1L.... �� / J' < F �`--�•`af }}(( 71,v. �.a u u u Y• ..y �� J`v. �• q �J/�/ .�' ,'� `•'�� � � � .r��^"" ..r� - N 7�� rvq ^ � y�0 - t i ✓ � T ,� r��+i t 1 ! ss>✓'n a t 1 o f+�4T r� Y ir"+ v a»� .I;t r tk., `S, 7-.�-1 t,r %�' � sTt v f s—Y.r r� ; „ o c,c�ti �. ft y.. f ,yr,a„ ✓ I '1. �i)j : ;,,�+t w Un t, y J r�� '� ! K aZ� .• ?t G i °`�° fp�' �•�'7���$ tr �,.!✓+°Jt�' o,�'i'J+ry e'•-ts.11-t.. Jt.��i°y ` Crti�1� Itt4t •r �c�f♦ .' �k(�^ <` i" ,t KKt M° {;i; a tri'•'-/.< '.'`� y°yi� Cic'i,.+ .,J 7t (`N f� a `♦Mt Ay.tt J� ;kJ.. sw:_r L`• A ° y .f"1�('S ' .1 vyt'J''� 1 Sia `.4 t r:to y� �.�_r_ �:e, ljr•1• N'. 4 :`t �;r e, Y# i U•i-l40j�9nAi 'Y�I tKrsJ�✓ 5 T, v �,�� A{� •, �` i♦ o y ~'P u R a~+ I ! ':. {r1 , .�C"�Fyvy'`}�7 Y�'ul.� i fi �ti��"� 1.1� t �4✓ C""'..�..�.']i~ U •y t'�•."'�,{F 1"t 7, IYti e'"j ..•1• T �4 ° ri 1 ♦�yJ '`n�'�.l�e'� f:,s..�� ,�„ ..' P „1 I��I. i � � : �� It t� "�r+,r » J -+ v "1i:^ ^ �� r�.�1 r-,..>_-,�.r�^y'11 a. -.,fir • Irl—�--Gr l �._ � �J •� a� .. r Q t .._ � �4 v",'+'♦ � n 4ti��' ;••® '^."e.•Ir��..1�.,� 11 N JS.../,•�_'l ..;�w�y?:OfV l Z } J Ij 1J t` ly Cet+ -- v19N �.;{ � C 1 ., -.n ,K4•SK ( �� ��♦,1 's:� 1..� III ts,+�--.i::a•"� " «..,...t.5.:. IR�t �+. r fi'i E to 1`,� ✓;` f a�%nr� t Lr 1 l�..r 1' ,,,. ..�..-•:... +•�`--,» +'{rJt�a�"� if i ��, imp a a~ s' T , . •l I i„�'^"4---t•--+ """i.l sY[ �' c 1 ,4 . I;,af a � ra�rY t,•1 nJ 2 `t4 ...`°'y °. X11 K" �� t »"� _ ^ 1'YY✓ ^'9 U i (1 rV"iV, tc" I j �i.. ( 13. YS by t' �` ..•.r,L.•.J-:. Y i - ,t. T Y,��- 7!)?1 '�� t > C11q o F ..�..{�-� 1�J� ..7�t.: f! ,�QfOVI�I6, G?) f yrr ♦ 1 i :.0 G' �� �+ .. Ij( _x"'r`"N ��,) :r..a u -�"� �. i�y- c�•"�.�""�"'t �i r. { :1Y���� =a�� s ' j 1 r ,.1»�• t t � 1�.� ° t ,� .•JL y,„r � 1 , � I �•`� t ± }i:a? I$!,}`4 � ut j 1 ♦ tl »+u/ � � y is k� 451 + ..,.ryr�+•a "►arrbl } �.�/ rte d t.li P a •}... t n rY t+, vJv1t ♦t.7�+� + ':.+..+ tt.:.♦ tty'' �� �°ti ? �311 J ,�4,. { 1 lly t -Y i. 3 ;yG •'RS.2. t i �'i� lli {I- _� 1 n i 11 "�•�. �'! r E1C ' 7. at f+ � � tY Ol1•KL1K( � �. G y'+I r: -r< G e 7, u [ ,[ ° ru� 3'.}.4 t1 t,3 :..a , !r1 R 2 rt nvv't.�-•oi4R«WU Oa:! '} 2iY.lL``�t- �t•tY1.r T it _R� i �7' _, ISS F• u�Rtt '�� i• is /"..'-irG ::l/ r,rr.,.., f ` IIt h1 wW[Ifr}. 1 t'yht i �••5.QT�, �t4 . t '12 11A L[ppH'v ;t�tit,'Sr y'C y�• c:.t .t. _..•i'�'y �.t..-....,, � �Cr : rrJ k •alN' 1' 1 J. Ni°14f ut ll'1 l el'J � C\/ t$.RJ �Utt3 i1 '3' �"�.�,.. �'t"'� u i� ffa �li� �'t �7� t� r. � n� � �'�lSl,)Pr♦ .: f` r'�,..t7•.v. =7~ t �, 1Y `J � - 1 �w w �' '\�j�"':.'A I��N r 7,.L,.14` T f. +. td : t � u u C! Ga+ RkGtl "waf... a •ti ;+ (1 d'i.Y !� _ KI�•f 4t�J � TN 1 �� ` t_ yt1, 4�1-`+1!} +, ; J) S'•��c�.'!;lvlI'.r, . �y WR L.AM. + 1� .#LI,t.��Gnl: a✓'>1 F I,s.1.1:- �' ,y Y_ly.t.f.,., .. r//acK��. .1�•*•''`` ..a'f.7♦i,�'J1"11l , ig^5 '�'/` �s.:t: e•Yw • 7'ti,• ,i .�,6 �1{��'t 711:"�',A � if ;+Ftp n�k"i ��t�( ��;�a' � �. {� r •� �w. ja t�'o!:e `. I ,r:• ,,. � ;v,.n* LFv,121t ��l •� ! �1`= �K�4 �rl^hulY1 `�� Yti.. `� t %._ � ,,. Mph' -..�4b . �� a �'•, tt 4aJ S '4r b..r i uxl +�'i�..,si CO•rft,li tJ•J "•.":"PI. C. �.I[rF "�� 'r✓¢.�1 • `]^., T•-r'Sli� 1 Y7'7ta' lid 1'�n tC.. - 24A J 1. k}�4y 1;xw1`�+17C or s« �q� 1 wt til w.� � li u a L wr9 a r`"JYy �••7:"�� !;' Y,F t' .; 1 }�rM"'A kSiY�{ Mf bbr;i� t �� t t♦.�rr ��rg lS 3 "'•'t FgYSiivrt:d AN �.:�' "vti ^• .l . G j�l T-oil i X77 or t Vr stn DTn{t irF ej c '�. a t1 , a i 1 h ;tsllJ apa,�lwe ia+•v:, 7'r � a �M4�1 r.4t>'+.t •ti. ;7p F t� , � 'r1 " M y': 1c� f rnn+ +` _ � _ _ � ,.,,..+.....•----i. � �'`�+". �,®.•--•-,•'-` . �.,1r ��F�lt�',;'..-•^_,,..,----'-��1!_....... '_..�..._.i, �; a�. �.�._..r^� :�.!, � !t=�.•....=.--:_..11._elrr..,...�.s,,-....��,...---^' r ,h ."�'"�„ 4 r�Ji.'u' ',1`�;; {, Ih:1n'�,V",q,,,�t411 +Y ri IT+e4M••�y•,+rRe�°4��,dlL..4 r� rl�,,,1� K,! 'a ctrr r,t,"-,"�•�,i p,ir y v p•" u7 Ow I- ''{ 1 y i � L"•'C � + ,'1 "LF Ip 46 , •, ` Yak+•,• /11` � �. '� srr ��,.�.. ''�+�'r'!"' ,.•�.wpi'�� '"'I'�'t.fr� A " vw"7r,``'•�'!"' �'"tn+' v cc�j( ;+. � �. - /�ttr�'+ �+��r "c--+•—», 9YGAMOIE HILL 7FJ: z �t4Y.lAA A � � rd4j} .. tla0 t'DWtR!!ry i6rt'tl ANtl 01U0� 1}^ �� +v AC,If.%U1 %vt tia 30 ';� 'CA 0 1hC11� lr ' T !t * Z}7 `sF7r^tI R i�l�•'� R_ .kms AaRO�llC��¢✓: u• V 12.x~ V U 'V .0 w f'n�..Y• U w65 Ui" a v 2r tj7i Yv rAU w [� �' : 4 I dy %• ' f lov 4 �'� i ; „t;„ �t 9 i1�g } k(1 } tvJ A v4 ai Y pa�,4 A44faNAYINY. /a- �. eA97t p .,. ji ,.+t : �hNryCRA �i x 'i If ' o t ren li tri . y 02 r• t . �+ n 1. Y r z: "AM t 01 f r i• tF o y 2esss � v yap' 4i ,`� -'rsc” � `, % v \fO w/�`.tievr � ci'(a 4�` z,•q.s.1 4 1, t P� N� ,�lT.i � T r . ��� ,,__ 5w,�, , .4t r•, \ �✓r �, ,",•� " 4,°ti �� 4k/�h;' ip u � 11 iy ,jam p' ram' U V U 3'2.61 uh p /)� l.. �9 J - CInNC[ a Y yp*�l t15PJ �J ttt. rwr• IG2 tt p r`�" ,l NYl ♦r d' ly4'� G' M aN � I � A.ii tit ,� � 377 13 la �tiwd D Z r ", Y� �{ J.•ti r^f.�.' art d `'� 5 Y>•!p,�t �� sat+' of?ty « � � I 31�"1T t ©� n �� K "( ,� G, V� � tlY`i :lY� iid:l.ik f. r%: • h IS '.. W.y.. ) 7 7333) IM �i ,a - � r � •,��. Y! 41 a'"m .� �I •am�i //!��� °•• olQ (� y YQ �i iF�fjK a2_M y N tya .w �a`4r/er .y.,}. i rir;-R t i'! 1�{ t" .• }' �l i yyt. ,�"�-�'['1• r�, 2fl0 iC �ti. , Rk it ti wti i L'k ! Ibc x GAN Nos,oE ° t IT ,77: 1 r ?ia3d1 T Jy1 1 At C4 .y4 J o" tiy2 �n .. Avt Nvt ,,2Y'. ", I;� :�;�Ls � ,.,Sy } fA3P I i ; toy. ��ft tplt' `,. 4i...10 p R. ! e • H pt�4 :y.'.k �` ,t,. \ i G ..� �. ft ...r to �7t AIT � tta R�(}�r A+,'•h tp''li tvk n.R`'��<A• lt�jK.... n n oma+ Sn0 `5,��! ... lit' l,� ;fan �v{ r Y // 'J S 4; 2a R . 77 r kk5 �fOVl��B G � v � 4� . � - � , nY� JI'l9� i, � 4'y'^'r"'^' - m e off\ :� ¢\ ( \\t'h-„Rl itla 2AS,Sk r y°a WljkA fl. 11 i rb t, h Ili �♦ 4 t F' i �a t y tli � -`i)� /' t" 1 A 2 §viiia/• f y.+D%r a , t 1 ei `T� IC :YUC.t• '';V%A16'Y 37=� tSS 1 ff ��� VVII "`vui $ 7 +a'+$ vt, A04o vt : 4'N i2. {'+{ o '� z�i � �-� � � �.� 1 r * � 25Na4 §I': It�'p,l ! �2� y•L�«+, � a h.dVdl[.Gr 'i� .r.+^� w �' � � J h /, 1" t ! •` 4 DE NWOOD dR ra5,1C i .j { Rxovlaf aD R :e'ri� ry ? F.brs_,nA�.�.. .. "a ,�jv AD M i&',.y.. r55d31 ,�54- + n �. 2.!!,be „ ., tlkplG a y - w i• r.a .:F P � Nd! CL CIA 39 _ •� APO ri ! F • .. ., ttl/v C m5 - vA .. 1 "Dao. R � p- Ra R s'. rd � � i.. ..�1 �, "! fe y` N!RAC .Y 7,�YlD 4ryEt,'jtl. � d'� 1A Yr{'' ),2r er+•t,tkgr yt m ka icy �f Tom' ¢I .. � .ryildRM -. taNAw Y, % tiw lij' 4/i Q ip N - w i 01 qui, c d N 'd r rll Dix- 'R 1.01.1+ h - WAY. ,1 4d hr�, 7,1 JQ,1 N iwJvl a �p4 a�� ° x s `i °n C i' ! f oRlv2. + r 2,i,tr iIy rasa , ,„Rt} ltCllAkt' +T "r J N At ' �ors'I o.ovlii 2.•e5r...•�....a t[4tE'ST "+� $ 24geA .ti ,i p . x•hnt. 1+! _ w t N. §t o• { � ,I'i.otil hC' :: wAoo,,.;�Mar�t�. _ aitl• 4 : ,tJ r� Nk9 PI.M�N', { t§«1? kVK [+� H D,DYIt[[ 4p �' N r ✓" F, n hAl1 Y69G� u U W n i a;� 43ww! . MUStBAti AV �f`3n 1 Ql a J yy wAUNLANb NC,aYC v:3vz Udd'im. J 3 dv / All '� l A t R, R1 /�' •,• y Ta rof!"Tvliw ok #t rE c ° +� ` R-'! i% ° •' i ” i aisa ooi tliir #ANB r yy R cf' ' NN7 �� nr h S y' A.Kt1Y►%ktRi,6iq C Oho sw _'wv,•.Ir,.:= v IT z' sr i, alr mo. ��s3 v s,i f' I i► Q�j � � nnLkRNn - "..r. �^'" a, rNOINQQf9lua. rcNQuLYANt'H -. [Ip11tl PAAIi. AVQNIJR ' i tlgdVILL4 iCALtOtagN1A b[Stl011 i _ r ORGANIZATIONS AND PERSONS CONSUx.'Tp' ,-D ADMINISTRATION OFFICE BUTTE COUNTY —BILLTURPIN r ASSESSOR'S OFFICE,: BUTTE COUNTY — LEONARD G OLLET _ CAL TRANS - HENRY ANDERSON, (TRAFFIC COUNTS) JIM SWAIN (HIGHWAY ;DESIGN) ENVIRONMENTAL REVI EW DEPARTMENT L' RIC HARD MOLCAR r STEVE STREETER GRAVES, RON .1:NOR—CAL CABLEVIS ION, INC. - BILL BR.A,CKETT ® OROVIL'LE ELEMENT AllY SCHOOL DISTRICT — HAROLD E. CORN, ' ®I SUPERINTENDENT 1 OROVILLE WXANDOTTE IRRIGATION DTS VRICT -- MICHAEL-NAMESS PACIFIC GAS A.N; ELEGTRIC. — J. Bo PAPP A PACIFIC TELEPHONE =JIM LONG 1 PLANNING DEPARTMENT;, BUTTE COUNTY —ROBERT GAxSER PUBLIC t+iORCS, BUTTE' COUNTY - ON BECER ,1 ROBERT JONES JOHN MENDONSA i 1 r r `I r r A.�'PENDx X J _50� REFERENCES BUTTE COUNTY. 19716. Z0X1NG 0-PDINANCE N0. 0 BUTTE COUNTY. 1971. GENE' A PIAN LAND USE ELEMENT BUTTE COUNTY- l 977 • MMOMENT'AL .REVIEW G un , �arEs BUTTE COUNTY. 19 GEI�EFAL PLAN SEISMIC sArETY ELEMENT BUTTE COUNTY'. 1977, IMI ROVEMENT STAWDARLS VFORE SUBDIVISIONS BUTTE COUNTY. 1976,, ENVIROMENTAL 71lPA09; %'qRT FOR ,KELLY RIDGE ESTATES 'UNIT U.S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE. `1926, SOIL SURVEY OF THE OROVILLE AREA CALjFORNIA' 1�P�'ENDIX K 5�. OF;CALSFORNIA--RESO UACES AGENCY C04UNU q, 9P.Ow, H in., c0VrF1H0R gAtE - CALIFORNIA REGIONAL WATER DUALITY CONTROL, BOARD— A CENTRAL VALLEY REGION 3201 S a�RE ,Akit 1ENTO, CALIFORNIA 93816` PHONEt (916) "5-0!k" 16 Marc' '197' Mr: John Mendorlsa Assistant Director of Public Works Butte County Public works Department 7 County Center Drive Orovi7le, California 95965 SUBt7ECT VALLEY VIE6� PRELIMINARY SUBDIVISION MAP` P, As sewage will be discharged to the North Burbank approved itrict ilihe0resshould site collection system and solid waste remove be no problem in these regards. However; ground slope in the area is on the orderonfa101c�ea erasion control pract We re t h workepriorat the developer initiate to 1 November of each year during the project life. The facilities developer should to keep soil also he required to install storm.water drainage erosionto a minimum. Please contact Mr, Landis or Mr. Crawford, of my staff; at 322-1592 or c 322-1�94.if ou have any questions.,. LAWRENCE PEARSON, P E • eMbr Engineer Sacramento Watershed Ef~C/ciis kPPE14DIX L 4 Ff, ` APPENDIX" ENVZROMENTAL :CHECKLIST FORM (To be coMp,leted by Lead Agancy) ERp Log 1179-}03-27-01 Z BACKGROUND l: Name of .ProponentCalifornia Land alld T1V(si eriY'�D 2. Address and Phone dumber of Proponent; Craig Estes 6060 Sunrise Vista Drive Terra E y��J,'ft 2 Suite 11,9 936 nt rp"rise i)xye Citrus Heights, CA. 95610 - Sacramento, CA 95825 916) 723-3327 - (916) 929-6984 3. Date of Checklist Submittal 4. Agency Requiring Checklist 5. Name of Proposal, if applicable Valley View Subdivision ,of 29+ acres into 80 lots ._east of Oroviller Z ENVIRONMENTAL IT9PACTS (Explanations of, all: "yes" and. "maybe" answers are r6quire& on attached: sheet!-2. YES MAYBE 'NO 1. Earth. Will the proposal result in sign ficant; A.Unstable-earth condi tions or in changesin geologic substructures? b. Disruptions, displacements, cam, paction or overcover ing . of the soil? N Change in c, topography or ground star- face relief features or removal of topsoil? d, Destruction, cavnring of modifica- tion of any unique geologic or physical features? e, increase in grind or eater erasion of soi7a, either on or. off the site? f . Changes in depositaon or erosion of beach s.andsor than ga8 in sil,ta- ta.an, deposition or erosion wh: eh may, mods the r�han el of a ri reg- or stream or, the bed df the ocean o,,r, arty bay, inlet, or Ike? g. Loss o;E prime agriaulturaIly-prc)-; ductiVe soils OUtOider designated ` uIrb,ri .areas 7 - -- "A PEOIX' M Appendi 1 - page of . z YES'MA' XBE NO i s Reduction in the amount of water otherwise available for public +rater. supplies` ; j. Rxposure of people or property to water related hazards; such as flooding? 4;, Plant': Life. Will the proposal result M substantial.; a, Loss of vegetation or change in t11e diversity of species or number of any species of plarts (including trees, shrubs, grass, crops) microflora and aquatic plants)? e.,o b. Reduction of the numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species of plants? c_„ Itntroductiorn of new species of plants into an area, or 1n,A barrier to the normal replenishment of existing species? d, Reduction in acreage of any agri- cultural. crop? 5. Animal Life; G7ill the proposal result �n substantial: a. Change In the diversity o'� species., or numbers of any species of animals ` (bi cis, land animals including rePtiloss, fish and shel,l- fish, berithic organisms, insects or micro -fauna) ?` b , Reduction of the . numb at of arid► unique, rare, or endangered species of animals c. -. Introduction of reW species of� annals into an Brea, 6 * su, t a barrier to', tllo' migrat ion or movement of anitxials? d . Reduction of encroachment upon, or detetiora.tion to existing fisl' or wilalife habitat? A)pend'� x r' page . 0f 9 YES MAYBE N 6. Noise, will the proposal result in substantias a; Increases in noise levels?.. b , exposure a.t people to severe noise levels 7. roLi ht and Clare, Will the proposal produce signi'fi'cant light or glare? 8, Land Use. Will the ro osed, proposed,. result in a significant a.. Alteration of the planned land use or-' an area, or establish a trend which will demonstrably lead to such alteration?' b, Conflict wittl uses on adjoining properties, or conflict faith , es:"tNl,ishad recreational, educa_ tional, religious or scientific uses of an area? W, 9`, Natural Resources , WI -11 the proposal result in substantial; a ,' Demand , `for or, increase in the rate of. use of any natural resources? ` b • lli�onanxene�abl�e natural xesouxce? M R9,--s1r o eett x Does the, pxopasal i.nvalve a risk of an explosion or the reIease' of hazardous substances (including, but not limited to, c'il; pesticides, chemicals or radiation) in the event 6C -an asci dellt or upset Co�n.da.tionS 11`; pCipulation, i11 tl-ie, propo a ,sl gni' Gia t,ly alter: ,tete distril uti6n densis~ , or growth rate of rhe humsn popu ation Jof, an area or phys,J -lly divide. an lishe' d ity estalacommu n i 12.0. 11ous�inW ll t e proposal. , Signs: :canthi affect existing hoUSxng ar crC: tf3 a C�efi` 11C fob" c'iddit l of it haus.ing7 APperidi.x r page' of 9 Ah YES MAY1�E� 13, Ttans orta3:ion/-Circulation. Will. the ro osa resuii in proposal - a"" Generation of substantial additional Vehicular movement? b. Significant .cant effects on existing ' parkins facilities, or demand for now parking? c. Substantial impact upon existing transportation systems? d. Significant: alterations to present patterns of circulation or movement of Taeople and/or goods?. e. Alterations to waterborne, rail or air traffic? f: Increase in traffic hazards to motor vehicles, bicyo a sts or pedestrians? 14. Public Serv;i.ces . Will -the proposal have an effectupon,, or result in a substantial need for new or. altered governmental services in any of the following, areas a. Tire protection? b`. Police protection? c,, Schools? d, Parks or other, recreational facilities? e,. Maintenance of public facilities, including toads'? f. Other,govenmen,tal services? 15, Energy,Mill the proposal result in a, Use of substan.t:ial amounts of fuel 0 x ener;v? b. Substantial :,ncrease in 'demand upon existing' sources of ene, or squire the development of ttow sources of:ene%gy? 6,'0 Utilities ,` �rJill tl e proposal resin t in a neefor new systenis, or sub, stanti.al alteraations to t1�e `fol,awin utilities;:` YDS IiYb,r N0 sustaining; levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal com- munity, reduce thein unnber o restrict the. range of a rare or endangered ; plant or animal or eliminate important examples of the major periods of California history or prehistory? b. Doesthe project have the 'potential shOrt term benefits to the detrimerit of publicly adopted long-term environmental goals?' C. Does the project have impacts which are individually limited, but cumulatively considerable? (a, project may impact on two or more separate- resources where the impact: on each resource is relatively small, but where the effect of the total o those impacts on the environment is significant ,) d. Does the project have environmental effects which Will cause substantial adverse effects on human beings, either directly, or ilw.rectly? a4 Appendix F Page, 7,,,o,f 11/15/79 APPENDIX VALLEY ` VIEW TENTATIVE SUBDIVISION MAp Comments Received on the Draft EIR Requiring a Response I. Statistical Figures used in the EIR are mis,ed,a,ng in , that they are taken. i'rom 1 4-1 97 975 g reat6st area years, while the grawth has occ urred. si.rce 1975., 2. Traffic congestion at the entrance to Ophir School attributable to ar�tivti school descres has not, berm adequately ibed, and' the effects of •the pra j ected trsf fic increases from area subdivision pra •eatexisting situation, including potential �s on this ic, safe y hazards t0 schoolcha,ldren, mitigations, etc. also should be described detail. more in. 3: The Subdivision may generate more than the projected students of elementary school to .31 age; some of whom may be bussed to other schools due to Ophir being presently at maXimum.enrollment, 4. Children may short-cut across private property from the subdivision to the school. 5• The proposed subdivisianma vat Y aggravate an ;Occasional logit er pressure problem experienced by the area. some: residents C To alleviate traffic congestion at the Oak-vale/01, intersection, the deval,oper toward should contribute handturn nstaanal. on Oliver ghwaytiot oaslwell 'lanes an Oakvale as tra s, traffic light. 7 A sidetralk along Oakvale Avenue installed at developer's se is necessary mitiate traffic hazards s ri tOoIch 8«'' The envxrontnental thassessment :dor Valley,View should address e cumulative im Acts of ,n growth the aria and impacts' to Route 152. 9. 'The p thropasect subdivision shdtild be' evaluated in terinS e State's of Urban Strategy Go�oern ng heW development. ..7.�,��.�,. 11 i ��� �� .� �; �, � ,, 1 �,h tables below summar�:za the manp��ter equipment and rc.j)oInse ti'1#en in the proposed ,subd vision. Normal. response to a structure fire is four, engines, oxte x+esc'U,O sdt�ad, ()Ae All are t�ia►� 1 Battalion. Chief and one volunteer fire company. engines oombination pumpers ,meeting specifioations of National ':ire Protection Association Pamphlet 1901. Manpower Std_ tion. �tnit Name Jtrt+nth tzhlttwe ' winter KellyRidgeol.wi.teer Company 20 2 2 4a y.- ;) 1 (day-2) gEngine Kelly �. y yide Kelly Ridge Squad 2 63 Oroville Zft,6,jne #1 � Way-3) � (day-2) Oros ille L, Sifte //2 orovill.e Eagine#3 3 7;; Palermo.hgine 2 (day-�) 1 (day-2) 55gor ergine 2 1" Res-oonae Times. -. Ana�tus R®na ncatn.• Txav�l '�xmp. C!`'3an -----�---- Kelly RI dge w Station. 64 C1xovil .e - Station 63 LIQ Palermo w station ?2 12 Bangor station. 53 1 I q Rro iectk 8 The proposed projeot �xs only one eX�ti. in, t��� ��rent `sof a enn�Lo-ration difficultie's would be enoount;a�re�� ;!o.9itiorLin.g fire appara.tu While allowing area e Acuation,- ynetat;,on ` the as�tin . of ornamental$ ��rii t �ernoval. ' of native 'ueg�tata.an �:ouxr�ed wz. 1 � � flee Uogetat�an whip:. d must roriuor the fire hazard w tb h px�oaoatf, ,, nxn e q csed 01 b ch"' j 1, '+err bur i ,remov o6hotatont with l.F)eal. 0z14,id-( ,xn0nN i RESPONSE: Richard Booth's recommendations stated that "emissions from gas powered on -road motor vehicles in Butte County is a.pproximatel:y 01.4 tonsper day .": However Howard Linnard o{ the California Air Resources Boardpracrided the followingdata which tiaras released in September 1979. Butte, County Butte County Motor Total. Emissions Vehicles Emigo-ions CO 209.0 ,tons/day CO 125, tons/day Org,An c Org. Gases' 37.7' tons/day Gases 17.7 tans/day NOX 23.1. tons /day NOX 13A tons /.day 19 OX 2.l tons/day SOX .7 tons/day TSP 79.6 tons/day TSI' 1.5 tons/day Total 351.5 tons/day Total 1.55.9 tons/day T'heso totals differ significantly l:y with those of the Butte 0oun`ty Air Pollution Control 1� str of which= are based on January 197$ data. But even these figures donotadequately d sc-rxbe, the .pollution picture *that Butte Co, nt res dents see on a d.ailwy basis. Butte Couny is onl'yy a part of the Saar,amento. Valley Air Basin. The total emissions xoru that entire basin must- be considered to -evaluate the impact of particular emissions oontributant. T'h'ose figures, supplied by the Oaliforni Air Resources Board are as f61loWso Sacramento Valley Air Basan 00` 1,880.0 'tons /day, 0rg . Gas 355 tons do, NOX 20'8 tons)/d. ay SOY 15, tons / day ,; TSF &72 tons/day Total 3,10.0 tons day Zest of Those SubmittingWritten Comments on the Valley View EZR. to date (12/5/79) -7 Lisp of those commenting vel}bally ov in writ Ing On the etviron- mental impact report and project at the January 7 ��zxd �an��ar� 14 9�3( Advisory Agency hearings APPENDIX Q r 0 C ASSOCIATES' ..-" ENGINpING CONSULTANTS 906P PAriR A.VENUE 006vt 'm CACIFOR41A 95865 PHONE 191.8) 53'918457 - February 22a 1980' County of Butte Environmental, Revieta Department l$ F County Center Drive Oroville, California 95965 Attention: Earl Nelson Re:: Valley View Subdivision Dear Earl: Attached please find comments x haveprepared per your request concerning the cumulativeeffects on traffic and drainage that proposed and D obable future resp d� tial cieYelopinents wixl have in the Oakvale Avenue ars , 'hank you for the opportunity of responding to these items. very truly yours, CObX ASSQCATES N chael Glaze MG/cab 'roj ect .Engineer A.ttachmant 719a%i1'kM1 4i0p.' i •N .y : .'.f tri r a S''/¢/, I r + 4'� ,rY ��' , r(,,%� /11� i!!x'' ! S {�, �+"'� i '�� •I.,$j � 88 .�,.'F r,l! w a..•,. --;r OP� r�*� � ��� � / r � ` ����� nd 'A� II I � rj \,a�� l;` i t ,.�,.-„R�✓�p� f`�",,-"'-,;.r.;e«�� 1 { 'H { g •rf �t�`� yl = i" t, fl+.. 1� �,,,r', �• ', ,���' r 15 5 y t� \ ► at , � j/ �.-.I J ��'.� r* •r y� - o ,. i `n � P r �. � � / �. r• "}' .�} 1( •'Y ..� ��� �,�� r �_,,n'f`'� .•ly � �iri�'µ i” '�1 'r 1�°� f � s"� jj� ' . ..?} j� � i, j� av'• i 'f � w"r�h- c - 't� ", �w '�``�,.. � /`�;. fy � � r. r�% { + .�r' �"i • • �. 'C ♦ y r" •� ♦ y t r r . p'r- " 1 � „ M, +,4,,kr?,t l• , Q i e' tf ir, • � , ,�a ii" � '"! r �ti tp 51T 5 ... .,.r d rS w ♦ v"k. V { r' 1. 4,l' �.y� yf,. �".: '�s' „y'sMv+.,-� ^�vy„1, �yK p. i ��, sm Ago � ,,, ��' ., y` {{„ 't, °, /'�" *., ,�, 6f�t� . „ r• � a r"�."" IDD?„ 4r ,.,••�' �. r , IF, �,- v r,: , u .. �,}� ' y -i.+ ., >� \ p'' µtin � � � i• y (� , , � { rt ". ti' [ '.0 � ,�e/lfrkvr p'.«.,t �i f "+ __� � j y a .+,/�� :,rj �l �,r .!'R / .�, rt f 4 \ ,y'+ ��,,'�•J :-;.. a�%'' r -. ,--'� J'�;�, � .1,s(y', ` � �, ,'"`.+, r\"'4'�,�-�'.,r 1 " ' i'1M. • ' "� A -..., /" 1 t,: x „.- / R4� "'7' �.�%'✓,1� �`: { .+ �J s * ° �" � w.wr a 'J v«yl' "�.� e `"`! i ^ r"r �nf •� �� � tines • � �',�,,w"�rf,���'��� N'S-'� •V�l�� t � R x'`» � _ j�/ ," ' j (., " r : �C 4 Zcs �;I 1 r wt✓ ;X4 A. `�, l 1 (� _ r l t} a+ t `{ 6SL ✓',r 37s ,««�{�.....-.�+.r1. lrtp�'�.�k,'•`�"%,� � � � ��v J� ,xEl x. " ,'��`wJ� { �.-.� �".. �.���; Yyi� `�• - " ' s { J'�e �„t F1. f 4 "q $ �Je� ^'! �f l :-x�•+`a.. r'" �; r r eo.� ��'I �, L° \yf ��� r "" �� • "R :t '+��z" ��� � +P r' tiv,,.�� ., ,,« fry ��'{� 7ro4 ✓ �7^� x �' +r` ,+,,;' �;,t,'rf !"f� ., ��x�„J r `� � �J 1%/ y : .,,.:'''�'..._....r f�% n{(1: ts, ry 1 ..:�' i .y✓r`1,,5,. �''. fes • �..,.�.4' �i t �„ .:✓ S 1 c �' '�.tzk v� "v.. � ,✓�ti.,•n � � . �� 4 Owl +�,/ _, r f .� r r a �'e � • �,„ �„i. k ,, ,.y y. r , y7 �: ` •.`y +..., .� tea ,„+"r'\ \.,,, r;' t :; 'i� � j ��” +y. ' ""'�"`r'"�"�'�'j-_ •r y ti � r S+ '; `ftl"' StVF\\ �\ °tr'ty^S�`� S' •� t'``h`� _-'� fr y` -•. f"', +' ,,,�t �'�.t r" � � Z,�� �^ +� �J� +� �"`?� '�� r �� -.., 'tJ �” ��'� ,��'•*�1r �. �" �r` � � �.,yJ�c, Jt rynr�JJ !r „,M,. .'°�,"'. �`..:.•.:,. ,°�' � r. Y,., . .a 1��` �a . ,rr ti swry �,'` � ,,._ l.� �`.. "' °,1 /•�/ /x .�';JlIr. ��. �..., Y_ ^" '^.- �x..: c•1 W� ��. �':4 yS .,p11 � tie,11( f, r'yt.-: 9{w( r J.; i- ����y � � •. , ,r `.„r �-�. I.. e, �. '�,'°... A ©,'W �, ,� '��r.,. ��t« "* y�, y���"'ifYy� S J ” ;�,,�" ,'-�� {""*�,� A� +/hu ��� ��� � e"' " ] � ).,.•,.��(l'.;.-r, « ^ M � I� :. J r ���,�.1� •1 rt r+>,,wr «r. �u,..yr r y i + t7' r ,'� ^„, r`.'rrx,�°r ti.,,,�',w""'•"i'14y �7r« l:�J ��? ''w „� f5 '.r 1,•;.. \\�, d1%«.r, ,h"*• �`�-..�«+,.. '..«,ri"'p,""�. '9'-" P•i"�. V t= /r ( �``a;� ( ara ��1 �p"r` r� �, � 4��r �r .i ii '1'•�+"4 ti'�r" w�, r � � �"'. 4y:,�j�d ✓��``. i„, ��t, 07 /07 it Ul~IITED NATES DEPART IYIENT Q '['H IN'TERIQR CEOLQGiCAL SURVEY CALL NGLE h6�+111oN gtlA - APPENDIXP Additional Mitig8Ltion Measurers Proposed, by Paul. Minasian S,QHOOLS TRAFric AN' D R©AD zM r�av Mr�rJT 'C08T List of Persons Co=enting on the Valley View Subdivision FIR .;a'b the Hearixi of r ebrua ry 197 1580 �s%�tr�irfatw i'ti i u1t.t+tner�r! naiil�t•t'ixp:trfar Vx, 1 ptA 7fi Gl- l', r P +yF �Nr, watt+ ArA:ranpra +into TO , �� .i +,fw� t W:° ll`L� °�r,�l t1 - ► itUJr /... t�w411��'�11�.�`..'(.1„j, e.... xxlfd#'1 NAt 147q 4. NImjl,.vw yolto rnitr _5�t" , CL.l tr ,l Ci.flNtt-PtkGEw,,r+J 2 itk t 1`Itic f7rdar Nn . , , 1#arrci FEE +" u5° S Milt rnK. AMiiw�xll td SPACR A00vit TH)s t.rNg C'U'R rt4C 1y� (�A690 n Usk �1 Hw, r,r Uururnentstytthnn(Mr[rr>f.;, f3i3,€it9 I >k.'t QMAl Au AofRa.0 Q Computed un (u'it vrlue ul hruper!$ 1inlvayNt! or � $r xa, compotud un full 'varlur les, Iterl, *114 r 1 1�ttF i+i:ri �R rut<lalnit!N thcroan'rt urnc u? .Nlr, t,t nfanrl•n til fYal y. 1. � La e4 y A{7(i N31Eir1 Nr #N nNl Y aNl ..4 %.j (1." 'tlr+, N /1 yll i7 *40,711"m ' c roam No 1.0. tnnfil VALUC CALiPOF3NTR 1&T) A?(31 rtY 1Jr�tT a ii ti3ed e(t4r, 'tr r lx YRL7�Y Yl «f'ir'JTl3P{lip b I. mated Pai-tret•6hiri n, r + 1 a1C that reui property xnua:tc ut the unlrsti 1`pa7iu tptX ti 7'md CauntyatlAtt i�i��� x" ,Staten(CaU(arriCa, deuribrd a3 EallaN ( c t Parcel 4. tits aihtmw n an pate al 14np of ai portion of the Sauth half of Section 141Ashlp 1'' Ci. K. 4 N, "x'rt the RecA7tlier, at the Counry�et�,8uttc, 9fataOici ogrCali ocel lrnis<,r onl0ctaburh24bt1478, at i� , ' 9 ¢ in hank 68' of parcel iiapn, at pagiii S7, A Cer[ittifo of , October 30 1978 in [look 2339 of 0ffioisl Mcorda Correction ties recarddd ;'j, ,aontyt EiYifornin, i,st pABa 288, rreatdr of outta lY xJi t� f0(;E fiER WlCit a tion—exclusive ensement for the construction srld mlaintena c• of 1 y 4 K Said tuna,.+taent to be 12 feet In width, lying 6 (tut an each side' gltnitnry s'etwer r of t'hr. follovinh descxibod line, qz, C4tam'bncing At An engte point in tits' Southerly and E' Abtarly,� linea of aid i'araal` i 1 f«, Nniii poinC else being the Northwest corner of that certain Parcel draattbied In rlaed Cit p,� irotq; Niittie K: fund ttnd Crena l40d p4tke to Orovtlie Sc"1(541 pistriat recacd it �,yfld4 lorceh 31; 1985 in ,Book .1 66 of Afti0lal, ttacords, MC ` a a 64 rc r ad, County, California,*, tl,cnee Eouterly Along the North line Of fieldaOrovilleu5choo'l 11 55 llta rlat erc41 Nnrtit S J7 0 onto'!+ Nrxrt;l� tet to the ixna pa°'lne aE ke[iinniitSi f, ' 7 t a>r t [ p �j N i ,54 fife[ C thtanoa trot- thi True paint of bIP �i to 1 fee ref t to !� t; Ownce 448t, 425,.41 �a! the Fast r y Ilnw taE said parcel 1 and title end of this rias ;Paid .Parcel' 1 ba l � nt: 1111, d,rarlbod in rht,rnrta,itl Paiffeirihinp above rafer,ed to, Urlltd_ ATzri,l p'A w y. ro.yrxn 14 F��"ltt`�i , , Ir'tl^s7t�.17 x.Ui�A1iU T1YY�1'i,� Na a littit,t4'9 pliri.nrrun� i�,�. 1�' A t�p 411tbO t 1la1kt�Ii1 i r,�w�4t 4�y �, Lih_,<„�,.,,,. iV.,, h^f,rlrs air [ht utide7t,fntlL, m , (ter x�IJ :tilAft lrcc}0"All "i K�Uri NO Ali 7 ) nMrad k w x, - rai[AI S?:t lFTAMP n to rtk to N the, cltilt r 1 oA R T s Irl ��pp1'i xut+rlibei Ye 11ta wlihi;ry i-11MMMctit, a'44 oi;khnwli 1, 11114 me aha( L "t �i�” he'w.4terutllBC xdtrit dq, ! hl%�{ MAlLUX SYAtZMt4L 6 Atl t1ACdTjib, Atu(lN)t 1 MINASIAN;'MINASIAN, MINASIAN, SPRU:ANCE ,& BABER 2 ATTORNEYS AT LAW 1681 BIRO STREET' 3 P.O, BOX 16,79. 4 OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965 TELE PHONE: (916) 539:•2885. 5 Attorneys for Petitioners AY 0r G�jP�J� gy 8 Int THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STA OF CALIEO.RNIA g IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF BUTTE! 10 BARRY ROCKWELL, LYNN ROCXLv'ELL, JOSEPH ) 'POPPING, DENISE TOPPING, GENE JOVICH, ) 11 LORETTA JOVICH, JAM.2S fiA.RTMAN, CHRISTINE hto NARTMAN , 'DON ST T. CL.AIR, MRS. DON ST 12 CLAIR, SHARON WEDI14 a WILLIAM PETERSON, j CORNELIA PETERSON, WIL;LIA24 SHERIo.AN,' 18 LOIS SMM,AZ7,ROWENA TRAV25, TIM WALL, ) REQUEST FOR 14 DIANE WALL, RALPH CARPENTER, DORIS ) ADMn!ISTRA-I'yVE CARPENTER, JOHN JONES CATHY rluDIN, REirORD LEE HUDIN, CHEST,�M SPITTLE, YaOUiSE ) 15 SPITTLE, and EDNA M. POEHNLEIN, ) 16 Petitioners, 17 vs . ) COUNTY OF Bu -and,) DOES x, through X�f, ' ) inclusive= 1� _Rzspordpnt 20 TO COUNTY OF ' )3UTTE,, BO?�.AD OF' SUPERV1,S�7R5:,;, DE1?ARTr lEN'!' t0r PUBLIC 21 WORXS Ei`iVIR0 7 tE1VT,la1, REVIEW Dc,PRT-KENT and PLA"'I7I1tiG 0EPAR'w'tiE�1t' a 22 Regarding;. the above entitled prace?dinGs �yd;the adminis�' 23 tza;ive proceedings on the �app1 catozi o Ctt�orxi� Land 24, Development and Va, lay View Inve ztar,s dor app,,0"Valley 25 v ew Subdvis� on" tentative' suboi�iisial7 Leap, xe Cowledo 111 2b your records .As .E£�D Dag. tr79-0.3-27-02, a1;so k::owra ?xa 2T A.. P 7,0 7.16 i 218,Y00 ARE HEREBY REQUESTED b; th+e ab6V--n y _ timed Pe i l.c� jj i 1 also named as appellants in the administrative pr°oce'edinr�s, 2 3 prepare and deliver to the undersigned the entire record in t),ese �` proceedings, including, but not by way`of limitation: 5 1. The application for A tentative s ubdiv,ision map, 6 inciudibg the map, written application , env ronznelfttai, data and r 7 information forms., accompanyi ng correspondence,,nd any ot;laer. supporting documentation ; 8 - 9 1 . _ The environmental review checklist, toetner with 10 written attachments and da, c unients m '� 11 3. The final Environmental impact Report, in the fo,i:�n as w z dertified . ,z zZW ° a4. �f, � NQY. 12 13 To the extent they are not included in the final. EIR, CN aj6�� a��o� 14 s any and all correapondsnce received in, any of the above depart- �., , iurw��" t ments, written notes of teleuho'ne conversations by an me4x�bec }� F 16 off With an i of st y :person respecting this applicst•ion fnr _<z _ �'�m o° G 17 ub- division, mapJ, photographs, charts, diagrams, studies 0 , r.eport . y z 18 an an y other written or (Documentary materials recei�red key ani z 19 member of', staff o.f' the above--erititlsd de;partsnent-s from a;pty peroc;n 20 or agency respecting 1 e described tenta:tivb subdivision map 21 application, from `thO date of the application through, the date of 22 certification, whether or not considered by you tobe apart 23 of the .record 24 5. A complete transcri t of all oroceedin s' of �+ g the BUTiE 25 ! COUNTY Subr3ivision Comritttee, Advisory Agency, ant of .goazc 26 Supezvisozs or, all ;!�f abage-indicated dates and s,ny othez 4ate3 27 when .Yearings or ds'.cussions were had regarding 'che described. 28` subdivision ma l map -A PP 'cation. 6'. Ariy and all. Other ,items of record regzird rig the do 6UT E _U NTY ENVIRONMENTAL REVIE4!ARTMENT E ease j.ccountjng Form For E.I.R. Preparation and Subd'2yison Initial Studic!_s_ PROJECT • V Valley View ;,Subd..'AP# 34-270-116 Log # 79-U3 -27'-01 SOIDIVISiON INITIAL 5TUOY EXPENSES,. professional & Specialized Services' Staff' work completed: hours @ �h o u r s @ - —_hours @ $, Initial Study Total X 2 =$ Note: Initial study surpluses cannot A refunded, only credited toward' E,I#R, preparation or to GbneraI Fund, ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT PREPARATION. EXPENSES: Professional & Specialized Services: Eco -Ana] sts 60.00, Staff work completed: SAS 13 h ours @ 7.9-9-- S 19 374 hours @ $ 9.23 1.43.82 = 1.82:29 � R —hours @ 9.80 =$ 176.40 Enn__ 115 hours @ 1110.4,5�1=$ 1r__ 5 6 EDN hours @ $10.97 -$ 10:97 hours @ $T2. T7 =$ 36.21 �L � E.I.R. Tot—ETIT Z-1al X 2 $ 2 669-16, 834:58,=$ 7 , MISCELLANEOUS EXPENSES: Typing costs @ $1,82 per page (initial, Study) _$ Printing costs (Initial Study)$ Typing Costs @` 1.82 per page (Draft E.I.R.) 19 $ 34_,58 73.. 2�2 Printing costs (Draft E.I.R':) Typing costs @ $1`82 per page (Final E.I.R.)_ 2- —3 Printing costs (Final, E.I.R;.) Legal Notices Circulation - (Initial S�ud�, D,rhft or Final EIR) - $ 2 R. 2"(27*J3 er x. zsc. Total Misc Expenses $ 269'.94-$ 269: 94 XPSES t ACTUAL TOTAL DEPARTMENT EEN $� 1,999.1 0 * Tota'A Eitpet�ses�� 1 99J.� 0 Total Ini!tia1, Study Expenses - Y.---- TOTAL AMOUNT DEPOSITED TO DATE $ 1,2.00.00` $1.q0. dor 7lnneac) Amount, i:o be `Refunded $ Amount Owod by App1 i cant """""... • t i 1 's t u,dy ins ) ,asubdivisions, includes �actut�a cost (In the case of of; a , Date : 3/19,/'$1 Revisecl AML 1. }Viden Oakvale Avenue along :A" to frontage aria canSt'rU t left -t rrr, lane at subdivision entrance. 2. Provide for future traffic circulation to the north as shown on tentative ; Grade and pave a minimum a'f five (5) feet of tate shoulder re 'a to formpcdest�x:an way �1 on the west side of Oakvale Avenue .a aha, the, intersection to the entrance to olihz r School; from pxojcct Paint a sroIJexd crosswalk acr,oll Oakvale Avenue at projel;t appropriate ' edest.rian Crossing" 9i ,t4 en"txance and install uat each direction on Oakvale from cross :calk. Provide adequate the SLil�d1 V1S] t'. sight distance !' traffic at the ent.arice to 4, Design the subdivision storm drain, system :to accommodate anV cl,.. - the Palermo Canal as a pat.eci stormwater runoff, without us -.ng runoff receptor. S. Dispose :o ,f surface drainage to minimize standing watex whit} c olild induce mosquito breeding,. G. improve and maintain the Palermo Canal (section through the site) to eliminate leakage ontolu:Ver elevation property. 7, All utilities within the 'project site will be undergroundi provide ani va'ult to prevent mosquito drainage system for underground br.ee&Lflg.• Preserve existing mature trees along portion Of the westerly effective means. subdivision boundaxy by easement or other Provide a no develoPtiieat setback of IS feet along watercauir.ses Provide drainage easements for including the Palermo Canal: significant natural watercourses. rile loctiort and width Of easement along Palermo Canal shall meet the requirements .of Orq'vi.],lew�'�yandotte Irxigatiorl District. Revegetate disturbed $.oil surfaces to prevent erosion and use native plant species siltation print to winter, storms.'" tothe maxi:nlum passxUle, e:ttcht. 11, Avoid aversteepened slopes in construction an,d utilize proper the " effects :from 'road constuu�tion ei��gi.tteering praoti ces to m.inmze'' and tl�e d.eveopment of building pa�is. " 1Z. Coni'lete raadt;ay and bui'1?1g 'pod construction ��efn.e the hca�ry l4 reci itat ion eriod bogiras in Dec`mber. man 'K, r s � r . r. i sf a r r Zi i) t f C. Li.. ♦f ,.s__' e J,, o�1 1.4 1.vl...T.r f l.L�.e--+Lp tL'i iz•Y n: �_•.. ' ?- rr•s _re fdK.... �-.:l i•. ,rf.r .:.♦ .•1 Fry �.srr ;i :4t