The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About039-130-02493-36 PROJECT SUMMARY SHEET Permit No. Pile No. NUQI;A QU11Z Applicant Representative 694 EAST 12TIl ST, ADDRESS* - CHICO, CA. 959�M PHONE: 916 342-7092 KOU LE- E 31.95 CHICQ RIVER RD.CHICO, CA 95c,�26 Property Owner, Address PROJECT DESCRIPTION: A KrN PP,,RMTT TO AI.I.OW A SE- CTITZEN T)WRT.T.TN(-, NO T.ARQT'R THAN s 1200 SQ.FT. FOR 1 OR 2 PERSONS AGE 62 OR OVER. A-10 ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF CHICO RIVER ROAD, APROX 250' W OF on property zoned located CROUCH AVENUE, 3195,RTVER ROAD. identified as AP .039-130-024 CHICO i town/area General Plan Designation Mal) # DATE Application Accepted: Application Paid: $ Receipt No,:4�4 --�' 17 Mailing List Prepared Notices Mailed Number - Publication Notice Written Environmen4d Determination: Categorical Exemption Class., Development R Appeal Hearing: v Comirlittee Ht e-5 $F Planning Director Approval'. Final Permit Dated: 0 Nhoua Chge - (item determined to be categorically exempt from environmental review) Administrative- Permit to allow a senior citizen dwelling no larger than 1200 square feet for one or two persons age 62 years or over on property zoned A- 10 (Agricultural - 10 acre parcels) located on the South side of Chico River Road, approximately 250 feet west of Crouch Avenue at 3195 River Road, identified as AP 039-130-024, Chico. (LPW) The Commission waived the reading of the Staff Finding. A video of the sight was shown. Staff gave a brief description of the project. Vice Chairman Lambert noted a letter received today from the applicant's son, Mr. Lee. CopIeQ- were made available to the audierice. Commissioner Nelson asked if the two esilsting dwellings are legal? Staff said yes. Staff said there is a home on the property and an agricultural worker's home. Staff said the ag. worker's home does not i1gure into the density. Commissioner Ferguson questioned if this appeal was made in a timely manner? Staff said the appeal period Was extended because the approval letter was not signed on September 1, as originally scheduled by the Develo�ment Services Director and thus the appeal was filed on time. Commissioner Ferguscn asked if there was a nitrate problem in this area? Staff said the site is outside the Chico Nitrate Plan area. Commissioner Ferguson asked if the mobile home was to be removed at the time the two story home was built? Staff said no. Staff said the agricultural employee housing i's hot required to be removed. Staff said the State law states the 62-1200 housing for senior citizens shall be allowed if they meet the criteria of the 'administrative code. Staff said it was the decision of the Development Review Committee and the Development Services Director to approve this permit. Staff recommended that the permit be approved and, if necessary, the Commissloh,coUld add conditions. Commissioner Nelson asked staff to go over the differences between an "Aunt Minnins' and "'Granny Housing'. Staff said the granny housing can be rented and is intended for one or two ,senior PL ON 6dt Nip 14JJ,094r1r mix , Uths citizens, one of which must be 62 years of age. Staff said Yviih the "AuiA MInr,4:<1-"' *.4, use is temporary, thu unit can not be rented, and the occupants do hot have to be 62 years or older. Vice Chairman Lambert asked if the Commission has the option to condition this permit for a certain period of time even if the Commission does not have the option to deny the permit request? Staff said this is correct. Commissioner Nelson said that given the density on the lot at this time, he would feel better with a temporary permit. The hearing was opened to the public. Larry Martin said if this permit is granted there will not be any additional people living on the property, just an additional dwelling. Mr. Ka Lee said none of the neighbors have been to his property and no one has talked to him. He said he wants to be a good friend to the neighbors. He said he has been on the property for five years. He said because of religious beliefs he needed to move his mother out of the main house and into a house of her own. He said both he and his wife work. He said the property is not noisy W day long. He said there are time when friends come to visit. He said his mother is 79 years old and needs her own house. He said in his opinion the appeal was filed late. Vice Chairman Lambert said the appeal period was moved forward due to the permit not being signed on time and the appeal was legal. Mr. Kou Lee said there are no chemicals being used on their crops. He said there are only five neighbors near the property. He did not understand why so many people signed the petition. jog Mi said his property is on the west side of this parcel and he was born and gUe raised in this area. He wanted to assura the Leesthat there IS no prejudice on his s de because they are Asian. He said he admires the way they farm, He said be sprays and uses fertilizer on his own property only. He said he does everything within the guidelines of the agricultural commissioner. He said there is already two dwellings on the 4.9 acre parcel and he felt 3 dwellings would be excessive, He said he hat been on the property and has tried to talk to Mr. Lee. Larry Mendonca said he was opposed to a third dwelling on the property. He s6ld the regulations for a sei-ilor dwelling State it Will be the second d walling. He said in this case It will be the third dwelling. He said the letter submitted tit-, Mr ' Lee was Untrue, and if people wero getting tick from the neighbors spraying, An', Mr. Lee would not wan I t to pUt'ahother dwelling on that property for his motheri He said this request Is hot in conformance With the requirements of the Greenling policiesi -PIANNING COWISSION X�XUTES -- ottoboir J�5j 1093,, qdifftY, Jack Brown said he lives across the street from this property. He said there is a high nitrate problem in the area and he is against a third dwellihg. H9 said Mr. Lee's letter states he has 4 children. Mr. Brown said he has seen 8 children getting on and off tile school bus. He was concerned a third dwelling would impact the neighborhood. He also stated he was not prejudiced. Nancy Corbett said she lives on the street and sells real estate. She said she has lived in this area for 20 years. She said she was concerned with the nitrate levels and with property values. She said the dwelling would be right on the road as is the ag. worker's dwelling. She was concerned with a third septic on the property. Steve Mendonca said he lives 3/4 mile from the site. He said he was against a third dwelling. He said this is a rural area. Harlan Wright said this would circumvent the Greenline regulations. Fie was against the project. He said it would add to the traffic problems. Mr. Ka Lee said more than once, at three in the morning, he has opened his bedroom window and had pesticides in the room from the neighbors spraying. He said more than once the County has walked into his house without notice. He said he wants people to come to him with complaints and not go to the County. He said he did not think he did anything wrong on this property. He said he has allowed other Asian people to c, -.,Me onto his property and pick the end of a crop. He said Mrs. Corbett has only lived there a little over a year. He said some of the children seen getting off the bus belong to the ag. worker. He agreed not to have a vegetable stand on the street if it was a traffic hazard. Mr. Miguel said this is an agricultural area and h9 has no problems with the Lee's farming. He was concerned with the third dwelling. He said the County requires him to spray at night. He said he triato to spray between 8 and 9 pill., hot three in the morning. Commissioner Nelson asked if Mr. Miguel would be opposed to the request being for a temporary dwelling to ba used by Mr, Lee's mother only, then removed? Mr. Miguel said ho would still be opposed to another dwelling being placed on this property, Commissioner Nelson said the intent of the 1w , to deal with Senior citizen housing. Vice Ch3irmah Lambert said Mr. Lee presented a property tax bill Indicating according to the msessor's; Office, the property is 5.4 acres and hot 4.9. Larry Mendohca said drop spraying is a heCetSl�ln his farming operation. He said the mote housing units that are put In, the h4larder it is to farm, He said this use should not be allowed In the Gteahlihe aroal �Ut�tt, OL t' - Y., X,140 00XHtS$%0N DIX"T , ES O'dtdbd 1' ej, 4 0 NT PL NR v The hazzing vicc cl.osed. Vii I ce Chairman Lambert said the Commission, by law, can not deny this request, but the Commission can put a condition on the permit for it to be a temporary use. Mr. McCabe said essentially she was correct. He said if all the criteria is met, the Ordinance states tha permit shall be granted. He said the Commission can condition this permit for a ceitain length of time. Commissioner Nelson said he agrees with the neighbors as far as the densibi goes. He said on the other hand, Mr. Lee has complied with the law and ordinance and the intent is for a senior Citizen dwelling unit. Vice Chairman Lambert asked if an Administrative Permit had to have the same findings made as a Use Permit in order to be approved, regarding the integrity and character of the zone in which it lies and not be detrimental to the health, welfare, and safety of the County, etc.? Mr. McCabe said some of the standard findings have already been made in the Ordinance. He said the Commission might want to consider future amendments to this Ordinance. He said the Commission has to go by the rules that are In place today on this request. He said he hoped the neighbors would communicate with Mr Lee. He said the Commission can put a time limit on the permit and tie it to the individual that is intended to live there. Vice Chairman Lambwl did not feel this use was appropriate in an agricultural area. Commissioner Ferguson said the dwelling will not decrease the land being used for farming. Commissioner Nelson said the conditions for this permit should be the same as the conditions for a temporary second dwelling unit. It was moved by Commissioner Nelson, seconded by Commissioner Ferguson, and unaiiimously carried for approval as follows: A. Find that the project is categorically exempt from environmental review; and B. Find that the Administrative Permit, as donsidered, meets the standards idehfi"ou, d in Chapter 24 of the Butte County Codei and C. Find that the proposed use of the property will not impair the integrity fAhd character of the zone in Which the land lies and that the use Would hot be Unreasonably incompatible With, or injurious to surrounding pt000tles or detrimental to the health and general welfare of the persons residing or working in the heighborhood or to the general healthi welfarej and safety cofthe County, and 14� lv53' 9 Permit to a D. Approve the Administrativ now a senior citizen dwellingUnit no larger than 1200 square feet for one or two persons age 62 years or older on AP 039- 130-024 (Nhoua Chue) subject to the following conditions: 1 occupancy of the mobile home is limited to Nhoua Chue. 2. No rent is to be charged to the occupant of the mobile home. 34 Meet the requirements of the Butte County Environmental Health Department for domestic water supply and sewage disposal. 4. The mobile home is to be a temporary use on the property pursuant to the requirements of Section 24-304 of the Butte County Code. 5. The temporary mobile home must be placed a minimum of 30 feet away from the existing structures. 6. The Use Permit shall expire two years from the date of issuance of the Use Permit. Upon application, "the Planning Commission may grant an extension of the Use Permit not exceeding one year. 7. In the event that the applicant who is residing within the mobile home or the conventional residence, for any reason, moves to another location or is deceased, then in that event, the Use Permit granted herein shall automatically expire and the mobile home shall be removed within one hundred twenty (120) days. In the event the mobile home is not removed w ithin one hundred twenty (120) days pursuant to the terms of the Use Permit, the County shall remove the mobile home and store it at the ownerps expense. 8i The applicant is to pay a deposit or post a bond to cover the cost of removal in the amount of $1,500.00 for a single -wide mobile or $2,000.00 for a double -wide mobilei 9i Meet the requirements of the Building 'Division of the Department of Development Services. 10, Applicant must also comply with all other applicable State and r local statutes, ordinances, and regulations, Note, Minor changes may be approved administratively by the Directorof Development Services Upon receipt of a substantiated written request by the applicant. Prior to such approval, verification shall be made by.each Department or Division that the modification is consistent with the application, fees paid and environmental determination �is conditionally approved. Changes deemed to be Major or significant in nature shall require a formal application for amendment W COjiftY," 10 N%Na COMISSIOV tmWns Odtobe T. LAN 61 T X F - z LL 0 z LU 0 >-: ftM4;.J wi 2 LL en 0"OF W U. ApplIrAnt's APPLICATION FOR ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT Applicant's Interestinproperty (owner, renter, lesee, owner'A name (Katherthan No. '3 4:2 Contactpersonforthe project(if othorthan theapplicant) ae op, K—A t6E 3ya- 707). RequesteduSe .5'&J10f, errIZEtt) ,U4k)r,- — 144661(f, W111F— Property locatlonandstreatoMmss(glvedirecUonsiflne,',i.',Ip.-eR)_ I I I Y3 CHICf') KIVMK f -f -V WILD t L A - ,de&iJS V2. Aft(0 (,AST W (�4 umrfs Assessor's parcel no, 0191 Presentzonlng 8-10 Current use of the property k1P—e(J(-TUPz Type ofsewago disposal method 15'Emt Watersourco EW—ISTWU62 Proximity ofwaterforfire fighting purposes (hydrants, ponds, etc.) (JAJKN0VJtJ Building construction (square footage and type of construction) A, ExisUngbulldlngs R9106WM Wim) &jo A62hWLT14�E (X�6t,-*A U101 0. Proposed Buildings 16-73 :Z FL -Z S t1,6 fl16,60-1 116NF- Describe adjacent land uses: Ao 17 rt)ja -n ty3e- [East ARI WIZU2C South— West. I hereby declare uhderpenalty of perjury that I have read And understand the Instructions andthat the foregoing statements Are true, complete, and correct to the best of my knowledge. Dato. 1 '7--�—!Z Appildanfa signature 3 bate— Property owhers 919haturoX, VeHfy: AiP.Wmbers.. Ownership. Zoning tion description Project de6crlptlo 20 copies o� plot won 1: 4:5 5�' Date recolved $ Robot No, Apo[calioh taken by - I r A=N A INSTRUCTIONS TO ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT APPLICANTS ,f app',10ant is r,ot ilie ov,ncir, -wilitten Inutheri-,atior by thp, nwner or other oroof of agency must be submitted in order for the applicant io legally sign the application. Application shall be considered void if not signed by the owner or legal agent. 2. All items on application shall be filled in as completely as possible. If an item is not applicable, please indicate by the term "N/K. 3. It is important that the applicant supply an accurate description of the location of the proposed project, including the following: a. Assessor's parcel number(s) (from the tax bills or Assessor's maps). b. Street addresses (if available). ce Distances and directions to narned streets, bodies of water or railroads. 4. Twenty(20) coplesof adetailed plotplan of adequatescaleto clearlyshow proposed buildings and improvements shall accompany and be made part of the "Application forAdministrative Use Permit'. The plot plan should be no larger than 11 " x 1 T', be folded to 8 1 /Z'x 11 ", and shall include the following in -formation 8. A scaled drawing of the parcel(s) boundaries. b. Location and dimensions of all existing and proposed improvements on the property, including buildings, driveways, parking areas, wells, septic tanks and leach fields. 0. Location and name of bordering streets, access roads, nearby crossroads, streams, bodies of water and railroads. d. North arrow and scale of drawing. 5. The "Application for Administrative Permit" is subject to review by County Staff and approval by the Planning Director, Any special conditions of approval shall be made a part of the approved "Administrative Permit" and shall be binding on the applicant. The procedures for County action on Administrative permit applications are stated in Chapter 24 of the Butte County Code, 6. In approving an Administrative Permit, the Planning Director may include such conditions as are deemed reasonable and nec;essary under the circumstances to preserve the integrity and character of the zone and to secure the general purposes of the Butte County General Plan and Chapter 24, of the Butte County Code. In general, said conditions will be listed as standards in Chapter 24 for each use, in unique situations additional conditions may be added so long as they are reasonably related to the use for which the permit is requested. 7. Application fees as of —Jdate) are $ —, Fees may be paid in cash or by de payable to "Treasurer of Butte County", 8, Before submitting an AdministrR-tive Permit applicationi applicant is requested to discuss with staff all questions about application requlrements� County procedures, zoning . provisions and possible conditions of approval, REGULATIONS FOR SENIOR CITIZEN DW . ELLING UNITS BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT The following conditions shall be applicable to all Senior Citizen Dwelling Units as defined in secilon 24-202 of tho Bute County Code and located within the unincorporated area of Butte County. It is the applicants rqqqqag1W& f- *—iw� +k,+ *1 ---- --- Aw--- I--- -- ---- k-- - . . .. . I . . licant shall be resnonqihla r rnwirlin �ioz r. " t -A k +k f1 ; f I t, He 'I �Q y U oun , re u, , , icat on or proo, o, com, conditions. with (1) The lot or parcel on which the senior citizen dwelling unit is proposed contains an existing single-family dwelling unit. (2) The `I* Ing area", meaning the Interior habitable floor space area of a dwelling unit including basements and 1v attics, but not Including a garage or any accessory structure, shall not exceed 1,200 square feet for a detached senior citizen dwelling unit. The "living area" of an attached dwelling unit shall not exceed 640 square feet or 30% of the existing single-family dwelling unit living area, whichever Is greater. (3) The senior citizen dwelling Unit Is intended for the sole occupancy of one (1) adult 62 years of age or over or two (2) adult persons, one of whom is 62 years of age or over. An affidavit of compliance with the age requirements of this section shall be recorded In the office of the Recorder prl,.)r to Issuance of building permits. Said affidavit shall Include the legal description of the lot or parcel and shall constitute a covenant running with the land, binding upon the original owners and their heirs, successors and assigns, limiting the occupancy of the senior citizen dwelling unit to the conditions described In this section. (4) the senior citizen dwelling unit shall not be sold as a separate unit Unless a parcel containing the unit Is created in compliance with the existing zoning and subdivision ordinances and the resulting density Is In conformance with the General Plan, (5) Two off-street parking sppces shall be provided for the � )Ior citizen dwelling unit In addition to the parking spaces requIrad for the primary dwelling unit. (6) Adequate sewer and water facilities shall be provided sUbJL It to the approval of the Environmental Health Department, (7) All site development standards as required by the zoning, district In which the unit Is located shall be met (8) The Senior Citizen Dwelling unit ehall be a conventionally constructed building or a mobile home that complies with the National Manufactured Housing Construction and Safety Standards Act of 1974, except that In the "A", "FR", and 17M" series of zones a mobile home, as defined In Section 24-21,28, may be used. Travel trailers and recreational vehicles shall not be allowed as a Senior Citizen Dwelling Unit, (9) The approval of this permit Constitutes approval only to the extent that the project complies with the Butte County Code and all other applicable regUlatl6hs, ('10) Any proposed grading which will create outs or fills in excess of 18" for roads, driveways, building sites, drainage ways or ditches on parcels shall be shown on the map included with the application and shall be reviewed and approved by the Department of Public Works, (I I,' i'he fequlremeoi:8 of all concerned governmental aget!�,Ies having jurisdiction by law, Including but not limited to the Issuance of appropriate permits, shall be Met, As the applicant for a Senior Citizen Dwelling Unit to be located within the Unincorporated area of BUtte County, 1 have read and understand the above conditions as they pertain to My project. Signed X )�6te` 0 0 -1 C) k V a3z -001 V oc) 5 LK 039 120J 001 00111 STATU8i. ACTIVE 'L. 039 130 005 000 �STATUS. ACTIVE Li 039 130 012 000 STATUS: ACTIVE MIGUEL MARY . `GRIFFITH JOHN ELLI6 39 13QN&24 '—'�- CH7CO� OuF5q28 -- CHICO CA 959R8 L: 039 120 015 091PI STATU8o ACTIVE �^ --' --- - - - VANELLA ROBERT M & SUSAN Drp ' ' GRIFFITH JOHN ELLIS -- 3068 CHICO AVE ' --- REAVIS - VE C�� - ' uHyrn r4 9s9pn . L: 03q 120 017 000 �TATUG: ACTIVE gTAT[jo ACTIVE FQRTIER & SONS INC ~^~~--� -- -----jj0 ' ~` ALBDD1OAVE,lO8l� 9160 AGUAS FRIA8ROAD ' ' ' �4RS928 CBIOO CA 95928 . CHIOD =. . " . ^. L� 012,89 �STATUS: PCTJV2 qOqT SUE L; 039 130 024 0 0 1, LEE KOU 1.4 MAI H STATL o�p uuou�o AVE 787 ROUCH ..vENUE ' C8IOO CA 95928 C�7ca Cff'qS928 � L: 039 i20 019 000 : ACTIVE La 087 130 07 000 STATUS: ACTIVE 716 REAVIS AVE 'CHICO BERTAGNA ORCHARDS <NC 31 1 VE 95 CHICO R RD P 3829 HEGQN LN CHlCn rlA CHIOO Q4 95928 ' JIL CA 9%2B -^ -- l30Ol8 0OO�747U8: ��ODg ~--- ^^~^-'- -R, CHI I Co JOHN DLlIGGS i'��' CR'nU-�AVE 615 REAVIS AVE - g5A28 Lu 039 130 010 000 STATUS: ACTIVE L - PJ39 i 3fil 023 0091 STATUS: ACTIVE - L. v ''-- 857 REAVIS AVE l89i GROUQlAVE `-- ~^ 95928, CUICO CA95928 v"^"° S ACTIVE / Lx 089 180 0-W000 K D ' �`v�� ^ ^^^---`----'- cRARTPFF 14uPFNCE r--'&R9JTH ' NL 899S CHICU|IS �IVFR 2901 CHICO AV ' CHJCO GM Y5928 3111 CHICO RIVER RD Lt 039 180 082 1-;100 STAT�� ACTIVE L� 0139 18rif 02P- 1300 8TATU8: ACTIVE � CRABTREE LAQRLND�-E. &FAITA D BIDDLE DONALD W& VIOLA B ^ 89Y5 CHICO RIVER ROAD g 5 REAVIS AVE U CHIcO nA 0.154pq CHIrn --"qRo LK 039 120J 001 00111 STATU8i. ACTIVE 'L. 039 130 005 000 �STATUS. ACTIVE Li 039 130 012 000 STATUS: ACTIVE MIGUEL MARY . `GRIFFITH JOHN ELLI6 887 TAFFEE AVE / '—'�- CH7CO� OuF5q28 -- CHICO CA 959R8 L: 039 120 015 091PI STATU8o ACTIVE �^ --' --- - - - VANELLA ROBERT M & SUSAN Drp ' ' GRIFFITH JOHN ELLIS -- 3068 CHICO AVE ' --- REAVIS - VE C�� - ' uHyrn r4 9s9pn . L: 03q 120 017 000 �TATUG: ACTIVE gTAT[jo ACTIVE FQRTIER & SONS INC ~^~~--� -- -----jj0 ' ~` ALBDD1OAVE,lO8l� 9160 AGUAS FRIA8ROAD ' ' ' �4RS928 CBIOO CA 95928 . CHIOD =. . " . ^. L� 012,89 �STATUS: PCTJV2 L:039 130 016 000 ST8TOG:&CTIVD KOGTERFR/ BENNETT KIM V & [&OBDNOD V o�p uuou�o AVE 787 ROUCH ..vENUE ' C8IOO CA 95928 C�7ca Cff'qS928 � L: 039 i20 019 000 : ACTIVE La 087 130 07 000 STATUS: ACTIVE RERTAGNA ORCHARDS INC BERTAGNA ORCHARDS <NC 3329 HEGAN LN 3829 HEGQN LN CHlCn rlA CHIOO Q4 95928 ' / L: 039 120 035 0001 STATUS-. ACTIVE \ � -^ -- l30Ol8 0OO�747U8: ��ODg ~--- ^^~^-'- LOGAN rANILy �RUBT �'- ' LOGAN DONALD L& HOPE TRUSTEES �GRIFFITH JOHN DLlIGGS i'��' CR'nU-�AVE 615 REAVIS AVE - g5A28 OHICO � CA 95928 � . r�T�O O& ~^^---+ ^ ~n| � . Ll- 089 120.0,86 1,100qYAT|e 4rrr01: . l3O C7O AnA STATUS - ACTIVE LOGAN FAMILY ' LOGAN DONALD | *" HOPE M TRUSTEES � - L. v ''-- 857 REAVIS AVE l89i GROUQlAVE `-- ~^ 95928, CUICO CA95928 v"^"° S ACTIVE / Lx 089 180 0-W000 K D ' �`v�� ^ ^^^---`----'- cRARTPFF 14uPFNCE r--'&R9JTH ' NL 899S CHICU|IS �IVFR "~ ^' AVE ' CHJCO GM Y5928 'cHtCOj ~ � Lt 039 180 082 1-;100 STAT�� ACTIVE L� 0139 18rif 02P- 1300 8TATU8: ACTIVE � CRABTREE LAQRLND�-E. &FAITA D BIDDLE DONALD W& VIOLA B ^ 89Y5 CHICO RIVER ROAD g 5 REAVIS AVE U CHIcO nA 0.154pq CHIrn --"qRo LK 039 120J 001 00111 STATU8i. ACTIVE Lk 030; f80 006 OP41PI ��- ACTIVE 1 WTsHT R HARLAN � N��up�T �2NDONC8 JOS5�| S GR & L~ IE 1"rV TRUST ' ENUONCA J08PPH G 8R FLS1E 1.4WTO-re � 81,1 5 CH1GO RlVtR 0 66i CHtCORIVEN RU , . CHYcn . r» ` o�pog OHIOU CA 16988 Li 039 1W003 000 gTAT[jo ACTIVE 01.3 8TATUsi ACTIvr. ' �RE�UJANtq j JR & CYNTHIA L MENbONCA JOSEPHg 8R & ELSIE REV M T ' MENOU H SR &, E-AIE TRUSTEES .ep�b CAzOO RIVER RD' 8861OAICU P%I05R RD RUST CP 41. 5TA U8;, AbTi��El. ljbROT,HY Nr: $T E�- -HONOLUL U ki v6bls' 29 96 CHICO,RIVER�RUAb L: on floa o0o 'STATUS IYE 9 CHICO 95928 C A -i Y c OFFM, N &AANC 'L:039 120 % jg5og HART ST MULLINS UdELIA:� RESEDA CA 91�351'� L: 089 570 024 000 STATUS: ACTIVE CHI CO, CA 95928 REYNOLDS ROBERT J'*tr. JANET L JT ap-90 CHICO RIVER RD CHicb CA ?5926 ATUS.- ACTIVE., �rjq bikl 026 1.401, ST w CORBETT WILLIAM F & NANCY K ETAL 3228 CHICO RIVER RD cHIcG CA 95928 Le Oay 570 027 000 STATUS: ACTIVE B�OWN JACK D & SYLVIA D 3192 CHICO.RIVER ROAD CHICO CA 939eB L.- 039 570 028 000 STATUS: ACTIVE SEER JOHN H & MYRLE N, JT 3210 CHICO RIVER ROAD CHICO CA 9592B L, 039 570 0it 0,01,'J STATUS: ACTIVE STGERMAINE SUSAN 3148 CHICO RIVER ROAD CHICO C A 95928 L: 031 570 021 000 STATUS: ACTIVE STGERMAINE SUSAN 8148 CHICO- RIVER ROAD CHICO CA 95988 L.- (,J39 5701 0,10 000 STATUS: ACTIVE DUTRA Wl[.LIAM & EVELYN R618 CHICO RIVER RD CA 95928 Lt 0189 5570 1'05 P100 STAtUSi ACTIVE BATTINICH WILLIAM R & ANN aT 578 Rio LINOO AV5 CHlC-U CA 95986 L: 039 570 015 000 STATUS ACTIVE BRUHN DOROTHY 2�96 Ck`ICO,RtVEk �OAD CHICO q6988 Li a)3� 570 016 000 STATU8t. ACTIVL 8�UHN DOROTHY 5 �9�6 CHICO RIVrk- I ROAD CHICO CA 95,988 L -. 03q 5791 0,06 000 8TATU8t ACTIVE 008Y WILLIAM JUDIT14 CP M65 OAK WAY CHICO CA Y5q86 STAl'U8- ACTIVE D6TAA WILLIAM EVELYN 8618 0141CO RIVE0 AD CHICO CA �59eb ADMINISTRATIVE PARMIT BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT 93-36 PERMIT NO. 039-130-024 ASSESSORIS PARCEL NO. Pursuant to the provisions of the zoning ordinance of the county of Butte and the special conditions set forth below: Nhoua Chue is hereby granted an Administrative Permit in accordance with application filed: July 12, 1993 to allow a detached Senior citizen dwelling no larger than 1200 square feet for one or two persons age 62 years or over on property toned A-10 (Agricultural. - 10 acre parcels) located on the south side of Chico River Road, approximately 250 feet west ot Crouch Avenue at 3195 River Road, identified as AP No. 039-130-024, Chico. 1. Failure to comply with the conditions specified herein as the basis for approval of application and issuance of Permit, constitutes cause for the revocation of said permit in accordance with the procedures set forth in the Butte County Zoning ordinance, including Butte, County code Section 24-62. 2. unless otherwise provided for in a condition to an Administrative Permit, all conditions must be completed by the permittee. Tithin 1�) months of the delivery of the countersigni-d permit to the permitteei 3. If any use for which an A&Ministrative Permit has been granted is not established within one year of the date of receipt of the countersigned permit by the permittee, the permit bhall be come null and void and reapplication shall be required to establish the use4 4. The terms And conditions of this permit shall run with the land and shall be binding Upon and be to the benef it of the heirs, legal rept6sentativesi suCcessorst and Assigns of the Permittee. SPECIAL CONDITIONS: 1. occupancy of the mobile home is limited to Nhoua Chuei , 2. No rent is to be charged to the occupant of the mobile home. 3. Meet the requirements of the Butte County Environmental Health Department for domestic water supp!y and sewage di8posali 4. ne mobile horde is to be a temporary Use on the property pursuant to the requirements of Section 24-304 of the Butte County Code. nimum of 30 feet away 5. The temporary mobile home must be placed a mi from the existing structdres. 6. The Use Permit shall expire two years, fronthe date of issuance of Tj the Use Permit. Upon application, the Planning commission may grant an extension of the Use Permit not exceeding one year. 7. In the event that the applicant who is residing within the mobile home or the conventional residence, f or any reason, moves to another location or is deceased, then in that event, the Use Permit granted herein shall automatically expire and the mobile home shall be removed within one hundred twenty (120) days. In the event the mobile home is not removed within one hundred tw.,nty (120) days pursuant to the terms of the Use Permit, the county shall remove the mobile home and store it at the owner's expense. 8. The applicant is to pay a deposit or post a bond to cover the cost of removal in the amount of $1,500-00 for a single -wide mobile or $2,000.00 for a double -Wide mobile. 9. Meet the requirements of the Building Division of the Department of Development Services. jo. Applicant must also comply will all other applicable State and local statutes, ordinances and regulationsi NOTE: minor changes may be approved administratively by the Director of Dovelopment Services upon receipt of a substantiated written request by ',ne applicant. Prior to such approval, verification shall be made I j t with bj each Department or Division that the modification is consisten the application, fees paid and environmental determination as conditionally approved. Changes deemed to be major or significant in nature shall require a formal application for amendment. NOTE: issuance of this Administrative Permit does not waive requirement of obtaining Building and Health Department permits before starting construction and their approvals to use or occupancyt nor does it Waive any other requirements.,/ !7 I I - __ z __ -V&!rA- Director ",f Devetopment Services CC: Land Development DivIrs/ion Building Division Adalth Department Department of FotgsttY April 26, 1994 PLANNING DIVISION DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROViLLE, CALIFORNIA 96965-3397 TELEPHONE: (916) 5:38-7601 FAX: 19161108-7786 Nhoua Chue 694 East 12th Streetj #13 Chico CA 95928 Re: Admiril'stra,'ve Permit, AP# 039-130-024 Dear Mr. Chue: On "�,-,irch 2,31i 1994 this office asked for your compliance to provide a bond or cab. .,;e posit vvith in 30 days to maintain the Use Permit approval. The Use Permit roquirod the 'oond or deposit as Condition 8, to insure removal of the mobile home. Thl's lias not inen e,7,compli8hed. The non-cornplIance hrs i,-sulted in the revocation of the Administrative Use p') " ilit. ShoL., you have any question regarding this matter, please contact this office between 8:00 am and 4:00 pm, Monday through Thursday. Very, truly yqurs, K, BKHi.d'r 7 P 796 163 367 Certified Mail Receipt No Insurance Coverage Provided Do not use (or International Mail j =WIUStATE9 MU10" t (Soe Reverse) Sent Street & No, PrIO 1 slide I& IP Code Postage COttifled Fco special Dolivery Poo Flonlrictod Dolivaq Fee Do"v' he 0 Halumn A t; howitill to Whom Dal I ' a CD & Data Dolivvered 0) — 4 FiOtUfn Aecaipt Showtoo to whooll o I 'y [Date, & Addro$6 at oalj�,j"O IWAL Postage P664 $ 00 POSIMOIR or Date C6 too PLANNING DIVISION DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERWCES 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3307 TELEPHONE: (91615313-7601 FAXi (916) 538-7785 March 23, 1994 Nhoua Chue 694 East 12th Street, #8 Chico, CA 95928 Rei Administrative Permit, AP No. 039-130-024 �1 Dear Ms. Chue: On October 14, 1994, the Planning Commission approved your Administrative Permit for a temporary second dwelling. Condition 8 of your Administrative Permit states, "The applicant is to pay a deposit or post a bond to cover the cost of removal in the amount of $1,500.00 for a single -wit , mobile or $2,000.00 for a double -wide mobile." Without the required bond or depos v ur Administrative Permit cannot be issued. Your compliance with this condition needs to be fulfilled, and can no longer be ignored by the County. If the deposit or bond Is not posted with the Planning Division within 80 calendar days from the date of thisletter, the permit will be scheduled for revocation by the Planning Commission. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact Lisa Purvis Wilson of this office, between 8'00 a.hi. and 4:00 p.m., Monday through Thursday. Very truly yours, BKH,,bd P P-98 037 767 Receipt for Certified Mail No Insurance Coverage Provided 41go4y,1 DO not use for International maii (See hvarso) 4 to III N a d Ledif roll UI-,(, Soma, Doll IV Poo ruo in. A S wing to, LD HU:011111 ShOwltltj ti) VVInnot, oni) AiMiessne n Addrvs� 6� TOTAL 116stago , & re C:) lin 0 Postmark Ct Date 00 (ktober 25, 1993 LOOM DOM Ll� �ftrlw PLANNING DIVISION DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 96966-3397 TELEPHONE* (916) 638-7601 FAX! (916) 538-778S Nhoua Chue 694 East 12th Street, # B Chico, CA 95928 CERTMED MAIL Re: Administrative Permit, AP NTo. 039-130-024 Dear Ms. Chue: At the regular meeting of the Butte County Planning Commission held October 14, 1993, your request for an Administrative Permit was approved. The appeal period for this approval expired at 5:00 p.m. October 22, 1993. The Administrative Permit is deemed ,granted when a bond or deposit is made, and said permit is received by the applicant by registered mail. Your Admim'strative Perruit will be issued after receipt of the bond or deposit by this department. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office. Sincerely, Wi am Parrel ID tor of Deveiopment Sem- im WF:bd Enclosure cc., *Kou Lee hie (?o4,,4 IP14-,,�� be 11"e. i /cat 7 au,,/v r-owo�k- Developmeht �Orvices 0 C T 15 1993 Orovillo,.Calliornia 'o Xt az,:l A4es, lee- a;�- 61,,eo ei,,ee k>d- k4V -e—lke—Zlt4l 7t4-.e- 7A--arA.4 a7,- &-.q, A� 41S., 44,1, -'s '/Z, V 4, 's" t�el Y-ee- leAl�rt-'*q C-4,rcl ot2�ro &.7 lr-� C-701- 6(�Al 0 4" 66� 4- A 2;, �Xt Zee jo.W� 'L-,,-Iel Axwe4��t—'oo AU-�, 17) �bovelopme I nt sorvices OCT 13 1993, Ore Administrative office 1163 EAST SEVENTH STREET CHICO, CA 95928-5999 (916) 898-3000 pe, -m it CrVCA, -t6w�l P fe em 4� Wo M, � October 6, 1993 Development Servion Butte County Planning Department OCT 08 to#; 41 cuunty Cen�.er J�:ive �Mma N Oroville, CA 95965 bear Butte County Planning Director: I am' Xoir Leej the owner of a Zone A-10 Lot, AP # 039-130-024. my wife and I have applied for an administrative permit to allow a mobile home unit for my mother Nhoua Chue. she is sevehty-nine and currently lives with us in "our home (3195 Chico River Road). The reasons we are applying, for this permit are as follows: 1, We have four r-,hildren aged 9, 7, 5, and 3. Our home has only four adrooms and because cf their ages it is hard on my mother to share a room with then. 2i; Because my mother is seventy-nilne, it- is dift"Ilcult for her to climb up and down stairs (the rooms are on the second floor). 3�. As we are Hmong, our culture dictates that we always keep out elderly with usi Thus we 0annot move, her to an apartment. My mother0s religion is Animismi This religion requires an altar4 Mej my wife and children are Christian and as such, we cannot allow hetto practice her beliefs in out home. Raving reviewed the complaints against my Pettit, 1 feel that they were based on preconceived ideas that all Asians live under stb"standara conditionsi To set the record straight, we ate Hmonq, not Vietnamesej not Laotianj Cambodian not Thai. During the Vietnam Warj we fought communist along side the United States. Ihcidentallyj my Wifelz fatherp my father and three brothers were all killed directly helping the United States block the Ho-chi�Milnh Trail, i1without the help from the Htohqj the United States would have lost up to 210,000 Aliterican soldiers during the Vietnam Waro 4 instead of 88o0oo," Said Representative Toby Ruth at the confetohdd on hutah rights on Satutdayj September 14t 1991i, Green Bay, Wisconsinii tiitortuhately, when communism gained control of Southeast Asia the I�m6hgs Were forced to �--scape to the United States6 our peoplej October 6, 1993 Page 2 my family especially, havL�, paid a high enough price.helping the United States. Now, I feel that my family and I are just as American as any other, and we deserve to live here without being discriminated against and treated subsL:andard. Sadly, my next door neighbors, the Corbetts, have accused me of several environmental misdeeds. None however are even remotely true. in their grievance letter they described my unit in question as a "senior citizen dwelling". Their use of quotation marks in their letter clearly states that they are sure I am going tn, open yet another Casino or sweat shop or illegal alien labor camp. Another section from their letter states that many occupants reside on the property which negatively impacts the environment W ith traffic congestion and after hour noise. in reality, fourteen L people reside on the property, most of which ate children. Since everyone gets up -arlyj there is no "after hour noise". The letter also states that there is not enough proper parking. on five and a half acres there is plenty of parkingi Another point muintioned in their let -ter is their concern for safe drinking Water. They themselves made the point that agricultural pesticides don't help the water table. This brings me to my next point. They have always sprayed pesticides by plane, and ttactor and never once given me or my wife noticei More than once I have become very ill from the unwarned applications. Incidentallyt bur gardens and strawberry patches are all certified as otganic6 No POISONS ARE US= AT ALL EVER. in shorto moving my mother from the inzide to her own mobile on the outside should hot cause an issue. In conclusion, I would like to Comment an each of the other grievance IL-�:ters that Were sent in. Most of them Complain of traffic Congestion. We have only 2 cars. Cotpate that to the hundreds of college students that use dhidb River Aoad to get to the riVett many having consumed aldohol4, Alsoi drinking water was a main concern. my mother will, use the exact same amount of water in hot mobile as she does our home nowi What about a tewet treatment plaft-t jiist a quarter of a mile down the tbad7 why didn't they mention anything about that? I Soma think that the mobile that I s on )ny 5 1/2 acres Is Signature Klu. L. Lee owner of the Property Hai Lhe Yi Lee CO -Owner of the Property October 6,' 1993 Page 3 !.Llegal and,' iAld have b een removed by now. It is legal, all regulationc. t been followed and fees. paid. Also, many of the' petition s.l.g. xres are from people living up to two Miles away - In my opinion, they are people not affected by my permii: in the least� 'By examining the facts, we feel that you, as the planning dilret;tor 't-ogether with your staff, would award the administrative pernJ,.,*t due to! 1. Our mother's health condition/religious liliefs. 2. To fulfill the needs of our children. 3. A mobile home . unit is not considered a permanent structure. 4. The appEtalers filed their appeals and fees after the deadline which was September 5t 1993. 5. The appealers should not bother u-- anymore, if they do so we will consider, them as violators of our civil Rights. Signature Klu. L. Lee owner of the Property Hai Lhe Yi Lee CO -Owner of the Property I Bowe, Coup. LAND OF NATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY PLANNING DIVISION DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 7 COUNTY CENM DRIVE -- OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONE! (9161538-7601 MEMORANDUM FAX! (9161530-7786 TO: Planning commission FROM: Planning Staff SUBJECT: Administrative Use Permit for Khoua Chue, AP 039-130-0240P Permit 93-36. DATE: September 20, 1.993 This item is an appeal of an Administrative Permit. The Development Services Director approved an Administrative Permit to allow a senior citizen dwelling no larger than 1100 square feet for one or two persons age 62 yearsor older. The parcel is located on the south side of Chico River Road, approximately 250 feet west of Crouch Avenue, at 3195 Chico Rivet Roadt Chi -.o area. The 4 acre parcel is zoned A-10 (Agricultural - 10 acre parcels) (9/24/74 by Ordinance 1498) and has a General Plan land use designation of Orchard and Field Crops. The surrounding parcels are predominantly 16 acres with a few smaller and a few largeri The residents of this area have appealed the Development Services Ditector's decision. Butte County Code section 24-40(e) states that the Development services Director shall consider approval of the Application After the Application is accepted as complete and the report from the Development Review Committee has been received. The Development Review Committee held a hearing on August 0, iool to review the applioation. the Administrative Permit was deemed complete and approved by the Development serViceo Director on septembeLe 7, 10934 Wh6ro were humorous letters of opposition itdt ared rb6iddntbi however, their complaintb were not relevant to the conditions that were considered. The approved Admi,nistrative Permit contains il conditions regulating items sUc . h as the 61'ze, occupd,ncy and site xdqdireraents of th is projeiat. The Approval of the Administrative Permit is based Upon the Ability di the ptop6rty and owner to meet these dohditi6hs,. The applicant demonstrated the ability to meet all conditions as proposed and aj)provAl was qtahted4 Butte county Code Section 24-40(h) states that any interested person may appeal the ' decision of the beVd1bpment Services Directors A request for L an Appeal 'was received by staff, September 15, 1993. This project is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality ?�.ct in accordance with Section 15303, Class 3(a) of the Californid Public Resources Code. Staff is in support of the decision to approve the Administrative Permit. RECOMMENDATIOM A. Find that the project is Categorically Exempt form Environmental Review; and B. Find that the Administrative Permit, as considered, meet the standards idehtifie&in Chapter 24 of the Butte County Code; and 0. Find that the proposet, use of the property will not impair the integrtty and character of the zone in which the land lies And that the use would not be unreasonably incompatible with, or injurious to surrounding properties or detrimental to the health and general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood or to the general health, welLare and safety of the County; and Do Approve the Administrative Permit to allow a senior citizen dwelling unit no larger than 1200 square feet for one or two persons age 62 years or older on AP 039-130-024 (Whoua Chue) subject to the following conditions: 1. The $'living area", meaning the interior habitable floor space area of a dwelling unit including habitable basements and attics, but not including a garage or Any accessory struotureo shall hot exceed 1,206 square feet. 2 The senior citizen dwelling unit shall be for the sole occupancy of one (1) adult 62 years of age or over or two (2) adult personsr one of whom is 62 years of age or over. An affidavit of oompiiande with the age keqLirdmehts of this seption shall be L*ecokded in the office of the Recorder prior to issuance of building permits. Said affidavit shall inblude the legal description of the lot or paredl and shall constitute A covenant running with the land, -binding upon t I he original owners and their heirsp successors and assighbi limiting the occupancy of t I he 6eniok citizen dwelling Unit to the conditions desokib'ed in this 'section. ,3o T-hesenior citizen dWelli.ng Unit shall not b6 sold as a separate unit unles6 a parcel containing the unit. is created in complian0e with the dxisting zoning and subdivision ordinances and the resulting density is in obhjdtmAhdd with the dandrAl Piano "o ofO-vtrpet -*rki'ng spacps shzll heprnvided f -r the senior citizen dwelling unit in addition to the parking spacee required for the primary dwelling Unit. 5. Adequate sewer and water facilities shall be provided subject to the approval of the Environmental Health Department. 6. All site development standards as required by the zoning district in whIch the unit is located shall be met. 7. The Senior Citizen Dwellirg unit shall be a conventionally constructed building or a mobile home that coriplies with the National Manuf actured Housing Constluction and Safety Standards Act of 1974i except 6 lipjall that in the "A"I . and I'VfM series of zones a mobile horlej as defined in Section 24-21.28j, may be used. Travel trailers and recreational vehicles shall not be allowed as a Senior Citizen Dwelling unit. Provide an all weather access for a 40000 pound fire apparatus to all dwellings. 9. The approval of this permit coitstitUtes approval only to the extent that the project c-omplies with the Butte County Code and all other applicablo regulations. 10. The requirements of all concerned qovtrnmantal agencies having jurisdiction by law, including, but not limited to the issuance of appropriate permitso shall be met. ii. Minot changes may be approved administLmtively by the Director of Development Services upon receipt of a substantiated written request by the applicahti Prior to such approva 1 1, verification shall be made by each Department or Divisi0h that the modification is dohsist6ht w i6th thim application, fees paid and environmental determination as conditionally approved, Changes deemcd to be major or significant in nature shall require a formal application for amendment. Adik Butte County Googrophic Information System MTE, COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION )JEC I T i SH At! NUMBEI: , 09-436-024, 0, 93-,36 PR( HEAKING DATE$.-. ocipbst 14i 1993 EXISTING ZO,NING.iA-lo APPLICANT, Nhoua chuo OWNEU Kw Los ,0QUEST., A661306flo PorA to How c Sonfor Cilizen Owallfq no 12NIr than i200,q fli-for bom & 06 Eirsont ol wo 62 or Wor, col t Y��.Yxss-,� -u Butte County Geopphic information System 10TTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION 0 PROJ –36 FRE NOA 93 HEMING DATESi oclobof 14, 1993 'EXISTING ZONING: A-10 5—FLI CANTli Hhoua choo OWNEI: 'Kou Lis [EQUEST: AdmIntsirdflo Pordf lo dl6v d Sinfor Cilizen Dwelling . ho lww lhoo 1200 il Ili for M br Iwo per3bos of �k U 0 Wor..- + # t Y��.Yxss-,� -u Butte County Geopphic information System 10TTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION 0 PROJ –36 FRE NOA 93 HEMING DATESi oclobof 14, 1993 'EXISTING ZONING: A-10 5—FLI CANTli Hhoua choo OWNEI: 'Kou Lis [EQUEST: AdmIntsirdflo Pordf lo dl6v d Sinfor Cilizen Dwelling . ho lww lhoo 1200 il Ili for M br Iwo per3bos of �k U 0 Wor..- Bernie RichterASSEMEILYMAN, THIRD DISTRICT 0 CALIFORNIA LEGISLATURE. STATE CAPrrOI., SACRAMENTO, CA 95814 (916) 445-7298 COMMITTEES: ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY & TOXIC MATERIALS GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION HIGHER EDUCATION NATURALRESOURCES September 3, 1993 Paula Leasure Assistant Planning Director County Of Butte 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 Dear Ms. Leasure: I have received a copy of a petition signed by constituents living in west Chico. These petitioners are concerned about the proposed Administrative Permit approval for a detached Senior citizen dwelling unit for Nhoua Chue on property zoned A-10, identified as Assessors Parcel #039-130-024 located at 3195 Chico River Road. They are concerned with the number of units being allowed on this parcel which is included in Chico's greenline to protect agricultural land6 I know that,your office has been made aware ok their opposil- tion to this project and will take it into account when making your decision based On Butte Cotnty'8 land use policies and the laws of the state of California. I appreciate you I r consideration to this group of citizens and all that you are doing to address this local issue. Sindetely, BERNIE RICHTER- BR4.jlw DISTRICT OFFICES 2646 ZANELLA WAY, SUITE D W96 COMBIE ROAD CHICO. CA 0928 MIGURN, CA 96601 (91613454807 016) 268-2320 P4ntod on Recycled meper 71. SUSAN ST. GERMAINE 3148 Chico River Rd. I Chico, CA 95928 August 23, 1993 Bill Farrell Development Services Director 1 County Center Drive I Oroville, CA 95965 Dear Mr. Farrell: De"lopmt Servic" AUS 2. 5 1993 OrOV1116, COOM12 I am most concerned about a recent notice of proposed administrative permit approval I received for parcel #039-130-024. This ptoperty, a small parcel less than 5 acres, is ah-pady heavily impacted by intensive residential use with two homes, the second recently added purportedly to accomodate agricultural workers. This parcel is directly across the street from my home and property and I am impacted very negatively with the current useage. I I'm not sure how many people live on the property or if any of them are actually employed as agricultural Workers as defined by the Planning Department, (Do you follow-up on such building permits to ensure continuing complionce?) However I do know that the extensiveAnd interminable automobile traffic to and from and noise from high human density on this property are entirely out of keeping with the intention of zoning restructions, create dangerous traffic safety problems year-rotind, and are destroying the rural nature of the area. To add aiother home and an additional onslaught of habitation to this property is entirely unacceptable. I strongly urge you to deny this permiti Questions? Please call me at 538-7858 during the day or 845-0640 in the evening. 13dt regards, 1� 1 ,-1 Susan St. Germaine This" 4ifidl/2 `a'cj�es al�r6adyt has tw6 large 'h6u'sibs" on th,� �` opert� r Y, When `th6-'he*iw hoU'se`W`as'bUJilt th'e do"ublb'wilde trailer c6ttaInly�"," should'have' -been removed, -oj� s6meone goofed' on -'the peirmit,o�� just neglected to follow Up. Three�houses, twd'new, certainly exce*eds I any'norrhal residential", all6wande in this area. 0.1 I object to your isi�uieing any�*Ip6rmit fo'r further h6usi�h4 developement on this tract. Thank You R. Harlan Wright 3095 Chico River Road A tii:. Ws, ztlb-O, sl�t MN4*-�, falto e"." a w!"it NI, J� t October 14, 1993 Nhoua Chue 694 East 12th Street, #B Chico, CA 95928 Re: 'Use Permit, AP No. 039-130-024 Dear Ms. Chue: Butte coun PLANNING DIVISION DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT BERVIC98 1 COUNTY ceNTER DRIVF - OROVILLEi CALIFOnNIA 0966-3397 TELEPHONE: (9181638-7801 FAXt (9101538-7785 At the, regular meeting of the Butte County Planning Commission held October 14, 1993� your request for a Administrative Permit to allow a senior citizen dwelling no larger than 1200 square feet for one or two persons age 62 years or over, was approved subject to the following conditions: 1. Occupancy of the mobile home is limited to Nhoua Chue. 2. No rent is to be charged to the occupancy of the mobile home. 3. Meet the requirements of the Butte County Environmental Health Department for domestic water supply and sewage disposal. 4. The mobile home is to be a temporary use on the property pursuant to the requirements of Section 24-304 of the Butte County Code. 5. 'The temporary mobile home must be placed a truinimum of 30 feet away from the I existing structures. 6. The Use Yernuit shall expire two years f!rom the date of issuance of the Use Perinit. Upon application, the Planning Commission may grant an extension of the Use Permit not exceeding one year, 7, in the event that the applicant who i's residing within the mobile home or the conventional residence� for any reason, moves to another location or Is deceased, then in that event, the Use Pe it granted herein shall allthmAdcally expire and the mobile home shall be removed within one hundred twenty (1.20) days. In the event the mobile home is not removed within one hundred twenty (120) days pursuant to the tdrms I of the 'Use Permit, the County shall remove the mobile home and store it it the owner's expense. 8. The applicant is to pa:y a deposit or post a bond to cover the cost of ftmoVal "in the aind'unt of $1 o5OUO for a singley-wide mobile or $2�000ioo for a doubld-Wide mobile, IVA 9. Meet the requirements of the Building Division of the Department of Deveiopment Services. 10. Applicant must also comply with all other applicable State and local statutes, ordinances and regulations. NOTE: Nfinor changes may be approved administratively by the Director of Development Services upon receipt of a substantiated written request by the applicant. Prior to such approval, verifimfion shall be made by each Department or Division that the modification is consistent wL-� the application, fees paid and environmental determination as conditionally approved. Changes deemed to be major or significant, in nature shall require a formal application for amendment. Should you desire to appeal any of the conditions imposed by the Planning Commission, you must do so in wri iting with the appeal fee of $250.00 to the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California, prior to 50-00 p.m., Friday, October 22, 1993. If you do not appeal and if there are no other appeal within the 8 - day appeal period, your use permit will be issued after October 22, 1993. Recently enacted legislation (AB 3158, Chapter 1706, Statutes of 1990, effective Janwn.y 1, 1991) requires that the Department of Fish and Game impose and collect filing fees as speci xed to def�ay the cost of managing and protecting fish and wildlife trust resources. These filing fees are collected during the environmental review process and are to be paid at the time the County files a "Notice of Exeniption" with the County Clerk pursuant to Section 21152 of the Public Resources Code, To 'increase administrative efficiency, the statute delegated the collection of fllm'g fees to the County Clerk and provided the County authority to collect a $15,00 documentary handling fee. The fee due for your p 'ect is $25.00. A checks made payable to the r0i Butte County Treasurer should be submitted to this department by October 29, 1991 P 'ect applicants should be aware Section 21089(b) of the Public Resources Codej r0i provides that any p 4edt approved Under C180A is not operative, vested, or final until r0i the filing fees required under Section 711,4 of the Fish and Game Code are paid. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office. sincerelyo PafUla 71easure Principal Planner PL*-bd ccb. Kou Lee �x Octob,er 6, 1993 .0'�4,,atte County Planning Department #7 County Center Drive broville, CA 95965 Oe�ar Butte County Planning Director: 1 am Kou Lee, the owner of a Zone A-10 Lot, AP # 039-130-024. My wife and I have applied for an administrative permit to allow a mobile home Unit for my mother Nhoua Chue. She is seventy-nine and currently lives with us in our home (3195 Chico Rivet Road) . The reasons we ate. applying for this permit are as follows: 1. We have four children aged 9, 7, 5i and 3. Our home has only four bedrooms and because of their ages 'it is hard on my mother to share a room with themo 2. Because my mother is seventy-ninej it is difficult for her to climb up and down stairs (the rooms are on the second floor). 3. As we are Hmong, our Pulture dictates that we alwayso, keep but elderly witli us. Thus we cannot move.' hQI to an apattmenti My motherts religion is Animism. This religion requires an altar. Mej my wife and children ate Christian and as such, we cannot allow her to practice her beliefs in our home. Having reviewed the complaints again8t my perMitj 1 feel that they were based on preconceived 'ideas that all Asians live tinder sub -standard condition8A To set the record straight, we are limongi not Vietnamease, hot Laotiaho Cambodian, nor Thai. During the Vietnam War, WO fought communism along side the United states, incidentally, My wifels father, my father and three brothers were all killed directly helping the United states block the Ho-Chi"Mihh Trail. "Without the help from the Hmongj the United States Would have lost Up to V01boO American soldiers during the Vietnam War, i instead of 580000.11 said ReptesdhtatiVe Toby Ruth at the donfetence on human rights on 8atUrdayj September 14t 1991; Green Bay, Wisdohsin'b I Uhfottuhatelyj when d6tmUhi8t gained control of 8ou�,.t.,,cast Asia the I4mohqs Were forced to escape to the t1hitdd gtatds, bu,�. peopidt October 6, 1993 Page 2 my family especially, have paid a high enough price helping the United States. Now, I f eel that my family and I are just as American as any other, and we deserve to live here without being discriminated against and treated substandard4 Sadly, my next door neighbors, the Corbetts, have accused me of several environmental misdeeds. None however are even remotely true. in their grievance I letter they described my unit in question as a "senior citizen dwellingO. Their use of quotation marks in their letter clearly states that they are sure I am going to open yet another casino or sweat shop or illegal alien labor campi Another section from their letter states that many occupants reside on t.he property which negatively impacts the environment ,qith traffic conasstion and after hour noise. In reality, fourteen penple reside on the property, most of which ate children. Since everyone gets up early, there is no Oafter hour noise". The letter Alto states that there is not enough proper parking. on five and a half acres there it plenty of parking. Another Point mentioned in their letter is their concern for safe drinking i4ateri They themselves made the point that aqrl"CUlt-Ural pesticides don't help the water table. This brings me to my next point. They have always sprayed pesticides by plane, and tractor and never once given me or my wife notice. More that once I ha!�e become very ill from the unwarhed applications4 Incidentally# our gardens and strawberty patches ate all certified as orqanici NO POISON8 ARE U8tD AT ALL MR. in shorto moving my tothet from the inside to her own mobile on the dutitidd should not cause an issue. in conclusionj I would like to comment on each of the other grievance letters that were sent in. most of theiA C!oMplaih of traffic cohgeitilon, we have only 2 -lars. that to the hundreds of college students that use Chico Ra'.Vr,.?- "toad to get to the tivet� many having consumed alcohol, I-,)1,,ik-!.nq water was A main c6heem MY tothet Will use the ex -act amount of water in her mobile as she does iti our home i� ow, about a sewer treatment plant Just a quarter of a - di& It m ile dc -%i v �,-oad? Why i n they tenticn anything aboat that? 1 4 N some think that the mobile that- 3's on My 5 1/2 actret is ? October 6, 1993 Page 3 illegal and should have been removed by now. It is legalt all regulations have been followed and fees paid. Also, many of the petition signatures are from people living up to two miles aw I ay. In my opinion, they are people not affected by my permit in -the least. By examining the facts, we feel that you, as the planning direci-or together with your staff, would award the administrative permit due to: i. out mother's health conditilon/religious beliefs. 2. To fulfill the needs of our children. 3. A mobile home , unit is not considered a permanent structure. 4. The appealers filed their appeals and fees after the deadline which was September 9, 3.993. 9. The appealers should hot bother us ahymor�i, if they do so, we will consider them as violators (if our Civil Riqhts4 Signature C� Rou Lee Owner of the Property Mai Lhe LCU September 21, 1993 PLANNING.DIVISION DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONEt (9`16) 638-7601 FAX; (9161 S30-7785 Nhoua Chae 654 East 12th Street, 08 Chico, CA 95928 Re: Administrative Permit, AP 035-130"024 Dear Ms. Chue: Enclosed is a coPy of the staff Findings concerning the appeal of the Development Services DitectOt4s approval of your application for an Administrative Permit to allow a senior citizen dwellinq no larger than 1200 squayle feet for 6h6 or two persons age 52 or over on property zoned A -Io located at 3195 River Road, Chico. A public baatinq has been set for October 14, 1993 at g000 a,ja. This meeting will be held in the Board of Supervisors' R -dot, 25 County Center D11-16ve, Orovillet California. The Planning coaraission recommends that the applicant or their authorized representative be present at the hearing to respond to any questions the Commission may have4 In the event that no one will represent,the applicant, please contact the Planning office prior to the scheduled public hearing. should have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this ofyfosl-cle. William Farrel bi :LF�.c'tor of bevelopmdnt services wu-'U�' Lisa PVtvis Wilson As8ociat-6 rlanner LM.'Ir Enc. Bernie RichterASSEMEILYMAN, THIRD DISTRICT 9 CAQFORNIA LEGISLATURE, STATE CAPITOL. SACRAMENTO. CA, 958114 (916) 445-7298 COMMITTEES: ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY & TOXIC MATERIALS GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION HIGHER EDUCATION NATURAL RESOURCES September 3. 1993 Paula Leasure Assistant Planning Director County of Butte 7 County Center Drive aroviilej CA 95965 Dear Ms. teasuroo. I have received a Copy ot a petition signed by constituents living in west Chico. These Petitioners are concerned about the proposed Administrative Permit approval for a detached senior Citizen dwelling unit for Nhoua chue On property zoned A-10, identified as Assessors'parcel' #039-130-024 1-ocated at 3195 Chico River Aoad. They are concerned with the number of units being allowed on this parcel which is included in MiOO's greebline to protect aqridUl�ural laftd4 1 know that,your office, has been made aware of their opposi- tion to this project and wllll -take it into ac -count when making your decision -based on Butte County's' land use policies and the laws of the state of California, '_ I appreciate your consideration to this group of citizens and all that you are -doing to address this local issuei BERNIE RICHTER BR'.-Jlw DISTRICT OFFICES 2645 2ANtLLA WAY. SUIK D 'A506 COME ROAD CHICO, CA 95028 "AN, CA 96602 (016) 345-1807 (Dib) �68-2820 P6616d 6h Pdc�tl6d Pbpet August 23, 1993 SUSAN ST. GERMAINE 3148 Chico River Ad. Chico, CA 95928 AU6 25 1993 Oraville, Oallfomla Bill V,-Wrell Development Services Director 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 Dear Mr. Farrell: I am most concerned about a recent notice of proposed administrative permit approval I received for parcel #039-130-024'i This property, a small. parcel less than 5 acres, is already heavily Impacted by intensive residential use with two hotnesj the second recently added purportedly to accomodate agricultural workers. This parcel is directly across the street from my home and property and I am impacted very negatively with the current useage. Ijm not sure how many people live on the property or if any of them are actually employed as agricultural -workers As defined by the Planning Department, (Do you follow -Up on such building permits to ensure continuing compliance?) However I do know that the extensive and interminable automobile treffic to and frorn and noise from high human density on this property are entirely but of keeping with the intention of zoning restructions, create dangerous traffic Safety problems year-round, and are destroying the rural nature of tile area, To Add another home and ail additional onslaught of habitation to this property iss entirely unacceptable, I strongly urge you to deny this permit, Questions? Please call me at 538-7858 during the day or M5-0640 in the evening, Best regards, 1� M�_ a 8L"" Susan St. Germaine I grant an Administrative Permit that the Butte County Planning Director is proposing to !,rty zoned A-10 identified as NhoUa Chue on prope e mit may, be g, anted, subject Notice is hereby giver Mj�p 1PQ W, ad, Chico. 'The p r to I cie Wo Mer RO A SM w4, 5 (AM3 to the following conditions: area", meaning the interior habitable floor space area of a dwelling unit including -The "living Ot including a garage or any accessory structure, shall not 1. habitable basements and attics, but n two larcie houses on,the Propertys This fellready haS cyL fS, 10.41h adW1 _Vof age or �%bTq!Cpg§1Vr-@M- A1,1,vIb,! qqq�&nce 2. Uhen -ffh,61 s V LW 0119q%� 'Or@ ecorded In the office of the Recorder prior to ion shall be T : or parcel shoul et6, of �,hls sect Ude the legal description of the lot their ep Said affidavit shall incl nd ne91 g b" issuance of U1 rig P ve I it � 0 *e1X*h& to the d hall pon�%Nte RnMc Uplan V 0 e.senior citizeMn, Three a allow4W&ai d '1�la IS section, in L LARW;kl�(Jrcel containing the LNFfibr)b%V4n a"Omiaq smyrasgT44 A*s4"4*q and the resulting ob�(Okts toWn tbr*IAM'QkI_` the existing zoning and subdivision ordinances deve1a00WQX)d2 eneral Plan. Thank YOU density is 'in conformance with the G Vittiit In addition to the 4. Two oft -street parlKing spaces shall be provided for the M11016M41111-1 �W parking spaces p6quired for the primary dwelling Unit, e approval of the Environmental 51 Adequate sewer and water f;acilities shall be provided subject to th 00 River Roacl S095 Chi Health Department �70hlng district In which the unit I-, located shall 61 All site development stan6ards as required by the be met, Itionally constructed building or a mobile home 7, The Senior Citizen Dwelling unit shall be a COnver using Construction and Safety Standards Act of that cornplies with the National Manufactuved Ho : iobile home, as defined in Sectloh hd "TW series of zones a n 1974, except that in the 'A" TIFV, a tional vehicles shall not be allowed as a Sehlor 24w2l,98, may be used. Travel trailers and recrea Citizen t)welling Unit. apparatus to all dwellings, Provide an all weather access for a 40,000 lb, fire ject complies with I 9. The approval of this permit constitutes approval only to the extent that the pr tte County Code and all other applicable reguolons� the BU Includim but 0overnmental agencies having Jurisdiction by law, The requirements Of all toncerhed tt shall be met, — m ahbroprIate petmi , not limited to Tile ISsuo" �tor of DeVelopMent Services Upon � be 001?Mved administratively by the Dim Ovbl, vetificatlon shall it minor changes ma� Itteh request by the �Pl?llcaht, p!lor to such 9PPI pplicatloh, ts.celpt of a substantiated y4h n is consistent with the a e major be made by each beparthieht 'or Division that the modificatio -oved. Changes deemed to b fees paid and ehV'rohmefital determination as conditionally aPPt or signifficaht 'in hature shall require 6 formal application for arnoindhiont, 13utte County Planning g to comment on the project may subi�lt written comments to the t)ltectot shall con -S Peesohs withlh� lder all coninients In jG93, The Planning terig, Upon finding that the proposed prior to August 25 dr, Department any time meets all of the above conditions and approve the request on determining It the aPPlIcatloP and criteria, the Planning Ditectot May Director by submitting use does or Will Mott all of the conditions- the decision of the pJahriltig it 1 County ices t)eparthrent 8 September 1, 1003. Any Interested pdr8oh may appeal orhoht 86M peal and If 11,,adcompanled by $2-90,0% to the Butte County DeVelol a written appe', ) �,rn, Thuirsday September 9 '1993, If you d6 hot 901 d after to h It will be issue Center tX, OrOvI11le, CA 95965 ' ' t to 5'61 od, your Admi'Isttailve Perml thei'� are no other appeals wltN' the 8ZY appeal Pet' Septembcr 9, IS93. 1__rZ1V1 :�') V r— /� C1( ; �A r Butte County Developement Servic0s), This 4andi/2 acres already has two large When the new h6usa was Jouilt the double wide trailer certainly 'should hive been temov'dd, or soMeone goofed on the p6r%it or jUst neglected to follow up. Threer"houSet, tw ' o ' new, certainlr y eXcO'Ods h6r1r6di residenti a -'l allowance in this area. I object to your issueling-any I?ermitrfor further h6usi'hg developement on tids tract. Thank You R. Harlan Wright 3095 Chico Riv6r Road Planning bep�rtrn AU0 -7 1993 We, the undersigned, oppose the requested proval of the Oro"Illop DETACHED 1,200 sq.'ft. sL I -nior citizen dwel.. unit for Chue on Property zoned A-10 on AP No. 039-l.",O 124 located.aL' 3195 Chico River Road, Chico, California. 1'. A double -wide M.Hi designated as an AGRICULTURAL WORKER unit currently exists on the property; 2. A NEW two-story dwelling has just recently been constructed on the property4 P 3. Now a request for a 1,200 sq. ft. (living area only) dwelling is being considered for 1-2 occupants 62 years of age or over. Our objections are related to �,he number of units being allowed on a 5 -acre parcel zoned A-10.10 the area governed by the Greenline Policies designed to protect and preserve agricultural SOIL. A 5-acte parcel with 3 living units makes a mockery and far'6e of Oreenline Pteservation of agrictlIttir.0 8oiA for ngrictil,ttiral, i1t10 . Wu rou'l. L1118 Lype W.' dUV0J.UJ)i!1CnL un.,u �--LICJ-U PUICUI III Lfili4 area DOES IMPAIR TUB CHARACTER AND INTEGRITY OF THE AREA INVOLVED if agricultural I soil preservation is.to be a serious priority of �utte County s General Plan and Land Use policy# 71 f. A double -wide M.H4 designatea as aft AGRICULTURAL WORKER unit currently exists on the property; 2. A NEW two-story dwelling has just recently been..constructed on the property; 'I, Ntj%v is ri;l(Illotli 1 01* it I j'200 o(ji 1,1_ ( I I V I lig Ill 11#1 till !Y) 11wtil I Itift is being considei�d for 1-2 occupants 62 years of age or over. Our objections are related to the number of units being allowed on a 5 -acre parcel zoned A-10 in the area governed by the Groenline policies designed to protect and preserve agricultural SOIL. A 5 -acre parcel with 3 'living units ma . kes a moc . kdry and farce of Greenlino preservation of agricultural soil for agricultural use. lie feel this type of development oil a 5 -acre parcel in this area DOES IMPAIR THE CHARACTER AND INTEGRITY OF T14E ARVA INVOLVED if agricultural soil preservation is to be 6 serious priority of Butte County a General Plan and Lc)d Use policy. .......... �J6_4Y C 14 0 Pla AUG 2 3 1993 Weo the undersignedi oppose the requested approval,of the, Oeoville, r;al.fornih DPTACITED 1)200 sq. Ze. scniur citizen dwelling unit for Njigna Chte on property zoned A-10 on AP'N'O'. 039-130-024 located,at' 3195 Chico River Road, Chico, California. f. A double -wide M.H4 designatea as aft AGRICULTURAL WORKER unit currently exists on the property; 2. A NEW two-story dwelling has just recently been..constructed on the property; 'I, Ntj%v is ri;l(Illotli 1 01* it I j'200 o(ji 1,1_ ( I I V I lig Ill 11#1 till !Y) 11wtil I Itift is being considei�d for 1-2 occupants 62 years of age or over. Our objections are related to the number of units being allowed on a 5 -acre parcel zoned A-10 in the area governed by the Groenline policies designed to protect and preserve agricultural SOIL. A 5 -acre parcel with 3 'living units ma . kes a moc . kdry and farce of Greenlino preservation of agricultural soil for agricultural use. lie feel this type of development oil a 5 -acre parcel in this area DOES IMPAIR THE CHARACTER AND INTEGRITY OF T14E ARVA INVOLVED if agricultural soil preservation is to be 6 serious priority of Butte County a General Plan and Lc)d Use policy. .......... �J6_4Y C 14 0 T Plantting We, the undersigned, onnase the re'qupsted approval of the AUG 2 3 1993 itizen dwelliag Unit for Nh WoVfj,'� DETACHED 1,200 sqi ft. senior t Chue on property toned A-10 on AP No. 039-13U-024 located'at, 3195 Chico River Road, Chico, California. 1. A double-xvide M.H. designated asan AGRICULTURAL WORKER unit ctirrotil-1 Y oxi n I-, -s nit I h o iir niior I �� ; 2. A NIRW two-story dwellinp, linct Just rervnl,ly boon ronnfrurrod on the property6, 3 Now n reqUe5t for n 1,M sq. ft. (living aron only) dwelling is being considered for 1-1 occupants 62 years of age or over. Our objections are related to'the number of units being allowed on a 5-adre parcel zoned A-10 in the area governed by the Oteenlifte policies designed to protect and preserve agricultural SOIL. A 5 -acre parcel with 3 living units makes a mockery and farce of Greenline preservation of agricultural soil for agricultural Use. # We feel this typo of development on a 5 -acro parcel in this area 'DOES IMPAIR THE, CHARACTER AND INTEGRITY OF THE AREA INVOLVED if agricultural soi . I preservation is to be a 8oriout8 priority of 8utte County's General Plan and Land Use polic;r. Planning Depattirent We, a,.h,e undersigned, oppose the requested approval of the DETACHED I , 200 sq. f t i senior citizen dwelling unit f or NhAA 2 3 1993 iChue on property zoned A-10 on AP No. 039-130-024 located 00110, California 3195 Chico River Roadi Chico, California, 1'. A doubl---wide M.H. designated as an AGRICULTURAL WORKER unit currently exists on the property; 2. A NEW two—story dwelling has just recently been constructed on the property; 3. Now a request for a 1,200 sq. ft. (living area only) dwelling is being considered for 1-2 occupants 62 years of age or over. Our objections are related to the number of units being -allowed on a 5 -acre parcel zoned A-10 in the area governed by the Greenline pol.icies designed to protect and preserve agricultural SOIL. A 5 -acre parcel with 8 living units makes a mockery and farce of Greenline preservation of agricultural soil for agricultural use. 140 feel this type of development on a 5 -acre parcel in this area D088 IMPAIR THE CHARACTER AND INTEGRITY OF THE AREA INVOLVED if agricultural s 0 il preservation is to be a serious priority of Butte County's General Plan and Land Use policy. PliannIng Depailment We, the undersigned, oppose th,le requested approval of theAUG 2 3 1993 MIIII[Acii�,D 1j.400 sq. ft4 seriiur citizen dwelling unit for Nto,ua fffe, Chile on property !nonnd A-10 on AP No. 039-110-02,11 lornt�rlduwy 3 t 9.� H I ati Rivol, kood C111.(,wo Id A double -wide M.A. designated as at, AGRICULTURAL WORKER unit currently exists on the property; 2. A NEW two-strjry dwelling has,jupt recen'tly been constructed on the property-, 3.�,Now a request for a 1,200 sq. it. (living area only) dwelling is being considered for 1-2 occupants 62 years of age or over'. Out objections are related to the number of units being allowed on 6 5"acre parcel zoned A-10 in the area governed by the Gteenline policies designed to protect and preserve agricultural SOIL. A 5 -acre parcel with -3 living units makes a mockery and farce of Gteenline preservation of agricultural soil for agricultural use. lie feel this typo of development on a 5 -acre parcel in this area 'DOES IMPAIR THE CHARACTER AND INTEGRITY OF THE A�REA 1NVOLVED if agricultural soil preservation is to be a serious priority of Butte County a General Plan and Land Use policy. r U Ast 20, 1993 Butte C�unty Planning Department #7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 To Whom It May Concern: We are contacting you in regards to the notice we received in the mail concerning Nhova Chue's, our neighbor, adding a third unit(and third septic) on the property, AP#: 039-130-024. We are one of the neighbors who will affected the most from such an addition. 'We are very much opposed to this "senior citizen dwelling" being allowed due to the fact that there are two(2) separate dwellings/ septics already existing, on the property. It appears that many occupants reside on the property which neeatively impacts our environment with more traffic, congestio.-t and afterhour noise. Alsoo with such high density development in our rural neighborhood, our property values may lower as a resulti In addition, when the Chue. Family, et al, sell their strawberrys in the wooden stand next to the stteet, many vehicles hesitate, stog, And park on our property due to the inadequate parking available. Also, the Chue's vehicles enter our driveway frequently to turn- around to their property. Again, the result is more congestion and potential for traffic collisions and other unsafe activities. Since both existing residences and fruit stand do not have proper parking, it is reasonable to assume that a third residence will have the same problem making a even more hazardous situationi Another concern is maintaining sgg drinking water at out residence. We are presently on two(2) filter systems for zhe well water to lower the nitrates to a safe leve14 Without these' Gystems, our water nittate lovel is twiceo 88 ppm, the maximum level acceptable, 44 ppm. So, to open the door for the Chue's, opens the entire area for mote development, more septic systems, thus more nitrategi With the agriculture pestisi6es possibly adding to the nitrate problemo it is reasonable that more septic systems will make an. teven- - more hazardous health problem -to maintain safe drinking water! in conclusion, we ask you to please protect us from further development that may change our drinking water to unsafe levels of nitratd8� add to traffic congestion levels, and devalue the integrity of but country property. Re ec' i, y .1545 Bug., 3464n3 FAX 916 age4�i6ebIRSCT oi6� 345-076 RESIONC8 Wi e R11F__1T NANCY K-CORSM cmz e t V_ - - - ii DUFOUR REALI Y LAI_�SN AVE., WIZ M 16d.PoWenlly 0�4,",W bPdf6jj �j Mob* W dod"I b�,*o NWdential AffiNlit, loo. COUNTY OF BUTTE OFFICE OF PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE OROVILLE CA 95963-3397 TO BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING DIRECTOR; L*wwm,ont Seri " #a AM 16 190 WJILG I .,,Ca I ttrm& AUGUST 14 1993 THIS LETTER IS IN REFERENCE TO THE NOTICE WE RECEIVED ON THE PROPOSAL TO GRANT AN ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT TO ALLOW A DETACHED SENIOR CITIZEN DWELLING UNIT FOR NHOUA CHUE PROPERTY. WE SERIOUSLY OPPOSE THIS PERMIT FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONSw THE PARCEL IS ALREADY A LESS THAN 3 ACRE PIECE OF PROPERTY. THE PARCEL ALREADY CONTAINS A NEW HOUSE THAT WAS JUST BUILT. THE PARCEL STILL CONTAINS THE MOBILE HOME THAT WAS SUPP088 TO BE REMOVED WHEN THE NEW HOUSE WAS BUILT. IF A 8ENIOR CITIZEN DWELLING IS BUILT THEN THERE WILL BE THREE (3) DWrLLINGS ON A LESO THAN 5 ACRE PARCEL. SO THEN YOU WOULD HAVE A LESS THAN 5 ACRE 'PARCEL IN A A—iO ZONE WITH THREE DWELLINGS IN THE MIDDLE OF A AGRICULTURAL AREA. WE ARE STILL TRYING 113 FARM IN THESE AREAS AND A MULTIPLE'DWELLING PARCEL MAk5S IT VERY VERY DIFFICULT. 80 FOR THOSE REASONS AND OTHERS WE WOULD APPRECIATE YOUR ATTENTION TO THE REOUEST AND PLEASE' DENY THE PERMIT. THANk YOU FOR YOUR TIME IN READING OUR LETTER. SINCERe V�,Y-, %V*pment Senifft AUG.~� 1 6 19fA ` COUNTY OF BUTTE AUGUST 14 1993 ` OFFICE OF PLANNING DEPARTMENT ' 7^COUNTY CENTER DRIVE ' OROV1LLE CA 95985-3397 '! TO BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING DIRECTOR; THIS LETTER IS IN REFERENCE TO THE NOTICE WE RECEIVED ON THE ' PROPOSAL TO GRANT AN ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT TO ALLOW A � DETACHED SENIOR CITIZEN DWELLING UNIT FOR NHOUA CHUE � PROPERTY^ WE SERIOUSLY OPPOSE THIS PERMIT FOR THE FOLLOWING � ' REASONS. THE PARCEL IS ALREADY A LESS THAN 5 ACRE PIECE OF PROPERTY. THE PARCEL ALREADY CONTAINS ANEW HOUSE THAT WAS ' JUST BUILT. THE PARCEL STILL CONTAINS THE M08IUE HOME THAT WAS SUPPOSE TOBE REMOVED WHEN THE NEW HOUSE WAS SUILT° IF A SENIOR�CITIZEN DWELLING ISBUILT THEN � THERE WILL BE THREE () - -� DWELLINGS ONALESS THAN 5ACRE PARCEL. So THEN YOU WOULD ' HAVE A L5SSTHAN 8 ACRE PARCEL IN A A~10 ZONE WITH THREE DWELLINGS IN THE MIDDLE OF A AGRICULTURAL AREA~ WE ARE STILL ` TRVIN8 TO FARM IN THESE AREAS AND A MULTIPLE DWELLING PARCEL � MAKES IT VERY VERY DIFFICULT, SO FOR THOSE REASONS AND OTHERS 1 WE WOULD APPRECIATE YOUR ATTENTION TO THE REQUEST AND PLEASE DENY THE pERMIT~ 'THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME IN READING OUR LETTERli !.AO) When recorded mail i -.o: Butt(! County P1 nning 0 'I Col nty Centsr- Drive otov ille. CA 95965 I OWNER'S AFFIDAVIT RE SENIUR CITIZEN DWELLING UNIT (BUTTE COUNTY CODE SECTION 24-202) Property owner Minila Chlio Owner's Address 694 East 12th St., Chico, CA 95926 Administrative Permit Number 93-36 Property Address - 3195 Chico River Road, Chico, CA 95926 Property Des,.;tiption Attached as Exhibit "All It , owner of the above described property, do declare, that the Senior Dwelling unit on the property described above is now and shall be occupied solely by one (1) adult sixty-two (62) years of age or over or two (2) adults, one of whom is sixty-two (62) years of age or over. This affidavit, which shall be recorded at my request, shall constitute a covenant running with the land, binding upon me and my heirs, successors and assigns, and limiting the occupancy of the said senior citizen dwelling unit in accordance with Section 24-202 and as Ified above. specl 1 declare Under penalty of petjuty under the laws of the State Of California that the foregoing is true and correcti Executed this day of _ , 1993t at California. Signed STATE OF CAtIFORNIA COUNTY OF BUTTE on this day of in the year of i9 before me, th—ed-n—dersiqned, a Notary Public in and for said Sta:Ee, personally appeared personally known to 'me (or proved to me on the basis of satizf57c—tory evidence) to be the pdrsons(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the Within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same. WITNESS my hand and official seali Notary Public in and for said State, *Pj.2Vt491V%Ae41dR,A�F BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given by the Butte County Planning Commission that public hearings will be held on Thursday, October 14, 1993, in the Butte County Board of Supervisors' Room, County Administration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Orovilll(:�j California, regarding the following item at the following time: ITEM DETERMINED TO BE CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT FROM ENVIRONKENTALREVIEW 9:00 a.m. - NhoUa Chue - Administrative Permit to allow a senior citizen dwelling no larger than i2oo square feet for one or two persons age 62 years or over on property zoned A-10 (Agridultiara.l - 10 acre luce-tecl on the south LA.de of Chico River Road, appro'ximately 2�0 foat West of Crouch Avenue, at 3195 River Road, identified as AP 035-130"0241 Chico. (LPW) The above mentioned application and map are on file and available for public vie -wing at the office of the Butte County Planning Department, 7 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. I" you challenge the above applications *,-i court, you may be limiteA to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice or in written correspondence delivered to the Planning CotMi8Sibh, at or prior toj the public hearing. BUTTE COUXTV PLANNING COMMISSION PAULA Se LEASURt, PRINCIPAL PLANNER To be published 'in the Chico Enterprise Record on Thursday September 23� 1993. Count Department of Development Services PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONE: (916) 536-7601 September 7, 1993 Nhoua Chue 694 East 12th Street Chico, CA 95926 Re: Administrative Permit, AP 039-130-024 Dear Mr. Chae': On September 71 1993 the Director of Development Services reviewed and approved your request to allow a senior citizen dwelling on property zoned A-10 located at 3195 River Road subject to the following conditions: 1. The it living areal°, meaning the interior habitable floor space area of a dwelling unit including habitable basements and attics, but not including a garage or any accessory structure, shall: not exceed 10200 square feet. 2. The senior citizen dwelling unit shall be for the sole occupancy of one (1) adult o2 years of age or over or two (2) adult 'persons, one of whom is 62 years of age or over: An affidavit of compliance with the age requirements of this section shall be recorded in the office of the Recorder prior to issuance of building permits. Said affidavit shall include the legal dpsdription of the lot or parcel and shall constitute a covenant tanning with the land, binding upon the original owners and their heirs, successors and assigns, limiting the occupancy of the senior citizen dwelling unit to the conditions described in this section. senior citizen dwelling unit shall. not be sold as a se 0. Shpara to unit unless a parcel containing the unit is created in compliance with the existing zoning and subdivision ordinances and the resulting density is in conformance with the General. Plan. 4 Two off-street `parking spaces shall be provided for . the senior citizen dwelling unit in addition to the parking spaces required for the primary dwelling unit. ,.a 5. Adequate sewer and water facilities shall be provided subject to the approval of the Environmental Health Department. 6. All site development standards as required by the zoning district in which the unit is located shall be met. 7. The Senior Citizen Dwelling unit shall be a conventionally constructed building or a mobile home that complies with the National Manufactured Housing Construction and Safety Standards Act of 1974, except that in the "A", "FR", and "TM" series of cones a mobile home, as defined in Section 24-21.28, may be used. Travel trailers and recreational vehicles shall not be allowed as a senior Citizen Dwelling Unit. 8. Provide an all weather access for 40,000 lb. fire apparatus to all dwellings. 9. The approval of this permit constitutes approval only to the extent that the project complies with the Butte County Code and all other applicable regulations, 10. The requirements of all concerned governmental agencies having jurisdiction by law, including, but not limited to., the issuance of appropriate permits, shall be met. 11. Minor changes may be approved administratively by the Director of Development Services upon receipt of a substantiated written request by the applicant. Pr=ior to such approval,, verification shall be made by each Department or Division that the modification is consistent with the application, fees paid and environmental determination as condit.on"lly approved. Changes deemed to be major or significant is nature shall. require a formal application for amendment. Should you desire to appeal the Planning Director's decision or any of the conditions, you must do so in writing with the appeal fee of $290.00, to the Planning Department, 7 County Center Drive, groville, California, prior to 5:00 p.m., Wednesday, September 15, 1993. if you do not appeal and if there are no other appeal within the 8 -day appeal period, your Administrative Permit will be issued After September 15, 1993. Recently enacted legislation (AB 31580 Chapter 1706, Statutes of 1990, effective January 1, 1901) requires that the Department of Fish and cost impose and collect filing fees as specifiedtodefray the t of managing and protecting fish and wildlife trust resources. These filing fees are collected during the environmental rev-iew process and are to be paid at the time the County files a "Notice of Exemption" with the County Clerk pursuant to Section 21.152 of the Public Resources Code. To increase administrative dfficiencyj the statute delegated the collection of filing fees to the County Clerk and provided the County authority to collect a $25.00 documentary handling fee. The V^ fee due for your project is $25.00. A checks made payable to the Butte County Treasurer should be submitted to this department by September s0, 199j project applicants should be aware.Section 21089(b) of the Public' Resources code, provides that any projec4 approved under CEQA is not operative, vested, or final until the filing fees required under Section 711.4 of the Fish and Game Code are paid. Enclosed is the affidavit form you are required to complete, sign before a notary, record in the Office of the Butte County Recorder, and return a copy of the recorded affidavit to the Planning Division, Department of Development Services. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office. 5incerel , Wi iam Farrel rector of Development Services WFtbd Enclosure AGR2CULTUMU AFFIDAVIT .Y Fi1PLOYER, MMOi E Please read the followino'careful.Ly before signing: Section 24-21.2 Agriculture Employer/Employee (Applicab-le only in zones A:.3,•A-10, A-20, A-4.0 and. A-160) !' An individual who verified, by personal affidavit and by affidavit of his employer, that he is, or will be, employed at least thirty- two (32) 'hours per week ,for at least sixteen (16) weeks per year, or'that his primary source of annual income•is, or is anticipated. " to be, derived from, any of the following described occupations (a) The preparation, care and treatment of farm land, pipelines j or ditches, including leveling for agricultural purposes, plowing, discing and fertilizing the soil; 1 (b) The sowing and planting • of any agticultusal or horticultural ., commodity; Y' (c) The care of any agricultural or horticultural ,commodity. ; As used in this subdivision, "care" includes, but is not limited to, cultivation, irrigation, weed control., thinning, . heating, pruning, or tieing, uma,gati.ng., ..spraying and• dusting; ." (d) .The harvesting of any ,agricultural or horticultural, commodity including, but not lni.ted to, picking, cutting, thrashing, mowing, knocking off,,field chopping, bunching,, baling, balling field packing, and placing in field containers or in the ve- hicle in ;di ch the commodii7 will be hauled on the farm or to the place of first processing; e)' commod�. including, but not limited to, loading, rti.cvl.tura7 ..a ,�.The assembl and storage of a a ricultura� or hor it g � o dsiding, a ,r banking, stacking, binningg and pilin ; (f) The raising, feeding anal management of livestock, fur -bearing animals) fish, frogs. and other aquatic animals, and 'bees in- cluding, but not Limited to, herding, housing ha:,ching, milk -_'n shearitg, handling eggs and extracting honeys (g) The operation,conservati.on, improvement or maintenance of such farm and its tools and equipment r Employer noey h • _......,Phone_ P (Present) 3/1" �/� cGucv, c Em to er s Address Present Name of Owner LQU an /L-/,� i• � ALL=' �- Owner's Address3 /Sfi Owner's Assessor's Parcel No. %% �- 1.3 ~-��f Brad g/Environmental Healt Permit Description and Number 4(,Ao�= Date issued•-aj,�� By ` Planning Department Approval: Date l -'C��c,'�/ Zone 1, ''/V Dwelling 'on AP#_ ��.'� � l _ "' ,9 y By 5, %'1 Flo declare, subject to the penalty of perjury, that 1 am the employerer of Lox,- address (present) 319j- e#YCJ) la on AP#�--/3,;2- And that T will be employer under Sectio -x 24-21.2 Q- , 'r f'or at least (a) to g thirty-two (32) hours per weep for at least sixteen (16) weeps per year on. Signed AGRxCULTURAL AEFIDAITIT MiPL0YEE ,. Empl oyefe Phone+ r Employee's Address (Present) S/5C Name of 0�•mer Owner's Address- `' ` •owner's Assessor's Parcel NO - St-I&*-ironmental Health�'1 �' t Permit Description and. Numbzr Date Issued BY; ;"• Planning Department App-roval' { . Dwelling o ,. Daate / Ci -. - - , i By. , do. declare, a sub jest to the penaltyof perjury, that°'^I am"he employee of — �.. /.3—.2 address (present), L4 and, that 1 I will. be employed under Section 24-2'1.2�i �tog) nor at least a thirty-two (32) hours per week for at least sixteen (16) weeks per year on le(.) -:y signed Notice is hereby given that the Butte Cc+;nty PInnning Director is proposing to grant an Administrative Permit to allow a detached Senior Citizen dwelling unit for Nhoua Chue on property zoned A-10, identified as Assessors Parcel #039-130-024 located at 3195 Chico River Road, Chico. The permit may be granted subject to the following conditions: 1. The "living area", meaning the interior habitable floor space area of a dwelling unit including habitable basements and attics, but not including a garage or any accessory structure, shall not exceed 1,200 square feet, 2. The senior citizen dwelling unit shall be for the sole occupancy of one (1) adult 62 years of age or over or two (2)adult persons, one of whom is 62 years of age or over. An affidavit of compliance with the age requirements of this section shall be recorded' in the office of the Recorder prior to issuance of building permits. Said affidavit shall include the legal description of the lot or parcel and shall constitute a covenant running with the land, binding upon the original owners and their heirs, successors and assigns, limiting the occupancy of the senior citizen dwelling unit to the conditions described in this section. 3. The senior citizen dwelling unit shall not be sold as a separate unit unless a parcel containing the unit is created in compliance with the existing zoning and subdivision ordinances and the resulting density is in conformance with the General Plan, 4. Two off-street parking spaces shall be provided for the senior citizen dwelling unit in addition to the parking spaces required for the primary dwelling unit. 5. Adequate sewer and water facilities shall be provided subject to the approval of the Environmental Health Department. 6. All site development standards as required by the zoning district in which the unit is located shall be met, 7. The Senlor Citizen Dwelling Unit shall be a conventionally constructed building or a mobile home that complies with the National Manufactured Housing Construction and Safety Standards Act of 1974, except that in the "A", "FR", and 'TM" series of zones a mobile home, as defined in Section 24-21,28, may be used. Travel trailers and recreational vehicles shall not be allowed as a Senior Citizen Dwelling Unit. 8. Provide an all weather access for a 40,000 Ib, fire apparatus to all dwellings, 91 The approval of this permit constitutes approval only to the extent that the project complies with the Butte County Code and all other applicable regulations. 10. The requirements of all concerned governmental agencies having jurisdiction by law, including, but not limited to the issuance of appropriate permits, shall be met, 11. Minor changes may be approved administratively by the Director of Development Services upon receipt of a substantiated written request by the appficaht: Prior to such approval, verification shall be Made by each Department or Division that the modification Is consistent with the application, fees'paid and eh-Arohmer►tal determination as conditionally approved. Changes deemed to be major' or sighiffoant in nature shall require a formal application for amendment, Persons wishing to comment on the project may submit written comments to the Butte County Planning DepartMent any time prior to August 25, 1993. The Planning Director shall consider all comments in pp Y P determining if thea lication meets all of the above conditions and c"riterla. Upon finding that the proposed use does or will sleet ail of the cohditlons and criteria, the Planning Director may approve the request on a September ritten 1991 by $290,00, t he Bute County Development Services Director t submitting interested f the PI Vices Department at y County Center Dr,, OroVille, CA 55965 prior to 5:00 p.m. Thursday September 9, 1993, If you do hot appeal and if there are no other appeals within the 8 -day appeal period, your Administrative Permit will be issued `after September 9, 1993. 3 Nhoua Chue, AP 039-130-024, request to allow a detached senior Citizen dwelling unit or an appioximately 4 di,.e Pd:,6ei zo„ed A -1L yo.jat,ed at ',ID5 Calico River kodd. Mr. Sanders made a motion to recommend approval for the Administrative Permit to allow a Senior Citizen dwelling unit for Nhoua Chue on AP 039-1301-024 subject to the 11 conditions contained in the memo to the Development Review Committee. (1) The "living area", meaning the interior 'habitable floor space area of a dwelling unit including basements and attics, but not including a garage or any accessory structure, shall not exceed 1,200 square feet. (2) The senior citizen dwelling unit is intended for the sole occupancy of one (1) adult 62 years of age or over or two (2) adult persons; one of whom is 62 years of age or over. An affidavit of compliance with the Lige requirements of this section shall be recorded in the office of the Recorder prior to issuance of building permits, said affidavit shall include the legal descriptina of the lot or parcel and shall constitute a covenant running with the land, binding upon the original, owners and their heirs, successors and assigns, limiting the occupancy o! �}.e senior citizen dwelling unit to the conditions described in this section. (3) The senior citizen dwelling unit shall not be sold as a separate unit unless a parcel containing the unit is created in compliance with the existing zoning and subdivision ordinances and the resulting density is in conformance with the General Plan. . (4) Two off-street parking spaces shall be provided for the senior citizen. dwelling unit in addition to the parking spaces required for the primary dwelling unit. (5) Adequate sewer and water facilities shall be provided subject to the approval of the Environmental Health Department: (6) All site development standards as required by the zoning district in which the unit is located shall be met. (7') The Senior Citizen Dwelling unit shall be a conventionally constructed building or a mobile home that complies with the National Manufactured Housing Construction and Safety Standards Act of 1974, except that in the "A", "FR" and "TM" series of zones a mobile home, as defined in Section 241-21.28, may be used. Travel trailers and recreational vehicles shall not be allowed as a Senior Citizen Dwelling unit, (8) Provide an all weather access for a 40,000 lb. fire apparatus to all dwellings. (9) The approval of this permit cons ,.rte's approval only to the extent that the project complies with the Butte County Code and a)1 other applicable regulations. (10) The requirements of all concerned governmental agencies having jurisdiction by law, including but not limited to the issuance of appropriate permits, shall be met. (11) Minor changes may be approved administratively by the Director of Developments Services upon receipt of a substantiated written request by the applicant. Prior to such approval, verification shall be made by each Department or Division that the modification is consistent with the application, fee's paid and environmental determination as conditionally approved. Changes deemed BUTTE COUNTY DV8LCPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE MINUTES Administrative Use Permit AUGUST 9, 1508 11 d to be ma7o_ or significant in .nature shall require a formal application for, I amendment. rF" Motion seconded by Mr. Erickson and carried unanimously. 8bTTE COUNTY DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE MINUTES Administratiie Use Permit AUGUST 9, 1598 c r gutte com PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONE: (916) 538-7601 I! August 9, 1993 Nhoua Chue 694 East 12th Street Chico, CA 95926 Re: Administrative Permit, AP 039-130-024 Dear Ms. Chue; At the regular meeting of the Butte County Development Review Committee Veld August 9, 1993, your request for an Administrative Perinit to allowa senior citizen dwelling on property zoned A-10 located at 3195 River Road, was recommended for approval subject to the conditions listed on the atta&,CA .notice, Should you have any questions regarding this matter, I se contact this office, Sincerely, Paula S Leasure Assistant Director of Planning PSL lr BUTTE COUNTY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES IEP 7 CountyCe.� �"seq� Oroville, A. 9*e-'3'397""` 0 (916) .538-76 L 3 a V,,9 Calltot+ria Date JULY 15, 1993 ()Coyly$' To: CHICO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT RE- .Adrruxus:rative .Permit Review for: NHOUA CHUE AP#039-130-024 Enclosed is preliminary data our office has received or generated concerning the following project: TO ALLOW A SENIOR CITIMLDWBLLINC NO LARGER THAI The above project has been determined to be categorically exempt form environmental review under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. This department is reviewing the application for compliance with applicable County and State requirements, or restrictions that your department may have for this project. Please respond within 10 days of the above date. If no response is received within the 10 days, it shall be assumed that there are no concerns or requirements from your department. We appreciate any assistance you can provide. Sincerely, Larry Painter Planning "Technician Comments: Chico Unified School. District representatives have reviewed the information contained in this application and have determi ed. " a': he app ica .tion nas no averse Impar on D�str] C a t� es r4 JUL 16, Date JULY 15, 1993 ()Coyly$' To: CHICO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT RE- .Adrruxus:rative .Permit Review for: NHOUA CHUE AP#039-130-024 Enclosed is preliminary data our office has received or generated concerning the following project: TO ALLOW A SENIOR CITIMLDWBLLINC NO LARGER THAI The above project has been determined to be categorically exempt form environmental review under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. This department is reviewing the application for compliance with applicable County and State requirements, or restrictions that your department may have for this project. Please respond within 10 days of the above date. If no response is received within the 10 days, it shall be assumed that there are no concerns or requirements from your department. We appreciate any assistance you can provide. Sincerely, Larry Painter Planning "Technician Comments: Chico Unified School. District representatives have reviewed the information contained in this application and have determi ed. " a': he app ica .tion nas no averse Impar on D�str] C a t� es I.dcr-,Dopartmental Memorandum TO: Development Review Committee FROM: Planning Staff SUBJECT: Administrative Permit for Nhoua Chue, AP## 030 .30-024 DATE: July 26, 1993 This is a request for an Administrative Permit to allow a detached Senior Citizen Dwelling Unit on an approximately 4 acre parcel located at 3195 Chico River Road. The parcel is zoned A-10. The applicant proposes to place a mobile home on the property. The site meets all setback requirements for the zone. The project appears to meet all of the conditions required for a. 'Senior Citizen Dwelling Unit as listed in section 24-202 of the Butte County Code. The following conditions are recommended: (1) The "living area", meaning the interior habitable floor space area of a dwelling, unit including basements and attics, but not including a garage or any accessory structure, shall not exceed 1,200 sque.re feet. (2) The senior citizen dwelling unit is intended for the sole occupancy of one (1) adult 62 years of age or over or two (2) adult persons, one of whom is 62 years of age or over. An affidavit of compliance with the age requirements of this section shall be recorded in the office of the Recorder prior to issuance of building permits. Said affidavit shall include the legal description of the lot or parcel and shall constitute a covenant running with the land; binding upon the original owners and their heirs, successors and assigns, limiting the occupancy of the senior citizen dwelling unit to the conditions described in this section. (3) The senior, citizen dwelling unit shall not be sold as a separate unit unless a parcel containing the unit is created in compliance with the existing zoning anc; subdivision ordinances and the resulting density is in conformance with the General Plan, . (4) Two off-street parking spaces shall be provided for the senior citizen dwelling unit in addition to the parking spaces required for the primary dwelling unit. (5) Adequate sewer and water facilities shall be provided subject to the approval of the Environmental Health Department. (6) All site development standards as required by the zoningdistrict in which the unit is 'located shall be met, (7) The Senior Citizen Dwelling unit shall be a conventionally constructed, building or a mobile home that complies with the National Manufactured Housing Construction and Safety :Standards Act of 1974, except that in the -'W',. "FR", and "'I'M" series of zones a mobile homy as defined in Section 24-21.28, may be used. yJ Travel trailers and recreational vehicles shall not be allowed as a Senior Citizen Dwelling unit. (E) Provide an all, weather access for a 40,000 lb, fire apparatus to alt dwellings. (9) The approval of this permit constitutes approval only to the extent that the project complies with the Butte County Code and all other ,applicable regulations. (10) The requirements of all concerned governmental agencies having jurisdiction by law, including but not limited to the issuance of appropriate permits, shall be mete (11) Minor changes may be approved administratively by the Director of Developments Services upon receipt of a substantiate,E': written ,request by the applicant, Prior to such approval, verification shall be made by each Department or Division that the modification is consistent with the application, fees paid and environmental determination as conditionally approved. Changes deemed to be major or significant in nature shall require a formal application for amendment. LPW:jlO Jui3 26, 1993 Nhoua Chue 694 East 12th Street Chico, CA 95926 q ffutte t Department of Development Services PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONE. (918) 538-7601 Re; Administrative Permit, AP #039-130-024 Dear Ms: Chue: Your request will be considered at the regular meeting of the Development Review Committee on August 9, 1993. The meeting will he held in the Development Services conference room at 7 County Center Drive, Oroville, California, and is scheduled to begin at 1:15 p.m, The report of the Development Review Committee members, including any recommended conditir ns of approval, shall be forwarded to the Planning Director prior to the Director's decision on the application. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office, Sincerelyy, Ar , A6 Lisa Purvis Wilson Assistant Planner LFW*jio Manning Depaotneni JUL Z 61993 BUTTE COUNTY DEVELOPNMNT SERVICES DEPARTMENT"� �jEi �` Iitclrn�? 7 Couaty Center Drive J U L 115 X99 01 Oroville,; CA. 95965-3397 (916) 538-7601 OrOVIN-, ; li;t�rnid Date: JULY 15, 1993 Toi ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH RE: Administrative 3tler nit Review for; NHOUA CRUE AP#039-130-024 Ane.1med is nreliminary data our office has recei, 'd or generated concerning the The above project :has been determined to be categorically exempt form environmental review under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. This department is reviewing the application for compliance with appli,able County and State requirements, or restrictions that your department may have for this project. Please respond within 10 days of the above date. If no response is received within he 10 days, it shall be assumed that there are no concerns or requirements from your department. We appreciate any assistance you can provide. Sincerely, Larry Painter Planning Technician BUTTE COUNTY DEVELOPMENT SEI:VICES DEPARTMENT 7 County Center Di"J nnln ,1 Oroville, CA.. 95965-3397 OftI;v+rr.o (916) 533-7601 '1 UL 21 1993 Date:_ JULY 15, 1993U mvllle, Q11110rhw, To: COUNTY FIRE DEPT/CDF RE: Administrative Permit Review for: IoTfIOUA CH.UE AP#C^9-130-024 Enclosed is preliminary data our office has received or generated concerning the following project: TO ALLOW A SENIOR CITIZEN DWELLING NO LARGER THAN 1.nn sn_ ter. FOR 1 OR 2 PERSONS AGE 62 OR OYER. APROX ,4 ACRES. ON OF CROUCH AVENUE.— The above project has been determined to be categorically exempt form environmental review under the provisions of the Califoinia Environmental Quality Act, This department is reviewing the application for compliance with applicable County and State requirements, or restrictions that your department may have for this project. Please respond within 10 days of the ebove date. If no response is received within the 10 days, it shall be assumed that there are no concerns or requirements from your department. We appreciate any assistance you can provide. `'incerely, �iy Painter Planning Technician Comments: o A� 4 .i "' W r�S psU"i"I'L COUNTY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT 7 County Center Drive .Oroville, CA. 95965-3397��„ (916) 538-7601 y . JAL A Date; JULY 15, 1993 0'"01111,;,, To. PUBLIC WORKS RE: Admin strative - Perra Review for: NHOUA CHU AP#039-130-024 Enclosed is preliminary data our office has received or generated concerning the The above project has been determined to be categorically exempt form environmental review under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. This department is reviewing thy; application for compliance with applicable County and State requirements, or restrictions that your department, may have for this project. Please respond within 10 days of the above date. If no response is received within the 10 days, it shall be assumed that there are no concerns or requirements from your department. We appreciate any assistance you can provide. Sincerely, Larry Painter Planning. Technician Comments A-14 �r . \ 1of - r *vOI v /' qr i' \�\ �r • o �+ ai Nw r 0 to V O APV 7-7r W H/z -®ns Arroyo wAFoP -4e 1 �.,.:,7t1l tl�t�i 1IF �!►il ��il F�� , �,1,1��f.�� . �.�. .�.,. i. .►. �. �. i i.. .� i i i. nnsa Imov iii F f t_ INFINITY SERIES r YN: aQ D_ _ DINING HOOKCAsr Loll 23 , T--Tr�l MASTER'' iIVING' 004f DEDROOXI I t7•_ c? t2'-9" I f Ir 1 .. - ab - IL r .iced BEDROOdf f` y 70J�f - 9' , 'd 1 9.69Ac LcA-` JOHN CROUCH SUB:, M O fR: 8k 6 Py. 81 e COUNTY OF BUTTE 7 s — DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES' Q •fi ... egg: f�.S.�Ist.T.�4 PLANNING DIVISION SE�Eo S� f zf 1i 2 4 7 Gc" .y Dave �.+,iHS , -"7rc, a,. GA 95965-3397 Nhoua Chue. 654 E ---,t 12th Street, Chico, CA 959 a t� Planning Dc-parlmiant SEP 2 O° 199 QravirrZ, ca fi;zraia �Sk�EdElf�t�fillEfi3tf�1EElSiiE� - c r -;.---�� Form JUI I r ti v SENDERS � 9-CompleteHome t anafor 2 for additional services. w Complete ltenrS 3. and 4a a b. �tiGnr C 1 also wish ta-11-11f✓''�f .r-"" #tlliowtra sorvic©s„t�or.arket<UB.-�'" „ , prtht Your hamo end oddra§9 oil the towso of Ill r ug o ton m return this card to you, r� i%i foo . — -� 1 .- �- N t 4 Attach this (Orin to the front of the mallplaco, r .n" iAk If v141 e - t' Addresst;Ws dr7ress , doge hot OtninIt,1 r + Wtho" Roturr Rooulptnequestad"onthe nlallplato 01. t numhai. t " • The hatWn Rucalpt will' to Wham the articin was dclpyk od and the nate Res r ad De1lVery allow c aanvataa. Cohaulc postmoster for fee,. k d 3, Atticle Addressood 4a. Article Number ]to, / -7 7 41 /� �,/ _ } b n qq,S 7" L: f C l Soy F� 4b. Servieo Type CI Reg(siered l (hsurod o I Z ,'/n� )�+ 1 co) gJrq Cortipod l COD El Express Mail [ Aeturn Reoe(pt for y 1 Q .►-t p o.o n o. 0 7. pate of Delivery ') jd , z °C 8 n tur ( ddrossoo) S. Addressee's Address (Only it requosted end foo Is pa(dl M ¢ 6. Slgnetutu (Agoht) Form JUI I r w-. i UNITED STATES POSTAL SER?ACE i, Official Business PENALTY Pon PRIVATE { } USE TO AVOID PAVEtdT { oElf POSTAGE; $300 l Print your name, address and ZIP Cale here a COUNTY OF BUTTE } N411MIng DaPArtmant r 7 CoUnly Center Drive I Orovlllo, CA 95965.w o3q, 13o- OZ� ry