Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout039-460-040h .� rA"� ' t ' , � � � I . r � I • �' j. o 1 � � �,. , i en 'I. k 1 'a �` y � �' ' 6��,: <-fey' � �� e,. �, � � � F1 .F. ti ��: tiy% � � .-a - � . , . :p � r • �s ' � �� .. �3: � � � 4 t Q , � . � .� . A. W, • a A. h .� &41 bEPARTMENT OP PUOLIC WORKS WILLIAM (03111) CHC -Or, Director 7 COUNTY CCNT ER DNIYC - OROVILLC, CALIPORNIA 95965 Tdephrjrjr1916) 514.46el RONALD 0, McaLRoy Buffo Co. pfanntm; ca"m Deputy 01tecfae FEB 24 1987 F(-,bruury 24, joij-1 Or*V'110i CaUfOM14 Joon 1,1,arsh RE: All 39-46-40 P, 0. Box 647 TPM Durlim, CA 95938 Otmr Ms, Harsh: AL 11-10 regular meeting or Lhe Butte CounLy Advisory Agency field On February 23, 1987i the agency gi*8nted a 36 months ext'Onsion of time In which to file the Final map for the abovo-reterencod property, 0,'?Pivation Will be February 25, 1990, if no nppoals -re filed—withih fifteen (15) (lays of the date of the Advisory Agency., action--wiO the Clerk of the Boord Of Supervisors, with tho appropi . to appeal fee, tit's Action will be finial , If You have any questions regarding this matter, PIVIse contact this offico, Very truly yours, William Choir Director e)r Public Works IJnMeindonsnl Dfroctor JM/ds cc! Planning Department rnviromnontal lietllth DON.Irtttionf; NorLhStnr Engineering NO -LACE OF DETERMINATIONO 'I"CDr Office of Planning and Research FROM: r1a" 'P,.1% yap tme 1400` 'Tenth Street, Room 12,1 7 C , t erit.L��c U ve Sacramento, CA 95814 oro ii1.(!, CA 95965 or h!7`, _ County Clerk County of BunteELEANOR iZ���C«�kCounly Cie.rk SUM -CT: Filing of Notice: of beteeminatxon in compliance with �ac�imn �211�a3�c►r-��1�1�2. of the Public Resources Code, ro ject Title Tentative Pareal. clap AP 39-46-40. Joan Marah te Clearing use se Nurnber Contact Person 7'elcp lone taho f submitted to Clearinghouse John. Mehdottsao Public Works (91.6) 534-4266 ue o ,the west side of Holland Avenue � � jest Location $0q r-aet south of t11c. intersection ot: Durhsm-Da 'tion t-li IAWY aai�tt t•Igl,l.an , � Project 1cripticn Tdntative Parcel Map dividit g 46 acres into four parcels, 28.7 acx'es, 6.�- across 5 $ noes and 5.3 acres ---- This Is to adviso that the > Utta, _County Advisory ncy �w:t li���~.: .. i. arucxa�iniLalw AN�iti M.I •. W appedved the above described prosect and has made the following cfeterminat one m-gaeding t1r_ above described projects 1. The project wlil, 4 will not, have a significant effect on the OnVirorirntht. An EnvlrtyrrrrienttFzi 1trt act keport was prepared for this projoat pursUar►t 2 to the provisions of CEQA. A Negative Derlarat on was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of UQA. Tt�m 9IR or Negative Qetlaratior► and rec6cd of project appro l may be exanilht'�d at; 1. . 3, Mitigatle)h trieastiros , were, �L VI ere not; made a Ohditimi of the approval of the pr6ject. 4A statement of overelding `:ohgldt✓raflahs was, .� was not, adopted for this project. Tate Received' for Piling Sign6ttOre 5taphen A Streeter t�i fi ��.� ��'Vi��d 0ar1Lt8t"�► 1983 ouftA4 L A W D r N, A t IJ A, L WrA t I T Y 41 WtPAPTNIPENT OF, PUbLIC WbU$ WILLIAM mm) 7 COUNTY CtNTPR DRIYC - OROVILLP, CALIFORP41A 05165 016) 534,4M C,�4 Plahning C*^ FObrUary 250 , Oepuly bltobiot Joan Marsh �aoldrrm RE: AP 89-46-40 8ox 647 C Tentative pa�rooj tqalj. OLlehatnj CIA 55938 boat m8i Marsht At the regular moebing, of the 8utto County Advisory Aqoncy hejd Vebruary 25, 1585, the Agondy adopted the hogabivL- detlatabion rdgatdi,hig ohVilCOnmental review and,appeoved the Tentative parcel 1 Mal) tot AP,39�46-40 subject to bhe00hd1 't110h8 A8 listod on the attached thdeLi It no appeals are tiffielY .tiled—vithin. ton (10) d4Y5 of the date of, Lho Advisory Agency's approval --With the Clerk of the board of Supervisors, this action Will be final. When the dotidi.tjohg of approval. are . 'M I'm . co plied With, it Will be Order for you to file Your. "filial Map" With the SutL-e County ud bopatent of Public Work8 for eecordabiort within hwenty-fou,e (24) 'tOhtho of the date of approval by the Advisory Agency, If YOU should have any qUe:5bions regarditig Lhig Matter,, pjo,ase d0htaob this office, very truly yours, Willialb Chett Director of Publid Works LTO m n 0 n q a im tds Assistant Ntodtoe Attadlittl0lit Pl Ming - 8nvirbhfflbHLCAj Revllelt4 8hVirohmotbal Health b0p6rbitotit Northst-ar 8,h(jin(,50tihg r Joan Mar8h r TOntaLi veParcel Rapt 4 paresps ♦oUot� srrLt: t;kis in eaw ectaot � urltam�DayLQn, '4i9,hway 6hd 110114fid AVO -6:1 tail the west~ side of Hrlland Avo., d'owh a short dr:ivowtry. Durhath art AP X9-46-40' gnginoert. NOeLhShar 1 n � neexLn Public works Contiit%an; I. provi.,do two-way ir.raveeoabjo access gS g8_Lb_1 to cc t rl°M a County maihtiftl ed road or state highway, jc cr AccoSs to, be r6801rvCd i -n doedg, an Y Cr'unl,y o:6fer:ed tb dedicatri.on ort the final mar) -,r r l rtt3tice and. Show 50 911t building setMba k line rnoa:jurod >±,rortr C�rrrt�erli acaoono s eascmoht# proVide t"Oeld rnai.rits0h4hdo ardreolt'rontt Show all easOmOhtas of record on the f.inal ttrajr . 6. Provide street namo signs per r�egttiremcnrrs or Qt:hc bo artmeti Public Worttis lia r t:o recoedation of Lho :Ci na'i, t1ta K 7'. Obtain ohdmachrttoht Virr'rAiL aria cor gLeuot standard toad. a0e66 11 tiraviding aduquat,o 8ighb ditt;andd at thL i iiborsoLbioh, OE addeso road' :rnd Rbli and Avenue 8* pay any ddlinquentr t;axee of current: t Axed as regtfirod Planning r:or(]i.tion: 5 brankhouse and butbu tIdjhg8 hot approvod Eft rerai,den-tiai, U800 H'061th boparLmohb dondit:ionst 104'provide a loo Et, i0achEi0td fruo set baa at~ourrrt o�is�a rr wells eltthor within the nropert~y or within lOt� t t>� o� hke property boundaeid§ 114 Locate and, it nedossary, rei,c�ca e bho sowatfr cr,is . b8al, sy kern: 90tVing the c�t�sti nrj dwolling onto Its res�ect:ivcr ,parer Nnter»Deportmental Memorandum w . ;butte County Ad fisovy AgOACY sr; plannjug 'Director Roport on "io ttrxtiVu Pftfcel Mdll Of Joan Akaysit (in AP 59-46-40 Vabruwryll)198S 'I'Stis, is a proposal to, divide 40 acres ,into el The iv,t,e.gen w tblg, is A—S. The Land Use ,Plan Map (''ho Butto County GeAdr l Plan, dd8ipatog ti is area a's Ctvehtxd! tMield Crop°k'i1,ot°o �ta�a no �����ai ��� or comrt��1ttit Ott" * I )!V, thO ` he prokloaaI dOOS !lot eO--PlICt wItkt COuftty ���tin�� nor 4Aadopted or PTOpased CIODI Ilt �� fire �tit'tt� C,c�ttri%y Ia#t nor any Count j specific or Community 'plan itecttmffiet.d apptow"I.1 subject to the f6llowittg+ 0011 itteft: Boni house tm66 outbuildlitigg not txPPIIbvdd, fOl' regIdontSai, use L17ss I y q 77777 ,a• t ��li"a`k n ST ka NOy'4��'r?q iWf k M k Allf tk 390 6 +14& A M' iUN� � r � f P�� w jj a �k��rty�°k � ! _�y:� l�l�,i�tx�. ��k,�kyy� �,�. yppgt oyy p 1� p trsy� �g . ':. � � � tkl oa Ir�F w � Does . �s>+�akk����a�� iil�ii rea �. k t�it�Y t� olli l I xw�i�ttra�a kt tlrlIliS edids WHO elu 110 01 ltv�.;rtr°�" � droll, Ii 0 wildlife ; t si 116.0 Stunt or gusta,julng Metal; IIMM � nlii;Ulf, "i� i�:���4i�� ��fC9 animal a"fiafliJ�kr����r�Y ��tf'Yl tik��'.'�wed ���+an '01 O��,'�malrJrjge �y C,lpiryCyfii�lte {��6��rOT'�§�y,t�ty c���cCJt���t kutt, {cFrCp {�ty�y�n� Apr ���+t'�.�rc�� e +r its�C��ar��t��tr u z�1 e. Ca Protect lr., ca� l ng - t it�i#iWi trttlYttattY�a#tt1 °� to t���l��� tcrsr���lc ait".f���tt ��+ ��ian tr impacts Will *rtime while J h toit IC&' pat ysl Mute 1.1tto g, P009 ., w.w' + a Y � y 't,Fi Proj ally. l Cw ll d but G��t UIRST " t Y lr t" a �t a�tt k � lsruji�t�At RtY 1�1lrrYu but vw r kY, Cdr rr' tlra total of A is the ,It�Y; "it anti; eda�kt fi���r.t���a it mail the _ �atr�°C; t�rat�tttrr+�t t kY,+[vrt; i �axrr:i iii � ii kC,.. noun the v+^�s�g�atc t i Yi a � �liii i aY aktll+9 se WOW 1����G � � k�lr WON rvt cwtt t; w a r 1itrCki c hIV tai t'k� lea: � a r tirCrC w'r��l by thu Wd A900'�� 011 the hogla 01 tht� klkCtY«r'C, ��t�CrtE���aa�a: MUD th PtwzardbraACmfutT�ltPA1 S 01 '1 �tt�e�A+�Y4 ca PpoJect could # Ci l kw ��v'uCIS ogm�ittk� C. lSI tin Y ...k . t i sv the In effect Irl th't-4 camebee 10 �+�.� kxckr:f��tl tkr Ike 'a't� CiC�tC i�kvcaat� have lx a�' Ctk?t l.a ul k ty will 1rt" rr� att°a ( u tlw t t liitC t1Ycw pr�o��'�r.r��;ed lit"�h�� � MAI have C��xla�it',�i�;�l��������i���lt������ t, C. ;.11r aYMy�, l; tiyS11 �"k+kk'Nfi thy. r,� 0 r°�aiY7t1a�U1t C � inima`k-m.t",; 41 �,rF—«•...,1...,�a':uk.:'r.ww."""�=tet a rr� ,I i we ➢�� r'i 77 IV TL yw M "4nd, oloxy6ico .Lo tt" Otto atw' f Itb I itfigd tot� ", ' O uo 0 I fir N t, b�ylyfar �� t. �r..��' �+$ 4*a""1. �4 3k i��Ak� � iY,�rw'.:1• '�7!'�4d i,�.:.!SAC ���:j� .�w �, y t, t a u4*=* ch 1 th ea ah Orr b M,I tioft d'o 't Which thli 41.144 i Of or #vrodj b Intlat a r lad t ole � + + NI .+a ty t 0, 16011,11641'e" 'vc At MIS T' ot t► off', t� the10 +'` [ on aw o b'4° F7 "fi V"itkAIN'w'7� leii►.t.i ki+4+oi'✓:"� 4 jj 01 ROMA r off'-wWultw t'uffdeVa 1 Ls a- ' Of 'i0" I b i d u d lids' .eft ay wu tdit' b6dy- ��t� Tf�%��� idtt;"g OT111Ott »: ���a ot ae voter 4,lOaii kyr v bicludift I oot m tt o,""� w Itity t d vt y tax' ti TO ugh he affidUlt le oa "�'� p Of ity Oil ' a 0 yy�,y{�j rte/ �",J. A i P n I i i I YM NO cha . 0 I the , ers ��� '��� +�# a• 4 0 I, r i�e f ft ;^ u, 'I 0, ..i :II!1 lot rWA {py�' "� y'7y �r��}y � p� g� �y #�lF a'�+I�yf.��!Fri w�ig,l�T 1' kyg4„��,1 {Y� at I ` ice, p� y�,r� �9P' k4 ki',7.�kuAG �Y+ I,"W'7' fid, �,n4C 7,iFl� IkdS�"F,`. r i go �$nny�y j�( �({yy{(� ,yp. Rqr YI ., ng I..'pry,011 JN M`+*+ 4�iFrFd�iAho a�Ei>Y�el.y . }w r SfvyN b.0 b'ductiolo, ,�^ �d '}h`�'� O .,_n};.i• �.. of� Ado spo'.os -m ll awl+ � �F �Alft{I � IA' M O t" d {,Y lyPiyi�'M gyp{,` �py�� yq��� M+� I'ii '4fl %;Y Y4ilL �... wx Ifts �'q{�ry'p����'��u`'� 'y V;I: 4•eW'+rtl!^yvc�4Ir1�.�I,[,��1@{1� Y �'�¢dp �4F�l '��1,�1y����,�c�fyn �47�"g'G�4ri �h ',k ��y}pf•�'1p'p66„�����MjMy. - � I 1 "�pY�� ��,r`�,I$'(,�{���tlx. Maj '. .., ��,y,+ ■�{ I{'�.� 1yywy �'�'jYjj��' �Iy�. �y ��'yy, ¢p ���y5� ��yp. ♦�^���1q�, i thali I• *� �py��j aid a 4� •rW'h3d�.�.4u^ 'tit tastt�Rfeta - �W filAw" l FW . e I1�K!<it��..ii'ji + ^ plj�yd{'(YeMuV'b/�iY'�: ttry� �u`�5 S,�g;'��]y1' � }g� � y}Y �}1. j��j .{g�' f��} {1j�!�} I'��vy�� '��ryy�7j`. ���yy �yJ,4:41 �A'�.�I 4'FJ f•'M �RV 1%M�+•tRr4 i �S' �•,IYFA�� j i y, III�.,Iy��yy�y^, ��+.�j 4S ,h!' 4�' M 'K rH fty" ..'�j}��y i s� yy ,{y, y � 3'r r '.•.,.v. N :.. j y�q]1 ,�lp'� yyy� {� y[yq�}, ,}�+^F �ny� �,Ly� w•TIAi Sl,AO�'' M1�VW'+4Y "TlYW , r ft1K 'A V N' X14 ` 6 4116ft, Hwy 6 of ft 0" 1 a 'h]}offi*cdyl{l.d l '. W♦r W��fsi,a �dfpSW WOft,TI# With,,A;gWb t Will, did, pvo-pd 1`� t'hf I std 5{�t h4n 11,0 tS Will 06, Pt,6068 m ' I 1 S�!Aw _`�I Ply r � 'MI �I �MWEi'�tK'iNG91iM .. iiyy7,'''��y#ys�luKl t �]�'j�.�L, IF M,W (p,JI�,K'[`d�' (�gy 'y��^;�, Y�,y�� ygh�ypq '�'� 5y!{�I �'(�,!yq$r$� hdMOIM �,rl" 1 ft MS' ul �M,M �'�F YMI 'X'[N'JP ' V 49' L. of ) . I J. 1 l�� yf ;cy116h.41 4 I ill 4W I'll KIWI •I� W lyy7r,p yyip Fy IHN, J 49u AM"iT*11Kh 'M "INWnqdo,0¢ dfsRYp, Myu¢( ft (�IWRif-4,06ftstoef1"I: t fail of air yg�(�{�! yry7 §�I/���} �4 �j$ �j ': ^II"F s3K'il iF iul IMiR X' 4F PG ' 'µN 1M 'k'14' m1'�tiA. �W ''Wi.4✓iA K�+K'rJUC WWN�" +p t., y3�7, {g�+�''��44vv�ypl+�, I��y,ycy�� ;�qKI�M � � d1W 'Ik tt;�I+X` i F' *�� ' 'T+r M' rif IIN c�.' 0111 ltt;"YsIJR.tat 0. di i�g4� rt+A ,��yyC��:ARR1k yjtA�,l�4d"I 74'A_ �p G � to, tottloy�S✓; 1C�3UNWWWWA I 4AU04 tow" (Kygry yqµ�' �1P f O +YYJCO 'Jb, lwl lir4Jp eni'do,Y full M �' ��-,-•� A {}�l� ; y���,f?'i'+p��':'�ry* ,u�uf ley xs■■ i�$+'�f��y�?11�' ,�i��,'pryu��yy��!��j� �y�y ��}ru�u ��{{pp�lp�"I jjAA��,,II `� .n1�1,y rid, 4ypy�,�q`{W�"+{V1u�+M1�Kl�,r � F�G"1wY �j 11kYG'ii44nuY4V:T � �iF'Arl� .. 'II{K"{�i+*uYv e m a {��u pry$, v �elpw t Will e, krre u y�fyn y�+L� p 4 11 K& lot � e ` rg $1 % �4 i And or ,. 1"�'i�Fx�.?� I Wi - 4"�i`Y'}�, di.L.i}�¢.. '�'.. mux+ .y yy .{� { 4, 1�4� o 1 GW'$y�411��+y'!µ�,jp .. `'�`iy�,dyit�yi, ,fry.�pi y U.yg� + '4�' yC7 ;'A�Lf FYf 'rif W. CQYPRr'7't! f t!J4�`.g"16 L&.::I d, �k+ybra Cri+�4�"IMF `4u � the �,6wtlr i SA; uraIA pM1 halfiu ay: � f.� 'Qy�r�dy �yp��I'�4��M1��,tt'�JI�I}, g 1114�If'.I{[+�yfP�f"pd IL"I.�� ICLj[p�4�di,{�y.�,'� !t�y�^'4.�� 4�{�`'.. `�fp. �ji ��{}.�jWWt W �'M+jII i. 1M 1"i V '�O��r3� W 5TRUNF!i!MWI �YF �rf�y� y��+" `00 ,ML 'R ��VII �t 1 G��yyi��rt{� 1. �y, ,p�'�.+'''11�cM1V'- �a fl, d wd F e, "hT • �, I a "K, J r rt Cli'. �'Wn�,7.��W � J,lWilti the t"'dj 'It��ryp�'�7y;`'� �(q, �1��g ��yQ� .R44�%' 4i JF �OA'���r�L�.. h,ekaithlo Y Jf. 'U f � Y� wM!1 p6 O i the ivi+- the h y Bit any 'git# ivp� �y7if �yy},�� yyti"),W111th r. I 1 I � IIS f l :..� , cor t�.. l fiUor s fe' 'the pron " a ifk u"A'4„t� i"s f'��S1�.k `:;��"� `'r ' b3op grip prap� Mawr07 tajtct'� e"'Moge Midi to, fild ra grit'b1ja,m� , tai valt S or trw M1 r AP 39-46-40 1b.- rurther compaction of the soil surface will result -From deVOOPment of 2 or 3 additional homesites. Ig; The orchard is located on Vina loam, a Prime agricultural soi'14. Durham is not a deslq.natOd urban area, though it has a def inite community csm' er. This property appears to be within tho community ceni'vr. 3b I t:,. A CUIvQ-rt under the existing access road is smashed and in need Of tcPlaceMenk. The problem is a common one up and down this street, rendorinq the drainage system ine+festi ve. A,a, d --, U; I I a - The Marsh ranch has been well taken care of over the yorlr+54 The trees are healthy and the property' well I -opt. '03prcval of this map will Split Lip what appears to be -a Profitable rant �n prime ag soils. More than 36 trees will be removed and.: repj,-AcL-Lj 'raydwel I i ngs . Forty acres can provide primary income for a 4'mily, Parcel!a of 5 and 21() acres are not economically viable for -c-arming. The result Of this map will be the removal of 46 acres frnm prodtAction. 12: OevolOpment activities on this parcel will affect all adJact?nt residences to a slight degree. The two houses which share access with the rallLh will be affected by increased traffic. IZc: The driveway off Holland Avonue is +/- 15 feet Pavement in good condition. At the entrance to this ranch, it narrows to 8-10 feet,. Very little improvements will be needed to bring the road up to standard. 14: Demands fear all governmental services will incl ease as a result of the new homes, Given Close PrOvimitY to town, the impacts are hot individually significant. 20a -. Butte COUMLY Maps indicate the sitc, may Contain archaeological resources. Plafltinq of th- orchat-d and con%trur-tion of the road, rv5idenco, and outbuildin,,s have altered the sr3j, Surface. Therefore, CA StArVOY will not be rcMuired. Appendix V Page 6 a Applicant: Joan Marsh Assessor's Parcel 0 Log # 84-12-14-01 1, Typo of Project, Tentative Parcel Map 2. Brief DescriptiL-; Tentative Parcel Mapdividi.ttq 46 acres. into four parcels, , 28,7 acroz, 6.9 acresi 5.8 act us, and acres. 3. Location: 1300 -Feet south of the intor%ectirin o+ DU-ham-DaYtOn 1'Uhway and Hol hand Avenue, on the west side of., Holland Avenue - an interior parcel. 4. Proposed Density 0+ Development: I dwelling unit per parcel 5. Amount of lm:r.,rvious Surfacing: - u. Access and Nearest Public Road(O'. Holland Road access from 60 +Oat easement 7, Method of Sewage Disposc-AIA SVI)t i C G. Source of Water Supply: individual wells 9. Pra,-limity of Power Limes: To original parcel jo. potential for further land diviziarts and development"., Zoning permits 5 acre parcels 1. Terrain a. Bonoral rapagr,,Aphit: Character- LevOl valley laild b. Slopes: 0-3% C. C-lovation; +/- 152 feet AGL d. 1,Amiting f=actors: None 2. GC14 a. It, Types and Characteristics;, Vina loamt deep, well draining soil. A prime agricultural soil well suited to, growing 0. wide rarigo of crtiPs,- bo Limiting V-actot­G; None 3,, Nati-irixi Ilazards of the Land a;, L-,.arthquake Zahot Zone VIII moderate hazard b,. Erosion Potential-. Slir#lt C:. Landsli,do Potential., None d, Fire Hazard: Unclassified o. Expartsivo Soil Potential: ModerAtu Appendix F (a) n 4. fin /, Ali 39-460 Hyt Ir (11 ogy nX., Surface Waturi Outte Creek 1 1/2 miles east: b. Ground Water: Ukkerlies area of heavy groundwater withdrawal c. Drainage Characteristics: ri. Annual Raj" -fall (normal)-. 22 - 24 inaho5 0. Limiting factors Visual/Sconic Duality% Acoustic Quality -Good, sporodic trains along SoutViorn r, it ; ' � +iaRai9 lroad . "nEr*ate n0iG* I uvel m o+ 54, r1b. i t Quality.* Good pip I ouL c Vogetatjoot Almond orchard G)ildjife 1-iabitat'. Small mammals 1 common exotic birds, no I,*,,nown rare or endangered zpetius- 10. Archaeologiral and 14"3tOr"'Al F<ne'ourcez in the A" e #A- rrHigh DttttM ,Ur-tvraj Plan designationt Orchard 6Md Field Cr a p n 12. L"', i st i n g Z on i - q ter rtosidvnce, barn, bunkhousoq sheds,E�tistinq Land Use on-- 3i almond orchard. Surrounding ArOal a. Land Uses: Single -family re%id2�nticA north and east, almond Orchards SR­ij C. -C b, Zoni Mq t A.-51 A' - V() I - Gonr Plan dell ohations: Orchard and Field Crops, Low Den, :ty Rmsid-entiali Commercial d Parcel 9-ites.' 1/3 acre to north and east, 50 acl-U&S + to south and west e. pbpul ati on% Low donZitY 5. Char actel" �3+ site clod Areat - 6. NeareEit Urban Ares:": Chico +/__ fa miles north, Durham immediately east 17. Ralavant Spheres 0+ ln+lu011Ce-- ,a. jmpr;ovements Standards Urban N/0 1,9. Fire Protection Service; St at -i wi *4b a. Nearo immediatolY east b. Water Avallabilityk. 20 h Schooln in Areal. Mirham Unified Appeftd,ix V (b)