Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
056-280-033
.. �t{1 .a. ik • .. . ,. �' ,,4I ff ... t o. r i .. Y ., ! x.-.. d.. ..... :. .. , ,, ... .,. i . V . ... r. rr � n.,.. , .... � e „ .... Y % t .. .•. ,. [ � 4 Y � ... .. r r. r. 1 , .: n 17. r. n...t .. �,. r .. ..n r, ,. ... �,! t. . � ,,. � b,. �w. .•,. P f � _Y. ,. -%. Y .•. .,.. �4. :.d ..... rc, 1.1.. .4': ,J. h ,. r., .. 7. a ,. ,. a. ,t , � r+.: __ .J h ..,:, -. ,. 5 ,9.E, �.�, ! •r Yi•,. :i I,rv,':. ,7 �P"' r - # .1 r ,,,_; . t . ,..a•. t,. �` ,i u � �, i ,� .. L .. ,7,. `Z �.. Y n -, .. ,. ,- 4, � r. , • ::. ,',ai'. w ,� ). {, .a �I .• R ,yo-- .. . .. .n. .- �, u. , .,�. _� -, C 77 5, ., .. n:' , :,. .. ,r+ .� ., e .. , �.';. ,,": '.r i / �'':1. \_.. w a: .) ,-., _ {{ �.' ,. .. �.. • .,. V,. �\..,'�,ydi51 Lv1� S_.h : *.t_1, .., .r,i .S i4 x ' -•ttf, J >J 1`£r.s:�9.7,,y`.M., .,',. �,.f .r,Aw�r'..s`.ln.1 ..-.', h,.Y0...,..�.......,:,K,, kC '�..,r .r .. Q 9 r t,i ..,, . ,.,.. r 1. , ,, ti�rh}:...,�i,,.. ,��.,;,.i',.. �,> ,u._�r. . .},.'r.' . .P4i... .r.e.� ... A w. . ..r ,,f�,.. -,., ',..r� r. , -srr,. .:..'.:,.,, ..... ..�tr,.,,fr,.u_.,, ,.,y.,.i -i,. .:. ,tte� z 'ia .,...r.r.��...,._ :......,,�.�, . r.. . . �,. .,. r. t,,�r�.,�,,.,i, ..... .-_�n•J... x, . .,,xM.,,,1r 7a��Rw_., . �.l.r rPbt�..:,.< _&... r .e.� . R �Rna,. . k1,�p,t ,„i�,14,r,1 ...l.I...1,!♦�r..• , -.7 1.., ... 7.,...kL#:.,r.. ,+k , �!... .. ,,r.t.. .:.s. .M' ..-..,.. . ,,.� .. .., ,r,.. ...�i,,_.�-a,.,;... ,.�v.. n.,... .. r.."......i .,a,..a. .. �.Y.'. :.V,,.r ,.a,, r , . . r2r�tr:k,. � , 'ur�tIrt'+a: i s }tr, , ,.7u,'r„.w-1 _7 � '- .. .aS.iA.�„t ,.r.r,.� N Lr. . ,r,t. �4 . F.., .. M1 ...arr�.:-.S,.. .re_...r. , ,ab'-..1.p,wn. .,,..a..r !.. V._u. .('.v,',"l.._,.�_�r,i.r,..w �.:.{: .. i 1, . t,.er'+C. ,.',,..:�? rr _...al .i.�:�cr.,.,..,,.i . ,v\ �. -r.� ,. ..! 1 ,.� . , ..-z �.J ,,._,,ai.��,.x:.�r..�, ra,.� v. N�rt .�tt:., .., .w»_ i u..h .r. .i.�"Y,-i...i a..r . . 5r N�t1�,7 .-.� ..� ., i . r.,,d, i.:r,.r^.iVimr, .�, .. .'{ri, .4' l.,., �.,i14.,. . ,. 1. , ,..9 F((\,„.,. r 5” �r..n,6,.,r ..r ..., , t .�r.,., . . ._...".�.,., �x..- Y�rk..,-.'.,.hr. „ , ,,;,k..It:i! t.ta�x r�.S1.rf,�tr b1T7,.ps a.i.i�,ty.�R p,i..yryS�S,t... ',1. �:��. . T.,rr 5� .. �r� .. P ,..}�7r.,.., . t,r J,#r ..t �.,•...,.�, ,... ,�. t� s.r e..v.vd �.1-. '�.�.r f N�.u N,V.,. 1 9. r7,ee4S� . 1". ..W1.". � . a.'r7.r4i_{,.l, .! ,r,...t.et,..�-� .. 7u�( i.Y1`+,e4f.~ ... , :.iv.. ' 4r�..5,i,. .. .m,,v..., 7 . r,r�V�.i ,7ja�},, i, � .r. .'�K-�..1.,.' , 7r ,,,.,,. 1 L �-... r _r,.a,.. ,e . .... n -.e.. ..., .,.. r ,,.. . .,...,.. w. .,..,�, ,a . ,,`a.�....�,. ., L,._... �eS,..ri..fi .,. ,.,...t..._...,-.'.,...,rsr.I.! :x"r...,.�. s .,, ., _ .5.i1,..,.:r�.,, Y. 1r,ie ...irJ,}t� .- ago o i. , s»�a.. w,. .r.r. i, .... 'R,rv.t_. . .. ,�..,r,7.,,.mwpp.:,. .-rr.:a''.. i t,:,..�, „' . _.h.. Y.,.� ..,�1f.auk.. ..t;r ..,- .TY ,r.!.,L`�ia, . �,...,.,,x...R� :L.,. : .-. . ,.�r...\...-,r h,., .v, .a...i._d.},,o,,.. . . _.,, .r .., ,,,,,+ r. 7 ',e,kkY ,4r.trr.x. .'-. th Y i_..t x0._xf,:..1 .._}lY.er , ',,oY7r.,Y,) ' t.�J�.,..,, v,.. k..,r ...,. ,.farR ..�.,.,.,A.�, .J ..s.,, _ .�., .., ,{.. ,rF, .7. h ., n,1� �.df.. h«,. f � ,r -, rt a� ,&7,# b.: -Y .d,- , \. r tj1tt.,r. .,i. 9- ,r.: + ..it s�,r...�,a.d ., •..,�...}.v,,,.r:. s,L,, ...l. .....,.. ,.eR....i.. ,,. .k,,,,,..'.,:....�,..{,- ,..... .t........:.-f,f.}..:, . . . , r�,...._.�.,...�..„.r.S.....,..., x.n .)� , i ,...C . . .,1.i. , ,iA,...,ki1,n',...:.�,t.,.�tirPa�,+._..,1 . .,�...wi,..�h,.. �, ., .... .ti'w:., !'..,,�,.w,.,,.. ,..`>. .�,, • ..r. ..R..,�.. y.5 :.�i.�,,.....i..'i r. •?., .: ., a,,...,t,'.�, . r.. ,.p.�. .t.<.r..,'.-...,. r�.:.... .l7,.c- S ,�.,�FS#, in .r ,.cf._u ,. , >r `..I, .r.,,r.. �1 .. ..a,r,-.,,..,�.�.....�.,.,d .. .. t, ..... /.v 1.� , :�_....J...,... ,.�.,.,,.r . � „ n�.... .•1 :�Ar_,.i..d,.�,{._.{',i. M . .:.�r,r,_iby1.. Ir i�'+§..�C1,i .�ra � � i.�F 'u,�I,�F_'.Iin t....,,.,..f...t �.,:.i,1r.,,.,....:..s..i. ,.. :.,, .n ... �.. , �r.4.. v1 . ,.rk,i f1r.._, :�f.�,.i .r�, .�7..,,.4i ,]!... �.r..,t. ., Z. 'rrA,... ���.tt.,i ,,�. t..s . ,.:,wJ ,..i.k..�.\i,1,- ..�L...�` ..�i ,..... �. .-t,e,,-.,.. .,ri�R.i,,, ,. r ,� , .nL'�6fiiw.,Cr, ,,., ..C�.-Jr..,.,#{.��..a,�-. .w....,�.,...,..,.. .. r . s,.._„�,v�ien,Stag �. .. i.!.,,.7. , .,s: a .Yw4rr., .+.R.r 1 5a. .1.:._W.„4a...... ...., »� r �,r. .., Er. .t,_a..l..,_.,, . , ., i..,.. : x,. ,,.,.��. n,r...., N,, . . ,.�., .,. I.r,.\,., . .\._. ,r,..._�.. .........ry• .�n. .�.,.r,.�.., . •. .-' .3v .-.tr,. a.:.t..� ..1� ..�� .,.�i,. , ,, . ,...,P �, ..k ra..,..�,s ..r1, __.. ... ,,. .,Yb..,.r.._�tr». . ..,. 61.an .1. . ,1".._...__....,r.,,�..,...�. .� r,1,�..,..,..d,_ca.,:.a,. R ,�..�..-r. . .�R, n .. .� a.. ,1... 0.,.�.v..,...,..t.M... ,e,.i.: r. S ..: . r ,..!,-v� r. .r ,�t� .R, .1ua..n�.�.S.� . � iN. _.1, t ,,',,..�r. . :td. ,11�t .;., . .e. „,ii�. 4.>. -, .,d,Y , , ,1( ., .1 .�,.,....,. ... : ,.. . .�t,.,1,M,,(.tr1t,.1r`:h..:, \. ..r. r .R ,, . �', «, - ,r, .r, .� � Na T.ur'I.4 t, r_,a§.r ..,- _..ra... . t. . ,,a.... ..:,. ,M,w,,,r.,'`.,. 4Yl. f,. 4.ie ya ,,,„ f. -, r�,R.,,..,_„,..:..a.,_.. ..� ._,•- , r. .,. ,..„� r r�a. yy,, . FMa.-n-Y u,.,. .Y,..�.. �..: ., Y ��.. .�.ni.`. r,., 4, :f .-.,. . ln-..Y'i' ��F1SY� T ¢- ?11 a.'hA..,...l . .�,.. ,,h.-� ,. -... . 0.,. a#.,7. ,..,r.,,�b.�....:.,.#�r...u.. ..rY',k.. fv:.. .,,. . , . 1 .. f,: ..+ . #».......tt4a. ..�. . 1x gg%t.jj14 g.'c• f y,r'�t..,,e+>:,. ,} iy-4�3 i.,,.,fi �,.:-' .,,., .. t .t,d�,...,,.o.s. ,. r.aa. ',4....l�: �t aa . ,:::' :: r ', �T ur .�R�L.-t`,' !Yfl 5t�.i .b Y, E 1�. ,Ji. +ti � ,9 Y..M1i Sr:.A'l.+Q.+wi-Hv.,,. ,. .R.�. I .,�.J. ,�.., lT ,C' ... . �.,,a,M � ' .,I 4A�,S ,r/s...j�, . � n, {{ tA��. r.,f.{�. �^r.., G'7i,U,� -( -,.+'.7 th_J�”s5, e1r,r�a.t.,..1, . .•�i, �,...,. ._4t� ..�., ..:�, .n��.,r� .,- .. ..x _ ! \ J 1 rrTti 9,. k rl.axi«,.,5,r . .r .. . . ... f..i ,e..�a.�,i,.Lt ..�..r .r�..:!t.r'r.: J i.,✓.<.J. �.er1. i. �.� ., ! ,i1� F. v ,r, r,jr� ”dr ,.a r. v ,,. }�.,._. rI.a 5 r .aI, Yf. �j}V"'7. 'li71s.._h,'ii,r.�.',a.rr... �-fl...r .. ,. .r,xbJ..J...-s... _ �,,.,.9..� ..,r,...•.a..!!, _-'.. . S. , . , t�,.,�x d. ..•.r,i..t ..H ., J'.> , 1. ,.ai.x ..r + 1.{ , �.�,,,..,_..._,'..5 ,.M.td',((.. F., : i.: . 'a. �s . �}4..:i, ...,,.dr. . .. \Y,, ...•..�:_.5,a. r.. . t . .,,.,r.9.� ,.,, . ,t,.1�,._�,....s. .e...,_1:r e.t._,.a Y u.„ .,,,�-,.3 -.,_, w. J ,� .-.. .. 7:.... 4 t . .,a I ( .>. Yr, u.r,..r+,,.. -� •..1l.,.:� tP,. ..w..,..R,. a:.:N� ...,...,�r,r n,ix, .. , ha�t .t,�a t.. ..k,..vAf,. i,.,. ,4..r_...,R,,.v:,..R.,,. :y+..,rG,#. .1..�.,S.Y...,..,1. 1... . .,.:.,. u...,,A ..� ..i.....•.5}..1.i ,” I. . r , Ii , 41'TJ�'. r9.Ji, 1 7, ...Y - N ,��r�.H.,. M -� ,. :.w .Ir ,.,„.aY4x. ....,,.'i..v. ,«rJ.,,,,,:...a,r.� .,.i.,..-�.e.,...r�. .. .r .�,,....r....aw..:,,.t.:. , ,,.. . . 7.,. ., .� , ,r. i..ra A,i.x ,+�-,, ,. � :.,5A7...-.a,r,...,`.,.,,.. ,..dk� .i.�.n.,,.. R,a.,.YC-t,_JJ};r� .. r�. .:-,• •.. ,. 1._t ..riw'.. .,S ',,Rt.T�rtr7 .r , .,,}.ar« w. ..}�Ia. vr.,.7'1,.. .r.�..#>_r,ak.!+,::.,..76.... ,}tt: Pk.,�r.,.�.t,{',,�,..,o,,,,'...i ri ,.:: _, X .-.r".A. yn :a�...i, ,.n,'. .1�.-,,e- :7,,..��4... . r .i. 4#M 'i.ir \. .5 . L".1 ,.Ya.:r,i,�1� '..r.�1� ,Mt�1. .. �y4k��'li, `3f�a�tS,d•1,�J,f a..-ir r,., .. m.a.,..tr ,..N :.3, r1. , 4i . 1 !.,r " r .a,f .; et,I.,R,�x,,�, T. ..a,..l,. .! r.,r.,d .'..� Yr . . A,d1WiR,., 1Y { , . ?�•.,.�,e..r.�r . .,r.„A,,.,, »,. .^. S a_,ct � -., r,,i, . g f� .,tr ,.,,1r'Yu�,.}w.t,',:i2iir.r,r.', -rr i 1Jt ,. i u�tFi,..f,,. ,sYc.r . N ��i,.,_.r,,.e.,i,,.�,„ �l,.h,. r...i. v . -. ,w,_• . ,. .+,1,:.«3.�...,J�k13Y.� ,FF5 '?4 ': .ta.,c.. ..,r..+Y �7.a,t,, ,k:o':..rrvF.t�1 � . ..1 y7 b. '�r 8Js0!,�••.. }Y'a5:�.h.,s.,Yt. no,.,, ,,,.,:.Y,x.i . 7ht.r. R .vr,,r.a .,L,.r-a1,7 . t.J4.�,.{,.. _.,Y, .:.:�Rt,:. •'Si . e3"^,tc,' „r.,a,,x.,.' ,w^�. . ° a:r�...T�v„.'r1.''t- . r. . i• :. r!i xX� �3...L.. r-.9 �'_. S.�',`4 : d"+1r,r.•:. m,��;tT..�'.d�f'x1L'r,„r P r a •f„,' �'f�_..oL..t•:'.. rtyY: ?. .. ' i', a 4”,a°.r:�.it`•4hr..«.'-.,+,,w,,»l• '�rr�^Y t„r.,,l i�0, .• it i��r•Fu .•'r:r1:' a� yY. . Fr,, .. sF•,fi .i.,.1. .,i:.. r,e .r:pYt. • ra» .� .C rr :.i .....t,.;•;;,:"bs.: ”. r. m ¢�. -u ra't;-,•r,kf. a.t..:6 ...V »1. ..r ,�...,° , `. ,=Ny1:i ..,...,_,.._at....,..�.. ,.w,Q..,.r:.3.,a ., 1,. a ra:.....r.',?., S..a:...,,..�,. i.,,ra•.5 �i..r;a1. ke.e�l, � .ar'�c �..,...,1<.�9, v"..�...� 4'..,..._n....c...,.k. ...r,.:M...r_. �.,.�... _..�7 - ��,Y }%t�, ,�a!:��_: .'�i�l „a,, ,.,nv .,.v.....'.k..r,z�.nn4�i��...,.JI%sE';�ta.i.ClaW,•..-.r.,_,r,h Li_.7;7L":.yr.,.%.. ..,fr,.,1s,,A...,i���,.T��. %iah,i�'rir :.t.,.n-a, x�.�:.,,..kreNc"t•:re.�..-:.a... s..,,.•3�.5,.,.n�..,6�r1,r ,. ,_a:a .,�,. ¢,..:;.:.r,.:.., oa,.._, 81890 tspr air al + --- mow..-�-------- _ ,— PLANNING COMMISSION' SUMIARY SliE]` T APPLICANT IDo, S. Starr_ .,.,..�., �,...� .�.,.. �.....,.,:..�,,, ADA "S'P.O. Bb 'L�. a For.osb Ranch _ +�tiVNEE2 Same...«....:.�.....,..,..�,....-A.�, "ROJEGT DESCNzFTION ane from "TM- 1 Timber Mountain � acre arms to "TM -1".. Timber Moixntaa n I aOwe parce18 ,....... --. - , LOCATION ..a proximatel, 00 feet north of -the itberl8ectiOn of Hi hwa 32.x., Schott -Road Forest Ranch 1mEs5oR'S PARCEL NUMBER(a) (81-63) 56-28-33 & 31��, ZONING TM Z GEN PLAN ., PROJECT CONSISTENT? x MITIS APPLICATION RECEIVED 12-10-80 3DAT8 REZORMIG PETITION SIGNAT'URE.g C=xbD .,...,�,.�,,„ 2CEN'TAGE i MATE LEGAL DESCRIPTION PREPARED OR CHECKED DATE PUBLICATION NOTICE WRITTEN , RTBLISHET.iN.- DATE JDISIT A.) AD PREPARED ,..»..,, FUBLIS: 'PLACE,' SPAPBR NOTICE(S) PUBLISHED 00 C. G. B' DATE MiULING LIST PREPARES .�.....� .�. ..- DATE MAII.—O T NOTICES WRITTEN MAILED 3 DATE COHMISSION WIBIT TREPARLM �....�.... .. DATE STAYV FINDINGS )REPARET} I. VV'IRONMENTAL »...,�. CATEGORICALVf E •MPTION .- DATE FILED.�:...- I xET=114ATION AND DATE ...�.... NEGATI11B, DECLARATION — P,&TE ADOPTED �. ���.. ENT. IWACT FORT - ]DACE QMT121Eb K.®w..,. ..........,.. OTB nM r.n+i• .,.,,ew..«..w�u�..,:'...uww.�,..w.uw.,..• max...�nnnin.+wr...w�..:.��nties.r.+,+w,.u.a..:+.+w.awr..r..u.�w�a..�.�..+�. OQMISSSON HEARING DATES ....»M�.,.- .., .-,..,......,_..,.......�,,....M....�.....�.... comissION ACTION ...�r,«r.,.a. .....+.......�.. w,...., .,..,. DQARDACTION .,....:..�. - ,,.. ,� ,,.r.�..�.�.�.-. �...�.,,:»�..... ,.�.:.w..�..A.-...,�.�.. .........- ORDINANoBE s) ADopTED,..... .�..... - -►� p` APPLICATION FOR REZONING BUTTE COUNTY' PLANNING COMMISSION APPLICANT. Read and follow Instructions as set forth ori reverse Side of this form. Applicant's Name DOUGLAS $.. STARK Phone No. ?�?"9� d7. Applicant's Mailing Address .F.O 0 Box 365, For, est Ranch Ca., 95942 Applieant's interest in property (Owner,iLossoo, Other) Owner Owner's Name DOUGLAS S. STAO Phone No, . 467, t j Owner's Address • 0 Box 365, Forest Ranch, 0± i ° 9591 2' ° _._�.�,� Assessor's Perces Number (s) API 56..28-33& 31 ..I J M Present Zoning— TM -5. - REQUEs,rEDZONING, Tx -,1 2 Location, dimensions and size of arca (s) to be rezoned )' e,e. g are_`ioc2te --An FQ —M -R pr Apox 0' N. of the intersaction of HW , � _ � �0Y" 32 and Schott Rd. Dimensions; .r Q Approxi 1325' x 650°Sizet 19.$ acres. parcels Were recently, subdivided into 3 five acre and l 4.88 acre parcel. ( 6 copies of final parcel map are attached.) Appl cants's reasons for rezoning See attached explanation ) y 1 hereby declare under penalty of perjury that I have read end onderst,'rnd the Instructions and that the foregoing statements are true, complete and correct to the bust of my knovvle' a and belief. y : Dated �12/3�80 Applicant's Signature ,. r /i Project File Number— ,General umber General Plan Deslgnation tyt ° Request Consistent?' yo Locatioh Lock/ D Imo o1 .ih`�c5iro �r� �`ts� Y 0 W VERIFY; it P> NumLxjr(s) j,ocation Description _. _. g Description Area Ownership Le al Descri tion of ) roof of Agency (if needed) !'�6 Maps of Area Prownt Zoning r�pti,ifo Co> Plannlncj rpmnu O D,ite Application Received �2 $ " Receipt No. � / D �• G 1, 0 1980 G .� Application Taken by oto 1119t (:gfiforgfx ; z �4 i t INSTIL UIONS TO REZONING APPLICANTS a , I , if applicant Is not the owner, written authorization by the Owner or other proof of'' agency must be submitted In order 'far tho appiicant to legally Sign the application, Application shall be considered void if not slgnad bythe owner or .legal agent. 2• All horns on application shalt be filled in as cornpietely as possible, if an Item is not l applioble, please indicate by the term'NA'. N 3. It Is Viry important that the application include an accurate and complete description of the property proposed for each requested zone. The application will not be processed until we recelve the ftsllowing, informa tion about the aroa(s) to Lbe rezoned. a. Assessor's parcel number (s) (from the tax bills or Assessor's Maps). b. Street addresses (If avail'ablsj, c. Distances and directions to named streets, bodies of water or railroads, !' d, Legal description (subdivision lot numbers, fractions of sections or distances jl and bearlhgs of perimeter dtmartsions), a. G copies o.f map with rezoning area(s) outlined (Assessor's map, subdivision map, R zoning'nfap or other map showing p.orrok). l d. Application must include a completed 'Appendix B-Environmental Information F`� orm, til 5, California Government Code Section :65300 et seq, requires local zoning ordinances to be consistent with a Jurisdiction's adopted general plan, County approval of a rezoning request must be miloported by findings of consistency with the Butte County General b Plan, Applicants may request changes in General Plan designations by filing op 'Apoli- cation for Genfral Phn Amendment'. 0. The 'Applicatiun for Rezoning' is subject to public hearings and approval by both the' Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors, The procedures for County action on rezoning applications are stated in Chapter 24 of the Butte County_ Code. ) 7. Application fees as of(date) are $ z. Fees may be aid in cash or h check made Y p Y payable to 'Treasurer of 'Butte Uounty', ! ,i B, Before subriiitting a rezoning application, applicant Is requested to discuss with staff i i all questions about application requirements, County procedures, consistency with the I General Plan, and the provisions of existing and requested zoning ciassiflcatlom, # 1` i� } a� APP ICANT°S RE. )NS FOIA,RE, ZON.TNGt Present zoning does hot represent the` "highest and "best use,, for the, land'. These Parcels p possess all the major criteria, t. for zoning for higher densities,; namely, abundance of water, adequate and su table soil for d,raina;ger level to fpantle slope, and easily aoceosable access 300' to Highway Less. than one mile East a1`the center of Forest Ranch Applicant is Petitioning for rezoning in order to increase and thereby reduce the: cost of building sites for Present and future residents of Butte Count A y� pplicant's ultimate goal is the development of Butte Counties first totally solar housing development.:Applicant is Presently completing construction oi' a 2800 sq'' combination passive and active model solar home on Parcel 4 Of the attacthed parcel map; The ;present TM -S zoning is artifically constricting land availability in the Forest.Ranch area where there is only a Limited amount of land possessing all. the major criteria for higher densisies; The County of Butte policy of Maintaining TM -5 zoning on land such as these is in effect preventing large numbers of Potential purchasers ( homeowners ) from p y urcha.sing and building on these hi hl desirable sites in the Forest Ranch area. Ouifn Ca, 1' nninq Comm. In conc2l,usion.. these parcels of land can be 'Moro eSficientiolEGI,0 1,980 and e0bnom ca4y utilized. if the zoning were TSI -1., C?ravil(er, G��s"yarlR�i nOUGLASr' STARR Applicant PIIfCpl9CINo Acquasyso Dy orolQlnc. :,snow 16th C0VM— a AUF W'504� � Oyaf r v r 1'r `�n wk4,4 ib i"o • Box 'lliR�l►�7� $.�IMIBk'tt144j �y �yC ��( r� '4rix�P�J/ a 4 t�ii2�dr'PY7J�''� �=I�'�,�g+•p� x j � � '�- dfil4R ^' A( � t z �,-.�,{. � . F �� _ " r r ori-R i 7 "�.r e rYM! �•ta ..e��X�t S.,t° "r�•, 4.� �X �ka � !+!sm rX+�,A" y 1 i � X`h� � � a ra ��yt r•..�»�iL, ,�C . � m ✓ 1 r'� ^ il/ j � y 4 ,� .MsJa-•K•fX'rp+�J. 1 � �� �, r � 1 M4XV,.x� ��? �w `4a lvlr6�t��14A0�1=Y r4 ¢vil ��U 1� S��" 1 ��y �Ryl��p�p1,� � X r� �,�Sp• � ,3 V �'yi � Y` (fn V ;a. '* �•Q 3x.eN.:*'.h : "'.,^"' 'i '� .! 'h 5.:, k ��u±. 3 fr' L +� �, y,,, 4 t A t7A):UkSl t 4(tlPOp jyQi Kt7 b h Y t e TS X• tri � at ,. C �..k� w,�.r�4...iww� •. d • � . iq�"CMFA.t«A,q i$) AND FOtVItk QU19'WIM(d) ta- "ewvj;ollraVlel, as his' 0030 and ossarato propeetq� tii'Qa16016 &aeclw nal properly IA the Butt* euuutg of P � idate eQ Cal�orada; } UJOS � ogti.on of the Southusat quartac of soction 32. Toeatmtaip 24 `+rr ,. �M •: s:,9 ost� �1.D.i3, M , and beta erly described f� I; _ , ' re+ora articul P ab�t01 to, Ahosrtn on that terpaLn Zoract &p recorded in the officio of ,'„ t� V.;*War of the County 0f 'putt®a ScAtQ Of Caticarnia on July 16th, 1.�,?ty ab 1c S3 of " P�eecol fps at 0 go 4. 6!4 OORTM 60xT11 ANO, [ 6SAVING THE" FROK a non-exclusive smadment for ewsd anQ is llc utility p oc•°e0 6q' feet in * dt as shown on said Percel �. r. Iwo Donald A. DrA®sechlag t srATt or Cn 4mA � GOY! oK 1 bda µ��6 y fdaruY .��dbr; A,W14smrrd o4w e! me, IAt` wxkr• ._..�..._..,� pw--wlr .M@" o :_ a.. __ . tin IMM I ^ .. . ai�+apalwerllrwl to 1. ttx ukrhia C Uppy L� Y f loetrwn.�RR wl a4Rfd nr p d IAet lk.. »-on.ciuied AA "W, "O!AKY FUUW CAtJ/p04P p* Y} } M: 1171TM1Qtfffi'� M Chae4bu COUMV Itn �n r eKIY�Vers'1^�►Vt+'vOEr'I7�0'gO�'4M }l1 � �15�' 4v�'� !► rwia�I PY�46 � �� Inw «.. rd .� «rw.i ..a `�I�'��; ' �� A�sAli1A liaAreavva as aro#sit► e►�ove i $(mss. 4 " N ew.ri.:w..nF:�.uYrJ..w..e-vs{+a.y r........x.,s+-L.4'F.iruH+tisww.,r..w: w'�+rwokt�-t.u•.....+-t....: ,.:. .: .. v ..._.:s:..- 4 --,,.. _..•-�.,.�.y���g e� �1'1.•tyg.. ���.q�,�. �.Vp t�Te �t�M�/�, `x �lD i 9Ebi see kv M6bO �19 Qdf) FiV.7Ay+4 V4 17MWf1sW� ��1Y7L6:. M. ciL ARR 1:i� YWN�D N. xTiw T"0.�,�at eaoe 8amaossra n®atorolatem xra.t c�is� DNut` 159179 Cky�. L.. $23, but LSO Or. �;�dm�ltad Y.akew NSoh iWJltlB+ena �! �, .a =.t ntieetl imoi 16MWO ww Feta coo* r' r P.Ot, box 365w �,oreet Ranohf 0a., 95044. IavA ttt t@e 01 cute o11 Butte $,';: unvaniet-w�GoEtos• �� � , , 1�Ifi COUNTY CAUF, ?(;Oe � $, •� (� attached log&l do®oriOdpA) 469 Ci: ►st A. "Wool 01 w tot f l) OV1148 a" use nfatiedne I" fefeomu of lased y I"c .. i fil pit i u.t.d A 80 19110- 31t0REO 00 C�BjIIbBNaD'EN iRtfiMCt? Aft 11�0 +R,tC./�$i or DOI i S S. STARR STATE OF WICHICACd Al' COOATV Op n-ul--A _ at , t7n lair 4;020'�o dily of /6u 6-'v ' 19 �'(j fafleem reo gerlurollV y :Starr, Vnra K. Stnrr, Douglas S. Starr df/Cubed Is .MITI www pNf Luted the lolijoial Ing""Wit ml ' p� the l . tln 1sd Itmd�. ef.auted the • . o. ' NA irra car ot. ub 1r. ,.NA". 6v 4~6'40lon eupitef y I.,,,—�----- k KKKuMurtl.ky Ttt."WIR � f lCtt'r!Fi,YT4J l'i}llu,t Y/+lUl Ql i�Rpi4C lY COlNCYID, OR � 4vs'KFOIao pN tV1C VAlut Itis LIINS G t�tVMdMNtts . RfttAINIPCt1 tHEMN AT TIA:t 01,$Alt >lrenatlrf d dldra.nl 1t ad+M dfl�lwit:nf lee. _y Raw nae»' , It I>raHed 61—L1Gtyt ..... �_iS.,a...1, RoaotdloR.Fee 7( .FJJIR1f p C` Tinv ZiSK 'iihnnei• t1Q b ,. q'¢ t Treitllft Teti . AddIR1f t•.. ry�tll 34 'I r room NO, Via. , 15911 ' t r .,f', � { �7i1 � �� �i,ii.�• � �i� "j�l��ti t�"t n '. h � 1 � it r � �'rF � 7C4 rt ' . � 7 �.� i aT,°� a fir+. ,W g e. n� r ' r� 15, WKIL gg M L Ifl\ A'1 d .._.._ F , .111 that certain real proparty ssituatu in th v Couniq of )iut ta, Statt Of ft >,• lifornia, describiad as followas 136inq a pertian of the Southwest quarter of Seotion 32, Township 2% 21'orth, � R&C90 1 ftatt,100i & Mand being more particularly 4escribod. as follows; P&*C a ®hour on that certain Parcel itep rucor�ed in tha affics oP 'rmarscsOar the County of Dutte+, Stat o of California, July 16j, 1976, in �? 11po a 53 of Parcel Baps, at pagd 4 LT=.R ;,11TH a ron-ancluaive saioeamant for road Annduhlic utility pur- ems GO feat:, in viAth as shmin on said Parcol ,tap.p rj P«(= 114 TIMRF.PF;Oti tho following dtAncribed parcel of land: at the t, wkkem& oomar of 1LaE 21 as atom an the Poop of ?asst lata 1id ,famed 9a 8 43 of 8m at pRou 83 th 8$, th=�c+e�, from avid pont � ` ' Of, g, Marth 1® 401 ,15" HeA. 25a07 feot themes South 87. 572 37" Enst, f 20.25 1�641 t31mo 8,5j" Is, A" Eaet, 77-43 feeti thence South W 011 20 ir�Sb6tbp 9 o$DfMet to W Smt;;h .11m of mUd Sm6tiam 321 thance aloes ®a14 *AMU 2ms �{ Westo 27340 feet to tbo past of-begimAn k i!,,1 • 4 � I M, , ,} • WOOL" t` W .... ... ., .,..,..,. ., w,.s.�� Y fl,. wr 0.. .MiAt> i :.i xf•:'r �7f stz } t u res 'Decomber 12, 1980 Uduglta 6tarr P.O. Box x65 ;Coreg t Ran h, CA 95942 M) 14 Rezolao File #81-63 Dean Mr. Starr: This is to —notify you that we v ereived yotax Opplicotion, for s rezone MS , " (Timbor 'lountaaa,n-5. acre Parcels � ,r, r' Timber Mountain 1 acrd pac�c�:laJ located pro iMat y apo foe t nor4h of the ins ars+ coon of Shwa 2 artd Schott Rorad.� identified ops AP 56, -PB_ > forest Ren.ch. We will sahodul lie ioarings at such time as the rrviwonment.l d.ete m nations and the recotnme'O dations of she rt of :Publie Works and t;he Bnuironme tal. oa M L have boon raceived by this of: lc1 o, Sincerely, S Bettye Blair Director of Planning ` BB: jc , i Til PLANNING:L?EPA,RTMENT'S INTER DEPARTMENT' LREVIEW REQUEST �7..`j�'1.S1�Ori: of Tr(7�'GSt�'�' �. --_— �t1i�S.si.F.I.e.L�!�ina Comm R�6UEST;_,daylew S'. rnant JAN 121981 - AP'N0. , 36-28-33 31 AP NOo Orovlllas GaliiorWA DESOMPTION OF PROJECT;.Taxa xai�aca� f3aht�$;t ��� LOCATit7N .agpx"p=_ �QO�`�+et tlgr_tJj of th!2 1.1���*►��9ct�_�1' �„ ��, Ba APPLICANTtAr� ADDRESS" 2.0. Bfzx �, -941 +[+'r439�'e OWNER. _ Elame PLANNINGCOMMISSION ACTION SCIlEDULED RETURN DATER'EQUEBTED: ASAP ATTACHMENTS; Copy of application plot plan, RETURNED; COMMENTS; Fero ProtoctioLh Roquiroments: No reguiromontn oil rozone rerluertt; howevorl --- if approved rind_ $trueWres aro rlacori on 1 act,. narcol8j certain Xirp protection. roquiren, tints will,be stipulated Tor re!carding on finiil. nM.L.— a o. t C�tznty T o Wry •r vn . Inter -Departmental Memoranduca r Tal Board of Supervisors i PROM: Environmental Review SUEQECTI Lochner. Appeal Of LIR Requirement L tlATtr September 19, 198'0 - The initial study checklist 4(,,tailing the reasons for the HIR requirement i;; attached for your reference. The basis for the bllt can be summarized a;r follows i The area was zoned in 1916 on U. commuility-wide basis establishing densities which would ult�mately result is the community character desired by Forest Ranch residents; Although this project is relatively sma,11 (nine acres), if it is approved without an 13112, neighboring properties should be given equal treatment and :the domitlo effect migdit come into play. If this were to occur, the entire area could u.ltxmatcly be rozoned piece -by -piece with no MR, resulting in significant environmental consequences in terms of a change in the community character, Crosion problems on the steeper slopes, traffic .i.ncrdases, etc.These are cumulative effects and the State VIR Guidelines require that they be analyzed prior to the original de - vision which begins the trend. Tho LTR ;dor .the 1976 rezone is unfortunately not adequate to meet, present state requirements. Otherwise it could be used a;i the i.Ilt for this project. This situation illustrates two thin Rs; (1) cumulative effects cannot be studied project -by -project, but must be analyzed on an area -Ade basis; and (2) if adequate tills are prepared for area -wide zoning Changes, an in- dividual project application can often be spared tiie time and expense of preparing ail RIR for an individual project. In this case the : ounty-prepaxed L-111IIt does not meet Current standards but the project could result in cumulative environmental effects, so State MR 'Guide'lines require preparation of all adequate IMI prior to processing,an individual project (see California Adm, Code Section The above comm,011ts constitute the basis fr the 1s'iR requirement.: I hope this information is helpful to you. Sincerely, Earl U Nelson l:nvironiiierital Review Director ........... sTA V air+ e-!L1r0AN1A .TNV nf150UrlCf-a' �,,HcY : raMUND U. ypgWN JH.{ GOV040011 STATE VAIER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD ft. 0. NAX 100 A 5ACOMrHT695001 01-m, F.Fr:. , r August 15, 1980 Mr. Earl D. Nelson lnvironmental Review Mte'County 18—F County Center. 'Drive Orovi.lie, CA 95965 NOTICE OF PREPARATION: SCH 8008051 BUM COUNTY'S NOP FOR TGZONE TO TM-- Thank you for the opportunity to review the subject Notice of Preparation, The State Water Resources Control Board has the legal, requirement to protect water quality and to provide for reasonable use of water.In light of these mandates, we teed information concerning the relationships of the proposed- project to Water quality and vr`ater rights, as lasted below. I. 'WATER OUALlTY (Surface and Croundwator) A Applications or permits required, 113. Kinds and quantities of materials to be disposed of and treatment and disposal facilities. CoConstruction activities that could res:tlt in later quality impacts. D. Soil characteristics related to 'water quality (erosion, siltation, percolation, seismic characteristics). FA Potential impacts of the proposed project on surface and ground– water quality (degree of change and seasonal variation).. F. Mitigation measures, including plans for preventing impacts from spills A-$ (7/80) STATE Or CALIFORNIA -RESOURCES AGENCY EDMUND O, BROWN „ Governor r r�•---'"'-yrs r�--._a.. " . _ - JR�v-rsra DEPARTMENT OF FSH AND GAME REGION x Fm4ronmen}e1 Fariaw Dept, UITE A RANCHO CORDOVA, CALIFORNIA 95670 SEP 8 1940 17(1j NIMBUS ROAD, S v JO (516) 355-7030 Septcmbe:i; 5, 1980 cc;: Bachman and ,Associates «, x APPENDIX B' 16. If residential, include the number of units,' , schedul.e of unit sizes, and type of household sire expectad l7« if commercial, indicate the type, whether neighborhood, city or regionally oriented, square footage of sales Area, and Loodinp facilities« 18, I,f industrial, indicate type, estimated employtTtont per shift, andload .ng facilities, 1.9. If ins tituti:onal; indicate the major function, estimated Omp.loymt�nt per shift, estimated occupancy, loading.; facilitie.9, and community benefit: to be derived fromthe projectt, 20: If' the project involves a variance, conditional use or rezoning application, state this and indicate clearly why the applicAt on is required, Are the following items applicable to the project or its offects? Discuss below all :items checked yes (gttrach additional sheets as necessary). yts No: 21. Change in existing features of any beaches, lakes, or hills, or substantial alteration of Freund contours,.. x 22. Significant change in scan's views or vistas from existing xesidontial. areas or public lands or roads _XX. 23. Slgnif.icantly change pattetno scale or character of general area of project. X 2'4. SignificAnt amounts of solid waste or. 1i:tter'. _ C 25. Change in dust, ash, smol£e, .fumes or. Odors in vicinity. r 26. Significant change in lalcc, stream or ground water duality or quantity, or alteration of, existing; drain,ape patterns x' 27. Substantial change in existing noise or vibration l.e'veis in the vicinity. 28, Site on filled land or on slope of 30 percent✓ or more X, 29. Use or disposal of potentially hazardous materials; such as toxic substances, flamtnables or explosives, t 1lulto Co. Plonninc mm• CU (�fp�U�til v.mF.+a,4t:� Apht?tidtx .li« � tti,(x ? t11 - YES NO 30o Substantial change in demand for municipal services s (police, fire, water, sewage, etc.). XX 31 Substantially increase fossil, fuel consumption (electricity, oil, natural gas, etc.) 32. Relationship to part of a larder project or series of projects, ENVSRONMENI'AL SETTING 33 Descr-ibe the project site as it exists beEoxe the project, including information on topography,,soil stability., plants and See animals, and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects. Describe any existing structures on the site, and the use of the structures . 02-05- 34. 2-p ..34.,Describe the surrounding properties, including information 06 on plants And animals and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects. indicate the type of land use (residential, commercial,, etc.), intensity of land use (one -family, apartment 'houses, shops, departm(lint stores, etc.), and scale of development (height,; frontage, set: -back, rear yard, etc .) _. See Report # 80-02-0$-06 CERT;FICATION I hereby certify that the statements furnished ao� a n` an the attached exi�ibits present the data and - information required for this initial evaluation to the best of my ability; and that the facts, statementso'and information presented are true and correct to the best of my khm-iled'ge and belief. • f, Dates '123%80 ,. ` �✓ j g nature- i h For lIwio Co, PIAliningProy it Gomm, i 1 Appendix E - page 3 of 3 tl� rI . tv. ENVIRONMENTAL CNEXKLIST` DORM (To be completed by Lead Agency) 14"Ro Log /f 80-12.-10-03 I. BACKGROUND 1. Name of Proponent Douglas Starr 2. Address and Phone Nvii er of Proponent' P. 0. Box 365 Forest -CA 95942 3, Date of Checklist Submitted 4. Agency Requiring Checklist 5. Name of Proposal, if applicable_:_Rezone: _'TM -5 to TMTM=1 forest Ranch on APJ _56-28=31 innd 13 II. ENVIRONMEI NTAL II;lfACTS (Explanations of all "yes" and "maybe" answer's are required on attached sheets.) YES MAYBE NO 1; Earth. Will the proposal result in significant: a. Unstable earth conditionsor in changes in geologic substructures? b. Disruptions, displacements, com- paction or overcoverIng of the soil? � C. Change in topography or Around sur- face relief- features or removal of topsoil? d. Destruction, covering or modi.fiea- tion of anuni. I ue 4 colo i.c o7: � ` 3 h sical e'atur e. Increase in wind or Water erosion of soils, either on or o.fC the site? f. Changes in deposition or erosion t,l: beach sends, or changes in siltz- tion;, deposition or erosion which may modify the channel of a rivet or stream or the bed of the ocean or any, bey, inlet or lalec? g. Loss ofprime a,ricultural.ly pro- ductive soils outside designated urban areas? Appendix F - page 1 of � YES MAYBE NO h, Exposure 09 people Or propertto geologic hazards such as ear.tKquakes, landslide's, mudalides , ground failure, or similar hazards? --- 2. Air. Will the proposal result in; ' a. Substantial deterioration Of ambient or local air quality? b. The creation of objectionable odors, smoke or fumes? c, Significant alteration of ail movement, moisture c)'r iempex"aturo) or any change in climate,either locally or rogionally? =—.- ---- 3. Wafer. 14ill the proposal result in substafytial; a.` Changes in currents, or the couse or direction at, water movements? .-� � -- ----- b. Changes in absorption rates, drainage , patterns, or the -rate and amount of surface water runoff? c. Need for off-siLc S•ut:iace drainage improvements, including vegetation removal, chantlel.i,,at•;ion or culvert lI installation? _ �"J.Itcrat,idns to the course o'; Flow oil flood waters'? �-- ---- e Change in. th,c: amount of surface water in' any water body:, Discharge into surface waters, or, in any alteration of surface water qur,:'tity, including; but not dl ssolved limited to t;dmperature, Oxygen or turbidity? QAlteration g, of: the direction or rate of flow of t�z� ti ound waters? h.Change in the quantity or quality of ground vat.exs, eithe-r through direct additions or Withdrawals, or throur h Interception of,an aquifer by cuts or excavations? i Appn&Lx F - page 2 of 5 1 e YES .MAYBE NQ Reduction in the amount of water otherwise available for public water supplies? Exposure of people or property` to water related ha ardS such ,a.s floodin5? 4. Plant f,i e, Will the proposal, result �n suFs ran tial s r, • a, Loss of vegetation or change in the F diversity of species or number of any species of plants (`including trees; shrubs, grasso ops, microflora and aquatic plants)? b. Reduction of the numbers of any unique, rare or endangerhi species " of plants? C, Introduction of new specie, of plants into an ,area, for in a barri:Zr to the normal replenishment of existithp species7 eduction in acreage of any agvi cultural crop? 5i -AnimalLife, Will floe proposal. result n salsa substantial: a. Change .in the d,i.versi'ty of species, or numbers of any species of animals (birds, land animals including reptiles, .fish and shell- fish, benthic organisms, insect or microfauna) ? ti . Reduction of the numbers of any unique, rare or endangei;ed species of animals? C. Introduction of new species of animals into an area, or result in n a barrier to the migrafi afi ion or movement of: animal$? d. Reduction of, eticroadlimont upon;, or deterioration to existing fish ;or wildlife habitat? Appendix 'k' - page 3 of 9 YES MAY'8L' 140 . 6_, noise. Will theproposal rest,/It in substantial: a Increases in noise levels? I".xp08ur.e of people to severe noise i levels't ,+ 7. Li lit and Clare. Will the proposal proc'Cuc F',na Tcnnt I Vbt or P are? 8. Land Use. Will the propostil resin. r.n a sa.,Enificant; a. Alteration o:l the planned l.-and use of an area, or ostablisb a trend whiob will demonstrably lead to such alteration? ; n b, Conflict wit uses on adj oixiin a propnr.ties, or conflict establi.,hud recreational, educa- tional, reliious or scientific uses of an area? 9`. Natural Resources;. Will the proposal .rl result in substantial_: a, ranyrnaturalse in the ofmuse ofdbd resoureesdto C b. DepleLion of any nonrenewable )� natural resource? 10. Rask of, u`psC Does the proposal involve r3' risk of an explosr.on or the release of hazardous substari^es (inc1udi:na, but not limited to, oil, pesticides, chemicals or radiation) in the event of an accident or upset conditions? 11- Vo elation. Will the proposal. sx ani > c anti y alter the l o(,;i t ion, tt distribution, density, or growth 1 rate of the' human population of an area or phySically divide an estrbl fished eommtni ty2 12. Hozsinc, V13.11 the proposal silk 'fcantly affect axi,st%ng housing, or create a Gema id for: addl`ti.+ nal Appendiac F - page 4 of 9. , t 1, YES t,,AYSE NO 13. Transportation/Circulation, Will the proposal -esu t n: a,Generation of substantial additional vehicular movement? b. Significant off6ce.8 ortexisbinp parking facilities, or demand for new parking? C. Substantial impact upon cxistin transportation systems? d. Significant alterations to present pattierns of circulation or Movement Lf: people anti/or goods? e, Alterations to waterborne rail. or air traffic? f,. increase in tra.C£i.c hazards to motor vehicles., bicyclists or pedestrians? ' 14..• Public Services, gill the proposal nave an:effect upon, or result in a substantial - 'need for new or a'ltored Aovernm6ntal serV'iCe$' 7.n any of the following areae g. rise protection? b, police protection? glchbols? C.. d. Parts or other recreational facilities? rA Maintenance of public facilities, in,cludin roads? f . Other governmental services? ?i 15. Energy. l-dil,l the proposal result 1.n: .i a. Use of substantial amounts oC £ua'] or dnergy? A Substantial lrtcreasr in deiwiftd upon existing, sources of energy, or require the development of new sources of energy'? r y ' Ariuendix p = page 5 of 4 =- � rtAxiilj N(7 16, Jt�,1.i..es � , I - _.,, 7 1 l ti Zc proposal result -1�5 ,. s.n7 a t I c I—f new systeniw , or, mlf7- ,ne4ntlFxl altercations its tlao . ollowirje R aat i'li t:.lc s ; :ePt d3 or natural gas? ; b Cot''imuniOi tions s :-terns? c Water? k d' lbewer (rwii;:l trunt;, line be oxten(ILd, �. . ptovid'Lng capri.city Lo starve now :✓cRtopment) a e,f^o<i wmtrcr c[ain;e7 I1_uttan •116:41th, 14ill, the proposal k x?'t Cr -v, .Uon or, anY health ha;&ard or not;Ontial fica,lt:h hazard (excluding - mental baealth)? C lC, Exposure of people to potential � health hazards? 13, 161"d Wasto. Will thresult a'ity significant iiarpa,cts associated sclid vaste d:isnosal or litter Crst�kl"o1? 19.. Atsthetic; , Wilt the proposal result Tec s"truct"id,l of any public designated or recogm-zed scenic vista open to the public, or will, the prop'osa•1 result in t:ho ctentlon of an aestaet9,caliv 0..Eensive site open to public view? 20 Reareatioil. Will thio proposal result irianr�r1 impact Upon the quality or quantity oiw existing public recrea- tion f9ditli;ies! 21. �lrcheolo i a n tis tori cah s 14 11 the proposal result n—aid a tcra.tion aE a si€rtaificant archeological or, histoa:idal site,structure, object or builditg7 # • �, Appendix FPage a e 6 of 9 z J_:. Y89 MAYAE NO 22, Mandatory Findings o,f Si n �icance. a, D&sthe project have the potential to degrade the duality of the environment,- substantially reduce the habitat of a fish or wildlife speiAes; cause a fish or wildlife �? population to drop below sell sustaining; levels,; threaten to eliminate a plant or animal com- munity, reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plana or animal or eliminate important examples of the major periods of California history or prehistory? b. Does the project have the potential to achieve short term benefits to the detrimentof publicly adopted long; -term environmental goals? c, Does the project have impacts which are individually limited, but r� cumulatively considerable,(a project may impact on two or mare separate resources where the impact on each resource is relatively small,'but where the effect of the total of those impacts on the environment is significant . ) d, Does' the project have environmental effects which will cruse substantial adverse effects on human beings, either directly or indirectly? 1 _ ' 9 J '- Appendix F - page 7 of 3 80-12.10,03 II'I DISCUSSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION Project :Description 1. 'Brief Description Redone of 1.9.8$ acres from TM -5 to TM -1,. 2. Location: AP 0 56 28-31 and '33, 300 :feet west of Highway S2 off Schott Road, lh-2 miles north of ):sorest Ranch, S. Proposed Density of Development: 1 -acre homesites would be allowed. 4. Access and Nearest Public Road($) Existing access to and through the Property off Schott Road via private roads: Barry and {Vanda Lanes. 51 Method of Sewage Disposal: Individual ;septic -leach field systems: 6. Source of (Vater Supply: Individual wells. 7. Proximity of Power Lines: Along Schott.Road- extension to existing on-site residonces. 8. Potential for further land divisions and development Rezone would permit t 18 1 -acre parcels, subject to terrain, soil conditions and sewage disposal capability, Ph s.ical Environment: I, 1. Terrain a. General Topographic Chhracteri Gentle to moderate sloping; Forest ,Ranch ridgeland b,, Slopes: Range: 5-20$, generally 10-15% C. Ii'levation., 2400-2500 feet• A.MiS.L. di. Limiting I�actors: Moderate sloping hillsides, in places 15-20%,. 2. So.i1S a. Types and Characteristics: Aiken-Cohasset :>o.ls,, a generally deep clay loam with good drainage and moderate - slow subsoil permeability. s b. L.Lmiting Factors: Permeability, variable percolation rates of 6-120 mindinch (generally 0-60) . 3. Natural hazards of the Land a, Irosion Potential: 1`1oderate Y�. Landslide Potential; Moderate. c. Fire Hazard: high c1. Expansive Soil Potential -Moderate 4. hydrology -'Drainage: a. Surface. (Vater: Natural intermittent drainage channel traverses area immediately east and souCth o.fthe sit1 leading to the tributary, channel. of LitLlt! Chico V,.'v 'e9 south of site. b. Ground Water: P6tentially limited resource. y Appendix F pfige 3 df 9 80-12-•10-03 UI:SCUSSION Or ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUXTION (continued) c. brainage Charac'teristics': Natural drainage is toward, the east and south into creek. d. Analual Rainfall. (normal): 65 to 70 inches e. Limiting Factors: Groundwater is limited throughout the Folle s t :Ranch ridge. 5. Visual/Scenic'Quality: High 6. Acoustic: Quality: highway 32 corridor nearby., Biolo+?ical Environments 7. Vegetation: Mixed Coniferous Forest Transition Life Zone. 8 Wildlife Habitat" Fine -Oak wor,�lland providing food habitat; within key winter range foi migratory deer Herds. Cultural, Environment: 9.r Butte Count General Plan designation Agricultural. Residential (conditional) consistent i0. Existing Zoning: TM -5 11. Existing; Land Use on-site: Developed homesites and ;access roads. Excavated .roads and mobile Homesites traverse southern portion of site (Previously :proposed mobile;home park). 12, Surrounding Area: a. Land Uses: Scattered residences and open forested land. Highway 32 corridor. b. Zoning: Within a large TM -5 district covering an estimated 2500 ac -res of ti"te Forest Ranch ridge. AR -5 to south. c. Gen: Flan designations4 Agricultural Residential d. Farce) Sites: 2 to 10+ acres e. Population Very low density, dispersed. 15,. Character of Site and Area: Open forested land With limited development. 14. Nearest Urban Area: Chico, 17 miles 15. Fire Protection Service: a, Nearest County (State) Fire Station: Forest Ranch Volunteer o r c Station 1� miles • FT' .,tati.on north of site b. Water Availability: None This proposal is a rezone from TM -5 to TM -1 to allow numerous l+ acre homesite parcels on ±:20 acres of land north of For,e'st ranch. The property lies in a large TM -5 (and AR -S) zoning district on the g a result of Foro"st Forest Ranch. ride that was created in )975 as Ranch comwoon;ity and Butte County Planning: Commission efforts to preserve t}?is rural mountain community. Appendix 'F - Hage 8a of 9 �0-12-10-03 DISCUSSION OF rMIRONML'NTAL LVALUAI'TON (continued) This prbjeeto if approved, would create an "island" of higher density zoning in the midst of a large blockof five -acre minimum zoning. A rezoning and, development growth, trend on smaller parcels could become establishod on the ridge as a result, encouraging Similar 1+ acre parcel divisions and ,bomesites. The existing character of this locality is open ruixed forest, gentle -to -moderate sloping ridgeland terrain wii4i dispersed rural residences along Schott Road and the existing :access road, Barry Lane. Previous :develrpment projects for this site and of, similar nature in r the Forest Ranch area include-: 1. Starr and boerschlag Use :permit for a Mobi'lehome Part, on this same site. (ERD Log # 79-08-06-01) (withdvawn) 2. Starr 'Tentative Parcel Map on this site, approved'' for 5 -acre parcr,.ls by Advisory Agency on 4.28, .80, (LRD Log # $I7-02-05-06) 3. Lochner Rezone from 'TM -5 to TNI -2 z on AP # 63-13.03', south of Forest Rd ch. PIR was required by the Board of Supervisors on 0-23-80. (LRD Log N 80-05-19-06) The proponent' applied for and obtained a use`permit 'in' 103 for a mobilehome park. Due to unforeseen circumstances, the park was never completed;, and was determined not an allowable or permitted use in the TM -5 zone by the county. Under provisions of the original use permit, the following improvements and buildings, exist on the site 1) A 16' x 161 laundry building (currently being used for storage). 2) Site reads and mobilehome sites are excavated. 3) Site water system is developed. 4) Two septic tanks are in place. Impacts of greatest concern are the cumulative impacts of the following' items, if the TM -1 zone were to become established throughout the ridge. Appendix F - page 8b' of 9 km e 80-12-10-03 pISCUS51ON OF ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION (continued) t .1b e: Development at the higher 1 -acre density would result in considerably greater soil disruption and overcovering than occurs at the 5 -acre density, Roads and homesite locations have already been excavated on portions or the property, (for the mobile''home park) with consequent soil displacement and erosion. Existing T0114, cuts need stabilization to prevent orosidn. Some development limittitions exist on this moderately sloping terrain. le; 3b,c; If; 3f The construction of additional roads and drive- ways, removal of soil. protective vegetation, and homesite development at greater densities will create an increase 'in surface water runoff, tial sedimentation causing increased erosion susceptibility and poten o£ drainages courses (especiallyconsidering the terrain a.nd 'high rate of rainfall). During any additional road construction, an increase 'in erosion ri;ay ocC'ur especially on the steeper slopes. Measures should be taken to prevent soil erasion. Surface water quality may also be affected by the greater density of development as numerous homesites are constructed on the site (and on many ridgeland areas if a'down-parceling trend occurs). 2a: There would be a slight decrease in local air quality primarily due to increased vehicle emissions,. Although this individual impact may not be significant for this site., it does add to the cumulative effects of increased vehicles in the Forest ;Ranch area,. particularly if numerous smaller parcels are allowed ori the ridge. ,Dust may increase from the addition+ traffic generated on area gravel and dirt roads. 5b,,c Refer to above item (le) 3hnis Groundwater resources are livmited 'tthe Forest Rach'Ridge area to varying degrees. ThWater source is locally intervolcanic sedimentary layers rs water -bearing and water -recharging of the Tuscan Formation. The potential is poor to fair for develop - Pent o£ adequate domestic water supplies, particularly for the proposed density of use. The downslope and depression locations an the region have the greatest potential for groundwater production, :dXpec:ted to yield modest amounts. (Reference: Groundwater,Potential. for -157 -acre Parcels int'the Forest Ranch Area; DepT"i o ater esources ar:.;5; I 'lvi . AppendixF - page 8c of P 7 i i 80-12-10-03 DISCUSSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION ;(continued) Future Well of affected by Productionls Prroo area could be of, adequate water is required by the Butte County Environmental Health Department for f 1 acre parcels (any Parcel loss to approval. If a than S acres) continuous, domestic water of 1+ acre zoning i supply cannot be shorn for numerous sinal] parcels, then creation n this area cannot be justified. 4a: Considerable forest vegetation may I be removed under the proposed more intensive development., which would modify the character ofthe site and area. Increased runoff and erosion may also result since greater amounts of unprotected land surface. would be exposed to intensive -rainfall (65-70 inches annual, average). Some site alteration has the surrounding area, if. induced to previously occurred the 1+ acre density should a rezoning .trend become establishedwould be subjected to substantial tree removal for developmen, t of roads, driveways, and homesi±es Sd: A cumulative reduction of important low-e]evation r dgelarid wildlife habitat would result from Conversion of this large Forest and parcel Ranch Ridge TM -5 district to TM -1, upo"ir subsequent land divisions _development. The ridge is important winter range for migratory deer herds. 6a; An increase in cumulative area noise would result from greater_ intensity of development, due rl centrated vehicular use, as rieZl�a, residentto ncreased and more con st Of the area would be developed4under 1 -acre ZUhing, leaving less open open forest). While the Highway 32 noise cors dox traverses the area, the Forest Ranch Ridre has a typically quiet acoustic character, due to the law density of cietielopment and abundance of .forest vegetation. 7: Increased area light would be introduced from exterior security lighting on numerous 1+ residential and acre residential 8a,b: The rezoning to TM -1 of one )Bartel tiYithin a large TM -5 district will create an isolated zone which allows a more intensive r land use than the surounding TM -5 zoningallows. Property was rezoned as part of the 1076 Forest RancheResubect zone. present Zoning was, formulated and apg]:ied to the area to reflect he the natural limiting factors' of the land availabilit (sewage disposals water Yc slope, etc.) .arid to reflect community desires. The basis for the original zoning has; not changed over the past 5 'ears - Y Appendix r - page 8d of 0 80-12-10-03 DISCUSSION OF HVVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION (;continued) The approval of the rezone could stimulate further rezone applications for reductions in minimum parcel sizes over a wider area. Ultimately these rezones could expand throughout much of the ridge, and could further expand onto adjacent steep canyon lands (designated Grazing-Open Landand Timber Mountain, currently TM-40 and TM-20). Approval of the rezone would establish a precedent :for minimum parcel size in this area (refer to section 22(c) at the end of this discussion)) possibly altering the character of this community and ultimately Affecting the land use pattelrfi desired by the majority of Forest Ranch residents. There are a few smaller parcels in the area that were created before the Forest Ranch Rezone was adopted. Parcel sizes in the 1-20 acre range must meet the conditional development criteria of the Agricultural-Residential land use designation, to be consistent with the Butte County General Plan. Conditional Development Criteria include 1. Adequate sewage disposal capacity, 2. Adequate domestic water supply. 3. Less than 3o% slope. 4 Reasonable access'ibili'ty to commercial services and schools. S. Adequate: fire-protection with access; 9a,b,• 15: Increased, natural resource use would occurs particularly, in construction of numerous access roads and driveways. Increased vehicular use and fuel consumption }vould al:,o occur in this outlying area as residents commute to the Chico Urban Area. 11, 12: The Forest Ranch Ridge has an existing low population density. Increased allowable development densities Land demands for additional similar rezones (and subsequent land divisions) would increase population and develcipment in the area. 13a,c This project itself could add up to 100 ADT on Schott Road artd at the Schn'tt Road intersection with Highway 32, The majority of the traffic will be traveling toward,hico/Forest Ranch. 'Existing daily traffic volumes on this state 7iighway have been measured at 1500 ADT in 1979 (2400 ADT peak month volurnes). Therefore, 'tr1if£ c increases on Hig} way 32 may increase and are not expected to catase- significant cone .tn since the highway is Well below capacitj► use. ftowever, if' large areas of the Forest Ranch Ridge become .rezoned to allow smaller parcels, and development actually occurs at 1+ acre densities, then traffic on Flighway 32 would increase substantially causing congestion throughout the ridge on the highway, as well as At intersecting streets. Appendit Vpage, 80 of 9 `' 80-12-10-03 DISCUSSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION (continued) 13.f: Sight distance onto highway 32 from Schott Road is adequate and congestion at this intersection should not occur as a result Of project implementation. flOwever> west -bound traffic on this arterial highway :is fast-moving(downhill travel), creating site access concerns from ingress and egress traffic movements. Cumu latiye traffic impacts from area -wide rezones would be created congestion and passible hazards. on Highway 32 and on local access i`oadsD t,nd at intersections a creased traffic on Highway 32 south of forest Ranch, enroute co Chico, could increase hazardsdue to the steeper road grades (encouraging.fas't travel) and } nurlerous curves on narrow ridges above steep Canyonlands. 14 Residential development in outlying areas is growth -inducing to the various public services. Fire protection requirements are of particular concern due to the high fire hazards,;particularly in nearby canyon areas, The nearest fire protection station ,is the Forest Ranch station, li miles south. `Adequacy of protection should be assessed by the Butte County Fire Department for the entire rivdge subsequent to School sfull buildout at l+ acre densities etvices are limited, particular) ment and res ue�ttial .use at 1+ acre pascel�derror 5Jties�throughout the ridge. 16a,b: Consi,derab'le utility extensions and increased capacity may be necessary if higher density development is achieved. 16d, 17a: Soil cor,,dition and terrain may limit the area suitable for leach fields. Sewage disposal characteristics are the ultimate determining factor in actual land divisions. Specific soil tests will, be required in consideration of actual land division, An divisions must meet the requirements of the Butte County Envir n- mental H©a1t,�;t Department, , l7bi InerVase,d density of development and residential use in this high fire hazard area will intensify fire hazards and expose greater numbers of residents to danger (incidence of increase). mash caused fires would 19: Increased development at the proposed 'density' will substantially modify the Forest Manch ,community's character and land use pattern. Considerable gpen forested land would, be 1ost� converted to 1+ acre ranchotte homesites. 21: An archasologfical s to survey of ridgeland proper.t:ies"is recommended. Sensitivity in this locality is moderate, Appendix P page 8f of 0 } DISCUSSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION (continued) 221)4 This rezone has the potential to establish a new, m:te intensive development pattern and density throughout the a,,pa,- modify;ing the 1976 Forest Ranch Rezone. The TM -5 district was formulated and established to reflect the natural limiting factors of the land and to maintain a suitable rural residential density for this outlying area. 22c: Those impacts which are cumulatively considerable are those indicated by"yes'or'maybe°responses on the initial study checklist. The E.I.R. requirement is based primarily on the,potential for growth -inducement. ARidge follows: An analysisofof the cumulative effect of this rezone on the Forest Ranch The Forest Ranch Ridge is predominantly zoned TM -5, a large, single zoning district that begins south of the project site and traverses the ridgelands north arouns the community of Forest Ranch and beyond further north for a distance of four miles or more. This TM -5 district covers an estimated area of 2300 acres total.,, Currently, an estimated 300 parcels ;averaging + 8 acres each)` exist within this single,district. The theoretiLal maximum development potential within this district, under current TM -5 zoning, is an estimated 460 5 -mere parcels (an additional 160 parcels), The proposed TM -1 toning pattern could become established throughout this existing TM -S district (cumulative request for replacement of the TM -5 district if the precedent becomes established and subsequ2nt rezOnings actually are sought, as occurred on Doe Mill ridge recently),' If this occurred, then an estimated + 2000 1 -acre parcels are potential, an additional ± 1700 parcols and future residences (growth rate of 600+%) Resultant development impacts from this potential cumulative growth are: (nut including growth from development of existing vacant properties) E 1. Traffic increases, on the order of 3500-700.0 average daily traffic units (ADT) or more (based on,a generation rate of 2'-4 trip ends per residence; if the standard`` ;I urban rate of 7-10 were realized, much greater traffic would result). This increased traffic would be prew j dominantly funneled onto highway 32, which has an existing traffic volume of 1500-2400 ADT (1979 Cal- trans count). Appendix F - Iaage 8g of 9 k J {I a 80-1210-0"3 ' DISCUSSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION (continued) Z. Increased,eros on from road and driveway development, n additional 1700 £-acre and from grading a ± hal of homesites, 3. Increased draw -down on limited groundwater resources from additional residences, 4. Increased tree cutting and vegetation removal for homesite clearing (an estimated ± 800 ;acres for +1700 half -acre homesites). 5. Increased wildlife habitat incompatibilities, and losses of habitat and open hand. i. G. Increased residential densities, population growth., urban -type noise and activity-, and possible incompatibilities with existing land uses and residents. Aesthetic impacts would occur because {i of increased densities (loss of desired Forest Ranch community character). 7 Increased public service demods especially fire ` protection service. (The existing fire protection is provided primarily by a volunteer station). t, } i Appendix F - page "gh of 9 ,_ t I I SINTi() SCH t srpEfr Arra Nes .. P Q STATE ANCI ill, coog PO"AGC 4 g LIXu. 94(101, 6EGIVfi:1Y 4 4SiRICTEOUr'LIveRy, _, aHOW TO WDOM Alin 0A1E d 0EJ"AHO v: SAOW TO NOM I)ATE, ANp a ADDR($S 0f pFdtVEAY d 4 CL a a DELIVERED AIN RESiRim 4 DELIVERY a o x _ VTOWHOM,DATE MD - °GF'As-,WSS 61AYYWITNSIWEU[14E TOTAL POSTAGE AMD PEES' ffi POSTMARK OR OATS t C 4 c i CERTIFIED MAIL FEE, STAMPS TO ARTICLE TO COVER FIRST CLASS POSTAGE, EE, AND CHARGES EDA ANY SELECTED OPTIONAL SERVICES. (sod (root) 1, It you want this 0010 Postmarked, stick the gummed stub on the left portion bl the address. side of the article, "leaving the noel t attached, and present the article at a post office service window or hand it to your rural carr or. (no extra charge) 2, If you de not want this feedlot postmarked stick the gummed stub on the lett portion of the y address side of the article, date, detach and 'etale the receipt, and mail the article. S Il you want a return receipt, Write the certified•mail number and your name and address on a ands if aeiace pirmitt, Otherw se and x to back of article Endorse frontlof ar icleeRETURN RECEIPT` 1EgUESTED au,auent !o the number, I 4. If you -want dohvet re's,rioled to the addressee, or to an allthOtizOd agent of the addressee, endorse RESTRIOTER OEVYERY on tiro front of the Article, 5. filter fees for the sotVes requested in the appropriato spaces on the frpnt of tills 'r�eipt. if return receipt Is roo, ested check the applicable blocks in Item 1 of form of of 1. t?. Save this receipt and present it if you make inquiry. T opo 1017-27e-rr2 i SENDCRS Complete Items 1, nd 3, Add Yop.,`ad4ceu bi Ow "AMM To"Vece mr met sa i 1.1110 rbHoWing setvlcc Is requested (dock ona;) C(1 Shovj to,:whom and data dellvc dd..:ra..i.... . ¢.. O Show to.whorn, dato and Wtodp of deflveryt.-d G) REISTRICMD bEUVERY Show to Whom and IS to dchnied............�4 Rr..".TRICTCID E]aivrRY, lahow to whom, dato,; and Wins of dclin y,S..._- (CONSULT Po,i mAsTm voit rCE'S) 2, M7ICU ADORCCUO 70, Stat�a Claaring}souse' 37AtitICLE DESCnb•r1oNt ftCCiu'(ERCD No. CCit7ivttb ND, INSURED Pr`D. -(Altvr; to obtain sl7naturo at addres p or opont) E t•.3vo iecchcd I}id arttclo ds:rfbdd abdYo; m EIGId NTUR11 OAddraisce C3Anuiotlicd s pnt h a. a na F"y�v�x 1981 `� 11 4 C. IIDORt3SSIContpiato o3nly It requat - ��.. M 10 m0: u!WLE tri oalvgn 9Hcau8E1 p N4.WiTtAU - a of L 9 SENDCRS Complete Items 1, nd 3, Add Yop.,`ad4ceu bi Ow "AMM To"Vece mr met sa i 1.1110 rbHoWing setvlcc Is requested (dock ona;) C(1 Shovj to,:whom and data dellvc dd..:ra..i.... . ¢.. O Show to.whorn, dato and Wtodp of deflveryt.-d G) REISTRICMD bEUVERY Show to Whom and IS to dchnied............�4 Rr..".TRICTCID E]aivrRY, lahow to whom, dato,; and Wins of dclin y,S..._- (CONSULT Po,i mAsTm voit rCE'S) 2, M7ICU ADORCCUO 70, Stat�a Claaring}souse' 37AtitICLE DESCnb•r1oNt ftCCiu'(ERCD No. CCit7ivttb ND, INSURED Pr`D. -(Altvr; to obtain sl7naturo at addres p or opont) E t•.3vo iecchcd I}id arttclo ds:rfbdd abdYo; m EIGId NTUR11 OAddraisce C3Anuiotlicd s pnt h a. a na F"y�v�x 1981 `� 11 4 C. IIDORt3SSIContpiato o3nly It requat - ��.. M 10 m0: u!WLE tri oalvgn 9Hcau8E1 p N4.WiTtAU - NOTICE OF PREPARATION' Butte County TO: _ FROM: Environmental.Review (Responsible Agency. cad bency 3 County Center: Drive Address '" -` (Address) Oroville, CA 95965 SUBJECT: Notice of Preparation of a Draft Environmental Impact Report Butte County will be the Lead Agency and will prepare an environmental impact report for the project identified below. We need to know the views of your agency as to the scope and content of the environmental, information which is germane to your agency's statutory responsibilities in connection with the proposed project. _ Your agency will need to use the EIR prepared by our agency when consideringdour permit or other approval for the project. The project description, 'location and the probable environmental z effects are contained in the attached materials'. A copy of the Initia F Study /�% is, /-% is not, attached,. Due to the time limits mandated`b State law, onse must be s45 $ sent at the earliest possible date but not laterutthan days after receipt of this notice, 'lease send your response to Larl D:. Nelson at the Address shown above. We will need the name fora Contac person in y our a enc r� y -PROJECT TITLE: Rezone: TNI-5 to T114-1 AP # 56-28.-31 and 33 ERD Log # 80-12-10-03 M PROJECT APPLICANT, IF ANY: Douglas:Starr DATE FobIruary. February.11, 198i Signature Title Environ. Review Specialist Telephone (.916) 534'-4717 Ir NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC All interested persons are hereby notified that a Draft Fnvironme.ntal Impact Report (EIR) is being prepared for the following project; ,Douglas Starr - AP N 56-28.31 and 33 - Rezone of 19.88 acres from TM -5 to TM -1, located 300 feewest of Highway 32 off Schot Road, 1�-2 miles north of ,Forest Ranch. One acre homesi'tes would be allowed. Commentsregarding environmental concerns and issues which ought to be included in this ETR are solicited. Such comments can be submitted in writing to the Butte County Environmental Review Department, 3 County Center Drive, Oroville, California within ten days of the date of publication of this notice, �- f Earl D. Nelson Environmental tat Review Director To be published in the Chico t Enterprise Record on Wednesday, February 18, 1981.! j% r k;: LAND OF NATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY ENVIRONMENTAL. REVIEW DEPARTMENT` EA R L .D, NELSON, Director January 22, 1981 Douglas Starr P. 0. Box 365 Forest Ranch, CA 9.5942 RE: Rezone to Thi-] AP H 56-28-31 ,and, 33 ERA bog # 80-12-10-03 hear Mr. Starr: We have completed the 'initial study of potential environmental impacts related to your proposed .and division. The results o£. our evaluation are explainedin the enclosed initial study check- list, Appendix rtFtr. Because of potentially significant environmental im acts artic- ularly growth inducement and cumulative effects, anpimpacp treport, is required pursuant to the requirements of the California En vironmental Quality Act. y The i3utte County Environmental Review Guidelines require that you, as the applicant, submit information in the form of,a draft E.I.R. within 225 days from the date of receipt of this notice at • processing q prior to finalizing th tsao£BEI.R. is required. We re uire ade os t of the estimated draft. This cost may vary depending on the cmpletenessour �ofethe material suL•mitted. The customary minimum deposit for projects' of this type is $600.00. If you wish to appeal the requirement for preparation of an E.I.R. you may file a written protest specifying the reasons therefor with the Environmental Review Department. This must be done with- in 15 days from the date of this notice. If no 'written protest is timely filed, an'E.I.1R. will be required. f The E.I.R, should frilly address all the. impacts identified on the checklist, including growth inducement and the cumulative impacts. Project alternatives should be fully explored in, the E.Y.R,: Also, the E.T.R, should discuss feasible project design features o£ future landtses that would reduce environmental impacts. 3 Cdrenly Cenler !)ripe - Orouille, California 0965 - Telcjphond, (916) 5344777 GOVERt ` R'S OFPIf.E a• e• �t . y ,x , . �:: • OF FI E .OF. °PLANNING „ AND RESEARCH r. 1400 TENTH $` REET' r' SACRAMENTO 98814 .EDMUND 6, BROWN JR; a �trv(rtrtsnluninf +..w;.Yrr � ,, 00 ve "NOR j .-Febr4ary 23,v, 1981. RrlHo cel ur TO: Reviewing A .ncies PROM: Ron Bass SUBJECT: Butte County',s NOP for Rezone: TM -5 to TM -1r SCH #81022408 p. Attached for your comment isDutte County's Notice of Preparation of a'` draft Environmental Impact Report ('£IR) for Rezone: TM -Cb to Ttlwl. Responsible agencies must transmit; their concerns and co scope and ontent Of the EIR focusing on specific information re the p 9 p � atinn related statutory responsibility, within 45 days of receipt of this notice. We encourage commenting agencies to respond to this notice and impress .'their .-concerns early in the environmental review process,„: , Please direct your comments to Earl D. Nelson - k, Butte County Environmental Review, 3 County Center Drive Oroville; CA 95965' j with a COPY to the Office of Planning and Research. Please refer to the ; State Clearinghouse number noised above in; all correspondence concerning i this project,, ess; call i Ifi you have any questions about the review roc eat (916) 322-8515. p y .. R8: v1 ti Attachments V/ ce: Earl D. Nelsen w } .. . i •.. a a woweiw++ • - - SCC #81022408 1 • N !4111 i le ;fir d QaarC• I= - ISCO SGr+aei: Sa eo$« CA 96814 . S1 d imU9SdJ fast TryRear 0401of 'Parts saki ua>c•wrldw i= 9 Sir. II's I I r1h F't SserataaanCo. - CA 99814 916?=44111 0 Jlttias,Trmvix Cal I form& Can=I ComW„i.4� 631 HwnlV Stme, 4th F1aor, UR FrWC1%C . CA 94105 si 3/S4,T-ate n1et daai Cfaoom office of wittarfie P+UaxrA 40W i7.Z1t x Str*C ftal t . Third Flom* Sacrmm "Ca. CA 96814. 9.1 Q1 s"'Zi-�3Tlr;I iLlnr� F4fier CaI 1 Renis enarw Carmen slim tQI1 t . Re,V 131 3' 531 --mm nCs. CA 95m 91611.9-"S. �= Ronan Xw" Pod I Ile I t C1 fa 0173106 ��11istvf StrBaat Sari Fruclur.. CA 94149 419/51;•1249 Beft Hit Ur- C/ilTmm o of VWC& of AwfOnaaa6lc� i1za.' Sb"C Sderasaaarseer. CA '93814 9t613�'$-93m~34• tlmi samdr,' Roelumclon• »card 1416 r3intt Sla."t Saer&Wffed. (tA �JIr14 47.6/Rd9�Y6a� , 0 "we:. of Uicinq usd ' Carw4y', Itiz9 S S Sacramm ea. CA 95814. 3S 6/ ��16.7 S'.r'. uy Cara. Cev' C C= M 'taw Itmx, Avem. Rout W1 Sad Fra else . CA 94LICZ 415/5?gT•�3tidiN R9Ir Mavis. bvi ren. ?row m: Ca®ft- Cwr— of Cmer- tciam 1416 111n par Stator. Raw -1354, ucrumneu CA 9981$ •g16/a�b�yi,,73.'' � 57 ► Sot Id jaim ftwac*mrse 1,0&gr 10 18 fiinm Strmwe. P.uw,iQd Sae.-9momft•. CA 951114. g16dC2.jr.-�91i3 p RflQsstve IR��YY., ;else. of Ftsbaadra 1!4.16 - 7111 Strpiwc SAwts neo.. CA 941113 h16/4rs31�'43' • _ la�i i'�K-fin �l�i •. � Sum Lmas Cumaaisslan i�7P - 13th Stmt: Smerammnsm, 0; ISM -4 91fr/7ZZ-TAt3 � W Caeeta Sri vie: ot"F'assd 6sra rlgricslE:i+•a `atme Sacrae+mm' rA 35Rta , 718/c3t�3-�iriRZ J41rn Hieddl : an 5taeaa Uaatst Iascurcas rant"I i;ard 21 3 . 14 ft Stratwr Sa=M=. Q; }.61114 416/3Z�-;583 °' q` P.Sul Cox At= of 'Far'"rr7 1416 ttin Strawc. R4,m 1306-17 :acramOm. CA 79814 7 t i5/sag.; I c4 0 4a F04 low Cmc. of rdaic®r O"Ou' rus ' 1416 ;cinch StrrwC,. Saeram"Co. CA 99F1i1 9 i V"11-1446 •lama45t Harttr'nvf Ube of r-srtwral Se"ices 1n 19 L 3 t"19C SacrasVRCO, CA 45,114 91fs/�5 77»rf 1 Nrirtsy Callus ".ptlE. rr f this Ito? 714 0 ;rrwlE. ?orri•r 1?ti racrmm�rEo. rA »•^;1w fi "1'r9 `x f 11 i e1P• �r>ra a �nr•,tnt►.:' ^r]•!'n ?21 inch °ur�n�. Ark flanr of UUTMULIST' D orftentt of Tremr-t—, titan u1sTrIct Contacts. Bob Brow Jim- Jei i-nek Oaparmant of rmn ortation Oepartneni: of Transportation District 1' 0Oistri ct 9 T a�''-i 'nTo S. •t Mouth Main Street Eureka,, 'CA, 965al' Bishop, CA 94514 Robert L mc8r=w Johan Gagliano, Oaf of Tr&n . en O rtMian of '"franspar tot an Di i.ct 2 Oi stri c t: 10 TOM�resrside Orive T 'C�artar way Rdddi n9+ CA 96001 Stacktnn, CA 95206, R. Q. Sk dwrs Jinn ;Cheshire �( DePartmt of 'Transpm-tai ion Oi stri ct 3 Ompa nt a F& Transpor tiaarr A) � District 11 Mar7wi tt:m, rA q.�az San 01 ep , CA 92738 Robert W Si eke, JrY. Fi sti and Game tleqlorw O ffi ees Oest of '1'r�nspos�tiorr Oistetct a. 7ITTaTtiit A. Naylor, p�gianaT Manager Saul Franc i s=, CA 94T 02 OePaftmra of Fish and Game 0 627 Cypress - � Win Evans. Redding,, CA 96001 Oepa,rtm"t of Transportation 0 i ski ct 5 ii. Lassen, ' ,Regional Massager Spat Luis Obisp ,tGA Oepa�rtu of Fish and Gages 93419T 1701 (Nimbus Road, Suite A Rancho Cortlova, CA 95670 Mash Par l i esA DOPaftnent of T'ttmportation B. Hunter,. Regional Manager District 6 Oeparftent of Fish and Game '01 ivd Avenue � Yauntui�l l a Facility, Bldg.. C' Fresno, CA 93778 YoWntville, CA 94599 A. H. Hendrix G. INokes, Regi ossa 1 Manager Department of Transportation Department of Fish and Game Dis trio 7 Ll 1234 Ea3t Shaw Avenue fpr ng Stt°eet Fresno9 �A 93726 Los Angeles. CA gaOlz Fred A. Worthley Jr., Regional Manager Harvey Sm' Department of Fish and Game is ricont, of Transposrtation 350 Golden SDiore Dis4rict B Long Beach, CA 9Q802. �.. 24""'�"Wes� °"Third Street ' xoae s t Ranch i. omrnuniby 46.61n. § P. p0���_. -,fox 381 a Fo e-6 n�JAl�ih, Ca. ,95942 r �^ '� s �'r ha'xj.y'�y� + �• �vTrnnmornai' Corigv+ L7��fi. Febwa/ty 25, 1981 Iqq d` Zai D. N4Zzon. Ertraitannten,fu,C Re7yr�et,r lkt,ec�ii Butte 'Cour `t9 -rnabwnm<:rt.&9 ne),,14 r Dept 3 Counfyc Cer .tcit Dla2)e Orto v.LQ fie, ca. 95965 14P and 33 Dean tIA, Nex,30nr The /oQLatair<d. cattacne P-o#,wrjt4V nergwwungr W"ide4t_c•anz -the 12anclt Cornmuni..ty k>S.dOGLf,L:LLan ,tli,rtlLe arer..ant n.eernerti3 orQ size F.i, i2, .Gl1l�1ai a) Den b i,b�ppI r 7 Tile .61111,wundlny a.&ea.5 a". a,L.8 M-5 oa m Xaiu t/:e conrmurzL't c .L� .to rte.tu�.n.. a.6 xanlnrd, /� e and �nne4at hvu g a ih;.s P2oPoiecl PaaceL, ng .to r(J 7 corx�d comwi�terlut;ne up -to T# wePL'� (orc vyuctr crt9ent n.1441 w«& -IL y,6tem�. lde do no i .to � ont eft � 1-40"g"40, -e-an Ae Pyuaven. P Po7�erttla ditrir !J<ltl t'iarucCC, t/r,iG 4:s n. t4kzLe�thecl > n a then '046pei4-t..i.e s and we&/, dot+rn a .`team r,.Jton,e lu'� LOM ite.3.r den tu`r�. den -UY IL" Qeen aPp��ove,rl. Z� 4b •Q .t`/t.e po.ad >�..Ln' nur�u'ttyi :off' t�tuQC-s tur?rl r7Pai�t z`!te dcwna,tertm avr�aQ'i o axt,teir, i C) Selwg4. rhe {wYrintiat a{' icy' �taPz`a;a �sy�iem�, �on er/cuvat?en� cli�pala� ���t`em) itz rr. <lzirdairz�t ttt<zteir laerl cUuM-sen.i„ou.34, conz?<urt rur supprx; e� dawn. �terun, d) Acce.d.Q:• ;dP rdau6r( quer t i on/ze tzcc� d z?a e i tfccn fli4ftrKxraf?, Srito t t l5�orut!� F')'Z".t Rant Road yPWM Llu* �tanclPoLrta` �a f� tt�.P.urne, M,. Ae and �SaPn� Fone t, Ranch Road .i.6 Walw .4gy *n .rub'= ��rut'rrrcr/, cdndCLL�on rcndl Srlwti 12<1 �� unpoved, gAatre.0 ori{'¢. The .6c/,nU�' raccn � �.h .us Fo tedL� llu zc/t %2<ip anti frru rhfPxlrtcn crs Pcc1.�tittrtjt .t`�tu;tc cluunry/r .sclzoo.2 yeurc, e) 4nap F4a�;. Aedu6l-gthe a.. r P . ce.lr 4Lze to TY+! -r Vicom ir�w5 a4a,24 .in .4.e.tiaden Vie p1wpo sect � r �2 crrtd ilre rpt •�a.�� <urn« D,�F4�„y� Panclt. liLrt:Lrnaz'e Cry, va-6 .8e0z1,6 to Buz a r�ru nq 2erlue a � i rt z`!t� artea iw.tlt .ate je3ultant prw�.Pe»z3 irz Pcr�ta�rurPl� � �y c� and d, ffp��ecL ' Tlt.a .L.e et ieeay.i�� ;�y+.e�s.ted un.eu wL.��uld•ir�j..eo.4� of n Pstn i ' cGt iuo'n anal Lt<LL.r' '. rre �otutc . fit' mesion, Thi ne0.0 a taee b Fort ltdme ,d.i..iu� araC acen .s wi-u zevena4 urn .thew l�a'arzce�,, S'fATC OF CALIFORNIA-REsoURCEs AGENCY STATE WATER RESOURCES CON` .ROL BOAR6 Ko':BOX 900, SACRAMENTO, CAL!r-oRNIA 66801 March 5, 1981 CDMUND G, HROWN JR„ Covonor •. �I d Mr. Earl A. Nelson Butte County Environmental Review 3 County Center Drive OrovilZe, CA 95965 Dear Mr. Nelsonz NOTICE OF PREPARATION (NOP) SOH 51022408 --BUTTE COUNTY'S NOP FOR REZONE:; TM -5 TO TM -1 Thank you for the opportunity to review the subject NOP. A copy of your NOP has been forwarded to the appropriate California Regional Water Quality Control Board. If the Regional Board determines that specific conceime not listed in this letter should be included in your draft EIRf they will re- spend to you within 45 days, In general, the State and Regional Hoards have the legal requirement to protect water quality ail to provide for reasonable use of water. To help us fulfill these mandates, your draft EIB: should 15r."6vide information con- cerning the relationships of the proposed project to water quality and -water rights, as listed below. 1. WATER QUALITY (Surface and Groundwater A. Applications or permits required. B Kinds and quantities o;° materials to be disposed of and treatment and disposal facilities --this should include a discussion of the relationship of the project's discharge to the capacity of existing and proposed treatment facilities. C. Construction activities (including grading) that could result in water quality impacts. Di Soil characteristics relatnd to water quality (erosion, siltation, percolation, seismic characteristics), i. �. y STATE, CSFCALIFORNIA—RESOUNCES AGENCY --,...,EDMUND O, DROWN JR„ Goyemo, DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME REGION 2' 1761 NIMBUS ROADS SUITE A , RANCHO CORDOVAN CALIFORNIA 95670 (916) 355-7030 �vl,anmenlal RQviow f�aa1„ 1981 d i MAH ; � _ .. BLIN c, , March 19► 1981 Mr. ;Earl D. Nelson Butte County Environmental Review 3 County Center Drive oroville, CA 95965 tear Mr.. Nelson e The Department of Fish and Game has reviewed the Butte County NOP to Rezone (TM -5 to TM -1) 19.88: acres near Forest Ranch (SCH 81022408). The following concerns along with mitigation measures to protect the fish and wildlife resources should be addressed in the EIR: E 1. The loss of deer winter range. r 2• Pc sible adverse water quality impacts to the s in Sutte Creek watershed caused b fishery Y project construction. 3. Impacts to rare and endangered plant and animal -species. M 4 Se,ondary human disturbance ,impacts on wildlife; harassment by domestic pets, etc. Thank you dor the opportunity tcomment on the subjeot.ExR. We look forward, to the opportunity to review the graft EIR when }} it is completed'. If we can be Of z<urther assistance, please contact Jerry Mensch, Environmental. Services Supervisor, telephone (916) 355-1030. Sincerely, Raul T. Jensen Regional Manager , 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALWORNIA 95965 PNONEs $34.4601 IVO°Cinl)�`.1, '18, 1.981 Douglas S. P. C. 13ox 365 Vo!rest ':Ranch, CET 95912 RE: Rezone of 19.9 acres from W1,5 to 1 NP81�31 63s-33, �. C.og k _80-12-10-03 Dea r i Ir. Starr letteY tivas sent to you on ,lanuary 22, 1,981 ailv,ising that an environrnenta:l impact ;repQrt was required Foil the abovo mentioned project. The Butte County` Csnv.ironmerital Review Guidelines require that a draft B. C.R. be subin:ittuLl to this Office within 225 days From the elate Of rcce i vi ng not-ification that ah F.I.R. is requa.rod. `rhi 225 day time period has expired: Ptfe`rso contract our OU"ice Within. the next trn days between 8 ".111. and. J. P.M. stating your ;i:ntuntions rcgal-ding this 'f p�r•ojer.t, 1F you intend to continue with the apPli,cation please send tris a letter r•equusting an extension of time .For submittal OF a draft Fl C R. which 111CIudes the rc.Asons rvhy the time extension is necessary. [.f we do not hear from your we will assuitte you intend to teruti.nate process g this application. Thank you for your at to this tttatter. Sincerely, ,I Richard 'C . molca,r 2nV:i,ronrncntat Review Sl)eci a i.st RCm,:,tkt 'F < m w aur tea.,. 05-21-80 - COUNTY OF S It T T E (PI800') PACE 3525 ST PARCEL t3€IMSEF OFFICE DF THE ASSESSOR MAPPERS DOCUMENTLIST CO OMP PG, EL. •PRC I ASSESSED G6NER / CARE OF OWNER NAME CO[1E PECORnFR NO STREET ADORE CITY AND STATE AREA BOOK PAG YR 10 056-28-0-026-0'.DOERSCHLAG DONALD A E BONNYLEE L PQ BOX 127 FQREa4' _ 0 056-28-0-029-0; RANCH 056-28-0-030-0' CA 95942 056-28-0-031-0 062-21' 056-2P.-0-032`-0 1725'-2.27-71 G0 '956-28-0-027-0 GEOPGE WORTH 8 E BEVERLEY LYNN RT i BOX 200 �£ 00 056-28--0-028-0 DURHAM CA 95,938 062-21 1RS9-286-73 CRABTREE EDWARD E LUCILLE, E' STAR RT SUGAR PINE RD FOPEST RANCH CA 95942 062-21-1859-284-73 00 Q56 -?8-0-0-2.9-0 GRIMES PONNY-LEE L. 275 HILLTOP DR #74 REDOING- CA 96001 062-21 2351`-207-70 :56-28-0-030-0 DOERSCHLAG DONALD. A E BONNYLEE 209 LA CRUZ AVE 0 056-28--0-033-0 HILL8RA'E CA 056-28-0-034-0 94030 062 -21'.172S -22T-71 00 056-28-0-0:31-0 STARR- DOUGLAS. S P O 80X 365 €QREST RANCH CA 95942 062-21 2478-352-80 00 '056-Z8 CASWELL ROBERT L ETAL P0 " SOX 281 FOREST RANCH CA 95.9.42 062-21 2326-117-78 0'0.056-28-0-033-0/ STA:RR HOMER C ETAL. TR P 0 STARK' DOUGLAS S BOX 365 FOREST `RANCH' CA 95442 '062-21 2439-145=79 00 056-28-0-034-0 ECKN'ANr hO.RA P O'BOX 264 FOREST RANCH CA. 95942 052-21 2439-079-79 00 056-28-0-035-0 V/ FUGITT CLA 0 6 JANE A P O BOX 5.5: FOREST' FOREST' RANCH CA, 95942 062-21 1627-522-70 00 056.-28-G-036-0 OLA 0 E JANE A P pi BOX 5:5-� FOREST RANCH' CA 95.942 062-2.1 1627-522-70 QW 14_28-0-037-Q b -28-0-03T-0 �, FUGIT7 OLA O E JANE A P 0 BOX 55 FOREST RANCH CA 95942 062-21 1627-522-70 IQ 056-2 9-0-001,-0 GIANFORTONE LOUISE 5925: JORDAN AVE 0 056-29-0-013-0 EL CERRITD CA 056-29-0-014-0 9453G 06-2-21 1695-.057-71 056-29-0-01.5-0 os6_29-0-016-0 10 05b -29-G=002-0 MARYLANCER PHILIP E LILYAN 2059 KEY 'BLVD 0 056-29-0-017-0 EL CERRITO CA 056-29-0-01.8-0 94530 056-29-0-019-t2 062-21 368S.-044-71 056.-29-0-020-0 10 056-29:-0-003-0 MARKOVICH PATRICK J E A1'AURiNE 0 056-29-0-007-0 056-29-0-008-0 00'000 062-21 16Pt5-061.=? 1 =; l056.-29-0-004-0 MCFARREN 'EUGENE M E JULIANNE` 1063: W@DOLAN4 0 OS6-29-0-032-0 CHI:CO CA 056-29-0-03:3-6--, 95926 062-2I' 1737-329-72 1 10 OS6-29-0-G05-0 - SCHRE-UR CLARENCE E EVELYN L 1590: YOUNG AVE ' 0 056-29-0-030-0 PARADISE Ca 95969 062-21 0"56-29-0-034-0 056.-31-0-00-6-o 1771-384-72, w'•'�•,..�+1 � lrn,�^� •n , , ;� ; �+ �:.1• ,i„ e ,' L » i„� al � �,% � �/• t ♦�� i ��, ' _,-19. s•v,..j, err.. r�� � . ��, ��.0 , � �� t � a�• L� r1��` �� ) d i : • � �� �Z Z,, ...L-' i•• T' ....�� � r� � �� �Y �r'/'� •�X•i� ' e,�: �.�I�.' ♦ �'"� r. 2pVtL re ILL—ie i •wr ( e e�,. r t, ` r • ♦ Y•"+rC'•+'+' s - : r ......;,.' p d . + t 1 S:ti1eo-.. LE«yUJ��'A. ., �^Y ,(K'.al 1 J �.. "•,�, e♦.,,w+ - n. ,✓:.�. • n. ...• , x '3 'i, . '� � y,r : 3v •., , .•� 1 �• )l �� S2 • eJi » •'i ' ti;^ ���", a 1, F• [ � '� �J �{ +� a ' J. � ,♦♦.. • �J e.... �• ,3 � A , W 'r � �,� J�.�;1 � e �-- �-.. ..,.., firT^ � L �.,. r S C 4 �.'ta 7A!. tYi )'�+ Y ' i?p'y r •. ,� � r ^f4.�>pf y'/ I � f \� ,,• r _ rN1 r "'Nit m'. r tom' •` " •' r� a .. �1.. J 3T'YQ2t'•., "♦ . 'C)V � • ��i Awl. � • (` / M: f _ r. �a� A t •.,,;:-' • rte,-” " ',7 �� 1..E G f_ N TM -160 iFe 'S3 It r�.��']I,r,y„„�„���'s�'1�.. ��if•� tt��1 ,t."�"""`"wrat��J^•rr� '�,"�;;,r,�, � , y s �L.•�* i TM -40 �4^^•�e„�"' -•.."�-�.-�--.a,.� ti. . I �'�'etit'p�'%}��*w'rx �t,Yr�.• ��rf�,� '. ` PAS - ` t _jr r ".. r ' ✓� L \ 6 Vii. � try a 1711r�7 f T, r,z R� �7 WIO o•j F'C'r 5l l- „ • , •; ; "�r'�T� r' ,t� r; T f �,,ra� t. �,,,.,�. S r: U:i9 Ie' j%f7 4�,r �C!' � •�+.'rt ar��� '�` �_ '{ ,.+.r i � � i `•r,A,w�d ge�rr 5p:..e1 � i ,�' �� ^... I/T� 777 �t �� r' \���� �3 R. i !' � rJ ♦a ver f'^ '. JO ° *'' zh r•f Y+. 2% • 'ze'Iry r„ �® z yyJ ' `I� Y J ZO p» f -e Wy r•r.....aM r.:� • r• :. • ^•(,�.j i]%+' ♦ 1 `• a ' �. 7� Y N•r; N 4N � � �, • �(� G� Y � w.,''• Q. Y. I �\ 1 e� ,ter,•'•, e I J i`( v,. l`'' , , A +� 11 0 Y .a, rd C ' � Y w�,y ; •, a * ,7.).� GY` 4• e 0 'tit, IV lilt lt _, ►,(} 1� %J 8 j YQ r �ti, aj !';l� ti, 4 / •,�, " �1 rev �� 1 •� • r�„--'' , �' " i�rw"� �'t`. ><I�i `i��,�' 1 tsx..W1 x• , , .�.:p „ _ � e _ � � ' ,� �"�"'` : , � + In� /fes, [+,(7��.q} �� rv-. Y•��..-•1� �.h�3j-w.���yt. .w,w,4 '�•� `�a� w.., ��r"�'M^'•N' tarp "�'.`.' ,•Tt„»� fj,:R,•,�.�' �.ie.•�•1-..�--w L 1 .. 7 • .."'. _ ' Y „ti� .r� �.et.w...wy�' " n. .Iw"'�r/� �:•' %�ar.... �*w IC > ' I +^f•�'� �,p• H� V l.l. �} �`'`-�wl r f+r� ♦ ' I h ,♦ �°'Y ��,� � 1 ,>, # . � ...-.9 , � ^.Y rjh.yw. .e �ai• ' •n`"�`'�� ei „t, `.v j .- '' ~' "� �• yS:lrry"rr 1 �A F2A D I S 1 ` C' ti a'•x` M ... :.. ri w J+ 1� Y'�.,. � .e ,. r 1....�.....t.,u-1`'.♦, .i..w1.:A.,„r«».r ,M+ ..r}- ,..r..w.,�.., iLW. .+»..,.._ - e�F�'r..+''•f•,•'. 'i ( I,. , !"« 'x l i 11� J _✓Sx %,, � I b + '' r✓ r r "�� � �� -,,� " U Al y�/r'1(L �,(7+(•� W !;+ > � �b"., i (. f o 1, , •.1 "T � l` RJ' I•" Y L ✓ r� rte' 1 I t . ° � YL;�i �,.., h ,Y�r�l! j � I '� � Y� 1^` ' �' .t ��r' n 1 f� '� .•. 1� ` � .J r,., GJ, � � 4.} r i w '~ 'r i � l a `e 1,,,.1 �` .,y . 1 1 �i :�. » � ".. 1 y'' I r 9 i M f r•7X � r :`^r," A VK ry.7 � a+ r .:». l.S xr { :.'t ��•„�: �"✓✓// �,V1 �� • )+•t •/ (� i � ,' Q' ,,' �A �'� �,C�1 s �� .. 1 �✓� T.^1 iA r c-1,,, lrj�, � r �� t (� ,. � o /l. "„ _� rs :k f Y j ar1`r' l wJ`oa - r i� t1r '' S�Ij�P�)1 is tY y4/' �J ;r; �� , '��k•�"�i t e Jill F3r� ;^ aaaa�; / +a ,+i Vit: }`Y4"•• L A li �1 % �:.h k�. �('�' , 0•' \.")Lvrs 1 �;����i).�4) )� '.•/ ' h .. ( / i4 ,rv�1Y ,s �i I,v ("A )l'•� {.�'.� yx t. '"� .* l �� '5 1`i''�/� �l. a3`^"� ,✓ ,{^ °,s• ! a r 1•'�I r. rYe r � ittt \ `;^�•,�.; ) iYr "��A, '; �^• 4 f e � II ) ,,. t � s�[ �qtF^( Y"r �„JY J7G14 1��+ ��.�x ..��.x4'��.~i%d, � r '•`1�. [, '( ...� ` 1 1.. I,..,r/./'l r� ,'' ;,': a y.% t• - �� fps +� �.,y. 1 l ?�. . �� � t �, � ,t��+�, ti•-„� >1 .':\ �' '' q, t fC�c/S/}r yMY o{ `sl f(t.� i fr � ` mow ' , 1 1 i�1 y L( +Z^ t4L �ML //+r �1f-� �Y90!--'?'�)�j o•. q.�+ �,.r,V° �1 ° � f f L � Li1" a'Y .`"I'�° � 1� Cr:�r, J � tw.V l�h�11•" r � t]'. '" .. ,. ♦ �'" t dry • �+ ° � Gr, �� T—h' � '" \ i � �` w 4 \ �'� r`�\/r) r J+7 °�. t{.'": l 1� 1\E. ?t.✓1 (.y 5 :. o ` i t•� L `.'�• j ).,�sv w� r \" iJ 1 '�` `I+� l.- kt:'�; ✓. xrtS = l .. r i w•.•.. ,( 1 r �• %r' ✓ ..n ]?3 _ n Irl 11r \ i? .J) \ i:lyl w�3r ia. 1}s 1+��(`rM-�s���•� 4 -Kt ., U� 1.. �• 'k, +� �,>!1'I 4 S �l�ft/ 1 •" „,� _,' \ t r% J L: \ �,`. r l \..M i" , {{�'£ Ar ..y�"�',,, •,� ��� r ;�L rr J �'f '� �r „��'����n `+�\t, yirt: r,ir �*�V T, r�L�%' ^ '"r, y, j }� �� fjj.��r A�1{t{L ��m ` ��tdJ o =. n _ �tt., _ , a f/��' 1, , r.. ,:., r r ; 5, �„ .,.r »,.Y"�,_ }; { , I, ! ; �`v • .�*.i ,% f' F `� S �` r.�" - ,Il; ,/ , , i t � � 14 �'' .,f � �S�c `" r '� l• � .. � 't rt„ ht,;,; �-M"`°,• �;° h-- 1<.~� F P f ) �`4^ _; /, r r� °i,d ,1�)C YLv ! _:a.r" 1t(11:,�!(('r ,� rlf .d rt�... ✓�)),�,fr.>J �' � l\i' f r g eM RYKAl, l! h, r e 1 ti 'N". ` L JJ {A• uN. L.. i• " "O > f 1 I o 1 �'.. ! 11 +�`.+ �. 'tif ��r C' ;r .. 2,'i: �.. `\� r •rr t, w '� =r � t�} � 1 1 � � T � �i t Fd "" � �✓e" \_,,r„�7•••7/�j r i L ��.� � �YY.L.� it �, � 1`..,J �1 r,4 �` �,r(f�l �I. Llr+ ,rr rr '.'firr f- � "•\'r' 1/_``ti.�, �" \-1 L ` �C��1� � ���j1`•'.i`` `r -- r 1+..�«F. F- «..1, � ,.r`.Nr= � �� H �rr-a N- f" "�r r { "r.- ,Y w- '•.,.:r .a,��, :{.� - ��.• � •. --.a-.,. .S?! ��' . S -k .'� � • y .� ,F ,� �,�; 3Lt,,,. �1 ""'�11��fi�' », t" 1 � yr 7i � b''���>� 0 1� ,1�(�(�"•-� Y✓ -.+ �i t. F'. }711 41r �t�U �i:�~.�,TS, alr i 'do-° ++v a v/ lz�� i•�y \ 4�l j; 2 -`.v4N `trf- .�t� `y�l,r°� stl +�% 8p YF,.o j Y`4 \\4�,� ✓� ii\ ��?�r',,9 V/ j ��^ "1 F r IV, y ,�L � : , 7�� �" / A I , by 1 � f i�.. it l • l.' 't['" " t,{{��''//p � n r 'M YA1 0," w s � � Al..tt 1 4 rli _t V it �,•/ r' r� r( � 1i� T�" k Joey \ rr I -,-", 1, Gert r r'�+"•^ 4i t��w+ J p'�� y \ tp 'rE S..ry".ns r�ir y.l r"y ••,,«+rd, {:C �^, (,[r{ t.-w'.-»,�L ' r.,u!�� @t". ��xt t'1 .l1jA ((( �•+ � 1 �+ � ' 11!! J. f J 'r' 1' i ,... � fi�,�� r� ��' � � �1 � _� ✓�� �` r 1�°' �' t .�*seuYry �J�� �� .,� �� ���� �i � .. i .,t: ".t.l SLI �- v r'j1 vY14 Mi ,Rf. 1 35' I (4'Q� d5. "vim j I1 %s�"'�drir i7A/J"+}Ir �.t1)Sji �N 4! t SY+.!"..x�^Ji �' + ) 4 \ � y �� rp �• 1 i rr r r."; 5 �" Y "5r-!%„ �,, jY•',\ ''/�Y��r y (t )r f�� �t '�r,- `��' •V '� • � .«_..,,,rte -r •-'-z- r�t r ti I . trt \"�V�l'111, �. ° }r« 3�.—•'=",.••� 1�.� 1a i , 1,. <:,r�� " * fir' i n t •• ' '�A � (�'� 1Y(�'� u��.1 � 1'�� 1 tt�') '; �+ • Q • J �r'�' i �� �" ,•a i ij A4 � " �� * a✓ : ! �•-\; �.,r � r i �,; �, � jy,i "� l,�ip'pwfrr'" � /'�S \ L I��� `��•� �. �". I. + � ',^'r•✓Y �1�' r�(/1 ,� r !!i'"' r "J Ir+ri +a�i +1 i G) � 4 r �'S'r7 � �I,F: 1YJ✓��t' U{�ry� ��r✓ 4 �J).� 1,1F � Y+ ' f ��.,,.�. S ` 3 A J��f?, ! .'i ✓ r r 1 � �' �( �. � "'•r ,Hc�,p ,J l�,! .. 1,� \ '� r, ii Y 61 "r��Ji*% •,^' ..... yS' •�t`.y � ��fti ,1'r,�_A '�` - � ! � �1 'r 'win Vol, � r )i 1 +� N_ i' 1 I gin;✓/�� N%Y ,,••��4 I1 -t7 ter (+� r ;moi 1, a..r J3i`✓'� r! jr rl �y ,V I ..I -•!'r+ a ♦ �� /i y"`./ r i aL aoy ,, � J. � i,�r' r .'';? k J =`••'� I.r f= �` .� y ,1 t S'� 1'"' �a sLw..«yF.,� ;,�t k'Cr3 ��`-��J�"1 "1�',`�(.�:;.-.�',.,.. ,=;.t �t rr 1 t . •�, s ,Jr Nti.� 'i J ! r d Y r r9,(Y F ri ✓ r + .Yl. �''� 5 1 t'1, i 1t..,y` " A+. zr �.A t-,,,'" +„r . � . • �j '� y 7iI ��A 1 r R .�.v ` �. "� J � r �t•ss�.. ,I a 1 Y � (��� L ��`"r, � Y \v-� Yra ��n t•�ftp...,R `�1� `�"i "' \1 ��'�-a " ry 1 .4\E �I ✓1"wr+ �1, 1 } y? i .� , � ,I . ., 9H r ty-a •v' I r l � .ny i t n/ :+L ✓ 'ti�?� i } l�\ 'ir\ 11y�� 1 fel �'`�`` (;' S"�'({ 'i(1�t C as j Yrs y} F �:• ;° }f " •{ f�/ Jll!'w t"• , '` : M},,li� r.,., r• J"" � Y� it'` rJ 1.1 r+'•'. °)' Y� :4 � Y 1,� Ave .:) (r ,,� rrr��",•9 s 7 �>^ y p..J r'3/'" j � '' t F'\ %��. V: Y _�/,r --� \ r ��A4t+ ,��e}.pry lora A.. •; -�"�b. (Z t'.,,,.. i G,.+. lr ..' r r ,{ •. t r�/r < . t s. t .�7 � �. " ry� �, 1p,Y� r"kiro m(I" IYc�lw+p p� fj 1 {T.'•! =. J`"A+,'",..I t rf�t C' at+ y.� +-� ❑ ,� y �� 1, r r' ", �'Nr) • ;�� I � tN `�) � `t ITE! � � I `� �y� � sl .� V "+ u°t� ����✓ *-"� 5, r� xf ' 1 " - ] j � ' I j - . �- y 1 :t�J'� � I t r, t i ' •%�y . .«... /� + f,•f,•�` +•' 4r/ k ' 7,{"•'.i '�i,. }. "!'. rte,,•.- � `.i�•'G A � ylitYahirrrj, , J. 1 d �.� 'rl S�� �.Y1 tl F'` •S , �� '+ �'w•A ; �-� 4rr Il " �, r.� r S!} t ,i � (� ..t''1a1�{F{'� p!. ��J ;"� I r � � ,�� 1 � ,� r' Ytrt . ;,+ 4�• I . • I � r ���M �tb ,•�7 r �1 f�'1 If R7 ° . r/ �� Ir r Yr.`�1 y� �� )+ $ �', �• �*, t p �r ~�� `••,e, L•'v \ r _, 111 `w 73�`•x�M. t'y�l .�i, Who '_,1�, f. t i Vic.. C ..> l u t �1 ��",. f ° • r )) q�A �A .Y._.-.� '*�'wA .� �y {,/ ,I• Y �.,. "1 �, f � ...� ..�. {,tr' �t �.',y �1• �c b,rr•,,L� �1 � rir.,' 'u �� `".� ` JY�1i � v . ✓' V�tJ\ 'L', r�IAN�' y���.. ..50 al �1 � ,,I tit's S x. �f✓r": fl �,w•-`,.",,..ru-+i , • V `" t� ,+, 1 �'; Fh»•r r F f"! „°•1 +j�, " t �: I + I �. rar �r 1'. J -'�, 1 1 ,.,� 1r)� /r...�,«...:., 1 "•l j} l/� j{w•..,✓" r xrI 1 v (( "1d•.7 rT v� �' '�".��^r'+� � t -r (} �� �'. , 1 Y'710 I ".k'a.,c! r '"'.�'f rf+ 1" :j C fr+ + YN� 7, r ✓�,," 3. ^ vi✓'�a, t t .:rY rti a n ° -•�' i � r'La '� ( + « rY'J' ,4�tr9A ,';� rl,✓ �... +ea�7J ,i tr .rt A. � h",• L �'�''�J�-", !r � i ,w� w.�a"�� +My , * ��2 Y i �� 4,'}. .y�. (�•,.,� ..1. �: 1 �, �' i I,11r��� jt i., A rl., fi � I J,�r ! r�.J� �'�- j ; •� � rr� _- - - - '- I�" '. .i`. r +C�ylL9 t+vr 1y((r t,r<_irl ..+I•'f(',a+ ,ll,...Y jk..,rt�. ?/f•i',rt� �/�lr'if'1 t`I+".•1�.Y1'=• A�I,..