HomeMy WebLinkAbout058-210-1661,
•
♦Lim.
.y• • ..
a .' rY�
•a '.
of
,
'
',
t
vis
•
y
ruN r tt
-
++A
PLANNING COMMISSION SUMMARY SHEET FOR LAND DIVISIONS
APPLICANT Gary Cowden
Log#87-01--20-02'.
ADDREISS. 6420 Oro. Bangor Highway, Oroville, CA 95900
OWNER Same
PROJECT DESCRIPTION TPM to divide 40+ acres to create 4 parcels
acres, _1 @ 14+ acre.::, and 2 @ 8+ acres
LOCATION on the east side of Drak Canyon Roar approxima`te�
_ y_2000 feet sotith
Of its intersection with Paiute Drive, Big Bead area.
.,
ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER(S) 58-21-1.66 (ptn
40MING FR-5
GENERAL PLAN Foothill PRWECT CONSISTENT?
Area Resadentl a1 _
GENEP.A't. -PLAN WCONFOIAMANCE RtpORrp
DATE OF APPLICANT SIGNS"R"z`iIPE
LAND CONSERVATION ACT CONTRACTS?
DATE APPLICATION RECEIVED 116-$7
AGENT/SURVEYOR/CIVIL ENGINEER: ikon Graves
ADDRESu,- P.O. I30x 986, Orortille, CA 9'5965
5
DATE PLANNING OIRWTORIS REPORT" PREPARED
ENVbETERINATION CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION- DA"T8 FILED
DE," ].1ERI�IIiJATION.:,_..,...,�.=.x._.._..,.....�..•...e
AND DA'Z'E NEGATIVE DECLARATION - DATA; ADOPTED
MITIGATED NEG. DECLAPA'. ITN - DATE ADOPTED
a. ENV. IMPACT PORT - DATE CER'T'IFIED
�._.. STATE C LEARINGIIotISE C14T,
8OBi COMMITTEE MEETING DATE
ADVISORY AGENCY NEARING DATE
ADVISORY AGENCY ACTION
APPEALED APPEAL NEARING DATI
BOARD ACTION
COMMENTS FOR PLANNING DIAE- TOWS REPORT-
.
µ-
i
�"'�"`�'w++n^+Www.a+e::�..w..+:+esw«Mww.+wi+M+.wYw».....w:rN,,nNKiww'+wyrw •i..wwa.'a.w: "a.w.ww.r+.yw t dNwY A N.wkN+M 441wY..�
wuawrwr.r,..,y,;x„;y�F .�t,xel+ts:Wr
. L1U { iL' UVU.GY .41
LAN
r GENERAL PCo 'ORMANC�EPOR'
FOR PARCEI:; MAP OR SUBDIVISION MAPBuffoCIO. P9anrrin9c
Items 1-4 to bi completed by applicant; � JAN g 1987
y �fOY1��Da�4PN
•— ''_ ,.� ...r..� l'>�,t� � N�-rJ Udo 13rl,�rta��
1 Applicant game and address ( /4 �d��...._�.�.
pp
2. Project Description.92CG
3. Assessor's Parcel Number(s)71, 6Ae
'�� -------- `• "'
t reg.
4. Proposed Use r?e -- ` //7 ;cJi�t.�.. �y ✓orf )�+
f`�A,%
The following o y the Planni,hitems are to be completed b
tg Department:
C'urrenC zoning ��"` �`.�.�:w.� "
land Conservation Agrooment
C,eneral Plan Designation�'�
Applicable Conditional Criteria
Not Applicable
Agricultural -Residential
YES NO
1, Agricultural Compatibility
2 Water & Sewer Capacity -- -
3, Adequate Fire Fddilities
4. Roa.'. Capacity & Maintenance
5: Access to Commercial Schools --�
Orchard & Field Crops
1. Predominant 5.10 Ac. Parcel Size
2; Vicinity of Urban Boundaries ---�
3. Agric, viability not impaired .�---'
Staff Determination; Project does . "7""does not _..
substantially conform to thnGeneral Plan and zoning,
Comments t �.1�� ��� t /J��rz ti .��•-,,,r�,�.y"� , , _
j
• r ✓`/ is � . -.� :, r � , • .. Xw-v _-•""... .�, . �t :; . , .
AS Till; APPLICANT IyOR' TE{E RE U>ST'Eb
LAND DCTERMINATiON REGARDING T14r,, coNPoi�fANCE p TEiS1 E;CENF LI AM WAt2E OF tC ABOVESTA>•1
PLAN AND 7WRIN0,
Signature of Applicant .� +/ -J"
LD 1000 (revised 6-8o)
Inter-Departme,ittat Momorandom
Advisory Agency
FA6M, Planning Director
kubjec"r, REPORT ON TENTATIVE PARCEL MAP FOR GARY COWDEN' ON
AP#58-21-168
0 A T r-,
November 17, 1987
This is a proposal to divide 40+ acres, to create 4 parcels,
1 at 10+ acres, I at 14+ acres and 2 at 8+ acres. The ptogot�t
zoning is VR -S (Vobthill-Recreational, 5 acre parcels). The
Land Use Plan Map of the Butte County General Plan designates
this area Foothill Area Residential. There are to 8pedifid.
Or community plans for the area.
The Proposal does not Conflict With (,'ounty zoning nor any
adopted Or Proposed Olemeht of the Butte County qetioral
Plan hot any county, specific or community plan.'
The subject property will impact a critical Winter doer
herd area and there are cumulative impacts associated With
this project and other nearby Prbjtats that have not been
Mitigated, The applicant has be6h unable to Comply with
Health Department and Subdivision Ordinance requitemehtt,
and has been in Process for an extended period of time.
Recommendation:
Find that the project does not Comply with the Butte County
General pla, Land U80 Map and policies, Find that the
applicant has been unable to meet the reqUiromohts of the
Health Department, the application has been pending for an
oxtbtdoa Period of time, And deny without prejudice the
Tentative Parcel Map application for 0'ary CoWden on
AP#59-21-168 in accordance with Section 15105 of the CEQA
guidelines:
nRH:* jmd
00
00: Ron Craves & Associates
Gary Cowden
STATE OF CALIFORNIA—THE RESOURCE!, AGENCY ---GtOR0t-DtUKMEJIAN, Go"Ofor
'DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GA
REGION 2' ME Do to It,64 piahnwj comqu
1761 NIMBUS ROAD, S'LlItt A
RANCHO, MROOVA, CALIFORNIA 06,670 MAY' P, 8 1987 go
(916) 355,7020
OrOV1110i callfornIA
MAY 26 1987
Mr,, David aironimus, Maocint�s Plannor
Butte County Planning, "partment
7 County Center Drive
orovillet CA 95965
Doar Mr. tilronimus-,
Thee LDi reviewed Gary CWdojj, 8
(�
�artment of Fish am amu has v
Tell at V0, Parcel Map (A,,,P-,i 55 -21 -166 -portion) and wish to revise
our attached February 3j .1987 lobter.
The project site is withiij a portion Of Lhe Bucks Maintain doer
herd's critical winter range that has boon alceady impacted by
ParcO18 loss than 2u acro,4 and is Within an area where, further
development, of the door rango is possible With mitiqaLjot)
Measurese
The Department has recommended that N!ie gothe, County Board of,
Supervisors adupt a series of mitigation ffie48uros for migratory
doer. The assessitt.,tnt a mitigation d00, Would be appropriate
for doer and establishing a IGO foot and 50 foot setback buffer
along 0a0h gidO Of all permanent. and' intormittment stteajris Would
be appropriate to protect the straam8l fish and wildllto values,
HOWOvOrp until tho Board has the opportunity to adopt and
imPlOMent Out mitig&bi0ft measures, we recommend the use permii`
be doniod4
If we can be of further assistanc0i PIO&Se contact Joery Men8ch�L
Erivi.-ohmontal Services 8upervioor, telephome (916) 355-7030,
Sirtceteiyr
Attachment
DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAMS
OWION, 2 I
1101 NIMBUS ROAD, SUIft A
RANCHO dMOVA, CAUPCONIA 05610
M -31907`
Mr: John mendonga
Assistant Direclt6e
OQt,bd CbQMtY Ddp4rtment of
Public Works
7 County, Cehtdr bVive
OV0,villUt CA 55196�e
hear Mt: #. Mend6m-ga.,
a
The Daparttadftb Of' Vith and, Cama has rovidwod-e!
Qa,*
Tentative P4tc6l MAP (TPH)f a ptoposal, to divide
adret into tour P4 tddlA of bout ,, 0 f -
a 14 1 at and 9 ade,d�§ each
(AP t8-21-166)* Tho pr6pdrby it 10 Cal 1 110 batik Canyon A66d,,
about, Eivo miles southeast tdd 416
do3gigh,atod dritical be Pa,tddilO, The tItLh Jt within
vihker rahcId 6E th thin thd
Subd4vigi6h and d6vejoptddn�t be the pa - r d 8uCkt, MoUhltAih: dddt� hdrdw
_,401
Migt4t6ty, deer use:
. . will 4dversojy a��fLjdt,
gubdivisich df lands into tm'Allot
uPOh tflig'r-at61"Y' doer U411o, of thdie taatlt e.s A4 lahd'8 btdofhL:i di
se than 20- V idod
into par cis
eviddAtj bode U8,6 bdddfftbs itIft a,ced's
and tho, availability 'be trigt'abory MdVatb6ht A:ff,6dtddk
tu8t-Ain hoed nuMber" foragd dt6p-t bolbw that 16VOI Ls�dty to
t A paL,,,.,,djg beootft�j 5,4Ard8 'be
lands aeo, hd� Ichgd,ti 8
ori4id6edd as being Abldtb 'tuppeje,.t
gr6toey
dooe use: -In ordoe
h6bibAt rhust. bd, in.-It6tot'o mitigate 'h'Pad'tg htigrdtdry dede,
the 10tj of Vdd �hd Ptthidted 01".*,twhero bo cdmpd,nsat-o for
viable door e,6hqdt,,
8ubdiviti6tig have Advorbtly
White , afftdiftod foore th-th 40' pdved,14 of the
dtiUC41 Witit ' rang -es, in 8utte cduhty, th L
the svbdiviti,�M/doer Cdhglidt in gut an eefort to ro8olvd
t"ee�,to CbUntyi
tbridd 6f adtiohg in a Ddu thc* b0P6'ttfheht has
A 6fter 2f 1986, ectp6rt,,
Peospfn"d td the 8dard o� Supd,vi'torij to i. omenta eaod copy
Proviou8ly t,timt to yo H5 � 0.1
8ubjt�et TP. 8jt,s, 18 w;thill an cled',
whdr(� eurther devdj"u
OPMtht d6h
iinplertunted >i
hit!
The tpm cite it wit be the 8udkig MOU11t6th d,
that has been 4UddiEdd by �� 1' .1, �� - 0 9 O'be hdrd
We would' not, bb,Lidt to t ld�s than 26 --acrd Th tro f6 ed
h ApptbV41 bf bhd, tp�,
mitigation ffid'a§Ut,"etr it th(3� f61A6w'hg;
ihiplemeriLbd
The TPM be, stibjeOt M
--,
a, Bede ,
fd&# to b
4dapt,6d by tho t6ard of
117
a
ry 1,
. ' John
-1--
of the 1;8 dhOuld bd thnlfnn O i91r"ISId.
barbLid wit+ t.01 all" pa 0"
b ,6n tr±unted 6 v+ nt h h � tl�nn.4$10nb t� n �
Tho trip strand should by ft �
g oundf the 16wdr strand' n r~ thorn i : b ru the
groundw
t tw
and not Ail6wnd tO nisi C'"Of t)"" t�.
:
bog brr inti �n �� bib ��'�ptdd by, the BOard bf
to an 6r`di.nArt
C�>;;rrt�l ���r�:Pty�.+�r�tai.�,l�nt:1r�+E�.
along cacti Bich t,r all �, �nti d�a
If. wd earlbd Of fut<thdt: AbdidtaAC'0P"e 0 -dot'
OnVi.Z`OntOnt`d'
1nL6ria)ly F'
Mn
et 4VA 0 -
, a
assoclai6es
Ma y '12 t 19 8 7
Jbb bra 87-001,0031,004 & 005 -
Vin ehf, Shorwabdp Arnold &tid C6.wd'e-'n
Duttd cdu4ty
plabbing Ddpt'
7' Count" conter Dr.,
4
Orovilld, CA 9596S
Attnt L'Avo "irdhim"t
Writ )OAVOt
WN C6. Nwol di*ft
MAY I vi 1987
Ort46*; wloh4
oto
Ma bdbh 50 MUCh andieVoh:,Moro Vdrbal Oxdhangej
eoncerning thii project that I winh to', rdqtate my eliontA p6dition
rcoarding thbfw four (41 pavocA maps
T.) Wd, will obt-din en Public Report an poi` tho Dittri et Attdrney!'§
eonditinft,
Kd, will add 2,11more gravdi to the dmigting rad d whidh will
offoidive ly tiring it t ) the old R8.7 ptandard, It h6d, Jbdimi iruipt.eted
And approved As' per the 61d RSO-Lotf 20 to -n aids Oraddd and r-avdil-
pd, The addiblohal 211 df .2 A. ft, tmdunt-g ta 6,vdj7 $t2joOg" , '00.
We will aligo "pull the ditdhogll and grada and dlo-ati: up thtk, rwidw
3 -We Will Met All other ro-quirtthoht-q'y tiwh ad Pith mid: Ctimci att"
backgr Health tdtbatkg#bdtr Roard, r6lbsi ttd.
40 Wd will build a, 26, foot wide M g tic exit with ill Of qr4vtl
out the Lsa.4,t sidt t6 tiq Hond. Raddf is pdtgibld. the 6WAdrg; t6 tho
sbuth, may thalldhgo our tight to do §o and it litigation bedofiiL.a
ft6edd9dry it WdUld bb, bixtteMdly co!gtjt tig wbil ag j-om1§thVj and wd,
c6uld 16§60 theta -fore th-cl csx1t wovli hr - phygically
If th18 is yauf unddratandirig of out aqrodm'orit ploaw. '46 ifidi�dt'ts
its WflttftO� go WO, FdaY, `qdt WO With this projo.ct, It h'4o bdon,
vd-ty I'dhothy and dxpengiva fat �1,11 Of �Y tlidhtg AM thdy qUlto-
ufidOr8tAhdiblY of vetY 4fikidu-q td tnaolvo the iasum,
Thaftk You,
to Vi
nar.r VOS
R(m Oravag aha k15
DUkOSMN66d
I� I I
yp
i
Ali 4A
MQL tat, 101"
sill W—AMI'm
C ,
11,01011 SOL, 5jU115400hp
I
WIN 1�011CRRO "0
+W..�.a ,�:-t,y��l ,,�..3.,"P�p��,...:.,. »: t^>.c... .w.ilyit/dE �!1���{��L'-71j C:,.•�,..,.-,-�^`��4�L 4..�.,^k--�w„-y" l�w d,. .µ.
�I�
I'IANb:�
of 6 f 4.�I �w.
4�w�sP WNW F
43
aloof Met t sle
t " ia�1palp :lt�u'i4�°tw'11�� h
rv'A t'1w tgam 'wl Eave The ppleattal to nNewhi ev
WOE pmej
tondooe M6 the tutAte,"
II ��
0 on the I�'fa� pop �q� � �l a� 041g %blob age t"�di Vid o.
0 but malamelp el I 16Y
project max Impamt 611 M or japg %I
hat Imemahouts
theta the -tapaut an oath remaurce i's tof to
rmi l t but shot . the o folt art thotstal of
II+
i,t
n n.;rPk lad furn r� DunAg�hqq' �'�
t. pw k
L; t,1 ¢ rr� fine pla M� � o r'. 4 �"I ULO NO boo �� bw
10 t�d«� , ��� ���:. i���tebt I "Id ,d MATIVE
ad phlart could haRb
yy1�1q�'MINT
W
0 fort In V040 ko iu"o b Hm
1RAt fhi'fl\'.
401+ rr 1CIL
;I, µ
'f l'iMxr the
Tye b d'ti�cuwrtx rrir tire" an
tMY� Oil
t
21 o
W
r,
�
_.i..� * IWC��,,,, 1 . 4� iM S � $�
xp dild
dft
�Ilq 11
Will Ulty
iF 1j
CJ'q
iy�""u�vgy {w
���yy�q�y� ��.yy�,:F: C�qq
76.
le
i ;�Y Or
pW.7�a
yq yk411J1{�1 �y,
I'
Uha� toy is or W
nY�'.��� �L%�@l�iD��
�B$IF�ud.0.4+"i.5�'� i � td �%?4���
W
i + �"r
�F V 5g,�y�,,rz Uod4;.1ytpp,"yq
Fl �yypp yyyy y.�0 tCa�'j� ylp,,
adadwt o LGmMa.T.RJI;F,�Li In �:ti.:R 1: 4.T�� �L:J30.0 .EJi.4':
d �" 0 t�' It may, d"Mini Of
i1votr or, §tviami or thl bLa Of the Oeddt, ()r�
any gS.'! "�yi 5Y l o t
Loss C� ptipid, ftxi' dugltural ,g ui 66119
yr
y
�d+u�
t7yyy��y,
�y
Ii4Y
}4;�WR�y�y,�i.u��Ww�,,A�;yF
,� k6��.�L,eFY'RS,x�ii�h �Ay, a�utld
�y, y�, W�
��y("
�rx axu r� b6 Alec 6X q 6 6 L y RtcR , Gdlo is
y � �i yy y� ya �{',q g� y� p� �+� W+c �y yip �
.? '�lL�R ' +?' '�Sy: iT+'�ayW LiAk as I' C71 �1 �M:7 WY
ppy�I91Lq
�iryn,.q y5� r�qq +pp!44
++WW�q{, yy.. '$
Sr !kir Alm" 1 � Y' r W� e1
f
*kir 4ae �y iT��(:� b
�«A^F:sx. �
ItJ
�,�Wy ®.•�4ey'�'y]� @ Ty ! "Fe�''�' r�gF'�p�{{yt��,y}�
The `F'rcmticla V V..ev.,V3rjd%-loft.inbl RJWV W ' 4i F•9'�A,'�'i2'. -..
r.
.
Of 5ui``° g
_
Alteration irRAtt attd °kutr%mm"NLy); md: $,
„4yypu��
�:�y9LgR3 +W 1✓;�w
,�y. # 3t���F151�0w�Sg$�Sy
J ice,.0 V.mL �iy4�n 0,0*�7G,�@ L,yiii"
.?"( i-[,�r
upIC
WL�L'
,wt�,,9Jy��y
ift dr
y the fdto ani atitim 6f vur do YOM10
.
�y{�
F.
�y{ yy �.{��y.� NT �y y}��µ y u� �} �i yM� {M�y, @ yid ��+k y��L _�Q ,�{{�,+-n..r.
All d'foh-q to the S.V.U�i rse S.iir f1dw 5 9� i.r d
rY.
yryt�y+�yG
Sra,
(kY�
�4.
Yl��
py �} y �4 y y yYy Lw .r� y (�y yW� F}�
J4{�r y the
:4: LiyC 1xii VwC! 'C:.9 Jit Y'G Ti'r i342A Ii l+ry C� W f.. C.i � 'YA
•w
ySy.:ha
Y
uM,y,a�y!
6 W
,yvy. �i �. f ry ova yY��1 /I� ¢y
�i"A. � f s Y.� di 1 f, c n ♦ �. r +a�, n any
YiJ 7� A:$ �'L�pi.
���,}6t�gW �y��y7y�
{i��l..-yD�¢L+' yf�� yG��� .y! yy yw�f�} y. �y�y y�(`��yj ��{LY"1
alto Wyatlo 4,1+V. r�"A.'Curri,cc watttw $ (juC,dity, .L �41�r w«4A45
Z7
.
A:1 dtlution, of tad,Ji-fec i tt or rdito of flov
2� y3 �
"'ift.te in the quatitit.vor quaof g,roohd
dithdr through dirpictµ dddit-igii8�Or vth
drdwals, or through, ita6tceptian of 4n
aquifer b., cufr� 61, ezkcavatsdt §
Y
A-rXpo. ,*-, ),w pdorle it � dpc*,r v to vidta4.
kww+w "
4
R11 iYho + dpots' Al egut w fill . .F ubit,PC b[
.RT�4
of AV qdglob of ptfttg (I udin r
Zi-opi't dad, u a Ildvitill�ky�i
M PodCA a JkY jo,tjQ�
'prY{ q C4., ityy
dgqCti�{Y{{ C'��piyy 6�y4,
y1Yt `p
y�lp�ry q
rNi4��+
now w df ��a MW ��a
' o v MIR (area
-0 or In a'' balrior to b g 1 u5 + r�4 �p$
coat Olt ox0tsft- op
t 0duc ckft or my, agficulturat, sept
ASWUM
� :; HAM" ,, pp"� v i ll the, praposdi, rosult' .
or waribon
c�
1t l , lag �� 4, 4 `� �'' dill shod flAt
W, or lagacta)"o
�_ �
°w
��yy ��i r� in ,,��yy pp ��u��y y�,, rgi of y� Wµ, a� yy��,�� iy u�r�µ ,fit
f �. �
or, 'od ed o
CIS o mw gv#t
.a voto'�'a of` y
bi t , `t l
7{'',.,y,�,lr}�C:i iy�y�{iLyi kn 1R Md$�W4�'7etird.+bY
Rw�alp'91 'YSyC
3M"Nimy
WEk'1MS6t,i
.,.•,
yjSr�a=uuu£r
C SII L`Y' I:JC ZI. �.7 dif, t15 oh�
�
7� �p
IallEId g I pmd4td
° kowl Vit !
,
^�..a lt' 99 +
+ysC.Y��.9JSr+r�,:gµI y�I
Y..i Okft i;'U p,fCi,.;s5,`kW C,,t �5u®�tlil; ilu
Lk7l,YC .G ty�p
jY.{,��p f1r��,.'�y+A,
yRSrYr
lafi I kS .a a i. W oa w
� R '�''., "� �yi�I l e r k, �y� y Get �71�1�
Will
�q� �y � y� yid ��
x'14 1 �i( U��J++Wqp .A 4y�: ��Wu 41 l✓1 tiK.9 + YS.Bk 3t at"'r A'&l,
{i�(�y�y�4y�rs�, ,,y,y�
. I 111 �. h, o � div,
,1N��y,G7y.�i
y
VINI't"
i"m dxtJ loaf 5ft or tw� tele�'w;d or'll"Imd-
uA:rk$i"� but floc Uti fol
or
�.1y ediuoitor pgot
JK
V&&iby4with t ol y
.
dmm it , r Arbwth vitt Of thd huibl '
"y
iH
1401151"G. Will tht t!�./'�}'e����;t e{�c�isti "g; hou�IA
�+��t�ilps�1,
iyy yr �.«J41 atm a �id3+4aftJ for ✓additif�iWA al hol��g4fig?
v .(
4
I
' K Y
'
Y
YES MAYBE NO
13,
IRAN PORTATION/CIRCULATION. Will the proposal
sult in:
a. Goneration of substantial additional vehicle
movement?
b. Effects on existing parking facilities, or
�—
demand for new parking?
c. Substantial impact on existing transportation
Systems?
d. Significant alterations to present patterns
Of circulation or Movement of people and/or
goods?
e. Alterations to waterborne, rail or air traffic?
f. Increase in traffic hazards to motor vehicles,
`
bicyclists or pedestrians?
1.4.
PUBLIC.S.MICES Will the proposal have an effect
upon, or Fesuit in a need for new or altered
governmental services;
a. Fire protection?
b. Police protection?
M-
c. Schools?
d. Parks or other recreational facilities?
e. Maintenance of public facilities, including
'•�'"
roads?,
f. Other governmental services?
15.
ENERGY. Will the proposal result in:
Use of substantial amounts of fuel.or energy?
b. Substantial increase in demand upon existing
sources of energy, or require the development
of new sources of energy?
16.
UTILITIES. Will the pt-oposal result in a need for
new systems, or substantial alterations to the
following:
a. Power or natural gas?
b. Communications systems?
c. Water availability;
d. Sewer or septic tank?
e. Storm water drainage?
f. Solid waste and disposal?
17.
HUMAN HEALTH. Will the proposal result in
a Cfea` a' on of any health haza.Y i or potential
health hazard (excluding mental health)?
b. Exposure of people to potential health
hazards"
1.8.
AhST'HETICS. Will the proposal result in the
o s`�5struutJ n of an), scenic vista or view open to
the public, or will the proposal result in the
creation of an aesthetically offensive site open
to public view?
.4-
YE5
MAYBE NO
19. RECREATION. Will the proposal result in an,impnct
upon 'tl e duality or quantity of existing recreto'lonal
opportunities?
1
20. CULTURAL RBSOURCtS .
a. Will the proposal result in the alteration
of or the destruction of a prehistoric oil
historic archaeological sate?
t=
b: Will the proposal result in adverse phys3r1,1:1
.�
or aesthetic effects to a prehistoric or
historic building, structure or object?
c. Does the proposal have the potential to ao,llse
a physical change which would affect uniquo
ethnic cultural values?
d. Will -the proposal restrict existing roIlg ous
or sacred uses within the potential impact:
area?
V. DISCUSSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL' EVALUATION AP 58-21-106(litn)
See attached.
Vii.
PJ AP charm )
lb,O.,e,fj3bicsfol6e: Development of at least 16 ho,,.otoil.on,� drivewaysp
additional roadways and accessory buildings-$ decksi oft poblos V4111
result 'in, potentially --TLan iVIcart b dist-UptIon, dISPIOCOUIOIIf compaction
and overcoverIng of the sol l, and changes In bopoqrrjhy and ground
surface relief -Foaturos, which tAiill lead to changes Iii olasor^ption
rates, drainage Patterns and could increaso the rafW ui- amount of
surface runoff from th, property. These changes could load to
Increased erosion of soils on sltewhich may result lit nIltation of
the stream on site, including downstream locations) Ot"d Could increase
turbidity In the waters both of the stream an] Lake Orriville to the
south. Because of these potential impacts, any dypouod soil surfaces
should be reveoetated and storm drainagewziys r1prapped ar other means
employed In order to assure that additional erosion dodo not take
P I M'O 4
19,4d: This project will effectively remove approximately 140 acres
of riioderate timber potential land from any economIc tImbor use.
1hAll of Oubto County 1s I ocabad w I th I n a Moderate 12arthquak e
Intensity Zone Vill, The subject Oroporty is located approxImatdlY
1/2, mile south of the 1310 Bend rault, t,4hICh Is of unknown activity.
Construction of buildings to UMIfOrM 81-flldiMg Code standards For
so I sin! call 1 y act I v -08s should provide adequate pro-Foctlyin io
OCCUPal'It-S in cag seismic activity.
.o@! Groundwater re5OU1rCe8 11`1 the area are ut,ikhowri and potentially
I un I ted , Sixteen individual w 1 1 s bm the 140-ar-re site could locally
deplete minimal aquirersi
�d 9 The subject property Is located in an area of critical winter
door habitat. Due to surrounding developments of less than 20 acres,
the area has been compromised, The Department of rich and Game h4s
Indicated that they will not object to the 181d dIvisions IF coma lh
MItigat IOM Measures take P1ace (see, attached 1ettei'4s From the
Department of Fish and Game)i It should be noted that of those
suggested mitigirt 1oto measures cannot take place under existlnth County
ordinances. As such, this project would have 8 siGnitficant effect on
deer habitat in the area,
The stream on s I to wh I ch pMra I T e I s Dark Canyon Road is a site of
sIgnificant r1par inm hsbItmL- amci should be protected, The Department
of 1z I sh and Game has recommended bu I I d I ng sethack s a 1 on 0-! the rzt-oek
which W 1 1 1 , if I mp 1 omenteid $ adequately protoct that habitat,
11,12: These- projects wl 11 rtproto-ht -6 FUrthtr Iritrucion of 5+ --acre
Pal"100 1 S into relatively UhdOVelaped 8-r-0as SOUthOF the Highway 70
carr I dof,, o Approval of these project -z may trigger rerjuevts for
additlorial dovelopmomb in Lho Immediate 8t -%ea and to the !. OUth#
IS.- The doyolopmotit of at ledsi- Ir add li;ion�'11 hutnes 11twin the area
w I d I C�'�
III ropi,,ocent an Increase in traffliv.; on Dark Cnriyoti Roo w h h 1,41 11
Increase traPflt, h6tzirds aind rata intf.'MaMde, t"OCIL11 r o fli o n ts, Dork Canyon
Road is a cul-de-saa whiLah siarviccs mord U-1an 20 lot,;. In such cosec,
the Out -Fe County SubdivIsItori Ot-dinanco roe-iulrow that 115�
a
ttAlf'.1 Cot
d,
_1rd O ;ICC
_ _G,"8 to Publicly-mz�
1 -*inch Temtativo� pnt-cel MP OzzhoNs I I rind roods, JO Kev I n
0 2�Fl-foot Y QU� (c 4-10
Sand Road �o the ,wast. j L
It Is rocothmorlded that tha access ra,jrj (pa
IUL
t)rlvo) ':)0- Oxt0hded to that r1jhb ,e
and improved so 8S to provi'do Cjt-Of"40V) OMd' that w1donod,
cul0tl0M. Socauso of tho ritimbers o
lots access 100 PO'uta DrlYe) arid the number of po,*orjtiq,I -j
lots that could bo created under the O'x,ttImq ddiLlomal
._On
recOmmemd0r,] that Paiute Drive ba improved so t Ih0-j It is
OmergencY veh'-
l,cles will hot the PUbll�c Of1d
)aye adequatO access, and that the
C011,5tructlon criteria will match the lnterjsjt�y 0 C_ I
b110 OuttO County 00nor-al Plan Cli-c4ulotton ElP IJtO aa r-OCIUlred by
WhOtit and [.&)nd Us(�
Elemoi-ito by ImPrOvino the road to the rivate -
m0umtaltli t�,OcreatiOh subdivisions (Dep Orptmeht ofroad Pubilastandard WorksPotStandard
R87)j as adopted by board of Supervisors Resolution 07
robt-�uat,iy s, 1987, -!6, dated
14 t These pt-0joOtt will "Present On
For pub tic servlto8 Jrj, a rural oi�lb8,ont ihct-04sia In demand
Power and telophomo lines, Will have id be extended
property as much as 8'/4 mild. Into the
2O: The subject Property It In an area of high archaeological
zoos itivityi Am, ar-chaoolog.ital turvoy waz perforffitti
Wth a Previous pro-FjocIl
and Clearance was reacolpmtmdedn a I . ctJunct5hbUldon be
noted that mr, archaeological site was dt9t0vdred on the Robert
Sherwood pal -043l , that s I be has been r.--jta I og!,,,j
initignition measures ed y 8hd no additional
zuryeys rec"MOmd0d, GOO the
11. MANDATORY FINDINGS Or 810NIFICANCE
at Gee: Itom 5d.
biC. The curmulativb 0,rrotit of four Schpa
ztL
Parcel f� P8 of
each fbUt"i I ott4
is the san't' as a 16-10t subdiyltlarl, As 5VUe-'11-i ta
should be developed to the came standards bhot I he projottZ
a !�UbdlylsjoM4 While the Impacts WbUld horm pply
assoclaod VII to
proJoCt are not significant, they aro, th each rout— I ot
5 1 Or, I -r'con t. If this projq!ct t when OrOUPOd td0o%"'hor,�
�-hom ovem oroater IMP�Icts C' r1goorz siffill':ir prol
�4 m be expoctod, Jr-'('-tz In the areas
a ctsf o
d_t I hj_cant l c1t, ensures
Show on the final Map a 100-fdot d0Vel0PrH0ht-fj-QC,3UkAiiock alorle)
Oadh soff` oall pormament streams
ShoN on the final Inlp a C
n_ root
do
_ v t
each sido Of all _ OPMOn,-fro(I setback 010ho
lnt'orrh1tt,:�rjt 5tr(t,.-jftjk4 (att mops),
31 Provide circulation via at least t WO IAOUtOs cons tructnqd to butte
COumtV 00-0a§rtftiont of r-Ubllt� Wora;ks
st.aridarcar, 0.11 CIS ( "al I I maps; )' . _ to PublicIV-11101htijined
147 Q
t?,UttCl COUrItV o,jr
dee lon ,s-tarlojartj, RS17 P(�V� Pc3'.;OlUtlon
Doerr d or Suporvi,sor., FObrudry 5$ 1987.
hr followilmo InItIOOL1011 MOOSUrOS 110YO beom sucIC4at,,tiod Lty tjjp
DOPOr4tMOnt o#' Fl..Oh and Gamo but, comhot be t.Idbpbod or lmpjOttj(ImOd, um�l I
vu0i time at; the autto County 13o;0 4d 0f �u v I Sor, rjtl, t, ,.
per, v 0 j Y �,
,!5, 'rho e'en tet I ve parte I maps sha I I bo subject,, t~o a dour m I t t ga- t tern
V00, to bo- tdopted by tine Oobvdor Sulbor\elsors*
6. Par 1"Ieter fOhclmo OP the par -,cols should be 1100told to Wurbed wlimo,
1*0 bllbw Pb89800 of deer, the Poode -should ba coms�"Ucted of five
St OOMdt 01'* logs or borbi2W wlooi ThO tap Ztl-dnd .13hould has ho
h1lohor than 4011 above bho Ot-OUMd$ the ldwor. ttand mo lots thwi
161* nbovd the grciumd,
1. Does shall be earn tr011Kaci and not Illowod tL-)
rUM f f"t
jQ) PUr8Ujht to
bM Ot-dl(14mce to bd Ejdoptod By the 90er4d bit� 8uporvlsjart.
R0- f (-h r te m c 0 *. Jaffiet M, Ladd TPMM4s AP 50-21-1669 Loo No, OS -12 -al -01
"81"
Appill IcartOO
Armotdj I�hr-w�,400do
Cowd*n M t" I rich
I
A ik. t lenet,int-, 1 6m
Avv(,�inswr-*n Nwoul 0,
tlO-.n"I-166 (tAn)
Log, it,
(37-01-"M*021 arid! 0,',-)
it Typo u pt-ojodtt rour° Tom tat; l,ve Pdr4ca1 map9w
aeldf bIlbdr*lptldh: TIJ divid1b 6 bat al Or 6PPt-ox-lfOOWY 140
'Ner"Os Irito 16 parc.01's. of febm S to 90 adf,*Og,
-3. LcjddL' I (5m "! 541SLJ.- 8I&J- O� t)at-k CaMYOM Rodd JPPt"Oxlmrjt'Olv 1/4
millo touth o� Saito Hlohway ?0.
4, pekopoddd Ooht;lby or up to 5 40t -w; porgy dv4mlllrid.
uh 1, t,
tali Mouht or Ithoerw1owl suresvaalmfat miftimbli
6 t Addbgd and' Nobrdtjt Publ 16 Road(.q) I, Pt-oPar4tv althor, ft-omto -am,
bde4k Cnmyoh Rbdd or tbkmt ac:eiasst to Dw4k Cmmyort f1wid vla
V, Mbthod of Sowmao'ti ittpogall: frid lyldual tbptid syttamgw
0 t 8durda oWator Supply".. I mej I v t du4i tato j I st.
90 PrOXIM11w 0l; Powael Llow; ! To prbpdrty*
16, Potoritl8l for furlthdr- lamd dlvltl,omt� and d6voloptodtito H10hi,
20flirig would allow P--I.i intro Pavcjt41!;j or 11 to 1!3 ffided poekddlt�,
14Tot°rt i.
Gdhdt4al ToPdotlaphle. Chtwladbew-f Mdddr46tt to gore tI,Ls
t4id'90-1�and abovo ztclopot- daMyon rAnvirib. , In 6 moutittiltibula
r*01ort .
b, 81 dodii t Noar, I y I ova, I on h 111 top,?o to ovot- U 0� g I opejon
cbhyom wollt.
51 dvdt I Off f 1800-9800 rcots 4bbvd Sb6 Lovel
d,i Utri ltiho Padrbbtis! Gttoptt- ztlopo -t ilomg &-mhyom H'allt ioftd
rd I 8t I Y:e I n8dcct'tL5S, I of I I tY OP s"WAQ Port leirl t of tho 0140p dety,
0. Typotl amd M�ir I piota, So 1; 1 So -t- I o� a,
zho I owM"ovel I y I Oatft on b i l I Y tort= ,;_1 I ri Geh 4b I t i no Modord. �Ls
ptrimeob I I I tyv
'b LtSeri biho P664 r- Shd1low dGPbh Glopts: ,q high ot*otgjort
PbtOmtltfl;8, Nbbui-dl' Hmo.60dd# bhd Ldhd
60 tdr4thquakd zohbt Mbdf§f'�bO E-:Orthr4UFjkt lhbtrtbItv Zone Vill.
b Grog tom potbmtloft modmA6td to, h1oh,
d, Lbhdglidd Potwitiol., Mc5dF4f-,-zftO t high-,
d& H'a2di-tit W�h,
64 IXOdhlj!VO 8011 Pdbohtiall' ! LCI
44 HYdt-r016bY
"9"
nnurraau waLor4t.
Of thd' fwoftfnt�ter ot v t
iw i I t'� pt if I t It I
OPPpox I Mato 1 Y Air, C' fif
"Pt
b. Oroundwatorpt Unknown,
braAmabo,, Area 1*, -'A
dt*afmaoewt3�yg,
d# Ahnual Ra 1 rif 4i I t C nat-maj is
LImit,ino pddtded*,.,, UmItnovIn' q
6w Adounnbio aualltyt High, U
7* Al t4 Oual 6V t i.1, I gh!,
r. —Im-t - - - - - - - - - - - - - - a
VdQ1bbtJt1b0 Mixodi tr~ ri 1 i art roroz�tw yollow r,,Im 1 1) Ut)i 0
le'. P I me, AT!36 madrome, 01b, 40 r. Imaple): Rod 04k
r1f4i tomo, sug. 6 0 tj
amd bOmp;O'Od'8x't'Qme'jjv1a mArq+
'a'fjTtd o
woody '§Ode"Cid 1 1461"I'VOIY dOM90 a w1do
het-baceout: pitiM,te. It
9, Wlldfit IltibLi't
ab: Thd '16dbttd WlthfM OM Area, b
SPOdIMI 8i'61691tC1 IM06rt4MoLl- )
, OMOOrdlr thio rJuaka
MbUhtdIft DOW4 Ho"d, 8a1d C-Ialttj ekomob Oxjbb
M116 tt5 thO 'baCt, J"Ourld Lakb Oroviijo,
P-1111-0401,- CftY-LtQh _ffidtj b.'
A"habotoolca,j Qhd Hj,,,-,L-dfz*jeaI jjQkj;e3uj4OO!j
rle taolt�.Ole'al at-ibiv High
(jubbe County bohof4dj' pj'jatj
ke'�C- m t d I I At-oa
1xftt1ho zonifigt PN.2, Amd pR.5'.
W16*bIrlo Larid W;b tier-s;1t0i.
14 r SUMduhdtrig 04oat,
a Uorief Us' Ooom
rut -di duhlit,05,
b. 2dmjmjt rk-*j M-bj
Cbm*
d. pardol Ovor. Mo oov4ot.
fUral
6.
TOMd
1. Nd4t4d9b Uf'Wih Ae%a!
0-4bbti Ane dlf
Cuunb(stbtC15 it r,a tt�t,dh,j
K*ad
Comp,
AVui laksi l 1tY f fr e hk
,,j #,ry
Schbol!3 1 r Af"ddl 'oldere Progf7lp"Ot
OrtVIlle Llmltm 41e;1h, School
"d0
StAft tit tAVIOPMA liqf
DEPARTMeNt OP FISH AND 0�4
OWn" 12
Mt RMV11 POND, 50311, A
Oltl)
PCs � 5 190
RV w John mAdonna.
Asm�*,-mnnt Dirco-tor
O(Ittl MuhtY Dopartment 6,f
Pub -140, Vlarkft'
7 COufitY C6ntor brive
OrOvill;# A. 959,65
'near HV* fthdongd,ig,
FED 6, 1981
Otov"U6, carliat4
Tha O'dpartmomb of Pith and' damhad, VdVi@Wdd DOwed lift Aelqbld#l�
timt,itivo Parcal tinp, (TpM)# b6 Idivido 0but 20 dcven�
mita f6ue ptedela, of f-ivd 4ctOa tAch (AP 58-21-166). Thi
ldi l6dat6d h-ojr, bark WYOft Road about f,fve, -milon, nbuthdade,ped-50ety.
ParadlOot The tite it wjtjjjjj the d'6919fiatod ret dad
df
the Aucka- ff6ufjt,&jtj
'aha Tpg bibd ig withift h pdrtion &t th,a At t h that
bden 4ff0CL6d by pm of -log-!. thorn 20-ddtO9t Therefom,
would nat objdat td the apPrOVAl of the TPM it tho E,011dwifig
mitigation! mdaaurced dre
Is the TPM bd "hJdet to d dlft
Migdei6ft fed
AdOPW by the 8oard dt gupq-evf§6taW
24 b6gil bcs, tontr6lidd: &lid hjt A116VI16d to reit, ftp
pUrt
I � Uafit
otdIdAned t6 bb ddoPtod by thd 'Board 6f
A 100'-fdot and -S-0 fOOt !§otback buffer bolt1 t blidtidd
- all P611mah6ft afid
610fior g eaeh did'@ n a
we caft be 6f further
r Y qtit
8ftVirOhMGM,td1 Sorviedg , R ijhi
or Me S't 0 e qtft i Lt.
Adgibhdl M4nngtr
(J1411 1
"'Ir
i 1C # AWNW i4 Tit 00MMh AMtY
' A_._..R..--.,M.._.g._�..yFISH
-•-- N_.h.O�ti..�$.-WME
Pyy � -.. ..--��--. ....^ �k '^r6 15•x'
1301 N0011A oelk% StAt AAN1. V0
'
Rr# John Aondonu
Ott Director
"Utte County of
Public W60tta.
oupty contot Drivo
brovw 95965
th boparwidtit bf Vigh d id 0,mci heig rovj,ovmd Obey Cowdenla.
: ' ( ,I)f a 01-606§61 t divide 00091m fitly 4
TentAOar a 4Y 104 0t And 0 Adr d
(A# 90-11-160 the, peopal
Subdiviti n and of thea clwilldvotgely 6h.
i6br door u,4v
y �:u +y�1j��i pi '��,on dr 1ytt,.,fidd y.�yr����.y, � 4)pg C j w ( { .yah}. ytilj . y yn� �$d�' y�J,{ (,y� �.µ �'y y�
i.y, tV Yil ltl��7,Y yYfiy cJM Fyy' {G C{w �'yyy. k+l .moi. yl.: y�Wd Wa4.1 �,�y�yFt�i�,yy�&�Il yg„I"yq �* ,y yL�'A.C3,,p. rlWKAndAy`��'yJ� by(��6}}��ot.-,Y�A'ir'y d i.�° Y,od,
�y �l"ay� {j[%76 Vr j�,.t�,,.y Cy9y i ,i yaW6j. B1'.lu yVlyy {1 �y (d"y'{"y���r%i.6§f �l'at�d+yi�l��y 'yaR�, Ayf�4�,i%��y i:�i {SCA;CqA �4yy4�.►,Myt4�d W'y�'id 4�.y{C�.l}{�;id y,
'V' i d6A4..t v 0' :G.I.r� u'6q bG^coitdg jM'3�. djrd .f # ji¢ �4<.L L\.iL P.P VC:Al4C Y�44 GA Fe C�r $r
c` lby bf forago deep bd ow that livdl fledds;,imry to
u.man sided nuhb-or * Xg Paiiatt, b6 6md �,-tjdreg O,eL ledg,t�
i nig and hd l6 �� ��fi iddedd d suing 4bl d t hd y,
Habitat iftugt bo impraved slid prob it
the 10 g Of Vi abs dear thjd edropowta for
4Updbdd w5te thea 40 poxcdhb of t1t@
the �y'�
qty tvIy{ b �yy yqy h jg�u�td yd6uhyt.,y b
,,.. GT Va tiJ'I�LB:k LI Gi: �i U �7�u 4i EJ Q�Iwls 4a�L►��,7� '/. 'CAS bodT:ifbbi 21 e�ejG 4'L
PrOgehbdd to th:d of, Ed
om"
v u iy s y�u� Th0 bubo t TDJ3 gj e. ars (seeWithin a 'ae ,
that hdd b`06ft 4fft-dttid by patcals 169d, t 4
W Wou d' fiat ob d� he � ���
3 tt r t t E H pft it the E0116win
la, The tPM bd sorb, acac 65 a ted r mftilg4tion tddo td bd.
�a
of the pardolti
1ibovar ho
«i
wk 'n 100.9' W
NO
t11 fti1 ri
to mi iodifith b"-a adopted, by W, U061ftl
4, AfI
bu,ffo
61 ofig, Odell tja df
,
bri'�a
NOF" AM
WARTMEt AND GAME
FEN 10 1181
Gwjl� "Jaik
Aet John
AMOtant
nu ttt toontv of
!past Ile mill
I'C�)Ontv tontot Otivo
0MV11"lif, tjk 9996"�Y
todt "Irt Rdmidlig4t
pith and CS"41 hAs e E�—'q fjb'r v,a � AtA t
10C
dam", Nut Powell A IT 14, C�4d�4 M#
tho peoporty in 100003 dWit, toot tiles N"thalut A
wayl NO* too its 10 WOUR the 0§110004 WINd"I"010h.
kl"Wlh diet hoes SubjIVIOWn dnj COVOSpunk of
tho Put& will mynably WON slyraory a0ey umv
WaVe 0 mmiam W W, Itt-."'untEdin door hOW,
hu
boon 6610001 iy"PINOW loin Va�'In 1ThdtOfCr(Jv
fttt blaJOC-t to SO 6porml A too "am A
90140tva todgwea. ary InpWROWN
TOA ON bo SOMM to a door MAQUAn At# to bd
Adpml by tho V10H Of supmvklev
20 pdfivotoe
barbod•
Qv Td Slow paggly at Qrt the fence
be
Ad too it
rind §ftould ba n, h1poe than 4Q Am thd
NOW; tm lownt Wand no Qjjthal go
gedundw MOM
0119 bo Camollad 411 h't 611dw6d to kuq ceodt pqvdqdqt
t011b ordinahta to,ha WPM Q t%v Soarl of'
supdri gump
4; A too-tnnt 6qj�Sj E00t IMAJ balryr
MAI Wh also A all bKodhont qhj
Arialow
Mr,. John Mendonsa Page 2
`1 we can be of further assistance, please contact Jerry Mensch,
Environmental Services Supervisor, telephone (916) 355-7030.
Sincerelyr
James , Messersmith
Regicn�':' Manager
STAft ?,)r CALIFORNIA—THC RESOURCES
DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME
REGION 1,
1701 .qj'Aaljlfi ROAD, SUITE A
RANCHO CORDOVA, CALIFORNIA 95670
(916) 355-7020
F 8 - 5 1987
Mr. John Mendonsa
Assistant Director
Butte County Department -of
Public Works
7 County Center Drive
OrOvil!O, CA 95965
Dear Mr. MendOnsae
C4nnu
FEB 101987''
Or0iM", C"'Or"a
The Department of Fish and Game has reviewed Kevin Vinch's
Tentative Parcel Map (TPM), a proposal to divirle al'Out 22 acres
into four parcels, of 5, 5.? Proposal
6.15, "! and 5.25 acres each (AP
58-21-166). The property is locate- about four Miles
Paradise near Dark Canyon R southeast of
Winter range of the Bucks M oad. The site is within the dosig'Mated
usvelopment of the parcel OL)ntain door herdi Subdivision ande. Will adversely affect Migratory deer
The TP�j Site is Within a portion of the Bucks Mountain deer herd
that has been affected by p parcels less than 20 -acres
We Would not object to , -011
the approval of the TPM if the f Thereforer
Mitigation measures are implemented: owing
1. The TPM)ye subject
adopted J)to
the Board
a deer Mitigation fee, to be
of Supervisors.
2. PO-riMeeer fencing
to barbed wite, -hould be limited
gTO allOOf Pat'WOels 2j3passageaof nd deS
should be cOmstructQd
r, the fence
of five strands
wire. The top !strand
the groundt�le 10WOr ,
Or less of barbed
should be higher,
no her than 4811 above
ground.
strand no loss than 161, above the
3. Dogs be controlled and
to an ordinance to be
not allowed to run free, pursuant
adopted by
8UPek'05orsi
the Board Of
4. A 100-f,'#'. and -50
along foot
'e of all
setback buf-fer_bo- Ostabli8hcd
s t roar)�-;
Permanent arid itiLorrijiLtoht
if we can be of further assi.,3tance, please contact, Jerry Menrch,
�nvlronmental Services Supervisor., telephone (916) 355-7030*
$I-ncerely,
James D. me8sersrqith
Regional manager
Archaeological Reconnaissance
of th- Proposed, James Ladd Land SpIlto
Butte County, California
Prepared Pot!
Pon uraves 8, Associates
P, 0 Box 986
Oroville, Ulff6MIa 95965
Prepared gy,-,
Jenson & Associates
Archaeological COhsUlt,fhg and Research
41 SkYMOL)htbin Circle
Chic6l California 05998
January 1966
I nt rodu -I ion
0 In order to assess the archaeological Impacts of j)
subdivision Prossd
vision Involving approximately 110 acres Or land aboutpo1.e5
Miles south or Jarbo Gap and east Or 8tato Route 70 within Buttp Country
California, the firm or Rot, Graves & Ass,6clatesj acting on ixii0ir or the
Property owner'Mr. James Ladd, Contracted for a complete records se,,j,,Ch
and on -foot reconnaissance of the parcel in COMP11onco with
recommendations received, from, the 5
Accordingly, on Thursday, butte County Planning' COMMI sfon.
9 January 23, 19861 protect ar,.hA#),ojoq
McGann conducted an intensive, oh -foot � Ist 0,
reconnaissance Or 010 PPOJOtt area,
for the purpose, Or 1000tiho and recording Otly evidence of proibie(oplo or
significant historic use and/or OcCUP8060.
The Ladd parcel consists or an lrrogul,a rly-sh6pod piece Or land iodated
about. 1:5 mq6t south Of Jbrbo 68P Immediately south or the InLorsection of
State Route 70 and bOrk, Canyon Road On the ridge above the North, tlrork or, the
leather pivot, bark Canyon Road rorms, a portion of the western p6rime
tov
or the Parcel which extends Westward to the section line between $ectjohs 35'
and 36, The current proposal Calls for sPIRtitio the land Into four
Pard6ls ranging from 10 to 50+ acres in s126, t6parate
eventually be subjected to hand perh6mesite 60ch of which would
perhaps other dove
View of the potential adverse affoo t of future cc)h�t�uctlolnOPt(M)OdntuSitiupalh
t I
resources which might exist within tho area, and in view or the general
brchodoldgiati sensitivity of the. regiono gutte County and Other reqL,16(joht
required that cultural resources be fully Inventoried and f6rM111Y assessed.
006r to protect approval, PurguAnt to Section 106 of -le National fjj$tOrjc
PrOsdrYkibr) Act of 1966, 88 amended (16 U, 5, 470)1 800),duAdvisory Council on 1-118toric Preservation (56 CrR and t)ofthtileor
1601818tfon and orders,
The remainder of this report details the results or the r-dtlulred
Orchaulogfool survey and Inventory and Provides appropriato
recommendations, All fieldwork Procedures followed guidelfheg Provided
by the State's OfffdO Or Historic preservation (S6drnmentb) and ore in
"06rffiftY With, aac6pted professions) standards,
Location
The JOM06 Ladd Parcel Is located within 6POrti0h Of the "Uthoalelt
quarter of Section 35 Of TOW118111P 28 North; R"06 4 Caste MAJI,v of the
U808 Berry crodkt California, 7,5OuOd (see olttach6d' Pf*d Lotatiom
Map i The parcel CO"18ts of 8 total 0( approximately 140 acres of partially
timbered and brush-cOVOPod terrain within UftdOrPOf8tad lands of outte
County,
Records Goar,ch
Prior to 961nol Into tho field the archaeological' records maintainers by
tIJ0 Norrtheott California information Center (C51J-ChIc6) were exomined for
any existing recorded ptehitt6tic or historic titan within', the project aroa,
In addition, the National 110.91sto'r of Historic Places tol.1.801 1083)) wa8 also
consulted, No Met ate currently recorded on or Immediately adjacent to
Ilio project, oronj although several Pockthd)W and Indian village sites hove
been, recorded with,in 1-2 miles of the project areak While none or these
previously roccird'od 84tos, would be afroµ ed by the oropoaed Ladd, project,
their presence Indicates the 16M of archaeologically tontitivity or this
zone within the Sierra Nevada Mountains, (cf, , Jensen 1981, 1065).
Ethnographically the propet area falls within territory which was
occupied by the Northwestern M'Aidu, OP Kohkow Indians (Riddell 1978: Figure
I). Although the ethnographic data do not identify 6hy specific situs within
the project area, the general ethnographic IMOPM800 In combination with
tho results Obtained from previous arohaeological surveys and onevntions
within the region (o6gj i Anson 1678,1 1970, 102; 08x, 1985) suggested that
t number of prehistoric site types might be located within: the area,
including the fol,lowirig., (,I) aboriginal middons located on the ridoeo above
Major WOW c6ursog and On knolls be flats adjacent to smaller draIh6g, s;
(2) aboriginal milling stations located On rock Outcrops within the vicinity
of good black oak atom t6lldction areati (3) surface tcatto,,rs of lithk
flakes and implements resulting from 064 UPM use and OtCrUoation'# (4)
Tdblotod finds of aboriginal lithie flakeS bhU artifacts, rind (4)various typed
of hittotie sites dating to time periods between about 1850 and the prea4ht.
Such sites have been recorded within the tMm'edlate project vicinity,
throughout Konk6w Indian territory and within the OrovilI6 Locality
gohonl ly.
Pidldv)+wk
As noted, fieldwork fOP the project was conducted by project
archaeologist b,, (McGann on Thursdays January 23, IOU,, The oh -foot
survey 1hV6Ivdd criss-crossing the parcel th: h6h-tyt(OMOUC turv,6y
transects ranging from 10 to 15 MOWS apart and partially following land
eonitourso CxbMIn8t10n Of the tUrf8dd IhVb!Vod M06016h of disturbed
area, infludimo rood cuts, rodent midd0h8i ond stream -eroded banks, for
evidence of sub8urfae.o cultural M4tbrfbI1,
Vegetation consisted of mix6d, confers and digger pino lhtorg,00W
with brush 6pW66 Including W66 -1811V codmothub and ffinnWitt. A16hg
Dark Canyon Ctedkj which cuts through tho wottdrn 6d06 of the pvc-odi, a,
dense riparian agtoclftIon w8t 6hcoun'tored consisting or berries, fOMS, arid!
o6vdr61' deciduous i troo toodim Considerable 0681t road grading and some
MihiM61 'ground 016arlho' In WJ0406h with oast, logging' wort., In Vid'W6 on
the Parcel, although these WOUJdM6t 114VO t0t8l')V Obliterated al] Ovidetlej.. ar
P0$( Prehistoric, Use or occupation if such WSW within the area, Arego.
dOhge brush and gratt, 0,ontenttation, particularly Within t1)
0 ou 'a
Portion or the Parcelcould have0000Ved some Of 0101, Wdence rop
Prohl's,toric and hi ttoe�jc utd/ocrupatlonl Particuldtly It Ouch dvidonce
C'006ted Of hothih9AW6 than light sur"tace tdatter-s of (10'08Or art1fdon,
Survoy Rdsujt8 Uld "eCOMMetidation
No evideMdo Or hOn-CONOMpOrapy historic, use or occupation: waw
OrICOUntotod during (161dwdrk, Cvldemco. of Ptdhl'AOMe usib WOO Ohcountdroid
at A M916 lddfle which was tbeordod bg, 6 PtOlMorit md,
Ud d
milli The Site W8108 of a, b6ftook fortgr
6t8t(Om Mubted at the eohflUdhd'b Of 0 tMdll
d6teond'ing w6tt,dtly, into bark CbhYoh Crook, Two granite, outcrops 00htg1h
0 total of 80VOM, bedrock "WCUOUIM 60 located on one or the outcrops
dhd tlX Mord l6tatdd 6M the sod6nd OutdPOP, situated l ca, 10 hittOrt MOM, A
thorough l thtpedtidn of tile tuPP6uhdlh9 area failed , to, PMduee MY additional
evidence of prehistoric U86 Or OCCUP806h, and this$It6 MY tient be vjow�:d,
as 6 satellite, task -'PecIfIr
-" locals 680610tod with: 6,ccupb(jOh at one 6F Moto
Of the "Or VIII806 8ROS rot6rddd within the qthbpal: vicinity,
The prdgtht Project rotult'ed
formally toodMino thl�, In,
161fto chid In to doing hiss PrMrvdd Itt,formatio iti
8research vhlud,�. No, further~ Mjtjg,at,6M or potential I" h
hd'
MKOSYi although It IS hoped that the ovth6r will prego MPACte" is
W
Nd, the site for Ite
Ifffifted r6croatf6hal Ohd gameroljhtd,p0St Valudg,
hd9btlVa field 6u lh view Or the
Parcel. are NdY 8hd r6cordt sedrdh results for the rehl-aind,or of tho
"66160fda'l Cld"ghdd is 6196 PWAIM06dod- for th6te arch;,
Howdv6rj, thdold MV6 c6ristmetion or other devel6pmojit activities rt veaj
dvldoho Of 8UbSUtfd06 prahittopla or historic, eultui al rnatarjo,l,
OrdN0661`0918t Mould be MhWtod fMM6df6tdjy in 5 qualified
ort)6� to, Wo$s the
Iffil6d" ofthe pr4dfddi 16 the Culturd'! f6860d0t IMVOIvdd,
at
JOSA'h$ P'6tdl* I'l.
1078 ArthaeOlogfCal Test Excavationg at Three Prehistoric Sltcc� witwu
tho Md'hdoolho Natwal Patott't Chico: treo Impt,ovomont rorml,
Butte Cour' ty* Calfr6rhid. ftopvt on, Pilot Rotthoant California
Intormotlon Center, W -Chico.
1979 ArChMIOOItdl
Southe4at ChWo Oeve'lopthent Project'. Ropbri Oh Met florthen"r
CaMOM16 InfornAldn Cohtor, CM -Chico, tnd: Cook & Arnigociateal
Orovilie.
1981 Archaooloei4tcdl peaohnmi Cance of tho 61500 Acre halon and
CbMpdbdto Timbor Wd Ardgt� But -16 OU PluMao Countiot
'Of
COH(Orhiki 110000 Oh File, Plumat NbOdriol Faroctt Ouindyt
californtgo
198k CUltut,01 AOSOOCO, 0MVIOW Uld f told Survey for tb, ,,p,,,dr
COIIM� We gHth b6Vojr_dpMdht Ptojdtt, YUbA Cbuhty, COJI(OW6.,
Adpon 6M, Pile, poothill b6floh atoup, MfirytIvilte) (Callfarntal! and
North, edhttat California throrM8116M Untori
198,3 AtthadoI60:1061 AWWWWO Or the PftPOOd 1100, Subdivitfoh
'roject 6n Yioofor road', 9'UttO County, Cabi'dM10. hoott on 1±116i
WthWt C0106MI4, Ift(OrMWOM OhWiz M-Chlao.
1§85 trf the, prap65Od Frenell 'Creep
Hydrodloctme Fir6jut, butte County# California" Aeport On rite,,
OrdyflI& Wyandotte ItMOOHM b1striCt orad Ndrtheag.t: Callfornta
Worration Lehter,CSIU-Chfoo.
WWI IFrwit A.
1970 MAIdtf and KdhkoWjIN, HIM(lb6ok of North Affioridwi lhdwtv volume
6'q COlIfOrhitj bbert, F. �qeiztp, WOSmi
rf pp, 370-386, theoritan
I h9t1tUtIOMj WASMMOOtlit bict
tinted Stoto.A. Dep8rfme-nt of tht Werldr
Docombor 3t, 1'083. Wa6filhgtonf b,.C11
UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF TIME INTE RIO
OEOLOGICAL SURVEY
MODIFIED FOR USMA FOREST SERVICE, USE
MOW043,
f
rPf�iF{{{
"��Yri �`p %" ,� •..u� a ��,,,,,,, �v�. r � ��� w h 5 � }� :. 4
tit
y,� . fir,• iy � � J J � � Y t�yP,• .
If , 'i F
"�...,"µ.... tC
1 f •� y �+
4
I Ir Jurk'r 4Yv�el
I,rJ.Pho
'r�,��..ti$�'' :�A 1 iMr'��a �"� i* ti v;�tr , �i,�r � '�y d� I�.F1 �;,.�,• ��� �r `(
no
•� lr I �t��JE5 i:3hIF + � (L� C7 �.�,��ci14. �9i1�,',''Yi �1: � r � p,�__, ' '•�, ,
sFw
C5� �,:w � ��' � ki�S` '�. � �.� � � ,. Ihw� u• �`~\ r rk r Iw'�`�C �
a ?I i s t >• 11x f �1 Y 1
l� i➢ ��" r� ti fld �w� !sist �i"� y�p#!�k
• � J ��« kyr 1. � ,,, -,� T � ,� _ ,.'
e )
ApproxifflAd
add
Survey
ArtC:,aa >� s" ., t ., ��: - :n �' - q �. wF � fir' :., t.�' •8'...E,�`�'�,�
T
}e
JolY t A! \tet
41 Fr
'g. +'�y�� �4.../y� �i r, fi 4 Yf{'� � ,�`(,. Vr.V4, �+', a•„` `�'w :e,
6tod'of itim, 3efol"o "Io no: vau I wo AV,
COPAMMOt Of PARKO AND fit-00ATIM4 UAomut,
ARCHEOLOGICAL SIT9, AtMono
4
UwNhio hino..
frolm gulte RdlO* 746, take Mp, tc4ftA RmA llft mild to intvf,
•till uitill
p1
gY
14 V-dy ft biad "g-OnA,
ion road; t1l t.ki f4pkf
gidd of vmd dd$l wid, tDirk Cd4y8n; ek witt th t-tg lo with
a Small 'Imam, dd tfibutaty. site thi F-efif ludiloa fjr tlw
2g �tlgf
WE- pipglp ti, %?�L
fttlill� 'arga, tr6t�dl.
0 0 ift t It ot. �q r ,g plip
Now
44, k6h,.AW atuit daA "livid,
AffifilA06 gad Ad'&6iAi 41-FItmollfitaiti, cil, le
�5�4
M _ _Iry
rAlt
"- r 4
�w
'',�.
w
yy��
Woo C ��e Y�' O YiA "7Gy� �
,�bbyyE[��
7M�.&u°W
�irti..�� G�!�:k#��d�3P 'Ai�i•��i���R`2Ya�'�R" �+,+..... ,
'4%iF�INi4l�io'� �i+di�skr'i�b�m'�'�' �iY4�'�x#�i�� ..,- •� _
u ^ ,i�d�u�w� .v v�"a;.:�..�wS.. „�.���,��,�1��,� lea _.,...,—.--.�-.—«•
„r.J�at
ly. L:WA0164S3i f9 Y. -tie a c '� ++'y.'""�`.�,'....,.,;.a.-...ve.�..b w
Mlal m« 2
� +'2+a "2 "+: 2 1 d. .l. r d4 h n Fa4 .Jk ,.. '.1._yk tit dl J� a 1p
�W �p p��y p i ,ywa..LL y{� ,,yqp _1y fJg�y
L�i1:YJ•6*FY,t goj tff,d: n9 tima l'Ifid A,+,n'SG)ny ix-.L.--r^t:�+^.+SJG.'i` F'i.,..---.-"`--^^.-
.-.... ".
w. .... .._..,w ....-arm—.:.....,++.a:�aa.u�..
4 '8
¢P , 11 J �?�tsi ,hd-hl- it �i �, v�cy �',<.-,-jrpvvw C
a ovW m
n
.—.w:.x..-..yam. ......
Oh 4W4 100'. NMI
UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
GEOLOGICAL SURVEY
MODIFIED FOR USDA FOREST SERVICE USE
s
121 ° 30' 629 m E, c owNry xa Alr.
39 45 I-- —� 30 Put coq
4,4 WI 131 r
i t Pal I 1( Y -y R 4 C 4t 5 E. 7'30
� I 1 i tri i 1� .� ;,° � �`" •Ir � � I 7)1
lit '46
e �'� ,, —I:, : Wr
16
p00�mN.'•-r ,r
�EA��'011p/`'tylr r.r :i"'•., .'�'`�.1111.,# t �({�
FI eros o lbtotl/i}Z011AYea1r �Il if !' `�; � 1 3,, 1� .
r° J arb Gap
Noo
26
99
H �2196t It�w��� ✓ il 1��� I �� �17 L_ I`
W V �t `1 i�'th s ,cb- �$4545A 1 +
_I
54515A� x,y 11'''1'• �' F
giI 1 i
4398 .��4 • s. , ASN"r iii» �'�11 `�� �, I �� 11 - .
Ih. � r � ��✓ p�� l�' r� n1 �ii � ' � U 5t tCS'�
Urkhill 1 1! I! //• ri i i ly' \1 t+yam ,�
t +�q o
/ r
Site '�i '1 I � ` ',`'�j'
Ladd N'1 , �; f3
` Gp%
U r
54545
1 -�!" •��`'. ♦ t,v.�-•"� . tt ; �w ; � Iii r 1 A ��
i.
4197
'�� �•• ) u r •`I I `� �� �1�'I
46,
. I '
• ( lY"
42'30" �n� i .'y
2.
54645A
� e
ca
SCT t" LAT ill
park CF-nyon Creek
112, () cups
Tn'tennittent Stream
Station fiti,
Cup
I,-),L-ig ElaLu
Nm
5 In,
Rr.ra2=n (06) 534-9687
associar6s P.0187X986 - OROVILLEXA95065
April 9, 1987
Job VsV001j00300041005
Butte County
Planning Dept.
7 County Center bri
Orovill;t CA 95965
attn! DaV(S
re : cinch, Arnold, Cowden and Sherwood
A.P. #58-21 '116 (ptn.)
Dear Dave,
Zn reference to the above may we offer the following;
I)kli IQ Co. PlannIA9 r-001UM
AP R I () '1987
OroV1110i c4tildmial
1.) Obtain a Public Report from the Dept, of Real estate..
2.) improve the road to the old AS 7 Standard (20 ft. wide, with 4"
of class 2 AiBi)i
3.) Agree to abide by the Dept. of Fish and Game mitigation measures
whenever it is possible to do so, or offer these as mitigation
measures voluntarily and pay the fees and raqtriot dog$ until such
ordinances, are passed.
We are vehenrahtly opposed to the chip seal standard as all maps
were submitted prior to the effective date of the now ordinance.
Also, we feel there are only 16 parcels off of this cul-de-sac
road as Dark Canyon road is a paved County Road.
The Skyway is a cul-de-sac by a very liberal interpretation such as
Dark Canyon Road. So are others in the County:
Wo will be glad to supply grade and drainaqe information on any
future road construction, which by the, wavt will. be held to a minimum.
A :speedy reply to this letter will be much appreciated.
Thank you
Sincerely,
ROM, GtaVO!4 and Associates
' .
' 1 7
..
..
- �
rl
r � ,
�A,.r i
1,
(\
�
•
'
r- • d
i_
� r
- '
�
� � 1 � s
� �
o.
e
� �"
�
e 6
N�
�
A ` � �
'
�1
� 1 r
r + -
. r
1
�.. 1 .! � .,
� f
A `4 r1 �� r r
� f
• o',�
�
� r
•�
r
er �
�
..
��
T R'
� i.
ti
.�
e
�;
' ,.
��
�.
f
A
� .
��ilEg,��
F
p
,
nrt.
r r +��� Ir' ..�
S,
�
�
'{bi
.
q
��
� �
'.
r
�,
.
�
�
r
�
. r
I,
�
r 7 . I ^ r
� �
� �
�' r
.,
_ �
�
r r
I. `
�
� rp
b
'
�
r
`'
'�
�
�,
�
. ,
•' �
�.,
w
��
�
/// i. 1'.1
t r
t, r.. Ir. 1
� �
.
�
r•�.
(. _ �{.,�
!
1
�'
� it 1 r
//j/
4��I.�i
5
�
•(
l
l
PLANNInG 404 i2'SSZc
APPLICANT
James Ladd
Log485-12-31-01
ADDRESS
400 OakVale, Oroville
CA
95966
OWNER Same
PROJECT DESCRIPTION TPM to divide 140+-- acres to create 4 paroC»ls_,
2 parcels - 20 acres, 1 parcel 51 acres +-, 1 2a ce7 45 - acres_
LOCATION On *:he East side of Dark Canyon toad, appxox. 20004 South
of its intersection oath Bich Bend Road,-Concow arca.
ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBERS) 58-21-16.6
ZC,NING�yr "Y��� .. GENERAL PLAN ' M ,,Ec `� , Gil ...__PROJECT CONaISTLNT?
GENERAL PLAN CONFORMANCE REPORT _
DATE OPAPPLICANT SIGNATURE
LAND CONSERVATION ACT CONTRACTS?
DATE APPLICATION RECEIVED December 81, 1985
AGENT/SURVEYOR/CIVIL EN ;INFER: Rosi GrVes . & Assoc w
ADDRESS. P.O. Box 986; Orovill.e, CA 95965
DATE PLANNING DIRECTOR'S REPORT PREPARED
ENVIRONMENTAL CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION - DATE FILED
DETERMINATION
AND DATE NEGATIVE DECLARATION - DATE ADOPTED -Z-;77:/ 6
,MITIGATED NEG. DECLARATION DATE ADOPTED _
t
ENV IMPACT REPORT - DATE CERTIVIED ,
STATE CLEARIN6HOUSE NOi
SUB. COMMITTEE MEETING DATE
ADVISORY AGENCY HEARING DATE r10
ADVISORY AC'ENCY ACTION - -
APEALED'_
APPEAL HVARING DATE
5 POiZ ICH USE ONLY!
$ut to County Manning Dept. Receipt I/
7 County Center Drive
Applicantt., 1�� �.L�� r��'
`roville, #CA 95965-3397' `
AP
916) 534-4601
Subdivision Dame (if applicable,
APPPNDIX.E
Date ria.�d L 3 ��
LAND DIVISION APPLICATIONS
Supple..-aental Information for Planning Department
List and describe any other related permits and other public approvals
�� federal a cnaies: J✓/�,�. _ � y city, regional.
state and ag
requited fot, this ro eat, includin hose requited b
2 Pi;oposod schedulingl'associatied Projects', .
p(phasing of subdivision units,
future development plans): � ,..
�, Anticipated incremental development
G3 What method will be utilized to accommodate surface drainage? Describe
how on -slate and downstt.'oam drainage chat npls will be affected,
5Proxitrity of Water for fire fighting purposes (hydrants) pondsy etc,):
'rl l: ��O��T"l�{= lvj r cL` C77JV1P1 1 f C!'n1Y(V, Ah 7V 'LO bu G..t..Ce
6, Will excavation or grading be necessary? Subic yards (estimate')'t,
u'C
7, Directions for travel to property (rural grid mountainous axeas (jtily),
d l 6 1� %" _ rj / J �la71 a �t� C..4 �r l �1i % =r'xa• r"� Iu `(" 7" G► ' � 1i l�'w .
d f t;N IROINENTAL IMPACT8 AND MITIGATION MEASURE8vt
Identify potentially significant environmental impacts'aasooiated with
the land division. 'What project design features or special, conditions
of approval (mitigation measures) are Proposed to allevint;0 potential
environmental impacts?
9'. ENVIROMENTALI SETTING*
a) Describe the project site as it exi.sto before the projoat,
including information on topography, soil stability, 151tgttts
and animals, and any cultur.11, historical or scenic 401)(Icts,
Describe any existing structures on the Site, and this u#ie of
the atruatuies,
b) Describe the surrounding prcpetties, including information on
plants and animals and any cultural, historicalor scartic as 060,
Indicate the type 6f :Land use (t°esiderytidiy commerciolF etn;.�,
intensity of land use (one -family apartment houses, shops, depart-
ht stores', etco), and scale of development (height; ft'oaxtage
fi'ir'04ack, rear yard, etc. ,
Ii!�trta b�'v�icapra
b�C t'3 185;
GtRTIVICATION! I hbteby eert-ify that the statsmwag furnished above and in
the attached exhibits ptesent the data and information required for this.
initial evaluation to the best of my ability, and that the facts, statement`s
and information presented aro true and correct to the best df my kno�rlerign
and belief:
*Use separate sheet for longer responses:
9L) k lrf+_ r jurL{} `rf C.t, �'r.. .a - �' M w Mw t ✓y, 1-1.41 .KY pa.c4 85
V V !
U
/rt/+'�//{�J {//1 .i ���.�' �� ��r/'�F/��� ✓�L,T�'�",-'WIM�i��A 1
�'-��'�.�, �-�../� ,�-,rr..�,zl � ;:GG.t rYld ��• Cyt %��t;�.,,�,� i''�`�tr�.c
.4
COUNTY a BUTTE
OtPARTMOT o PUgL IC WORKS
7 County Center Drive
aeovillel CA 95955
515-5J4-4266
916-534»4330
February , 198'6
ouffo CO. le,�igtn l„ triq�,
Fed gel 1986
OrOV16, 1000
d'ame' M, Ladd
flora OalcVale RC; AP �8-p:L-166
0110VII10) CA 9596 Tcr�tut;i:v�y ��zyee� lata
Dear Mr. Ladd:
theA enc adopted t y_,_
At the regular Mtetin of the Butte County Advisor Agency held February 1f3
p he negatiVe declaration regardit�� environmental
► view and approved the tentative parcel map for A r di
gubJdct to the conditions as listed an the attached theot, X66
if no ap eals are � )
Advisory pAyer�c �s timely filed.6a raval�� Within ten 110 days�of the date of the
y app with the Clerk of the Board of uporvisor�sy
this action will be i:inal
When the conditions of approval are complied with, i will be in ard'
for you to file your "final 100" with the 5utto County hep4rtmont er
Public Works for recordation within twenty four (24) moMth$ of the,d
Of approVal by tho Advisory Agency, he date.
If you 01auld have any questions regarding thisattor please contact
this office.
Very truly fours,
William C11off
director^ of public Woi ks
n Men ansa
gsistant hirector
d�Ins
Attachment
cc. Bnanning Ehvironm0hta'l Review
virorftital Health hepartment
!!on Cravat
tg 1110 �ReVised 2_�C�84')'
James
M. Ladd', Tentative Parcel Milp, On the east side of Dark Carryon Road
approximately
2000' south of itS ntersection with Big ilond lioari, on r��
area;
AP#
58-21w168
Engineer;
i?on braves
Public
Works conditions,
1,,
provide ttao xray traversable access RS -8 -LD -1 to each pdreel from a
county maintained road cis state highway.
9.
Access to be reserved in deeds as per county ordinance arid offewed 'for
dedication on the final asap,
3`,4
o�ii{�5�0 ft building so-tback line me.asurecl from centerline of access
Shir
easement'..
4,
provide read mai nterrance agre&reWt.
by
Indicate a 50 ft, building setback from the centerlina U` Dark Canyon
Road,
E.
Slow all easements of record on the final nlap.
7,
Provide vtreet nalne signs per reguiren)Onts of the Department of Public
Works prior to VtWdatibn of the final snap.
8.
Obtain encroachmeht permit and construct standard road approach providing
adequate sight distance at tite intersection of access road. and Dark Canyon.
Road.
g.
Pay any delinquent taxes or current taxO as, requireC
10.
Mddt tho requirements of the Butte County tiro 8opartment
Henn-th Dept, condition -W.'
w cw n 50 1't, lerchrield �-ethack *om tha dr,'Arl(Age watl.- Det pat(aeld
and 4
0hUw a luachfte,tdse-11,tick from the :4+im.. of Vh.0
cx'r ek on parcelo I and 2i
. .
;1hcw the u3able two �wre aew'aO d3,apOcAl arra peuvard to meet the
requireimenta of the :lutdivi, don ovdAnatwe on Parc pI!..
NOTICE OP WTERMIN, Al
TO: t tloo oil ann. ng and Rdsdardh FROW 1 tatttrt tl C �idilr tfli t�
1400 Tenth 5treat► Raom 121
5soramtnto, CA 9$814
Dr��
n 95965
or
county of ... tiUr:ra:
.. F111hg Of Notloe of ��torfriinat oil finCma1lan�;+� with $ootinn 21168 or, X115'
of the Pub9 R'Lswuroo C .
�AlJORM BECKUr�'eurrl���iwr6
ro t 'fitlo_ _. _ ,r k. Lt.
AIP? .fits %1 put ..
�
Niitie
oi� i i e _ trlap
f�O .t,add_
t tc Z5 r 1hg hoi1W Num er+ cwta t #person
Cit subr ittad to cidaelhoduse ' Tclo� orae Nu'm '
_.Public worka�o?i�.td�ri
lit 1,dcitt an n the osat -41dor of imrk. canyon
2000 feetgduth of its inter goctibrii with 811bdAd Road, COfttW area,
1 p Tdi�tat
eot T�sc`tf tion Vo Paj:!el MAP dividing 140 . a I d t _ 6t t , 61 dtdato 4:
j++ ddl i tW6 At 20 Ao2o19, at t '`: and Ofid At 45
T114 f& to advlso that tha
bU t" : gt!UOL�y
appt�ov6di the above des tribocl projd-c hhdg has �ador t tha ��96WIOMIUJO n , dotarm a lon
gardi t abn++a doserlbed prajodt t
1 'iha rad t ; �v1ij, -;,will r at$ Navea 61ghifioant effect cid tho crlvirotirnot tw
to the rovi$iort bf . .
Ari 1r►viromar�tal tt t Cat ryas prpardar thls+�jctst�it
A, Ne-g-ative b6diaratIO Was propared for this ped)d pll°>=St taut t the
The Elk, or Ncptivo btolatatloo arld etedrd of peolddt apprdvai ray be
eXaMined ate
lit1'gatlor it�ca ttr`c warn, :ward h6tj made: a r dltl6h of the approval'
of the ped1dm
x A statLithOt of Ovorldit CahMderatloh
. ;� lVar t, biopted f dr'
tiffs pC�1��Gt.
li�
pati' Raceli►ed' :for 1~111rfg
5 Heil A,, 9i toet e
Title
In��r�p�p�rlm�liigl Mersldfohdun�
TO., ButtO COufttY Advisory
lx ROPOttn Ott Unt at ivo, pare ,
February, 71 1986
This
@ 2 a t o bat �, ��rt����
l a rop
promit
Tho a d 2,
thddAutat ll Couhty rt to t� d ra
f t t t tt
aWahl Or thift
tm s Voot h A . hoto are tto p 1 to Oe Community
Or
Of Oft"Imttty ,PlAft.
Ndt dt An archaeological gu:tvdy SIng 1btOCOMOlido-dwt� kfor'�tj t'� �^j4rl
Rots V'favdg
Or
P R*4
PI arwo I no, COMM I Vt-', i Of,
tuoxctt Tontntivb popqol Map too Jazo, N, Wd
AV HOW%
no,* M-12-.31.0
Map to dividCy 140 6005-
ft;,", Ono OF U! 8000 anc ena
rr Of "0 mrcvb
48 OCPQSv
did* 04 Jark nvan RON*
ton with 81-0 HOW MCI orovi'lld
Thd Otto wat; Prapbood, fop Al W600v Ifol J'OtIt" tat-,
81.64-08081, and it AdIUM We
Of ithlO CUr-post KNOCK "ho, UP vv
gyp
Jeoppod in Wr."if" T -"#f t-150-401dory 1100 Tho
OtUdy PrOP&-od f0f, thoL 'O"'0tv0p won vlovov WOUS but x 4 Covoy or tea'
Inaludod in thil CuPrOnt btstAtIvo pnpeaj ;Mijp* At tKO t?,M0, Of tfi§
original wavvtv sopilution* a mitigatoa Neq3tym
MommondoS With 0 M10600h to to thdt an dych=01001041 survoy bta
Prefopmed tot bnv fuvthov divy0yopt* tho ot too PoWtWo-
Parcol of Wy time to tul-1voy. lob apoa
It
,0t�gJtJVjtV* 6111d On
nocusaa,v 1,n ovdm to, 'f alowsca"t
oxiWit. oti g1to grid . 14 to to wol, uppropyoto Mit 16tibo M§BtUP01*
th* suuJoet proporty to =0 sonatod so on 000a op mvndl Own Qv,�
bond habitat t bad in W A006 th3t tho b0pdotwoAt of pith & Wobw
ho ntw-paynniq W WWOU 1oy5 tbin 40 0=5- TWO YedJOC't
dung pt-opogo. deoat„ ing two pdnto" of to mron dnehl tat thowpoodals;
sto, vmttod he-xt to ptlticalnr4-Aaq.Jtt!q in 0!1rd from APPILORI'Mat0y I Wro OP
to 1U jj�,-rovs* As suuhs town project would not bb voth Other
dovalupmem; in tho 000A '[Ahd dould 40 v1sweJ a,, 1"Wt'-4ojo (,nMWmr1tb havo.-
ON Yet troop eoealivbd ft�om tE,,n 00-Parth"Otit of Ptsh & Sato Indthevofovo
thyo pobbstmont �:uuld dh6H90, 64V "do"Od''w
�j Jjj at , J 9 -dim tt.021
mgm -M IA to-BbAW
fflj§gU,t id dubboMtod at this tiho, An, AVChMAWCal
gurvdy will bo A0CWg6Vv in oedea to dotevdiihO of SlOjmlfltdfi�
Archodoldgitdl dr tlfadth ox0t dem alto ond* if tot to dov&OP
yppropristo mittgotloo moosupoga)
to
My,
at I
a Ox 242 W cook
.xU;i-"' inIi,",b YI �f'� TM�r.agy, M y�
{' SN�S5 a j �+...• Alf l .t ?� G.
t �,x1'
9:���'� i �'"l�W�iG�"r€" a4�"'k� P�"wfl.'� � 1'��Lt �,i �� y�J •D it ,
�mj.aux uo�,' p ��ir�'� ����°.� �0. R�� �11..�.�&�"C. fC'M i L
kit
A !r ,�n�� N�^r
a
5..,ri.t, r yi* i.", '1.. t
'r:�`4 ��^ l _,.�' p � i•'n ��'w"F 4(nrys� ;m'�n��y� � .w. : " I' -"�� �. i jr"'_�,' '
.2�'
4&iWw
q M � Ca f[" i ti W� �� , is :.1.11 �n 4f F' Y�'� Y�,• • .}r�. J
I' VaiI'�"it� YJ�, .'a.tI". Gu sii`�u,_V
t a Henry ,p1 i,i`yy �` 1t ,Wp
Vrolkf U YJ'a° dwui: e C. B'4 Py• �
r
.�a+:
t
' � � lti . �° ''� � ,• p 1 t' %�a�° t"E' ,"�E''r"t '� �'„ t�'`.,u C'. k:«.tlnl "��',.
! A
. „ E5* aM,�,� � �� °:�' w� w "1«�.".� k�a�.�e.Mi ��. ?^',�� �• �4�. � M nY C..y ik� �"^d� �N?j"4�'�v"'i` �°,...
n"I that "11!hcugh colic 11,�,OpbOCI tl O';"! y 610 1 !�zvjui L
2' It t -r- will rat 1'';i! a ',"tH„k'i'MM'#. tt
"'A i 4'IT"P T un,
ti11`t .. ro 9$".',',F�j .d .ac . ; Y 1111 I.!Lo a i- * , A
the vr1.'iq`91,9sivv' 1�,.i MAY bavo ti
anJ '.9:�
<, ;fix,• 4 obot ._24
w
David R4, 111twilN,
v
t
a
wo
gP; pyy{yyyyy jj77 qq���py�yy may( y� F y�7
itY �G ✓ d �1 R, Y o p A. poinal, 3k S.n!.P
• ;;ppi�gg ��jpp Y' �,7rrYN{g�j �y'd l5{'�
LZ 11ot T'`!.
i � 1
Wy�oiz
r O
4iuyya'nnC{pq":�.j�igpa`y
date. 4, u ,�110,
«. �p
ti4�i 'i:.. ��s��� Cl��i I''��CF �,+•Xx '�"�'»4'. I`�'Y�•wi '�
�3'
•w{�f..
c q =-r&'V - C.wc.n
," ACdA * ` t
<fF :I'w
X''i .�'��> 1., �-k ti7� b,�,
1 11C'.RryPy� C�iyy�II 4, C.1, t. Nx V:. .�i. U � k , o
A1+�y ��
p, �❑`IF -SSS y
''Wyyy ;�``�rpl.++.��. (�
rt�u %�M
���. �� ���x�����F.S �,.:.� �6�'�S t,Jtl. ,il.�� ,`'.�rp�� .•l� "�1����-Ik �4
4. a
,:���.ek:°,i���� i;�°� ,x�,
��d4�C"�4"��.�tJ��a "�v: +,d4Ai�4�4 �.'„:`��:,,�•�'.w°,�.,tL4'�,�
ppei
I4.,3Sr�y':'.i' up�vl...5°�Uw,yke�uwh�U°y..,:'�.`.'J.}ml�,�
�F�X�+�4Vpj+�"�'I. �.�v0. l �.'.:'.; �1C i.w�C: I�.,��P' �I�WW�� •M�, 'l� E".. +;l. �l..0 `S.w i4
q�
I�4��H,
rw �I .y
ri 9 it'. +� s Py t �',�: Ydi �� : i i' � :ai' . �. ''. *,
4+ %�.�it.W x� i✓'�,sw
x�,+'up�a"a !�'!mgyv'r.»k�r
Mww.}i'.ta
c o
iSy,an„uW�L�. mml�
p�yryp�FMy �.d{ta ",-N$.w
lo"tN-1 �°'�..' r i�:S V �+7aG, M'° ..+ RA''iV - t.J� kS. 1�J; .ta �i � ti.��w.b 1,.4 H.
pp'Yi�
i4;L'Ju�i�H@
' V,� �
W�"F �: � � Y "M F..7t i}i'. 4�. a�i�:�i I'A,M� S;,r 4 .'� +,,,. �'`M 4v� �c �'.• �� � P' rw y. �1e w f' V J"� N � � �r
S.'�'p
��"<'q4�kA%Ind u`-.0 f.i 0,u-3tmt 4,4� wallc.*rte
y4.,.{,
_..,....�
°,.... _
fti
T, v;.'. w"wW�� *`� �.'` .". .'�!� '. �4 �•° 'lpy n• i=-'yi'.!"�a' i,,,
f,,.4tcy%yy
_
yy�'��e�i�ee:!, ,k'�y�'
tt�`v�-"�
j.
p 1�`
LR1f,�'..4 ik 15.y; 1tiRk'c�.I.:FM LN i� aLb
��y�. ��}y"�[t�vy�tt;''�ry''''�{�y
• � '�',
�a�+yp" y�pWq y ��p� q 1` ,F
t kr4 HAy
Tn �t$• �yq'� I� {,.� i:� '3'I 'f°.%0 t 1 4 tl {� v rlxt ✓ J'Y..
•KIM �A.{3�.} yHy�1.,a
y�, +}�+
iJ yy�k y yy,, 4 G r ,, v.s y`4� pyv y�� 4' In
Fy���- :#w ifw _''���1.�€r4 iA� 5Y'l. 4.ku `W
ei Me ;,�}tt� t c W
w�.A4S.&W.��X���"J� tilf an,
�.
mater s u o,
t
YES
h1n NO
4. pLANT LIVE. Will the proPostil result in s'ubstdntia
or number
a.. C ange in the diversity of specios,
species of plants (including trees,
of any
. simbs, grass, crops, and aquatic plants)?
Reduction of the numbers of any unique, rare
v.
or endangered species of plants?
of plants into an
c. Introduction of new species
in barrier to the normal replenish"
X
area, or a
ment of existinb species?;
any agricultural clop?'
d. Reduction in acreage of
5. ANIMAL Lipp. lVill the proposal result in substantial
numbers
a. Change in the diversity of speciesor
of animals (birds, i;and animals
of allyspecies
including reptiles, fish and shell fl',h,
benthic organisms or insects)17 .
in the numbers of any tirtigt�c , rare
b. Reduction
or endangered species of animals?
of animals into
J
c. introduction of new species
area, or result in a barrier to the migration
an
or movement of animals?
d. Deterioration to OXisting fish or, wildlife
_ r
habitat,
--
6. NOISE. Will the ,)roposal result in si,bstantial.:
levels?
--
a. increases in existing noise
Exposure of people to severe iaoise levels?
b.
7. LIG4T AND GLARE. Will the proposal pyoduce
s r.gnfica.r�.t light and glare'
-� .--
g. LAND USE. will the proposal result in a
alteraltlon of the present or planned
su stan'tial
land use of an area?
9, NATiJIt.AL RESOURCES Will the proposal rbsult in
substanta a t
a. Increase ita the rate of use of any natural
:.
resources?
b. Depletion of any cion-renewable natural
resources?"�
10. RISK OE �UPSET, tiji�.j the proposal involve.
Arae off' explosion or the roleaso of hazard-
a.
ous substances (including, but not limited to,
in the
oil, pesticides, chemicals or radiation)
an accident or upset conditions?
event of
b. Possible 3,nterferenco with an emergency
ovacuation plan?
response plan ar L-ergency
ll. POPULATION, lqill the proposal alter tho location,
rate of thea human
istr: ution, density', or growth
population?
1 , HOUSING. 1jill the proposal, affect OxIstin� housing,
housing?
V
ur create a demand fo-r additional
YES
TRA�SPQRTA T.1-0-N'//C1RCULAVT11TC)N�)ENO
result �n•
ill the proposI
a- Generation of subStantial
4 movement? additional vehicle
bo Bff,0,:ts on 0%
'ist,ng par king facilities,
demand for nel%r parking,7
Substantial impact on �XiS4—
system$9 "Ing transport.,tion
d. Signifi*
Icant alterations
to
Of Circulation or movement PrOsOnt pattorno
goods? 'It Of people and/cad
AltOrations to Waterborne, rail or air t
increase in traffic hazards' to motor
bicycl*
Ists or pedostr,
PL'Bj'IC SE"'Cr" the proposal haVc. An
go Mian, or result in a need for 11eW Or altPled
VernMelltal services.,
a,, Fire protection?
b: Police protection?
C. schools? ...
do Parks Or Other recreational facilities?
e Naint0hance of public faci7jtjos, I
roads?
f Other 9OVOMmental 8ervi&,7
aENhAUY, lVill -the proposal result in:
se OP Substantial
I - amounts of. fuel ,or energy,
b, Substantial increase, in demand upon ex, .1 -
IS tln,�
Sources Of energy, or require th, de�O
Of new Sourr-,Lss ' V lopment
Of 'nergy'?
UT IL I T TE 8. lVill the
........
new systems, or substproPsal result Ln a need for
followingf ' antial alterations to the
a, POWOr or natural gas?
b. communicat ions systems? 41
C. Water:
d. Solver or Septic tank?
0' StOrm Water drainage0
f, Solid IV,'-qto and disposal?
17 8U1...IAN... lit -AL
a creatlo the proposal result
D of any health hazard 0. I)o 4
he'lit], hazard (excluding menu tontial
b, EXPosure of people to potential heqltll),?
hazards? al health
Is. At� S Tyr, ir ICS' 'V"l the Proposal res
o FS t � � it—on O� ult in the
the public, or Anyl-8cen't vista or ViM41 open to
creation W1. I the Proposal result i
to PLI C of i an aesthetically OF " n. the
bli V ew?E*ens'" Site Open
--. -.- --�4
M
YES MAYBE Nth'
AntiXnATxUN. Vi1.i the propo:ial result in all impact
upon the (1ue; i. �y or quantity of existing recreat,onal,
Opportunities'?
CULTURAL
a. tivx Ll10 J)roposal, result in the alteration
Of or the destruction Of a prehistoric or
histric archaeo-�ogiclll
b. Villotile proposal result sin�adv rseyh s cal
or aesthetic ePfe is to a prohistor, ��^
ltistorac. building, :�tructurc ox obje cto
C. noes the Proposal have tilt* potential to Cal.ise
�I physical change tvlti.ch ivotrl<i a i~act uniquec:
othn cult:iral. Vatuos`?,
d. Will the proposal, restr'ct exi.sti.tt�� rcli� icarrs
car 5�ec S'e'ri use:; tcithin the potential i.ntiar ct
arc��t�
c
vo , 15 CU551t1N or. i`�1tI RONMENTAL EVALUATION
homesite►vhich oott7, rup ion yr 1 a it from aanat u :# on iii an additions
e, �, �oxl d�.sru ta.
Id. ncrease t:tie eros on susceptibility and sadi:mentati.o
ni" the, site in downstream areas, Stabilization Of graded areas and drai,nt
Y depending p
improvements may be Headed de �endiil upon location of tdic�, x+cldxt:iona.� home
site or home siicrs» Due to the size of the properties this is not expecte
to be a signx£ic:a.nt impact.
1 h: The Big Bond :Fault traverses t.ho lmmediatO area causing potential
s0ismic *,ppeople,, r
evidence boiai's,ult�j,rovemantmir tthenrecgeologic I there is no recorded
the Big 'lend fault. All of Butte County i;.s in ti moeldratc� n this area near
int�.on9ity' zone Wit,
hrosion and Land site slide hazards are rated moddrato to high in
is mountainous region. HoWeverq the 1it�z£�rCda are probably 1t�1v on'the
.
tn:d stabilization pract�icas should bo insti,'tt1 we ha .a011 ..exoads
d elanrd areas ivithari the sate 'fin reduce
� c7 �.n constr ,i' .
uc� of , an
e home sites HOMO sites should be located on the more level..oridgotop,
and h lltopr within 'the property,
3 b : Storm drainage can be readily accommOdatod by onsite drainage
courses and Creeks
5h! Soil limitations eXist :or onsite salvage di,sposa3 Ysterris borrause
ot" shall.ar�nOss, ste;apar Stopes on major portion;; of the site, and high
orosion Suss opti;bil,it.Y. Ground wa.tor rOsaurces may be questional to dtLq
to quantity and depth within the yubjoct property,
c� 1, importandi
5 d4 They projoct site lies Within aux area of special, biol.o»� '
b rV3zltiCsp deer 1lerds. population Op . ` .r
ro,iont wilt resiz�ict t�e��xtxt�r���at�Q�im��%��lr����1 mcpt u� �i�e.,t� habitat'
size tit the �tJ,t o hul)itat6 The- lti ge
proposed pareels would not sigriilcant:ly reduce the habits
in this case and the; surrcunclln Il:i klaA
developed ivi�ch numerous `id Ild� efiv`irons is currently
10 acre home sites which r6duco the value of
this spt;ciilc "i to 1:Ot rxtiti.cal habitat.
A
PISCUSSrON OF t-NVIRONMENTAL, EVALUATION (continued)
� property will "re resent a '�,
14: While not si � ifxcant the develo Ment of an addit�0441 homosito
on thy" I� n 4-cremental lncreaso And demand for
Public services:,,
17 1
b �'s rte r
; ted hi is
The natural fire hazaz'd of this arei�
�Cerere Flan;
Safety Element) dine to v�.getatic�n, terrain atitlying� 'rt�rr��,, location away
from mayor fi re protection serva r
N
"tie at d 1im.lt6d >s
acc Ctitu�re residents.
may be exposed to taildfire hazards, Also increased r i,dential. activity
may increase the frequency of w ldland fix
burning activities es, particularly from yard
20 z
d, The ixrojert sate is located within aft arOA Of high arch(leologital
sorysitivity, bovelopment of roads and homasites could 'damage or destr"I'
significant archaeological resources in the area, Axe
,arcllaeolo�;ica1
mpactsurvdy has been requostod in order to more complotoly cssess lay potantiat
,
1�1) p Xi 'jo Ph c it
LALPA D, Loft
I i?
T.vp' of
AOPth bst
--1 — if- — - -1-1t - —I M I elA I naL 10—
P0
2 1�
4
V Cd i f
jqn �285
444 -rtn
A. it WA
llod of
oLt it so
0 t a S*
01i. n' W"if aj3- "I
l
to tho
ti on tha
WA � TIP �il y rtl
ZbAing would *111OW
ty
ltind aliove
J-t.04!PdL.�YOft tavino ih A 'ni6iiti+n4*iA4&A - I
4 a
lAuva-tljx'I: Prom 18,000 to
Pjrox ,
1! 0
gravoll
kOln-on hiliv +'.titvi,4�h
V.Shall,6w r mio,
o L,aiid
t -h
b Lvo.'.Jol.
M-6 64, t) 1 �ih d.,
thd
dtePidw ii
y
d wifth.lin
Shoot colitinued
(14
(normal
Iq-
4 A- :A
Et)
so fir,
MAP
rod
ttft,", fti t n
Spo 0 0 :4
a win
sit
J tIvj 'I hill"'i, 1 10 IN
dtchdbologj�,41 tent a yh
- - - - - - - - - - -
Py,
xx
rad Property, f6 r
09t land Ott r t
opdn- ford6t yj
Andon
it rural
'ton_ loss
-Nm-� ��, I .. ac v
SpArC61 -,
tit rclta
land g
0
p Jft i 16 ropjon
r;.L
Aron., 140
Yjivow.
vd1uhtoor cdo:
r. vI �tl b 11 +
in
Appondix 'It"
II
R fey{
H
m
14
��� .
` v71
isvii
c
u�;.= m.. ...�� r
::1, wa J"$✓ gyp, Yrk
mrj^p�
4.mY'50
:m:_ ?'d',,A
*:.tdAy 9dst�,. •,`
Ar, 4001 R
gym^'�,il�e
777
t5c p
ti
ik
p
q w d'i1
!>
'
�.+m#x,�,._.'' 9 ;; y; "',•, °+r` p , <" d
q z l
+��IPtl4r Vf aP fl, yy.g�q �° P'w. w,
�i"�/Fµ AR
f,4 k�
� .:d ;�_, ��. J, ." '�*. ; �S+s :;'.. �,s. 4..�• �:� ��rI'�
�N'
Q
c
11
a'F7a9�y•,, " �#� #. {..�"a �q Y i _y.i" w y A +� rM� k 6�"9s ,+}y� yp�—
.,...r«'.li+.f�k...,....,r a .. �'. ,'1 r,. -a;. k �'#,da°IS e.,C�l3.k'. W:ww �Ii _.
�M #
� .fir �`3°�`�°� �'�:;
a
�q Y y
�'� t"� Ifs +r:"JT.Im
yak{' �� }� ti � •do-
,patRv/
`�•'�"'' � �'b ���k rly ', .� �t�,r �, + ,�., .�ir��� 4y:�, .,,,y,��, yy`w „>w ; �" ;�I���»�,a � „,,,, �� '1 � � i,:
• y. _.. 1 , ,"a"" `.',
suf a
;
py q ply
19W�� M7� r,ai
A _ I
�y,Iw
WeJ � �}Y Y � i� .�t��y".' o• y� r,,,
.A . ' I tt � yk ACf
�J
al �B _ • � ° � , ' � �:�
�r kk3 Y k 4� #.i e,^ }a. " � �' 1 � � ♦� �._._.. ��r.'w wa,«m.�Y df'IT ;y t`.Y�°�. �. _ 5 X —
+y+ _
4ta
m
0
11 VV -1
if p4 � F
¢4 +t Q' mIt
om«
' L M :
Y�4'.�LI �""•q .y��p�'��.Y .11i,.. Nw �u ' �
�..�
:�y�,i�y, '� T. m'�wW.
i, 1�'
'.
1Y
M'
I, '�,v�.a
.? v?' `"" "' }
Y� •".
w„
�' i
�• to
i »i i ..p w
°`� ,0111
y ,+
5Y
'.
r ak l4 4t .f'' «
R�'t�"�C r
9 k
.wM ��
r«s
.c a ..
�
„, ,., -. ...:...-�..�. w-.. �......x.
,r
,
� Y
4'1 '
Awk
55
�� M