HomeMy WebLinkAbout061-480-027J .
.:,. 1
�� �,�, � '
®,.
•^ e �
._ � K
t
'i .1
-�
�r� \
�, I
� Id �'k7. . 1 e 1 A
•i
1
\
�
7 i
-. r
J �'e
�
i
�
1
e �
✓
�
� y t
1
'
' �
..
...
-
��
-
�,
� -
•
•
.h 1
O �
.`
�
-
_
�.
f
p
1
..
..
aM1:
\,
1
�
•
e
i'.
1i Y�
� 1•{
.'O
/
, e ' e
�,fIi�
VV/
1 '11\
u �
� J � .
A.
�./•
n ..
r 1 t
_
-
,�
.
� a
_� ,
�e• v
,
�,
J .
.:,. 1
�� �,�, � '
®,.
•^ e �
._ � K
t
'i .1
-�
�r� \
�, I
� Id �'k7. . 1 e 1 A
0 0
PLANNING COMMISSION SUMMARY SHEET POR LAND DIVISIONS
APPLICANT Sid McQueen Smith Lo #87-02-25-01
ADDRESS 1320 M-�-. Ida Road, Oroville, CA 95966
OWNER Same
PROJECT DESCRIPTION Tentative Parcel Map to divide 320- acres to create
eight parcels from 30 to 50 acres.
LOCATION,_.: On both sides of Bell Ranch Road approximately 2800' West of its
intersection with Orr Quincy HighKa East Oroville area.
;ASSESSOR'S PARCEL,NUMBER(S) 61-48-27
ZONING U GENERAL PLAN Timber MountKaWECT CONSISTENT?
and Agr_ictl.tural-Residential
GENERAL PLAN CONFORMANCEREPORT
DATE _OP APPLICANT SIGNATURE"
LAND CONSERVATION .AC's' CONTRACTq?
DATE APPLICATION RECEIVED 2-24-87
AOENT/SURV'EYOR/CIVIL ENGINEERS G..D.A.
ADDRESS., 220 Grand Avenue] O oyille, CA 95965
DATE PLANNING DIRECTOR'S RnPORT PREPARED
ENVIRONMENTAL CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION DATE Pl=
DETERMINATION
AND DATE NEGATIVE DECI,ARATION DATE ADOPTED_
MITIGATED NEG.
DECLARATION DA'Z'E A00PTE0 .�. �
..
ZNV. IMPACT REPORT.' W DATE C4RTST'SED
STATE CLEARINGHOUS NOS
8UBi. COMMITTED' METING DATE
ADVISORY AGENCY NEARING DATE CIL
AOV 80RY AGENCY ACTION �
e
..... ,, :APPEAL HEARING, DATE
A�?P�4 APPEALED
0
NQ'. ,CE or DE:rr-JF-lr,?
1M1ENA('CON
To Off -ice of Planning and} Research pounty
rrZ' PROM. Du ,Lu C
1400 Tenth Street, Room,121
Planning m
Deportent
Sacramento, CA 05814 7 County Cento
r Drive
or Oroville, CA 95965
X County Clerk OCT 0 '19eCl
County of Butte
G. EMERO
SuBa7
aEc: Filing of Notice df,-Det-ermiilatio-ry-..ind6fii"p'liance with Suction 21108
cir 21152 of the Public Resources Code.
Project Title AP # Name
1'entative parcel Map 61-48-27 Sid McQueen-Snlii-h
State Clearinghouse Number ConLaCt Person Tele-ptione . Number.
(if submitted to Clearing:iouse)
SCH4?t 87042120 Jol -n Mendonsa 538-7266
Project Location -77777777
J On both sides C -Z Bell Ranch Road, a
pproXimately 2800
feet West Of its intersection With Oroville-Quincy'Highwayt north
and east of Oroville.
Project Description Tentative Parcel 14ap dividing 320± acres into eight
parcels ranging in Site from 30 to 50 acres each.
This is to advise that the ..Butte County Advisory Agency
(Lead Agency or Responsible Agency)
has approved the above-described project on 9-28-87
and has Made
(Date)
the following determinations regarding the above-described project:
I. 'he project -- will not, have a significant effect on the
dbvironment4
2i An Environmental Impact Report was prepared for this project
pursuant to the provisions of CEQA,
X
A Negative beclardtJoh was prepared for this project parsi�ant to the
Provisions of CEQA,
3. Mitigation measures Z—wOte# -.�Wete not, made a condition of the
Approval Of the project:
4, A statement of overriding considerations Wa8o _-2j-Was not, adopted
for this project,
This is to certify that the final tIR With comments and responses and record of
Project approval inavailable to the gehatal public at,
Butte County Planning Departmtht
I County CeAttr Drive
Oroville, CA 05065
Date- Reckyived for Piling And
'stip"3 at OPR K
Signdtufle
Stephen A* Streeter, 80nide Planner
Tito
AVited Mardi 1086
Atk %164 u
'
4 % -0� -1 el
'AX
t
Tentative Parcel Map
Sid McQueen -Smith
Mitigation Measures
AP461-48-27
1. Meet the requirements of the California Department of
Vish and Game regarding streambed alterations for bridges
and/or other stream crossings.
2. All disturbed areas to be reseeded, except road surfaces.
3. All Woad construction to be completed, including drainage
structured, surfacing ditching, etc., before the rainy
season erosion.
4 Place a note on a3^ map that, "with the exception of
crossir,gs for prs • =:,e driveways, there is to be no
construction acti. A,.i.es or removal of riparian vegetation
within a strip of Land measured 50 feet from the high water
line of Sycamore Creek" and also "Meet the requirements of
the California Department of Fish and Game rugarding
streambed alterations for bridges and/or other stream
crossings.
5, Note on Map: "if either of the two identified
archaeological sites are found to be within the limits of
this project, offer a preservation easement to the Society
for California Archaeology.
.. �
A
.
�•. -�
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WC)i1KS
WILLIAM (Bill) CHEFF, DIrO001'
7 cOUNTY CnNTFR ORIYr: * OROVILLl1, 0,A1,II1OQNIA 95965
Tetcphdho- 59161 538.76111 RONALD D. h1«ELROY
pdpuly G1IMOOV
Bu+tn Co. Pinnning CgruM
c�xTz�xrD MALL SSP 2 9 1987 .
OrdV1110, Cax1forlIJA September 28, 1987
RE: AP 61-48-27
Sid Mcqueen Smith Tentative parcel Map
1320 Mt Ida Road
Oroville, CA 959G5
Dear Mr, Mcqueen Smith: ry Agency held on
At the regular meeting, of the Butteutneatx� declaration with
Septe,Iber 28, 1987, the Agency adopted
envircntaentel mtitl8ations and approved the tentative parcel map on
the al,ove
-referenced property subject to the conditions listed on
the at Lached sheet
If no appeals are timely
tiled ---within. Oen. (10) days of the date of.
the Advisory Agencyto approval --with the Clerk of the Board Of
Supervisors, this action will be final.
-- val are c Iplied with) it will: be in order
u Department
ldhen the conditions oit apF tl with. the Butte Co1.InLy p
for you to file your find_ map lour (24) months of
of. Public. Works for recordation within ty-
the date of approval by the Advisory - ge
ncy
. questions regarding this matter, please contact this
If you have an}� q
offieei
very truly yours,
Will._j oef f
Direc°_,,.r of Public Works
J tlendDon s -a
A i.stant Director
dM%ds
attachment
c; Planning Dopar meat
cnv ronmenttal �lenith Dtpnntment
ODA
,
SiJ McQueen -Smith; Tentative Parcel Map, AP 61-48-27,4 parcels on
both sides of Bell. Ranch Road approx. 2800 ft west of its
intersection with Oro --Quincy Hwy., north and east of Oroville.
.Cngineer; GAA
Public Works coed .tionsi
1 Provide two, -way traversable access RS -8 -LD -1 to each parcel from
a county maintained road or state highway.
2 Access to be ;reserved in dr:eds as per county ordinance and offered
for dedication ct L -ho final map.
3 Show 50 ft. builaing setback line measured from centerline of accent
easement.
4 Provide road maintenance ogreement.
5 Show all easements of record on the final map.
6 Provide street name signo per requirements of the Department of
Public Works Prior to recordation of the final maps.
7 Provide cul-de-sac at the end of the streets.
3 Obtain encroachment permit and construct standard road approach
providing adequ�ite sight di.stan�te at the i,nterserti.on of Oro Quincy
Hwy. and Boli: Ranch Road
9 Pay any del,nquen{. taxes or current taxes as required
10 Verify legal. acct 4:-;.
11 Plate stop sign at :Lotorsection of Oro Quincy Hwy. and Bell Ranch Road
Health Dept, conditions:
12 Provide a 100 ft, leachfield free setback around existing wells cither
within the property or within 100 ft. of the property boundaries on °
parcel 1.
13 Shaw a 100 ft. leachfield set~bk from the hi.ghwater line of the
creek on parcels 1, 2 3 and 4,
14 indicate on the map that ateas with slopes in excess of thirty
ercent are unsuitable for sews e disposal,
The following mitigation measuto8i are required
15 deet the requirements of. the California Dept. of Vish and Game
regarding streambed alterations for bridges and/or other strv,j.,t
crossings,
''Erin
a
MCQMEN SMITHY TEM
16 All disturbed areas to be reseeded, except road su,rtaceei,
1.7 All road construction of be completed, including; tlrainago aLructur,es,
surfacing, ditching, etc., before rainy season erosion.
18 Place ;a noise on the map that, "with the exception of crossings
for private driveways, there is to be no construction act,ivit.es
or removal of riparian vegetation within a strip of land
measured 50 ;feet from the high water line of Sycamore creek" and
also: "Meet the requirements of the California Dept. of Fish and
Cnme regarding streambed alterations for bridges and/or other,
stream crossings."
1 Plnc,e a note on the map that, "If either of the two ident i, ted
archaeological. sites are found to be within the limits of th18
project, offer a preservation easement to the Society for
Callfornia Archaology.
To!
FROM,
SUBJECT'
DATE!
'a
Inter-Deparb
%0*4kil [, Memorandum
Butte County Advisory Agency
Planning Director
ONREPORT ON 48-TBNT27ATIVE PARCEL MAP FOR SID McQUEEN SMITH
PART
September 22, 1987
This is a proposal to divide 32-+- acres to creatri 4 parcels from
40 to 160 acres. The present. zoning is 11u,, (Uncl,,Issifed).
I The
Land Use Plan Map of the Butte County General Plall designates
this area as Timber Mountain and Agricultural-Rek3idential. There
are no specific Or community plans for the area.
The Proposal does not conflict with County Zoning nor any
adopted Or proposed element of the Butte County General Plan nor
any County, specific or community plan.
The project site is not within a Development Area as shown on
the Deer Herd maps Provided by the Department Of Fish and Game,
That Department has stated that 40 acre minimum um lots are
necessary in order to avoid significant adverse effects to beer
Herds in the area.
Since the Project has been -redesigned to Yield parcels of at
Least 40 acres, the project is no longer subject to Deer Herd
mitigation feest a Negative Declaration regarding Environmental
Impact is appropriate and approval or the project is recommended
subject to the following -,16itions:
1. Moot the requirements Of the California Department of .Fish
and Game regarding streambed alterations for bridges and/or
other stream cros,,,,'nqs.
2. All disturbed areas to be reseeded, except road surfaces.
3. All road construction to be CIOMPleted,, in drainage
structures; surfacing, ditchirig, etc:, before the rainy
season.
Contractor to Provide for adequai-e moisture content in all
soils Placed in road coj10
lstruct� h so as to aid in proper
compaction and dust control,
5i Place a note on the map that; "With the eXCOPtibri of cros8'1-1gS
for private driveways, there is to be no Construction activities
' Or removal Of riparian vegetation Within a strip of land
measured 50 feet from the high water line Of Sycamore Czeek.11i''
If either Of the two identified archaeological sites are found
to be within the liI
mits of this Project" offer a preservation
easement to the Society for California Archaeology.
j -Mc
cc: Sid M60110bhkiSmith
GbA
AP PI -All 1* ( 11
COUNlY (lir BUTTE
]iNVIItON�iTiN'I'AT. rIIT'C:KT.1.S7' 1�C)Rt`f
f tri ��iie i�r>nrr,l rtc�`1i^y' j'e.�.�v'gl;r=nrY�
Lug 11 8'7-02--25-01
I. BACKCI01TN1r Al,
11 61-48-27
'I . Narne of' Irroponont SID McQiJEEN-SMITH _
Z. Address of Irroprrttent and rrlrresr�ntat ve [IE rllsplica1111e}�� � � ���
'
,Sid =McQu __ecn ,Sfn_�.th. _
1320 Mt. Ida Road
22
Orov lYe, CA 95966 - Granc1...,Auenu��..�
0rovi1le C 5..65
'i , Project tl�-Sc r i lat i rf;r Tentative Parcel KaP..n "
ITA'I T; t.
MANI)A'I'011Y PINIIlNG14 (rl IGN-111CANC-11 Yfi a r11\'Itl; NO
.� . _.
a. Ir(le h'Irx rtri(c't Iruvc Hit' Pot(Intia1 o dogratle the.
cluErl i'1c r1i t11v (wnt I ronpla=nl , subs t;i Itj IIIN� rL-tio "e
tllC-laallit:at oi.1 f ,i h (1r wildl i lk" :;peci(=s, e itI. e I
Ch -01 (,I (I i I(M 1 c in,puI'ltitill t(1 drop below Sell%
+aahttiitlltlj� I(=r.el= ;, threaten to vIlminate a Irlilnt or
;inimal k-olltmunity, rodut --e the nl.lnll yr Or restrict the.
a'artr}kt (1t :r ratr`t .1r OM(Iangc'rt'(1 plant or .animal or
(�l intin,lt(� ianiw��rtrlrrt exitlnlrl.t:, (1T" t11c1 T>erituk
o l ("d i f`(a1-111a of prehistory?
1). lit) c+s t)w It0liOc't h.akv the poterynti:al to u(:1lieve
'hort,tvi n hellol'it•. to tho d(�trimcnt of Inn,g-term,
rrrtVi rOW -ntal tvo fl s? to short term imlrar:t on the
environwe=nt k one which oceL11•8 if) a relatitse'jy
brief" period of time while lclrtl�-t(+rm Tm)raets wTTI
vn(Iure I lit tt r'rrturc=.1
111(1y itir� �1r°(zip t halo inlha�ts tthich ore indivi(lu-
a'I'lyIinrit(�1, Ir1rt �unl.,latitiely cOnSirlrrrable? (A
(1ru,'t(s(t nRcly finvaact on two ur im(lrO sep trEite rvsotlrces
lwher�c'� th+ irirl�ir�,t Ezra r=aach resouret= is reIntivole=
switl, hilt Idwry thu vI'1'e(:t rrt the total Of thosO
impacts oli LIMIJr011111ont is s 11,11iI'i(:ant.) jC
(I, Poo. thv r1,,p=et har(� (11virnllmentt'll el'1'ec'ts which
Id" v all -s- -111),;taaltt t..tl at(1vorse ('fl`ect;, on ltrlilintt
h(+inp;5, "ith"I 11ii-oath! Oi• indii:reetty?
UG i'I'f711T N;1't fol% ('Jo 1)(� tvNta 1 V t -NI hyr t'11c1 Lead rlgzncy )
tan the I ra;; is ZA r1(i�l im.l ti,a�l ovalualticll.
1Al I i r.d 1 hr 1,11,01''W'vil 11r"JeCt Ct'IIILIl NOT lrnve ar s i gn i l'i ennt e l'I`cet
tilt t hl. ( ;
�2-
IV.. ENVIRONMENTAL ACTS
exp anata;ons o a "yes" and "maybe" answers are required
on attached sheet(s))
1. EARTH. Will the YES
' '' proposal result in significant:
MAYBE No
a. Unstable earth conditions or in changes in
geologic substructures?
b. Disruptions,
k
displacements, compaction or .
overcoverin of the soil.
c. Change
in topography or ground surface -�-
-
relief features?
rl: Destruction, covering or moriifitst:Qn of any
-`—
.unique geologic or physical features?
e. Increase in wind
X
or water erosion -of soils,
either on or off-site?
f. Changes in deposition or,erosion of..beach
sands, or changes in saltation, deposition
or erosion which may modify the channel of
a river` or stream orthe bed of the ocean or
any bay, xnlat or lake`?
_
g. Loss of prime agriculturally productive soils
outside designated urban
x
areas?
h. Exposure of people or property to geologic
hazards
such as earthquakes, landslides, mud-
slides, ground failure or similar hazards?
Z. AIR. Will the proposal result i7 'ubstantial.
F7 Air emissions or deterioratio,
f ambient
air quality?
b. The creation of objectionable ouors, smoke __
.
c
or fumes?
c. Alteration of air movement, moisture, or
JCc
temperature, G-• any change in climate,
locally or regionally?�
3.WATER.` will the proposal result ill substantial;:
a. Changes in
currents, or the course or
direction of water movements in either
marine or fresh waters?
b. Changes in absorption rates, drainage patterns,
or the rate and amount of surface runoff?
c= Need for Off-site surface drainage .improve
mnnts, including vegetation removal:, channel
ization or culvert installation?
d. Alterations to the course of flow of flood'
wate 'rs
e. Change in the amount of surface water in ,any
water body?
Discharge into surface waters or in any,
alteration of surface•water qua,laty, including
but not limited to
temperattire,•dissolved
0xygon or turbidity?
Alteration
g. of the direction or rate of flow
of ground n the quantityor qualit of
change a.xwaters?h.
waters
L �
,ground
eeither�throughddirectaadditionsor tva:tlx,
-
drawals, or through interception, of an
Aquifer by cuts or exc.avatiotls?
i. Reduction in the
�c
amount of water otherwise
available for public water supplies?
j. Exposure of people or property to water,
related hazards such as flooding?
�2-
YES MAY) No
4. PLANT LIFE, Will the proposal result in substantial: MA
a. ange in the diversity if species, or number
of any species of plants (including trees,
-shrubs, grass, crops, and aquati-c plants)?
b. Reduction of the numbers of anylinique, rare
or endangered species of plants,A5__
C. Introduction of new species of plants into an
area, Or in a barrier to the normal replenish-
ment of existing species? X
d. Reduction in acreage of any agricultural crop?
S. ANIMAL LIFE. Will the proposal result in substantial, -
a. Chafige in the diversity of species) or numbers
of any species of animals (birds, land animals
including reptiles, fish and shell fish,
benthic organisms or insects)"'
b4 Reduction in.the numbors of any unique, rare
or endangered species of animals?
C. Introduction of new species of animals into
an area, or result in a barrier to the migration
01, movemen,4 of animals?
d. Deterioration to existing -fish or wildlife
habitat?
6. NOISE. Will the Proposal result in substantial:
a. Increases in existing noise levels?
b. Exposure of people to so-vere noise levels?
7. LIGHT, AND GLARE. Will the proposal produce
si-
911'.cant light and glare?
8i LAND USE. Will the PTOPOSAI result in a
SuE-stantial "Iteration of the present
land use of ail area? Or planned
5. NATURAL RESOURCES: Will the Proposal result i-,,
�Ws_t_a_n_ti�5j _:
A. Increases in the rate Of use of any naturii
resource
b, Depletion of any non-renewable natural
resources?
10' RISK OFUPSET.Will the Proposal involve,*
Rsk
a: T'of explosion or the release of hazard-
ous substances (including) but not limited to.,
oil, pesticides, chemicals or radiation) in the
event of an accident or upset conditions?
X C_
WOO " "LerrOrOnCO with an emergency
response plan or emergency evacuation plan?
II. POPULATION, Will the
proposal alter the location,
a'i5_tr_11.Fton, density, or growth rate of the human
man
12, HOUSING, Will the proposal affect existing housing,
or create a demand for additional housing?
b.
Communications systems?
c.
Nater availability:
13.
TRANSPORTATTON/CIRCULATION. Will the
YESrIAYilla N0
_,_ �„,,
e.
resuit in: M`-' proposal
f.
a. Generation of substantial additional vehicle
movement?
- -
b• Effects on existing parking facilities„ or
demand for
new parking?
C. Substantial impact on existing transportation
X
_ _
systems?
d• Significant alterations to present patterns'
Of circulation
or movement
goods? of people and/or
e. Alterations to waterborne, rail or air traffic?
_ G'
f. Increase in traffic hazards to motor hicl.r�5,
ve
bicyclists or pedestrians?
_ X
14.
PUBLIC SERVICES. Will the proposal have an exfcct
upon, or result xn a need for
new or altered
governmental services;
a. Fire protection?
b. Police protection?
C. Schools?
X
d. narks or other recreational facilities?
.X
e. Maintenance of public facilities, including
.roads"'
f. Other governmental. services?
--
15.
ENERGY, Will the proposal; result in
a. OTe of substantial
amounts of tuel.or energy?
b. Substantial increase in demand upon existing
sources
of energy, or require the development
Of nein sources of
energy?
X
16. `'UTILIJ'IfiS.
Will the Proposal result in a need. for .°
new systems, or substantial, alterations
foll.btving: to the
a. Power or natural ' 'as 7
b.
Communications systems?
c.
Nater availability:
d.
Server or septic tank?
e.
Storm water drainage?
f.
Solid waste and disposal?
- -
17. IMAN HEALTH. Will the proposal, result in
a, Creation of any health hazard or potential
health hazard (excluding mental, health)?
b. Exposure of people to potential health
hazards
18, AESTHE`Z`ICS4 iV ll the proposal, result in the
obs trti pn of any scenic Vista or mew leen to
the public, or will the proposal result Lin the
creation of an aesthetically offensive site open
to public view?
4
YES
MAYBE NO
19. RECREATION. Will the proposal result Lu an impact
upon the quality or quantity of existing recreat'.)tial
opportunities?
,
20. CULTURAL RESOURCES,
a_, Will t e proposal result in the alteration
of or the destruction of - prehistoric or
historic archaeological ite?
b. Will the proposal result in adverse physical
or aesthetic effects to a prehistoric or
historic building, structure or object?
C, Does the proposal have the potential to cause
a physical change which would affect unique
ethnic cultural values?
d. Will the proposal restrict existing religi,,us
or sacred uses within the potential impact r
area?
V, DISCUSSION OF ENViRC,NMENTAL EVALUATION AP 61-48-27
See attached.
_E -Y ION AP 61-48-27
_SSION-_p EN -
C'
11tifflMD-r-Y
TI-Ils project involves development of eight parcels On 820 acres reelalonong
the Lake UrovillO shoreline In a remote, currently undevOiQpGd
OF the lake and coor-ityi The project will requir',e construction and/or
improvement of access roads, improvement of Bell Ranch Road off Of
Oro-GuIncy Highways orossil-Ig of sycamore Creek (tributary of Lake
or,40vi1le), and development of circulation roads within the property.
Soil conditions and groundwater JITTIltations create severe development
constraints On the site, as well as steeper lakeshore and ravine
terrain,
The Butte County General Plan designates this area for
Agricultural -Residential and Timber ountaln typcle assificatiuses- Lakeon (OrovLakeille
shoreline lands are within the Public land use
Oroville Stc"te RecreaWon Area). The surrounding lands are open,
undeveloped Foothill vloodland with scattered residerItl8l development.
Access to the property is restricted at present.
, l.nificantly alter the existing character of land
The project will this area. Due to the remote, outlying nature Of the
use pattern of undeveloped terrain, several
region and the relatively opens ore involved. If further divisions tt.
potentially significant impacallts attained, Impacts Hill be considerable
smaller parcels are even tuy
and cumulatively significant.
Impacts loclude'.
lb,c,e,f; DIsrUptIOM of soils removal of vegetations and site
11 increase irase runoff OM site off site' potentially
alterations wl opment and h
increasing erosion and sedlmeMtationi Road devel
preparation Will require considerable grading. The topographicomesite
Ddifled. The disruptions
character may, In certain areas, could be
displacerrioPts compaction and overt, ver in@ of the soil
significant, particularly if and when subsequent red1vislons to
smollej- parcels sizes are attempted bifuture owners:
Boll deposition and siltation could t -cur in '8/camore Creek) and
I],f allowed, thsi� would be a serious adverse
thonce Lake Oroville,quality and affect aquatic life of the
Impact which would reduce water qua
lake. See the attached comments from the Department of arks erosion
and
Recrootlohi Measures Most bo develoPOd to reduce or prePvent
and eedImentatIOM ImPattgj Erosion potential and lamozllde potential
In this area are rated high On slopes Of 30% or greater.
e County is within 8 Muderate Earlthquake Intensity
1hZone Vill, of Bu
Thtetsubject property is located approxillatOlY One IT'lle
east of an Inferred fault lying under Lake Oroville that Is 975 associated
lthe 1
With the Cleveland Hills fault system Wh1t,h supported
to Uniform Building
orovillo,aarthquoke. Construction of buildings
Code standards for sel8m1colly cl
, active areas should provide odouatb
of seismic actIvii,-y-
protection to occupants In case
2a,ki: The area is predominantly undeveloped, an isolated locale where
very little, If any, traffic movement occurs. Because the access
roads and interior subdivision roads are required to have a chip seal,
dust generation will Lie lessened. However, as the roads age, dust
generation irflIl increase unless the roads are maintalreed to suitable
standards. Smoke will also be created from residential burning and
woodstoves.
3b,c,f: An increase in the rate and amount of surface water runoff
and erosion from the site will result due to the introduction of
impervious materials 00 site and from the development of now roads and
graded areas. Runoff will be channelized and concentrated as a result
of road development. The access road will cross Sycamore Crook;
alteration of the streambanks In that location will. increases the
effetts of these impacts. Also, waste and debris from the development
could be washed into the lake Haters.
on-site and off-site drainage improvements will be necessary to ensure
that severe adverse Impacts to wager quality are not allowed. Silt
basins; energy flow dissipatorsp channelization and culvert
installation may be required. Enforceable mitigations heed to be
developed to protect the lands on site and Off Site and receiving
waters from erosion and sedimentation.
Sg,h: Croundwater resources are limited 10 most foothill areas In
this vicinity and are unknown at this site. Sites near the 'lake may
have an adequate supply, although depth and quantity are still
uncertain. Fire protection requirements could Increase the demand for
water. Community wells should be developed If smaller parcels are
eventually developed.
Groundwater and surface water quality of Lake Oroville potentially
could be reducc-J from sewage disposal on the site.
4a: Removal of vegetation is Most significant as It relates to 1,,,)e
Increased erosion potential. Vegetation removal will result near
homesites and along access road routes.
4b, This area Is considered sensih',,Ive for rare and endangered plant
populations. 1"rlbilltrla eastwoodlae It potentially found In the
area; but, Is not considered rare or endanoered in Butte Countyi The
vegetation on site Is of the Chaparral and Oak -Scrub communitlds�
Factors used to predict the occurrence of the plant were: knowh
locations, upper elevation llmjts, and associated plant communities.
occurrence of the plant on site Is considered unlikely but possible,
Bat Development of hoitesltez May result In the relocation of resident
wildlife species onto Surrounding open lands. Wildlife could be lost
from the area permanently Should the8e adjacent lands be at thelt-,
maximum wildlIfe-carrying capacity. Species tolerant of man's
prbsQhte will usually return to an area Subsequent to construction.
The more seas iblve animal spec los will relocate frofti the area
pormanentlyi
of the Subject property Is
15b: The area to the north, south and, west
habitat for the Southern eald C-7a9le and the
identified winter, both of which are rare and end,�n.qered- The Bald
Peregrine Falcon to the higher
'in the Lake oroville area bef—e rzturnino
Eagle winters eat. Nesting pairs are all-,O to be resident at
elevations to ne ptor nestiog was observed oil si,e a pre.,IOUs
during
the lake. No ra es usually occur In canyon areas with
survey. Roptor nest sit t sites may occur within the
difficult access and therefore Met
property0s boundaries. I be introduced into this remote at-'e8-
5c: Domestic animals wil
5d; This proposal$ and espeolallY any subseqUent further land
div*slons, will contribute to the increased deterioration of wildlife
I it important miGratory wintedeer
habitat In the area. The area Uth and west Is also primer
habitat
range. The area to the northy $0
for the Bald Eagle (refer to item 5b).
oped open land acoustic character of the area
6a. The general Undevel al residential acoust I c charaC-er -
will be altered to a Ur will become established (traffic) tools'
Residential type noisres
children, etc-)-
7 There are presently no light sources 1n the I mmed I al;e area
tly undeveloped Open wzztershed lands
8: The surrounding Uses are mot The
and timber-mountainous terrain, with nearby recreational lands- in
Wray establishment of residential use 6nd further and division activity
the area ay drastically reduce these use poland
and on these
Additional land div
,Ons on adjor��ent nr� jPi--rtie`
be stimulated. Housing .rv--ket opportunities
created Parcels would in the area.
would increase generally occur in an area where there it, presently
j3a,o,d,f: Traffic will ccess roads are substaild3l-d$ riarrcw,
very little traffic use. Area a- urrent Use- Some bx1r7ting and
circuitous dirt roads with little c lder�-I-Oe eradIPO
proposed roads travel over steeper grades where cons -roslor
I
and improvement of roadways will be requireds Increasing
suscoptlbllltY. Development of traversable access roads Will be
Road and th
Ranch e ad from Fo-emmn creL�,k Road are
requirodi Bell illo-QuincY Hlgh-waY) thence to
the only existing roads out to Orovromountain road,-di that are
Orovillew These are narrow, circuitous restricted by
privately maintained- Access to the site is, therefore,
road conditions. -represent an increase 10 demand for public
14: This PrOJOct Will
services In 6 rural area.
and telephone lines will need to be extended Into
16a,b.' Electr�41c8l (to S I on w I Cause growth I Mducemerit to the
the 'Subject area: ThIt eXt
area and to the lands they crossm
A
16c: The source of domestic water Is Potentially limited.
16d, 17a: So 1 1 c,,nd I t 1 ons and steep sl op I ng terra I n I I m I t the arta
which is suitable for leach field placement. Specific soil -tests "lay
be required to determine the su I tab I I I ty of the area for sewage
disposal purposes. Sewage disposal requirements are the ultimata
11MItino factor In any actual land division.
16e: Stormwa ter drainage f ac I I I t I es N i I I be required; part I ou I ar I y
for the protection of Lake Orovi(le.
16f: So I I d was4;e d I sPosa I may be a I I m I tat I on and a PrOb I GM because
of the remoteness of the site. So I I d Haste that W I 'I be prodijaed may
be d I sposed o f I mproper I y and Lead to 1 1 Iter and I 1 1 ega I (JUMPs.
la: See Item 16f.
19: The proposal will affect the adjacent Lake Oroville State
Recreation Area. Increased access capability to shoreline lands that
currently are remote and increased demands for recreational facilities
May result from residential use adjacent to State recreational
at this locality. lands
An analysis of the demands and impacts upon these
adjacent public recreation properties that w 1 1 1 result from the
project Implementation is necessary.
20a: The subject property is I ocated in an area of high
archaeological sensitivity. An archaeological survey of the property
was performed for consideration Of an earlier project (now expired).
That survey indicated the presence of several archaeological sites in
the Immediate area, some of which occur an the subject property.
MI-b-Igatiol't mea8ul-es regarding the archaeological sites were
recommended In that Previous. survey (see cony attached). It is
recommended that a qualified archaeologist be contacted to determine
If the suggested m I V` I gat I on measures are still adequate, and * if not,
to develop appropriate mitigation measures.
�Trlc�c �
a: Rai -O and endang,%ted plants and animals, wildlife habitat, and
Important archaeological resources may be Impacted by the project
approval and IMPlementation,
b; Growth- i,nduclng development In Outlying, remote lotatlons is
discour -aged In the 8UttO County General Plan.
c The potential cumulative effects of sI9mIflc8MC0 are the ones
which are Indicated by "Yesu, or "I'laybe" responses or, the Initial Stu
Chetklisti dy
d: The erosion and zedimentatic-1 bf'irec-t8 of project development On
Crov111e resorvo 11, surface waters must be analyzed,
. 9'
-S nnested M i t i
1,. Applicant to apply for and diligently pursue FR -40 zoning on the
subject property. (The FR -40 zoning is necessary in Order to
ensure that the dwelling Unit density is maintained and that
further divisions do not take place near dral
wildlife areas and watershed.)
nageways,
:2. 11eet the requirements of the California Department of Fish F,nd
Game regarding streambed alterations for bridges and/or otter
stream crossings.
3. Show a 100 -foot building setback area adjacent to all property
lines in common with the State Recreation Area (minimizes
d
residenttheial limpacts on recreational areas and on Wildlife areas
arounake).
4. Provide a 10,000 -gallon water storage facilit,,, on or near the site
for fire Protection to Butte County Fire Department standards.
5. Applicant to construct fencing to the California Department of
Fish and Game recommendations on the boundaries of the State
property along the lake. The fence is to consist of five or six
strands of barbed wire with the bottom strand to be at least 1611
from the ground and the top strand a maximum of 4B"'above the
ground.
6. Form a homeowners' association that will do the following:
a. Monitor and enforce road maintenance agreements recorded by
the owners and binding upon all lot owners.
b. Install and maintain any necessary drainags, improvements,
Including siltation traps or sedimentation basins as required
by the California Department of Water, Resources and/or the
Califot-nla Department of Parks and Recreation. Covenants will
also Include statements that vegetation remo,al on drainage
slopes 18 to be Elvoldod,,
ci Review sites and development in order to implement the
recommendations for Protection of critical habitat or
identified presence of rare or endangered plants and species.
OWO Fullmer Subdivision (Fdot1jill 1), Log Noi, 79 -11 -OP -03
Potter Ravine Shores Tentative Subdivision Flaps Log No. 85-04-18-02
Applicant: Sid 1111cQueen-Smith Assessor's Parcel
61-48-27
Log 4 87_o2_2";_01
DATA_ -5LIEE1
A. erg -sect Description
I. Typo of Project: Tentative Subdivision by Parcel Map.
2. Brief Description; Dividing approximately 320 acres Into
eight pprcels ranging from 30 to 50 acres each.
3. Location: On both sides Of Bell Ranch Road, approximately
2800 feet west of Its Intersection with Oro-QuincY Highways
north and east of Oroville.
4. Proposed Density of Development: Averages 40 acres per
dwelling unit.
S. Amount of IMperv,ious Surfacing: Minimal.
6. Access and Nearest Public Road(S)4 Via Bell Ranch Road from
Oro-QuincY Highway and also from Foreman Creek Road.
7. Method Of Sewage Disposal; Individual septic systems.
a. Source of Water supply: Individual wells.
9. Proximity Of Power Lines: Approximately 1/2 Milt east.
10. Potential for further land divisions and development.* The
existing General Plan designation allows a range of parcels
from I to 40 acres, depending on conditions. The existinc
J
zoning on the site requires rezoning for any parcels created
less than 20 acres.
Bo 8nvironmehtal Se—tt-JILD-9
Physical Env J _r6nment:
I. Terra 1 n
8. 8eneral Topographic Character: 8rushys rugged
foothill -Mountainous terrain above Lake Orovillo.
116mesites Occupy ridges and canyons above Sycamore Creek
and Canyon Creek.
b. Slopes: 5-409, becoming steeper- niaar drainage coursos.
C. Elevation: From 950 A-0 1800 feet. above Sea Level.
d. Limiting r8cbors: Many areas of steep slopes.
2. Soils
a. Types and s Characteritldsk Rough, broken and stony
meta -volcanic area. Gouldlng-Auburn Soil Assoclatlbn,
dominated by shallow to very shallow eroded solls.
b. Limiting Factors: Relatively shallow (1-3 feet) soils on
Moderately to steeply sloping terrain.
S. Natural Hazards of the Land
an 'Earthoubike Zone,* I'lodorate Earthquake Intensity Zone V111.
b. Erosion Potential." High,
C. Landslide Potential High.
di Fire H8zard:i Czxtremei
e. Expansive Soil Potential: Low.
4. Hydrology
a. Surface Water: Sycamore Creek traverse,,; the site.,
be Groundwater: Unkho"n3 potentially limited.
C. Drainage Characteristics., Site drains to Sycamore Creek
which 18 located on site, thence West to Lake Orovillo.
d. Annual Rainfall (normal): Approximately 46".
e. Limiting )=actors: High erosion Potential and Potential
for degradation of water quality In Lake OrovIlle.
Potehtally limited water supply.
5. Visual /Scenic Quality: Very high; area of
activity. Fn I 40d human
6. Acoustic Quality: High.
7. Air Quality: Good.
mol oolcal Environment'
8. Vegetation:. Chaparral and Oak -Scrub communities.
and Ceanothus are dominant.
Manzanita
9. Wildlife Habitat: Upper Sonoran Life Zone. Within range of
Bald Eacle, Peregrine Falcon and migratory deer winter range.
Cultural -EEnavron
1—ment t
10. Archaeological and Historical Resources in the area: High
sensitivity area.
11. Butte County General Plan designation". Timber, Mountain and
Aoricuitural-Residential.
12. Existing Zoning: U.
13. Existing Land Use on-sitot Open foothill -mountainous terrain
near Lake Oroville. Area of limited human activity.
14. Surrounding Area:
a. Land Uses: Open land and Lake Oroville to the south and
West; b�-)ert mountainous terrain to the nor-th with
scattered
homesibes to the north and east.
b. Zoning: The area 18 Mostly U, with Scenic Highway zoming
along Oro -leu itIcY Highway.
C. Geti. Plan des ignat ions t Timber Ivin.t)nt,�jn and
Agr-lcultural=Resldentlal.
d. Parcel sizell: 2-6 to 640 acres. Larger Parcels beyond
OrO-QUIMCY Highway coir idot-4
e- Population: Very low Population density In the area..
16. Character of Site and Area: Open m0writalnous terrain with
- Widely scattered homes.
16. Nearest Urban Area: Or-Oville, app -10ximate) y 17 miles.
17 - 110leVarit Spheres of Influence-* Boundary Of Lake Oi-oville
State Recreation Area is adjacent to the west:
18. Improvements Standards Urban Area". No.
19- Fire Protection Service-,
a. Nearest County (St0t0) Fire Statibi-it Soasontj Station 462
at Harts Mili, approximately 2-1/2 r,111cis north; Volunteer
Station #61 at RotkeY-f'bjler Road, approxitnatoly 10 miles;
Y0ar`k-r0Qhd Station #64 et Kelly Ridge$ approximately 18
Int les.
-12-
b- Water Availability= Fire tankers only.
20. Schools in Area: Pioneer Union Elementary -School District and.
Uroville.Union High School District
STATE OF CALIKORNIA--THE RESOURCES AGENCY
f .(31101i(E DEUKMEJIAN, Gft lwr
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
P,O. BOX 2390
SACRAMENTO 95811 1 '
(916) 445-906 i
March 1.1, 1987
Mr. John bendonsa, Assistant Director
County of Butte
Department of Public Works,
7 County Center Drive
Oroville, CA 95965
Dear 1!r, Mendonsai
Tentative Parcel Map
.. Site 1►icOueen Smith
The Department of Parks and Recreation has reviewed 'the subject document,
The proposed project may affect our property, Take Oroville State
Recreation Area, by increasing the leve] of siltation in the lake.
The lands proposed for development l.ie north of the Foreman Creek unit of
the State Recreation area, approximately one mile in t;he Syoamoro Creek
drainage, New road construction and feature residential drvolopment on the
eight Proposed parcels will contribute, some degree of siltation to L akL.
Oroville by virtue of increased, concentrated rtuaoff.
Thank you for the opportunity to review this ,
apprised of the progress of theproject,
Out,'
keep us
s her, .lames Ni.
Doyle, Supervisor, Eovironmentnl Review Section, telephone (910) 324-64211
address above.
Sincerely,
v
Richard G. Rayburn, Che,
Resource Protection Divi -!on
r
»N r L.r 171
ti4v •A='
�tl1RRtltAtitAt,?'z..
Ott 7Hp
640'OA M 11ICO AN t�Aln, ?L
NPAR ORMILI$, 81fm COtm, mtmRNIA �
'ART I ttimao� Celv►nfs
- by
Peter M, Jansan,
111TROLIMali
In older to evaluate the nrlhacologicaT titu.l+� a proposed sub-,
dit-ision involving 640 acres of brush» and tr utoverod 1 ,. laced S neat
CroYilla, [3utte County California; the:o of tba prof,'.r cortr,,°„
;or an archaeological reconnaissance and records sanrch of tna Ont rr
Eyj (y rvdy Was conducted ttly 4 gild July 20, 1950
ra act arcel� 7'ha su �LY� � p
the author assisted b archaeologists Jolut 2;uacandlla slid Will Stra iru,
California state tlaiversi Chico.
1116 Proposed project trill itivolva stiWiVisian of the p1rcal into 20
and 40 sora par cis Which will later be sold arncl prosurn761y ddvelopdd into.
ranrhr., h4I or h���»sites, 1st I ,.ht t1t' Y�h�, Irot�ntirll,�olti�erlo dd into
of the project to llistotic ariDor j1r 11stu t =sites rhl4h �M'gi� coMir: I t
Within the h,)ondririd 01 the, prop.srty;: the I:hltironmentai Ravidw i►eptirt-
malt of hunt Catultl� rdcn�grended trap COU017,11 resutirees be drrdd
he shy fat» o- [IMehtill Ils�act Report prgwed for th6 firrbdJ%-1 t.6n, ,ab;!
hdnca the no- for the ke;;ent,archAeOlogical rcconnJts;tnce,
7:14•. i4vn'ia,
X quifto'y 4tijhrtrr r
11ze pti)ec,t nrett Js located not tt�oa+t r,� t}ruvkllr Al. .,
,,» skiiatelY tract a the t>r+�vtlle+++ ► aF
at�,n or LAC Cltoyll.tx, within the ln,+ak toolill) r htoiifort'1Nova& , ;�rx
rn AaYacia
ovvr ,wfn�i IargttlaIn� t,ltbltt they po of rnuAt' 1►�u,, l,pClr' It« wliphtl'y
u� �r 1511U nbate me,I,t sof lo0i .\s notal, tiro pit+tiltr,rgi,,ts o
1 f fill
Of �.et:tlon 7, Ttntlsltlp ,".0 A`, flatnl;t.: 1?, ntt► h+rnrG t't�tuls� Gail ►r.r'rs of
ntiJ.
Vegetation keltiti�z the , art el f; rharaetgristi�.rtily� Ir,z,.<r ;o-totssn
irtd hl"At les opctr St,n,as of ons which gil •e tray its drnsc �t3tn , of man
tKrstta and other I(ru!,h i~ -t &)', %est-racitg " s1tt;+0% and to r►ltrnr riparl
an
C(Nrr:.rnitics In the shaJr.l of spring eed tai it, °. 4,1111 intarmitGe
stream, Ce►ma tihnlahi r11�, the n
parcel k ,t, •,tt,J iso i i„Y r txtutemittent
rldi,e• With tinduJatlrig, stt;p to ve"my-slop►>„ 1t11st�at
IU�tYlltlLi ,�llil:Cll
l.tlurcefr,►pltteally the Ific}•;..tn fall • nzar th^ .ntcr o4 territory
o cupictl by 1hr hard rr tarty .; ►� ,, or ► ,n,.•,� fndlanL,. nith� a
u h the ethno-
graphic, ►ttfartnztityn arni 7h'e d'�»s n_t iJ. ttifl ,artitt,l .; Jrs�lcs or
situ of sigrt(ficrtn C rcitl►r,, thri '� a`cyt arc3t or 1 rr.�JlM.
xrane;�, tL. ethr►ogrIlPhil it►fC,rs�atIca in cC•`!atnjvion with Oto �ra alts. ob-
taineJ fruin f,rct4brt as.:,:ralaf;irat wtrr�r}r trtthitt thr r i; :strestcd
that 1,01etal prehisttMrl, site t}, exit withtrti
Cludtng the follotting: (lj rborig ntlt�-eeet3yicd roe' 1n�
w` lt;rc� '
ibin,tl midiit:ns ran$int: C1,:-20abor-
�� �to o.R�r (2J
1Qtr cehtireterq i� tied th, Nj f1► or
above 5 hnusa pit dapxosti3nas, lOcateJ.on tcrracas, sa_I ��s 4,d tib cs
chart+ strctms or above the old Cour" of thr. lvrth Cork cf the Peathe?r
River; (3) aboriginal mmfaze scatters of b:+sx1G, olysidz,.a; and chert-
ilal,es rtncl arttfuc.ts, (4) a ri ail bedrock r111%ng Stations, including
especially bedrock nortr►r.;, anJ�(5) isol,it,-d ilntls of al H"It al lithic
fln}.es and artifacts, k",;t h tltcs Le been recrrr1%1 for ou"i(nr to iin
within Sitilar envim..� Intal .:t% -LII t,ithin i;p;e4r+:, to in ttira.tot, f,
V10 occurrence offrrrtfswct asi
ti.as confira,4a by 4,r^•Ins yr a, exonof
=-z , l►ssrte teeor�ls ° ►i G iced parcel
District 2 or thu so,:Ity 1,0r cali..,Irziti Utz', haeology at t: is a, Prior to
t;aittd into the field ty,;,, rrrar ►, rc ew�1n*J, moll; z tcR:al of
throe rt ardeJ aborigiotl N'tc•s. AU or the ?Iitt,q h,.11.
ick Med In
^x its
M
,�!
tl•ifr vi t ror Ie e,l ;lJ1, trt .11t 14 i + +��t. 'b t;, i i ,, t�: t e tri Fact
1 532;1, th^ Clot l a l L,er in,7,� B `. t i6 C.` n � ° 4 � ftrh't-
�t Al t�ttfrt f. yrtrl., f 1 C� •nit,dn
A, ,zttt'ti tlbtr6ct, t w < t,►t ►. r: , t
be d1�Ccr
rvk";
,, i tt itisMIAtion
tan�i�+tl►(� of ++lllaw, 1►►r►P vi►re;s, s1lRpktr rin(f l,'itf
lr ie Irt,tixINjtr►0n1 r►long zrhrlr't seCtions olr ;;yiu,nt,ru f► :.ze►r• , rm Isit,rej and othar
pdC+i+�t y tlern9� ds�taa Wit atatteerrt +1.ter t o►ttcift lk►s�if��j�
nminrd a `skemytit vel), > t tyil
} far nv tlenefi of nborfp,innl anti/or signirle." PtT
tart°!e uw or oct'lio atoll iilr:ing the'%urvey th► irrntnd trtvr•
rrmatt l in order to a l►ort� the rottnu 4urfato, and ,tl t ro,il��►tWmtd its ala l
hairs, dttchns rind na(1 outs porn oxiilined: 'ur rsslhle lrulientlo o a
(edr out Cncc rnse,urt�(�a. 1'trrt ,�icutar ntta►t Ian was F►arn to rl►ix,►�s, ,fin trnt +tlna�
and loVcl spots ndjocent to Syon,r" Crcv1 ;and the �tnalI jratn
tributaries which feed 111(0 tits stream, ml t
kl:St11,'1� ltNt1 LtK:rx.rll:n7r1`ricl�S
As anted nlicran, u total or three sites hnd IrtTrm IrrO r m Iy re"ev skit,
for the parcol, The location or 01-se site,. ne t•�rrrviltly t•( ord�;(l'ha��.
boen in,licatet! on the n„ crnppanyini, Prpjr. L •1rn Sita 1.tc►(t Ina Al
t,7rt.i1 Of this report)(h,r n(ldtttcln+l Cht•r�o iderif Ifled as iizc%
!;1) w'a'a �cncounterc(I (1111-'1.1+g the �pr�sev swV.." 11(1 ti'i71 11114) be d,tsal,xsrd
bz±lo,�,
r1�EtUI-?G7s `11tis site 11,1 recorded in 1906 b
' y 1.rtc ltittt•r o:t tyr
basis or tt►tarnuttlnn itrovrtict< b>- ,S;r•, Young. °i'he site was d S r,tbstl as a
"rause ns, �'i1t11v ►milt one dance hx►str and t Y,1 �fpwiier Imu'rt pit e
j pres,,ipns," k(ttcr :[SO armed thL� o,tiis"ten t� cf sonic t trnti(�I1} t
asrecoan t histori< m,•tterlal�, �r„lL in an jV4 2S-tent piece, the �sxtil
t:1s reco(ced as stroddritlr the �+cctTan ti,Int b► tl�ern lectIoCe 7
overt reconnaissance resulted in t!,? discovery of no nboriginrl sTts$a1r
this section line, although we di ncottnter a conte(npornry str'ueture
within the vicinity of the recotdo.. site but S�inft l»recllntt iy uctur e
oF, section 7. The area; possibly assn the loccrlo of fisc utrar3ginal site,
has been greatly disturbed by bulldnhirtl;; lavelinp, dr a troller pad site,
irrpnrtatioii of a trtailer; and iripartittion or grs►lnlsk 8rdurid the trifler
anei. In aSSoc.iatic l,r t} the grade;( ac ess roadq, iT tills 1(),:ale 'rcpta.
sent- the original location of the 3kr` s°
the site have been rem )r *cvd or coa,c•r,cti lv,ithn�'rcyvGl�i �13rC 9 rkcl tbpn all rates a�
the 1; probahly lies sam d.isCz(r e t� the el;t, citbro to r ho•,� V*r,
01-ki tl►o C►rovtttc�=�tnrt ° i ” Orin), Crrr;1
lagh►,ay, llotre%vr, this nrdn Falls within �ctian
8 and wits not OX
dY jrinq tlao cottr;c or the pre lit Ye► annaiss (r��e,
not rri�i�.lre �l' �atc r l l11 �2
°e
.1 P cnlrldlhr, totrl�! wi thin esti
i . z=c �t1�tuil, '► "' y t" rs sit
C1 r tr , 'i',w site ttvolideti in 19'Cjfr 11
1 I:I°it' i�ittt+r on alt
1�,rwls tar tivrurrt,ltirrt I teWr.dod b, Ferttri1.
i+► :dk.t rn tlrr� ,arc 1(111 w,, cr• � `"� . l The only d ri )i, t
G roko:l Tt)rre t,t,.; that tha t t.1 Trt.orr"aiion
fill'
liItage 'rf (�yi.,►r,)„r1 Ii. l E, NO r , ��is .4is a r%vt1w
the+ icuera rx � , r”►•idciA;w n!" *.u;;h a sitw:� 14t� tsir,cr'►`oal vrTthi�i�
ct arancwfar they11t;1arahPl{oje't'inirrl11*Kill this .11(s� ito 13 rccor� Ad,. yl
CA
lx1N 27t,; Hits siva was nlsd rattlktirct tri ?r „, e
�i/j d� ftA�ra JCC lay f rftt ttftiat+ t1rN
f3,by�
fact t+„served at rhn to a"�`bFrvr9%��
►nt rciilna ns+ cvicientt OCra ho�sarrpi.tfvil1u1 kn�or1'r�trticdrJn tilt, or
sr•� ierord Corm, fkrrovar
OhMilian Ilnkes mid i'e dis titoreci it Ii>ht ` strr'Criry sttattor olg1lial
r ono granite po5tle rrcgftfactsa inclu:linT; ittiti bs;alt f basalt
t"et triad guts revealed no�evidenco orb s°btsurr��r�,pfremn�thaQ �fttt i
ttbor.lfiinal mstrriols could be ponerrtr although
the A-1larizcn soil. t�lra} ressed ns r+u:h ns T.p cent,imetcrs p
PressIoit n,,i In Order to detorin}nC the r,ti'tr t to I'll, such cjAmt
y have occurred, and in light of the pottntinl ativarso i'
to the tM1ining cultural restntrces at this
mcndntion is offered ns econwlcal yot ni>�Ywuiriatt h.th.i �ful) eructs
loth, this lolirJnK rcc;
adtorse innac s to this reseurco Fhuuld t�ia ltroposrcl sut
as pllrttr?edl �� n aC� the
kiivffilon pro,!ted
so centmeters, 15 no
8) the sito should be nipped l f;raatar th t
ti wtlrlEfllrr inLet!v�
b) tto 11,12 test pits llild be excatattr; i+ithin the nee; of hi
surfaCd r,rtiract .' rr rattrti7 in order to dr , , ghost
suhasurfaca deposit e`ist .tr`ire whether n ,tii
AM
gaiCicant
C) a Sogahlila pf the 5t/rraea t^:lturial4 aT,• t
rect�tcred wl,hn 3m. collection cells i o ' alt Ito s'sk
Of the dY.z 1 ` err<tticaily
};nosalc artiCrrtits which eXistnat�t.� to ebtrtin A useful sn,r�,ie
slte,
Harrirtg the discot•ory. o%' a t1pnifarant :sub � ,
is an"Cipiited that this data reco%,c urfacrs ca,
4f tt prafessiontrl reirbrt of Fin.iinSs r;auld r+;ns 'n(prOju, it
�' Pr�'*ra�a coupled tattti iron
of any trdvcrs6 Jmp.•tcts to the site; I�hich multi result it } action
tittitc adequate mitigation
hnd ari haeolokCcei clearanCt, Could be reco, handed tr}ien C 'subdivision
the project. tion of
}IL03an Et
°c This thoriginai site t,;ts l akhci;tT,proxintttelj� 30Q
i�tcrs r"ast of 44d r,\- 3T^271, Since Ehc site rC ro
house tilt vilinge site it Cu ild Silk tC rose sants nn e�borigt j
described to Crit Cittor as slit is Teti nt th t ate t,'lt eh Dfr, 'yds
r.rnf4 at rine lar,,, rr °"`C' i f..,n ����.�^LFII elle }n rtrty^ Case
III ti ter _1411 r t "' t r l,c a; ton t-, r t�1G site con-,
Q rlCtrr`s + EIua�M t 15i 'n! ilt'1�1 �.irY,9tr+��F �J meterk
xrt dIai;etCI). l'attlwr trr �t }.•ink r,
Sub»surface w.ttcr,lnl� at , graclirrt�> u.x.,: sr7°o nT °v rti Grp .aklr„Hely
dcz.rur,rlati.olf of �p ro�iw,_�idlykstfie,rnin.i �ha # ret�tk;+le.i n r t, Or the ski n aria
was alst� rel hc,,1 .fn nt: t,• centie.•fers depthk ui tilco mld n
Clearly` dzac,hVd niar ,tnr Yrr,i"Idmt hales r+rl� 4'itktrt c,icirrrr dnri, midd<>h
' It qu7tititiYS GC e k1 c+latiriti ahi ,, ,.r 1 ,r? ixidon;
Fkyttnl andptysalhltt cs►lttirdllhi+torical vnluds b6 Old slttr tfit foJIM
niitigoi�r►t,tvr: r�tao►t;}entlrttiur►q a.rr» affpratl. t tiny
��yT' +�4��-�tiCNs`3t1 Esn
Y?re miss scats rricioitt ngthtxl to ensure rrservatinn k�►IIs! tett to lncytAfq
the Site within an easa�ent Which could t%un ba granted to t.ho Soc}at
taz VO iromia411cma Art %Pub,o� ptmont. This is the preCerrrr} alit
l.ttiv rtlternat tv^ kle far Hann ;« 1
sJnre it hatrld erlsura iroiervatian or, till +Ilydad"y rvall�
pre*sankzd resource for futuro reseat-ch"rs, use.
2) In the avant that preservation of the reavurce Crutt►rst be Assured
thMIRh strAnting of an ct►serea►tt or sorre sil�ailariy Rf[ectivct t,rrangoe►elte
a. pz fes iottal nrehagalnRis}r1 dat'r ►citrvcry prugrnO }s rrcoritnnrang
A MOM shouts) be designed to lissoss tha full sr<Jcntititirasrareh �h
pateretia_i and sulturn 7/h stogy"foal �nlles nJ the site and"
inditutot;
Nit not nevessarily"bez Itrtitexi to, tho foji0wing
a) tantout r►app $
in of the s}Lc in not lest, than 50 t:rltLlmvtar intattire2a;
1e�-Wavation of at lo,►st o;,e of the house pit doprensions;
c) e.Xcavation of at 10,1st s1x lm2 test pits w}th%n the midden arca,
d its iduntj,iied an tilt acro pstnl n artilt, : logical alto Ina
PJ
dj p'rocfr ,titin of a p:afession;►1 report of findittgs tirich includes
an expiiC'it evaluation of the research potential of the rosource and, r►ctadatibns, if deemed appropr%ato, for comple a mitigation of the. adverse.
xmp,lCts Of subdivision and deval,op; ent to the site, It is
the testing program could 3tsait ba dthit
eemed It miti�tinibjiodlthougl
this detc urination ,�buld have to be basad on th' findings of the test
excat;ttion lehase of the ;project,
5li`M Y
OF I AWPCr Ri tUl•t N -DAT IbSs
Site Q4•I.rf•27 Sitq .is appargntiy itic;ttct} dhtirely Outside or the }}ic}aran
parrcl and ►,iXi t►ut iyc1mpactt�cl by 'his t /t
.s projecrclure-
claRitat elerrance is zecpmmended.
�- Earfrktnt'*� 1ltiarritio:9.i� the tte�icJcncc oft�tl,e"tur
farite Could be
untl during rer��tnaiti:;,rncer anti hence ar
chacolttgical clearance is roct - 411;led"
SittY CA«ItllTr7.�i: lite Site t+ .� rli�Cgi`er c} to be a gt►h stM'Fnco 'scattor, of
bttSalt''"Id otsi,'!' El",rkaa and ""'facts with "the l?ossib.i,i`ity
oC a >ti'Wr kyr shallaw st�,•sttrfaeq dc• sir' bein
A ltroEcssian.Il. d tttr recovory program tonsisting or CX*
-
tavtatlo�t �C res fin" tost tats, cantbur r+?t lnar,
,.e;+ €:
�,�lynt.r�,;6�aggi thn
Sita,i13ck7r►att 1. ProsarWa ion of the reraurctr tfirougli nvn,iainnce 1. tf>m
preforrt.4 titPtivo altornativc, .5110d f1cail it has
been su" ,;astr<s that: the site be lr Clttdud withln�an
aascn.unt Uhi.ch that be grhntrd to thxl t;tc i#aty i'ar Cat,if-
otnin Ak.,l�„aaolU "
a Epr mrut agtmtrtit, fnoring this, it is
rccoaTe^.Jod that j roresstohai data �etttvary irragr+an be
the -
it +a at the Ito, to consist or rAltour mattping of
tho :_lira at*,,, cx°ava iidn of onp io:rt3ts frit dcrression,
C=a-.Ia%irn of, rh,�r 1m2 test pits, torr] pr ItrGGt,am of a
protest, Sona) rc,nart of filitnttgs r;ith p,►rtl(:tilar atttantian
Flver►
to asb,,ssment of trst+grch
p�tentlat
and tu; «ttraijhl5tr5a )Cal the scientific/rvalues of thol rom)urce.;
R
Y