Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout065-700-01540 r : I'.�"��5l �FtCjJ'EC:T �LS'MivSA�t.TT SY�EE'r _ File No. Logs Na GARVER GONSTRUCTION applisanC: zvptsantative ADARESs. P.O., Rex 6226 Chico,, CA 95927 PFioNEx 891-8BjQ Betty Lou Parker property owner 3:502 Iroquios Ave -Long Beach , , CA 90808 ADDRESS;; uSE �' RrtIT to. allow a; mobile 40me ns a Teugorary_Second DwellinP F3Y f n a .f 777-7 r r- 7 VAX zeX � 5`f locAted�"� on propert7, zoned -TM _:� % ` =ASE_ k a Y �,��a• � F ?,200 . entified as AP 065-070-015 townla-aa: lagal a E. alp -Z >44CH -1doY - sG tERtL PLA3t AESIGNATI6i( Agricultural Residoatia� f" PRE -APP FEE PAID F 2 2 , 0 (� .iECEIPT N'UMER: 11888 APPLICATION ACCEPTED; AL: PP.. PAID REZONING" PE�Z ON SIGNATURES' CMC1 0 kERC;..NTICGE: NAILING =LIST: PREPARED .HAIL-C]iJT' NOTICES WRIT:FLN' 1'IAILED` NUMBER: r f 1 G NOTICES: LEGAL; DESCRIPTION PREPARED PUMCM61C NOTICE, WRITM-1 v DISPr ky AD PFrA4,Q.E0 nVSFAPER PUBLICATION Cr C« G ti R DATE OF PUBLICATION:- IN mL, smv PREPARED t ENViRON%Mr.AL DErmaxArrou Categoricai, r�cAmptfbn_ FILM: Negative Dec.zraticn FILED Mitigated ttegaciva Dacl=.- ian EIi'rD:: -_ sivitronmental. Impact Repast CERTIFIED Other."". S'ul= CLEARINGrIOUSE 1W. -MER: c IPPLICA-WIR.E`PP =ATIVE. N` CL-IC:ITION OF E:NZRONMMMA1 DETERMZ'i�lTIO,{ +-� Ff.41NI:iG COtR1ISSI0NFTFA.R_T'iG(s) VAI aq� cT .�© BOARD OF. SUPERVISORS'' FMMUE_NG(s): RESOLUTION M411ME„ (CPAs) ADOPTEAs; MIMMUCE ZYMBER ADOPT: t;OTICE OF DEI M11MATION (Acpendiv H) ;1 a ' a, t f Carver C'oustructiotz (Item determined to be cote + ��� lorically exempt ltom environmental t Timber N a mobile home as a tend o, zoned TM- ( _ P ; ary second dwelling, on review) Use Petintt to allowta property noun in 5 acre parcels) acid in a Watershed protection Zone, located on a south side of Rambling Wa a identified as Ap 065 -0'10 -JL5, Magalia. gVIDECP151Oximately 2,200 ft. east of. S kyv'ay, The CorPmission Waived the reading of the Staff Findings. A � Y Waived g video of the site was Chairman Matson readAppendix F of the Watershed Protection Lorre, "The Curient zoning Shall be maintained within the lylagalia Reservoir, Paradise Maven Creek Watershed, other than to allow the consideration of Rdlservotr, and Fir a larger minimum parcel size."' 1•Ic said this application was againstgtj eprinci les established in the Watershed. Zone. p p 4j The hearing was opened to the public'. lichael Carver said the question. is whether this application: is said that typically with an "Aunt Minnie" :he would be applying the correct process: He after the Perm, dwelling is' built: He said in this casemb le homeois there the r dwelling Y want to build a permanent residency. and not they- want to remove the moble tome after the permanent dwelling on built. ether or the Planning Directoes rim p arycoHe said ncern is that the mobile will remain a permanent dwelling, even after the other structure is built. Sta�f $.a 'd it :could be, more appropriate for x a permanent second dwelling instead of the "AuntMinch to submit an application for -Mmnie'' , IVir. Carver said he was told by Planning that there would be house ori this; ro er rt. P P il 1'ie said he was welling to dhangepthel pplication from a another permanent second dwelling: temporarysecond d�Vellrrig to a Staff said if the applicant wants to amend: this a lication he will appropriate fees for a .new application and :new hearings will':be held. have to pay the Chairmaij Matson said a second dwelling Would not be allowed under, th Zone, 'He, was against this application; a Watershed Staff said if this was `truly a tern or Pp ook like a temporary dwellin at differently.: Staff P arydwellin it Would be looked said thea licahon does not i gi �otnMISS,ioner Lambert said if the mobile home is allowed to stay while built, cart the Commission condition it to be removed before a Ce Certificate, . y bile the home is . zs issued for the perinanent dwelling? rtificate, of Occupangy # lst7��1r Cpm r f. Staff said it would b `hard to enforce a Certificate V 11 once the power and water is on-site. Staff said the of Occupancy moven con py on a private resi ince a ca=nmercial, development than a residential dwelling, of in this area With control Mr. Carver said it was unrealistic to remove the mobile home While the house is being bunt. and displace the family a constructinga Pe p in the code for a mobile home, Staff said there _. man rovision a to me, but the mobile roust be temporary.p rY e ent ho be tem ora while Mr. o Carver said the original ' staff finding estirimated the cost Home at $3,500.00. He said he ,is Wil g to post a bond of removal of the mobile ux that amount. Staff said the recommendatio Pl? n is for denial. Staff said If the Commission wishes to.' approve this a lication, staff would ask for a motion, of intent with a ro conditions. pp priato " Commissioner Qstrowski asked the applicant what was desired on t%vo homes? the Property, one or Mr. Carver said when Mrs: Parker bought the prope not be large enough for her needs, He said MrsPParlc rty heknew has handicapped mobile home would needs a .larger house to care for her children. Ile- said Mrs, Parker also needs her daughter with her to help care for the o is children and Other children; to have Commissioner OstrOwsk-i said the Staff Findings infer there i r dwellings on this property. s ,a Way to allow tmo Staff said thea licadon could be amended for PP a permandnt second dwelling. Mir Carver said this is what he, is proposing, vacate this and a Perm second dwelling. hearing he `will amend his pplrcation requesting a p rry G. Now MY, 6325 WAtershed GroupYa an Oliver 'Road, Paradise, CA, president of J'e the orgaruxation of citizens of the Parade.: a Midge Idicated to abct Our protecting the domestic water sn 1 of the Town of iParadise construction of a large dwelling while retaining the mobile home was Opposition to Xie said the water ,in Paradise is deteriorating: H!e was agains 'this as said permit would increase the density and contiibute Aunt r�nme , Permit:. He said this to the degradation of area 'water 'supply, amended application. d vacate .his hearing, and he should Carver Said the Comnrussion shoal .are P P a ren `vtxri Staff .• published �noted g a S21iere wilt be additional fees axil the hear z� will h- dthe applicant will be starting over from the be"• a to be re- application. T g with a new Commissioner Lynch. asked if it would be a re-application for a new use perm-'? . , Staff said yes; t Mr. Carver said If he ha,, to pay fees for a. new ,applicatioi' then h continue this .hearing than to vacate it. e world rather tdnamae Vaircloth said ,she has lived in, this area 'for a_ long time r zoning, She 'history y g before the TM -5 gave a brief histo of wh the area. was zoned TM -5. She said it was to slaw clown develoj;ftient in. the area; because of the Watershed. She said an in development will increase the cost of maintaining the road. She crease in A, g said if this area is going Coun alto�tnain ain. She was, Rambling. Road should be, dedicated to the County for the against this permit. She said over S0% o f the owners in the area are against this permit. Property BIanche Bell said she .felt the same as Mrs. Fair clath: She was against nst the peiYnit, Mr. Richard :Long said he agreed with the other two speakers. He was a ai Permit. He was concerned with how long the temporary use would be. + g nst the neighborhood cl;aned with increased density. He ,paid he hated to see the net Lee Cage, Paradise Planning Comnussianer asked if PID and the Town of paradise were contacted to comment On this project? Staff said they were, The hearing teas closed. CIO hat�a5sPProwed . iarie,• Lynch said ;he thou g tht there was"a. similar situation about threee a but he could not :remember the name: years ago Commissioner Lambett asked if there,were any regulations re ardin _ g the square of what constitutes a singl& family home? footage q . Staff said there is no raaxamtmi foata g a re uirerztent: a i. .. but. the Comnusmon has already a r With increasing the density ih the ar as concerned wi tY e omnussiotier bstrorvsla said h ..weed.. _ the near code amendtrient fdr i•�tny Hdusing last Week 'densityd the this bane b" a a' I;Y approving i G4,11 0 TILE NO.: 065-070-015 BUM, COUNTY PIAIN NG COMMISSION STAFF VIN'DINGS -June 18, 199, APPLICANT Carver Construction OWNED', Betty Lou Parker REQUEST: Use Permit to allow an existing mobile home as a temporary, second dwelling and construct new primary dwelling unit: AP NO.: 065-070-015 SIZE: 5 acres LOCATION: Approximately 2,200 feet east of the Skyway off 'Rambling of way also known as 6350 Rambling Way, Magalia EXISTING ZONING: TM -5 and WP (WaterShed Protection. Zone) ZONING HISTORY Zoned TM -5 on October k5,1974 by Ordinance #1507 - SURROUNDING ZONING. TM -5 SURROUNDING LAND USE: Single Family Residential SITE HISTORY: Currently the project site supports one single family dwelling. GRNERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Agricultural -Residential APPLICABLE REGULATIONS: Butte:: Count� . County'Code Sections 24-43,, 24-47, �4 1740 24-196, 24-303, and 24-304 1 : i BUT17 COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS -June 1$, I991 �0- MMEN'T REC D Butte Gount rare De artrrient �eorn �1�e artmeht.of Forest FirePrevention.,- " generate oril ave p This will Butt - Y ry minimal efFire De Department demands." e county heriff s DenarTment• "Tlie Butte County Sheriffs has the lowest orucer to - citt;sens ratio of any Lase Enforcement, A enc an the 'entire State. limit the services this department can provide the citizens of Butte Co Budget constraints severely or rezoning creates the Possibility of further impact on the resources of this County. New construction f the +additional calfs for service. This will result in a further deterioration o ` s department with. ( service provided ;by this department to .all citizens of Butte' county, f the level of w � In. the event a .funding mechanism becomes -available to it crease the Personnel in !his department there would be no objection to the proposed,number evelo of sworn rezone. Until that time, however, this department regretfilly c Opposes or rezoning," pment or, PP s any new development Btittecount� Public �'Vorks De artment: Drivewa y must meet 'County ;standards." Butte ceunt Environmental Health De artment: " " departments requirements. Sufficient, proof has been given that the The project as proposed.' can meet this following conditions approved; The mobile home is connected to applicant can meet the and well" anexisting sewage system Citizen3° of Nei hborhood: See attached letter: N�LYSIS= The project is a request to designate an existin Temporary dwelling so as to allow a permanent heme' .,to be c Sting mobile Name on the project site as a, existing mobile home, The project site is located jest east of just north of 'the I ambling �Vay, The existing mobile home is located a he Skyway Ind south of property lines and approximately � '(1 feet firom thy; approxOsa-imately 150 feet from the existing heavily wooded adj°fining parcels are developed with single family atcah of the home` The states that the e�tistng mobile sv,1l be occupied by the roe dwellin s. and grandchildren, g The applicant property owners daughter, son-in-law The provisions of the "Temporary Mobile Homes" ordinance co` the Use Permit is requested for, will be the second unit "to a ntemplates the dwelling whiel ' n already existing a on the project site. In thin case ;the applicant wishes to build,a new print2 tinuni the existing ry g p{ nd unit . y . leave request doe not et the strict int'erp etatinn o {hem :ora p ry second unit, The applicant's` dwellings. In aC nin ddition, the existing mobile home has been nsialled tgithoatfu porary second: g `which reduces its temporary status. t e ,mobile and asvrun s II deck around u ,.._, F3UTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMfISSIOht STAFF FINDINGS - 7tine t3,19'91 The "Temporary Mobile I40mies" ordinance was intended to assist families in meeting their g lyousing needs when the existing primary dwelling unit: no lunger satisfiesthe ly's housing fami needs. In this case there is no existing home on the project site which the applicant considers as the primary residence; Instead the applicant i!3 proposing a new home be built. Therefore the new home proposed could be designed in such a way to as to accommodate the housing needs and desires of the applicant under the provisions of the current zoning code without a use permit for a temporary mobile home. After review of the request and the Butte County Zoning Code the applicant was of the .fact that. the +Ilse Permit re uest did P informed q not .meet the requirements nor intentions of the Zoning. Code Section 304. The applicant requested to pursue the application regardless of the Planning Departments disposition of the application. =4 The applicant also has the option of amending the Use Permit applicnjion to request a Permanent second dwelling unit which is aliowed b use classification which should clearly accommodate the applicansermrtrequest. in the b f applicant Chooses to pursue this option the hearing must be Ile -published to reflect the permanent status of the second dwelling rattier than as a temporary as it is Currently the Commission should vacate this hearing and evaluate the amended published. Cation, RECOMMEND Instance RECOMMENDATi NS MAKE THE 1+TNDI OTION.: ACCEPT COMMENDATIONS OF STAFF MEMO DATED NGS LISTED UNDER "A% AND � D June 18, 1991; UNDER v MAKE Y1�E MOTION -AS OUTLINED A Find that: 1• This project is categorically exempt from the provisions of ;the FrEironmental Quality Act in: accordance to Section 15303, Class 3 of Yhc California f'uli(io Resources Code. 2. The requested, use permit noes not meet the ttnf;ion of the "Temporary Mobile County Code, Y C Chapter 24, Section 303 & 304, of The Butte Homes ordinance as outlined b' ha to y, 'The applicant has an opportunity to plan anrt e �n the primary, need dwelling u,ii x to meet the housing needs dt' tho family which would Preclude. th' second temporary dwelling unit on the project site, f� a temporaryse . r gi p j to be �. Deny the Use Permit to allow the exrstin mobile borne an the ro ect site come rorad dwelling to a proposed prrinary dwelling unit to be bunt on 3 { ro ect, lncludin9, thoea required by > r ri 4 j;ttt and:describe"-; n4Flerrelated pormits and olhL F1J{`�o aP.f�N1/i(�.(��fpti�.tf {�L/1 1 r~itty� rregtonal, state dnd Federal egenclos: -- tlESIt7ENtIAL, Include the number of unite, whether units a� single b � I Rn��I9� t��ltN L le t`r ll and . 3" �" <i� (*1(.L '- t hypo of household size expected. t Ur l 7 or regionally orlenked, square loofa o of spies area, and t#sp ComiAERCIAL, Indicate the type, 141ie2her neighborhood, city iit�mdrrg o ling f l7R►ALactlitles., indicate type,' estimated employment per shlit, ,and loading facilities. fit+ ItISTI fUT10ttAL, indicate the mafor function, estimated em ►loymenl per shpt, estiv.tnted occupancy, loading facilities, a►►td oommunity benefits to be derived from the ptolect; { V4Rt7NPdENTAL WPACTs ANo tAITIGATI014 MEASURES �' tittr ntll niilcant envlronmentat linpacta associated tvlih the use POOL What protect design features or special twtentlatly sig res) are, proposed to allavtatepotential environmental intipacisl �►ooditlons'al approval (mitigation l,ressu ENVI;IONMENTAL SETTING' to ect Including Information on topography, soil stability, plants and ani- ;Describe the project site, as Et exlsla ltetote the P 1 structuiss on tine site. and the use of the structures, nnai,s, 'and any cultutal historical or scenic aspects.Describe any existing .81 Prttes, Including into -mat on plants and animals and any cultural; historlcal or sconic aspects: �+ ,tiascrtbe the surrounding prop of land use (single-family. aparlmentsi shops, depart ty indicate the type of Land use (residential, commerelal, etc.) intensity d marl tnr to etc.), grid scale oI development theight, frontagd, setback, rear Yard, eic ), ' Use separate sheet lot longer tesponses.. f ('tet p�i4 t�".L/� t ( i t't t�C t tri P� ✓t Ll bt�l r-, -/a -,t.C3t't�t,iC"IrhtdIkti1Cl.� �}''�!C L l;;.i•� � �t)f"�-�at�rwll.�lt°yr� F����t-•l,: f�-i`~�,('' U..:.•t} _ I I L: `t' y 4 heresy .dec me tinder "penalty of perjury that I have Lead gn �understand Ole Itisiructlons and that the foregoing statements are #rate4 complete and correct. to the best of my knowl_dge and Applicant's slgnatuta Date P.rp %�-'e9—.tom petty oHnar`s signature ' y .N, tJse.`I'ennit; Number __. Request: t)st. to allow Location and stze.ot pnrca((s) V�EtipYt t ., ,., . , • ti , `_ . ;F p act Oesctiptton c r n -� M � r A,1l. Number(61 i I Zontrtg and pequlrements • . vs �,/ pwnershlp proof of Agency It needed) lion boscrlptfon M --- ^ _�r�",'�i dPtes of Plot plan .. , 10. TwweaM+Jw a'i W Y 'h M Y 1 Yi Y{ ' r;,� • ,M) M ,i>, "N ham° ".. +: /, f11 ' ` >� ✓r Rdcelpt Number t> Data Fteealved Appficatlon taper by i > iNSTRUCTIONS TO MINK APPLICANTS it nppllcnnt is not the owner, written authorization by the owner or other prop( o[ ogency must 1 j be sunmitttd in .ardor for the applicant to legally sign the applicatinn, Application shall be. ' considered void if t►at.signed by: the owner .or Icgal agent. «• All items on app licatinn shrill be filled�in h4 completely as Possible, , cable, please indicate by'lhe term NA [f an item is not appli- cable, r It is finportrint thra the u �� prajc tincluding the follow gt Supply nn accurate description of the location of the proposed a, A:rtses3ar's parcel nurnbr;r(s) (from the tax bills or Assessor's map, r). b. Street addresses (if nvnilnhle) 1 c. Distdinces'nnd directions to nrjrned streets, bodies of water or railroads. Y)" `iiventy-fou, (ll) cc les o(a detailed plot plan of adequate scall ;ta clearly sfloiv proposed huild- ings and improvements, folded to $;s x ')L inches, shall r,ccompany and be mnde part of the r" "`Application for U a Permit". if 1116 useermit is a p pproved, ,the ),'lot plan becomes the np- proved development plan for the property,'The plot plan shall include the following inlormatfon a, A scaled drawing of the pnreelis) b'=undaries: b. Location and dimensions id till, existing and proposed improernents on the property, including buildings. driveways, parking areas, ,veils, septic t'nnlcs and leach [fields: C, l.,ocation and name, of bordering streets, access marls, nearby crossroads, streams, bridles of Ajoker nnsl railroads, North arrow and scale of denwing, 5� 11, a "A licotton for w•„ � public . 8 Cfrinmissian;. Any, spec", , 'conditions of approval shall be made a artproval by the Planning Part C'errftrt rind. shall be � Permit" is sulk ect tri hearin s and a o[ the approved "Clse i> g pp p y Y muse Pat- 6. are stated I UwAcr 24 of the $utte Count Codd, bindln on thea applicant. The -procedures for Count action o g> "fhe Planning Commission, an the basis of the evidence submitted at thepuhlic hearing,may grant use ' pttmits when if finds that the proposed integrity ,uses o[ tile propetty tvii.l not iml t;ir the and character aE' khe zone In Which the land its and that. the use wo"M K de tin- IS%scam atiblc with or Inturioos to surrounding properties not stet"ranch1, to the 'neral health,� p . s residing or working in the neiglrharhood tics° to the health and enera wellard of the Prsun ge safety and welfnrc of the county, to In sppravin n use permit, the ilnnning Comlfii6816i may include sueh conditions as ar'e deemed teasnnable rind necessary under the eircumsthnces to preserve the integrity= and rh,nrnctcr of the zone and to secure flit general purposes of the Butte County Crencr'h) Chan and Cllnpter 2d, of the Butte County Code. Such conditions mny lnplttde, but are act limited rt lot. of yov. �� p the limrtalians., development plan appi-nval, hours of h elation, fehcio' , dedicotion of L $ time . , d street and drnina c im ravements. r °n P. h Gandlttons Imposed upon issuance of it y ell the permi"t_)h requested. use permit niiist ha reasonably rel ted to the use ftir tubi, $� Applicntidn lees as at (date) are § rarA may be paid in cash or by check made payabld to `rfeasuirei of butte County'`. , 9, Clefiue suh"it'" a use pttrnit tipplicutlon, applicant Is requested to discuss 'with atnff till quo§titins about applicutCan 're;iulrhrncuts, County proced'�ures, arfi, prifvisions and ptissible rfondit ons cif it prat i1. 1 mx fir. ! i'„••�. ,' S CONCERNED PROPERTY OWNERS '' 24 19,'1 ' 15333 Doe Lane .Ori«a.W �� .Magalia, ea. 95954 Phone 873-2757 July 20, 1992 Mr, Len Fulton Butte County Board of Supervisors Cam 95969 A? #065-070-015, Magalia Rambling 'Ray (de Sabla) t6tlg.ihal hearing date,: dune 27, 1991 9;00 a..mm Board of gapervisorsI .Room. CURRENT CONCERN: Antxcipated reapplication for a previously denied use permit for an "Aunt M;inil' or Permanent 2nd dwelling on 'the above parcel. Valid concerns of area residents re -the real .need for such a use permit. Valid concerns re increased density and over -utilization resulting from the granting of this use permit together 'with the new proposed intermediate school Which ,presents the potential for ,overtaxing our current surface water ,- s'upPlY.increases ground water contamination and the fact that we are in the vat�tr :shed and in very close proximity to Paradisq. Lake_. w Dear ter. Fulton: 1; am writing this letter to further define our recent phone conversation, Mrs. Bette Parker, owner of the above ;AV rYumbe,r, -Rambling Wade S'abla3.requested a use 'Perini t, hearing which was year held one ago on June 27, 1991. This hearing etas regarding a, 41se permit that would change I the J,ega�, status of the existing Permanent single family dwelling (manufactured type home triple L de) 'to be CALLED a +temporary second. dwelling" (Aunt Mini) . She I - stated that she heeded this existing ,residence to live in vhi.le a permanent new very large home of; 5051 sq, ft: could he rusted oil the sat O `ptoperty. She was denied the Aunt Mini Stai:�iolitus at that time, but was trill she could reapply at a'later date, She was further Informed ,by the planning depti that they voula allow her to continue to 'U80 the manufactured -home as a temporary dwelling only while constructing her neer residence provided ;she vrite a letterer of intent t reMOve thi.A manitCar'tiirprl home rinse her per, home Oat construdted. This home is now n6ating completion. this past week* Oe were verbally informed by Ht$4 Parker that she troy fin ds a need to reapply for an AuntMini or permanent 2nd dxelli,,,ng User permit for the pre-eklst.ing latge manufactured home on the property for which she was deified use one year agog and,, � which she declared in A written statement to tho planning dept i' J `, b Page 2; that she would .„ remove upon completion of Vondering if the neighbors would db�ect to th.istrucction. She was j 1t should be noted that Mrs. Parker Upon 1 she plans to care for the developmenttall.yudisabiadg states, that Children on a verjr limited basis. or unwanted Residents ori, t however, strongly suspect: that she i5 in -Rambling why group home under the guise o actuality building a 'Parker Tamil Home►�. f a per private r' establishment yin the 'LongBeachabefoerated a lar such She is also simlar;such cuxrently owner Of Parker F'amilming to paradise. I Lrfrdgepoxt Cr, in Magalia (Panes) and is a y Home at 14685 I licenced care giver. unrelated 9 r;. the legal r No .one ob`e.cts to her caxin fo up t pex°sons in her home. In fact. It is admirablethatMrs � Parker 'Vishe5 to Cate for the unwanted. because of the .increase in 'househola size,,, nolscase,second rhovever, -hero .be permitted. Zt is also admirable that she wants to hel ence her young daughtor, Tanis Berry and her .family in an '�Aurit p situation, Theze.appeazs however, to be no a Mini need or any other obvious apparent financial difficult to comprehend, an »nein. In fact, it is- y genuine need or extremely why or, how this triple wide cduld. conceivable reason as an "Aunt Mini!+ Index the Possibly legitimately Certainly y gitalify �. guide lines as we understand them, y anyone able to build a .5,351 s need fox, an additional extra uAun.t Mini" g ft have does not show a 'real need for an "A'urit Mini'► or unat.and casts doubt an It woul,d certainlya permanent 2ho dwelling. ppear that Mrs. Parker could find a separate nearby residence fox her daughteri* 'e would ,like to remind readers' of this letter of the tallow Important facts- We are in the water shed and in very chose proximity to paradise ,Lake and are zoned T14 5,, We, are all. on surface we11 Water, We are ridt porehased our permitted to split parcels. We all are out hero because Ot the TM -5 s1bW growth done and knowing that we were in. the water shed.. ,I ,east until ado ante t is o�tr g uted to slow down: growthr at understanding that iM=5 u►as instin,.ire: re,spohse to y11 was p°lice and £ 'Protection and a assured as well a £aster, accomplished: We are in a dz`ought and we hadeninrealfcSkYVa oa6 ground water contaminatidn. oz cited as already conitaMl: ated eine thedett townd Of recent ares pcblishea in the zecerit Paxadis.e Post. Paradise as Should Mrs. Parker be successful in obtaining her above use permit, is :she not in fact acctsr�plishing the same hd�six�d a-ilia1n her y Y s p p_ y arae us 'split °tir 5 acre throw out mM-5 and, let property? 7 the water shed and forget POr lse and about pzotectin contaminations Why N about'the real threat re ` ground water y ..hbuld Mrs: Parker tie allowed to have the Potential for large number of persons 11011*rg on her 5 While the rest of us are denied this pritilege acres the Stats n ... � .,,__.. . ,..:, - w..yw.,..•». +acs+`. +*... ,ate,. s,?r.wixa ..M. ... u_-, �w.rro t,...,. A' May , 1991 Butte County Planning Commissil r Ms. B.A. Kircher,, Director of Planning .Butte County Board of supervisors 7 County Center Dr. Oxoville Ca. 95965 g . Hearing#OS5-070-Oda:te; dune 27 1991 9.OQ a. RE'- AP 15 Ma alio (de Sabl m, Daa,, Ms. Kircher We k>ish to voice our concerns x;tgardir_g the above appl,icat3or .r a use Permit to allow a mobcle hone as a temporary s,� o ;d dwelling on property zoned IM -5 and zone on the in a watershed protcctn south side of E2ar. Ming Way in De water lt IS rowth inorderthat TM -5 was institute g ci to slow siva water su 1 "totolowweforvithemestabli;shme as prated mux Pg y• establishment of adequate fire protection;, 91.1, etc. and othex additional public services pxio to aw Population ex ansiont adequate at this time.. pWe all These public. services ,are n,�t arei because of the low density zonincaand audeeut prconcernothis fragile environment and o supply, We all have invested our life savings s Wetedosnot want cur area to ha s borderline -commercialism: bf concern is the ratio' of population permissible under `f Ms which we have bon Per ldobysCaunt}�nof,our arls unl la for a single family. resilience plus an additional .six unrelated persons all to live under the same roof acfclition o� an Aunt plug_ the Mind for all lot owners who cah s,Wi a need.: real or otherwise. ibis for an ease could �lrasticail lower our current water table, and increase possible rlinatioh and Increase traffic. We are on a ground water canto private. toad. ate are hot agdihttt a 'family helping out needy fdmill members, An Aunt Mini unit should be granted in cases of extre►e a temporary basis i : e. reed and pan; to help aged' Parents or aisabled Immediate family membera We assume the re use perfiit refers to bove the ekistlbg largequtripler wine the aunit currently on the above desctibed temporary residence property to be used as a Occupying this unit. (Ount Mxni)isfthe the fact family currently family now occu the cutre,ht eying this knit has in out opinion a greet patelltial to continue to ' grow in numbers and casts same doubt p. Mind status: a are of the under g pr perha s on heir��hat aelaxfez an AuntMini cans.truct�: h g germane dwelling is to be d on t n this name 4 an 5 property In addition to the Aunt Mihir This tiew► dwell in' will not only house lts own immediate famil; members o. but in,additior, be allowed to house up to sips unrelated r t � ; f, _ May 31:, 1991 tutte Count,y 91anniny Commission 118 "H.A Kirc4-er, Director of Planning butte County E:Oard of Supervisors 7 County Center Dr. Crovil.le, Ca. . 95965 Ott: AP x#065-070-01.5 Magalia (de Sabla) Nearing date: June 27, 1991 9:00 a.m. Dear Hsi: X ircher z We wish to voice, our concerns regarding the above applicati.v.n for a rise permit to allow a mobile home as a temporary second dwL�wling on pro,pert'y zoned TM; --5 and in a watershed protection zone on the south side of Rambling Way in be Sabla It is our understanding that TM -5 instituted to slow down grpwth in order to protect the environment as well as protect our 44ter supply. Also to allow for the establishment of adequate ,tire protection, 911, etc. and other public services prior to .any additional population expansion. These ,public services are not adequate at th'45 time. We all purchased our property in 'this ` aroa because of, the 1 w density zoning and a deep concern for out f frag3.l.e e0V1tonMe.nt arta pretious water supply. We all have invested out life savings here. We do not want our area tc have borderline .commercialism ,,Of concz4n is the ratio of ;population per lot size in our area ,�)ermltsi,blt under TM5 which we have been told by County officials allows .for a single 'fam'ily residence plus an additional,' six i,„ntdiated persons all to live Unde the saMe roof plus the k"aditicmri of ani A:wntmini for all lot owners who can show �- need, real or oLherwis.e,. This increase in population could drastically, ,lower our, current water table, and inctease possible ground vattt and increase traffic. We are on a private road. 'fie are not against a family helping out needy family members.; An Aunt Mini unit 81Nould be granted in cases of extreme need and :on:,. a temporaty basis, i.e. to help agad parents of disabled 4mmedia'te family members+. We assume the request for the above Ise permV.- refers to the existing large triple wide tun,it. C' cu l)~ently on the above described property to be used as a einpchrary residence (Aunt Mini) for the family cUrre,n,tly 0ce;npy bg this unit. Of, concern is the 'fact that the. cu.tztnt gam,zly now occupying this 'knit has in our opinion a giteat ,�rotdhtlalt to continue to grow In; numbers and cast's some debt Otarhapi3 on their real need for an Aunt Mini status'. We ar,e xof t ht understanding that a larger permanent, dw'el.ling, is to be C:rtnstructed on :thit same property in addition to the -AOht f1jt'i.; I ' is new dwelling will not only house its own imine ii&;4e facily .:,embers, but in addition be allowed to house up to six unrelated r„;$_iwsons. on careful assessment, this particular arrango ' eot -,7 r • i May �, 1�i91, "1: Butte County P;l.anning Connnis,sloll Ms. B.A. Kircher Director of Planning Butte County Board of Supervisor; 7 County Center Dr. nrovil.l,e, Ca. .95965 Re" AP 406$-070-x015 Magali.a (de Sabla) Hoaxing date! JUnO 27 1931 r $100 a•m. Board. of Supervisors' Dear Ms, Kircher: Roam it is Our understanding from a notice g received from the Butte permit that would chane t Carver Construction wan Count Plarznin Commission that Permanent single family dwelin legal status ks a use of the exating dwelling", so than another very tobCALLvj) 1 "temporary second consttucted on the same. propezty ylargepermanent dwelling can be It is also aux Understanding cahstructed it g that after the th the "temporary secondhdwelliincitt not . Owners of the new home is but that it• be all:�v�ed. to REMAIN as artemved property that this wa from the property., Y, the •existing 2,000 plus s p ry .residence in home would :became the "Aunt Mini'+' of the Howl con g- ft, triple 'wide Mo trLAR home. y sttucted Larger It is admirable'that the owner of the daughter, Janir, Berry and' her family in an oants�tto bel but, the size Of the ;'temporary second dwellin r+ is p her ob3ecti.ng to rt .is oux understandin n "Aunt.. Mini: Situation, Aunt Mini of up to 1200.s g What we are q ft The ex s .,ing ht,mt.ei.Iawuallo�ws an ' much latyei titan that maXimumr g testioh .is it the plahning commission allows `Catver con ;t u ptrmit ction this they will be aliowih two homes of MORE `PtiArT 2 0Q0 ase ft. on-a pro ert to sto` p 1' zoned for a single ymily residence, 9 thtlp i then property owners ih the area 'from, ddn estinvhzat is xsting pexmanent primarlr'diellings.be cal it g that secondeat+ell ncJs�r sa that they � ...i,, reeltem ar property with relatives, e deal ' ��.d another home, and ioshar elf risih (The idea migh`. catch an gf�,°cckly, due to g P4 COS and lack: of a�tailabil;it o . ►ould be that there would be: y ~ i4-opertyl , The e fact double tile: amount of Names Parcel, a fact that an enVirOhmental,l;y and social;: per Planning omm ssirz eheuld consider. y conscious die also ask that the planhirig commission please k the above deacleat 5 acres is 10 ted ih a watersh eeA i'�+ mind that ,one;' Alcor please keep in fiind that this s,a e d acre,spistwcti,oh a; i`ex lOD feet of the �south side of 0amb ing V panwhddlnisralslate school. on this same - In, th4 same wate;she+i e r n LAND OF NATURAL WEALTHA:: BEAUTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT" March 14, 1991 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE- O OVILLE, CALIFORNIA.9,965.339'7 TELEPHONE. (516) 538-7601 Carver Construction P.O. Box. 6266 Chico, CA. 95927 Re,- Pie-Application Review AP# 065-070-015 Gentlemen: This is to notify you; that we have received sufficient assurancesfrom. Butte, ;Coun Environmental Realth and Public Wo6cs Depa„"tments that your project can meet t requirements. This fulfills the Pre Application .review process. heir Pursuant to t1le Butte Calinty Plannin which states, "Upon tentative approval'of land ettnt P erm t or va6.nce by Review Procedure Mali he Lia Environmental Health Department and Land Development Division of the the artme of Public Works, the applicant must sl.ib nit a completed formal application, inlart nt any required changes. from the orgzn2il submittai and the balance of the fess within 6 months of the tentative approval.", no additional work shall be performed on this ro"ec;t until we have received the remainder of the application fee in the amount 80ti0 of'S 7 p a and; if any, required. changes from the Gnginal Submittal. Please submit the fee along with any ,required changes from the uri 'gin submi "t Butte County Planning Department no latter than September 8, 1991 or our at licit, will become void, and in order to corit;nrie the project, you will be re' aired to re a Ion P q Pply, Please make all cl;ecn a `able to th�� Btytte County. Treasurer. Enclosed is a field marker for identification of the project: Please SecC d the ribbon " conspicuos place on the site,, preferably visible froth the roadway, a l a9r IrI 4r, r- 95954- Y=< L $. Lt 065 070 OOP. OM STATUS: ACTIVE F l -sal 3 GAUMER HAROLD E & DIANE 3 JT - -, 6447 KARI[V CT- .Y MAGALIA: CA , .. °x 95954 — [� r L: 065 070'006 000 STATUS: ACTIVE p , : LONG -'RICHAP,D T & THERESA `- •t P 0 1494 t. . .BOX MAGALTA CA - 95954 .:< Ls 0,65 070 007 000 STATUS:, ACTIVE FAIRCLOTH FRED LOYD &, EDNAMAE L ;.' . _ PO 80X 339 MAGALIA CA: 95954 . ' ,. L: 065' 070 015 00 STATUS: ACTIVE PARKER BETTY LOU; TRUST 4 :. .T PARKER BETTY LOU TRUSTEE •- 3502 IROQUOIS >>„. LONG BEACH: CA t 90808 �{ L: 065 070 019 000 STATUS: ACTIVE FOWLER MICHAEL & BARBARA ANN 2860 E OLIVE HWY OROVILLE CA. . t,t = 95966: Lr 065 070 �2t,,000 STATUS: ACTIVE '•, . f; a BARCLAY SCOTT E' ;& LAUREEN H TT - �{. 15341 DOE. LANE , > it • MAGALIA CA 95954 r L: 065 070 022.0081 STATUS: ACTIVE �r BELL FAMILY TRUST r BELL LAWRENCE R'JR & BLANCHE E TRUSTEES -. DOE N 15333 F - it L ' MAGAL-IA CA 't ` 065 070=-023 000 STATUS: ACTIVE = it- G%LMOUR CHARLES ,P & DIANfVE 'N ” r 2112 F BASELINE Y f GLENDORA CA 91.740 .024 L: 065 070 0017 STATUS: ACTIVE DIMBAT CARL P & BURNETA H Jr 15305 DOE LN +.. MAGALIA CA 95954; [ 1: c L: 065 070 025 000 STATUS: ACTIVE �r PRINGLE CHARLES M & ELSIE M. •, rid P 0 BOX 611, 1'# MAGAL IA CA 95954 f , ' f ` L:. 065 070 026 000 STATUS: ACTIVE , .f . •y WILSON DAVID A & JOANN M JT F PO BOX 1206 MAGAt_IA CA; 95954 ;a . - L• 065 070 027 OM STATUS; ACTIVE: TRIPLETT JETHRO [.-. - 1476 148TH AVE }}* SAN 4EANDRO CA 94578 _ Y,a $r w L:, 065 070 030 000 STATUS. ACTIVE - KATZDOFe E-RNIE T & CONSTANCE a, PO BOX 617 PJAGALIA Cts 95954 Y 06'S 4710 001 000 S►ACUS: AL`11V1= NROALIA ISA 95954 L;065 070 027 000,-, STATUS: ACTIVE .F TRIPLETT JETHRO + 1476 148TH AVE SAN LEANDRO CA 94578 L 065 070 030 000 5TA1US: ACTIVE KATZDORN ERNIE T & CONSTANCE PO BOX-617 MAGALIA Cpa 95954 L065 470 001 00th 91 Al US' AG [ l VE �{ 5T . At9PS 'JOHN R & PATRICIA • -F " 13-/, SUSSEX WAY + ..' ' GONLORD CA , t ,y 9+561 ".' L: 065 470 PLE3 00.0' STATUS, ACTIVE P, .. ALFORD EUGENE K, & FRANCES E }. 15296 TOREY PINE RD ., MAGALIA CA 'Ap' ' 15954 ` • , • F , T.t , t ttd k yy a,4 . n N P eA P, , • 1 « » ^ ' � �'�X k� N.•` � ,;Fr P' dirt, � y May 31, 1991, Butte County Planning commission Ms. B.A. Kircher, Director, of planning Buttel County Board of ,Supervisors 7 County Center Dr. Oroville, Ca. 55965 RE! AP #065-070-015 Magalla (de Saba) Hearing datie June 27 19:`+'i. 9100 R -m. Hoard of Supervisors' Room Dear Ms,. Kiz:chez; It is our unders,tand5ing from a notice received from the Butte County Planning Commission that Carver Construction wants a use permit that would change the legal status of the existing permanent single family dwelling to be CALL8D a "temporary second dwelling", so that another ver large Y g permanent dwelling c¢an be constructed on the same property: It. is also our understanding that after the new home is constructed, it is the desire of the owners of the propexty that the "temporary second dwellingto not be removed from the property, but that it be allowed to REMAIN as a temporary residence. In this way,- thin existing 2;000 plus sq. ft. triple wide MODULAR home. home would become the "Aunt Mini" of: the newly constructed larger . It is admirable that the owner of the propert daughter, Janis Berry and her family in an y wants to help her ''Aunt Mini" situation, but the size of the "temporary second dwelling" is what we are objecting to. It is our understanding that State law n allows a a Aunt Mini of up to 1200 sq. ft. The existing home in _question much larger than that maximum.. It If the planning commission allows Carver cjobstruction this use Permit, they will be allowing two homes, of MORE THAN 2,000 sg ft. on a property zoned for. a single family residence. What is to stopother permanent primaz dwellings pro ext area from requesting that th6it existin n p ntow rim iY the Ings be called utemporat and dwellings so that they can build ant�ther home and nshare' property with relatives. (The idea might catLh on, quickly due to raising prices and back of availability of property), The effect parcel, a factthatAnulenvironmdntall and socia homes would be that double the amount of per d be Planning commission' should consider: Y ll.�+ conscious We also sovbel ask tha e planning irk m commission please keep ind that 5actes is located in a watershed protection tone. Also, plddbd keep in mind that this same 5 acres is Vithih a few 100 :deet of the planned intetmediate ,school ori this same south side of Rambling Way which 16 also in the same Otekshed; s 1JTS-rTzxBTJ-rG0N ixslr C(:)MM:ENTS ` `.. county Public Works P-'SS0XMQ E: ALAN"ACT .1WT "County Environmental Health State Water Resources Department C,Jty of Biggs U . S . Forest Servic e city of Chaco U.S. Bureau of La,,nd Management City of Gridley Butte. County Min_ng Committee City of Oroville State Department of Fish & Game Town of Paradise - California Native Plant Society P;lanning Department State Div: Forestry - attention. d'State Transportation Department Craig Carter p Regional Water oual. Control Bd. —><L State Reclamation Board Butte Water District- am; r nS California Water Service Co. Richvale sanitary D ,strictr Del: Ora Water Co; North Burbank. Pub. Util. Dist. o'�J,ID Skansen Snub . (CSA #21) Thermalito Irrigation District Stirl.i.ng City Seater Maint. Dist. Other Thermalito Irrigation District (CSA #26) 2F.i22GAT=ON WATEF2 PG&E North (Chico') Biggs-W.Gridley Water District �_- PG&E South (Marysville) Butte Water District Pacific Bell Durham Irrigation District _.;State Tv Cable OWID Viacom Tv Cable Paradise ,Irrigation District PRchvAle Irrigation Distriict Table fountain Irrigation 'Dist, c xox �xr� rr thermalito irrigation ;District S1 Medio Fire Protection Dist« *X- =County, Fire Department/CDE` DVAj!NAGF, D=ST72YC1T CJ:NT Durham; Orovi.11e or Butte County i i _72ECL:AM..A.TSON i7YS1'`ZT�.�.�;: State Highway Pat' El .County Sheriff �— R'VC90MMSTT7EE�5„LCONIMMS8tONS Chico Area Recreation District Paradise Pines Architectural `Durham Area Red. &Park Dist. ,' Control Commitl:ee feather River Rec; & Park iJist. Butte County Farm tur2au, Paradise Rda. & Park Dist.a� Communx.ty Ast6ciatidit! Rithval.e. Rec. & Park Dist, State Parks & Red. Dept.