Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
066-080-036
».1 �aax ...e .. a ', v :�'• ) .•gym10, z r 4 7 i V 3 J 1 pp r i . .ty'.. ��i ,.4 ?4e.. I .. %). ...«. .., ..., ,... .....,.... fi:. ,. . `., ... f. x .... r f a -• � »< tr._ �, r .y , ... i' '� �.l k w gas z r- e ✓'r a I' / pi• y p f 1 • rt v m n s •fid • � -'�" • •„��a �^ � • � I � f f r, �, '• / n'' 'rl�• • 0 I. ,. 1`, v`Y f- . ',11'yM ♦ �1• A ,� � N- ' •' • M a a. Log„fes .orperatibn Howard Slater D.H' Slater & Son - - representative aaplicant Drawer 5176 375, MorehEad Avenue a.DDRESS -- Chico,, CA 9`5927 Chico-, CA 95928 894-111 _ 893-3333 ME: Same property owner' r` ADD;=Sz y FROJECT��:SCR'k7P=iE7= Use Permit to allow1) Expansion of a 'Pre— existing non-confo—rming- us£s to allo:J a members lounge, 2.) A sign. iii the required setback, 3) Parking on a parcel across the street on troperty in e same..oGmership, 4) Compact parking spaces, 5) Useof alternative Landscaping- R-C/RT-1. locate& at the nurthwest and southwest corners of �,vrogrty zoned Andove—r Drive and South: Park Drive identified as: AP 66--08-36 , 38 town area: Paradise Pines f 40 and 41 PIA- :,ESIGNATION _ Lo:,r 'Dens .ty Residential DATE 1 PRE-AP? M PAID: 195 50 '1?,V= rr"M 9516 APPLICATION ACCE TED;: F7iNliE. AFP. PAID: .So RECEIPT` NUMBER:j3 � LZ REZOb'ING PETITIO?f SIGNAI MS• CHECi�` PERCENTAGN: j MAILING LIST PWAURM i HAIL.-OL*r NOTICES W'RIT"'ENF _ _ _ Newspaper° NOTICES HAILER, ?�UMEER: Public,: IMAL. DESCRIPTIOK PREPARED PUMCATION NOTICE WRITM DISPLAY .- - ---- --- l iLSJ rPEit PUBLICATIml 0- CP G B R. DATE OF PUBLICATION: - INITIATE =VT PREPARED' ENVIRONAiENTAL DETERMT_Y7ATION3 __ Categorical BxeWtion. FILED: Negative Declaration FILED: Mitigated Negative-Declaration. FILED, EnvirOM3entaY. IMpact' report CERTIFIElix -- _ Othhert 4, STATE CLEMNGHOUSE NMER: AFpLICAn/REPR.FSENTATIVE NOTIFICATION OF EMRONRN}TAL DEIMWJMTION PLANNING Ct'2i"fIS5I0i'F HEAF.IitG(s) .-� BOARR OF 'SUPERVISORS'' RESOLUTION NUMBS (GPAs) ADOPTED: -- ORDINANCE MMER' ADOPTED.` N TIE£ OF BETEE MATTUPM (A,p�. T(a--C R}' NMI i , ,L� NO, = 8'��,8 and AP 66-jos-:3E+ sUTTi COUNTY PLANNING C"I55IQN . . STAFF FINDINGS August 27', 1997 , 5afor* Corpora`l+.ion APPLICANT OWNER*same e QUESTW- Rezone from i�^C (Resource Gonscrvs:tl ren) to RT-1 (minimum Dens I i-,Y Res I dent'I a1 Mobile Nome) and Ilse permit to allow 1 expan s i an o s, pr -ex st l ng nonoor1 form109 use tt� aIIow a members lounger 2 a sign setback, 3e parkin@ in the required on the parcel across the street or' property In the same owr ersh +, s compact Park IhO spaces, and 5p Us� of alternative 1andsda 1n9ti AP E>6-08�3�i, 58a '11`x, 41 AP NO." -- x.82 aures x SIZE= At the northwest Bind southWesi LOCATION corners of Andover Dr'•i,ve and. South Park Orsi fie) Paradise P 1 nes t ' 1=?�ISIING ZONING= R..0 and RT-1 'HISTORY= 1975 Or-d 156 ISOZon i Trl Nibrch, 181 1V5 Ord. i. ,ZONING andezo�ed 1560: SURROUNDING ZONING= R-C 8hO R i .. i Single Faml1Y residentl6l o model 0RRQUNDING LAND USE= dome, and skyway g Con forhlanok5iroreport i SIYR i=il'S1'O��+ � abiandoniixert dra i nagem easE9mer�r appcat IOh Reversion to acreage pendih9 to Join club houae porcei w r. d: s , 'SUTTE ,COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION' STAFF FINDINGS - August 27, 1987 r,equirements. A rozone applIdatl"an has also been Wed to rezone the --Tubhou;",a property from.R-C to RT -1 The rezone will el I tol nate the 100 foot setback and need for a: variance to the front yard setback The T--1 zoning district has a 50 foot Front yard setbackr and allows golf I courses upon approval of a use permit. 4 o me tal review has been conduct At env i r n n ed and a Negative Declaration Us recommended. All patent,,! a l impacts can be addressed through conditions of t -61s use permit. _ Expansion of the clubhouse fat111t1es is considered an inproveffient to the golf of urse property) 'mak. ng It mor" attractive to the Paradise community xpans.ion as compatlble with the surrounding land uses and 1 s not, expected to resin t I n excess i ve no i Me, or tra f f I c . Th t= _appl I, cert has agreed to enclose the cart stot-arue building to provide noise attenuation to properties on the north and northwest,: What 19 team by enclosure is that the cart storage will be mo1^e than a carports It wI11 have ,-i wall at i --ho northwest side. A sign, now exist In the "front yard setback. A use permit for such a sign must be reviewed i n terms of publI,c safety and Potential for intOrference with rt,blic Works activities. This sign is riot adjacent to an Intersection t,r driveway, andj efore, should hove no impact on vehicular sight distance and safety. 'the sign,thould riot Interfere with Public Works octivltles; a it is veru unlikely that` South' Park Orly e will ever need to lag widoned As pert of the modified Use Permit apwllcat mt $afar has included two Parcels across the strOeit currently used for and proposed for park I ng M 8y l scot^poratl. n these propert l es into tire` Use Permit 7 lounge Parking cankava legit rriataly 1 ocetea cif f -s I to, 74 pae k i og spa-ees are shown oh the site pian 16 are required under the code calculated as follows. restaur~ant ; l per 3 seats l 5 pro shod:, I per 24 ti sq f i, = 2 i pro office, l per 300 sq. ft -,r » = la ecreation lounge, per 100 s41: 2ijl golf course, 4 per hole = 16 for a total of 16. 7 of the spames shown are shod far compact cars. The County parking r rd i mance does not now provide for oompact spaces. Given the tendency towerd smaller ,. _ _. for �. w .: .. cams ca�i fit �! cars:, allowances for compact spaces seems reasonable. Nlea�urement of tom-`ot tnbl yg i bepant0 4 x 166'paesp8cel of Itshowed i swrecommendedothat no more' than P -O% of the spaces be cbmpactx and no smaller than 8' x 161All comr~act :..paces Si'r'a11 be so desighated on the pavement. inocl The f I nal request umder this Use I'erm i t Is I ±' I cation of the l ar�dscape standards . Landscap i'ng Is rc� _qu i r: d under, County Code 8Lct 1 ori 24-85 as fol lows A ten fok,3t 'i and;scape be'tHden any publ I c r I ght-r # -wav grid park 1 hg lot; and an add 1 tl on 'I b of the r~n ire lot" aafor� has requested that the native vegetation on the for side of the golf course park 1 ing lot be retained In 1 I eu of Pl'ov i d 1 ng urban l andscop i ng. Native i atlds"cop ng It more In keeping with the vege.tati ort Pound on surf^bund I ng 8 Al'itl;Nl)T C V ColINTY _ U'!t II[JT I'iz IINVIRONWINI`Ah CHECKLIST FORM comrl,'ptod by Toad Agency) f Log ,ft 87-06-1.6-02;03 SII AP 9 66-08-36,3.8,40,41 1 . BACKCROUNLI I( Fide #87-48 1. Name of proplanant _��#i:�R�OBPS�BA'rT_ULL x. Address_ of p�r'oportent and representative (if applicable) r far__C.Q]� I. ra S Uri NC1wa r�c3 fi t a im Jr'awer 51715 3753 Aven�]e Chico,,_ CA ,1)5927 Chico. CA 55926 fi Project desc''ri.ptian Use Permit and',Rez©ne I: _ r. j _ t l MANDATORY IrINDINgS OI~, SICNI;FTCNNCE YES MAYBE NO a. Does the protect have the potential, to degrade the quality o f the environment, substantially recluse the haL-'tat ibf a fish or titild].i.fe, species, cause,A fish or wild<lifo population to drop bell-W self- sustaining 1;bve7s, threaten to eliminate a .Plant=o_r animal community, reduce the number or restrict the range, or a tare nr endangere:d plant or animal or eliminate important examples of the major --eriods of California history or prOhistory? b. Dees,the project have the potential tO achieve short-term benefits to the detriment of' long-terAi, cri�*ironment�a goals? (A short term impact on th�:� environment is one which occurs in a relativelV brier period of time while long;-term impacts will VV endure into -tile future.) C. Does the project have linpacts which are individu- ally limited, but cumulatively cptsiderable? (A project may impact on. two or more separate resources where. the Impact on each resource: is relatively small, but Where the effect of the total aC those impacts on the environment i,s sight ic,ant.), ,, ! d. Docs the project iravd environmental effects Which wiii cause substantial advorsd effects on human beings, either tii.'rectl.y or XndirectlY? I11 ; I)VI:lt tNA' ION ('i,o ba completed by the Lead Agency) On the bast7 of this initial ev�5luatior1 lllsvl find the proirosed project COUIX NOT have a significant enfe.ct oft the environment, and a NhGA'I'IVE I*CI.AItAT1ON will. be prepared, t/wE fi►td thw, although the proposed project could have a signirlt Z'arit o;rrect or, the environment, there will. Trot be a sil;nificah-t e t`Ceit i n thi Laso lige �:tt�so the MITIGATION MliA6UtttlS des yr ibed an the att chod ehcet havo boon 00ded to the p'rojec`t, A Ni:(ATIVII DI:OI.ACIA "TON Witl be pr'eparcd, :I/wI, find the proposed; project MAY have a : 1gni ricant e f feet on the eny ironihollt, and an IiNVIi2ONt<i-NTAL ,INIPA0,`P I2iWOA'V is toCjt1i1'ec11 bAlli JUIV 22, 1987, COUNTY 017, BUTTE, PI.ANNINO M1,11AIVINI'INT La>ffa M 1e Associa P� �illter Itry i ewed lye, r • ENVfRQNMENTAL IMPACTS 1� xp anat.ions a a r► n ►, on attached sheet(s�), yes and- maybe'" answers" are required 0 1. EARTH. will the YES prapasal result 'in'significant:'' a.—Unstable earth MAYtE NO ; conditions or in changes in _ geot- o _gic substructures? b. Disruptions, displacements compaction or -.r - 'soil? overeoverin �F g o.. the C. Chan$e•iri topography or surface:` ground relief features? •�': y H,: '... ,. d. �iestructa.on, cc,vena.ng• or moeiificat,kQn of any ' unique geologic: ._.d.. '�..� or physical £ea.tures? e. ,Tlicrease, in tvirid or water erasao n tof soils, either on �.. or off-•site? _.._. f. Changes in deposition ox. erosion of- beach, sands,' or changes in siltati-on, deposition Or eros,ian which may�modXfy �the. channel of a river` or stream or tae -ed. •the ocean,or - any bay, .inlet or• lake?•*: • g. Loss of prime .agricul tiurall ►- outside prjyciuctive . soils designated urban areas?., . .. h. Exposure of people or property -t,o geologichazard"- q. sliders'groundsfailhr"euoresimll'n:dslides, mud-• ; -, ar hazards? 2. AIR. Will the; propasal result in suibstantial - .+ a: Air . emissions or deterioration of aanbient air - quality?,, ., b. or creation 'of objectionable odors, smoke fumes?' c: A1terotion of air movement, moisture, or `-""" tempc+rature, or an change in ----- climate, ,locally-- - or regionally-? 3. WATER. kfxll the proposal •"result in substantiai 4 T--Changes in currents, or the Course ar' direction of water movements in either ' marine or fresh waters? b• Changes in absorption rates, drainage. """" patterns, or, the rate and amount of surface runoff? c Need for "'---• off••site• surface drama •- g. improve- merits, including vegetation " removal, channel- iza:tion or culvert installation? d Alterations to the course or tloty of "flood watersl e Change ill the amount. o"£ surface water in any water body? p -'• a f. Discharge into surfarce- graters2' , o-- alt ration of - ` surface.1dater ualit q y, including N but not limited to' tempei^a are,-,d'jssa�.'ved oxY$eri or hutbid ty'1 g. Alteration o£ the direction or tato of ` of ground Waters h. Change in th.e y. of ground Wad. quinti Cy cir qual,yt rs either thrbUi h direct additions or With— drawals, or through intercepti on off' an by GUts o aquifeV r excavations] i. Reduction in the amount of Water otherwise available £ot public water supplieso txpbsure of people or propErty to zrater related hazards such 1s flooding? YES. MAYBE' NQ 4. PLANT,,L?IEE.. W,3-11 the proposal result in substantial: a: Zha`pge( in the diver's%ty Of spee,i� s , or number of any spec.ses" of planus, (including trees, shrubs, grass, crops,, and aduatic plants)? b. Reduction, of the numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species of plants? c, IntrodUc^cion of new species of plants into an area, or in a barrier to the normiil replenish- .m rt p � of exist.ind species. d. Rent educta,ori in acreage ultu o£ an a ric ral crop? y g _J S. ANIMAL theresult in substantial: ' LIFE. tilld erproposal g sity of species, or number; o£ any species of animals b rds; la��d .animals ` ( ' including reptiaes fish and shell fish, benthic orgahisms or. insects) ? b. Reduction ,in the numbers of anyunique, rare -- or endAngered species of animals?. c, Introduction of new species of animals, into .� an area, or re0u:lt in a barrier to the :migrat,ion. "+ or movement of -animals?', d., Deterioration til existing fish or wildlife habitats 6. NOISE.Will the proposal result in substantlai., . ses in exisrl�irtg no levels? b. Exposure of people to severe ;noise levelif 7. LIGHT Ajwb GLARE. Will the proposal. produce significant light and ,glare? � A.., a LAND USE..Wi Il, the pr0posal result in a. su stan`tial alteration o.,5 the present or planned' 17 .land use ofan area. 9. NA'IOMM L RESOURCES., Will the proposal. result ,in sustantia1 i ai Increase in the rates of use of anY naturae retburces? ` b4 Depletionof any non-renewable natural resources 10. RISK OF, UNSET. Will the proprosal involve: a- A risk of explosion or the release of hazard- ous substances (including, but not limited to, Y o�.l pesticides, chemicals,radiation) in the event of an accident or set conditions? u `o b; Possible interference. With an emergency response plan or emergency evacuation plan? _._ Ili' POPULATION. Will the proposal alter the location, a'strib Tori, density, or ;growth rate of the human population? 12. HORSING. Me ttie proposal affect existing tfou5ing, of create a demand for additional housing? 3 ,� �� �...,. NO .. YES MAYiS ' l 'TRANSPORTATXGN/CIRCULATION. Will the proposal e result n: e a:. Genexation of substantial additional vehi�cl; �y movement'? b Ef;ects on existing parking facili�As,or ' -- demand for new parking? Substantial impact on existing transportation ---' c. systems?.. Significant alterations to I)resent patterns and/or of'" irculation olt movement ef'people goods?? ,..o e Alterations waterborne,, .� ;aa.1 or air traffic? . f, Increase in traffic hazards to motor vehicles; b1cyclists or pedestrians? - 14. PUBLI�G SERVICES, Will � the proptasal. have an effect altered upon,' or result in a. need for` new or. governmental, services: a Fire protection? b Police protection? --- C. Schools? cl Parks: or 'other recreational. facilities? _r._.. y- e t+laintenance of public facill.ities, including air o a d;s ?" f. other governmental serviced?' 15 . ENERGY Use of: ill the proposal result in: substantial amounts of fuel ,or enc=rgy �--- a b, Substantial aFncxease ir; demand upon existing or require the development sources of energy, of energy'? ---. - of:nGV1 sources 16. tTILITl�ES. Will the proposal result in a need for alterations to the n s or Substantial �4r sy stems, following `- a. Power or natural gas? b. Communications systems? - ____. -Xv c, iV��ter' a•vailal�%`l ity , . JQL C d+• Si. -Wer or sept. tank?' e. Storm. water drainage? --' f. Solid 'waste and disposal? 17, FIZJMAN HEALTH. Will the proposaldr ntia health hazes p 1 �. Creation of any health hazard (excluding mental health)? Exposure to potential health b, exposure of people 18. AST #ETIG_S Will the praposaI result in the AETICon vista or view open to :. .� o s of any scenic or will the proposal result xt the the public, creation of an -offensive site open to ublic mew? to, P i7VSCUSGI �_ T QM AP 66 bN OF �fvfV'IROiV�ICINTAf fLVA UA I ` ^•0$-s6,e etc. l b, c e Jhie but k of the Idisrupt;i: on and compaction on the property Fins fat!]i t i es. An additional 21 ®0 square feetar^k i n'g 1 of and Go f courae alread,- occurred with construction of't" const�,ruct i on of the new will be compacted` 1 th golf cart storaesa, Conversiorj Of the existing ` golf course' storage to a members ° 1 ounce will not reseal t in any addjytional overcoverino. 10: Aiken so i 1 S on s i to have a moderate to 1"i'l gh y of^, Erosion is accentuated by the high ralr"hfall rate; ?0 lnchpo ennually. Erosion is of eor~cern a 1 ong the smal 1 creek/swal a on `the i�sest side of 'the ciubh',ouse facilities. The�drai,nage plan. rcy c _qi d re' d under Item 3 -ha1 1' i ncorporate eros:i on cortitr^ols i ons'. ,; prove i Sb, #?be: New construction on the clubhouse facilities, isnot expected to .ge S gi_ ..aerate a sUSstantial amount of drainage. Whit f be acc:otromodated i n file sma l 1 cr�;sek /swa l e i maned i ate l y 'to the ratbd west. can golf -OUrse parking 1 cat to tha aa.st w i 1 1 re to i � � The q r PrepAarait i on of . j dr-. i nage 'n l an , approvs. h by the papartment of - Pc.lb l It Work i, and l' nsta l 1 at i on of the requ i red fac 1 1 1 t i es The requ 1 rLrrieh-b fol- ,;a g p made a condition of the Use, Perini t,. drains a tan will be '#c : Remnants of the `.original Pine and Cedar' forest over the r �ti dge ss'ti11 remain on the fr:itioes of this property. The aPPlldant has requested that mature trees be ,allowed to remain along the east side of the park i ng r 1 of property a standard "*Urban" iE1h,dScaP Urban"E3ndscap i nW. s an a1 terh,et i ve to f nstal 1 at i oh of 5d: Retention of the existing trees'is likely to Provide hab i t'�st. for b i'rds In the f mmed i ate v i c e n' ty than would urban lands lands,capin.g. storaExpansion o£ the ubhouse facilities and 'cart e will marginally increase noise levels on site: The greatest chaMOe in the noise environment will 1nvolvle the location of tfe new t farther north and cart storage. It is approximately feewest than 6 hy other existing building hOw on site. Adjacent residential uses to a he northwest may be affected by the 'increase in ,activity in noise In order to protect surround i hg residential uses; the i�ae Per -mi 't w i 1 1 be conditioned to require closure on storage buiIdlrig. the north side of thecart8 The present land use- of a golf course and; rel be i ntens f i en}� { f. these m i cs are approved c The proposa I conn w l s ated face i' 1 core for►»s er to the present. land use on site and 1S compatible with surl^ouhd "rid 1 ohd uses. tfc. ex'i st i rig G The, iRe26ne f f^om' R_C to RT -1 l^I i !'1 br i ria ti7e tore )no Into conformity With thOtoning" d i ehera l Plan des i e -hat i on of Low .Dehs i:ty Res l dent i a'1 . The . e triet permits gblf courses and related facillt►ps with approval of the appi-bpr ate perhi i ts. Appl i cant: Saf8rj C ?0rpr�r.s�t,ori AP U, 66-08-36-36., 4,0',,4-1, ;i Log # 87-06-1-6-02,0?1 File' # 87--48 DATA SHEET A. Pr off. eat D6gcr ipt cir, 1 ` I. Type of Pro,je�: „9 -Use, Permit and Rezone. 2. Brief Description: Use Permit to allow the expansion of a pre-ex i st i og nor►-conform ng 'Use to a 11 ow 1 ) a members' lounger 2)'a sign in ;the required front yard setbacks 35 parking on a parcel across the street on property under the same ownership $ 4) compact park i;;ng spaces, 5) use of alternative 1 andscap i ne and Redone from ,R-C `to RT-1 . 3. Location: The northwest and southwest corners: of An Drive and South Park Drive, Paradise Pines: 4." Proposed Density of 'DevelopinentZ Construction `of an addJtional 32110` square feet of building area, approximately 1009 expansion.f. 5. Amount of Ympery % bus Surfacing". Approxi mate 1 y' 75x of the 2.82 6. Access and txearest i'u'al i c Roads s ? = Properties front on Andover DriVe and Park drive, 7. Method :o+` S�ewag® Disposal;.: $optic system and leach 1 1 nes . 8. Source of !ulster Supply= Del 'Oro ''Water Company 4. Prox i m ItV df Pcwor Lines:, To original property. 10'. Potent i,al further land d1tvisions and development: Nin `lmal Phys J ca l End.` Ij,ni- `^ 1. 1 .. Tears l n a. ' Ce'nera II TopbIgraph Id Character: Upper ridge tan-d : b4 sl rapes = 5-69 generally i' n a southwesterly direct-Ion. C. Elevat X2360-2400 feet above Sea Level: ,on= d. Limiting Factors. None. 2 . Sol l s. a TYPes and Characteristics. Aiken SeHass moderately slow tpermeability o slow , Well dra l n i rig, mod i Um to h i gF eros i on hazard, h i' 9h l y suited to t l mber produ;:t`i on greater ..than 60'" deep. b., Limiting Factors: Erosion potential ' 3. Natural Haards of the. Land � a. Earthquake Zone; Modetsate Class VIII. b. Erosion Potentials Moderate to high. C'm Laridsi l de Potentl al , Low. d r" 'ire kbt8rd i: H l oh c. Exparlsivcs Soil Potential= Moderate-. i 4 ', Hydral dgy, a'. Surface Water: Small swa l e feed i ng 1 nto '9utte Creek 1`'�on f.Vl the clubhsproperty.: Groundwater: N/A � c`. Drainage Characteristics: Natural swale to the west of cl ubhousef property, man-made fact l i ti'E :s a1 ang South Park Drive. d. `' AnnuaT Rai'nfal'l(normal ): 70". e' Limiting f=actors: Lack of underground urban storm ijrainage system. 15- v�� .,ual ,/Scenic 'Dual i ty: Mature stands of timber at edges of property are scenic.. 6. Acolist,,�C Quality: Moderate to fair. 7. A I r Qua,l ity: Good 8. ` VQgetat)or,�e Pine and Cedar forest wi�.h mini mal native understory�ljintroduced 'landscaping 9. and grasses. W i l d1 1. f Hab t tat": Poor. .Cultural Enyjronme: 10. Archaeological'and } iistarical Resources in the area: Any resources nt have been comwromised by extensive construction arias use of Property for parking. 11. Butte County General Plan designation: Low pensity Residential. 12. Ex'i string 2dn i no: R-C and RT'-- 9 13. Exlstin6 Land Use an-si'4a: AP 66-08-zs6, clubhouse facilities;; 66-08-38, 14. vacant; SSG-03-4p and 41� golf course parking 1oti Surrounding Area: a. Land Uses: Single -Family r0:i0dential, commercial an file east side of The Skyway. b. 2onin90 R-'C, RT-10 CC. gnati. ns- c Gen. Plan desi 4 p Grazing, Low Density Q and en Res i dent i a l, rCommero- i.a i d Parcel Sizes: Urban shed lots. e. Population. Low to medium densities. 15. 16. Character of Site and Area: Paradise Pines commun i t Nearest 1Z. Urban Area: Town of Paradise, 3 miles sauthv Relevant S hetes of Influence: Town of C'a'radise, Qct! ord Water Company, CSA 4. i'8 Im rovemenStandards ts P rds Urban Area: N/A 19- I= i re Protection Sera ,ice. a. Neeai-est County ('State) Fire Station= Stations 33, 34 and Within 6'3-mile radius. b. Water Avail ab i 11 ty: Hydrant 'on 5l te. 20. School s in Area; Parad i ;se Un, 1 f i ed Schou i "D i sire i et. 1 1 11 �nninJ t^.o,m ApW i i aat anfor, se Poe -mi y �� Pat -C ]. No. Q --+dor N 13 �? y :rg.y 0 y • 441,10 2 1907Oro wale c Calitgtrnfs Tho existing sit -6 i e the Par Edi sp Fi Cerres. Ga� � Gaur"dC;- �1eti vi ty Centel-. it i;s ] acated art dry Appe o,ti mate v, r ', at t)le, nartheast tomer Of: 8auth hear4 Dt-' Ye and i,Jndaverl`» "rho topooI� �tphy `iris fay: topprcr.e;iinriely 11erCt-nt siCes sai stsaf p ne ,' �egetati c•3n cans y fir yrrd Cesar trl`e.es and m�tn�an,ta bushesw TltE a. etabx'e rtteri a wx th e„Cei i ertt ,'� drx n�tce the +; p ` .•.; _i nxfic�rtt � �t.t�tura�, y''�hi+atcrr-ica). crr•- Sceni.C" as e�ts are kt�awn , t6 The a�ioa by,1'ar�cti �� �'i ry�"zs r;n1 f . Gbtirsc» `sirrgla +amaly �Vi ` theThe oa iginat design i9 -F the arra � and its present ', functi.t;rrr featwees the calf tour. -,e i t "h�he , pr�imr ry rrecrea-IonaT. ;,.z�,�eriity.. 'The Cour se winc#s �sr`err��i� thrGi��gh -the waaded swales fIarrked ;bin al tides t;y cresidenk� ai X�t�h T. Oct raver percent a+ the course memberrti. ] S v� ary ad;�a�rrt lots. � a pra t opr f, ;{� 'i nen. Go!+ Cour se fac ,lz -ies bseryfi�y irw'r�x,itde T wrap s u�rrtt�ly i� st�uare feet 'j, restaueari,tt. . rt* i ma pprc;aimate�y 1�� g e feet, and airy ].i,t�+�ture fc�tyt az Car~t str�rage tttixding with 1000 SgUAre feet of r;ac�,l�.sido s�arag�, ''The i g dart pra,�ect' ,.�nvpi�es eretendin -the e,;3>' t�i�r�� if rear tge shed i (S6, X 214') by 1a' feet to form a '21,010 9 qa bLtiIding. Thh3s �hyei� t�r�auid �sgrtare fc►t�t herr be upgraded to ,-ttCr, mrt,adate Iran i Capt ed ri�strarrms and membor' lounge hdt �` �- thye —t Additionally,, tadd'itir�nai pr•Elsery�xy availob],e a X�+ " t t1Cs square feet') 'crew i go!+ Cart st%gage ph o'l lWould by ;ganstr��tt+~� ed ta: r�rp i acas the area lost. The new area of the members " 3bunc�e wr;.r) d +~raver an e;;isti nc, rauL-si de Concrete si fib, rased for golf Cart %tOria19ey Al I contburs and drainare Would rwr=trtain the sine., No tree; or Other vegetation etatibn Would be removed or distwl-bed,; Same lar'rdecdp4n9 would` be inrrr"eAzed. The exioting racif r pane, `and aidaryga wauYd e eprcrdr tcerJ to f P�m natural et�nt i nuati bl� of the, ,; i sts ryr ehvi r"trnntental l,y sohmi ti ve +chi texture. The nett' �- ci � 3 o tubi f aa,i � si:nra r_ bu_'1-dirt wau;l; d ,be �, aCatrad Along ,the dartheast side of •the gn"if rwartrse Cohter., ,then ]:t +� architecture +. dttp , c' to the, details of 't?ie pre�erit •r atx l i ti ea.. Apprr:.xmateiy oleYoh Aqrna] 1 pins+ fir, and Cedar treks wrrt.rld be r dmc�vrad S3tt �,Op0grvAphy�,and design have beech cpot"Oihated U:� rni.nimi.�;e the MuMber and ,ai4:,e of trees to bio m0ved and the quantity of ui,e^k, try be rrtoyod 0*4% 2rr �'j _ thin yar)��d:�)-• Tl�.t" btti.Zdirr� «� ^. y w M p I i5 w st.ra� i buf" .Ored .fr,�in •the public rd.Rd b trees and, Other Vf 0ta• idm and the, hi1;jtttt'ax C'OhtMtrie of the situ The new building mt�,�trtt to , r»t] y rept aCe the Clp,tci,ty rt'# the existing � ► squgre foot bui i d t hq and 10 06 squar7Q foat outs,ttle stCr�ge area e,; cepa All is t1a be �Ltnder^ dove+ in, the ' now f,.jai 9l i ty. Andr ana Dreifuss - z - 0 8 'P,.O. Claude M111lea.gue ; BOX 7000-148 $nh 751 Ann, Moxley Redondo Beach, CA3605 Magalia,,, CP 95954 r Maine Avenue Long Beach, CA 90806 66-08-02� �� 66-08--12 ' ,� 66-08-22 John g .Schle el :13926 Andover Leroy Bruns 4467 Toyon P.d. k ; Cliff ford S�thiles Magalia,, CA 9.5954' 9 Riverside CA '92504' 1-3375 Wingo St. Arleta, CA ;91:331 66--08-03 66-08"13 a w 66-`08-23 James Jackson P-0, Box 1697 William Pon bur g P.O. Box 1128 Harry Taylor Ma alfa, CA 96954, 5 Magalia, CA 8595 6499 Shaw Circle ;; Magalia, CA 95954 66-08-04 66-<8-14 MSA.vin Renou 66-08-24 O . Bax $ 81 �� alia g , CA 9554 Joseph 'Kallbr er l66 Muir Avenue , James Fazio Santa Clara:., CA 95051 14091 Skyway 9 Magalia, CA 95954 66-08-115, 4'j66-08-25 Richard BroWn William Benkosk: P.O. Box 99? P.U. Bax 514 ' George Rusinko agalia, CA 95954 Magalia, CA 95954 ' Pd() Box 15'69 Magalia, CA 959.54 66-a8-f6 C, 66-08-1.6 66-08-26 Marry irons John Girard 13940 Cascade P.O.-Box 644< Margie Dreher Magalia, CA. 95954 g Culver City, CA 9023b P-Oi Box 644 Magalia, tl CA 959.54 66-08-07 i 66-08-17 66-084.27 ? Joseph Penroti 18536 CasVade Drive John Woolfolk 13910 coria Ct. Oliver Brown ga�lla, Cry 95954 Magalia; CA, 95954 4 13905 Cascade 17r a �, CA 9595 r 4 Magalia, 66-0808 66-08-18 r q u. 66-08-2g ` John Aspinwall Pi, Box 8818 Quentin , Ritchey y X253 I�orzna Winkler Magalia, CA 95954 4 6130 Monterey ftlgr. San_+lose; CA 95138 13903 Cascade Dr, Magalia; CA '95954 66s-08x-09 ! 66-08-1;9 n 66-08.29 J'a os Darice 64:59 X ,ingsdale Ct. Wayne. Cushman 11.46 W. ' 187 Place John Myrtle Piagala a, CA 955546538 a, CA 9o24g 6533 c ysta5.'�, Spting s Sari dose. CA 951.20 66-08-10 65-�b8-20 G6-�08-30 !AkVina Gorman 6 150 Nevada No, 6 Scott Stephens 141.31 Coutol0ftc Rd. T2ob ext Crowder Woodland Hills y CA 91361 M49alia GA 95954 1-180 Bmpey Way. San Vose, CA 951.28 MU Vb 'L'wbq :tax-rr �56S6 VD 'O`F�ebew `C`8906 KO 'S'txeJ 'ettotkg �, .,, o- -'34 r 66-04 06 ri °,.... . . with Ethell. Victor BYmrose , 6 6 05'-C,9 t 1943 Drendel Circle Pa-rads se, CA 95969i P.O. Box 1527 Magalia, t, Eoosev°e1t '�Fcyrd 2218 rit.. wh:ietne CA x5954 D , s P.ttsb'urgo CA 94556' 66-08-35''66-04-07, etc. 66-05'-1,II . 1kxuel 'Vargas 1.3915 Andover Dr. Joe Canzaneri 23908 Carver Dr. � Exhange Eat.erprises �xazlia, CA 95954 Magalia, CA 95954 P'O' Rte;t �! f)04 66-08-36, etc." ; r Magalia, CA 95954 66-04-09 Savor Corporation � a{�er 5276 Donald Griffin 'Milton 66-05�3.9 Milton Chaco, CA 95927 Box 436 �° Magalia, CA 959 Molakides 1101 Needtham 66-X38-39 Vacaville; CA 96688 66-n4-•10 z ' ? 66�-05-.2Q 11ar'ora a Per 3 rosea T3903 So. Park Drive Delouie Gra P.O. Box 436 ' Donald Tablas �'�agalia CA 9595413866 - M.ag,alia, Cry 95954 Tulsa ct. 6°6--DS-42; . y a C.A 9594 Mac�ali.. r 5 66--04-11 �' 66�.Q5-21 Melvin Nesmith F.0 . Box. 1008 HarryHammond Ave lchael 081111S4ratan Magaijai CA 95954 F San Jose, CA 95128 13864 TUl.sa Ct. 66--0'8--43 1 Magalia;, CA 9'5954 66-04-12 66-Q3-pl. Charles Conrardy P G: Box 21.62 Charles Davis 1039 Longshadow � Charles Mosley snyvale, CA 94097 Ct. El Cajon, CA 9202.0 6730 W�ranc';.k Ct. 66-03-4.4 _. Magalia, CA 95954 66-04-13 66-03,-02 Melvin Car enter_ p 262.1 Buc7�eye Prod Thoerner i , Lorraiq New port Beacji, CA ,92660 13882 Cascade. Dr. Magalia, CA 95954 Fain 39997 Codas 1vcl., #253 6;6-08-45 z Newarkr 'cA 94560 66-0;-0'3 iatyrence Ra ley P' G„ Bax 501 E, Anderson 1.3873 Andover � Farris Carter %Iagal.a, CA95954 Dr. Magalia, CA 959.54' � P,O. Box 114 66-09"46 Magalia; CA 55954' G6-05-02, etc. 66°-03-04 LaWrence Vittori 13899 80. Park Drive McKelvey Smillie Norman P* Magalia, C1� 95954g P.O. Bax 1842 B'urx Ln aMe CA 940lo r rbstor! A 1��,Fi3 So Park br Magalia, CA 9!5951 6G-0�"-03 6605-Q 66°-0`3-05 Gilliam Davis Poi- Eox 9011 l�tdgalwia, Augusto Baltiyut l6z William yut way Michael Pl,atko CA 95054 Pittsburg CA 945.7313879 So: Park Drive ;aga1 ia. CA 95954 8666 �O 'oo;r�0 y Prig' 84 y 0►�9 �s 'E�ip1t°CA.,TtFI� �riEa1 - �3iD��R1��HAiiYtHAC��19AlS. — _ v. ,. ^ Srx%a Dira�r.. 57Fi a;N;a�rsd�r. Ca. X95927 ��( WWC1-c�a, I:) spitLFw �..'.(.ftit�(� i NMr CRs On how "d ilia �qC Fr:�logopt shgv�thgg' res wham dde0q dt tleGwdry ALI �a.8/7 OF Inter-Departmental Memorandum; C TO 'Butte County Assessor's Office FROM: Butte County Planning Department SUBJECT: Safoz Corporation_ ' DATE: October $', 1987 Pursuant to section 65863.5' of the Government Coda, the following identified dentified as 66-08-36 38. 40 41were: Rezrne ftom to zoning district: X Granted a variance to the, Parking Ordinance to allow 3 spaces to be double pull through and, the tots], spaces to be 74 including doubles w;th.no more than 20% compact measuring 8 it. x 16 ft. X Issuuse to allow � wa m�mbera_lour�F,ti, a. signeinatheorequiredlsetbackrmit parkingona parcel across the street on property in the same ownership, compact parking spaces, and use of alternative landscaping. UsE PERmit vT.e COUNTY PLANNING irDP�ff:r'���ON Odtoter 8, .,19111 ,. DATE a (Cert t ft ed Mal 1 Retrt, . ) P�ERMXT NO. ( AP _ 6b "08- x' 88. 4U . 41 { ASSESSOF-,'S PARCEL NO 1 tp4irsui,kit to the Prov i s i ohs of the , Zon i no Orfa d i nnce of the County Of - Utte and the special cgti'd l t Irons �4t forth below: SA#or` Corpori�ti�on' i=tt hnereby 9r'anted,, a Use y "Per(: i t i ri acoord'an�ce. w i th app 1 i cat i ori I 1"l edLi 6X4/87 for the expuns a on,," of t pre -pax i stl hg nonconforming use"d:b ,al 1 oj4 : rrbers 1 oy�n$e, a sl gn " i n the , ' requ r+ed 'setback , ar~k l no onL s parbQ.i : oss the gtrect on pr,+opera: 1n the game, +;�wnershi tsar^king >� pu compact aces and 45 r:rna .i ve 1 Andscap ii ng on property -,oned R_C and W-1 1 oc ited ht the northwest andr southwest corner of Ando" Vor Drive and South Park Drive, Paradise Pines. f`I Fai1ure to comply with the conditions spec(�)idd herein as the basis foil approval of oppl iicatloo and issuailde of Permit,, '1 const l'tL&s rause for- the revocst i on of said perms 1 t In accordance with the procedures set forth in the Butte county Zon i no Enab 1 l no Ordinance,. 2.. Un l-ess othe'rrwi se provided for In a condition to a `use permit, all condi t i ons must be com.pl et -ed by the pQrm 1 ttoe w i th i ;p 12 months` of the del" i' ryv afi the countersigned Permit to the permittee - �f any use for which a use permit has ibeen granted 1s not establisshed within one year of`the0 of retielpt of;.the counters i greed permit 1xy the permittee, the , \perm 1 t sha 1 f be come Mull and void and i^eappl i,cat i on sho�l�l„`wbe requ i red to estab l :1 sh. 'the, ,.use ri ' _ t -gPECX'AL CONDITIONS= CAP 6-S 3b. nage easemdtit now coveri,t,c'�fie { ropel^t+ dra t na 1 � tarrnal 1 y abandon the ` Mofit the roqul remen'bs of the Dopart:meht' off` �;publ l c Warks for dra1naoe. Comply with roqu i roni�.ihts of COIF as ti,,atod In the Me tto dated Sepl,ember 170 198? rrom John Hawkins addi rig th(e ql l o00 no e « Adequate vont l' 1 t ion ; eXH. q §ust system whether machanlcaf it 1, p!F q C>" Y +x '�l IT 71r�-,FA� n r Ir r c, b: Oute i dd gel ectrl coal shL. toff far battery 'chprgers� old i l y lent r.��"la�ble,� Storoge of 6c3iarts,)aftQr 5 years. r flammable. 'br �cambust 1 b e meter i-al s stored i t bu except, what i s i1 n the cavi: > e. Dior:--combust i b t e roof . <1 f . Outside shutb f f for L-P-G C i!f proV IS tons of` the, 'Park I n Ord t n ces .,exc t than of F?, the spacr3s shall be,double 'pull through and that the fatal v� 74 space i ncl ud i ng doubl es, shlal 1 be an acceptabl e� var i ince to the parkin OC'c'r f nanpb ' and ho more than ,�20,i shat be', " ompact measur it ig An hew curb cuts, onto, Y Souti; Perk pr+ `Andover Drive to, meet w t th the 8PProlra l o f the "PhP Works. �. arttriertt of Pub1 l c 6. Fence the ,southwest 0i 6per ty i'.rriA \w 1 th s 1 ght' obscur i no 6 ft, fence wi oero i borders th'� res i dint i al ot. 71 C.r nnect lounge to appy' ovod sepia ge d i spcsal, systemInstalled ' for ex,pans i on. (�' I, 'O Connect to ma,lure z Doi;, Oro Dater f qtr ddtrte�st;1 c �t�ter source. 9.4 11 t et 1 n pees ovef Pr operty as ars alternative to . standard \t�ur� Jt�C�'• 1 andsc�# � ing . 10. Arte dsedthe� �``e4t811 of tea cart story ge shs11 be c6mpl1etely. ., no larger doors pbrm1ttd� Alocal rant must also comp l Y' w 1 th n l 1 other ) app, 1 cool a State arici statutes, ordlnancesr and regu.latlons t hereby declarm-)under pet:dltY of , per lurY that I have read;' the, #orogding condltions that they are in fact the „cohd tions which were imposed upon the grant1h&�,,'of'this us0 permit and that I agree toab1de fully by sa i d candt t1 �aii-; �„ t� Dated.' APPi y cant o NG tt . x asuance of this Use Pev'-m 1 t does hot waive requ remet,t of , obtaininsa eUi1ding and Health Department permits before starting c mstruci ion , nor does It waive any otheo requ i ro►nehts CC! Dopila; of Public World (x) 81.ktt1it County Planning Commission H641th bepartmont Cita i rmah I? i rt~ht clt of rok0try „ V'A141ANCE COUNTY PLANNI G eM I SS I O, NS ertrtser � I?,A7E'� Ce No. c ` C„ AsSCaSOR *S ,Pdi2t~'L t�iU. �'ursuant to of ,#;c g Ord „ ,�•t Prow i s ions - �'1e �� Bwtte n i n I hc3nCe p� � ` and Spec, I a3 ootid i t i r5ns' he County- � her^eiay granted a ftarth : be +w ara4"ar Cow a' Y , 'to the Park - or' anoe� i t� at c,ordance w lr P rt�ti ©r� t s and the- ''c tal IPrdilnarrrwe td ;et.ld�tl+f' s,. h a . _,.t R 1hrou paces the r ace to be 74' ih l uci tai e� thr° nem com sct 'masts b g X 16, ft. on , prt Perty� armed f2� W e' than 200 , nrrrr-tth�west and s(, u hwes�c cnr , prrs e� C taaci R Dplve Parodi so pines.1 located /lredbver• fir l ve and 'South Park j SOECIAL iCOWITION5: > , see Use permit 487-68 for eoriip i t i aril I hereUv d - ec1 are unr_Ier penal ty,, of forego i rig °^and i t: dt1� perJuryr thatc) z have were impc+s�� upon the that the read the Y are i n fact th`� sand i t l ens which granting of.•tkiia varltince� Aird that I 'y .by said cendi�;i > I ,�agrae to ati r 'tie. fu Dated ; ; L. `)• z ° - Ap i,:I Cklh#' I ssr.ranae h f----- iii1l5 Var"`ianrr does r'e uirement' of obtainih efoCruiidn not WQive Department 8 and t��a l th nor does it Waive tartyhcather requi am ntsre nstrr.r�rti do 'Chsi � Butte. County Planning Comm i s -.O cin CC: 00partltte h t Of Pwb i It Works, t 2 Health 0000 3rtMe3nt l�epdrtment of u ,r } tte PLANNING COMMISSION 7'COUNTY CENTER DRIVE . OROVILLE, _ALIFORNIA 95965.3391 Sa'for Corporation, PHONE., s38.760� p Drawer 5.176 September 28, 1987 Chico, CA.. 95927 CERTI#-TED MAIL Re; Use , Permit/Variance AP 66-08-36, 38, 40,, 41 Gentlemen: We are enclosing the original and one copy of otir, Permit No. '87 -6.8Y - allow for the Y of a pre-existing conditional. Use , nonconfox:ming++use to allow a members expansion lounge, a sign in the required p parking spaces and us ownersh�.p; compact p i e of alta p � y landscaping ,. setback Arkin on a parcel across the street on roperte in ti'1.t same and Varz�cn;a No. 88-o to the Parking Ordinance to a11oW spacestobe double pull through and the total spaces to be 7.4 incl,.iding doubles With no more than 207. compact measuring 8 ft, x 16 ft, on property zoned R -C and RT -1 lcoated at the northwest and southwest corner of Andovet Dxive and South Park Drive, Paradise Pines,, be Doth copies must signed and returned to this department within 30'days from the receipt, of this let-tere will then have them vol' idated by the Chairman of the Butte Count PlanningCommisaYon and the original will be returned to you for your records. please be aware that failure to return -Z.he signed cop es Within 30 days will result in the use permit becoming invalid,. Re-application to this tIpartment Would then be necessary, to pro j ectproceed With the ,, The Use .hermit is deemed granted When 'this permit has been signed by the applicant, With 'the counter signature planning Commission; andof the Chairman of the ; said permit is received by the applicant by registered mail, Should YOU have any questi6t,8 regarding this matter this office between, 10!00 a.mi, and 3.00 p m, � pease contact 5inc rely �.rche:°r b11 ttttor of Planning Roc, , , .k . r'-,. ,. 1 N CO) InEl CIE 'rI RMs WQ.'fY'T-CJ"1 �p = Office of, Planning anti Buti'e ,t;oun.ty - 1400 Tenth street,. sacramento. CA 95814 ■ , Plant ing 1)epartinlent, 7 County Center Dvi viLi or SEP 2 3,11987,0rovihle, CA 059,65, XXXX County 'Clork CANDACEi.GRIl8i35,(3ufteco, Cie�k County of 'Butte By. MERC! S�TY3,T•"c�'�CM Filing, of Notice of Determination compliance tirith section 21108 or 211,57. of the Publito c ;Resources Code. Pr Title jeAP li Name Use Permit APJ'66-08-36,"38, 4t), 41 8afor Corfaorati on (i# submitted touCleariner Contact Person gtiouse) To lepFione Number B.A. KZRCHBR; Director (910 538--7601 Project Location_ At. thee, northwest and southwest corner of Andover Drive and South Park Dr ve Project nescriptionUse Permit to allow 1) 1;;, 5 Pansion of pre-existin noy- conforminguse to allow a, members lounge,' 2) A sign . in .the required .betback 3) Compact on a parcel es F, b) �hesireet on AropertY tin ih� s�e`nwnersha:�, 4) Compact parkii g states,. 5) Use o�f alternative landsca in T . is to advise that the Butte County Planning Commission p g Thi -,4 (Lead Agency of Re8poh8iblq Agency) has Opproved the abo re -described project on September 17, 1987 and has made (Date) the follpt Jing determinations regarding the above-described project: _ 1 . environment. wa l.l, twill not }lave a sighif icat t` Tile Project X ---�-� ► ' a.rfeot on the 2An }'nvi ronmental impact. }tepoet was ptapared for this Project Pursuant to the provisions of C8QA. X A N09dtive Declaration t4a8 pzepared rot thir,, project ti tx+suaht to the provisions of CRQA, 3: Mitigation measures were, x Wit,+ar'e nt5t;'riiadCd i Ctltidi.tiiin of the 6 PPtoval of the proj;a 4 A st itemunt of overriding, considerat•iotIs X ,,watt, � eras noL. adopted for this pr'c►jr.ct. This is;. y to rc)t t it;, that the final Lilt with cohlmentr,111(1 t;;periNes ¢tnL iej:oVd of t)roiect atspr;)vat: .is avail,ablo to the general public at.: butte County Planning Duptirtinrjnt 7 County Contar 'Drive; Orovillai to 05965 bate Rece x vod rot' Filing and po.q t i ttg at., S -F;itGit: tir. � stepher A. Sirre0ter 0 8eni6r planner hrvikod iJ jreti 1086 tw � E 9 Ld�triDr, !r Ci 1 Hn n ✓ 2 Y CCumhe1h D��, B en Be, �� NUI w 1 nJd u' a ttaa'gCl. ;�,\ 9^+he y�aln g D 4 L t4 or, 3 - nein � f«+td nr. t. n n. E�tell{ 5 W fern } U i ViuUr„ eCM10 Coln 0 * Af , > ': �4binMA"e• � ..w«r:w^Gil. +c.� ��.a. ej,t+`,�4r' �A.':\•I. ,« .,.,.-M.��+ �ra:+:.�} +�>+a4}f�o�� ...r..w; i� ....,.+.w.nu.., _ e + � .Inr cold Riot All f { q dan Hill n` �``—• a'I Y. �;,�> 'Psr .r q qs !•a, p •p �r \�i�.°. oaf' � a + � y r�'. `q e' q �' `�"6 ��r'� .. �� �?i• v'+'!• iiw C' 1 ° u ,,�YY{� Q•. ��,aio'A 1 h+ti'�tl t �' U V Co` a � 1ut� y _' � . 1 n �, �4 t t ' �r M ��o �• �i 4 R � 4 � to wit �� . Gla t � t' � p •L X11, w4i n� P, 1.. VWi Pula La QO �' A Arse I I rErw CG. # rv>,e n wtr ` rs ai,4 err:e3 a , d 1 y'f 4s kC{ft n.e....,,rq nf �� '�� r `told 3;LI 'S �%LLi SS w y 1w, 0� G a Eq t1t r ' ,���l E§{ t. Intleh MAIGA 1A I', qR rlfjtrooJrNW1e{ t tuna C hl oar �A tj �� V r � V+ ne;ll.l r @ 3 I glpnEVIENI ' Iv .,� Ch � �Gffoa o bn1eV 1 0 hall nag4 ,ry v. $ rn 1 r wii ci. q"+, 4 , cr, n "veiralll` nl l� � e € � v • : , 1 --S Pp. e m ! Hnpgysucklo No WAV Z b�lmllh .� [ENtRV14LE awns,:aw,u.+x•,w«9 E ,...aw»•... p,w..»el«,..'w+x..ryai p a�*'G"�' CEM',. °IY. lb y', r Q. {y till cpr. F i/ JCN to, Fmev ludo, PARADIS Mtn flf1. a f, J..r.r c 13,nn 5ulirke tl e w / a' t ��. Ottli �.. a fl �i�l t Fr I Ni ' J O 31: CA.�a1' : ¢ 4n Atliar., A A V',ewWr �`1 \ti a � ur11w W,r 1yy. Icuq,inmh' �: � : �: � w+�+w. y,.,. ., I J - _s � , 11' CC`s 1 •� f , j �o'. i a le � �E' ,� n, ylml'ar d'. .. �, :i i a f 1 � l( �' � � , t ,�.- eu .I �xV� „�"�..—...i a� '4.� �p Ib fi°dr r r •r+' V ' +a �' � 5 � , C r , t a ,'.'. Killdiili •rye � 1� Ile �F 1 +„.Ilc t���M � YfMW r. It tlutlll�t r�� 4 tnyn �I a, 1 II}Inn as �tw tt ' , e/ l EIiVAT10N a+ J� iml4d1Jyr �5�" r l y �Yuferr i d r� +1 1 t o f p ' 9 n, �;4 h" 1 M1 13 'r 4 Y« • 7 ,s I n h•S�. Y r 1 orti tw o f ,'. 2 1 ' A j II,�r46n fP4� �'� NIIII ,41t o f Mons � � � i� � Mr L. 5 r�1 ��X� "ISS a � ��clt� kw�� �, vAdll:/ +ryyi Wa Zan t5 LI< �r+ltn� 59$ SC 0, t" m a a rt ` y�Ci VIRf rntrA is r r rc� i n� IrC1Ah + l t y «a j r f91tl Aml Iml_. } v vw,in�r f¢itrh .. l4MlaiM« I 1 I Inter -Depar thental Memor",andum Me. Planning CommissiQn FROM: St SU S BJECT;afor corporation Use Permit, AP 6E-0$-36 DATE: June 17 1,087 The Safor Corporation had appliedfor .a Use ;Permit to etc and storage and construct a members lours e p golf ,cart course. At the regular, Planning Commission meetingaof MrchP2?es gtllf + , 1987, Specific the item was continued to June 24, 1987, to resolve a nur;ber of issues. ally, construction was y wa.thott: benefit of a variance. Suff acientlpa'kinghin nwas not shown tb �nnt and setbacks on site Plant and some of the spaces that were shown were sized compact oars: far, the The Parking Ordinance does not. specifically smaller parking r y Provide for the property out �as�asdrainage easement, the horwhichlnoubbuvision map set ' could be issued. ilding permits After working with staff` Sa Per to allow: for Corporation has a I- Expansion of a g ppliecl fora new Use construct a members lounge, and enlarpistin nonconfc.:ming use to prp- ge car Place align i the required front yard setback (exsin)Calies 2, required off-street parking to be located on a parcel across the Allow an property in the same Ownership; h sheet of native vegetation and trees .A lieuaof thect kstng andaaces 5 requirements. Use A rezone a rd Use clubhouse PPlication has also been filed on the Property from R"C (Resoeliminatdurce Conservation) to RT -1, the The fronteyardl setback, The RT -1 zonisatback and need for variance to the setback, and allows ng district has a 50 foot front yard golf courses upon approval .;t a Use Permit: SafP Corporation Still needs to apply' drainage easement cov:o,ring the ro eri. for an abandonment of the abandon the easement in order Pd tyobtahey areare of the need'to applioation is ecpected shortly,building Permits, An a rezo Because of the substantial revision to the. Use Permit, and lncl et the project is how stubject to environmental reviews usion of Use Permit application is also going through the pr�.,-,�,.�The new process, Under the best of circumstances the P ication before project st; tr•. td be back You in its modified form by early August. Recommendatzoh: Cnnti.nU,e the hearing forw other hearings fard to August to consider, at the time of the or 5afor, whether to vacate this hearing or act _LMT:Ir on it, cc: 56for Corporation I i u�,3 urystall springs IAS hbSSSEn San Jose, C? .95120 �� ��, Wd a FOR�I���il�i � � 14F `10 4. f7 77 7 CA NUAJ_ epeor, WIN;t'-w, 1, 7T 44 T21 14� , .4 C'v HT 11P-40,164, W—Fn4 77 00 THO 1�1 104 IT 4 Y!, rj�u b Ir -UL4 '24 .:,r IT LA el ej L4W 4c- IN[OL[ �r WH le+i 1q,_6" /Z 4 W,- -rc:� Ilk LAM MECK E j 4A 4 4.1 �A �7' �7. P>N -el d •fl. F.� n � � pROJECTiH�D 4 Safor Cbvporatxon ' SCSI # AP#66_,08-36, AP # s: p255 FxUE-� Log07-- J 30 Da} Review Period Ends, SCH Review 1 ,t Period COROS'PONDENCEt �,L—��� t ` A"� � � �y T.�r, � Y �r��� 'n 8� r 3� t��� it i�� ��'� '• . � �� �.. qtr r rFr. up , lrrp.,J ra 1 1,43 1 c F`Y;�.�� -1101, �f 56 T)ay Acv + " I �r r (3 k 1�' �' �� , 1111/ 15 , � �� , a1 r,.•, ri. Y�rPeTiO fir.. / r�t7q�.r,�.r�ra :�.1 "''L7L.L:l`Ilsl 1 N.11 1 { 1 Date Actio� w, ....,,,:. .�� ati .—�M- ►� 5 Q 7 pr, Ra�kets�„__sitePlan, Locn - --i----t�—er�” ...y. 87 Fi 6/1.7%87 TO f'Ce\ Mem Cdated Q17187 , r, v O Ir 1111 , ii .Safor Corr oration'- Use hermit tItem determined to be categoricallyexempt from environmental review) for expansion of a Pre-ex i st i ng nonro%i form i ng use to allow an en lArgement of- gol f course clubhouse Ci•Tities on property zoned R-C (Resource Conservation} l0catLo,;at the northwest corner of Andover Drive an. South Park Drive„ i i�erat i f ;ed his AR 66-08-36; Paradise P l nes area; north of, Paradise. <tont 1nued closed from E3/27./67) Safor l:orporat i on -- 1Oroposed Neaat i_ve Dec 1 ar. at 1 0 regard!ftg. en i ronmpst i ng -n-ntal ione. 1 mpf oac t +. and 'Use Perm i t to a 11 ow E�Nraht i on of a pre rm.i n6 Use to al 1 ow a membars' 1 ounge, a s_1 gn- i. r1 the required setback,'�parkinq on a'parcel across the street on Property in the same owr'iership, compact parking spaces, and Use of alternative lands.capinci"on property zoned R-C (Resource; Conservation ) and RT- l (M i,n i mum Dens i ty Res i dent; al Mob i 1 e Home located at the northwest and southwest coi^ners of Andover Drive and South Park Drive, identified as AP b6-08-36 38, g0, 41, P4, ad i se. ( Cont I nuedd C l used from 8/27/87 :Safor Corporat i on proposed 'Neaat 1 Ve `Decl arat ion regard i'ng env i r•onment impact and Retgn from R-C (Resource. Conservation) to RT-1 (Minimum Density;'Res- dental - Mob '11e Home) for property located on the southwest corner 'of South Park Dr've and And-Ver Dr i ve, i dent i f i ed,. as AP bb-0�3-31`;, 38, 40 , 41 , Parad` So P`i nes . ( F i l e 87-48 ) (Cont l nwed c 1 osed From' F/27/87 Staffstated that there was a memo 'from_Pubfic Works expr.Lessing concern about prohibiting Parking on a public road Public Works did not agree �o paint the 'curbs red; Staff subm i .ted a Inemo from :CDF recommending additional conditions with conditions 1, 2, 5, 6y 7 administered by 'P'ubl i c Warks and 44 administered by Pi' ann l og. Chairman Walter stated that the CbI i-onditions appear to be r4easohab1e Commissioner Lynch asked how they would enforce Condltion 4. Staff stated that after 5 years there were be no storage of g s carts Chairman Walter stated they were justified to requirei sigf't-obscuring fencing where this borders a residential l of la He d i scutmed al waiver on 5 pari< i t7g, spaces to allow for the put 1-through sparest Staff stated they _would have t.0 grant a Y blt4l ance to the Park t1ib standard: l t was moved by Comm i ss i oner Lynch, seconded by Comm l,ss i oi7ei^ L,-3111 ; and carried for approval of the Rdtohe as follows: :I A. f=ind that the requirumenis of CEdA have been completed anal considered In ttiak l rig th i ;s de'c l s i on and r+acommerid that the Soard of SuAery i tors adopt, a Negative Dec 1 ar^at i on ; an,d �llT,T +Y�%��i/. I.LiM,\\1i�i �0 NYf>.. ✓nJ'l+N4m- y�5 + „a C.ti ti lChLH'111`b M1 Vlr M �, i MMISSIOLl hfYtd[1TES ,eptehiber i�� Xi3g� �� �;�. •��iG�A�������� ., b. Au4side electrical shutoff for batterY chargers, readily identifiable. C. No :storage of gas carts after 5 ye ar s, d. No flammable or, combustiblematerials Mored in building (except what i s l n the cart t .. e. Non-combustible roof. Aut i de, shutoff of L-,P-G f i f' any on 4. Comply with prowisions'of the Parking Ordinances except�t;hat 3 of the spaces sha11 bedouble pu;l1rthrough and thet the .:total of 74 spaces, l nc l ud,i iig doubles, 'shal 1 be ao accept�3b 1 e Variance to the Parking Ordinance',' and no more than 20% shzll be compact, -, movaswring 8 ft. k =16 ft. ., Any new, curb cuts onto South Park or Andover Drive t0 inpet with the approval of the QePartment of Public Works. o. Fence the, southwest property line with sight-obscuring6, ft. 'fence wh,_-'re it borders the res !dent 1 al lot. 7. Connect lounge to approve sewage disposal system 11e°«sta'lled for 'I expansion. $.; Connect to bel Or'o Water for domestic Water Source. 9 SgllIb'ain mature trees over property as -an atternative to' standard ",Urban" 1 andscap l ng 10. The northern wall of the cart storage shall be completely :enclosed C .e..a no ;larger doors permittad). 114 Apel l cant must a1 so comply w t th 611 tither appl i czs i e State and local statutoso ordihandesi and regu'1aLiuns AYES: Commissl'oners Lambert, Lynch and Chairman Walter NOES: No one AOttrNTt Comm 1 ss 1 osiers Forbes and Peabody ABSTAINtbi No one T W Y tVTX PLANNING COMFt NtITE 5 apteinb17'x.98 7Oil- j Sad-or Caraorati-on Use _ Permit CItemi. determined to be cat,egoricaliy exempt from environmental review) for expansion of a pre-existing nonconfcr°min;9 use to,allow an enlargement of golf course clubhouse facilities on property zcned R•�C <ROf Golf Conservation) ILO ceSoUrde ated,at the northwest 'corner of And Ver Drive and South Park'` Drive, i dent i f i`ed as AP 66-08-36,,Paradise Pines area, north of Paradise. (Continljed apen'from June 24p 1.987) and Safor Coroar^ationr proposed Neraative D �t'arntion regarding environmental impact c.t R and _U s e P er ____s m to a l l ow . 1 Expans l on o f a pre-existing nonconforming use to allow a_members' lounge; 2. A s:41 an i n the requ 1 red setback; a, PIark i;ng on a street On y parcel'across the, Property in the same owhership; 4. Ccam act spaces; ,. ej Use of alternative' landscaping on prope"" t zonedkRnC: (Resource Conservation) end RT-1' (Minimum Density Residential Mobile Homey located at the northWest and 'southwest corners of Andover Drive and South park Drive, identified as AP 66-08-86,, Be 40p 41, Paradise Pines. and Safor Coraoration proposed Negative 'on environmental impactDec1a- and Rezone from R-C '(Resource, onser9at zlon to RT-I (Minimum Density Residential - Mobile Home) for property Drive identifiedoashAPs6b-08x36, 38, 40�ner of t�ndar4lDriVe and Andover, (i` i l .e 87 48) se i' i nes, Staff �;tated that as the commission will recall the first Use Permit application had problems meeting the parking standards.,. Staff said the applicant has made another application for a new Use Permit and Rezone, one lhat the approvedrst Ilse Permit hearing should be vacated ff the second The hearins were b opened to the public iam Pehnberg stated he was a member of the' golf course and he was In favor of the concept; but iia lives across.: the street ' and was concerned with the parking on Andover and South Park, Drive, said he was concerned with th the ;)ei l ocat' on of the shed because it WHl 1 be i n the �iit i to 1 e of very rival se, growth of trees and could be a f re hazard. driveWted the ba,' Ne stagy from teddartlshedd to Andov,r-- Heawa;�econcer{hdd W11 y • ussed the On Andover: witih parking Mel Nlesmith wanted some separation between the parking lot and residences; He stated there was no „ , privacy for resident and there is a :problem with dust: He asked for a Wall oi^ fence, We Was cohcer•r�ed ' faith drainage from the parking lot. kw�+"$iITTE GOtIrITY.ji,ANN N i TON Nti yy uea r � i��y ,.. {T TP . ,r, n r 7 ' wYv ,. i X', e 'tt t,-taJoo 1 fal k stated i t was dangerous w i th' peop'l a park i ng on Andover., She would '1 Ike Safor to enc:ci:.ira e ` _ of park on Ando'Ver or Iona Court,, 9 Peop1P to n +cmMIssioner Lynch asked if the applicant could be asked to pay for s: 't.ri,ping of curbs to stop parking on these streets. taaf f stated y,es , but enforcement could be a prob l em Chuck tJvet-meyer stated they needed to enlarge tha 'lounge and cart ziborage, and that he had a 4 member support 6r t,be per oup with him in favor of . S 't, ns. 1�Saward alater contractor, was thereto .an�Wer questio ria r"tnan Walter as' ked if there was ro.bm for golf cart' tra I l ersto park ii Mr. Slater stated that aple11stthe Park 1n,g spaces were standard sizes He, Stated that ,; 6st their carts at the c 1 ub or they dr i ve em from home if they live,,close enough. He stated that Safor was not Vp favor of ppeopie parking on Andover. He said they Would be willine ,to stripe the curbs or ;Whatever it takes. Staff' asked if they Provide area for people who have their Boilf carts cr7 -ksra i 1 ers 4,"0-. S;) tater stated -they have another lot that is reserved for future' parking. He stated he agreed, with the staff report except;for the W~ect^eat i an room . He said i t was not a club or• 1 odge and shoo l d not r-equirp that many parking spaces. He recommended 11 spaces instead of ?2 and Ichen some of the spaces could _ be designated for pull through ,ir•a i 1 ers He said there was a problem with a fence, he did not feel i t, •would fit with the surroundings. He said he woUld prefer to Use trees as a: barr i'er. -toff ditcutsed different types of fences that would blend With the area. dor. Slaters stated that there is a parcel for future parking. He stated that 15,0% of the carts stored on the property Were gas and 50' were electric. He said they Were not stcring more carts ,just Wanted to do a nicer job of staring them. He stated that no gas is a`lloWed to be stored on the premises. He said 'there, are chargers for the electric carts. He stated all four sides af'the shad will be enclosed: Comtri i ss i over Lambert asked if there would be enough park's ng If street parking Was prohibited. Mr. Slater stated he Was trying to 'Oet parking off the: .streets and Into the parking lot: r}�. , ./�, ��.,,Tt►T.�:) u 1..� j �q)AT a• . ti � �W.�' M�' *a'M'u�n*w•+i N�:.+ .,»irrr4.' y t E COJMI 1 aPj IA. 1Y►' f Nr; ummis`k, 2`1xNU�,'E5 y:At1RUs4i� , ..'�8yadW 4f. , 49Y N BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMISSION STAFF FINDINGS - May 27,._ 1987 COMMENTS RECEIVED: Environmental Health•, "3. Installadditional leach lines and septic tank under permit and inspection from the He411h Department. 2. water s� rice shall be, provided by the :Pel Oro' i,wt {r Company." Department of Public Works: "Parking in this, area is sometimes difficult: „ ANALYSIS,. The application is being considered vrider Butte County Code Section '24- Nonconforming U�;es. :The existing restaurant, pro shop, and cart storage are nonconforming on a number of different counts. They were constructed in 1974 when the property was zoned A-2. Clearly they are an integral, g part of thEt golf course on adjoining land`s. Construction and operation of a golf course required: a Use Permit under the A-2 zoning district. A Use Permit was approved subject to .meeting Hca th requirements in 1971. Under the A-2 zoning district, building setback WAS 50 feet from the centerlineThe existing structures are 50 1/2 feet from the eenterline., The R• -C zoning district requires 100 feet. A sign is located on for the restaurant which. is located within the front yard setback. No Use. Permit was ever issued to allow this encroachment. Signs are Property g dl�o restricted, in the R -C zoning district. Theis nonconforming becaus-e of use of the buildings; location of the; buildings, and location of the ,sign: Theapplicant proposes to expand the eX-,Sting cart storage building onto 4 concrete pad. The total building would be expanded from 1100 s ft, to 2,100 sq. ft: and be converted to a lounger ,Building permit Plans show the 'lounge to contain tv„ shuffle board, tables and chairs. The cart storage i.s, proposed be re7�ocated onto theeast Side' of the property. ` The new buildin will t6ta1 2100 ft additions are g•P" .� aq. Both building proposed to be located within the :fratit yard s�;bacic: I f Positive action :is contemplated on this Use Permit, it would have to be conditioned upon approval of a variance to front yard setback. Twenty f(,iur paces are shown on ttie plot: plan, 5 of which are t sized, for compact cars. The plot plain does,not show t existing spaces Based on current :regulations' fort he number es y parking spaces would be required, lalculation for parking is as follows! 16 for the restaurant, , 2 for the pro shop) 1 for the, pro's office, and 21 for the lounge. The lounge was calculated at a tate of l 'space per one hundredsq, ft: under the lodges and clubs parltii standard, property lines are not shown on the plot Although the p Pian, a quickscale of the Assessor's ,map would indicate an additional 80 feet'to the west of the 6itst3,0parking lot g p g is available for additional parking+ By ' 2 i f•f J BUTTE, , COUNlT pMay. � NG :COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS 27, 1987 eliminating pr'iaposeit� spaces 11, 12, and 13, a'driveway could be built to loop around,inta the expansion area Mervin The expansion area'is ata g two barks of stalls. for picnic talid.is storage. TheghtZy' different , grade and is now used adjoinirij;^ re,`, �; parking :lot shall` be fenced from �.ntal, properties. ;Landscaping shall be'. follows a A tail °root strip along South 'Par Provided as g k Drive and a totaa of 57; of the entire lot. It should be noted that the Safor Corporation oia clubhouse, golf course, and two lots at the, northeast corner ofns the Park and Andover Drive now used for parkin South Ordinance does not B, The County Parking of meeting the standard. t Apu�nuinbersif-site40 prooert3.es for purposes and could be sold at any time by the Safar Corporation for housing.d RT -1 41; are no,; zone those parceis are to be used far golf course , If minimum be treated with a dust parking -they hotId at a' Palliative. The property was yet out as lota of the Paradise.Pines Gou�it Estates Unit ��l &,., div sion ina . ry Club It P A note on that map reads as, follows ' o the Count of Butte for the disposal of drain; e Y on, over and'4%under all of Lnts A throe g water throughG shown hereon." 'his lot is clearly a drainage easement on which no build n Any requests fora buildingg Permit may ,be issued.' this easelAent., permit shall be subject to abandonment of The Resource ,'Conservation Zone does not allow strucreaturer3. P P 'G ?-'nes not appear to be an. appra riate zoning, di _ P• , For this the arty. Surround;;zg properties are strict for for :consideration of a zoned RT -1 Which does allow golf course or country club with a Dae Permit. The RT -1 zoning district or possibl the pp` compatible wi-`h the `golf course operation.. Would a tzar to be more y P -Q, wo A field trig:.o the property revealed a group of well kept buildings. 'iia facility appears to be well used and P attractive' residents: r liked b area In considering expansion of a y withninimpanmiso onbemusdtfind etrimen that the ex nonconforming willrmnot aonflthe _ detrimental to the uses Moth conflict Permitted and conditional of the zone in which it is located and/ Adjoins, The , -C zane.daes .not permit structures, j It would be; therefore, difficult to find that expansion th these buildings is compatible with the tonin district, however, the y- golf caurse operation is an accepted feature of this communit is reasonably compatible with adjoining res' uses.y and was approved under Use Permit 3,h 1971, ident3aY RECOMMENDATIONS: A, 5ind that the Rrn►i►,�i,,k•',,,r'o actis categorically exam t fr�revieaClass 1eand environmental . , , AD tiENDUM To APPLICATION FOR USE PERMIT "�h rata �:iir►t iJk � � the Par RdisO Pines ` 01+ rour5e, Activity It is i,gcated an an a pprox..rttlatec yu� ecre site the _t "� f�r1 1 i�1ee'. The topogeil-phy rtht~+a t r_arncr M+ South Park' Drive and Ve e•tatiom 'Varies -from plat t, cant slOOm--- Fir and cedar treaS and inanzanita tiuohes. The sti1, i t 0 t,able material Wi,tht e;.cmllent drainage. No hj%tc�rxdal or scenic aspect are tctlC��sr! to q�gui s•t;: at the *i •te yChe 'ter iso i' r►c- 01' Course facilities pr ezvntlY pra sl7 p Of K,Ippr`•r�,�,imt:tEa.y 700 squ-�`� a eri.��taktr��tnt of pprogimately^ 1100 %quare •F ed., Lind an 1100 square +oot lgpvf. Cart tar ar c� building Wi.t% 1000 square deet of outside S•t:iCr�r��ing golf C art The pre,>�ect ti nv lue es1tertdingtcthe `Far~ine>ax is�1r tSquare oot storage s1-ell ( X ��} 7 b� µ� Beet i ltilna "1"17 shell WPLI1dt�e�s7 c�ttrtg��n�tai�r�dO it.1 ydOd ac�trma laf�le h, ,ndieapped r e„�t,.r ooms and at the smite, Additionally, a :�rwr` X ;�1' (z1t�0 sqtt�Al �, feet rravt q01F cart sta r•ago shell would be a nstrttctOd to r"�at` lc,:e the area Iast Thor new marea m the rnerttbar crut�ge c�e�ld ,cr�we� 1-t1 curt'tu r , ,W cJ far ca], F cart_ tor4g, ttr"s out-si da concretL slab ata t_i:se g z1i` tur4beci.M ;�zmer candraca ilg ttttlt:'r cart a�t�1 rr3rrai.nape v�r�r.ti.�i remain the s�.ant� � be ' reMOVe�d Or o p' tUci Lt• oz.s car Other Svc e ,t �. tuattld h� si.rillgs wot_rld be increased% "I"Ire; evistin�s r bF lines nd r"eprodla ed to +orm a natural �ranti.�;�:t�ttsir�rt Of'soive the ex;i ati.ng iNteer� et t psi t�tax t t lrag 4 leu ldino would b lis aiF d aloM9 v e; e ti t`1C5r hib l+ ! t1 901+ ClLtr' rentor•°. "i:'h artMhi tt?c :r.dro t< atvtl d iupl i c� ire the details Q+ the present w �tl ties' Approgitnately 010VO-n '300.111 pina be es, �Fy, ,�h�{ l�eerrnrxi r rGG�rri ated to rem0-vod. Site topOgraphy and de ig m nartti... `L1 number and MIZt-- a� tt„oes to be trecnoued al"Id the •rte r h or uxrtt it ► f cls r't� t be maved Slc� than �O yar�1 9 u "thy« buil �i9,r7fa re it-: ? y fat"t�' Or4ed front hecdrl public �rafi� the by t�i� i �trt�he�tnr:w arec�et.a•t jOn 4;!rjd the nz'tur a tailwiinc is meant iia oxac tly repl4kce the c,�,pACity Of tt)L e"" t'mg iloo trtar�c. c i� i tti lding and i.t500 sgQartl [e~Ot outm"L �ttar�tgc ,LArea ex, rept a" I a «” to b ',Inde°r tover, x to thc rhes= f oc:i l :L i M i d i 66-08=11 66-08 21. Aia Dreifuss Claude Mulleague Box 751 Ann 'Moxley 3605. ,Maine Avenue Box 7000-148 Aedbndo Beach, ,;C� 920 7 Ma alfa Ck 9595 g 4 Tong Beach, CA 90806 6 -08-'02 66-08-12 66-08-22 john, schl.egel � Leroy i3rui s C,liffo'rd' Sthles °,ingo X3925 ;Andover 4467 ToyonsRd. ,` 13376 St. ,maga'3' ia, CA 95954 Riverside, CA 92504 Arleta, 'CA 91331 " '66-08,;-23, t98-03 66-08=.13 jes Jackson I William Penburgg Wilbur Thorson ' 181: P. _ Box 1.,697 P.O. Box 1128 3.350 Oakland Rd., Sp gala, CA 95954 3 Magalia, C, 95954 San Jose, CA 9 5112 6,15- 38--04 66-08-14 66-X08-24 ViP_lw3.n. Renouf Joseph Xallbrier James Fazio �.t3. Box 881 166 Muir Avenue 14091 Skyway agal a, CA 95954 Santa Clara, CA 95051 Ma galia CA 95954 6-08--05 66-08-15 66-08-25 Richard� am Ben'kosk I George Rusinkb Bcrx 9aysn x ° P.O.. Box ;514 P.0.,, Box 1569 .': ral a, CA 95959' Ma alfa, 'CA 95954 g Ma a,1ia CA . 595 ; y g 4 6a5-08-06 66-08-16 66-08-26 Harry irons John Girard Margie Dreher. 1w3940 Cascade P.O. Box 644 P.O. Box 644 ticl al ai CA 95954 Culver City, CA 90230' Magalia, CA '99954 4. 66-08--07 66--08-17 "f 66 `-08-27 Jaiseph Penrod, John Woolfolk, Oliver Brown 1"1936 Cascade Dr. 13910 Iona Ct 13909 Cascade Dr Uragaliar CA 95954 Magalia, CA 95954 Magalia,, CA ^95954 6s-08-0$ 66-08-18 66-08-28 Jdhn Aspinwall Quentin Ritchey Norma Winkles Box 888 6130 Monterey Hwy. 4253 13903 Cascade Dr. ,P.O., Ma,gal.a,SCA 95954 San Jose, CA 95138 Magalia, CA 95954 66t-08--09 66-08-1' 66-•08-29' &ard Ki - Place 1146 W: 187 Place Wayno Cushznart y i John M ystal Springs' 6533 Cr sea Sainta Maria, CA 98454 Gardonar CA 50248 San Jose, CA 951:2.0 66�-08=10 la 66-08-20 ` 4 66-08-80 LaXina Gorman Scott Stephens Robert Crowder 6 tl8 0 Nevada No . 6 14131 CoUtolenc Rd : 1180 tmpey Way �Ioodland_ Hi11s, CA 91367 Magalilat CA 95954 San Jose, CA 95].28 5L`C60` ' euzoz �aW oYuo 92026 VD D . p os tz a06 �D ' xxduaXitt •, Q `r�o�IC £ £8 `xa uep-toQ £26 ,,tQ pTAeQ z 99�C p x stnoZ 0 xoao8 bundA 6Ao4 �6-0'8-34 ..._ 66-03-'04 Keith Et fell cKelfiey Smillie 'Norman, 3943 Drendel Circle P.O. Box 1842 Preston 13:883 So. Par�C Paradise, CA 95969 Burlin am CA 94010 - Drive Magalia, CA 95954 y 6'6-08-35 56-05-i�8 66-03-(, � H. Griffin P.O. Box 1180 Augusto Baluyut 162 William Way Michael Platko Ma alfa, CA 95954 g Pittsburg, CA 94573 Z3879 so. Park Dr. Ma 79 S 9 , CA 95954 66-08-36, ` etc. . 66-05-09 - S'afor Corporation x Roosevelt Ford Drawer 5176 2218! Mt. Whitney Dr. Chico, CA 95927 Pittsburg, CA 94,556 t 66-08-39 66-05-18� Marjorie Perroset � 1 Exchange Enterprises f 13903 'South Park Dr. P.O. Box 1004 Magalia, CA 95954 Magalia, CA 95954 66-08,-42 56-05-19 11elvin Nesm] th Milton Molakides P.O. 'Box 1:008 1101 Needham Magalia, CA 95954 Vacaville,y C$ 95688 66-08x43 66-05--20 R Charles Conraxdy r Donald Tobias P.O. Box 2162 13866 Ct. Sunn vale CA 9 Y o 4087 p Maga�.�.aulCA 95.95 � � 66-08-4 4 66-Q5-21 Melvin Carpenter Michael Osullivan r 2621 Buckeye 13864 Tulsa Cts t i$ Ntwpor.t Beach, ,CA 92650 Magalia, CA 95954 66b-08--45 r i 66-03-01 , ' Lawrence Ailey P.O. Bax Charles Mosley .501 Magalia, CA 95954 6230 Wyack Ct. Magalia, CA 95`954 66-"08-46 6 6-03-02 Lawrence Vittor 13899 so. Park Drive. Lorrain Pain rlagalia, CA 95954 39997 Cedar Blvd. x'253 Newark,, w. CA 94560 , 66' 05-01 66-03-03p E. Ahdersoil 13873 Andover Dr. i Farris Carter Magalia, CA 959,54 P.O. Box 114 -515 Magalia, CA 95954' ti FiJ �€s Cotttttiitb itches 1,2.3i d4. c, TtiPtN T Ott ..t orethA t youc �scidr�et in tint � Br aid&« falium to dd this WK ofw"sttthiAt alrd from - 4taaiK+r�e Fa �sws z -`3s ,.'"Y dat3verv. dot 3�'iifttfa[ iNs 24d� fai'lq,�nt►C s�f�e� �E a+raittbiea �omuft pc*vnagwf,,r few old CFeck baxW .cr for senr3ceist raq+-ts& 'a _. Ift rho+nrso.wtta<n..dat+exndaddfafdaeY�N« 9' l `2. Q fiestriatscC Dttivery: V ' r 7: Ankle Addccnasd trsx Corporation �j.er X276 : G'hico, 4. Y paofServftv.- r«.. Q Registered D Tmucedc Cererle O � P 481 943 049 lv-.. t�ta+nsi9uata�nsniadd restea9i t and �e,�scncr��tz=FiRr_ � y M— x — Qata of Dettwtir n fl �" ' CIALt�t181Mi �...:...,. $ CIA�RINBiiAU sCT� N inlM xyr+,r�r�wc44fraa's;,�'ndEP4 pkv waa� �t�v�s aag 4rrsi+h�nV. nw�rgs• t;o pistsiC'iri+� � .a e�nsi �-' o6uU , `C"t OF BLS � 1M�• b4Ift *jW1t.a ffirtt t ciao t * '. t�ndnts�+Kr1 als'•Re�tiurr� Rsasipt �►e�1u • � umbsrT rd s arnt 4100 of Fo or) 10 1{dti. �tld $ 0t, APt#t Bu1tRa P.4 rCA . ICItY►*tAtw,;ZtP Co X2GATIVE CL 1) ARAJ ION REGARDING; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT 1. NOTICE`'HEREBY GIVEN that the project described below` has been revrewe� + rsuarit to'thProvzsians o the California Environme^+al; y - '`n has been is ResoUrces { Code 21100; et. se and , determinate (�uala.t Ac o.£ 1970 (�'um vi a made that it w111 riot, have a sg.n� £cant effect upon' the 'environment. Lo # 57-06-16-02 2 DESCRIPTION aE 1'R(?JECfi; Use Permit t AP 66-08-36,,3$, 401 r 4l o allow l)' Expansion of a pre - the r ng zrbn-conforming use to allow a members lounge, 2) A `sign',in the requir"�ed setback, 3) Parking on as Parc across ,the streat on, 3 • LOCA7 70N OE PROJECT;, property in. the same ownership, 4) Crarnreet Atkin spaoes, 5) Use o .alternative landsca in p g I, P , �S 4• NAME AND`ADVRESS OF uthwest'corner of Andover Ur, & South'Park Dxi At the ;northwest and, So P PROJECT APPLICANT: Paradise Fines, ve' Sa.(eor Got ox'ation. Howard Slater Dxat Ar 53.76 3753 140rehead avenue Chico, CA 95927 Chico,CA 95928 8- _ M1TI` yATTON MEASURIES -i he ni;1oneb. A copy of tial stud ' , ardi�tOF this Project is orrOge nvironme?�ta1 , f ectoat 7Cnnt} Center az ive Orovill(_). This study was: Adopted as Presented., - Adopted with changes. Specific: modifications and ❑ . supporting reasons are attached,: 7., A public hearing on this Negative DecXaration was he decision making bore, 1d by the hearing Body Butte County planning Commission Date of beterminat'ion September 17 1987 Doter'mination �---: Cn the ba of the initial study of. en1;ix�on�7ental m act inf'artiaaion presented at he�rr•in s con11" p , the pro )asa1 and OUT Own knol4ledge and independentcresenron the We find the r ch i nopo5ed p.ro1 cct COULD NOT have a signifi.can�tc effect E on he environment,, and a N8GATT Vp I)ECLARATId V hereby adoptotjs We find that the project COULD have a�signi>icarrt of j on the environment ►`�trt 1ji11 not in Chas ease canattsete,,,t attached ntiti.gatlon moa.strres described in item above o W are ey thxs r���.Cerence made conditions of- proed adore+jai. A co»ditional NECATllth DECLARATION is hereby _ Y \S C at, n,��ta t�° a ..",.•`_`.' tetet; Chairman Butte County Planning. Comm,. -sign N'ut � ,'rar Ct 4aa `���"br��C� � ,� iP,I1LDl. � ' t,.�,��' 7/ `\•T,—,... + 1+ D I!y,f)ir E Ctr .Yi. Na Dn llatltfw fitly A tr' � ec carne rs, � T.ka LMPARA DISE;! Ion DG y� PINES' sfnr.All. :a u: ,.,, .r.>: xa:raa.:wwwtrmawwv x:+.a.taw'. n+rvwu fir.^fv •y u.+,xa :.•r Cr k;e.:." `s 4,. -Ss.. ,: 9a �,�QO �O �N- Gold RU-J\ Z' I wi - o A I,i �� `!•'�• �v/ ontfM3, a Q y': 1" y,.P Q ��`` ; u �_ - f�.eG4'S'1.tA # ? .rp a a,y zPiMiB n. Ci, da+n _t. •ay31�, a ' : � I ,rr_ar+a GM . ru,•.a ••.w..:r. r ..wr D \ Ftlt Gl •N• . �fi4p1V�' 6n ,rF' f�i , ` !4(�i, Mnt r ; F" VV n� MAGA �NtNtfn i � J -r, ) [ Jndim,k �kttrreal Nvtacl . Y j� � T y. r rR� 1"A4' Y too yp ty s16. n'�tAt Wln �IdJCia" \i01*��vtEw a:, �t Y t �- U r cur, cl a r ^ o� � ,Yrs .. � t*r ,R:, �'runCY.ro �rJt .�e�•�' `4•�`..s,.�,:•�y�•rwrY�''__FF P C.., � .F / p 4a � �� VI �.+ r,. w �\ �°�..�.p•` 1N•n wexYe `moi Ep ,-, . �?. • ~ y .1 , J I t r` ..+c.x.rww i%r .+xsm.f �,f'�� Ln. ■ ARAD I Qiflaelfnln n ln, ata � l v nh . \I bN Mi; "' ' i C �ynti t� f�alnlr yJRa r Lh.rin. y. (fJ\01`�. o u•i+.i nw�n M'gJ.lu In � • 00 0 � � •ala/,� � 9 Iwo, ! wV" 9IumMmci Pr Va �.,,,_•.r.-.F�_ ,,. J /�a� 3 a lcy Jbetintlnxi rnrti�,ir -..3 V fnnit+r h L`J j . r s � 70 4n.x EI ino' a 1 pointry RtlnrJ w Ct it '"x+ ] u tWd' J� c Q $ t. Ci�w ttm to r. "'Ki, iln,rs P Flrfarui UERVATION / m n is 3ev' I s; x' t o .. L t M IIf POINT tl 4 J, a 9 yprmt (fain, fire.. -. E tcrj; •. p r omn x 1 MaY�en� 4 wLkifd+ f1eH c Non tlraAW . ?iBlse qua e o. Iola ln. �r r.w !aaM;M Ln omni 5 y PRE• CJ1 ► 0 far of hrr RJ, .� to : tn. w 9 a nrwn 6 to �' q t zp�x. oacl s U i. rrotix9 •k x ndhp t 1 - - dyill Sit tli 'T— .r y r M SnraY:a, �� y Ydnrllry I 1� t,•1;.�a.J �,....... - -- FI LF No. 55 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING- CommlSSIONH ARI G DATES APPL ICArNT- Gb rLp, OWNER.,, �jqq t�fT'031. a,a.Vr+t-. Grb ti caa,..br. - _ ► EXISTINGc �.► o'tY-y» a ra ff+ n�� T�;;�q��' �„� �-;+�,.1 ♦ Z. OA i�- C. SCALE Ge4 , a c CS u May 18. 1987 „Y �i Mrs. Betty Kircher Planning Directoir Butte County Planning Depai-Iment County Center DHve Oroville, �Califart�i'a c ATTJ' Laura Tuttle II'iRADI,SE PINES GOLF 'CART 'STORAGES RECREA'T'ION BUILDING � SIJJEC`T" AND PARKING MODIFICATION Dear Mrs. ItIrch er.. _ 1 INTRODUCTION - We are writin , this letter to provide ioackground and" which we hoe will help 1 :add#t(Gnal infarmat#on comr:aunit needs an We want tt� serve the local golfing p� p ��ou help us Y d retain as much of the natural set -tin y offer q g g P Mas passible, I hoe you will shareathiWith Mrs. <lecher b the ro�a s will be appreciated. Y p and because she known our As to further clourtes , a ct1py, ftFtis�i5-to beir;anseht tie ��°hcerns mentioned. Director since at will be reviewed t g the, Public Works the process. . V his department someWhere during p We know Bill iCheff is familiar with the coulr S,,6 since open#rig day and we share his interest in providing goad facilities, good atcesz, and convenience for golfers and the public. PROJECT ITEMS _(BEE', PLANS] 1 • Replacement and Relocation of Cart Storage, The storage will be the same size or slightly smaller ut. will now be totally covered. 2. Add to and Conner isting Dart Storage Building, to a Rect Related Building, Since it will ioe for teatiotl he vise of golfers it will be related, five of� tient f r spaces acessed Afo L nn Pcr �— The parkin Y" p pa ts. g pian' shows I t cat -1 be oxpanded to twenty -;,#x, seven of Which are compact. On !Sat0rda sixty percent com acts using tho lot, Y May 16, we noted more than p g This wouid satisfy the additional spaces required for a "recreation building. 11 T 14 li S A F O Rc Q _tt'. r O R A T 1 O brOW4r 5176 � Uhieo, C:tl it; ritta 95927 (916)t194,11Ub o a..•. 41(11 .: tr 0 rl p C,.5. t Page Pro Complek, Modifications 4. improve the lots d No. r _ ,� e. i{ These lots are adjacent to No. 1 tee th<< a cut rent capacity of w D t� s ,aces and renovation under way,to increaSE the parking tc forty-sevenjdalineated spaces. Weis be realize �t By nrnalalh a �� par fall afor$cothe street: 'and �r� will to fifty-one mixed spaces for a possible partially of from asevects nty on can �to creased seventy-seven spaces' far both areas r' 5. Hold Lot 161 as, as Natural Buffer. Lot 161 to the west; co be developed for partoldking but we believe you will agree it should be left as a natural buffer for as long as possible. Community support for this plwn will be Shown at the hearings by the appearance of the golf club members "who have raised their dues to pey for this project. PROCESSES necessary to accom fish these recra We. agree and are more than willingto go through the planning processes y p tion facility modifications. C, Use permit application. This process is underway with 'hearings scheduled, If this could be approved, naturally we Would like to commence con sti"Uction,• . 1,,. ning change from "R-01 to a zone hitting the historical use: We worm like to apply and have concurrent connsideration or at least have the processes run concurrently. 3. if a variance request would assist you or allow us an earlier solUtion, we would be willing to go through this process. We would ' certainly abide by your judgement to decide whether this would assist you on our project or just confuse issues, 4. Apply for abandonment of a portion of the drainage easement Which we understand covers all the lot now occupied by these facilities, An onsite look easily shows the Swale occupies only Portion of the lot. We have already retained Gary to write thappropriate description for this request, May we process this request concurrently With the others? USAGE AND Nil'fiGATiONS After much research and soul searchi►lig we ask that our Use be considered a "related recreation build"!11 since it will be Used by golfers and their guests. Forthis, tileparking requirement equals ones ace er two hundred square feet, Please note from the pians that no food or beverages will be commercially dispensed. The pool table and shuffleboard areas do hot lend type buiidings�mselves to Certainly the we w'ou1don not to ' of fe oedl and club meeting ee shop with another eatery Golf cours.,-s produce ji termittan�tzia eUse,f not, the high occupancy of lodges. Please consider this in making your judgement, Page 3 .Pro Complex INodficatlons ,j 'We share your concern for adequate parking and for easing street congestion. Earlier, Lots 32 and 33 across the street were discussed with twenty spaces''currently and forty-seven: full :sized orfifty-one mixedspaces how under construciton. It is true, these are residential lots that have always bean used for parking and they "are across the street'. WO cannot move them but their use can b4. assured b recordinga/,heed aestrictloh limiting their use for parking. We would by to an4ording in the Deed Restriction that you suggest. It would also be clser .to the course facilities than Lot '161 to the west. Please agree that Lit 161 should be protected by similar deed restriction but should be :left as a natural buffer as long as possible. , Can We agree that the building use is not a, lodge and that properly protected and delineated parking edjaceht and across the way will meet the planning `criteria? With eithr;`r of these determinations, (I_ot 161 ) the natural area can be kept natural, To assist you in your determination we will have the_aceossa-thy:-straet parking!' ready for viewing in about ten days. As an aside, the Nugget Casino in Sparks has much of its parking across the Are'at and it se�+�ns to work. Many California golf courses also have across ,), oad parking. Some other factors that help In this mitigation are; 1. Twenty percent, mf our mamberrship t,'ye adjacent to the course. 2. Golfers that play together often drive or ride together, 3. The capacityof a- narrow nine hole course is limited in the number that can actuzilly play. We concur withyour ;Concerns about congestion and oh street Parking* Bill Cheff, as a Traffic Engineer, will know that some motorists willalways use on-ttreet parking even if sufficient and convenient off-strect parking is available, In such cases it might be necessary to place a time limitation for oh—street. parking. We would never suggest this since other expertise should make such de(!sions. In conclusion, we hope this information will assistou in our Y processing., Would you please Offer any suggestions you might have to assist our efforts. Can you make the following judgements and determinatiohs 1e 0ur application should be ,for a "Recreation related Building" and hot a "Lodge -Type Building?" ''v, 22. Adjacent parking modlfiEd to twehty-four or twenty-six spaces is SUfficieht to meet the planning celteela. 3. Across the street parking properly delineated aid protected by Deed, Restriction is a Mitigatloh, C, 1. t 161' to the Can be state andLorotected with ro riate kept It strlctla lis, its ne+tural buffer p pp p ,� . �i ' i9a�'/.r5.'�li. iSi''i�.wi'Nrlu �)II .,t.n:. d N • , �Nfi141 \'Ini.... r r IOOx as e.r M,d.«r O++rrr 4r/Ir d'Jb MORR it of •res r+krrs�n.oroo,�w/ttr% r ! h� rlYfH Qi fi1M11106 MSS , fylivcti'S orel 4 ;. / •�// TN[ GALIIORNtA t00R01MATt 3VITEM tbhE t F4 N rr rt 1 •'1rs6." f a/� raN.a:ro.� i.rav F . ..rry� j+rJ �\ i� �• rjLtSIASLIS"CO FROM TRIANGULATION S7411004 . •� �. iM s \.. rMV v!'.• 1/ �W ,/ , CAMMILL 1tr2.1 UtrtSSM. Y-701, 49-t FrRs'! ,• ,! t \ r►�111 ' r nr,• !r'i ,'w1. ,. �°" is �i*%.iYj t.,J .•-r•••-� ;%."•'fj•,•'�;e'1 TO. TRIANGULATION STATION /ALDMOUNTAIN �•t "�, \. ,.`ifd .rN.rr�• _ lyAi�+ .' I N pil'! • t +M• [' `.9r. ^ 9 4\ i/'rr.6.rrJ $ .er /� ; ., .1N�Er1Al:}fOril. Y•/91'.9/L/21' SEARING �, r•j� >'` ` r, \ r ' a +bnI/1) +a' jjy 'L +r... • �'1. 1 �- 'C /0��.�a A N.a•,� !iS :RLCOPD OP !t AS SMC ON THAT A13 ,!r ••, ! rw `i r,.••, .! I • URVEY to MCI) IN COOK !7 PAGES, �... r ice. a or Er tr. !D ,,.. qoa R w' "11 Zip t`V ♦ B t , �r (r P{ s•il „ ?/� s�! si' r ` N ♦ t A ' �._.-pISTANCRS7! or / 3f'.CUTtt COUNTY ISTANC ••.• .ill ,Dlr' 'S, je+1!'0 \ost �' it iAr-.[�iN :6 r�./i ,� � s / ♦ �...'.a � 11DIM KRSON ARE 6810 013TAItCt31 '� rf ,r y�l /! trj'►'t �: r ! Z !r!al. yD .« / r ♦ AV r. MOLT IPL\ NY t.000111I TO O/TAiN Gk0UN0 r •'t" / 1 rrr*r 1 >t .•'rte• \ rr .r \ Ir'0 I: a r ew. e..J.. A �tr 1 A/ P 9J ?IT ` � PC ,.... � �N. �.! b / 6 ���I: s^ r ' w.p•, Z` 4 ,li' °,L � �, t M ! ,`� �,'� '?l+l l `� Y?A ��•y Z' � Pd/ A � a , C �'y� t'�stk'• •�O � � •�•s.J"'4 t � •�/wv+•. i Z t ,♦ y3fR» b� Of 7t Q 4f /y 83 7 a^/» Ner•n•. •rl /G i>! _ 3 44 �e „dl i �tr�•t7 ��i•` • �`:•taz! a O��r w1" t �ik i .w a�;y�"t /7� a �`. „ n �4i "� . .�, I •♦ yro.v'w I r�i :uIMH•nt ♦ i R �//6� T O. •. ,, 11 110 rdyyr'r tr � : +., - T � J f�':i• '":. I .raw• - •• 7�,._. �'+Ut�� r��frN ie . ,t r,LL 1� � r�fD '/1 .�!'+iM -- ,. .i„',h' � f n. 'P»•-va��yt' .;�c �„`♦D:��,+ . . `s .7.V617' Aad. .!•... ✓ Z ��• y t/i !�. .Ci"?ZG fp'^•�.~► •` '... i� r !•.,y ... 'h�.ai`+.41• �•.rsir:. ,., f r 3� �lrrrr � i � .s � 1�� `�r f �'`�`'kiir ��, •... � .Z� � •Dr•/: k#, � __ t Z a ?/i � ' �` ?? � r �"grvrr • , �yA.r ♦ ` �✓' r�J¢�}e 1 rryi M 1 }rtr• s` * , ,��lr,r6yW g�°,rCri! »YNr1 J r� 27I a4a aly v A .� S'QT�s fly\ . • //! -- �L", y Y /�) , � :•r!'r+lr r� .,, ` � .: �!� ' '.t .}�I•'�� a ' '¢w'!' "'rr � /i:.. _-_ �♦ � i lsd :%t+8 t.d e• r' r +!1?t--- % r Ns i ` •II'rr IV.. �K MM M;r. .• YKN ,ty1►Y!t) %(i y dti.� �: .! D ....... a r. Awl+v'!n lfi !r!+ .r s . r ,j t' ' !a. tt\� t ,D 0 •� ' •h �� SAM” /NOCK /Jfi !` �wle t • , •Y y . � lr..l+�>. � �+ Jnv nr `t ?dl r err �''..�+� �t /�' r � • •oy; ' 1 ;• �� jr J `'tt M t ��t�,{'• y, 'y,, Y, � ��y /49 ; K —1 4 r N t j dace: s fQ. `���t a 7p yr r V lGD .• � f 6 it,�f1 �tt �G,�, � ' r{ �� �� ��'� C �rIT � 'R j+M� � � M�t � R • � • ir•�jrA Z 1 - Q � N �n+rr'n• `0 �6t?o. , •A. G ; , a rd IGI • / ,, • p a ¢,. /fir. �$ Y h ?co � . �� � �• a � r < � a < 7/ �• �'� f� P Vin` a a � i .an• , � r �, � �, :;: , a d G' �,� + ��+.: � .b � � to t,,, ♦ � 3? � /, ` R rr 't r rl � y� � # n. ... w•l..ii•n•i » 'L ?04� 9 1 .fir%_ Q ? ♦+ /' 'd w Ir m ,/"�•.: Ei .d�`'r 4t,` , "., ^t+s: •ty,y, ( p ..a�' � : o i�r q .q� /i0 r r •,j v+� rr „.` !,� �► w ' 10 •s d V f• 1+ t 1' V : Q. >, ` �/ + µ� 1 y, r, • d T a •� a .� p ►" f 1► '� g/TSP / ►� ? ,. a °/ ,� 2r?ir• . 1 ` c i't 3 .*}. Jit=n�==, 164}., a !+ - �I,�dorrA * t t',J. •� r 1 ?0! .� 4`i► 6 i'( `': r /t0 .�ia ; O �e� "rvr `{ `►`s Al '1", �t� eR:i9 ,.� ,�:1' nl �3� fP. 1 . r ` p�.r wL� / } d4 t f`�`•; I� i s ro'` ` 7�" r 11 +r� ' �' t• Iij1 �., � 'ti •r A L ` • � vi",','e'`",� \ r ►OUMD y/a• InoN 01N TADC[h R.I:fRs 103lsrarrrra,r)It , '='' r �N ;. ♦, `' �." ),OUND:koNUMENT AS IiNGRN 6lirrnrnrrnui:ff00-6rrrilrr.•,-II.R „ IA011 NICE TAGGED Ot,t, �` } �' /�e.r .1y�p wr • • for alta »,r,rrf •irWry,'"p f JCL'.. y�•WCG/ I' • . l e • • o SUBbIVISION IiQ �Y ' r bdT : It ! i11JN iiPE TAGGED R CrEr IOlA:rrrrurrtJ✓` PARADISE ' PIIUES , a/► , r s r hET C►a�TERLIi/i, WM1MEjlTcr,uuur rrrrruar r f. r r yu.,,.N COUNTRY CLUB, r *� � OL /tA6omN+I/, �N1f . �' TlROOOTA!G!3. • .! /C,{_/.i . s. 6 y.w A "�r t .. r �r sI t' .:t, o", r r '0p1►ti.IAdLlIlAEiACAo-,TitilT[iEAjlTt1If1 ENYSAT lE�MilErNtT,�l I':Pr�r.rrl1is6rrE6,frai+u.W�r:�rfrbcr6rrrirCrfrr..��rrr• C.0 � •i EQ . Si T�9Ai� TE S TALI ACRES C6I! UNITnnO•11 SEC. 2 2&,35 & m tg�NKs-MO,M.En.rlo 1.05AAA.0,Y•6,0 1A.let OUTTCOUNTYy CAL 06O W(.SCALE, 1PgAVNIAICOt/tiL4kLLIDT OgNER3NOT•INDMCTpbVTOt MOE OWL& o it Wftub 0 111 .. INoN VIN WON JAD 11,C,cr /orl . .a, 1N[rT A oY N f11tATf �•.'w.+ir.V •r 'i+•N 1.»r..w»arY,wi.r.ut:i r a++r an. • Ji � wi. •w:,sir 1 :�: w: y1r Jr r. r, r. . r, .ar , • r 's r . r.+: J ir»sr •No» rrs,»ra,»rw:i:.»w:'wwr.w.r•.w.•F'+••rtrrr.,rr+N..r.,.»ar... :wr h�•r.r...ar..wri -.r+;...r..i.r+r+.+ ' aw rr».r.rr'.. ♦ W .• Y hi, rL.w �rdrilM » . • . .._... ...rte. Page 2 ` Pro Complex ,Modifications 4 lm rove the lots (No. 32 33'/ across South Park Drive. These lots are adjacent; to No 1 tee with a current capacity of tWentY spaces and renovation underway to, increase the, parkingtt treet;sand it dWilleated spaces, We realize it is not adjacent, it is acro be addressed later. Bycmaking �oss''bl partially o toayof fromaseverity onects it can etoncreased to fifty-one mixed space-, fora p seventy-seven spaces for both areas.,' 5... Hold Lot 161: as a Natural Buffer. trot 161 to the west could be developed for parking but we believe you will agree ft should be I eft as a natural' buffer for as long as possible. Community support for this plan will be shown at the hearings by the. appearance of the golf clUb `members who have raised -their dues to pay for this project. PROCESSES, We agree and, are more than willing to go through the planning processes y p ' ' y if icatiohs. necessae to accomplish these r=ecreation fat.. I mad Use permit application. This process is underway with hearings scheduled'. If this could be approved, naturally we would like to commence con struction . 2. Zoning change from 011-0" to a zone fitting the ni^t r'ical use. We would- like to apply and have concurrent connsideration or at least have the processes run concurrently: lf' a varoance request would _ assist thiaOU o�roces A SWe Would ah r 3. i we would be willing to go throughp `sol utioh, , o decide Whether this would assist you on our project or just confuse i` y bide b your ja g.�ment certain a sues 4. Apply for abandonment of a portion of e dr�n,age easement which we understand covers 611 the lot now occu led b these facilities. An onsite look easily shoves tl-111;swale occupies only a small N.E. portion Re retained Gar Lo ° lncott to 'write tl°re appropriate Y Of the lot. We have alrooddY y pp , descrlptioh for -this rc toit. May we Process this 'request cohcuerentiy With the others`? 11SAG� N1MCATIONS After muK� research and soul searching we ask that our use be cot sida:red i " It will be used by golfers and their One es guests, F r this, the parking cluirement equals one spat o �t eve►^ gIV 9 related rerreat�on buil ram. the tans that no food ag. - 1 y p ease note f p hundred square feet. PI Will �e commercial! dis ensed. The pool table and shuffleboard areas do ti of lend themselves to the high occupancy of lodges and club meeting certainly we would not want: tt a ordi2e the coffee iauildings Y 1 p ���p with ani�ther eatery". Golf courses produce intermittaht use, not tl'�e high' occupancy of lodges• Please consider this in making your judcjemen"t. Page 3 Pro,Complex Modifications We share your concern :for adequate parking and, for easing street congestion. Earlier, Lots 32 and 33 across the street were discussed with twenty spaces currently and forty-seven full sized or. fifty-one mixed spaces now under construcRon. it is true, these are residential Its that have always been used for parking and they are across the street. We cannot move them but their use can be assured by recording a Deed Restriction limiting their use for ,parking. We would agree to any wording in'"the Deed Restriction that you suggest. It would also be closer to the course facilities than Lot 161 to the west. Please agree that Lot 161 should be protected by similar deed restriction but should be Left as a natural' buffer as long as -possible,., Can we agree that the building use is not a lodge and that properly protected and delineated parking adjacent "and across the way will meet the planning criteria? With either of these determinations, ( Lot 161`!) the natural area can be kept' 'natural . To assist you in your determination we Willhave the across -the --street parking ready "for viewing in about. ten days. As an aside, the Nugget Casino in Sparks has 'much of its parking across the street and it 'seems to work. Many California golf courses also have across -road parking. Some other factors that help in this mitigrtion are: 1. Twenty percent of our membership rive adjacent to the course'. 2. Golfers that play together often drive or ride together. 3. The capacity of a narrow nine hole course is limited in the number that can actually play. We concur with your concerns about congestion and on street parking. Bili' Cheff, as a Traffic Engineer, Will know that. some 'motorists will always use on6-street parking even' if sufficient and convenient off-street parking is available: In such cases it might be necessary to place a time limitation for on -street parking. We would never suggest this since other expertise should make such ;decisions'. Ih cohcl;usion, we hope this information will assist you in our processing. Would you please offer any suggestions you might ,have to assist our effortsa Can you Make the following judgements and :determinations: 1. our application should be; for a OReoreation Related "Building' and not a " l..odge-Type "Buildhg?i' 2. Adjacent parking modified to "twenty' -four or twehty-sbc spaces is sufficient to meet the planning criteria, 3. Across the street parking properly delineated and protected by ;Deed` kesti-Ictio' n is a mitigatioh;. p r West an be kepi In reserve in its natural buffer state andLpr tected' With appr6briate ropriate Deed Restrict ohs. 1 F.4t't1!>j``. �`ih �5' 4//M1Y` # i. •r' 1r /A{I!'QFNEMiiM01i �)/ 3/3 ' TNC-tAL taNplk C00101►► / /ry/rifati Mr•1"t4.IY l r'!w IOOK :f OR Mrlr'�' 3t[Y It. 114�f,M0/, 1 NTt f'(STEM lOhE t ' IDOK sI dR AIA/7 r\esfR +i�f\ I a!7 rrY .,o'+ �' ', r rj r"« 1 , � Eli, fe0Yr t111ANGULAf►ON f -OR '., /• >tii • 'r..... rt .710 / ..nM �•r.d am• I.. . TOTTIIIA LATIW/ S1ATt_i1MD Y.Te1,tAlr9{) 7 : \ . tt� f MAfI1L•:k•Lt21.2f fN 0044,40 MOUNTAIN ilit ry t♦'�. ` \ ««+N.r• `4M NNeN e�.°"•'c°+Ar J t'�..._�i q•IY♦.+ i G, ' ►7fii Ey, Af'1H0 f ` ee,421 tlEARINa l ♦ J _ lo►AT AaENDEa 1►►' w �\ c7d nr Ir•R SII! 'N 6iLE0.IN Y00R f7 r�cE! r « r a• J " '" �N � ir0 2 w t 1fii.►� t ^ �. \ \ �,e +.r.rlrffR) N r'y.?i t ti rti.,r ... ,� is 1� /O NI,11 t� pyrr i ► PLCOp0 Of fVI1VEY : \ • w+ etc •fY r, 1.1 BUTTE COUNTY': IICCONOSr ^'X "-`� - 1 A : D►STANCE3 SHOT °IEN[ON 11NC T D►STANCEft 't/! t• j tA`9 s>t}/.� ab'lllq k IAlLTlrlr w ID00►1f{ TO 0{1AIN OIIOUNO r f i`.i 6f�: , bMTi't•.,.� FIt �'j(°''jtl; • plftAIICES, {,' 1-��tl�� 't e!°�rt9 \ ��y Y.r�►'f° \ Ur t°°°/ ci V�� 1'° ".t:K �� 4�• V tY 1 Cyl v i� ' „ 1 � / P; t � I � S t r �e �, t3/ A Po. j J Z � ut� �•6�,,.1, . `O � ^urr�+ •s�''liil y � �. Q a /9J a ?I! ,/ �•� �� t/! 1, � �?Rx•4•y � �. � �7. w, � 7< b� •7 >/` ,?. , ?'" t � G a 5 � "# ' ql' •tR . $. r� • + (f I rOp'r' � � - t5 , �' . '� ` ' \ rwr"MN7 � 3 • " d , �*'/► y � +rr e. '� �.: ''�'x#�" I1t �R � Qtr •.�,ayar�n r { u�,e�•,.'� " �, 1 j i + tl o, � Q1 +..ij°v ° Z Vr' 1 t/ 1 N r • yji, +��i. :.iFKy`• �Z Yn,�" t k� ` E "iH1f �wrL N . } M V 1 4• �.. Fi$i• Alv t :'b t1� "> r . • Ea �1. ! w^ �+."' i ye G t ^ e irsvxi • /94 ., ,fir � � a 727 .,�r� . , t I a �• 7 1/ir�aii••:t �q� raw. % �1jy1 , 4. 95. N Y Irl a . . �' 1t'_ i„»,"-`i� \ ;• G wy�ttrl • �1 1, A/0 4r- � rxY ''\,r e I .;r�,r. ,;. y :d [t ar.•1•r' 'it; •�r��;~ / ti., i. J"►?K1 Q,t j�•e ` •. e.rl. ♦ i� ,iPr.rr 1tt.�{ lYl �k:�. 'i.� '.! rr•1•Mp ,,�+r ',1 I -� �r td Ir /96i'vK +'�� � � ; ?tE �►� v4' ?,2'G I �o^ �''w'�,e,,'^n ,:,. � "��ie� �Yi......•'"- `; ,., ; . � � � / r.ir' ��, � '4 ...�:._.. 1+ q/ i rlr,� ��� ?� y.�r' r ,,�1 ,�i�. A / ~ �s 3 tJ., • ' • � *f 1 .� t00 } �. ,, �� h. , d � p� •,,,-� ,^ ..•,,•�,r-�+'.• �'� �,i r / lli �. • j► f J ,. . .! L d' . ,,: - .fid � ..ti M�o ' F`,�,•'tp.{'„ ,na+o.' . tt, ttu Z /l� 1k' i� 116• ' � i�tYr ry �q � t/7//.rKl �, 174 .�.� � ��e.�"�''i!b IA .r �lY ,., t• +'�'�ti%F1' ' � i . w,IfYj1 y �4'w: y ,Qt . {•• I ' 2 ►! r "i6t e 1.061E .rr� ayt yl �/, ti� L , ,• r „yr is -� e Y imbrx• �;1 : • 1,. writ , .•',r•e.e•., • R r,�,rart+Er, alb � tp . ,y� !1►\� •t, � u• i 1� � ,J,.lE`[7' ♦• P '/►'►*`NYM1% { �1.rtA7 1E w NI Herr•' t"'qid "44 1 �1 t"1 {/"� ° N' W r� ys } /IFiy O ewtrjt : i ritrr nrY �' -� 164 •r ,4 ot3 ' � do; Min ri' p+ l96' tt Y `�,. #jc^ Y/ tp 'a�o-.�F,/Cg, / ° �;J ►,, p . q' �' 'kms �d��� ' i r' y1,li'rrY Y� IGi Q �. '=�;'aay{ " . '1i t Yt, � P b C1! +"" • ' ` ' 1 ; , 0 S��' "tR �4 ?O;�✓ YiL , M a w , ��� � § u°� 9t+' � ° tYj / ''��" K??/ "�e a1hp0 ;� ���, P: � ,/ , k ► �a 33 �. � �. �.r.a s � � yy tl I ri, /� Y�r�.'h r f' a ,p ,,j •� i' 1 /y7. R !i � / t• IQ i,N {[� 1 \ ,. � i >L �P � �•j1� " Pt '�' YP 3 � r \'J� �' `i'��°. 9, rf'•• Q Y���f� •�'a 6. ' ° r n , a t03 i O . 2, •ii �, NO , �. titl it � Y :. � ?/ i r e 0/ v � " . . ,110• . �" ', _•0. d' r +�� ti• Yro 4 " a. � b 31 / C � � •• +}.,, g „, «Yiiir• \�.. r ! *.. d' fir+ + a :1�a. j /Il, 1 R � 4 P ?G or � $ r 8 !� Ten• ,� " •�. t�y b / `Zi p�J -...' � s o ! T"• $,, r'j� "�, m 'r4�� � �► h w �•+ t + A'va Yr wN•e/+n•r � r:d64e S r .y%` ` �ht /I/ �iR lw..: 8 Yri'rb• / #�' r •r`"'Ss.•�,^'aj"' k" ' �+n;,.•;i•%bi'n'•+� �.y01 Z.9 ;r U /I,•�, R /.rd9 % 0li ^tbi u` 1144 ��C> `i•�r N p ry'��+ • .I Yi� •• �{ Z �/f''Yi �LtOdYI. •'I,t'�Y ` 1;�,sr�t �- 1�9 'u, ►'t711,, Y�',B! "'•►r { �6. , �i, Ga. � r� �1 •Ij y w. t'! r • ' t 1 +� t � � ' ,, ,` $ �� '•• "`1 , b'� •C b. , ,_ �iY �••i,� %3Et � ` 4 '•�'9'; +n� di`�..' � ` • rt%«�.,r 4:h �� �r'V' 'tr � �'t Q+ ,' '`-'�!, /%bx�4 +' � ti'l1, �� ' '",+.`+ •. 11+Id Yo'`r •' � t^t ,�P ,i'�Ir •�„�f �+'�"�. � , ri � O 'tC ��11 illn 4 a.r w1 M 1 � �, I - •./1' fff e'rip°II a j:7 e " +1� �� / Q�3^ �l iC{ 1 ♦y` biil i NY4•ni + M , ,, w ' �� �,IL ' ►OUND �/•• INON,EIN TADOCD N Cat- EOff a lta 1'.• X , • - , ... , 1_ ., " '.„ _ . 1: � ;:. �OUMa 'NOwtIMCNT A! eNOtRI ,.a i rl,lwall a " •NUn+Y K " ' a " • ►ijw 1,. f.X f IROp'�i C 7AgOCa N,CaElf 1.. 1d"w.l • ' $�la) kle�.7�.r' i •. �pUND ! IAON mot TAGGln N CaE,r f0 "•' 9Elr- Sh/Lr�'T 1 Y y tDff, an ,�+ IIET Y' � - W PtP� �I��SE Pl��� ulaaLT1Y L.......:Ili i IY H {:Y ••• , isET NAIL. AND t1NaYYCOUNTRY ., p GLU�3 P1. ha CEMOLIN M01A1NTAi - a c c au"w +FI YI "'Y'+'� .. {' ' . Y 9[T tlACN t11NL'`iil at Y il,tl... + ra1l.roYa1'C�S rte. UN, NO. y r r. TaiAl ACAEe Mf,tlef y a�r7.. ' tlftltli " " ,.. �' Pt'hl SEC,. 2526" OU '1� �; � �, }UeLtC' UTILITY rN'1ENENT' (FIUY[a ,�tlrluN�O � tY wkliw LDT�;0 ► i 1 �Y NDAM . _. ,. "1 .r •• 011AId•KCIT EASEUCNT (DaLYI t. t. Y1Y,Ytlwa.Y:il la ,:r r , +Va �uTTE C._. PON . tC�, aD. : ° Lote llJ►F,D,t,r6;eli ie,lu q w'r�� tl M RN 11 �, t ` . MCCAiATICiNAL tASEMICNt 1NJt/1"I>Ia+.na,Yc "uN - 5ckt UgHNY ifFi6C0iiMIDpK+lyn, 1971 I a a ,' r '.. CAtin hY FNS ABDVC: bYlAeCfLS ,`' .. o ef1CtP ♦111" ♦ tliikETe 0 BE WOODY Vitt:6H 01H WIT" TAD NlCatc r yr c '� �I/AP �! Y l6 LOT CDhNENS HOT INp .u, 'YYr,F ort,;.: + •.r,.a a»�:.«+.u.t-+.—"" IN ,� u.. .r i rLa"...+liJr,..ai'y,W " r..++1N+..Ar.a a.i.✓r. .i" .aw.«4r:r I.s d Orr •) i%1'i+ryyr--r.�wa w. "....ai i , a: .11.+.:.,: p aw ,. �. ..aw �-a1'—:a:>'•� .�•_'— ``•� w t � ��'� ......�.. �;'�' .�'s'. •;�' `fit A count rI tFl t -.=Z, LAND 0 f NATURAL W ['ALI II t,,! PLANNING COMMISSION 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROYILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3397 PHONM 538.1661 M Safor Corporation May 1, 1.987 J .., Drawer 5.176 Chico; CA 95927 n -i , Use Permit AP#;66-08-36 . Gentlemen: M We received your `pre-applicatikon revie47 request for the _ subject Use Permit.; Butte County Public Works and Environmettal Health 'have received the information you Submitted. The planning Department will consider this application complete only after we have assurances from the above: departments that the project complies With appropriate ordinances and any conditions'imposed; can be mets it is the applicants respphsibi.lity to provide any additional information needed by Public Wotks oz Environmental Health to meet their requirements. Public Works may ;be contacted by telephone at 538-266 and Environmental. Health at 538-72.81 for furter information as to thei)' Evaluation of the Propo al and their requij^ement's The Planning Department staff will also be revi.eW,ntr thea lication s pp fo,. any Y, Pedialco nditions or modifications that. are appropriate, shou5.d you have any questions about the pre=appl�.caton review, please contact this office, Sinderely, 8-A. KTRCHER Director of Planning cram an'ders :Planning xechnician Cs:jmc I titer-Departmental Memorandum T0: Planning Commission FRO, ft SUBJECT; Safor Corporation Use Permit, AP 66-08-36 DATE- June 17, 1987 The Safor Corporation had applied fox a Use Permit 'to�eXpand:golf cart starage and construct a members lounge at the Paradise Pines ,golf course. At the regular Planning Commission meeting of March 27, 1987, the, item was continued to Jure 24, ]987, to resolve a number of issues. Specifically, construction was proposed within the 'front yard setbacks without benefit-of, a variance. Sufficient parking was not shaven on the ;site plan., And some of the spaces that were shown were sized for compact cars The Parking Ordinance does not specifically provide for smallet parking spaces. And finally; the e aoriginal 'subdivision map set , the property out: as a drainager could be issued. seement, on which no, building permits After working with staff, Safor Permit; to alow Coxporatat� has applied for n new Use construct a' member Expansion of a piereXisting nonconforming use to y• l . s. lounge, and enlarge cart storage facili2: Place ,a sign in the required front Yard required off-street parking to be located sonbacparcelsacro3i Allow, tes; s the street on property in the same ownership; 4. Compact parking spaces, 5• USe, of' q native vegetation and trees in lieu .of the standard landscaping re uirements, A rezone application has also been filed On the clubhousd ptoperty from R-C rezone'wil.l eliminate the 100 faotesetback andsneedLlrvatfor)v to RT-1. The e iance to the front yard dsallows•golfecoursesoupan.approval ofsaa 50 faotrfront yard setback an district Use Permit;, Safor Corporation still needs to apply for an abandonment of the drainage easement 4averirig the property. they are aware of the 'tided to abandon the easement in order to obtain building permits, app:ilcation `is expected shortly,, An Because of the substantial, 'revision to the Use Kermit and inclizsi.on of a rezone, the project is now subj@ct to en it, and The new Use Permit application is also going ihrougt, the pre_applcaticn process. Under the best of circumstances, the project should be back before you in its madiied form by early August: ltocotnmendation :, Continue the hearing forward to August to consider, at the time of the other hearings for Safor, whether to vacate this hearing or act an its LMT : l,r cc: Safor Corporation