Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
072-290-154
FRQ�TE_CT ST7M1'`ARY SHEET a Fi e to: Log, No - Charlotte Speegle - applicant �_ representative r ` 1071 Hurleton- Rd. ADDRESS: Oroville, GA -95966 (tt + PHONE -1t I property owner. F � ADDRESS: a AI / a kennel; '. PFZ03EGT I?ESCR1'PT=ON- USE PERMIT to allow r�o F • ' � r Y� ���- o f , r tiv� fz� a.�(�Yro# Yy +r"`l w eg - r I r6'Hta�T on.propzone�dy located east richt on o ' Identified as AP 072-290-1 54— town/area: - � r r GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION A -Res` DATE: 12177 5°715%9 225 ,fl0 PRE -APP FEE PAID: 1 RECEIPT MlMBER: j APPLICATIGN ;ACCEPIED; O. RECEIPT titiriBER: iW IB$ FZ2{AI: APP. PAID $ . (- .` _ - F REZONING PETITION SIGNATURES MCKED PERCENTAGE; p HAILING, LIST PREPARED; MAIL -OUT NOT HRIITEN' News:E = NOTICES RAILED NUMBER:. Puhl `c LEGAL DESCRIPTION TREPARED PUBLICATION NOTICE; WP.ITMf --- _ $ DISPLAY Rr� AD `PREPA HENSPAPER PUSLICATZOtf G P G; B R: DATE OF PUBLICATION: _ INIMkC STUDY PREPARED f1iVIROtIitEtflAL DEIEtttlriATZOrI: Categorical. Exemption FILED.. _,- Na_gative.Declaration: FILED: - - _'- Mitigated negative Declaration; FILED, - Environmental Impact Repo=t CERTIFIED: Other: - STATz CLE'AMIGHOUSE NUMBER: APPLICA14TIREPRESENIATIVE NOTIFICATIOrr OF F.,IVIROtItiE'"rM DETEPHINATIOri PLArIrtIriG CAr4iZ55IOt:' HEARI14G(s):: � ` t Zo• I.:�d IRlrtc�s7: �� BO..AP.n OF SUPERVISORS- � RESOLUTIOrf r{GtIBEX(GPAs)' - ADOPTED: ` GRDI'rANCE tUtE� ADOPTED' . k ttOTTC CF CEI: PsYI'(AII0t1 (aFpendir. H} FILED ax 1 I � d 1 ' 1 C tl � Y d✓t � ,JN J ar, ur,. ia d,1` k?^ Yfi+9''r., t , y,+ t'<" y� t n 1 g; Y .......... � .. .._..l..ar,•., A BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION ; MINUTES'- January*28, "1993` : >. �,.,, V. BUSINESS FROM THE FLOOR ON ITE24S NOT` ALREADY ON THE A ns will be limited to five minutes (Presentatio r AGENDA The Planning Commission is prohibited by State Law from 1 'i I 'I taking action on any a.tem presented i�F it is not listed qq on the Agenda)I. None. j VI. PUBLIC HEARING PROCEDURE ti The Chair will call for: A.lj Staff Comments B.'1, Open the hearing to.the public 1 Proponents 2. Opponents 3 . , , , Proponents rebuttal, ., 4. Opponents rebuttal 1 f C.' Close hearing to the pubs is i D. Commissiondiscussion E, .Motion 4i F. vote It is requested.'tlat presentations be limited to a will maximum of 5 minutes so that all interested parties have opportunity to addres6�the Commission. Following an your presentation,,print. yourname and addressu on ► �1 c^uratL: ,,'.;he speaker+nothe the record will be aA VII. PUBLIC. HEARINGS. ` cy ,;.SlPro posed. Ne 900 a m• eraiaonwith mtigation tioasures regarding � impacts and Use Permit to allow C a private breeding kennel for up to 99 adult I►Ui' (Unclassified) dogs an property zoned of Hutletoih on approxdimatelh a _. 1/4 mil west of Huriet n Swedes P Flat Road, Laky, Wyandotte area, identified as AP ort -290-15p4, OroV�.11e. (y S) (Repuhl ished continued o en from,sanuar 140 1993 Staff said that this hearing had been continued to obtain moreinformatian from Rabies ControlPdA. Staff this tem again '. a mission hearing so, said that the Com previously published and itb� today because on "the, wrong ebut the P rev.ous 'testimony, roti � g �. that the Commission receaved isapplicable. m The hearing was opened to the pih�Lic. r n.. _.M.,. -,.r.-, w . ..... y .riur•ti+,., r w-•,�..w. ..r.,,yr r—+.t µ".. ..-vw. - ....,..i.0 ,a�...+-rv.. V d0.4�17..V41 t i�llN li.tl ` f ' a .4 •tl1 .g; i'!. lPY,� 141G,1}✓;;r K f.. f16 1;1 1 '4,. :�.5 ! 4 ,a e r i.-,- i _� i i �l 1yy} �+ :bf ..Y.. .+s+f � a}} a? ,c b f ;, q' s s . 9;.d : '.a. • :t, app s r� •Mn,` c rh +., t e, ; p-' : . ...:r ,. o. ,i -� , .. sl b , st i,: „ .! J, "r r'r, a �V s�" it ,! . t,xl 46ot! . „'l.l� 5. :• l,ii 1� , ..,L 7 1 .r4r:r!. 1..1.:.. ,� , �;%r7 •"r •, �„ } pr. ,7 , t ,r } l.. t .r} Y, otltir?I - } a!+>:r,., 7 t , i a. r:r i � �1 ,q :''..,.4i..,�,`,ia,.i%5;�:'4Lka. ����i,,-..�i.(«.�$Ya4ltnrl�.r`ii,6'.'.G`.i-+i:l:L:_4�..wdy�l.itit�:`t;.UlL7µ°l..w»9y}.}ct./.isl.:+•rid"1Y:'rkt:L..a:7.t6'sw.Git��.}l,'r1ti:`'y..,!}.,Vrw.;tdu;:...i,.�'.�1.{,..i:': ^..6:Iw..aap•.w+a .,...iia"'w°dw-.l:.d+,4ix.'d.A1Ll,--,Y t.—y' ([. (`1 { N { BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSIOY+i MINUTES January 28, 199`3 �f�[l DonSpeegle representing Ms. Charlotte S ee le, said that Mary Johnson from the SPCA, neverstated her qualifications as Director of SPCA; and that her�g statements were not ever proven to :,be true in Tehama County. Mr • Speegle' said in regard to the neighbors complaining about the, dogs barking, he, had never 'met most of the neighboxfs until the last Planning Commission meeting g . He said he knew three of-his neighbors who had ' never, complained to him, and he has received two anonymous telephone calls by one person in the last five to six years;. Mr. speegle also said a citation has never been issued for barking dogs. Mr. Speegle said that "they;', have 10 acres and have done everything necessary and { agrees with. the :Planning Department to be in compliance.. r� p g Y to answer any questions. Mr. See le offe.�ed .+ aeelleswinds said she purchased poodles,� hod 1984 and 1985ad si e said that he h s� Staken ` her poodles back for breeding and has`also-brought= veterinary,papers for her dogs, that at. no,:time did she ever feel the dogs were not cared for, properly, treated, k and on several occasions, she left her dogs.in,the care of the,Speegles. She also said she•had recently visited the Speegles and 'things have not changed, the animals are y still cared for .and loved. Robert Morris,,said he is 'Mr. Spoegle s. closest neighbor � and' has never :seen the dogs mistreated and has no' Yet , complaints. Speaking in oppc� 'ition of the project: 'i Frank White, said he Lives off of Hurleton Swedes Flat Road and that has concern was the ;noise the dogs make._ " Irene AY..cock 10p4 Hur�.eton Road said that her concern was the dogs bark bonstantly. } Beatrice Garriga , 574 Lodigeview, said that she opposes the' project. She said' she .has a dog, along with veterinary, receipts to show cost for the care of the dog. ri She said she has hAdL the dog for three years and only in the: last year, has she been able to pet him due to thedog being mistreated �R Faye Malone, lii5 Hurleton; said she • v..nted to verify that the petition letter's and everything that had been said at the meeting of January 14 1993, is still valid. ;r proponents%opponents Rebuttal: 't : r� ~ w........,..a:......•,...::..»...r.....,.Ky--...yw..�w>.yn-M•..,...w••..,:,-...,.._.._w+:._.....:w..w.w....a w+>k-,:c:._,w,..,.. ,�...,..-,.- -,-' �w,:. ...,» - .» •,� »., ' UmN �,obw-,NINUT95 ...` janiTTE A� �5I ,: • 's y a N rt. Y ry k w7p4 (1. • n .y '. r N , AT-'y f v�l�M N � Y?yh S 'F 3 1 x le J 1;. � b ,, t u r'. �*, y/r a4. '{ fi Ni :1 1'.1 .. .4•A .1 /!'•4,, y i SS{1{ '1 ,�' +G. ,i r, ,); � i > ii r, �f:; r iix . °,ti;"rjr,°` i rias ..rA:;, .rp,.:.i t Yi+�r,9;C.r, -'�;� �, L )1 A i.'� `�,�..�+Ce • . -I. IY'. . ,:.. rlS.. '." i ''IS1. �4rM A'iA+4 �Aii�` 1 3�.yi li}. •� � tS.,.«,tvw• l� IF j! Cr�'e 'fir rte � •ir (.�^.V i, °'` 1 1.'{ (i"•r �. T bi. L n` 3V,4 �1 ! ���r9 1 kl 4. ", .c4 as W.w triL1 a�zva. v,rF �tu... .17r. w" 4,1L e.� HUTTVE COUNTY: `.PLA'NRJXG COI�ZMTSSION MINUTES - January 28, '1993, • ,t Mr. Speegle said that he does not know Ms. Garrigan and doe1 not recall her ever buying a dog froYn him. He said�� it that if there was evidence,, their procedure, forever, she has a complaint, the Speegles would replace the dog. i g , _ g pound, he .; He said that; if she got the do from the do ng about.: kip; knows nothingof what she. is talking Mr Ms, Carrigan said she had not got the dog from�i from the after ���, Speegle, that she did get .the dog pound the dogs had been tak en away from the family. $� , , gain said that she has purchased dogs Carol Edwards a q goes wrong wi tthp ee e from the Speegles, g they offer to �p Sfeerig]esland the dogs, she contact p bill. She said. that :if you buy , pay Lfor the veterinary ,. animal tro„m`the Speegles, and they guarantee �t,,you E an can count on it: ((,, f "Robert Morris; said that the Speegles have done no wrong I w. and he :has never complaine&. " -.. {{ r y g r yA cock said that f the Speegles are asking for a Ms i 1 -L do c now will the people iri the - permit for dog -► j neighborhood sleep at night?, - Mr-; White''s friend asked the. Commission why. the State', or 'County has not done anything about enclosing the � Wand dogs xn a b wass closed to the public, The hearinguiacl , M Chairman Ly nch's g that if the application is - in nd tion All app co which. has been required roved that a recent ken. el Use Permits be added between Conditions 6 and 7, runs 'shalt be enclosed, which Mate: 'All , ani shall, have concrete floors and enclosed .curbs; and shall :drain into an improved septic systemic , Commissioner Lambert stated that she could not support d¢ rr the project, that her decision is based upon,testiinony received at all hearings. It by 'Commissioner T�ambert, seconded by warmoved Cobmiss3oner Nelson, and' unanimously carded for denial i .,..:.x..--1w^w,...,:...-:.y..-,..-w.-..._rr..,,�r'..w....-rr-"`w""`+ay�„"*��{{�iw.;:ji:_..n4.•r••w}..y..},-•...--,.1...,-j:..«-�t-wN},,--.('!.+w,,,:;-,w+�1, } y,*�ryt'�+ a1 c'lii,GO.`J7 7 Or7 X1114Y VJ;J i 017,1�.L., I. 0 1 .. ... 9'nw `H t ;=0^, .4 vu.uJ+r ^'P✓ _ e.a ,.,. .0 .�.. rye. " ...r..0 NN +w.e:.». A' .:x:.-rM m..:y xu Aoi w a� * iia" " Sof,r Y:._i. Nji+ At �'!' fir, Ns. ray v .1 r ,•. Y=S' . t�.q . _ i r +',, Y hh •,4 ` � r 'r 4+;` I a ail { u l,.a df t ' i:, ld i!, + ?;1 f YI4 A,I " r1A �" A lya !A?'.a � w l' dl 1 t! Y 1 - 1 r1aE,t h �` h i '1 ` �°,, kll'nT�MI�LfA7�✓i41na,.AMh .l. .S r 1 G` } "'�Y ih ilfiY.r i•.j 1 - 1: 1 ��YYIiLILklA.i.f.wvw�r��S �1Y�1_Jf.+. p tXw.»{.I.S g,,hd ( y,p 7Ir�,u ; ItA ^SMr}u.-t.«:As.i A K" :f�dl(ji�{_{').^'*..4W+! U%+R+•,raY.W'i �Y4`HHYi..,�i�c..:,,b.�..a..n3 iA^u 1 y}1 4 I, YYf , 41 fr j 4� , i It was mov by Co �._ mnussioner Ostrowski,. seconded b Commissioner Lamberty and: unanimously 'carried for de y Waal as" follows. A. Note that the ceduirements of CQA have been completed and considered in 1t making this decision; and I3. Find that the proposed use of the property will impair the integrity and character' a� t of the zone in which the land lies and that the use would not be unreasonably incompatible with or injurious to surrounding property or detrimental to the , health, safety, and general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood� or to the general health, welfare and safety of the County, and , , C. Den the Use Permit to allow a dog kennel on AP 072-290-154 (Charlotte y � Speegle). said hearing handled earlier in the �med6g,was continued to 10:30 a.m. �Y`Yi' , and was uiht adverteStaft kle i tly put on the agenda at 9.00 a,m, in error. Staff suggested this f hearing be continued to January 28, 1993 and re -published to 'allow the applicant the opportunity to be present. ! ` It was moved by Commissioner Ostrowski, seconded by Comnriissioner Lambert, and unanimously carried to vacate the previous motion for denial, on the Speegle ,applicationA''L It was moved by Commissioner Ostrowski, seconded by C, ommissioner Lambert, and unanimously carried to republish this hearing) and continue it open to January" 28, 1993 '1! , at 9:00 a.m. I � Commissioner Lambert asked if the comments ' valid from the SPCA and could they were earin ,;. the comments are on the ,record and can Staff said d staff will request Ms be usedan , Johnson come to the January 28th meeting also. l,A I 1 BLtT'OTJfV',�` px�A�S�C c+gk�isbR MNUTS�, v n ariva.r x;4 :l 99 3 - 11 1 r . y,. Y,A,..,A�.. r p ,tdr ,4` u 4 e •.,? 4 G: it iy • 4_f :7—. ( LNw 6 k,: 4A `A•.rk rn �'a�.l r '4, !nA'n Wk- FyY t rrT *1 �r n „ F � ��Y, 14i � Ykf � '4V •,. rr...dti , , ..s• „r , �: x, `' 6 l , ,,x ] ',:.�. . r.. e. ,tJr4 : iy aVb,e 4 e .. y'te , U ,.,t^..i rit ' 3. ..' , r A�.�.:q..f-d�,r�.4.:I�.,....u.k��r;.�i,+.m..ei.L=.t=-1,�i�.lil..1.�4..�'t:,YSuli'!.;ow'U-f1G},d+1r0w%��•.,."....1.w."�4qi,�:.-,it01'.4.��,,::11�•i✓w»w'kr4 .w.w.+.,,,r..J w�a�+k:i,F�,...,.m�h+.,.�a.,»�-.�-•,.-.a,=:+•-k;».++:.wr.�:r,',:+,...;."+,..«.Jstl,.4 91 ..4 �1 • Charlo tom,.- SAe_e le proposed Ng 9:00 a:m, p p gt:. Live .. De rad tion with mitigation Use Permit to measures regarding E.n� ironmental impacts and allow a private breeding kennel for up to 99 adult dogs on property zoned U i1r (Unclassified) located. on the north side of Hurleton Road, approximatelya 1/4 mile west of Hurleton Swedes Flat Road, Lake Wyandotte area, identified as AP 072-290-154 Oroville. CBS Continued open from ( ) p December 10, 1992 h she was not in the room during the last Commissioner Lambert nosed that Although g g meeting she did listen to and viewed the hearing on the monitor in Administration's conference room. Staff said Tom Reid is present .representing Rabies Control and a member of the SPCA is also present. Staff submitted a memo from; Tom Ree, Environmental Health. Commissioner Nelson asked if the Speegle's have a permit is for 50 dogs now, and 80- ;0 90 dogs were observed on theProperty? } Tom 'Reid Dire ' Reid, Director of Environmental Health, said the permit wasdf�he 9dogW elate there were more than 49 dogs observed on the property, H&,said permit revoked becauseregulations were not complete or coinpf ed with, nt, said that the Speegle's came in on the Earl Yuunly, Enviromnent4l. Health Department, ' . � t g last day of licensing and Miss Speegle signed an affidavit that she had met all regulations And, had under 49 dogs He said Vvlien the property was inspected there were over 200 - C' dogs and the permit, was revoked; 1' ' Mr, Reid said that the Rabies Control staff was called as a witness only m Tehama County. Thehearing was opened to the public.J ' K The SP eegles were not present. Mefty Johnson, Director of the SPCA said there have beencrudity g $�. against the Speegles She said there have been numerous complaints.She said the of coms. their ts were to tion froth the ptoo lin 1 .+..n , i , She submitted ofthe kd en eels showing the conditions, She said she photospoor , 18 dogs that w'epre taken away from the Speegles m Tehama County. She described the • .. poor condition of the dogs, She said there .have been continued reports of problems on ^rm ; the Speegle property, She asked that this permit be denied, Thebearing was closed tJTT C0C1NI"t PLI�IWN±NG COM1 S xdiq M Nt] S .'i7antila ,4 Y;9Sl r 77 ty * y • r': W W 1 } .i'F r� F Q,*a}�'. rLy n +r; • � �Yk'. t, Y � f .W r• +•} 3. 3", T e« k, ,F .. The Commission waived the reading of the Staff Findings. A video of the site was shown. r �+ Commissioner :Nelson asked if there was a Menne l there now. Staff said not to their knowledge. Staff said they can not prove how many dogs are " presently on the property. Staff said they have heard dogs and would guess from 15-20 �. dogs are present. Chairman Ost rowski noted. a petition recery received in opposition �::nd a letter from Mr. Malone and a letter from Mr. Callahan,in opposition, 4 The hearing was opened to the public. e, Mr. See 1e s p g said this application speaks. for itself. lie said he has tried to be a good neighbor. Commissioner Lanibert was absent at this time. t, ' w Chairman Qsirowski asked if this was going to bean indoor kennel of not more than 60 clogs over 4 mo:iths GF age? , Mrs Speegle said he was in, agreement with the, conditions, lie said he was willing t g o � do whatever the County requires. Commissioner Matson said this is a large parcel and asked if the kennel could be moved to the rear of the property? Mr. Speegle said the kennel can be put wherever the County says. Mrs: Malone said she has lived there 17 years. She said the; sound carries and it is F difficult to sleep froth the noise: She strongly protested this kennel. Cheryl Maclntosh said the sound carries up the hill to her property and she can not have ;7 { company because of the noise of the dogs: y 'a Jill Brewster` sa'd she is bothered in the suni er by odors connected with Mr: Speegle's dogs. She was concerned about the quality of her well being affected. $lie was co ncernerl with Otho value of her ptOperiiy going down if' the kennel is approved: Jeff :Macintosh said the dogq on-site now are not controlled, and he -lid not want ;firs permit approved and the situation to get worse: ide was ;against the permit: 10TTL i 0bbNTY PLAN'NxNa 'r� �» Decehtb e� �,0 �.9 9 MMx'SSx©1� 141 NUTl;S a 1;;. '77F.. t 4 t r0' i ^ r r •yl 1 T i � � 4 Y ^'n� T � +y l A:. �.�,.i.C.+,i:;.:.riJ:.'1•.CYIISAY'.uaatS: M1hL5'fAi.�wi�{St�ili7%�.�....•+•-M•�� f.iMA.+�ii I�i; �'r. a:Yid:1:tt1�31-..+ww+F"'...r..+'-IrrA+�.+N++Ld'.u'l+aYuwka�.LdL{1sCw"1-�-^.is7Yw`..k.w'flJ.fk.1�L1irSSl,l•:N/ L ami fi ° 19L�11 is + '. U11A w; I tl •,. e p�. s 'health and was a anst the noise a kennel would'+� Ed Brewster said :he moved here for hi 'h g i cause. Franklin Callahan said the noise is terrible. He said if the kennel is approved the noise, • will et worse. He said, in February 1991, Tehama ,Coon confiscated the g County animals from1; Speegles. Count Mr. Speegle said lie has a suit pending against Butt theyn se ! County the Speegles were wanted. He said n charges were everp rov n and he ". guilty of anything. Jerry ne agreed Aboutthe se. He said he understands Mr. Speegle conditions. not f aMal n puppy, avit terrible Mrs. Macintosh .said she would like to hoar from Mr. Speegle on how many dogs he has on the property now: r • y number of dogs on the property. Staff said the can not verify the r Mr. ,;Callahan said the lady 'in charge of the SPCA is familiar, with the case in Tehama Where the 'Speegles' dogs were confiscated. `r ,, Mr. Speegle directly, how many dogs were on his property Conunl r)ner Nelson asked atthis, P? • r. S end if he did know he wds not wWin g to say. He said o • . e said eve one hastobe somewhere Hp said 'they tried to move to Tehama County. H r ' the SPCA in Butte County phoned' Tehama County to tell 'them they were moving there. y d confiscate He said between Butte Coun Tehama County, and other Counties the di tY, !t } , approximately 100 to 150 purebr.'ed dogs: He said 'ie is :in ill health and can nrit work kennel is to his daughter with a n income an d g 1 �11 provide because of Koppers. die said the: P .. neighbors from the noise, it will also protect the nei P Chairman Ostrowski asked what breed the Speegles sPecialixed in? I Mr. Speegle said tiny toy poodles. He said dogs do bark. y Commissioner Nelson said there was a signed statement by him or Charlotte 'to keep �9 dogs )nty in 1990, He said; the license was revoked for having an excess of 50 or more � dogs 4 he was ` thees were dro ed. He said lie aid a fine the first ttrr�e Mn; p g g s Behar was cited the char were dropped: ` Gond time he _ g S He saaid cited. 1• d with the lice Commissione�. Lynch said he Was Concerne rise being revoked: He said the Commission needs to know ii the license was re-nstatedr d , sr�.. T�ecembo` l.0 >:� x.99 BtiI'Tl CbL1N'IL L'tAN1�ING G(�NYM�SS�ON lvi�I�CIT I.+ a �... man �• : �: w. ..r; w„_„ , a �r-, , s r� � s„ IR ., '. •�' ,! br i N4 a^A "Pi *�` ✓ Aw Nf ,.YRIa 14 k'Q k'r ,h AP Jt ir.�� w� "'+ P r+�a • ti Yi p, w • S, S k. I r 44a ,'tFi 9 rP:; ?�i.11a�S'ri :i,: +l y:;C�l�1 A: :v''c1l>,c.slxt,�N d., 4 '-.. k'Liw;,�,4 �3wb711::iY "Yds,:". M'��Ifl:sia, ,Y.'iS:wF,::RV%:*,.wr+:-'T +,•1•.•�.•.-,wr.w.�.r>•wru.wP�'u,`ars>xar=+k.w;'+'.t't�taSik�wiR..N:uar iNt�7y:Y .lova Cx+44c. I Sl�f( the best of their knowledge the license' has not been re -13SUe Staff said d• t0 g Commissioner Lynch said there is a false statement being ;made that a Planning permit 4J[ 4 �X had been issued for the site when'irn fact it was not. 5; . e license was legally' taken away. Mr. S Oe lL said p g he did not know that th g Y Commissioner Lynch asked Mr. Speegle if he made a statement to the Planning r Department that he had Planning clearance for his kennel? , Mr. Speegle said he has not signed any statement. Staff'' noted the statement on Planning Clearance was made by Charlotte Speegle. _ Chairman Ostrowski asked if the STC40 specifications confine the noise of the kennel? Staff said, the standards would reduce the noise by about 38 Dbs. ' Commissioner Lynch said an indoor kennel would be concrete. He asked if there were any outdoor kennels or runs would they also be concrete? Staff said this would depend on the number of dogs allowed outdoors. He said this K would be a condition of the Health Department. Commissioner Lynch- sa4,�, the Commission has required in the past all runs be concrete: •greed. and drain into a se tics stem. Staff a Commissioner Lynch asked .if staff 'went p y r on-site? i G` ,+ Staff said they were on the proposed site for the kooriel only, not the whole property. Commissioner Matson said the breed and number of dogs should be stated as conditions if this permit is a rayed:. P PP Staffsaid this is handled in Condition $, that the permit would be limited to smaher dogs. Commissioner Lynch said he wanted someone from R' ables Control, and the SPCA _ . present to talk to the Commission and answer questions: He recommended that this item be contlnue& it was moved by Commissioner Lynch, secondedby 'Comriussioner Matson, and carried to continuo this hearing open to January 14,, 143 at 10;30 a.m, and requested staff contact Rabies Control and, the SPCA 'and any official agency or person that have investigated this site to be present at the 1.4.0 meeting i , i'llll� x 0 BU` ! cobI y PLANNt 11 CO 88ION MIxtjTLlS b.eo , .9 . c , I`J �1N 1 ICH+ � ,ukk S�J �.MJ _>h Y H' /'•.1y * �� S� d r ! .'1 1 wYC Y`,N � S _ ln,T i ,wu {I 5 i klli � '��' 1 ��- .. If 1 ! ¢ �K.� W^, Y '.I , V �I k III I `,, yds 1 �A • W ��{ 1 I " ,1= li 4 I�'li ^� t� ' i �j i , A 1 ' �� , 7•f 5{Y ,l{ 1' 1 1 � ,I� d17�7,.. A1F t Y1 I •{ 1 I �,+' d ' „`�N ni � { I i ' �Itl� FN1 k :ji y)1p vY., k. i• t } k 1� I 2 y `, k Y 1rp r "."1ni:�(i`w..,i,'Ii.IC'.i%.�il�1Ci6:«i ."�f!'it�BYtbYhtWitiur N}�R1�'•,W��..uu�aaRWu.. "furMGI,N.n.+ysr..-.,.,..�.w.umwu:+u.tx.cu)uv�+t�'.�tk54:ik Dfi{�!!'«3St:Y&'liLiWlt3te+lt�s�1 � .. .t..'{��e1.Id�7Yb�+�fl�iti4t'liGinl)�.�:��L�:L�.i}:11�'iGl�lSh9�t�51S$4�,:"1Pu14M31a:^.`.!'a4uliu+ixl�Ytii3L!N-lidY't�LtiF=�'•.t' r .01 tib 1 t g continuance, but h N.os' Commissioner Nelson said he would .�► ree to the, c e has real orobh— with this permit request: APES: Commissioner Matson, Lynch) Nelson, and Chairman. OstrowFsk s NOES: No one ABSENT: Commissioner Lambert Commissioner Lambert WAs listening; to the hearing in the Administration Office and W �.l b i able to. participate in the .deetsion on January 14th: k„ D No one r t A t, 1 � _ i gm� r COUNT2 p AN=N; MITES .. ... ._ a , f . }[ ' } R1 NR 1 W .jN `✓ysf��}•�1�1 k {ibd'» yf 8 ,rly..i.W yr u r + 7—Tr t .. 6r I t Qli r„,fir i 3�-; t;rY 1 `VrT i h'. to l? 'v .✓{ i il` v�;.�. I� s I t i ,..a 1 M1 , s 1� t t''• J, f' ! q','i r r ?r rr'' 0 •'�.�,yN e e•7 ; f , , 1 7 r rt i "44 jia r�� � J r ,, ” t a ¢ , l ,r r• ' v i° ' !p , d l r r i i , I ,, y { F ,, I� ,,, a e ti, k i Y4. `♦. r.a 14{ r �t4>Se �!i � �;i, t� C j4� ,..',1, 1. iy P ':"a , t.., •, '.!{t5 t a. ' ,il , ; � 'f+g , 1 ,•'e,;. Isr t{ J,1 (i. :'ia+' +aM1� �, t+ '"'.�u�.ti u�,iaw�.atA�k�.: ' ' ,i 1s �,»��; F{a�:,5f �+in�ida'�a.46i iicuty ,�r.r.�IG'1..>.�,r.tv,•.,.,„yw:,w�is:.u��.{��i�-'.}...a �.wer;::1"rca.,-����1,,,..« s:,at.�,ii� , a_«f.,r ..w...,.-� k '' >S;et`�b� (J -1tryk 93'-52 Public hearing. ' charlotte tpeegle, consideration of an PPEaI eJ'' of the. 'Plann.ng,,rComm nssion s2 ,dental mid a use permit , iprApasec ilagat;i.� e,.�de ..laration with mitigation w l ' onmental impacts) measures ,.regarding envirto ,ralluw a,�4 pXvate breeding kennel for up to 99 adult dogs on , property located on propezµty zoned n n (unalAssified), the north side of,Hurleton Road, approximately 1/4 mile west of IIurleton Swedes Flat Road, Lake Wyandotte area, AP 072-290-1540 Oroville'area;. (92,8) MOTIQUi.I MOVE TO UPHOLD THE APPEAL AND (A) MAKE THE APPROPRIATE FINDINGS (1-4); AND (B) ADOPT A e( NEGATIVE DECLARATION WITH MITIGATION:MEASURES AND GRANT A USE PERMIT TOALLOW A KENNEL ON AP j �072-290154 (SPEEGLE) SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS 1 14 (WITH C09DITION NO. 9 AMENDED TO 111v-10 MORE THAN 5 DOGS OVER THE AGE OF 4 MONTHS MAY BE KEPT -ON THE PREMISES UNTIL THE -INDOOR KENNEL IS COMPLETED AND INSPECTED BY RABIES CONTROL.” M VOTE: 1 2 3 a, 5 NP (Motion Dies/Lack of Second)` MOTION: I MOVE TO (A) NOTE THAT THE REQUIREMENTS OF k CMAKING EQA HAVE H ' IN S BEEN DECISION No COMPLETED (B) D FIND THAT THE PROPOSED USE OF THE PROPERTY WILL IMPAMTHE i ER OF THE ZONE IN WHICH �T 1NTEGR AND CHARACTER THE LAND LIES AND THAT THE USL WOULD BE UNREASONABLY INCOMPATIBLE WITH OR IN'MIOUS TO t� SURROUNDING P1tOPERTY OR DETRIMENTAL TO THE`{{ HEALTH, SAFETY, AND GENEi2�'1L WELFARE OF THE J PERSONS,,RESIDING RESIDING = QR WORKING- IN THE �A NEIGHBORHOOD OR TO THE GENERAL HEALTH, WELFARE AND SAFETY OF THE COUNTY BECAUSE OF NOISE AND SANITAT`i0N IMPACTS AND (C) DENY THE APPEAL FOR A. USE PERMIT TO ALLOW A XENNET� AOR DOGS ON; E ; XP d75�29Q-154 (SPEEGLE). VOTE. 2 Y M F.. (t�tioh Carried) • 1N E HUTTE COfJ ' Y BQAA Ox' SU EN ISORS 'MINI3TE5 - MarCY�. 9, ���993 z, re I,r � S r ♦,., to �, 'v N.e, A N �` . a y.v k" r ,., i � � iN�.r 4' c•k a 04 it I '7 f i f : �'�, ✓� �Yt 1 ".1 ! 6 � .1 Y R f i.�. t 1 I i! y ;��1 y� '.F 1 •J 1 y � � YI r I 1 1� i � I 1 , '. I I G Y/". I 6 � Ylilt�6.,:.:.1 ,�lu�aif�1S.�S�Jall..,�y:S�.4'�i��.",.�,�i�,vL.i�d���':la„'�i7::h�iS1��;.:"s4..�4,�"'�i.�i'.�iA�i:R1�u_"�Li•. 'i �1i%�'�.,s«���.rAu��w'�'�:,<..�eca�1,°..,a.,�'rii�:��.Pii-�..::i.'�,......Alu�i.4u;°�°.:�:�:5.;:�A:tlLs'.:�aY:asc::a�.�t�cs:Vrura�:�+1�maAa3�a.�flli.:xk:.k~::u.,,,C,.:.iI�,.S�Xd.°....+�.§o»,� ,, 4 FILE NO: 072-290-154 ; 1 9LITi'E COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS - _November 4, 1992 .APPLICANT: Charlotte-Speegle "NER3_ Same )� REQUEST: Use Permit tri allow a 99 dog kennel , AP' NO.: _ I 072-290-154 `SIZE: 10.02 acres I I LOCATION: Located on the north side Hurleton Road a roWmatel 4 mile west off, Hurleton Swedes pp Y 1 /- Flat Road, Lake Wyandotte area, east of Oroviile k EXISTING ZONING: U' r ZONING! S'S' TORY: Zoned U on Sept. 17, 1985 by Ord 2488 \.: i SURROUNDING ZONING. U l SUG LAND USE: Vacant parcels, rural residential ntial Iand lases: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Agricultural Residential ' APPLICABLE' REGULATIONS: Butte County Code Sections 24-47, 24195, 4; _ 31 , CO MMENTS RECEIVED. Enyironrhental Health - Must install Under permit froni out office'a 10b0 gallon septic tank and -+�50` of 2�'SS wide leach field, 4 I I; 4 I y, f , , i I I, R7777 AAL r a I C11 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS - Novevnber 4, 1992 Public Works - Driveway must meet County requirements. Hichw y Patrol -No, significant impact, F I" ANALYSIS: This is a Use Permit request to allow a private 'breeding kennel for up to 99 dogs. The property is located on the north side of Hurleton Road, approximately 1/4 mile west of Hurleton Swedes i Flat Road, near Lake Wyandotte, The area is rural, with the parcel sizes ranging from 5 to 20 acres, and is mountainous with the average Slope on this parcel exceeding 20%. The applicant has apparently, hada kennel on this site since 1985 and up until 1990 had a kennel license, for no more than 49 dogs, issued by the Butte County Rabies Control Department. From o land use perspective, a Use 'Permit was never granted and the kennel legally It of a change in Section 4-4 of the Butte County Code na1990e ,theRabies l abies Control Department began requiring all people applying for a new or renewal kermel license to sign an affidavit stating that they had complied with all Planning and Environmental Health Department requhernents. The applicant signed, such a statement in July , of 1990 and received a kennel license for up to 49 dogs, Upon an inspection of the site in November of 1;990, the license was revoked for failure to have valid rabies certificates, for all dog = and exceeding the kennel capacity key 50 to 70 dogs. It was also discovered that no Planningpermits had been issued for this site. The applicant was informed of the requirement for a UPermit In December of 1990 and made pre -application in May of 1991, The application was deemed complete in April of 1992, The applicant has chosen a site on their propert)j that is westerly of their existing mobil home: 'the area is about 100' from Hurleton Road and has ! %,nen previously leveled. The level area ' is approximately 1/4 acre In size. The property rises steeply to the north from this level area N and is heavily vegetated: r 'the impacts and concerns with this type of use Include'noise and sanitation problems, With the. potential for 99 adult dogs and an unknown number of puppies on the property, the noise fffrom the site could be a nuisance to existing and future 'neighbors The kennel site is near the i bottom of a valley that forms a type of natural amphitheater, 'When staff visited the site, the dogs could be heard barking from varying distance depending upon the terrain. The closest resldence' is 300' to the south. There are two other homes to the southeast that are both a roximatel 500' awa from the proposed kerinel location, The roe to the west is an pp Y y p p property undeveloped 2-0 acre parcel= The negative impacts of having a kennel in this location Increase as the area population grows: Ho overs even with a rezone, it is not ahticipatea that the area will develop into parcels of less than 5 acres. Noise impacts can be lessened by u, 1g retaining natural vegetation on the slope to the rVth, and providing a noise attehuatin'9 features to the south, east; and vest such as a solid wood fence combined with shrubbery► y.yr _ 2' I - r 7 ' ' c �, .. F l� pt e� t ✓MY,�, r. ,. i 1 a w: I K r 1 . x . Y :iV J ' tr' f i ;nt iFC��V�i�t1{}+1a 9„Fswij1S;rlsakfi�UYlxsww�d rwxsxurfIIca htitw^s ttxzaa x ra+w . 1 �1 1 , G�fIT°i f� ;r"t1"INTY'PLANNING COPAL MISSION 5 'AF f FINDINGS - November 4., 1992 { hay bales. ,A more permanent solution to the noise problerd",;'to construct indoor kennels. l l Sanitation d6pld also be a problem since the dogs will 1 �.3 limited to an area that is f^ tuber of dogs pr.lposed the slopes on site, the low approximate 7f ' 40 . Given the .nu s rea permeability �.f annat ondw labete thigh hunless sill wastes a e� pa ed' on areceives� regularthetbas sl for surface water contam _ ., ti tank or the kennels ar,a constructed with concrete floors that are, drained to an�approvededin small and leacn field system. it should pe noted that the applicant specializes in bre g j ooc'les that produce significantly.ire;,.+wastes than a large breed. The amount of noise' and 1 breed sews 6generation would be aff ced by the kennel operator changing the type breeds bark `ll 'g more than oithei s h,,+ously, q lar'e breed will produce more wastes and some �d !r l 4�i With the potertial for up to,140 to 150 dogs on site, including pQr�p es; it is important that County Environn ibnAal Heayth Department and Rabies Control D. pay+r+'s gent have access to the site to insure proper saniftLion and rabies vaccinations including stags cm � the dogs as required by Section 4-4 of the Butte County Code The; appi�cant has stated t'rtiat she is willing to construct indoor kennols with an approved sewage,disposal system at soma time in future but wishes to use pczrtahle kennels on sand or N pea graven at this time, WawAe disposal will be either chemical treatment or a holding tank. Noise attenuation will be i ni-ited to the use of straw bales, fences, shrubbery or some combination thereof. These methods could be acceptable for a lesser amount of dogs but are i inadequate for the number of doge proposed, 'Unless indoor kennels with an apt roved Nage p y constructed project should not be supported or it should b : limited p y_ disposal s stem ae constru ed 'the to no more than 25 4�dult pcocnles with esodic venficr�tion b Rabies (. s F ' L- E Ht'iwith indoor kennels itis recom►;'anded th, the number of dogs be limitod to no rrt -than +;II�1;adult dogs. RECOMMENDA T S NS: i A� Note that �iSR3 requiremel�'�: of CEQA have been completed and considerud in M(M: inp i this decision,, and t B, Fina thet'the ro used Ll of the roe will impair the integrity and character of the �pr p p, p rtY p 9 p. zone in whld7 iho lana iiE;s and that the Use would not be unreasonablyIncompatible with or injurious to surrour+::ing property or detrimental to the health, safety, and general Welfare of the persons eesidin or Workingin the neighborhood or to the general health, ' welfare and safety of the Co untyy becaue ; and: C, bevy the Use ,Permit to allow a kennel dogs on A.P, 072-290-154, (Speegle). t if the Coal missloh cah make the, required findings, then it would be appropriate to make the 'r following `motion. { , roe' � r M • ak t', .. > x , i„ i tE• ! , k*ki .. i "a {, +Y't, N r urSrMA�44wX:`lz—+Y.lYi .,.(Frx=(J'+tlItd�tx,Lu. "..��..7.--.M.So-H�i,.�..ai:+�i+�ti-�+�1.Tk�*+.OidO`-Ti.S:i9Yl�k'aui::':._1,'xi-.'+.b.4=w"R+a'ws:e:.?Fr } °a,.It,.i^ ti,�bwiii�YNLk14riG4<s:Y.a..:�'4C1-Y�tlnlafNAMV.'.4..�d.MiWYrW k+flk"..:ayo.NYJ:.W1i..:Y�%L•a+Y' x. F C BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS - November 4, 1992' . MQTIOW ACCEPT THE NDATIONS O F STAFF MEMO DATED "AY 4 UNDER November 4, 1992; MAKE THE FINDINGS LISTED U; , MAKE" THE MOTION LISTED UNDER "B" INCLUDING THE y 4CONDITIONS LIS1"ED 1 THROUGH A, Find that;11 + 1. An `iriaf study was completed in compliance with the California Environmental I ; Q,ialiy Act. • , k' 2. Said stlady and comments received thereon identified poten�ial significant i -' environmentaleffects that the project may have had, but: E , a. Provisions in the or proposals made by or 'agreed t� by the. =pIani r e such effects o ai Kip uch effects o, Mitigate pointi' ffects where clearly no significant environmental a would occur, b There is no subsantial evidence before the County that the project as f revised may have significant effect on the environment 3, l he proposed Negative Declaration with mitigation measures has: heart t completed in compliance with the California Environmental �Uuality Act, f 4, The proposed Use of the property will not impair the integrity nor character of the , es and that the use, would not be zone In which the land 'li'unreasonably x incompatible with or injurious to surrounding property or detrimental to the health, safety, and general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood or to the general health, welfare and safety of the. County, because t and B. to ation with mitigation measures and grant a use Permit to allowMove a keadonnel on�AP 012 290-154 (Speegle) subject to the following conditions k 1: Construct indoor kennels with exterior walls that have an STC of 4C1 or greaten ? The floors shall be concrete and be designed to allow the cciliectioh of wastes to a coileCtion point that is hooked up to an approved "septic tank and leachfield system installed Under permit from the Butte County Environmental Health Dept, Y Na more than 60 dogs over the age of 4 months may be on the property at any time:. 4' hTr d WW'77li X + • � Y W r x t a f'. w.6 M m`A,' 1 *'I Oxy ii,lu�it.�"4Y.r14:n.tkrgtcvixSelu.hl`;YuluearY'q,!•1Je4.ia.ssLxi,�k4,rr�fis.;i�r.,wwttik:a�l1'1ilStib:°�'-i,�iq+r'�`�.:w=-,�1�.'"••r�:»l+lir.:31..4,L»t1'3is4.Mii�G=w�'?sent$.;teArm:,..i„,rc.:+ircwtwr+e+al-+:#c=i1:3C,*,Lrfk.Y,l'td:•„"+F! xi#:eA'x[:lutt:"+btwra�.K, { t ' i BUTTE 'COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF_ FINDINGS - 'November 4, 1992 a 3. Kennels shall be located at least 50' away from any drainage $wale on or off site; 4i County .Health Dept.,Iat all s Control. 5. a valid kennel license issued by Butte The pp ty Butte Goun kennel licensed and aecolrtlance w th Sect onr4-4 of theliButtle 5. All do s shall wear, a colla the and J' {J County Code, 6. Dog runs are to be kept clean so as not to create an odor or fly problem. Removal of fecal matter is to be done on a daily basis and disposed of in a i71 ' manner' acceptable to the Butte County Environmental Health Department. 7. This Use Permit shall not run with the land and shall terminate upon the lease, rental, or transfer of ownership of the property. y Dogs kept in the kennel shall be limited t- breeds that generally do not weigh more than 15 to 20 pounds as listed by the'. American Kennel Club. E 9: No more than 25 dogs over the age of 4 months may be kept on the promises until the indoor kennel is completed and inspected by Rabies Control. The following temporary noise attenuation measures shall be used: 1 r A. Retain natural vegetation to the north beyond a distance of 301, Vegetation- , within a minimum of 30'shall be cleared for fire protection purposes in all directions in accordance with GbF's recommendations; B. Install noise attenuation barriers along the south, east, and west sides of the kennel, The design of these barriers shall be approved by the planning Division 1' of the Development Services Department, K 10 ' The applicant' shall, allow periodic Inspections by the Environmental Health Department and Rabies Control to' insure health and sanitation regulations are ` being compiled with. ' 11 Y Applicant shall obtain building permits and a septic permit for the existing i structures as required `12 Applicant shall Pay aI delinquent property taxes r`lor totekennel being established, ' f l t { 5 i i 1 s, ., p, :w.,.v. w. -eyrr ca ,....,,.:.r..- r-;..-.wtY!^fMra.:x,.-y-.:. Mu...w •yrfwaw :a'rw+w,asWw':.,r ... .y :. r_, -w. ..: ,,..,4u_. «.. i "yt 1 P kk e '4t ` a ik Sw i x 4a 1 �•.• I I A A f � i � it -i I i �I •fil }'4h. }.I� I } 31 Y' x;.14 fi + Y F ;.`(` 17W1 i l w! :�r1 1 9 ! it � i 4 1 " n H i V ky � II 111° Y y 'r y'Y�• I " `' � �"" � �'' �t�t� j l } , 1S{ MY� k � K .•�.^ �4 x ���� Y IJ � �,} t I i"n �� w v i I T "p, t I Y ' :,.� r ''"F kry , I I 't n „1,_, Sl�a'.^1r �1,4 ��'! s tY 1l"'t� i i� '�e. Akt �ty��13yW fk.C. �•'a Y1 n^' k `'�Y '1'1 y A � } �' t' I! M to �" "f � �i i4tr"itlaitv�S�."h,.4i.ilk:`&tts�iulta >�i N µ,cvu::<e�uc.�'.s�n�n�ceFua.�ira;...:;�v;�;irW�, c&:.�^ r�::=1q,' '1��,;il�,;,i.'�;,'�9,r 4r.• .:#.+usW°:dix:tuu�s'arl.4m, Y' !' '� `' �Q :nc "� 1rP4i.t.[t: 4i " "..i�'�t+srv,:.�,k„«,.,:wiwW.�it:rhi:5u::7�"C7i+�,1r +dur:,et�'=.vk4us4a�• i• Z9.„ �titi ,w.v _ r B' TT COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS 'November 4,A992 13. Applicant must also comply withi all, other applicable State and local statutes;,, ordinances and regulations. I i CBS.cS Attachments to Commission and cities: EnvironmentalDocuments Site Plan Location Map` I ; q i _ w 4 IrfC, 6 I 1 ,t 7, xa rti, c': is a t� t APPLICATION 0 ;111"S iPEi�M9'� BUTTE COIUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION APPLICANT: Read and follow Instructions asset forth on attached sheet. �•G� Phone No, Applicant's nat7e;* .,.•-1-1� Appiicantas`mailiriy`'addresa /1271 aMa td j Appilcant's Interest in property (Owner, ;lessee, other) owner's name and address Contact person for project, (if other than applicanE)/N� 1 P t zR iszoning.zj�,, a� ►�.®�� � 1% �.,r Pr Assessor's parcel number(s) ,..r "' esent and size of parcels) i Ute tj S c7%-�3,'TA7N _rR S' a /11, a rv� �.re< 11 I C� �� f� e � )4t) L.PTof`1 i2 r bgoul l t-e c'°d�ir f5 'rte Street address—.fn..1-�----.-.---5� Directions for travel to property (rural and mountainoUs areas only)-. 11}&- Y-- ��"f�,��3 It t4i 61 1 i Trow &) -f4 V L t-r T C5 AJ t-f u P L 1?16 0 Rcl ; ti development and use'' a -0I tdct ko-kw& L. _ 130i C ..J Descri flon of proposed ON G gD I A dz a F. 'C� 1PQ Q 7) L r ,_ " o C-� R A u f �.- W ... ---77 U- Tk (, L l;" R 12d1L,5 �j 51 l L.t iZ rt Description of existing land U86 lAnarzaL4- aaz-Ewe, A- 1 hd/'I`n - � Preposed schedalinglassavetoamentects L,� �Itb bet_ ks N�At� Ahticipated Incremental de I p e _P , ~' �'O WC, L) dimensions) square foota 3and used) l .... J building constuction (stats (fit t, l LAR L 1= 1�Nt l AtJ •Zd X l 5 -- 11 �„ a. f=xistin9 bullditigs' fz. b, proposed bulldlhgs._;F C 'Hazardous rflaterials to be used (inflammables, explosives or strong ohemicaia) dally hours of operatlon Number of ehiployees - u_ Number of tiff-s'tteet parking spaces provided �r Eklst)nglproposr;d sewage disposal method'., Proxihilty of power and phone llhest CSN 51T' ` blstance to natural water course cr storm drain'1-----�-- /S/ P Le A, Anticipated on and off=site drainage 1mproverrl C,e nentst . Z p Water yrof Y a ing.purposes (hydrants, fonds; eros) ,._..�; �n'►' = ._.��n}'7'a �"d �'i` �"�Oi12 V,1=.,yaU,c.f_ w for/ Proxlmitwater f re fight 't i' i a ��j 'N(11 exr;avatlonor grading be haoes`saYy�l Cubic yards ,(estfhtate)+_ `' a , ,.. t ,.° 1+41e N. Y� �,f�i3Y .$�F ♦1'tµ N ISY., ° Twy+ �M�� "y+" P 4 �, .,, ..+7 c� w I i ,�: 1 ,. t 1 t til .� � i ✓ ��"t r � � ' '� �'t,�w.'�'.�r+�..lea: ue5 Slu,+s4„u• v.,-•q..n,1,M1r.%„=�1�W".aWA%'45R-t{nEcfdib.-i.:s'-W+hbxt !TT «r -,-.w.k.. ,-�.w .� ,.-a..ww �.M.....elx.,+.,.,eso:�.,.:r...-�++w.lt+?[o1S=`uS."',:„, ydCw • r e List and describe an other related permit other ubilc a vale re uiYed for thls'pro act, Including those required b Y p s P pP„CP q 1 g q y } t)gJonal,' State- and Federal agencies: city, re �J IF RESIDENTIAL, InolUde the number of un(ts, whether units are dingie or multi-story In Height, schedule of unit sizes, and type of household size expected. N E} f IF CQMMERCIAL, indicate the type, whether neighborhood, city or regionally oriented, square footage of sales area, end � loading facilities,` !94es 1t �t(=A) 0 t.-6A011U6- QfG,G file s � �(�A-Ije, + © ftwumcc91 J YPe, estimated employiF INDUSTRIAL, intlfcate tmerit pee,shlitt and loading facilities, ju f}< C Tv N y, ,..; and community benefits to be tlerived from the project.j estimated 'employment per shift, _estimated occupane loading achities IF INSTITUTIQNAL, indicate ) . N N —1 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTs AND MITIGATION MEASURES* i , -I Identify poteri ally significant environmental Impacts associated With the use permit. What project design features or spe,i,3'Jal f conditions, of approval (mitlgatioirmeTsures) are proposed to alleviate potential environmental Impacts? f 00 yeti-wIKC )tke-u"f"Alr` Mpa�-fi ��-i•1C,r�astTicN ; ENVIRONMENTAL Nl NG O�Desdibe )eproject site as It exlsts before the project, Including information on tbp"o raph , soit stability, plants and ani- H mak, 'and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects, bescribe any existing structures on the site, and the use of the structures. Describe the surrounding properties, .Including Information on plants and animals and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects, Qt Indicate, tlie type or )and use (residehtlal, commercial, eto,) Intensity of land use (single -family, apartments, shops, depart d` ment stores, eta.), and scale of deVelopment (height, frohtage, setback, rear yard, ptc,). I .r Use separate sheet for longer responses, r rh i s t s O- o oT k t L L; ,t o--o)4 tv t' L7 es�r k i} �d I't � �� ti i ` 0.etiaS S r ie skv s 1, ib V w�it, Ic ., Nie- e. 11Ava, 4168 I't�s}u rwcl i 5,hcq p C p a�cn�t`7_�Tec fi 1-hereby declare under penalty of perjury that I have read and understand the Instructions and that the Ioregoing statements are true, complete and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief, Date ; C7 A )loant s signature Date Property owner's signature ✓ j I Use Permit Number, i kdgtiest; Use permit to allow Locat[on and site of parael(s), , V�PipY . ject e.. crlP tloh 5 Ownership ✓ zaning and hegUire-Menu Proof of'Agency'(If ndeded) Location be'sdtlptlon gdoles of Piot plan Ill - U.. bate NeceiVed, Recel'pt Nuri beY Appllddtlon taken by. r . iCiV r na S .1. '`, "F 1i N . F� le. et d !Y t .4„„ 'r%d .,1. r ark , uiv M•4. N't'�;,'^ .YdAr'r.,•+. 'n-=^.'.9�d:1 _ _ 1 'YP'� ii vT •� ”! .-. 1 I I t M i' t -•r w x1., Lr iPe"�, * 7 m � �% .,! 44, �a , jr U w •`! y �' n , ,� � a �. h !M'�+` IJ �'�v,rf '�.� A ,1'". ✓�vdd ;A` s ...4 i t ....5}.1.1..1. S,:iq ,.4.....�..,uw.R.P.1.7.LJ+i'.9tLJ:(:ri.+�•--A �..�.JnYdt-. .,-C+. i..,A..,i`i �An'a. •....fv. ._ ... .. ...� _ 4 ,w _.. .-..+. ..,u-. 1 q ? �1 3i=l, �12'� Caitlf STATUSa ACTIVE • MALONE JERPY R & WANDA FAY 1115 HURLETON ROAD r, tlROViLLE GA 05966 L: 072 320 030 010 STATUS: ACTIVE t< i NTOSH JEFFRY D & CHERYL pL- y� Jd �y�f 154 vlhvi 6 i W i Ub : ACT 1 VE 1180 'MT TDA RD SPEEGLE DON E ETAL IT p ' GROVILLE CA 1071 HURLE T ON FIG 9576695966 pRr,1VILi-E CA f f;1;= xr of t:t11 +•S+f7 STATUS. CTI:'1 JI: GAP I AHD i S 5 -AL AVE L: (4'12 295 )53 000 STATUS: ACTIVE 171`1 W�JLLUWA'� �IpRR I S' ROBERT 85 SAN r' RAMC I SCr. CA 1075 HURLETON RD M 94132 _ OR OJILLE CA 9566 L; 01 72 4RO 014 00 STATUS: ACTIVE MACI'EY DAVID D r,55 NELSOH AVE L: x)"78, 291:1 155 571`0 STATUS: ACTIVE NEl.E H i131,.LETTE Mll HAE': G NINA C 0555 _9b5 9`a 3448 ChOSSMONT DR y� sf►N JCSE or, �. qj� L: 032 48 015 1 170 STATUSi ACTIVE 951'32 Yrt MACKEY DAVID D'« AVE Ll 078 320 006 0,10 STATJS : ACTIVE i 655 NELSON 'CA HRYPJE BILL u DORIS OP,OVILLE 1181 MARIE ELLEN AVE 95965 WHITTIER CA Y L: 012 480 021 000 STATUS: ACTIVE 90608 1 PI ER EUGENE T ETAL SING J'f 072 820 124 00G1 STATUS: ACTIVE = 8 650100 AVESAN; 95125 SULLIVAN BERNARD J & DELIA JT j e JOSE CA 1126 HURLETON ROAD OROV ILLE CA 95966 L: 018 SI022 Sl`h1TUS: -ACTIVE DWARL�I���(?f CINTRpNEEA & 'DANA Y IT L: 078 220 025 C�t00 STATUS: ACTIVE I?2111 PROSPE f ST 94 4( CALLAHAN rPAWLIN D `�'; MARCIA SUE ( HAYWARD CA 1790 HURLETON RC? OROVtI.LE'CA 95466 Lr OPP- 820 +x726 ' 700 STATUS! ACTIVE. CALLAHr+RANKLIN D AN & MARiwfA SUE tOgO HURLETON RD t: ORCVILLE CA 95966 v e "u•xru k.+ ars; w+l -.'r:». ».i.^ :,a -.h.+ -b �iws wa,34,� x r,.^ . . , w.� ,. x..;.,,.w r:,,. aas t `iN.+-w.. + rF ti .ate°"`;"' r baa+,', r ,r I0 1 1 'l 1 t' (•+ r 414';: i � t .�.:tii % ,��� rJ r,- 1 i l { , 4•q y � 5 , 4,� y t "..^�, 1 r IF:. ! a •- x,+ +; �,.- i ' t ' - - 4 I',,, { 7 4 j,:•;�:,7 lr" 6 +4�.,:f, r k tw :°' 1 r:.a: Vit"' i1 i t ,1'���r{ � e „ e r i� lal 1 1';� r r){r� . I • r ,� y p a. r r�l a ,p�fi �yj� j,.� } I 1?',t UP ti 4j... r y y1 �;.t' x r, P 1. .. 15 ; i p J t .•y +r r , +,tail r a ar ir�� 1 ,,, rY r f +' < '1>/ 1 r_x.ut,9 I x;` c � '•i d � t �`' t} `a �4 °��'" 1 rk �"t�''�Tf � J y 6 l" w1 i�-�: f� N4i. •,. r y ^ v . 1'C 1 .'^f rl :, il":u �.!l...e,..- v ' I I .."a- >�Fl11TC.{91b11h:�P,.«al:$1:4W`)15Yt11Y7i1Alvt�..a...�;M.:.w+i.:�a+�.a'.arl+4..+�,..w•``�wJ.4w.ta..»,rar.�......we:...wn.v�+:..+_.�.:+w,'ti...:.+,�.�1+..,.....:...._��+�+w�..-L. x.�..:.e--...w.�,.q>�::-++:.:.:w.��-+ r INTER-DEPAR'TIVIENTAL MEMORANDUM' 'TO:,Craig Sanders, Planning r; }„ 11 j FROM: Tom Reid, ' Environmental Health ;I rf S'U T: Charlotte Speegle'Use Permit l �IaATE: January 5,1993 ` w The above itemF ras continued o ' n .from December 10, 1992 for additional informa�on. ` pe Because; 'the Speegles have filed' a claim, against the Count, a c%omplete operational history cannot be provided at this time. The claim has been referred_ to County Counsel and Risk Management, kecords do indicate however, that .the Depa tment obsery t; approximately 80-90 poodles on 1 the ro ' A ut November 1990 and verification of zab�Ps ; acs , «tion was provided for 98 dogs: Attached are copies of kennel license application st<omitted' byl Charlotte Speegle 'on July 31, h 1990, indicating Planning and Zoning requirements had been met. TRJmlf Attachments i 7177 t � "r_ ' �L+ 4wr�i1�!��,u�.c kl�1.•.i �r x��Y`.t�5r� {"x"4. �r}I':"Mw u X�''`r�y�rF �+�'�C( .+t eiy9 ry'f:�_��a''f,:, '.a 7r 7��;� + i H _y �y '� , ir, rt✓ s v. » r tJ i vii, -'G4 ��;�@�K�W�13�,t.k��lf;l`�rz..'t3ti�ib �i. �G1kE14S`�#lts�hr�Jrtuccr�lrwu�iiuzi�tacv,�.ii%t�:lt1'.5�.'r• +'.; r a.y �'w���n�`"'�•°.i�•'•�! i+..� T'i�,}ilil�.::'�jLSt�.+' !:.'. "J,i1�15'"a�.'r o- wwwL'1 �',:»at.Si�"-aw,a.� � +i'S':!khVi4:t;.L:'t.�i7i:k�:°_,. 5 r .e l O�siz ut _ 5 - -"� PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 i TELEPHONE: (916),636-7601 i March 15; 1993 Don and Charlotte Speegle 1071 'Hurletodlos:d Oroville, CA 95965 _ RE: Uge Permit request for .A.P# 072-290-154 t Dear; Mr. and Miry. Speegle Your re-application >s bean.�� �turned with our check #248 for '252,00. This application was taken ;in error. Under Butte County Code Section 24-60 Reapplication, no new application may be made within one Year of a previous applications final decision. The only 6xception4 is when a change in circumstances of the regPs a't has occurred. The change in circumstances must be determined by the Planning commission to be sufficient enough to warrant a new application. The fee for the special hearing is $150.000 and the request should be addressed to the Planning Commission:, Enclosed is a copy of the applicable Code. Section for your reference. If you have any further questions, please contact this office. Sincerely; rr B.A.- Kircher Director of Planning k Lisa Purvis•Wilson ' Assistant Planner Vtjlo - ` ct\wp50\mise\72.29-154 �i f , •,; i 1fc, + ^ �y r� rY ��'� Fiat y ��.� r��nt.w k;� + r ,. e n a"' t � �.'r � ��) , t:t i " - �. v a°^t'4 kd µ1+P'�+:)'t.uW+M�,�.r..�R ��R+J�♦ ! �I♦ r �A ,... h� � +.w �� v ' R I I _ File No. 072,6290.154 Log NO. AP No. 072=290.154 I BACKGROUND 1. Nems of Proponents Chi'rlotte:Speegla Ce. '05966 21- Address of proponent and representative (it applicable)i 1071 iiurloton 'Road Orovills,, C 3. profett description) Use Permit to allow a kennel Y YES YBE Nr, CtISSI�bN- OF ENVIRONMENTAL .EVAI;G?�TION —, D IT;.. NDATORY FIINDINGS OOF SIGNIFICANCE 1Doan the proj act have the'Potential to degrade the quality k .. tbiF 'proposal 1,0 11 hot significantly degrade the envi"ronmentB ~ , of the •hVi-rohment, tubstehti611y reduce the habitat of s _ - fish, or wiidtife. special, cause a 'fish or wildlife _ populatlot4,to drop below self-sustaining levels, threaten to oliminete a plant or animai oommuhityF redvco the PUmber or restrict the rings of 8 rare or, ei,d•hgarad plant or animal or eliminate important examplas nP major periods of _ Caiifornie history or prahistdryl i..ede to -term hPi'r'onmentaj goal's; 9- i propose will hot Ina _ H§ _ Ze benefits toDbas 'the othe tdetriment ofhaVA the tlohg-t•em hvihohm•ht goals? k Th l h occurs (A aMori-t•rm impact oh the sod of time i While 1006term in a ra ,,tively pries stied at time impacts Will 'endure into the filtUres}, s ons,whic %'_ -s ro osal Will hot have a. "significant cumulative impact on the 3. boa'1 the project have, impacts Which', (A Project may ars individually „_ Thi.. p p _ im eat on two or Mora se'areto resources Where the impact fohmenta ))massed h two ce ibut i ere eco r6tii esli,atively ,but Where the effect tli cf the total of th y. os• iaiPacts On, he enVironmeht. is M - sighitieant,) a aln R,- this pro otij will not have a `signifleaht adverse effect Oh hUin n '- ba, q, boss. the Project have environmental effects which ,0111 ,,- p rause substantial adverse effects off hUmih beings7 either directly or indivottlyt �' III. DETERMINATION on the basis of this initial 6vai0atiolii 1E tihd the jp Wro osed prro,ject COULb'Not havh 'e sigh,ifitaht effect on the environmahh end a RtGAt1VE bttLARAT16N'Will be Oraparad, _._ _ l' _ be ,a ii"hitieaHt effect in thin ease beeausu the i - d 4 et :althea h the. ro osed Project 001.6 have a significaHt::eifatt on the ahVironmant third will not, g _ T/WG,fih_ h U p P p Di1TIGAT1oN MEASURES described on the: atlethod sheet haus bash added to the p'ro;ject: A=NEGATIVE,bECLARAT1oN will be prepared, ' C, pE bR is re uirad, � p p ,j ► gnifieenE effect on the anvironmonf, end in ENVIRONFiENTAL:IMPA T _. REPOAT 4 1 WE tiHd'the pro osed ro •c! FiAV'heva a COW TV LP GUTT �tANN[NG bEphl ll�'NT�^- • i bA1O April ft, '002 Gyi Cre a der tr ` gavjsN•d byt � � ,: ...................-yrl ttrr, k' P .., \�I : ,,q•. r. i, ',.. n ': :..:, ,• y. ,;,;.v„ ,: , _.i,, .. �r„ sl -', r. . -,a. w'• >.. ..'i, kL i..1 r, r :..,.. n, w . : . +.. .. yr , . r. , ; ::,:. w' •, : , ., :f , Y •-.. .:. �ti ,.' .,. . if .a WW ... M,li , ke .Y y, �ly'�. ,,. ry If v:r S:NrL+ h: ,�'+i�,.:'. rFP :..� ,i Pias.\": q a i� a1,-0; : ` Z - U _ t I r , , , v r +r .a : :•.:, , a : ., � a r • � , r .: - r:. r , -v:�'. Vii., .': �i� r.:: � , .. -, �, rr ✓ n. X , ' r , c 1 I ' e i +, j r ' �o } n, r t, r; 1 I . A?PENDIX I I I _ File No. 072,6290.154 Log NO. AP No. 072=290.154 I BACKGROUND 1. Nems of Proponents Chi'rlotte:Speegla Ce. '05966 21- Address of proponent and representative (it applicable)i 1071 iiurloton 'Road Orovills,, C 3. profett description) Use Permit to allow a kennel Y YES YBE Nr, CtISSI�bN- OF ENVIRONMENTAL .EVAI;G?�TION —, D IT;.. NDATORY FIINDINGS OOF SIGNIFICANCE 1Doan the proj act have the'Potential to degrade the quality k .. tbiF 'proposal 1,0 11 hot significantly degrade the envi"ronmentB ~ , of the •hVi-rohment, tubstehti611y reduce the habitat of s _ - fish, or wiidtife. special, cause a 'fish or wildlife _ populatlot4,to drop below self-sustaining levels, threaten to oliminete a plant or animai oommuhityF redvco the PUmber or restrict the rings of 8 rare or, ei,d•hgarad plant or animal or eliminate important examplas nP major periods of _ Caiifornie history or prahistdryl i..ede to -term hPi'r'onmentaj goal's; 9- i propose will hot Ina _ H§ _ Ze benefits toDbas 'the othe tdetriment ofhaVA the tlohg-t•em hvihohm•ht goals? k Th l h occurs (A aMori-t•rm impact oh the sod of time i While 1006term in a ra ,,tively pries stied at time impacts Will 'endure into the filtUres}, s ons,whic %'_ -s ro osal Will hot have a. "significant cumulative impact on the 3. boa'1 the project have, impacts Which', (A Project may ars individually „_ Thi.. p p _ im eat on two or Mora se'areto resources Where the impact fohmenta ))massed h two ce ibut i ere eco r6tii esli,atively ,but Where the effect tli cf the total of th y. os• iaiPacts On, he enVironmeht. is M - sighitieant,) a aln R,- this pro otij will not have a `signifleaht adverse effect Oh hUin n '- ba, q, boss. the Project have environmental effects which ,0111 ,,- p rause substantial adverse effects off hUmih beings7 either directly or indivottlyt �' III. DETERMINATION on the basis of this initial 6vai0atiolii 1E tihd the jp Wro osed prro,ject COULb'Not havh 'e sigh,ifitaht effect on the environmahh end a RtGAt1VE bttLARAT16N'Will be Oraparad, _._ _ l' _ be ,a ii"hitieaHt effect in thin ease beeausu the i - d 4 et :althea h the. ro osed Project 001.6 have a significaHt::eifatt on the ahVironmant third will not, g _ T/WG,fih_ h U p P p Di1TIGAT1oN MEASURES described on the: atlethod sheet haus bash added to the p'ro;ject: A=NEGATIVE,bECLARAT1oN will be prepared, ' C, pE bR is re uirad, � p p ,j ► gnifieenE effect on the anvironmonf, end in ENVIRONFiENTAL:IMPA T _. REPOAT 4 1 WE tiHd'the pro osed ro •c! FiAV'heva a COW TV LP GUTT �tANN[NG bEphl ll�'NT�^- • i bA1O April ft, '002 Gyi Cre a der tr ` gavjsN•d byt � � ,: ...................-yrl ttrr, k' P .., \�I : ,,q•. r. i, ',.. n ': :..:, ,• y. ,;,;.v„ ,: , _.i,, .. �r„ sl -', r. . -,a. w'• >.. ..'i, kL i..1 r, r :..,.. n, w . : . +.. .. yr , . r. , ; ::,:. w' •, : , ., :f , Y •-.. .:. �ti ,.' .,. . if .a WW ... M,li , ke .Y y, �ly'�. ,,. ry If v:r S:NrL+ h: ,�'+i�,.:'. rFP :..� ,i Pias.\": q a i� a1,-0; : ` Z - U I� i xV. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS:. YES MAYBE No �' DItCUt58 ION OF EIt�T�'I'RONMEMTAL -- D,�; ALUATiON: is r, , F f, EARTH WIIt the,ptoposal result In sidnilicanii-' r t i9 ,, x - ;The earth proposal WIII :nal affect Subsurface ea , a, g i f b" I., x _ " _._.— This proposal will_rnsult_'In some minor disruption of the soil It the - P p be leveledz Wane compaclloh will occur In the kehncl kennel needs to , - ,. r,. • 1 , r rr ,... �,Fi .., .. r r ti : e I u, 's ,, ...:' \ r. r. .. ,.. ,: 1. �' I .,. ., I ,. ,..{:. a .1, ';'1 ,� .', 'r ,-;, ,. k ill, thisIs not a Significant etea on a to acte Parcel, ` ,e , , r: cx' x Ware minor Ievellng may be needed tot the -kennels, The amount is :not r seen as 519n11lcanl, d. Destruction, cover Ino or mod illcaIIon of any x The site has no unique physical features, • unique geologic or physical features? e" ihcteasWWlnd or Water erosion of sollso x the proposal Will _hot cause erosion" r k It , ,, .. , .,.. r r 9 a e. J.. , ... '. "' �: ... n"..E:x:, Y .,.. ". • �:'. , r. .. _. .. ��� :r. � '.:, '' I .,. -1• • ,i :r �': ter.. ..� . 4 ,, t 1« Changes deposition 01 erosion of beach x The ptoPoSal will not atreGt any WaleTcoutse, - I 1. ,�. �, ,. � ., � '., '1 }+., , . .•, ., r ';. _,: I. r '::, 'r � " or erosion Which may modify the channel or r 1 4w atrivetbor o taker I li ,I , 1 f :y f t' :1r 9 1 1 _x Thi"s proposal does not 'represent a sIgnlficaht loss of PI !Me gt i, areas? Watts outs de designated Urban areas 7: agricultural soli;, _ h; tXposure of people or property to geologic r , I 4, • , r, haxatds such a5 earthquakes; Lairds ides, , I mudslides; ground failure of simllot' ' •.. �... .. 1 .:v. 11a. .}Y�Y.;kikWSi'e3,uM1::wa1<:M.w.;,.zt} F�4-- -`"_ a7: "iy.:..�,_ � _..r: .ruw.....u,.,+....:,:.,T,..w—u 's...r,.F-r•.y., w_.�r._'rh. ._ ,.x... _., t I� i i xV. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS:. YES MAYBE No �' DItCUt58 ION OF EIt�T�'I'RONMEMTAL -- D,�; ALUATiON: is f, EARTH WIIt the,ptoposal result In sidnilicanii-' r t diti7 ns, or changes In Unstable earth conditions, ,, x - ;The earth proposal WIII :nal affect Subsurface ea a, g i f b" Dls:rurllon, dl3placemeht•, cpmpacllon; or x _ " _._.— This proposal will_rnsult_'In some minor disruption of the soil It the - P p be leveledz Wane compaclloh will occur In the kehncl kennel needs to overr.dvering of the soil? area, Approximately 2500 'squale deet wIII be used fat dog runs, thisIs not a Significant etea on a to acte Parcel, ` cx' change In topography or ground surface x Ware minor Ievellng may be needed tot the -kennels, The amount is :not rellel ieaturesr seen as 519n11lcanl, d. Destruction, cover Ino or mod illcaIIon of any x The site has no unique physical features, unique geologic or physical features? e" ihcteasWWlnd or Water erosion of sollso x the proposal Will _hot cause erosion" r k ,Ln either on« of off s tern! t 1« Changes deposition 01 erosion of beach x The ptoPoSal will not atreGt any WaleTcoutse, - ,In sands nr changes In s.tltatlon, deposiilon or erosion Which may modify the channel or ed of the ocean S rearnlet atrivetbor o taker Los's of 'prime egticuidUrallY _x Thi"s proposal does not 'represent a sIgnlficaht loss of PI !Me gt i, areas? Watts outs de designated Urban areas 7: agricultural soli;, _ h; tXposure of people or property to geologic k f DUtI'e CountV'.IS in a Moderate Earl quake In"te slty zone vl1l., AI'1-0 hl� {q� -not the placement of a'kenhel on this Pfopetty: _ haxatds such a5 earthquakes; Lairds ides, this Will : affect mudslides; ground failure of simllot' ha? ardst- 2" ALL Will the proposal result In substantial? a, of ambient Air emissions ot-detetiotation _ - x. The. Proposal Will (hot affect air _,gUality'because the increase In the number of vehicle trips its not signitfcant, a f qualityl b" creation of objectionable odors, stroke n oke' ... The Will not create nblectiohapio odors', smoke' 'or tamest sel c. fum0sr of Alteration of air tnovembnl, molslure of th"e. ptopo`sal WII,I hot affect the atmospheie" i Inclimate, _ locallyte)t teginnalhlyVrchange ' a. w"xiea{ Will the rtopasal fesult In Wbstahtiait A. changes in,,cutrenls, or the course or ,_ x' the ptoposal Wlii, not ONO Any Waletcdurse, direction 'ot wato movements :lh either _ b', matlne or fresh Waters; changes in Gates, dtatna9e x;_,. ��: ---- Dialna a pattern should' not ,be, signl,ficantly altered by this 9 w ver `ahold-ttomthe site may contaminated by local Noe i - AM pruo(iti' of the fate and amount of sutlace pro dct ,be mat or �l the kennels are not properly malnlalnad. +' , 1!. Need lot oil -;i le..:surlace dtalhage x_ No off sf.te dtalhage Imp'rovbmants Will be r0qufted, , [mprovement3aihc Udlhg Vzgelalioh temsval, I d, chehho)UP 4sn of culvert Installatl00 Alidtations to Ih'a c0utse of 1I6W of flood ,_x._ osa WI I' of slghllIChhtly attedl ahy 11'ood conl'rof channels The Prop_ 1 i n Worst? of Watercourses,: , f e' ': « :. .... ' .. ,r „ «, .` ,w „z- , 1j .J,tey,y34A4"'{,41,1L � `. . '° - y ,1p�x'y��igtAlttG.34 ,.r,?rlhEi$:�ww4�rt�l�t•„ith �rli,�4K'"SiQrtJ `ttLfL �z, +!!au •,r iYrir7�.zltiLShc�Wli1 _ . , •. ,,,;,.:�":�.:.dr, 41 .,,„ate, ,.:, 4' - t,: •r ..: , '. ':. V ,}.. r":. 4.r.. ., .' „ ,. -,c. ,.,.. i Y1 e:. rr�. , ,.l Yl.. , .-. 9n h T «.,. ,.v ], ..' 4r..-4, .,, p: T : I,, ! ,-.. i, .. r .. r., R. . >• +k: ,,. ;- "i �1� .+r'. 5rt : e,.+, :- , ,�...�, h «t.,, ht ,lF,r. r, a.:. Ve waY!l�jf # n. ,.:: a•. �; i f�iirr w d K.. I ,. :,. , ,,r.., M , R 1' Y 1. t C R .. � .. a, k _ a '6 els are in between 2 tlhainage %"alai, 1f the kennals are not r Th k nn S properly maihta.ihed% runoff to these %'Wales may :be contaminated With animal 'of Water body? y wastes; Kennels must :be cleenatl on a regular basis and wastes disposed :.,, f, ... k _,_, See the djacussicn for litam 3e , , alteration of surface water quality% including 1 r , Of- turbidity) , Alteration of the direction or rete of flow of __ x The Or W1.11 not effect the diha4tion or flow of ground Wetera, g, ground waterit h'. Change in the quantity or quality of ground k'- The proposal wi,il flat directly affect any aqui?br: •r : withdrawals, or through interception of Oil a Uifer by cut q s or excavatton1f R 1, jJ . :e, k The project Will hot "effect any public water iupplyl available for' -public Water supptiesT _ _ iUra to Watar�related :„' I. �. ^ ♦u .f :: I a o[• eo le of; ro GV'ty Co flooding, The propasel Will not 8P People P P , I 4 1 `c , I' n V e, , 1 , r 1 R: _ __ The . ro osal will not affect' plant' life because the site contains no P. P any species of planta _(iheiUding treoil shruiis, &ignifican! plant lits+ - graa:a, cropsi and aquatic plants)? bt Reduction of tri fUmbers of Any unigiiii rare or k The ilte contain& he rare plants, 1 , + et Introduion of 06W species a pt all 11 to, an dt barrier tU the nohmel rioichi%hment _r ,;r ,l era&I or in a of ex:istin s g pecioi{t ; d, Reduction in acreage of alt a y gelculturol Crop? , .,;� .._ � of cote a e rleultUrel crap's end is prasenlly da-veloped The, ajte does,{ n contain by g 4 5,NJMAL LIFE, Will the ,proposal result in iUbitantialf uu¢dLiir¢'i.Vi]ta31iWe4uiu-�u:c�,nJ—s '.:: , :: ,.':, : ,. , . , ... , K4¢M'+tl ¢ ice• :+.�=„-au��' •5�.= wrstMu:♦uF.we./Il.r _,.. ... :....+wn+♦.r4:M,:lu�,,♦N' ���. ..,.'>.«:+.usw ...r : sY .. , Y 1. 1. R .. � .. a, Change in the amount of surface water in any �— k _ a '6 els are in between 2 tlhainage %"alai, 1f the kennals are not r Th k nn S properly maihta.ihed% runoff to these %'Wales may :be contaminated With animal 'of Water body? y wastes; Kennels must :be cleenatl on a regular basis and wastes disposed in an appropriate manner a; dictated by the Envlronmantel'Health Deportment. f, Discharge into surface wet�rs, or in any ,__ k _,_, See the djacussicn for litam 3e alteration of surface water quality% including r but not limited to temperaturo% dissolved oxygen Of- turbidity) Alteration of the direction or rete of flow of __ x The Or W1.11 not effect the diha4tion or flow of ground Wetera, g, ground waterit h'. Change in the quantity or quality of ground k'- The proposal wi,il flat directly affect any aqui?br: Waters, either thrtugh direct atldilriobs or withdrawals, or through interception of Oil a Uifer by cut q s or excavatton1f R 1, tiedtiction in the amount of Water C'.' rwise . :e, k The project Will hot "effect any public water iupplyl available for' -public Water supptiesT _ _ iUra to Watar�related k a o[• eo le of; ro GV'ty Co flooding, The propasel Will not 8P People P P Eicpo of people or property hazards such at flooding( _,; 4, PLANT LIFE, Will the 'proposal resUlt lis WbattiitiAli e, Change in the;di0irsity of species% or humber of R: _ __ The . ro osal will not affect' plant' life because the site contains no P. P any species of planta _(iheiUding treoil shruiis, &ignifican! plant lits+ - graa:a, cropsi and aquatic plants)? bt Reduction of tri fUmbers of Any unigiiii rare or k The ilte contain& he rare plants, endangered species of plentit et Introduion of 06W species a pt all 11 to, an dt barrier tU the nohmel rioichi%hment _r ,;r The proposal Will not affect d?iialjng pier,( life. era&I or in a of ex:istin s g pecioi{t ; d, Reduction in acreage of alt a y gelculturol Crop? , .,;� .._ � of cote a e rleultUrel crap's end is prasenlly da-veloped The, ajte does,{ n contain by g with a single family ' sidehce i 5,NJMAL LIFE, Will the ,proposal result in iUbitantialf 1 1� ^ et things in the diverse( of 'spacjas% on number& ,; ,.,,,>Z,_ bA t _t a diverait, or 'number of'ehimal life - the .proposal Will nof: signifi h ly ,h Y _ because the'aite does hot support significant animal life or Ilhbiti"t, of any ipecied of ah;ims)s (birds, laud shinati i1.ncluding reptiias, fish end ahettfi ii sh', behihie - organisms er marc. i” b, Nbdoetion in thQL ni,mber% bf any UnigUei rare or the i(te contains ho: rare ahimilii, st endandspacieaaciasl e: Intro duetoonewof anime'is into An sj, the prapoitl Will not affect ekisti"t Wirral life, , o ti bhNr er to the 001-A1611 Oil movaiof aft g, Dalerioratiof; bf exiiting 'fiO or `Wildlife + s, X� _ . locatedin a critical deaf¢ Winter range end ii in area d;lsig;lat'ed Tha-site is t. range (loon( b Rho GAlifornla as a development ir4i on the mops prbuded tog Y y t f hsBitatf Dapartmelj! of Fish +.6hd Game, the percal it already impacted by the residence, the kennel will hot have a significant imoid: on Wildlife as ibng it the degi era hot allowed to roam, '6,: OtSt, Will the proposal reault in iubitAht�"hil in hoiae iavelsf the otehiii to lhareesb the hoise levels orf"t 'site, the proposal will have E_ p l ' d, Incriesia existing - r ..., .:..-., ..:.vim ., LIL mi., �rA'..fF. Oq r J+.. .�tx '.. 'w ,.. d,' t :.'. -M. �l. �,. �. Nln.l 7777'7 :. ... �. Ir '..>. .M "^ .+t 1: . , ,,, >:. w•. ....C. ,. . n. M:S .X.,«.. ..9 f. r V hic1esi Incresa in traffic hazards t motor lo o ! e _; k _ ,_. The p roposel Will hot result in, significant lncremanthl increase in traffic bicyclists or'padestrians? _� and "related traffic hazardu in the area. 4' 14. PUBLIC SERVICESs Wili the proposal 'have an effect upohr or result ih s need for naw or altered government servicesi ' e. Fire- protoctian? ..�. k Thpro oael will noi''rasult in a significant inerementel increaso in demand e p is in very , for fire protection in the ares. However the project located a high hazard area, To protect the dogs in case of (ire, the Use Permit ,fire ahou d be conditioned to YamoVs all brush Within 26' of the kennels b, police p rotacNont ,_ k The proposal will not, result in a significant incremental increase i n demand : for police protection'ih the arae. � Schoolatk The proposal 'Will hot result in an incremental 'increara in demand for school C. ._� services In the area. 1, d, or other recreational fecilttiast_ Parks —'— X _� _�__ The ro osal Will not 'result in an incremental increet`e in demand for park p. p -area. and recraa4ioi facilit ea 1n';he a. nc ud ng tech ties,, to l i g Moads�nahee of publicincluding , k The prop ase Will hot result in in ineramehtai incraate in the heed for p p l bf and other facilities lh the areae r 1 maint6nande roads public ' f. 'Other ave n'entel servieest h g r m �, _ k The propossi Will hot result in in incromentel inereaas In demand toY all _ _ other governmental ssrWc#>N n the area,. i 15# ENERGY, Will"the proposal result iris Use of substehtial emoUnts of fuel or energyt k the:propotel will not Utilize substahtiel fuil' or snargye b, substantial iherease -ih demand upon: ekisting _., - X The proposal will not uba�ahEjelly 'inpreese the damendrfor on6r9ys sources of energyr or require the devalopment of new sources of hirargyT t6. UTILITIES. In the proposal 'rysult In e, need for new - systemsr or lubstentiel,eltarat oni to the following! e Powar or naturaid est' r _ `_ k The proposal will not affact'electricil paweror natural gas distribptioe ' t systemsc ' s b. CbmmbhicatioFti syatemst k The proposal will hot affect,toomunication systehii. 6i Water evailibllityf , _::.., k The propoiel'Will not affect 'pybiic Water iyitims# dr Sewer or asptic systems? _._.. k -:: "`�— `—� The pro asell Wi1l. hada to meet the ragUi'rementi of the Butte county Cnvirohnental' Health pept# The appiicants must ihatall'anothor ieptic tank and lsichfield system for this shimal wastes, 11 dreihige?r_ It The proposal Will hot have to provide storm Nater drainage facilities e, sterni water ,, _, f, Solid Waste end dlspo'ial? _ r_l5 ..':' The proposal Will hot:efiect nbiid Waste disposals 17i HUMAN HEALTH. Will the p"roposil rsWt ini ai an - _ Creation of any health hazard or poter4ial hazard _ ,k _ _ :. _. ._, - o c sate uhss ittir eondltions-if Che animal's t r n Y the propeael het this red for their wastes hat properly dlaposad'of. ` tat hesith t (eRcluding Men ) are ho! rdparly tired for !end_ pahiolie,pns o_etiohi b !hi Butte County EhVirohMihtei Health Dept# or Reifies Control De tp'wili help assure that the taeility_is Mdlntainad'# in additlohr oparlypmaintained k6hheit rbujd affect ruooif surfeco Water quelityr, imRr'. . bi ... , :: .. Ekpoiura of people to potential heiitn hezerdst _ _ -_ iso a !o o' health hszard: This proposal will hot, ekpa►e p pl any I 3Sla&a „�,). '., ',,+»., ',.,�.'' ow»'"""a_, yNf,��,`...�',�•..:, r# w77x�Frr~r.:'.y. " GoO , a �f , 8 AESTHETICS. 'Will the result in the obstruction �. Y. __ .�- T e proposal W111 not result in an aesthetically offensive iainq because it - h P, p 1 proposal' of any scenic. Vista or Viey open to the publ ie, or HilCethe {p consiit.snt With surrounding development n proposal result in the creation of en aesthetically i , i offensive site open to the public, Wewt P -' EATIO Will the,;pro oral result in an impeet Upon 'the X __ The propos a May -`result in an incremental increase in d4m4nd for park and ) ,._ - F 'b jg; RLC _ qua ,itY or 0 entity o'• exiitin9 recreational oppoi�tuit{es7 ' recreation 'facilities. Y 20, CULTURAL RESOURCFS: os i•osUit in the alteration or „__ e W111 the prop n) ;,. ,_ X The 'proposal :will not effect archeological s t*%, V _ destruction' of aprehistoric oi" historic ` proposal result,,,-edVerse physical or `� b. Will the pkop __ X Therproposel W{li hot affedt'h{storic_titess p f eeithetic effects to a prehistoric o,?histo�d I, - buildingk:structure 'or object? " the ro osal have the otential to cause a C. boas M p p p �� >i p � uial essources: fihe;pro osel Wi11 ho' effect :cult physical change which Would effect unique ethnic ` cultural valuest t - Will the restrict existing religious or >t ._ The ro ose1 tvill ho effect religious resources, p p d• praposal seeped Uses within tha potOWil impact erea4, : i P, 1 ,i , r . .I i r ' 4 't r ` , , ,. 1, �, ^ '�. ,',5• P.i,' % . " kkx,,...��,,;;����/ ;..rr( ..``ry4 t , Rqqp. d--: y , r r ,. n. IanteE lk f0,1 k('iV 11 a. -? 1t11 i6.li'iiZt�h.�'il.'wiii>•1'+•W:L?:l�a,}i IYdFkt9l i Fy tiYi �HtikY k3 'n.v. _. .a, :..: ,. C r., -xal, x',.Y...•r, t , ..vr., we-. .r. ..: ). .'-. u,r , .=ri. .. V: � -•.v ... u. r.- f.--� ., 'r.r ...,. ',.,n, wo r'Y. � t p ;. n .%. :....... ..,.,t n•b: €'_7aa rr;'..ua.«.✓.; -,. '.^--i' ., '. 4 .... :): . ,1 n•.+. ;,apw_ �, , ,.. ..,. ...., :. .:..: ,.+ - ..._...:,. ., 'r.. ._,.. a.: ,:.,_.,. .:,_._ -__,.. -'-i---� --_ _..___.....-. - ___ ..�—.�-�_�_�_ .. _•ice_ - - _ .� y ,r, , e r " , I, r I r r , , , , t'. - r I , , r ,. ,.. ,'.. .. .tom.. . ... T r i :., IY%tlEAc:.edrba:•ki.Jn.wa.. ', , 1 ..,.. .h+M=1vA.r+S,+„.�r....,, a ::_ wu+uul.•i-ats�YN•....W . .:w_cw.-,4:,f„---- -_ -. - O�Yikt�Mr..1WLifi�:M1�'JMRIi� '–•---�---•�.n•.-•a•— i.N.V�r,-n v' i Environmental (;h Wist Evaluation of Environmental Impact ENVIRONMENTAL'REFERENCE MATERIAL 1. Butte County, Planning Department, Earthauake and Seismic Safet Element. 12 Butte Cony Board of Su ervisors: FaultActivit” Ma 11-1. Agricultural Preserves Map, established_bv r Oroville GAt CH2M Hill, 1977.'' Resolutrion No- 67-178. oroville, CA: 2. Butte County Planning Departmenti, Liquefaction Butte County Planning Departinent, 1987. potential Map 11-2 Seismic Safety-element'. 13.' National Flood Ineirance Program. Flood oroville CA: CH2N, Ril]., 1977 _ insurance Rate ittaps. Federal Emergency 3. y g p tent. Subsidence And', Butte Planning de art Management Agency, 1989" ,Count Landslide Potential Map 111-1. Safety Element: 14. UfiGS Quad Maps, Bangor oroville, CA: CH2M Hill, 1977. 4. Butte County Planning Department. Eroei on 15. Soil 14avt Chico 9251/Oroville (1!9261 X1" Area. United States Department of Potential Ma 111"2 Safet4nlement. broviliej CAi Agricttltuz� CHr2M Hill, 1977. 5.; knave 9'oi1's Butte County Planning Department. Fn_ 16 Soil Survey of Chico ti9251/orobille 1926 Area. united States Department of Mati 111-3. Safety eloment: Oro viller CA:a CH2M .i_ culture. Hill, 1977- 6 _ _ Butte County Planning Department Noise element Planning 17: 8. Butte utte County Planning DepartmentianButte PYotecti n and Maw. IVB =1. Scenic Hiahwav elemeint. Orovil:lei CA Hf.l], 1977. Count Fre Facilities Map. Butte county fire CH2M Department Department o 7. t Count Plannn Department. 8cehic.Hiahwaye Butte yf �'oreetr1989,California scenic Hi ht4a .Element.. Oroville, CA3 CH2M H 11, 1977. d. Butte County planning bepartittent.,.Natural Fire Hazard Classes Map 111-4, Safety Element: orovillej CA: CH2M Hill, 19-17p:- 94 tU,Zte County Planning Department:, Archaeolonninl"' Sensitivity Ma1�. Oroville, CA": Ja'mea. P� Ma_gt 1983: 10 Y bo ntylPlanning Department. School bistric�. Matte ii. Northwestern Dibtriot Department of Water Resources. Chico. Nitrate Stuft.Map, , Nitrafe e:, The Resources Aoenoyp State o Callfcrnla� 1983 g y s I ^ R re, T a. (" I : f.. . \ 1 ✓ G ` , �Ye", 11 1'� _ 1 l �'r�• �t t, E< �� .:+ �. 1 r .:�k , '.., i F, ;f t �r h,'� , 'p{{ st , 7 t i,�, 4 , '.p:. d t 1`,i 1. i,n Iq 1.,1#.1,"t 41f�. /t, �";r r °:C'•.;,r� 'I ,�9: d�...M1P:,a:��1,=+..,..••n r�� x w ��, � tS '' t `l I i. )rti _i 4 t� � t tip, u , f� a ' � � �,! y, � : I rkiY ti�at, d nit 1 "YvWil9 I'I' ��h ti0 � i:f ri6�h"A`aLb+a+�rdt,�+.'MI?11aAr.1+,,,..�..+.1,r-.:c•.+..,-+..d«.;.i� Rw f, . • . s s x - A 4 ..k d MEMO TO FILE To.. Bettye",% i Y Pror 1. Lisa J Re..t72 29U -1S4 Charlotte Speegle Use Permit (Re-application) Date: 3/19/93 1 hada phone conversation with Don Speegle today. He had received his second application back in, the mail and was questioning the non-acceptance He is aware of the 1 year no ' reapplication period after a "final decision" has `been made, that is why lie turned in the re_ a lication the da before the "final decision" had been reached. His question then, is May p y d retur n his call. uld do so an e re -a 1 or n pp Y . ot? 1 told him 1 had t� ,ask the 'boss for cl;az kation a would 1 Lisa ru,.���M If ' r • r �.,i� 1 �'�P /rt�xcerh: d g -y' nl Ww p Y � r l d{ F a tt431 f•+�Y N�p' 1 i.M959:dM3%I:tYi'ti�iit��,kiill 351 r:Jii«Ci1Y1 'Yuu`1..iii+wa:Ni%u1 �1%%Sk1%t4}Jbll�%b'f+YPaJ.C1ii�E'WC"ls�li�d7-"f»'.'fAL;Y..l` tlA'Cr,::E/12+kkli+<, 1.="+��+, ,,:.,— ,e;.xksnu�tu,�3taf�'1sY-i3' + m, 1.13 ,i E U7 '�r ..J ,- Ai�)D OF NAi',jRA. WEALT{-t A11,1 5 t DIRECTORS OFFICE DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOIP "ENT SERVICES p t 7 COUNTY CENTER ORI'/E OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95968-3397 TELEPHON[ 1916) 538.7601 ` �j ;! FAX: (910) 6536-1785 m March 10, 1993 , `Charlotte Speegle 1071_ Hurleton Road Oroville, CA 95956 Re Use Permit, AP `072-290-154 Dear Mn Speegle: At the regular meeting of the Butte County Board of Supervisors held March 9, 1993, j g your 'appeal of a denied Use Permit to allow a private breeding kennel for, up to 99 g P p , Oroville: was denied. adult do s on ro ert located on the north side of Hurleton Road Shouldyou have any questions 'regarding this matter, please contact this Department: Very tr y yours, William Farrel Develo Ment Services Director p ,a WF,Ir 1 ` cc: Land Development 'guilding Division Health Department Department of 'Forestry f 5 a. ore ZMR +.lYf'u a - t`' 6+1 ,i 1' rS 1 tam, { 6i a' f" "• ^ aµ { ttaC + �, �,.II'. 1 a. p' y w C r "�- ` k,F..wraw �i'� i t �+�" , moi,. fi :., MM, a} 1•4Sf r ."i*. t'j. tv L 1 l wJr4r{I4ey'. ....1,uin-.....%i�.n4r.S.uF v.6/l..iw.al-..i......r., V'i 1i ' nd,' ', it r 'fir • V i c! I < < y'4, �S �•'�,�+:' Ate. ti °� ' K if.f.a:�i 14.•_;:..:,.,..,.,..a..--:+`:-,..s..,;:�.".1�..«.,.::,r:,,..tillwtlKn:.ar�...wt�,G:.S�.....� . i. e^' S.-i'.Y45Y4c ��y�N'W��4>�.N..i�'�y'L�Mb.1��:1+—nU, A ����•, f 'H' t ate ti flr/ Butte 0aft l� F, tom.~ LAND OE NATURAL WEALTH AND ,BEAUTY DIRECTOR'S OFFICE TI. DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES { � 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 959G5-3397 }� TELEPHCNE: (9161539-7601 MEMORANDUM P'AX; (91 G) 538.2785 l ' rp �i y 15l TO: Butte "County Board of Supervisors (!� FROM: Bill Farrel Director of Development Services G Craig sanders, Project Planner SU8JrCT. Charlotte S peegle, Use Permit., AP '072-190-154. ?. f DATE:,; February 26, 1593 r 7; RE QUEST[RECOMMENDATiON:. I' t Charlotte Speegle - proposed,Negative Declaration with mitigation measures regarding environmental impacts and Use Permit to allow a private breeding kennel for up to 99 adult dogs on property zoned "U" (Unclassified) located on the north side of Hurleton Road, approximately 1,/4 mile west of Ijurleton Swedes Flat Road, Lake Wyandotte area, identified as AP 072°290-154, Oroville. i Planning. Staff recommends thatL the Board accept the Planning Commission's recommendation for denial of this project. - ;i t SACXdROUNDJANALYS18: 7� This is a Use Permit request to allow a priVateL breeding kennel for up to 99 dogs• The, r o ert is'located on the north side of Hurleton Road, approximately 1/4 mile west of Hurleton Swedes Flat tte. The area is rural with the parcel Road, near Lake Wyandotte , sizes ranging from 5' to 20 acres, and is mountainous with the average slope on this parcel exceeding 20% ; The applicant has apparently had a kennel on this site since 1985' and up until 19 90 had a kennel license, for no more than 49 dogs, k; 'is sued by the Butte County Rabies Control Department, From a land use perspectiVe, a Use permit was never granted And the kennel was never legally established. .As a result of a change in Section 4" ` 4 ofthe Butte County Code in 1.990, the Rabies control Department' for a now orenewal kenne I began requiring 411 people applying r l: license to sign an affidavit stating that they'had complied with all Planning and environmental Health bepartment requirements., The applicant signed such a' statement in O'uly of 1990 and received a .,,, Y.' ➢ . 4v �, inti Y 1 •' i Y 'aY -} C{ k....: d cna+. a't+: ur ck, 't .. 4. v....z `.,rIN..+x . y.,.,u ,f L. ,Il"t aSr., •t.! `J . 41'z.}^ ,1l'S ?,��.�4.�`1%,i Ll aJ ?�i.7�9.MwA � £) Iv •xY �fi:uiJ�l7iiN4.�1L.•:.al \�iYI.���1Lt'1�.} xltli+uix(.ti�:.1AY `�..4as.w+xi.,. /1L4� Jr�L�w��iawk..Fi.�l.1Y '� y ..:}.�.,..A.tab,at3klti��i�=:{4iwaLr...xF:N,w�r.tLCY�i..wMbh�•i..���tvl�r...:i:.�.,..u++..i j� 4 yy kennel license for up to 49 dogs. Upon an inspection of the site in November of. 1990, the license was r.voked for failure to have !i valid rabies certificates for all dogs`and exceeding the kennel I j capacity by 50 to '70 dogs.. It was also discovered that no Planning permits had been issued for this site: The applicant was informed of the requirement for a Use =permit in December, of 1990 and made �' pre -application in May of 1.991. The application was deemed` tk complete in April of 1992. The applicant has chosen a site on their property that is westerly n' of their existing mobil home. The area is about 1:00 1 from Hurleton Road and has' been previously leveled. The level area is'9i approximately i/4 acre in size. The property rises steeply to the north from th,'is` level area and is heavily vegetated. ' The in acts and conceriis with this type of use include noise and sanitationroblems.With the ote is for 99 adult dos and an s on the ro_ert the noise from .he site unknown number of p puppies Y R. could be a nuisance to existing and future neighbors. The kennel site is near the bottom of a valley that forms a type of natural Amphitheater. When staff visited the site, the dogs could be heard barking from varying distance depending upon the terrain. Thele closest residence is 3'001 to the south.- There are two other homes, 0 froms the y' to the southeast that are both approximately Y thea proposed kennel location. The property to west __ , undeveloped 20 acre parcel. The negative impacts of having a kennel in this location could increase as the area population a, r grows. However, even with a rezone, it is not anticipated that the area will develop into parcels of less than 5 acres, Noise impacts ` can be lessened by using retaining natural vegetation on the slope k to the north', and providing a noise attenuating features to the south, east, and west such as a solid wood fence combined with shrubbery or -hay bales. A more permanent -solution"to the noise y� problem is to construct indoor kennels.` 5anitation'could also be a problem since the dogs will be limited to an area +6 , the number of Tiat 1: approximately 70 by 40 . Given' I dogs proposed, the slopes on site, the low permeability of the 6 soil, and moderate to high rainfall amounts this area receives, the potential for surfac e water contamination will be high unless all wastes are picked up on a rec ar basis or the kennels are constructed with concrete floors that are drained to an approved d septic tank and leach field system. it should be noted that the applicant specializes in breeding small poodles that produce significantly, less wastes than a large breed. The amount of noise and sewage generation would be affected by the kennel operator ` changing the type, of dog breed that they raise. obviously, a large breed will produce more wastes and some breeds bark more than a others. With the potential for up to 140 to 150 dogs on site, including puppies; It is important that county Environmental Health Depaitment and Rabies Control bepartment have,access to the tags p p � nations including tags. to insure proper sanitation and rabies VaCdil h y , Nle f1 Yk P � u �T r Illi / ,f wF k• I�, f i 0.1 ( % �, .1� YI i W s fT i i 7 1• q i r r 5 ,5j r d• i s �> 1�, ; '~ . � h•A.. R f .t ! I,.Y AL Ii 'e ' f k f 1' r i w 3 r • y A„ S i mt �Ae4 i nur a 1,1a.rv. ,p .!, z i { w„ +«-...++I'�;4:�.� ��u�wG+� d1�.i+1tU...S",:��..i! ..iCL:v3l� ..,.�iw'�}'`�' .�Ak ,..Iii' �l�t�.�+.•.�7;.F..1.4_..}:W�% �� r....C...laa.:«,.1'a '-^"-E i f r A 4Ni. - . YIIt M_ ALO N`4V^I' • • on the dogs as re �uircl by SC1, ection 4-4 of Y q the Butte Count Code_ i The applicant has stated that she is willing to construct indoor;! ker�nes with an approved sewage disposal, system at som6 time ,n kennels on sand or pea gravel at future but wishes to use portable thy Waste cis oral will be either chemical treatment or •s time. P a holding tank. Noise a aenuation will be limited to the use of a y straw bales, fences, shrubbery ot, some combination thereof. These but be methods could :be acceptable for a lesser number of dogs may Unless indoor kennels Inadequate for the number of dogs proposed. •k sewage disposal system are constructed, the with an approved �t pi6lect should not be supported or it shouldbe limited to fewer is,suggested, with f animals. Twenty to twenty-five adult: poodles by Rabies control, Even with indoor kennels i periodic verification g limited to no more - ber of dogs be lint recommendedthat. the,"number ao ,i tit hanS60 qui t g s PLANNING COMMISSION MT?ONa 4 rd testimony on this ,project on three' The planning commission h6�iY separate 'occasions. A The majority of the testimony came from Thake neighbors that were concerned with the noise from the dogs. th« su "orted the project. Testimony for were 1 or 2 neighbors pp and against the projert was also.,received 'from people who had purchased or otherwise acquired dogs from the applicants. The the hearings and spoke '. local SPCA representative attended one of this Use permit for reasons, relating to the way, the out against dogs_ were maintained by the applicant during a previous inspection. f The Commission, after hear�.ng a ll of "Al— x,ublic testimony denied the request. MOTIojj. ALTERNATTVEl_ : i The folio Wing motion -is recommende d, A. Note that the requirements of CEQA have be? -,In completed and 5 • g considurLd in makin , this decision and � propose uee of the �arcpert'� will impair the B . rind that the prop -in winch the land lies ,and integrity and. character, of the :zone not be unreasonably, ig,co��pai:ible with or that the use would ion uriois to surrounding property, or detrimental tcj the 'residing f health, safety, aid general welfare of the per.�ons to the health, or wor}cint�n the neighborhood or general and safety of the County because of noise and we]fare sanitation impacts, and C. Deny the appeal., for a Use Bertit to Allotd a kennel dogs on A.P. 072-290`-154; (speegle) i As an alternative, if the 'Hoard can make the required findings and r u i x.�* ' '•M 5 M.R X. r;{I1c�{ ` ✓. fd't } 1. J�r. I}' 1• ry..• ; . �r I' / •♦ ',,. I. .. " ,. , d V.• �M W a,1.♦ h Y n • A, A R+rix �tii,rar w"a« . �ri °.;% }� '� 5"5,xk;, w• - Fa i •Li F� { {ir' 1. Itf I i Yt 1t ;. f 19 ; , ) I 1s4eY7'7,::�1rA.layi:,yt�;Lz",..�.f'..,-',,'a'�,1'Vea`;•1=.+--L�7idL.�dt.;w;:ik�FtiiL"•d."iXL�.t-SJ) 't would be appropriate for°make the. e a eal i a the ► wishes to uphol PP C foll.owinc3 motion: • 1 Find that: ° in compliance wit y P h the An inits„a”. stud was completed ; California Env�.ronmental Quality Act. ' 2. Said sl and comments received thereon identified that the \` P Qtential sect. ?ficant effects x but:' project may, have had ► _ ' p� t pY ov�aions in the project plans or prc�° osaLs made avoid such 11. 11 by or. agreed to by the applicant would ` ate such effects to a point where txg t ; effects or m; ' ` ntal effects would no significant envirQnme, clearly occur >.' I b There's no substantial` evidence before the ' Count have significant that tiie project as revised ma y ;. . ti effect on the environment. ion with mitigation' proposed Negatite Declarat' t 3. The has been completed in compliance with the } measures California Envz,ronmental Quality Act. The pthe 4 r use of the property will not impair in which the land r integrity nor character of the zone not be unreasonably ;. lies, and that the us�� would ' 'ble or injurious to surrounding.property with incompat� end general welfare detrimental �.o the health, safety► or- of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood welfare and safety of the ; , eral health, Cr t ge e and 1' ►the ount becaus ._ B. Move to adopt a Negative Declaration 4�%i'h mitigation measures kennel on AP 072-290154 and grant 'a use Permit to allow a following conditions: (Speegle) subject to the �. Construct indoor kennels with exterior walls that have be concrete S The floors shall an aTC of 40 or greaher. be designed to allow the collection of r ved and set �.ic collection; point that is honked up to an app septic from and leachfield 'system installed under pe"'mLt Health Dept. the Butte County Environmental the age of 4 months may be on �. No more than 60 dogs over V g Y ; an time• t hepropertyhan at y 3 Kennels shall be Located. 2t Least., 50' away from any . di:ainage Swale on or off site. 'applicant shall►at all, times; f` -eve a Val' Raba kennel 4 • The a,t ; 'e`s Count' Health Dept.i issued by Bu't�. t yy fh"' iM� f 6 fl A"1 S ! . i7 1,kr4.i�.":.'.Lliiir«1a�911:1'islintwku"^iti�flMI.YSS:LL:i'a".'r6`..L"�tL7'ii«:3..�.ri.1Fs. r, - . h control. A11 dogs shall wear a<,,collar and tag identifying the 5. kennel owner and app: icable Butte County kennel license number n accordance with Section 4-4 of the Butte County Code 6. Dog runs are to be kept clean to as not to create an odor problem. Removal of fecal matter is to be done or fly p _ on a daily basis and disposed of in )nner acceptable to the.-Butte County Environmenta�l H�.� �.� i� Department:. 7 . This "Use Permit shall not run with the end _and shall." terminate u11 pon the lease, rental,'; or, transfer of ,((, ownerCnip of. the property. d r4$ c7 as a 8 boas kepjc in the kennel..shall be limited to breeds that geheral.ly do not weigh more than. 15 to 20 pounds ! l l -Club: s listed b�, the American Kennel move than#, dogs over the age of 4months may bei kept on the premises until the indoor kennel" is completed and ti" inspected by Rabies Control. The following temporary noise attenuation measures shall be used: ( A. R ` - etain natural vegetatida► to the north beyond a distance of 301. Vegetation within a minimum of 30' , i � red far fire protection purposes in all shah. bt clew direction: in accordance with CoPts recommendations. B: �r►stal?i noise attenuation barriers along the south, eaat, cru` west 'sides of `the kennel.. The design of these barriers "shall be approved, by the Planning Division of the Development S.srvices bepartment. lA. The applicant shall allow periodic inspections by the Environmental :health Department and Rabies Control to i insure health' and sanitation regulations are being' � complied with, Ili Applicant shall obtain 5tru turea Permits' and a sPp,tic Appli g . permit for the existing s,, required. q, property prior 1 App g to the kennel established+ro ert' taxes 13. Applicant -must also comply with all other applicable P. :state and 1o�'al statutes; Ordinances and regttlat ams. 1.4. Minor dha_nges may be approved administratively by the Directors Of environmental Health, Planning or Public Worlds upon receipt of a substantiated written request by the applicant and only to those conditions or requireittents recommended by their respective departments. Prion to such approval; vetificati,on shall be made by each Department or Division that the modification is � con. ste�lt with 'the', apnI Ca :ori, ices paid and f, 77 ; +rl b ,4.. L<.r„n.,wiY :4a Yh '�fi V,77 Y a(4,,Y>Y c r,rk1 rY a"k'yie + f r a r, e W A w 4} 'q 'I: M, A determination as conditionally approved. ehvit66ti ht4l de e , Changes ' dee m�`ed, to be major or signik,lpant, in nature by the respective/;affected Department Hdad\shall rd(juir6 the a pplicant to submit , an Am,endnierit 3V /Ir <I iYTS 4 It ....... . ,. .,. a ��yµwW,w,aa.ai,..>x,+114'V?b.ra.N. r3uFAJrcorcl Y i ua,�r'L �S.�.I.>l�a.�i1,h..a«.+4JL WYi"ldrLai..i'kzr..�l4.w Y'.ry'A1y.'i,1SM1�.A�4 :r coon ii t r y r Ig DIRECTOR'S OFFICE DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965 3397 + TELEPHONE; (916) 538-7601 MEMORANDUM FAX! (916) 538-7785 TO: Butte County Board of Supervisors 11 FROM: Bill Farrel:, Director of Development Services Craig Sanders, Project Planner SUBJLCT. Charlotte Speegle, Use Permit, AP 072-190-154 , DATE: February 26, 1993 REfUEST'/RECOMMENDATION e: Declaration with mltigat'Oh ro Dred Negative Charlotte Speegle - p p regarding environmental impacts and Use Permit to zoned measures a private breeding kennel for up to 99 adult dogs on property y of Hurleton Road, Oto (D'nclassified) iodated on the north side 1/4 mile west of Hurleton Swedes Flat Road, Lake i apa':oxirnately Wyandotte area, identified as AP 012-290-154, Oroville Planning Staff recommends that the Board accept the Planning 5 denial of this praject. { Coimmission's recammen dation for P BACKGROUND/MMLYSISs f s' This is a Use Permit request to dllov: a, pr-Lvate breeding kennel for located on the north side of tip to 99 dogs. The property is iiurleton Road, approximately 1/4 mile west of Iurleton Swedes Flat the Road, near Lake Wyandottei The area is rural, with parcel mountainous vri•t h the -, . ,, . n rom 5 to 20 acres and is sizes ranging f , this parcel exceeding 206. g p n average sloe oa$ � _ 1 apparently had a kennel on this site since i985 The appl�.cant h pp y than 49 dogs', and tip until 1990 had a kennel license, for no more Butte County Rabies contr6l Department: "ram a land issued by the use peispectivej a LJtd Permit was never granted and the kennel was U change in Section 4- never legally ssta fished. As a result of a cd0thtYoaly Code in 1990, the Rabies Control Depd±ii*ent 4' of the al�tte began requiring all people applying for a nett or renewal kennel had t,omplied with license to sign an affidavit' statin g that they Rdalth 'Depart'ment regti�.rements. The all Planning and thVironmehtal 4 a' 1iCant signed such a statement in Jul Of and r`eoe pp o y .• rived a , , m AA 11! 1 r , , 44 4. s 14 f kentie'1 license for up to 49 dogs. Upon an inspection of the site in November of 1990, the license was 'revoked for failure to have valid rabies certificates for all dogs and exceeding the kennel t� capacity by 50 to 70 dogs.. It was also discovered that no Planning permits had been issued for 'this site. The applicant was informed ' of the requirement for a' Use Permit in 'December of 1990 and madea pre -application in May oftion was deemed 3991. The! appl.ca a 1 9 complete in April of 1992. t.. o _1 y ;. s westerl ` The applicant has mobil home The area is about 100 from G_ g on property that i of the,�r ex�stin m Hurleton ry previously reveled. The level area is I� approximately 1/4 acre in' j � 1 siz, � � o the } ' Road a p property Y steeply nd has area and is heavilye ve tatedstee 1 t °! north from this level'. g,. The impacts and concerns withn,this type of use include noise and sanitation problems. With the'�potential for 99 adult dogs and an f unknown number of puppies on''th13 property, the noise from the site could be a nuisance tswexisting and future neighbors. The kennel site is near the bottom of a valley that farms a type of natural ? amphitheater. When staff, visited the site, the docts could be heard barking fromi 'varying distance depending uponon tho terrain. The closest residence is 3001 to the south. r There are two other homes to the southeast "that are both approximately 60.0' away from the proposed kennel location. The pr:perty to the west is an 1'1� undeveloped 20 acre parcel. The negative impacts of having a kennel in this. location could increase as the area ..population grows. However, even with a rezone, it is not anticipated that the area wip p 5 res. Noise impacts �< can be lessened by using retaining natural vegetation on the slope ll develop into parcels of less than a ac to the north, and providing a noise attenuating features to the (" south, east, and west such as a solid wood fence combined with shrubbery or hay bales., A morepermanent solution to the noise problem is to construct indoor kennels., Sanitation could also be a problem since the dogs will be limited to an area that is approximately 70' by 40'. Given the number of dogs proposed, the slopes on site, the low permeability of the soil+ and moderate to high rainfall amounts this area receives, the potential for surface water contamination will be high unless all wasters are picked up on a regular baa'is or the kennel's are constructed with cbhctet'e floors that are drained to an approver, septic tank and leach field system. it should be noted that the applicant specializes in breeding small poodles that produce significantly less wastes than a large breed: The amount of noise and sewagegeneration would be affected by the kennel operator changing the type of dog breed that they raisei obviously, a largo- breed argebreed 'Will produce moa^e wastes and some breeds bark more than others: With the potential for up to 140 to 150 dogs on site, including puppies, it is important that County Environmental Health Department and Rabies Control bepartment have access to the site to "insure proper sanitation and rabies vaccinations including tags ��`�''+""'M T r. '� A i ' i:�" 4 + � A.'. 4 � y ^.': r 19.E -� ' 1 1,� � � �. C I T +n y� I• .liikti.j�:±1RE.dkC'1�TfskrwY-Ytarluaut�Nl.Mxw+.�xY�!w+-+++; 4 on, the dogs as required by section 4-4 of the'Butte lCounty Code.j gcodoor' The applicant has stated that she. n .s willing ,tonstruct it time in c kennels with'an approved sewage disposal system at some gravel at future but wisher, to use, portable kennels on sand or pea wastE�,disposal Will 'be either chemical treatment or a r this time. gise attenuation will be.limited to the use of holdin tank straw bales,'. fe'A --zd, shrubbery or' some combination thereof . These methods could be acceptable for a lesser number of dogs but may be inadequate for the number of dogs proposed. Unless indoor: kernels with an approved sewage disposal system are .,con;�tructed,. the c should notbew�zupported or it should be limited to fewer project y,:� ro et r � gg , animals, Twenty to twenty-five adult poodles is suggested, with periodic verification by Rallies Control,.. Even with indoor kernels • number of dogs ,be limited to no more ' it is recommended that the ' than 60 adult dogs. PLANNING COMMISSIS.IN ACTION: j The; Planning'Commisson heard testimony on this project on three separate occasions. The majority of the testimony came from neighbors that were concerned with.the noise from the dogs. There were l or 2 neighbors that supported the project. Testimony for had and against, the project was also received from people who Ithe f purchased or otherwise acquired dogs from applicants: The j local SPCA representative' attended one of the he and spoke a out against this Use Permit for reasons relating to the way the inspection: dogs were litaintained by the applicant during a previous The Commission, after hearing all of the public testimony, demod the, request. r MOTILINZALT]MRNAT VES: i followin motion`is recommended: The g A. Note that the requirements of CEQA have 'L —en ' domp� eted and considered in InIaking' this decision; and I, H: Find that the proposed use of, the property will impair the land lies and integrity and ch:arac of the zona in which the of e unreasonably i7•,compatible 'with or that the use wOul injurious to nurrounding property or detrimental to the V health,sa et and eneral welfare Of, the persons residing y; g , health, or Working` in the neighborhood or to the general `because welfare Old safety of the County of noise and sanitation impacts, and C Denjr the a` eat for a Use Permit to allow" a ltennel dogs on pp' P: 290-i5�; 5peeg le) A : 072 As an alternative; if, the Board can make the required findings and { i, tr+ I + ,. h. .. V V •,r Tushes to. uphold. the; app eat, it would be appropriate to make the i f011O.°wing;.. inotio n- A ;k Fin& that• r An ini.tYal study was completed in compTian ce with the { �. California Fnvirontental Qualsty Act.' i J d study sand comments ,,.received the eon identified Said 2. 5a that the environmental of potential significant feces project may have 'had`, but: ai Provisonsn the project plans or proposals made such by or agreed to by the applicant would avoid to a point where effects or mitigate such effects environmental effects would clearly no significant occur. -befor - nae the icant b• There is no substantireva.suaema Al eV ha that the project as y eesignif effect on the environment. The Negative Declara"N:ion , with mitigation proposed measures has been completed in compliance with the m California Environmental Quality Act. r I 1 wh c �mpa� r the j p 4 . -' The proposed use of the �r tz ' the land the n in integrity, nor character o unrea�;uaably g- y not. be lies ..and that the use would injuriousto surrounding property nju incompatible with tor pty, and general welfare detrimental health, s or of the, persons `residing' or working in the neighborhood of the ; or to the ' general 'health, welfare and ,safety _ r County, because _. and B, Move to adopt a 'Ilegative Declaration with mitigation measure a ° -� 54 and grant a use, Permit to allow, a k0thel on AP 072- P. g conditions: S eegle) subject to {.ire follow�n Construct indoor kennels with exterior walls that have an $TC of 40 or greater. The floors shall be concrete of wastes toa and be designed to allow collection up to an approved, septic collection point that is hooked installed under permit from tank and leach, field system the Butte County BnVironmental Health Dept. x6 more than 60 dogs bvei` the age of 4 months may be on Proper t� any time thety a 1(ennels shall be located at least 501 away from any 3. drainage Swale on cir otf site. have a valid kennel The applicant shall at, all times, h � Rabies ,_he license issued �►y But:te County H�.alth Wept. �. k ` y 4 - a ,M i rrte- ♦# `,. Y , »s":.ww1�pp W+wsryol"ao_'d'!rCw++!Lw�.r+"' `I - - .• � �+ 11 i.Ix V Y �yA Y a �(k'� I Y f Io 1 4 �, ' iiLi � ) A N %i ✓ y 1) y ' 1 9 f 1 y ,+. Wf w ° rl t �r e b' is j? 11 1 i t" 4 7 1 Tn � ti"� ....'' t E r 1 , L)nr�..L'«ItlAtlulkl"S:7b.X,Swlaa-Ik:.iws w •H .••'1••.-' �,� i • iat•.u+�c a_,..hyn=yburttae....»Y�.uyY„Sawa+u.m.r-l,w�ti.&aYllAwr4451.Y' 4aYWc-4t+{Ik�Jk., oeus " IY{ cpntro7 f 5. All dogs. shall wear a `;collar and tag `identifying :the Butte°`,County kennel license y kennel owi�sx and applicable with Section 4-4 of the Butte County number in ac�.ordance di Code,- 6. Dog runs are to be kept clean so ,,a . not to create an odor matter is to be done ti or fly ;problem. Removal of fecal a daily basis and diiposed"'of in a manner acceptable I k on to the Butte County E17 .1r onmental `Health Department. 3 7. This Use Permit "shall not run with th'z land andshall transf terminate upon the lease, rental, or � All" e ownership of the property• i t mit l be g bogs kept n the ke has eto t � ` i , 2 0 pounds, le h mozle than 15 generally do not g listed by `the American Kennel Club. g.t No more than 25 dogs over the age of 4 months may be kept kennel is completed and ; R on the premises until the indoor by Rabies Control. The following temp ovary inspected p _ ;e us'tsd: noise attenuation measures shall,b A Retain natural vegetation to the north beyond a 4 distance o 30'. vegetation within a minimum of 30'' in a17. sha].1 be cleared for fire protection purposes, directions 'htaccokdanae with CDF's recommendations. B. install noise att6huatior barrieris along the south, The design of these ~ east, and we'ot s' of'�the kennel. tho Planning Divisi�� of roved barrier, shall be app by -the Services Department, �y the Development L0. The ?a licant shall allow periodic inspections by the t°' Envi onmehtal Health Department and Rdble. Control tata on regu� a '. • 're being insure :health and sah11 p th. tori lied w� ��. Applicant shall obtain building permits and a septic permit". for the existing structures as required. i. Ap P axes ;prior 12apliCant shall pay all delinquent prop,rty t to the kennel use being established. - . t 3 Applicant v, -t also comply with all other applicable and regulations. State wid local statutes, ordinancras 14. Minos t.Yianges may be approved acIministratively by the `'Aealth, planning or Public bitedtors of EftVironmenral receipt n a substantiated Written-]^equest 'by Wnrls upon the apply cant and oz,"il ' to those conditi.on's or Y ;, departments, by requirements recommended b their respective shall be made by Prior to such apptovalI Department or D'ivilsion that the modi.�ication is each dons stent with the; application] fees pa,td and. 1 =17�,1 d F+ 777"T kp • k � I �/ t r+ +� r , �i �,, ! , I !II ' a I 1 '' q�� � u •� i � !.• IrY 1 1 A � � + � i � x;.�.l kids 4 li i I� r � rY 1 ! h �� q 7 y �� I � +{ k i� ! 9 J '1'F k Ir yi'•'r � L 1 '. 'lye ! , n" } P 7 1 ! ! Sa ri i ,,, 1 r '` 1 ! �� ift °+�' 7,�• I h. i n °+`� It. 'I�. �L�tihll•rwi .r Ir a. YT, 1:, a � 1:� ,ia' 1� I 'ti h 4 i� � `I �'4 �r ne;ii > � I'i� � to �"I �„+ I 1 �'�. 1 I t.V .! � � I .,�. :. ',' � + 1 •,� a ,: 1 r at _ .. 1`.'. 1� 4,4 d y 'rr , spy 6 ”' i � I+ ly G� Ih i ,t'y' i ' 1 1 ;. '3 t S 1 •r. rt ..-" 'e'--: 1 -a+- ` r..n+l +,.w.:»r..<4—...Y Cum -� k 5! ! % rr 4�' .1 �bl i4 t�a ilk 51 Y.fl:$u'11V.Y� 15�.X:":G 'A.wvi i tSMMluka.Ksilsb.aucl+rr.w.�.. uw..�,k...: . ,y i i '� r..ie.'++.4,wp I '' tiL'�Miiw�+a11�M„Aa..ilv'�11a=.hFwM�+•M'� •�'' 11 +� rcived. . determination 2.s canal tionaZly app }i envranmC�ntal or significant in nature by rs�anf}es,s�k�emed ,to be major Head shall require the { the �tspc'ive� affected Department an amendment. applicaht'tn.submit /Zr 11 1 I 1 ra 1 I r 1 ,v i r. r("� d ! W � � ♦y t pp . i. �_ M �'`�} I ytiF r x _, , �'Y., 1 L! � * � _ e '; d t - lF e � r ' � •h'. y u h klY i" r � � I i( Y Y 1r � P i, C�. ai sl y,`1/eCom, f5W 6 {w %,•' 1 m �t ss.,�a7 Of 07 1992el � At He- � C � (•%• � + 7 y^' Odor a4clwo- 4e 'be Al'4 Ui�tF'� e2 els 7`"�i 1%' G - D ris-41 er m �f x �h .w.'" G-. �, � k'.� t ..E ��*� �v��� .W „9rNx•,H '�S ���k 1 Poi• I�A�W 1 � ���' � wx { � ,� y .... 4J �:i... '. �, �`.'4 ,,:• .a.�,P'1�pY.�,Cr�,p�,y�' k}`^,� rsa�k*�yA .r �;a'e h,e� - -- ,t1a -- ---. — __ t9 to � r 1 •9 X u r ,\ 1 t 1 h �{ 1' 1s �� s r r � r`4 I �� i 1 A' .r 'N st�ilbdw'£4L,iU"y�(eArlealfti;wa'R'+W,nf.Y.lasw°+.�.,s...+•:.. JALlWaryxm+M1dz:+=iliuAislWw::1.Rar..r•:'W+�rrrxxa'nC��—' k�lSNw14:.::.10.':e1PG.'�i`�='•Al�lYti>$' �i'Ati1=7°taNwuxaiurwr,..�..�.,..d_.;+.+...:.a.,.w+rwN. �' .-;+•-� •••.•d..,:�„.>ss. rug.+,_«- I a r.Y 4 t 1 PlAnnin, Lin ,artment ' DEC 0 1992 II Lr. I l �- l._. L ta` �ti ,u 1 j J'% Yrt 'S S , v n :�yAYuViit: t c,� i/ , ,�►1��rni li 7r /,'ilj oaf; j.,/9� { L, y^M n 0. of ; IV w IH j. r h w ' �.�^% V —[.� 1, L(�•�t..r !U i,` 1.t. 1 a L. i t h' d � h y cry cid �� n� rj `c.•^; -� 5 s �-" z. �", i' r \ , , 77 A ti, N, c! C� i /`�'`'r% Z.• t` r [f V. 17 i dl bell 7c� IPA 7-' 7-7 J' I I �f 1 rfl' 1.: M tl• Ib " �L �) MM N9`"Yr 1�4 M Ht,.^f�j� YX'yA} k� K A.. �t>4� �� ��. �+ d. dr: +1 ) tYn^�V ^ •t. � 1 �� vi A a ''� ' � r . ^ a A A� .y t' • .I 1 bZri , o f f r. t 1 r, G •.� q � 4 i , I z a � ,� t ,� t i. �.� ,'t` {� t : t: ` Cr t.: '' ,�, � ;;. ia� �' �r:Ji:�:k�::itS�46!,Ud'1YYV?«4��141aWIOS?ui1+aW�,�.�... ' ,.,,YW.C+aCOr.1 �a4�41ikLs�itL'tlltrwriwPli�.kh'ttk.M1'�.`�;.+rl+'Cl�INL`56itdFlF.�`mtf�J6Fct.nrY .,.::[Wd.aek+.•+=•...........,.a,.=..�Yww.....M�A.ta++;�+s;.rtw.�n,�� ,e:... L, ....aww ". In 'regards to th fo11o4ng notice: Publ c Notice `h nnhi, 06partiman2 Hearings wi[l`be held�ftl Thursday December DEC''11 'U 7 1..$Z !+ 90, 1992, in the But ie Courity Board of I��li 15UperYisorst,,. Room, Coulity Admil+istration j ,`• Center, 25 County Center Drive, 0roville, California, regarding thb,rdCtowinr item at , the following time: i it ITEM b4,W1jICN A ; NEGATIVE DECLARATION YIYIi MITIGATION MEASI'RES HAS BEEN.kECCMENDED 9:00 a.m. Charlotte Speegle - use Pen::it to A. Low.,o private breeding kennel for Up..to 99 adult dogs on property zoned 110 lfZ (unclassified) located on the north side' of hurteton Road, approximatety 1/4 mile i west of Hurleton Suedes Flat Road, Lake Wyandotte area, identified"as AP 72-290- 154,;oroville. 6 , The above mentioned application, Decloration, °and map are on file ,and t • public viewing at the office '7 `. of the Planning Department, ti County Center'Drive, orovitle, California: 1 if you chatlenge the above applications in court,,. you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone `else raised, at: the public hearing described,in this notice t; or in Written corresponlOnce delivered to the Planning :Commission{t at or prior to the public hearing. I' alltTE COUNTY' PLANNING COMMISSION II B.A, KIRCIIER, ! DIRECTOR OF PLANNIAG b 11; iA j WE THE UNDERS?i NED'NEIGH30RFIOOD OF HURLETON ROAD, LAKE WYANDOTTE AS 1"aA� WOULD LIRE TO DECLARE OUR PROTEST AGAINST CiIARLOTT- SPEEOLE 1 El'rEIVING A USE PERMIT FOR THE PURPOSE OF A PRIVATE BR'r;EDING KENNET, CONTAINING UPTO 99 'ADULT DOGS ON PROPERTY ZONED ��Ut' `LOCATED ON T,HE NORTH SIDE OF HURLk.TON ROAD AP 072-290-'154 OROVZLLIE. , ADDRESS rIAME r y. rr..-yr a ✓ y Y ✓ r , .,` i .. �^ ✓ �% ,,,,. "� f.�.� L.+ fir' r i 1 / r ,!'n / 1 =--rte 1 fir++' k ,r r ��� �L.l.•� i,� i i 'ti. e"r ✓„ •t w,0 � / rj •- w�,z r r + 4�� c. y �". 1. :. sy � f� . °+ 1:� �•, x.. .•4y ,i rlD'7 .r - k. ; t• 1' �W� u.,. `�� . w +i �•. r ` , \w -LA, i 1 �1.. �,;�:• �.. �,�}.°'�,r "''Y. .+` � Hof. -7-777—ti. Y v4, , . n 1d �1y L 'gI X { t.1Y 1 '�' 1 ( �� l ��•��� h +i dl4,1 y .f •: } r '� r, 1'4 I a 1 ]k 1k r 4 t d iF i ry/ ' a\ 5 d ;: y 1 i! 1 i } I q ,w 4 a" �',^ r �,"T`1 d �' t '� d r ' i f r i �:, �`, 11 r td !i • ,� Y i l 3ti y � } Y � Y I w..Ll 4 y 'rt_. ', 1 1 �r h ,� E q mY a d``i'�' I � f yGE d, y}'1 `t w s$v {....a : Y�r.v:�L�,.w�... ..,i .•21 ' y h �] 7iY�kiY "11'.r� J�'.ao!iSsh4.�•4.SJ.LXw...�'1�.Y�.'±u ivab'•�Y.s;{Acwnv+�., n �p}p yy%G "" .w+11t:1+:idd a:XEsiu4+�+ki;itir.ia �1ASN1:we14-:iuAl.,-,.ta ai:+ M+J=��li��` : a � ! �i.� ��)�i �y � " , Ft �+� � J�G.•G/ ' � J � �) �3� rs y�y. I Y i d 4[ I / / .�� ( d J Y r� 4 J !✓ •Li-�t"r �1 t. �'" !,y "`*''✓ .r...�.r i }�i ele j4 b I 4 ti t� f Y1 Y ` G q �ta _ 4 = i -- ----------------- J M may` i 4 4'"`Yj`*'i W ., ,f YA'SL. '"'I`b% 3 t ✓<Aw.K % :y 5N+ k'>t# d Y' n k yl.: V ' �MpF+KMYM t "i��i f r VA .t N c , .:. x i7 � jY " � i `" w &'+i eV 'R t. ♦,� q., Yb , A i t1 A`1 F ti.f i 4 a O W, �� ,if r( 11 1 ( . 1 i i a l a t �. I I.' 1 1 , t � ,!•. t 4' i 1• � v r'y 1 I r r { } ` 11 y '�.5 a�.i S ;.,"4 r +S I:•, �, } ^ t a ��, 5a } ^ e ;.r IES' , Apt, .D1V�I1�TISTR ." ,IV]� ' OFFIGE } COUNTY OrBUTTE 25 COUNTY CENTEA DRIVE �Yrf OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3380, sa •a T©ldoono: (916) °538.7631 I MEMBERS OF THE BOARD: e Fain (916) 53847120 I S c�UM�ri 608 MEYER JANE DOLrtN i JOHN S: BLAMLOCK MARY ANNE ROUX ED McLAUGHLIN CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER GORDONTHOMAS f lt i February 19, 1993 i MI t Charlotte Spee.gle I 1071 Hurleton Road` . Orovlle, CA 95966 Re: Use Permit; A;1' 072.1190-154' Speegle: Dear 1�ils, ; The Clerk of the Board of :Supervisors set public hearing for March, 9, 1,99s, 'At 10,30 { a.rn. to consider your' appeal of the Planning Commission's denial cif. Use Permit to allow a Or breeding kennel for up to 99 adult dogs on property zoned "U", 'Iocated I P � on the roofAh side of Hurleton Road, Oroville. The meeting will be held in the Board Of Supervisory' Room, County Aci> 1inistration Center, 25 County Center Drive, ,Oroville, California. Should you, have any questions regarding this matter°, please contact the Planning Department at 533-7601. between 10:00, amii and 3:00 p.m. Very truly yours, John S, Blacklock Chief Administrative Officer JSB:lr r .010 1 ( I r 11 ` 1 1 w. �� r .; 6M r ';: � � :, M �. v,,'t � t'✓ � ,� '�'.r r rACr.4 +h*wYYe, wM (�F,w.n + d M<t w 4� :,� 0 9 xa � wr a •,} t r r, ' ���`�`'� I 1 i i 4 ar �S`^1 r k14 '1� 1 I•,N }p L i y ��F. S � � y ,f �,� �> « } �.. s i� { rrt; Z'e { . ., 'y s i }, « « t of .r y r « ^ n i 4 a � •� k �i., ' : i« L ' « a « s r 4 s�tiy Y y « A w r «,. 1 � .�, '� ° 1 t is • k It y . � ` i I t! } - ' .� wA:w"hAxhsun%., ui�ri..+�i_,.w..,:,'o-�ww� '+ •aske4aAs}...M">.w.lt.:.lt.'k.k':PtFuf.Y_•trv�::.e:ett l - <.,g r ,i sw „ a h. uta Coun �w r, LSAAN,Q OF NATUPAL' y�N A c H Ai4 3 .;' � w - -r Department of Develo ment Services pp PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - ORCVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONE: (916) 538-7601 j+« Y y December 10, 19921 } k r Charlotte Speegle"( 1071 Hurleton Road Oroville, CA 95966' a; Re: Use Permit, .AP 072-190-154 r Dear lets. Speegle: " �I At the regular meetin of the Butte County Planning Commission held, December 10, � g�. 1992, the public hearing ,was continued open to January 14, 1993 at 1030 Am. to consider your appllcatio n for a Use Permit to allow a private breeding kennel for up to 99 adult dogs on property zoned "U" located on the north side of Hurleton Road; Oroville, k Th's meeting will he h enter 'lle CaUforiva. P 25 County C he �n the Board of Su Drive, Urovl ernsors oom, w 1. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office. Sincerely, u 1 k B. A: Kircher �> Director of Planning BAK:Ir a .,,,�,.....,.. ........ tt. 1 I 15 M1 5.i•.V.J4Y:'I.:aD'At.,�+«.tawv'eaW+o•wra�4..Mr Y.r;aw..r>-.Jw.'�it<Ca"�Wkriii=rb.tuA,:snzr,�s:LlanHxt.SWs'A. v»t•'d x°10.:.^R�J.'75c'3x4=1'd? j.}> Jam' ::P.%fit '.WU,.�,�f�„rcidy. '••-t4.-S0.+S`L.4,-',�P.,.... Ga.,..'..a�,,.w.-.W,..__....1....F-'"'•:..'.,, a1 r,�i;:Yy�,'Ix, rx*. .. t COUNTY 0 I'i E LLE -CA (FORNIA ;r` P .RCHASE ORDER OROV I � _ U { Cl:'. _ 26 9 �, 4i E Oroville Mercury Rrgister NIssued By Planning l' Attn Donna Department p 2081 Second Street , Orovi le, CA .95965 DATE INVOICE N0. AND;DESCRIPTION _ AMOUNT CHARGE TO W.O. # t y QUAN. • 1/13 /9 NOTICE 01, PutijiC HEARING To be published in the Orovi.11e Mercury � on Tuesday, January 19, 199 3 I° k Please n furnish this office with two _copies of the affidavit"'6:E publicat ion. � '' (Speec�l.ei Butte County Planna.ng a {� ti county Center Drive Oroville` CA 95965 _ itlr r t Y i, r f r TOTAL i, the undersighed, hereby certify that, to the best'ot my knowiedgo, the services or arildes �L specified above have been performed or dellvered or, Where authoi'fted, are heeabyconteaoted tot grid thdt thtire is a Budget Approprla"tlon for the same, f bated; --= p Hzed Deputy elnvoloe1Date Deptr Sub. Invoice No. Ericumbrance � Woos Amount hisoount 1 tyro eot Subr Cbjr ° u� _ 'PIN f=Naob, � 5u6mIt WHI 1, GANOY and K id PURCH01Ni with vehdat s Involve, stain GDLb �Y + a 7 r ,yi - aY t a Z ft � aalY Y y , (.r t.. :'� '� , v.- Y � 't .0 T. si • . gat t ,�$�at-.!y I_.� } e.Yl r i. •�ri�+ .'wy�Y '1lla i,., } `z�. ,�t. ��, ,.i.0.7)t4!,s i,:, i,?nY # k .t .Y }.r> 1 ri•. vas �. eGts xhi 1>« -.+ v _,;« a,� ii t h ��`1h. olili},s,�t,a.,n..,.� ,� , l It �` r t Inter -Departmental Memorandwn t Sue Johnson SPCA TO; Merry FROM. � Craig.Sanders - Planning � on, pment Services ' ' D�evelo Divisi SUBJECT; Use Permit application for a kennel .in Butte County, Charlotte S ee le, AP p g 072-290=154 DATE: January 20, 1993 • , The Butte County Planning Commission is ire -hearing a Use Permit application to allow , a fennel for 99 dogs on property located 14u�rieton Roan, east of Oroville, Due to an. error on the agenda for January 14 .1993, this hearing was republished for January 28; 1993 at 9,00 aazn, If at au possible, could you or a representative from your { Janna 28 1993 Planning Commission. meeting? The hearing organization attend the g will be at 9:00 a.m. if you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact me q at 538-7601. CBSar 1 . 1 ' - t {I 'r t x • � ,• � , , t . ,,. x, f .. � rr �Pp r Y fa'r t„'1,.t � d r {� • w , i t „y. � rr i �' 1 ' .g ,� - L w �l i�: ,4 y . , i� ,.. � 9 k ,..3 :..„a, r �� ; + , . , t ,: 'rt . B,A.„! • a� 4 „tlMr, a ., ,s. ati � ".;, � , kl ns�q , i r 1ay..�� lle�P, I zi ' � a „I INTER DIEPARTMEN`1'AI. MEMORANDUM TO: Craig Sanders, Planning, i ' Environmental -Health FROM: Torn Reid, SUBJECT Charlotte <Speegle,Use Permit DATE: January 5, 1993 I r The above item was continued open from December, 10, 1992 for additional information. ” Because the }Y5peegles have fled a Maim against the County, a complete operat^nal history =j r;.• cannot be provided at this time. The claim iias been referred to County I counsel and Risk Management. Records do indicate however, that the Depar['riicnt observed approximately 80-90 poodles on Zached P P rtY rification of rabies 'Vaccination wasprovided far98dogs. roe m November 1��0 and vepoare copies of kennel _license application submitted by Charlotte Speegle on July 31, 1990 indicating Planning and Zoning requirements had been ,net. �I �iI TR/m1f yf Attachments 5N } i I k. + �x x��A� �. 'Ax IAS♦ I a ) 4 a' x I 1 1 , X - t k y:r ,xrtr ,v 6r $�r��� a b,t � •'f ( r d, A xX ._,. � v ` _ ' ' • e r + i "h ' ri,_ �t , '. t +;� ^ � `,�t � ` ' ',I J t Jy� � `1 C 4,: d �I -i k ly" � i Itl � � "•�y I t � , ' I � fl Q !tf + I;' �f '4� r+ 9 ':I , ' # 5 � 15 ✓ J 1u ILI i f Y � �1 �I. •y �i c � a4, ,o nl it �1 J y 1 +! i ++ir # �'s i4} ;�+° 4 a '1 f� I f Iq,'�I I '� 'J I ,:, ( lt� 5, .t 1 M l;i i Y 4 �.Y o 1 •..f tj� 7 I 1k +J f, kK� µM1 44 4 t� � i :i �',S� ttv�.` n 1 •. .,y r° 1 .. 7 `• w..`. . ' ° !:I. V- A 1 � k • is 'rxy 2 ia1'� nl j . � 1, 4 �n i# � '♦+ ro',. . ill f1 �� ,� 5� �� ^ s .w �1 i v ytY •bcte^Y• i � � y u:it �3W+• wr..'4auS#.k �"`��.• �.• d+-:t42+ter" •er,µbus•rw9.t�f*:'.X4c....Y��..slL1....,t'�,.�'.2-•i'v�•.,�«��f:,.k}`.,"„._•:3-,.....,02ic1''�9''•aY�';n..>H",akt.�” rfs�tl�r�.kii�5ll�i�f��i�L#�t�l�tki�:�,it�M1J+�:�..14t#lt3�rou7 °' N'^,51.1,.9Ss11�'t�3)w1.+l.V�`i�t4�!�,Ci�r�>y +� r. 9x we ! � Iki � KI j Inter -Departmental Memorandum t TO: Earl Young - Butte :County Rabies Control FROM: Craig Sanders - ,Butte County Development Services Department SUBJECT: Use Permit application for a kennel in Butte County - Charlotte Speegle �k DATE: December 15, 1992Ih The Butte CountyiPlanning Commission is currently in hearing on a Use Permit application !, + to allow a kennel `for 99 dogs on property located Lon Hurleton Road, east of Oroville, The applicant is Charlotte Speegle. At their December 10th meeting the Planning Commission continued the hearing in order to get more information on the pr ' jzct from the SPCA and t; Butte 'County Rabies Control. If at all possible could you or a representative from your f Department'attend the January 14; 1993 Planning Commission? T'�.e hearing will be at 9:00 41 am If you have any' questions regarding the hearing please contact me at 538-7601. r , " f 0 jIP � „4 r•.,t - , •i:,SY l T # ii`^'ti' l t ipa0k I+K+'^ iC"Rt..m,'la7 t 1 " `7`T EL *'#'# H_`i,:. `T""C"•"!•. yN .., AMM ._.. , y t r ' • tyJ u + a'lIY4 PI °•� 1 M A�� � � - i • H • r 44N, #i •. L4 f W .. Y � � I 9 # - t �• A f f 9 y �. �, 1 � e 4 I I �'!� � I 1 1 i I � q '� I ' !' v�' I �l�4' .il+ .. .1. }.7 l •.�I Y ,,i. ;��fi a'1• • !. 1xf '4 q `I..,u 1# 1 S e Ic ek f� S'' she !f 14t (�P..P���S� S I 19 a 1 Av _ �r:. �'4r' m t.0 i« 9 N--^',6• • «.n.• � h �"k.f"a�ti."i.�"i' 1s,.�L-..,N.t�,a: -�i.,y..tk-1n. I %1�� "���.'.��4, e� ��ti 1 ,Pfi� 9 � 1{ .,.1 �Ie��t,`'}S4`:��r'�54��C�•�ilf 1h''Y.oa AY'„ Y*:Ej%y�«;��ifa3i=;i.rLJw '� y- N� l-I11W��Y /�}� /7 x ' �-t Ae- .4 ' a4 ,t } y M r I G I �i AI r a Y I Y t Y� `� qPr T� � y r �S' dzl Y I� �� 4 . ri i 1 1 I 4jl^. ' 4 !, ,,: ` ` i 1 . ;. •15.R a . -I �2�. . � R6i1C.fe,.li�Cl,��.`�i,4is�A,�A+;Kali�'6i'xil:�w�t... ....u,,.uw..v4+:.w1-.t.......:+,+-N..+wlabx•rJSUO'ic`eYh4r'k:t�Si:l'ski:idh.d:'JAI:Lfi`�.9rR..k1l.�.ltia�'4�rst:+Galccuu:::aa0+emuw..:wet2rk:::d=+"�1d1�'�."�'G.k�^'�FY'lY::x:B!.istf,U•ttY::.v,Rietr.:iro.,u=%a-- 1 a v ' y fou `ter ia/ ti H i ^4 De art nt o ev t Services — �LA fA �EPA��IVIENT 4 j 7 COUNT Y CENTER_DRIVE — OROVILLE, CALLFORNIA95965-3397 dj TELEPHONE' (916)538-7601 ELEPHON } ; November 3, 1992 Charlotte SpeegleR ' 1071 Hurleton Road ; OroVille, CA 95966 2 �. Re. Use Permit, AP 072-290-0154 Dear IVs. Speegle: r . Enclosed is a copy of the Staff Findings concerning your application for a Use Permit to allow �. 99 dog on ro er zoned. U located on the north side of Hurlet on g P P tY Road east of O vill ' � F he hearing has been set for December 10, 1992 at 9:00 a.m. This meeting will be A public g j P 5 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. held m the Board of Supervisors, Room, 2 -- � h The Planning Commission recommends that the a licanit or their authorized PP to respond o an questions the Commission may representative be present at the hearing p , y Planning re resent the applicant, please contact the In the event that no one will p_ have. office prior to the scheduled public hearing. m Should you have any questions regarding this atter; please contact this office Between 10:00 aim. and `3:00 p,lm, Sincerely, - lCi rcher Director of Ptanhing - �/�,�,, Craig B4 :Sanders Associate Planner CBS,1r d +nca , � • v, b r >.:: an 1vr d , 4 �(� � ,• s e `1 l j V.•ii i µ R yl. b 3M a. i4.14 AI yyY tiYf Yw �p' L-. yin! .rYy y rE, 11 R" rty x w � dR YT 1..= • • A k • ., i» �I K 9 ,. �1 r ui 4J Al" 40 1A ax fe 1. Comml ION F PUBLIC HEARING P g Commission that I public hearings heidby give P Notice is n by the Butt County lanrAn Butte 11 Board Supervisors urg r 10, 1992, in the Butte county. oar of will'be held', on Thursday, Decembe e, California,. Room, County Administration Center., 25 County Center 'Drivei Pro regarding the following item at the following time: MM_ UELM Q, NWHICH NEGATTVF DE -0 GATION ME ASU,RES —A— HAS BEEN RECOMMEND—ED drulel for up Permit to allow 'a, privatebreedingk 9:00 aim. Charlotte onekke Ude to 99 adult dogs on, property zoned "UK (Unclassified)located on the north side of Rlitleton Road, approximately 1/4 mile west of Ifurleton Swedes --area, identifie Flat Road, bake Wyandofte'. d as AP U72-290-154, Oroville. mentioned appficatiorj� Negative Declaration, and map are on 'file and The above 0 1 of the Butte County, Plajaning Department, I available 'for public viewing at the office above applications in Drive,,,Oroville, California. if you challenge the County Center court, you maybe limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing desc-dbed ' i notice or in written correspondence delivered to the in this Planning t mmis ion, at or prior too the public hearing., Utim COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION B. A. KlItCHE P-; DIRECTOR TOR OF PLANNING is �hh .. , L+. •. Q. :.. w � cat. - C ,.� r :1 "L : 7 r y�?"y�" 'f , ..•Y"t*c:i ka,i , +"i 't a i `t!;a 1 PA?` k :. a'.,�, Wa �•��' a,: ,•r ,.i,.; Y. Yt 'r Z" ,,, • rr"•1 `r 'f�"' ! t `F • iC; ';���, i + i l.v,. "::y rp x aeC.: a t:,,+s< \'�,,.dr.4} r , L { ; .v d Y, .'� •� "�!i U �,.�„dM1 t s+C�n i L t' yAY, .},Ar: d i1• f. ,,r,: w rr�u i Jy ,;a { ��^I r,flla'1� .# v .}•'r ? c ""v L. t,,ri , ,� k; .P: sat. '.iL a,:. ti7,1 i .5N yy.P,..iF.. ",��k'.ni"'�r �.rt% � � k• �,t �fYai -+!?,��g. ,ji .,,� I+i t ',"� �rr.>'�� Yt:b k�r,}t,+ �� �`l�'�v�': r, 'i�,r t ` a,�M. - � 3. � F, "k4� 1`'t �> t �J:r#ryy r�. r a`,- �" : � � . MLf '�!'� • �#• tt, a '��� UAL '� tY• t�,. tf��+r'y7�A 7�f�9iY.4=.t:, r L •a.'t • x�Y L� „`fid .1 t �+f��. i ' ¢' ' 4 pit. f• i �'"i ! ^' In }}A{i�/J t a;.0„-y�l�r 'At`1r}y "M yk*.x:,•} i' rod! a kji�tj'f�:ft W.,'. i ^t};,':,sy„y"i �x,.p+•{r, ..> ',. ty,-,tom,>. ' �S,rJ 'a � M' ,� ^Xyf1Z,Y• r�t,'r1.9:i4a"�r'JfyL,`,#r }�iie�'": �'' 'k,1,• ,�. . ,+�.. F. t R, d aft . `; r, ,t}s k. W ,�. .( ,t AI rK• a t� , �h p. ,w ,•Y.e ,r. Y'}{' �1.. •7Lry` r� � t t 1 vt} � a ` , r, •� �`s�},.,�..'•,+.' L �,x.`i IK.,V'_ l �,• r ' {B1"r� ' •i. C �` � h,.e{ � f ��'�r'+•/''t` zt .. a tom«;}. v {.L i;. ,•.�'E .` ;i`t'r �..x�r -�, '��'. ,. `. . j?N,f��lt 7i'i `1:! r�`� a* YL.,.: ";a� "". {,i�' r"., tf f ,gthl. ;P` -° ,p�'P k�:.: , "P7 y. 1 '' � . ?a' �' it ,• }4' �` p � t dx t� .�/� �. "±its .q u",�:" � . 4'�^�,1�� �.p�rLY�,,�k � !,. L;,. � � t ,:• {%=�'E','7 '1 Pr'�', ,�.L• � ,..r.K �'p�; r..'�i ri�`1�4) . ee�.,.!�i i� '�?.t[��tXri . •� . � t r:+f• .'L.. t xnl N;- �r�yYLK7�7�f ����V^f�'{•Y :'ti:.f;.y`." �iati9l.°•itt iivr �Wl+ ;f'{"r!,RA �� '�, �vIJ' Y�4 hlcY, �, 1+ ..ti 1 � -.. a e r,rp:, 4 .r,,,,... b. tt • ,�rfa''"'Y_ , aY i'�1.1i'}'t 7 ' . P?�,4U,j� t �� .,!'a,,�.,, +, .epJY .1'__dr-C7F,L•1 t ,l"C .:'R �,M,'r .Ityrt�.i i' a! 7rlty,�`( .',z� MIX Y S 1 'A ,.,M • 1'tr. ,r,M: i rY;t, , F ��"'� q�#5 �41 w�•6+ice t,tdw' aha �"Pj jx."+,+.,r;Y,.414 IV 1y1. ^e:. , '�'`..j}, • a'`„dr '•+,.'7 d hitt �,rt.p f,- uta. '(-¢ '43 .+r, d.tt„� riFal°+,YC`w'.1�d:i$. ,,..r". '` `H'1'.. il''7•P: _�M•r t� `: , .�r, t;` ;�tt rS! ;:��`-.�'�'�?' a• 'Ti.r• ��lt^'��,, , �;�1�'L� d.. MY}?, "y;ti3�••�`+; j,i + ,..,Lk�t;r,,.,J,t.l:"#' ., e�.""y: ,.,,{�" dcr `!'•,:� It RrY,Av..j,,.9t,+,y'_a.nF:., .a,,.+ q,' I.' rE '$ k", ., ftvft:! .i 4:_.'C:'»�,p it - •?. �V+".: f�; nt'if..r .,r•Y�Nx Ill ,` :. 'tSr 11 ,ka .��[y��. t kr , '' ' fed p ?' -i rano• at'Y_,r .: r}7,.,F:r1-/M'oWt.J?•'.','didL:lk•g;}^r t tl °x ,�� y6 '','tyr: +•. daR'Nt• f y ,!o•4r ,-jI �a _ 9. `i a,} i.Wi } J\ ,i=F'fi " r e:! ,6/wr �rlk.rtt L, },• ,.: .,�j� ,� ,vim •,%..N,,rr,,,��'' nn���' a+-�7"'!^'�3:1^E>>t)gY ''. ,�.ie:. ,a '�.. t'"dr P.IYvr-�+.,,i+ f rL�. ,h� 1.,<.•:n,,,N -��' .4"�.;.ti, .:r (`h i, al g.-.. ,.. , :t.;� r•rW tvy. .r,�•..tt: }ta, 1 .Er ri• -}}. Er- 3t w k,_. t,..a r,,, ,l .y;; „ c ar 'f:+.^L.A� :.;„tp .I t,L" ,�• �tY. +c, .{ 'F, ��'i• %!E .� ,.5''iV.jj. r �X.. ..y,,.. � .G r� , >ti . t ;L b� 14 , �rt .j'!, +,,?',�*Ptr, p.;et', �,:ii`kya• .' .: `F. � .,, .}'"' ?� /i,�, v ,�r,�i � rt, aE•//. 1 t, t. yt w,v, !�' .,'.,. d k rY � st- ..Lrl:.,t+,...,•.'yS' L ,Y.f. r1 ,y,7y. .y , .'l'^.'F''"�tj'j{ f: r ji{ti"•t •.rnR. .I�t °•�''ts t;.i+7f h:\ {i#'J,: .,..:q,; r," `', {dip@i"� ` y ..f , yk i. `i.,tN , �;t�.•3s'ttr« Y;i3� -1 al - ;;Pk,,i $ a�.. ;. r; l .�J.'t{/ +4�;1��.'•1.E, A, fp '� .p.t'•�`.t.. d";:r�•.r' k'z'!lt..z,EP, ,caf 'ifYe k�.azp.,,ii. ;; R yT+ .,�,fy}�i. � .h•.. tk.. i.,, ;r at �'.e.,,�1 {rar��.:� w �Nr'i'k'1.a , \.r -r ,. ,, ;fit a✓ .Y• '(. .Sr '.'3".: �y,..,1-'�Y ..y„ .t 1 r >r :• � ° «t r1 }"�i;: ,..,""`7 at».'.� ,t nr-.."7� > if �n,, � i. rl• j�;� i' '.,� r', ,,y •S;� C+:$1:6� , p 'k`: •�' • $e.xL;!,., ,k§i, �"1t'.',Y.�!W, ",-, t:rd �t�''Jr�;. .,1� j{ n:. Wiq.j�,. ,..v+°�11.r , .�y�`. ; r•,L w, . ,� ,,d+ 9 L a 1r , , ..�`i *.,,+ a.:�,.,` �`�ai�iy4up°� r• L. � ;�'13•}. '1?,; .9�`..., i ;L/�(:�i ' tv., �i�•i"Lg�`?R�'.W4Yx i. , •17'� ,!e��. f 9d. .4,�y� Lti� �; 7 i� ,7. ,`.'ak, ! pC y'!. t.�'a $:+�'•/�J�`} "ti t}c, r , Tb4> S- �;ttt '#• i4f ,e.,rht, w +t!^ "t��.'it` s � 'Fcw<<> #. ,�. 4 tii •t6'Ix �y,... {,;" » i ,, y, •.'!.+M:r. �Q.. ii'' <;5 • t .t11L '+ '.,n',+� P.#! ,rrt�,t'' t,\,,, a L'k-'R �.+�',,rz yf;.• r ,€ •P> ' L ,. rr i�rAS?'NFti.ti'+}.L 'a "1 1�, - ',g .; ri`i;7�d:,;t•' 'ePt_»} �: :"'9#�' _? ri'.' ,t.:p;...!�.. ITt y�Kv R b '7 p+7�W yfi a i #�l• ¢y rt� 1 h` 4v 3 f a' ' �s a td zlas' �•f� r r '+.,,ka +ff 14. S`'Fi.d:• e- 1 d»'"z' ` 4 bi?Y r l'r,a :9` , •, L • V. , 'f9'A. t i`ti'} -!!.. In �� �. ���� ,, � r+ •t, .t .L +it. X�51% }; 'i e-b`y.i« rL•�i .+iE i' d \ ,i rt'.'� a. �, ,:l' +�r�+�' • t, Y•\. r�y4Y'ir �tL.� {a" lt;. r �L•1J �. ;t .Li�1}f `,',y"+�r .y"„2 t, ?,` r- ��pr 4�l�a+Ii., 7 1?� w'`;'k` tri ,,, ;x•t.Rt� v`�'t�l'�j'�.ijg3�ii+R'J. "t t{�c_� }�ryy a•�p! -+,•- ,�j:a r'�. .'�GrjrF,F?r.:""µ :t,i?rJ,f »%T L yr L'rr.^tf tt; N¢ ty. •P%'P. aZ} �� "r��• rxr7, i},"�"�- „Ctsad1•'t�r. �,- '`y # .t ��ia,� ` i M`rir S tyi,-9 Z } b'4 Ur 1 fi r .ar . �:.r v�•f,.t ..at rr:, w 7;{ t . �,¢ri, 1, �P'L# `t f sie �.. .� L�,{ trlr, . y'... • 1 ?I iS,'Y `s: i, 5E' < �y •,�, �!: G+ d%�, $... ,, 1 +j".,P,' '_ , Mt' �{fig , J tr"X: .,lr•4,s*ara rt ittf��i',. g r.' -.:X'µ' � i . M -w `% '� :•k; iiL'^r `C.9 41"'t` q, e! t:"'�i �,,}, k i 1{i�y.�q•I� \ rt. {.y>s �•�F' -: CAM vY',t ,,1 a i tLgv,,,a:�a � r .! _ ,+ ,6sKr.k •l A:.:.- 1i: tt�q.' ?�%,+F .�'.. Sz t f • ,p •t'' np,• tr, i Y� 5 f•hr�1L{ v Kr t: M1 4 :hu,b.f;6,x i .'. ILLTUI?., d�i{C 'n 4d. vF,j�''.'• Ln y. L•GLp,�ikY".t. ?,+v, ,j7.,fi>`- a. v .`..a u,. „fi: "i ry CrfrS:Gi�,' },g .,�rt;'�!",&�-J••..!�.:,�' t3. ,��a 'n� �„ rri .r:'1 ai. .1�twkc,��. !•,C, p .y� _j..r.��appi j � %�(,�F Y.,t,1 y • wtJ 1YY'.d:((qq,,'�Yd ^,j 'u�N{ y7pj( R` a,��" a ,r f r,l,'1"!tyls .}1 .. �•rl":irtw�g'+^"'; $v rr•>s.t #;ItUN T1-':rS�,.;•°dF,,.:IL { tm•�r:,, Ott, �,'.,�r• 'tx,•'ra�wJk::�p�r,• .: �',. �..W 4 i}, ♦ i � Sit i'�j.:� 1 A " i.+J.3 T `�:. x ,�{, 4Sd•air iy "i? !' t.. a, '-,.. d.4 u ip•1 +` tf'�..-,�i� r 0 �-r h 4'� •c , G. '' h's d ","1'� a 't ;fir 5."%y} t 4 ? +,.(S tir.;a�1Pi'"E:a ;a.Lt:. rnwT": •irX..cp7�•; +1'W;t:• ;t,1•s*d ';t;, ,r }F.. any. n ivf 'k;!e Y�., �:y, t PA , 1 r c i.,,.,y ,.,r , �` •!' Y `r ,.i {'" `t! 1Yi a "�''G♦'i✓,'r• -+>r?x �Y `�+�7; :4x1t!�i il�y^., 4, �e{r7y,S'Ji )a�T:`�sSY }!,+�ut. Q'J i. a:'..t 43':� ^_�4.'1 FtY. 'h 3i. a� J°, F?lq t tii ar' {Lfit', i,E >?♦. 1 �3 ;• t '�4J 'p.. F;aL 4a �� bi l: 'h� v, °°;7�L�','7i "eY'•' ! :.hr, K¢t K.. ley t , K 6r %^, �a._ k r E,s y , ,.. w•)t.. t:y n tps+ - .k+ r rr} r: i,: r it ':' t p a .i " n �ist,, a•a; d r; ya;id+yt�pd 3z } , ; `ti'X,ry�:k!'1 � i:.: '.f•! �"I: {�pn Jtt :, .x. ....f. r , .. . i A"`�. �'. i:- Ah. f)'+ ,. .T r.a•t?4d. �J' ti .;. 11 L:�.�i'a.'v,, ,1 �k jM L: j' 1 J l.K �yYlL f�4Aab "' C'�!:�:r4; '�F �.'.. . {�%K K.'• ...#, ,i:,. .t ;,W P,t i �"� i.: .:�.1 i+�r. -,. :' b':a � 'li' . , 4�}•�. tE.N, w+..t�J•a. .�a'5♦ 3 :2`:, .8 yPa �. � t (., ,, (. •y.� y,. "fig t4„ �' I V!.,.,Kr..aa'• r.a r r+K'.N:T'v. 'i d,r •+r f<:; k. it5tt2:,r.i, r}i i� t,," x }?•zr„ i, i , Yr rM't. #r Q' ' lu , ,.t r :�,. .�.t (,•o,'G• t�")rryNp" ,,h., 4't �s, rF d.,. IJ; ,r�',t�, � 4 a. r `g�' �q , r 4 t"..rJ�"�'F.L�tr.,, "n%.n i 4'. 'seg r G "!A, .. erd �". �:.{'," Gp,y�f,, .Tir vl} Szt.•. °u;FX. t• : Sh!nYv ��t +'�'•:.,4Y°K.: r,Lt b;; u.. !Z �°.� t1'S-, q.,, . r , t,:, .i .� Fn L. « ,,�, s h'1ef�� �4°,.+i,.�l ..'N jLh {'• :++ rj1=tP�g,:•L:.,. ,�. 1, q a..:+h.r:v ;t'� f ,s"E 3•`��lrt•...a,M �`: ,A': d ,r�:r'i:',.'yv, L } 1�.,v.tji TI,/�r>, kt,: i y:�t ,�i4x t"d� :•t�+v,x 4, t.�,1i,' f7.,,r0.. r'piat:r;7;:h,#51 z,1{4'. } ,9 ;}' +�5 .+t+ W',la)'Y� u,*.i• _•., `1�3'j4 LC. �, �, .�,'•�K tt.•r- X ',K7.'ita.;.r W�+,.iJ ",; {w.'.. ;f r. li(,�l',.v...V, 'i!, t,ja,t t{ '�,ai,'i'�•yr.no.- ,,...,y '�r,�.. E;,,4� dt.,, ,.Sy W.,t: ':t :•t• :1"-. �,p" p htiq' a jS h r, Yzr `Yr �,t1 \i:��,�'E �'tjizt�A•"' ^•tty; � F f¢,R? ��3.ru f� t��;d . �,�y t,. ufV:�th; ^1p•• ..t��1: 'k�',ar';.•.l' r�. d. # . r `.t :.,r ,�N.. rt sRi.�i` + i''�, •^:e,5'rF;l;.,! 9. ,lA �i�{Ly'E'. tdiR".ts i #'_q ' rdfal/,..758 +1ta 73..: r`ir"^rty l't .4by�:..r:. z 3� (•� e`�4' ti: �•I'tr 4 � µc. ,, s,- w „ti't - t "r;y • tt i ��'t�t(.� .Lz,.�, `'"ti�" •� tt ;F\}::.v,.. ,i /p4i,'�`�3J' �' 'w'A x Laf aRvF" n n.' `S. x'' rra'".+�,d�.� k"4 °.t t tE.� . t ,i iJ iy r xt ,. r. d•.xt si5t ,k', n.:t r � Q A5 AC, 4-,k. �}•S�yJf �p�}�,! �}{,. �`'•a.. w. .,E.'�:a :y pl"y�,t ("_.an rW.::... ', y,°�� Pt t �,...� �`vrf;l •e.Ad ° ,:1'i ,{1 �is W(ti�k �'(.r^'.d•',�u�t(�'�«� 1 �LY,4vi�. I.L „1.�� 'W iG=t t' tMr,.tii +.y'.^'..x�a ,C:•JF'�{„�!',r 4. "ill« !7. .:. 1, :{I+a! °,nit .r,�i 1� ',":,'1. t -!#"_,,PJ .''� '(, Ol ':'•i"'1 sfi., �''".rtlKt+ 5" .l S{, j�1 r:�.,. .�' ,id!`1,t. "r° �;.'{�,/rl�., ,��. ..•i`, '�6�.Ly�'.i!.•P i .y. � c�; , s ..+'Alt (^�' � ra. d tv,,Y. a. j- r..ap5;r ttx'f T WA.. ,{,iV1. {:,u, lij , '� 1 } �i x ,,! ¢`.L aj kx r ,a'y, ", ,�X "t7�J'• /r i`p f of y,'�i'd! kJL4Jb; �Ct�3''d `,, f"C; :',�Nt3 .7'�.Y,. t" i'•�r.'. Y,s r,�J � f�Jl,''r FM.a '� . ��' !4!, \ ASctQ �'.:-�P/��. V..9 �/, °b x T• M ; {` ~v .�,. '� f'� 3L Ta•AtP �L'ii C7F\SL' .say p' '� Y. t �., � � m 4�...!w _.\ ,r� :'h{r - Y NM,..t15547/48 h �a,k};,7J ay / i a. d ,, h e s+ 9 e (. + ,LC:, s `tr i,{k, t.,,, ,` ., /5 7 O aC ✓ Y d. p , ><` S r vi t.,.:�:Ev , : 7�j';„t�K _,q�.a�..��t+�,L�'���'y �i Nh gt!1E���'fir+ft��.t`i�11.7;�.hi�.5'i.i" A::>tl`.». y•''r♦'` -...5' ;v�tr�y�3� ..ar" O ,$•.. .rtJ`ll.a,.(, '�b .Pr .: a! ,-'a .t.;.. :. 9.,..I fi.r,W : , .h 9 Lw. * , «., .. / • tti", }•��,vf J+xr a•\lam �j� `�iy y 4�v l'Y yy !r'' " sg" �' t"Lr x ri,'!t�ti t ..q, t dry; rl O.+. �t,wd tom, � t , 3' wiry t � t� r � ° � �-l��i},• � � Yt�fi• �Ae'4o�.�' ;�A',ai^�;'"+:t M yy 3�: ' .:Ft ff-ti ar'.•+ H• },W t,Y;�l "a. r'p�i�!''J•�ytd t: 491t ',�C;y4, 'l' ;T a � 'y1R aai'•'t♦.: ".''% i' W�%,'.i;+�,t:`:v,.tlC[•'` ,5�" e,P: y,':�r y:.,..x,. •tw y,4 '..y. {o, c•y':1 •' Jr„��S d:, ;��- rt,•k+'bl ��t.�?�',..r� `.l.a .�+ , �sr Jr�,ct}{,'� r. (,a �tr;i ± t"Y�,:xkr�t(.� \ ��,_ cJt,`..:i'��h a{+qct' �x;ta r� ;,•h. +y.,. 1 ,'! L yx:..t r r a 9 r}C,,"X 1 ;i{tl d�,,,alk li. ,a � r! .A * .. •:` ;'. •'ter .:��.t�i ,i1tG,,, ' N••l .•,r ' ':: t .r, �"t c e 4 a r }; ta� �. � � .•Y 'i Y v a. 1 is k dt' 1 Y tr`, 'i`.• % '�' k :t,'ik �' r r 9 r, r1d, f 1. r ., '. �ld, 1f r '.- , �,,J d r {" zfi `i'P ° s a .ib_ _�l1 ?%• �! , ^� � r` -' 9 a 1 +" k C 4 r i j µ' r„ N Y.ey' , r .. ({L�t„�d��!°1 SljJ}'!, �• } i��3 ,=!til'�,.'r ti,¢ �.SS5�h1'd; ':.xLr 7 !�`u.: .�, ...�5. ,{��. y1 au�:�k A44,g .t�• a� ,ty ._j 1�'. M,,r 's9 \�Yd r,.' A{�yl.`` yyw f9C tM '..t '1; S N".-�}.:�N }i,� r a't"L.a,a'�irq•1"s,r' .r•. .: ,. q, ik f`w". �� "t'�;t '�tv 'ti°5���.,: fly, ` ..:_ I r s 8 �Jx ���fi��'�. �i 'a-� '�"; 1'�tit S' +..r Yr.^- 'aa tv r • h +, :i `. b = !ta -�e..� . ;.r':r'� �*#.'r,i E'Lr' Y , rr t y n*' l Ar !'+s,l i %I, } r a . =. .:,:LG E4 , 1' d . + / 4Y' y,, _'.:U y,. •'¢ a , !^ 4!° :A ".v n� ex -a w4:' `z'3't`t,y : s •'i{. .,�,4>r 61. x• .r t✓ti u, F9 '. �!#, ».;t.� '::'rC,i .,t, .s,�r1s1V .. �,l+f- T K ..a �, 2 .ab, v f - s• i n,,j '��1 �d:, •,L...� i ,k a � � � .�., ,t., µ` .,'� n +' .,,. t�''►t j:��'' N ,ivlA .r�,%r4"vy,�•tt!'{� �,Ff,�,tAl!.,i�r.c �It'tttys r. { !�(p{ r�! �•' � y,A� 'tt: � � 1'Fyf �P �Fr� � 1 rRy.i�, X ' q / : •0 i5 '•� 1 .L n 1if1:'+ ; 'h IL,r �''t4 6 t L;� ;y -t,�' .{�, i'.- 1. ��.,•, �.•',[ 1 'M ^i, z "•tea lr ,t{'.t4r G. Q�,�`+7'tt { fig! �`, tS �t�v f }' �J�fLSJ ,5 �,t !f", a_nP .f. sdr 'F;° ?'1M; \`. J ,,+ M". C r •;+77N dk.. ,�:i,y�A-q"gid i r: Al..�=� p 4d•''!�+ i '(,'i, "I k . ..Y M<:� '� if k'Q� fii°J'w�''f•L 'i: aY • 7 �. �.1. e , M �,�� L{•%�(i„r!' _ 'I� .. t f" i' +, t���1���.� L��,��.,tt�' ,J •�.tr' ,nX i �G. • Hb � '" ii` r, t'd"' !" .'� ��.,.prjdYA� � �a ai•.tx tih��. ��., Yi, a. '`�S4 r} �t� -;� E�r�}�,�•. �l';: 'fn ^4 AyL� `, U ,a 4 •„at,.,k •, t?r+� . F Px # '. •n+ �f ',S� b. ,f �., �t�4nfr,j! , <"'�i�" y:.(:'�' e.• .�'' J,a. ..,t:�;��,,af k1. �,,i1.,i1�� ,a v' �,.. .;. � k. ���,� �x�?ik'�"�' Y��' I r�fx �`�' Y r �i 4q; 4, ��! �t'�6�L'�L jl y+(/i ,�'i �r�,t.+� M �MSt%';�,�iX't.4�r.. �¢�'�i'.�•tr�s"�Ittc, jfM�` ;4Y �f! ,9., 1 •.�I�Y+��'•1"4c.'.:w,t `�..,;x;��7.,�ice..� ti9:<':2 4��r.t.Y ".''�� n .,��/� -�Wg• ,j, j , d :zi. � r {�..��•r� r � r S t';�" • �� � yip+ <a t S � `Y, i�T � -� , r,.�J w ;, ', Y,, ,k, � ,; '`+'t��:n,' � arty, q i!•i d,. :P. ,.N. �'o Gtr '; �I:^ \{' ��`, ., �,� { ' • : r :'�(! � h�,': *'�"' • ito- Y. v t h� f C' r. � St I r , � +,r �# � �. � d• rk , xrt R ti SI {S , � " .e A,v k �{ , ,r�}��v'(: iq • u 'ar 1 s 0. �;3 f + , a , x 1. , > ,.• :, . .•..�17".. V ^^ r,F:,h. i'Ft. ,Aa.,<,k „t', ti, k,?,,.4 i, . .. 4n ., , -....- _,, rr�!.: L.s + .i'�,.oF`�, .,, !'(W;,lj.,q 1r,'.,,`X'. :�`+r`'t,, 'J�•,la','-r « it; w'..,rcY .. r'gpp 17cr!, rL..:i1Tt •t st�.�y�. 4L �'1, W f, } �.;"': 't^..R'..tc ' drr ,�. �,7i r.. L'i,. r „sre xt �.�'t ,),M. �'� :�AL� 1 yu ,y% .z,�n'" �Nti :♦^:,fP � -ii . t�t!'R: '!K p ,.f, C • � :� .i . ',., �_r ,` ' :.' �# •'w °.,�/�� # p'i4' I'`°' � '�'.. $l�'• i , v' _: - „' a W.�: �.. ,. �, . , ,i m r= 1 r • v. tti.., {.! It } v. - .,y!�t �i�' ,'l.� c� t t+& s 1, 1 ; 1" t, a., l%V, , l.. . , !' .1 .,� 't r 7. i.. � • N_.. � f'k R s • � �� }y.f y 'M.. � �� .a• .�iax R r M`�... °. ", ,rr'pa� C ,ie v,�f , �. Alr�o- �./1..f Ci. i Lati♦ M., .�` �dt.. W:.. :w: d +td, ,r� '�. 'r, SPY, 1 ✓in 1'p 3 'i �7k'*.. ,�,,4•oa. C;,d..•,ra,' .E•'.. �,.,.:,,,... 'i�'.�'.. ':.."'..'..'f, r"�tyXa..� :. �'Pt7 :+F,a«y;i,,,'��.-t.#rq,i •,V,ii°ta?�.tyt �4i t i.,J�{'k�y4�rt" ".i�tt ,Ir ,3* ,:#t.'n &, , j,..rq,rr a,11}.,r IJ••�l�c. ,1,,, „r . tv ,ry , r ,%�" a,y it.?1!7:.f;•� r a. r5r# , ,r51tt'•ifif: d ,,,, .:RL!..ti JAS. ),� r..yk?s'•� •i�v,Y:r�;`Wyltl it �;t:w 17 •kt�.•rj C7 r7 r !:t!z'^ ty}f !i -:: Q - yy pqS: 1 9 a •yJ1'C,.t�tM+INt,i�1' iF t. .p.)*Jy la.. .:civ r.LK!?t': !��y � 4 i`rv.s. t',. "k;'}� el,' s,r.,!,x „�!. �l' ytrt tE r"�fpt.J.°91 :Soo ff i� ' t . ; ,$ hy• p+s :a,', k: '..t Y .. tr d,A it,� ii , i■� 1'} �yX .l . , ' . V , {,(.. .. ,�'h ::'A'' , ,4 F, ,( x,�. i,;Psy� 1�.. i, �'V,r •tir,' y 4'1 Td ri `k F', 1 �Y•. Y. 1��': �., c. •.A^"d� ��. pp 'lir �G'^ .p a ' � a i,�..,}•u /rr'�iii {.�' k, ii" f'�+ `9+ �' ,' clJtrir�..�ro�.'r! ,,tJ' ,�,f, 9,dgax�yt !• r,;if}kT,,'�4� "'z '.,�'M, (I'W%.�k':L tk r�:'A•' ,:,+ •, t,vf Y�.`p }:.:. i`• i'�,'.:', (y i J• _li .' N �., '. k., rr, ,;'.ti•., s•.. da ,Ni iAli,R. ! ?, is �` �,A aF t• ELtf"; t.W , f ? ?,Y, ] 1 tF as . 4;rkn ��y •z h„ Thy ll' i; ! P4'T64,r A w a Vr r rl 5X n ,:ry1 f. I ' 't t '•!...K.'�j ",t",'!+ 1' 9{['';i��qq.'��, ;,1�' lidt "'1•# fl'.1R`Y. Y. r L; _1. ui, ,;'.t: (P,rKryT'L./=,. ri �'V..r''f r: +:'4wa'': i:c h ry a• l„;4 7� f5 �" �• ' ! � t�?,�? .`�� IS� ,F . tete , �:k,w ,trkl , }�� qyr �,?i ♦ 4�'y" a:t,^ij�l�,�.. o .r•;,' L�1 �;C '�,�^�:°w .nib p•n . �+, i,� t;`., tr i . � .r, - •� ' '�''d, .� � '',«' " e' v �:i q,. �,. K ,t�` r Y �1.. , +r: �•�'.. M ti , �5 v fi r ,el ;,�': a ,• tt:. (! y kd,. ..y.. k"'�,S 81. � F �•�� 'i � a�';r :,���7. 1� i �/ r r'S CI'• 'i ,�d" ; 'Y"{: � •UY'1i dA: ,i{ L t t� i\r f A m.•^! 1 (i} :,,1',: .. r. r,t,k4'.rt.�, ?_,e,k,.t,>,. p;;^.�1,,kLk•,fr,r-s,"': � 4 �"'� t t ,�g, +5. ,�'' L'���! �,1vn� '�'t' #`��,1, d H 3'. . �,yy;-♦„'p�;. -:_ ; v.:?iY i.+� tY,. •� �al�',i `-1 1'r It y ,,; ,L�., F'.t1.'• c�!,r��kr. ,'Sx y vw'C„'u°:S':,'Mti�'7� yxt�':'.. ai:• y'�'�i {J�a}:., 'YJ(;G ,� a_•ry� w t�ti1 d:r �, .16" J. Y,.Y+�« �r ,,.t'�,t N, �fl �. '+: .�r,.C.. f, e atr+ '1 �• "�•( .i4v;�:f;1�.•o.r y..qf t;i��:' pJ ��,�x�,. .a��P�`'�:,r�tyr,�b" ; l td: ^�'�'t al fip a :�.;4.N f :lfLh` \k'\ a.Y.y•,, �.a,/ i '��, i'P.��.. i•Lr ti� �'. ,i.+.: y,. :k Y r6 't. '�'�!µ'n�l �, lr �?:%+t- '�,l`'Sp�^i'#[.a ,Y 3r ..$.` 4'+'+,}!, y�c..: L, ckf+7'v-w t, Wo t�:,r. 'FrI,: C,i :.a h' to ���� /�:rr �+�`I-SWt}+rx •��tt�?�y •. ,� �. it :�'1'A; bN', !;,'iq�,h'!1',C,\#. 'W l,r:t.�W;. y\tr'�:1, .l'. {.v. '.4,.i .;,,piSi'`. Y�da�'gri ?,R L �Jr, •K;,�t�a�� i.,I, L,.b yel f.L ' l� � jj'Ct�1 '4 riRC i e���C i 7��� + � 3� A t� Q' J i,{W ��`t'i��. 4g ,,y l�j {k , E.�:t tI '� � piy., t�i••, • r• !..: it. L •.� - f. f • ` � ��� ' ! - ti± rk 3 \ a c-., v c ,4"��, r, �;,y. ,,y�, y ..-.._ i , is�q � Ri fl'1�,r� .k rN bi:�}'{'„r �kL r``L ` + r♦1 � ,q�'�' , A J. 7x'Y`,. �Y ,?. t F d.-t,A�•fi P^ 4 al T >` .z„`;% y n' r!,ri�e} k kt �' it ld;hY' � , �', � 't`�bt u*' 'F .�t d!'i';.•3, it �"i a r 1 ,tC. i �Y, r�. `>"ra t kaT ii ' apt r�urcc1t,7(p��L,tyL�y� „ (r � �,�;,(f.,l,'� { ;,, v1�2 ,'Vr•, i �• ,yp �,ld. .'!'1 �.�"?�"�ti��' :rf �"f• i1:1 �•LM%,�t,.I�,t' 47 Et ��i i� r�IC, t�` ,(,,�i �.:. •'i'Yt'\5is�-. 'f#U' ,#, �/' . it♦ ''I r:bi('� L1N, !l..,�.', t. _ 1 'i. p P i, ri i, ,n ] r 4i . 1�� ,t `r ', ,o, i! J'ta 'i / e r ', {, 1i y 4k� S-.rt!�,'pi"1•iR r Y1a .s „• t �� t :iv ,c , � � �5:�, �`A,n iyJ;�r�`, �?t,r �+, rs. , i ;� i •i� �f; � . ..' ". sry��yy� a!#���� R;}jfa{..-,P�j.'Fiv�.,""1,�;? �iY�'�Gi � y. t �'� .A 1• `�i �a+t '`N' y `�"r, ,!L, S C, {'i!L'A4 cyla �5 ^�a+',k, �� +7��j, , y, Pr i'•'r r 1 �� d, r J` T' b; Wt:r ?la' ' r, Yy y!: . ,uv' ,t ` >N'i>z^.•'"'it i:rt't:;' it'p;.. ; , .v . '>M, .- � t0. >,� � � � "�+�' ;,�ryj 1• �,�,'� ,l �o � � i ".a;ti� 4 i .r � �,�. ¢ r"Rt ;,jY1,G �iI,M i:.�!yr .#�r.`,?►, d7A.'.+ ' r : qil?i•?{• a' ! li,a1°`�: � � xArd�it J J +�. f?' ,ri`S � � :,t k 1" ..zHl . JL ,} 3ti�� S; gltpq v� � � t� �•. r1 ! �r bx��oi� r. , r +�i; �s ,+ r� l� ,:. + l7r � �1'� �„ � : �tR,.i ,.:.'FD � ;..o'�v l3 of t -, a a;L ';'i� f Lf�t,:'t' 1 :r�'t\f�q'y`.�,�,�,. yt t•: ` '�ylt;"�rI tib* r M °'� r'k 9 ��«A;. - i+tl�ed�'' ,�i �r - r:A" jL a �j�+r�., ai ,} r .w +�' t��. q4_t; aT >, P.{�,q ,>, .t+?�• � ,1+-, }„ �,c'�ib a' {d 'T r4? rt' „,�/ �,� ? St' t �r'��1.,: + � ��ca�; ;,, P f'1 : / ", , '{,?� at . a�M *.h�1 ..,�. • I•: i; ,i1 f .�'::}-�. •��C ;�' t:: , .`ti.."�k ��t! t, �fi, C F7F.i•�•'.` rN,. .l:1" "�, . � :lii C. rr. d,. { � k'i♦! 5 , 4 " 4 '_ >t A ' •+iJ;ai ,r L.CC,. a.. . �Y "trYJ �'P .. �'!. r.:, ..,iY aY tp1. .. i ��.. h �k ,, { ��v� � ,. J•�:. tl h,� b :., l yi, i ,'i, s 1 , 'ri^.: "'r, #., �, ;f ri at„�,•,14 � • N!t:' ' .M1;tt AL', A'la,l�♦�,n :,i���. , �•1 . � „J,R .{ �.L ,rw d.., i., c-. .i . + .J 'f , .d-� . +y . w � ,,��':i� r ti; ts,� „� ���' a � ��t' ,'�i r� �� a., '',rC. „ � .. z v [ � I �• � . � "<,, � i ��• �!.a a9' . r s, ,�,+ 'zt,a 'kk t :�'>':,t , ,� i�#K w R �' yF'a : ��� , L.B• � ,C `'S , i�l! L r. : {:� � f . i '1 a � � � a A 3. �a , 1. � .i b,i• a'{�. - �n �. V'. �ti ;. i' .�.t'�f..I .. La ♦,� t� 1(i ���.�F,4 � ..�.�"„t����'�b P,��'�' �'o��a:'.��Y�l.:T.:t��:,�i`��.�i'7.A!'f:t•P ,.Cr:w`��?l.;'� '��f ��••:;nrv';w VI f 4 .�f� .' r wy ) ( d w� oWIN jt C y ! 1 1 5 1 } 11 Z� i., Y f'i ' yon x „ 9t, w n :, a� t �� a' � r �IP"1 1;� C ! t7� 1 1 I� 1 i _ t ,.�N�4 y�4 �s t 'i , l:a + 1 f �J .S ' 1 tra } j i �u,N�'. "{ � '1 t*:���i�/ -+�t 441i6'':. Kik. •.k 44- ,�. ,. �2,1, ,.. F'. A, " �•.`"6 k' i.�°w--. '1 eq:^�.ff -.Y i. . ro .Iw• .�( .�5. �j, }. i,t "t�q r1r is u1 :.;t�� 4 al„�.�.. ����11 LLyy,,��,,ttVV'''';.5 L !Q9lf :. 41 AiY4��,nV4�4�i��WU t4�n.�t�i��i.w�L.�W.1��+4 s+ ��'}: ;J9al+. �µ�. stw..lw4rw!». V1'iN�4:uw,rt�-+=+wo.M+�-,•=+AY.'x�•4Yu.a#Lf � �.I/` �r..�.e�L�:..-:4+u.:i�,�.M�,�w4"in ,t{ 7 1 ! '�4t�,I.' .'l +i 41e4MrriwM� mar w:..K+t:� �. _ i+. X I` 0 ' , i 1 y� Y li r ,ill i h e ! tyr .1 t iv, it it •a, R �f r , r ji t,. t�• Sp , i +, '� ;:11 rl! 4 .�l 'l 1'y 1 ! iii\4 p� t`• r tl. er oww �ili' 1t '14 1��4sitF?,����, :,,>e{e �.„ t {, Y �'d, 'i 1 rii �t x e„M1�: � F°,.9I ✓w . tNl '&� ,,5 =?,. � r; :.,. , ':; w,�, r , r r. tir, t C. �,+s...�:,W.::nw..+.,f„��W�w�..:..tk�:tl9l.a 1 1';.1'-tY.du....,,,.=1.u+.+:+...etaa«....wiV.`.1,.:.rw+.,.,.:,.. "iJ,l��4��'1.� il.�t:�kf�4”�'1u.rlsp�yi,:.�s'.:L�:;�i��ut��,:�it!+�ik�l�,a'..,.�.`12t�i �N•�-.c.,Ud.i�.� kr,:� .r,,.• i... ,.�.w-«•„i � G4.uc,,u t% �����' JAI _ n• 1^ 1•, .Ty , , Me Ij t, 4 7 Go PLANNING DEPARTMENT `u UNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONE! (916) 538-7601 June 19, 1991 ; , Charlotte Speegle 1071 Hurleton Road ' ` Oroville, 'CA. 95966 RE; Pre -Application Review sd Use Permit on AP# 0'72-29Q-1�4 _ I f Dear Nis. Speegle• Ibis is tonotify yoi that we have received sufficient assurances from Butte c { County Envuonxnental Health and Public Works Departments that your project'$'. can meet their re uirements This fulfills the Pre' Application review process. �„ Dur suant to the Butte County Planning Department Project Review?Procedur ce b anual".which states, Upon tentative approval of a land use permit or vana�_ _y � the Environmental Health Department and Land Development Division of thee Department of Public 'Works, the. applicant must submit a completed formal` application, including any required changes from the original submittal and thea , -balance'of the'fees within 6 months of the tentative approval." No additionQZ« Work,'shdit be perforrried on this project until we have received the, remainder o£ the application fee in the amicunt of $780.00' and, if any, required changes from 1 the original submittal: Please submat the fee along with any required changes from the original submittal � to: the Butte County Planning Department no 'Tater than 'December° 19, 1991 and your application will become void and in order to continue the project, you will i { be required to re- apply. Please make all checks payable to the Butte County I Treasurer. I I ,y `*w wq M „ r :jq, v n ' s J, ' r YI t (,r ty V ,,r V " r 1 Fs t . t .�.. r � 4 7" I °; ! F f •. ! °I I (. � r I,;P � , Ya ,91 1'�� I 9 '7� t, n. N `�' t , 11`�4 I �. >< .. �"N1 i!�V,. °� !. i �, 4 y �,r � � 9�, 1 ,: l'• � I,.I,' �.,. t t t:''. i ,!} '` 4 i � Y , t ^,+, it � �1', t Ole .,l•.yr M �:-+r r L :':j � ,;.;'-tv y.A'q'.'b I�.v��+;:� .,,i, 'I.„ 4 ,�,�f:7 P .0 ',..% r t ,,..r :�•� a1 ...� ,'.:+, i,. ';, p, y ;'w -.,}'e. , a.. ,. { ,r.. k4 {P ,x{;M.w ;. ''l,r. t,.Y } E� ., 1>� y,,.,,`�i•. 1 , q.. ,t{;, ', %�.:..e-x.1:.0 wdF.+.x.Uk .• ..IS , ta���`�l� �i�.';.;:u,..n�xlv:,wx:ikE '{`�u9�1!f�t�wCtr��hl 4:�vi}Jt�.';,is11E�.fin'��'nv.�,9 �r�x.'+'..,��:i:s.�1�.,•..�t., 6�ra.rh:'.i,�cdatP<43o,.;.,:b*..d4.,—�•t � ~v , June 19, 1991 Speegle Page 2, k Enclosed is a Meld marker for identification of the project. Please secure the c ribbon in a conspicuous place on the site, preferably visible from the roadway.,'♦ If you have any questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact this office any weekday between the hours of 10:00 a.nL and ,3;00 P.M. } Sincerely, I f B.A. KIRCHER Director of Planning Larry Painter Planning Technician BAK:LP jlo Enclosure y , 9 r ; • �P. � w • A ;1 , H 'Rr4 ' th.1 t< az',a ,u n_n. 9r .4lt wt rt x`n ,r � >kr 11t13`iyl°a"yi9 Q$+a %t1"P. Jl u a y pjN,� 55 f 1'i a ..., � � 1 14, 1} I ti�'fr i , 7 �� .� � t 1 � •,. a � ti (`Z�'"+ r�s a / i 1 � ��', 1^ a,t i �j l'�aJ 4+ w .: t} � �t-" k w t VA ` � �ti „4� 4. t . a 10 1 Il,. , C {� - +4. r \ .. w �u �• 7 '�` r 1 r ! t � ti� i} ' a rte✓ v � 1 ''7' � 6 tr .4 i a �` r n4 I � .l, . r r a 1 .:1 ! � Yx, y�.r Ya. ..f :� � � "f §w. � i r 3. •'f t + lr ''.ee is Ji• 1"a 1' ;i + r y._;. •.. a. 1 }�.:i�l J ��4 ..4. . .Y.,.... r� jx''Y .. � ii la•6, ?U"'o `.-"-}rmr J, r„„7 �tl yrf .,�,,v {.,�ila. r}l�ytl4 p, t. i,. �' S ��,. ,N y (y,• yyy'+,,,y:ry1.>. y..:�a y'. J..,;,lgS has i,.r5clitrrt,.(4..,. i..,t4�rt. '91•:.•u,.,r.lx,,,,c. r 31 )r.., .- .. u a,w w Hi .��. V.A`3'E�ruh�.�`...,r.7wj1m�+a:'4�:a`y�.,�:.rA,':w�.M`.�;uT.rka%�il»als:,«..�,Y'�•w.:�xt.,xt..•_$•435,�.,�.wtw,".�.w....Lak�'v..eJ:w,;;,. ,I LAW OFFICES OF �{ AROSTE a'M COOKS, EPLEY & GENGLER� f3`0'CIVI0 CENTER BLVD, SUITE G PHILLIPa C00� P.O. BOX 3067 ALBERT L AROSTEGUI �1 i O NIA 95992 ROSERTC. EPLEY YUBA CITY, CALIF R TELEPHONB(4M 071.1100 MAILINOADORESSE ROBERTM. GENGL_R PIC. BOX 3067 G. STEVEN JONES YUBA CITY, CALIFORNIA 0922 `ti) TERRY L FLORiAtJ FAX (910) 1871.1401 ;t s FRANCES LrHANCOCK F. March 17 i, 199244 }Grr v 7` Ms Lisa Purvis-WilsonI ` PlanninPlannxn Dechnican g Department: VW Butte Count OrCountY e,CCAter Drive 95965 3`39"1 Re: Use Permit to Allow Kennel -- Remaining Fees Due $780.00 y Dear"Ms Purvis-Wilson: p . 00 re st's ur.; �A setter ` Enclosed please final the $78 Qu hexa��..� i of February 21, 1992: Please proceed to process the Use Permit Application advise this office if at all pOssible with 48 hours or more i`n notice when you 'would like to inspect the area proposed as a � kennel. .0 will then contact my client and get back to you as to an I� agreeable time. it is best if you Can suggest several different # dates. Thank you for your cooperation.' I Very truly yaurs w QSTE 3'll`) coo p AR & GENGLER PHILLI � ' COOKS, A. � f PAC : I's in !C. Enclosure cc's Ms. Charlotte 8!0eegle 1071 Hurleton Road Oroville; CA x .t;r.,f< ly V it � „ r•+ ,4.' - I t,D, r� �� ar p } � A t t a /F � w �k. y, a w t . • . , tJ d I 4 e � , a ^ r P X111 , e I , e „'., � r-. 1 g. 1 ... a .. ....y., , .., • ,� , ,...., , OFFICIAL 121=GEI1"T „a�+ COUNTY OF BUTTE I STAifl' OF :CALIFORNIA - OFFICE OF PLANNING OA I n tOTAL. i r.AKCO i1o6 VAP IA NIC ER VUnLIC z NINO BNV OT/Ikp APPLIC ADI'T P. . r d _ So CALTli d 64 r , a, .rr+, r, .« r •.. A@'.r .. „j�i,r. .. »♦. , �� �� ry •r,,,. �.t.:.:•u.:...,r+a•�:..,u ..,.a;.r.-.mr�,a,..a...:-r-'. s.....r:. -�.._ r I r ,�'ih. ., !� GIII .s 0 ` ' 9 Z Ot7 .i8 �(70't t .i i alb, 1,9 Q 0 0 ill 'a 1. t , r Y LZ00 4�Q9�IIWRn1V1 ' rr 41tib YapelUv j0 w ar I I I I , , «------_i.-----OUT Ou pue q Ta :e'--ptinu ua�ag t r, 00l08L _ �0 �J3a!!O t . . i • 311101 AW , otu5e 1► ` ' 'w `'s ' ' 4 ` aoeea v� ''Uh ven,, i „ , J I' Y I ,.. . F�. �I r ,. MVI 1b §A:HH9o11.v ,;4 41 „ . , , ., .'. , •' .' : I ' ' 1. .. '.. .awe:.uxtili+v u5i �.7 "`�, x.... ,, '. 1 ° w ,e,bl:4ulvw.uu Fssx'.w:lwsd.,_ ...e,�...... ., .....,_: w» a _ 47 I. `kiW:lYl]ibu>%W4NYW Rw.Fb3 YAtr�._._rYr.,w -___=ur»+s...,,i...r:.+:•+,r:r,�r2unout�`rt'^r ...° Abdo 'If1mispHy ..aWf'r�'^�'Y'V•M:.N44ti:M1rl1#,i�•«Yii+rYeK+U.x4.>i=+•I All y , r e • d I 4 e � , a ^ r P X111 , e I riticElpt x.2788 IAy , OFFICIAL 121=GEI1"T „a�+ COUNTY OF BUTTE N.. }. is STAifl' OF :CALIFORNIA OFFICE OF PLANNING OA I n tOTAL. pURt:•3 r.AKCO i1o6 VAP IA NIC ER VUnLIC z NINO BNV OT/Ikp APPLIC ADI'T RrCEI,V:ED FROM . tlOy _ft Et:,/ IV60 WO CALTli d I 4 e � , a ^ r P X111 , e I riticElpt x.2788 IAy , OFFICIAL 121=GEI1"T „a�+ COUNTY OF BUTTE N.. }. is STAifl' OF :CALIFORNIA OFFICE OF PLANNING n _ y r I ; ,i 9w issUE Y d a, .rr+, r, .« r •.. A@'.r .. „j�i,r. .. »♦. , �� �� ry •r,,,. �.t.:.:•u.:...,r+a•�:..,u ..,.a;.r.-.mr�,a,..a...:-r-'. s.....r:. -�.._ r I r ,�'ih. ., !� GIII .s 0 ` ' 9 Z Ot7 .i8 �(70't t .i i alb, 1,9 Q 0 0 ill lion1: a , r Y LZ00 4�Q9�IIWRn1V1 ' rr 41tib YapelUv j0 w I I I I , , «------_i.-----OUT Ou pue q Ta :e'--ptinu ua�ag r, 00l08L _ �0 �J3a!!O I ! . . i • 311101 AW otu5e 1► ` ' 'w `'s ' ' 4 ` aoeea v� ''Uh ven,, ; AOId 1.gOS X ,.. " .y' • yry :liNnoboV J.9nl11•,.�^ r ,. MVI 1b §A:HH9o11.v ,;4 41 „ . Abdo 'If1mispHy All y , r e • , . : ' h r _ � i. I ` , :. „� 7'` , ,� .., { 4 c . r -. , : •,t is t 1N A i\i f5i1N �cl Aii`ii t434rr�rltl� '• Y 76f.-I4'S aiY°l�ii.:1�L1�� � { M•4 of„A11v N.i Ii FYi314{f ifi141� ` , ,. U.° y F .� . ,1 •R[T LLr k d 71 ,,. j'.i ♦r� 11 AA P., , , '. r : : ,.. '_:. :_, ,. M,.'t , 1, if n'r,V Yfl.,• N�k,.:'M �Y.% Aw.t. F., . A:,: ;.-, a :. ',.:.� ,_.: ' �,• _ >:.. or A+r, _{A 1 n , yr I :7 � r v) r n r 1 �1 d t � 1 f } r 71 - f .r r A � `163 1+50 Mail Rede .a - - r �j Certif►e No InswaOde Qovetago Provided , Do not use 16f International Meil l r (See peverse) i A�y143A1N1G t� soot toott a SPeegle �� sltoet a Noe 071, �Ilurleton rd. I'' p0„ slate 3 zip Godo Oroville, CA 95965 postage carttngd Foe 8oelal Dotivefy Feed-� 1 Ansfe lidd t)tltVoty Fee FleWth at, lot 9howing . o� to Wham & pots tlollvored A lot- tleadlpt Showing to Whomr pato, Addross 61 Do' 1 votY, - 7 WAt, POWs, � .., # 6 Fees00 t oslmatk et oetb C9 ' " , r :, ,, rr ,,t ., ,. • +-�r r .. u. . r . c,i,g„t, � "1 � 4, r r . t. , ri>, n �,.,''�� < ".r ' ;w.4 k � e TM4 ..I �.�. �p:•� ; s. � o �, _ ry i rip. �p y r� a Y r r : - . r .`, r..;� lr�" -. . 6 r b YS �. `, ,.., . `. r�: r; ,� a S," 'Pi'.`I ul,�t1 ` �V �°� ^ " tr{f ,'kr ti ! i t h4�i,'"! � ,, r), � �. •: .� ,k. .r.,. •?.�.. .G r. 1.. t?F+',>t.. ',..r rf 1rr.:,r..:d "+�l „}P a: i ,"kn }r,rti" k^;? f ,,:°} r i,^.7^,.! "'_,���'" l ,�uiy, ,.,,i ' ,.,i..;u,...J�..k+l,.r~r:...�,..r�:.,,, �j. ' •i �4 ¢?i �a "�9'}I� iT'eh4 +C,ik'g¢C�1 ����bk:�j.1�1'yr��# rr.4°�it�^��Filf �.f��;,1�.,gr .,%.r.a�,a!i��i�4iiva�;ri.��t�4ici.Str,1��t3�„Ak.Ji..,.aw�._.«aw'6..,a1._a.�..w3r.:,1�a5:..u....t.hk..:..,.�..,Sr.iw.�:..c k&t..w. +i:r:u...iuA�,....��.-c..•t �S' f� d N' 3A'i k` `- hPnarfnent of Developpment Services 'PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 TELEPHONE: (916) 538-7601 September 16, 1992 , Charlotte Speegle Road 1071 Hurleton , Oroville, CA 95966 e CERTIFIED l RE: 1-EnvironrrieZtdl Review for Use Permit application on 1* P# 072-290-154 r i, Dear Ms. Speegle: ` 1, It has been more than three months since this department notified you that your project has the :potential to have significant effects on the �en�ironment. You have failed to agree to our recommended mitigation measures xnor have you suggested any alternative t mitigation measures. As there exists the potential for significant environmental impacts from your project, art Environmental Impact Report will be required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act and the, Butte County Environmental Review ; need to address A of the potential environmental effects of ; Guidelinzs. The EIi7. will , project listed on Attachment A appended to this letter as well as those issues i the ro ect li required to be addressed by all applicable state and local laws and guidelines. r y y y... g If you Wish to appeal the requirement for an EIR; ou: ma do sob submitting to the ► y° Department of Development Servicespl5nnin in the reasons why an ETR should, date g Division, Within 15 day � of this letters a written notice of protestp fy _g y not be required and the required appeal fee of $502.50. If no written protest is timely filed, an EIR will be required. If you choose not to appeal, the preparation of the MR may be �utiated by tiling the , following With the Planning Departments One Authorization and Agreement Form for the Preparation o#' Environmental 1, impact Reports dated and signed by alb owners of record 'or their agents (cop's enclosed) c 2, Your selection, in writing on Attachment B, of five (5) consultants from the j County, approved consultant list to Whom Request for Prorosals (RFPs) shall be .sent' copy of the County -approved consultant list aswell as Attachment $ on z; htclt said selections are to be indicated are enclosed with this letter), 5 {r rr.� r r , b.CN +Y rrHR�+��'v ♦� M •x M sxlq, ,had. r i k J ,* a r a F ,'k Swr.,'� " drt x r �'^,I ja r ' tr ' >:"1 a�'. raU} ,':� r F .sxri,�'1 al � �i � H�s � i'�7 F��%;'� +n I �I,' ,r' r , i�l lr r. 4 t:,, a °< <a•�i tt ['.:tt t a;w r! td r kL 40"1 ° r :,:ri xa,s•5a j(..44a's''' �.wr3b rr1;.♦ r,�(. ' d �,,,+�\ter' ,`'',i' a d,�'. 1 ra I ;f ,` h�C l4{r ix.! •r.) w�. b .r _,wtl i k r# r at It. sk i;"'+i G k ...h�i '�d)1 a r ' .(>':'t L{. Oji rct�fo7,r 1 'f: y j:� R 1 l i v J i j' �' 1§ b `� a 1 i d kl as " r :° , 1 v r�.. ka,e� t t r�,r , rl {i J '^(4.. t t( 1� a ' `.; ! 1'..ti"r, Fp '^j i = iE� 1 1 '�1 : { f (t � rY :•'D ''1t .1�+ ay 5 `t 1 `✓G�, w ,1F ( �'rx t 1 j;. , r �.v ltx r x}`r I �-' w a,,..l �i{7. F#,r r':.� If1 SSS.�y^ S ,, I t_ i �w,t^; �fA�. �, I y t ��t t 4 `� r., y�. '�Sr� "a j.l a a .{•� xr 1 aF4 ,, a� !. ;4� �1 �°tY li � 1 .!>r,4` x Id, 7 t,. ill iy x �(s�• j rr' a � ':_tt 4 Spy"n4. Eca -a.. ..y 4 ,"'a.. ,,,,.1 `� L`t, er r v t A^r / ��! .a�ilS} �;°.,,e j�11 �. - " a :#E r:v. j d�, �� r_' F r .r ,% r ,rtj ;� rY i, 1 '� kt 1 ig 1vi § ` �. ^}+?ri � `��M ah r k➢�I �, it (p�y h#�, ,i..:+..dasr_! �r t ,"'�.�..uy;.,,,,,-....,nari:..lr6...a.diu'� � j. ' , ,+� �a t ;��r�L��l �jG�li;gt�a�.:�� 1�t Y�°°S�r, � t0 ' i?; 7�,�i( ��ax�..��cv���hutj. �+v��"�}�i�C��tC,:wii�:-.r?• (.aG=+'i.4��3�p6�kY..t.,naLL. .�.�iril'.a� �' ""t!'"a y. { 3, A Request for proposal and Contract l.dzr,.�isk,21 io'n Fee of 11 1. 1' 1 4�r r°t it it 61 y $22.50 4. An EHL administration fee of Upon recei t ai the above, the Planning Division i,* ll' preparA and mal yin RFP'to 'the' p 3i^ five consultant' shown on Attachment B. The �x sammng Department will review all to the ,RkP, `choose a consultant; and n'r�tify you of the firm selected. Upon g , x ^ with the environmental consultant shall`: receipt of a letter from you indicating concurrenh f the Planiung Department selected, .and funds. sufficient 'to cover the, consult;nlr' fed; ct with the selected consultant } t' executE a contra of the County's EM Consultant and ContractingProcedures is enclosed for ! A full copy g y tyourself with y t in its entire to familiarize our use. We strongly encoura a ou to read i the process nd teh costs involved. P, ill be set for tli i It not receive.a response to this letter w�tlillS days, the project w � ES s g hear n s before the Bo .of �..�u erlYsors for :dezu�r +1 If you do not wi sh to continue with the project; nl'66.o notify this office at your earliest c convenience so that the file can be closed. many Aday I If you have airy` questions regarding this atter, p�V,ase .contact this officer } between 10;00 a.m. and 3:00 P.M. Sincerely, b Craig Sailers y A i� g r ate Planner l q,; i t 1'V 1 �f+hi.. C yrllr 1➢ 1. l 1 •1 . 1 1 ., a 1; r t Y ..d h Y,:1 I il k 1..• t hn-...A Y 41, :. i �. :yt � 7' 1-{ } ,' tl \ I C D Nf.1 1 ." q n „ '„ ,1 ''rl r i r ,1r,1 1• r'> .,,, r�. b 'k Y •, ' .Alvi V .0 ..Ir d .'r1 a`,i YP'.�,YC ` ".IF�f." J`1�, "1'ttl4 , Pi. Att.1r:1't >• V k i a T L�, i fir'},.; i., lv� ° } Y..'., � � 1 I. l yr tgi 4Y� -,'. k i t ..:'.•� n rf, r'1 _ ..; ,:,-' rt . ,..t,. ,'ya +^ 1. 1`` t5�e { :s+4r.• v� 6 ., .Sr.. ,1,{ rl 1 Y Z. _,.r,t4"-. w,. 4 +•.,1, a-.--a>•ar"Iaa . 6, Z tti i. sart •1- 1�:1. h i .X, ;• P ,t.(..,. rl, . +.... t.t...r�..•:...wr....��,,,.'1 , �� C s "er ��:�'3 ' fie* O;P�'"6 1 1 , a P �, .. r .Y..,:�,U*+:;.-..1 (r<s.:.•.ue....•--,Nu to?a illi : M� 1.u;:t.1.,>,.w,d,,:b.tw»#i..�s:-,a1--, {•' ,? ICA 5�12t.�i r s i� eyl'S1i i51i i s. P1 u. ppY� EN MONNIENTAL IMPACT REPORT CONSULTANT SELECTION ANS CONTRAC TING PROCEDURES 1. The County may 'retain consultants in the preparztion ` and evaluation of � Environmental Ympact Reports (EMs). If a consultant is retained, all costs incurred 1 . P p the applicant for for administration and re aration of the ETR shall be borne by , the project. • g f qualified environmental impact 2, The Planni L)epartment shall establish a list o • P established list will also indicate the firm's particular fieldt report consultants. The est of expertise. - Environmental Impact Repo�I consultants wishing to be placed on the shall slist submit a resume in icating the firm's principal personnel, wo. k expel ience, ; atement of qualifications,' as eas of expertise, and any othc . , information deemed necessary by f the Planning. Department. Selection to the list will be based on experience, e.c ert'tse to ensure hi h-quality, m-de -depth and and YP g p t t. knowledge of the County, available g compeehensive environ�nentah;innpact 'reports. Consultants with a possible conflict of interest with a project, directly or indirectly, ' zitant for the project. shall not be conside 1 old as cons 3, Following the determination the t an MR will be required for a p� , j ct, a letter shall he sent to the applicant stating. that, a consultant must be retained to prepare the 4 , EIR. The letter will also inform the applicant of the issues that will need to be addressed in the EIR, appeal procedures, and a "' eneralized description of the g • a consultant selection process A: list of County-approved consultants, an Authorization and Agreement Form for the Preparation of Elks and any other pertinent p � 1 information will also be attached. . # • . y . g the following with 4. The a `plicae t may initiate the preparation' of the EIR b Ellin tl ri y the Planning Department. ' One Authorization and Agreement Form' frit ,the Preparation of a. vironmental.Im act Reports dated and signed by all owners of record or En P their agent(s); b. Applicant`s selection]y in Writing, of five (5) consultants from the County- consultant list to whom Requests for Proposals sha11 be sent; j approved A Request for Proposal and Contract Administration Fee of $1100. c+ This fee cove-1,planning Department costs, including preparation of the Notice of preparation; up through submittal of the, Draft ETR by the consulta'n and acceptnce of the document by the Planning bep'artment. �a J A V ^�, r. r 1 ♦ r r } k.., 1 i tF 9. •.+ 1;`, 1 fyt� d !1 fii �C y h n Y. y;u y Y. ' b.(.i li yn ti r ! �.' tb {; .. ,. ,', '. 5t '{ 1 r ��A. ,r '':h {. �ty 4 t,cf 7. �} ;f 1 f - . f� '' �iL t:>++.i.b.....J..n«....-.i..w:....n...r,.,�.d.rl ri%.e.. �.•wwAM'=m..d 1 t �1 ,»N's�9.: _w..aWl°+ikfk}.tY:bt+�!4A�dHi'rtAlll�iz ''+tea' tfy i d. An EIR administration fee of $225. M h This fee: is estimated and covers the costs incurred by the County for processing the EIR. Upon completion. of the revicew process, and P Y r to the fication of the final EIR, th app pay an costs in certi.. e'� licant must a the County � excess of the estimate. The County shall refund to the applicant any surplus f p County shall not certify the final EIR. and act on the project' de osit. The until the applicant has paid the County any costs in excess of the estimate: At such time as the costs are greater than the estimate, the applicant shall pay ? the additional amount exceeding $200.00 within 10 days of notice by the Environmental Review Coordinator by registered mail. In the event that payment is not received for the additional amount in excess ,of $200.00, the Environmental Review Coordinator will immediately cease processing the EIR and notify the collection agency. All required fees may be submitted on one check. Upon receipt of the above, the • g P snail it to the Planning ` Department shall prepare the Re uest for Proposal and �- P p qY , ` selected -_consultants and the project applicant. 5. Bid will be submitted to the Planning Department by the date specified P . proposals P in the Request for Proposal. The ubmtted proposals shall at it minimum agree with the scope of services and proposal specifications as outlined in the Request for r proposal, and shall be valid for a definite period of time. Incomplete proposals may t ! be rejected. The Planning Department shah review and evaluate the scu e, content and to determine thebidwhich best ^i leteness" of the bid proposals in order coo. p the ability and qualified staff to provide the services required. The t demonstrates • selected consultant. Planning Department ma hold interviews with an or all of the y y ` _ and quality ;oc to help in arriving at a decision: The scope, content, completeness will be of equal importance with cost cProvided s eie }i , contained in a letter to the a 11carit 6: The Planning P a : • shall } 1 receipt of a letter from the d cat nm the date f exp ra t n of the proposal Up ,f applicant indicating concurrence with the environmental consultant selected, and fonds sufficient to cover the corisulta. 6 fee; the Planning Department shall execute the contract: ' 7 If less than two of the selected consultants submit a bid, or if, following a discussion Planning Deparfinent that exceptional witlt the applicant; it is w',Id judgement of the ry rcumstando exist that. would pr the use of the selected 4 ; dr e+ctraordina �ieclude •' consultant, the Planning Department shall, at the request of the applicant marl out up to three additional Request for Proposals. Pi7or to the Manning Department sending the additional Requests for Proposals; the applicant shall pay an additional fee of $l50 to Cover, administrative costs 'associated with the distribution of the Request for Proposals and review and evaluation of the responsive bid proposals, 8.If the project is substantially revised dieing the term of the EIR contract, the incurred in applicant shall pay a $185 project revision fee to cover the costs ` : tions, and of the ro- used s ecifica P bution of re uests-f P p redistri q+ ' y : addittonal contort with r g� ession .. -es assleea enc 1 - A ab r„ti ^.; t: .. °.... r h'J"'''� 9 yi! '"�44YN.,"..1 "`.xw}. y'• a 11 ,. I x r i 1 1 i A � Y 4 1' `r i 'also Wish to reaeivr�' " (for sn sl'r SENDER' ibliowIng 00tvices NDERte item6` .1 endidt 2 for Sd feel: and, e & b, dhibl�eva ser oif this %otrn 1 . Clime scan nonle d' On j Addrasseb's Address est . print ydur name and dd to cut, andhit that W the front , the this fbrm to t fiY allpiecgc or b7~ tha , 2F Q Restricted pollvet)l " " . Attach ermlt� bask if ,epaae does nr�" Rscbl 't Requested" q leen next'td or "th d mallp Consult ostmsster..fbr ' W'rlta Return thycla number fib+ . 4a," Aet'c�lON mber P Z 9 16�, 3, Article4Addrbsded gee Chairlo i;e p 4b. Uervito 1�pa Ihsurod Reglsts i�7I , $,.r iet 6ii _ltd CA 95966 l COD Cortifidd N6turn "pecaipE icer OY�oV e) moss l�hel��eYaha dlss y 7�—"�-a a Sii l;ollvorY lor,ly it rdraunstod �, {A dtes edl Addrbssee s Adittess d fed it paid) a Sienetute S. Slt'Apdntl IG Rp.TURN REC SST. p5 Fbtm 3� 1 � Oath'+ �u,s, ttgR: i�Ae�-arsnut D(�NI�ES� P, 1 4. 11 'A �r4 It, N II �.J -. lu t�oun L A, PLANNING DEPOTMENT 7 OOUNTY 6�NTER DRIVE - 0. OVILLEr CALIFORNIA A 95966.3397 TE LEPHO-NEI (916) 538-7601 Charlotte Speelle 1011 Hurletoft Road OtOvillet CA '98966 if 'Dear Ms. Speeqjej On may"10,, 1592 the, Butte County Planning' Department mailbd you, if Initial Study for environmental impacts regatdin your (�),,a,copy Or an a' Use Permit application. The letter that accompanied the Initial within this requested a response from you wi, in 15 days. As :of Study' equ date no response has been received by this department. if We do not hear from you b Enviromndnta]L 'Impact report j. 'y July 6, 1992 an -10 -Please may be required b6foite you, can proceed with your pro]-ct. contact this,d6partment as soon as possible. in-perely, Craig anders Associate Planner ifl tt 77 y, ++�'},��,�t v 1 ,",',14:��ait1a45iL`:�a+:�G..��i.+t".�. ` tt�:,��1i��kiti:.+i•,�..t,.,.Y1.S.7..4.:,� i � 1[iii!_r..._wL•>v4�t:�:3+;•,:u..`.'.•'t4.u.,.a�tilcw;.L1..u.��:tL,,..;..w««'..:.:_x..L:�;:w...u...y,aa,....,+.• wn:;:. 16 4.' , LAW OFFICES OF k. AROSTEGUI COOKS, EPLEY & GENGLER 1130 CIVIC CENTER BLVD, SUITE G ,s P.O. BOX 3067 ALBERTJ, AR aS ti+; ROBET COOKY YUBA yELtPN'ONE(918)O671J1 IA 95992' MAILING ADDRESS: ROBERTC. EpLEY R ROBERT M. GENGLER P,O, BOX 3007 tiV d, STEVEN JONES YUBA CITY, CALIFORNIAGS992 TERRY L. FLORIAN FAX (818) 871.7A81� FRANCESLtHANCOCK , March 17, 1992 Ini yz Ms. Lisa;burvis-Wilson Planning Technician Planning Department Butte County 7 County Center Drive ',Nroville CA 95965-3397 Re: Use Permit to Allow Kennel:. --`Remaining Fees Due $780.00 Dear Ms. Purvis-W;lson Enclosed please find the $180.00 requested under your letter ;of F'ebrua'ry 21.1 1992. ' Please prodoed to process the Use Permit Application and ffice advise this oif at all possible with 48 hours or more in notice when you would like to inspect the area proposed as a kennel. r Will then contlact my client and get back to you as to an agreeable time. It is best if you can suggest several different you for our Y Y peration. - - '.dates. Thank coo Very 'truly yours, h , P & GENG.L �: v' �RQST coo ) " +I, PHILLZ A COOKS i PAG 'jsm .� Enclosure cc : Msii -`Charl6tte Speegle ' 1071 Hurletoiv Road Oro i1.le, CA. r i `"►}II sw 7777777 ��y icw sdte.adr'iAw.,,:nL.>ww.nl...'.',.»...,.�?v�iva+wrd'v�i:aertn+tr,:.usairw4.�•1'>v~:zi•:F!,9.,dt7� :.idr. n'Ski;"t..'.`'vii+Yt'.k':SE:i.C':.).t;��`Biu.:1,�:1i'.,k'a.{:'air.�;rae:,M:.rw:.oa-.„'��w3ti:uaap,rcxM�;lavv�t,+�.;aJu.•'.ma.�a+s3bua,c--..—_ .,.„m,u,.vxa, ^' a FEB �2 1992 s (1 777 1, CHARLOTTE SPEEGLE declareR"thaifllcuttemtl tooestablish a f i` kennel in the County I Y t, kennel in the Count of `'Tehama that I will complyp with the T�;hama • y County rules and ,regulations which are attached, or such other ' regulations as are amended frc 'd gime ` to time in the future at such e such appJ,l.ic��.ion.t time as T would- 'mak y } itis my current intention to apply for a Use Permit and Kennel License in 'the County of Butte. Such application fox° Kennel License and Use Permit is pending. The: -County of Butte has not indicated to me when they will act on such application. {' yrom 'I will attempt to complete those applications in a reasonably I will 'fashion, although it may take more than 30 days for tie to do ' current .financial situation. ''L , P g Y b , that under my I agree to complete my applications for Kennel Licenses with the County cE Butte on 'or before: April 30; 19-92. Upon completion of the application for use permit and Kennel Licenszs «nd the issuance by the. County, of Butte of such permits, 2 will notify the Tehama Count District Attorney -s Office. After the Butte County's Y applications are granted, I agree to allow a,nspections of my kennels upon 24-hour notice at any time after the Butte County licenses are in place and prior to May 31., 1992. DATED: �'anuary 22r,1592 �%•r� ,' i r' Gl >,,, �1, �' ,.; �.' � SPEEGLE� TE t CHARLOT ' Attachment 4l r l� r� $cnlc h(34 Pad ROUTING — REQUESTbimiign r LJ MEAD To [--(A ” ] ei v •, Co HANIJLE hS-�he_ C❑ AP0ROVE G:'�5' a Our 1 i.t t"Cs and ” ` wfm j ti r . (� V #ORWARD 1. s ok Id1 AlrrlipN l'nrirr Ir; KEEP OR ISIVARa t��Tj,1J P t? k4,, A0 0 ROIEW WITH MC s - i pale .. From . r ��i , '�Y -4 '4`w N i wyP,nu Ik d wF�'A ihv 1 "+r "� C+ r'Fruii `"�'4'k'91�e4� •qac. '"r"- 4 �i 4- � �f � Ie+P. / w " a���' "� l'r: "' I+ c '��4,�r „g d'�; a s v. ��' rx i a• b +' ry o 1 a+. '� ,� ° .�. ;+' "� i 4 r r I � ¢ err I S•� ,� •i i. � ,..} kr Y t �i'�"�'i I �t ��. e." I ., S nr%1r¢I.,.xi�+w�.�nuar�•e�.l,:...._.....«.`�ij .:», .a.G; �v<p,uw» .. �.�a.a-..e..,�..+.aawm� �"Yaar.Y-.�+�'�+�+IFA�xklti'uPtRIk+SYwi..1.�.'.++�+t•Ws ^4.#vuea++����F�� �_ X, . � j%�.�� 1 ,.,`•. pY3;:115.'..�. 1•ut-V�`I.Vjtil.Ti.{'d'k.`�11U�1�.'YJ�SlL4b�44bM1e W.1:3LY1tiP+A��i�' �` � ! C11 . T11 LAW OFFICES OF L. AROSTEGUI, COOKE, EPLEY & GENGLER i 130: CIVIC CENTER_ BLVD; •SUITE G P.O. BOX3067 ALBERTJ, AROSTEGUI PHILLIPA. COOKpS YUBA CITY, CALIFORNIA 95992 MAILING rADDRESS: ROk1ERTC. EPLEY TELEPHONE(916) 071.1100 ROBERTM. GENGLER PO. BOX 3007 }, %• G..STEVEN JONES YUBA CITY, CALIFORNIA Bb992 _ FAX (910) 671.1461 f t i TERRY LFLORIAN FRANCES L NANCOCK I� March 17 1992 Ms. Lis' a Purvis -Wilson Planning Technician +(� planning Department =, Butte County rl 1 County Center Drive , Orovillr✓, CA 95°65. 3397 ?. ° � Kennel Remaining Fees Due $780.00 Permit to Altou ; Rd: Use Dear Nis. Purvis-Wilsons r find, the $780.00 requested under your letter kI Enclosed please, x of February 21, 1992. the Use Permit Application and u rocr:ss + Please` proceed to p ore in if at all possible with 48 hours or m advise this office like to in"sped the area proposed as a notice when you would kennel I will then contact MYclient and get back to you as to an slggest several different ; y You can, agreeable time. It is b y daes. Thant you for your cooperation. t Very truly yours, } STE cob, & GENGLER O r �( PATI A COOKS .� ACijsm Enclosure E FIs, Charlotte Speegle G cec 107 ; Hurleton 1�oad oroville, I, i ,. 41 � 2 A7 ifs .N t+�A F � Vb fltr nr ., .r �„-f.. 5 #'1 •�. n '.R t ik !YM F , , , : a " ,! r , S 1J , a P. 1' ,v x t . ' I I , , : + j - „ , , � i ... w..,>—� _.� .. .,.,a•.�..�k+,yJuMyyy�,y..-VitC1�.StsltdCfit+k3i�41:idb.5i::},i�X�i ��.'. , a .1,a...pr},A.r(4.Y:a.W+M>�.Mk'vaeMu,.J`.•di-iluad+v,lW s,+M=;a+_I4,+.�'.".x.s 1 ,. - ���, •,r.. X • ,..,. ,. e+ , 1 .I •1 :,... .1 w,. ,. \.,,, r. , M w ,. PI, , •. a N' 00 a �, - r , -7i Ltl e- C.of v' N �u`S '� LCrC 1. yi, " GATE RBCEIPT 'TOYAL. PUBLIC' LAFCO - 'U OIt V/1BIANC E$ PUtl1.iC tlOCUiA ENTS YONINtl ENtr HEA LTri OTHER APPLICANT RECEiV ED FROM ya 1! No. :rIR.CRIvan WORRB p6RMiT6 RECEIPT 127:88 OFFICIAL RECEIPT' COUNTY OF BUTTE STATF OF CALIFORNIA OFFICE OF PLANNING d r r 1 . ANMO'M,?/XiNXk''K. ,yl�ft,a •N, ,f.�,ti., H., s^t, • ♦Wi M'_.,» ... .. wi.u,..i:. ,. _ .♦��"_ aM'.'°b+1,'rr—Ri . :1+1110 4000a ax �o • +' r`w' �� t ,yi4r ,+ � _ �09981MJigl `I' ell tt n in�iii110�d�111r�01�prQ w. _. _. 5 b `1 `I o a . OT Oup u T;a 1E�I14 UGAGSAjunco 1 jL0 Jo biouc)G4-4nq 00 � ,N ;F57V 1j.L ., d t 4r ♦A3 i 1 . ,. v —6 k. t , $1upW N •,".. ; .. ZM68V518 .s, JzFq; ,r 6Y '. 1 r.t..,n �.,a7-0:�'�1a_ 1'I• tti A '1F.»,M,'... 1.. '✓4 I]tIt..y4 "+N'a�s�''Y,i,„ �,µ^;A:p>.«,,Hx Ht "fr1 idC � j9Y0 u�OA. ,ct r'pYaw 1.�r •*t,,a ,�,,�,tt,,xAt„. .. ” PN' .�` �1r� di I: A°rt"`r. ♦�ha[x` Hn^^o isnu� W'�. 1. aF .v r A�N • ,h t�t 1`.ti,w Nt1N0oO e,4iynW�„ 1.yV IT �.' 1. �X„•K . a• New +rahh ir - p .�, . IlAU'” ..,�_�'�k�3q +N1 ••, • a37owan �s i _. - - Aboo Inonsow I • � .. . ' , � is ' F ! i 1 i �1' K i M41'4J9kI,114t 1 7'iJ } J3lY1J JilYi. eii1Y14°X:i li.,,1�, i.'- ml,sai ,�riu a•4 . � a r,p�y;X. P P will t.g .fl.•Y•1,+y�ti.oN 4 � t F}!t(1YSiilP/lUli:'N!I:.tX'� 1'l Y YI1s,.,.�.�PC11 L j� Z SY��.�.n�i'.e. , y _ : - 5i .a' low ,:,, •'' r a h" „x L,.rr.i E. i r .«M tx .. - � + .':f... , ,. M.4T, ,,,yy , ;,'-,r y J,i4l a ulwi 5 +q 1 I r • ``t �.(`1 ' , , �t t 5 � : r5 ra,'ii'v,"1.u+:awusu`a5>fuY�++ar%d,.�aWSYtC�'r+SS''A4#a.Vi'ri?Y�,C�IiSt���AtiY..�'Y:11f:.iP`..±iN1;�f1.Ia.AMjddr6S;..', ..y:war,.aSyxJ#!:Y'U':tiCgLwawM'qr:.ps.sw:!..+�,-,',:�.ilwrw+-r+z.+w:'° - " t t 'ouW+n.,w•.. < .. _,. . �: ,.rr--..ate... _ I'' �:...,. , 7 FE8 2 5 1992 I currently da not have a ` CHARLOTTE SPEEGLE, declare that I, CHARL !i{ kennel in the County of Tehama. That i I attempt to establish a kennel in the County of Tehama, that I winl co1.mply with the Tehama, a County rules and regu lations which are attached, or such other regulations as are amended from time totin the future at such tame as 3: would make such application. It is my current intention to apply for a Use Permit; and t Kennel License in the County of Butte. Such application for Kennel �+ License and Use Permit is pending. The County of Butte has not • act on such aPP 1' indicatedto me when they will 1icaton. I will attempt to complete those applications in a reasonably prompt fashion, although itmay take more than 30tiays for ane to do � that under my current financial situation. I 'agree to complete my applications for Kennel Licenses with 1. pi the county of Butte do or before April 3n, 1992: Upon completion p Kennel Licenses and the of the application or fuButte of suchapermits,: I will notify the Y issuance b the Count t Attorney lls -Office. After the Butte County on 7.ehama County Oistr1 Y pp I agree to allow' inspections of my applications are. granted, y kennels upon 24-hour,. notice at an time after the Butte County i licenses are in place and prior to May 31, 1992. r 4 DATED: January 22, 7.992 CHARLOTTE SVEE61:,E� Attachment Sctllche T884 . fiPtleE•I0 Rout ing•Reques! Pad ROUTING f Please �r) `]Oun . READ To _J' I_1 HANDLE T� t•S iFS 'jT�r1� —Le S 11), 4 0 APPROVE' aiid. u FopWARo it�d�"Sdrrn r pETUaN rye ma S -t �•s m �. r �� 9 _ KEEP oR nISCAND U_1�r (,V 1° �•1'1� �Ud_'7 n�: F;EVIEW WITH ME } dale , , �:�� �`'' Ptd;�i lU�.�l• . _ ��-a-Q.� _ t- , a x, ,.., t'PM _„y,*a�W-yvrw�✓M•I• t kr$Cn+lY4tw. "ti4'NV r l" ra'93u k��W Y _1/`fr.' , ., 5 ,+--a _f. 5o CS Ai 9 H`d+y+•ar.'ib 9WH o..d r ' W pyti f 5h ° � � . e. a x A• Y'.i("v M�fS '�i: � rv�i•a1 V'y s 4� 7", 1-,� P -,y INI, 1, 'q' V, -N PLANNING DEPARTMENT 1 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - oRoViLLE, CALIFORNIA 96965-3397 TELEPHONE: (P16) 5qg-7601 Ffbruary 21, 1592 Charlotte Speegle 1011 Hurleton Road Oroville, CA 95 966 M U86 Pertni't to allow a Icennel Remaining, Fees Dud, $ 780.00 J Dear Ms, Spedglee• The Pre-Applicatidn AevidW,,Proc -ess requires that all Information and fees rieeded from anapplicant in order to process the Pre -Application must be submitted within six months of the initial Pre -Application submittal. I it are. to be notified inwriting. exceed' All applicants for Pre-ApplicatiprIs exceeding the me 14M4 You now have 30 days to respond and pay the outstanding fees, or Your project will be considered voi,& matters please, contact this officd. if you have any questions concerning this I A Lisa Purvis-wason Planning Technician ,777i i 1 i V�. Stw tq ," i ! : 4 5'v 4* f 1', a� �Y r j i 1 �' .e. o .,� f+`:.. v .+ar f : 1 i� •.�+ ,J. t ! ' M '4 `i � 1n.'„ � � a.. h e,e 6•; ,1. 1,�4i - �l h...,iL t!� 1,� d� d ��!„, Y 1 1{0 � Y f a ! :.a , ) x r It { S`•r aW � � `�t�k ri � ��� h �ll � r I `;,'1�'�� {�� � ���t y �.� •i P� � � i t , '' d � � .� R � . �• � � 1 � .� - i .( ri , �'i + r. 1�',i 1 i 't�. ,'I i v 4w (,�� 1 #:�. ! M"t 4 4,' J a p ! •f"� it J W :L-,. • d>•.. Ip.p r l �, ♦ l F..�44.aitd57: ik: �" .tgra.�a,r 1 61 ;u .a:A.a�h+l,�io..�.L count !DEPARTMENT WT OF PUBLIC _.HEALTH, t RABIES CONTROL OFFICE II, 18-8 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE E Q OROVILL, CALIFORNIA 95965-3317 a TELEPHONE: (816) 538-7409 of (916) 891-2807 t Y [[++ S 9: Mr. &Mrs. Don'Speegle8-28-1 1,071 ' Iurleton Rd. OroVille, Ca. 95966 Y Dear Mr. & Mrs. Speegle The,FPlanning Director, infor"ins me you need to come into their office # and payi'Oe remainder of your fee so .your application can be acted Upon- The`„waive- you received' them is an extension six (6) months willing to rant an extiension �, fror>,( theilf d6 arttad.n. Rabies control �s not a g g p of that length.We will work with you ifOu a the fee due at Plannin sa tfiat your application will be considered. Y However, if yon choose not to do this, you are then ,operating a kennel within the unincorporated area of Butte County wst`lout a use ermi t or kennel license for which this otfic ' shall c te' rou pato court. p To avoid any Luther legal ac tion'by this office et this time • Department and. do what must be done x' suggest you contact the P],an'ya.ng .Depart to get a use permit immediate) me { Larl You” Sup visor' + Rabies Control p J I .t 1 1^. r� . lr �: � r nl 3 'J J h i, p F v 4 ! �.+rr tlY .7 ti � � � �<: kk vl 'K *'a!'"'vlr . is w w a ♦ ,, t ,: ,,P+ � + '� a � +• s+ I • ' ,. , : � � +G: ., "—�,t,k �7,.� J'.n wi w � ! � �f� �.. � a w� r r�. I � ^a. h iCq'+ w "wit v EA U TY L AN D 0, F N A T U R, A L W E A L T H A N D B, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEA R BiEs CONTROL OFFICE itA 18-9 couNtY CENTER DRIVE o OROVILLE. CALIFORNIA 95965-3317 TELEPHONE.6) 06-1409 or PW (91 )891.2907 February 11) 1991 charlzotte Lorraine SPOeglO 1071 iftrleton Road oroVJLlle, Ca. 05966 Dear Mrs. speegelAs' The intent of this letter is to inform you that the ButteCounty 1990-91 KennelLicense issued you 7/,31/90 has been :revoked. After Investigation it Wat found that you had not met all obligations the Butte - County Planning Dept.; Butte County Zoning Department or the Butte county Environmental, Hpalth" Department in order to obtain the kennel I itente. so, your kennel capacity was 49 dogs and you had over 100. If,n the -Iija fQture�o you wi sh, to ap I Y. for a 'kennel, 1 icense wi thi h thi 8 county, yogi yott will I I iave to comply with all the laws go�lerning, kennel licenses. Sino re1yi arl Young Rabies Cont ol'Progra ordinator S J . jq it ° .,' � '� rJ � a s a �° kY a J, � 1 i ♦' ' X r. Jf {r 11, 5 All +P• y' ti li ;1 i y� 1 1.19 ` .,awYv aat,.�.�'�w+,,.l.. .'Mi C.'WJwK;�i:sW«,nw+.....kYl*�ul�kagcA7a+tis'n:d+u.a.wipe;.v..J..a..,-.,1...;::......�a.-+A.�.p•'=- •».�.s;i'4..]�.,......:, Lw,..L.:.u,.,... w.�. Kt.�.iw,�_m ,, .°... ...C.n� ,.w.i1�,+L,..,:i'we'.'-u ., e... r+.n«.•+�+5. i yl ,I G pp I L "i ,uta OunL� ±—FNATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY LAID O r PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965-3397 } TELEPHONE! (916) 538-7601" t , ?i June 19, 1991 ilk Charlattq Speegle 1 1071 Hurleton. Road. s` (7roville, CA, '95966 i` Re Pre -Application Review Use Permit on AP# 072-290-154 Dear Ms. Speegle: This is to notify you,that we have received sufficient assurances from Butte County Environmental Health and Public 'Works Departments that your project ; can meet their requirements. This fulfills the Pre -Application review process. `I Pursuant to the Butte County Planning Department Project Review Procedure , Manual whichstates, "Upon tentative approval of a_land use permit or variance by the Environmental Health Department and Land Development Division of the Department of Public Works, the applicant must submit a completed formal application, including any required changes from the original submittal and the balance of the fees within 6 months of the tentative approval." Nci additional Work shall bep erformed on this project until we have received the remainder of the application fee in the amount of $780.00 and, if any, required changes from the original submittah Please "submit the fee along with ,any required changes from theoriginal submittal �I toL the Butte County Planning Department no: later than December 19 1991 and YO ur application will -become void, and .in order to; continue the project, you will be required to reuapply, 'Please make all checks payable to the Butte County Treasurer t fi„I • r v y r. u.., 'J, yw--777ti 77- 7 I ,��' .r, t �, t al a r! 4 �� }n iv, i Sy 4 + :�' i tp �l',. 1 t ,• rt 4.. t 'I.' .'rd 1 ! r f t .. �, «.� t d _ � ',+Sr l , 1 .,!i t � ^,p a p:" 1S} s S u i xp 1{ r -- r Yl�", t ,�l N 1 1 , i at .`ul F�, . r l ; r "•I 7:•:✓ t". tA k, ,rw l�,,w,a ?; .>_ _:.� ��+^• .i r a .:: " . � ,�.St%tii is7A�.kI�:::.hd4;L�MtiUti/�IWSi�.�kF9f�i�taculu4`r�:P3a.Su.�+� •., .. , ^ -ar•. liiu�.ixyi°�ri«�t�Ytsr.�uil.1 r , {, June 19, 1991 N18. Speegle 4 Page 2 (` 1, Enclosed is fi`;� el',d marker for xdcntification of the project. `Please secure the ribbon in a conspicuous place on the site, preferably visible from the roadway. a 4> Y 4 p g S , P to contact 'x it you have, an uestions re ardin this matter, lease do nat hesitate this office anyweekday he hours of 10:00 a.m. and 3:00 p.m, weekda between t , Sincerely, B.A. KIRC14ER � Director of Planning �4 Larry Painter Planning Technician F w !BA K:LP:jlo Enclosure I ,i t , •U'•' � h w 'P F ;�I t Y ��. � ww,� 11x N�:. adr w: ,whl4°'.& +^ 1�'�la� F '` d ec w. q.` �_,� r +...:.. p, '''`' i .r o 1 VF h k"Sf"' St, rr•� ,x p k .1 l� ...rt � Y _.K - y. • ', � 4'1 1 Irl` 1'^� 1 _ ^r r ..,, ,1 , b r ' .t.# . s ::s i' t 3�� � ,r � r i 1 el l � �,; $ � ' ,� ;� #�, l o n , { 1 xr � l r�9 ( t r j rr r ° r � 1 �• `j fi � 4 ! ir,t t � a{{ �� f , � 1 � � t ° r ! 2 p :� � 9. I �'! ` t # 1 � ��I, >♦i i� a4 # rl fi ,� , 4 t �� t,� #, + s v P' +� • r �rr s ." 9 V •! a .: r j f} ' �� O �. �a '• t s a o • # r _�.u. r ++a �ti ° ri x"1"e 3 _ ' 11 a� '� - t r � 1T 1Y � vs+=•y yyyN r� r 1 ' PUNNING COMMISSION B �r15 U'ITE COUNT� NCY k1 , , LI HEARI j Nn OF R'E-P�T13LI HEI➢ PUB on that a re -published published the Butte `County Flanning Conimiss1 Board Y Notice is he given by 7anuary 28, 1993, in the Butte County public hearings, will ;be held on 1bmsstration Center, 25 County Center Arive, Oroville, of supervisors'. -Rolm, County Adm1.ini, time: • the following • t the following California, regarding item a { AS E ATIVE Dp('LARAT-1(N AT ON _ C ----_--- S. FTA BEEI4 RE ME1�TDF,D ( F.EGARDING ENViRONNIENTAL iMP o kennel for up private breeding Charlotte Sneeale - e PPrml' allow Uncassed located on the north 9:00 a.m. • i# ) xoximately 1/4 mile we of Hurleton Swedes ,�� to, 99 adult1. dogs on property zone side of Hurleton Road, aPP identified as ;P 072-290-154, ` Oroville.,� Wyandotte area, Flat .Road; Lake Wy re o on and mag n file and available for d hle Negative Declarati Center The above mentioned Planning D, ,pa tment, '1 County G At the office of the Butte County s licatioris in court, You nlay be public viewing you challenge the abavP app California: If y P �. Drive; Orovlle; correspondence delivered to the Planning 'limited to raising only those issues you or someone ;Ise raised at the public hearing mp "escrl*ed in this notice or in written ublic hearing. r at or prior to, the p gr;P rE COUNTY PLA_ COMMISSION B. gI1�CHElEz DIRIaC',COR OF PLANNING l� ` Regi`star on Tuesday, January i.9, 9 To be publishedJA the O"roville 1kle.cu rY Novbmber 5, 1982, • i i 1 4 1 +ryr 1 .. x r � k ,��,3 r n r✓ Pr . n r v,h ' r 9 rm-' n E a o z i - .w r ri; 77 rt � * e., •w 'a. '„ r.'r�"mak "y�•tv 7 >,`^,r«.+wka K:.. els ..:•�' •.»�.sCY •i 11 .e ,e AM` , `'(s ., i , i a x.i+�},C rod' L k}r n • & � w �.• ky i n t$ � 9��'T, it, 1',C -CtA '31 'T -1 BUTTE C 0 "NN T Y LA NN, 2: N G D E P A RT.MEN PRE-APP� 1.4 LICAT10% -cEVI.ZW Ta, Date: May, 20, 1991 N 0 -Applicat-10ft eview REE - Pre m - Info=atiori Chavlotte Spee - Use APIt 072-290=154 n-ry data a u C e has, -eceived or e,n, e r a t ea Enclosed is preliminary bliARJ to allow a ;,0TV'SPEEGLE-USE PERMIT cbhce--nihq the fallowing p:tojec�.. kenndl, on property toned "U" (Unc lass if ied) on, property l6cAtbd Olive Hwy. east lea ight'on 4orbestbOn Rd, left. on Hurleto'n Rd6 ji identified as APO 072-200-154k. Provillei 6 s e by ctheckina,�, the a p p r Op't- i 2L -L 6 bOi�. sp n P,jease. 14ndica'I': e your 0 to this PrOject.. this Depatt:P--ts �Ohe,pra'ect as propa�:iaa ,,an nteet that ham been c 2'.,ve n 4, req'Uire.ments. J. qt�. f i c i e t tab 4, diondItIons the ppl'--anit (t6�rj ': 5 yj j a'-P.li,�',t'�.w`Y%h?.4 ;' `1+I'"��' !'.�"t"+Gw it6. .'v L«aSi1,1L»'1 �L4e5LihAk1�4';'ik.�:.+arit�i,�f 'S}"i,LiCAeki:...�F!;kiwi..l,..%Y.�::iC;'-14.1iA'F'.iL'.lilldiMu&.A,-.m:z:.�il�:;:'�+dkti"iS.1%i��Gxl^...-tt.$:.usJalUi:��:'`•w+•!•»:wAa.;ik+=.�4. �+.,..�;..�'+ r BUTTE CC" TNTY 'PLANNING 'C%UAISS ON ��-� t ' 7 County Center Drive 4 Oroville, CA 95965-3397 (916) 538-7601 .0 � A ka TO •CU I Gi' DATE • ��-~I `, "� . , REe PRQu'EC'P REVIEW&; 4w .: ENVIRONZMENTAL EVALUATTO,i Charlotte Speegle, - Use Permit AP# 072=290-154 ed or enerated Enclosed is preliminary data our off ine ;has recei.v g 'concerning the fallowing project: CHARLbTTF SPEEGLE -U .. SE PERMIT to allow a M kennel, onrroop_erty zoned, "U" (Unclassified), on property located Olive Hwy, east tight on Forbestown Rd., deft on Hurletonidentified as A..# 072290-154. Oroville we are making a.n assn essment. Of possible enviromental impacts and will be ,preparing an environmenta-1, document, either a Negative Declaration, Negative Dec 1.6e ation with Mitigation Measures or an Environmental ' Impact ;Report (BIP.)' e' r Please provide wfY, factual statements, ideas for investigation, or .� opinions you can offer in your area of concern or expertise that relate to e..ther physical: social., or economic impacts that this pro3;ect alar generate i PI.ease respond within 14 days " f ate: fir_ no resaonse �^ is � �, _Y generated by this i.nenta].� i at iswFicl" re :.o.�n�.yhatomthe are ,. _ Y I { no significant envij onm e Xi project. �J .2 4 1991 fi II provide." �� { �. �' t+Te. appreciate an assistance � p � _ ,,, Sincerely,, BUTTE GIS, PLANNING DEPART -Mr. ,y j*r OROVILLty CALIFORNIA I . w Larry Painter PlAnning Technciari r r r' % + .rl Comments : 6 ,t•�'ct� y?� ! ?'roes Your agenc+ wish to' rece'i've a copy oz tj•ke en*,•��=o:::ikenta� coc+=er•t Y Mensural study for Negative Dedlayation (with or wi th out Mi!.»ga --oft init� es) or ulri for this projects i T E '�;J' - �� a 1 yN ii' . , i�pi,K r P i',p ' ' •7.. Ft'Y•1 �, Vt ki ' ,' w�9,` Ja wk�e+i r�'n;,� Ye�rY, � 1'aPr x r .in .Y � � ,k .. ,i �• + YY 1 ^ • ,... ,..- ._ ,..... .. .. .. ..... .. .. ...... .: ,.... :.. ..., . - it . .- ,,» ., .,, a ,,,IDucuicanor; ana when- ever any such ;person is taken into custody r-'-" "'..��•, moi' �u�ccA yuannea as pr�yv'ded in Section 607f of the Civil Code, oe xilmi! duty of} thereforby any officer, such officer must take charge of such vehicle and its contents may enter any place, building, or tenement, Where there is an exhibition of the fighting, society, ;. rerulatiit together' with the horse or team attached to of birds or animals, or where preparations cause tl� such vehicle, and deposit the same in some are being mads for such an exhibition, and,, of such it place of custody; and any necessary ry expense incurred. for taking care of and keeping without: a warrant; arrest all persons present: Amended Stats 1987 ch 828 § 36. Cal Jur 3d wise tah,'i dog or the same, is a lien thereon, o be aid b same can be lawfully cover d• an if the uch Animals § 91; Cal Jur 3d (Rev) Crimirsal Law § 1440; Witkin Crirnes p 440. sickness,�i the labo} expense, oranypart thereof, remainssun--- paid, rt may be §',597e. Mirbility for dare of impounded other m'N recovered, by the person incurring the same, of the owner of such domestic animal] Any person; who. im- P ounds, or causes to be impounded in an such ani, owner, s, � domestic animal, in an action therefor. [1905 eh 519 § 2.j Cal Jur 3d Anamals 89 Pound, any domestic animal shall supply t' during such with to such€ x suitable §§ Ph. Gal Jur 3d (Rey) Criminal Law § 1435 confinement' a sufficient quantity of good' and wholesome food aril deemed 4i Pitkin Crimes p 440. ' " water; and in default thereof, is guilty of a delivered; § 597b [Fighting animals An ] y person who, for amusement misdemeanor, In case any domestic animal is at any.time so impounded and expenses Jul care of a' or gain, causes an Y bull, bear cock, or other animal, not includ- . bear, continues to be without necessary food and water for thereon, ing any to fight with like kind of animal or creature, or causes more than 12 consecutive hours, it is, lawful far an Y person` from time to time, as may be lawfully ;w' It sha,', any such ani- mal, including any dog, to fight with a different kind of animal :or creature, anemed nece.x. ary, to enter into and upon Y Pound in which the animal is confined, pounds .l reguIatroi or with any human being; or who, for amusement or and supply it with necessary food and water convey; gain, worries or injures -any such bull bear cock, dog: or other, animal, or so long as it remains i,o confined. Such person is not liable for the entry and may meitts, ttY cats and causes an � such bull- bear, cock, or other animal not collect the reasonable cost of the food and a public. Inc ,any dog, to worry or Injure each ' era and any person water from the owner of th.e animal, and' the animal is 'subject Vo enforc.einettt of a money i*grown b �`terinari, r tohluding who permits the 'same be dont on any premises under hia charge judgment for the reasonable cant of Mich i. , s for a or control, and any g , y person who at abets,operative food and water,'lar,mal [1905 ch 5'19- § 2; 1 95,., ch 1 SLa t st` u Y v p.. fighting g P w6ttyling , such anittial or creature r, guilty ofsa inisdemeahor ti[1905 y ,4 or Cnrttinal iv§§ 50 13q Cal lur 3d (R Cr Animals § 1435 Wrtkin Crimes i' Ar, p suchl y chc519 p 43,9; § 2, uannmary (8th ed) p 2513. 1907 cl, 456 § 1; 197.1 cls 1075 § 2,] Cal Jur ! such a de 3d A a§anals § 89; Cal Jur' 3d (Rev) anal , [ Marie o ed of anim euthahasit� not pp 0 1440 I44I Witl[in Crimes 439 Duties7f of it slectted a� Every, driver, r ibed? 597c, owne , or possessorP animal, who shall permit te same to be ui ! that such C!Jwmng, keeping or training air- final for fighting]. Whoever owns, any building, enclosure, lade, street, square, or is iricil"' nation deC� possesses, keeps, or trains any laird or animal, with the or inf, of any city, city and count , or judicial di,strirt, without hospitalize" intent that such bird or animal shall be g g exhibition on of fi lthn , or is g g proper care and attention she an convic ' 6e deemed ' guilty mi5demeanon tion, uflt _of a And it shall be the li emergency, tc services �'' Presenttatitahn lace P. y P ' or tenement, where P. eparations are being made for an duty of an peace t of t he humane owner's ui or society h exhibition of the fighting of birds or animals, with the intent to be present at such society, of officerofficeof aCe Quad or animal regulation department of ublic i fees, fines,' the city, et ex'hibi- tion, or is present at "such exhibitiono is guilty Milt of a misdemeanor, agency, to take possession of "the anim$t 'so abandoned or neglected and care for the 1 the animal:' This section shall not apply to an echlbiti'ori of fighting of a same until it is redeemed by the owner or claimant, unlicensed " tirtal was ft, ,and the cost of caring for such �' this cost it b y '<;.iF'�Sr�.��flkp"�i!M'9,1iG4,�k1@_.Y l�c.e .a..b.,.. .y},.�. rr •f.;� 4 225 DEERINag PENAL § 5911 animal shall be a lien on the same until the No .Such veterinarian shall dec decision criminally whi he or 2, charges are paid. Every sick, disabled, in- civilly liable for any $9, makes or services which he provides pursu- } firm, or crippled animal; except a dog or cat, f this section. ant to, the provisions ot which shall be abandoned in any city, city and county, or judicial district, may, if after Notwithstanding any, other provisions of due search no owner can be found therefor, this section, any officer of a pound or animal le, be killed by such officer; and it shall be the regulation department or humane society; or as duty of all peace officers, an officer sof such any , with he of a papprovaolice l of hs heriffs dimmed'iate '. C, society, or officer of 'a pound or animal may, ' f nt, regulation department of A public agency td superior, humanely destroy any abandoned ng cause the same to be killed on information animal in the field in any case where. the ins of such abandonment. Such officer al including a, where a veterinarianis too lts notravailable and to move it j t d, wise take charge Of any amttn nt. dog, or ;at, that by reason of lameness, would be more humane to dispose of such 3d g ,s feebleness, or neglect, is unfit for animal. [1905 ch-61 19 § 1951 ch 1608 § 7; sickne 1963 ch 1583 § 1,• 1970 ch 580 § 1.] Cal Jur nal the labor it is performmg, or that in any 8991 Cal Jur 3d (Rev) other. manner is being; cruelly' treated; and, tf 3rl Animals§ 615, 1435; V►ltkin Grimes `� s ed such animal isnot then in the custody of its Cnmtnal Law§ im- owner; 'such officer shall give notice thereof p 439, ] ling ahorse= 4 :any to such owner, if known, and may provide § [Poling ll ,fig or es to jump u 4 5978. [�' it suitable care for such animal until it i`s is a method of frothing rsuading, or tent deemed to be to a suitable condition to be which consists o (x , m such manner nd delivered to such owner, and any necessary enticing a horse to dump ' f a expenses which may be incurred for taking that one or more of its legs will come in , lal care of and keeping the same shell be a lien contact with an obstruction consisting of Any ues thereon, to be paid before the same can be kind of ~vire, or a pole, stick, rope er other � for lawfully recovered. object wtfh brads, nails, "tacks or other sharp fut It shall be the duty of all officers of points imbedded; therein or attached thereto ole, Or (2) raisin , throwin or moving a p be pounds or, humane societies, and animal .. ' g g on regulation departments of public agencies to stick; wire, rope le other object, Against one P and for police and sheriff depart- or more of the legs of a horse while it is, ed convey, a jumping an obstruction so that the horse, in; y Ater ments to, cause to be conveyed all inured legi� uch cats and dogs found -Without their owners in either case, is induced to raise such ict or ' ay a tblic place directly to a veterinarian legs higher in order to clear t(te obstructign, {' , to be a and known by such officer or agency The poling of any horse v unlawful and any the Vetezinarian that ordinaril treats -dogs and person violating the provisions of this sec- Y cats for a determination Of whether the i y al Jury 3d Ani= one shall be immediately and humanely �uch al sl. ��� §sl'gutlt of a misde� C Cnm[nal LaiW omni t97S ch 560 l ch destroyed or shall be hospitalized under mals § 89; Cal 1 ur 3J (Rev) Jur proper' care and given emergency treatment: § 1438; Witkin Crimrnak�es p 4€C1. 39, Any, such veterinarian who s all himself tper'fo rin inacli ne •to bet pursued by dogs.] It hallibe � I MC 439' such h det§1a On. nlawful for any person to tic of attach or euthanasia on an animal if the owner does not ine or redeem the animal withtrt the locally an ower for the put- prescribed Als fa,4ten .any live animal to Any aria prescribed waiting peixod or if he�de injuries devitt propelled by y Inial to bechursued Any that such animal has incuzred se ere j pose of causing such an p e in or is incurably crippled: If any such veteri- by a dog or dogs, 1 shall tie Are be Any person violating any of the provisions j u � naricn determines that the animal ! or hospitalized under proper care artd giv of thin section shall be guilty of a misde- And emergency treatment, the costs of any such [1935 + h 431 § l,] 'al Jur 3d 7' an°t. �.tned setwices which at provided pending the ,4nirr+nls § 89 t:'al Jur 3d (Rev,1 Criminal � d artment, , Lary ; S. Witkitt G�riirtes'0 r the owners lo4uiry to such agency, department, the, or society shall be'pAid froth the dog license .0,0y' Prohlbitions. regarding lighting d ory.. fees, fines; grid fees for impowtding dogs in [ - . t toile the city, county, or city Arid county in which bird rams oz lashers� It shitll bsell, bartet� Al so the animal was licensed or tf the animals for ,anyone to manut`actire, buy, unl►censed the urisdtation iii which the ani- exchange, or have in his possession any of } �, the teal was found sttlsiect to the pte�vtsion that, the 'mplemeiv s commonly known as gaffs Or cr or this cost be repaid by "the Animal's owner, slashers, or any other shArp implement: lie-, ry . suet: A i �r ' n li •," 4 4• f. x 0 '1 K? Y1, V , I T Febi:,aary 26, 1991 El Dorado County Department of Agriculture `' Division of Animal"coxitt6l Aunt ,, Pat C aerbout, Director' 2301,Coolwatet CreekiRoad'" Placerville, CA 95W Dear Mrs,. ClAetbouti On February, )91) at your request, I exanihied the 12 poodle- typedogs in your l, _ possession, originating ilng ffrimTehama Courity'. All the dogs were unkempt, Ungr60med, with filthy skin haircoats, and very thin. milder case f the a severe dermatitis (allergic type),: and two others had a 0 One dog had 91 same. One doghada severe pitrulent otitis (oozing ear infection). one dog was depressed and 56/6 dehydrated (cause iinknown). one dov, had two small mammary tumors. Yi(,;8t -the of the dogs had dental tartar build-up and were in need,,of dentistry. All but twoof r fear of hu ng alized beha 4 t) dogs demonstrated utter man handli (un,5ocV10 (handlingi cleanliness, goo ming, onclus' an 'ohly be that basic needs Y:c ion c feeding) as well as, the medical needs (diseases, infections, dental problems, tumors) of these dogs were, b_,,;,1'ng neglected. S4 erely, MC Janet L. Cicero, DMM. JC:lde c: Loren kemper; Tehamatounty File: Ulcero,ltr T 17 1 �17 v;ww �1 � tit � ! b 4, • I 1 '� -, 1 4l V•yi l Iii i .` 1 a n x, R .Y i � v- � ✓ Y w l •, u, uu.raua#t�t k5M, w, i awiaD tuSy J uni ttra2 7u r,.iuc�. druwi� wi• �w .eta p . y I' uciut far fife uVur�r �u�� ufi �4uult .,Jo nhals Of Solano County, t13�Ll�tRy, 12" 1 99'/ S0b;6C7 ANINALS RE,Gl_NQUIS116D 70 7EK,,gr1,1 C0107y CON17ROL !3f . C/URLO77E SP669ZZv rc r- I(, c i ." ON FeBI lAR1f r, 1991, Ide R8S/ OND,_ra 70 A C44. ;h.Larl T�ILArtrt COI.IrV r / lrt'Ili, � C07ROL 06 760K '�,9R7Y -F9LVi (4 4) R00DLE POOEiLE dRaS.S` CARED FOR A7 OUR MCIL17Y, ON T68RUARy $, i q.;9 7, 0E RELINQ1LISA8D' TEN ( 1 r.1�J IOr !Ae AN1,,I'1AIt S 70 7/i rTr'tr2�14 /lilt IANC ,.OG.LE71 �. ON FLi RUARY 9. 99 J.,' ;DR. BARNES, 4 LOCAL b`'47' CA NE 'FO OtA ;rAC 4-r'71> TO CAECk 07 71/16 D09S. i1ZS t11WDZN9S 06RE r'IS fOLLOId,,''r I I'I�.1.�Nli7i�Z?ION +', NAMD S XN9AO0N RAtlZ, D,l6 701,11CIt OF '9/Z0001rV9 ();e AN K-r1Vt7 7RZC'!C /KNEES, DUE: 7(7 1s�'Di,�Cr�LI�IT,NtlN7 �r�4E��t,�ry ld11.t P(doArlS DRY OEs ES7EN, Ve DEN711L PRUBLEi'I.S NA46S, i4E7',�tNED 7ES7LCLccS IN OANY Off' ME AN!1744S r c ry E i ,AU 0019/1 Sri ��,�1'rC i OSSIdL 71 Rbc'-' OF Vie A.iV,l'JIALS lde.A� 4W.11"7E OLD, 141VD $UXP- P6D MANY FORMS V/F DISW AND T,NrZi�/'l,t?iESy ANL► r7 Glr2S t7Et:t'8 I.N 7Nc� f���ST tAt7�rRE,�'7S O� 7,�� rlrl'.l` IALS 70 " 117/1ttN1 C 7/Ml. MiS gc'EAV AL C CINDM" ON OF 7NI 'ANX/ A45 ZS P 04M 47 1-1657. 1.1x1 " S ANS'; 4AY L-rV t ',9 CONDt7j6NS XS 128SPONSIPU, rOR P111ca 0 7/1 cQ*P COMI L -V It e. i I ld"�1R-�` U1l,�il,�ti'7Ii1jZ'N� 7`/L,� t�rlr,Ti�I;�LS r C'lii' ,� 7'u1r1` Gi`.`h: �'tks)cTOr:7 i�7 7N..1zfi 7tr'IE lilt~ !'i NA f c` 7'U ��Ll7f1RN zG r'It71 c� 0� , 7/16 A.N:�`NAL�S j , 4)E OILL ,` No 1d )Y6 -1V 111ANY i' AY r' 0.0, bbX 866, VACAVILL�, C3ALWONNIA 0606 • (701) 40,1192 fa 6 '777-7 �I S� � u� T. � � F M Mti tq - � Y 4 I� •a ll i� , Y�•� r �{ � I � I l V, ' Xl f i 1AN" �� a '� , r': gra � � b i � �, ` �yu t t �� e 1 � tl Y , � n. � � ��� 'vutpneiJ�o.•.:..4:ttsi 'k." a.uu° u.+=mow«r ¢ ;..e,......,w_,w..-. .�..�we,.�,..,....... ....i-«.., a,'._... --+.r+ �,ai i' Cit;SaLkv'a4A1e,�lswd�4.+na.riu..+.aw. w..�wz+tW Ul6t�.4i�84'�+. .. I Mk 060 fof X10 rAniffials �1f�o1 ot 6 ru, Cif solano count _ y -CON7INUU" BE ADlr >i1QL". ii A,G.L. o 7A6 4N.ItIAL.S 0tU f &A V6 TO 13E CL4ANU AA'D IINZ�cZ 90 EN%f rV.SI.t'6 i VE rc^ j "r It j�. gAoo xNG. SEVERAL VZ1-4 !AVE 70 N,4VE 7k'61/2 iVIV S CN,I/ i 17i S 7KEf AAA SO ,LON9 AND CUA4 LIADCA SO BADLY 7KA7 7r�� PATS OF 7'KL ANIMALS FE T 1 r c C DO V'G7 70UC/i r IL0 ytz0t(JV, D IJfIEA' 7FI6y' S7,gNDi /zES�EC7%LI�.L 5y [36NNT_ E I'MALKS 1144 419E S. P, C. A. OF SOLANO COUN7 . ,rpt,' /c 1 .y, y0001,c-098, . ^ r ANY r0/%lit O r , Po s .70 r NONE 0! TKF, E ANIMALS, KSI E /�r.r_�:11 � �"► 1/,4C.CINR71ONS, I NDEl2 ME CbNDI,7I'0NS 71YO lJE/2E LII tt1 y ,ttb 7`,4t,tf �c.S�.A'T A r > ° ''AS IJELL AS 0 LM ANINAL,S �I�.AGTR AAZ7.IIRD 7C 711PIU806s r'►ti jar 110(5 00108 tN CON74C7 017/ii i 11 17 zS my 0� XNSOh 7/IA7 7/16 oIJN�,1 VEE` LER IMM5 7r t SII�'F!Lt4Y1r7 FAC:ILZlY V "loll .. 70 CARE 7OR 7�IE ANS04LS PAOl�6Af A 4 P,o, BCX W , VACAVILL'Ei 041FORMA 85696 (W) 446.7722 .. .1 ti,r. _ t 1l, � r.. a ry i <,�k�t Lt W�„ �y�aa? villa '• tvn n T` v:Y 1 1 .) M , o � F +1 o,'.. i �k rrft r ��#5r rr � � ► +, �._, *4 . ',♦ ��I n '.��'kP 1�.t c�4 �.i tl dr i, 7 �.4 1 i . � I ' 4 i, S ,",� �V 4 ��. i�.W ��,..ti,.,�u..1+li�'daC;:kt�573rt'+%�1lak�tiali•'.LFJdV y `�}r:.:u.�r:�.uu' ` rw.�..w�.'+uil1=�itMfkMMr%tuw:uu�Y:.w�.�+�w+i�i»v+1rR k � � W.m.4a_y...l,.i... ..-.......r .� e..w»r..J r�.�.«„ �...,:�P' . �GJ 4 1/,�76R.INtl%y REPORT - ,FEBRUARY. 9, 79 9 7 it..�hytij 3R. Y.1 `4 J I t 5E1'll" 8Y: LAI,<5 0R0,Q I LLE q16 529 j *19; 4 1 Northwest S F C. A. 2668 -So. S. Ave. /�OrOville Ca. 5506 5 r.. , 6) 533-76,3G MOTION T1, CRIME, ?e,,CLA'SSIFICATION IINIQTIM'S NAME LASTj FInS.T, MIDDLE (F)FIM IF, UUM.1 74, A(mmes§ LLMIDENIEJ BUSINESS s, Pmomr M" ..-On Febrm�x Esponded to Tehama., 'Cc _An i nil a TtAr-Q-1, Q_,as mi 8.t-- j a -'6 1j e.. Jmpo ditent of-sriLuala—relemoed. p it . hyi, Eighteen 18 pbodl.e.-dogs were.. -released or), h Oescripblan,01-_,�,�hfa animal pr.. d.i In proyUl, Q h�ilter. ,A qisivbi 1A S f 0110Y.13 Y". 4vk?10U 41h, e �2-e" J�uc A nad to ,hpiyzi� ikilm,4p. g.q,� -Avay 1XA from ir , . re, a r to andble_tJaese d ,Note 1111 0� these ,, Ctogs .. had-impabted Anal g Ia n d q,,s -------- Note-,, All. of th6ae dogs,._h4d..S,eYf!r6, tartar bt�ijrd Up on their teeth with z,*:il;d to severe gUm ir,riba,tions.. NkSPOA Sex Age Calor commimts 336 m Syr Gr;y/ljl'k tRih, missing tee'th'leye infection 356- K, 2,yr Apt,icot, Vety thin 351 '14 1 2yr S i I k/Wbt Missing teeth 358 11yr Blacit vt2ry thihi eye bi f e LAI 6 n- 359 F 4�yr "irel to 0 bb hii 661 nq o tyOtblid HOAtb Mu I v4iv 360 m lyk Red 361 1 F 3yr White Im1. pact",ed 8bc, 'd anal glands �I esse 38 F omth Rod Very Thin 63 2) y e Rlaok 364 Black "FCOADIN13 QVpazm TYPED ay 4-L3 -11 Dt►tE AND TIMI 1„ ADM"~1 TEA TO*, OtTrCrIve 0 Jwmu P�tiitol. qtr rarol _MCACAi RYINED NY BA 0 OTHER t 1A 7 77 ✓llli I.. rt 7 :q 5 l +" r 1 K4 ,',� :( 1 1 L ^+ 4 ,+ 'tri t : , 14 4 :y e �,, r1 + k�1'. , ➢ i I.M 33 I �ri4 t n I, , s x y. • p ) ,i" - � <i I , �J 5 .r� kd.b.triiY.ai+�'�i'sbr'i�hYl!LhlllX:i�k6'etiaMwli�i..a�eu.es a'++.nr..Ca+.•.�..�a��pvs�.�.i�i .w Me.-,.-.u.u.-.,.-.+-, ....,_.....,.,...,...,`t-.._......,.n+-�:,a LAKE OFdU ILLS >' 2--13- 4i i •,13F'Irl ?iFSti_•�2:s� 16 5? lU=l�: i ' l` Northwe�et S. P. 28613 So". 5th 7�ve i oro,11i ll'e Ca. 95965 k" ii 7 U OLA551FICATION � TO -CM 6CDT1aN LCRIP.f a 9,! 7s. AOLIRES6 11ESIDCNC! Ot7EINE8D Tp. PMONC + 1 73, VI4TIM'!1 NANO' " Ga'ST FIRST, MIDDLE Irinrb IF Mu � Sex F 3 r white Ver thin t ' 365 , y y 366 M Syr Chocolate 367, M 4yr Grey Teeth m s6ing, severe gum irritation . •1 . 1�-...w•«.�:.�1 .- r 'r. vnrr > - ••._—_ .. a,_r1.'H .,. ..:. _: ..-, Sr.. }}} 360 F 3yr IGrey Abeeeeed anal. gi-nds, eye intecti;on L 369 4yr White 370 F gm�,h131%/Wh`b boots abCessed anal glandsi eye infection ; 1'Yr131ack Paeiblregnant Y p F fyr 81 ack v 37� ery �'hit� r ,r �I S' f _ter � ......._.. Wg11N QrFIDCnS, RECCMDINQ OFFIDCII Tp .. TYrEG �X DAAND TIME RQVTLD pT ' rUniHRR ci3r"Iee "OoN Yt>r f4I pETuoTIYf bli pp El JUVENLf n' pAThc1L nc"vi�wca yr �r aTNEn ' 1 rsa4 4 rw� ►r }v"� �,1r� .,��s�"t^ I�" rii 1 {.,�s i~ .. ya 4 h. X, VI 10 jj 41 0 "0': 00 4 �n7— ved at "Tehama, County Animal. On"February 7# 3.991 1 arri, isor/8tate Humane Control accotpanitid by Animal Care Supery _ksbuty ergdant T and Agent Bob ficei� Kira Lanham-Snydet, S om Mar .,Of r With Gerat to assist officers frarit Vehama County Animal Control A-1large number of dogs surrendered to., them. Upon arrival I 1 obse 11wVed numerous dogs contained in,cajes in vehicles, on the shelter premises and in shelter kennels. All Of the dogs Were 'the in need of grooming. The majority of dog-s,l 'Viewed were in ' desperate need of grooming; their had ircoats were extremely matted with, mud and fe-cesr their tails stuck to their bodies. Many of the dogs upon general observation showed (signs' of eye ptibblemsk minor health' problems and long term. neglect. The majority of the dogs were uns cialized4 The smeilinside the k I ennels, and the areas where dogs were kept was strong of urine and feces Onde�all of the agencies were assembled we made arrangements to'separwEe the,dogs. -Xim Lanham-Snyde'r was their Tehama officers to eValuA dogs to determine requested by te bilit�y. for Adoption. As we handled tzrach dog we observed suita 1. -oblems With their well-being. Some of the health - many other pr --- 7' - -p rd�fftUM 11 ei f r -aps.�d 01 P tumots, def druidd legs, -dogs, without teeth, dogs ;that were-bliAd — -cataracts, ear,mA es, ei�acjatibno,�undesdended lee--iticlesk ear 4 1. -.01 , . d eyes, weeping eyes, hairlos8, and infections, red and'iritLame long, tibeha dogs -were it'a lano SPCA ken by -So without i Forty -.aim •*-tentaken ght_',evalua',�4-0711,r__ of-of'.,do4s .were- ile Societ 2/8/�ql and evaluated. We loaded 52_ dogs in v on _Humat our vehicles including' in -1 of the dogs that were unsuitable_forteind I d " qj. al A .4--otal of, 242 dtg�s wei'd euthanized, at 'Marin Humane dogs. On Soci Humane.pickdd Up 12 On 2/�S/t. FrI sco 2/8/`e��l��.80-rgea'nt''ToM,,�4��-k,,,ks):)ury delivered 4 dojs� to San anoi Animal Care and c6litro'l 'on 2/0,/91 Oakland SPCA picked up dogs.IH sr R 77- A. V