Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout078-280-01501 zz. 17 ITEQUILLA STOVALL 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy, Oroville 0-7 �;Lg 0 -(? 'S Contr- LUczak Construction, Oro rmit#3633-80B,p (reroof, inst. e Plbg vents & replace interior doors) SFI ermit#333-89B,P,g,M(reroo'f-­' S wal heater & elec clean up)SF l I QI I x Stovall, Equilla 3041 Oro -Bangor Highway Oroville, CA 95966 // //e_��tiq, IN � �a N0. 1.0339 NASi1N6S, UN Butte County Departm, ofDevelopment Services 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 (530) 538-7601 Telephone (530) 538-7785 Facsimile 14 April 2004 Ms. Fannie Tobias 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy. Oroville; CA 95966 Re: Response to Complaint Letter — 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy., Oroville Dear Ms. Tobias: Thank you for your patience in allowing us time to research the records regarding your letter of complaint of "poorly done work on Equilla Stovall's home at 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy" dated 01/02/04. Unfortunately, the loan records from 1988 through 1990 are no longer available. We were able to review the building permit file and a more recent (2000) file provided by Connerly and Associates. Findings from these files are summarized with Exhibits A -D attached to this response letter. The facts we were able to ascertain from the Building files are as follows: • July 16, 1980 Building permit taken by Walter Luczak Jr. (contractor) for re -roof (5 sq), install plumbing vents (3), replace interior doors. This work was inspected by a Butte County Building Inspector and deemed complete on July 23, 1980. • August 28, 1988 Equilla Stovall was notified by a letter from Connerly and Associates that she qualified for the Emergency Home Repair program. In that letter she was asked to obtain contractor estimates for repairs the staff determined to be most urgent. A list of contractors that had worked with the program in the past was supplied along with the letter. The letter also stated, "You may contact any other contractors you feel will do a good job, provided they have a license." Mrs. Stovall was asked to supply three estimates for the six (6) items outlined by Friday, September 16, 1988. (Exhibit A) • March 27, 1989 Connerly and Associates requested a written inspection report from the County as they were requesting permission from Housing and Community Development (HCD) to make a $20,000 loan under the current grant. • February 7, 1989 Equilla Stovall applied for a building permit for re -roof, gas wall heater and electrical clean-up. Mrs. Stovall completed an "Owner -Builder Verification" indicating she was acting as her own contractor. Subsequently, on 08/29/89 the Building Inspector for Butte County inspected and determined the roofing looked properly installed and indicated the remainder of the work applied for on the permit still needed to be done. • April 26, 1989 Equilla Stovall was sent an inspection letter from Public Health indicating the repairs or corrections required that needed to be done to rehabilitate the dwelling. (Exhibit B) • July 18, 1989 Equilla Stovall applied for a building permit to relocate vent pipe, reside house, foundation work, replace steps. Records indicate this permit was not issued, meaning work was never authorized to begin. Notes in the building file indicate: o Mrs. Stovall again filled out an "Owner -Builder Verification" to act as her own contractor but showed her intent to contract with Kevin Jones, and unlicensed contractor to do the work. Records show State Farm insurance submitted information on November 29, 1989 indicating that Mrs. Stovall's homeowner coverage covered Worker's Compensation insurance for employees including but not limited to painters, roofers, remodeling and repair contractors, chimney sweeps, etc. Mrs. Stovall was notified the Owner Builder verification information was not valid with her statement to hire Kevin Jones. Records indicate Mrs. Stovall was called on January 5, 1990 and advised of 4 Fannie Tobias 14 April 2004 Page Two this as well as need to supply sufficient plot plan and building plan information. Notes attached to this building permit application indicate: ✓ (no date) "Stovall, unlicensed contractor, ordered off by Connerly, 2 complete plans, $7,000, Carl Moore" ✓ March 19, 1990 "Ward Connerly advised we needed complete plans and new contractor must apply for new permit and we can refund other permit to Stovall. Connerly to advise contractor". ✓ April 16,1990 "Tanga/Connerly" Going to job with another contractor to try to straighten out" Facts we were able to glean from the file sent to us from Connerly and Associates are as follows: • . 08/21/00 Butte County Central Collections notified Connerly and Associates that Fannie Tobias had notified County that Equilla Stovall had passed away (6/1/2000) and had provided a copy of the death certificate. At that time notes indicate $800 or eight (8) months of payments were delinquent. • 12/15 Note indicates, "daughter is living in home — paying rent, children (7) inherited property". • Connerly began working with heirs on an "assumption to convert to rental dwelling". Application was sent 12/18100. • 9/17 Note indicates, "Fannie does not live in property, sister (Helena) does, home is in Fannie's name. She still has assumption application, says it is very "complicated" and she will mail it in as is and I'll [Connerly] get back to her with what we need." • 11/7101 Letter to Fannie Tobias indicating information needed — Signed "Information Release Authorization" for all persons on title, Source(s) of income for all persons on title, "Tenant Income Verification" and "Tenant Information Release authorization" — Helena Heard. There was also a reminder the rules governing rental properties and owners of rental properties were quite different than owner/occupied units with a strong recommendation that the option of refinancing with a conventional lender be explored. (Exhibit C) • 09/02/02 Letter to Connerly and Associates from Fannie Tobias. (Exhibit D). • 9/25/02 Connerly note indicates staff attempts to work with the family for almost 2 years to get them to assume Equilla Stovall's loan. Options of refinancing and assumption were discussed. The family did not like the fact that the original 0% loan would be converted to an interest loan as an investment (rental) property. Staff was unable to get Income verification on each of the heirs with a vested interest in the property. Family was now requesting a reduction of the loan balance. Decision was made to recommend foreclosure. Summary of findings in response to complaint: Rolled roofing (901b), as verified by our Building Official has a short life expectancy and it is reasonable to expect that it would need to be replaced every 2-4 years (compared to shingle roofing of 230lbs that has a 10-15 year life). Your letter states,"repairs have been done 3-4 times since the original rolled roofing was put on". We can only assume you mean since the building permit for roofing finaled on 8/29/89 as there were no other permits taken for additional roofing, so any other repairs were done without obtaining the required permits. It also appears that other work you are disputing also was done without benefit of permits, so the Building Department did not have an opportunity to review the quality of work or pass it upon inspection and there are no records of this work on file. File information clearly shows that Mrs. Stovall was advised to select a licensed contractor to perform the required work. Mrs. Stovall clearly at times acted as her own contractor and file information indicates that although she was told work must be done by a licensed contractor she attempted to have work done by Kevin Jones, an unlicensed contractor. Connerly and Associates reports that Mrs. Stovall would have had discretion to authorize and release payments for work she deemed complete. An attempt was made to get records of payments from the Butte County Title Company, but we were advised that after seven years the records were purged. 0) Fannie Tobias 14 April 2004 Page Three The file from Connerly and Associates picks up in 2000. Loan payments were delinquent, the County and Connerly were made aware that Mrs. Stovall had died, and the heirs were renting out the home. The record shows that Connerly worked with Fannie Tobias in an' attempt to get the loan assumed as a rental and encouraged exploring conventional financing. Staff at Connerly and Associates who worked with the family recall there were no complaints regarding work on the home during the entire period that assumption of loan converting it to a rental was in process until the letter of September 2, 2002. The letter of September 2, 2002 seeks a reduction of the pay-off amount due to allegations that "contractors" chosen by Mrs. Stovall were dishonest.. It appears that a complaint was appropriately made to the State Contractors Board, but it is unclear why this wasn't pursued to compensate for the allegations made against the "contractors". Again, the County's position is that Mrs. Stovall chose the contractors to work on her home and that Connerly intervened when it was discovered that Kevin Jones, an unlicensed contractor was performing work. On October 7, 2002 a recommendation was made to the Butte County Loan Committee to foreclose on the property and a copy of the September 2, 2002 letter was attached. On October 22, 2002 the Butte County Loan Committee approved the recommendation to foreclose. On November 13, 2002 a certified letter was sent to Fannie Tobias, Catherine Harris and Florence Young "Official Notice of Foreclosure Action". The note balance was paid in full February 12, 2003. There is no documentation, of any complaints other than those noted in the building file of Kevin Jones (an unlicensed contractor) being ordered off the job by Connerly and Associates and Connerly working to "straighten things out". Notes indicate that Connerly and Associates worked with Mrs. Stovall to resolve this issue when it arose and disbursement of payments which required Mrs. Stovall's authorization would indicate the work proceeded under her oversight and to her satisfaction. The Stovall heirs benefited from the 0% interest loan in place from the time Mrs. Stovall died on 611/2000 until the note was finally paid off on 2/12/03, over 31 months of interest free loan while the assumption of the loan and conversion to rental property or conventional financing to pay-off the loan was explored and the home was utilized as a investment rental. Please be assured that this matter was reviewed thoroughly. Due to the facts presented above, the fact that there are no building permits on record for the rehabilitation work, and the family benefiting from 31 months of interest free loan, we consider this matter closed. Sincerely, Deborah DeBrunner Principal Analyst Enclosures: Exhibits A -D Cc: Allen Jones, Program Manager — Department of Housing and Community Development Liz Fitzgerald, CDBG Field Representative — Department of Housing and Community Development 3 Butte CountyDeparbnent ofDevelopment Services 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 (530) 538-7601 Telephone (530) 538-7785 Facsimile 14 April 2004 Ms. Fannie Tobias 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy. Oroville, CA 95966 Re: Response to Complaint Letter — 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy., Oroville Dear Ms. Tobias: . Thank you for your patience in allowing us time to research the records regarding your letter of complaint of "poorly done work on Equilla Stovall's home at 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy" dated 01/02/04. Unfortunately, the loan records from 1988 through 1990 are no longer available. We were able to review the building permit file and a more recent (2000) file provided by Connerly and Associates. Findings from these files are summarized with Exhibits A -D attached to this response letter. The facts we were able to ascertain from the Building files are as follows: • July 16, 1980 Building permit taken by Walter Luczak Jr. (contractor) for re -roof (5 sq), install plumbing vents (3), replace interior doors. This work was inspected by a Butte County Building Inspector and deemed complete on July 23, 1980. • August 28, 1988 Equilla Stovall was notified by a letter from Connerly and Associates that she qualified for the Emergency Home Repair program. In that letter she was asked to obtain contractor estimates for repairs the staff determined to be most urgent. A list of contractors that had worked with the program in the past was supplied along with the letter. The letter also stated, "You may contact any other contractors you feel will do a good job, provided they have a license." Mrs. Stovall was asked to supply three estimates for the six (6) items outlined by Friday, September 16, 1988. (Exhibit A) • March 27, 1989 Connerly and Associates requested a written inspection report from the County as they were requesting permission from Housing and Community Development (HCD) to make a $20,000 loan under the current grant. • February 7, 1989 Equilla Stovall applied for a building permit for re -roof, gas wall heater and electrical clean-up. Mrs. Stovall completed an "Owner -Builder Verification" indicating she was acting as her own contractor. Subsequently, on 08/29/89 the Building Inspector for Butte County inspected and determined the roofing looked properly installed and indicated the remainder of the work applied for on the permit still needed to be done. • April 26, 1989 Equilla Stovall was sent an inspection letter from Public Health indicating the repairs or corrections required that needed to be done to rehabilitate the dwelling. (Exhibit B) • July 18,1989 Equilla Stovall applied for a building permit to relocate vent pipe, reside house, foundation work, replace steps. Records indicate this permit was not issued, meaning work was never authorized to begin. Notes in the building file indicate: o Mrs. Stovall again filled out an "Owner-Builder.Verification" to act as her own contractor but showed her intent to contract with Kevin Jones, and unlicensed contractor to do the work. Records show State Farm insurance submitted information on November 29, 1989 indicating that Mrs. Stovall's homeowner coverage covered Worker's Compensation insurance for employees including but not limited to painters, roofers, remodeling and repair contractors, chimney sweeps, etc. Mrs. Stovall was notified the Owner Builder verification information was not valid with her statement to hire Kevin Jones. Records indicate Mrs. Stovall was called on January 5, 1990 and advised of Fannie Tobias 14 April 2004 Page Two this as well as need to supply sufficient plot plan and building plan information. Notes attached to this building permit application indicate: ✓ (no date) "Stovall, unlicensed contractor, ordered off by Connerly, 2 complete plans, $7,000, Carl Moore" ✓ March 19, 1990 "Ward Connerly advised we needed complete plans and new contractor must apply for new permit and we can refund other permit to Stovall. Connerly to advise contractor". ✓ April 16,1990 "Tanga/Connerly" Going to job with another contractor to try to straighten out" Facts we were able to glean from the file sent to us from Connerly and Associates are as follows: • 08/21/00 Butte County Central Collections notified Connerly and Associates that Fannie Tobias had notified County that Equilla Stovall had passed away (6/1/2000) and had provided a copy of the death certificate. At that time notes indicate $800 or eight (8) months of payments were delinquent. • 12/15 Note indicates, "daughter is living in home — paying rent, children (7) inherited property". • Connerly began working with heirs on an "assumption to convert to rental dwelling". Application was sent 12/18/00. • 9/17 Note indicates, "Fannie does not live in property, sister (Helena) does, home is in Fannie's name. She still has assumption application, says it is very "complicated" and she will mail it in as is and I'll [Connerly] get back to her with what we need." • 11/7/01 Letter to Fannie Tobias indicating information needed —Signed "Information Release Authorization" for all persons on title, Source(s) of income for all persons on title, "Tenant Income Verification" and "Tenant Information Release authorization" — Helena Heard. There was also a reminder the rules governing rental properties and owners of rental properties were quite different than owner/occupied units with a strong recommendation that the option of refinancing with a conventional lender be explored. (Exhibit C) • 09/02/02 Letter to Connerly and Associates from Fannie Tobias. (Exhibit D). • 9/25/02 Connerly note indicates staff attempts to work with the family for almost 2 years to get them to assume Equilla Stovall's loan. Options of refinancing and assumption were discussed. The family did not like the fact that the original 0% loan would be converted to an interest loan as an investment (rental) property. Staff was unable to get Income verification on each of the heirs with a vested interest in the property. Family was now requesting a reduction of the loan balance. Decision was made to recommend foreclosure. Summary of findings in response to complaint: Rolled roofing (901b), as verified by our Building Official has a short life expectancy and it is reasonable to expect that it would need to be replaced every 2-4 years (compared to shingle roofing of 230lbs that has a 10-15 year life). Your letter states,"repairs have been done 3-4 times since the original rolled roofing was put on". We can only assume you mean since the building permit for roofing finaled on 8/29/89 as there were no other permits taken for additional roofing, so any other repairs were done without obtaining the required permits. It also appears that other work you are disputing also was done without benefit of permits, so the Building Department did not have an opportunity to review the quality of work or pass it upon inspection and there are no records of this work on file. File information clearly shows that Mrs. Stovall was advised to select a licensed contractor to perform the required work. Mrs. Stovall clearly at times acted as her own contractor and file information indicates that although she was told work must be done by a licensed contractor she attempted to have work done by Kevin Jones, an unlicensed contractor. Connerly and Associates reports that Mrs. Stovall would have had discretion to authorize and release payments for work she deemed complete. An attempt was made to get records of payments from the Butte County Title Company, but we were advised that after seven years the records were purged. 2 Fannie Tobias 14 April 2004 Page Three The file from Connerly and Associates picks up in 2000. Loan payments were delinquent, the County and Connerly were made aware that Mrs. Stovall.had died, and the heirs were renting out the home. The record shows that Connerly worked with Fannie Tobias in an attempt to get the loan assumed as a rental and encouraged exploring conventional financing. Staff at Connerly and Associates who worked with the family recall there were no complaints regarding work on the home during the entire period that assumption of loan converting it to a rental was in process until the letter of September 2, 2002. The letter of September 2, 2002 seeks a reduction of the pay-off amount due to allegations that "contractors" chosen by Mrs. Stovall were dishonest.. It appears that a complaint was appropriately made to the State Contractors Board, but it is unclear why this wasn't pursued to compensate for the allegations made against the "contractors". Again, the County's position is that Mrs. Stovall chose the contractors to work on her home and that Connerly intervened when it was discovered that Kevin Jones, an unlicensed contractor was performing work. On October 7, 2002 a recommendation was made to the Butte County Loan Committee to foreclose on the property and a copy of the September 2, 2002 letter was attached. On October 22, 2002 the Butte County Loan Committee approved the recommendation to foreclose. On November 13, 2002 a certified letter was sent to Fannie Tobias, Catherine Harris and Florence Young "Official Notice of Foreclosure Action". The note balance was paid in full February 12, 2003. There is no documentation, of any complaints other than those noted in the building file of Kevin Jones (an unlicensed contractor) being ordered off the job by Connerly and Associates and Connerly working to "straighten things out". Notes indicate that Connerly and Associates worked with Mrs. Stovall to resolve this issue when it arose and disbursement of payments which required Mrs. Stovall's authorization would indicate the work proceeded under her oversight and to her satisfaction. The Stovall heirs benefited from the 0% interest loan in place from the time Mrs. Stovall died on 6/1/2000 until the note was finally paid off on 2/12/03, over 31 months of interest free loan while the assumption of the loan and conversion to rental property or conventional financing to pay-off the loan was explored and the home was utilized as a investment rental. Please be assured that this matter was reviewed thoroughly. Due to the facts presented above, the fact that there are no building permits on record for the rehabilitation work, and the family benefiting from 31 months of interest free loan, we consider this matter closed. Sincerely, Deborah DeBrunner Principal Analyst Enclosures: Exhibits A -D Cc: Allen Jones, Program Manager — Department of Housing and Community Development Liz Fitzgerald, CDBG Field Representative — Department of Housing and Community Development 3 nru.nr�rq: �{ W l . _ANIN L.KL & ASSOCIATES Mrs. Equilla Stovall 3041 OroBangor Highway Oroville, California 95966 CONNERLY & ASSOCIATES, INC. 2215 21ST STREET SACRAMENTO, CA 95818 (916) 456-4784 August 29, 1988 RE: Butte County Emergency Home Repair Program Dear Mrs. Stovall: Our staff has reviewed your application for the Emergency Home Repair Program and determined that you are eligible. Your next step is to obtain contractor estimates for repairs on your home'. The following are repairs that our staff feels are the most urgent: 1. Install new roof, replacing rotted sheeting as necessary. Provide gutters and downspouts: 2. Ensure that all wiring is up to code. Re -wire as necessary. 3. Repair -gas heater in living room or replace with wall furnace. 4, &nsura- wood stove -is -install -ed -to code --in bedroom. 5. Hang exterior door where missing in bedroom. 6. Install stable step out of front door. 7. Replace any substandard plumbing,. Attached is a list of contractors that have worked with the program in the past. You may also contact any other contractors you feel will do a good job, provided they have a license. Please send us three (3) estimated for the six (6) items outlined above by Friday, September 16.2 1988. Please feel free to call us if you have any, questions, -n ncerely, Pit SOPHIA PAGOUL OS SP/tc Enclosure HOUSING W PLANNING • COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ,{,; ., L tt•f ��'fia.L. {� .wL q V�1 � rte- :--. ..... . ..... �:.� � e .,',� fpr rT T' wv`a `�y�. �"!:• A,e�� &any, & i4 Zi T r A. [--I D3 UT DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH Address ❑ 196 Memorial Way ❑ 7 County Center Drive O 747 Elliott Road Reply to Chico, California 95926 Oroville, California 95965 Paradise, California 95969 Telephone: 916/391-2727 Te • lephone: 916/533-7241 Teleohone: 916/872-6305 April 26, 1989 Equilla Stovall 3041 Oro Banoor Oroville, CAJ 9966 RED Rehabilitation Inspection -- 3041 Oro Banoor Highway, Oroville, CA - AP# 036-021-044-0 Dear Mrs. Stovall: On April 17 and 24, 1989, an inspection was made of the above listed dwelling unit at your request. The inspection was made as Part of the rehabilitation program currently underway in th,_- El Medio area south of Oroville. The dwelling is a single story structure with wooden siding, composition shingle roof., concrete slab.at north end, pier, and po--t south end, served by community watery natural gas, electricity and private sewage disposal system. The house exhibits weak and sloping floors in living room and bedroom off living room. There is ground to wood contact on north side. Water heater lacks proper discharge line on temperature -pressure relief valve, lacks proper flue and adequate combustion air. Roof is deflectincj badly on north end. Dwelling lacks proper roof and underfloor.vents. Sliding door and front door laces: proper stairs. Exposed unprotected wiring evident in kitchen and in west exterior wall. In order to rehabilitate the dwelling under this program the following repairs or corrections are required. 1. Complete all corrections or repairs as listed in the Butte County Emergency Home Repair Program letter to Mrs. Equilla Stovall dated August 29, 1988 (Attached). 2. Provide an adequate underfloor support system by adding Piers and girders as required and replacing all damaged materials.- Remove and replace all damaoed or deteriorated floor joists, sub -floor and. floor covering. Provide. adequate underfloor ventilation and crawl space.' Equilla Stovall April 26, 1989 Page 2 3. Strip walls to frame and provide bracing, studding, etc. as necessary. Replace damaged or deteriorated . materials in walls and make all exterior walls weathertight. Insulate walls to R-11 standards. 4. Flake all doors and windows ooeriabie and weathertight. 5. Provide an adequate roof support system by adding rafters, ceiling joists and bracing_ as required. Remove and replace roof covering replacing all damaoed o- deteriorated sheathing. Provide adequate ventilation and insulate -to R- 19 standards. 6. Cleanup electrical wiring; eliminate all deteriorated or damaged wiring, outlet boxes and fittings; unprotected wiring; open or exposed splices, etc. Provide additional outlets as, needed. 7. Provide adequate plumbing fixtures with effective traps and vents. Provide proper supports for all drain waste and vent piping. Provide proper leak free plumbing for all.drains, waste, vent, water and gas lines. 8. Remove and replace cas heater in living room. Verify that wood stove in bedroom is properly installed. 9. Provide adequate combustion air and proper flue for water heater, provide discharge line fortemperature--pressure relief valve. 10. Provide wood to ground clearance on north side of house (newest portion). Regrade lot to divert water from slab and side of house. 11. Provide proper exterior siding on north end of house (newest portion). 12. Provide proper stairs for kitchen and living room doors, and sliding door in bedroom. 13. Provide smoke detectors. The following items, although. not required, are strongly recommended to effectively prolong the useful life of the dwelling, and/or to make the dwelling more habitable. 1. Provide continuous concrete perimeter foundation. 2. Provide new cooling system. Equilla Stovall April 26., 1989 Paoe 3 9 Most of the corrections or repairs listed will` require permits and inspections from the Butte County Department of Public Works. Permits may be obtained at 7 County Center Drive, Qroville, CA, All work shall be completed to the extent necessary to provide the desired -finished product. This may require tile, linoleum, shingles, wallboard, paint, vents, or whatever is necessary to accomplish the finished product. Should you have any questions, please feel free to contactmeat the above indicated address or telephone number. Sincerely, Howard `Snyber, Director Division of Environmental'Health HJS/mlf ccs Public Works — Jim Glander Connerly and Associates, Inc., 2215 21st Street, Sacramento, CA 95918 Attachment CONNERL Y & ASSOCIA TES, INC. 2215 21st STREET SACRAMENTO, CA 95818 (916) 456-4784 FAX: (916) 456-7672 November 7, 2001 vls=� Fannie Tobias P.O. Box 5574 Oroville, CA 95966 RE: Equila Stovall/Butte County Home Repair Program loan Dear Ms. Tobias: Thank you for submitting your assumption application for your Mother's home repair loan with Butte County. In order to continue processing your request, I will need the following items: • Signed "Information Release' Authorization" for all persons on title - Catherine Harris and Florence Young • Source(s) of income for all persons on title - include complete mailing address(s) • Completed "Tenant Income Verification" and "Tenant Information Release Authorization" - Helena Heard As we discussed in our,telephone conversation yesterday, the rules of this program governing rental properties and owners of rental properties are quite different from those for owner/occupied units. I strongly recommend that you explore the option of refinancing this debt with a conventional lender. Upon completion of the application process, I will present you request to the Loan Committee along with my recommendation. I will notify you of their decision as soon as possible. Please feel free to call me at 1- 800-722-3436 if you have any questions. Sincerely, Karen L. Bull Loan/Escrow Officer Connerly & Associates, Inc., for Butte County Home Repair Program 1 f 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy. Oroville, CA 95966 1 September 2, 2002 1 Connerly cO_ Associates Inc. 2215 21s' Street Sacra*nto, CA 95818 r: Dear Ii1r. W. Connerly: I am writing this letter in reference to loan #34039 which was granted to Equilla Stovall who is now deceased. She passed away on June 01, 2000. The Stovall family would like an aoljusted pay off amount in consideration to the money taken by Carl Moore the contractor suggested/assigned by you. - Mr. Moore was the second contractor to work on thetbouse. There was also a first contractor, a Mr. Kevin Jones (who was also assigned by ;you), also took a considerable amount of materials that were supposed to be used in remodeling the home. We tried to report Mr. Jones and Mr. Moore. When I attempted to .seek compensation for these losses, the State Contractors Board, informed us that there was only one $5000.00 bond purchased as insurance for all the homes that were being remodeled at that time. I have kept records or copies of paperwork showing monies that were issued to Carl IV[oore in 1990; which totals to over $22,000,000 for Carl Moore and Kevin Jones. Marta. Sierra finished up with an additional loan or grant which wasn't enough to do all that was neded. The finished product in no way looks like a house repaired to the tune of $45,000. I was also promised money by you for my mother to live with me while the remodeling job was taking place. I never received anything. I had to forgo it because there was not enough money to finish the job because of the. dishonesty of the first two contractors. I feel that I should be compensated for this and the losses resulting from Kevin Jones and Carl Moore's dishonesty. I'm asking for this to be shown or reflected in the pay-off amount for this HUD loan, #34039. v A copy of this letter is being forwarded to HUD and another copy to the Attorney General. I've been given the run-around regarding this matter for the last twelve years. {if satisfactory results are not granted, I shall proceed with pursuing legal action. Sincerely, Fannie Tobias e BUTTE COUNTY TITLE COMPANY ESCROW STATEMENT 3, IN EASr 611.1 STREET 1909 BIRD STREET P.O. BOX 1929. 6402 SKYWAY dGJ. CALIFORNIA 95926 P.O. BOX 051 PARADISE. CALIFORNIA 95969 (916) 343-3716 (916) 617-6268 OROVILLE. CALIFORNIA Date . November. 28, .1990 .... (916) 533-5511 Order No...... , 31256 PC l RE: Equilla Stovall oRROWER -. Cotmty.of: Butte _.__.__ 3941 -Ori -gala c/o Connerly & Associates Oroville, CA., 2215 21st Street Sacto, CA., 95818 - - DEBITS CREDITS De a; bQ_Escro - ----- Paid to Butte-CounM Title Company- $ - 336 .OQ - $ 15 nnn _00- _ Paid to Equilla Stovall and Kevin Jones Paid to_D� amot>d.. Lutr►ber._..______.----- -- - � d_-t9_Fquilla_Stov,a1L&J)iamond_ T > 1mher -- Paid -to Equill_a_ Stovall and Kevin Jones - 3,700.E --1,L2_5_.8.&. 1,164 ]2.4b_ fid Padd__to_..Kevin_-Jones _._--..------------.__---� _ Deposit, to Esczo�a20,ODO Paid-to.—Butte.—County--Title Company ........ ..___.___-_--= -- _ Paid- to MOWACO-..f .-Carl...l�nos�_____.-------.._....-.-___ --- . Deposit_to•.escrow__..-"---------�-----.....----__...---------- ---- ---� Paid to _Carl _Moore-_for_MQWACQ__..______.____.._.._- Paid to Ric[)a �xybtall.-.-----___--- - . Paid to Eddie Mason------__-- ------.--____-- Paid to Carl. Moore-..-_ •- - - - - -._ . _.... -- ...- ---- —... Paid to Carl Moore ---.........._..---_...-.__-•-------------.-----..._..._..------... - Paid to Marta Sierra � --De opsit _to._EscroW ...- ---- - -- -- --... -- =- - - Paid to Diamond Lumher - ----- ---�r3� �- 4CL- 00-- --277 —14� .. 2,00 000 490 .00-. -M Do - � 9_nnn .---------- , -. 00- 74- -238_ 2,248 76 2,000 00 - 5n0 OfL -- -948 Paid to_Marta Sierra _-_-.__-.-._.--... Paid to Butte County__.Title_Company Paid to Marta Sierra Paid £o Butte County Title Company Peid_to-Marta Sierra ( HEREWITIi (.--------..._.__.:..... _....------------------ -------------- TOTALS $ 40 500 00 1$ BUTTE COU TY TITLE COMPANY >3Y ------ - / . &: Pat Castle/tg Escauw Officer S Butte CountyDepartment ofDevelopmentSenices 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 (530),538-7601 Telephone (530) 538-7785 Facsimile 30 March 2004 Ms. Fannie Tobias 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy. Oroville, CA 95966 Re: Response to Complaint Letter — 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy., Oroville Dear Ms. Tobias: We were sent a copy of your complaint letter regarding the "poorly done work on Equilla Stovall's home at 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy." written to The Department of Housing -and Urban Development (HUD). The letter was forwarded to the Department of Housing and Community Development, who sent us a copy along with a request that we respond to the complaint by March 27`h. We received this information on Friday, March 22nd and discovered that due to the age of the files in question (1989/90); we would need some time to locate the files from storage, pull all the information together for review, consult with our housing rehabilitation contractor as to any information they can provide, and respond to you in writing. We have requested and been granted a time extension in order to develop a written response to your complaint. We will respond to you in writing by April 15, 2004. Sincerely, Deborah DeBrunner Principal Analyst Cc: Allen Jones, Program Manager — Department of Housing and Community Development Liz Fitzgerald, CDBG Field Rep. — Department of Housing and Community Development Butte County Department ofDevelopment Services 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 (530) 538-7601 Telephone (530) 538-7785 Facsimile 26 March 2004 Allen Jones, Program Manager Department of Housing and Community Development Division of Community Affairs P.O. Box 952054 Sacramento, CA 94252-2054 Re: Response to Complaint Letter from Fannie Tobais Dear Mr. Jones: We received your letter of 12 March 2004 forwarding the complaint of Ms. Fannie Tobias regarding some CDBG rehabilitation work done in 1989/90 on the home of her deceased mother, Equilla Stovall on 19 March 2004. The deadline given for response to the complaint was 15 days from the date of the letter or 27 March 2004. Due to the age of the file in question, we require more time to locate the stored/archived loan file for review, review the building permit file, visit the site, consult with Connerly and Associates, our housing rehabilitation contractor for the project and develop a written response as requested. We feel we -should be able to accomplish this by April 15, 2004 and request an extension until that time. Please provide the current' contact information for Ms. Tobias if you wish us to respond directly to Ms. Tobias in any manner as it was not included in the information forwarded with your letter. Sincerely, --Debarah DeBrunner Principal Analyst STA.TFQF CALIFORNIA -RUSINFSS TRANSPORT_ AND HOUSING AGENCY Arnold Schwarzp�r Governor DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS BUTTE ©.-.® 1300 Third Street. Suite 390 COUNTY • ; ,, rn',.. P O. Box 952054 / Sacramento, CA 94252-2054 MAR 2 2004 (916) 322-1560 FAX (916) 327-6660 DEVELOPMENT SERVICES March 12, 2004 Jennifer Macarthy Manager, Program Resource & Development County of Butte 25 County Center Drive Orovi Ile, CA 95965 Dear Ms. Macarthy: We have received a complaint from Ms. Fannie Tobias (copy enclosed, along with photographs) regarding a housing rehabilitation loan to Equilla Stovall (deceased) forwarded by the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). HUD has required the Department of Housing and Community Development to act on Ms. Tobias's complaint within 15 days of receipt of the HUD letter. HUD also requires that we keep them informed. We are forwarding to you the complaint from Ms. Tobias. Please review her complaint and respond to her concerns with the appropriate action. We need a written response from the County within 15 days of the date of this letter. If you have any questions, please Contact Liz Fitzgerald, CDBG field representative, at (916) 263-0470. Sincerely, AllVamManager Pro Enclosure . Cc: Liz Fitzgerald • US, 4— 1 VFII mw� 0 ;ter-��-o�- • Pte_ �, Or 0-4 C,4 �,,s� �-��-(, da✓n, 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy. Oroville, CA 95966 September 2, 2002 Connerly & Associates Inc. 2215 21 s` Street Sacramento, CA 95818 Dear Mr. W. Connerly: I am writing this letter in reference to loan #34039 which was granted to Equilla Stovall who is now deceased. She passed away on June 01, 2000. The Stovall family would like an adjusted pay off amount in consideration to the money taken by Carl Moore the contractor suggested/assigned by you. Mr. Moore was the second contractor to work on the house. There was also a first contractor, a Mr. Kevin Jones (who was also assigned by you), also took a considerable amount of materials that were supposed to be used in remodeling the home. We tried to report Mr. Jones and Mr. Moore. When I attempted to seek compensation for these losses, the State Contractors Board, informed us that there was only one $5000.00 bond purchased as insurance for all the homes that were being remodeled at that time. I have kept records or copies of paperwork showing monies that were issued to Carl Moore in 1990; which totals to over $22,000,000 for Carl Moore and Kevin Jones. Marta Sierra finished up with an additional loan or grant which wasn't enough to do all that was needed. The finished product in no way looks like a house repaired to the tune of $45,000. I was also promised money by you for my mother to live with me while the remodeling job was taking place. I never received anything. I had to forgo it because there was not enough money to finish the job because of the dishonesty of the fust two contractors. I feel that I should be compensated. for this and the losses resulting from Kevin Jones and Carl Moore's dishonesty. I'm asking for this to be shown or reflected in the pay-off amount for this HUD loan, #34039. A copy of this letter is being forwarded to HUD and another copy to the Attorney General. I've been given .the run-around regarding this matter for the last twelve years. If satisfactory results are not granted, I shall proceed with pursuing legal action. Sincerely, Fannie Tobias _ BUTTE COUNTY TITLE COMPANY } • O. L EAST A 9 ESCROW STATEMENT r STIIEET 1909 BIRO STREET P.O. BOX 1929. 6402 SKYWAY .ICO. CALIFORNIA 95926 PARADISE. CALIFORNIA 95969 (9161343-3716 P.O. 80X 851 (916) 877-6268 OROVILLE. CALIFORNIA Date .. NOVelDbPx 28, . 199Q .... (91 G) 5�J 5511 31256 PC Order No....... , .... . RE: Equilla Stovall BORROWER _--Cotm ty- Of Butte _._ —3041.--9re- Ban ger- Hwy c/o Connerly & Associates Oroville, CA., opREss — _ 2215 21st Street Sacto, CA., 95818 We also enclose: BUTTE COWTY TITLE COMPANY By....._ _.LGA'---------------------....................................... Pat Castle/tg Esclow 0111cer DEBITS CREDITS Depas,j t to-Escraw --- — Paidto Butte County Title Company - Paid to Fruilla Stovall and Kevin Jones3,700QQ 2 Paid x2DWond.. Lumber-•.--.--.--- -- - _ Paid dto-Yquilla_S-tava1l-X Diamond T j 1mbpr - __ _—�aidquilla_.Stov_all_-_-- -- Paid to Eguilla Stovall and Kevin Jones Paid tp_•kevi.n . Jones __•-. _--. to Escrow -..._ : ... __._. ... - - ---- -- Paid to-Bu.t.te .-County_ Title Company--.-- .------ -- _. Paid' to M�W�►OQ_l._C ci_L�11os�rE----------- - "Deposit to eSQrQ "DeposittoesczQ--=---------.....---- - =--- _ _. Paid to Carl -Moore . for 1 W Paid to RidwxL -Drywall—..---_-- _.- ' Paid to Eddie Mason -__ -_ _ — _ _---Paid to Carl_ Moore_ -_ . _.._--•___--_ —_-...258 Paid to Carl Moore -- Paid to Marta Sierra _ - Deposit_. to Escrow ,. __•_-_-_ Paid to Diamond _ Lumber _ •___ _,.- -_ Paid" to_Marta Sierra Paid to Butte County__ -Title --Company.,., _ Paid to Marta Sierra Paid to Butte County Title _Company_.._......._..-.—_- - -_ - - paid to Marta Sierra - $ 336 — DDL 000. -00- 0-_Paid --1. 1 1,164- 19 -46 .8& 65- - 46_Paid 2-150 6,330 - -- --2 77- 14, nnn QD M -- 00- 00 -- D- —20,-000 Do -- 04— 000 goo 00 - 490 OD 74_ - - 2j248 76 22000 00 R, 900 _ . 49000 40 0 -__ 509 0 I � — CHECK HEREWITH _ TOTALS $ 45,500 00 $ 4525000, We also enclose: BUTTE COWTY TITLE COMPANY By....._ _.LGA'---------------------....................................... Pat Castle/tg Esclow 0111cer AFTER RECORDING REIN TO: County of Butte Central Collections 25 County Center Drive Oroville, California 95965 FULL RELEASE OF GRANT AGREEMENT IN CONSIDERATION of the payment of the debt secured by the Grant Agreement executed by Equilla Stovall to Butte County as Beneficiary, and recorded as Instrument No. 90- 17438 on May 1, 1990 of Official Records of Butte County, California, the undersigned hereby releases said Grant Agreement. Dated: Q I\t) State of Califor is County of j" Lctve' On YR 1.003 before me, i eY�o lic— AVM Personally appeared V12,✓ Personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(,s� hose name(&& is/afa subscribed to the within instrument and e/s acknowledged to me the hhe/thug executed the same in hoisfher/t authorized capacity(!&s), and that by Weher/then signature(s�on the instrument, the person*or the entity upon behalf �1:7 NMEFFORD Signature ommnsi365B36 Z i*MYComm. Notary Public - Calitomia = Butts County Expires Jul 22, 2006 • �y BUTTE COUNTY APR 17 2003 DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Date: 4/17/03 To: Deborah Debrunner From: Colette, Central Collections RE: Full release of Grant Agreement a Please see enclosed Original Grant Agreement for Equilla Stovall. ;A release of Grant Agreement needs to be signed releasing Butte County as the �J tbeneficiary. bi t �, ,rte If you, have any questions you can reach me at 538-7938. t eta yam,: Val 8/4/99 AFTER RECORDING RETURN County of Butte Central Collections 25 County Center Drive Oroville, California 95965 FULL RELEASE OF GRANT AGREEMENT 0 IN CONSIDERATION of the payment of the debt secured by the Grant Agreement executed by Equilla Stovall to Butte County as Beneficiary, and recorded as Instrument No. 90-17438 on May 1, 1990 of Official Records of Butte County, California, the undersigned hereby releases said Grant Agreement. Butte County — Beneficiary State of California County of On ' 5;"V, C�o C) before me Au7— A -p a o ef4yd, /JW" <- Pers nally appeared --x-)e 6o Personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(gwhose name(g) is/aF6 subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me the j 61she/tly executed the same in ,�K/her/tWe authorized capacity(09), and that by lam' /her/tFjefir si natured) on the instrument, the person or the entity upon behalf Signature: _ .. ALICE AAfRI t+kEFFGIZD Commission # 1365636 Z Notsry Public - Calfbomia Butte County !:_My Cortvn. E-'Vms Ju122, 20!76 0 NO State of California County of On ' 5;"V, C�o C) before me Au7— A -p a o ef4yd, /JW" <- Pers nally appeared --x-)e 6o Personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(gwhose name(g) is/aF6 subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me the j 61she/tly executed the same in ,�K/her/tWe authorized capacity(09), and that by lam' /her/tFjefir si natured) on the instrument, the person or the entity upon behalf Signature: _ .. ALICE AAfRI t+kEFFGIZD Commission # 1365636 Z Notsry Public - Calfbomia Butte County !:_My Cortvn. E-'Vms Ju122, 20!76 XPI �� BlfiEC0M7M COMPAnIV AFTER RECORD114G RETURN TO: County of Butte Central Collections 25 County Center Drive Oroville, California 95965 99-1 7438 90-017438 R e c F e e Total Recorded Official Records County of Butte Candace J. Grubbs Recorder 8:00am 1 -May -90 GRANT AGREEMENT BUTTE COUNTY HOME REPAIR PROGRAM CD •• m 3 1-0 Equi 11a Stovall , hereinafter referred to as Grantee, owner(s) of that certain op prerly �escri ed as follows: Parcel One and Two A portion of Lot 3, Block 18, as shown on that certain map entitled, "MAP OF VILLA VERONA, BUTTE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA", which map was filed in the office of the Recorder of the County of Butte, State of California, January 17, 1889, more particularly described as follows: Beginning at a point in West line of Lot 3, from which point the southwest corner of said Lot 3 bears South 0' 04' East, .193.50 feet distant; thence along said West line, North 0'04' West, 63 feet; thence .leaving said West line, North 78'34' East a distance of 140 feet; thence South 6 04' Cast, 63.0 feet; thence south 78" 34' West, 140.0 feet, more or less, to the point of beginning. and Beginning at a point in the West line of Lot 3 from which point the Southwest corner of said.Lot 3 bears South 0*04' East, 148.50 feet distant; thence along said West line North 0'04' West 45 feet to the Southwest corner of that certain parcel of land described in Deed. from John Curry, et ux, to Walter J. Stovall, et ux, dated November 1, 1965 and recorded November 10, 1965 in Book 1399 of Official Records, at page 312, records of Butte County California., thence along the Southerly line of said Stovall parcel, North 78'34' East, 140 feet to the Southeast corner of said Stovall parcel; thence South 35'20' 45" West 35.0 feet; thence South 69°17129" West, 125 feet to the point of beginning. hereby acknowledges a grant of $ 8,500,00 made by the County of Butte for the rehabilitation of the residential structure on the described property, subject to the following condition: The Grantee shall not be required to repay any of the funds granted, provided, however, that if the Grantee sells or transfers title to the property to another party, unless transfer of title is due to death of the Grantee, prior to the date that the grant is fully forgiven, the County shall have the right to recapture the unforgiven portion of the grant. The amount of the grant subject. to .recapture shall be the full amount for the first year. After each year the amount subject to recapture shall be reduced by $1,500.00, until such time as the total amount of the grant is fully forgiven, re amount of the grant shall be less any funds returned to the County of Butte from the escrow. a,o-!1433 -z- The Grantee agrees that the grant shall be a lien against the property until SUrh time that the amount of the grant is fully forgiven and that the Grantee shall repay, to the County the unforqiven balance subject to recapture immediately upon sale or transfer of the property. Signed this date, ATril 30 199.0 by: qui a o a Grantee acknowledges that the County of Butte is advancing funds to insure the completion of work to be performed by MOWACO Constru4tion. Any proceeds resulting from claims against.MOWACO shall be assigned by Grantee to the County of Butte. DUE ON SALE CLAUSE Should Trustor sell, convey, transfer, or dispose of said property, or any part thereof, or any interest therein, or agree to do so without the written consent of Beneficiary being first obtained or upon the Death of Trustors, herein, then Beneficiary shall have the right at his option, to declare all sums secured hereby forthwith due and payable. A portion of the amount secured by this Deed of Trust may be subject to a Grant Agreement in which case the above applies with the exception that upon the Death of the Trustors, the unforgiven portion of the grant shall not be due and payable. q't1 ova I a e Trustor a t e .19 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) (Acknowledgement) ss. County of Butte ) On this 30th day of April in the year 19 90 , before me, Pamela J. Eutsler a Notary Public in and for the said County and State, residing therein, duly commissioned and sworn, personally appeared Eguilla Stovall personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(s): (U INDIVIDUAL) Whose name is subscribed to this instrument, and acknowledged that he (she or they) executed it. (❑ CORPORATION) Who executed the within instrument as '-president and secretary, on behalf of the corporation therein named, and acknowledged to me that such corporation executed the within instrument pursuant to its articles and by-laws and a resolution of (❑ PARTNERSHIP) its Board of Directors. That .executed the within instrument on behalf of the part- nership, and acknowledged to me that tho partnership executed it. ITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my official seal, in and for said County and State, ay and yea�lab v ritten. ara13Ma0aM0V.aumaZtd tr.r.UlmaSA0Wa.� i r ' 9.Q .� •;..i• Notary Public in a for said County and State of California ® ,°- PAMELA J•UiSLE My commission expires: �,� j 12 y NOTARY PUBLIC -CALIFORNIA ® Gutte Cccni+ W FD -1B ® My Commission Expires uepL 7, 1 got ®�ano���tafa®®veastarice��ela�1�� END OF DO.CUMENr f 0 OCT 2 4 2002; BUTTE COUNTY ADMINISTRATION CONNERLY & ASSOCIATES, INC. OCT. y 8 2002 2215 21 st STREET SACRAMENTO, CA 95818 OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA (916) 456-4784 FAX: (916) 456-7672 LOAN COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION DATE: OCTOBER 7, 2002 TO: BUTTE COUNTY LOAN COMMITTEE RE: EQUILLA STOVALL PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3041 ORO BANGOR HIGHWAY OROVILLE, CA 95966 HISTORY: MS. STOVALL RECEIVED A $15,000 HOME REPAIR LOAN FROM THE COUNTY IN AUGUST OF 1989, A $22,000 ADDITIONAL ADVANCE IN FEBRUARY OF 1990, AND A GRANT OF $8,500 IN MAY OF 1990. THE ORIGINAL $15,000 LOAN IS DEFERRED, AT 0% INTEREST. MONTHLY PAYMENTS OF $100 (ALSO 0%) WERE TO BE MADE ON THE ADDITIONAL ADVANCE. CURRENTLY, THESE PAYMENTS ARE DELINQUENT IN THE AMOUNT OF $2,250. CURRENT CONSIDERATIONS: MS. STOVALL IS DECEASED, AND THREE OF HER CHILDREN HOLD TITLE TO THE PROPERTY, WHICH HAS BEEN CONVERTED TO A RENTAL. WE HAVE TRIED UNSUCCESSFULLY SINCE THE BORROWER'S DEATH TO ASSIST THE FAMILY IN REFINANCING THE BALANCE DUE OR APPLYING FOR AN ASSUMPTION OF THE LOAN. THERE ARE SOME CONCERNS REGARDING CONTRACTOR.PAYMENTS AND THE REHABILITATION WORK THAT WAS COMPLETED. A COPY OF A LETTER RECEIVED FROM FANNIE TOBIAS (EQUILLA'S DAUGHTER) IS ATTACHED FOR THE COMMITTEE'S REVIEW. THE COUNTY'S LOAN IS IN 11T POSITION. THE REMAINING BALANCE IS $23,550. BASED ON COMPARABLE SALES OF $45,250, THE PROPERTY HAS A LOAN—TO—VALUE RATIO OF 56%. RECOMMENDATION: IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT THE COUNTY BEGIN THE FORECLOSURE PROCESS. EVERY OPPORTUNITY HAS BEEN GIVEN TO THE FAMILY TO RESOLVE THIS MATTER. CERTIFIED LETTERS WILL BE SENT TO THE HEIRS GIVING THEM 90 DAYS TO REFINANCE THE. BALANCE DUE BEFORE PROCEEDING WITH THE FORECLOSURE. LCR - STOVALL PAGE 2 RECOMMENDED BY:( REN L. BULL LOAN COMMITTEE: JANE DOLA APPROVED RJ BEELER APPROVED/ WARD CONNERLY APPROVED COMMENTS/BASIS FOR DENIAL: 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy. Oroville, CA 95966 September 2, 2002 Connerly & Associates Inca 2215 21s' Street Sacramento, CA 95818 Dear Mr. W. Connerly: I am writing this letter in reference to loan #34039 which was granted to Equilla Stovall who is now deceased. She passed away on June 01, 2000. The Stovall family would like an adjusted pay off amount in consideration to the money taken by Carl Moore the contractor suggested/assigned by you. Mr. Moore was the second contractor to work on the house. There was also a first contractor, a Mr. Kevin Jones (who was also assigned by you), also took a considerable amount of materials that were supposed to be used in remodeling the home. We tried to report Mr. Jones and Mr. Moore. When I attempted to seek compensation for these losses, the State Contractors Board, informed us that there was only one $5000.00 bond purchased as insurance for all the homes that were being remodeled at that time. I have kept records or copies of paperwork showing monies that were issued to Carl Moore in 1990; which totals to over $22,000,000 for Carl Moore and Kevin Jones. Marta Sierra finished up with an additional loan or grant which wasn't enough to do all that was needed. The finished product in no way looks like a house repaired to the tune of $45,000. I was also promised money by you for my mother to live with me while the remodeling job was taking place. I never received anything. I had to forgo it because there was not enough money to finish the job because of the dishonesty of the first two contractors. I feel that I should be compensated for this and the losses resulting from Kevin Jones and Carl Moore's dishonesty. I'm asking for this to be shown or reflected in the pay-off amount for this HUD loan, #34039. A copy of this letter is being forwarded to HUD and another copy to the Attorney. General. I've been given the run-around regarding this matter for the last twelve years. If satisfactory results are not granted, I shall proceed with pursuing legal action. Sincerely, Fannie Tobias _ °' BUTTE COOVTY TITLE COMPj*Y ti ESCROW STATEMENT 453. 194 EASr 6r1-1 STREET 1909 BIRD STREET P.O. BOX 1929. 6402 SKYWAY "CO. CALIFORNIA 95926 P.O. BOX 851 PARADISE. CALIFORNIA 95969 (916)343.3716 (916)877-6268 OROVILLE. CALIFORNIA Date ...Novewber. 28, .199Q .... (916) 533-5511 31256 PC Order No....... , .... . RE: Equilla Stovall ORROWER—._.QQV ty .Ot Butte _._. 3041 -Or -G, rani c/o Connerly & Associates Oroville, CA., 2215 21st Street Sacto, CA., 95818 DEBITS _b Paid to Butte Counitle Company 336.0 -0 - Paid to Equilla Stovall and Kevin Jones 3,700 Paid to Diamond... Lumber_.--_. _— -& _Ead__t9__EgUjlla__S_LQVjlL&Dimond T „mhPr 1 164_ .65- —Eai i�tQ--EquiIla-.Stov_all---- 1 9 465 - Paid to Eauilla Stovall andKevin Jones S CREDITS _, Paid to_.Keyin_, Jones . _.. _Wait. to Escrow _.... _ . ...... PaidLo _Butte . County- Title Company__ _ Paid to Paid to Carl_ Moore . for _MQWACO _._—______. Paid to Rirh .Darby_Dry tall_._ _—.— Paidto Eddie Mason_._ __ _.____ _Paid to Carl Moore-----_----- -_ . _..-.----___--= Paid to Carl Moore _ _ Paid to Marta Sierra -D- sit_to..Escrow. ...__._�---------- Paid to Diamond •. Lumber .- --••---..-__-.-- • - - ._...-_-...- Paid to_Marta_Sierra ._--------•--.-•___-- Paid to Butte County .Title•. Company ..... Paid tc Marta Sierra Paid to Butte County Title Company_ _ -Paid to -•Marta Sierra ....... — ----- ..___-_- _ — - - -- —.. _--,QQ4_.!L ........__._.—.. — h , i iO O() — 00- --29.x000 W-- — --- —277 4.0(x1 00L_ 9.000 00_ _ —9,o no goo 490 Q0_ 258 7L 2 248 76 2,000 00 — RTS 0- 8 11 - 9. Q_ 4,_000 0 -- 40 0 —__ _509.10 HEREWITI-I enclose: - ---- ----- -_ _ __ — TOTALS $ 45,500 00 $ 45 500 • — BUTTE COU TY TITLE COMPANY --.. ------------._...._..._....-----------......__.._.------ BY -- ------------- Pat Castle/tg Est -low officer 4 • w. gpMIN0= ICE JAN - 7 199b DEFERRED LOAN REVIEW CO1V MrrMENT REQUEST • TO: Butte County Loan Committee BORROWER BACKGROUND LOAN SUMMARY Name: Equilla Stovall Site Address: 3041 Oro -Bangor Highway Oroville, CA 95966 Mailing Address: Same Annual Income: $7,920 Monthly Income: $660 Income Level: Very -low Household Size: 1 62 yrs+ Yes Disabled: Yes DISCUSSION: Amount: Loan Position: Interest Rate: Term: Origination Date End Date: OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 12/05/97 $15,000 1 st 0% upon transfer of ownership 8/89 N/A Ms. Stovall receives income from Social Security payments. Her total income is $660 per month. • 0 Ms. Stovall's monthly housing expenses are approximately $220, consisting of: 1. First Mortgage: $100.00 (Butte County, $22,000 is not deferred) 2. Property Taxes/Insurance: $ 48.00 3. Water/Sewer/Garbage: $ 72.00 Her housing expenses equal 33% of gross monthly income. According to the County's housing rehabilitation program guidelines, very low-income homeowners are eligible for deferred loans. Other low-income households whose housing expenses are more than 30% of income, or who have significant medical expenses, may also qualify for deferred loans. RECOMMENDATION: That the $15,000 portion of Ms. Stovall's loan be deferred for another five years, until December 2002. Planning Division JAN 15 1998 Oroville, California Stovall Loan Review LCR •Page 2 Recommended By: Je an LOAN CONMTTEE NJ I Approve ❑ D ®' Approve ❑ Deny 46 14-11-17 Date t-\�,A,:K Date .Z--.,141 1? 2 � Date ❑ Approve ❑ Deny / 3- — / a — 9-7 Ward Connerly Date 0 0 RECORDING-AEOU'eSTED BY c AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO NameF County of Butte. -Street Central Collections- Atldress 25 County Center Drive State Oroville, California 95965 Order No. Escrow No. SHORT FORM DEED OF TRUST AND ASSIGNMENT OF RENTS ��-31968 89-032988 R e c Fee . UU Total .00 Recorded Official Records County of ' Butte BUTTE COUNTY TITLE CO. Candace J. Grubbs Recorder 8:00am 31 -Aug -89 RB 2 SPACE ABOVE THIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE TF11S DEED OF TRUST, made.this 23rd day of Atigust .19 89 between Equilla Stovall, a widow herein called TRUSTOR whose address is 3041 Oro Bangor Highway, Oroville, California 95966 (number and street) (city) (state) . (zip) Butte County Title. Company, a corporation, herein called TRUSTEE, and County -of Butte , herein called BENEFICIARY, Witnesseth: That Trustor IRREVOCABLY GRANTS, TRANSFF_f1S AND ASSIGNS to TRUSTEE IN TRUST, WITH POWER OF SALE, that property in Butte County, California, described as: SEE EXHIBIT "A" ATTACHED HERETO Should Trustor sell, convey, transfer, or dispose of said property, or any part thereof, or any interest therein, or agree to do so without.the- written consent of Beneficiary being first obtained or up6n the Death of Trustor, herein, then Beneficiary shall have the right at his option; to declare all sums secured hereby forthwith due and payable. TOGETHER WITH the rents, issues and profits thereof, SUBJECT, HOWEVER, to the right, power and authority given to and conferred upon Beneficiary by paragraph (10) of the provisions incorporated herein by reference to collect and apply such rents, issues and profits. For the Purpose of Securing: 1. Performance of each agreement of Trustor incorporated by reference or contained herein. 2. Payment of the indebtedness evidenced'by one promissory note of even date herewith, sand any extension or renewal thereof, in the principal sum of $ 15,000.00 -- executed by Trustor in favor of Beneficiary or order. 3. Payment of such further SLtrns as the then record owner of said property hereafter may borrow from Beneficiary, when evidenced by another note (or notes) reciting it is so secured. To Protect the Security of This Deed of Trust, Trustor Agrees: By the execution and delivery of this Deers of Trust and the note secured hereby, that provisions (1) to (14), inclusive, of the fictitious deed of trust recorded in Santa Barbara County and Sonoma County October 18, 1961, and in all other counties October 23, 1961, in the book arid at the page of Official Records in the office of the county recorder of the county where said property is located, noted.below opposite the name of such county, viz: COUNTY BOOK PAGE COUNTY BOOK PAGE COUNTY BOOK PAGE COUNTY BOOK PAGE Alarneds 435 684 Kings 792 633 Placer 895 301 Sierra 29 335 Alpine 1 250 Lake 362 39 Plumas 151 5 Slsklyou 469 181 Amador 104 348 Lassen 171 471 Riverside 3005 523 Solano 1105 182 Butte 1145 1 Los Angeles T2055 899 Sacramento 4331 62 Sonoma 1851 689 Calaveras 145 152 Madera 810 170 San Benito 271 383 Stanislaus 1715 456 Colusa 296 617 Marin 1508 339 San Bernardino 5567 61 Sulter 572 297 Contra Costa 3978 47 Marlposa 77 292 San Francisco A332 905 Tehama 401 289 Del Norte 78 414 Mendocino 579 530 San Joaquin 2470 311 Trinily 93 366 EI Dorado 568 456 Merced 1547 538 San Luls Obispo 1151 12 Tulare 2294 275 Fresno 4626 572 Modoc 184 851 San Mateo 4078 420 Toulumne 135 47 Glenn 422 184' Mono 52 429 Santa Barbara 1878 860 Ventura 2062 386 Humboldt 657 527 Monterey 2194 538 Santa Clara 5336 341 Y01(7 653 245 Imperial 1091 501 Napa 639 86 Santa Cruz 1431 494 Yuba 334 486 Inyo 147 598 Nevada 305 320 Shasta 684 528 Kern 3427 80 Orange 5889 611 San Diego Series 2 Book 1961, Paqe 103807 (which provisions, identical in all counties, are printed on the reverse hereof) hereby are adopted anri incnrpointild hr!lein anis made a part hereof as fully as though set forth herein at length: that he will observe arid perform said pu)vlsions: and Thal the references to property, obligations, and parties in said provisions shall be construed to refer to the prope.rty, obligations, and parties set forth in this Deed of Trust. The undersigned Trustor requests that a copy of any Notice of Default and any Notice of Sale hereunder he mailers to hind at his address hereinbefore set forth. (Individual Acknowledgment) SIAIE OF CALIFORNIA Cuurrlyor _ _7�___ Butter ---- On This 2 3 ru _day of _..ALLg11S. t_.— . in the year 19&C)- helote me, the undersigned. a Notary Public in and for said County and State. personally appeared _._._. A'agiL 1 Ia�t.Q�La1 i---• — — personally known to me (ur proved to me, on the hasis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person _— whose nnme _._—_—_—_ _._—._ _—__.—__subscribed to this inslrumenl and acknowledged that __—__Se___.___. __..__...._____ executed it. WI I NESS my hand and ollicia'l`seeaal. J r hlr•f7uy f uhlic in and for said.dounty and Stale. Pamela.J. Eutsler 'i Sign lore C!! "I'ruslnr f I.� Equilla Stovall ' NOTARY PU^I_tC-CALN=Ci NIA Bf ~� My l3utta County 7 1991 1:31® M Commissici Expires Sept. El (Notary Seal) DO NOT RECORD �. The following is a copy of provision to (14), irlclu sive, of the tic titioas deed of trust, r.ec in each county in Call orrtia, as stated in the foregoing Deed of Trust and incorporated by reference in said Deed of Trust as being a part. thereof as set forth at length therein. To Protect the Security of This Deed of Trust, Trustor Agrees: (1) To keep said property in good condition and repair, not to remove or demolish any building thereon; t0 Complete Or re3[O/r promptly and . in good and workmanlike manner any building which relay be constructed, damaged or destroyed thereon and to pay when due all claims for labor per. formed and materials furnished therefor, to comply with all laws affecting said property or requiring any alterations or improvements to be made thereon, not to commit or permit waste thereof, real to comit, suffer or permit any act upon said property in violation of law, to cultivate, irrigate. fertilize, fumigate, prune and do all other acts which It on, the character or use of said property relay be reasonably necessary, the sper.Jic enumera. m tions herein not excluding the general. (2) To provide, inainlaln and deliver. to Bwteliclary fire.. insurarrn:r satisfactory to anal with loss Irtyable to Beneficiary. The amount collected under any fire or other insurance -policy may he applied by Benr.lieiarV upi)n ouJr.b lrtlness'seCurCtl her,!bV anet u, setch artier is Beneficiary',toy deter retiree., Ur at oPlion of Benelicirity the ¢retire arnUulet'so cullecle,d or an•: past thereof may be released to T rustor. Such apilheation Or release shall "Of cure or waive any default or notice of rlelault hereunder or invalidate. any act done pursuant to such notice. (3) To appear in and defend any action or proceeding Purporting to affect the security hereof or the rights or powers of Beneficiary or Trustee. and to pay all costs arid expenses. Including cost at evidence of title and attorney's lees in a reasonable s+, in any such action of proccedir+q in which Beneficiary or Trustee may appear, and in any suit brought by Beneficiary to foreclose this Deet. (4) To pay' at least ten days before delrttttuency all taxes anti assessments affecting said property. Inducting assessments orf al+puf ulnont water stock, when due, all incurnbrances, charoes and lifers. with Interest, u,, said Property u, ant, Pa, 1 r.l+eieuf, which appear to be prior or sp Prrew Ilelrlo, all costs, fees and expenses of this Trust_ Should Trustor fail to make annn y pav,el or to do any act as herein provided, then Bei�liciary or T,Llstee, but without pill ylnttun So to do and without notice 10 Or demand upon Trustor and without releasing Trustor horn any obhrlalion hereof, neav snake or ill.) the same a, such neannn,, and In such extent as either may ,leen+ necessary to Protect the secul fly hereof,Beneficiary Ur 'Trustee! being authorized t0 enter allot, sold prOPe,ty for sucl, purposes. appear in and defend any action or Proceeding purporting to affect the security hereuf or the rights or powers 01 Beneficiary ar Trustee„ nay, purchase, coolest or compromise any incu,cebrance., charge or lien which in the Iutlg,Ieell of either almears to be. Prior or see PnrrOr hm C1o, and, ret exercising ally such Powers, pay necessary exoet,ses el"Ploy counsel arid pay his reasonable II`rs. 1!i1 'To Pay ung, ediately ami .vilho,it denial -0 all sums SO expanded by Benehc;ary Or l'rushlr„ write V te.,est feu,,, Jou• of ex Poodilu,e al the amount allowed by law in effect at the date, hnrecf, alert to pay for any statement provided foe by law ire effect at the date hereof regard trig life oUllga tion secureei hereby any amount den+anded by the Beneliclary not to exceed the rt,axlrrtunl alla.ved by la•vv ;,it the unle when sit;,) slalcrrle,ot Is denta lded. (G) That any award of damages In conr,eetlOrl ,villi any tc .!emnationfor Public use of m u,)u.'V to sold property Or ally pall thereof ,s henlUy asslgneti and shall be paid to Beneficiary who relay al)PIY or release sack ntU�eys rPtetverl by lion in the same roan her oriel with ilii, serener (Ifire, as above love for disposition of proceeds Of fire or attic, enswal,ce. 17) )'hat by accepting Payment Of ally sam securer hereby after its clue (late. [nlr,,PI,ciary does nal clave! Ilis right either to r ,Ire re Pr nr,.let paY leee ret when due of all other sums so secreted ur to eillclare default to, failure so to pay. (8) That at an y time or born tinh tinge to Un,r., wllout liabilityand there!or wethrt otnotice,nalert report written request of Beeliciary al presentation oftills Deed and said note for endorsement, and -, Illout affecting the personal liahility of any person for payment at the inttebt¢tfness secured hereby, Trustee relay: reconveY any port of said property. consent to thn e! making of any ,aP or plat thereof. Iola ie., granting any easen,e,+t Ihernon. or loin ie.+ any ex tension agreement or any agreement subordinating lire lien or charge hereof. (9) That upon written request of Beneficiary stating that all seer's secured hereby have been Paid, and upon surrender of tiles Deed and said note to Trustee for cancellation and retention and upon payrrlent of its lees, Trustee shall reconvev. vvilhout warranty. tale properly tile,, held hereunder. ,rhe recitals in such reconveyance of any matters or facts strait be conclusive proof Of til¢ tiud,fulness thereof. The grantee u, such feconvoyareee may he described as "the person or persons legally entilled thereto.- Five years after issuance of such lull teconve-yance. Trustee rnnV destroy said rote and tills Deed (unless directed In such request tb resin therm. (10) That as additional security. Trustor hereby gives to and confers upon 13eneflc1a1y the right• flower ami a.AtIlority. luting the continuance, of these Trusts, to collect the rents, issues and profits of said property. reserving unto Truslor the right, miu, to atry default fry 1 r,.tstor in payment of any in deb led tress secured hereby ler fee perinntlancr of any agree"10w hereunder, to collect ill,-] -UO,, stn:h relies, issues anti Prones as they beron,e due ;tire) payable. Un 011 Orly such default, Beneficfaty Wray at any time without notice! dither ,n person. by a9rnt. Or by a receiver to be., appointed by a court, and without regard to the aderluacy of arty serurily for the indebtedness hereby secured, enter upon and take possession of said properly or any Part thereat, in his own name sue for or otherwise collect such rents, Issues and profits, eodurhng those Hast clue and InePairl, and apply tire carne, less costs and expenses of operation and colleclforl, Including reasonable attorney's fens, upon any indebtedness secured hereby, and in such order as Bene, liciary may determine. The entering upon arid taking Possession of said property, the colla<:UUP of such rents, Issues and ProLts and ilii aPPlrcatron thereof as aforesaid, shall not cute or waive. any default or notice of default hPfeunder ere tr,vandale any act ,folie. Pursuant to such notice. ( 11 ) That upon default by Trustor u+ paymrlel Of any indebtedness secured hereby of n, prrlorfetaflee of any agreement hereunder, Ber+eliclarY relay declare all sums secured hereby immediately title and payable by Orlivery to Tntsten of wrille,e drelar alio' of default and demand for sale anti Of written notice of default and OI el Pcttan to cause to be sold said property, which notice Truster shall rause, to he, hied lot record. Benrleciary also shall deposit with Trustee this Deed, said nate arid all r.locun,Pnts evidencing expenditures secured I+rfn.by. After the lapse of such time as may then he rogvirerf by law following tile. recordation of San.l notice. Of Jelault, and notice of sale having been given as then required by law. Trustee, without dmnaelJ or, l'rtlstor, shall sell said P,o1wrfy at the tune and place fixed bV it in saw notir,e of sale, either e.% a whole or in separate parcels, and in such Ordef as it may deterin nal, al public apclion IV the h4h ¢st hrUdrr lar cash en lawlul money of The United ";I:rles, Ilayable a1 little Of sale. Trustee may paslPant• Sale (.II all or any PorliOn Of Said pt OI,CItY ily palrllc .Im,OU flretl,Pr+i at Stich IIP,¢ oriel PLIC¢ of sale, and Iron+ tune to Lillie thereafter may Postrio,',¢ such sale by puhln; oriel Otu+r.e r,+ Pill at the n,,,r lexe,l by the, preceding postponement Trustee shall r¢cltals u, Such decd deliver to such Pc•,chaser its deed conveying the, llrone,tV see sold, but wrlhoul any covert:pl; or e•: arrnn lye express or irr+plied. '1 lie of any ,natters or laces shall be conelt,sive. Drool Of the, irull+lellnP,ss thereof. Ally Persofe, including TRlstot• Truster, or Beneticiary as hereinafter de fined may purchase at such sale. After deducting all costs, fees and expenses of Trllslee arid of lhis Trust, eneludir+g cast r+f ecnte.nr.e of title, ie.+ connection with sale. Trustee, shall apply the pfoceprls of sale to payment of: all sums r-xprleded antler the. wrel,s hereol, not Ihen eePrnd, :^nth accrlrrd Interest at the amount allowed by law in effect at the date hrreol, all other sums tile,, secured hereby. and the ren,oe der. ,1 any, to til,! IIP,sOt, Or persons legally entitled thereto. (12) Beneliciary, or any successor in ownership of any indehtetlness secreted Hereby, relay Iron^ lune it) little, by u,strufet en ,, wri Ung, substitute a successor or successors to any Trustee named herertl or acting hereunder. which a+stmn,¢n t, e.x r.,,:Mets by the! Beneficiary and duly alk nuwled geed and recorded in the office of the fecorder of the county or counties where sold propeauldl tV Is S,Lu, sleatl be conclusive proof of pf aper suhslrW trop of such successor Trustee Or Trrestees, who shall, with Ont conveyance tronr file 'r n,<n!P predetesso,, Succeed to ail its title, estate, rights, nmeels and duties. Said instrument must conlafri the name of the- o,igr„ill Truster, Tn Swc tired 0eneficia,V hereunder, the book need page ,vhere this Deed is recorder) erect the none and address of the new Trustee. (13) That this Deed applies to, inures to the. benefit of, filed binds all l,ae 11e.s he.,clo. tile,, he!"S, legatees, devisers, JdI,+I„snalars, exer.,,tors, Sell: cr-ssors need assigns. 1 he letter Belief ir,Iary sit-ill,,call tire uwocr and holder. Int iti iintl PIe,J!lces, 01 the flute SOCured herrh Y. whrlhrr or 11131 oa,nrd as It¢t,clfciary herein, In this Deed, whenever lire context so teeluires, the n+ascu line gender rnclu ries the.. Ien„)rr it. and/or neuter. anti the su,yu l:.. r„tt'ber includes the plural. (14) That Trustee accepts tills Trust when this Dend, duly rx,lcuted and acknuvvledged. IS 'Ila ill. a public rf!corrt as PI Ovitlerl try law. Titlstet! is litit ohligattld to notify any party hpreta Of pendinq sale! un(rf rely other Deed ell Trust m ui airy 'clear' rn P!o,:cedu+g rel which V.t.slot, [iln,eli:ialy n, Trustee shall bP a party unless brought by l'll,st¢e. DO NUI Ktl;L)KU REQUEST FOWFULL RECONVEYANCE To be userl only when /tote his been Pdirl- To Butte County Title Insurance Company, Trustee: Dated The undersigned is the legal owner and holder of all inde-WI IlMSS SCILWIll bV lilt, within Deed of Trust. All sums secured by said Deed of )lust have been fully Pai[I and S2111SfICd; alld you are hereby requested and directed, un Payment :o Volt of any sums owinq to you under the teens of sair.l Deer) of TI ust, to Cance' 'I evidences of indebtedness, securer) by said Deed of TI use, (leliv- t'red to you herelvilh together With said Deed of Trust, and to Ieconvey, evitduiut willranty', to the parties desiiplau!rd by tilt' terms of said Deere of Trust, the estate now held by yciu under the same. MAIL. RECONVEYANC•C TO: V _ _ Do not lose of tL!slrlly Iltis Doed of Trust OR THE NOTE which it secures. Both 'lust he. delivered to the Truslee fur c;lncellation h0011! lecrnlVCyance will be made. Qri {s..+nl -Fa .r+a Z O LL 0 Z Lu Q U C/) FSI P9-329$ EXHIBIT "A" PARCEL ONE: A portion of Lot 3, Block 18, as shown on�that certain map enti tled, ""MAP OF VILLA VERONA, BUTTE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA", which map was filed in the office of the Recorder .of the County of. Butte, State of California, January 17, 1889, more particularly, described as follows: Beginning at a point in West- line of Lot 3, from which point the southwest'corne.r of said Lot 3 bears South 0° 04' East, 193.5063 feet distant; thence zi.l_ong said West line, North 0° 04' West, feet; thence leaving said West line, North 78° 34' East a distance of 140 feet; thence South 0° 04' East, 63.0 feet; thence South 78° 34' West, 140.00 feet, more or less, to the point of beginning. PARCEL TWO: A portion of Lot 3, . 13.l.ock 18, as shown on that certain map entitled, "MAP OF VILLA VERONA, BUTTE COUNTY,. CALIFORNIA", which map was filed in the of -f -ice of the Recorder of the County of Butte, State of California, January 17, 1889, more particularly described as fol:f-l'o`ws.; West line o£ Lot 3 from which point Beginning at a point :in the the Southwest 'corner of: said Lot 3 bears South 0° 04' East, 148.50 feet distant; thence along said West line North 0° 04' West, 45 feet to the SoutliwesL corner of that certain parcel of land described in Deed from John'Curry, et ux, to Walter J. Stovall, et ux, dated November 1, 1965 and recorded November 10, 1965 in Book 1399 of Of-fici.al. Records, at page 312, records of Butte County, Cal.iforni.z, thence along the Southerly line of said Stovall par- cel., North 7E3° 34' last, 140 feet to the Southeast corner of said Stovall parcel; tlience South 350 20' 45" West 35.0 feet;. thence South G9° 17'7.9" West-, 125 feet to the point of beginning. END OF DODUMENr 1 � • R CALIFORNIA ALL-PURPOSE ACKNOWLEDGMENT State of California ss. County of, On personally appeared i - before me, iCQ } VVI f r�fr -V-d' /U'�rtK f I Lkfrc Name and TNe of Officer (e.g., 'Jane oe, Notary Public ') ALICE ANN MEFFORD Commission # 1365836 Z Notary Public - Califomia z Buds County My Comm. Expires Jul 22, 2006 OPTIONAL Name(s) of Signer(s) &ersonally known to me ❑ proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence � to be the person(ef whose name(ar is/ar subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that helshe/theI r executed the same in hislher/their✓ authorized. capacityi;,i�s�, and that by higher/their signature(,s�on the instrument the person(a)s or the entity upon behalf of which the person4,ar acted, executed the instrument. WI NESS my h d and official seal. ignature of Notary i Though the information below is not required by law, it may prove valuable to persons relying on the document and could prevent fraudulent removal and reattachment of this form to another document. )esZ� tion of Attached Document Title or Type o current: _ Document Date: Signer(s) Other Than Named Capacity(ies) Claimed by Sig Signer's Name: ❑ Individual ❑ Corporate Off' r — Title(s): ❑ Partner Limited ❑ General ❑ Attor, in -Fact ❑ Tr tee ❑ ardian or Conservator ❑ Other: Signer Is Representing: Number of Pages: ® 1999 National Notary Association • 9350 De Soto Ave.. P.O. Box 2402 • Chatsworth, CA 913132402 • www.nationafnotary.org Prod. No. 5907 Reorder. Call Toll -Free 1-80D-876-6827 i .`t .y - After Recording return to: County of Butte Central Collections 25'County Center Drive Oroville, California 95965 31256 pc 90-006905 1 R e c Fee .00 1 Total .00 Recorded ; Official Records County 'of ; Butte ; Candace J. Grubbs Recorder ; 8:00am 22 -Feb -90 1 CD 2 NOTICE Or ADDITIONAL, LOAN UNDER DECD 017- 'TRUST NOTICE IS IICRIIIY GIVEN by the Undersicjned ( EQUILLA STOVALL, a widow trustors ca.l l ed Crus tors , that they have received a loan from COUNTY OF BUTTE herein called beneficiary, in the sum of -beneficiary $ TWENTY TWO THOUSAND and no/100******do I I ars, and that, as evidence thereof, said trustors have executed and delivered to said beneficiary a promissory dote for said sum, bearing date of February 20, 1990 NOTICE IS ALSO UCREI3Y GIVEN that the indebtedness evidenced by said promissory note is a loan of an additional sum by said beneficiary to said trustors, which the deed of trust, hereinafter described, provides shall be secured thereby, and that the payment of said indebtedness is secured by said deed of trust, which:was executed by said trustors, as trustors, and which conveyed certain real property described therein to ( BUTTE COUNTY TITLE COMPANY, ) a corporation., trustee as trustee for said beneficiary, and which deed of trust was recorded in the office of the County Recorder of the County of Butte State of California, on the 31th day of August 1989 in Book Serial No. 89-32988 it 11 of Official Records at page DATCD: February 20, 1`)90 EU la Stovall J,P t 0 [.� �4 C—' DO (Acknowledgement) STATE OF CALI#NIA ) . SS. County of BU ) On this�1— day of FPbntary in the year 19 90 before me, M0ni ca Brodenwig a Notary Public in and for the said County and Stale, residing therein, duly commissioned and sworn, personally appeared uilla Stovall personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(s): is subscribed to this instrument, and acknowledged INDIVIDUAL) Whose name that he (she or they) executed It. (0 CORPORATION) Who executed the within instrument as president and secretary, on behalf of the corporation therein named, and acknowledged to me that such corporation executed the within instrument pursuant to its articles and by-laws and a resolution of its Board of Directors. ((] PARTNERSHIP) That executed the within instrument on behalf of the part- ' to me that the partnership executed it. IN WITNESS WHEREOF. nership, and acknowledged I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my official seal, in and for said County and State, the year first above written Oaooatttaoaaaooutasas�a� ~ • 1TARYIK BiiG s . J -���� o • �� NOTARB Fl�� i Notary Publ c in and for said County and Slate of Calvornta rr��ttyy � . ' ►ea My commission. expires: 10/18/91 n Aiyf,otCLis.1901 o Oct. 18,1$1 i �atitp®aaaaeteoaaosmotsoo�® FD -1B EN® OF DOCUMENT O{111CIAMIT IIILCUV101I' A11 AFTER RECORDING RETURN TO: • County of Butte Central Collections 25 County Center Drive Oroville, California 95965 90-017438 ; R e c Fee .00 Total .00 Recorded Official Records County of Butte Candace J. Grubbs Recorder 8:O0am 1 -May -90 ; CD 3 GRANT AGREEMENT BUTTE COUNTY NOME REPAIR PROGRAM EquiIIa Stovall , hereinafter referred to as Grantee, owner(s) of that certain proper[y aescri ed as follows: Parcel One and Two A portion of Lot 3., Block 18, as shown on that certain map entitled, "MAP OF VILLA VERONA, BUTTE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA", which map -was filed in the office of .the Recorder of the County of Butte, particularly described as follows: State of California, January 17, 1889, more Begi nni ng at a• poi nt i n West 1 i ne of Lot 3, from whi ch poi nt the southwest corner of said Lot 3 bears South 0' 04' East, .193.50 feet distant; thence along said West line, North 0'-04' West, 63 feet; thence leaving said West line, North 78'34' East a distance of 140 feet; thence South 0' 04' East, 63.0 feet; thence south 78" 34' West, 140.0 feet, more or less, to the point of beginning, and Beginning at a point in the West line of Lot 3 from which point the Southwest corner of said Lot .3 bears South 0.04' Cast, 148.50 feet distant; thence along said West line -North 0°04' West 45 feet to the Southwest corner of' that certain parcel Of land described i.n Deed. from John Curry,: et ux, to Walter J. Stovall, et ux, dated November 1, 1965 and recorded November 10,• 1965 in Book 1399 of Official Records, at page 312, records of Butte County California, thence along the Southerly line of said Stovall parcel, North 7834' East, 140 feet to the Southeast corner of said Stovall parcel; thence South 35'20' 45" West 35.0 feet; thence South E9017129" West, 125 feet to'the point of beginning; hereby acknowledges a grant of $ 8,500;00 made by the County of Butte for the rehabilitation of the residential structure on the described property, subject to the following condition: The Grantee shall not be required to repay any of the funds granted, provided, however, that if the Grantee sells or transfers title to the property to another party, unless transfer of title is due to death of the Grantee, prior to the date that the grant is fully forgiven, the County shall have the right to recapture the unforgiven portion of the grant. The amount of the grant subject to recapture shall be the full amount for the first year. After each year the amount subject to recapture shall be reduced by $1,500.00, unti•1 such time as the total amount of the grant is fully forgfven. re amount of the grant shall be less any funds returned to the County of Butte from the escrow. -z- • go -11438 The Grantee agrees that the grant shall be a lien against the property until such time that the amount of the grant is fully forgiven and that the Grantee shall repay to the County the unforgiven balance subject to recapture immediately upon sale or transfer of the property. Signed this date, April 30 199 0 by; qui . a StoVall Grantee acknowledges that the County of Butte is advancing funds to insure the completion of work to be performed by MOWACO Construction. Any proceeds resulting from claims.against MOWACO shall be assigned by Grantee to the County of Butte. DUE ON SALE CLAUSE Should Trustor sell, convey, transfer, or dispose of said property, .or any part thereof, or any interest therein, or agree to do so without the written consent of Beneficiary being first obtained or upon the Death o *f Trustors, herein, then Beneficiary shall have the right at his option, to declare all sums secured hereby forthwith due and payable. A portion of the amount secured by this Deed of Trust may be subject to a Grant Agreement in which case.the above applies with the exception that upon the Death of the Trustors, the unforgiven portion of the grant shall not be due and payable. dtJova I . Date Trustor bate t J 2�z J 9- 1438 -z- 4 The Grantee agrees that the grant shall be a lien against the property until such time that the amount of the grant is fully forgiven and that the. Grantee shall, repay to the County the unforgiven balance subject to recapture immediately upon sale or transfer of the property. Signed this, date, April 30 _ _ _ 199 0 by: v � ..Eq ao a Grantee acknowledges that the County of Butte is advancing funds to insure the completion of work to be performed'by MOWACO Construction. Any proceeds resulting from claims against MOWACO shall be assigned by Grantee to the County of Butte. DUE ON SALE CLAUSE PJ Should Trustor sell, convey, transfer, or dispose of said property, or any part thereof, or any interest therein, or Agree to do so without the written consent of BeneficiAry hPinn first AF, taincrl n+� i:nnn +I1- t, -.r T..;.,..L_.__--.._..._ .,. 90�.� 1438 3 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) (Acknowledgement) ss. County of Butte ) On this 30th day of April in the year 19 90 , before me, Pamela J. E itsler a Notary Public in and for the said County and State, residing therein, duly commissioned and sworn, personally appeared Equilla Stovall personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(s): (� INDIVIDUAL) Whose name is subscribed to this instrument, and acknowledged that he (she or they) executed it. (❑ CORPORATION) Who executed the within instrument as -president and secretary, on behalf of the corporation therein named, and acknowledged to me that such corporation executed the within instrument pursuant to its articles and by-laws and a resolution of its Board of Directors. (❑ PARTNERSHIP) That .executed the within instrument on behalf of the part- nership, and acknowledged to me that the partnership executed it. ITNESS WHEREOF, t have hereunto set my hand and affixed my official seal, in and for said County and State, ay and yeaPiF b v ritten.is 0 �� . ;P`;':; PA";"ELA J.U7SLE Notary Public in a for said County and State of California. '�.. _ My commission expires: �,� �,., NOTARY PUBLIC.C, ,LIFORNIA N ® Guttc c*un.j Is FD -1 B ® 01 ComrMssion Expires Sept. 7, Fit ( ) Since your ..income exceeds the amoi have a share of cost to pay or obl; share of cost is $ b� of cost was computed as follows: Month 1 Gross Income $ Net nonexempt income $ Maintenance need $ Excess income $ Share of cost $ [] Enclosed is a RECORD OF HEALTH CA] follow the instructions on the i medical, expenses exceed your sha coverage Medi -Cal card will be is completed and approved. MC239Q 9/88 �36-a21-44 Permit#2342-89B,P(remodel) see ltr 4/26/8(' 6 'N L) i, C� CA COUNTY OF BUTTE - DEPARTMENT- OF PUBLIC WORKS • r 7'County Center Drive - O'rovi116, 6aI!fornia 95965 - Telephone: 916/538-7541 APPLICATION AND PERMIT - P RMIT NO. ASSESSOR P� &EL NUMBER �L �'J(n ZONING BUILDING PERMIT OWNER /J �1 J (� TELEPHONE S3 SQ. FT. OCC, BUILDING VALUATION a , v-� OWN S MAILING ADDRESS �s�,il>r qsfss CONTRACTOR'S NAME • VV- -, TEL PHONE , CONTRACTOR'S MAILING ADDRESS Fireplace CONSTRUCTION LENDER UNKNOWN Total Valuation 1 $ d0d Filing Fee $ 10,00 LENDER'S MAILING ADDRESS Permit Fee $ ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER LICENSE NO. Plan Checking Fee $ Zr Energy Plan Checking Fee $ ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER'S MAILING ADDRESS Penalty $ BUILDING ADDRESS p� Permit fee $ Q Z PLUMBING PERMIT Filing Fee 10.00 Each Trap 2.00 Z_ fo Solar or heat pump water heater 20.00 LOT NO. SUBDIVISION NAME PARCEL MAP Water piping 5.00 _00 Each gas water heater or vent 5.00 _ O USE OF STRUCTURE SF Duplex❑ Mobilehome❑ Other SPECIFY Gas piping system 1 - 5 outlets 5.00 4-_00 Building sewer 5.00 CC Ina Mobile Home I S I G I W 0.00ea TYPE F WORK New ❑ Addition El Remodel Utilities ❑ Installation❑ /Other ❑ Describe work: /1E=�l�G - .o AAy Permit Fee $ 3100 Contractor ELECTRICAL PERMIT Filing Fee 10.00 Main service (50" OR LESS 100 OR OR LESS 10.00 Main service EA. ADD'L 100 AMP 2.50 CONTRACTORS LICENSE LAW I declare under penalty of perjury (check one): ❑ I am licensed under provisions of Chapt. 9, Div. 3 of the Business and Professions Code and my license is in full force and effect. License No. Classification I, as the owner, or my employees with wages as their sole compen- sation, will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for sale. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I, as the owner, am exclusively contracting with licensed contract- ors. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I am exempt under Sec. , Business and Professions Code for this reason NEW CONST. DWELLING OCCUP.a OR ADDNS. ACC. SLOGS. , /20sgft NEW CONSTFMULTI-OUTLET 2,50 ea NON.RESID BRANCH CIRC ITS PO ER APPARATUS e OUTLET CIR. _(SINGLE O Ex. ccu Ep(OUTLETS OR FIXTURES 20a50tBALI 30 FIXED ALNS. EX. Occup. -OUTLETS P(RESID )REAJ 2.00 Temporary service 10.00 Mobile Home Facilities 15.00 Misc. Wiring 15.00 9 Permit Fee $ Contractor WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE I declare under penalty of perjury (check one): ❑ The permit is for $100.00 (valuation) or less. ❑ 1 have placed on file with the County of Butte Building Department a Certificate of Workmen's Compensation Insurance or a Certificate of Consent to Self -insure. I shall not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the W. C. laws of California. Notice to Applicant: If after making this statement,. should you become subject to the W. C. provisions of the Labor Code, you must forthwith comply with such provisions or this permit shall be deemed revoked. MECHANICAL PERMIT FiIingFee 10.00 Heating Cooling Hood 3.00 Ventilation permit Fee $ Contractor I certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct. I agree to comply to all County Ordinances and State Laws relating to building construction, and hereby authorize representatives of the Countyot Butte to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. 1 also agree to save, indemnify and keep harmless the County of Butte against all liabilities, judgments, costs, and expenses which may in any way accrue agai t said Cou t in co a nce of t anting of this pe - X JW—L Date Signatur of Applicant — Owner❑ Contractor ❑ Agent ❑ An OSHA permit is required for excavations over 5'0" deep and demolition or construct- ion of structures over 3 st ries in height. Mobile Home Installation Fee $ Energy Inspection Fee $ TOTAL PERMIT FEE $ Occup. CONST.TVPEJ SCHOOL FLOOD PARCEL P11 I NO I ISSOE This permit is hereby issued under sions of the Butte County Code and/or work indicated above for which DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC BY PERMIT EXPIRES Date the applicable provi- resolutions to do fees have been paid. WORKS Date ILPIA Receipt No. WHITE-D.P.W.. TELLOW-ASSE330R, PINK -INSPECTOR, GOLDENROD -APPLICANT AL COUNTY OF BUTTE - DEPAR7"EXT UBLIC WORKS - BUILDING DIVISION 7 COUNTY�CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE CALIFORNIA 95965 - TELEPHONE: 91 538-7541 PERMIT APPLICATION DATA SHEET ' Permit No. OWNER L 0lvI- L A. P. No. �Z Proposed Building Use Building Inspector Date At time of permit application, I was advised the following data must be submitted prior to permit processing and/or issuance: DATE RECEIVED APPROVED All items have been submitted . .................................... Plot plans in duplicate/triplicate, signed by preparer of plans........ Complete plans in duplicate/triplicate, signed by preparer of plans . . 4. Complete engineered plans and calcs, with wet signature on plans .. 5. Energy Design Compliance and supporting documentation ......... 6. Statement of Intent for Non -Heated and AC Buildings .............. 7. Engineered truss details and layout in duplicate (required prior to plan check) 8. Mobilehome installation data including manufacturer's installation instructions....................................................... 9. Fees of $ .......................... 10. Chico Urban Area fees paid ........................................ 11. Park fees paid ..................................................... 12. School District fees paid ................. 13. ;.Sanitation approval from Health Department ... 14. City of Chico plumbing permit ...................................... 15. Plot plan and business license approval from City of (see City for other requirements) 16. Planning approval for (A) Use: (B) Parking: ......... 17. Improvements may be required. 18. Driveway permit (construction approval required prior to occupancy) ... 19. Pre -Ins ection for re ulred .. , , Pre-Insperequest to p q � Building Inspector (Date) 20. Contractor's license information (No., Name Style, Classification) ..... 1. Certificate Of Workmans Compensation Insurance ..C��.�.�.. j9at►�?.. %u 2. Owner -Builder Verification (Given to owner V, Mail to owner ❑) .......t� ` 2 Recorded copy of Agricultural Acknowledgment Statement ............ _ 5>4 Letter r) signature authorization ................ . When you issue the permit, process as follows: Mail to owner. Mail to contractor. Telephone _ and hold for pickup office. Deliver w/inspector. Other Applicant .. Copy of plans sent Health Dept., Fire Dept., Other Date The following data must be submitted prior to permit issu 1. Index permit for above items No. Z } ', --VL 2. Additional items required: 61L't - L44,,: 2 Date (Circle new item not checked above). Contractor, designer owner as advised of above required data by_phone_-nail counter by ��date Contractor, designer, owner, was advised of above required data by—phone —mal l—counter by date Plans checked by Date Plans approved by Date Sets of plans on hold in Copy—DPW File cabinet AP folder I COUNTY OF BUTTE - De'partmdnt of Public Works 7 County Center Drive, Oroville, CA 9596.5 Phone: 916-538-7541 OWNER -BUILDER VERIFICATION Attention Property Owner: An 'owner -builder" building permit has been applied for in your name and bearing your signature. Please'.c6mplete and return this information at your earliest opportunity to avoid unnecessary delay in processing and issuing your building permit. No .building permit will be issued until this verification is received. 1. I personally plan to provide the major labor and materials for constr.uction of the proposed property improvement (yes or no) 2. I (have/ ave not) signed an application for a building permit for a proposed work. 3. I have contracted.with the following person (firm) to provide the proposed construction: Name a (o Address City e2� Phone tq-z, 9, 1 6g Contractors License No. v, c, 4. I plan to provide portions of this work, but I have hired the following person to coordinate, supervise, and provide the major work: Name Address City Phone Contractors License No. 5. I will provide some of the work but I have contracted (hired) the following persons to provide the work indicated: Name Address . Phone Type of Work Signed: , Property Owner Social Security Nu er Date NOTE: This Owner -Builder Verification is sent to you as required.by Sections 19831 and 19832 of the California Health and.Safety Code. This verification must be completed and returned to our office before we are per- mitted to issue the permit. � . LIFE INSURANCE _ [ , � .� � ' EQUILLA 5041 ORO BANGOR HWY OROVILLE CA 95966-6234 NOVEMBER 29, 1989 FIRE POLICY STATUS H PH. ( )533-9171 POLICY NO: 95—C9-0420-2 F YR ISSUED: 89 / PROP 42000 TERM: CONT AMOUNT DUE: MPP TYPE: USE RENEW DATE: AUG -01190 DATE DUE: MPP pREMIUM: 2 BILL TO: MPP . COVERAGE INFORMATION MPP ACCT: 931779 \� DWELLING 60000 PREV. RISK:. 0 ` DWELL EXT 6000 PREV. PREM: 0 B—PERS PROP 42000 ' . DEDUCTIBLES � C—LOSS USE ACT LOSS CONST: FRAME Q MORTGAGEE ZONE: 49 J q—PERS LIAB 100000 PROT. CLASS: 5 ` DMG TO PROP 500 YR BLT: 45 M—MED/PERS 1000 FAMILIES: 01 ., `^ V .` U . � � � ` ACCOUNTING INFORMATION: CA GAR ASMT ^ o <' ^ [� 6. '+ | ` STATE FARM INSURANCE COMPANIES HOME OFFICES: BLOOMINGTON, ILLINOIS JIM HOLLRGSWORTH Agent LOUISE CRAWFORD Office Manager 197VMitchell Avenue ` Oroville; California 95966 Bus.: (916) 533-3907 2.89 FORMS AND ENDORSEMENTS FP -7193 SPECIAL FORM OPT RC REPL COST CNTS FE -7205.3 AMENDATORY END 438 LOSS PAYABLE ~ ; . DEDUCTIBLES APPLIED: 250 ALL PER b o (� MESSAGES: MORTGAGEE ` THE COUNTY OF BUTTE ,C/O CONNERLY & ASSOCIATES 2215 21ST ST � SACRAMENTO �. CA 95818-1784 ., `^ V .` U . � � � ` ACCOUNTING INFORMATION: CA GAR ASMT ^ o <' ^ [� 6. '+ | ` STATE FARM INSURANCE COMPANIES HOME OFFICES: BLOOMINGTON, ILLINOIS JIM HOLLRGSWORTH Agent LOUISE CRAWFORD Office Manager 197VMitchell Avenue ` Oroville; California 95966 Bus.: (916) 533-3907 2.89 FORMS AND ENDORSEMENTS FP -7193 SPECIAL FORM OPT RC REPL COST CNTS FE -7205.3 AMENDATORY END 438 LOSS PAYABLE conducting such operations for commercial purposes; and employees engaged in care of lawns, shrubs or grounds surrounding the residence which are maintained exclusively for appearance or recreation. S _ • The following charges apply for this 'coverage: Private Residence Mandatory - ir"Emp 1 oyees-C-1 ass i f-i-ca2-i ons!"" Additional Charge -1, ;Occasional (Code 0910) I nc 1 udedri-n-Bas.i.c-Homeowner, s Premiums In servants (Code 091-3)^�r� $170 per employee �-Outservants (Code 0912) ! $115 per employee i 34-40. RESERVED FOR FUTURE USE. State Farm Fire and Casualty Company NORTHERN CALIFORNIA State Farm General Insurance Company FPL -05.349 i. Homeowners 5/15/87 NEW NORTHERN CALIFORNIA 361 10/15/87 RENEWAL UU,& �O L CG C RAS dC�i_sC - OK i �,•�..Pc,©�, � �� c o . �t��s rJ c.cr.,.�os ,fit �z- mor L,���e t o — `' v T a� a,ST-S i (� 0 6 irt-se `9+Ko�c3 L Cz 1A-..ro I Gp,tSZTL GI-L"7L $ ; Ls + t 1..c►�r .�+ .v /J b C :ct jses i�� �3 c S ' 1�MaV cb L d �I i CREDITS, UARGES'AW OPTIONS" 33. WORKERS' COMPENSATION 3ML'eGvlsi kS j'-e��¢1.0.5 The .basic forms provide Workers' Compensation coverage for private residence employees as required by the California Workers: Compensation Law., This applies -i -Hess -pursuits coverage only to nonbusiness pursuits. Bus -such as rental property and offices in the home are not covered under this # , provision. If any_of the following classifications apply, see table below for the required charge. kl A. Occasional Private Residence Employees (Code 0910)/ ' This classification applies to each employee whose duties are incidental to the ownership, maintenance,'or use of the residence, including the performance of household domestic service and who is not included in classification 0913, "Inservants", or classification 0912, "Outservants,. I B. Inservants Private Residence Employees (Code 0913) se This classification applies to each employee engaged for not less than 1 twenty hours per week in household domestic service and whose principal duties are performed inside the private residence building. It in- cludes, but is not limited to, such employees as cooks, laundresses, maids, butlers, seamstresses, nurses, companions, governesses, baby- sitters.. and housekeepers. fj C. Outservants..Private Residence Employees (Code 0912) This classification applies to each employee engaged for not less than ten hours per week in household or domestic service in connection with a private residence and who performs his work principally outside the private residence building. It does not apply to such operations if L. the private residence is located on property used in whole or in part i� for farming or dairying. The classification includes, but is not limited to, private chauffeurs, employees engaged in cultivating flowers, } vegetables, or other agricultural products, provided the insured is not conducting such operations for commercial purposes; and employees engaged in care of lawns, shrubs or grounds surrounding the residence which are maintained exclusively for appearance or recreation. S _ • The following charges apply for this 'coverage: Private Residence Mandatory - ir"Emp 1 oyees-C-1 ass i f-i-ca2-i ons!"" Additional Charge -1, ;Occasional (Code 0910) I nc 1 udedri-n-Bas.i.c-Homeowner, s Premiums In servants (Code 091-3)^�r� $170 per employee �-Outservants (Code 0912) ! $115 per employee i 34-40. RESERVED FOR FUTURE USE. State Farm Fire and Casualty Company NORTHERN CALIFORNIA State Farm General Insurance Company FPL -05.349 i. Homeowners 5/15/87 NEW NORTHERN CALIFORNIA 361 10/15/87 RENEWAL UU,& �O L CG C RAS dC�i_sC - OK i �,•�..Pc,©�, � �� c o . �t��s rJ c.cr.,.�os ,fit �z- mor L,���e t o — `' v T a� a,ST-S i (� 0 6 irt-se `9+Ko�c3 L Cz 1A-..ro I Gp,tSZTL GI-L"7L $ ; Ls + t 1..c►�r .�+ .v /J b C :ct jses i�� �3 c S ' 1�MaV cb L d �I i Vw i It jogPWW �d e+s zeal 3;pucmsuj Apsma .. !S�� d' t�r:� AOL��� . . .. � . ---------'---'--------' ------------ ---'----- - - ' - ' ' - ' � L-� ' ---'--`--- - -~~ %Y- �w -54ayP, l( ------ 1. o- -- - ------ dffi y. - — —Jli - t4 -- -- VXT - t tA--V o � Q h t _ li 1. h -)10—. r!0 11 i E .Q X, t-( P POA- S I•. � Ib _ W- VAFe/L_-S 36" MIN. 0 m c� 71< W I -P x CA 'M.AX., . :.,. ., 6"Izi e�Q3 � 3 R r1 1 (7 03 7J o ern n 7< Q X 3 � Tom; ,....STT.._•=->-._.. , 30"- 34 7q -li 1 i �a o — . o —, Fn C--) 0 O D r Z vy. i -40 p 71 0 m c� 71< W I -P x CA 'M.AX., . :.,. ., 6"Izi e�Q3 � 3 R r1 1 (7 03 7J o ern n 7< Q X 3 � Tom; ,....STT.._•=->-._.. , 30"- 34 7q -li 1 i �a o — . o —, N 0 D r Z � i -40 p 71 7 W <cz CD 'm O m G",� ate" MIN. STAfR i o: � W I DT4 m D y .3 o 5. m y i CD CUa s- c "c o 3 NC rn r O Y X Un C) N * n O o0 : v 0 m c� 71< W I -P x CA 'M.AX., . :.,. ., 6"Izi e�Q3 � 3 R r1 1 (7 03 7J o ern n 7< Q X 3 � Tom; ,....STT.._•=->-._.. , 30"- 34 7q -li 1 i — —, N O E tm n G",� ate" MIN. STAfR n � W I DT4 c 3 Y X COUNTY OF.BUTTE - DEPAR'T'MENT OF PUBLIC WORKS 7 County Center .Drive, Oroville, CA -95965 PHONE: 916-538-7541 Equilla Stovall 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy Oroville, CA 95965 With reference to the above subject: DATE l,)/19JR9 RE. .Building.,Permit Application A.* 36-021-44 X/ Attached is: Application for permit Mobilehome Utilities Installation Sheet. Building Plans Mobilehome Installation Information Sheet Engr. Calcs X Typical Plan Sheet Owner -Builder Verification Form List of Codes Enforced OTHER LL We need the following information: Permit application signed and completed where indicated with all copies returned. Fees of $ payable to Butte County Treasurer. Certificate of Workmen's.Compensation.Insurance or check exemption statement. Contractor's License Law information or check exemption statement. Complete plans in including plot plans. Plot plans i'n Structural details in Complete plans and calcs in by registered engineer or architect. Energy. design including Street and drainage improvement plan approval from Land Development Section'(DPW). sets of plans in accordance with the changes marked in red. Sanitation approval from Butte County Health Department at: 196 Memorial Way, Chico 7,County Center Dr., Oroville Skyway & Elliott Rd., Paradise Planning approval from Butte County Planning Department, 7 County Center Drive, Oroville,. for. ` Completed Owner -Builder Verification form. Recorded copy of deed showing Recorded copy of agricultural.acknowledgement.statement. X/ OTHER Two comRlete sets of plans innliuJing rnnf framing_ framing, floor framing Also we need a ntan of the Rtairc (4PP AttarhAd ) i Should you have any questions concerning the above, please contact Linda Sexton of this office. Yours very truly, JFG/aj William Cheff Director of Public Works ,� %J.F..Glander Chief; Building Inspector COUNTY OF BUTTE - DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS 7 County Center. Urive, Oroville, CA 95965 PHONE: 916-538-7541 DATE 7./;n.1go • Egr..illa Stovall' RE: 30.1 Oro Bangor A.P. ' Oroville, CA 95965 36-021-44 With reference to the above subject: t S ' L� Attached is: f Application for .permit Building Plans Engr. Calcs ' Owner -Builder Verification Form .Mobilehome Utilities Installation Sheet Mobilehome Installation Information Sheet Typical Plan Sheet List of Codes Enforced OTHER LL We need the following information: Permit application signed and completed where indicated with all co pies returned. Fees of $ payable to Butte County Treasurer. t; Certificate of Workmen's Compensation Insurance or check exemption statement. Contractor's License Law information or check exemption statement., 1 Complete plans in , including plot plans. t Plot plans in Structural details in Complete plans and calcs in by registered engineer:or tchitect. Energy design including Street and drainage improvement plan approval from Land Development°.Sectio°n'(DPW). sets of plans in accordance with the changes marked in red. Sanitation approval from Butte County Health Department at; 196 Memorial Way, Chico \\� 7 County Center Dr., Oroville ,. Skyway & Elliott Rd., Paradise j Planning approval from Butte County Planning Department, 7 County Center Drive, Oroville, for Completed Owner -Builder Verification form. 5 Recorded copy -of deed showing ' Recorded copy of agricultural acknowledgement statement OTHER Pl a cr. 'nr Ni rlw Should you have any questions concerning the above, please contact of Chic nffira JFG/aj� Yours very truly, William Cheff Director of Public Works //J.F. Glander Chief Building Inspector 11/-" T. r+ nl V%.1Ar\r\ nn rVr TYP z CrUARDRAIL 1-9 F I �6"MAX. DECKIIJ G GIRDER U) u PRECAST PIE K` 14 x 14 MIN. FooT I NG 4"x V L X FRMN U. CLIP - I 9 2°x 12" STAIR 'STRINGER. 48'0.c. MAX. RS -TDP VIEW 11ft11r%r7►111 iln-r rtln1rlil rA17 n, flf71TV 3/gl BOLT I MOBILE HOME OR DECK -7 r - 6" t MAX. I 9 2°x 12" STAIR 'STRINGER. 48'0.c. MAX. RS -TDP VIEW 11ft11r%r7►111 iln-r rtln1rlil rA17 n, flf71TV 3/gl BOLT X I erk4" PRESSURE I K4 -R oR f REDWOOD PZA7'E A"xl" POST 14 MIN. - ADE"QUATE DIAL, 0NA L 9-25-87 13RACIIJG. TYPICAL RFSI DFiVT/_•9L STFAS ��o/�DFC•� COUNTY OF BUTTE -- DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS 7 County Center Drive — Oroville, California 95965 Telephone: 538-7541 MOBILE HOME OR DECK 6" t MAX. MTL. FRW) L --- CLIP (EA. SIP.E) a a 4!,A 4" POST 2,V 12" 112 DF I'2i 3/a,, DOLTS X I erk4" PRESSURE I K4 -R oR f REDWOOD PZA7'E A"xl" POST 14 MIN. - ADE"QUATE DIAL, 0NA L 9-25-87 13RACIIJG. TYPICAL RFSI DFiVT/_•9L STFAS ��o/�DFC•� COUNTY OF BUTTE -- DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS 7 County Center Drive — Oroville, California 95965 Telephone: 538-7541 .�. �� c� � � � � �$ r� (e-l-qy �y- 1' _ : ,. �r/• _ i s pjC � � ._ _ i" j_, COUNTY OF BUTTE - DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS rf_ 7 County Center Drive - Oroville, California 95965 - Telephone 916/534-4541 APPLICATWWAND PERMIT PERMIT NO. ASSESSOR PARCEL NUMBER/ 2 -- .�[4 ZONI" H BUILDING PERMIT OWNER) , LWf✓(i�L� `S'fe/�AL� V /t©• TELEPHONE SO. FT. OCC. -BUILDING VALUATION 4 F� OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS AJT e -'. •' /Ga - O c•' CbAl C411CZASe—NAME/�- . Er. ` TELLQEPHO`N CONTRACTOR'S MAILING ADDRESS 3 A li'm #a) &a CONSTRUCTION LENDER UNKNOWN Fireplace Total Valuation $ LENDER'S MAILING ADDRESS Permit Fee $ 00 ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER LICENSE NO. Pian Checking Fee $ Penalty $ ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER'S MAILING ADDRESS Permit fee $ 5-00 BUILDING ADDRESS SOW ORO 94AIC�Ooe AwY PLUMBING PERMIT Filing Fee 3.00 Each Trap 2.00 Repair drainage or vent piping 2.00 17, OC) Wates piping LOT NO. SUBDIVISION NAMEPARCEL MAP Each qas water heater or vent 2.00 Gas piping system 1 - 5 outlets USE OF STRUCTURE SF[E Duplex❑ Mobilehome❑ Other SPECIFY Building sewer Lawn sprinkler system ��00 TYPE OF WORK New ❑ Addition ❑ Remodel ❑ Utilities ❑ Installation❑ Other 00' Describe work: — E_ F�ij 50 /AJS%f t L Pe- Permit Fee $ S, 0o Contractor ELECTRICAL PERMIT Filing Fee 3.00 Main service 100 AMP ORLESS5.00 ,/6•/(%T 5 l ,S� � P� 14GE 1,1rCAE �,� p(�Q G'� l/ • Main service EA, AD ,oD AMP INBLDGOCCUP.&) 2.50 CONTRACTORS LICENSE LAW I declare under penalty of perjury (check one): I 0 I am licensed under provisions of Chapt.19, Div. 3 of the Business and Professions Code and my license is in full force and effect. 1 r' 4 4 _ _ / License No. Classification :'❑. I, as the owner, or my employees with wages as their sole compen- sation, will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for sale. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I, as the owner, am exclusively contracting with licensed contract- ors. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I am exempt under Sec. , Business and Professions Code for this reason OR ADDNSNEW T ( ACCL20sgft NEW CONSTR ULT' -OUTLET 2.50 ea NON-RESID BRANCH CIRC ITS NEW CONSTR.POWER APPARATUS & NON-RESID, (SINGLE OUTLET CIR. Ex. Occup( ouTLETs OR FIXTURES 50 @ 25z BAL@tU¢ Ex. Occup.(OUT LE P(RESID IREA.) 2.00 Temporary service 10.00 Mobile Home Facilities 15.00 Misc. Wiring 6.25 Permit Fee $ Contractor MECHANICAL PERMIT FiIingFee 3.00 WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE 1 declare under penalty of perjury (check one): ❑ The permit is for $100.00 (valuation) or less. I have placed on file with the County of Butte Building Department a Certificate of Workmen's Compensation Insurance or a Certificate of Consent to Self -Insure. ❑ I shall not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the W. C. laws of California. Notice to Applicant: If after making this statement, should you become subject to the W. C. provisions of the Labor Code, you must forthwith comply with such provisions or this permit shall be deemed revoked. J Heating Cooling Hood 2.00 Ventilation 'Permit Fee $ Contractor 1 certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct. I agree to comply to all County Ordinances and State Laws relating to building construction, and hereby authorize representatives of the Countyot Butte to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. I also agree to save, indemnify and keep harmless the County of Butte against all liabilities, judgments, costs, and expenses which may in any way accrue against said County in consequence of the granting of this permit. X - ' h' u Date �1 �� `�� Signature of Applicant — Owner❑ Contractor B Agent ❑ An OSHA permit is required for excavations over 5'0" deep and demolition or construct- ion of structures over 3 stories in height. Mobile Home Installation Fee $ Land Development Fee $ TOTAL PERMIT FEE $ U OCCUP. GROUP I TYPE OF CONST. PARCEL PD ND ISSUE This permit is hereby issued under the applicable provi- sions of the Butte County Code and/or resolutions to do work k indicated above for which fees have been aid. p DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC WORKS �1r^�/ By ,` , r Date 77 7-•�` PERMIT EXPIRES Date - -' , �- �( ri Receipt No. �! WHITE-D.P.W.. YELLOW -ASSESSOR, PINK -INSPECTOR. GOLDENROD -APPLICANT COUNTY OF BUTTE - DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS t 7 County Center Drive - Oroville, California 95965 - Telephone 916/534-4541 -� APPLICATION AND PERMIT PERMIT NO. ASSESSOR PACEL NUMBER -- d 2 ZONI K BUILDING PERMIT O �-�;— ¢�^ ` 0��/IuA J/ D(//TL(.— TELEPHONE SO. FT. OCC. BUILDING VALUATION 51 �J 8� OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS ®0 00 R: CU LLMZAKKn/� E PH in CONTRACTOR'S CNTRACTOR'SMAILING ADDRESS D� CONSTRUCTION LENDER/ F�r(Jm/ / UNKNOWN Fireplace Total Valuation is a� _ 00 LENDER'S MAILING ADDRESS Permit Fee $ 5 Oo ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER LICENSE NO. Plan Checking Fee $ Penalty $ ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER'S MAILING ADDRESS Permit fee $ BUILDING ADDRESS 04/ Off ' ,Bi4i(� �,e #A)Y, PLUMBING PERMIT Filing Fee 3.00 Each Trap 2.00 Repair drainage or vent piping 2.00 2.00 Water piping LOT NO.SUBDIVISION NAME PARCEL MAP Each qas water heater or vent 2.00 Gas piping system 1 - 5 outlets USE OF STRUCTURE SIFE"Duplex❑ Mobilehome❑ Other SPECIFY Building sewer Lawn sprinkler system 2.00 , TYPE OF WORK New❑ Addition Remodel❑ Utilities❑ Installation [2 Other Describe work: OoF 5 $(� /�S']�[r �Lv/�%� • Permit Fee $ 57. o0 Contractor ELECTRICAL PERMIT Filing Fee 3.00 Main service 100 AMP ORS SLESS 5.00 fir'/�J�� * /•Z1 . �C�// C /�/i iO /7 h/�/l Main service EA. ADD'L 100 AMP 2.50 OR AE W ( ACCLB LDGS.CCUP.&� 20 sq ft CONTRACTORS LICENSE LAW I declare under penalty of perjury (check one): 1��rt I am licensed under provisions of Chapt. 9, Div. 3 of the Business and Professions Code and my license is in full force and effect. !�c :Z,Classification License No. :� _/ 7 'T 4- � `►" -I, as the owner, or my employees with wages as their sole compen- sation, will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for sale. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I, as the owner, am exclusively contracting with licensed contract- ors. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I am exempt under Sec. , Business and Professions Code for this reason NON -RESIT R BRULT 1-0ANCH CILET ITS 2.50 ea NEW CONSTR.POWER APPARATUS & NON-RESID. (SINGLE OUTLET CIR. 50 @ 250 Ex. Occup(o X OR FIXTURES BAL@1W IED A PLNS \\ Ex. Occup.(OUTLETS (RESID )REA.) 2.00 Temporary service 10.00 Mobile Home Facilities 15.00 Misc. Wiring 6.25 Permit Fee $ Contractor MECHANICAL PERMIT FiIingFee 3.00 WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE 1 declare under penalty of perjury (check one): ❑ The permit is for $100.00 (valuation) or less. I have placed on file with the County of Butte Building Department �I a Certificate of Workmen's Compensation Insurance or a Certificate of Consent to Self -Insure. ❑ I shall not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the W. C. laws of California. Notice to Applicant: If after making this statement, should you become subject to the W. C. provisions of the Labor Code, you must forthwith comply with such provisions or this permit shall be deemed revoked. Heating Cooling Hood 2.00 Ventilation permit Fee $ Contractor I certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct. I agree to comply to all County Ordinances and State Laws relating to building construction, and hereby authorize representatives of the Countyot Butte to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. I also agree to save, indemnify and keep harmless the County of Butte against all liabilities, judgments, costs, and expenses which may in any way accrue again t said County in co sequence of the granting of this permit. X - Date (� Signature of Applic nt — Own Co tractor 0] Agent ❑ An OSHA permit is required for excavations over 5'0" deep and demolition or construct- ion of structures over 3 stories 'n height. Mobile Home Installation Fee $ Land Development Fee $ TOTAL PERMIT FEE $ �D�Ao OCCUP. GROUP I TYPE OF CONST, I PARCEL PD ND ssuE This permit is hereby issued under sions of the Butte County Code and/or work indicated above for which DIREC R OF PUBLIC By PE EXPIRES Date the applicable provi- resolutions to do fees have been paid. WORKS Date7—/7­9_o �_/7-u / Receipt No. WNITE•O.P.W., YELLOW -ASSESSOR. PINK -INSPECTOR. GOLDENROD -APPLICANT c ac S. �5o�s S� �d � Permit#333-89B,P,E,r, Equilla Stovall 6 30.41 Oro Bangor Hwy\,, C> / �/ Tror-e�j ��� e�e o� COUNTY OF BUTTE - DE&\RTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS - 7 County Center Drive - Oroville, California 95965 - Telephone: 916/538-7541 APPLICATION AND PERMIT FP RMIT_NO. ASSESSiR ARCEL U BE ZONING - BUILDING PERMIT OWNJER�/^l// C / TELEPHHO)N'E7 .SQ. FT. OCC. BUILDING VALUATION ` OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS CONTRACTOR'S NAME TELEPHONE CONTRACTOR'S MAILING ADDRESS Fireplace CONSTRUCTION LENDER AA UNKNOWN Total Valuation $ Filing Fee $ 10.00 LENDER'S M`AAI MAILING DD,DRESS Permit Fee $ ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER LICENSE NO. Plan Checking Fee $ Energy Plan Checking Fee $ ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER'S MAILING ADDRESS Penalty $ BUILDING ADDRESS Permit tee $ c:;2 f PLUMBING PERMIT Filing Fee 10.00 Each Trap 2.00 Solar or heat pump water heater 20.00 LOT NO. SUBDIVISION NAME 'I • 1 ` PARCEL MAP -Water piping 5.00 Each qas water heater or vent 5.00 USE OF STRUCTURE SF Z Duplex❑ Mobilehome❑ Other SPECIFY Gas piping system 1 - 5 outlets 5.00 Building sewer 5.00 Mobile Home JSFG W 0.00ea TYPE OF WORK New ❑ Addition ❑ Remodel ❑ Ut' lIties in t I lati [I Other ❑ Describe work: �Q� Ck �„ Permit Fee $ Contractor ELECTRICAL PERMIT Filing Fee 10.00 I Main service 60OV-OR LESS 100 AMP OR LESS 10.00 Main service EA. ADD'L 100 -AMP 2.50 CONTRACTORS LICENSE LAW I declare under'penalty of perjury: (check one): ❑ I am licensed under provisions of Chapt. 9, Div. 3 of the Buslnes$ and Professions Code and my license Is In full force and effect. License No. Classification Q I, as the owner, or my employees .with wages as their sole compen- sation, will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for sale. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I, as the owner, am exclusively contracting with licensed contract- ors.(Sec. 7044) ❑ I am exempt under Sec. , Business and Professions Code for this reason NEW CONST. DWELLING OCCUP.EI , OR ADONS. ACC. BLDGS. h2sgft NEW CONSTRE510,MULTI-OUTLETNHCIRCUITS)2.50 ea NON.R ESIO BRANCH CIRC TS (POWER APPARATUS e (SINGLE OUTLET CIR. Ex. OCCUp(OUTLETS OR FIXTURES 200SOt SAI -9309 FIXED AFLNS. Ex. OCCup. OUTLETS PR (RESID 1EA.7 2.00 Temporary service 10.00 Mobile Home Facilities 15.00 Misc. Wirin9 15.0019 Permit Fee $ WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE I declare under penalty of perjury (check one): ❑ The permit is for $100.00 (valuation) or less. ❑ I have placed on file with the County of Butte Building Department a Certificate of Workmen's Compensation Insurance or a Certificate of Consent to Self -insure. 1 shall not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the W. C. laws of California. Notice to Applicant: If after making this statement, should you become subject to the W. C. provisions of the Labor Code, you must forthwith comply with such provisions or this permit shall be deemed revoked. Contractor MECHANICAL ER IT FiIirig Fee 10.00 Heating 6100 Cooling g Hood 3.00 Ventilation permit Fee $ Contractor I certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct. I agree to comply to all County Ordinances and State Laws relating to building construction, and hereby authorize representatives of the Countyot Butte to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. I also agree to save, indemnify and keep harmless the County of Butte against all liabilities, judgments, costs, and expenses which may in any way accrue against said County in consequence of the granting of this permit. X >��'' r /.�� �� k � �,, 7— �• Signature of Applicant – Owner ❑ Contractor ❑ Agent ❑ ion of structures over 3 stories in height. An OSHA permit is required for excavations over 5'0" deep and demolition or construct-VMIT4EXPIRES Mobile Home Installation Fee $ Energy Inspection Fee $ TOTAL PERMIT FEE $ oCCUP. CONST.TYPC SCHOOL FLOOD PARCEL P11 I HJ I ISSUE This permit is hereby issued under sions of the Butte County Code and/or work i ted above fo which DIRE F PUB Date the applicable provi- resolutions to do ee have been paid. C ORKS at Receipt No. WHITE-D.P. YEL Low- se CSSOR. PINK -INSPECTOR. GOLDENROD -APPLICANT COUNTY OF BUTTE - DEPAR"14AENT OF PUBLIC WORKS 7 County Center Drive - Oroville, California 95965 - Telephone: 916/538-7541 APPLICATION AND PERMIT —EYT T NO ASSESS"ARCEL U BE ZONING BUILDING PERMIT OWN TELEPHONE LL / S72 11o4Z_Z_ 3' SQ. FT. OCC.1 BUILDING VALUATION OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS -170W aWZ9292� Ib OWN// - CONTRACTOR'S NAME TELEPHONE CONTRACTOR'S MAILING ADDRESS ___[UNKNOWN Fireplace CONSTRUCTION LENDER / Total Valuation $ MAILING ADDRESS LENDER'S/ Filing Fee $ 10.00 Permit Fee $ ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER LICENSE NO. Plan Checking Fee $ Energy Plan Checking Fee $ ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER'S MAILING ADDRESS Penalty $ BUILDING ADDRESS Permit fee $ PLUMBING PERMIT Filing Fee 10.00 `ate 01Md�'� Each Trap 2.00 Solar or heat pump water heater 20.00 LOT NO. SUBDIVISION NAME PARCEL MAP Water piping 5.00 Each qas water heater or vent 5.00 USE OF STRUCTURE SFO Duplex❑ Mobilehome❑ Other SPECIFY Gas piping system 1 - 5 outlets 5.00 Building sewer 5.00 Mobile Home S G W 0.00 ea TYPE OF WORK New ❑ Addition ❑ Remodel ❑ Ut' 'ties In tai lati ❑ Other ❑ Describe work: - r ie u r, Permit Fee $ 1,q 00 Contractor ELECTRICAL PERMIT Filing Fee 10.00 Main service 100 AMP ORV OR LESS10.00 Main service EA. ADD'L 100 AMP 2.50 CONTRACTORS LICENSE LAW I declare under penalty of perjury (check one): El am licensed under provisions of Chapt. 9, Div. 3 of the Business and Professions Code and my license is in full force and effect. License No. Classification as the owner, or my employees with wages as their sole compen- sation, will do the work,and the structure is not intended or offered for sale. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I, as the owner, am exclusively contracting with licensed contract- ors. (Sec. 7044) ❑ I am exempt under Sec. , Business and Professions Code for this reason OR ADDNSCONST WELLIN GSCCUP.al) YzQsgft NEW CONSTR. MULTI -OUTLET NON.RESID BRANCH CIRC ITS 2.50 ea POWER APPARATUS e (SINGLE OUTLET CIR. I Ex. OCCUp(OUTLETS OR FIXTURES 2ALO 30 eL0 Ex. Occup. OUTLETSP(RESID )FIXED ALNS.REA.I 2.00 Temporary service 10.00 Mobile Home Facilities 15.00 . MiscWiring 15.00 Permit Fee $ WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE I declare under penalty of perjury (check one): ❑ The permit is for $100.00 (valuation) or less. ❑ I have placed on file with the County of Butte Building Department a Certificate of Workmen's Compensation Insurance or a Certificate of Consent to Self -Insure. / L� ' shall not employ any person in any manner so as to become subject to the W. C. laws of California. Notice to Applicant: If after making this statement,should you become subject to the W. C. provisions of the Labor Code, you must forthwith comply with such provisions or this permit shall be deemed revoked. Contractor MECHANICAL ER IT FiIingFee 10.00 Heating n g Cooling Hood 3.00 Ventilation permit Fee s Contractor I certify that I have read this application and state that the above information is correct. I agree to comply to all County Ordinances and State Laws relating to building construction, and hereby authorize representatives of the County of Butte to enter upon the above-mentioned property for inspection purposes. 1 also agree to save, indemnify and keep harmless the County of Butte against all liabilities, judgments, costs, and expenses which may in any way accrue, again t said Co my in c seq ence of t anting of this permit. ` ,_ X Date Signature of Applicant — Owner ❑ Contractor ❑ Agent ❑ An OSHA permit is required for excavations over 5'0" deep and demolition or construct- ion of structures over 3 stories in height. Mobile Home Installation Fee $ Energy Inspection Fee $ TOTAL PERMIT FEE $ OCCUP. CONST.TYPEJ J.Cmoo1JFU)ODJPARCFLJ PD ND ISSUE This permit is hereby issued under sions of the Butte County Code and/or fhih DIRRKS work7'ed ab4Date P;_1,MIT EXPIRE the applicable provi- resolutions to do have been paid. A Receipt No.e WNITE-D.P.W.. rELLOW- De[seOK. PINK -INSPECTOR. GOLDENROD -APPLICANT COUNTY OF BUTTE - Department of Public Works 7 County Center Drive, Oroville, CA 95965 OWNER -BUILDER VERIFICATION Attention Property Owner: Phone: 916-538=7541 An 'owner -builder" building permit has been applied for in your name and bearing your signature. Please complete and return this information at your earliest opportunity to avoid unnecessary delay in processing and issuing your building permit. No building permit. will be issued until this verification is received. 1. I personally plan to provide the major labor and materials for construction of the proposed property improvement (yes or no) /� c�for a building permit 2. I (have/have not) signed an apple g for the proposed work. 3. I have contracted with the following person (firm) to provide the proposed construction: Name Address City Phone Contractors License No: 4. I plan to provide portions of this work, but I have hired the following person to coordinate, supervise, and provide the major work: Name Address City Phone Contractors License No. 5. I will provide some of the work but I have contracted (hired) the following persons to provide the work indicated: Name Address . Phone Type of Work Signed Property Owner JT", Social SecurityNu er Date NOTE: This Owner -Builder Verification is sent to you as required by Sections 19831 and 19832 of the California Health and Safety Code. This verification must be completed and returned to our office before we are per- mitted to issue the permit. p 30- CD) - (AH CONNERLY & ASSOCIATES, INC. 2215 21ST STREET &Q ERLy SACRAMENTO, CA 95818 (916) 456-4784 ire ha�..� a cc�e�e 01) g_ oycnncc—Leri a.i- �cU XaA�at �w�v.C� O'L 101, Equilla Stovall 3041 Oro Bangor Oroville, CA 95966 LAND OF NATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ❑ 196 Memorial Way ❑ 7 County Center Drive ❑ 747 Elliott Road Chico, California 95926 Oroville, California 95965 Paradise, California 95969 Telephone: 916/891-2727 Telephone: 916/538-7281 Telephone: 916/872-6308 RE: Rehabilitation Inspection - 3041 Oro Bangor Highway, Oroville, CA - AP# 036=021-044-0 Dear Mrs. Stovall: On April 17 and 24, 1989, an inspection was made of the above listed dwelling unit at your request. The inspection was made as part of the rehabilitation program currently underway in the E1 Medio area south of Oroville. The dwelling is a single story structure with wooden siding, composition shingle roof, concrete slab at north end, pier and post south end, served by community water, natural gas, electricity and private sewage disposal system. The house exhibits weak and sloping floors in living room and bedroom off living room. There ..is ground to wood contact on north side.' Water heater lacks proper discharge line on temperature -pressure relief valve, lacks proper flue and adequate combustion air. Roof is.deflecting badly on north end. Dwelling lacks proper roof and underfloor -vents. Sliding door and front door lack proper. stairs. Exposed unprotected. wiring evident in kitchen and in west exterior wall. In order to rehabilitate the dwelling under this program the following repairs or corrections are required. 1. Complete all corrections or repairs as listed in the Butte County Emergency Home Repair Program letter'_to Mrs. Equilla Stovall dated August 29, 1988 (Attached). 2. Provide an adequate underfloor support system'by adding piers and girders as required and.replacing all damaged ,materials. Remove and replace all damaged or deteriorated floor joists, sub -floor and .floor covering.. Provide. adequate underfloor ventilation and crawl space.4/ r Equilla Stovall April 26, 1989 Page 2 ✓3. Strip walls to frame and provide bracing, studding, etc. as necessary. Replace damaged or deteriorated materials in walls and make all exterior walls weathertight. Insulate walls to R-11 standards. 1W. Make all doors and windows operable and weathertight. 5. Provide an adequate roof support system by adding rafters, ceiling joists and bracing.as required. Remove and replace roof covering replacing all damaged or deteriorated sheathing. Provide adequate ventilation. and insulate to R- 19 standards. V6. Cleanup electrical wiring; eliminate all deteriorated or damaged wiring, outlet boxes and fittings; unprotected wiring; open or exposed splices, etc. Provide additional outlets as needed. Provide adequate plumbing fixtures with effective traps and vents. Provide proper supports for all drain. waste and vent piping. Provide proper leak free plumbing for all drains, waste, vent., water and gas lines. Remove and replace gas heater in living room. Verify that wood stove in bedroom is properly installed. A� Provide adequate combustion air and proper flue for water heater, provide discharge line for temperature -pressure relief valve. 10. Provide wood to ground clearance on north side of house - (newest portion): Regrade lot to divert water from slab and side of house. 11. Provide proper exterior siding -on north end of .house (newest portion). Provide proper stairs for kitchen.and living room doors, and sliding door in bedroom. Provide smoke detectors.. The following items, although not -required, are strongly recommended to effectively prolong the useful life. of the dwelling,.and/or to'make'the dwelling more habitable. 1. Provide.continuous concrete perimeter foundation. 2. Provide new cooling system. Equilla Stovall April 26, 1989 Page 2 ✓3. Strip walls to frame and provide bracing, studding, etc. as necessary. Replace damaged or deteriorated materials in walls and make all exterior walls weathertight. Insulate walls to R-11 standards. 1W. Make all doors and windows operable and weathertight. 5. Provide an adequate roof support system by adding rafters, ceiling joists and bracing.as required. Remove and replace roof covering replacing all damaged or deteriorated sheathing. Provide adequate ventilation. and insulate to R- 19 standards. V6. Cleanup electrical wiring; eliminate all deteriorated or damaged wiring, outlet boxes and fittings; unprotected wiring; open or exposed splices, etc. Provide additional outlets as needed. Provide adequate plumbing fixtures with effective traps and vents. Provide proper supports for all drain. waste and vent piping. Provide proper leak free plumbing for all drains, waste, vent., water and gas lines. Remove and replace gas heater in living room. Verify that wood stove in bedroom is properly installed. A� Provide adequate combustion air and proper flue for water heater, provide discharge line for temperature -pressure relief valve. 10. Provide wood to ground clearance on north side of house - (newest portion): Regrade lot to divert water from slab and side of house. 11. Provide proper exterior siding -on north end of .house (newest portion). Provide proper stairs for kitchen.and living room doors, and sliding door in bedroom. Provide smoke detectors.. The following items, although not -required, are strongly recommended to effectively prolong the useful life. of the dwelling,.and/or to'make'the dwelling more habitable. 1. Provide.continuous concrete perimeter foundation. 2. Provide new cooling system. Equilla Stovall April 26, 1989 Page 3 Most of the corrections or repairs listed will require permits and inspections from the Butte County Department of Public Works. Permits may be obtained at 7 County Center Drive, Oroville,.CA. All work shall be completed to the extent necessary to provide the desired finished product. This may require tile, linoleum, shingles, wallboard, paint, vents, or whatever is necessary to accomplish the finished product. Should you have any questions, please feel.free to contact me at the above indicated address or telephone number. Sincerely, Howard. Sny er, Director Division of Environmental Health HJS/mlf cc: Public Works_- Jim Glander Connerly and.Associates, Inc., 2215 21st Street, Sacramento, CA 95918 Attachment Mrs. Equilla Stovall 3041 OroBangor Highway Oroville, California 95966 Y JP l CONNERLY & ASSOCIATES, INC. 2215 21ST STREET SACRAMENTO, CA 95818 (916) 456-4784 August 29, 1988 RE: Butte County Emergency Home Repair Program Dear Mrs. Stovall: Our staff has reviewed your application for the Emergency Home Repair Program and determined that you are eligible. Your next step is to obtain contractor estimates for repairs on your home.: The following are repairs that our staff feels are the most urgent: 1. Install new roof, replacing .rotted sheeting as necessary. Provide gutters and downspouts. 2. Ensure that all wiring is up to code. Re -wire as necessary. 3. Repair•gas heater in living room or replace with wall furnace. - /--- 4. gnsur-e-wood_stove--is --installed'-to * code- in bedroom./ 5. Hang exterior door where missing .in bedroom. C,Z'. Install stable step out of front door. 7. Replace any substandard plumbing. Attached is a list of contractors that have worked with the program in the past. You may also contact any other contractors you feel will do a good job" provided they have a license. Please send us'three (3) estimat for the six (6) items outlined O' above by Friday, Septembe � 1988. Please feel free to call us if you have any question s/ J 'a"S3ncerely, Cil a SOP�IA PAGOUL !OS lk� - Ak SP/tc `\J Enclosure HOUSING JIPLANNING • COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ASSOCIATES r CONN;�.RLY & ASSOCIATES, INC. 2215 21ST STREET SACRAMENTO, CA 95818 (916)456-4784 August 29, 198'---... _--- -- o y GZ/2� Mrs. Squilla Stovall 3041 OroBangor Highway Oroville, California 95966 RE: Butte County Emergency Home Repair Program A Dear Mrs. Stovall: Our staff has reviewed your application for the Emergency Home Re-pai.r Program and determined that you are eligible. Your n -ext step is to obtain contractor estimates for repairs on your home. The following are repairs that our staff feels are the most urgent: 1. Install new roof, replacing rotted sheeting as necessary. Provide gutters and downspouts. 2. Ensure that all wiring is up to code. Re -wire as necessary. 3. Repair -gas heater in living room or replace with wall furnace. cwt 4. - Esnsure-wood stove -is - install-od to code.'in bedroom. �'.�f �-I' P 5. Hang exterior door where missing in bedroom. �6. Install stable step out of front door. 7. Replace any substandard plumbing. Attached is a list of contractors that have worked with the program in the past. You may also contact any other contractors you feel ' will do a good job, provided they have a license. Please send us three 3 estimat for the six ( ) ���� (6) items outlined above by Friday, Septembe 0.6-? 1988. Please feel free to call us if you have any.questions. 123ncerely, Vim' SOP IA PA d1" GOUL OS SP/tc Enclosure HOUSING PLANNING COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT �� 4 A/nl, u� Butte CountDeparbnent ofDevelopmentServices 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 (530) 538-7601 Telephone (530) 538-7785 Facsimile 14 April 2004 Ms. Fannie Tobias 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy. Oroville, CA 95966 Re: Response to Complaint Letter — 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy., Oroville Dear Ms. Tobias: Thank you for your patience in allowing us time to research the records regarding your letter of complaint of "poorly done work on Equilla Stovall's home at 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy" dated 01/02/04. Unfortunately, the loan records from 1988 through 1990 are no longer available. We were able to review the building permit file and a more recent (2000) file provided by Connerly and Associates. Findings from these files are summarized with Exhibits A -D attached to this response letter. The facts we were able to ascertain from the Building files are as follows: • July 16, 1980 Building permit taken by Walter Luczak Jr. (contractor) for re -roof (5 sq), install plumbing vents (3), replace interior doors. This work was inspected by a Butte County Building Inspector and deemed complete on July 23, 1980. • August 28, 1988 Equilla Stovall was notified by a letter from Connerly and Associates that she qualified for the Emergency Home Repair program. In that letter she was asked to obtain contractor estimates for repairs the staff determined to be most urgent. A list of contractors that had worked with the program in the past was supplied along with the letter. The letter also stated, "You may contact any other contractors you feel will do a good job, provided they have a license." Mrs. Stovall was asked to supply three estimates for the six (6) items outlined by Friday, September 16, 1988. (Exhibit A) • March 27, 1989 Connerly and Associates requested a written inspection report from the County as they were requesting permission from Housing and Community Development (HCD) to make a $20,000 loan under the current grant. • February 7, 1989 Equilla Stovall applied for a building permit for re -roof, gas wall heater and electrical clean-up. Mrs. Stovall completed an "Owner -Builder Verification" indicating she was acting as her own contractor. Subsequently, on 08/29/89 the Building Inspector for Butte County inspected and determined the roofing looked properly installed and indicated the remainder of the work applied for on the permit still needed to be done. • April 26, 1989 Equilla Stovall was sent an inspection letter from Public Health indicating the repairs or corrections required that needed to be done to rehabilitate the dwelling. (Exhibit B) • July 18, 1989 Equilla Stovall applied for a building permit to relocate vent pipe, reside house, foundation work, replace steps. Records indicate this permit was not issued, meaning work was never authorized to begin. Notes in the building file indicate: o Mrs. Stovall again filled out an "Owner -Builder Verification" to act as her own contractor but showed her intent to contract with Kevin Jones, and unlicensed contractor to do the work. Records show State Farm insurance submitted information on November 29, 1989 indicating that Mrs. Stovall's homeowner coverage covered Worker's Compensation insurance for employees including but not limited to painters, roofers, remodeling and repair contractors, chimney sweeps, etc. Mrs. Stovall was notified the Owner Builder verification information was not valid with her statement to hire Kevin Jones. Records indicate Mrs. Stovall was called on January 5, 1990 and advised of Fannie Tobias 14 April 2004 Page Two this as well as need to supply sufficient plot plan and building plan information. Notes attached to this building permit application indicate: ✓ (no date) "Stovall, unlicensed contractor, ordered off by Connerly, 2 complete plans, $7,000, Carl Moore" ✓ March 19, 1990 "Ward Connerly advised we needed complete plans and new contractor must apply for new permit and we can refund other permit to Stovall. Connerly to advise contractor". ✓ April 16,1990 "Tanga/Connerly" Going to job with another contractor to try to straighten out" Facts we were able to glean from the file sent to us from Connerly and Associates are as follows: • 08/21/00 Butte County Central Collections notified Connerly and Associates that Fannie Tobias had notified County that Equilla Stovall had passed away (6/1/2000) and had provided a copy of the death certificate. At that time notes indicate $800 or eight (8) months of payments were delinquent. • 12/15 Note indicates, "daughter is living in home — paying rent, children (7) inherited property". • ' Connerly began working with heirs on an "assumption to convert to rental dwelling". Application was sent 12118/00. • 9117 Note indicates, "Fannie does not live in property, sister (Helena) does, home is in Fannie's name. She still has assumption application, says it is very "complicated" and she will mail it in as is and I'll [Connerly] get back to her with what we need." • 11/7101 Letter to Fannie Tobias indicating information needed —Signed "Information Release Authorization" for all persons on title, Source(s) of income for all persons on title, "Tenant Income Verification" and "Tenant Information Release authorization" — Helena Heard. There was also a reminder the rules governing rental properties and owners of rental properties were quite different than owner/occupied units with a strong recommendation that the option of refinancing with a conventional lender be explored. (Exhibit C) • 09/02/02 Letter to Connerly and Associates from Fannie Tobias. (Exhibit D). • 9/25/02 Connerly note indicates staff attempts to work with the family for almost 2 years to get them to assume Equilla Stovall's loan. Options of refinancing and assumption were discussed. The family did not like the fact that the original 0% loan would be converted to an interest loan as an investment (rental) property. Staff was unable to get Income verification on each of the heirs with a vested interest in the property. Family was now requesting a reduction of the loan balance. Decision was made to recommend foreclosure. Summary of findings in response to complaint: Rolled roofing (901b), as verified by our Building Official has a short life expectancy and it is reasonable to expect that it would need to be replaced every 2-4 years (compared to shingle roofing of 230lbs that has a 10-15 year life). Your letter states,"repairs have been done 3-4 times since the original rolled roofing was put on". We can only assume you mean since the building permit for roofing finaled on 8129/89 as there were no other permits taken for additional roofing, so any other repairs were done without obtaining the required permits. It also appears that other work you are disputing also was done without benefit of permits, so the Building Department did not have an opportunity to review the quality of work or pass it upon inspection and there are no records of this work on file. File information clearly shows that Mrs. Stovall was advised to select a licensed contractor to perform the required work. Mrs. Stovall clearly at times acted as her own contractor and file information indicates that although she was told work must be done by a licensed contractor she attempted to have work done by Kevin Jones, an unlicensed contractor. Connerly and Associates reports that Mrs. Stovall would have had discretion to authorize and release payments for work she deemed complete. An attempt was made to get records of payments from the Butte County Title Company, but we were advised that after seven years the records were purged. 2 *�A Fannie Tobias 14 April 2004 Page Three The file from Connerly and Associates picks up in 2000. Loan payments were delinquent, the County and Connerly were made aware that Mrs. Stovall had died, and the heirs were renting out the home. The record shows that Connerly worked with Fannie Tobias in an attempt to get the loan assumed as a rental and encouraged exploring conventional financing. Staff at Connerly and Associates who worked with the family recall there were no complaints regarding work on the home during the entire period that assumption of loan converting it to a rental was in process until the letter of September 2, 2002. The letter of September 2, 2002 seeks a reduction of the pay-off amount due to allegations that "contractors" chosen by Mrs. Stovall were dishonest.. It appears that a complaint was appropriately made to the State Contractors Board, but it is unclear why this wasn't pursued to compensate for the allegations made against the "contractors". Again, the County's position is that Mrs. Stovall chose the contractors to work on her home and that Connerly intervened when it was discovered that Kevin Jones, an unlicensed contractor was performing work. On October 7, 2002 a recommendation was made to the Butte County Loan Committee to foreclose on the property and a copy of the September 2, 2002 letter was attached. On October 22, 2002 the Butte County Loan Committee approved the recommendation to foreclose. On November 13, 2002 a certified letter was sent to Fannie Tobias, Catherine Harris and Florence Young "Official Notice of Foreclosure Action". The note balance was paid in full February 12, 2003. There is no documentation, of any complaints other than those noted in the building file of Kevin Jones (an unlicensed contractor) being ordered off the job by Connerly and Associates and Connerly working to "straighten things out". Notes indicate that Connerly and Associates worked with Mrs. Stovall to resolve this issue when it arose and disbursement of payments which required Mrs. Stovall's authorization would indicate the work proceeded under her oversight and to her satisfaction. The Stovall heirs benefited from the 0% interest loan in place from the time Mrs. Stovall died on 6/112000 until the note was finally paid off on 2/12/03, over 31 months of interest free loan while the assumption of the loan and conversion to rental property or conventional financing to pay-off the loan was explored and the home was utilized as a investment rental. Please be assured that this matter was reviewed thoroughly. Due to the facts presented above, the fact that there are no building permits on record for the rehabilitation work, and the family benefiting from 31 months of interest free loan, we consider this matter closed. Sincerely, 1 Deborah DeBrunner Principal Analyst Enclosures: Exhibits A -D Cc: Allen Jones, Program Manager — Department of Housing and Community Development Liz Fitzgerald, CDBG Field Representative — Department of Housing and Community Development 3 I 1L - Eli W I'elJ1V1V�LKLJL I Mrs. Equilla Stovall 3041 OroBangor Highway Oroville, California 95966 A CONNERLY k ASSOCIATES, INC. 2215 21ST STREET SACRAMENTO, CA 95818 (916)456-4784 August 29, 1988 RE: Butte County Emergency Home Repair Program Dear Mrs. Stovall: Our staff has reviewed your application for the Emergency Home Repair Program and determined that you are eligible. Your next step is to obtain contractor estimates for repairs on your home. The following are repairs that our staff feels are the most urgent: 1. Install new roof, replacing rotted sheeting as necessary. Provide gutters and downspouts. 2. Ensure that all wiring is up to code. Re -wire as necessary. 3. Repair -gas heater in living room or replace with wall furnace. 4. gnsure- wood stove is-installLsa -ta code --in bedroom. 5. Hang exterior door where missing in bedroom. 6. Install stable step out of front door. 7. Replace any substandard plumbing. Attached is a list of contractors that have worked with the program in the past. You may also contact any other contractors you feel will do a good job, provided they have a license. Please send us three (3) estimated for the six (6) items outlined above by Friday, September 16.2 1988. Please feel free to call us if you have any questions, •`'Sincerely, Pit SOPI�IA PAGOULOS SP/tc Enclosure HOUSING -W PLANNING • COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT .......... 9 vv1 'y -{- -4 Address Reply to April 26, 1999 Equilla Stovall 3041 Oro Bangor Oroville, CAJ 95966 LA D 0r Ti lJ Al 1/1,18 _ T f.I7 3- . .l T _ DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ❑ 196 Memorial Way ❑ 7 County Center Drive ❑ 747 Elliott Road Chico, California 95926 Oroville, California 95965 Paradise, California 95969 Telephone: 916/391-2727 Telephone: 916/533-72S1 Teleohone: 916/872-6308 U RE: Rehabilitation Inspection - 3041 Oro Banoor Highway, Oroville, CA - AP# 036-021-044-0 Dear Mrs. Stovall: On Aril 17 and 241 1989, an inspection was made of the above listed dwelling unit at your request. The inspection was made as Part of the rehabilitation program currently underway in th rl Medio area south of Oroville. The dwelling is a single story structure with wooden siding, colrlposi 11 .Bhino).L- roof ., concrete slab . at north end, Pier and Post south end., served by community water, natural gas, electricity and private sewage disposal system. The house exhibits weak and sloping floors in living room and bedroom off living room. There is ground to wood contact on north side. Water heater lacks proper discharge line on temperature -pressure relief valve, lacks proper flue and adequate combustion air. Roof is deflecting badly on north end. Dwelling lacks proper roof and underfloor.vents. Sliding door and front door lacy; proper stairs. Exposed unprotected wiring evident in kitchen and in west exterior wall. In order to rehabilitate the dwelling under this program the following repairs or corrections are required. 1 2. Complete all corrections or repairs as listed in the Butte County Emergency Home Repair Program letter to firs. Eouilla Stovall dated August 29, 1986 (Attached) Provide an adequate underfloor support system by adding piers and girders as required and replacing all damagedd materials. Remove and replace all damaoed or deteriorated floor joists, sub -floor and floor covering. adequate underfloor ventilation and crawl space. Provide. Equilla Stovall April 26, 1989 Page 2 3. Strip walls to frame and provide bracing, studding, etc. as necessary. Replace damaged or deteriorated. materials in walls and make all exterior walls weathertight. Insulate walls to R-11.standards. 4. Flake all doors and windows ooegabie and weathertight. 5. Provide an adequate roof support system by adding rafters, ceiling joists and bracing as required. Remove and replace roof covering replacing all damaged or deteriorated sheathing. Provide adequate ventilation _and insulate to R- 19 standards. 6. Cleanup electrical wiring; eliminate all deteriorated or damaged wiring, outlet boxes and fittings; unprotected wiring; open or exposed splices, etc. Provide additional outlets as needed. 7. Provide adequate plumbing fixt:_►res with effective ,traps and vents. Provide proper supports for all drain.waste and vent piping. Provide proper leak free plumbing for alK drains, waste, vent, water and gas lines. 8. Remove and replace gas heater in living room. Verify that wood stove in bedroom is properly installed. 9. Provide adequate combustion air and proper flue for water heater, provide discharge line for temperature -pressure relief valve. 10. Provide wood to ground clearance on north side of house (newest portion). Regrade lot to divert water from slab and side of house. 11. Provide proper exterior siding on north end of house (newest portion). 12. Provide proper stairs for kitchen and..living room doors, and sliding door in bedroom. 13. Provide smoke detectors. The following items, although not required, are strongly recommended to effectively prolong the useful life of the dwelling, and/or to make, the dwelling more habitable. 1. Provide continuous concrete perimeter foundation. 2. Provide new cooling system. Equilla Stovall April 26, 1989 Paoe 3 Most of the corrections or repairs listed will require permits and inspections from the Butte County Department of Public Works. Permit= may be obtained at 7 County Center Drive, Oroville, CA. All.work shall be completed to the extent necessary to provide tle desired -finished product. This may require tile, linoleum, shinnies, wallboard, paint, vents, or whatever is necessary to accomplish the finished product. Should you have any questions, please feel free to contact�me at the above indicated address or telephone number. Sincerely, Howard Snyber, Director Division of Environmental Health HJS/mlf ccs Public Works — Jim Glander Connerly and Associates, Inc.,, 2215 21st Street, Sacramento, CA 959le Attachment i. CONNERL Y & ASSOCIA TES, INC. 2215 21 st STREET SACRAMENTO, CA 95818 (916) 456-4784. FAX: (916) 456-7672 A November 7, 2001 Fannie Tobias P.O. Box 5574 Oroville, CA 95966 RE: Equila Stovall/Butte County Home Repair Program.loan Dear Ms. Tobias: Thank you for submitting your assumption application for your Mother's home repair loan with Butte County. In order to continue processing your request, I will need the following items: • Signed "Information Release Authorization" for all persons on title - Catherine Harris and Florence Young • Sourte(s) of income for all persons on title - include complete mailing address(s) • Completed "Tenant Income Verification" and "Tenant Information Release Authorization" - Helena Heard As we discussed in our telephone conversation yesterday, the rules of this program governing rental properties and owners of rental properties are quite different from those for owner/occupied units. I strongly recommend that you explore the option of refinancing this debt with a conventional lender. Upon completion of the application process, I will present you request to the Loan . Committee along with my recommendation. I will notify you of their decision as soon as possible. Please feel free to call me at 1- 800-722-3436 if you have any questions. Sincerely, Karen L. Bull Loan/Escrow Officer Connerly & Associates, Inc., for Butte County Home Repair Program ear .r, 3041 Oro Bangor Hwy. Oroville, CA 95966 September 2, 2002 Connerly & Associates Inc. 2215 21s' Street Sacramento, CA 95818 Dear Mr. W. Connerly: I am writing this letter in reference to loan #34039 which was granted to Equilla Stovall who is now deceased. -She passed away on June 01, 2000. The Stovall family would like an adjusted pay off amount in consideration to the money taken by Carl Moore the Mr. contractor suggested/assigned by you. MMoore was the second contractor to work on t. . the house. There was also a first contractor, a Mr. Kevin Jones (who was also assigned by you), also took a considerable amount of materials that were supposed to be used in remodeling the home. We tried to report Mr. Jones and Mr. Moore. When I attempted to seek compensation for these losses, the State Contractors Board, informed us that there was only one $5000.00 bond purchased as insurance for all the homes that were being remodeled at that time. I have kept records or copies of paperwork showing monies that were`issued to Carl Moore in 1990; which totals to over $22,000,000 for Carl Moore and Kevin Jones. Marta. Sierra finished up with an additional loan or grant which wasn't enough to do all that was needed. The finished product in no way looks like a house repaired to the tune of $45,000. I was also promised money by you for my mother to live with me while the remodeling job was taking place. I never received anything. I had to forgo it because there was not enough money to finish the job because of the dishonesty of the first two contractors. I feel that I should be compensated for this and the losses resulting from Kevin Jones and Carl Moore's dishonesty. I'm asking for this to be shown"or reflected in the pay-off amount for this HUD loan, #34039. A copy of this letter is being forwarded to HUD and another copy to the Attorney General. I've been given the run-around regarding this matter for the last twelve years. If satisfactory results are not granted, I shall proceed with pursuing legal action. Sincerely, Fannie Tobias BUTTE COUNTY TITLE COMPANY ESCROW STATEMENT ), 194 EAST 611.1 STIIEET 1909 BIRD STREET P.O. BOX tCA Fon SKYWAY .1Ct:, CAt_IFonNIA 95926 � PAf1AO1 (91E. CAU -6268 A 95969 (916) 343.3716 P.O. BOX f1�1 (916) 877.6266 OROVILLE. CALIFORNIA Date - . November. 28,.199Q .... (916) 533-5511 Omer No....... 31256 PC. RE: Equilla Stovall o1ZRowER _--Qg>mty.of_ Butte _.___ --30+1--Qro_- ►ger Hwy c/o Connerly & Associates Oroville, CA., 2215 21st Street Sacto, CA., 95818 DEBITS I CREDITS De)osit io _Es.Qr-o_w------- Paid to Butte_ County Title Comanv 336 M - Paid to Eguilla Stovall and Kevin Jones 3,700 Qom_ _ Paid to_Diamo ►d.. Lumber.------------------- --1y 125- -8.& - 3ai-d--to-EquiUa-Sto-,aLL-&J)iamQnd- T a_1mber- Pa d tQ Equilla_..Stovall______._------- --12 46- ._ n 11cn nn Pai_d__to_..Kev_in_. Jon es e . o Esco<D�- -- - - --20-000 00-- _. ._ ------------=- ----.----- Gyz_1T...iMotolseQ ---Z7Z 00- -to o -Co-m--p-a-n-y-- MBOWACO...fu..Cat -- ---141000 0JD-. _Paid . Deposit_to.-escrow----"----------�-----.....---------------------- 9-(lnn D.0— Paid to _M9WAC0__.._____.____.._.._-0 2, 00 - Paid to _Carl_Moore_._for RichagxL.l2axb� �x�tlerall._.____-___--- - - Paid to -_ Eddie _.-____-__ 490 4Q_ _Mason Carl.. Moore---- - - - 74- --Paid_to Paid to - Carl Moore2,248 - - 76 —.-_.........._..-----._..__...-----------------..._...----------� Paid to Marta Sierra 2 000 00 s__to--Escrow—.--,- poit R_5(L 00 __De Paid to Diamond Lumber .- . _.._. _ ....___ .... - -- - -- 8 41 - _ _. Marta Sierra. ...._...... _... -- ----- - ----s Q -0 - Paid to - - -- Butte County__.Title•-Company_ .. ... ...__._.___.-._-_-__-____.____-_-0Q � -- Paid to Marta Sierra 4 000 _0 . -- --- - --- Paid to Butte County Title Company ___.._ ___.__ 40 0 -- Paid -to _ -_—_- Marta Sierra 509_.10 ---....------...--- ---- HEREWITH -- --- — - ----- TOTALS $ 45 500 00 , - - $ 45 500 00- --- enclose: BUTTE COUN`ITY TITLE COMPANY !�e,............................................................... Pat Castle/tg Esclow Officer