Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout30-4D GRIDLEY - BIGGS LITIG 1 OF 1d, 11 • ♦ I w �. L Vb• � .I.. O'r •.1 "Ir f� ••� • , O x ° A 1 ,A , • :red r• v + t r M 91. � o �P w i fl. .t + d!P .in •.' ` • �. .. ++op�, 4 u + �y y1 4 1 d II' .�nr 1 6AW � 1ZSI-I ffi MORRIS, 11VC. ,MCH,-FJIDGE, MAKSH r r�tr tl rt�ceY j . ,'I; a MAKYWILU. CJ .LIMKMA 95001 1� 0 Qe y�02 '7 li _. 4' Eumok S ATTORNEVO FOR Petitidhe " VU40 C wwYr �4 R JuN 8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE 5TP.TS OF „CALIFORNIA 91 " IN AN 4 BUTTE , D FOR THE Cat�N'1'Si OE .. .. 10 CITY OF GRIDLEY, a MunicipalNT 11 Petitioner ) NOTICE OF COMMENdtMg V5. ),. OF PROCEEDING 12 )i, RESOURCES CGDE 521,167 5)�_`_, r,, CONTY OF BUTTE, a CUVernmental c' 13 entity; 'BUTTE COUNTY BOARD OF ) SUPERVISORS, BUTTE COUNTY j 1� PLANNING ComMISSIOr, and DOES I ) through X, inclusive, ) 15 ) /�y� {/ . - Respondeft8, 16 17 TO RESPONDENTS AND TO THE'BUTTE COUNTY COUNSELS 18` PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the City of, Gridley, a Municipal 19 I' ,'t!orporation, has prepared and sent for filing to the-Butte 20 ..ounty Superior Court a Petition for Writ of Mandate and =Writ, of 21 Administrative Mandate filed, in part, pursuant to Public 22 Resources Code, Section 21167, Said action is based upon the 3 zoning ordinance co,m,,only known as the Gridley-Sicggs Rezone, 24 ,adop..ed by the Butte County Board of Supervisors on or about Ma 25 18, 1982, and for which a Notice.of Determination under the 26 California Enviromental Quality Act was f1led on May 191 ,1982., 27 said Petitior w;111 be served upon you upon issuance of, � q � rt.` i j � •, V 0 1 sumto xa's b the: but 1:6 County S�apr�� r�r Court Clerk. U` {`s 2, DA' S'Ds J+ate 3► 1982:. R cR, Mbdt, MAttpk a TiJRI X9 0. INd r _ r s q_ NL DA 'D R.' LANE, At"oxneyn�t3 �►»e 7 8 f� A 9 , �` 10 12 13 W �'o� M a 16 19 2q 21 22 23 24 z$ 2 -z -= Q 13 mental impacts, resp6ki,dent :BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING GUT�ixss Was• ; ` e" =Y � 1�i. I required torrepare r�°• envi.�onmertal impact report by 144 , u z rz u ^ rT{ .N � ° o N Cal'iforn`ia Admini t a9.i;Ve Code 515084 to Iden"txfy the s gt�xf - �-' a' a rt + I N iJ c ` w i 1G cant effects of a pta;e,:t on tti`e environment, identifyalterna 17 tives to the -,,.project End to indicate the runner in which such sC ` is, significant effects r,., be mit"gated or avoided as rlequited by t9 Public Resources Code §§ 21002 and 21002..1. y 20 10i Respondent 5,,, -.TE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS was under 21 a mandatory and mini,-w•�rial duty ii -posed by state law including; 22, but hot. limited tO , %'q blit Resources Code §§ 210020 21002.1, 14, 23 California Admini t:r t�'ve Code 515011.6, and 14 California 24 Administrative Coda 5IS'J8`8; not to approve proferts as proposed if there axe feasible ,alternatives or f25 easible measures avail- 2 able Vfhich would Liubs-4p.nU.i°ally. Jessen the sicInificant environ 27 mental effects of sick projects. "3" 1 I within the same the; rzea'l property located within the unincoa:- 2 ''porated area of r0"sV:r)n6e It BUTTE COUNTY and within, the .sphex6 of 3 influende of pets. ,'J: aXexl;,,i i �I -PROOF OF SERVICL BY MAIL CCP,10130, 2015.51 declare thdP Yuba «. .�,... CaPCOMI-a. 2; 1 sen Sa midy►rljoF/sjnnicayed inj'the zounty o('._ ,.« .. 1tci3k4v`iw+cnni�' »„ 1 «.. « t i; g c:: y i$i t' my (builm /rssidaraoe)'ad e.. ei htsen yearsand no4 n parry to the with+n cap: Z5 D. °reet Nla�vSvillet Califtarn a e , $t NOTxE' O]i� Ctit�`*dE�C3EN'i�� , 1,� « K1,{ves3 the wsthin ....«....w. «�.�....ww.,. »w .� ....»;...«w., tZ>pRbCEE rNO (V6'Z TC RE81t, 1A ES.L i tl biE+ tb �ti ' 21 .«..».........«...«..., ` ..w....w.w On 7re11.«r....:....»w.........«w.•.w«w.«+..... .+.�:..+� ....r..u....wut.nwiw.www» .o M li 1. roaf enclosed 1n a ►.clod envalbpa with psetog thtty F f�tNY'i 6w+n 'tit in laid trust, by�'p acing a f a cOpy'th n ` : f . � hlatysvil.�e, Ca7.xft�rn�.a F United Statist mt�1 `?• ., LANNING COi+it�lIsStON _ BUTTE L4��NT� `` 7 C�►unty QinveDrive _ OroVJ116e,, Calif6 is ;95965" 22' Bu te, Iwounty dierk/Tux o i �io i $rJTT ^��UId Y 50ARD OF SVPERVISORS i 25 Cou�t`.�ty Center D`riv Orovil5 e, Calif'cirn .a 5.5965 �COUNTYCOUNSEL 15 COUNT1j QV BUTTE' , 25 Colux*ty Cutter Dtive lb OrovilAe, California 95565 i 17 21, 22 I dsci�ON under penalty of perjury tliot' the foregoing is true ai;d correct, and that this doaioraillon was oxecuted,00 r 24 jurle, 3l 1582 lto f « . «.:.a of .California!+ ..wH.....t u::......:..w.::- , ...... ....... .. . » .. ... «.::::.« 6CO 6 "Coileen A. Clay , ):...a+ .ua:u.a.a a...a..t idtldlAiUHfi. o- - �, RtPi: p11FNIN't PLoaM ;No. ti-S �t�mreMays► rnit�'aniO sUPY O i p.. r ....r..�....,, 1KASA� A1:dl AiJ41RE5S OFA'fTr3wNEY: "fE6E�0iJti Nqt 7dj 2-. 's t3R cturtr usr c+tw: ICH f rUIDGE, MARSHA MORkS,,r IiIC. 1129 D. SEre to Maryswi'ile,, California 95901 po ef?hc+zae: (9 10 r` 1,2-73'7.3 l� h rb 0y Fb cae+t,ei; PP i On e / inter¢;rntrme r�i xbwt .jrW�e4i�t� rrriet +r� ir7�+nktw t4mm it any. end Poli Wire"' ntl �trelC i�{�tlnezti ° d SUL�ERl CC1t3itT OP T�dL : STATE OP CALIFORNIA �e r y d0,:;BUTTE" y „ I��� �l#�1i`i' I"AR ',�',H3E C�lPJ1;�C'�` „" r trUA'0FF. CITY AF GRIDttt° a Ainicipal t orporation ji , 1Y� „ oFftxoANT. COUNTY OF(,,`:PlJT i1, a Gove'rnmentaal entity; BUTTE CO' QTY b'A'Ab tr r SUPBRVXSbRS, IIUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSTON, and DOF,S" �t�ix>�'t1�k;t� tntlnsiv (i, 1 j l Ji T.IOt. ;FOR Cn'RIT EASE NU E 4 '. ��i C� �. Off' MANDATE ET �..._ .., ..:_....�..,. t .... hCOTiCE! You hpve been . utd� The',Court may decide i�lVIS01 Ucted he aido dehtZ�t►duda, El' xrits(ittat puede T c ay�pinsR ou �+ith utyoUrbeing heord unless you respond daetdtr contra t7d, ..sire sudlehvtp :� znert�+lt quo Hrlthin 3St d>yyt, idea -,jtie infort"Uon below. s.ponda'dentro a 'M{oa=;.e Yiti intormatcl rn iq ee�i`jtae. 'it yo0 w6sh to seek'�hi 6vice of art rMorney In this S1 Usted dr-,sea solicitar ieic6ha)j;o de un aboOado fn matt6, you thowid do so promptly to t►,tat your written este asur,to, dr�eria hacerlo inrnet�iatettiente, de ait>1 ' tesponse,'.if any, maky bt* "tilted an'titnl, man+*ra, su respuesta esarita, st hayl pa, Auede tft 'tegisirada a tiempn, .>. l< 1'.-TO 'TJHE t:IEFEN©ANTt A civil dbh)0l9ini.has been filetl ty the plai:ttiff a9i3inst you. It you with to defend this lawsuit; you,mltst, !nw thin 39 ;days atter this summons is served on you, with this.court a written restiohse to the CO-plreint. Untett you do so, your default wiltloe watered or, applicat!on of the"plaintift, and this court, may :enter A JUOgrntrit i-agaimst,you for the relief demanded in the complaint, whieh could result In carnishmenl n5'wages, taking of money .or propctly or ort►gr reilgti regUem d inthe crtmplalnt, ,�. tLCAi� ,DF NI. ,BECKER '� 1982 fu! . SIMMONS 61 =-----+- 2.'NQTICf To THE PERSON SERVED: You: ar! served "(SEAL) ' ry„ [] As an �indiv;dual detet)tJttnt, Ib, { As ih't person sued under than fictitious rand Of' c. fJn behr?Ito t:. . . . . . � ;CCP 4 ii,5[ ,(Minorj, r alnderz ,[� CCP 416,10�(Corporatlon) CCP 416.7 Incompetent} l� a.,, • t © CCp 416,2(Def, ct Corporation) � 'i. ( CGP 416.0 (, iatlon of r'arthershlp) GCP 416.90 (individual) Othart r ., d, = ,bY perRwnal delivery.ort :(Date); A writttn r,±tpo nil mutt be in the form pretttrbed by the Geidornu'Kules of Court, h mutt. tib f�leC in tmt churl witn the pipp,!r td n� 8ee anp proof of. teivme o1 a Cavy On @ach.piaintrt'.e'•1}od off tend on 66th plaintiff to repreter10 r an attorney the time when a tummivt t oots-co terve ;ton a barb+-may wAfy tlepeW11Ag bh 1he.method n serwce Fnt a►ampls, see CGP 413 td tnrnugn 415 3J The wor,: ",Complpml' rncluot5 t rots•comptetnt, "t,{trntit 'Intiuoetrttitp ' imptii maht, *,poiandant" inetUtleL drott•oelendant. the e,apultrimwdes the plural (tbtie revetee for P.fboi al ° rrrlte) _ . r:! M 10,t, NiAKSf4 6 'NiC'iKKM lt4C- l �r�rs�ttu�* «i�i3tt JON �atii 7�7lyT2Y1 By ' S �ikt4tvs ton Pett t3 anex cc B„t4a+Cw1�1i� JON SUPERIOkCbUf2 y b P�Lx Ol�1�I r,y CO YXTX '0>'„ �i�"i"1'E t. .. Cj-'Y ;OF GR�CDVEY, a Munn' � ? corp'ora'tion,10 Y F vs,. pMA� Er lAt� D WRIT- 22 COUNTY Off' BUTTE, a, Ge�vernmental ) �AD 9I�NISTRATIV97HAI% j! , 13 `.�. entity; B'U'TTE Coctr��r'�' $OAAb 0�' } , F S�jpERVjSOj.k$ , BUTTE COUNTY +' 4 • 14 PLANNING COMMISSION ,# and DOES I '? through X, InclusiVe,, l , 1 Resp�nderits 16 V7 Petitioner allegest. i{ 18 FIRST .CAUSE OF ACTION y (Violationof C.S,Q.A.) << �. 20 1.. At all. times h4 �:ein mentioned petitioner was a munic� > t:c�rptlxatilon duly authorized and existing under the laws of 1 Za the State 'o£ California and being an incorporated city vrithin ' 13, the connis of the County of }butte, , At a I 7: tlm,4d s herein mentioned,, respondent COUNTY AP 2j HUT'TE Wa ► and ik�w .is a chartered county oz'gabized .and a fisting ; 2G under. `dna by virtue of the `Cojj stitution and tliz laws of ,the f 11, Stat- of Californ 'D ,;t IJ - At all ti nY s herein mentioned, respondent RORD OF 0�ih(1pEItVi t SO.R OF TqE COUNTY OP BUTTE was and now is the '"ally � .�_ ' a"the- 4 uty., ., ai�ng. ted boc_y of said county charged 3c0i8txtusufficiency Of repOrt a U and determining the othersi ofrearrVII zi alt 1 c, env roz menta XMP -act studies performed for pr�jects p z +�rrned within the confines within 'thin the County ole Butte and adoptiziq <"d sheeting zonz o_d'n ii ances in .com lant�e­ with the ifia , Cai£orlia. 8, St&° o Q.,.., At all times h irein, mentio»ed, responder l: 1Q PLAKN NG CCIiMMISsloN was end now a s ., legally .constitu »a,.=` 0. y charged with the duty 'of planning for Bette County putiv t, to 11 _ '' ; 12 GoveriYrner�t :Gods X65150 and is eine of the responsible agEnca�.. a i3 for conducting hearings and mak�.ne� findings on envie nmei�ta�. o �w . of :Butte id impact 'reports prepared for projects within the Coon y acewn 2 °z ^+ iS as defined by Public Resources Code 521069. < a o i6 5,: The idealtity and capacity of .re'spotidentis sued he���.n as . U; � r 17 Dues I through. X, inclusive, are unknown to petitioner, who t such, fictitious nap"'I Their 2 1S therefore suers said respond6nt's by ities, whether it be governmental entities, p�l names and capac .., persons, associations, joint 0 p tQnturers partnerships, carpora�- tions, and/or read, partifts in int21 i rest hereto, will be set forth II -11 -ten the same have been :ascertained. es ondent BUTTE COUNTY PLAP.NxNG COrZi GSYON proposed to 23 areas of Butte County located within Assessor#s Book Nos. 24 rezone the . � axI" 25 11 9, 10 ?l, 22, - ,;4 and 25, enco�rpassing, geneYally es cf But county' .commonly Ynown as the Gridley -Biggs area 24 ' 27 surroun&!,ng the city limits of pet'tiooer and encompassing -2- 4� ll. Respondent` BUTTE COII4TY BLANKING COPl1!iISSION failed to I 2 c. h prepare a ettvrc,ncne�i�a]; �mpaot report for thy. rezone prool.n .i 3' which, COMPlitd Tait, the provisions 'of, the Ca,lifoVklt& tnvitbh- 1atd mentai t2ua'Yity Act the State and County guideine+. adoiated ,5 pursuant thereto. Peti'tioher is inforni ed and helees anal '+ 6 tho:�Obn :alleges that d purported e0v ronmental impact ttpotl � 7 prepared ;for ,a &.0ezal Van amendaient.to tf4 ,txitte CdUnny pian Was revised and modified irk part jj,respn ►detat �`' ;/ General BUTTB COUNTY MANNINO i OMM'SS7ON in an attempt to crunb3y wit� i ' I the .requirements of the California ErivironmenOI Qualify Acten Z 11 the guidelines adopted thereunder. However, pebit.rriier` s.s `n 12 informed and believes and th()reon alleges 'that said BnVironw mental impact Report diad not address► the project as fina.l,y O ,� 13 �.. ,. rices b6tWee0 proposed and omitted to discuss significant da ffewe Z rd z, _ id a W' `, x �_ • ' i d the rezone project as thy; Project discussed by' said report a,�r „ = N a;�, a a n y Y p Y BOARD OF SUPERVISORS finally ador�ted b res ondent BUTTE COUNTY N a wr 0 161. 17 12. Respondent BTITTB COUNTY PL T COD4MiSSION recoirit►3eindd to the respondent BUTTE COUNTY BOARD OF &O1�5 that the r: 1g 19 t Board of supervisors approve the rezone proposal. w thc�ut mitt:-� U. significant environmental impacts which were c'�wsed by 20 crating said proposal., some of which impacts were specifically i.dent -� 21 fied 'the environmental impa�,t report. 22 t ,in , 13-. The COUNTY OF BUTT %, by and through its duly authorf:zci� 23 24 representativrsx respondiant BUTTE COUNTY,PLANINTNd COlg4XSSION and , respondent BUTTE COUNTY BOA" OF SUPERVISORS is under a mandato 25 duty to deny' approval and to not Carry out a project where 26 ry ?the environmental impact report identifies one or'more x 27 -4 _. 61 , (L- significant etfects unless changds or alterations ,in the. project 2 have been required which mitigate`�ar atloid the dighifioent s environmental effects Or sp�irciio ecpr►amic, social ox tathex , " t:onsidexationr make infeasible the m` �igation mbssurbis or 5 projecta-1."!o- , natives identified in the `tial, e'�t roitimasntsi I�6 1)7 impact report by ,the provisions of the Ca`ifo EnViront"Oent's . 7 r �.nc].ut3 �nq, but Quality Act and its � i'` s guidelines adopted' tke g g i ; V ' not limited to, Publio Resources Code 521041 ex, 14 Califoteii& 9 Administrative Code §1508$•, 10 14. on or about May 18, 1982, ,res on'derit Witt CO0NT. It by z 11 and through respondent BUTT'B COUNTY BOARD'' F SUPERVx5bR8, f 12 adopted an ordinance approviAq and carr in o,,t the rezone a' Cl $ 13 pvoposal. and purporting to reic�ne the subject real.- property w x" u 14 accordance therewith. ti sv 15 15, On May 19, 1982, respondents filed a Notice di beteC- 0 0 „� W d W'a � N a _ 16 minat,Lon of the rezone ro osal determinin that the proposal g project,, 17 will h- e a significant effect on the project and adopting; 18 certain findings entitled "ove,rriding cons iderations,"`'a copy "'of u , 19 which Notice of Determination is attached hereto, marked EXliibit U _ 20 " ,�' corporated herein by reference. ) A and ir,, , ' 21 1.6. saia Notice of Determination is defective and entored 22 into in violation of the requirements of the California thvieon- Y i 23 '^ Ihental Quality Act for the reasons set forth above and for the 24 further reasons that the "overriding cohsidera'tions" are not 2$ fadtuall.yt true and do hot authorize the approval of this projdot y 26 inastiww,gh as feasible alternatives which have less sighifica'nt ', 27 effects .gin the environment are available: c 17, publ ,v 2 168,,provides that is Resources. Lader. 'Section., <<� ` 1 2 r l a doter`mina� actions to attack, teviow set aside void or aftnu tion finding or decision of the Butte County 'BO�rd,of Supervi� sora andyj the County of Butte for fa(iItire to comply ^ ith th'& iY -, 5 provisions- of the California ZnvIedtental Qualit Acts Coder Section 21000 et se'gt shall be l�rou+ht.`by W�ty of 7 adm nwstrative mandate pursudntJ to Code of Civi 'Pr6c6dure,_ :! " x section 1Q94.5 c, 9SMOND __GTlorI CAUSE OFA1 10 Mitigation Y (f'a'ilure i o Follow Miti ation Measures IRecommend�d b ; >a�1R}° c� 11 a 18, paragraphs 1 through 17 of the Virst Cause of 4ct;ion ,�� 12 are incorporated by refer -sr ce: C 1 p p or the,rezone, 19 fine Environment�il xm act Re ort Pden . • el 14 proposal identified severa]. specific significantenvironment ►:� x N 15 g, same of the mitt ation effects which: should be mitt ated g aa,+aq 0 5 16 prnPosed',.by the Environmental Impact :Report called dor z spori� � 17 dent COUNT`: oP BUtTE to meet with e -'%-consider the needs and 18 desires of the other public agencies -affected by the proposed L� 19 project _including petitioner herein and the effect of the 20 influence. project ra ect on petitioner's sphere of �.n . i0. The general plan adopted by the COU13T`i OP BUTTE recogw 21 21 22 ni es the necessity. to coordinate the developrAent of land in a " <' 23 cyty`s sphere of influence with the city in order to provide .for 24 the azderly development of the city in 1,ight of the proposed 25 1 probable future anneuati.on of the sphere of ,influence to the 26 cities involved. " 27 -7 • �A F . t 21.. A reasonable alternative to m?tigate the s]gnificant u �" 2 - environmental effects within the sphere of influence of het' 3 II tioher would, be the forva6tiofi oi' an urea planning oonnmis&,,6,n. aS, ded by ,Government Code :665600, et',seq 22. Resji dents failed to utilize "the x0itig6tibn mea'tua yad6ps ctho2 6 (( 'et forth "in the environmental impact, report and 6d, 7 N0 'Xce of Determination sets forth above 3n violatio of +y CI g a requ` rements of the California Enviroftantal Qual.it Act' ` � and 9 refused to mitigate the significant* enviro men al: effect ► it h oh could have been miticrated WitL , the 6kpr`ess statement 'by irrt*mbers U 11 of the BOTT9 COUNTY HOARD OE' SUPtRV1SOAS that,, these effeota, ` f -- 12 might be mitigated at some time in the future,: a"11 of whish .s" - „ Z� in violation p ' y respo`nsibil" of `�e5 ondents r,►andsi.or duties and 41.4 ities. N x,N'l5 2�i The rezone proposal adopted by the Butte County $oard 16 of SupetVisor6 violates the General Plan adopted by Butte County, V Juj r 17 1 and State lad in that it pr6vides for ''leap frog developmehVI", 1�. and causes significant adverse environmental impacts, upon Eutte w. JA 19 County and upon Petitievner herein includirigi but not limizked td* 26 severe drainage problems which cclxld have been but were hob 21 mitigate significantly by folk "ing the mi �gatian rec0ra ridaw 22 tions contained in the EYR ,and by adopting )roposals by Peti_ 23 tioner 'during the hearing process on the E'IR and the adoption of 24 the rezone proposal. 25 MUSE -210 Or —ACTION 26 (violation of Government code 566302) 'x 27 240 Paragraph, 1 through 22 are incorporated by reference, -7 .:9- 1 251. R, bpondent, COUNTY OV 1301M'E is required t6 adopt a 2 General plan for the physical developmentI i*�f the dounty pursuant s , 3 to GoveVnment Code, Sedtion 55100. I' C 4 {i 26a the Goneral Plan 'to be adopted by Resp&Aent CC1UNTk O 5 Omit, is required hl dovethmeht Cods 8edt'lon 65302 to ihciude -6 certain mandator elements inoluain but7inot S 9', limited, for an, 7 open spate element which must consist of a diagrain and,.text U 8 which setforth objectives, tines, prihdipals and plat proposals`. 9 20;« The open spabe element of the Butte County GehdtIbl 10 Plan .does not comply with the requirements of 'lata in that its z i1 contains no diagram or plan settxna forth � � ` 3esitnattd open space . 12 are4s', and is further in violation ,in that the same reflects and oC' 13 recites that prime agricultural land must be piceterIvedi but ip X S,W 14 makes no adequate provisions therefor, 'M � IV MIRTH CAUSE Off`,,ACTION N �j h 16 (violation of Government Code. 565300.5) 17 28 Paragraphs. l throU h 27 are, incorporated by refer'ericj. g p " k 18 29 Government Code Section 65300.5 provides that -the 19 General Plan and elements and parts thereof should comprise an 20 intergrated and internally consistent and capable statement of 21 policies. 22 30 The Butte County General Plan and. the elements end, 25 parts thereof are not ,interhally ;consistent when considered as 24 one comprehensitte plan and therefore Eesr+ondent COUNTY OF SUITE, 25 does -not have a general plan in effect: as mandated by roe;+ernment 26 Cede Section 65300, ' 27 PTVTH CAU88 OF ACTION .:9- 19 SIXTH CAUSE 6r,ACTION 20 (Violation of Conf.1' of Interest Provitiob.$) 21] 34o Paragraphs I through 2.3 are, ih.,orporated by reference., 22 45. lkespOndent, Butte County Planning. Commission and I 2Respondent BUtto CbUhty Board of supervisot.t. are required to 3 - -eA- 24 hold a public heariw4 on the sufficieAcy of the EIA and on the 2$ Proposed Zo I' ng Amendment purttant tb the requirementsnts 14 27 (Violation of Goverhnleht Code 665860) 31. Paragraphs I throijgh 30 are lncorp6rated\�by rdifereilc-, 3,32`d `GbVernment Cc�db Section 65860 providez that r�oifa'ty 4 zoning, otdir.&-n6es. shall be consistent with the general Phan dt 5. the county and further provides that an. action �o 6, nildtc:6, 6 compliance with this requirement may be brought withtv---O days 7 of the rinact of an y new zoh'Ing ordinance. or timeridmer) td any a e'kisft:ihcj ioning ordinance by a proceeding for a i4tit` Of btidal: under the proVisibns of Section 1084 Code;j of, Civil 'xbrbcqur.*,(� 33. The zoning proposal adopted by' the Butte doUAY B64A Z11 of supervisors on, may 180 1982 is not consistent with the 12 County General Plan (assuming for the purpose of argument that 13 Zutte county ha's a Oeneral Plan) in that it does not preserve in 14 prime agricultural land, call6 for,Ileap f-rbq de'Vdlopment"* 'U [me U M 0-- 1$ _ails to ,Ifi6ite adequate provision for drainage,, -Of ptdpekty, and %D fails to cona4,6pr the General Plan of Petitionor and the needs U17) of Petitioner for the future, logical development of the titj 5 a L. . I 18 within Petitioner's current sphere of influencei 19 SIXTH CAUSE 6r,ACTION 20 (Violation of Conf.1' of Interest Provitiob.$) 21] 34o Paragraphs I through 2.3 are, ih.,orporated by reference., 22 45. lkespOndent, Butte County Planning. Commission and I 2Respondent BUtto CbUhty Board of supervisot.t. are required to 3 - -eA- 24 hold a public heariw4 on the sufficieAcy of the EIA and on the 2$ Proposed Zo I' ng Amendment purttant tb the requirementsnts 14 27 California Admi.rtistrative Code, Sections 16564 4,.'".65 Ad, W 2 Glpverhment (Zcde sections 65054 and 65054.5. (f 36. ,XOMbersof Respondent, ` Butte Cbi my Planning Cgmmit, 4� 4 siori acre ro cquired, to comply with the conf',lict 6f �interebt 1aW,� S the Political Reform Act of the State of ,Califo'tnia by 0OVVrn ment Code; section 87200. 3 7 Government Code section 87100 pro`v'ides- tho't no g blie g i official shall. make, p,hrticipate� in. making ox in any, ,way attem Pt 91 to use his official position to irif.luence a t781-0 nmeiYta-1 deci-•.� y 10 sion in which ,;ham knows or has reason to knoO he has yA it nancia l Z12 36. putte County ;Planning Comr ssi.oa ea RAS, WHE8LtR, had ' financial intexe�3t as definedy code section 87101 � `z is he ro +rt �►o�t% more. in the rezone proposal i t p � y �x vW o ^ 1 � than. $1,000.00 directly affected by the decision on the 5016torld d J In d a 6, w �6' S p the proposal. �.:d Comlr�.ssa.oner disclosed the existence of yy� a- 17 conflict S5f interest but, in violation of Gov*62:nment Code, ; section ;87100 'participated in mak.incj and attempted to use his 19 znce a governmental decision affecting official position to influf p y r -. 20 . the rezoning of this parcel. , 21 35. ',the rezones proposat recommendea by the Respondent 22 Butte County Vlanning Comtni:ssion and adopted by Butte COtInty'` 3 Board of supervisors was tea oted by this violation of Ohv�,irnment 24 Code, section 87100 and the entire h'eari-ala. process leading to 2j the recommendation and the adoption rendered void by virtue' :26 I thereof in that the real property owned by Cotnmissioner- MF, C 27. WHE1jtV, Was zoned 7f:jr residential develop ►s:iht, which znning G I `Io- ' " r�^ w constitutes "leap frog" zoning and serves to place agricu'l'tural t 1 ,land in a zoning for residential deNhalopment 40 By virtue .of the foregoing, the entl'ra hearing ;pepptut has been violated and the adoption of the xoniag prop©sal in thio first instance is ,v614 :for refusal and failure.' to comply 'with,) u mandatory procedural requirement's for the adopt-ion'of I�'th6' SEVEN'r1I CAC�SE b' AC'i41v (Violation of the WI -Il' is }tson Act) 41. Paracprapha l througyi 23 ark""} 3,icorporatedy refexex0e. 42. Retpond.ent Butte. County adopted b:� itesolut.'on 110 ° 67W17b on December 5, 1967 the provisions of Gt3i�`ernn: ne C0d`,� Section 5X:240 fort;the preservation of agricultural Jl Ind, cc►mmcm� ly )tnbwn as the "Williamson Act". 1. 43. Pursuant to `the Willia!Asoh Act, ,Respbndeht! Butte Obuhty, adopted a Trap setting forth 6gricu ""vura1, preservof4 within the, bounty of Butto, including agri,cultural preserveb 40 5 t and 6 which encompass portions of the propeir'iy, v,"icrf is tb subject of the rezone proposal 44, 0overnment 'ode, Secta.on 512 0 provides PIat the viae of any land located within an agricultural press rvP 11a,denti,f5ed by a 'County and hot under a' "Williamson Act dbhtrart"' shat)., 4ithin two years of the ,effe6ctive d6te of aby oohiiract on 1 -mad within the, Country be restricted by coning or other seitbblo, means in such a way as not to be ;ineoripati.bl.e with the agticutural use ox the land, covorhmont Code Section 511*( , defines "agridUlt'ural use" to be use o land .46r the purr,, procluctnq -an agricUl:tural cbnmodity for corbetcial, purp 12 $. 13 14 ZVIQ O IT y : 19 20 " r�^ w constitutes "leap frog" zoning and serves to place agricu'l'tural t 1 ,land in a zoning for residential deNhalopment 40 By virtue .of the foregoing, the entl'ra hearing ;pepptut has been violated and the adoption of the xoniag prop©sal in thio first instance is ,v614 :for refusal and failure.' to comply 'with,) u mandatory procedural requirement's for the adopt-ion'of I�'th6' SEVEN'r1I CAC�SE b' AC'i41v (Violation of the WI -Il' is }tson Act) 41. Paracprapha l througyi 23 ark""} 3,icorporatedy refexex0e. 42. Retpond.ent Butte. County adopted b:� itesolut.'on 110 ° 67W17b on December 5, 1967 the provisions of Gt3i�`ernn: ne C0d`,� Section 5X:240 fort;the preservation of agricultural Jl Ind, cc►mmcm� ly )tnbwn as the "Williamson Act". 1. 43. Pursuant to `the Willia!Asoh Act, ,Respbndeht! Butte Obuhty, adopted a Trap setting forth 6gricu ""vura1, preservof4 within the, bounty of Butto, including agri,cultural preserveb 40 5 t and 6 which encompass portions of the propeir'iy, v,"icrf is tb subject of the rezone proposal 44, 0overnment 'ode, Secta.on 512 0 provides PIat the viae of any land located within an agricultural press rvP 11a,denti,f5ed by a 'County and hot under a' "Williamson Act dbhtrart"' shat)., 4ithin two years of the ,effe6ctive d6te of aby oohiiract on 1 -mad within the, Country be restricted by coning or other seitbblo, means in such a way as not to be ;ineoripati.bl.e with the agticutural use ox the land, covorhmont Code Section 511*( , defines "agridUlt'ural use" to be use o land .46r the purr,, procluctnq -an agricUl:tural cbnmodity for corbetcial, purp 4 5 . '5 8, Gov ernment Code, section 51231, 5J.23t3, and - 2 i i r�equres �he county to adopt rulers conce'rning the ,$dmin'6trat3.an those V 3 of . a rigultalra3. - � g uae�i gouhdi g preserves, lncludihq��defihin 4 .. � to be compatible uses tri a9kict1�',,tUral�uso. P%irs'uant to 'thid e Sf}'sequirement, Rest, CauntS of Bute 6 t(�)qh Res.pOhjt'.0. h. \ toaxof5U eri6a.es adop t.6d Reso]ution No."" 6gW fioBUttCounty x lahuar 16, 19'�said SresolUtion prcvigod lm part ithat�� a. a minimum area for,,a„ compatible use shall be ten (10) a'Pzes (With g a certain exception under` which a fine (5)` acme minir�uK'�Oeay ,-a, 1p canaid f:re ' )` limiting the nu'inbexl of die') l.;ings .to one U 11 � in vlit per ten (10 acres a; a` m'.n mum ar.d: fUtth' . � � � t j � �� 12 in that certain other g uses aly"e compatible uses in ate aaricul 0 � �� 13 tural preserve. t. 14 16 Petitionets are informed and believe and taier,*611. — W pg� M ' N IS allege that contracts were entered i��to 4��.. uant to tU�. g - Z. 86 r 2 a 6� W 16 - Wi1li.amson Ac's in butte County tnilliamaon Act; Agricultural ,f' 17 preserves 4#5, and 6 mire than two years prior to the adoption % 'A�, 1� of, the rezone proposal, 1y 47rhe rezone proposal is in violation of the k1aamson , " 20 Act in that it does not make provision for the pteseriration 01' �I agricult�:01a 1 lands and zone property in a way which X it incoio',W 22 patible with the agi:icu1tuxal U06 of lana ,r3 thin an agricu"1r`.u:zal 23 preserve specified by the County of Butte , and directly► attgttpts td urbanize the agricu!W-ral airess wit'hx.ri ,aq-icultu.ral pre 2S Serves. " ",M �1, �AttoYno�►,s k'ees} V 11 i c. 48, paraq ph5, l through A7 are introrporated by:fezenc�. 2 0. Tni: i .petition for Writ of Mandate and 59r� t �, 14dmixii s- 1 R trative MandAitwas brotight by Tostitionex}.t e an(�xm�aar-« , 4 tart; right affecting the public interest and to conez _ g? icer: benefit on al,l residents it Hutte Countyo in+cluding#, but 61 not limited to, residents withiis t Q1 corporate confizx6s I 7 Petitioner and the acts of Respondents vpmplai4pd of are',big , trary, capricious and in vitiation of �Wl by virtu'a rthtr6ot* Petitioner is enii3ed tb *torney's fees pursuant to r4Yrent 10 Code Section 800t Codle of Civil. Procedure Section l0 l.9"It' aha" z 11 the Private Attorney Geier6i Conceptapproved by the, CiAforhia O ''1� ,_. WHP#2EF6,, it is respectfully `kaquested that`': t. �, 1 Cowtt is`Sue a Writ of Mandate`,,irec;tit g that the X It. a,2 � w. :, h a " 15 `' action taken b the Hoard of Su erviso�s o r Y p Nevada. County in,, .N c` 2 16 adopting the razone proposal be declared null and void. 17:: 2. Respondents be oommanded to promptly and diligentlyol" _ 16 proceed ta,,tako all action end do all acts necessary to`enforce Ig and ;imp"Mt nt a proper gener'a1 plan and proper zoning thereunder, ddsignates and preserves prime ai gric ltural. ]sand ,�hd`W ich i 21 mitigat�,s 6,11 adverse ehviromehtal effects. 3* tot the issuance of an Alternative -Writ of Mandate 23 Cow6vai.ng Respondents to perform the acts req -tested abr5ve or tej j show cause before the Court at a specified time and place why 2 they have not done so tpon appl.icstion by Petitioner 2G 4� Vor attorneys' fees incurred: • �' 5, ror costs, of suit incurred horoin :13 w ': 6. Fox` suk h other and ihirther relieg as the Court may ,40,14 DA : J ui�l.e xD 3 , X 82 DAVID R o - ,LANE' 7 Att'arneyt for petttichot i :a is �w z(. 14 A � �o4�W` AG 20 l i� 2 2 �r26 2 �.� . r .1 . µ.,�, MOM "'MAPLSH INC, J \J` lith'. 6 i 7 ►WltA".cit21 ft 3 lrtr►toNe ��,,; ,els ,w�► 1 a4. 41 80p$9JOR COry>izx OF TUt STATE OF c�IrC7R14tA p9 IN AND FOR11 THE dbwkY or W � CTT`at` Or ORIDLEY, a MunicipalNo. 18143 1 Corpvrai�:rn, ��' Petiticiri r ? DE�:l,A1�ATIONS 0V OM&AWNS 13 ` 131ifle k " . sal , p CCit�NTy,'?OV bUTtt, a Gov rnmi t ; ✓�'' \ ld ` SuPElkVI 6Rb,EBUTTETCOUNTYDPLANN1�JG ) JUN � ' 11 1 1$ COMM!SGiId1'r, and DOES I through X, � Carovsl�r C+skfo� inclusIve, ` I, des onde 17 18 "` I, COLLM A. CLAY, state and declAxe as follows. 19', I am tie secretary i a,a OA`vtb 17. LANE, the attorn!y 20 for the Petitioner in the above entitled action. ` 21 bue to inadvertence, the attached mxhibit "A", entitled, n � r :1 11Ndti.ce c,£' Determination" was omitted from the Petition for V I 25 Wrat of Mandate and Writ of Admini.stra.tivo t-iandate, which shoUl d I' 24 be mado; a part of said original, 25 ` 'l declare under penalty of perjury that the 90tdgcih5 26' is tj"ue and correct 7 L7 r Executed on at1he 'fir 19$2,�ajytJy14azysva�ls, �ralifoxni,�. APPENDIX H OF DETERMINATIMI TP Sectotar�! for Rotoutces L 'E 1416 Ninth Street, Rooin 1311 h Sactameritoi CA 95814 44Y 1 9-lgo� 4)t, c6uftt� Clerk Count), of Butte 25 County Ce�iet Drive ELEANO SC R, ly C1*k Orovillo, „CA 99965 PROM;; Planning Dep&r4ont 7 County Center Drive Filed) Orov.Plao CA 99965 8UVtCT4 Filing of,Notice of D&termitatio,n. in Compliance wi'th �tojoct Title am on,'16;ral, Plan,, Amen ent- tutte Co., pl�`nning CO,mm.' drlidxey' "l,earitighouse Number (If submitted to State ClearinghoVit) 'Stdt6 C 80050616 Contact.Petson be'r ,-Bett)�e, Kirchqv� Pluning.Director .(91,6) jJ 534-.,4601M, ,Ptoject Location ' BoundeU by Hamilton Road FeatheroRive'r C e. . Sutter CoUnty, on s. and eastern limit... x A-AA►111112 0 Projcict Description; '\_ Plan Amendment from Orchard & Field Low and Wei,4ium Density Residential, Cominercialo industrial and Publoie to Crops, LdW Density Residentiali Medium befisity, I Residential, Commercial, Induttrial�, Public, High Den', �,ty. Res-ideAial and:, This is to advise that t the tutte County hoard of SuOOTicultufal Rdtidenti: tffy- —Ai � n c has made the foillowing determitiation8 regarding the above-described bed project - I lrh'Ll 'project Nj will havo a significant effect' on the environment. 3. -0 41 SY [:] wiii not A& Environmental Impact Report was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CtQA, and was as roquir d b Seet-ion 1* 5 %, certifi 008 (g), 14 California Adrinistrativ& Code. tj al A t Idgative Declaration was prW ared for this j 6 iroldet, POL11,5uafit to thV Provisions Oe N -QA. A COE 0��, t6 Ne itive Dcclar4tion mal ba e\amiiied at t � Plannirig ped,` rtmcnt, 7 County Con-ke'r Orivio, Oroville, CA 95965. A gk�ticc tif Exampfim ttas filod indicating this project L.:i q�XOMPL ZTOM GnViTOJJ1ft-J1L0L I-OVIQW. A st��to"Iont or, oNrLr1`1dilig cons 3'deritloii M was, a!� noti ad*�,,od for this peojoct- mitiiation measurcs adopted by the, Lead Agcsncy to rodute- Cho impacts of the approved liroject 4)!-0, See attachod Ovdrriding Cons ide ra A CORRECIED tA 9/io/8?2, 13 nAture pion A. StreL,�ter or Planner Sdetion 21108 ot '21182 of the Yu li% v,.,Resourdes Code 0-10-'03-02 180- -t �tojoct Title am on,'16;ral, Plan,, Amen ent- tutte Co., pl�`nning CO,mm.' drlidxey' "l,earitighouse Number (If submitted to State ClearinghoVit) 'Stdt6 C 80050616 Contact.Petson be'r ,-Bett)�e, Kirchqv� Pluning.Director .(91,6) jJ 534-.,4601M, ,Ptoject Location ' BoundeU by Hamilton Road FeatheroRive'r C e. . Sutter CoUnty, on s. and eastern limit... x A-AA►111112 0 Projcict Description; '\_ Plan Amendment from Orchard & Field Low and Wei,4ium Density Residential, Cominercialo industrial and Publoie to Crops, LdW Density Residentiali Medium befisity, I Residential, Commercial, Induttrial�, Public, High Den', �,ty. Res-ideAial and:, This is to advise that t the tutte County hoard of SuOOTicultufal Rdtidenti: tffy- —Ai � n c has made the foillowing determitiation8 regarding the above-described bed project - I lrh'Ll 'project Nj will havo a significant effect' on the environment. 3. -0 41 SY [:] wiii not A& Environmental Impact Report was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CtQA, and was as roquir d b Seet-ion 1* 5 %, certifi 008 (g), 14 California Adrinistrativ& Code. tj al A t Idgative Declaration was prW ared for this j 6 iroldet, POL11,5uafit to thV Provisions Oe N -QA. A COE 0��, t6 Ne itive Dcclar4tion mal ba e\amiiied at t � Plannirig ped,` rtmcnt, 7 County Con-ke'r Orivio, Oroville, CA 95965. A gk�ticc tif Exampfim ttas filod indicating this project L.:i q�XOMPL ZTOM GnViTOJJ1ft-J1L0L I-OVIQW. A st��to"Iont or, oNrLr1`1dilig cons 3'deritloii M was, a!� noti ad*�,,od for this peojoct- mitiiation measurcs adopted by the, Lead Agcsncy to rodute- Cho impacts of the approved liroject 4)!-0, See attachod Ovdrriding Cons ide ra A CORRECIED tA 9/io/8?2, 13 nAture pion A. StreL,�ter or Planner Orchard 4 yield Crops, LdW Density Residentiali Medium befisity, I Residential, Commercial, Induttrial�, Public, High Den', �,ty. Res-ideAial and:, This is to advise that t the tutte County hoard of SuOOTicultufal Rdtidenti: tffy- —Ai � n c has made the foillowing determitiation8 regarding the above-described bed project - I lrh'Ll 'project Nj will havo a significant effect' on the environment. 3. -0 41 SY [:] wiii not A& Environmental Impact Report was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CtQA, and was as roquir d b Seet-ion 1* 5 %, certifi 008 (g), 14 California Adrinistrativ& Code. tj al A t Idgative Declaration was prW ared for this j 6 iroldet, POL11,5uafit to thV Provisions Oe N -QA. A COE 0��, t6 Ne itive Dcclar4tion mal ba e\amiiied at t � Plannirig ped,` rtmcnt, 7 County Con-ke'r Orivio, Oroville, CA 95965. A gk�ticc tif Exampfim ttas filod indicating this project L.:i q�XOMPL ZTOM GnViTOJJ1ft-J1L0L I-OVIQW. A st��to"Iont or, oNrLr1`1dilig cons 3'deritloii M was, a!� noti ad*�,,od for this peojoct- mitiiation measurcs adopted by the, Lead Agcsncy to rodute- Cho impacts of the approved liroject 4)!-0, See attachod Ovdrriding Cons ide ra A CORRECIED tA 9/io/8?2, 13 nAture pion A. StreL,�ter or Planner [:] wiii not A& Environmental Impact Report was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CtQA, and was as roquir d b Seet-ion 1* 5 %, certifi 008 (g), 14 California Adrinistrativ& Code. tj al A t Idgative Declaration was prW ared for this j 6 iroldet, POL11,5uafit to thV Provisions Oe N -QA. A COE 0��, t6 Ne itive Dcclar4tion mal ba e\amiiied at t � Plannirig ped,` rtmcnt, 7 County Con-ke'r Orivio, Oroville, CA 95965. A gk�ticc tif Exampfim ttas filod indicating this project L.:i q�XOMPL ZTOM GnViTOJJ1ft-J1L0L I-OVIQW. A st��to"Iont or, oNrLr1`1dilig cons 3'deritloii M was, a!� noti ad*�,,od for this peojoct- mitiiation measurcs adopted by the, Lead Agcsncy to rodute- Cho impacts of the approved liroject 4)!-0, See attachod Ovdrriding Cons ide ra A CORRECIED tA 9/io/8?2, 13 nAture pion A. StreL,�ter or Planner 79-10-03-02 Obi EIRktDlN8 COh81-DOE tAT'TQNS (a) The Butte County General Pxas� calls for pexiodic revieiti�, and a date o£ buse classifications (� f th�toug' otjt the Cdunry. ,', Thind. it project is a pa7�t ;;, o£ this (7ngeing Proce�;.� r I fib, :The land use designations dieing l dopted ,epr sent 1 an impravement over present land use 'de5i:Rnatiblis in that they were formulated with the hei:p Of u citizen npur to mors e££eetively i ij lenient the goals and ob'dctives of the 'Butte, County GenerAl° Plan. The land use catepries .being adopter are ;pol+ ntia lye ` Cc) �a °-'less environmentally damaging at:° full buildoiA than the categories which previously were 'n' effect for the a'rea's iohile still providing 'room for comfnunity expansibn (d)' 'the hand use patterns under cbnsideratidn provareaide ge Parcels which willsofferrarea resimil dthe to offset\\' 'dents�' food and energy resource demand by becoming partial' W self-sufficient through produding on the premises a portion of tl'►eit food and energy needs (e) The land use categories being adopted repres6ht a x eoopevatiye effort reflecting the growth policies of Butte County and the communities of Gridley and ` Biggs whale .spheres of influence rvi! 1 develop under County yrurisdiction until such time atha, contiguous atoat THt PoRtGOINO If iI fF.!l HENT Is A COMCr COPY 0� THE ORIGINAL ON PILE ahu Op 05=10 1!4 THIS OPPIGL, hY N 5 192 Cid,`.° p }H5 SIJ�ERICNC k; " •kms w • "�+r �t1:��iY bF iiUTily /+'! ,MANOR M. tui "i By .r P, POF 00 SERVICIE 9Y MAIL f_ CCP 1018a; 2036, �'�' (�hl�,(q r'eill4lf�i'11 O�/+rtnplcysd':Ini ih. rouny �`faina..�'aq»••n.•».rnuritp ilibli(�`inic�w•tP.. ai�tA1�;13fiiiO4�aii��>s.➢dicY.Y»lacH;it4urvey x 1,t►�y (buir�/rhi�filcbitd+r�ttfi flli .OQM 6F eiohtNh ye01i Mnd not ty pnrty� a the wi,W tt tpube` � WKirTjYif. h,zngt �y.�.4jY�,.�,���i�a .„iyy•� �.Q.y ,[y�: p Mi•Y';yy�».aK1aa.•,. a � �y yy� 1 icyb '` n rK.1Gl avfa..K,afY.`•uK ae3 lr�r»1'1 F�^����•rKKnr 1�1,x1HKi•KaG:aYrifi .Fa HFhaj}ii !»lGY4iYiiiFlYiiNYiiti lairCiliiH7aK1;41'ij„' /rye Ar un :. V �11 .GYYaliililf.NYa • 1Y 71. 1Sylff u��;.�Ya11a. . K»AKi.1Fi 11 a1r1h YN; C:iF...A..... a »»3Ns{AMY a Ia1F4A•u �� 11.faMgFitY tithglYllr)Y Y�g1•i 1 r I�5e�tie I;s+s KafY/YiaOfCiral4G1,jf4H«iM�1/K• .��t M �:,riiiK pf»iNau/f:Nfr.Haa.NGiiK11WKa•A1Li»4•i•»rNuiaN:/1 //MKa»iiFiRMr4xaf Yal»iiU4HYU oR the a•I:RFYial ,1uNptia)»YRiifibYa MKWr.4Hi.AiulYi/Yp"3 1r tti° to"void ceuam, by pi4x�np a true �y thec�bf-eheioied in a rrniud entife-,e with parir 1l+trrM #e�l1 id to rD,e hD `, j Mir ��r� lle fc�rz► a 3"90..of ,YY ridc�otrlsid a� faiiawN, 4(ilitC State/ 010a�i Of (�uaiN•.YFr... •». K. »....»• r /.ou»..•• . ar »»a», • » n+.0».a , ........... iu»iva.ai.aKGN4:!i aft x , C(JCTNIty TjLANNiNG 'COMMISSION 10 `i Couhty Center biive orov _lle, Cali.fot)aia. 09965 ^, r, CLAAR A6 WttgoO 12 0 'utte i3011Y ty clerk/Nx �Ut'tr✓ Coutii�S► >�berd c�� Su�eirvisr�rs 13 25 1county Cehter briv� jl nrdville Celifnrnia 953'5. � ;G 15 cot)NTY Cr WMt 25 Couhty Center Otive X$ drooille California 95965 1 ' 090AGI: biguelmVIXAN Attbr»ey Ganearl 16 555 Capitol Mall I, s"vite 350 acratrieito, California 94102 19 y 2 I detlore under pehalty 01' per]ury'ihoi the Iorngoing It true and .6trbct, bad ihot thlb dec►brolloh wok sue -mod oh 24 15,92 uHYH. •r.r aa:waau»...na.. 4i K»,r.wrM.✓+.M ��'.T•��� "'A' Q'nna,H..r\gM4,Yr•unuYrn.niufrraal� WhfoehI6. �a Q.kRi 4"" 1rtiB . •... » �:: • .�ti•Y6 O1'41�'1T1}ifAMCI,».GinlYiprFia.wFY.1YYilprNN•IF• _. .GNATURE,. t �uos 0i-- Na Mui�pLY Fb►tN1 No ii+8.:.. flztintet+.fw vih:"riYa ;nrl:�..�mf>�r�,�.P�r b ' y irr:. N rAAi _ i 1 do JL oil v .� ti. F e �"'"""r' iii" nn X11, h t + �. �.✓ ,ew..ri.�le � " �'� � , _:. a U� "�WII��e" `li�y1��i� l •�.: ., .�. a1�, �. f .''G1\ �/'r wit, * d C(:;a�J 4. t: 'ars• •t S. .?�.rd:r to 4,� .fit �. , '4Y-• IF r ' 14d1k» .+d 1 I it �ie �r�'iiw�"`. w Wit. WRKe.!`i.erY4 i 1 � 3 4L! C ( i tialiri+� il� �' r Ioa. iHrl� irNit j'r � r