Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout78-105• rte'; 1 -� PARADISE MUNICIPAL ADVISSORY CO'UNCU, Butte County .", Butte County' liuil(liq - 747 [,Iliett [4md �- 11amtlip Californiii 9 909 .°`*.w,........�" .Ir It) 0 P.SuhCtY,fIJ�iZJ September 1, 1978 SEP -19to ti+ROVILLS, C,AMFOFt OA Butte County ,Boxed of Supervisors_ Administration Building Orovill.e 0 California 95965Comm i oio G°` 3%jaantnh a Honorable Members of the Hoard! oto vtllu, �+ul►�ntnia The Paradise Municipal Advisory 'looncil (14AC) met on Monday', Aup ast 14, 19789 to review the zoning of the South Central and'Nunnally areas of Paradise and to ascertain the desire of the xcsidents and property owners within these areas. The purpose of this letter is to present to you a summary of those desires. The areas under consideration are bordorect on the West by the 'S.P.R.R. night -of - way, on the South by Duschmann Read, and on the Bast by a line due South from the interoection of Bi.11e Road and Pontz--Magalia. The northern boundry includes all property faoina on Greenwood Drive and CentWa:l. Part Drive, between the railroad and Mark 'Road. Between Clark Road and Sawmill. Road,, the northern boundary -is Rodd, while East of Sawmill Road it .is a line parallel to Ryan Lane-. The Pollo4n, is a summary of the desires of the citizens of Paradise as expressed. at tho meeting: 1 All parcels ourrentl.y zoned. 0-2, R-1, R-'IA&C and R-3 should remain zoned as they axe. 2. The parcels on �bhe fotty corners of the intersectionof 1 unnel.ly Road and Sai, mill Road should be changed to a zoning of 0-1, 3. In the southeastern corner of the ar,?a included in the discussion are two areas currently designated A�R and cne as SR� . The desire to combine all three into One area, designated SR-' was expressed. 4* Commercial use off` the parcels oil either side of Elliott Road between the railroad and: Cl.arlt, Road should not be pexmi,tted except Pot, the parcels cuxsrently desi�nated 0-2 at ,the Intersection of Cl.arlt and ki.liott Roada. 5. One shall l.ot, located about Soo feet South of Pearson Road and West Of, Clack Road is ouxrentl.y desi.gna.tcd. AM2 Ltd. That lot should be changed to C4 to be consistent wi:asurrounding use and zorzzmobi1 6; The entire area 1�z7; �eJy deli atou A-2 Ltd, contains many homes, and aii equaJ, nwmbor o.:f caftvontional privato reoidenjeo, with st;a,tte;tea parcels of 141 ch arts and orafto are practiced. ".t i:s, therefore, again, recomglondcd that a riow zoning oatogoay, RT -1140, be created to ocvor all of thece dobiroa and. bo applied to all the remaining paxoele desi� reviewed. aai;©d a!i i1-2Ltd. I;hroughbut, thb area 7• Several residents and proper-by ovmers from the area have t)nimals, suoh as horses, on theinproperty, and a few have duplexos or other mtalitple-family residences. They veto informed: that if the ouxtent use of their, property, all of which is curront7:y dosigna•be1 A-2 Ltd., is legal nota, they oan oontinv.e to use it 3,11 the wane mariner even if it is designatlsd as a new zoning catv'lgoi,'y duri.ne the massive rezoning offer .�, No one in attendance at the meeting expressed oppoe!b on to any of the above suggestions. Therefoxe, MAC recommends approval of all of the above dosixes. Sincerely yours, Warren H. Humbert, chairman Wil: rh oo: Butte County Planning Commission ratte Cotmty ;Pltinnirjg Department ILIj F�q BUTTE, COUNTY PLANINTNG COMMISSION NbT'f,CE OF POBLIC ME :NTNG Not-Ice is hereby given that the Butte County la,naiiig Commissi.on will hold a joint public meetin.g with: the 'P4i.radise Municipal Advisory council ,;it 7:39 P. Al. on December 8, 1,977 at the. Veterans' Membri.al Hall at the cornea' of Skyway and 1a11.1ott. The r;ommissioli aIld IAC will. be discussing a program o planaing and zoning for the Paradise Commun,.i.ty. The public is .i.nvi.ted to part i i,pat.e, LA1dI°ti NCi J4 J,AWSON Director Of P'LInn:ing MUNICIPAL, A, 1V 4 Ql�X COUNCIL - Paradise W. M. Balken 6644 Dolores Dj ive Paradise, Ca, 95969 Claude A. iurgess i 7066 Clerk Road Paradise, Ca. r 9596) k�J t Harlan Duncan 241 Valley View ` Paradise Ca, ; 95969 >� Warren Humbert � :W 1255 Nunnely Paradise, Ca. � ♦ r �ry 9596..9 Leonard Loyd a 5682 Paradise Ave Paradise, Ca,, Dave 12i�.ey 7578 Sk way i Paradise, Cap 95969 ♦* wltl yy , , r �,, . " Y Y, i `W • Y ^ 1. �}" '3 VFr • Y r' • • r. r Y b C J f �U UNT PLANNING COMMISS.ION AND PARADISE MUNICIPAL Al)1VISORY COUNCIL **AGENDA for JOINT MEETING—December 8, 1977 I PLEDGr of ALLEGIANCE IIj ROLL CALL, Comma ss oiler-s ; Bennett li�jorl7ard .Stutz IVia I ianis and C:ha a. roan Gl Iber, t MAC; MembL i-i: DUncan Humbert Loyd and Riley Iii O? N AND PLANNIN8 for PARADISE COMMI)NtTY MAC and the Comm? ssioners will, be discussing a prog'rant of Planning and zoning for the paradise commtinit The public is TN1rITED to participate. ADJOURNM8NT Meeting to be held at the i'ctOran,$' Memorial Hall Skytway tIliot r "ORY 0011 OIL rl BLBP1i0t4,b M111"ma A NIJ euuu.,)T Ws 1977 TOTAL 00NYA0*,'Jt 5 'A NOTANSWrl, N. ,r�1tllJt Do you support the coftyupt, of an, adviSol'Y Council such as M.A.C. to Serve as Lt 11aisoft or line of communications between the, residents ()f P*,vradise and the Board of Supervisor$? 5.24A Yis 4, 542 (90.37,,',)K1O P.21 (4.390 9 4 - 7 2. Do yoti believe the residents of J)aradise should have more say in the future dove lopment of their community? . ypS 4,850 (96.49A)NO 69 (1.37,'S) 97 86,/, 2,14'A 3. Would you support some form o" control over the removal of ,nature trees in 1), yr,,s. 4,414 (87.82;Z)10 406 (8,071,) 4,, In housing development what density do you believe should be used in 'Paradise? 0 � 93 581"1 6 4 2A 447(A) 1, to 4 dwellings per acre SS 47A) 2�'J(B) 5 -to 8 dwulliMgs per acre �5.illj/') 5. Should there be more mobile home parks in Paradise? 140 yrisl,020 ( Pry .29,10')NQ.�3( 130 .711/0) 86� 6i For the safety of school children and other pedestrians which of -the, following urbaii i,iliprovenlunts would You SUI)POrt? I (A) Curbs, gutters and sidewalks -993 (11.791") - 2'49J _595" 1. 97.$l,.' (13) Wulkwt-Lys 3, — t –_ - C-7--52/, i 1 LIAO 0"6 (C) None, of the abovu_ — .11 - - 7, io what areas do you feel glAch improvements should be made? (A) All residefttial arOUS 438__ 8.71t41j) (52.02A (B) All hceavilY traveled streets only ?_,bl!) to bAc (c) only those streets contiguou, 1,097 (21 .821�0 schools- 8, in tho area oT law enforcement which do you think is most needed? 4.16 1 94'� TralTic control 990 (19,69%6) insistea 95,84'A :864 76,881�' ('13) Police PMtectlioftl on voting fov both A g, Would you like to bavo itnd Particil)atO in, a Neighbolrhood V W04ch ptogvm? 5 0 4A Y t 8 3 73,6 (74.'13,;6) N 0 , 8 3 16) 94:96 10. Would you be willing to ouhtribute time and effort in as8i.4ting Municipal. Advisory Council. by attending meeting;$ and/or you'r dommufticating YoLkt ideas alld opiftions to Couftoll members? 4 49A 5, 1) No 95 , 5 11, Would you be willing to assist your Mullicipal Advisory Council I by serving on a. coMnlittce? 54440 _5 (.3 1 . 37 V 17 +�i5 telephona, ovorveyorii work()d can tht t,Ip's, telephone o"Orvey. They were Linda tbken, Joan z.ndor..oi,t, �lr�{:� s Armrtrong .kt,arnona wilken, Opal iiiolcrieil, r"ormrt .HrRaclen, lrlro Pzancis brown-, 411t1u. a�'txdene srowninr;, Lee: zf urnsYde Lee Cage, Jeanne Oarter, [�Ia,ry t�ruise irI.m .Joan, Harlan Dunottn Karen J!;iomann, 4arbarra, �,'l cen di-troline Pr, uoer, Pt-tm VifrtSe, Vivian Frank Maude Gavvet.-�on Fl ore noea �Xilley Oilliram prinks, Reva Harding, (Irrace Harrell, Betty Heller, Helyn Hilke, Joyce &: aarren HiAmbert E. 0. Jacobson, Avolyn J'ohn,.aan Ors. Line. Kennody jell en Lehman, h,lrq Arthur Leonard, 1Gima Loyd Macy Mann, Lydia 'McOhie, Harry l+.",ltrr. ay I,°r s . Mart. o n Noll I:etty Owens'_ burbiarea. Palmer, 21dith prirr, itrdyF4 Porgy, ,l'ohn Polivka Katie Ross teve Soarbouroul h, Billie i.7chuenemeyer, reorge Shaw, hIrs. George Smith Irene Wel.bourn, Lott Ann ',Vhite, lsther Wiexloart, Betty Wines) Rebecca, 1,11robel +There were 276 r.hee:tra oi` re(,�i 7, -coved voter,3 with approximately 12,676 names 54 oheets (includiaiL; 10 s;her tri which were lost try a prospective vurVoyor) reprosentin.- 2,557 names were not worked due a lack of telephone surveyors, It is e,atirrtra.ted (646 names) did not have telephones or had unlisted telephone numbe+rt; based o,i the .tectal number of riames, the survey reflects the opinions of .09.64,16 of the regi teved voter i in paradise w Lased on the 222 s;heeto worked repre;3enting 1 % 1:�q aae.mps the telephone surveyors wer, e sable to contact 49.57;4. r50me of the telephone ;A1:Wvoyor, lubmitted commento made to them by those they interviewed. 001VIONTS PEkrL llJ.r;n LO r'U.00�0101. 140. Several people sire opppsed to beoa.utae it is "healing ;some of the woundn" the people should ondtire to convince them to incorporate. Some people are opposed to PIAO because they fear it in a camoufla' god attempt at iritOrporata.ori. p MA01 is a Mound, idea as, longi ass there are roprosentative Oitizens serving, None should be can the 0ounril who contempl.ato poroanra<l benegito by Ioervin,I s r�i�Ut`�z endas and meotintS time,, and pl:ere obould be re�ularty in nowspaporn so anyone interested it a par ticulitty item could attend that meeting. Al oo j Council members ohould be available to the citizens for comments or airing problems. I= T'1 r ate.r. 1 (o o4tli Id rr !' �.!"<t.Rt y J:aIfni Ii"ar with 1U C l hrouah Ito Vgp4M,4Xr °, . o, ylo. t r,r.ra<al , t:I, ht ' urvoy �, t.,ond idea and wore cooper,jLivu,, I t;rr`"11i :t, Vo+ , poo -11, :'illi'+ +IJ4i o a.l. %boLi t i"r'he'thcr the ,iur ey (or ilny'Lhit,b, ,inUl d .10 111.1) r ;0()J. J. 1 ,lt\� , r�,�:+ alt 14;.-i 'X. 2 ,!t 010111.1 .1 b'the Property okrrit, av!,i (not; venter<<a, etc.) who eho r.ld have Coro i.t1 Lho ratture d -vol npmori1t of the community, cone (-°rto l e -for t ,hould be. rrvid 'to f:,et the Planning Commisaion back uo whore thoro 1 . a t;l;riie x-opro,,antat i:ve for the Pa rradipe area. Ones-ozrveyor ropor-Led r raly of the noople ;alae contracted, especially the men, think It i = time Cor .inc,t)rror'a.tion q1.0�." T, l+,rr 10 L lO.NO, inelivicit:l.al property rightt, mu. -A by respected in regard -to tree removal J eci yiono , .,ever:tl people )dvsanr ed the ide;L if aa, tree is removed then: a new one should br, pl!ivited in it�i place even ii' in another location. 116 )21011'Y Woo !.:irn,yr people v,eve rte,;, rllntle,i t�,ith tho wording; of this question. They would have liked Yh 1 or . per ac rr; choice rather than 1 to 4 per acre'. ,,Uolzt 4 people who voted :for the lower den8ity qualified their vote by ��d iric; they ,Celt 'thero should be some arartments in paradise, Yl"zr-idi.`.,e ;"+howl d have an environtrient-al r't% r It' too late, not1t, to do ajiythln,�,- 1 :[i` 3ono,,on t et;7 in the te,r-M j! f;one 1 jo not i .i l any a ; c+rtrete;n t ;at ~.11. ;;'e don r t want any, ;to more buil.s int; until we get ,jewpr . h4ve P, �*,VO W'th ceiling; W; in 0rogon -- no more 'People, :Yo more buil oAnC =- we. are notmeeting :fire and safety stand ards,.now. 1 interviewee, oommented angrily on the :statement that the people in Paradise erre r,oi,n;'<l to r,et the %p artments whother they want them or 'lot Made at the whoI , , L-1 nint,; rlommi.tter. meetinC,, by pl,anni.n Commissioner Jerry l;verhard Olull.e 1 .:ivy y�5.1,j� a, w r`C:pento.i the ii'L �+C4t.l .4 .J t'i t,'�,�r �. t�%• r<t t as r r T rr �,' ',!'r�t�.tw.L'ti�'r.�i.LY a.(� ,,lt;:;tt��;`� iv\d, One tn,a,nCa er oti n, moj)jjo. ' home pPar<k° i`eel s we should not hove more mobile horrto pRlrtt,: at le 1,rvt until there ire water and sewers to suppprt them. TO IYBI-,'TI0IN' NO. 5 ( cont' d) e relatives verhave been forced to ive tip ted theyr 0105 al peoplt, their conventional horn beocaWie of high taxes and have had to movge to mobile homes. one ,purveyor reported, even those living in parks were of the opinion that Paradif3e had quite onoti& mobile home parks and that the tax on these parks are unequal to the tax paid by the conventional home o%iiers. knother surveyor r0portodLlorne p I eople questioned whether the eicistina mobile home psrks are full rind .she 5ugge.9ted a surirey be made to find out how malty empty spaces are currently in existing parker 1�4n. Some people commented they would not be opposed to more mobile home park if tax4,Ition on mobil-,, homes were made more equitable. I people feel mobile liomes should be in parks only and should not be ,:)everal allowed in -cesidential areas. We should &evelbP more acreage parcels into privately owned mobile home lots E1.9 in Paradise pines. Ing for mobile In with conventional homes. 'homes. They should not be mjx�!d There should be proper AonI BIx amp I e Garden Lane Circle (off Newland Road) , (I CO!SIBITTS PI�RTINENT " IjIISTJoII ITO, 6 mentioned with hex, permission) $U69estm t�jrs. rilrudy Vatter, 53r �3 Sawmill (name accomodate those who lacing a bench about every block along walkways to P 9he plans to place a bench in front of her, home walk for health's sake. GREAT IDBA (Telephoner's Personal thought'* � 1, 3 03? and label it 11�Valkorll', iiest could even be a an many walk as prepcvi bed by their doctors,. A bench COU 4 foot length of lot,, ati'aed halfi This might become a civic service project of I or mora orgunizotions as walkways are developed.) � we would look like a b)',g citYtl- people told one telephoner# ?'No sidewalks 11citified" blany people ob8erv,e,d they don t want Paradise to become too came hero to get away fV0M llcitYllt or ,we moved from, the metroi,�)litan area to get away from city livine, and WO don't want sidewalks" ,ialkways should be on 1 side of 'road only. 8everal 8tI,eLeoted that bike trails are neea06 in addition to or III ; tjr tion with walkw '-10, 0Oj'JI0q4.@NrII:JI TO JBO)TION NOO "tone submitted* PFHTJIaXIo 1110 UP33-TIOx 140i need more 4 -way f7,told Sidn!4'i Ive must have a signal Jirht at 3kyway and Oliver before someone is killOd- There MholIld be More Ked ctoss-walkr, in ParaclioO. I v a i interviewee ;u� ested plain clothed detectives to curb narcotics with the .3heri;ff l s right to pursue l.aw breakers. 1 interviewee sugi c .oted more oevere .sentences by judgeB i'or the law hreakerr. . OOIAN1 JWO IMIRT I NT 10 o. U l'::> IOX NO. 9 Ma,n.,y, nighbGrs seem to already have a "neighborhood watch" program of sort::. 1 interviewee said he had a dec,,,0. on his front window proclaiming he participates in a "neighborhood watch" program, 1 te.l.ephone surveyor, commented, 'I'Ve know what it means in the way of education for'the neighborhoods but moat of those contacted had no idea as to the implication of "Neighborhood Watch" program." QUIItiENTS PE1t1INUT TO QUEVIOX NO 10 Many said they could not drive at nig ht or were otherwise involved but would contact the Council members when they felt they have any constructive sAggeotion to offer. COMMENTS PBRTINENT TO QM3TI; Old 140. 11 None submitted. a wl, t ....-....... t M t, "PAKALIME MUNI(2PAJL ADVISOIRW 'OOLJNC L Elult� Cuu yty iDirildinq -- 747 N;IIIott Itaad �. Parxdiao, Calftbrnia 9>s)hrl 0 � May 190 1978, Butte County Board of Supervisors "'"9C County ndminiotratjon Buil6i.ng Oroville, California 9596` oro�rl l978 Knndrable M(4mtjars of the Board: odif°rnI4 This is. in regard to the potential rezoning of that portion of the North Central area of Paradise that is currently zoned !IA2-Ltd.1' The Para4),pie M..•unicipal Advisory Council (MAA reviewed this » rarea h;1; its meeting on h1ay 80. 1978, b0fore anaudtence Composed prAarlly of property owners and residents of thq area: The area is predominantly occupied oy a low-density mix of conventional and mobile single family dwellings, ssveral of which also captain home businesses of the "arts and craftelf nature, withcommercialenterprises concentrated aroand the intersections of Clark (toad with Wagstaff Road and Bilile Road. The area also includes four mobile -home parrs, a few orchards rind a few residences that maintain riding horses and similar animals. The vast majority of thos , s.� attendanco agreed that; Ii None of the area should. he zoned "CommeraiaP beyond that currently approved as commercially zonod. t 2 All of the area currently zoned "A2 -Ltd" be rezonei ►i�r�t,_ 1 u 3. The arts-and-orafts types of home businesses continue to 'be permitted throughout the area current .y zonod 'HA2 -Ltd." 4. Those parcdls which now contain riding horseo Or dthor animals ahoula be permitted to retain them, but other parcels should not be pormi tted, to have such animals The MAC concurs with all of the above and recommends that the North Central. area of Paradise be zoned accordingly. Oe note, however, that Section 24-1$0 Of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinanr.+4 of the. Butte County Code, (AT" 1 ii zoning) does not permit home .L."ie.fA:u:::+:.:.+1�' 4 1 Parxc3se Munio.jpal Adw,sarS` Councilt, May 19, 1 ��8' iage _ , . ,businesiies of the a -and"crafts type. Sect:i. 24-135 (11-1 A&C) Ormits arts and cra is but not moble homes., `0e`eel that t he }' absence of a zoning section that permits single family dwellitg Un.it,g pa.- parcel, including mobile homes, and domestic, arts and crafts or professional, services is discriminatory against .a type of single family dwelling unit 'that is becoming incrdasingl.y PopP , g g o ulax. Therefore We urge that a new zan3ri category, , KT -1 Alk':, be created to rectii'y this omission. 44e also snBBest that this . a nEu.r zoning category be ;applied to all of that action of the North Central area of Paracr4se that is currently zoned A.I--.ttd. VtOr.y truly yours, i H` Wkl�.�tEN H, HUMB RT Oha firman HJ):' jh r cc: Butte County Planning C--mmission Butte C)ov y 'Director of Planning buttO COUntY ,Director of Envi,roninehttal, Review y: e r 1 1 w 1 IYiiiiVJ+..W V •:� �+.s.i 'wwi:i.4.1`rri� _ Irr� x t1t3, 197fl Warren It. Humbert Chairman Paradise Municipal advisory Council 747 rilliott Road Paradise, California 95969 I)e.qr Mr. Humbert; I recii,vo,-'1 Vwir )ot;i-er or ''Iav Y'1, 1MT, coknev n" ^,minp for the North Central area of Paradise T have Placed the matter in the Planning, Commission Agenda for June 12th for discussion. P"ollowing that meeting I willCorwa,rJ the detormiri.ttion of the Commission, to tho Council. You and any other mombors or the Council ,ire certainly wcicomo to attcnrt the ,June 12th meeting. z 'thank you for your interest in better latid-use in ParAdIse Yours very 'trul Lawrence J. T,awson Director of Planninfr r' b,7L : lr mwxint, 11T, 1978 a Ilutte Cotoity Iloilding - 747 Ill ott ROIA(I - Paradise,$ californ �t 95909 ;i,to County Board of Supervisors alga .• ,tm3,nistxation Building (Ildl;ifornia 95965 W. T' ,r,.iblo 1.'omboro of the Board; On w"�aY, 10, 1,97 3, tk G !�i.nicipal Ad�tisory Coons"il (MAC) Met to discuss the potontii :r- : orting of those axeasa of Paradise designated As Middle Skyway aid Lower Skyway with t1he reoidento of t'hone areas who attended the meeting. Emphasis was plaoad, as uc7,s ll) upon the elimi :a,tion of A-2 Limited zones. The Middle Sl way/Lowex Skyway areas are bordered on the South and Boat approximately t.;; pito S'outhexn pacific xight--of-way, on the North by Wagstaff Road, and on the West by °t hr,, Pa=radise lrxiggation District weste� �.� boundxy and a zig-tag line fxom the wt�ssterti end of Elliott Road to the i.nterseotion of Lucky John and Wagstaff Roads. ,5 r t:lxa.n thrso area:, only z,majl scattered sections ar.-e zones A-2 Limited. Ono cr. ctir)n :,nned A-=2 Ltd. at the Southeast corner of Lucky John and Wagstaff Roads t t°rT1.w (Q small lots. Since it is in an area zoned R-1, that zoning. is xecom- this small eection. .Another small section that is currently zoned, A-2 Lt.I • ,,,? tt '.."�,)rth of Posey ',ano and primarily surrounded by areas zoned R-1 W there., R -I AC is recommer coed for that small section.. The samo is true of that section t ,n XI warLIn Lana and. Bil.le Road that lies East of Fern Lane. s Ilnxgor nection of rovoparty that is zoned :Aw2 Ltd. lies between Roney Run Road. and tho oozmoroial area 'gest of Skyway. rQhe Xoxtheastera portion of that section contains ,r,vexal duplexes and other forms of multiply family dwellings. Therefore 14AC xecomw a, ,' do thalt atea, from Longview Dive to Itoney Run Road be toned R.-2. The re=dnder 0111' ttlat Mictio-t, West of Longview Drive, is prime residential property with a view r1 4testi r.,anRvaai at fxegixerit spots and should, therefore, be zoned 11-1 The final puzoel wi,t;hin the axead considered that is zoned A-2 ttd., is that bot tiled :u tear} "Tor h and JIost `by the railroad right-of-VOy-t on the East by Poster Road and t,.o Oo*x'th by the prop000d extension of B oohmanh Road. Since a. use permit ha.o been,. +teM for that caira pa,roel to be oocupied by a mobile tome Vatic, it should be I d !,2UP. ' fid• �la�sni 1978 6 Tt o parcels t Paxadioe axe szc:nea 1-4, andboth lie Within fVao axean under considow- atl,On, One, located at tht) Intexaeot,on of Signa p and Neal: Road, is our p4tl.y oot,nxdea by buoinern o:Mlo "�13' Wa, therefore, :rMOonmena t:,a:L that pascrsa L 1 zoned b3-4'� ao io the Baric; e,ido cl~ 51gy-Way beyond. that .'u;-temsection, TI -w. woond 11-4 liarccl is located at the end. of Centex Street and io ocort-'Od by in aPartinent house located on that portion that is amabl,e. A steep ravine oaroaaoo the a'ao--viindow a:V the paxcel.. We xeomume4d that this parcel be rezoned R -3f Xe"Am Donnity, l:.40 Eatrongly urge, a that a, maxim rlpsj-,pity zoning, R -4f should. not be Permitted 3:n war oroa gtithout a centralized y I fact, Di.AC Would ouppoxt a county limiting the dens ty� c� e dvell ing Unite to a maxi mu.m of ei +, o utilizing only septic a,34to s `410ndoes at the MAC meeting on June 10s 1978 on the above tocommendatiohfj. w✓��.,�.r + Warren H Humbex,�t, Chairman �= cc: A4)i'rectox, Butte County planning Depwetment Cha,iman, Butte County Planning Commiartun Y rib o, p�Qhn rove//o, l`t 18 bt f PARAMSEMUNICIPAL ADVISORY COUNCIL Butte County Butto County Nilaing - 747 [ Iliotl Row). �- I'urtt l tri (rttlfnrn i ��5�)G Aut ilat 14, 1978 Iaitf= ' ouaty Board of Sapervisoro Building 95-965 V . t:.n, r" , Iemborz of the Board: a c; in regard to the potential rezoning of i.,Iie East Contral portion of Pawadise, W.th caphasiz upon those areas currently zoned 'IA -2 Limited and A -411t. Th„ E- t Contval area, which lies East of Clark Road, between Wagstaff and Elliott Roads, nontaino primarily mingle family xeoidencea, several of which axe mobile homes. Some x,at#, ;cult xe is included in, the area with many of the residents owning aztimals such "�Ii.•Gil the exception of tho new shopping center being built at the corner of ° � and Clark 'Ratxdw, commercial aotivity is rostwioted to light commexciVA primarily i�ac;t ;gi(le of Clark road. ,Joao residents of the area that attended the ,MAC ;meeting on June 12, 1976 expx:essed their c)pi.'nielio, ac follows! Li pht commercial activities -should be permitted on the East side of Clark Road$ but no more shopping centero! General cemmexcial activities should bo ,reatvicted to the major intersections on Clark Road. 2. Animals should cohti.nue to be permitted at residences that meet the xequive- mel to far spaoe. No objections lgexe expreosed toward: either mobile homes or arts and crafts in 'the area Only ,a very few residences -in the area ow tai.n,. any arte and o rifts enterpwiaea, but mobile homes aboun(14 fn vie�a c f the above, Kko recommends that; 1) Major intersections with Clark Road, i.e., ; 1.11ott,y Wille and Wagstaff Roads be zoned C-2, general commevotal C) Other than 'at �osz t1 tr rueCti.bn, the East side of Clark Road be zoned C -C, �'onunvsi i,t�,`-Commorcti2�1; 3) Tj.e remainder be zoned AR -Md or, alternatively, S -R with variances permitting mobile ho o ,; ani 4.) A liberal policy be adopted for the area to permit variances for axtd Si2eerelry' yotlr�, �u�o �D` Ptahnrng �p G 1978 xqaxxen. Rufn'bert: ohai.Vulesi cP:�t recterx, Bi tte County ??lei .rig aepai merit CJ,.t,L =aftj Butto. County pl=iing Commission R�4M PARADISE MUNICIPAL ADVISORY COUNCIL Butte County Ilutte County Building — 747 Elliott Roai — 11aradise, Oi ifornith 9Gh()c1 September 1, 1978 Hutto Co. hlalining cortim SEP 5 1978 Butte. County Board of Supervisors Orovilln, California AtImini.atration Bud,iaix �'�vJ1.1o, California 95965 Rosorabl.e Members of the Boards The Paradise Municipal Advisory Council (MAC) met on Monday, August 14, 19M to review the zoning of the South Central and Nunnelly areas of Paradise and to aooertain the desire of the residents aid property owners within these areae. The purpose of this lettriv is to present to you a summary of those desires* The areas under consideration axe bordered on the West by the S.B.R.1., right -of-- i,rny, on the South by Buschmann Road, and on the East by a line due South from the intersection of Iii.11e road and Pentz-Magalia. The northern boundry,iholudea all prtapexty fading on Greenwood Drive and Central Part Drive between the railroad and Clark Road. Between Clark Road and Sawmill Road, the northexn boundary is Elliott tt Road, while East of Sawmill Road it is a line parallel to Ryan Lane. 'rhe fallowing is a summary of the desires of the oiti.zeria of Paradise as expressed at tho mc�ti.ng 1, All parcele currently zoned 0-2, R-11 R -1A&0 and R-5 should remain zoned as thoy are. 2. The parcels or, the four corners of the intersectionof Nunnolly Road and Sawmill. Road should be changed to a zoning of 0-1. 3i in, the southeastern corner of the area, included in the discussion are J. areas currently deoignated A"R and one as The desire to combine all three into one area designated SR= was expressed. Commoeoial use of the parccol.s on either aide of tlliott Road between the railroad and Clack Road should not be permitted except for the parcels currently designated C-2 at the intersection of Clark and Mliott Roads. 5. 0iao small lot, located. about 300 feet 'South of Pearson rioad and West of Clark Road is currently designated A-9 Ltd. That lot shoved be changed to C-2 to be consistent with surrounding use and zoning 60 the entire area, largely designated A-2 Ltdb, contains man;r mobile homes, and an equa number of contrentio iol private residences, with scattered paxcels on which arts and cxaftu ere praotiaed; It is t aotefore y Again recommended that anew zoning category; RT -i A cG � be eveated to cover all of these desires and be applied to all the rama3ning parcels deei(;rnated as A-2 Ltd. throughout the area roviewec 7. Several residents and property owners from the area, have animals, such as horsos, on their property, and a few have duplexes or other mulitple-family residences. They were informed that if the current use of their property, all of which is ourrmatlyy designated ,A-2 Ltd., is legal now, they can continue to ubo it in the tame manner even if it is designated as a new zoning category during the massive rezoning effort. ^ Ido one an attendance at the meeting expressed opposition to any of the above =ti*-;Ms ut ons. Thorefore, MAC recemmendki approval of all of the above -desires. "I lu 0:00 .y yours, ``arreza h. I umbert; chairman "wn: rh Duii A Co. PW.100 COMM. SEP 5 1978. co a khrete County Planning Commission Butte County Planning Department OroVIII01 C It or►ia Buttr. County Yiuilding — 747 E1111ott 110ud — Ntradirw, California 95969 n Soptember 11 1978 Butte Comity Board of Supervisors AS. -A aistrotion Building ."Ile, California 95,q65 Rarioxablrr Members of the Board: DON Co. plannintg cotntt'm'a 1978 Qrov1110, Gap;arttltt The Piaxadi.se Municipal Advisory CeunoilMAC meon Mond A to review the zoningt �t aye August � �+, 1978, of the South Central and Nun.olly areas of Paradise and to ascertain the desire of the residents and property owners within 'theme areas. The Purpose Of thin letter is to pxesent to you a, aumma.ry of those desires. 4 The areas under consideration are boxdered on the West by the S.p.RcR, right -of- u y$ on the South by Buschmann Road, and on the Dkst by a line due South from the i.ltersectian of Bille Road and Pentz-Magalia. The northern boandry includes all Property racing on 4reenwood Drive and Central Part DAve 'between the railroad. -uid Cloxk Road, Between C?,ark: Road and Sawmill Road, the northern boundary is Ml.iott Road., while East of Sawmill Road 't is a line parallel to Ryan Rano. TIM following in a summary of the desires of the ci.ti.zello of Paradise as expressed at trio .mooting. 1+ All parcels currently zoned C-2, R-1, R-IA&o and 11-3 should remain Lone. as they are, 24 The parcels on the four corners of the intersectionef Nunnel.ly Road and Sawmill Road should be changed to a zori.ng of 0-1. 3, In the southeastern corner of the area included in the discussion axe. two areas currently. designated A -R and one as SR= The desire -to combine all three into one arra tlesigrlatod SR-�r was e:tpresoed. 40 Commercial use of the p cools on either side of Alliott Road between the railroad and Clark Aonrl 01:rould not be pexmi.tted oxoept for the Parcels currently des g^..tta C-2 at the intoroeotion of Clark and .1.i.ott Roads, S. One omalw 15t, Located about 300 feet South of Pearson Road and Nest of Clark Read is currently designated A-2 Ltd. That lot should be 6. chatg,d to 0-2 to be consistent with surrounding use and zoning. The entire areae largely designated A-2 tltd., contains many mobile hordes, =d an equal number of conventional privste rea3derices: with aoattored parcels on which arts and crafts are practiced, It is) therefore, again xeeoinmended that a new zoning category, All -WC- be Created to cover all. of these desires and be applied to all the l remaining parcels designated as A-2 Ltd. throughout the area revi»eued. 7. Several residents and property owners from the axea, have animals., such as horses, on their propertyO and a few have duplexes or other mulitple-family residences They were i.nt'ormed that if the otiixent use of thein, property, all of which is ourrenrtly designated .A-2 Ltd., is legal now, they can continue to use it in the same manner even if it is designated as a new zoning category during the massive rezoning effort. N'o one in attendance at the meeting expressed opposition to any of the above , a,ri, ; otiono Thexefoxe, MAC recommends approval of all of the above desires. :.',a.x COVAy yours; �+ 1 r.d Warren H. T3umbert, chairman BtAild Co. PiW,,iA9 COMM, WH t. xh SEP J A IS cot Butte County Planning Commission pcavll�, Ctsiixorr�ta kEalrfe County Planning Department } BUTTE COI,INTY "PLANNlN NITNUTHS - December 8 .S—PF3C;TAL MIiI;Ti96 717t -'I i COMMISSION 1977 WIMI)ISIi MUNICIPAL Aayl.SU111'' Co �at�Vetei'an M . �rla°l. 1IsM� _ Skyway & Elliott in. paradise 78-31.1-1p in the absence of MAC Chairman, Warren Ilumbert, the meeting was called to order by Vice Chairman Harlan. Duncan with a pledge of allegiance to the flag 111 then ir:troduced 1IAC Members: W. 'MDalkon Claude A Burgess Leonard Lloyd and D ve 'Riley Board of Zoning Adjustment Members: Loris Camenzind and Al. Appleman. (Bill Collins arrived a feta minut;os later and was introclucod. Planning Commission Members: Frank, Bennett Jerry taverhard George Gilbert Ilonry Williams and John Stutz Chairman of the Board of Supervisors Bob Winston :Manning staff; Bob Gaiser, Planner Hazel Dallas, Secretary, and Barl 13ai.ley, Chairman of the Planning Committee for MAC Mt, n tncan turned the meeting over to Mr. Gainer who gave a brief history of planning and voniaxg in the area, -1e said that the Land Uso M, '► shovii in the General Plan as adopted in 7971 is so small that A is extremely difficult to dotermine the boundaries. He then displayed a. large map :recently prepared by staff draftfiman 'show-ing this information more clearly. He added that, since the adoption of the General Plan, laws have changed to make it 'ncreasin.gly more importc.nt NCr, Bailey reported that in IM the ,State of California authorized the Boards of Supervisors to appoint: municipal advisory councils, that the one in Paracliso established a year Digo in November was one of the first in Northern California, Ho presented a land use map ,;howing the present uses and indicated that approximate.l.y 60% of the tea is Zoned either A- Z Ltd.. or A- R. He added that planning and. orderly growth is necessitated way the 610, average annual growth of the connnunity, DUTTh; COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - December 8, 1977 Bob Gaiser said that the plan is to di'v.cle Paradise Into 12 small Study and to have -rr,n aroa meeting each,rto,itli to study the present zoning, future -coning ,and other proble,ns in the area. Mr. Bailey said that a questi.ollnaire is in the prepat°ation stage and asked that the Commission back tine offor, is o F MSC; by recommending Board funding for postage, etc. to sonci mailouts to all registered voters in the area. Ile added that it was hoped this could be accorr,plished by December 20 so that their .First area meeting could be planned for around January 15. Louis Camenzind said that the Board of honing Adjustment is trying to abide by the law that permits use in many area,; and that rezoning is a step in, the tight direction to protect the area, Al Appleman said, "Be sure about the type you rvant and got it quickly,► Bill. Collins roitorated comments o;f the other 1 zA members and added that there; are few restrictive zones in the county, that 13ZA is charged with t1>e responsibility o.f interpretation of the General Plan as it affects the genexal welfare of the County and that they must ,Ict in such a way as not to adversely affect surroundi;tg areas. Ile added later that the recommendations or MAC were weigho making by the W d heavily in decision Commissioner Gilbert commented that with the combined efforts of }LAC, the Commission, and Planning st-1tf there is no reason why sensible zoning cannot be worked out for this area. Ile thanked MAC for their attempt "to make the work Of the Commission oasi.cr". Johne �y ntz said the � roblems toe are facing wore caused b n y people who c:"10 t'o lltt roiinty from Los Angeles, San. Jose, etc., to got away from the p ob:le,;i . , instead 1),rought then, along. Ile said that the time i;- cora.rite Whon Tr, potential land use must be delineated on the land tise maps 'or till? genera. 1,�.oti and that all others (uses) will be eliminated, He added that dovealulal;,°- ►tocol to know what they can do, and that the Problem that the Coimni,ss1o3, tts faring is whether to do the zoning first or cha.ngC tale land use 'mLap :First. In answer to Pain Fickett's question as to how the t�- tablishmont of lower density will be handled, Mr, Badley s aid that it will. 'bo done by the people in the area. >•ir; Hopkins --Tori or Chet 72��asked that those people trlto depend on q,,;1rultura1 pursuits :For at Least a cart of thein livelihood not be zoned out of business, In response to his question as to what affect losing the agricultural base in this area: would have on water rights, Phil Kelly Paradise Irrigation nistrict; said that he sloes not expect the water rights will be affocted. r - I UT'IT COUNTY PLANNING CnMMI',SSTON MTNUTt S - Deeembor S, 1917 Mr. Cai.ser commented that, to his knowleo o, 41 ta'tic agricultural zone - A -S, ai-10, A-20, etc., had never lacotl alat,i.aocl .Cray in T?araria5o and that there 110 l and in Paradise in thc± ']V7�1 iP]an1,1',oi1 Act. I'le Added that most of the .::I ' r•('00sts in the Paradiso arm have been comerned With horses ant] ntoirt 1r - ' ;+tress- -for and 4agairlst Lo,c- 1"))-scs and for and Against mobilo (tomes --ant] i-uw,indod people tilat zojji)nl't crj,. be ,app; ied for at any t;fiiio--that them is no compt:tl.si.on to w4lit for MAC tc► �.r.t. In response to a rla1osti.o►1 fl -oil) Stephe=n 13arbar.ill, Per. (aax.ser sa:i►' that no -Cee is rerluirod for a Planning Comntisst, itattiatecl x0zo inh. .Dan painter m =d what a}aproar.h was being taken regarding the of ,t railroad bed. ;Mlr., Gaiser s1,id that it was his understanding that. there was an attempt being in-'k.de to :secure some parts Of 1;110 rig]tt�oCwtvty dor a: roadbed—which could also inc'ludo pedestrian tvalktvays and bike paths. Bill Collins of the Board of Zoning Adjustmont, asked that peopZM "c.ansidOr the implications of 4 Lanes of traCt`ic ;into and Out Of Paradises►, Jack Coyly said that if the use pormit4 wol.11d ,lust be climina.ted the probl.cm wou3d be solved. Bob Ca:SiOr explained that with the present System of ordinances ave have,thi.s 7 s itltpossi.lale because All zon. ng dis ricts perynit Certain. thi7tgs only avith a t.rs0 Iae :mi.t Mr. Lol 11 rent( the County's most restrictive cone, R l pointing; out the uses 1loaved by use perltti.t even 7.n this zone: Claude Scott asked if nll, use permits amd varianeos could be he d. back until the area meet' -11gs- -Until After the area can be studied. fir. l lins commented Haat lve (BZA) by law "do not drag our foot", tut that input from all people is heard . John ll in,ke was Concerned that tli0rc, tvas no zone in the Para.cl i sc area that would permit :fruit larocessing—excopt tho A_2 Which hall boot called illegal zona e4tr1ler ill Mae evening. N'tule ],aylor-Tayyl.or? asked ir iir" central Skyway area would nor. t e 6 - good ]glace to start this study, atic] added that the proposal was ior the sewer system to shirt in that area and bring in the other areas later. Sylvia: Cooke, Pl,oyd Powell, 'Ad others insisted that prop0rty oavrr .rs be notified ed rcgarda.tr al l me0ti.n1Qs held to consider rozon.ings in �.he area—rather than r°cgist Orcd voters As had been indicated earlier, dirt. Bailey said that the questionnaires were being designed to serve d dual. purpose and cited the o�cpense of making t ''teens" by computer and two oomailings for the some 12,1100 regi storod voters and the 1.0, loo p Prank Kennett said that the people in Paradise are lucky to have M,►C to do the "log work" on rez0h inP,, th4tt the present Board o!5 Supoxv; sots are demanding compliance tvrth set d0lolopment standards and it is cur respons'"" ty to ;set up the arra so that, it can be dc�*oloped in. a y PLANNING COMMISSION Minutes 0,icember 8, 1977 46 manner so that somethijig is loft for generation.,; to CoMoi Mr. Balkell gave special -banlcs to L. � Mr. BailoY fol' his assi.qta,llce in responding to sTpec:if.1c questions from rcsid011t$ 'V0j.,,,r1,rdtng use pormuts. ]VIr. Loyd said that the Zoning should be Such that Wriancog and, use pe;mits would], be hard to cohic by. a Both Mr. Duncan and M r. Bailey assure(l, t1loso in th(, * U808 of property 4ill not be ch�-;IngeO by this zoni audience that present 119 study. JL'Vly E'Verhard commented that lie thought c_,Vory_th* said and pledged, his Personal support of the 0 TUI ctipp-,opriate had been Frorts of thos present. Mr. Camenzin(I sLiggestod, that blocks be placed on tiro proposed nairc that IMUld a -eccipiollt If,aquetion- '41 s a property ownersor just a 'registered voter --ill all effort to make the 110tifIcation process easier, and to ev<�tluatc inf0r=.tion received. Phil Mace) P,1radiSe "ttol'ned, reminded thoso present that their desires for a balancod Plan of rostrictive resident,Uil uses and expanded coin- morcial uses are celhtai,nlY limi.ted 1)), facts ­Iq,1tOr_ drainage and 0 , sellagC PrO]110111S� adequate roads, availabilitu of public utilities, etc, lie suggested that, for startOTs) an inventory of J'tl-e,,,t ,qysto, be made -,illd an overla; map s�1101ving the existing Systell, b s marl(; that these rosponsilile 0 in, for sUPOY1.119 fire Protection, recreation, school Paciliti0s, W(tt-or, and public utilities be imide aware Of the proposed plan at once; that Hhrl possibility of obtaining sowers )e further explored and that drainage pli-ns prepared by McCain 4 Associates some years ago could be dusted off and b)-Ougfit UP to date. Mr, Duncan, Tiot(-d that iI t was n little past 9:30 P. M,$ibanked people for their i .- nte2st, said. that; in his opinion, tile mgtttr had been well covore", announced that the next mocting. of MAC IqOuld be On Monday, Decomber 12 at Just: ice Court, and adjourned the meeting: (early in. the ]meeting' he 11"(l in"t0cl those interested in viciving SOI At least 50,' 0r't'tn'tg1C,!Os0, f7�oiel free to stay after the meeting and (lo the m'q'ps a't c OsL Who signed 010 guest register did, just thrlt--Vlowod the maps and, talon,ili�ormally--Llhtil long after 1.0 P. M., ) TAP'8: 78-54-1-199 2 -All SS -1 -All. 2 MalfUnCtllahed -4- tf_Q8 dMMIZ -- DeCeMber Wsl 1977 "17-2461 DTSOMSTON: PALUISE MAC REVIMT OF ACTIVITIES PkR.TAINING TO PARADISE LAND USE STUDY RECENTLY COMPLETED BY TTS"u PLANNING CONNIT' E a AND COMMMUTY VOLUNTEERS APPROVE WO AOTIVITTWO FOR T11E FUTURE iEZOXTNG OF PARADISE ANI) FUNDING NOT TO EXCEED 64000 WITH ADMINISTRATIVE OTr-ICEH TO BRING BACX TRANSFER Discussior cif the Paradise M-10 'revie-vi of ac',tivit'�es pertaining to a Paradise land are study recently completes try the planning committee and coimri�anity volunteers had at this t nic, Iry arl Bailey, Chairman, ti MAC planning committee, presented the land use taay map developed for }, the Paradise area. The map shows the zoning on each parcel of land, and. the use that each parcel has. There were approximately five people working t on the map for about sib weeks. The map is color roc.ea to show present, useage, present zoning and A-2 zoning in the area. Chairman Richter Mated that ',- Board would,like to commend MAC on the work they have done on this project, Mr. Bailey stated that MAC plans to hold hearings on each area of Para.disa regarding what zoning would be best for that arC;a. This will be noticed. If the proper zoning was in Paradise about 60 ppreent of" the problems for the board and the realtors could be eliminated. Mr Bailey stPrted that he was in favor of having property zoned before a residential subdivision was appro-sed b T Mr. Bailey asked that the board approve a fund not to exceed $43500 for the notices and mailing of notices for the proposed rezoning in the different areas OC Paradise. Bob Geiser, plann Lg3 stated that i the P ,anni xg Conmin ssion had reviewed the map on December $, 1977. ?+fir, Geiser stated that the Planning oommiss.ion a.ppr'o•red of the idea of going ahead and having meeting axea, byareay T ownero., The commission felt this was a oodaW47v fort n advisory group to take uoma of tho load off them. On mob'on of Supervi8bt Lemko; seconded by Bupervi oor `1�1eueley and unanimously parried, the IM activities POt6 the future rezoning of Paradise was approved and funding not to exceed 44j 500 with the ,administrative Officer to bring back a transfer wad approved. t .. y BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - ,lune 12, 1978 A. REVTIa11 ANIS DISCUSSION Or PROPOSI,I) Ri3ZONTNG IN PAf ADTS1? '18-102-2-175 Mr. Lawson, with the aid of a map, Presented a zonin.1, proposal .dor the north centra], part of Paradise to change the po(wkcts of A-2 Ltd. to R-1 A P, C. After discussion, motion was mark by CommissiOo-tel° 11-Verhard, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, to instruct staff to proceed tow rds setting hearAngs--changing the areas shown as 9-1 A & C to l -'I. AYES; ComIlissi.ottets Rverhard,; (111bert, StLitz, Wheeler and ha -Liman tentlett. NOES No one. ABSENT: No 0110 Motion carried+ :�_ . 7