The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About79-71 �_`'"'�'�� . ' - 1 `• r'f S :.� ."le • � , �?. . ,,'' / � . b •`,�� . � , yet '�a� , � ifi • , . �• ' .. ,.� o N • ``�� • 1� ^i � JU17 1% 1978 78-1302 DISCUSSIOMi. ALLO XXG PETITIONS TO SECTIONS 19-10 AND/Olt 19-12 :OF THE BUTTE COUNTY CODE FOR PLACEMENT OF A MOBILE HOME IM ALL ZONESRECARDLESS Or _14HETIIER THEY AP.E DESIGNATED FOR M033ILE DOMES Discussion of allowing petitions for variances to Sections 19-1.0 and/or 19-12 of the Butte County Ccde for placement of a mobile home in n1, zones regardless of whether they are,designatod for mobile 11 mes-held At this time Bettye Blair, interim planning directoV3 stated that at'the present time these petitions for variances are only allowed in zones allowing mobile homes The matter is to be discussed later in.the meeting, -, 78-1336 AUTHORIZE BRINGING Wit OF ORDINANCE TO ALLOW PETITION FOR vARIANCE , TO SECTIONS 19-10 AND/OR 19-12 OF THE BUTTE COUNTY CODE UNDER 'HEARING PROCEDURES_IWRESIDENTIAL AREAS Supervisor Richter stated that the petition for variance to Sections 19-10 and/or 19.12 of the Butte County Code for placement Of a mobile home on property is a very good thing. This is for care of parents: This enables younger people to take care of their parents. Supervisor Richter suggested that the policy be changed to allow these "variances with a public hearing to place mobile homes in all zoning areas„ At the present bir, they are only allowed where mobile homes are allowed. They should ,n be allowed in residential areas inhere µ there are conventional lorr,e Chairman WinstOh 8ta6ru 'iat he was opposed to this as 4 single family residences' are entit', 9 to protectiono On mt'~ion of Supervisor Richtet, seconded by.Supervisor'Moseley and carried, an ordinance to allows a petition for variance to Sections 19-10, and/ot 19-12 of the Butte County Cod,6 for placement of a mobile home after public hearing procedures in rd idecitial areas was authorized to be brought back. to the Board. AYES: Supervisors Lemke, Madigan, Moseley and Richter NOES: Chairman Winston w f H COUNTY DEP!#R1148NT Off' PUBLIC HEALT11 Division of Sanitation SUMMARY OF COINUNITY viATr,. R SUPPLY SAWLLM COMMUNITY SUPPLY ORMEY TABOR CAMP 1975 DATE; LOCATION 10 00+ MPN F t RI{S samples �Y(.,.NnrG.«.if,yr wa Ma »n. "µ./✓x+w. � u'^p ++n»» WI .u.w.«1r4F..✓, 3..;w uu �!{��u,,.Y �ifr i1N v)fNfeY 111.4 i1{ nH ya..a.,NUN�:�� "'""r..1.Ni Nr ,. ... I/G LN. 4J L /101 .......... . NN,4 •.�,-».•• �T,�J r,�1�+.M1.+.+ aH»nl.w» N�.4.�...lrr»»u«.+�«tee.+: ..HHr, Irw rNWi RnwIN 1f I,w+,»v+«'+"1'«.1 .WrN+n � �3 �s1..S.F,/•1i7lX.A�«.�vf.....w.,..i.:NN»:.w.1.+H ,NN..�...Nrw�+wNwa,. ,ww+��r.,wv:r.w.-w .fr:«n.N„»«.ww.uwN.N� N«.r�..+..«rYWiN.iw ��+,.:.!»:r..n.»•+».ra+..rR»w.. 74'.... .......... wNwN1r-wNINWr«NNNI rw«»:r:NWW,rTH «,.IN. r e.N Y 1 w,NNrrrr a,Nr V R rJlr'IWN4y.a.wkMiN,,• i'. i tH N ,, ! .��Z ✓ » .. xl,t,�»i,N ,N . W„Hw........... z2NHHN «MNN.4Hw+JN• w«wNN NWY1NNWh.W, NN»«,r �. �r .„..k.N.r:«.».».N», Rww......N...•,•.-+.rw»«.K v.w.:W,.» ....�r,,,.Y�..�Y YNN fu..:,.�..N..+.r...wlw-N:.n:-.»«I.c...««NNnN...:ffWrNhw.NNN»« N,«..«». .,.»..x»r. ,p,+� ,��34z.1'' �4r`�N a.sfww �� «r,NHUN.r1......4,w:N- »m ,1 r.» p•rw�r. .+W». y ru �Vj ff.. .N N. 1»., 1..,.... N .. .4:«»Nr . w,.rN r lel N•» N.«I»I+ ww,.d,.u. i ((//�� ♦✓��JN7•� � CZ.1 1. ..�f� ,r4.f..,N;: _ rte.:..::: 1c...,«:.r.,k....«N IN ..�..,«..�:N:_. H:,{r: w1«Yw1-.»r+.N :'{4A,f..1w.. .3linNnlN N , IL.KAwG Mi 'NNw»a,:4+ifnw'r ,+ iw YMfN.rNf N.,+N..n r..w rw +I r r�11N.............♦ . )rN N WNw.»..�NN,1« �:,N •! . .4YN ,. r...wr. ........ r +r rrp�•�1 .» �.`nu••`7^"N«Ir{WN»,.�.4W+�Y»+ R+». R41-��f•4, . rlrw.ft .-11uW,H»»r • w:i,:4 w I wllaN« ,.. p,wx+tW: :�N N.R r.....l { �i .,1 »NYi;.W.. .1'«Iwww W.YNIIHYw w 1) N rnr 5N, N»N»4 w.'�"rf"Ir wR�Nu-.4Mr:.1.1✓•' �N4 w�,"F�.».r»4+�i4:r...y.»«:�::rr Ywwn�rM:w.n.+...wwa s. ��F.nt TI• YN.. N H, n Ii»4u 4N.„�»^RYYI••4.4.I x.w,W4r,N..«ar.r,w4»t+N4»+4 r,r.r.NCHN.w,+R ,.♦ NM„»N•YVr.»�+N.I«.,;sYNY�.p..rww1.1:.+Yww.w.i.�.«««»NW4N«.rW:.uuH.i, ,_, %ikH..N7;.�N:4«.�::.,W.,, ., ............w {./4 ///"//////%///�� .. `-1 ((j-IJNr .IHNNW"r MNW.w Nn11,4rL(« Itl ^ w«» N» +wu. sNJ»jwr _. ; . , v W ♦ Nw,wN -..-:rM++»»r.�N•«sNm.HR uN. . x ,..N rw.. NY �-. ,..,N n N.I r .r.H . �. � . ,... W.N, r�� »,u. 9 »w Iw u,M,M4:Ni:.N.Y,nwu*,ww ILL r„I/•r.4L� 4Y+•,[ r •W1,7'*"^'.�'�'—^:fN+,•u .R..H.»u .Ni...----- '.. �'.a++-+Wvv.., M�ffN.�!», 1. i.N a +u41»YN, +Nw •i :»m IN,«.; ��N4W4,.NNw,NH,1 IwN. rwl.". w ,ujTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISS)ION XYMITES - August 21, 1978 B ITEM NOT SUBJECT TO CALTPORNTA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY Ar,,r Butte County Board of 8upervisors' proposed aMendment to Butte Count), Co(iel Chapter 24 amending the foljoj�ing Zoning Districts to allow mobile .homes": A -R (Agritultural-ResidentIal) A -R=S (Agtitultural-Residential) A -SR (A,Qrictilttir-,'I-Subtir'ban-Residential) H -C ('11.115ghway Commercial) R-1 (Sirle Vaml.ly R- I A (1-finimum Density Residential - Arts and Crafts R-2 (PuPlox Residential) R-3 (Minimum Density Residential) R-4 (Maximum, Denslty Residential Restricted Sorvi,ce) - R Mtburban Residential) 4-R K-1/2(Suburban Residential) S -R-1 (Suburban Residential) ;R -N (R0sI.dential-N0nCbnForminjzj \Mrs, B'Jaie Tevlewoa staff tindings noting that this pl'oposed amendmentwill, encompass all, zones jiow Prolilbiting'mobiles. Proponoftts: Leona Wilson, 6368 Lincoln Blvd, Oroville, spoke in favor of the "Aunt Minnie" clause. Opposed., Mard Cameron, 18.17 Merrill Road, Paradisej stated that whoa he wtis Supervisor noone worko4, Harder flian he did ror the passage of the "Aunt Minnie" Ordinance) but tll,'It t0tql problems had developed 1,4 pollcl.ng, 1-161 asked if thOV0 Could be S01110 guarohtue J�rom the Department of Sanitation as to enrorcomont. He added that the Proposal being, considered tonight would erase the integrity of all resqtvictLvo zoning and asked that tho Commission rocanimenct donial Barbara Ing) 467 Circle DrIDrive,Orovitle, bara I K' t. H, lkehorn, 188Mrarywood 'Drive, Paradise, and 8arbara Oddy, 7.872 Marywood Orive, Pararlisd, all spoke in. opposition— stating that to,allow mob ilos in those areas wood. Compromise all restrictive zonn'g, Ti was noted that the hearings Eor the "Aunt Minn. loll' ' mobiles weire 1)u5lisho4 but that the area vegldeftt.q were hot noticed. It was also noted tint the ordinanec provides ,for a monotar ' V deposit foT abateiftent but that the, Boa -ed of Supcevisor.,; had no or required such deposits. BUTTE COMY P..ANNING (10MISSION XXXUTh8 - AUgUat 21) 1978 Couiisal Siomson ox,plalined -01'at the propo.,-,'I't before tile C0111mi 'Ls,5jon lJould allow us a "perial'ttod" 'uso l,n these zollos, and agreed: that approval CoOd I.-iostlit In two mohilos Oil QIILx J)"Ircel, -Ono 'as Cl It Permitted" use and anothr,,ir an "Atint Mintlic". i W,Vrran Humhort (16-1-09)� ropro'; Oat I fig lIAC, snid, that he ivas there. to I . gatbor moro 'inrormatl.oil about )lear-ing and that IMAC wouIrl consLdel the 111".1-tter 'at tfich. moovilig, no"xt week. Arthur Stewart, 77.26 Skyway, stated that possage of this ordinance would leave to insurlance foi 'nvestiments in restricted areas and added that there !snuld be some way that could be policed Worked out to permit Czmllie, to toko care ol" thcIr oldet•lyi- Sats Gardner, P 0 Box 1202, Orovil le, owno-r or 5 acres in an A -R zolle and Poreseeing the need. ror caring For his atlod parents askod that the "Aunt Minflic"law be rowrittoll and made eilrorceable, I,itida Oslin, 511"79 Fickett Lane, Pa,radtse, ,;pol,,*o against the proposal, ant in response to horquest ,ion as to how o contractoi.* could have a spz,cial permit For li'vilig in a moot lc.for over two yeays While blfll ' (1 tng a home, staff explaLned tli,*I,t the ordinance, had been cluangod, -to allow annual renewal of yueh pormits. (244) i\ Fr goon, 6920 Mark Aoad, til ed that there be an ord-Inanco that would roquire installation of skirting anJ awnings Oil 1110biles- to holp aithance thvil, appeftliallce. iame8 Starr' -;s question (6582 Ilocky Lane) as to tile dorill-ition. or a llfriond'. as it opplies to the "dont M1,11ni.01, Ordinance Yemained. Linianswered. Commissioner L*vo)-Ilard commonLed that the mobile home restrictions as onforcod in Paradls,e Pines were Very effocttvo, Chairman, B00110tt, COMMOILO(I that the "Alint NiIIIIhie" was not being enforced and it was, lift his opinion, wi,ongr to downgra.do zoiting by parmittlhg, mobi'les in ro.,ti,-Icted, zone s Commissioner rxorhard sugqLStOd t)llqt° the 111,"Itter he Continued -,i.nd Counsel Slemson ickod that it be COr,tIhUOd to 'I t[Ille certain. hear'n g w'I Tho hear, .5 closed t o the public and attor discussion Commissior r Hverhard made a motion to contintio this iftattoy, untit the second rogutat meeting artor this, Lt;ito 20) arid. to ask the hoard iC they are OC "M tile implicatio!.,., of thlis proposal, His motion was soit:,_,nded by Commissioner Suitt-, niid uno n Lino (is ly passed.. MIDMUO - August P11 1978 In response to ,ci rom.�ost from Mrs, 131air fog some do. inito direct"jon, his to PreSentklt%c�n to VIC HOLITO Of SUI)QrrVISOry Comm SSi.oltrr RiVorhard adclod " T r T.110 San itrr.tion Departnte rt~ I_ti ro"",Itl.nt i o;; this ordinance, vnd there IS .SO11l : qU, s tK:iMi Ll rhe), care, Z would I i kQ -,o"know how. I wo1jul 11kc, to Rilut,r when—is it ori the of tho original appvorriI? If the*ve a ti no compl i.�r7eo to the regia l tit ion; , ►41iFtt tec rai.�c{: e do sue have? ATr Ivo J11l,ted to this Chapter 24 (ROttO County (10dIT If note wliy riot) or should wo Ido, and with rospeot to that, liow mitc-Ijil, BOAM or, SMPLI RVISORk M114UTEO — August P-21 1978 78-la"02APPS-AIRANCE: WE1RD�, CAMERON Mr. Cameron stated that he felt: the Board had made on error In asking Counsel to look into changing the ordinance under Chapter 24 to Allow mobile homes in 411 zones. If the change were allowed all zones would have to be changed to reflect that mobile homes are allowed. This should be clarified, In order for the Aunt Minnie to be allowed in all ,,i&oning the zotling must be changed to allow mobile homes in all zones: The Planning Commission held a meeting on this matter last :tight.. The matter was continued to August 29, 1978 for a report from Counsel and planning on this matter: The Board did not intend for homes to be placed. n all zones. They were wanting to be able to plane Aunt. Minnie 4pplications in all zones. BOARD OF W NI MV WSORS MM05 W ,A,us='f; 29 � 1978 78-1687 DISCUSSION CLARIVICATION OF 7NTHNT OR ,BOARD OF SUPERWOORS IN Anowl0G MOBILE HOMES PURSUANT TO SECTION 19^19 OF THE BUTTE COUNTY CODE ("AUNT MiNN1'G" AMENDMENT), N ALL ZONING DISTRICTS Supervisor Lemke asked Counsel if in order to allow Aunt Minnies in conventional home areas all of thos4, oistridts would have to have mobiles in the area? Jim Griffith, deputy county counsel, stated that Del Siemseti had been working on the matter. Bettye Blair,+ interim planning director,.,stated that thathad been Counsel's opinion at that time. There are other points that need to be resolved. SupeT-visor Richter stared that he had talked to Counsel regarding the statments about the Aunt Minnie. He indicated that the presentation was not correct. He :telt there would be no problem of differontiating the Aunt Minnie from other mobile homes on a limited basis. Del Siemsen,, deputy county counsel, stated that it would be a special use within those zones with special requirements that are required at the present timer Mrs. Blair :asked whether the special permit would be under the use permit process or 'special allowed use. She is concerned with the abatement proceedings. The proceedings are now field under the Board of Supervisors who holds a hearing. She wanted to know who would hold the hearings if iLwete under a use permit provision. Mr. Siemsen advised that the Board of Zoning Adjustment would then hold the hi.aringsb Supervisor Richter stated that he had received a csll sjying ditat many of th,e Aunt Minnies are illegal and that they are being rented and used as multi, -family !units, It was his understanding that these were enforced very carefully„ He wondered if there were Aunt Mirnies that were not being abated. Lyna Wnhart, environmental health director, stated that there are 67 active Aunt Miaftiesi Twetity of 0-:oG -- <<a�Lre been issued within On last year. Twelve have been renewed at leaat once. Thb ty 1tave been renewed more than twice. Five have been canceled out. TY. program ties been taken advantage cif in a Zowi' instances; The Depar,tmenL° has to hake the persons word, They attempt to make sure the same people are thete�, They try to get signatures. The fact that this is a temporary ;situation is explained to the applicants„ This is basically an exemption on the septic tank requirements Mrs. Blair stated that the petitions for variances are under the Health Department. If a use permit is needed it would tall under the Hoard of Zoning Adjustolent and the Planning Aepartment The abatement. procedure could then be a zoning violation proceeding. It: was felt that this should continue under the Health Depattment. BUTTE' COUNTY PLANN1140 COMM � SS ON MNUTRS - September 20t 197th A . rnmT T1MBD FROM AUGOST Autte County Board of Supervisors' proposed ((79--7) amendment to Butte County Cade, Chapter 24 amending the following Zoning Districts to allow mobile ,homes A -R (Agricultural; -Residential,) A -R -S (Agricultural -Residential) A -SR (Agricultural -Suburban -Residential) H -C (Sighway Commercial) R-1 (Simple Ramily Residential.) R-1 A & C (Minimum Density Residential - Arts and Crafts R-2 (Duplex Residential) R,3 (minimum Density Residential) R-4 (Plaximum DensityResidential - t Restricted Service) S -R (Suburban Residential) S-R-1/2(Suburban Residential. S -R-1 (Suburban Residential) ,R -N (Residential-Nonconforminel Y 79-21-2-253 Mrs, Blair called attention to the "Proposed Tdxt to bo Included in the Use hermit Section of all Subjret Ordinances", and added that mobiles 1n these zones would be "Aunt. Minnie" mobiles ONLY She then react a mcmoranc:um ftbm Lynn ' anbart, Environmental %, eview Director,' as ,follows oATEI 20 Sep:tercber 1W8 The Planning 06-a rissioh is considering the posoibill-by of permitting "Autib 2�3.mliet" in zonos where Mobile hombs are not normally permitted. It seems to me that this is a policy deci8ion to be made by the Commisci6n and the 13oard of. Supervisors. The otiginal haunt ranniott ordir:ance crab, adopted by the Board of Supervisors in IoAay of 1973. Since that time: 70 Auric ;athie variances have been issued 22 have been in effect for leets than one year 1,2 have been in effect for one to tiro yearn 30 have been in effect, for too br fibre ;years' 6 hoe been cancelled vo.'Lun'tari.ly The trend appears to 'be for more requestb for variances. Some requests are discouraged by our departhont arta tev& reach the Board. But more -requests d--0 being received. and granted by the toara as i r dicated by the ti.gurer44 Some, l Peel, are more bt a matter cf convenience than necessity] bUt I do rapt feel the't r BUTTE COUNTY PLAWNG 00*IXSStMN MXNUTE8 - SePtember 20. 1,978 there has been widespread abuse of t2ao intended purpose of the variance procedure. Beforo the crt,Linal requests Lo to the Board they are re:viewecl by our department both, ;%o to 'the reason for the request and the capability of then lot to adequately disperce of the added sewage flow. We also review the requests for renewal to see that the reasons for the variance still exiat and that the eevx o 0.10posal, is still functioning satisfactorily. So,ue "Aunt ;irx4es" are issued not for a variance from the sewage disposal ordlnatyce Cas in oeverai areas) nut for varies+ce from other ordinaneaR relating to sites and lot sizes. Ro attempt is currently being rrade to requ ro the -posting of bonds as is required by the ordinance.. Proponents i Neal l irV, 268 Old Tda. Road, Oroville, spoke in • savor or the Hunt hiinnc mobiles, but asked that no other mobiles be, allow ?d.in these zones Opponents: Barbara Oddy, 1872 Morriwood Drive, Paradise, asked that no mobiles of any 'kind be permitted in zones now prohibiting them-- particularly hemeparticularly not in R-1, zoning districts. (480) Ikehorn, 1.883 Merriwood Drivel. Paradise, echoed Mrs. Odd r r s statements and asked that alland work to got their area zoned 4ome years ago not be wasted. Word Cameron, '18.17 Merrill Rot, ,,disc, speaking far himself and for the Paradise Board. of Reil asked that mobil.ns not be allowed in thosr zones. Their concerns weve the lack of policing of the nttMinnie mobi.lea and th, ossibily.tY or- lowering t�ronerty values du ding in zone and placement of mobiles in the area. He asked how rentals of Ai ° ,Minnie niobiles could be ;permitted. In response, to a question from one of the Commissioners, Mr. Vanhart said that, to his knowledge, rio such mobiles were being ranted„ There was discussion regarding methods t)r policing these installations, but no formal recommendatio,is were made, Mrs. Blair read a lettbt; from,Xodma Utt, 2368 Stearns Road; Paradise, in opposition. Motion was made by Commissioner tverhard, seconded by Commissioner Wheeler, to recommend this proposed ordinanco,as submitted, for approval. AYES; Commissioners Bverhard, Stutz and Wheeler. NOBS Commissioners Bennet and Gilbert. ABStNTt No one, Motion ca ,riet1. BOARD OF STADERVTSQRS MNUTES September 26, 1978 78.1858 PUBLIC HEARING DATCS SET The Following public hearing dates were set: I. A public hearing datO of October 17, 1978 at 10;30 a.m, was set for consideration of extension of interim M1 (light industrial) property located west of Cohasset Road, south of Sycamore Creek, north of Frontier Ci-.c1e and east of the drainage easement, Chico. 2. A public hearing date of October 17, 1978 at 10130 a.m. was set for consideration of extension of interim C-2 (general commercial) that portion of property not within the city 'limits of Chico located on both sides of Mangrove Avenue, between Cast lst Avenue and 888t 5th Avenue, Chico. 3. A public hearing date of 'October 31 1978 of 10.00 a.m. was set for consideration of Butte County Board of Supervisors' proposed amendment to the Butte County Code, Chapter 224 amending the following zoning districts to allow mobile homes: A -R (agricultural residential), AR -5 (agricultural. residential), A -SR (agricultural -suburban residential), H -C (highway commercial), R-1 (single family residential), R-1 A&C (minimum density residential, arts and crafts), R-2 (duplex resi.dential), R-3 (minimum density residential), R-4 (maximum density residential, restricted service), S-A (suburban residential,), SR -1/2 (suburban residential;), SR -1 (suburban residential), R -N (residential -nonconforming). 4. A public hearing date of October 17, 1978 at 10:43 aim, was set for consideration of Vern MCMath proposed negative declaration and rezone from "TM -20" (timber mountainous) to "TM -10'x, property located appx`nximabel.y 1/4 - 1p.j miles north of the intersection of Doe Mill Road and Schott Road on the west side of Doe Mill, identified as AP 63-04.61 and 62, containing 74,34 acres, more or less, Forest Ranch, S. A public hearing date of October 311 1978 at 10-30 a.m. was set for consideration of Stoneson DevelopMont Corporation proposed environmental impact rep(,. -'t and r,.Zone from 11A-2 limited" (limited general) and "PA -C" (planned area -cluster) for a 120 unit residential development property located approximately 400 feet west of Clark .Road at Nunnoley Raad, identified as AP 53.12.46 (portion) and 54-04-82 (porton), containing 25 acres, more or less, Paradise, 6, A public hearing *late of October 24, 1918 at ma 5 a.m. wag set fat consideration,of Iiynolta Homes & tee Colby proposed negative declaration and request for amendment to the Butte County General Platt Land Use Element Plan from low density residential, 1-4 dwelling units per acre to medium density residential, 9-12 dwelling units pot acre retail cocrcnerc al, and industrial fro their property located south of Ornva.11o M:.nut,es, Octo`Lgr 31. 197 d 78-2077 rUBLIC HEARING, BUTTE COUNTY BOARD OF SUJvv gV1SQRa'pRppt�SBp AMENDMENT TO THE BUTTE COUNTY CODE, 'CHAPTER 24 AMENDING THE, FOLLOWING ZONING DISTRICTS TO ALLOW MOBILE HOMES; - A�-SR, H -C, R�-I R-2,. R�-3 R-4, S -R SR -I/2,_ SR-�I and R -N A R, AR -5, T e pu is searing on the Butte County Board of Supervisors' proposed amendment to the Butte County Code, Chapter 24 amending the following zoning districts to allow mobile homes; A -R (agricultural residential), AR -5 (agricultural residential, A -SR '(agric,dtural-suburban residential), H'wC (highay R-1 (single family residential, R-2 (duplex residential), R-�3m(nimum density ial)r residential), R-4 (maximum density residential, restricted service), S -R (suburban residential), SR -I/2 (suburban residential), SR. -I (suburban residential) R -N` (residential --nonconforming) was held as advertised. Bettye Blair, Planning director, set out the background of this hearing, stating that it is the result of the Board and public request to allow mobile homes on other zoned areas. The amendment has been published in the papers. Memo from Mrs. Blair stating that there could possibly be a conflict of the General Plan if this request was approved discussed. Memo from Lynn Van Hart discussed, Supervisor Richterstated that it was his understanding that it would be extremely unlikely that density request would be violated. In the Chico area, a mobile home could not be placed on certain lots due to the location of the homes and the backyard and sideyard requirements. Hearing opened to the public. Appearing; I. Word Cameron,, 1837 Merrill Road,, paradise; spoke on behalf of himself and for people requesting t� ° , to represent them. He sfated that the only way he would support this vias if the people in the neighborhoods would come out and support this. If this were to be approved, there would be numerous requests for the placement of mobile homes in rosidentlal areas. It is a problem to police these matters. In the past, the Board has tried to zone areas in, the way the people wanted It zoned. 2, Ms, Adele Perry, Chairman of the paradise Board of Realtors; spoke in opposition to this amendment. 30 Mrs. Kedma Uft, paradise, filed her written opposition to tit'` amendment with the Clerk, 4. Mr. Paul Ager, Dunster Drlv,, ,stated he was aonaeA!ned about this omendment. He is in an A -R disN -neighborhood is in � 4t Process of circulating petitions to rezone his are„ , „„r A -R to Rrl. MAC °f also recommending that this area be zoned R -1a He spoke In apposition t( o amendment y5• Mrs, Katherine Harris, Valley View Drive, par'adke,j spoke f 1 opposition BOARD U)VU Mixttat ria 6atober 31 19'78 6. Mrs. Naorpi Culley spoke in favor of the amendment. 7. Mr. Jardin, OrovFlle, state, he would like to harp his Parents. He falt the people of Orovi Ile should be allowed to place these mobile h on fl °4ome.$ properVY to take care of their aged parents. 8. John Schuck, 5800 Fickett Lane, paradise, stated people di rit need to place mobile homes on their property to take care Thep a Long before mobile homes Were created, children took care e the' parents,, .parents in "' �)r own homes. Spoke in :apposition to the amendment aged 9. Mrs. Jackie WoodccciC, parodiset spoke in opposition. Chairman Winston stated that a petition signed b filed in protest of this amendment. y 114 people was Hearing closed to the public and confined to file board. St Derr koi Lemke had questions about the amendment. There are no provisions within the amendment to state the size of flip mobile home age or condition, He asked about the deposit amount to be filed for the removal of fho home. Supervisor Richter asked County Counsel if the amendment could be. approved with the deletion of the R-1 areas. this could be L6ne, Mr. Blackstock stated that Supervisor Ric inter felt that the old people should not be Hiarehoused w-rnd out of sight. to purpose of these mobile homes is to provide i t o lo),ra;y dwelling for Wilder people. The home has to ke removed When it is no lai, w ;eded Chairman TWt,,tfon stfuted th t o the people that warehouse; their pc;°tints now,. Will continue �,w� wareh }r:;e tl, , y . and he did �,� a need a mobile 'inure �,, ,., i -1e took care of his aging grandmother pressure brought on this Board to allow 'ed en lire prop4rty, There hos been no areas. Hs does i ,i know what leas brought �this�to the Boainnie " rrd5slatte'nt ononed i _. Supervisor Madigan stated that in his neighborhoods residents would be allowed to place r mobile home in the front yard of their parcel or in backyard. He would .}ate against this amendment, Supervisor Lemke stated that it seems to him_ that the rnajorit of t Opposition comes from the paradise area. Y he Is a terrible thing and that they do not beloThewmPlIhere there nit arethat 0 ho bile home that is on unfatt assumption, mes, If Was moved by Suf,,Irvisor Richter, and seconded by 5u ervisor Lemke that this amendment be sent back to the planning Cotr;t isp _ i recommendation that the N areas be deleted from the amendments with file the planning Commission direct themselves to the o"riteria of need, sizer age 'and thaf and condition of the home. and ghat they briback their recommendat►on to thin. Aoord for board cons dErat on o ng Chairman Winston spoke in opposition to the motion, that all the oratory today trbout fire ware He submitted continue even.if this amP►;.�a.: �� ,, housing of the elderly will still BOARD OF SM-ItIRLSOIRS - Migutest Uotober N t, 197 Supervisor Richter said he appreciated the sinceri ty of Chairman Winston. H.) felt that if the neighborhood concurs with thii request, then the mobile horse should bu allowed. The people should be given the opportunity to p-:5test on their own rf they do not want the mobile home in their neighborhood. They shouldbe allowed ;'o make their yawn decision. VETE ON MOTION; AYES: Supervisors Lemke, Moseley and Richter NOES: Supervisor Madigan and Chairman Winstone there Chairman Winston askedif�vould be any objection to having another public hearing on the amendment following planning Commission's recommendation. It was stated there would be no object r'o such a hearing. RECESS: 11:10 RECONVENED: Zai C'V otic: �jlvxowli) IIIMI PI'S i ..,� Novoi-ber Ill., 197a M. A+ Holsworthy of al,� parodise A.petition has been receiYPO slgnbd .bY 38 persons protesting the proposed amendment to Chapter 24 of the Butte County Code for use of mobile homes in restricted residential areas. Ta be discussed at time of the continvotion of th6 'hearino, concerning "Aunt Minnie "placement of`_mabi,le homes, BUTTE COUNTY PLANNZRT' r ffI��UTEs - onfISSION November I 1978 :CII. REFERRED FROM THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS on October # tober 31, 1978' A. Butte County Board of Supervisors' anend,aent to Buttc County Code, Chapter amending the foZlaking Zoning Districts to aZlol,. mobile _hones: A -R (.Agricultural -Residential) A -R-5 (Aariculturai- Res idential) A -SA (Aa ricultural-Suburba:I-Residential) Y -C (Lighway Commercial) R-1 (S -Ingle Faril.v Residential) R; -I A. & C (?'nirrun Density Residential- Arts and Crafts (Duplex Residential) -3 (Mini. -Mum Density Residential)' R--4 (ffaxinuni Densi.tj Residential Restricted Service) S -=R (Suburban Resident -l) S'`R-Ij2 (Suhurhan Residential) S -R -Z (Suburban Residential) R -Nr (Res id:ert.ial-Nbnco; '�rornine) 76 -Lo -2-25S xrrs,. Blair read the foll"iRg menorandum from staff, dammed Iv Z978r ovember 13 The Board of Supervisors, at their public hearing on October 3 -1978,, referred the proposed amendment bay to the Planning C'omr,!ission recommending the fc?loi.ing l_. That the Co,' -mission consider and establish specific requirements for findiz� of need for the additional dwelling 2-- Consider establishing minimum size requirements for the moble 3- Consider establishina- bPossible maximum age of the mobile. 4- Consider establishing m.ni,-num standards for the condition of the mobile, Ainstallation of the 'mobile and Possibility '?f requirements for skirting, etc. . Lalete the R. -Z zoning district from the anendnent-r this to include the RI A &C. After discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Stutz, seconded' by Commissioner Plheeler,, to recommend to the Board of Supervisors this proposal. be approved as originally transmitted to them by that Commission. tLv AYES: Commissioners Gilbert, Stutz, Wheeler and Chairman : Bennett. NOES 110 one. ABSENT: Commissioner Eberhard. otior carni --d. ((i9-7` I w Bob Paulus - Div. of Forestry °��'; --R—ev Crim, m� eri , Nth. 46-044-2ASol y i y}'ny��ytW „( /� j �{may! `Ne Varionc© from the stnndn�rd fs5' .ran taxa to .. frontage for parcel 2, prope rtY zoned A, -Z onthe NW corner of Ohio Cu11 Chico ...-,.....�,......a.... 'McK nneY Bros . Inc. ��.,I.LLItLJ.'1`ar'»,,,,,+a+•n.,r.,n,w,wwrwr.nnw,w.N.r�n 1002 East l6th Street, Chico, Cs- 9592E ss T3GAp2 ? OF ZONING ADJUSTM M., T ACTIO' SCiiEDUIM, 11/20%78, DATr DISTRIBUTED I. lLTTCIU�NT C,e� zo -, �# .»: �"-.� .dM NY'bri 4.� i'�4MY��6p6�16RFYi�1RYklkif4'Y11�LL16N�Iw5".S'Y �l:pw7i..S; V»�:Ifka W.�;-V6a':a.'�fWstl.:.Wh►?ri�'iFitt4a. �:%+4M�'p6sY�'SX':.. WYE•" "'� 4.- Mill) OF SuItT714vV-Wit-�1 MINUT111"s Povem` er 21, 1976 - - - ?- .Lir. Y. ., i:i. LY W W P VA - - - - - - - - . 78-2192 PUBLIC WRING DATE 'SBI! DISCUSSION: BUTTE COUNTY BOARD Or SUPERVISORS' PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO BUTTE COUNTY CODE, CHAPTER 24 AMENDMENT TO Tats FOI,'OMNG ZONING DISTRICTS TO ALLOW MOBILE ROMES: A -R, AR -5, AwSR, H -C, R-1, R-1 A&C, R-2, R-3 S -R, SR -1/2, SR -1 & R -N Discussion of the Butte County Board of Supervisors° proposed amendment to the Butte County Code, Chapter 24 amending the following zoning districts to allow mobile homes: A -R (Agricultural resident al),, AR -5 (agricultural residential), A -SR (agricultural -suburban residential). H -C (highway commercial), R-1 (single family residential), R-1 A&C (min;iiarh density residential, arts and crafts), R-2 (duplex residential), R-:3 (minimum density residential), S -R (suburban residential'), SR -1/2 (suburban residential), SR -1 (suburban residential), R -N (residential - nonconforming) was held at this time. Bettye Blair, planning director, stated that the Beard indicated on October 31, 1979 that they would possibly consider setting a new hearing for consideration of the Aunt Minnie ordinance. This should be set for a time certain and readvertisede There was no recommendation from the Vlanning Commission, A public hearing date of January 9, 1979 at 10:15 aim was set for consideration of the Butte County Board of Supervisors' proposed amendment to 'Butte County Code, Chapter 24 attending the following zoning districts to allow mobile homes: A -R (agricultural residential), Alt -5 (agricultural residential), A -SR (agricultural -suburban residential), H -C (highway com"rcia).), R-1 (single family'residontial), R-1. A&C (minimum density residential, arts and crafts), R-2 (duplex residential), 1-3 (minimum density resplc,ttial), S -R, (suburban residential), SR -1/2 (suburban residential), k -1 (suburban residential), R -N (residential - nonconforming) , residential-nonconforming)z EXECUTIVE SESSION; The Board recessed at 1.04.50 a.mi to hold an executive' session regarding litigations RECONVENE. The Board reco,wened at 1102 aam, following an oxecutive session regarding litigttion. Nothing to report, Baouutv tootmuov''5* !Wo .+ 4 #z a m' ke CI e4' sa qi m a to w cn Ct w G7 f� c }q m K 'a in tiu ie Matthew Wn Wistreich, Paradise. Mr. W49tte.ich forwards a petition contiainirig 47signatures of homeowners n'rea who are opp6sdd tohaving the Fa int• minfiie'l tra3 ers edmiit in{:b their e.immunity. To be provided tit he h�eorf ng on the proposed ordinances oharige. n., I ,1.7(RJ11UD 01' k;TJ1 110u+,F tl u__ JLluuar, " 9* 1979 79-69 PUBLIC HEARING: BUTTE COUNTY ;n1), OF SUPERV*SORS. PROPOSED AMEND_MR1,41 TO THE BUTTE COUNTY CODE, CHAPTER 24 THE ZONING DISTRICT'S V ALLOW MOBILE HOMES _ Tho public hearing on the Butte County Board of Supervisors' proposed amendment to the Butte County Code, Chapter 24 amending the following zoning districts to allow mobile homes, A -R (agricultural residential), -"'-5 (agricultural residential), A -SR (agricultural -suburban residential), H -C (highway commercial), R -I (single family residential), R-1 A & C (minimum density residential, arts & crafts), R-2 (duplex residential), R-3 (minimum density residential), R`-4 (maximum density residential -restricted service), S -R (suburban residential), SR -i/2 (suburban assadvert'rs�d SRThrssr'bGrbean�ubls hed hearing. (residential -nonconforming) was held . ` Within the proposed ordinance would 1 be a statement that the variance would be granted for a period of one year and could be renewed annnually, Lynn Van Hart stated that the trend appears to be for more variances,. Someone from the staff goes out to the site to inspect for water and sewage disposal: Hearing opened to the public. Appearing; I. Ward Cameron, 1837 Merrill Road, Paradise, He explained the "Aunt Minnie " variances that are in existence at this timo, This proposal is an expansion of the present ordinance. This privilege has been taken advantage of by many people. He did not think the Board should change and allow these homes in all zones. If allowed, this might negate i`he zoning. 2. Mrs. Adele Perry, Paradise. Stated she was concerned because the amendment does riot specify the criteria for the type mobile home that will be placed on the property. She felt that there were loopholes within the ordinance that should be closed. 3; Mr DeVere Pace, Chico. He flit that with the dollar getti„� <,heaper, this advantage could be worthwhile for many people. 4i Mrs. C. L. Harris, Paradise; She read a prepared statement in opposition to this amendment. 5. Mr. Frank Brazell. He felt that the Counr'y should not deny the old folks being taken care of by younger members of the farnfly. He would like 'to sea the old folks g kfah a butter k:hahce to live properly 6. Garrett Burke; paradise. Stated that he resertits statements made by Mrs. Harris, He lives in a mobile home becciwm he wants to live in one. Fent he should hout be allowed to place a mobile home on his prope*ty to tape care of a disab 7. Mri Roger .lardiriaire Ward Blvd.-, Oroville, stated that there are two times in our lives that we need help. One when we bre a baby and othgt time is when we are did. He set out ideas on how this could be handled. Parcels should not be less than one-half acre; owner should meet County's building r ' ,a 1ati 01" code and requ frements for :sowoge and utility hack -up.s. A bondsliould be posted by the proporr)+ owricr aridi file si+r4lall'� .�";ra ,�- : fjsibio kir the nacbi l l7ptnc no., The mobile hrmes should be kept in rocoono.ble, rapair, No coinmercic l , oncd arta should be al lowod to have mobile homes. laearinq closed to elle �Ubf is sand confir)ed to the kard, Q Because Choirman Lomks 'is 3.#r41St Ut� this time, Vice�Ghairmgn Winston felt this hearing should be continued to January Ib; 1979 so that, the etit re Board would be present to vote on this mattwi' z Heoring continued to Tuesday, January ICS, 174 92 7�- BOARD OF SIWxM •ORS PUN' T45 jan,t qxy lC , 1 CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING DV,I`l"1' COUNTY BOARD or SUPER'nsoRS" PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO TRE, BUTTE COUNXY Corr o CHAPTER 24 AMMNDI'NC TuE rono:WING ZONING DISTRICTS 190 ALLOW MOBILE '110MES IIA -R" (ACRICULTURAL itESTDENT,ti1t)r If Alt. -V (AGXECULTURAL RESIDENTIAL), "A -SRS' (ACRICt;!MUML-SUBURBAby RESIDENTIAL) t 11-C" (HIGHWAY C0I0MMAL), TSR -1" (SINGLE FAMILY tLESIDM NTIAL) a, 1IR-1 A&C" (MxIQIMtmi DE11SITY REF" ..C.NTIAL, ARTS AND CRAFTS), "R -tit (DUPLEX RESIDENTIAL,fj, -311 (MINIrM4, DEiN,J. RE,SIDENTIAL) $ 1IR-4 (MAXIMUM DENSITY RESIVE NTTAL RESTRICTED SI RVTCE) "Ss -R" (SUBURBAN UsIDENxIAL S l/2" s ) , "R� (SUBURBAN, RESIDENTIAL ,w',11iR „1" (SLTBuRI3AN RI SIDENTT.AQ , I'R-NI! (RESIDENTIAL NONCONFORMIIAC The closed public hrarkng on the Bute County Boarcl of Supervisors, proposed ameirtdment to the Butte County Code, Chapter 24 amending the following zoning districts to allow mobile homes. "A -R'" (agricultural residential);, p1AR-5" (agricull aral residential) , "A -SR" (agricultural - suburban residential), '%-C" (aighway commercial), 'IR -1" (single family residential), "R-1 A&C', (mit.imum density residential, carts & crafts), "R-2" (duplex i:esident al) i. "R-311 (minimum density resjdent.$,bl), 11l 4" (maximum density residenti�jl restricted service) "S -?t"' (subutbon res1dent:i.al) 11SR-1I2 (suburban residential), 'Isla -"O' ( nur;)an residential), "R -N" (residential nonconforfting) was held as conii,nuiF, Discussion" of the testimony of the previous hearing held, at this time. Chairman Lemke stated that he had 'listened to the tape of the public hearing. Supervisor Moseley stated that Frank Brazil and DeVere Pace both spoke in favor of the amendment at last week's hearing. She .felt th4t there may be some zones that shuiild be eli„..`aated. She felt this Was a good way to help 'people. Supervisor Winston stated that he was opposed to the amendment. For every person that appeared at the henri.ng for this there were probably 50 people against it. He felt that the ordinance would bk, a further erosion of preserving certain areas for single family dwellings. Chairman Lemke advised that: he had talked with many people in Paradise who were opposed to the ordinance. This is the first indication that he has had that there are people in other parts of the county that are opposed to the ordinance amendment. Supervisor Wheeler stated that she had re awed more call against the amendment than for it. Supervisor Dolan stated that she had received a lot: of input regarding the mattaro Ste felt the present method is adequate. She could not €;o alon- with allnrvin mobile homes in all zones. CLQ airinatt Lemke felt that the solution In the single family zones Would be the guest house provision. It allows a 500 foot guest house, with no kitchen facilitiesPossibly the Board could eonsider a provision that would allow conking facilities in the guest: _house. r .0 : a amendment as n.* seconded bt, Supervisor Dorn x ervi.sor Winston sec and carried the ordinanc ed in memo :,from the Vionn:.ng. On motion of 5u e e , �.. R , .. _ ' p olan Airectar dated November 16 1975 was denied �1Y1.S; Supervisors b Wn el x and Winston, DOSS. Supervisor Moseley and Chaia.litan Lemke., BTr-TH COUNTY PLANNING COMMXSSION 14INUTES - April 9, 198Q P. AUNT MINNIE - Discussion of possible %mendments to Butte County Code re: Atint Minniei Mrs. Blair called attention ,'i the Commissioners to the -following memo dated April 9, 1980 from staff. ,As a result of the Piant rezoning which the Board denied on Mar c1 2S, 1980 and then or, April 1 adopted an AR -MH -7 interim Zoning allowing the applicant to make application for an -"Aunt Minnie",, the Board of Supervisdrs asked for a review and recommelidations from the Planning Commission and staff:` regarding possible -relief for similar situations. The Commission may remember that an amendment to the County Code initiatedby the Board of Supervisors—which would have allowed ,mobiles in all zoning districts under sbmewhat similar circumstances as now required by "Aunt Minnie", was heart', by this Coirmigsibn in August And September of 1978 and recommended for approval. The B6atd on January 16. 1979 determined to deny, this amendment to Permit mobiles in all zones. If the Commission withes to reinitiate this amendment; staff would be happy to brixig it back in a more specific form. This matter will be carried back to the he Commission for 9-.tioh 'next week. Nie BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING CUA` MISSION MIN11TV38 - Apx34.1 16, 1950 VII. ADD ITEM. A. Aunt Alinnie (Amendment to County Cock r u—c 79 �7) 80=57-1-284 Attention was called to the memorandum received last week by the Com missioners concerning this matter: it was agreed to recommend that mobiles be allowed in 611 zones (as proposed by the Commission on September 20; Ic OW -Departmental Memarcgtta T0., lalttnttxrrg commissioners FRO141 �, � ' Interim Planria,no Divector 7 �^'° % 13rtt) .•, l� Manx, I suRJJ:crr Amend;it�4 nt to Chapter 24, Butte County Code DATE! August: 3.1 , 1978 The Board of supervisors, as a resul-tof continuing i.ntorest on the part of the citizens of Butte County, requested that the Manning Comn,lission 1101'd hearings modifying all zoning districts to allow a mobile home k -i be placed on parcels in conjunction with the existing development to enable families to cane for poisons or i"amity who by reason of age, disease, infirmity, or other cause are `unable, unassistecl,to properly manage and take care of them- selves or «ou,id, benefit from familial assistance. It is the Board's feeling that the provision for maintaining such persons would, be ben fi;,ir.l to the health safety and welfare of the people of Butte County. In order to facilitate this proposal it will be necessary to amend all zoning districts which currently prohibit mobile homes. It is the Board's iixtent that the -7o Additional dwelling °nits would then be considered through the section of Butte County Code 19-1.9 (called the Aunt Minnie Amendment) which provides that mobiles may be installed on property, that the mobile shall. only be allowed where the zone allows the placing and uta]iza.tio7t, of a mobile home, that the placemen". of said mobile udll still be subj ecA, to the variance proceedings as provided within afore- mentioned section o,f the Butte County Code 19-19. (see attachment) Staff would comment that inasmuch as the zoning distri,ts which now allot mobile homes a: . exporiencing these additional dwelling units on parcels through the "Aunt Minnie" amendment that the densities recommended by the General nl.aa. are compromised. Additionally, the Commission should. con8idex the continuing dialog of the "Conventional. Residence" vs "The Mob i;Le liome,''ia addition to the increased densities. BBjhd Attach: Notice as hereby given that the Butte County Planning° Commission will consider, on Monday I August 21., 1978 a project not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act; 1 Butte county Board of Supervisors' proposod amendment to Butte County Code, Chapter 24 amending the following Zoning Districts to allow mobile .homes A -R (Ao,ricultural-Residential) A -R- 'Agricultural -Residential.) A -SR �kpriciiltuxal-Suburban-Residential) H -C (Highway Commercial) R-'1 (Single Family Residential'4 R,.1 A. & C (Minimum. Density Residential - Arts and Grafts R-2 (Duplex Residential) R-3 (Minimum Density Residential) R-4 (Maximum Densit}, Residential. Restricted Sdrvice) S -R (Suburban Residential,) S�-R-1/2(Suburban Residential.) S -R-1 (Suburban Residential') ;R -N (Tle8idential.-Noncon.Rormi:na) This meeting will be held in the Board of Supervisors' Room, 1859 Bird Street, Oroville, California, and is scheduled to begin at 7:30 P. M. BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION BETTYE i LAIR INTERIM PLANNING DIRECTOR Published in the Biggs News Gridley Herald Chico Enterprise Record Paratise post and Orovi.11e Morcury UWAGE DIsPOSAL 19-19 See. 19-19. Variances. A variance inay be granted to any of the provisions of Sec� tjr�-,.s 19-10 and 19-12 of this chapter by the board of super- visors. Anyone applying for variance to this chapter shall petition therefor directly to the board of supervisorso and said petition shall be accompanied, by a fee of twenty-five dollars which is not returnable in the event the variance. is not granted. Upon receipt of such a petition the board of super- visors shall set same for public hearing and shall advertise notice of such hearing pursuant to Government Code section 6061. And provided further, such hearing shall not be sched- uled earlier, than ton days from the date of Publica,tion. Variances granted hereunder shall contain provisions which will accomplish the ,following: (1) That the :nubile Moine may be, ph..'ed on the property without violating any of the setback reqviraments. of I A 4 the zones in Which the property is located. (9) Thrt tho niobille home shall only be allowed where thd .tone in which the property is situafe allows for the placing and utilization of a mobile honie; provided, how- ever, that thure shall be no requirement for an addi- tio I nal site for said mobile home as the term "site" is i ized in this 6aptetj or any other county ordibAftce or code provision, in that tbis allowed use is temporary in nature. (a) Th,at the mobile home to be placed on the property rnttY only be utilized by a relativ3i either by marriage or by blood or close friend, of the owner ol, the property on which it is to be placed, and there may be no rent charged to the occupant of the mobile home, The 'mobile home rnsy !)e owned by i6ither the owner of !and on which it is to be placed, or the relative or close frind who shall be n8ldftig therein: (4) The variance granted hereunder shall be for the term of one yoz The board of supervisor6 -IA application of the property owner and without a public hearing: ' may grant an extension of suL,,h variance for periods 202.1 SUPP, NO, G.,11 Ple, A AFT, ZIRI�N TIM % o4, W. e "�441 5r o4, k 1" ,'1 eP7n •fitt# k �ttn kl igp{p' - +. a �xA d .1i y�.,�( � a�' v*�.., �t Y iH.� "tit+1yt.�C•xi"++�++�'�ii `Y f Y * i r s#, z� � e,r• 19-20 BUTTLI COUN'T'Y CODE § 10-20 not exceeding one your, In the event the applicant who esiding within the mobile home, or the conven- tiona< residence for any reason moves to another 'lo- cation or is deceased, then in that event, the variance granted herein automatically expires and the mobile home shall be removed within thirty days, In the event the mobile horne is not removed within thirty days pursuant to the Berms of the variance, the county shall remove said mobile home and store it at the owners expense, The county shall require either a deposit or bond sufficient to cover the removal expense at the time the application for the variance is approved', The amount of such deposit or bond shall be determined at the time of the hearing for the variance, The request for the variance shall he signed by both the applicant and the relative+ or other person to receive or render assistance, and ,l*all provide that Butte County is liven a right of entry on the property and the right to remove the mobile home, and More same at the sole cost and expense of the applicant. (Ord. No. 1357, § 2, 5.22.73 Ord, No. 1580, § 1, 5.6.75.) See. 19.20. ['Use of "gray -water" for on-site plant irrigation;j (a) It is ,h ,reby provided that notwithstanding any of the provisions of section 19-4 of the 13utte County (lode, "gray }eater" produced on a premise in specified geograltihical areas where the board of superviso>,s finds byresolution thvt t (1) A critical domestic water shortage exists in a specified area; and (2) Strict Nvater conservation measure., are necessary in said area. (b) As used herein, "gray -water', means that liquid house- hold Svaste normally associated with the kitchc t1 sink, laundrv) bathtub or slinwer and Nvashbasin, slid specifically excludes toilet or urintll wastes. Irrigation of plants with "gray -water" shall be done in a manner which will not cause odors; or breed= Ing places for mosquitoes, or outer nttis:ince, and further theme shall be no "ponding," of staid water, (Ord, No, 181.5, § 1, 3«29-17; - Supp. No, Gil 2112:2 4 dk� Yvy#a wy1 �� r n. s •� n' « a wad ,"a.' * i r s#, z� � e,r• 19-20 BUTTLI COUN'T'Y CODE § 10-20 not exceeding one your, In the event the applicant who esiding within the mobile home, or the conven- tiona< residence for any reason moves to another 'lo- cation or is deceased, then in that event, the variance granted herein automatically expires and the mobile home shall be removed within thirty days, In the event the mobile horne is not removed within thirty days pursuant to the Berms of the variance, the county shall remove said mobile home and store it at the owners expense, The county shall require either a deposit or bond sufficient to cover the removal expense at the time the application for the variance is approved', The amount of such deposit or bond shall be determined at the time of the hearing for the variance, The request for the variance shall he signed by both the applicant and the relative+ or other person to receive or render assistance, and ,l*all provide that Butte County is liven a right of entry on the property and the right to remove the mobile home, and More same at the sole cost and expense of the applicant. (Ord. No. 1357, § 2, 5.22.73 Ord, No. 1580, § 1, 5.6.75.) See. 19.20. ['Use of "gray -water" for on-site plant irrigation;j (a) It is ,h ,reby provided that notwithstanding any of the provisions of section 19-4 of the 13utte County (lode, "gray }eater" produced on a premise in specified geograltihical areas where the board of superviso>,s finds byresolution thvt t (1) A critical domestic water shortage exists in a specified area; and (2) Strict Nvater conservation measure., are necessary in said area. (b) As used herein, "gray -water', means that liquid house- hold Svaste normally associated with the kitchc t1 sink, laundrv) bathtub or slinwer and Nvashbasin, slid specifically excludes toilet or urintll wastes. Irrigation of plants with "gray -water" shall be done in a manner which will not cause odors; or breed= Ing places for mosquitoes, or outer nttis:ince, and further theme shall be no "ponding," of staid water, (Ord, No, 181.5, § 1, 3«29-17; - Supp. No, Gil 2112:2 4 dk� Yvy#a wy1 �� r •� n' « a wad ,"a.' * i r s#, z� � e,r• 19-20 BUTTLI COUN'T'Y CODE § 10-20 not exceeding one your, In the event the applicant who esiding within the mobile home, or the conven- tiona< residence for any reason moves to another 'lo- cation or is deceased, then in that event, the variance granted herein automatically expires and the mobile home shall be removed within thirty days, In the event the mobile horne is not removed within thirty days pursuant to the Berms of the variance, the county shall remove said mobile home and store it at the owners expense, The county shall require either a deposit or bond sufficient to cover the removal expense at the time the application for the variance is approved', The amount of such deposit or bond shall be determined at the time of the hearing for the variance, The request for the variance shall he signed by both the applicant and the relative+ or other person to receive or render assistance, and ,l*all provide that Butte County is liven a right of entry on the property and the right to remove the mobile home, and More same at the sole cost and expense of the applicant. (Ord. No. 1357, § 2, 5.22.73 Ord, No. 1580, § 1, 5.6.75.) See. 19.20. ['Use of "gray -water" for on-site plant irrigation;j (a) It is ,h ,reby provided that notwithstanding any of the provisions of section 19-4 of the 13utte County (lode, "gray }eater" produced on a premise in specified geograltihical areas where the board of superviso>,s finds byresolution thvt t (1) A critical domestic water shortage exists in a specified area; and (2) Strict Nvater conservation measure., are necessary in said area. (b) As used herein, "gray -water', means that liquid house- hold Svaste normally associated with the kitchc t1 sink, laundrv) bathtub or slinwer and Nvashbasin, slid specifically excludes toilet or urintll wastes. Irrigation of plants with "gray -water" shall be done in a manner which will not cause odors; or breed= Ing places for mosquitoes, or outer nttis:ince, and further theme shall be no "ponding," of staid water, (Ord, No, 181.5, § 1, 3«29-17; - Supp. No, Gil 2112:2 Infer -Departmental Memm Tac Pl,annjng CommissioalexS Snteri;m Y?'lanning,Director pan+, Rot tye Blair , SUBJECT, Butte County Code Amendment to Chapter 29, DAMAugust ll o 197$ The Board of superv:,sors, a•s a result- tof continuing interest on the part of the citizens of Butte County,requested that tile mPl lei homeo missio be on hhold heapings modifying all. zoning districts ced on parcels in conjunction with tie existing development toenable f dies e to care for persons or family who by reason of age, , Or other cause are unable, una.ssisted,to properly manage :end 'take care of them- selves or 'would benefit from familial assistance. It is the Board's feeling that the provision for maintaIni 6 such persons would be benefi.cral to tile bealth £; safety and raelfare n t�Te people of Butte County. In order to facilitate this proposal it will be necessary to amend all zoning districts which currently prohibit mobou'ldile ho itconsideis the Board's intent that these additional. dwelling uni.ts through the s-ecti.on of Butte County Code 19-19 (called the Aunt Minnie Amendment) which provides that mobiles may be installed on property, that the .mobile shall only be allowed where the zone allows the placing and utilization, of a mobile home, that the placement of said mobile will still, be subject to the variance proceedings as provided within afore- menioned section of the Butte County Code 19-19. (see attachment) Staff would comment that inasmuch as the zoning districts which now allow mobile homes are experiencing these additional dlqelling uni.ts.on parcels through the 'Aunt Minnie amendmerit that the densities recommendession d by the General Plan are compromised. Additionally, consider the continuing uaalog of the '+Conventional Residence'' vs "The Mobile i-iome,"in addition to the increased densities. BB/hd, Attach But,.o County planning Comnizsiont Orovillo, Califolmia Gentlel,en, 0 P,6,5 Valley VietiRri%o Pnra(lit3oi CalifoInia Aut"Mot P.0, Propooe(l rjow "Aunt llinn011 ar'0110,10111 As long tire residents olt' all 'IR -1 area, VII Protest M10st, viroroualy the -proposal. to ao:end, all, conventional hap.ie zoning ordinances t- o , yermit mobile ho,, -es. This intrusion of mobilo homes -- under any Via: re, "Aunt tvlinnie" de - C �ooder or otherwit�e -- into areas presently prohibiting thea will be the root -in- be - door ,"or the destruction of all t watveet,i3On now tranted the ccnvenl-lioral hm,,e oviners. The residents of 11-1 and o+%,,cr areas restricted to conven'tiolml. kio es v-orlted lotig and hard to obtain these -protecti-vto zonings. Once ab. "Duni. 1.4inniell rob lc is allowed in. ani, of these, it will be extremely di,"Ejoult to I,oep "non Aunt M-.nnielsll off other lots. Xt it], our unClor- &anOinr that. the cmirts have ritled that; all owners ol* lots in to 6ubdi,.-inion trust beIU.%tod ovilally -- that is, if a nobile home is allo'.'10 in an area 1101'r liestrieted to conventional homes, under an,,r eircu-sl.anceo (other than the mmei, of any other lot can not sul)0coliontly be denied thy: righ,.. to plate an origibal dwollinr vobile on hir, lot. Residents 0:� cl*00e-- it a olc-,-ilar situatior, cannol-, be discriminated aCaineti our tt.jjce court -enforced dec6 raotriciiono would likewise be destroyed 'b,,, such. action. Tweiv— --ears at 1Y r o the handful of us who lived on Valley View ,Dri-.e obtain, 0 a000 off' Ithe first 11-1 zoning in P,radise -- not Just, to:- oqr subdivision, but also �or the aljacon!, vacant: land bectiuse I'an,,r at ty I ,po of zoning vias iiicorApv.I,,ib1e with she exiot-ins doveloyenl,-" F, or.,. ;;hat borinninfj- R-1 (or R-1 AN) has been adopteO, for rmst sol tho wont sir'le of the Skywa41- to the northern P.I.D.'boundary. in V,71 11 -he residents o" the valley Vjetq_ViIIoF Plieljge-Cre&te°oor a12a obtalne6 R"I zoning for tho balance of Vallov Ride Drive and ,%-.he rat-,aindor of 1"AhO vacant land 8urr6undiiis us to the couthorn P.I.D. boundary. As a result of oux, earl;; i-mrk, the Valle,- View-Crestmoor area han devolope6 into one o'. the finent rosi6ential areae in Paradiaeo The Maltnin,t4 Com.Assion and the Board o" Supo.-Visorc lixie be0n, spared `1.0 ofte- bitter omantional voi mobile coatrovorsics on the et wire wost side 01 +he SI'74*iqta� ojjj� ajjea jr__ still sue-=Arded b,,,.* over 300 acres oi' vacant land jqj� -ittl for ,jolli jpith ihe nro,.,ection of 11-1 tonin has the ,,.otont dtvalopirr into oxnersivo 7'ir.,e subdivisions. With tt.e 0I-,rroe%eti'nr sale nrces oil hor!oo and vacant, lots In orr area, and the frequent turnovoisl bane will continue 4,,o oocalatej deopi"I"'o Propooition 13'(iii cont; et;, to JIv4 deprooiatiuC ',,ax base of rmbiles). Demtrm' the nrbtection 04L' convoritionol h6!r6 R -I zoftine, b -I 4 0 j "! th propoodd "Marti I:itmioll 0'-dinaneb and who knows how these lands will devolon, Plannin Cc;. mincion - aAu ttr�t9 ?Gl, 1 �t k xf people wish to live in mobila„ hor.,x.,n (or to house elderly rola- t•ivoo in theta), t:ha:, ir; their pri;vilero,, but they certainly do ,not lxsa�a the riAlt to intrude into groan whore tllc are not; wanted and whore tttoir intrusion may dent°roy the valuer o» +he oonvontional hon„os.' I attondoO all'oi the discussions on the adoption of the oris ir,al "Aunt tlinnie” ordinance. Some, of -the then, Supervisors oxpreoacd great c;onoorn that ouch an ordinance ntiCht_a.t: some future time: be used to dertroyr conventional horiza zone pros oc.ion. They wore moat: rpeciTi,c that the ordinance adopted could be uzod only in areas zoned to porelit mobiles. Thera alio was Board discussion to the effect that it voul(I be better for conventional horse owners to acid ra small guest houzo or sone additional permanent living; space r ore Compatible with Oho existing ho o, rather tkian tringint in a tevipora ry "Aunt Minnie" mobile. We rogrot -eery much that wo cannot be at: laonday night "s spocial greeting;. We also regret not; havi;ntt, had a chance to alert friends and neighbors to the potential o�P this now "Aunt Minnio" proposal,, Evan the Parmdiso post: Caccordi,ztg to its editorial on. Borard'di.scttssiono) does not seeM to r,galize the lone range ir;port If such an au',end;iont is adoptedsirno should be erected on ovcv-, road ent•orinr Butte County reading: "Conventional home buyers tale notice. i:obile horses can be placed on La:n,1 rieco of property in this count -,g r0naardloor, o: zoninC ory doed rostrictions„” But that won't hole t;2105e o.' US noW linins-, in P-1 and other res=rictod zones. Please recomr and al,ainot- the adop of much an ord hand. Those ca un who have voluhttar,ily sought and obtainod the protection of conventional horse zoning shouldbe ontitleel o :retrain it. eet ncesel^, Clint ar.•io) TO: j3utt e County Boras"d of Superva.sors PROW Belk, Bla w, Interim Planning Director su13JECT: Mobile libmes J,_i All ZrUles am August 2.LI l 1978 Tho Commission has continued. to September 20, 1978 an "open hearing" coi,lidering mobiles in thOSO cones where they are now prohibited. The Planning Commission requests} clarification of tho Board's intent regarding allowing a second residence, a mobile, pursuant to Butte County Code Section, 19-19 (Aunt Minnie Amendment), in all zoning districts. counii y rounsei has advised. the Commission and staff that it would: not be legal to provide for "ti.se-variancos" within the zoning districts, for example, if mobiles or trailers are Jnr. ohibited as "!:ermined uses" then a use permit or variance could not be considered for—the mobile, therefore, all zoning districts would be required to be amended to allow mobiles/trailers. Tile Commission requested clarification on the following Points as to the intent of the Boare,. in light of Counsol's advice regarding ,use-variances;' 1. Should mobiles be al owed in all zonOs? If mobiles are to be allowed as a "permitted use", would this not onjy allow the consideration of "Aunt Minnies" as additional uses, but; also; permit a mobile as the only residential use? Hojv many mobiles are -now. existing in the County on "Aunt M.inni e5'" 4 Has the County been successful in abating the "Aunt Minniesl' when necessary? Have the Code 5• requirements for cash dep )sits anal/or bonds beeii imposed on '':Aunt Minn.ies" and in what amounts? BB db MR$. M. 13, Uxr � e �'• llC7 « 18, 11ARADIS8, CA1.1VORNIA cn September 13, �s, �q 1978 -►'tte County Planni,lg Co121nission 7 County Center Drive Orovi le, California Gentlemen: Since x live and own property in an fit_ I am very concerned about theproposalltoistrict, Plating mobile home: for relatveon any permit regardless of established y lot threateneFto nullify the concept sin�gle�i've restricted residential tonin y wor).-ed hard to obtain in order tech �maiay of u property and t��e corltren�;onal.housinotect our Of our neighborhoods g `=haracter Once a mobile: kionle is allowed in an area zoned against such instr�llations; there is doubt thdt other property �tmers Prevented frog in teat area Could be awn lots, b�nlc�sstzon3in mobile homes on their they become trorthless ions aro upheld, ,uestions also arise as to tuhether these �� installations " may become permanent, temporary permit expthe ires, or whop the use for which i was granted changes, who is to force the o�mor to remove the then illegal mobile home loophole would be created. for the crcumve and °eta onA of zoning; laws. If this proposal goes into effect, a Persons � 6uld be dr mated for the onvret man enjenee of a f eta: Very truly yours Iced= Utt 2568 Stearns Road paradise CO. �nn►� .fig �om�i'�r' 8 �rtivil�e, C�r�p�ri�4, PROPOSEM TEXT TO '131: IIvC1..UM-1) J_'4 THE USS PERMIT �51:cTful (� r�].E'S1113�ILC1' ORDINANCES () Uses permitti„d subject to f' rst socuring a rt5e Permit it eac1l case: (� Placement, on the property, of a mobil.r ]port^ to be ut li zod k l.y by a, relative, either 1))= inarr age or b)- blood or ca i o.s;o 'rime, o t 41 the oi�ner of the property on which ic. is to be placed, and there may be no ront charged to the occupant of the ,,obi]e home. she mobile home may be owned by either the owner of land on which it is to be placed, or the relative or close friend who shall be residing therein. (a) The mobile home may be placed on the property without (b) violating any of the setback requirements of the zones in which the property is located, provided, however, that there shall be no requirement for an additional site for said mpbilo home as the term 'site” is utilized in this chapter, or any' other cokinty ordinance or code pro- vision, in that this allowed use is temporary in nature, 7}e use permit granted hereunder shall be for the tern of one year. The Board of Zoning Adjustment, upon application of the property owner and without o public hearing, may grant an extension of such use permit for periods not exceeding, one year, In the event the appli :ant uho is residing within the mobile home, or the con- ventional residence for any reason moves to another lots tion or is deceased, then in that event,the use permit granted hey~ein automatically expires and the mobile home shall be removed within dayfi. In the CYOftt the mobile home is not removed Within - I days pursuant to the terms of the use permit, the County shall il„ remove said mobile home and store it at the owner's expeinse. The County shall require either a deposit or bond sufficient to cover the removal expense at the time the application .for the variance is approved. The amount of such depost or bond shall be determined a at the time of the heariytg for the use permit. The request for the use permit shall be signed by both the applicant and the relative or other 'person to receive or rendez: assistance, and shall provide that Butte County is given a right of entry on the property and the right to remove the mobile home, and store same at the sole cost and expense of the applicant. _�4 Inter -Departmental 11,11ernOrandum 0Rf'o4t %rat) Vanhart, SUNEe.rs O."O xlt nATF1 til Jolii:.omber 197 Tho 1Arj%niT)g1 OomMi l3i.on Iol considering the posolbility tai' 1wrtni.ttiYCt "Anut; 1,4miosll J,Y�,�.rxn e " ire ::iobile homov, are not, normally ��;�t°ud ttod. it Oleorlrx to me that this i:, rt rol.1 rY dooioi on to be rxado by the lirmvdfislorl and the 3oartt of Supervi aoro Tho orlgi,raial. "Aunt ,; a nn3 el' ordizianae way a,doptet.t by the Btaa."d of Sul arvi.sort, in Y *ay of 1973. Since that tivio ". 70 Aunt Annie variances have been i ,azxad 2d h avC1 been in effect for leta.�f. than ( fto um'r 12 bava been in of foot for or:r, to two yoarn 30 have boom in oVCoct for two or ynaro 6 have boon vamoll.et1, volanta,rl.l:y "aho trond appeara to be for more rotitoot;. Per vari.anroo. $owc reqao;lta are dizcoi raced by om, department auxl iievor roa, h the Board. 'alt nore rsquostarare boi.ng eor�:elvad m.xd. Lrnantod by the lioard ao Indicated by tho figure -o- S rae, I Pool, are more, of a matter of conveni.eilao them novo ,•oity but I do rxt fool, that there leas been vti(lpopread abttxe of the i.ntondod purplm;e of the va.-,Ianaa w000dure., Jofor�: the oriLi.xlaal roquo.It. to to tIl-,, }lon rd they are revieved oy etw departriont both ,as to tho rauon for tha regiin8t and the oapabil,i,ty of the lot to fadegiiatoly di.aper-o of the added, aurware Pl,ov. We al.00 review the regaeat Li for ronoWaal:, to see thit the reaaom :`or the var.iagoe oti.11. e:dst and that the ewag;o dip nal-y>toin 1.,j Ot.11,11unrti ext n; pati :r#`aatoril y , aria ., ►r izit :4nni.ealf rare.,,cued not for a vari.ar.ee Prom tho Oewap div.opo,70 ordti.ntz,'z; Via,. in-,evera.l. area,,) but f o- f ropi othor otTliRtr,n or, `to nitez aril lot cizel", 10 attempt i.w eurrontl y boi.ng wado to requ re the - povtii bonds as in required by the r r`la �• 5 � o 0 r , pr')'J w4�U11 I+i'v. -AT,S.iyl. :,.i.y.f�, l d: i.�..:fint♦./`. rAy ) ♦ c,t✓r.Lc.L'd E i:e t ri j it 'C,7' 4`.i j L `r.••r-, ib �/ t l i i• ;1 a- �St '4`t;aGFiCi t; S1"1t`i3 "t . % r � - r ,F � i z *"t•C'«'?C�,'1.G." is"" 'f ra' :�l.' '�i`.ri'ttb""t:�:"',�e •5 i,•i 1,mrL4.110 U.;G: '1 f!bi'll -nrc o t,te x:iEu in- ✓J i i -%tal r +" f '.'�..) ..+I_,,.yi4 ,. '. .' �'�.. A.,+-rr _ yam. "t yip �, v�f r� Y^ �a' �, 3 '�� iY.� ��'"'y {CM' ��.5 ��tG+ �j,•°�lr� � ..•�,. ii /fr' ,ter!"' � �: + +�'% I � 1 •'"` +, r r � 4 � r.�! N 7 N� �. •l* ` ..,.w � 4, '� �� 'i t..J.tr`'r "'� w.^ r '' t;++- ` �. �"`� � +� r,. � G � , y ` � /', ''� .. . � ,. �r � . l L, ] l _ y +,/}r t,.tll ,,.+.. /._.r •` wr✓-!' r ;y .5 e,, +`"y 1e4,`_.'. ..•` .WA� r e f "' °�.;+7r.L+ ,�'✓P r..r t � .+ � ..r• �� w r' t" f t y .Sw t� -k. .1. .+f`�J/r�.. "!' �/' � � � .•�" � r r,f �t ,dr.µ �''�,�� , y .I .+r /Ci ,li•.4 °! +•Y,t.•w r,•�+ `� t � �( +rl'% 9 .,� •t i'/+��+�"�} 1 v .'t � ,�(' � �r•' .{. , r • r' d. A f , G t A ",r+l• C 1" 1 �� ) r �j "ry L• ,, t5�x.•r, �4 •,✓ �j Y f /..`f„�r"�,. Lr✓ �� +w... ,i1�,�,.' �.,,� `„.� "" .+✓"rA.,/�,r-^',�'/w i+'4+"�'� yL y��,% �'�"` l �rrC(��+'wrCV 1.'', �'. a 431 i ,Yrd of w:)APOrvjlt �A V j rd y t R fr,.l t� �l, y �?t'G1,cot Nti��./ YX� ,.,rl! ! ��. V4 f.L� R4f %j iwZit ("'o LAID Y�Ut bail G or -nureWuled t ometi in Rl a/)r1,1,, l�r;r' tr,j! .-j-)t e,,t .ot2 hf uEoir ..Y11?^ *": nii• ttk°lrel's:orad tho `: 5bilcs arca to be w,Nrl .ti Ohardship cacas'f.)iN! -. .a,tptrrv.r, rt -,1 robi lru , as tr, their C. af1 ;i1. le, ./ hf� /:,9 rental? � V', fit, 1 •• r ��.' , y L• el AA w r 7N .� _ 4x' l G' + t, t� . • ., ti 4 i •i t ,..,w r 9. da •w.+«_ . 4' •.L y r L ✓ ;;ti�;rr,r..✓,�clr Y%), ��w4cJ � � U`1�� J,�zC`�� c... �� , �r�' Gc��'r�� .� Lk y.1' ae �'L . G\..•' •,=u •�k.✓� „two' kir V (AY.rr �. �a •,�.-C j�.l..•.�«""dl L Y.,L ,:x rG'`w � +•% + /''., �% ^a+,`� tr;%''�"��+y;G� r 'r1 ri ''�r,/�'�y�'- '"�.r.:r IP Vr }j r i,rr�'� v� fir'• �� ry" t �' i y i r��''�� rY ��y� ;. � i it W �` + i � 3' � � � I J , � �'� �� C� � ;rig �c�� w ,�; � i r•''` :i I i L U'� x a��ti Ca W+•��r.� ,3 1859 bird 1;t. Crovl.11s Ca. Was the U.Ii lydirtledo prpbr,g4t the pro, o.,od a•+o;jd.,.,etxt (to tjra :aunt t ode). 0l, use of w'oUio horst s it' rOstricted resIdetitial ziX+�c1:;y a The majority OT PeOP10 Puilro-n aly built or purell.azed ho,:;eo ill ill BOt'it3iy SOP uk'O j13Vtola bio fax:` Vivir L uY1dera''and the '.1ob:11-a a. -O to be uaed in CO xo� yr3 II the Supervisors have over theso ?''Obilaa, as tsj tljair� 1 _V iYal MO. and not even -Wally bo used as a roatal? :'X�'lT1Gid 45� 7, �, r -? 44 '�C...E"�'-'�.x'.,. �i� 1�'��;�,� 4� Utz •�� + , +r�•�r r,j r r<��'t lwt..'rt'�c'r.,.•' :1 t: r 1,+ J! 4 �7� � " •� � r "�. ' ! ' �k l l / + � f fw> j. k r e`.. ° %✓ l .>. � . I °'7t J 1 i J r L '1 '17A �M1 r� ,I �%�� f Y,, .. .A. A. K%�F�r. �" , I � V'L � ��! i.� 4N✓'�.+j.. w�_ i- F+ . r. ti w « � •ft 1 �� X r r r � . % Y ��✓, + �y ,�'�� 4 � � �r r",.L.. � r ' „' "y° �' s ; :a' �' i, � `.. ,y ' a r,rl �,+.� / C'�L"`Z`l""`✓�L�7L:.t..+ �"C.+'�,l`�.i a.��.. �'(,i r .�;%'„R.•r. ��-�"f , r�.�•. �...C.C,„,�/�j'y .. ti `•."° 1 0!'�,i � +./. r � .t'` I t� i ',� • �Y',rrl�'r S.� 'i. 4� �,r•��i� Fj. '"r �,�. i>�'M7 ` ) y'� 1 � � a% � y� a h �. Butte ClouuY ty Poal d oi $uporv:! sors 1851 Bird St Oroville Ca. 95965 Fuedao Ca. OctabLrr 2-41)76 Wc. the undersirpleds protest the proposed ameimmunt (to the Butte cotmty ccde, for use of tiobile homes in rom-bric ted residential nrwtso the rpa jorit,r of people purposely built or purct,ased howl in RI zcninq .for tle protrectt on 04 thtzir investment. T'p understaad`the Mobiles aro to be used in "hardship cases". T -hat ccntrol will the sunerv:i.scvcs have over these Mobilea j as to their ao al im, snd not eventuaiiy be used as a rental? Signed r . 4o ts' L cQ t , 'y�i,4 ,r �,�i+• t[ :. �C�� C'•-+'Y.� F � � , . r �. p. •+ f � j7 ' I ' i` 14 � �J r� r r' i''�," ��yJ .�i,aJ,,,}�r Y� + �l �r 4'�Jj`4 L.� V n,� �'�'✓ +�. /, i� , 1/ 4L:'a' ��L� �f ��' ' �,r ( w .w ,.' s.. � Y 7 ?r . ,% Y' j Wr V (:.� i � L•r,:ia�.. ✓�.'��U 1' t, .41 )'�. L � G J V /' ., r � .�' �✓ty+'w'it-"f. � r re., �� +�� •�i�,,, �*` �'t��»I�yr",^f+is:' /"�w�, -w�`i 4'��:�i� � �� •j. r`i.✓�� / �.r y �1` li".rNrs ,{„j�� .r..� �F'��L.}'� �L.�" {��G`5-""�""w1�� j, `' j+ /C% �.yy .`�,Wt �>'�, � �,,, 7 +•rL1��-` 11';"'1 , w r r / e'. � ��j t- 1 � r,��'i• �,. �-s� �w3`� w. Y"+ J•Y� r lkir �i'Y' x. r �^r.r :, .fir ,�,w '.`S,,i' ~I �7� r��/. :s�.,t`r✓'�a ��s. +�j .,°�„1,' `�`�:� - �{��,y J/jp,'/r '. k 1v ✓- . I r I ear/ a ^T:� wN•./ �.rl� / •Yi y r ✓MI I� 4” Y' i � rF �y 44iY.' '/w+ /)' .� M� u' 1 Jy ��I�� rj, � � ��/�� ` hy, ♦ � � L" r � � � : u'�( ��./ •. �d'IW( .:i'� „��r�.rV l.Pd � � v ��I • ��`"'�. "/^'.'�'�`�'� ^ �` '41441loo r t "�i"''� r �� 4� !4/'� a.+.' ,�r' ��i � /' !� ,•Z ,,� /�K.,.'tf�a/"` �,/,,Y�,�I{ ^'..f I i /i,,.'' .�t G�+�''�'a�✓ ,i�.d 'a IV i I October 2311,W8 Butte County Board of Supervisors 3.659 Bird St. ` Oroville Ca. 95965 IY, ar Sirs; ., Wtthe undersigned,* protest the ,proposed amendment (to the ,•� $11tt6 . r County Code)Xoi 'use of Mobile homes in restricted resi riential The majority of people purposely built or purchased h.)m s in Rl zoning for the 'protection of their investment. We understand this TWobiles are to be used in sshardsh3 oasesile V+hat 7 4 w control will the 'super -visors have over thews Mobiles. as to their D` legal use, and not eventually be used as a rented? Signed .fir t/' . �G.y✓ 7..� $I G, `I L4 y l �� fw'�f t� !C. , .• `` 1 t:t r:', w �.'�` it G 44 4 r �� w - J I Mayr 1 LZ 9,, ' ��;�� `��•� � �C��:.a�r►«��. �f v ! ( �""! L' 1�,1 ✓`I✓. �. ' f v f:i,4'�.+'Y •wY (..—•. i{.fii,"'�.n �i r V� yI`UF ��f4ti.✓'1..•L ✓✓1 � J a _ "•",'.,rEI lig `�,,k. ' L� t,i+at ` G� GdY�� ;'� 4Gtt,� d i . ��1 t it j! 4` G - ` /a.: Gt, 01 ,01 bf LI Zj 3 3; k 117, ' cy r 3 3; k 117, ' cy Partse Ca Uctobe r, 2 3,v l97 8u to County Board of Supervisors 1659 Bird st. oroville Ca.95965 010ar Sirs; wej ie un�iexsi �sd ro�ethe hoppo�cndmPnt (to the Butte by (;ode)for usa of r mobile xesinrestri.cted residential,, al:^as: '� o CO M r The, majority of people purposely` built or purchased homes in F71kx v zoning loth the protection of their iCiyesttxent. ?> VPj understand the Uobiles are to be used in° hardshi oases o hat r tihardship �� control vill. the supervisors have ;over these mobiles,, as to thdi.r legal use, and not wentuall.y be used as a rental? Vhl , ,,,,.rte ` � �f �+, . "'<wr.�""' L.:_r ',� • '^ �4"./-, lrY"Ye �^'r P.'iT / V. i � ,r• �.: 1/ r �'+1' 12y'fx4L�'. y • vGC. •1 w �i .A y�r ze is l J t✓, z { �" ':+xl"r „t` ."":.Cy. ��• 1 jr,3'x': wr"✓H � � �.-+'I" �"' F /"✓ r ir: �5•. �r < '4 - r' �c i"r�b'.+a, d' / r as `�`• 4„'C4'+f-•r� r�iy n ' .:.. t �w,-rx� n.A'L,x...nJ 1, ` • i � : ,+ . � °r� fr �f ^ '�i +,J y7 ,:��/j�/� e ..; ((�,x !?�u...fiw+Cr'�i•.. i✓ � ✓ �� i 1+'t �,�a.' ��.+u4'� i+'y4 �°,�.J�• w-Jt`'�c. 1. Li �, `�x ±;J* � /. (;C,/� 't c;,, -x;`„ "il,!• .� rt, 4.�, "� i ft �'l�'�I' )Iia �� A jt,t��"1r'� cW.�fi Aa M•^ ,_,Y ` �/n A`� t •`� ^ `ry '" i •X'" „� �-�•�i��'r Yy.'� i , }✓'r,� t� rr':�� fa %" �/�'s r: 4 %! a ..� f '4rr,A,..t� �-�- r ',Y•J" 0• Y _. ( F t i ,... �., a, tri �' 4 n j' J1,T �v�r�•� ��"� �� i� ��" �ll�i'r� x tri A�. • ✓` ,:;R ��` 7 f /'��.�� IA ��i/��.j•�',i'jt �9.+.;''�'V 9'.t1� �"I' '�l �w u rr Y e +� yy ...° r. r ,f r" � sr � u;, Aww �iw..KGu �: � + � ti„` `M'J,• ,��c '. • F r7",E,�w � li' ;.. W. / Ysr f.r �� c v. t.; ^.�+•. A��,. t i. J �.►r'r•'7..� M ty l/ d r_�. Y�' ,�`i r rICJ � itis•+'tom. ' "%i�'.r't�',+:5✓..�..n.{� r .�F,. .+Y �eAtAl lei r. ��'�-i:.�LL'��.�'"'+ "•y�+7Y:�j'��'�,�»�� >.�✓ �i;J ,��iCJ G.�.•� l�l��%�•t'( aJ �`x-�i"'� ��• 9 •.� i' f� ✓ • (+ `� lx rr ., r"la... F] � ,y � \\\i.��;x,� `'t.��i.C��1,�, � r„�Y i1,1�,��v<i,;.t,•. F �� r� / ��G«;'� �✓ / /�tc �>,.�',!. Vie, �lytiy.aw.+Sa,�. �J}J� / Y� �A✓L•"%,kb,�' +'� �� '� A& �i.�V trt'.i(" "V'4� IXn• �' +7 y ��ty j�.„�.a�w r` VA„ IfM'J ti F+e..✓",rz tyfyl+...1� i ".�.....r j '� G,,,. ,• + C:c..� 1�'• L, ll November 14, 1973 Mrs. C. L. Barris 263 Valley View Drive Paradise, Calif. 95969 Butte County Planning Commission Orovilla, California Gentleman: Proposed new Aunt Minnie ordinance At the October 31st hearing on the proposed Aunt Minnie ordinance, it seemed that Supervisors Lemke, Mosely and Richter, in thein anxiety to "do something for the elderly," have totally missed the crux of the problem created by this proposed ordinance. The aodthetids of a mobile home compared to those of a boat or travel trailer, or whether a mobile home installed next to a cov6ntional home is or is not a dastardly thing (Supervisor Lomkels words) is completely irrelevant, Zoning is voluntary. The Courts have said people have the right to determine the quality of life they wish in their town or neighborhood. Adoption of restrictive zoning ordinances defining what can and cannot be allowed within an area is one way of establishing or maintaining a certain quality of life. Residents of areas zoned, for conventional homes have chosen their quality of life -- just as those in areas restricted to mobile homes have chosen theirs. Supervisor Lemke seemed to have forgotten that some of his constituents in the Fir Maven or Sierra Del Oro area not too 'long ago ca a to the .Board outraged because the county had allowed a conventional home in their deed- Jrestricted-to�-mobil.e-homes subdivision. As a result, a new zoning ordinance called, S believe, M14-1, was written and adopted restricting such areas exclusively to mobile homes. None of us quarrel. with the right Of residents of the 14H-1 area to Prohibit conventional: homes; not do we feel that those who wish to live in buy r zones Mobile home living is a way persons mobwithin the shoed demand entry into areas zoned against them of life n -- let such a "latter of financial status, as anyone who has soon. the current crop of double and triple Video can attest« What is at stake in the proposed Aunt Minnie ordinance is the integrity of, or the destruction of, all conventional, home zoning in Butte County. Supervisor Richter expounded at some length that this now Aunt Minnie nat sY e p e warehousing of the elderly.!' We who l*veInt;hese conventional home xones y there are other rore compatible ways to care for elderly an our zones: a small ,guest house or a remodeled area within the existing home The primary oppositiot to this ordinance is from Paradise. Six off' us (:one rdPre8dhtiftS the Paradise board of Realtors) spoke it. *Two Petitions in opposition have been received by the Supervisors, bne cobtdining 114 signatures, the other 38. Perhaps Supervisor Richter and you gentlomen Of the s over60and 6Qaa is Ivor are not at4are that 50;0 of tl o paradise Population r; % 50 years of age. r am Ourg that four of us who Planning Commission - 2 Novorhber 14, ,1978 spolce fall within the over 60 bracket (certainly Mrs. Ott and 1 do). No doubt 50% or more of the signors of the Petitions do likewise. Two younger people from Oroville spoke for the ordinance and castigated us 'as being selfis, and unwilling to care for the .elderly. We who have come out so strongly against this ordinanco; are not ungrateful young whipper -snappers about to "warehouse our poor elderly parents." We ourselves art Aunt; Minnie (or TJnclo Andy) -- alr)ady facing the problems of age: how much longer will we be able to drive our cars, do our shopping, live in our own houses? We are the very onete this p-oopose(l, ordinance is supposed to be written for; yet we have risen up In protest saying that dcstroying the integrity of conventional home zo) ng, opening all areas to mobile homes, eliminating all single family zoning in Butte County is not going to solve these problems. This is wbat Will be accomplished by the proposed Aut!! Minnie ordinance; this the crux of the problem -- not the aestheticii, of a mobile home. I am quite at -rare that this was sent back to you, for the purpose of deleting the R-1 areas (which would protect our area), ba it is just as wrong for the others. When the precedent is set of an Aunt Minnie mobile c,i one lot in. a subdivision, it will be impossible to keep other mobile hetes off adjoin- ing lots. Should ,!tint Minnie be physically feeble, but finf icially sound, her mobile could well. be A 2 -bedroom 2 --bath double wide (to iave room enough for 1.3r cat and dog, plus visiting grandchildren, etc>) -- single family zoning; beoomes "duplex" -- two separata ryaidences (oi:yed by separate individuals) on the sage parcel -- "duplex" zoning Athout the formality of either retorting or splitting it. When the purchaser of another lot comes in demanding a permit to erect an original mobile, split hips lot into tyro or three morl� parcels, and threatens to Guo for such approval., the County (like pent, us Pilate) will wash its hands of all responsi�)ility and issue the requited approvals, saying, Let the people fight their own battles to maJntzin tht integrity of 'their neighborhoods. The whole concept of this proposed ordinance is wrong. I hope this Planning Commission will send it back to the Board with the re:ommendation that all conventional home zones bo deleted and that Aunt Miner es be ,''.lowed only in areas already zoned for mobileo$ as the origi,:al ordinance Wisely provided, Sincerely, (Mrs. C. L Harris) , orO►'i%la, IY4 a Inteft pas$man$al Molnora�ndiu_ -., 'Vol Plannin Conimiss'oilers IROMi Bett7o Blairs Director of l?larinin Proposed SUBJ4 rr p sed amendment to liiAte County Cade, Chapter 24 amendin tr DATE- November 1-3; .1..97Zoning districts to lllow njollile 1101nes :$ The Board of Supervisors, at their publir, h ..earing on CGtnber 31,. 1978, referred the proposed amendment back to the Planning Commission recommending the following I. That the Commission Col=cider and establish specific requirements for'findings l need for the additional dwell ngr. Z. ions dor establishing minimum size requirements for the mobile. Con,>ider establishing possible maximum age of the mobile_. 4• Consider establishing minimum standards for the condition Of the mobile; installation of the mobile and possibility of requiiements for skirting, etc.: 5 Delete the R-1 zoning district Brom the amendment_, this to include the RI A C. ........ ......... Paradise Ca. November 7 ;1978 Batte Colony Board of Supervisors 1859 Bird St oroville Ca. 95965 Dear Sirs; n� We, the und•,rsigned., protest the proposed wmendment(to the ;butte County Coc1F) for fuse of U6bile Hoxkes in restricted reoidantial a.reaso'. ,,aj o i ty Or people purposely built or purchased hoAes in t;,m < restricted zoning for the protection of -their investment. as 'We understand the Mobiles are to be used"hardship cases"Obat Control will the supervisors have over tie Mobiles9as to their legal use and not eventually be used as a rental? Signed e- ss x.rs�lr�+�c,•rz�c�+� •..+ .,�i� 1��X'�,•� rr�!s ._G��-4.. , �f a A 7 �y +� ,� � ^ ��w'd. i; ., i+ c7 �.J , l } aj 5� �. E: fir`^` « .+.�''1,G'��'k�?.�'•K...+r+-'M'"-� .« ... ..,•X'..�,Af ! t'X'�t,i. -• ..w�. t':';,X.•✓ +. r ..''r,� n:.�s'�'N,. �� i' t f • t r� � . � }. X t. • �� i,1,K �y » �~ ��;� �1, � �( �i ,+nr `� n + •. «�. . ,.. lR.�,�+tX!1•}Jk'yY'� �f .,✓:il ,�'G,� � G' 1'` ! � ('" r "fi;,I �ik R.li�3`�, � + �, r r �'`S-�t- �f'1��J �i 1 .�Q .•r1lVi. �1 L��—O t1, l'L �'' r jl✓t•;': »�..., i.. r q�'4rL,e''Cla s ".4 e . 7 A�. Ht tea, rX� .. .� ` �•+.', •tr ..�J .M M+{!�'�'1��4i�',w,.N x.. t.., .. ,. f ..� ;r •„��4'yl!"r�hMr�.'y��l'^✓�i�W;Yi4.f�X { ,...•ar. .. �"•r� l" G t�t�•�+�y..�. i41'1�CS+�,'� Mi '6 ��hN:":iU)"�� '. �-- *1i' X. '`,. `n.� �� r,� �w�14' "1" `" .. `� „a✓C,J IF: ,:G4• 1.;,.y .t ,w "A', 4.....� '. tee•`.,, .tS ,+.,,. �� .tX�y�-+..V'�J. rL..:r, ! i. � i F(� �i,/.;/ �.r�-&�a ++ p7 '4 iw. 1 L`�'S�• +�G4+ +•%L.+C+;.N� a,L ° `u0. M y L, ALL �,�.��~.. �,�? .uww., " s.xa r+rrlR •W we. wAtw+!�i�+•+vv ,, �',�;;;,,� t�-c:..::.:. ... j � `� i'+ �s�r ",.t +'� � 1.1� y✓ • � Lf.�.�.xy�t, ix+4''t,�� _ .�=:a ..., ly .�S.I.ti�� fps Inter -Departmental Memorandum TO, Butte County Board of Supery:sorsa FROW Bettye Blair, Director of Planxiing UrBJYt Proposed amendment to Butte County Code, Chapter 24 DATMI November 16, 1978 ' The Planning Commission considered the Board's recommendations and modification of the proposed amendment and determined to not amend the ori gin al. recommendation. 'Tile Board's action of October 311 � an�tber�pub��Cheara heed aring On ��thelamendment afd have no terLthe Planning ion to nCommissions recommendation.. y , c Inger-Departono0fola emorandum Tor Planning Commission. �noM, Bettye Blair GUBJECTi t1Au° nt Minnie" DAM April 9, 1980 As a result of the Fiant rezoning which the Board denied on March 25, 1980 and them on April i adopted an AR -MH -3 interim Zoning allowing the applicant to make application fcr an "Aunt Minnie", the I Board of Supervis-ors asked for a review land recommendations from - the planning CommIss on and staff regarding possiW,e rel.ie�f for similar situat'' ins The Commission may remember that an amendment to the County Code— initiated by the Board of Supervisors --which would have allowed mobiles in all zoning districts under somewhat similar circumstances as now requireil by "Aunt Minnie", was heard by this Commission in August and September of 1078 and recommended for approval:_ The Board on Janualy 26, 1979 determined to deny this amendment to permit mobiles in all zones. If the Commission wishes to reinitiate this amendment, staff -•nuld be happy to bri,ig it back in a, more specific form: BB/hd