Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout79-90 18w Project may ,r, e cult 311 tra.�f i a i ncro,� ter,:C_ Condamnatioll W:id, p-orobase may be neaoG Jany f or road . w.l.d oan in C, Traffic data J.zl ir.sufficient, :ao noasuxes cannot be adequately discav�,,ed Possible need for and potont;i*al impacts of vide.ning R *lXF Road should be addressed, n( Taxpayers sl,.,illd not have to pay for W341doni ne the voa,d Vu Other access road should ba listed as .A ria tig*ata,on -- h.�^il road is a possibility �- tto�Lld ncod brid ;e. Tra_ffir ostimates are uzareali,st;;ic because of time that survey was done. deed for assessment district „t:or, .road: construction, would. ,i set precedent with: implications beyond this project. Improving Humbug Road would increase traffic problems, speeders, etc., also promote muro rapid. d.evo7 op-,Maent o the area. There ctould be a ,range of impacts resultinS from increased; h.wnat contacts. :project o.atrance is on a hazardous, curve, site distance',' This PAC project will add to the 10, OCO ADT 'bro j ected. o �� I1 Humbug Road* c'f r W.Ia:,DLIFE Property is a major traffic torr dor for dee, and other animals which cross the eastern part oa' the troperty to dater. VIIt Riparian vegetation protection limiis shouldbe doubledfr_-m s t100 feet to 200 feet at the very least.. Gane fish are predators of mo :,qulto fish (� Question should 'be addressed before ponds are filled. More information needed with regard to impact cm fishor' es '") salmon spawning in Butte Creek. - ro ger ) �ti11 be disturbed. � 11y (~djacent tc Holding onds where salmon, reside seasona Project t ma wildlife fisheries �' �� y result �.n tai sp (fisheries) destruction.; Grey fox, porcupine, bobcat and coyote viere no'me. tlor,,cc S n EIR. Wildlife area will be surrounded by sulbdiv w h.ons, K-1 zoni..-, and a road wildlife ife will be trapp=ed;, , a(.vO. op -��-u ref` [,�1 s" " ► t�.z►�Leh be•.-p«,w) blar: Cumala'tivc e,nvirom onta1. ef.ceoto of Imown, projce'Lm j'n t*he arca should be addrossed. Remaining land could be deeded to 6tato Depaatmex:°L oP Far4"s, and .Recreation. $—L mi .s���^��4"►z��x��:�� ass of public access, to an ex �ensa.ve s Lx�etch a� Butte Creek. Publc access should be guaranteed. ... - 3 Ancient chinese walls migh-L be b�a� 1 o ozed Aesthetic c and historic value of cax»y'= Would be destroy-z4,, ,. a r v�Oe of, pr Re �.ns-ead. o�yeast; e ig L'e-� tbz" )rl� 1 i ars Van e Kamp 3/12/80. .ucr- e e o' e sx►-L l:�z1, �e ua w C�. �• •, rr:�„inn°,..,�r�pa�.ts•�vre:`�o.,,.rt.o.�,.*a�r�xe`e�ed. E��t�r�-1ti"--�ma�3�er�--�c��-1�3�-r�o-ve�-����r-»�;•�.s-y..p:�:, .off + �'l'L-moi '^"G•`--"'er�� l! r. INTER- bEPARTMUL MEMORANDUM �S1Y i1VAi P" ➢F'f M; 9Y �O, CM1rV, OFFICE OF BUTTE COUNTY COUNSEI. .���►`� � tM E'�$� TO: Bar! Nelsoa, Environmental Review Director itl�llk� :Cw�+�ni� BY: Delbert M. S-tems-en, Deputy County Counsel. SUBJECT BUTTE CRI IM EAST EAC RC -ZONE DATE: June 1.8, 19$0 It is my undors tanding that Al Beclt, who prepared the tough draft SIR for the Butte Creels Bast PAC Rezone, was oontaated, by some people in the area during the time lie was working the the rough draft: EIR. It is my ;further utdot8tanditg that Al Beck did not at any time sol.icito ;from these people, or anyone. else in the area, infotmata.on for purposes of the preparation, of the tough draft ZIR, Having reviewed the Supreme Count's decision in Woodland Hills, particularly ittePerence to the conclu- sioti 'by the Supreme Couxt that in order to satisfy the requiements of C'EQA, the opposition to t; he project should,be contacted and information solicited from them for purposes of prepar'atio'n of the draft MR, it is our con- clusion that the process by which the p.to-sent draft EIR on the Butte Rezone has been prepared would not meet the require- ments of Woodland ltil.l.s, Therefore, It is our recommendation that your off�,ce iev1se tie draft BIR, incorporating the information you have su;'3sequently -received from the opposition the project, into the draft, not on the basis of a comment and response, but, rather, as basic information, once you 1ta�e completed that, file a new notice of completion and recircula;te the draft 91R. Should you halve any questions C r)no-Otni ng this matter, please contact this office, xw �� DELBERT ,M, IENSEN ` DMSIst r rn 114 Wast Savonth MOVIL10 +► 01*6, Californio 96929 (016) 342.6991 pAavrr nm�s�itat Roview C �i>►' June 16; 1980 j ala4 :�. �� 1980 iluFl� C��ir►�y jtarl U. Nelson,, Director Butte, C"o-o ty hitD 18-11 county Center Drive 0 ovill:op California 95966 R.l CoMmmionts on butte Crook halt AC I)EI Dear lia r1 Following are our i,ap.lies, -to Caxr11110TIt•s nil the above oforencod FIR as summAl0d :In your letter 4ated .luno 12, 1980, W I l:Ft11., `f IT it E.f eeng upon Salijiov -,fit the 0Pt i)erimit r1ss`stanco moetiug for this�prejcc' 0218 A'i gUSt X9793Richard Pflnt, 'Pishorios Biologist to" tl�O W art�i nt. Of ZiiSh and C,�►r�c�, stated that Butte Crock, J)e4twaett the t'overed Bridge and Highway; 99, is Unattr c:tive to salmon" His stroam survoys indicate that salmon avoid this stretch of the crook, l gofer it g holes an spawning areas above the Coveted Bridge, One possible MW ------ for thLs ma.y' be the sound transmitted ihto the water r�rom, ag- gregate extraLtioa activit0s on the, subject fstOpeKy; another reason may be the concentration of leach line c*1"l"'fr,rhts Norm ox st'i, lrouso along Humbug Road. Wildlife Access to Butte Crook - Tho c itkca or sagnifi- ca,rtcAe c7 �..�, f i�r;a,iia t ' -I-'1c co r c or" For wildlife at the eastern rind of the s i tc Is Unknown, No e:Wrw,r c:e of a mu j or do6t trail iµh:roui; � tilt e�.etatc d oa open s Geos d� the pr��lY �." y was de- tocted durin, sgrveys of the eastern end ot the site; Due and other wildlife do gross Humbug Road in a numbed of atea.s, Earl N Nel man PA1,1. v Orovillet CA Juno li, 1940 but prime crossing arcus, tts notod during, rrty wildlife surveys condic"tod for thAdversity of Call nia in 1970-1073, appear to have been changed by subsequent K1,evylopmant along this roadway, The current pattern of linear development d6e ud,vorsely affect the free movement of wildlife. '1'O wildlife lists included in the 1111.111 contain those spac as kkn wtt< or, suspected to regularly occur in the k►1ea. They 4►re not in.- ton4ad to be exhaustive, but indicate the major wildlife specie:., Of the four siiocies listed in the cotttrnent iqttoro only thegray .(:ox, uxacxai :stay regularly rtso the proposed dovel.opmant area. Coyotes have been okr� Arved on the canyon rim, primarily on, the ;youthrim, an4 further upstream on the canyon fl.odri Bobcat usually occur at higher 6l,evatiozrs, but couid triter the area in marc] of deer. Occasionally, young male porcuplues pass throggit the aresa) usually-awry frbm the ripitian area, along, Butte Crook. One reported Kghtitgl in the early 1970's was due to release of an adult porcupine by personnel ot the UX, Public Roalth station on Humbug .Rotrd Setback from Creek - Itate law kcquiros a So foot setback. to p 0, pit`°waterr"'rJual'ity no additional setlrack is legally required. The 10D foot setback r°ecotmuended in the ill.ili was included, at thy; suggestion of DFU Came Warden Will Mhoq to rotec:t riparia,in habitat and to provide a wildlifo corridor along the stream Tsol.ation of Wildlife 1'�u1atl.on�As lndarated earlier, the i.eadov;upnent patternRn;1umbug Road has had a sig— nil"i �tnt Spact upon wildlife movoments; l;orcing animals mov,ing north and south to pass through gauntlets of houses. and foo riparian on to detour :dor si. nific�ant dis�tancaV The 10'0 house pets or to setback, -plus lands on the south side of Butte Crook, should provide adequate area for spot les moving, trig or dowry the canyon, The lrroposad P.&G. A designcd t q retain tttost .of the sit:o in an undovolaped state, to serve as a wild- life-area, ildlife area, rather that subdividitg the arca :into 5 acro aricel;; as it is currently Zoned .lit VC)LLU" ION 'the comment; ort he occurrence of a '';strtog layer" in BUMCrae �� Canyon do not make itown he dur�a.t!on o this occurrAce or the nature of the; pollution observed, The layer is most pr°obabl.yompose:d of particulate matter Kom agricultural op- erert;ions in the Sacramento Valley or, forewt fires l.n the foothills. It could, however, be a. laycr of photochemical' r _ CA - J4.LbFo i: �6) , 1980 Oxidant or a c}catttbltt,at°t.urt (,),f iqtr"t i.c1ilt.Il�t0:% and ox td,4nt o I t ���� tt.;asuitOd ti" t the obaerved la►yatz, :� nru�st � ixal�c►trt a int t�-� V(11*;a� 01 1).erriods JI ttta�dsatrtttttr�a^� al.id� wjnte�r tvl�c�rr V��rr�c:��I���{�ur��rt: �rt t'yho ." aerb,atttc*tr'tu� Valley is poorbcrs,t "1'ltr* ic��tcl tta,aa�Ma�aa���ry it, Ou a 'C i 5y - y further " m " � N rJ b ,r C Ly y' t l � Creek 4u �,r r� �i.r�, ttt � � �I to ,rw' �t.1 � � .r'' �� �"��' � � .� �w 4 � 1,10 portions of is e eout1 h . i � arr �R s ta-501110 50 c�t�tt4 � t. rcOns ther o to b atti�ttir 4t worau tIr y ttur irt,R t}tc.s�_ �����:��, sc�ttt �'c�trt3,i.a� tion fi{ :thy utrtryrarr ry � ; y b c> "t' tri 1 t�acY rrttrr tr icl � tdt O r gravity d ai.�ttRrge c,taus:od by da t`forential heata�ng Of ttrc l l ay and, ttit� ttn'�a.i us y It is trine that air pollution Can, da,ttna VOg(",tat.i,on, Most xesoareh has been fligi.tad CO,reduced ytalds of-,1grr:i.. Cultural s xtWle1, [nex udiit ; trGr gra ttab C,e res f Ozone is the ,pollutant of Primary concern,) although, irltrcrge diaxidd� tac voxyacetyl .a ltriato (PAN), sulfur diraxi.d,,o, rtrrcl t�yttr"ca�;on. .fi.au�a�.ide a,ry Krise lcttetan tto �,amago, . plc t� and oduc "Op yl Wldsf This is) ttt'�1JOVOr,, a problem carug'od. by tv'idQ-,k;C t.Ia air tataJ iutaera, t~r�y l ittlO, of the visii lea pollution in ,�Iutte Canyon, can be tattrbi.buted to acct iv ties in the c`unyota v Most is traus )entad r'r'at11 tlM Agricultural and Urban areas within the air fl,asiit, A tlaraugtr tbo vej'Jeul,a r traffie tassuc-lasted With the ixrbotrosod d(,'t+`t"jcaptttLxrrt would; iloprbosent an ttaeroltt tttal i.n- uret'S(r III a regionalprobieia it woultit not It, t:t;�I:C" datoct- quality 4ab:l~y reduce t;tap at!r° c ualit in Hutto C,r+txele Carryuyt, mosq T "U ABA t'l"Wti N Initially, the Propel% shaping Of pond odgvs w,111 ri11vii.nate brooding areas for itt0sctuitec ,, holt the eventual tleve'lo ament of �g � produce w virorittrc.n,t for roduc.ta.c�ndof seltie trtnst t►a.t� s �ec:i '�s. 3 . w w �� ►c utxen alert ► s will, �tcaduc c raC�itM en f' R � � i 1 s. �l�ac,t.rat�' fish and vc.ry small garde risk will Concentrate In these 'vegO4 tat ci arras, away front larger predator Cl.stt, and will aetr a it od .:rrs crtiaoz�+cl u,i tclarvae. As t�� ponds takilzo , Prad atnracuatac trs("ct8 will become more g�gn.! ar.artat mosquitoes.. trodator,% Devclo pent Ot the West end el" tiro tar"a,per'ty would eliminate the !)raffia Impact Casa, the 3+ mile, Sogl ons. 61' tlUffibug t�eradw ,1iow,� fiver"B utrlesa ace 0ss to: the, Pre'j6c:t was to b mom the yway the ltutrtttin�-q yw ty intersection would stiji })e a.'I`�foct d, AeCes;; di."Ctly onto tlxc; teyW4Y WOLItId Toquire a new orae'raaatr trim! and.. mo i;an ares. inn. Avaragc trip let19th would be o- etuec d by, a ,are ittratMcly thrr e Milesyl with attendant reductions in air, Pollution and energy eonsuttrtrtion w M acci r CA Junk, Dovelopolent Nita the we' 44 end would have a b�,l�k"titk* IlItpa,et oil wildlife btcatIsOl %;��$�,�a� as aI.�Moad* welt does the eastarn 'tit) of, 00 V),!OWrtYw which Is curve'llitly hew .11ig 1111iled..- �qy66.` za�"`,�d jr, I`I�'IGely � 1jkl1Y.i to bo neater at, the wentk'rn clidy r doe to. ItOlova The tisIdelitt�ak~ +' f Albert A I iv' CALWORNIA REGIONAL WATER QUALITY' CONTROL BOARD,"" CENTRAL VALLEY REGION � � �ilkkr� l,�i�� t��str� �"• •a�6`=� McCain Agsodate& 492 fin dodo, Avenue Chico, CA 509 BUITE CkttK EAST 761 01411 PAC, 11C TIC, 'COUNTY We hove rnviewnd your P>^apmdd u1 ago, d1spotal SAW, foe- this cnndok` iMura devulrrpment. inee you, propose to diAcharge Sage into deedoor tailing adjaeent to gutta Creed nf`fluerrt li�tli�tatiahs Will be 0�tabliahed With a cuaiolian klofti- tuning Progralrrr the doer e of tlAea,trl nt MgVITad will ddpend on the filtration agility of th0l Buil between the lnar:trline tMhth lrnttft and pagnnal high gmukld water. As wu have di'Stuas di the tte intral Board' hay no, eti,jer`at 04 to an aetifieial aril 10050 C6n9tr�uet0d' tre,l'ntr the l uhfieldf provided thkit i't adequately treats, the aewagtr befdre ekrtering trio ground Water. Assurnio a mirrimurr Skil layer4 Below the leaehfield trckrches(honpeh, matrix gr`4vl� the pebbabldL efflr.rerrt likrritatiarr waul�l be as foll(w. 11 30. Day Daily nen t,uen;t tJrr.i't : Aye�rg ttf A tl�15, nr,l' 40 fit Suipeklded Solids nkjl 40( total t;elffoem 0gakligkms P?3 5�g Effluent marritering of there Wfittituent§ vrauld pr6bably ba eoquir°ed, on a weekly basis. Molli torirrg wells ddwtr gpadldht frm the lea hfield w ru,ld algin be required to aggUft nkat MIN wattle cerrtaminatian daet not nccuir, if a thicker artifi'e.ial geil filter it. peovidod between the leachfield Akrd gmuhd water, effluent limitatinrs enuld be r"elaxodr When the f011dWin9 ih-IM irat I is recdivcd� thi repot b of waste ditchar;g Iona, 00M CREEK EAST 76 UNIT PACs BUM COUNTY will ba tonsideW completolf 1. A. copy of the "final EnvIr4inmetiti tripact Nnpnr o ii fiot r, wAsto dischdroo roquirewskit wpoWbill'd public entlity to ent"'tthe program for o O�°��CnNi.� i ls, AM' public � � iii NaN r r qufrefflo"t CAA theft h drdited And df&t tbu'ted to totiC(*ened Individuals, �� ������ ��Yr° ����r �iNNk� ��i�11'iNi�., ��"��� 'Viowioo 411: n t of Nii n fh waita v 1 N� ' , i N r nN� "� nn i by �: 1i ii � r Jnr 4n >W nn at public hearing, tblfteo and duty p age colitact iti+M tit (016), J'92#19% ANTHONY Jt LANKS, P.G . Area toga ioe acraniko WattrOd } Buttd, ryarrny Efivir hwfit4l hviws it nr� 11 � ftutt ;y coon 1160:1 th Nott 0rovt1le • '�MF4�,i�,� l�I�.���`u"'�e'�� p�+l��'$ir&ii`x'�:�YR(&' 1*134* '40 kow't gom 44'0. 0140 .. t *d4o agi'4 il l V4 rt ! t , •o d' ,I J- » t. • e w e r I y h yy p �� r�ti✓ tT��`�' � I 1H r ri 4 I ,r ua i n la d I.�� � 9 � �`.rt�7 Rpg "y r.. ( �•R� �, R 7 a 7 i 1�" �� ' kfc��N3�Ypt p M s YJC"'' 4 ppJJ,, w V; ju4.0 u i, t i "r:Bi �F 6" N!� u � ;�aC6 �1"i h""'; i yl� ar � � ,KI ' � <• yl�� I° ,I' Yl Pr OJT rj '-f"' J i I I a .lt 1 ^♦ � 1 '. r i , hi», Gni�l'. �., _ � 1 L '. '{ IL +0 ' I I ll' ,I I I� Il lµ( M 0 14 16� 6�1 'f 4t ISI '• �y . " '. .x r.als lu ,I.a f ,1 fiY ll„ �1'nteh".Yu Mmnt IRS-: vul .�pJ�f p� p n JI� �:4�. �n 30 `t I e f' �y 4 r �,.y, 'a�,Ji C I n � a1 �f 1 * `' r �F r � i 1'. .. � a l„." sx.l �u .. � .r dp �, i� t i. 4. .JF; � �+'w ,:..;t. � ' s• �. �a.a r�. u:a pry Sx k �`-:. + N,. 11yy �yy� pry }� u , ,.y it 'i..' 4 A 4.a �l �'��'� � 7V S , R L ,: } � � e �l A4*l ftirM'k;1�"�.� rk � � � .. �:.� 1r + Po •v� i' � 'I i ,�': ( '�`Y t"" r At ,�A 1:,� L..L TM ("7 A * �'� T V✓i M r ..W� V1SR:t i..k . 4._.. * 1:' I i F R M6 ti"AIN PAY 9 tiatot�i ' l t ier", wxf J201 'oe" dtI ir ` lrl# UR btdift,446 ":fob Pit dI ti 'ao" I-WL40 #511 rk6rllob d Pit txd"O. of tfil§ applidandli sic# 01700121190 If Ye d.i ttiftf 6ta bk vorvv tttllv�glv tdt b b- . 116alth. tcipto.l i r , d�, y 170MUNO G. 13ROWN JR, aovehooh Ruh Of I* GOVI1 RNOIVS OFFio Q.FFICC Or PLANNING AND RESEARCH 14050 TENTH STREET SACRAMCNTO 05814 �iPG a7r.pi;ri� (916) 445-0613 i"1(.�f't�7 � •'Ali=i,� May 5, 1980, Mr. Earl D. Nelson, Director Butte County Environmental Review 1.8-F County Center Drive Butte, CA 95963 SUBJECT: SCH# ;79082119 BUTTE CREEK EAST PA -C D' ar Mr. Nelson: The enclosed comments were prepared by the Departmen of Trans- portation, District 03 regarding your project. These comments were riot included In the package you received dated April '40 1980 certifying State review of your draft environmental document. To ensure compliance with the intent of the 'Califov nia Environ- mental Quality Act you should attempt to incorporat,. These addi. tional comments into the preparation of your :final environmental document. Sincerely, 2C¢�� 5tephe V. Wil�;lamson State learinghouse SVW'/Ila Attachment cc: Ken Fellows, DWR State- of California 1 Rusin®ss and, TranspaartaSla�n Agency To State Clearinghouse Dot"; April 18, 198o 1400 Tenth 5,_ree Sacramen , Califoxmia 95814 filo 03 -But -99 Atte g»ttie Creek nt on Anna. Volvos East P.A.C. e SCI 79082119 From t DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION — Telephone ATSS 457-4277 District 03, P. 0. Box 911, Marysville,. CA 95901 Subjectd Caltrans, District 03, has reviewed the. Draft EIR for the Butte Creek East P.A.C. adjacent to Butte Creek in Chico. While this pro`ect alone would have no significant impact on Highway 99 traffic, we are concerned about the cumulative effects of this and other similar developments in this area, In addition the�oj ance with the State's should va UrbanStrategyforlloccatd tinge ew urban devel- opment within existing urbanized area; presently served by utilities. LEO J. TROMBATORE District Director of Transportation; kz?. Ike" R. D. Skidmore Chief, Environmental Branch of Tatzrr'�r GovCRNOR'S or;rrce f IrPICM 4F PLANNING AND RESEARCH' 14400 TENTH S"1'REC �17YiPbtltYftYg1�� �e�iYlptY �'di,� SACRAMENTO 95814 EDMUND G, bIi.OWN Jlt, pov�HNCf� i� t, 411fo Comfy April 8, 1980. earl D. Nelson Butte Co. EftVir, RCv ew' 18-V CountyCenter or, OX'OvillO, CA 95965 Subject SCH# 790521,19 13,Utte. Cre:'ek lJast pA-»C' Dear Mro Nelson State agencies have commented on your draft environmental (see attached) . Yf you Would like to discuss i� docmjent. tecOlnmenrlations in their comments, contact thest fnfr�msthan ed agencies Whose namee' and 'addresses appear on the cofimeits . You may formal,l,y respond to the agencies' conur�en is by toxit n to. thea (including the State Cle;arin 9 COrres ondence on all such When filing thegPinal tl , e�rou. :nust rzc1 ude all COItlnellts and responses (State lP. GuJ de lines , Sec tion 15146). coitlplete �r State reviei�i o£ your drat environmental doctment ill t ,.,b be TO aid it preparing should end tstae-agenciesnand thetal eOt� nt8ce on planum ts' projeot.,, rou. your �lotice of Preparation as prescribed by 8s 4 and 9 and Aces at�,dh of. the 8111 Guidelines. T f you wot id Caro for as8is trance or if the _ - need arses, Yi�e OLi�:�;e c, Planning and Research s availably tc� ,,� y. agencies; distributsa 7otices of 1?reparati n;�dox an to aoontina i meetings, mediate disputes, and hold -ratio a,dat� t oi� ed hearings Please contact arida Polvos at (916) 445=-0013 if YOU Yia„t,re ary ques�a.l�ns 5incerel�` c I... Ce hen t171' ll i. ain'c, rtu'c cleari.nghous .'VW,/act Attachment r ; ken re1115Wte INR " I ,Stdfo 0 Colltdrnlq Ceti !... he R rauraas Apatley of Callf6enla Memorandum, M'r. dahies Burns To Pro;JeCts Co-ordinator soul ces Agency 21 March "1980 Resources Bui1dih , loth 1~loo�4 Data, and Butte County Environmental Review 184 County Center Drive O'roville, CA 95965 From 4 Calltornla-gagloijaiAter Quallty, Cnnitot 116od Contral Vancy keg,4i 3201 S Stroott B drama d', Callrotitia 95s 3 Phditll, 401.027b BUTTC CREEK CAST PAC DRArT M, SCiI #70002119 aubj Sewage from this proposed development could adversely a•rf6tt the Water quality of Butte Creek and local groundwater, A roporl des ' p 1 y igned con structod and maintained sewage disposal system may mitigate this water quality ioipact but sufficient information was not included in the draft; EIk to evaluate the proposed disposal systom 146 recbmmond that Toha!Bapproved heag nsposal Sys tei's adequately detailed, r ttueCunty Healt06prtmatand the Regional Board can thenmake specific comments. If physical limitations exist that cannot be resolved with the proposod special engineering dosig'n, the number of units would have to be reducer, EnCiosed is a copy of our 19 September '1579 request letter for a report or waste discharge and an Outline of aur additional information requirements.' The developer has not responded to this letter to date. If there are: any questions, please contact me at (916) 3221592, ANTHONY a. LAWS Area Engineer Sacramento Watorshed r AJL/cis Enclosure ccr Butte County Health Rept:, McCain Associates; Chico ' srxrr hf r'atir(�rF��,� sG�(atraCts M�l�rs`,1"� � � x C/1MORNIA fi��CrION��L WA (�,':.�Q��� x CONTROL «IIY NTROL BOAI�C�� C �� AL Vr LIXY REGION Own 5 MnITtv :A0M0410, err, � t,,. KXrlMdrrlA' f7'Jfll.d tnc�rtrIglu ��x-���t1 ,r l� �rrp�tt?IIIi1Gt' ���r)' Al Bock f"r,tyu,Jtrr,rl ;h;;is �icicic; Chico, CA. ';9506 V r hRI.fErOSED f3U TE4 CRE LK PAC' .. 75 UNIT CONi7tlM)fllUM, OUTTE COUNTY Anou your dirpt har qa could affect thU Wai% c'af Lf7ty ,YLOW Vu" WO requaWd to MU 0 Wort Of t'f,'riatlt Eif ncchnrUo wi th this orfr'tku. Thr. Ctrl i f011114 lr'lxUP Code raqui Pei any Cjalson proposinq to di�,,Char«rfp vr�istf,. to Me l e w h hQi ona l 130d rdd a report or tho dfachvirge containing such i n frrma. firm as t«he Briar«ri ruqu i r'us, Win report 5 al l he UCtrlttp An i 6d by a filing- Fee. 'Ecru wa tev code further provides des that nu prurson shall Initiate dny now discharge tai` wasLe (rritrr to the 19060"ce of waste Mc,har e requirements, the expiratid Of f���� days fyt- er ti litr(p a tromp letad� Report Of 00M Discharrpr„r or the �tcat�ichal Doard s waiver, whic.hvvr~r uccurs first, E;ncl(r ud are: } Wj instructions rnimg fee sc:hudulu, and blank fttipor•t of 4taste Discharge fu rill (M) Add,itirhal inf`tw+r«nutio" ragwir'ennnt�, When we MOM the ccampylked r�ePort containing the adclit� (ihjl nformati0 if r`vgatru , along with tho ap�prlicable ry ing fon; we will fearinrtlat, wast, rft5cirar�� riaqui,puuuMs for your di sc har ga, the MOM Un of hu considered camplQtu until IIl prr"uvi0ons .ar the Califurbia Wironniantnj Quality Act are met, Al,l f►rfor«Ilryt M artcp t.fu riling fun should he SUbMitLVd to "thif eaffice1ct twithin,do days fromfromlthe(fa tae Of ' cbrrtarwf� pilo at ��ltri k-322-l02 if You have any questions. A11RHONY J. LAtIM Aroo t.n(pinu(,,r �_ir � r'i1trJtw'rr t�0 ���i tC7 r'�a f l C"f� '.i:.nelurlur$es '. jL/ci 8 . .,. _.... _._.._, .._........ .. ....... ... .............., .,-„—r.,...-m „.. «�.M,.-,.,-......,.,.,.,-.n...h...>mwru.z,...gra.+�.�a•,;..,....+.-ocM�:.,�.e.,,mvw,...ibr�^wed:.i..,gra,.r.—�i.}w.;am.mrMl..ad.;...C,.,.,.,..«_,,:,,,' CALIFORNIA REQUAL WATrQ WAtw TY CONSOL DOARD UNTRAL VALLEY EY tYMON Ner n W{�S'�� Or��Osnl� t'rt�1hS �1NO �vC�O�h��N” Desai ire and map location -of poet l ati on Costs WSPHS Manual Method). 2' boscrtba soil profile and reap lonoti'on of tout holes CC feet minimum depth)' gofine 1c�ral ge0109 al hazards rolatad to waste disposal (fracture rockE sand and 0rarr01 stratas, jmparvious 'layers, etQ 4. Map 0000 000 and Proposed Cut and fill 11 banks, 5, bisouss depth and d root3ior) Of nrOvcsrrrent Of seasonal high clroundwateri Mid ot:hOt underlying oroundWater, Map location Of m411siry 016as, springs and areas of moor drainage 7. tlisouss annual PeOd it0tibn arra+ flund hazards Ma 1tte disposal area, C protrosed krolls Within 100 feet Of the �= Ma�� looation err all ow,ist,it�.. arra 9i,iap location Of all draiogo oouraw and waterways, Wk5`i� n�s�o�A 1, Submit dotijn of WastoWater disposal systen x 1ddhtxi'fy charaotor t its of wasto ether# than wag 3, Oeacribd ahow t# 0 arra mainteranoe procedures for the wa te ditpbtal system Ohd rasponsible parity Ohdividua,l$ public ontity3 homoowhers associntioo, Ott.), 4Submit 1 storm di%inage and erosion control plana MOM 0 d, uni 4_ uktoi Aoonty Ira r. P JIM lltArjjftf tt�ttar.trEqu'Afnt>n,y Dottts tlnttatttC Nolooft ralvIronloolital, ;Ctt�tr�t� C�r.tt>;t� 1,84 Cnrr>tty t� ttit r 1)kVn f�t"tUVt�t! Cly.. r t►�Jt11 't° bap'tiYfMlttrN uF Fiuf� ood o.hriics Subj�t�tt Cottb, Crouk taot PA-C� sit 71,1062110A t�ttGtt Cnurtt w '�ttr ap.irrr>nr;nb of Molt attd aaftio ttaa revidwa, braft i:tt€ ,twttr tli' iitt Ct aat tagett< VA -C Whial't propngots i itc� ttavajopttt 7curt t«r Ctlttttnn t 4foo Ol.uOtnr dh a 375-anre parrot id3 r:an � citFt Ct�rwaft Ott t3ttnt~ ottttt �. Spddirid cotztmatitu aro tin r()j .otaa* 1, The xagtt:tt*L.>tit,ttt: or should iital.twr x� x avian rjtttxtt� 4kv na apoo-Ifiud lit rain t. IR ' C ttd3 t i� of t9t*t7jv�� appk'oVtil ,, 'x Thd meoit ddal dated A ttrttrurrt r'onewat,ian taxa ah'd w rit t o-fugc e0titAinn iii a-v4luo, riPrtriAll tt€tbl at; . Al n d6b4 it ion P"J"ti OPWvdln do -ed torts dtian iirt,% .ud ng t uturn. tNtry iop ffiartt of tion 4raa ah6uld bO tequirod r Tho davalnpar, niiott.t:ri' be, ac ote that nfiy altc!>A4tiott o twat, cliatttitl d ttut±ta Oeek, swill kdqu t e nn dge� o ttitIntt tJ t1� tlt ' ' �:p t hi --tib tttict i:ish F�rtd CatEit� Code �entAtett �G� itani you .t*nr t:hn tpt*�+turiit tooiitrr>rxt�'i tCt ianpnrbtnart pan be a�t�i�tnra�n� pl�an� �tintra�� tt�db�rb iii ia�taaatit �a��ni�tt� RAtta,�nr, i#dGiatt. 21 �`�C t.tnbt� tiaadttnrtdtta Cardnv Cit ]b� Cr-arttab3 ti�ephtty� {57C� Par mon" di memorah"fim �u�sa �r " t Yki Y1 t Oil Lin r0V Butte orr olt ��,aa lu, April 1980 haws IOVteWed '010 6:fta Environmetit,41 j pa(w to ' p pc� twtttM � + Z t1a and (f6vclloplobta Anil W*111;h t,+ IF bepar.0- , a .tkoli tvi,n t�fdh'Odty � f0 iftel cion in the T"'x4ot .' w4 .tw"1A4 4 ku�,�+► onSw,�L u+ l tAit �:l .'.' '�M Fac; Jag µ t,l th A.PFYA �L;e GP yy,. V 4 IT P&8,4 24 - Tho 3t 4t mO tr that the pilopa, ;ed niatont with the iftt (Jftb of thee'ra,l: Plu in come- what pvddo�ist�eotpyl� o tieano �dnd tftiry3°1, µriding',.. denalpI. t yi t►VyUyy�+� that qt��{O p p V duelling urj t , aila Within taho I-to-40 a e: per Utl t>` ranged of the " , : ltx ',��1. r " eatog.ory,4, Howaver, the d.etet inOtaiOft of do,noLbtx.,-aey�4,jtkt ours d 0040MI Puri will be Made bY tho Planning. pepart meat ttnEff the JPI aftning Comlias on atd 'thy 00rd 0.f lsttporvi8oro Only after a 001,pict eview, of the rolevant p"lithe and dt andard a cca.tain d in 611 adopted aia�ent0 of the piaft, Particular attddatiO4 will be paid to daafd-MAUde With, tho follotvin ph i- ' 47 VA�kJ..L V rlt 4J 11C1 �. G! 1J1.117.3�y ('7,EJIA: Jl G- Y \r 1 VJ�IIhC� lA m/-lr .L !J Cil L k'f Y �. wampatia.:bi wlith xlajs;f.boring aEM Tj—t"ura a t .iti y a Evidence of adquat e wataj atjd curage dj�apooaj Pa di by 41, 3. Availability ae adequate Fite PVdbqdtion faciliti#d,, 4, Adagp,atoiy ma-iftt;aihod appfcvad mad adcaas witihuf- -f3�Gient ea,pdaity to Servide ateaa _ t o YYia a accc.9aib, lity to aotjjtaraiai ser via to ata par es 01909 bad tezid riti 11 a tI4,ti y S6i cand.itiong aud water availability, EfTects on adjade t u8es,, crop prcductxa,d:r'jijVeotxocj gtag'uf,�,. t0v" Y bc' cSOU ca 7 a ttlnati6n and, tiviid,jlfa ob i t at vGximitY to, Public roadz and othe± pubjj,c raalliti. s: April 9-t 11,MO L,4duo ria 9. Erfooto oft fi i e f tw-Irric lov n, a m-'tI s t1ate quality -�••gy quality. yip$ � y� 100 Local ly� ti, ooll,004 g� yy� yy ..YY�� 'q,,, it k to nt i4l ftt ,Peat in adat, Vroodin vP .. dxleatoft 11 <'� ` C:l,-n �l'+e R■' 4'k ." 44, .4 � iitli .d9 'll [P9WiAl. f,1'F.7 Page - is-oUndio r "Water "Ply" ift�j�,Iude a bekef Iter r gam+ +.�C�4.'n� lli �L �. Ptiod e"t ��i4.7��t", into �.Jy��J,r+ allow, 'r.u� u.Iw4�J.e'r, }w9r but duladian, or the local Impem"tI, naftoly, the of 'new viello 0C)TVilrig dwnlliftgo on a. p ui ' r-- z�jvvitI6 the r do tioarby hut ss oft lluftbug; R Ad* Sle Meed o tore �rx iu� tht itiad dAd zuggp t app 6 riAto mitig4tion meatureg III tadd eVident by Oatotantg ift Appeftdit 41 the J"ydrOj6gligttg, Oft � th t love q epjkgo ud.kjgrcoul ''hig �td� r0dfi"gd Ibutdol that ptosped�a dud±gd W0113 Are ftt 0ftd6 ±A9Lft& aftd that redhargo gelid Ate Poof I0d&ti ft3 uji which to develop do dU ,q gmuftd- FaterTP i6di, shduld be giv-,Vt td dtItiftKI tha PtW ti it 11 dom:c'atid CVato g7up+i:�. rvdd, dup,ruao' dr gr6wid b6tirdeg . o the wemt of tho dlovf� b jftft� of 4.*. d6hfUtih beaquae there uro two dirtore t . jtPrn&tj 6 e,ib re erfod toy 81 -0 th"A t'�aI prr r*P-nt, t�nde 6fi- �.i:�,,y�tJ:kiZ'atim 18 r ;gWe1f:tidl &Veli pdctft o yr`� 3w the 'TO o 'edt" dItdff,fttiVq w6uld be Jao nO4 J'ult fto V0Z0fti , , The 1111�o Project" alterftativd tho no reton hg dltephaUve which would r3�� w mend of 5--tadre hoffto ite under' the exi, tj fag HyR-5" toff 110ieSites" headiog -,hould include diope t� of tater wit,'haeaW&I 6hd 1 o8t oll at water withftnf al away prof nedrby doitestio wells,, L 4 c �{�� q C'y "�i{ Y }}t�phu� � yp` the wli,t '1� i.rhe �r &���a �.'4.6�?GA��.� h�lt�,?�Cn t l.s ho, bVJd!i.lui�O . hu' .P �C_k 4, ki SII. I.'i 4�.+i. wa.l.d L$? LI, tillo ativreat Illeve ra-N,Uwsll rymv, wild iff" lief"i T..3 Y'SIii C:A�IF�A owl at, thio Ca �lJii,�;�,�. tc; cwcx ����4 n3F; JI WJ. .f.t d4d4#ry ���"�_�iag �ilfi���}��t��ypRllyyC..RyyC+�(,l(y»j %�,��i.,„,1 f,,) C7yL�1p1 �c..�y���y y�aiy��r��JRJ0.�M�alg y"� y�� �N�y�y f1�„hW4�{r�'K-� larg 4,F;p��l�`si kh d.tlX�.yl C@.ia+yR.y'�y�ityr��y�o, N: Yv�R�Jl���;+,�..a�,' 4u M:,WAy�y�yp PJyA '4-�' Y i .k+t�ry�+l P.4vvly pS.ry.Q�pky!�t p {dip y�N,rn �y v i�.X P?'.➢i+GF1�A 4o T•., fj i,.,,A P Iw.i4'4d19Y�*.7 M''T:7�A+ l th pplica io a,lot. Plolft3 Gnut{�mitf;(A cn AhA , {j t -mabio he rojiw fA utu ray ne of a���a ioeot hro8-totirtho or than pi te1j`'and t m not (it, any- 6, te;,yy��pia��nyyt�.c t th%%�.��,tpr�ll[[,, iit�yTTyA� rit'ir i-ohta i.ch #ife ��p y{�� 'u��'���W`.a�tpYavotftb'`l a y{f�ii�y� yy Vigo 51 lite EM do0a, fl�t n't'�:�Yw a cgl,'l lye#j��:�wy�'��,yob' t�'�ab- q*p qgg ✓ry p yn4 CGd..aµµ tL i to the, &y cli4Lthat ile phA d volo to-txt or e Pv6pity i the ft -A � O neaf., �ought pn-fetal Review o albeoft'able Lalf niterAG1iVc7YpIch y6uld f{aiibly attaii, hq3ji9 t eon4iderauori of futthor dov�- ldpbb of the 'P,t�Jedt nibs itoelE thtough, poozib,I� future rezonitg G,C,,r-,ra, ftid-Ila' tld hel-16t'ili:i:tig r:,P t t � d v Old niomea W' �y y., fi o 0..;1 �. u . s t:..t l.� �� i'.. �.. �i,a , ct4nfan to th:e. i1q,no'b x of; 'than propo ed development oh the 1 . from� teagqld 1y1�..ba tls:d.d l4i.YJ.dowAip4.4Ha t7 hd 81W wrwrom other il4L,-Pc.Mt— tr } ., � ' �' �� tiiGNT:J KiT dI�F.Y.�&'k�I N�� � `:w �;•;J $Y i �,�ry ., � AN ANk y to ton" ruwulf ve,lk'(341'�011 own a le'u ck eppis �¢�,�yN � �lY tieV�''"kbi lkf bl)ltl; ,wjtjo �� '�vrl, In te � w1 h Batt, .. �r z' J , �t V- twe no -p a � �� two w� cplll llc t v� � 4 14 1- � � ��p Jam ' Creek A '� u'le f r��lift. u _ ��Oft ` the p1l"W5. A*P ' .it, U11 i ` he MAI to 11to wl O"Alletla v . ,', hili ' tun 0 l br low Or Q thin, bo fteudd"y Addition. ihat wanit loath IA" uUr typo Ot 4614, duf t : k Off4 UO theAct UpLarakfied,ul, It tow, dd* Il;raw11cd�VOUIA � Virt� ' 011 l tdd With ` h 41 , 4w Thi ' hpro, In th.0 PIA I ': po"lat the dit Wauld ddublo,, lfbio, nAttjrA.j br a tf#nd havo an dffifilty of holdlig th hili. � `_Ole. the etmft w 44 �i ZL let 44 J4. µ,P,?�„ �,''7i�" 1'..,3' ,p�P F,'E'.✓4t1'.,.i�, �,Je� `ir'�..'JIA".,,, M,Ii 1 '«u dd 961904,b "ty c 11 a, braft` d3 ; *ts Doak' Mt, me nuttd Crop?. ft �µ�7 with y�� y� ed -, y.,} yt yr �y«t+p'ygM.y',�'�+p�g� ij&",.;K%i.k `' 4$i` A». �T '�." �,W� d"a X4. y" 'k.ti°. ry. 1%tl 4+ '. Vlanw ca W ynal yy$ t � i yp.�� %y� � y ,�wy q+ d� , .yy�j, {y q C.�i1k 11 a '.�:+ y�yAig 1t'Y3, +,a'G.:.'3w 'nf*n.�«4$N',N..t y�ya 4+y.��#'t y�5yn P4 �nryp Ns+gy�+ yeas too To �i by"id gg +�30c" !� _�7 mi i aa will, tam: lb 'from: ' , ptoject ato i 4;0 until I, ov% ca"O�a� thew b36ht frog. yu s Preliminary analysis Environmental Impact Report/ Project for Bute Creek East PA -C, Butte Creek Canyon, CA TABLE Ohl CONTENTS PAGE introduction.....«...«:.,...Y...::.«.+.'.••,#Y...:.:.. Summary and Findings...:..««........... i .�,»...•.:'Y•.. Wafter Quality .. :.... . ......«' «, .•..' Water Quantity.. 2 •.b «• H'•• ••Y....• Traffic 2� + . . . . . • • • •.« • • « . • r.« • » . • • : Y • • . .re 2 pi�» .. .. .. _... � . .,.• b.. Flooding».•.. 3 .b.«•.,.», .• •..,........ Police Protection 3 ........0.1................ .... General. Plan 3 ••...«.....•-....Y.•.:«.........., Proposed Project h +•.•....».. .... ... ...:............ General Plan and Zoning 4 ...... .. History of Present Zoning .•;•...,;........'.,.....' 4' 5 Failure of the Proponent to Provide Adequate Data.... iY...... .« ...:+.«.... .. .....Y.......« Wildlife Habitat/Destructjon . -.. f • . . ♦ ... Conclusions ..........•.» ...:. .. • ,.. .:: 11 Appendices—ii... .•:.......:::.......«...... 12 i.. A. Agricultural Residential Zoning •. B. Events in the. History of the zoning of Butte Creek Canyon r:.:... ,«.........:. .... ...«:: 14' C. Regulations for a Foothill Zoning Ordinance ..,.•« 17 D. Regulations for a ",FR-.5"' District .... ry ti Letter to Baldwin Contracting Co. froth Butte County Planning Department .. 25 F« Response from Environmental Health Department ..:.. 27 G. Letter to Baldwin Contracting Coi From Butte County Health Department ... 28 H« interview with Lynn Vanhart ::..::..«.:,.....:.... 3.D Z: Letter from Water Quality Control Board to Resources Agency . 32 d. interview With Water -Quality Control Board •....;, 35 R« interview with Steve Sorenson; USES ....;.....:.. 36 L« Butte Creek. Rezone EIR oh.Water Quality .......... 37 + Map 1Project. Site a . Figure l.: Development Area ::« ..: ... 4b .. ... ..... -------------_---� ase A11h Aft Environmental impact noport/project for BUtf;r: geek. East Plan Area Cluster (PA -YC) I 4utt Creek Canyon, ,Butte County, CA Introduction We have been asked by the Citizens Committee of Butte Creek Canyon for Y conduct aft- objective review and analysis of the draft Environmental Impact Report (d/EIR) and the proposed rezoning for the Butte Creek East PA -C development -4 In order to sethe aforementioned otstitWas ue e aartoestablihthe iactthat therearewoisses germain to the Proposed rezoning and/or development One deals with the actual, request for a rezoning, and the other relates to the potential impacts of the proposed development providing the rezoning is granted. In this particular case the requested change of zoning will have to mee•�: the require- merits of the Conditional Zoning DeVelopmen-L Criteria as outlined in the Land Use.Blemont of the Butte Coun y General. Plan. This pa" �a, ainong8E other the things, requires eve tler�`" e cat adequate water and sewage disposal capacity; availability Of adequate faire protection, and adequately maintained approved road access with sufficient- capacity to service area. The proposed rezoning could be dehied if any one of the criteria are not met: The ­impact report should have addressed these issues with. the afworementioned requirements in: mind, and have. Provided full disciosure, plans and specifications 01, such essential services. This information is necessary for the, regulatory agencies and the general public to conduct an adequate review and make intelligent comments on the proposed. rezoning and report We regret to say that this has not been done in this case. In a mariner of speaking the d'/EIA is incomplete and lacking pertinent information required for any entity to adequately assess the potentialimpacts of the proposed re- zoning and/or project. The fact that the report is insufficient is also confirmed by both local and state agencies that have jUr-sw diction over the denial or approval of this matter. Based upon official docutitents and written records there is no doubt that the project proponent has had more than an ample amount Of time to address those issues of vital importance to the proposed projec� and also to meet the intent of the lawt in our judgment the burden of responsibility for provid- inq adequate inforihatibn does riot rest oft the entity that wrote the d/EiR� but rattier with the proponent and engineer r �}�. Ys r� ice. vert a...�a�.. .., 7 .�.... >:.'1 :.... ��_,�._ Y:. Ya ...,.... i :_. t 1 .: w Summary and Vindings Issues that have not been addressed at all or nAd(,;3rjtiately, addxess,�ltl Later Quality The prosect proponent has been asked by the various r6gula tory agencies to supply speci;f14 data on their ,suwga disposal puns over a year ago and have failed to comply with this request. No specific plans or specifications havo been the Rec,�ed e tater - my Health Department or submitted e. Quality Centro tither to �d �ut�to Caul 13oa;rd CRL'QcH) . doth agencies stated that they do not have adequate information to make a determination on the proposed reonia+ anti/or the d/EIK. The Regional tater OualiLy Control, Bos.rd is recommending that the Eli not be approved until the sewage disposal system is adequatel.y detailed, so that the Butte Cour►ty 8ealth Depart- anent and the VOMcan make specific comments', Cater Quantity Eche developer has failed to provide a plan to supply adequate water for to proposed do'volopmerit, as roquosted by the Realth Oepartmont over a year ago. Serious questions have been raised in the BXR regarding the availability of water, These have not addressed definite solutions to this problem Surface water Was suggested in the d/Viii as a source of water, which would requiro a tro,atment facility. The report fails to mention the type of facility or method of treatment: More important it clods not say how much water will, bo diverted from ]butte Creek,and at what time of the year. This raises a number of legal. questions regarding water rights,i txtrac- tiara of ground water could have a direet impact on the amount Of surface water in Butte Creek, which serves as a ground water recharge source for the surrounding areas, and also for Chico and Durham. Extraction of water from subsurface sourcet. could have an adverse impact on the amount of water available in Butte Creek for -those that have adjudicated rights to said. water. Downstream owners should be notified of the project: It could also cause ground water overdraft in the micro environment, traffic p.- 1-e—, -,._ _. sked the developer foie Tho_De` artment o£ Public forks CDpV�) a . 1-i_ , ,. o de�volpPer; no ana tio.s o roadway tion or tr4-►.�� j i' �'~ tadw�t 1�CCt�rc'a�ng to °� Y crtn:.f:igrxra- . • C, wi t+hin tyre p�oposod d0v�ei,opvront was cb,t", stea as a tht� °pork done „ n the preparation o� th1,s rdpplt. Yr The d0valopor has fai:l.od to prodUco e traffic angirrooring study. Tho DPW is aski.nq that the developer deed thirt right-�r�-or,along the ont+jro, property on ttumbu�, to dtms`ke the n000ssary improvemortsx This is only a reguast Ind is not logally binding at this point NOrhtntiom is macho in the: rOport about the cost ar potential iropaots of widening tho road The courrtY Will have to condemn and purchaso properties alciyg Cases the only havre a prescriptive r ,, on wiaoning the read. TA many ug boy �' y right to about . tum nd .wont �+, ad. is ntC eight ;feet along the road whereas tho a/nxn sugctests a total right-015 -way width of at, .cast thirtywe�,ght feet for seta vohicular use. Tt dould cast up to $,I M11lion a Milo to bring humbug road to luinimum oauhty subdivisio' standards According to the j)pw' how not have ,any plats in the, making for i:mprovehlonts along Humbug Road, The proposed ptoject will dop'initoly con tributo to the accident tatev and more importsnb will. add to traE l IC congd8°bion and serve as attObstacle to emergencY resrionso vohidlos, To summari2d, the d/VxR. totally za is to identify the adverse tf-Pacts of increased traffic and Consdqucntly renders it impoo8ible tis di.seuas Viitigating measuros r. ire Y Approval of this` projoct will : Ad-td- tae the burden bn the 13utte County Fixe 0 artmer�t arid. also inoroago the potentiC;l of Tiros in the rospeativo areas, �Cnitial responso time to tho projedt, undor the most optimum conditions is si. minuteti providing the one resnonso vehicle is available and not out on another call. Back-up response, tiMee as stated in the d/2.tR are' in error: rphe area '8 designated as a wriidl&nd fit& hazard area and once a home datches Tiro it is generally lost, Fleocl The historyof f1Qc�diri in the pre ".ect area � � _ is no oeCrGtc The �Idbd8 of 1964 caused. didsute 6 -the Skyw &y- The obit ousadverse efE6CJts of i;lood protdction efforts aro referred to but are bot eva.lt�atod or analyzed in the d%FjT2 especially the dffoct on downs-tream pxapert es',. l�,y.�:ce T�.roteCtiori eYlfcirCetn � to speCity tI t e and Tavel -of olAW Yip �,' C report �c'1],1S.. + Y p ` ... � eat sd.rvices available to the res,. ect. Minimal epansit5n of the dairerage o thi critical subject in the d/ lit Will e�tpose serious problems y includilig a prabablo response time of 20� d tniriutes and. absdlutdly no sdheclulod patrol; or drime prcVeh-tiori service 4Cenoral Plan ��A1}�I1�rp�y4yy,��!'..iF yah ppqq'N-yAi`y. yi4,Pp%.t6.1'iyiF'Syir.!i'.7tj{{i4�j.}#14y�.y7' a�5.yy?-'q{{CIIyy'�'Cyy�4Yt'�y��,'�'.;+R$a.1yi.R.0 is qq 1 tt �+�Ro-6 �� R..(+.yJ'��ri'6d, �kf �,3'��l.Yaininti �f k.Y 'k..k.f A i.i arF�.i i` V .f #5MXKa Vii, l.A.,k. 1� .Ra till k '����11:Y 7 u.✓ 'Y::' Wa PrOI)OA --t ha n failed to etatt to provide atlempaLe� deli to MOOL ties ie!t i requiremento (,!� c�r�w,dWO ,'II Oonin bf the i dire i n ii wi tib the i t (to'and OnCOL p dp ifty right a -w to allow a ewdtitlut4ar hattoIn r)ro e ct in a ktMotd wi diand firo and lo6Plait, ated is try in a planodd dianater. It U1, r -Or thtso 4nd Daft+q�doftttA ir t0d i�l�i1Y toliitti��,csii , k.i�at� w� t,rt�witw� �ttaai 'Review D rtndb� amend h d/0111 aft4 ve rapes. t O MOOMMdhd until the propohdftt o, aoWt the required it'rfyormatAion thorn y giving t ht! rogui4t ory *q6ftqLOO. and tha. public, of opportunity to dd ent esti. 'nomobbity with }� They Pt6jeeft in located approxim t rAy five #41do aoubhoadt of Chied On llumbuq Road Cod Ma i'� Projec Atd ) , They ptopo en )ta; rdqud trail' that, t fi � l t+e b re2onad rx to rtt-5 (Plan Area-tWiuutd,t o AO9jdentidA) to prolvidd ibe thd ddnt ud- bion of 80vdt` ty-fire qluntor64 ronliftntial unit s; on, Old hold in common,ownerahip by, owne~r 6 d dt�dx�ta -five hdihd � 1 being,datign ted, &a a, natural dors t~io da and WiMUE rof°u d under t hd cotit -reel. Of the hotitaoto"nor' Codd vlquto i The prdjddt ditd ig d6saighated at, A ridtaitiugai ttadid6nt+i l (1-40 adrda/dweil.inq unit;) in the t6dentyiy rovitod Bra d MU111t f adhdtai Phan, Oujffrbnt 2dnifiq is a Pkifflat geg.0� uAgricul,t-yural utdg atiel titql# family dwdl.iine'a at rurj1 ddngiUt;dd . -40, tM: 40 y i'"ft- 20; Ion -461 andCr* coricll � e rial i . C`e r' z5tr utr c�nd -� 5 A-it)'y "rin-i t hrdug xrt-o t h du liM-104 i AAWMff- j AT-lA? and, PA -Co gubjedt; td finclingI*,. Hifi dein, OOkml try With d idit ; fid "%6hifi And bdrreidpmdnt d. Itatia iigtdd below Compa-eibl d with, itdl.ghbo" ting agxicul tutdl d&bi `iUd§. tviddhdd t� aclet ttatrd WAtoi aria sewagd digbogal cap Af—Y Availability- of aclequatid f td ptotya ttiott fadilitidtt.. 4. Adequately to nt;a nod approvod, read- ace sg wit::tuffi O�Idnt dapadity td ed.'vite atear 5" Rdaac ruble ttoodigijlbllity to do i drd tai i rry .dda, and sctietbis to rp""ati"nr ItIona 0yq.`�� L"s,MN.FAc cIFt�4ur. 4�'�R��6�,At�� It With tho Into-qt of t1i � `i 'rvined (r(ftjrkj PI-an: A41 do aign m the" orda do Agr Ouitural 11cflide tLIL , The tomort 01000 110L datiqu At l ddread! itself L:O itoma 1P. r and 4 of tato- conaition4ja toning nod criterl t "aach, In diNfibbly0a, nod combitiod dry for the denial and 4pp6vaj Of tho ,*,Rj. WO mist bear In Ift fid, that 010, PropohonVa JMMU03t 1 not 4 c0bdidtiMlt Utwi but totjr(tj -001iditional e6halot tit *,afi9 'dquant.41 it in ptmw,uv o Ouse 9uY19d&t that n view of thio fact that the 6pott ftli ff 'to ftdtfro,i b t1w tea.. .. ... regr M pax And, `�i iftta-� the quality 6 lir in the `,r i���tta� fid'' prgohi rdqui d ri Yd" Of 46110-Atift 4tid hard %6rk zind a 16t of takp y r.* dollar r o thd f1hol apptovaj ttitv p and at that timd pravi ed a dogrod oStu a,cd t ?d tanyon dwdll ro that thoir efforts would help t6 preserve thdir 1AY of Iiaad, the quality of the L14 iY n OnVironow tinct gtill, allbw bt1wr p opLiiMty Ownorm the tigf t to deV6i,01j hdir, r pd - tiva lands. Thor wa$ inaviLi ' nj ffidntion, .0 pYi r� . toning in ani of the of f i iai d6 'tdfxt§ t jnut�g r PEdP6§dl ade: by iitfio�r PrOP0hdtt9 dt 6pptno its of hutto Cry ;any-66h. d n iitir �Of'ling P dd4gd This a `t had he n Confuted: by 4 thorough dv� car ho liff d di tk�dftd,,6 Pdktdihiflj to that rdadhih Putthl�4rmor r i wad the intent of th.d 'Canyon kdW' o-te to znairit in i r �dtM68pheke aiid j ifji�tylid WO it vias eta tad Vin; th it Prolpd l�d z jadti6ng f0t a pboclill gohiitq 6rdih in MAY irk 1916 (Ood nppendi% i!y x. Tha butt-6r Cotifity Ward 6 9uPd,rvia6kg Pdmii d and, adoptdd tfid O''dqulabiong for do PR-45 dittridtbit Jane 2,7 r 1078, (god Aopwidim ' y iit wh dh t1jiti W4no, ridr�tibft Of i inn PA4Cp A dittAdkY i eVioo 'of the ftwd- r cz ti Sri t ra iiirk rpt itidivat6s that th,;tds, kid, way b yyh6w�ifilj thAt adh 4 its (V -C). wold bo aliovpody. lot aidn Ott 1111rch lit W�9"M h mto douot � nuttt�t 0190 luhint A yyt�qu to valdwi �+pp �.��ip �`�a�re�t �� CmIl�p�#,. ei v .. # tit. i Riek.ti4Uk Itik°'.I L41u{':� Amudix 1.3; Mieque�,y yy,,�� to Milo t�.'�' iquwn t t �' ,ai'i' 1 ofm. ft:�L.°�'�,� �.w. out tov e i e"mmuntep frog 'th(I varlow, Evil polley ;arrted out by tho pldunit*, t oClmmenta and 110VbMf f3ddd by tato Datt � �ttt p tmont 'dollov:� botoro we maty°ot omirm" tytowfl :of ultzi h4vdi and p6tedo 4 Plana, for or til9m t o amor wid wator � ��'a Xis dot �� �x�����t�.��t t�aa .���btt to, thd vatt C011iit lift tlo bOPIttmOnt On Mat6h 0 ,0t over a yoar -ago (reieir Wo Appondi. d tta Uq CO- # ficlvt.�z 06 Redlith 1ibpatt Mr*ef t requngtinq I t. d dtioa ani /o.t=y ddtAil to, � bdv� Ito f-fate Or-` 151 td fir* tytift vatihatt,,0 bjrtjtor ar vvj,,gjbu df t 044 jfdalthf ftttd Cowity H alt b y rtmof t t `tha, a t idt dd ei t a dt itt Or a bpodifldf6p, . graft the p ojd t prdpcndat or t eik" dfiqlfladr4 Thid wa , # � C a p ttion"!A Int vi With Mt. 'Voli tt dI Ma dh hd fact that t1di it1fdr t m glad bot -d Csi ve ' by thi H861fl Ddpa. tft t etas al-§c dd ��:ttyIh a ptf%6nal IdttkVitiw with, Mt., Tom. Ri r, On Mdri�h -26# !006 dt h Wato_OddiltY c6fitt;dl bdakd 4-tic c6r,thtdd that the -did not. rdedivd, gp6diUd ifiIdtMat bft ro- atdiny thtd a0tutil rwthod aid d t1 jib dt tdrJ , tdt the djgpdsaj df 86wdt4gda Thl;§, vmg CdAftkfad %ti a Pets'oh'al ihfer itw with- . Tony 41 I on d . ,15816 dt 2—:,130 p-M. and 11ry - �Ubsoqueiiit tialdp t� lull .014, ttvvez:j tqcil:3 {{�`ant to' 1-0t, �; *10 ntatinti that. �� 0-to o Gk s - ��,•��n, ' i It In abilut M asst _if o m �� b�dt A 10 ta 15 Eta WOW cud Ovorage '1 l" ' ld th Probablyrelefit of Himpamictin. altwti N att t ablilp, Eta", �7 afu r-A it. w a2i fxw. bouts o thwi i ft's. , he Itll , t"i ocolA n, � �� to the pp'J qe{�y o �W ""�Y'pwWCi ({Iy (�}�{} "� V 11■ny .,pW q{ y � y i M . cµfth :i or",, Jthat t F.p' � p� rlv4.i�4t �L1"s q a4�.7. �W W4 w➢l kN� .YI Y F 1 ow it paid ihfftfAlon a-lkvl OU4 wt wo' dti Wtat'can, o ddita Aot ptov0d, ,a�'Lut E` , ptj41 a� withouttr d typo tiz ififdkmnt iw; ivelemlditfti- to to p 1:T gyS:p A,i V yp�. sky, {yT . Wy,{&y.Y.KAIS.V.}N1j{iiFyµ y'i'iAlnwl? 17.Y 'wti ,Y..K,L-+ ���''}' *II''0 E G�' {�' Iff��Y'k mvide tomdo .lcihlea]L 61,14 chotnimix quality ' 'vb J1#,C add t4 h t'rh(� t*kiougo 6ty r Mit d hey only c, it ludin hitch, th b attORMti df Gha t hdrd omal nt~ ai!4 Wduld hot eomtettty 04 microbial bt bad tet idoqj *,1 IqUd'i .tiyOf the t+aatek zf 1�utt i crd o 'Otho-it been Urditeat It Ig tiara td a ahr BOttbr Cta )i C i#§d 1Wd dd h6t hrdv, adolIqaltd, dalt4 f loot r diiY �� elf have data, (soa Appetidicet L atidy , fi , � t at dffidot a Are fads if 6/Ela tdgatd cq ' TMS �ly��yyx",Olt I It ja� '--jt v ' t'A"- ft's" UAW, 1 il' �rCt fit,, �Vr`+ .839 O#' k tJ �kk'C i,al yyy ��Tg' ' u ry�,g g6 N� Wy�. ��}y±��.A.:4N,y,���..tJ;apNy i:.k iw._� IE�ic1, t V.q 1A1'.WAU�i.•".I '�+�A,�;:�'1.Y 1{h„��' 'l �il'�7 t dIGc'+.r��1�4�fx gid* F ��..`�L+d .m '�, .? � is M-6.i. r 4,01 c %A �1 :b+,.ot' RWO lo' �''vu k'i'lt + j r".:kT tl3kl awl uv %F Ki4 1-; ,,o e ""�j' L' k • i � � I. ,"` L} IMhj" Vit lF:�..A w��.�u� r bit p t but l`l ti4 'flit `'ku3LC yyo, yp ��q�q yy�' �a gp�� ( � ���y �w �:.° ���y� � �� �� �yy����5�y l p . rk� �� � � � ��a on pV�IC 471 VY..1F�& ��� 'SA:��Ji $AG.'VP 'G..Y ANG aL.FA Cif >.w� ��(t'PN-N'�*�(���4 S.w %✓�.+'N 4"J�AL iyVuu��S5'rr� tvr Op "''hiutth�k toral aItI �� ��� f' � s -° the ehi 6 lie eta' r 5 -«. �x�al *� v water supply system" raised by the Butto County Noalth Department over a year agcy The d/ IR also Cai1r� �o address item 3" Plans for Opera tion of the Sewer and Wa tot' Sys Lepis rurthermore, as stated in the d/EER the need for 11lood control protection may, require the need :Cor reconstru�.tion and/ox relocation of the existing levees which would .have a direct impact of groundwater recharge. If the proposed levees need to be extended to the west and/or require sheet piles of some other, measure to reduce seepage during ,high-water episodes, then the possibility exists that the.l.ocal and regional groundwater recharge might be reduced signifies= cantly. Additionally the water levels of the proposed ponds could be detrimentally affected, especially during the dry season. [Groundwater recharger p. 15] It should be noteu. that the preliminary levee proposal would allow some backwater flooding of the development area during flood events. (This :flooding would not affect str. ucturc * situated in elevated pads.) ,kdcli •- tionally, it is iike.y that some recharge would continue to occur during flood stages when the local subgrade becomes saturated. However, the presence of any subsur- face aquacl<udes would greatly reduce the potential of this recharge mechanism. The report also states that there is a need for additional studies as outlined in pages 51 and 52 of the draft repor-. Mitigation measures are offered in the report to help reduce the aforementioned impacts relating to groundwater/recharge. However, they are limited in nature. These limitations Will have a direct bearing on the groundwa`er basin and recharge system in the regional area; this .:n: turn will ultimately affect the availability of ground eater to adjoining property owners and future residents in the immediate area. As stated in the report it could also have �• g yadverse p- ~t on g 5 q serve as anrecharge s8icmkem forogroundwaterne of the ainrtheuChico andDurham areas. The report also made mention of diverting water from Butte Greek as an alternative water supply. it also stated that another measure to mitigate for the potential loss of recharge would be to divert water from Butte Greek to provide limitred volumes of y'. ' er. to the proposed ponds to assist gremadwater recharge, r'o•rh of these proposals raise a series #of answered questions and issues. F:4rst, the a&,nt of water and the time of diversions have not boon addressed; both. of which, are critical factors, for 1,0 the fallowing reason; most of _thewator on Ou,tLo Creek during the months between April, and Aucust ktas ,for irriecia Gaon, Purposes . Sec t dl 1 been adjudicated have a specific right o y, does tlae project proponent to draw water from Z3utt.e Creek, and if so how much are they entitled to and for what purpose? Isere again, the project proponent did not provide adequate information either for the decision -maker or those that are sincerely trying to make a fair assessment of project/the proposed rezone. Problems associated. with the limited amount of water available V the canyon environs was noted in the Final , gable impact Report for the Butte Creek Canyon RezoneninDecembe of 1977. (Refer 'to Appendix L) xh December As development occurs in the Butte Greek Canyon area the demand for water Will increase and the amount of 'water resources available will decrease in proportion to demand. The major problems associated with an ar increasing dependency on 'the limited mater resources as^e many. Some. Of the co,7cerns are that we don't really know the amount Of water resources available. Development will, not,take its real toll untag, after the tact. that is to sa dwell int;s in Place consuming this water, and ei.therV�because ill � Of natural overdraft, changes in hydrological; f4a,tures of the stream, or a dry cycle which is not tilncomznon in the Mediterranean climate We could exceed the threshold of available water supplies setting the stage efor a naturaly and/or man"induced catastrophe. It is also important to note that over the years canyon dwellers that derive their water from the ground have had to dig deeper wells.. it is common to have wells at 2()0-3oO :Feet for domestic water supplies, We have also experienced problems With surface and subsurface wager supplies on prope:.°y adjacent (contiguous) to the Proposed project area. These probler,!s were attributed to two major factors: the project pl"oponent; Butte Creek Rock (Baldwin Contracting Co., Inc.), had dropped the level of Lhe stream in the past which directly affected the fl,ovi of surface water in an adjacent slough causing economic hardship to the property owners due to the lack of water for irrigation ptarposes. Surface and subsurface wate by the drought. rs mere also decreased: The d/tIR states that ahle,prospe;:tofgetting water from a fe v deep wells is not ':hat promisingj it may be more; suitable to have a series of wells serving the respective development. This could also compound the ,prob'�ems, d over draft to the adjoining property Owners and the amount of Water in the stream itself. w Wildlife Habita:�/Des tructIon The d/I ITt states that inthe long run the project t.3hopla help to preserve wildlife values of the sita, ecaase the proposed PA -C would bind the land owners 'LO art1gx-'•"emen't to retain undeveloped portions of the property as, a w:ldii.170 refuge:. some impact would occur as a result of the project and during the remaining extraction activities' The report also says domestic pets could adversely a4f-edt the local wildlife populations acid increase exposure to zoonotic diseases such as rabies. As a mi.tigatIng measure. to -the latter problem the d/,UTA says all pets should be confined to the homesi.te when unattended. hogs and cats should be vaccinated against rabies and distemper. The issues raised are real, but the solutions are fictional.. The report completely fails to mention the potential impact of the proposed project on the fisheries especially the salmon that spawn in Butte Creek. These resources have been declining over the years. This decline is partially attrib- uted to Butte Creek Rocks' (Baldwin Contracting Co.) Policy of extracting materials Without providing safeguards for protection of fisheries and their habitats. There are a number of holding ponds where salmon resido during certain periods of the year adjacent to the subject property, tat will be disturbed. Conolusioris Wei, tried to address the issues raised ,n the report but the most important issues such as Water quantity/duality, fire P rotection flooding,traffics and police protection p were not ade uatel addrssed. The sole responsibility for the adequacy of the report lies with the developer and its engineer. The sole agonoy capable of correcting the deficiencies ih the report is the county. The county should compel the developot to remedy these deficiencies within a specified period of time, and if not so remedied, the county should deny certification of the EIA and disapprove the project. { .0 . terryAyAW%'P)KP'��w;�ti�IX �Ay�` ygr�yy *GB�GUVa}UII.t1..1.1 .[�.:�S.11J.C,.�f,L'.la.:kl ! q j dM����+.� 4 4�r w7« �? CCi. yykyy. tCC:t.+y- �1r CVy Wd e.7 iJ. iL[��,r,L.ou 44 w7�M G+�Ic`k�+ w't �.k, .l. SS.F ItL,a,�.ty dv�/ G: ��.liie L.J.h.7.., f�.�.t la 5 7 4 tion ar�rUses: Animal, husbanr , Xorestr , Ireton se an��al ut�es occupa a.ons, zna x n, 3 outdoor recrea��ion 4 � 5 hom:c 6 3 favi . sen�rata.on activa'bloo, airports u` Vis, e va.ronms Eal. public PrO- 7 i Q' aacl qu si�ri'ublic group quarters, Ogre homes axedsientslr�dgin a s, 11 Site Desimation Criteria; 12 13 l.. :beyond senic,e arses of commutlty Water dnd so than 3 Zjeo% dopes, 14 15 i g 3. Adjacent or near to e`i.stiri� roads and ptxbl.�,a utilities. Not; wj th n fl ood plaits oxo Imotd-a. 14. 16.. active �aul,'ts� Pa8t 6Mcial actions, 15 17 13 ntensa.ty o,_;_Use: Minimum parcel. size bt one to for l6 sa.ngJ,e�-family dwelling per Parcel. ages.. One' 17 19 �0' other uses and setbacl�s re l.a�ed tq�x�ainta�uprttralschXaVA animal b, 18 g atter. 21 22 cn,��ten�t 7 odes .A."20 , A -40 i 'TM -20 , W11-40 , PR"20 VR�-� 0 b'& C ' 1� 20 24 , , , Conditionall pons stent hones: A�•5, A"110 TM -,1 �, - FR to �R1 �. 2 21 -bhrtx 25 .if - , & pAWC, subject to pindin.�y!O' , , Z5 24 with cond�.t, o�;al Zoning anc� Devel,opmen-b criteri�� l��st�� below., 2 25 Crond3,tior�al Zoning and Devel.otment Crite . 1. Comjae l� bler._.Wi With 2,� 26;. 29 ei;hbor�. agricultural activities 2: Evidence cf adequate water anal setrtago dioposalr aapaoit-Y. 3. Availabili �` 27 �3n . 1 q ti of adequate fire protection �acl.it�:es. 4, Adequately mail tain6d approved road access th 29 50 32, to service area, �v� st�f� �c� e�� c�paci �5 33 34 Accessibility to commercial services xi, and schoolIs .'� ,�8 . Zoning, E.antors `j 5 y 34 36 7 y �� �ng parcel sues and residential. cl�tris�:ta.es� 2 Slope & 35: 38 3g 3. Soil conditions and jgater avai�.i.abil� ty 4 x''fects on adjacent uses, 6 �7 37 4j 41 . �y l.i crop rodUctio, vestocl� gratin;, forestry, resources eattractiohl pan.d 1rtild�l.i o .habitat 1vwd.mxty to a•J 3� 42 pu`bl.a.c roads, and othKir 5 ..r public facila ties' Distance from airporto, railtoads and industrial 4 41 4S 44 U.ssa 74 2-Xi8ting Utilities and c_rainage facilities. 8, paten a,al. �' � �2 �5 � �F - .. Or' Sti�rface C���dc�f1.T]. l:,an.dsl dea ate+ -, , ti. , e:000' on g� ,,� � d_ r i to �* �='..I J'CU� Oil nr�ise+� tra�fic ��'+�fi'AI and a�`aT.�e�'- r 'i.7 L 45 44 46 47 i �� vu, q�.dWw� r qua y-- a.%z 4 ty V-Udlxfe ha` itat and gox eraZ ezivtrot total quala+ty. to local desa.res� �,� 5 45 11= 1'oten.t'al. for pest 41 6 4 7 49 � 4 ,5 40 51 �z 55 54 56 55 56 low _ APPENDIx o 14 + EVENTS 1N Z C140RY ail rj.*2 zQNjNc; OV 11 ,419 C itUK CANYON, Aan-FobNeed 1. 7$ for some kind of Zoning noted by group off' Canyon tesi.t. %tto, Beginning OZ Wo'Ok on Poothill, land Under guidance of Planning DOpaartMent. Ea�ar 75 I'Oloet in s held in Can on bet.,+ L-erj pTann, nq be aartrrorit sta�� and � to receirre: a.ttI Ut on post.-able zcin3,n prod rtaal Vail 75 County lahfting stal.r prepar0s voOding proposal for, canyon. Ott t�iH-2 r Ag icuXturalw5,1C, 20, 40, aand 160 axore mi'mcmuttt.. man 1576 Itearitig at Pl.aniiinq Commis8iOn 16VOI on this propo al which 'ras turned down by canyon rosidexlt: bOcauL a it c`l�.10tl dd duplo,tes 4 / other and a pa Mm�nt buildings, and �. . 44 `iM 1`/h�.ch ��ou�.d harria resulted "in heavily impacted areas, ospociall.y along the edges Of butte Cxee3 . In addI 3.6h there was as recdOited need for a provision for omaall home businesses in the oanyono which none of t zoning'classifications Cheri oCounty books ri for, which and �:rovi4ed man canyon residents depend on xar pt:3 maor r y secondary ixicome. ►>an 76 Decd sion turned over' to Supervisors who give it back to Planning Dept and thegroutp off` poople that had gotten; in the ioftihq quostioan4 This group of approximately 2u original memborot begins the task of p:repating a zoh�nq proposal that'Oduid saatis�y the Majority Of canyon. residents and includa the bh-bite area orioihally. to proposed, maairitaiA the integrity of tt- o, canyon as a Whole. ,A *tell survey and other preiiminary studies are Undertaaken, %!aan 76 The sttpervj8ot8 pass an interim -a zone eo,r the entire proposed oriing i-area as a result of Potilbionso letters, and hoarings which 'Indicated the need to repjaXcethe .A_2 olassi_. atatiOh eeb 76 for the canyon area Until perhilanent zoniticg coiiid be: affeCte ttesearch continued on 'ooth ],� eorea t�:ona i. lana use Claaaifioa t on, Thrc►ugh a series Of Moot i nqs in the spring of 76 vith the Planning Dept stafto Plannillg birector, the Supet±Visor for the area, planning Commissioner* PG&E, legal representative tar Butte Creek 1Rock> as�well a s meetings of Canyon residents a C entervxl.�.et p the ro osed hand u0b plan ca�m� into its resent foehi The p� afthi;hq staaft rev . e _ op r ... s d the draft, on, t'uto deb 76 �s.e�.arate Odda scone befotothe zonzh cl.assi:f .cation a�aat+xofied all dohoerhedo At the sattlo tlimeb too 261 q.. map Maas at�tier''t%sec tt� reCe ire pr'olima.naary imput from resf dens on the zohihj map boundakies'j This mi�p basically reficcted tnit iihos djeallvn for the oridinaa county proposaalb hbWoVor jletkSonablei change: requosbod by-iaandW. own rs Mere ra �• Lttiotl odi g grated, ata >aa 5ta:or�, the court from the zona.n` reap, and a acre tonecWa�o...r or . . inxn' a�,nyon fld�or was er rldrtah establa.Shod, inbehdod to hold .futh parCe] ing until;. hard tray 086 available to assess is paarubs of higher Lotti 76 Proposal g - 't'hes�'o the iia land Uselftnoa the a on ti. pita are C rICU' : t ` g,. ti ed in the eaanyon and p6b tichs are col.l.est e `. �d l;rld�.cati.ng t;tappc�rt; of 70% by acreage l L as per County bkd harices j j 709 of the px iv a be Owned land in the Canyon dVftod by those Vito had 8igftodl in, 9upVbtb of the goninq ptoposa.l,. xf C'S bovt. (bapt o& $ ) and n V= l.a ftds wore 1hdludod i ('they are exempt froa7# zor�iiig by ].>aw) support was estaabl.�.s�tec� at 61;%fi SuM.mer it i nd body that, there aaro ax corltiddrj lumber OE ;res det'it a bio Vail 76 �.� in the middle Eta ijyon arch wha were eo-yutst ,n parcolS than the 3 acre Minimum of th.e, �td hffti f proposal of that bitooi. As a xeoul't: ` marwY TO-1eb.inga ViOl th nWUP and tr,ho z hfng Cc�kt�hiitxt~ccr the PrOObAt comproi iso o tare Jett'-2 2cnt? WA43 creat:od Thr the � s�p1��c��t�;m�bo�Y' ��� �c�`er� �� the cor�%�.,� of t»'hc zoning e rcsujt o,e t~hene rao c� . ttr on: we etx to bo eaS011able i4 Olah t~hc impact,to to tahe Uroa would nota bo trteuwrably moxo than at; pronentr nna t�6 atr tho of t.ho aromi Doc 76 The "'crying propaqut in .J,bq :CIna� �Qz� along with the formal, poi 'h' onb are $Ubmi,ttrqsd to P1enninq Dept: Olcng with bovdrexl. hundred: f- donate adh duled to 4uppoxh vari du buroaucrat le ddb 77 �cttcr aubm tit odili,t:t k� etyn nr Cdrtutil s ra rt quontiirwg. that t:hi tj g .. � petit t ons (0-0110ctaed the summer blufore did ori xr�it+ie�ed �c�rt3:n �`z�r �t+trt p� � � � 't'h o�.r' k� anig CornMi-M do Passed thea tequc � on to ty tah n �.r�ne. he present PlahlAn:. Cr Mme S oris hoVever phis it on' vai�j Ovidoht l 8uv .. e 77 The geed Zot tin gj,��s and,Vorkbeins , do the re b tr cnk thea nre Ou b PtObba h _ ctor SO and str�keout+line t~ount~. the t✓�� t��:a�ectrcr lybi- and Work beglrts by a cottimltrt:oe oz canyon keslaeratra and and'dimo two da~axotw this dccumohbi This trho. titkdh that a $100 0000 OePOsity VdUld have bdeh requ4r,cd E6,t enY Vork ORpdct dd 04 trhe 9tR ntip.Irt mon or 160al ct� 3.ne tr . doInfia+actre,d :662this purpbgtr d 77, The tfft is iubftjjt~t~ed in tz'te:'t~ as, a�ut*�� �otxn�� �nc� c���. �e� y q hpr 78 vin4i EIR. Rearm a schedulod at Plat'hift comm � + o rx �nvit6lnmdnt t! Oualib �cha aye CoUnenta�, i BOARD OV OUPI latoom; �iirxlrr��rn �Irw$war� paid �� hhowldd' 6 Of tFre labor that a qO$ into titos reaes� presrSlci1 suggasted that 1 fhesa irrdrr�id�uls wtrrifee� d'1{�ert ty xari'tn they! tau Id apply to ISI rrir�l; aliiml sf'aa (dr'?J madho orAd, Iridl i�lur l taa� SbONI's6f Mod,adf, (61f tura 110d.rd sh6uid 66 1ulted by tlia majority, rxf fhLs aple w d the PIc;rrr AO eed� to �a a �irid t�, ti,e i�tpllrr���talr�ri - fl,�t fhls rt�zc�tiI could hot result In .ddvor$6, tfsu Fcridln�s t+� by irtrrlud�d rrittitit�! duf' Ott taatlen of supdMstJe Ldmk y seaaridedortt�by Suj��rv�ser Medt�et� Arid rrarrlecl,�, Iai��tt d befwe � "Wu��u�a Rodd �ri�t�uttb"i�'r��reat,arr�t�va eare ;�ar`rwu'N�� 1'er �rarty� �. � rr p it, y Y I: �y.. w rertlr►� II�y�,�r Load, aet�f�iirlrn i y ��d f� � �"�a?ei tllrea i�irles �r rra �� 60 rrrcres roarer i r1e�e ruri 'f }� p - a rax"faf� ayes Lill, e��k �r� ��r��� +'1 r -� "I i' 1 � '� � � t�' trod "FR-160'k da}iiiii w r*t atia irri , Iflt 26JL 46 wd I60 adr`e: drewis) praW. the Butte geek Cnri ari from' skyway rrar`tFr fa a prastl tatelY irtries r�arlii eF tleilf �►�r was approved: tis w6mrtflu by I Irar rriri cdolhitsOr m w4h f11 i"ir►dir tlr t it Is riststaryt with f�i erierel pl'am ideld flat. the dev laprrr rrf t6f aat d a ear ruby result m adversd etfer«fq fhd `(e110WI ig 6rdiftJoi edt weed. ad'epfed 66d the Chalrmwi aufliartzed to Ogg; acrd tl of Me M4ielpyls pdrael delated ear,siderdd ds a' [aseurce ares. )rdrr~art a 1940 thi'orri A-2' fa "'P�L�" rr 1941 w p zr e fe " PR--r 104 wa+e to 104J t'a OrIJ-2-0,,, 1944 carie fa "PR-40 it r i 1945 rune fd "M460 I" A1�i aj ry rs LeM61 J1�tit�ligtrri, dh8 Ckdtifrrrbh W1606n N68-S: 886ptNfs6rs W- 96 ley °rr 'ter q i Y` i ZONINO ORDINANCE sp-ON it,to3np" anis ' " bit' this; d140���t �n and, � � lvov, lo bo do o w n, r u di� ldki - a p, 40dti ,. td, malvitalti a atmodh6t§, and jjrslabdArda- �� n di th of n ardu and rem: quiromahtit bot tart}lot Aresc horai'n with ► : tc mbnimum a n cWald pdrwf ttl. . 4. form of 61obditld b' domm nr. ` tWL Y W duato aniV00 bY, th'Li tawru" an d6ntil .00' :%anis' d6r Ag df ti t 0 of thig dedifiaho mti 1�rnd gai dAtgo, and i s y Fath Wd s i and ht6ga j kdi§pjng4 vaisal anti` pa-dtiwi s �Ok Pndv�,d6d thAti�mt all. ' ana; a iso on: ate k6pt pedmij§69 f a Pot dAdh hovae.. Ot hts cj tt1 OVOW and (4 ) y6dr. �� tht�tsx� bneunz�s agtudofk:* t. v r �y ,w i i .bo Por itach ll y9 k Ew l: ff'i lA. R�YRF '�T ' W At ytp7,4d Pwe y" ON, For O "w rw 4nd f6a Dillplay and" salt),, � a. t oh,:; ` hot lfidjud1bg NOT'moria i"„i land U- do; alf 8' .0,4011trilkhk fang l y tmlldo rY :broad, md Wi 2 )' Aid pato aalaup tuft'd 1041b dddupaltlatij tit A, 6 dr eftidos Oft tho prajjj6 bs Not fttd than dile kddlttaf t may v a a df, o the Pit- xbe- lifaftdd is tdbnaiilohtde�ra ft Bari `es t be �_ , , ,..;,,. ` two prgo apaden, Ift,, 9-'#�1�a�l4 ki WM'U.4aW ksa�l.:k t.�CarR.x ltE l'k'. 31` In any, rc4uirc,,.,jA tititly " pOrtlitted Pho� `,muniulmf tol IN, MH OWL Ohl, #xqftv4,tJ MOO duat*- brightm1olit bo Objoat o +Odorsb atdh ,or dfttVti#�o� d '. • kenijib M,,,tojj:o bite; lid"t U00 Own fivd: It �amil boat a. dampg : w .public find qual'i-Ptiblio uaoft Itia r Jt ]fba- for a 110t rG c por ribi gal, fiat b ld thy, Lott frog- ++ a tie `sJ t{S• I k' it �y1 S c k�+l i 1+t1 u* �Ci c l i [I °! (5 rot ill thd, defitdelift4 bf h � �„ r p o. x eui Pod 6pa Aid' toemlidAicr Rb A4 the 6116MO-114.0 6-f "I'd dd x; Al + 7 l AW V. wtt: :.V .v.l lalet'k n4.. .ar ::_., ,'•, ,.r .l.:a.. ::� . v=a+ .,+• y .�,�. ... �!t ! JIu + �E'�V��'�"�s �.n M+Y..� v .e •+ i� Th b a l o, ul ationa, 11 Mae 41 brava mirwo voopIng widlfig, " al Oft ,An for ,61 u4ef, Is " f y aria l A finlit was# and fro s i' 1 . W 4wAg,. 4q 1.aV {Rall lbo Matot Tfieyt "emi al yl/ 14 or kopto oa tho promigdt, r I, 17! FI ���� 1MT.Y }.�' �1�]r M. :M V✓� ���M � '4� 'M�LY X�I�� �W'. I�'i 17 'fi drod, * 01U ",4ttaw. lob,* i I� y�; 4Wh'.wotil'"aa , a 4 if :Li. W �' ��� iwM �lr,� � F 'i✓•Mb Y+��.y. �� �'YIW � �� 9ir1�V' � r f y3r, k p'w .A 'Y.Slifig 4:..FG prk 'h XLY 1 w V t+T. r:Wt 4sl ,ih 'S i. M' ",yid llty r;.�'�+'Mi # I 3� �y ���ir �Nj t'OW';I'y�. ya.y�y 444 ;a. Y aa, � A , , `i P�M1 Tr tgoK#r '1 'flf��([' .J �T"5�,1�k'Yn�M {ty4um,y,j,1' (.� Iwad Halted II i o u wa nA ;i. 9 - ar arts fma otaftow WT40"t, 14 t1to pifvalor�,& Ali thofiid, bAtIons dall b tti.bpat t1b tip flo"n.6, o ' lfbau A itOtlo Iib# Ahd � „ P _ i jg rte+. Fi' 4 VAS: , Whowl, ii�:r��i. f' 'd' k]W� le dd y d+, yg„ Jy rm para., da bj „L ., k� 161 s dr ' & &ftpgdaC "for"forV,-ijt'i' i� f wonvi.ad 6111t � If 22' not be located in any xequ ,red yaxd a 2 8• Accessory uses and buil.diftgs custatnaxy and pertinent to PGtmitte�d uses, !including guest ha ses, barns, 4 shops, garages, and storagaa axons. S (B) TIM VOLS OWING USES SUBJECT TO 5ECUIRING A USE P8RMZT 0 IN EACH CASE, 7 1I01n6 occupations, mining, and excavatjn" which 8 might be objectionable because of noise, odor,, smoke, dist, .'briEhto light j vibration, polltIt', 10 traff4,-c cotgestion, wrisi.ghtzy storage a- eas, matemr- 11 ills or equipment,, the 1►andling of explosives or 12 da119er611s materia s, or tlie storage 0f -one hinidxed. 73 1013 or'-moxe galons of inflammable fl.iz3.ds. 14 2. Commercial kennels and animal hospitals on sites 1.5 not less tx.w, .1 fig (5) acres. 1.6 3. Private or commercial outdoor recreatioAai; =acili- 17 ti-J5 On sites not less than fiv (5) acres, L-i- is clutling but not is tL,ol �c;.. tisnsr racy°satori- 19 al chaos, riding acaa:emies and stables, hunting 20 :` 0,19es and cawps, boat ramps, and campgrounds, i' 21 4. Public and quasi"public uses b1cli3cI�n sci?ools, 2 parks, tjSeUns, reeti.ng halls, lib•rar-es »iizd {3 �ove,�;7rteri�: r�cfices 24 w . 25 25 t, . 23 1 .,) Lot Area . - 2 Miriiinum required area for a lot. Per reside'Atial 3 dwelling unit shall not be less than five (5) acres for 5 (D) Lot Width: s Mini m I SECTION S, The penalties fog tl�a via�at%nrr of the 2 �, im os hrrdb n Zoniny impo$04 within, the district shall be as pr ovidecl in 5 the Butte county Cade, cltapte'ir 24, this brdinante shall, £rom and afterits ex5 ".ective data become a supplement to and part Of the' 5 Butte Coun4y Gode,. Chapter 24. 6 SECTION 6, This Orctinancd shall be and it is hereby 7 declared to be xn full force and effect from and after thirty (30) 8 days rafter tie, data of its Passage, and bafaxe the axp.iration o£ 9 fifteen 15 d.4 s after its � „ t � Y pu�saye this Ordinance shall be ' 10 purlished once with the tames of the members of the Board of 11 8uperyisors voting fax and against it in the Ch,, cb Efttorprisej n 12 er hews a s a newspaper published xn tit„ County of Butte, State of'. California. 13 PASSED AND ADOPTED by'the Board of S!:pexviso a s of the lh County of B'u4'to, Stateof C'a1if6rnia, an the 27tn day 'of .7tute, 15 1978, bu the following voto: 16 AYES. Supervisors Lemke, Mt digon,, - A. " d' Chairman Winshon 1: NOESSupot✓isors Moseley a d Richer 18 ABSENT; None' 19 NpT VOTING; None 20 21 � 22 AOM tT A� INSTO, Chairman . n Buttue County i3aard a.4 Stt t -visors 23 A't°T'DS ' CLAPK A, TIrLBpN, County Clerk 94 and Vic~of-ricie Me -JR, of the uI)dard 25 28 Cl br: or ioputy �rdh 'MtlRlYVl(dWdtlAnlvYpLi Y:.i.�':�.uaL'i�fh�1l�Pii6'SWa1.4RaaAeasci..ar...�:_'' f, t. + : r � • :r, " + ..+r 4Vw.�i i titc�t �w , JA r f x�1. .rw r r .'.. r a aY+r • ,. +�. , x . r . s. ° .Y ,", " ' • i °Wv. 3 ' k«tr'rx 'Y br"," " { t . r 0.. + w , . t+ h .r 5,. " r�=t ♦�'. F rr;. r �i 5'�4 Yi"'+ � '„+"'i � U ! ,M' s” � i •i w rr � yr '," 'yY Mr 4 d �"' • tl+v a. ",. r *,=`i ,r.N Y +r Y �y wW�' t" ,'.n+. i *a�°r_ " �N�T Y +r' 'Y YN ��;�,yn y, «, n_. ..., n x�. yYYJ ri 4 .. t✓'+ Ra, . j� d r r « t"' Y �+:e wt `i,. r"v r. d�, 1 • _p r " C.1 =Y r. + �i+•i}4,i = W.. r ..•F".�� Y,p ''h i"n '., d "t`.Y i«r t �,,+, i x x • rl r i♦"*'" � h' ter.. .. rp � ti 1r j �>r�.+' t � F • 4.a 0. . •,� _ + r Y"�, 4 k 4 t.=.. a Al, 1 « r • ti ' �'� Y itY � i +i+�t. +�rp March 1(��1t1 y t �.7 l :f.'i '�' ,, s%'i h Y �.', ✓ 1 rr••�5. , r 4 M .. t'L•N:�. ,4�"` w�S .. VJ� F '.i Y f " ,. `} " r x.'C r "Y � ` «.r "a � xd •t = l � �",� � I ." 6 »"" r ' ''lx ! �."� '� Wj7 "�. �yWry = / . � it • L� � ..YCti r " °` w ,x r r t r ",! 1 i `g n ,aL. t ,+ w c td �• ��ra }" a,r+ " a ," , Ir � ,� ,w=o r �,, is ,� y rj rY � w. ,=4. syr = �t� ': � 7 x Li 4., -B 4" .... ar�cw i. iM k rj' t into s •r t t%" �a Yr"r "r t '+ r*t �• 2 t =3Y yYi�f +Ytw " ";+ rt +- kiwi (� M s L +ry~�:7y� bn 4 Y•° pt. F sting r )67 � d and. Yuba:" r` �, p7 l� "rr,t ' •l + •t y MarysvzZZey ,Ca 959ol"" Sa _ * • '" " k� Y� * �'+x�`w+, . " zone " • u , t r,Jlx 'Fw ,•• ""L �� t: t : ,i 4h w•.. r ,;' - 'Y , y� Y" " 1 Y'r r �'.�'.'.' , Y, �rA,,,�r',+ ♦ �, . This z , . cation CD4`rezone,. have rE?G�xbBt 4i I M F -is r a rezone. that h yd hots; K n ram Ur ppb ` .w Parcels) "FA Mfr. FFootFi� X1 Recreational t parse tox (planned, r ty IDCat&d Ax'�ia cl-usteroro",•", l �. appxox�mate 2 . , o, `Roa.d and Skyj4a-I iri%atseGty � 00 �eaC;sduth�,��t a£ 1uiirbti t d -$1,3) 4�i.�.,58.:5b 40 �x'��p Q�°n��adert��faed Fie, Al�'`s 4Q=4Z-Zfi �r`' ~ r i ..r Ch ca ' . �..r �•, "� 5 ' rid 4d� 7 y " 1 =� ,�• Y t .." 'syr w.. ✓'rµ x''ya 4 ' « rjµ J portion..p" til t r . r�rM� i•/� �l', n . �Y 4. r . 5 `, '`!Y. v y* t" t '.t'•{ Yh 1Y s `• � ! , II �: PI j ll ",moi �j' ". LM � `. .l �yfY. s'.�.`� i•Y Y ^ �, .s t it r • C +n A. r, � 1 Y. ! , ' •iw" �y �7; i x , �1 rl iQY �'"yCi r•`rti heduld Public v "r i • enuuth a�ronmentaZ a"terfiariatanng�enat srocel�ne as the w i o Ice, a ed` yy th's .: f•a j=t ='.1 1. 'T° � +.• Y 'pY 1f '. f a .r Y^ ♦ .3 �• • ` M t ! tt v , r. '�pi.©aSe "Y n ro ' Z75 nclosed�. ecaapt:�, asbt -4�; a Jaz r..Y r y „� . ao , x ww , yo aPPI'" oat zo ' .. � (I S 's"F� i j rR' s r., } :Ft n d#••ij J vt t r ... r r s • , Vi,�.• s ��* .. r �i v{y„ " m ry r 4 � MN•+. � � }t 4Ya Y •3 �«" YY y�� ri r " Y� ` .r+; Y` r +.x '`i�, r r " ��� ,� iR s•x+« * n..: �'� .l r.,i Bettye Big. B8 t.�r• zx eotar of Planri' jr tne n .. . J• �~4 f. l t rri�1 k r,.,• -q ' ''did_,. � Poww..•,_. - � � ' Y .d IMY +r r ,+Y. r. 1 .. ..e_ rr, Ys'Lur •a�"hY .. :Y! n 26 ,., J. • .S;.N r."'1. :4 V.L,..' 4:114« 001 No • .(✓ I//y p T www 2. location..kAOrt-11 Plan Dosig-oa�ion,., .1 4L Zbn As the applicant Zop tho p0quo ;ted r�:�oz�' rad; x�o.�`orro� on Lino 41 the :Vol bion:�ha�p hot+,•coon the �,ul��o Court�,y Deno a . P�.a.n and Illy iOZC)njng Ioqut has been 041a1 rted to me by the tmd.or;3a geed plarmitg 8tatP momboro Cti tanking this : cozoniri8 tipplic,-Itioll s X am atmoo that the zoluo x atu roc �o �itrK; �io�.o coh'torm to tho Butte oo=n Ooneva l `lam �1%'•�=�j._� �` '�' y,, •» r.rl�ict tLt '� u Rd Gcr rl Ing c3Mr,1. L ,y it rJravi�i�� CaCi;orrtf� u 1 erd ( tet �. 1y .� . - �• w ",,_ '� {41 t 7 Y r t+A:rlrli wfw Yn 4k.wiYr Y l M r Y w x' , M APP w q R .v i,�A ♦jay �+ �y,lyay� y, '. �rY1M.Y• K«M+'. �/ l W' i i tL ,4 4' 4 a &0 Mid'wi n Caotxarting CoMpi1ny, Ind. O L t+-hd'yUt i, °� w' a /« �.xetaa«r.e:•-1i. Re.'hx '�..:a�Yy a: Butt& Crta6k gAst PA. au�d3.�v3�ciott y tiz depOL taut isji.§ ravidWed t1id tont t ti'bo subdivigion W41A, 106'tAuttd ctdak nett PAC., lid r0b6tb6rtd thO fOII't;Wih9 itif0tiAtiott abd/ot ddUL h'd ptovidddtha prior t e W V adle.Ato Ott t,1t$ �«+ lt�%Ili vO Mljl 0.11 j)X'6tMdA V tdlo UAd titd Adobo add sdwagd digpotdl tdtwbaok datdmeittt, ����" ► 2 providd d4a On dc"Ve"l ptbeytt of it puhlio water .tygti�w to pro'V` dd dotogtid water to t IO atibd Vil' ib i, So Nid` idd data on f6tTatitzori df t: sower Md tntdhbLhdd daitttkt' to zaiflta-n the, sewer 1ittd� "dj PUMP. �ttjtiort to the ptopb.4ad sc�� dobtain ofoetdAdd bat tile C4 6to:enid 5tcLtO jk6gi z i aytttcr q it Cdntxal drd ir,duAttg approvhll of tpdcitia pzbpot'00- to pvdt�s tuiderpound writer iic1 gutta Crook 'tbla NOWA& Owntt±.tiblitiort 5 p oVida rdi oiktiah 4dgt dtitut atrtd aiX pth t is dor the pra a dd e e ditpb;ml 6dhtitgg 6, PtdVidd data bit mdth6dA 'b edittebiliri snasnt�itc►�s'' xti t�ti prb ' ptS�� +por�d� t�z►c� i��ea i` itidiGrttet wi tiro tolta-LIud map drttit ogd 6Astb; oats iia to i Iit�d t e 3 SUIVECT Do, t�. P r$On rrttOt*V1,eviedJob � M Agency: genWyt Wreleohon+4+'= Na...�=µ-'wy.:: # � Tor ---"---. �+--...sc..�._,,:�uc k ��'... 4l Yt �.1a�1 ,y�4�,1r 'GIW t� �y ,µ.��y �,tyy y �µ j —..,,•—.�_pg.,,}� � yso� �, ; Yp A4A spa _. �.�' �y iiiyyy�� �,.G,l►1� ��yY,.,i�ly�:.�.�_:�i��t��t�� :��iE�L'�1 ������� ����',. W�(,�,�� OMIS quo Ltdd,�.��w -thin 1icii�tti w u i MO C� .BEQLD '" Wd wAhit ddb*09 &P ill tho ipf' d ati6h, - y LL LP -P �� ��UL LAIR ' -MM Wt LAL r P1���7 - xhd fdithd cb rye,€ -L6 �brr that to tit geo4hd watexbag 1j -» Person Interviewed".. Referred TOIII INA y had bet'n, r-su mi -ed t dat y ..,.�•+-^---�w..>,t....�........�., ,yam � :-.. �r OIa..` 19, MOM V60 U o T It, body oopio of the iftfOrmdUdh Otbmittod on both ted gdtef gupxply "_ PO--TLitt- itIV&s, g1�,,y[p{g ry�y ' Mi 'yc �L�I Mian. ,�Yr Ult 111 GW ' 1100"'wro yAgency Floor . s g and DOW.) NOV t'lovironnPatall pc�vte.j4 13. p conter, Dries On I � , 95966 .yy..' -- .1,`gyp' '1yp� a 32 NIM Not, Nut 4 ;old KOO 40076 0hlkf", UM OM SI PAC OM t1n,*, CII j q i' j bj , * MAR, 2 q.UAIitY' ROW tfeek and 1 t �A properly pd to vtoucted, ad f to but suffickht }Infort4itiion wll. , not Ifw fudfidf" til* qmft WO WNMaefld thAt t ,15 r1a not hi- w9roved until On, it ddMOWLYetafle io that Butte County hod"Ith Crepla;t=.30 and 0- wcan theft, makol tpotfl mm"Oh' N If phyM-t I i i t l5fig'. a f st that wftfi mnoly d wfth the preposp3d epoalrfteerfn o .:, aw e to a � � yy y� f. �� �J.�$" a ���$r ,`„N>��'” Y'�;� ���'Y:�����"w ��'�,M'"" ,��'iM' �� �"�"�%�; � of ,w %t d4 jar i 6m an nutlipel Of ba On"tDpe icas flea votpli&4(t to this Utter to e e Areal tfigi or R k is t hOme t cutte County HnIth �v . t Itcalift a F. t lqw Cfalo%, cat, t� do Calirwhi* �t ay y� y�}, y j q ,�y �V yg� {� ��i ryes ,.�,}� �g s7 !' r��t,�y����,,��tfdl ���,�,��+r�� T.� pp qµ. Wt' �Ak y„� �q'�d�m tid, Aly��,v y'�,F$fi, I14ta�.LJwM oviogYJgi 4vi'tg. �o7y ��,ey��ay�y��y CT i'+y«y'A,yi�yaiIl�ji. ��Ma'�JL I�� dt, the, 4.�Y:.A'[.Y d, i ��k a4L'L, ".to liko .i411md X.w Ciha oJ0. .l C',+ a � �»'7�itim Al, +cw$�;�'r X41 WP * �pt63v y�o t��k� 0 +k. G,.� T; O gR4Y�.uO kY���,aC: (viA r'Y,+Y.1d ffts., X110" 4 S Not of t is oulmdd, W6 Vill W, oMila td 6v�fda 1, II vd otplot ' out CMIND C ARS P EMM;. low tmu"' ,110, 1914 Al oak m Win= t1m, M 9599 VAPISED OUTS MTR AM a Is VAT MAMIUMmi CUM WIN y"ul thWTO= of wasto Owbargs 01M f fb°, MOM(cto 9p O the oo ON anC011forold Met WO ba A W arg wlma lux' -m-kv '.V, V"A.-tor '11e, ru t tt w wavidew MR p o pqwn thalt MWWF l array new 101 "64.Y,SP OW MIND a'F.Implo���d t�"„f�K.�7�ka 4".f L'�k�$�l°..� 9E.�'AS �.i'�%��1: �.,p �'�i 'k.t`��� e1e 10401VOY, WAY" 1010d are. In) W MMUMS filing CO StOW171, as Jl b1ti hpn�t ot jal the, piled, along with thm applicapi; Min IE6mire encs for you ipchirry, Ina—ma.mm we to C SSW t :'Ald'a al 4 proMi'chl OV tho callforolm Invireovental quality W ow t.�A-L' u Inforc.w.It OA and IM H1181 MA Wald 60 cublit tea% -V' dif"d withim . fran W3 of W ve t r' leafs �r~ ntnt o dt (916 y6j have any qu stim. -a Wines. UU lots ta'rlT*+a."j