Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout80-122A UPPER RIDGE & LIME SADDLE GPA (2)r P LA a ITEM ON WHICH A DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT HAS BEEN PREPARED Notice is hereby given by the Butte County Planning Commission that public hearings will be held on Wednesday, June 17, 1981 a'-7:30 P.m., in the Board of ,Supervisors' Room, Butte County dminis,jration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, Cali- fornia, regarding the following. - Butte oalowingButte County Planning Commisslora, Upper Paradise Ridgy Amendment t o the Land. Use Element Ma o f the ButteCounty T p o unto General Plan for proper-uy generally des ;gibed as beingthe Upper Paradise Ridge located north of l-aradise, South of Toadtown and Stirling City, we,�t of Sawmill Pe .� � Peak andtho wr�,at branch off.' the Feather River ana east oft e h Bute Creed Canyon, containing 30 square miles, more or less. General Play. designa- tions to be considered are . Graz,�_n and Open Land T1 m oun.tain, gr_icultu•ral Residential -Low Density Residential; Medium Density Residential Commerclul,; and Public. The above mentioned o l.lc �ata�on, ,��' , maps, and draft environ,m,eiiL-al p report aro on file and available J."or public viewing at �.rr��act x�, � � �. .. the, off ice of thc- 8u fte Count-, Planning De artmc�i�a.t Count 7 Center Drive Or � � � . , •,�' _ �, , , y ov lle , Cali Envi' onmental Impact Reports t are also available at collegz, Y couraty li-brariee BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSIO:M r; 'ETrlY J,:.! BLAIR DIRECTOR 010 PLANNING �, II111I1II1IIJIII1111III.III:f�J11Lii_IIIl1,III11I1I111_ -3 � I� I)IILI�III_I1IIlIII(IIIIIIII I I �...S 61 lllche 1,_e`0MPA' MARK LARWOOD NY 4 i NOUN", P LA a ITEM ON WHICH A DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT HAS BEEN PREPARED Notice is hereby given by the Butte County Planning Commission that public hearings will be held on Wednesday, June 17, 1981 a'-7:30 P.m., in the Board of ,Supervisors' Room, Butte County dminis,jration Center, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, Cali- fornia, regarding the following. - Butte oalowingButte County Planning Commisslora, Upper Paradise Ridgy Amendment t o the Land. Use Element Ma o f the ButteCounty T p o unto General Plan for proper-uy generally des ;gibed as beingthe Upper Paradise Ridge located north of l-aradise, South of Toadtown and Stirling City, we,�t of Sawmill Pe .� � Peak andtho wr�,at branch off.' the Feather River ana east oft e h Bute Creed Canyon, containing 30 square miles, more or less. General Play. designa- tions to be considered are . Graz,�_n and Open Land T1 m oun.tain, gr_icultu•ral Residential -Low Density Residential; Medium Density Residential Commerclul,; and Public. The above mentioned o l.lc �ata�on, ,��' , maps, and draft environ,m,eiiL-al p report aro on file and available J."or public viewing at �.rr��act x�, � � �. .. the, off ice of thc- 8u fte Count-, Planning De artmc�i�a.t Count 7 Center Drive Or � � � . , •,�' _ �, , , y ov lle , Cali Envi' onmental Impact Reports t are also available at collegz, Y couraty li-brariee BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSIO:M r; 'ETrlY J,:.! BLAIR DIRECTOR 010 PLANNING �, II111I1II1IIJIII1111III.III:f�J11Lii_IIIl1,III11I1I111_ -3 � I� I)IILI�III_I1IIlIII(IIIIIIII I I �...S 61 lllche 1,_e`0MPA' MARK LARWOOD NY 4 i NOUN", r -• , BUTTE COUNTY PLAT NINE C;f�rU1xSSI0 � `'TApp FINPINCS August 0, 198 C!T]I�I Y't7}a tiJliT(;]i A D.rlT, 10U87,y CEii'i'I]"I:Is1) E['1vJJ T1r03,,t%': f i'ALr 1 But County Planting, Cainttt�.swj.ar Gex rx�aJrt 1'7.zrn �'.merdmenL irout Lb�,� Detzsii;y :Rosidont-iol and Gx�a a,`ut Open Land to Loin ` Dens V]esidofYi i.tl A x a.cult axed;, Pttbla c].c�,fxu� �- � i td i 1 s��• ural. ]�r;5 mt ],la,�UPT) Ou, M.me Gaddy c� Area dont; aticiial tzeaz' Peutz–T,asala.a� ]ii of Paradise. '"�' i z om Kunkle Rorurvoil� to the The p plan forrouact is to recognize purpose of this area, amd to tune deyelo gnize existing development in the ,X:ent in thea. Lime Saddle Water Distr c;t: �'�te existing 'General P1,an DesignRtions were ado"x► the formation of tlic water district. Because of Lhe recent availability 1 in 1971, long hefare of domestac water there is a. potential for development that has not existed, in the past. 'T1 I areas Proposed for commercial designation recog sting commercial uses. The areas to include thexwater district's tank'site, Public . be designated as public the area around,Lake ox,Oviile belonging to the State of California: p ti 01' property, and ne artment o.f Puf�lc tYo;`s,z i'Nono.' Environmental Health: "No objection to General plan lmendtnent meni or Ian vision to meet E'nvi`ronmental Health requirements and the Subdivision Ordihance. d+ Any thvilup,_ b'�F,e'; "PGF,Ti had no obj e„t.ion:, to the R-C; zoning oft that ortio keseriroir lying east of Pentz Hi ]tt��a p n of Kunkle 'portion lying +lest o t Pehtz goad g The PC, ver the request AR"!gH l on that company to dispose of its non untilit � (State) is all on t his that portion of this land l y-hrOperty. Sometime in thegfuture If the zoning, at this time,jxcould�beomadenAftwMHtt �l�,abothy be disposed ofz' company will save a ;gre'at deal of tame►� you and this 4 rrtlifornia,.,State Fir Kiva . patrb'1: t�P rat onn;—, �' - ---_ +�711is project hat no infpact ori (:HF I� i 1'he totrr of .}'Rradise .ia cunceitled frith the offec�b of ,land i�evelopinent in the proa:Lniity al` nru:.•lc�ipal baitruiaries, any land use chxhges that requirb r g the :nu]7icifr�112blidlces ,i-Cds]d�cOha3 P Police and flx�e p Protection; ris well i _r these .factions,. 41e suL�tnzt that any dDV016pmertt of a substantial nat�xre be made poi+� of the Tony as ;a condition a,f a naval aniexed txtd ue auf�gest you amend your genb:ral, plan text to regUireuid in thl s praepss, taking F l ace :he#xr Whivipal boixndt�riee to ntnpYy with th j tv d6vFj dav'elo then atahirrde. W'rj xb,�X xo that i , d Oaunty jand use prupasal b re agntzosr ex sti t. y and laxge dim-I pat ,et hs to°r*., sed and 'We endorse the proposed ,oYuinge;^,,; :Jug r Ut1es'ti� hovevory that ti tem be added tot u ov_dr PrOld'e paliaiea which wild: a"estil.t in the h prtip000d amendment whi ctt rlap anti dltpll cgt bn of public se,—vice fluiotions Tuank dhod of ell uxfdz cthehal opportunity to bat:xnent on this p> opb td1, i Y guy ! i, Inter-Departmental 1�emorandum To Ron Max, Chairman of the Butte County planning Commission Fpom, Planning; tepartment SUDJEcrt Backgrotund of paradise Upper Ridge General: Plan Revision 'File #80-122.A DAM May 27, 198 r The Butte CountyPlannin , Rezone for the Upper proposal for �° Comma.ss�.on anita.ated a proposa a General Plan Amendment and ,ezon_se Ridge area '�;n June, 1580. ,The existing General Plan map was adopted in 1(Y�l as part of the 1971 General Plan. The Land Use Element text was rewritten and, adopted in,1970• She maps of the urbanized areas were riot Changed. Iif;)f the more definite nature of the, new text, the old map ha'. become Unworkable) hence the proposed trap amendment. In most areas the proposed General Plan designatLonIs were chosen an order to recognize and conform to the existing zoning and/or development. in some areas physical liditations snob as excessively steep slopes or inadequate access Mere the dzterminibg factors'. if successful, the General Plan Amendment: will be fol.lowed by, a proposal to rezone the A-2 and A-2 Ltd. areas to conform to the General Flan and existing development, and to `bo. compatb�.e;�ith surrounding deve":tor ooment. In a fecases; rezohl*n i s being pro posed where,the existing zoning is unrealistic.E©» a small lot zone applied to an area of excessive slopes such as ,d canyon, wall.) t r P NNiNG DEPARTMENTS iNTERDcPARTMENTAL REVfEW REOUE Town, of Para li,80 � y *I"�'" EQUES7: Review & Gprnmeat 6f tL,41:�i1.1'G AP NO, . 60—J 22A LYABIML DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT; y APPLICANT. ADDRESS; 2CA OWNER: PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION SCI-IEbULEp RETURN BATE REQUESTED;. ASAP DATE DISTA;t§UTEDs pT'TACHMEN75; ,copy of 6130112020 &;plotplan ETURNEb; COMMENTS See A�,$,gohed Sh®et., t _ , �� i 0 • �4 7i� Aj,�ve tiP fro 011A AESOURCES AGENCY Ed,41UND G. aRUWN 1R, Cor.ono� v-.pr!eiY4UY �^.s!'s: J. a.,�.a.rti4"sissa z.::kilcn!#_t=."':irt�Y.a:Yke'^ ,d`.°,.m's d: .. �rs:"�'.:3:xR`ss7IL:M„sus.�-:`nil'.-�...'.:-'�KL•-1:t�axi'".X. & �'=.•�:•�a=::ar iz::k:•i',Y.�...tt n•.c.1';�wh`,�'Y.:;.�'r�---^r r; DEPATMINT OF FISH AND GAME REOIS�N 2 �'� 1TOi NNW$ ROAD, SUI7t, A 0,4860 COIWOVA, rA lroxNin 9sa711 'Ail Jti1 y ll: j 1980 { Mr. Earl 1), i sOn B�tel hviionmental Review tt LB Count y lntcr. Drive oruvi le, CA 95%5 Dear tit. Nelbotil. I The Department of i s3h and Game has reviewed the General 111an Ammdment f6r paradise Upper Ridge hild Lime Saddle and han the '�olloting t:omtnents# S gills.cant ncieagcs in the DeSabla area are designated i �S YJ.out UralkJ csisicntinl whicli pct-,,.its parcels jitth one sc e uithirhuth6i,. tie recommend Timber Mountan zdnina with 20 acre minimum3 Which wnuid IOtd nccs.trateiy reflect the na'tuYe of thrresoul;ces . Timber mouritaih zoning should provide better protection of ncitural Y'esoutceg inaludiEtg hrt'r►g of epeclaJ. bibiogicat impor,r.hnce which occur within the project area. Ytovigi n Cor the l rotecttnn of resre planta shotlid be ihtludedv particuintly in the Lime- Saddle arca. J•ull devetopfttetlt of those hreah permitting Otho. acre tnlnithwlit3 1 , would ze nt.lt in the lobs ofiho_se species.� w ,Thptii, you for :th6 opportunity to cdmmeht on Olt projects � 9ittc�ely� Wi. Lt 43 deer , issiet,' 11eJ;'ioila`i kis�ttage+ BUTTE COUNTY PLANNIi COMMISSION STAFF FZNIIINCS ltagtist 6, 1.980 C M71M, MOR 111111M A 111REVIOUISLY CrIJITTF1,111,17 CNV IRG.'I,; 'i IiTTI, _ U177; .1, 77t'(?RT ^1:11 17:1i1; U5�'' 7 1. Butto County 21atiiAIIN Cot,,lr iosioia -- 0 --oral; Man, Amendment; flrom tort Donsit and Gvazing & Open Land to Lot, Deri:yity 1esidofttial, Al' ricultural-11oe:i dontial., C'ommolicial and Public l.oc.'Ratod, !]I tho upper Limo O3iddly Area al:otig and real: x'exztu-Plt; �. aIia' 1Ht rvoui li,unklo. Re:tervoia." to the 'fo:vn of Paradise. ' The purpose of this project is to recognize existing development in the area, amd to plan for future develop.;ent in the time Saddle Water District. The existing' General. Plan Designations were adopted in 1971, long before the formation of the eater disti:ict. Because of the recent availability of domestic water there is a potential for developntent that has not exi.stet in the past. The areas proposed for commercial designation recognize ejtisun-g commercial uses. The areas to be designated'as public incltidethe water district's tank site, public utility property, and the area around La}ce.Oroville belonging to the State of California. Department of Puhlic"-forks; "Mono.'' r , i Any de mentrorm�andldi�asaon " toomeetetnvaronmeritalrHealth ZemnUiremen'ts and the develop, Subdivision Otdinancd.it PCR}:; "PGe1i ltad no objection to the RLC zoning on that portion of Kunkle e;servo_i,r- lying east of 'Peutz kightvay, ho'Never tie reiiUest AR-NtH-1 on that portion lying, ire. tt of Pentz Road The C.P:U.C. (Stat,d) is allowing this company to dispose of its non-Uttility propertyyi Sometime in the future that portion of this land lying west of Pentz Highway may be disposed of. if the zont'tig, tit' this time, could be made AR'-mkH 1, both you and this compar,- will save a" great deal of time." Calif�� pia State .1ti h,�ay, Patron. tiTh ,s projecthas 'no impact on CHP operatY.ons , �' In the ro�t'Lntt of t:tuni.cipal boindtiri with :the eSpeots of land development ' e f` s obticernet� ea. Any' ltttyd use changes that requi.ro � he l b.t►i of Partiddi3o 3 the rbv, ' such as police and i'ii'�e iote- coot ca UeIX 17 p aa other nlYitinipal Cervices shodd conai,der these 1:actors� , We aubalt that t tiy dovel.opnent at a nti'bst&ntial nature be atuiexed and made prim or than Towin as a; condition at approval. Tei pial iii this procd"ss, we suggclat You ainaiad y attr general. Plan text to requi.re airy devel'opWeht taking plado- near tntinicioal botih arieg to comply' tti.th the local. ddVeloptuent aE tndttrd l', too teitdixe thiA the 'Fount- land tise Pi'Ioposal by and large s uiplyr 'reoogni.zoti exitti.r g ,patterhg and uses &hd Bio endorse the proposed chahgddi WVb aiagreat j h014a30, tliab ,ti text be added to the pro, ooed atabad:utbi t' whioh' 'will. provide `Polidiee uhioh will result in the avbidanco of ,itiriedidtional bvexr'p ,and dul li.eat bli o.£ pUbli o servioe functions. Thank you ,to the 6ppdrtuhity to conmtent on this proposa�l:t Mt" BOTTE COITNTY PLANNING C0114I8SION MMITl S - August 6,(9R(l C. ENVIIT '7OR W .ICA A PREVIOUSLY, CERTIFIED W171-M,D 1. Butte County Plen.ning Commission - General Plan Amendment 1'om Low Density Residential .and Grazing & Open Land to Low Density Rosidontialt .AgricUl.tural-Residential, Commercial and public located in the upper Lime Saddic4 Area along and near Peiltz-=Magnlia' Hiq. from Xwakle Reservoir to the Town of Paradise., 35n Ms. Blair read staff.finding.5. There was no ,;orrespondOnce. It was noted that this environmental impact report has not yet been certified. Propon6fttsi Homer Belt, Lodi, owner of property about 600 ,ft. south of the Paradise 'Town limits, on Iontz-Magali.a Highway, asked that his property be designated so that he could develop a tobile home park with 5 or 6 units per acre. Ti11"mRah Paley, a Pehtz Road property owner, asked thatper rn °the-area be designated low density and added that the Health Department-Would it only 1§9 hook-ups to water. Mill Ce&us,, engineer for the Madre de Oro Subdivision by Btuer- Harrison, Inc. j asked that it not be recommended t'liat the Town of Parad.ise ; 'be allowed to 'leap-frog" as suggested by the `Gown of Paradise (ift staff findings). hearing wasr e losedi Commissioner Max, finding that this: pro pus.�';3 meets !Jse dement of the General Plan, ,made a motion that by resolution this general plan proposal be approved: His motion Wa.s seconded by Commissioner wheeler. AYES: Commissioners llh.eelery Lambert, Max, Bennett and Chairman _,_ Gi'lhext. 'NOES i No one•+ A$SBNT: No one, Motion carried: M§. Blair commented that a- hearing on this matter Would Lie ' het by the gba'rd of SUperv�isors for later ,in the year- that only one irate change `can 'e made thi' caleandar year; ,* r RESOLUTION PLANNIzNG COV--`1SSION COUNTY OP BUTTE, STATE G-V CALIFORNIA RESOLUTI014 ADOPTING AMEN Di•I)~NT TO Tli1r LAND USE MAP (UPPLR LIME SADDLE FILE 80422A) OF THE LAND USE ELUENT OF T11P nOTTG COUNTY GENERAL PLAN pp CIlERE11S, jaursuant to Govornment Coto Section 653S1, hearings have been hold by the Butte County Planning Commission to consider tile amendment as sh6wn on Exhibit "A" attached hereto to theLand Use Element of the Butte County General Plan; and WHEREAS, the Butte County Planning, Commission has reviewed and r� cul►sidered the Environmental Impact Report, attached hereto as Exhibit `0811, prepared for the above amendment-; and MEREAS, the Butte County Planning Commission finds t'tat the � proposed amendment will be consistent with the land use now in the area } and Will conforn to the text of the General Plan and be in conformity with policies in other elements Of the General 'Plan; this finding; vein based upon information presented at the hearing thereon before the Butto County planning Commission and the resew ch and studies on which the amendment was based. Noll, T1int-FORS, be it, resolved„ by the Butto County -Planhi,ng Commission, pursuant to Government Code Section 653S2, that tie amendment to 'the Land Use:s shown on Exh3;0t "A" attached ,lereto, be adopted and inrorpo"rated 11 thin t11@ Land Us `"�; o£ the Lnnd Use ';Element of the ,. General plan of the County of Butte., PASSED AND ADOPTED by the. Planning; Commission of the County of j Butte, State of Califori `a„ on the 6th day of August 19801' by the follovinp; ; AYES. Commissioners' Wheeler. Bennett, Max; Lambert and Cha:ixmah Giibe N0S5 3 No one '{ ABShNT' No On'e AINED ABST : No: one 4. Ron ifiax, ..Vide.hai: man.. . _... for: George Gilbert, Cha irmat Butte dbai ty Planning Commission �;` 1 OAD Or- S1 PrMVTS'ORS = p TRUT13S September 16, 1980 UCONSIDEREA HEARING AATE_ AN�"*ENEftAL 'PLAN The request by William Geddis for reconsideration of the hearing i date previously, set for November 18,1980 was held at this time. Bettye Blair, planning director, set out the background on the request"fo Mr. Geddis. The Planning Department has several,projec.ts ready_ for the General Plan amendment. r' r Supervisor Winston stated he had talked at length with Mr. Geddis. He was sympathetic as them project had been going on for four years. 1 Bill Geddis, engineer, set out the background on his project. It was initially>started in Je,nuary 1977. They were ready to ,go forward after several requested changes and the General Plan language changed te, open anc grazing as opposed to 140 open graiing. Chairman Lemke noted this res in the Lime Saddle area and thore i's a problem with water. When this project goes through 1,t will give them a I greater aupply and'sourse of water. On motion of Supervisor Winston, seconded by Supervisor Moseley' and carried, the date so for the Genesi Plan hearing involving the Breuer -Harrison, Inc. Subdivision :be moved forward to October 7, 1980 at 11630 a.m. AYIi56 Supervisors Moseley, Wheialex, Winston and Chairman Letnk® NOES: Supervisor D010 -A C Sal it i J ., 1 s HOARp Or SUPERVISORS - I�tiNIITT S Oct6' et 7, 198 COUNTY PLANNING BUTTE 1602 ADOPT RESOLUTION 80-214; PUBLIC DE'SITY RESIDENTIaL AND CRA.INGCO 4DffOPEONTAN' TO LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL, T IAL, LOW GENERAL 9LP.ev AMEND MIT AGRICULTURA'i,-RESIDENTI,kL; GOI�RGI.AL t�a�ID PUBLIC, LOCATED IN THE UPPER LIME SADDLE AREEA ALONG AND NEAR PENTZ- MAGALIA HIGHWAY FROM: KL�itiCLE RESERVOIR TO THE TOWN OF pCommission General The Jublic herring on ':Butte County Planing Plan amendment from low AAd to deanriculturality �tesidantial,ntial &ad acommercialand zingAandlpublic, low density residential, g located in the upper, Lime Saddle area ;along av,,dl near Pentt-Magalia Highway from Kunkle Reservoir to the Town of Paradise (i.em on which a previously certified EIR will be used) was held as advertised. Bettye Blair, planning director, set out the background of She had posted two maps: one An; exhibit from the: General Plan amendment. theproposed Plan showing the existing designation and thither map showing _ the ro osed designations, Earl Nelson, environmental, ,.tvi�ew director, set out the 'backgrounu of the EIR. There is an error in the memo sent to the Board„ Remade ito llY ;reference to the fact that tthfwouldeletQd froms be thebe ehvitonmentamomo.upTtseoproposedt � is existingv lie asked that presently p t for the s.outhetn half : of the proposedy allowable, ltte project. The roject'would be more dense thaw the develn meat entl The EIR was wr northern half has the same concerns Hearing open to the public. Apu4 ng: 1. Jai Garner. lit. ;Garner rjwns property nortb. of Chico. He was concerned as this was the last considehMtbA Planderation ofendment General flaa this n amendme:l2 4 for ts year. A hearing date was set for y 8 mate so that ro: ect could be hearr ^,t that time. for November l8, 198U. He was trying t0meet the November 1 .:his p � Ms Blair stated the Board hdci teceived a lettet from SidpGo don te relative to this property. She understood that this prof ' project that in the 'environmental review process. Ind'catiots &.ave been that the project is about "to come out of Env1. ironzenta� Review. Oil Onknber 15a 1980 the Planning Commission will hear a General phe Jeneirhl amendmnt for theeidwillshol:d theaamendment i If ruintile is attiot on t after thefrst of thea Elan tot`ay, then th y yea.t. �tEc�5s . L t42 p,m: 1tECONVENE : 1:45 p e in. Mr. Nelson &fated he had chetked with staff as the 'strocesa S f the Garner and Gordon property o + There is L'n initial study in p Should bo cotripl.eted ws'�.khin the �tRek. TKs.a project }gas 350 d a�tia�.liaga nd it shoo on ,41 acres,' wrhetd other pzo jeLta of` that type have required impact reportis BOARD or, sunmyusom� MINOTriS October 71 1980 2: j � ,. SidCGordon Mr p Gordon stated there was: a project acrasa the;gtreetfrom his project that is of the same magnitude. tie felt tt;ey could a use the findings from that EIR for their project. The first time he heard: of the hearing scheduled for today was last Thursday.. He wanted to knob* why he had, not been notified of the change in the gearing date. He was objecting to the procedure that was Tarried out. The host of the project he is working, on ;could be increased :by $9,000 each for 376 homes. He understood that staff advised against movlg the hearing date forward. He wondered if the hearing was Ibeing advanced'to be before Measure A on .the ballot has been considered; Del Sie=en, deputy county counsel, stated 'that the ques'tiun of whether -Measure A vould effect these General Plan amendments would depend' on the Board as they have to implement the procedures because: the measure deals with the General Plan, Supervisor Dolan stated it could very well effect the change in the General. Plan amendments. Every project would have to $e reviewed at that° gime;. She 'felt the measure would 'effect the amendmettt: p project being ;consi:deit.ed todaySu ervisor Wheeler stated the ro ect b y was ready to go where there is a possibility thil Gordon and Garner proj�Rct might require An.EIR. Mr, Gordon stated his engineer had advised him that yes possibly an EIR would be required There has been an EIR done on the property next to theirs: Mri Nelson advised that the determination of whether the prdvious t'IR wes suitable would be Tedd by the county, They would have to review the facts and see if it meets the criteria. Supervisor Wheeler asked how Measure A would effect the General Plan imendmerit, if a decision was not made today and the amendments were allowed to be considered on November ;L8, 19:80. Mr. Siemsenstated Me,3sure A might or might not have an effect on the actions taken by the Board on November 18, 1980. The Board might: find thdimselvzs at the point of undothg something that was changes or they may hot,: Sttpervisor Dolan 'bat the iaiiue was that the Sda - had one General Plan Chan a that could There have "^ t wntersctha.tabeiiave they could been requests Froin property o' have their (projects ready by the end of the dale,i8 yii, and would like action souls on them► ,.-r:. ..„ •-li ,..::.. ...... _... ,.., _. . _.,... a , BOARD OF ;suit rmrrsw mmtrrn 7 Octubur i, 1'cJd0 i 3. BillGeddis. for, Geddis stated they started ,this project in. January, 1977. The EI2 and tentative map were submitted in April, 1979 to October, 1979 the General Plan was changed and they had been assured by Planning that this are was going into the recommended one acre as:ea, iSomeone at the hearing asked for higher ,density. As a result the text 'was Changed to open and grazing for 40 acre parcels where before the open and "I grazing would have allowed one acre parcels. The Planning Department hook the General Plan change forward`. He asked that the Board take action_ on the General. Plan amendment at this time. 4. Larry Brooks, planning, :director, Town of Paradise. Mr,. Brooks stated he was not opposing or ;in favor of the project. He was here to let the Board know the. Town was concerned with this area. The property along the northern border would be ambitded that has parcels I bot"� in the Town limits and the county. He recommended at a sta.Ef level that consideration be. given to earourage aan^.xat3 n to the towr, when there in development is that area. There is ail overlap of services in that area. Tlae town is ready to work with the developers in this area. S. Carl 'Fisher. Mr. Fisher spoke for Lime Saddle Commun•i.ty Services District. At the Board's request, they gaited for the Board to see whether the community of Paradise would incorporate. Ad,would like to 'see the Board take action on, the General Plan amendment Tillman Daley. Judge Daley seated the zones of belnefit pay for the payment on the loan. This is the reason they are regl%esting low aensity to make the difference in the payment ofthe loan. Harrison ,end Breuer will put in their own i 011s and. of the are swztessful, they will turn them 'doer to the district for operatton. There int another developer ih the aterl with twelve tots the district can furnish 'I'Mter to. They can only furnish nater to 194parcels. They cannot furnish sill tine waver that people would like furhish;ed Supervisol-,' �Iinston stated both Mr Garner and Mr, Mel'?ne, raised questions as to why 'the,applid&ht6 had not been notified of the change in the hearing date. He wanted to know how many General Plan changes Vdre in. process. " of Ms. Blair stated the u y ;,g' gd had the Board and asked for tht"t �Novembe°� `18i 1.980 h�ariii,�'date At that time, they did not Have a. Project before the Board. Thea=e was a project coming before thcl Planning 'Co=iissiot 'i'here' were projects that were hot neartha hearing process and vert ncit: �. contacted. The Gordon and Reline project -is a privateptoject: and in the t P,nVirotmental Review' Department They would not be no %�ntil they . Isere is A hearing po6ture, BOARD CST' SUPrMMORS MINUTES October 7, '1.8Q Super,". or Dolan stated that the same time when the Board 'did change the General Plan heazing date, the Board was aware the,Gridley- Biggs change Vi6uld be ready. There could be any number of ptdjects waiting for 1*11at change. Ms: Blair felt there were three private applications for General Plan avi'endmerit siica the last General Plan amendment. �� ined to the Board. Hearing closed to the nt,blic and conf Supervisor bIl a felt it was 'unfair to approve a General Plan amendment at this time when there is the Oroville and Gridley-Biggs General Plan amendments that would ba ready before the end of the year, which includes 6,000 acres: Ms. Clair 's'tated the Gridley-Biggs project will be heard by the 'Planni'ng Commission on October 15, 1980. The south Clai.co project will be heard by the Gomm3ss`'_"on on October 29, 198.0: p Supervisor Winston stated Measure A is coming up before the public in November and the„language i5_pretty plain. The measure is talking about coming into conformity within six months. There is going to be an agricultural committee making decisions about many things r�ilative to the agriculture? •.ature of the ianO 'tnd talking about area surroundingto urban development. ��Y ' action the Board took today p it vdt moved by 8Upervi"sor Winston that having reviewed the contents of the draft environmental impact report, the comments received, thereon, and the responses to those comments the 'final environmental impact wad, to 'be certified as having 'been coimplati"ad in complianaa ,report i-Jth the California Envitbrahtnta?. Q,:ality Act, the State ETR Guidelines and ti-.z Butte County Environmental Review Guidelines; finding the EIA is appiiaable to this project; 'finding the project will have a significant ` then environment and reviewing the alternatives that appear in " effOct on tel report; finding that �taae alternative"s are ,.tint teasonable, being; 1)' a project With smaller lot sizes; 2) a project with larger lot_siaes 3) a no I)roject; 4) a project with cluster of multi-family dousing units and rejecting those alternatives because a cluster of keeping 'r multi-family housing units `as pointed out in the EIR are .not in ; with the rural setting of the project site; a greater density would result 1� in a greater consumption o£ domestic water), as the Boara has already heard as to the limitations it, the`watcr; increased density would requis a waste water treatvient[,piant; projecW, faith larger lot ;sizeb would not �., "a lend; ptoing that P tie rovers , _ the the' di�tgiGonsit'e.ations whichJustifythetpr oresentptimea face of the environmental concerns is that at the p the current, . •. General 1P'.tn'nesignetian it not conforming to the Genital Pisn 06li444it hei+ag s Stuart ninrel typo, :toning; firicling tdet Cha project 3e. ,in confbrpl taco with 411 eitiAnti 60 thr Butte County 'a tnttil Plan HOARD OCA 80PJ!RV!Q$R5 ii,INUT8S Octobi6r '7'f 1HO Motion withdrawn. On motion of Supervisor Winston, seconded by Supervisor Wheeiler and carried, having reviewed the contents of the draft environmental impact report, the comments received thereon, and the responses to those report was certified as having ween completed in compliance with the Cutter is Environmental Qu lily comments, the final environmental impact < r Act, the State EIR_Guidelines and the Quality y Guidelines. On motion of Supervisor WinstMl, seconded by Supervisor Wheeler'' and carried, finding the EIR is applicable to this project; finding the project will have a significant effect on the environment and reviewing the alternatives that appear in the environmental report, finding that the alL'ernatives are not reasonable being, 1) ;'i project with smaller lot sizes; 2) a project with larger lot�sizps; 3) a no project; 4) a project with cluster of multi -family housird units'; and.rejecting those alternatives because a cluster of multi—family housing units as pointed out in the EIR are not in keeping with the "rural setting of the project site; a greater density would result in a greater consumption of domestic water, as the Board his already heard as to the limitations in the water; increase density would require a waste water treatment plant a project with larger lot sizes would not fie representative of the most efficient use of the land; finding that the overriding considerations which justify the projat the ect approval resent time the the face of the environmental concerns is that p he current General Plandesignation is not conforming to the General 'Plan policies,b_ing a general type of zoning; finding that the, project is in conformance with all elements of the Witte County General Plan; with additional overriding considerations offthe project area Is on the boundaries of an established community, being near Paradise and mmunity; the site does not appearing to be a local extension As agricultural land; mitigations' appear to have any significan are available at the time of tentative map approval to minimize environ mental damage; the General Plan ,amendment from low density residential and grazing and open land to low density "residential, agricultural residential, commercial and public; located in the upper Lime, Saddle area along andnear 'Pentz4tagalie, kghway from Kunkle Reservoir to the Town of Paradise was apprd�led1, ResolUtion 80-114 °as adopted and the Chairman authorized to sign: AYESt Supervisors �ib'lele'r, Anaton and y Chairman Lamkei Vice, Chairman doseley. NOGSiiSupervisor Dolen+ AB�aIMT. t Gordon 4 Mel: ne &a Associates 1124 B Mangrove . Chico, Ca. 95926 October 5, 1980 Butte County Hoard of Supervisors 25` County Center Drive Oroviliej Cay Rea General Plan Change Gentlerien ft has bi en brouight to my attention that the regular scheduled C;•�neral 0 has how, been Plan Chati,ge (G;,P.C,) meeting of Novertiber 18� 1 9 8 up to Oc't,bber 1980. ?' By alloizng the change date you may have cnet my company up to one year in developing tithe. I have but, one; giuestion, hots can you justify this action? y You have' t, Uairly placed a" burden on myself anis 3 to 4• other people to appeaso''thdl whim of l other porsets s th' closing I ask that you r,"`lange the GPO O back to November 18; 1980 as 4as originally scheduled. ! Sincerely,, . Sidney P . Gott�o ti Gordon Me7,ihe 8e Associates } i , � d T 1 111 i Bill Sottas, bnv xotmen'tal Review QhnbgeZ iti 1,:1v jctradloo A= and too Kau { aka ;'Kro DAn Kcrinc-dvi om n of suit 134 newas .HCl. l gx"'adine I�Ivwm, requesUluu a rpoobai.derab in of a. propnoed Plan ,Josipmiui 6f OhLo panob! from 6hu Gming and C you r and toAV �,���xy.���m. g 1.+��aIdenta 1 o na P pose or ftho u�4� R �Ys�r.4a.ri$ r.�r�,�rel#6itkS 4;6 thh nox61a, AO yol.i are aWtire, � alope, aooens and the obil t;y of property to ,;support of .b �mibe wastm, dippos-al are major area of 'rho Otoumy Al'tor lookint at the ni6po, rod. t:Onzhlp to vxitit.Lng uaeai roads, c,Lo. and in oozasuV 61"'ion 141th Dove HironzrAual projoet pliannor the pop t. SO ooulaludm that }ice is reasonable,pofor the roll a Avely level porti oni o th0 Pr10 oVr DeAa.l t7 �co,dc.ttf., 01. d06:'( n�:itio perm as ty r�ar� e r:olit of �; �o four eras. do pear gro�a a � , . L-hin. _ PUO _'x"Ose eW, L�Y ddniidox�tat!6 �r,1:im mit the do'�'�elo�iriota'G of Me property wo Apnraq u'E3 dasign L'4u, Avran. em%lt lansivive to the environ oWOU oonnpaims found in Wo ores. 1t is our undaidt!,tandAl t; W 0 are preoeany ' utdler-- tokitg �S,M teat ,.lie �1�a 1-0iaa, disio Aron .land. lyse :Ata should �� L"114 f"� it be rGVI'Od as oh n in "1 0 ac+sompan ing �corox chola it rod) a I you h ve quem"L ilta, p101a 0 o€ ll 4601. �. G L ���ttneitt ' wY g q ,e si Inter-pepnrtmeetal Memorandum rugene teen, Superintandettt Paradise Unified School, Dist, 'Terry Ash,t•ic hd6le,r Paradise t.,ccrettt:ion D18t. B;nuna sawoya.uf i 105 ComlitWl brive 566 Pearson Road 6626 Skyway DIt4g,71ia, CA 95954 Paradise;, CA 95969 pirnaise, CA 95969 Word it Denny Prom Main 257 kosewood Dove Larry tleooka, DirLdtztr Paeu lise Planning Dept. #15 Wynclt Ci:,, 1.ingalia, CA 95954 �ingalie CA 959$4 5555 Staoloy Pnradise, CA 95969 Cerin. R. & Robert H. Woert Tom Rogets Altacal Audubon Society John Htbd alcl. 40 Endicott 11 LA C95954 Dili;' ia, 95954 S4S2,.Millwood Lane Ischool.siarillities Ping Unit Patadisey CA 911969 State Dept, of Ed'Uc atian K 6 ii; `Trafnller 721 Capitol Will 180 Catv,de }give Diane Booth Sacramento, CA 9581.4 Mngalia+:'CA y5954 Paradise Post P.o. Dtawer 70 Jim snowdeo William C, 'Tete Paradise,, (A 95,969 kept. of Fish &Came M tte hanger Unit ht, 5, 'Box 551 176 Ne18oti Avenue Latry Risser Chico, CA 95926 Otovil.l'p, CA 95065 Daily Midge Gazette P.O. Hax 25 State Cleating, House Roy Pence Paradise) CA 959>9' Office of Pldno,.Img & lkov ew P,O, OR 451,, `Taadtadn ;% Iwo loth magalia, CA 95954 Collie 'Webb Cbiro-'Knterprisd RecordCalif. srtcrnmenta, GA 95,81.4 . 'rdhAeta ,Osoc. P, r ` Box. ,5J 0 ilon6tabl.e Alan Cranaton 811g. 1705 Murobiabn Drive f,A 94010 i,kadiae, CA 9$969 229 Russel Senate Off•.i,ae Blurltngame, Washington, D.C. 205.10 Kt1SL 'TV Attn:, hick Rigsby - Honorable Solo, tlayakawa William L, Sviltll P'aranisc U.M.Q .ed Schdoi Dist. 1.80. 9, 4th Street; United Stair' Senate 'Teachetis Alsbelation Ct'tico UA 95927 Gtashin-ton 17:C: 20510 g , � + 95969 Paradise OA , Bntty't3lair, Direttor 116norable llutol,d T, Johnson h, and W. Pauidali butte County vianning Dept. Ray'butn house Oftjvt Bidg. Appie `Tree Village , S_ County Ce.di:or Driva Orajtilln, X9 3lox 2'47 Waghington, h C, 20$15 7G Patrick Drive Paradise; CA 95989 Vitl Nel'6o' Ai bitectot Assemblyman Stan stathdt�t Lathy Kroitz �chr,o In, thviromdhtai '1tevidw Dept. Attnt Rdy Natbnitx Paradise Pre 7 Count Cr:ntet Drive Ordvillec OA 95965 P,0. Dox 470:? Bedding, CA 96091 P.O. BwX 597 irataciioe, CA 06069 Mrs, Richard U, Swith - Mt. ry Mrs. Kennetli L, Iharpe Mr. 1i►1 1i r., Gadfrq 245 F`erl;uson Drive Ipgnlfn,'CA 95954 Linda tied Court MAgalia, CA 95954 P.O, 13ox 7�9 tagalisy CA 06094 R6bart Lbikej Sit fitrs,Rae! Jordan Butte :aunty 325 Pondrer,.o'sb way 1.859 Bifid Magalin, CA 95954 ` Otovilio, CA 95965 �11�1tb rwt. C�rar►hin� �triutt, ': . lorovil}o .�lifarniat l� u r time (94ftforxttta �"• cscivr'RNorr's oR�tc� ,u{}o Co. • annin C Is QF,O�:i OF 1►LANNRNG AND RiG5EAF7CH �� { Cttutl 1400 'TENTH STMETI ' E B SA`C.RAMENTO 9E814 EDMUN6 G• BROWN JR, OFovillo� Cplifptdta t _ QQN►x,4011.,. February 154 1981 TO rii Rexponsitrle and Caent#nq Agencies FROM Heidi wast a/ty�ab SUBJECT: Butte CduOty's NOP for Paeadise_Upper' Ridge& Lime 'Saddle C-0*Mhity Service District GPA CCN 61020322 Attached for your comments is the Butte County's Noticd of Preparation of a draft nvi mh ental i ImpacA p;oer Ridge & 'Lime Saddle` Community, bjst_ Environmental Impact Report (tcIR) for Paradise U S 1 p , tie project lead age' consult With 'responsibl A under' rovisions of A8 8$4 t� 'r, 1 ncv must agencies in deciding What type of environme mental docuht to prepare in compliance tsith tie California Environmental Quality Acta(CEQA): We' ask' that responsibly agencies transmit their concerns and comments on the scope and content or 'the transmit, focusing onpacii'c iniormason rolatei to their own statutory resgonsbl�,�lity. We also encourage oonmenting tgendiat to respond to the lead agency's regyest for consultation, as it is in them best interest, to e�"press thearly in eir concerns. thi CE0A process: r Comments should be forwarded dfrettly t. the lead agehcj contact:; Dave Nironimus `, r Butte County { 7Coobt leCenter' bwive CA 95965 X90 634.4501 With a dbo to tie C1 eai•i nghcuse, within 45 days of i dCei pt Of tti i s pati i Please refer to the Stuse number no ate Clear ohdted abovQ tri` all 'correspondence s tohddrn ho this project. If you have any questions about f:l a reView Ooocesao call me at Attachments 1 Please cohtact rite at the 666 b. oumber 1f y`bu have signifiCat t concerns on thus 0 neral �p1ah am�hdmeht and fe,e,1 an early 1000 tiilsl'' of state agencies would be useful rd: Dave liiron#mus .. p1S1`tlft34'11001 LIST'.�. 'Al I1 fIt^ Lar�eOtL James 1'ryneP Air Aeeoumn aoaro� 1'x00 15tH Stmet ( 040C. of Parka 4vd 00crwa6lon JZ20 K Street tta I i , Third Floor Cd 99®Ts �f 95$14 it 914/ 5-O 916l7724441Cn ititlia� Travis _ California Caaseal taeaisaion 831 kower+P Street. 4th Floor tticir dal:Gfoa►to Office of HistaMC PPerrrrat'ian 122tf K Strut Mali, `third Maar tit i ;aa Frantiy�u. CA 94107 Saeram co. 0, Q58tc, ' Llndla fain Robert Tenn Cal t'1'0MIA Enury CoaeeiIs ion 1111 How Ak*xwy Row 171 ]' P0161'e; Uti t 1 ti4i Cca+ei.ision 350 ,MdAllistor Strsee Steraawnea. CA 791125 San Francisca. 'CA 441IR 9111/430-6+t(1� a1S/597-1249 S\e"0"t ; CAIrmml- Division of .teras raue.ica 1120 =y' Street Reelaweaion ¢aar+a Reel 1416 .41" t SkMle 2. S4erawra: t; Sacrvwto. CA 44814 _916/1ZZ-4995' 916/445-1624 rays iiali adbart wha dik of. Goaeinq dad tlaterwA lugS Streee � S.: , 7ay Com. R Oev't. Ca xt. 10 'an Itess+ :�nve. R000 2311 ( So,,va�rta, 4SR14 San Fnkisco. a 14102 .CA 9161-4163 ' atsle�r�aea Rik ttevib. Eng►#recd Proar-aeP Caord,�, aye st.,�r,v Oeat.' cf 1416 ninth comomaclon Strsetj oaw lySj► Sol id ;:arta 1lsnaoee+snG ''oarrl I'M Ntnc13 Strait. RdbW ;o0 eo. ca 99$14: 5aM�; 1612th aerae�. - 9+61 �S916/72..'-x!,915 Robert tharrattred FukWhimis i3eot. at Ftih Aid rww 1416 - 7th Str*at107 State Corgi issid., + Ilk" W*4c 5aaur"Ca. Cal Owl! er Saenvwico; CA WIN 7161445.17113- 916I722�t81� , , Cr+ Corddn 5 + aaat. Of Fdod inl +tjrlcaltur�e 1227 " Streat id IW41esdn 314tH Uaur R"Wiress +`iinersl .c,ird 2125 - b1tfi Stiredt Sacra rnCa. rA 79Afa 5aeWa ►to+ CJi 96$14 '}1R/d4'S-�i6RZ _ /' 4161'17�r3'!A3 path Cb x eae. i 1416 hof Ffiothorertt� iSfli. 7 Koo del taik teat. �di� liaerr R$sourot Mita Yllnth 5lre�tit. nn. C,1 79Ri4 .aeraim"t Sicramenta, Cit `9VA14 , 71RI=iwSa9i4dtt4+etc.Rdda 9T6j:1d�.74t6 h. raves �I� rn� " Dwinit `'G'astvlllo; 'opk Irt19 l atrstc of r��4rat Sirjices IMS � L`beaI GQNe'rnmPtit Unit SaCrdMentdi r„1 74Ctt,1 , 71 AI:d49.�71t'd1 Rarity Cb111ns ^edt\ of �''aly �) PkA 0* tc i trot WWI tIA1'12 41ni iR itit i i hIN 1hn `!litr,a �ti� 1�A�iiinn 4y.efr��nir;+ ra=►su n21 tiny, 'R.1T+.s� 7SM ii+eti A t I�, -2- E., Potential imparts of the proposed project on surface and ground-"- water quality (degree of change and seas�:ta1, variation). it F. Mitigation measures] including plans forpreventing impacts from spills. VAT,ER RIGHTS A. 'Existing mater rights and pending applications. L. Availability of water for the proposed project. C. Availability of water to protect existitnr I"n—stream beneficial uses,,.,-,,., { of water. 7n addition to pro'iding the above listed information in-the draft',, Ela., A'ppii'- dAhts for pro,js(As tha.'',. have an e,� fen+a can ,eislz, t o nuality br involve tasa`i.e-- A, ;dater disposal must contac.11 i,i,r� aurx�-,p 'a e Regiokaal Boa.�d. ,; ApplicAnts with ojedts inVo`from st�rfacr� or underground stream: ti hts of the' State Board. .. ould c iit.ut Lhu 1,i!vi.s. 6h ofWatereg ` Gi Schuelle"r, Legal and Teohh!881 8e)-v3.i",es U3.Abi0n y 4 Tony dc: Mr. Landis s y California die ions! Watt.r Qualit Control s k 86ardt'Central Valley &-Agion 3201 S Street is Sacramento; CA 95816 1 1 I,4 w