Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout83-85B ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTS 3 OF 84, 'ii i a ;, ti _ i xAENT P, _ AR ANS REOVATION VgN via lid! 0011 'APO 100 T'reosfti`rrn0001 118 Cedar Street U I t I - AxPro act Raw: forkaf,"AW �Alf SCH M1 Woo oVItO�' �L�,HOW '. Qtot��.� AL,'., "Nn,44tiv on Tr &AMS POU Gg 19 R : 01 1 01Mq M 1)(ImMme"t CIIvo'r %t" at'O' Oneraw ti$$ o; Once!& t1ho :gmbjv,iiar�li 'i tori hou no reg latup aluiriruvit m fake POSIt applicattod and r err the �r��,���� � �utponal impa � l � �� 1111ort�� the qu ply' 4rrd ���!� Ao o idt"nation appar�tuni :ial in A stit-6144 k;11 Via anul bask; arra' C2), 01 06 unlit% W thd SSW Park Sy'tk.ow It io USC MOO Q1 0CrtJdS eiOW0100 APP YOpH aid' MAUPOW WCMU iMcde WhAt ctleeui tly` av th➢ ty a jqu,1 ity avid, I.C,llfty 6f Ovidus: wordatio OPP'OWWO W the, praject Areaq And WhAt they 101y W.4 f "� , C. 1�i9p� t�' `�i Y�l; +�IY` �ii':It"1 w���`(��,�,a iffy, 'yah Ctyp'61 qual rt,�� or d�ri4jtit d�fvScr tion ppory��r�ry���t.��c�.ppOp�N MitIgnti ��r K - ! � �.i t �(,�Vild �J f upundd ! The ap f i cat ew Chou d cover Cil6dl t Thi+ S U AT the Erojectfs impact ro Mhnt i c COOL i M OUS t i 'iahar 4os o wMild.1irej accent, Watce �l ity and Or= ro„,� Q1000, ter all casesti V10.�i 1 � 1, gi� e;l thu �pedj dt '15� i OU'di ng, all aopurtoniicis Ah 03 00MV tranmoiss i C n; T 1 CiA, diverMOO nobaturay Pewold the MUS ton matoelan µ,tii`x0tud Is tile; ap*;'a`itati n", rw 6lit�0. PNO1 OntM 0t4 tion from l'icorr;O I'a °d��r.r'i�Trl �' t'ix��it� ��►��(��ti,��rit; l�� ACCUPOCO, 0I'i�C,� tha Own, W Whid��i �;hd ppaj:e pr"r1M�uell �fV Iulxlic 'i CC 6110 t Ira rOdeaattodr �dakr')6607 Ora alicy. Altqy,otq l► � 1'! y q Agnehod verr your axw, t`up finding W varwnov idat iinn'5 r€ Matting the f-pple:ar.V mQM19 will bay ahveyod Qu ha F~'edlt"ral Vaill MUM r:or y �iiiri';jinj toy iyu eoosloaration in tl tar,rll'infug tetn and munty �' of Solt 'v It Nei .16 MOO h-0-0 44,wfie Ag, 't Vattalud ` ''OY 51, '� of" PI L '. ` Rig, 'e aa; at a aat i OJOMn: oilt' paelfleout + �"ry - � uSOO 14; dau. .., "Old, Aitt i� ti ° i' A 4 It b 6u" It x �4�n?�{���_a jYy+�, �,j�� „yuryy�ty�ry.�: �`•,}`y��y: .e{ V�Tr %e Wf�V �.44� L? rbaMii.Ei 1R G, 'i#43.V�:.t t3 PavIti' w b t` Pr Aftcit # OM r a 6: tug 10 ! teft, CON, t l ON Rohl +Wray. f9, CORR fm "91 PAW M.1` fir` i. �WWI!" , �a. UdAtfolh debt Ut Vogl, tho ja"MSW , OU Of that •R� }y pp - L7������,,,.;•.•_. Y ,,. .,. ���.��� +I�r �� �4r�A•A� �,Ll7 �Ciktt;.�rd�I��1�3H:s.�.'F... ,(• � W ou TON' Wit 6, t. du Yo 0 06joldt ridtfa,jjA it w iti,may} } fu n� int' J b d I f.fl. ( r 1 RF tVW'UnO,., , r dufty hat 066.6 � �,' Ile 8 e i 4 # e ani allb � th � t a ���ZW ds t � � Wi ITMid Ad 6f 'libid, d§6 6 6110 hat, i td aggoo dna . th s- r % 7 tetea da•�rt bra r� Yj5 'a�' :ie�iaw' �ri5t� d'oe a�hi�h1oris io ha�i � ll ad r1 . fi n Of th"' (MA 6061 � � K,. � ��� ��I I t�dh���o%krfy h:�iie'�ca'hW; 1 ad air f �h�i n t COPg county, ga.. { 'rI gy 04w4 i SUMS' Or OPP- I�� If f t M41OW-41911 of, k !� a '1 t • err �I�'. ;��i� � �; 3 hdv Mill foo `to :. r fro of rl fi4 f�6, g�; dAND O ary ' fee t 16 0a' e � iM A,ng tfiiv . 6 tgn rf -'vkd4 P; .nwMt � ;+�,d�•w� i�, iu �.-,�c.:�.u„ui f naii_f�. .. � cr NIM ! tfe West side Butte Creek Canyon on relat%V l; ;r oVeeIevata on gPadUra llly becoming higher above Butte Creek as i.:E (alis to lower 3 elevation. The pipe Will be on concrete sadd es about 40 feet apart. An above. -ground structure of that magnitude Will have 5 significant. vssual sm acts a d ri g con,sftuct 4 p n also dun an► wi.�1 6 have considerable impact on plant and wildlife Construction i will be difficult. Mintonance will be necessary; a Vehicular r access trail al,on the 9 pipeline wall have to be maintained, I;; 9 should ;be anticipated that. this element o'f con`strUction 1(1 Will be s[r„elect to ,continued erosion, ants, 1 F a r.uptUri 0 should 11 occur substantial damage w'duIdoccur tothearea, 1+� The inverted siphon across Butte Ct0e. Will be a 01 arge suspension bridge Which will have significant visual 1.1 imp'act:, Downstream from the inverted siphon, the conduit Will, y �► again b,e 5--1/2 f font diameter titer ;feel pipe on concrete saddles and l(i will require an access trail for m'aintenan'ce. ii II, PROJECT OPERATION AND REBOURG�, UTILtzATION, 1' It,appears no consideration has been given to 19 alternativeslto. the above -ground pipeline conduit' such 90 . as a: : tunnelBecaus e of the significant environmental impaet' {,f ,s o _, f an above-grou.nd p�,peline some three and ono"hal fmileo -_ loo 9 running down the Butte Creek Canyon) use of a tunnel should be- given 3 23 cbns derotio and the econo n mic impadts Weighed carefully, " The section ofxhib t B on Re"sour ce Utilization 215 should include a condition of l.icensi.ng that at any timel the t� -manmum fl ow of the ttrrbin'es plus the bypass flow (a total �''' of 51 cf5) is not present in the Creek at the diversion dam, ail f' 4� of the weter should be bypassed down Out to CreekEne �. r 5y pebdueLid is -2- •'fk'R•?,-p.'�ytQ ;ti'vailtil4e.rt 'w'ar•>y i • 4 N7r ro..n, u:w ^} �tlt'; e ,I.'.`^t,. atdA„4+.1 .,.�,.,._,.., .. . _ 1 � 0n ! page E=-IT-,9 in"' the lash parag,rah, it is diao�ussed w that the msjor natural source df turbidity in 6Utte in 3 Creek the F6111''is the turbidity resulting from' the firstaarly 4 rains , Nh�n the summeraceumulsted dust and'dirt 'is gashed into t he Creek. 5 P Indicate The re: ort s that it .is expected than the fj cons'trur`tinn act, iVity turbidity W, 1, be 7 no worse than ttie fall nate ral turbidity. However, the fall turbidity 'resulting from nat;uzlal, causes lasts for on']y ashort period during theinitis a` ' r xnst 'while 9 the potential for increased turbidity f'ro'm construction nc'' tivatY, 10 particular.ly from the pipeli.het Will last' throughout 11 and owing g the cot�struct.ibn erlod. Also th'e P X� scarringof the hillside' which must inevitably result From the pipeline eonstructinri wi11 cause 13 an J***wr:eased level of tu'fibidit y for s ime Ila Yeats until the area aa. coin letel healed o P Y Verr�;OWh t and naturally stabilized, ,h In SG'Ctlgn 2, the r,'educt,inn in f q�j5 k In �'Utt�' (Fi ' fir th;e diVers3on t;q the powerhouse which ,yal i be caused by the pr.ojectare presented in tabolair fncmr, We have' the refcre • r lb platted the 10- ear mean' flo` y w changes in a graph attaohed he, 1 as Ex bit "ln, It should be noted that here is -6 an error on iab1e, U-4 in that the 10-year mean 21 flow for 5ept'embet" should b.e 4 nfs instead. of the 29' cFs as shown in 'the table. fay .., ,x In 8e0ti0h 2t pageil; paragraph E_ s Mitigation' Meas ores Proposed, Item B staves that the c'.onstr action 21 o'f the pipeline ' velli, avcad areas of highly uhstable soils , —, or st.ee p slopes dur'ih construction, �t mus g t be 4�' reob niz g . ed that oboe the pipeline is d''esi � . and good cgnsttUotid n begins, it Is not i'ealJ,y 'possible `�� to re 9-h the pipeline to avoid such areas (Ni i becaUbe the p pel.ine is restrictIn tiie amoUht ofgrads ah'ange, Arid 4 ;_ area of th:e lVersion dam ibl a ma t, or of"dcmabrn' and; should ouch 0 0 o flow slide roaot; veto: it eo,uXd �'t11 the lbypldlss and' intake , vrtirl�o' of tha, platlt C ra u1 gcoldgic str�dy ;ohou�ld be conducted to, do,termi e whother or not the ttrUdtutbi 000,10 bo. r;t:loc as ed he irres Appendix 'Os t triol Verterirnto e+'nvtt�,nmoritsl to Rtrport dells riot appoat to oddraao 4-ho p0a,jeet '0.6 it is proat!htly, punned and siloul ` be updotpd That' repprt diaouaoea,' the prdt h,de of the reservoir whish is not now inolUdod in tho' project; and also trel'dra tri• the;. pipoline being dl:most completdly b'ur3.dd, ltl the db,dve"grouted pipetIne ';htia s,lgn ltkoont 0h,V1kbh-,4 610nt'dl itripti, oto on p1atj 1if{e acrd wild11fe during and after 121' tytjnntructi'dt1# petrt6ha surv`oylh, for' rate im ondtangared tpoolos 13 including spo`ttod dwl`) bib'khowledge oatnp; img Methods troy nat Kovd been adat;uatd; 'theta is 9t,eep te(lllt'ginil #6dl T'ifiit'ad aoceaS;: b,iL:t:Ey 1t the at�r�ve-� robldmo thdtadt its 1h d-dditloti t-.d p ordor 1r E6, proporlly evalud'te th6 drivirah'ftVd ttnl ospeo't.tl be thOl pra, oc:t 1 all of rho folSt�wing imp>cts rr'oad t bo ovaluatdd; ) tho Icl s ntibipstod, typa j h6ndliog ,arid' _stcrt go of oh:omio is a lbito; 20 (b) dontt'el ref ins,trtram t,htrt=mal pollutlt iw; �'o} c;tlrrjr�lativo i�lpaots +21' to Outtd Creek ori wotat dhd pishotyt (d) tludhing (lowe n000;isary 22 bo kdep spawr74hg bt=oad dle,a'r; (a) loss dp wdthdd grav&.1 b tt and'. 0111 itnpatr't on sparred Wcpipdtb; (':f) full d,bMpdh,btit Am Pbf hob.itdt IN ltidS atoll df a11. Vli W4,1,rd ig000di&5' ail pt &-PCd jddt 1,6V81§ f T :, 19 atibil ira'rri.do'rs, (h} Pot t;�pro ot.t: ect ioh og) pt'citf` ddo,f. habitat value° shduld be dgUdl Eo dt greater 'thd pt d-p,td'joo o W h'abita.t values (d4'tdrtiif1at1'on o'f post-pto,jedt valud toat~d bh4 tht LSI eontribu�'id"d cif habit8 ttl support t�f dm-m,oroiai and rracte-A idhAI r t hdrji r4'9tllire��.�, th�r�.18' tt���1t��1� ' 'et`�dQ; #�'�d w Igoe el dij rapt,'Or protootjoh tj$j l hdo ` M rob tii lho �f tith ti`I the C + 3M08tt6' dhd davoleproent dt spocif:la plan fey remelreX, c e 'dim6nt. ftolk diVereiah ''Otrueture� ►iet includIng, rlufghln i�A Ori l down*atreero; Cx de' 1 p ner, �nf e�eet f e p16h LO prov d for Pdeeb a of growl 661 w dt.verei�n r . blbueturN� did m eblii�eti.ewt art rt ref Aopj,.iedht to f'i ld cheek the pre eet 6.ree fer' then m ere ' depe'qjte: and, utljjjet;lon t `detoeM4' mt' tho IeVel 6 S.MPOOLl"Oh, ther t" heeer ' ent id tpetWd life Or th,e pr; ee �`�erofere j thel t rdhI ger teX Rupert tie It, pro-tew,tly, ie Odhbl ,tuted dbee riot, #dOOudtdly addkt IS ' the dhvit(W d: ht'el jtrfpadtb Of �et%t rpt erlb aw are of the eante' goti eerwdef""e t); _,. � �d�t Atid the bepnrt,i��ai�,t, sub,�i;tt� ed` b the guireeu d Lehd. Merie n'f Pith e td d,6 the dri+d redpe�'�ful'1jr tb e0rieidor end Oddr6"q Lhd" �aid W611 t8! t.eViewit�r' the licohee. AoOoe'k fu11y §ubkitted; .: butteeuity Cdurti os .1, 7.•c�,_,. z 2inF?iY�'f , , e C. tli: Ni10Y�° IR 0 eta 1 n. wf � a .- ..,, . , ., .. 4E5A -- (ufC��iHY_�l FLOWS BUTTS GREE SE : ctl O - ct it d i C CSL ry�nyh a�.0 ..__ _. LL f�CLL . . —u —W - C - Gerry-� F n ock. molt 6e� .tare Fe�s h-ar. 1��r'- May 1uoF r :. MOUTH Jug -..� 96 a ME 64M CF onthr ftrqil4fi dS_Ct €lE c Ei �3{ i`i i - ' ,s ilt X53= �EiE6896- LICetsa._ 8 tAt 'ar CALMANIA COUN Y UP C � r 81: IOCU* 001tig dully dw,a'rrti ► :' . the County ounao for the County, dr 0 wtot POLI ild" dull duty' ttrI tod ad' d tbbtAty -jhidt h o had fetid; the tOrOO 169 i0 ttu,ffiht 6A kftbWO ltd cdh.tib 't mid Lh6t UJO, ddffi 16 ta'u't 6 'hio 0w 'khiow, log xcopt 06 ► i ' , Odf#1 1.h € t6tdd d�1 �i���ftdtl' off' ; #11 tit' to Chad IhOlb OV ' 00,10 tO tbo blUo. l ' �wW " r p M m rl*" Subad.elbdd ond' ,awtirll t0, be, fa, 5 doy�y9 Of A 190 i �.:ifi k R �Y IAS _ I,.�4 s4 46 �If 1 G f Y G N�+3t llr t �y�,, f y 1U l��p 11"0.' �4 WVc ,yf h� the Itsi 0 , yy,��� ��yy ,,yy }}�� yy�,�� g, i �+..ay;+;�fyq: �y yyt4 u,� .gyp y � ,,,y the fi�.fdlly a0,\ Li y Ehd4 ,1 ht� di thit dby, �u' �4 dd the ' 'may ra kf fry y� µ� y � { �. �y. y � y.y y{ yp, �y y�. y..f' �j y,.{ 'j,, y,, ,�# �( �tg yy y� fy. I tJ ,4 G' UJ.I Ii. 4l Fi is fl 1". ff; U Wn' .-011 p ttiiet i;�47[Ilil'Y'1: 4,! V �''Ct;Ftj �i j �At 1I1' All j. y.7( �'+ t�ryf, ��'.yy �y�j yy.��' yy�� ��..yy yp�y4''.� Na ,,y ..ypy,�,�tyy_yy ��yy yj.�,.. �.y. yy ppi J� q��y. f�^ thN f.iG .�,11 b0d G'' twirl ��G7Mle '.§1 41�.l44 7y RG�,{ lab-I�l be, d i' l O'ddr.� dd'' ddJ d btu' t d6 d 4 df W d p° wr t l d� V. fi 1 hni �yyyyy p�, . Au, h6T, :� ���•5 �J,14t �f6Z�.4±Yk, , ty, Boaj�,r�d oft q{ I:iaJi1.�a doo q��q y 'g j,{t ,y� [E .J�6, ,,yam{ �k: :5e R4 ., ,114iAa kw 4i, din • of �@ rye ,,y� g,yy� pr i. 4+r�� kY�14� n lis.��r� Id I „� �y yy,Lyl a si y� I f d .iuiw luilt cofix p0fft,},� "O��,,�� } y.,�6. j � C Wf:;'?4iYMAGw' tityuAdo,4 h ' a � d y i� IR %f R,6 1 1}y� y 4x1 c lu :To W y t R l .�yyj� ow pro dw Tl'1 'i5t 0jag ' d. }. �uGit tdv .1 1 ' � M of I� I tVIA.., �. 4 ow 00,00th text Am, Vol Wt g" aft ib" Ot 4vVow no 04 140 to + Olt a" io ., ,,ay,tua ii0pilla'd: Viet 06it see jut M fidt . G 'M w71Gti�Y'^kii`Wf' iiMYx✓6WWM^�R 1T^' L �..W�M+.N.'Fsn M,F I FseAt 116cfi ' ; acv e � X046 gets ro ' g oo the" Opo fad" b Met .I. �I d� 6u 114 it it +i+ '�e' isgdg' i will e6an11.1 to i - *44,0106 mi fa WordVIA ta00h 6fa _. l A4o, UAW � m ha � l �'��� dc� 0�tcr,�� �` .� ,. �. �w�.r���� ���" ice` �ri��.�i�i� �. , 1 ltd tliar I a'ueb cars, + iAnd dtly 0,badOL+, '. MCI �for OUAim x VA dl sy 06 ve Will ta` Wit til the . r ' whoheed, ,. ih, ;did Ito and l?1.�0 fu tiho hedrinq Water ox(jutO* An *J, Uub AA fdow i N+ali Of ' 1lo' 'load'. ' + P JIM Xbon't the tufty�Ing, 6"viriftfodilt,41 ' or it lsthbulti'dl bft du d makaAtie ''-Old igd:��'tO +aw In that thvd, It rwid lautall ftac�al With :; day ddhjfj,;. • to "itsAiatutal st:Atdo� o' t C' apparent from similar and . e, k,pro,3ec e coiomic., p,a t,jj�_j brun now n• ohvit6nme'htaI reat6h!� cause a cons I c 46 truct"on re%4 ok. dppj� idant st%ch as this ono not to, d,bmiplete the measures that the y !qet,, ...out in goad faith to provide: " .Q Or cbi-icern'i thdrefdrd, thatatti�hlpt bi-. : an the applicant prior ;to the Ya made �by, t 'Of - -'-RC 1. Ic a :1 . 6nme'j to w- i t -h partildul.-Arity, what efforts wi 11, be m4do t6l co mpleto the mitigation measures disci tgecli and to ii1sure thdie, dt''OMlotion PI'! V by spedi. IC-, akt0t,and tb e cost, Of those twtti s ut e s IIx N=D, TO XPEb ,ti '8, PROCESS t *31 comp•J ains that the procea's }fes to Ceh far, t6b brig. We dgtdo: the P r 0 d;e 8sin t, t, hbhas sen A, lengthy one. Howe ve.r, an a th ijriod. in VO I V6d' dhow I and large, . lthese dolay§ been cawed bythe apoli, c- an' b Tile HGF wins to be f 40 by uio alppltoaht in e-arly, b ,5 be c -'em erp 1 )8'4't ti ok many toht.,bs thereafter, t6 1,6 E 6hy port of the EIA to the Cdlif6enila Board 'of tj'ate-r, thoreV e agency. ':�rther i.n the early 6prili! of 1585, tlpj'll Iddilt met With thO DeP6ftniebt, Of t&tOr kesourcta.4 o thei T3 -LM o' the butte � ctoik Trac, I ' Cbuhdi1j. at tho dito to, disct1l 0 il j7 new orbob!gdlT+- OA;-. il, , after tab - at . sib: t,jInet t*11at any:wtittdil spbdieidatiohb wded presented td any dE tlie abbvi�i ti haVd beeh causer by tllb Ipplidlamto and We WoUl bbjectt to, tI.o -'616te issuance of !iden td dUr4 a CONCLtl$IO r � A s inda.ca.;ted abnva' �.;tt�le teas'..... 11 t:nSC - , bn Wi1 ' the I �. is I We tjoe in this cash should bepecitecl. fip�al.caK's concern for w � e'canom�cro'asors g�ve�is �at��e evi�erace or� ���� cor, Ohyl a ;l r burden Will be' Cc'1txSed b cid: eCi1� rt7Ct3S y p of ec5mttten and revIbw r not;m forded M w It is' therefore, mir ca t�etn, Wi goat' th4 ' dd . iott t� I u� <° hose tech spedikl i b , dj th E'ER prncfwed rx t ' no>+tft� 1 tithe irslta,ng ttia �cetise. schedule ptio.rto ' ' • •' bATL b. ,,, �?.�' ► X 8 5 *� I , ttspetuI� lY subm,itted., t h DOUCLAS B JACOB do bc'hai • F N I v w tiL SM2VlCE.; � �( Y .Y a W t h'a~roby c: t Yt eta h�.s ci�i s���r ad �h y t'3 for rp �► i'ig docutent, all ;parts is admittt i to 'participatel rooeo4i1�t kef=6 mCtt thF�erae;t;gytq acy CoMmistion and. sport +,ha Vddetdl tfiOtJ Ylttlzx ctb y Camp k t py tis by oauOi,Ytca b � bo ttta3.�.ed� cS'btaLje pr�opaid r to d4dh of 'said �t dutoa t h"10 day of 00tobar t Yy r CGtl��t"ixtti�.a k:. .I � LJVUI�IJ:YA� IJ•i ���C��J. _ Attothoy p6dew Road Y Cal .i.forn a 9,065 ya�r+`aµµyy +ty Y y: Y f; Y' ki P 9:, r z 4Y Jawar h fi eimi if o� Vit' DOE, ►% � ! OfiamlhaoiA lot'i ,�Iarii i t 1� M I k : ' 1 'a�" Tho Y Mott + I Ot ley 'th, thlo axe h4bi tat ws, O It both Pf . .iv, wabi1 4 tub o- Y t e" oft A Ot abi tho U4161 a end. erome, A" fee flotra4tit"intiote t 1 -la, a'd'o-i, Ohtalff ba + k s;,4 1 1. Y � fti Rill 66 lent ieJl+ iu,.t 'that ;b i�Lali 1' by 6upy i n th'+ f i ''�iitr, It tk y ; $l* , 'rl rlrtr illi, ,p„,,` eonti z �u{ ri ll shly� r ttlOati rt ea Id b - Nw gem, 4 th '0�r �� ' it s � gem, ��tty� i.� urad1lbwi l 11 B; 00 U 2.4 leas ftidh i Z,PtW#d t -ati l liff If div iso-#11;11 'Who At tho r� ��04� jIN Uia ilaior � Of the Ufot y� r