Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
83-85B ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTS 2 OF 8
4 —27— noise 27—noise and it ct,eased human activity. Audit-ional lorig-term project- r elated 'impacts to plant and animal communities would be proportional to the degree of erosion and mass movement attributable to the original project construction. The loss Of the cahyon's scenic and recroat.iohal values would' constitute subs tantifAl. adverse impacts The proposed 85-mile�lc�ng pipeline would have a major impact to the visual quality of the canyons The loss of this area as a visual attraction is sig=nificant because it cannot be replaced in character or in proximity to the public that currently uses it The proposed project would eliminate the semi -primitive recreatiapal opportunities of the carryon, which are currently protected by the BLM's `Rodding Plan. Tho project is incompatible with the primary uses and values Of the areai which have been established through public support and involvement,. V1. CoNsuILT11'1'ION AND C;'ooRDINA' ION Commission regulations require pcospective applicants to consult with the appropriate resource agencies before filing an application for license This constitutes an initial step in compliance with the pith and Wildlife Coordination Act, tiie Endangered Species Act, the National Historic pre servation Act, and other Pedera,l statutes. preapplication consultation must be complete and documented After the Commission accepts the application, formal comments may be submitted by concerned entities during the public notice period. g pplicati,on. The followi.n agenc'�es commented on the a, Ac enc pate of Letter * Departments of the Interior July 18 1984 * environmental Protection Agency ,lune 27, 1984 * The Resources Agency of California June 28 1984 * county of Butte, California August 2, 1984 * Indicates substantive comments. The Applicant responded to the agency comments by letter dated September 131 1984. The following interventions were -received for the proposed Project. xnterveno�7_s Date of Letter California Department of Pish and Game May 16, 1984 County of Butte GMay 17► 1c 84 pacific as and Electric Comi�any May 17► 1w184 [�utte COIML-y Trail Council July 16,, 1584 P.T. Persons May 21r 1984 . ir.:>,, /vi+I.a 1 u' •, • «w. M'ir.4lfn.:.iux,.... i„JnVx+Y"i+ "rN fMxW rvt.*H.+'h+'hA 4 -28- VII. LITERATURE CITED American Fisheries Society, Western Division, management 1,982. The best: practices for the management of wes'ter n rip a:ians ream ecosystems. Bethesda, Maryland 45 pp an J P Ward, and R.J TerrestrialB1�c,kfL.A. B,ren , ` vertebrates of the Forks of ButteerteZ' 1983i pro, area. Appendi�t Dr gCIC. 198, applio'ation for li_cdn,�e fot, the. Forks o Butte Hydroelectric Proj€_ct, FERC No. 6`8961 California. Burnett, J.L., and C.S4 rennin s. 0001 1962. Chico Sheet. California DiViaion of M. nesgic5acraOf menCalifornia, California r Butte Creek Improvement Company, Energy G1 oW p� Fgy Growth �artnershi I ECIC ih Gtou and Ener for the Forks of Butte Hydroelectric 1983, Application for license roe California. Y lectrac Pto3ect, FERC No, 6890, California Energy Commission. 1983. P 104w83-001. 5acrafnento, California, a, Jport nnelectricity. azyt gg3 y. 01361 PP. Plus appendices,. Dawson, B 19II4. Hydro project, proposal sites Fatad%se post+ May 4, 1984. A-7. buebenclor Er983a. Introductibin to 'rf"ek eI�., and A.I.A.I Kubert. botanical resources. Appendix E, BC1C 1983 a for license tor the Forks of Butte RydroelectriG l�rcatio' C`ERC No, 6896, California. d r E and ;4. I�ueberw oder T r I.. Itubert, 1983b. concern. "A Plants of spec' Appendix tar BCIC, 1.983 a the Forks of Rutte Hydroelectric Project, FCRC prb'ect f(ar r pPli.cati.an for lt�ense California. 7 o 68961- Forsmanr ED., E.C. Meslow, and Ei.M. ' biology of the spotted owl in Oregon. Wildlii ehL, 1984. DMstribution and member. 87. 64 pP+ ohoge6phs,; Flinty R,A, e and F.A. Meyer,and its impact o1977. The DeSabl,a-C6nterville Project n fish and wildlit-e. California Department ot Fish and GameUhpubliashed ]rile report, Californaz. 39 pp., Cited in BCZG, 19830`appli.cat�ion-qion 2j rfornto, license r the Forks of No. 6898, Cal.iEorna, Butte Hydroelectric,'Project, FERC Ceoloocal Survey. 1970. The national atlas of the United States; Uf ArAerica, beparL-ment of the 1'►ttevi r, WashingtOn, D.C. 417 gip. 1 � . . •:1 ',.:'.y�• 4,1 ii:Yro, rM1W .k..+411 rh4.11Pb Mw:riM Mw7.e W MHkOM4141 MlW1a« Robbins, C«S», Bruun H.S.zi,r, and A. Singer. 1966» Birds of North A.mez ica. Golden Press, New Xotk. 340 ppi Za;cn- 1�1;. 1514i, Habitat management series for unique or endangered species: report no4 joy spotted' owl (Strix occidentalis). technical. note T-N-242'. .Bureauof Land Management, pepartment of the Interior. 2:2 pp VItI. LIST OF PREPARERS John Staples-EA Coordinator, ator, Wildlife, fe, Vegetdtion f and ildlife Management) Alternatives tin part) (,Ecolog�,st; M.S., W Carla M. Rurzyk--Cu�.tural Resources (t�isturiar�; 8.A«, EiistorY}' dames 1461'mes---Socioeconomic ConSielerations (Ejranomist B.A , Economics) dames B. Layzcr-Jgat.er Resources and Visheripe (fishery Biolgist.; Ph,biv 200109Y) - Peter A. Leitzke-- C"700lag and Soils (Geologist' M.A. , Geological. SCienootl OF Gregory ;14 ,Mannesto- - Aeczeat3.on and land Use (En VironMental protection r . Specia-lint, M.S., Outdoor Recreation). John A. Mitchell---EA 5ditot (Wvi-�d,itor; E3:S:, 1yocial Science, tin postgraduate work in g David C. Starkie--Visual. Resources (Landscape Ardhiltect; B.L.A. Landscape IArchitecture). Gerald' R. Biqa 'soh---Need for Power] »Alternative$ (in part) lr�ngit eer B.S.E iE- o' General tnOih6er7ng) w ,t�. { osz�r G, Larson, H.G, Oscar Larson & Associates Kenneth G. bj jj 1j, Ax. Consulting Engineers o Lend 5urveyars John C. pima, LS EdW1n E. Iiudson, R.E. ]ames.W. Crebtree, L$ $ot • 001) 4d5.20d3 r;asylCnk Telex: U SA + 6377H579 reef + R dSax 3808 + E CA 9$ reke +. 3 Third St : u Int'I : WON, OSCAR lAkSON °' 13'aa�t%gip �%Pf1Yl�ICt irs. Bettye K� rcherr Director County of Butte �ply toz QTS: � ��b5:� R., 43 6 plann' Deet 20 becember 198 7 County Center brive Orovill0, CA 95965 Subject. Contacts for rork's of Butte Project bean Bet: ye - Xen. Da,tJ n asked me to :60 zVard to you a ,list, of contact ad(jresteo t�iat w� cane for the Forks of Butte proje t. I and send�n have list for the g� you s Copy of a MC project, as ��� as a "sting of organizations We have, canau ted with directly, Please note that Y do not; hav0 the consultetibi list beingused n by the State 'Water Resources Caritrtil Board, �-Vwi1L-kms attdhding your 7 January heariri you staff report; along with the Meeting arii�ounc lesser e. a iwo Lop sexlrl 5incexely OSCAR CARSON & ASSO� MATT!,$: U4AOc , IeAwdk R. Chad Roberts Director; Envirolbl' nt&l SertriCes !Miclbt B1C�,CSSLtrE tubi a, rp f taitd Managemer L Uk alX Dis riot op.' jce Pedd l - gtod isoDrttce Area o Pc4dingy 56002 Calix-ornia tiopart ri Of 'i h Calito Regi0h 2 1701 �timl u c j 8Ufte l.Wdho Co `dova, CA 95670' Cad i o=iepa of Patrks & Reateatiori PA J�bk 2.3g0 $-lcxamerttta; CA 55811 btaft September 5? 1gHS 9p 6 485, ....--.. e so Alex. 5`a:sonralti l0i-esldent tertx 1161te held' r esi, gilt tatte Cre s �CMPtOvemeilt Company Vice peegideht L ,VW � tiY._ A , �..d59p 912 Caatlb �oqk c6urt Chio6# Cal- kt_ Liyr py� �: fth AVOnuaVL Ildw Y'60 b6p61'tfWht 64 the Afty 0�► the e of �ri 41J-U-8� LJ�G��Y' '�� ��� ��ir��'l�ii sneer Yti_ Aitihi�tgtotiy X31 . Atte �► A -ycs �� tie 56ta` } A sta ►t so+ + tar r t� i�r a 'for, bove"" opmollt and, ; „'* y' , 66240 t t f 6C6f ttri At,tri� ������ 1 t : , �C xe k For69t Sbrvide p}C�-box 2417 � Co des C}i e t rerat'it�n sq �y UAW U r W aebld' lob , 8urve 405 Ratidn'al Cee Adgton�� VA; i290ii,t �ar�iara. �C�eht��P1�x 9 on teVille polder Admin3atrati�c�l��+��arido��.,'�erof �0i fox Oortland OR n '' t� i atii I �i'v NOAA RM6 68,00 b�partment c�� �+�mri�exce l4tfl aad cdrrat.jtut.a:on lybhfi It, 'fan be Attori�e,�� Gen��a� dad 1�a�l�n� �`�� � �, _. y Ir onti tt Aaaistant Atte rnejr GcYC+�i�a' Pacific' �`s Y�1d.en �- ari' ete" e Camparly Dparttnen berti DStnaagea lepitty ACtc�rtt et1e `a p �� 1'6x 7442 5 h eAnelbcev, C-Alllt6enja J4120 5aera;Me ltci j CA 98814 .�elf�ert 5�emse� untbi1h5P. deer e g� Ift�irir Tornfatiag.. Gd1�ntt butte Cdurtt�► Tcn 6t, Paradise 5599Skywa Center DY"i+ie Or f�ti i Ca�:�c�i�'nia deb i e, Cal- drtii � W,Au. yXu,sr�i:wY:q_. � � '.�, _.._ .�}�'M.1r�wwr�, X,W.�""'w�"Mk'"r.+�^F 4CYgn, ��? �`�����.� �•"w�` ,�*� ���� .I 'w�� �L&Jr my 6m, 01eastat� ot 'the Ati rpeeMn 6 u tlth +�i�ifg Otte. u�1�Xt� y vtkohi'000h bd 103.4 dati, ditieb bog IM Whotbe 10,240 CA, 09223n , nrt iC6flmonth1#tbjbct i t5tit i 41 w UddhillObtl 'DO 20013, y R : ftled V1R,6.0 ftvl it'd I, A* ydc►�tdy ��ya;� ' ia�' t��r��.�0h,L X �{�c .y �y i F � �i�.4 i4►6 Vh �' V 4 ia,fl LA'S t°tti W W4 ����� ��iogi��i �uz�re�►� �rt�� ���tn���;� A��ia� .��x�rn�� a�ie��� lwwtio15 �X ��b��! i It getaatt suftb iii 4r IIa�t Tyyi1at�� 5116lt� iix� 097Zt1# bald. �c�. d cs '� t t �ti y h e Paalf id dad a i� i stn �r�lry5 tav b6pa tffidh nnsn ROS Mgt 6U id MR 7442 tea i epi 6tsMille 9mi prand''ig�6� GaZifa hia"" 14 th d, wik"� aci (il�ICct'tiit�i a� $tib aii tartr60 s�4, 1 e/6 'Mutual tnorqis 1260, pini ttre,t sgltd07 walhut Cre'dki ex, 9406 �r Yuba dity 61,1forhia, gorqah6d With 1681 81rd Auto . , 1 A4 tial + Yt', ,d 09101, Nthwi', `Plitual Una C toa"ft Clio, 111PIOW) mfmfl*"�. H104 o 0. O 1 1, if � t 'l �`p� p���yy.'�yy� Wt, (����,$�, ��y� F : iA 4.iR'4G•lY i. O 3.i.R R' i; Af Ar' 7y71o1:' I.�VT4 w �4[!'19,u ty o YA6pta At� _ y� Vit' 4w '6 iiia torva"C) tabar dad" With N 64calit6mid, 0$9,63I _ TR# burro w jaebk and" Rte'a'A AL is „- r 11 r . n. "ata a@+.'{ref";s.{*:�, ' ."S*`,[r., 'sxj""w.yre .Mq •a':.,.4`,l' +�" t'+;xs* » i ,0 y,rm r r , r ,ung �# "fir r,C..+,:_�•`• � �� � a rs r a:Y rt",`� ...:� a ",� t>I..y , "�+� '"3Y��`t"k ' . �.�.+o � ' '.a TC .r �` �d'• s�' �, `. S � `� � **, ' - ue x; .x � 6 ; J^ ,"w y y+,pj,a '�'+� �»,x r.Ly, p * �Ntti � �..^ i�+°�;"� '4 '�-• � rad iq-� �'i'ai" '� a� n� � +� �" [+n e ?'�S •a e4 : '.,.`" �i� V��"'+' �tj..war it .�Y"'"A����+a"�k �. �" `�, � � w� � « 'i � � > v+<S t b G� •rrr a .a t� ii,� ^#'sa.. K'" xn. t +.r. . -"re g'1 *` s1 Y� 'SAi P 1°' t'p;R'� ?. yIM, x � � rsra dm �wr t L � ��'� azo +a a,,i., "'+r.•Yl, a+�'r � tiw� �,�e: �•k u ,n v � wL r� y�.4��� � .irk ' •� >; �, ,�,,,'� ,i r �y . � �^° �� °x� �'SV�� �"�s+`�"4 `y4. ��'.�n-,�'Fi �.�"F of �,"�v+y�tyt a�'✓��:}J+� °�bb.7.r x'S� 'sy �w'av+�":; �a� 't.`» gyp Y �i."?'� '' �' �x.. �f °,s°'r d,�''� ".;`+,'kwr} "b :CA' keg,:,'i1ro i. r 41�'c^t•i,,, *rey 4..t "P. "`'' 4e:^ ,e". t�.,Y'.. m ��' w hti .,ry r""� r '. L u'".; P. -*6 �'µ•fi" 1 wr �A. Iti :�eW�rC•rw'*�:;,j�� y4 �. +`.s'R�.-p '"� J""'+w "• ka N" t '�k.•$ +>. �h + r�'`"1 w"'.>..at pja *�r•. a 8•mc E«;i. i vq^4 ...dye' .a �m r�--s § t'%",, " ,"1^,' w 'fi &�l�u•' .� U w+ y - n '�+,� �%N k y, 3r l '� . +"• vi ,y baa yy a� �w �h� b! '�.-•.�rr�j7'� "a',< _+�r ,.a rt��i�',��h��X,,;n��• ��c'"TY.pw".'.-yam ,"Jxs �„y 'jic, yY,.. � �, *, a, *'a i m' ri '� :ice Dly k a kr' Y x vn ��>� t� s, ��k ga „+... �"�`�r.,r"'tr��,•���.aYY;�'prC�.�," `� r,'�,w ,.h",� w� „o'p,�,. �,�, w��.�t. �?V,.; s yv�wi 7 �� ";h + �Y,�°b' +,n.�- . �,��"�'�sh w•h,,�,y' '�E;»M�r. ro'� '�+%i`" "�r�` }5y>Yi . ryr�"5r'r�'i� � .�*.ifdr�+� 't,�„z'i�i§ y.lpw'�S N^� tYitireW. +. . :l"� xa xn ; ,a M ,,,.,n`'k':tp > ' -' s4 1!`y'q�-- r y 'U { '.w.'.¢ `pp w •Yj: �'1'iw:+A K°...3Ki 33,, X l yfGr}q!:.. w t ' *n J - .• p;,.gL y .i �;p reZ sir`" ''" .r+vyw ,.LLy �"CA" S T•dyZi : : kV�,L_'c['..1^":_,yW l":Y w,d'3 y� k w+4a`✓" t'1'">1 "„ +r..t"'..waa�. r,9Zut3v a;� ,!'rxJ} >"�, ,"�_�` `" � a r�" ,y e�y a @''� ",ery ".,+�� r� ,rm,rW , °m[ ��•� �^"wntaxR jTAn � v. x �t,y-.z,+ *u���� � ..7 r Y ��r�"��y;�: re,q�ey,. .. �s� -,,,,•„R .w�, . „ •q -- 1 1rT6 F ap t w <wa. V'A' ` x"� ��f'' � 7 '�'� q�e,�$ '�` ln, o- 1Fay«�;-�� �`i� y'a • - S'`,'«.m•-cid""`.,^,^a�a'<i"`,.a.�,:�reS+R^n. p.,��;a...*iJ;M.sy, '-�'t kb .�£,rex;s1�`''"«.,,'TM'. 5'�•,i�,N N"�t«Fit�Y'.11s'k":".F�:`" tF.:;�. Baa F»,t ..."2, w }"-"•.-.< 1�w4 y, d .. }pt� yM"7'P R 's ',� °in a'r: da" X3ti �` •. +.#„�.7, .@"* .�,, lit. � "'�; #�•. �„ 7� � d"""'�-A:.�} �. .�+ rr,�, aP' {t ,�, ��" a ta�"" w«,,'y hT ,�, y�"�'"-*.�--'�.. %�'�' T"^�"w �h > �Jp� 'M.i' s ''�'"aNv4r $?;�.�-`-'`�a,v r, :t �'�""ix y, ,y�'��•`.i' z i, <+G:,µa ,a„°'kF � ;4`a'� r +A Kj,+� �..i`f+ "�,��,�,1���'"'�t x ,y, ,�. �'«rw'�i !� w a1•R'?rd�..a,�. �'r r f'Gt"��y�s'.c .: *'» w ,+F. �.,p ,a :�j"w 4 r ,}, y"..r�+"'n:'7_nN^.;L `�,'. 'y„P$3, 'k�:,��°.a rn '�.rri ���i',.,,,«,>°'��.,��'�t�'"�yrs-'�r,4.�=,"i �,+pie. ?�" S�,G"' "•�!"�L,��i"�'ti 3i;J4« �.,. -�.a;r�„y,,,�, cY:y, f��'�`As ��w��'�.rE°!*'4A.�tTM�Psaa��a.`�,"M�'t�., � a..tS-� : u ". ia:::+rx. '3 »Y 's0.'i` c .`•f �" .. -� ,:ys Ir ,7y , e,1.W , N '�" ;. e S ., k'ws_ x.S uq,. ,''a .r +�""y aY F ••t"G•«in. Irl pn'rt""?°�a�',}j�.4. w�,�,4i}, 4~y �� �C��`''..�:.�+'LL�;>���^�,�.grt��I''�+"��+a"»w�A� M M� M Y' eta Ri '4�. ":8 .w r' +.,, w ,...,, •i * ' ' 'r'aF'y, ;'.R. '"Yi a a•s .+2 �. " x k' re+ M° '4+"I.µ1sr "Man, 4` ai' ,, 'd" rn p' "', " 1y ", r..• P' ��, �li,'4aaa���k�,,y � '�'• g+q+` 4 :3�����*.. .,k,.V��'•F; -. ..ice' �'y', �} ;�'� �1 �' '�?���I; ya"a'��,5 '1,%�'�;� s,d���w�� a ,y,�`.� �'� '�"=i" "" M �'+.;.� b er ".� Za. '.ji" is 1 ^x' :R. 'GY �'. " .1✓ !i'.L'r �'s,'.�S /ti ".n:.T � 4 ^ X` �4;i?Y4� �� e •4 Fx. i� �,Q4'?Y � '�'� � rer, �'� 4 � $+r "�, r � i^''{+•,' �. •i. ' ids � � r �;h %�iw,..�;'S»X"+s�, � °6��'rw r""'�{"w.',�"'i{, �#igy �µ'a`Ss w t ,� 1���,�r5,a'w •A s -•,ern � � -my ' ��'�:•�• ,� � r'r � a , r atm, **R` ��� �� � �; .. }e�,�+� ,�. � ��wia�»� ,Lu,„,,k. �.�C Y �� 7 az �" � �i v< n� •h` .,.,T. "� � p. � w,. it ;.: *3x ti"�•. `'�i,� �a"�"'� t �� .0 `".", mai R " `^"C 'h�•i.'�l�S".,l„�'<UE' g���.�'�;�a;.r`.'',�,'�r{�+ ao "r. r �' ¢ {R s. dp;i" .y,.���'� a 'C.t,.��$1.2'3,.iad"'iC'1'K +t,�,4m�.5"�3.m�Il!k•�T'Ys! �p, Y r`"`".:11�"�''i3ur'r� b �,. 1("a +"�`•",�;,,Wk'�„'i� ��$"�',y� ,�y�d�+.� Ae�' ..y���C'� 4. ,x4. ,�'* � ��« -. t.: � ,�'�• R'�'� "�' ,�a,,� , ,�r ''kICs�� �rrrw. -�n °iT f' „ .i ,%;...;fat,�.,. � *`� • �` � a aaFa "� " ��•� .tr ';ti:;it"1 :,r°1°5 �^'4.0 'k+1c,+'�"'` ..'.{"�,_«',,�a�+I" �+nwYCi,a T,F• .r.,+?M"tuIr+" v�: a- s`.r Y.a.. "F,i•r ,�, Mµ'; `g._". ��------ , w,a p "".` �}P+ r .. +: •4rY a �;ta�`�wwni,'�'n �.��.°�'` `�? r.�, � � �" «Y4yv, � n ya �n.�"':.ca�'�,y ���2 �k � ��y.re?Y� - F.%r � ��;,,.'�Q�'�° "xcog.-" y Ml Mark Padabaugh P. 0. Boit 329 Chico, California 95927 January 3, 1986 Butte County Board of Supervisors County Admi ni strati ue Center 25 County Center Drive Oroville, California 95965 Subject.- Forks of Butte H.ydroelectrfic Project / Comments For January 7, 1986.Public Nearing on Draft Environmental rhipact Report Dear Board Members: I would like to present the Board of Supervisors with the following comments and concerns regarding the Forks of Butte Hydroelectric Project. I understand that these comments will be forwarded to the State Water Resources Control Board who is lead agency in this matter. I also understand that Butte County is a responsible agency regarding this matter, My greatest concern for the County of Butte is the fact that its General P1&n is Inadequate to address the issues and matters related to the proposed ;-project. Specifically, the County s mandated Conservation and Open Space Elements fail to meet the minimum requiwemehts set by Government Code Sections 65300.5, 653021 65302 (d) , 65302 '(e) t 65302, i t 65560 b) 65563 (a) , 65563 (b) , 655641 65567; and 65570'(&-d � The Conservation Element of the Butte County General Plan is a twenty-two (22) page pamphlet adopted in 1977 which briefly �'� g Countibesrnome of e terms afmeetin4rsthe re u3 natur'resources, found in the q red scope of general plans, the Conservation Element contains nothing that could lead one to believe that Government Code Section 65302 has been adequately, met. There are no rolicy statements, ob ettives standards or, tan pri n.ci pl es; p menta Th vel of p pro orals found in this Ele a le detail found i n the so-W l ed' Cohservati on Elements vari aur' discussions is limited, very general;.and covers each discussed topic In a hap-hazardous and i ncoinpl ete manner°. This "Elemnt' e' does not even consider the County's forest, and mineral resources Butte County Board, of S:.uper`vi soy -s Forks of Butte Hydroelectric Project January 3, 1986 i n`its limited di scuss i ons There fs no discus' ion of streamsideland,use re ulaons watershedmanagement anti protection, critical habitat, rare and endangered plant and animal spedies or energy andhydroelectric` resources, among other concerns. The County's 1977- adopted Open Space Element does little to improve itself over the so..called "Conservation Element.d it also does not substantial l y cortpl y- with " the requirements of Section 653.02,, Thiess Open Space Element contains twelve (12) Pages of discussion �+hfch is interspersed with non-binding recommendations. but with no policies, objectives, principles, standards or Tan proposals, The, he Open Space Element contains not a single map an"correlated text to define and designat_e.open space lands pursuant Government Code Sections 65560 (b). This Element also fails to, -define, critical open spade for habitat, recreation, or scientific and natural studies. The County's Open Space Element contains no action plan as required by Section 65564. Butte County also adopted an optional Recreation 'Element ih 1971. Thind1socudinTlthreemaps. eElement consists of ten g... The (10) Pales, !Recreation Element" faces the same judicial insufficiencies as just described for the "Conservation" and Open Space Elements. The "Recreatio'rr Element"' contains none of the ct,Iteria-required by Government Code Section 65302. "' "s of itself to Nor does the Element correlate or coordinate a` y situatilnvaluessuch aandhpot�n�ials �'outte uld beopa�sal where t ec reati ono prerri'i um. (The Bureau of Land Management hasi concluded that the site of the proposed Forks of aU.tte project is a high quality recreation,' area. " This so -cal led �Recreat j�on E`1 e�nent s also 'clearly inadequate°for meeting the minimum planning requirements of the Quimby Act or for Roberti-Zber g park, and recreation grants, The: situation is further agtyravated because Butte County is one of onlyrseV without a countywide parks only several California counties The t -o allow a situation where gravity of thYsafiButt�uisiwitho�such��as gray the Cohn open Policy'and action uta conservation or p pace poli y program of even the `minimal standard to condudt a minimal General Plan policy assessment for this project. The Board, therefore, will be unable to determine whether the proposed project is consistent with the Conservation and, Open Space Elements wheel considering necessary permits and 2 _ Butte County Board of Superviors' Forks of Bunte Hydroelectric Project January 3, 1986 entitlements required for the proposed Forks of Butte project,. let alone preparing and forwarding written comments' to the State Water Resources Contral Board. If Butte County does not have'a sufficient conservation, comotenNhelement so as to either literally or substantially Open 'space p y y provisions of Government Code Section 65303, the Butte Count General plan is therefore invalid as a general plan Count . lacks �a Valid general plan, t meeting the requirements of Sections 65300.5 and 65302. if the y y 9 p he County may not lawfully approve an subdivision or parcel map or enact any Zoning ordinance or issue any certificates of compliance or, certificate of a caval (see Camp vs. Mend�cino Board of Supervisors, 123 CAT, Aop: 3d 334October 5.981 1 also have additional concerns that include the following; 1. Need for Projdct. The California Energy Commission has concluded that there is no immediate need for hydroelectric projects of this scale,, It is clearly i nappropri ate ' to proceed with this project until, a clear need' i s establ ished acid all local' planning and environmental requirements are t6tt by Butte County. 2 betrimental effectson pisheries The proposed . proj ddtwill si ni f•i cantl y reduce the local c�mhensator y, j... y: tiga p pp a and P y mi g tion: Pull a lication of Fish �e udi n � sport, �i slier i�+i thou, ade uat aryl Game explained; and exte ided to the proposedehdIu Code Sections 1601 1603 and 5537 should Potential application . iproject, ,. 1 udi eg' In the dEIR. � Cod p Section 5943 should be examined described and Game the dElR and mi t i gated; In r a Butte CouhtY 8dard! of, Supervisors Forks of Butte Hyd'roelectfc Project January 3, 1986 3. which 1� Epotioo.- The 'proposed;_ project inadequately -controls 6�0-erosionfroln Construction and 00st-cobstruc,tioh physes. the-,dEIR should not be approv6d or certified untill the CoufttY Of Butte has ado te4 a initigating dh erosion dtrol ordfnandd 'ch applicable to Conditions presented by this,rapos'ed Pro'Jdct. furthermore; Butte Creek it, a cr:4fdal' sal mon spawningStlrdlao and fcluded In protections covered by Fish and Game Code Sections 1505, 1601- and 1603, These Codd sections are not examined and mit'gatedto the d5M 4, Nolse. The Proposed projectis1101, t Y. e r� � —se impacts 1:00'dt bd, add Ua�el' mitigated under CEqA or State PlAnhinj Law until the ; Cdahty of . Butte adopted a noise control, ordinance WHO is doplidab to COhditiOn"S' presented by, the' project, t Would like to thank the,80ard $or W� opportunity to nbm;*it comments on the f=orks of Butte Hydrs its dra de ectric' Project and ,f �IR- t would Wrecidtd yo-ur writte" response to these comments. Most sincerely; Mark 4 TnAvERs► JAcons & vjCjtR file 19 MAID PZA1160-N RdA aCiNAa 41i, tpAvc�ea /►rt�►1)rtt, J�t,i1r01iie:.�1: F aaua►As ..�aGows ` ' ��.�{i� :i��, 4fy��iit�% um R1 NCAN �. Rtl0(r" 4�C %g '3Ct7�� November Cohn Cordes -John Eastwood Ass76ciate;; now 10'tombard Street# Suite 410 -san Franciado, CA 9'4111 Re: Forksof butte Project near ai'ohn }os i writing r and out �' amtirncr�n ern n a the fpr��e���teart�rcu Arai. Courieei a laxly in light, of ocir recent: review of t:t�e supplement t'o the draft anvi rohmental Impact report 1 ieci for the -Vorka of butte HY :roei.eatric project, .dated October lg�� _ After discussiohs with the butte Creek Trail CoUnaei other environmental organisations in the butte area# and members of the geheral public) it is the opinion of the nutte C -reek grail Counsel that the prd�ect as prop6.gdi in the suppi.emeht to the draft irotltnerital i,mpastt part. fa, considering all � p indludin recreational, aea etic and environmental,lthd best possible project for any' farm of hydroel.e;ctric project on 'tatte Creek within the area designated. 0 Viausly„ tha rec eat#orial et aeathio and environmental resources of the, area oul:d be best served by the '"no project alterhativeO but, in rev`iewing the cur'rei�t laic cue f`t that it willr have i.tt,l.e impact upoh those resbtirces, and therefore appears to be a 'viable pro jedt from out prrsspecti��, There remain two things that d6tideth us with the draft. environmental iriPdt report and its �upplemei t, Vie of, ali;j the doeumeht seeds to envisi6hl a set Of Wood, steps a"t the diversion i6datioh ftft the 'ro6k, bank of the creek do.wi5 to the diversioln itself. Although t o kdd6,gn ze t hat aitch st opt make it! eaiji.er, ani rt�ife effectivd for htaxntaihit5g the ciit e.rsior ani` intake oh&mbeir, We are opposed til any such cdhstnc�ticyti: it is, our request that such rfi6bm-td`e dohattuctioh be.. removed from the L ' �. area and that 'the areae be left in as natural a state as it P oesibly cen be o thout Manmade st, t`cture5 cf any kind obvioui� y' the divdtition and ihtakde dhatnbet needs to be at the N, john Cordes November igo, 198 odation, but tirtciilatry, stiudt�urd6 such as t«he steps _06h end ho'ut+� b- delete from +the plan, abtir Arid of paxafnoii�t imptrrtazyoe to th the euttioi'eek Courtse grid itierrtbexsf general Ct ilrliurtftYr are t afouai;dd to etfgt xe that the plain a proposed i�f the buk l tent tib the draft r *ehviron:ttiohtal ifrtp of report � adhered toy Out we�neern ib flay r nrre the pt doers had boefieted r aria p he proposal appr6vbd by too yr rir► it `ederal arfd tatre agehoies, minor Charfges iri the; 'tructure of the plan will. 'Oddurr, , or oorti;t notion ptoblemb will, arise, thdt neoest ita a devie ion from the proposer bite greatly o� noethod that thi oould happd h4vih Bastin efL'eet. upon the r�rtvironrrdehtai# reoreat,fonai arid', aesi.hetio +�aiues ifs the f:ea. Thus j wte need bete for* of sefeguard to trail] the d rddk and the rhsouroee thorein from athe mc�difioat ottir ohet,ge, utlfdrtunate aboidaht eto tie �+ u►1dsuch Vi try happy t`o Work' with ih de elopiftg soWe r +be g you, . g Cteek Treii heltdo oh r�ot'ual a reehteht bet�wdett oursei� end sterb e7ru thatoml to lho nbure drat such ohah eb or visa trot . happens ptovision is allocated to resol�re the ptobiem in the dvdht that something abet h ppdo toe Wii1await to dieoust hast` we otrn arrarioe for such a ddhtteot orjjbtudture to safer",''U&td end endure t±he pian �s dev'iatiofi from it. prop©sbd rather thdh Any, tfub'r except es spedltied sb6vtj we bblieve thot the I oliY ed iri the sulppIOMeht to the dea.t t ahvirortme, prop oa t repofjt dated i otbber � 7 is s good dne stud it, oertait y ttie best fot:fn -of, pro e t oouid rf�rision for butte, dreek at that i 5�6ti6zt: d hope sih6d ,e'l that we, d6h Work but. Slue Form, of safe tier as didau6sed'r Arid that rho pfcipo6ai hili Xhavie, far+Wtf±d with, the +�eve1t pmei t Of' the, pra oot� fh dU'd a at# the east post bie effddt up6h the hatot6l t�:- �' esouroed atda 'The ''; rail ant se And Mettibdtb of the pif Join with, t�ankiii cit fa,t au' b,i,c rile ih e ard' Y... r oohtiftued oaur'tbay, and dbapdra`t ori h tti ,e g Wi:h u's to safegu,drd the aYea o opdh to but, oomt�ettts ahs kee iii,. dor beim,. p g tlidfii� firiniy ih Mihd' whim atmu rtg , iti topbsa as it #date t ti eiita . r and dot. geiiuire�,y beiii� �5cineerfied about the area► 646 condeetig, a d A, ;, - t�y�ir�►+r�t�r��r�tr�� ���� �i:��b ��+��'�� �'����` itl 1� 116JO., Ott 10414op etyAt 0,6bloy Wi*t i h i ho gou oi��l������+t bf this #imbho* Wvwv ob At booth ijr, h ►ii►r►�1 1 r9 wotvo-d, the eolddl ii► 1 hi +++ to Kiri i t the t the, pr + t d X11 db�r �r rti a �'+ w mr11 +rout' ' 1 Iwo It LOKb rel 6tdd tiisit-W dry �.,'tl���b-i+�� Ofit-d �, � � � f dry tIvi{ bOhdu l d ti bu`�' dit w t Alta h wd d d r �lr �° w i doh l i , bio W �Fadb Oib������r`��d,0tohdl� r i p& 1 i hd v surd v46ji 6etad bibW i t wbil td, too ��t<t�� !� lag ►'t tit �i r•rrw� d is d r h w �utcl V46001 t id Prajodt with 060hed 46ut d h d y-0-6 ''ad d' xr-1114 the t ri l d 1 � . Vida chi l F-r'tisfi bd tH ttr wlb hdi1' i , bhb d�s�c:bem,g at Or�dpowbv d � ' bhp b er t O I WO(id b�r�ri b I+r 1 "'hO tAb i wdr iiddeibgi ., Chdl���� ��r�d����. bh�lr. wc�ui'd bd. v101:Ad` 1rw Acer �" iir' bi�c+ � i i dd Met �'w�Irrr=F�►d� ����r�b hr�c� �e�� ��id��d bdtwd�o th� bN bh. �d k di tr t r~t grid th6t bti r � .� ted � ir'��w �b��rt 1~t�d h�ir•r�W�1 rd�dur�d' 1144 do thd ti r''a i Y .y clrj w# prst�r�+rdi�i r�6' tki� �� �� �±;�+�d', i�' 1��ddalbo� t6h Basked td r pt i w bh i A ijedjjb�+ # i fid dub i T t w;i :hd'r aw t wh d M41681 f w61 MI dd i rig' wh�bhe� thi ! ' i c w' r� mlftfii4 wduid bd d19fii ldwddt shy hacf eer i i�rrr ete'k d r ut, heel dc�irfmj �'f6M6.0 'L�wOdflt: sdi'd thd ka td bi t-j L-ddih t e be a sbi��eti ► r hO s4at O l die to,It r + thio- ' h6v #iaoa t6 -`dot -01515mwalAlil the u&01:0POW le -w htt Isho tha 0- prop- �k ww� r Y�r ire �i; i (Of1m, I A " OUb t l d 9106Md i 69 '06MMMn t o :an theAM I hd t 41,11 flat ih thl, Arid 19mg 40d'tlaft: } ' 6 Ad a ' h^+ for the eagm ftf nderdl PIwn dawityl Mid AP t6"t 'w4f tit' AG (f6brd , gUbj �€ ; u 'dbuhtl PdAdd h4am h-bu r' r fig, tbh§ eUd t 6h ba fithfin el 11 6't9 MY 66' ia.,.. did 6n 00 i'` i tai i3 rl f : 1 WAY Ora sl6i AM` Obw' I�'ILJNtit4t ''� #P - rd'A Wh I h, mould j h AAd i w kb, � �'' "� � � ��" � p row Hondo., ua WO ' t� iti-bi#; willl W th' °ttato -,t►i, � %►� � � ter- ��,�r%��►�,�mid tapaim, 6r, i i :' .40"T X 6 4di ahgt odt X16641. r� Ow 'Ov4r' ddAuddid Oefidttehblti,d i6 r3 tsri i i cahM+�i trig 't " ivid 'ii + rig, 4 a,, iA4 Ad6ip4a p1` ' ► ' ` 4 34 to w-vidtilfiat k I 61 t4 MRIAPUBt -1' 614 6p4tk4 1 tjfig'; IM, s#�f4r ttY' 4ie1 by, 1 n Go �,r fo1y w1t th4 9UAdAib6dd m6dt idA l6mA IdAr 6fi�w 69 f liiv ru 'e by the bd flet A 60), 1 it nr� C tib M+p:'r-grrV. VFX 4w V alai /1,Y �'�' MEQ+ M1U 'i'j y4gUi�i 1awIh _ Cf yy�g pY{`-11A., �i( a1:��_ I y�p�y !t.lI\Gi1� u,r y }� �A W M` M 41rM r WxO 4i, 'h : 1 wce l ih , , _ " kt ultieft-V m tai ki id ' Wth thy'. citshve,611.6c ; � *MAII hwN 0" e * i Imigal * ibg * diivfea rat ti6o, 10,06 struatupial13f6von Ub'le -u*d 'eft A*tglutl S` fwa f lu"- "lid. U'Ateago sit, t Od § Ato .Atle�ily e bids m "i e#ss ,661116 414 * Oaa eb, , l e `, t6itigto fit Ail to Oftv"""Wit Wuga All 0166 1"eal igoulo ent, td ffivhIfvi ► t� t� ri 4 u i l l c" the thtAka stelu°tui elague# d,to �' h t dawn mid ft-atuefi Out I f i d��' + � i 14utl Bei fi" to m* 61 0'allu' lan fig a Aldviapg afrdff%oi fie" r i!'uatle' 'o phi, uagb be,mith, fi thA, ,j y �yt��hy ire` W4 f 11 il. Ita m 1 . �M d . h1e.i nth t n Water temperatures be 1 aW 68' degrees i`' be 1.'ow the r p i'ntrak,s s{-r-Wtturet when the item creta F above the intake structure. 68 de acs res a're' below care 1t).. ROOUcel the aesthetic h . tic impacts of the. pro : a'• The 1ri,tak.e structure 115 designed;to take diverslon;fiows from a pool area in the river. To prevent, ero ton and limit construct,l.on lm acts the __.:_ . p sot 1's -b ?tposed thr ouph. earthwork Will tie mulched and reseeded with adapted grasses and f orb's permltn as possible:, Where vegetation must be, cleared to as soon whenever construct l an, the vegetat i on w l l l be taper tsut er postlb e. Sedimentation and erosion control measuresp as outlined in the California Regional Water Quality Contro'lBoard's ;Gui del t ees for Pr'etect l on of Water Oral l tv Duri of Construc•11 on an 04�erat on c�+f Sma1 _ dro Pro ects, wtll be followed in the construction and op *titin of all features of the project. b. Excavated material from the tunnel wt11 e,ILher be ad In road bu 1 1 d f ng act 1 v 1 t 1 es oN-4 1 t w 1 1 1 be p l aced on bq.rjch land neer theL tunnel outtlkt. The spoi'1 will be contoured and seeded to stabilize the so 11, and ''make the landscape more attractive. Drainage will al:so'be provided to divert runoff flows from erodible 'surrfaces. c. The eXposed;surfaces of the pIpeltne and penstock will be finished In a non-ro'flective natural color to mihimize the contrast Wi'th surrounding scenery d. The , proposed power house wll$be designed so that PortionsWill be Placed - underground (see FERC Cxhiblt F-13 drawing). The roof and walls Wi11 be painted a natural color to blend with the surrounding vegetatl_on. Service areas w111 be kept as small as Possible 1b1e to minimize the size''of the. disturbed area. e6 Specific mitigation 'measures to be implemented'on USES 'lands to minimize the contrasts of project facllitie5 with the natural environment; Will be coordinated with Forest Service personnel at the time of construction. The With the local recreation district for carne will be done located on PRPD lands, Project fac1l1t1es 11. Cultural resource impacts shall be reduced'by: a.- The crossrcouhtr y partlons 6f the transmission line roube have been surveyed. Portions along the SbUthern Pacific, r1ght-of"way that W11'1 be ut1"tIzed for the overhead transmission route have also been surveyedI and a ved,:by, r ppro SHPO. b. Changer made In the p i pe t I ne al 1 grineitit have, been covered'" by an archaeol agi c.al surrYey and an €addendum to the archaeoioglc�l report. n'UT° Gp1iT1 Pii�%'.,. �.a, _pjSC)t`.ZUTES' tl'C ob""i' ' h7�i"1 i�85 Y r !�' r The; cul dural resnurpek EdentYf1ed as CA-13UT-864 on btamonci I internatl'onat 1 and w°E i;l be: avoided by adjust no,, the pi qel i ne routin . 12. Forest Service and DF8 'wildlife biologists will be consulted t the time rampa are desifined and constructed to proylde fcr the passage of wildlife over the prOject pipeline in areas of soils too shallow bo permit burial of the. pipe. 13. Comply with Env i rronmenta1 Protection Agency concerns ;for 'water" quality protection during construction by: a'. Cornpllance, wl'th upstream and downstream water quality standards: b. 11 on control m l t 1 gat l ori measUres; as 'out i i'.ne:d prey) aus 1'y i n s.5 the rR r e. iheasures to avoid stream pollution from chemicals as outlined In USFS mitigation measures. 14. Pursuant to Section 5937 of the Fish and Game Code, applicant will release. the following streamflows 1n cfs from Its intake structure for the ►maintenance of the West 13ranch Feather River's fishery and riparian resources OCT NOV DEC JAN rtS MAR APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP fro 50 60 to 50 70 70 70 65 -wk 1 46 -wk! S0 Sb 60-WI42 40-wk2 55i -wk 3 35 -wk 3 50 -wk 4 35 -wk 4 The intake shall be In that, the requ� r^edtructure str'eamf' ow release:nstructed 1 s automatically cal 1 yhandmann i cant,i n�s7l l y bypassed« _ 15. Applicant will release. the required streamflow mentioned in Condition 14 at all times from its Intake 'structure except when the ,water v R tem erature as treasured by a recording therma;graph located 100 feet upstream from the powerhouse tailrace, exceeds 20 degrees C. At such time applicant §hall release additional watery up to' the, entire inflow to the intake:structureo as is necessary to prevent water temperature from exdeeding 20 degrees C a � pPl i cant shall a l be required u q lred to `release only sufficient' Water, UP to the entire streamflow be e , as may n cessary to ma'lntain n 2 degree C or less difference betweenwater temperature at the point 4f intake« 16 Az low re l eases and temperobure regU i rep ants w i l i be (rtOr,'+ 1 01 w,, . by a cbnt i nuous' recording stream gage and rerord i ng at two sites approved by P l sh and Dame The recur �, k a'g Q6�16 and thermographs sha'1 l be groper 1 y operated and 1nb 1 ata i red by app l i cant . Ther, da i 1 y redoeid of mash i rnU6 and. mini mum f 1 owls , max 1 mum temperatur'e's and da'i i y pdwar gen6rat i' on records ok rt iilVTY, pl.,AivENIi�i xNU'i'l; shall be provided to Ftsh arida Geme annually, by gece'mber 3l, of each; year for the Preceding October1 Sep lcembet^ $0 water year.» To prevent fish stranding► Increases to the, amount of water diverted sha 1' 1 be, gradua'1 and at a rate not to exceed,30'percent of the total streamflaw, p -or hour, 18. A fish screen aca;eptab 66 to 1 sh an'd ';ame sha.l l' be 1 nstn l l edon the Intake structure, ' and sha l';1 be properl y: operated ` and main- twined by the app'lIcant. 19. t w 111 by a method acceptable to the Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board and Flsh and Camey remove sand and sediment from the pool immedlately upstream from; the intake strudture on the West Branchur Fther;,River to a site acceptable to the aforementioned a encles. A11 accumulated materials greater- than o, equal to one-half 1ndh In greatest dimension shall be, returned 1n an ,appr,dved manner to the West Branch Feather^ R 'ver downstream from the Intake structui^e. A set f. -c1 eanln0 diversion wdir would be 6h acceptable alternative. 20 To prevent Erastori anal sed1mentatlen of the West Branch Feather River, road constructI'on and conduit a1Ignment sha11 be 'performed 1n accordance, with an eroslon control plan approved, by the Regional Water Ouallty Control board. 21 Transmission 11nes shbll be des1gne,d and constructed in such F way that they are not a hazard to rgotors. 22. A 1 1 at-aas denuded dur'I ng prro,jeet construction shall be reseeded' With nativelant species valuable to wildlife. Denuded slopes P R shall be dovered with a protective mulch or other protective reseeding technique as soon as practicable f'o116w1ng lathe work ata specific, site, but before Clctober 15 In any given year. Slope pryol;ectl on shall be repeated as ot"ten as necessary to ensure ergslon control. 23. At least '90 days pricar to start of construdtloni applicant will submit to Fish and Game for its revieW and approval, engineered draWtngs of thF-. Intake structure, the fish screen, and the powerhouZ601e tallrade: These drawings shall be deslgned by a States -1 H anded C1 v 1 1 Engineer. ' The Intake structure shall be designed to pass the 1' 00�-year flood flow and the O'utl'dt of th e fish flow release shall be constructed 'In such a manner that silt and debrl's do not obstruct the outlet and the, e tdl ease is made adCur-atr0y The powerhouse M preVeidal1.y. tail rade shall be designed �toutoma�nt strdombanl< eros l ori when' r, _` poWerhous water js relAaseoLfrom the e 24 . I�urauan o Section 1 f the Fish and Game Code, applicant ntisor Se will, the b1 innl603 n traction or a r g of pro act dons notify` F1sh . ,g and Game and enter into s Strraambed Alteration Agreement, nbt; I ncorrs I stent Wterms e6f thl�§the Department taprotect fishard w1IdlA�e�resources 'c. ur i ng pi eej jdct "during ora ,j ir�iUlYY XILIi' Cl"�4't 4tAtl 1"IJ AY�iI'a' V�11�"47 %g�. i ,4 _77., M1f r 1 I7 T,V�UI`/i. :F A URI' J!'. a y ' 1 h 6aI`A1'SSlat<i aat���i. con truction 25. Applicant wl1l, for the 1I.fe of the projects permlt ,access to the project by a9ants rrepiresaht I ng F 1 sh and Gams, without prior- r^ ornot not1 fi cst 1 on o to unsure proper 1 ndorporat I on and operation of f I sh and w 1 1 dl l f:a 0146tdct on measu res 26: Applicant will implement any remedial action and/or measures found necessary, by Fish and Game to protect, maintain or rostore fish and wi dl1fe resources adversely l`mpacted as a result of fatTUre,to, comply In whole or 1n part with bny oO' these terms. and/or conditions for the project. 21 Apo IIcsnt wI11 malntaIn and 'operste the project In compliance with the aPorementioned terms and tondIbions for the lite of the - heproject, project 9rlegardlass of whether It operates +ender a 1,1cense or, any other regulatory program of the Federal 1✓hdrgy Regulatory comm 1 ss;i oh 28 . App 1I cant w i 1 1 I ncorporate the o f ar{emen t I oned tel^mt and condi t l ons In any subse�4uent sale, lease, coriveyande or other entitlement use of interests to as to ldsally assure compilance With said terms and condi'tlons for as fang as the project generates eiectr1d power. 2�3 At the t i hie of f 1 nal des l on , 'app l I cant, w i 11 subm i t det6 1, "I ed project maps to the Cal I f am i s div 1' s I ph, o f M 1 ries, and Geo i ogy show1ncg,the 'locations where specific erosion or sedI'meat control measures will be required. Applicant will provide a comprehensive erosion, on, control p l ori' pr l or to commenc,l ng 'With construction. 30 . Per the pre l i m I nary support 1 ng des l gn hnd report r se i sm l c 1 oad i rig w i 11' be cal cUl otvd Using U.S, Army Corps of Eno i veers tM-1' 110-2-1 a01 (1960'5i, Water^ pressure' from ea►^thquake action will be appl'led to accordance with EM-1110-2-22.00. 31 Tunnel spot l matar i al will be Used for f-Ove,Oetbbi on purptises as feasible: 32� Apo. - a livable fed eras. p st,at�e�and loralastatUt+ss�yord(nancesoaner gpp t4 d re U1atlons� i r 1 I7 T,V�UI`/i. :F A URI' J!'. a y ' 1 h 6aI`A1'SSlat<i aat���i. t... ___ __�— -_ _.,__ _____T u RaVILCE, CAUFORNIA , i:i ."¢u JAN 7 E��AFiD at: t�U�t:t�Vt�alis, , 164 T '�%" -L'1� *�'1..� G' l=��r"�. '' ' 'C'�%� ��• � v"'f4"'`"' ':A,?.slti.i.; -"r �.i t 41 IC, w a � Qce Ito h ' Ir +� 1 r 2' J/ ..�eel tie;:i gs d i•r. zI `'. 'Srr�'i" y-�'•ilii'N.•g �sis••�. . '}s4 lyi ...gi =j• ...xJi t1r••1��Ii liv .,a,Y,p.11 'i'Y� 1 Pi...li, ig L. iii�ii f+'6,616, i• .IlNuili •y.i, N ".4., 1 1 . _ 1 ♦ 3s 1 t of ' . �- si •e s�.,: �•:#i.•sv ." iy sem. it 3 t- �' ;..•,gtr « s scL : ; s. ?r s ' = yI4, rg- i"i # i3•_ i 7�� � .;I '� 1,8 � R �'..,, � }, '"i`s��'t� I�. 4osi ,• � i ��� a ,t.•.•„ .i a ,a : a,.••i s i a �u,,.,r�,��+,pL''` i t3e,3.i� ;µ�t,Jr�yi1 t,•.x s�• s�n,sa'• �F .• ,_. y 1i .._ M�w.nMKtlk�i �Y5!rnh r �Y �'n - 1 � �Xl M ",f,,. :- 3, u '� � ���/✓,�1�y\)�.,/� f 'M � Nom, i �.. .-. �..-�-s. �Su1'.::�'"r :wF�u.Y.t^:•;�xµ `ri � ..' ;,. :.:�" � F i GiJ 4V' �: - ✓.4 i JJ � �t 4 k � �1 W� f✓L 4µ. �y�� '�', T Ll , 1 � q wPi�v" � 1. 4.-. �.,:t Y`J� .�' d. 1� .. 4r.A KC`a ti dolliY%" JAN TING w'ry.Xil .`.�$� #yy W M�Yy1it Y���j! Y� Ywj'HY�p+/ y�,�1 Iq't P�'/fM'� N� iWPi:1�Y:��V�� yy��R.y Y1*•:J' �d�4:,. �i'V v� ��;�Y�Ci�.�r'w'� t 'k`:�ai„ W`:L;:����. ���;'Wr'y,���� ►� t`�'°� �Y`�4'V11u+ ... r ����y �`"�• ,y, �t i' �L �y f`�yq gvv��,, �����( ` ,,,, ,,YY 44.'M�W�,�'�+'i� Vl.''1. •^riu 6�{1: 4t1iRiA�... ALA, ti ,tK rr � � w� � � � t ►� ' lrr _ - t r Fr Y ���� M . • ; , � 4 r �: 1t s �' c ,rr+; �� c � � M"a 't.. ' rate s � kcs -�v.'Ctia �. •� �«U4"'': 'i.N �Y.'l'.�7'�� �K+d'Y�+✓�'\i �X'.(J ��'!.✓. � n�` it ,,y 1 � i� � ���y ��.v�. � 1. •_t, ^i �1wwi. 1yi,Pgriib tMA. T+'+i✓s ,.�. r4"40.1'1cr1(��{t«I� ��'�45. wM'�:4 ,„„h,:�4�W �w N:. a�t,iA.t t'��%: „�N��N T` F1�' � . �11, tL,� w�w� i�Vj �� Cr'�Y�t�t Y{�.�i "`'�"�t,f'1'l"' ..k � X3:4;+4"cr•��r •�' s��. j`1'13�. ���Vii. � ".� 5•`.�.�.. 41,a �.� dE���. �4�� E�dts� p'��'�"4p ,�w'y •:.��4' �,.'Ur'C..l:.��G�'lE,`F�''�.Gu� +Sh' Vii.}�"i'�}II� j i�'�;+����4���# • � �. x.w 1 'i la • �.r +�'.IL� . kT�`ri{iid���{itis, ,�'�� y��.� � Y . � ox iyy.�v�lk +�y(�fa. �'S' �.iN,4�. ���fi�p 'Y'L '�°T�I.'�'� '�J'�tt•.9 i�� ��'t1L1 �'1 �. L�k�G�:.�, (� �j �r� AYXi�i r4aYa:a L� �j.. 'W".Il"1�'�.'��i "'"�3 a.. ��.� i:; t'14,�iA„ w..'1"rwd,.}�';; eE4'11.. t�'M'Vb}, '��»'L��'�. ��T '9F�� .�• �, . Y: 0. �:t%.. Gt. L..`arE •��.� r� 4'�lt�� c �� Yt� � ..: 4a4 QN, Y 4 ,. rY , '�Lslutt vrrw ryPr+� $,irm `w'� kn� °�.i' �� +� M"'�-•:.4T. ! W. �'�+ �L V i�1 f`� 'fin r� nli{-1'�4144'�� ��, r � � V F � I• 'SY'w 't•� tW � �fi�"r^yt• 4' 1 W 7. �. %tau) 1" « a wY J .f f '. ' w�`>k r,Y� �V' F i �� � �M+4J•'�� �� � � Y+`Y ,C�"1.ISF A'`E%' At. YCi'tYAL Yi-it}? �4 i` t i 4L. r w'4i 1-L� L��i 1�. �t •L..-lk r F `1. "i4. �C k �� "*�� Cuktc�'tr" .��, yti�.��x •��,Lti: I����,t., �,;U��S�� �,�t�V�Akf� .� �`+, ,�r�.+ • J1, :� �.,� L'.,L`�;t� ` �'��` Lx3 4,� �%� � �Y4tc��„ ��.s� tf?'Y•t t„.+1� tea. « ��•, w 1 �'' � �,li-►�,�l� � �`� +,: "�4��' �:Y] ,"u 'v'Et i tt`i r�Y r�F�ki bah 1�� r4�” : Y:4�� �4 f'M� dV''� �.a�.� N ' - ''A� f 7f�i ,�1Y�n �. �1 ��8!l CCNkit i" ti ..1•.. AttameyAt lam+ 1634 armyd Cat"fi rr IC6, i:A 9392 (016) 893.4710 COM i �iT CC2 CBCTn itNxBG MAP'91AL�. POR T99 P110POSB�1 FoRIKS or BUTx9 40 Jet .Uary Yj 190 pUbiid 11Gar ngc andi4abie Mdtabde4 Of thd, Autte Cdu it r earrti d Suparvi opd: Intrddue.dri apd d '"dr` hot tdi this pu�blia hdar4ih Yj but +�� r►� udst th�te6�'a to attdnd eddd l.t td � m dotdmerytd ddrtnt a � pez•sdtr��ir�aerc�� aid made � pert t,f the bo doriai�'e�dd y t ehVi0ot�mdr�tal 'reV dW pi�IOC' ' fpr4 this part Will a'ttet p't t10 bo brie t bu�tthe itagn ��� �t� and die rit triba Of ai nifl.daht dd�OVdd dhViObh-tdntdI im0adts that hid 0'", r+ will edsuit froom thea �ridad p�t��er�t �. daf tdtidd that a; lboee thoedulgh ahAlYdia be Pedv dod Ait r po geaeY�� fde thrid drirrirz��nm tx pe�riew rpadao the Cc�Urtty df b�ittd, %as a atat�ttdt� , _... a ds` gtiated ���es' driailil.e A tidstir�d the dde ud3,y 6f a� ai��ririarxmerztai l.inpadt ropori�s arid�ri t Huai �:. � erisai.ty Act (OtOA) hav badri tuil� dhmpiifdd with ��ir�drirndritai tither, acid tib:' tera Grit+ that tha t�dsi - Y► this tte Ddu � �' da�4d his t; +� r�dt� dris � rit �`ii�,, piro�a Arid id btr d di aridai�t;�` df eta _ _ tE�d rit~ it f t�ot� th3�s ped dldc b * 11+ea ddtful.i `ti at t�iia `pe6jodtl.:arid pi�eddhbl p sutbmit th y`dti that ddtai]r� opec:if�,d�:��f aid a�a�at�d�is ridbldathisAaar►d�ti`�liririt Pdadd dd Arid iiitdiligerit datdrhiih&ti - ,, of th arJd do rieodiViability). r �rir4oat dntai, a6 8dgU#dhddd df this pedjddt g vi apt �'hd Ca' 1144 Phii dr�virda dritel �r4dodas wtad ftiand4tdt� :E�, the .s�.att�r4e to diiduPd that they tight, df the p'ubiid, the p6efildd ih such d' WAI Y bt at thin' y dart izate ..i y Wdiihd be pubiio dde'l.aidn mIet�a.. Arid dthar4 cvai+hind#�te l,i geht,iytdigh the; eta virwOhmehtal.. impadtd of � pt�pdsed pr'd�adt bdspitd rsl I ri k riitmei4 r;a. d6hdd'ehing .this i�d n`tdt?tts ari: i ,�idr�t 1. Wc�� d at�bi�itt rig t2'd�it11��1��' ti Yvdmbdr4 1 8p B ridt 06yiddd With dale of th t raft 11} nde vde the dmprdsded by, i y"seif utestid la Ahd 06nd - Ohd ft Yiai't:ei� ., iric' dthor�s st edi `$d 1. afid�td add ih t thrit thdddo B) i This 21R, pairYta the ddddj;vjfig Ojdti�i�f beaft ride iris i'eai'din this p cti ars s tt dse fats ria' s ' d it the g pr�oposec' ria e + iitnitad to Pepdrt x This is fdlaa Afid �`tii s td i fdei the ptib id df the bafth5, ddv- dd e `f'dt to 6f this i pot ��d�d�►t : efar Addeddsi,jig the epedifid de6dddf` ddijddeh W.sh tcs data that airi d tasiddh of 8ubte Cdt Ceddk Gari' r5 ''tY 4hd i. e ih AU to jl ° ndaderit to Witte Criselc' I d�nd t q'tiierltl� dri�d� the ir'�edlyd�:dist' �:�ri,tda � my famil.yf f'f*e- dei that #uttd' Cheek stip" toard dig 06rVisbOd *.9 January, 6w 1905 tioaan!hiking t% o ur b + int hilr d n: ta'e64 dt o ' 40.d ped.J6 ; vduid like to .ihodeporatd the 0610mfmi a probantdd by thettteCounty�idnrin�dtort n thdir tt r df thd, ado'hid rd ddt � , hi it iddrUii i i bd, addrddeed be€care thiel 91R, id dandidered dotdpidtodt del not adopt the purxn.rxgdp►rmdntfnamtndntn; Wilde ted hdddir g, gat"bubdtdn+tivo bai3av a that held aovofite, and ih fAdt, digttlftdahtt * �dmmddte ;t id dettiad 1AVI thea a prapOed bYdrddiddUll# prdJOt hWdt b iti the public rd intidriL%#tl.f, danfdrm to, the r'+6quip and td of tho 1w ai hd not- dignifiddoti� �d�dr�td�. i�p�at t_ +�tiv�ironm6t�t This ped.jectt id ddf di tt -i dddh of the Vovdi-blahti,oilod d�tegdrri,dd A Mrd d.dt_: tttdt b . iri_.: tt..:ttbii d t d' __rddt, �:ntdrdnt t�r�h�.�-��i���mdt:t t�idt it id intt�+� p�bi%+� "d dt d pie tti `Ul dIddbeiddi, eci�r� Y But, 'it �d also id thd pubiid rd interedt, bd, prdbd b fiah and wildiifdj rddrdatidndl and addthdtid valudtif wriiddrraddc ardad grid dWr A;Vdee3 dteddmd and dedekal., in order, to ovalUatdi What it ddtttally iti the publid id bddt ifitfaed6t it, id nedadddr.Y ba eiidiytd dpi reidvaht isdudi§ t It riudirtg tufted pdwdr attpoll y and detand�r alta rodti.Ve sduradd of dtfdr y And the dir virdnrfteritdl impadta of tbd prdjedt (d acitt6ddd be' l6w)., A dddidi d ah6uld bd edddhed Wily after ednaldet�iti tie rexatLyd bdnaiib td the Put�.1 � b6 6t fir admpdbing bcnt ifi.dial used 16 the ire ct �i�tic�h prmd rited aid the 9f ft ddea ndt ddtdbiidh bb,dt thiel project i 3d tl d pubiidAs iiibdrd6t t U dddmd "U 61 didar .h t the pubiid and tiab rd durNe ram the de didpmdtit cif this p'OOdetk { t i1e q the t0df t kTA Ae �t ttl fig -u-- `pl�eS to ; Ci ` ah6w that this peojoldb id ddatiatdiOdlA f fdeaibid, 36W ere bad public d trd of 6thdr dg6ndidd bel ddtarti:ria th' Ab Chid ped jeat bard dttfFididnt dapitail and ddUedd of Nfi& to endued thAt dpidadtht ei�bigtiaribdd,4#tea ftii3d ped ed£ 3i b« OP'dbdtit dr d t u tUPd r are ddtidbNdted diad bit&iiv§d: if -A ' prejoa dd ped jedt oil MAtta O dbk dh6uld bd dti dnitpid bd the G{dttnt to arfsttr d thdt f ifidildid dap -tdlt i.� :d , tidwi Mid in th-a A;d meritii ieci gb6Vd j it id iti thii Ubild ts, ii tded6b bel h-dv& k dlddiij � 01, t.itif"Ol Oil 66Wibe cid Pc,Owdk�x fav Mrd ofu�dr 's .w �d d 1096 Oh4b dittOg . dh tt (ia 4) �'hd �� rOPOrt ��� �t '� 16dd hydrodlddbr f, rhIt ed gh I b the it' (,Jga '0N 7 didw Aoh-thb. hd rrtdd hard Wit tdgul;dd +t;hof rr+r r u d ddtr�da ubt it rdt d �r+ , ► + d hit ted , r d t haviahigher d16trioaI, bulb - Tho M dded 66 POOV ddd Atl A"11" .0 o iof �* the 1686 Of t4,9 rd dhu I r ddd r dr 3hvdaltai'dl,t dad dht wt ' h ; + the uut did �,h# rod' 0, �r rid t (DUrdaa dr Laud Mat!' 'AiOh) Will h�' V'§dtO � �Poidhd��ird��r�� ddry .ddb ttho 000,66t, 116, 6.ud ) t#.6ti r� y mdu�:toriug of r { d Pedlij daa+ whd r ddmit h 145 , 00. lu i3rCfi�" JrrAi�C7r AYr7 Ltl�A pkv �yg py j,,, Oh q��y y� p,„ ri.t��i t�� r6vd�iue & f. bud h� �a��� , . , Char it thid ea dri u wig- hdgih l h 1 r hd with► the oddbld, df adry dtd ba that t6udt OrdV ddd Ad e6efit otidd it the p(j&g hag applidd � iMPA-Add ' h d ane d a d dr ►�.aht-i 'fi d- 00t db4 dd that .t r atjv'o, ;1b d t .i' t�sK�t 1 ` "h tt t id d¢idtI�t'�EtrfiT!dhhtruhidltht'� �E1 d,jgdu the 066-dih 't o h gYidi utlli rad aid h3. Ate- miativ# the imv tai ` hdt� rd dh t t bd rd r+rdcl? Wh b dud hd lh h rii the d iisd the 6 Viedbiadfit ,t thd't th10d d;lnia�' drb t +'� puhhvddduedd ' 6p, Pedbi'dift", 1 'deddr td Abd d.00edvi-d the OPOOddd OP6Jd t, thust 'i+h:r od btd� 'hci fddiaid�.'ad hy'drd��.edtr a ddtd (Th d dduabld s dads hd ui d d6tjd-dtdijt with the tOdda, G ari Md"U"d"t i Ldhd '086, Piddt U'do P'idh fd thud aria arias i' �. s ac . rld .uda t (e dight td de+r ' . i�p id h .i ace s iiri th Ll pari.. dr�oe�.ectr`�.d' ��� r�. w, . thd� Plan daj�.s fdP 3.rlc�r+s�.dad rddi�e hd� '� � pd-gj6i"1 y Rdthd-e rimy, a id'eOA S tLM 'hAd-ddsfit 1Y, �.d �i Ysg the .ati'cl ti, a sgfizi , tiv bakaftdtl6ft t0: pr .if f ltd �egi0t1 t �'�I�di1ig sa�ah, o"000� � oo o'tho Us 06 060061 1 'With A. demi" rami 'vo d, , i' , 'o.�r3f 'Ad*- , oohoomoliem vi " th# eftbogyl phi olid` do r : + V Y od that 'thy doo;� Ka Mould no+ ola or Imood U143.ioo"A+� �geojodh i.00', ltd 46n_t o the i or m�#4dtivoly �ar� :owe r��, ��� �► Mots 000 of off' This is, 6 fob Oftbo, Usal did bro oo o o r0000l'oody but'i's pl4fitis 'bo, lfhdd� due ddimutd,4 tit thd rut, o o oo " % * ty, 60401tit dild dqr;eo f19' dbeidt ohopgy addoi e6quirotaon a oot o �t a of � douhty hod f'ohall,iat+od. 4 Olan o N_ „ that o o o& Owde A. �,V bl % 000 s hOP6 16 ft d-116ludsimi ,, . foo ftoeg dohdAr � ian? thbe thy. peo adt o to tho cza 01:66 �i�10'dude A hi$40e ftt 66 t. o' datifthdN the'dlifb;Mi � W'dtd0 Coda ootl�iit 1243'1 O ablialid that raor eatidtial U000 y Aod f st -h ���c����� ��o�ao��ot� � o� bdo ftatal, Uoo of vdtd s Uill bo Iof ss's o tow o o� t Ob io �Pfi��ofo �isoo oc d i1dUN 'ppoeoo j6jj * A4 'Will, b, zi o ai�tWts oo thrid bldhorio o o o o �oamoo t-1 ad , the U o o fig" o o ah ofd i fia t o ogaigolo: (Ass k s14 f a d 069b without. pop# ififoeg tioh o j p0000 fte, 061dd Amdag. t'hs topti r o b4i f'dc� . quolity of - dtedt�h�. i o e+ d at- of a o ii sr�tl Mori . r' so iso .oih', oafiddehifl ori f I i e' .o fri i t ao s'A y ofte ftah � aifib , a fio diii datd�o adtdpj% .h4 4f o iez� 'Oil' lif in hd'apa e o � o fides i i ` disdusdi- i of`h6V oP. Adt dff-at,s is Oposot 'i ill MV 'oif 'widdeg, ftWd i -1n Af that sAfty sultawi'a #ori Medal ty A04e a for t d � i d b' 0 - ho tt04 Old" 1 t 119 d ahai*4 thia 919 eh uld Vie. 4NkftOd 60, thol n As logo 0&e0 i ftr (� the e-tivi o" fit May eouit it, thbCoMpat., ii MA matuirds thO an 'M tati-Ai an nal t klubigaivb lifiokdt that' 106,t have nuadraud., abhor tided. " b'd -f t 614 Ift vaowaythat supply pater 0 the Vona 6r the obb� s Ift ,Addict , dab bh-e d8ihr Pe est 14 tiffiti,6064 Ift, th4a- MR* € ae5 ete+ Alm'; Eft IdWified f sigta edfi 1-m dab 6 the, dfilled f0 t � e WMAY9115, Oddld, boquinad, .far badh B9110is, in fit AOL to fflifii itfid, 6,p fil the ktft hummed §1gralfidAft LH64160 AP'e iddi ,& 'ed hikid ffidluee f ighe " y ge Yd', e �eec' mtndy�te at n ; rir� i spa tme i� � ddittifi.6 ' t e ,# �;gdui� s J ---j Board of Supervisors -6- January 6, 19$5 The questions raised in the comments and the Planning; De- partment's memo need to be fully responded to, provided to the public with ,ample opportunity to response prior to the 8IR being considered for approval. In stated that datais insufficient addressed in the. EIR, :t is Y of the to determine the actual impact or that there is a disagreement among experts as to the effects the project may or will have« (See discussions on impacts on ,fisheries and on riparian habitat.)' i The law is quite clear there where ,fact • s are unknawn or there is scientific disagreement, a worst ease anAlyaig must be prepared. Noue is contained in this EIR. Further, ..1Ith the new proposed changes to the project, there .is no new scoping or information provided to enable a, reasoned determination to be made on the project as presently proposed (i.e., no archaeologi- cal survey on new pipe route). The proposed project i's not specific as to what actual mitigations will be provided and states that maybe this or possiblythat may be done, Y This is hot specific, enough to allow. a determination to be made as to the adequacy of the proposed .mitigation• The EIR fails to take into account the effects on wildlife of noise, dust, blasting, etc.that will occur during construationi Brief mention is made as to impacts on recrea- tional uses; which also mentions that there is no plan should the pipe or dam break during construction. This project by its own comments will take 15 years For thi visual impacts to be mitigatedo This represents a very significant•, amount of time, especially Por my children and myself to wait, until the known harm from this project is mitigated. What is the impact on the wildlife in this areafrom construc- tion? The ETR is very shallow in its analysis ;and "must be re -done before C g da n compled _ with,. r will be happy to Provide -a morethcroughAnalysis of an ETR that has at least attempted to meet with the requirements of CEQA. R pee fp:ll/��� PAUL Ti PERSONS Attorney at Law PTP/ec, 1 CERTIFICATE OF MAILING (CCP ,SECTION 2015.5) The undersigned, CLAUIDINE CAMPBELL, at Chico, California,certifies to be true, under penalty of perjury, 5he within that she is over 18 years of age•, not; a party to t G action, business ad P.O. Box 3542 • dress is X26 Broadway, , Chico, California 95927_3542; that there is delivery service to U.S. Mail at each place addressed; that she executed this r certificate and served a true copy of the foregoing document 10 fully prepaying by placing same in an envelope, sealing, postage thereon, and dep,oSit ng said envelope in LT.S. Mail 12 198 1 at Chico, California on the 7th day of Tanuaxy , 1 131 !� 141said envelope vias addressed as fo'llo'w ; 1),i State Water Resources Control. Board Dxvis'on of Water Riglits 11` P.O. Box 2000 Sacramento, CA 95811) r Attn: Doug Albin 1 IS 21l 1 22) i 123 24 ?G 2r ATEOr-CALIFoRNIA _ _ GEDRGE DEUKMEJIAN. Governoi saATE WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD DIVISION OF WATER RIGHTS S PAUL. R. BGNDERSON BUILDING P.O. BOX 2000, Secfemento, CA 96810 Sacramento, CA. (91.6) 324-5722 In; Reply Refer H to: 300:M27815 O'u"o Co. Planning Gomrrir August 27, 1587 ' AUG 3 1 110 ' �JrovllloA Cdiifdtuiq TO Parties Interested in Forks' of Butte, Hydroelectric Project Reference is made to my letter of August 3, 1987 to Mr. 'Paul Bartkiewicz concerning the Petition for Change on Water Right Application 27815, Forks of Butte Hydroelectric Project. A copy of ;that letter was sent to you. We now have on file the petition for Change which requests tike following; 1. Move the point of diversion approximately 1;2Q0 feet downstream to a point within the SW 1/4 of SB 1/4 of Section 27 1*241� R3�, M&M. 2. Move the place of use (poWerplant) approximately 800 feet downstream to a point wi tha n the NW '1/4 of NW 1/4 of Secti oh 10, T2.3N, Ut, M05&M, 3. Delete pipeline and penstock alignment along the west side of Butte Creek. This will be replaced by a tunnel on the east side of Butte C 00k, whic; will extend from the pointof diversion:to the place of use. A supplemental Environmental 'Impact Report will be prepared to address changes in the environmental impacts along Butte Creek as a result of the project changes. The applicant has not provided a date when it wi11 be available The supplement will be circulated through the State Clearinghouse as rfstluired by the California Environmental Quality Act. As stated in my August 3 lotter, parties participating in the hearing on the corks of Butte Project will have an opportunity to comment on the supplement. Sincerely, Raymond Chief Division of Water Rights cc Mr• Paul M. Bartkiewicz 'Kronick, Moskowitz; Tiodomann and Girard` 770 L Street; Suite 1200 Sacramento, CA 95814-3363 .�. • �r��r� � • J � ` � r e tv '(94 694441 61 .✓ � �, � Ili.+#" �1«+.�� ,i` w I. 4�w�I � �IMItR � L}� �a� ��. (�+ ^' df' � ✓r �. � � � Mi.� ^ ��' f 1Wk�: „� . �.xr`1 Vi^�i#� `��� � ��i *'� � � ,`. WO Jo leJ wY SY aw ky} f / IF I 5 �r1 ri�'-?4 ' A,�,�ykr %r°fl✓e.,.rc+�✓}N wr .tom +} �/ "�iy�,'Y« r,�,�"iy,�.�r61 W l�{w.'F;. 4J V* I '. �`� } r " I�j " / ' wad ex 1 42 '' t4fto Caw ootd „ as Via, u n 'W*�'1a: Ohim "um (260)119644ii OPO Boxion I4 ,I May 14 106 v ak Nat, toad for tho. Ip,l,.. befog of fluttd. aLod&s ludiatdd dhilvr a i6ft', Eft � I iia . �yIbur told" I '4 VY Sdd 414 iL h 15031 y� ji S 1' Old C6,unt vd, aftorib,iadaWd, L efiji W6 . a And will 6A �tilfi impact t6 � � aiy Cd daft edd ive ft m i . d 1 b6pd'd Lhat Emig joai tdr f' dV aidt aft, e�.»fdfmr aftt r, r ��a PI C%Oh ria. € ' `c h ' i , ►6 P iala � ' e t 5 �6fid'b -V fort�3 LmEdot cC 'J �� Y�� • tia aizat iia a fhd Wong.' t 0adf @@kal, head a IEyw, (g,6a, 24-4`) f; ti a` oi�r1 cic er a a i t ` ; dZ s , A ftum TW6 MAY 4 f 190 d r ` ;pug' Ws ,las t NI '1 da k1" Aft Air Pollutialft Mubuld foil into tato lottor e0O-q* '+ 4606 h6b bpply 941jo.6 0 not dqual y Ow eftb6fla 1 - dy Wad ad.. bl� tho ' for at A 'Oft, 'goad+ % at , M "may f P d ddt '§Idly ypa r6fkg jot jjoj� 'y(��,' (y]��p■�������� �y■�y'y' 4k���i.����� µ�t✓� �43AW�1l iZ� �.Y #r ��Vi.�� �V4 �V�+1�� ��y'k.V' 5i. N aha r" tit i� y� �y, }y, ,7hag �,,y y� ,{� U E�r+� l:�-J �4�ir i..7Giwl 1>1,10,iei- kw11: ta1CR;4. asr� Camba atut,�-ally, prdvidd y ��t64h evvlbw ltd ttCet w& `i .sl` ataff of l a qtoy 3t�r aha; 4' 5,64i9thhad Ed that §p, djdjJ.to-d t6 ftvibwl alir p d b. the N u' s - r{ i hits caubty, aft �! you w_. 'w to 00 when t i .tt b Add AA kow j - At .tfidt Wft j 4 �P �f i Circumstances orOdi'!tions changed as prcwded' Section; 15162, or (3) A responsible Agency becomes a Lead Agency under Section 15052. Nate: ' Authority cited-• Sections 21083 and 21087, Public 4 ns 21080.1, 21165, and i,esouroes Code Reference: Sectio X1167.2, Public, Resources` Code. Formerly Section, 15064, Discussion'; This section is added 'CO provide a short and cone',e sUte- ment of the Lead Agency concept. This statement is essential for the .clarity of this article. While the bulks of this article deals withh identifying the appropriate 1'ead Agency a summary of the Lead Agency concept is essential because the cozicept is i:u.edamental. to the CEQA process as'a . whole. 1.5051. Criteria for 1Yhere two or Inore public agencies will bd involved, ,with a identifying the project, the determination r)f which agency will be the Lead t I.e d, Agency Agency shall be governed by the fo) lowing criteria! r (a) If the project will be carried out by a public agency, that agency shall be the Lead Agency even if the project would be located within the JLxisdiction of another public agency. (b) if the project is to be carried out by a r, rOngovernmen" ta;l person or entity, the head Agency shall be the public agency with the greatest responsibility for supervising or approving the project as a whole. (1) The read Agency will nornlaily be the agency With general, governmental powers, tueb :as a city or county, rather than an agency with a single or limited purpose such as an air pollution contz,ol district or a district which will pravi de ,k public service or public utility to the project. ("2) 'W e. e a city prezones an area; the e.:y wi l,! be the appropriate Load Agency for any s,ibsegt..o7�waf annexation o p , . plliai e env ,ronmen- the area and should repave the apr, tal dooWnent at the time of t11( The Local Agency Vormation Commission shall ,!,S.t as a Responsible Agency. (c) Where more *than one public agl. 1,y equally Meet the criteria in subsection (b) , the agency which: will. act first on the project in question shall be the Lead Agency. (d) Where the provisions of subsections (a), (b)', and (c) leave two or more public agencies with a aubstah x i. 'l I claim 73 , Sec- 24-45._ tSame--Form fees.], Applications for use -permits shall be r tads to the P1 snr: n.t ,Comm, s s ion ,and shall form m p y by the gravis ins to elia » t: itt�' , Corttr i 4 �n nrttinrr on a foriTi ar�p�.nb d Y plot pnaraC� 'des of the of pert_ . 1? r when it finds b ding fficient to sha�v the proposed 1 mould not b the zoneoin j biCIl rnpaix the if] t• prb-' s of the usi or riot i he e t nreasonaW . i L e lan gxity p e etailauoround• d lies andel Every application shall be accompanied by seventy-five dol• ding properties or detr ca patible with, ar at tiro use Welfare of the persons r i menta Juzious to Lars ($75.00) to be deposited: in the tounty general fund, no or to the , esidizi 1 to the health and �enera.i health g or �vorkin2 in the 2euernl �axt 'of which shall be returned to the applicant. (noel, No., F � � welfare` a neighborh�d 1750,, § 1, 8-31-76) ! Evidence or,- at and safety held and the hearin S' of 'the count3; I' disposed of int k hereunder (B) herein. COrd, 1'�Io. he manner get f shall be 1eceivc i; - 24-46. [Same--�-Hevring•..d x750, forth in sectio ' ►pec. M�-4&. 1, &31-7Fi) n 24-27 Upon the filing of a suffic ant and proper a.ppSic;ation eni ['Sam '-Ri ht of payment of the fees f Comp avid oit ed for fikta time 6 the face � The deter appeal u on ' � , urination o n Pan denial• tYa F- r, - be ficial unless the - Iattr11f1 r > Procedure, V the a writte �, f.,grnmas5znr shall. fora tiblic hearin �, p' boaxd n a da of supel" Sci s appeal is Y follo�YLa he date by 5 cep lu.fand wit g A notice of hearing on the application for a use per2nrt said ei of the 0 the eighth the clexk tJt, shall. be both published in a newspaper bf getipra.l circula- ; filed gh y falls de rniratian nth lendar on a Ie ,provided C cl iJ .a 0 p•m, do the gal holidays , that if tion ;iri accordance with. Government Code section 65554 and �'� is pen' for next da -.the appeal m.a Y be (3{10), feet .from the exterior boundaries of all property upon `i 1'vo use Cope Uf Said appeal to h6 dier Sial ini ffice o 1 be mailed to the owners of all Property within three hundred f w business, the o the medlatel f the. permit iin3 Pl.l nR ' far liicl an application fox proposed use has been made, mid ! e cpirad. y be issued i. xna (;b11r�Ci5 xn notice shall be mailed to said property owners at their last- s filed,''' nor may such pe'inYit b ntil said tiztie fora h " f until the ' Issued i appeal h mown addresses using the address from the lo.test equalized � Y►�ithkn ten uoa.rd of SU n the event rite ,r ' assessment roll of the County, of $utte, except that: in no board (10) drys of t' visors att' pe l case siialJ Mess than den (10) separate and individual prid operty b ,hrin of s be adV ghsll e � e dicey g tl ahnin sapFeal ea Y Pervisor•s Ellin i g r• .Said i 24-4G, The boo ez-tIsed and 2i far. a hearing,, appeal, rd of noticed g- Said e�ners closest to the area being considered be toti,.ied ithn native shall indicate the t me d ate a puce of the hearing main the fin�n sup et-�,isars snzll P�trsltant to section and the location of the subject ro ert . Failure of 'any prop- i bbird of su gs regtiired ri decide such a �erty owner to receive such a notice shall not affect in any vided pgrvlsors heade 244- above, .. ' ppe that all a L. S sh$il beotinduct'4 ,. ala i. aiaziner the action taken by the Plrnrling Cp;tinissinri recd pplicatong eco de novo 7'hz or Lhe board of supervisors, (Ord. NOo i750, § i, M1-76; �endc�°anq rxlad� or pers maps, e�h, bits and prop k Ord, N'o. 1701 § 1, Z-222 1) It �a5 Or.1 Y be co �hrzserired to Starr Sec. 24-41. Sam Criteria for ra ub jec o f ar Plank ria r' I nsidered not subject of the board by the board df s�, Jean to`,revie supetvisoe - pervisdrs, r - trim i i 2-2 4h` (Ord, IVo. 1,75..• cou Z'he p . Y in g t;•a cti77 0 rcept b shall' be tinol and • ya ttsof 1.ttnzz� Commies ro,nn the basis of the evidence , ) � � 1 $_1..75, co1zi,peteztt Jug. submitted at the heari OROVILLt. CAUrORNIA 10 V -T 3 0 1935, BOARD Or sUPE�V STATjsoRs UNrTED L 'S OF' F AMERICh Btrot& THV rp-mEmL JMRGY RLOGULATORY COMM ISSION PROjtCT NO, 6896-001 ENERGY GROUP GROWTH OBjEdTj'oNS 110 AIQTION and to nXmIT9 issidhom OF LICENSE • BUTTV CREEK'IMPROVEME T COMPANY the rtiquesst Butte Cree% Trail Council hereby ol'Lk,.�- to Utte Hydro - 131 -a of a license in the Forks of t for �ithmediate isnUtt ,kW Trail Cotincil 00pr6jedt'�)v 8Uttd.Creek •el.edtric, P 6j znd therefore, hat appr6- action, fob license said immediate isoUanCe Linder the ptiate stand -5edt to Irlg to ob , X procedur e.. to said ComMission's ot Practice, and three - imme6late issuance is bIseLj Oil th r certain 1, The applicant liat been nconsistent With 8pecikicatiOhO Of the, proJddt, and rtIC tlleroforej� require '11 not be variedi ever-0 tliat tbese spedi,fibationt WX -actors numerous initqati6n 24 Applicant 'hat presented 3. fdt said Vnit gatIon fadtOrs-, assUrances hot presented any but has J.soue.a and brie, the: license slibUld not 0 Until this is and roque6tz 3, The applicant bites t, me probl dws ation wer expediencyn, ckireent as ys . All Of the titre del' airl thc s1loul 15e don"ec I l caused by applicant and they to reqU�gt the saillie, oqpr..0 TV ICAT TON8 APPLI'" CANT'S !NCON0018t4" T CouncI'l to-gatcling dondarn of nuLLO trOLk Tragi 1 this points refers to the new specificat"ons of app icant, that 47 CFS 'would be sufficient to provide appropriate safeties unde'r it argumentb of the California Department of Fish & Gante and the BLM, t1l a t 20 CC'S` Would be Previously, the. applicant has suggested sufficient to sUpport, the water flow in gutto Crook4 They further stated* at Public meetinqs, to tb,-, bepartnjehk, of V,ish & dame and to the, Butte Creek Trail Council,, that 47 CFS'Voulel be infeasible to support the project", Ofeel t1lat bw we see that they they, ca the support proj eqt w � th 47 , CV S. tld.' applaud this prove ion i n th e: application, and.are dd3Jqhtb0 that tho-appl ',cant has mare this change, IiOWiBvers bas6don the intOh8ibtOhcY OE app]icantls starico- oft this issue in the past, We feel ad,'.MahEly E114f, FtRC should require a specification, in the app' "cshots Kjn(.j .1idL L, that ".he wztitOt fIdW in Butte Crook sball not go below 1.,1 is nr,W I evol. aC 47 CVS for any reason camstid by tho -applicant, or. successor 6 cmpahieb# users, etc. 14 This raltillirOffiolit should be specified to be, th6h"Valuable, 11, MITIGATION VACIPOA9 Butte (alreek Trail douncil applauds the mitigatiotl: factors: PtOddh-Edd by the appl. loaht in tillbir now Plah, 'However, J., that Plan dfgOrb "ib s0990$ti0n7 6V sPecifitati6hg on 'hbW t he app lidaht ihtOtid-4 to d6ffipleto- and fLjj,t-'Jjj tilt)LIe miL-igat.ioti ffiL&bUresi the Applic.4ation, cofitaths no t4a.fo-qatitc r►ria sureties o£ how the PiPOIihe is 5OD15 Lo bo buriodj trees are 5c5j'hcj lie; 4. replantedo Any ihJUted Of PldtbOtici dite WiAJ b (:A r. to its natural state, at ca As Is 'histOri'Oal!,Y apparont from ecohomito ptactidai or un'%nown simjl4e and, other projects; env,Jr6 I hmentAl reasons Cause A construction. drew Or applicant such as this one not to dbMPletO the mec'8VrP--q that, tbo.y set out itl goOd faith to proVide, our comeertip thotetore, is that an atteluPt bd yfiade by the applidant pr-ior to tbo, granting of 4'VEMC, lide-lisez, to, I' doscribd with What eftojets I)& made to c(�Mp,letc t'Pa 1c, the mitigation measures dioOMsqed,t altic! t6, ihsUre their Covietioft A by gp,dj*.:tjo. d;ltdso, 6ho, to guarantee the dbot esi thoba MOO�,UkO6- lit, N TO 9XPEDITt vAdotgs Applicant colAP.laintt t Ot. '010 11 0 taken far too L d long. We, ag'ted the Process in this "hOttivl e' liar been a lehvthy cine: l4owevet3 all amalysis, the timd ptrioda ibvOlvedo 8110W til"I't 't)v 6 11 cl I► thesee be doaayb havebeen caused by the C-1-ppli�t n Tile, ElR wag to bo f i I od by 010 ZiPP), iclilt ll1 Oftt I V 1) e c o mb e r 1984, XL, took tfl�ihy months Lhoroaftatt to get any form of the 81A to the Calitatftia nolr(l of W�jter Romirc-as, the, reviov ,.jejehoy. Fur-thet, lh -LIAO darty 4Pting Of 1985o ON 10-dilt Met With the Oepdrti-neht Ot Water A00dUrC0.s-) the SL'Rl the llutte Creek. Trail Cot ncilf at, thd, dita to discuss their rlQW proPbsa' Tt WdBh't icor siX nibhOis aftdk that tihlOi tivtt vany Wtittdtl Spoulficatiotid we),,'O Prosontod to any ht the dbo-Vd These dulayg 116NO AII 1106ft Oat'800 by tll* 00-l. we Would object to OA0 qtJht.111C cf an 1 immeditit-e 3 1,qsuance of- a to cure d ProlAom t1int t''11V nt)l)lt(mtAL 'I..bsolf has cnueeh t: �'" w u, MAS4"`14 W ` L ti b tAe , I N I "United States DePartmetit Or the: Inte Ail t . ;:` Y i Tilt ACS WLY + 'wAS111146 iN� mc2010 It 04/66 i ttdr '1d i# ti'r tti P Aurt�b� ���rdttt�y roddit1 thou.",i� tt�1��t�� t�t+Y �xrtt=ttti i���ab Done �Ir# plutnbt hod, dvl w 0d hit A 11006 t � i tii d�u Duttd 'tate �iOtt" roahijm (Rid that, Old HUMb h t �d lmud' llt d irrtdwatid odddd to A01a1yzo- t+ts t#d1 tri t iit�t�i�rt thdst,rrCtii � u�t md�t % ddtt d �r rt tht�t art ttdd rtit# ThOl tbRO tit t trY�rfithtg �i°d pteodtttdd by tope it ddf #d as, dbtuol ci iii ttiq l id: It I!— We wduid. �e og Gtr � itfdd roup iaddro�ds tha�sa� dot €:011.4 ori a: xh3bit I p d§itiort. w it tho'�tcij t Methot o6t'1gidood t"+ 11dating dt this ti ►ta: ° _. � �, ��� �t��tddtidtt �� a �����a1 havd hii lukd' the di�fo_ti�ry� Mtrtit u" teejn� t da�i iiti t� t : ruz�tr b w+ritlt n tii irYi tiiiit e ti�tt 4(o� orf Old Vtddr P+�twiieAi;t 91ioutatdd r v+�mp ixratdk Ciowg PMW, the ropmed diV+ t•si t : iitt', iutd 't�+d va fi �ws' v til tad ti i dl it addc�i dadd Tdbid lti ft'pl y sJMU f izt,�rit r iii itlstrdatrti by' t i`i tv4 't"it a rtt� Oh the toditddlogy de �ddib+�d iti ��hibit �i3tiIdittt�i titr d�ttt � Riudi� �tt�i 660 Motion W' _' W hOM thy` i t 8M I `" warttdf ,6 It Oddo' ttid dat�dlat'1dn: � t'twg tit �tittl9�r Mot lit ` ottd tl�iblttf�"l�s n �diti�it �� iV£1 � iVl rtai�stit E�FId ttt 16h 39 0 �`'tilt' ,�d, but It � uti�fdfir ttt the fold -ala 010 tbd doth Rede j data: ba n d itsicta:0 rid MOd a�tri tt C LIM . bi= dd etttc its 1t i� Old, tittiddr�tatjditt tits BU A iii �_ r. ... j d" rtaiicliii' t trpatt �����}i�►�� ct3r�Vo�`gi�titita� 't�tit�1' iota oi`��i�i��d piojddt i�t� �rto��`� ��i �S� ���i t�N�t�i� ave a'rlg, rit�w'� a td boitlg 8evAdo6d4 1t is' �isc� the Ott � G%iiC izwti i pr rtfiieilt i+i h rx tip �t hg dor th ii lids "416 fig f1gutra: h v tori ddvId1dptd dttad thdid4d It I pMMd �tr��tI 'I tai bi�ii� a�It t: fits u- h� �d . " 00110 nr d� iit�t tib ttt��dtdcl�- fid�+i t�th�t� thah tthd �� c�� tui+ ted i�uthc�i�� rti� t whidlt °o1q of iso. datifftdtivd, Od ft the it Wd ed� ivit�, tib c�tt�iti�itlri �� i;�htixt �� ��itt+� Crd�� w�iuic3 b adV� s iuAlm y t'edtd.d by 1, ca c� tti iiiditjt ri�i iE gtdtittd dlsturbit i trftth 'cow i si rt ad dia td rasiOtc f611' M cot�strudtiriti� d�udvi r Nid distil that ttdcaieftlsed triitiatt#ttti tiiciormtiticttWit l;� a tN t1i�rnia�nt �i ll � atiitl �Vata citAlt�; cwiirdl d (i�WOCO i druid dept ttrt t t bf IA &_ 11606filbldRoftneth P& MOO' cdo j.e, &W tip,84Army Carpi 3t Uri Invors- Others W111 h 11,16 Wit 1�r 8t* 1tt turbid Ytyaur' "try 1� ty > + +�h tru ti lei ti ltyw� ►�« "to110011pottt room: s4titatliid r orttty 1�iddtod that they, 01 t DOOM Oh tt rit+ i ia�i, the $twOn. ori L41rttiw t%i t1 i�rttd �► a tttti"itlif+�i ti tt'r itlr t rft toquestod Itt the OtoMeafits lotttr Of Aptil Of 1981# Dowd. ott surva.tlom id f�.rf1 M46 10 the �� " �r �� t1t� �� �� � 6t. yt�t �tri� �1 o, �1t�d' atfttelptod ikk at, tov�gtat1o1� &W mtftty, 41'�tutbo + rcttq Wits t pdi4 th1 X114„ wd bdck thtlt md1mtnt lattodootiait would ba arit11i 1t 11i9 1 ttt it1 t"titt h aquatle hhts#tat. tike 669th tiedi, '00'"r,dimad"M tt-gii'tdifid, tho t ttirii" d�gi i ktt�ttt at wtttdr iitmiiiy 1tt 1jttttd, t Ok hd9 b&ft a trig►, r fats 6 ari pubut- tats wt uge dodbl dod, tA okomMW i1i tits With$fAwttl riom ftr'tlt tr rititi rat ofiffy Ohd the ifuffilhati ttt d t1mb 1i Negt tr6M Odd&fiddle 'thd Cr1jdkW iiiµ ti ti itti ti tl til git � � t1tr # pteomodl by tits 0 t t rrtr►1 i t t �" I flity `d ur ;, N Idiwa, bthighly umtottid i g i teip tippo' t tri t trt britt, tt15 ith�i rir ttt ci 1rt iflftt Cit a t�3 r ftault r Ca ilritt ► i1t t1E1 ifttri� Uftptilbld fifdo& bdd itt t;+t'tn Wit ato ted � d hre�g 1h tho. ' �9#dift tout' aCu hoar tai b� a� �'+�rO"m Tho tfr tori aiitIn ritlttiriiiittralridi 1"t Cis##iY a hay t 1ivdr j it .1 Or ttt t1 t a h the rout ttici: trttw� t'4 i 1141141 d of, tt,,*' 1'1g'uod t ip t r+� �t of atw;�ii ttia 1 i'ttrrri ti�ti rogordthg, tbd' Matirit�4h"�� �t �tt�trt*�t�► fig int �ti fi h itslt�t c fi3tid a th�� t Ar fi flag r dtttmooddi bi t,h 116'rrfi ttrt 6f,#i41i ttf 'ttt thl" Itho w ttodeo�t"bid 1ti4mi'm bypft "flow level tots th p rr abs rtx� t t t t igitfir , "ridgmea, I"hd fth find lows r 6m unded tfgura bf 47 uVid, f0t liar iCt U t#fi trf t ltfilS f#�t1 fd4utrdd W trtdifitttih t#i iiitbxtst f ' " tiu;t t1tt trot dali`t�itlg d1�rf itt twfdpratlr� tai 'the iirrr'rVjt� tha prltriiry FlOWy �aiu Ift the fibk tdd , od � ftf re41ddiAlat f•abibbw tfout# 1t', i� littdri that thOd',bd # itt habi t ter the hut. mp 1st the + +ei Mbit e s*-V14a) est mj teg t11� quantity of 8OU httd ro�� crfdtdr,tti" tdbd �e�ei��t�r1 end fe rig ted #; : d tut, tett *'6116:`9Itd§ h # i ,ai1l #c+ y 4 5tifri tt Ig b a' c1 tY a 6a rdadb width ibh a 1.1 op+�� the °i~ar+d It rb6ibed 1`r"� t tN liud6t ut, rift reri l � d th rfi� Iia d ri h r tfdm. with do-pud" ji t rind the txssuf fptiM th6A idrgd• imui,,m�lit blast be tibld 16 traverse the fd4dOd White, �ft��+�hti�#fi and lay'th— ddAdditf the M dsti '" tclttdh 1rltlst at # tat tri' Width 1 . ddttt t6pi i�ttftiil s Iia a irfat that th t 1=-fddt t.6ritt ' V� �i tfii 1Yicitii t 8 ui t9ri ciCcrl�lm tti � dug randhod wduld bd f "'Ulf" tuts t1 �tfC1 h;:t� OC66-4 - th, t h 6-f66t b t rauid rdair d �Vh r %eh��pt r �CYtMtd r ctt bid tiled to 1tiada thc* pifid U NA,4lg4 11LCti £kt predi tldtt btt $pciils` vdjV'"bd . �ft he u�ttcu#atod tlfdU1 k:i"ihAftidtidift d�alohl mothmsr a 10 tiriu urs p�cc?if ed AMttmth9 a r �ttdb ' d width �� % ftdtf fihd ager=� egg stoise tc� b 'te"w-nes oC tess 'thAft the d'p' ekz' 5 fig;ttra m 't # i raxtil�i tett'' 1, 5:i � spr3iis getidr#td'd w6'Uld bd �uhi ' ►ard4, er" #itietrr fa c t t� eclnd ii tOd' �►ittf th �i +' ` e pMOr u , tL � t tate 00fiddit rd t&, _ titoq�to " "t f6t thtFe "Mt.4' It 1hu` b� IM+ tiiltM1lMliwlkt Mai fie, AM fthd thfiN_X�Osa MIA t thod of O + 001of + , ht�Mn b#bdt :'Al N'th With otiff�4' ,t6 bd t ut u ttti0 at ddbr su mqi ent Oration P-.e�nd � Apht, ti'tU, Ug1thm , ttt4, bo&t d6fitiholog. mm,nti iMa in t ti616A that ppoothtr6ms int til drM§tt vd Oldut:, � + � � ��� tir���r'` itr iYd jdddt� ifi tt» 6mlwt. Area. �'i� t it. � ewichily itr,de r t f t� Pith art ��'�t� �`� �����:� i��+�t�;���Me to tiog, and &VOid Aral On't would, bol, fi.t' LA ����� '�� �� , dint idt tt ttid hrt ii a fit w ri � i t� � "h � b U14 bLif M- ed"fuet. MOW) � `tiiittt�r ,Orlih,tdi'a tky be, 0-ampt t with turd M600efil 6f, Afty W tr ttrt � frY gi�tCaW011 A�bU k 60{10.?17 it thGdia.tid�t�hYn/ �0 y000 Lid& �4�yf� :5�tlrapo8fduld i tt i bd roo&ted t eat ` ►ht ti7d z i 0t .fi Yd& t►t t ' ii � Mir 0661601"M , duet' i�M, cttfutt l' t t ti�hE thdrd. it 060 §tCibinit 41dfi itt M 6§ ff Y ( int t- but t tt u ", the tir�tito- tt'udttoit dh tidtdis'it t3�ut�, t,.tfFu> tti'd std ht hti'dv ( g fie prod Ortfii ar~iC turn r d tti $j xiiri�rt ii"eth mkfid,wide e tiro a�i5 ud cit' x M ,tit fdok tfa W -� tirtl��t��� hthis�iy zt'r ffi . tri �t�,u �. �f d'di� i�hrt t�ltti hddtiiitt�trdrist itis tibir"�vttlt�t i�ttdt tri tr Edi rpt +t,iy+rr �Xi�rriitinitld"66w6d' by a�trit�OyM n'Cif tint u rif §Ytd b t t6Paddfe 9*6164 .. gim deiW tint titdr'd old, fide of ixis arts Mitt trttliFrit d da daft pautdv jhd ddritifidtt ai'dfi a ct sigtrult d distd d rid t ft hi rr, tied' tih9 uMd Amd fftftAi��s tib tr�st��itit� aibr� thd' � i���it t d tits firieadta l'vYfridra Whet° t ' tit tndtuc# t>ttt tied hilt hrfie�� � �� �� t�ct�� %titrfci fi��'' Tact"alt�ct� t�i�'��'r�idrtl�ti� rtdpa�xta �'�S'ibtd �ir� ��' t u+� #� �ttd tiivd��idh, fit 11; fiiti: it t3 ' wiffi dsi ++ ch3W +' that thJVpp t oo ado 6.; ) but # MAN 4 �° Ault4 ' tow #: tt�i ` µ` Ott .jp y� y,� n! d 01 Y4d. C71 ,�Y y�Y�J. $yy .#�Ytipq�+ y�� �1 �„ j �A4yk,:UA yI �Fk iA +J l; i�'f �iffi 4tQ.�F xf�i �yY MOO PAR �SJ ���Q'�I LM �M,�,��34L th PRO ,! ha ty Md, ft kf it i� WAR tlfidMJ+ �yyyy,�Jq+y� ¢vy,(�{��,yyVQ, v:F(�,�gr�rt„pL' {■it■�W`yS.. Id.Gi { y[. "pY Y�j�f yr.�'"'1��p"�y��.`J.'y� �p��CkC �e �{p5��j}i tA� ,�Y� evidiAihTf,. 1�I E �hA 1 [j +LM 1 �J ) l' �i�`With '96 1,04 f6i J�.AeA4AU& Rf AiMliCtl�N: Md tt % t w d Ify, in i8 r .i �e si et a ih���'� � � 3r�i�„�� ���'` ; „� xis, 1tr t` € y d hhjfur th its fid s `16 dt ►icy. IV@Pd d1 �` I c ity afxaftbo th _iim- fw fib Wed ba tSC t4►t i b�f'3 ft`clr3nr�d z:�