Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout87-44B BCBOS GPA AP=VARIOUS LOG#87-05-05-02 2 OF 7pate: January 21, 199i To Charles. Nelson, t Butte Counromc red A. Brooks i; !•- Y plannin CSU, Chico 5 Commissioner 2213tructor & ConsOltant in comprehensive P Subj: Review of proposed Ener reation Element' for ButteaCUralbuntlaming Recreation Resources, and (specific y, referrals are by page then number) Thank, ,You for the oppor.turiity to element and make review Of Butte Gount pertinent remarks that this proposed Y and its residents. are in the best interest-- element or 'part I w11 not 8lelAent, same of the Natural address the Energy however, wi11 address Resource or those elements that relate t�' significatlt and v1taOpen sAace recreation element,: recred,,- parts of a s Well ` as the In suinrnar . Iatur� Y, as related to Open Space :Recreation this naderuat proposed element al Resources and , and does hot .1 confusing,, poorly organized; guide the Count provide the directi:oti needed to lead or Protection, y In the area of Natural and enhancement or Resource and. Opera Space tdCreatl- Ohneeds des meeting curl:ertt or pite its size projected provide this planning tool and the; furtt7s exile ded to I Will r provide Pcitlt sore gross deficiencies an diret~;ioh_ for praidin d, as time elements intended. an ade uate allows, q document for the This ddcutnent is somewhat 'deficient fro n For example,. the most si in the docutnerlt• gnificaht and the only Cover to Cover.. title 9aen*+a y re�i,red element –ter , js not even l iste�9 in the cover o nage', Unless one looked inside, one 'would not even Open Space element was contained therein., know an `rhe plan pr.o eel that the p k1 taken from State guidelines requires �y Plan be ihteg"rated _ include extensive . Internally objectives a backQ--r011hd data y consistent and that it policies standards and act.iOn06 the the p ti Plan, pro ase The proposed element is not Internally is not The With ekistih in this element. y late ttet and g eleinen'ts as they relate to topics adequately ,address provi it doed' riot Consistently or Eac�ilit _8 lt._ the Natoth.exaptov pion of recce address Yecteatioh ar f cl.l li i -6 at el �� �patiotl areas and or the, pe}l �r~e elellC"' }lta lt� pr6vlsiah of �C�tUi�l tlt t . ecluestr ah trails or. paths 1t�lib 115 etc in the ci•reul,atlon elementyCle, pedestrian, data is totally inadequate. the backgreurid' meetih s Wh le there g with or input frattt Sejected may •have been some data and there Were ho professionals, is Prima _._... r. unary assessments ► , . curve s . Y act so;llo total comt»uh it es, i . e Cohasse t; i~ores Y . e tc h t Ranch, e'tc ,a are riot even mentioned ire the elements.. Also some {major recreation. areas and facilities, i.e.', tht State Silver' Dollar Pairgrounds, the sfingle largest; public, quasi-cottu'merCial recreation facility and program in the County, was never mentioned (Under State facilities) in the plan. The role and ' needs of or for commerical and semi --public recreati.cn resources are not even identified in the element. The rale of the county conce�rn.ing recreation is once suggested but Identified no where in the plan. The proposed: element states that; (1=2) where there is conflict with other elements that the policies regarding energy development .and natural resources protection in this plan take precedence`. This is not proper within the State Planting laws or in preparing sub } plans or elements w1t;hi , a larger element such as this one. The Recreation and open Space: elements are a part: of this overall element or sub -element and as such cannot be separated out or voided where they conflict or are not mutually supportive 1 agree this the easy !way out for a consultant or developar of a; new element: H'owever, all paras of all elements must be • consistent and the conflicts or additional needed changes to any j oth l' er element or part thereof should, be Identified (for approval), Now can this element be approved not knowing what .needs "or conflicts it creates? The goals (2-1) are, 'a conglomeration and are totally inadequate for Recreation, Natural ResourCes and Openspace. There are, only .14 goals listed for all. 5 sub elements combined,.. at least 15,basic goals are needed. for Recreation and Qpenspace Alone. The objectives provided via one sentence for each goal are insu.fficient'to realize even the goals listed let alone all those that should be provided. As, noted there should be at least 15 goals for Recreation and Openspace:.:each with at least five, most have seven or eight, obectives, or steps necessary to aCcotttplish or move toward' the realization of each goal ;For each objecti-Ve a pal ay, itnialutn+ nk kiuti measure bridinance or proposed O'rdilarlee 1110t it d'ataily, blit iA ditEAR I) it M1t-ftq; Fallowing the proposed elements (inadegUatt) goals and objectives are issue's policies and implemehta.tion statements W. These issues and, policies ,related to the County's needs for these elements and the goals and' objectives appear to be quite different and not necessarily related or correlated`. There is also is no continuity or match...pekha;ps this is the reason for the separation, between many or most of the goals, objectives, policies and implementation statements in order, there should be (1) issues, (2) goals (based on needs, issues, resources and constraints i .:'mast of which were not identified for each. element);r (3) dbjectivez� to, achieve or, trove toward achieving goals � (4) 0011cits, and ;(5) impleme�htat 3'on ttteasdire- s:' to; accomplish each objective and 'policy« y i In this elemen 1Yhich`a to be a Of "boilerplate') infor.mation, pmanyss large ex ehave mass been identified and the unrelated to the listedFolicies are, as noted, almost completely seg;tion should be separatel5andndcohaving` mFplete,ectivesEach element or rather than � information split between sections or sub -elements:, Lt wol8 be CK• to have a summary chapter or section if it was consistent With the sub -elements; however, thisis not the case with this element, Each sub -element should follow sequentially from issues, then goals, through policies and Implementation as 1 outlined above.' These should follow logi f tally and sequentially. The entire purpose o. accomplish' objectives andimove towardpachievinion measures :s to not do to in, thia planning document. _ 4 goals This is Further, i , mplementation measures or programs should b � S11 provided for each: sub -element, acid riot a, a � sp iorgasbord of financial proBram listings. revenue should be augmented for recreation,: The listed sources of At best, there should be an environmental checklist for each element or sub -element. I find it virtually impossible to rationally s;;gcest that a Checklist or EI,A could be done for. this entire planning, element or set of sub -elements, particularly if this plan was adequate and complete: However, since the document Is so general and because few y implicatiohs people rria understand it or its perhaps this is why the environmental review wi.11 be attetapted for the entire element, Under NaturalesoUrces glgh.ficant Natural recreation resources from view urces and scenic corridors, trails and cultural areas are not adequa.te7.y mentioned, assessedculturaladdressed. Also the existing cond.�4ion of these resources is not identified. Further, from time to time in this section (I:e a,n« :implementation measures that don�t4'l5) there are policies do<)t''t match 'up wri.th the Issues and go, In this section, or. of the element policies in the second section (according to the plan clit�structton): What' there does hat follow from Issues, goals or o"bjectives 1�here are generalities re many important issues ar areas, i:e, water recharge, the element. notes these areas should be protected;• however not even the most obvious and significant of these areas or locations is specificall, Mapped identified for protection: tihat Y pped' or good is that. The need is to identify and a- y this information in order that - follow. Theme pF Po�.icst:s may... generalities sia lied are virtually useless for. taking any action to eserve and Protect these areas. �r tine t� t y-� the Ssstie or 'rale of ri Chiu is i eat id 'nti ,ierlle or aidresse Tk1r the Coun p m rily recreation and arks iibtrict•a F programming or activity agenciesi They have no legislative or pt6tect, the police powers and can do 'nothing,tb "+ s natural recreations resourcesecreation resources Many and most identlfie:dr, tet On es mapped areas in the County are hot pp. fd}: protection: t�tiat in the way of recreati�sh cox recreation facilities is provided for areae o�.�ts: �N Of or between the rec. communities outs.ice ofeation districts Cohasslet Forest existin listed? Nothing! completelyRanch g cities and D, g• Ent,i.re Sterling Cit astrictsi i.e Ranch .4 r Y,Butte Pleadows: etc,, are not mentioned, There is no valid identi�ied or facility Incorporated needs fxom assessment of recreation or unincorporatedthareashe recreation . Plan. area. upon which districts, to base this Under State Recreation such as Bidwell- Resources CDist;rict) silver Sacramento River maJOr recreation t6--g) Dollar, 'Fair ^State areas park and . the _ gzOvnd� etc., are..:. Sta e s not even listed. Although alluded to Chico area. The statements there is 5rou s .re t,ailsno private! caro in P specifically interested P g in the maintained trails. in 1l inaccurate. There are With identified Theta are trails who have mapped and ado ails cities, towns adopted these in loin adopted trails and and districts ...2've also worked o 9 trail;; bikeways. (I know Oil these plan for such areas as I' Paths and trails as paradise CO'imerc al and with groups, role are iritic some 'Public curately and Recreation Scehic highways, corridors inadeguatel facilities and their this element Y identi f" ed These and vistas are not and mapped. general ..plans have been °bviousl rens '-I know I identified in some locadentified in Y we reviewed put them in, These documents government dents el. biggest issUe is the but Y ng cur-__ tto t and County t s tole in hel in future demand, b"' ' not only this C t°_" `btect an recreatioh Y hi an best or Onl °V resources, y be done. b recreation resources` Y the Co;.rnt where What does Y• (6-7) ount,yls d"emo it mean to kee gra "hi;c p recie t tannin and vil tri"hds? The Co a i°n in check P pp gg 1 do littl�y untFY has with the !.s riot i�rip;roved• The � to be done no recreation ver seotl- on the county if this e Y inaccurate+ demographic element elementary school The ag'0s in paradise w trends is influx' of sough population ib increasis a.e deali18 ('E•s.) p Pulatioh East Asians i.ri g� There is g� the increases affect su the county, a strong is the Count � ppl" Evervgrie What is y re supply and demi, Y and demand = so whit? kno�rs. need to that Where importahtJ. but meet these deficiencies? are the deflcieircies:?' assessed unknown situation This appears to be and deficiencies Needs "oi: the Identified It s cur.�ent demand Wexe Identify should primas; ResdtL Vist-Q Seytn (6-8 This is one of the besb para ra hs In indicates there is a need for additional recreate d°current, it t further motes these could aid the Count ion facilities. what it does not state is, who should do what.eCdnort (true) but identifies nQ County responsibility or role., Earticularly it .this is ludicrous, -What is the basis of the not the standards from or in he parkland fee,? It certainly is Eee should be based on what is, needed element or plan. The local recreation needs in all comintxnities in the provide. he for' areas beyond those paying a Ci,h county...in all _ Y or Town dedication fere C6-8ju guidelines for Preparing a local element ,have not been followed government Rec;reatio have no authority over developers (or9)a development. recreation di�5tricts the County, to adopt the tools or ordinances p It i.;; up to resources the districts need (6`9) - to provAde the The County should have a si riif{ beyond the existing recreation digstrctst role with, between and dependent ser Vice districts and is bath independent and County's largest economic �resazxr�recoulde5benrecreatione, ifTh� would properl y plan anti art in tti.- regard's Again I dont undfi rstanri the measures on policies and implementation Pages 6-1a- ' l ThLASe 410 not tie-in with an and ob�ecti'ves and the few goa1R� e,+- Y goals - element do not have related the first part of to overall poj1 -les, etc: The opehspace element made uatel recreai;ioh areas and;na"tural resoequat-e y identifies open spate lakes, etc. The open s ace i.'e•, streams, water�rys tied to an p policies C"�-G) are fragmented; not. lhcomplete, Y Inoama or ob ect ,ves and are inadequate and provided. Y cases no implementation measures are it identifies he er The best statement In t ntire element or document 1 (9-1-.7),-eTies and defihes a need fora .G is 7,61 - in recreatioh.oWever, it does not say, ghat flits is County should be impletnentec`y s or how this The important biological areas, etc. hot mapped for :toning' and protectioh ' ih the Appendices are:. Append,! rposesi The .SilVer bollar list Eac1,1 ttes the r p t !� t al Y. p .i along with Mari other areas, VA 9rourids is in the �ridix bu �1h 66hijejlao atei are n frill ted Ci,e, gymna8lurns, rneoting' Card ties, etc. faefilites listed under CAEtp CUni.versit riot Chico Area Recreation Dist i ,, et �, the 1'. Bidwell Park,, etc.) are r#ct facilities. °. r 17-7 gate to w Un _�.N hilJCM1 t EAITti# .��� AM z 5EA y PLANNING COMMISSION 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVEOROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 9596s.3197 June 10, 1988 PNDNE. saa.tso1 .: Michael Clayton Michael Clayton and Assoc 5764 Paradise Drive -aces Carte Madera StF_teM 5 . CA 9ag25 Res General Plan Element and EZR DOAx- Mike With this letter BU uo Prepare ah Energy to County would like to offer t t our General .plan. Natural Resources and You a con�,.ac� interview comrriittEeYweepuperoroto all Recreation Element for work and presentation to the A contract has been" s. the General_ Plan Prepared detailing the . of other badder scope of work relies scope of work on both heavily he EriVIrOnmental ltpact state law Y o your proposal t Report• =The- e en } Fount ro the General Plan n he reauiremehts of Y f_om the Cal,,forrli« Eher'deli Yes, and the for Performance are lis- on Page 4 or, grant to Butte Energy Corl4"'lission, Specific titnel%hes V�ith both q the contract and confo' Your bid and the Re uest for Proposals staff: I��e anticipate that: the Boarci of S contract on June b prepared by Count, your timeline- • 1988. uperVisors will sign this please hot-, us so We c et Signing date twill if the contra an make necessar Lfect safelPlease sign the enclos+d cohtrar_.t and ret.. Y adjuttments. y; t b trill then circulate the co urn t to our z ignature'brior to, Board apbroval. htract td office Lammed- bests revisions zn the County officers for . we 'W11l send you a hew orievent County Counsel rug,. Please call if genal to sign: -al,so to set u . you have any questions concernn to workin o a kickoff Meeting far the g this contract, and.. pro eat., g w�.th you: � tae look fort�ar ��ncerely _d »A: KRC�BR bi.rectbr of Planning .� Laura k�► little Attbciw ,�,e Planner L�TJsjs , Entlosure cc: Nancy Hanson: calif,' Erie - 5I7' Comrlii�si.ori RUM, cif S d+1lPfsrlRiA V GEORGE: bHURMlEJ m -tumor s3 lE LANDS tOMMMSICIN EXECU71VE0MCE 1809. 13th 5000t tLCr'J .r, CARTHY, Cfetltenant Goverrnor Sacramento, Golifomia 85814 +VRA,%,Y DAVIS, Contraftel CLMREf. DEDRICK 109fF, Ditector" of:flndrice ExerUt!Va Officer itri}a o. Piant)tntl Co,TM k ', ItJt'rrvillo, �al�f `trt April 18,1 108 Mr. Bill Turpin Butte County Planning 'Department 7 County 'Center Drive Oroville, CA. 9,5565--3397 Dear Mr. Turpint � This letter is in response to your Notice of Preparation (NOP) of a Draft: Environmental Impact Report (ETR) for the Energy, Hatural Resources, and Recreation Element of the Butte County General Plan staff of the State Lancs Commission (SLC) has reviewed the document and has determined that there are soveregn, lands in Butte county aver i��h ch the SLC has jurisdiction that could. be affected by the proposed action.' Those sovereign lands generally include the beds of the Saramene 'F to River, theather River, and Butte Creek. In additi' cOn eertin ttaterways i . e. Little Chico Creek, contain an easement for naviqatiob4 Any development projects, such as a;:edging or placement of structures on the above listed sovereign land,,:-�,t would, therefore, be subject, to the permitting and leasing' requirements to protect the wildl, 'fe, recreatio _ Anda, responsibi ' o f of the SLC. The SLC has a strop interest in nal � id ecological values of ,these State properties. the Ftrather r,�ver, as they tete within the ' .ye Creek, and y j Sacramento Ri eer t Butte have been Far our' snformation the Land and Tide and Subme- * ' a eyed. state Boe�� ,it formally ,classi#'ied in the . s�,C Tnventory of C�nconv g hands as possessi ng igniEi+rc environmental values Of statewide interest. Based on the values specified, see. tkhi'-it A, the affected portion of the :gat � aMento River has been classified as Class 'B - Limited Use; and: Butte Clrotk `ed as Class A. Restricted and the Feather River have been classify Use, 1rhe8e'use classes are defined as follows _,.4 9 _77- �le County� AIS i'OLLUTI N CO►NTR®1L DISTRICT, A28�` MIDWAY, SUITE 2D i d , arave. !a, Cali#amts d0 �� DURHAM, CALIFORNIA 95938 (916) 891-2882 i ) Bill Turpin', Senior Planner l M014: Jeffrey 1Iott, Air Pollution Control Officer x I i PUBJECT! Butte County General flan Energy, Natural Resources and Recreation Element DATE April 11, 198 Tae Butte County Air P611ation Control District (APCD) has reviewed the Butte County General. Plan Energy, Natural Resources and. Recreation Element: The air' quality policies that will be derived from the final document will need to con form to our existing State and local regulations and still be flexible enough to incorporate ruturs restrictions on industryy, agriculture and transportation related sources. I have btiefl.y outlined several items below which will impact the siting of a. facility or a project in Butte County. These stems should be included in the t!R to expedite the evaluation ,and permitting process. Any project that has the po, Tantial. to emit air contaminantsrequires the proponent to obtain permits to construct and operate from the Butte County APCD, The length, of time to issue a construction permit can take up to six months depending on the complexity and public interest in the project. It is very critical for power plants that may have a contract with a utility to submit a complete apiplicati n ,to the APCD'wcll in advance of the scheduled construction date. The California Olean Air Act (AB 2595 Sher), 'which was recently signed by the }Governor, mandates APOs to meet an annual 57 reduction in all nonattainment pol-, lutants, This will be achieved 'by' lowering the Best Available Witral Technology '.(;FACT) and offset limits currently contained in District Rule 430, In addition, All 2595 requires APGDs to insure that certain transportation control measures are implemented to, Achieve'these targets. tach, of these measures have the potential of affecting any exulting or proposed source in butte County. In addition p to District kule.480 and the rovisions of the California Clean Air '� al.iftl iwt, there are several new legislative.;requirements that will impact project px�ipos�ls LL8 uUt8 Air Toxics' Not iSpot,s and Assessment Act of 1987 A summary, of AB 2588 is`enclosed, This law applies to any source that emits 10 tons or more of a criteria pollutant or emits any topic pollutant ootl-y tained in the At 2588 toxics list (toolosed) in summary, At 2588 requires facilities to source test, submit an 'emissions inventory to the APC6, di, d. pay, emission fees, The APCD is required to rank Potenties sources according to their facilitof being a public health risk and perform risk:assessW:nts.of each 0 :3205 Hazardous Materials Emission A summary of AB 3205 is enclosed. 0`bOr items that should be contained in the DEIR to assist an applicant in per-- Vining and modeling requirements include the following: Etwironmental: Seton TVTOUant to Section 15125 of the CEQA guidelines, the DEIR must include a dcacrip t1on of the. environment in the Vicinityof the aiarendmentf this shotuld Include a discussion of the�climateointhe the valley and .fctOthills Of Butte County. The State: and ;Federal ambient air and quality standards. dtfv+u:l.d be represented along with a discussion of the ambient pollutant condahtra tions from stationary, mobile and transport sources. These can be provided by the AMD lmpacts- Pursuant to Section IS126 of the CEQA, guidelines, the DEIA should desc direct and indirect impacts of a ribe the project on the environment giving consideration. 9t* snort term and long term effects. The ambient air impacts resulting foe a project are considered, significant when the project has thepotential rutin to a,violation'of pix ambient air quality standard, treat nga nubl cntrib= Muisance or adveruhly affecting the health. of people living o"r irorking in; an area, S ecial. attention should be given td tale impacts of pollutants on sensiin, a 'recep;tors such. as : Ii Schools (children) 2. Hospitals (patients) 3+ Convalescent, fomes(senior citizens) 4. Agricultural Areas (crops) '�smission Quantificatiarn Aro ect P proponent wa31 be req,41,red todiscl 4 the types- and. magnitucdti of both` paint source acid area;soutce em .ssions, Tliu analysis includes emissions from the project construction phase, on and off road vehicle use associated with the: proms jl,'at and point source emissions. ratio nary source emissions from cogeneration or resource recovery type pro are discussed in. detail in tPA-AP-42, Cjects afnpilation of Air Pollutant Emission Pact�rs} Project,.; that involve land use decisior►s tiohich iconsist of housing,industrial or Commercial coinplees should be #` valuated' based up b the use of fuels for heating, electric power' generation,and motor vehicle uses iso be found in AP -42': The. APED con also These r stat stationary provide emission taetors far stationary nand mobile 80urces4 Every applicant, whether it is a point source or area type source; should compare the emissions from the project to the APCIVs SACT liiriir: as specified in Auld 430 as a general screeningmethod ad f _ar, signif3canr,e: Toxics' All emissions of toxic compounds as referred to in tiro, �i .list must be uantified and disclosed to 'the APCD, and a hedlth tis) 'sinent must be preki :t.ed for those emissions deemed significant berate a permit to, construct will be ., J►i r Nesourcesboar ^r° 15 U- Tochn i cal `Subpor all v I e l ofb. w. October 21. loss I 7 A,tA TOXICS 'HOT SPOTS' INFORMATION •ANC" `ASSESSAiENT aACT, OF 19$7' i FACT SHEET ON A3 2588 EftISSION INVENTORY CRITERIA AND GUIDELINES �,o,' 256'8 raqu I res spac I f I ad f ac I I l t 1 as to subm I t compr!lhens I ve, .a 1 r -',0,tIt s ,emission Inventory p ans to local_aIr pollution control 1 st,r Lets by s,pc>c I f l ed dates,. T'he cr I ter I a and 9U I d61 I nes wh'1 ch it. l I iia ;dop ted by the A l r Resources Board ( ARB ) pttrstian t to A$ X588 w`"lII asst t fa;c111tiat In p`reparIng these a I r toxics ants,stan inventory ,plans. The ARB 1n consul tat Ion with the air, poltr1tlon ctantr`ol d:ts.trlcts must develop and adopt t h 6, crlterl:a j end ,u,tde1Inet by ma y 1, 1989. Fac 1!Ity operatots mu t Inventory :,ertattct tolIc substances - that th>eIr facIIItIas ra16asm Into then .7.' 'fit a I r Eaoh facility bUst prepare a pian specifyIn5) how, It ►x111 a' 10:0 1 %Z amiss 104 'Inventory . 'The Plans must bo SUbm l t t ed to F tth,b Ztr POI IUtIOn control districts for approval. Upon appeoval „ h teacf'ac l I I ty must ImP lement I is plan an and sUbm i t an am I ss`I on Jnrantory report to tha district. The d;istrlcts W1 I' reVlew the ,reomrts and de'totmine which fact litters must prepare risk s�es:sm a n is ., .t h16-h 16 lc �:�ltistance x .are coy!nted7 The AR9 has comPIled A draft list of about 300 toxic substances IIL,e t*fled by reference In A9 9688. A copy of this list is Y 4-vaI1.1ble '"rota the'AR8 and W11I shortly be forma ly adopted. 1,he Ikst ay bo Updated' annualIy according to cr.1terIa spec1fIed:lig . 1'n'e taw. POr purposes of the emIts Ion Inventory 0') ter la and UIdid llnes ragUIat16h, the 11sted subst'an%tes have been p1Iced Inits two groups: r 1'3 subdtanc6t .fnr +which fact I ttias hiuSt ,duY an, i ssions; and (Z) substances for wh 1 ch f ac i l i t i as are )t� ;hdloate any Use and/'or production. 1rlo. nrt r north A fac1llty is subject to the flrst Phatdl of the roporting rd-MaMts of 88(t Slatcs, anyistadsUbstanco �;ts,ds Oree ieacesS(beanysubs`tan ce which' reacts; to 'form a II'sted substance)-+ and, (2) it Qmlt;s 25" tons or Acre Per year of total Organic gases: Particulates, tiltrcgan „pxlde,s or suitor oxides., Fit llitlps I(st'ed In any ezlsiing tOxIt ttso or toxics emisslon survoy, (ntventory,:be report ra'Ieosed or conpl lent by a district are also itbjett tc the first Oisase reporting regttlrdments; These'facllltlos must submit their emission Inventory ®rt"t to thn tit 0QI'1UtIbh controi'distrlcts by August 1, 1985. FarilltIdS roloasing grea'tet than 16 And less ' than25 tons piss year of total organic Base,-s, particUlatcs, hl'tro�len oz idol or sui1Ur oxides and any listed subttaiica or orectlrsbr mUs t subrn t em lss l'on I-nvehtory plans by August i , 1890. Stalld'r toUrcet tray be covered iat'er,A `e� S u:err eml,ssIon; Inventory plan must Include a deg-„ri : pilon of the ,eti which wI I I be used to quant I.fy 's.ubstanco �°tor 1 a d each hazardous PIrv:�.» AS 2588 requires source testing to.b.e Used whenever ;nary to verify em:isslon estimates to the),extent i c o'109ItA1ly foaslb a, The crI land ,, a Idelines wl i t conditions �.t1f rA-4 -11: and locations where source testing or 0ther 31:r'e0ent tochn ques,are to be required and will reference gVf�d methods. For those em'Isslon points not reQuiring source tf#t ng or other m©asuramont to:chnlquos emissions must al tied by -ono of the a be pproved estimation methods Iden'tlfled ;l.n 14,b;o Cr I terla and guldrl lnes. InVant0rp`Ians must speclfy tha acs'1`mt:a"t Ion met -hods or outer measurement technIbUes that arl I I ba tor' each emitted compound not quant I fled by soUrce test 1>ng, ng emlaslona7 Elaa ;AIB �r 1 1 i make available AUgus t _1:; 1 989, a technical support A:!:Wfitnt that will further assist focil!ties In quantifying using that accepta:ble �6mi5=ZJbhs est imat lar methods ident i f'Ied In Ift& der i ter l a and CU l de l 1 nes. The document ;m.t r° tat s ng co,:jprehens l ve ov I ons f or uI w l i l proide em i ss i on ®st: I I on �t;~chln,lgUeS (EE -Ts) and for using other accept;ablu ostlmat I on Im41h?V41s such as em;i'salon factors, mass b:alanco, model In a�rs�y,!cttont and engintsering calculation,, 9' A H sample of an FET and other e.stimatton methods,IdentIfIed in the ctltdrIa and irla� lncs o9 regulation y 1a 1 I i 6o ava i I ab I e bo tore August i 989. . are r t Mk asAeents read raa� .c i s must r e v I o to t h e emissi'on data submitted by facil itie`s, � o j':r bf December 1 1990", they mast � t hold a ttb 1 1 c 1���4 P hear Ing t:o g, s,zr �tlze fa- Illti$s for the purposes of health risk l assessment re"r,Uti+r,am6nts. Fadi I Itles destgnatcti as hI9 h pr lar I t mus t sub+n 1 t zs,Sessments to the, dlstrlrt by Uay1.1991 Risk' assess.r,�ents r�I I be r6v1awest by the dlstficts and by,;'the �`. Fa ec+ar tn.ent of Rea 1 t:h Ser�v l c es, c ts t I t op er<ators mti5;t not i I y aril a:`posed y parsons of the risk assessment resitl is I f a d,1 str tct daterrines that there Is a significant health risk a'ssocia,tea, with rhisslons from the fadilltyy xi i r 0aad1 irid fn R8 t • o adopt crItar1a arVd" guldq Ines IGrr emLssVon Inventory p1n , Pub I lchoar I nq 115 31chodU 160, for h or i I, p n AQ,1'gu s t 1 i 989 ARB�y s technical support document on emI'ssfon estimation techniques will be available. A -UV s t t , 198910 Dowdltne far facIIItles to submit first Inventory plan to air Pollution control d`Istr acts. l�a:ce,mbor 1 - � r 38.9* Deadline by which the, dl tridts must approve, modify, and Approve as, modlfled, or return for rovlslon and resubm s.SIon the facility plans. .IUn e t g0a t 9, • edd t I tie, for fa D cl I i`t les to submit emission Inventory reports to the dlstr'icts,, August 1 , 1'990 t 1�+-25°` to,ns pet year Dead I ine for su'bm 1 t't l in tic llltilos) Inventory plans to air poi IUt lon control dIttr Iidt _ geoembst 1 i 990m Deadline for dIttrIcts to decide Which facilities must pr©paro risk assess1entst �g 91 a 0e,ad I l he for 3 1 acted fackiltlos `to subml r Ltk atsassmonts to the dlstrlctsL ° Appl I 6 to facl l itles which. ManL fractUre# formulate, uso; or, reloasa i )sled t>ox It per Year 'o i" Cr I t,er (�' substandas Mid whIdh; emI{ 2$ or more ton 001'lutants; to if current distrAct ale and t 10d I l steel I n taplzlcs emisslon reports or lwventorles r T • y! 4 I I 4nd i x. A-I-T �1 4, Substances fe. Which mi ,�Q—h7 - ssions Must Be OUan .if,Qft Che MI cal, Abstract Service (OAS) thimber ,Substance Name 75070 Acetaldehyde 60355 Acetamide 107028 Acrolein 79061 Acrylamide 107131 Acrylonitrile 107051 Allyl chloride 117193 2-Aminoanthraqu,inone 61825 Amitrole t 7664417 Ammonia 7-440-31 Arsenic Ai"senic compounds (inorganic) 77.8442.1 Ars„`- 1332214; Asbestos 73432 Benz zne 928.75 Benz:wdine Land its salts) Benz idine_based dyes i 56553 Benz[a]anthracene 205-692 Benzo(b)fluor•anthene 207089 Benzo[k1fluoranthene 50328 Benzo[a]pyrene' 10C447 Benzyl ch'lor'ide 7440411 Beryllium 542881 Bi's(chloramethyl)ether " 7726956 Bi.omine x `Bromibe dompoun'ds (i�organac) 106990 1.3-Butadiene 744'0439 Cadmium Cadmium compounds Carbon black extract 58235 Carbon tetrachloride, -- Carrageenan (degraded) 7611.1 Chlorinated flOorocarboil (CFC-113) 1782505 Chlorine 56757 Chloromphehicol 108607 Chlbrobenzene 13909096, 1-(24chloroethyl)•3-(A-methylcyclohexyl).- 1-nitrosourea (Methyl CCNU) , yiubstancQs For Which Emissions MutBe DAntif 1* ed (cont.) CAS dumber__ 67663 Substance Name _ Chloroform Chlorophenols 76062 Chloropicrin 126998 Chloroprene 95830 4-Chloro-o-phenylenediamine 95692 p-Chloro-o-toluidine 1'8540299 Chromium (hOa'valeht) 8.007452 Coke oven emisslons 7440508; Copper Creosotes 120718 p-Cresidine 1319773 Cresols' 135206 Cupferron 668113 Cyciof,aximide ' Dialkylnitrosamines 6`15054 2,44iaminoanisole 95807 2,4-Diaminotoluene 53703 Diben ta,hjanthracene ?!` x Dibenzofurans (chlorinated) 96128 1,2-Dibromo4-chloropro,pane (08CP) t 106467 p-Dichlorobenzene (1,4-Dichlorobenze0e) 3,3'-Di-chlorobenzidine, Di`(2-ethylhexyi) phthalate (DENP) 24A113 Dimethylamine 60117` p-Dimebhylam :noazobenIdne 57,147 1,r)*mlithv!hydrazIhe 17181 01itatn,j ti f .te i - Diotins (chlotitiatuad di`be4iodioxins) ; - 5bvironmenta;l tobacco smoke 106898" Epichlorohydrio 140885 Ethyl acrylate 75003 Ethyl chloride 106934 Ethylene dibromide (1,2-Dibromoetha;ne) i07062 Ethylene dich'lorid'e ichloroethane) 75218 Ethylene oxide 96457 Ethylene thiourea Fluorocarbons (chlorihated &'brominated) 60000 Ebrmaldehyde - Gasoline' Vapors 111308 Glutaraldehyde Glycol ethers C ;i, 1� coot.) 126,078 GriseofulV�in�n�e 118741:He kachTor obelizen'e Hexachlorocyclohexanes 77474 Hexachlorocycla,ppntadiene 30201-2 Hydrazine 7647810 'Hydrochloric aci'i 74908 7664393 Hydrocyanic acid Hydrogen fluoride 7783064 193395 Hydrogen sulfide' * C1 Indeno 2,3, cd � � pyrene Isocyanates 74399.21 lead 108316(1;hargan Lead compounds i c) Maleic' anhydride 7439965 Manganese 7487947 743937.6 Mercuric chloride Mercury _ 67561: Methanol 7483.9 711556566 Methyl brarnide (Bromomethane) Methyl chloroform � 624839 (1.1,1 -Trichloroethane) Methyl isocyanate. 80628- 101144 Methyl methacrylate 75092 4,4'-Hethyleno bis(2-chloroaniline) Methylene chloride (HOCA) 191779 (Dichloromethane 5937413 443481 4,4' -Methylene diahilihe (and its dichloride' ) Methyl mercury (Dimethylmercury) Metronidazole 90948 Minhler,s ketone 91'�g3 Mineral fiber Naphthalene 74400aa,Nickel 13463393 12035722 Nickd1 carbohyl Nickol 61674 subsulfide` Nir'idaza;le 98953i Nitrobdhzdne 382705_ 79469 Nitrogen mustard N-OXidd 2-Nitrooeopano' 561.85 62769 N-Nitrosodietliylartitie ' H-Nittoso.dimethylath ne A3 irrinir.i..r :. jyj I Stjbsfi k noes ,Fdr IhiBe, Ouant�fi .ad `c apt.t ,,, .member 156105p-llttrosod' S�r�,st��o ►��m� _ hepylamine 924,163 N-tlitrosodi-f-but:ylamine 621647 N-Nitrosodi-n-propylamine i 105-05956 11-N i troxometbyl ethylamine' 59892, N-Nitrosomorpholine 100754 N-Nitrasopiperidine 930552 N --l1 i trosopyrro 1'd i ne 434071 Oxymetholone PAHS (Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (Plychlorina_ted biphenyls) 1?,71843 Pegs Perch IG oethylene (Tetrach1ot'oethe6e 50066 Phenobarbitol 10895'2 Phenol 75'445 Phosgene 7803512 Phosphine _ 7723140 Phosphorus e 85449 Phthalic anhydride 7758012 Potassium bromate - 57830 Progesterone 1120714 1,3 -Propane sulton:e 11507.1 Propy l eine 7.5565 Propylene oXide Radionuclides 1782492 Selenium selenium compound Silica, crystalline 1310732 Sodium hydroxide 100425 Styrene 1746016 ' 2,3 7,84etrachlorodihen2b,-p-dioxin (TCDD 62555 Thicacetam.ide 62556 Thiourea I 108883 Toluene 584849 T61uene-24-diisocyanate 910'87 To"luone-g, 6- -diisocyanate 79016 Trichloroethylene 88052 2;4,6 -Trichlorophenol 51796, Urethane 75014 Vinyl chloride 75359 Vinylidene. chloride " Xylenes - 7440666 Zinc 1314132 Zinc oxide W denotes a chemical category i i 11 w AtaDendiX -T 1' Sub an ahfLC�r_.�addt'iQn,__ or Other Chemical Abstract Service ^--p%�`stLaIlL 53963 2-Acetylaminofluorene 23214928 Adriamycin 1688537 A,2 Aflatoxins ' '. 60093 97563 P-A. inoazobenzene (4-Aminoazobenzen ) o-Amtnoazotoiuene 7.12685 92671 2�Amino 5-(5-nitro-,2-furyq-1,3,4-thiadiazole 4-Aminobiphenyr) 82281 54625 14mino=8-methylanthraquinone Aminopterin 90040 Analgesic mixtures containing phenacetin Androgenic (anabolic) steroids 114292 140518 o-Anisidlhe o-Anisidine hydrochloride 492808 Aramite Auramine 1115026 Azaserine 445866 Azathioprine 205823 7 Senzo[,j]l`luorahthene 1980798017 3 ilenzoic trichloride ,(benzotric'hloride) Benzy'l violet 48- 494631 Betel quid with tobacco N-R-8is2-ch tor.oy �_ � eth l 2-naph thy) amt''ne (Chlarhdazine 1538 49 Bischloroethyl nitrosourea Bitumens, extracts of steam-refined and reftined bitumens �' 55113 - 25018158 B l eortiyc i �a s 4,-Butaned�iol dimethanesulfonate (Myleran) Butylated hydroxyanisole 3068886 (BNA} beta-Butyro'lactone 305033 82939 Chlorambucil �` 143500 13010474_ Chlorcyclizine hydrochloride Ghlor'decone (Kepone (CChl),rn ethylj-3-eyclohexyl�-1-nitrosourea 1073t`l2 (CCkI�') Chtordmethyl methyl ether (technical jrade) . Chloropheh;Xy ber;bicides 1 A�»5. r } Subslaugs Fow Whick Pro on, tlse Or Oi her r Presence Mutt Be ReR4t t (cont.) CAS Nul�.Ae, r substance Names � 156G3, 7 11 Cisplatin 63500 ^ ,r Citrus Red lao, 2 1490:1(,,3'7 Cycas i n 50181) ;'ryc I ophospham i de 4342034 Dacarbazine 20811813 Daunomycin S02" OUT (1,1, W-7rich'loro-2,2-bis(p chlorophenylI)ethane) 613354 HX-Diacet,ylbenzidine 39 554 Lit 2,4-Diaminoanisole sulfate 144,04 4,4`-Diaminodiphenyl ether >m 6t 68 Dibenz[a,h]acridtne 2;24420 Dibenz[a,J)acridine , 1 sif4159.2 I9-0ibenzo(c,9)cabazo'le 112654 Dibenzo[a,e]pyrene .49,40 Dibeozo[a$h3pyrene 139559 bibenxo[a,i]pyrene x , 19130) Dibenzo[a,1.]pyrene 542156, 1,3-Dichloropropenr= 1464535 DieporVhutane 1615801 1,2-Diethylhydrazine - 55531 Diethylstilbestrol f j 64,619 Diethyl sulfate' 223807x. Oiglycidyl resorcinol ether 94596 Dihydrosafrole 119904 3,.3"-Dimeth6xybenzidihe f 55738540 trans -Z [(D methylamino)methyliminoj-5- K' �,2-(5-nr_tro-Z�furyl)vinyl�.-1,3,4-oxadiaz.le 159 137 3,3 D�methylbynzidine (o-tol�dine) 79447 de r 540738 a, 2D'imethylhydr;az iner 630933 Diphenylhydantoin �-122667 1,Miphenylhydr�azine (Hydrazobenzehe-; 1937377 Direct 814ck 38 2602462 Direct glue 6 1318021 Crionte 50282 rsttadi,6I 17 0 53167 - E trole ` 57636 5'thin y estradiol * Estrogens, nonsteroidal * Estrogens, steroidal 52500 Ethyl methanesulfonate 54350480 i Etretinate ,. 1 Sub��S_E4L�Chi�h Produrlion USP n� B Resorted (cont,.) 765344 Glycidaldehyde 3;57075' 2-(2-Formylhydrazino)-4 (5-nitro-2-furyl) 877301/4 thiazole Gid-P-12� ( Amino-6-methyldipyrado[;1,2-a:;3" 2' 67730125 16568028 -d,�midaz4le) Glu -P -2(Z -Am i nod i � pyrido,[1,2-x:3',2'-d� imidazole Gyromitrin (Acetaldehyde' 6 0319 68 methylformyl hydraz,one) Nexamethylphosphoramide 034932' 76180966 NYdrazine sulfate IQ (2-Amigo-3-methylimidazoC4�5-f]Guanol 9004664 4759482' Iron dextran complex ne) $01042 Isetretinoi0 Lead acetate 7446277 520854 Lead phosphate Medroxyprogesterone acetate 148823 Melphalan 4484208' 75558 S-Methoxypsoralen 3697243 2-Methylazirid'ine (propyleneimine) 5-Mpthylchrysehe 72333 Mestranol 101611 74884 4,4'=-Mieth;ylene bis(N,N-ditnethy'l) behzami`ne Methyl iodide 66273 129157 Methyl methanesulfonate 1 501.53493 2-Methyl-l-nitroanthraquinone'?ncertain purity), 3-Methyinitrosaami.nopropiohitrile � 54001914 4-(Methylnitrosuamihc)`-1-;(3-pyridyl)-1� x0257 56042 _ butanone (N,�K) 11 -Methyl Nk-nitro-N-nitroscguanidine- tt _ Methy.i th iourO 2385855 Mineral olls Mirex 50077 315220 Ritomycih C Monocrotaline 1399,18 5-(Morpholihome thy l 3- i 50.5602 3771195 nitrofurfurylid'ene amino 2 L oxazol°idinone' Mustard gas(4ulfur mustard) 1Jafenopin 91598 2j -Naphthylamine 139139 Mickel ounds comp Nitrilotriacetic acid 502879 5-Nitroacenaphthene '99592 1836765 Nitro�o-an.isidihe Ntttdfen (technical grade) A-7 Mar Sti 0!1 For Which Rtgd! ction. 2 Mil e nBe 'Rekorted Numbgr, ,a 5ub!�ta a Name F 5551340 1.-[(54itro€urfuryliden4)amino;j-2-imidazol id`ihone; : $31828 N-[4-(:54itro-2-fiury1)-2-th'i.azolyl]acetamide 51752 N'itroge'n taustard 1116147 N-liitrosodiethano'lamirid 759749 N-Nitreso-N-ethylurea 615532 N=Nitroso-N-methy'iuretli ane (N -Methyl -N- N-Methyl-N-nitrosdorpthanl. n i t r o s dorp t h a n o 4549400 N-Nitrosome yl; finylamine 684935 N-0trosoj-N-rnethyk',urea 16543558 N-Nitro'sonornico't` he 13256229 N-Nitrbsosarco0n0 A 68224 Noreth stervne 2646,175 Oil Orange 55 794934 Panfuran S ('Dihydroxymethylfuratrizine) 62442 Phenacetin 94780 Phenazopyridine hydrochlotide 57416 Phenytoin * Polybrominated biphehyls (PBBs) 3761533 Ponceau MX 356409:8 Ponceau IR 366'101, Procarbazine hydrochloride Progestins 57578 beta -Propiolactone 51525 Prapylthiouracil '' 506556 Reserpine 811,012 5'accharin' 94597 Safrole -' Shale .i It 132274 Sodium o-phenylphenate - Soots: 100481.32 Ste!ic�matacystin 18883664 Stteptazotocin 96093 Styrene oxide 95067 Sulfallate - - Talc. containf ng a�best'iform`fi>aers �. Tars 50351 Thalidomide 139651 4 V-Thiodianiline 1314201 Thotlurh dioxide - Tobaccoproducts smok;ele�t * alpha -chlorinated toluenes 95534 b -Toluidine ;r A 9 , r , 111 l i l 5u `stances Fc,r �h i oh Prat ian, � ` PrsenGe ' eoor�� (GOht 636215 o -Toluidine hydrochloride 8601352 299752 Toxaphene (PolyohlorMated camphenes) Treosulfan 62244 Tris(l-aziridinyl) phosphine sulfide 624.50060 (Thiotepa) Trp -P,-1 (3-amino-1,4-dimet'hyl-5N-Pyrido[4,;3- blindole) 6�, 00071 Trp -P-2 (3.-Amino-l-methyl-5'H-pyrido[4 3-b] 1071 indole) Trypan blue X6751 trach mustard 3561 Va lProate $13602 Vinyl bromide X1$;12'° Warfarin = denotes a chemicalCategory i I A- .— • ....... .... . . i.-, i..i. .n. , cw µ : � fi�lated tlteretu. Tht� fees hall not exceed the estimated. costs of review hig rrAv';,rriyt ttit;, and enforcing the p6n. for tvl ich the fees, are charged. 7J r �istrick board shall hold.4 public lwaring at least W'days prior to the- meet trr r tit district board at which the adoption or revision or the fee schedule is to tt:i►,lk�red, and 'supporting data on theucfual yr estimated costs requirod to. pr-)w;dxy the :,ervice rar which the fee, Is proposed to be charged, shall bo attide a :iia al,tr� ttt`tliat public hearing, .�1;'�ta�l r�ny violation nC any proti•Isiott of this part, or a[any order, rulc+,,or reg` trlii"i ra4srtf thr .state bourn: or of any distriet, may be enjoined iri a ci�kfl'actioit h rn�out ate name or th��pe+yple of the Mote of Californiii, except° that the plain- t,,�?t`taltult iaat bo required to allege Facts, lael r, M1itdi tlittxttr.."rcrne y* uk lacF pr lei she -w, or tending #rr shoot, irreparsbfe dairtage or (u) Thestate board shall prepare and subatiit to the Legislature its ree o n dl►itxorts «8th regard to theTcgulatibif0madne vesseh on or before March 19, ,15 `Fite report shall be prepared in consultation Mth a maritime industry, sl ioritre,'the districts, and members or the p4bli6. The naritline industry task l"r� sl;,still hate representation from oil refiners,,marine tol;ei ��esseh, dry" eargo; sxsela, atrtd'tug'and barges; Including, but not be limited to, the following groups„ �r ';a 'ate Galffornia Association of Ni -t Authorities, ��� �'t'.►.e:l�oreigri,Shipor�,tters Assaci;ttipn. r3,1 Vve, Independent Refiners ' ssocfatfon of C lllforniit. Al ase PaciCc Merchant Shipping Association, far airine 7`unker Cttrnpariies. .6 Vic: United Mates Coast ward, iba Tae report shall discuss issues anti impacts Lb'.. trill r-Osult fiorn recom- :rr rjerll oaittrol measures. including, but not, lirnifed'to• conloet tine imt;act on Stade lzzt;r'es ltesd (rtv) Vie state b 11weni�li�titns or ,,►r tis4 March 31, tsd) ,t��uthfng itt zr�;or r.�,�t�atfoit or#ot„to Julys al���t�� ATir7ntV� rtltir�ter of n! urret �sadd.e distrad is r Vii;. > delete erattxi adop3t. fal Prior to IMA4T.ti ,alb SAVF:T't' OOD 87 f 11 The need for the emission reductions exltecttId to be achieved from the im. plementatonor the proposed rule or regtiilation, and the extent to which the rule or regulation is necessary solely for the attainment of a state ambient tort quality= standard. (2) 1"he reladv4 e cost of aehiev ng the emission reductions from the proposed' rule or regulation compared to the cost of feasible reductions from sources other than powerplants (3) The at'ailaibiliky and technological feasibility of control technolggies rP-! quired by the proposed rule or regulation, (b) Aides acrd rogul'at on.s affecting the operation of existin POWc-rplants adr pted after January 1,1982 by the state board or any district shall take into con. siderationthe findings under subclivistan raj. "140 tmn 10. � E;�,} a Ttov T c .vet a�Y AND RESOVRG,F. 13ECO,'ER*( Pi ojMTS 41515, The f4gislature finds and declares w that present methods of genet. acing and, ruing energy in California result in substantial waste of sueh energy through the loss of'exhatist steam.and heat which ii not retzoveredor othemise put, to use, and that this waste taf etiergyr results iii aziterse nvitonrztental and eca> noiriidimpacts acid accelerates the meed for new powerplant construction, and in' , ereaasses dependence upon, impo ted oil, (la) that the. use of cogeneration .technol ogre can substantially inerease the efficiency of energy use in California and on also resultin enOronmental and economic bencAft for the peopple ar the state, (c) that the expanded use of cogeneration technology isspecificatlly encouraged as a matter of natloiial: energyM policy through ilio tax anti regulatory incentives pro- tided in tate'"atlomal Energy Act, and through state legislation which entourage's . lam pp t . g .. , p �ei,' . vi ) ° . chi. ex ditfous a rca:' of royer,ts,,�rtdd theonstructton an operation of ouigeneration Facilities will result in. nn incremental air qualiq, emir ', r �° flu r•a9.g er I not adept airy rei;ulat ori to irrmplemet t the study reel m $e establish cinisson rrciuireme nts to myarine vessels Pf& 'shall be constri►� i to pr#iMbit 6darcement of ttnv ?g tnarir`i a _vessels �tt loch had iii adr }j�ted by aoy dis- wl ►r isamended th.et6afttt. qu rdssels shall nak 13e sul5ject ata sulfur dioxide emission re• ca hitig In this part shall boa on rued to prohibit adoption;' m' e dt regulation, governing sulfurdioxide emission vessels, trading the rftajority of the time in intrastate as. apt or in interstate commerce, bi: ween alilorma and drCernetatbratflyrulerar.Yd' l�tongovernfngsulfurdf� th its on roarthe vessels rs:hit{h had been adopted—by any;, th 1. 1 i of eet r my ts>itid jttnuaryt 1.19W, and as of iiwt data si i nae teci stakutei tvh1 is enacted before Jt)nuary 1,1950, leptin .rules of rdgulatitiris tvhlch iirotiltl affect the o' i h hh r e air, brim arid' that such hen t sl4oL dd be recognizdd nus for te�tcogeneration projui:ts. furtiher l�rrds aid declares ta) that !'he disposal of liquid is environmental and economic problems tot local gov- rj �Ehhat resource reccivery technology pttseiitly ext'Is pal waste to dnergy^ while also reeovr�nng substanhat lc� that the construction of resaii(rce recovery projects onrnental oats edonomic problems associated with mul e at the same time producing additional supplies of en- I (d) thlitluch'proJeutsshould theroftire be encouraged ►til growth 1h Oinents In th tants+ t estate board or MY diltrict shall consider itn toe cifY they supportfn iitkoXtnation "relied upon rr�itli ier findsand ddclaresthat the 1p r 3Mendmerits to Reallyauthorize' local: oVeronieats'to. rovide Air Impact of projects Wit comntUIiM1•i a benefits, s' dad resource reeolverr° projects, pay} prolIWing re" estate ►tttpleinentation plati devotop, kk, cooperation with thd'distridtsu and the r inventory 6'. ootehtiatl cogdncration technology ;staid ti�haclt cot�td lei* crsnstrurrited before 1557.. " �� ttr`�t�tt .v���s.�►��° t,°c���: �k�t*'rtr AND SA Fct�� ��t.7.ta��. 89 41519 `Chestate board, in cnriperation.svith the State Solid tt'aste Management i produced basis' than t Board, iht� distrrets and the regional plar mA agenciea shall develop nn;#ns'e tar p ? ht� em#ssions svhiGh ss cold be generated by the fossil fuel" -of potential resource recover), projects %s hie are lanncd orproposed'16 lie Con- P S generating the absence of the _.: t setedliefore j9fi3� ��rdlect#or faGrl%tGtr�G enQrahn system �n the axr, li:sin iti P C),( tttilv. it ' di lacement credits shall be credited to a prniect or facility' only to 415201, in preparing the inventories required pursuank to Sections 1516 and khe ext,enk � cessaty to sakisfy:district offsek requirements, aril only t lolq, tfti* stile beard shall contract wv'Y.th pri ate farms or utilize existing board has been grarited.Far offsets provided: pursuant paragraphs ? y of er credit ' 'ision (a) of Section 42314. p p-agralihs {)and i4) ofsiib• 19 p jul div std, ws•}.riches er costs less,,80th rrventp�rtrs snail be tori# �Ieted not later�tharr. 1; (0) The cogeneration technology project or qualifying facility pr6poneixt, and GFt t*riari 2, t# t�;st'ti�)+ 11(3 t a7ro r^ ton COGEN sit � -tt» s'A' the owner, or operator of the purchasing utility; shall provide to the state board or� � A SOUR REc+ s"a~iti' Pn jF s the di'Orict, as the case may be, the information nut publicly available from site scar to make the detertnan.a,tinrts ret#(tired by.'ths i or loei►1 agemr#es svh#ch'#s acct i ate districts shall' prow'ide For, and shallperio�iaoally r•#se al :ap- S. 3eGkion,1'l'he infsource test data fnchide but is not lim#t!cd to, all of the i'ollovviol- nate, the ro`th ahbvvanees necessarw to accorn n shall 4Watt, . ial . j tl . rtiodatr, the net a#, tt 'ty � t21 Chronol ormaho ta, rr Uali if any, oitageneration technolcg projeets and resour" rt"v en pro)eGts ogical fuel use data. (. ) x7traant;t Sec y j r)' 9Sx and subsequent periods thereafter`,' t,3r Chronological elertrie load data, be .a 9 tfh in rovidut tho utility p na bepftfeac wed nn4.�3t4 itted so that, state grid federal amblei)t ai. quality P g r h dis lacement credits required by this sect#on, grid for purposes of this sectiononly the util# if oat. an .a lrcant,, shall no be re- xa attainloVed an maintained or that reasonable Furtlir r °pr ess be made .ko- t}', pp quired to furnish emission orkets on a case-bycase iasis for the project. This sem. (b) if appr i. 4t Wr.the districts shall submit to the state board, for ie-lusion 'tri hon does not permit a district cats a case-b%icase, basis telimit the abrlit' of tho tail - the nit state implementation plan re%ii ons the necessar control measures f ° r it, to operate its, e 4litithydrocarbon corribustion facilities in accordance u%viih the they-,9MWVth alloWances (or federally app,toi'edr nonattaittme t llutai ts, nd e. t� uirelbefits oft e 'ubhc Utilities omnussiorx or the os ernirt bed of a public q rsorsregu#red'by siibdivis#on anj. P! utr'tity owned by manic#polity or other political subdigvision afhe state. P toy Agdistriet wvhich lacksa federallyap rated, demonstration,ofattainment 416 5, a). lir consider3r , ; { t khe offset requirement for a pto�ect facility vvht h q Ey" gen d#oxdeis nail utilizes a riculkural syste roducts, ,crest waste products, yr si re �ir its v he d mb "`h all wartceforaanv for un #ter this sectio until ;% . g. i f p s, riular organic - o s[fter the distr,ct makes: both dcitiortsizations, I' deral:a r va' n 5 biomass fuel m a steam. generator (boiler), to produceeteetncal en rgy, pp o [shall be or to be used as a digester fceedstock in a cogeneration.facility, the disks%ct sha I m. 't +witty afker public notice pied by .the Env ronnionkal Proteehota elude the incremental emissroris benefit that occurs because those wastes a e dolt rmioed based on re lation ado — _ r not A . pp° - - . po y . , R � , x p ce and' o rttrnxt}^ 1"or cbmrxierit After a district dem.LL tLs sed;. of b +tiprytt f#eld burning or b},w forest -land burn#ng tt' th�lsiornass Fuel �t eritx the,distriGt Ftiay estabCrs a :grOW4jt al[oscanee by a7ltrcating s 'airld urduiitril}=ar okhersvtise be burned iii that trtanner'in the same m>~ air, basin, The, 4�.gri siffit :th r control ease she ambient air qualitystandard or through adop em#ssic13 credit hall be pffset at a ratio of 1, to l for rionatkaixtrtienk 1Iutants'if within iJ' miles, itnd at a:raho oF2 to 1 ifFurtlitr than IO"ni les wwtithin the stone air, Iii. 'ili.dewelop" basun, u-�MP .�rid_u ate as t ��ss.xn Goo nation sv#th ilie state. board, shy (aPd he a p (ire to determine khe ruagiu tulle of thG : ib) The districts incl the stag board, tri cooperakionF shall develori and, on -or emissicr,�, ,from thg existing r?ctz is gciierating syskem'#n the air basin which before Yulyr I,1983, and at least once every twvo )rears thereaFter reeviluite a r %vjWd' be displaced if cogeneration, technolu prq'ects and,' uaiifwan favi `acs cedura to. deteernine the (availability, and magnitude of:the oils�ts resultin from 1 q l h eniiss#o»s bene lits; #ncl'ud#n r �. rtYristructed. The procedure shall be used once each year tai detertnine tis+; � ui �ecoun ing Fal the quatitit� of bt �4hht . onia,% material the #ncrernenkal uta dasplacerrtcrik credits vvhich:shall be used in review�tng .he' rmit.a lica= redits calculated for purposes of Sectien 4231,5 its nrc`essari''tb r rrf r.xiesv Go ettera�ion technology pe pp ensure that state and fes eral ambient air ual#t Stand irds may be achies cd `unci g gy proJecks and giralifyirig Facilities during the rria#ntairied, or khat reasonable Farther ' t:OL',ess be d v ei.. antifiable pmade toward ttttainrmont. f re rp p . rc ,ar itd Sushp ens<tre that the G edits are real, pernianentr qu (fi e app lira!(. shall row id'I the state ark or a dlstriGt, asthe case vias° be V, A �distrxck may reduce the emission arrack requirerneht fora Go enerat# r ' Enc infarmaatfon nok pulohely available from state or local xt eticies svh#ch is'n t 6,0z+project 'br uahFying fac#litkyyf�� by the utility' d#splaceriir r t Gr�dats deter4' essary "to make the determinations required by this soction. The info, atiori. shit ri ed pursuant to S.ub�:visxon la�� ,In X11 ca. s #n which a cogeneration tech- to i irtcludc, but is riot hnutud Eo, the following, p eGtarualrf) rug faciIit satisfies subdiv7sior lc) -,.a distttict shatl`xeduce tlieo ClI die +qualitj+. of fuel or wtasie to btu of us6d in the Fitch#t}F. set; �tiretsien"t for .the protea oe fat#1#tyr,liy the itiilhd d#s lacezi enk cr'diks i x�.{ fit L7 Et l\tiSAtE:71 : its 14EAG',tt AND '$At, ;Tt°CC)bt.' 95 t Elie prevention of afire ;hazard which cannot 'be abated by any other area in vrhich the disposal site is located, The permits shall alkirr burnarr Onlyoil, days during which agricultural burning is not prohibited by the state bard ur= b file ittsireretion of public employees in the rr,ctltocls of righting fire. savant to'Section,418 « t p y g fire, rr lien such ilii; 3s trlr o ermit shall be issued titil there is filed rv' 1`) instruction of em lo; e6s in methods of fighting, [ illi the dratnct a rti rittcn stateN pp sett atttoti4tnt to perimt, an pro tistd far,ndustrial purposes: rnrMnt bye fhe owner of the land q1i ►vhfrh the disposal site i [ t pp r: s o. ted, or, his agotit, xtd 71ffi scthn# of barlti.bres necessary to save life; or, valuable Property purse- or,!I`sottie atherpersun as 1a►vfull?';°Itt possession of land b such nth' r t ? = y e person, Iand b the city or county, >tt !i#, ��«�.°t1o11 �t25 of tho'>�ultl;c �tesources Cady aplt�ravin the burningort sur.h y p r to issuing a perrnrt, the distort may inspect the mood waste to be i .t« i lite abaternent of fire hazards pursuant- to SCa ttan 1 trig 1'r%o f,�ivoi0e or pest prevention, where there is ;art tmmedlate need ror and no bu m, to vetify� that rt is txc[usi cly nonindustrial -wood �vaste,lrarn tr i s, a iraes reu., «:Itabjtl altafittttive tti burning, :ind inrush. „ kNQtr%rtithstandin Sotion 418W with respa co woo • y "te from treys disll�el The state board shall approve the'use of amen outdoar,lires at a clesagnated a :t. ashes ten property biyitt der'' ' ; sal site to disp�ose of such woof` •j:•este if such all operation of tlta d s" .l site vs h p pe: y thj disposal P p %61 not ,prevent :the ach,evenient and maintenance:,of am ie elri ed far eorrtrtiercral is residential put- b ntitr duality t t«u► gs the property, where they dards. Vie approval shall be granted for iz Inin,mom of one °ear; t t au ' i3rrtl !r hen the crittinsc sul.t d fi o brush rle;traitce dine in rom< ip! In :teekrn Ppxdvnl Frgnt ilia state board to use o y pen outdoor fires at dim plutuarwe wit roc i ordinances tet re uoe fire haz rd� a district board may, apart Is pawl sites rhino hour the courrty fo dispose ofsucti wood waste*a ot�unty ma sulr bryr�1botion or the request orally per4on, authorize the disposal, b} aped outdoor reit Its Plant for the disposal of si�eh wood 'twaste in the. ca me},b r tete use of a tt l~I~ "t)„ of' stt'oh rwarst'e, an the property where it was grown, under the rdnr�ihons outdoor flnr ; at the disposal sites, y � �spvtr it in, ctiun �#lt 4 � as The Ler islaturc hereby finds and h . " . these valuable sites that because m Ori autlaoriatiorr, ower er, tt1SQ4.� shall bei la{�si� t s ire ver}r drffiGult to abtatn,declaresshbuld:be reserved lrir ry '4 . nder Sectio"ii 4,,1� or or V'; ed after such date as the,state board inlay determine, baited' upon a Ciidit g big tt•prlori( tvastesuch a arbage and lore -volume rubbish, and ihat the di sxl b}^open outdoor Si:w•es of nig volu ne wood waste x,711 het prolong the life of suchr 3bttSf .:xi alternative mekhoit of disposal has'ti n :developed which is tr chnatogi� g eronom%cal) feasible. landfill ire Elar��ever, ik is the intent of th a l,e��slaturr11 f int the disposal, by open alt °`ted y outdoor f fres, of such waste: be reasonably`re..tilttted so ur to not r eale: a nwsance u?!� Burning may lie authorized under Section 412 ortly^it it? sig»Ificani[y teduce the ualltt' of kh�e ;imbient air, a dis se ofsuch rt,iste b. fel `Therefore• ttre states �aarci hall conduct st[rdies of tit t 'I'he di$tricl;;board [rods that itis is ate desirable it - - lternatiti'e methods of of it by'Other res, g from trees, vmes,� or bushes, other than b� open outdoor: Eby rtvng It tos:itar}tlls la,b[e means,such as, but not Waited tat31ft of rvaadw.�sf.-9�'r' C. ba;I l`hty`irl,str3 has ciryvelad rritezta fern such sal which shall include «,s st r• y pe ; i r 18(1o,a, t;11 lyxeept as �rovirled in subdivisions llil and tel., thaw operator of a prnr� .«tlrrrs to rmpro c the rombusttbi[Ikr of such rr ask ie reduce Its nmol,,; leve soIrd waste dls oral site lhail submit to tli P district on or. bet`ore jW%,1,198 a stolid,' b, pP pc P > waste air.; ualrh= assesstttr�tit«lost report t tat conta[ns'all Of'the follorr�ig I state aid las a car uant to subdlvl' rr SIF l w r err the criteria +��.ee o d tr ,s - ea tnlnc rf tltt're is airy tinder oUtd lattdtl.[ a� mt rtttian if t- n y e l l hese solfd ry a del S g Mi 3, granted, s,Ia _. 1 y t results % , la's perimeter. 5t'1?tIi`itrfr polTuhon oihtr[ officer, atrtfi,such/pe,r tit shall allow tour nrrl are% b't1 Atna} ses forte dise�j[ sit fflindnU Ili , s,iwitstitlg which a ricultural. burnitig as not rohibited by the state br urd urn solid waste:das osgtl site to dot rutin ,. air qualit ret to the • g y e the affect of`the siteOtt; tileenk maid 4.ri Section •t18M, _ t ii r � Mestaesul s to. de t rininee'the � quality. i �' p X31 �hentical clari;rtertzation � y p y 4 m siur5n of as t,��q 1'hd district 'ltoard;tna ado t rules'arrd re�;'ulatiotis: tc� authartze ori burn stn+�arhxirttrliediately� above thr!scrltd rvasEo thsposalsitc, or;fntmedi.7te1 ,bore the', ixr� ;rutlr�nzed under Section 418Q2, toren leu' each pr po eJ burn Prior'to autho solid r4aste' c[Ilssposal site and rvrthlct the Bali i waste z[[$posal'site, as;oppro rate, as t 4xib air pollution 'control offic er to Lsu& a pertttit tot the burn, or to delegate deturrruhed by kile;distnct, p to ► ,Aur pollutaotr control officer the authorltyr ko operon"e or disapprovib each prey y Any ether nro� enation r Malt the district boaxd htitY cegriire; ley e�tot �iµnry* : posikrd btrrn afcerconsiderahan of the aritotrht of rastew to be burned, the season of regulateon. ,thear the arnbient air tjuality, the proximity of the u-astry to di;veloped ureas, nr: itt* solid rr«ristes: air quslity« asse�smeht test 'repnr'k shall be ere' t cd in act or- smSoi'hcror oddttional criteria as the distract bound mai establish, danr tt �rrth,the guideLnes der«elopod by the staid boar Ursuan o suildtiisinYt: �lnl� ' l icy `v ahvlthsttlndiiig, $ectiotl 4180 a di$trick. board may authori2e lb ` The nperatpr of alt ityuctive solid rvtrste des tgstr[ site sh31 r;yrrt tier alit the screeitin soli- $. Ub t.t�o the litnitatfons ltti Section 4180 and this sebtiott, uhd use+oropen outdtror , g questrontiaire, dot'eloped''pursua t tasubdiVision te' . to the is' Tie y. i} t sky rrr ott'unty to dispase';of nonindustrial wood waste from treses, vinesi- trier -on lir briar,: i4oveSml r 1, 19116= orales the operator is r `aired to srxbmt .. . anct lmxiish at disposal siteYs,l&A(e:d. above 1;500 feet elevation trican sea level any re o, Contaihftrg the satrnG itiforInatioil sp +Clfic+d lit subd[visio a urstiati to u the state, Oral, any eilevdti6114n,they area. designated P& the *orth rant federal, st .te, or, dlslrrrt orcllir, of urtles exempted pursulrrt tstsU[ oar siont r . whir 1.�asGri k�,v' the state board pursuant te5 Section S9W 'The district shall evalurlte the subtziitted rrereening quatlonnalres- ear accordance f,6�i Autl orizatlon fur such burning if gfanted ;shall lie xn the Farrti of et ruts %vith theitiris deve[opod 1)ursuunt u) subdivision el. twd shall detertnirie sssts ,rd!bw the district and by the fire protectl'ctti agency hatrting jurisdlrhof, or er the then Clt�e operator of the site be requartAd to sulitnit al�,,or a portion af, the Ili, 1 y r. « -Whether __. 1.­.11formation reouired to be� teLoarttd In a �[ id li4'�do Yeti erli�trFe« nay EHtitikt FxN4 �a fi i`AWAFf:;YCQDfa HEALTH AND SAF 1'T, II y part, 7'}te district shhll irgtify the operator'in writing on or before January, ;T, 1987 U the information Wentifie4 !n Sub&N isfon (a) to lye submitted for the site, ' (3) "Operator'} means the person yvho operates or manages, or who has o er- receiving this notif eatioti, elle operator of the inactnvfi solid waste dis salter aEed or managed, the solid waste disposal site. Tf the operator aE the solid;`yvaste qufr submit a solid by°este lift t,a( ty assessment:kest rep ort containing, 1 stte . d,sposal.site na longer exists, or rs unable as determ ned b ;the districk to c grrirecl information on or b fore jurivary 1, Iggg, to the dis rirat, g, the reg % ttt the requirements of this section, `yoperator" means ai k� rson ti4F +a a vn br fc,l �l district may exempt front subdit7sfans ,(,,t and Cbl a solid waste disposal who, has owned the solid �y'aste disposal site; site or inactive solid Waste disposal site which has accepttad or, nal containsiflnl (`tl Perimeter means the outer bousiri , of the entire solid waste disposal: iuoxt: attd nortdecomposablesulids. 'I o rnceive an exemption, li,e 1) erator of the Sika roped* waste Site 511411 submit; On or before O� 7c'i:tber 1, 1986, a Co of a[1 `tntfts (,) y ste disposal, site" means a ptatce, locatiarr, track of land, area or ddtscharga requfrrm'a nts pertinent. to,tho site, and an � otli o data ,all waste premises in use, or �6ich has been used, Ear the lantiati ilii s ' ai solid tiv , fslrte t to deterntirte xvhethex an exernptfotr ahauld be granted to h ie far the :tste, �" defined in Section 67Ig of the Government Code, or hazar�us waste„�rs defined �d) On or before ebruunY1,19�ix,tl,estate,boa'rd tiff fiootdfnatfbn ititith thedis• 4ckion titi77l4.f; office (;oyarnnient Code, or both. trtrts„ Shall develop ;ind publish test a t5) Specified air cantaniinants :means st,bstmr ccs deterrrri teal' to bca afr' con* s s,ncrIt report speril'Ang the air contaminants to, be tete forwaste air ualit as taminants by the state board in coordination with the distrit accepptable tes'tini,arialFtkal and reporting methods to artd idepkif n is Thestateboardartd frtg the report, empioyod in comp etg- tam Hants f6��piir' bt�es o(tthlrra trite brg compounds to be air:con. re,' On or before Ootober e ° F pp g e zene, Chlorac thene, i,iL i ,19866 the state board, coordination a itlr: tpt' . ' drbromoe�haxie 1 chloroc khbn benzyl chloride, chlorobenzeha dichlo<oben- xrcts, shall des elop and publ s a sexeenint� qut�stiarttraire for fnacti}�e solid �e di5 zene 1,1-dfchlor6ctt enc, dichloromethane; form aldehyde, vaste hydrogen sulfide, as�o al sites and gtritle�liness for evaluating the questionnaire by the distrfc _ bylcne, tett'achlorometh4ne, toluene,1,1,- trichioroethane trichlo- MU to subdivision N. The screening questionnaire a is pur : ro thy lene,etrichloromethxne, ,xylene and any � oth.- r , + an 111. 41vo 6u id WZWL°disposal site to }re es aluated bisect ri the nate shall ageof ate by Eire state board or a district. er si.bstanee deemed appropn= 9180t;. Nothin in this article err: terials in the site, the quantitynrnweriafs in the site the 5rzt* of ,the like and' g t ele shall' be construed i uff s prop oiling btining for the Other shall rer'luite 3�dittnThe defines fare the. rig'the'scxeettfng question disposal of combustible or flammable solid w to -weigh hex il' ingan its ro.rrtisi?s, ora en aukdoor'hres piste ofa Burgle -or two,famili dwell. d"rt4 t's, sC�lioo }the praximft of the site ttr resin used only for cooling farad for human ls, artd Other sc nsrtit e areas, and to pad- partifiular attention to po- : beings or for rt creational purposes. tosiden adverse ,rrtpacts on facilities such as hospitals acid schools and on rtidcxttial areas, within one rrirfr~ of the sits*s perimeter, , df p district htasx ree4'aluafo the 'ta 418tH. :v'othing fn„this article shall`be construed to prohibit burrntrg:Eor rght- srt Win ted pr�rsuartt to vtt' • . status, of_a solid waste disposal site, inciudin ofjtvayr clearing by a public enttty� or utility ar.(or Idvee, reservoir, and ditch main• q pe g tenance, ��o such inatenal may t burned rsrsuant' to thu.section unless a ` Ag.- assessmentrcaite asolid ts�asteairquality rtest re rcgulirte the p rato�r'to submit or, pp } po er anuar 1 1 ncultural buru,n Is not prohibited on the da pursuank to S ctfon �l1 ,and (b X , : The dis= 'that shish give wrikten ftotiFtcutiorr to ikhe operator of the solid. waste:tiffs sal; ` the material has 9cen prepared by stacking; t� fir , it'r Other methods to ro that i� soli cl waste Offs uali , 4 po $rte carnbustfc�ri as Spec* b the airillut' g p ,scute q t} assessrrrent lest report h' tri be subrnrtted,.:or that the - p =_: ,on control affieei ,haNi ort reiisr;d.;,and the date h4 uhtGh'lh re rt is to be subm,t ltd tin rG' >brt-iso? , pe 1 t )urstdictf 1 PO 416M, 116'state board -shall anis n city or county to use o rt outdoor faros A rl distrrck shall eitaivako party solid tvtoair ulfty for a lirrtiked time oni�� in tts;olseraban of zi sone# waste dump, u t'theindin' Submitted iitrrsttant tosubdiv�istahs (a b and ' , assrrssment fest reports that,ecause pf sparse oputatfoti in: the eo aph)cal area, a, r.. 9 t. l: t, end deterrrtftio ff the re port, technical difficulties, hf solid' waste dam hould be o e tit d economic an testtngk unalytft?al and re rang �ctho4— crsmply with the gu delin �deve o p� p pe e nrrnr+r�it to sirbdivfsion'Idl.Itthedistrfct.detertnrne5thatthe�solldn 4113p,\ottitithstz#ndin SoGtions41 a asteafr 4ual� g d 418w 0� n outdoor fires tnay be i# �5snrcnk test react cnrnhiies r t Ehe guidellines ik shall evalilato tho ta. used to disposa of Ru rah kttrstle (5alst la kilt '�y�hen�n �� «, isi riot dete�rnes, after ey aluatron of the to rt. rid cutis 1 ttEhari,” b� a chic fire d 1 po ultation tvfthrthet dep�trttnk�nt at fire protection ageync<•:Q!`a cit}, conn , ar Eire protection district, . e rattment and the California. NV Ute M,3nagemen .board; that..le els bf;p the State forester or, his duly? authoiixecl re�res 1 p �' s' t` r inure 5pt clfied air writ rminants ppose a health r k to urnatt ne a ttah e, or, a county ;ugrreultural t►c cin ironrnent; tiiodistriat shall tie a ro air �rerrtedfabings�or a throat cantmissioner or an air 1>ollutan control officer. w p action, 1 r 1! n tltskrfct dctortnines shut a solid wasto� air quihseSsrrie �151U, or,islattds )6cated15 or mare nrfles from. the tnaihland coast; p } pp 1 p dam rias .cote l 'tiytth the guidolures developed pursuant tri sitbdivrs o�nstdrepo t (ti he rovision$ of Section 41701, shill 'not t, ' I to smoke fro fires set r t l� a the eon,, czstrict shall pini ide the, of the site tiy7th a rt ritten notice eefftrirr the port arid'; hall require, the r for 1. .., t ade k) y : :Ivo district shall adopt ;rn�• hile or regulation strictct than those rov°d d q acies of the 're � p � c a to correct the defIccrert by�atr tt5"th resjieet to r+pen Ucftdrror EiieS� 4i Pot the purpose, rc slits xechan th 'Mort b� a elate deternuned bin the district. f r11 ""lirtuctivp solid waste d►s sal '• 0, Eoilarcing definitions apply• 41811. the:prov�isfirns ai slits article shat! riot Sit i�rsede . ►; l situmeansA snlid. vitsto.dis saps.. :. oficns di'tri .:hv a r It _ ilx,: ru e or. re;ulatron ok�Feceir~ed oris`solid waste -for, dispas:d after Jaarnrttar�K 1, 1 5•i site �yi�reh to s rt, hien rttic br r gt,laltott �s,rs in effect fpr lire itr trrurc`y ears prim t:.t i.artdi.tll gas"°ttjeans arise u ntreated, raw `'as dertyRe� throe h a natural tiroa Sr?pte mbfir i9,19rt1, g 5s train tht� dtramposttfoti of or ariic ti:iste epasited''fn r! $olEn ►r I+ 4151i?w `1 h tyfr pollu'trdn control officer of a ty di '' � ' ante disposal strict in'a unto titin a lip. p r ¢ pc les iii the 1i este, ulattran ot,iltKli1 ire less, i, otf ;ruthetrf.►titrtt lhc� diskitis b�itrd„ r�aa►r'tiut}tttrize, ' t alutielt of x iatf e s C b}r ix!rtnitA upc'tt ��tritltkrr iirt�s tar the 1#uMOW til dtspnsms; +�t' text ulkitral yc� stes r or cont the e r 1tk� 11k;,fC ill AND 5,W[: ry coj)'F. }i1 ALTt1 ��D S:�I'T ri' Ct7D� lot) 419:1 Proof of correction shall consist either of a. Verification itrsuant to Sec- 4198{1.5. For purposes of this article, "t XiC waste" means hazardous waste, at,,: tion 411;.2 or of a eertlfication b�. an isuthorized represeiitatit�e of one of the fol lotiw:rtg ageneses that the alleged violation has been corrected: dehhed ill ection'23117. tai 'Che state board', 41981, The state board.'shall, In consultation Mi the affected disMet.and the (b) The State Fire Marshal. ic) 'Cite district board. emu ions Com inchneartinent. of trntion of toxicaste materials, u:cojnsing am available data on the (d) Tie departrrtent of the• California li.ighwat+ l atrol. The state hoard shall report its landings to the Legislature on or Before Januar 4197: (a) Proof-ofcorrectfori by verification s}t:tlll consistof a vcificatinri bythe o%�z4m or 1,19f, . g 41982. The state boards , mon cocEed_.�Thte ovrierher Ur for cargo tank thin Elte alleged vial ;fieri has hall after compleEfng the study referred to rn Sectio; p m. _ shall notify the a which issued the: theaffected districts and the I9epartrhertt of'Hetlth notice tri ap' ear at least 24 hoursia advance or the tittye tvhert the correctianmay , raid after'publie hearten' s� establislt ;dellaIts 5hrvfc es be ins t»t ,sF eci5in the loeatian or the gasoline cargo tank;. b-y the dfstricts for' tht,} incineratton of to `e it�aste Maj et for the issuance of g w a erils; i'he guide tette spall ei?tesetltati�'e 6 the isSuind agency fails to appear to make the inspection take into consideration factors Including; lstit riot [imiCed fti, the Fpllowin . e d ta�rititnd la and time the ntvner or operator shall, prepare and subrtiit (x) The charactcris es of,' t ' g p � , d nalt of` ur that the alleged Siolal.3on has beer; tor- ibS Therrtethods t�7equ pment ��ailablp o minimi`zc�Abe tneinerated. prJ sect d.c .ton under, - e _ r eliminate the ertiission The state hoard shelf ada tie of air contaminimts; p gulatidns for the mak n and fubmiss on of vett- fi ttioits Csursuant to this section. (c) The applicable federal standards, including, but nutlimited to, the regola tfoi s found in Part2641 of Title 40 orthe C68e of Federal Regulations (40 C)'R 264) g concerning standards for ottnets and o spa ed pi rsuarit-to this art➢cle ig nptice to g , _ aerators of hazardous waste treatment,, 4197,: Each da that a. asoGne car o tank which is the stib'ect afa of such tnc storage, and disposal. he ties., l'Vhere the guideluiesdevfate from the adopted fed• s apnrated without correction star standards the r,' Clatioza nz uent to the date or tl� notice shali� constitute a separate offense sub- anon far the difference shall b noted h ; the board. to the Pena ties provided in. Article (cariimenefttg riitJt S"teflon 42400,} of 41983. (a) Thhs'�trticle shall not be construed as prc�'eriking any district from Ch.ip'er 4 establishingperrnit 4riteiya more skrin eat than the defines •�1974k a) )rzcepE as proVided in,subdivision Cb), Ar, tieie 3 (commerrcinl; rv7tlt Oft g � speeihed in Section bort 4l a) of ha 8 J - title 5 (ntmeicin u _th .4e torr pyto env gasoline car, ri tank stib"ect to Ar- (b) Thus article shall not be construed as limiting the nuthorit^, of the D:c art- p ment,of badaIth Sei'tl0a to teernin-g hazardous V.hasfe contr1 (Chapter S,� (cporit� h _ 11 riot apply to airy gasoline car o- fib} "The ,ether rovtisioiis of C.hss article she ga nlrnc{ng r�tith Secuon Moto of Division 20) � or toy regulations promulgated un.. tank 10lttsan oltrti Ie ticlj c n of Taxteo `astiw 1� t9$I. d authority P �fate�rials et' the atitEtori of � Cav�ians . 11,6: Uolavure ` AkMl 4. Et•F6H�ir�Sta "I ADAM1", rinds. and declares that. �.a means bid trod extensiielV in Cahforzua' Article 1, 1'eririits �,,.. ralxv tea rctkiS, rimaril�r.h�ecrwip of the. extensive area mailable for gvefy dis"trio board tris}+ establish, b re latio%t a rmitl, the low cyst oflan'd as a. niethad of df Y t p� s}+stem that spasal+and problems tt nth air,ptil» reriutres, except as othenr ase prop iced to Section 4010 thitt tiet'ote aft ltitfpn. , II y perxon bul ds, etects alter, ,`rep laces, operates, or uses an} anc�le, :macf line, equipment, p (b) 13 ause prablern may ri ault {rant dlsposin of certain loxfc waste mate- ar other conFrivatice u frit h ata) cause the Issuance 'f ' cotitartinaiits sv' is in lattdiails, incineration should be irtvesttgatedas a, m0hod of dis` sal. sin ebtatn a pc+rntit„to do sa `from the air pollution eontral officer of Elie d s t r t The regulations ma '. . to ri c ,po when corny gu } pg'oitide thatz ' rmitshall be valid only for aspechfied peg ( lncfrieratfon ofcertain toxic tvasti materils.has the advanta a tic clod, However, perrr!itAsill be renewable upon pa}meat of this teles required pard to " sal by landfill; of.lxr eakittg down taxi; waske matennls into teal fatless coritpattn l5 4t elements, urs ianI to .Section 42n11, etcept Albetd action to suspend er rel �+ke the p�tmft ()The incinratiart pC certafrt t4xrc 4 aste'iititttrials;earr rettit fn th ;recti initiated p. ursuant to 5ectiiin 4230 t 4231)7, o1f ;t23t19` nttd SUclt actio dt5ctfon of ever , ivhicl� can hpifs to displace t}te cambustiaii af.fossile net pre- resulted in nttl aeteft 11ation to ata eitd' nr regio' ' n has reduce depende►ce eri imported energy�supp)ies, d sp hi? the'perttyit lig the air poli lutian control oflicet or the liearing Board by whoni or before �t+hp such rection C+e1 lm +a i or incomplete incfiserahan iif toxic waste mathtinls.can'. result do en initiated and all appeals, or lime for a els from, such f e an p ` o, Eton h' exhnus#_cl t m ase detejrnirna• has be ,t oblic health, and hazardous or ap6i c }lir �r tions t� life h ' be harard6ut to a 1� � y as bean yu p ene�ittttin'ietitally significant ahii ,12. 1, A y i' rn l or laitteif i eis'the intent nd o$ POO s stem est•tblishe p eetiort 423i>! t sii 111 do alt of the Thereft, hgw i foilatw n _,ty� a of the 1.e�'slature to invest.;" ale the d utsuahttau g (ri. lansure that the article mitehihe, e tri nient,:or i r,tttr�inelor ry i - hods,af erts+9i itg" that emissri5ns fitan4 »ntjineratiott ul ,toxic i�vastes do not ens pp .: -,.- h ch khe bfige ypu �ho htalth and ,4elfare, whsle dre'ern infra v0"At a o is permit �tias issuist shall not prevent or interfere with the,; ttafai -nein or is itt . g par err Ee roleY in nonce of aho nplilfcaiile air qualit�� st$itditrd. ! , e i�-ttia. i , of ta+ric>}Kste itatorials in calf- y + satisfieProhibit bh bit ffid i mf et to of a perittit uttless the air pollutiati ittxo), officer Cs r.inerahon; tat In td& In the landfhli rti 1i g li r etfa adopted by the dist:let fi&rd. flint r , s��•r;,t�..,,n,. MEMM 1I ttt:tik.`Itt.�1;e"D apt tr11' CtyD 11,F-AL 14 AND S�tt�MI t~t�iy� 11� `b) 'very d►strlctil,cluded'within subdiS'fsian (a) s11411 provide, dataand:anal � to the stake board for ii,tlusfon in the report 9.313, Lxcept in the case of a contract entered into between a county district Pursuant, and the countlP, a Contract entered ►nt,t t►rsuant to Section 92312 mayprovide � The nate board sha11 ronsulk �� ith districts and other interested parties that Fees for permits shall be paid to the c►t kor a • � , pr, ,r to prcpanng the report required under subdiosion (a), y county a hfch issues the pernut and pa pt p su (�, rrlay be retained 6ts;that city+or cQurity,,n whale or in part,;�s Elio ransideratia �) ansmit co sof he report oatlre o er yor and t ion, a the state, board or art thereof, for issuin the n, sl `tr p p he Ug►slature. g perm,.ts, bther�vfse all fees pard far t1ha,issliante of e 1 This sectinn shall become inoperative o,i July 1, Imo,, and as of January 1, peillfts shall be paid into khe district treasury, t , repealed, unless:, later enacted statutes which becomes effective on ar be. 4 1, .thstanrliil` an at r te ' +` #sire J,har, 1, 1i3, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes nt�perative andexcept as provided in this ecHon no dstraiCt sh aFany d stnct prmitsystem, repealed, .�}l require em,s5tant offsets for all of the folioµ rig.�requlre ri nts; ' project which satfsfi+�s 91.2, ' ng Section 92311oj , a dlstrict shall not adopt or ,li- t it The Project satisfies one rce recon a ro (ay itiah�thstandt n co enerpa on tee ria o o£ ed th or r%ou popes w,'hicJ, exceed actual district administrative costs for processing or en- e following size criteria, rsag pert'nits' applicable to arty of the following: ( l The pr6ject p,raduces 50 megawatts or less of electricity+, To the rase of, / sponsibilft la iu t F'xerfbed burning operations on state re combined,cycle ptajtrt, the 1 capacity of tlirr $team; tiirbi:*Io may ex +er io wrrris of a permit issued by the Department of Forertzy+ and F e Prafe eluded from the total electrical capioit} or the ,project for ur ses of this Wa r,t.to Article 3 (commencing kNd lection �f9tl of C hapten 7 of-1�art 2 graph ,£ no supplemental firings used For the steam' portion and the combo n uF Duaason of the Public Resources Cade when the purpose or the operation is turbine has a tnxnirnum efficiency of 25 percent, irei ntiorn ofhigh-intensity wildland fire's through reduction of the t"glume and (Bl The prajeet processes municipal wastes and produces rliote than 50 mega. e�ozstu,t of Witdtand fuels« wa(2i` Thele o�w�ll a �'�� alts, of electriCityr, g g Po nate de ee aE llution control 120 Surnir! " of Vegetation be, disposal of slash follor ing timber operations e� [ teehrtblog} p e apps , ed finder regu}ations adapted by the State Board of Forestry pursuant toSec- { �"CT or ] .Al;ii+ as defined and tb t ie ei,tenk re aired .b the clktnct p tem, q y permit„Sys- tion i ,d'ence acid spread of fires on timberlandt„ rpose of reducing (3)'' Eici;ting permits for ori rteM I o sir 456.. of the Publfo Resources Colo and far the u y ql equipment ta;be replaced by':thp- rryjeck, t"�� �K ildlar,d vegetation management burns, F6f ur ses. of this ' ' het}►er the eyuipntent is btt•ned by t}ie 1, loam pr,a t er i � � slydfrad wegetat,on management burn” mentis the us Of re5C °beubd,v,s►on, protect, are surreindered to the district ar mpod#tied to rohib benefjt ►any of the eiUnd' ted by,a public agencyy, or through a coo eraEiire, ' . . r, d burning neouslyr hEh the project to the extant ne e3 a y p uita� If Operation soli p ,agreementorcontract Iii• c s D to satisfy distract offset requires s�silg;publ,cageilcy to burn land preom(na»tla�ca�jered vc�l mertts,'The etnis tions ceductirns assoeaaterl �c�ith the aha � -; ,r th chaparral, ax es, ntent 'sliap be tr�rdited to 'the ro"ect tdattn of existing equip. gtasswr;smhdirig brush.,For purposes bF this siibdivisfoii, prescribed burning is 1$ rules. l? J. _ _ elnm,sslona offsets Irl accordance with, t1�x=� pried apptieatiotl 6f Fire to t•e eta on to achieve tiny+ sp ,-.W ob octivc on as 1 (,ky The a p i, t ected'in advance of that app rctitfa,I The planned applicaEion of firm rrna PP icant has ro�'de I offsets to the extent they are reasanabl + a Y able From fa6wgos it a y kali Occidental, i gra on, g p operates fn the tar, basin and st hich mitigate the re, be, Pxais or iclucl nor !o adaptllt g actf�7ties. described i►i ` and a 'h ma,nul inl acts Iaf' the projet�t. rtaktiral or aec►d or revfsn fees for Elie. d a (Sj For new;proJects ab.lchl�urn inunicipal�ivaste,. ahc `dl gas, or digester as, (2:t�rr tx'1i� a istrletshaU hold public hearing od shall cor.Wder the f 116* 'the lip licant has, ul the ludglit�.nt of the d►strict, made a o«l Faith :effor 9 trG W. cure alt reason blsry available uinissions eEisets to mitigate the rerriafr m ftpact sa �iy t "tie costs of the fees on Private landowners and other persons who engage the project, and fir: secured all': reasotabl + g' -.f p .. in ttMlies speciTied in paragraph M., :(2l, or (3?, y a� anlable ofFsets, r(1l �triy r�'enues eurrentl . y prottided tri Elie county= foggeneral govern nient 6 , t (bl This sect►on applies ko any tiroject br tc loch an gliplicaEion far anauthority prtbli4 arcricies which administer ptlbl#c' lands. y o eoilsruck,s desymcd QMplehe by the distrlr~t after January 1, .1985, clay If'the X11,5. AI.&trict beard inn y;` „N , y ,nere..,e its fee sc}iedule ad ps �inf ted lir t"OVS net. � r lions, ctynibinl d with'the fret emissions from project3 ^re iously - enerate suFfic#ent revenues to`'"a 9 fa . opted under 5ect,6n ou 1 his 5ect,oh, are less thtin" tinount protnded fsJlIn th�:1 ` li• the ixp lemer,tatfan of + ," -. p y r any district ca>;ts Assoc►Ated 1«th , b e gto%k th alloWtuice establi'.Aed by t11�. i»stn wt pursuant. to -Section 91 pp p Section. 796.83 of the t;oiertunent ~✓tide ar 5ectiolt. if a chstrict has not y+et praiided a growth1loGy,�, ce urskiant to SecEion1tt>t the 41 grott kh alloSvance is Zero, For purlioseabf this stjbdlil�is ' an, "`net emissions"' means the roj't s ettissibits, ic�3s ,i,i;r affseks prodded b. r the:.a lit dnt a 43 2 To in adrturr,steriri,ts J,ri iilft syste,tl, a dfsrnt board marf;cotitract d p�acemeiit credos, 'mod �►ur e - y . - pp nd.less uhf ,ty with ,asiy� cotjnty ai city includeti,;in 11 hale or,n part. wRhin. the districk, and at ' e Thiss scant ko aectturi 9l60a. S,rah cai,n y or eftr� i7iajr eon"trai t Mth the distr#ek i:or the; . +t nt eCt bn does not re(ket°e a project £rs)r l satisit n alfa , Ifcabfexe li liar~ C, (Prevention of Si nificant flet ri & I ly gWre pr forinanee of stir mems oC f Mg e, oration) of the Clearl Me . & M pi? s ilistrir"t air polut#on eons aMended fri xgi"'i 92 t,,,C, $. wcirk i,l th riarrie +af and sub ect to tl►e a " I of al oF, the ' , . _. ,. p t ff�icPr, department, ar ageriey"b1 ptirsuahk to fart r', eW, !`1 et: setl.j, �r any rales sir regulations adolsled tr 1 rtf#icer the buildtn de alrtrnent ar: o her a Y the county ar such city Ohargetl i iEh the enloreenierit aFYegulatinns pert Ening to the ere> bonf c'fxnslru tfor ; rect►nstrtictlori, moterilent, eonvers#on :�ltera' 92319,1x (al gkopt tis pravided In subdivislori b) . t . , erilargemerit of �iaxhdin s' or struck►res, .Ion, c.i i!ider. federal lacy cold ritwithstarid#gig:ori sEate o Iocal het extent perniisstble g Prevention of sirn�Fieatit dotefi►,'orakioh rule �r r �►,i tfr. ,psi ►w ioriirce tiev,ety dr f Its. Itt'1�TIt ��,'I� SAt=I';'T� �dy1?Ifs I�kr. AQ—'ti AN $A MA Cpt?E T �. Permits onstruct�oit a1 a ro'ect'�which S�" 1 r g �.a ,�., a di.,trict shall issue 7crniits for the c I l. � � g P � burns steam' enerator lbai}eri to iraducc electrical energy, or"to be used as a d#gester 1?ml al wag te, landfill as or dr ester gas,' of thri follotringcotiditions are feedstock in a cogenerat#an facility, the-.distr#ck shall alloy+' offset credo dig ste trided in Sections 4160 # :tnc! �I� o. I he project pxacllrek's lees than 50 megata°atks oE' electric#ty; ei cept ais pro. x�urierlt k�ri paragraph tit. 4 Ia; dal tie district shall#slue of renew a permit far, the construction at reg fz', the project wilt utilize the appropriate degree of pnitutinn control tech. new � rmit fcr the o ration of, or issue;a Bete ermittior, the com h5n :.N "Pot I:l required by the actor sourriY ri vieav rule of the district* project tvhrch burns muntctpal ivste or refuse derived :fuel u p c�e.for„ tuft Bio .ti katil'or.L�1 grrirntoftltedtstrict maduagoadfalth g 1U project applicantbus, in thejud Iatvin conditions haye been meth 1 p J t' prevent'or int bless ell of tfle fol ,a tb secure all avu#fable em#ssion offsets to xwtigate the impact of the ptoj wt, r The ro ec - %,j riot p erfere with the attaitunent or rrs nte- 4t rr Went offsets or other 0111190 Ron measures are root atrailnble. The applicant . nonce of state and federal am�siertt: a#r uteri st wi � ' ards, ' eu rp as r uircd ttrsectire ttil Etre offsets whichart a%yailabl'e to mitt ate the air „i"� he project iw i eompl} with all licabl stn" „ impact p j prior to issuance of the pp- e . lssion hmikahons establtshccl, +rssLatu ihipftr t of t1tC prrrjeet, except for ro ects ttltich eocisxtute ailodifirtibri permit or the determination oFcornpl#once. r ndef the dlstnct s nektt Source ret ie�v tulemin �t h#ch case"the (3 The projeck 5v#1l, rtEter issuari.ce of the err k oc deter y " P i»n.e sstrn s �urief u'#red to provide offsets 'From far#lit#es s teach the applio,nt ance, comply i is cperat 1 with toxic air rOntarri' control mO pinah S, the ctiskrict inant c. asuns ado ted. b the d. 141toxo ro ect roducesSo megawatts or tabic but loss on:'�417f10 for khe p #strict' ptfrsuanf: to Sec» proteCitan of i ublic health. 10 " '� � _ g an 3�66tr acrd regulations ,k tytltlr.,ta add ted by the d elk dui , ¢ mocks tlpie r`egittre�tnentsrof ` paragra s thacrt Sime a��atts, of eom�litrnca Sectsnd#ng 'cttbn ��3�I.�„ p gr-.phs (2) ana . 3);x,is located in a ;dis- p e ytrith this subdiNision shall be'consistent with a reasonable schedule, as W t hra:e state implenientation plan revisiotis have been approved by the l ria dekprmined by the distr#ct. viakati rktal Protection agency* and that has aftained, or is reastinably.cxpected, to (4) (A) A health risk assessment is ettbrmed quid it submitted by a`tt�, =fluvial air qual#ty� standtirds fat any criteria pollutant far x*hich suf6 tent to both the state board �artd the Stnte I epartmen! of Health "a the district gxvst��tfa� �lowances are available in the air flail Sen** for retreta The.state board shall retie ,yi, and, within 15 day's, notify„ the district..rid the ap li- q h maintenance plari.ar, in'the cantos to whether the data rtaini.n k bi` ` p et s e r i"eck wattle cause,tny criteria ptillutairt to. xceed Ehrr ay�ailable or pos- ,. g o _tiissioiisand their im Act' on, amlifent p j s growth allotaance, the applicant secures offsets in tux ambutif equal to airg�ih ate adequate for coniplehng its ret #ew ursuaht to thi p5ribtti� inion and > ante, and processes munlct al yaaste fr whatddit#oval data; if any; are required to corn tete its r " tlzs rrr the girth alloty p s em bite or p eynety. i4 ithin 0 daysb e r .: rriicrpahhes ring„ project under this paragraph shall cr M 14 to ith a `° ?� recti#yrng the health. risk assessment, the state board shall submit its ca,'�le vro,vention of sigrtrticairt deterioration rules nd;regulat#orxs ppl writing to the district rib the data p�; rta#nin to emissions and their comments iii: i a rrrip�et on am« art prapesed project N fitted uhd'er sUbdivi#ori �a as s liient air uglify'• `I°he distriet shall forware q copy t ' p y g w 1 h:.... ora ctncal tiny = �ioar t td % State ,be-partmeht of 11, Sera y bP he c rrirnents of the state rrat acit �of6t1 miy atarattsor irate, thedstracfshall deterrhrgre ithetFierthe abs. The Stake Department aE pre feet ruat is the regttiremeb1s of this section and„ in.mak Its rl ,ternr'ina ' health Set i ccs shall ray#eta+ arta, within 9U` eat s of rode#in ti the , ntial eniissaan a# nr�nc»feria l}%atant fro bbh, sessrYient,s all submit its coitrments to the<d#strict n. g heatth rrsl, as s1 .1 rirraxader the pc to po,. m raject.faeili o the data ftnd findings reI ' ties tand Elan deo elo a ria mate 'errttit con litiokts. The district +shall submit i #lig to heap ``effects. p pp p ' pp p" dein rrrtslxetion grid supporting arial� es„ iiieittd3ng t,hTh flits afryorretiteria I- CRj.bar purposes of cornplyting with kha rer�uirements Oft h#s parditaph, the p t?o Sidto Department orRealth-;Ser0ces nifty select a_ a tl#lied rode ndent c &Utsir�d.a prop rate permztcbridrhorls, to thr<State Fnerg} -Resources CotrserF pc. ohtrac- p . " for to,rev#eay� the data and findings resat#n to beth effects.ln. those a p d _ p , t review, by the Inde . ndeut, ... bit axxcl ©Section 25.5W of iy st"on Iorofthe Nubs heti aha tet f: caiti�„ pe cbntrnctbr sha ebm , ones, the me uY xth s a cis Code. pK tttith the fonoii�ing regti#re- menu. tai ats , rttitt issued pursuaht tb subdivision sal, and an determination 16 he tn:irlie i at fact pursuant tcistibdit isign (b), shall, meet the a, d#tional r u#re} performed in a tnak►ner cons#stent' %ith guidelines proModd by the ,ems afctioti x#2315. y � eq deC;� Be re„vet4�e�ti b • the state de attriient'for accuraa t and com 3kafe m # y p J4 fill 'fhr tirxtie liM#ts established under Scctibris t a95fl .tiS otl,I,- acid (ii#y 13c sr1bnr�itted by the state de artrnen tot y l'eteriesss the seheduies established b . this gra a i in accordance it ith =” ldf oho Ob 6,rnment Code far appraisal. er dis3 Pp '' l,oC dei ,login ria Y p - g► h, r Frp P t e disknet ti~ be rho-, atended for district revicaa' or an n ication % a .perririt fora y �,'ohytithskattding Section fi103 oft e Government dodo the "t r+�c�ve pe rlrt shall project upon the mutual consent or tha distnet alta tho peiH. f re►m arse the;State Department of %1ealkh Sere- ices r `. pP Nottti'athsttiodin Section 095' or the Government Code ori est contractor desx rated b h + o n uRied indcperitlent mactautanc to this sechan shall not ei tied n r , ensroh . S, V the statii department pursuant ka subparagraph f Rl, far 65Wlhi _months bey otid the t#lice htnrts ed In re1!iett xng health ask as;esshient !or an- orbject stib rks actual costs in�urr • x Code jest tb this $echah„ es,,1 The dtixs shnllti raidpublic, rlt tiff90. of Fh , f"ec a Cbvernriiertt exteiipon cit r hon at' hist days pr#or'ta the ef= (D) , an apphcakioi for ani" project' Which butitt hluntei 'ftl taus � r r. " nsented to undersubdiarsian kd)it<hiehshallspec den fuel isnot complete until bath tifthcfalloiy#n i p t o close �V���ro��isl'nr,, and.tlr� durati'oh oY the e`;tensitin ��rsad=7'hedistrictshftll pro• .F#) Tlie health r#sk.essritent has'beeh erfor g ha c been accomplished; y fret p . rag+d:trnd is subrii#tted to the din• J pu , hispublic natlf#cation it bushing a hotice ante a Week. E°or ttttl zrt;irttis e1% PL #n' q tteaa°slsaper of general citculatietii an the r!s"striet �dI '"fie state board grid thState De�rartmrit al'ylealth Seri tees or it ndetit contractor designated by life skate de artualilir'd $4 5�; l n'considerii a " vitt#t for k lhde' p. meat pursucint to sub` arct- S l facility �vhlch ut#1#z Is a cultural waste p� , p PWCF tcts,'fl"' oft, ii rite rodtiets, ar sittt'ilar `ar ah#c ,rcastes as b rriais fuel in.;a Ti� (R) ha" a t.omploted their rrsi�#civ pursuant to thio pp'ata�rrftph, and have Buba ted their eornrnents to the district,, unless the Mate board grid the Stag nA The' fol lowinct is A s� r&Tl -6ry of A83205 Hazardous Ma trialsand 5missionsi Waters and approved by the governor oh !� September, by M. 986';: 1 r -After January 1, 1989 ., citi.es or counties are prohibited from issuing a final certificate of occupancy unless a: business that handles a hazardous mater -al establishes a business plan for 5emergency p or threatened release of a hazardous materrialto a release -After July 1, 198>9 , cities ar counties are, prohibited from permitting .a facility to be constructed within 1000 feet of a school without 'first requiring a risk management and prevention plan 'end additional information, as specified .-City and county fire departments will be allowed to issue written orders to Correct or eliminate:a fire or life hazard, and to issue citations. -APCO's,and AGMD s will be permitted to review risk managemInt and prevention programs fo-° acutely hazardous materials. district's are required t;o issue a public notlace and review any comments received before the AACa can issue permits to construct for any source located within 1000 feet. of a school, hospital,, or long-term care facility: -fhe approval Of an M or negative 000 aration foi' a school con struction project is prohibited unless the lead agency has cone salted with city or county fpf'ficials to identify Potential nearby facilities that could emit hazardous air emissions: -Construction or a fat I city within 1/'4 mi le -of a school is prs- hibited unles, the school district is nOti#`ied and con8ultad.: -the State is not responsible for reimbursement of these si,ata- mandated local programs, i The rerluir0dots reit this bt l l affect many d fferent local ager cies. specific requirereais f'or air district.'s aro summarized be- lnw as they appear in the 44,41th Arid Sat qty Nda Sections 42M1,6 -i 4930i,19 -The A00 is required to pr000ro a public notice prior to the issuance of a permit to corrstruet Of modify for a source located within 1000 fleet from the outer boundary ct` a school, -The public notice 5ha11 be distrtbut�id tc) the parents of children in any school withih t/4 mite of the source and to each address within a radiuk of 160 feet frw thh racruer property line of the -proposed new or modifiad source, -'aha 00 shall reviow aril cr;,tisider all enmthiiht,s received dur1raj the 30 days after the notice is issue=d, and shall written responses in the pertflt appVdAtion file pr'�,f %- pel°intt i$aU�n4e be inCorto.rated into the a emftrregr'iremanttsedtidh I ; ` the noticing roqu rements,as y g p� r"i' iT� dis- qIx' trict rtrles,vther re uirement,s;�ndled+ car► i ) 4 a ►n bye nt Air Qualit��r t nay Pollutant Averaging Yime Galifornfai Stanidard5 , , National Standards x . Conoontratlotl �. M�ethod:l 7 primary" Secondary '' hlathod 0 Cxono 1 Hour 009 ppm �1g0 ugirt>v) Uftrtivkkit Phnl'omeiry d,12,ppm (935V0463) Sam's:as Primary Std, Etttylono cherNfuminescence Carbon M(ortoxtde . t Hour 9.0 p r ) (10 m m: p Infrared ersive 8pectrosrz�py (NOIR) PPM ��0 mglm3) Same as Primary s, Prim Std Non us ersive F Infrared Spec#roscop�y (Noffa) Hour - 20 ( Ppm 23 mglln3}� pPrn ti (db mg,m3) Plitro en 9 Qloxide, Annual Average Gag Pune nascence' 9.053 PPm (100U0 3) Same as Primary Std. GaS P.'lase cherr�tt�mi= nascence 1 Hour" 0.25ppnl (470 ug/10) Annual AveEago g0 u (0:03 ppnt)' tuttur Oloxtde ; Flttcr;escencb Pararasoant"tne 24 Hour 0,05 pptlt" tt31 ug/ 355 ug/m3 (d,l4,00 3 t-1out. 1300 u 101 (0,6 Open) 1 Haut 0,25 . m pp (555 afjlm'1) u ; w Suspended' Particulate : Atlnual Geometdd dean 3d ugym3 Size Sotecuve - Inlet High volur»e Santplbr and 15o uglm9 Same' as Prihiary Stds, Inettfal Separation and, ravmetnc " Arsalysis mifitior (i'Mr 24 Hour 5d ughn3 Wavin etric Ahaly3ts Annual Mean etic � 50 trgttil3 Suflatas 24 hour 25 U.&I3 Turblc0metdc 6arlurtl Sulfate Lead 30 day AvarAg a �3 15 u 9 Atomic �;dbstit bort P Atomic .Abs o lion Calendar calendar, , 941m"n Std, Sudi Ogen t' Hour Cdg 04'03) m Hydr- nktde $TRactah V;oyl Chloride chloroethenb () }�J y ' ` 24 Ho& b,010 pjpri! ( 5 U04, t) Tedlat 6a4 yy��,,jj ♦ w \.IollbdICin, Gas.,' Ghrcmatography ,� k 1llsibtflty I�bdu;ng�. Particles Oisexvatton 6-1 In sufficlotlt amount.lo reduce the ptovailing_+u)sibillty0 to Ie'ss Thar► -10 t 10 Whbh the rbfatfve homla, Y is'IaA�1h 7d°ld' .... z y applicable Only in the Lake T060 Air ®aslr Carbon Monoxldo $dour g pPm (� rngirri3p i�blA . vlsIbillry Asduang Pat110ies 1 Observation In sufficient aftunt to rbdUCOL the prevailing vlsltyllityi to less than 29 hilleb:' i'hoh the tbMativo hutntefity Is tbstt than 1'%• (Fd c►traotas an e6VbY0s `stdo) , 4 i NOTEM .. ?. California standards for OiZ60e, carbon tr+onox de, sulfur dioxide (1 'iiour) , nitrogen dAoxide and particulato matter - PM p y are values that are not to b$6 exceeded . The t sulfates, lead,hydrogen suifde, viny I chloride, and visibility reducing particles standards are not to .be equaled or exceeded, 2; National standards, other than ozone and those based ori annual averages nor annual arithmetic means, are not to be exceeded ;more tkia,n onc!M a year, The ozone standard is attained whom the expected number of daysper calendar year with maximum hourly average concentrations abovethe standard is equal to or less than one. 3. Concentration expressed first in units fn which It was pro mulgatod. Equivalent units given in parenthesis are based upon a - reference temperature a5f 25.o and a reference pressure of 760 mm of mercury. All Measurements of air quality are to be corrected to a reference tem o temperature of 25 C and a refereracO pressure of 780 mm Of mercury (1.,013.2 millibar),* � ppm" an this labia refers to ppm l�y vvlurrie, ar micromoles of pollutant per mole of gas 4. Any equivalent uivalent rocedu.re which ich can be-shown to the.satisfat,tiara of the.Air Resources-8oard to give equivalent results at or near the level of the air quality standard may be used,. 5; Natlonal prima Standards: The levels of air quality mai ria safet of , riecessa � ry"With ora adequate g y t6 protect the public health. Each state must attain the primage standards no later than three' years after, that state's irnplernentatlon plan is approved by the Environmental. Prgtectiob Agency. 6: National Secondary Standards: The 'levels of lir quality necessary' to protect tl�a Public state must attain the secondary standards within a nr is of a„pollutant. Each u is wetfa.re from an knob°iii ar, amici attd adverse effec Pp Y easonable time” after the implementation pian is'a raved b ;the I RA. 7, Referenco method as described by the 8PA4n "equivalent, method" of messuremer:t may, be used but must have a "cbnslstsnt Velatlonshir'O p to the refence method",and a-nust,be approved by the EPA, 3i* At locations where the state standards for ozona"Andlor suspended particulate r atter are violated. Natlonal s#andards apply els4Wh,ero. 9• Prevailing vr's aility is cteflned as the greatE� t visibility M ich is attained otF sur a: sed P around` at least half of the horizon circle, but not neces9,461y in continuous sactoM,, y A R ` ARS 1=ac.�t �lleet 38 revised 718$1 AAAtRp �,s c,i ;CA11fORN1A—THE RESOURCES gGEN r' GEORGE DEUKMEJIAh1, Governor 13 FARTMENT OF CONSEWATION ` D1ttI IW1GF ADMINOTRATION uut p " ' 10F MINES AND. GEOLOGY CO O• plahti Ng COMM C0113460 0 OIL AND GAS APf[ D1V(I.1( sh`� OF RECYCLING f [ 1n� wS 1416 Ninth S1r"t SACRAMENTO, CA f�5814 s TDD (916) 3242555 April 10; 1989 AT5S 434-2315 (916) 445-8733 Mr . 13 111 Butte O= 7 C y planning Department ounty Center Drive Ornville, CA 95965-3397 bear Kr Turpin: Subject; Notice bt Preparation (NOP) of a Draft. Environmental Impact, Report (ETR) for the Butte County General. Plan 1 s Energy; gatUtal Resources and Recreation l lefient. SCH# $9031110 The bepartment of Conselrvation has reviewed Butte County's NOP for the general plan elements referencedabove. The bepartt6ht is responsible for ino.nitoribq farmland conversion on a statewide basis; and also administers the California band Conservation (Williamson) Act. Since developme.tt' of these: elements could have environmental impacts on agricultural and Williamson Act contracted lands; the bePartment of fers the,following comments. 'The loss of prime agricultural land should be identified. and treated as a sirrnifieant environmental ifipaot: The California statessthatla project Will. normallyet's6q,° Appendix G [y]) e Code Section 1a00have a L i,gnificant effect the environment if it. Will convert pribe agricultural ]and to rtn non-agricultural. use or im air 'the a r�.i<jL p g trlturpl productivity of Prime agricultural land: Since it appy-rats that these general plan 'elements will have such an effect, the Dra.rt EIR should pro idenformati on on the Mimber of acre's of a9`ricultural land to be developed, the value+ of the siise P r pof�ential agricultural theadty fi aC+tspof ` farmland conveys ion, and possible Mitigation we recommend that the bra:+ct En contain. imp ad fol.lowzngcini_ormat;3 ^M to ensure the adequate gas sessment f :�mpaOts ,gin these :ateas oa o the agricultural character of Butte Couhtyj including; - A map which identifies the. location' of agricultural Preserves, the number of aures Anic. t d in each preserve (i.e.; pr.imefnan-primE): ype of fan Von ernment Code Section $1282 Page I Two r (c) Fbt Purposes of paragraph'(2) ofsubdivision (a) cancellation shall be in the public interest only if the council or board makes the :following findings: + (1) that other, public concerns subsy tartiall oiitwelgh the obi ectives of thi ;a chapter; and 2 there that is ri a proximate noncontracted lana. which is both ava fable and suitable for the use to which it is proposed the contracted land to ptit, or, that dovelopilent of the contracted, re contiguous' patterns of urban development mofproximate.noncontracted..land than develop-►tc.ntd p;s used in this subdivizien "proximate, noncontracted land" weans land not restricted by contract pizrsua,nt to,this chapter, which is .sufficiently close to .land which is so restricted thatit can serve as a practical ,alternatIve for the use which is proposed for the, restr3,cted land Asused in this oubd,%vIsion "suitable' for the proposed use means that the salient features of the proposed use can be served by land not restricted .by contract pursuant too: this chapter. Such nonrestricted land may be a single parcel or may be'a combination of contiguous or disdontiguous parcels. (d) For purposes of .subdivision (a), the uneconomic chaxlacter of an existing agticul,tural use shall not by ±4self be sufficient reason for cancel,iation of the contract. The uneconomic character of_the; eXisting use may, bo considered only; if there is no either reasonable or colnparable agri,cultUral use to which the land may"' be put. {e� the' Iandc`wner i s pit_ ion shall. ba acct pahied by a proposal for ti specified alternative use, of the land ,, The proposal for the alternative use shall list those governmental agehc::es lciown`by the 1andowner to have permit authority related to the pt6posed alternative use, and the provislans and requiremerits of Se�wtion 51283:4 shall be hilly, applicable thereto. The level of specificity 'requited 'in a proposal; far a specified alternat.,: use shat be, detettin4ad by the board a council.as that neees'sary to perm,„t` them to make the findings required.. (f) In approving a candeftation pVt8Uant to this section- the board or couhca 1 shall, rat be rec;uired to make any findings other than d 1h acdci�i -'on' to `those eXpressly set forth°� i.n this section; and, � i ��rere a lacy e= 1.h S'ecti of the Public nesoii on 210l� 1, pp r X . - rces Code , +bATM "DF tAUF6fWJA—THE RESOURCES -AGENCY = GEORGE DEi11 AUTAhl, GoMemor A "'O;RNIA ENERGY COMMISSION �`�°C�.lsfannfnq+✓oz�, MS14 4IINr01 STREET fd,6 j;r WIf IJ' 0, CA' 45814-5512 APR I o 98 Oroville, Caloom April 1, 19851 Mr; `Bill Turpin Outte County Planning Department i County Center Dr1w) l oroville, CA 95965-33;)7 - Aek Commkint -Oil, NPece 'of Preparation of a Draft Environmental impact Reptir•t for the' Butte County General Plan 'Energy, Natural Resources, and Recreation Elements Dear'W Turpin The Caliiornip ` EnergyCommission (015C), appreciates the opportunity to, 60"iment on the, 'Notice of Preparation NOP concerning the Draft EWrol!menfa) Imps Report (pEIFt) for the County's General -,Plan Elements. Our comments address the following areas (some of Which are discussed in the County's :Initial Study); . Transportation Soil resources • Visual Resources AIr Ouality Socioeconomics Noise Public Services Earth Resources Land Ur,e ` Paleorltclogical Resources • WastA �Aana ement g Cultural Resources • Wator Resources riological Resources fienerat Comments:. In general, the NOP appears to Identify the most likely areas In which significant lr 1pacts ,could occur, however there are a few omissions acid corret`tiokis Wlticll should fue addressed, t igen the nature of the resources and types of specific projects Which may result from lmplementa- ,1106 of this elerrient, the DEIP should address areas the Initial Study (is) hidlc4od, Wouldnot result I►i adverse impacts . Potentialdevelopment of resources or projects could result in frnpac is to any of the l:5 Envir0nrribM61 Checklist Itelris for which an answer of ,no. is givon. i.e., checklist Items �i,d,' 4,d,x 10.b., 18,b.3d., & f., 10,, 15.b„ and 16 oe ), The IS' should be- revised to reflect the jposs bilityof impacts in these 5hvironmental Checklist items, .and tits G►EIi should address the potential for such Impacts and identify mitigation policles, Specific comments ori areas Wliich should be Indluded in the DEIN are organized_by subject areas below. April. 7, 1989 Page,2 ?ransportation The DOR should discuss the potential for new projects, from the element, to generate significant im acts to the transportation energy projects resulting g p j particularly ,dation syston of the coon ty, The most typical area r ' 3uch imparts is to road transport where e;.iall p � increases in traffic volumes May occur. This is et riy pertinent during the construction period for such projects, when. relatively large volumes of ti,"avy 'truck traffic may place unanticipated stresses on what are t�ssentiaily light dt qty; rural residential roadsi This may be ''particularly true for large biomass conversion projects which Would need to transport vast quantities Of material t gthr,P- plant, The DEIR should discuss the need for, And develop transportation mit g ;tion oolici�es that should be considered' on specific projects to reduce the i�ripact(s) Which may occur, particularly for the rural portions of the county st►rved by seconciari rn� pr�lrcy could re osis transportation mitigation on projects to include, at theleast,r example, tine q p Projected N 9 Y � I), ) g I1) existing and Sewetraffic voiumes in terms of Average Daily i raffrc All exkstln and projected Level. Of e ice LO,, � passenger) vs, heavy truck volumes (AD'Q, 4) adiequacy of existing structural capacity of the roads 5 need for Increased mainte anee or repalr/reconstruciio 0 the existing road network, l.6) effects on existkn n -n ` and i) ,safety conn methods to reduce sut,h effects,. g park's►g 'facil;�ties and- need for aiterriative energy rosources aftr n requires the transp�srtation eoftr hpzardous use the development of constru tion and operation of such energy facilities, the anaiy is of safety considls during should i ` ly traffic safety, but the safe transport of such hazardous materlais.' include not on Dgvelnprtent of sner p ". ty p gy projecis in close roxrmi to airports and landing fields may result in sl. i ifkcant impacts to thes0 facilities, such as project location in relation fields the air fresu t i hekgt,t(s) of structures (transmission lines,, stacks, artd 'cooling talars) and Potential int u r Sion Into the ,airspace, and visibility including rrmarking or glare problems. Mitigation policies should Include measures to reduce or eli`mi'nate such impacts: l Proximity si to, the if line oftfall Is ideihte occur in close roxrmit to rail facilities coni derattori thou begiven ry �cr heavy equipment or materials, if such a msthod would likely reduce the Potential severity of impacts ort local roads, .visual I'lesoUrce to the Checklist, ROM 7 "Light and Glare �- Will the pr6posal produce sl. Ifs lRdlerring. ight' and glare?' and Ron 18 °Aesthetics -- Wiil the proposal rE3sult kn `the obstr o t oh of any i " Of ars sedttietivailttd o offel SrVe s to the public, or will the propo§oi resWt ir7 the creation P ` Y " site open to public view?"' While the It notes the potential fior visual resources impacts resulting from specific In the d by The bE the NOP doe p die actions allowed by this element, s not Identifythis as oris cif the areas to beds IR 06uld address the need fdr visual resources mlti discussed,, will assl;at In Identifying,, visually sensitive arba; , including designated and gatlon prli�les Which eligible scenic April 7, 1989 Page 3 highways, and should discuss the types at mltigation measures which' would reduce visual resources impacts, in particular; developing power generation facilities which u'se ,natural A n Location facilities, can lead to significant fight and glare resources as a fuel and new recreational power giants In rural locations ca;. °f new recreational or industrial 'faciiitles such as IMpacts: on surrounding area, �Locutran ' read to severe degradation of visual resources unless mltlgaion policies are establish0d, For exam le, that lighting is shielded so that it does notImpact the night-time should rt given to a CountIc ensuriny such as Butte where much of Its ,t-tractlon for residents and •� particularly In .non-urbanizes outdoor experiences,. n visitor's is associated with Socioeconomics • Referringto the . Checklist,' item 11 ,Population -- Will the proposal alter to distributi on, cionsity, or growth rate of the human population?". cation, flu new residentstbris related to otent al rm acts on tOMmunities ;end their residents ibis item p p , ermarient ar temporary] Into the county or to a serieof fluctuations ations ituo 'to 6h �ncour;ty Population, Population changes Dissociated with developing new energy facilities , new lities recreational areas, or using natural resources can sighrflcantly affect a community's physical and fiscal ability to re,-,pond 3a such chap esu are further discussed in the section on public > rvices�al effects of such population changes Population changes can also bring a potential for overallch,:ftes in the socioeconomic "fabric" of the communitles. For exarnpie, change. mayr be associated with Increases in densltyy, ',pith concentrations of new residrrnces, or with developh,ent of new commercial services in areas y ry Ientially open space. Such changes may be very subtle and could involve a shill. In the set of values Underlying i y ng the existi,ng community s#ructure, or they could affect the existing pt5litical "balance and voting patterns within the county or within " ' pa g inaivdiral communities; 'Where <I roSIrticular neighborhood character is desired and shared b pol May y Regulatdionsss6 that he cfta�, tor1cles bretadded Use Element or Zonrn to the Land g increases. A erved and tnaintaired in spite of population Referring to tho Gheckllst, item 12 'Housing Will the proposal affect existing housing, or create a demand for additional housing?". gy ('"TEj facilities could a property hip Imypa,.t goes beyond the concern that 11Vastet to Ener. �, f[ect ra a values, or perceptions related to living do,�ta to a waste disposal sits; There is a potential impact ato assoda{ed with an `lnflux of wormers or IUctuations in papulation caused ,t�y recreational users which affect'the demand for hot.�sing ;both permanent and transient (egg»� hotels, Motels, RV and itiobile hone parks, or cani�� sites p ) The "county :Land `Use anti l-tous►r� Elements should be reviewed and modified to correspond with the new Energy, Natural existiti He,;tu�rdCes, and Recreation Irlement, to ensure maintenance of'a healthy market for housing , resldents as well as providing temporary housing npportunitles for workers ?ssocIIdttd .r I r April 70 1989 Page 4 with development of energy facilities, use of natural resources, and ,increases in recreational Users of new or improved recreational facilities. Ppblic SerylcG3 Referring to thb\ 'Checklist, Item 14 "public Services Will the proposal ihave an effect upon, or result r, a need for 'new or altersd governmental service? (c) Schools' As presented In the Checklist, the statements of policy,mpact and mitigation do not refer to the potential for impacts on schools- associated with an Influx and fluctuation of nc �. rnbers of people needed to work on the construction and/or operation of new energy or recreational facilities, or with developing natural resources, Often school districts do not have 'the financial rescurces to provide additional classroom space until the need for the space haspassed, while existing financing programs are several years (at best) behind in their ability to provide funding for new classrooms or schools. While existing laws allow cities and counties to establish developer fees to mitigate potential school impacts, such fees accrue only to the school districts) In which the project is locatedo project impacts often extend to additional districts which will not receive developers lees, in its regulatory review process the CEG has mitigation fees ,per, ''protect-im' ct student" to a' ` district which project, providing established procedures for idents in school districts Impacted b a roject and for rove p any distrlc which can show project-related Impacts. Additional Information on such procedures is available from CEO staff. Checklist Item 14 (f) "Other governmental servicatV,, This response should at least be a "Maybe" until additional ;information is available. For Instance, developing of new energy facilities or natural resources may create ,a need to develop new or additional_medicai and health care facilities. t-and. Use The iS identifies itttpacts on the, county's land uses and )and use procedures which will result from th16 element, and Indicates that policies addressing' these impacts, and amendments to tVGeneral plan, will bo needed The bEIR should also discuss the potential Impacts to the county's environment which May result from the developrilent of hydroelectric resources if these :policies are not. considered Eecause the permitting of hydroelectric facilities is done by, the Federal Energ',� Regulatory ComMisslon (FERC), monitoring of FERC applications and proceed- lngs, ,and involvement by the county it! those proceedings, will ,be necessary if tl-.e 'county's p i re to be Incorporated into, the FERC decislonk environmental obcies and .concerns a ftt- a `Manaaemenf r. The beIR prepared by file county should address issues related to the inanaget�ent of solid g y ton and operatlon of electric generation and hazardous wastes enerated b the Gen,.truct April 7, 1989 Page 5 facilities. Both hazardous and nonhazardous 'wastes should be included.- The major areas` which must be discussed include the projected types and amounts of wastes to be generated, the methods used to treat the wastes (if any), and disposal methods, locations and disposal capacities. The potentially large amount of ash produced from biomass combustion facilities could have significant impacts on local landfills, affecting their ability to accept wastes from other sources or shortening their operating lifetimes. The impact on the availability and .capacity of landfills used for waste disposal should be discussed or references made to the County Hazardous Waste Management: Plan and Solid Waste Management Plan. Mitigation policies to address these issues, and reduce their potential impact, should be developed and Included as part of the element, Water Resources Checklist item 3d - change the checklist to Lead "Yes", impacts*# Impacts of hydroelectric projects have a direct impact on 'the volume and timing of peak flood flows, The impact statement should be modified as follaws; "this will have a direct impact of altering the natural flow of flood watars,, " an-stream impoundments for hydroelectric power generation ar I water cohseNation may cause increased erosion of river banks and stream channels dog nstream of these facilities ;by decreasing the sediment load of the downstream releases, .Mitigation should include specific policies to include "sufficiem', development guidelines,', to minimize potentlal...impacts resulting from... downstream sedimentation and/or erosion. y Checklist item 3e - impacts should Include increased evaporation losses as a, result ;of reservoir development Also temperature and turbidity effects of impoundments should be included with a.mitigating proviso that all such developments recognize the potential effects on downstream uses. •3f - Policy statement should Include hydroelectric power generation and water conservatlon storage %611106s and the potential of temperature, dissolved o p xy9en and turbidity changes caused by water Impoundment on the downstream users and environment; Mitigation should address the ;effects of hydtoeiectric poW'. generation on water quality. Checklist ltem 3h-13utte County may wish to consider a policy concerning ovardraft of groundwater basins, S 'Th .oil Resources e id expand upon the potential sources of impacts to soil resources Identified In h 18Envi onmental Checklist Items c, throu h f, , While hydroelectric and 1nir.;h ( 9 Y g activities t April 7, 1989 Page 6 ore significant sources of soil erosion, other'types of energy development may also contribute to this Impact. An example of this would be the usO of the residue remaining from timber harvesting for a biomass facility, Removal of this material would leave slopes even more unprotected than normally results from timber harvesting and would increase rates of soil erosion, The cumulative impact of existing and future development on soil resources in the county should be identified, One approach to identlf)ring the historic trends in erosion and sedimentation is, if the data are available, to use water, sediment load levels, The DER should also review the adequacy of existing policies, procedures, regulation, and standards regulating soil erosion and surface mine reclamation within Butte County. If additional measures are deemed appropriate, the use of performance standards, streamside :buffers-, the posting of bonds, and other approaches to erosion control and land reclamation should be discussed. To adequately address soil erosion concerns regarding hydroelectric faci;`rtles and other types of development that are not dig z: tly under county or city jurisdiction, the erosion control practices of the appropriate state (California Department of Forestrlr) and federal (U.S.. Forest Service, BLM, FERC) agencies should also be reviewed. If these practices are determined to be insufficient to adequately control erosion, then the DEIR should recommend additional measures, OE71 should id enthy :,s.► discuss the status of Protecting irrlportant agricultural land in the county, As part of thin discussion, the criteria used to idr7,1ttify agricultural land suitable for protection should be provided, The criteria foLrnd In the Williamson Act is outdated whIIG the ;Soil Conservation Service derinition of prime agricultural land (class 1 and llsoils) may exclude' economically important areas. A more appropriate criteria may be that used by the California Department of ConseN h Important Farmland Mapping Program . The discussion should also .include a review of the adequacy of the Williamson Act and other existing land use policies and plans used to protect agricultural land, historic trends in agricultural land conversion, and the need for additional measures to protect agriculturalk%nd. Ali ualit In discussing air emissions or detarloration of ambient+air quallty, sand in considering mitigation, rt should be noted 'that -even with t.he, application oz policies ki reduce air quality Impacts, cumulative deterioration may not: necessarily wilt, still occur, The goal of policies and mitigation should be to reduce air quality, impacts to the lowest level' feasible, ideally to zero; Policies, implementation guldelih#z and +development standards, using currently available technological applicatlons and management practices will treed to be developed, to that they will address .site specific projects when 'they are submltted, and will involve other agencies, such as the :Air Pollution Control "strict, California Aiir Resources Boded' and. She E:nvironrtiental Protecti, Agency. April 7, 1989 Page T lois+e Th deterioration environmental effects listirt., of t OP should addProbable "Noise emissions or of ambient noise uali Noise proto Policies should be addres sed In the DEIR, and if already adopted as part of the county General Plan or a county noise ordinance they shouid be referenced. The discussion of potential impacts from power plants should Include development standards and policies affecting facility siting, and the potential mitigation, through currently available "echnologicai applications and management practices, of potentlal- ly adverse noise impacts, Earth. Besources "The DEIR should address policies to mitigate impacts on or from, geologic feu«lres or ha Y resulting from the u-0 ,�i'natdrtal resources, or development of power plants using energy res6urc;esb Such hazzords might include earthquake shaking, land Instability; erosion, oQfii��.9, or naturally occurring hazardous substances, Pa!eantolorc , Rrces to the Checklist item 11 "Earth" -- Wli the proposal result insignificant (d) destruction, covering, or modification of any unique geologic or physical features?', Consideration should be given to identifying the potential for paleontologic'.-jesources which fol` the: miti ation and data collection from an such resource p developed' Y „ Would be disturbed b a Proposed project art'. � set of owls and affected should be y, a protect= Cultural Re8ource§ The language in the NOP and the IS Checklist focuses primarilyon the potential for impacts Oft cultural resources associated :with tt e development of hvdro-electric resources, Other types of energy development should' also b2 included in the NOP discussions, Even with construction of a cogeneration facility oh an existing site, there could be a potentlal for impacts on ethnographicr prehistoric or historic cultural resources, • Referring tc the r^, 6c.All0, item 20 "Cultural 'Flesources" The set of existing guidelines included with the NOP needs to be expanded considerably to reflect the statements made deve( p o- hecklim for developing 'guidelines for mitigating impacts to cultural resources, j In mores ecific ol�cldt and gUldelines; contact should be made with the State Historic preservation Office (State Department of Parks and lidcreat oh) and tine Native American Heritage CommisSIOh� CEC staff would be willing to provide review pmeit of such policies and guldclines, anti comment in the deveio,..