HomeMy WebLinkAbout87-44B BCBOS GPA AP=VARIOUS LOG#87-05-05-02 5 OF 7s,
i
BUt E COUNTY, ,GENEEtAL ALAN
Ener v.
�3
Nat ,
za1 P,,esaUrces and Recreation Blom ht
REVZSE,F3' Sahec uZe of -Tjq s
p���i:
schedu'z�
-
15.2
14,-JU1 f -a 014-Aue3'
i.15
18 -Hug
15.41.8wug'
.
5-�
18�p ug
=Au, g
15;�
27�ep
15.1
30, -hep to 04 -Oct
1 .2:
04-O;c,it:
16.3
1.l�bc�:
16 ,5
1 � pct to 25 -Oct'
1
L�ct t 25 -Oct`
Was#k .17
00 -Dov
:SSS 18
t✓:r mhihei with T 20
29-vbv
- FIdbliC Rev i:evi
- -- -
d2 -17e tt 1Si --'Y an i
20
62-066 to i's -LI
an
ask 21
07b -
Tw°S k 2
0 7'-E _I
.
'�Is k 23
to be !sc' 6hdUieri
, OR
r
l
Cal ifornia; dater Se va,o
1,540 ''Esplanade
Chico;' CA 9592'6
California Nat"" ,P1 ant Society
Calif6.tnia Native Plant Society
Daunt .Lassen Chapter
'Patrick�. Kelly
i. Herbari
be t, of Bol.. Scum
P
Mt;: Lassen Cha ter CLAPS
P �
California State 113niversity
900 East 19th
Chico;` CA 95929-TOSl5
,St.
Chico; ' CA §5,928
Berry.-Creek Community Sexvices
PO,• Box 387
Berry :Creek, .CA .95926
S izabeth Norton; Vorest Planner'
tassen'National Forest
55 South Sacramento Street
Susanviile :California 9'$13Q
p
1.
I
i
01
r
.. � ya'.s:n std •Wi.
M ah M
0d•A.
Mt. 1..44ra Tuttle
September z 1088
Page 2
ork In PrMir c5
As we move into September}.t:veral activities are ori-gging including
1 The review of elstin ,'normation collected'by the County
2) The collection and analysis of additional informatioj:
�
3) 'I11C ldt ntifieation of a rea3avaWe energy development scenario far Butte Coll[llj/
I
l
j 4) The preparation of the Administrative; Draft Element;. The Administrative Draft Element was started
I at, the e'nd of August with the effortFocussing tin the Rosource Production sections Of the, Element -
specifically, agriculture; timbeey and water supply. As. part of this effort, additional inforrtial on is being
C=ollected to support. the update and/or preparation of these sections,
Clpcaming Adivitics °
,,
During the upcoming report period ('September) and toll -owing final review, of the ;Initial ;Study, a Notice' of
re araban null be re ared frit the
P p prepared TrleriaCnt ,EIR, and submitted to the State Clearinghouse,
9 The primary work effort during Septcnriier wi11 be ori preparation of "the Resourcc'S?xoductfon and; Resource
Protection scctioiis al the Natural RcsaurCCs Coviponent, and preparation of the Energy Component of t'he
Element. Work on the Irnergy component will include consultations with Pacific Gas
r
and Electric Co. staff
during ca'riy to .mid September far the purpose rif more accurately defining thn energ�r'deyclQpm�nC st enario;for
BuRe County over the uexi 2b years, Consultations with P�aiiaE will lie follbved �vi1i additional consultations
with the Energy Comiii ssion, 'SwAca and Department of<Water ltt
sources;
It is also anticiptited-11coortFA4tation with the Citizen's Advisory Committee will ,begin toftrd the end ''of
.
Scptembc"r. The initial riiccting'tiVill alln�v the ttirisulting team to present intormatibp on prolcct"bac ground,
stGdy proess,'and schedtilc to .CHC committee and �t Will prgiride a f6rum for the Committee to .Contribute to l he
l p.
Planning pracess.: Of particular frif ortance gill be the discussion gF'key planning and, ,issues.
(5verall, the project is moving snioothl although considerably greater effort ��ti11 be required to prepare tho'r
Cncrgy develaprcicnt scenario. Subsequent Program Reports Neill be issued. minthly 1t°itli the next report being
issued the. first' week of `October.
it
SrcerelYr.
'a
ap.
ltchael O'. Clayton
hf 166601Clayton iQ Assoclatds
6,g;
�1� �pi?0
i
l.GA4K�Vl l < kJsS../l.�Cr",R
• tl..:. .,. ,.
1�J(4+.F�
V�,1
"06, Cali76t
Ar Al'A'1989,
Mr, Bill Turpin
;Butte County Plarning Department
''County Center, 7 ;•County, Center Drive
j.fOroville, CA 9-5965
9
JtG; Energy, 'Natural Re tourees, and Recreation General 1?lan'Element, 1'rofesional Services
ivt - &A 76b No. 880(?�
Invoice No.
Billing Period:1: arch 2r. 1989 through March 31, 1985:
IiT"ask
7 Review Data. 0. .. Y ...: , ....:: , L . 5.0 Hours .
$ 200.00
Task, $ Conduct Agency (consultation and Data Collection , , ; 44.51Hours .
S1,61.750
,i
Task 10 Progress 'Reports ,,'. ..: L . , . : L :.... , + :. 1.0 Hour
$ 2.00
7iaslr 12 Advisory Cotnmittqe 7vlr.,eting : L , . , F ...: , ; :. , ... , 1.0 Hatu •.. ,
$ 60.•10
Task IS 'rel are Administrative Draft Element . Y . L . Y : . L .: 153.0 Hours
$S,S3Q.OQ
Task 16 Prepstre Admin1.istriii`ve Draft EIR , . > :: .. , ..: , ::. , Hours .'
190.00
.Subtotal Labor . ': . Y :... , � � . � , , '. r ... L Y . . F , : 213.0 Hours
$7,624.50
BXPENSkS
'
'ravel
L F i',.Y L i(♦ i 1 r p•ly Y i L : •�l • , ! ! ! ! ♦ , ! r Y : l ,'a ♦ s .
r
Pho tocop}y in,g
o
'
u - -
;Po
,-
/1/9!.25
telephone
L elephone: i . Y L Y ,i .L . + h ::. S' . ,i . Y,': I Y '.• i`.I F L . / L L . Y L . Y . a + 1. ', 26.52
Adminlstratiou Ig MID 4.
j
1
x ,.
Subtotal'Ekptin5esr.�.li.. L; .:��.a..;,��Y.. .F.r;'.�.,a.wi:.;i3L.L.
S 328.38
'Total Thls"'ans'Qice ... ... .',: i : a .::... l • .: ! J : , . + i a .: F .. .:..:.::. :
7,95t.11s
Total Oastandint; :<,: k . Y .:; , .. s. a. -Y Y 1 i 1 .w l Y i '. e• Y L i:. i. i G a 1 i L Y Y i Y i i
.Q
1 R V�l1L' ,{ill Y1 i•� V.L'' R 's J i:i J i: i• L.J r i•. :�. i, i :' .. F• G M n i };'i M F i i F'F i L a 1 i, .F S a s. is
�� 9JG>l70 i
1
7�+
iithael Cs; Clayto'ti Date
Iu,`Ciehael Clayton & Assc►ciates
i
289}1 �-3
.1rU 11wra e DdVe
Sur#c +i
i�yr
y Cl r
or i4'1 H A �9
415 9x'01991
-chael CZaytont
9U40 CO. Pianoitsg Canto.
Assdciai
i
December 23, Lbs „
-
Ora��lla, Calfomia'
MS4 Laura Tuttle
Butte County Ptanninng Department
County Center i County Center Drive
a'
Oroville, CA 95965
{
;mss. Energy, Katural Resources, and Recreation General Tian Blementa
Professional
MCi4cA. Job No. 8800 t Services
Invoice No.
illinu Pernod: I`tovembet} 1 through :November 30, 1988
7
Task. Citize �dvissory Committee;..:
. ... :....
Task 8 Condbct riigency Consultation and, Data
2,0 Hours .
, S 1201,00
�
Collection' i . ,
Task 11 P,rogress/Update Meeunes%Repor is
10 Hours .
, $ 20,00
Task 12 � ., .., .....:. .
Advuor�t C:on =tee, .Vieet_ne
13 ours ..
-
a&"
S ,r>00
.... , i .. „, , , .... .
Task 1.5 - .
I'Ietf „ ve Draft Element ....
14,0 H
ours .
, S 624'JO
�drnxntstrat . . ; . ,
Task 16 are dmimstradve Draft MR
36S Hours .
rz
• S#x�-9 00
, .., , , .
95 Hours
Subtotal Lshor
... t , .. ... Y- . ...
75.5 Hours
S3,=61,00
E�M%ES
Mileage/Parking
.i.;: ..,,i ,. :..,..
5.00
,.. ,'...
33.00.
i
_ - . :-1444
Teiephone
..Y.+,. •,i.
drruitstratzoa @ 10�e
S'
18.21
.
Subtotal EYpense5
... i .
S 144.66
Total This Invoice
....::
a-
S3 505.66
..
. t .. • 6, Y • . s a. . . i i -
S -0—
'TOTAL. NO
'OTAL.NOW DV
Nfichael G. C
yrcon
lit hael Cla*ts5n Associates
Date Ij
=0041
r R C}ar. tiiisur:1'o
w� i
-
� 3tlN
''C0rte7 M-JJQ.M CA949
413 x'"191
,_,
----.�.
,. ,�� ,
,. r
,� �> ,
.'
Wfichael la ren
Buij
r aeCo. ManningCa►sm.
y Ass6cja
PEC 2,11988
December 23, 1983
Qrevilla, 'California
R
l
i
I,fs. Laura`Tuttle
t
T3utte County PI anning Department
P
County Center 7 County Center Drive
s
Oroville, Cry 95965
Re. Energy, Natural R esourres, and Recreation General Plan Element,
NIC&.A ur
JoNo. 8$004
Professional
Services
Invoice N6.5
Billing Period: November. 1 through N. Tovember 30, 198$
,
I-AI30R
Task 4 Citi.;yn Advisory Commute„
. ...Y....Ai. ♦.Y •: ..
Task $ Conducz,�.gency Consultation Data
2.0 Hours ,.
$ 120.00
and Coilertioa y , ..
Tall: 7.1 Pro ass U date Me-tings,/Repoms
°� p ,...
1.0 Hours .:
$ 20:00
Task 12Advisory,g . , . r • i . i i .
Comautte- �'4feetiag
1.3.5 Hours
S 567.00
.. , Y F . • .. i .
Task 15' Prep aze i�idmnisuatie �rafk Element
x'� 0 F"ivurs
2,
$ 624.00
....
• ~ �
Tas1 16 Preparer.�;dm—istrat ve Draft EM , ' i ,
36S Flours
$1,731.00
k . i • i . . : � i +
9,5 .Hours
Subtotal Labor
.. . i ♦Aa,i..•i••yi. ...... .i.
76.5 Hours •,
$3,461,00
,E.YI,'ENSES
MJe3ge(/'�i+f' •
r i . ... ... ,• . k .. , .
photocopyin
S1�i 7.5.00
i . • ...... 4 .
Postage ki:.9• ••� k sii• i.lrka
h1. 33.00
y + r k r i• i k t . k : ..
"Telephone .:i ,-
5Y�3
.... � .. . k i ;i A i • • : • i
Administrai�
:F.ti i• •1
y�♦♦iii•• •ik •. k'. ia.k• ak•i
. 1J.15.
.
Subtotal Ekbenses •.�
♦ + i .' Y • • . V 4 . k . i ., Y i • � 'a i f • N L a • i . i • i
$ 144i66
Total This Tnvoice
• ii, i i i. i r. i J ik l r k
Total 0utstanci�ii
• . ♦ i
a A ♦ a y
a i.: . k
�Si3,605.66
TOTAL NONV DUE .
J
....
k i k ♦
53,605,66
,..
L ` .. •rte.
Michael G. C
J z--2:5
vton
Michael d: on � .�ssgciatcS
Date,
s0o�7
..: "64 l�1ri"Ytltici 1Jir.Y9i
,.
��ile ♦�
Coo- idemCA NOZ .
4151 9�i-0191
L
i
h
'un
LAND OF NATURAL WEEA,ITH A61D BEAUTY
PLANNING COMMISSION
( 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE : OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3397
k PHONE: 538-7601
Y
October 4, 1988
Mrs. Diancy Hanson, Grant Program Manager
California Energy Commission g
1516 9th Street
Sac
rarrento, CA 95814
Subject Butte Count-y's Siting and Permit Assistance Grant 586-$7-009
Dear Nancy:
Enclosed Py
please find co .bf Butte. County's financial report for the,
period of 4/1/88 to 9 30/88 in grantdagreemenh our grant agreement: As
We had discussed earlier the t was received too late t6
Prepare a financial report for the first quarter. Therefore, this
finaricia'1 report covers the first two quarters of therant
All succeeding report", Mill be fo.r the preceding quarter, $ Period.
Project Accomplishments
Task One:
Preparation of a Request for Proposal. Bids were solicited
from, firmg qualified to prepare the County's Energyand Pe&vsation , Natural ResouLces
and Associates Ewaesment. Interviews were held 6/3/88. Michael Clayton
hired to prepate the element. Projected timeline
2/18/88 to 5/8/88, Completion data 6/3/88
Task TWO: Develop a contract ,and Work program, ram, which fulfills the grant,
agreement,,, meets the requirements of the request for proposal,
addressplan es all mandatory tlemdtits in the general
p guidelines for
,Pon. space and consetVat bn elements, and conforms to C%A4 projected
timeline 5/9/88 to 5/29/$8. Complet,ioa date 6/10/88;
The project i, on schedule at this time, although, tasks One and two
took more time than previously est'inated. (See Mork schedule attached
to grant agreement for timeline of task one and wd);,
Work Underwa
y
is
that the d"wired pi+dduct is achieved, Mor hprogress and to ensure
Task Three.: h consultant. to monit
Work tsit
ay , ..work products tender task
three include preparation of the Initial study, draft element and draft
environmental. impact teport. Task three spans the period of 5/30/88' tci
8/28/89. The .initial study was due 8%16%88,: and received $%,15/'8$,
i'lanning staff and CEC staff .submitted comment, on'the initial study,
which were incorporated in a revised document submitted gj25/8$� The
administrative draft element is dire 4/15%85, although the county es
contract with the consultant moves the deadline up to 12/16/88,
r z
.� y Id fv4
'In addition to the initial study, the consultant has provided the
county with regular progress reports (see enclosures), and a general
plan consistency checklist.
I
The only difficulty encountered to date has been the appointment of the
citizens advisory committee, County staff has been working with the
board of supervisors to appoint a committee which represents resource
preservation and production groups, energy industries, and recreation
providers or user groups. The committee needs to be geographically
`as
diversewell. The Board postponed makingappointments for over two
f
months as a result of 'heavy agendas and budget sessions. Five members
of the committee have been appointed, with the remaining eight
y
anticipated to be appointed by 10%4188. The first citizens advisory
committee meeting will be held 'approximately ,two week`s after all
appointments have been made.
Budget
► �,
The county, has incurred cost overruns on the required match,share in
task one grid two. Cost
overruns are not reflected in the financial
to gort, as the county will take full. responsibility: Item 7 of the
L
Elrit,,
financial status report reflects budgeted amounts for tasks one and
aai„U:
two, and costs incurred to date for task three, The county's actual
costs are shown on the ENAR Accounting sheet. county costs to date
rb
4;
total $5260.29. State expeinses, consultant costs, are in budget. A
total of I9 933.93 has ut to
been aid othe consultant. from the 801000'
_
rants They
,g prosect is progressing, within budget:
There havz �;nn :;�= nersonnel changes, or issues to report.
Please, contact me'if you need, any additional information or have any
questions concerning this progress report
Sincerer*
,--
Laura M. Tuttle
Associate. planner
[..
�
cALCFQRriIa� ENERGY ca.
wlssron
'
FINANCIAL STATUS P.EPORT
(R£1tISED 5Js4}
2 w
I.y...
T. xerVtenc Organizac:on
(Namrt end" Complete Address)
2. rant 110
"4. Approved rant Period: "---�--�•
arc tots reoart! 'ri. = copies
s""
Erstte', CErttnty Planning Dept.
986-8"-009
01/25188_ to: Califorota EnO'V Com,nission
07 25 89 Attention Aat..;4rting Office
rnn
7oizriGt/ Center Drive
ectptenc ►. a,
�,.o,/ ay/ ear o o„*
..rtor
ay ear 1516 Ninth t{reec, NS, 2
Orm-.+ ;I;l CA 95965-3397
;hovered oy n1s sport
Sacram.tRtd,,! 95x14
O4j01/Lo no �ialss
ram a .o. av earn Yo ,.»i
FINANCIAI.STATUS REPORT
BUDGET EXPENOtTURES
is rertod
Unliquidated Unencumbered
10 ate
Obligations Ealance
b. fATIr VIiARE
Perwn ll__$erricos-
0
0
0
Taodract,lg Ezbenses
00
1I 0
- essionaT
I 80,,000,00
19,933.93
10,033.93 I
0 0 t
r
6Q 0-66.07 i_ I
oI
wbiis�rr3c ion t<xoenses
I 0
I E7
0
TOTAL
80,000.00
L,9,933..93
_
19,933 93
0
601066.07 I
6 ec
asdirect Char es
I 0
0
.)
L
U
0
0 0
TO—*Al
80,000.OdI
191933:93
19,933,93
60,066.07
7. IMA75H' SRA:RE
Pcrsorrne3 . _ �
�
5 07,,78
2 150,86
2 150.86
2 92642'_
' L'�erattno EzOpnses
I
500 00
0:
0 L
0
1
Consultant 6 Professional _Services
0
0.
-
ii
500.00 _ 0
sustdTAl,
I
_
5,57,781
_
2,150:86 I
0 I
2 150.86.
0 1
°
3 r�26.92
Endirect Charles
2 893�-34
:
0'
idTAL-
8,47'1,,1.2)
,3,266,:51
3,266,51
5,204.61
8, r+AND.iC7Ai
88 471.1'1 I
23 (
1100:44 23.200:44
.
certieldaticn;
9. FR3RR REWEiSTS FOR PAYMEIht
I teetify to the best 0(.nby knbwledce and
R1: Fu)ids Requested TO Date;
16,060 belldf that this report is 2berect and
complete and that at l outlays and
toss CEC Retention
� (_.`) �
unIl uidatL obli i dons ar
q , ft for the
0 pur'pos s ' h
s
.or n the: nt a rca
g
n
'pe t, ,.
1P1. Disbuescmi is to Date; _
.
'16,060 ,1
z
CEC USE D:14T
rungs an liancu
0 S na[ur�» of ucha�
9 lien ertl ymg, u
icia
jAmount Ahthorimi
14A. kfRCM
tt
Approved: .
DfYector, Of Planning
Lc Grant maplpr
ype or Frinc Rame and, 11t a
Approved-
I
��. .Ar4CJItT de T,YIS REQUEST x6/05/88 (916) 538-7601
___�
FdR PAXrlEPii
t rogra� r7anager
37933793
ace Reporc uonttted one
er
Approved-''..
rants Office
C U UN r 111G TTF 1C L u3L fjNLY
Acirbur cement
.
Retention:
`—Advance to cover estimated fund "needs
Amount Scheduled: 3
forthe tine period
-
ro.7 cw day, year "
o ino day yearf�
�,_..� 5tbtut Report
CALIFORNIA ENERGi' Cay.4ISSI00
FINANCIAL STATUS :REPORT �y
(REVISED 5/84)f -
fnvo"ice Humber
w Rectptall rgamnatioZ. rant no, 3 `
(Name and' Completeda, Approved 6- rant ?ertoo:
Suaait. tats` regi and 2--- co-lei---
Butte County Planning986-87-009, X1125 88 tot California Energy'Cormisston
Cattnty Cenfpr Drive r�°m____���ao�/ ay/ kart 07 / 89 At;entinn Accounting Office,
brov l:le, CA 95965-13977nectptenc- . ;,°o overea By in, ° / /ear r 1518 Ninth Street; Ms..2
kPort �' Sacramento, CA 95814
i0/01/88 12/31/88
From ,.o.i ay earl
o .0 arr
FINMCIAL STATUS REPORT
BUDGET EXPENOiTURES
ts'rerloaUnliquidated
y ,"r�, C SgxRE ( "-�o late Otilioattons Mande
pkr,.onnel Unencumbered
_ Services J . 0 �tar
Qpnratt= Eiipense5 d
0 j 0 0:
1 w� 0 li �
Profess�
Consultant b i°nai 80 000:00 I I 0
_5 OOO:Ofl
,44 933,93 60 066.07 0
C°nstrtftt, on Expenses :++ f
0 0 0 I
_<118S0TAL 80,000.00 25;000,00 —� 0
44,933.93 �,
Indirect CSaroeS 60,o66.01 L 0. ! 0 I � °
1 0 y
0 f 0
TOTAL 80x000.00 ' 2IS,000,00 I 44,933.?3 I
7 ,MA`It�_ H SkA15E 60,066.0, 1 0
Personnel4
5,077.7$ I, 000.00 3 150.86
fteratino nenses ' 2:926.92
E�0
Consultant b P.rofessOnal S•ry
50000 250.00 ;00
°
°
SU8TO3SL - 0,
0.
5 577.78 1 250,°0' 3' 40fl,86 1
Ir,dtrett Char es 3 426.92 ( 0
2 893.34 /77 69
648.38_. 1 164M I
T�OaAt. 1
8 475..12 1 898.36 5,164.89°_
8. ,.1GttANO +"OTAt 5 204:61 °
88 471+12 ( 26 '898+38 50 098.82
i
Certification; .
9.,Afdk AEOUtttS FOR PAYMM1
1O. tunds Re uertsd. TO pate; 111 9.T titt1416f ty to the best of my dlfidtedge And
o � ,933.,93. Qell,.f'that this report 1s correct and'
complete and that All outlay, and
Less CEC Retention (`= 0 unliquidated obligations are / the ,
U. Gisbuese5ents to patee r6'O°Oib_ � Purpose set ort t he gr a4reementa
i � CEC USE ONLY
12. Olunds on hand:: 0 (Anoilnt A„Fhoriaed.S
S cu ero utnortxe° t.ertt to r
Y 9 t ct a------=--_.�._t
B.A; K cfM JAPOrdvodt ...;
Dixet tor. of Planhtr,g ct, uranc , onager
pe or rent me an° It e L
I3. AMOUNT OF THIS-RCdUEST Appcavkd:
FCC, PAYMENT .... rrograrq arager
25,000.00`, port upattte° one umoer A ,roved.
ate ne
Wants ufflce
[_t» I Aeia ,uriemenk t aG HC u KT .
etentt°n; �
• ( �t�-- S •�__
Advance to eover eseimated fund heeds Amount Scheduledt S
X f.�� the
time:period _
reds c:o: oa
y Year
1zl3ilas
TO—r— day yearj "
I,W.,,,;� Statu Report
Vin''
7p li 0 1
4 ,
.NRR ACCOUNTING
TaS staff Rours Rath (l) Cast
11nd r eat (2 ) Tota'L Budget ed
LT (3) 28 11 -,0 8, 478i24
298..06 726.30
64 20.76 1.328.64
P 28
669,17 201.7. $1
16.2.3 454.44
41mbtotal 120
235b72 690iiI6
2261,32 3 7 i77
6 2 ('�5�^+ 3434,27
2261, 22 1,172Y 9Yd.. +J�J� i � A �� d
r
s. L'Z'9 17,0$- 153,72
79.73 233.45
ylet B 2 21.7641,52
21w54 68.06
�1y�.95,2�4{•:J y (101---y2�7�4�( }'`2•9i,6�w,5'1s. y yj1.60:
.. '� � :/:5 �':il ./F � � I« Ir" �F � �'4 Ni1 � %4'ini � 7s � � h. � R � � � �� x'i � /R f. � :R..)S. � SF .G � 1f � JS �c�'A fG F � � /. � 1R R �C �F T �lT.. T. ✓k h ]c � �� �R,JL � �
"hare LTO) 40 17..0$ 65342
LV4.7 15.75 17M93 282,40
r� sf� .ti
3$4.38 1037,-58
L.4 2 2:0. 70 41,52
IMO
O s6
21. 54 63.06
0f 9,30/88 57,75a�u w LwI W �y�,y007i12
. . w �" � Ii ]�. '� I1 IS � vl. �'� � "F.
(.522439 5453{
+. IVi Tw /F JV �' i\J,� ik �
as
}y�5,2�,y.a1 uyx
h" vT..� � �Jk, FS' iS'dG 7t ✓«. ei' � 7: '.Y. J� 'il''�� � Tir` .Ay `�rv''� � [ '�. h"
,w «iii 068 $.75 3465,68
1796,61, 520,29
(,1) Rate + benefltg caloula:t6d at 35%
f2) Indirect = Actual x .5181
50erso+nnel. cost$ pe,�
'J..ssS 3y1a
}�yyT
r
.r
i
1 OROVILL5, CALIFORNIA
GENERAL CLAIM
iCLAJUART: Michael C:lmv bn & Assoc a
46cREss: 5764 Paradise -Drive Suite 5
CITY ASTATE: Corte Madera. CA 94� 5
IMPORTANT:
0ATE OF CLAIM: 9/13/88 SEE INSTRUCTIONS
ON REVERSE SIDE
�15IIEMIT CLAIM TO DEPARTMENTRECEIVING GOODS OR SERVICES
DESCRIPTION OF CLAN (DESC.RIBE FULLY TO AVOID DELAY)
i+
Manthl_y., billingo
rendered in re ara"tion of Ener
w . Natural Ryan,;,-r,�
and Aecreation Element of the Buti_e Co n
L
Plan Pur.��>.ant to contz;act signed 6/28/$8
55 AI21
1
Payment 2,
TOTAL X5, 432:99
f, the undesstene4 declsre tiridex penahk of perjury thst the be,rvlce• dr art Ous c[l lmcd have been"s,0erfotmeil or deliveredrltut that thte
el"IfA is trire and correec}tk as atatad. „}�}}, Q p y
day of of ». Stp.
6 I bats,d this 13 � 5lgntltttre bSClo mum,
t.�.`uuww.:».u..i.,:«,y�c.
r
tr re 'underil,: thinid. ►ierakiy certify that, to tha.'6eat of Y knowledge. th'e oe:fOlcea or "Cles *0e ed ed a6ti tlue liven edorme r. e•
1t�l ed and that there is a �ifdget ApprcpHailon or specmkl , board Approval ech:ekor,e' far t ytl e
ith
bateddnYySepi+Calm
i ..
' pr .. _
bept. ♦Q(� (� .ij of, -- ." be
Et arm eod Ur AuthoHaeB b evt�
"Cade a:..4ti«`,'. Y«.L.dY..O.h.ir ..urr.t.e Code ..u:...r.ua .0 VA1`ABLk FFtt7lli w.G.,.Q. r
DO NOT WRlT
E BELOW THIS LINE..•.•w�...$p�C.•�,�0.�:"�s"».`.«:ti,: �1iNr7
AUDITOR'S USE ONLY
,Nb» rNV, NO, INV.. bAte �EN(jUMB, G(iOSS Aiv1,` ,
4!= 1 1 CJ4 JMr7A
F'ROJ. SUt�» C1EJ. CLAlM _.
• WfichwI,CIqbn&Asso id
September 2, 1988
Nis.. Laura Tuttle
µ
Butte County Planning Department -
County Center 7 County Center Thrive
broville, CA 95965
ite Energy, Natural Resources, and Recreation General Plan
Element,
4MC&A Job No. 88004
Professional
Services
Invoice No. 2
Billing Period: August 1, through August 31, 1988
I_ABOk
Task 5 ReviMv ExistY hg General Plan, and County Code
d
Task 6 Develop Consistency Guidelines
Hours
S 240.00
, . . Y .
Task 7 Review Data i
, L5 Hours
S 60.00
.
"' .. « . Y
Task 8 Conduct Agency. Consultation and Data Collection
19 Hours «
$ 820Y00
i ..
Task 9 Prepare Initial Study
, 53.5Hours Y . ,
$1,713.50
... Y . -. . Y y .:., . , • • • , ` i •
Task 10 Prepare Monthly Progress Reports '.
Y 50.5Hotus 4 ..
$1,675.50
, , , . Y • , ..
Task 15 Prepare Administrative Draft Element
3 Hours ...
$ 186.00
.. + Y ... , . Y «
'Task 16 Prepare rwYnistratiVe
Admi i
: 4 :Hours
s . =
S 200.00
Drafk Silt ,
,.:xY ♦ i...'..= i Y « 2 Hours • . .
$ 120.00
Subtotal Labor 1.
_ • .� .• Y ,• 3 . i ....1. '.Y Y , i . . « » a ♦ '1 r • . .. i
137S Hours
$5,009.00
"(PENS,$
`TxaVei Expenses
y . , ,
y •.. Y •, Y. , Y n. V, L i a Y Y F. Y
PhotocopyingY • , 4 • .:
S 23.39
P7o$iage Y.. ,.Y: 4=,;: ,y«. •Y. ..Y
95.80
i ell�one' y i. ♦ . : : 4 . Y Y
Y$
L7'
. ; . Y Y Y
CompUterJVVordprocess Y `
S 11.63
g `Time , Y ..
Ytldtzuiusttation @ • • 4 • • . Y .:.. Y . '. 4 .
S�{ 1
♦ L ': . i . Y Y, . i • Y . 4 n , ..:.. Y W i . Y i' r « . . : Y =
d 38.54'23,x3.0
.Subtotal Ex�tnses . Y Y . Y , , , Y i , • ... , 'Y. a s♦ i G Y i i Y i..y. Y 4:• Y.♦ • 4
4' Y.,• % Y Y«
_
S i,,jj
}2Y99�
-
Total This Invoice
Y
fioW Outstanding
4 Y 4 b
• 4'. t s . .. 1 1 4.» i, �4 .. a .'.,Y . 4. W r x 4 .....• s .. Y t y: 4
4 4 4 1 1.» 4• •
1i.
TOTAI, NOYY
bV - 4Y.. r.f:Y♦ Y.YY x
...
$5,432.99
a7ichacl G« �ayioq
d'
Michael Clayton 3c Associates
bate
3;'64 M- radise Drive
Suites
Corte 4ladeta, CA 94925
X113 wy�.1b191
ayn y A`C OI 7
GU}l�T �io. �91i�1�11tj i✓'CifttfS•
December ?3, 1933
Caliiomta
M4- Dura Tuttle
l
Butte County Planning Depa:ctment
County Center 7 County Center Drive
Oroville, C.4, 95965
Rei E ergy, Natural Resources, .and Recreation General Plan Element,
C-&Ik Job No. 33004
Professional
Services
Invoice No. J
Billing Period: November 1 through November 30, 1983
-------------
1ABOR
Talk 4 Citizen Advisory Committee
....: L i .... i • ...
Task 3 Conduct Agency Consultation Data
2.0 Hours ..
S 120.00
and Collection
T 11 Progress/Update Nfeetin gsReports
1,0 Hours i
; $ 20,00
Task 12 .. i . L . i • . ..
Advisory Committee iVfeetia *
• 13.5 Hours i
. S �6?:00
...:
Task 15 Prepare Admin.istrats'e DtS'Eiement ` f . •
14.0 Hours •
. S 624:00
..
Task ,16 ...... r ..
Prepare Administrative Draft EIR
• 36S Hours
S4131,00
... , i .. i .
9.5 ,Hours
Subtotal Labor
, .. • . � ;
• ... �
i . i ;, . . tip';. . f • . L . : • . . : :: i ._
76.5 Hours i �
:S3,96100
MCFENSFS
/Parking
Weaen.
i� Photo-copyingi
( �
S 77.5,00V0
r r f i i .
Postagea• i :y i i ♦ •. i s r f• •. i
S 33 .00
.. i i. a'_a i i . d 1 i i
_. Teleph Vne-_:.. i
Yl. .i+.70
_ _
_ _ _
• ! sf i • • y.
Admidstrahon g101u21
- • Y Y ;L ♦ i a i 'I f••• i '1 n. Y f •. a i. a!: i. i
.J._ 15
Subtotal .E•�rpenses .
, ::.a..lr .: #.LiiL. . i.L.f h:, i'i!♦
y
1466
TOW This .It voice
A TOL4 Outstanding i �'k • , i ,: • i L . } i a „
, , . i
-X3,1505.66
TOTALS NDUE
.iii♦ :L•a L'6•aw•a'L• •a:
Ntichael G. C yton
Michaet Clayton &i ttociates
Dake:
C CbS 4� �i.il ora. CA 9V2
41 u2-, O1jgj
f
_
n r
-M adClay
��,.�».� n �+�"���{�«�v�Mr ar•Ga,�� �+��.iti,� ,r,-�.�;rr��,..� r w��r�s�,y
October 7, 199,E
,Mr. 'Dave Hironimus
J3utte County pltanning Dept►rtment
rC'.ounty Center
I County Center Drive
Droville, CA, 95965
Jia:: Energy Natural Resources, and, Recreation General Z1lan Element, Professional Services
NMC&A. Job No. 88004
Statement
ContractAmount %i...{ ....Y�.i. .'.{%. i. Y.
$1231990,00
`Total billings, payable up to AnJ inclltr�rnj; ARAIII i1�c;
contract Value perSection� �t"_ompenstation'paragraph 2g
of "t�c►nsuitant's Alrt;cnient Cor sul�mott`��i�` �l tt��,... � , i % i . i 4.: i ..',. i , Y i � ., ,
$lf)0;431.9Q
. Amount P,44. to ✓4t6 ! i M Y Y Y Y i �i Y K, la ♦:' Y i{ Y Y W 1 i 1, i•. {.{ i• Y{% i'. l i
94,,2.40
7'OTA1 Ac1►{SUiJN'I' DUE
f$00,41m-- S94AAbi
6,19960
cc
=fir
mea trey t-" on
Opera( hana .
titutl Clattt�i Sc Associates
CrL,%ad ;
I
.
161 g:q���l OttatYl�, Suite 2M
415 883.9211
FAX 41.4
J
Dep'artt
b.
Revising of dr'aftelement to a proposed final
element. The draft' element shall be _revised as
necessary to reflect the comments and concerns of
the Planning Director, officials of state 'and local
agencies, the' Planning Commission,; Board of
supervisors, citizen advisory committee and general
public., The Planning' Director shall review and
approve an administrative copy of the final element
prior to consultant printing the number of final
elements required by Section 5d. Consultant shall
any
make an changes to the element de erred appropriate
by the Department.
2. Preparation
of Draft and Final EIR:
a.
Preparat" Ein accordance the
law;i of,thestateafof California, the Calith
forma
Environmental Quality Act Guidelinesi Butte County's
Guidelines, and the work set
tzhibit , attached t hereof by hereto andro 'made
andde a par by
teference. The. Planning Director shallreview and
approve an:';administrative copy of the Draft EIR
prior to Consultant printing the number of Draft
EIAs required in section 5g. Consultant shall make
any changes to the Draft EIR deemed appropriate by
the Planning Department. ;
c.
Preparation of the response to comments generated
during the public review period and public hearing
held on the Draft EIR. The Planning Director shall
revise!- - and app; ove Consultant's responses ttj
comme;ats prior to Consultant making appropriate text
revisions. - ti-
c.
Revising of Draft EIR to a proposed Final EIR. The
proposed Final EIR shall, consist of the Draft EIR,
comments and rF,ommendatians received on the 'Draft
EIR either verbatim or in summary,, a list of
p ns, orani dations, and public. acenr_ies
g
On thE Draft EIR
CbmmentinQ mmethe donsultaht'S
r �
responses to significant, environmental p&,,nts r�I,ised
in the review and consultation process, and all
minutes of all public, hearings through certification
of the Final EIR.
3. Coordination of Citizen Involvement:
a.
The consultant will be re tionsible for snaking
recommendations on the composition and structure of
the. citizen advu`..sory 'committee, sta.ffitj and
t,
conduc„ g cAC meetings, provid- monthly (o� more
r
freguen ) w.itten progress repo. is to the. CAc, and
incidental osta e'and
P 9 printing casts.
b .
The consultant will be responsible for conducting
element workshops with the CAC eneral p ublic,
Planning Commission. and Board of Supervisors,
A. Attendance at three public hearingsincl7ading
responsibility for presentation of draft and final
element and EIR content to decision-making bodies as
directed by t,ie Punning Director Consultant to attend
all
meetings deemed necessary by the Planning Director.
All
public hearings beyond three requiring Consultant Is
presnce will be charged on a time and materials basis.
�5 Number of copies requiredto be submitted by consultant,:
a.
Four (4) copies of the administrative draft element
as accepted by the Planning Director.
b.
(75) copies - of the Draft Element as
accepted
accepted; by the Planning ;DiE:c.t4r
c,
Four (4) copies of the Administrative Final Element
as accepted by the Planning'Director.
d.
One hUndred 100 co ies
Pof the Fin'aa Element as
accepted by the Planning ;Directt)r.
el,
Four (4,) copies of the Initial study as accepted by
the -Planning- Director,ir
f •
Ebur 4 copies of the Aaminstz:a �; vp Draft ET R as
accepted 'bythePlanning Di.rector.l
g,
Seventy-five (75) copies of the :'Draft. ETR as
accepted: by the `Planning Director.
h.
Three (3) copies of the, to comments and
si gr env ronmentctl points raised in- the
review and consultation 'process, and any revisions
t ereof.
I .,
One Hundred l00 copies of the Final En as define:cl
t ) p
in Section 2tc, as ceztif,ted by the butte co uaty
;Board of Supervisors
W
One l) copy of the final. Element acid'YR i,n. Word'
Perfect and Lotus l"Z -3 (if' applicable) on a $ 1./'4"'
floppy, disc from an IBM -compatible computer,
3 ''
7.,
�n a,
6,
a cs
Gz
d P hi
Maps and diagrams will be prepared for all inventoried
reisources, constraints andproposedlocation of
[ facilii.ies All graphics in the documents will be of
professional quality and reprocduci,ble.. Graphics,will ',fie
orae of three sizes , 8 1/2" x 1111, 11" x' 1;►" 36 x 36"
All original graphics will be cone at full ss ze with ink
of mylar. Black and white reproducible, `camera-ready art
i' work will include 66% black information on a screen
7 Binding
All documents except the initial study and responses to
comments to be submitted in 3 ring binders with tab
dividers. .Binders to be. clearly ,labeled on the front Find
spine with title, date, consultant and county. Element
and EIR to be submitted in szpazate binders,
s. Information to be Furnished bf the PI a fining birecto.e : the
Manning Director s ibrar;y resources and
ann 5 ha mace avaa abb�l
file material of a public, nature as may be ;regUe8ted by the
Consultantt. The County is not responsible for generating ;any
information,. data compilation,, ter anal��sis for the
consultant's use in preparing the element or E 1,R,,,
C. Time of Performance: The services of consultant, are to
commence the aay o lowing signature of the contract by the
Roazd of Supervisors and shall be undertaken and completed in,
such sequence as to assure their expeditions comple'tion'in
light of the purpose of this cd,:ntract. In any, event,
Consultant shall comply with the foi.lowing:
1. r ( ) p f the initial study shall be completed
andsubmittedito the County Plaitiing Department nol later
than Angus -L 16, 1588.
co
Four (4) y of the administrative draft element s011
2, ,
be comply ea .hing
Department no later thanDecemb�.r ar.men. 16 1986.
p ���and submitted �o the Caunt P].anr
3. Four administrative, draft 1s. I jR. s shall be rrompleteu
and submitted to the County P16ha ng Department no later
thG►h January 13 1989.
Section A.l.a. above, shall be completed and siibmitted to
the county Planning bepr rtment r10 later tb,aILI �7ahuary 0 ;
4
' S, 'Section ,A.2 above, shall be eomple� and sub fitted to
1988. g p no later"than pebruary 1'�-
t e Count F annin De artment
5 5ectibil A.l.b.a ..: Sectidn A -2-C. above, shall be
compl6ted and submitted to the county planning Debartment
no tothan 15 calendar days after the Planning
p
Director
has reviewed and acceted the administrative'
final element and administrative final E.I.R.
Extension,
f Time --y, for good cae.
... us,. request:
Extensionons ��f Tme•ime to perform the services re ir,
qu ed under
Sections,A and C above. Such extensions which are .mutually
agreed upon by and between County and Consultant shall be
,incox�orat�.d J_ written amendrne:nts to this contract and
attached work program.
F.. Liquidated DamaOOs a The County and Consultaizt agree that time
is of 'the essence Further, it is understood that in case all.
the work Galled for under the agreement i;7 not finished or
completed within the number of working days contained herein,
damage will. be sustained by the. county, and that it is and
will be difficult and ;impossible to ascertain -and determine
the actual damage which. County will sustain in the wvent of
and bY reason of such delay. It is, therefore, agreed that
Consultant shall pay County the sum of $50.00 per day ft3r each
and every business; day (Monday through Friday, ext:lud.ing
holidays) delay in 'AFnishing the work in excess of the number
of working days pre^.cribed herein. Consultant agrees to pay
liquidate' damci�ges as herein rovided-
�-uch li p and in cc;�e .the
same is not paid, agrees that County may deduct the amount
therea-AE fr,am any money due or that may become due to
Consultant under this agreement
r . Combensatioh i
The County shall pay Cc,nSultant ,as compensation in full.,
for all services performeei by Consultant. pursuant _ tip tris
agreement:, the sum of $121,31,950.
2 0 Contract compensation will be paid by the County bas;e"' an
hours„of work performed
It the rates per hour desdzibed
in the schedule of fees included herein. Said amouilts
shallbis pais monthly, with 'the following holdbacks ,until
�d p 7 p eted if necessary:
schedult_a ro. ects are ccam 1`
a T1.otal billings in. excess of 15� of the contract
amourt shall be withheld until the initial study it
submititied
b Total billings in ekdess of 40% of the ctntract
ra
= n
said eases, and after° the or EIR isbroughnto
compliance with theWement
ourt order, any
remaining balance ofthe10% shall be paid to the
Consultant.
3.
All payments due Consultant pursuant to the terms of this
contract and specified acceptances by the planning
director shall be paid upon receipt of an invoice which_
itemizes hours expended, personnel costs and material
costs.
4.
All payments clue consultant pursuant to items E.2.b.
through F.2.g. are subject to the successful completion
cif the previously desc7' ibed task: (lit.) Payment of
F.2 i:. shall not be due until F.2.b. has been
successfully completed„
G. 978rrail.
1.
nnsultatit warrants that he has the expertise or has
experts a#vailetble, to help him in, the preparation of said
element a ad, EXA in a wprkmanlike mance?:, Consultant
agrees that Wits key per`gnnel shall not be replacbd or
reassigned to other duties w„Athout prior Written app;i;oval
I
of County. :;uch approval shell riot be untdasol:tably
withheld.
2.`
Consultant further warrants that he will, prepave a
legally adecauate final element incompliance with
California State Law, GeneralPlan Guidelines,; California
%nergy Cor[unission Grant to Butte Coy;nty 1986, the ,'IRFP;
and scope. of services. Sf, the adequacyof said ele'hent
is legallychallenged, Consultant agreeto promptly make
m
oa.,.,. fications in, thefinal element required by the court
or that. _ are-, deemed advisable -by the Planning Director, or -
County Cou�bsel to comply with: State law, or reimburse the
County for: , the reasonable cost of such modif,,a,.ation, in
which cage the County shall have the right to retain
another consultant to make Said modification.
3
Consultant furthe. warrants that he will prepare a
legally adequate'Vinal EZR that. addresses all potentially
siani:Eicant environmental issues in oom bliance with CE;QP
and as outlined in. the scope of setvid8ti if the
adequacy of said ER is legally challenged; Consultant
agrees to promptly make modification's in. tf1,F Final EIA
required by the Court, or than are deemed adv.si�ble by the
Planning Director 'or County Counsel to romiil.y, wit�, CC�Q�k,
or reimburse the County ;for the re�so:nable costs o't sac€h
modification in Which case the County shall have the
right to reta.z another consultant to mace said
7
x
I
modl-fication
4 • If the Planning D�.:rectnr be mes aware of new info
through the
public hearing process rmation
the element or certification of prior to ,adoption of
requires additional technical the final ETR which
the scope of work outlined' Studies above ana beyond
in
consultant shall provide such this contract, the
c e r satate a, a time and materials basis as
the studies and will be
mate and charge schedule outlined on
contras-t, %ncc�rpora ed in this
Termination of Contract-
14 Either r part ma . to
giving the yother par.�Yat�Stdas�agreement at any time by
termination. Y written notice of such
satis',lc,,arily completed r shall be paid for
ll
said termination. Prior to the effeotiveadateork
of
2.
If Contractor shall voleite
provisions of this agreefient, County of the terms or
to terminate this agreement. y Shall have the right
County # s written notice the eoff ective �.. a
event, a.11, finished or immedia1.tely upon
to Con-tactor. In such
studies, and reports unfinished documents, data,
contract shall at the Prepared by Consultant under this
become Count 0s option of the Planning Director,
entitled to recej. ejperty, and Consultant sha11 r
any satiswast and equitable c��mpensa tiara for
Notwithstanding-factory work performed on such
tie, above, Consultant documents.
relieved of ' liability shall not be
the Count `' to County for damages sustained by
y by virtue of an
Consultant, unci County M. breach of the contract by
ultant until such time as the exact antountpayments to
du esCaunty from Consultant is Ar Gama es
determinEtd . .g
Changes:
The parties hereto ma b
Yr g
p y mutual written a redmetit
ce forth hereinabove in r�-ices or the �znount of co
n athe Scope of the se
this agreement compensation
P
e
d Subcontractin Consultant shad be as fully
Count a resp
of Y the acts and omiss4ons of his sttbontractoib3.e to
he it forstile1ac s aii�deetx or indirectl a them
and
Y y mployea b ahem
Y
by him; missions of pets°ns directly employ ed
Assi�rnabil..t%y
su consultant shall of as'
s agreement or an" sign,, transfer or
prior, w�: itten donsent of the CoUh merest therein without the
,r
'Corwri_ght • t)
din wha Pots
pr!= -7'c ce - Na e y maZ�s , r�acuimen
or part under 'r'?ther the
Subject to an application fo;r co th,,.s reeinen`t shall be
Consultant. P:Yrg!it by or on behalf of
? Indemnification: Consultant shall
�iarm ess t e ounty. indemnify, defend and >ho;d
and against ahy and alltclziimsc m
• agents and employees from..
i expenses of whatever na nature, i
ands'• liability, costs and
tees arising out of injury'toiorlceath ofuan costs and counsel
of or damage to any pro _.y persons or loss
Willful acts pert y restaltin
or negl.�,genr_e of g- in any manner from the
employees, licensees or Co=nsultant, its �sgent;s,
this contract, maki�zg or perform;tnce Of
guests in the
.. IndeDendeni. Cantrac`or;
{ = Coun The Consultant is not an employee of
contracto be classi:Eied as an end
r ,� an §ha 1
e?endent
,• Proect Representative;
des 9nate a Consultant
i
Project representati and County shall, each
responsible for coordinating the _e who
Part, with regard to the per"forma shall be totally
(forts or the respective
under tYi3s agreement .
nee oaf the work as set forth
shah be i4ichael Prod ect represEantative
Clayton; and for Consultant
County shall ae Laura Tuttle. r project p
re re�entati`ve for,
changed upon the P.,otiect representative may be
Consultant,.
mutual agreement of the County and
Fx Interest Of -----___ _ Consultant: Consultant
preect Ot"FFias nc interest and shall :not, accxui e
director indirect aUvenants that. he
ot':er interest �. • in the ,Pro j ect 6' ' thy: r any interest,
With the w.�ich Mould conflict in P yject Area �e any
perfox'manc,e of his services an matuier Yo grk
fUrther covenant.a that in the hereunder.
pe`rforcttance of this contract, t no
having any such ;Enter
person V
mployed
twindin-as confiaantial:
` s c shah... be i
at,e prepare or assembled) b°f the r'ports information and
y C
are coal: nt a' y shalt
idential and Consults onsu�tant under this contract
made available tc an arees tha:j; the
prier written a s .g t� on with not be
y iizai,v`dual or oa ar,;iz,a
pproval of the Planning' DiI.- : , r ou ., the
treach of Agreement:
In, the event that either Cou,
by, the other my is
Coneemen r Brea
V su tans shat - at an time or. time waive any ch
acr
Waiver of an ,�,�h waiver shalt not con
of this
Whether of
st� tti-, a
Obligation.,theo sauce; Cdr uanyedo the breach of this.: agreement ,..
r co en.�n4, c6hditioh 6r
S,y Non i_ scrim%a on clause
9
♦4
F—U-TBIT A
r�
SCOPE OF wot,,K
`ERS•TANbINNG OF'I� REQ
LJPID UlCpjZI) SERVIt�
In response to the RFI'
suhmtted by'$uue
Proposal 'tor the Ener County, "Michael C:ayton �: Assoaaces
Energy, Natural Resources and Recreation Element of the County has Prepared a
o plett4 this comprehensive documentwill
guideline for the implementat'on of the countv�erve as the foundation ng range
General plan. When
s energy, resource and long range g
ti objectives and Policies, Our approach to f open spat; and recreation goals
informative and instructio project
with a clean P J be to Provide a document which:'
ufficient flexibility to allow for iads`vidual Y written text and an easiltr used format. It u both
Policies to resolve interpretation, while will Contain
ceynfIict and establish loa ran a also providing
g g Planning, directive realisstic� eaforce ble
s.
loping a comprehensiveoli
P ry document of this nature is a coal le
components and tasks. One of the r .
Policy or,ented land use do moat important skills our P t PrO-ess, mvolving;a variety of
cumeats. Our firm has offers is a fanii(arity with large
and Gcncrzl plan Elements boeh from an ' =ensive experience in wormi
m=house l g on Genrral Plans
such, we can work c;ently with Butti Court planning and consultant's perspective. As
-' pr"tical and consistent policy lam County and mtergoverruAental ageneses and
zesolve long range (ted use confli gunge,ovativb solutions, and re can Provide
cis. Past experience has alistic miti,garion measures to
services required and the process involved in fa given our firm a clear understanding
extensive ,ezperience in re a'litating legislative ,pct oa. F of the
preparation ,and certification preparing
pro�ammatic environmental -ther, we have
the project's Eavironin,etital analyses' which will �zreatiy expedite the
Paramount in our approach to the preparation of Impact Report
this General Plan Element is the development of a
document that: l) complies wick al(Sta[e,
wide olicies and re mandated requirements; 2) is compatible W16
develo e •comprehensive+ ons and 3) u easy to use and understand To accomplish P �t document similar in format to the "~��;.sting County-
internally consistent withexisting Butte Cour' we will
involve a thoroughall General Plan and Cour ty General Plan and
the Butte County revip.w of all pertinent documeII incluain the and policies. This wM
General P • g the Elements that presently coin '
�ieveIopment policies and standards. tt}s Anse
Zoning and' Subdivision ordinances, .
the Cour dinances, and all relative
Canformance with State mandated requirements foz the preparation of
guaranteed through close communication with ally a General P
adoption process,` Inti Element will be
1'lis wfil:include the Office o fp esPoasble agencies involved in the review and
Government Affairs,ahe California ,» 1 ng.and ResezL
rnia =ergy commission. and the Stat the state Office of Local
'M be maintained with "the State's General F
gouse. Strict adherence.
and Development Laws, and the _ Guidelin
C, California Common Law, Planning, ?_o
+ • amental
assessment and docuarentauon wi11 heo Quality Act '�8
Prepararioa of'aa ' and r {CEQA). Environmental
Initial Stuff y, Adaun�strau" Draft EI' pDraftnatic in supe and will involve the
the rdeat�Eieation of appropriate an f �' Draft EIR, and Fina.( EM This
court decisions re&at feasible matis;atirn i.�eeasures find the will include
titin r t "cent interpretations af' CE dari6cation of pertinent
G.� to ensure a legally defensible document.
9o�bl, dmitse p aIan in age sand use policv
Planning process is Butte Co dues Will be a viable and fate al
P urtt�- ;As su it 3r part of the
otenttal of many Propcm owners. �'' will effect the rights and development:.
This could result in sia�t'chan
and land development patterns, Therefor geS ur Butte Co►lnty
Work closely with County s � the pot ` ` . , policies,
P ental ensts for public controversy and v+e �vijl
the • taff to encourage ppbLc
Punning' process, Our t , cxteas(vc PartraPadon and ,inter agency totitrt`bution early in
controve Cam .has experience in wnrltta
Presentations, and developing Practical g'with tilt ubl
rsv and lana use docujtents.. F G Making Public
. problems,
Productively to idenily issues and establish re + . `
This exper:cnce enables us Louse pubj1e
to dtfiicultroblcats. F'
and with rstiZdns , urthero our experience;in livor " •.listic and workable to
grog P( • g �g oft General Plans
adva►tinge of.krinwin Ps' annin Commissions and Boaras ofSit a and General P .
p rvisors Elements
g how to la
dill legislative acddc�, , ivcs us the distinct
It is also Important that the
aPphtion to the General Plan Element full'! the re
C�orn(a Energy Commission 5itiu quiremcnts set to, by Butte
County's
g and Permit fl3ststance Program, Specitically,
r
2A KEY ISSUES
'This section will briefly discuss several issues that are key to the development of the new General'
Plan Element. Thesc issues are both topical and process, This list is nor All inclusive but is
representative of those areas.of major importance:
ZA Enr-rgy
'
The County Board of Supervisors, through a grant from the California Energy Commission. has
authorized the, preparation of an Energy Element !hat incorporates energy, natural resources, open
sP a- and recreaclon, tato one collective element. Most jurisdictions in the state t31at presently
have Energy Elements focus on the energy user, primarily from an energy conservation perspective.
In Butte County, there are numerous potential sources of energy production in the region, including
hydroelectric, biomass, cogeneration, wind, and solar. Altho=h energy conservation willbe addressed:
in the, Butte County. Energy Element, the Element will look at energy predominantly from a
productionpoint of view, focusing on potential energy growth.
The primary purpose of the Energy Element is to provide for efficient use of existing naturai
resources through logicaland balanced land, use planning, This will include idendlication of energy
proOuction options, while providing sufficient background information and perspective to enable
i decision -masters to make informed land use: decisions involving complex and conErover"Itsum, The
Element will also serve to inform "the publir :.,ld potential project developers as to the location of
p energy g ' ,s, and spedic mitigations and development standards to be expected.
otentlal ener generation SI[r
-
Preparation of the dF,,.ruerz�t�3..:EEw.�l
t> maseunte-will
ill require
, brief
r^„ohistory,
ehsfu energy d
evelpm
en, dinveWoryof existing and potential �xereysources m the County, location,seam'and
nent
potentiai ower. So of nerdt11 inrocogaeron,�zbdv4 ,1%ona idt
projects such
w
as PG&E's propoted
coal-fired power plant, and the Orov ile-Wyandotte SmgationDi-taices proposal to divert water for
`. hrdroelectricplan,', Once the locations of potential energy
the development of the Rock Creek p P p g
somms have been es"tablLh-� a cumulative im act analysis wt�l be re aced addressin the physical,
social and economic effects that can be experted in Butte rounry as the result of energy
develdmuent.
- 22 Natural. Resources
The adoption of a comprehensive Natural Resource; Element will be ont of the most sig cant'
factors shaping development in Butte Cot:nty. It will be tkfe to used to implement many of the
land use policies established by the various elements of the Crlsntv's General Plan: As such, it will
involve coniroversialtssues requwing nnoVativt� solitdnns SppcifittaIIy, The: Natural Resource
Element will set the standards for where and how urn -urban land should be developed in Butte
County, or eonvexsely, where and how land should t dt be developed. It evill establish the specific
polldie: dictating the densities .and types of deveIopxja��nt allowed within a major area of the Countyt
and will set the Suindards pertaintng to the specMe zoning of all of the County's open space,
agricultural land, timber and forests, mimral resources, hazard zones, and culturally sensitive areas.
Yt Will 6etore be a rueful tool in solving current land use conflicts: rt will also aid the Planning
Wwon acid Board of Supervisor in making coinistent and sound long angc land use dedstous,
ll as help the individual land owner understand land use regulations pertaining to his or her
Property,
,Dytci• Hcrd l'o "ufR atiori.
Ong: of the most sensitift topics to l,e addressed by the Natural itesource Clement will be the
potential impacts of land development on the area"s deer herd population. 'Past I. -did use. activitirs
have negatively effected the tiger's t?ta tory corridor, '�7evelopment in the foothills and niountain
areas has reduced the deer's winter range, and has rest, Itted..suminer range atcess, The Departmelit
of F sh ,tied Csamr, has prepared a reg oaal policy guidtIne for development to the deer herd range,
1-6
1
t,
i
www
.. _ mon�-�..1LniCn
The current Butte COULitYReCle3tlOa o'
new combined Element will ` t was adopted in
1eQ eationat lariiates. Sp aay.factors that dire 1971 and is in need of revision, The
involve m
Y, this �Y relate to recreation or ,
riparian zones, .forests, opens ace wall include issues Pertinent to ri assocateif
fog on lOn P iZsid'in general, all public lands. ,lakes► reservoirs,
3 range recreation planning and �� s'mclud�zxwe coon The Recreation component will
Cities and the, County to ensure ince
include: neighborhood coasutencv. The s tion °with there '
�.hborhaod, community,, and re, specific issues Of `�°$ s incorporated,
res„rvoirs• oral cora ; jrs_and art gxonal ;state and federal aroacera to be addressed`
Parks
e re creno as; scenic routes; and private, re r campgr°tmd and
eational facilities.
.Although a Recreation �Ieme>xt is identified
required Open Space Element identifies as an optional clement under Stue General Plan
Recreation element. Specificalj issices that would a Law, the
Private arks Y,.Ihis will involve a PPrssessm ly be incatpor2ted into a
P and recreational facilities qualitative
Poses. 111s Will include: and an mveato essment of the den•.sud for public and
..,ry of areas s '
citable for parks and recreational
q A description of the •
tYPC, location, and size o� existin
rccreatiotia.l facilities; g Pubiic and
Private Park:; and
o An assessment of Present and fu pazk
lure de
�►, w;
trails, and lake, acct ; •, p ca ds for s.,, ..rid Per and x�.� >'eatzonal,facs,t�;; , a xt
P PAY ofparks {acresj'ti Www, vs �� �,dic
Ca�cOL`f omire .Park and recreation sites,•
o,
° A review of feller n lo..,.l
' aI, state an ' ..
° i a plaitis for the acgiusitioa and improvement °f public
n .ia�t►.. �.td ai3+sts of areaslands;
o pr of outstanding scenic Of
Agra ms for proteczio
o nr conservation and acquisition of open
The identification of ou sPa d lands;'
ding scenic, ' toric, and cultural values;
o The identification
tstaa � his
of opCV space for public heal
regulation because of th and safety the re y
hard or special conditions q e Special
a end the ide mann
gement or
"'
nr,r,cation of the dernand for trail=
ecific standards '�il.l be developed to • , t al use,
24 QuSciby Act,.feet, pzovide a
oriented recreation•
Geaoral mala Cone; defensibl a 'jasas %r e'si1-i6lis
hment of
71,e concept 61112terng
COns3ste ,
exist, either to meal or • - used is California i,latwing
Fasergy, Natural
R. between between the romponca Law, means, stmt no Policy pry and R.eceauon MCment general P P . conQi
General plan; l't will will be ` The Butte
that defin
be patt;,of c lust one of;sevezaitat county
es regioDaliland use olid C°'uprehensivc City County, elements in the Noun s
that aic easuy undP P es., In order to provide Cohesive and ca Brenre
t p� tO dti
.ratodd and enforce,abl, it tY Process
causistent,;Rravi*p:.s`n , ' makers �' essential that cctiy
dcnM-�, all land use documents be `
B aeWsion v-th au ince
-..••s p'- "tie baserL Fated and comprchensivc basis oa "'Which hind u;
The new $I ith will similar, in format to the
consistent with all Gen ��$ Butte
thoraugli ' eral P1aiti Eizmen County,General p
review of . pertinent &Cumea 'County ardtuances and ptjudes, �' and internally
County General pl ts, mcludin This will involve a
• tits, the County', . g the Elements that presentl
nes and standards. It and SUbdivi,ion or ' Y comprise the Butte
M PoL will atSo l quire a reweW of rxistin , and al) telative Bevel'
g uicorporated $t'tteCour pment
ty Cities'