The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About90-1 REZONE PLANNING 1 OF 299-07-03-''l, 90-I PRO�T _<STTMiYiARY' S"HEST T..ag: �Z�Fila YC. Timothy & Ruth Davis applicr_nC ADDRESS: 5159 Eden: Road Paradise, C.X 95959 n=c a77-2774 representative Same ADDRESS' -- Rezone from: U to FR -5• P K � vn property --e st — located or, Calernbar Rd. ,d south of Wayland Rd., Ivincr v 'T_- ` Rd - 55-3 -102 Paradise idencxiied as fiG town/area: GENLRALE zrav DESIGNATIONAgricultural.-Residential Fp_..z^r rr c PTD:: ' =i i5' 11-0 0 0 REaIPT MMER: 10845 APPLICA ION,ACCEPIM ;: ECTAL AFP. PAID: RECEIPT MISER REZ— C'q ;v PEZTI01 SIGMAI= a[ ;CKFD' PERCEMG-: / MA_n TMG .i'IST PR=FARM MAM-OiM NOTICES W-9MF�Y NOMC SS MAILED LEGAL DEc .TPT Qti PMEPARED PUBLICATION: NOTICENMI= MWER. 12 DISPLAY AD PREPARED' 10WSPA..°E" FiBLICATION 0 C 9 G B'. it DATE OF AMLICATION "NiMAL. SMD`L PREPARED FWITROylMTAL D=—.4I tAIICK: Categorical Exemption; 1 Neg.— ve Declaration S tigaced Negative Dacla x-_ri; n Environmental I=act;Report. FILED: FILED: =liD i C...7IiF_ED : Othar: VFiZCANr`:�PRE,"`EMAX::C'E `IOTL=_T=1O:t OF `VI.R05� it D€i-_iMLkFA_: O.''3 :I' a:NI.Y'G C.^. MISSIC M .RTD G s /O' �1 tib 4 • 'GIC csx,,t s � Af.i�' f FOAP.D OF SU?_-MvrSCRS' :x'r- K.iG(st RsSOUMITC NULSER. (G?Aa) ADOPTED: NO= OF :,.L'.sL'R1,MTA1!C x t'Appendix H) FILE July )1989 zo J�Ly; �g News: 9-2-0 , s�cf Public. -?-a'57 IA 10. Report to the Board Timothy and Ruth bavis denied rezone from "U" (unclassified) to PR -5 (foothill recreational: - 5 acre parcels), property located just West of Cal.ernba:l Road, south of Wayland Road,, approXimately one mile. south of the Foster and Wayland road intersection, also known as 4496 Calernbar Rosd� Paradise - i'►ction requested INFORMATION ONLY I BUTTE COUNTY b0ARb or 8tPtAV18098 MINUInS AVOUST 29 � 1. 85 77, 17 1112(7,IIiC"1' 401I "m „1TV and i'utlj_Ds33Z1c rcr44R9r07-��3-01 ,55-37 1.02 AP 11 90-1 ff 717 Cl;i1' {Z.`vici—( WIT Y s ►;rte Acton �M� Timothy and Ruth_ Davis - proposed ,Negat1ve'Dec Iaration regarding environmental impact and Rezone from "U (Unclassified) to FR -5 i(Foothill Recreational 5 acre parcels) Located on Calernbar Road, approximately 3/4 mile south of Wayland road; lying east of Neal road; Identified as Ap o55 -37-0-102p i'arad 1 >e . The Commission Waived the reading of the Staff findings.. Staff said this would be a single parcel of FR -5 zoning If approved and would be considered spot zoning. „ha.lrman Lambert noted for the record correspondence from Mr. and Mrs .. Ster l I ng I n favor of the 1-6�zon,e. The hearing was opened tCi the public Ruth oav is react a deme � r��a l of Y`sC�property values, t h'I ues;She said that property rights an at the Sterling's also Want to qo o a 5 acre zoning In -the future. She said she would I!ke to ,,*gipIlt her I acres Into two parcels and "sell the second half. She said she already has; a buyer for the property: She spa I d she; he;us good so I l With 300 f t . of leachllnes. She said Foster Is her main access road. She sa`,d as far as Police and fire prot�sct I on are: concerned; it Is better If there are more residences in an area. She sa1d they hab�e a 5130 ft. well with good water' and will spilt the well with the people that buy the other parcel. She said tier chi I dren go to a Private school and the chIIdren of the other farn..11y W;III ga to a private school as Wd I I She gave cop l es of a book e"t►t{ i t i; ed "America In prophecy" and -.:;,aI d thel •M i me Is com 1 ng when peep i ,G will need -to be able t:o grow tine i r own food Commissloner Matson asked If itArs. baVis Was 1lving on the property. Mi -s. DAVIS said they 8Lre p i aCYn (n, °rt moving 'there In September Comm lss lover ostrowsk l 'as It d, 9 I' this project a l to Was In the: south Phrad Ise Rezone arab, staff said this 1s correct. SttAff said the Commils'slon has recommended 20 acre zoning for this area. The hearing 'Nat closed com m i s.s i o,erer Matson said he Was notI n favor- of th i s�zon l ng . He said tjjh�4 commission should either defer this, heathuntil the c i t i 7uhs Advisory Committee mattes l t.n re6ornmel1dat i Ott 1 oi- Deny the Vit', COU�V y 'PLANNtNO 'CC1r+lCyf18 abN MIl!itT 8413_ - Al qw.'t 10 t M I:JR3 _ da .0 �,..t..�....._�_�.�� r......_..��.�c.��...,:�.�,c��:�t��iirrl�o��l��ll�♦fl'✓�i1119��h�� Staff said the Advisory reserve Policies, Committee met yesterday to Work on ,the p Wiz, not the zoning. Staff said the Urban reserve policies will not change the character of the area as far as the recommended z!an I ng . Chairman Lambert asked If the project were approved, the applicant would not be under any of the requirements if an Urban reserve was estabilshed, Staff said the urban reserve required that any time a subdivision map Is flied they would have to adhere to Urban reserve policies, It woUId be Predicated on how fast they worked on the urban reserve policies, 1-10 said if the Commission wants 5 acre densities at this loraLlon, the Commission could do that at this time and at the time of the subdivision they would be Under the urban reserve policies If adopted at that time. Chairman Lambert said she Was not willing to approve this rezone and the Commission should Walt for a dei Ion on the+ South P',aradise Rezone and the eecommendatlor`� from f -he Advisory Committee, Commissloner Lynch said t -he Commission needs direction from the Board on what to do with property In the Interim Commissioner Forbes said 'that if the Commission C(5htlnues this open it would save the applicant addltlortai fees, Chairman Lambert asked If the Commission was holding the South Paradise Rezone waiting for a response from the Advisory Committee and staff said this was correct. COMmissIones Lynch discussed the MaIntenance of Wayland Road. Staff noted that Calernbar Roan 1:s a dead end road. Staff also noted that the 'sown of paradise has prezohed this area for to acre parcels. It Was moved by Commissioner Matson, seconded by Commissloner LYhchj and Unanimously tarried to deny this project as follows: A4 Find that the regU l cements of the iCa l I fornl a rn, i ronmenta l Quality Act have bcteh completed. sand B . F l nd that the 'propooed FR6.6 ,zoning i=egUes ted does riot meet the conditional zoning and developmOht criteria as outlined by the. Butte County General glary due to the lack of evidence indicating adequate Water and seWage disposal capacities,, availability of eidegUate fire Protection f'ac l l l'- l e!s, and capacity to6�►ervicedtheparea; anrlroad access with sufficient C, Deny the eetdne regUest of FA -6 :ion l ng On AF 66-87,101 t;-lmothy and Ruth Davit), BUTTS C'OUNTy PLANl�i r r; CCil4lM C7N 1�9" iyitJ ; S tis t~ 1 I) � , 4 FILE NO.: 90 8UTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMM 1 SS I ON STAFF FINDINGS - July 28 1989 APPLICANT Timothy and Ruth Davis OWNER: 5tme REQUEST: Rezone from "U` (Unclassified) to rrR 5 (foothill Recreational - 5. AP No. SIZE: LOCATION: EX 19617 I ;NG 20141 NG ; ZON I NSG HISTORY: SURROUNDING ZONING: SURROUNOING LAND USE: SITE HISTORY: acre parcels) 056-37-0-102 11.77 acres. Just West of Calernbar Road, south of Wayland Road, ApproXimately I mile ;youth of the Foster and Wayland Road lntersectlon,, also known as 4496 Oalernbar Road, Parad 1 lse "U" (,Unclasslfled) Zoned "U" Sept. 17 1985 Ord, 2488 "U" (Unc l asst i f;i ed ) Rural residential estates, open space; and vacant lands. This rezone; Was r' eque;sted by this proparty owners elle to their desire to subdivide and build an ;add l, I ofia 1 ;A ng la fam i l y dwe 1 1 1 ng ort the eXlstlnd 11.77 acre site, The ex I st i n!O zon I egg of "LI" W1 th 20 acre minimu►rk pa'rcol sizes wi l I not allow for r-Urtheir subdividing of the proJect site, The proJect site Is located In BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMiSSIoN S,rAFF ,F I ND I NGS - July 28 ' 1089 GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: APPLICABLE REGULATIONss • close proximity to previous rezones conducted by the Butte alt County Planning C;ommisButt ApprexImatteIy 1,070 feet to the West of the project site was the Morgan Rezone which rezoned Unclassified property to FR -10. Just north of the project site approximately one-half adjacentto Wayland Road and m I `f e Foster Road, the Kelly rezone and Bourgeois rezone were approved by the Planning Commission and the Board of Supery i cors for FR -10 zoning, Currently the whole South Paradise area 18 being considered by the Planning Comm I ss I on for a rezone and Urban reserve, Citizens Advisory COMMit tee has, A been established to revleW and develop a urban reserve policy statement for their Sbuth Parad l s,e area, Agricultural-Residentlal. Butte County Gude Sections 2-4-26; 24-195, and 24- 1 1 2 .4, Ca 1 I f°Orh I #9, Governmeht Code Section 65.800 et, seq. f,: >Mr1AEltii l . _REC IVED Ga: f 1 forty I a . Department of State Fish and Gal -rte, "We have revs eWed ._.� SIU-jecC project or report and hav� o_ comments � t this t Ime, Pub I i tom.. 44'orks� : "'Farce I a to be created In conformance with thapter 2" Of thi�.�Lutte County Code." 0 Town cif' ParagI-te: "See attached merhorandum dated 7/17/89,, Mk'.- aroLMrsa. r'rm oavls "See attached letter dated 7/204/89,oAf�li L 1+S ,1�S This pr-oject 1.9 a request to rezohe 1 1 , 77 ztcres from "rj,, to (Footh 11 C Rec:re�it I ona I- 5 acre m I n imum lot s f zes I=p` I s 100'5,"'d of f of Ca I c:rnbar Road In souk h Farad I . Mpri;r jest site , ahe ppro,>t:linatr I y 2 I _ BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING Li-% i I SS I ON STAFF FINDINGS - July 28, 1989 mile south of the Paradise town limits. The proposed trezone IPlnnna higher density than the FR -20 zoning being poposed Commission. The requested zoning designation would allow the project site ss subdivide Into an additional 5+ acre lot. Such a zone:: change request for one Isolated parcel may be considered a spot zones" due to i'ts site and situation has I Idrilationshipoto surrounding zoning. "Spot Zoning courts and is deflned as the granting of a rezoning that would single out a small parcel for a classlficatlon different from that of surrounding property.nthe athe Planning ang commission has rezoned . the surrounding area posFR-10andhasproposed FR -20 and FP -•40 'toning classlflcations: If this rezone 'was granted, It would create an Island of FR -5 density. The prop osed project Is within the sphere of Influence for the Town wn of Paradise has recommended and support of Paradise. Toed the Butte County Planning Commistlon rezone proposal of FR -20 thls area. _, 10 acre m 1, n i mUm parcel sizes. Parcels surround I ng the Res)dentlThe Town of Paradise has prezoned this area asRerno project site range from 45 acres to a low of to acres Ther"ea parcels wlthin the vicinity which reflect thg density of 5 acres as requested In the FR -5 zoning. The project site is designated by the County General Plan as A -R (Agricultural -Residential) and zo;red "U" (Unclassified). The requested FR -5 Zoning Is a conditionally co,nslsten: zone under the Agrlrultural•-Residential General Plan deslgnaticn Whr'Ich requires that the following findings be made prior to approving such a zone. CC)ND I T I Cr )N I NG DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA - I, RITERIA-I comp".r ie with neighboring agricultural activities. 20 Evlsle w of adequate water and disposal capacity. 3, Aval Ity of adequate fire protection facllltles. 4. ikrdel f r: y mai rota l ned approved road access w i tFt ss i gn t ft cant capa to service area,. 5. Reas�. , e accessab l l I tY to commercial services and �tchoo I :s ZONINGrAc:_. �_ 1. r_xisting ptr el sites in residential densities. 2. Slope, I, S611 conditions ahJ Wati<r ava1labIiltyy {. Effects of adjacent us a, crop production, livestock grazing, forestry, resource extraction, and wildlife habitat. 51 proximity to public roads and other pUb,lis factlltlea. i. 0I stance from a 1 rports, ra i I roads, and I ndListr 1 a I uses,. ;t 1,st1no utI i I i y and drainage fact title: 3 I I[ ` r 0 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF FINDINGS July 28, 1989 8. Potential for surface cracking, Land slides, and erosion. 9.. Effects on noise, traffic flow and safety, Water quality, wildlife habitat, and in , quality, ty. 10. Local desires. general envlronmentol quality. 1 1 .. Potential for pest Insect brt-arr i,•,, The General Plan sets out many factors which must be amending the zoning ordinances which are cons►derle in nature. In addition the mostly quantifiable 1h 'terms of goals and objectives tmustbaisoabeocs considered by the Plan in decision on zoning, to Insure that the zoning of aln rendering a i'ef I ects the communities de!s I res as to 9 I ✓en Parcel And rate of growth Which has been setquantlkY, character, location, recommendations. for"'th by the General Plan This area has been through several zone changes in the past sl rare to the abuses which ha+✓e occurred W I t,h i n the A_2 x Years pu4+l lc outcry. zone and the As a result, the land. Use densities established by zoning regulations for this property have ranged from 8125 square feet to 20 acres, Residential General Plan designation, the Count g n9 a zone for the Agrlculturat- provIdes Very little y General Plan choices guidance In that It allows a wide range of ;,�,om I acre to 40 acre outlined b per' It densities'.. The factors Y the General Plan Ih considering canslal s rezone request have been considered and addressed b g A conditionally initial study prepared for the Y the accordance with the California Environmental Quality Aczoning t. In Declaration has been prepared for the Y Act. A Negative zoning compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act,amendment In RECOMMENDATIONS A. Make a motion to continue the hearing open until such time As the South paradise recommendation for the Citizen ReserveorPolGi°mr;llttee makes a Amendment for South. Pardlse. -y General Plan Should the Commission feet ther=e is no need tc delay this the staff recomrnens the following 'hOtlon item then A. Find that the requirements of the California Envlr Quality Act have been completed; and ohmehtal 8. Find that the prposed fR�g zoning requested doe condlt:lonal zoningand deyelo s hot meet. the t3fltte Count pmeht crlteria as outlined by the Y General Ptah due to the lack f no batt;. adequate Water of evlclence to and sewage d i sposa l avalrabr;It.y of adequate fire capacities; pi-otectlon facilities; and 4 auTTE`COUNTY PLANNING COM ISSION' STAFF FINDINGS -- July 28, 1989 Inadequately maintained approve road access with sufficient capacity to service the area; and C. DRDavis).Deny the zoning oni request of FR.-5 zoning on AP 55-37-1.02 (Timothy In the event the Plannlng Commission can make the required findings of the Gond tlonally consistent FR-6 zone in accordance With the General Plan then the fofloWIn,g motion Would be appropriate A. Find that the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act have been completed and considered In making this decision and recommend 'that the Board of Supervisors adopt a Negative Declaration; and B. Find that the propose(. FR-5 zoning request conforms, meets or exceeds the conditional zoning and development criteria because and C� Find that the proposed FR-5 zoning conforms to the policies, goals, and objectives Including the text and map of the Butt County General Plan because and i 1com i_ zonl�ngd tohaFR-5hei�ha3tard of propertyupIdentors ifieddopt as aAPOrdinances n 55-37-102 Imothy and Ruth D%i, i-s) Attachments to Commission and Cities: Environmental Documents Location Exhibit Merno from Town of Paradise dated 7"18/89 Letter from Tim & Ruth Davis dated 7/24,89 5 tfMO C1% Plannfng'Coo mi, JUL 19 1,989 Oroville, California TO: Butte County planning Commission c/o Butte County Planning Department FROM: Al McGr.eehasl, Planning Director , 6A.<_ SUBJECT: Davis -• '.rezone, "U" to "FR -511 (file No. 90-1) : Project Review and Environmental Evaluation DAT1a4 July. 18 1989 C:OfIMEN`1'S q.1he proposed Pra j ect site is located within an area that wms recently, prezoned "R-10" (Rural -Residential, ten -acne minimum) by Zoning Ordinance NO. 188 adopted by the Paradise Town Council on June 6,1989. The proposed project, if approved by the Butte County Board of Supervi or$, would create a potential. future land U80 density that is inconsistent with -the current prezone and planned land use of this area located within the Town of Paradise LAFCo adopted "Sphere of Influence." This project shall Contribute toward cumulative adverse imfsa.cts (environmental, social. and economic) 'to -the Town of rias. acli.se including but noL limited to: 1) impact to Wayla.nd goad and 2) further dimirnish provision of structural, fare prol;ection/increased :fire hazard, etc. Other potential, impacts tria,t warrant analysis include: 1) effect Capon, local deer herd 2) effect upon provision of Butte County public services, and 3) etc4 rocessed apparently without. being included witiris being Please ex l.aa.n why this particular project processed � n Or coord;itiated with two other Butte County lana use projects presently under Consid.eration. .for this immediate land area (ex. South Paradise Rezone, .pile 89-4; a-nd General Man 7vnendment, Soutly. Paradise Urban. Reserve j f::l.e 89-36). AM/cap Cd!Town of t,aradise Planning Commission ..gut �"Gunty ,Manning ;sept, Orovilie, CA 95965-3397 Re Rue one, File 90-1 Dear 114r. 1.1oore: Thank you for the environmental evaluation which we receyctl a couple days aV.) �`(e would like to addreos the ;issue in r�uerk;ton. rection Ty 3 - 1»,eduction of water. �je don't believer: our location (almow y the bo,, yom of °trho 1iva.ble area in Paradise) will enhance tar: di-. ct- on ow" tot€ 1, WItor �.vailability for people livint, in �'ara�� oe above u: aho obtain 'their water from the Para�a� eo din �a t�clieve ire igation for, a;� ricultura.l. Durno e , as 11tell as dome. -,tic use is a ; ood a o: of. tho wa.tor � in the aqucfers and will. aid as well in �`irc prevention. lection. Will a- , IV` B to the value User of The additional houee ane garden proposed the r)lanne.,_" area and land use Of the area - as far fit in perfectly with future aS ;;c can tell. rection foo morY. l:" 13 a>,o, vehicles a ..ransportation day will traverse ,,hi le it is true that a al : �.a V,'r, wa not R ernbar,, 'r�` ylanex and.20-tyye�:� lookon thio as a tletriment but a: an Vriend„ of Our ; havoc alroady Col,,* ;;heir ho:. c s antici y tzn the buyii1t; of half off' our la2'ii . t �Theycarer planning to build,. right wvx<y. Thr mor people living on Calernba� WmA - -the More fay il.ie;_j a t ilw blo to im. rove tho roa,� . Our. OvM faMily has r � n'" out the ocl;W in the worst vection of the road end 1•,0 rloula,nPM01tats the holp others cool, �� qy z, ,fit y is i3;�neo: b' r r+ � +C' h � r ,. r�y� { r+. ry yL.;�,.._.`N�y+y��.',ra Ae1,C3w`t U.4 the .-.7.an 3' Ot, 1 + from Chi0o,' 4Ja f;','1 L�c.�lnci"� cco Goy {4e. Other a�"e4`'«� an=fit they are not to 111ove here in the irwn- edia-te future . t��qq q allot fa�-,1 Z in I ars+? (7,1yw�yon "toulra ac's: to the tabase �irom which o draw .;- and--- '�J y:,yLiq✓3.1}Y 4. h�, ll l�/tbiai. Mc�i 5.4'x.;. •. p ce-wion 17 lata 4 i'irr protoction. 1 horn .".ith la,, Anelareen is 10= faro hazard •;,h an .._ ry ,lacl` . +�ink. an ohruo Oak xn the summer tier . cr"e ars l.anninC to inc'1:all a l.ar7 r: cut -or --,r: round Dool which 7111 hole in tho ovont of a firo, :t�c ion III litb - olico Drr'tact i on: The., rzorc 'ami l icc ti�re have livin,r in Parae iso on Calornbar '.>f,. tho lek; va�c?a,l.�.o�n an(! trer� �a n i7 rrW! ? l entorienoo In the rant with botcMreex� hau enc problomc havo occurrod. (rco �thec ^-nc� ow 1o•t ;rr ire roe eivect tWO ft—y. aao frog; a, nea'-Zhbor concornoC abou,, ;,�:^:"��,k�ue3t^:� a.n our oroc:) . _ v Da'tr'ig letter -• pa y Section IV lbc - "later availability. r e had our areal dui Tho new well will )e X -'s male X30 i in a position V -111th t o c ed t i .Fait i t several tames and share the water n mine. Of being la rd 0q. 580 Foot well and gives an abundant sty )l Of good with our neighbors. ft. past of concrete ha„ already been ecu ryd anood Watery !' holding a 1550 Gallon Water tan for this aid in the event of a fire. purpose. . � C1pat on P l'ha� -foo ;,,ill ,:.'oction IV l6d - uet��er sµ c en.+ p arse ? inu oct'orl Zvi htfl in soleach lines Were e Ju,st com��:e cet� ice• etasignificant ,n the adjacent 'founts•, The s�0il is bee,uti�u Y. 'bcliwve that tho soil - Parcel a.:mount ox roc�� rav 70 haste reason to Please let us IMOW When a viral_. be similar in character.. "Al for � �' Public hearing Will be scheduled, SoUz lnr� cniczeration of a� request.Tha_nl� '.'Inc eroly yours, ;ZV. an 'I rs. TiM Davi,,, v•� Plamntn �?rovitl�, ifc,mt ,Ora /7c. fA hoe x ' /ulr r,<' r"s cC <>l �u'a'" o ti /c Ire J'c.,� r� � �.-► c /os<� r�drlr<t✓c .l1 � �'c r s/ c.�� d+ � ✓ C� hh v T✓a C ,,v/ ✓ CIn Jri 4 % f a i//C KAl OIIr! IO,fJ a r !/�V a tri r;f ✓�! / r � Y<C'f � / '.�/T Nli /I f f n s 7 a .cc r�✓arc�rr,r Q►? r1 Corn?i cii71� C.'i l`ifi.Tlc��(C O/ 3vyfJ//o.: f �j1 c., . r;C✓ i,..c,,� �&<-ee .`.... a !� �;< �� r` c d' /, trc Lars-+O� iiti, v-c t•:+u r �c c a;/ uc r y tiG-I'c�' 'go zL fvr C yu ouwr-i WAes-, tC rZ ciit G„ vf, d T' ,L', %fes{ Ctaa.t% Crr,�o r-c,(` � CGri,jr✓r�c� , j '/ Y , g7c,/ Dear We, the LMr1L1i-1-rIqrsL:1d, O"e pircpek1ty cfpjrler,s VjItf,11Y the S-ClUttl Ote propp-,-tien, i5t*r�L- lo(=;�ted in the "Ut-bari Peset-ve" ar,Lza thLjt jiet-: ,jest C,f Cla-`P rc-lad, t;rorth of thr-- �)mham-Pentz t',: -ad, Ease ,t of Neal t,c,ad, Arid S-,C,Llth of Wa/la-eld ef.-ad'We f-wo /ooj be-camsu wc- ar-e %-c-CP twid be-liiridayy ferices pror4letnE. voil-h r c- 5 1., 1 t i ri rj 11.1 1 2 V P S 41 CIA. fit -0 1-,azards- r'iwSU1t2riq fw,c#rji .miri,lted of rod, Fj rev- --I at-tod bl ro t1hri --t I Inf- P -t -i j F -1E: 1 Pit, r� c: *, 3 ri r .4, dLI5,t and eusooltairlt J'Cfacj .Ialaage from spee'diliq qohlcle!s, lattet-, aeod exposutL, to:, jjkjj 1. It y th rt Lt I d cor, jorictim*c• of the trLf:!.P-Ssser'v 1rg)Ur*t- the-toisOlveS dUriyF_0 tjjL41), .trlcLjthc,r-- I,zed act 3-v2t1e55 Oft OlAr Pr' f'PL-rt.Les, Of -O' hiAlyl CrlexCern 2s wii,-L? ci-Ittletti, which jvlt cAn L-coneq,13c 1c.S5F- d 1- 1 S the timEe -mci ejwpjrlr,,* fent:,Les, as vje11 as Pcnterlt- cif Jivestcic-k, and fire hazzar-ci. As Y'Oo-i MaY ah-e8dy Priciw,out, arec�, tnprIser cp'el eqtl-erne hl,gh rllsp arE-e, - 111,-st of this area is dr'y Or,assland Ch8P-kr1-LA1, SUb)L-Cj: tc-, pr-evaalirfrC �, ee 1, 4 s - u I 1 1 y larids that, Irl the, rs,verlt it f1rek vif,:-uld easily t.11pe Whit oo,w t,Jc1jojiSm arld pic'ssibly 12vos, LAS woll as t tj.- .t1rJeC arid J:jVe& r,C,tLtfl of C, own of Par- adise, and E-,utto L1 e ari ar.. �_-ro Into the T .4 em vehic.tlar et c ot:,E: 1, C. C -1.1y, 1� ir' eitl I primarily I Ifn It F�cf t Cf t We -1 pir, I — -,-Ate 1,1cRiAf1,z' York 18rie oncl L*4,�--th which br*artrfj e;.ff of W;c — east' pl-tc, c1f roe has L r.,P 5't I I i IIE-- r LP t C:; Ort I V r C, t h rt C4 t �voljd thc c -: t t i� VJ Cern h I t h c a b 10 1 s r, v in 11 1 y I e, f t d civ) P% Cl'f hor.-tw— e,/ e o, the Pcesonce Cff th* CI-AbIC' --1ttOFtL-F tcthe fcc, t L!s d, („Olrjt VibtAY r-OE4d hvi5, L,*or, pl, IY p %(t rtf, r E. e+ tt'et&—pe?--a*eIgpo� "kOe'tj t.*,ut"t .51 r 1 Ofil they e deter^rens ficw, btlert rt),I. ablo effec,t W0 a r im-� V) I- I t I riq t h I -.: I tO yc-o., b0c tAu5e v)r- rqq?f! ^.ur he 11: �wjd Oidvi,L-e, lee Acirfat3r't tv the whirt" vot= onrlot-ttomd Mon ef:'t Iti-IbIe to'that y bfflSr artLtl.kr 4 g t :1 r�,4 r, _q r� I y tit., 3 d011ice I ri I tpipt t cr as y,' fouly dou-111 �%Ppticlpriate — Ltf ) W ho -:Y t il r (: t h c, in o:4 's,, I ta tj rA Ij f? rf .1 a t I ir, !i 49' 1, , Y t 1—e i D ;:i P E t I r! P1 ** Page 2 of 3 b) Who bears the court cOsts ft+r prosecution for tresspassang? c) What kind Of response Or action can we expect, if we report license plate numbers, dates, times; descriptions, etc. of tresspassers, and what agency should we rePvit this type of information to'' d) How does one make a ci t � zer,' ar•-rest v How Cara we detain tresspassers';, (bearing in mind the limited law enforcement resources it this county) e) What k1nd of dr_•comeot zhoold we have that Would grant each ether au- thorIty to make reports O'r^c ltltenl s arrests on tr osspassers of the other property ownersol f) Qxn wo build a 90:'t t Or gptew on Calernbar road and/or `r`oeP lane that would nOrm010 be left open, but posted to the effect that it is, subject to cicrsr..,re In order to detpin tresspassers, for arrest? What would be the proper pasting on and ar"d:. and euCh a gate's Please send your reply to the following property owners: We also request that this letter be kept confidential; Specifically! we do not want any meo l l privy to its contento to we do not want to alert ar non l st t 00 any others of Our vulr,erabllity. Respectfully your"&, Name Name Signature: _ Address: Acreage owns: 1 area + _ wcrevgo +��wrred , z rr ar^ea . _ _ Name. ` Signature ----------------------- Sltonntune: _ --------------- Addrows t .................,::..�, w ....».... -. _.........-.«..w ,.. (address ,...� .rte.:.. - Acreage C' no 1 Y' area .._. �.�+ .. Acreage owned in area : �,. ----_ --. w �^lF,hr'le • I'�jciK,7L 3 «.....«_..r.r.«._._ .« _.. w..0 :,,,...... • [ PAM r.li E' AddY`k.w `.-,.....«.., ---- ...._ »...u. "C r C,ng �"wt'ak.'d In wr`so i (DATE) Fuge 3 of 3 Name 1, Name • ��_.__-------------- SiC�{ric:tQre:__ ___ -� tea. T Sigroat ure• _ _ _ _ _ Address: _ » _ ..T .. . Address AcrL:�age owned in arWr�. ___ ._._._-.»_ Act"eage owrt d in a-rea. ,__ - - - - Name' Name: ------------------------- Si groaturE S i S:Lg'rlat Lore 1)cldres . Address:---------------------------- --.. - - a wined i:rt rea: -- .,.----•--_ _--_--------- Acreage c,wr�ed in area: - Acreage --_--•- ---_- Name. ...,...,� Name` ------------------------- ._-_ ._:.__:.._: --=----=E3 $Ignat LLre _ _ S i groat Lore: Address Address. - Acreage c+4tr:ed ire area. -----. ---- -------------------------- Acreac� owned in area. w__ ----__w, `f'hiw +r has Al --o k+eer, sent to the fo1lovorig individLIals. .lett Mp. LSROY C.l UID, SHERIFF" MR. LEO TROIw1HL..E'Y, CHI- r DICE ;3:S CoUN t GE i FIEt DR- VI E�-ARADI SE= POLICE D- h i1 QRL: MLLE= LPIH. 959b5 5S9b PL.ACR OLI PAgADISE, GA. ,� Mit. RrCHARD RICHARDLANDRUNt lrIE2E CHIEF OrFICE< OP i":FeE CtLJErf: lffk. MICHAEL HAY, w-" lf-WAGE:E 7C-7 E?IRCH 1'UWN Or 0ARODISL F'F�E 1 13ISI:� t ice:Sl LIJ TOWN HALL.. 5555 SKYWAY PAkAnrsE=, CAN 95969 I' I � �trh'U (v0. l�l'DnnlrlCj OCririrti, APPLICATION FOR R FZONING,ILIN :,, ,' ; t-� IIUTTC C."OUNT1' PLANNING COMMISSIOJ q Orovdla, Uifornl APPLICANT: head and follow instructions set forth on la5t page of this form, Applicant's Name —:Zm, n rG! `ir rL: c� ter, a--�.-- photic Applicant's Mailing ArJdrets�i'r.7Nr1a'ct.c2 y Applicant's Interest in,pronertu (Dwner„Ltssee, Other) j 9',fy Owner's Name and Address i Contact Person for Project (irother than applicant) _ Assessor's Parcel Number($) Present Zoning_ RequestedZoning .!Yrrr�lm:x�y, Location, dimensions and size of areas) to berczoned � - r✓� s---:�'y lL�"! -` ��, LAe— Street Address tf a ltc,able Directions for travel toert ro p P Y(ruralandmountainousareas3only)44 GrC.z�iyjr resr IGC Applicaht's ; easons fur rezoning 4 _ Proposed scheduling/Associatedprojects (formation or service district, etc.)�'_��✓'/� r �2/ 11 Anticipated incremental development (ruturc development plans substquent to rezone); EXiStitig % proposed Sewage disposal metllod; Proximity orPOWer and phone litres; bistante to'lilt ural watCrcoltrseor&torn, dtAin; ,4U1 't+. �t. l Describe anticipated on and orf -site drainage improvements (pU:D, MH p); Dcscr` eho .�..,,�.��c,7�!� w onsite and dow"i tream dr-inage channels will be affected (PUD, MHI, Water source: r' � '"` [•�.� • � ,moi r Proximity of waWr fur fire fighting purposes (hydrants, ponds, etc.) r. " 2uwl "V WU rzca�aton or grading be necxssa ?`2 rY Cubic yards (estimate)? Use and describe and other related permits and other public approvals required for this project, including those required by city, regional, State and Federal agenciest a ------------ IIF residential, include the number of units, whether units are single or multi story in height, schedule of unit sizes, and type :of household size expecw. p. If commercial:, indicate the t r -' - pd type. whether nefibborhood, city or rraionaUv oriented,,,joufireFnrtaac cif sales area, and loading facilities If industrial, indicate type, a tirnated employment per shift, and loading facilities, %r A II' Instliutional indicate the major function, estimated employment per shift, estimated occupancy, loading facilities and community benefits to be derived rrom'the project, v 1�; p'NViltga?_W Y-fAI .,.JM.P-AC`t'S —A tJME:A5URp`S Identify potentially significant crivitohmental impacts associated with the rezone, ghat features or special conditions or a proaect design cnvironmcnlal'itnpact 7 approval (mitigation measures) arc proposed to alleviate pntenlial - y ...s-==_,.�,- YC"'r gam"( �l ,..�,..tx+CS•e»�l r ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING Describe the project site as it exists before the project, including information on topgraphy, soil stability, plants and animals, and any cultural, historical and scenic aspects. Dcsc,ribe any existing structures on the site, and the use of the structures. „�/'ar' r �/t,C %GIi�Cl:v�t�i'�l.C.�LG.f.GLrir� GRi'i.. /� ,�.C+(:.CR �✓ J�'L`C,.=ry+} 1 ex ce-t a etiueyC y'p e, -C- O- � -V- c e.li . 2 6, t� " 410-V Describe surrounding properties, including information on plants and animcJs and any cultural, historical, or scenic aspects. Indicate the type of land use (residential, cornmercial, etc.), intensity of land Use (one-family apartment houses, shops, department stores, etc.), ettd vale of development (height, frontage,. setback, rear yard, etc,); X t :�u- 44,,_ye 0�1—AI, .__�;^.1_ry,�.v�,_, <G:/61:. J� l C��r ✓✓CI G��—< k�� i.�. �fi`t�Ctr—.w .r;�+m. _d a 1 hereby declare, under penalty of perjury that I have read and uhder,tthnd the instructions and tl ,qt the ft''"?oing statements are true, complete and correct to the (jest of my knowledt,. and belief. y ✓ ~• / � ��f-C`.r ttr- /D u_ Dated;. , . _.� ApplicanVs, �,, ,1i4lra,. ✓�i ',sf : �: r _�#.. Dated,_. ' �` l'rppertyow�ner's signature wo— t , Pro1ect Pile Number,::,. General Plan Designation Request Consiswcnt?_ Reaueft; ReZonc to tin ts1 Location And size of parcel(s) , C k is i h � Verify: — A P. Number(s) � — � Location Description Ownership Legal Description of Area . r proof of Agency (if needed) "Maps of Arca/Developmcnt U Present Zoning Plan for PUD's Reproducible Master Map of G� Development Pian (PUD's tinly) Cate orApplication received Receipt A iication Taken By---------------------- _ • G,. S+ Y i 4 1. If applicant is not the owner, written authorization by the owner or other proor of agency must be submitted in order for the applicant to legally sign the application, Application shall be considered void if not signed by the owner or legal agent.. 2. All items on application shall be filled in as completely as possible, eery few items should be marked not appliy ziile by the term "N/A". 3. it is very important that the application include an accurate and complete description of the property proposed for each requested zone. The applicant will not be processed until we receive the following information about area(s) to bt rezoned, a. Assessor's parcel number(s) from the tax bills or Assessor's Map. b, Street addresses (if available). c.'Distances and directions to named streets, bodies of water or railroads. d. Legal description (subdivision lot numbers, fractions of sections or +listances and bearings of perimeter dimensions), r.f� copies of map with rezoning area(s) outlined (Assessor's map, r-ubdivision map, *2 G.� "e y ��,"FIs ,," or other map showing parcels), ,/�;��, �1,1- 4. California Government Code Section 65300 et seq, requires local zoning ordinances to be consistent with a jurisdiction's adopted general plan. County approval of a tezoning request must be supported by finding or consistency with the Butte County General Plana Applicants may request changes in General Plan designations by filing an Application for General ,plan Amendment, .5, The Application ror Rezoning is subject to public Bearings and approval by both the Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors. The procedures for County action on rezoning applications arc stated In Chapter 24 of the Butte County Code. e. 6. Applicant fees as of .. s L l (date) are $ Tees may be paid in Gash or by check made payable to Treasurer or Butte County, 1.. Before submitting a rezoning application, applicant Is requested to discuss with staff all questions about application requirements, County procedures, consistency with the Genitral Plan, and the provisions of cxistitig and requested zoning class!ficatiom. Order No. Escrow No. P-30097MAR Loart No, ' E3c -001961. t Rec Fee 1 Y: 00 DOC L .00 WHEN RECORDED MAIL ' Recorded t Total; 83.00 official Records ; Cfr. lairs. Timothy P. Davis County of 5158 Eden Road ButtR ' COMMONWEALTH TITLE CO. Paradise, eA 95969` Ga.ndace J. Grubbs 1 Recorder' a E R::ooam '20 -Jan -89 B(: 4 - - - - SPACE ABOVE THIS. LINE FOR. RECOROER-5 USE MAIL TAX STATEMENTS TO: 2'2.00 DOCIJ�FPTiTARY TRANSFER TAX $.._..._ 29 .X Computed on the consideration or value of propony conveyed, OR SAME AS: ABOVE Computed on the consldarstion or value teas lier�s orencumbre�a remaining at, ti isals. Signature q1tooclaranvor AHn: eterm nine tax— Firm Name CID MMONWtALTH TITLE & ESCROW COMPANY AP4055-37-0-102 GRANT DEED FOR A. VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, receipt of vjnict is hereby acknowledged, F�pq,D JOSEPHG>.. BRAUER and PATRICTP_ R_ BRAUER, husband and wife. k hereby GRANT(S) to TIMOTHY P. DAVIS and RUTH A. DAVIS', husband and i wife its Joint Tenants the seat property, im the: Cbcrnt. Uniin.corporat?d. County of Butte State of California, described Its - SEE; ATTACKED'.. The Deed Restrictions set forthin the attached, legal description are hereby accepted.., A� to Timoth Davis lRuth A. Davis ► t .i ! 1 Y} s Dated' J'ngary Jpse,,p� �, Braue;.,. , STATEOFCiALIFORNIA. {ate Patricia R. Brauer COUNTY OFA �d r��CFfAA j; ort_ .11�....f!11�,-•--:� a_ OFFICIAL. SEAL before me. the undenigned,a Notary Pubft In and for said Stalk per- 8URNE. j FUMEO1S zonally appeateQ�_..i�s.:--ir,,.«/!'.[lX—f`/y. _ —4tom �tTOUCT-CALtFORFiIA ltat ire COUNTY MY COMM. s: fires S egg personally known to. me for proved to met an the basis' or satisfactory BURNET J BOURGEOis, �t NOTARY PUBLIC- CALI ORN1A' lE%' OV,dencej to be the persorgal whose name(3) istare;subscribed .to the .l IOcANGEIES,COUNiY" i within• instrument and 'acknowledged tomeihathelshoitheyexecuted Mr^n" I.expi� SEP 12. 1939 :. ..vim-oc•. �e-ST-a�w:.7 �+V�.-� the same WCTNESS myhand andoHk ial'sen{. toff- --,c sr" lee off--- 4-14t"e1t. Signature f f� F°`"` 145' MA X STATEMENTS AS DIRECTED ABOVE - f , f' If! 8s-01951 Order No.. P-30€147 SCHEDULE C The Land referred to herein Is described as fol lows. tail that cartai:n real- property, situate In. the County of Butte, Unincorporated, StZte of Cal ifOM a, described as fol Lows-. PARCEL 1' Parcet 2, as shorn on that certain Parcel flap filed in the office of the Recorder of the County of Butte, State of California, on September 19, 1`986 in Book 103 of flaps, at page 90`. RESERV ING TLIEREFROK a< 60 foot non-oxcIusIve roadand' pubI !c uti I Ity easement as shown an satd map. PARCEL 1`Ic A non-exclusive easement for road, and public utility purposes over a srrin of tand 60.00: fest in ki:dth, lying 30.00 feet ,on each side of the followi.g; described centeri'ine:. BEGlNNING at the Northwest corner of the: Northeast quarter of the Northeast quarter of Section 33, Towash Ip 22' North', Range 3 East, I•i.D.B', d M.; thence fat lowing a.tongi the Nort%erly boundary fine of said Northeast gsarter of the Northeast quarter,. North 87° 3911 46111 Eat for 164.44 feet; thence North 2a° 34' 1111 l=ast for 83.00 fest to a: point located in the centerline of Wayland' Road, said point being the true pointofof beginning for the center[ino herein descr bed thence from sad true point of beginning, South 28Q. 341 1-111 !test, for 83.Or' feet to a point located on: sai'd'Nori;terfy boundary I ine of said Northeast quas rer of the Nf rtheast quarter of Section 33; thence continuing South 28° 341 11"i1 nest, for 395.39 feet; thence South 440' IT' 3111 West for 637.34' feet;; thence South 27' 571 41`11 nest, for 586.58 feet, more or less, to a point on the horiherly I[no of the: Southwest- quarter of tha Northeast quarter of satd Section 33, said point be,tng located North 88° 401' 3311 East a distance of 616.32 feet from the Northwest corner- of said Southwest quarter of the Northwest corner of said' Southwest " quarter of the Northeast quarters the..ce South 170' 251 3911 Vlost' for 1095.09 feet to the beg.r`nning. of a: tangen=t 500°.00 foot radius curve to the left; thence fol Lowing along: the arc of said curve, Through a central angio of 20°' 291' 211, for an arc dLstance of 1`78.80 feet to the end of said curve, thence South: 6 561 1,811 West,. for 135.91 feet to the beg nntng of a tangent 100`.00 foot radius curve to the rtght thence following along the arc of said curve through a central' angle of 13°` 251' 53t1 for an arc distance of 33.44. 'feat to the end of said curve thence South 20 2:21 11:1' West for 100.54 feet to the beginning of a tangent 1100`.00 foot curie. to the right;. thence following along the arc of said curve through a cantraL argie of 9° 47" 4211 for an arc distance of 188.05 feet to the and of said; curve; thence South 301 091 5311 Ifest for 689.957 fcet to tri& beginning of a tangent 1`700.00 -foot radius curve to the left; thet`ce following along the arc of said! curve,. through a centra[ angle of 0° 4.11 3011 for ar. arc distance of 287.56 feef to. the end of said. curve; thence South _20° 231- 2211 !Vest for 191 28 feet to thee* South tine of -the f;ortheast quar1�er of the Southwest quarter of said Section 33, and the end + of said. tine., PAR'CE'L f 11 F A eon-ercl:usiva easement for road and public utL1ity purposes over a strip of fC<irt 1nueal Order Na: P-30097 MW Legal Description -- Continued' Tand60.010 feet in width, lyl`ng Southerfy of and coincident tq following described: tine: BEGINNING at the: Northwest corner of the Northeast quar} ^ of the Northeast quarter of Soctkgn 33,: Township 22 North, Range 3 :East, M.D.B. & M.;. thence following along the Northerly boundary line of said Northeast quarter o: the Northeast quarter, worth a-1- 311 y6=` E:.,±, for 164,44; feet to the true point of beginnins for the tine herein described thence from said true point of beginning, continuing North 871 39, 46" East along sal.d Northerfy boundary fine for 274.,74 feet to a point located in the Southerly boundary 'i i nes of Wayl and' Road,; sa l d point bed ng fhe end of a tangent 280.:00 foot radius curve concave to the North and being as shown on that certain Parcel Map for U`i0uca'Buf ding, which map was _flled in the office of the Recorder of the County of Butte, State of California, in Hook 86 of Paroji Maps, at page 30;_ thence contfnuing along said Southerly- boundary line of Way�and Road and along the Rortherly boundary I iAa of said Northeast quart(=- Secticn 33' for 6G -'0' feet to the end of said described fins:.: PARCEL [V: A non-exclusive easement for road and nublic utlli'ty purposes over a strip of land 60.00 feet In width, lying. 30.00 feet ~. each sida of the following described centerline: BEGihNiNG at the Southeast corner of the Northwest quarter of the- Southeast quarter of Section 33, Township 22 North,Range:3 East, M.DB_ d M., thence following along; the Southerly boundary It'ne:of said Northwest quarter of the;Southeast quarter, North 89* 591 491" West for 1340.09°feet to the Southeast corner of the Northeast quarter, of the Southwest quarter of said Section 33 thence following along the Southerly boundary If neL of said Northeast quarter of the Southwest quarter, South 8V 581 27"'?fest for 606.94 feet to the point located in the centerl'lne of Calernbar Road and the end of salad described ilra. P.ARCE4 VF A non -excursive easement for road purposes over the area located within aS0.00'fooi radW5 circie, whose radius point i5L located on the Southerly boundary IIna of the irthwest quarter of the Southeast quarter of Section 33`,: ToWnship2 North, Range 3. East, 50.Qo feet Easterly of Jhe•Southwest corner of said Northwest quarter of the Southeast quarter.. PARCk V i - A.60 foot, non-exctusive easement for road -end publ`z ufliities over the Easterly 30 feet -of the following described property: Parcef i„ as shoxa on that certain Parcel Map filed: in the office of the Recorder of tho.County of Butte, State of California, on September 14, 1986 in Book 103 of Maps, at page 90. This: deed is givenand accepted under the following` conditions,: 1.. TEMPORARY-STTtUCTURES.- No structure of a temporary character, trailer, basement, cent, shed,L ca.rage, barn or other out building shall be used as a: permanent reside -nee, except for a period not exceeding 365 clays during construction of a permanent residence - Continued .. esidence. Continued.. .. -'Order_ Pio: P-3eJ97-MAR 89-01961 ' Legal. Description continued rLIVESTOCRs No: animals', livestock ■, _ , or Poultry shall be bred,- kept, Maintained for .commercialpurposes: 3. DWELLINGS;' The living space of the mainstructure, exclusive of r the porches and garages, shall not be less than: 800 square: feet. A homes shall, be on.a permanent concrete foundation with wood', woodro pct, stucco, rock or brick exterior, with a. minimum roof p inch rise: in 12 inch run.. Sheet metal roofs are not permitted. of 5 Any breach of the terms or restrictions of this Declaration may be. enjoined or abated by appropriate proceedings by the Declarant or by any owner or owners of any lot or lots' in the four parcelsdescribed herein. If any restriction, covenant or condition herein specified or any part the!:�jof is, invalid or for any reason becomes unenforceable, no other restriction or covenant or condition or arr part thereof shall. be thereby effected.or impaired:. _:.... _..... ... .-.. _.,. ;,gyp. 8oLiriGEOISI }'0RK' E �-. r O BOX 477 PARADISE CA ._ µµ f-'.0WSf-'Y, JAMES J & SANDRA L JT 2714 WHITE AVE GTE 201 CHICO CA 95126 FISCHiERd;EVIN H SS DAv1Sj TIMOTHY P & RUTH A P 0 Box 2t:1J3 5158 EDEN RD P'ARADISf= CA PARADISE CA 95967 95969 z '�AhSER,L7S4�lAL13 Ffi�'ED p,: �ELDA 9RAUf R, JOSEPH 8' u PATRICIA R 1?. AYWOOD[7D F'ALOS VERDES DRIVE 4! NO HOLLYWOOD HOCALIF 9160(d17914 s PALOS VERLES ESTATES CA 91x874 ,- t JIS, JAMES WAYNE ETAL TC 8EGf;,ETT, DEAN R ETAL ' 008 S014N`HILLS DR 1E516 TEN14ANT RD MI'LPITAS CA 9SO35 MACDOEL Chi 9'6(%356 � 1 T S.OURGEOTS, f �t1KNE� .� SSS RTCHARDSON,CALVIN K & BARBARA ETA's 2401 PACIFIC CSS HWY 14801 6-081LIOLINARI CT $4 '4ERf90aA REACH CAt�i54 STERLING MATHEW J CYNTHIA A JT NOTTINGHAMtHAZEL M 8S P E207 SAN 1308E AVE O BOX 568 ;Ate FRANCI8c0 CA 94118 PARA ME CA 9596' 7 „- �,.� Ft:Vran. y;!<.. s�•r,,.u7..?k i.� ,r. +• n.mnRen »p.rr, . ,. _a?��pJH'�F*?�-`°�"_” .. �,;...,. :.,�� -.. -. 10 2- B COUNTY' PLANNING COMMIssis 7 County Center Drive broville, CA 95965-339'7 (916) 538-7601 TO Forestry DATE: July 3, 1989 RE: PFOJVCT REVIEW & ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION Enclosed is preliminary data. our office has received or generated concerning the following project:_ Timothy and Ruth Davis - AP7 055-37-0-102 Rezone from U (Uricla!iaified) to FR -5 (Foothill - Residential -5 acre parcels), located on Calernbar Road, south of Wayland Road, lying west of Neal Road., Paradise. (File 11190-1) we are making an assessment of possible environmental impacts and, will be preparing an environmental document, either a Negative De--laration, Negative Declaration with mitigation Measures Or an Environmental Impact Report- (EIR) . Please provide any factual statements, ideas for Lnvestigationt or opinions you can offer in you-- area of concern or expertise that relate to either physical, social, or economic impacts that this project may generate Please respond within 14 days of the above -noted date If no response is generated by this inquiry, then it shall be assumed that there are no significant environmental impacts which are potential from the project. ;4e appreciatkle any assistance you can provide. I sincerely, Buffe Co. Nponnttiq Comm4 Larry Painter Planning Technician COM-11eftt8t. Any ZoriIntj that creates mora parcels will have at least Minot c=ulativo itAP-Ict ori Fire Department by increased calln, Does your agency wish to receive a copy of the environmental document (initial study for Negative Dctlaraticrr (with or without Mitigation measuro8) or EXR for this project) - Y�ES NO .1 - ., I . . ." . , 1. , I , , 'l " . - " ",I "'I � ", , �v; - I , l"', 5l":, , , ,,, "l il �t, /� j " " I,.' 1, ;it', j. o� I III , i, � �,� ,�" 1, ., � , - " lil� - I l" , � f� �� ', 'I'll ,� , 71 ,f � ,Vt: :''I'll I , ,':i, ,,,, j. ."I. 1; - ,i,�"- -, 1"" olit. , 'A . �l I i III ", ,�-P,,, 1 1 1 , I 11 11 � ,,',� � �-' I r "', .11 - � 11, I , , - ,�, , ,., , , -, �I � 11 i , . I 'll I ''I ,I " I , � ", I- ,� I , :,, .11 ;1 � , '�,, I " I'll ��' -, : � I " . , ''I , I I I . , -, I , 1 ,,, , � It , 'Ii, � I , I i , , I Ii, , , , ! I Ili , , I PI , I `1 �'Il -I ,,� "'I'l "'" ", ,- ., I . '.I jlil�!, �,�', "� � ,�� I ""'l I "'61,1 . ..... I ", , .1 �' l , l�� ,� I, , � � , , , , , , I , � � 1; ,I I'll ,I �, T. , ,I � It ixl!!, I. �" , . � "T, , "I � , I , I , , . � I; ", , , , , ; , , , I-; � ''ll , I - I , ',,�' : . �� I � i,�� .", �,- i ,-,"", �. , I , I, 1, , I ., �, I I �i, �"l " ), � " " . , , . , � , , li, - . . ,�, ��.',,-i "l - � 1, it ,, i I , ,"! I ,�:�� 1. I -'i '. I � .. � I I , " " 1, : ,I I . d - I, , , , � , � ", I, , "14, � I , , I�, � ,�,� I ; li" ,lli "- �, ill � I l � "" �!� � ,�;�!� � � �i ,f i I , ; i'll I, � �, � I- ,,� I, " . I, ,,� - ,It " , ,,, I �, l I I ,I , . , I , , , ,� I � I - I 4 � I � � ", i, lilll��,', ,; ,; " ", � � , � i , I ,�. � , is � , 3 , , , . �, , :� iI , if. I, ili l :, II , , ,Ili . :" 1 I 1, `ml , , � . II 'Il I I l. , 'A � I , .1 � � , I � ,I � , , I� .1 , ,, ,� , , � . l t �,, , , I , . � - , , t " I , , ! " ,it I � , l ,�, , ,,� �, I , I , " �l I, :I , . � I ,l, I . I� - " . . , , I , � � I ,�. I : �.1 ; :, , I I �,,,, I , I I� . , , � �-, , , 1� t , ,I " -, , 11 � , I I � I : I � I ". I " 11 I , , ,,� � , I 1, � I - , I . , , ,: , , , , , I I', , , It � i , , I l, , ,, , , , � �� - w l.i, i :� l�, i � , , I" , ,'I I , , , , , I I I l� I ,, I I I , .. . ! 1, I , 'I � , I I , I � , , , 'j, . 4. . p , . , � : " , , , . , I , � ,: � , , I - " , : � i " , , -f � , , , 'I, . � I ; I i � I �, I" �I t , , , I I , � I , ,�� , I I I's , , , . I , : I � 1 , . .i � , , I I 1 :�, � - , � , 1, 11 I I I � ) � , . I , t . � I , , f'! I I , , , .� � I � , 7 , , I : � , I : , " I , I . � , I I I , I , , l . I - ; , I . I 1, , , ". � I , i , !!, . � I �, i , � I , , , � I � :'. , IV� I , ,, i 1, , ,, ", , , . �, , ,�i I ,� i: , i t I , , , , " , �, i , " , - . . " � . : . , � I - 4 , , ,,, �! , ,� , , , , . �, � it I� - , !:, , � , , I!, ",I I . I I 11 . I � I I i, i, ll 1 � 11 I-) - f , - � � 'i , I l I ��, I ,,� � , , I , I l I ,, I , � i ,, , l , , , l I I ", . I I , ,,, , .1 I , t , If, ll'��,, I � , , ,;� , , , ; "I I I � �, I� ""I �� , I , , , I , l , � .1 1, I � � ,� , 1 . , I " r ,; ,,, " , , 1 �l , , ,, , � , ,I i ". � , I. , i I '. , , .1 , �(i I i �'f " "ll , , � , �I . . I 1� , I I I � !I , � , .. i I "i " . . , 1 . , I I I,, I , 'i � III I � , , ,� � � , - - ,I , , I I ,, , 1, 1'�� ill ,,I � i i �I, ,. ,, I . , ,, I I 11 I , , �, I . l " . 'r, ' .1 , . ,, .1 I I I '. I � : ,� 'I " !.' ,. , -1 . 11 I I . , 11, I 1 1 , It , � � , , I � r, I - I 11 � ; , , - t I � " I I , � I, I � . , 'I I I .1, , � , . - � �, � I - I i" , , , l ��, , , " ,I , , - ,� , � , I: i "" �i , I! � , , . " , , I. , , , 7. ii , I I,, ,, , , , , I I , I 1, , , , ,I , I , ! 11 ". I . : l� �, � I �. 1. " 1� I . . , " , . I 11 1, ,� If , I I , �� , l, , , - , , :� , 1 . I., I , , � � " , � . I � I I 1i . i � �.j � �, �, �, 1 , � , , I . i I , , I I h , ,It , ,, I . , � I I , �, � 11 , );: " ,- I , I r I � � �1 1 I .1 'I , � , , 3 , i. I. tI " , , I i, � " ; I," - , � � . . I ! j I . 11 � , . .1 I , � k , I � , , I '. i � I v I 1 , ,. , i,. , " I ilI;� � . I" I : , I I :1, I ��, I I � I , , , , , I I � . 'i I i , i , , ji �� i .1 I , �, I i � , ,�, , I , , , I 1 I 1, I i . 1, , I - 1 ,, ,I I � I , , " ... � . , . , � l!l I ,I �t . , I � l . ,,, � , , , , , I 1 - i� ` ,, � 1 1, it � "� I 'I " , ,, , , I , �. �, I . I I , 'I , I . , � I� , , , . li , ": , I ,- .I , . I . , I I 'I 1, i i , , , , ,,, � I I . I 1, . , . , . , 1, I , I � , " I - ,f i"i I ,, , , , , . .� I . i I I , I , , I t " � 11� I : , 11.1� � , I � , . I , , I " ,.� I I .. .. I 1 , ,l� �I,:� , I , � , , I , I, it I , I " , , � III; , I, I i ,I, i�,� " r _ " � � . I I , 1� 1 , , , � , , , , . ; - : , I , I , II, � , ,I , , [ " , �,,�, , � ,'� .l , ., I q , I 11 . , I, � ,� ,, ,l � I I i I , I I. ", . I jl�, l , � I If . I , l 1i I. , .� � I , " r � . , , , I , , " 11 , I � . : �, 1 I. , I', , I 1, I I I ". i it . I I l( l 11 I I I , 11 , 1 fi , :, , 1! , , i it � - � , , 11.1 , , , � I I I � I I � t .". � � It : , , , , ,I 1 q . r I , �� 1, [I . � � , " , I I I . . . , .1, , . � , � I� : � � ,, ,,, I � , , I 1 � II II , , I I ". . , , : I I ! , - , , , I� I;, � I I il V I � I , , ,� , I ,: 1 , I , - , , � I ll : - i . I I I I , , ;3 , : I � . � � , I , 5 I , I I r I, , I If I � i , , ". :, V I�,,'l ," ,,, , , i , I " , I . "," , , . -�, I ,�, .1 , � � ,�:: ! , � , I , I I , . . -1 , ; , I I. � I , . : � � , , , �". - , ! I . � f , �� . . �,l I , , , ". , I , I , � I . � � , � � � ,,� ,I , � - � , ,, li� , I ,,, , I � , � I, I , , I'., I I I . - , � I ,-, i�;.� ; ,I. m 1 -�, � " � - - I I I . - I il I ,i, 1, , , . , . �A , ;I . , I, , I -� I ., � I , ,I ,, I I 11 f ,I 11 I I 'i � It'i I " , ),M, I I I I , ,, I " �, , , I ,l . i I I � I , , � , :�, , " � -1 -, , ,I . ,�� I . " tI . � , 1, , . , . , I � - I tox I ; , li� I ". , � ! , I ,, I I , � � I , . , , I I , � I , , ! � I I , � . I l . � l I " � ,:�� ., ,I�, . , 1 , I i� I .� , - . � �, - � � , ) Ili "' ',I; -� I I :, ill I � ,, , 4 41 :1 l . - , , I I � � , 1:1, ,�i, � , , I� , I - I t . � . , ,I 1, . 11 , , , I � I , , I , . � I . , :I . � . I I'�. I I I , . ,. , . , - , � ., 11111111111111111 r ................. , � l 1. Z I - . ;,�. I p , � I I � � I , I � '. - : " : : , � , I I . I I I I . I I , - , I , � . I I I "I , � - , I . . , � I I l, I � I ', , . , �, ," , . ", , , - i , � , , , - - I �, I ,� , I I , ,:, : - - , , .. � - I , I I I I 1 , . -:I� , , � , �" " ��, � i :. 1 , I � I �, i , I� , , , , , 1. I I ; I ; �, � , I , � ,,, � I � I I I I 11 , , . � � , . I . , � ,I ,� . , . . I . I � I . 1. � . �, . � I; , I, , � !, ,l � � I I � � , 'I . i :I�', I , 11 �, ,I , , . , . l 11 I , ." " � I , : -1 - , , . I , !I . . �T ,,, ;' 1 1 I, " , , , ... : I . I i: , , � I I . ,. ,, , I � , , - . , I I I : - I, I , , , 1 I I'l : , , . .;, 'J , " , I .1; I , ;I , , I , , � I � I � I 'i. , ,; 1. . - , I� � l I 1, I I , I I , �j � 111�, � , � 1 , I I I; ti II P ; I . , , I I � I I �� , , I I I � : � � I - ,. , . sl I 11, , . I I , . te , . I Ill I . , , . ,I .. , I 1 - . ; I, . � , � ,; � . 1I " � , " - . I I, I I I i I � I . I 1. � "" ,�, 4 , ,: , . . , ; i, I - , , , ,� , � , � , 11, I I - . , I , � .1 ,� 11 : � , I � � I : J , , . I , 1, .,,,I, � ; � l, � . , , . ,� � . I I . l I �] , I � , - I ' ii . � , . ,� . , ., ,11 ,� I , I , .1 � I : I � 11 I - I I . I :" ,It , i . , I li : 4 , ,,,, I , , I - , -04,f� , .�I; J,, ,; i�, I . � , , �! f ', ,#; , - � ' I,` i . . I 1, mo it I , ., � I , t , ', I q� I , I , I ; I I , , , " , , I I I , 1, , - �� I ,I , -, I , U� � J� - �l , I , , il I �i ; � '� . ,. I I' -I, , AP"il 6104 I ��- I , I, hyil� ilo(,b -i, R i - tb� , " ) �a �l il" 'I 1, I ,�, I ''i, 1, , , ; , � �,I;,,, � I I ''. , "! -I. , 1. "", 4 I �' '': it ', " , , ", . 1 , I I �'f, f , , 'I � , 11 'I ''I� l., ii I'.�. : " ,,, .: � ..� T� ", : I !''. I"'I'li l ,,, "lli,- �i,:, 11, -`��l -.1 1. 1, �. ,, 1. .I, It'll," " � , �,', , : � I,:�` ,: I k I, �- 1, .,,I ,,,,I - 'I ,",I ,'�� i . � I , I, � 'p, j , I ; . - I , �, � - 1� I . -1. 1, rA - I . ..:,�-,: '', I I ,, f ,;I 11 I _ ,I " � � I !, Ill , 'I. . -i " �i,' I,, ,,, :111y, , i ... I, !I1, ;I1 li''', 11 il!l, 7 I �,Il, l ('': �I , "ll ,!, , I '' - - , -,"i",-, ,�.�i - ,,, ! ".. - �jl,l �,' , "; .. I 1; ,-:o,�, l', � , i, I �'-ll .I, I !, : - �,:f ,, �I,l �, I �l ;� I '' " I � ',., 11. � ,! ,I, I., , ,, '�,,l . ` i 11 i, ,:I� ,,,, ,�:,;, I, _;� 1, ""'ll-, � 'o- ... I ,p �- I - -, III, ,,. ":� I ":!"",� I , "' ,!" ,, j,� � , I'll �I I , -1 . - -,,,,�, ,, �,, .. t,:,. , : p,' I �` I . . - I I ,,I i�": -J�� ,I, � , � � .; , I. I I �'.1 I I , � I.11 I ,I li I: ,,.III ,, ,,, �.,�:�� ,'(�l jjw i : � , -, ,,` , "I I � I� " - .Il )I, i - I ... �,�,,,, � '' ": , �1,.,, - 'I, I ", I -�.� iI . , ", ,I'' f , I. ,I e "t 11), I.- ,if I'' "I -',I� I � � , . , !, , , , � ` ,,, l, , I - "i ,, "i, -,:`�i, , Q-1, �:1 I I . . ", - I h I ,, . . , . . , - ", , l':' - ;, .- 11 1� � 11 , �- " I � , ;', 4 ; i; . . . SFAP-W, , 'I,,'',. ,�Il �, . I l, � l "' ,I ; � , , � I �, li,i I, ,lill, ,,, i:� . ,�, � ..'� Alia�zt , I , ll!'' I il, ,,�.,', , , � � , 1 i . , , ""''I! , it; !! ; ,, 1. - - ''' I 11 . I I I I " III, I ,,� 1, �I , �', �.' , , �, . ,,,,,I �(l'�If - - 1�1' " , Ili, It � -,,,� �ll, I , , �, , ", ,I, I, � � IIII, I ", I 1. ,, , � ,,,,,,,, , ,,I j; ,�, , l:,;iI,,l ;l., , , � I ',I " �: � '. ,,, ,, ( � �":-:� � � " , " t v ,,, "l- � , ,,',�- I., "I" I , !��,' ,:lf �' �-�i ., ,, l" ,,� ,' ,,,I I � ,I : 1, � ", !�,l , I "I ,, �l " ��.. 1 '�4!' 'I- - 'I I �, . ., I,I- Ili I, I'll-, 1. . � � I -II, � , "I"I" ,, ,,, , I , - , , 1, � - � � �; ., I , I, ".. ,,),:� . I J I 110 I � - .. I 1:,�, I!,: 11 � il, , ,� �,? I, I � I, ,1�1 I , , ''. , I,, . 41, "I 1. "I'', ll%dl .1 11 .1 � I , " I "',-,". :, ,I'll '' �, I.'' ,,,,, fl, , I 1. , . I' I,. , ili.[I, 'p, - , I I I - I , o" I- .. , . �: " :lI" ,ij II ,�l,l . � � , 'J"i "I �- lv..�ill' I I 11 - 11 Ill I , "'Y'l, , ,,, , I � `- �l l , , � " -'� ",!, !I -,I- �� "'' I , I I I I ,,.,I , , � I I i" �� , , �-I, I � I I , li. i J� I �6. 1 -, , - , , ,, - 'I .,;�Il " ,-j. � . , .: I:" i.� - . . � . . I J,I,:�,, J;4 �,�il,`i,,�f ,, I� .1 i - . I �, - �, I.", , k�i),tia)"�l 11��,"f h lei ,, ., - il III, , . �lli - , , , ,!�,, ,$�-i.�I;,41;6.'�It,l - ,� , " - 1. �,-,: , � 7,:, - l. VIP lxn i e , , *., �, - , - . ,lj`,!;l:I ,l I '11w � 7,ri- � � . - - . . I�t I ; I '-., - I :.I rvll'e. 1�l- � , , ,� � 1,1,,,'Y,, , -:, " . " � � . 11.1 I � , ,!, I, "ll,11 , . I I .11, a- � I I,Pi!:J:' ,r�,�- I �,, � - ll,u I �o , -, I , Jill , ,it , iI, . �� ,, t, . ''. � . I 1j"ilziaLM ,4,0- f, , � ". , - � ;, ,I,�. ! , , , . v p I , i " .. I .,I,,� �. . , ,ifilit, , ,,,�,, I I I I;,-!, !'I" .l, " � ." 11 i'� ,; I., . I - , � I , , ,��!-; 11 . . ,, -pi- , ,, , , , . , I . I!" i 'i", I if, ,,, �� '"; I 11 ... ... . I " �I, :, 1,�: , , ''f 1, I ot 1: Ili, I, , ,", , Il, t! ,i-l;� , I l. I, .I: , � . ! I I , . Ill . � : , , �, ,-I 'I, T,�! I Y I it )1,� i�-f - !�-�','��,Ij,t,,,,I�l,l.,l� , I .t, l, , ,� 1 1 ,11, I'' .� , il'i I �I, " ` �l I �' ,�Ii J,,�� ", , i,,� 1, 1 Ill- , , , -,-,�lf" I� - It ,�il, I I,, , I ll,�, ''I "'� ,. . i, i.; ", " 1 ,) I , li ", I I '"Io' lt� I :. �, I �i,,ii- , - I� . ". i �, " � I I , , I I'll I , , . � ii � , � ,,, -Ili. - r � ":, � � ,, , � ,,, � � : 1 , : ... �, � "� , .11 � ; I " , ,,.I 1, � . 'I I.I i � � 1, I, .! " I,,"!, 1: , � :",:l, I , 1 " , �,� l iv, , I'll;'' I 11 ,,Ili'.,I�. � I ., - " I , I , '', It li� , , � I I -, , , - , '� " f - - - j I� , "I I , ": . it I �' " J� , iil,�(�!�;,,,; ',� ',f " ,, , ''I , I .!, , , I , , I "In 41iil�*, J- I , �--,Iflai , - If, P� ,�,`?, , I I , , ,%j�,,, j. t, �6'i,� f �l� �,-�.J, 1�, , � 11; I " I ": � " k P. ,, ,,, �, ��!: 1'' ,,��,6 ;-�% 1�1';'�l I l -C , jt� l , �)�j,:: � , I., � , "' ,,�'6' 1 1 .. . . I �I, - , " ,it I� , I" .1 '' �, , ,,, I , , , I '. 1 .�� to ,I� I I, i - :ll, � 1i � �I,,� I " � I �. ,I :; ., - I "' ", l I - � 41 1 ; . , . " - : lill �� I Ill , it" 11 , . , ,4 , 'I 4:1 Ill "Wi4litill';l R �h` � , . I �� ,, , . , �, , ,� .tv ... :, ,� , , � lP I -,l, I All �: I'., I 1 , - I, ", � I , - ,�,;l, I'' ", , li 1� . ,? " "Ill li, O� 1, , 04 11, if� I' " ., I .", ,;, , , I . - k �'. , , . 04it, , I � ''.I . 4, �Ij 4t ,I , , A : , I - , 11 I" ,. ''.", I l'. , . � P " 1, 1, , ,,,I , if ,� at", ot � I hill � 'l , 'III- It , "" , , - 1: , I �. " l'� ", , ', � I', i " " �,�I:t ,; I , I I I il i,-bh'cr6,,, t" Rl�--, �,I�jt� A !��! �1,�,J,iltp;j 0 I- ., 4�fl''� �i of-� 10,130,�ii'', 14 �I'j 446y-f,4�a6ilfl� i., , , I, ,;, ,, li, I " �Tl I �, 1. � �!, � " , � � ., � I'll, .1 1 1 ,. " 11". I ,: ,. , ,I. ,;, � ir I " �, � I " , , , "I i f� �. � I ill , �l, 7 - ", .,�,, I, , i1';";' 1 . " 1pa � t I , 1. '. � '' �; " '' I ii. 11, ., � ,� , , �,�,. I ll��;::� ' - '' I I, , " , , I � , - I,L� ",. ; , , , . �, ll, , � ,� I,:, � Ii. �l - ,. . If ,"-, I - � - 1, 111�,,� � ,,, , '' . . ,i, . ;� 'If , .-lwi''I,,�v 4, , ,,,�,�, � il;-. - l"i I --,� , �.,,,� , , - -v * , I . IF, , ,, , � - . ,l 'I , , , -', , . . 7, I� I.. � t .1 , . � - , , . i , ; , TI-1 ! .! , , , A 6 1 1 , ' , I �, , , I Ti, � ' I � I � ' ' i ' ' I l � !�, 6`lk�%*i 6 , It i i '�i p , I - it" 11 , , , I ., . . "', � ,)i-, , Oc , ,, i 6-th 4k;1l,.,,-_;'l nty i . I i 1, -7,, � '91, '--*� i F i 1;`O, `440 r4i � " c'a'I'l'o �-r t�;b 4��,,:� �:, ". " � �; �;, li�j-,- I!A, �� i 1, 1-1.14I ", �;-., . 1. I "I . I "I '', ':,`��i,�,I��;"!,�'e �': 1,� , I , � !li1l�,,.l..I'1'i'�. 1�, J, , I I ,,�, "';1"T, ." I, "yli;': , �, fl, . I . � 11 I � 11 I, , , , 1, ill ,,,, , I , .1 I" 1: "I, I, It �li ": -- '', , �� " � - , . , . �- , i. "I"ll, l I ii �::11 ,,, " I % . I �", I 1.'.,;,',��_,,t , , , ,j I i -if . , I . I'' 11'-'I�l ''I'l , , ,J,�,, �,f�, .i ��,�''fi�,�,�,,, I , ii , , - . i[i�� il ,I , , , � i ,,,, , '' . I �l, I " -i " -; I, �, �, , ''� Il. � " 11, � , " ., .�I' , i, ,I 11 I ,; -Ii� �l ... li't"I""'ll. -i;'t . , iXl�, 1 " I , .'' -1 I . ii! � ''I j �,Illl- l 11" I ,�, l ", I., �, �, --, I " . I I . , � ", ir , - 11.1 (", , , l " I�, I . ,III , I , , .i , .1 . , 1 ,, � , - , - , � .... I. , 1'. II I I , I . I 11 4 1 11 I 'I , . - - I- - I � - I I -,,,�., �'�, � I., I ;[�'. I I.-.1.11 , � %ii Ill' - "�, , , ',��, -�, I:, i , �,I,'Ii'jl l"i-II, , I ,. j f b" [� l: - I � �;,'..�,,f,�' - .i , I I. 'i., - ljolnl�'Iil�t�ll .,I�ll� 0.0��, ". -', , �t,l, I I -li - " ,1 .. I . -, , "I � . , I . -." , , I �,--. , I - � . �! r TO � . . . -�� I I I � , 14 il ,,,, � ,., ,it " � I ',Jl'� � � I . , J � � ").kl��,l�i,�,�"IV,4'."��,4�'IF�,9� I . - .. 1� I �., 11, � , I . � , , �,., I , �, ',. i . " �, � 11. I . "" - �, i , ".;, illl -. [- "I I ''.. I "', 1�') - -� --` 1, ,I-ll�! ,� I , I I , 1- " � I Ii , I Ill ''), I* II.I.- -, . i��Ii' ". r-�el .1. ,:.: III; la, , ." 1, li'!l 1, �,,, , , - , `I`i� I , ... � -'t�!i:- - �I, � - f,M,fv'� " I �;, I- I ,, j.'' ',',�"` I, � T/I 210A i i�-�37� i" ` " ' 11 . �,Inlri - , DI',"', ,iiii -, ,4 1 � ��ll.l ,. I.I... "i , , if �,� � , , ,I tI , I ,, , - I", 1 � "I: I, ,�, ''z.II:i,fI�, .11111 I'll ,`� ""Ilt, � � it , �:�,��,�,,,,��,,�,��,,,,��",(i,�, ! i�llt, � , " TI; - ,, � l�': - � I , , , , i I ',I ,,� ��, ;-v,,,� ,I : I . � �l, .1,11-1.11- - I �Il-":flll - � ,.� ', 1, 1, , L� It �,, 11 ',",I , I , ., -:-', ,.,� , �, � I I) �. I Il "I 111,Y)III-1, . Il , � � ,� 11 I-, il:;��! I .It . I ,"��" J'�I�,:"'I i Ill �, I I, � ,,, 1 t w'. �. - I,- I'll., �1111lt,,.-11: I.� :', 3 ,I Ill J, :..-.� �'*.", 1, � . -'. , , � I , �I, I � �. 4 ,I 11 i � , ) . , I ,, ,.- I I - , , , j I ', ,,, I � " l: l: I , i , ,,.��, . .1 �` '"'l. '� , , i ,,I, . 11 , Jlo� " , .", I !", "f ; , �" i, I � � I 11 I�, 1 .71, 1 1 1 ,. I , . ),I I", 1�1�,Illl i"�, �Ilf,.I� 'll" -,,,, ll--I-,,i I ,,, I I I , , I '. 6 ,:�-i. ,`�fifi , i � �, �i -I'Y�: ll I l " � I, -�, 'I, ,-Il,ill f, I I , "'. ', ,I �,, " , 1.17��l- [ i,.,l, - , �,.,�ll .- -I , I'l, I ..,� . - �,l - I , ,,, f� , - , I �i if ,Ilm. , ,:. ,.,, , � ill .�. * lll�!��I�J�) I11:1. 111.11 � 1 1��, "I I 'If -i ,,:- If 01 [ I 1 ": j I ii 1, , ,,,I �! !.:;I "l, 'I y,' I ( - , ,, �i,� Ill � I '�, ll� i " I ,�:.��,,�i-i�,,�i""f,�,,,E�o��if�I �!,l .,. 1 �� -, oP iu-4,l � r, ". I . I,, .1, I L I 1, '"I , i ,�,,I, ..'ll ,, 1, '', 11� " I - - � � Il l.'', ��, I � - I'll, 1. , 1, , '! li,j,� . I -, 1,1; ,. ) )I 1, ", I I, �, , - It". I. 111�' , l;,J'1 , - . I " - i � ,,, . - I ", � I, 0, v ,,, I , I, "' , ,, , . , ,�,� �. �,,_ .1 I 1, , , "I a, , , I " l l ": ,,�, 1 ,. l 1, I" ,��:,o�� .11� -1,,,�-..�,,� i I " I I , 'I �, I,,, I '' i �.l _--)" 1, i i - JI: ", ,,� !��,l �; I� ! , i,�' ", , , . I ,I' 2 , -It. I - ',�, ", , . ,�.-!-- I . ...... -IA-,i-�.l�l. l� -�t,�,: � �,'Zl I., , �-,�, I .� ;Ilfl, " 1, ,.., ,�I�Ii-:',---,-- .. , 1111- - V-1�1.. � "' I , - - - , .. - , ,�,�,I.I�-r�,!�i� llt.-,�j,!-t ,�I- - -1-ll-1-1- , ajf,�,,, -I - -:, i'r --, j": ll�i �Vij---' - -- - -I-,�.�7'-' %-'�,,'-',,,�.' ti. 11 1-14117-IRl- N-7.11ji , I., I I� ,� � " � , , I � t , �'� " I I l, , � 1, I . . IIP 11. if o'll" I �� ; I. r,", � I 11 I'll 1.11 I 6, ,j 1, � ,, 11 A , l, , �fs,,-, � �, ��',' -, - "'I I, I i!- ,- - -, - -.f ., ,� ,��,�.��'�;.4�L-.,,,�-,-��. . -- tfl -- -!I- I , -'11' . I 1 ... I � �,Ili�, , ! "'I , , , F I ; I-I.111!I 1 ";r,�., , , Lm,- . � � "l "I , I � ,;I - 1. I -I fr ., 1 � , I 'll -� - �l I" ,:, .. I I I ,,r ,,, I � I ;��,, I" , III '. "I' , I, - � . I , I 1, I ,I� ", I r l " l" ;�.j, ;l1i I 1. 11 I I I . , i I �l 11, . , vi; , , ,, i., I illK L i 4'1�4t I ill , I ,i,� ,,' �!��, "I 1 , �ll'o`P'V,A T, III , 4' , ,.;',, I A J�Tt ` ,,.# ... � ,", ,f I , 1,. , I . ., �11 I , - . . " �r�., ,� , , ll.'' I , N�i , . � -lil"),--o r- -1 - � I �Il ,t I I - �'111 I �, ,-,,_I� -,. 11''j. �":l I', . I, �ll � , , "''u, I '' I - � ", ''. : 'j, i., � .!, I ,�.!`� i�, --�-7*�- 11 , ", � " I � t - , , - ., �lj, l ,. 'i, " It , , ,��,�llll!j�l��li , , , I' I . I, l.�AZ -�`, W.Il , - � , , �,Il � , , 11 ,I 11 , , , " .,r;� l It, I ,l ; 11, . ,I 11 I I I'll � ; � 'I� ,I��,�! I f[ ,I-I I I '' 1, I., I , 1-1, , ��,,�.`,,:Im . . ,, III I .. I �, ij� "ly - �. I;):'l I Mill .11��l �:I� , " , , "�, I � 1, " , , I I , ,,I it ;, 1pi , - , I 1 : , , : " . -� I I -� 1 1,�, I l,Ill , , , � ,,�,lli`,'��l� ! , " ,, . Il;,.,,' � . I �': , l" " I . . , , I �I, . 11;,-,-, , i"i ,, Ili l ,,, ;� , , I, ", , I 1,1:4, 'A;'..:�!;� �i, ,� . . 1 � ...... � �, ''i , ,l ,, ,�Il,,Rc I ;I' ,,� I� �,�; �,, I., l I, ". I . I : ,,, , ; .Ifl�'I- , t'! I i li, - lIil,,� , I, , : f I '', , l� I . " i- �;i ,, ., , "',:, ,,, I �., , it, I, , , -- I� - , " "Ill, -fli�-, 1�,�l,m,p; , I i , � I�,, �.i,�� ."��.l " (I , , ,j "'f 'L, ��' I , 1 1 '.�, I,- I � - �, I "', I'� I . � I I., I 1, � ,�, ". , " I "' , 1 I ,� , 11�,� i , . I "'' ,- 1'. ", . d i�, " . 1, , I " ,#;I , � "I ""I , I , %�lt,ij,"", t,p�;��, , I, : " - - " ,! ,:�'. � , , , I di r �Y$p"-- I ,. -, , , � 6 � , �`ii, Pt Iii �f , t - , 1 1;�. '� 11 Z`0 ", : � j 11 i " I ..�ll :t,,�o 6,�I,�4 i a : ,,�,I�, if.�"i`ll Y, '. i " I, , I ,, : , ": 11 ,� ',,r I I,, ,I!, I ;d , ,�.f ;- I . il " � V ,; �Il � It, . , ;, :" I ,, � 1 - , -1, ,ll , 'I '', I - I - . .1 .. � I - , ,I� jr ,: � , r �,, ,� ;,' . I Ilir, ,, , I ;-I, . ; ,l �, 11 lii - 11 , . , -!�,, � , � it"', : I , i I I I - -,4 � Till O h ih 6"' r I iii � M. , , - , I �-1 �. �l I , , I , ', ��,l', �!:, , , , 11 - I - , 'i;l'l -� "l Ili . 1: , ), I I . I." f , , r f, - � � , "Pil -, � ., , , � I � �l?, ,, , ,� I-, j , I i I ,: � 1,,I� l! � . I I'll, I ": ]i Ill -11 - i, . , I, 'I If I ,I � '�Z,,f, 7� :, , tl,� 11, . �. I "I 11 I 11, - I :. , -1 ;!; . " I ir , li it 1 'll i , � l , , :� - �,'l ;, ��,I,, I, I � I - ii�v v , �, ,", ir J�411 "'I'l ft I , "'' - I I ',if I ,� ,, I,�r I� - � � , " , 11 - t Y", i, 1, t" ,, :I p"I it, �; � "III - �, � 11 , �, I, t . , ,,�i, . 1, , ill " � , l 1, -1 1. I I - ", � ,I , O � 111911 I , , �� , 'll j .1 , j , ,�i 4I � r . T �ti,,C ?I .4, , �l I I " " I, -, � ;�` "It" , 1 11ii'l �, " ;,�, , � � � " ,,,, I " , " � - e, .." - ,: ii " 1, -, �,! - � I'll, I 11 . I� I , �,. I � � ,,,I V, : I � � ., . , , � " , I , " � �l I . � I I., ", , ,� , 1, I I� � � I. � l� , -- I , , , "; r , I I I il 1. ,: 1, I I j,� t'l ;i -i I �,� � � . - . I I ;I!t '� , " � � ,, I "i1j, 'j, ,I . , : ,� � . 1 1", , , "' I ,, ; It: . I " il" t, I , � " I , , . : , . I "I � !Ill ,11 ; , , � "! ,� � �, ", I ,� ,� ... . , � . . .1 , � 1, ill I ,I, I I I � lli� ,, ,,,, - , ,, I . I �� I � '. 1� li t� ,,,, " ,, , . , I lj ,, . I I , ,,,,I. ,", � .� I . :" . J- j,- I -iw " it ,; � - �I, , - �i I ]I 1 i� , . I 11 I �li, , ii, , ill ,'. .;, � i� ,,, j, .� I, . . k , ,I, �ll, ��l ,,, , - . " -1, �. I 11 III �t I I ��` I I I ,,,jl.,_ l�L, k.�', 2 � �: ', 1�, � 1 I I - I - -, I, �l "! , I . 11 .11. , I , I , I l , . : " l , � !;: - =I I � , -l.111 "' I- il 1. ,I 11 . -T--ii -, - 1. I i, � V- - �l .", I �i- , 11�1 I , 1, I ,� I , 'i� - I ,. . - I - . - '': - . 1. - I ll-yi,�'. , - `� ., ,,, ,; , �� Il;",., .:.--j, �I. :ii- I , I - i , , I -, il� ,t-- i.,- -1 - �'l� ,,. , ,i -� " - 11,� I - 7F -, fo, I .- -.-I'l i,�,;!-1 ,� :,,7, - " - ��-.-I:j j -, 'i", I , � I - I - ,[I ; - � , t�.,:,i ,I ' �I, 7lf 1 I'll , ; " I - , I I I I I Ill! I � ,: , ,,, � ',�� , ", i f,I ), , , 1 ) I I ., -, :, , t . 1,41, .., , ". , , -� I I d , Ol 4, � " 11 j, It , I - Is , '�O,�,!�Z, '01 , , -.`o , "� , , �" I �,)to , , ; , I . ,e ", , , , ': -lil.,�l;1'.":;', �1, f �, I I Ili �., "I , , r, ,1 ,I , lia ,��1,1��t,�,��r-"6t�)0.,�6,ti�� ;�,�.",j;pVt- .� 19 . 1, �, ., . '. :� ,,I ,, 1�1, I - ,,, I 7, i", I'll rl,�,, � I ",", r� �, , .p _lj� n., l", ��, 164u, lt*10 1Jdj5'e:�.,: �:`i,"�j '. A III, � , � . ,l ", , , - 'V� �. . � '""'. l!li7 ,i 1 1,�, L'. it "� I ,,, I )11 0 .. ''. I I -V� I .1 I ; ., -,l I ., I .. I'll - I - , i �11- i - , .1. IrIU I , . � , , , - - , � I't- 11 li-� �i , - , 1 . ..... q - ` t to. � , .11-� ''It ,I i , I "J'' I -, ,,,, �, .. , I , , 1A I.,; - � 1, 11 I I, i . ,,�, ; , "I"q - �l. I , If! , " , , li, , I T , A`" � , , t, Ill I :i I, 011,44: '' ,I, , '"I'T I 19 I, I , li� � ,,x-�u "'I IT:6,fl �Xfji),,�""J_' -Qu� �JTT,r��Ij ;M,ly �ld!tfI '41 " , , ,,I II.��, , , I,� fe ,, 7'-J,�,:'%, P, I, i, - - , , , I . , l , l, lUt; , , .��I;l�Pji "I 1�11 .� I t 4, h, I X� I I, t- , , "I - ,: I 4 1 , , l , . , 4 t , ., I 1� I �,, ,;j�l�-:--' h .!i , i'l)". � �: -, ; "I . 11 � " � , i. i'll.': . ) I 11. 4 ,l , III " . , , , 1 .1,1I c�, ill, , Tc-�, r .1, - I , - - , , � I, -" I 1 -A V.,; - I - T 1'. [;,�, , - iil� �'I� ., lidlt;� .�daf .�, I f-,'!�q I l:,liblo i, A(Tlllft� ^ -fi.. I ,,, ;jl 1,; n a � j k, 6. -��, 1� � I I , I,� ,,,, . 1.1: Al. I I -� " � l-,�t� i �": , I , , . I I I I ,,!,�l I �- ,''. - . '' MJ,0�1. - K"'ll! 'O.41 - --y 11�l -!W �4111'1' I , p � , � ., ;::[ . j '�'I,�i,, `;, .� ,,, , !44l, 1., 11!01.1,i.11 'ev, Mn I I � I—' -- q il ,I,, , - ,I 16, ��: l, -I. - i - 111, I I I ,., i � t-� ,,� I-il'! ''I ...... �� i "i ll it " " �, �,e �(" oc�� ", , I 11,I, ,. I , ., '�,I' 1, - I I -1 � 14 � ti ii, tr I 6 V.I�, � I I 1-11111. 1. ll,,I�S,�,yj� IL.L,6, , m', , " .� , , "'' ,;, ! ,,,,, - , ''i- .Ilr 1 t, � -)", . ,,, Y ��,l,,I� I " I. I , ','I Mol, , -l!P-.. ,,,,, , -P -,4, ll*ok I 11 I !ll - -i":, , 11, , , , 2,,� I � 1; , t-AAi f t; 1�Ai, ... j" ''t4i 'j, l . I �. - I't, , U� ,'% . I� cl - IZ ,,I Q,P � . , " f ,''Il.- , - 'I" , , " �.17 f-,"`-� ... " ,II, .I - - 0,1 �:6-lr-i,',Ill I�;,�� 1 � � ,l, Il- 4 ll -, ,-, 1, , , ill. ''!, I,' ,, Nj�j,f ,�� I,� , '! , , � , , I I I I, ", I ""I l- 11.1-,:�,,I, ,, i � I I 01 I-. , , I 4l'I" 1h I 11, � ,� , I I t I I , ,, � .,;� , , ,I I jil i, , , �,' , 1, �, I I III I., 1:1.; � y�'Il� , 1, ��,, I . ,,, 11 ", � , I`, I i� I,�, I� - 1, l:), , I ","I - . "I � � . (,,.,I � "Ill' -; in r , k " � ,6 111&1`t�b� III, ,,, " . "I � , ,��, ,, ,,, , , !�,� I ) �,�.,P:,i� ,� U. � , - �. �!'.'� �, , & r,cj ; � 1�,fj d loa,te", , , I I I :E,;, e : 11: � '' ", I,� , ". ,;,� - 11 0 il ,�6 ,�,�� , it: . Ii I ''I" , - " 6 i, - I , ,N,i�, el" I I , IdMII " � 4-�,,�, Illit, j, , , if, � L -li 4 � t�:�,p 4 . .. I'll i , " ll�k � �d, r, ��$ i ,-'�, �, � i �,o 0 �, 0 I ,,,, -10 i � i-i� I-A �; i ,H:i��, il� ii I I 1 4 1" " 1, , � , '' , � , I , , , . � , 1 I ,, ,, � I�Il l''I. �, �, d 11 . - I I il� , ",,[ Y 1, � i'-I 7 I J, I I'l ,,, oi . , I I �:,�;Ski 'f fl.414, , -,I -, .:,I 1 4 "I 11 1. , I I � 7."I , - -I ., , I o ": , � ,' k ,,I . I 1, �gl 10 e��`A '4a,i1;l' i 6, al"M'., �� low 'Ifb6l, �'Jii,h'j-,�"':':,,�f:% i , , :, �,�,,,,��,.; �� III, 4 , ye I II � � li i�,� , ,'0- l, �:`il, ,, - - I,� , ,� � . M��j , �` �, � � I Vtlto,� I . .11.1 .... I, 11: i,--;!t",�Il" I , - ��j ,,,, . ,ill I; ",,(�;��, 1 ,,� ,,, .,� �:, . 1 , I. '' , � ,, � III, - I , , - , t , It , �`,'Ol � , �t4v, torv, LI, - i �Q � . - � It - - �;: . , I 1. ",;,j,l-- - , ,II. it .1 �l - Ui! ,., I !� " I - Il� .;o, i �, , 1, tll-� I;-''-,.`fl1l::--41�.11 , I , - , 11 �I. , . I i" .. I il Ill,, I "".,;� ,, l� . , j,''ill I I I , I "' . I . , I... ". ,,"y - , ,, ,, !T� I 'I'll I � iq -11 I , Ill, I., , �- IlI,'i,.li_,lj".-1 ''� I-�' _11�1 - -'�"':.i.;,i�jl'l -1 I llj', � _ll�:'l , � I� -! ,,- � . L, �, - �� . � ��,'� 11 - ""'I""'Ill . . f- A � ;�;,� , �: I, ,,, � I 'I ll �. 1, 11 I�l ""', �,jlllkk., .1,,ii,�cj W-V' ' ': i �" I I :'I : ill 1 L._ lv�; I , I I , , " -- ,'I j. � , .. I I �Iill - it � .1, . 11"'. ''"ll 11 I ,I � I ), II I., i ,�-, '' , � 1p'. �,��, � ". � -, � ,,,, "Ih, '''' i , . . , �, Ilj"� � ' '' I)Lj l' I , . .11 11 I', I I .11, j '1,,-,�iiiIlllQ, t' ll��ll, l, t I : -Ill", i � "q "I i� �11`1 ''I I', , :,-'r,''I ",� I. � II I . ""�', I 1, 111.1 I 1� I "I I 1, A', 1, " , 1.1"it, � ;, I I, -1 I , '' 4, -, "!,- I." 'I � , 'I, ,. i i ,,, lq,� � '1,�,J,� . , " l, "I �',', I.z ll-";-P. i�,,,, w � t. �., I 1, , � ,��,l IIIL l I I:, I, I I . I I �, :1", ,, I - i�,,j , �, 'I, 1� I 11 � � � , . - I , � " J'� , " , " - , :l :�� il. Ill '., I', � � I ,J,.� ,; ',.' 1, ,, , I ['0, � , jl'�, ', I' , '', . -, , I I ,i 11, , I , ", " -Il , 11�1- " 11 11 , �l l ,,, I I I I -f I , . '2� 1��, 11%, I , - ,�, i'l, , " ,IJ'P "I , � . Ir ,� , I,,�: I�,, ":, , . . , 1, , 1-111l,lll,��, h., 11, .", 111,I'll , .1 - 1, ,I '' . I, �, I� ,' -,�IT,� I I I . ,, 'I''ll 'I", ., 11 1 11 - I , , ,�Il 'I Id.i! I '.`-'�-" ;1`1111i� LI i fll,� li,-lll. ', - 8 ,I', �', , ,"� .1, - ,I 11, jl� -. . il il - - � '. �Ii � I , , lIl -1 , � I�,� , I., -:''�,- ,, e, .� I ", i,', , , - , , r , , , , . 'I, � : , ', i'! �, Ill'.il'. I -1. , , . k%, , " I., ,-.,j - 'I , � . 'll , . , 11 . I ,,,, , ""-�I,�I!.,, I '�, , ll�'�,�I`,� I I, - ... � I , 12 . � A 1A I - .I., I I , , 1, I �'. , fil, �, I I i.�-,� l, '", NO I , ,a l.-ri n - ", iti � ... I � II( , -: I.- I'll I I - " , I. 1. I � ,I! '� "I' I ""AM ,;i "s, IV, , . 1. I-Ii, - , ,,, ,, ,,, I. �i`� it. I ill'- , ,�'. ,L:, 1, L - - 41;t, m! I I � �� :. , : I - ! ''I 3'', , �',, , , - � ": 1j,g__L "I'lil 1 a * 11" I I -!;� � - if 1, I i �, I -� l �I�I, 1 , , ,I I ,,,,� ;,I � (l, "'I I 11 �,�l , `,� I I - ,�O" 10. - f ", , � . .1 ,:,�,� :, i� ,� -'I,�', � II . ,� , i�I, , I -�ll "', '� � - It "I ,,,Jjl�-, I, , ,�, '! L-4- � I� ��.,,�,- V � �, -� , �,,, . 4,�-1,41'1 1. I I , o 11 JI 11 . ,, 1, . 1, ��"1144i-,� �-, � �ii` � - �j.:.-E'-L,�,--2i� I 'J" , '- , �. " . - �l , - �', � l - r -.:�i � �. �- - I , . , 1 ,J:�,��I,li,-_-7�� 1 �--, l �,� ". � � I - �,!, I , I - � - -1,',-----7I,�r -,�,Lll,�I� ;:�-�7"t--'l;f'-,�.-47" l 7,-TI'1,-. -i - u� , F, Ill, -,. ,- �'l-!Tlfj� , ,,,, 1, I ,l-,---,fi�1-- I ,'-, - .." - � -I — 7 . , , , 'L � 11 - ,I- .it, -11 , 'JIll " "I , I -, i'. , it, '', 11. l. ,.- IL- ,,�,�;',!-�.�, ll t2;,4 , "I 1 ,I - � , '' � —, �1� �1'6,lii�', "?"' �J�� I'll , �,;,, -,-�� ,, J, Ili ,I;�, , I ,I - I �,Illl � . � ; ,, ,it ,, ,,, .Ilil, ., I. 1, . ID 1,1-,�: "", 4llilli ;,,I , - �ii I,�w-il � , , " " i ,ci -jll� .�-,,,t lill ll,l �i I:,�":�,"' I!., i ,�., Ii " l "Ir . . . ji,!I�iilt� � 0 ,�I, � .,I , "'� L ,.. .j I'll , ;!� ��,, ��j ,�i , Pt, Ill6l, "�: " '10 110 �i- " ., I ',! - , , 5 , -I "11, *I I - i.. .11 1, , , 'I, "t" I l, , .1 , - I i, [ " , ,,�',` I, I 4 ` - , 'I I [!""; , �i"," ,, -i 1 � 'I , ", - "ll 11 . , - .70 , , -,�!H III � ;,,, Ili, I � . I . , '�, li ; 111), 1- I Ij� '', , f"i ', ' I, Zo�flfljlj�jg , AP- , ' , w I 3, ,� t l,�',,(,,it , , -�! !] I,!' I 1- I , ". . 10 00 , 11 l4bc.,:�,,r � of '11 I ,,�� I i , l I �Ift I , 4 Old ,� - ,l4 ;,� J,IC r , I - I '' .� , .1, � �""`,�T`ll 1� , I�, � "'� " ll�iif,- 11 �11�. , � " , ,� �, i� ", , ,�, ,;�� . , i, INt I I-- I',, , ." I - � din -t � 01�� I , 1, I-"b ,. Y,'13,`16�r � , , i " I �'. ', ", "! ,,, � 11", 11 " I I ill, J.'! 71, , I , . ,�g . I ", , il"': , � � : f �l I;, I. � ", , "I ,; )" ,, ,, i�l- I I ,�� I I, i , � , k i ��,"�.,!:,�i;, .I - 1, I 11 ,;,I , , , It, ILI "', i, '. L: I ,*�r, �, �;,l - ,�' 'I ", ,; "I t. - . " I � i, ,',!� � . , ,661,1, , Uth", T.111i i li�r4j- ,il,", - I", I ,.. ll,l ;''!,; . 1, Il"'Cit I, ,��, .,; ,,,, �;-`, f i '' , I ;i;, 1� 1, 1,11 i. I II, , I I - 1, - ,'I W4 I, i d , '' . ,:� .� '4 -,��I_;,::, �,l �,l - . - ''�, �, '' , , 'j, �l': I !i� �ij,�,�I,I, �,�',,�-"%�-i,i ,. -, ',:IJ�,�i I, . ,. I " "l" V I' �, , l�� , .1 I 'I qir ,,� �l "il),�',)' " . it Il J''L 1'1�`�`-,:',' .i� , ,�I: `,� I�!,I-�,' I l I , , ''M 11, ti�l ,, I,tT, .1 ". � j, I ,� ,,,�,I, I 1. .,I" , ., -� i l, .,.I 1 - 1, it I - . I � , Ill, - ''. ,,�--. "I'll. I' ,"ll"', ',,,,I�, l': 10'i'l - , ,j �:.'I�� I Ill. �, I" ,I ''" " I :1 .. ,-h. )"`�',., :, -i :,,I, , , � " � �1 �il, ,III . �'I-14'1,,' ,., ." ., .1, � , I ,, I'' , 'I , ,, -- " , I "''C' � i"'lil0fl, �,,�,'� � , " lill � !;i; , ,, I �, �, I, 1�,,l ,, I ,,f�ll " � -I �.�,�, �lm. it. .. 1! ,,, --Ii,!�', �, I �, �i- l - " I'., ", - i. 1 1; �,- . �I "I - �'. , , ", ,, I:)", . 1, '. It, , ,,,, -� � I� � fill I - I'� , � .,I, l, j: I ,,�,l ', 'I". I " I - l ,11, � I Id l 11 I i , 0�,, �!-il. ,�'il� ll I j , il, . �I. I I I , �. , ",l - I , ,I; I --�, 1� il- I ,,,I I . ,� ,' ), 4, ..''�,, I `� , , : -,!-� , , I� ,') I � I, 11 I, I �� -! I : I I i", .l, It ',��;: ,, _- 1,�,, ,�,11�� I I -Ilfjl.-��, orl�I�., � 1. I .�l�,-,_,ll t,,I-',',�',i,,'-,'., , , � �,,,., " l:L,�,_l :,I,)��, ", l_�i�,Ii- !: '', I;" ,. "., I , . , " �I,� .I � " , - "j I.:! 'I ,� . : �, I', ,�, ,� i�l,,I'lj '"' , . [ � ��,",� ;11 I 4i l�� ", ''. -I.I,�,,� . ,p, - -- f , -1�:"qi`I,;,, �, I', 11 , I ,, ":,I � -i, ;, 1�1 ,'l, , It''I �,,, ,;,l , ,�, �, " , I I ): Iii ,L �I-,�,ll,, - ''I I -�'- � I I " - " �. I � , 11 �.� 11 I I 'I ,.I I '�� 'j� -, ,I , I .1 11 � �, Il ,", , 'i ,I , I ,,- 11 " � I !',`i-,i,,'1J,I,-ll ;,p;ii � ,,,,,,,, il,:,i[i ,11"j� , -,�! 1; .. . . ... 4.11 � "i" I ,I - ,�!I��, - , � 'I't ii,i, I �l,�,V- � , -�,- ,1--:� ...... "-.. -, � .1 - ,-,� , , -, ,, � ,t� z � � �i,, , -, I �, , 'l, .�'., . �-.,, I I",.Illl- -,I I- q, -11, "� 'I, - - , .1 it"A � ; ... ... "' I �l - I �:�il, ;I.I�,, 1 !�, �li;� l, � ,�. , . lPl� 'I � , I 11.1 ,'- 11 I 1; -:,i,.��fP�- ;I I'll � - ''..'', i '�,J� , Iv,6l,.,',l�,, ,"-I�lj I � � ,,, ,, -, , -,�f�- "r I ,I ,,,, 'I - `I�'.7;;j� ,", , , I;, ", , 11- ."I"', � , , -11, � � , i-.- ,- , , I - I ,� -,,l,l,Vl'�,,,f7-I �,� !.'l "' I �� - , �,:",�,,, ,I � ""l, 111"."", ll�:, I� �, � i, f I ,'I, -,--�-il �lIlllllkivl-, I , � I . 1,�- 1111, -.0"'"..", - , , �,ll " I ''. .it;, "i, � , , i I l"I ", � 1, I , "'� , , , I ,. . , it ;M,I":1 i -`!,." �, , l�, , �I, I . I lr� I 'I� ,I, I. " "i "; NI � , ,I, , , '"! li, � I ,,� �: ''(i, A":'111 I .I , , ,�`I,ll ,. ,I, ` i I "l"Ili 1 ' " '' il'�" '..'I�l;,�` " :� , I : I - �, " III "', , t, -`,,,-;, I � w 1, ii-,:,�;� �l: " i", I . 11� -i""'." jl� "� Il. !I) . ,,, I - , , ,, ,I 11 I , ,4 . .... " i. . " I I , . .� - ill , i,,i - ,, ,,,, !�i" I: I� i", , I l , ", �l , I ll'j'l I I I �, � �l ... . ... ��II ,;. �.'. III ,,;,- I: 'i'',; '' '': 'll-li, " " '' if, -';,j-,l. I , ., i", !, :- ,, , L ''. , �;�:, Il I it , '' �,o , , � Vfl,�FE �"4 Ill, i l I: � �,,: �,S�,�, l-1,';l�,Iit,,' ll-�,,, jp� ;I I l , � -. � i,,�� I - '' ,. �, ., I ., ,i, I I , , ''t": . I ,, _�l 1, , � ", I�, A lit ,, 1, . : , I I �, 'I , , I,. � , , � , , -illl'; I., I,,,� � ,IV , I. . , � I " �;j,� , I i ](11 . I 'i .r' , , . ", ,I 1, I I � �-I I. ,,, � , . , I , , ,, I . . , " , , flil , � I , , , ". I .I , "I , I " � I � , 1 I, , I ,I I-I ii, . I , I I, , I . , .I. ii , �, 1, ;'' � - ,, � �, . , I I " �� - � I , , - jl�ljl l , ,,, , , , , " I'll"'. I , , I -�,,l , - ,., , , I 11 I I i,,�q It, III 1 11 � , . , -,I I' i� . , - I.- , ,, , , , : �, " I, . .I, , I I�l 'I'! il, I I ,, 1, I'll. , i 01 'I I , , , i� �, "ll, ,� '' �l, I � , �I��, ,; l;�"Il 1�1,',. [,I I � I, 1 4 ,f I � j� 16 , , �, "I 1, ,, , "' , ,) . , 1. , , 1, �; , ) � '�11 N�,: " �,`� �I�i� ify I 11 "i 'i� 1 � 10`�, . �� ill I I I �W�,;, i il "ll"'; J,j�.",�- I,�, �, , "l, J, ,� I � ; !"i" i , I 1-'��I:,�`, li�,:,,� Il I 'I ,,'I I It, ,,, ,,, �11�;Ii,l- I - . I - , I ", 1 il- I ,I, 111. Ai , "'; I . � 1�l, I,"! I , �` " , �'1'1, - i �� h � - , �,, �; 1. III , , � I , 'I ,I".. , , , , ,, lI l ,i�,l ; 'I ,, 1�1 I I I', , , ill .. , �l 11 ''ll ,� I:, :� i", ,,,,,.,, , Pli-�;[l-,,,. ,,;" , , . i'f, fell , , I 1, ,I , 1, I, i , "I' ", , ill Ill ,, "I, 6 I l� i - ,, , 41, I'll,-, t- f� Ill I � �,J,�Jji . 1:4111, - bli -1�, , I ; i, , i, " ': , I I , , " -, �'), I , , �, ,, , ,, I , ,;� , i, ,i I it ,�. I -, -lll(lli"ll I `i, ill ,, ,, l, - - , ,,I, � A, 'I l' �, 'I , � " - �, ii� i ;� ,,�� , I'll, �,,t,,, 1 � I l,,,!,� � , I , I,� , , Il, � " , "il , if "'I I, , , , � II.,"-, I, , - ,.� I, I I I � . , �l I ,,, 1-� Ill , i" [ I , I ''I I I ; !il�1,;l1l.fil." I , , - �' , 'I" , l'."I"i 11 I I;j_ �;� I . , , I., 1 IV 1, �.l � � I ., i �I, � �, �III ,.,,I,,�I�,� I .1 I I � ,'i, I 181111ill , .� I I , il� I � 11 , ,, � I ". :f��,:� t -,(Ij� ,, , ., I ,l i ., ,� � . , �, , , " I.- , , .N. - � I � � - , , , ;� II 11 �I, "ll, 11,f� , ,, Il I � � ,)A , 1'. ", � ''� I.. 1, ,, I , , - .11 11 I,�.; i�f &r , t" -or, It i:' �, 'I ,�Y,",� , , , �61A'- . I " � lhi�t� I 1, O A. , ,, � I rj� *`11�A , I lt� ,, , ,;�,: - � ... I,,;� it, �,, � 10 I, , �� Mi I�,k]" . �i� � �,h,t , I " AtV N;,. -- , , , , , " I� � , ( A . ?, �, n , I� 1�� I 11-11 11 � �,, ,li?, � � �' ��.,Ibol�vt,t o 6 L i H I , " I 11 I " , , - - i ` I " P I I , �,, ,'� ,, 1, , ,,, : I �lf, I 7, ., - , 1, : . , i� ,. f"', ,I: , ,� ro)�I6 , . , , , �,, ; �" I _ , : ;. � , , lo�,� lt I I , �. I , , � I 11 . ,. I I ;� ��l� ,,,,� I , I I I 'J.� ,:,,�� ,1,,��, �i C iblillffll� Ljl;� -�f�," I� ,,�� . . .l " ll,�:l?, 1� ''I I ... tili" l ,� !J, ". , ;1 I � It ,. �j, , " I 'I , I ;IIJ �;, .. � - I �,;�', � IL, ll : I, i 1.�,�'; :; ,I �� :l , , 1; (1, I ij.�,I)I,qo,L. . , �, I � ., I - I I '! ; J. " ! " ",,,::,,� "I I I ,� I , .�; ,,, 11 � Ili ji - I � ;I.j,� I ., I il " i'i'l;'l, � . i I 'I' '�Jlk 7�';,� 'It ,l, I I , l �:.,Iill' . ,lill, "� ', 1, , ,11 !. 'I., , fl Ll 1 , ' -I, - l '' , - � . . - , I I, III, I 1 ,,,, i, I III, I I,, , V - I ,, I J.,�I-ll�,!l : , 1�, - , , , " I , I cl��,,ii3O t , , . 'l. , fL,, , i , , 11, �,� .! Il ,,!, I Dt ''", ,I , ,III . 1. �,� �, I . ".., , I , , 1 I 1, -,,'III � I I ", ."I': ', � ,I ": ,, , ", , I I I , I I �l . �,,. I I, -I , ,, II!, ,!U �l I , , I� ,'!: I , �,.- " Pj�,-Il,, I ." ,,� ii I I li , . �, I I, ,,,,l�III '. . � , J� I , " �,- I if 1, ll� I, I, it i,,:' , I , ,:, , '' I ., , , , . , , , 't � iI !I " Ii 1, I-, , �!,l "I ; , l 'L i l il � ',I; I'll, It ", "� �', i. ,I I 1, I ; , ,I .. ...... 1, " . I I .1:` I " II, I , , , , , , , lv�' Iil�,,, l " , '' I "I I ,I'll 11 li�,, �,�,,! ,. '' , , ill�'Tt;` 'id"I I I , - .. " I �illtl - " ,,�O', I� I 1,.i .1, 1, ,-I;I� ,).;, , , , �l , �', � I�li� I � ., 1 �-1 ,- , ,1.� 1 ; Lv-';,� 111` I ,,,, ,�.. i , 1. .. �,t,. � , , I, l I I I , ': I� ,� if� 'i"['11,ii TI,,l!4, I I I - ., ,, " I , . ,, ! 1�, �J��ll.l,,j .,� - �� j,�, " ;' � ,�, ; I, .1 , ,�� . !., i, I . , . "" i , I, - I, , '!�-. " I 1, I , 1 I �, , . .1 I , ,I, , ,� , 1, ;); , I i�,Il� " " , ,`� ,If i`I� J, � , " �,: �, I �j t., !, !" Ill,, , . L� - ,I ", , " I �.:. .,.I 'it , ,-, � It' " ", ,� I I , I , " 11 ,I-�, IV , l I I` �l INIII , 11 I 11, I'll ,� i i , Ill � . ill , ) I '!I �, �,�, , . iii � . I ,�l '� j I Ill- I Ill 1 . I . . '', , ,.�'�,�;,! :, Ill j_' . 11 ' 1 ,� � ''t, .. . , , - il - I . ,� . ), I ,,' - �t 'L, � � 11 � ,I I. , I , . I:I,,,�,",j, '�,:,� "" I, I� I , - I , ) 11 I,, I H lil'., - , "If l., �'Il, !(I ,,, I", " .�. I - 'I �', I�4�, llj�.11., , . i", 'I', I lili t I i: ,;,� �� ill � I 11, , I , - I , I - I ,,,,,, , ,,,, i j ,!(,. � � , � ,��, ,'I,, t "I , ,,, , i� ,Z. "I I'll" ili: I'�I� , ,,,I,, , , ,", . �, � , or,,';�lo u ,, -,,��-i "r,il, I �i, �'�,� I llf.l � �1�1641,61,��,�,`� � W�q , ,, ,;,,'ll ,;ll,llj,lI1 ,. I,,j-I1':; ",I !�:_,� 101-l� III ", i"i , "" , , 1, � .1" :�', I I 11 I , - i . 1�,�i, ,1;� P, I -I., , I I ,!I I �1), , I , . ,,I', ,; '. �, ,;,,., - I �,; -� " `,� ", � -,,� "I . �,ll'.`. , " ll�j ,I I:i '' I, �, �1:,;i, '' .I . , I - � lc� �Y, � 1 , i � I 11 '' I " , , I If � �n, i,!!� "I , � $ � "', l I �. , ,� , !� l- ,iw � ,�-'lli I, !.�,: "'; 1. � l t " !, ., , I . ,, , ,. ,,, i'"I 'it , "I, 11-'�.l lt,ll, !� I �, 'I, 'l ,;'':,. 11h 11l, "' L I l'. ., ''Il I, , ,!�', ; . �, , ;,::,!''� � I! "., , ,,, I I, I - I � Ill � l',�, , , I� . 1 � 1,; �ll..� .�� "'i"l-, ,�J- ill �',,0111' 1, it ,� -" " I ,I - "tol � ; I ,.�: I';,:-il ,,; 'i'' �, t ", I . .. ..... i 1, 11 � �: I L', :,11.:'I� "' I". " ,l ' I . lil )� � Il lit I 1. ".. 1, .; '- �I, I!- -,., l .11. . "� '' I'l I : 1;l,�11�:`, " � , - ", I. � , � I, ,I '. lj� .:�,j , I. �� I,� . 1 -!,:� 1, LI: , "', "', ll ji I , � ,,, I , I;�, �; �l � I, i,ii,, I ! I . 11, I - - ,�� ,�' , ,r I', I � � ;�Il ,; "" ,,, ".I J1 ; ,, """', . `1 1; 11 I , , ":I� I � I�i,�y, � ', 1 ;111 11 1 �V ", J�;l`j I I � , - li, , 11 , , .lb .1 ��11Y,ll 1�l, [-�J �[ I , I fij�,41 , I j j'.I'lj�' ;llI!!d:, ,�I- , I il� " "i, I I" , "' ,,I " . I, , , , ,c . I ,,, ;I,10 j ," I :p, if 11, 'i. ,,'t. � " . I, 1,� �:, � I, �. ,. , "ll, � I'', ll�,Iljl. , r ,�,�. ,, P1111'' 1. Ilp, , ,�, i I I , " , " " 7. i . , � V I 11 " I I I , '' - ,. - , I, I T t , , III 1111�1, .I . I., " 1, � l, `;�.-,Ii I 1� � I I ,,, � i!,l I � � , , I , ;, ll ,,, �[ ��, , " I . ,I. I ! - l `.,I �� , it' � �, � I, j� , , l ,I, ', ,;,,� !.,.'I� - , 1, � 11 ,I "'I ".1; l! I I I " , I - "I ii"i'l ,, , .1 "I'. it. ll`� I li, I � it .''I'll 11 ,�l It, . ''. I'll I " � i .l III . . I I II , ":I "J., �,j It I. I I��'l I 1, . . � .1 'I ....... Ill I,!,;. I.l. I �l " � - , I ,l:�, I - � -11 1. ",'I , I I, 1. � I.. "l, � I I I I Ill, "I-,, I l I 1� l, ill'�'!''-��:1,1��'�,:,.,��,�l. ,.:, , , , , , , I ., , , I I 1; I - I� ";'l ,� ��, . � I l, I , . .I I - I N, 11. ill " . I V,ll I , , � I. " . , - , ,'J I ,, , , " - , ,�' I .1 1-1 ')'' , ill, . " ',�, ,. , , I , I , . , I,;,�, , , (Il;�] ,,, l;',"' " t 11. , 'It ,, -Iql� liq�� , " Ill ,I, ,,,, , 1.1 It I, , t te*, , I I, 1, 1 � 1, � , , 6111111* ..! � ,,, � , �': 1" " , ''i , . it I I I ,�;�!� �I. ill"Ill" �!I� � 0 �:: ,.!��,�,,Ain��,�"4"",��r.i',Iiit,,�i(, ': ,, 1� " . i ,:i ,, � I , oll Oft , . I , " ll� I"� io, I � fl�, I - I 1,11-1 il-`- l 4 1 1 l; I ;I � -1 ll� I 1 , I . ,-�,�fii- � I � I i��',,�� I:, �.Illllilllllill ., I , 11! . �, � I , , , -, , 1 I I O" Ili i� I i , ,I , P, 1 I, � , , 11, r. � ,,, I .1, I tl� Ill, , , 1"'L , 11 I I I.4 , I" , It "", - it : I, I , _�j f'':,;I'-'l, it, ll,�, ,�I.,�I,Ii-:I,I,Cl�!,�� I' � l" , I � ""I'i, I I I , � I'll. L' � , , . ,� i, I'� " 111" � I "I" �,"k, r �' j 1) i I ,, l"', :, "J"':, 'IMIII, "' 11 .it ,,, - I , . . , , .I� �, � � . I � , ,,,�', �,- I. - ., I,, ) I I I .", � It I'I I � :,,. ,�. . I �� , � , I � �I��!�J, - 11, 11, ,,, J, �� ,�� I,, * I I I I,, " , I, i, �i, i� , " , : �;;! ". 4I 1 ,,, , ,."I , I � " " ll�� I � I I ,'I il i'li fil I llf�, I , ", ". 1 I I'll, , ( , �; ""C" , �l'll . , ,I, p,,,�, , ,. ; ., . , , , I I' " � , , � I l I , � ,,,I�i ,Ili � ,, I , .I,- II IV ''I"ll'i , ,., , I I,i,lj , III i, g P: l, "I I, , " ., ,.: , ,,, ,,, , , � i� i ijji,; , , . 11 I I , I , , , I , ,,, I I I 11 I I 11 I , -I'� I. fill - ',!,' ", 1 ,, 'i'lli, .'I 'I '' '�l" i, � 'l, 6c I , v �-� ;�,l li,� II, , . �,., 'I , i , I ll� .". �� ": i"; ,1,��, I ,� i 111, ,,, Pf �, . , � lil , . , , I., I `II I � I . , � ii � I. ')�' A,,'j,p��tl.-','� ",�, �',Iil,] I Ili l: 4:, ,�, I .1, il.i, , . I, i'f'l-;�I, I', , I � I 1 I , , ,� - It I I I ,t . � .� � . , 16� , � � j , I'l, I _r . I l - I) ,,, I I if ;,"t � ,, j'' I�, ol �Ilj !I , li: . , , � I '' i �, "4'' I� "o 6'41�� ', I - .... . .. I,�, i i � I , � I, I I'll I ., . , , "ll, I I I ., , 'i I , .� Y,ili� � 1,l� I , I� �� , � l" �'� I . � "Ilk, � ..I lf� � 1 -- 1- I - li, - A � � i'i'! , , ,,� I � I� I , ; ), ':Ifi.��!'_l `_,,��;',,I, li!��A)�,,�-',,.�. N� .11- .'P,fl, � 'i I,.,'�I,,',llj�I� ,� �`-O , lillf I , , 1, ,, "I'll '', 't, ,'�!.,jr I jl,,�',l jl�,". 'l.".''i"",�-.4itli� ,,'-':i, i �t, I!l; �,- ,v, -;�`,ll'�,,.`.,-,�!',,Iji� , I I I4. !-Iili�, 'i-!;i,.,-i, . I, .1, �.., I A ,,, �, . I � �, t , - "ll 0, I ,, ,,, ,�, , - , .1,,.r(,," Pi, 11 , — ' �11%l, 'i, I , I_ 1, ", � 11 I , � � . � :1 J.Jk i" I "Ill,11-1 I " - "'tl it '. I -Ir `� 11 i,�, �,, ,I,�,:Jr, :Y-t 1 - � "I' il',''I ,,j'� � ,.I , ". I'L l, 'I'' I �` JI ,,� I il,":I',Ij�l, ''I' I I'I' ,11 Ll,'I� ' I I ,.,.,iL I I, , h'', I I 1.1l, -il, ."', �1,,.I'l, "Ijl. I I p';"�� "'l 7;,I,� Ili I I ,,I �. ,I.�, ,!,i;.-' 11 (ii lli;','�;,,�` ��I,, , ,.. ,- 1, , I : - l,ljo�,-" � I ii - " � I- I lI I 'I'l ?, I , 111-�l ',�Ijp,l� .ITiY'. � III, Ili 11, '14,:l I Ill 11 ""�'� '1I,-`r l-I - ,l I.. J.��., ,�r�!l`�,,Jf��`� ' ''. I'��i I " ' , 1, 2"I" "V,� IL: . .I', I'll .�., . ,I II ol� I ,i)�, .,,r,,'',,,l' .111 11:1" �31 "Jil." lil; r' 1�'Il, �I , , -t,,1!,,,l,1'j. ,' �',,,,,Il,l, -,;,I ". q "'. � i ",,�:j�i,�,'��i'��,�!],,�ii!�:,!I"!��'�, :;,I LU ,,,.z ql'I'll' 1. I' �':"�', ",r-��'�,'�.'��;�r�)�l,'�"Ill,'��,,,.,,�;'',."!,��,�� j -j-- I ill �l ,j , -� , '', � "I,,, . ''.qj"�l flI,iI,l-;f--.!i, � 'l: I! ll� I ... ;I ,, .-I-It I if '. .�, ,I , I I, �-, . , " - !!; � �:, li!�,�� " 1, ; - 11' .'' - -I ,�, � "! I ,,'l,)','!:l,.1!�.,,, I ','I �," , , I "J.". 11" .i') I—, 'I I,� ri�!' �1; I . , I P . , , - l I , � 11" .1 l ) ,It .I ��r r�,,�!:�-�:! ��''illr;,!I�i�i i , � � 1- I 111-01 'I "! i jl- I � I � , � � I , I., l "I ,, ,,p, ,, , � � , I � "I" I , " i,,,,, ,�i: 1'� IL'It ,. !I,,, " � ,, , ,, ,, ,,,,, � � I 111" I�Ill . I i, I, I, � Iiiij," � � � ", 1, I �,,,, .,,� " '' I I'l I� I , 1 I,7, l" I, W t, 11 1, 21 1.1 I ''I �� lll� 11. ,,,I � l: 1', 1, I'll, I 'I , -I' � I) il�,. I� � - 1, I - )I 'lll Ili , ,,,� j illi. � I " TI, �, , I "I� �, I '' — � 11 1 I. Ill i,�" I:, 11 I I" I" 10III'l., " -, � i i, � �l I , .� , im, I '' lil"r'' . , � - I, , - 11 �I ,I 1 I W, I 11 " I.'j ,,,,,,r,, ; . 11' Irl .' " i l, � i,� i q "': I .'.�. , i I ,,, W 11�2. � �t., ill, I ll , .,. , I I ,lj� , i ml u 1. 'ej N'� � I �1, , , , , I, I I - , I � � I I �� , "I I,, , , tt� t," Ir " - I" I J' 'I -� , , �. 1, � " � fjq&,�Q, "f pj 1 ', t�`N,Jfllo li ��JJJN l J��O'r . liiJ , , , , I i " * 1 , � , 1. . , . , I . , . h I I , j_ , � 11 I :� v I 1 iI �.�' . � I � I ,,,,,r I 'j,' ,� , " .4 " , , ., r � 1 fj'�$"J� �j r.� il ill , 'I!, i �� rk r, a � I I O"', I i Sl ;�I! ,'I I,� �� I , "' I ;,l - 11, 0 Al i w ilLA 1 ��ItC pl , r , j . f�, Aff. it '' I I,�,:,:, ll�l l�,:",I,l ;1!1� , ,11 I . 11 I " til I:, � , , A)II, lli� � it 1A " tA �, (�, � k` �! E � f , , ,i��,Pt I , �: I,,,, -I, , - -- ,, I I ,�: ]I �,:71* Is - "IL,,� '',I 'I�,Il , I I,'I, I![, I I it , 1", I L I'' . i w, I � ll� J , ,, , , , , ' �!1,11':; I'l ,;",,P�,I,� ""�,r " I�. "'�,I! lj� I i ,�', . ti lv�� C '�; ,,�,:,,�� " M Ilt , I I:�:,l i ','�,,i '. . i , I', l�. ,, � I , ,, I I � 11 -'11 - I It It `� I �r'lll,,t:jl-q ,,,I,,, ,I,,j, ,i - 'I ,,, - - "i. ,lill �i, . I It, , , - It, 1 I ;." � : " " , , ,,,I ". ,", -I I .� , I, ,,I ',.�, , " 11 i ,l , k Q I ... ... ll , I . .1 .11 I I �I, i !1111, '�, I �,i),rl -.r.; , ,I l', I:, �.� 1 , I :�I�I, I 5i Il "�, � " , I I 1. , �" ,, - I' �' I I i "'ll " � ll , ''I f, - , If l� " , I I� ,l, I .. ,it - ',,,','I - ''! "�,�:�Il, ,,, ,.". . .. ... ,I I � � III'-, 1. I .1 ", , , .��,�_�I, , , I , I � -�O,% �, � ,,, , . j, . �11 I , " , .. � 'il ,� ". , , , , � " I , ", '.I, 11. . Uf ,11, ,,, , , 'r , "I . f, " - "'I"'l , " 1, 1, , I lt� ,!� �� . 11 ,1,"�'j .., � I r , I i, I 1 1, I, � � ii, �,� Ili I " , i,[, '! 1,16 ,, j'j.: � lit 11 , , I, " 1. �!Ii il ,I I: ''I", l, I , � , �, 1, ,I , I , � ,;� - I , , . , " �Iul��, 11 ., I .:,, '-, ll,;;I!C.11:'".�,,� 'I'li . ''I" li 11('T, i' I ''I 'j'' �,,',l Ill �'! t'�:,i lj,:,,,� � :�''ll:t", , I I, I i I, , l�, ,J: ,, �I' i 1�1:p;-,hl,l, �.� � 'I ,, ) � [.,� 'i� ,l!'', " � I I "l ,; t ,I I; I I 1"I"' 'Ill , I "." �. ," , I , l, ,.. ."I", , I ", , ", "',�,-',l,ll,:,j,jI ; o � "[ ..'I I 11 . I 11 It 11 P �, "', "', ,�� "f� "'r " i ,' . ! 11'. ,,,,,,r � 'll�ll if,,,,l' y,`ilTl,l�jll, 11 f,,l;"W ., -1 11 , 11'a I � ��,r;,l " . 11, ll,� �, - il I � . � , i ,� - ' ' ,I , .� � I Ill III';, 1.1 , ;.. j I I I : , I ,"� ,l . ,, , , , . , ,,-I- I �� ,�, ' , 1 , ��, A il I 1� 11,`1" I `�- ,' r�,,r I'., � �!.l , ;i, r�". il ,. ' I' ' I 1�111'ill-, � ", - , I , " ,;:I , I I I , , " " 7 , � - 1� ': : �!,, � I- ,: . 1 , � I -I " )�,' .' I ji " ' � '�Tr �'' Jl" " " I ':'L.;,, , " l i , - I, � �, I i ,I '', I � ,i . � ,, I ll "ll, � I I 1, I, I , ,',r,l "I,:. -I' � "' I , "., j 1, l". ,, . 1 � . I , I ' jjj,',";$�, i I ,: . " lljl,� 'r . � - I, :I',' :,��t. � :,, , 11�1 I , r , II I ,, " �� 1. , �� I] .f, 1:1�li� - , , 1. � - , � . 11.1 � . ..� I . I , I 1, �,fl� . - , , ,',I M f, I , '!"J" , 11 I If " " , r', �,,, Ili ,,, �, I � I', � I, ,�'; '' - ,,�Il,;�l � 1. ", � 1,� "ll" . I, I 1. -, � , . ., . � i l�, I , �fl.,. E I I 11 � -- : 'I, , I: I ,q I , ! ... , 11 dv � I """l, 11 I.; I' � . , ,:��r.1, , l,r,,r I � , I I. . -:: . �� ji, - 1, '11�,l � . � ''I 'I:l�,liIl i , 11�1 I ,�'dl , II , � i;�'I'.'Ut'-Ill , i Ill I 11 I. )I I . - i, ,� , '' I I l , � li� : -�'I�l "� if ..'' � � ,I: "'l , ,' If l � , " - �! �� ''. -, 4". I�, "'i, � ,J.jtl.��,- 1, I ,,,�Ill -'l, L! �J --1, ., ,, ' " ' ' l'- l' �`�' . ,I I j- .,. I , I,. � � , . � . I, I I , " � �� , -11 ., . , - , I - , :�: , ' , ,�' .1, I Ill � r llll� r i, '� j., 1 1� � ",'I , � R, fill L I!, k V I., I �. i J, 1� I I I.� I ,.. d - .... % " � I " I " � ,,;, , , , �1', I I" � I, "i ... �",' I ,, , ll �,l -, '. -Ijfl ,, . It I., �'rl, ,,, ,,, � I . ,I �I, , , " ,�. It . [I ; -, , � ,, I , , .1, i, , . , ; , - , , 1%. il � � � , , r 1 t I ,,,,, - � , � ; ,�, � I � �. I, , ,,, I, , � � , , - I " [ I,; t 1 �ii � I � I , i I . , I I ; 1, , j , I , , . i , I ., l� 11 i I " ""'Ll, ,, � IM "i " ,I, , I , I . ; J[ - li'l If , [ , , I - " , I'll I , I I '-!" 'l, , , , - "i I, . � I ii iii"t I � I � ;i,; ,, ,; I I � jj�' I ;,.,��,', l� � � v . I � "I , i ",'� , ,I I I 'I (- "ll I I rLI, 'I I ��: :�,�j ,, ,I i,1 qr� ' �: Ill' ,'I 'I 'I' � I- (I rif) � � I ; j � . � I I Ot Orf 14 11- ..". llll—�� I :1 I 1 ,rl� ,� , , 'I , ,, , , , 1!� I I : � I I . , 4. " lll 'i: )ij ,�I�j ,.yf;,jl ;.;" ll--'�, I "l, ,1� .."O.Ii, , t ( I , ll , il_ jr,l, "i , , �j , , ,,,�,, I , il., id ill I " 'I I " . I - .� � , , "!" Ill I I 11 . � I I, : . i J�' I 't. '�' �Ill ;-r i , I . , .. I , I I - � I I I � ' rt ',l, �; ��' ,,� Il' . , , I ,, I ,,,j��, 011 - I fl: I ", Ij , ,. " , "." ,, , : ,� I � , I ., . I I i I� ,, .� It " 1, - I j- I . , Ili li,,� -I I , ll,L, . � I I[I,,� i ,, I, ! � , . � 1 ' ' � ,� 11 I lI , , ,� , ,l,� j i,� ,j:r , I ' ;J�', �., .., , l�:", ll� :� � � , � ��I, .1 !! �ll�['. 11�1 �l I ,l , , 11 � �: I I , lit �, ,,1 f 1: I 1, i, )i ( i I , , Ill I I I �'I, ., �l I1,T 11 1, , ,� I , I ,l I I ��i,, :� ,,, 7 - t ,I " lip ' ,_. " I I V:; i", f I I T I I 11 . 1". I': 1, ,l" '� 1', I�Ifilltl I I ":I�l ,L �, ' ' ,�' til ,,, : ,. , .�� - ' Ill L ' � , ' � ,,, I - Ill ..I� ill . I .!I It:, ''I i, �;. �f ,;,. , ". � . I " , r 1 1 , , , ll." ", , I I ,. I I I I I , - 1 I, I , I . I, 1 I ,, I , 1 , I . , - I - Of ,,, ; f I,�, � .. " . ,,, 11 . I � . ". i ,, I - . 'C., "i , , 1 , ll� , "'. , - � - 'r. , �I, ,, " I ,, f , I 'I I "y. , 1, i �� ,,,, I , ,,,,,;,jI ,il:- �, .I : I' If I'J�'r' ." � I i I ' ! I 1: � jI, ,i 'Ll .� Ill I � Ill ' 1 I I ' ' " 1" - I'- ' I � I i , "ll, I I f 0%1; iIl"i) ,1�i ,'I � IIIII �� ", , I � : �: , - ,it I i, , " ,, , 'If;j, ,I -- , 1, , - 11 ,, 1;, ,I� I I l_y�lj r ii, ' I.' ,: .'ll I I I , � . . i I � , 1, , I , I " , " -, , , I ; ",I ,. 1, " I , . " -1111 _" , p , , i� " ,� , il,,', It' I � , ., l'Ll" " �, , I ,� I I., , , � III li:, l�f� ;; jlj,�� rl i� � , 11 I , :�l . , 111, 11 I ; I I ,] I ,,,, I., I I I I I 1. I ;, I' , i , (I "I Ill wl ,,I ; lIi , I I, ,�,l",�i;,, , . , 11, i , I It I , , � I ` ,., . , , , . . , "I I I 1� V� !, ,:I ,,.: ., � . , �. ,I ,� I , :., ,,� 'L ' "I i �, � 7 ... � I' I i 'i "I I I ,� "I I , q I � tl�,,i, I 'f,�� li�, ,,� � 11 "I I i , : � i � " i mi I. I "A "" It , . I , , :l, : ,,, : � k" � I ill 1, , �, , , ,, � , . ;. 11 - 1� ,: Ili �� , ,� . , " , , , , 4, � , � . " , - ,� ,I -i ,, ; 't, I � , , i , �� i"I"' :-1 it - " I W;j'i, , I' , II ' L' � I'. lj� I Iii ;� , , 'I"':8 I " I; I � ", I' � I I � I ,, 11 I � "I ,,, I - l . I , i, IT f .., I - I,)l '� !- l I! ii :( " "', , I 1 , ., I" , 1 ! , : I � 1� ]� - i ,t.l, .�i, 1,�, i I? ,I , .�, 1. ,,,�� il I "tell � I ll:ill :,A,I It, �,t,,. . , I ,, , . . . I I I ;l" ,�l I f "I " ,l( ,,,I !" ; .;, 11, fl'� J Ili " , " l, � tt". I � I 1, . I .1 , r , �,,�:, I 'Ill I , , � , 1,�7111 1,,iil, �, ` �il I I;, � 'r, ,.�j I , � , , 1 , ,,, ,,, � I ,. ,, ,,J, , , ,-I ) I ,l I -1. I I. .1 I -",,� I I ,,, I,, I �;, ,, I� , , �,t ,I- I I I'll, ;Il ! t I", If i III' � " , " I., � ,,, r ,, -, � _ ,;, ;,- I I , , ,,, , , ". ( I i 1 :' r� Ili �,� ', jli',I� � �' I � i'l, ,,, ,f ,. l. r.,� , I ' , , I - I i. I , I I ,11 , � , I , , , I , , , It , " . . , , ,, , I, I .. ,ill I ", "i �ll I 1. " I, �,�, Ill , �l ; ., , I , , . I, 14I ) ill, , ,,,, I , � I , 11 I i " 'I, ,I I ,, . , , ,� , k� � , ; , , ,i !,I , ", I',, l: �, .1 � .� ., , � ,. I., . I� I'll, ,� ,; , l " , I ""' , .1 I I �, � l , t , ,I �, � ,I , I , �, , � I , . �, l , ,I ,r, , It, , , I �, . I I , 11 ,I , 1,r I,; , , , I 1, ,,; ,. ,I� " I I. , ,, , ., . . ; , "�, ,, , i , , ,,, '! -, 1, . , I . , I . ,;,I I 7,1� 1 11 I 1, , , , I I i " , I: " ill", � I . I I, . �tl " , "' it I I - ') " ," I ,I - �I, , ,i ,, 1� " , 1'1�", Ilk: , � �i I T ,."i ,,, I I I, �, - , I ,,, r 1 I, 1: I., 1:; . Ili , ,, ," ; I ,� ji I , I I I l ,� 'I"' 1; j i 'C)"" I I ` I 11" ' I , i , I � I � it " � I I , , ,, , � " � . " , . ,,. ' ,, , � , ,. " . I '�' 1, 1. ' r I' , - 11 � I l- 1 , , , , - I�: , - I , i , , I " 11 I ,� , , 11 I . , , , , Ill III I., 1, , ,I . . I �. , , , , ,,,, I�l ,�; �, , ,I, 7I 1 �, , i , --,,,,.I, I ... I 11 I�it' 1', it , I , I , I '' ,, I , ,. I i I I 1, 11 I i.J " , I " , 1,�.. I " , i ,' I 'I 1 i I ,. � ��!'' 1 I I ,� . l� . � , ", t , , I ,i� , 1 T , , , ,� , , I I I I ', � , � , I .1; if" 1 t 1: ... . .. I . 1, ;, , It , , , , � � ,� I I I . , '� � I ! ,�: .;, , �l , , , , ,, I. , If I , , I , ', I , L,I .I�` ; ,� I 'I'll ll, Ii, � I I � � )II , .�,- ,, , , , , . I , , . . 1:, I , � , . � I 1 , , I ;� it'' - "I �� `.11 �' I � 11 ' i, I , I, I , ll� I � �1 I .1 ;I��, I 1 iil , , l, i, ; � l, I Ill, i , I, 1, - ,, � �,t. ,; l , �, I I ,ill ,_,-, � ,I,;� 1,� � I,��, llp:,�, . I �, - "ll I , I , , , I! � - e. :" ,,, I "I I I - , - , ill , I -� " , I I , , " , , I , , I, , , , ,r I, . �, , , ,,,:, I . �. : , I , I ,l I U t - I I , � I � It - ,,,I 1, , - � I , I . 11. � 'I I 1 . , � , i�,,l Ii' ' ,I" r', l 'I ' " ' � - � ]i, , 11, �� I -11, , � i , 1 I I � l I , . I I I , L I � 1, I � � ' ' :r,,;, , Ill' , '' 'I -, , I !;l, I., I I , i � I . I ,I I I I , " , I ,.!' �� ,,, . , , . . � " , , . 1, ,I . , , I � � - ; I I I , � .� I, it :i" I, 'i , , I " � 1, I. I , Ii I I I ,l I , 11 , ,,, , i" l,;, I I , , "" I . , l 1. , I- I I" I . � I �� '�l , " I � , �, , , I � I ,I,r .' I ''. " ;,�, � t il li 'w, " t ,, I :i. ,, 11 1 :1 il. . 'I . If IIr I . . , I "i . ,l " � , I I �. I . I : C - I �`t'. ; - - , �- I 1 I , 1. , I, , , �i�' ` l' i' �r ,. ;, i , I , I I . ;I , I ". I"I �:, , , , . � �, " ,, I I, I I . , , , ; . I � I' I I ,t , :, I I� : .� " , � l: ., I I � � � I . L I , , . , 'Ill ,, ,. I 11 ,, I , -�,- - �,;�,Il I I . 1, I � r , I I: , li , , , ,. , , , , . I [ . t . . . 01 , � 11 [�� " .1 I I I � I, I I 11 I . I 1% , r l�,I I , I : ,� � ,, I I 1, [ I , I �, ! I , �,l., , ! , ,, , 1, ,� . I , � I I I ' It "I t ' ' r:. .� . , . I ,i , I , �: � i I , , � L; . ,r� � I I I , , I j , I l , � , I , , � ,, . . , ,, I I . .11 . 1, I , r ,�,� , , j I � � x ii �� , I , , , ill I,; ;, ; ,. , I �j 'I I ., I i , I , ' I i� I I I i I 11 I I " , 1 , ; I � � I � I , � I I . I , I , "; , l I " � , " I , I !, I � ' I , , I �, i ,I . ;; , I �� Ill � I th , " , :� I :i I. , � , I I � I : � I i �; - I , i � I , : 'I i ` . l i � , I � I I � ; � :� 1� , 1, , , � I , : � 1 , � I I �, �i I I :11� �, if � I , , 1 � , ,I I , I � � , . . I , , I ;I � , , . ,, :; � � , i . �:'o, I� I l I. � i il�� t� .:: ,I i, i L;1 11 ; "li � � � i: � � . �4I : � l � I .I , I 1, 1 Il � . ": I I I, , -'. i��i: � I ,i � � : I . � �t Ili �� : , ; I I! 1. � I � ! . , , ol , . . ". � : -.:, � � , , , - , , � :, . I , ; I I ! I � I ! � I , , . I t�. � I I � I I � 11 I � ! 0 Butte County plannidg Commission County Center Drive Oroville, Calif. July 31, 1989 Dear Planning Commissioners: Wo are writing in regards to the rezoning application filed by T.niothy and Ruth Davis. Tbuy have requested a FR -5 from the current U zoning of their pareel(AP#055-37-0-102) We strongly support their application to the fullest extent. The development in that area lying east of Neal. [toad and: south of Wayland Road .has been on 5 acre parcels. We .feel that the other property owners of this area would also agree to a FR -5 zoning instead of the inappropriate 20 or 40 that now exists. Y+:e would appreciate a rezoning application to be sent to 2207 San Jose Avenue, San Francisco, Calif: 94112. (ince again, wa urge the Planning Commissiorj to consider this zone to us all. Thankyou,. Sincerely, In 4 parcel. Ap# 55y-87-0=90-0 y1UA► 'C'Q�1Io' . LAND GF NArURAl VdEAt''� A .0 5Ek��?'1 �x PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95955.3397 TELEPHONE; (916) 538-7601 August 11, 1989 Timothy & Ruth Davi 515$ Eden Road Paradise, CA 95969 Re; Rezone, File 90-1 Dear Mr, and Mrs: Davis: At the regular meeting of the Butte County Planning Commission held August 10, 1589, your request for a rezone frcm "Ll" to FIR -5 for property located on Calernbar Road, Paradise, was denied. A report of this mattel- will be made to the Board of Supervisors on August 29, 1989, If you desire to appeal this decision you must do so, In Writing, with an appeal fee of $150.00 plus publi.s'iing costs of $100.00, to the Clerk of the Board, 25 County Center Drive,, Oroville, California, prior to 5.00 p.m., Monday, September 5, the end of the 5 -.day appeal period from the date of this report. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office between 10:00 a.m. and 3:00 p.m. Sincerely, A. Kircher blvector of planning 8AK i 1 r T'I ` COUNTIX PLANNING COMM! aI Y 07 Count Center Drive Orov'ille, CA 95965-3397 ��foCo•Plenning (916) 538-7601. JUL 2G 1989 4ravlla, calif TO: Environmental Health DATE: July 3, 1989 Howard snyder RE; PROJECT REVIEW & ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION Enclosed is preliminary data our office has received or generated concerning the following project; Timothv and Ruth Davis APz 055-37-0-1.02 - Rezone from U (Unclassified) to FR --5 (Foothill - Residential -5 acre parcels), located on Calernbar Road, south of Wayland Road, lying west of Neal Road, Paradise. (File #90-1) We are making an assessment of possible environmental impacts and will be preparing an environmental document, either a Negative Declaration, Negative Declaration with Mitigation Measures or an Environmental Impact Report (EIR). Please provide any factual statements, ideas for investigation, or opinions you can offer in your area of concern or expertise that relate. to e�.ther physical, social, or economic impacts that this project may generate Please respond within 1.4 days of the above -noted date. I1 no response is generated by this inquiry, the>i it shall be assumed that there are no significant environmental impacts which are potential from the project: We appreciate any assis::ance you can provide. Sincerely, Does your agency wash to recea,ve a copy, of the env"ironmental d (initial. stue3y for Negative DJacl.aratiotr (v ith or without M tigooumertt ation Measures) or EIR for this project) 7 -ES No .. AIM Butte County Plannicig Covanisson *-I County Center Drive Oroville, Calif. July 31, 1989' Dear Flanning Commissioners: in, regards to the rezmng application filed. by Timothy and. Rutrl. Davis... v� requested a FR -5 from the curre�it u zoning of their parcel (AP/{055-37-0-102) . We stro,igi support their application to the ;fullest extent_ The development in that area lying cast of Neal Road and south of Wayland Road has been: on 5 acre parcels Cie feel that the other property owners of this area would also agree to a FR -5 zoning instead of the inappropriate 30, or .40 that now exists. We would appreciate -a:rezoniag application to be sent to 2207 San Jose Avenue„ San Francisco,, Calif. 9411,,):, Once again,, we urge the Planning Commissicr to consider ti' -is zone to us all.. .. Thazkyou.. - Sincee1 parcel APS 55-37-0-90-0' W 10 01 ffutic tount LAHD Or NATURAL 'SALT" A �.' c, r,U PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95966.3397 TELEP"FIONE. (916) 538-7601' August 1, 1989 Timothy & Ruth Davis 5158 Eden Road ParaOlse, CA 95969 Fie: Rezone, File 90-1 Dear Mr. and Mrs OaVIs Enclosed. It a copy of the Staff Findings concerning your application for a rezone from U to FR-5 for property located on Calenbar Road, approximately 3/4 miles south of Wayland Road, Identified as AP 55-31-102, Paradise. A public hearing has been set for August 10, 1989 at 9;00 a.m The meeting Will be held In the Board of Superviso s' Room, 25 County Center DrIve j ErOVIIIe, California. The Planning Commission recommends that the applicant or their authorized representative be presert at the hearing to respond to any questions the Commission may have. In the event that no one will represent the applicant, please contact the Planning off'i'ce prior to the scheduled pub 'IIe hearing, Should you have any questlons regarding this matter, please contact this office between 10;00 a.m. and 3:00 p.m, sincerely, 8, A, K i rchcr Director of PI,nning Eire-Cit L, Moore Assoclate Planhe BLM : I Eric., 47: Indsan no ��{. .� 4 :/ . �'t«•� _moo. to • «. l q � N ,� {Vi 7..:wJ'_., of / 7►r-s Z ,;tw P� ,�. •` ' •-'A` • .r/'• ,04' Stnea Cl y4- f G Sr — oney ,� / m ` = f3rnnk � { r / Goa ary tett" a f c� � �' L *� SunnysYdn o� / pancn c / j Of Wjv 114 r�y .•' ' npjrvbO40l 0, III / �1 t'ARmi SE p F q tiro i o NousE � : • ; � 1 a , o rl� 16 32 • y r • „ � � ,• ••' f 191 4 ' ti Ir to c- � +t•, learCraek`• Ranc h Road11 • j bul Inca Or riot iern ' ✓ Flat OAd 1 01 R" C y t5trpeMbottl oc s YAWN OF 'PAR (S 1 PARADI RRI TION RIGT BOU GARY a+ +01 rr �� I1 +� 2tj+ +1 a�+ 7 alj 271 <� II w�i r r I i r r r + r FR-10 271h op gqr PRO � 7k 1 7C 1 >t r� n jl!T FILE BUTTE couly"Y PL.ANN(IRC COM,MISSigN (�:It��4I Tt`�'Imd= w� raAVI S AP r . SC ALIv cirri EXISTING _ ZIONE, noun LAND OF NATURAL VVl;AL7H AND $EAU7`( PLANNING !DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3397 TELEPHONE; (916) 538-7601 July 18, 1989 - 'r�mothy Ruth Davis 51,058 Edebn Road Parad I stet, CA 9596-9 Re: Rezone, File 90-1 Dear Mr. and Mts. DaV i s : The Butte County Planning Department has completed the Initial study of potentlal environmental consequences anticipated In connection with the above-mentloned project, a copy of which is being forwarded to you. Please review the enclosed checkllst, noting particularly any environmental problems which could be minimized or avoided by the care and manner In which the project Is carried out Also, please review any recommended mitlgation measures or conditions of approval: After reviewing the checklist, YOU may see ways to Improve the project deslgn. Design Improvements to minlmize problems are endollraged If you note any er)lors or om I r.s i ons In our evaluation, please bring them to our attention. You wi'II be notified of the time and 'place of the public heaeing for your project'. If you have any questions regarding environmental review, pie ase contact thlb Office between the hours of 10.,00 a.m. and 3:00 O.M. Sincerely, Di A,. Kircher bj ctor f P in l4rig' . rent L. Moo e Associate Planner Ent: APPENDIX I C OiJATT'St op 13UXXIE NV��CaI�7M N AC. CIIV_CKTr SST Foam (To be completed by Lead Agency) File 090-1 LOG NO 89-07-03-01 AP NO. 55-37-102 I. BAcxgao INTI 1. Name of proponent Timothy & Ruth Davis 2. .Address of proponent and representative (if applicable)! 51:58 Eden Road <. Project description.: Aazone from U to FR -5 Ii. _ MA1ViJA?_C�FZ3C T`�NT7YNGS bT' S:CC�.N"l� T'rA.ivc1✓ I. Does the project have the potential to degrade the quality of the environment, subs.antially reduce the habitat of a .fish or wildlife species; cause a fish or wildlife population todropbelow self-sustaining levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal community, reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plant or animal or eliminate important ekamples of major periods of California history or prehistory? Z. Does the project have the potential to achieve short-term benefits to the detriment of long-term environmental ,goals? (A short-term impact on the environment is one which occurs in a relatively brief period of time while long-term impacts will endure into the future.) ;. Does the project have impacts which are individually limited but cumulatively considerable? (A project may impact on two nr more separate resources where the impact on each resource is relatively small., but where the effect of the total of those impacts oil the environment is significant.) 14. Floes the project have environmental effects which will rause substantial adverse effects on human beings, either directly or indtrectly? IZI___K)R- IER) XN.A`_C:ro-It (To be completed by the Lead Agency), On the basis of this initial evaluations INE find the 5roposed project COULD NOT have a significant effect on the environment anti o. NEGATIVE DEG1.WTION will be prepared. INE find that although the proposed project COULD have: a significant effect on the environme:tt, there will not be a significant affect in this case because the MITIGATION !W SUW described on the aLtached sheet have been added to the project, A NEGATZ % DECLARATION will be prepared. INE find the proponed project 14AY have, a significant effect on the oswironmont, and an ENVIRONMENTAi. IMPACT REPORT in required. DATA;: ,11J1Y 12 t 1989 YES MAYBE SO V,_ COUNTY OF 8=E, PLANNING DEPARTANT rent: t, Moore _ Associate P-1 '/17 t1eviewed by! i IV. ENV TT2CyNM'E.'NjrAL. 7'mPAC'1rS (Explanations of all "YES" and "MAYBE" answers are .required on attached sheet(s). 1.. EARTH. Will the proposal result in significant: YES ►1AYBE NO a, Unstable earth conditions, or changes in geologic substructures? b, Disruption, displacement) compaction or overcovering of the soil? c. Change in tonography or ground surface relief features? ..._l.. d. Destruction, covering or modification of any unique geologic or physical features? e. increase in wind or water erosion of soils, either on or off site? i', Changes in. deposition or erosion of beach sands, or changes in siltation) deposition or erasion which may modify the channel of a river or stream f or the bed of the oc^_an or any bay, inlet or lake? g• p g ly productive soils outside designated urban Loss of rune a ricultural �v areas2 h: Exposure of people or property geologic hazards such as earthquakes, .to landslides, mudslides, ground failure or similar hazards? G. ATR. Will the proposal result in substantial: a. Air emissions or deterioration of ambient air quality' b. The creation of objectionable odors, smoke or fumes? - v c. Alteration of air movement, moisture or temperature, or any change in climate, locally or regionally2 ---� 1, gAMC Will the proposal result in substantial., fj. Changes JAI currents, or the course or direction of water movements in either marine or fresh waters? b. C;hmgas in absorption rates, drainage patterns, or the rate and amount VCJ Of surface runoff! r, Need ,for off-site surface drainage improvements, including vegetation reiitoval, channelixation or culvert installation? d. Alterations to the course or flow of flood waters? _ �G e.. Change in the amount of surface water in any water body? �. f. Diticharge int,w surface waters, or in any alteration of surface water duality, including but not limited to temperature, dissolved oxygen or turbidity? g. Alteration of the direction or rate of flow of ground waters? v h. Change in thei quantity or quality of ground waters, either through direct additions or withdrawals, or through interception of an aquifer by cuts or exCAVAtions? i. Reduction in the amount of water otherwise available for public water iG supplies? j. Exposure of people or property to water -related hazards such as flooding! 4, pLART.t1F'EtZFF, Will the proposs,l result Ui substantial. a. Change in the diversity of spezies, or number of any species of plants (including trees) shrubs, grass, crops, and aquatic plants)? b. Reduction of ttie numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species of plants? J c. of Species of plants into an area,, or in a barrier to Introduction p now 'sting species? t1'r d, Reduction in acreage of any agricultural, crop? W2. f r , w r 5. 'ANIMAL LIFE. Will the proposal ,result In sutist.tintial. a, Change in the diversity of species, or num}°.ers of any species of nnimals (birds, land animals including reptiles, fish and shellfish, organisms or insects)? b. Reduction in the numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species of animals? c. Introduction of ttuw species of animals into an area, or in .i barrier to the migration or movement of animals? d, Deterioration of oxinting fist; or wildlife habitat? 6. NOISE. W.01 the proposal result in-;ubst�u)tiala a. Increases in existing noise levels? b. ixposare of people to severe noise 1.1als? 7. LIGHT AMD_ LAKE. Will the proposal produce significant light and glare? 8 LAND USE, Will the propotiai.l result in a substantial alteration of the present ote planned land use of an arta? 9. NATMW, RIMURCES. Will the proposal result in substantial: a. Increase in the rate of use of any natural resources? b. Depletion of any non-renewable natural resources? 10. RISK OF UPSET. Will the proposal involve: it, A risk oG explosion or release of hazardous substances (including, but not limited to) ol, pesticides, chemicals or radiation) in the event of an accident or upset conditions? b. Possible interference with an emergency rehp,�nse plan or emergency evacuation plan? 11. POPULATION, gill the proposal alter location; distribution, density or growth rate of the human papulation? 12, EOUSINr. Will the proposal affect exista:,g ,dousing, or create a denwuid fox additional housing? 13. "TR.AIS'SPORTATION/CIRC; i1..AT'iON. Will the rropc5al, result int a Generation of substantial addit:onal vehicle movement! b. Effocts on existing parking facilities, or demand for nev parl-ing? C. Substantial impact on exiot.ing transportation systems? d. Sigtrtificant alteral-iont to present patterns; of circulation or, movement of people andhr goods? e, Alterations to waterborne, rail or air traffic? f. Increase in teaxfic hazards to motot vehicl.,s, bicycc,ists ox pedestrians? 14, KMLIC GERVtrES. Will tho proposal have an effect upon, or result in it need for new or altered government services: a, Pire protection? b. Police protection? c. Schools? d Parks or other recreational facilities? a. Mmintenance of public facilities, including roans? f. Other^ governmental services? ,3- YES, MAYHF NO 1.✓ r 15. VIMY. Will the proposal result in. a, Ilse of substantial amounts of fuel or energy? 11i1Y8E No b. Substantial increase in demand Upon Existing sources of energy, or require the development of new vources, of energy? — v iG, UTTLI'rTIES. Will. the proposal eerulf°. xn a nerd for new systems, or substantial alterations to the f'ollrwipg, a. Power or natural gas? b, Coam(unications systems? �. c. Water availability? d. Sewer or septic systeml? e. Storm water drainage? v - f. Solld Wast and disp6sal7 17. HUAftW HFALTH. Will the proposal, result in: — a.. Creation of any health lt,,rard or potential hazard (excluding met,;al health)? b. Exposure: of people to poUnt,isl health hazards? 18, AESTHEffCS, Will the proposal result in the �)Gstruction of any scenic vista, or view open to the public, or will the proposal result in the creatioh of an aesthetically offensive site open to public vie.;? lq. RE,RE:ATTpN. Will: the proposal result in an impact upon the quality or quantity of existing recreational opportunities? 20, Ct1LTURAL ):ESSOURt�ES, a prehi�torhe io al result in the alteration or destruction of a cOs r'historic archaeological site? b. Will the proposal result in adverra phyviral or aesthetic effects to a prehistoric or nistoric buildings oe stru-.ture or object? 1 / C. Does the proposal have the potential to cause a physical change which would Weel: unique ethnic cultural values? d, Will the proposal restrict: existing rel-,giour, or sacred uses wit.rin the potential impact area? 7]S C`LTSsx�►i� c % 1�TtTr1 Cil MI♦:7�`.T;AT... J,:,VAr-TYAX'-r N See attached, DISCUSSIOirG OF ENViROMAENTAL EVALUATLGN AP *55-37-302 lbe Development of one additional homesite would be permitted from the proposed rezone which would result in minor soil disruption, displac emeni, compaction,, overcove.rl;ng, and local chajlges In the topography. In general, the terrain of the project site is mostly a relatively flat ridge top.. As a result, minimum amounts of grading will be necessary to provide for driveways and building pads. The Outte County Grading Ordinance is anticlpated to mitigate any significant Impacts caused by the necessary earthwork associated With residential development on the project site. In addition, the densities as proposed would also help reduce the overall amount of necessary grading and earthwork required`. ig: No loss of prime agriculturally productive soils will occur as a result of this zoning amendment. The project site Is characterized. by residual soils from lava flows, rough rock outcroppings boulders, and shallow soils overlying Tuscan formations. The site of the project site In conjunction with the poor soil conditions does not wend itself to commercial agricultural operations. Soils that are typically found In the project area have marginal agricultural value. Ih Some seismic activity has occurred within the' general foothill zone. All of Butte County is within a Moderate Earthquake Intensity Zone Vial. Construction of buildings to the Uniform Building Code standards for selsmically active areas should provide adequate protection to residences In case• of seismic activity. 2a: Some short -term air quality Impacts will probably result during the construction phases of developingresidential housing on the proposed 5 acre parcels. Increase vehicle and egUlpment emissions as well as increased dust during the site grading and preparation will occur. No I"ohg term air quality Impacts are anticipated by the addition of a single-family residential unit on the project site. 3b: The project will cause some minor changes in the absorption rates and resulting amounts of surface runoff due to Impervious surfaces related to paving of streets, parking areas, driveways, rooftops, etc. No significant altering of the basic drainage pattern Is anticipated. The density of the proposed project, 1 dwelling unit, per 5 acres, will minlml'ze the amount of Impervious surface to Iesv than 6% per lot. Such densltles will have very little Impact on surface runoff and drainage patterns within the overall drainage basin. '11, The pro posed rezohe wc,uld �lloW the creation of an additional homeslte on the projOct site. Slrjce there are no commUnity Water systems In the area, individual wells are being proposed for potable water purposes. The development of an additlo'nal single-family home on the project site may deplete the limited aquifers of the ridge. in othor al`gas with five acre densItios on the south r►dqE,, the Infiltration rates Were hot sllf f to i etlt to insure reoharg( and resulted In drawing down of the Water table, Limited Information is _ 5 available on the quantity or abundance of the South Pal-adise aquifers. Wells al -e commonly found by water witchers and other means Of Intultlon rather than through scientific: or geologicpr Information. A potable water supply systems should be agUtfers will U prc+vlt�ed or proof that the r� pport the anticipated withdrawals of water associated with the proposed density should be made prior to any subdivision or development. 4a The diversity of Species will be expanded as residential urban landscape plantings' occur and non-native species are added to the project site. No sUbstAntlal reduction In the number of existing avecles Is anticipated due to the five acre rsizes reuired by the requested zoning and the overall density oflallowed development On the project site. Prior to subdividing a botanical survey should b0 condUcted to determine whether Sldalcea-Robusta (Butte County Checkerbloo;m) Is Present. This plant is listed candidate 02 species, and 1s known to occur on ,d as a federal the project vicinity, )acent lands within 8c The proposed Spherein the Town of Palladlse.prThecTown oflParadise has recommended Infland csuppo the the Butte County Planning Commission rezone -2 supported this. area. Surrounding proposal of FR -20 for prosect site Is ndi g parcel sizes range from 20-40 acres. designated by the County General Pian as A}1R (Agricultural Residential) and zoned "u'l WncIass(fled to FR -5 zoning I5 a canditIa_natI )• The request. Agricultural -Residential General Plan desirgnation, zone to the General Plan requires the following findings be madAs e such the approving the FR -5 zoning request: prior to COND`I.TIONAL'ZONING AND QEEVEELLNT CRITERIAr 1. Compatible with neighboring agricultural act_Ivlt es, 2. EVIdenc.e of adequate Water and disposal capacity: 3. Availability of adequate fire 41 AdegUatel:y maintained approved facilities, pprovecl road access With sufficient capacity to Ser4fce area, 5. Reason4b I e ecce --M. I b i I I ty to commerc i a l sery I ces anti schoo 1 s. ZONING PACTORS, 11 tklstlhg parcel slzes and residential densities. 2. Slope, 3, Soil cohdl t i ohs and water availability. 4. Effects of ad.iaceitt Usesa Cro forestry, resOUrces extractlonp cfProduction, Wldllfe hab�estock grazlhg 5. Proximity to publicublic raac,s anand other public facilities, 6, Dlstancea from Airports, railroads, and indUb&I ai usiss, Exlsting UtiIitles and dralnaga clilt 8, Potential fcr surface crackfh- lndsli les, des, and ero 51 Lffects on noise,; trafflc flow Andsafety, Watersfoh. gi.lallty, Wildlife habitat, and quality air 10. LOca f des I' res , general en�r I shin. rata f OLIa i i ty , 11. Potential for pest/tnsect breeding, 13a,c,d, The requested rezone would allow the possible deve'Ioprnent of an addltlonal single-family residential unit on the project site. Such development Would generate approximately 10 vehdcle trips per day over the existing trips produced by current land uses. Ten vehicle trips in and of Itself Is not a slgnl�Flcant impact. However, cumuIat1v6ly It poses sub tar.tIaI trafFic Impacts to the area. The project site is serviced by ;.-, narr,ow, mounta!nous dirt based roadway: Such a roadway Is cons Id;:red Inadequate to support the anticipated traffic load. In addition, the existing Street network which provides general access to the lower ridge ar,=A Is limited to Foster Road and Neal Road. Both roadways are narrow, local residential streets, Which have been impacted by South fridge development. Both roadways have been forcedto operate beyond their intended design capacities,. Development of the proposed site will further add to the cumulative Impact of the ridge transportation network Calernbar Road Is a dead end roadway which does not provide through circulation,. All traffic generated by future development on this ridge top musttravelup one tingle roadway. Currently, 1 -here are no proposals to make Calernba,r Road a through street and this roadway services more than 20 residential lots. But L,! County Code Section 20:133 states., "No cul-de-sac, In a rural area, shall' provide sole legal access to more than 20 parcels, except where all parcels are more than 20 acres In lot area or clrculatlo*n is not practical or feasible because of topography" Prior to any subdivisions or development o -F the project site as Allowed by the requested rezone, roadway Improvements to Neal; Wayland, Foster; and Caleenbar Road Would be necessary to mitigate cumulative traffic Impacts. Recommendations such as roeAdway Improvements, Implementation schedules, funding options, must be developed prior 1. subdlv'Iding In*;,der to establish an adequate transportation syst:CJ;,. to service development In the South Paradise area in accordance with the Butte County circulation Element, and the Butte County Subdlvlslon Ordlha.nce. 14a: The ,project site resides In a high to extreme fire hazard area with minimal fire Plghtlhg capabilities. The hearest County fire station wh ch Is Manned year round Is located In Paradise Pines, Couhty Fire Station 033 Which Is a0proximat;ely 8-10 miles from the project site, County File Station 005, located approxlmately 3--4 ml les i'rom the rr�Ject site Is 'a seasonally manned fire station for the wildfire Seaton, Increased development at this site would Impact on local sire 'fighting servlces provided by both the County and the T'i' Vlh o,P Parad 1 se � Due to fiscal constra'I nts and the threat of fire s'�a{,Ion closures, fihancing methodology should be identifled and Implemented for fire fighting purposes prior to any subsequent subdlvlsioh or _-(uvelopment of the project site. 14bt ISuttO County Sheriff's department i responsible for law enforcement and protection In the project: arda4 Rapid development in -7- rural areas and restricted budgets have reduced 'he department's ce,cpacity for preventative patrolling and rapid, response to emergency cGclis. Prior to any subsequent development or subdivision of the project site financing methodology should be Identified and Implemented to maintain the Sheriff's Department at an appropriate staffing level. l4c: The Paradise Unified .school District has been Impacted by rapid urban growth on the Paradise R I dpa ' area. School fac I I "I t i es are close to capacity and as a result a -_._,1oo I impact fee has resulted to -finance new school facilities. 16c The proposed rezoning Will result in the need for an additional well to provide domestic service and fire protection for the additional building site allowed by the new zoning. The water well will need to provide suitable flows for domestic and fire protection uses The water supply and water quality will need to meet the requirements of the Butte County Public Health Department; Butte County Fire Department /Ca I I f orol la Division of Forestry for fire p _ nk I ng water Act protect and the California Safe Dr 164A Individual septic and leachfleld systems are proposed for each dwetfing, Due to the Tuscan formations, sUrh systems may be prone to failure. This areal. Is subject to high groundwater and springs• A large part of the area have very shallow soils. It is anticipated that numerous problems will arise In issuing permits on the proposed projecl. s i to and meet i ng the reclu i rernecnts for sol I absc -pt I on systems for disposal of ,sewage. 9 -Oa- The project sfte Is Identified as an area of high sensitivity' for archaeological resources. Due to the high sensitivity factor of the site, an anticlp,ated subdivision will be required to perform a records check through the Department of Anthropology, Ca4lfornla State University, Chico, In order to determine If s i gn I f I ,ant s I gilts may be located on any property proposed fc)r subdiviolon ;tr development. The records check will determine whetheo in archaeological survey of the property wlII be necessary and whe:O,f„r any further mitigation measure will be heeded; BLM; i r ApplIc'ant: Timothy & Ruth Davis Assessor's Parcel 55-37-102 Log * 6e-07--03-01 DATA SHEET A. Project Deschl_ptlon I. Type of Project: Rezone. 2. Brief Description: Re?one existing "U" (Unclassifled) to FR -5 (Foothill Recreational - 6 acre parcels). 3. Location: on Calernbar Road, south of Wayland Ruad, lying east of Neal Road, In the south Paradise area. Also known as 4486 Calernbar Road. 4. Proposed nenslty of Development. I dwelling Unit per 5 acres. 5. Amount of Impervious Surfacing'. Mlninal. R. Access and Nearest Public Road(s): The project: site Is accessed by Calernbar Road, via Wayland Road,, Nea,I Road, or Foster Road, 7. Method of Sewage Disposal. Individual septic and leachfleld system, 8. Source of Water SUpplyt Individual well 9. Proximity of Power Lines: Adjacent to property. 10. Potentla for further land, divisions and development.: Under the proposed zoning scenarlo two lots could be created by sUbd i v l s I on 13. Environmental setting Physical 6hV I ronrnent: 1. Terrain a. General Topographic Character: Relatively flat ridge tap. b. Slopes Varies from 2-10%, c. Elevation: Approximately 1500 ft, A.S.L. d.. Limiting Factors Nohe: 2. soils a. Types and Cha"eatterIst1cs Soil is mostly characterized by Aiken stony phase; stones comprise approximAteiy 60% or more of the Volume of the soli. Solt Is approximately 6 ft. deep In the project area; Residual soil from lava flows, rough oUtcropplhgs, boulders, and shallow soils. overlying Tuscan formations also exist on the project site. b. Llm I ting FactoVs+ soII depths are shallow; underlying volcanic mud flow and outcroppings. 3. Natural Htz&rds of the Land a. Earthquake Zohe: Moderate Earthquake Intensity Zone Villi "9 Cultural Environment: 10 Archaeological and Historical Resources In ti'ye area: High sensitivity. 11 Butte County General Plan designation. Agrlcuitural- Resldential. 12.. Existing Zoning: Unclassified, 13, Existing Land Use on -t0 tet Opeo Space Grazing Land, rural residential estates. 14. Surrounding Area: a. Land Uses: Open surace and Town of Paradise b. Zoning- Town of Paradise, A--160, A-40, FR -10; and Unclass Ifled, C . Glen. Plan Desislnationt Agricultural'-Residentlal, Open Space and Grazing Land. d. Parcel Sizes: Parcel sizes range from 10 acres to 163 acres, e. PopUiatlon: Rural residential, 154 Character of Site and Areal Open space With rela,tively flat ridge tops and canyon l oild Areas. 18: Nearest Uiwban Areat ToWh of Paradlse, 17. Relevant Spheres of Infiuencet Town of Paradlse, Paradlale Irrigation District. 18, improvements Standards Urban Area: N/A 196 Fire Protection SerVlcet ai Nearest County (State) Fire Statlohi County Piro Stat lon 033 located ,approximately 8-10 miles north of the project site. Seasonal County Fire Station 086 is located approXIMAteiy 3-4 miles north of the project site off of Clark 'Roam, 1;0 " b. Erosion Potential: Slight.. C. LandsIIde Potenti,;lt Moderate. d. Flre Hazard: Varies with vegetation type in the Paradise Area; however the project site is generaily considered high to extreme In fire hazard risks. e. Expansive Soil Potentialt Moderate, 4. Hydrology a. Surface Water: None, b. Ground Water: Underground aquifers- are generally found at depths of over 500 ft, on this ridge top. c. Drainage Characteristics: The project site generally drains towards the south and east Into the Dry Creek Canyon Drainage Basin. d. Annual Rainfall (noriria 1) : Approximately 40" per year. e. Limiting Factors: None. S. Visual/Scanic Quality: Excellent. 6. Acoustic Quality.- Excellent. 7., Air Quality: Good. B oi;oglcal Environment: 8, Vegetation: Chaparral, sparse foothill Woodland. 9, Wlfdllife Habitat: Upper Sonoran Life Zone. Cultural Environment: 10 Archaeological and Historical Resources In ti'ye area: High sensitivity. 11 Butte County General Plan designation. Agrlcuitural- Resldential. 12.. Existing Zoning: Unclassified, 13, Existing Land Use on -t0 tet Opeo Space Grazing Land, rural residential estates. 14. Surrounding Area: a. Land Uses: Open surace and Town of Paradise b. Zoning- Town of Paradise, A--160, A-40, FR -10; and Unclass Ifled, C . Glen. Plan Desislnationt Agricultural'-Residentlal, Open Space and Grazing Land. d. Parcel Sizes: Parcel sizes range from 10 acres to 163 acres, e. PopUiatlon: Rural residential, 154 Character of Site and Areal Open space With rela,tively flat ridge tops and canyon l oild Areas. 18: Nearest Uiwban Areat ToWh of Paradlse, 17. Relevant Spheres of Infiuencet Town of Paradlse, Paradlale Irrigation District. 18, improvements Standards Urban Area: N/A 196 Fire Protection SerVlcet ai Nearest County (State) Fire Statlohi County Piro Stat lon 033 located ,approximately 8-10 miles north of the project site. Seasonal County Fire Station 086 is located approXIMAteiy 3-4 miles north of the project site off of Clark 'Roam, 1;0 " b . Water Availability: Water tender only, ' 20. Schools in :area: Paradise Unified School District. w hyo'u'tte coun f LAND OF NATURAL WEALTH AND BEAUTY -- .. ,•sem �- PLANNING DEPARTMENT 7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE - OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 00965-3397 TELEPHONE: (916) 530-760,1 July 3; 1989 Timothy and Ruth Davis 5158 Eden Road paradise, CA 95969 PE: Rezone, File # 90-1 AP# 055-37-0-102 Dear This is to notify you that we have received your application for a. Rezone from U (Unclassified) to :FR -5 (Foothill -Recreational, 5 acre parcels) on property located on Calernbar Road, south, of Wayland Road, lying west of Neal Road, Paradise. An initial study of potential environmental consequences anticipated theButteC"OuntyoPlanning Department project willbeforwarded by p J g Parried to you. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact this office between 10.100 a.m.-and 3300 p.m; Sincerely, B . A. CES) Director of Planning BAK :feu. y I 4 BUie COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSI140 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CAX 95965-3397 (916) 538-7601 OuflO CO- P1,nnnfnq Opsn% OraA`, C id;rorno TO Mate Dept. of Fish and Game DATE: July 3, 1.989 Jim Snowden 721 Cessna PE: PROJECT R73VIMI & Chico, CA 959.7,5 ENV•IRONIMENTAL EVALUATION Enclosed is preliminary data our office has :received concerning the following project: or generated Ti,�othy and Ruth Davis kPu 055-37-0-102 Rezone from U (Uncl:,ssified) to FR-SthiljFoy iw� ( , Residential -5 acre parcels), located on Cale-..rnbwr Road, south of ,layl.ana '.load, lying west of Nei "--e. Riad, Paradise. (File 490-].) vfe are making at, assessment of possible environmental amp,-+ctr- r be preparing an environmental document, VT ument, either a Negative Declaration with MiiCu!wion Measures or an Enviroaunental T �"+, 'C.`WCG C`L" (EIR) r M Please provide any factual, statemett8 ideas for investigation, or °p -pions you can ofwe,r in your area of concern or expertise that relate to either physical, social, or economic impacts that this project may ' g"nerat� Please rxaspond within 14 day, of the above -noted date: If no response is generated by this inauiryr then it shall be assumed that there ane no significant environmental impa is which are potential from the Project. , S'!e appreciate any + assistance ` +"tance you can Provide, � !7P� 1 �•� avG "10'60d dub'ed ro eco Sincerely, Cr PiX)d a. Cvrre ho commtnts of 60p�y'a Oth—�t1 signed by, JAMES 0- HE58ERSM1T1J �-�� P-s�CCYtad,4litr�dCr gf v'f Pai, r7dfY1d Lai ry Paintex20 �1 Planning Technician J1JL . 19 Cotrlents Droit al studycforiNe to De a c�oj7�� of the environmental �#o`cpu�ment ( g c,laratsorr (with or Withou i s ' Measures) of ;alit for this project) . a i*,, b�ga'tion NO;