Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
PARADISE UNIF. SCHOOL DISTRICT ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
wle Gkac� urd,z sib;►�i�d urp opposed zhdvrrametl4 of the V.11y Vi►v jub-Vivi$iori aild tote ANOr°th ,E"10st xrtr:iric Resour!,es Sub-Divisiob and, °(.,qu(58t that tha "IR board fret b tht-ae t"wo devc"Ir"pment s or, the vcJj I 'W�' 8�, ,t,l. tics t,k"��xt�u', out thlr,, �;�I� axte� ,,tthr'e��� st�c �� t rimy tare t asp t ' cin ` `�`�-rI fi urc,s Those cf zs l i v l r tier 1,not� t bflt Outi- lari ust grclgth has boon since 1975 2. ra laic "t .l .+'1�Oig On DFw 'y!"rai 1. r�3 �}1ii i5 A�jf/ r�t4�ti1. tJ t.l.✓rig "+ 6°rY�eL1y ;4.. 1. M+��f .. a Alvem-o tivll`� be increa�;ed 1C,1+,,4b the' tti� :Ib�t�.iv� �'.r# � he Developerit e�ti,mite 560 trips per day from the Va�IOY V,L.rw ;0:D o i rxl:�:�nc� -- �;he�'i this fl4,,uve is` doubled' by; t<<cr th 'gest F�r�ci t'xc 1jcj urtccS' t w311 'Pu't 1.1'20 more ctlrs on Oral vale �ivK�`AQe at peak t'r'�afr"j tImds t"zRYtile to gat on 11ti�y« 1624 Thi► l interstldtion is Ir ad y- c0ngamtor1 us ,. thea rr � ranco t (phl'r 301,4001. As Cr�n'z;;;estaetl j ,ptart:1 cta� , lray*iy, Aare rain; days and during sthool �,gncticoz�_, d. Is taro ��x'Iccd lor14, 0a,kv'aIo R�1rc�rlt.k� up, to :i1.e either d:rr��'ti���, r�tlxx�n� School1Otiorls. T1,z s increased tr4ffie puts cotjr children's sa` telly in ,xcp,k �k;t' 'tl�it?11 1.r1a%rin; to c,ro C;� ;val,0 Avenue to F;Ot to OPhjx jehool , as; l 'A ac' "is .tett"'. that this inte,rae.-Otirn co'�.ld a 0 e problems, The Lrovo3.opgrs s tflte tha-t, 'lall.oy' View S1111: gOnerate' only <t `itkid lits at; C,�phir C�io+ of y;:.nd 'thl!'t' a ttlls CC)�:l,d 1up '�algen '�nv� the 'ib-;livi,sion to dal %vely to d °f qtr {'menta'V cp�-_n,,e3 jjoyy y�o�y to y "r 5 ,•. _.,F IL3.1:' U. �:rYi� w.i t.V.+ll/ �, �1�tt V,7�QC-�i.�JM .F`ai'r f4an I `�hii snit -aiv. sloll kii�,".. „"'nor ate `E"; 1"iB t{h an ti`s isu, ' °�t �f4 �ii ;1; tl,a &1 Iublei by i,ort ,I e,5 tTh ref`cire.nce to a t �ry=Pal i.�ric :4�::�"c ! , r t, ►:rn t�� t�. : 'xp z°i1► �, „nA�:( ty� :'.r « iiarc►ld Cara ,� 1 �� ..M��:�t �.lti ` 1 �: ' t .x -� .� » h. r�r i .,.y Y. a. t :l yp »'�'� 'V vx•4 t wy }I �i . �.ri fil.Yr 3�+�, ry 4. - 1 u � yy 'r S yy ��. �. t� �'x, w ,:'� �.V,. ". :,, �'�yx-.,.�i,�+.+ t.�a .t ei .. .i 4.�C4V�4. i.;� VAL fn'.,(Vi0,t�11 Al -'N a") iV� Ywj ��� ��n.v44r%tr?(: t L i. %Y,u— would,11 to t .iR. :a .i ix: -`i,� ��. V xl i�Msl i:i A}� i e' i°�li �;`�'; ��3�� �.rr (.n %� �yY•t YJ, 7e" �� '�'1 �.y t��.G �:r�. vi �t. �l,�: rf �����f',J ,l ' x J{ 101 1 Lit 1 1.1111 Ri+r�1IItOt.i i/1y r'�(`,. °).°r{x{ P 0 f4l�iw i v ,>I� ° a .' i� 1x1tr a r' k'` w t 9�zry � ;r�"1 � � x�,� d ,►3r i �e t I- L, �° z xi ,,in:. ry �.I' alt A x. I'4 ��Y 'Ar.in 4^ a ,f,Mn x lY ...4 4'M 'v b.sYr#� 4 4.V. 1'.irte,! btit 4y� ri �1 .4`rs �. zw:.,i Vl1 i"i ii iF. i�./ An,1 '1;.F.Yu r,lyttto w,t":`�rar ihi4 '..'. +5�i$�.37 ti - ick t�i y�1' ,.ityti .4r to!A't'+! 'NJ'«.k ?«iF", M"1"a.I:1 is 3 t ;''i'i a ';j'; . ' l .i . R�+ 1' an ty, h w < (�i°a.` Rfa r i 4: �C w# 1, c.a VO 11 L" hr, p"v0 R{ y" s'} i xl C1v4.cv� triwt;� ya.!rpl�x �'L�i"igr.:w�L f�"i�n� 4��jk� 7 w+k4e t kfri'. y 0 :a �Na�`e l i�w tx6 !h J aft 4 j t �►{ °1 �r l,xrr �' �'�*t- 00r%c'i' C'alfktr rrrQt=vIfra 4ac�x:�,�xt frb*nro06tv4"lim ';ez l011S '} ^{ r-� yrs. #. [ y Y 1x'I, i figs y+ 'yA♦ .L Fi,l �7 �,tp %rrt'�?V,�1r W- .�I {'+�,`M1'*.'V �,+in7, oni i4{,t i «��.. r..�a� 'ith Y i <x hi x°": '4 �"F���°�'" x��� ., i°i �'���� aJ 4p • "�F w�i. I`��A �� � ° Y"a; & x�wA yy �"} �'i�y w! y♦ N {:x {. 6x �� �J. u� �r'�►� ° %a xVl w�i,��k�,.�r7, ,� �� ltl,n` ��v��i +.t ��'4.+�. P",� i.F� !ta a' r+�« '�-�{+moi �"'%cr �F�.;�y �f��°»X Y'V� k»�F:�� #a�. ,r d "i, M� 1 °v � �'.• ,V 1. r'.t x iy,' 7 �'! m4 el 1 .i,+ �li�vx".L. i+',�+t t'ry irP , Ip•r^ ! �! � �'.�. } , � � � : �'� t M 1i D �� � i y: J L � � t .t 1G � Yyc �•� '� 1 k �q �y * ug ,�. tr t'e, Sx, .tuT.Y. t '+�,'Y'fyja,"5'�,p w*.a♦ ,.� rw+v_p' R if'�i fix 'e:ax$i�d.,, rj ,�. !w .�j,t't - a f� ' 1:. 14 aubl oivfaton n1ld th ov North eOt PU0i..N:c1 !RP. 0,184,attb—DLv.1,t)i:wxt i sand a"equ,o aL t:hnt thoy x,144,o(,mr' tt• voato t hb5n ' two 'cievr l 'c rrltr.a G"�a ° t Y� t'Gzllcawa�4� rsiaa�;�sn �; I a DO vOlop 8 ��t i�41_:3 ���i� Ir[iro4ir�l�a #,4� �:jMCa �"x��' c(�C: �.k5 tl��Ti,it.,1 �,J�Jm �i x•I x.,y. 010Y arlo basod "'leo e a" tai It -vin here `.:,taw lRt1t �1�1R' In rgot *t growth has i btM r7 3i1'lce 1075'. Ir1`:lxAve' r .,�1�: �., r FRY ;, , , _y c� pe u 1975 stati,atxc� t:t�a;i l td -o17 is 0. '4- t raa�a w`11,1 R itir. `t� ;.�}+ 011 1); t: {, t t a lay Dj%Volonetr a.ytt..t t to �"A,t1 t;r.t�p� lax drr y j -_O 1 'tk��l alai lr% Y `f'lt+1.� aa1,�r,l r� �tt"tc�l�l th t°1 Xtra i.S dotil3 d by k;rrLh 'Weat }ar S. t, I t .111 tyr�t 1�?�r� G��div�10. Av ,-mile .tat' n�trl1, tPtr��t C� e L,1 tO g0t 011 llwyi .t.tap. '.'�t*tl frit s' tinn ` G .r a.3, ari,r�j��4tk+"+ tlr�: tWaa4r+'i, rRee to iph1 9t;�'l,00l i q 0001' o,4,11 t bd y 1'iC'1Fi 411'1 r•'iln �d,t;";3 xt r �'»,_ sx , y�,i .� t' �z�� � ,r:i�x,�,�` +�t�laf;}r`�, `� i•lnct?,1r�x1,r,.+tl"°i aal"i 1,:a1+i;�ax.3' A; Ca:11-v.alo, Avolitio up, to 'Mille t:4t,laiWrr t� � tL xt �itrinf' aa~a�t, 17• �a i'tlti rt,kt `i°fYi.ra ifar;t+ aRae i vva:xrrlo put � 011"T ch11L,rix� ' Ceti t in l"l:it h a 11" ,l, l ig i to p 1 o'n .., &.' It via to A v r Pn ),e to z a; t t<ri Ophir, Jehorxtl. t.`al A,rwaa .� rlt tt t� [-hat thIl 11'ot.aarue,ct on ct)jld po x. . The Dt ol oper.y :.q taa t z tt�ttt; 7,111ey View will co; r to. 6nl it :;''!+'halts at Ophir 30'.0olx 0,0 thrit a 1;ti could c toaken �nti0 t:ka'r� .xati" livlaal0nr to 8,11ev1;11*e &O.11tira.CnI �'.On-('; i��l_b r 1 •i sa't 1,'711. �I"�"1M''�� ( q�l i�� + Lt;t., azt b—d1v1S1oit wi, Jtt�l+a7'nt P far r °";"t,l`t� 'than t+:1 '�'.1,r''4Y1: j�.t p . ,� � 3 x til "la kl �taa U�' l�sor_th aj��-�t,_� In ; eJ"� i° rt�� to,a t�a, l�llr`;l�a a B as +tats a.at,1 art �tr Vit" J1tpr�x Ilit end �qt;�� i:—��alrtat?fl_ 1a.:.t t,.. x►: �rylZ i»lr,� l t lR 3},`+ �1 ' t t 6l 1 at» t :. NSS &n`3 D alt=cam that tat< tz•�rryt ietk:�'_t a btu; would cse taIFon, llt;t� t'xAK ,r tt� .,tivt:altJlat�i �tl,yt"i<�eit�s dithln a, One the0lt�ral laior � Ili t1)1n,; �r.�l�i,rt� ':5i�.t,�nca� `�h�:r0' 1s a,� ron nfjw I,) � r rr r r,+ �t � �,+ � in t t t o d aaum cca��.�rt. �lyf� ch.l l� dn. of y �i,i�;ttt �, xx1,# 11ira l`l hfr o'cho"11 Di trAct, GQ be tyLls�rv'Ci: {:i'1',i61 s chl d ei1 cielR4V, 0 t C t 11 t:t♦� t„y.. hM Fw. r k �,� ,.t �4i:,xtas� aly,�� "u��;��Gti;t, tax"r•r,�s� ��r��t ` e tae ' t'y 't� opt r; i r S�ct`► t� „,l "► , t' ;� `�;a (( s;rt +i.twcX., rG Gly ,fit w l..! cont�!ntie to, dr;s l�'25 � 4 C.�a�/+��1T a `+�♦ .Y•ll.+� k < .11:1•«'+'X" U:a, i- U1, `xi tri,*0 ti'i..l..a, aF*kr!�Vt C.1` litr• 1 t r, Y + rZ1 fit, tr� pp,A e,d int i t;ts3 c rx �� yy � 9 , �j t W� r tl �. bw, t'I .iy t Cf �' �E. 'd--nn:1 ,. �i ;v y'�"j �" ;tc)� l}� aV,Cj1� t}i" ,�r'.? t 1)r�t3"Et S� " 471 1i' a' u' �r {� r n w^ , v inE 1 xy' rood t'l•C�cfl l:'1'i' 'ta 1.0 iC to 9"> nM c ez, ..._ t st i�` c t . OJt.a i , ��I'i4t i,�tta ,i.;� not r ��allf;�� �i �k r;��r� � � �'.lxak. ",fit• i,«A:t1}.l"i�� �t�l.'a�`t:1�t.� i ;� �' r "{ 'wt t k'.. +r't� i.l.�rl' OPel , 07-P0n "'C' ,U 00 ft irlpy t}� litw:i jx� q M °irr Yyr"i k, 441E 1 a q qqy p u yy } q y i t, w ti 4 k t,eF i��K o ryry;l � r''tv 0 a ;Al , ' �� � i"E r ,t « y i � .�� t cr e-, j + w � � a' r � (t ` Y11", 1 �M.L t,k ]}� �q �x d�ryij,_. }�K., �,/ .�}1�.1111;7W 7 'obi 41rr '"N, . x - "its L,,.a 4)7ti 5 * e We 1iEat uzlciex�s;Ly rad elf"e t�PPOSPPd 'to �l:b cteVelopbent u ` tE�l.n E'�l t;,." t.e�t " E irrls car �a,ad t,E1r1, lort�h WoJ � Pacifie i3esnl�a'c�� �a��-i7���,i���tarlrj requus t thn't f:h WIR lso(tr'i 'O to f�"Oe t'WO d V'0:L0PJ40; is 'or ti c 1, +h4 i7cI VeiP ers, st ,it titics, t ,"roup.k 11 Ut; 4 a� rJ 71 :Taw 4 .Xd'ol6 rK"Rfr" ' 4 tEloY are a,od kirl 197/ f:E.lylXl'i","i: �EiG7w{� 57�' 11 yL yF j -r"y .j y� �"h '1 -rlwO _ li�;i:�ry� -bene .t,ri'ar.w: ViYth 4an., 'b .�'a i hi�✓.C,Alo.+.�. -3,0!' .+. _ 2'. 1. o1 1 .tV�l� [ • ."U' 'ka1It lr' L t3Q J.AC!"fM, ,,ed r by tk;e ttvvo s,ib.:; avis t.ori,'�; Y , d Ebt: � dx3Vt 1C�ki X` �3.= +i'd;. J� l' ,r `` t X Trt' �� per dnax �"n tz ty..x a y ... fey' a s -,# 3 D 7 t a�xt�► .. �rE3 tl t;Ex t ;, t"i;;u 'e is doubled kit ANorx t;h ,� �,y �y � j� � y y A, F). 1r P (, ci «�e it WI 1:1 but i 0-akvalio x�vanu at RwnS ' tr r' iC t. txr� 3 I.r1;a t ,Axa,trrv.Gf2,43s17tI',^c't'Loll " is already a!,ma dit�tr�d trrolla -� t r+ 2'1taL� ll� �l to ophir i>c1,0 :� a N0 ao,J- " f_ �, �1�,, meted, ,,ir't�x�uN ly�z M /r�7i y(y�{;p ,y;{/{ n i� a school i'1xr7 �.�arz a,-rN T illo,nt O Y(A b. ♦FW xi{(Kx* UP y_ LbyA i■ Mx [�i,t /J~3 4vh tail i cr �,,. itlkrsr ri lrecti� r� (ILIVIn :7ch(jol J'P.a�t; oligg, r�s��d tratflq .put�. sur' ch�,ldrWil s safet r + q yy y� } } j yid ��:Cl X11"uy �VEaerz ti, itltlt9 tO S.rot;;3 Oaltvale even MCS ;.d t E7L` 4iN+4110C . Cal Trans StY ti a that tt.io intarzec"tio co,i ,d poor-4' aEle 01s " 1)��vi�t��Rr`s stag til&`t V 1.1- flew ��t�:�,ll 3l Rildents t onhi.r Schc i a t;h�it lis cauZd , , n rate, cr�iy sut� division to �11QV,Late additional coliZestion. ems. �'We that this• sub division, will. =°,Onerato 1"ar More th�ne�;�e�� ��a 1100,1 Drt,ed 31 wh i ohl v�1.11 ag a,wtn L) doubled key Nort'la j- ,,t, rrj r _p.rxence �1, tc irµiahanc�.�n r ' #�iPofx jiti� eri.nt� enda t 'Ir. FtarQ d �n t i �«1: * ..:j� c� ►, = --r } Esq Indiont�ed' hO relt. °t!�.t,s' l�I'cjcct would artgdiuc :rc:e ti7;�a the Pt'OJr Qt(`d 31 Ntudentts- id gt:at d t hat at 1 i4tJ ,�r'tt Esc cct d in, race " x u"ITUa�tec Bart l�us resl lr be tal err into ul -.vi si c�nr_, �1rlyttilli g "011,tlAll � one 'a.i l rtdius of tile school disAnnomi Therc 1,St a s tronri po3sibi- lity, t,h rtc�r i r, :a �,ivUld b ' dr�l it caz;�inr; the childrIen, 0,z' "t fi en t 1" i I c, �dt llts krr i �a C 's hia+ i G D str .ct to b buto,eti to Wier tt x e�,�z,:A^cr zt t~Eac,a: two �lcveiriat�rt�ts. �i` t?�� ilfirct� do in tat�v�ta���s taw+ l; tl1�e c��7r3 st''hh0e tc;Mi �t;�f100,) tEaa.� not Daly )i is t�Y�r�.t �y �" #��y .J 1 of 011A ldreil y d y 5�xri _tt� xt ;> h zt ♦n w�Rµr the proof )r,j .O y ilr.xtr1��1 til` ��r� ��ct� � "�F ��a vya.l . , c r�tr =0 to dr s.1 as it currently 4�}p�c;vil'ya;e3 �, t `in the lAroc'li;.ti S," � �i � CCIgt ilf, to drain d((jes prorlf�m l . Yw! Y Y tx Ip h F i.ro TL a�"f � t'y tri .� area titi11 Of v ^F���i:ior� .tr�1 eVen 1 ttx� °. i ; at t � + r sofa' :� a y d �cbd } cn sick ery�l� °�#�� to� zqc-3;i o tl5re slc d� 5%� """ 4�`a.'i;�'r✓ar Y ,rr S �etga r�ilr s cav,r rt 1.1-„fol,” to pr.ovfa; r'i ,<tc xax" rt x �tzacr� Y k,, y tae raw ir0 � e��.ivirr� OX d�C' 1li F;a rhis. ro Qot �?�'����#M� �Fl�'��"t�wG�. r�.C� �" �t dire � et1 1 o hJ1-1 riir i ct i i b x vxlld M regtl is ,dd to tolko tib n ss of s toss iticra is 110°t worr ned Y dov,e .e r� `+and t.h "tlt 't yrtdh fw'Ci 1 ";t Cra.x }�k city Vc1� per z. ik.rit ka�qvp ccp3 a,inod of,jc)j' V ter �yt Lilt `x";1.0 rd. e1 .Tt riQ Vl .l r d u., di. CD,: sta����- fla t thrix s stcr s( ulr. e ik h tl c fir; e t.1� n DcVo,1 �'l rair is pax `rie tEa �. 'Tl leta� aux # U:4 m ,fit" 170 Witor x t ;eurrert 'es", Y " 13 ;`,: 1- �o ('1143 Lill, erai.gnOd UPO Opposad to the dovd:;Apc;rr�rrt of the Vaj e;y vi.gw Alub-0401JOn Who o Nt ,nth.Wool POW# ResourpeA 1ukr-l7.ivjs.Q all raqunst Pit the i`IR t pard- veto thaso two develwr,ramonter for tine l.� 'rh D voloAar 0nt4st1p.s t:ta.r"&tapt;nrnl't the sit erre uneonl. $t4 gar, they aq leased oil �ri'�`1.r.:�i� fir,,.ires. hose of us living hare know thatuUr 14r9d t growth has uen sinap 1975 24' Irrgrfi,� � U i lr th Developers 1515 statistics . tr�.ft e o �d�xtxv;zxe AVAU0 W111 bO i.nCrPL.xexl rel � b;;� t�ha t:wr sub {i!.vi i rarl,�r I'he i. �Ovpl.eap0rs usLITUp 50—t rips Per dray from the Valley Ww 3;D. n 1,,13a" ;dhOn tbi.r flaur z Wdatiblod by . orth. weqt padi.flo R0 61rd s . .III put 1120 smarev�dr a' orr C)rltVs?'e Avenue st agrtraffic ii& trying ta got m1 iya 1621 This irte�s�eGior���vlr;cyy cop>T o'.4 t. t}d find danyar6gs tR?q entrance to O 1111.1 Oichool Is coX'1,gasbad, part4au- I ir•ly on. rain.y c pys U11d (iurinschool funct:ionso M5 are par°M Won; Oa kvr)la kvi,nue izp to 4 n1le eit"iiZer :i.,roctl n during,,`icdAoo C►. at<tans. Titi:a Irlhroaaed traffic pats Or ch.il.tirab's safety in joapardy r,A.tua h4ving to ;:r O. OKi.&c AVen to get to Opbir a rahaul; +.,rl M3""and SOtc'!;3 that; this ir.L{ (`sect {on cu ld pO o prahlens. I. 1*:31111- '4'he Davolopers state tfhai Valrley. View Wil,:, zenerat;e only 1 students 0 t')phir ARM and t nt a bus ool,r: be taken ihtc� the,a,atx»�"�4,vi;r On to vl'lovi to additional cor2estion ploblems. it too! t ttx 'L this 80"division will teen;; seta far More than the suggest d is 00 ti01 V 41x1. 49011 be dqubled by North lleW In roUrpnoe tom s 01 Ophow convolau LOW with sup6r i s tend6;n t� t . arolda Cor at l:t"45 rd<aa on 90W4l 49,, he `indiaatr�d iso Pel tr Chas project would OrQraaa lama tlda t;h prjQd tnPf 31 Mid= and Xte i that at pr���jogt he could in no: Wa,;, 3Wtq,inntea Onto a bus would be herr into t.t1da;'aatb-dLvlsl.d�it.,. nythina Whi,xsa one mile ka i.us of t.hca sr;hoo to��oati��,�t•�:�� bii.hij walkAnq didtanea. There is s strong posa:ihi- I i LY Chu u'd Al.itr 0 Wdul,d Oa ciFawn crus.i�ng the childron of pr, oaun t 661dixants wit'hi.n 0.11114r 'IchoQi District to be busaN to obher .rphc'.ja ,, .r�;d'�lar•,, c9€Ltk k<l;�r'.a�a talo-Ad:Velc.iri ants. if ohs ahi' dgendo, txs.ve to Aho d 1stanno ;to :;plydaol MOW only puts their atety .in Ri,dQ alsd ' rbduce etre ex" bl � o,i. .t lNS ��izka��t-xwra-torr, 4�A�r���� iZ�iiv#+��b PrWAY TWA A AN . QAOL /0 of ,tt, .ro 1, r:t aJ. va #%1. &t4ai14:.A ?liAO to dr1uld:'hM3 it +i..k4'.i ri i1.4 y ,Iw.z• t' a ">a�j ,.r 'lei r r � �r tl �� ;,�tLh Moats will c nt"ntFto drain init t ' 1 AY2�m.ka��ai�tl ; x"a`Vert th , u 'wx'{ g will To s;t�t.jli..�i, bb?!l�l�td`fy oCtJiyl� aJ.,�4y�yl�t`;,i� }o/n iA ;)y :13.t tPdW WrV 1101f: a�`y wl' t<y {[d a.l !+i� 11V',r�l•r A•'i3 11`J•'4 t ny to t)040ini POKL "irk',"•''O.A. uwurs Q41,66, aw'G'v�*'? a. a 0. ilIt i_ d, dot )1 i r lir xs r in Rlti �'�{°5iM1�et1`: .adir�lti Gad il,*ped tm y����r'«�»,it3t::pyai t5 :il• V a'lv t "iii ti atr �90 t, ,.)r" :agcy 040't'victons bo TV p j. �!► r '� ., w;��rry re idi�R.*iaG'�:, 'i��rvp` pd:�t�risl��innd �!` � dlt 4vs,t'or pres�rxz",� ;drdrl. {�� pp y� y j� q � � Wy Whims y yy ^.* % nr d t na "A1'�1�hm d.�V Jam¢" k��F t� L:ry� - SY SYI I IJ1�f i..i �� 4ed. ,ir rxl Y y �y P Y G' f"10{3 V11 � �la`6'd4i�C1M`% 4ir,drtt�'iri7dt �.�; .i► �' 'LJ. .�`i;l,t�tA�':.' C�R"� � "�"��1 }'(�Y� rt ��` i.,. 1 tiffs i,jy: l!10 ISO, . n t�r,:.Vf�,i�yi;,";M""r.lt '<. w�tfrs lie ta.{iwt r �tl;x 1'`ek�i�t �u,'i.;y tyt� �.1 t�"3 '".'• � t w "} "^. � to �_:. t'�q 1" ��5 rt " �, " y Y ' ;1e Cho u:i,l�:rs,l.� 1�tcS '<r�"�: �>k�t+s�s M tib the de elopm,,nt of tt.n �'fx� i �y V l f� ,r «� ,lmw.L that tho «.iit oo;krd. veto 't1 nse, tWo clovr'lola firit.;l for the f 0, 11owi ", z'0A.,0ta,r ' �o 'etla I))veI e.r,e ;ata,tIati.e F rthe gall; are waro l.istle c,ri Lt.►x y rxro ba, ti, ..l �r� � �I�i.»`t'#� Cwt t I v e 's. -hor'e op u:s 11vizyi, here k:rar��r ttxrrt lily lnrlgiast ctruwth tv, I ocf, �;11Zrr 1 t'j. " 'ii,a t"ire �- U:�in ikiAF Developer's ���7� atat�� �tiC.S � i,rr;,rf'1, sera- Avenue, will, be l.nert�atierlAIC41,1n by the Wo sub -per vlsle�r�Y�, The 6'sltl:,Vit�ei 560 trllsd per Tay-f,xrori the Val.Loy "Vii.w cY]I^rlrl ;- wr'hcr1 trk7!s £ t;tizc it doubled by �'Ior4h tY ;it T' el' e icl`ws1Ix cns it al•l.l1 put 1120 ; oro odors on Oplivrale Avenue at; prirrl~ t`114C'Ci:C: Liz -not, tzy:,14,, tk7 .:t tt� kkwy. 162. '1`1��r� lyitersection t:3 �r.l,r ;e",t�r�cl rrr1'1 si:z r; car,,III,i the 0llt.rarlca, to Ophir N,ct o01 is cor►„os tad, WIarLlct�- ] lIrly oll, r "i'd'ly d,Iy� rlri4�' d r1:d'.eq sah,00l fllnctIor” s; lwpl�' rx;••o ptrlm., l ,1 ; .'ik va) e Av'o:no : u, t� i s;l� c �,lt.l� .l ? _ x�ct` to rt' CkL r, trip �3�lrtr, I ru,i,.'tiOtis, "?hl_.; inf.woaoed traffic Jnjts Cur on:11drr.ri'r� Satety In: jr�01141%� W1,11on having to ero!%; O. tVu1e A14" =NUe tea feet to 01)1111, Jallool., "r'l Tr »L tv t t:� ; t kIlit t Cs ]'.rr t �1I's rrc# 10n Cc totyv,r pr'oyle.rr 3. Tho 1),Ivolopevs. s t',xi'rr,e l' Y , "11.111 o V iov wi'lli1,en,e.I'ca; ,P. only 1: :ata;dorllxs at 'Optxk' OGlt,ellrld tE7rat ;~, could be Owintoen into ki3 ll'— "liv a-10, tO vl.l,�..vla'te addl tl,��i-�a cr e- c..,stxion prob e".ls: Fie foal taifi.lt C. 1t irb- i'ivl; l� l.a rr111 ' ;��r� � � to fGr -ore than ttae, s �r��l:e(1 31 wh+!o.l. W111 na.ill 1,o O>NaE b, lod, by Nor't,11 Test;;. In viference to rz t l.,uc ltor7a co,"lvlakaattri«.n with 3iiporiiitendantj 'Mr. 1%;h,rold o"rn it ,.), 041 ,-Z6-'J"g.tte in4icatod lice feIt this project w,01110 G Se: klvoi3o't (»sl 31 s"it..�C.l�'3C����"� s.nd � t-ll1ted "tt1�t at tyT03i'lrt 114 1"OQU 4E1 lio �,iw." P;iarrlrtteo t t ju,s 'watld be taken into 4ny.tElinl Y lti)fn n' on .r± lr 'r6'11U or tk)r: setl,olel t4lC zko(I t'�ii�k:l'in 1�ir��k'i�"�"� ��l si,t�r�cie. '�'hr�.rt� 1 s' a )txC�tt� pQs�itkrl" .l tyY t'#l:.rt new wot"r1; si be (lrrlarl7 ytt�to ych fildryen o'�f��"SS''p1k'+�:/�on/t��1 1 .r `ice Op , n� 1 r .. lye I✓LtJ", $!hl LC7 ., L"�t. i]�y1 in l:. li�i :�tt�.� tditl li ci?�xi`i� .:rchool, D46t,rict, t thostl two.If the ellildr6n do have' to, Uwk d stwlnot) °to school �i.�oloolyth,O.o0t only«mitt tIkveir saetyIn J"I.I.r4110 0- t•ia fla wit�l`ol;is but al,,q• 0 .t.Yl ll�0z1 :;t;Y\Fi„I�'—all,LL11r,� !it�'rrii.I'9, p1��.i1'£.itX.� }���0'a�'X"tY to'' '.�pc"yt'ar SC.l`r(�ol t.'XYc)y�y, t ll s" 4r x' y} t c J"J'('A)rt1.Y i ..i . i,e 1 * aai ry q YY� ' l"' 4e 1 ,-r � i t l 1'` s to �" 4 {: " w w t r c o � t � iit.�,,,:. to, jos Y� y`� °� �. , •A �i F � F y (, 1 L'.!t Y. M y l .:{. �✓ ,� drain, a i n �r wv «r�aar.~th�.; p«Yn�sk1V�C�t ttl;tsat�ayt'rll:l k;YY.r stz+lpied o.t* ve�:�t�t�orr A,��(� G 1, ti t i ti 'i.f �'� jE�[wl]����� J., 3, �wnl oiCE.'1�+�.� i y ",� `, 'sl; v I, n 1G' ,' ;«':; O,:� r " W It ., t 1 i w ." e�Y Y r ,Y' i '� Y Y r �* �v�r1t. ~1,�, iw �1� tx��,��Yr�.y i.la�t� r y b:l.i � ��'CkY«Y t, r,...��i.,�'Yl,ttd c..r.err� 11 If .l r Iry t. hl,"i 11U;O"�,Aoo: "vtitC!�l f1(r,"' dr1n �ir2 "Ifs"l till. � �IAd 'v 0,1*AY��a. 1,"1 WvII+'�a��4� �lv�:: 1"t�'�,U l %"1?� T�� `�� : lKi �k"l�' �����`�:5��'� a ti��3� t,��1 w,�� Wc 'r f.M not �x,r.`:�ri rn'd br �i,.�.�,t3 "r�e�el�Ypnr�.,ht �nal,d tr � ,' �. Y ; Int cai a I t.t.fS"i Y 1 t tC1T1'� lZ�z sib t'k'.r l'�evt, 4 y� 7"a,, 6Xp onrie 'srliai `di�.-�J t i�,fL '{itlt'��1�d�����`% p� � �iF �t'1` aq'w�a x 'l qq i :, W;i x" r X 3.1«1,, 0 raw a tii" "Xis : W.i t.tll Hyl : I, grs�trwlir ;'i �,y �it'f�l�.on, d:�.�7" lad«,�xyl�wYft iw�rr�� Elii�l t�,�+.i:�: r3t�r,t,e� �l:at t'.sejr' 1�nw .rv,tv;;: sro►al.pl ter; " *«= r } era ocy`,'i"ta ".nti'k�i I r1 t t.li m tl.,«1w til. l�«� r.,;lnp , } kF d r. ;x .R Ci�� no w11,110U w Daub-�ijvj$1Lo1n and the Nox h�i�tes>r�FaO3�'�c Re ev�rlopmG?t t; of the Valley V o�,r z'egi�estr ttaait; the JsOa d vot these tv�o Ou:ec s sub-.Divis, a r�r followfnq xleasons: pme.nts for. the. .heY cavo+�pors st1c throe Ftout o bci,�ed on � H--75 urns, the �rTFt are WIreallst c :gas that o lar est Tha,re of us 1 lv n ftrre Icazoty '. growth has begin s�?tce 7. 2. Trt'f c �. Us1 1£ the De.ve-.o p ers 1 Coal va7 e venrxe 1411.1 be 1nar�'ea�ecl�x�l# s�hay��hers traff' c on Tltd 1)eVOl,opers ost i;nato 5bq tri ' two �ub- alone - v 11@1a this fi ere d1visions. t< 11 s doubt.edeb:idt�1'o,rth�gest �Paa11e, , tr t.tt� taut X 2� mo° e coxs o.n Oakvale Avenue; ate f c iesotirooa ` � °' het on Miry• t This iritersebtlon ls. Alread Peak trff'c r ' ��nd �t=anl;c�rous _ �: times oit rain dahe etxt.ratloo to. 4phir School s cony - - y$ and, during, Y l pa es cid a.l, rig, t o Wale Aven,11e a to �. � school f^xnctioris. ����$a, I�art��cu. ti�i tt , s'Th n rar e e tlter d4.r ' ction�d Cars sc�i3� "d 1s lXcreased tra :r, puts our children's se. l eop�xc,y �xhen 1t�avlrn to cros4 d1 TIix�s sttE,s 1;Ila t this ntarcect;otavirould'to yet tb 0phry;achctol • jcttc 8 -- The Devi o e ys s t pose prol)140$1 1 studenvs at* op'la rpac,hsoot to that dall,e, 71elw will: on to tai 1rctrl ito ada�,d th4 , co � ;�cnexate only 1 s�xtd that. a bus could he ta�en �ratc� the that till s sub.-div;Lsion w 11 n,7estion vrlt °cit will again b generate far problems", y »yore the the t0lU.Ohone conversat of 1 d b ortL� "x est, ester 3,1 on n ��rlt,lt Sa1perIntendanir 1lr..x ro C to a � pOdta�w _� „ 2E - Corn ext .o., fi9y he ii1 cated !te feat th1W A e thr art the pxwo' ec�tod. 1 t Project would iyt� crilt_ 1A= - coiil:d in no lira, r ud ont s ozad stated 'than tha su -ijj 'isiottw . Y uarantee that' a l us ro id � °`r �.��ti:3it'f * 'J th ,a�n al lti x:'rar�� t t t1 a oale ''r ta�S� J. lity thca„t i1,?t! iin=��. a ,dt,�tsnce ����e' nodus �,. the sr�t�ool r �sic3eltt,� t° L'L� , 's 'WOUld Lac nolle: �,s s strong ; t�ss�k�1� dxri,lx (7SuS�arY phla Y�clroel nistxict to, benbuss�e��to� sof 1 why .i ��' prx't L ate these taro' d0v0 Opm nts;: l , " llw ti, o stCu oe tb 4hC c other scf�ools -i 1ta.2• r d110 to trax��1cLt�ori�i!tric�t��t�ba�t.o��� nut hildren db h��,�� to �w ..II i of ry the r 'et , rr1 WJrCjdil.'! s 'jtla p't�.i�n 45 .-,W1 pr,t.�le�, or � n y -+tet; arc:n will ° cat~ty+nue to r�jo 1 x'ihl i" x ��^°.2 nhc" Stx'00ts 4� "Ai lei w� " it Ci yr , atfl � tit. ' z�oa Will litbc tr i.n t WAO to dr �.:'i i f ,tk,�vh the ot,.tizt o kpo of y 1 ` 1 rwiL.Ma r thw ,at sr « ,r4?�a��ta *1.iifr.G� to ��5,* hbi ? ' �« r s ' iw � ey' VJ-0vr�� ;j i "� �» w }: '^ t. ,dye y a td`a" ho t�"E�Xr3'w'A. ;;,q? 1ii"ati A i Yk i�4 t�.Z.0 7.1.IVt1)fi. W ry.w 1 ltcz-e se f100-din- t tltn; tlxiul�cy�r-o�ated.o ro twRw+♦ �yy �t 1�rd ,V L�w.✓!M A, S tr„�A A (;w f^ f f Y' ti M yy' c y .�)I— ryj}:{ j�}iv +y 7 p yy ph r a�Flnpy.y?Wis In �p� }{p tL F�'�j.;LI{y:1 L�'+rrla. k�'tJ e��hrf����yykiib,��a1G r{(s no tt . ;r :t.,l,civ ttL`w1 have '01 1. Al at .,r Qvcr Lfcibo t `' »7.4:'T� Via, ?ter a:r a� P11 `t.7'l sal tJ�re, St C. Ir"ihA�s�,L �t der, Lit^ olid n bar the, tt3r:io tkx+ Mxt�"cta tLxt .their zteAtcpe olaias tto ,uxtx' utt , rat`' o�r�a� r t:t� nt. a co a o ^ys et». should 'k)r, or+wr r,ix'rr t%t4 «y �sd+i.:�7}ytn Y' kir Atr tw 'Je the urtr�ex igned aro opposed to the aevol,c)pment of tv, Walley V: Ow uY?-i�iv siori ttrld the 1,10r 'gest I�ac:� i'ic Resalxrces Sub-Divig ,u rid request tht tt the . T s aea:�d. trcYa these two dev�elo.pmeats f(?r the foil owl'tig reaStXIS br v l ° p rs s a t� sties througt.jout the EI are r ax eal istic �; they aro based on 1.9'7���'� �i�ures, phase of u:s livingYterci ktlara� that aux lamest rowth has been since 1975. On 214 jr �'� c V trig the De ~elopers 1975 statistics - tri irvis ions ,. . - �- Ciai�vt�le Avsntte W111:be, l,ncreer3ed 104% by the tt o sola-� . ��1e llev ldp ra eati�n to 5! NOTICE''OF 'C0NIPLETIOy (oDraft env ronmen'Cal ImpactRr-*,'nn,-N1 1I1 r 4 ., 11 ' �1 ..� ♦ .yfl - SOCS TES` k ** .R �IICHj, 71.1L]Cl Cr 77�� ryry administration & test PAULA t8ASURE !. resia,atohi & anal sis GL'NNt�A RAYBr7RN Qxa�l'aics, For the sum of the firm rel r f .. Ass`ca iaEes, wa's zeta 'b tie Schc�o7 bisttil>t to 7 y the �'ara'c sA L7ni1 zero rizre th t.s tpo�- t anr'1 uciate the bistzcts Environmental mhe. relation hip. bet:wecn ;,Coop Cyu del�,,rx` s. � k . AssocxaEF,s a s, contractural and pu,'$D Ohl eristin Y'. with no other rejatioxtah t� 5 between CoQ} Assor"jates and the tete subject xo `ect F[J 1 ox roncJusit�ns xnvoverx+:in'Cht•he5�rerahaonof'urnc 1 I,3 re o t �,iexe ccotn lis, iec7, by Coo .�,ss'ocaai eS independent basil; on a I TABLE OF CONTENTS k�AGT; AP PENT TcP,S xNDE . ••• •..,. ..•..•. .... .•... is INT.RODUCrTXON �I'T pROJEC!!,EDESCRIPTION A. GEIJERAL.,..:...:... •.. B► PROalCT LOCATION. «f ..., ..•. .«.::.a. .,. . C OBJECTIVES :SOUG IT BY THE PROPOSED PROJECT , .. ..... D DESCRIPT10il OV PROJECV S TECHNICA.L,, SOCIAr AND` ECONOMIC W'ARACTERISTICS, 1• GENERAL...♦...',..♦.,.......:. ♦.•... ••:••.•••. 2. PH!SxCAIt PROJECT DESCRIpT.XON•: � ..; a. ACCESS. - .....,.. 7, b. PARKING ... ..♦. $ c• STRUCTURES• .. ....•. • ., ..♦.. d• SITE CLEARING AND EXCAVAT 10N......•9 •r. e. DRAINAGE;: •••: ••♦•• :•..•.:„•♦ f:` IMPERVIOUS SURFACES,:. •••s, UTILITY SERVICE ........•. ..:...... q` ,LINES. •. ..: .......... ]1 12 •: h: StWAGE DISPOSAL.. :. .. - .. . i . VEGETATION PRE SE;W ATION 12 : • o i13 ...o i.......• ....:... ... 3 • CONSTRUC�r,tON' PROCEDURES: 1t , . -;F. .....•........ .. 4 . ACCESS AND ,TRA VIC CIRCULA'.r ] 7 • ... , • .... 5. PROJECT ECONGMICS.: ...-.:;.. ]3 E. PROJECT, BACKGROUND.. .20 : ;,... • ..;..'.....: « : , .... 21 IV. DLSCRIP`110N. OFENVIRONMB T t . SETT17;lVG A. TOPbGRAPHY. A .., .. G'{ GEOLOGY' 8EISM !CI`I'Y-. ..:. ..• .•..:... • SURFACE DRAINAGE..•• .: GROUNDMVER 26 • ,• , ; • , , F. ...,.: .. ,.,. • � ' ` • • • • • i • • • • . G G�ILDLIF.�. r27 . ., :. R. ARCHAEOLOGY. 29• . ♦; . x. CLIL�IATO.LOGY:... 30 • ; .. ... .........: ... .,.. J: AIR QUAiTY• 31 .:. .. • 4.4 ..., . • . r .,.: ... K -LAND USE.. 31 L. SOCIO-ECONOMIXC :. ♦' Mr PUBLIC AND QUASI -PUBLIC SSEtVICS .. . ,= . • ..... . 33 111 fIA�E SU � .L .. I • i • A i.i• Y ♦ « 21 EWA,GE TREATMENT•: 3Z • 3. r ELS T • ., .... . :..: ,, SAS �..i C RICIT,Yr ELEPCIONE 35 .. • 4. POLrCE N, .. 3S 5 . .1 RE' PR0'ECTION " • . . • • . 3 . PARKS ANP RECR +'ATION, . 6 . 4 JN 37 7 SCHOOLS ..' ..•;,.,•:'..,.'...{•v.»... f® 38 8. PUBLIC STREETS. N. PUBLIC SENTIMENT 1. ORGANIZED? COALITIONS. .• •.. .». ..,.. ... 3.9 40 2• EIR COMMUNITY FORUM....... •; :•• .: •. 3: PARADISE' PINES: A RETMEMENT;COMMUi�XTvil ... < . • . .. • . 42 44 0. AESTHETICS• ♦. .... ,.;: .• P. NOISE..:..,,•....•.:...........;......,.i;:.:Fj; 44 Q. . TRAVVIC .. ..; ..... .,.•.. ..,..., ...... .. .... ,V. ENVIAONMENTALI IMPACTS 46 A. B. GEN,ERA1;.... .......,.'...•:....•..;.. ..»•,».,.•.:..;.... SIGNIFICANT .,ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OF T8 V, PiROP600 PROa.ECT, AND MITIGATIONS 1• TOPOGRAPIICAL IMPACTS,.. ......... ... ».:.»,••:..,. 46 2 SOIL IMP. ACTS.,..,..... •......::.,::....: .....- 46 49 3• SEISMIC _IMPACTS, ...... ......:. ........`.. .: 4. HYDROLOGIC 49 50 S., VEGETATION IMPACTS ..: ....... ....::.... ..: 52 6. 'WATER QUALITY IMPACTS, .,.... ..• 53 7. WILDLIFE IMPACTS.....,....• ...♦.... .',.... 54 $• TRAVVIC.xMPACTS•••••I.•••••• •,,:•.•i.w:♦,•:•• .89. 9. AIR. QUALITY .IMI?ACTS..........,;.. ,..•...:.....:. ,:, 56' . 57 10• AitCHAEOLOGICAI) IMPACTS..:,.. ,...,.....;•.•., . 11. NOISE IMPACTS•....,. .. .:. ....:............ „'..«..•.. 58 59' 12 . AESTHETIC IMPACTS , . .:. :.. . • « : 59 13. LIGHT AND GLARE IMPACTS,, •• .. ,•..» ,,,.: 14; LAND t7SEAGE IMPACTS•..• .. ».• .•..,....•..,...•. 60 61 15. EI4EIRGY USEAGE IMPACTS ...... •. •.•......;....,••••.. 16. P08LIC AND QUASI -PUBLIC SERVICES' IMPAC'T'S s. BUTTS COUNTY SHERIFF DEPARTMENT :.....;..•..,.»., 6 b. BUTTE COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT., ..•.., .:.•. •.,:. 62` G• PF�RADISE PARKS & RECREATI.(JN DISTRICT, 63 di PARADISE UNIFIED SCHOOL DISmi2zT,� : U C.� CUMULATIVE IMPACTS OF THE PROPOSED PROJECT & MITIGATIONS 65' D. ,; ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTShIICH CANNOT BE AVOII)ED.,• 66 ' E GRQWTH INDUCING IMPACTS OF;TIIE PROPOSED ACTION:,,.•.:..... 68 F.` SIGNIFICANT IRR.VRRSIBLE ENVIRONMENTAL CHAr7GES WHICI3 WO'UL,D BIS INVOLVED IN THE PROPOSL'D ACTION' SHOULD IT BE 65 IM'PLE.. • • ..: , ....... ................ USES: OF !'!IAN' S» G. THE RELAT'IOIVSHIP BETWIaEIJ LQCAL SHORT-TERM ENVIRONMENT AND 7'HE MAINTENANCE ANI) ENHANGFMENT OF, LON" TERMPRODUCTIVIT`Y..... ,, .:...' .:. -.. • ..,:.... •:.::..:..:... 69. VI., ALTERNATIVES TO VIE 'PROPOSED PROJECT 7'0 A. No>P.ROJECT.4.4.::.... .... .... .... .. ' 7Q B• AITERNATIV,S SITF.LOCATION,S.. ... ... .• .... ... �. C• SCHEDULINu AL;r0 NATIVES ,. 7'l 1.' y.EAz-'' RCSUND SESSIONS ,': •• .. ..., • . , . � .. .: 2: DOUBLE...:. 7 D, EXPANS CON OFEXTST.INO FACILITIES . • • , .... • ...... • , . • . • , APPENDICES �; s � :nexl )?aqa fox' index ). APPENDICES APF8NDT DES'IGNATI:ON LOCATION NIAP . , » . .. .. ... , ...: , » ....... A VICINI`.CYMAP.,.»....,.».....:...:.......» STUOUT POPULATION DOT MAP—,. ... . di • 0,.. » .. , , .: » » C „:...... .. PRELIMINARY SITE PLAN,; ..» .... ....:... ..,. ..w... PROJECT PHOTOGRAPHS.. SITE ....... »...:..» ».»»» .:.. E FIREPROTECTION (LETTER FRONS WN1• C. '.CELE, COUNTY 1;'TRE OARDEN) w , F COMMUNITY' FORM .MEETING FORMAT. » ...... ' Ur�19�. SUMMARY OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACfiS...... )DETAIL OF DIVERSION nxx�.. ...,».: ... DETAXL OF ROCK INLET AND ND DISCHARGE A1M3, . .:. w ... :.. .T PrOPOSED ACCESS ROAD TYPICAI, SECTION..• .... ..» .».e.. K ..... ., MAJOR WILD.GIFE SPECIES, OF PARADISE ,(ex0erpted �,roxn 1980-1gg0 Town ©f Paradiso Gemeral. Pian`) • .......... ..;. .:..: L CONII14ON PLANT SPECIES OF TETE PARADISE AREA (excerpted; from 1980'-:400' Town of Paradise S iEATION PARADISE PARS AND REC DISTRICT LETT$R..., ... » .. ... .. N , SHERIFC' DEPARTMENT LETTER. .... » . .. .. , . ..:.... 0 , .. QUALIFICATIONS OF BEM 'S'TAFF INVOLVED IN'PREPARATION OF EIA.».:.. P TRAFFIC COUNIZ.MAP.��.. .�.....:: ..:�». ..»... ... ....... Q BUTTECO�tN T PU:3LIC WO2KS DEPARTMENT L�TTR. R •, BUTTE COUNTY EL VIS70NMENTAL HEALTq DEPA'RITMENT` LETTER.... IND ANn AGENCIES CONSULTED BUT ,NOT R'1✓MEN CED' 'IN TEXT).'. T » FOOTNOTES: .�»:.. . ».,. ..»:... .,�,.:... .» .��..� .. U PROJECT INITIAL $TUDY PktCPARED BY 1 t CO'. ENV REVIELjj DE T. �' . PROJECT ARCHITECT' LF,^T,SR..:.. , » >.. ....°.... :.:.: ... ... ... u1'' I. SUMMA'i�X the subject project proposes to co.nstruct buildings, ch. ild'ren's play facilities access roads, ,ancl Underground utilitieson a parcel of ground which, i.�' completely undeveloped. The 'analyses conta.inod, herein re.�vea), that the, physical environment of the site itself will cxper,fence a varieEy of insignificant adverse p r� , Lm a,ct .5 togethi,r with < the following identified s.igni£'icant adverse acts Soil disturbanr•.e and alteration of topoc�� apliic features; boss of vegetation, and associated w .jdl,ife habitat; Displacement of wildlife; Lass of natural, open space; 'and, Reducticsn in a,esthetirc qualityof project site: Mitigative measures have been stipul-ated herein which ubstantiallY Leduc 5• e the sevezit the y of impact; lasted above. However, the, mitigations do nod prevents the occurence of the impacts co?mplrtel.y.- The project Will also, creaee an adverse soGiai im aGt for those residents of the' Paradise Pines residential development Who relocated there to take advantage if what the antics aired to be a community reserved' Y P ,. for retirement'-age-people. The establishment of an. elementary school at the proposed: sate, as Well as I on,any parcel 'in the general vicinity of- tape Upper` Ridge, area, will probably et fact a change in the a.ge-t•.rend of future> Paradise Dines residents,; so that there will be more families' with children, and fewer families beyond the child-bearing :age,' Together wXth the significant, adverse. impact8 which wall ke r produced' by the pr0J,ect, this report; also identifies, several significant beneficial inpact<s as f0llows T "he site would become an eXcel.lent 1�epa.xMentr "commandpoaI andepacuaton center in, tha evon � �� �'nr of an ar a e l ere y Aver-c� oyvdi.no of V,USD frilities�r t cr xl eliminated; PUSD transportation costs viould be xedtxceti by $4G;000: I rAn enhanced educational env�.ronment would I rstx1f for Upper Ridge studente;' n enhanced educatinna;l environment would result for. students no 'sharing facilities with tlriper;' jRidge ,students; Pacilities wo id be, created for Upper ll qe area recreational ro, rams , a and, n q The site's purchase price ($100,00) grOa.tly, enhances the project's economic feasiba.jity. CONCLUSION The Proyject is, not without sicrnia:icant adverse environmental, impaet-s: However, the T)t6ject appears to be viable on the basis` of the following overriding considerations: The matiRaticn measures 8tapu]'ated herein will adea,uately reduce the degree 6f severity of the project's adtverse a.mpacts and should be attached to the. ,project as conditions of approval.; Tl e projec.t',s design is environitientally conscious and brovides £or maintenance; of the site's natural cond.ition,'as wel1,a9 preservinq a large, portion as open space; :, The proposed usa 0f the si e. involves a� great nuaber b b neCicaal uses Lor, and pcisitive �m n pacts � o the _Paradise co unjtY, y%y The: piroject doe's no♦ e.liminai:p the current beneficial uses of the site; anc, ti Alth0tigh' alternate ves to hhe project da none appear to be able to acoomplisb,the rneeded rel.:e� for the schopl district s oveta r-crwdot fncil t es vqittiout creating' mora adv'LArsc`` envirc�"mentalimpacts than bhe project. Y v,4 011 2 x� x�'rRQC7tIC'1'lt�[� This report is an assessment of impapts associat(id with tII0� construction of an e.1ementary' school; ' in the Par('idise Pines residential area. As the title implies, It i,s at7 "EnvironmentAl impact Report":r and not strictl'� � "Net7ative Environmental Impact Report!. It, is for this reason. that both cidverse and positive impao't>s have been ciltod for the varioud areas of analysis, Where possible, ma i ,i.gations for. the adverse impacts have been specified, whil.s"t7one" was espotase for positive, iitpacts. (obviously) the m�taati`ve r , Mitigations have been st'ovlated in two ways•--tnindative and sugcres five: When the word "shal:l" is used., it is intended that, if the project i.s approved, th.e mi tiq:tion become a "should" the project approval. the 'word conditi an of When is used, it i.s intended that the, appravinq a,q'ency should to the mitigation a given, seri.us consideration ma.kinq condition of approval, if at all feasible. Accomplishment of some of the s,Qgges ted mitigations are dependent upon the `ot:her Public cooperation of agenci es, such as the County the_ Caunty in e Department, and 4VOYks Department or therefore could not be specified in a marndative manner. As the Table of Contents reveals,. 'this report reviews the those nature of the project first, based upon input from officials nvalved in its 'desi:gn and creation. Sect0 t�Ly, the report cOnt1#115 11f�7YMat�On. �'E'5�arched b the Cook Associates' staff and by the Bureau of nand Management 'SnvironmEntal Assessment for staff as submitted in their the pra7ect. rhe 13 data was accepted ;far this report and invol.vecl in the the dredentials of the ESM starE preparing infoYma t o l is included herein :as Apponelix ' 1" . , Then and on, the basis of the infox'mation contained in the first two sections, an ar7alvsis is made ' Wtth the result presniltecl in the form of po�ected - impacts the various pats of cro iect will have on . tti,e envi�anmeni-» La:3i.ly;, a discussion of various project alternatives is p'.resented, The repot is intended to be !comprehensive and complete. or avai Iab'le However, the potential; exists that some ,fac't de : in,l a.rrctltion was overlooked.. rt is for this r- of teasers that t,h document i;s entitled " DR''L' EnVixonmental Impact Re Ari ". it, shall remai6 a` draft during the ; zeview . "FINAL ' period prvi ded by law, and �ril'l not became a iX1L Environ t 11tal xvrpact Repo. Un,�i. pula] is and :ager cy Yespoes, togetherwith comments by Gook Associates an those' Yesporases, 'axe at;tachrd to the. document► and approved, a ro3car tthartse conplcto Aa by in the of ed School District , in the 0�nner serifed California Env';i•ronme.ntal. - Q'ia7 ity Ac.t. PAGE° I C. 013JECTXVBI S SOUGHT By THE i'ROPI�SSD �'�0�7�C'r r roiricle< ari; The; Obj'!wct ive of the }� A�b5e . project is to p E6011-it,t7j.tYtin the'Paradise Unified •,iAna1 cd catibnal. addal additi, ' to rel:Ieve overcrawcled con4 ti ns that District 8cbcurrently exist. .,:he issue at`han.d,, as well as the subJect o this document is needed but whether the reoPAaice r a_s tzct whether a ,chool, i school site and the design i�1. thaL speak n9, env rannentally s'a rid; xt soems that, genorally and opponents agtee that a new both project proponents; school is needed.! l er can £ irtna tion of the need for, a new school within 1! ui h All.ocatian Board's agreement to the PUSS is the State asci st in financing the proposed facility. TbOir 'Policy financing unless. to not participate in sck�aol Gonstrurtian a district have reached capacity all sahbol facilita.es+in so that, a new selaol as needed within the immediate future.' is nc At ' sent, the State Allocations Board withol:di pre 'the PU90 satis3 a.es al;l required :further i=unding until- administrative Processes (.including enviton mentaI) Attendance statistics (revieuted 1:rom 1971,1 also verify that i has been increasinq the need e,ci.sts. The pt7So s enro].l,ment a rate of 3W per year until. the 1.980-81 school year when at, it decreased by l•'5 The present school. year statistics the last;, and PU5D staff also pxoJect a ease over aredict L-h:at this trend will continue. The de411 �evate increase in 1980%81: , was probably due to an p. school and Paradise Christian facilities. Sty Thomas iAOre iaYiile anotlli parochial 5chao1;both added clasarobms, by a local: church. school 'was :started a tzlatiai� which would be attending the Thew studentp in tl�a Magalia andtheraPUS,n proposed new school reside Appen.d!iac ' C' is a. flap prepared by Pines areas`. which indicate s wii h 7. dcit the residence' of each tud nt in district e Lementary the Paradise Pines area enrolled' i n a tittle a.f its preparak:ian; Noveraber, 1980,, school:Fit the there. were students ';livinq in that area. At present, the students living in the MatXalia:, Paradise traospo,r;ted to Pgnderosa p i:nes and AeSabla .,are are ' 5 chaol located on `Pentz-Maga;l.ia ,Fih;way 3; T;letnontax,y ► : mils�s� south of Paradise Pine To accomodate these reSxdir �t within that s.c'Yiaol' s chit-dren, as will as tho8e locale,. second incl third grades at: Ponderosa Elanientarlr School and Paradise ElemenLarr School: aro operated the the ' trend continues., dcau.ble' sessions.f grc�wt� district plan'.' to extand the' clbtble siran fo'�tta to Elemt»ntary First . include Ponde 'c sa E'le�net l ar,y and T aratlis,e Cjr,ades a.jsO Prir+ .�l.,`5 -. .. _..... ,. ". �_ .. :.., . ,_._ _� ._.._._. .:�..�.� oaifsal�rnlfii�iuwlls�l110 'l�1N Append x 'D' is a retracement by Cook Associates of the preliminary 'site -T)Ian preparod by theIarchitectoraI fi xm,- Rat.ougrh Reynolds; of Rocklzn, Calii ornia, ret tined: by PU5D for this project: This repr :cents the mist compl. itE l description, of. tbe proposed physical project layout. It indicates the relative location of tort buildings to be used for administrative purposes and classrooms,-togehbO r wittt a smaller bathroom build nzt I w tl ways I th.► site tiode,8 road and a fire access lane parking facilities �for aYprox. 80 vehicles l • drainage faci:li.ti es; two la.rgel pUyf; 7,oILd8 an area or a septic ,field within one. of the pl.ayfieds; seven tatdooutL or turf ateae; underground .utility locations; and the remainder of ;the site as "undisfr.urbed" forest green; belt. The proposed project is a two-phase, five -plan. 7't7e' first -first phase (the praliminary site plan �-Appendix 'D'--_ provides differentiation for elements of th(e two phases) was initiated by PUSt7 ► s application for ftynd;i:ng to the State Allocations Board,, and preliminary design efforts'.by the project- architect. ;''f the project. i; approved, the first prase will be complete with, the construction of 10,520 square feet of facilities, including nine classrooms and one 86bb6i;di4ry building..,The State Allocations Boardl has gtantod $1,482,789 for this phase, which is proposed to accomodate 280 students. AS ,statad earlier, the funding Will, _. . M • be released 17y the sta tw xf and when the prosect � administrative processing as acro tp1ished. rhe second ,phase will involve the construction of sddit'ional fa.ca Utkes to accomodate a total enrollment of frog 60"0 to 500 students. A seperaLe application;by the " PUSD will have to be madefox this i n that the State Allorations Uo7rd will not approve fundintt uni~iZ evidence exists that additional: facilities aro needed over and above Phase one. i 2. PHYSICAL P>7OJ'VCT DESCXt:P'i'1ON As stated -earlier, the facilities proposed for cons.tructaon will ultima,tety occupy 1G acres of tlae i.nvolvecl :�k0-acre } axce;,l The. uninvolved 2�1 acres at eh Proposed to be I t in an "undiattzrb�ed�" I annex with the exception of ''nature trai i,s" ti`.taly eno be,t7er education i PACE 7 ,l avoid extensive grading for the creation of bu ldIn- fi pads. Their desi n -on g: Placement and the site ,shall be accomplished to create- aesthotically unobtrusive buildings in a natural: setting-, The .buildings shall utili�: ae natural materials„ ( 0..9 wood sidinq and t- imber construction) Calor selections will be compatible with the, existing earth colors andnatural foliage arid - shall blend kth or simulate the su.rrouhding vegetation and land., Phe proposed'project will not devices'.fax occupied space. �.nvolve mechanical, aaoling,, p P However,. heaEi ng of 'the classrom buildings will utilize mechanical as. well as Passive solar, systems. The tvo classrooms in oach building will be "small connected by ;a graiip room", above which will, be a heat collection and storage area. This area, will have glass -encased southern exposure and, be: egtippd with thermostatically operated blowers for heat , distibution to the classrooms., The r mechanical: systems will "back serve as -UPS!, for periods of pxol.onged overcast or atypi cai i y cold .days. Fuel ifdr the mechanical 'Will,be system propsne and will be.stored in an underground tank in the vicinity of the pstrk,ing aro-a, as shown on the site plan (Appendix �D��,*k g 1 kThis desi nation shall hereafter serve as a reference to a footnote of the same number' to be found in Appe;lldi�c U' herein d, Site Clearing and Excavation; According to the amended "APPLICATION, FOA ANO CE9 15 EO STATEMENT OF BSTIMAT m C65T OF x LEAS-Bt1PCkTASE PROJECT't .x fileel July 28, 1581, by the Paradise UnifiedSchool District with the State Allocation Board,; the following areas will be involved the in clearing activities: Clearing of trees- parking &walks 48,00 s.f. Cle a rin q trees rof for building pads - 30 r (?00 s. f'. Clearing o tree's for hardcourt area Clear ing' of trees: for playfield - 78,1100 s. f. Incluc3ing grubbing and waote removal ' - there approximately one mature' tree in ev',ery, 140 sq. ft. of land area O'lus`many ,� Young ees . Z.h trees.. ('he figures listed app7.y to the pra�iect as it ; will exist after' the final is phase completed.)' according; to the �oregoina, the total area affected ,by, t;Yee clea.zng (1.64x,800 s:f,, or, 3.78 aces> contains `8.175 mature PAGE. trees. However, a tree 5nventory taken by Li.ppincoL~ Survey;inq indicates that there are only 1.055 treed havrinc{,' a trunk diameter greater than .'l5 inches on the entire 40 -acre parcel. Since. the total area affected by tree,clearing is only 9.5 of the total 40 acres, it; would seem reasonable that g.'5% of the total number of trees (10,0) Would be removed. 1.1herefore, it must be assumed that the, tree, removal factor of 1. per, 140 sg;, ft. should, in realltyjI be 1 per 1400 sq. ft. This Wbuld,produce the Oora believable result that 118 mature trees will be removed, due to project construction. in a telephone interview January 8 1982, project architect Clair Eatough acknowledged that, the tree: removal facto:,, cited i,n the application ;noted above was a typographical erro According to architect tatough, excavation will occur rxmarxl in the re ara a p y P P. t o n of the, play Ft e,7 ds . The emended a lication, documented above and rel6tinq to the Pp total project, indicates that such work will, generate 10,, 48.0. cubic yards of material, 6, 000 cubic yard,; o whi h will be removed from the site, and 2,400 cubic yards being compacted on site (assumedly, for road subgrade and playfield rgrading pur'Poses). The proposed x�he areaspresentlyhave a slope o£ between 5% and 6%. p j p ns call. for excavating •playi attho high side of the northeast playfleld area to a depth of approximately 6 feet below the original ground line, and. 1 to a depth of approximately 7.5 feet below the original ground; line at; the high side.:of the southerly playi field area ( see ;Appendix , T)' >. Some of the material: from the excava`ti on s�ould be placed as embankment on. the low side of the pl.ayfieldsl--to a depth of 2.8 feet at the northeast pl:ay;6ield, and to a depth of a, 5 f.eetr at the southerly pl,ayfield,. ` The resulting slope of the playfie'lds after excavation and, embankment wore would be1.3% di I towards the south. e Or,knage erosionshall be con trolled by the use ofrock dfains (French drains) at the edge of all major parkin' g areas, hajrdcoutt areas and other water sheds where erosaori e%pectecl .. ......Becauso . opt tie 7 a; s10 ._ e at the parking area a,,a central rock drain i n the I .parking area mill be .,constructed as shown to t:61"!ect waiver . 'and th1 will be carried to rock clxains at periphery of , the parking areas an i f requi fired,,; by u e.. ground' pi po located to day] 3.ghb <e-ktended to; a, po tat of int,orsecLioci with" na,turail ground: surface 810 ' iri P to� the e�isti, q s1t0_� d.rainaq PAGE 10 stvale. Rocks at surface shall be minimum 2() lb. bould:ers> **8* All roofs of all build will be designedo have gutters, and downspouts which drain into roo.jt cells of a minimum 3011 diameter and 36" deop. **4**, _ According, to architect Eatough, a corrugated metal cu;I.vort with aflared end section at tr;s inlet ends si ecl aodordi ng to hydraulic calculations, will be placed under the zlccess road where it . crosses the nat•ura.l swale in i:t nod thW�:st portion of the school site (see Appendix 'D'). construcw tion of the access road will also involve g>u"ari'- ; aside guttez which will be 1.29 feet bo-low and 5,50 foot away: f g, the road 0 al edge pavement. Water front the road, - Bromrf areas ` s Will drain along t.ltis gutter to join the floui in the drainage sWdle (see Ap tentiix f. impervious Suri aces: Approximate 76,161 square feet, or I.7$ a<res of Impery bus surface will result rote the coctstruc;ti on of .bu.ild q roofs, roadWays, parking' areas Walkways, and ha'rdco,urts f **5**) . This represents 46% of the, -area to ba cleared forproject! facilities(164e50.0 square feet, t otal noted above At has present., the site an estimated coefficient of runoff ('; c!') ( accord ibg to B. C. Q.V. D; Standard No D-5) ; of 0.,38 to 0.40. Assuming a minimum time. of concentration-f 10 minutes, and rainfall l intensity ('ci tc) for a 116 yea storm bei.i�g:2.3 inches pe.rihour (per .0 P.W,'D: ;Standard D-2), appro .imately 3.5 cubsc feet per seeond (Q.cia) of rainfall Would, flow from the devoloped portion of the proaec1t site ('situation areatly sim:01if ed for the sakeo discussion) . (yor the sake "of reference, a 15" diametor culvert at critical slope, fl.owinq foil v�ith no head, can accomodate 4. cubic feet✓ of drai_rnage per second:,' A 30" diameter culvert under the same condit- ons can accomodate 261 bic :Feet per, second..) After construction, thelayfelds and cleared areas 830 square feet) will' have an .estimated coe>rficient of runoff 6f 0 50, while the noted above will have ' an est:i:matod coeff,ic:en�t~ of 'runoff Of 0,'00 to Assumi.nq tl�e same 10-year storm would again produce 2:3 inches of �raanfal per hour, the ;, amount of surfaoe �. drainage from the; developed portion of, the oto aft or construction would b feet per second.. This oonstitutes a 75 `inoro,as.e in runoff genorated by the,. same area a' 4b, ovc�, me,nt b' the o osed. ra; ec " after develop Y p p P 1 t. P�1GB -ll The Drainage Pian, attached as 'A' to architect Clair cited earlier, shows rock-fillr�d'rexa�;h r Eatough's letter, drains to be located to receive surface drainage frim a;;1. impervious surface facilities, and ,rock wells located. t,0 receive drainacie from all, structure roofs. d. IJtili,ty Service Lines: r involved in the construction of the subject project wall, be lines, to the schoo, the extension of public. utility. service site (Appendix- D' shows the proposed location of these extensions). Electricity will be supplied by P.G & E., and lines from the wz.11 be supplied through underground existing o�rerhead l e$ within Compton Drive zigt�t of wa.y is at the project's northern boundary. Telephone service pacific ^'lephone and will be extended from provided by existing facilities in a p'ubl.ic utility easement between Olivet Drive and Hood Court at the prajPct's northern Oro Water boundary. Wates service will be supplied by Del The school project will involve tying to an Company. ext8tinq water main at the southerly end of; Olivet Drive, boundary. Natural gas i rear the project's northern bouns, not in the Paradise P nes area. The propo.sPd available school's heating facilities will be fueled, however, by propane gas; which will be stUred underground on the site, wthiri� the parking area.*�*k h. Sewage Disposal: Public sewage; transport and t,rertment facilities do not with exist in the paradise Pines a ea*' xherelore, just C, edch residential unit in the area, sewage di.spos'al will be ad on site by meads of a septic 'tank, and leach The site plan (Appendi; 'D') fie a, system.: prelinta.nary shows, the proposed location of the beach field area as ' r ti,dez a 270'x 270' f1::7 acres) playfield: beim u The sewage leach fields wit .be located away from Design and I' all site d a na e swales.. 4 construction shall compl. with State standards and the re uirem nts of Dtitte County. **7** q The aroposed leach field is situated <on a r.idge--back, between thotwo natural swales which traverse, equa�clistant the proaect site, being 5Ob feet from the nearest was eaurse. rt w ,l.1 be located witc►in orie of the f] at.te'r f 7' areas ofthe site. An Ocl:obez 19�b-;nvira'tinent��l Protection Agency Mania al, On�-Sate ftst�ewater TxeatM, and ,acurtient--"Design PAG13 12 M Disposal Systems (Report #EPA0.25-180012.)---statos that a school with .a cafeteria and no gymnasium will generate an average of 1;5.9 gallons of wastewater per, student Per da, Usa,ng this figure, the proposed scbool would :be ret�onsa ble fo.r. 14,.310 gallons of wastewaterper day, when it reaches its ui.t tate attendance of 900 students. The f011owing is provided. as 'a coMparison, of the px'aject' s wastewater contribution to surrounding rAid'e tial ` oon;trUutions: The school site Is surrounded on three aides, by a, relatively high-density' residential developrli-nL. Within a 3001 foot wide; bend around the project -, boundary there are ;103.residential parcels. Ther, Bette County Environmental Health Department.:uses - the figure of 50 gallons per person pc r, 1 day to calculate the amount of wastewater that' would be produced by: a residence.. On this basis, when; a1l> theparcels are developed; the zesulting wastewater conttibution_ would be 17,0'x` , gallons Per day (assuming an average, den iter air 2..,5 ' oe:rsons per, household). w . Vegetation Preservation Project architect, Clair Eatough, stated that great care had been exerted, to preliminarily, design the location of tXie btjildint , access road, fire lane, and. parkingareas sd as to pt.eserve as many mature trees as po;C; designated, site, more than 5.6% of these ,ex.i.nta ng larger trees will be maintained.- Buildings, field areas and hard .court areas will be located 'where tht cutting of major trees xs minimized andon those portions of the :site requiring the least grading, Also- Meld areas and hardcourt areas -will, be broken down into. their smallest reasonable components to permit their placement in these areas of the site w-i.th, the fewest trees. existinq; - All ll paths and walkways shall' , be designed to wind' naturally through the existing woodlands. Cnnsid'erai ion :shall be given to maintain ° tha existing Iscenic quality of the site and to minimize changes in the natural landforms. hit cutti r :finds sounds along the streets, and ms hyyhway, motorcycles, radio and loud' s Fakers n� p . achynery and, e construction activities,. repair equipment,. air conditioners and compressors, hand tools, said the general, sounds of people=in the, =oily tran8hotions. Noise pollution is normall associated. y VI urban' areas with riga populations, magyar yntra-obmmunyty travel routes and industrial. land uses. Par,AdIse' and. its Upper Ridge area does ;not experience the eX'creme noise levels eki.sting in 'other California' Met,r'gp,olatan,' areas. However; the are,a!s increased grov�th has brought with it an increase in noise levels. i'1Voise;, as-perceived by According to. C. H.io- nnchester, Ptohums and loudness, measurda hunterms offpetch q.uencyrc�ttt high whistles to xowrumbles and roars.. Frequency measuremehts are expressed in e.cJ-es per sec;ratid; they sensation ,Of' loudness a.;s determined p.r-ima,-eI j. r by the physical intensity of sound expressed 1ji decibels. " Accoustira:l engibeera have ranked loildness levels of sounds p�erceicted by thti ,hluta . ear :o.;t' a scalae usi iq "the cier.halsl I '(db) as the measure. unitof. Star'tinc7 gat L--he' thres'tjold of •hearin'�,the sale � extends from zer to o 140 decibels, the threshold of pain,, identification of a number off' noise ranges itt deoibell that may be' observed in' a i5evelop area consist the Eo7,lowina e a:' Quiet rural,suburban ar a at right time 35 . , db b6 tlxba`ri resicdential area at daytime';, 55=G5 dbz- c: Light 'ca:nmer'rial traffic over arotnmercial 'cla street at �titne, 6�'--75 d,b d.ielico tier fl in' 9-- p overhead_ ' db ._ e, Ti^uck oassyhc, ohor h Ohway, 90 db.' f Diesel freight train at 40 miles' per hour, 4Q fee:t away, 100 db. To better txn;clerstand sothd, , the fol lowing characteristics acid faotors deve' l bperl ' by the 0u iet City Comt�i ttea of the to . �va.s�oh tri, el es b �� ttie �,, q;, cauoof g Cali .farkZza Cs tie's ares od' ` a: Satin d in a va tatio.t� "trai sntitte�cl y rlc5leotiles of air, b. the decibel 'is, ,a very conyeniet uriatyof measurement because,o£ the tremendous sensitivity of the ear. G. T� i �p ca everyday ,sound levels range from 30 dba,' ("very quiet) to 100 db a (extremely loud) or sometimes higher. ' d. People do not' perceive noise in direct proportion to sound level.' An average person willperceive a change of 10 dba as c:oundng twine as loud (or half as loud).` As a,n ,example,' 70 dba is approximately twice as loud as 00 dba' e. Sound flay be "steady", ".fluctuuing'' or.. zzlpulsive". 'impulsive sounds suchac riveting tend to be,.more annoyin;a than steady broad-band. noise. I The extent to wha- a sound exceeds the " bachgr.ound o. S, is a measurE I ihtrusiyeness. This baakgrcund noise: is, also, ,. called ambient noise. o,. Ambient noise varies with Iodation and w th the time of day or night., h: Sound gets qUI ter as the source gets faa.ther - aiay: The relationship of `sound level ` to _ distanceis stranger however. Every time distance from the source is dotibledr th, sound .level, does down saes: db. 'reflected i. Sound can b sh'elded and by large objects just like Tight: 'rb provide ba�ckgri and for det'e�in riing nog se impacts a8odiated Wath an elementary school, Cook Associates hook fIel,d ineasutemellnts of atiibioht noise levels at C1PIA, Bletoot6 y School on Oa�v�ale Avenue in th'e 'Olrov i lle , area on., 0 at�uary a 1, L i`5$?.' O�i11ir School.' is ver` s.arni lar in stucnt ages and location type toy the subject- project. An A weighted noise 1"eVbl meteStandard. S1.4--19,7.1 waw lased. (Because tl�e 'human ertr does not react to sound,, at tow ftoquehcies in the sage wad► as soUna-"at', high fecu.ertcIt es� the quality of sotihd must tato be eval'>tatecl. n 'iA+Wbigh.ti -q 'Ne,tw�orkll is art�'va.ded+ IhI sc uhd ` level itieters to Simulate the t utttan e�ir ��wea ght� z�g sound e e ex leV �.s a res, p ed in units 'rests were k -it ab taakch to determifto ztta's.a.tt tiM noise levels which e� ect'ed ':.fro could be m �� p childrdi! p�layirigk '1'o :;l. accomplish this, a fii st grade class of approximat�ry 25 children were positioned on a paved playing surface (such. a surface wilt reflect. more sound than one with a 6atural covering such as grass). With the noise level'metor at 100: feet from the source, the children were instructed to yell, as loudas they could (extreme and atypical pI,*,ycjround situ,atioia). The xesultirig noise level was 84 d"Ek(A). With noise level meter positioned 200 feet from th-e source, the: t noise level , reached 78 dB(A) when the children yelled. Afterwards, maximum noise levels were l measured using a. gchildren involved in an organized roup of approximately 50 game. With the noise meter 100 feet` from the sourde, 76 dB(A) was meas1. ured. A mise l.ev el of 7o dB( ) was measured when the -meter was 200 .feet from the source n both test` situationsr the noise source was on a paved surface Which extended cant' nuousl.y to the noise level me tor, 'with no . -. obs:tru,, ions -such as trees or pec#:eta.t on--tieL teen the two. Tests were then conducted to .determine makimum'noise 1,eVels' ■ that oot ld b.�_ ekpected from school busses 'transporting student: to and from the s'ub ject school`. Noise levels averaged'76 d$(A) 'f or sii busses tested, with 80 dB(A) be iriq .gene; at:eci by the loudest (a tont -� :heed. --drive pickup? , prridu.cer sa peak ,no �wt�e le vel of 17lt ,L(°A)) . The , noise leveJ.e il�were neatwred at 60 feet from the sCl. at a location :wproperty and here the busses were departing the school i cl�mbinq a grade of approximately, 15% Measurements taken' 200' feet from the source were below 70 dB(A) (lover limit ofnoise level .meter'). The measurements taken aro con,sistettt with the following from the' 157,7 - Noise Eli ment of the Butte: County General P an .automobiles can create noise � evels ' of 60 to 70 tR: and` txucksr taus� es, : aria partly"muffled autos can ctdat6 levels of 70 85 68b .: At 80: feet from th:e source. t 'rv�ew on 0anuar.' j 1, 1982, Norman �toberts Jri a.n in . e y Princa al o Op'' IT tl.etnentary School,, stated that portions of the school's student's are outside a+ - his sdhool 165 ' minutes C,inclutl3 ng 20 mintite:5 prior to,and after vf-fici'al school hours::) of a io5. minute day (8: �15 I J,I, to 2:� C N .) . This fieanS tha`:' someof the 5Ghool It studontS are outside ardcourts 48 of the da '. ands. an the p,layf ,e�.ds a ftcd h y 8 , C0N8TgU,CTlO't4 "0 FOCI I2�S if the proeot 'is approvedr funding for atdhitectural plans will be made aeaalable by the state: Prepar.et�on of these jal ons, feu iewf by a nvolvee. state aaet:ci de r aria cotrip t Live bid at�is5tiarr t�otild span a tame opprttiama,tely' air totiths. Uj o ► award of the ooristructa.an cbMtroc to the bat--wiritl.inq GtSCl�`: c�ldthr r 1? to 18 months toll elapse until com etion of:the otdupi INX BI, parcel's southerly bo1 undary. Although a gra�Yr�l road that across the ioc ouilty aeasetnt, connects' the two stubs; .pgrtd, and, F3LM `land is actually only a publ . not a public thoxoupfare• oblic troadspo'�'h�ssmenasomthat p. Drive which,, are pav .d a be providing an access easement '00 fret wide front' B[ay will, rive to. west Orly the public por -3.on of Compton Da •the the school $iie (seelppen boundary: of Because the gra,rel mad:across the' BTutiI land dogs e� is"tr choose it Gt tne�ans 'of some pegple out of conveniecice, access between Ferguson Drive and Ponderosa Dace ve• �� �� ro osed 'to extend fto t the south A gravel fine lane is P p pro ' ed te to an; end of Ola vet Drive sonthetschoo' ' staccess o,ad� at the east end intersection w 'D' Access by i oa the road's an -site loop (see Appe dix °will- be licnited to.,emergency use on �y r way, of the Fire ,lane according to architect to tough, Wiest Park Drive (labeled as South Park DrivG:� on Appendix projt 2010 fee'.: of the ec C�' cuffs across the., southeasterly for access e:a,st'sro this .paved parcel. Nq prov�a _b fished re..ent, ss cafiaccomp at. p hownvewa ra n} eXiser► oad c. d. 71(' �, roach or dv v y " xrn, 'an In texvie� arr i?anuary 13 1982; P[JSD Superi n.tenderl`t chool is the pt:'oposethd suL Geneveil sated thatp tinfil 'beyond 'tire firs ase t thinghw lkirig expanded rp'l include grades K through d, only dh dsen� Wa - the; school 2 miles) `wolf attend. distance of proL".used mill be transprtlhoset�hldrn�ln grads Since busses trough to to ani y r erimeter would also `the 2-m p. th'rouah 3 who l�.vt� outs�.c�.e xle be transported to parade osa tlementaxy School. Busses -4 throu9", cvo uld continue to transport children �n grades the 2�m�le perimeter to Ponddrosa: tubo live within` rales K Ca ok t�ssoc ares est`itates 'that 15h ch"ill � schOal site. scorn thko.uc)h 3 live raX�i natelymJ 8�5sstt�den�ts volt c Anue to e Therefarey app Schpo�, involving bussed, to �?o nclerosl elementary — lthtt ��PUSb V inancia.l busses err ► apps imatoly k4 1982. that he it bff3 ce'r; stat a t� an ri at on cofttm st savings o abc tit �t�mates a�,v ink . t. p e .' lln% jipon occu atxo`� o thotild bece pminated,�rahc7mat aytate to 5d b�cs"zn�.l per day mile; the initial. savinct� to the , d strict o': $ 89 peg lt tsculd. be. about $�5y00b per yea t :Cter r .i ansion o ., the PrOID seri, ' school' S a.'rst phase s ' rrrad %to l d; at �hd c ,ildreil a rbf X,haprr amen to Eh sixi4h i l9 1 Unified School District, 3aintl agreed' that when the nr�lr1 y `g arose for an elementary school' in the Upper Ridge, the PUfI� would make a p.lic;a.tion to BLM for the :sUbJ.ect site. Lar01A and Del Oro Water' agreed to furnish water to , the site 10 ' g o relinquish . its, hold on the zeturn f0'r PiJSD s a reement t 10-ac�`e Steiffex Road site. Consequently, on September "2y,r 19.71, the',three invol"v04 entities--PUSD, Larw n, and .Dc1 0 ro Water',einto an agreement whereby. Lar4�in extended ubatered o boundary, p 1, water facilities t0 the gLM site bo and Del Ora water agreed to provide water to the propolged School site (said agreement is, on file with the Butte County clerk's Office);. Zri 197.2, 'a $2,000 —,000 bond issue for additi0na. classrooms 11 to relieve overcrowdinct wa.rr defeated by the v0lwers. Again 'in 1973, a $500,000 bond issue for air Conditioning and other casts, o initiate year ,1round school was defeated at the palls. in June of 1974, o�cercrowding became so acute that grades one through three we placed on double sessions and grad cies 7 through 12were. placed on extended days. It was at this time the school district and the Paradise Parks I and Recreation Di;st,rict kariterecl into a ;joint agreement t,a build an elementary school an, land owned by the Recreation,,, nistrict known as 111 e 'Park: A ''$6, 000, 000 bond issue 'was' placed, before the voters and was subsequently defeated. t3oth:, the PI0$, Board of " 'Trustees and the superintendent believed the issue was defeated on the basis of the proposed: school's location: There:cure,, another $6,OOG,Q00, bind Issue was paced on the November, ; 1974. ballot. This - issue was to ; rov>_de additional cl , p ' assrooms at each of the frur major schools; anrl'was -was,-approve roved b the j p y voters :. Investiq: t ati ons continued, thereafter into ways of, permanently resolving the student pGipulation growth prc1,7.em _ but without "a resolution bei riq faurnd Faced with continu,inq.increase in en ollmeht and a`need to expand the facilities at the Paradise High School, in September, 1Q76, the °district 'sold; its thrcr:e-acre sdhoo! site in `DeSa. A and used' the funds to help finance the putdhase 0- five acres of land e%l to the P`'arad se H',igh Sdhool.6 in 1,9'78 j the PP, &M) was agar n con ranted and. asked to meet With the PUSD to discuss joint use of the 'Ville Road Parlc, situ;. Ho�tever, the pPFtI' board unanimously voted not., to J meet with the PJ5discuss: the Pu8b has rejected the Piiie Road park as 61 posysible schoral, site: ti ....uaure .: U�t7 decade n the .PP& D re ccti0n� the P d the t any 71fl�er k� J , schc cel site tvou',ld have to be, located in the ti�agalia h.rea r . s�.hg student enro .�lnlent from that �r ` dile t0 i ' Ctba s ea . PAO$ ,2 r C. GEOLOGY / SliXSMIciv. 1 The geology of the parcel is primarily volcanic. The subsurface- straticgraphyconsists of breccias interla Bred a�.th other Y vo'icancs and stream, 1. deposits of sand ands gravel. ' Below the v63canics lies a basement of rnetamorp:hic and ul�.xabasic intrusive"rocks. it has no known; paleontological rosource and; no known geologic hazards, **10** The Bureau of Land Management stated in, the Environmental, Assessment quoted above that the school site has been classified as being non -mineral. in character. This information was checked against •the California, Departmeot of Conservation 1952 "Geologic .Map of California and found ' r to be consistent. The Draft Paeadisa General Plan reviews earthquake hazard i studies prepared by Guyton land Scheel in 1'974 and by Geomechan'ics in 1980, The following is a s.ummazizairion of they core clusans reached by those, researchers as they, impacted ''upon th,e Paradise area; Of known earthquakes in northeastern Cali`fornia), 90s were of intensity V �Moc3ified , Mercalli Intensity Scale'of 1.931 (MMI5)> or less, capable of little; or no damage. There have been no human i.njurres lot deaths and 'Only.,ver small' y p.ro ert � � dama q �; P Y. g e from earbt� uakes -- wit ..- ,,. ; � -_ h� a. wa thin nort haste"rh Cad to,r - One large fault,; thol Honey' Lake Fault,: should become the subject of further,;,,. res.earch and "while there is, no evidence than this Fault system is ns notpotehtiailY an erou.sevxdace i complete' in this rogarclF 1' Since a' hypothota cal i;nteiisity �xxr earthquake might occur anywhexe in northeastern 'p`1"annina �CaliFor�i a, withi'ri thi.. :ogldn should be r ;based upon this event as a maximum inte;.a.ty. earthquake hazard. in horthoastr-tn California is not great w he n compared w i th the res of California nor is it great whoa com )Arecl with other natural' hazard Systems 4h the same regio►a'S. 1 I r PPiG� Z5 r I r D. SURFACE DRAINAGE' As ,disatitsed under "'Topogxaph"y" above, the., sites has natural .dawftwaxd: slope in a southwesterly direction, with surface drainage, collected in two soperate 'swalescrossing the- northwest and, southeast cornersof the site,, respectively. The swales. are mi as to their ,collection area, servicing' only a limited upstream watetshew: Water collected in, these channels drains southwesterly, through - ed metal culverts under 'Ferguson '30 -inch diameter corrugat 1 Dr.1 into mare clearly defined natural. channe] s. AE ,the water leaves the developed areas they, join small creeks which ultimately"drai.n into Butte ,Creek Canyon. The two swa es rioted above drain 'independently to Ferguson Drive. Ther- t waiter from each is carried under` the street via the culverts also noted above.' ThP one' receiving drainage from the most westerly swale is ,lrjcated approximately, 160 fee(; east of Ferguson Drive's the inket 4onr fiurationo e. mptCintertion,Witon Drive. for this structure iri.cludes aflared-end-section at the :. ehtrance to the pipe, togather� with a paved flowline leading to the pipe entrance, and'a paved bank rising frctm f , the flowl.ine to protect' the roadway emban}cmerit slope t the, top of the roadway ("see Appendix 'E--61'). The culvert under= Fergusonreceiving dtain4age' from the most easterly swale is located midway between Compton, .Drive and West Park This culvert does not :have a flared-kerid-section at Yts ehtranc'e, but does have the benefit ` of pavement rlis 'described above. - An on-site inspection was conducted by -Cook Associates' Staf on Noveta 6r 19�, 2981; just after a 6r -day period of . ' extremely heavy precipitation (the, Paradise Fire Prcitect:ton District recorded 12.58 inches of rain in the Paradise aYnea'' between Noverriber ll and iovetriber 17, 1981;, with a total of 198 inches dor the entire month c November) At both' , ' noted,- above, there was no a agent culvert crossings n pp evidence that flood'inq�,had occu ed or that. there was a;. potential for ElbOdinq in: the future. Gere hi txel who has been Maintenance Foreman fox' Butte County Public 46,rks Departmelit in the' Paradise area sincebefore cohstruct'd of the Paradise Pines projects stated on becember 2q, T 8] that the subject culverts have always ader4uateiy handled,- the drainage' coming 'to them; end that 'there 'has never, bee -ft;. s`ioh of floocint ei'thei:' of them. His re ort was` an occa . q p coh£irmed by sa l�. Cheff. Deputy' Director o the butte; County Public walks bupartment, thdt 2661 E: GAGUNDWATER T _ ` "_here a re ,three. groundwater systems underlying` the area. The first is ,3 shAllov perched .aquifox at the '50 to 75 foot' level which flows laterally e W,th th'e surface drainages. The ', two deep aquifers are at 100 an 200 `feet respectively and are utilized for domestic' supply." *k12** "Suburban development with the, associahed' onsite waste wate faCa lit'ies have. affected the shallow aquifer, by increased: subsurface flow an& t:oliform pollution, Although'these coliform levels h«ve increased, no health problems have been identified by responsible agencies. Increased ' coliform concentrpt ions in the Little. 13titte Creek 1 -system during ,-inoriths Wlth. little or no precipit'ataori %ndicate that da,scharges of the shallow aquifer are '�inmOltYenced by the'`presence of partially treated septic effluei'it which` Inturn ends up ih surface waters: N The water balanca of , the watershe: tis stable . at the, present level .of suburban development :, " * 13 ** Pre`cpi.tat.ion aha runoff provide recharge for shallow, aq� alors which surface near bedrock 1 outcrops and feed streams. Vegetation slows runoff, decreasing erosion and aiding infltra'tion' Development alters the water balance and the hydr"oi:o'rid cycle in an ,area. _- - Water wells_usually draw from the desper and larger aquifer's. As water use ihcreases, waste Water discharges in turn" increase. These discharges are made into the soil mantle am can cahtribate to soil saturatian:, This, Water percolates through the soil contribut%ng to rechargQ of shallow, aquifers. Whom soils reach saturations the, taste tvate,I percala:tes through, the say is into shallow aquifers with only paitial treatment: These cbntainiriated water`s can ., eventually enter stre.afis, 14 ON ' F: VEGt'CA 'the Uhited states bepar. tment of r gh Arid Otho � 's Mc o£ Aron s Of Sensitive Biologics) Tiliportatice ihdiates that the project aaa is hot a sehsi Ave habitat area; Also; the 1978 So'i.l-VegetA ,10 Surrey clues not indicate the ekistehce of r,�re or ehdangered pant speeies within the projec area" 'hear non-eitenca was co1ifi rmed b the BureatY a f. P�G� 27 r 1 farPst. • In the lower H Y, h Habitat suaabYlYty.: g montane coniferous . forest haba.tat of parcel . sidalcea robusta. sdalceaun�-y Status Candidate. Federal Threat`enecx ('WS) ; (C�?. rare .and endangered in party 17?a Habitat Rssoc3.ation : Oak woodland,. chapparal.- suitabi Moderate along the Habitat 1Yty; escarpment._ of riidde Butte Creek Canyon. i rf pl:ants listed above II a>~e add`ed to ' tl.e dist 'i n the future, Suction t:ederal proposed and '7' donsultatiot with . dish ldlife S'ervYce would beI : it ed. C W3LbL'E d siibclimax vegetation provides good wildlife The mi.xe teat diversity of ha'bYtat and generally supports a g" `:d�ife s ecies ('sea ;AppendiX lt. for species List? The direr and wa Z . p hin Wsnter range for ppper Ridge area lies wit It is, believed that :tbese wi'thlb, a. deer m�gratYah route. s�evelopmeft, I tk . 'been by sting cue al read altered routes ha y R «al.dl fe speGxes nhalaYting ox ueing the parcel i Ate hose associated wit'hP and arere el.atLvely f'onthills mixed canYfer typ es toler;ai�t to human eneroachmen Mammal sped hlacktailed deem Ereqlen It, . the area are: 11Yr rel. ' tclCAcn ► slculk� vatiaus western greycS t `s naso pro'` ed for 70 sma�.l mammals:: Habitis a ti dd scveta7, reptiles and +:0 8:d ave an sC)ecies arid, ' ,amphibians. Serra boys an 'el vati�n oE' 2060 feet withI the,, tan,ita I\ area le sib 1. ox Matz pp l�p�� ;3a''s v�here tE ere a s l h amp Ito ftp I oweve'r r the r ' a dexecl ha r_ bear . ` berries co'rts . R 1 aspect, elevat:ionr and p]roxinnity to; water. rmp rbn b to the �,sand gam Vegetal mater.alsr � ere formerly abunda Northwesberm Maidt.i wnt in the ittimedi,ate vicinity. The resource eul:?�`ra1 :survey conduct"ed in 1980 in he, eastern Eby g St ff> was, concentrate one-third of the pa, ce1.. Bxcept for one isr" gVed, '�a the' find, a cobble hamrtierstener the results survey were negative,, L CLIMATOLOGY 2'he climate of the Paradise area maybe char46terized as an type. This c:timabe has warm. . ijlland Mediterranean; cl mati'c tii mils to Winters WilUh ammertiperiod to hot suttuners and ;coo],' vir,ter precipitation regime. The long, dry su p yet is is some ixnigt�e;. to the Mediterzanean climate ,-a ., Y with most of California. The fe.nttire shared' commonl b._ the ciassdge oE! in w� �zter period is chlr11 erized y the north lat:it.ude cycJ.on c storms passenq eatbwa d from bringing itaast, unstable. a'> masses into Pacific Ocean and interior Northern California19x*_ Average annual rainfall within the Upper xtidge area is low o 1.8.5 inches ' s However a between 60 and 70 �nche. lg$l,r and December e5Wxricheslof a dedto l9of r n was te6-dr „ _ 1, 1981, a al 3 pracipa to ion fell i.� 15=-18 riches above—average for .' b�:e Parada�;e area, which triisp rioa of the year: *20 * QCJAitTY L ` to . tzrtaon of th t in the' eastern ` p , Sh : p ] P is lt�eabed � �`o ec, s k ' air bas,in 1 5 ehdl used by iey Air Basan. Thi, aeratn?nbo �a] The the Sa erra Nevada Casoade and coastal Ranges iriauntains forma natu � l c u n�sacanw onhtun p npw thtman.y x>a�. pol into the va11.6y, clava, 1 qht winds, and. high of�.ospYier3mc si�ibi.li�y far stinhy' a nan�a�taa nment it bi a by the Cali oi^n a c ryatc R'e.0Urro s 'Board The area s also affe;ebed by a frequent inversion facies ynl,ons ��ihi h' ti ads cooler as r u.ndei a' warm a�.r mans; , t aricl he ps to crcat� e tC1e ntn ane po111bion coneentrati�on lttal.nttten't roblein i re u`ires a licat`�,on ani ; appzoval of a use permi i for q app proposed publ}c land'uses,. inc udi,ng "school and recreational uses'. k*21** Although° the subject property is enjoyed as open space` by` area'res dents, the existing land uses"designations' do not inherently g ara'ntee'that the site will perpetually be used as such. Any change in the status of the subject property under current state. and federal legislation would require consider.atiori by both county and federal agencies. i The BL'M must reclassify, the subject parcel first ',From its existing , other status' if multi-puarpase use status ,, to some any; development is to take place. A.n erivitohMental asse•,smen 'must be done as was done in the earlier stages' of t :his project - 1£ the BLM had changed the status of the land, Butte County could choose to .r,ecX:assify the property under` it,s General' Plan. Any change by the County, before BIM` reclassificatio, n coiilc: '�?ose a: confl iCt between state laws and federal . 1aw. i L. SQC CON 0mtd • The following s e�ccerpted frog pages 10-11 of the above-- noted BLM Environmentasscssmen ,. ? The Paa:adiSe area Pias been popular retirement area for at .east the past 20 years and is one of the fastest growing cot�munitiesin California. Growth to the north of Paradas� began essentially with the develbpment of Paradise Pines suiadi- 414s`ion in , i§70, Since Paradise Pines; ;a number o other smaller' subdivisions have been developed • � �pp q � he upper k id,, area Is� brie in the. a er rid e. _ of the fibre desirable paces arot�rid' paradise to live because of climate, aesthetics, ;the' price and, availability .of land, In the town a buil ,n Pots and a- s allabI6 ' hodbeare P dist,, d� a1. scarce. The price, of a lot .is $2011000 to $2� 000; and neve three --bedroom homes carie' 'tronl $�0 00G to 1 $EiO,000. n ara se na.ne's, 'lots rsnge �xi�m $13,00I.0 to 2G;OOp and $19►000 to 'wfQOQ along r .. the cool co�irse� A comparable three:Wbedroom ho use Prada se. nes is approaziinately' $B OOO lower than<iri town (data coll'eced atom private read tom's' and appraisers 'or these reasons; r the OP00- ri( qe area is: PAGE 33 • .r - r' expected to receive the greater percentage of; the growth in the Paradise area. From 1970 oto 1975, the numbek of buldihgpermits issued fog= Paradise increased at a rate of6� per year. The increase in 1979 was A%. The number of permits issued. for" the upper. ridge :increased at a rate of -8$ per. year with an increase of approximately ' l2 in 1979. Most of the cjrowth, is e}:pected to occur with con' structian of lots in existing Subdivisions.Approximately ane -Half of the r existing lots in the area have been developed.: Once capacity is appxoarhed in these subdi- visions; growth is expected to begin around, Ninshew, Road . Growth has been r `' ve y smite soutt. oi` parada se and= :is ,- not ex ected to a ncre p a.s� substantiially'` in_ r the near future. The reason .for the limited " growth ,is the topography, shallow°soils, and availability of y water. The Paradise Irrigation District services this area, and is almost at ' capacity with exis.ti.ng facilities; r The primary employment in the area has been aar�.ctilture" and timber need. _ orie i;ght Indus xy and services ha a moved into Chico .arid Paraddirecliise; e: a result, honbase r moretrouna i `� the area, Between, 1971 and 1974 the fastest-grovaing sector of the population was in' the ,,19 to 344 age, groUo - s Which grew at a- roxstn t - „pp a e1y- 13 � -,per -year. is � ef1 eeted� iri thei avetage t�ccupants ,age, wh" hi was 51 years in 100, and had dropped' to 48 years in 1975. The upper ridge area 'is fo116Wing 'the same trend: Paradise Pines, ah 'the 1970.�s early, was primarily a inobile home patkl be.couse of c -,and availability of 1otS. More homes ht.Ve ° been constructed andtrithe trendm ' is' away fro mobile hoes toward mote con've ntioftal homes. r r ?l .Pt`TB-. h T� C'QLD 1� QT�51-PLT13%,YC 81CZ1Vt:ES 1: WA`f13.R ttltnsta c `water i;S supplied throti4htltit the Paradise, Pines .r r�s�denta al area by the >e Oro Water Company This is .a brivately owned water purveyor and is bu totei7ulat rZ�fiGI; 3 4 by the public Utility. Ctimmisson., The system installed for the Paradise Pines! pro'ect' 1n luded an 8" ; stub extended to the boundary of ,J the; osecl p school sage. Thiscame about as a result of an agreement entered into by the Paradise Unified School District and th e Del. Oro Water , Con►pany on September 21,, 1971. The purpose of the, stubbed water main was �-o supply, water to future school facilities which were prvpased for the subject site at the time of the agreement. _ **22** The Del Oro Water-Company has" made appl i cat' i on to the r Bureau of Gard M'ana gement to place a well. 'on the Bure'at' s property West'Of Compton' Drive . ,(being also west bf the school site), This location was selected due tv geologic` conditions being condusive for a well facility. The ptxrp.ose ;. fox,,_ the . proposed well ;_ is :to augment1 exis=ting= sources to provide for annually increasing useage of the ► company s system ;in the Mag"alia vicinity ana ' not related 1 p ** ** to the pXo osed sphoo;�. facility: In a letter to Cook.As socxates dated Decomber c, 198,; Robert S. Fortino, V3.ce-Ptesident of Del Oro Water Company, saa rl, "'Del ,Ora water Co. is currently seating the adjacent sub.division5' and has over one million gullon5 of fire reserve wh-ieh would be available to the scihool district, should the need arise."' The company has two elevated storage 'tanks having a capacityo.f. _ 800" 000 gallons and 300,000 gallons, respectively, With undcargrouncl' storage AV, ailable on a pumping basis. Their water system has a volume of tisooble d,i sty ibution ,storage of l., 200-, 00"O. gallons and anavailable flow of 4,500 gallons pet MI,,nute for four hours, atpeak or near -peak deznand, .24* 2, 88WAC2'DI8136,8AL',, A pU'blic sewage transport anljor'' treatmeh system ;does; no, exis°�; in the Paradise area.; Sewa&01 disposal is, 'gay accomplished use of r vote, nr wsite SysLetns, usually of a Sephictank and ` leach -fiolr '_ type': The use of such', 8yst;eimg has affected the sha'Llow agiz;Yfers in the, area try` increasing subsurface flaw aria coli £or ,` tillution. m A increased coliform concenbr J.ons J the L: ttl Butte-Cxei-k system du1^�ng months with 1Ittle or r,b �Srecapitataon itieixoate"there are discharqIes ref the shaliaty aquifers into the surface , croekt, The water quality n� tie .9 1oc�t U .. , . a ua; e s. S r w nfluenced b the n re e c.e of . � ti q � t? p�z ally treated septic eh'flt ent ttiYhxch evenhually enters surface waters: *.2* 4 I _ PARKS AND REATION E R .:. C. 'lay t}fid; There are cIo' :facilities atio-ra, e, a public agency in ate 'avallable to the public. the paradise' Pines area 'that Paradise Pines pro-erty Owners' Association has a fadill 1,.",V but: it i.s restricted to :Ise by' their membership or As', approvedby their membership. The; DeSabla F'ire'Hal] can be has used by community groups, ho�a'ever, the single building limited. space. k Many independent Special Districts, in partic- ular, recreation i districts throughout; California, lost more than 60% of their revenue from the property tax as a result of the passage of That's two-thirds of Lip to 90% proposition' l3.> of; total revengee. At the samtime the �JPpor p. ome- Ri.dge area population has increaser) at hen nal r.ate.....••The Recreation District is unable. improvement goals• <at this time> to meet capital The,Re4reaaon District does not haveany and or facilities in the upper' ridge, area. One way to achieve some of the needed flac`ilitie s is ta'com" bine tsao or more public ,agencies and other cammu- organizations. �, joint pciwers nity ;service agreement cansave the taxpayer dollars and pzovicle a q"reat'er level of service.*27* According to ,the County Planning Department,' the, both Paradise ,Inch the - -use need in a r test lan i i. ,.: 4 e� P s,uch upper ridge is fore recreatLona�. facalit�.e��� -. fian playground, 'ball' elds, d developer) t�arlcs. Open because of 0 en :space is hot a primary concern, the amount available: **28** T=. S.CHOC�S respunsxb. The Paada; e fnr srhified School District is providing dor the eaucatIons' cif pri ►a�Y i ntermed� ate and The second ry o-ve chi.ldreh in the,a `ac�ise area. as the ,l,P district services a large rural area+ a's tae;;ll of Stem inch City y 17e Sabla ►tagala a, ar�d the comnitinities i Town o'f paradise. Th `1 sphere obility e ctends bf ICtlhicel from just north of Htttp rieadows to just south PentzrMaga�sa Iii ay and f"rote the Feather Rserdoir on Rive Cahyon to the Butte Cteek�,Canycri: D;15tr�ct fcila t e conaS a. ,rlt� o thre. obramefttary q 00 st � Stei^l'ixIg City t� ementary sttiidc�nts) ; t in t;l 02fi student$) ; P'onder'.5a Elei1lenta;i y l Pax a d`i.se Dl.ernehtary ( in > .'' ` I se i stiiden is y . The ca stx ct a so has ohe.uhinr high shoos tS95 PAOB 3'7 ': � Streets whit' interconnect major access roads ( suc}j as Ferguson Dr:.ve) are d6fllhed !'Local as Acdess Roads Cul-de-sac streets (Olivet Drive, ,flood Court, Wake Court:, etc.) are prescribed as "Mino,,. Roads". The standards I)y which Pa.Ladise Pines' streets Were desi ned g and, constructed are somewhat unique, and do not mirror . the - standar,, .. ; d,ti contained in the current Btitte,County Subdivision Tnprovexnent Standards, The uniqueness came as a result of.an' agreement between the 'developer and the county, concrete' ' cha ch the develot.)er was excused from rdn strilcting rb, ,,gutter:and sidewalk, and permitted:;instead, to' const:.ruct wider -than -standard paved shoulders and t Asphalt cIoncret (A.'C.) dikes thro,u'ghout the pr.Oject:'. The Joss Of rural atmospherethat would have resulted i`rom the. concrete O rbing and sidewalk was somewhat mitigated by the trade-off to A.`C: dikes: The developer was also spared the adrlxtio nal expense of the concrete fadilit.ies. As shoFm in the photograph of Pondetosa Drive; included herein It_41 , ("see Appendix , major access roads in the' area of the project ektend bcth ways from the centerline ftr 12 feet with a cross' -slope of 2This ,is considered the road'`s "traveled way". From the edge of the travdIec(' way the roadway continues on for 8i, feet more With a cuss-�sJope 5� of to the face of the A.C. dike: The dike is an integral part of the street collectn street drama e and , g q :;. it 4- -0 inlets into the subdivision's' drainage system,., Where the road is built on an efibari}:menta the f11,1, -slope drops b4f at a rate of 1-1/2,. 1 to the natural ground, laeloW, beginning one Poot beyond the A.C. dike.. _ . Local access roads in the project area ate 26 feet wide (13 feet rbm ..cent s to dike)'' ,.` and 'are e2p�f,eet yfeet cul de sacs 'Wide (l0 from am oenter.la.ne both Ways to A. C dike) . , ' N. pUI STC ;noxmv NT ORGANiZ ED COAI,r!xxbN5 Ptibl� c opposition , . • , pp on to'the ra " . . _ e_r, is s�xbst }? 7 an! _�al . In Each,. Section 1'Sg84. c of the Callfbtnia Dnvironmo"'nta L Quality Act -' Wh ,ch sayst�iat'"an Bftt should be preparedwthen there is serious public controversy ,. concerning'the 'envir6nmental effect of a pxrt7ect'r, Was one of; hhe bases upon 'atilch the Butte County Super',iar Court ktiled that the school district' s Okeviously approved Negat' Ve becl.axat,i on'' tinttst be <<, W�th'drarun end an ErR' be "P re fired. p` pAG:t 3 9 , puki :m'to receive input from any individuals who had relevant to ie or ideas theyfelt Were issues of the pxoposecd project. Tiie varum; varcn� ntal e n .. _ oJ', was he],.r� )ecember 14, 1981, in the mu�lt use bu�J ing in Paradise. Publicity of tho Ponderosa Elementary School or �to th, conduc 'ted for two weeks pri `� g r p tmentsiof' aatefthrouvTh the public: service, announcement de ar a ICQM! togetYiex with paid radio state. 'ons " KPAY,, KHSt and of the meeting in the 'Paradise 'Post, a advertisments P er . , bi-week`1.y Farad ` se news aP Approxi nately 150 individuals attended . 'the• forUl.r, ��With ing of. them presenting information or. bpnn ' ` which �.ncludecl specific ' outline (seaA,pe Vc"rrnat' p udiested5 forum and a s gg list of discussion topics, ' guidelines wa.s provided to.all attending- sub'ect project' were represented at the oppon,en sof the Pines Home URWA. and the "Pa:rad�,se - 1 forum 'by officials from OW nets' at Associ��ion`(POA�• TCoak teen forici the fo'rult was subtitt d to Associates never • Appendix .s meta' and is attached he a Proponents .for the project addressed the forum primarily as stibmi.tted ver%teen .manuscripts of their ndLvi.duals. ;Some ari�d�or data outlines to supe oncernsverball�vments, co"tnmen.ts The while others simply prevented their c comments (these fa`Jlowting is an outline of proponent represent opinion and are submitted o'n1y as sucYi for the purpose of. infotma "Oh) :' - �,:. he sdhoo prdject' Would require development h ].esvirig the a_ o Y ' 1''G of Y.ts 40 -acre site, natural; oonda remainder ` in an ape'n and site 2. the undeveloped portion'o. the school educa�ioh ootild be util�.�ed far an e nvironinental; by the school district program proposed 3 • The Par^adi se General P] an indicates the is choice Grath the proposed site a goad 'erspectlye of rld-se .J-mpact- 4 • Noa.se problems otic d be mi rigated by the 200feet a miri�°mum > of ' bufferzones c Lending between the 'boUftdary of adjad0ht properties acid the developed portaan of the school site. .. Wlldli e anc� Water' quality will fiat be ` si n f icah► ltnpac , e G 'the cur.ent datebJe '' sessiorlt, at i�onderasa ha�'dsh�. 's on childreri� �letnonta>},� School. r.tripare P arents anti teachers and �ttiob by tpl�eved ;cons;trtc.tion; and occupata c e pxoased PAGE' '4j school., 7., The Paradise Pines ,area already hasa 'stu.dent population of 338. 8. The new school would' relieve other schools in district and would t & e bussa.ng because the the children who would attend already live in the doub'Ie vicinity of the site, and 'the need for se ions would b;e rernoved. 9. Children Waiting at bus stops tend to play and become:, inatt e ntive and, therefore,: are a, traffic hazard than those walking to a greaten neighborhood. school.' 10. E:kxstinq . schoo,l sites do' not have available ' on; ' sP�.ce for facxlty ex ansi_ _- 11, The low' purchase price of the proposed` its desirable from; an project site makes use onamid ana taxaye: s point of view. eC p e` 12;► T, e upper Ride Brea is secure' red ativ'e to p, , , iibl�.i emegencesr l3. Paradise Pines is riot a retirement community and was never repxe'senLed as', such by the"; documents establishing developers or any projoct dewelapment criteria. x Several times throughout the forum, Cook Associates staff `native school site's be requested that the iss:.. ue of alte discussed�ws5 also one of` thy: suggested tapirs Of the discussion on the Meotinq Format' distributed at throughout the r be inn n of the forum. Nc one, however, hath cohcouYse chose "alternataves� entire two and one-�ka7.f. as their subject of dI cUssLon. -S MMt1N 3 . PAI2A018E p'Ir .�'. crxd e Walde�rness Area. Inc-., an the Members of the UPP g Property O�tvners' Association comprise a Paradise i Ines latae portion o. the popLiatLon in the vicinity of the that Pa id V,0 proposed school,. URWA and the O� 006ntend is a co�ncun;,ity whose property owners axe Panes platine zifiar'il re%ired or semi-r"etired. 'Ch& POA. +naintairis that P y �stifies their a Poll it took of thosendiv,iduals {st oft fir,' or controlled conditions, in the cohten,t�on p rlla nc� May 6r'''may �'tiot � tave e i tedr lea ring its " accu aca�es Xljustiiab�.�') p, 1 I , rt that ''t e ma coria of the develo me�il» s URWA also rise s h .) Y P owners are in apposition to the proposed. school ,for ri�riny reasons, mo t of which arelisted in their ' "Summar of Environmental Impacts" (Appendix ' H') ..''However , James Nolan, URWA President, stated ,at the EIR-Public Forram that the basic reason he was opposed to the school was because the Paradise P'nes deVelot,merit was "sold" by realtors; as a ''retirement" commuri'ity, and that 'the.. presence of a school will only entice' more families with, children to move into the area. Y p' ay, have been The "retirement commun�t re resenta uon m made by realtors to `buyers o parcels, but no documentation to this effect has been found: A promotional booklet published for The Larwi.n' Group, Inc., developers of Paradise Pines, describes the pro'ect i,n the following _ __ fiariner z .eational , s first rec Paradise linea, Larw n z colToUni�y, �� has met � with �-�,+ccell�e'nt buyer response in all aspects of gt�al.ity, design anal. iritelltgenb marketing. The 2,1;00 acre second homecommunity is located i'n the foothills a Northern Cif ornia's Sierra Neer ,aa � otintains. Carel ally° structured to preserve the lush' inatural. forests, Paradise Pines oEfexs an exceptional recseationatl environment: including a dramati recreation' center, sWILmming facilities, stables and bridle trails, a golf :aurae and other amenities. While the prdject is referred to as a "second home community"; picturEs from the same page as this ex:cerp'L show, children riding horseback. zn £act; nine of the twen.r-five' pirture,s printed in the booklet involved a child ox children. .; Theproject's Covei�antst d6hditi6ns and Restrictiohs the document in which ate restrictions would have been included had they been intended, coitairx no constraining xi5;l.es as to exclusion of children or families i the resa.dealt currently owned by retiitetrient-aei.geve ndivpduaftce is have al 8 ti been rented to families With small children, finformaton supplied by POAmembers .' at BIR Public Fbtd i without docwhentat fon). A survey was prey red by the "Paradise �etifled School 'Distric't acda ientin-g the 'lace o: tech demo fox each child in the vic.ihitte above Magal."A 'Withi ll the PU180 sphere Thoi~esultinq inEar>nation teas cr -hica,lly part>'tyed aii a dot ai a reduced copy of t�hich as in"chided herewith as Appendix !,S 1 . 7�'lie, map t which, b6came a P tL of the , � ..; documertaa oi� o tho UR6�A suit ag:ains' PU5D i`n At:tgtis�, 1��3 l , idhnti ied , 3 8 childreh ih gr,412les C tht, ug h 6.,ori tk G 0' r subject area. As of January' 111_t,11,082, .41 children''from the s area were enrolled. 8 w 0, AESTHETIC As, described above, the project site is a hi�v�1y woo ded the heart of a relatively dense greenbelt located within subdivision. The site provides very desirable and suburban quality scenery for those whose backyards abut the parcel's the site for picnic ng hiring, i boundary,; for tb,(, who use joctriding, or motort"ycling; and, fpr those ging, horseback Drive or Compton dr. vin throe h the ,property on Went Sark forest and underbrush provide a Drive.g The' dense 1 p nts, continual y' g teen interlude from ma.n-made �m raveme n_.oise and machines. N0:Is E Because the project s ite currently i5 a fciirrested, open At the space area ambient: noise levels aie very _Q the pxajec1. t site most noises, are from natural th center of Cc�a 1dl ii e, rustling leaves, etc. J with only sources occasional man-made sound's (loud, vehicles, chain"saws, Metc:, fiItering through the trees. G The bouh'darl' Of the project situ on three 'sides is also the l area.-'as--.discuss,ed boundary o a suburban residentia-11 this location are more obviously earlier. 1oise sbutces at mann made and noticeable. The most apparent noise source vehicular traffic. Th_e current noise situation is not Unlike` ghat of the incorporated limits o the residential arF4s within Town o Parad'i se. The:,tefore, reference is made to the Getieacal Plan (Section Noise `dement o the Totn of paradise descri; tior of t1.e area's rioi'se 5 2 ) for ' comprehensive envie onment { tYie General Plan Vis. avail able dor xeview „' and%or purchase at Towt Hall ; 5555 'The; 5ky�tay: ParadiseY GalifoirEiia�� . � , Q TRAEf',�C 4 -. F Because at' the tbpog�aphical nature o,. the paradase ark r oL G11jdh the ''�subj"ect prOjec the U rner Ridge community', Y cessible b �ntay of only one p cite iS a", pant, is acea PAGE 44 public road- The Skyway: From the: intersection iht- section of `�•'he Skyway and P:entz--Magalia ;Highway to the Park Drive (approximately 1-1/A mle)>; Skyway and South traffic, traveling from the Town of paradise to Magall.n and the r.'oad• the communities northerly thereof, must use same Map (Appendi.x ';4')►` the As shown on the traffic Count daily, traffic count (ADT) on ,. the Skyway ; near ave. ra e th.e Buttt� Count P Cottelenc Road, as measured' by y ublic 9410 , Works Depart,'ent (BCP) in 1981, vas This section of The Skyway was reconstructed in the recent a realignment past, providing a wider thoroughfare a'nd traffic -slowing curves having short radii, which eliminated thus greatly incxeasinq . the capacity of the higixway. Assistant Director, Butte . County However', Bill Cheff, Public Woks Department, rin a letiez captained herein as and Appendi5 RI , said that the intersection of The Skyway to the of Ponderosa Drive is coming quick' .y point _. _ L llation of will necesi.�ae the ii�,�ta congestion which Y traffic signals (counts for this' intersection are shown on Ap' pendia 'Q'). Be also stated in :Fin int6tView on January of a recently constructed the develo ers 82 that e 12 ,► 19 r the vicinity of the intersection, have already - bank in cant°ributed t)zb�r prop share towards installation the' of a t'' signals. According to+ dheff, unusua`1, .lack "htersection is the reason design of the accidents at th3.s g n initiated by his department, but that s�. pals has not been will for the pr,eparatioa of the 'construction plans project futir..e. have to be done in the immediate As discussed abovie, 341 students who reside in the Upper - at Ponderosa E ementa1,y 1 ntl enrolled Ridge area are pr�ese y School. Poh'ierosa Site Administrator Abe Memeo stayed ih busses transpori� an zntervsew ori. daniary` 13, 1982, tiSat s,ix ri th:e moaningv anc seven buS5es these-S'tudentS, t0 school transport them. home tmore busses in rho aftt�noon clue to that anshorter for Kinder; artar,) .Ie also stated session 9 from this area an average o'f l curs }aririq stridents and that inclement weather does not carents occasiu.n,, ... �. studehts- trabspo'rted by P a.hcxease In the number of iri cars: On the basis of the fok,going figures; txansport;ing - of does note contribute students to and from school ` At times to the traff situation tly �urrent � A. h1. � to � 8 : l`5 A. , j f lows, 7.�c s:ignafican ac f 15 of 'pear, morning tr s,ckioo�� -6� ated traffic is inol.ve,d,j but ►iot3uri'ng pia) evening ,flows-- : 45 P:M: to 5r45 p. PAC X45 and across them. 14ITIGATION #2A-1: Slopes shawl be car -'fu engineered so as to minimize the erosion potential. Excavation slopes shall have a slope ratio of 2:'1 or flatter, and embankment r,�Lpes' shall have a slope ration of_'2:1 or flatter, Slopes and other disuxbed j( MITIGAThON #2A-2: l� areas shall be stabx ;. zed ' aga-inst eros i„oh by placement of a+ wood chip mulch on all unsu acod, excavated or embankment areas for which landscapiis 'not proposed. prior to tho rainy; season. Wood chips shall be prepared by° processing tree trunks 'and branches ire a wood chipper, and shall, be; machine blown or ,hand spread to a uniform depth of appro:cim;ately 3' inches. Chip si-zes should be: width, from 1/2 inchto 1-1/2 inch; length, 1/2 inch to 1-1/2 inch; thickness, 1/8 inch to l/2 inch. Chips from ha,'ln dried or azr dried m u' _ material shall not' be used:. k MITIGATION 42A-3: Upon, completion of excauation and omb`ankment of p'layfielas and/orprior to the first rain season a f, it, e ki commencetne;ntI construction, diversion dikes shall be corstru;ctedalong the lower, end of the playfields,„`atthe top of the embankment slopes i per the detail ncluded herewith as Appendix 'I to pro' ent co-17ected runoff' from flowing ontro W = slope faces below.- The diko shall be compacted`' to 90t relative compaction. The diversion shall be outle t to heavily vegetated natural forost are a or artificially ttabiliz,,ed areas.' MITIGAT;ZON #2A-4: All ares at. ese rved for landscapi.ng shall be planted as early in the construction stage as possible. All, landscaping s11a11 b,e maintained in perpetuity>; ,chemistry IMPACT ,2B: iftor alLerat� will be iri' . ' one in ,soil , dine to�potr o -chemicals and rertilizers NiITxGAT1iJN .fig; Cotlstruction equipment shall, be.- carefully maintai.hed to prevent spillage of fuels: lubricating "material; and hydraulic luI if an acc� dent re -suiting iii $pillage of such chomical i§ ocours durinq construction outside an area d s;inate, for road0ay-, pa,rking or st' uctu-rel ptirposos all containinat�d' ntaterisl shall be removed ah& disprisoff--site. he void shall` 15AG2 47 a , i i I be fi.l'lod with native matE:ria1. ing fall in s10 A areasr �bilit, ,, expec Y IMPACT 42, : Soil s Y the, may' be difficult, to maintain when children choose to rolling and pJ , ng Muse the area, for running, is to be used ford,;groun MITIGATION-02C-1: Plan_ be heart ;and cover and revegetatian, shall resistive of foot t`ra, 1c. } MZTIGAT'IO[�2C-2: In areas where human would produce erosion unmiticitable encroachment by mulching or planting, pr$tecton fencing shall "the feo from be< installed' to preserve area trampling. IMPACT 42D: Minor disturbance of bedrock mai' occur during procedures. corstxtction p _ No MITiGATION'n2D•.ne. r ,L� .. bvercovei'ng of soils due to IMPACT There will be bads,and parkin area's; buil.dingsp construction of paved r g ands als; and pawed play ; area;s; from' stock it .rig o mates p from haste and clebic s disposal. MZTIG TION 42E: All donstructir�n castes and .I stockp�.l�d materials shall be debris grid_unused ed from the pti6ject site ed' oxpdo sly aftez romov ct�irplotion of each phase of the 'work.' IMPACT, Y 2F . Construction vplh1_1ole trafi is iail'l ctitnpact 1 des ignabod to retrai . n at, n natr�r'a soils ae, NfSTICP,T>ON #7F-�-: Cynsttiction traffic shal1 big to routes' according to restricted precle�termined types numbers of veha cle, anta cipated: anc� Mazkes or teritpoxary fencing shad he uti,li'zed to def ine to3.`te l ocata ons, Traffic during taet Weather 'C e roll' bated . shall b � d c7esic rise or paviriti mITIGA'"I N � ��' � : Areas t iinmedatediy at,er 1 shat i Ise con'striicted cotttp Ction of fo ndatioris ► 'and Al 1I ` vphictilar ; cti ities shall: bo calix acted froth �:heso areas thereaf ter. w I� �f 3. SExSr1TC MPACTS IMPACT #3A: The potential for st'ructu'ral damage clue to gtoiundshakina exists at the project site,"just as it saes in ail sectors of; the Sierra Nevada/Cascade;foothilIF MITIGATION f3'A: No'rie. list' nc� slate e cons tr,uction codes fa''r schools roar, G than adequately insure that project buildings will be ressti�ve of the area s potential ova seismic a. acta.vity. CliYDROLOGT IMPACTS IMPACT Wt There `wi111 be an increase in sedimentation in; the drainage sw�le crossing the northwest dorner of soil surfaces disrupted the; by site r marl. due to erosion of p y construction of, the access toad in the vic;�nity of its 0r.ossihq of the swaler but also potentially from other the 'swale areas o corn' tradt��ioh further removed .from . MITIGATION n 4A -'.I : See MITIGATION ;i 2A -,l through: #2A-� .TION 4A-2: Those, Bases of the projoct �1 MITIGA . f, p . construction whish involve soil clasruptlon (e.ct:," road work, building pad preparation, l.andscapingr placement of undezgraund utilities, etc.) shall`- y the be 1a.tnitec� to the no;emal.ly dr months ` of Year. + MIT10AT11 6 n�A=3: In those Oca'tionS tahere centerline profile grade of the access road the roars i le utter hecamos greaten that 5�► g ,,. p .� 'sh"l he aved co tltinuously from the ed e of palvemetit of the roadway, to a point an the slope; veent. bank equal, inl.evation 'to the edge o Pa era Ie, To ,event erasion o the MITIGATION , IA 4. p r6adWa'y embankment at the drainatre swq rile arouhd: tYie ciaiverlr ih�.et and outlat; a rock.net and di"scha`t�eapron shall be cotistruc�ted�r per the de herdwiti as Pni3ix ta�.,l �.ncludec� pp MT'TTOATXON 4 4ALSe The roadside`gutters alongside , ' t17e access riViad shall txans,� bort Crdm their h KtII'GATION #5B-1' When trenchiia £or Of wider to utilities► sewer ,L�tcement drainage pipe boards sha11' hot be]ins� or trees; feeder fed to roots shall hot ;be cut in a► area inside the drip line o£ the tree bxanrhrs':other than as provided below; damaged trunks or o�nased roots Will be painted immediately with a grade of tree paint (care far serious injury should be ' prescribed b a Y pxofessional forester ar lice'nsed true service?: where en4xaachment into the drip line for apassible, e di6tance qual to one-half of the drip line zadiu_1� t no closer than 5 feet sha11 be permitted oriaane of the tree ode ri"lY, if such encroachment will a116w the tree to remain for landsca an q encraachment is° and floe condo cted Wa Y.YI mxnilnum disturoance o the ground stl mace and tree ,roots'; and► tree limb removal, whex necessary, shall be� done Mush to `trunk or main branch and that area painted with a good grade of I tree , paint to pro£ession�alorester or licensed tree, service should be 'consult.ed,), ' MITIGATIONCommon utility trenches shall e, u U lj 7 eel wh neve;r po saib �hxT1GATSOt4,#5B--3: During construction, building materials shall be stored an bui' .to adway and parking areas. ldIngpads or D41T1GATIONg prepara�.i6h, �5B-4: Sub rade of the aacessroad and�paiking lot shall b done f ,rst„ to Ede the Ccbantj,, a working .. area for the refiainder of - s . ,ructlO . r onfq ��TZG�msOW #5$-5 • Surface c,�. oration shad be' returned.,to its orxgxnal and coa-lfiglratiori after ` camp;letion of bakf% linuro,. underground fac'ality trenches. M ?CZGA' O T �; Di8turbeti sites�--es��eci;a� 1" ripariana�� shad be Y rOV60tat'ed 4iith na'tiv plants tplant lists should. be obtained` g=roin a" prod ess�'ona� Forrester or licensed nurseryman;) as soon after completion o£ co,nstructioh as'' possxb�e. , IPACx 5C: Increased , ... Will human zeta vitt oh. the s , ., l lessen"the aba,la:ty of s� t vegeta.Y:;ian to propar�a��hool X MTT1GATT 0N ,, #SC.:I. r,, dbP he or borders' w ` hzoh would. pA68 51 discourage foot traffic should be installed bv. the District if at . becomes !apparent- that scudo- is arid,,school visitors have a tendency to walk through areas of the developed portion of the SCI1001 51te which are:, to remain :natural, X MITIGATION #5C-2: ContinuOuS fencing shall,be installed around the peritheter of the developed' portion of the school site to presrVe the designated open and natural space sectors. This :hall be done incrementally as- the phase construction of the site is accomplish�d, MITIGATION 45C-3: The Paradise unified School, District shall include as a part of the:" "Project. en"vironmental Learning Tree" program ofal - education► a. . "segment covering - they imj acts of humans on tim�nateUthoseeimronment 'nvi 'tor ;and ways ed or el , pact's S. MiTI6ATxON'#5C=4: Poison osk grows prolifically th:rough theproject -dt ; site. Cha 1dx'en learn gu�ckly to. ,recognize the plant and are riotoribus for avoid'inq its habitat. The, annoying,, side-effects which are prod:ioed,,,by contact with the plant "no dGubt helpconsiderably in preserving, the 'designated .natural areas At'such. r 5. WA't,� t UAT,I'T IMPACTS - ■ IMPACT #6A: soil disturbed by const ructiori of the school site may be carried 'to the on==site drainage sweles and eventually to Middle Butte Creek, by sheetflow durj`.nq sfl tox"m situations, lntrusa.on o ;this setimenta"t�in, into tho water's F Niddle'Butte Creek would degrade the water herein. quality of MI ' CCA`MON # 6A See miti atiot s .. ., s eco foie p "Soil. �mparts��, AGT pl ayfietcls6mey intercept shall o;w bagfei�rs,ottidstalterIng Cher course or aliowinq i�hts-usa on of undesir`ahle' materia s: MxxlcAxrri #i�?: see'Mit,gation1A: maxkings in accordance witbti,,Chapter 0 o the Cal Trans _ (State: pf California„ Bzsines's and Transportation ' Agency, Department, of Transportation) 'Txa.ffic Mannual Should',,be!,placed at'the following intersections: Ponderosa Drive and`Creston Drive Ponderosa Drive and Compton Drive South 'Park Drive and Glendale Drive South Park Drive and Andover Drive West Park Drive and Glendale Drive West Park Drive and Ferctusan Drive, Ferguson Drive and Compton Drive r MI'1'IGAT20M #$A--2: Bicycle/pddes.triac Lanes should be established. They should be signed and striped so' as to be obvious to drivers, and should be placed on ;lajot Access Roads within the 5-foot '' paved area betuieen; the edge of the street':s traveled way and the face: of dike, irr, the fol oiaing locatioh's: i. On Creston Drive from ° C�tadit Way to "Ponderesa Drive; on Ponderosa Drive from The Skywa ' to reston Drive; On South Park Drive between ureka`Way . and Ferguson brive,- On- 'West Park - Drive between Glendale - -' Drive and Fer uson Drive �liT,IGATIO 8A-3:', Asphalt concrete walkways should be installed for pedestrians and bicyccli, ih con ormance Wath Butte County Sub di'v%s"on 'ImLProvement", Standard on at least bh6 M side of the "folJo' in` st- w e is e School' access road as s Town nn Ahpea&X ' a Com tori Drive from Ponderoga Drive to School access road;' C'Oii1 u'on Bre rive prom rerM usdn IS.ra ve to p a � end 61 pavement, ergusc n Drive dram We t; Palk Drive to Compton Drive; Cletidale Drive.. from SoU'th• Park bLvato i West Park Drive; Andover Drive ifrom BooneCourt to - South Park Drives . IMPACT f8B: Cons chtruction of phase one of the proposed sool wi11 a11ow the,PUSD to transrealize a45,;(1QQ savxnga zn portation cost savings. MITIGATION 1118Be None. ,, Imp'ACT W:� Traffic, in the v'd in itY of the, sch601 slte, especially at the intersection "the , of Skyw" and' Pondezosa Drive will increase by approximately 10E cars perday, not including staff and' non -student visitor transportation;. MITIGATIbNSBC: The Paradise rini,fied school District shall rovide, letter a pan credit in amount established by the county County Public Works De artment which shall uai p P.USD of t ontr_z butian b the yamountg antee a const.ructlon o£ traffic s na` foz the c _ , 9 s at the intersection o� The Sk Wa and ,, SkyWay The r Pondet os'a Dri4 . h amount shah be proportionate additional, trafEia which � j,1 x�nter'sec- p pzo os�ed school at the sub ee on. 9 A7R QUA`L7r.PY rhik'AC'1'S `. , IMPACT rrgA; P:royect area air quality' Will be reduced during construction of the site improvement 06rtiorn oj�`,the proposed pro ect dire o dust .� and a .nt exha " dui me p. ust enerat,ion. g MT!iGATSOt ';A- i See MitigatioriZF�3. Mf,T GATIbN , #9A 2: A dust pallative osprinkled water shall be appli ed to , all 'disturbed areas' dl rihq construction to Maintain moisture of soil to a depth 6P 2:0r S ih h — 68, MI!IGA'xON 9A-- ,..,_: ,;' . 3 «Ons,'ttur, tion' e u i mn . N nvol e ved 1n Wank ;aitt mud, shall be thoroughly cleaned prior to l�;avina Project sate to prevent, trckiri n dk i q Ucl onto 'Ptib li e t Lrdets C Wli� n ..... � the: maid wall be pioked tip by' vehicle ttto and become dust. � r I MITIGATION 9A-4: Paved areas use(] for 'I stockpiling aggregate construction materials shall be vacuumswept when cria;terial is removed. MITIGATION ' 09A--5: Trucks hauling aggregal:eS to ha the project site ll be required to,pro'ride, canvas ` load' Covers:- if extreme wand cont itons' ex>_st. 9A-G: Con e ui ment faith ITI TION p faulty exhaust emission control devices shall not bypermitter on the pra7ect site.'; MITIGMCION >#9A-7: The project-proposes 200-foot' naturalvpgetaior► buffer' zone will; 'dor the most: part, naturally mitigate this impact. ' I ' r u :mass` ons from busses - tra nsporting IM ACT 9B •` Exhaust P children to and from school 'will be: reduced by /3 upon occupation o the proposed school.; MITIGATION ''k9B None,. IMPACT #9C: Ari a. crease in passenger vehielo txaff c in Ythe, immediate va ca.na.ty of the proposed s^hool wall ha�Ye a negative impact on the arr adt •air dual ity du'e to ,increased emi Bions. M'TSGATION: 9C: None. The increase in' emissions will be nearlyimineasureble l0 , AtCHAEOLOGICAL IMPACTS IMPACT #10AThe results of the :archaeological survey conducted by the Btiteau of Land Mari gement in'di,cate that a potential et{ist`s for artifacts to exist tin the project site Constructa,on activities might de"stroy subsurface ' arti.Cac,ts. MtTMATION r 0,1\ if: sub-surface excavation ` activities uncover prehi-toric at,tifa'c:ts, be other' evidenceof prehistoricc ahoa+iga nal occupation, construction the ;invol:vedarea •Shall. `in ,be stepped �mmecla ately ani a guar died archaeol'oga st` _ sh'aIi be oi�taJMAjediatel y in orde to recommend proper iii. t-a,gatib o the ad�rerse im-p-acts bt the projer;t to the cultural resbukdes' inwblved. PAGE: 57 I 11. NOISE IMPACx'S IMPACT 411A: Noise levels in the vicinity a,f the project will zncreasc due to the' additional tra fi,c-�-passenger -- carsgenerated by the presence of a school, MITIGATION n11A: Noise from sourcen on the school site wi11 be; attenuated by �,he dense vegetation I whish will be preserved between. the perimeter of the developed portio;t'of 00 school and its external boundary common with r(tgjfdential lots. This stri has a minimum width of; 7.qt) fejt P on the nor .h and east sides,' and a minimUin width , o£ 300 feed on the south: , Busses will not, impact the area noise environment Burin the �Yrst - phase of the' 9 proposed school s. operation, This is tr.tie because only children within the prescribed 2 -mile radius walking area will attend the, school, i3usses will, 1 not be delivE�xinq children to° the new school.. Children `1,6he- area attending rade 4 and above g hove w+'11 still be tr ansported by bus to other PUSb7 schoals but th' j is will,�not requ��re any change xn th. number ,of busses; circulating, through the immediate vicinity Of, the project. Asuttre phases of tho proposed school are built bd children in grades g through 6 are enrolled, sses till_ transport chil:d.reti -to and' from the este, This will also br.in about: a zeduction in q the number of busses travela,ng into Paradise,, It would appear that this future ;arrarige'rneht will not involve significant changet from, cu tont' sa:tuaton, � - NPACT ;01113: Noise levels in the vxcinit�r o the sial ject increasd ' prd'ject t�11 due to children playing` ar partici,patinq in physaoal education bn the school�S hardcaurts andpalaykieIds. 'MITIGATION 1TT3=1: See `Mita t{aElon 411A, .. MITIGATION', Tho con tihu:otts perimeter '.. L ' fencing around the develo ed onion Of the .i schools site as:sipecii ied in hti:tigation i 7A 'tv311 insure that the attenuatinq veg�tatJ-6h buffer. will 1 remain y 1i �5e r ? an the "la"" t�eldeddurin ou.tdoorl cti y i `� G, a yI les. Pwt 98 i IMPACT #:11C: Vnel project site and proposed deotiln insures: that the school wi1i have a continual quiet en�r,i onment in which to cond'uct,I the bof education. MITIGATION ^ O11Ct None. The 1977 Noise mlethent of the Butte, Caun'ty General Plan lists pub it schools as' noise receptors.' which "need adequate' quiet to properly conduct thgir activitiea." 12.. ESTHErIC'IMPA'CrS IMPACT #12A: There will be a reduction irkthe project s;a te' s eesihetic qualxty due. to the aJ.ter.ation of; the project site for construction of the proso facilities. MITIGATION ;r12A-1: Tl.e natural .areas and buffer zones proposed ,for°' the project loc:ztecl outside of Shad 1 Cal xn ter bbetm?ennthenschool' ett%itlntoa tovide a scteeh p . p t and occupants of ccntiauous resxde.nts and travelers ;on adjacent streeEs. MITIGATION 4,12A-2: See;Mitigation n'7A. MT',,TOATION #1`LA-3: Veje.tatiam Clearing for the d and fixe iii through the st��rc�ol access .road l natural areas shall. be 1 imited to 20feet_. as _ required by 0!e Bl tte CountyFxre be'partmeht-,see Append.t.c F`') oh each syde of the actual' physxca unit of the roaday £a:ci°lc:txes; 13.. ;IGT AND' OLARE TmfPACTS ThiPACT 1'3 A: tlg' ht and; glare will "be emitted from the circ ject site as d result of teflectioh it 61M the $Utfar=es of bolding, streets, 'anc� ;other fabricated starfa;ces. Mt'TLGATxON SMA -1: The natatttl ares art6 buffer 'ZOne pro, Z�^se,cl far' hhe, proJoe - �ocai ec3 outside the deve'lopecl areas shAl1 be maiht°dined in project gemeated 1ight Anel perpetuity, toscreen �. late fLoM reaching occl of conAguoiis ,ezaxdetYts hd t"ravelets on adjaG nt streets. L�r`CsIG T nI` i�� 3AB i. The wood sii Ing buil"c�ing e�tericars ' ra osec�' for the project wia:C, ' reduce p p � , the amount o light hd glare esvaj�7.ticj from the P A' i 15. ENERGY L(SEAGE IMPACTS IMPACT prol2osed #15A• The facility will :creme an r►c ease in ,elec'tric energy consttznptiOn,, MITIGATION :*15A-1: The, project's proposal iao ta q stem w�.l;l.t�ce ut lzze a mechanical the amount of electricity that would be contained. 1 cons. m, was' t , g ructed. if a coolin syste s ', r a k• MITIGATTON #15A=2:; i"he prc�jec p pa-'a�c solar heating ,yatem 1 include a passive (,mechanical, heatinq system, also to be >Ft ed) will ie ity tha tw woul,a be reduce the amount; of elects cbnst�med if a mechanical rieating systeut only was ' constructed. MITIGATION` #15A-3: See Mitigation {{l3S-�' and ' Mtigatior. #138-3. roduce .a se in the IrPACT T'15B: The project will p r�increa the Dtd1: Ora eater Ctitpariy. izse t� water supplied by I A -io' 15B -=l Water reatr cticn devices MI G fcilti e's, and in should be' used in bathroom future cal etezt.a faci 1 Ities: ,' duced ve atl6n shall 1�II�'xGATIONi513�?,: Intro q et of rbu,c ht- resistant varieties which are t onsi t - - fjativelant�/' or ,'rese;ml�linq nata ve plants n� the Lix�per R a.d qe area. u, During the ;constructs Girt i�f the prajr:ct there IMPACT 15 c.. i e o pctroleuin -, duels; . �.n the us wig l , be annc]ihydrauliccfluids. lubra,cant a , gVelGATIM4 4150: None T I CSPAC T5 16. PUBLIC At�D ��A� Pu sy C 1 mMr�T a: - ,. are sub.'ec to vandaasitt, IMPACT T ►p�c'al y, scl,f IMPhsdhbol Ori , r chid burg 1ar es Ex stehce Ql the r6peaed, Drive. Thi8 access should be gated MITIGATION #16B-4 : _ Aceess shall be ptov'idC:ci,�, L� the` lav fields' so t`._at �n the event th[t e is used to house a fire camp or refuc�ee:�;;, those areas can be users for parking. MITIGATION ##I6BW5: All brush shall Lo c;i -C1 from Within 30 feet, of every building and tree limbs removed that are within `10 feet of the roofs MIfi2GF1TiQ1V #1 613-6: The access road ah(11113 b a :24 feet a minimum , of wide and that, - a 20 fop;t��'''ar zone. (fi;t br'eak> be provided on each side,,, MITj'GATIO'N' ##16B- A 30 foot fuel breaC pith l0 foot'firebreak) shall be constr�ucYto and 1 maintained a'rcunc ; the perimeter of the. deve-Ioped portion sof the site.' MITrGATION #16'8. One cla8stobm,shal1 be set up as a enti. ire cieartinerit command post .for ' wsd in the event o;t a major fire. 9$jls could include the installation of additional phone' a hacks, etc. County Fire -Warden W111.iam Teie, or his des,ghated repre'sentat,ive, sha11 bL- used as a design advisor in the accomplishment of this ' mitRat"ion. MITI"CATION 16a-9: A fixe detection and alarm 'shall system be .built into eac, stru,c ure. The alarm sys Aim shall bo connected "to a supervised central 'alarm station. ■ C . PAPiADIS .PARKS ANDI;CtDAmI0N DISTRICT •� (see PPE -RD ` Letto-'r, A'� dnc i I' IMPACT 4160-1: The proposed pxb ject' s piay.fie1 ds and hardcourts, wi 11 provldb public outd66r recreation acilYties tahch 10ou3d other wise be;uhavailable, MITt'GATIbNi6G�5: Nohe xM ACT 16C-2; The 24++ ackes Of pt stbt tEb be left as' a buf-er %one and natura0s Ur'' futur-e geriera,tiohs o p. eserved o eri space„ .p PAGE 613 i ,I MITIGATION 416C..2`: None. IMPACT #16C-3: Deve'Opment of the school project will reduce the need fo:: the Paradise Rank'', and neereation- District, to develop park lana in the Upper Ridge or- MITIGATION #16C-.3: No d. PARADISE UNIFIED, SCHO L 'DIS'rgICT IMPAC 1'16D. Establishment of an 'elemen"nary sc'hoo1; ion the subject site will provide 'several positive,,impacts fox -the` Paradise; Unified, So ool District° and the community it serves.'The 'following' i.sa list of beriefits which will ; resu t .groin ,approval' of the pxaact, submitted by PUSD t Superintendent Genie Even: 1. El'iminatio'n oF over:=crowding at the elementary schools, particularl"y +.he Ponderosa Elomtnta:ty .School. 2. Reduction of transportation costs, by apprt�xitriately $40, fl00 (l0�) . Establishment o1 a neighborhood `sch0oi ' neo le lv the p i.hg', i , the Parada se Pities area. 9. Creates facila.tids for an bub, -door educnt on program ,dor all `the elementary, stu:dets as Well ,as the public at large b. Increased instructional t'itne for seand and ' third grade Students who azo current"ly on rouble session-: 6. Rdduction ih 'the. amount 'off time secohd anc� third cirade studehts must spend on buses doing to and irom school `7. Reduction in staff stress; created by: teachers having to Shag class rooms; t6ddlhers havihq to tqueb2o_ prograriis into sb6r,b ' pe ::,L o time et'c 8: ReclucLi6h of stros's on parents,, by allowing ala. �childreti to be oh th"e same schdduie thilt savihq working Mothers from 'h0viilg to make J Excavation and emriankzrient work will alter the sito's eistina topographical: features. 2. There will be overcovering. of soils due to paved roads e and parking areas., buildings, and paved play areas. 3. S,ite'.eleari' and construction Wil"1 cause the removal ng of trees;, shrubs and other vegetation. 4. U'ehicular traffic will increase in,the vicinity, of the proposed' school, especially on rainy, or inclement days, when parents,, children normally walk to school, choose to chaueffer them instead. ' 5. Evening 'traffic will increase in the vicinity of the`. Prop ed school whe�i°-there are special- events which utilize- ol facilities. schoi �. There will be �h increase in water run-off due to impervious surfacing. 1 7. Where will he an ir±,Crease in noise from chi outdoor recreational activities. 8. There will be a displacement of some non. ax-* wildlife. *Gr'i a a /�ir�;uus �trs7t�°6s"a�. The following are adverse impacts which cannot be avoided not construed: if 'thenxoject is ct r ■ 1. Ponderosa Elementary School', and paradise Elementary School will. be forceed to continue double sessions for second and third grades, and W'il have to e:cpand that scheduling to other gradeis as stpdent enrollment from the s �t. '; S.s intended than ala, adverse pro3ect area increase, impacts with double sess ons--shortened class ' days, par,tlt/teacher impacts, student impacts, reduction in after--schr5ol activities; ':� etch: =will be acknowleded, with- this item). 2 ► QUe forced to continue providing Maris", sb will b ' por;ta-tion to. Pondet0,s': ementary Schoch, for all students residing in t1�e` project area, includ' ng' aidal"bionel. b t 1 1 fnr those invo-l.ved In double sessions. 2. pC1Sn will be Eos ced to imp! ement ad, itional. 'tempo'trar mowx ures tx Accomodate gro:tajr14 student bhtoll.msnt tahi,ch gill inoE be; cost effech:ie on a long--range nt o "u;].at�Qn the Uppor 2idcje 4, A� 'stUdo !� a.,t�creases a.1a PAG a _ r G. "THE RELATr0158HxP BETWEEN LO At, SHORT-TERM USES OF MAN'S ENVIRONMENT AND TH. E MAINTENANCE' AND"' ENHANCEMENT 0' :,OIJG=TERNf PRODUCTxVITY" The j question that must �� be asked prior to aper oval of the subject project is Wi11 the ben ef ' t,s aojb.A dated W construction of the school narrow the range of t�enefie;ia' uses of the project area's environment or pose, lana --to risks to health or safety," Construction, of a facila ty such as a school, is considered to be a short-termuse of man's environtncnt in that, relative to;_ the existing age arid'potent l al diltatign of aur environment, man-made strtYcturps rarely .colmparG relative to life -span. Although not lonq_tetm in nature, en developments through the centuries have often thuiarted the porpett ,ation of certain elettients of his enrrironmesj t, ultimately eliminating them txom the earth (e. c or endangered, animal orlant s ecies) P p Therefore of , continual concern to taays lean, as well res the "man, of tete :f Utuxe; should be the effect of his activities on the envi.ranment O� ;*suture genera -ions T.ha'se responsible for choosing tc�e fate of the subject Project - should °carefully ' wei.4h the poli ti•ve,ene'its which Will be producer by construction of the school against the potenbial adverse impacts to our envirObteht on a .Long-term basis. After, carefully stuayinq this report, the Paradise i)nifipd, school , D1.strict EOa.rd of tdtxcation may approve the subaect project ,Only if they determine that the short-term use' of the envirotament associated with construction of the' scho�il will be ma.t e be2ieEiciaJ than Maintain1.h the s,it for the enhancement of its potential ;long-term '�xoductivity. Tho information 'contained heroin seems to,sticxgesf: 'that the " gteldtesb long"term impact which, will result' from the construction of the proposed project will be the lass of the project sit'eas 'a hat ural, forested open spaceti Nature is siilendidRay ly, &ed .on the site, and residents of the � vc Izity enjoy the luxury o;f v�irtually undis�4txbed , la erness ' hich it affor'd's. Associated with th,e 1pss of open spice and W"l, is; the �loas of tt�.e trees chick` wild be cleared to make way :for the structures: 't�',nyt, reritoval, anti the removal of tho potenbi,al for propagation " 1 of them w ] b-� ' peims;he,nt With h cbnstYu ` ' Chan of the project. PAO' ' S. a Y.r I V I VII. A%TrIMNATlVES TO TETE PROPOSED PROJECT th`e,;park i 's,' o A.' i0 PROJECT ' As wi th any' development consideration, the al,t,ernative of abandoning altogether the project proposal must be considered. In the case of the subject project, opting for the no�-project alter'native woti'ld require finny: xig that the . p resent' facilities of the Par,adis:e Un fied 'School Distract are adequate to.: not only accomodate the prese:nL ehrollment-, Mas ted but also adequate to provide for the educationt�l of estudents ,needs all future enrollees. The opinion of this .xeport, based. A Para, upon, the data cnllectecl and ,contained here'ip is that this is not a viable al ter'natiue. tbatd Of B.. ALTERNATIVE S.ZTE ,LOCATIONS inoofyporat; "Pro'ect As was iscussed above in the Back round" s ti 7 5 :sec o,n, several. bites have been analyzed by the PCJSb' over, the past 12 or 13 years a$ootential locations fora new school.; The, deter ination f 1 m t o � he PUSD 'staf and board is that the ' subject site is the most feasibleof any they reviecaec3 N relative ',o ec' ft&4108-j location; aria site"suitabii13IL'ty. One of the 'alternatiVO sites which has received a creat, pa}Au u11 .. t./.l» G 4 ...G would appear to S1te, It would th`e,;park i 's,' o OistrI cty t"Here ' be Made, °The P. on the basis o` The Ply&RD' residents' » rvil;7 not ]: Mas ted already b estudents A Para, tbatd Of inoofyporat; r the people of Paradise"id not favor building an ` j additional school; and, The, PP&RD would ..sell the land if they are unable to secure funds to develop the park. On the basis of the forgoing, the `opinion -)f this report is that the $1116 Road Park is not a viable atornative site' for a prpject sim��ir to the subject proposal. P noted in the "Pubic sentiment" section of this report, �s n p ► Invitations were made several; tithes at the b Community m ed by Cook, A$8ociates for' i'nfo,rmation, about Fora conduct known sites that would be feasible aternatxve 'sites for' the sub'ect. pro ect, No res onses were eves' i0 J j p n ode to those invitations,' ...I Cook As�oc-iates staff--- reviewed the :public opib ior..section_ ("Letter;s to the Editor") of the Paradise Post from 19I ,to the ` present and ascertained that no viable al.ternasive site., had bee"ra S C ' 'sted which had not been analyzed by the w PUSD . An,'in-deptk�'analysis of all available vacant. land in the tipper Ridge area 10a4 not done as a part of this report, However,' it would seem reasonable to assume that a site upon which a school could' be built does exist in the less-di!welaped areas,. Eecause the other, sites would necessarily elkisL. in undeveloped areas, thepotential. for_ them Having the availablE utilities is low, and' the; - pot11_ntial for disruption 9f natUtal areas is great.- _ Thepiof this report is that alternative t 0J,ea s prooably e but' the -environmental impacts r ' lost associated with development of them for a school would be either .as great, as, those associated with the pt.61?dsed . ,I. -e, or greater. Ci SCHEDULI .. G ALTERS ATIVE5 1 " - 1, . YEAR I20Ui�D SC Year round .' schddl. ih,, bLIves an attendance pati.ern� arran emeht which divides the 8tuden g is into �our.ro;tatIng, atten at ce group'.p; with ea0 group being an t acaa�i While the others are in school The ;concept pLovides 25% more space without the need' to Other advanta' buil:,d additional. .facilities'. ges include- Less instructional time' spent on review .due to shorter vacations; General classroom i:ehavox of students socros, '` to improve,; i . as Students seem to acad,emi Cally ach ete as well:. those on a traditional schedule; and, Staff's vacation activities are more varied. The following disadvantages are also inherrent wtli the - schedule : ' costs increase due to the need f0 A'. air condtioned rooms; additional transportation; sj�ecial- cabinets for storage; a clitianal, utla ties; and, more administrative, secretarial , custodial' and specialist skiff time;` Rotation of attondance groups elimi nz<tes normal staff preparation time; Vacation periods are altered, sometimes involving children of the samefamily at different tifne's; Participation in yearn-'round schedule would be .mandatory rather' than voluntary as in those areas' w where it has been iati.ized stccessft�tly: Vaca lines are iY� con'sta1 b use` leavin4 little-' -- t.i,me for ge'nerAl mal,,itenance work;; and, Some enhancement --type p>rograms are curtaa lead °due d invo lvement., to lacls� of .continuity a� _ The pOSD estimate that at the current rate of growth f i student` :populatidhs at both ponderosa E;Leinentar,y School and Paradi:-e elementary school would teach tete capacity ovid�e��" b even ear�Yoind ool before the end of the r sch 1r y 2- ��chaol year it is the apini;'c�n o: this report' that year-round school i.s a itiable temporary solut.'l of e� isti, g oder--crowding 8bWtve,r it"is billy temporary at best, problems: k _ it not be considered as a prefetrable t;erefoi e; can , al'ernative above the proposal it add it. can ibe provided 'which vii 1 allow future e�zpari'sioh and i#OW, o;f stl�deht' populabl ,dn. � pG. 7 2.« DOUBLE SESSIONS ' Double sessions is ari alternative wh cPv, a"s discussed earlier in this report, is already, '" beincrutilized'' fo'r, second, and thirdgrades (and beirir considered dor first grades) at Ponderosa Elementary schooli3y startirq classes earlier and reducing curriculum and activities to mini mtum standards,, capacity, can be d'atzb''led with rio additional 'cost. The educational disadvantages of this ty .e of scheclu p n� are so ,obvious and wtdel acknowledged tYiat C:aok Associates y does not believe an 1 -'depth'anal tis as necessary, The opinion of this report I's? that double sessions is I a, viable, but undesirable, alternative'; 'he pegat, xve educational' iriipacts associated 'with this sched'ur, 'impacts the environmental associated with the proposed Vi^ D. EXPANSION OP EX18TTNC FACILYTIES Anatys.es pzepaz;ed by the PIJSb indicate that addit ono] class "rooms could be constructed' at ;Paradisenrermediate ScLhobl.. Sixth grade students from the district ��o"uld be moved from their elr,itentary schools to the s ek�an.ded '-. lova _16ft: - f Lana `area is av ilabxe and- the cen rali,za,bion o students into an educational park (i. e:, Paradase Elementary and intermediate) reduces costs int the areas olf trans ortatian -and ca.�pteria« p 5chaa` 1 facilities such as � ' -. offices, toilets, 1'ibrar-y, etc. ;' could be t1ti:Litzed by bath schools, trios reudi is th'e number` o 11 dings needed, t it has been estimated by th;e Pt�SD that the Classrooms and an associated gymn'asi�im or multi-purpose zoom would cost ,would appkb i Oa$.1', 500 000 andpr.�o'vide relief to the � district for 10 years. At that time, alternat1ve soltittioris would have to be pursued 15 ` t�]e Opp 101 of "-this report that expansion of e3.] S'�1C1 1 litip`s is riot an ecotlomica�_ly viable a� ternat faca Ivo-, in that t it ^b 'I only :temor6 ty xelie« alt the enol of the projected '10 � years of, relli eLf the dLijb .c:tWOUI'a again be � I nvol�re in sima'lax corls�,de ata chis' as the subject pz0j.bof. . Q i\\ r�-p I a� w 1 I ' a 1l ) Vit. +' �•,.q•Y'+r t w.w"µ'*1•'�..y�'ti„�.++'td�w•*wwFa 9� f .0 W A �.n.�.0 � y ,1 � r 1- 1 41 �• �� � i ��� t� , r r g 66 Nt na ax 1 aOt.W If 441' o • � `• n. .sv t ? � M'!MA) a PO/U(%%SB i .'*`���—• r Reservorr AZ;j�,tli,` 4 a y14 Q, J Aii`d ; 4, At Y.D({N Gvr+. �(r ob,v ' At iWPw009 tT '1AAPbN' 141' A0. ,wtTn0At1-;Klw .1ail'1R r,s5k1 v ° �+o�' i iii t r xto '^ ' ♦ pAtt' L N w ` All 6 OICTIV 1 ct '111{114. F r' AJ. CAOCRtT C .1.1gbA; i 41t r 1144' o r J • hAl4{ ' + a Ak,. 0Alt ■Al .1'141141�t'1 1 «, '" t� 1111rY'O aMN{ Cdrtgi rrr 1 e 'f. r. i q� '%itp1 N. l� / A[ .100.1 CF .1'1tlp A4: VAiIA'h Ct.. 64410'10.. Ah COLTtA CT A.1411hK.. -� AM' Y 4l1Agp Gt 6Nltll: M �y IAN '�•.�*41 V N x ! e 'i" v '� a e d s `# ~• F�, a �• � '� �a.111.41 � q� t , P �� $�`At�s �, �• 1ihA1lt1 � r Q T�iiF> r45 utq � C1h v •k 9 ti`t 144 R 116 �. "il ° ar AAVA.10 114 A/�w'1 0A h r 1�� i""r-,� 4V. 141 „"� « �'ra Mh i 1444 .1MA4VV 4N �q S wF nt-�`" ka �a•� c.A qr.000r AAP, AVi t,A ��' 6�1.��fltF 1141 � � - . .. iY4 L N 61ri� to W �atl ° 7 -, .z is . .. ^ " >t p 's t, +w wAAiFtr' I 3 d ��"qqt"k �♦r .wu1 xct � 4��1 �'� 6mA'r flil,}41 Gq � 4Y, r V ?)q «• r a x®r r P� 11G�e�rtvo'�r - ' PRDJECI". )Yl Ari ntF 41 414 11ttW., iA , j I I "•'krw.. SITEw n<- N � #♦ � 1'Yw its * w � "'*,',i' . � lb�+tAY "�{I � +�•..a LNC irk Y' Mpt'� + �4� 41,� J.'.h,��c '`,tr, t{'�,ti1 � r # s�o � �t •% 'i) ny Aa0J9d� t� C �� ^ ��•+ teed t+`id °'R'PG.• e+At.. r,'1 R * a R NIla. u01,4wr pt.- �« �y wt a e W'w Y'f C1, - taw A41�l� NC•N11 �'' �Y i}i ld YArl4tw r +Mt u,, m �4w'4� i - V 6R•rX4 GAt �" 3° •r•�"1 p 1'4 � A'�. ,:: .�-a.w�.,� i.+�. 1�x p&JAiAy Y1A ar sAatAf15 A t'i ' r 1 �{ * Q ; 'w R+xSb v kA"rA �tld Ae�si 'bd «jARV op e•Y•41,. ` if aw ;! r+'4' Rada IA OSAfA mt ti � ` �4 " ♦ E u N4515 ,,++ r hF1J 4Y' F�i2+y�rt' glJi 0k�'r 4 Ih 7rP. �w I°h1' a tl I d, l A'.AV'!"��, 1 ix J41 RM7 F0t1M 1Y {N 4y .+:i;+y" Y �fr'Y to i�^t. ► a 'A" n r`. a@Atli" kB9kfYA4C'' b�+I"55A tAkt, Y J.: ra:}'� t i W 541;1 Mlxtr^ tl dd A lv C01 wt Ci aYA41e!!z1 4{M, C't 1'4 ,r 4 y, r a ; ayKG wzi 4 t 1 C M t rb'i+ R` v �. 47'q' " ,fir, ;l ` rFaAc•A s ata, M l�r �gss ct k n• .. 6 r ,m/d � /. '� « dA Ctwttt,rl Ab !a '1X$.141 ;ik of,{" Ct a' •'Aa�P^y1 zt aF' -t k �i41lt� ,6iiF�C�t br # •y „ �>, ^ r t r a t Qgei2t�d �x�A�ilrA( w�JZrG +,il"N Yv G1 . �., *v4 ., I'fty1F. F RRA05° "A471,ti, l" Y i Rpa w ctMOAt.AY4 ' � ppt,+a��b+rxhA•� pp t�`{�y At � f,h►�;uz�l`� kw"1"0 Ata +A A t t KCA",!•1w rj -. n 4.1'1376 �L�K�,9 »A as„ +• rF .1 9�Sw ,� �� 4RAAlkN aA rr a d. � � Aatw � •�w n t yytM"4tt(JA. M r !, l •%a t p4AN ' w �Tk q vNtN a"� �' �.1t+I�k .1noNr cry---w^i+��x �y �`,�� • � t1r. �'y, � s �, � IA.. r n . ►� h�tsSh' tidtbliAt i!M �' bp INS p1' AP'OENb1k � i. 4-4 .. y � �; . ,��.,t •'4:de is. ire ��� ,t�. ,�' Y. i y �, 'tip . •1' �y� ,� a y" pQt} ;t�.. e> yy v a ia, i ,} - �• 4-4 .. y � �; . ,��.,t •'4:de is. ire ��� ,t�. ,�' Y. i y �, 'tip . •1' �y� ,� a y" pQt} ;t�.. e> yy v ia, i ,} - �• V"4 .. - 1r. . . ... +•. y... 4F�..i• .'`fit: �' f` �• f, . r ' at low 'All , ir 01,j(' A+"ta u,r! 9 • '� � �k �� �*� t; ' { . `. •},�.r� !}��[,,Ny Y'Y a a � N lC,I?H•,� YI, � � � �k�'. ' nii�ty�l9�ini '� Ydv 4• '' _ .� � �qr�7 9 � p ' t+uea r .4 ♦ "'1r '17a ) t r ry r � t r° tE 4+,AI r♦y�,. " rn d �r��a{;��{t'r�q?itC t,y*a '� tr,4�t y� :; �tW.1+t��"'-'FY"f �7:�fi. f'. S }tea i 4, V''i,�?'w3yj, k"", ...... rMj`a Yrs S a ``4Yp� r , 1� t' •� yy�, n �7 :Y ,a„�•�d�eF'�i���T f�.:ldrtt�'�'F'y�♦< I��� Aw.}fit Y ti ..1 Q to br w _�•" M`4�'� off ono-il WA}� ��... bYq, {«Y'xy ' ''f". �f• �J' il ,=1%. � � /f/ � 9. � �r. l:. .fir �'� �. • "O �w '4't'f.,t��`vtV�,'y � A'+w%+�+ �' Bei ,!a ' r 'F6`X' a.. "►}.Y k y � . !AA.. • { _.. ,k J�fl l , `1_tll dei p;7F.'P'yc'V �. �L . {I� \ I�N4...r A* .�� . '�,,.. � " �'� rM~�l:A^I �t "'•�•. ,�'' _ rr` `' b, k'µ� J �17�1��' tR a .Y. eZ fc..,n^'. 7.1 r-• y� � J/} t f 4 • >n � ,y„.. ,..fly A� Y• _v, x JI ✓+/'�"t ��� rS1 � . • i f dsY ��4 p�'+ *. i' Y I •• " r ,� . r , • 'XM r f� _ �' �� � y+ ;yeti �; "";��,si�+"* � . s �.��:�`:;,,�'�` l,��'T�. ,` • �. � ,�\ !y, )'R,f "ti y+ � ,,. $•� �"(� '��� ��,,�, ,. t W.y ' ya,.. ' .` \.4�«'k1 H. �• 1:� 'v«, 4t"y 4.1 .a * r �s 1 +"" '►Y� �'�t pax df a ,�+�,'�„ Rf•.;t �6 7 es'. *' Y •� .tet «�' y` y, '.+ti �+. rW A � •. i ♦NA�rp vf?y o � kiph }�� i'^�� �' i • } a �� e J 1 ., J f, �,t.:' �,.r S:lf j�., �� '� , t �h�j•,, � �7'na?; � tit: � �. ��• �"� '��-�.,, +� , `�i ��..� . � •�Y � l y a :f i�, � � � t • �' �'�+: { J �t , !�. ,n 1..1, }': ,,r ` • iiµ _e• +. � if '� � ,` -'ii. • 1:` �.. .r� z'ir 7 � w�.yk Ji � •i,�! jw i Cook Associates - '2 - beaembet 22' 1.gr3't li the'£ire was ,reported a's a '►brush £ire" and thle da w"Asot 'h 5 and tl ry 1+110 initial ;w`esponse would include sir,. en' nes, two b.i. ] ldazers, an ai attack plane, three a� t tankers, ;a large helicopter with skew, two, handcrekrs; A tattalioll Chie£ and a nivasfon Chief (Attathment 2) Moc nent and equip, onnel wou. pets 1d be dispatched` as needed::' TE1> ItRE PROBLEid The fire problem in the Paxad3 se Pinta ,arca is not any difert!nt than the Problems encounteted in the Toon of Paradise or any other haghlky potrtl;tl`ed mountain tomn�tinity» Mb;te "fires occur because there are more pea le `1'he potetrtial for a major fire always ekittsy but the prrwsrtihtte a£ a scha o'l has no :elationsl1i to this p potential, al, Ln. fact, t'he ugc of the ScttCstr l as a _safety island ft the event r; at a ,fire is benetici a1.� On;e 0£ the concerns of the people in the E,rc_*a is thAG the rand s stem is inadequate to handle an evacuatiar►'. The IlPines" road system in the i good cotriparec to the "funnel �i;ng" ,keeded' to gat dowrn the Sk yway'» Fire r' Department planar do not call for a major evacuation in the event of A fiie» t,Te would only evttc.uate isolated :areas, those that are going to he ,. y , the school .c . be used to, house thosetthat we ve£a!§k ed tb; IeAV e their homes : ouJ d 'The occurence i0f fire in the ithmeili ate area OZL the school may inckease but: if r proper P ecautions are taken, rhe potential of these- fires! beconti.ng ma `or could b''e 1.es tv other 3 s than mas "Pines".; areas i n,the IMPAOTS OF THC SCHOOL 011 THE ;F-M,..j)2PiRtl'REN'1? r .1 have ftVi.ewed the impact statetrieUpidge ttilildexrtess nt prepa"tett' by the per R Areas dea1.�.0g - with pit U6 ss.fety» To the best ;of our Ability; wei identifyany sigatifteant, impart t the schsol ta3'11 have on the rite 'department operation.Seboals just are trot i'ii e p> otection problems. r1EASZIRES'. T11A'1" 'CHID 1:7128 B)JPARMENT I�WtD 1,Z1tE INCLUI)1jD 11V THN PLANS POR ; 114 P, SCHOOL r That we be able -tts gt+t within 50, f0et o - e eactn structure with out f'ir apl�axatus - That no building, be irdo tr than S00 Eee!t- £rotr a fir e hydrant t1lat can r » prr�v� i de a minimum of.000 gallone par tttintltcc Tha an emorgericy, to,Ad be ptttv� d" d coktneiri ing the bite, tinct Soot*ti Park Dkive Thi r c , s A .cess sflaui.d; be 1atec� «. -� Th#t access ge providt~d to tate pIdy �t "talds so that it the tvait the is used to hourci A fiYtW uEm1i tis i'c>`tgees" thetYir aretzs c`' !"d n used, f bt Parking, Thai; all brush 1 s clr;ar� d `y btillding and fl tbm wj ttii,n 30 feek 0i e�tea that tree lJm s are ryirtc�ved that' a tr within 10 t+cet csi Clic �odf5: r , r■r�r �:. -- Ahiat:NtiiX. �j WA Mt:�rali�, C�1 nom? ;:t t,} 1kOl : � "Fle Gil OrovL' It i)I cl ; ni J Gi-,3°!, �4tkv r';1'ary, c rlvi ronrtcr? 1�al • Cnct: OLSain Loth the iMI., and ,Ii Cts, ty c Lhe. ir,c i,nu" 11r�'ri ..'� r�t`:4`iC?;, in teM be Sub,tc n,tiRa i riilh. p 40 acre t'orez-L wii C 11 �'E2 _jr1''%t�;1 laC)I t:�y a 'L >; acre element scklGol vi th tho .Otvontual GLU(�.'+1,,1.t j O� �CJCi 5t11r1f:l1,1"'7 � t rtLa or Chan+7Q, r1` r• 1+n' ,. a. �, 4 .� : 111t 'I � I �Ct� tra r c, 111iT,9F'1 {l� u1.t Linc 3, at'" ohilclt, noJ 5 y- rl o: , r` arid through tho }y4 ,.'c Cj 1 + �r}'*f C c �rt(t�r1o� i 0I1 ' TFSL;i Ltii e1 v2i`j? rClilrl �r'i:r�ti�lhtlf ll1 Rif c�viit:Fllit� C) iit�'1 7ro QLCl�r �� ry �.. r.a _S .rj. ''l.;i, k [ly (,Aft J,�,r, lit,�i! nvcie rhe ,r O la sa �' Ali foot barrx x of t.nt;CJN� on thO ho U1, and oA:1+Jt,oi I the 5Chpol and, Pepit'iondoS to more Ps;Ie11oltSga ("al wTali �racL�.r:rl;l; �r x 8 r'CrAll :Ls at Ica�t 8 " ' r o t�It,k tw �Tt %l1� 111:Civ')'-' I,Gv'.r high ura 's ,,III halro ttla art'oct on n�4s�� rc'duct— y h�ryt Thus som- 1 ,�� lit. vrz �l t ,• brin t n o;itabl= shed hcr� :� rzt rl h;�tn :try , .,. ' 61 noise levol. bye to a vEx;y ho ?ally peop �. L;:10 1110ved to tht .Pines''"ea -to K:.�'C?_'}� t.h;' .e � t mat �5 ., 'l lll.tslt7C`Et:i LZ`a;, t'nrnE:<l:',, etCo will k3E?' r+y�,�o`'a f,, (J ''+aye, 5. ,t Grp i . Ca . " r 'XSO C k � Z Ss 1` t;� ra eJ.l k l sbrae local re. l'cic:ri ., to " cnsider rg6irir. trs escApe the rlcsise. Li�,ht and Grlwra g la to r_i x�earlt �tr]ti ers i �� ti The :i"o�.l�h.zn � wi. M si "' � � e en`v} dnrr►�tttal impact: ' d° i+'or f tla�nn G'`'lP,11t a?lCk for �4,fvCLirt ty, pLtrr}rive' the propO8ed 6CF2ors1 huve exbl ?rinrlighting, in spitz; of the prioposed ggreeribe:lt- bufrctr Zor're the 'trot,onti.on of site tran-sli will hot completely scree these l ghte f'rnnl ra:� dental ho<aes bord,lrin' the sit,-, since the slehoal: d.*LoL t~ictropat,«;� to sham th?~ proposed ;3i.tie 1'ra`Fsh 'tho Broca recreation district them AS no a ,thara.ty to A arr+ `u he estabk sl��t o;l° of 'rii«kit .i ht ct tta'roatj rix a:t areas t tooth6 , o `uz-thex' add? t t, ' u•ht anti ` Z�rzrir.! tl ;c: "'hc #`off 1o40rir! el� i J r sigttLfio<tnt s:tv�'rse 'env rants :rltai 3;ilpac�,.. ao TFze pi,a w ;l land ua , far the : +� doc�:dG 'ha:i b'con l rabY c iana ent. Thi ( al.4 i e QMan '* a d aiiiin , �, .y' b property t�;�az�ere purc.ha,..d tl�oa,k*' Pro) becait5a 3 bziz�ke;rcd a l a 'I'f'iµg�or rlb�«i't araa. Ti eY nattlratiNtra;�eti by t1.e actio 0± th© federal oVF17VAetlt and t 0 100al school di6t at i'hus the 1lt,oi�zt,: otz af' Thr,; t,tazliet .1<'nd >1, of the €:res has rioLmet tdth much ptibc lci'caL 4pprQia:l}id n.o: rnrt.r+ tCp.n tklt,,oourt.i� This trend i:r ro;az-rled t�-itFzr4at ��on�lex b k local, reeidents 'hocatt6ei it qene Itpilfir;:6u'her 7,.0 ;.t para v ee1� tc .spacila tzon txrtc� 1'>it;.ua4e a;Luez,o.,o;i ba: thd pr'opbSe( 814 ueit v�l.opaltant w a1ar.nf.n7�rtit: vritki�tiproz"tIjo tffia ` mtiriy acl— ids6 of ani Msk.ai�" i sh:�ci �a�z+r�t t�ee�rlerltiJx�l tzr �t izr �l�?mi at n]. o u t4. 'Vd h - , p 1a 6 5 tot eons bey,hd 'tre cfi.l ri 1a=i, aria alit. iM, a et�t'tX 3,c�hnt boheltict trh� iA a,W, i tty rr d } �: l Ll rli'r 1. �,rtd � y ikiC�,- J1 Aia and bl tiftd-.`l'k,1C3i1 �, y' c r w. . f .1 . 1, ;l,�t � - � :l. �.�z1.n`��.y- teirizi . to bra l,h 1.�a1� e.ctan�:1 shod swj o� t`teptii"oa� parse 3c �� tt p5 �11w. ocl ; oFr<hluhi tiw; ;1ta , t ra: ori zc; t.,� ter i y} y9 r {�y y� lyt+ ♦.1/� y`�qi§�Ylhaty�ryy'�+�'.J.�-�„�ti�.Fa1l��.tr7o:1.yuld"C1,�r., dlubhout� LFJTr��L�i:.-11 4�J+4;?j 'l lar 117 .41 VQ�41i 4''1 J.�i'6.1.k�Cit:it/ri_l� PAC �� A .4i�4.GG Y L"lal ,♦ t r tterttz ian liar <itik�s ha jtLt1� t iro r Y�tc� ` ` tza ret t.or3 ` rk lbi.on of public ro:cr0°it" ;wt►��i: f aa„ LL'li3.tt.ri tY1'tr4 rt;ii rat` rl3a irter rlr�.n:iliYr.,,°,,� rrlrc5tirl�;i>7 ra`,iv of ar, e ` 1 APPEN�Ik N � oi• 8 UZ W, J at!, 1wl-fj 1• lii'.. S iilt,`di�' N i The L al.l♦V 3Y.i,.Ik� '11 .i..1. •L .2 L/ .75+ I.t J. 1, 1 4. i9��. •J n.1. �'�..Y.1„ I l y "!.v' n ..i.i 1 La ti YS.!`S"�J .�]fM i1 JV!.+i�rlsl�v'n 1.ICuYt:%G Y: �,. ar ci.06 'i".,. 7.whC? O -pa :,a.i,aae the .. a6 the }J�''J' j ,i.ncr4, d41Mn& fmradd?,'flivno?anti and ;l.ngiL64lse altaZs 2`cltr3 r hen _i ,r.Atti'L � .3 l:..rit lv �+n% i f ^ O. ' c rLll.an ' `fit, r� , � L ^. ttta aert>and of the a'iraitJ.oi`Il 1t7 �aci~ea o t;h� r�,ot w�ticddit ona, on and .I�c,r ar�n run�r� i �h �. �"' rrcm nds .' nOwablo natural iwosourar:s tai sk .oi` Sai The fo].?,atrilg, mar ri.sttJ_t 4 r ai'i.c�'cnt ti 'I iMpact r�►:Ytnert l� bttee are no sources Lor natur ell s �, I.n �, f F ,. _ _ " " in the ryn. 2 13 yax• thi ror�as.d c.noo rx� l ?ta.d, e tree F,yxye 'Of rte t s p C ti wtii;-�.Y�nT tic"iiellell- i."-p.ropa-1 in tl, e'4 thcr �. da`n� ofiposion alld �mpelldxn f,`i;. 7'he parlcinU o 'ip to >8 c"ars oh uhf: propbted pdrki.ng lot is a"pQb'anti.2 so1'Vae Of d�tm•e around o,In�e;, -:ha.ldren, the pci,s' h� e it l af' �:oxio r,Yzenta c:zj; bI� �rats,ncl �►nd, `r:2:znt � � ::onA I.S a;Sourctl of datl�er to ''Sttt�dont,r`i a, w�� r, y rd ., 08idcn ,w .�bOVo. all a s the cI :rt ear off'irr catziea a an e�:p].o'stian,' scoici ret, ar arson ithx;`h;'rtaulc end an the c t is ntp and residerltt seed tpv ci to :�tf; Community. s a,, u uci ' Population The .tolloivznt, Will result ll is s118n p-:C',tjt adti~� rsd on�rirort,`ns,ntal, a The propasod pro JCC Will, have, a u rio'ar 1.Ip� oL orl the ;pa;p+�"L' ` area .�Ilri otzt�dirt ; thd; sd>haa C a;+id the U er Ridg&, m � .an of the I p ip .�he area a_ tilt: Pr+�pbsocl schnbl was oki in illy de' elt)p�d and ad.,t�r.,,.l soei as a rrt romprit �z�E:a pl,!3en�,� bene It l S '�Jo cul ated, : s ix x! a s :tl � y �It tlz�t i by gQ to F�5 % api X`t'7r z ec1 I.x" 7bla 1, c r �rrt n iili r aloe i.ts ar'1 p As the pr6tmsed Schuo� ��ie���l.t� j5..,, t J S cl I., �rf prok�able that ,hd~ older rc:idrtts sra 11 t,ant 'Ea t<;Acato tho as hc7r; atxriIirw tho =ho' ina}' ,nf; P( ble 14 loca t` bll i ai" runNr•r ,�= b bon h6 - it of pop�il �Ita on sliru! tl nae be a�tayredy fit' i�' 1 � `., n.,ar the s�,hoolb , �;ii3..£ cWItl bet -;"se- wotU o.t the v,�i:b`Lo �,,ttroa�* in''the'n,f th �at �` p i al hc,..� booty .sal,d ar d went is . ciceuYxancy t1l � � 'x"ar ae thb rate o.0 i tz�ltn; perp tat o: ;carr n the 0 .a; r i a s tl:e z oath z•a��s zrt' gah6'a ttttt .dr t4 � i3t rA^ t nor stit"Vey; 1970) this 'meel'd�te .fiarn l� a�.�r� �n li to o hatttrvhol,tl upper xdi; a, is 2bk � sorb 'bet Plle�stirdy ut;�tl Sat this rt:et4�r, Usas. a schao pc�pttlawxar► a� ` ii -•t ;�tuda�tt s 1��;,�h�rt t�ia3c 5'itlat.+,on � ,� th ,p�.ri+o„ocl,scixa�il, This �'I�;w a h �etl ttti.rely tipciYz ,t11� st �Ws x"'rbm the at i� suht�o '.arLnanistr txan and it txb'� ve,11P;Led The ropol't also itp,te;t tltat !Tazadise sGhaos ard: on :cioitb o sfw;3�x ailo�ia ";`o corre,c , the :atat,t:meht etY[1 the 2na and 3rd graciet dre an douL-1 ... St tsxoiis a,ttdl t-116 rtu hrr an double, :;eat .an 'this eai is :est` �` than dt that t -i last : yoat� ' h ttdba mi af' 000l. l7us 'tr�s,i' w3 rr t�tl � It ht;tideixts to f'a`ri� cls ::e ft�zr ?�, : ita�e� �, t�1 ;xta t.�i t r✓a ;x r.evr' school. sd;llool�tt tvJ,l at tl t:L, ':� �3t� w 'Phil fd`�»w 1 w c.tlt eltl'vGw, "ice' »+ . ., zl.lti s� cl�i anti ,`. "hi; l�ttt .�iirY ta.t' nell adyhtol clop rx trio ricart ot` 'a rotat-let2ti i' , ;tz 4attrattx�r� i n ito�;,r` V4 'o.t'.v`try�,jtid l.oy a -a' n� t h o : .yi 1;x� y.l,a'hyxY e v nt ally gt t l i?ll Uclonli.,M” S PIU+kj ���I.,+t}u`l, l'1�lI W5F.,4::FUtZi lC3t�lr di f Skl �j �u'i���1f �/�1����. }"fir .�3 `t iy`:n la •. c" Yi 3 ray tit sl. ii:2.i a r;ontl ter rto It 2 ��iil�s ones t sddita,�� tt v°ol'i., i.dar tt def c t ih m I �i► rt;h t, ` tr�► j' o 1: Gh ley 't tour not o?sno� �Y p�.�•� �� a f �. a add on h �'4 flak• troe't:> lig the " �Ailmi air a 4�iii e tiltovkj h t�t0 P, rn° p 0,sbid, acll�ttira� a, w tt� pandro tVay utitl Cra;k;tarijr;to, fin' zn z.tt�a o;i rta i3de`,tva,lh:r, 'titlpavtd ste:et 'lrai.nte A08NtliX 11 r r- "e6 JVl tfjslli�l, f;A '5q$95 r' a,1, Li Gln v`;<.i1�• 1M11^ 70�i.0liti T `J,, ltl ond: r, eo a z iond:flk�"Ant atIvt rs6 cn. 1., only ''}inti.mtCRL1� Y OI' t'.O t'y f ;4ti'1ti"L7Yl 1)Ot'iC il:c boil voi1:�.1 f;t ( t o utt j �a tO 411COver � ikf�y»AYl 'etT't� .cm. ir?;x tl uv be bt1t-a.�, -rhe y c:i7dez vrf�L(;ri� Of i17��T1ificrncs: J�"�:vEir �'3T1(�I.rIC3 LIYfC c 11, b�:o� rat Cf� for _ r, �xa9`ri ratimrnta a 5).j�l'i�",��.cr'1�l. e by the 2'c?'v,:lilti r7�>=i1L^+j . x! 3yy�/�12'C♦�1 Ca ilial] ui:E"ti QI _'Fle Ut���r1, U« •, fee1:3 4. hat ' i�ktta J. ' 1Q f f' g ?- ; t1}[tyf�St♦F T 'a ni «f`. 17 H�1 .4. 1pCt4 Vv9i a, Tho project. does, have thv s ; t ibs ificalq•t,enti t to �i091, ;ae the Ottali of tno cn.vIrormati in the aaa�;�c,i.�tr ait�:ti� of tho p-oJect; subttt tltaa zY 1;,� 2`E''C�LtC( t�'l r. . ;tc1t; 7ittit o� wildl, ; 7e... �' • �. c�.es yn bhc� arra; tl�i�oat�n �a �`�'r�sl.call` rs�txe:p the ry. �-'� J �. `.' yi.l 1 t. t .ts�t .nn3>��t� caru;ufuty on tic si :e; 7� dttCt;-'F:rtd +estz�Eict tEka ran�;� of a" r,�ra or arlt k xf �� plant, or 4.ni tla:i � i�":l t y`=r � � •�" �.�, � q� Asa Ca•lifottd histo�'yu b 5ht5m bein Venofa.to, .of the proj,ct r%L1 bo t, 't ;s c!t:4;`arn�arzta of puU?tical y a, OP ltn�;..; r-:•tn t:r_v ronm�l�t'al. goal so` the Y cl1 l oz, it; r;as: r socia6»eGori6mic athasph, re ofsant--t-cu*',rotftent rra,,ij] bt gradu4ily citarigo_i CJ'v"or -iho long -tent 1;eWlod to tho dotyttt?21ofthreli�L �e�'CSCk^.. c o):=: un t , o • The, f3;�tic1�',1l shr rl't o,t a: school atd x't crs'auiOTl arena �1a 7 CTtG'rJtui2 t;` ,b"he Otlw'yl*- irib up o.t ti► l 'rcmaxn n 6 ,oct•ao of this wncl.•Liid, aY'ea, k 'Tho asbab i htslcnt t> ' s public rLicroat :oflay area Wvj.' :tt a pl anrlatl coikt�ltla tri "y el bo tlrllu,:t�hle llti��lxt Duch as motof ry,rlr €;stns etG. a.n'tb az`e;x a C4 'tlo } ropo tl b.rel jooi will, ttcvc .x:ltyox„4tlt . ac r 7c F�lv� r r.;n i7t,a irt�1Ct,' nt; thC: local vo and t`atax xtlt'l__Orj �11d St9�l��,� httt� khat ;vb the of•��-u`i"�.t?' e�C7tiJ;t- strGat►1 Flttccts Of pb', tttecl i'u- —off 3.b why w'c ax�t~ �nslau].Yt�y (>h the fro R11 X11". j: :it ]"tJ Ft �iav Of, oilirf",a#1 }ll1C'� lltl��l�r�"i"�UY1t1 4tcl�ic cSp da Tho' projcGb vnal h�Lu' actv rst: ;;ot ion ria xby resit crit 'btrcatts off` nc� otl�� fuel t;o :lcsit1tlarlj i.Ylcrc;t4��ci i1oa at:a'os o� r'a' s turc rtaa t ti, �.nn d"f tr..�.,� arl� ukitiat'L�toxv la�:l o>' vrl.�.tt7..�. r:, aril j rwsort,fitL j.y ttklttitt� �f, ' Mi LCl wl Hung Toi, ,: On�!,iittC2»t.t �b:l afd i 2tyY't` t;1o31 A�'phlblk i r , TILE 21AJ'OR WTLllt±Pn_nPECIES Ur NLAmALS Common Name' Sc enl:� 1, J4 in i �3ltdger (raze) TatLrdwa,'xaxus, -'- Sig b,:own bat _ Black Bear (rare) 'GtOS t Black-tailed jdckrahbit amexicxtrtus Leis Bobcat cal.fprniC�tln L n'. , fus Brush mouse Brush rabbit Peramyscus bo}o CrLiforni deermouse 5�IVilagus baclttnnni E'eronyscus ca�fiinrncus and r,,r� Gt111�ornia to,;;lirrel g OtQsermophilollt3 beachE'yi.: Coyote Can7.s. lantrhns 17rver ,mouse Dutiky�-footed woodrat Perom scus mariicttlatus i Gr�ly I'oX Neardina fuscxnEfs UrOC:.'p � n cinerer1ttraettteus, ' Lahr-tailed meadow frtouse M6untain lion (rare) Microtus longiraudus hiu7 e (black tai'] ed) sheer, l;elis concolor Odocoilew oni5 'myotis bats -hetn riyotis spp. Porcupine taar_oan Erdthisoh dorsatum Ring-tail'(rare) Proc on lotor. Bassariscus ,r SilVery--haIxdd bat astutus� Lasionycteris ri� ctd gatls _ - Spotterl skunk Strie skunk Silo ale_:' utorius P — r i Totansend's-Chipmunk" �iephitis Thep Eutamias t6uinsendi% " rpwbxid e shre Vagrant shrew Sorex trowbrid ii Westerngray squirrel Sore.c.�aprans 4 Sc3.urus griseus , ' -TA S "Mha's Huhntrd Claypra anrta Ash-throated �'l datcl�er y rtyia>rcltus_ cirlert�sCens -� tabs-tailed pigeon Cdlumbh fasciatd _ BeWidks wren ---� mlir `o manes Mdek troated ra ► 1 1 j e g J w� y ends p�vfl-Creter Cil lifbrnia a�C4 aCCti- C tt,ia tain3.iax 5 .jai A 7 Gottia Caliqaal .helC .Coerttl l�cl ns Y.ophnritai 3 Grunions Cedar �a�:l�:i:ttg I�pmb�e� 11.a ccdrr�rr►m �'' ctlippin� sp�r�oto S �x'r,ella dr z � �Jhll.ota �?et�a�lt�3dan Coonon bushl;it ,i;�l7onota Psh1t>xi�iaYu;, riiihttniia C%l►bzte� foam Ph�Pnr�di�,p Oehetnf APpMbik ,L ..................ia��i 1 lid LT: i r Coo ert EtctU:lt 1� 13utco 7atnadct=nsis Dttn;riy wa�;)�!pe:ckcr Den7 capos pt bescc:ns ,. iib?: Sparrow P<. s�erc r1 C Gs„clt4:?'n--crcic�Yed kS'ngl.et uLu � satxa�a Go"..rl t�� crot>ned ` sparroca 7onotrlchia l et%coplt�'r lic"t it thrash lt}lc�c�cltla �;at`Gat.a Ito Luft ta�.n chickadee ' 1?artt�, ;atabe. i ttotci;;tiu dove Zena.idura inacrouta. Orat+t;s-crotmed wa`rbl.er yarmiuor colata c Orogoti juno Junco oza ,anm __ Pla,Lj,, 'ta.t:nottse Parus itiornatutt, P ,ij+ nutha y;ytch- S�tL'd rmaea' ftbrcastecl nuthatch S f Gt a canaden3 s KetT--taijed hawk L Bu4ea 'cttna:0cqtlsl 1 Rc:i-tr ngcd blackbird Ake, �h�eniceus 'i'uz;�lus lZobn m�rator3.us Tiouh--ta�.tgecl sra]1bti�i Skel�optery� rutit;ollis Fttitiy cxocmed kingletltl Repu� cal endo is it nous hummin b3xi� Sala hp otos xtifus Soni Sparro�i MetLlc2iza melod3.a 5tai?lnS St:urnus vulgai�:�s Stellex s aay Gy anoUtta stel.l.erl „ Itirkey vulbAr CaGliartGS aura 'Var,'ed tl'rush ' xxo>•Pus-.naeyi�ts s �ert;t�.ilion 1*l,j�caEcher i�ti�t oc� " hwlus rti nus. .�_.�..� Vitileti�l;reert swallow TaohycYneta thalassina, taesteret bluebifd Sx u;1 a "ttta�:icantta 1Jaatetn tanager PIr<ttiaa ludouiciana tah"itbi-easted muthatCh Sitt;a Ca3ol inen Whl to-t;rowed oArtbW to otrich� a leuco�5hrys 11hi to =headed zaaoclj eCl.ar - Uuxtd'voctatro�; "albolarvat:u_s. Yal'loty-b�:L13.a°� ' sap5`uc�:er Sl3ltyra�ousy�riust, AMP l!B!a9' ,Nb RMil. IyE Cotnmoti Maine Sad ant:tt3 0 latri Ahh�.�ato� 'll.z�rd Cerri�ranatus ,.00eru�etts T,vlitt tits ��] its - Vit'tttl U§ ctrl i �yznias . Oaixxorti i a kin sndlre iariclla torosa cal -Uornib n' Olt . Foothill yt.l 6-0-le��ed �ro� Flyl.a rt 1ill�t artei: srtetkr 1`ior:tt�t�tin g . `�,htlfitlyoplti� elo�att� � ' 1'�icl .ltl trtro roB llyyl l] Ci�lfttd'tia 15C1t +it�t batt P I'ac > l c >attiibcr boa Sad Sttnctttclors .�.w... -- t l;tlitaclon sit w Wastoy i pond talo C:L;c;ntntys' itto�.nto�.at.a . Ccttktrtt "tett tlu'srtetl�ozoFa 111CAt=a'w . wad uti o Utyrc 0 MIX 0 COii`CGy PLNT SPt0 s by THP', PARAbISE ;ARCA Cannon Dame Sciontik c Nama A�\i3UAT, GR.gSSES ' FaXtail fescue l� Q stuca n egalc(r; a R biome BraMus_i ruben,: Slender wild oats Averts barbata ' Spanish brame Bromus madritKt:►tsi( PERENNIAL: GRASSES ANb G12AS5=LIKE PLANTS l,entmon sopa StiP a lemmonl3,' Parish_whoat rass i . py P l neve Perennial blueg,ras �spec esar.f,a�h3 many stem sedgy y Carex multicnulis ANNUAL Po RBS , Common dwarf flax t� Pe8 eral .non taicranthum _ Lithe tartaeed � c,aiva _ rtadxi � i Slender annual fireweedEp3iiibium Small: flower lobus ;minutum Latiis micranthtis Yellow stax thistle Centau rba_. oistitial'is _ PRt�ENYNIAL FORKS: _ - Aster Aster species Biue flicks f wild hyatnth D�.clieldstenma p�lchellum _ BolRnder galium Calum bo%ander3 ilracket� Climbing fern igaliUtn Pteridium acltii lini(m pUbescens Coft ton woolly-suriflowet Calf um huttallii.. tent(e �) r" iph'yil.um lanatum Erand Eflorttm ;tritillary,; Fzitill.ar�a species Iris h.l.emath weed. iris mac"rcisiphon 'ltypericu(n �fa�ning glory Pectfdratum Galystegia t(ccidental�`s i 1'w*16 filil.l t4to ;Ascle ins Gordi�folia; 'ci%po t;, n, cle TAuschia ke Ll o Shasta Puccbon .� � UthoeUermum calllf Ili Sna1�i�131 �Dicholost:damayulubil e Sisl fiix pea, tathly us s iJ phu eus Spear-lead (nouiitaln dandel;Lcri'g8,LNi� etra> t ScSap plant �Chlorogalut�( o(tteridxgntiM tthite ],ot,�ei hal tweed �ti era ium alts l fJ;orum .�,Q513 .tta�;�-tu�.fP CalaGlla�.tl(� ([tCl(7,C1p11 1.].t(s r �Eltlfac�Odf ffbm the -Pb bdlt .� `fJfil�. iJ9b ,s ���roi AF'PSNpIY, odor 1 bf", TEt'S&S AriD SIIP.uss I; gl leaf map] e Acer tttacro hy�.�.un i p ----------------- bp ul- de zirclh jeafr'ounCa tr `1a11o;any �)c .bet _o Quercus doug]_=tsz T til e oak ane, retrer� b ' .. $Z�tiWr oakultat'uc1rL I (Zuercu5 l,e1J oi, t~e]� - Gal ifona a ialack, oak -w Ae'sculus ca13 f orxt i.ca . tornia 'tiiirkeye Ca lx, Utnla]l►�aria coli f ornie 't Ca] ifoxri;f a laurel; bay tree J o1 rej�a rpt] a o.r, a r�utme C1;tifo�cnx g Gc:rcis accidenta:li- Ga1,�foxn�.a scrub .oak - Galifoxnia. " d uerctts dumbst rr� ozliGtyon` cal:i ornicum- Ct►lifoxn averba sang Vthis calif'ornica call: f0tnia w` d 'grape tic�r'ctt3� 5 ctl YsoJ.eP3: ctrrysolcpis, Gatrjb live oak Adenrastom�t faSG1Ct� t] ?tttm fc13Ca culaL'utn �' G}iittilise Ceanothus ineerimtis Dea`ebtush Pinus sabiniatia' bigoar "iris PseurtdGsu�a meri„;ziest llottg as -f i Gs�'r�?4t frlemon it � �retrlbn:t sil:ktasscl popttltts fretnonti I+remortt Gottctnioc'oi1 la rax. inus d_��qta. vl6oth it Ash Ribes species 'I �' _ bbsnl errY . Cal6c6drils:.dacu,rrens' .y Y!] y �nCenJe--cedar ` Qita't'cus r�slizcnii ws].iz ; xrtter or live o k 'Geattiothus emmonii. 1 --emtnori ceanothus Co'tntts r►uC`tai ] i %'ttca f c datfabd" Cictllat �. ,. l 'ipc-stern ,c� emat "is 11n. iva Toxocctdendron tl'],vers.tlobutn - rod stirt� bak Pinti� �idYttle�roSa £i '�.ri e Poriclb � ,.. � , rli esGtrn . , tte'tC.Us raa.s].>�z�nix Shrtib iii Ora -(jt,, ><i tr �k Ithatrinits r ibr .rubra . SiOt cbt'f cebcrry ' i.nit " � ambe%tiana 1 Suga>" p'i`ne liu� e tomo s aibltt ifoiia o5�i�,t1; Chxistma ileve x {ieatroLhua.Gtinc tt.lis t�ectel eaf ;Geanti hus� hotld��r'Iclx`an' ot3,derit;;t] e: � 11t st.drt� Etta .Or p] at�tinits_ Aa�cm�isa t�Haterri scatnortr Antis rhbritbifo]�ia t+ 73tt- tvldet A c�" b tea irk ida C�ititz eaf�' menti eta' Sa] i eb ' tI � ocS T�ei��fcha.n�,ti�, d �tim� ' 1 to iircaal ao3„L 4�1,tnipi7tt�ry Cr].tfnri°t,ttt fw;ari;tn:nt of T'oiesLz`}���J�; ' Iji AP��NDi7� tit Pop e 2 0 l' a j - -z^ r t .,i ct. t�laj i ndopendant Spec r,a t IS�i str' cls i n p"�srt `cu 14 r, d t str 0% of' their raV�il�td from the hhrr�ic�hou'h Cat i tornia,; lost more than 16 1.t o;f, the passacge� of Pr-opas l �. ha r'�s ;propertyresu of c"30 'i 0 90n of 'Cola I revenue : /4t' 't tie srrtnv t`i me: ,fhe two-'Fh i res i.:r , f B a phcnorn0h 1 t, 4. ; e: e population lot i on has 1 ncreaso, llppo;r Ridg P P the Recreu�`ic�ri Pisfr�ict is unabla i 'r stressing i s thG The po i n t�7 r.eet capi'hat impravemont goals., thc�cuRe rericlge r'r�a0 01 rrCOneoway PIS t tial have any land or foci i i� i e r n to CaflliYi t1rJ 'i"'qa or mors to achirVs sane of the r3eeded facilities1,01 rit nS vide a, qr-ezr, ar pubi is agencies .a;nd olhor`communi't orrdot larsgarid, Oroo save '1-h, a Faxp y pcla.ers a reetnen t can level of s@rvice. A good example of this joint t:ff� rt are -the Tha Ochoa t prow i deo ur;- t i y:h;fed 'i IQ s courts a tha ht gh s"choo t ., iaVe to be, urchased sepa r�'r�f 4i (y by` fiho tti�3 _land;, wh ch d i d not P Rocreation Distrl`ct. Recreation District obtained a grant' to construc'h the coatis'. The h School studen''ts anti the ga'nerat Wig r_ ?'hey are shooed by both Para of the school tn'the tinea Ubviausly then public. The construction tri t 1 benefit. the recCeattonal roods of a large nutnbor of rostdents the upper .ridge area p,�VQioped pCay arQas``l�ri I ( cjt tow fa.mi l t':e5 and fri©nds to enjoy aufi-- door acts v i `i'i es loge-.; her: `fh�i. construct i on' of meet t ng rot°s �v i t Ca r otigofwna�roargan t za tit ons. form serve de c t ubs) encouc age an foetal" drone, arts acid crafts, sports, anii p!`ay9 rour7d Prrghams such a5 per activities carr b,e conducted for 'hhe I_tbe ehP Rterideddand Seri,iar, adult and adUlt programs and Jc�viccs canc compl trnented: kes'ihet i cs ti "o bu t I t homes .neix e$thbtic5 for whom? A feW nearby resrdenis h Zl3ureau of Land hlar►age�- to he Bur'eu of, land Management praprty2 i t very c Isar ''l tial tda j acre p'arce l rtier i , by th'e Way, ma'.de to u, l d hava 'been `traded o,r tot d a"t a flture f eo d A Wd I t �}� l annad r we I -des f griad "pub t i c fac i! j'fi I nnrhtad` cYon ! raven o20O has by,,'a Il resldonts? The School di trlct p the `i-iree :s►d.0et wit'time`Eer na`tura.l bGf`fo.r Rorie arou''nd 1 ihe, end cons i"ruc t" b i d l,#9 ;5 th arelcompa'htbte thl,s fact t i'ty wt t I ijo propar'i'y he ria 'ural sits: Cerwta161y' `iht, aesthe> ice of` the ty: p 1 easatt for the st.ildents, facu ty; end acommuri Ofher' POOSihlb SitoS. . �,, was aVai lab'le. rc�.��� itrtow t edge nt tf"oas 1 b 10' s i i'c r t or auiw., i a`I'c tho oppnrtuh `r "i y `i•o wcspt nd j`io Your request fo,r input ' I .a . pp" r•tic oi'i pf 0 t rOnritcn'i'a l i mpoc i F�cpc�r` i t0 sincercl�y,� ,/o 3 r CCr Kitsrie t{vonLes t�hr:;t�ii st T� rtwyid r;hta`ri Apr=rJiirit .y PERSONS AND' AGENCIES CONSULTED BUT NOT REF'FRENG,BD TN TEXT . Jim Carpenter, Manager, Paradise Pines Property Own6r8 ASsoc;lation, ' Sti art Edell, Assistant )3 n gi rl eer ButteL CountyPuk 3 c: Wog};; Depar-bmernt. ,7im Glander Chief inspector, Building Section; Birt o County public"`Wotks Department. Gary Lippincott.,' Partner; t�ippiricot/Guth, StjrvEyors and Engineers, Paradise. Abo: Memeo; Principal;; Poridero'sa Elementary School., 1 Paradise., Sch,.. , Icon midt : F�,nanceOfficer, PAtAdise Unif'ed'School District:' Lyin VanHart, birector, Butte County Environmental fIealth Depar�mecit. r i d Ap��Nblk '� h"04TTNG)'1"C;a ' X* I *)R, r'l'l t Y V]:k_'W W.I l:it C1 a i i a4tta�»���;iYt� E a'1.i1f � i7 cC �i4' r'it�� rj� � � `� I-1 r Ch L to 1,s I� ► i t.► ,1 �:.' �:!'l; a3 r t;i1 f. � t» !LY 1, -1 � �t'/ �3:.� . flrltailrii�ti t"II4(}.:llt`ai't,:ical'I i=ar} C0T`.L:i.i, i3 �aL�tf�Mt?i"��: cif E�tiMa'G�r� 0a s taLo, 4. e+- tasG.' �'r`taelt.t} �1�_il� �>�, 198a (ar± th fiILis rJf',' 1,hG•; Ci�r�•i��;rr'I�a 8t,a;ti4 :Fl1:�r.3tt�;t;atirf c;aar�j),, Yitt'4iiti)C IM :tt?f` fir•r,M ir` L ♦-atcal"eph &0 E R R Hr't=tlite—ot'sp I�in} SUpte'Olber: to 19 Q' �,, M.,,'xc�s; r •l,:rl t � r� �: �. t5 t: � L i to 1'I . E• to t3 r +:i.,. 1 to t:, ,. - t_ a -'t ,. ' **6ktK Iwc'3isoctyh] ' 1 I li:f�r V 0, W } lot:.' ♦ ;t; 'l, i i- atbi_ h xxo't'tt�r , rtit» IchfrYr4 iI Cyr; Larsd H6rr�tc:#c mc..%rit� 'Or 8 -rt Envf.rOri 6t•31 p�. r �5sIm0 tt r�Clr� Lr►I"tri t1lac�1MrI'� �tx�;ct`rf�3°Lvta ctfi aU Acre F'iairCcl Lc t-, Ire Pat!c�L5G�'aclltaa} tJ� kt I'Ll 9 xt t7 ,ti d:4 } 6 7,# �GWI"I GI'�. I"`�Y`:id►.i.l.�:iti.- G7 r`-c3'�"'% C� .. :� ,��,e } t"'2zi } !„f G.1 6`4 I” I rl I T x I'rjep t;s�;taM r�L I�tpd o itis Ci'g�; ljnO T`{I 1,0v h GtMf� ;-T,t rid; !•!ar+3t,rt f, 0 tv ti'tes I"' trrad;is o.ai; .a� ,L r",Ij LjI �.r f`tarl.a't�1 Laic r;,y . % kt T.t'_�:ft l�ItIt{It± ;I.l'`Iljt!t`Ua( lf' r:i.th ;1aM 51"1t:tWC3t,�rf0 I~ t OaM- bo(:i6rf:,ttGnt f b:i.ty;ItjtI'�'al;} It9I ,a`!',af„lit,t:.+} up + :t«`i`l;STj.io ettarIo iI'7'li:?rviCAw W� ti.t:r`'�f`'idll:L��t��; �� Y`� I''TS��{;t�'ti o , Y � '� tw •lid. to 1'•f I� �. �,'l: i' �.`(, t 0- LA ly i't o,I"I o v SJ w ,l. 'li h "G r` t r1 V i Tb i") o t► t 61 6, i''I a .19, l� W i, it-, � °lAi L I�. f.t `l; `I� r~� 1 �i 1"r {� �% J F' l d I` I) I :i. �'{ t„t I.) t:?'I,t t r 't,° t � I'i'l� f �. � 31► ; APP NDIX ► -� ' I F�gt'eement ��0tw, a WW, ;?i� !"Acar I'l'; to F'lT>.CJV�rS' '(;eT` a'�i�T`V:i.»e"> eri ' L �-� ' • a baSLT xc1, T� Larw' F' a 1r a ri r. � e t:1 vol �. i' �. c.. (�i 8'(. h C� a x _ x r� G i a•»� � �:nt� � nri Rol 0,V 0' �!aLOP G�a�►F>�;i-� t9 acra't.s��rM���r 21> 19:71- >9 2a:►;k Tt-+-. u 3,hLc.rvxcaw . WI tP Jai±' F'ri'I,., qtl Oret �lat�r CaMl�aro�, Xi 2`JkK* To 3,elpht]no, ir''Lev,viow with hobor't S• Fortinot V'J'.co F`rSidE'r1t Del L7rcj Wator comjaSh9 2130/a;L ' air . aii. 1 2c5hits air, ChacI�.e E_;UtL Gcf8r�17izn.get'ti , Ihi1:i .7ti;►tlr 'ar (ih F'aT`aria.�: h"ii"tE�a CI Pt t Lara SO anx, EF�D LttiG3 .hibaa '04-� i-0It W;1 ` �1 `"SJ`I`► M r1 : s a t o G,' h o ri t i't o r d •l 6 f Y` it M V ' T` re Ott a r„i (? C'� tf (' E: �1't'l. G fa �_� rl �. ; i�a7.1:'r/13�... e �Wy 7 '('vom Lot Jbli t011 t V �r� �-Ci't irrfai-�, F'aracii�� eci� tiara arir3 F'a1'�3ri��QA,i0a� `I't r'6'bego b r '21, :081« •, '2�3 ,h >` C�Li~f> tJN e i'�.;l�e � 10 0 �.1 • ` 2 9*.9 TwiXr.Ij, I7utit,+ i;i"il.t,YrVxLAW ,Wa,o i~vii> Sup or+en•torideht, `FIJSb, Cyei'' TYiudy et o to l * t Pis 'anis'Ot Cal ifo1`h3-a ' i�tfut�Ml�.t'T' 1I i.9o1 0 ,. :. � � N'3 i � r: "� ` ! � sY` : t:1C` e is z `li e stloW felt Inte view I i r - t t - Yr. 1e cox ro `er, Y: L�:poSuxc �o neop ri p _ - q ha ds sucI a5 e.a�. t. h uwakes , ' .eolo�� c zax '1r:Yn�slicl�s Inudsl"��as, �,rC)ut�ici � 7il.tirc , , ox s' m'i1a. haa�-s? i1,l], tlYe T;q �os,a� resin L in: Air r 17 a. Stibsitant al ci�t~e i r� °� i:ie��i of >,1 alit ambi,'nit oi: 1 nrtal air elu y w b. :The creation. of obicet'onable i = odo: S , stilol e ox fumes? Lw , Sign if ican-t alteration oair, movenent;-' moa stnzra oenperaure? clian9e in'cJ.ima �. or. any iorYal:.w*' OX r Locally, " 3. j7atex. iJi11 tt e ;�ropo � xesu.�.t in subs anti^a.1�: a. Chanes �y qua xents, of the; coijrS4 �s? -- or dixe:et"iori a Oaten moiemc-1 dr a b, Cha e� Yt hse� lation rai✓ea, i ; the atc� and iilc urit .of pa GY'I1's , nr surfacel t e r XU,ti0 . c, Need! off site s"ur ac drainage vegetatibft irYcli!�1 .nd a.mpxovement 0 - c�taY�In� � "�.���`c ��:on �� c ulveL t,..,.,, J' ":. tallait'-on? —0. ..: r.l'�`»C at1 (�1LS t:0 the c•G7u1`$C' . Z3�; : '7 w - Monad v teYfir, Chan ;e trl�e atrooftt^ o tgatet 7<n way �7' 7` body i '. Y�ischar e, 1CY tQ SLYi f:c Ce Waters , or iii. an ' a�. �'ra.tio 0'� s it'Utc, tJa arualy y, ripjudw�ng butt- not temporatlira, d.i 8'ol-ve limited o :y en,!o� UY by laky s -----• Alt'e r a it �_ CJ nj o the {l J. r e tr i l7 n1 -t� X. Y t6 of, Xv e7� �y1 o11iYd t,tw' Xt1 Yhr Cyt. nn1t'Lty11 Cyr Cltnr'r. a»1:, *Meir ,. i t. I s %h ough ", �'tkG7�in4�. a.:a�� :, ��. 11t�-at'�ya direct �ndiilitiotll,s oti, tra� Cy'L'� L1YrCiLnt�l'� 'I.Y�t:4tiY"�CSI71*3_t7Y'Y C"?� a1� I'�r. •n for I)Nt iYEYt', a ur av 41 til,c tt w .: i l e 23 r i .Y YES MAYBE�Q mot Redi:ction in they � r�tr of �v,tt;er ' oti`lertrI so available E-or publ i C 4. water supplies, ? t j . Z.x;nosire of. neaple or pr.i�p:rty ' to viater rel ted h %'zb rdii, suc;i1if_s fl.00dinq?' 4-1 Plant ►,i e, 1,lillI the proposal a: esul t in ,s5stanti.al. ' a. Lass of vegetation, ar chanpe in the dvexsi tsT of s,pe,cis or number of aria species of PI -ft ud .ner trees; shrubs, grass, ,c,: ro.ps', m c- oflbra, and. ac�uatc :plants) ? _ ..._; ,. b• Reduction. of the numbers of any ung.,q. ue raror encian e� ed ,spec -es y+ry 1ryee o yt t c c . Ztttroduction of nPW spOcieS of plants into an arca, or in -a barriLr to the normal xeplena.sl ment of C. exist i ns specie ra�• - c . Xecluc tion 'n z-�creLav c o any ag r. i C`11li:LtYal C.rOrr? i S Anima. Life � tv"l1 the ' pry`}p'o 'lL t es�ilt ;LiA ubstan tic,I a, chal , 1p In t�l.e C11,VC'Y- t- t7� 8- 'es S r & . 'or numbers, a� an .s acxes.of p a'in�mals laliimal,s • incIua� r Yc tries, Exsh ani p f .slti, ben h OtP,all L81rIs; insect or ' �,• mlo-ro.Caunaj'? b. Redott'lOz'1, of the T11:lk,arS Of ung uriiqua, rare o' enC!c' n 0 HCl $PPC�e� 1 q T1J C a� 8 C+ xntra:cluctiOti o'� ri;C+l .�''c1t'S Of 'aft,ar �,maj:s t , o, Yo,stil r iti a 1 ar crrito tot t,yv ltl �r�C1 }4�L1 1 ran1.5 t .�nh"1 f2ll't,r ,gi6hmE.n I.i(7pn or deter7yaX:c`1tioll to $b i 11P of tra dl,a it li�a b ,u t ji APP't0l ��e Ar "1 :j ij , R 1 6 �lIi 11 ifil c ro posal rc Su.1t 7.�a _ s5$taThri4l.: +, nQreases Jr.noise `leVCII fff���JJiFFF b . t::; -pos=y e o eo' �1e to sever. a noise evelSa % . � htr and glare J`I all the, pro}'08A ',or r n1 odti,c s ;n r ,�� 1 igl I',l r e A y:� i 1�and t1se. 1x],11 thcyproosa� �'C sult. ' iT.Y A r a Alteration of the Planned lah use of' an area, or 'estAhliah a frond .G t.jj'l will demoagt ably lean to S L1 'Cl. ,cl,1 altetAtion? — ` ' 'res on aCia��217n b. Conf. c 3 u� J 7 GF X41., t h or eoyrrytµl tk pyrc}�pt, Irties,j l♦Y�igr� 4 i,� iia e lr 5.t r 4+1,� La.` LL U 1. L1 art 53. Lr 1 is w. . L- tiona t ?e uses of a� ural sou,tces_: t° 1II tie PtOPOSAI � PN + row jt ii subistan,tw al- or increa; in tl�e rate L�etiianr bu. '• , n t- , ' t cwabl.cU . pepiebion o� afy, n r� xr 17, Ali sk of 'llbset,' nogg the ProPova' T raas}\ o.- an, 7,QTI rte o ve a`e1.P� 0 } alaxd0 tlte, r G1o�.S e o,, �. lYlQltld� ! 1 }JU tlot', l iS1 t�G to jC51.� y nest "c de,s, dbelylio. Qr rate otriritt} T1 the event, Q,. at Deb ' s �w. 1yI yy�j� y ! yr- j� C�ilf h.e s rel �c tip 1. 1 Lt ar t:ltr� ir�cLrf t' 00 L L d C}1�71 :a �..', , tiro e t;;�'ho f� t t� tt'.1 opu 31: stn tist:abi.-1h0d :O)'IhUMI'`11,t. "` a Will the op 0sa:t, Gw;s�71t11, ;yi`1.�.x,?x��f;ttt.���°�i-C? c lat o A i1et.1ktl�tl fain �"ce} i'iLir�Yt��tla "Y �i:� Y { `i x YE8, NO Tra tts rataarculati Willi�h.tt uon/C Proposal re$ _ a r �x�neratiotl O ull " bb N r t' al tadctiriox,a7. veh ctzlar iovemrt�? ' r b. Si:iicant e�fcts �. oil, e ,i parlcingao'a.1ities, or dL'lltand Lor new paxl,Zn�s? r c. Substantial inpact.unorl e ist� nes; trciIlSDOrt ci -- on s sCeG? y n cI. Si9nificant a'i terations to present patYrnf..a;irouatiat� car movmert`t of neotile ancl',%or moods? e..lteratians to ;�ra`terbnrne raid. r�r" azr >;ra it? rncreasc in trah�twarcls to mc�i ox vehicles; bacyclist4 or pe:dcsst iatts? public Soxv.ic.es, jail the, P ro pasa�. ha�re � at1 e,,:ect~ upon, o result in a subGtant; Ajl needr; ��onest or lter-ld s;d'trernment~al services in any �f the01 �ri'rrt areas a, I ire Prot eationl ,,a - b.'olice prntcction`?' e• Y, C, Jhhool S.? L»ate d.'arl�s o� other recrea ton, sintenapte o nuhlc :aclitaic;s; utla.18 rci� tnc�r''ot:cxnm;nLa svtco? i �K a, ase a sitb:� tan a al fic3t nts d Lt, off: en�r� �e b , 811 18 1,a3tt 5 ct1 n eas l tl clemir"id 11poTi existi-ng 8,ourr. es of6 1 L ° tor .:. _.',. Lti7;G"y, thk-' tt�w��.G7�'?fhi`!t14 Cid• C`1G'y? � j 'sourebs y Y I ism.► l:a Ut.il r:Lr, i7i7 1 tie c�rn�as�t resu� t MAYBE - " 7 ris� C'x4tt1-07is, to t:T]e fola.ot7�174T. � tltllit1 e s�. I Communications s s t ? (({{ ' A, ci W. a t �i, fe �y'y � Z. SII• SLtve (t>3.1 i �:ur51� � ill be ��tc-n(jed y Prov riinb caPtIgLt ' to serve ric r devolopment)'Y' e. Storm water dr;aitta;a? tica�.th: uOL result aii r a • Czcat ,on of any or ?�otent<ia1, health. �h���a'id mc'nt:a health)-? (et��.url;n I� . ��' nsure ,.• O' pang le 'ta , at»cnt��.a�. health xds. — 13, olid .juste. 'the �n dnY s p P y ;rt5, (.`rtnt: -- 1mTJ�t,Ct s s9Cla(2Cl �C) tea tlt sod id t'ra, t� dis�a � - tai l�tc> '- cantz ole �est�liet;i.c: CEJ tate nap5n,s4�1?es>lt a f ruc t:i:ct n.� des i l;riated' ar �ec�o 7 Y . any pllti 1-id tan�zed scena,c `�x.st�. • aperi t:a the public dr iI1 theprapasaj. It~he '' result. ani r<):e:at crt ae's'thet ica 1y o. ensive 'c5 an s td pi17.�c,'vi.et7 lien ta. C til t� 0i ro b s "1 n an II,npafst upon he quit it,y o qup-tit y o cY stitip Pub:!is cirrea ti zi -f -1,linties �• r• a' ,I21 Arh�1a ries,%Fly t tater 1, t•i� �. trhe rioos eta ; w " - Yy t ill an ::1 ]. 1:ex tw i r,�ti b 0 10 a,0,�.ri 1 .gra Y 1i.1 st�ta7r i,45� si.e s ti}ufi�ui-c i+ M" Y .� i~iAxtr 22. 'i�c111 atb1:- Fired n�'s�iCr3tic, Gn' a Poe; th e prby�0Ct 1_ a e t:he pot '11ft, b-5 ciepxade Ithe CfLlalLty' ofi trite environment, suns tan tiall i' educe Y the habitat of a fis. h or wa. species, cause a I18h, or « .1clJ.i f e pbpLtlatibn to, C a~0p below self sustaining levels, tl'1r;eaton to eliminate a p iatit or:, c11i<.mcll, Communit. ber dr rosta� i et th6 rattpeect oica rareorencs rig ererl pl,ant;. ox. animal or_' elim-inate iriportant examples 0fthe major periods of C�aliforn2.a his'tor - � br p,.et°tistoty _ b.: Jbes the Pro,j ect have the pbtential i tarta ve sbbtt to benef-its to the debziment of piblicly adopted l'bny-termen.virontaenta �oal8;7 irk w C f noes the project have imi7aCtS c,��11 Cly Are. individually lihiit:od., but ativc� consiceralc7 Ca projeoty may impact on ttqo or more' soliarate tesourtes zrhere the impAct on each = resou>`ce i:s xclati.vel ;smal'1 , but e�hero, the. 'ei:toot of the total of those impacts on tho env;iro,nmeat is sI;ttifllcatit, f d e hoes the, prol ect havb otiviroiimerita"I effects vr;qicl� Will cause subst<am la% adverse, elpects oh hurrt,ti be�n�;s; e thea firectl or. jnrl�. `eci lyy! f r M Af'p�wbt�t V ._ age l 1 t 5 ,, ,*�' "r r s t>_ .; A S f s s ' q , :.. i i Ir•+ • t F ,.,r r 7 ,r,r.� rY�rt a 1:R`K«A It . 'r v,i ° i#':. fid, "(\� S i +�`4,«� a , ��'• 1 +^ Yn, a'>;+�t 'L /r ^� a «t f i1 Y4 �1 r I\ f. r* f'�+-t"«�y'�' ' E`I �+ ,I "rr�.x,« t 4 ,� la f•- l� + v - d r t + z� ,i'{� f p fi ,/flr ( #. ` � 5 1 "'t /fjfyl t �,��✓° t i i Y i a v. rYia ;'] t' tS- t (a I 1+Ida�x� vJ't �r �' ';• J Z; f'r ♦♦ I' Sv "tr,.r" + s # .L + e .�' r `• d %.. lr1nr ..rt r lea '�:.tw -t !r r r f°: '" l '„l. ex #!.r..tli l " f j > �« I `1 Ir 4 f r 9 t rt r<'\�qt'> s rdy�i'!,,' � + ranee-r�4, 1 r �t{ i r k k� � k#` c' >7 tom`+'' �"•.t #+ v 9 i L L f t #, ti r'+ w� l �. { T r „ i r 7! ) i±�•. r _)% ,..� .. "h,. �s, ti i k „! i�+✓ ;`�,1q+� " ( :U y ,V, )1��;. ! e �.. T i � i � Y { 5fi+ t �tlllllu l:f M'lr"51�5.a<,.✓. ��'4.i i'-1 � ��rr ix" 1 a'y��"# Es �, �,.',.," �tl«�� " t« ### i w '�w kflkk r`F yw .'J i rr. r t r �• 5 "� ° '� + +',w • s y1 :1 i '` -S k ,% #,�."5 kl 1= .""�r r ,.r ; + (' , «+ . as t ' .�+:+` ,� w,.� I[ t '4,4 a„•�°u 1,,,! 1"': � v 5 u�'r a Y'• � f s s""f . i,+' n � P \' "// h� f:"• � /�'� , i ,7 •, fY.4 � +� �' "'+ £M~`�F�"sq., (� i PEfllk f r .)'r:' �� r' / ,a t:;( w ya , k / ✓*, yt 5,.,.% girl { „hr..L+;1t r '1±�1, ti.L 1`�r �y '� (rL �,rA;,Si+b"„"??��° ,,y .. rtA ',StV, +•2r {lt. P;..: �lrr J + •'1X.�rfi tfr'Y i.17� -wl( f �Jy r ...,.�..r,yl' u• 'jttrn �� },+/ti` is • � r; i j tti r ” r,w„ r � t yv�•.� `•. ` ) Y TUptllyl4fMi�� r� 7 L �•`ra� r: 4 �'". q 1 r1 + A r. •w' ir' t' «•..�.s, r ✓,� antis 1. 1 , + ►► r» phi !yY°� }A y r r "+ "r+Y�� a l - r v % '.? :w t a ; f . ( Ny 1• by ' 1 5 a- % w5; l l e r 1 .aJrt�� ! +yr j' r } r. { �w-:n .; it ,+ - > J �f '�"►__'•"! ;r .,,�I:�' %ix� �,' fj +,.;��.,{jrl � . "-•J; V r �•,'„j�r.• •. f ..w' L`•t�-L�ihi��.>. a�`a,.. . _•` n x(, 1. a ° `` •) f '° }"ni es llll 3an41r'' 't' [`{, .lg r✓af ',(+ cervi, i'4��jj r f +y'i4 r 9 S�r`��j ) wM :oa•. �a "ttyr ,� + 7r��+t�. sky '( i f1"r'•Jl��r}}'*y`t✓. ° LM�,i`,r°`L F#a4�y"�µ, X e ✓ � f, .FIt +:+ � � C'�p � , '., + !/ ✓ •i't�a + � y k+x ^ QANIy t�+',, rJ�� � � r,+ {.l ' e ,,r" �• `���' `�,'�+r,� L� � �t�'S\��� n�iu� f' ` � o Iti'f'r n,R•^ ��'� 444 ^ r� { {'' # + # '. i^. 5r %'•� �, Lull E, ! rl , 4 � Vl r t 'LI � ! tp ,,.1 � L•.h. N 'C r sr 1,((S1 1. t✓ ts+ (,iEre ' .w.«, t •» v ; ) �' .,: w rw' �� •a' '�', aft �r, f L?�1,fi-1 7� 11"i d'f' f4 :I 3t kr 4 . y151 t ! ti�f t ✓ t. t� J r ! + G ;, V^ir r t+u Cba: "h+S ( ,�� ✓' . !r s xr,.° h ' .w`+, i �, k +l ,� �.. , I �..r,» • f' t . ,r \ti j `» r",. ♦ #!t\ i.t {^a_ ri •; [Y Mttr• p t f:..,{°� Yi Y, t �"`•"'4+, z P "#1 1 E �'' ° ` �E i E •< ?a rF�� �✓ � filo 44, � v. t' °� 'a L t}' L rr ' ��i4n•�wr ;-'' +` r i I� y' T i't ' ! - .�� i i +t v• !'! t .. . t -, k � P g, c l' tia r'�>-�1 t}J i. rD # ,{7Y-%��.1Y ."1! °) �``r�' w *,.. i ��1 X'•�; L� 4 ` �' �:• �* , . + ti �-y 4�ly''r•1 +�� x w >'� Lai: a �f+.:,J',..a ��l�r,�•. .�.: rtV+ %f �+`'r s r .f"�r� r� 1 T�� '����.4 n� 1 1:Ti « � _'. �L ``� �!�� t• i ° � #• F ++Y.r-« .\ st r. {,� � "fit .x�rr .�w xf^i�:� ` �'-y� ".,.w ( t �,..Yt •. ,,5, _ l It f�.:+"i �,«o '.:" \4l 't `+ � k,�i 7 � �k' "i�+t'�:�1 i;.;�.r + � r'Rl 1 •i`�� ! {-K,,{�.� , C`{:.\L li, °`{�j� r..:�a �4 �"'"♦ !' 1 "'*(r..t. �y1�L4Tils y�'qy y,.t. ,t. i« �.+ F/'�_ t� rim Vii, •'�- �k� 1 i U111h'�; L,., r�xy JJJ , {{ r � a ^` 1 ✓r}^;r rL' ,t 4l «! 1 + ir% � r^`rX h. �"''-a .r�{ ',: } )jj A f l r, y� { y k .✓ f �'�, r .:,1. ; : » 1 1 $!►+rem f N•tt'+,. y i `�...�J1/�''•'�, ri� #lyl fAr �° A•%#* �•Tf �,l '.tet#�'. .-. :• .n� Y'rl 9� f i' etv'L� ••.: ti K # 41•�i Lw'�•' ' „ .. .11aCrfilh.'711 tp+, , �:+M , ,+ � .✓^ : ! .,+r .. t"` r. 1 J - p ,{'.i . � t, •(.k '- e t -dC� FI n�, ( t � s. r� �t "�' ) 'pl�cur4� 'i . ,..;r > , •. Is�t rr,1,4 y � f 1 1 «:. •t � '�.r�k,+„t•u L { � � +j {l � ±F' P, i ✓ .�^'l' npr / r/,�«yy� �".� ( ft�� t # d .. � 1��`�yrrlf � r �, �i4j5� •'"r. �* +.! l #f".: i�X'=^��'7 �' +� . L �� ry�+A �R:^^ �+�Y. ( } / Y� >„yi. a •• Y � 1 ;f+5+ � y,p 5411• X ritL''''�ra� f fa:l � f* «. #C � ,y�. „� �» +Vt* I �/ ! , J ri c � 'Y �t, 44u E - 'S.0 v�. ) i } � t ♦ Vie. Ire r ,+ d 1. 1 Y N I^'yx + dal' '.'. ;.•J +�a « r .',aft ,.. .f r ^t, e{ e'j1'ElllCsif L,�: .ti x '� alfa M. p Ir I�• ib� ti' ,a+ w i } .r1, r .- r � L • rt a r�� r % t4•� .1♦ r � ��.. .+ lrt).X fig53 �I •+�1 u. + ` w k+ 1« �11,w* N' A � �„ �' � # � 'l�. f � v#.� i r ' r > + a G �'' � ! �t t #r_..r�,_ .-�, ! f vy�14^'"'"r• f fafl�y , x ."^ ' "i L�' f t 'k".�' �• ' a � ��t i' � •" f > � L '� • ! r f `a�11p r y�rf � y «+. �� f •�„ �", � r��1.r^J''iy,x (r � r:M 5 f � 1 "+ * ,.� � '1' y� � i. � ++ �"�x+�. j L'•,.,•.l "�r Y' i 'S (+�� `��. • x� 1 i�...a ss , 1� a �,5 1l f5 C„'`x'1a" It'xf ';.-ti + � �-v`: ppl! f .�+ +. �.rk+`Y x•r,yri "; �r%y1.. ity,l X -f 4}�;l � a..'r r�i� � .4.. �s�,�~ � # ly '� b ! # 6 iM '., � � �+ �I"v� % ,�i,w- u�„w. �• 4 X 1„ J�4 4 °..VY�. + ��. 'Y C 1�G' t�: '..�i Y` f. t" a, u •f Z. � Si y« t kT � e i "�4"x r v r, ay�"` � �• � r i 7x # �. " ,r ' .* �' 4,i.#. �� t-+. a � �; �l. , �� , y � .r.� Ji•+ 'r�j z✓ t � ♦II /f to #i"^,,•j ,l ry ' r A f-+'••✓ } f - r �l i "�'k. ✓ .. �"•1 I ro f +... °rst° �. x A'?. +r r• ti � t ;4 1r � �.z ! r � t",' rs:• r ry t l •: Z l � •x _.au;+,"" { Y° y � �r` f ; ° ` rr r r f ;f f• x x'l . "� - f "" v. i ! L Y 4-k ..cF'4 � r,�. � i ?4 " � �� 1+ � fl �f ,.•" L p .t" ..f z r i r 7 ,'. ,*a+' - �r• i� 4 , a,. � skx+�•:+ra ^r•{.. '« w ,✓ '� �' � -- � tr�'W" i"`t f{:r { ;�r' ' 'Y, a It, {:�Irw° 4:���•`'`�af ��r,� ?ai7 �r �'«... � � �, �xty 4 J + it '' Ft�+y 1` ; 7 f •'i, + �� 1 5�+. 4"i Y � # '' ` �'' M r' � '' ,� �4.ilY' y,m r!. ff r X v 1,p �•\ i�1,�ti " y 5 ♦ raE L 1 u I /.. ".�i,jyP ' *� r �. �y +,.i li �. ry`�';� . � � t.., r, 'I ; � ♦�. r° ,'� 'Y« ' .. 1 r f } /r%,.� r xr�,�����j+���r G�4f 1�a f5 `+. ar :7 r r' Ji,-�; tf � r�vY iJ"f sa SI'l� ti # Y,.yV-*t1 � � ♦.� Y a i a SSI v r�',��+ "' +� ��r�11 .� fW+ 1� r`� 17� r JG. f5a �ia G • �L! f� �" f "7f� (��� �1 t1 f� ! �,i♦ 9 �r. 'f«��� �'° P.� �-..:v �� .c-aL' ('r Zu4d + �. r+ s" 1, 1�'t r L,�� y ,f .� '4, a•..• �„ �. )t ur r :1 P �. , 1 F« jj iJ+�A! X°�I,f'u-♦ p�,:;�i f,vorf" iM"� y,,.Y+t,. 1✓ s •.. ,a '4�'yn"�*w•. lui,i + #h a +»:"+i: ""�. ^ >j • f �'.. ��•c r ��fd 'iii, 9 f,b JFr+. #F`� j4Ti .ryd Il f ! `��, f• �)' ^"L' "'.i�il ,rr«. s #� Ja t P 1 ,I,' _''r %� ffy ✓1 • .i;ln""' 1 1� f` ✓ fX K` r a «, J P ✓`. i Y' ti f {� #+ « �''."'lr r,. II :: • -.xr� , .°,.. «a i � �nl.ar� ra r � y i � a M r,t „.0 „Jv4 t',y F ti >i y}� �,� e ; � 7F.'�l �«'. f `� ' t• � tr#f'''� �� � r � . # t w �r d«�.F f 1�, .! .'T 7✓.- ^ , pp w p tLv r ! " f ♦ !'�+. w, _ n f +' 'k ,y I. Y'.� y� {. �+ y 1 `. .i r r .� t 7a \�,�aL L"l'`� n�J � � r C #r,. w7 *hry r u �F p 5,ra r 1 m" . r 1 e a ��Qt/�-! t• a t �•�' +� is f�*�''ri", # r y � �Yr : i�..rt.•vti .,iii• ✓ 5, y.t i�.u1�'�OJr. l 1 r.. �� r «� 's�w�f �+��'r +�:� ,q �,:�� ; a,4 f�ltX� # �f r `,"(w lebd "y i , '�k`rf'q t',:! nY ' .J„t 1 kii.,�.+' t� I •.'t.. It.S a'r. b `►� (� r �f �'",� ��• �r � �s. �q/ar e �f �L ,/ ''"''� >� � v � `7.''•'� t ` ++, '+1 1 i Y� 1i f i r r,.•+«y. 1j t r i +"'. -"moi " t' ” �# I , si � + Ilr, �� sr# "„ r � !rV » , w. a # i,+� d� � • w y, —'�` L �. -+ r=+^"ss��. u..r i,+ ...IL � a.0 -r/r .Y t, F" ,JWy � •r„#Rr .+.+s ��llr '� .(L' .fY �•.sn i i�4i `moi ;lrsr" , a l f � f � '��� x �f ��;(j-' "� ,.«:,� $5. +�4 •iC ... i. :v rl Ir «,�,^ 1i 1i i a�lir{.,'."7 :5 f (, Yn�+� ft y tf Y«� > p- `y�4'r'1:N u i ,., �, �j i fr (t++'t±`�Ft; ��yJ�{�r+��y4 w''`���ryr��.. u� iex�y Y�Y1'«r +r+`i; t'' #+L�w Q,�`•r''� ✓'� aY,Y. #j��l It "�j � err tt ;.� 1`'�j �Y.yit '•.rrl''4„f x�+�1.�sX �Y•t }�s: �'St 'r45r 1«�1 `` f 1+ ✓' ft�.��'F�' yl t t 4zlrt�'f ` ,p` . r�'' ..f ,•) `!'4j I° a.�tra 1!. ; � �p,-0 r".P' .N i + Yl l •x "+I k'°�Ilj i + /, ,� �' i .w:�V%j•a' ii. ,:T l� ) y' jw ✓ .1 # ,;vrr A ! r r {;" ✓ #'k!.» ' :'. M .• i M t '�i" 'i 1 '# a Y � 1 / i '1 1 sk r ry i, i i y`.'; ±.. a�{`+ +1,. ,�+r, re ( .f fJ r l-, V 1r -!x �v «it'�rn.iiD. yr< Yt =•"1 4"{ yc! /)A C ) ;+Ir .re i iI li /t{'n ry .,,. '%� 'rl i1 L�•, •!x .i1, s5tp r+ R - n,'�rr+""�"-." r€� R'I� r+r +'; `ytlt N+ruii ikl� 1 -. y; 4*+� n. r, n 1'�; r`°`�x tt I �.C�»..y.,rt ��} t5, t,. yra,.a'�a t+fi{i :�:� i�"a. io+1 ! jI iSy ,°\ ki. • tS .;� "P ;. f���; 7 r„s•.wwaf...� Y � ik'hC�7'1Ellr J �r✓f' t �'' �'""'"''r try,., e;;hf'� � �� y r, 1' ` L'���a• - •�+ � , , r, � , ff +„ � �. r 5 � , .. � ,,. rr ,� � , li +'. ;• t r t+ Y '' } ,, yh, wy": r»'w h „ a. �: a'i '.. II..0\, t !t''� °� '.���. ? �„ f x Pi+1u •. •`,"1A14u°4a "... y. �',trP �, '..rrii :iL at) li w'. a j i�: Fr taa `v L # y, ".'• V rr .Ir xk •1 � i +.P ��..dX n+t%1"h( «fiE(�� 1. ' ". f r }f, tii-� yt. � t! � �+ , ,fir•. r#r `•, , P'.r � i! °`•+•r•+ �« fxi y, k fjr::. ! Ci 'I h+e �1.�� �w. \X i +, i• r� dni �i is /„ '�`• 1 ; r i i + r S✓ .rJ„ +., l t t y� 5 lq ,, 't." '� ''tt ,fsr�Ff i+1a`4i;r x# • f i.�`Ss( ii.3 t��. 'h4 " # ` '. n' :p • . .:' ]a ••.(/%"#V 'S 1 .. �+i S,P �/•�.' "Yy ��0 ^i 1 P Y' Ih�,r til rhv �'1r :"'jr ti k1Mx1y7 of ar ;w bt a 5i ++`r�t t •-.r.na�.ct �s+' ,Iia , Y.�� r>f,f . � x 4� + w r ., l � � a # = 5.'. t f) a F t i }•'nxt'n � { � , � ' c { . �f #a, t+ F ��• r • loll", �r:7J, M it,«•,. lY`:S i. rirr a i �`.f+ it Fir u h `t 0J5r! •',.xy f !'i :, �+1;,, � '' ^� �1 dz'k r x'+,12j%!'i :t a + utF iw\M a, 1..,*.. # `x+Mrdt .. ry �, .r �I,fi"'' t� �� . ,. 4i :Fir 14��.ytp.�•i �! f ^ It eaa ,f',yYf S b t # r .r i i f r,»� :Y rr r, . • r +i r {+, i t `+� itt�'{ L'7iT�P+ 7 M.,: Y r+ ;kl `r + • »C`�+ r. i+..% Ir✓ . #:a,{' t fl11 rrs�.':, iT� jL• a !� L�' a, alF C,a. a . r.. # ,# i' ..r.S + • in'i .r C,+• yft !�i a inf i+�w I�t.a. �!r i � . 't ' � :. •Y -..� � � ��, r 1..1.. .. # � >-, p, E 4, rf 1✓Y ^,•!Y ^ i i,rr�r . �h'k�21TCf1'y� tW'+i' '+i� snQ 1. 15 Sr#ii»,rl)1f� .a �dcs�"'9.i'e �.y il,�.L+4 �,i��»r i1 .L 1'i w,i *� �s rs+r,;.i f il'#1f '' ri r',=r f; � i"''v c�,Y" ! ,;.r'���G•r,,� r„i•"Yrfa a� -'ry r!}rtLa, �i. It P i'f.. Y. yrY, ° + _. 1,� � y r'y�ii C:'i�!5 �rd"2 a,. 'A u yrt« ,i'. t .., ,ter# �Y t + i � :.: E ry tf++�''.'',� i p,.t=r Y ,.X`^'�r� ,r+,r . �!r+tt tsi r xYi�'+�Y�sn ����,F av i'��P F.a i �X•,«�i� a t�, � .•:1 ,;� ��.ti 1`:_+1 :`� X "s a r„'J'r ) , �t � L...r. � ' '� i.tiuifat•t.aa rxL•rr.r #a � � ) t iy t ,' � + » .:. , �. i r �I »✓yF . f�' r t � %� � �y (� a . � f I K:, Gt r��.lo �,r .,ir��,F ,rbi «�` �' ;,�L�!r it j 1SH+iry�a,r`��wY� *” ��r x� t,�ti �„r#ls �j "a" L�: �•w,J ' ' �q`y, -q r "�a'k� , af, yy '+ .:� �'.t' r'�++ +C r ��wl; rr 4') t i+ si V .i_, f:+:'i�. i, / } .r+Lts. Y.. r 1 . { 1 4 r ( �•'�' �f lati` "+ T , '' y+ f � w y ��� ;+� r �,t ,d;,q t i� x i.. j t�xb'` 4t.`P � F Ii i i l•, -r'+ i .. t l � '1 r #' }"i' r # + a, fir',,. (aa" WL ., ytru ^..Vn!r �' If i;. 1 4 ►#.) r �, r: �F �', j.Xr. wi`I i ja, 1; L � ��t •t w L��«1 # , ° , a { l �� q i „•r t !:° IX � J P.� � r.. y ,, , iy,. J r .,v � °f a 41 t. ,.ji s, � `f � � � e „ � i y a f Y r &,+i*ti.+rts.+ r++ h� i' ) ,a J + +' .. , "I . y t {.. . ✓ - ;k # L i iiL i t 1 { '�: » +c iriif J � a. x r.. S" tri+ 7 y , r,Y4+i .^ � y'i.tl r�t ,k�� 1} �•L, t°I , i.f qe f: r,�t��,` U� ig' •aa# ; fl# 1 «+,.4y , s)) 1at`!?5 f ° ^ f f w 3 i q. W;r`t 'I;:N, �^' '�' . -T~e sac t � ri..l �.f si Ct {,. �t"'t�. Ctr ��n V �' � ....... „r.. -,., r:,.� x.. •� y' H yr; f ' Y �,./at1i�• � # t �' a#'t � r ,..� # sf (.iia r s .� ..�+ ..;� , K, x �- J.. " ' Y jtt� .iEir>� :��i�� " �+. _,`'w�.`�"�;*3� �� h•L I�Ot��+ � I dt .,��., 1 k ll iN, x:O � «,I W.T . t ,� r ��l >, + �. T^ t ' �. .�. wi .. K �. �...•�rr.: « , ±.» k ` ; Tucl3."stt'iti£ j•tlll�' r",..,ti Y �J, ` ^ rM ' r , di. y a 'ree r� +i � ♦" M � �4 ' t « I« {A tR r� ;�^`. r' ,r ',�•. Z✓"fir t . '� f'1'1� , �t • 1 �'b• �. N � t"'rY� � e v 4 i +Y is Fsb iY 7'p -a V ,:R �'r'' ? ' k t r 1" f�A3 t v.� �V ♦ '< �1t J:' � '+..t;,_:,�.�+ � � r'�` 1.i � s ii d".., a,rki«»�u,..� ,.±+.�. t ..;.1.� ( _..... ri..".._.......,M '^. r ' F ! l ,\.. f -7 I J t is � 3 4 _ +.�• ��h'r-,..✓ "/ SCC 6 S ( ��s^ �PA,�...-...S:..r.--{• � ,•}r „v 1•�'v.�.��� iY�.. y .rvl.�. 1:,J!/Cn• 1� 'ak..=•r,..:r•( T, `rlEs'Jtl Ilt+ meq. 'IvWn atM�77: fa ti �''� �� ":C1 r � ar S( ^�•,/°_� l � - �� rti ��1 + r,,� � _- � '� � - f.- n',Gw h M1c5 v •" ? ' r j 07 / tom. �..,,«.,.;•:,_---a-,.).-._ �,.�:� `;r r.....�..�...�..�_., 1 fr:,-"-,.._. , tt ?P7l``•'�/� fit,kq ^y' -Y!% f ,�"�Ir + S11 ' r..y} ,�.s-'i r* } �, '� � "1)/" �` y' .,,, k t� A�,! �tqy "`�'SOuI!{ Q�� w �1" / �b�' �} «t Cxsz�,i �t1 �,•h � i T hk siE�"fir/ r k � �}11.r,+..g..,. + A{+ ......--. r i r� , ' j�, �,� �, tea '� y,/fk/ry •�-=.-.1r�...> A v' W � i � t � y,° ✓'' � �� R � ,r,.:i- +ri t �� r' � �. � taa � r r"x � •.A•'r1 * t„`,,r Iif X'i'•-.f �`Rrr.,,,,1. 'r Yss,,,rx, �.,4 jjj : I Jl` S _t't: +i.:.'r.`.v>*.«-' * � Y 30 4t.Qu " Yr • r�«ar ij'}y r �� r". ' .�� �3qr' i r' • t Va'� �1('�i u' � L��"' p ,, r r f,..' ± i � t �' � _" �,� i• * 7, Y � ..%'.� ; _, t,q•4'`" C i'� j'`'' ST �� t' fre�Yk � •+�• �4«, �'i GoPiVol } w« ,�` / Y ,"``:i!t„' t •J'il / vt ''y'r" W*i+ + �'� y �(vx`.""�•`�'-=••!•��.�n•� 41 ft x t .,�' '.,'N�� '� r yam' -'1 "'� �a�.� '•�.,. _•+ "�� Fes""' ��� I r �' l � T f �S r �` !i`� � ,•SSI `vt'''��2�1 _y ��.c k'r y'C s:.... ,,%�,K•`Y' Y v'1 ''i �` 'y4 .;% i Ik•' {tl i.' � kc'L.'ii.� ` -t{ r �.3r l,ti �,. «�'���-^« ` r i.1� hyurw �•..+:�,1 «�+�n�«,ay»A yw;w.:. S �� n '..Pt �` .u�«', �+.n � '� Y ti- � v,t y,r �� •'' .�. v3,,�.Z, ss•..rrti".. �." % W+...iw....�,w� � w.«ww ....Lu..1.� t .wy...> ....qe+ 'i LI Al Yt + t"D r+ V r fir?3q �; .� Y �± i T%GPrtk7`�I C rr' _ *°t'�.��.. r3� ^•.� r.��. __.tia, , «..r, M•, is ar ' q ' a„ t> r.. i.. •r?a's� Wx: i*^ r_:°n • > � ..: l r ♦ [ r v + r a e r �r try a• "r. � y Mr ,5 `w �� �y � « n • a ' e `' w �: , i iS it{i�rr tti` A t K • ty. y r v u iVtl'�AS tA'. '• r � ['G �•t 1.,' � `; '..� t ti,�• 11 iY'te +±Yn.`r sr tl 4y v rr•• �rz 1 a v �U �' b P.3 n+ a�"iyaysr{:Vh' '.xOMA n ij r `'1 ', i r- \T 4 _ 0 CO ' t�LUATZ t 1 R0, 1 IF.,, T111� El t i1 t� e c R I X Z', , _ 3)xSClloSlQ,v 01~ tol: _ _ _ � .... •i ate1 : 16 acres of '.{'axest 1:and t,'i11 be r.6cl f ,Od 1b, e. Appr ,xrr > and martially cleared. lio�yevex, the praject site cans'i:t5 a; vc-y gentle, nearly level fridge terrain, r.etluiring ortlj' lirni�ecl g'r.adi.ttg. ' Erosion )lizards are typically ;moderate to 7 oiv on area ra:dg, Iq lds . 2a; T"l;e prajoct ' vill generate vehicle circolat on on Po .derosa Way' and concent of vellic1.es in the local, axe,; ,, (bussu, private Q d ve]1iG1Ids I transporting, children,employees) ,' reducing the localizeI. air quality%. Construction, also Will" temporaraJ,y reduce air quality. Tlies'e effects are not expected. to bt si gnificant in v ,er. of p1•esent as r quality, of the Paradise vicinity and the adjaccrit Dirge open spaces t.hi,611 provide large till, ingvolumes, the .2c: Pavement oyercot:erings and loss of vebetatian �vi7 i}lcrease'. amount of local gxo.und lice tiny (".heat island" effect) , 1~his factor Dave littited additional area cffoCt:. considering; the project area illval�'ed anal;' the ;surr'oundirig( ;:tellsiVe`-. Sllbiilb?75101i :'.did road dev01Opment ral.e cauacit: 3b, c:" The mite and area to the sotitll'' I' Ve existing dna y creaks-, acid deve'lopmetlt improvements . Itttirior shallow swab es sexvir g only limited up`streant Watell8hdd areas traverse this sit};edin f; south into more defined stxearri channels (sout of -, i✓er'g'usoll D'i3.alre %� mile dotvrigtrea-rt, the se creek8 depart developed axerts, flo0ntig into the Little Bt.ttte Creek Canyon) ., °h: Runoff £rum this property= el,itGleiutt'o Cr6.6k, . the proposed location for' the camnlot1leach field 15 near the bexnriing of a drainage si;ta.e. 12elocatson of the leac}i field ntay "necessary to I avoid contaminant potential Cont'amb ants may inci'ease 111 shallow aquifers, ;51tallow wells, and ]l1 d6wnstteam creeks if the 0A, becol;ies satttrYctec� and the setVago' ais� osal capac� ty is e:tceeded.: Although doum8tre:a;ni�r;atei' rluaa�tyti inpacts are a concern' and pateilti«rl prolilettt thro flout the Paradise pizzas rCg�01 Coilfbrmal tt- With butte County ]vnvaxelimeln l git:al'tl1 �-ec{iriremNtl'ts iVill mitigAte thIJ— conce,'Vjl ; soil tests ]lE?r 0 "lTIL'tl DI1 tJ to �1�LGi1tG o off' Gllf: G1�'r1f�,o +Ci15poSrT- chai„acteristie! . (ltefex` to Appendix A for' soils data)" Lodcllirtg areas shou'1d be i�nstall'etl it the areas of slotaex �iercbxatari 1, sinGo Sevcr�tl. Potcolai ion rates wL'r6 tori fdSt, fbr g6Q8 filtration andtlloUtment .of l ♦ litattt 0LicaIit}4,11141,OIIAe'ltt Plati foo P'4-tradi, so n�ia �taIiay� (�talrc)yt 10 7', ��) , 47�tf, es M. Niutit: ottWcxj� y ' ya,11 COt't�111t�:11¢, ,t.;li�,�.ltta'o1's tittttlolri,t"iv, ails 1 W,It ell Quality itl dy- !4apaIi-i Iq�ater�sheers'e1•rto i,� t1e'Ill tmr�G of;'lt`ttte�i f�esoiLrces', �014tNtlix, v r e i i 1i 11ts x, )' )tl#0,cxea;t)`onal . ,� ,.. gar o se,cur�: ai �: Additional neccJ,ary eater P.etention oi`axecs` and facI ItiCs t•, I1 ihcxease area la }iti.ri shotlld adet{ua;taly scretyn th'i.s the `l)u . er r,eenl°rClt . l ].an des s G `%s 'si`Ce for Sa: 'r}te" X , te.� e..istin Butte Cou,lt)t Ccliara�,cn hand u;.sesa`'(rxopo:�c� xev,isiari Gxa��n�-(Jp Loi, pensx Y ].,esjaeit.ial and to �tlb!' Lis_ os }Atte County l a Sllrl�n��-,Laitim1$sa.on) . C1�r1f.rit zoning is e Clll7 fax pubJ ).r' ,1ai'id u1 �l1illl�C �51C1J.p©15,rplaygrounds o d �S r� Y CtC.p T}1S �xo�iCt"�1.) l)e Tip i. ' 1.ICILIt� n aL'i.0T11� )a Iltls 1D S a ore land tlsc on -.5 4r q and l 15,t Ott Ized asea xeCreata,o; al fati'1.�i�ty. Could al's SC}Iao1, w4 hich Could 8bt Gammuni:'t)� contxavers;y tlas ejcycloped o I th.e bas'%s �i ]and use conflicts since the c}Foo` siet fromet}1expxaposedtp °y ic] d.sionrt-hC- ll t300 f NearUY residences e Hort}7 and east, �;h:ile no rasidences occur adjacent to tilt: south vx r,=cst: bet) to 7�t�t}nice piitent i,�i? A LG, '00t -A -I reer batt arca has pxoposctl can., lic'3;s , Ho'ti<<e rC2 , sCltt Al �I;C tiv ties (�]a rti CItI!'r_a f c i svo lenof e gree , )1IOn of €sc.t t}1e a ea I eicf1 WO,-rhn:od to a mxiLar �� t 0 ±40 resicieiices frartu, 1��ndcr.0sa I+4y , o' tce''01 sill:oe t;l�e rlrl�n f for -0r the akytvay' 4i7c1 tl-ta x -o ject site r,0 4 7 pii] e), (8"ce 3zi.,' c; f et cn 'It rein disce. ttssi.On of trace f:ic relatGt1: imp ct sj yt'i�mefarsarldltdtlitaonaln *'`?Ut} from tho sk tiay Std�Ct5, l�r.a�*idh OG:11 atcesS rt the rl�� a r ��a54 Oft private 11TOpb t�' 1�1�l �Ilc1`C�sC. in xCSiCieilCc:S ii , tltc }acal area as cl il.tlreii 1ea1k to ana tom School. llowevtr, °Glee site iis61fr;tx.11be E0lirec1. r gb; Vi px0ject -Sita has potential for sustalilied �ri.e d tinibcr o00,H0, timberstand ($" production I1t� CurtloiltlrY supports a � a.] ual�le " 160-acTc "B'U'l site), Tho' Project will rcmovo 40 acr,c.s �Yo;�t Ort tr°ta. tot`a'I crls1rtcreia1 'tiinb �r product." l�bWCAera ro lttcin loc'a"�igr1 of'.thi5 forest sift, sc1)ax� fblomiothergtialm?er the cfiec°t; tia��l1 �to� b c s ul)'s't ori t a.l - 0rest areas 11, 124; The scl001 ,i.s proposed, to serve e�5aesiolxi t 1ca abil tys�o7s�rve Ridge iii th hp C? ini.tta7 a.)' jjI)pbr 'Pa- ratlise , i:'liC lat"a1 arca a5 tientanrxty�a�s . elleI)ler paradise Ta,da too jyclp" at0 xati.r,ec :PIAtion e:�tii7ato f s'' 5100 l7r=ti{)le (1050 Census,a1y o£ >>;7�bn Dub to etenb))i c •eIottclitiolls y costs :of local' (a °e aGc aae is �+8 years) ► lard a ttl housa�ti aitd the reti;�entcnt cliaractc:Y of fly . }�aTadise Fines rr bion; cort'ttittlet3 JoCalro�tn �n etlttcatia�a tlerlaticl 'nabhxca. ;sucltla't�;V: for e��1'1tlCibn, A 1ticl s?ch;drecasts arC -too ty]ertell4ax)- school t�jf G'i1cbLlrdrez,popt: at�:dn;Y'0t�t1,retltzce `!"o1;1i� 1>axad�sc ov , rcro�� d a)�d i:)"� il,9Po or t.1011 1i1al)a,tts all ex _L,jjL " o� reduce c1; i1y� 1)r).' tr�Iff%c aIx tho f;)ci 1iti s,, 5 10111es south; as �ti+c].l. 'Is atar",Schools ; 140; c school Oun s al d .y rids 1,C>'oaS. Op o +` G rCci t �� X<�LU711t],eS ��,n �llc �.T`ea i'1�.1:}1;t�Uf'J: tJ1eSi.1:'c��1,0;1�'� Xc.s��lent� fox t`�aiJin and 0 • t ' poi1, sprlcc c'3.)1?Gkl'la>; f'S. 14e: uotnpton llrive tea17 reclt;i e im 2`ovemen and' ma' d the nctiti� s llo.ol ser: *es only''the IOCA1 UPpOr Ridge comr:iuni t red.uc I8' domands orl Town of Vdxadi ao ' scJ;clo].sr �hoil cizcl:�.aaI' 011 the S}.jiray wzll he 2erduced ahci fuel, consul to �c (Z:s})etrial,ly ties circulation; busses t r �x 1' on rccitscec. go110 � 1 calxy airerage 5-G nli i'es 15�r 1.Xpa115 C eS�To IUC. h 0 l }�. ,'at1!r Company f-atilities i.'s ileCes5i3r Howevcr, Biles exist in the y art j iiccn;r subdivisions , 1uc: Re.�cr to iteri 3b 'and item' `3' J '7;a 1i pz'opos;ed 1eeat on contains itacier`ately clel9ae fore-st .coti►er -. and a, i, s near. urldevc7oped canyon �jy"a e, e .. -sioPe� oonta;anzri deri,c clza xrai. iire Jia,zards ai-e 'considered Jl }t throe hbut:'Rdradise hazards uccU. Pi,Iie.s reside;tltial de U. to i Oil aptlbcli�r?� access fuxtJ.c� incrca.ses ly���zrcls, r�str tii c cap ct5t�s�c�JYe�ci�acuation' xi'tt� ror tic paradise lip 1)e;` }:i d e +'et2d C . e55 of w-betllor do SC'} ool �.S �}U��t' Sj1nCeSj��al)`tJn .G.IiStS X1'Ve On t110 hide I1Qrtll,l e lilt3�al,xc? . ' rt'� trdrri,tsieslli. 1t5: solid 'ir'aSte and litter V,'Ill Jje u'C�'nOr teC b1' L}X a.Cz1,i t' c�I1d b;* { Y �J7 i �, d Oren } C` Loss o open Space is V].ewod as 'a corncern vy laca,� resideIlts rtictiar�T since 4his 'ltif)�acre 13L��1 ;site y is bne o t}ie last renl;�iri'' i z• cls of t. iider�'i.o cd land in Pa�acl.a se ,, � rl� - terr.aI;i alo l.l; the �ost. ides (oxcept fr;r stet C6ntUTta ty controtxers' * P-ca;1 oh y over this proposal cetlters around 1Jte axteratior of the -- ,xrca's !raid rcti.rement' comrt�;un-ity:l acid Of, L ` ae. res�.dent� d e}zarac er I}oii�ro�tex-, 16 Wily Aicr;es ap the total 160 w�lXthe �eVel�redir Y�onrncrit 20: TJ» proposal m y a Cor e�igt'..n,g reC1'oatiorial tl9e a� t3 e site; are�l rcSlde;lt5 turf, loss 0' ;a. ren axi;A aild the ejiri.v<rt crtvi.rcal�merit) . Not�•euer, xncrer�sed rccreat:Lollal e:ppoi•tuftitaes ma)} 7"esti!! from Use of t)te P't fields a-lic� 4 G:IIeI al tcl'100�., gto, ndS, delll'�nti 1omt�ltLlilr�t'r I s � ci i.c �ritpre,re't+icnts a)` d : 1 s t t1 aerations are made, l�ec'�mmertciatio�ii �'� "ttattt7 e center'!` onrl, relre � tr`ai,i :�:iti i.1or'"""" lygtom shmdd b.e 1 ori �t pgrti�t oC tyle sit to reta;xti settle of alar+ si'tr;'s llattt",i aticeS,tJyc+tc .cJriactet Cactt�ti'e,, } to `15e tl,� eti az� t�rir i.rrylttttc llrta! d,dt,ci t7,et7 itl�t ioe:s�CJYoc�� ���;�,l�rr��rtos ;inrlts, acid .: ,1►i cIra'co f a ca1 Str14 101), !�'as rYorlcJ'itct cel h�=�� ntzcJ t ;lei 5=ax�z e tats 't eiI? .. i ��Burc�iti I, i or.} t rtc.c � ►1r 11�J'l0rt:71t.t ss trr,s t�r-T7` rl; oov rbc cls t i i A0pNDi>Z V ,f REY i� ��r,. i""""REldi,Yt•�' A f3 , 1 I. 1 llutcli d.airi;s W ,Ith gravelbases could be instGillccl X11 i), qCCt: s o, �;. pax`r;a.ng areas and roads. 1&; 12ori drains; ca d lae doi�trispoutaC1 intoe dry ti�.e1.�'s '0 7v .511a -oIyr j o,i ai 1 drains ; 17, At Least 5.00 oT the "Istiiig trees and $elected ve�ot'at.a,on shouYd be retaa�:7�,ed. l)ar};ing area sUr a'Ces could be constructed in. a J.tilttic. type pu:v'ing- With grass or gravel filling t, open lattice. l5, Y Locate facilities to, minimize. the decd for cutting' and 'filling and to comPlinont, not dominate, land forjns._ 20.n l",atural Vorigot:ati;on shOuR be Ie t' zn olid around J : p,�.rF;ing lots , adjacent: t,o roads and around :strv,ctures. This Would rdduce tl c; vistlal im acts and allots more AYatill r infiltrat:ians, i ;- Gol ors and e�'tuxes o ttgli�y�, able-strilctures sl` + v� s ` lotild, blend U1, t or tiimu]atc the surrounding Nregetatioin and' Iand. T1i3,s croulcl help y uce �1ze I reC� ontras't, Id th.r In 8'otti11g. 22, .1 O� Cat -e Cl.WO90 OiSV 1st17 l achfieldsJL--i areas whorC ��e�edlati:Cy.l tests ndICato rates of 5 i!jinute8 pcx itic, i i' �I I „ _ ■I r 'App�Nbik � odgp' i of 23 i T1ilEL E. LIPPINCOT i {,,. T. LIPP111COII �* L. 5, 2730 1. S. 3531 r fs ha d. if i $ U 1007 131LLE FtC?11D 0'0. aOX 671_; - PARADISE, CXLIFt'?RNIA 95959 ��. PEACQLAt,LON_ T E ST L OG i FAiM E Peradiae Un%fled ScE,onl Dish • JOB Vo. -062 RATE play 13, ;3VEi1 t�-► i'4. Lnncfgr5: T2jN. `aT I Oi P7 ice Pi' Ara [3 LOCd LIL:pESCi�IpTIO.N Alken clay .dam, feu emaill s : 4ranCtlar.yerl] ��j„�rl to 32" all 12 holed ih foilowitj.g:fest data �W as obtoine"d in conformat�cQ with th� approv0d 13u?t County soah TeP�oce;dure of 1968. Dept. Prcolotlon 'st 11a; 12 1981 bt9innin9.at 11 OUxl.m• enrS:ing of 3:00p•m• -; Holes Cyt" presoaked on , _. Fi OI.E l�0, l .2 3 4 5 G . 3D�" 3011. ?0-�-: -=n�� 1f fit"- t5'� DIA= " rime Drop Theeprop Tir�aas drop 611 . p ili Irr�prap me projg.,§n Drop i TI„meDrop 1,2b0 12:0 12:06 12;0Ei 12:: i, circ 12':30 dr 12 : j4 dr 12:36 dr 12 r; ✓ P dr 2 : SCO dr 12 : G a1 ry1 1..:00 dT .. :. 1:04, E," �:L16 dr i 1:08 clx .- 1:1Q dry .,_._f 1x12. d 1:0 cir 1:3A31�1� 1:6 d>; 1:3e cir -140 _ G" 1: _ 3; � 4 d 2.00 dr 2.04 5,314` " . 2 :06 �> _. t ��i 08 rir . 2 :1012 5 dr clic 30 2.04 5✓�, 2:;36 d + � :.:3g cir -2 i�}0' 6'! 2 i ►2. _ 6 rfr v 3`.04 dr . 4 i j.n j'0S 2 x:06 dr�:UB °dr` x:10 1,: 4. tnan: 2 min= i"' � 6 Iiyin. I' i \ t 1 3 r>�ih. ~ 3 mini i 5 math. 1PAUG �6. 363 sit 00 r G y y APp�NII�t V mage Z� of AP 66-01-Q1 PARADISE PINES EttMENI'AItY SCI;OOL: Consolidated 'List of Mitigation Measu -es 1. toDi-turbed slopes. lul(y engineered so as minimita therosionPotential Fx 2A�1. 2 Slopes and other disturbed areas shall be stabilized against erosion by 'plzcement of a wood chip mulch, prior to the 'rsinj� .season on all un surfaoed,excavated or embankment areas for which landscaping is' riot ,pxo s, ed,i : 2A-2) 3. Upon c:ampl,et1wi of excavation, and -embankment of, pl.ayfields -first al d/or prior to the, rainy soasor , t3ivexs ,pn diJces 8ha11 be constructed :along the lomrer end of t)1.6: playfields, , to,prevett collected t,unoff fxorat 8011 9 onto slope faces beloW The diversion shat] be outlet to h:cava.ly vegetated neural forest area or a.rti f a cull y st,abilxed axeas . ( EIR: 2A=3) C Ali araas reserved for landscaping shall be planteda.s narly he �n constructionsta ,e as os g p Bible. A11 landscaping shall be 'maintained in perpt usty:' (a:Ilt: 2A-4) Si ` Construction ec{ua,pme.r,. shall be eaa-c..ful ly maintained to preVent spillage o fuel, lubr. cairig ;material and hydraulic' fluid.Ehk: 2B) 6. In areas whero human' encr'oalhirient �gbtid produce erosion un- mitigatablo by malch .ng orplanti ig, px ototta.oh fencing shall be installed to presorvothe area free from trarnplin�. (t CR. 2CL 2) N 7. All construction' wastes and d;abr', and unused stockpiled materials shall be romoved from the p olec.t sato after comple- tion of each pliase of the Work. IR: 2-8) 'Constrifotibi tr,Iaffic shall be reser cted to predetermined tout ;Markers or tomporary �'eftti.ng shall be utiliteci` to define .y+outs locat�.b��,s,. (ljlR 21~;l) 9: A�°eas designated, fog` pal ing shall ' be const uoi:ec] unr►ea t-ly al tea° c.ompl tac�7t of r -o' ns y hnd all voh�cula.r act�V t,xes Ld'IL shall be conductexl ' �`gYi1 these aro�,s tie onftexk I✓112; 1+-3)' : continued s is e s ) • r t on At ca_ u Consolidated List o A9itiga I ' 1'0., Those p1, a8es of 'pxoj'ect construction which, involve soil tlx,s, d'ry months o the, ruptian s]laJ l be limitQd to,the normally Y, ;(April. October) . (h7 R: 4A- 2) 114 ruc'L necessary toad aria ara.inage improvements per. the Const _ County 'Publ C IVo'rks -Depax tmnnt u requirements of the Butte 12 in those j ocatzons where the cer�texline pratile gxade of fhe than G%, the -aadside gutter" access ro,-Ad, becomes area' ar shall be paved .' (QIRA- s) To prevent erosion o�: the eoaawal y embankment at th;e clra.inage �niot and dacharge aprati si,rale around the culvert a rock slTal.1be canstvucted. (ErR:' 4A-4) . 14. A d.us1; pallatiue o spxnklQd ��iater shall' ba applied to all travel ed routes d using- construe ion. disturbed area: or . (E1R'. 9A�2) i 15; . . .. all �be tho='Qu hl,yy, cleaftya prior tai GonstxuCt,a.Qn 0 ulpment sh g mud ionto pubic 1 caving "pxo) ect se to prevent `�^acang streets .{EiR 9A-') it) Trucks haul,.ingaggregates to the project site sha.?l be re- (ExR: 9A 5 uid to rovde canvas load co��ers • reP 17'. at tocat foci lit es in o deo thervedat w'�POnlymthoseet eesmar�dxe - -- - trees, -and shrubs wall be pros . m�j br shztLibs ivfa�.c]i are 3.4 direct'�lity - - - `st be clo sed canst �Ltcti on shall be Iremoved. All brush all every bu'il.din and all tree limbs i�iitli�.n �tifathin 350foot of l!p feet a building roofs -,per Butte County S"7xe Depari:ment:) hieh are extreme c���i ,hal'1 be taken not to dhmage t]ios e to re`maan znc'luding `their root syst�;mr . A-1 8• When 'trenchingfor 'Piacement a 'undex�,ro irid utilities, scut not 1e crit pines:, ar drainage pipes i a) feeder roots shall �.nsi e t]it dr�.p Pine of alae tree br`ailc]lesd I� H yl an area than as provi'dea below) ;damaged immediately �3ith trunks ox epase foots tree Paint (,ca,~e 0 5exious rvill be p,einted Injury should bbPn'scrxbed by e pxofossianal forester or into l3_cezised t ee' sexva.ce c) 'oalist�ruc jon ienc-aa,chtnont )' be p ami led, but ,not clt�sc'N tii'ari 5 Feet t]ie c ri +l Ine may on. o e Pude Qi t]Ze tree 'an�:y .3 . sue}i car ci'o r�tnent will Wit illoly tie tree to ''die j� eserved foi��l ridscap�ng aria minimum 1400t disturbatoe:. (br}ti 5 ) 19: ren e t�iuding Matu •e trees) Foxy'the sclio'a.l egetat:�.on Clea g aoco. s road and i'-ixo fano thi�augh t}�c natuY ell a� eas shell to o feet'( -s e u red by the Butte County Pi e j be 1 mated liect't�al , h si )epaxtment) an bac}� sad' cal 1n��ts a ` t -_tri tp y be.�retaind the roadt�tay'ar.�li. t1e:rt,titr_s !te�getation s}�al'l eterit p ossxble arounel `arilg ].otsy ;adjacent to �'aads, -to the a _ m aot� ; yid ora i d truotui,es `ta reduce ne�:giiborhaad v�six� 1 p xti lzA-5) i Consolidated List of Mit a. rl gatIo Measures continued) 20. During construction, builda.ng materials shall :Ue stored on 'parking areas, to prevent soil building pacts or roadway; anal compaction. (FIR : 5B,I 3') 21. Da:stu.rbcd sites --especially riparian-'- shall be rove-etate (plant �vath native plants or other -drought r�sis'tant plants be obta.ned from a professional forester or l5,sts should licensed nursery=man) as„soon after completion of construction, (>JTR: 5-B-6) as possXbl:e, prior to t}'e �oanter.rainy season: 22: A continous Fence (5 feet high minimum) s}ial,l be installedu the of the developed portion of the school... around perimeter site to preserve the d.esig.nated. open 'and rlatuxal space' 8eCtOrS. FIR: 5-0- and 7-A) 23 Fences or obstacles to deer 'm3.grataaon or o°thee animal movement' on the Ox e'!nal boundary of the shall 'not be constructed undevt�loped project site. 'phis will allow local and migrating deer to lase the undo sturbed buffer zones and areas noten- development as habitat and ingrataon corridors. volved in school (LTR: 7B..1 24. A 200, -foot wade Forest bolter greenbelt shall be maintained eastern Property Uorde'r, to be preserved along the northern and • p . ,p ity an Its natural,: and:istu.rbed f orested. state in e1 etu 25 School crasstval}: road paveZont markings in accorr}.ence with Ti icanual, shall be placed at �;hapter i0- of the Gaitrans a -. the l-oll6wing interseCti'ons ponderosaDri'v'e a.nd CMgton Drivo l -onderosa Dzi,-Ve and Compton. Drive both end s D� xve ( ) Sout:} Park Drive and Glendale So ul” Pa,•k Draw a`nd Ah�Over I)ti,ve South. Park 17rave '111d, Vexgilson ive (both ends vor"gusorl ,'briire an Y Ow"tit Drive 2 Baeyiwle%peclestriar lanes sh:a11 lie established, signed and rnacls wti�n tie` 5 foot paved: area stxpec� on raj,or aoess 1�'etl,�een alae edge o the streets s traveled wdy and the face of dike, at the to:llawng t. of a, On Creston Dive f#om Citadel ay to Ponderosa- hri`�e; b On nonderc�a br.l.lte firoyn The Sky1Wa r to Creston. Drxv`p > , c. 0n South park Drx vc Uetti�+ec:} A1�d-over Drve end. l�erguson Drlvey d• on South FaY1i Dryvo >�e�tiYeon Glen' 6 Dr%ve A1C: Lerg�r'sor',: rive (b6th etlCds') }, On Sotitr► Pari Dr�i V botrVe.irri Pondero a Way i i . and 'Pe��guson Drive y i i AP 65-01-01 ADDITIONAL: POSSLB LD MI!'IGATIUN MEASURES_! I a) The embankment slope at the culvert crossing of the dre�nage swale shallbe paved on berth,sia s of the road. (E :R. 4A-6) b) Ai! trees within 1 15.0 feet ,'of a school b'ui l ci ng should be, -inspected by a professional forester ora licensed. tree` �� . Se V i r ce on an annual basis. Those trees found to be a direct danger to 'school buildings shall be ;removed: (Elk: 5B-7 c) Construct Compton Drive through to Ferguson Drive from Ponderosa {day per Butte County Public 14'orks reqtia.rements: ci) Asphalt" concrete 11pede.strxan walkways should' be anstal,led' in } conformance with Butte County Suodivisioft rvpro-ttement Standards on,at least one" irl 1 of the f�o17 o v�ng streets 7 Sch.vol access road as shown on Appendix D of the Ell 2) 'Compton Drive from Ponderosa Drisch ve to ool access road; 5); Compton 'Drive from 7-e,rguson Dt 4've to end of j pavement; 4) Ferguson Drive from South. Pari i]r. i��e to Compton'_ Drive 4- e) Contribute a proportionate sham for future •traffic signals at the intersection of the Skyway end ponderosa Drive. f) An emergency (or circulation) road should be proijded from the site `to South Par, Drive. g) `Zitate'^ conserving pi actieeS end, equip,ment (mater restrxctlon devices on ba:throofi fcilita.es' and to the feature cafeteria) hou,ld be- installed to ma.n�.m�.ze ��atet use: h) Du.tcl drains with gravel bases ` cbul;d be constructed in t, pa, a,ng areas an,d along pro .ect roads to reduce off site 'runo �f a) C��eate natui-a'1 areas and h;a king trails a or envy ronmental t'ducatIort, and tonal' 115e5 . r uV1C ! J1A Negalte, CA 95954 2 we � The �.• `r• iES1L1"$ it► vi'n1.fican't ad'rer E rm1 rOxlPrtal, i,cnpaatS' Air• jhe. E Z f ollO. -.na dll � a aril ti. If the proposed sctacsol expwntis ovar a periaa of t.i,mie there vt bn,a significant dttE.r oration in local air duality c1u% to o ;;jecta c»1a .tuMes from a concentration o.f cis esel bus tra_f�ic� ernpLoyee auto''ti-i,t ic, de1..vox'y and i° maintenance 't':-ack �ra:':fic, rei-�i•zational trai" iv. all •Tari eties .of 'L"rai �'ic to .. and fron the school location. ^ FI mes .create health pr ob1 �,ms for pcoplo who . ]oaaned in this local.., area because of lung, propt erwa hay .. a •�.mher -of` trees and acres of venation loll t an ad - T he removal of a large n 1 jG ��• verse reaction on the moisture acid temperature of the local arta. Trees and s`� veg4•;{ion retain moiure and assist in modEratiu7� clira?.:iG ch2nges as well �f as r'►elp direct tend currents, 3 pater: The. folloAng wi 11 resultir. si n� f" ant ad"versd' ' ttt r ronraental ir�pat:ts s ao A rioted cn pa.ge 1, section lf> ttierz� ate a nuahbez 'of"onal stress that flow throtgh the proposed site,. Tha crisp, uctioll of b�t��dan�s, }parking Jots�-,, '' p a a r p' h r -y tre of Water' movemen� goads lav' i..lds and se tic areas w1U. , change the cour.. Ib: W11 even the pax-tialclearing of lb urea of the Propos 53,te and the .clea,T Wing of i.nflau�cable debris and unfit;; ;ra'.rti� from the entire: >~0 more .°c to the,fate and amau.•it of y„1��r�t��}Qr r„r,oa]1 be; dras�cally increas:i. 'then the soil becores sa.turated ti th fre u ,nt stead ra nSall and aceaaztcc .i heap." ra xl- fa1X o~V. r a short per nd a£ tat�ta(Novt tuber 19$1)" the clay loam t6psoi.l. catLnot; absorb fast enow-h thus altering the drainage- potternt and cascadilna mLnoff to the ox"f�site area to erre south of the proposed schoal, .' c. There is need for more Off-site drainage i apro�:eme;►4s to take � a,� of wurfsce ' �3aters Sore �s f� am the no:Ythe'rn px4 of nt= 3re ��ist } e di xected by dridn, ' ' 6.V4ea. or i osed lb Gcr� devalo n nt and the esent culvei ale pa pe under the ra p-. p p p A H ease sei' rc±no,f f. a creased 1h,I 81OHe to handle inc CroF',a �EI'tl5on Drive rilist 'be ri d. �icated in ar by and c above floctl �;at cio acc�tr at the, pri~se:tt time the site in its natural state inter years with local r6tidelnts) Thus ; tie propose cle4ting and constrtiuti4n wit] note only e�:ter th+� coux�Se of flood wittez•s b•.%t increass their ��a.ume. fa The di char E` infic� Ti flde watery fro rciofs, paz•ldn lots, roatxsy pl.ax fi.�ldsp atttvmbbilesj busses) not o-.pactdd soli will dotcrioratc stirfaca rtater gtlaLi't as Well as 13, a rtrraaoe the ttxrb'S dit�, b Uzi ess cha;i�elcd or rul�rerued therorxl l boa s�bstant� a. chcir;Q iri tiie a3 riot io z o " the flo�4 ',t ttd •aters. h„ t+. the County &rd the MM have .indicates that there ctiiild be a sibstantzal cht!n i;i both the guantit ~ and_'L o.,�+iia'li.t of �sround v;a s t'hro,t�h a:�c�;a.tid:�s t the iipral"y an in erceptions of the aiqi lfer by cats and excavatio• i s oi�e' of the rrf� xi sub ion ad�,m', e taiga 't,o "rho cn��� rt;ri�rent� ' a +i: '1"hopY�`Icution of t, itaJ. clY•o°litter'GoItpA:� "iter supplier to appro`i.: Lely 1 of ',ttiti tJppsr iu�i ) to the bV4 to dr' a;i ill; crl xw de.ral xrope rty Next to the proposed school ii di catos t ;�t a `til] y a�� ev Oped 6ch5o3. t�otiild reduC the , tt iallr�t of water avail.abi6 to ttze pui1libi, it the wateyr�• company is cc�ncex-rred : ahead fora the ttc3r c e � e mu L p a oes a bl.a x•edizctxona, iPa9� p blit water supp y. i A "itr tht3 uanniti� � " P NDIX � 3 n n. Y 3 E. egetatinn,; A. Referenco is mad®; to poison oak in the study,Since it ts:doubtful that rechild 4 op will learn about the plant►! and, learn to avoid( it? there is : poss- ibilI ty" of ahealth hazard to younger children. There in no reference to the chemical control of this potentially dangerous plant. 2q The theory of leaving 'a number of 15 inch diameter trees standing it arra n, occupied by children is potentially dangerous. While the plan caLls for cleaxang oerhang3ng limbs back ten feet from buildings does not les3-- en the danger of mature or senile trees falJling';on school huilcl nes dung wind storms.. 3. Vegetatioh situated in various areas within the campus Paritneter and bel; buildings will beshelter, for small animals. Since there have been repoi is of a number of rabid small animals and rodents in the' araa�there may be S health naxard here for _ small: childr_en._. 4. Mairntenance control of vegetation within the proposed fuel', and fire brew.%es. � ., at various times will be required thus adding to operating costs, r g« ofe;'ence is made to ground cover plants that must be hearty and resip- tive to foottraffic. These plants should be specified then the ropor4 JsL talking' about mi_t'igati`oh. ., p h?ali,ca Protections 1: There is nn way that ate can be conv3riced that there i4ijj hot tie th+j deed i rr additi.orial policy protection with the construction and operation of the posed tial school.' Just the factor ai children wanting to school on thu N - - , y --path throe h forested dreas viei.otis do s* os��in streets bic,clo lanes pa g ,- B,, P moledters$' vandal.1 _ etc. will double "the Fiinouxit of police; pro`tectinn ct.Ila for the; area. . 2, Since there•,3 a no: sheriffi0.,sub-=station in, the Upper .Ridge •the. respo for an timer enc call can be delayediunless there is a co car in h 1. As; the economic situation in the Chun becom°t§s more acute, and the Co'ent"r budgets have to be cut, it is posgiblo`that'adequate police protection rot the ttppox Pdge can be` reduced below the present leve],. R. G. fro Proteetions ,�, r z.� ' part" Lai in a school: surrounded b a belt u�i 1. Fir o -3 s a x Gal ha F rd.. pa 5 y' ,mate- al. �ondi�rosa `inti is often reperred to ds Attu �Cr t.i P .- ,flammable <atid i s a very flau�iablc� type of tree Whnthex• green or dzy. With fees: :`tees being pines) a 3b Soot set bick is, not dere enough. a' , NOTICE 0r. PE "ERMTNAT I. , AP X66-01-0 "N rARY SCk10QL' PA RA,DZSE �ZN�S `FLbrr ! - Consolidated List o; Mitigation Measuxe Disturbed slopes shad be,careful y engineerc ; ;o as to minimize the erosion potential. (ETR: 2A-1) 2 Slopes and ,other, disturbed areas shall be stob�',`lI d L1ga ns't, erosion by piacemenfi of .a wood chip mulch px i 0', to the rain season ori all unsurF.aced' excaVatea or embankment areas 'for Will cli lands:eaping is not :proposed.. (t:'! P,: 2A� 2) 3,' m letion of exca �rat.�.ori a><1cl em .�nkme n t c� e as Upon co p iri season divexs7.orpildy and/or :prjor to the ,First ra y likes along lower Bila aF the play Fields, shall be constrticted ,the to pretren`t collected ruAo f From ;Eloiving onto slope daces The diVerSx.O,n shall be outlet to heavI y vegetated ; below. natural forest area or axti F ciall,y stabilized areas . ESR: 2A_3� 4: All areas reserved Foy lartdseapirg shall be planted as early ha11 ` g as possibl c, All l st�i .e anclscapingsIn the be maa.n ainedu ri pe "pettta ty. (PIR: '2A-4 Constx ctl.o'n ecltiipmeilt shall,' lie ca-lefttlly nta;tiztained to sp jlag o;l Ittcl, lubvicating matexlal, ana hgclraul!ac prevent In areas Whet 10 liuntan encroacxilient would p oduCa ers of tin table, lay mtilcl :ing or, plant lig,, protectican Fencing shall be talled to preserve the" ares frac :Eroni trampling. 7. All constrtiotioi� iVwistes and debris acid unusocl stucltpiled materiJAS shall. lie removed from the prof edt site 61ter comple" tion or each phase b the �Vo'k. (t R: 2r '. Construction x. a1 Fac shall be restricted to pxodetexmined . c utilized to shall b' ` p g , rc iite ` Markers ox tohi ora`x e Acijft be locations, hxR 2P-l� d>✓:F.�ne rbLX �� Areas'desI;;riated 0 pr1171T,�511aMIJe CgSt5tY`LiCC �S111T1C't'iitey' vch;i.'cular act�va to es a,Et r coin 1� tion off' Cotindat, ons �' aha all shall. be danductod .r-toin these areas thereattot': (1;TR.; 2p��� Consolidated hist o:E Mitx ati;on I�4casciies .(cQ.n t to d Those phases' oC project const Ljctlon w17.ich; involve s.oii c};� y r mot s ohs t1to be �.imatocl the noxm, � �1ry xupa oxi shall. ,'to year (April - October): (E[R`: 41-2), - Con'struet necessary rocnCountyiPubiGtnp°r}:stncl Sxtmetit}� n eats of he .Bu , re uxxent l2 . Inthose locations where the cen`t`erjina pxo C e oracle o � the 6% the roads`"L '0 butter access road `beco"mes greater than shall be paned. (ELR: 4A-3) 13, To prevent erosion o E the xoadvaycentnt�dis}a�oaaY�tonge stivale around the culvert, a xocl. Shall be canst`rtactad.. 4A-4) _ 14. A dust pallati've 0� 'spri.nkled water shal cons 1tc ion ', a].1,: tra-ve, ed roues clue aisttitrbed areas or (EYR:9A~2.� l 5, . ConstrttcCian ee�t�ipment shall be thoroug, �y cleaned prior ta'. mud cnt� public r ro ect' site to prevent tracking stxeets (F.1R 0A-) 16 Tt'�ucks� haulm gg-regat s to the p1oj,ect site s1na l bio ,reg (ETh� 9AN5) �} uirel to'rovi.cl.e canvas load covers. l7' at an Y,ocate' :bac Ll'a_tios Iii "ardor t}der V`et .O mn]�tliit�lOSCe CS eeSmallCl will be pres _ - trees. arc} shrubs major shrub ti�ttach bre ;gin direct .cortClict i+ti th i aeiqty (All lt1 construct ion shall be reMaetj : ti itlUil 50 feet of every' buil �it,g arts treeall ct s v thin 17ep r ment.) l,0 cet aE' buiidirtg roofs�-�Pcr Euttc County dare w`h c}i are . - � e� those c _ ;►, be taken not -ta OAR'- _., E ctiyeme c�.r0 shall. td remaa ri inch ucltg their root systems (E1R: 5A-1) i n '' o'r ,ac'emen ib + undergratftjd utalitxesIII, sewer �Vh� n trench g shah not be cu.t. est a) te'eaer rants ]encs; or dxaiage pipo bra inside the c1r�p lri an are" lama cd trunksoor exposed roots` than as provided belga; b) g 'rc;e (`care .dor. se r� ous * be p� When intmeda �ttei y ivy tki paint p2escribe'd, by :Yp eS iailal Ee e5tG1 ar ry s}loujcl'be lnjtlin 1'lsed roG sexvCe); c� Codsbtit�iot Glose;rcthent5eet the dxip ia:rie may c germ . t , . Side b„' tho tree an7 : i such cito'a ehmont wil Wi ani. sid ana with lanclstap�ng al osv the t 'ce to ,be 'presexvecl fot tis tubance; (T2; 5`130 miri.:amini toot 19 . Vegetate an c.leaz•in (e lclucli`ng `mature trees) ' fox' 'the schot l t.hro.ugcclii-tbe �t scce5;s raid ana fire lane xe be lith ted to 20 feet (as ret�ua x y tjlet'atuButterCoitrit of 6.1 Abe Dopa tment� oh e�1�its ich. s� cls: a the a e tet p}3 n� shad reta n,ecl a. raadtivay ilC tj es'. ritux�sj n.. acts �iCekt to tort the lets add �' �a the e c. cnt passeh•]o atdullci x g. . to vcducc iieighb6thoocl visual tiipaots: tndo6rowjftcl structures _ Consoled lted''1,:L5t. O Mitigation "Me as"tu0s (cgTltlTitled) -- ' 2 D ir' rig Cons' TUC:, b.u:lld�ng materials shall be stored nfL pr`c ent so�ILI, + > acl��ay, and park:�.n areas, g building S to Q co,mpa.ct�ona�s (EIRE: 21, tevogetatc Disturbed sites=-esp'(c alf rrou htnresistantbplant$ (plant With native pians or other c1 ction lists should be obta'insdsoonma licensed nurseryman) a tErpcdmp7�eticnTof'�const'r the w nter rainy season. (ESR: 5,13.-6`) as ;possible, pr for to 2z, A. cont nuoiis fence (5 feet high in nlmt�ntortion o ethin 'the developed p esscho61 around the perimeter o the designated open'and natural space` site to pxeserve c S1 and Fences or _15staG�es'to deer m�grat 1na:� botnc tryit �oEltl�evement on the shall not be cbnstructed ndeve aped proj ect site . This Still all�r�v loe1. and tt.tg'x acing and arorpt n` deer to Use the undistu b.ed bUffer zones develn hent as „.bit it a4jd m ,x ataUil c r do volved' in schoel '(`51A: �},: A 2,00-'foot wide forest btife�r green bordexshall b, etaabetpresert�ed along 'tlic: northern and eastern PT, along sta -, P. petu�:ty. ... und'isturbecl' 1o7e'sted to xn cr tri its natural, 25. School cro`s al °road paVemcnt nark�t nua ns�ia l�benplact �cedhat — -- Chapter 10 a1 the Caltrans Tra�r. I's ections the fo11ot � ng „ nt0 Ponderosa Dr xe and Cres ten llri've 1�r�vc %?onaaTosa' btive and Canlptari South Paxk Drive and C1 enda.le )31 1, �'e (bnttincls) South Perk Dr vo and A'ndovcr btiVe We I pork lir ire and Pbrguson nx ve both ends) 1«ex uson ''Dx�v� tlfi Compton Drive g 26. B�cyc,l e/pedestt a all lines shall Vbth�rittlbie35-, , I tSp vecl area reads } strlaed on itta;jor access th.e edge n::f the streot's traveled tvy and the' fico between o.E clik.o � 1t the fO ldiva.ng ovations a. On Cres't'on Dave -f-,t Cj t iclel tr ay to, PondeDrive; b On Ponrosa derosa Drive dram `r'ho Skyway t Creston brivo, }Vest `Park Ai i re bo't% 06n�lndovcl 1)r ve c,n :and' , on lV�st P, �=k_ Drive betwoc't1 C1 endale Dr i vo and FeTtis'bn ;Drive (boti ends)' vQ botween Ponderb5a e On 11:est, ;�1�stk Dr and Pexgusori Drive .y Con.. 07 a dated b St of Nlit,i atipn Alcasures (continued) 27 . Con Form' to the $iitte Cotin�y V r, e `DQdpartment rec�u;iremetits iTprotectio'n iricas i:res whi oh includeil a) Structures shall be designed 'so' that fire' apparatu will bcable to get within fifty feet of::each, EIR: 16'B.-1 busldxng, ( ,) b) No building shall be pore than 300 f"eet £rom a fire hydrant that can provide a minimum of 1;000 gallons per minute:, (''tIR:.16B-Z) c) i All brush• shall be cleared from within 30 foot a-F, ever building and txee 1—m' xemovrd• that a.ro vvt h �n y b1—�. ETR 1613-5 _.. 10 feed of the.--Hofs. ( ) d) The accessroad shall be a Min. _Im of 24 'feet Vido and a 20-foot clear �onie (f%rcbx.e,ak) t.o be pr`ov ded on each side of the road: (Fylit. 16B 6) e) A 30-foot fuel,' break (with 10-foot f'i.robz4i,a) shall be constructed' ancl, ntabitainnd araun�f the oTimeter o the deye o"ed_part�,On of the sitsEIR�� 16B-7) E) A fire detection and alarm sys teM shall be bui 1t into each 5tritG'ture': The al'qVIII ,system 5h"all be C.O`ilhott0d (EiR 1079)`. to superrri seal GGIlt'ral alarm Station. sub-surface ey�cavatlon activytios unrov'er prelii stogy. is aiitilaots of other e'vidbncb of preiIis'oric aboriginal occupa- ton, corlst'rtictian in the irlvolvecl aree shall lie stopped na a�drchaoolo�stht bdoltlacteaihnediatelY � r ori ot adverl11 setly tletoClet-a*edaa�eirr�neproperiixtiz impacts of the ;project to the ou1'tui'a.l rcc�urcos involved: (ETF t , 1 OA) 29. and ha`nld6urts shah. not be lighted far nig7i't- time u e . CEIR ,0 ha ter for 1' ghting shalt bo s'l eldocl to rec7,uc�: g� ave potential, $1 �Juts'ao noise levels, sllal.l not eltceed 60 dll (Sdri on acljacerlt y 5 rosi dents a propei.�t es . 32 Noise shall be oontro7led during 'cortstrtictlan by ixiititng Iwo rk to riortnal ctayli.ght houxs an�1 req irin� proper , muf:E 1.t}x - ^n all etupinent: Gonstriiot p'odestxian acooss patlliv�iy5 tb, the scliao Yard Wont U86 11 DtjVe anrljor i i"a n butli Park Drive . l t nP Gu -01-01 ., ADDITIONAL, PC1SSIBtE MITIGATION MEASURE5 w , a) The etnbankttlett slope at the culvert cross�.ng of` the Idrairiagc' both.sicles oR- the road. (ESR: A-6) s�v�1e s}gall he paved ;on b) A1� 'trees 1,*j thin, x.50 feet of a school Uuil:d,ing Should b by forester or a licensed tree inspttcted a pro.Eessioria.. service -on 114 enrival basis . Those trees found to be a be removed,. direct danger to schnol b x ld nes 'shall c) � Construct Co nptctn. Drive through toy 'PergusO11 DTIV— ;Exom Butte "CoUnty Puta'lic Vorlcs rt�c'uirPtnents . ponderus,a 1V8y per d) Asphalt c"onc-rete pedestrian_ walkways should bo Installed in With Bute County Sub 1-60n Nprovomen , eonfo,rmance Standards on at ,east one side of the foll'o��rin streets Selo"ol access road as shown on Appendix D of the 2) Compton Dr3.ve from ponderosa Dvive to schael access ro'I'd �) Other roads as necessary', as, dete�`mnecl by Butte County' Pub` s c tiVorks Dopartziett ; e) Contra la�lte a poportn oriate share for future traffa c signals the 5 and iron ci•osa Drive. at the ntersectj n of yt,raV f) A�' emc�>gerioy .(o ' circ,ul-at;ion) road sh'auld be pro c�ecl Erotn the site to'' Nosh park Drive g) �Vatex' cons ;r��in"g pr ct� ces and, lei' 1i1pment (�a�ater res tr i,c:tioir the future ca�etoria� devices on bat}zroom focilitxes aic1ri .. _. ,,, iter Use shot be �nsta11ec1 to m�n�.m`�ze v h) btytc}i cl,rai11 tip- tfi gravel bases could be constrUct6d in thh along >bsr�s to 'rFditee ofE�sI ptr ing are��s aitch :'�ro�ect Tunoff.. �) area's ahcl, Yiilc fb>" env,roimenl tualing rta. et u"cat:'o' and ,ecrostloi al rises; W/ I