HomeMy WebLinkAboutPLANNING COMMISION MINUTES & AGENDAS 1/2000 - 6/2000• m
M,
771
= '•
ml�
_ , " . "'. I WJI '.11 lj!.",,��` J, I, I/, " 1 ", � I ,
:t 1,
V zi f
A `0
�it I
M9i
tit
YI 0
M�
Ir
to q;i
atil W,� Pit. I
I,
ZjI
YJ`4
§T!
In
W4
II V
r'! rill
N '40-
1 1711 �q"" A
., , .. .1 ,
14,
qt. A 1 11,
in, .
V&I 'INiA ?11 Iq 71 c
lit
lo i:, mlti if r.
At j;�Iqx
t �j I � 'i"til
W lit", A,
Lit. k I 'A-; I's, , Iy 1 6"
ul. "Y fill �,f; i., I'lin,
9_0
It'ititill ". 1, 1 ��l , nx,
k�s �,i
I,lq I I—' t k- , , _ m
Ii!lfllitl" A, I A1,14, 1.� -qA! v
'-q,
A�z
J
"t I, AV
I, c
tit,
Mit�,�P I
Ile
A
It,
A, Ili
"If it If, h\
W&,q WROil"Wit-A W,,�,
77—
IJI'Iii`p��',II,AJ A.J 11
ISSION A
WINUTES, &
04!01 :37 PLANN N
ii�PENDAS :Iii;112000 �to 6/2000
m
It J,
�.A )'l
01 T 4,
It,
14, t,!
It
jw
...I Y,
it,4,f
tin it
tj,
6
�X
T7
tTj
Ittt1It. . . . . . . . . . .
nj
vvas mooed byCommissioner Lambert; secondeclf iiy Commissioner 'Cage, and unanimously t,arriet to,
` �� t
approve the rnmutes as.corrected§
F t
t�
V. ^.� items �
CONSENT Co, for T�icse
i
sent are s et a ms are
approval sin ons motion items considet�ed`no-controversial. „,�4o
,
prosentattons wilbe (made, hovyever, some quest.ons may tie ask d'
The Ohare will Tisk if any court ussioner or member of the publio wishes to pull a.consei�t item for d scussion. rie1' guestanns
t majbe asked on any'item,
Amen lcan,Tower Corp4d1on (ATC), proposed Negative Declaration Vi,tI.mitigation.measure's
regardmg. enwxo ; ental impacts and ilVlinor Use Permitao allow a l85 foot'communications tower
' and ancillary iuprnent to support digital cellular plloneservice ighway 99i Four cellular
;phone `service providers will colocate'on this tower: 'The property is Ltined A=40 (Agricultu'tal - 40
;acre parcels) local to- d on. the west side of Highway 'J�-approximately 3,600 feet southf Cana,
Highway; north ofChicoi APN 047-100-1.39 (Sly) (Mid' 00-12)
Chairman Leland explained the Ypf ' c duce corcenung a Consent Agenda item. Ile stated that he had reviewed
4
the information submitted. He said flus matte> was throughly discussed at tl;e Platnung Manager's 01eetingi
it was moved by Co t'mmissioner Mooney, seconuea by Commissioner Lambert, and uilanirriou'sl carried to
Y
ti acceptthe consent agenda as presented and deny the Minor. Use Permit request:'
„
Mr: Wilson noted:that there is a;10 day appeal period
- r' L BUS11�1>GSS,�FR0 TI -IE 1FLOOR ON 1TIu�ZS NCT -ALI Y ON TH�AGENI)A;-
T
done
w,",
LICHEARINGS:
Paul Vandegrift' proposed htegat �e •Declaration regdrduig d iviionmerital impacts and Rezone
from TpZ `160iWP (Timber Preserve 160 acre parcels and Watershed Protectioty `C)erlay) to T1vM-
4601 Wp (Timber Moitnta�n 1,60 aotr; parcels and Watetshed Ptotectioh Overla�� rim an 9,31,40d
sitewan80acparcel. The ro.1tis ocateird a p`roximatel sic milr,'noith of the ToV�n of
Paradise , al'15428 Skyway, Magu�ia; at the terminus ofMead'j"kook itarcla .l+toad, Wliich iiitersects
the Skyway 1,000 feet south ofbe.Sablx .Reservoir, AP N O�i5L060-00� (i�13)' (REZ 99-01);
earth `wss"eonttnued close' for a le al; b inion from CouhtSj Co n some
1Vlrt reedon salt% this It d g p
g ' tinsel o
ffiie tons the Corr irnrssion ha, at the ,last meeting,
C:}iarmati.eland'said this opinion states "that the Commission does have the power to redone' this property;
.
r
Mr. McCaoe, b6puty C"o'unty Counsel, said the pxovls�oris of.theatersled Prateotioi Zona4-235,10 (a)
(2) doe's not prohibit tlie'Comtnissiort,from considering fil 'rezoiiei He said lie Cottnmissiori can'make a
rezone reconximer{dad6ft to the Board ofSopervisors;
a
r■ NNING 3UTTL;CJUI�TY I'i,AGbMMISSIO'1Ci'C)r5 kjUN� 29; 2�ti0 � i'AGh 2r
'';'t'�^ j Etll'r T kr"4"'1: '". '4d"A '..ii 1 Y'1' ry%Y rye �:7' "SCi' Nr5" ,�•, h' ht. W-.. - '.s
y„Rr - , i
f ?M �+ M 41W 'I
77.
x �i.
11 r
x+i; 17 k )�, 14 4 ,%• Y1. ,Y it.� „k �, .,i . * :,' t. ih ' V .aiy ' ' :f .,. .Fi �'h i
rG
.
f'�.{V.Ik(7YJY1iA13eSFAliiaMlhY+t'44 awon .a'�.FF..�1 .M •,yy+w.,. !.wvay .M.n Hy..,..ir,. rp -�,;,
1 1
11 I
., .this' o en the hearin
e tions the ro anent from the audience would
g d if she.;"qu s
Commssioner a aske P P. p
1 i d Fy
l
.Ca .
t
' ` ' . g
Chairman Leland discussed haven a motion.to re=open the hearing
f 13
'.
_
Commissioner Cage r-%ade a motiantore-opeithis Bearing.7 yl
f.�
a to i e nottce and r e`sehedule flies hearin 1f, 'ou ire' oin
ne g g
at the Comixiis lion would d g.v ,,, g ,�'
Mr. 1VIcCabe said th
,
y
to it.up so everyone would have a,fair opportunity, withnotice, to come and participate. `
open
r
Cage if theproponent a I'believethat that is a different situation.
Comnussioner s:d she.justyasked question,
She said this is done in Paradise; plamung hearuigs Arid other' planning hearings that she has attended.
`'"''
Chairman Lelandsa idrin ferms'of fairness, if you allow one side to speak, and we have not given ie other side'
t
i
notice that there is ::going to betnew uifoination from tl?e first side, it is not fair• He said' he is inclined to not
open the hearuig •
l -
y _
I l i
i
atio
ti e e ma ahead b�e inform it
Mr. McCabe said the CoCommis:iion might ask the question of staft, He said �i r y y
.
in the file# in the record, to arigi the questing.
�•
a�
t
Coninussioi er Cage s iid {here are'{CiiviromnenWi uYipacis associated; with flu's praject. She said, in her opinion
Sq
l'
there`are 60 cars with 2QJ people, there should be a septic system and riot portable toilets, :_She said Ivlr:
Vandegrift is advertising his property as a reheat. She asked'fdva description of What is ednsidemd a retreat;
Chairman Leland said lie did'not see the characterization of the land having a', Caring on this decision to
,
rezone.
Commissioner , age said in her oping, a retreat; as advertised by , Uandegiift on his sign at 916way3 where
entrance' is ocated, would bei place where, many people meet; conventions and/or camouts in places 1,
this: Slee said the Initial Study states that there will ,lie no change of honing in the Paradise Vijater'shedi =
-
MV l McCabe said hisopinion was regarding,s ze of the reamed area and not land use,
f
Comrl�isstoner' Cage asked if staff kiievu whether Mrs V- d' ',ft bad information that flee Paradise Lake Dani
was going to be raised which there would be a possibility of portions of tihis.property being inundated, She.
said if this project is approved there should be three more conditions that should lie added, One wottld'be about
the road leading to the project. S1ie �taid other develop ients;require that the mad leading to airy development
leas to be vVhat aid :$utte 'Cottnty road'regiiirements are, Another thing is that it should be required that in no
way ;can ai runoff fram this praject be, going into Little butto'dtCek which flows into the Paradise Lake,
domestic water system for znore`:than 2V - people. She said they should require a septic systein be installed;
c orks standards,
She sa*d the rbad shoiild be brought tip to PubliW
Mr. Breedon said flee !ondiWhal honing Agreement;has a condition for the road: He said GDP wa - satistied
with this od, iditioii� There.was a brief:disrussiani"
tt was move by C tniiussioiier Mooney, seeond�, i a Camriihssibner lAtribert to reconvnend approval of .flies
f
" request far'rezonly,g for peal,Uandegritt; subject toy'tfle i ings:and conditions in the Conditional-Zoixing,
Agreement,
Chairman ,eland said they addressed a lot of the issues at the last Bearing and he was,carifortalile with
approving thus suli�ect to theSta&. Report- as, ivell, He said there is a hat of provisions in here to reduce runoff
�►U'rrE COUim P:LfiNNtNG C(SMtvIlssIbN 1V(tNtJ I gS ' JUNE 2�, 2000 :PAVE 3
IG .0 ! F4 f, F % b 4r;lf 7"G ; f� F J � { C 4f 4 i 1'•,: 4 � ' o k �"y1 V,- R A4 F- r- l l G i f i ,�t w1 A T y 4 �'I/ i'" U .. � k
.. r 'iv ,pi..f , R k' 4y ,u`,�- "� ,'?•.. y :FI' r t : '� t .r 'eY kT ',IGt k., ,,fiW M1 a ,piq r.lv s,; r •M r'd'''h. !m !}T,;� .t r �' ,i�•it it t } 44 i ,y h ! i d.w
P
� ,,
+. �}h, ,. r:�• 4 S `V r+ t� 1, li''y4i 4) �r II rY :; 1 �t'` ,if `.: ;`, r 1'I: .. �`�9a, c. t A 5 l Ii..l 6 '� J .air?.u.•t4"u111^`AP'i.`w.'W'"(+n` 'A W" f`- .. ,,,_ jj, ''
,1 �. � a r v t w• t t i' J r, ,�4.. J1�1,,u.4+.tzi.J.6s�',.r,Fl++%f..«•'.ra�»ka..,w !� P
?w�1 - ,
r.� 5 ;
,Vol and the porta potties; it will riot increase the septc.,lo He said it
'
in ,the
and as long as they are us g gr
;. `uire a sepric s��stem He said the applicant has provided the Assessor' office a detailed
e
to re
outdbewors q
the' �ea for tax purposes. He s°aidhe was inclined to;iapprove'this reques..
'
,f
map of
to amend the mot onttie three conditions shej4suggested
t:o the
'
. otion ,adding
commissioner Gage�inade a m an a
, ad, that there be assurance o,no runoff, a
to widen`the ro'
planning Division be included in the motion,
septic. tank lie -required
k
The motion dies for, lack of a second. : r
�r
We nn the first,motion:
?p}°
,
Muoney and Lambert; and Ghairmaii,Lela�zd
;APES:' Gominissioners
%10ES Commissioner Gage
ABSENT; CoiniYiissionerNel son_-
,
RINE o one
the Board of Supervisoma dopt `a Mifii gated Negati•ue Declaration with the follovwiug
I, Recommend
,. firidiigs;
�4
` ' ` as coin leted in eompli;ince vo`iith the. California Environmental
Study w
A. Find that aii Initial .p ,-
Quut`ty �,ct, Said, study on ,' e, potential significant et�.rirorunc icant lovels,��d includes
il
below sigr..
mitzation,measures that would mitigate such effects
a 1 'zed and considered the proposer:
H, The,Planning Commission independently reviewe ran 1
to is decision on the p oject,;
` aration with mitigatton' nieasures'prior making;
rTegative Decl
mitigation rr►
-
and hereby finds that the Negative Declaration with
endeiit •ud etri en of Btitte CO ,which
T
r T T —=
{ ance and-reflectsthe-rode p g
beovi levels of si fic
-T —
is the Lead Agency.
the whole record before. the Board, including the Initial Study, and, any
'
Find on the basis of
C - that there is ne substantial evidence that the Paul Vandegrift Rezone,
-o0 the',
p
comments received, ave al si ficant effect
q g :
Planiniig Divi sign ilo'No� 12ezone 99 -Ol ras�n i ated Wi
y�, •
nien'tal damage to fish and
` the ro osed roject. improvements will not cause environ
fh The design of p _ p p , regarding impact tb fish and Wildjife or their
`ode
i
'lrllife or their labitat;;and a miniirius" exemption
vJi, 1 :.- TM460 WP will not signiel "aptly alter permitted land
is rr�commended siilce',the rezone to
ha ' y tttiliz� existing impr�t�erneiits; aiiu
Y !
uses andthe proposed �7se Permit, effectuatedh this rezone will
if -
dote m actto fi 1 acid �Vildhfe .or their
" rmmed to have a de minimus P
Lias -also been .:viousl'
fees purstiant'to Ash and Cisme Code Secttoti 7 ='ltd) )and 1A.CCR
hafiitat. The collection'of
I I 753x5, is iot ecormnetided:
Vande rift; to the Board of Supervisors aiid
99 Ol for Paul g
al' of Re
IIT, Recominpild app by zone
Ordinance<foi` the initiiediate cttneellation aitd
recomiiiend that the Board of Supervisors'adopt'an
:. rotectiri
TPS l60°WI' (Timber Preserve 160 -acre parcel§, Waterehed P
rezone of $,37 acres Froin
' "T1VI�160 lVTountany 1�0 acre parcels, Watershed PiotectionOOieriayCs
OvErla Y. to WP (Timber
to o Conditional Zomrg Agreement attached to the `Lonii g
Paul Vardegrift subject
Exhibit ``A": with the follov�tig £filings
ifN b,�1NtNG d1Vti�v1155ION .� MINU TC5, IUNu 29� 2600 1'A.�
�W
l A •' dW Y 4 .. : § 1(I 1 -14,. C ar'W
,. ti
i 4,; ' J1 r''Q4 i M'r T.• IF -0.4 d ({�• yp 11 i1:, V x'IF _aM .! K"`.A �i ,S< • f:.
,' a n I 4'.,e
r.
-1V
It
I
IM T
,a... t i I ,Y. ,fx '•1':'L , ', �.4.,. 1 s.:. e^'"iw-!a''1 '.. "i''M,,, R. ♦Yk '"nl.{IU l+-. V:'+4, SF... ",:IC}.,.•# G....r.^.
„W.a:, ra, } �, .,t,r, 4a Y,f.a.., 4 tr 3;,,W .. t.,4 J s..
v,ai,tls.Jo,.,f n�,. 4t, l.In,t,, Y 1✓„1. F..a, r. Yti lr J,..-7/
«...qda, e! - toad atMk t1. 1a..:. kar.,, !-a 1:....., x f h .,9,, t.",c� ,.�f976c. .r t
,.r, +.. t) ,+ �„ c, ,. v. ..,..Vr, }, 1st 9 ,.8,.'l «r j ,JS.„4f., dr. u. . b,. d. 1i, .ta ! fa .I+rn it...
,•.. 1',, h"•4W.i.0 is .. 1, t. -,"th ...., lk "h . t+ n..,.,,,, «{a's. i, } .',�.- r, e-...0 Vt., ja, 1 ilt r tl. f W
i r,. , j,�:•.. 4 11 , r: ,r ,ht... 41.� -., .. �,dr 74t.t. . •.,. !R t. :..,txn,,;tin, .. �r,<r,:,} .i ri ,,.1 W. ..
,, , , ... ky ., 1. ,er ,. ,.,,,r "t,l. ,.. t .,}t,. �,.. p. n. .k.._,,. .. �, t ,�}'F,. .xx xl,x. A, s, a ... ,,. 5. x l e
k -•x � , , �,, r ,, r:,, . t d ,sal „ , 1, , r: (, i i,v , �N; ,,R } tr, kh„ \ . d \ 4 ^ rt, r+Y y. ,,l; , r .s c
„65. til y♦ w... .,.wa ri ..: ,1, r , 7 ,.., :. f., ..7 ;:... Sw., J., Na!'« i+ 4";V�'wU R'`r'.. Ys .J.h7x ff(.
�, .�a x 1ry l 4 >.rwD'�k } ..+
:r'l ?iud+ w:+� ..i„•.:. 1„,cl ,t1, . 94 ,. r.. J.�, �W S4J., hr,.w..d 4.;.Y xx ,-h 1:., G, d.3r:,yr„ ,. .SP d, v,,.. . :, ,I.,.,_I ,,r?t. 'r..Klr•- •.4 dAxu. w ,. Y f. '.d ,.
, rr.a.:
ppm
xx 7.,
7 p F,J:. ,.•fin„ -t t9'i,-tk••.r jti. ..;, , 9,2 .. .�t+,..,. �'� , ,Nd'tH_t•k.k .r,. ,.. Im.,�....r. 4 A +„�}d-.. �,. i ^5�4'r , #., ; r.,. ,..,,, ; `✓. ? , r
{1,e Y ,!, t, �
i�,, Wf it 1'..
913 , 1x :. „ . Jr+' ,i t Y.. S.r • „lx:
..}va1.1 o nr, ,a.<m:eS ,+y..12. f_ ,
x t: ,. a:..�k _ rl, , d � G Y*,F: �i :� �,! ♦. .. ,,. I.:. 9 e r.. NP . 4. ♦ ,h .. r. i:4 F 1;+J 1 t1. rLS, , I,. A , T W .1^di+^,+.' �h itx �i �4 .,1, 4r r4 � :•� ,�,J:, 4 , j
. t t.+Y .i ,,1. _x• r. «.. :, x &. , _ . , ti.., 7`j
,..x i .. ,.q,. .a,. .,4k ,• a,. , , , ,. ..ff. l... .1i .i'P4., R, 7L, 1.: Nt'et- - f ,at ty{} :7 W }},h.. ;' da t ::w , 9r t n,. • 1 ",l, ll!da,r •il C p a+,. Cr ,4
.. .:�. ,.. 3. t ....r: a ,}, i ,r, { .,. } a},, v., .n.. ,,. .• "t e ... .... 45 •,,... \ . . ,
x.,.,,:.- w <� ,.1„.kl .t-.,. tl .a:, r�R,, : €... t
5 ti"f�l s' r � +,.n .a�. 4 � 'a.� rp. �t�r� .e,1.,�1 !� ,h I�q,,i + .tl\ ;r DIY, :jl,�. d ";+ s •,�.
�.. .. ,.5 r.,. a. 7,G. .: . ,:.. ,.M, y,.. .,q .. �,,.., ',. .. Y 't �Y'W!4. ,x . . ^!k'.v �t
r, ti a .. .,•rn,x , ., ., . ..: Y s a r9 .! r{ a r .. � �• Sy
t „kYr;`e�, �ta. ,. F� '�,. .t� �
,.:.'J,. Bch'
.,.., ...... }-0v. .J 5. t ... ttt°•. Y„ Aa t�{1 ,,, , :o. �, .W Rr” x.., ,7 4Wf ,1! r:. ...v.x,• {. . .. ,. +u,. „; , ,.{ .l'F.... }:1 ?,, -o. ,.� JFK ,:3, I:! J,,,r(
�,,.
t, ',x,r \ +-„ i\ ..,,:, r 5 :i n., :l,.i 'L. 1. .1: v9 ..{, ',1, t •;4J -§ •Jr ':, o u;,.�.!F
.r.
Y. , fxt,l. ir..,: ...#.. r _.I ,r-,.
� .. a,• m W :I rt. 'y: „„"pp. t ,, , , .. •r.... J.. 1 „ 9 - •n,� i F� .,. fit.. f i y t ur '.';W. ,.� t'r
Y,-.,l� ,"b' �. a,J ,. ,.... �. aw !Z , A,'.GL I1,,'.1,x'. i .../KI.Y� ,.. ,- r ', 7. -�i. :, .«':a ra r:. •t3 „y�S. 1
� . . r s1 , o. •, f ,.it. . r .. a G f ., ,d .., r: 1x..r: , h r e_ .:1 ,� 5 x n ;JJ , ,e{ :, , ;.4. I ha,,t
*IMt� ;... .,.r.,l.. 1. f. 1xr.i 'a•,..r.,rV;r,l
cit. r „., � , ,. ;
! ix d , � ,, t c b 4 �,1..r ,,, 3 �,, , ...E , �s J. •�,r .,:: r. �' . a„U . a r, ,: .I,, ,J rr }Jy . t�4 `k , r, �+: - ., .,,. r , ,...J 1 3 + {
,
(
i:+{:.,,.+•,�. t,�'�.-r. x, < t,.. si f)`xF.YL,9.4 ,,.. A, v'.'f. 4l.. .. erq .�, a3•.:.f'hti, 1^Y Y?;...ti ,.): �J.. t,,, r! +. t'lf •:` 41 i.,„al.. r: 4: r.. �u,.. .S, c ! ,:, l s 1 u,�.
..': ::+. i...,a t.y,!irx .b l., M•m,;.ti, tl "y,. .L: ..I V\ :, ,�<, ,.,. x�aY `'4.'t .. �v lt5 .. ,,,. .a,t.. .,a7 }. a,.
,A 3 . , ,.....'� �x�,4. ,a � }.n4- k• , 1.:.�i r. y --N
....,, x ,:e k... 'n... •... rFl. qer, a',4 .. �: t4, ((4.1, qrF, .. e..,, ,l... r' "3.. .:;t < ! -aa p' d,.
c;y,2. �r... t �« i �r .��CC,f.1..r,, .�.
:. ., �. r..E e!:. r..tl• ,5y... ..5 }i �J �';. p, r � J Jk r`941 e:P. 'rie'.w ^* 'il a.x �, r• F11 ;,< I
�y t6*.y
l{. � 1r1A I fe' ,, rIr I.-'},.. ...+ l.,,i: . �•��• due. }t. t'r. �',}scs} f'�r'. J'i �lr'�
:;; ., . . <"1 e{,q. J , a .,•`i ..w u.l. , .. ,,. '� f,,Wj . , , 14,. a)r ,.„ xi 14, :I r, � ,:r �t .12i: N,r�n1,..7 � J, ,d,„z- ..Y.. . �d r � �y- +r uri.,}.�li4ar,d•1!n+t�+,+,oLGex!9� li, ?r.,
x•'�rt ,�..: ,4i ,k f i..1,1 �... f�:, +.. t1.1 iV ,:;y f. vZ „ i ', ,. x d,,,. 1 a,.. ,.1 �. � . ., '� n:� ,I ,C •a ..r_ a., �:�1>!+. _ �.x
, t
�{ 1,r .'7,� .. :+ 4f,. ,4F tl, �t}�t -rt h ♦. E.V% �,,,{. 't1 r.,� , /�• a1�3{Y.1''ilii.x.., 41” r«'l+b�..,•'{y�'iaN:-t ,tr.�'& Y. ,'•,,,�
�.: ,��Il�yl.r4.�•���, i .y.. , rt, «.. 1,J✓� rrK4.i� 1�'°,u'�a�x,'�+ary . k�++�..,,.°i..'H.�'L,",ru 11 .v v �� '. a �,�,, t, ,( I qxr 4,
Ayr
y
4Is ra
J” ,• r �'� 11 r, I Iwo rl i `11,w
• �, t.J + i �t �. 'lli
lY „ �I1
1
r
5 L
The immediate rezone, `as supported by Findings A - F above; confonris to °Butte Cuun+y
13oarl of Supervisor's ,Resolution 79-20 whch.irnplernents the'proCedures for immediate
rezones of Timber-Preserveorung Distl7cts r .
, t
t
f
ecoriiniend;that a Gonchtgrial Zoning Agreement be executed pursuant to-ButteCounty Code `Section424= L
R
25.40 '(r,)� This 'agreement is made `betvueeii he property owner and County of Butte and `includes the y
follovtwingpro, islons:
Y. .Thispro�ectconforms to Butte County=Colic Section 24-2315 10 (4)(2), which requires that,currerit
N
zoning be maintained within' the 1VXagalia Reservoir� Paradise,, Reservoir and Pirhaven Creek
Watershed;;and that consideration of zoning proposals to a larger minimum parcel size is allowed
as supported by "the following renuirements, which `are agreed to ,by the applicant
1r The8 37 °acre area subject to this is not a separate parcel and is not eligible for sale,
lease or financing separately from the legal 8acre parcel to Much this. area is a part,
U-
rN
I,+.i
' cxe:ar :a "now classified as a TM 160 Wi' Zoni x ay not be rezoned to
2:
IOY8 8 37-a L rig District m
Y
allovt% the creation o£ any additional parcels,witlun thu 80 acre parcel, the 8x37 acre rezone
rsite; or allow any alternative land user
3: The 8.37 acre are Y'' sib., p p, x. s does
a ma be as
ed a se crate assessors parcel number, .and that thi
not':cansttute aseparate legal parcel of land fox sale, lease or financing purposes,
r
4: This Zoning District shall not be enlarged beyonits current sizeacres,
r ` ' ection 24-235Y1OT(,i)(3)of tli,y1TP zone, which states that no change in -
ect cont
ornns to.S
BN,aJ rhes pryY ' .I
zoning shall be 'made land no Use permit shall be is'ged unless and until the indl�idual and
. 'act of; additional sewage disposal acid surface water runoff created by newic
cumulative imp x. x o adverse impact on w;';er:qualvty
development can be proven to the approving authors to ,have'n
of tile, watershed; as supported by the following ''At rants req'itirements, which are abreec't +o by
the 'applica W.
V r `
_ f ,
1. �� z
p � tamed wxtiiinthis rezone shall be in con On,
se t., em proposed on the areacon e
My to s st .
wthrWi� Zone ;Section 24-23.5.10
a, r R
1' No gracl,tng shall tape
lace within this Zbili ig District during the wrote r months as defined ft,
by the �Vateished Protection Zone, November, 15 through
April i; in'confarmai�ce with v�rn
Zone Section 24-6123-5,J0(c)(5)f
Y'
Mb
' f, . ,Ol lshall be
,
Alf arkin areas, drveway k and shall be m 99
..t-a n
f F
34 With 2 ruches of C1as5; 2 'aggregate base rolye with Dse perrm `ntainetl to this Y„
sed m acs orda
de�+eloped
c
x y
j xoa s
ance with?: zone
2�w23;5,10 (0)(21 f f ,
R Section
'
r
standard, m c, 01 orm
4
File #99-01' conditions aril mitigations shall=be upheld a's long as the use
r.
it F
4x �:lt Use Perm ,
take's placef r
1.k
I'
x I •J �M1 :
: l :
, 4
I
l
�I•
l -
, .. "^
1- v. i..
u N ,<a 6
1,.
PA,
r x. 20
ob � .
:
w BU I"Cu COt�iTY
AWN.. o
'Ni�1e, v C Iv3��t55101� � Milt TuS JU�1 �
_�
x,1,•r,. _'f 1J d'in.k .'6..ry,`k E,f �Y :`,,i'f5 t r.'n+„P N+". a .;;g. :,.'.., ++m ,. ar'w.�Yvlvy, t \ 'b':'.a,A } Y �Ap ''fit •» ,! j.!
!u^.w �, • 4 r�Yr *
� a�, {e�, f.,,.n. tuF ':' t ki rr:a'. NJ�,!• k tr+Jl'N4rEap 4\ ,, .'r. Stxr ;'� # Yr IyUYx aP 4J"-}"aa'.4r" "' '” a'�'.. '� . .1�
�”
't It ^d I
,.
`µiciil�iTh'1�4GS�.1!1A'LRCE«tlirtd43Ystf�lviitiltxllisaYklew,:tuwsdtrt�Ge+uaur.+w.�u'».aa >M+',+du+.v'w..-t;••w±-zws+.,,.r ,+.w ». --- -ti ,r,'
r d � �
4
TM
1
yy
.1
' i e
The.property'owrier shall comply with ail the requirements of the Watershed Protection Overlay:
1
+
aT' Chander Sidtier, proposed Negnitive Declaration with instigation measures regarding '
environmental impacts and Vse Permit to allow for the construction and; o ,erat on of a 3.,300s�. ft.
r, convenience store,; with two fuel islands including three gas pumps each, and a 980 scjt ft. carwash,
on a 179 acre parcel zoned M-2' (Heavy Industrial). The properly s designated as Industrial by the'
General Plaii. Water supply is proposed byon-site well. Sewer service is proposed b on-siteseptic,
system The carwesh will .utilize a recirculating water system. 'Ori -site ""retention of ;drainage and
i
p p �Y
stom- ater rs also proposed: Proposed store Hours are 5:00 a,rn: to 12:OQ a.m. The roe is
located,on the 'southwest'cor!ier ofState HighW4y 99 and West Liberty Road, opposite; Hollis: Louie;
south -of Vity of Gridley• A N 021! 170'-052 (DB) (File # T 00=1'0)
. ,.
I�r Breedon a brief summary of the p�ro�ect ) He read info the recorO a letter from Paul Bretag,
'
.gave
rep,rese>trng the r'esrderits �.of Ilollrs 'Lane;vho are cori,erned wvitli ,tlie Sal of alcohol close 'to the;
neighborhood and the potential traffic hazards; and they recommend i� traffic, si�i oy 6 done,
orier 1Vlooney questioned the re -use of wash water and'hovw they will di •nose t i,e materialsthat
=edout of the water,
Mr. Br�eednn said it v�ould be dW, d of properly. He said it will be handled by Water'Qiralit}► Control and
l;nvionmental Health..
E
nen° t
j� Comrmssioner Mooney said on the drainage requiter i says" `all storms up to a 200 year event". He said
;
}
` he has never heard of anyone asking ,for 200 years.
1Vir'Breedon said the reason fora 200 year event rs the sensitivity of drainage in the area and the fact there
.is ari;eXistingl ` le' mm
sats, iflie was the applicant and hit with a 200 year event reluirement, he' Would
Corrimissioner Moone Y.
asked ii no;one else is required o design for a 2Ri0 year eVetit, how can they, ask for°i't in this case,
{
Comrrrissianer Lambert said the store hours are riot°in the conditions, Shea.ked iftle hours should be iii
the conditions!
Mr: l3reedoii said the lioitrs come into play when figuring the traffic volume, He said a 24 hour convenience
`
store has a;sligitfily higher volume. He said the applicant told him this would normally be a 24 hour story;
but for safety 'r�sasons he "Vvants to close during the worse times of crime, frons 12:00 a;m, to 5,O0 a.m,
Chairman el and 'ask ed;6out the re -alignment that the'C ty of Gridley is concerned about+
'
lir: 'Breedon said West Liberty R.oacl, is adjacent and north. bf the projectToll`s Lade "is south of the project
of the east sl a of HigliWay 99, leo said both roads form �r intersections, off set from one another. 146 said
the Crty of Gridley belie�+es this is,a hazardous condition and they want the streets aligiied, 14e'said the
City;'s General plate sl►orVs the West Liberty Road algtinient going tl>rougli this:ropeity and Would preclude
tfirs proaect from ticcurrrig,
■ Burr>r COUN`tT PI,A 0NG coMMIs81OI M M, tWT d r Nn �, zuoo it r dt 7
J
e
�r..PV:,'.^,' y�At75 •( •". ,,+..,. I. v ,e 1 nd:„ "!,..4,a, 4.1" :.,. .id.,.r.P r, { �:X ,.,v�.M4�k ., Ali,
{A::J.....,,. 0.A ,•frka, A 4 .'.. a da,,ftf.ed ik..t . a",k.1 . z1.,d... ea:. ! Y.,1npY . J 4 ! ,"np„.'T..�'Y4,. n i.5aY 1"„�.V ..]^.fl ,., :4ry+. .b''r:. r�;=u�1 ,.5. nP-.I.,.r::.nraryr`. ',�/T^w. 1. .. 4nr,r . ! t! ', 3.L, .,,: I h'# �. re.w."^,. rn,.i., GF,ni' v.�. !er. 1�', f�k, , ,gyp C ^t•P.vrt.,{ Yt p,1 a .0: Y'F"'.e;,+ aa w, 4 rt,, t n,� f ". '1' 1Y7 ai1 r. „l1as1...,..,.
,,.".,,:•,.y�r_dv:i
.�,
,.. Y :y�.. r v•h. n . ••f,:'F� e r Fa,Y ,,' '. n,.y , .•rw(�"V f-�5:...l wi�,tl r 1
} 4n t ��...�± N, n.,.�: � rr, I..,w, rsrtt�ia i ..,14.s�. e, a.ilG .+aol+.", _« �., Tr f $,¢•%jwq .r i Y '%d „1f'..>r1 #' a ,* 1
:. p ,, F�., ., ,i. }, 1,;;._ ..yg� q.•...4 .. i.. i .,.. h. ,W,�.,rl A. ,.{ :�r..Fn�.. .Ty.k�i3t r!. J. 'S �a. rl w..•mt1 I! t;,:., ..'.Yh,r t.a 5... �. , a, aiYv. _v d :.Y. .! �'t.. as , u.
._i'F ,.rn. ,:.. N,rr.t.. ,a zp., Y, ,..1 e>r(%1 i,w.,{as.•Xx ,.. ,., . r.u. +i,t 7 rr.;r. .+.x,i 0.''yd., c. .•. r,t ,.. ,x�.iV ,n^ „1. tl. C+:1.p.:ldrl ..,r.! y 1 I. „;�
� ,�, ,: , v15i 11p.,:. , 7 r i. ,,. ,... r. 7 ,X .� ..,, 2, Y.'s;r r L.. �r* r. T r. as aV. d .. , ..r. G .t - ! rl'.-, �. a `: - rF �Se. „ r J f.. :&;,. ! r lf.. a,. :•” .+a w r;,a.. ,
�,. 4i „1. ,, �. ...+...0 V ,'i.,-itl �ie'4:.i,a, .,' .a11.r, t:r..1.:i,"�,>�.ti`t. h�!a.tkp. .R 4.: hu.�y,9 i i. ,r .�. ",..tv r..a. ..�e .�I �,. An 1- ,... Srt•r. a.,,,
I ,,. n ,,.Y'..., la .. ,� ,. .. i$. i , , 1. ,.,: !,{h J ,w � ,..!}., n. #i t .-. ,. r..7.: Y.r. 1.. i .., ., ,�a.,, .: , .t :GIs r'„ , , '•.: `X r,. 1.:.v,b 'r •id`.9 .I i.l ,.',
,.. , ... ,.. i. � r r , _..ln 4 a4. ,. t,'., ...• ..xx.?.! ,V, w �.:.+�' + { ,,.� h i n6 , . s � .i I .roll. i .N ,} l + ,mss d, .,. 53 i ' -� r S :-.y ,,. t
,. tai Silll ..t:. ,. �Ci .x+"'P., r..,r_ .Y., ., f { Ir lr�.i 1 -w ::(.,.�.. .,U TkS. ,.: ,jyU.y u; .,t /I1$. r. .5 �. ad� .I.,S �I. .Y. °�• f1.. .,}.rw
t�, !., �..r ,.,y a7. ,n. 4C .,otii ,Y• 1. ,{ 7.. t ,1., .tjl. d i', t.tr.,f r .a:t -4• i.R.
4r 5'*i a,t s nt..+,.,(. •••',, .4. �,A% .r. '..� v' ori^.,�. 1, Yc. �: r".:; x,. L. ,' ,a „ ,*yp .."„r..z� f.,'k�l ...,. ro. '^I. .-i ,. 1'sY'. ;.vti•3. a '. alt j r.rw. y
C.. i, ,., ,1.... .. ...F ,., Y'.:..y •. i i ',a.l { • a9k:.;
,, r, ,r4•W. .y.. t.l; k. r., .-C1. 6�t{' d 4 Y.,., �
b."t. .e 9 : li. .i , a^t. ..t.. �.� ,.f ,,d:, �1 or dt 1 yif 7.
rut
P'. ..... t Sa.n._kt,,k... •,�,,,,$s ,-,<,,.yl,a.� `,1,.+,14,:.1-,r�,. a:.t�.l...,-..�,,.,.sA...,t{5 S.P,i.{..-yxak,.-.a.+C �"«w. a'tt rj rp
t'j1)(�S
, ;"d t,r"t. 5W dx ».^r,lr f,+1 5,.,,'X a'rr,;.,S•:, v ,; f,•id i azy 'y,y,l b, ..r_f
l v, t . 7 # d .A o n n'. i -: ad n i d ✓tar, a 3'r 5 �u a.
k.,. 1 a«Sr.. ti t. - (,1 , t.., rrd',. i1a . k.,, [ .c4'•«..,.. zd r: , ..,�4v...". at1,�,,.A, r na t4ad x �,. r , ir,, r rt �`•itiJ C . n n {'.,
: ::, re" ,.: tra '79. ,a .,.. ,,. +•,.a ., r i�. ,.. .4.!X4... t,. �a. .., ..., ;_..5 R4h 'rt_raxlL.Y lrs
,Y 4.. a. .^, _,.1 Y , 1...,., a. k,. ,: e... ,I. ,1 ., •n.,... .{...{. �... +V. • ... P.t ,, rot ;,x ^",. k,r,. --F.
fX..4u'w..,, v..r - 4 , X.,1I�4,•. ,l r,., ..•, :.� 5a 9.bn�.,.l.,.. '.rq. r• ':. YS ,. !,
, 'vl .t:,...: ,a, tSar�. .. ,S,"}}•1,V, h,r ..�:.. i.,"1 ,W t 1.. Y tL.,t H., rXir:c,/'..�, ...u`A: ;B,a ,r t ab.'a .,^^; •p:4t 1r,:hT , d';'it
a ., t c1 { .J.. , ., ..$. h. ". 4 n .o,G.:. , :..•. „ M1 .11v .. ..;.,. ; .t,e ,,„l "E1, It , ... 6.. , v, , „:. .. i r �� r. - ,.. G:,,1"5 .�„rn ai}.:•.., 1 1 f:;°e!a li Sj'J.. {, bi ,.1 , "..r'},i°.;r
.: 1 1.N.,t k.a�.. ,. , .,., ., .A.. t 4..., .,. .1.e ,t,t ,. x, .. .,i. r"5.w. ,. t al ,a..rri. ,,.II r. r.t r ,., *r.. � ,..a �.
,,,, �,"$. fi c•„w .r $ : ,., ..K 'S....r ,:... ,.. a +1 1,r,!•t• c; i .$ _, +, lJ� .. .t t.. .711 w. M,St Sft
i}., H ' �,� .... �. .r: , ,. .,, ,:..�:}..-Y141i v.” .R �6 t � nvr 4a . <. ,•� C .,:ry.1, r. ., .•t :•,r,.., i^, h 'p •t., '+4b,},. ""r,
•11.r. SM.:. d,. a t. 1, 1...,.. 1, :,*.,, t. ,E,_,♦ :,,.,. r'a, l.. n .,Y 1. ,r ..: r �.,:, fa
ro -.. r. l: f. ar 1. n ez r .:. kb•,r1 b„ '' ,.'N , 7 4a r.: r.. o.... r , p".I k,; 1,... 1 ._ »•:: "S . 1, ,, .., . 'ifi"
.,X ii.;lr•. �., .++�.t,, . ,, n�i. :G, .Y' ;r. :.. .Ty. c.e. nr, +.1),
y s J » h •,� V v, ..At. N d 'l ,e I l a,:,:..! 1„ T ,.ta.. ,✓tr4$r h V a 'irt� V. , �.1 .k i. r hX,•x'. ,..k M !+ i'— .. J•K. i. .
• ,, ., h„ J 4 i 1 1 i l waw'
r ,,.,.,, ,•C ,..,,r ,.�1• •I�ti._ ....,, a..l,.•,.., ..w, , t.>,.4. a at ., ..,•, ..,.,:a I .,, ...•.";..`' d ,
,,,, a... �:,{'y, �,.. r,`J•.� v .4, ,.. `+: L, sl.,,n: +� r„y4+..i,ib .v �� � .,,.,. r,,..a ,...«. t.:...�r, y..”
�t y. ... .+4 a .,rd';L•rl,i, ,d;!•e �4•;XI•;+'i{'a�" 4.I. t .aa: rY••1f. Vr,'•,.,..:.,c ,.,r '1..,.
r # ,Aa ,., A41.... r.., , ;+.. '• 1,uAY .di }w,M,t+, a, l,i; •.;i ty }r..n i.-; '�i •., Frha .Vt�„C x,. , 4 I.a `f ' .:r 1. 4: rya, a. r p :h-..% atatii:.1
, .:• r 4,:i1 ,.. t, . Y 1 , :r �; t��} ,. 1 "X . 1- !. L"...�i ,: 41 5i� ... Y^ A. y 5�. ,.yr: 1 . '” Y •e . :' l i,l ( ! IRM4;ii�J' '. "
tJ,�., r ,4,.,J�B�+.�t Y v. �rai.,. 4 •,SILT t d c»,�. + ..? '..
3fPhUi'iPt��A'uY.+.IUB'i+'4tlutak4CiGY%4i�ti+1'i«uwiiuik"'4'4lir++�.r',aranXi'1f,.ps,.':i,kiat«u.�tr."'a.u»rtl,r3: r.+tc.A «v?;:�i'Fu •n ddv.,..,.w.a.,w•+�+N�^*a`„.� naw,.,. r na..,.+r�,aa4:lrl'4""!?',. a , 1
4
)e'
T,hheanng`was opened to the public.
5
y 7 d + E
�# r,<_ k
Roger Key, tepresentative, said the'appI cant agrees with the conditions. He said. the retention gas � will
be to the southeast of the store. 1
Chander SIaid lie is aware of the road alignment,proposed in the future;, He said he�talkeii to the City
of Gridley; and hemould get.the'tand next to his property,•the old.right-of--;way, if the road\ as changed and;
the .Cty would gef hat portion no longer needed for'leachfieldsx
Tlie °hearing; wa"s closed.
}
_•
It was moved by :Chairman 'Leland, seconded by .Comrnissioner Mooney, .arid t*nanimously, earned to
appzo�e the Ute Permit, UP OQ-10) for Chander Sidher, subject to the findings and con ditions'listed below..
Adopt'. Mitigated Negative declaration with the following findings
_._
Find that an r`iitial Stud wad cor,'npletedm compliance with the California Environmental
A Quality'Act:4''Sad studydentfied potential significant environmental effects and includes
mitgation.measures that would mitigate suc11 effects'below significant levels:
t ,
B. The PlanningCommission independently reviewed, anatyzed and considered the proposed
:..•p
Negative D,claration with mitigation measures priorto inalcirig its decision on the project;
and hereby finds that the legative Declaration with mitigation measures reduces impacts
beiow levels of,signihcance and reflects the ndependent udgeinent of Btltte CO which
i§ the Lead Agency.
C Via""rid, ori he basic .of the whole record before. hv, Planning Commission, inclitdmg the Jriitial
`^R !fir. •1:. r c .:t w . k ;a!hs 1 .{r. 1 .., k e„, 7.y � .a rina.•1 , 1 S', i,t Y :i
r .`41!r d.i ;ter13 , '�•y, i k`,,h rTi' f"^.}, na. +i �-0'' 1 _ v :'� � " d is s , , r � , � td, a;. ;
n
...r �. , u, ! + e .,kir C :.% ., a,., ,q. u.: i91 ... k, - ,.,:. t4 .k 1 ! "1'.r ... h ,,.re'1, • . i 'anYS. .. .. . W tk, }.. i.'i :J 1 .Sx ^,t a ,fi i l 'ti, 5 Q'..
r.
....a � 1 { .,.,, , •.,try ,x.,: , ,'i. f. ,.,,. + .w,f,.« , �. ,+. r ,t , ,. ,. r...'S R.. 1Lq - ,A,. y -+1y 1t{elP,. i � .... -„ i 5a.., } ... , ltt.,+ i9 t .. �,
R,E-.� .tx Vi..,w1. 'a, ,,..... k,,, r..i.y, ". Jt'+...r,. 1. •.s *+,tr«.�,.. >'�Fia, ,rc t. ,.1.1,. ,o-. r „�7,.i 1,..,:. M1�r. .. re,}^ :t rltyr,.,swr �,{d..,,? a': ai.
: ... " 1rr, 5i. 9 ic h,ti5a,.,.:v.. ,. , �a.hw,,V.L.C,l:...ee,:1�ae..t,,6. b...,i.!y-7.„, .!;ayt,#. :, 'l „At•L.-r.,,..+ ,,-,,.w.n..,.,rp„,.hv .#_1),„.,r.t.tsdv.�,. 7 .,.,.r.."naY.a1w.tcP ,�, i" _.... -,'.1k.,.!.,�tM+e.a+`]:.{.{t. i., iia9v.,,..f. ,:.a '-!, ...1, .}r„:.tMk!.t+.,v ,ro-,. 1, ,,,., .r i 4.4 .,: r: , (nl.T;: `tt,1a�a.a }r,}..S's,,,1:r: iiisY.nS,. 1.r, 7 .4..w., r�.'.b.yi. �w�,Iy.a,,yAA r+„!.:ed.L;s..,... ,lt,.,lt,v,r_:6tcrY,....1,+, kp. Yi.g,1'<.n;r.,�.,e,.-.,�.k.>,�t ,c.„i..,,s.1 r,akT,..,.>.a +,,.�1. ,.x«1..i:j-.�.f 6w:i.z.0T.o�9,hi.:.»-"i,sC1.,1.,...,.:.Zd,+.,.1:;., d 1 ).,,. .`h.,.� ",lCu'.4.•..,.d,v !*.,,. ." rY..... ,v,) ,.,xt,,�,'t,",rt SVI
e.a -'d.„}..,:lC. ^'� (,1rt,( 1 �.l,,r, :v.Tr,1... 1...�.c,6nt,+' .trr ,r,:.,.h�vrrxd. .i.,tt9arwt.. ,M1oa.. .. -r,..-},i.. .,,.,, ,nu. , ,a:a.�f.a,.'I,c'•l+•,I.,4:
itt1. ,4:.P-1,-*
y,rtNd, r''aY-: .,>,t•.�,f.',,<,Y"
r �,(# . a - eff' 1'Y,z' r•r4 1ii. .
..
�, 1,.
1..,'l T,.6k,
...,. h�=!.k6...~�{�...�.;. ..� ,j,.,.. ;.w. w ,. .+ '}py�.,.d e.�y. ra.. „v.; 1e1ar,9, y s":5v...k...,,a,7...
., .. i.,..5d sl...a 1. ! A r..r1, a... ,. Yr fid: .i-fY. a i. e a. I. ,k., ,� a liM. 1,,54).iV /I .. f , ir.
Iy. .. Q,.t 1., ..>y.., '7i. �, St �.e V-
.. _: .. ... r �, 11. 'Y r''°.a r,. +.,w , wrL.. aY .6 7i -4. ,m. � ,,r1� r .,i ,r {� . �.a. r, .
g.. e. ., ,: ,i.. , J, L, etrl.>{ ts,.
i r In % tU �x. , dG
eh r..•i, .11 *, 6 tirv,. a 7 ,s„ .! , 5,1, , 1 .? . T.: w i..a.. r»:, fr.t , t t:. �, k t.,,og5� 5 -y tcr� 1 •.: r ,,:le.
l.. y5`t i` {,t. rr r 7 ,o -r a:r'=d1b
v r . r�.., L E' � ,T,.,,�y i
hs *n. .,, ,5 . �..v. �.`.^r ,a r, r. S f 4-a .i,`r:rr�
�F C t ., 1 I 44 � {{�� ' , "i
., ,.'�.-. �, 0 YI y .. M1 .. �.,1, ..' :r ,,•t. l., },5r v. nd( r4{a tF t3 •a :},Ji7 i oi.-Y;^ ..''r-5 i= a. }t:: i.. '.,.. ,,,, f1.:Y".'i.1. 4. ilv,':`� , ::•1 i' -.i -a-.
ahs:.. r 1 :61{{t:. ,•.t�, ,,... -.I ..,-..t r. t. ,..�. 1.
,e. S i4 r" 1, a1..,i•r.J..f. a,.. t:a�. ,.. { G
.,.. ., L.. kir i.ltv., qq yy t b`�kr '1r .tt.r. 11. °Y .. ,, ,. t`pp .4.A ,. . 'a^ :�a , .- , Sr+';..t �1.� n:s.-., «� nq i 7 .:.:r1r., .-7. .r,,:. 1: �, ..,;� r •'f 6 ai+ n9 1 rr
p• +.,-.....iy, .i .tw. :Y,r LS.i , .t1, .krk„ 16 },Yrn. ,A.. ,... ,..1 i,.,,,,e `.e �' :,;. ,, .�,.,., .5 1, .'r :%r., a ! a ,,, Cf}�. -..t t
m
� , 01
.,.,p,Vf ,r... -i ..r, .l. ;.:.= o ra 4 .• ,;. i, as , ... r I ; ,:'1 6< +., r., �s .. gra .dr q� a,�.y iy
. '. ;4 :..t; kfl ,f..� 1. r}ri}„1 'K ,t��. �4e ,l, i ii,.ehriti t. iz.,1?i +e .,;!1': w :,:5.,,>. i "4v; y, .:.t a t .^:.� 7 t i., ,.4 1....f., t, ,j,: e+.l. 4riixA�a.•tiv:' r.l 'q :
vin1,t.,. ,.,yy n, ,d>„ ....-.1, r, qt, ,. ¢I,x: agt t.. .. ,-,ri +k -..,a �...,.tiYc„1,, Ar. r rtt. ,5e 4•. y., .rW. >k *i. 1. luw.a}.k�diidl.. C�ra,,u
.i c,. i, fY.1v . , .', r 1, .1 r,
,. ,r; I�r t,-•, 1x �.. -�; ..+,bb .+ t;; t, f,u'v ,1, 5.; . 1 ,- S`,,,>", e �,.ad,r,.,,l. !.'t h'',���':t,+1r, :+'t d},yS ,1.n;�wy t'. ,<-r�.'�4h ,,_. tk;.ih;a"^.*.y.,.+ir•�:�,.r.,,3.4 .,,.,...lrw:.,. a W'.. : Yt:ti /r a :I, ;': �: `i
,tib„S.fr ..YA:,,>„41, IY krri.riwi',Su+n�na:y a!
Ywtrrittt�{'3�4�,'6�"+1,6:;wt`�arlirl"ltt`+1{!(lglNha:aCJ�a#Uis.NldwNki,l'.
.k�
Con'#5 Tlus will Y s orlaitate Rout g9pcsed use"
thtion an hazard :
ensure
ithat traffic caw safel "enter
and will iiot,present to existing traffic flow S {lr
2, Development of the use shall include iinproveiaerits to the street 01
frontage, including ;a
curb, gutter, and sidewalk, along State Route' 99 and West Liberty Road, in
accordance with.Dep' ierit of Public Works Conditions #6 and#8. i.
Development of the use. and on site drainage retention sl`all be in compliance with
Reclamation bistrict #2056 reuirementg for improvements to` the existing drainage? it
systems, in. accordance with Condition #4 and Departrrierit; of Public Works
ceive additional r�
Condition #10. This w 11 ensure that the protect :will not contribute to- localized
tinding: properties will not re
floo
ding .problems and: me
p
r d that Burro
drainage from the
j ll be in accordance
' iuence store -as a -Food Estabhshin
Oporaticin of the convo ent shall . v '
with Environmental Health Department Conditions #11 and #12.
f�
5e Installation of underground fiiel tank and storage o£hatiardous material shall be iri`
;1 accordance withEnvironmental Health Department Conditions #13 and #14:.
6, Installation of on site sewage disposal systems shall be provided for the Regional
�+
dater Quality Control Board's Need's for Waste Disposal from Laiid Development, +
in accordance vvitl Conditi011,015,
'f his will ensure that the on-site sevVage disposal 1
,,system accounts. for the seasonally high groundwater in the area;ano the large volume
of evvage generated by=the proposed uses
Air ualty shall not be advepsely impactod as t lit of project approval with the
l'.
7' Q - -
inclusion of $utte CountyAir Qtiaity Manager n district Condition #16 v�hich ,
rewires ;a Pei�nit to CbnStruct print to site devel' �;a at= '
w 1151
0
n
r
S k 1 be upheld by the incl
g{'ublic Resourc=es God'e 4290 '(Vire. afe Regular a t of : anon
o Califorliia Department tti£Forestry Conditlon,t, ,a ding oulldmg ldentific
and addressing, fire truck access, and Are hydrant installation;
ondit`oiis of k' pi'oval:
c P
Pla ilii geDi"vision' �
The a licant shall erect a fencer along the Union pacific Railroad of sufficient design and height to
1 s pp t
discourage trespass along the railroad uropertyt Tlie fence shall ruts parallel to the developed portion t
of the property. '`This fence shall be ri5taItetl prior, to atiy issuance of a certificate of occiipaiicy fol'
this project,
-ca
ar
2t in accordance v 11th Butte County Code l d to l ndscapi0lig6 (o)i Sip gross lot s
ercent o£ the a
approximately 3,900 sq.ft., shall be v
�tt
to Co �n Fi a T)enartment
a;t"� 'a 9r'neht6 T+o�w'�r�
«L
i
s
++ UT' JttN>r 28,.2000 1'AGIs 4
13,, TM is COU1 tVPLANN1NG COMMISSION M
t
„ ,::i
y,,.' i, re••r.. t '" a t r•xN�.: N4 r tY;t=
,it s na .'�' ,a , }; �, a u w•s. ,, a isx
s :"_ ; ` •;N tNY1yP * X � ;,I w , w � N, r 0 � i'SM a ,e -t + � �> r I f L4�_ ::
r
r '
� ktiWAM. 11i`� WxgITIW'�trkittN;*"klSt ?r1.<.wwca0.a,.a
V
fit
r
lic 3 esources Cade 4290 ire
`The follown mit ation:measires are: required to :addressPub R (�', _ Safe
g $
1i:
Regulaticn5). They shalt be completed to the satisfacti6ii of the California Departtiten of Forestry,"
}
pnc�r, to issuance of a i:erftficate of occupancy for the project (Mitigation Measure #2) '
y t
A. Building identification anal/or addressing shall meet Public Resources Code 4290 (Fire' Safe
S
Regulatioic) rt
R
B. Pro tde" ari all Feather access of"at least 10 feet wide with a vertical clearance of 15 feet that
; az
will accommodate a 4(1;000 potitid fire apparatus "to all, structures.
r
C.' The shall be' required "to meet' the California Building Code and California Fire
.applicant
Code requirements for the type of occupancyrand related fire hydrantrequirements; ,
t
g
,t� $cslamation t�ictrct#2056 '`'
l
Prior to site develo m ert't the t shall irtiti ate increased storm water.t-onoff to Reclamation
', p' app hcan
t�
.g .
g ' This shall be accomplished hy.providmg an engineered
Dtstnet #2056 and Draina" a District #1.
;
study to the District "Engineer for Reclamation District ;#2056. If ;storm dram?„fie continues to drain
itito'Drainage Disirtct #1';, the increased flow shall not increase the water'surf' a elevation within the
-District. Ti addition, the discharge from the Site shall not exceed a 10 -year pre -development flow=
rate, All storms up to a 200 -year event shall be considered in the analysis. If storm drainage is
redirected to a Drainage'Distrct #2056 canal, the discharge fi'orrt the site'shall not exceed a 20 -year
All stot7ns up to a 100 year event shall be considered in the analysis;
'Pre,
The, ”: of Grdle Iii- `rovemeiil Standards'sha11lic used for runoff coefficients, rainfall intensity;
][in-
t ' y P
and otl+sr associated design criteria. Drainage District #1 and'Reclamatloii District #.2056'shall
1
review and approve all designs and plaits. Satisfaction of 'this condition , otild;be coordinated with
r Y i i
p " men o£
Coiditton.#10, whtch,retlutres the submittal of drainage plans acceptable to the,De art
r
Pitlilic Works. (Mitigation lVleasure
C'ahfcirnia:D'- arm rtr.ofTransportato
1
a g MIti q rhn o
5 The foilowin Mitt ations are re aired by the California Depa en of T�Onsp station prior to
issuance of a certificate ofoccupaitcy`for the project, in order to address the p, �ect3s mpacts'on SR
g9 ` (Mitigation Meast re #4)
A, Aright turn' lade onto SR 99 fidni V►1est Liberty Road shall be pro��ided with a 12 foot traffic
R
1
lane and 4 to S foot slmldersY
B. The entire shoulder along the f tighway frorfage bfthe project shall be widened at least 4 feet
F�
to create a 1 foot wide area for entering and exiting traffic. Striping at the. south end of the
r , ro erty shall introduce ata` Aper to l nn velucles Uacl .into the through lane,
p p g
CSite distance on SR 99 fromr the project shall be approimatety 500 ;feet, Tlie looatiota'
road sighs; utility poles, and any planned landscaping oil` business sigtis sl'ial.l be checked. to
orisure that they.are not blocking views. 1riital location of these featu`es shall be shown on
`
r
the applicationplot plans,
b, A'Caltrans Encroachment 1'eririit shall be obtained for any work conducted iii the State right
of way.
COpLAN1V1I�1G'rblYi�Vll 'i0t ■ tviti�iiJ`rtS i 1tJNn .29, 2900' G� 10■
er;;13tJTT tf1�'C
„' ';+54. 1{ p7 :7' d' •i;i : t i i(, 7.4 ” R 1. ,. ..i•� q -..*h -. ...'y • ^' '•!rvhT. . ;,. K ''"YtA.f: ii:'I,i R1w....
. r.. _ rrr,�i t r. �'',•yw� ..9 7, da'
�' it ��1 ,, ,;,, . � �i. 1., 1 ,. R,ti! M1it �4 }1i.„ i. . a Sl t tli ! iM,HN. `Tt n Y.:�fr E 1 �' i � 14. « 7 ,.t � „I . 7 . Z l .SiGv .,
{�.3
,"��. try L�i"S y((('q{i5.kt{�4 G`i 'ub1�� ,. xv Rd k �q 3 i r 'iti ;�1 c {,� � yr •s.s.>,.w',�+-w.+—
d i •'i" ! 1•bk4MlihY4'YAvinVkySaFs.�l4�r�i-ierwfw.!^+ i
, drrt
tl !
�� r I
til �yih} '
,
4�1K54
W�"."'€:3WA�.4>slki�i�AYltihAk4NMiS��:W.iJF�iGJ�k1'MI�V.'Y�.�kMkrS.0
i }
f
ee
E A streeth ht shall installed on the West �Liberly Corner,of SR.99.
g
�,.
D w.
�partmenrofPubhc.` or s -
;
I,�
:;
r
6 Pnor to—the. issuance of `buildmg'`permits oUtam eticroachnient permit for all new or exrstrig
N '
dr" a roaches,and construct' hem to County standards,as specified in County ,Improvement
Standards.
•" ,
1i M
I.
�.
f a
40 feet of ri' t -o w
1 e _
�ee's im Y
in .f
the is, of butlamg permits deed to Butte County, l p
,
from the centerline of �7VestLiberty Road. The right of way shah be sufficient for the installation
standard No. S-5 at ali'street intersections.
j
8 Prior` to the issuance of building pei°rnits subiiit road and drainage improvement plans for the .
E
A
installation cot.structioi of the street frontage improverrierits on West Liberty Road and State
_
and'
Route;99 to 1tS 1 standard, mcludtngbut not limrted to P.C:C:'curb, gutter -and' stdewalf�and,the
d
`'
'
aired street sectiozi for arcels vc�ith gross acreage of one acre o less. Construct or: install the
p
1
req
required hnprovemdAts`:
9. Prior to the issuance of bfiilding permits dedicate a one foot''no access strip" or relinquish abutter s
t alon the "West Liberty Road and State Route 99. frontage of parcel except
rl his to Butte,C g
g Y� . ,
at approved access p i
R
; k
�draina" `shall
�� ° or a be
ion. f
30. Pnor to the issuaricet 1 permits -a plan for :a permanent'solut g
I
P go,
and a !:� �+y it De artri►ent of Public Works. Tlie drana a laps shall s
submitted to,' ., pp tl p
,
r- :. _ , _g
how drainage vVaters shall be &Wtied on site, and/or conveyed to the nearest natural or publicly
w
maintained drainage channel or facility and shall provide that there shall Ue no increase u� the peak
-
- .- _ _ floes runoff #o said chanirel or facility, _ - -
FriVtro° irie�;al�aldl
10,
Ptihl". Health Department reguiremcnts for,tlie provision of
�,
�.
11. `The. applicant must!;comply with all
domestic Vvater supply% to the public,;
[2. Ownerloperator of any proposed Pood >rstablshment shall submit' plans to Envrornnental Health '
for the approval tprior to constructions a,hd shall meet'all applicable requirements of the California
`
'
iJniform Retail Food Facilities Law (GURFFL). OWherlOperator of arPood Establis�uneiit `shall
�" ..
submit an application a1td fee to Etiviroli ientalHealtl for a Permit 0 Operate.a Food .Estalilishrrient
such e' tt "rior to.o pningi Suc h ermit.c' an onl be'ssut d after an iispectiou by
and oUtain s p� p p
k
.
4
t blishment as in fiance with Cit
I Environmental. Health verifies that the Food Es om itFFL
�i3, ` tion ofU`nder ound Storage Tanks (tJS`I"s), obtain plan approval anr'l installation
i'
Pnorao,rnstalla
peririit frolii Eri�ironmerital Health, Obtain a;pethiit to operate UST's prior to fuel sates
14, Prior to storage, of fuel for ether hazai'doUs lnaterial5 at faCllity, sui?mit a Hazardous Materials Release
``
Response -Plan to Enviropmental klealtht
,
l3 Tonal �xlateC� iii}y ("ontrol hoard
1
{
QttNT1'PLAN fINU COMMISSIbW, "MIN itJ1�tC 2gF 20b0 M'.PAt3 1'I
N
t a'BL1'I`!
,
771,
; ,i` ,' Pt" ...y�tl ^Y d 3 d d tlt:� tR iFy4 y ' 1'
��{4 A 9 r'1` V+ � { Y, t',G•n f ♦M t.. c.`y k [ a' �,t. } P w -'.Ml. i:1J 'A 1,
If
1 F•'a T',4
int, v .a > h ; 1� p'k a, r
i ..rte �v. x a t..�� nil: G •'.
C ! �� M1. ��M
y'h-
',}�y��y1Y(:e'J71r�3f�3Y�dh*i!kttMhl�E1RtiHY�fY+ts6blk`dklWu>xQtf,�,q::�vw.us.ir+�r�-L.:i � a . �.—"--WTD+•.^a,.w» �.o.<F+.,a.?.a.a+a-+a,..«»« -••, -
"
15. Prior to operations, the.applicant shall submit the `information required; for' a determination of the
)II
„ 'Regional Water Quality Control. Board's ;,(RWQCB) Needs for Waste Disposal from. Land:
1
Development Upon review of this information, the RWQCl3 shall. determine if Waste,
!!
�!
Requirements are necessary. Upon, finding thAt Wast6!n.ischarge_ equirements are necessary; the
,
applicant shall submit a'Report of Waste Discharge: and filing te`to `he,'RWQCB at least 120 days
;
befog .itis expected that any wastewater will be discharged. (Mitigation 1Vleasurc #1)
''I d
a�4 •
i�ictT1C�
A t'uality=lyfan emPnt y 4
,
` cti uct Pernut;``�uom, the Air .' uali ;' Management
btam a bis
1G. ;' Theapplicant shall o trict Authors to Con Q ty
s
District; prior, to site d?velopnlent:
Cay & Flertrle I
.Pacific
The -Pacific Gas & Electric Company'indicatcs that both gas and electric facilities arein the;subjecf _
area.`4An existing' 8 inch gas transmission line is located 10 feet riorth,,afthe south property lure of
West Liberty Road. Any grading over this dine is>subject to review✓ PG&E. Detailed grading
by
plans will be required for review to. determine conflicts and any possibl.crelocation Worl� in order'
t ' ' p'pe and to protect the pipe. Any relocaption or rearrangement of
muumum cow er over i
G&� facilities to accommodahe
to the'prolect will be at the developer s ex ease There shall be no
•main
building ofstructures or the storage of any materials over or under any existing PGBz$ facilities:
�nated t re is a 1O:,day appeal period
Chan'rman Leland hat the
6
- e Matin adult businesses the
Zoutng Code Amendine►rt An Orduiance prohibng and r g g
--_ccrtain
project is `exempt from►,he California Environmental Quality Act pursuant to CEQA Guidelines
--
Section 15061 fib) (3�. =(RW) (FILE #ZCA 00-01)
`
Mr, Wilson p.- e summary, He said the bearing was ,continued to he7r from County Counsel
,brief
regarding 'questions raised by'the :Commission, He said this amendment will orilyY allowadult' businesses
1�1r and answers submitted by County Counsel,
He briefl reviewed the q '
in the M-1 acid M-, zones, y
,uesttons
,
He 8aid'orn the Durham Pent Road site, there are some hoines n the area, He said there are no sensitise
land uses ieitt to'the.sites noted on the exhibit inap+
E
*C iiDeputy Coupfiy Counsel, said this is a published h- '1
p;
Tlie hearirg H►as opened to the public.
George .Mull said ie is the Chairman of the Board bf Tliree .Kings Inc,, tliat ;owns and operates the First
the Coiniriisson's role estanlishin'
Amendtrient Club north ;of Chico. He,' said lie had. some Coininents on g
, , .,
sites, He said that `this item,would 6e 'sent back; to staff for further "lidWoWt He said the United States
..
ConstitUt on and, the S;uprerrie. Caurt'•s intetpretatoii of .tile constitution, require tliat if the County is -.o
tl a locations of adult businesses, you must allow for enough sites available , d their jui sdiction
regulate
to rieet the heeds cif the pul;lio for adult businesses, He ;'said the courts have decided -146 criteria that the
be lduking for available sites, He said a similar case is Topaiiga Press us, ,the City
Commission needs to at
Ike ;,aid, "tle Cit of Los An tiles claimed that Vario>is sites were ai�ailable to adult
of Los Angeles,' y g
- , le, but'listed :as�
bug' c8 and `stet the'adegiyscy requirement, He said thele Were sites that were not iisa '
PLAI�NtICOCv1MISS10N MINUTCS � tONE 29; 2006 W PAO , tl..
G
r
M' )tJ`I"I`E Gbr JN'1'Y
v,
B Y �, "o dt Yi, 3 {;,• 1; 777''T, .wwi
i �' �Q v , v
''" ) 1 i I 1 11, Y A (� MI �•yC r. Y i.f,pJipi 4 1'
6
. a t'..,,, r ,Y I� 1 1 1-e •r; I . +: �y 9 ''l �Y :�:., � -0• } ,:'in f.: er r;J.t. � ,i,7f•. ,r'. ,-„'•+,
'' i'+ A `, r. ,r..';' s c'� « r-. �."` "1 11. at s ., �•)., w '?J'i h. .: ,. r .1R. .. pa j,. 1. i.., d x-rro r, ,l , ..I" „17 .i- r,4r.! dSi..V.. ,1,., r 4;7".: .1 *«c i �
+. r ,� t ., ,,. .,:, ...,,e' ..•'.. ,.. 7..f,1'• t r._r, r. ,x .,. ., * .,,', ., v.{.. ," ., .� 4. ...., .; F 6. ,'» ..k. ..! w,r ,'�'Gi7,, ,t�,: "r..,v. d YFr r7. ,f ,. .FI L
-:
,>, a.ui,..*< .. ..,.1 ^,etq ..,, ), 'zy., ,.+ .'v e.. Iw. �.5'.,i}..., �;1+,:,.1*l. ...•v, A, •{}.J �afss :.I.,#. e,,.! . « I,lrpu3V) ; ,a L•Xt' u. r�rk, :r•I” i ,rf'1t` „).Y.r r,... �,. 4, ,.� ,J .. .1a.
# f r r.,.n;. I.y.:.. •4. nr r,i ,:)W \'4 r a .B. 1 .. .} ,,. ,} .. ,iP..-. sl . a:,;P: x MI : „R :i.,) 0.,.k,) .a Y,=� . t.� „v+v
,�J,4,...,.:,.a..fr,...1. 1. ,:.,:knrs,i..1..,, ..,,w�-�`+t",1<.'�s., v,..,t l.. I.. ri.,rr.'n{. r,.,.. ., .w4. 3* t��J1let;, $,r•' irr fia_. e, :,�
i 4-,-.. k �. r.. .6,. Y.. l .,, .. «„ ; :... ,. �.1..«. +. 4 ., r., i _«k(... rrt, ,.a ':k � � ....d ,: ru a. I r.r .,x,. ,.i,a r 7, r is •, a1'1 ,h:'.• �.',
+t > ,..�Ar r- r t.. ,,l 1w. ,. 9,a.it,,, t S •,-''n.. .+y,, Yf" ril ,. > E gg ,t 'sd7; dri r X. .t3. � y� ,4
.. r..
..Yt.,
.,..n ,' } , # I"i , < ,.'r . ,a . ,...< »+i, n ,, , ,.4r ra: , .'"w' �r. f'.t:�r,r + r , q., a• � �
.. ,, iU.., .ah 1 ,.. r✓.. a:a.t!� '11. ,l,v. fag r .. Y. Y i +. a, ,, +, u�t, :( ry4,(i, 1 , ,,1 .:" .., 9. r+..l k h.. :r n�s.i ,,y I.� 1 �.x
.lF.,,�ra. <. H. �,: <. ,.H. pr _t.„e d t. ,:.�'.. F. ,.:,a.a. .r„a, .1.d''n t",r +.vl. ,. ., ar A:. t`. .n•'., ,, I= )„41':
�
.,a,u. ,,..,•.r -,.!L.,+ ,E„ y.... ,.:#t , .,. .,w,.di.r e m.-. ,'l+b..r,.n: dir.,( •.. f+ t '�t s. � 'S. li ,i. nPE., ,a.1?r!s r"' +!• riy f 1::.i
k.La.. r•r
.S' t'i..u, rIL •v ti., ,F• �r .t. ,rt�9 ..0 t.l #t: :f.
�I ,..rM1 rV;• ,�„,
�, ,r ,+r .j
) 'hp
f1 ,•,..,/'�l:l,a
,...e .,Vi ,.,i. - , . R. ..,.S,h. ,;+,R .. u3 ..i� : ! .,,, . , 1" w ,,. ,.., 4 .i....,t :...+, �r... r f 1 :..,. I t .,....: : 5, i P°•,«-rrJ • r + + n , t r # r>r7p"+ot=
t.
r:, ,.n,
it 5ra i,f, r: "..1 Fl., �rkU
4+ -r , s.,. -., �da vr� ,. v. r Fah, ,r .t',5t. 1 , 6ra, d K'rfr t rl
M.r Ir-, „, qRr,r.r,',,1,4Y1 1 i:.r.a .„,y e. ti ,t a )�_ .. r n,dS,
: 66 i. .1
..{r:. a ..R+.�-6 �} ,✓t v^Y al : t 1 d "t "•S r I r, i.. . ! �1
{. +d.. :.... n/..i , 't..! , r. t 19. a t I -'•'s @ a L�..'a
•FS -:•y.. :+4�rr. .a2 air r1 ,,'� 1,i` y7.nt.+1, ,rb 1: 's r,',.',:.» r. a �,.w.'IIJw'. }
l.} ti .4 F:(*4 �.: 1':(5: l.,.l.i 1 .J' flrr f. .i.5 �} it ...i : y'0 .,j„
q r
'''M1^4
:I} t „
,q ..,:1 � ,,. ,,.�.. r 'Y :�:. ."• 4}.. ,,. .1', .P I 1 �:, ..i 'Y1w,�r.v 5ni i: �i.X YF 4 '�� 11 N9,r4 %
.+7 1.,vgg ,.,.Vs v`•ti, ,i. E. t,.,.:, 1. ;,.. o, .. s.+ {. :,,.:fn4}Y.6. `r.: Kh. 4'�r�i.lriv ).,»I. ;tmUwh x ��4.'t .�, 'ts.. 1, i, �,,. ., r4,j , .ry a,,,� .,. a�,'', 6.,b:,ir.:r+M,i�%du+>rlt4•`±.We�.At,�nhf't- r� ,;..'
•1•'.�(4.:•,,
w t�"', (:wiWulvrnLau'i�t ! �;�.� '4 e t'�r bd �li1J::iw tn+t._..W(,.Yraw aus.=i+-gym"-wu:..,--}s-`j •---m'I'Vt � t 4 1 '1
� "'"`°i'ti' rr ;:� r•r"q'1”. � � I �, r Wry' ' it " � � } }
1F�i
It”
fusable y,He sac L objectivecriteria is whethe -thesiteis-avail"able fornormal cprmbttial retail busiMeS',
are' there Certain infrastructures such as roads, street, lights, idewalks, power, sewer;
i� other words ;
!`a.elephone lines, available. He said a vacant lot is ,not considered available. He samdr mn analyzing the M,-1
and lvi 2 zones'mhere, are 'only 1 or`2 sites ,available in Autte Count).He said if,that is the .case, this '
.. Court because she Coun• has not rovided sF .
�=;durance wii�xrinot hold up in co , , , ”, ty p ufficment available sites. He said
m the case of walnut Properties vs. the City iii` Wlnitter, the'Caurt viewed the City of Wlnmtter's claim that
there were 3 available sites and the Court concluded that this Was'yvoefiihy inadequate and that was for a
city of 81,000 people, He `said it is tfieir claim that Butts County Inas not provided for a sufficient number'
of availal,l�� cis. 1 Te Oaid the interim ordinance can not c ^ used a second time. He said if he was to get an
injunction; the Coiuity would be without an ordinance for aliproxinnately W days:.He said if that happened
ry,
he would have to consider moving clo`ser't, town. ''He "said the First Amendrrtent has been a ve good
corporate citizen+ He suggested that the `commission recommend the Board take'ordinances 3X45 and' 34$4,
'rework the Ebnt page and turn it into a permanent ordinance; to getthi9 passed before September t t h` fIe``
said at that point the pressure'is off of staff, who ci ,then take the time to come up with a constitutional
ordinance. ''He said ori Page 2 of the Ordinance, W6, it,talks about legislative:notice: of Jt stice Souter s
concerning opinion in Barnes vs, Glenn Theater, that the regulation of nudity is -appropriate to further
govemmenfs important acid substantial interest in preventing prostitution, eXual;assaults, associated crimes,
and other "adverse secondary effects. He said when he argued the case of ]daps A&M
vs, City of Erie before
'united StatFs Supreme Coltrt, 11l1
(I/99 one of the first questions was,> "ms"'this a lavv of general
Y'a application7" He said this proposed ordinance is not a law`bf,gerteral applii�aton. He said Justice Sc�ritsr
apologized for what was a wrong decisoiv in Barnes; He said S ustice Sower said "in B2rnes you could rely'
g + yin. facts. He said irn Pa s A&M J e Souteh cir ucarl t
effects, Without lvokin -,"Into the underlying g ,y p , ustic
ori second' `
stated that "no'' you mustlook at the underlying facts'as far as second . effecter go.• He;said the nint `
court stated in the case of Cab vs Getsaii C+�unty in 1986; that sap County could rely oii adjacert.citmes
and counties studies. Hesatd there •were no adult businesses in this County before the 1?Lcst Amendment got
liege and they have' been here for two years. He"said there are no secondary af&0 , fr yin his''businesst He
.y;�i, ,, +1„� r Yrl;riarice_ as far as . -a denial of the, permit application, this provides for prompt expedited }
judmClal; CeyleW under a i dw code settlony A r or ma + + -_--
, , does p'irst Amendment Club
t
' staf�to revise thig. ordinance+ He said this ordinance not grandfather`_the
With 'd
in, He said this ordinance needs more +rhoughtfitl analysis by staff, 13e said the ordinance talus about
by 'S'eptember 16 1998 and the First
"iii a business that was, existing ori l in operation
grandfathering
g intoopera eratioft until October 22 1 ' A ' Federa,
y
Amendment did not y o p 998. He said the btou ht actmon;in the 1
+
Civil,Rm hts fat of Section 1983 1964e He dlundi�th ttorneys
Courts under the g :
Yin :'• ,r.".
erns with this Ordi
d by the County, if the planti,fs Win. H' p nances;
£
ees are reimburse
f
and alt he heeds to do is-ut�in.on one'or two. He said it could be very ecpensive for the Gvutity�
r
E
Crmmissier Mooney `said if he understandsIr..Mull correctly; tine Courmty`has to have parcels'n IVlull
f�;r them; they don't Have to go OU and 1Ynd a piece of land and rezone it to 1VI�l or 1V1�2. He; sand Mr.
is telling tliat'the County Lias to AvelyIVI-1 and 1VI-2 property iii late for them to tti'se., tie said lie knovVs
p..p�y p, r
c
developer$ that are going to take the; secondary effect of the lavtrsuit and say that their First AlYmendmer t
ofprvpeity,
rig}ts;are being taken her"e because they have to gv through a lengthy process to create a piece
v�;hereas these Adult:business j�eople just ave to say they want a site and it is provided+
1';r Mull said t6y are not a enlpt franc the process He skid a typical business that wanted.to open in this
County Would,go to a regular'G"t ort done, resit its' and open:
Cottmi ss oner ; ooh- sandy" `dor he would create' a C�l or'C-2 zone+�' He said that wuould--be them
YTc said what he is hearing lvtr, Mtill` say is that basically the thing about the availability of parcels is that
Butte County does not have enough parcels available He:'said what lie is sayii7Q' is,there is 9, lot of. land hitt
G
1i. CJ I"I CC1tJ1 rY 1'I}ANNI C COIVIMI'g1b ■ VIIN[1T]xs �It11�>r l9, '0004, PAGE 30
�
,
J
'.
. h n., '<•,. it ,: .',. p,..a , 1�:;` o.;yfrr. ^...,. ss„t rcL , ,tet :rS"+.. 4 ;t .. Y''' .+r., .:.: f. L ,....,.',.1 .t} v, , i ry ,atiii ,.ail, � J jYI fl I,. L,: fid, I^,,. Ste .a;il N�'r
:,.. :, 11. ., ,..Y.. i t ,,re .. n.,� [ ... +•,:. I, Ali, .+.+,. . :.,•::,:. t{;y 0. :roar, n ^ .,�!: a.,i. u„ i en , �,.ta+. y i ,t. c t i •}'•a, :%:'•,, ,
!.�•, `*,, ,.r ,f.�n� „., .,, ,, k r -;., , .,4 f :,..6+. ..0 a _:.p i..t,,::a, N r , it .,.L .i{°'! G,.'.�y1 d . a. S.a ,,}<%� "' } "d. t1�!
t u,�qf� 7 , ♦, Qv. 4^.n ?� 1.� t, � '+i�r: J.�;-, ri�t� 1 h 4 lea«• .J dt , . i.,,:t
�� of wS'd S .a rY �1r. pha"' tirk., ; tr ,a .M,,
o, .9a, .I ;.,':; l st r , .�,. ', .?t,. o a + } ,d, X
, :•4. ... , ..11:1 0... _ ,. ,1 v w .. .: +4.,,. ..,. " .. rf ., ,?,.. .,:! , ,w,., -a. 7. ,: ' „i'-w.i�5 ., a,"r a' #rt �• i. f 1 ul 1 r.,t.,td' i I :r,.'i� t a -r i t.r w r�i;l
. , +,t,.t+,. o .y. d. ,....s. ,o: .'al.,,y., :r.p ,. a. ,w.µ kv :�, ,:,,,,. rflyykP ,.,. v,•N'u,i,, .vAi, •.t. .«y.m •,.LY,. .Y'ik. ,I::a', r •rf'( :F, +, u
r .+._.+I, .,.,: .L a. -. .�. .il {,., }'�.) }r. „Y,.t: r Y.• , tt rY n S. a +111 .., -. tct.I,I et, .yV iwY- iI• y" ,rs , x.. p Y e,"�'•,r•
i�,•., ,,.. � c , r ,..� � , 4 'f�.f i I.
t ,9 Lhri "� ", .,... V, -,, 1. .1U ...: fr t... Jul ..:.t r.t, ,r Jr1. t�,:r ;11„f Y r: +,4 'yM `+ t+:: r •� :•.:4 `` ,:}^. �, "'. a. , .. r).:'?. C .?t., ,YdJr Nt.�
'1;:. u. u ,.".,1,..,-' 4rt7 =r,:, 1 v,t..,,.,, .w1,.M#.,, _y. "1. +n ;,r„::�I f.: y, 1
jiY.... r1ys..w..r.-7 �. ,.,v.. h. ,4 .5,. ,,,... ";c.!tt' t�"d;..w. 11 1,ro:.,, �..tt.ar' 1 t+-'* r
p t .„ a t ,t •..t t a?,,,• , r • ,Y :,,t ;i Y, 1 ,,,. M t1.J r"t, cl
1 ..,::: r.. i -•_:, kr .,..., i1 .;, .:. a.r1 1t,,''��tt .a..rk�",
m'" r .r;:; . x
7. :e:1d,, .,'tn_i i .•r..
t tt
ww «; `Y a -1 �. J :'r•,{{'a ;yr Ryv
.4.�. .+ .�
i
I .. rl{4 1 a ^'i, -,r ('-',, � 1.,...,::. 1 s .,.y �., :,•¢.:c .. ,,yr 1 k�,*".. .... 'ks \'.+.P ,� ,�".y r a ' a n .t+: lY.... 1 Y. x. ,r# i #:.. ±.1C� Y, 4 l{+'t
- t7.: .,, ,_,. '�• .ro +1i t.. ti;: t r,,;a�l-t i. :,,.1. 4;� `4 S µtd^�+?{ t.n:r .w/e,gly 3..1 td {tdr' 1. t,. 1;.•1 r F,.11:1 � r.. ,ryr ,f.: +-rill t `•�+' t + �ie ,r, Fs.` t v,..;+1,'.
„'. t $i �::-+• ,i �., t n:.(*, ,.Mfr.,,, i ,..... , .• ,. a � ,,,.,x;!,4r ,5.. •,, c';::d � �+.+ ,. ! is „,, :' ! ,.. r!, sa k�;,e-, .,. .;q'}:. , ,r5. 4 1'"I t x .t� t"'. a. ,e a' tt u" '. y,i1"::.r.
�1 t ri,,,.i.'i « i-� F.µi., rt a ! ;.t... a, � t, f-.;... t d 1`�.,..4 .vt� 4 : 7 � ,. F':�' . !,°i.: i, i r , � � +r, f t , 1 ti �� a x".. J : :a I 1 r v .8-''I :� ,�! .>r•:.tit 4'" �, tdt
y.. t.:i� t• ly 1 Iu,t� g " la .. :, a: S t..,l{Ir ,.. s t.. ,. r �, ..,.�,. 1.I. 1 v„ {Y .1:�� 14 ..t,., '�N 1 Ih�: �L,�(L t,. ,l iy'e l",.j
- t1 i`..�1. (,: . tl.,..,• ,..r ra ,Y, n,l,.,.rl °;r:;1 =.r �.,a*+ tk ,1+ w, r. ,.y,l x I,. ,1 'M1• ( t i',al *SJ.. I:. ,y, aJ,,1 �! r„ i. 't +{ •t:.:za';;:i
.5,.,�;..: .:•. , +4 I•„ r -, r 4 t .> r t a •. ' n31.Y ,%° . « . ,-�..;.., i,ry w. •ij::N:¢', i , 4i +,, yLr Al ,4 .(I !. Ln }' 1 .»ii�5-ir+?p.,diti+.S nai;l�a/si,AM,.#RtLii7A/:6ry,.5y�# f
1�id�i'44;,L`diL1'!t^�f��tlUj,4�'t
rt {
(�-y tr F r:
„
Corirnmissio.'ner rrIooncy said the'' Corninissio' is here to do a zoning ordinance to protect the pub as a ' 1
y
whole who have a first afent", en right, acid it. will not be petfectr He said if they do not ilk, :thdo rdinance,
it will be chall&iged and possibly changed, and then you move on.
l
r -mance , and e " th` or
1
Mr. Iviuli said then the County might end pp changing the o rid p 4:busu7esses, k
ins ea of one: k
Commissioner Mooney said he did not. carerAJ He said if you want to, go there, they have the right. to go �Y 1
e:
then �7
€ J
1VIr. Mu .Comrnissio�ier 1VTorr_FI-y if his constituents lows that die does not eare, than when you result f ,
in more business rather than less, they are goipg to be concerned that he does not care; that the Board does I
not care; that when by passing his, al ohol,can go in and people die ori Highv,ay 99 that you don't care'.
He said he thinks Commissioner Moonoy wants to :say that he is a thoughtfuIj onun ssion member that is
om `to do the'ri t:thin , to o back and a •� ,I ;
g r I ,. a said stafhas failed in several vt s t dolhe best tliingv� and to pass the;best ordinance y r
the can
pass; , H Y
Commis
Mooney -said the public has a right,to their life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness, I'care about
i
t to tins plire lY
that, He said he.bbelieves that if the pub i wants to go to lis place, they have every right to ;go
ll or the right not to go,
Mr. Mull said he totally agrees with Commissioner Nfooney; an d'he' agrees that there should be some kind ,
ofzoning. He said there are places^.where this use isnot appropriate such as next to a school, He said hat
you have now is lY1 1 and M�2, and tte �irsb lArrienthnent :Club,' and a restriction '7� J' feet away from bars;
churches, schools, .eta He "said this ordinance increases this", POGO feet;
4
Chairman Leland said the iriteri
�yj I h y '� F y�r.v r .✓,, 4. 1 F @,9, t } :: p4 It 1+x `tt'Y 1 n•�: IIt •r + ° {. i, tl" 11 +,+ yj
i'V4 ,: �1x: ;:�,"•.a>
a�J� `„k "'..
':•. k ,� .;�'i swr . y:. .. {..,.° lLL1:lr:,+tr.! t „I. ,i ,t,_.. Vhl .'„ aw.i, t, �°hy r +.,1,, 3 S yf � n.l". t „ :1� < „ `+.�� a {, .ter° t:..t �,. ,. At ,'k�� .r ,,,,
,nIf:
, a t.. ,; a.,
n...i. . ,;llr Y,f.. 7,. •e 4,';bVr Sv t ,Ir j° �i:* 1 qn,r a ah•,..:' ( 1't„
+r,9, !W! x .i, :.,!°:71� I u° i.' S,1 i."t 61. r :+rti°: t rf1 rh .'Rt 1, 1 1 ,.'i .A."; d, 3C 1 t i
,,. ,
F ,l.. °F fFn, ti u,l tl 1a `J c�5u u, }V S" y Itki i . s R, t � r t '`va , � '
,l1,
,' {r., E. i d •�xl. , r•
yy tsI e w ri,, i. a 1 ippt ',� r t t, `, A1.9VW�.Mae'.!;,' , Wr �t I� >+�?7t 1rA+o+.r ,;wry,.;,i�? t�r WF! FfI i:R.sv �i•:s rJ�g..z... li ,Ntaxi1 �� S ,,, r1 it, 0,
tome
re S•r ! 1;,I. ± r I ..iSf+ t I, ,-u ' I +.
t
,'a ...,; ~ti a,,.)1,,4; ,i';s+:., � "+:.t,,,-�.in.,94 aI..M...L,d ;°, a,,>tir..: ,,,1se.'<rl�;, •++=+eYt yti,µ+ � t
c , 1 •. i , y,tht,,. , r \.
4,1t
..c2`1
a
,:i'9V + tr ..,,'. it ..r•. A 'atf r:i r , Y AF ! 'k4+4r:++r++it+?+•'-'iWi�+v :.�
L+t s � , Y ;"�po ,VY .,1,.ti�ax �`1 .wr•L+L a.,a ' pV t>.v,ltw,,.w!,ee,n+.w,.,.,«rnr�::, ru.l �+..,+F^+.%+�+ I' ,�1
ra Gii1±t� +�j13ELIG'tGit �rwlkt'i iai,.1�L1�
u
f"
i
I
4
rid of or hurt existing businesses it is better He said when the Supiem ,
Court in", on vs American Mini
heaters, Justice Stevens made it very clear: that •f. a new ordi"r ance,v.�oulc substantially restrict or put out
Of•busiriess, the only existing club, it would not stand. He said his us ties
`sho someone else could open G'
it is true`that there are"enough.s tes ,to open adult business+,s t they w.znt to, +r l 1
k another" club in this County: He saidrif one, club is grandfathered and has full nudity, and the other club can
not.have full`nudity, `the oilier club will n'ot come. in. He, said, therefore; iFthey go bac. ,, I change this "
„ ordinance to 1VI-1, M-2;300 foot away, 'front.door to property .line, it would probably pass a constitutional.
analysis. He discussedhi"s Vested rights; in the First Emcndment Club.
froth, the
ted
, I7 .:;
Chairman Leland said 3f the First Aniendni�»t `Club is �randfatlieredr' anddthey �� 1VIr.1Mu11 to say tl at'
operational restrictions, but they are imposed on other busi►iesses, did he un ,
that itself is constitutionally suspect as an impediment to the other businesses. °r
Mr;1VIu11 said it, is not because: its G?ae',same.as a restnctxon y�tt ';�,�uuldplace on a timber xarm or on an
`industrial park, it would not affect the existing businesses.
Mr. McCabe said li'PMbelieved- CYiairinan Leland as
the question whether Mr. Mu11 had any problem with
4p
an ,of the °operational criteria that are proposed, and rt i5 proposed that those would be binding ori his
Y,
business` and any oilier business wider the ordinance. He asked Mr. Mu11 if there was a problem with any''
of opera1honal.onteria�,p,:nposed
eetly
1VIrY 1Vlull said there are two criteria that>;he is opposed to. He said the 10 foot separation' een the stage' "
and the audience; with a 30 inch high railing tris a barrier. He said this was a long way. 1HeesX pence for the
the atiiourit of floor space,available for,entertamment ai d changes the :entilo, nature ofthp
here' en le`Won't goy He said. t also restrlcts'any kind.oi;�ipping He said this is how the dancers �
point w p s and the women keep all their
5 doll' i
make their inci�ey: He said the girls pav a stage fee, from 10 to 3 t
linw'tliev earn their living, He said this Orcliiianc i places a permit re utrement for
:.: � :r; . .. :.[ ..,,. ,:.,, ;, '.r , , �, -,..: 'r 4 ":..�': - .'. ,; .. , 'Y V. '+u '-:: -_ :.3';; -, 1 ::.^• :.! 7 , r'7'0i `.b-,' y. ro Yt.
4 ik r,. .t.. t r `•,: ..1 .+.v, 7.1. .t; .h. 1 ..,rt ,{r. x,., x ;al ^i,, ,",. ,. 1i e:r 17n. "1. f.> -.�1 .tx..,rsrn.f
rla, t. v H r �.:., G„},: ,:: �n 1. ,!:t,. r:.e ..r. Sla rab^.3,• .,.. �.y r. .,. ,. .F .. ,..,-.,1.
„,. r., o , , ,<< � <;, :,, 4„ x.,, _ k,r i *, , ,, y ,., .. P• yt x t .j>.. .qe, a r.,
,.. r Y�r.. i, u I r t ,� .:,,: ;. ,.., „}r k i r�-41k , I '' ,..Il ...,. y . ,.ti 'u rv,, k M, G . r 1 r ^I 1 t s4h',-'!1,ax, ic. •, � r "'?%,;:
,� 1a. µS6. •s. 5 �}},,tii !. ,y4) ,l,= „;,�:ftk � !>°,,t ,raY�,'n• tern, �',r„ 1 ('�� i �i?c` rf 7r w w r
:.4 .>„, 'rr; .}. .: ..,h„.. , d.,.f .., .. d,_. a,. ., ro.•' fr. ,F. ,., .;: 1 ti a �,a el_ a,i..t 'l. 'a t
S ,t...., t �1tt a. .er, s„ ,t,..r. ,•.:,. ,. w.r-. >,,.*�a. „C r9s.:✓b. w rf+r! ,"+a�a;' t „i., 1,}{y,,:X,i". ns`;xtj .;5•{ .11,ar,.:• 1 «r ('�', rr `",
.� t, ! 1e._+.,se + fa 4 ,ac ,ut.,:: k �., 'l.l`6 y ..i,,; . ,, 1wr r.. ,lx.,rr :IK. r•� 1. ,�t it :! 1 s, l,. ..F Ip ., ^�h dd rr .,,.f'
r"'Z'wr.:,.*',r t 1 r. ....0 t„= : •> .,_. � , , , .,ry : , 15 r t
G4 a^.t. -u1 .« "Alr{, 1
.:::.^ ,, •;emu.. r....,a.�. ,�.,.
..,„7, �}.,P t, i .,.ittt�:� ,, �, t7;:�4kt,.,�,.„. .1l• a, ,� r. ..�7 ..;r4,i}. a.,. t't,i (:::1
r- rn 4. {.. y ,44rw A, pit ,1. 1,, wf- 7 r5, :a r• I, it,. 9 „h.. } ,L, •�.: -aC�
:AIM
.a..1. ^ :_:., ,. . , !.7,•1 7 ,;t.
)... tl i :. 1. .:1. die :.�c wib :,.. ,,.<.9 ,., qq-hi, 1�td, �v. }. t ' VS, ,. , t :r
•,�4 ..i, •.d,.:e. l,x,.W, .l,ra •t� �. i.,, >nj
,.> f ....,t> i."ra G n 4' i v . t^ 1'r°Y•
..1.. ! i.:..... t.. ... ., r, -.t.. .:.k1 a., +„d. `4 ':)i, i�A qq.X,,k 11''.„. °,- { '1, 7�;, a. ra. t.,,}.: I' ti h+ ,"g:7:•.:
ddt r ,r sr,^t,} , .x.. ,ti, .,t 4. }tin •, t ,+4 ,.«lk S w Rrxi,, „au.,,aij'... 1.
1. Mr , , t n. V a a, .� ,..r 4 8... ,. •h» r- 4 c , „r: +1 .4;'h r1 1 g=�' 1.. r .r�t da x . , �) ,,l�.r / a k d 't t1 ,4.'.'.t:3+••',
�11r•,,. ,r.g,( 11 �}_-�,,, 1 r�,,..:a . . , k,"r y ,.,.,{{, +.f ,•,,,-,f t ! }Ny l ,• ,fi .�,.y , ,:. , 'f ;,�'. q �n +.r
(,,f'l.•„<,.; f,,. 'S. {.. n.. .. e .fir i. ,,., �. .ly ,ia 4,n.. t.d 4.r. f }': +',a f. ktJ „wr 1^.i'F 1 d �4 ,+ :'F ,,+
,h r,.a4 1111\.i il,- It` 1 f ' . o r.1 .: ,. t ,:"; r. b ,. ", 1i,...y 1..r r �..,. :•�:"b r ,{, f ,.'C. YI. �.r,, :il , F ...��,�tt rj h
:� .:. ,.. �. ,,« . r5 hy+ htigql i l-... «.,: x. 1 r., '7; r ,`r r,. :, � � y,m ., r.:aw ..7^,: r�,f ! c,C ,- ., I x.��l . •„s d., {r y l a r •+flys
e ; ,:,. ., 4 � - t.e :., .d a• , ..,.1 n.., < 1,� :: r5 . , i. 7 i.t:rt 1l J F': , , , ,.. ,.,, aVi4,•.. .,.i. � „ .,,:: „ +. ,:..,. +,..:. ,, g {{ .. ,°: rr'rC " � 1:'_ „ n•e•�:' l � f ,,`,k` !i r.ti ,'ill 11 Ydr:r 3
1l .., :•..w?l 1, k. wi„ ar gs. a .,,... .. � u4.t n., tf� 1tr. �,[�_ kt. .,, x ,.,: k... . q4 , ..._.w r n .9' x -Y. I,.. ,. f :l6nq �. i;: r,.ln ,! r:' 1 xf ,"i ,tr Pl,'h
. ,w. .;t 5 �.," ya + , Yr 1_, ,, '', +• , t k,.u:. , z r =+a1i. , a ..,4 5 .. 1^ . r �x'aafi.. , y..l, r .,. , , .. , 1, l t ,,, .,,
.r ...
F + •, a.'t : a, � V �. . >r f n:'.
,. : {� � dv ,.,.:A,:q. .,Y, -:`I•.. .•t 1;,. rS ., .., ,:,,. a .x, G-'.tl57,y k, .., v.f•, i'rv. .k ^,l`?h ,:.,...,. i,rJ..,,,. n.4'41«.. :.. S`` n ,• ^V"!r m:r tir. a�e+6�4�+`..6 ,, :•�,r
- 1 d i.., a I , ,'k,+ • t,t 4 1,l„ _. , +- 4A.,. -t �'Frvl r;. .4 �j��,{r^;,.., .rif^. :.,., �S ., o_:c 1�,,.,� ,.:+,to " Fi, . , ,:� . ,, ,..,, � :.,w g/ ;} ., „h..,_2pr„ ,r+ a , 4'r+ -a, ;.
t,�..,. p,, a ,;d�. ,;F. 1,,Gtll , 1�>.. IS`x 51,I•.rt .w 5 1 ! Irsl:.,.m'� H ., ny'i4 ;i:S< ,�I.,� ., :.. . a ,«` Yat y c
jN: ,x�+f ;4`'.4 n'- 'i'. �'� a, '1 .' -},l�l-5,i,11�r,: F��}r :e v ,. ;!, i,t 4 . ,,I �rf', 1 3. n. � •n r `ai,l..,� t «, e , FoG.:.r.«.. j !}Yka! �aw:r•b>,i,.y�:wt x�..e..+.,i. ,d 5 ♦ } 5:. aGw:?
i 5 }>r �yAf"1AM4, t ,.1 Fk� 1 a� n ° 1'fi 1 ,.dl} 1`+„1��,�1�.•l,ti�� ,sl,k�"r• S ..{�rM�41..:.+,a,N-+rw � �.;. ,, li , ^:
y� I
��ir � �} u1 r(r •� � �1 1� ty �k
I :
t r
as oke aboiiit itlwas on someone that was fired when
Ver :Mull sa>>'ct on tlie, drug violation that Georgeann p
r' s
e, found.out; aUout` the violation' was prior to the man''SJ`emplo entx the sat
4, He said the violation
f� n Where was no connection with the club He Bald 4N
wa 1 scrmeonitunxedrm a DJ for'possession m his own hom �x
as':�no violation with Ai3C. Ike said the comments from the'DAil office are offensive He asked the
t: isten to the dribble and scurrilous accusations fxorii' the DA''s office �+
., ^.Commission to no k .',
,', ht want to confer with Nh i ;Shanahan, contract
r�Ir. McCabe said oii some'of the;pou��s raises today, they meg ursue before this goes E
attorriey;.before this goes to the Board.'l�HE said some of the legal issues they can p
Tre said one of the ;questioris raised by 1Vfr. Mute was'whether^or not you have: f direct
,��
:F
I
r: r uRw r w.
,n, v, .!6•.. .',..»,� "1 :.r ,.. , 1 �.. ,..,'�.:.,., ! 4,.... '. �... it ` t rs.v: t "': dq ,"w,:w y'r:. , i ,{V,. r a_¢Vq 4.f ra, ,::.;.., 9�{,.. .„t, ",i+ w-4x11 l;S .. P,. a r.,tY .3 ,d. ,r „t l 1. (,. m. j i ii r:
;:: r�.�"fn .. 9 r r,•* : , . °, 4 ., .', .,Fs ,, z - r a ' ' •.`!Lyr ., .,.. { ,i - xa, .l � . 9,. a” t, .t. �t 1', t ~<! � � r.'t w 1,
.1
.,-.,.. ,,:. s.. ,. .:.i.,, n.,..Y ,i„ ..,: 5. ,.w �. ,, . t. ,-. ... hj. ,..,;,.w u,g;��'vw :YA'C, e.n,v, 1 r.�. 'l: F.,.r `np S,Ipe',, .-r"': � ! ",a d• i..+d 1. �1. ,V't, f;,,.+ H wr;h y
[t�.., i„ e,: ♦ ! ro,, y ixa, ..1 > ,. !� t, '. �t^,,ar a F,r
.wc«.,
,.,,..,M1;
t � _.3 1..e.. .,....1 f ,..,, ,6.., }.• r1., M, .+„ ,.4 a,.;.�..--, ..�,.:.,. 1 n> ,t 4.5• i p_. '{. .. „•.,, :a .. r*)�r l k_c:::'kv �'.. +.w ! di,.. ,. R, , rt .,.- r. .,V Vit:
• ,+. ,.. atv,+, 4.:.x T,. r,.�,.. ,, a .Yr:r "x)' ,,r f ,.. 1jM1 ,. � r , .. ,., { rt Ytr •,Vr .1
t. s.. : a...6. ,. r, r'r .x ,! w ..w se ,. :1 ub...t, 'tri-•,a•.,..- . . !1 +rr t..gin:. h:,.
,T, .,:,.,, ,..rt.l. ,r"...,L 1:. .".,. ...5„•..::.,1.1"._:�,r'..A ,,:...,:=.r9
rrS «,ww:,..'t,
5.:
t.l.r, r, ," 5let� g ,,t r.+�; M1I • .t., t e4l r,,p� ,,,r ,,A1Ea1
.:a.,:!
,
c. :. dr:/.r .,, r1 Rt..Y 44yy ,r..,. s,., ,, .,.,,>, 4w,.h r.,Eaf»L nl.,.l•:.'.w. C{,vyi�'r er', �lf, t.: {!'i U...rIG Ai 11.... -T,v f •:. y, "Fj..
... r ;.,rw4n ,rksn�.,1g, ,,..,r w -.: r,:.,- w f•..,.-.i.'.x.a;: �l kr ,. ,�.,.—�,fVn g:,,.. ..�w. rt,. r„ r r.: �,. 6.g. _,...r t,.,.. aJ.,,.rl..ci. v ,Y�w, tw••,w "t. tx,x:",. a SS ire. wYw t, il, ,,
„{
.. ,.I „.,.4,
�'a'1 r F1 t.
.': a yt.:rc !.., i..d, r.w,. ,,t l .. :.r ii,.4�1tt. I�f ,.,,tt t„�l.t, Ey,.., h t Lc-.w •s w., ”,{% ;. i.ro; .w. .dr. .w� :..-;4..
,:;; 45.< 4 ,. :t, !.L^f ;5r.� ..:, ! ., •. ..;. ,..4 sy .... ;...; ,,, `� ",. ,. "gid ., .+" t6.,w�•_n , .., `r ,,,,r alh;, i "x.
,,. ,. ,L,... ,.. 1. r ........ ...... . ,. _:.. ...:n. {�i. - a r. kr r,. , +�...a .... ,w. L:,... <.. r �'dU. #. .•w !?I _a .w', r, 4'-.„. .d. ',,f ,. s• ir'. a r.u. N 'ii.r.
.+.t.'h ,.r. s s.,,.,4,`t];;'9:.1 'l'� ,r.e'ryAuia.,t-4i.:rw .c „t..,1 ,Y..in+4:. :�7 tr Irk E: ( i) A' �,'�,{.. i t •t,t 4:15, r
:. s . '� �'V'.� E , h ..;�, '1.. '; ilV t :h' , 11, ”' ,.• Ih , ; ": f. Y r. �° ly,rr;s... � ..i .ya :..i i e,M. 1 �A 1 V �
WTI
:
^, �f
: !:,. � Y f- {... 4 .i4 x kA-.n..1- .bw .:'.:., t dr ... r�A�,... '#�•To-.v:. p, '{tt ,, ,. .r .�.•.' i. r, .,. x::r.• 7Y:�w a`� ir' 1:{.. I,,':.
..; 't.e i..:.:.3 1! • ,.,'ra 6 ,Y...,,,::, 1. ry , if. ,.., ,.4 .. t.. ...:...... .t.iA, Y.. l,. ,. y .,:t� ?, ,�r.1;, ,r l .4' w, i !,r '1.Y:, r9 ,t
„ .w . , . n.. , ..r., ..... b , : + 9N+ ..r, Y.: :. o. x: ,.: , ., m�<; r � .,,... x.� J„+i� I .c 1 � ,,j { r�i r { at:1P # ° G.• .4 Y r „ �,; ; r ,rr .!M1
dd
i '.. •.. rOtl.. ttr � ” Y � wi ! 1', 1.,� lwyr i 14h1,. N{,. -.,, 41� " '. r ,
iR1tv.acr�tl�iLtl4�'4t�fr'''LiP41'p}!�•tiilLtigYil. iA! `',.i:�>t ray. ! �i vi I .,rr ,.l '+ru r V r x:,.."e f+x •fj '� Ya �';p ry r r' I -:e .".. �i y,r + I,�p {` t �.', .t Y{ i, �• r g,:.y d V.,,d .,.'S.
,St
1 rw
�. Mr.'Parilo stated thatahe effect Of the grandfathering clause is thattfrom that date there are fiveyears under
which that business can _continue to' operate. It is an amortization program for those .uses that eis'ced prior,
,
to the interim. ordinaixce; The Firs Amendment Club, Would not fall under, the;amortization since they were r r' ;
—r.' „
1 approved pursuarit to the interim ordinance: '
Mr: McCabe said he was notsure that this section even applies, to Mr Mull's business, and nil reason to
change title date. `Ir
"` d said this should come back to the'Corrimission
Chairman-Lelan ,:but it there is not eriougri tune, move flus '
forwaI to the Board. 'He suggested deleting: the operational 'limits 'for the 10 foot barrier and tipping
�, •:
restriction. He said they need an analysis on site availability to know now many sites We.need to have for
the size o£this County. `
! ! i Y:I Vr
W
tt�.
P
U 1S
sinner Monne said that" th.rre is no other-business that comes in w
it tilities instiu d " be
I i u e to b e
i
fo`r them, why should i is bed fferPnt.,
Mr. Parilo -said the :Commission should give direction to County Counsel because of the time restraints. He I
"said the earlier ot'ainauce hada requirement of 750 feet separation to the lot line, IVIrw NIu11 is'recommending
300 feet. He say this is an Administrative Permitw He said they show 8' locations in
'the County that would
meetthe ariteria,on the number of sites available
!
Chairman Leland. said lie is comfortable suggesting approval of;this or'dinat ce su'nject to future advice on
the above to ics lie talked abouts He said they should look at the riuinber of sites required in the County arid, f
p
ask TA Shanahan to also focus on the process for;' appealing a denial of a permit. 'He suggested that 1VIr, ,
Shanahan determine the appropriate distance from, a sensitive use. He said ITe has had prableiris with the
" ent of bound to boundary: He said' ? Pettier way is to measure from the-door step of the adult
rrieasuteiti ars°
business e " ce of an adjacent��sensitive, use orJ.`to the'boundaryofa residential piaoperty. a
ntrditd to the; entrap
�,- HewoUld like to:deletethe o erationai restricticiis, reduring separation, barrier, and,tippnge Check file
p r notvve hav��;avi,iltible sites with Ialie a ro riate criteria. Check th.•e. !
number of sites nee and whether o
procedures fort, he denial of permit, and change the method of measuring separation of adult businesses and
sensitive uses+,
,
Commissioner Lambert said she is willing to have the two Counsels to address the hdip$. and take their t
teconimendations to the. Board.
It was moved "by Chairman Lelandy seconded by Coinmissiorter Cage, and unanimously ua'rried to
recommend. iliat the Board of Supervisors ad apt the perm nent adult business ordinance as drafted and with i
the modification's; 9Uggested Uy staff and 1VIr,1VIoCate; with the Following changes: thdt the operatibial limits
relating to physical battier and distance separation 'be eliminated Arid that the prohibition on tipping be
O'li'mmatedw That the r iethod for measuring distance's between adu It businesses and sensitive lases be
ealcttlat d'froiri the entrance of the,adult business to the entrance of the `sensiti�+e rise or to the boundary, line
of"the adjacent residential zone, 5iibject to any further advise that staff arias give the Board concerning the
requiremeri"t for anurnber of available sites, available iii this ordi iaiice; us revised; in Butte Coiiiity; aiid the
constitutional permissibility of the pernlit denial process;
Scott Y; Steplicirs proposed Negativi l�eclsirntibn with mitigation' measures regarding
F impadts aiid,Use pc taut; Mining Perntif; anal ReClamat", P1ari iii acdordaiice with
envirotiiimental
i iurrfi dbtjN`'Y PLANN INCr COIVIMtSSCUI 1VICl ty7'�S JtJfVu "9, 2dOd''r PAGE .1 '
1
;;" tix,,, I a ,:� a rr !,� A � r .t t : :� ..••"w" �.::� .� „�l<'x c'� �. 1it'i....:sGs� '�� 'rrrwVr{t^"!�+"'�`""" l,.A, .. �:: 1,�� rw t t .. ., ..„'Xf: �p�. .� 0. s•
..•»., ,^, �,,r, +-,:, �'{..,a > ,...«'.. trs�.N., 3.,,:f i ,. e31ta, ,'+..�::r r ,s ,., x r.,7k .. •>•.. Ja"'t 'P ,:.� NP. ,;,e ;7 t, r. I !"r.+{.. .3,.(.� 66 ,r r%
.}� -,; E. 3 .,.,. .4. k ( , ,:.., S s .: , , e{ _,..... � .... oY,,nI ri ,. ,. ..\1. r. .. C. e y.. ,, ' F. : ,, k ',rti ,<, t. ,, :{ i• c,'1 t:, 4Y. J drt r.,. 1 f� . ,.q S.,r r J E LF { :F �is�; r
'ry, a } s , ..44, _.., s .h , . _, }„+p fl,r:S, ,. �.:, s i \ , :jj: i ,.1 ” r,l 4q, ... r. r , r F , . i i7U. •I - � , 3U: a I , ! .19 • > r .! _fr 'fd
:,As .hkn, trf t. ., .. .. R. .: :.. i :- .. -.r 31. d,. ,,..r .\.d.. i.. ,, ,. ➢_,. 4. {(. .vn } d ,. r. 5 ..x 5. '4'. .di, ',;� u'0 � lu'4.. ;i4
,: r 4 S i a, ! r., ....,1 t . t. .., ,i, x, ., ..'r.1 b A • : _,.L. it „.k. ,. I r ., re: y , ..k,� .. ;,�, @S' .. t . - 4. '?a- ,... ,.. {,.' •.a P:. Y .,it: •
ii',.oi..-rl,-
\, i.r . -. � , ,., a ,�,, , . ,.i: ,; � "r4„ r, , . ,,,. .,. '��.,, i r kA,•,..:1 . tl. ,,, hi , "c •c . � P "� p r, >:'�., v, � �,., ,} � ➢ t, , r9�.
o>'*\' ' ,i,`,
r ,
L rr 4p l
_1t i!
':. ., ,\. 1 ','rr 9.r, '.._, .n t.. r :'3; ,.,.6. .. �,. ... E,., :1.n r$: r •?n ,;il. +.. nz
I .
,.� , � j :.tk,, k: ... , ,, :4 4 . .. 3 r, I . ,.,n... �:�:r n A... h... , ririi(, ' R' .4➢'.{,l fi.,1ir .: i,r., c . it �: yn}, ry .a . �r „rpt _ i ,. Fi'Ir "!r}. , ,� ' .. » �Y n .rar � .,.,Ir,tr
i ,n* .,r . .+ . ,. , t ,. ,�; r , ,,.. 3 R :.,, c (7 "^ r� .h' a�...# 9 w. ' 1 ,, . w -:u(, , ,; h "�;, ,,t*ia,•At { y. � �5" 1, 5L➢ 7�'V, a + ,-„ 1,,. " ri
: '.i ,.. «At ,s9.-. Y�.1Q„,., . k,ri,. It..+At 11,'.3.._, :� o« t.. . f,, i„ir.. ., r 1r'?w�h t : r.' ...`, t.^'t” �;^s •E' I ,;::a, S. :. �I,� I h. .,1 ,r r ,, E... rr:! u, I. il.d , :. �::iiF'r '•
k.
;.t
6.. .. I *..:"• ..,.. 1!149 :.:,., rxi .,"1, 4 •.. , ' _: `p a. t !'... 4.. :[�. 5.i-.� 5 4 {. .�{,F. \ 4 Y.{ 1 s1 � )' lo- t d',.
t,
p,,,5, 41},
p.tt<{➢.1 a .. tI115,, s >_ t•ii. e. ,uFp 7r L.({, a i +'i". r , . 'slF.t:4, 7w '..=r „{ I .i �.+➢„.,,,. 5: •1:;, k ,,,,.} P,,,,.r,.
4.,. .'➢..,�.,. 1b k1'1.1,.:- ,,:,1.1+.iral .')s:-...}:.'�,,..._.., .c.., n,. .r .. It-�:a'dG, ♦ >,a.., d4".1,«:1�i,.,,•,f/� c.5....�VN �^ ,.{ R., A'.N r,.. .t„ .f
Y., n.A :7,k..I.{i .k.,N ,�, .,1',,�I :.� tr .1A}•1} .old} A. 17..if' Il..'1 .IAi YIY. d � IC r}.,I "f l'u. i 1.,•'1.
�t9,._ .' 'R.t..,..,...T.. v A..f �\ W
s4 pk ' .. 1 ±':+r.•.
I , t x• r. 4 V. 4. ..k 1
;.,:
r..7 I.. r,..k a. : c , .: pJ ,. r fix r. r i`t9 .,_t ,.!^.r;'' „ . 1 -_."'. ... .F. �t-.,.r .,r• .J r
i. tJ, .,rl
.. . , ,..4, �',w. ,,V. 5irh1.UJ. ,A ....,:sr.....r. , .. ! r . f x •SL .r T , P�'r . -+ i a»""t S
t s ,, l :. 5,. :1, ,. :. .. 0.�1. i. ..1 a7 Na , 'uY, a J . r...a..
,,, � Yl_ �4 '3,�.r e.% .! , s. , ! „ ,..,: ,4 11 a. 'l�. ,"ras�pp � J4.... .,., ; a..X J �,a
..AE � ,i ,.. ,r ,..E_ :, .,.: ..,.x. ,iy..,c }.:{,., e,7�:SS t, ,:'nd., �. ,'n5 ».1::�- k, S., �.._ 7.. ,t.r.,, ,a,1:Iwsrr +.. `4, ,/� 'r..�, 'i'» m '1;', I •-tG=..-r-+'.
1. i... ia;r., 1.,, 1.r 'i,��� ilr +. 4. k,r E.u�.,.v}hh�.,.�.... i��..i�.�, h. J. '3d'. 1'T v9A"N: f{.. 'i,.. .,, •. 'I \ n"%it., l .t l.: t 'f i:.' /:i'. ;.r
r., a. t}..t 1..
t, (sj d ttV 4, 4 \1, l „Itt 3 l .T a tin t cis ; 3
�
r ,:,1'r1P d.p.,o ..i. ,n ., ,. ,.-,... ,',. 4 t .r': .Jc,.. rr l... ➢ ..,E. r M.�,
l", ,➢,.. Ir.e �,.t, i w.l ..t:ua
"�i 1 ,." .,r al,t r • ,. . , n , r , .r + ➢v � t r ':; f'aEiniifellali'lifik�li:.1ti'��'Sik1J.E•ly'�➢ C .,, 3 iX , _ `�,�
+,: � „w.Sr'1.ti+'S�t,..L. .,..,r..la ,,..•u.w+.:;,:�ns wAmt i,yry h
$Yry� U'{tiT!!�hvd �'b�.# Ei�,L'�1Y4SC19`�w`kE�i.ci.��41.,45tGs!•u S:IrYwWliil.,�ii+319'.},r�L»iia '9• +?N^^?�•'1 "^I-'`'^^'”. ,:
r 2V
� kf fpr,
7J�
t ,J .1!
the Surface `Mining and Reclamation Act, to operate a surface aggregate quart) for the extraction of
basalt The m ind!,w�ill encompass 5=acres within a,326 (+%-) acre`property. The apiilicant proposes 1 s'
to
utilize -a srdehll method of,excavation whicli will leave a graded aroa and a cut -bank with a.35= j`
degree slopetlY A rock crusher; rock screen and settling pond rs also proposed. Munn o . rations will
take'place, over'ten years The mined basalt will be'crushed into road base material and hauled off
,Maximum°anticipated "nine depth is 70 feet. All topsoil shall be conserved For later use in
reclamation. The mirta will be reclaimed at the conclusion of operations for use'as a grazing area;
which will also support natio a annual vegetation and local wildlife: -Access to the site is provided a,
r by Canyon Shadows Road, a private road. connecting with-,umlaoldt Road The ,property is zoned
�f ,' "U" (iJnclassified) and located approximately 1.5 miles north'of the irrtersection of Canyon Shadows w ;
Road and Humboldt Road the Little Chico Creek Canyon`1!2 , R
, 2E,, Section t 1, MDB&M' f I
AP•N ('S3-290=05.6 and Out -290 057 (DB) (File #MIN
anning Commission will ad�
ote After heann lu
ly g t s item, the Pl ” jotu-n, � and reconvene at the
area. The ublic is elira ed to attend both the,hearin
protect, sitein order to tour the Is card p g $
- -
and the prhect tour. „A map, shall be provided, which indicates where the Planning
Commission will be reconvening after the public !!fearing in Orovrlle. Transportation to the
site will riot Ue provided and is the res ponsibility'o£ indvidwals wishirig to attend the site E
1
r:5 tour.
7.
;+ I
,
Chairman Leland said it teas his inclination to not take testimony+;now, He said they sljould meet at the site
after�htnch I ,I � �.
J/
MriBreedon sal rf he, had a correction to :something tliat vyas, "aid at thr` `last meeting regarding :IVleridian Rock '
Quarry" He said 30% of'their rock.supplids other people than the railroad.
i
Chairman Leland said at the last meeting. the �0 inhf ssion Fisked;th ' the mailing notices be expanded. YIe
dtc"hae thein -look at -the, erlam d fathesaidstaffan
field', trip: Ike safe", it wi11'be difficult to take testi►nony at the site: The hearing'ut+as continued to the site at
f 3 i00 p.m. for °a field trip''and then to August `10, 2000, at 9.30 a.m, for an open hear1. ing
r
s
The regular meetiiig ad'oumed to. lunch at 1+30 p,im and then to the site at 3:00 p.m; i•
a ron� Scott Ste heta
s Abel
i he :field trip stat�ediat 3;.1 10 a.mi fi1te��fohoMng people were at the mrnmg loc t i p , �
Ascenci% Mary Brownell; `StcV, Meline; Robert Melirie, Lrsa Speegie, Ted Crary£ord, Mr. Hall, tacit
Meline, Dan Hays, Ronda Purdy, Robert Seals, Maryellen Largent; Brent Largent; Mike Mooneyy Jack
W�lUarrlspn, l�lrfia Lambert; Rrchar It elands Jetta Gooper,',Jeff Mott, Bill Hohiies, Dap BYezdoh, and Ly'
RW. ar son"
Walk d 10 look at W t
The theioa` here the The around:the area started at
the' cattle chutes and went down
would! be" .then 'lo ° "lie east towards tlfe creek and hack {to the start, me 8tephe�is said tlter'e +ill b - no
i S"' 4 i'. i. 1
materrals washed at the ;site, He sand they, will keep'the dust down with prpecl m water Mr Stephens, said
there will Abe about 8 trucks a day all yearn` Ike said.he uVottld like to !lave the operaton,be open on the
weekends„
I
id their rs the noise'trorii`t}te cruslfer oiri a the can ont They said
te eo le at the srte sai main roncerz ` `
Y
p q`
p p g
g p Y
people buj iri thisarea,for the p ecce and tiieti
,
i
it bt)'fl'E C+DtIN 1� I'LANI�1 fiCi�COIviMI�5i0�1 MV TSS �C1�1.%'20, 00' PAG9 19�
E A,. ti. F+..� r 1 »✓<r ,i A'j r uQ-04 1
Yid ti a +� :rt .,C6•akpj3�',n t»� < AJ fir . �.,k} # rJ A �'� l i1.. ��{{j% V4 7 ,..{ Jr rl^,,,A ! ,.' ;, ,P g"'ll i{ s I� x. 1, �A
t �� �hFayJ�n'r i
•, 'N' ..:.,,.,. . a. tL
,,.. ..,! V,. P! �Ex .;, , .. G.. . �: s�„�, J7 ,.4. h,. :... �a'y. „� r ,.,. iJ P ,3+,5 ! R .l 1" 9" h.1�] ey >f f 'i" 1.. +,, 11 �•i� r
. .. kh:. . .1. ,.. ... 4 ryl. , : , 4 h, i J,
y+ ,. , a: y .,, 1"t :,,q,- Sa+o �' rJ. k,: r+ 1: ... .. .,� n. �i>. i ai +, r.. .+,fin.. a'•_r ;.;',yw, 4 +. r, Y . r,.•i, i� ,.,� i� ,�t 1 a x
..: � < . ,. ,;�i,.A • A, ._. k .nr , � t , F,. .2 ,., , i
`t t r r y`'�... t,'k�.'l...t, .., Yt
, . ::� a •, �. [... .:'♦...,. r... Y k �, k ,6"..�, h,; Yr . c. + 'V. �F� ` t :k'i�• t 1:.,� rr. .. p•:,
sa .r, v . a, 4 v ., , ,.,,a� .. t, tx-u � {/, � ti �+, ,. , "t<.,,t�-, , J
t .; .4. ]„ «fir; ,. w n .� ... ,2 r.a .. r .�,.r -R:,. + G'T ,A,.4 �:. > ,:i -�F 5� .=1, il.,.:P
,i��Aw.,�. rt1 w;t,.k r� � t,3.rliat.� i+'w. �,
�'
„,. fi.. s, ,. ,.�i. 'a. i.k, r (. ,Ya .,. :."y�, , ,,, .F, t.. ➢ .d . .;,w .r:l,
i l ar,, � t � 1, lr„• ,..^y., .#+. ,`6F+F
r.:: ,. k:u.. },�. ? .,tr , n. r1 �. 4{ u! ,, i Is �..'+t 1 S S•t1, v i ,o gd:,; ai
��� at 1�,+,�.t, oSa x ,lt. ,:, x..l,L. �
� a 9 7 +. Mar S, VIM, t : r : t>. , � ,i,l. ,r , � , s« 1t r . ,, p ; f . v •,4
I ,,. ... t. •. ,,. 't ,,.'” .,1, •,k., +:,. . h,.� yi. , v.i
1� + , 4� S, .� i • rn .r:. . t. ,,.. • 7 • ., je.r. ,Ag_;,,, Y r ,• $,l t, ,, t9:. ,,F,.,. ,r� �ir, _.y.,, �.d 't: i,y-.. � f. i.
„
..,#t,'�. ,.,rb,,. ..�arr� , , 3 ,,..�� .1.• ei[ts o ,y+-'�':� �.t;,..:A
1 6:,.r q ., ,. r r #i :,] rp•.1. .. i +•� ,. 1.-k �tf s 4i...�, .e, . J, �.r•) a„ ,. w., r, s » .,1+5 �, ., +fi .. :: it n -b ,r� $ � ari ;r he. r ,r F, c1. Y,Fa„g n,� u,�,� ,�t � l is rout �" �1
. �,.: 9 Y • k� ,h + .,.- �:„•fr 1: � , �x „�.va 'G}:. �,t,�+ r• t`�S a d s 4,. f., , , t r„1;� ,r, � h' t ,l.fi P4 1, {. 1 rr;ti:,. l�yr,
,rj• tt.i w ,,d,. atni :0 1: I, x, .,S,.A} .�r+ 4 �,i'`1�r ,t, a• rJ; 'i. a ,�,# � a2 ;.0 +s,.. ;rr, .:r' a Na %r
} , „ G. 'X:v ., - - • ' ., .. i Y tr,. J , ' .: + �, 5'. , a sz ro )
'.,,. , .�[4,...p-.r .Ld;-:.. �Ee,...,'bi�v:,.%-. .,..„.,^y'jT.Gl ��3RS.•s. ,yR{�..,t.F�4e;:�ar4+".'.; ,t.art9,e ,♦*�+rEE,nqe.>r �.,l,'1.lh, ,..l„�,1 .d,.. ,k.. +„.�5.„,,1�..,.,�t`.t,,+,,. . .a , `rt.,,,.. ,. nai :,r ,, 5r1... r., i.a.r�t1 ..,..r1.:rrY,1._,E, 5,;r.,,,.t.a5.,tY,b ,ak.C.,lr...l,..oMl.pl�1�, �r,1:�. +�M.,'$... 1T,, `, ,�f-y,, p„.,tA(E.�.G. 1t ii(r, yd,:r.,yy}r.cb.t:i,:?..f+.s+.S„.',{.” ,..E+APd*4,i.i,,�•.I.6FR,,1:n .N:Yt. {iaa,t.i S.�i:,...,.!...(,. .,,yy'�• t45,«,�. ✓..�.„w,.:A...x,�., •!1 . ,r. h �,t�._, �i.l„..,rx, 'bt''4kt.i,ftr,.4a,4.aYw r>t �a_,. .<,.:. N ...Ii.,.a_,f,: t, . o P+1 �eC. C:•a, {+'Y.,.. '. .„...n.,�.1..ly 3 .,'a,f?r. C fl'�'l:a,.(11:.,,.,.-rr, r1:1vX.,ue1P+, ryr7lrS,.h.r \<,F�1. .:L":,u"c,.F. r. '. , }�t,v,^. 1�)7y0Y... 4r4., 1,:�h,x�,-S(1 a , r .ars- .t:,%.rarr,n�r, i F
cr]T,t.,f..
..
a.
' ,. G �,.. . , , v A..., qq , :. '4 t , ,i 4. r. ai-. � : } .�.„,•' k1 f. v f . ,, ,� P ± ,�w : t' ,.. 4 s°:>7. � .,. u.'Mf fi:.
,ri. ,l ,V 't �'i. `i ^'1 ,;6 r: t5, , ,,.�'.,_ nst .a. d..>t ,.a ,�..., w, ,.Y l'Cc :+ >i:„ ,tk, ,a, ,,,� . t,-.. ,-k, +t., al .pa* r .� y: r.. Th d •r9. ,, 1��:. ;Y..
,v, ,{, +,5P. �, 1 :,, - ,.r:, `,• S @ - a'.:. ] t + •;9}; t...,il
r,.. ,f. 1 ,v9, kk.,:r ! Vit.. .4 .?.\1 ar • �?:' cA:, i , ,� .. s, , i f i. r�l;” F ?'.�, ,+,.. -Fl ., a1. �.., . a, ,?
sa, Yi+,x �t�.r Gt�. ,+.. ,! ,t5” _ � r,: .. +..:.. 1.,19r 4 a,...v� ,,,....r s...,, aar,�+, v.. �.:'1.
r..t, ," ,c: j1 4,. ?, , ib. t �a t ...:.. 7, 1�r k ,1. t/r%�t.,a �' i,,. l a n. ,,. ; ,�[4 1,,6, 1 . ,r 4 e ,,,e, f,� .: .V ai:r ,, ,, t .� +5' �-i i< !
., ���t. , i1 r +ta•1 .yy,... 1.:I�j �te., ,n .1 ,...fl..,.,,. .h e 1, .,. b..e ,. r.�.. i. �. l ,V,4...., a( IG x..1�.yY 5^5, Y ,, i..i8 w. , ,fir Ir�� :1 t., � rjP :''
.i S'.,� tt '�.:,. �M1� t,', t N � •,F ei
+. , S +” p!,. F. �t+A .,, 1. ,., :I �,., ,..: > 1t �.. 1 S .,:I•. h. t �r. ., 4 „_..-'' r> , '•, ,. h, �.r ,:q r�.fa Y a _.;.. ,.i. -4. 4 ri f, •. 1. +I+ diaU,L�G+f ,:.
.,1 � tj �, ,,; , .�F 4 � r,? :,.,,! „ 31 c, f,, St.� :..•7 - ,I - , .,r r", �, tt +.'d �il, <,r; ti , . ,,. 3 r,;t'- .tY � : lP;.° a a < {-,r, , ,.F.. ,,.,�� .,:t iY M.'
;le?xd� ,,.. e a,r'' r:. x+r ^r6'ib ,:,G...e 1 7,t r [S., r ,✓, a „ i•;.F 1..: a. .,-. .'f,n .t n a ., .r y. t +
t
twrsZ,4: 1# +,a Ix•,.. I y-�,. t;+'u St;ti4, 1';,1r�.„.,t,.:,.,�3A.,al..s�,2+*%a•a:,E ` �+,'j
arw`i GA4�. .'v' ( �, 4b�i .., 'i?i 1+,A`qt t,=,n,�, Y `ia.:, 'L;;1 k V•? „;It`i.,,�,.',G,a;'=t�+�'�W'�d'—+"�tl�nL.`r`"”'
N t �� wt
,
i..
0.
1 n 1
t
1 ,
AGENpA (Presentations
USINE5S FRO10'T,THE�FLUOR ON ITEMS State Law fi
VI. Bill be'1
r : ` CoinmissonO pro bibb�Y ON THE taking action on any item
united to five minutes• .The Plartnmg _
om 'r t+� 3j
presented iiitisnothsted on the Agenda)
lig hearing will be opened to the ublto for I
P f, t
pLTBLIC HEAR12” The Chair will call for staff comments - T
P ;i °�
oiietits +a `onents, comments,"and rebuttals. `The hearing will be closed to.the public:and discussion confined to the -
prop b PP y
<
Comm%ssien. The,Comtnission,„will then make a motion and on the atein..
niited to, a maxiinuril of 5 minutes so that all interesfed parties' will ��
It is requestdd'that public initiated presentations: be 1i our, resentahon, please print your naive and address �rn the
hake an opportunity to address the Coininission..IN,it)wing y P
q speakers §hdet'so that t ie recofd will {be.accurate
ton and has not died by
tion_ of County y
et been. consid 1 ,1
The recommenda staff is vidicatedbeloNl Zt is only a recommendat
ng Division Office
the Planning Commission Copies of the Staff Roport are availabld at the Planet' '
a e,voted no, Commtssio sent} N
3:�- (COI11mis0DA r g rx
A . ` Approved
C ver Nelson was ab
ode ' riftl - roposecl Negative.Declarat�ou regarding,environmental impacts �,_n'
9 3Q a,mr Paul _ • g. p ' Timber Preserve 1i;0 acre parcels andWatershed
't -N' anttRezone $r�ri'TPZ T6tlIWP,(
,,
er
Protection by lay to: TM -TSO/ WP (Timber,Mountain 10 acre; parcels and
Watershed Protection Overlay) on an 8 37 'acre si t+.�� ttl.in an, 80 -acre parcel: The'' '
prop '' locatd.a roximatel six miles north,of thu Town c� "Paradise, at 15428 A
roe is pp y E h .t A u„
S'tcyway,, r�agala, at the termuaus of lVleadowbrook R auch Road; w)tcl htta t ects the 4
r Slrjnay 1000 &dt,jouth of.De Sab1a Reservo 065-060-0051)
���er APN
In
I
tl1)i r
—�
,ve
YO
i
>a. A►
Ph f,
+
• ftiott u�itli mitigation trieasures
9,30 a,m,.
CUander' Sidher, proposed Negative DeclarR,
regarding envvronmental impacts and Use Permit to alla�v for the ooiistructon acid
wands including three
operation o£ a 3y3tltl sg, ft, coiivetuence store, with two_fdel iw, - _
zo gas pumps each, and 49, 8tlsg+ ft, carvash, ori a 1,79 acre her Genera Plan: C VVate
industrial) ' The property is designated 'as Yndustrtal by
supply is proposed by an -site well, $ewot service is; proposed by on site septic
SYStetitL ''The crv�rash v►�ill utilize a<eair`culating wafer system; ,On-site Of
00'nalm. to
drainage and `atormvuater is also proposed, Proposed 'store hout5 are
iyaim,e is locatedi on the southwest corneto
f State lIighvyay 99 and
h.. ro
�GL�tl p po5ite Hollis Lane' south of tlie;'Ctty of Gridl�,y. Al'N b2�
�. West Liberty Roach app
t. M921( (DB) (Fii'c Up 0tl=1o)
C.
Sind For�vartl for Approv,►1 4�0
4 ”' , r
l
t
,, adu
, and r
g
am
, , .: - ng egulatm cert,
g;30 a,m; Goumg Code A' ftdment - An brdmance pralubiti
'` tis a�totn t` from the Californlrivn'onnrental Quality Act.
buattaessesr the m ec p , 3 (RW) (FILA #ZCA 00 -OL);
p fbi i )
pursuant to GEQA Guidelines Seetioh 15061 +
Continued open to August ] 12n01 0 at 9:30 aim:
eclaratinn with mitigation ;tneasutes
9;30 a.rri, „ Scott D. Stephens, propased Negat►�e b iVliniiY Pe►Lmit, and,
regarding envioninerital impacts and Use Permit,. ,
`�iclmatiori 1°�au in accordance with the Surface Mining and ReClamatton Act; to
_ traction
sof lasaltL
Tie mine
will
of the cit
operate a suirface aggregate quarry � f
..:, , . y 1vtl5alat�:rMAi;>ihiDA'
e JCINE �9, 2ggq i■',PAG1r 2 �
j rl v ten,.., a 'Y'^o,.. • r rr +,� . n1»,r sw IeHirWsq+ �. r .rtwMYd Whin P.d rY+ 4 ri rt :5 R
n71 , r , ',v. ,;,a ,. < „ 7`,Y.,. b „ , ate., , w „�! - A, e,:'r,• o, '�,tpi I•"4 . +t +' '"d'! n ,nf a yt .t. �' . +',.. ,�;.
rr ft,e.
A „'r -.r. � � .. 'Y ,[ ,xs + '. t 11r r` b i1 r' "r r' ,r,'S �aN }s( ,, rj,r fix, ,Ft a, � ,� �A•:, r a i.'' i i y Orn r
r
ll
r
.t .v, ..•l, � tr "e. 'j.
»
h4l Y� �.,. F•., -v. r i
i , r 's +.a ,... :. _.\ , v , v a ,,. :r , d' '<,, l: '... ,i. l .. r.... Y �d yt. «. t +a'Tit „q �•T^ a.. f.
l#r .,:.7 ,�.t. yV s.�ex .,'we. ;. +. ,ir ,•< 4 ...,, r .;'S .a'kxk_ il. u. . a,r b. I,{. n -....J"+ I ... ` ai ''i.:h r'4bi+:y
,�1. •.,A. ,��t:.,,.. ,..;::F.c 5..,.rr :.ettu-I.:..r�n
4 n r, y,. . -.. , l4 � t. i ..! : ,:. 6 �F 6i1 rrr., d ! a �. � I e Orr : rtr l >`tr^� a, y a ii ,'�.a r wr.:,. Y H -,,.. a a,• 1 :. .1..
,`M, a .. ..ai 1>. �>«: ..1
.r, ,� : i (., .:: _,,. ..,,. Vr , ,,,., •i� 1 ..1. .., �'.e�. 1F .. _11.r. e�,1 ,. .. �,."...i,r., v ,:., ,>r. h v1 ::,. nf,. +;. �. a. 1., r,j al! ,1
.(.hlri
r .' ti's 1�t t r1,)�,,p' awef r,,r•,A
,��,.
t , S• .,� d r. ,., �.� .ti ,.� e .., .., ,,,.LiP''+... , ••{{ ,' r.rra�o ,., <.r1 r�...r. M �., �,, ti ,. ��r3, S ,�3 .,Is .a;aat# ;rro,,v,"Ed., <' �.,. W,, .
� . ,. :. �... ir.. ,..; ': . .. :.. ' •,. n r i�::, , W ; t+r - , ,:. � .� 1rd > .r ,v ,, Frd,- a, 'S ,5 )r.n�. #y ar �:,�N+. U�r„ �° �,--7,4N.
rs.
v}S, 4 k "c 7 ,i.'h , 4 ..Sh
:� r � q
.. �. �5. ^.k+ 1. ,,11d::,1 'ti!.'"�•! >yasi6..:x, k1 :�: r:,l.:!�F,. �4aq:) j
4. , q : }gip ,. L, 5,> ,. ,r?r:a t f rid„ r'
•', -r ,a . , Vit$,. i P�1: � ,, ,,� . a A. S 3'.c, «+ �l �,>
� t �: �k4� a ' >• u, .y.r 3a',{, r .4 � :a r t" I as l". >.. S?''a:N,.,u : w,{,r,r , d r� , � lig., RAJ., . � ,:,r': .: s }� i , r ,
.:... k :%.. . , 4 i... F u -'•Y`;fdr;M.'i�ti ,i?r i '§ , .. n aS.. ... "x , .1.. h: dl, ".`� . ,rR 7 w wt f 1 d .,,x T •,ab' i
5z . r d b1 h5 r, 1'i, ,.,tn r.t Ga rr. #4a
i,�y�.-..,.�,r •..., ,, -4 :. .5G..i5 •e 'x Y4d�.yr�, 1(1�, 1E ar, i{1,,ar(, Yt e. r � a�{�„r..,,adi. .a:• t ,,.. n. i. {l �K .j{
,n F`i.� Y'C I,r: :_'.1L r...,t �'., 'L.t :i1. �I/C+-..1 S 1H. :•+'Ii 1`e,r:. "5.} �f �. ;, S - f.
�.a, n1 '�#„t7� t.r..':•
,..� •'.. ih,.„. ,a .5a , E, , 7�.., .!i,, nr �, r. 1 rr,,.9.” dr. gid. ! a. i� .r>rdi, •. a. l.. :.r
�. {, .t�M ..,}.?x” r..•„0. 1.«-t .. c.. S ,.. r,}.i.=: =X �a, ,.,!i r :au.� „J g v,t •'.P .k„ �{, +„ ru,.r�•'�,
4.Fd!<.ny,.,i.r.-n1 ..,..,.,,, :7 fi:l..
M,. E i i'i?t.., t. a1.i•t:,:� ..r�. 1"+ rlt .:. r. erl�.. )! �: k._•.. •1} . r,. , 4.�r 'a:r.,i t'r s�u
r. ,. r• .l it X11. �, }S vhr a�}arl ,6 a 7: V - „ >:,. c r•.tr.. c,At i�ari.. i. r;�:rt'{ ,: t;'::n. r
°b a ...1''{{ ,.r ... 1:. ::.Y,.4t ,.,t 5 �,•� ` .i, zG".'a: �r�, :.}y :� f ',4f ..' .s> ><t
ir1I', 448 .,,19. "1 .
.,r .'rr; ;rfaie.
#..:n•,.'�r :6
{
t {;ap., gash t,rf.
'?• .s .: :r. aN,.. �a FY,.. } ,t. !r4 ., �. k,. a'�,r ,4, .1 44 pp ./'•_i` -3.G . # i, `t :i1 R a1 it a- t M�., :!„ r ,Il. ,!,.r .� 4 it 1',y e,
` ' ;, ,t �:, !, v ,d, „k �, a} ., i ,:� �,.�..,t e?, . , . t# „ PC 'r .,.n .,v .r :Y•:a,.. ,t .n .. i.• "� �d � V`" r a .,$,: ry i ,'k'.: ry ��r �r.. , r , T.r � ,1' ,.: e Y • , r f k4: ,+:°
s ,a'F, a fh �,.rs .?,{,� : .1 . , I 11'w'1,.rS 4. �. � L f, f,ya• ''fha4 , 's<:N.y a,i,. h:,y r. ,. i ' f , � r ,A,• 1. r, b ,r. . e .r Y � � G+. ,.t"Y;_•� � i
•�:•. .h r:, )'. r, ..e+. '•r,rr +l r )II'}iL..w'�{- 1 , (S
t' t c' �C� ,< s ,1,: , � 4'r:+� t , 't, t• �+r:. { ti►' • , o^. �,�' , s � 1 x a ,
o,3a i 3i r :e it t`+ k . 4, �.•, �'
� t,r :{c -e1 ..., "Ut6'. 'a ,�..',>'�is:�i.%rr1,. trY ,{z r. 1, ,,r .,e •',r r'�. .}'" +x,ryF x.">,
,, .�,,,r 3d: r,,*,�' � •i t ' •<; , ., �: •ifi< af« „r�'�a
dr..,' q , . V,. ,
� .t 1 - . . «:�..., d'+ . r- � 1F, _�,_ :... .0 rrt-1 ta.J,r`5✓rk�i � ( 3.
U� te� it , k;
L w 111 F�il�NUCiitua kMtei.�Y�1'+r3audi+�Wn+d.+ye°S�lw_i� wwt 77
if
��,i�1�,,�r
�1
I rt a:C
..
r
f
i ,
eincompass 5 -acres within a 32;6 (+/-'acre property. The apphcant,propose�o;utthze
a` -a ",fail method of excavatton which will leave a graded area and a cut bank with
ir4
a 35 degree slope. A rock crusher; iock,screen and settling pond �s also.proposed,
c Mining operations will,;take place over ten years. The mined Basalt will be crusned.
into load base maiertafand hauled off site. Nlaximtun anticipated <mine depth
feet, E111 topsoil shall`be conserved £or later usq in reclamattonr The.;mirie will be 1 r,
reclaimed at thy', conclusion of operations for use as a,graztng area, which will also
annual ve etaton`and.local wildlife, Access to the site is provided by F' y
support native. g
Canyon Shadows Road, a pnvate I�'road connecting '•with Hum=boldt Road. The ti '
' roe is zone d"`LJ"�(Qhdlassil e . PP Y
' " on Shadows. Road'and Humboldt Road, m the Ltttl Chico
and located,,a roxmi es no
�. thepnte s
' e ' ion of Cary,
�r
Creels Canyon; rI'22N, RZB,' Section 11, MDB&1 APN063�290-056;at>ld 063 290
057'(DB)
Note. Auer hearing this: stem;, the Planiung Commission will adjourn," and reconvene at they a ”
proj ect�site ;lri otder rto four the'site area the public is'encouraged to attend both the hearing` ,
and the` project tour. A niay shall be provided, which indicates where the Planning ,
Commission will be,reconyening after the public hearing in Or6yille Transportation to the
s'it'e wi1L not be provided a>;id is the x'esponsibility of iiiilividuals Wishing t0,attend he site
,
r ,
tours , J
{,
' st
on ar:d
Du ecto
r'
Cdr nts
e utilized � '
VJII, GENERAL BUSINESS Tht'secttort of the ae>da :s l0 6 y tete Plaitrung r t►
o DEvelo nietit Se"tW:ces on' items i}'inte►'es't, goLtoedl discitssiott, pr •itdins for W/rich staff has beenfdhicted to do,
f P.
research" and bring bank to the Cotninw on” Iterns,Ay B, & C ntay riot at�Ua3}stbd addressed at every hea►uig; but wt11'
altivays be listed ds part of t/te agenda, ,
yl
�.� m C7rdmance'U
dat
e
Zon
'
A: General P1anI g p
i� I3y �?r�Legistative Case >✓avv Ulidate
.;
sl:
.rPlanntng'Coxttt�ssiori`Concerris }
IX. GOMMUNICA`i'IOl\1S: � orri»itauctitiana jwpeiVdd itrid ►efet't`ei i (copies of it comi>fu»icatlons a►e.aVnitd� e j
' in tfle Pluruiing pivisRort t��dd:J
X. ADJOirRNNI I T To the Steplich s.projep situ
s-
IiC; IFLi1�INlNGfAGE11rbASIPCA06Z9.a0
,
1�1f
,
I.
I
I
i
i
s
y
I.
,
i
,.i
•
C
:
,
trx-r our T� pL ivr� a COMMISSIO Ob 2000
'
a
' y� r+•.�� a g'v :,x T, «� 4'u: it„a of ... k., 1 �” gyi;)r, n� 'h � , •�' , y.-.�. �,a ".
•',..,l;,H
t, �° ,d•�',..:.,w s. `4 r _'-! t S0.' r +'r a
'y
�� 'X 'k: .,. ,I. �: „3,r:.},•;W ,'�.r,.ayRr1 ,Y>(Y "rq.. yCn Y�� '�
'h"
wi451tawsYNtlwl�.llKrwfM,wu,fianuiroauuuw�.uyp,wY.s.-.rv+:r.w>v,•,.,. *Nr..r•naw.w.-.�+«wrr.,,.,-. +•r^ -� �r
;
:
y ,
I'.
I
i UTT '�:T+i IN ;CONI1VIxSSI -N 1l�hYNU S'
in
I
p r NE g� -20W
'•'.i
IV
:4 it I. rd�
��
'
II
X. PLEDGE OF:ALLEGLA tE.-
"
ROLL CALLc PRESENTi °r'Cage, ]`Mooney, `Zelson Lambert, and
"
",,.,Comrn.issioner`
" ' J Chairman Leland
"
ALSO PItE$ENT Stephen B. etts, Senior Planner�
- Dan Breedon; Seniorlaiiner `
r'•
.aridy Wilson, Principal Planner
' Nick Bltena, Chico l nterprise Recoied
Lynn Richardson, Secretary
Jstaff
IIL, AC �'EPTANCE OlF AGENDA Coi»aiz scion. meiribers and may 'requcst additions, deletions,
! ;
.
or��Yiangds in the Agenda order.
hWasxnoved by dome ussioh Cage, seconded.by Comriiissiorier Lairiliert, and unanimously carried to accept
!
the r genua as pxesen+edti'
'MI1�1iiT'ES L Apni27, 20t1.0,1VIay 11, 2Q00, and 1VIay:25, 2000
pril 27 2000
'
"
The Cdl�mis ion had the following corrections Page 7' Lind 22; change "proposed'; to "existing"# dine 33,
change "onto" to "l0rt;� r
Commissioner; Nels�z said on page 1, Line 11,' #1 'needs' to .be clarified; He said "some of the language is
' ' ' et d. what g1 rnearis as "Amend tfie current Abricultor.1 Districts that is A-5
confusing, Rd tired to mteipr e
,
to A-1 0 zones specific zones to rricltide,Orcliard'arid Field Crops; Grazing and`Open Space, and
,modify
r Agricultural Residential designations,' Separating those three out,` "Specitic.cliarigc 'should apply to Orchaicl
aid )?ielit Crops onit,' He "sai8 io 1et staff reword this portion, ;and brim it baclt, lie said oii page 15,
5; it does l. -t Mate what Recommendation. Stdff to list the options in the inmates to make it clearer, The
Ivlinittes for "'` 'il 27s000, ilave been revised and Wil! be xe-sulirnitted for approval,
tt Was iiioved by Gotruiuss oner Gi- seconiied by Cozrnivssiorier'Moonej+, acid tuiariimo�tsly carried to
continue fhe r"tes` to dine20`00,
*W.
f
cat�rtr�lyANr Itl `IvIINtJ`Tu5 tllN 8, 2Q00 ra 1'AGL 1
num 11G co MISS
Yt
x A
J't� �1 •nµh y.W F I,� v c ;t +d,mYd ✓i'e ,i Gi" `':.: a.r cIC �?.p v , -5 r °�.r4Q dt
- i '' 'I.
s» :.
--.�
4i
1
May 11 �
r4
f, n
Lwould be Page8'
L the 47, change was to 9llowmg o�s,Paga fomussonhadthe fd `„ e .
f mons"# Ln3clang
''«han
T"Whe C2000 `:
t
�tine, 10: � Ap iipplicati
4 add '�also Page a
ktschange`soe oken.
ndless"tonds"PaLm44 �y.
�.
It was moved by C ommiss ober, Mooney, seconded by Commissioner r?elsori, and unanimously Carried to
approve ,, e minuted as'uo ected.
1
• 1 1�
May 25, 2jj000=
CgtYiririoner Cage doted that Shane L. Shane was not present at this meeting '
F.
It by Commissioner Lambert, seconded by Cornntssioner Mo°oney, and unanimously earried.to--
r
was' moved
appra?e the nxinutes with the one. correcttoii.
p'
l NP -controversial. No',
w ,
COI�ISENT Consont Mems are yet°fora toval in one rriotionk Thesd ite, arc considcrecl non
V,
preseittation wril Ue made, haSvevert softie questions may be'asled.
item for d$cus'sion, Brief questions
the Chair wi11 ask if any comrris�ione"r or member ofthe public W'shes.te pull a consent
mx��be asked;,o6 dny item.
�I
on
1
BIJSINE FROM TIjC• AF 001t ON LTEIVIS NOT :ALREADY G11'+T THE AGENDA:' —
- -i
i
1Vtark Nelson, sal, he is a re side of,the forth Chico Specific Plan_(NCSp) area He said he is trying to get
an,aiiiendment to a11oW' a temporary mobile Home on his property for his mother
VtI, PUBLIC HI•;ARINGS';
i
.. trient ro osed Ne i<tive b
ucic County Fare Dep a� tw ) � p p g eclaration regazdmg
Mermo .Butte
Gh � ,
eilvroiimeital urlpacts :aiid Use Permit to alto " ^:1,91,3 Square foot vohintee' i"ire station,,Wtth, an
a niet l
Tlie ro osed £ire stat'oil Will;lie g6luartized
office and a bathroom, qn a .5 ache lease area p p �.. 4� , s
fire engine' The lititlding Wtll not iruttallj�
hnildirt :and will holo oiie water tender vehicle and one
` ilh "an
g batluonnai These amentttes, along W
be coruiected. to :electrical 'service, and will riot contain a
atlaUle� fihe fire station wtll belocated
office, i11 addedlater when fuhdtt�becomes a
g ,
The fire,`stAtion use v�ill ziot iiivolve the
roxliiatety 42 feetfioiil the edgo of Cherokee Road,
pp With volunteer
llazardoii5 materials ox fuels,, The station Will normally e tlnniat.
storage of any, to
firefighters only coming to Aft ft
the Site to pick tip'tlie frre vehicles is locat ii is the east rs c1e of
`Tlie
Nlaintenanee of vehicles will not 'occur ort the site, property ppy p
Patterson Laiie/T .. to Road, Cheroltee� APIA
Cherokee Road; approatitriately gd0' feet north of
b06500-01G(T3) (0POd-11)
{, A video of the site was! 8 iown, Ivlt'� Setts gave a liitef st rtmmat of the project,
ri 2
� w 20 0 o pA
13CTTG t"CJiJl�1T� pt,Al�ladlNCl COMMISfOIJ lvtlt�lt 1 CS 1[iNG 8,
-
II "r�..
„ {
�,. y � 'l "'�� �yl 1t;,a ,atk 4*,r Y 1W..Y { `fir,. •' "F'vn +� iT Nt,. V. y"�`i 11.YY..w ' Yf 'r7� .,yM MUI,.dI M K Mybry+{� f .! t rly ,a. k, Vc 1'&'Y}• iY
Y
t. .%I'
H', r nU .�
b a vs i I' + r � toy r i Y � v � rT Y Y � : � ' � { k ,, a � I ➢ v ; , ': F
w"rY.►7gt7lt�wrx`.l�t..r.:adn:ruQ�iclcaaew�ns}airnsvrnrau+r�ra;waywp.Y,u.......... .wuwwry.„:...,..c.rsY.�,Yy,,w4..uw�•,.
1
x
I J
r;
Commissioner Mooney said he did not think the applicant would got a building hermit without a toilet, and
he dia not thiiik they would g 1' toilet without a.septrc permit. {
.
r
Mr Betts that Environmental Iealth v�asiaware':that a'bathroom would not:be initially instal
y y t
said
applicant did.do so l%testing and ; Environnient`alHcalth dxd: approve it.
�,�
Commissioner Mooney Isai& there does not, look like sufficient area for'` he 100 /o leachline replacement
requiremeirt He yard file last;fire station he did the .County required, two Handicapped showers and a,
restrocitiiY Tie said he Use Permit was° the easy part, He said the well was not'shown on the plot map.
G
"y
IVIrY $efts said it sm,rtlie!uppernorthwest coiner oftlie property acid is not shown on;the map.
Or
Coirmtiiissionet Mooney said flus is a building with an occupancy.requireni and will require handicapped
r
restrgorris.
T ,O hearinwas opened to the public.
There Was a re resentatie $ere' to anavt�er questions,
p
The hearing was'closed.
It was moved by Commissioner Mooney, seconded by Commissioner Lambert, and ttnanirilortsly came
,
to approve the'lJse Permit fi , 'the a Butte CountS� F re;Department, UP00-11, to allow a volunteer Fire station
subjeot to the findings grid conditions listed below
1, Adopt a Negative Ddclarati A regarding endironrrrei tal iiiipalc as detailed in this agenda report with
the following indings and authorize; the Clair to sigh.
A, Find that an Irtitial Sttidy was contpleted iii cornpliaiice with the California Enviroxunerital
y si tficant eny�rotitnent al
uality Act, that said stud did not tdenti any poteixtial `gi effects;
d that a Hf'ega five Declaration is ro osed�
p p
�
I
13Y Find that the Planting Comnissioi ilas considered the proposed Negative beclaration
` together With corYimehts received diiriiig:the public revievu process,
Find, on the basis of the whole record before the Plaiviixig Commiss on, including the Initial
” Study and any comments received; that iltere is no substantial evidence that the Butts County
the en
l~ire'Departmerit Use.perinit pi`bject will klat e a signtftcant effect ori.roniriiit�
`. b, Fi id tliat;tlie proposedNegative,eclatatioii reflectI s the independent jttdgetneiit atik 'nttiys s
of the Cuitnty, vi+liicli is Elie lead agency;
1he.tlesign offhe propdsed prbj�ecf itnprovomen ts will trot cause eiiVirotttueiltal datxiage to .ash and
Wildlife or thieir tiabitat,;tii�d a `de iiiiniintis" exeinptioit regarding irripaet tb fish andwildlife or their
�.
habitat is approved because the ,5 acre lease area lies already beenlcleti.,.1 an graded and does riot
cahtaiii ai y ifive Habitat's The collection of -fees ursuattt to pxr Game; Code Sec"tion
t seri$ .: p �h an
711,�4(d)�3� and.14 CM I'53,5. is not tequued,
�
I:
I
I .
13tJ7"T"E C(7C�NTY`'PL�W, tN COI�MISSi(�I 1� N(1NT�` ES 911 JNC; 8, 200 1' Glr li
�:!axs,.wmmr��`---"'n+.�W—•wl a''r 5,_ 9f�`Lf { +X .r' , { 1
art V.., l
V. � M� rr57Yi xN .i� � �l.' V •`+ �' � r''.. G �4jN k'r I �
.. A.< '.:..,. ,,
Y,
e 'R:. .1,5,.. y4. 4M- )w_4. vr,..n ,).. „e .,,a:, t,. r, a.q a., .,I ,a ,,.ru,J
RtI 5 ,.., , °' , K_ .t.u, I.,.,%u, ,,,.. 4 1 t .. §. .� K{ h..r,.. ;(:i24 ,: f �. :v ,,.
,.. ,, ,,. a.,,t , ,I e i.,,,r. ?�ktrlkrlr: �` � ...>" :, ra ., .ktti. ir, * .1 , 1 . 7 . , ,,.�K.,..S 't', .1 �,�. t �:a,4
,,_r ,..,..1 ., ..1 I r.. AI.K.K.. i [., c s..,: .:a a ,^.,0 tw.ia.. d. .y,gy. F a. ,, 1"•�y
,1 ,.,rK r .,� ., 7 ,.'�,.. �lr.zt �'aSs.,... ,
, �r te.. 1 0 , i.: 1 ,. r., i Y,�,. 'A - • 4. 9 •; I . x .� ; 41 i ra< .j, 3: , � ..wy n 1 • t ,� ^c.
" `,4,..�, , ,...�. �.:. •,.. �'=k, 1 ,<il-;. t � '' ......ft.. ,� _ . G '.a ,,-.. ! :�; .z s.. r
r? •.!t. _,.rt.:,r ....,.. d,,:.1 +re_. i,P v.. _.r..'u. t-Si.,,q,}t
,:. �...,«c.r.,.:..S.aYiw•
,�. r1, ._r. b, .r.l .e +fid „ij., ✓1 �1�, A t,. %r X d-°I: <.
.., i
�.. , ,.L,.. r,1. at'Mr. µ c.._r „1..,,,-.Ll, r:, �K.n ♦ �„ ..ri,.. ! 4 . , a.,r � ra•« !i fy l";,,. z,. .1, .t 'i i, ,K2� ,r:...1 �2.,{ l V M rr .�., ° ..,,, .., a ! ,... f, ,. � , Z,, ,,a..,.. Ja.
rC: ,.• .4x . ,t . i ,xE� - �..,,, w� 1:. '�3 ,. 4 , . i , • ,, .,� � Y,,
ti..,3,t. L 4t 7. ,,q,1{.t% P �l• G,{ r.l at -ui r,,
k, i
,. a L•S 5t p;. ,ry r' .:6. .# .S
,..:, T�P4 2,..E ,r, ry..l ,i ,>. .1. °,t .. r 1 Ar ., ci . �,. . ,.,. yr#.,n, k a., , Kt, {, �I.. �) rl 5 • ,�'i h r e `rk,,.r•>v' � .t ! y' i .: .�t ,�
, .,4 ISk . .! ,� " t,V. id. «. 'h .,, :. 4S,AA m ,`+.},>.l >.ft>.�,., J , r. xa ,t„1h�.,. 1.Y,K, 1. t;, ..r,:
es TK. r... td.,t: K .S..,I.r .Pq11�,a.,, ... �1-.. ... t., 3 ,t 6. m, .x .,t t+,. >R,: ,,:,_ 4 ..,.a-
`,.,.� , : .i. trA .. Y.. -.,.u. �l � r', {•,. ,., tx :. :, ra`,W n:<, Z.., •'1:1 M. .,,,., , ..K{ A+Y r„ „i ,,:.. ,' 7) �.� -. ,. r7.-h., L.
1 :. .e.d :i. .,. .b, .,i .�.:, ,e � 1. {,. y1 ,.. y,a .: 9,. ,I. tq, ry. 9: ,1 ..lk. ,. .'ak4r. Y, 4 t�:. ,r,, � d'.x: e. :pY 1., ,+1
YYtd., ..�,...�r. r,:4 4M1 �... 44 �uh...q, ,. �.,-�t Yk1rh1-v ,3 "d .,,1,� ,... t. +{5..[..4 s.t.1. �. .� i s rt..tar
:.,,. 5.. r :�•.- .vu a n: xr,�te ,'1.. q. ,. K rr :..,,r,.,-ST:a., 4..i, Lr, %1 `S Y '�t' ,•'t^ �G{ a �,ar,
1a1�.a.�,. . ,.•.: - ri..=+
, .
K „ s ., w (.,,, 3}v,, r, tr, . ,.l= .•r.
` 4b, lYa,.y..,.. I ,..r ., ,1,,;'i '. y. ,,#S ...aP.... V ._•.�.r r ,.tx
x•.,, s 4P 4.1.. s. r n. x r r z.., «, .. iF �t4
.4,� ,r. r •,. :.r. ..,,. ,y 3. ..: -,c ` +,. ai.l , .a
e„ y ,, ... .: �, n r. 1:, AA .a .1_. i� l i,.w `. 1\. �, ,� ,,.. +'
,Vy ,N. ...a ,i..�. : +'.. ,... ,. ,.. ..1wa{.}}n ,5 _., r, ..%t ,., .n, Py.{{aj «... �—,1 ,r, ,1 a t.,,..A s,
1 r.},... 9�.. ... s. i,�,,, �.. ,,. ..... : �i .«.. 1,... ,�. r. ,:.i:l ot1{,. !,. -,i. r.4 „Y .l..i f. ..e .,Sae ,. KI, S. K, iP,✓<..11,c.1 ,.r �. .t.
1: t..r, P..:.., M1. 3 ,« �'a3.. .,tp 3 ,rt x, ,,Trot
.—., „t,.N 3 ,qSy, <..e,.n..y .} 'y i.,. �, , ... ,..:.. 1-G r. Ye bl.t a,.J..i ,Pj -i. _K .,.[i e.iaS9.,- w.,lti,,.a sri:'*. 1 '14d .; ,.,'•.r p.,•
�� yr:�. 1.
•.. ,. , ,0 1, ��:; ,.. �!J4 t.i..
� �♦ C,:.a' ... :,, JJ ,:. • st,1
• ,.,:.q , ...n rF i 4t r5t, ,� •!r: t ., , K r. y�K sA: r,rY„{11�,; i. V, „ ..'Pt, �' .a ,r... '� ..1. �'+., 1:1•.i.,' .., 1tK*4t7 i.,: ,, .!`,..y } •-{u n+,.., �. ).. '1:;
3„'I ,:I r,e'. r,t r
st,{ I sx t 1 R hs , ..F, . , .. .. , r, , `1 q . ,, . v . ;.; i 4 +; •, a � , Y, r r
:.. s' d „ 4.r...- 25ri«: b. t, ,.. . e 1...: .. ,,tti,.,+. r•f V», 3..,,,K 1'�.'ih.. 3., .,, ,.,ra 'K 1:r m. .., 1< (,t .., -i. 6+�
. Y., a . c . ,,.. t,�,
I �it' r a+•--� id's i iN •,: �y�.,, rl {. ,.k,: Ir,� ,qt. .1,.e:.:y. 1 ya i I. u�.alj 1 ...:+,
;; , ,t . ,: 1A �1t e3 t,, c ,,kt ,, . ,,`y'1tt, a, ,:i ,, .t3, , ,,�, {,Ze «,xu �,.,,{1..,•r:�„.r, r,,,.K.... r.• .,s. v., r,i{,, ,,
b. 6.. w:. .tk /,,. Lt �. ar ,r-f'- 1 1, . � fir'-. -rS ir` ,. s^'�-}}. m' :.,x'�.. 1,, kai�, :Yi rl ..,<ta , „t, f. it e•� ,,rF :'il
r �:.+,. .t�•; .. �1,. ' , xr,.. 5v .... ;,b '� 1 y(r ,, � �. S t .::r{ }.. •. .r :'i .. :1;� 1 r Fi” r J lt5f+. ,a ,V, t.I” 9 , J
;'; �4, � � , ,A �::, � �:, ,:.. k q., i ,„'.:? 4�.t,, t11 ,• ,t 1 a � . ,; .� y s, .., ,� r a �Pr , s�. :�' . � P �� ,t ” � t „�;
' �77—�'orii9�ii+tiYk.%a+11a1J� ;77,u i= t�i klwal 44eC" a ?pli it s s ',t a Yuaaw a)a (y I-?
I r y
A
a, tk i I
k ! C)' •y:
r I ff
5 a
:
III, Approve Use permit 00-11 for the Butte County,,;Fire Department, subject to the conditions'<fouridK
Pf i', in Exlubit,A, with the fajlovying findings:
proposed iiso of the ;propert}� vyill not impair the integrity and character of the zone in
AN with.: or ti
the land Les' and that be unreasonably mcompatib r� f
the use would not
I
injurious ao, surrounding property, or detririlental to the heal%'safPU� and general��.elfare
of the persons residing or,"workirig m the neighborhood, onto>the'general health, Weitare an
safety ofihe County because:•:
V
,
1 The ro osed volunteer fire statlori ��`I:11 not causega significant increase in`noise :
p p
light, or veh;cle'traffic;: i
The proposed volunteer fire station does not involve :the use of any hazardous: , a
j'1 niatenals'� or.hestorage of fuels; t
G � r
:.
No wehiele re p air will 'occur on tho `site.
h ' ° The.proposed volunteer fire stahori well decrease `Eire department response,'tmies, :
4
t B.. The ro'ect`is corisistentwith:the Unclassified zone which aho
` vis a pt�lalic use with a Use
rr Pernut, and is const,�ipnt` �_ the Agricultural-Resideiitial'Gei�eral Plan land use designation
r a SecoidaryUse,
t which allows °a �'Uu 1
rise as
,
Conditions Of App _toy, ;P `
,
' '. Planning Division'`> I
l 'fhe" ro`ect site shall be de�eloped'in accordance with,' the •appo`ved project sitei plan and 'the
P J .
condit<ons contained herein+ Said site plan is on file in the Planning Division, is identified as
``Exlubit E" aril dated March 2, 200 ;and isAncorporateci herein by this reference,
-- — — .
Loll ,
u�S11n�.:Dtis
2, $wilding permits shall be obtained for the fire station, Plans s;�iaf1 b'e prepared by a licensed or
registered arcliiteCt o'r engineer; authorized tolpractice in the State oaf California3 The structure shall
be designed in accordance' with the 159ng Code and shall 'rieet the requirements
of the' Essential Services Building Acte
FnitronmPt�taj Nealth riivis'ioti � , ,
� I a r<, K, K
i
ii `tallatron
of a bathroofit
tic. errnit shall be obtained ' riot to i s
A sop ,r p
Eire�l�e0, ment
I
`construction, installation or-de=velopment of :structures or facilities on the parcels/lots'sllall conyply
lWtth the';latest California die Safe' Regulattniis,; (Public iZesoliraes' (;ode 4201, anti all
other
apnlicablo State and County codes ordinances aiid.regulations iri'.effectat the tcrie of applictiaii for`
improvement permits3
' ' � 1 ' i ddon audl'or addresses sl ail be installed in conformance With? ublic 1�esources
T3utlding ident�fe t
Code 425 ai1c 'shall , e posted at tho `beghini ig of building conttructon `a=id iiia ntaihe,
it
t ° ' t continuntxsly tltereaf�err �+
)T"c1Eg2UUb NiPAG�
of t Ck
w
;Y M :f ,, 'R :ME, a''' a ,)
kO, ,^r, v. # a
;1� „ , ..., r1"j _'.,, I :: iia .� :.*J t RK ♦d` }r�+. ,z .,�� i :4,. '�u Lrt "'S',x .c .,9k• a :,.if ,I, e}:. fir+ j
u�. V W
'. e , •y. j, � t rh.iA t l'r4 u„ ,1 q ,. �a r.A.;4:�.�a� ,:-�'yi d "'�.. wa r ",^r„y,1 V� .i*' I -,. u- ..t•,WS ua«-!A, n ?. a ..
..t t� .,0.y,... z..... . .,-... 4,t, d' ,.t ,r i,._r,.,, t., y. dM,
V. ., 1a} ti t t 3.. ld� , ,^t x.. 4, ,l. + •ee ^ d.r, r $ $ # „ t + i^1w., 9 3 t . t'V(4
�n : , u t, . r,.. a , t.,6 t Kd ,, ::. �. , . ,.1� i m1 , ', J•.'.
Ni,
5 w, 1,.7 _..., .. h! ...u,p.. ,..Vt �. ,'r,+. ro t)...
s: + , , .. #: E ..• , }. , ,i u# 5.f of 1s
�?x1 $ r }r, a .4e.h. �4A, a rri t} tt
g,t .J;t
51.+.r.t.,. 1�, +„'1..Ji
jt. #.r:rp%., L, .: ,.r ±+,..A .y..d., ,„.a „ .l , ,,,r.yy ..,,r,td fi,. hs ,y,. •a.Y"„
w. ,)b; A. (.. tl:,....!. i4t.. . eR" 9 :i,!r t±s. ; d., •.,,Y;{Z.^ v. 6?, ,,. �'4J'.`:;.., 1. e, a ,"+1a^�'G.6 �.. a :�( .r • yc ,.4':,, I!!
.'s5t. t.1. 1. t y..,a t, t .+ A .../ lE. „ ,n ...f... t..,,i [.:
•WrA'�.. {dr Rp{.1 Y,,,.,,..dtirY
saVa+,
t.t
,.,..,�.r...„.v .-,�.d ,1,.,, 'a6a..„.,. 9. ,.L..'F., i:,,. ,. k,r.. ,... ...p 6�...AI. n -•Y rt 6 ,1.rJ y rats°t#k"9 vk( 'i,
,.
�.,t„tw.
t a :.. .0.1. ,. , h . S � . '? :, y,. � :'•iC^ ) � # ;
y
1.a. Ui.#$�.a.
'"dr,,.r
�.. 'Yt a ,,. d,. � i .,. ,. ,: �,2..M• . lii � . S" �..�{.
{,.,:. , Vk,tt ,::�G4, ,.:�.. .hof ., ..,r, 1_•, ai ,. R...�G v. ,.., ...,a V�7,i. t.: �'#.0 �.: .<,. , .a.. },,.-..,,,, .rC ,a1 -i- ..P ': - 67.6a , G._,rr. A.,. e 5•�- r:5a t.,.,f kn 8 a. ,i�,7
..: ..a} �tt ✓•.!� . .... j, .. a. C�y; y. 6. ....v t.3,, .� .t ,.v..�
,, :: , s ...4 i.„.. . ,�. i..�t� .. h,, '+1.� 1u .. ,�Jy,. itµ r... 14 0 ,4 '1 �°i r ...1 yr 4,. ..J x'L,s, .�^7,.-��.�..y, 0..1 .,. �;. r'��{}.:p� .��r. .; .t. r re,.k Jar, a.i�. •. i.'.,rT9,rIN..Ma.. i,11 #,. ;F.4 a
:'Sv�y , 5{ vt ,... .1A 4 �,” n. ..r ,n x4. q:, ,x �'k'� Tk,y. 7.., i. ,. {.,i .,ri❑ .,,`e,, , _r ut, .xk r. �E T,.R ,� ry .,5 , a t 1. 9r:1.
w"q i,da,n .1 r.. �., a�. r ,a 4, +p w, �. ,. .:' » sK,.. ...'l'.,, 1-' aA- ,ei4+'. .,'ir,• :r9r,.w a ,C G ,!!.. ,y:�,r �
..
5.,6...t}..,• •d,
a .*yU+ E.'ne.l„ k �L,au, ,t a, f;� +:i. ,tid' �.! 7 ,,. y...!'h( !.
I.-�..„., „a. �; >, ,. ..w,,,, ,"r,. �. 7, t'' yY.. .i: %:J. .+,rcx '”.#�,.M -fa•.,
ti .5a�^� ,. r1 iad ^, ap , .� ,�� ..R I�...,.� 1 r d:�. 1,,-,, C 4 E,, t. a' ,: L S.. a , . t ,�... R '+,45s.9. .}.. rf. ,r;.r- r •V.. t
`u, i. ., ,5 p. t ,1 . , 4,1, �R:ar x , .,,i , ,.4 ��.r/i,:`.r, .dr a,t{ ,„ „� ,�,` I ,, ,��,, �,,_�, �.,�. .i 6^,Igl ,�r rt ., :i
1, .x r64ht V• --t di�,. "v;+..� 5 5R: „1�,� ,el.rC?a !>xS liw?: wfi....i..p c.ik:tt: ,rr � b•i�.., p,�„r
,..�.,,, S .. ,l. ct ..0 ,., ,.r. � n,. ii 4n ^'t a.d tM ,.. nv,. �,� ,., ...i...i''rl,,. ,t
��., ,.�-d`-�1 , r i�a.l:. j ..' ,. i. I,,tf d . ,.�#.y:,, , 'yS... ,. ,. v',^ n � , S..:r•.r .,,'ir�dx ,t,:I 1+
� .�.aw:n...��a ,.1 =2 t. {..0 4 ,.. �,.: ,.. ,i:...fifx� r . r !,-.Y...iriir, f ,.7i ,r: ., a, . p ., 1 .: �,.,..-..r.l, ., ,-r —. 0.,i#dr•, a ti � t.Va '�°k..
.py,, d !r y1. R < �1r„11, 4i r ... t ..,..,.,. ..,.,~f..,,.•''t'. ., ., 9. ,,, .,i,:, t d4.,...,..F.:,. ni,.xr .. . k ', E. p, ':r. .S
y
'H.,..
,'t,
..
7�t .,r..n, V,. !a_ t!}"..�•
Ni ,� ."'¢ tl - v 6, .. &41. .1111,. 4�1: 4.e,. aC. � t.'7� �, ,tr,..i ':3. 1.1',.� �'iPu, �4c, t.6TM 5`.,rn t,
�' •.,_: �: b F. -.:' •.G. ..,i y.�,� x. ,.,.! ,,,, ,1#'. .:9, ... ♦ a.t r. :. ,,..l.,,a,l r.� * , x.y+. .„".,'• U. 5;` "!.r {, , �S+ f-
1. a �i, 1 i : a 4b. ,,. 7..16, . . y . e . .4 : } iEyy66 i,:t„ r. ,1FJ w_:..•,...! a r t' .,t.� +. +.. : , p* r ,
t " .'�. r.'y:.,.r:�l!.}Y, •I ,F,p� ,a,,�... -1„d,S..k.,,'t'� o:.. 1,81+,`3 £,.; w.,f d:'F ..qx�, t .r, .1..r. l.ply°#r5 '�. ,{.,s, y '�;:,9 .SSS•,,, a>t:..,..., ...67....1
ai,. .,l,�.. fir'. }, �4. , .' ; e ,�; ,• ,” ,rP,1 t Z?it � �u'�{a�: «d Sn , " 4 .w w:�?ig':�,`s
k tqy h, .��W�,wi,� , 74 r Y ,y7„1 .• 6, t,,�k,.it. #n
c4as6a�i1T6r61uarLLlik,}.4M1.YsIF+w•U`,ti1 4 aUdUirr�C;r6»++i...6”®i.Sati°�ll.3ar.4'+�'i,,1A. �.Ls9�..ai,.+y,..lit++'.t•"'4.',`,..'yrl„a,«,1..5AS«'Iw 1d. lE�
it zIN,6#pyR t,
' 4,., l '',' Ik kir rd• .1'
{
v 4 ib.
, Q;r
;,
” t'Was;`moved b � Commtsstoner Nelsen, econded by, Conimisstorier Lgmbert; aril unantmous y carried to
Y
! ttitr ' �pp. a �, ` g below°,.
recoiri>e �d a +oval of th_ts rezone forI�ale=Penne REZ OQ O1, s>b'ect to the findings fisted
a 1, l�ecommencl the Board o,f Supervisors;adbpt a Negative Declaration With'the following findings:
A . ^ An'Tuttal Study was completed to compliance with the Califotnta Entroninental Qitali�ty
' Aet,'.and no s�gnitYcantnvtronnyentaT tmpacts �c%ere tdentified: r y
B. T11e;p1anrung.Cotrntssion independently reviewed, analyzed and constdered Ehe pxoposed
I�Tegattve Declaration^prior t'o irtalcing its decision on the project, and,liereby fmds'that a ,
'; Negative i eclaratiori adequately represents ifn ac"ts.assoc ated Vu t"n.,thts;project and reflects ;j
€a the independent Ju gem( of Butte Coonty tvhicl ts.tlte Lead Agency.
"1 R !�
i' Cr Find, on the basis of tliewhole recordbafore;the plantung Commisston,''tncludingthe lethal: t' t `
w; Study and any co at tliere.,ts no dence, a Date'Petule _ "
mments recetved, th substanttal.ev that th ; `
1
Rezone; Plaimtng Division Ptle No. Rez�00-01� vytll have a stgnificnt effect cn the
'enyironmert!
1
. and'
� 9.
to -fish
, e
tY, The destgn of the proposed prof ct ttnprove�nemts Wtl "na. caus envtrorunental damag
wildlife or, het+ habttat, and a mtti inns exempt on regard' impact to fish and wildlife or their
{ habitat is recamtnetided. The collection of fees p>irsuant to
!Fish Code Secti'on,711(ci}(3' w
and 140 CR 753:5, is not recoinmend'eda '!
i
y '
is
Recommend' a'` ' +oval of:Rezote 00-01 for Dale Periiie to the Board of Superutsors and recommend
I. Reco pp
tliat�the Board of Super+ sons adopt at Otdinance rezoning fioI ni TM -2 d TM S t1.o TM -3 property,
iiieiittfled as APNs 060-110-104 aiid 060-11o�11S; with the following findings:
6 is consistent �vifih the Agricilfural Residential"-General`Plan designation as
e prod ea, I
supported b the follovti+tng; ,
t
incompatible with an `ad'acent a 7cultural operation, since no
Aa The proposal is not, mcomp w r y &�
agricultural operation`is adjacent6
f $, Elie project is in an area provided with adequate private water service and on-site
sewage disposal Capal ility�
G,: A Bittte.'County Fire station is located wtlwi the community of Bitte Meadows; k
' approximately 1000 feet south.,
a
y' �
D1' 'kate access to the property is protded by Btgger s Lane and Greetmioote Coiitt,
54, E,_' Tire property is reasni7aliiy
.40c"ssible to .coiinnercial sei°vices and se, 00, y
5. uiitaln�-
conform. to'the ro
er lVio
Tie ext�titig 5, and 1,95 ac a p�+cels p , posed Tlviy3 (Ttnib.
acre parcels) zoite,
,
' e10 tne'nt shall ne re aired to coni ly With Public Itesoiirces Code
34 Fttu're restdeitttal deV p q p M
4290 (Fire "Safe l�egulations)i
I311`I"CE� O JI 'Y h :A�iNt1 �I ivtisslON :� ltih�t�T�s �� Jt)N9$, 20 00' N L�AGt; GW
1 d'
-
:
M.
a d't. 4 �"� I.a",4 y a y v M ry:5 �• s^r ".h" t �.'�. ; sMR,� _ , ,
ver w', a+ IeM1,r...�tr'��wr4k,,iGl m�,q r±r
.: r, *4i ` -l.N r„ c is "a r 'r?. �;"'t `?vt t.>!7!: ,r ,. i, } ,r.,°...�,. i„ " y: �;�ftr dr«y..., a kkt.,,=,y� �a -r. :.�t�my•i ,,:.a Ja yR, Sy,Sfl in X,::�' a. '.`a+%''" ^,. �5, s 1
*, �'• " rri:. , ., .. 4.a t',✓ .: r, ,a v ,., A.y y 4 ..,?rary m'a t *�u ,, R u �S ql, r 'rl ,��'y, 'i"d" Cva , 1 .r0. b rA r:av o b n 1
� �
� a ���I m P � � ° '�
Y > '
�'�� �� • a
.L ,.. rr .. :t" .. 4.,, fff{:' i4 r„'. _.. a Y, t:' f.. r'7".r .r,• ;1�'„ •nt.> r .t t.-,+ Y
r,a14 ,rtq t:. s: ,ah t. .t v. .t, . .a, .. .l .f;, t;, 4 ,.•..,.r.H; ,s;.., v.. .. r,r'+ AYi ,1 i• i'liatiitlid
hd r• .l e. .. +t.a ,.:ry,,1k; s,., .._y ix ,.. ti„ xn ,,,{, ,,, d1 .144V ,r.h9`"natr ,4 §tr- }. 1 tir''
fr "iJ 1?Y ,f ,l Ia .. ,.1 h:,.. y..° ;Sit.,, �. ?�'v: r, ,f. .� r ;, t.rr� ..t. i,i � 4� d�y,l •.'9. ,I 711 Irsl 1 ,.t%
5 r � e ,ra 1K a ,l 1L, S. , � 11 y . ',�, . r ° reN % Z ,�
. . •rr �,�I.i�• t ..},. ,.t �... d• ,X..i :«.. }.y '1. r '.�': 1,.n ��
...t. S•t o,r ,l.eV ., , pr .a; .` !t rt a- >•7 t•, f A, n a4 n
r , ,. r. . , i'•,lr .„ire a.a ,..f 1�;;t. ,,. >,.1, e+ �, ,. �..�,�+ 1,��•, r !„ ..�.�'''
.,, tY• ni„r .. t t4 # ,.-rr,,r,,,.�4 , x. h 4 s �1 4 ekM,:
>.., . fi.i {. « ,a ,r. iP. yi....wl. .. .,.tl. i +..; r_s. d... yd�... r
•... ,.. y;:,,.t�..,. .. 'v ,: Y 4.: �i..44 3 n!h4 ,..� t .., „�. Y pf .. ', .{. ^„ 5. .. ,. .f,�, Y �f..
rt �,... . 1 :fit. 1 , 4. +, i y,i 1 e 1, �,.. r,. . C,... .,, I ,.« U r ,.>, /„, A,...1'4 (: , .{,.PK1..;. . r. .•.�, , i 7 - t �.1�'' r
} .h• q � 4X ..[t , V'4. %, 4w... t : `fr i . � : � 9. ♦ n n. P. N c.. a., "n 7 ;�. r •f,r. r.:>•1
,r'{ 1r.e •,y i w. �';+ t+.t !,5.� i., 5 �'>+ia 7. ,w r i �`Jllr't .j � i n , 1- .,fir, ep. L,.3 '1=M bti
4 Y.Y1a h 1 .t 4. 1. fi.,. 0.. 1j' d c„w ), F v tY {� '1.
., ''i7r �' .,. C a
� � ",'{. kx, L tt, ti :1+ } , .,,. 1,a,•:9,lar. {r. .M t-��'{wl ' r. � , ...
,..,.w , 1 . r, t ., .•,: ,” $ r -' ... { .c.. � I
.�"� } x tr A ,,,,1 i +tie`<,�af, :rt _. i4 i � fir,-„ %1,..,.i,. 1. !'. Sk. ,1. ,t •.0. ,,�:n, t.. r, l._ -.i A 9
�! �.. A. ..�.. l4.� r, ..G ,.� ..✓ A.1p rv9 s. er, .'!.. Y.- rr t"i Payr
i S 3s :hrt. v.�,-. � ,.. . •ch. ,:,, i , ., a , .. Y . ,:.:qtr P... �..v..t GI,S Fr.....�� L , .,? ..,r„rr 1 •":.., a 1..7 c r... ,-,nL'iy'�r+ .5 t., r> 7l-..°• ..4,. r««. ,a."*.,,.
r h t ,.5, fs I 5 .. y.-.: . .,-..r,•s , d , a- ! Yr al C
74!'. �. ,.s r•i-.,11„ ..,. ,1 .'. .tt �a. �.� ,.r ,.. r..t Y .. �f 'r-: r. -. r p rx �' d,• r ,..br r+ r M17�
,. >._,•-i,�r ea,..•,, 71 ,. 4 ,r.,. �t, ._s 1t, .>� :,A�+A r, 4,_ r , r,,.•{,w x+ ,.NF, •,,a..t_,• ;k+t, � I4, .,r'4 r.0 y
.�A•Mk,�.l Irr .-,.p.,. ..r, r 1. r, ,/` ,�.i:-,JA' �«r. a.3a ,t+"'a ;>•
_air•. t. 1_.. L,4 , 1><.. kl ln. a F, i.. ,t '5,,. .a. '� +:ta- n 7 r.,.:'.t, fit•:,,: .., 1. 1 } rif?'ih:al I. '�.
+. •+. r'V a. , 7 J, ,,., .,.-,' rl I, rh... c:. t'a�. r4'1 4 t, • `1.1. ..r{r.
, «,.,4r
.
11 ,..� .,> .� 1,5 .�,j .. a.+. �f. s. -.. •.1. Y. ! j'4....
'•,i��
..., , , �.. q.., 1i •.n. A a. t�... eig.-,..,-A, ;..1t-
g tf ., , .r -_ r <h • - a.. ,,... r c. ,., aL.,- t,c :.,'t, q{ �:`"1 k.! s Fa... a+' x ' 1.: rr "
�. V
.:,...,
.. r, ar.,. ,, r.LN 2. , rr ,',., .. .• { t,<.t rt. a:a,ir: LI, : a`.. ,h {.11
--P41
-...yo
..:v. a:•Y.r, to t,. .., :'Lir. a , r r . r 1 r, h t. ,.,"�. + I, r J 1 . a ♦ r. , ;.
. It. l> �. �. `9. a. ,n ,> '{nr., ...!;pit
«r ., 5' .. .., . �.1 4 �:i .: .4. l.r, t l a: r ^ .•. i •1 • �., pp , ,.Yd.A1 r.T} r ° tl: 'r,•rt L M,. r.., I ,r
... .. r ,. ,4,,,. 52 r..` .:,..}r ,. , 1�I, ..rC6� Y. 4 `'•t + ,
,fs r. ItA.: t. ,,. 9, ..t l.t 'Y .. i. �+,. ..f, k6 ,., �.::. .: r. r':; t .�n'r .. ,,�. 'r;l±„ I3"',
ab 7s: ,1,. .. ., 1�,4 .L#.r�..1 "l,. .,, , . 1. � ,r a>. i +«.t ., e, , 'n r'f .fit; �c j:q SF .a alt'h „1 r �{., Qt C
tt P �. ,,_.., ::r ;, al. , 2. a. y. rc.. b,.,.3• } �,,. (. �� .4..t..' .^;.-1, 4)�'.
w{,§. t. s ..;N,S ,r; u -'z'{9, 1}n,`�4f •.�. a,,r'1. r ,y. ,..a ._4a:, A":.aa.: 0 1:�:.{ r �„• ,�: 7
r..• L ,. .. rvy... Y. t..tki•. ,.d7.,. i':. !.5*.r'li� trr
ii� r
y;{�{�{" ,W� rc r•� w .. gIP'rl
h 5 uNptil0tiie.'�:��.apY1Pl1iiA dA,.l1'�i kI1 Ak f
4k rah t�Giiru.c uuE4u , a . ;.r I , -1- w et lttitixtdtk t
t Y rr t
r.S l ,�
}
' i A � 4 1 f. .1.• Ir',il; 1q
f
d„ the. want to k p forming residentsahere, which creates4aa conflict. ie said,:the. County
y ee the four r}oncon
! 4
ezthei keeps it ;reszdelihal or go to 'general commercial and eliminate the residential. He said if they;are ;
t : dealmg with_ noncon£ormmg uses and dealmg with a request ,to rezone, now 1s the time to eliminate :the
re'sident'ial.. '
Chairman Leland asked w *'the Commission thought about zoiurig the back half C-2 acid leavuig the front
,
r Com�niss_ioner l amb-rt''aid she did not like the idea. She said there is <•r railroad track ii%between, iiut,'on
�.; iother side ofthe tracks there is'a �uce.residential subdivision:,
Chairmen Lelandsaid these are dee lots and h.e'felt they could hake a more intense zoning oil the back.
4, ...14
Mint: issioner :,lelson said the residents are noncoftfor>ning and i£the intent is to go towards coniiner'cial
4 the residents will be r'based out, [[[
i' {
, Pt_j 1pC'
1
Commissioner. MooneyF satd,;as the residents lea�ye,'there will be less need have C=1 zoning
e : Haid he
;t chid not want a.0-2 a ejo the arca that would be offensive)
Coiiuuissioiier Irelson asked if the rlCounty Wants light or�lieavy oommercial uses along fligliway
"A �{
t
Commissioner Lambert said yoii lia�e C-1; zoning no�v, .its'a matter of what level of commercial and how
f' nisch traffic T ighWay 32 can take, etc..
- a
Coni iissioner, Cage asked ifthis item is passed onto the' Boafd can theCoirimission add .conditions later? �
r, Wilson said' on a`rezoine you do snot typically impose conditions unless your going to initiate some kind
zoning ==He said it is itis understanding that the applicant wants this zoiung, so lie call ptit lits ' T
falirication facility onthts�property .
hoot knowing for sure that sot ieon'e- Id: be
Goiiun�ssioner .Cage said she could not vote for .this wit
conditioning this change in. zoniiig4� -
Conitnissioner Lambert said site has a problem �vitli the roque'steel use if it requires a `G 2 zoite; She said. she
wotYld ieconulietd denial, :she asked about findings ori CE(�A,
Atli
r, Wilson said it was .not I ecessar'y to deal with the environmental documents witli a reconiinendation for t
tiehialA i
xt'uVas moved by C6n niissioner lambert; er Ca `e and, `carlie '
,r dental t'or tCe&-tie .ta C'2 for Blattte RoUerts�lfndin :that alis isostitt a C-1 vett acid 1yeo idoomtnexid
not feel
4 Y x I 1 t. _ 1 A 1 Y y i I
'dotiifortable with tij�gr -Aiig to a C 2 zoitriig, She said fi�idIng that C�1: t`s m kcepmg wtth the height it o'od.
sctiool5 at�d res.iaents; and C�1 lueso%11d be cotnpdtiblel4
}
AYES; Comnussioner'Cage, Nelsiii ; kl beA' atCha rniati Leland
NOES; Commis"sioIle r ?Mooney
AESEN
No bile.
Ala T
S AiNED,
rro alio
+
I
I
F
s C3U't"I'L CCitJ%�� PI ANNINd COMMISSION :*'MIN
Y , 1 .rM +$.a tilt, .iP rF«":'�1 4'{Y n'nA :{y11 r� rytt..^7.`v� N 2 4Y�'wti l•'4!. x,, ,I l f6�ryr ,.a rat t` +.
17
17_
p, + r
k re a �t;. x°' r 4 eC: ,r �, `'', 'ia•i 'A' A t ° w r' ° 1'
u � y,l rp";,•s. n tt. do
1 M .
i Hifi a'�+ •Fr r ? ;, I, f I,a,',t r ,� 1(� ��1 � `# a „'�'"" w
- 1 _ i .�L,7 rw. '��.e � ;y.v .:a r.q Y,� ��` ux r e ! ti , r P-.:., a .i �.�'4,'y � 4S�", ,. �. �� }w♦ ra 4,i�^ M�4. "'rviwt ., _ up���'.r r."
IVA,Lk VYlLQ!JA&,O..—
ttt 61jed. to the zoning request lle i n'tig'!
itflbpak&gup 't rifol-nisAO-thepblic" §ofdi6,'WP:zOnc,l, flo4ald the pote
d t. Allow anoth6f parcel.
n 146: gald, the A � f6dinefit, W901
for another lwas,a.co'betn� 9,
d Mf 8. slasituation, under the TPZ 26fting,
I "; Willis 'Ifisiln his dfice'to look atUtd
J
X,6n Roliners; Ass� 'd h asked
-num parce �jof parce s� o' �- d a nber' 16nd
ze. OSItEdlt ne th
tr
uli6eTax taw—,Ou,i�t., 1 1.9 i t
'tta nrodiidion. iffiddr,"this chabt6r,may not �d."divi e in 6piitoels
iim h tmi� In s� mrP.P. .1z P. nqilliill�etla
al . , r, iJ,. ., { r .. ,i, • k ,r Y .. ' S',t , , .4,"`libµ, - , .. , +, .et.. ,. ,. a+-4 xu, n i!. .>~ i}.r 'i' w d'i4, .I t V 'i,. , u,`
r 1
t ,. +<. , 'a t. F : t .. r ! 4. $, w. .x , 4-:E', s -,. i• wi+ . h , '„ bS ..f x , i y,. 41 t. VI ...-,�.,
I: ': , .. 5',}.�,..u :�il,1:C,.+:,.§,.u.k ...Ya,_+, ,-hs a.=4..:;�,_1„I,.r;..,t,, �I, .rSE: „yt,.•.�t.+5. k .1j .s'3.:.,p¢af>_.,..1,r....,...� ,..7 4+2:'rM,t +l . c�fd<i,J,l,,1i.{n �,3t.Y„,.,•;t,�r„..�,, �5t.4 ,1.., kfiyr...r .i ,4. y.'dfi ,-A.t,",t.,, g „, t.,i..:. . 1w..�,,:I..l._., S..,.i.. b:,..al..,r.•;,;,. . •,,..v: .,,r..i, tt.l. . 4. .:{Ixi,k.... ,=4.Y.:e,kt .,.S . ,�,�t7n ,,:•,:.:a,Q.r..4.�,,,wi Y.„,.�,ri..,is„.a, .a.,r.., i!.,i .•i... .,.'rt,{..i e a.f�,t,r .. t,Z'w:,.7..t :,,...Yt..,.,.1, lr.4,.u..xY..:,..a.t :. ., ,.n: �,mg..'.#r.. I.„r-l.,4. .,:.,K,.r,... Aa..,:.cs,:,, . . 15r, +r. u,u♦.,Yi�,yt•,l„.�..l. ..P,..a•t....!.l- .11,.o.:_...•..,f'�,pePr;l ,,:t .. - { r"9 4•r.r+tl+'�.t,.,a" xtyR,i,1, ri.i. .,l+.e1r.u,t..`....t,i.7,',{,:r..y+k. . r.�.. Q„`,.trr.il.r..t ..r..�Y s..t...,,„.t.rl . i,,k, r+.,Lsr+,,„...�`..,,P94., �!Ya,S,:,:r�..;di•ro,.t. a+. dw:,..o}.:. ,yr,5 ,,'... ,i1. -1r.#,Ch1.,:,. i�. .;,6,,.,�.1.,.:..,w1,Y:_.P,,Ay.4.. ?-.,`+. 'a,,: ..1. tYn(r,w.,.a 7irx.47.t_,: t{+i..,Ly.ti�,,,3.,./.ysf".,. >,..�,;,..,. .u1:.S1,;x.,.,... .t.ru.d.�t'. .,�,:lG,.{,r:r,..r,.,h: j «1,3•titi. ,iti '.Z"kro•�'f,q',�•i.1'.0. ta,r st. Yi.�.#1..i,h.e . �i.41,d ) .1� . 4,r 4!1 �m1. ,.?�::M,y�C.,..d..,.'�F.p..�..J.. ,.d'.l,f,.1,1:4.nrl.,,.i...,.,,w,. :,,'., ,.,.Lx .a�,t-.`,,.: a M{�... 1, Jd..,i1a 4.,.e,,:„.:x,.r,a,4,.,,,. " ,xni..�:.a,'rt7.,,:: 11_. tf.`Y,i„i i 9l.t,M,.,.:4,A..,,t.i.,...•i.. :1i7r... :?r.i.....,=.,„ il. .,tN,bjj, f., :,,:.,,'u•b.t, 1C+i.JJ. : Y�y•a,t-� ,r.�rt1,,.1.l�..,.r �. :v.s,ac:.,,.:_x kr.,{,.'.„.w�';.,r,.1±1-;,M,.Ff•+i,rYr+i,. P .Lnr. a ,T1r+_ }P., naa.k,Y.I. �. 1, .d,t..o,..l.Y.,v�..r:�i,4 :v,.1:.-f,.+s,,t w, ,i ..} . .atI:' ,r,'i.dn,a '.l, . ka,i,,« ,,.('#.,#:.�Peqr.'v°;. „;,r -r. a w.�;r.:r.;.1 +rq . v..i• :..,,,oa. rI, ):y d,",�ttC,S ,1:,.�..irarr. J.�,i� iI,y.rii ,r^,,:.,ilyl?1t .i;ri,Pt..., `i,rS. _
I4.iI!:,"p. .w.4�.r�,,Ck.S..�,. l t.;�.,.".t ,,4t!",1p,• ,,..n:,,d.1 : rt5dr(':y • < iyI•)
t!"M�qV"':.'.•d,"
h„ „: #, 1 1#
rt .
Pi,
„,r �Y:,7-. 0:ix1'�#r:I,}•
..i;
'
... .�Yr.. 1
I a it ,
;. , .,, a• ft ..rY ., 5,., a :. ti- .,..., . c' ,E„ aril r�«„ Ir. .;-� _ .,. .. y 1 ,fix., ,.a« .. n: r.{ �a..,,» . ..:,� re ,...,g, ,.l •+rvl, � 4ai"r t., . i. `C
r �,. ., -r•N <,?.,. ,., i.,.f.,,: .., , ,r, 4a,i t.� ,. y„�l�r i f., .w,, :...: Ar.•'C: ,•-� ,. ., t.,�a :. .,:u�. i.9r T I...c,.r r,. t w,�. tr , ., I ,: tn, 3 .. ,. 4 ,:. . _ N � � ,� �, ... a �'� V . 1 ai. < ��l , t , d. n. �, 4'n. + � It .11 -, .. a .., a � s t• 4Y � ,. w t ; I
v. _ . A :y � , �r.:1} e, ,r:.. , ,.a �,. . L r, §N 4 .fJ snySk., >' r• 1 . t..'Y i.. .D ,t. a , : n, r,,.rr. ,,.{ .µ,i. ad:, ,
',T,.. F L,;{. (( .�:.. :1 .., pe r4 :.Y. �S� L. i y ,.iY. ,., Z : {. k,: rM. . tt g V � !i yy 9... ;F., ou � r r::' E,. •-.. >< l.r��q.. ",_ , t. !..°S':4'h 1. d •tt.,, rr. '•-y ,iz ri ':. rt -„t „l.v,.
.. �.0 ,h'1,:-i,rl Qik, I. ,.. .x k1i :,« ,k t«„.. ., t .+ki+:,�•,,.. .. 2. :�, ., ,r,.�trr:, .��n. iXt21i.. .•)T t, a.t, 1 ,.,:�J .rt w.. ,.
,.. i ..r ro. ,.. IY..n 4 _ r� 61. ..r �;r .., •k t. �x ,t,�. ., i v. ., ,'pr .. al�.4., •"9S, `s;..a�:i 4ayY ra.5, 5, .1a �'. „.,t,n91 a:J.., y,r.+. .4' M� i'f.t Id',� r• :ti' n} aY y :..4
a
hx.+..e.
1 i.....•r. ri ,..k h A ",,. , ,? 5-., _ J d,.. , :9y 4:.. 3f 6 ,,,.... n e ,,..
r„S �S.. n1 �i t�l t �r .t: +..d�9 Y Y5 ,.: ,.i li..�✓e 1., .i7 7:7i i 5 rtr'4i f�G� ai c� ':'�P" qi�
.,. ., l..+u.. S .., ,.,. .lS ,� .4 k, •.t 1:.. ,..„. r„ t.r a. e., Y:, d }v ;; v`a1 -,Y. •t.
i �,.tv,..,{. ^.,v � „ .v -t :., 1 ,..tSs�"' ,•.,; .: `,r., :ru r I
•fir
to :.,,, �.1 i ,,f.�..(`,: w�5 #.1 r,e; t:Sn
.+.� ...v .., M ..� „ x.. r ,r.:. ..: .,�,.r. t ;.':+ c. _,. :t_,,. .. � i. d
..,,i.. �.t.. .r.e t4.. ,1. TI ,v.,,•. .r•. ..., It�,. )�ur_i.: .. tl..,k�...#.i'd+,:n
!. .:., A 4.., ,. !{Y �. .fi vl. r... r. ',a. . .. cos„t �, ,. cl,...., , ..r iv
I.,:'+
« rr.(` r. :, r- :. ,. ., ,.,. ro, r�ryry.r, «�, 1. ,L°i:�u s,. ..r+IF.5g4:,L�•,., n,,,,,kµb..,y. ,, .. x, 1 J-,. :. ,orA 3a ,'1.Yw
r ..:. .54 ,. „ 1 .rt :� r.Y. « r4S+'�. kir d . ,.4�,.,.1 1.: ,.1r.�,� 4 .fid. �, .r1,�. 5 �I.,.a 6„_ � .Ca•i: .1 !., S« rL ..r„ r 1 i� . .k, ;a,,., r ,¢ 1..1 h i.y. 1:. „s a�, 6 tr ri.,
t.., ..ttt. r.,,. Jt �,`?, 1 ik'.,.,,.,.�,,.ti'4i1 r, 1. ','ss,, w. -„.a: t.e ',t. rl s.Tk.•i ..,�• ,,,a4; +la .:..,! ,.-.i'±,.,; r. '.P 4 .a 1.t. y, ,{ IAs::+.+ r, dJ+ r
ypt 44k i e, ,i ,,.. i x:fi .F a 1 ,qr •l !✓•p irc,, f1 : r Ps e .,t a >,,r4 4i <, P 4 :. , ax tau ., �: ; 1 ,,, .I
,M.ilrV.l..1i°Yi`,,.. ❑ `di•..t.. ,':,w.t-"" 1'0
.. s ,. -.4, ;.,,, , :,, b ,'r ,.t{." J aq-.,.,•, , ,. i5t , 1 .4:1, d Y ,f ,r i-�� t � ro „l., ;,<•.
,K
i1 ,S,7a ii4:.u':t.f9la.l<,t`y}1`,a•.3,,uw.Y.x#, sv,a.".r'J:i,:.t�k.•k.- ''ud`.' -i ,r'
rr�}i'6M`�R�ltWtxu��h1'471w�•+a+,�Sriwi+ntlr�.kS+,ta.%'�"e,'lkY..y. kSthS.=^'k' ' r��rll r
' IY
- r
1
, 1
hU1lYlifi 'ated.adverse e' fect'upon the continued timber growing use or open space use of oilier lands owned ` r,l
bet and., rodtictiorr. 3. The existing of an opportunity for an. alternative use of Mid'shall not. alone be
timb . P g` , , . tori. 4 The uneconomic
*, sufficient rson for granting a request for murediate rezonuh pursuant to this sect
character of the exi`stuig'use shah not be; a sufficient reason. He said'there is a. great tax savings 'by being in
the TPZ.
- ' as a roblein taxing ari 8:37, .acne parcel separatety froin a 10' acre
re
w
,
Comnussioner Mooney ask hf the p
parcel? t
I
Mr;. Reimers saYd; note hfhe has a parcel to look at so the appraisers cant
, find he 8.37' acres' easily:' He said he
j, y . r� tion, He said he would
would ;itot want ilia appraisers to hove to ;find his site b a meets aiid bounds desc p y
dike 16, see a separate,parcel:'
There W as a 10,mimYte break to rr alce copies of the laws -and or
for the Commission.
Chairrnai► i.eland said Ivlr.'Reimes't;point is tlia�t ilia Commission rieecisto make the ririclings iii fV• relatang._
t,
to imntediate'rezon ng from the TaX LaW Guide;
VTr, Reimers said the draws `a direct anally between tlhis and,agricultural preserve properties on them. He said
if someone s s a contract with the Coun , m gr p serve, with a minimum o£ 160 acre parcel, r
tgn ty, ` thea cultural rase
He thinks the TPZ is the same way. ,
` es and,you Wiil not divide flus t
you cam net say because it is zoned A 5 ou can remove a 5 acrepea, cany less "than 160 acres. He said he did
He said 1tlhas a"nitn rnuin of 160 acr y k
notknow hoW the Gornmtssion pan'rnalce the findings thatths is in the public interest. He said�ihe aliiihcant w
king to do. T1us rezone would violate the
si ed a coriracC with the County that he Would not do What he is as
contract He said the tastes are 169s tb.an they would be otit of thnea PZ. He said the imprtwements are
appraised at market vattie He explained the tax procesfi for' TP71a .
r,r,• v�iSt;c ��fiessoi's'.Office, said there are t'o inetlods to go irbm 1�i0 acres to 16b acres, from v�atershed
+:
i i._'�ii....::.:::avrn�n`rit!1�i?1't?'I(1111 Y10:
"'d r
I `•x;r Y y.r u { ,t ;r i - � i, a•y ,:: ri 'i a try i;:„ dl "w r m',r ow til, av ��� tl � d^ ' i t,..,,.
. , t:,:�.. , II k tit, , n -,.� t• . J4 � 3 ,,, 4 ..�' �. ..,,. - _. �. ��_ r i .�:� Pl. � ,., .:� a if, ffi f k4 I l:�ryrr rs - : ,_�.. , �, .: � .,` .. _ . .. , .., _ .. - .
TV
,- ,,: ..a ,,r. rr:,! .....t h. t, .4. it .i. r ., ..t t:.<, «,. C„ let, ..,. `s t.4 ...'.,,. ,r t w. ... •, ' >, t;;,i r• :,k:,. t.... rt; ra1•r .-.lr ',, pa, '... 41,_
,_d, .. 11.. to fia 3 x. d i r. x4
,., ...
� �.:+..,,.. 3t.. .t , .44...a:. c. � •,-, r�t,�a:,'`rt.. h.,d.�: a.n.,_.Jlr,.,14b. la. �1: �t.. ,:.. 1
i• � ..cl;l4.,.: �t• T>a.a;;a k: � .. y,lr lFi'. � .. W b I xS 7 ,..1.., i�. .:!=,II, ,. i-ry 1 ,, ,'.'i.a M
13 $ 5. $.., l:, ii, ., (• .n',9 f...y. ,. , $a4 ... ,. a.' a^FA4 , MY,=. S .. `♦ I.,,.r - tk. .. 1" .i,, ,1tC 1 i•,t.l,. Ysr
pp �,: z h a .
$; °i, ,fel �,x v 7 w..$nb .$ . I • ?41e��. (IF,,....j vA a,. x r t,. S,. V +i: .,, .'x1s'
r• a':tt r r <r ,. x ,, ..• At b:e �7.. it a `c+ : , r •.z n Mnt +r n ..��y.��.?,.Qrry �7. t+#., '.eF i ..,ts $. d ,. 6..1."e, o I ,." -, . -`i LP t + i•
'a:.,.d.l,. .. 1L t; •. a., a,,,...; r, .st, ., tP -i-4 1�. .,f. ..1"Fr}Kh(( ",9. •. �'6":�' l.r. 7.n d1 :f U....
a •va.,, y'.,r . u,r r.1 v. t':..i'... 7, il..w . 1_v ,.Q r�y� �, S .«J ,. 4,.. a.,r'/.., \,r .. ..., J.Y C I ,�,: rt, ..a' ;tri. i a i. M1Y s
,.r..,...,. , ..... ,,NQ. .# A „. r h"n7 ..,'� r,-, i. yu, 1 n,. i:�. Y} r,7,k
.,, k: d�.eE -v.s .M.ia a},l. fi`dAFw. xAi6i.: ti .:x. d. t"h...,d, 11.; $� \rt>' tl -tf,r
. ,w. Y i ? .1 ,x •,Ix.a4s ' xrs ,' , Il. xi « 1'r °r` .r'I^" I+l� F 't.
s :n t ..,x, "wA r... i..' 4ir� 1` ,.x-}., . 1} Y." t,rt:,• Y N t
tD1 _r i 6' ,.k, r er i .,; t .:, �.r , t+'t t.a• .S „4, aY 1c, .t, �.
A r.r ,l 7, ,.k' .�,,1A,1 t t. ..:G ,,..,.;y .,z,„.6, a k.'?r F: ,1 15::.
t .,, I,.a. S (f. a , v,;' x sV , .,. 'v 1$. , ` x -,p.:, (, 9,
..., � 4i;.,x• .1 . ��-., •, i .`�°.. a . ➢:- a. i. r.„ t . �... „r• ,'r,t f t:.a ,�. y r1 rx#'• , 1, .1
', _, d ,5 V:A , ..,,,.. r x a,t . , , ... i1,J4 � k , .,, t• b ,, f .1,. } :L e, atyo :, .�� r f., 1 .. .. ....... .. � ,.h He
t, r '1 `i.rel: A: his fp „ 'ra.;...y i
;'•, k..'R .. •,., o 4 ,e_ r'v ,` s- ,,\,.$. r :t\t.....111 F . 'lJ, ♦:reY. -. ji IY 1'i.. f, .1 .1.. .V. x -,?. 1 r1n n1.yJ1= F -Y .:7” r1 ,..'t�
,.-t...,. ,'1' ..tVVc. .1, � 'a,e, ✓✓rat 4. .,x.ht.4 ,.,h h.. �., =,;i
All
i. a.,, `Gi. ,...r,,,; ,''S,... ?., ,.. 3a,., Y h'ii.-«, 2.6t6 n.. ,.!,... ..-!, I, •.n ,. ,_... x"(. �..aa „lxsv .x. :V•,« r
i A , ar A,f., ,,r f, .d.. .Y... ..'1 » t. ,;n Q• a.k �: 1.F 9 y
,,',.� ,. 1•�... 1((4 .. //.�,,,, 1 .4'`.. 1yr, ,. r E'4`t�:! y�y ,rJi11\ �, i 1.,•ry1 .. t"y.�n y'r„ t ( ,,1}k p e ro.
\, S. t. i.,,. ,. 1. SW1 s a.. 'S...1!, J. r b1 .1 V•, lir �n N Yoe . •4 „.,. i.. 5 �1,, ,$A,, .,161,:. ? ;.:Ti: 18�t:? k 7 Y.V,
,
i'�hs..�+w�.,r,. ;3.•t . .. Vr
S ,t, -,I . x. ., I Z, ..Yr . .,t ,1.... ,tsu+
a ,�, $ rc !.'.4 , d w { ., :YIxc. ...i.
t k1(G�! 5: �M, s k: 1 v.1rh,i`r�.ia..i
:._ ,,. x,L,.'M1.$:., f,:: ,.V., w r.'tss"'*7....,... •.. ..e.. ".,r n', ,f ..��v {{ r5,
t,.tw , tr: '. Y. ,,➢4t, {a ,,.._+., , ;S. t,. ,. x .tr,'.6'-1
]ii, 4kt G � l,ra ., .. t a'.,,,,uJ °tr i r„Y .r r•-` �'4„1,
,o.4'�. r..
,.„ r: ,.; r ,. '➢.,. ,,. �t.J 6''r Z ,�.CadA. } :a ../ x i rr
�:
,.1�.,--,...d..,
?,?.
+a �.:[� .,11,. i [au i.. r 1 ,„• ,,E ,\. 'a a 1.,.,, ia::..F ;.3s1 1 arl ...5 ,t k .,,V.,., e$I 1. �..� ,et
.. 1: 't”.,. l.. .♦<,,3 1,l., .,,V$..v ,,,k}.: .. ,': -...s iY.a r,. 'r,1 h- rr.$1
...r y, ",.a) ,p.7 ..,.,, ,,: ,,.. t�r�1.., �,, .., .4 0 ;�.�.»na. xt-..«J rbn; ,., ,, is r,.. ,.A re. ;Ta a,la ,1'+
,. T ,..t µ.:rd„ h\ 1 (r.. I�w , � � 1ku,. i V ' 7 , I -.,'.
,f, 1 :.� � , i;;t , .qq,ly y y.;', alt ,y� dtV+� tt1; d, a,” r' .; aj`X ', afk i �`d� � ; �a <; !�' h?f.f �'1 { r,a,:'^ o`Jrd: x. 4:t:�s•.li•ft.�r+F
�.; }t.!: r., ��.,t.14�J t t.�•,t4 `.ii' ,SY ➢ tf , Y I,.. n� ,v:: r r, -..Y �.I,::+ {n,. , ,b 1 ,.As,r. «rd-.S,«ari+w,,
6'1,5yk. h�,., ,4% .. (' 1;1,«, S! r1�y` Jki�. ,r. �$' { "k sti r,�, , '4siilixr a-+�..+xru.+*Sf�.tx r Mxt""r5"-.'`'af`.'s. -
"�•.Itxliik7kil'�t",165si1:1'L,96`9+'kti:1�46.NrL�urta„k T11,L°1.'•;w,.,t:'i,xsww.il��,.+1.,,,['�'+a"LJ._.5;q..,. 3sa a,� 1'ii}tritttt'
is kA !V titll I IQ, r9
r7 �'$ di p �• rp k. v ltay t yt+�.naN,
:
f;•, r � r� '"t
r
={ �� b' OF �+L WEsA
L`ANNA1URLTH' AND 6E'AUTY ;It il;j
rL� J.,1 5 I •, A,
pit-�'`pLANN{NG{ DIVISION F
4 ' t
A�t»� }
DRIVE OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
^`�t�ig"C t Yt" R +' i'' • If CENTEDRIVE•' oROVILLE, CALIFORNIA .95965.3397
7 COUNTYP,
'"%,ar,`; "#tip "wk XYZ r, TELEPHONE: (530) 538.7601 }s
FAX";(530).53B-7785
TE C�IUNTY PLAI�TNING COMM SSION
AUT A r
' AC'aCION AGEND
,
KNE '8, 2000
i 3
r
-T�IVIE.
I'LACEt Board of Supervisors` Room
,j.
County Administration Center
25 County
Center.,,Drive,
a;
�r
-
,
:
broville; CA 95965
. s
T, koUDGE OF ALLEGIANCi,tE
�r P�
ROLL CALL - Corrimssioners Cage, Laniert, Nelson,
Mobney, and Chairman TJelarid,
III ACCEPTANCE OF AGENDA Commissib ' niei6ers and staff;may request additions, deletions, of ,
k
— cliaiges in the Agenda order. -
2000 continued to G729),1GMay 11, 2000, (0l�), and YVIay 2, ; 2000 Coli) } x
�VILNU7C,IrS , Apri127,, ,
,
,
V; CONSENT to'
item's arc set for approval in one ir{gttbnx
These items areebnsidered non-Coht'roversidlr No G
presc►ttattells Will b+r Made, if 6xv0dr, sOnia ctitt`,stibns tnay be riskedA F
The Chair•"will ask if aiiy cbn htissioher iir ttietnber of the publiewislies tb pull atbitsent`ite"tti for diseussioha Brief �Ueations
inay be sl dd on any, item
r,a �, - 1}
S[1SINESS'FIYOM THE FLOOR ON IT�'h ' NOT ALRLAD'Y ON TING AGENDA tpresentatiohs l
�y'ill be limited to 'five tith�utesr. `The i'lanhin Cbtnnii5sioti is prohibited by Stale L'aiv froth takuig ttetion Oil any ite.tii
preehted if i0s: ltot listed vitt ilia Aget',dit)
4
ubh
c '.fo
r
VIT, PUBLIC HEARINGS The `chair Will �a11 foe staff comments, 'fhe hearing will be opehea to t►re p �
_.
pr poll opponents, bbhrhents; and telttiital�l Tlii: hedring will be closed 10 the public and diseussion t onhed to't►te
pr pollis5ibtia The Conttttissioii Will theh ittake a, tiiotibh and Volc oil the itetnl
1 tes so that dh inteesled p Will
tirtid i, p
►t is retttie ted ilial publie cess the onttnissionr Cgllowing your p esenfahnn pleas p y. address qn 'tlie
iiintted tittr hani+r and
►tuve an o iorttinity to add riot
tttitiated iesente ons e
p
speakers sheet sb that the teeord �Yill be deawlte,
' NIG Cts tsl
' � � 1'AG>r 1 ■
d.
" ii bt 11` Ti 1�1�I`i'Y P,LA � IVt1VI $
Y Obi M Ai;6billA � ,ILIN� $ 200
cit
.
k• ,,t.r`; v „h k'� r {,tv x r:.i�:h a•2i a';... ,i xu U ➢,•,•,Yl i AY'y:! r 11 'tSWi,. Mr
i .�`, +§� ix F Sax,x" !"' );�' 0.; ♦,. �t w 'rt F:rYr 5ti ? d �!. �h n•° t.i,�tk 4 {°�S' y°y
l." V, � a . I?VW , ..^ x��a>.�a"i- n-:, 7, 't �. l b�;�+l a � i ..: www. a�'. ka.'a u� �� -'.''if` N .Y r "w'^v.•6 �11� 't --. �'� r' - ,-. _ ... .. .. ,- .--
.. ,rM rti ♦ -... .1 r .,..,. _. .. a re ,5.`. i.. . ,- _... : m..,.-. • n.,::
1 :'�,i' •, ::r, b i 't$4.. r .Yr K.. r„r. ,...: ».� Y, .... .,:`,i , a{.:r ! a ..1 h4t4. 9.,:y. tt. P r fJ t141'
a. 'TM. ,d"^aa . 4$r. S kl. r ,,;h a •t l a-- r e
_, a. t: ,,,., .� p :•s tt t, r !.. r: . f: W� ,.,- n S„tP, � 1:.4ro., � .,M 9 , ,. 'f � �t:!
,I . Y:D .;, r,.S i ti h •.' 3 : �7 .;5.� , v) r . C 4 �.� � t � S
r .auT, y : 1ri,r. r r � :�y :4 ,Y. ',>tr h! r• _ .t , t : r t. ,, , y..rt
'.:.t..y:+,e, .,..«.,, • ,«f a•;:.. ;yr, rt.. r �x� I. �1 !r l�.:A ` yy +•
,:, .r ,.. ,. R , , ,f. .., A . � .' ,$ .t r4 � , . r... r• 'i:r�: °s ..2.. F$1 1yy'�7•J:Zt: �i ` �trtr� ,A r .. y
iGK... 9... t. u. ♦. 1: i:..'A,
11 :b .. t,,..rrl.t, ih+..} 1 i:'tb�f � t,': i , ar. ,� .{ v 1:,. f '•i?, + :Ar't.rti %iy,. ..> t{b -"+� r:�> H' .�.. •,l•�' p r.9,.
•: i'•tdi ���: .,.� r,r� ,5�}:,� e A. r,yr.,4 ,. 4r< :ti', IT �. �, 3, .. � y::.y � 5f; ,, #E .ly. l< o y.N° w: '$�i '�«n r4rl }"''I, ".•1. n4 }'.'';�(#3..
AW
6 roS'. 4o1{Iv r"!.b Y. `e! �:. ,. t d.: . `�:,. r7• V r n t °w .r9,::, l i.;
"r .. b ii� � �%.: h jig ,
.•,. „„ yy. �; ,,. ::, dL.Vr.'i.a+ayn:•, t.'i r
yy ., Y.„u , , '.�p,.L r.,,.>�• .:v �,. Vit: t e.. u o s>pp,,M, ,• _7"... ”, •.n., ,af ,�,) .,i. x..{ �,•JJD.,
.. A L«<. k o h 13 r . ',> x.: .,9 .ir: ,, „ x .., :tr . 4 , 9,.. r rJ J. w,i l.. vv rt° ,t .} .. :, t9 t:: f „'F C .,�:${ }, r„t.'.*,,t', r 1 !.+�_ . "SW 1.• p -• r.., .. r
�a ts: "O"ll ,t«'e�i�,. ,u4.p :,li ,yy 3. "vrt. .��4•, r,�it, �.1., �•+� 9-rx•v,.. '� „t,94,na p�. �.. ,er. c�.�...r'.«•r,J�cYr. a.,- t4- � e«y .�rrt � f. ,9 ,.I., -r$, f,K ar.,
-y-� .rl �y -,F ti>, i' .J 7 .Y �-+ ,$r r I t :4 '4 LY. �•Y c. ,t.4 �. y. rr �( .,rY .r5 1 I.
.i.Y. �. .'tiiS' k.' r 9 c: `�. , a of : !: i,.ft Tu: _ ,ry ,,�. ”! r- a'ti a: rr�::.
.:• ,; �i':.. �w .. 'C d':rw �,i':�17. t 1 +' nd•: .' :. k �,' stru>: � ...... _ .r �f.' .�. �y..a.•,: .;>r , .�.t .�. YI'•. f. e � LT'- ;.w., >.,� y
,r a.5. ., + i . �r r c ;.,tr,,. r r1r. •9 , r58r J. �� ...p •!� rl:..ryr- j , a. arr e: �. ! 1�',. (
:�,,y }.:�rt .YM.',e :^M�`+�>:. y'7�.•-.E�r9u k.,..:1.">r:.,., 7.u{ ,r.._ S.J� (etir..:,t'1...r -1.r .i.,. r'd..w/�.
r r:1q.4.iu.+1:9:Vw,1. "%• ,1 , r iD.lr ,,:!a+1 +•'t rtr , lid« Jse. .�1rt ,T ..
-...n..,t1, ..r. t it .,,,, u t t t .r ,., r s (. . t ! {
`p ,�yr- •, ,.�: I, ,,p5 r-, ., .. tt..:df..!r: c. ^,::. 'r hr .r.tp t :Y.„rr+r .,pr,. .a y.uA. ,u..a:l �1a n.r„.t.",
r+r.v,v t Fa,�d a .,s s4 4G1..r,...:,. ..,,1,_. , , ,S. 1.7I E ri..r•�trttYt:, , n}.. r: 1. 5..a i.�,sl.,.rr: fir::,; „>L..r1.r.Jti�s, rl,rr:,..,.
t: F .tv, '. '1Tv4t S w 1... ra. .:: „ t .4�� .. Sl•[
',n :..•1. ;i I. .. , ,'♦' p.. ,i 9 ,1. LI. ., ,r r�..r 1, j) rr., , Y d .r . >.:a . ,.�: f+t rn.. p [��.,.�
.$'6„e , ,4 .(, ...� ,4 .+. r� ,y ..�... r.> e
�r , `tis:.�«",. m..{.. S....
>„ , 'Y a,l1��P �", .,
�A,,, A, , .:�t .'.. �F,.,:� s. !LyV .1, I c 7ny 4,.:T .,q.<': �a : d t• r.'S ,: .i
.J.1c.., ;y
1 ..,
t+tx,�,, 4 w, .T � i, fy Yr . r r•l r � � ,F,•> $. . l a9 $,4 •,r.. l r ),';e .tit'., r. r,i�
> .!rr.. > {: :.1. .S« .B ,5r ..•, :-1 r...r .,:•ti , ^ nl{ 3 #"'. 3!! 'S 3ri,. •.
,: r- ,.1. �t r. b :S, u, -:.,, k•rt" .r '�<1. n :., ., r�u. �1L (N
r4 z . }'.,.e•• lie• t u NK.. .y .S. +1 i,;. •r',it
r J ::..-:
'�.6 ,., •.{V. v3. t, si, i;,•...).,}"'ti s. r,. ,r.r, Y >a, rn'' A4S li ,•a tt kvx y..: l+�d'F<:
rrtt •r. � �Tr .iru
r•, >.,�i.... �ttl:
L,. t i.. 4i do a d'rnb- w '1n r ., t.>- ¢ I .,.. I: , .,- ... 1 a t ,.4 I:,,�D4 ,> ... as ,t.'. ! 7 ;,.. U x•11§...,.. 1. IP. ,C1:'
.•, w., J tS 1)1 {S
e...}.ta � .: �y �1..
,.C.lu., x. • rsi7 y .. 1 ,,., >�1,:r'1 trT' ,.-r:.,:: ,.
rs. ,,.<uil a t ••nv t�T 4a.. Il.q, i. V I, h t�t+ n tlk"Y ., ,cf7., a +P. .Y. : x�S_ :.yF...r.,a,. „y t a14 . , 3r ,v J.: r. , s1....�4 1._. 1 1
t't ai ...6r �iy , �.. �4 t�+ �� �i:1Z.�a:,. , t r i i r �. ^ r .v r. � ,q � 5 ?S'i , rf.
.., r.. ,. ,�, f5 ,,,:. i•r.. -�A. ti -r. ,1, n� ,k,tt 1 tt "•4A` ..., �'u, •r'e Y�nq...yr., y�M✓�.". „,,.G,, ,r:n Hq.t t' ''.:.1 ... J ,a f,. . 1 �.,iS ii.' {'r,!,.:w
>$,�: �+.0 , s, �_ l: ,,.i, L'i ui $7. re}�i �trz''ll 4,'. r:.�r, ..w.yy4+r 'al•,ai: ,.. ..,. . sa.,>a41. 1 1 ,..�i' 4r t' r .t. a�".. .,r 4• .�'���t,j�51��..•-r. •e.y
'T ;T.,[',' ,,v+,P:, 1lot'rur t ha
, ti 5•;r , +. W,. +�'�ir• : � .,. �``iy 9 �tsy
;,:. .04.:. t,:,,�::.: .':�ly%(t.r•, i't}: '�� �, �t.lY i. s•k rl,0ig ,tY u'.t:?;1{�, ;1'g1SM,r: 1-i:':W,STtir9.'.., �7 �:'rF. 4"t ,.._•.. r,a"�:,.1,' 1.4.«�4,..r:�:'d,.f+n.�''Y••r
ri I!<1 �(y, rq...DY ,t>,r ,r.r,� .L.. (`Ir e�+�.)),4.•fF, v14. }�i. ':1 AV �,,,`}�..41 T1'r .,T!'k,.Fr',. r},, Clt.-1F,A'-wr...r�.. r.(�. 9�t �;...�'a�i•!e� �!t;««v #Wi.',.'.,t�LxA.W . r v}u �. atj,i%
ll�l9itWl+}aL
lO
t
r
L r _ 1 C• j ti! 1 y11.
V a1
,2
7S
is rt � � r {IryJyr,es,rlty �..
'Cha recommendation of County; sfafffis.,inchcated
below. It is only a recommendation an& ias riot yet been considered by
the I'lannmg Commission. Copies, of the Staff Reporrt are available `at the Planning D>Vtsion Office
A. A proved
C uck 1VIer►no.' (Butte County Fire Department)` - pzoposeed Negative
h
Declaration. regarding, environmental,impacts and Use; 1Peoo n 'ori a115 acre lease; r
�r U square foot voluriieer fire station, with an, office and a bathr. ,
tti area. The proposed fire station will be a galvanized rrietal building and will hnnd ted
water tender Vehicle and one fire engiri6l, The bin lciing vvi11 not iurtially be co
a : electrical service, and wilt not contain a bathro,�m. These'amenities,'alongwrth'
_ tiS
an office,'Will,be added later when funding becomes available. The'fire station will
:. be'located Otoximately 42. feet from the edge of Cherokee Read. The sim
iatron yvill
use wilt riot involve the storageiof-any hazardous ,materials or fuels, Y .
norrriallybe uiirrianned with voliuiteer firefighters only coming to the site to ,pickup
w
the fire vehicles:to tespond to an emergency Maintenance of vel�icles'will not,occur, '
_p y
on the sites- The property , located onl& east side of Cherokee Road a roximatel
800 feet°north of.Pattersori L; aie/Tippytop Road, Cherol�ee. APIA 041=500=0I0 (SB)
r
(UP00 11) (VIDBCI) r'
h
B.` Recommend Approval 5-0 i t
' ental irn acts and `
�.
Ne alive Declaratronregardingtaui
r� / acre parcel from TM -5 (Tnnber lVtoun environm a arcels ` to TM- P
i 93
0 a.m. - Dale Penne) p p g
Rezon a
3'('fimbcr Mountain'3 acre parcels) and Rezone of a 1,�5 +/- acre parcel fr4rn TM -
2'' �xiiiiher Mountain 2 acre parcels) to TM 3, The property is located east of an
adjacent to.Bigg
bis Lane and Greerimoore'1060ri, east of the intersection of Writ
T ars, ;acid Biggers Lame, in the col imuji of Butte 1Vleadows. APS Oti0-110-104 .
;` and 115 (DB) (PILE MZ b0 Ol)
C.. Recommend Denial' - 4-1 1
x
5
`r act
x:-04. iA4 s dame' Roberts, proposed Negative Ike c alato C g e gal Comnierrial)lon two,
aAd Rezone ;from C-1 (Light Cominer t ) •. ad'acent to"Notd
;parcels of 1.$3 acmes eaclit The property'19,located int`theast if and
` rI
+ eet southeast `of `West Biglrth
Avenue State IigliWay 32), approximately 650.,E
r
Averill, iii the •Chico' areit; API
043,100-010 and Ql l (DB) (F1Lr ILIrZ 40-02�
Gontiuiie closets to June 2g, X000
D y
tr �. ,
z
Ii
� 0 'aetnr - Paul Yandeglrift proposed Negative Declaibatl6li regarding environmental Xhtpacts
and R xonc frons TPZ,.1d0%`TSI' (Trmher Y't`eseNO l l6il or,
pa cer and �Jatersl ed
1'rote'ction Qveriay) to T1V1 16'0/ WP (`TirY►her lVlountain j 160. acre pareelr,and
` 37 acre site within an 86 -acre parcel `
Watershed Protection �7verlay) an an 8'e
., . ,+
J
propetty is located �pproxiniately six miles north of the Toon of Paradise; at S SA8
Slcy�v y+ lvlagalia� at the terminus oflVleadowbroolc RanOh Raau, Wh bh intersects the
t
Sky" gay 10U0 feet south o De Si bl4t,Rcsef` _ rt AMI1665 065=06�-005 (DBj (l? Z 9 - 1
�bl)
I !
,h
M
r
,t {, �r I•t a ■ tCCl!I`A�d11NI1SONiA'
C�llA � l�p#zu S 20
,
I r ::ly . r ." � � a E� yrlJ- .�Nr •hArr -
.., e Y x ry F.M. nr.. 1 , .. 1 Y M•,-11. L, ! .Y� rk :A... ,s�r;'w:.. M:i,�7 .1 Yk, y1R a ,f M t:.
j
�'d+. r::;. .:,1 r ti:t•a,+s.' FW ,o.. ,,:h1ea •re 1.: x r'.,1. �" 7N a.:v .a. r•e Ne, .i��:. k;r l..r,•;'„:.p:1D 87i �,yrr .a b0+, e+ y,} z r be` Ar 1,
' _ '':;�,, .�,c,:1. •y,.,,,.v.... {,t<"..;n +.,a,,r°'.' r ts.,l'•r� <lir'•:t ,;�e,:.r, #, , °r .r r�ar�J;✓.1�r�i ,,< ,Ir ,;r�,:;,, t"��'`.:,, ai''Sj ':�: r r rYfr'"bar>Y� �^wY 4a ',",: ' .",,' d ,'5:, t�'::� ��':�: :,
v ,.::,� ..:. , .,..s.:{.v,•M r1•,.eat,,..,r, •l.t:.+.o,..ttie ._,..::i' .... . .:....:.. „I• _.;. . „ ta.leh: ,k H.,W .., r ...�,,._x. _. w�' , .. „ ,,,.4... . �+tW. rich ... i' r , .,,..r, ..:....
i
�:
':; ,�
,, :,r
�Y
s
d`M
I
i
I �'...,,I,.. �r�.
t
J
i
r
{
_ � �'..:i
rl
M
,�'h
i '`
:r.
,::
� � ��w�
�`��";
r r�'
"i
f •.i N;F
� x,
r
IS`'
1
�t
;I
1 'r
�:'.,. � 4
i
i
'.S'�';i. ,�.
i
j:;`
� "!'
�� �...;;:'�r
". t �u'�.
,i
r
r.
� , r
� � � iG.�pw„pi � ud5 V �� �� i
4 ♦ i.
=
i{' 1
pT
t M K i Vt
z
i
1VIr: Pardo said that'heading south on Highway' 7Q there is a.vista:o£tlie Buttes and a:towor will alter the,>
4
k.
t w T+ , r
t. i, j
a.
�vista.
He
e owner 'said he has had or 30+ ears said there has been no crop
Olen, Akers prop sty this ranch f y
, i
dusting on lus place or the adjacent orchard in'tlie last 10 years. He said it would Ue a small` arriount of time
'
in -Midi the tower would be visible against the Buttes.
k ;a
Commissioner''Mooriey said lie could not think of an tun a farmer would use that would be 150 feet fall.
yt g
He `agreed it would be hard toI alth the tower.
Tlie loarin '' �i+as closedi
g
}
5
h`
Chai nan Leland said a 15 foot tower would be more intrusive than a 100 Foot toweri
y skeet if the painting as required
Comiruis er 1Vlo e a
p • b,
lY1r } etts said that the Commission can determine.the type and oolor'of the painting:
'.
.
Chi l�"lido Seland said he' would approve this request at l Ub feet with a neutral color. He said the applicant
can come in for inodif cation to add height at a later date if necessary.
Coirimssioier Lanliertsaid she could approve a 15Q foot tower, lattice, Vrith the top being paintedin orange
r
and `white'!stripsi She said shedid iiot feel that t.h,eview of the buttes was that iI of a problem at this
locati.bn, She said; she would also vote yes for a 100 foot tower; noting the potential, of other carriers'adding
more 'tower applications;
'+
i
Commissioner Cage said she. agroe with Commissioner Larribert, but 6uld.11so like to have a red fight
on the top of the tower.
With a 150 foot tower:
Coinmissinner Mooneysaid he had no problems -,- - _ _ -
Cliaimari Leland'said he would like `to go with a neutral color at 100 feet tal". There wag:a brief discussion
on aesthetics verses safetys : A" said 'Condition 3 should be deleted because it is redundant. He said
dishould be changed to' add `°not' after.,'`shall"
Contion 11-
Cotiinissioner Nelson asl.ed if there was a difference in radiation levels if the tower was Moved closer to
Highway `70.
eLuca said ve little differencei He said thele will lie mi Yiinal impact to landowners daily routih
Mrs rY ,.
u
airiian, Leland seconded by Coniiiissoiiei` Nelson, and unaiumotsly canted toapp"rove
It w s moved by -Ch , t
j
L1se Perlin 00-12 for AirToticll Celiillar, fora 10Q foot High tower, stubject to the tiidiiigs;and conditions
lisfed below,,deleting Conditiori'3; add that the tow er is to be painted a neutral' colas and change Coiiditioi�
y
l 1 'fo add "not'# after the word zrsliall'�; change the'Wo' "stealtli'� to ,attics" Yn the conditions,
(.
}
_i
Oi
1 Adopt a Mitigated Negative beclaratioiy with the following finding i.
{
l iiid that an Initial Stud .was completed in complianc0 With the Cal fotiiia l✓iiviroiuniental
_ i i i g` ` 'roiimental efforts alta
Ouality Act, that said Study `id0iltified potential si Iliflcant e1iV1
}
■ M ' 25 ' 00 W aAGc 3
MAY ,
COt1N"i Y "PJ,ANi�flri0 COMM1SSl(? M.lNi1'CC5 X0
1
h
a� I
�V�
..:.'��
:'�
.'".':3
'� i
�.. :.-,b
k'
!A
'�a
�!
L 4
�.
1
e.... �':�,i�
��
i�
I�j
i'f
t
�'
. I��.:.
t
��I'� r�
J;�
H�
�I
11„
i
I
�'#
I
{ �e i
P�
r �,
i i � el^.W
.. �... - ui.. .. _., .
N t,81 "V,�T #,iLSl I Ili VA 77 7777
A
All %
The:16*erA or orate alattice and shall be aimed an6iitr- I 6olcif:such .that it fits d� 'gn
iding
f the U96, Permit andbuilding 'd.
to
Witat i6harict&16f the protect At( D Nor issuance' 0
with the agricultural
all submit -revised 61evAiiicing of 1 4id lattice design: and submit -colonfiateiiiii
aiiigil :sub, revise
I
The tower 1 it 6fthe tower tbtjj6,Pla11ffing,,Divisio,n Or rpvidW',vthd, approv,a
i hshow.hebo c
which e signIAM
�4pproved latti d dd
s� �Ij co ii�orio'to.. the,
ormIts shall
't d" -th thi Permit
constructed with
approved and
d calor;. jtiga,i,pn� a
co t
We (M
approved
t
r to 60 JAW tJ of the tovitf 'It '6,iilt al aerial'applica applicators shall notify- Alj'�agrj
prion ns, u, C 1011"i'.
be, ittice�deslgrfe The notification shall 2
ty, io
d' in ffi6 C 6un , o 0060611 of f
location - a
regis ere, that 11
s�6
applicant �slj Mi
lip-t6wet.' Tfip'� ap'pI t all
u diniiteg, 0 t: ,
d f
Ilia, latit -44e and e coordinates , , ion Of flic
have notified to�'qonstT46�j
the C ount
agnculaerial a tpp icators rp 918 in e' v
tower. (Mitigation ,l ea s a
c e "rile
building: `641 od 9
shall comply e and electrical
ywitij Ali appficdbi �bu n_
thd Facility I I I
y.
wer to III&
t ed structural fheBiAldi
t .,8lidll su nilt iffoati ftoma.,regis er A tun 0.1
deft, on
Fadility '000174 Or-, h
- : ", J) hirty, 0) feet in eig 'Will
of �t
that all,Aggoethted, tower81A excess:
D ivision�, a pol6§ and,
, I I'.- tjjifonri,%'Aldi Code.'
'sustained 'a s je4iiiiedby the 09
withSt winds
rI
.... ... b e` tl cil I
o A
shpermitted'n IPP - ilit
No adverts nig or display a, Y
A',
adversely affect Jitstrucitifo. shall not on-site sewage disposal`
5,
nin, b t
t v�t.RQm:iho,D"-"giotlofEnviro, ena Health.
without'Written : I Division
6tits rippairarea.appro
Sys_em
Yj
ions
of Facility shalfhot, 'Vjq 4te any existing , aced res restrictions:
6. e, the
Aiain pine road
d6thdt qdC0s9 toca,publ,id y t 'd
T -he Fabi ity shall hiiob'a tw.61916 (:12)'foot wide all -w,., feet pt Vdtfioat
s
40,000), Ptifid 146 apparatus een
sUpPOrting,,a-fbrtY and 0
r_a0abid:Ibf
I Ther shall t go d�pt fol timer gqAq.YpurpOS §
oUdootl chiblepteoulPinpil
e 6 no stora dp
regulations o e —A the FCC, A and any other
fteility shall thin burrent,itmid -a' r, ds, and fegu
�h
9 d
later su�h Viieffit if s&li standards,aft,
Facility; t
tAto and/or Federal,. agency with the authority o regu
rhigL
or.responsible,,'POAY shall b the Facility into
y- owner , -
-hanged-,, t prppert 0',0
alationg 'Are, changed; effective date
ise&stamdard, and t�-'bils within -ninw, 0), days of tie,
with such reVi gutati
ctimp'll'a,ftme d'Seliedtile ISL mandated
Idtiong br I ent pomp lanic
bfls.ubh: atcls and' 0 Aless, a itiort sttif 9
stand
controlling
s e c "lif 'any flnid,
d Facility of b th sha"I 'lot 9 ellerate I of Vadil ids on, le
in excess 0 f th C
nC
electromagnetic 'equency p M#) bftddI6Iequb radiation.
adikion'(E,
ad6otdd, standards f6fl ftiffidii 0,#Osdei, Is anidildedL aver iiffi6,
'It 6 .1ital, to the health, safety;'oi welfare of person
It �is f0tind" that the Facility Is Or W1 e,(
'Idei(s) owner shall b
ifig.'br'fp' 'e-it'such facility, i I I I and prope,fty,
irk"' t6iiity' then the
siding n A
iacetnent of the Facility. Iii no case
�d solely 'is
jointly1101 9( e,
fe
found t
6 jd6iti6wif it u
shall the Va6ility remain in', I r
Tlie Facility skull `not lie 014hd t a create hazard to health, safety, or Welfare as esLilt of FMF
it long s It meets
spi. Ideill y sp,
dint ointhe l a
pto FCC T:65.,
u
-
i
Ljftp, vdu tv PLAWNG CQ Y 2 1 2000 ■ p
N
I �ir V
I lttplp`�4d1p'i��lt \s,l�a't
liJl�At,Ul1 s ` kluw�k�.iN7r -0
I
,
GO
I
I
G l R-
thea hcaiit-shalt post'
Priortu of the building: permit fo> the installation of the Facility, pp p
issuance
a performance security in an amount anal foimdeternunedy the Director of Development Services
li ft uenc" consultant selected b y the
st of a one-ame test a radio
that is sufficient'to cover the co t Y q- Y
Facilites RF/E1VIF emissions ;comply with FCC
' County sufficient' to detet7mme whether the
If the Facility's em ssions'ara detorinined to' exceed FCC standards, the, applicant 7s
'
standards.
re' wired to pay for such' other tests and oilier corrective ;measures as pare necessary, to establish
successors and; such noncompliLL ance shall constitute sufficient
compliance withFCCI 0E 65 and its
to commence a ermi;t revocation hearing which may lead to permit revocation. The
'
l
grounds
applicant, shall cooperate in all.respects with the. Comity'"s constiltar'it to assist the consultant to reach
c
his/her concltisi0il'.
4 '
2. that: are -not m continual use for a period of six (6) mc►nths shall be cOu saiieesl
,All .pacitities
abandoned: AbandonedrFacilties are hereby designated as unlawfiil and as public n
building for the Facility, he applicant
regtiringno amortization period. Prior to issaaice of a perrirnit
detailed from an appropriate building ,industry busines's or 'contracto`r' for the'
�.
u
shall obtain a estimate
i of the Facility, uicludmg the proper disposal of all removed materials and theretui� of site
removal
to its Ong final condition. A copy of the estimate shall be submitted to the Building Division for
of the upermit
4-
rev-, ie;w and',approval prior to issttance,of iingpem�iits. Prior to issuance
a perfoxiriance-sectin y,iri'an. ainourit an
ibail
for the installation of.tlie;Facility, the pplicant shall post
Services that is, sufficient to COver the C05t Of
'b
forrri determined by the Director of J7eveiopmeilt
the Facility, proper disposal of all removed materials, and return of the site tO its' original
y
removal of
`' in the event that Stich Facility is'.abandoned, or if the pernut has,been terminated for
'condition
violation of its conditions by the County after hearing, or has eXpirecl, and after riottce laS been given
'
been filed+ If the Director o£
n
(, to the owner/optrrator by the County, no apph�aticin for ren ewal has
determines that the Facility is aliaridoned, tl�e applicant may be required t6
z=.
Development Services
all' equipiiient belonging to the applicant from the preiriises and return the site to its origin
t
remove If such Facility is not
coridihori v�ithin thirty (30) calendar days' of receipt of notico to abate,
within thirty (30) days, the County may
;
removed and the site returned to its, original condition
,
. neral ex e, e4
re a the Facili"t at the a iicant s and/or land owners Dint an se
mov y pp
4
,
'All letel support. Facilities be painted aid/or screened from view With adequate
-
-ground --4d
lanclscaplrig .appropriate to the surrounding envirotin�ien. All aesthetic' treatments, including
t -
landscaping shalt be maintained as ���proved for the life of the ;facility:
1
lA�,' 'Elie Factit +bay not encroach +into, under, over, abovez of upon any public street in the+
Comity the absence ofa valid encroachment permit from the'Ooitrityi
unincorporated area o£tlie in,
i ''shall a'rinuatl` submit a written verificafiOin, attested to under
The owi�ar/operator of the Fa ty Y
1$,;
penalty of perjury; sighed liy both'the ' 'O'ner/opeiator and an FCO licensee in, the employ, of or
retained by the;' ovtwne /Operator,. that the radio ;fr,,agoency radiation/electromagiietia frequency
(RF/>✓1vIF� emitted by the facility conforms to safetd la idards set forth in FCC OFT `65. The reports
set by the FCC and the Gounty
p.epai+ed'for the Facility shad conform to reporting,egtiirements
'Elie reports shall be submitted to the Piarining 17ivisi-Oh and the Building bivision no tater than
alUary 31 of each year,
�.y, Imes t_o p re�!er. access b the u
t 6; The Facilit` .sh.11 be 'secured; at all t' p y p 1lic
:17, Applicant shall implement measures to p"reveiit fugitive `dust emissionsriiig all coi strttcttait
t
j
iictivittc's'
t w6b0 r ['AGtr 6 r
I
N M1NOTt a
r 13W IT 9 O' LINTY PL NNtNO OMM ss1O ,
1
,
Yi.. _ ., M, ,.. .., .a r.-:-. . +:'t T'.'. z:r' . --1' AwF,,'F ,rx', ,,,..
r� u x. c.+.,, 1 ti...ra4,a+. „4 e r,i ;5 ..x w.. b.1. t at'r•.v s,1'ra>fir7 {i„ a.{; ,+r, r. y.,
A .a:.. t .., ti:.ti .q,. ,, 61.. -„.r.4 „,U,+,tn,q. ,.,,,, c.. 4 ...,.• >• V' 9` ...r 1. 4 311 ” ra.;..Ft"•,
[�„ ,.5 ��,. . ., it 1�. r h,, `i'' :.d r.,'t. ;.. er ,,,9.i .,a'. '30 .: �r y .,.; a. f ''r:f �, ri1-'r •i.M .;:?.t r, ,_:S,i
,m f •,.. Pa -.,1d at ,..yi,t��, �x.v. ,;.U<8, �... ,, :.. x.. k9*.... c'F d ,�,w iG. ..r ff P.n jµ7, �Sah •c,Y� tr. .C, 44614
i. ; i, ,,,r �, n g} : r, .CC a, .k., s 1�. �. , 1.. ,., t . x. fig. , , "G�", .'�
a . �' � a., d.. , . ,t , .i x..:S, r.�7.t.'Yrr� . A, �. R ,. I ��, 'R .,yA. s< �, '�. � .,7 Y , t lr.: { 1
{ e {h iV ,v. .1 ., yb. F ..,4 - . a. { , i,` ,� F ., l ,r ,1 ,4 i . ,a sl x is7 . • 1 {.
6 ,, t•'. t... 5,1, �,. ,, b , y., F F, .,� ,:a.6,:- 't u t t � -p., 01. ,;,t„3�. r a,a rod .5 .� r{ r,. - 1
_41vii ,.-av L 1 . :c.. l.1,C.,, .tv',r... •a.,,. i _i. r �. 4:.«,• .• r. c r.FF,�.v,= ,4f.YT + ia._r, i( A.
4# µ .... }r 1 .. T.. . � x 4,v. �,, x.•1.. F .Sy Sv.. �,. ,a qC.., +„ �.,., ,r. :gn r ,. y}-�`e-�, c,• ..i. 7P,. v6•.. a,rd,: 1 , :..7 * "a4t'
+' C7 �4 x�. }Mer`•.. r •,e..,r .�n..,i r-».M.•iltt}�d
>�{.,,- .,.
5,,:. :r.:. 'M, Y�• , r 7•i. 7 ., u. ,.. .� „ix.+ d . a4.. 3,: 7 r. 4) r .4 ..Ir. [.. %PTXk't3”`
�. ... :.. .. f,., .. + _., .. r,. ?u ...h rh trl `r. tr ,�•:r,4�,r�.u. .r'., a , i._ yy $ ;N I .i, "a 1., in.t{ i`t'Ka,. f
, r•Y .. t, .. ',,. .&.F.. >.e. S.. ...A,+,y ,o, , ..r. , ''.!l .ml.. .'1 ,F4•. i'.I,y t .e?�,. ,F 2:' „�. titl ,.:6 :.(
..�..1'4.,�w,.r..,. .. yi, „+,.•+ 1r�Y'n. s ...,,. „irl.:.. -.r..s .a.,gy.i,-ea R. e. ti-., +-.+Ri• ,,,.,-1+`;•t.1ti., kr��;:� 1,. Z{„ ;.�`, �4t 'a ..Y �., ,Cf
,..v, ti..rFF b..,... .r -..M }. , ..ppkr. .J, { h r ,,,.! _ iF.:. 3 r.., .a...if'k.,t.., a}•�.. ,yjq, ,..,a ;,''1, •:!... ,Y. :, i ,1..9 '� �.ar.�,.
,. ,,. �.,.+. .�� ., :4. ., ,.., £,.. ,v X.,. .. ,f.
s h.
..clt5,. Y, Ca 17,,...,}, tix' -a4.F0 ..�ra«. ,, t '� t , , Mt .�, ,. .+ z 1 re^,t .$,r. .F. A4P ..p)'•� k
r a. . j AI'll..,4 a,
.` rv. {, t s1�!„? e,..
�.,t1,Y w, N �, :h., ,.fi,Clr,,,. 4,. , f .. o.^ •.4 15..i.. ^;. A „?a�N`
yyt ,{: i �ryy:k.,�.x,.v- �. , ,, � vi�,�..,.^u. , :i.. 1"l. a .. ,,.... "I .6_, .5,:.,,,K. ,� ,.. � eer..ri4r,a. ^i;l V�•,YF- �� a,.. h..,,.x .,,. r.. .,,.r..., , ,•.., ¢r:..,Ei.� ryry
1 Y'i .�n+1r ,t .r.. P� .1 T,+ ;h .L 5•t. . ,,� •. r. R.aa !. , f 117 L. L,v �1. .,,, �.,., .t.. ,.r. .1 T �. . `,•..p 1. E. e+� .alit ,��^.L,. ,14 V "i"ru:C'
.vr:. ,...e,41- .�55.�,'(1,.A.{11i., ,.J r..a:. :1}.. ,.ti.11•! `F. g,t ,. ., ,... ., •,y ,: 17 ,u Z.{.1•.. , �,. ,8. ty.h.4r`,r f+.. �c.� i •r,. ,,�: ", ,
4�,r[' ,ia
f
;... r,A a. :Z� .,.,,, � 6,'i .bl..•.la,\. r ::. ,.... .r. ,.:�i v. +r. 2 F.. n •,�a,a.r,t.�v5� ,..�.. r7,.�. 1 .,,-t.l..qq.. �;,r.., >I „sr 1+�'!t i �.U''� M1 rE1: �'+rt:N4••^,.;R
.1F ..., �S, F 4:, 1 ,t a. Jr .. ,. �g }�,. ,�. 6�7A ,. r, , ,, nS.4 .. Fh ,. .. U' ,� �..y n,,tdy .�,,.{ .'p A,r.,yi P..t ,r..F„r,,. 1 Y. A . F1 ,s 1Y ,, ty:, t �,• , ,�M1•-,
`•. :, c.l i. yc .,.Fa a o��Ia. a.�}„ e: ,. a,A ,, ::� ., 1:, ,, sr1, Jy��,2.. �s,4•. ,:%*�,. as � ,� { „N, 1, i Ge-, a �•,r ,, <,,: � +1, 7: t. t ,t.,,5 r r.
,,. A r.b �f,.4 4 ,y.} �. �,!� ,+ .� �.: , r.I•.i311 .. .. .i, S, }I , „j .1 ,,:.I.r i. 7. .4-#7 :7 +1..x +lYi i°'1. L^t...n.l, tFY. 7: 'Y.a yt
95 „ai y G 4 f' . t,..Fi 9 9.kF ,.:� ,..Pus , �4 '�n.k,.,nte . .. .. ,..1 ,>k�. L.,i .,i. p4 tr 1.::+• .. t.,•.r✓. s, d, ., is,_ 7a F, (., RY
r•.d: 'ah. �;`t r•j, }, F
V 4 "4i. ,.,, 1.. , i +• `F.,. .Y. .. •,-. ;,. i.5 �.. , _(•,. ,da . �. Z y. 1e �h r,.rn. � -:x1• A 'r�# «:p' I'i , .+�4 � ..Lr
{,
r r�.:(, f -.•5
r4y t.. a 7Y+ �,�, . d. + ., q,F•i •c ,1+ _, Y. n"tl .. .`r! .. Jw a
,� =.,., h,.: .1. kF .,,. , xr .t„_,f ,Y .rrr3 ",N. 1, i'...
r.,.• -. �,,.1pr.l M. ., +�,1YrAA�.,•w..G. r,.L.,
, Y:a.. .. ,}.�.: 2} 5+r..:+•,a. V.In, n 4, ,�,.r �.., F i,
.7 .. LdRt,�, ki i! :,,,ty.},. u•w I_; .,. +tt ;r ,><.,. , .,f '.
.1, �y.i«. � .. .. to ! t f. �EF�'.Po
% f+., , � Ft. a'A. , - �;y ., r ;A S. , yL�.,rR � 1 ,.9, i5 ( 1 tr ,,, , x,,.. r, : ,.. ,, , x ,; •r. '� ,1,>, r l a, lAa1�S,A
,q ♦..A. r� }�.q r,.�1,, i S i . n, 41F,.1. r.. \„ �A.�.y,.t i.
r ir4 4 kit. ��hg5f1: d ..:. r1p, ,.o-.�.:t�. ^i,y. 1 t ... F„ 16a. a . +t.-. ,.. ..d ti: { ...�rul.arW,N+w}�'WTd1dFiS e.
1A �,.,, 4 .A 1.A0{g£i,rr !:. yt 1"y,{ r f 0s 1'r�2tT.;,;
., a .:11„!='�'c} ,;,y+ ., 4. .w ,,,\ • ,,(, 4.p"«{,l! rr: S:.-+Vt� F , 4 „+t , .fv� .:,, t ,rl.�i0 .f +:,:. ."•..p.,,y�,,b,tu,,:',�:W.,>�.F�..-,-.. � :., . .1: �• -, ,;'. ; $ L,,{ '0..
r�.i J ; ...}'s ,,4-�h4 r r�1S. wYd,.�1:t%ii.Ltt+ s:R1;"�*+' • ,. pA .. <, .; t 6u � �:.s`?,f
�a 5, 6 • '�e�4 � ,.a "z�, ,.,>.,.w :F�e< ia:...:•., a" ,� ,...•>a;�., r ,
s ��t�r�(,w�1q'�1'�l�i,x�:iy+1 .Yr4-1 i1°c�ti �. its I'L� I” rq�y41'�.IuF...,.Y60,.t cil.
1:f E0td7tlt1081�..����:iA, �.,�,��.�
y 10
st l�1j�.
.L�
J'
e
r
'is`t''" ` 1 - Pp �P j
F: . elo ed m "accordancewiti thea roved>!, ro ect; site plan aned as".`'� ' �If i
;tF�l 1
1g T,he pro]ect site shall be dev . P-� 1 ��
tions contained hereiniY ' Said site plan pis on file in: ;the 'Planning Division,is dentifi
condi ?
Exlubi .E" and d ?te-starriped.MarchG, 2000; and is''Mcorporatedherein by this referencei,
1
Ir dclV D
lg, Prior to use of tnis project, the applicant shall contact the Planning Division For a diel inspection
to'veiify all conditions of approval and,ordinance requirements have been met: i T
r Y o- rS4
CAN(): com 1 with all other applicable State and local statutes, ordinances and
20. Applicant must P y
regulations>
I �1
Ptt ilia ork D enartn�llt ,1
t shal]. submit documentation to the Public
: 1. 21. Prior"Ito the issuance of building permits the applcan;
g hows the location of the communication
Works Department £rom a regsteredcivil'en neer that s
facility
lease area with'resp`ect to the 100 year, floodplain; Tf the lease area is within the 100 year
lain licarit shall establish 100 year floodplain) elevations and ,tlie lowest floor'
I r I 5 I
floodp ar the app,' Show, the'. site plan ma for buil it
permits
ons by
g enmts the 'elevati
elevations for any structures, p on site:
" cottouYs) ':and`ih'e location of an accepted NUGJ� benchmark and a temporary .
to the Public.Works Department for review wind approval; If the ProjectM
c submitted _._...
aid phiushall b Is,notrithiri the' 100 -year floodplain, flood elevations are not required.
itlun the 100 -year #loodplain:; obtain approit
val from the
the commumc f, tyease area is ri �+
,I anon facile .1
if,
22.
x titer Resources prior to start o£ constructionF
CaliforniaDepartment of W_ � fr
ion';facilit"'r Plans and calculations shall be ti
23i; ' Btuldiiig Pennits are ;required for the convnuriic
at Y
pr.pared by a licensed. architect oi' civil etg
ineex authoz zed to;ptacti e m the State of California. `
I er
Fti` iroriniental NPalth
Hazariiotis Material Release' -,k spbnse-L P: O i, arid: Inventor~ fo" `m to the
�r 244 Applicant shall provide a _ -
Einvit6iitnental Health Divislon.
1 I
Cali - -
" cress o1i Highway '10 shall rrieet Caltrans' Commercial IDrivewaytandardsF A
The driveway a i
n an work in the Highway 70 right of w
aye
25 Caltrans Encroachment Permit siaall be tl eaed p aroi( shall submit doetunentatior to the Placuling
Motto issuance o£'liiiildiig ,peiynits� Lipp
Division front, Caltrans that states the driveway rirnects 'Caltratls' Coiyvriercial Driveway .Standards.
t ,
cal period.,
,
da a" >
a �0 p
V�'ilsan stated that tlt
ere` is .S' Pp
lVlra 1
Ong
h
OlVp 01
toget' R,osSUei g, proposed lYegati a DeclAM ibn With mitigation rxieasur tonedogs i�ty A t� 10
t ,,• eil�itonmerital impacts tired Use Permit to a]lo�vralCennell fog° up ate a tthe end ofVil Gairie f'acc,
(Agrict�ltural'ltesidehtial 10 acfe parcels)} Tle ptopetty
1 r
1
r 1vtAY 25,.
20b0 o PAGE 7 ■
. N� CoMM1551dN U
;
Y 1 ;,1 1 'A'ilii �' h +lir 4i ✓c fllrA vAx svNxf• is 1 dW,niHa
h !. brr r. U ; M y '•ori + p A*+it F 1 r•a V x J ?{ 4 Y M'.• ! Y' -
f;� •� .'r'{: r1f+ t S�tyk %,£'!."qrf. 1 � ar,4 tm, ', ,a3 r' le +,�5 i, C. f, tiv r$v ,�,�.,�'x�4F. '�. d*x.A�.ji�,+w. r,s !3 •k a,-:;y1,4^^y .1 1 xk r•''!`.. �p.9r x.1+44,,+_. k .
V4 '��'t SleA 1, 1�°'<`a 6x •�rl.a�: aAfh ,'.,� ,d '..N'�t r4 �,aa'':,,, . r.r� m+'.'I (" ':.� 1. ,.,
� c'�� 1�r �.�M 7kt xi-fiu rµ haw •,�p�•a �'� 4e'Y � t �,;, ��h .", a ,� y;. ; '� f ".�ij 1%� �qi�:";, � �,�,�,�.'�°'.,- � f�?'�'a �,. 8 �ws ('.;, A¢ i� '�i � iM�'�I'k ° ». �� aei;., i �>¢.'� a ,� ���
µ�# .Y Wyk .+^� K • t y
A� A
y. {: „.,. ...., ,.. n. ,,,w. ,.- r.- - -. ,, . m< n• x ., .,,,.as _r v„ a
,�, .. 9',. A,, ,,. ?4 .I.. .N'.. V li,.: F'( 5- a ,.M. d e:Y. -i i ll -.-t.V
n. I. ,."9. ,.,. e,.Y . .. a1c y, rv.i, rvn , 1a ,. "tt, ,a ti4,,. i. o. b .4. P,. n.. S .9. ,d+, @ -a,.,, .d ,g. ., ri:4¢ t9 f'"..,:;.','?' ,_,v.,r.itl r, ,a:.« .i ikl, r; �j ..r., }:fr, i!"1T .,a,r-»:ln[
1 Iv�:,,, .,it._, r.tV..# aS , �.' x�! t 1�1 n y ,�e1,,. #C, ti, �,,. 6s ._.u,ti ,r a, ,CI w C h.:.e,;r( ¢.J
at .a? ,:, . < ._..6. {:5,., li . 9, w ,r A,ali . Y + .c, r- h ,t a y c, , ., 4 f, a r ; ,t v. , u .. . a z.. R:.0 I , ti.
1•qqZ +, t y [11 a "�w,. r,a33.a. ,_j.. ,.y.. 3,, s,.. .».,d .,q(,u ;..4Y..,.� I v, .t, u,bt {,r•1 p k ,6 t. d„h
�.., i-, 5. .1l., ,. ,. t..,. ,,, ,f 1.Y ,., ,. � 4 E. , P. ,., . v. .. n -"d.. .,r�.i. �. t, { a , r '..i . s«.•+ .�. . al L..u,.r7,Yti!{P!L", r �
y �'- t . t.us 1, l '� ,.. ..,a,. 1F. r M1F. y .l ,I 'm tm .r�r�: ? { ct . >? _.,,;el la iC, .:.. ,.ian ',l,,C 5.., : ,..... , i �i „ly p.,r ; •; . G'1't'[.rl:.3,. , •. '�• ., ^. .1. , �. ,tt
+y.}.z, uy .I
9• 1 ;� t,t�.,. 9c1c ^R ',, , 'Cl l.v'.w ...,x.• i,: r tl ,,,.e, i,,:, r z t ,, r«f l,» baa t �,r,.*y i?,;o t. ,'�-, .4
.t, ,4r<, � , r �. .t'.. ,... -»r M., s ,1 x a.. ,. «1_. ; ,� { . ,�s�,Fr J9.�• a.. r.s 1 i.� a1. r . 1,��,��yy 1 u
,w t �„:».,, & f ,..,'Vr...,,. r +. ,..b?l.kr fit ,,.. t.., 1y. ., rr ,.:,,t , , ,1:°:>i.i 'b ..y-.axa •ti.,'.' / Y1l: „� 1 P,r h. i'u i.. r p^nl::,<4!.
,.. .. J lr..zF :,... �4e--:�.. .: a!' ,,,. .,r .:.: u., r,.ar1 ., �,, .�':\ , �.��YyT.,. .t }A ,.. v.�� y. ,.•6. .: ,.. h:. le. ,A.. •�n,,.:.. ,1:�,,t er i,av Y,A h `w•4, t� ir.ri�,�, , f .f. 1,.. .e„e4 .,P.
i
!p„
- :.. .. � , Y„ „ 4'E ;.y.S�, � _,., Fiy:. G. �¢ia t . 4... ,.._, ,,t�l�. .?a Y�^, ,1..i .. ti�w `� v u.� `f... � '�+ y ,. r ,,, t ,., ,•,d .,, ,,, 4. t ....,. Ir , it.. 'i..., . , .•v t... r tI .'t yet:. d�.. r. r. , ,, dp,1-, f, t � y :^
,..: �.'+, '4$, �.r .. l.. t+,t a� ..,sl. .7.4.tr, ,,, � ...,b, r .. t. 4 ..,dry».iS >f iy 1r„.y 1, ac ., ,.5, 0.r , ,i „Ea ,Y •Y0.., ar.r /g,l: !..`�u`; v •�Ml,.Y!^'i
..i ,, .�7.v.>'y k. :�, ,.s1,� ., e., o ,-. ..c. i.'i 1 ,�; _•sr I :: , a... {. ,ti t +: ' EJ+° r a: ,. s, :� 'Sr �t. .�. a, ,.�x..,.. : .:{..,J,.. -,. S�' ,a ... „. k < n -:,a .., nu> .: {. .,.::, .rK.a,,. :
f f
,
.. ,� o { ... c.r ,.... ?... ,,., r : v1 .. .• lu -a1 ..i a K, Fr, ,w,t {'N xf: d .1. :.v 1. ,. ..[Y: ,�' k ,1, „d.. ,� ti. ,t t ,Y y 1 -3 Civa.9 •I:' a -: L 1.,,t, .t.... ...
tE. 9.,.. �: a:tt:. 4 : isl y .x( t . , � y ,. 1 # ., >. a ,;,t. 1, e y . k ,. . , r3 ,. , xJ t,, a. , . l Y:.. •. # ir. °r,•r r , _ Y i sr ,:1 t ,,: � ., � ..
a fu f :• ra «�:•., 1, .,5 .. ,:4 "t .t jj } .e... Y, ,+:.� 1.1. .�,5t ,.., i,.:k :t •:, ryyyyli ai, .,a:•, A,.r.u. �,.. .4yy �r t,-. - �k. ,.1 :1 Y ^,: f.r. ,hlir r%'r y
Y 9� 9,. •r .. .r �Vy ... ., } .1. t. 4. :.>.. ,- .., .,ti:Yrt�..x k e ¢+y ,; t, wt �. � v.'+•{., �., .f !, y: ,I'A �i -\ nit.S �,.. :s t "r� n .tt Ea' f,.r J-),
• •,s. Y.�.. � _,,l
.x d .. «r.,. ,.. ..,. a 1
ti,
>rr. ,rs,., r., i y:
.u. M. d-" " t.
t.. {t TIP
,r"
r rtit1.. e. t t l t 4 rt y l ,vi i! a t t ri a k•
1.: ,h, :,•�., , , a, ,(, :. ,.41�iv r Y rr.4
`<..,.p 3 4tt , t y , .e 1'•.,t..r.: y Y: r :,vt,1p. { � t �+' 1
, r,a•h,- •t0. �,.•..r w,ta': •.rd. ,. r;,.
y�Ca 4•'r ', ,. X -:,.,..• .,y . �,. :.. ,. t ;, ,a.<'n� x �1 ..,,- 7: ':
vt, :S t n4 w k � � ,a :..,. ,, i,,.. ss7, rk .. r.r i, ,F.x..,. ,a,.. r, �r r.1>:••
'.,:,. ,>t., Gd{, i .�! 3 .Ici '+ tr:- r .,,.iJ•ti. PIP, 1, a„ti ,. .r'. ...�.�{ 'n., r:.;ii4
.. v'Y r r ,., v ., 0 •. „ k -•
t � t JJ, � ..1k ...:�• \9 i'" a �4. a ,..� }}
'14
�.r r ki:,. . ha
( ..-:. <.!tf.4, y� ,.�.a ..1v�p. ... hf ,. v. .., a6 '91 {. ;• �,S ,.,, a -i. yr ..«; �,,�, r., ,, t., ..L ,ti ,. r.�M"Ar: S�'. ,f•�:Eb. a.,r »v t „a�
�.k,tU.,'t. y j4. ,,+�k1 #. 9 r, n.., ki,,, .r •, s, ,...:d t. N,.. r.,{, ,). «,t ejf'.glta 5.... ,,, , ,!:. J. c�i :"MJ. .:t .,.r 1. {p..
Af,. .*.:� ..t �.tr,•r•Y7 1 ve...r ti. 1.�„..,
<.,. � ; Y , .. "{j . � ..:, } t C Yt • ,, . t, ' tk�r. 0. ! .ry ..
1'. - ,aY..Y 4.... r2 el. ya,. ji.y ;ttr. ♦n., th.4M , , .rq d ,: :i �jCl dt ,:+� "'1'.. y. .ka.rw •�~e tifi F t�t �-^t. t?�}:.. ,: F i. �:iw.d.,�IS4�Y�dk4 f :,I'(.
� { } . , E� �,.? ,i„J• 7.n ,'�:1 ,,,. n, e �y r ;v . •.l:ti;!, °J{ a„'. ra �i , �; ; , , a;.,f, k w. r 1 ' P a , •.. ..1;.;u1'.y S1, zt.,,
•,s . i,.a t �tµ 41• , n: y ,1,� y c 1�,• .. 4 a°G `^4�: c:'? L'� w t 1. �: i w0.ra a 9L c aL c� - •,o - } t bJ t�lf e . r w
411�:6��51+a{Ii tli�iteku�swuw.� y� s ..M3 y t«. a- `y jj, rtr
r *� k t � �t• � i � s , r,rd�l
� i,�
4 '
of the �DRC.runnirig late;'the present times could Woric, Also the.Commissioners could �1�e notified prior to ,
, 4 r
"`' ' did not waut to chart a the tune of their rieeting as the engineers dike the eaul�r
the aneetin The DRC g
niori�ing'hour
'' n CoirurussioiierMooriey said it is one thing,:,o notify the Commissioners that the DIZC is ruining long, but
Iiow Will they riotify'the publ" w`
N, llson d15CU5 st 711111SCT
ttt
MrY ,W' sed allowing for flek time iii'startng Cod on meetings.;
p.
C�mnissiener hTelson said.hd would rot'niind �tari;ng in the afternoon.
` Goinnissioner'Lambert said that would cause two, of ther.rommssionerstc� either, stay in town between is
l
rrieetings of go home and come back:She` said they: should l continue to try •to wo"rk the, problem out:
Lsl,; t
Cha `rman i=eland said they should continue this item to the first rrieeting in ugiist.to see how -things are
1Wa i
,te:. t➢ k
`chgives some
whi
ry'
Mr,�Vilson said the CoiniYiissioii By-1a�vs. say normally 'tli' a mee,iing will begin at 9.30
' `' ' tlexiUli to ubiish• later ltimes. 1
t
DISCIISSI0. Tiriie,and da to foi ,a field trip to the Scott Stephens' proliertya
y' 2000 It was noted that if the` item is
i I41i, W llson disri}ssed liavmgthe field trip after the meeting on Jun',, fi,
pn the agenda for June $th,,,and the field trip istakeI within S days, the field trip yyould not have to be; oticedy
jle.said the agenda'ca,, say the neetir > is be ng'adjotirned `to'tlie field trip site:`
t -- -` et as there to talkaout
rv1r }3i e,.don scud the land oWn uv
y
i � ,
Gif' 'ITait'said tiie Sidi will work tine; iie saiel the'property;is 20 minutes from Chico and 5'1(J i ninutes on�a
iiyate joada 'fl, 0, d o`'wouldiipr&ide a map,l He said file public 18,1111i ed, die sai x
{ d
p'
field tri. Will ^t►ssed the
ileCtionS aii[�•Sal 1'
aii one wisliin access other than during the p need to call for anppoiiitment He tfisc�
Clition o ytlie last ll2 mile of roadE He, sr d it. is not th6 best, ire said Yle�cotbld f ick peopi up u� 11e•gate
cru
I f they Wanted,
I\%lr iViiseai hotedxtl�at tius`r ill
'lot,
be', a public lieai i.g acid the field trip'will ita be controlledt I aicl
che'trip is'fo gather ini'o`ir'iatioz from the aplicaht ut the site.
lvli, hall stibnutterl info'rinatian to theotrimissiori'to be Considered later and said 1?e'Will sent'a rriap flat.
I'atilo'. paid the field tri
tb be a tour
of did site, he dill nat want to caiiritzct a,p:if�?ic hearing at the site,
y 4
fSe ,rind Whitt will heed to be eontiniied to a date eertaiti from the field trip date. ,
Y'0
.4 1
14, 1'! * i
u
1 C01VI1V1(UNCATx(JNS: C`dt!e�i�titicatrotts t e�eivc�il nJlc i'et t. , jCopic�s ofC61�rrtililicntie�fs irre} ctVctilalle
I '
irk"?Its Plak i� n bivisid)t U tee
Xe A`b;SoilI2NMEA
i
+i
a 'hY pLANNINd C
OlvtMfS�tN ■ VINI'C`':YAi'52000,AUT �I
1
7,
• r
,��•�'kR h'yt`,t: „� "�w k. i;-:ytr. r K(ra .aia' �"r', `I4N .b.,,:�t aky
Z.4
i
ri l i r i n G 1d w ty
t 1 r'•yr5. ? . : r;x, a :.;. 4 'i u''i 1 a , �k y ,la pn.t s'.i� �Gt ° •�'�
. , Fe`s
w+ a
*,, b ��� f *�^'i
IM
y:r
In . lo:� ip 4 wn
,.i i C :'X. ,:, Y a. x + h fi.-;,!.. 5 r • r. !, ,:6.y R,. ., { f'1. .'Fl.• ,F: t): ,dW 7.> alj lin..
,., ia^
,.. W r.., .: 1 w,:. ,+: ,. !. t.7.. r .:..r.pi. . ,.:. '�:, tea . \.i .+,.a•5!r „ c x .G. .� rl.t., 1•+t„r>9 r'E}' nF 1 - ; y',-.rf ,: j , a. +Ia..,L. 5 ,� � rn . ,r• '
'.... .,,>..._., -,�Vt. ,•'.. r�i : )):,.....f1.,x&1 ,.,, �.�,,>n., rr¢¢ I,t rt rN ,r. ?�! j. ,++ �#.:,,,r�+,,Yt' ,,:>t:.,;• .kt 1a; �, ,.+, i A f>t,>A?, yl,. .El. ,.d c.S ,r. 6"r,
, ..4 ,.. „ .ar 5t �,, ,..1 .. i a,. Y. ,.. r
jri� t. ,,.. .,"C .;: fi 1..,.4;r-
: tr «r4++ $.. 1•.. �Wt -i: a, ,,, r .Fer YY i.
a, � .. t �.. r s.t i t ..t� ti. t l ,M{.:. t. 14 z
i ,._..a r..+ ''.•.,
..gt,.4yy �r...,.ruir. ,._. {,.,9a�t,r,+�'�Vq.4� i�rt, .n, Ik .,n v ,,, tr ,�.1 �..s%+t a,la,.•+;., +�,. .`4S t S ,,:,n fN,
� t t:,t.A/.�,....%. �`�,
. r, .....}} E.,
jF,St YF., ra } ..,b. t4,,�to.1., ��, tY,y r�..'� �, r ,�. � .. <+tk, ,+rx16, ,t .+.�,,�..,0 �� }. IS «r ,.:,tr�,:. +�•er vu,.,,.i jU, ��r,r ++a
, 't 4 . } t .. l•k` j , ,�qq pp , 1R , t � ,,. ,4r . {�• u. 7 < .r x t f �1'!;, C1i � r aj:. �:,' t 1.. , 5 •)r , . l , . , � A r
F V., trr2 dh•', 4-« •M .a. ..�_^e,. ,S�$:'. +p. ti ,,wA? i,:a^`r..r a., .��^ +:�,1'.
'}' � , } +u.,. �, .r.:} •'a • • .., i u , "- „• t l '(,o.....,;:, � � • ., , . •: � ., ' , :. ,, ��., 1 u . .,r, ° 1 r,t ,'r ej , ! r 5: . iF : m . + ,
' ,: ,, , �r,'.. � .t..... .t. {4 tr•.�,.., ,t .ppyy .... t'' t,l �, t �.: ^r, 4, .... t 4 C l;nu r3 r ..., ,. r+-. : , •,+tl �t',d `.+a ,�..., '7,,.«. �.(1•, a ,t 1 rt t ti. F,r,., , �M
k. a r, .:t 4., "i, i . {, °1,i .. t . i : ny v { , i.,.r, s•,. FF p, ,.f , u is n at w : til. r n t^'+.. AE: F: "', +r,:+i+ r, r+r . r iS t;.rl. i.,. }4 a r:.b,., f.. 4'.
. � • .I+, +
+� vt y`S.•
fr , :.,`1..y : v „�. Y.. �,+•. .,+. ,..a ..; ..,r
,•, ,e q''„a . , ,. { to 5r�. ' ^,'a s,'S. L .1 t , V{' `�E, .1• r
t ti . ,.r , : t + •• } . i ,....,t, r , r; $, , L C{ la. ,l .. «11, �. .,• 1., , ,,;.,,.C� t. ^,R U i aW 1'V, a {r;.`F•. .t ,. t,. r I s•Vi 1 - ,..i. a� , ,(t. i. „ a it ,11.
:, .. , ,r ,t t ,.1,,� ,Vk, <: a d �t�• '.:r 14 , � �,�r. �.> h �A• � � , s t%. c7d , +'.y ,+ � �,,e '•ur,. ,.r.,+i a,. c. •,S
L�,. -.` t3 l+H A', •ti +,., r.h k,, ,,.d,.i {4 .Er r�,, d, ay,�tir.. a. e.., e.
1. n ., .r A ,T,. l., . tt4➢.:. ,l x -^.3:, t ! • .. o, ,t 1,4; n
i
,1.. � .. ', a, , F. y .... :1..;.- . „Y. r:.•, ,.. ii. 4 �,r,. *r. ,.; e •Gla ,., J}., !> ,,,, r+d .?;�q ks,. r'e.. t 14',� r1,.:- Y. ir. �rrh Vie. y�^.
., , e. ,n ',i �,. r.• +i, ,., k �n...•a r�.,, 4,, 3 S1,4a irt,., it ., t..a`�. ,04 .r , .41a,. ,, ,.. x L. ,: .. J. .+., : rt i yd ,�ra1. } .y e,, ... �a, 4,
h�r� j. .,. :..1 . w � , r! �, l tv.v, ,..:!!. r t . .d#, , �v�1 �`.. w a n .,ts.. 3,.: ht« -1-< tr 1:.tr :. t, '..• r �',. "''' t.. , . l
'C
, . ��. [. {t, .. .::. r �Y:+ et ..t . ... � is �.r ,. •,':lx , .�& .. ,. ,. , ,'t.. - • , ”>`3.'h,.. , .::; d:. ri.': �i '.rv4•. :yi ,,.1'
. .. ..?? y.5 �. !. s-y.,�.c i..r, u., 1..t ..1., q„ « r,. .. ,tL. , f h tyY�". .i. Y :,. J f.." 1 t..t ,:,'ya's e.• r.. �.,�•.. r; ,it. 1, ..r, ,�l ;. j,
_ , .5 ' L'4. , .�{ . �t st . t „s . , ,t, , , . V ±, � .rtpc, s .z �' � i •. int, 1 i ,, �- . r, , .., d f7i i? ,, . t .. .. , .:,. c ,., + �, 4 n
., '�. t u � r _. � r> �,. Pa ],l.t., Y. 4,Y,a ..i:„.t,, pk� +,ti, {,u { + „ �•.,i 1.. 9 a"t a
„ .. ,%! t� d e°1:A•a w 1 r ,',� ,5,, ,.,,, P 1,� 4 , .. � t > .S rt'+ ,. q, tr :,.,.'l..l,, � 1� f .r n;"°,}., 6�f / r rt ": d .� �,"i;�3...
,i: ,{. ar t l.r.dt, 1 1. n, .k t. f, � 1� ,t �, .ra , .,•4t � , � 1 +Y� , f �, .Y} at . 1 �.)) ,,.,{ < t , ? , ,..t ._ 6 +,r ° 1 .. .. y�i t , . 1, ,t rc, 1 ,• a tt p d ! .
,,.}.: 1ra'....:.9cr...h,. •. t tdia. :_t,, s.
,1,. }}qqa r .rd r.d i. t.. .,1.+1'.r,,d 6. ,1. � da. ,•'. +,,�,rFr{ . i r :h a,xe
•• t t,i, A..' :�. ,�,. r) ,}t; .�."ti��i 4� r.:+ , t 4, a .'�,M.ti, iy�,! r.. a.. 1., - ' � 1, SI?r ., �..a. ;.rJ s t .S. �,; t.. + ,� R:e �t�,.V . r is r '•; 4;t
.Ylr:4�«..1,... ,., q .". ';°t ','- K"'xt... «t "t'i ,r r.,.rr, ,,, ''..a .... 1.;: J.P.. 1, +'!. 1 .,,.. *d ^..e.,: rr.mJ. 1,• f1',1.4r � ..4 ,. i
� 9y.:}. -�,a+ ,,.t„ „� .. Pa; , r I .,. s. ,k( ♦k. � .:�9+.. aP }�,"1. d � Y
"��+ `"4 �*t�� • ,.t�,'S � :Y�. r 9r .,v N t,q +a t.,m ,, b .• - :.. �j d- ,�. � _ 1 : a, ,
i + 1 ,:. u 3 1 .5 1 . a i:?CitYj. ./. ,,..1.,+„ L. i1 ..•.: to l,'r�,,. d.,..., .-ft.r y..�l. .1 r'E, di ?,y,. +�jti t ,j++::uU ",x •'!'i. y„1. L� ?'ti, "(' r 1'1:-; •1.,.
.:._)�k�.M:�.rlas+. ,1 r.: �:, .,,., „�.•. �,Y ,e.4..Y�,. 5,.,1,1.t..� ,. u...i�, t, ..t. r +,.. .r. ,orp t .1.. .i.r
, _ 1 tS�- . •,. ,, ��t,,,h, � '�a. ,Vi �. + trAn � ..tt` c IC' '<1.a ,:t1 a , t,-,., 'E , +�i ., , ,, r . J `�A�"K�4 .I x ;,'� �n,E? .,� � r r.. ' ntl�, : � � ��w�:�.t.E,6�t�.t�+� t aM1a.
�tir t t�r d;1A'fl:s.
' 'r'' ” b� �Ct�1G, tt�� Y� 1 ." � i 1+w: j',..�.,,�; � ?°,1 u.r , �Vflr r ,r s.+.t�.q�,.xiu�'��• � °�u�. a -r•— *'•
a
4 { {'F
e u�
N, , iki
jctil q � 7 ,r+r,p�
I.
a, f 7 • P
,
` Chairman.Leland added the sentence "Virishing; cleaning, ywaxtng and polishing are permitted. to {�y, sj
j the end of Condition Na: 3: He' also mado're'ference to Condition N& 5 adding the word not" n
the third sentence.
t� t�
It wa. s moved by Chairman Deland, seconded by Contnussioner Nelson, and unanimously carried
w tol app"'rove UP °00-i 3 for Oak Ridge Cabinets, ,subject to findings and conditions as follows.
a
",JC,
Adopt a 1Vlitigated Negative J,661arafton with the Following findings:
i
r
S
i
feted .in Com' liance Witli the California
„ ` A+ find that an initial Study was comp p
Environmental" fZuality Act, that
said study. did not identify potentia sign ficattt '
n.. enviraiunental effects; and that. a Nog\rive Declaration is, proposed, K SSSS)
Find. that,'the.Plarining 'Coinrrussion leas considered the +proposed Negative
t- Declaratio ,together with comtrients received,durmg the public review process, Al
.; 1
t C: Find, on the"basis of the whole record beforeAle;I'lannuig Commission, including , ti
the Initial Study and any comments'received, that there is not substantial evidencc
teat the Oak Ridge Gabtnets' Use Penruit project wilt not have a signficant effect on 4
y. the envirbutrient:
1
Find tltat'the proposed;Negatve Dedlaratiori reflects the independent, judgenzeiit and'
D+ ,
anal sis.�ofthe�Count which is they leadagency.
y yj
Er Adopt the Negative declaration regarding erivirotuitental impacts;
with no mitigation; ;
+ r �.: 1 l
trieastires, and authorize the Lhair to sign+
I
Tl o `desi n bf th' ' r a _ e envt .onrnen, -al damage to
e prop(
ro ect in rovement $ e�cein tion
will ii±Dt aauS
fish and Wildlife��o�the i ltabpat' and a de Alit " ` p tegardmg impact to fish and
a
wildlife o"r their habitat; s recommended+ The collecttan of Nees pursuant to Fs1t and GameI
' Ad)(
CR 753r�r is riot recommended+
3: and :1h C
r
code section `7w 1
roveMUse }hermit 06 13 for Oak{Ridge fyabiitets, subject to the conditions found iii
TAT, App
Exhibit "A}7 and subject to the £allowing. endings;
i A '
The, °ro osed uses of the, rn err will not int aii the integn y snd character of the
p p.. p p y � p. .
k Y 'bit + � : :. asonab f incompatible:
zone tn,which the land hes, Arid that the use would trot ne nitre
yvittlt, or itijtlrious to, sounding properties ar cletrtmet tal to the i ,�. and general
we, lfare of the (persons residing or wor v. g iii the neighborhood, onto tl�e'general
'health, welfare acid salfety of rho .residents of the Comity becauser
�' lz The project will only create a verb minor aimunt of vehicle;traffic,
,
2; The rdlect Mill not create :aii significant titiisei'emissions, or odors,
p.
I ,
r' - thrr` , -i DoT e vlticli allows a ttised car sales lnt.'Mth", E
$j rhe prq�ect is ca%list
cint with �.
I l 1 1. t4•
UsePeniut; and is cousisterit with the industrial enexal Plsn laird Cisco ..est nation
whieh dllciws eotniiiwial rises as a ccoridaty rise.
— 7t •�
I
r. auN t�ANNtt> cc�tMlss"ION Mrr`tufis • Iv1t�Y 1, zcbo pAC3•
[3tJ7"l'C C 1'
yL
+�. Lr. - , , -« ut•,:"t•,^IyV r Iva d,i wn , al.l+• t+c• , 1 ,i
:,, ., r':. � .�•, e, :. � A k ' P..,
rpd 5 C]r .rf LC>t'AJ+. 1.1:: , l °I;:3 *':+e: A +v. IA.d.I :� 4nl,W ;f "„M:i�'-A # ..,rl..r 'j ,r 4AK ,m. ,, r,YIM ..r, ail ':,,'C:a 'i4,,.. j'ti r'L „x•',d N a',';p�1, td C+iY. .A
9;.., +4 `S �r ql r d,5,,.,Rtrp N✓��
u.
••. I>rl ,. 's.',, ; p,''r :`- ,: 4, . n a.'}f y �;'r ..,y q �v,{�, -.
ijMtd
tiq �' �- s#,.
1 ,. ; t i.rp �; o i . �Y++. . .r :. 4. t.4 ... _ r ,a�an 8+v �` � w � s. Q ��.x ' rM' !�a{�" n , -�++ ❑yf
:� � �
y y�
� � �
Y' j ,
nN
s'A
.y
r
�f$,.
3
I,'
-i '.. ;
lj
u
'.�
�"
-..;,1....,.,.,
i'
K c.:,
r
� �y'
r..;�
��' s< {Tri:. � � F ui�r m y � ,,��'" } �
W �.t Aa��>,�. � 1� � � N"}. !WA
� sµ;1 r P ,� � a rr wi�.,
''+.. Y .. A r :J:'• r .e1r-•., .y:.Y s w , !' i',, .L i w. a ,.. '.. , 4,. , ..;N rT, 8 , t i 4 5 n., A- . +d ,Y. .4•. "t:.. . L 1 : fl'. 3. T . . I. tJ _t,�,,.''r4 161".. 'YC' 1', '•},
';. Jo..-Y:c.. 1. t..t,.,,;Y., ,,. ftp :n...,....:. 1 ra,4:...aa..." Y .!„ .t .a.• Ra..al,dk. + .•er x'3;� B,£ m.'I'llY
. r.. nE „ :'tl. tib. ' f, ,m a.r rn xlt ,+Y 'Jd �•
'1:1., .:5 ,R A, ,r•n 1 ,. ,C.f .(',: :'�. .h4. -,,, .. �1. ,� A, . 9,.r r"Nr .: rc. v. ..iy. .,.I t.r -r., slAt#' t - t
t All.
-NI
Al
.at'dt p,,,,.a. S',i i 1.- i.. „t ..t.i wvh, f/I1t, .� .,�ie•:.4pi",tt,
u,. r „-( Y�ii• t '.. e. . Y .. „ •�Y[[w.•1 at , r'd.+, . r ,,�.. ,Y,t. , n ,tta.
r fir. .. %.y t 4,1 •.},. r+ ar.,,.i. <,.r ..'R. y, t. i,.w+ 1 ri, x1�Jl., `r7. -s { i.. ert� r., ,. ,. A. ,..1 '.Y..,,:k
irc. roJid."4 a, :�. a ,a f n. t 1. �,. a ,. tl itF
... ^} i 1 , 4 c"5 x {.. ' s i..
., .t . ..e k. .fit. :.}, >,. .� 'u .......if,dt`..i . " t au.. 6,t }'G ht �•',. :.r ,r LY..,,!ry F. , jV
,.,'•.`V., .}. � > 41-i_.,.i?�.� ,,. y.! r.i. {
,., ,.t•.ri A.rp F,1� .: .. ,... ,. n,. ,. .. - ro- �^.,
11•, `� �1vr. , i., jj,,, r...:. tt,.r w.,: ., � „nw S. 5 , tv, a ,.. u, 1 .tt�{,y M ., l R � :Va.' •R s' y" ) x .:. I ,w t .,: , , r < }. c d ��. < r „',Ir .p
...(. 4 F5i1 Y... ✓,d} 5., .•R. I4F �t ,.. Ynb- .: i..,.;�l i}., ...., C4�" yji; ,.tit i„1. 1Y .i' .,,, .i:T em b'NM �, i:�..,n wr.
r h ,i.rf
1 wa a }'k.ttro}�.� e t.. o-tirY u.. d,4 rrJ v#.. rx d'x!:1?pd .. F+- +-Yt '.i2f `, ,••y .
, , 'ti, „` ,h �. v 1.., a,at� �.,t ,t a� Ir 9, .;, }.! .: dt „t , n ,,. �+ r ,.Y ! •:?� i. 3 . ,s"s' ^, t. vY w .; t1Jr �, 6.y �.t"•`!Ya
t . X { y
„ �., ,i{ ,1 'Y}Y�'.:,r n 13 4,9 •�Y-• f�'4., ,.t..n fkY > 1 aj •+t {,'i# r.. {:� Yi,ki ,r,�j ie.•{. .'t M,rl:.:. J ff
:,. +,C. „ ,.1 . ... hE-# Yr'„ , 1 ;.,.,,,:,5v� k ..t; ,1,. „. „,, ... i.•,. a: A ..4.{ Y �1...r",e r.. ,L..
b , s IY•..:- ,. q�f .., . I .t 1A ':`:; w n s`^k , : :, � � t ,y '� •. f{
:, tin n�.,. a t ( ! x.;e,<U.S +�^R.. J 1 o.',a ,h 4. a e't;,-.:, 4�i�+n e., ,.;. ,. d.rtr. L. .3;•�.+. c.. a u, ,s .,, ., ,. ' .'t , r.'4 .. .,• 4�jb((,�
�,...... .. a9".. •, ii a.•
- t r,.: t, .A.,v., ftl-„ r „i R• 1. ,.. . ,, n. .... �.A.. 1. 5 :a�..
...« . w ^., ,h,. .SP .,l m.. YJ. w,.. ,,. 5 .r. try 6t. 1 cn• A,
.'•7 s., r �t I, :. -..4, �;�, t � '.,,h. �• �� i c Y.. .t± , >� jj ^r ,•IYS ur',,t ,b',,
i i v . Y� ,+A. •:t a,,� { , I r c 1r+"��. 1 r?'v. i :,
S�L.. �Yik 1. t w > , , A . r t. �� , , I
k9,.. t. i....a liyy •a .r•t„,r6.. c.. 'Vw: A, 17. .i{?..1.-,i w ,. ,,. '4. r.nt. ... h`.S ,e ., i. =.D�-., P r°1.11 .t..i, .. _-..., ,.x .. �r.•q.
$...:aYY1 .A}k :�,i, ,eft,.,, 4i.s�•r
L: j 1E,t [ra�i'. i rt � {� .,�,1 .T ^,h. 1. t.r. f .�, 5 M. d rai, kl; ,�,4 a P .'.dtl•r ,M1 :�il.r i./, .
+i 'id�. ,. 61«i. •. „ °,a'i�,r,S...
'%-t:! �..r a. r,1 `A•.
.t Y r-.
.,,., ?r .yb, .. wh - Y t,
...4 e..
ty ! »r l }�� tt, s~,,.. t , �wR ,r J -Y• � It n e+..
a , 4 a,9< tit,. t.„ ea” .aa i a .h �: i),v y i, ,.7
<4 • ....... r { �t. :.:> ..{ .. +kr.,gr 4 ,.. .,.0 °tr,. A4, >4 j r:• w:; v „l:: a - R °„ ,:_. ?. ,.,.. .i ,,, '7 t
Y: 1 ,,. , , w.,R. t C " .' ..,. ry ., k ,.,. "tr ,. .. q„.:. s k .SA .Y..,, '?,, r,�,l +g,`{ ttpL. ,.l,.,r t 'f laa. L. a:u: fY7f ,.. i, t p
w r _1. j1X1P..,,.... •, d! .: ,14t .w y '- Y,, .9 r . <. �., p1Y},. {..-..C...a' v e,..� ..,� .,. ,, "`. , N ?, ', :.,, ..r . 1,. j..v ♦ ,,.{ } 'gin
r � t..,..:r',.. ., � ...,uc, ,it4 ,.,t..,.�t„c•.14. a.„. :.,. ,t„, .,...• ,,, ,.. ,' „p.-kG+t v t+:t, :iw st,�„�e.,f< L ".Uptke''dYTrt`Ii%Y1b....
Vi t. 0e,
,.t.: A,t i {Lsl'j?'',rt hi>l xh. A Ltts.uoG.pA�
dY. tt t1at..,t�1a (, :,., frt.(
y,. .,.. , *?tl *i: 11... L .:..T. a . � +.., , °. ;,„. ; «. „•�,�., t„ . d t�,l.bt.':%°_'. �V�'
\ -..:•R: i +, ry t+,:.vf� ,'•,i •.e ka, •,,, -Yir.' i:l,',.tt•!a �,(�l. a.t..,.,'d. t 34 �:'��'+ q M4Y � r, i +a J iP'!��; ,.- l�. t. 1✓i w «n,�.�,m..rr-1,'..,• ,. f i � �,s
d+r. J'sJhktlrR�r= }}d y.wr.S .•'.�'.X.;y{ 1 n V.�..sY.n+lai=.u°
t i 1 t ern a i �hsP try s19 . x«
i3�tla'�1�:a.ttt.h3
°Ai
�,
i
,
' ' 11r1'rrll `r 4 ° 7S
iorier Mooney asked Mr.
Stephensif the plant was gated for security reasons.'
Comrurss
$tepheM said gest''
, t
i
t
I ��
The hearing was opened to the puPi
blic ' I r
4
w 'i: J141 11 :
ielle� W lhaii on'stated that she would like to,,request'that the notification be extended to P.
Micl
residents of Autumn Lane,
le,
reside
House TMil, Stilson's Canyon Toad and Wilder, ? '
0
irm.xi Leland,stated that the Corr%niission'would`take a break from 1Ot25 a,m., to ,1.0:3 a m.• i. I
Cha ,I
�. .
g g Were a lot of
E'
Chairman: Leland reconvened the meetn at sked thai the members of he pi bhc ab de by the fire
people who' wanted to. speak, therefore, he a
ute linz�tatioxi,on cotnmerits Chairman Leland stated that the Commissiozi would be holding i
mit
another h'e`aririg,'tl erefore, members of the public cold speak at then second heari;ig. , I`
A., Fender stated that in addition to Attumnane; T A� del and Lower Doe r�
eir-Me. Shirt 'L.nfan }
1 Stilson s Can on.
a Michael
Road, Wilder; notification should be farther e:�tended to B
Mr. Fender ;said 1?e waw c4nceined that there could be an erosion problem due to the fire
MilllZoada . t,. s M e tura itrtt anclhow the public vWuld enter and exit the r
frot.astyear. Tle.was coiruerned wi ? t tldlifk.
” Mr, Fender'said he waS,not opposed to business, but that he could not'see how he aperatioi
� >�
yvotld benefit residents ut the area. ,
sa that his uncle vias the original founder of the;antds Ranch, which is the closest !
George Barrios d t�
hoti�r; at'the bottom `of He said that it would benefit the Couii because it would be
€,
r the cariyoitA He also stated that'the site
economically cheaper for the p'ople to use the rock tltt is in the carryon
aXea is'secluded.'
tt h43G Ten1VIile.House Trail; sand lie,was concemed with noise, hours of c,peration and was
aeffM d to. the op tion of tlie'aperation pumping front Little Chico Creek= He said. that'the oak
oppos Mitori>> rogramn Mr, Motts said thataa $20,Ob0 bond
seedlings wo1=5d not survive'�vithout a m _ it.g p
vt�ould not he enough. for reclamation and tf jit4t' the Commissio a e° r� herdnnanageme tl orae
conservation easeiiient He stated the` proposed operation is w�thi
and asked What #lie impacts of the operation: would hVe `on the zone, Overall, l�Ir: Mott said that
"rice'the'm acts ;ire piotentially substantial, aft environmental :innpact report should be prepared;
�F
si p
, t
its
an
' er
d + rodent control would be practiced without `end, g g
ow
Cniiiinisstoixer Mooney asked 1VIri 1VYu,t l� �
the species.
1vr, Mott said that cages could be p
laced around plants.
11 .one cif the ovVriers of the subject properly, said that Scott Stephens is a business Mani and ,
Guy
'14all,
at he is vve11:t1touglit o£ Mr,'Uall said that the operation will be veiy cleatt'and � pro cc (groin the
e credlC which is reifioved and p
,that
anyone: Mt ball the operation is above th' > k
creep attlrtliat;tlte road is private: 'Le also said that thev Have hada wildlife iianager ort the property
who rias stated that there is rio conflict bctrveen the wildlife aril cattle,
Mrs Hall':said tlit the site
` will be tieclaitecl to ;its present coiditioit oitce'ihe operation is complete, find that i►, will itdl Have
r' aiy negative effect '
,
» ,
---
a
1fhAtJN11�t.I GOIVIMISIt�I`� ivClNiiT.FS MAY 1l, xd�U PAC;g'7�
ti hiU`t'Tg COUNT' I t
�v s, ">a,r7`a:. :v.A,-; ,k`#+� ,�' t: ,:� t �,e �+wr „`r:*��d K:d:..,a,6 4•M rtea". '; tax z , a a.,atus�' .. d, w
'
f 7777-777"i
Y , w ,5 p:. .se wxM,.M�.•:.,'t,:,.. . -'d,''„o-,1sJ!p L�1,�:VI�1,t dr•w.i”
e.
w
sv�
h�" ! rr iN � ,k ,..t a„` .'� x '?# r dez; ' :)y,�j' i aid! {. iY w '. y x �y � q ro� xy«„,,, 4 W "•i y 1 t>w
, . Y! ,. Po ''1•' .. if : 'r t
,1xgn•. .. �,,, .:,.r .t;:rii`; .4w? ,it dtq. '11 v@': ri is i+7r•b
.,� S.. ,h r. .v.,. `i 1 (• r ,.r� r '`:d i.. r3
��. �.: .. ,:. .• ,.Y 7.•. d s. . :e 1..r „^r f.GL. :i .,... �#-t A. .: ,ry,¢ 'R. I� ,3. A., .. r ,7 ,.,.. .. ,... ,..r, g.,
a„ G:>_'at.: .4. a ,e ,,.,.: n :1 ..�, Ie , .. .l f +.. a, G.-.'�.i h.. ...: !�. y. rA.,l ,,i ntr r. ,.'y AP. • ,v l r .: 1 '•:a:] Av'! .,. A. F , r r °:. 1 t k.
r.. r,. ,.,. ,: ',fr ,• �A! , r ,,. � :,.. r +.% 4 , cA,f.,, '�. 3r f _ . r i r.E er 1`l g1 r 4, T tl
.,':, + r a iy .;a.. rt l.k ,1, }k. f.,,5 z.e {,yr .... '. �. .. h, i.. a .r. r„,, ac? a:h iiia „r.. Vv.b. ta. F.. t ,.L : .a: �, G”{1,, ,, rr ,r..d,.: e:,•, rli r..
r, rllt
Mt ,'4e,... ... .:r .,. �.., ., !, 1� .. t:'.,:.... ., r. 'fir ,, t:. _ a.a,. ,.r, ,e �',,Ji.. d..n M..,r., ^r :)i a 4.1i. L .7. 1. r yr :.r. iB,r t•
. •, i � , . . i M. ,-, . ,. G , .{r. r y a�,y r :.., , ,., .. n s➢..: ri , ' 1' ' r.. i:, `, r r ; t 1y 1 '.i': n ,
i, , E y.,. i,„.r ,a r ,Ai ;±r 4 ar, ,,: I. it w,+r4. •h, v !.Y ax ay r , ,i.,, .� 91i A 4�7„h r{ ,raj
g 1 r { •%i, r....a Y f.9,,: ,V.,r h x. :. .1 .i r, h ., .1$.: , ::: r %,-:. n,-{.li ;,..e• :dr i4i�t, ; �t.. }
„�., it .�.. M v.VJ. •.„ r ,..,{ ... :I,.,,..I '�.. :.p. ',�`e+ ,. '-,R. i ir< :.t,i 0.A x a! V...
,. r. �; ;SrYtt��,,r .�',6. ..tfiro,. .:aSr ',,rr lk'A4.,., r�,,: i ,. r. I .5n,.v,.,E.t`r. ,�:..i d.o.,r..,.. '. ;e�„s_pai.rt,,...,.:..,,r,. .,,tcry.,at.AiX.,sw<A-�.i,,t ,,. «et�,:t.¢„.iC., .{„r . . �..a,J,. ll, .aa.,,r.- r :1., . taA ii;,a 5 a: r v.„,,;r>k<rSi3s. ,...k,r;��_.. , 4.,,+ 1°,i:, .,, . '.tiyi. .{dr r..�...0�L�; ,,, ,:{.tr., . ,.,4 ..,�.{,r iL`,..,7 .p:N.4.{,.r,e., t.'11..a,:...,�. i .. ,,1,Y,tWs. yyr":�!rk-. .:. (�,.y,r.k, ,t.,,�, '..{.,..r,....�.,,.,..a,,:e.: r_ yy5, .,k�,� a,` ..iS. .. ,..q,-�t.r.;.t.+�"rj✓ Aa,r , r, ;k�- t{I„,+3ni L��,n.dpt'r�.3r'1•,,c„.,., �,1.l.;, i.a�,i.f;.. i±'rGr:,,i{„,r,l.,., r{ .iY r:!�e, V.4n�. ,, 'i,�,,, ,1t.to.'. ...rn,.,+..r, rrd:r!,..-: 1 . p,,:ca�y->�. ., ,, .,.;.;.,.i..a;r a , .r.,.c 5 11 )..„ra;t. ?i,:. . i .1.aJ,, i , . ,, �v ,i,„ 41.. ,., �.rp:.rlIr,rk.''t.”3 xdiz '• i! { +Y"�
rt . , ',,R};,.rsr:,,�l;, .�. �. A th.A 4' ,-.''>.).., r ,..n,y7r� 7t ,YI .rrr�r„r a., �.,•t•7,�a.,,.]q,”.,.rr1r�,ru ,A .tr{ �z, .{ , ,�n•
.t
�I
'.rr1tSl,s
,1r,i,:;,•^;
Al
k. 41 3 } i
a,f.. a9:a S},.. .:r 9 �qr.. ?.: i S w '}. I.n. ,. •�: v,. ...A .l>. ,.. , r. :..,, .ti,.. ., -i r U, t, i.r:i� y. , ,.,i ra �d;..,. ,, +..,> . „,. ., ,{., {'"'.5,.. "a;• .S _.,5.
A :t ,.±. {.l :,I ,u. q 4 �, r h,r a..,sr:r, F.'�, .s , .,... r r.,,,.„ .•.� �,4.� t.-.,�:.,. .a.�3,.1;:... o.. ,. t. "r .r { .t ;�:.. i�` ,i:
a, ■J, p,. 1 ..r 41:,r, .pe . f {.Air .,. .� �.a r•.. .h ,4 '',. 4,.. ,.i;."i. t �l, vt , E'
..-I, , ., .- ,1 t,. ..{..,4A,( ,4 .. e, ,�'Ar. ...+ ii, wr.,. ,.;n i.m t"t„ tr=.....� r / t :;rl. {r,i � G!:�,. ;Ink.:, 9 :,a �,4{s:. yt'I t•t- .rk`.r,,.. , :1!z.,�,
r.y
,,_, '1,,...n°..,t....Vft,..�r�,,.r,t)r't lt..X.,... .,,..+i+. . ,.. ,.,.°,irr,!tr.. r.. �<.rrrt .x:;r, ,ii:.r�r ��t�z4..: ,.,,..,'Lr... ,.. t. ir.;''lr.r ':�,a lr: ,yr,tp :'t.p,lf w z,l•.4'.
:, r. 9t-i'.fr::' x...,,. }},, ,,.z•., w. ai 1,+, .,,a...s >rCC11 ar,} r,..r: 4:(1, z 9p..-.. ..ptG.t., q
,9 ,.. i• It�' r P., , r,l ir.: it �;rA..: a �/.,r;1;,�.1 , '..i �.'r'
i a t, +.t�, t.. , t I)}w` .l w _.r 1,• 11 ,, k t,. , a°a, r ;, �, -sv; ..;C I i �„i,.:a.. t / '�, ;'.?
:,c {{ •r.':i 4:, ,,.,, ,•a r s.. r i...! i , ,.t ...,' .�At� t ''.;. ,. w...�_ t,,., r.: r,.' { , h, .i;:
...: - � { r 1:-;5.. t ur,�y, ,r.,, tri a ri .,.,1 {yy. r•.. •1�, 1� r ,:,: i l+z. h:r,,. t ,jr. y }., �..,.. '�E, �'F I . r a .,f, r t,,. �. �J7r4L � � " .'fd'p F •, s •..,''. ...: •u: c: r,r i ,t... y it 'rJ .,'.s , ,n .•1:.1:-; , . .. ”" .. - �LT.Yq.,,,r4t,��� L� .r ,'rya,
.y. ,� ±,rl�.. �,; 1,u1 ver {,3,i,;;lyt .,,,, �rari i1 r'•�A htl r�r,4+„1, trrtal i"., y `4r r,, r lurr vt a,a •Jr ' �r6 "A {', 1'.`"..� 5 #ir '�4*.
"6S4VPLjC4?`iP�.•r�t�i,jl4,`li]Y�u'`1Ul[It�.agli4aM4+ �;i.+a�:L.l t...uc::.Y. ia.F„,r,.u4,r.,aoY...,,:irta,:lr++,T:..,.,,,.”a:,«,��N,«i,++.•t,.'.,,'.a•r-..,`..-n..+;;-� j(i'r, '
ti
t A
r
Ff
oes from the entrance gate to
Chairman Leland asked IVYrr Hall what the naive of flit road is hattg 1,
Canyon Shadows Road up to Highway 32? t
Mr.::Hall said that'rt begins as Santos Road, the road then splits and is called•`Wtlder' ;which is:
actually Canyon Shadows Mr::Hall also invited, the Gomniissioners to come and visit the site,
i
e Bocl�atchSecretai ofthe Siena Club, asked if, the Negative Declaration hadbeen sent to`
i �) Charle , �'
the State Clearinghouse..:
Mr, Breedo
en
t to the State Clearin
house. r
�•:, n said that it was not s g
r` `I;
$ocicratch said that it is a criticat issue,,that the prc;,lpl't be sent to'the State Clearinghouse and
that the mitigation measures as written; were extlromely vaguer She noted that there vas nothing in j
Writuzg as to a planting plan Or'how trees Would be watered ;or hots dust wouhA b:e handled. She said
that oil behalf of the Siei7 a CtixU, she woutd like more information.
Pf i
Chairman Leland, said that the planting plan is Within thE: file and is available .for review at the.
Planning Division,
CoiiimissionerlVloorie `;asked if the ropoiients engixtieer'waa in attendance.
y
P
Jo,u Stouffer, Consultant, as vyell as a hand Use Planner for Tehama County, said. the engineer is
idl1ae ,, ndersion and Rolls, and was not resent; Mr: Stouffer said lie lias known
1 Byrd of Rolls A I p ,
Scott Stephens for appr(jXinixtely 15 years and does yearly inspections of his operrttion: He stated i
that Mt. Stephens' operation is one ok,tlie most reputable'operatons in fiehanla'Courity.
Commissioner `Mooney !said he had concerns with the drainage frorii the pond and deist cortrola
r
M-- Stouffo>•, said is 4 id pon-19,-f or`drainage froiv aui acid tliat'ttte water (dir a galto is `pec minute)'' -�
” r wastun or '
Y g g
used,will be absorbed into 16 material. He said chat thele will ito_ t be an screeiun on �
s�tc Mr. Stoufkei said that tie siltation pond was formed to catch drainage: or siltation from tele
operation. `The pond was, designed to preirent siltation frori: coming offthe rnii e site and going into
Little, Chico `Creek. Mr:'`Stouffer said flint tli operation Will notpump out ofL;ttti; Cliico Creek and
that they Have a 20b -fain well on-site Which vVill bt used:
'
'
r Chairinatt Leland askedhowMitchblastingLWas ei vision
' :' y aiid flint the blasting will be in..ground, He also slated
Mie, Stouffor said once �riayb'twice a ear
that a $2U000 bond Will be filed and! that $5$7,37 will bepayable to the County andjor file State to
assute; that reclafnatio' n- this project wife coti�ply with 'tlie Revlamation plana He stated :that the
grading; r'eseediig aild revegetation will be completed acid that aho-!ear inoriitoringptaii liar been
established with funds de' 6 tiated to bust ". the reclamation. I r, Stouffer said that they kelt it e noise
Wbuld not be. a Stgnifitaij, level impact,
Tae said that this ;project Would create a ore economical
, f taro their raids:
TV ,cath
,., _ ho pian!' � _,
souice for the citizens a li area Irv,
k the 1; orest Rana
Co
iy ` t G
t %iii Was fo 9 a tyl l�
mirtissoner lambert asked Where the tieares L��� �t>< � ie of i�iateria
Mrs f3reedoii said that tele Meridian Quarry Provides n`o road uaateriats'aiid provides e�tclusively to
the! railroad,
i
Y�i�INCi bMN[ISSION lVI1Nt)IT MAIL'
Y � e� � 1; 2000 " �AG� � ■ � ; ,
,
�: n��T� COCJNrI' k'LA i
t n ,,rG, r+1 ,r'y`,.,k, rr � t fr n `!�. ' 0/i1 "nF xra(a .M>`r t'�. ,�' E4 {Xri fi.t"t �Ae I: .�I•' yr , i ) ° ,:rr, "4 a }' : `'^*i `: ' , { t I t l �p,�iw,, , ,, a bd, r�">r rr z;F�. 1� i�i A '9F f r'A: ;e t"f, t
re'r,,y k °rryi+.F•.G.
11 ICY
7-7,17--, ?i *. ,r;t Fa 11a AfirM
i,
puppzs asat of the numer of.dogs allowed.: .:
the C ' .... `� horn t fy conditions!
ommissrort.has'the aut
Cltairrnan Deland asked if y o moth
�.
F
COlt, ssionirx Muoriey said where this i A rel�iew for +compliance with conditions, the Conuriiss on cari state
that they' do not see 'a pro'nlem�
Cairi�rissioner);arriert sAid she is not comfortable with making an opinion on whether the )ISOAS aricult�itat
or commerc al,.
I
f
It was movedb Commissioner Mooney, seconded by Corrimissinner Latribert, andi.inaiiimd'itisly carieci tb
i
ridte that the :Comiiissron reviewed the: erinit'and that the condition s are being nietY
p
f
Y
1
orksliop Vegetation'RemovAl Urc1uiance
G
5
` oin rein Grist.
r� sanClers "gAv e a`brief "siimiriai Letter received fr
d
Commissioner Y skid regariiulg the staff's conrrlerit'thatthere is nothing in'the County Coderolubititig;
'-
,Moone
veget tion or tree rdnioval In 4.bY'. to Ct mtyf'ubtic l�Vof 81,10,rdiriances-yo�t ta,e to hake perntiss onto remove
trees`from potential right-:bf-ways,
'
...
� 2000 I'A�E �M
1: cOU T`Y 1'I,ANNIN�3 OM[VIISSION w MINUT 8 ■ PE3IttfAltY 10,
.,, ,, ..
,, �< � ' a
<., • � ��'
t
�i
,. .. ��.:
I'?A
/d14"N' , ?.4 �`">!ri� vy rx 1,.
'�,."r
r
t,'
b
rw .� ,. a ,a �.. r:;J e F , , �' t�4r':'r�•in� „�i�w ,; r}a .,E, w fi''kK�,ln irr�� r..:f.
t Awa .r'w F ;1,+.. ?�.... G:+;. s, � , ....., .i4aJ. P°'�'¢ ", �. .� ��!il�r r :._ ...,. % " i+'..'�4 <'� t4".,, •�a t ..^ a . ti,nj u* a4i . 1,i, ,, �
� . ,
1:
yj
The workshop was opened <
"
i dna Mae<Fa�rc th said if the ' .. ould think about harm 'thi
� ,. _. ._ to � the sh
is co�si�eruig,tlus as an ordxnanca, ; , W ,. g s
r
\l;ounty
` go'up to the turiber line:, ;She sai d the a of review is. a concern: She said' CEC�,A rs ortant and ou °should
,rm ,
put`the process tri this ordinance. She sad this proposed ordinance is good She sai"d slie, would tike t gee an
ordinance:on vegetatrrin and brush removal for over one acre. •
Mr, Sandcrssexplarned that the process has to be discretionary Yo fall under CEQA:
r_a
Mr, Wilson �rotecl the options s ibm 4ed to the Comrni� stou a,ttlre Staff Report. He said the focus was on the
Scenrc`nghway zones 'b >L
Convnission�;rSLamb ert said the three main issues axe erosion, aesthetics, and removalof habitats.
'
Barbara Manus, Butte l✓nvironirnental Council; shov�!ed prcttt'res ofwliat,happened at Comanche'Creek becaus'
e
= of tree and wegetatron removal .She said tlus`ordmauce rs. needed, Shp said this ordrrrance would be pro-a;hve
,,
,.:,ms ea of reactive: She,sard `we needt'rading ordinance:, She sard'Ythis ordinance is a good first cut. She said
theariiirtssrori`might want to have'a conuruttee of people whohave expertise in this area woxk on this
ordinance,; She said they need a compre. ens .ve ozd in
;
Burnham said that large scale.clearauce is becoiftm a common.occurrence and they need a very struigent
ordinance, ;tiShe sa d'the or' inanoe should inblude discretionarypenrut: She said she r� oulcl like to see Scenic
'-
Ht,hwa� lands rrxoi,�ased in Butte County. She said ,Garden load should bc:, zoncii Scenic Higlr�vay. She said
tiits�;ordinancc i rf adopted, should be enforced uu oilier zones also. She sand the„elevation in the ordinance
should'be lowered to that of Cbmanclre tree%:
y
Cortimissiongr„IVlouney coriune"Hied that he. lilted the ,A.gerida keporty
"
111 t'w r��..-. • i .,nom Y' • GS, •. ...I ,. �� Y w.. . �. •., w • �... i _l. 1 .J ..
1N
I
..': id �4 t7j h f v • q.. � i ,C;: l ,�p—^nw'^,
+
ii IG JQi.4
..r-.n�'4 evuq^ T" �: "`�.+ r G .
�f Ct A'k'i1 k.. ir'i i'.r�
`�
��:
;`
rt
',.
,��.
��r
��
,�
�,
fy
i'' �,;
1, ,.,
;a
;.
w{
:'$
f'
;;i
�,^�'
1
'i
'' � ;r tii
,tP%'
t
?;, .
'��,
��
.,
�:r
,k
t
',t
,(i
_;;;
,.
�� "«;�
i.. �
Y,:,
7
��
ry
w � i.
rf F�
}!�
X44 `, ,,'1 n.4 � I� +"1pF ��� .�^Il ��l
I, ... .., . .,. ,..
+`�,
1,,,
,�,
'i
,'
.;:
.`,-
;;'
•;;
i'
�;
f
'f
I
a h, d
� r tiN`� � � ���Rlj � i n o-�.' p�
aw ea 1
�' � "�� � �
« 'I..i; It ';: eyl. t. ..F.., i w(' ! :lpx{,-,::� .• .., i'. ,"^ ''til .Y.....
3e !::.., ,... , , ,.. •:'Yrp': it s 6,.. ..,.t.. ..:.. a+ .. a.. ..E'e, �.. . .d .,r+, ,•4r
Y i. e',. R• ,.@. i r: =51. .t ,. fr'.t+..".t.
.r r.
„"�. .�-w- �-.p.; � ;„:".. frw, ,V(. "+r . • t.V>;, .,.+ ,, •p{--: '� J,lia'1;..+ { ^, Iri's>ti, i•. � ,{
f5 7, FVr4 .3 ...,,11r 1 v ,t. , r,
Lk,.,,„17.,r ..,� , '�. n. „pl. :a 1lf, ,+. t.�,,:, i •`r i rr- «..g,.
Al d ,n4•, •.,,,, r.4. ,. 1ki ..}.I.- ,. •r.. ti ad ... I�.y;., "��.G,'"k,i :kl , m.::w:•�.., .�,, ..., 1,.,�5.Si i 4 I ,.. •.
.•, . ..a rb? 1.!,, k: ,.. • .{ �I,v .< f ,w:l, :! 7 t... k Ir ,.• ;,. 1 r
..,dy,. , ,..!...1++ < ? 5•,� v .,r +. fl • r :�?i':
, s: ', r.V., 1 .. 1,. : { ., u. ,. ,� . y..... ., ��I. xsn ,.. Y t 7 e ,,1. ?„ r.c i. , .�n •, .. R.
4 p +, .y , , :Y ,,. ..pn5 :i ,. �..i ✓ �,. ,'0.'4: n;” ^ n`!'xiJ`: E ,x .. .:,, ` „ ku ila 1::p,i
.... E.lt+. . 1Y,r_,,, ,f.+,5 ..{.,��.. -11 ,;k,.y. i, i,,,+,...+:. 44..,{rny �.,{ r-
r,B.: , :. r..,, ,.`:�� . _ 4 .. wti I 1>�. <,... A , g.Yw.p,'h • , y 1. Iw,:V; er t, 1... tk,. 4 n?. Y.?t, ,Y r. ! ! b: ..f, if t a w, ., n:,t:
� !'1! ,. •, tl.,,, .,,., i , .4 „ r, �I ,,, ,6i I Y,..,. ,n... s.- . , 'j. 3 a. '�. +. , tt,..: ,.. I .. � .. !. C � � pft i it riet~•?:•t+ ct .. ,.bw'} •.d
#!!, ., �•o ,+rrV a,., wy.+,uy ,.• 11, a ,i 91�,.t -:. :, I:..,
.. t ., ,.,� n. e:.. ..5. I. ,.,• ! ,e{. � it„.+Y ,., la+ ... { �?'w N`b.” ,. p,, ., ,11a� .•K ,ta ,.4..a. Y {).
? . .,;., a e i ,.. b,,. 1.+. ,., w ,.; -.k, r 1 xi;4c 1,.u.,>{ rC r11. �� >a , ,,. s ,,.oi -kt•> s -.a lY'• ��d' a , µ. ._ •1, t r -; r_.. P'.
I,�t vuk_r .t..�i1 tb., r, C ,<,. } , �.. ,ri.. ,.GN 1,,,,., � ,,, , A, , rr r� , •, , . u _ + ,, � ,
�';
x. _.., . s -.,. „ ry( ,_,.,.. 4 t., - c, : 't ),. ,.. v i,..:rt.,,.«.k., r�:.t (, {...,..., .a.. .. E ,,.vw ,;,, kf i •,,: :,.,..> .i !._;r„ r L
y.,.... t,. 3F .•Y,.... ,, w -,,. +1,.'1. .,, ,. ,. ... L.,, a...Sir ,.1�,.,_ q.,. w... ,, .n. f:.V .,. .t .., ... kr�.. , .n-. •I. m.,n 3!- }Y^r. ,r 1 b. �aT�. n ,ai { !�, Y r « . a rl{ . r,.�. u . a 3 i,., I ,i , r 11 9 , y1 .4b ,.t «
s a.�, ,., ; i 4 .a,'.• r, t.,,'k.,. �r ., :4 ,_ .. � ..,,u. «P. 4a , ..: »� ; a,,' t +4i s
, 1 � �'�,,- ,r. ,; .�". , i s r.. , . . ,. ter r,3.. � � .., •; , .-., ,.'� r L� ,.r, ,..w� , �,: r ,: 9
. I' .} ;{> r.: G S�. _.,.�.,v ;, k. R. t.,. i. '.: .. 6 :b ; f� „ i �.a141�+„ + 6 � a. ar , .I,. ,ti �n.... t, ,�} v t..... +t, 4 „ .. ` • i
! krr .. e f - a .. � i..-., �. _.y •, ...... . ri«,.. s„ r.s.- :4i. a. u'�� ,_e.-, e 4 S lu �4 s 1 x y. •�u ,,,. ..,.+xi"� , Ya .d• >, ,., r. l } s$ �'dk� �',:;....,rN t.. ?4i., l r .:':Ix;.. •11
,,;. .,. ,.. ,.yy ,i i.,n„'i,�. 4.. ,4: +V,.• .X •.w 4.-. 1,.,., i. `at.. ._... .�• r{l,a tl .,,, .., 1 r.U..q «L, .„ « , .> �. „t.. r�r :e:i ,1•
„ . ,{1 .l..4 a. a. ,.. ,. ,.1.. ?i,. 9 •_., , r . , ,. r..oU �� ...1..r. .V Y ... „ « .. a , .., u a,+. ,i .txi :,_ J , . , '+I .4.3„i ,'• ::ia elii. d ee.f,,! Y{l:22I .}Y,��-.«.,kYfJ � /! +, e : r ...{
.. ,., a'y...s,. .: e.,.r ,. ,tki8, ,:'r :.�,0. t+. o€ < .;:: r, =M -:,r!5 , .,,«.. e', ., L.:.,o ,.1 n. ,a! 7, �,.. y,. ,,�, .. >,±1,y r ,. yF.,. ,, ..+, . r,,j, ,i„ ,..n,PS I�•4_, r.,t tl,,.
`#.. ++! • ', 4. ,.:. ,,: , .. 5 w+. ,, . t, �,.R tn,t .�.: 4 .n,. ,.,,,.. ti, .: ,! r: �, . w ..r! - . e n.. , , I ,'.•u.1. .... , i t -' , cS?} dt; Y 1 r':Ca
.. 4aK W, S+,> X1. !l.., T,- :7 .' *y. ..,:ut u. ;.?.. .... r. r', ,:A „ .41, ,.•et•... -.i1 4+, b.r. ,]' ,+M, I ±'M i, p nr c4 r r_xi. ., i .al 'f
•. r• ... „ ..:1.. tiw r r.H ;w..? V r�'.-�* . •...,, • <!t -,: ,+' � -W .± ,. � . l.Y lE:. ,.... Y ': ,? � w,,r, t. 4. .p, « a r Vi; d, i`• '<. 4'
:1V S...§a,1,,.7 1 ...E,Y,S,r ..a r�,:{wr.. 1 1,1 h {.'�14�`r e,;.,.... ,;+'ia cht. ,4+ r�• .i:�it I ..'.t .,.r',� Cw 4.pn,.,. ls:s:��„
7-., ia. n ., { ,.t, x„ 4. , {.e d.,,. rt..., _x. ,' o �:I i. ., .t h' ✓ f 1.
V:. . {r k.4."V .k.;1, ''iiVi...P �.. .,^. xk'kl:: ib ,� t. 1. n c;`r'. �r.1:'” I: 4, e i. -F- j 1 -:P'?l 4 r. }�4 ,r,; 1 'r•. .I,... r�z, ; •I , t
s
k t,a? },.,.. i fif, n, .. .,.. I. �, �+y . � - �: #.. '.• ,1 ',, ,... i � wt 1. , ,.v .S. n .. a. _ r.. a +1'� , r - 1u; h'.' d,- i': .wi , y i
«.,. 1 a =J, -.v fwy4 .r,, t; � ,,,'?.,e .. }a:,'« .a ,: b ,_, �,I« �,'� ,pE i.+c «.tt. ,{:, d c , I a ,4 ,I,.. a «„jr .t•.,. A, :d�,t� :C'''
P ,.,, - 1 y .,. ,:,ltJ ,x»r..,. ,,_ .,�.ukv k,.i. t,s. .yh,.., irS.,:I: ,., �. +w.--_. r= 3,. h ',..•.:I i a5 ro. ,$ t ,,.+.,;r 1
'..: -:• ,., ! ti 1u�,, ,� � v.... ., ...,, 4..�... r,h ,x .1,, BVI �I ^ t ,...,.>, , ,,,'w ,. r . = r,rk� rr �,. n., . I n,. ..1 s ,p..6 I � . a ":�4 , , h, .�'{ . w t 1:? I,{ 'x�
t �.,. :r ,.., i�arpr., ,✓,l. .. ,�1 ,r... ., r.,-{,.. ry,v,. ..I. '..w, ..r ra , .,... 4... ;.,v 1. a. P +�'v. F r'T • o ,° =:b4 ,. -t '„au:.
,. :. 3 � 4 .:§xit. i� , •.., ut, 4. �,..,.. .I :, .,1 r V V:. ,.y, ,. � +. +,., ,w±'aY':. < 3,1 ,. r; a � -
,:
lr 4� la+ k` i1_ if.r:. +�ly,i � d;V,+V9� ��'1t� S' ��{^•+ I 1 �4r�11, ; 4 f., i, v rS, 4 w �,it: 4 � tr , t � i u�xir,�iw+� •���7C�i1d y t l a
,+. ;Ykl.�`l'>+iirkkS �4.krt.,1tH+a.ilru,«+k.3..ark.•Vr>4�!rtiiiG+:si41w.r..1..rSE�I�.ufM+�Y+.-„n.4;�,'5.,:,w�.sa..>.y�4. tk1r'�-u1r.�wr. , { I t1 �t
yat.il r,4r
�`,ra1•.�7 sl. r � t��� '+t'�„�,v►'rr.a�,� ,1 , ' til_ I p' r+ y
{� l•I, 9 to � � 1 f y1� ,M,
,
r
,
,
u
t •�
.I aun
x
1:.
rI.AND' (aF NATURAL W.ALT,H AN'p BEAUT'Y��'4
I� � PLANNING DIVISION
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELAPMENT SERVICES
7 COUNTY CENTER DRIVE •' OROVI[ LE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3397
:TEL
EPHOI`+E:' 530) 538-2601
FAX
{530} 538 7785
BIUTTE
COUI�TTY PLANNING CU
A
ISSI
Im
UN .
ACTINGNI)A
JANUARY 27, 2000
TME: 9:350- 6-i M--.
PLACE; Board of SupeMsors' Rooln
County Ad mstration Center
25 Couniy Center DriVe
Oroville, CA 95965
I= I
w r
T PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE?' ;
II. ROLL CALL,- C' stoners Lambert Nelson Monne and Chairnia arid.
ormn i Y
is '.Cage, n ..e I �
III ACCEPTANCE •OF AGENDA Coim ii�sion tnembas and taff may request additions; deletions, or;' t
— . -.-: T __ _ia ...�:.:..,... •.. �itn.. A �i.N'1 iw`/w1«�pN ii -S -. r _ .:.- �_:- —:- .. _ T --: -__ __— .. -_ - —
it
Y,
{�I� � ��
..I !�
r,
�t
'r
t
;',,
L
�` .. ,:il
i' 1 4
5
{ �
4
f
'. i "' 1.'.' �:
I
E.d _
1 •�kA'i
1
. It
ti �t�.
i'.
�*'Yi yy r3'� I �yf,
MW"f ,t4WAi5.lth���t"'�111� "�* jk,$bkw—M�"`—..S+,.l:l¢de
e �i
i
The Commtsston asked that the changes staring on Page 19, Line 26; state, the'suggested change t6make the
minutes clearer,
ed b Commssioner.Ca a and carried to a prove the minutes
1.1t was moved by Commissioner lambert, Gecond y . g , p
of Novembei 18r 1999 as-correctedy the following vote;
AYES' Commtssioriers Lambert, Mgox eyNelson, elson, and Cage ;
NOES No one
ABSENTt'No one
' {
ABSTAINED; Chairman Leland
pecerriber.9'.19y9
he Commission had the Nlowin corrections;" P+a o; 10, Line' 25 change"`own" to "owned", Page 11, Line
g g
{
9 change "moving" to I expanding" and Line 10, change "to" to "and."
t
CoinmtsSloner Mooneyasked if the Commission ,could have a tneinber of Animal, Control attend in etili
regarding kennels? -
'g Erickson $nvironinental` Ike` De artment •'stated that ha will send. a re resentatt `
Crat' , altl . p p 've from Animal
Control to all meetings involving kennels,„
A
It was moved by Commissioner Lambert, seconded by Comriiiss`ioner ;Cage, and unanimously carried to
r
a rove the minutes of December 9, 1999 as.corrected.
pP
VIL' CONSENT Consent items are set for approval in one.motiom These items are coesidcred non-controver'sia[ No
�p ,,; , . q � ked,
resetltatioris` wil[ lie ma o, hov evert some u , t ma� , a
missipner or miy'` ► �, �i[►e public Wishes to pull a conseti't item for cliscussion� Brief questions
The Chair will ask ifany corner'
— may by asked ori any items-
evne#li and Jennettte Niblett (Itt r l �iianed ;to ;be citagorcahy exetript from environmental
reV ewe 1Vlinor Use Permit to allori: r,k, ; , anent second dwell ng'uri t ori property zoned AR -2.5
(AgAl ult "ural Residential _ 2,5 ac! The property is ;located at 13707 -111 show Izoadi
Ivlagalia. APN 066-360 04 (SB)(M 1j? 0 -04)
Commissioner Lambert questioned the water 'supply being from one well'to both dwellings, She aSkLd what
pl?- he property is divided?
ha ens tf,
i
rominissioner 1ooriejr said the applicant would leave to show Proof of watexf
IVff� ttiekson said the applicant will need to "ser aside an area fora second well for the'second dwelling, He
said the liroperty owners' can, enter into an agreement to use the existiri well for bofh parcel's He said the
Cottrity would ask for a recorded dater line easement,
Cha rtiiatt Lelaridrasked'fegacd ng ltents 6 and 7 otI,Nge 3 of the report; It talks about road improvements,
two ` ` ' would the. a licant lie re uirod to a cage°Ninisliew Roam as in 46 oir
its Was pp pg
oif hne u t ertrianen ilrana e s '
p P g olution au eta:0 -
r n Trg CO[1NCY PLAiVl�11�G i ONlbiIISSIbN NttlVtl'MSL d JAN[IAItY [ 3, 2040 i pAG>: 21�
1L r
i4 hY �
I A' ., A ° �4 A
.W �j �� �� � � �
R
Y. �
�h t?.
a ICY ;��i � e� t ski ,��m )�y..'h h ° ��S' � iF .°W4
r�4 ,s� y � %�°�� °:7 � r t A
4 "btu+ j��'�'; (.
p 4
dt7. :Y.. i bf., ., 'I JY. (... , 1 +tix: t'4+ x ,1, n 4 w.. `t 'V'4 :.. , .. . <. :81 rn FY. .kr. 1' d ,i,>..# xa', Y 1;1 ,... '9.J-,:. ..�t •I+iY, 4 i", N 3.'11 v.. lir 'p
. :.. :t'k..,.J...l w s. .:,:,«, a, 4 't.. _,.u.r, ,.�:. t,. ,. a....r 5; ., : iS Vdr.. ..t: lc:�r °I ,I._. , »a .. ., w,. :, t. ...,, ,.. ni.. ., , 19 r.a.; r'^ �. .p: -C •+ ,. ,t w.r
v„ V,.. r{a ,.+ , a. , pr,J.y., -�`., .:,,. ..a, i1 r Y..S„ '4.a! J,...iL. i9:.,.0 .... r.,v.:k;t.:.'A. ti,,,..a•a .. v d ...0 .. tt.. h ,,r..,,, ,,,r,. a.f.. , , 1, • ,,J.,
I,r.,�...,
:. L ,r 1 i.. , .: `:,lr=:J9 1 t,: t, ,., t, A e, XS. <1 _t .. r,, �,r ,4 ,, t,a," rY,.. :, .7«. •.,,,r. �5. i. Y:71*..t� l i..., ,,,'R #r .,1; i..4:'�,;.Y ,� ,�+�( :i.
•.•,.,
:taY'..�,1.
.., _t,.{�.'"`�,e
.., }, ,:, T:�«,.,d r » • a. t}, uD r h ! •e, �„ r , .,..:..a,.
„t tiY J?Pn, P
d., r ai :+uWt. i9 '�', i ....}.. y,. F�41• .,y'*4`6"0 �#+'k,
'rt ,?;:i. ,1 a,1 .... ..:.4 ai ` .aA'+•, s a '{l,, ..�. ,h� ,
It ,� r f, ,d, . ,1 rW= , . •A,+ wi � a R x-- J
'.:• at,M1... �ti. en., ...:k..ak-�,r..,,. ,?Y...,.i}-r.kx t{.�5..,,, t. :,�.: 4,a.�Pa.:s'x�'E.�.�i�,l
,V "!. j , ,,.
s:ppFa.�n.^Tr,� l
7_,+
„� w u k. a,� r. E{ r{{k p{,.6 ..<�ii I Its 1C"r ai .�.k3 Vn++. ><«, 4 ',5 i ,{� ,.•¢:l>a . 4 .,. „� .:. F,}: Y.. .,, o:., ..^v M, ,aP' :-.lt .t l �a�:` i 5,. V, f�^ „Y✓, f d
.0
5 ... ? q ,• ti,t.l,AYI *. .754, iV ,. ,., ,. a.t,,,, .,+ +Cv r; r},, , , d' r .6a+,.,{ av*aa ��,F,. a iJ 1f++„ tan r
y1`s ,:. ..., ti ,.Y..az .i.�h ,.i,., ar.r. .,«::...: .r:'- } .t,1x ,^4`f. .�f..«L „�a} t�. ,,... r„ ....,. r. t ...it 4:., ,.r w+r:.. - .r 1 }'::bYMS .r9�#iJY'. `u:.;Yirw',l!,tY•.41:.,':.
s. --',:4i...#�«ii., .. a, ,.: t.,.....- rr I ,...., 1 r:'I��:Y'� Y��V'r ia�... ,t»• t : sV�... r .� x, .. i'\+....,.:r r..., .,_ �- L'pu's. t' }., v. 7. , , ,.g4:=.�d". N L: rY.�'d5, r p '.#•5��`ic.Ya,: u�'d.. as "�.% , v Wi
1 1
'�'' , , ✓ '. '-0.,9 ± r.,. .. 1i �,' Ya:� 4r'i ,.1 , ,.+.+r. �R ,. :+.. rrt .'Air 9 ... ., 'A_ r � y. .J.i, :7o -„t I p... � +i.Y. 1, f `:c�. �F o,y-.. .:d
'a,
v;.«v v� \ „Y 5 }.,�, n 7 ii t .,,r„ a..,ti. P 9,, 5 i.pSto r, tt•..
b, `` .°s' '1�,, i 5 , .'rg.. J,, . + .,,'�AR6,., Y°y,+ #s u.9 tc.�}.,.. , :4kr , >.? -A t . +,r .. f. .l-. , r h. IS , i, r r.Cf:, . i ,»\.,, ,.I «. ?,t W.. ro ,., , ,,,, !,a. 'i.• A. � ;:a fY„': r tr Y. i ,. v+. {'i .,4r,: „l, 5Mj .&� r. •t a r,: : ..r,i. h. i7:,. «i ;>:. . �r p�.. - a e .n. i'-'. r,. , c: , s #,'.�,.0 ;!rr ! ., 'r: ,J.-
ra 9..1 u 1 .. a r,, s,. ,A5 .: 1,,, < - C ,:, r ,..,,di*� s.�'.�P. .. •, ., .., r i.. R „�b , � .. , �.5. - `5 ! ,.r 9. � ,+: i�' ,.�.�t,l C �+,;.`-� r r 4,aat p „l;:, ,.e5: t. •pP Y .;W�+. 4,.,1, ..tr^. 1rv�i,. ,
.. \., �, ♦ .:. 1. , ydYY :, $. � :l, l 1.. } Ys v... 5 i. ,..,7: i. iN � , I.,:w r .r.. ,2 ,^ +X! �Yr 1�. �y r. },�*xrale� 6 a .,. '9 :, „ a e 1 'x` ,} v I. �.. i . F Y,. i ' ;.. 4! r, � Yr, x t. st ,. �E,. 4,
.. 1 � t nota . rk 4+a1 , .....,.2,:,,15, �C ,..:.. 1r ,9...,. ..., s,, .: r ..r4 r !'�, , r : 6 1 6� Y. Y , ,1 N.,. , ,*}A i .. t ' A �;1.. ,.cl . r ...+:..... , d i, � Y 1 by,.i: . ,1 ,^. xz'. a) 41 ::',,.. r...i� •�, 'P ,, r) ., 3 j..,.r;Nl:,i
,.... 4.�4 ...,.. ,i A ..._t, p -• a ,. . r+1. .,, .v., ., ,�.. tr \ 74.,. 5, ,, .�., . .z a# 4 .:Y i{ I Dh�. ..y ,.. ,.. Fs�,.. L „_' el. .t, r .». ....:: r- Y.rr ,.. .Y r'r ,. f ,5;�t� av .t,.::..
^- ., i,�: .0 a At.1 �.15 ,:x, ry �. ,4. ,r9 ..t r. ,.14\.,. ,",P,•... +. akl.Y 6V �+.i..x,.. "'l1 r. Yn.�, ft ,) rw .7.1 ;..,+�7 s, -r .Y:C.,.z •�.. .,aY-a,r.a., ..�. ,e ,.1,. ;.9 .�e, ,: .rr ,
,. S(e,� 1,. r, 4, , 4,r, ,A. ,.,.1 ,9x. �J�;, :tlw �Y, , a, s, > r. -. ?6: •”. , �r , ,: .�i...i',. � r �.,;.)t . ,r , , ! _, a.,h x„ ,. , ,r �f' . A f.4p5r ,:
i�7l51.§ F�W}t �a �u # I i �,7.i{ tiY d �Y � i P •Sr �'. \xt 71 +r •, 1'k fr. % yY 1a ( t ['+ \'�.
t .'.:1� I,- I �� .r � _ - i •�I t14 ygli17,
Y
1 1YT
el 'hearing WaS Closed.'
i u d^�/ Ilkl
i
,. `' r I r.. r s '1 � •t,' a.-
' It w y, er Mooney; ,seconded by'Gommissioner:Cage, and earned to recommen
as moved b Co'M' mission
approval''oi the re20rie for Gerald1ErfiWDale River; REZ 99.-04, subjectl.to the, findings and the
t
91 Condrtianal Zoning Agreement conditions 11"sted below
I Recommend the'Bcj Fd of -Sup tviIs 6:isa do')t' la,Mtidted l�fe'gat i;e Declaration with the £ollovuirig ,
.� find
wprigs: Ali
,i
,A,'.ii rmtial Study was completed in compliance with the Califarnra=Environrrieiital Quality
Act tdenh£ymg potentially significant environmental effects that the pioject may hav6i, The
w design ofthe project and riuti "atiolns added'to the; %lett as shown iii Exhibit "R" .Condition
b;
'1'�vrll mitigate such.effects'lo a levelo£ihsigiufeance.
The° ar
i
Bo d of ft&v mde end'
p .. p eptly reviewed, analyzed aid considered the,proposed
f Negative Declaration,`vVrth ,itigatiori.ineasures p for to inalcirig its decision ion the project, �,
and'` hereby' finds that a Negative Decaration;. with. ins” gation neasr►res, adequately ¢
represents impae:s asscciatecl with this project and reflects the --independent judgement 6 , 5
r { l Butte County.,,
r
II The;design o£the proposed pro�edt'im rovements will not cause,environm.6!tal dams a to fish and
p g
I�
wildlife or their habitat, ,and a Me minimus',' exemption regarding impact to fish and wildlife or their
habitat i� recommended.- The collection o£fees pursuant tolish and Gairid.Code
, r
J and M t.k 75155. #is not recommended. `
r
e,
TII. keeomiriend tlic,13 ard,''o£ Supervisots adopt ari'Ordinance approvmg'Re"zone 99-0'4 and adopt `a
Resolution approving ua 'ondition.Zoriing Agr�emettt stibj ect to Condition-# l -listed ti xlnbit
} with the'£oilowirg fimdmgs: " }'
1: The project is consistent with the Agricultural Residential Gerieral:Pian desigtiatiori as
supported by the,following; - '
a: Condition 01 requires that a Conditional Zoning Aogreement be°recorded specifying
that onWsite. se`1 a cfl8pos al inforinatioi�' be 'rprovided to, the satisfaction lo£ the ".
Env Health ;nepatineiit, prior to any land division ar deveiopniert, g1'the
P'
Y,
t��r •'
b. The'. roe ' is served with access b Ricliardsori S r%rr s Road a+minor Icotrii
p i: y p g ty,
road: ichardsoii Springs+ (toad intersects Coha`sset'19 , ad, a 'County arterial road
appiokiiiiately ttutee=quMters'of a mile to the solid west, Tliese "roads provide a level
of service which allow fol unrestr'i`cted truffle flow:
i
h`titure development shall be "fequircd to coihply With Public Itesovices Code 429th i
.; .. r
i
regarding the provisini o£, ater avatlaliility iii arilwlits adegixate,t`or fire protectiong u
irite1*011 sprinklers or le protection of structures! Arid oflier fire "safety 'standard :
I i
di Tile proposed 20�aCt`e parcel size is indicated as being „Cpnsistent with the
Agricultural iR,esideiital denerai PIaiY Desg!iatioti:
I
1 t1T C 'dbIt NTV:PtAINNINd COIv ISSION 0 MtNf1TL5'Y iAt�tiAV.1 �i zd00
r
, I
S Y ��'. �;w;c"ava,i Y'C y'ry„�'."t �i"fir„^� • "fFt*'"uP Jd'S' " J; ir FAI Ott”
a
'ar:.,? ''.a' a r R,. ,'i1 i}. 7,Y �3.•s'd'.,D'.r 7l4^, .�P.N , Cti,.:sr .uy,.. 3 S .:, i. i,i�, y 'FiS,J,ps 'y, '. o?tt r'yA'iF#;:';(Y, Y w c'. i},p
,,l t -.�.. .r a . t ,,W„t,.,ra x, 3F i.. i ,.. W , t. (!, r o• 'sr:''",iv,� �'wj 1. .,r wa !k. ,
Id„4.a` iillt :.,,. :d ,I, ;,... d.'F•. -,n. .{yi Pp ,r.;, pat ':.,,,h A �.�.,. i} ,.. , y ,.y., _, s,. ,�.i;r F a 1 „i ,.: Mr p....'?' a F'''... 1{'7.".'I^L� +:l r'A.t '' «: v1 `4ny�.... o
;m
ti
a
2
H a
JIM
%
Onj 1 rS, Aq IT han
ass.
t t
I 'the property 8ub,j ep o e sh
A -A rqjedt:�idp6sihg"osubdivide,-otdevelop't rezone shall,demonstrate ly" p
4
hd," f the 61 County EAvironmen a Health t n order ,
t7' iof� tentative map
to`de'rabristrate bfi-si e. sewAge, capability pilit''Of the application
it
z,rnapi
�'.tentative "
Mee-t,,usab'1e,,4d;i requir'P se alge:41sposdi.syste s promulgated in the
'Mel m i
"
ib " f -
it to, an6rds dix'' VII,
;Siibdiyis� imp Standards; A, p'pFn
4:
0 y 1-o"nv prTiplit: , . �
County
'V-k� 6
to th e lao.
Any proposal "Lk- i altdffiatiV�' �SOW;igedi,s�oial systein due f u. 6-0 area fo k
site disn'bsO: §fitilf require a maintenance and oversi'Af entity With,
conventional on sewage , 1-1 1 1 1 1 . I I - . ''I "I
-:
ii
1'W', t6�QualityC Olit dh proposal Capproval r �61 Board:
se
dte"'d'-' C y--ca,se,
�Y.Ahd 8u
AYES:'-:Cbmrqissioners:C
NOES' '.Cdftiinls§ioriefs Lambert and Nelson
ABSENT: No, one
AB A04EE 0 one,
4c
TIS] t jd� h to be utilized by die:PlqY' mi'd Drrector
'L, �[N
h
X. B agi
GENT - -
I do. '16d 61d iias be�ii,dhwkd to
wit gea'6 1A
V q scusstohi
d every 11, a, but
resoem �,dt and britig beick to thd6mmissimi, Renis A, g.&C'ptaynot always,,bew-ddrasse'd r e I
Vhvqys-_e i e wspic
P-1 till nahide.Update
A. General , Plan/Zoning In Ordinance
B. LOgi§1atiV' ase Lave Vpddt
on: OILI rft
81 'C lice
ing-3orn is 's
-tllftt'tl 16 Board oz 8upolVis'ors approved Vie the .Business ,� ark Ordinance
Wi Wilson informed the Corift'19816h OA
if, area as i i e
i4e 'said ea w Ident ti di'
and General flan Aitiendment ort Tuesday; 4ty "11; `2 0 0,,, a no spedi .6
?
If J,
letter and ap.onevt_ oms( gilt
Corrmissi() i ' ' 7 'Anb6i said she r&div6d,ti'1ett' d
1Pl_
I . , I , I t q
be. -oil 6,t,� lid, g what e handle "these In U'r
g 8 6kdd Wfi �t the to
h: 'Ut "in I ai.ber,aftip 0 Vproprl 0' � Ay
e ini roj
.,ca.,
I
tf ShId'Ito told W_ � fl�, not 1 1 A i..
thbin he ,ou no
'-",in'' "ib or 1jelsonsaid e., rec'e1vd&'1he,saft1 6A. give ah opinion,
om issi n
aft, 'app ica ion,
riot 0 rp"I" 'g
Was ,is v a oil withbut" havifig all A i
a t
t.,:, i on said et Bard 'o give n OPIOI
UN ... Y., P . 6 t. 6'
NNjf4 COMMISSIO 0 1 TE A
■ Urrg,Co T FL A,
JIM
xr� � M � J��t �' ;�, r`» � a
iY ���r��l�y �yi 1 .'I ,, _ mei y' rr.�' �.a
,. :�, r .
''-iU 4 '�"�kgr11 n f,P .,fir,.. k, i,�f�; d ?"M�1 e4 �1..':w,�. iF 19""r }. If+ "q i':!: •e7. t+/' t':!�yA.� 4 µKt i;P*'� ;, t�1['. ,I.�C �� M i, :, .1+ti v 1.1 ,�':-.'s 1�'; I
-
t1 .' 1 ,,.r tr, '� f .0 vP Kj�.•r "a+_i 3. M � 1 1., L'.w,r , h' .w a....
j 11 a eem t from
Item detenntrled to be Cate one
Kenneth and "Jeanette Niblett ( g a y p ,
y ens rotuiiental review) Tse Permat to allow a permanent second dvvelhng.uriit on
ti
,Miaor
' property zoned AR -2:5 (AgttculturaI Re-Ao pial.- 2 5 acre parcels).: The property rs located
at41167.1 nsley V RoadlVlagalia. APV 066 360-094 ` SB 05)
,r
Ir rJ
B. A `roved'
Pp
x� 11 1
l�oyald and Elizabe7h;' Penland - ;Item 'deternu ';d 'to be categorically exempt' from
J.
environ: iertal review) M�rnr Use Permit ,o allow a p%rrnatzent second, dwelling ort property
zoned ;A�R (Agrloultural Residential) 11he pkope . y is located on the'west side o£ Victor
brive; approxiriiately 425 feet north of Nord HighWay, in, Nord, north o f Chic , AYi i 047-
``� 490,002'(S]3) (1VtP 00-04)
FROM T EIPL,OOR,ON ITEMS NOT ALREADY ON'`Iht aAGENDA (Presentahans
VIII:, Bi7SINES
" ` ^ - Hill.h'e Iiniited to five -minutes the. Planping. Commission,I'S prolubited by,State Lnw from taking action ori any item
r
presented i£at is not listed on the Agenda)
ri
IX. 'PiTBLIC !IEtLIZINGS ;The Clair Will`call'forstaff comments The Bearingyill beopened to t1�e public for
to the and dscdssion bon>ined to the
proponents, opponents, : omments, and'rebi�ttals. The heanng will bo closed public
Comnnsston. Theommtssion Will then melee a matron and vote on the Item.
"nested that tibhc mit ated resenta+iops be linuted to a mazit -`45 minutes so 'that all interested patties
"address
q oil the
have;an opportunity to address the Coiimissior� following yoor presentation, please print yout: name and
speakers sheet so that the record will be accurate.
the recommendation of Count staff, is mdlcated below Itis only eebinmeMdadon,and has riot yet been considered by.
y
, ,r
pies o£the Staff Re oif are ayal i iM1 ti Ogee
the l'laaning Commission, Co p la{�i� at the P annmg A� V�s�o
" o Bo:�rtl of Su ervisors'��2
m' Prov tti
A." I�ecom end a rout to
pP P
''-iU 4 '�"�kgr11 n f,P .,fir,.. k, i,�f�; d ?"M�1 e4 �1..':w,�. iF 19""r }. If+ "q i':!: •e7. t+/' t':!�yA.� 4 µKt i;P*'� ;, t�1['. ,I.�C �� M i, :, .1+ti v 1.1 ,�':-.'s 1�'; I
-
t1 .' 1 ,,.r tr, '� f .0 vP Kj�.•r "a+_i 3. M � 1 1., L'.w,r , h' .w a....