Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
PLANNING COMMISION MINUTES & AGENDAS 1/98 - 6/98
1,11t.j;4t;�,.,[b, Ao; AQN,,q A4, jl�f i �,W ;i Ii;IA 11;ij q mt'�ee, , , � I , I "' , r 1. , T !,;, . . Y. t , I I el V1, i't, .—i. t,4;t, I.01 "I i� J�f �i "JOW" N11 ?"it, %xi I;" l9W Aia qj) 5j, '6 " t , tj,", "r V�V I,j IiAi , ""l'. W, �, I " ; i -, i " — , , . � "i , , �,IV I i" �� , i0y INI�� .4,%. �jv � '44, l( " , .10"'Iti , �.,%vw 111911 lll fill' till � I I ." , I . 1, , — r4 , $ , I , t �oA� I I ". � I I �, 1, iel� 1: !�,;, , . . , I I �, , '10, 11 , -1 A I If i"t it R WE "Al f !!��l PI s A N, i"A '.f, q� MWO "'o Ir, OjO 11�,i. I;" y il Ilt V TI ;,i. 44 if jll� , ;",I —, � "I . , , , '), "'. ". ` , I , 4, �? 'I s, ff e J, �. 'I �: si� -4, �, I P'l., J " , v", 10" 1,,. �4 j TI 11V . i4i _.tY%1, :;b "43 "'v 11" , vp q I� Vi , k .1, , ) ,, I'll tl� 11 1 .,� 7 Of, Atli, , �' ., , It'i, I P,,,- . .1 , im" o" Vim lV1 r"'. �1, , if "it ,I Y'I A-0 j T'j" I' "Ol Ilik"111511 , I ,, ., , _'d , I 3 &ri P I,W 1. 111. I—el W', XA A if, 4,N 'VA x ", , m" �A e.t 41 l. I � t, Ot, it lt .1 j qt, Alp, P NNING MINUTES,:& OMMISSION �AGENDA_ A 19,810,610 itit�71 10, s"'id�i�t��(frYlfitY,f111,1.'ul"i�"'.4"iitA`Ki+�'tl'6%diifaa1+�4rtiaji..srt....i»Y::.W14.a....*,.,>,:.wur+r+arroYr++aa.wns*rcw+•5'y+q.5.r�»,�+u..,b«.wa,,......,:.�..r... M.r ^-'- -- r, r. r }I . p iat7 tiyheele - ,, proposed'Llegntive De'c'laration with mitigation measures regarding r environinental "impacts. and TGe Perrr� t for a'boarding stable "for 40 horses with, a.riding stable and '; s a 'feed,` and' tack store on property" zoned A-Ar; (Ajr cultural "- 40 acre parcels)located on the. north W,est'eorner of V�est-,Rio l onto F..oad a ld"Smith Avenue, identified as," ;022-100-024' and ' JP0$-20) COmin an abstame front" #itis hearing aril stepped doW -from the dais! ' issioner Lel 1Vlr. Sanders;gave a brief rsnmmary of the project, 'He said the applicant is requesting" a feed, store and tack 1. , shop for which staff is reoommending denial. Staff is recommending approval of the "boarding stable: He; - said there are twb parcels-of approxunately 29 acres, liut"only 6 acres is being, used for'this permit He said he is :concerned With the amorznt of traffic the Horse show events will generate. He -said staff is asking that the number' 'o f ho , to be boarded be' hm ted to 30 He said the tack shop is recoinri ended for denial as there is riio provision tri this zoite fora commercial use, Chairman Lambert asked,: f this'proposal '' on two , parcels? Mr. Sanders said there are S underlying lots" W& '.o parcel numbers. He said the project proposes o use the Smith Road'fxontage of each of the 5 underlying lots. The hearing Was opened"to the';pub 'IC. Dari VJheelei saidwshe would like to take, the tack store out of the description, She said they will only caxry accessory tack for"bordersShe said they would like to have the feed store available to the' neighboxs' and H "club: oto buy feed ifthey need to, She submitted a petition signed'by het` neighbors tri' favor of project,, she said":tliere" is no- feed` stoe in the "Gridley area She said the traffic will hP ,> because ti g. ' g " going ry one entrance Will be at the be ronin of Smith Avenue, She said she owns 4 horses axid.is oin to bti .. more. She said different .clubs and organizations will wantfto use thus arena. She said there could be up to' SO people at an event. She also wanted to be able' to use t'tie' arena'at night after 5 p.in. for roping. She' said they laave owned two of the S underlying ,lots,,for 5 years and have.just recently purchased the other three: CcimmissionerImooney%Was concerned with dust. Ms: Wheeler said this will be, a sand arena and they will control the dust. Commissioner Nelson asked staff yvi:ere.do they break from retail fo comrilercial: He said this project does not sound lke'.a commercial operation. He said it sounds accessory to the proposed use. k r" Mr. Sanders 'said there is no problem with selling "what they grow: The probit is selling, f6el not grown � on-site t,o. the general public. � Leland; representing'tlie Dos Land Co , said that Mara Bayless, owner;, has no problem vyith this project: lie. said the nearest rieigh$.or and 'ownersof the prune orchard are`Ms: Bayless: He sant the Wheelers have been good{neighbors: 'He said theze'will be limited sales to products used for accessory to tlie' project.` BUTT.}; COUt`ITY,PLANIVING OOIvfNIISSION ii MINU'rE$ a JUN>r 25,1998 Page"O ;w ir rk ,M. Fe.,`" ' !F .fi,,t Y4ew,r (y �`t6f1SS N SS F.,�' Fi,,m S k^ �p.ha',°. rt.:w. � �SLSU .Y:! P •6''k+Y +'F°''u�`. hl '4A,{1''rQ.!'r'...l :`t,T}}f� ", :, "b. it }. kf Ykr,y'rt1eCw.;•Yl,i.{I(rAks5r: ei } , }941Ni, NrY'i (.. �4:' ,AA:" Fb{`'rE �n r'ns'. ! k,°}.A;tt, S.itriF F. -r.,...i"Wr, es.. .A ,fy•.. tP� tl�aud ,w, .r,.: "„y'r: Y i !. S ,' , �Q:° Mil - �" a�L "��LL�3,fd��csaisl�w►& 1pi11�U7Wl:pip ilc,S.Aliviroa,.ws,,.;urb46 s.a�.d .;:i 4 L'h .o-.�..ISic wl skb'y+•'�Lw°'�°' �uyw�L.�iwuulihiwi.:a.1i.,llwa....3 ,ub: WA 'yy SU'I'TEAN1YIlG COMMISSION 1dII1�U7CES `i JU77. NE 11,1998 1: IPILEDGEOF ALWjiANCI'J r ROLL CALL: PRESENT: Commissioners Cage, Leland, Mooney, and ChairmariLarnbert " { AFSENT Commissioner Nielson ' A%S�O JPRESEN ' Hacki anner ' ror �ey;Associatq,,, �om Panlo Dteplien irector` Development Services y Niclt E1101a, Chico Enterprise Record f Lynn Richardson, Secretary III. ACCLPTANCE' GF AGtN1DA , It was moved by Commissioner Cage, seconded by Commissioner Leland, and carried unanimously for �'" ' ro genda. accj"tance, of the Agenda— l., Approval'.of theminutzs For May 28 1998: Commissioner Cage made a coi�cp00on on. page 7, 4tl paragraph; first line change "on piece" to "one'piece" If was moved by :Commissioner Leland, 'seroncled by'Commissioner rage; .and uriaxiimously carried for F approval of the minutes as Corrected: ' V. CONStNT None {l BUSINlESS FROM TIIL FLOQR.UN IT�I�IS NO7l' ALREADY ON THE AGENDA VI: , No VII. PU1ILIG+IEARING5' The Dra# Eriironniental lrnpact Report (DEIR) 'for the M & T Ranch Mme Project (1V1TN 96-03) has been completed and is available for public review. fihe project Ys a request to develop a sand,and mining operation With associated processing facilities; crusluig and screenrig, processing gravel plant, ready mix' concrete plant, and asphaltic concrete plant, encompassing. approximately 235 +7 - Material to be removed to` a depth 0 70 k /='feet, conveyed to the adjacent piroce5sing plants, acres, !,gold or a"sed as new matenal,to. produce asphalt and/or concrete and concrete ready nix" The site Will be reclaimed to YOU, recharge ponds, wildlife habitat and other wetlands, extending approxiii ately 8100 feet in length and 140U'feet in width, Perrriit life dobe approximately 30 years; BLJTTE'COUN'I'1'PLANMNG COMMISSION MINUTES ,kwK I1,. DO$ Page 1s �Y. 1 L .i`r—f`i+y. 1"`V`�eroa•}. {�M N}ro iWr fdl+f'Y Jv iNWr AYi w4yyw.: eu,.S'._Sf1M1 '�#'C H"W 1, k♦ {{,, i h n, 7,"C M'i, wtlo'F M.J { a* 7 ..k. k<' V' Y 1+" f F N ` ?.. {`. rwn il � + �.*9d;. I ! .. .. LS 1 r4 } i� +n:M Y'N A'; iH..� �YM�A it �+.!.,�%">��1.iM.`'"L Non .iii y b.ii{�Y� ^tt p'i.Y. 'ice il'"�' ..lu"il.i ,Y, .p+` S1 hryN Ytiv �� � W4 � i .�,Y%Yi%ItJ}L.. 1tl1P+.51L"iN4bi'•�YM%»SYyw. 4T111d�..+✓_% +rW-n Na ..uFf,.a ..w+ +++••e+^+n� Cr — SlFlyfrY• 1 '.� i / I able to make.a, good.living from the property. He said this is prime farmlar►d, He said & T chooses not to irrigate their property. Ho said` the M & T ranch used to support livestock grazing. He said,a lack of proom farming cvuldbe from.poor farming practices, riot poor soils. He asked about enforcement,of t' the mitigation measures ifthis is appxoVed. He said they would want the operation shutdown incase of Tiny " violations. , p Yolanda Prentice, 9 366 .River Road, submitted a picture of tier children,at their bus stop. She said traffic is a mayorproblem: She said the _children will be impacted by "trucks ori Ri'�er Road. She was against this project She said she was afir Ad for the children in the arta 'because the trucks will not alveways, stop ,for the buses. She: said this, project will impact the Durham. Unified School District: Ste ,p Prentice, 9366 :[liver Road, presented overhead pictures. He said he manages ari orchard on. River S Ro d';and lives the e, 'He said on Sections 4 4 of the DEIR,,or water'duality, this sectiornis not valid, IXe said the information wastaken from, a very partial source, HE said there are many maccifiracies In the MM. He said.the,de '-ment is riddledwith ambiguous language such as, could, assume, might, etc. Section 4,41 says the •applicant, will monitor water tables for the first two months, He showed an over`liead picture showing flooding in December 97 and January° g. Section 4.43 states that overflows into. Little Chico" 6 Creek are rare eh disc eed with this statement. He, said Little Chico Creek floods even in less rainy years that'this one: He discussed grotuid water contamination regarding their domestic wells , He said he was very concerned with the pollution of the groundwater. He; was concerned with the accumulation of heavy metals i dnd stilt in the ground water. He said this needs to be adequately' addressed. He discussed possible flooding oft sewer treatment plant. He questioned the statement that this would' create new jobs when all they are ? doing is relocatiuig'from another site. to said once this type o ,plant is approve, they will not have rontrol ' of things like the itraff,, patterns. He was opposed to the project: Rosalie Cartwright, 3986 Ord Ferry` State; said 315 acres of farmland wouldbe lost with this projecti; Dust' will cause air pollution She said road dust will impair the orchards n the area. She said the number of trucks stated in the DEIR are not realistic% they will make as many 'trips, as flit as they 'caii, to make a profit.; She is concerned with traffic and the children. and bikers.:She said this project wih damn he greenbelt; reads, and s%afety of the area: o'Rogers 25 Chico Rivei; Road; said he has lived there since last August. He .said he has witnessed two _oger, `# } dogs killed by cars; one car accident and orie;bilce, rider runoff the road: He said this is. a 30 year project. He said he is concerned and.would like to see,'the prgl�lexns resolved instead of'mitigated. He said.cerxient and asphalt, plants are' a problem. He asked if the waste areas would affect groundwater: He said people drive faster "than the` speed limit and rt is dangerous. He was also concerned with the ,quality of life' 1 changing. R Dan 7uanarena said the; M & T property use to run sheep, He said it floods just about everyyear. He said an 8 ft berm is more like a levee: He said there are `foo many negatives with this project, He said there is. - a dangerous ,narrow bridge on Ord erry JolinNlendozasaidthey are farm pe.'oplpan d.opposed tothrs project. Ike said mining isnot anag. use and e ' llo ed ori a land. should not ba �?v, g JoelMigu I aid he utas against thepmject. He said.he has worked for this ranch and Have always been 'I a goodneighbor until this proposal. Hewas concerned with water going intq Little Chico Creek. He said -o', traffic is a serious issuei He said 1'ie drives a tractor ori River Road, and moves. with the bikers, He said ip ®,BUTrg COIJIVTY PLANNING COMMISSION a 1bIINUTES JUNE 1, 1998 Page'; -5■ . .... . ...... .. ,, :. ,.. .. m . ... _.. ,ro .'J..Yf p,MRYT3r:M11 w... .. .".. -,:... 92, Olt' , 0,04,� '''die comments were refereed to the consultaht: Staff eco n ac Thddbfisulta will do a'f1nat!d9pbf"k'k:tbfifi� s"do cunentj �R 4ppKP, ah:and 'the. w prod opf.' ng,,. b6tepu s et orpu 1c, I far ill, blf h : said jv,AftPaulo said itwas hard t di f.P prpjpqtw6u d'�9,rOscc rescheduled cpuWdb �1Aat e as ;Se p te'nibjen 'S - airman, e,suggpstedjhdi6inA&be s6f for the` &6t Meetingn id ffie ?xv65t,fin "i ".p, aatft —IGET, 'gin ill. NEA"M A eneral" o_m` ng:'0;r,. iname Update at, e Case -;aw, POW C., 'Planning Commission Con6eb, nupdate ptogat itbthe Commissioners',' H Paolo Banded 4phase patbindon I the General Plan ,out said f1ere,rev iLlbe,aineewlpUn oria'specia informatjondlf6rUM. 1610gaVeabrief SU11m4ry ., bfi- Bearing of.the ,'First ��ah''d'Second ,:Phas.'e'§'i 1, 6,4,pp public can etah& said therd will b th ut of t ,AIp- Chairman Lambert ti fherdis abhe dy�, Airport Use '6- 0 VoikshO�:Ofi Jun 25 195$ man Visalia. Tkan8p rtatjonwascat arranged f, they Woreiterestcd, ADi0U1t1vMElo1T 9 IAQ �— �- 0 Sj Commission; Thdr6 being her"b M0680i T 4fiffladjourned 05 P.m, ng', s Ch r AnNina 161aW b N T ;;�WEDOCS\lYIIIUTBS�Mi�T0611 ['C WBUTTS C MMISSIMCNAM TES agp LA.N ...... .....",Virmn; 44q t'- +}!(�i�dl+rai 7 p('NI i 1. - • i r a. . ti SAM r k 71 (OE NATURAL VV FAITH AND BEAUTY 4 �} LAND ^ Y f r � df ' tC i.ti5 x� Y 2E� PLANNING DIVIMON ' ��� DEPARTMENT qF DEVELOPMENT $RVICES k ?u° }G�,ti'y,�`"�.' 7COUNTYCEiVTERDRIVE OROVILIE,CALIFORNIA 85365-33.97 a t 'rEI,EPHONE: (530).538.7601. Fk( (530) 538.7785 , D` TTE COVNIY PLANNING �OM�9�IISS�ON , AGENDA dune 11',:1998 ;` ` - :T 9 00 a.m K PLACE: Board of Supervisors' Room - County Adn'inistrationCmter r 25 County Center Drive orovlle, CA 95965 X. PLED(;E OF ALLEGIANCE JI. ROLL CALL, - Cormnissioriers ;Cages Leland, Mooney, and, Chairman Lambert. Coinrmssoner � Nelson was absent, ACCEPTANCE. OF AGE1�1D►A Coiminsston riiembexs and staff may reciuest additions; `deletions, III: or,changes in the Agenda order,: _ IV. MINUTES ;-A rtovatof the, minutes f-i' May 28, 1998. , k v. CONSENT Consent items ale set for ;approval in one motion, These; items are considered non- No presentiat-- will be made,'howeVer, some questions ?ay lie asked. controversial: it if ` commissioner or member of the Wrshes ;.`►ll a consent item for will ask an ,public The Cha Y,, discussion.3rie£-questions may b'e asked on any iteral.; Nom k a �I. lEUSINES5' FROM THE FLOOR ` ON ITEMS NOT AL,RE t : E AGENDA (Presentations;wrllbe,llmited to five minutes. The PlanninS Commission is prohibited by Stale°La`w frc�n takiii,.aotion, on ally 3teirm presented if it is nat listed on the Agenda)'' .staff, comments.; The headn will• be o ened to, the pubhe for VIX: PUBLIC 1EARINGS' The Char vrill call for �, • P i _ proponents, opponents`,.connnents, and rebuttals,; The hear<ngvill be closed to the public and dniscussion •�confifled to the Corpm�asion. ;'rhe Coi"Ission will then make_a motion and vote'on the item, that initiated presentation's be limited to a'maximum of -5 minutes so that' all interested parties will tis requested Public Nave an opportunity to'address me Cocniia�ssiop,, following youx' presentation, please prnt yo"ur name and address on the spealt'ers sheetso thaul! record will be accurate. 77777777, BUTTE COUN'T'Y I' CANNING COMMISSION L�AGENDA"�JXM 11,1998rg , y Q1_ . ..t°1h ,f x .wire +. +e..: jq. li ;J r..,. ,db��:�. ,,.a^"., a3, �•'" ' `'''.Y•1, k° ag".,.q;r Mp �,�. ,t'^IJFy .,7 6, of ;IGfioa.p.4'4"�t 'tiA rf ly�w"4 el:wtr w �1 A k .t r 1 .� .n 1l K .- „v c,i c" W 4.. •.. "f �Yl'S t�`A^y,{.:, ,.�.�. Ys �I�A,�k �� ak�t�` IN�C� �t ?4 �`�.��' k`i�e�t ��be" � � ,. Xt � �. eel' �"�5 ,ryyz.>;; i� x a� r.� 5� �, .Y r: _• i:5 e,' � _ r 4 �.� 1'a' r y� "n.. ,.A^ „4t 9 ,lvJ�' R.}v. fie' Yi k'.x• 4` iA' �' - � �i��4r�'��:a'':'i�!X'�iY�it��`t�'��tl�ssk•:��'u�i,a,',.,s%�.'+r,r„vrir�Cu». �s,���,�r.�.. u,�„1�:«;,1.:?,<w�._:,..�:«,�.:,.,H,�.,.,. k� c(•. '".v i `.ate{ + r r 1 k � a q The study.area rs lobated generally, along Custer Lane, south of Oroville-more speor.�ically defined , as that land bounded .by, ssel Road on the north; Lincoln Blvd. on the east'arid Railroad Ave orl is located in,Supervisorial the west comprising an area of approxrmately 1,12' acres. 9! pxoject Y Distrrct 1,and within'the'Craville ,Enterprise Zone. Mr. Doody' gavea brief summary of the project 1 Ie• also gave the background history of t11e'area. t ire card staffrecomrrrerids,Item 1 and 2a on Ne,,q,, of the Agendaiteport: The hearrn vyas opened to the public. ` on er said ,sloe is co-owner of the one prece of property that fronts' oii both Custer Lane Shat Kipp . arid' Lincoln f11vd, She way; coricerried about fhe zoning on. Lrncaln Blvd, going back to Lincoln as ago, on a very busy, street, that should agriculture. She sand it would heave tier S acres on be coriurrercial of rrrdustrral. She currently has a business on her property and wants the property left 1V1-1 zoning. Slre paid.,Custer uLane 'is residential and Lincoln Blvd, is commercial, or 'Mr, lo he told her there would be, no ptoblem with r industrial, She said she talked toPan- acid zoning the -back of her property AR-1'.arid leaving the front half on Lincoln Bled. as lVI�1.. s lu1r. Doody said the first two columns of AP numbers ori Page 12 is,the property, that is Interim AR 1. Zoning, third, row of parce . nurrrbers is the property fronting along Lincoln Blvd. Staff is asking that these be included in the AR -1 zoning change: Tess Brasier said his roe was and commercial zoning when it was purchased, later zoned p.hrty, ; p .AR to.Industral, He asked that lus property be put back to AR 1.except for the first 30,f� ft fronting ons Lincoln Bled to. remain IVi 1. He' sasu this rezone would change ,the minimum lot size allowed, bTe said the front ofhis property has been for sale as indu8irlif property, He said he had with losing tl=�e industrial zoning along Lincoln V. a problem - -rtel Vrgrria. Callahan, Custer Lane,•'said the rezone will riot cause problerrs• for existing businesses, .' Sle said Custer Lane a residentiaL;ar ea.. She said the Enterprise Zonae is west of Custer Lane. MT She"asked that t1�e rezone,' be appro•Ved to protect the homes. Mir Sanders posted a rnap showing;the M-1 zoning and the existing residential uses inthe area. ! Ruth Liglitle said slie owns, one parcel on,-uster lane arld one parcel on Lincoln Blvd., and both ' properties have a home on thein, She said slie wants the, AR -1 zoning. a tevensen saidl she has 3 acres on Custer Lane. She Bard they.were zoned AR 1 and. she Lenon` S _ Wants to ;go back to that zoning. She said she was rezoned Tndustrral without being notified, lVIay Elms, Custer Lane, requested the,AR-1 zoning, r ' fuses viii LiricolnBlvd. are residential, He said he Dan Brooks, Custer Lane; Said the majority o ' fhe A17r1 zonn back. He said the tits dump has. caused a lot of hardship iri this area.• C. wanted , g� , n Lee; prdpei y fronts ori,Lincoln Blvd, , said he has:a small business that has been there for commercial zoning for pxoperty along; Lincoln Blvd. kTe said he was :R 1!2 years. He wants'' cencefit ' d with future ex ,ansron o. rs usrnes s. p BU COUN`Ll' PLANNING C01yIIVIISSTON t 1VIINCJTES 2$; 1998 1'a�e 7 y •� ♦ rF f �c, 'i M '.'. '.%. I l'' �.. 4 ,r ,. _... w '! ;,;:;V '. :.,...�4 Y i. �; ,. El ;. L. ,; ;. ��, ,. ,� �� a �, .: �,��,. t: �R�. � � '�"'"�, r., _ ..�,. �,�, t ,.t� a..t y',f,.. , .,r.r ,.r .....a: v� lv,=r�. \f •. G,r r-,-�" ,,, ...,.F :'n,; .;- r �: ' a r.^ .. ,.f'. ail <5..r B, ,y, p. \. ,.L •q�N. .(. r. ^6 SM:c.,.. Iwt,' v,..i I.a? •. 7L t {C i ,,1��.. d. >L w .4 }., d.i^. !l. s f, BL+ :q :); ,..,.. S�.J4111 i \. �, .� Y 1. '.0 �, i ,�+£..�:... , .. 'Y\,. 15... a .7r 4a., ti'ci r..'F:Sn �irl.t .'� 1 r . tl., E9'. ,. lY .A.. N� l 4 )+�� ir4 J } ♦ :.v.•�!1xL. YY !! " i t { , �. ty, {L , {. {{ .. 1 , ,1,R .'^ 4 .. v � j r. Sr . 55• a .,. � . r.: $.. ;•• .� si ..,.r } w., �,1 :.. , . . )p,..' Yea,. , ,, I .. r yy�, ,.•.: �}y. j .�, ., .� 1 3 .,..s ',r . ,,, a, 1,..j, ,1.,i �. ,, t. ��..5..... �,7.. ,_ ¢) .. �;.:, r.,,..i.-r .,.:w,r ,J. ...� ,r. rv.,r,,., ...,.(.r .{, .,t t,'•,, �, - ::i i it i'{. l r..r ti, : a .. G . , Ir.(� . 1 �'A., Y. T4. t uk r.�vr ... Ao: i -i.. ., 1.� �, yw.. , ..{. �i.. �.}. r H `i S - 't {r� �Bx 11 ...i ' Lx. tf ..) 1 xjf / i. M�. M1. y, iki � .. ., t,'+{ •.i , L' L.l :. y.r,. ... 1 S� -1 - ...1.... 1;6 ., 4;! rI`S L ..I. /,...pil -�. 1. r: ! .. ..ay, B, i54' i n1 44 �,,, r{�s b. ..3 fi r.'/Y'' tl. wY ,5, ,': ,r, ., }, ,.3a'. y.,.�a^IA q4..n rti. y i" 1., ,.ie ,,B T'i. .'i xi S i' rt t >: 4} fi \d° r:'+. :q.° ,.t ' •n:�- k,a,.y4 , r i a. a ,- I-" Y d .I„ ,, tb 1, t, .,r ,r ., ,, 1. a, t ' ; F, q Y. B•e,,, �y c t; . L. - F, i °.. V, 4,^a , , e. t . ,S Nl RrAAB 7.A +.H 7 r . ,,'�`� d q..%'i.. i � A ' f .t; t r k� i. !,"'� .: `' 4 . '• ws' dalMdw ,t,y ( ,r p,. '.r+[ i a ,. i x�+e5ti �,. aJi ,o. ..+. 4 .,,.r !' ,,,6. ..ry \ 1si t.� -t. g: t "k,. ..+„�, N+.S,qe i .. t.., .. t :. 1„ Kl ✓p,iv r. lr ,�t . .afda"ikiUii iHrh la. !,. ? S "r} Ai ?'. },,.,'7,,-, Wi�G > �4 p+E„��: i 4„ ! . l ... i B .?F''y: ! It7�r•:yl Yl. .. r�i } f " h � �r,.: 7...i, 'r*r a' /}h i •#..vl i `� i } t, t,� n L A,.r �. d. f ..,. .. .. ,. ..,. p.4,5E..t .YY ..x: 1. ..,{ _ I x,.q, �V ' t.. t..Cit1q -`,'t, ,,., .. ix r c,, r•S .'! ..,. ,'4 , r�. .�.7r .- r r, ..]i.^ '.i ra %.}�i ,t. { 3,.t �.. Yg r)3,•..S .'V.: •YB t \S. 4r. err +'r&'�.t, i L., ., 'i, `?a[..w ',.:z rKi rv.w !.:,n a '">,, ..�Ftth!'`...4.ri,w'+ttlr�' ..: , #.. tx � 4 .M �1.1,!i' A> ,o5,� • C4�,'L�" ',,;. B+1 t'..� ,,, '. 1.46,j } i tr s >.,� \ .. l 1J .., r, , �� .�. ,., h'Y. ..."y� ){ 0. .t Y � ..i..4•-•,.1r.``JI "�1:.«« ., .:.. ..,7,' - ,: .'' ,+�Y `v gft'4At,i;'e�'�1.,•4•i .5t ., 4.,di,�9t.\p1t +�:F'. �,q ,�S,. Yit. � Ir �'11•:•, t� xr��(te}s4a�: '�4,, ..- uJ'+�t"\r 1T �1PAfdirr57! I.ir+.#+1iJ. N? Lar E� BjSIII + itakktfkal"�aB�\I�:Iia:ids, 5A4� ,r« kE,',Aw.�.+t4.avrwaw�iw,.�E,i� '' l 'ki11i lw; r• .Y]., ,.'t'. .,f i w�. �'. .af ij..t��Y {. ?�+' e �, raj i ='�ku ,i #�> 7 ,G a (� ,"�i r 1. r A4 2t�160�I;Y��y r`r}.�''7 E u1 ,I> J 1 11 I A , �' f ' ': '. 41 y�( . M t! C Y r �� t}B a'41 4B Y Ill I - +: �� t �. �r 1 yvitlun the Or�o�ille` . t �, �:1 ki4�Cr The x 'ect is located uY Supervisopal Distrtct and € 3B - acres p - J IDE IN 11, Enterprise Zone, �DD�' C�; ��" ` �' , ,'I �,: ^' {� Yr e' cr fs 6, b ' Ott l e' hy� tyle planning f `Br , ' ',BY1 111e1E 5 'hts s ctr erlda 11 .eneral " ' , Interest,', g i'. 11 , �l� mt�»t11 v1II `i'UNE]�AL Servl _es, on Items of G, 6p artd .,611 eC1' je Of ,SGV p, , .. l 1' '" LLL„I .. ►TSSlI?t?'; "2isston, I staff hus bee►7 llrectecl to da reseaeVh ahea i u did 4r'itel rsfot'W' , i�g,'..'buti . C' 'dot always he addressed at ?7'1. `fr' mu tlae Ggnllnlsslon, r 1�ems A, B,.. Y �1" i list d s part.©f t ie. u990? a• �" I ," ,�iLl ' always'"die A Geri ral plan/Zon ng QrclinanCe 1U�date r . '1 „ I. 1. 11: 11 .1 I 6. .11 �,., "' r ;: X.e r slati�!e' Case I.aw date _, 611 .. Cw Planning .0 i issio"- Concerts n 1 , .- -1. .:`. I.' Ap�UXJRNMEI�iT 3.�,., • ,C�17JPDOCS�5AG1✓T�fOAMOCA01 I - .1$ `I .i ago i , r� �� r 3tr ,., , 1 -., , 1 - -L. .y, _ , , -,. '. ., .'-, Y f3 l�� 74 l ��„ 4' . it '-� .() _ r I 11 X31 } r 'E .. 'I _, I ' 1 ' 1 I•'. (I. i. �k 0. I[ .. �.I , � .1 . � I � I , , � � , � : , � , � I � � , I L . , I I � , � � � , , �, � � , , � � .. I . i 1n A .. , ..' L :r. :.1. . r ^ N 4 ,- ; r ,I _ .-. , '' '... IJ , , _ c .. __ •, �, I, - ., ,� If '.;1, Y ?0ENDA+`'MAY�8, Ih98."^ cdt N,T PLANNING COMMISSION y rr I31.U'I PE ,, 4t`t - .. Y. \ 6 L F 1, d1 r t ( 1 ^Y r. ' n6 i r w. r7 ii Ixvr 1, r n X 1.' h ,Y. 11 to �' +j '""'d v w* I r Ir.re 5. R i r'! k � . x 11 S % e s .+ rw lr, t B : u +J A '. 1wc �„ a e rr'^r art � : i ,,yw.-,,.,+ ': - tJ~ i. x ,.. ...., ,.. :, «, ., ,. ..:,� r. .n... ., .... ,, x. ,.sa•1:. ,..... •...,, o. «,a4 c :, ,� ,,x*,,,in.7hq} 7.,., x ,,,,,.. r ,1,.: Sn.,,-,G yf_,y _x 8.4, � as«,. �, r .:,, sx:}...,_. F, a �:r�' ..aa.?"...:raY!?.M .,.+t..v 7`M"q.. i !°��y... h1; .t:ru,.wLtXr }V,•`;�t s 3 v �.4 % �.[, ,� r �, r,i,yi ju.., , s <,„ :, .i Ir t�i4 a t"d. 1•t' { ,, ar;tt e'j", , r 1 x ,,j, R xr.. ,. x al. . .*r.x� src ,i r7k firms. x1A l4a B�,j .Y,.p w� k M4J8 C.f 1.- Y b. '"1wi `<` 4�1 �Mc;u. E.t,l..v .�, R� FW"' i J' 1 M , X.x ,' A . ,..r'v_ w. a k '-Y-j . t 9 Y aSr~ '�. h7°frtiY�'t� 'inr y`w a4 ,m d,ua4,�J, "uiu�! 1. a., •Je .p[. k,�iy�r'i",t 1 .W,{, �f :?� r.:4' S-,�r "t I_ .. ,.n e. .. �1: :�.� t �•'II A '1�1 s'F. ,i� �i�i ��: {,^ ;� r '' 3 ia,l. T/. 4i. +:'�,w 'lir, '`i61 '�+jY, � ti ."! 5:��% •A. i .i;� l h' �,I i i, '�! L' ,i ';i.. ';1, Y( ;Y -;S yc i r Fr. ;r. �,' �� ;�. i �. I f. ' %. '•,(! r•w1i.f -, i11 .\ ti .1 k � t't .,r t4 ., � ,,. }... •. �> (+. .,n t t ..., ,�(.+. .#{e i �.t1� �, i 7 r z, s;is + a '' f t n��r ! V pj' .qj;.. .14 .: �r..l 2d `r._e i t u i., hr... ,s-' y t r r 4.^ a;ad l § i+, ...s { s _ r r .� •, a� r� s .:,x { 14a:�ir it +t7 fir :�. � t rf Y��'. i a S J L pl 1 > ,.SICa.{I,^' !, y,yr wrd,i+.S{�:l�i. 1 ,f•: it yt ';l xC ! 7c 1 7 a + , U a a1 f 5G Y,' t �I i {h aiV k"a,U �r> ras'Wr #6y � aS.V �. Irf 7•. .a N\ i s:,'Cpt _ 4 ra� ;. i# , r �� r} .' j it �: ,,tl .,i%) C,� II '* i �' :'�t�rr 't'r,�i7,1 xl ny '.'1 . � Yr { L � r,,.l4.n.-.t;�..;H+•w.ru%r+a�4�+' "1'""r_�L�S.rbyWdt7:fi {{(J +r' s � ri �V 4 ° Y'r a i+.i.wu+:+.rT :•. r„dFl+., « 4t,r.. w:, r s 9 / 1 �,Irf'�.�iSib��'�4i�����131}3aL•71gi�is�sku3::atn�-��+ `,,.,,y5.��.; ...ii,_+.—+� ki4r .» ..lr1.r ,. i:.:.w»Fw — }a , BE , ....4. ..r r, �.I A T Iii R A L WND AUTY.5 A L tH _A 4 4 4� Herbert W Brewton - (Item determined to f1be, categorically exq mpt from environmental; `second AR 1VIH�2,5: J Jt resew) Use Permit to allow a dwelling unit on properly zoned (Agricultural Residential - Mobile Home - 2..5 acrrr .parcels) located' on LonO Tree 'R' d ' approximatety�330` feet north of Falermo Road,'identified as AP#025.2.40-021, Palernno: r (LTP9$48) (SH) A video oi`the site was' shown Mr' Sanders gavea, brief summary of'the project, He said" that there was adequate room` on-site to accommodate the facilities a's;recommended. y a entioned that she had Co, miriissoner Cage asked at what. time the video was taken. She m_ visited the site on Apri19. 1'998; and had noticed that there was snore than orfe'.mobile on the Site. a The hearing was opened to the public: Chairman Lambert noted for the record` that neither the applicant nor a representative was - .: 1: ' present. 4 The hearing was closed to the public. Ireland said he was inclinedto vote £or'this project since this is not a double t ,Co-:missioner density situation and that the lot size is more than doubletheitummum arcel size. nr It was, moved by .Coirimissioner Mooney, .seconded by Coinnussioner Leland, and . ' 40-021 unanimously carried to approve the JsePermit for. Herbert W. Brewton subject to the findings and conditions in Exhibit "A' ; as follows, Section 1 tnvirontnental Findings.° A: Find that the project is exempt from 'eilvironinental. review as allowed under Section 15303 ofthe provisions of CEQA.as a Categorical Exeinption Mass 3 (a) exemption; and y l Section 2: Zoning Ordinance Findings. < A 'she proposed 'use ofthe property, pursuant to Butter county Code`Section 24 45:10, wi11 not 'impair the integrity, and character of the AI�iV1H 2,5 and the use,will'nat be unreasonably incompatible `, with;,; or injurious to, surrounding properties, or detrimental to the fieaith or general welfare of the perspm residing or working in the neighborhood; or .t'o the general :health, safety :and welfare of the residents of the U because Y:' ' , 1'=1 The proposed use is rural ,,rest en. i, in character, consistent with surrounding y parcels in'the axea, ; The propane density; 1 dwelling unit per .4acres, is consistent with both'the $utte County General P1an,density and. �RMH-2.5 d zoning'densi:y, and r p Buite Coup y Planning CommissinnlN utes ,April 9,19.` Page 2 0 I� yM f k ^ N.' M l *nrctutes, dumping,, 1x11" material, and/or excavation, „except for 4&,699 �c requirements such as a bred e, sliall;not be allowed within 10`0 feet; of the of bank of Rerry.. Creek. Limited vegetation. removal necessary for flood control'aucUor' to reduce fire hazard is permissible, liowever, all ��egetation ri mo.4l'shall be approved by the Califo Departmer►t of Fish and acne prior to'rernb�tai. ) l?'rior to ,any .clearing, grading in or constntction in a str`eri` bed, including ' intermittent streams;: obtain a California Etsl and i7rame 1604 Stieambed .Alteration permit as per Department of Fish & 'Game requirements, (MM} 1 - - S: The access road from Zink Road to ttie main »atkng lot at the lodge, and the main "Par"king _l 't at the lodge, shall be coveted with at least two,( )inches of l Class 2 ;aggregate material. and maintained thereafter (NSM) 6. All new fencing on tte project site ;shall ie limited to,a,mammutti of 5 wire strands.,:' . TIie lowest. tranc?." shall , be at least 16'` .above the ground and the r upper stzand shall be.no lti iter than;4," shave the grafi rtd. t 7.. f Amplified music shall be Itrriited to Friday and Saturdays only,'with no music occurring past 10 p.in: i 8 A x essunzed water a stem' t'nat meets all Fire De p y partment regwrements,, shad a nstalled`.vnoa to completion of'tlie lodge (i1iIlV) ; d Bi tte' Cbfnry'Pl*kg'Commission Ivhciufes-:Aprit 3;,'1998 d n9�C1 !lfk � rdMknllrh le3> NC��IRi'�xp�3q�N'�ia t'�ix�.:r�rf4Nr.ia � �4�'{'�'4:Si�".(M`i",%9x.'iC�.Nfi TSw;ifi+llIhK�''.✓�'Mi`:6%'C'"�x�}tfe^Irt4..+nui..,a...........�__ .. . . _ .k ' shall be established •at the camp Materials: to be „ c Ari on site recychngsystem rebycled shall include but not limited to aluminum cans;. glass, plastics, newspaper; cardboard; and steel cans: The recyclable materials shall be to" A_ recycling center 14 All outside: lightsi on'.the pioject site shall be .fully shielded ,and directed straight ,downwards: Mercury vapor hghting fiMures'shall .nat be installed. .� , Lighting'of the:playing fields'shall not be permitted. ofany azchaeolo cal surveys conducted'on the. 11. Applicant shall provide a copy z 7 , Applicant shall follow tor` property ,to the •Planning IDivision for review. r. ecommefldatians of'the .Platuung Division for protection of historic . f , ` �resource4 and during construction, should any' archaeolog►cal, . archaeological ,. artifacts be,discaverel,' the Planning Aivision shall be notified immediately; ; and all v✓ork shall cease until a qualified archaeologist has: examined the a the site, subrinitted his or,her findings to the Planning Division,, tifacts.and and recommended clearance to continue. Recommencement of construction shall be';upan the approval of the.Planning bivison,• "(1V1Iv1i 12: " Prior,to, issuance'of building pernuts meet therequii`ements of the California r Regional Water Quality Control Board, including, but not limited to; water clulality certification, Construction Activity Starmater Permit, solid "waste disposal'plan, and wastewater treatment and disposal pians. 13, Existing buildings which shall. be put to a new use shall be made to comply vyith current Building and Zoniing regulations for the intended new use' 14. During the months ofNovember through'Marcll; the number of people using the camp Facility p?�rgathering shad not exceed:50. 'Prior to the =first camping session, :contact Enloe' Fhghtcare to riotify,'tham. of . the camp's looatic�r aria to assist in setting up an appropriate emergency helicopter lanluxg' area on the project "site , Applicant must also.,comply. with all other applicable State And!.local °statutes, 16; ordinances and regulations': Public Warks 17 Prior to the issuance of buildin r ennits obtaita encroachment peimit £or all l existing driveway approaches and construct them to County standards, z, as specified in Caurtji Improvemer`;t Standards: 18 Prior to the issuance'of building permits deed to Butte County, in fee ^simple; , 3U feet of right-of'way from the centerline of Zink Road ,The right of. --way k O$itit� County Planning "Commission IviuiutPs -April' 9; 1998 q Page 14" Q' r, "iiia -41 Of the Butte A. Avart por$040�to: Section 19 'b granted, maybe gran, e County CO on air ,existing lot'or a-rce1,When special p' soil circumstances ',are licabk, 16-the,ptopOrtyinvolving #he: chargoteristics, h-I:0%surrounding property chatAderis ics jopograpY rdm eftt ariancesmay iranieaonly to theusable 'arearequirements 1chdrol98ntheAppen bC. jabl& lCuftlativeeffects shall 6e considdfddprior to is, 5"0'? , o any variance.ance'. In W . "basin., evens alla variance be Spihied that i� ouldprovide less usable area CodCode;Chapter =, than ttie requirements of Butte County An'A.polidatibnr�rzI:shall, le b6 made `in!writing ,6n:a form prescribed )y&,heaIth d6parthptt,', Upon tion, e anager, the Heal ift Officer tqge- .with the M 6f't 6. Paradise Aftei h', , 7 - I � f the water Committee Irrigation -oni District,'And the. Chairman o e:, of the Upper Itid'ge Coordinating Council, shall, rriabb an investigation to.; -A variance h ou S-1 I p,granted., At the conclusion ldb d6tertnifi.6 whether i he investigation, thej�ftc 'tor of Environmental Health shall prepare. a w-n order granting or d6nyi hj the variance, and shall include in such written ordersp�dificlfindinggs of fact and reasons, far its granting C., If the Environmental Health Division of the Health; Department denies 4pp cgtlofifbrlanance�ihe applicant may1le an, app With the Ithe jalityr Control Boar,&vinwiiin i en ( ays after State Region ?Vater Quality al W P by the State : gdgional Water Quality ontroi' �C Thdh Board shalt be fitial, 'Erosion ' Contrbl'iMeasu Measures Shall be surfaced existing 1,x t , I All driveways ,,for new, homesi sites new exist o s, least' 2inches ofC do e;,'se`unless required quire to be :th deve.opeto higher standard. 2: All created an division shall be surfaced 'if ,with, 4, crea e re .roads 2aggregate b to a nummum widthof 20 0 , minimum mu..-m Bet urlossrequired be` to ,a d byrather code , i Ma- aintaind Countyread, o dnonts. TfilsstandA,r'd shall'ap y. re' juirp oxistipg,rom ora higher standard, through the parcel being divided: iremen s-as, be d Soa,s:Andriveways sha,If, meet,6- 6 requirementsp' , ' LIi"fil by' PublicResources, Code 4190and 4291 idButteCounty ire, e Aegu or as prescribed by the Butte Ggonty Department 110, Work C omin�sion Minutes 2[ y 3iaS19hll7t,i0.sJ4ktiYaw,4ihh�a?Xc(ocsva;a,c«wuzwtiucw-ww.u.+., ,,.,,, ....4. ,•.---- _ --- f , r, r p: ,C3 . 4. Erosion and sediment control;plans, including provisions for wet weather coridttions skull be ' subriutted with, ,all building permits, discretionary development projects, anti grading plans, excluding;structues that fall under the provisions of 5;ection 26 3 1 of Elie Butts County Code.; The er`osion`and f sediment control plans shall include both toporary'(frst year and;permanent r' L erosion control protection measures ti�st prevent. sedimenx and,other pollutant !r discharges from'xeaciing:�wate�slied drainages and streams. The, erosionand ' control plans shall comply with the'recommendations o£a qualified .sediment pyo%ss�onal involved m the prparatidn of erosion control -playas..,' Said plans r, shall_ be reviewed and pproved'Uy the Department' of XV61opment services: f rr ' 5. Thi, erosion and`'sediment adontrol plan shall include. the time of year for construction activities, No soil disturbance shall occur after November 15 or , befoxe",Apel It unless the Dir'edtor of Develapmpnt Services, or his or her r authorized agentdetermines project soil conditions to be adequate to ,r accnmmodate;development activities. ;,,All such areas where land clearing has , been completed between April 1 :arid Novenxber '15 gilall be. revegetated, + hydro seeded,'hi ch protected;or otherwise stabilized no later than December Should grading be permitted during, the rainy season, 'the smallest U£ erodible 1'and; shall be eicposed at any one time and ttie time „ practiGrile area of exposure shallb'e minimized. Temporary` erosion control. measures shall be, in place ona daily basis. , ' 6� No structures shall,be placed;'within'204 feet of the higb;water mark of the Paradise or iViagalia �.eservoirs or within 50 feet of the top of the bank of any AiIi nt,Awim xin +E�a,miict rA- ot7t edition o f r. pri191 1998 TIME :00" � VLACE: Boatd of Supetviaors' Room ' G County., Administration. Center Z Caunty C6- eOrovihe' 0 t6vihe'CA 95965 I: PLEDGE OF ALLIK AANCE " t t"stoners e son 'Cage Leland Moone and Chairman Lambert. II. ROLL'CALL Com n s N 1, � . y, .. ' III. 'ACCEPTANCE" OF AGENI)A'Comtrtissioi members and staff may request additions, deletions; +` or, granges m the ;Agenda order;'; �- Y. 1VIINUTES Approval of lheftifiiutes for March 2G; 1998, _ > 6�. CON 4N Consent items are ,set for4:�ppioval in one motion. These texri.s ate considered non- controversial. No ;presentations; will be made, however; soiree questionsinay be asked, The CI "r will ask ifany cominissiond or member -f the ptililic wishes to pull a consent itemi r discussion. ` Drief questions may be asked on any iteni VI. 3T15Y1VESS FR®M T1L0bwON ITEMS NOTAL DY ON THE AGENDA (Presentations will be limited to five minutes,' the 1'aannh�g!CummiSsion is rohibited.hy State Law from ta_mg.act on ori any It preseilted if it ,is not listed oil t_he Agenda) VII. PYTI3LIC Ii[EARYNGS The Chair will call far staff corninents; The'he_aring will be, opened to the public lbr ro otients o p' , conune,nts, and, rebuttals; The he p c and disen�sion confined to the p p , p onenYs` aru�g Will be closed to tiie ubli l Cotmttission._The CommissiotriViil then make a motion, and -vote oiI the item.'- It is iegUested that public initiated presdntations be iiniited to a inaxitrutn of 5 mmgtes so that ail tate"rested parties wih Kaye an opportunity WAddress the Cofnmiss►on > Following your presentation; please print your mine and ad8ress' on the i ry speakers sheet;so tliatthe record Will he accq'rate. The reCOmmendation of County Staff is indicated below, 1t is only a recommendation and' has notyet been cofisidereV Uy . the Planning Commission: Copies of the, Staff;.iteport are availa. a at Elie 1�Iani Ing Division Office: I3UTTC'GOIJNTY PLANNING Gib MMISS.(bN : ` AGENbA , AhiZIL �1, 1998 w, y,;mteau.w..ww.wvwcaeua.ic+++aA+ w rufpucNNwvml.Tuv,cCw a..0+v. t{{ ., , 1 71F., 1 lIi iJA 0 j LL 1 "r :1 y la " I r !A Approved 5 0 � I•s z. , 9 00 d.fl - ' Rerbert W Brewton = (Item dettgVIAmed tol be categor pally exempt from , 1 envir°onmental review) a Permit to allow a second dwelling unit on property zoned., AR-MH 2.5 (Agricultural Re'sidentzal - Il4obile Home - 2.5 acre parcels) locateci on r Lone Tzee .Road approY ixiately;1330 feet notch. of :Palerriio Road, id64 fied as AP " :025-240-02z, Palermo. (UI'98=18,) (Sq)= Approved S s I 9.00 a:m = Nathan St.. - �otm detezzri rigid to be tate rzcally from environmental (I em 1 review) Use P rilizt, f6le a ``V� eleome to' Cairo" ,sign an pzapetty `zoned A-40 r (Agricultural X40 acre parcel located .on the west; side of Highway 9, approximately 1.;60 feetsouth of Ariifa Road; identified as AP 047 -2G0 -X 01, Chico. , (SB) (UP,98-22) (VIDEO) f ' C� Approved° 5-Q I 9:00 a m The Okizu��r''ouzidation -` proposed iVegative Declaration with zn tzgatign measures regadzng envhoimental izn1;`acts and [Yso Permit to create Camp Okizu, a public/quay, publie use to; allow s non-profit organizatzozi to operate with coznpoz ents fcirr elinin ;food re ,;, staff office, +staff refrc�i�t livzn uarter. ` ui kitchen staff `i g� p. p > g q a c �. storage space; parking spade, for• 25U people pCi Week/300 people during family camp on property paned "Ut' (Unclassif-�ed)1'ocated'at 105' Zink Road, identified as AP' 062-240-007,;062-1'1`0-003, aiid 062 250-Q22,.026, Berry Creep. (SB) (UP9,8-21) OEO D, Appro+ted - 4=0 (Cozni�iissioiter Nelson was *b 611 for the vote) <, Butte.County 6azd of Su erp V150Ts (Item determined to be a "General` Rule FxO ptiori from environmental review) ,. onind Codd' Amendnient, to add the provisions, of the Policies, Procedures, and Standards' for the Firhayen Creeh, Paradisc-, saw, Axid Magalia Resezvoir Wate sheds (Resolution 87-251.) to Chapter 24' ol'the `Butfe ,County Code:;; VIII(:'` `G NERAL'B�tiSINLSS This seetion o f the agenda is to be utilized by the`Plannihk, Gorrrnzrssian arid I3i�'c cto�• of T�evelapnaeiit;Sei vices ori it.,ena of interest, general discussion, or'itrris for which staff has ltceii directed to do research find brirtgUdck tc� the; C'orrinission. Iteriis A, �; not Ge addressed at ever y hearing, Unit }vill alu>ays be listed as part of the.agenda. _ A . Geneial Plan/Zoning.Ordiziance Update ;I ` B Legislative Case LAW Ulidate Ca Plam iilg Commission Cdnceriis r 1 IrX. VR MET T r r T3lJ TTE COUN'�Y PL;AlVNING COMIVTIss . 'AGED k , AI'RtL 9, 1298 ' T 4} - iP f !r M �1 t i '"V lii 4ae •J i14 R •�,hJ �', M 1 .i y f p M,Ilii. .1 1, S�'F °Kr 1 ��. IF"i ,xd � I �} +,e, t Y I k+'f dna Re,'t•IH h' yJ # .( R f T , �* 1 1' F• i �". l i, R Ff 1" .` 0 k 1 I _' 4M �'i9}F I Ak 31L ,A a' q•^ .M i t' v 9 +�+ � ,Yi'r Yi.(M l �f y,i � 4 :�� i _, ... .., {,; ., '1.4 "ry .i, _ ^i1r ' A` ''�i .., i ,", r. �la. . Fw. c+, rb !' w .+.• . T }.i;' .? BUTTE COONT ' PLA1o1NINCG CG1Vd1VIISSION MINiJTES=.1ViAI2C)EI :26,1998 The meeting wase called to Wer at 9,:0.0 a,m; in the Board: of Supervisors' Room, 2.5 County Center Drive Ori7vxlle µ{ `I.'LEDGIE GE'ALLLGTANCE IL,, RO1LL CALL: Piresent:. "'Comm issioiiers�kNage, Nelson, Leland, and' IMCooney '' and Chairman' Lambert ,Also Present:' Craig Sanders, Principal Partner .p Lynri Richardson;; Secretary' Nick Ellenaa.Chico Enterprise Record, : a Shane.,. Shane, Paradise Planning Cornm. iII ACCEP"I'ANC]C OP -AGENDA Co'miriission ineiribeis;and staft' may request additions, deletions; of changes ,in the Agenda :order. It WAS, by Con;in'issioiier'�Cage secondedby,: ommissioner 1Vlooi ey, and unanimously carried to accept the agenda ass.. W.1lINiJTS - Approval oftlie minutes for March 12, 1998. The Comnnission had tl* following corrections and additions: Pat*.^, 3, Line 41 & 42 change to read "Come iissioner Mooney said -he would like. to see,an endangered species report which tells individual 1 people where they could live;", Page.ti, i,ine 1 S, change " He" to "�17e" Page 8, U e;10, ohahge "it sownt' to `zits own"; Line 45, change `,aecomm,PdatP" to ``accolnim: ated"; Page 9; Line 5, change "that" to, `chat", Line l 5, befoxe "Peutz" add "Dili Bain": lime 37; add, "She said `to let it be understood that she did not vote for the ro'ect onl fol the and use cafe or .""� p. J y Y.. . it was moved byComiiissioner Leland, seconded by CoitamissiUner Cage, and unanimously carriers to approve the minutes:gas corrected, V.CONSEhiT Cans6nt items'are set'fo"r approval intone tnotioti. These items are,considered non-controversta ± No presentation7�'v ll be,tnade, liowever; some guesti6ns may be asked. The Ghair;wiil 'ask if airy conimissocier cr,membet`of the uUblic wishes to pull a consent �tcm for discussion, Brief guestios maybe asked on aiiy iteib, VI.,$ITSINESS FROU11THE FLUOR ONITE S NOT ALREADY UN T�EEDA (Presentations will to five'minutes, The Planning Commission is prohibitedby State Law from toAn action on any item presented if itis;not listed on the Agetsda) ' N 0118 r I , Butte County; Planging Commission "Minutes March 2G; 1.998 Cage ,l q F y' thereafter by submittal of declaration in a'fornr speGifi d by the Director of Development 4 ` Services o; 6. ,'; N.a permits fnr`any additional dwelling 101;be approved unless the Second Unit'is first reirtoved, or'a`Use Perm tis approved by the Planning Compnissioa. 7.... Construction, instahation or development of sti,uctures or facilities on the parcels/lots sh111 . comply With the latest Gal�fornaire Safe Regulations,'(Public Resources Code 4290),' and all, other applicable Stafe and County codes, ordinances and reig latioiis 'in effect at ' the trine of aplica"tion for irrip•ovement permits. I 8. Building; dentification and/or addresses shall be installed in conformance wifh Public Resources Code 4290 aid,shall ue posted at the begin ning'ofbuilding construction and { ixiaintained continuously,thereafte�, ; 'liewo , a ressurized' water system, or water stora e tank-� payrrrent of $200:00 per i created pa�cei into `Battalion S water tend fiend, �s reduired prior to tice issuance o a boldin ermit:. gP , 11fii, t' sha11 comply` with � 11 other applicable"' federal, state and +local statutes,; IO. App � Or -di and regulations. i i r , Tames files , ,= (item determined to` be categorically exempt from eiiViron nentaffeviQW) Use ermit foi a single family dwelling unit on property zoned M-1° (Liglit Industrial),1'oeated approximately 1,972 ft. west of Lincoln Blvd:, at 5973 Lincoln Blvd:, identified as AP 036 270-0 4, Qrovi lle. (SB) .(LrP98;17) (UIDLb) , vide o of the site was shovvt Mr. Betts gave a brief suniifiary of the project. He said staff, is recommending d9pial: Commissioner Ivooney; ,said the report states that residents iii. the area could cotnplaixi; abotit industrial rises and the industrial ►uses can cotnplauz abr;ut the residential uses..He said no one wins: a'd it is a gni ed situation in this area V ith both,bidristrial and residential. Slae Chatiman Lambed s i noted' rece pt of the cainnients ftonr Gary acid Carol Zeliiner. r E The hearing was opened to the; public'. Norxian Load, D & D Homes; said this xequest was previously apr,�oved but Mi Giles did ,aof. have I id aaoney io pra,ceed: =He said fhia`.propbsal is for Mr. Giles to a yeon his property: �e said the, tegiiremetlts fo i water diad septic can be,•niet Commissioner` 1Vlooney asked if this is appioed there should be a coiiditioii fo "Obtiaiia an encroachient permit and constitxct driveway to Caiu�ty standa"rd's on Lncolia I31vd," Butte bounty �.Pla im!i S ommissiofi Minutes=:lVlarch 2G, l X98- ' Paige 4 Cl "CkS�ir"✓dia�ilu+.�lui`�;;a;41.�',:L.J.taa;:.l�w,d�wa.;,:5.1;...=P..a.r,.,. W.xaw:�r�n�.uo,ua�+ww.. .H...>..,..y - 4 y +} V {) ipri.1' "'i designation,, newly irequir ,A landfill property and air re Oyeday General Elan adjacent,51 ac , ; , ;''' parcel. .Xncluded; iii the amendment is a proposed change to the text of the General P1an� ixiakih provxsioris for uses That are related;,to ox `sixpport'the landfill ose: (CSS (GPA 97-Q3 Mr. Sanders gave.a brie £ summary of the, project, ,C sSloho ssioner Leiandquest ione d expanding the dump on a Negative Declaratoxi and riot an. EIR. Mr. Sanders the dump, waSL, expanded on a 1`Neg., Dec, in 1997, approved by the State Waste. said M ananagennetttBoard`and Lnviron tentaI , Qaltli�Depakmidnts, r Cominissioner Leland was concerned that tlY s 'project was riot:' under the scrutiny that nr4yr,.4., applications 'are., " TThe hearing was opened to the public, m DeWeese, Solid Waste Manager for the Cotuity,-Was present to answer questions: Commissioner Nelson said an mR wuld loop at the landfill for fiiture,problems, 1VIr. DeWeese said they need a, aceto put .t , waste in the County. 'He said this is not a new use fat ' Commissioner Cage asked him about deep furnaces 'instead of land fill? lvliX: DeWeese said it has riot been looked into ,in Bttte County. He said they don't usually get a favnrable,reception'beeattse of air pollution. CommissioiYet Nelson asked what kind; of application is f led with the Solid Waste Board? Iylr, DeWeese said they have to�tneet the ininmuin standards by the State Solid Waste Board and ` Water Quality Co' itral Board. He said there are several 'steps to, the application. ' Coin2riMioner Cage discussed beep .furoaces as being a'viable alternative. Chairman Lambert. asked if pal t o£ the urea vVas going to be. the dirt used for cover"? Nfr. DeWeese said,yes. ChairmanLambertssaid site was:concerned Wthrunof£v,�ater affecting.pxoperty down stieain froiii '1 this property. Mr. T7eWeese said there will lie` retention otfds and deh dratrn i'ocedur`es He said "the s stun is Pon, y gp y in place, aild:operating, He` discussed limited burning by private individuals; not allowed by a public facility. 1. �AI Bultc County NlnninCommiston Mi(iutes-'Mrcl126a 1�98� Page'1' 0 Y71f R R p h1 1 1 77"77 P# 111"# C 9 'r t§.} r r., 1! }� U h� f � 4 '1 cl 7 4i •i� i M k y V� ,'�Y �' Ii �j OaY( �Y \_ , 7 L '' f �F�' by*�' 'h i .. Yr . + p � i13�MR'�l�' �� `�t�'.. � w ryeM� 3, T fR 4,, � � 0yG-' + • � q } � .: � � N� j �,.;.. y 4 w.";�f. � 6� '1 Yl xC �� A V � �t `'1 1 7 � x ry. rtd xr u+9�: A k".'xr ,�'A.p. j ,� , '4 �a �' , �,:. �h k . c:.,� :c.,:; 4��'�' ,t;� ki„� r Y �t.t ,� . yy i17, WSA67;RikS7.�kWba'nH.r:l.P7W3y�iaW+�,.u.'r,4.We:al M u+l+,atisw...ww>=.w+awn+..+�-c• -- -•— —,^— s i • 1 yr � .l . ., I ) - �C CONSIENT Consent Items are set for approvaltn one motion. These items arP co. nsidered`on-controv rtial 4 , No prSen ll, be made; ho,: ever, csme quest►ons'ma)t e.asked T'&C hair Will ask tf any aominisston r ar member of the phblic wishes'to pull a'cansent nein far discussionY t' Rief questions maybe asked on'any item; VY.BUSINESS IFRO14>(.TIRE iFLO®R ON I7'EI S O ALREAD' ®N SHE AGENDA # a (Presentat�or►s will be limited to PNe minutes The Plannin Commission Js prohibited by $ta'te Law from taking nctioii oil any item p"rescnted if itis not 1isted'on fhe Agerida� C VII. PUBLIC HEARINGS The'Chair will call for.'staffcomments. The hearing will,t) opened to the p�.ib "to erhearin'" •Hill be clo,ed.t� the public and discussion far proponents, opponents, comments, and rebuttals. Th g tonf,iied:to.the Commission: Tie Comiraission�w,ill "then;inal:eanotion and vote.onthe item. Lt is requested that public initlated'presentations be limited to a maximum of,5 minutes so that all interested t . parties vviil have an opportunity'to address the:Comm�ssion; FalloyVing your presentation, please print your name and address on the"s ealcers sheet so that'the Kecord will' a accurate, h The r`ecommendat'ion of�Countystaff isindicated below: ��l �s,only a recommentlatios� and has not yet been considered by tie Planning ComntissionY Copies of the Staff'R-port at available at the' .Planning Division Office.:; s A. °The County of Butte Plain ing Coinmission sliali consider the Central Bautfe Cou'niy, Y 11 Gemer" al Plan .Amendment to consider the creation of a, new General Plan land use designation of "Agricultural? Preserve/1'lanned Community" 'incorporating the 4 standards and critei.ia 'described in the project. The proposed. new land use Issues Options Report; 1.994, in order designation is iii response to �ptioin 4 oi'the 4 to lirovide'for a plalined''gro with coini% u�;ity i7 the County outside of the present incorporated coni munities. { lvlr� Sanders said Fish and Caine was given a cagy of the Draft'Bnvirorrmerital Impact Report (DEIIt�' i following the last meeting. Fish and Game has submitted them comments and LSA has responded ' to diose cuiiiirients� Mr. S riders summarized the document, stating Fish acid Game's' concerns. There deeds to, be a clear delineation. between the primary and secondary areas. Mr, Sanders explained a ProgramElR`and the subsequent process. -He said'the responses;are adequate acid should { , be in thefee rd. i The hearing was olieiied to`,the public. jl Linda Cole said regarding the comments ley Fislx and. Caine, her concerns were x.�itci'the constraint lairds The document from Fis and Garie,:talkssabout;planis and nesting spots for Bald Eagles, 'She said it kenis that most dtiie primary zone is c'onstraiint lands, Site said the EIR is not'ade , ate, Rick 1`Jorlund said they liaye riot had aclequate';tiiiie to respond to LSA`s response to the is and Game cbrnments. IIIc said the letter talks abotit %000 acres of developable acres vliere only 3 000 icres will, be tleveioped, He asked that the hearing be continued. ' ge 2' r .t Butte County Planning Commission Minutes-1Vlarcli 12, 19923 i t Fat7 is y - - the two <ttetris I-le,isaid approval; of t1ie4 s.i dtion, sloes not meanapproval oithe project, He said. , CC if.,these items are approved the: next step yvould .be a Spec, :Pl'an :(SP) At ;the SP level<, env > onmental documentation would, be -required and at all future phases. 16, described what.a SP ` does: Tf a SP is approved; all future•appltcations would Have to lie eonsisterit With the SP. 46'said" this new designation is .a policy issue'and the Contmission needs` to decide what JeA16r,Butte County <r Mrs Chaffin gave a Brief surnmary of Report T regarding the new category. Mr. ;danders showed overhead maps from the Issues and Option Report: l . Existing communities " in the Cotu ty, 2. Expatrsion area Option 2.. I Using smaller eonit"nunities'far growth:; 4, Potential for iiewv eo Dmum tes. and 5 • Lop cat rural residential" areas that do not,. :e iitfras rueture ,as is needed in Other options, { Mt. Pardo 'said t1te;Tssues„and Option document shows liow cammumties could grow, riot necessarily { , W here it"would grow. Mr, Chaffin discussed Tab le'1 of the Agenda Report on development in the Cowity, Mr, `Sanders expla'tied Attaehtnent B tables, 1Ie d, 'eribedhoWTabldI was formed. ffe said it"gives ` bil the `idea of what' is potentially out there. for development. Mr. Sanders said the Cities took canstrairitsinto their plan within the spheres, the;. County did not fors the unincorporated areas. t Anything within,the sphere it is assumed infrastruchtre would or could be provided, s Conitnissioner Mooney discussedtlie devel"upment potential in the Cotirtty, He' said there is land that neverbe developed; Mr;'Cliahn; statecl'laow lie calculated fihe growth rate in the County (Page 3 of Report 1), He:tallced i -. aUaiit policy questions Page 5 o. pot 1 and abaut'Oeneral Plali consistency PIe said the proposed` Ladd Use General Plan policies are listed on Attachment A,, Commissioner,,,, Mooney discussed B,2 near"' a Caltrans transportation eo 1 idor, or near aii overpass." p: Mr.'Chafin said the Commission can modify policies as.tl eysee fit, P)e.discussed the. preparation, L of afiscal analysis: He cad `the two recommendatiotis on, Page 'I 0 of the report s There was a" discussion on what nuia be'r was used to anticipate growth. E { ChairrnanLAioe', cashed if staff had figures on the Cotntnercial .and industrial portions, as they did ; an, tlae `residential? r 1VIr,. Sanders said they did not .took at the need. for' Coinmercial and tidustt iaL 14 said there, is a limited supply bf Industrial land available. iii the uiiticotporated area of the Couiatyx , Commissioner Leland discussed whe e growth should oecurAnd whatictnd of growth. Butte CountyPI ►iniiig Comitt scion IVlnutw-'.tYl06 42, 1 9$ Page. 4 q f \ / J. ƒ / 6 \ � / y � /; � « � � � « / 6 x w \ \ �\ \ \ \ j \ \ & ) \ \ ) ( ��� 2: ��������� 1' }� i �' '. :. .�. �' �� .^ �C, � I. _ '. � l •'F t. 1 7 1 V t, '.. . �: I .. � JAI 1'. L( .S •-. 1 ' h �. r ��: �� M. , 4 �< � ,_-....t v. ,. _ m e 4", fv jj r .5 :t-� 1 ', - ,,} t :. � ti t. "F ,.,,+� F 4).�4 i+ .`:s ,+.. t, �k i •ti { dt +' ; t ° v } {' �'. t i 1{!.,-gY ° 1 ,� '.41,: , r,'�i p S,. S v 7 ..t a+ 1 1i'i s # i1^-tr� .{' 1.4.. kt: 1,Jk 1 { ".. r.,;i'"1 ,• a �[0I 7 i `� � ,',1� i , f r sa, t i i f,li ¢ „k 1,T x ;,^t.✓ rh .h .. •,,.. r` ,..': y'!e Y t r+t.,R.:', S d'a:: a ni 1 k+.. {: , +r r ix' };- 4 r ,iv45. .'e}3 } ; "r9 J , r i±`'1 ,1. d .t.,,.e L S ,,,.x ,{ 5,d'I y,;•, ex 4M :t.r�4"� 4+ ,.,,4 Y R`�;, t'}:vr d -r N ,i�.'�Y° .s'..• Y: °�ti- :h,> } I.t-;' ir1 U a:P),'r.. ,t 1 't4' :'., ++' a.•''S1'..'Yi° ,�` �.�+) 1 ['e' e} e•,{. / 1 xf t ,':I: { ,.:ptt yr $ ,y.: r ;'{',.' I,:�',i7.+�.W .e.�".: `i ,•`a, ;�. �{ a.%� t ,b, i' c,.1t;. ,i�-, t ,Fl r +s ,)..,. lr•'n ,...n l4 _., ..„:. C ,., .} i 5. •`1'ttt. s,.<'. .k.'. i,.. .�u1 ;�...,i;4;., ,•�.:.., .. ..�},f. t r, '` rr., yc lti +.. +. ,�� y '1 ..la 5, d f .j{ :, .:'<1 ; if✓, i 7 , ... R6'.2...r.f cg,•. Y, r'.; y,t,w x �t .res i y,U v.,^•i Yy:,.y'l ,rr°w `,.."+tl.l ht%e"-r}.X3anrr iila (.: t'.a i,. di, ,.,.,Yro _� i" ra�:r-1 of ,r;py1 ;Jp, ,fit 1, r,t;r}.,. r.. � y . f r •�'y e.+ S; .r< S` r ,,..,{S%' t rA } r:l V , s 1 } , ”, , ;n !1 6 ! ! � y ° 114, . n� trJ6h' r � u'Y'S ° (y r ':::> r r} l.,.., g 4 7 r `s , Y t ,rls"'WI`t' "V �•}. �. c°4 ,�.,,. { 'r'ia. '"'±��u ,r r`�`.' +k. r' ," � rY{++.a � >.,,. b'1„ A, '^t4 { �,'�5 * v+•{°:1," +, t' �,: r .ri ''�' +'C o .sJ r i s i, d:, { t,. , r ;c ,t e +', - 'sea l.. ).. �YIl-. f°.:t1 r,l k. �,U.., 9 �, 4''`,A, r +'r 1w i. ,na ',`. t �k,/ w� 1 -r;t'- r j. ..y t Il. -flr + {'. j1 7,: 1 we'; •tl' r• ,}�'. °y-1, 5 y' 4p""Y' +, ,,, �: e : 4 1 U1.:C `5 tlA e�,�R.Y �it+ • S t +t : N o '�a e I r w �U +•'i ° '��,. "� ,{ .,': ! '�'°;� - ���`ti'ii'1 3 T'AikrtaRriiuit?'l�tY:+kap+:a,r�w,�w,w,ss.4,o:t.,,«.�n; ami btu e i .M.y," �.�. ,, w:- 1 ��,•i s + ' ` t, r- tY}, ii , rr d 1,1= LAND OF NATURAL YJI fiGTH AND BEAUTY rU�a PLANNING DIVISION' ' + rn ❑ e I" ° `` DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES i1• 4 r ¢nrA+� : 7 COUNTYCENTER',DRNE --OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA 95965.3397 FAX: (916) 539.7785 I ��JTTE COUNTY PLANNIN COMMISSIOI1t s ACTIOI�T GEND March 12a 1,998 ' 00 a vmt 9'.rn. II: ROLL CALL Cotrimi ,i 4 rs'Nelso , Cage, Leland, Mooney anct unairman La111Ur, CE OF AGN]DA Commission: members and staff nay request additions, deletions, III. ACM or changes in the Ageiidaorder, Iy, 1VfINUTES =Approved the minutes for Feb' gty 12 acid February 26, 1998. ; V: hese CONSENT Consent items are set for appraal iri one motion, Titems are "considered non - No Will t e made, however, soiile g testioi(w.may be. asked. contioversial. presentations The Chair will as if any': c,orriinssioner ox inembe); of tlZe'pttblic vwishes to ,pull a con"sent item for ` discussion, lr3rief'que,stioins may. lie asked ori any item. 'VX. BCJSINESS:F�OIVITI FLOOR ON I�EIVIS NOT ALRE'Apj' ON T)ETEAGENDA (Preselttations be limited to five nuntites Tiie Pialinin'Cominssion is prohibited liy State .Law' from taking action on any nein Will presented if ltl�is not �lsted on,`tlie Agenda) . _ hTEARIi'GS 'The Chair wilf,01l forlstart comments. The hearing will be opened to the public for PUBLIC ro o: cotnmi nts d'rebutals The hearing Will be closed to fhe pubhc'and dis_cuaion confined to the oiients onents p p', -pp Cotttmission.' ire Coirimission Will tli."en rriake a ifioton' and vote -an the ifein.�� ' ue'ted that ublic initiated presentations be limited to.a maX"imutri o5minutesso that ah interested parties will Itis req s _. p ., tease your name'and address on ttae have an opporiunity'to addressithc Commission- #olloWing your presenfation; prlpt, speakers'sheet so that the Fec:ordi11'be acburafe. is below. It is only a recoariit�dndation and has oot yet Been considered by The recoinine'ndation ofCounty staff indicated 'tie Staff Report ai'e available at fife lathing bivisihu Offjee. the planning Cominis'sion, Copies'o t SBU I I ,,CQUNTY PLA?�ININ �CdMMIS5lON ;:AGEI�(17A "•I Ivlarcli 12,-1998 Ya,-3'MS•rl�jYiF� .�a.W 5,47 _ .,:\ ` 1 ''� ! Y'r, . M rl I Y �r.M h� t• R . ' I Y �.'�+�. dR ��f� �3' Yr i .,{ Y, .},� r 1 P�- .1 q'g' 4 W n '4� YXi �'� f 1 fy'f�:'M sE. Aw}a� t� "• �G f YP t r • .� u � A 4 Sh If T� W uNr'� A iukM, x �� � a9 i, __ t z * k rt.A r w 'u,'S{'.Ye1�#': `, O�Jf4`?��:{'1h�'i r,f 14: ,',� 1 �9.+�Xu �Y, y,�Ftr:a.i.My Fi}+1++f�4M'St's{If.iu�k.4LW1�1th+M,11(�kd3�Hb{1i64ua�hYablkulil+lFR.il IY.+Fii.,..., . ,HCl Lw. 55��>�f t MWW,4`FeLLLSf1?9^`�idlll r , i t Re ort including the' Xish and Game A: Reconnnnendatlon to cert1fy the Bnv��onrriental` Impar p. I'd d i , Camnlents'and'responses, as adequateand .ecommeiid denial af'the Pro posedNew Category, G:erieralPlan designation, , The County, off' Butte: �'la1?ning 'Cgmmissiori shall consider the Central` Butte County l^ A General P.lari' Ame�ndmeiit to consider, the creation of a new .General `.Plan land use Community" incorporatiniilg the standards and designation of"Agricultural Preserve/Planned new land use design. anon is in response to ' criteria descri.ed�nii the project.proposed " C 4 of y sues �4c Options Report, 1994, m order to, provide for a planned growth F { ptiQn community in't Couoty outside of the present incorporated communities, ; s B ' IZecomr iendati 'fo certify the Enviroruriental Impact Report,,, joclud ng the'Fish and Game denial ofthe proposed General Plan Comments antlesponses, as adequate, and recotntnend Arnendhent,. 'the County- of Butte sl'lantung Commission shaYT consider the Central Butte County OFG Project to amend the °pxese�it land use designations' Of Gcncrai Plan Aimendnic- &Open Land); A -R (Agricultural-ResGdential); and (Orchard aid Fleld Crap), GOL (Grazing Ge1.neral Plan 'land use designation of Agricultural. I (Industrial} to "a 'newly created Preserve/Planned Community;" far appr'o�timately 1'8,000 > acres.:of land on. praporties generally bound"liy Neal Road on the north, Clark Road (SR 191) on the east; SR 149 on'the o „ and includes ro ernes on the West side 'f SR 99, southof'Durhain bayton Highr?vay south: " p p g y nding aportiOnOf the Durhsrn- xtendln to the 1Vhdwa ., The amendmetit also in attic D`ayEon'�Nelson Area T'lan� is be idilized y, the Planning C��rTmission acrd , >CNIERAL i3USY1�ilESS This section of the agendn' to items ar which staff has been f' P�risining Nlazager'n " items. of interest, genra7.discussto, or, direct tl to do''rese tr��.arid bring back;"to the':Conzm ss 0A Items A� B-& C »lay not al�i�ays be addressed;irt etrery learirig but will and�crys be listea as part of thergenda, , G d ral PlanIoning Ordinance U date T3: Legislative Case Law Update r`:C. Plaguing Commission Concens Ap,�OVRNMICNT r J;\W PDOCS\AGENDAS\PCA03,12.4$ BUTTC COUN T Y PLANNING COMMISSW R AGCND . i' March 12, 1998 ; a 1-:T '7sK4ir`3'�V d��ly 'Jr' H E kn Hi A �'k �� t �• 1 r ,+'� ' ...,.,. n i ti n°. t �'a , a r � r yr w• - e x e�w 't t ;. � � .� d � z_ J+ ` .. � ,.. � I , 1 0" , �, "I . . .1 -11 1 ... ........ N', 21 Co" n i dieato w, 'It i's only Wteodniffiendation and, Jile re,,orpniendatioifof Yldbelo has g 'Commission.'�p a h' considered, bCopies U1110 Staff Deport re yet beencp available the Planning Division at f r6vww)' ftyexempt from ervir6nmeiftd pp es 16m dekninetb cote r1a- permanent second 'dwelling; unit. tinder the provisions' 'Qf,P!1tte P fil't or,a-pormane er I County ,code SOctlow4-2800h,prpporty zoned 'AR -.WI 5(Agricultural turaI `2i6sidohtialMobile , I mo R:o-'ad',' on the _;northeast Nome - 1.5oor'e, parcels Ideated-onthe east -', Upper, Paler '0f n AAvenueat,6975'Pnkoadidertifed asAPd f ppIAletnidloadAWessin aldr .027 Palermo: P'98-04) -M d' brief summary bf o prpjec,,i r, Sanders. bth :cd the;address above to r6qV'6915 U, alero tomnusslofter C go 06niect poetTibRoad;" She:asked. about the mbile'b ing:coftdI conditioned for skirting and to. be placed on kundatioti. '*.'S -`ande.rsAaid'tjieM:,Are notequir, requirements: fbr ;a permanent foundation or skirting, change,to Condition 9 to add "prior to issuance of mbort fialked about trpossible p 6- the 1- t y Of this Property, auilditig permits" e.causebi q lislor r. d public. The fiddrin'g-wa :oven cl�'to the Ub ic, sent t this Issue.. There Was no one to spear pre p 4 The hearing closed. seconded Commissioner ly It, was 'moved�,by Commissioner Moonq, �ge Leland, and unanimous "con :carried Approval,.ag.:f1bll ks, -for "Si "FIN I SG D Sdotibn,:T:: Ahvir6n6iehUql,,V'm ins.. 9, A: This application for a lYlixtor Lyse Perritt ,allowa per ent-second, dwelling, unit is Categorically, xempt OlAdnviroiiinental. review,,an, d, iSectiori 2: Zoning, Ordinance ,in:. mg§.o, a io- 'c§ �of the propose use A X' The p opose design, And operating iaract6rigti i0d' t, size, toiny Code, of-the accordance with the purposo.,of:Citpief240f�tit. p,i , All the development zone iy""hi' ;the lo6ai he,Butte County Plats, :,dnd tdhda*,� oft le, Coil' 4t "d, policies Y."Aft A t lanti'lhg Commis, �pmmki6fils, inutes afeMi6q, BooCounty P is lm 26; 998,, 1`i Page 2' �72N�7 Tv Yl� 7',7:717 I Y ti t a pr.opo! c. �liatacterigjf6s f 6 iddusd Wilf t ,tali B .3 d, proposed: location,. q era ing 'bleMth 46d, will not,, adversely affect ar be : materially cletkimbrital to a japerit be .,c p0ti, qT th or natural,-.reso�rees wi 00 14 RI'ven, 6, us6s� rbsidofits! buildings structuresat 4 1. rmony in scalq, ]!:�i ojiige d density, .:,.,Ha,' lability t of public Rad ifiqsr services and utilities; 2. The dvaliab , desirable I 'hb i.character,' Thei harmful offed,,ifany, upon esir, �neig 'orh 0-od in gratia r 'oftfaffic and the and physical character of'surrp ding k i .,s rep Pj.' The"suitabilitysite forthe tyPintensity of use or.development Which is ropqs., p e'd ��6tjjor, . _t, sed Any televan Use 6.'A -impact, of ,the prop d Ignan :I har- pteristlaoftli,epropom use and the The, propose location, size, os_ operating -c a 1 1 conditionswhich under it willbooperated bnain tained- will not bedetrimental lo the public "hi - ' tis: �i , jiii onients in health safety �or indiedalty inj injurious to properties improv and ne 116, AIII t vIL ity-aild .Theproposed use will comply Witheach of the applicable icgbt&Provislo §:df Qhdoter 24, Section 2,80, of, the, B tpurkty'Cdde. Ij 10 Section 1111 A_In ns LanA,2, of this exhibit A, "Minor Use Porimi t for to, adings indicate c'Vbjedt an egrityH bgw,lnc� on 027-060-006 toallow apermanent second dwetqq unit Is kqppr6vsi_ibjectto the conditions l sted.hori 3 7 w R.Mino changes may be'approved administratively bythe Directors of Development Services; Q: t by Eriviroiiniental Publ10 Worlcs.upon receipt of, a substantiated written yoclups ,�sI to those conditions recommended e y the applicant ,,and ,,6nlya jig piitequii:effieo thow: pr's, 1, approval, v6d verification be made by' each resp6 A V' d Pronto C c i, e epartm _,s Department orbi"vi 10 application; fees,paid an. environmental dotok inali,oiias to iditiob+dlly"4pptoved.Ciange's'deemed to be major or s; ig,niuI capfi'n' nature sla,11I requite ' L "t b I n, I AP P,Ijc tion for amendment. G.. Conditions of Approval; �6xpeod: 1200, sq t 0 ilid not 11reee Th&� SO nd Ifillt S Provide.two additional'i "OfPstfloot:spaces, dimension ; ,,6k: dkap _,rport pripy im An attachedwith a maximum b 24 s permitted, y ; 4" Adequate 's eWer an potable water 66111fies ;shall be provided under, erm. as � determinedbiyth6 130 Ame0tat a thDi C Butte id -unty, PIAi%jhg.06iiunmgIoft, Minutes -pp. to*� 2k,'I 00s �PpgO13 c 11,1111 ij!,IJI11 11 At " f ,�: }n,. ,r, ... �,.;n .,.. .., :�:; �.. ;,,. , ,:'.. ,,: : TY+�'t : �r ":.A � -.: (, } 17f I;".: rrr :,�. r4.,' �Y,P I.,W i •:,j.:: T, l ^" +J ARY,,.t . ,. A, d, 9. ,,,, °.,, a ',.;.1i. MZ .h. r A,Y 1 c :`9 �. `•It" , fl.. .,rd, t ?i1' 1 1.I '�^ }D, ..Q:,..p,. l :a%l ,..4 .. ...... •!,,, ., fi,,,< . 1• ;a,, ., } -. ,� v.d ha.,, ..,n•,€ rs.! , ,-.., ., +L b, u. ,A ,.r 5.: •3v a , "q, . � ... ,, ). ..10. r l�J '.�� u+ •,rr.. 51,.: ,F,r.; yl�" ,...,.. :.� ,P. '.rd„44rJ; I, L ii r•5 rrj.Ay":'•.!r ",(C a `•i, .. r.. r.,r ,[ _' „'.r r ,:..n ,• ., e. � a . ; vr:.r, t i 1,�. }.Lt,., S6 P, r, a ,}•, gu 5.. �q, ,rr 4 :Y,: }; 1 lk,t . • e; 4v, .aA. i H� ,; ..` 4., ,..�.. 1 t ,1,1 '[ . „ .,... rls„ � ! ,v.JK,...t.. k ,, a .., r.'„7f..: � n7 :., ,r. , w.. '[ ' �Sn:.:,•M..15�.r�.,:.,,N �'� ,'r !•.i S �i YW .. .• :..-; ,n„ ,1,, ,.} FIX `'r ,�• n, r ,.1'1 AS1rx ,'rr,", L,%'.;:', a *a..':,' t ,y'-:i'�y } r, 4,�•r rl.."'%...t , rr,, ", , ..., •', i,• ', n,-, . „S ,+t ,-'.a n , .. , • 3 :, A. F a "rYp ,.t •rNI' .F ra, .. ,:,f !,ri „ lir 4`' , n i . ,"-i 's!1.,... r ,.c, ,'av 1.+ .,`A, S. ri, a:• ° [ia :.'s• - A......i.r v, ac� • �) d. •r aiy ,: �., tS1. ,,-,r " r. t. a#! r",� a r, e. ,dYtl ++t°h." _1 -q5 1.. � k. r v ", '.0 „ r ,,. s,,.,E„ . r .e$ -4r , t; ; } ! s,, 1 '•t ' P .;y Pt !!4 , . e x .a",^ ,...,, f.,: u t >i., .. d ,nb> ,,. ....4 kr . 3.. ,P,. w a' l ,, :rt,. -.. a .,�`}' I a.Y ,i, 0 f:n�;.x 3. 0 .,, �tt ,J, . a, i, :1 ,r4:.rf� i J. .�, i :ce ,f .1. q0 A, �It ...1.. t.. c. ,4,, ..f ,•t 5 , 1. 1. . 1, rt ., .yr3.L. ,u,f .:1. " t ,.Y, „i. ,� 7 :'o ., ( h iN l ' "t>'It. a 1• ! ' i` 1 , s,, r ".rn Itm+' i xs J .! r' t.�,,,A .,.: \ x i iy :,,. ::s 1. .;rrF, .,. •, ..�4 o.Q,7. '(J' }1; v . : ,A• t .. -,, � ,,.; ,. , ,tM1 , :,: .. :: ,: ,rt ,.. ,.,.-r4rd:,, „. }, a I•' ^`�I ,. S- ,,., C - : }+ Y E , ! r 2i u + a � fi t v x�a ,.r 1... ..i ._ ...... .1 ,....3 .1, ,r .4 ,t£ r..,, .. !r' e i • ,f -.y.d.�,ih., . ,,., • . t.,r...a . ,,r 4 f, r+•..r V�9. r f i. ,yk. fil.r. arn...vm e.N •...: ,....�y„ ....,S +rl, °t.. , .f , ,.E"b tv tf"a... .o l e.,••,,ti.,,,tt A., It1rl'w r, ,.r^i.. i+ n, -.7 d rM 7 6..., :.1 ,A.,��.,}.. ,.... ,,}k t .+P; -t ,{tA .A 4. `.. .! ,. ,.I », �:i 1.-. ,, :1 tom,.., . a{.. ,.tr ,i,. :• q.. ).�., r. ,.rAJ .�fm r. ,naw- f- r '. TI rr 1,-, r :.t �k lr ,... 6 r,. 5.. �•,.�,.;, T. },h.y.t. A..ir a.1 .,.4 ,k, ,, .�t�'qyw yr 'n 'a3•I d+ry ,r r. y. ,,,, x1. fr ,:,x„d. �i,: C. t.,A. ;4 11: 3 h, erP:. 1, 1 ' ";x f f v x!� .7. .3 t„ � J.. ,..,, [ .,.} n.. .A ...1 ,n,N . �.. � x..n, r: r.. 1..1 ':.. },,-;r .n•: ,.tr9 r,ft ,.t !. 9 +,. 1. 4��.-• �A s. SS rM1' wi }.(f r"rk'r ,1,4t ,P:a, t �:. ,p, r a, r. ., 4.,d v e tf , „µ ,A •4, nri:ii•j jjw, ,, , €, , ;..ai,e�4 _, } , t' ,I . ,..?„ ,ros' 4 ., , ,, .f, ..t :,•.1._ ,. , ,,.bf�s,• r ttr, ,._ ,, r ,4, f'. r . ve;a•t ra, . � , Cr .t a. + ! , �i ,J�Nx.. (i I;...,.n4 +..n v •3.,e A. .'c. til ... �, r ,' ., ..4,14• ...Y ,,. ..A yr }, ,.�?,, ,. : :lar d. ,I,P:, fy.:: ,., r, ,f.. �q} i l r ..ir' x' Ne i . ti<., nh: +; .- ra..f b ,� t..4t}7 ! �:,, r4 . {.. 7., A., t , b , a� , .r ,.u, ,. t T •`ard.tr:� rr 4., ' f. eS . �r. .,. +t't'! yr.Yr<.,,.,. ., t( ., t. r, 1},,�.., � .,-....?.}. »1.:� t x. •..« ,. 5fi. br^"�,:'1.Sf :: n. o' 4 n. ,.•'r ,.�,,, {r,,., .y,, ,r ,.Ai., ,-r4 I.., a.r.,7 NL rR ,d.. p, .. .. .,y f A. 1, s A;": �. L.�. t.t. s,• .�- t. kr _a;}jr,„-,}}.•✓rj�fr y..t v7 "�✓t. .u. W ..Y , 1.�:. .r.,F .+r,,.•>.r v t. =5 `I . s.. A�:,id1 : �•.'e t... {.,}t�:. .. >.. ,�r .. - "Ai.'° � .,n.,. h R 4..,.r �'':I•. t4 N. •;ir .+d L. ; Arr, ,t ..., y 4�...,.., ,r,}ry!., S".:''r LpE.,.'.,n4 ,,k�;t �'i�'k:5'S'};'i 1.,'�j-•r-..q,.y. ..o o ', i. Tf''"•� ".,,�+ � .Lt u4, il,,r �� ' ,1, , . r 1•W n'Iti h, 6 ilf A ryti sd .y 4 +.}.0 rn n, t � r "• r • v ��.. ,q. w��.wrF.`+-r.+uv�.,w«.4.y .ucw',e�xA1+'�dt�, dllnrieefllki,s�awraYlM�•4'u.iNP�-�A.lrwlrwr.utt.'{y��M:.wrr.,�pa,1kL.!.�,..LL+1'i+?tk�'4s�K�.,lnAffi1F1,1@,fiv>.it+H1�. �.. H,9. ,i�l+++•.r.r» r<...,T A• { f e1 ( , r; 4. JIF IN t= r;r r4 S. Either tlie. 'existingr'sinle family dwelling or, the Second Unit shall be 'owner ter occupied. Certification of o1Ynership shall; be required prior�0permit issuar ce,and at ntiully thereafter by submittal of a�:declaratioh m a form spec; fiecl by .the Director' i c ol'Developmert,Services 6r designee. t` 6: No emits for aizy adclxtional dwelling may be approved unless the• Second Unit ,is ?a p first removed, or a Vse Permit be al proved liy the Planning Commission: 7: Construction,, installation or, development of structures or facilities on tl�e parcels/lots x1,91 don ply with the f atest California Fire Safe Regulatiions,' (Pub1iG Resources Code 4290), and all ,other applicable State and Cotmty'codes ordinances acid regulations a 4 in: effect;at the time of application for improvement Perinits. r 8r Building identification and/or,addresses shall be iinstalled in conforni-,Ui, with Public i f Resources Code"420 and shall be posted at the begii:niig of building construction F A t and maintained Continuously thereafter. i. Remove existing illegal moliile home and existing house. under: permit from Departrrient of Aevelopment; Services, Buildi!ng,Divisign. � 1Q> Relocate the iriobile l ome or contact P. .,& E. for relocation of their gas Tine. R t 11. Applicant shall comply with all other applicable federal; state and local regulations: r *4 >kiv�.* FatadiseRod:& Gun'Club proposed Negatiye.I)eclaration wxth:'nlitigation measure's regarding eiiVironnletal impacts' and CUUe Perijiit to -provide •for flip' construction of a 1; slootingiarige including caretaker residence, club housez shooting platform, septic, well,. All parking fol, `100 cars on property zoned "U (Unclassified) •and "S=H'(Scenic Highway) located ,on the east side of the Skyway,app oximat6ly nine miles east of Chico and two miles , + west of Paradise, identified as APN' 040-520-09 Z, (SHS' (U98 11) (V IDEA) video of the site vVas;shown:` Stephen Hackney gave a brief summary of the pio�ect' He sub initted `a supplemental Agenda Report dated 2/24/98, He said this request is consistent with the zoning wifli a Use Penni!, 14e discussed the design and safety features for the project , bre said the Commission should require an independei, t'noise .•study be preformed, He said "the Town of paradise did not take k a positian;:on this applicatioixr' He said the applicant has contracted to have the noise analysis done. ' Commis"stoner Nos on;'aslred what w64U be accoinplisl ed with ati independentnoise analysis? e{ , 1Vt ilaek iey said a specialist in'the field would do'. the analysis,' X Ie said sotuids may aaliieve 600 standards', but because the;Aots are' nternaittent, the sound niay impact the neighbors. x Commissioner Leland said the job of the study would be to. analyze Clic noise level and the i oliloxioisness of the noise He saki ane of the• icey .issues is'going, to be atteftuatioi of noise, _ , 4 i Biifte County Planking Coinm�ssioii Minutes - l:ebruary 26, ,1 �9&' '} Psge• 4 , M 7 ° A ". A r1:?J r 4,'� yTA �?. �td`ti ); nxt art• Atlrb+ �A >EY k t ,ql � �� q .r � ,k, r rcr . d� ;,: ••. e,T{, 4P"e °0 q 4.d i r yf- `Y `�.t E�. IyC'�•� f,F, ,,yy.A_� -0 i f ,. _ ,,.-n„ e _ .., .. yesterday with shotguns,.' He said the,.noise fxom the'Skyway.ii�te-dered4ith the test, HP.discusseci the test at! 'how it. was, performed and, the trouble with outside noises. Hesaid at one"and 'lz;miles , aux ay he did not register, 20dB on the e, er. 'He said he was willing; to contribute on'the County's ? ' update o#;the Noise Element, ';,He said the nature of the >ioise could, be obnoxious under, dertain' circttnses 1 E Mr l-lollenthaner discussed liow shooting at the range occurs. He discussed,dB levels of other types 'of noise. prari Main talked about'the,opportunity for families to shoot. She -said they hold charity" shoots and target shoots. Tl eie are safety classes for children as well'as adults, Edi ,hunter safety classes:. This' would provide a safe place to�Aoot: rr, PaulMqlters, Chief of Police, Patadise said he has, been in law enforcetrient 28 years. 14 stated experience with firearms. He. said they need't adequately train law entoi cement officers, Need, a training range that is outdoors There is'ino full service facility'for law enforcement to train. He explained .the duties `of a Range Master and stated that there will be one at all times. Ike said: at the' , ,range 0111=Tig1>way`J�9 & 70; rifles are not,allowed r. Steve ScarborolYglY said° he is not opposed to the guns .rr the shooting r7rige, but is concerned that •.. ,:,.�.; P.v1Sutir+`iL.rzt ! bA 7t3w„�34Sa:P 4 �,, 2..s,.un. iJ.�.�. ? `�.�' amort sioa needs to male ure' he public s ingests are protected. a said sat 1. Point, is located closer to this property than the closest residence,and hay scenic and historical value that could ibe impacted. } :Bobs Persons; honieowner, in' opposition to' the .project: Resald illegal shooting in the area is obnoxious andAhs. use would also be obnoxious. This application is fora large facility with l00 parlciiig spaces. He said itis bad planning "to allow this facility in ati area that has different future development potential:; He said,they need,'to look at alternative sites. He said this itse will be ' inapproprate,in the°SII'zonealong the Skyway: die suUniitted a lettei on acotstical'aioise,, j, Bol; James said that'/z inile past the; Blum iesidenee aie 30 more Houses, that will be impacted by the rioise"..He saidth s rase is a tlueat fo their property values He said lie was not contacted by the Rod Gun. He said sound spreads: He said the entire ridge Uhind.Indiaii Springs is used Uy hikers and horse liack riders and is directly across from the proposed rpge_ Noelle b`erdon, Fuvironinentalis`.t, discussed piobleins with the Initial Sttidy. She said a focused FIR i ot, a full Erivirontitental Impact Report” (FIRS was needed. She said the Initial Study did not o adequately address watery noise, atr: qualify, dust, aiid increase in traffic„ She; said there is little or soil over"tlie laai'dpan and, water esii be ;a ptol;tetnF Slte discixssed'the ai'fects of giiri shots oaf ' suaouiidirig wildlife. S.lie.saidtlus was not addressed in the Initial Study She discussed recycling" ({ mid recovery of,bullets and casings: Artifacts may he found on this property, She felt a full ETR vas necessary: Slte satd rheic are;information gaps in the ,filo, ; i I 1 I Butte &0 11 1'lztnnitig Coititti sslot! Minutes - Febrttary 26, 1996 ''.' Page 6 d l �, .6,,ar1 ''" 14\ '}rwyyri+ { x a1°4'%4. a t`ryLid'. `+rrJ..�rldQ'131116}9fitg.?'{Et1.7GG:Ytia£:'dAtF3+`.' ' ylatidwad7.'wFF*Iw71aNuw^aa.'y::w,.... . i, a ac and,. �. ce n itl t r ff Con�rtussaoiter,Cage �atd she Was not'd the. Rod ,:& but is.ton r ed w ;., � . Bre safety. a Horton presented a letter. He said they should: look into whether this project is safes He ,Rocky, 'otherranges across the Country Have had bad 'accidents. He said this was dangerous ;near a busy highways. He said, he .oNjvns a vacant parcel adjacent.to this site, "He was against the project. He noted that a'coupie of sites 11W.to, the dump are for sale:. He discussed wells iii the area. ' Corninissioner.Leland said he was inclined to ;continue this-.hearuig: He said lie vias not will ng to . Trove this pto�eet tbday� He was in favor of an independent noise study.' t Mr; Parila sald'ih s could be eontinued for an independent: noise study and further environn enn Q q doct7menJ;at on ,,The°hearing would',be re-publislie. and re -noticed. James lutz, Butte Creels Canyon, said there'are shooters on BIM lands, unsupervised, since the Club has` down while,loold fora new;location: He sats%they need this facility. { shit g ' WeridyMul'cahy `said no one Wants this use tn;thei zieighbCi46ed. She said this' use would destroy the peace of the area`. She was against' the protest. k f Lottie Bluiri'said her property is one;in le frons ihe'site,' Against the project: She said sh e does not t , ,lie said she;s very, up by dais proposal. want to loose the cYuiet, ,$ l Larry Adkins said lass liotise is near Indian.Springs. He was against the.proJectIe said noise will be a factorw He said they need a full; 1JIi2 . Hesaid`tlie Rod & Gun;people-do. 'not live there: He said 1 the residents do not need to be'subjected to this noise. yThe.heaxii g was,�oseld: � c Claai7iaan.T,ataibert said slie' was'conaeriied with'finding compatibility with neighborhood. Slim was: cancer`ned with traffic safety with a 100 car evetat:. Coimmissioner gage said they need a..facitsed EITt ori traffic, iioise, fire safety, and the,Scenic ' . fJighwayi 1j k' Coirirnissioner Helsonagreed that `was the right projec L at the wrong `location He did not think `- an EXk would sole tlae problem. He said the a pplicantsshould put their energy`in o finding' .another location.' ' Commis"sioner Leland said there is the subject of annoya"nee to the neighbors` and lir did not know if a noise .study would everrado comp ams of those ne glabti'rs: Comnussidner Cag , sire safety has" not, been iACttigated, e said traffic noise, and It was moved by Comiiassinaiei Cage'to continue this hearing Fand require'a foctasecl EYR. , utte County Planning Conuriiss►on Minutes February26,09811k Page& q y ,' •:. A p t 1 1 ' d p 4 N '` F_ V 4 4 s 4.n�.��{ �1�i� 251.4 'iY��Wffafi+*'{af�4! { 1 � :�}iArM+rt A4,��rIMh4:w.F+••."I.H•Mdk+lYW4uM.N5arii'""'t.. 4 � ,�, ;� UVJ +w WO The motion died fora lack: o a second', " r� Mr. Pardo as%ed' if the C ommtsston wanted more infomatiori before making a dectston. omtnission dentes this project and it goes to the Board, can the a1.1 Sibert `asked if 'tile C Chairman Lam. j Board ask for,'an E] IR Mr Partlo"sald yes.. ,i Cage to continue this Bearing for more information otx ixose; traffic, '{ It was moved by Cotxuntssiorier 4 fare safety, and scenic highway. ? Tlxe mottort died for` lack o fwgccohd, Commissioner ,Nelson the`'applicant, will spend a lot of money , oir a noise study and the {laid costillsdeny thlsproject. Leland said Be vas cotxifortable wi0., the staff report; but aot .comfortable with the Comtntssioner noise problem. g; It.was ntoved by Commissioner Lelart!i seconded by, Commissioner �� s t affcfiretsafety1and to -a ide 'endent N re flus hearing to receive an Ii p otse Study and for staff scenic highway. AYES: Corninissinners Cage, Mooney, Lelatxd, atxd Lambort ' NOES: Catiimissionei� Nelson ABSENT No one � ABSTAINED: �o>one `" i bsn CQfCltx115StOner Nelson was a't at this titlxe. 1 , _ronin Code Atnetidtrtent%Re7ona - bepartin, Develo me t S rvc lees (Rein detei'nained .. A County wide rezone/code' to be. a General yule Exemption from envtrontnental review) on all parcels ;currently zonedf AnRM 2; San l amendment cliatzing the zoning desinatio Residential Mobilo kl 1, ARIviH-2,5, ARMIIa3, and ARMH-S (Agricultural AR2,5 and Ak- (Agticultural Residential, 5' Acte parcels�e to . AR, AR 1,, AR2 5 1, 2 5; and 5 acre parcels) respectively and elininatirtg Sectietxs 2�1 Agtcultural Resdentil Froin fixe Butte,County Cade: (CS� Oc 98 02� 106"a nd ?4=100.1.4 �, [3utteotGityPlanning'Co►�tmission Minutes . feUruaiy.2G, 1928 r Page 9 t� -, ._�..... x:R iwvr�`.r 1,1i' .,.. „avP lr,+nrlJ.unn,Y.vol nxi.uWdrWi. Wdr.rrrwt. W44ri %f, k511A @Kd ,f". vvwl { m •:.�u»L. 1t�„5.y..rrr.Gl.¢4.yii.b knl,..isy;,wi�.nti�b e l:wil�Yr��.kN a'l�' .a», J Mr: Sanders said" this is a cleanup ordinance of the or approved in 1997 eliminating""pre- ; HJn mobiles in all zoiie5 allowing mobiles, The AR -MH and A -R zones; ate" identical and approved redundant;, Tae AR=M11 zone: is no longer need. ra r; Y ooney, seconded by !Ch6irinah Lambert, and carr od to recommend It was moved b Coniinissioner M' approval as follows:. 1 ;Y IND q ". G Section 1; Environmental Findings. ; Find that„tlie project is not;subaecl to eriviromxtental, review under CBQA. as per'the general , wale,e tempon- and Section 2:, 'Zoning 4�rdinance Findings. df A. The proposed changes to the Butte County ;Code are consistent With the Butte "County. ; General Plan; and Secttoii 3: Action i Subject tothe findings indicated �n Sections 1 and 2 of this report, move to recommend that AF the Board of Supervisors adopt a i ordinance rezoning all properties currently zoned AR-MI to A-P�, all properties currently zoned' A.R=MH 01 do AR -1, all properties curte"ntly zoned AR -2.5 all properties ciu entl zoned AR-MH=3 to AR 2.5, and all AR-IVIII-2.5 to Y. : .1 ctitrently zoned AR-IVIH 5 to AR S andeliinirtate Sections 24-100 and 24-100.10 pro ro iii Cha ter 24 of the Butte County Gode. f p I� AYES: Commissioners, Cage; Mooney, Leland, and Chairman Lambe NOES: No one Commissioner Nelson ABSTAINED. N.o`oire VOL G]GNI+; U'L This section, of the agenda is io ttl►lized by' tEae Plurtning "BUVS�INE98 Cdrritnssiori arid” Plannhg lllarttrger on (terns of i��tenest,,`genet al disi�ss «Yt or it�ri:s for :.: welch staff has been directed to do reedreh qni� b�'i,g bctcic tv the Carirrtrssion, Iterris A, B, , C may r?ot alrvttys be,addt�essed at v01 hearing; buf mill always be listed �s part. df the age.:'da. A. Creneral I'lari/Zoning Qrdrnarice Update B. Legislative Case w update" 77 utte i6, 1998! BCounty. Planiiiiig Co�nmisson'ivIinut'es -ary Febreh2 r m 1 , C.nning, Comnn'issian Corker"ns 1 1. Discussion - F1'exible,Lot Size Ordinance -Initiate Code Ameildirient -set' for hearing, CommYssioner"" 1Vloaney said 80°io open space is excessive:" Chairman Lambert said the. PUD process would come through the Camnission, wllerea5 the flexible lot size would ,go thi ough the DRG only. Mr. Sanders said the PtJD,doesn't allow that. ,inuch flexibility in terms of.stntetuiing the subdivision �5! and requires a homeowners assouiation..14 said deyelapers are reluctant to use the PUD process,' , ChairmanLambert,said shed" not, .see this chaiia as an iin roveax�ent for the ubl'i of the Coun g p p - tY i Mr, Sanders said this type project would need less roads, v�ould have �i�ore open space; He saidthe fr Y PtJD' process is cumbersome arid, is not used: , I 1, Commissioner Ireland was concerned with clustering`the homes next to a i eiglibor, that'iriiglit object, 1 vvi, _flexilile,zoning. W. Sanders said ihete will b.6:4 public hearing at DRC. 'Mt., Parilo said "there will be a mandatory preliminary reviow of projects' with the flexible concept: He said it would encourlge better design acid contiguous ojien space. He said clustering next to neighbors, would be discouraged in the preliinipary-meetin , IYIr; Sanders discussed the ratipnale for, ar hig at 1 acre minitnunis', le doted that "there is very little acre zoning in. heL County = - - r Chairman Lambert discussed yvhat happens to the open space. and: wlio main ams, it. f. i Mr, Sanders said flus change is not proposed m the Ag zones i lvlrPan lo said this ordinance would make if .easier to eliminate in. the future, 1` I COMM ss, Met Leland, was; absent at this tune; , Chaif'maii LarnliOf discussed easements it! perpetuity: Mr, Sanders said a conservation easement is stroiigef'thari'the zoiniig. Mr. Parilo said this' atriendmeiit would.apply County wide; except iii ag. zones, hle: said thOb at Plan proposal far Central Butte`s wouldonly apply to that specific] site, Butte County Planning Gon1-019sion IVluxufes -.February 26, 1998' ,°; 0age:1.1 p .11 % i� - 14 Commissioner Cage, unanimously KWsOi, t"Was,hoved byCqAit�issioner,seconded It -hif�ites or anuary NL MINIj Approval APP of the f, 22 The CofrimisMO41140he following corrections and �additions,-Tagd. 2,Line": S, and Page 10, Lirie W -'fCagel Page '13 Line 18'add' andh6foma tesponses,wo old, be added, to the 'glianglo,l ed- 4, 'Sh ag q j.4 L h .6WOef$ P F e 57% p ilne 15, c atige�`:W,Oer 60 k6pohge to Omni nt t d unanimously carried d, dbydom ssioner .-Oney, an. I �xvas move( !"by Cori issilofieOCage,isp-pon e theinintiteg.as torr, e, d r ppyova,l of I I 11 r I _ I , 1;1` vll,cdNsuNT co entIteMS ate sel,for ,00, tian 'Th se.,iItetu-are' cofsiW,eidh6i- 11. made, gboe estionsine k X6 pfdAlllk?0017S�W be )i WWO91 qu of;the 1c ')Is 1, gjj� a consent {tent Tot disalission.. 'lie Chau ovaloOf iYcQift!W4YSldndlIor, or -Opubl. ii Am q, 0 Brref I'tS beasked 9111.7 doyildmi , L TlkE AGE NDA VIM l3USlNE$$1F9OM FLOOR lTtWNOTAUtE4Al) ON etil to 'five pdilulq�, The Plan�hig Coi.iiii)is'sidn�,tsp)-ohl'bitd.d by �ldtelaii)fto vt atl6n�*lAbdNiftei ,reg - 'ted ifft is riot listed on the Aketidd) adtl6h oh,anY iItelp pn�sgn None. c Op K will, call fop staffcbminentS, The hearing will Ge e the public �,`OUL .HEARINGS Tite, -Chair f -Propbllenlq"opponents, con qW. ),-cbut arhigigill: be closed tothepqb dis,cussioll, _6 'I'' I i illlheapiakd a tliotloh,aod vote, oto Od Uetfi- olinnission. The,C lk eottfned to oitiml. oi w Robert 13c Ann Stephens prop', 0.se d,, &gativa Declaration with, im, ig-a ion measures k Plan to Chico M regarding environmental imp q" and an amend. 'men the r LL Co M, change theland .use designation on 'acres Residential ac re Vacd)s al'd.. OS (Opel tninimwn),acre :P,*,e.,ls/00cf'ISpace), Spade) to SR-1/PD jPD (Sub�rbhn Rogide I acre m, mum/Planned Development) : a.nd 'OS/P) ('OpejSpace/Planned Development) -1();iglu Industrial) on r. erty - .located b the -stMdebfRlcksLane, apptoximIate1� Vi46mile;Keefer Lane '(continued ohfiniled OPdn).' d6lififled,as, APN 041 25441� no t ll'S ) edZ/12/9` Ro.gaV6a; summary of,tAe,revised, OA dated ;-,MrS`anddrs,submitted i n-eW g,erdgtdP . Ibrief ieporfi a eneompasses fia"was :discussed4i the -jequest,ig Approved , thehanres`wo6ldbe,incl4the.text:6fAjeNort 00cmi-jai, (NC far this tproperty' only. irieltideg, setback along the d age., ooneysa le"Oppll ram ner'M i'd 'e col),imissio spaa�n6 , I - I I , . I I . l: sl niqrY, a'amatr,, Ipprt an usp� :and q the open space in He s4id the ``103 ac:rip W . s� , setbacks aloli he;'C:: r 0 Butte cou I plWilifficCofil N6 f M, r 'p, - a�i` i. y - � .. � � r.,},rw—y lt'ii _ +t� ICY I 1 1 I C6ntnttS5i6ner Nelson said this proposal is still in the same t�ligllt path and he did not think "ALUC''s detertninatton would change. t Commissioner Mooney askecl`:f the Uoundary of the Open Space was determi�ied by the sound line? , 4 ! } Mr Sanders" said it appears to coincide V'vith the nose line on the map. He saidprotection of the airponja important, Ivtr >1vlcCabe said i`he legal question,. is hove ALUC mates it deterrninatiorii He said.the Public I Utilities Code states wl en findings, are, made overrulig7 - AM , they must be 'specific, but does 'not address ltow ALU C makes its determination. l' 1 J Mrs Sanders,noted a letter subitiittecl from the City of Cl ico Airport Conunission aslciiig that this application be denied.' The hearing was opened to `the pu'o1c, " George kam.,mei.er, representing,fhe Stephens; said he did no't thbtk anything would be sexved by sending this back to At or`to continue it::He asked the Commission to make a decision today: He said ALUC does not "want to approve residential deveiopnieni hi this area, hie 4Plieved the analysis In its 'letter is sound, He said he took pains 'to work with `Planning staff to make this proposal,, consistent with the opgrati6h, of the airport. He asked for support and, a recommendations for�approval to the Board, Norm Rosene; lives "two miles north of the airport; said lie is a pilot and an alternate on ALUC. No, said he was there as a supporter of the airport. Airport is' important to ilte County He said safety is the issue and tk at all t'atal crashes have been in the "pi" flight zones. He said this property" is one of the -busiest over dight zoites iiiAller Cori'nty. He rliscussecl-airport noise, He objected to the proposed increase of uensity near the o port. He did not :think the Stephenswei`e treated unfairly; i r Brian baldiidge reside of the ;blorth Valley Pilot's Association, said he was concerned with enc oacltment. near Ilio airport, : Bneroachirient is the number one zeasorr for the loss of airports .He ` discussed ,general aviators and the needs �tley serve..He said they heed to protect transportation utf asfructizre., � e said that this proposal, should be denied, 7eNemy Kenyon, pilot, said if development is' but in this location, it will be harmfu to the ;City of Choo He We 986 the different businesses;'that use the; airpor4. _t I Ivlr, .ICaritmerex"said lie is not insensitive to the aiipert, He ;said he has worked ;closely with :staff on safety and noise concerns, YIe said. ;3 out of 4" crashes are in the app oacI zoites and tion in 'the ove fligltt'zones. He said they db not wanf'to change the 1.03 acres of O' en "S ace: 1Ie a reed with p P $ the,6conditions from ALUC regarding noise and safety. 1, lY1r.',Sanders said the ALUC flight track shows light traffic oyer the residential area,I , IVIn: anurierer said the bombers go overthe open space flight iracic uttc County Plannitig CopttnX s"OH Minutes -FO rd, 12, .19 8 I:: P,Age 4 b l� 'it! ( i -5� lfa,� `y:'l p FYlf Yl 11>�A � 11 iPili �IYS fUi le /T YS 9 JI•:vy,.t F�i Y'!. >I �I':, 'i'�'� P Y t+f h r ! rF ' Use `' ,f .•R° FSIr«q `�� 441Ci h h „f �' «r� Y'{ : y�Ati : y y `xJF iW' Mk �X :y Ys! t ,p,,�• Ir, !4 1 C .t � 2 i h�t � • a,.. ' •'•.d` Zy '-�" a, "Y��1...��lrr Y f 4 .' .dye .lu v. L.f.'A if {. i .N Y^ 44ri"` ., t � �f„Sy ��', T r = q T ;YY• c11 i4rX',M+3L« r,.'Fwp �' �+d�diJ n +ii ,., n - &i!1 _ d •n�ti ttk" l ' o! '4j Mt. Sanders pointed, otzt.th'at flight tracks are cgiiceptual. i The hearing wad closed.. Chain ian Lambext'asked if this could go to 'ALUC at thexi next weeks meeting? Mi: Lucas C',cmiixssioner'Leland saidhis inclination is to refect this project. He said a`lot of`comProinises and i a lx coirirnunity work vweiit.in the Nt,SP, He did not ell was unfair to thepp cant. Conunissioner'Nelscn said the should re ect this ro osal or work symething out, He said, based Y j p. 1� i r, on the"iiifoxmation they have, he, is willing to deny this pz`ojecf: it was moved by Commissioner Leland, seconded by Coirunlssioner'Nelsoii, and carried to deny this application "irt its entirety by the lollowig vote: G! ACES:. Coinrnissioriers Leland, Gage; Nelson, and Cliairnan Lanbe'rt 1; 140 11, Co"ri?missioner Mooney,', rTo one ABSTAINED No one findings denial based on the concerns from ALUC and the City GoTruntssiorier Nelsoil'suggested .for of Chico -i", The notion;;was'carried without findings. } Charman Lambert asked if the Cornmissioii°wanted to continue Central Buttes to 1;3Q because the meeting ,vas xunnitg late; IVIr. Sanders card the coiriments v�ould' b' ori the Rdspoilse,to Comin6nts document only, Tt was moi�ed by ComiYaiSsiorier Leland; seconded by' Corrimissianer Cage, and tuianimously carried to move this,rneeting to 1:30 p.m, today. _ *A Roberta Kirschner proposed a ative.. cclaration Wr mitigation rrteastares regardxrig 77 enyronmeiital impacts, and, °kClse Pexmit",to operate tl'e $ary R. Kirschner Wildlife , Foundation : an edttcatianal: ngts profit zoo :for the, keepi ig of tarp" 1, s {cot gar leopard, '' lion, tiger; lynx) and other exottc� animals on pt'opeity-zoiaed A 10 `(A ricultural 10 acre I B�*wQe Cdunty 1'lar[ning GommISSO i Minutes - f ebruAty ,'2� 1998 r:: Page 5 I] A r+ I Fd r 1, ! 0,1;1' 'i. tai '11 M d�s v.; n, 1 i�,� ( d y �@ 1, r'• bl.pp r 'w S,IW u a �.�' ,4 77 i u r i Section 1: EnvironmentalFAn ings. A. Aixmtial Stud was con feted in coni fiance with. � ' Y . � � the California Environmental Quality Act ! ,p.: identifying p+Stentially signifcant en�irozimerz'tal effects that the project may liave,, i { t Provisions and the design ofal e project.and the conditions added to the„prgject'will mitigate such effects to. a'level of insig ruticance r B The;design of the proposed project iiiiproYements will not cause: environmental damage to fish; avid wildlife , or their _habitat, and a ,de minimus exeznp_tion to the. collection of ' 'bepartrr�ent of Fish and 'Game'Enviro unIF ei�tal Filing Fecs is: recommended; aizd C. The' Flammng Commission has indepentleri'tly reviewed, analyzed, and considered 'the; proposed Negative Declaration With mitigation measures prior to, ilalcing its cieczsion on the project, aiid the Negative Declaration reflects the independent judgement ofutte Comity; {:and!r j : Section 2; Zopnng Ordinance V dings. A. Tlie ro used use of the prope will not im air'tlie ince ri and 'character of the 'zone in p p ... p, p p g tY which the and lies and: that .tlie, use vyould not 1�e unreasonably hicompat ble with, or .inju'r„ious to, surrounding property; or;detrimental to the hbalth, safety and gen oral vVelfare ' bf the persons residing or working in the neighborhood, or to the general :Health; welfare and safey Y o f the Count Uecause,. 1. The character of#lie area is agricultural residential and rural residential; and i 2 The A-.10 zonng;oftlte propertyand the size_ofthe;property allows, a,grioultarat uses,.` including the beeping of large animals; and 3. The physical Cliaracteiistics of the site including available parjciig, access, sewage dispasat;'asid water availability will accommodate Ih6 proposed use; 4; e number of'veliicle; trips' generated by 'the proposed use is consistent with a ? residentiat area; And 5, Taae;operating hours of the proposed.'non-profit educational exotic nni nal zoo are ' compatible with residential uses; and • Vf Conditions have Ueen ro osed. that'wih redo ce not , , p . p se, odo , and fraffic;linpacts to .a less than saguificant level, and : F3 N 4' Tlae proposed project is conditionally consistent with the A7.-'10 Zoite and is a Secandaiy lJse ' iiiidex the .Orchard and'.F eld Crops G6neral Plaz land use designation; and f Section 36, Action I3itttc Ccimty I�lannm; Commission Ivtinufes Hebruary 12, 1998 'I pae9CI i.. �, .... .. . A', ,.:4`.+., AYE ..6 neif,.fh brjyRIX1JM1i3YLf�:'n.f"rt1Y C.r...rYsn r! s'vt•,..�.:4..xa�0.u......ve......n.ur..M usl.uew...�u,...�._�.. i4 �= ��ax 7,i7 It is reguest.d that public' initiated presentations; be limited to..a m0lmutn of 5minutes so that al interested parties Will . have ari opportiinity.to address the Commission. FollniNing'your presentation,p ease print your name and address;omt ; 1 t` the speakers sheet so , at,the record will be accurate, The oCuunty staff is indicated below. Xt is only a recommendation and has not yet been considered recotnmeridation by thePlanning Commission, 'Copies of the'StaffReport are available;at We Planning Division Office. A, Denied F , ;jaiGeorgi rnerer a re a tati e - proposed Neeati�e ec g rati'ot witlm rrlitigatior.' measures regarding; erivii'onmental Impacts and an amendrlxen� tb `the Nola} Chico Specific PI " to .change the land use designation on r SII-1.(S'uburban Residential; -1 °acre minimum), SR 1/OS (Suburban' ; „ 23,0 acres; from Residential - 1, acre patcels/Upon Space), arld OS', (Open: Space) to either�SR-1/PD '3 (uburbari Residential 1 acre'minimumlPlarmed Development) and QS/PD (Open Space/Planned Develgpment) or 1VI=1 (Light Industrial) on,property located on the ' west side of Hleks, Lane, approximately" Vz to i mile south of Keefer Lane, identified as1.PN 047=2-`141, north of?ChiGo (CS) (GPA97-02) ; l i3. Approyec with ;changes in •coniditions 9:06 m. RoberEa Kll schner . -proposed �1e tive ' Declaration- with mitigation measures 't regarding envirolniental impacts and 'U e drift to operate the BarryR Kirschner Wildlife Foundatiari an edtcatiional non-profit zoo, £r the peeping of large cats (cougar, leopard lion, tiger, Ijnx) and other exotic animals on property zoned A=10' (agricultural -.10 acre;parcels)located at 1843 Laura Lane,, south of Durham Park, approximately d;00 feet west"c f Lott Road,, identified as APN 040-260- - 72, Durham:. _ (DD) (UP 98-09) (VIDEO), C: Co.ntiduled Response to Comments 6cumeait ;d�Open" fox'Fish and Gauge. Only, to larch I4 1998, end Publish for General,, lan ,Category and Ameaidment 1VIarch 12 r; t00, At'900 Am. I 10:30 a,m- K H 1•Iafmann = `The ;Response to Coi�►ments document for the Final Envtroninenfal Tlxlpact Report for the Central Butte County.Geheral Plan Amendment y (File GPA 96-04) has been completed and is available fol public review The project�M includes a General Plan Amendment to ainelid the County General Plan Land Use t 'g g Open Land, Orchard &Field Crop, and Industrial, o desi nation ftO0, Gratin " &' 'of ilx ; fti Agricultural Preserve/I'lanned Contliunitq for{ dpproxirriately '1$$000; acres land: s The project alio includes ainend'vng a portian.of the Durham -Dayton Nelson Area ` Plan" The project site: i8 generally bound by Neal Road' on the, north, Williams Road (west of Butte College) on the east,SR ,149 on the south and includes properties on, the: west side, of. SR 99, south of.Durh'am, Dayton Highway. ANNI%iG COMIvII�SION (i AC1'lON AGENDA Q FEBRUARY 12, `1998: ' ew sf n UI r rh s,,,, a provide �'ffiel the he i gom ursdqy�.,,anuar3 ( 2 2 1999- el to Planning. , esplo'n-se- 6, ommep -doc W! fed , eFinal s on raft h ,R Environmental Yriipact Repoj:jh6,pu;pqg6:oftfi&heangisjohave the' consultant j*o e, e cumentto lme Pianning.Commission and "toexplain .its ro ein the CEQ&proce5s p6lidhearing, willbeheld huisd e ruary42 '1998 at Whkh ,f1. '. time; ,the �P1ait ig, conxmpipp�wvinghdd4h�6"PQ to review-and ananalyzof e_ 'm._�.m,is " the . evaluate -the document .yi IInakeladet'Ormnalon as! to the., adequacy ResponsefecommerOdtion,for certification ofthe-fina nvirohe6tal fpact epof:t6,th6Boardof, Supervisors. (GPA96'04) Con inueoppAJrqnhaJanuary 22 198) _v , - GE E BUSIN998ThO the a is oy i ized by' P1annipgz6mm Joh I ' and'Plh xg rpn items interest; ussionjorJ ews�ovhich s has bed � : , irected"to. ,d6research' and brh4,bdqk tothe CohnlsSioh,ROMA B & C' tqlube ' ddrese t will'always be& d as,�Otqfthe agenda. , '. AGeneral Plai/Zoning0rdinance Update - E. Legislative, ase Law Update , , q C. la Commission Conceals x ADJPURN9E - ,KAAGE DAS\I_n98.ACI K 41 JL j Y"12" 199 �,O� CoI�"ISSIQI�,, 0 AMQ�N: tl4r* 0 FEBR . A 'G -iT' I 'T` m � 3� !� \� 6�� �� .� « ,� � � � f' »� y ,y Y t ;.� ++w �l,� ! �r;h n?Yr � F;r � ��z-�°$ 7M �,y"4'� �,(`� ��� c q'.i nY '�"�'e t .. ���� �.. "�p1A y. 1 .T� X � aC x��. � xw'4^�& n flA4 "y I � w �. ° � � .+e . � raw � Y.�7149�a ��>. � � A,. W r m � k �� `�_ ,� �, A 1 y f2 � �xL 3a °'� ,b, . r �� FX �] � �� I. ' V ) b 1 A t .•V . 1ar+us33.taaa:�Nneux-,cc ,+.awu...wo,•�.:•..-•Fn. - - art h11'`�sa'iS'SGF.rr'i�ir�!Yr1Y. SL«ti�i+4wYWaiX;:1:;. Ms .,.e.askFaa .Jvtu'.aFr. l .: :, yJ 3 Yti� tfiY f - r • V d Chairman La�rnbert asked:oh Page 244 Alternative 2 regarding devel tipment ,on the, east sidedevelopment is nat allowed on the west side, will the acreage be di�ded:.to the east{,! ,if side to compe.nsate� ;• �; allowed on the west side, the bubble needs to hilt Mr. Meyer said if development is not on the east side. He not �bb ieve they need more area. He •said the project can be' .does accomrrioda, ed,with. the acreage .on the east side as Chairman Lambert asked if he wastalk'ing about acreage,Or density? .- PJIr: Meyer said it could be `a combination` of both. H6" there should be sufficient y eon acreage on the east side'to absorb an loss"of°acreag„ the west side. Mr, Parilo said. the Commission niay" take comments today, .but 'the action on the. �i VAP -` Fi i docurrients will, be taken on February 12 ' 1998° " a B'oatwn ht acid this is tl%e fourth meeting. He did not want the hearing extended any, D, n, g further.; He said 'they havo" refined the "project, restricting; if to 3 million square feet to reduce impacts on roads. Limiting "1/3 of the residential development to senior citizens ana{ to 'redu,ce school {mpacts..He said they are co.mrnitted to having:' school facilities built tile-developer"s ex ense?Ot the time they:are needed: Commissioner Cage asked if here was any'organizat'ion of "the land owners who. Willhave a say where the different land uses will occur?, Mrs Boatwright said yes, they have met several tlrrmes. He'disagreed wifih the bEIR "and' Cpl='s need for new personnel is overstated,: =0'ne. station only "is needed. Sheriff's said need one new substation is `alright, but 1 new deputies patrolling, is overstated as it "for applies to this project. `The air, pollution'control measures should,=be the same as fnr any 'is ' other pro1ect. On the TID response , Butte b -910 ground water model misguided>to be used for where wells oould be located. Commissioner Mooney said that: part of the industrial land fill issue has to consider + reoycl{ng- • , Mr, "Boatwright aid it has not been included, in the project description;, but he ,had no, problem' Ith adding'recycl ng. ' Nora Burnham asked that "th, e.Commission not be pressure by. Mr. Boatwright to rush this process, Rico Gtaneo;,who lives m the butteollego, area, asked if <the comments will be done oh ' i' " February' 12, 1998? s Chairman .Lambert said"y68:6! the environmental document, but the project can be as commented on t subsequent meeting. r^ ,. M " ,.c Butte CoUht" Planking Commission Minutes -.January 22, 1998. o Page 12' 1 , i;3u11p1,5D.f Milia.�A4?iJiW:°151AJitiVky�.1d;LW.4+&+Sti..3d#4L4a'iF..«rl�tuw..tt� '�^T"^.?r^ —' - ,�,tJj aI�,, y y �c �'of the one take ar e n. w' e would like to e meetmgto' ' Commissioner IJelsan, said litak o category and project, Mr,'; E3oatwri ht said that, conceptually they have enough information on the EIR to "make g a decision': They should be'ablo to make a decision an the project of the February �2th meeting. is process should be thought out carefuli . One Commissioner Nelson sa*d th.. " y more month'; s., or»two to rgceive the Fiscal Analysis is, practical, Chairman Lambertsaid theyneed the information'requested to make an'informed decision:. Linda Co[o,.who lives m the Cherokee 1Natershed .area, encouraged the Planning Commission. to ,consider tha',General Plan category first. She said they need the Fiscal ;. `Analysis, l Jan `H 61man`a�+reed with the need for the Fiscal Analysis. She said'there has not been enough time spent on these ,hearings yet She:l.noted'that thero has been no one m, favor of this'projOct at these,hearings: ,She encouraged a night -meeting.. " Rico Cuneo said he supports, the, 2 issues being ''discussed separately and said the , Commission should take as much'time as they need': ,. Mr. Parilo said they need to consiclar creating'a GP categoryto accommodate this type of development first: Fie said there; are separate policy questions on creating a new, L P' date o rY� .g It was moved .by Commissioner Nelson; 'seconded by CarrimISSlon"er Mooney, and to tentatively set. March` �2, 1998; for the whole, day for the new i unan'hi" usly carried category and project: Theywill hear, on P6bruaryI2thlftheOfjfmation is ready nr not, l No :other `,hearings to be schedule. on March 12, 1998. X. GENET AL OUSINtSS Tlils seatlon ofth6 agenda;is t6 be' utlllze' by ih'ePlannirlg Cominlssion` and Plahn►'ng Man. ager on items of interest{: general discussion, or items far which ' -staff has been ' directed to do,rese'ar."ch and bring back to the Cainm►`sslort, ''Items A, '6, & G May.�nD always bei . y listed as part of the agenda. ' a0essed'at every hearin but will alwa s be g �,. i A. . General Plan/'Zoning Ordinance' Update' Legislative Case Law Update. Planning 'Commission "Concerns' the restoration of%a,'�r 1. Request for an extensib,n` of Gime limits .for nonconforming structure; for Jess Brasier ori APN 036.191=077, located at2b'Rlelsier Place., 01 16 Handled earlier in the meeting~ r 1 Butte County Planrnng Commission Minutes January 22, 998 C1 Page 14 °D ' 1, , I' Owl T,16,C 'h 6i*�W#lLt'isk�Llf'einy,ddint�ist,id,herort-�em.l�Lor, f thelpublic A , e �que� 1000 may be k q 0'6 e .0 # any QMl OWL - P. 'D. U T 5 A' Y NATURAL' W A L,,;!,.,W, A, L T�H ��A,N' L A NP' Q iR IIry PLANNINGDIVIISION ;fD EV 0F DEPARTMENT tLoPMENT'SERVICES COUNT OROVILLEo CALIFORNIA26M430 CENTER 7 q "ONE. The"Waing,wil[b dponec to the pub, for VTELEPH (616) 538-7601 T LIC HE h6, public ad Cussion IX:;,PUB -g W closed p JjCL 0 1SL A (9I 6) $38.770 FAX: F til OMM SSION -B'U: TTE''Aft'OUN T Y;,PLANNINO C Yi i BUTTS COUNTY 'PL IN lON C1 'AGENDA 0JANUARY Y 2 z toggn AG EN A jgflmy, 22M 19'3 t.N y� ZT. TZ :q,a ,0 '0 11 T P LACE: -B ard of Supervisors' QQM Q - County Admill'81ration Cehte,r,, 'Couhty Centor,000� oroville'l, QA 95966' LLEGIANCO PLEDGE OF A, d Chairman it, .... age. Lela di Mooney,ah�La. ir,b ' e �:Corntylissp,nd' Nelson, C n RQLL 6ALL rs SELECTION -Selection of Charman; Vice Chairman, a80c.0hd Vice Chairman fdr j,9 6 Committee o thO, 0 t R6VjeW AP P, INTME.,. T1,` - ApOpin ointment t A� staff ! e additionsiI, ACCEPTANCE' 04.06m,ii mb&s; and sa, May request -nis�sion rne ACC V. deletions or changes in th6,Agen6 ordle i 0 - foe eipemb-0 11 1997.D VI, MINUTES APP,e V0:J6f:tp0 minutes. a im-onewtoh These items are c 0s06fed n.s'e j itemst for viti CONSENTI ' I 'I� non-controversial. Wpresentations !,b& made,. h Over, some questions. may be X- it 6 nQ16hf item6itemfor discu ssipn, v - A , e �que� 1000 may be k q 0'6 e .0 # any QMl - P. 'T �ALREA Y 0 THE 'END A FLOOR'"'ON ITEMS, NO, it , 1NESS1rfROiV[,:'THe" -;from taking " C;!, : 4qoh prohibited y gqt,� Law VIlL,, BUSINESS 1, 'in b tedb The -Planning', qrnmi� Js {Presentations-�0/ bo, 11trited to five i nthe ' Dm presented Ifi j4 not )1Agenda) on any, item action The"Waing,wil[b dponec to the pub, for T LIC HE h6, public ad Cussion IX:;,PUB -g W closed p JjCL 0 1SL h W111L pOOOWS, comments, roij s, T� P. " L "t OrM d... the h6 h -donfjhe� to 70Conjn��$ on�'�� :PL nf�n,!SLS16;1,1'Will� Yi i BUTTS COUNTY 'PL IN lON C1 'AGENDA 0JANUARY Y 2 z toggn t.N . . . . . . . . . . . . . ZT. TZ T N �P (1 10 t:-s'so"th6t'alj ifitere'sted., I- i, ie d Pr, iatjons,:b,6 lim awipAtIdmo, Mlnue. d't Oblid, hl ia psertl lt6d' 0, y. 1 to 6ig(jpstea atpi t ppase prin ,,,yo P pbrtuhity. p,80dros§;t �:qdh7thlstlon. Foll6wingy p t u bp . -6. 1. - ''ovares6n,,, , '96 . , �'l Ura 0 J, t� rd:W#i`b t tic address dh; the speakers shQOsp that th6l:. W cl pme, an a ress d n tion -t is only d)"not been T)6 recommendation, ion, o t 8 indicated belov�i��'lt o, recomme -d t- ftbttnty�s 0 1., "I fi DIV s jotq� opt esI., o, available jt,th6PlOpnjpq. Iston icons ld&ed,,by�:the 06hhing co, M", mip R '0 Ipfflce 0" -'A taff dq lo. ppr :. t C -d'L6r'ri Tp�b�� (lte0h,,detL' mine q ca,egorloq 00 exemptfrom i,p d' Gr. . . . . . a. M, r.edory'an environmental Mal to 41 owl El permanent second A W), wir, en, Je on ohs of BO County Section 24=250, if der Od el dwelling u hi un ropOrt'ytbhe 4M�26Tihber- Mb:unt8dh acre parcels), els),Iodated 6h,the O, west slde ofRIMtt,P6hch.jRop j app' inMely3/4mile norih,oustato r f O-360-011 6 i&046"F&6si R;�nch R68lO,,Jo. d6ntMed,'AP Vli ' Forest Rgric :(MQPW 3), -k �6 d Approval Recommendation Von ' Staff R0,60Mm