Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES & AGENDAS 10-24-79 -- 12-12-79
0 , BU" TJI COTINTY PLANNING ' COMMT SSIJN MINU')'BS October 24t 197,E �; ���?���[�r�i�d�i}i 41�' AJd1�J�l7,LAN1rJ3 � r •9 �' .4, ,� a.-.. �, .�,r, ,° e; .'� I ' . CtO I,1, CALL: Project Commissi,oner,s Ciloert, Lambert, Kennett Max and Chairman Wheeler Absent: No one; Present: Larry Brooks, Planner III; i:arl Nelson, 'Environ- mental Dir ector ; Laura Ursenyy Chico: Fn,terprise Rocord, and Hazel Dallas- Seovetafry 11 APP tnV 1 , " NITNUTHS Minutes f'or � � � �� * � . "Shirley" Y,,Yar d with the �Coi.loruizy); t%orx�ection Minutes CCwLgi�ei' 1�' �rerc al}prove "Beverley":. ; Page 6 -'Lthe 11 `6han e Shxrl , to Minutes for October 17 Iverc approved as submitted. TV : CONT-INUEU FROM April 21,__1979-.' PUBLIC HEAPING A TO CON81 DBR MOUI P 1 CAT ION OR REVOCATION OF USE PERMIT J x; hielvira Sparks Us 'permit to allow a, second -handl pants store on property zoned "CW1" (Light Commercial) located on the east side of Lincoln Blvd., appro.imately 1/4 Mi.le: south of Kusel Road, identified as AP 36-202.43 and 44, south 6P Oroville n Mr, Brooks reV oiged a: womoranclum :from 'Vii;ge Anzalone, Zoning Inyestigato' dated ;Octobar 24,, copies of ivhicir had been furnished the Gomm ssiQngrs Melvin'Sparks, 5319 Lincoln Blvd. said that he did gxot have tho money to do what he pi•omi.sed, to do duo to a death in the Family and a serious ac-. cident Which his iviEe sur-fered. several .months ago and that lie perhaps ;would have td go out of business at this ti ae, Opponents: No one. Tho hoaririg was r lased Commissi.onrr (;i;lbert mado a mot'on. for Conti:ltui,j jt ' to 5 mog1fh$ (Aprii 25) from trnight to give tho applicant anothor to 0-lect his building. C.ommissionar ilenne•tt commenting that compa.ssiov is a co4mo4ity in, human affairs t1iAt: vvo do not have omigh o�T." and secaaided the mati,on�. AY St Commiss,ionors Beginett, Gilbort, Mage and Lambert. h! 0 , BU" TJI COTINTY PLANNING ' COMMT SSIJN MINU')'BS October 24t 197,E �; ���?���[�r�i�d�i}i 41�' AJd1�J�l7,LAN1rJ3 � r •9 �' .4, ,� a.-.. �, .�,r, ,° e; .'� I ' . CtO I,1, CALL: Project Commissi,oner,s Ciloert, Lambert, Kennett Max and Chairman Wheeler Absent: No one; Present: Larry Brooks, Planner III; i:arl Nelson, 'Environ- mental Dir ector ; Laura Ursenyy Chico: Fn,terprise Rocord, and Hazel Dallas- Seovetafry 11 APP tnV 1 , " NITNUTHS Minutes f'or � � � �� * � . "Shirley" Y,,Yar d with the �Coi.loruizy); t%orx�ection Minutes CCwLgi�ei' 1�' �rerc al}prove "Beverley":. ; Page 6 -'Lthe 11 `6han e Shxrl , to Minutes for October 17 Iverc approved as submitted. TV : CONT-INUEU FROM April 21,__1979-.' PUBLIC HEAPING A TO CON81 DBR MOUI P 1 CAT ION OR REVOCATION OF USE PERMIT J x; hielvira Sparks Us 'permit to allow a, second -handl pants store on property zoned "CW1" (Light Commercial) located on the east side of Lincoln Blvd., appro.imately 1/4 Mi.le: south of Kusel Road, identified as AP 36-202.43 and 44, south 6P Oroville n Mr, Brooks reV oiged a: womoranclum :from 'Vii;ge Anzalone, Zoning Inyestigato' dated ;Octobar 24,, copies of ivhicir had been furnished the Gomm ssiQngrs Melvin'Sparks, 5319 Lincoln Blvd. said that he did gxot have tho money to do what he pi•omi.sed, to do duo to a death in the Family and a serious ac-. cident Which his iviEe sur-fered. several .months ago and that lie perhaps ;would have td go out of business at this ti ae, Opponents: No one. Tho hoaririg was r lased Commissi.onrr (;i;lbert mado a mot'on. for Conti:ltui,j jt ' to 5 mog1fh$ (Aprii 25) from trnight to give tho applicant anothor to 0-lect his building. C.ommissionar ilenne•tt commenting that compa.ssiov is a co4mo4ity in, human affairs t1iAt: vvo do not have omigh o�T." and secaaided the mati,on�. AY St Commiss,ionors Beginett, Gilbort, Mage and Lambert. 't 13L1"I'TE COUNTY E},t1NNING (' OMMIS8lC N M7'NUTM5 0Ct0I)QIr 247 197q Chh. ie as n . n6tk i„t} t c0Mpas1:6W but t',hat .1b, dia It`av�.e a cot that , ,Whefler pxef; comm . ` r ”"no'" irate r�ra.t}a t}�o }abou-s�:o p�,i.�-tn iouwi.th tst�a:blis'liac} procedures a"nd oation'n .. ,, � ,� � regulations . ABSIINT No 'one, Motion carried. J11 . EC1bhTC HpARiNG CON'l"Nf7ED "F.OM SI;PI�EMp}t 2$> R, Terry }3arnes' - Rczone from "A-211 (General) to "T�t-J.Q'" anid (79-llty "TM"'„0''" (Timber Mountain - 10 and 20 acre parcels) bn pra icrty lncaticl on .both sires G;f Ponderosa Ways, approxi- 1 matolyi 2 miles south t5 f : Kalil Rac}:, Road i , identilfiecl as Apr 71-02w272n,mo °e particularly clescri.beci as TM -10 4 The S 1%2 of the N 1/2 incl the NE 1/4. of the NE of sec M 11 T2QN rsM TIi� 2 0; The N1/2 of , 1th�a VW1,/4 an.a the h11V 1/4 0£ the, NE of Sec .. 114 T2nN Mt. NIM7M. All dontuin inA 33p.7) acres, iolre or less, novthoost of frou l].e 80-22 2,�z9S r H � Mx. Brooks again read :staff finc Ings ancJ added t�a.t tJ e , , iixc,:,}Yorks Dep- Rrtiiiont had commentod that all roads in this area, are sul stdndaird,. hart. Nelson call.(d attenti.ori to 0 letter from the applicant; dated August 7; 1979 'ft uestirig' that 10 -acre parcels we -to .'requested, for the aa.rger ht his department arra is remote a.ndns .l added. . t ess portionr ,o.f thttr 4rea and 20L 0111 on the s.tee pert ottio . lie added his rtrnent rocagni:�e5 that the � rr�� ative inaccessible but the par*cel,s c -e iar`go nasug,} so that imp,adts wi-11 not bo.slgnificant. r 1idb0rt 4d9k, y 305 Nilldal.e Avec represonting the app7I,ia4nt, suggatted t}gat this project be ho�id in abeyatiee uftt .l, after the submxssi.oti of .tire proposed p yr }I , a p ro osed sut�cl:i.v`�.sori ata l� t}rr. a � ��.ieant and the ma can be studied. A lottor, dated October 1:9 1979, from Itobort, and Audrey t. Gilbert and Jon and, Jurib 1C6chbl in opj�bsitiort to this project was road. Robert 8 , Cllialc} Rock, commented that .the area. developed in Section 12 w, tiotua'li a tto �r ea anYl a sox �rd,5,sod, grave cottce�rns: c�nncernin g. availability of watt stn f.}ie a ea,p, even for parcols already developed# }{eciri''r; no voice to t Iirr cetttr6ry;17ai rr1n jt1}1oole-r cotlt;i.nuod this pro j el4t OP}�N until the iitoeting of Docombor 5, 1911-1. BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING GOMNITSSION MTNOITES Octolz^r 24, .1979 'h; PIIBLIC HEARINGS NEW REGARDIM E R?SAIqfi OAT MAT 3 . �2itf�flkd�4�"!Atfieiw twdoI1 A. Schott - Rezone "from ►'A.2 Ltd.'If and rig,.11e (Dangle Pamily nesidonti;al) to "C-2►1 (General t'ommet^cial Property locate' on tl,e gest side of Lucky John Road, aprroximatel.y , 400 feet notth of Skyway, identified a;> A'P 52-012-52 (portion) more particularly described as Beginning, at a point on the west line of Secy T22N Ut JjDB&M located 1724.2 ftp. distant froml$ the NE 1/4 of said Sec.. 15 thence N 00 10, F 5G�6 ft thence IV a° thence S 06 041 W 431,E q Y thence E 171.94 ft. thence S 01, a.0' 11 146,8$ ft,; thence N S2° 3$ ► to 18.02 ft to the point of beginning. Excepting therefrom ,al.l. that Property located within, 550 ft. of the c4tr•Cerline of Skyway, Contai'n0.00 acres) more or less, Paradise, 80•-22-2»55 Staff findings were read by arrynraoks. NO. also call.ed' the attention of the Commissioners. to 5- 7a o petition signed by22 Togidents of the area. in opposition 1.6, ,this project,. (Copies of this ,document had been sent to the Commi,ss.toners and it was ;lot roa&'6t this time, Mr. Nelson said tliat his departincitt's 'main concern was porhaps. a Lack of compatibility of this ; 16'rojeet �,�iCit the surrounding area) and added that the. relatively snt411 size ox this parcel wcuid make the impact insignificant) in their opinion, Proponents; Rudolf A� Schott,' 50"52 Almond Avenue, Paracli'seo said (712) that he piaritucl tohaste 0 units on the parcel., but nothing commercial. Opponents Gete.Ilavis, 556 llocvG ,Avonuo, presented a serles of photographs of this gron acid the surrounding area, ad' lig that there is a mobile home park to the;' east,' to the west a cafe and to 'tho �or`tY2oast �illothor mobile home park- -the' combin4ti6t of wJjje.. l tnalcds an intolerable tilafCic situation at prosent.. Mrs. door"t,(, Davi s, 8501401irc, eyIstessed concern that the present owner might dispose rif t io property to I someoild Who ,would. ddVol.op cor6ldrrc .ally. She wa:s also 6011COTned about drainnge imd potential odors front attellpted sewage dispos Al' Constance I#dmtiticls', 02110 Li :ky John Road, co�pla.inbd �tha.t spveral times recontl�,,s�lxe way unable to get off of Lucky John Road .utliuse of traffic situations y haul. Weaver, f)20,4 LltClcy J'olta said (278) �;h:�u t'� traffic. on Lucky John—particularly at the and where the cafe is��is a ter�``fbl.+s mess. ' lti i -a !I COUNTY PLANNING COA1A9xSS fON NITNUTPS - October 24, 1,979 The hearing was closed. Motion was made by (,1otalmiss'Once pldx soconded t Commissioner Betnett, to deny this project_-expressijI �txcernr' a))OUt thy. pr�,l�le�as J II- ,. wauid have,,,, on this 1»9 acre's AYTiS 1 or ma ss a enaz�s Gilbert, Lambert,, Bennett, Mal" pa1�. �ha� rman 1 . `. tV)xeQl,er. , ABSENT No one Motion carried, 1t was rated that this clecisloll could 1)e appealed to tile Board of Super- Visors, Rudy Jensen, ETAL - Rezone from 11A-2 ,Ltd." and "A- (Agricultural Residential.) to"SIS - 1/2" (Suburban,Residential - 1/2 acre parceis)property located on the south side of Pearson Road, approximately 600 feet ~gest of Pentt Magalia Highway, and 'on both, sides of Stearns Road, more particularly described as Beginning at the W 1/4 of Section lD, T22N", R41 z I thence following along the centerline of Pe'ar�°ori' Rd. easterly, rar 2,1.50 ft.,more or'l.ess t6 the centerline of Rockford Lane; thence southuresterly► along the centerline of Rockford lane for 210 ft, to the N line of Lot 10 as shmshi on the map of Jhd � Revised Stearns Tract; thence a;tong said 14 lipid bf" Lot 10, westerly for S70 ft, to the centerline of Stearns, Rd.; thence southerly along the ceilt l,Yerl.ine of 8tea,rns Rd. for 2�O fit+; thence easte for 5 1 ft.; thence southerly fc�r 246 ft. to the N line of Drendel Subdivision; hence along the N line o,c the said 1�rendel SubdivasaorU westerly for 55 ftp to tho NW corner of said I rendel Subdivision; thenoe follow- 1n,g along, westerly bou#idary line ,of said lrendel 5 tb- clati►xsion, sotatherly for 420 ft, to the northetly. boundary of Sobrante Park Subdivision; thence followin' -9,, along said northerly boundary of Sobrante park Sub - 1 vision, westerly for 642 ft. to the, cemerllne of Stearns Rd.' thence folio rin' along the cento rl,ine of y . Stearns Rd � � soatherl, for 1 2�b ft to the soultherl�� boundary hire of said Sec, 19, Thence fallowing along said southerly* boundary ln:a of Sec. 100 teste,riy for '875 ft,, to the 8W corner of said Sec-� 19; thence C along the wasterl.y boundary Line of sala Sec' 19y � 4,. MIMI COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MTNUTl,S - October 24, 1973 northerly for 1,324 ft. to the SE corner of the DIE 1/4 of the SSE 1./4 of Sec. 24, T22N, . NE 1,/4 of the SE 1/4 of Sec. 24, westundarlerly for,, 66.3 ft, to the S11 corner of the SP 1/4 of tkie NP 1/4 of the SE 1/4 quarter of Sec. 24; thence fOl1Ow4n9 ,, P�lonft the westcrIv boundary line of said SE 1/4 of• tbo- Nh 1/4 of the SE x/4_0 northerly' for_ ,61.8 ft. to the SIS' corner of Parcel 2 as shown on that certain Parcel map filed in 'Rook 67 of Parcel Mails at Pago 44 thence following along the southerly boundary line of 'suite parcel ', easterly for 322 ftt, to the SE corner, or Said Parcc. 1' 2; thence following along the easterly 'bo°unaary line of saiO Parcel, 2, north- erly for 707 ft, to the centerline' Of Pear: on Rd.; A ,thence following, along the centerline of Pearson Rd. 34 int of ' beginning, easterl fax P i)ft.o a' ' o Conta, n�n,g S acres, more of Less, Pa%adise. 5�- 23.1•.r11.4 ., Larry Brooks read: staff findings. Tile Commission agrood that this '11eatin should be postpone) as recommended by staff in the fin�iinks µt,� give the Commission t?yo benefit of the T�t�Pact JtCport required for the two ptOjectp Proposod earlior in the year i"or a. Portion of Ois area. The hearing; was oponect to the public. Dennis Coughs 1801 Stearns, Romi, staid th'Is appoa•rs to lae tlio only fair way to handle tlmso projects. q Neil. McCabo, attorney for "tho nppli(tants of the twos projocts mentioned above, was in agreement, s , y, � ed this Hearing �'� l;No�beJie�teii 1�erh2�,ol,gr9�T Cha�.xma.il 11�laet.7.er continued VI ABANDONNfriNT. A; its. E. Paco - Abandonlitont of Publie,Uti,l.i.ty nasetnont9 Paradise Bines Country Club Estates, ,Lot 85 Moti,011 was mado by Commissioner Max, socondod by Ccimmi.%sione�r., lambert, to recommend mend approval of this abandonment, AYE80 Commiasioners Gilbert, Lamborty Bennett',) Mav and C'ha.irman BUTTE COUNTY I LANNTNG CCMMXSSTON MINUTES M October 24, 3,979 NOES T Nth' onrN r i s 4 4t. N Tj� t,' N r y) v-} "�' a ✓' 0 e n r i ;. 10 ABSENT!' Motion car�'100, VTT MTScrn-TANt-OU5' ; A. ST Tt � DDi/l i, ?1MpNT PLAN ,N Jos ep i L,' t`ra.nk,, Lal 55, Skyw4y Plaza,. Aid 80-23-2-27' Motion was made'by Coinpis:l ioddd yig"4,j�nor Lamlert,, n to approve this development plan as submItted•» AY8S Commissioners Gilbert, Lambert„ Bennett, Max an, chairman Wheol.ex•, AtaENT CVO `ona Motion carried. Viii. ADD, vrnm 'A., r LAND '08P, 13LDIII:N AND LAND llSt MAG • - 80-23-2-73 Larry Brooks t oviewcd the 9-page memorandum from staf,l" to tba Ciommis s Wo dated October 1.8 1979, out liing proposed changes to the Land ttse Hlement calling parti.:ul.ar attention to Plage .1 which itcluded a request for a recommendation oty the North 1=tspl.anade lid highway :2 proposal, and the mofica.tions on the map to place property which is undoi Land, .Cons.erva- tion Agt'eement into the Orchard and Field. Crop category which had previously boon proposed for :a. commercial dosighation r Comyrt� �s toner Bennott made ti suggestion ggestitati. that the following hottsekeeping,r c`ha,nllo: a,n thtt, bniicl Use Text be lnade: y Pale 28� , Litle Clxan e Word rrcooperate" to reconsult Orchard and Field Crop category, 'Line 29., change a` e'r^a9e" to BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION HiN, n - October 24, 197 Page' 6 .,L r�G . a Delete the sentonoe " Qx�l. r ti�lC�. am'00 nts leve. en w made to the Land Tise Map since 1971. ►r Page 56,1 Lineo 16 to P-64. Delete the� lin P� Page 567 Liiie 53; add; It r . _ and 4iiicatilon of afTocted property owners " Page 57,, Line 22w. Delete the ward. "many" 'there was no formal moti.oli., hat sta-r-r was instructed to carry these Tec ommendations to the I'oard, Commissioner Bennett commented (395) that both North ;Rgpl4nade and Hilghway 32 had been heard and reheard :from :'both sides and made a motion to send the Land Use dement back to the Board with changes as recommended in the memorandum mentioned earlier$ and an;:ludi,ng North Esplanade and Highway 32 projects, Commissioner Lambert seconded the motlon (for purpose of discussion Both Commissioners Lambert and Max expressed the opinion that both North Esplanade and Highway 32 project should go back for public hearings prior to their submittal to the Board. Commissioner Lambert expressed concern that there 4 Is still no definition. 0:6 "a triable Marcel" in the Element, AYES: CominiSs'iorie-Tn Gilbert, Kennett and Chairman Wheeler, NOES: Commissioners Max and Lambert. ABSENT No one, Motion carried. `CX, k,WOURNMEN ` There being no further business) the nmedting was adjourned at 10:15 E. M. L TAPS: 8OL-22-2-01 2 -All 24-1-80 DUTTR COUNTY PLANNING CON11MISSION MT.N,!�TtS - November 71 197 1 PLEGh 011 ALL11GIANCh II, ROLL CALL: Presents Commissioners Lambert, Bennett, Max and Chairman Wheeler Absent: C6pnmis,5iQner Gilbert Also Pre5ont . ' rntrur ont, Brooks* * Pix ector111; Dick Moi car-, Ianvi.ron- Asa, Depart- mont of Public Works, Laura Urseny�, Cl�I T;ntorprise Record. and 1.1azol, Dall.a.s, secretary III'. APPROVAL ah MINUTES r i 14inutos of October 24 were zpp�roved with the f01.1011ing COrr0ct;�Pns Page 7 Line 6—Change "nodi 1 ation" to "notification" -.-change °'�2" toI'aRe 7, Line 8 PUBLIC HEARINGS I, TVt1OX WHIG- XTEGAT,I1' DECLARATION - - IT kSCAR �` tR\ T�2_ ?T4EhT�tL mP. CT S BE ��.. 1; Carrell .' Liblin - Use permit to allot" two adda.tional dwelling units (mobilo homes) on propert;r Zoned- "A-2' Ltd'" (It~;mated tenor al.) , l,ocwted on the west side of Sawitia.11 Road approxi mately 1550 foot soutll of Pearson Rcad and SaAMil.'1 �toad'intor, sect a,a`n � dents. -Ned as AP 54 192 � S . paradise. Larry Brooks read staff findings Proponents! . Garrell S. LiblIA stated that he. was fihancial.l.y untble to Comply with the proposed conditions and asked th4t is al)plication be withdrawn. Cppon.ents ; No-one The hearing was Closod. fitotjon Ivas made by Commissioner Max seconded byComm!s5i.0rte.` Lambert, to accept withdrawal of this aprilicatiOn. AYES: Commissioners Lambert, onnott, Maxo and Chairman Wheeler N013S No one. 11OUTV COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MUTES M Novembwr 7, 1979 AhStNT: Commis. ioiier' �1�. ert; Motion, carried. 2. tipper Rid& SDA Church Use permit to allow new church facility on property zort6a "vi-S" (Ti.mber=lvtourxtainS acre minimum), located on the east side, o, Skyway; approx. 1'100 feet south of Davtorl Jlbylp 'till loadas Ah 65-OP-11, south of pe 'Sal-la , S0' '24-1.449 Larry Brooks read stela fiiftdinhs, and. changed Genero.l, Plan de,� �j nation to limber Mountainous, Dick Molar t'epol ted that his department had recommended.:a. Condit" onal. Negative with Several mit.1gatior, measures. proponents: Robert lob}key, p 0 13ox 649 Magftli , Ca. stated that 'the.�plan was to . build the recreation hall :first; and it would be used as a multi purpose facility) until the sanctuary could be constructed He added that the seating capacity would be about 250: >;thal. N Mckoynolds, 17e YSabl.a, said that L she hold Lived )jozxt , doorr to this property for 5,0 years and that a chuX;,kch was needed in this neighborhood. Slid said that pjans were to do everything possible to rule this acred4t to the neighborhoods nponen't.s . No one The hearing was closed. Commissioner Max, notiri that although this project could havo a significant effect on the e,nvi.ronment, there will not be s. g P. n measutes listed below. significant xcant e1•�ect �.n tlx�.� case because n the tna.ta. ata.o ; J:. Vrosion control measures shall: be implemented. at the time old �on;5tructi.on. Al'+l gvad.ed ureas shall be Otab,:il,iseti with. Gravel. or pavoment su:vfnvi iiV7; y > porimeter "kzerm's, 1dridocapi nG, and other soil stabil..;i.,lzati,oxt toohniqu.ep. 2. Earthwowk shall be schodul od. during the non-ro.. n. r mea8on. r' s :11oaclside,'drainage ch'nxaelP •hall. be properly aonst=cted and stabilized (riprap) Drb. nage shall bo ooriveed. to a mtu al dwain,Age course 40 Prope rf' sued, and 3nntall+ed cul.vw�ts shall be placed in ; any drainage courses crossed by roads or driVdWaY04 Ji • ,y1 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINU`1'11,5 a Novembor 7, 197 al. lay . a* etaa ned W i�tkai.n the ,100- �; 0 �-1 arebetween �e � y tad bu , Lt in � d ted the d evol.capmont plan, kt y 1.9 f The Ratti Gouxa:ty Fire Depar't;m.ant-Upper Rldso;C'iCo Protection District shout, hout d be aonoul,t od conc.erni,na fire: hazards and 7 ; Tf rA% ,aro,.11neAl.ogical. sites a� otifaot;s I or subsurface Icultural o jorsts a:pe enoo.u�to;ract or i sco�rcrad, luxi.Y t de leJ,opmE�a�t o the property, a proXessi.oncil,. archaeologist sl;loul.cl be conteco�t:ect i.mmcdi•otoply to purvey the: iAnd pr:i.o to l:'u%,tb,or die°tiix0ban.ce 8.. To improvo sight distance, at the two 41gway acoess road exit :oanc:es, .some vogotat .on Lmder8row•tb* slaotll d, uo removed. made a motion that a Conditional Negative be Mod. His 'motion Was seconded by Commissioner Lambert AYES: Commissioners Max, Ls.mb r't, Bennett aid Chairman Wheeler. r., WES No one A135 N'I` 1. Col t tris $loner Gilbert Motion cattiod j 1Ic, Commissioner Max) their noting that a conditional negative is to be f=iled and finding that the d�roposed use of the property t+ti11 not impair the int6grity and character of the zone in ;which the land Iles and that the use Would not be unreasonably incontpati'h10 with, ot; i lurxous toy surrounding properties or detrimental to the health or genexdl wellAre of-,,the persons, rostdi.ng or �16rking in the . no ighbo�rhoort or to the general 1iealth� ,'wblfdrb and surety of the County, made a mota.on';for approval of the `'proj'eet subject to the folloiging conditions 1 t:hru 8 Mitigation Measures above, j e, heed to the County of Butto 40 :C=oot of rightµof-way Prom the centerline of Skyway 10. tbj,,,eel7a trmanolit solutiont ffor dtai.nage.. S�aY►mit drainage plans Ri to p �r •l s for approval and install. the required facilities. 11. A dry type fire. protection snr nitler system in the building and around the eaves of the exterior. The system mint have stxMcient water supply and he approved b registered Fire protect' Oft i engineer, This is be additio�nyto ny requirements il*Oseci t ! n IT 'BUTTL- COUNTY PLANNTNG COMMISSION MINUTE',S November 71 1079 12 PomnIV with Sbct inn. 74-�S-I e 13. Applicant mus-. also comply Ath all other appl.icable State ani -local statn ts, ordimtincos and areg,ul,ata oils.' itis motion was seconded by Com iss;.el1or Lambert, AYp Commi ssioncrs Max, Lambort, 'Bennett and Cha�i.rttrain 4111er43: 1.ex, NOES; No one. ATISM: Commissioner Gilbert, a . �a Motion. carr. ed •, T. O CONSI EP Mf1DTl='T ATION OR RE�IOCATION_ O. USE PETL4 T 1. Clinton Bpnnett, Bennett 'realty - Use permit to al.l,ota , t estate sales o Hice on property zoned "A -2 Ltd .'= I ott�.���„ s the west side of Icy►aY,approximately ,250 feet south. �^ Evergreen brave, rtentit,�crl as AP 64.66-15, T'aradas'e Larry Brooks ea.lied the attention of t1lo Commi.ssi.oners to a mwmo %; the zoning Investigator stating; tIlAt the ;Give hydrant teas not yet iiis, rld�i. , Clinton Bennett said that the County had finally succeeded in patting,; hint "out caf apera.t ion as of tonight" by their unegw-table conditions and �1 regulations and added that they might as well revoke h18 permit; it response to a question from Chairman Wheeler lie said that he had been operating for over a year at that location withc ut being in compl,ianco with the conditions of his permit. There was n(Wne else desiring to spea'le, The hearing was elosed. Commissioner Max made,a motion to rovoke the use permit under consideration ,"on tho request of Mr, Betinettla" His motion was seconded by Commissioner Lambert, AM: Vlommissione'rs lambert., MAX, Bennett and: Chairman Wheeler NOBS Nei one .AMENT Commissioner Gilbert Motibn Carried .4 BU' TL' COUNTY VLANNINC COMMiSSTON M.TNUTUIS y November 7 1979 CA"i1;GORICAI.L " "`�.�MENTAL' REVVEE �t �,. James T. C001',�. Variance to allow a carport 1 foot 4rom t116 side p� operty line on PTOpert�r �onnd "AM2"' Gene a l) locatedoj, the east side of 12tH Street, approXimately 200 feet south ai Feather Avenue , ina died as AP a -1S - Oro�t.i:le 2-404 Staff findings were read by Mr .. ]ro0Cs , Proponents: The applicantsaid that the- owners of the prpperty just across the side propertyisne in queS I tion-Olad the 5cTCPxOblCiQ. It was also notes] that property C0 the wast across tale ttreet had a garag:,. within the SOtbaclt area ,jn(t it was also reported that the sub' act 1) oPerty I s a substandard size 10t opponents: No One. i Ilotion was made ]�y Gomn"i ss onor Max, seconded The hearing wos coos r , by Comriyissao11er that because of Laii4bvVt:, to approve this ] cation o_fivariance nthilts` chapter' deprive.!', the size and surroundings, tl1,e strict app this pr ope`t•ty of privileges enjoyed by.other propertry, in the vice lity and under identical zoning claas:i ficlation. AY13 GomrniS$jOners Max, i,ambert, 1313rtne � � a Ycl C�lRi rman 1V11oe1 er w NOUS No O"ne , ,r... Ai35UN' ' dommissioner Gilbert. Motion ,carried. °' k1 2. tr S rmppedge -Variance to allow a tMr.c�� art 35 it, fro�t� conterline of Roble Avenue on property mied "N-R't ' (Agriotilt Residential) located on the northwest corner 0i Orta -Quincy 1414y a.nd Roble Avenue, identified as AP 35.301-05, Orolr#L11c�, 50-24-21-557 Larry Brooks reach staff:f"7.n�l��kL;s pr;pporents John Coppodge said that the louse wtls the same distatce from i .ie street as the carport, and that the house had beers there for 15 or 20 yea�S it was els Practically o noted that at tyle house across Robel is pract a, BUTTE C(?iJNTY PLANNTNG COMMISSION MINUTHS Novollibor t, 7971 the s,ame di.sta) ce, from .the stxo opponents No 011,0 The hearing was Motion was made by Commissioner Max, seconded by Commis ones Ja nilat� �t, tip tapprovo this variance, finding that 1aeeause of the surroundings the strut appl!icatioti of t.h,is chapter do:prives this property of privIleges enjoyed by othov property in the vicinity and udder i,donticol : an:ing classification. AXE Commi.ss.ionel s Lambert, Max, Bennett and Chairman lYhoel.er Hots 44 No ori o. /1� 8V SIT: Commissioner Gilbert. Motion carried V ADD T'E'RMS A- United California Bank Revi,ow Site Dovelopm,ant Plan (:80-32) Mr. Brooks read' aaportlon of a,; 144 t.'et Brom Lo�rvin L, Ward as follows., a map. I'Thi.s plan 'is very similar' toL tthe prelit►iina.ry J)re'vi.ousl.y _approved by the planning Commission. The one exception is that in order to avoid conflicts with the Hutto County Health, Department, concerning a policy which wi.l.l. not allow structures to be placed over leach lines and in an effort to save as many trees as possjble, the temporary facilities building has been placed approximately 55' rarther away from the front property line." Motion was made by Commissioner Bennett, ,seconded by Coimissioner Max, to approve.. this site development plan. . ' - , Chairman Wheeler. ' AYJ's5. �.omm�;�s�,aner.� Max iyallrl�ert Il�.niYett and Notes w No on.e ABSENT Commissioner Gil bort 4 D. Burbank ;school ; i.te a All 55-l0t-40 Mr., . Dfaoks Baia, that' a'is to wao pending and a,skod that 'the Commission f iAd the disposal of this proport1y' in c onforttiity with thre..General. -PlAft and, with Code Section 65402(to tonfirm',Prbitidus tiCtiOn Of thq,Kahn,ing ,. Commission). 13UTTH COUNTY P.L NNINO COMMISSTON MINIM November 7, 1917119 ` Mot �i 'tivas made Y Comrnx ss� o '' gannet t, ` s and d. b Coi m�.s91,0 e1;� T1ax . i t., to f1pd this sa ,e in conformitywithSecj,.ion 654-02 ,end wltr� the � iitte County General Plan. AYES: Commissioners Bennett, Max, Lambert and, Cb airman WheeIe'�- NOh84, No one. ABSENT:z C"orrtmissionor Gilbert Motion carried' C6 RtALTONINC SU'PI:,RVISORIA1, WS'tRICTS 1n response to A. �1.dgLiosor on from ilairagrne heeler,, Lam, �� ��pkN yid that Ixa. matter wot 1",, and that the Commission w4informod of any I U, PLANNING CoO.JMISSION MEETING DBCPrh9I3u17 26: There of Ill lie nom 1- f t U, PLANNING COMMTSST(�NTT25 ASSOCiATif,�r s Commissioner Bennett gave a short resume of the Planning Commis'; on A�soc� ati en's mean n Sacramento 1n5Y week Ile said that the meeting was .in'terestinp and informa.t'ivo and that attention was focused on housing and the :'inns:ing 16m6nt.; POO HILL DEVELOPMENT tn response to a qtesta.on, Mr. Brooks said that OPR is .naw doing a study on foothill develOpMent and has been: reeruitil.g for a �oathill I�ro;j trot Manager to do tlaei coordinating ADJOURNMENT There bung I-JOL other business the meeting was a.djourneO ,at D-410 P. M. 4-1r RAE :WIIEBLER,- CIIMMAN BUM COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES November 140, 1.:79 , i I. PLEDGE Or ALLEGIANCE' II . ROLL CALL: Present4l Commissionors Utinbert, 'Max, 'Bennett, Gilbert and Chaitman 4oeler Absent: No .one. Present: Bettye B1air, Dir ector'of Rlanningp Harl Nelson, Environmontal Review Director; Laura U''`seny, Chico nt�rpri e Record; and Hazel Dallas, S c,rotaTy Ill. APPROVAL O ; MINUT tS Minutes for November 7 197,9 were approved as submitted `IV. PUBLIC t1VARINGS A. PROJUT FOR WHICH AN 1 NVIRONMFNTAL IMPACT REPORT HAS ALREADY BEEN CERTIRIED Mi D. Uayred and Win. Towne - Rezone from "A-1211 � (G"e' neral) to "SR - 1%211 (Suburban Residential. - l/2 acre 'parcels) _ property located on the south side of Entier Ave'wue ap>' proximately 750 feet east of Midway, identified as AR 40-0443S $ 37, more particularly described as All of Lot 14 and the easterly 455.78 feet of bot' 13 of the 2nd, Sub of the J. x. antler Ranch" as ` revised per snap of record in Map Book 8 on page 2 of the Butte County Recordot; r1 Containing 17.50 acres, more or less, 'Chico aa�25-1-270 Mrs, Blaireviewed the staff` findings, caping the a ttont nn of the , 'Commissioners to the fact that there are 4 pareel8,in this proposal in excess of. I acre and that those 'could., possibly be 'fuTther, Isubdivided at a future date, prop onents: Dallas Loris, Box 36-C, Nimshow'Stage, said that the final .. �.y ...... the be happy map on this subdivision has boon submitted and that he would in stipulate would be no further division of the 4 pd-tcels to sty. Mate that.. there w The following residents of the atoa, all expressing concern about proposed development. of adjacent and nearby parcels -"asked that the BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMM188ION 1 MINUTES ,.,November 14, 1979 zoning designation be for parcels a,s ,Iarg,e as pos�sib".+a--c,erte nay' urger ���d.� t�?.a`n' lI2 acre�t `'. .a � ,� �, • Kon klassen, Route 3, Box 324''(Entler Avenue) " Bob Martin# Route 39 Box 33 3 .ok and Beth 'Chgmbers, notate 30 Box 32-A 01A1d Maty. Gpible, Rowe 3p , Bob 3Z�P aw Roy Becl:hold, owner of 5 a.cres,I jus t across Entler frMn this proposal-, said that, he would like a guarantee that he oould split his property" y , • future - . r ththis,,sane wa �,. xn the .� 'I , d;, dollimis,sionet Bennett, comigenting regarding the The he'aranig ws.s; close problems already imposed qA farmers by developers and noting that the Environmental Impact Report for this' project has already been certified by the Board of Supervisors and that the proposal, is in conformity with the General Plan) made a motion to rocbininend atpr6V4'1 of .the' rezone to SR -1 ,(Subu�'ban Re-sa.dential 1_acre parcels) -not SR,- 1/2 (1/2 acro parcels) b His motion was seconded by icommi's9ioher,,Max* AYES! commissioners Gilbert, Lambert, Bennett) Max -and Chairman lhee'l.er. NOES: Noone► ABSENT: No one, Motion carried► V. ABANDONMENT •: A. Erhart Abandonment 'of public Utilities easement 'Unit 5, Lot 51, paradise Panes 8Q -Z6=1 -1Q7 _ , Mrs. Blair said that�the petition appears to be In order and that there a° no objections from e�.ther Del oro 'Mater Company, Pacific Tblbphane, Motion wa$ made by Cc�maui5:sion fir, ` . tnx'ss'oner Lambert, r Ma seconded by Com to recommend approval c,f this abandbnmentP AYES. Commissionersiheeler. Maxi Lambert, Gilbert) .Bennett„ and chairman, r. NODS No one. ABSENT: No olne. <' Mot -ion tattled. i. _ n BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES . November 14, 1579 A0.0- 1xBMS I1 A Use permit on AP 50-082«18, Rev, K. O. Backstra.nd, Christian Church of Paradise Mrs. Blair reported that a lengthy communication, had been rete v,,,d from Rev. Backstrand regarding this "matter --addressed to the Planning Commission --but that the problem had beeit rOfOVred,to County Counsel, No action was takeno B. CITY OF PARAD18B 80-26-1-240 In response to a question :from one of the Commissioners, Mrs; Blair said that the County is �'bligated to administer services to Parada.so to the end of the present fiscal year --June 30, 1980. :She added that i there s an up -coming meeting of county officials regarding these problems and that information will be relayed to the Commission when available. III. ADJOURNEMENT There being no further business the meeting was adjourned at 8:,30 P. M4 TAPE: 8U' -25 -2 -All 26-1-208 /Rae i eeler, Chairman BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES -- November 28, 1979 1. PLEDGE OF ALI,VGTANCE T I . MOLL" GALL Commissioners Ga 1be rt`, ,amb * u'-;, Be.nn4 ,- Max and Chairman Wheeltr Absent: No one. Present: Bettye B`I: it, Director of planning; 'Dick Mol,ca.xx ,, EnvironmentalRbview Department John Mendonsa, Department of Public Works, Fern Wilson, Dally Ridgo razett nada _ Hazel Dallas Secretary III, APPROVAL OF MINU'T'ES Minutes for November 14, 1079 were approved as submjtted4,, :ry i I' IV. PUBLIC HEARINGS, I A. '"" xD)FTE 2MINFD TO BE ITEM CATEGORICALL�B %`I' FROM ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW, Charles Aildrin Use permit to change a noir-conforxiting use to a more restrictiV use, specifically, a televis't% sales and service shop„ two a shaver and vacuum repair shop Oiv Property .zoned "A. -PI (Maximum Density .Residential, service' 2ene� lbc,, ed on., �th.e sbu H .side of `a Y�Ctel"1�; + t East A w, aPProx;iiriately` `6� ` �Eee ba `t of Cohasset toad, iderit f ca' as AP a8-0947, 'Ch ' i 80-27-1-2 1 Mrs, Blair astaff yregardinggth�;ipr�peC�ed that there was nd'cbx respondence infile Proponentst Mr, Alldrin read a 1�-ter from an adjoining property owner stating that he had no objections, He also said that he had owned the property for 1.0 years and that bec' Emse of the traffic situation ;the area was not c;ondUdi'Ve to good fafttily 1i.�°xng. Annette Gookib said that the business has been in operation fur 6 or 7 `months and that: the average customer count is lb, Opponents No ( ne The hearing was closed. Commissioner Bennott, noting that this project is L exempt from �nvironm6nt4l: roView and findit g that the p oposed. Use of the -property; 'will not impair the integrity and chi, tacter 'if- the' zone in which the 1s;nd lies and that the use would not be t1nrea8ona8.1.y in` compatible witho or injurious to, surrounding properties or, detrimental to the health ov general welEgre of the persons resid'hg or working in the neighborhtod or to the general healti�, welfare and safety of the BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING C6141ISSION MINUTES - November 28, 1979 Y: of County! ow deny Motion for- approval of the pro ect subject to'�the County, made a mono i� 1. Frontage improvements on. East Avenue must meet the requirements of the City of Chico Applic,,nt,. must _al,so. comply with all other Sta.o ar4d local statutes, ordinances and regulatioAs;. His motion was seconded by Commifssiono,r Le.mbert.' AYES: Commissioners Max,`Lambert, Bennett, Gilbert and Chairman Wheeler. NOES: No. one. ABSENT No one. Motion carried In..response to a question from the applicant regarding Condition No 1, he bras told to check with the City,of Chico. riaraah -mCGriil, - varinnde to eI:l'ow .acarpo ;t` Z `-feel "fr,() the center .irie of', Kakdi�, `e ?3r2ve bn pro,pe — 7. zone, s%' i°RT,"�.,°? Ofinimum c3lensit'y Tie$xdentni{al-M bile 'Home' located ,on trhe ;,north'°, aide of Kokanee identifiedias AE 34-71.-43elOrov l,le t West of"Lori ev3.ae`. Drive, $0=27-1-1.63 Mrs, Blair read staid Bindings and reported that there'was no correspond- ence. Proponents; Tuve Sl:igar, architect who designed the solari'tation o� the mobile home said that because, of the large stones encountered When the site was being prepared there Was no other place to put the carport. Ms, MdGr-11.1 said that there was no access from k,royo to, this parde1, and that her proposal would riot block the' view from parcels ort eYther do of hers. Chairman Wheeler dosed the,,hearing, Commissioner Oilbert commenting that development of solar; energy should be encouraged and,Aot�ng that this project was eXempt from environmental review, and iindin� that 2.. Y BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION , MINUTES - November 28, 1979 that because of the size,gshape and topography of the property,�;tha strict applic.at on of this chapter (Section 24 49) p depraves this p Pony . �f °:kivijV he "V'i044, �;�7?mt and under identical zoning classification, made a; motion ,for approval; His motion woir, seconded by C..:,,ailssioner Bennett. r, AYES: Commissioners 'Max, Lambert,, Gilbert,° Bennett and,MChai!rmarn:, Wheeler. NOES: No one. ABSENT: No One. F Motion carried. Approval, was subjgctFto the fo11owinglcOndition?: 1. Applicant must comply with all applicable, State and , local,, statutes, ordinances and regulatioAS' a r, W $. ITEM ON WHICH NEGATIVE DECLARATION REGARDING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT 'HAS' BEEN ?RECOMMENDED: 1, Steven storageLarearUse spaces tor'betavailable formobile �to�thepark gen general, gene public on property zoned _''A--2 Ltd._ " loca'te:d. hpprox'imatel.y 1400 feet east of Pent z-Magala°a Highway, approximately 300 . feet north of Wagstaff Road, identified as AP 8:0. 2z-5- 0, (portion)o Paradise. 80"27-,1-447 Mrs. Blair read staff findings. nick Molcar said that his department had recommended a Negative Dec - laration primarily, bdcduser the site had already been disturbed.° y F p s Ino ositiot to this o`ectt ung Mrs Blair re orted that letters had been received from the follow residents o the , are pp project'. � Arno Ross, M.D., 6588 Shay Lane Michael W. "Rocklin, �,0.8� Shay Lane Her Lucid le Daniolson,- 659 Shay Lyne :... Allen oaMSilcott, + 6684 Shay Lane Mrs lcott, no address given Mrs, Blair also slid that h lotter had been roddivect ft6m the appla,cant stating that he would ,be out of town tonight and' ws.s atking for a continuance until Docember 12 She then strongly recommended to the Cbmmissiort that they make no BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES November 28, 1979 decisions on this matter--or others in Paraeise-without official input"`from the newly formed city of Paradise:. ., Xommisstoner Mix said that., �e :�1a�d .���t± r �o"�" ��� , r� q�n7, �i�,���� '1ri> �:n°°oPf osit�;on7 to this rpr,ajea ' Vivian F Eric Frank, 1767 Whitaker Rd. L. Si Stutta, 1955 Stark Lane Mrs. L. S. Stuts 1955 Stark Lane Clayton M. Kind*, 1514 Merrill Road Mrs. Linda Huxtable, 1942 Stark Lane Jane M Sikora, 1865 June Way Velma M & Gerald R. Kennell Mary Brewer, 1850 June Way Wesley A. Fieth. (Dr. & Mrs.), 6660 Shay "Lane Harry E. & Helen Smith, 1.878 June Way W. L. Healy & Catharyn A, Healy, 6565 CePter Pine Dr, Clark Anna Green, 6562 Center Pine Ur. Truman T, Ella Anne Dawson, 6569 Center Pine Drive Ada & John Maehl, 1882 June Way Carolyn M. CArr and William Carr, 6672 Shay Lane Mary Gary Syfett na address 0 M T, Boo Sunawell, 6675 'Shay Lane Mr. & Mrs. Arthur Z. Johnson, 6562 Wheeler Rd, Lee R. Pa.att, 6785 Matell Road Mr. & Mrs . Cli-fton Morgan, 178,2 Merrill toad. Dr. Pail A. Dewhirst, 1886 ,Andrea Place Alfred L & 'Constance Gu=„ter,- _ 6665 Shay .Lane Katheryh L. .Kempton, ' T9 June Way �+Ia`rie E. S.” George, rim. address Mrs. Sandra.Dunley, no address Councilman WilliAm Molding, 1651 Timber Lane, expressed opposition to the project. The hearing Was closed. After discussion, Com, miss;iorter Max? omme�nted that due to the overwhelming response. of people surrounding'tltis project he could see no purpose in postponing action. die then made a ttot o,n to derilr the requeste extension, tljs motLon 4Y-i 5 y, `.,#1c CCI by Commissioner Gilbert and unanii,mottsly carried, y a motion for denial findingthat the ed..use ` o hepr,op'etty will impair the integrity and character of the.zone in which the land lies and that the use would be unreasonably incompatible 't�ith, and iii;• jurious to, surrounding properties and detrxmentai tO the'health . and general welfare of the persons residing or working 'In the "nei:ghbot- hood and to the general health, welfarer-;and safety of the, County. His motion wis seconded by Commissioner Oilbert. AYES. w , Sennett, Gilbert and Chairman Wheeler. Lambert, Commissioners tart,: Lan NU,ESI No one. .:_4 : F BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - November 28, 1979 ABSENT No one Motion carried. r., 2. Clayton L► Bartel Bartel Weldxn Use rmxt.to allow Y . K, a we ,ding ,shop on property zoned ►►A-,2►► (General) , jocat.ed; on the .east side of Pacific Heights Road, goes of State Highway 70, approximately 1/2 mile soith of Georgia Pacific Way,'identified as AP 36-51-45, Orovillo 80-27.-2-259 Mrs. Blair read staff findings and reported that theme was ;lip correspondence, Dick NIolcar said that his department recommended a Conditional Negative because of 'their c,oncern5 regarding noised glare and possible,opposition. by neighbors. - Proponents James Bartel; 149 Mono Avenue, asked that Condition 1 be waived,. and stated that he was planning to plant English Walnut trees along the entire frontage. In response to a question from staff he also stated that rental of shop space at this locxation was not a needed, this -- own permits if p permit- that renters would obtain their, Opponents! No one. The hearing was closed. Commissioner Cyilbert, noting that although this project could have a significant effect on the environment, there wi11 not be a significant effect in this case because of the mitigation, measures listed below. 1. Noise levels shall be kept below 65 ObA at the property line. 2. Glare .from. welding activities and protective right-ing, shall be shielded from passerbby to prevent. excessive glare on Highway 70 and Pacific Heights Road: 5. Materials stored outside must be kept neat and orderly in appearance for 'aesthotlCa, made a motion that a Conditi0hal Negative be filed His motion was seconded by Commissioner Bennett. AYM Commissioners 'Gilbert, Bennett, Max, Lambert and Chairman Whoelcr. NOES No ohe, Y BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION ' MINUTES - November 28, 1979 ABSENT: No one, Motion-caxri.ed Y Commissioner Gilbert, then noting that a conditional negative is to be filed and finding that the propesod use of the property will not impair the integrity and character, of. the zone in which the land lies and that the use would not be unreasonably inc ompati.b,lo with; ox_. injurious t.o, surrounding properties or detrimental ` to the health or general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood o.r t6' the general. health, welfare and safety -of the Gouty, made a motion £nr approval of the proj ect sub j ect to -the £01 owing'' L)i Yditionsi. Mitigation measures a, 2 & 3 above;, w' 4. Screen plantings on Highway 70 frontage. 5, All outdoor storage within fenced area. 6. Surrender existing 'use 'Permit No. 78,11 - ppl:icant must also comply with all other applicab A 1e Sate and local statutes, ordinances and regulations. 4is motion was seconded by Commissioner Bennett AYES Commissioners- Gilbert -, Bennetty Mar-, . Lambert andChair,man WheeNOES; No one+ AMtNT No one _ Motion carriod: RECESS:, 8:45 MEETINGA8CONMM) 8:55 C ITEM ON IHICH A BRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT WAS REQtfiIRBb .6- r k t..b BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - Novembeal 28, ;,`1979 1„ John Lon and Barnggy K,Ukolsfc t�se ' ndom iti o prpP ad X11 PQrm o e log,• a -zA no t . o �' n� n ��. ` r t �. �antarvx.�4..�xMft��a��' ns dcnt'0% ,,.on, thei, east " side af� Stearns, , dv"osootl► and easy o the �.ntez�sectxoA of Pearson Rd. id ;i1,tears�t:, nd., Iden pied as SAP .543`2-b1, ,Paradise.. l 2 John Long and B4moy. ZjlcolsLy itse perma.t to al1o.��� `a unit z.ondona.naum on pronextyened "ASR" (Agr��cu�,uxal. Resa,dentail) located on the: west sicl�e of St,earrX,* RP ad, annrox. l/4 male yest of the , in.ter.section of Pent Magal is Hwy s,; and 5te,arnp. Poad identified as AP 54-321-04, Paradise, 80-27-24521 Mrs. Blair recommended that action on these projects' be ddferred ` `ae na ie official comments from the new City of Parl,tdise. Until zv Dick Molcar stated that the'Impact report was written fox's both projects. , Mrs. Blair reported that W.mre wati a letter in fife from California Regional Quality`'Control requesting a report of Waste Discharge be filed. She Yo'�iewed letters froin the folIowing in oppbsi.t..on to those' rojects- letters reee:ived sinde the last hearing.: L. S. Bright, 235 Hatteras !Sttbet'Wobdland Hills, Ca, 91367 Ira C. ,$ Anna k Parks, 5237 Co`dttry Club DriVo Bob Baiocchi, 1859 Salida Way; Joyce Taylor, Nutmeg W6:y.- Wt, and Jim Plood ' ! Associates, p O Box, 1085,' 'Paradise Commissioner Max retorted the receit =dtrt estoiidence fro! the followingin opposition to this rajectojecs► 5 y h, 'e�Ci trus HoightsrCa No c opY of , letters Richard A. Clark, 1$S38dliada Peter McConnell.1 605"0 Peutz po4d Ira C. Patks 5237 Country C1trb�`briye Mr. $ Mrs. James 14, Aftaerson, 5491. Eago,40od 'Lane and t. S. Bright, 23360 Hatteras Street, Woodland Hills Mrs . Blair read staff findings 'for both'-p'r~oj ects; add+Ag t'd Condition 3 'on both the fdnow ng 'sand instill retjuired facilities Proponents; , Neil McCabe, attorney for the applicant, said that he felt that the �7 BUTTE COUNTYPLANNING COMM18SIO,N MINUTES - November 28, 1979 EIR was complete and well done He said that the Town of Paradise Siad adopted all the brdinancles of the County, that he was requesting that r ti>e Coariss�a p, S- Icy biz the s- plow ap efct" Vinci nod cavi uec,t,: ion on their' pr *oet, since appl a cat"io'rt 'hid been made matr Months ago. He further stated that the applicant Doped°to dispel sotle off`'"the mis- understandings regarding their project'j-first, there would"Ibii do sediment ponds. He then turn€fid the meeting over to John Long (321) ,who doscribed the advantages of condominium' Mown 11louse)' �,'ivi;ng. said this would be anowner-occupied situation and played. 'a t6pe,by, Barney Xukolsky describing the advantages of condominiums and pa�nt�tl out that such living is the trend` in many areas to replace houses" "in the middle of a small lot. I& Dan Cook, 2060 Park Avenue, Orovi:lle, engineer for the applicant, using colored slides, gave a detailed description of the proposed project, pointing out that it would be in compliance with the land use pro- posed for the area and that all problems of traffic sewage`dis.posal,,. drainage, energy conservation, fire protection,` etc. would be solved. w•t Let Exhum, 5374 Edgewood Paradises owner of an adjoining 30 -acre ss parcel also spoke in favor of the project. (:ppuite: .s . Clint rreedl,e, 5511 Desante, was concerned gtbout, growth, Rudy Jensen, 1867 Stearns Road, said that he was representing many people -most of thea members of the Southeast Paradiseu�t heir ,Homeowners Association—who had p life"s savings into single-family residences and whose 1,,)vestm6ra and way of life were now threatened, He added that 27 of the 31,property tr :'►yrs . in the area had voiced their' request for SR 1/2 zoninb= "and, that 6,,v. thc, .5 who di'dn't", 3 were developers, John Botsford, 2940 be Mille Road, said approval of �':,� s" ro j ect would be precedent -setting. He expressed particular concerns aa`out .drainage and additional traffic and asked how --with the requiremoot0'°'that Butte County has for leaching on single-family lots- the 40 -unit Un—'LL Could be permitted at this location., Jim rlood, president of the SPHA, said there is 'overwhelming public sentiment against this urban concept and questioned that this would be an owner -occupied project. He also expressed cgncarns about sewage disposal, effect on, the schools land the lack o.i" dccess for adequate fire protection- -also the less of hundreds'of trees* Torn Councilman William Holding expressed opposition to this project and to the rezoning pro,j ect to come up later on the agenda (5.99) . 14e also said the Vire District should take another look. at this proposal, John Shock, 5800 Pickett sane, a resident of the area for 4 years with an insurance background, asked that this project be rated by the Pacific Eire. Rating Bureau, -8- DUTTL COUNT' PLANKING COMMISSION MINUTES - November 28, 197 26-,2-225 H. V. Morris and a Mr. Thornburg also spoa a Li.- tnst the prc:jaeo � in rebuttal, Mr. McG`z b'e sail; ::tlx� t :s x�c bit�y_ QE F ti,� OA ng , rx . : a person could depend on being able to do something with ails property, and that this proposal was allowed under the present zoning. In ElRrT�werense madeoxn, 1977 --the laston, it as noted that studies available aft counts in the ble from the public Works Department;; Mike Glaze, of Cook Associates, rebutted Mr.'Bots`-orrdis,f e'a°rs about Leaching and percolationand, referred to 'Page' 10 of :t,,he ETF; s:oncerning; drainage problems, _ p Y e removed from this tees would b site. Ban Cook said that comparatively ew t The hearing was clo8bd. The Chairman 'noted the tame, ll ; 00 P.. ;M. , and. ,a motion was made by Commiss,inner Max, seconded by Codhiassionor. Lam'3ert and unanimously carried , to extend this and other hearings on the agenda..' if slece scary, to complete the meeting30 minutes Commissioner Marr expressed concerns about the traffic a.ecess--particularly the 1800 turn at 'the base of the hill, the extreme fire hazard, and possible loaching and drainage probletis. Commissioner Lambert said she folt this is, not a proper -location for sue -III a project and agreed with Mrs Botsford's contention that if only a -Pets single-family dwel.lin.gs would be allowed t*r,� .- coujd 40 units be allowed on one parcel. Chairman Wheeler commented that lie felt +he developors had ",touched all basses'', that there was 110 circumvention, that the tIR was suf- ficientuwbut dial question that the. impact, of resistance of the neighbors was not, stressed. Commissioner Max, finding thAt the prdposdd use of the property will impair the integrity and character of the zone in which the land 13'.es and that the use Votticl"be unreasonably incompatible with, and injurious to, surrounding Dtapertles and detrimental to the health and general 1,ml.fare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood and to the genot'al health, welfare and safety of the County made.a motion for denial. His motion was Seconded by Comm!ssioner Lambert, AM Commissioners Lambert, s�iax and thnnott� NCh5 Commissioner Gilbert and Chairman «hoeler. A88tM No one: .p� r..n BUTTE COUNTY PLA NTNG COMMISSION MINUTES W November 28, 1979 Motion crtried. . r a {'� �'j yy pp • ,. pp ' ppe C71_ ;pYr.Y.�!'3...n he'Y�cnt bras'. °a rased# no£ the a D-, CONTINUED FROM OCTOBER 24 Rudy Jensen, ETAL Rezone from "A--2 Ltd." and "A-A" (Agricultural Residential) to "SR - 1/2" (Suburban Residential 1/2 acre parcels) property located on the south side of Pearson Road, appro.ximatelj► 600 feet west of Pentz Magalia flighyay, and on both sides of Stearns Road, more particularly described as $eginning at the lig 1/4 of Sectlo.i 19, T22N, AAE thence following along AL.- centerline of Pearson Rd. easterly, for ",150 ft., more or less to :the centerline of Rochford Lane; thence southwesterly alon€ the centerline of Rockford Lane for 210 ft. to the N line of Lot 10 as shown %n the map of. the Revised Stearns Tract; thence along y � �azcl N line o Lot 10 westerly for 570 ft. to the centerline of Stearns Rd.; thence southerly along the centerline of Stearns Rd. for 230 ft.; thence easterly for 581 ,ft. thence southerly for 246 ,ft. to the N line of Drendel Subdivision; thence along. the "N line of the said Drendel Subdivision, westerly fog.` 55 ft. to the 1411 corner of said Drcvdel Subdivision, thence full w- ing along westerly boundary, line of said Drendel Sub- di�►ision, southerly for 420 ft. to the northerly boundary of Sobrante park Subdivision; thence following alongsaidnortherlyboundaryaoe 5obrante Park Sub- . � centerline of d,iv�.�.on, r,esterl for 642 ft to the Ce Stearns std. thence following along the centerline of Stearns Rd, southerly for 1,280 ft. to the southerly, boundary line of said Sec. 19', Thence,folldwing along saic southerly boundary line of Ser. 19, westerly for 573, ft,. to the S11 .corner of sa,11 sec. 19; thence µ alon the westerly boundary line of :did Sec. 19", northerly for 1,324 ft . t:o the SP corner of the NE 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of Sec. 24, T22110 R3E0 thence' foIIowing along the southerly boundaily line of said 1v1E l/4 of the SE 1/4 of Sec. 24, westerly for 653 ft to the S11 corner of the SE 1/4 of the X111,114 of the SE 1/4 quarter of Sec. 24 y thence f6llo•u•1119 alon" the westerly boundary line of said SE 1/Q of` the I1E 1/4 of the SE 1/4, northerly for 618 ft. to BUTTE COUNTY PLANN''I OMMISSION MINUTES November 2a! 1079 the SIV corner of Parcel 2 as: shown °ori that cet"tain paxeel map filed in Book 67 of Parcel Maps at Page' '44; thence following along thesoutherly boindar line o said parcel 2, easterly for 322 ft. to the SE :comer ofsaac r cel; e2 .thend fo lc,�,r:.o g the easi~erTy boundaxy 1i a of sa�.d Rarcel 2 north erly for 707 ft. to the cente:,rline of Pearson ltd: thence fo:� " Pearson along the coz�terl:inc o f .Pearson Rd.- easterly for 320 f t. ;to a ppoint of taegxnnn. Containihz 85 acres, moreof Ness,, PaVadise. 79-26-2-309 - Staff findings wore reviewed and the hearing',"vas opened to the public. The a:ppli.cants had nothing new to add: It should be noted that , during the, prequs hearing Ctrs Blair had recommended that decision on this matter be postppned until o:ffical comments are available from the Paradise Town Council, and that Council- man Holding had expressed personal opposti,on,,to the projgct. Opponents Lee Exam, 5374 Edgewood , the owner of an adj.oning , 30 -acre parcel, expressed opposition to the zoning concept Dan Cook, engineer for Long and Kukolsky, said that his clients would, of course, opposed the proposed rezoning. Neil McCabe, attorney for tong aria Kukolsk y, commented that the use of this effort to defeat a project "smacks of unfairness",., Lucy Flood, Pentz toad,, said ,that atV zoning that,upgr4des property 'in Paradise is good. Noting that the time was now Ili 30 p.b1., it was txnanimousiy age°eed' by fife Commissioners to extend the meeting to complete this item and the next item on the agenda. The hearing was closed~ Commissioner Bennett, commenting that it would seemp jR ro er to let the ..Town of paradise solve its own zoning problems, made motion Yto verommend`denial: lois motion gas seconded Commissioner Gilbert. AYE5; ComMlosioners Max, Lambert; BEnnett, Gilbert and Wheeler, Chairman NOES No ore AB';i?NT No one �..; Notion carried, > 'he applicant was appraised of the Appeal period, -ll.L BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES ;," , NoYember 28 197 V. ADD ITEMS tATEGORI`CALLY EXEMPT FROM BNVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Don Ralverson, Vat,iance to allow aP automobile parrs store 34 'feet fro�the centerline of 8k v Y wa °, .property on . zoned "A-211 (General) located on the west side of Skyway, ` app'roxsma"tely 850 feet "north' of Zne1an Drive and Skyway intersection, identified as AP t�n�A0-14, Magalia Mrs. Blair read staff findings. The applicant had nothing new to add. Commissioner Max said that this was the site of an abandoned gas s"tatiort» a'structuro that had existed for many; many years,, John Mendonsa, Public Work8 Department said his department doves not knot where the centerline of Skyway is at this location. Mrs. Blair reported that she aftd,Mti Halverson had talked to one of the engineers in public Works regarding this' proposal and he "xad indicated that there would be no. problem if the structure is within the confines of the existing limits of the building. Opponents: No one. Commissioner'Max, finding that because of the size and shape of this property not to grant this variance would deprive the property of privileges enjoyed by other property under identica1 zdning classy: ificat ' on made a motion to grant the variance to allow an auto4 mobile parts store, limiting encroachment in the setback to enclosure of the existing structure, His motion was secondee by Commissioner Lambert. AYES;: Commissioners Max, Lambert, Bonnett, Gilbert and Chairman Wheeler, NOES. No nne ABSENT; No one. Motion cs.rriea 'r r BUTTE COUNT X'LANNaW3 COMMISSION MINUTES - December S, i979 .'LBDG' ,11T>BGIAP�Ct..�t was mcitr; .; �t. � y No'flag??). ROLA, CALL: Present: t;ommxss5,an�rs Gilbert) Lambert, Bennett Ma:k and Chairman Wheeler Absent,- No one Present: Larry Brooks, Advance Planner; Dick Moxca.r, Bavironment,�I P��view Department, Hazelkrt ecretary I T i , FUDLiC HEARING A CbNTINUk `Ri 'O 'BER 21970., Terry Paa Roy orae from 1t�; � �(Cotieral � to "T114-100f and 1iT�1 X111 �PloutttFain 10 and 20 acro na.rcel.$) do rropor ty boat-.IJ on 1,001 sillos of Ponderosa Wtly, approxi- ma to l), 2 miLl•Os souklt or 1trtl,l 120 1;°ttnacl, identl,rierl as AP 71-121-2 `,htoxe 1ttrt cttZ;lrly cl.os,. l,x:cy os: T;•'-10 Tho S 1./2 of t110 N 1/� , �tt1c'1 `tits NF, 114 of talo P r 1/4.0f 90c, 11 `i'"ONI IM, MM&PI, TSI" ` 0: 1.111.E N 1:/21 oP t110 NW I the MW 1/4 Of Gilt? 1N 1/4 of soc . it v. .. T J "lt)13Fr T: All eontainitg dill : j �jgres ;ri r ►r, rk Of <IeS.q, northditst of (Irt��tille it teas reported that no a.ppljctatioIl for a.,wiubdlv�,saon map had been received. fihbre tivas noone I rosrint to spoalr for the t�•apl.acant. OpponPntst No one, T,.ho hearingwas closed. ft nt11n t . Commis Drier x1i 't ` map had not been led as w g that the subdivision Promise .,, that ny AO was present to Speak for the prod ect 'that the area 1s remote and large, that there is hO cirCUl.ation 'pattern and that the , County would be Put t , a lot of expense to make the area mi$ccossr Bennett and tnc,,luc7ed th ttcit�.f . +a xblo made a motion Por denial t1is motion was Seconded b egatisaorte n, Of coils7deration of the proiposo No�,cative l)oc:l.ara�kion F CiGhert, Bennett and Chairman W}feeler, AYIaS (.onu►ts;� onet^s f�iaic, LapniieF t, NOFSr No one. ABSENT,' No onc, Motion carried 4 s L BUTT '.1OUNTY PLANNING 'MM1SSTaN MTNTITbS Pzcember 5, 1:979 ENVIRONMENTAI �.► .Din 1tvinJ. w . rf,ttq." (heavy Inclustrial) prolwrt'y locntod 671 l,rat?to$ of r"l,arl. itorrrl, zPnrnximatel.y /z mall soritlx cif TRrascan>>t..n 1�O'� rl, arlcnt,,afiP rl 2t, 27, 34 and AP 54-17-1 x, 19, more la�rticjtlarly rl'escr berg as Parcel 14*Dopinni.ng at ilio south 1/4 corlior Of Seci 2,3 T22N. RIB TIJ11B01 thenco along tlfe m aalti S contcrl3ne of s7�rl Scc. , ' 00 Zia 1 2�1" T,, 571 14 I+t > thence S 81 8 ° 41. 34'1 W n .15 Ft w ; t11O'nc0 N 0,P .3 01.'t 1U` 100.71 Ft,; t11011ce S 10.* ,50 , 2001 IV, 1116.72 ` ft tlionce ,9 00 0210011 WY 335,74SC -; t4ont7 X, 89 r 511' 0" 017',lar t;hr.nce i j �► �, :54,21 ft, Moro or Less to tl►(; S Zinc of sai.tl 1 tlaonce a8911 50 15'' Ti.along, said S 11,10, ti75,On ft. more or lass, to the pk),iat of bog;lnning., Patcol, ? The northerly 310 ft. Of tlae southerly 4,70. ft, of the S111. 1/4 of the Sri 114 of Sec, 23 T22N RR: �+'.11IIPP Iiarcol 3� The norl.) Orly 45 f t of the, sokttherly 524• ft. of the wc�st'crlyr 360 ft, of the St -1/q of Sec. 213 T22N 1M 6011fi 4tCrr'V1 V I4,.s aJ.S.4 oi Larry Drooks ead staff; findings, Dick MOIcat said that the same Chock. List for environmental. rgvio1v 14a8 used for this project that was used for the General plan chw ge a, few months ago, aftd added that a N'ega°ti ire Declaration had been recommended. - .aid (1,74) _ . haVo the Zoning match the sbwgines$ inaexistence aa.nd tor` •the rezone ��rvi al of the businos$ in -the future, In response to a ,,Guarantee survival tl��est�.�ahs, lie Mated that thetherar�auld be no necessary'Packing ,�..�,-across' tl�e road £ram the m�'an plant but that e' i for parking, etc. opponents Tile, foilowir'g persons oppo"ed the project bod4uso of the nature of the proposod 11.2 zoning, but non. wv�ro In Opposition. to 'th.e E1e3nke's :.-.. , pres'ent t�pera.taon.. Josoph d M di. Donator 5427 Clark Road Cerel. n Setty, 5255 Old Clark Road Lisa CArdaropol.iz Villa: Palls 1er6me Mtkale 627 Circlowood Drive rti �I BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION r HINUTES . December $1979 and Ramona Mit1al.e, same address A6 licaring was' ol.osed C,emmissioner Max said that Ile felt e postponed for 2 •or 3 Weeks to give the T16wn of Paradise the deco a forcomm. Chai rman Wheeler " decision should t�til�., , �oC'� exception t6 that sug- gestion, commenting that the Commission would rfo`4 be making a final de- cision On this 'j Tojoct Motion Gilbert, was tothen econ recommendpprciva:lsofnoT t����xezon, ea.ri,secon:dori 1i�` �t;omm�,ss�,gner g proposal. _limiting the area. to the same area as was approv;° .� o;n the General Plan Change '(on August; 22, 1979 -Industrial designs • :Jn should extend to a depth of approximately :1000 on the.western side of pp Clark Road and to a depth of �. . approximately 504 on the eastern side of C"_Irk Road) and finding the pro- posal to be in conformity with' the Goneral AYES: Commissioners Bennett, Gi,Wbort, Lambert Chairman 'Wheel.er. NOES: ,ommissioner Max. ABSENT: No one Motion carried. (H4,s motion containpd notatiorx tlha:t Npp * v� cl;ata.ti.on ha.cl, leen eci;zs'ct,-xecl Lee Baxter - AMendmomt to conera.l. Pl.ati Lan(t 1►se)?lemertt �iap frM n LOW Density l;esiclential Designation to a Commercial aesignatiob property located on the nottli side of Faton Road from a point 24O,45 ft. eh.St Of the east; tght-of`-wa.y eine of It cl;s Lano t«o a _pint 495;70 ft. east.,,,'f said right-of way .line, and cxteniia.ng north to a depth of Soo ft, identifiect as AP 44-44-34, Contitii,i p 2.9.1 acres, more or less, Chico► Larry 13r60ks read staff findings,- Dick ` ndings'Dick Mo"bear sta.t�d that a Negative llocjara.f::on was recommended -that there were no natural , ' Ivironventdl concerns Proponents' Lee ba�tor said he had owned the property for 19 years and ex- pected commercial development near the intevchan.go. Opponents: (ze]ie I1yeir, Route 4) Box 427-x') spoke in opposition !Lot onl)� for Trim: el.f but for 9 neighbors and presented a petition with 47 names against the peojoct. mom 1'ockman,}3ridle drive,' expi essed . coii Brit r3 r:. about ossib {� � 4 . r e le tiY"� nag t tra.ff'ic night lighting problems and said this '.s noir an apt`�ropri4t" location for more commercial Tom McCread 4 Rdsoma.ry 'Circle, chicak rLoPreseriting Chico 2 r� against tasSa � of this laud use change. , BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMIMISSXON riINUT138 - December Sp 197 Mr., Baxter in �robutta.l *, said that liglitim wo4la be ditoctea' tomarA tho``, stow .age %rea,,.. that the business wQ.,u not 'be apes at 111ght, 14i.11, have. c4rbs and sidewalks and,c],c so to al.r,eady developed commorcia,l area. 'the heaving was clQse(� Commissioner Lambert commented that sloe could find no need. for t1 -is spot type land use clia,nge and for more. commorclal develop- rgent in this area made a motion for denial,. Her motion was seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, and also c oaatalliesl t1le notation that flit., IVoga,tive Declaration: had Ivan► cori:�icle.rad. AYES., Gorjutissionera. Mai, Gilbert, Lambert, Bennett and Chairmo-n 4he-eler, - NRliS No ane; ABSENT; No .one: m6ti.on carriod. It was explained that there is no appeal to this action. k sk h .Iamos T. Clanton - Amendment to the General 'flan Tana pse Blement Nat) from an existi,gt, Low Density nosidential designs- tion to All Indt str.ial-des ignationproporty located on the east sicTe of Li.vOphir ,oad$ south approximately. 895 ft. and it( a depth of 261n ft{, measured £roan the center- l.ine,of Lindvin Blvd.;, ielontif .ed ''Is alp 36,27L50 F, $1, clan.: . t_axrxng 5 c�cres, tnorta roc less, Orova tl.e 8��29���557 Staff findings were read. by .Larry Brooks, Tick MolCa.r commented that the main impact of this project would be traffi.o and added that a..Ne;gative Declaration had been recommended,' proporivast�ons new add. Y ents , James T. Clanton offare�. to ansii`er q, :but had nothing Rudoiph Schulz, route 2 Dox 2767; Oxovi.11e and Lawrence 14,ammo4$ 6111 Lincoln Blvd.) Orov 1.1 e both spoke - 1 favor o ", the project. ppponontsti No one, The hearing was closed. Commissioner Gilbert said that ho was familiar withthe area a -Ad wi.th� th.t-�, growth prt s;sures there and, noting that the- 4Coritm.is:sion. will.. be reviewi�ig the ro�oni.n,g prion to any development, made a Motion to rec imiend appi,oval, by r'osol.� Lion, of this amendment to the 1General Pl.a:n9 ;La:nd ire - °,_e pont m)a.pw. .(.,His.. mcatiy6ft:Y'waws seconded byrc}Commissioner n :�rtt� ass.. �.ricl�ad.t.d 'ti..�l nt)ta.�i �iJiI t, it the NOgiti4ivo Doc aration hvd been AYES: Commissioners G�tlbarr - t�fax, tamberi , Bennett and Chaitmazi 777 d J a•........... it tUTTi COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES December 51 1979 NOhS No ono, ABSBIN T: NO Ono. motion carried 4 . NEW HEARIN03:: ITLMS ON. WHICH DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORTS tiV�RP RI CIUIRT�D t<i :latrd; llcrmil..l iol� t, t'lill ia•rt 11 11AV tt cneralJ! to 11SR„,111 (Suburban Rositlojtt 'al I .tc7re parcels) property, located on the northoast: corner, of Garner Tarte anal State Hw,y. 99, idontifi od as ATS 44-041-69, more particularly f�e.scxibed tis Lot 3 Of f � nl .) rocojrded In eta Book 59 on Fat eq�� A �anr X1.9 in the office of tree i r lY . 9;5 Autrc Count per.oa�clr.•. , ()J1txtittiYr, 7 a,Bfi mors. or less, ("hien. Sraff, fitldings were rend by Lavvy Brooks. Dick; iNolcar said t17s1t the environmental, impact repox`'t that was used for the recent Lap.d Use Element Map change for this prolicct was used for the rezone, hropotionts: Na otic- 1. QpP0nont,q, No one: The hearin teas closed, Commissioner Bennetts, common - ink that this project had, 'been, � � the mill for a long time and that 116 could ,find no reason why it should not be apl)-r veds malro a motion for approval toting that it •is ,n coitfo-maity with the Genera.t Plan,ills motion was seconded by Commissioner I.aitmbort,, Tt, :jnclucicd '010 notatiba that ' tllo linvirotlmot tai lmpat t ro-I)OTt was 4 de >`iiiltissionctrs Ronnott, lamb`, rt , C 'l.l�c rt, Max and t;Il airman t'1ltooleT, NOES No Ono ;A-BanNT I No one. Motion carried, BU TR COUNTY PLANNING COMMItSSTON MINUM nocember r, 1017 1. anctto Copnti�i ,Plannta�^axo�ruri:,saoi,� µ Raz,ori rc 1 �► � " �Ctio e � Al " t�sicic4r`tx�tl��;, "�l-f.�� (l;xin,t inct'LtstrxEll), 111t-11, (Single Family Ros;idon-tial), "1�-9►' (MaxIn tnr �lensxty ROM.- dential - Restr .cte(t Sorvico), and 11C;-21" (reneral (omm6rcial) ,property located or, Motif sido.x of hspla.made, ;from ,the inter- soction of Esplanade and Stata, Highway 99 to Lassen. Avenue,, more particularly dkoscril)cci as tt-4 All that property located within 10o feet of and sotithmesteriy of the followring descrilit cl line:' Bof� i.nnint; at the n1�,exr:�ctti an of the nort,txe,nstk�r,l y off.' -onion of the nortlitvostorly line of Evans Tract per map of rocord in Ilnp PMooh 3 on pale 67 of the 1"otte County 11ocorder �'Inet tho wast rip ;l,t-of -way acne Of rlspl.aiuv'r, thence nortlo-mstorly along said conter- l ne 2574 2!t. to the ml n.C' tho, hero .tc Ltoscri bott line, C:otttai.liin Z0.6t2 "Lerost morc or less U-1 All Mutt p,;operty lit! ended on the northwest i)y the center- line Of MUd Crock, on the northeast by tho centerline of Stine ilig1way 01.), rift the southeast by the conterline of Lcora Court and its easterly oxtension and on the south- west by the cer,tcrli.ne of Esplanade, excepting therefrom all that property ,locatod iiitltin 700 - ft of the center W lino of mora Court Containing 10.74 acres, more or loss C'21'. The all of Lot�4toxcept�the northeasterl.� '300 :ft."al I of Lof tl ot and , �o southeasterly 431,4 ft* Of said lot 4, all lots of " asmoralda Tract" per map of record in flap Took I on l ago 5:1 of the Butte C'nunty Recorder. All that proporty, 1,oun(tcd on the southeast by Olnsmeralda Tract'" per map of record in Hap Dook l on Page 33 of the Butte CountyReoortter, ort the southwest by the conterline of tspltiilado, en the r�orthv;est by the tow-axtli:ne of,, Raton Roast, ttncl ax, the northeast by tho cent6rlino of Stato tltsy,cJ,xcoptin; tilorefrom all that property locatoct within, 5130 ft 6 of theconterline of taton Road) all that property logated witilin 600 ft. of said 'thsmeralda Tract" aad also oxcopting therefrom the following described Parcel A portion of flpncho Arroyo C.,hico located in the County Of 11ut:to,, northwest of the City of C:hi.co g described a i Commonci,np, at the intersection of tho Nil line of Lot 4 1 - rI I, s BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING; C OMM'1SS-10N 'MiNunl`l;5-'necembet• 5 1979 a£ r�f�,sinor .icon. T nc t" ��rr m +� ,.. ecprcl axa �l l? oO'k r_r . , r Page 33 .o f �t11e utte County' •1.ecorder and tho east r fight - of -way line of Esplanade; thence N 370 20' 111, 990 ft along said right-of-way lane to the true point of beginning of the liarein described parcel; thence N 520 1.7' 561, R 1.370 Pt. more or lass to the 'wast right -ref -way line of State fttvy. 99; thence N 433 451 34" 1V 332,07 ft. along the West riplit-of-way line of State I-ltvy. 99 thence S 52° 17' 56" W 1335 ft. more or less to the cast right- of -way line of Esplanade; thence S 37" 20' F 330 fto along the east right -of 4way line of tipl a.nade to the true point of beginning All that property hotlnd,ec1 on the SH by the centerline of Eaton no(W o on the Sty► by the ccnterlifto of Esplanade, oil the NIV by the cOnter.lino of Loom Court ancl. :its north- easterly► eaten Sinn aftcl on the NE by the centerlino of Stato Highway (90 VXcopting therdfrom Lots 1, 2, and 3 of that parcel map rocoxcled in, Map Boole 60 on 49 of the Butte County Recorder,. all that property 'hounded on the NIV by the centerline rt,': Tonea. 1Vay, on the SIV by the northeasterly ,lane Of Lots 6' 7 ) S , & 9 of "Waters Sub No. l'+ per mar,` of record in Map Book 35, on Page 42 of the Butte County Recorder, an the SLS by the southcasteily line and its e:Ktension of Lots l0 through 15 of "Waters Sub No. 2" per mal) or T,.tcord in Nlap Book 43 on Pafe 7 of the Butte County Recorde+r, and on the NE by the ccntorline of State Htly, 99, Lot 2 of that parcel map recorded in Map Hook 45 ori Page 42 of the Rutte County Recorder, and all that portion of Sec, 9 T22N RlP I`t1)1101 bounded on the N P, e, 11 by said Lot 2'; and on the 5 by the northwesterly r3lght-of-way ,line of Tonea Wayand All that property located Within the Tight -of -way of Tonea Way, tXcept ing tlleroftom that Portion cif satzl, right-of-way located. between Esplanade, nncl the soil tlYeastErly extetisibn of the soutl.�vestor'ly Line of said `1ot 2, and also except- ing thorofrom tlir F011otlin;g described l»reel; A Part of the 11 half Or- the RV 1/4 of .sec. 5, and a part or the 1V 1/2 or they N'1'4 1/4 of Sec, 0, loth in T22N 12111, r,lllBUt; more Particularly described as follows: Commencing at n point on t1e westorly right-of-way lint of '',state sin Route- Jh" (Vreeway), said point being 106 ft ,wosterly at right angles from engineers' station 252+301,9; ; thence southerly along said westerly right -o£ way 'to the centerline o. dicks Lane, said point lacing tl e ;E.C, Bs' thenco S 000 0q' w along said Cantcriine of Hicks Lane to the northerly corner of the Shasta anion �7� f t31J'Z'o-I'1.! COMIT PLANNTNG (OMNIl SSTOM l`11"VCl"I'l?a � laot��►1nhc+ti S . I �1 r .J school Di,,;trict property as ;cle;scri,jxe� , ill, 1%78 OR 360; , cords" o 11ut;toc --Count californi,a' ', thence 9 3° a distance of, 061,25 ft, ; thence N E2-° 05, E, a distance o,1 745 ;Ct, "anoro or loss to the westerly right -of -gutty of said "State lla�)r. 00�'i »honce northwesterly along said ivostarly right -o�l -wa,y lino to tho point of heginni;n, r e .� cepting theeef-ro,ia all taia,t portion witIlisn all county roUds', also (;-acc'e'l)t ng thorefro;,t; Beginning at the MoSt, aaortherly cornar of the Shastwa. union School District prdparty as, dQscribQd in 1.75 011, 560, records of Butte C`oonty_, Califo aaia,, ivhI0,i potat lies ill,the centerline o. llicLs Lane, thonce from saaid point of 1a©,8inning. N 66° 00� 1, 24712 ft., thence �1° 0+ 1? 54�7,t35 ft„ thenc^ a tWo :00' IV 247..12 ftP.1 thonco N .111 30' 11 549,85- ft. to the point of boTriAlAing. All t lvi-t protjerty 1 ocaterl N141 of and within 700 ft4 of the c i,,tv aiitl tts Jl0rtlict2st.Qrl)►' oartonsi.on. of Leora Ct. y the centerline of Esplanade, rind ail tlae IM by tlae ceittorlino of State Hwy. 99, Th7 t portion of the AlR 1/4 o'F Soc. 5 T22N 111E lIDBfA2 located S W of the contcrl no of state Ilwy. 9.9. � That portion of the IV 1/2 of Sec. 5 T22N Rlh MMIM located S and 1V n.i Stato lla�y, h9 and t4 and, JI of F?splanade. A - portion, of Sections, 5 and. 0T2wN tZIP rtDI3F,T4 described a,; foll.ote;y inn ng © ingcit tho int"Cr'$oct�on of the centerline of Hspl.anade g� rtheasterly e.Xtension of the southeasterly line Of Lot 2 0£ that parcel 'map recorded in Hap Boole 48 on Page 1.,2 of the 5utto Cou It Recorder thence 5 5211 041 H,r 665.0, ft,; thence sou.thoEasterly, parallel with the center line of ,P,splanado, 01.1.5l ft.; thence N 526 04' F; 05.t1 f`t w y tl�erice southeasterly, pa.rallol with !arid conterl.ine to the nc,rliiuoterly lino of Lot 2'of that parcel map rocorded in. Book 52 on page 51 of the Butte County Recorder; thonco' northeasterly along said northeasteri,)t lint and its eattens_at7n to flat* centorlino of Esplanade thence > north» ia.,ci contorlili�c to the avc�stoa�l.y ti.lt�n;g � point of beginning. All of parcel l3 Of that paarccl xlal) recorded in ir,jp Book 50 oil lxaga 5 of the butte County Recorder. , Contain%nfr, 182 acj,•es, more, or loss R-1, Lot 2 o:E that pCirool h;t:aa recorded in Map Hoof 41 on o BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING CC mmISSION MINUTES December S, 1,973 Pai;e 42 of the' l3rat•cc, County Rero• do", �1,tdal,l that Portio"n, of Sec. .0,Tzu Rip, "mmVIIM3,1und It on tlye No to ana'IY icy5aacl T,af,t an on the S iiy ,tlte rtortltwater]y right-of-way !ino of Tonea Way, and all. that property located vithin the right-of-way of Tone's Way, excepting therefrom that portion of said riglit-of-wc. o located botween Esplanade and the southaastorl;y extension of the satithwesterl.y lino of %aid lot 21;anci that portion Of the right-of-way OF State Itwy, 99, located south- idestOt'lY of the centerline of .State 1lwy. 99,. and between the northeasterly extensions of said Lot 2 and the south- easterly linin o,C hots `l.o i it oui h 15 {� "Waters Sub.. division No. 2" per map of record ii) rMaP nook 43 on Page 7 of the Btttto Coulnfv Pocnrrlrr, ContAini'1 i , 31 11C.",rns, nore or lo,s ti Chico. Std -3(141 -fir Larry Brooks read staff tit dings, empha.-tzinf; the fJl:t that staff would recommend that considcration be given tc substitution or 1111--C (Il.ighway Commercial) for the C,--2, Proponents t Harold IV. Peterson, 300 l spl anade, owner of 48 acres had no objection, to tho t -1=C proposal, Vern 'me ofattt, 5proble05 msfland�still said give 151) lez�Commist tile sionnsople controolanswer to some of tile Dick 8isel.t, 156 l;aton Road with property on Keifer Rd, felt it would he unfair that soma parcels could do what they wished under the C-2 while others had to go through the use permit process;, Don nrooks, 817 Rio Chico Way, a tkod that the C-2 not be changed at thin by elle use permit procedure, 11-C, zoning that would delay projects eittte. ]301 NoVn.cic also spoke against the Tiw The hearing was closed, Commissioner Bennett, commenting- that he would. like to sae some kind of Con.trot along the 1 splailado trade a motion that the C-2 and R•-4 as proposed on the exhibit mals be recommended. for H -C and that recontendetrenati,n for the balance ol` the area be a.,; or.igly iiiaing that the proposal is In don{ormity with th,e Cleneral PI all Ilils mn=t:ion was :seconded by Commi,:.sionor Lamberti and ineiuded the A. �ilil,It ati the tile II,It tAll J;11,N C;C1N5 C Il, OmmxssIoners a7:lUert, 11e1inete, 1-atillaert, Affix and Chairman iVheeler. NOhSI No one, ADSBNTI No onc, Mbtiook carried ��w BU1''TH COUNTY .PLANNI'NG COMMISSION MINT ITS - December 5, 1079 TV ASAN13OP4PNj1) DoUore abandonment rT' 'a' eusetncpt �� Paradises Pit>tes, No, I2, Lot 12() A Mrs',l ja,vo�As ,said the request, u.ppeared to be.' ie Motion was made by, C,ommi ss;i wicr Max) s000n,(ieti Gy C ommi,t $1,oner Lambert, to xocmrinlctld approval of blas_ a_b;andomltent. AYE, S:. Corm kssioiter.,%Wlx Lambert) Bennett Ga:lb(irt at��I Chairman 1Nl�eci.or , ; - NOES No one AI8tNT No one Motion 6arri.ed V. M18CBT,'tANt0U8 A. Mr. Brooks announced that tliore :Is a sca ihar irk. Redding on Decamber 13 a1 d 14 conducted by CCPR. l)etalzs Will be nitill ed to 'the Coffloills0oners as soon as recei�re i� � perhaps Thursday or Friday. VT. ADJOURNMPNT There being no Ot'1Yer, 1 usi.ness o the itioot tis* was adjourned at i.b -.45 P. M. 80- TAPE; ,✓ k ;�Cl�i.� i2a 1V]]eole�'� ,i:t�r►nan 302-2 -2-067 ,1t BUTTE COUNTY i4%ANI�If�rG COMMISSION'' MINUTES December 1, 1979 I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TTI: ROLL CALL; Pres iii: Com' jt. inners Gilbert, I�,�'�ttbert, Max,, Bennett and Chairman Wheeler Absent: No one Also Present~ Bettye Blair, Director of Planning; Dick Molcar, Environmental Review Departmont; Stewart Edell, Department of Public Works- Laura Urseny, Chico Entorprise Record; and Hazel Dallas, Secretary III. APPROVAL Or, MINUTES Manu ei Paragraph ercha, 1979 were aproved with the followirig' correction: r. , p g "Bennett!. ITEMS DETERMINED TO BE GATEGORICALLY"XERP`TPROM �NVIRONMENfiAT, REVIEW Pacific Telephone and Telegraph w Variance to allows an equipment shelter 35 feet, from the centerline of Humboldt Road on property zoned "A-2" (General.) located on the southeast corner of Humboldt Road and Bull Hill Rood, ..,,identified as AP 60»10.4$, Butte Me.° 3ws. Bettye Blair read staff findings, and stated thatthere was no Corres- pondence. Proponents: C. B Sanders, representing the applicant, and in re- sponse to a question from one of the commissioners said that this structure would not be sight-obscuring sand that the reason thoy did not wish to move it further back was because there were several large: trees that would have to be removed. He added that were this not in snow country that no shelter would be provided for the equipment. Opponent$"L No one. The hearing was closed. Commissioner Bennett, finding that not to grant this variance, pp . , property,, including, g becaruso of, special circumstances .a 1a.cable to the nclud�.n shape, topography and location, would deprive this property of privi:.a leges enjoyed by other propery in the viciftity, made a motion for ap- proval. His motion was seconded by Commissioner Max, Arid tiadb sub. Ject to the following conditions 1. ► Deed to theoCountyoldtButteRoa50 feet of right-of-way from the cterlApplica.lit must also comply with all, other applicable State a:�d DU'TTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - December 12, ID79 local statutes, ordinances and rogulalt 011� !f t Gomm�iss onors Ca,a,bQrit Lampert, Ma-X, •� &Ano to- and Chairman 'Wheeler NOt$ No one, ABSbNT No one Notion 'carried,, 2. Clint Gordy Use permit to allow a mobilo home as a su econdd�welling on property zoned "A•.2 Ltd, locattd _oh ` a of Jones Lane, approximately 2so feet west of Clar�Ci�oad, identified as AP s0•-35q.C! Parad..s�� Mrs. Blair; - eoad s•'tafffi.nding',s and added the following comment from Environmental Health Department: asequat.e. 1rea appears to exist :dor a 2nd, dw* ling' ti "it fid. pp' well as a lot split, iiowevbT) there" does `ippear, to be K �ic� gess prabai ems to 'Iiark Roaa t'.ia_ Jones Lane, 1t a use ',poi°ntit ' is apj)7:, ved , fo 2nct ,d�voll i ng}nt�i�it the wou�.d ° sucggost that the dWeli=g be sd Incatted"as U a T6`iVf'6a �titre land 4i.vis:iDn,11 There was no correspondence Th-d ;hea-r4ng;-wa.s -closed: Ptop6n.ex;tts Clint Gordy said that Paradise 146altl1 1)epart%dnt Riad checked his Xila.ns and they seemed to be sati s actory, Opponents: No one. Thh h;; :vizi wars cies e.' Cemmiss ae Ma noting that thi spro" Oct is categbri,cally' exemptfrom orivironmontal roview andfi:nding that the prtipq:§ec`! Use of the f; proporty will not impair the i:ntegrri ty and character of,, the tone in which the land lies and that the use would not be unreasonably in- tompatible with, or i.njurious to y surl'ound ng of off` &0,t- re mental to the health and general wolf-art, of the ns residiro or 'V�orkin in'the x�iAjOibo hood or to the general healthi welfare and safety of thb ccunt�, Maio a. motion for approval. of the ,pro' e-et subject to 'the folk wing conditions Veiify legal parcel. 'l 24 Provide 2 off-ste.eet parking spacos i"or each residence diesighod in a.ccordlande with attachdJ' standards. 3. Socond dwelling to be located so to allow for posb ro- f1l" di'lrision v F. BUTT: COUNTY PLA19NING COMMISSION MINUTES - Locembor 12$ 1979 Applicant must also, con►ply with all other appl!cable state anc ldo�, stttea`, .:dlr�'ncht1 rogilat His motion was seconded by Commissioner Lambert. AYES: CommissionersMax, Bennett, lambert, Gilbert and Chairman Wheeler,, NOBS: No one ABSENT : No one. Motion carried. Ab-ART SIGNS, Inc. Use permit to allow s'igh 33 feet from the centerline of Oroville-Gridley Highway on (property zoned '.'A-2" (General) located onthe south side o£ Orov :lle-Gridley Highway, approxiMAtely '600 feet west . of Larkin Road, identified as `'Ar, 2,r-1,30-20, Gridley, 80��1-x-�00 Mrs. Blair toad staff findings and added that there 'vas no co` rrespondence.1. .w, Proponents: Gary.Youth, 2440�Lastern ,�venue,iSacramento, repxesonting, Ad-Art Signs, emphasized the 'Importance of being able to see the sign from a distance,, Leo King, President of Kingfs Markets, Inc,,,said that the buil x d ng which now houses King's Market will be put to another use, and asked that the,sign be allowed,'.;10 be placed where they would not lose a 11 parking space because of- it, and that there are no p;':ans to move PG4E pole Opponents: .No one: Tho-heating was tlosed, Comm fromyssioner environmenta5 review andtthis findingrthattthe categorically of .p � � property will not impair the integrity and.charneter of the zon: in which the land lies and that the use would not be unreasiadbly_iri- compatible with) or injurious to, surrounding ppoperties'ji, dots= rimental, to `the health and general welfare of the persozit res ding or working in, the neighborhood or to the general health, welfare and safety of the County, made a motion for approval of pl,icement of the sign 42 feet from the centerline of Uroville-Gridlt�j� hi ghway, subject to the following conditions:, r, 11 Deed to the County of Butte 40 ft; ri.ghto:67W;,;+ trOtt the centerline of Oroville-Gridley Highway, (No .p ivat.e structures., ;.' allowea within, the county right-oi pway) . U 13UTTP,COUNTY PLANNING CQMl 41Sxo MINUTADS Dacember 12, 1 Y -2. :,S��Li*�f1}�.1-sha 1 6: �,jl�p.� <�7 <y '{"4..{t*►/,. y.}t. -'(,�� �_ . .�61ifi-I ct f'�it�J�s.Lgil ��r4t' 71G , 1~ the i ltersection \ sign must be placed 1, miniatt im of 42' from � nt x as " ,. , ,4. Tho use pexmit may 'be :evoked ,or modified by :t c p '' i l y h anni.ng Cornnfson whenever the Comma.ssxon de;;�,ermines :hatrt�mr�w�al,, �c�hr�cat�,gr�� 'Or modification o tie encroachment is necessary `,`to maintain adgt�aate i » tri#°fi.c safety as: a res�ul.t of Any changed conc�it;xan or of an public right-of-way Acquisitiot,stir improvement pxa3act, S • Any removal o relocation or modificati gn regua,ri�d 'ta Condition. N04 2 shall be accomplished without loss or c0st 'to the County of Butte within 30 days of notice of th'e ,decision of the Planning` l CommisSIon» AP p�3Caf�ttitC.�sS a mush a�st�a .co�plY wa�tla Ali other ap�a�.�.c;able State and iztes and regnlatill �rns» clis motion was seconded by 'Commissioner Lambdr. AYES: Commissioners Bennett, Max) Lambert, Gilbert attii Chairman Wheeler. 0(i o orifi AtSEN`I'rt No INlativn carried.. E . A. too plercb C1Se p rfiit' to al.lbw e reskabiltia! mobile home dh 'Propdrty z}bned ►'M-2" (Hedvy liidustri'al) located oto the southeast corner of Baggett�Marysville toad` n`a . ett Paiermo 19aad, identified 48 AP 36-S,0 221 t 'Mrs, °t'Ia'ir toad, stafr fife ings. j;� thtto w'as Ino torrespOl,donce P' opon, Aai,ee pieVice said fith'dti he diad no c�bjccti.bns to ,the " proposed eondit�.ons a.nd ddaed that m6gt e� them had been ccm�iiel f with alreadly. PP one,, 'rhe heard~` was �clos'dd� d, oftents? ~ �� Cott id,. tsi.aner Gilbert, hotitg that' thi, prof oct�,s categlor caliy exempt from environmental reivew and,,fi.nding 'tha't they proposed use of the prop,,,-1 :w'ill not impdithe into and chat ac o the tone i-,4which .s .6 Land 11 des and that tho use ivouid notbe u i easonably r� ate. , s, r BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - December 12, 1979 r. compatible, with, or inyuriouii to, surrounding properties or dot- rimpntol to ;lae „hell t}i id � oral we�;,�sr o the �orspns vas � g br`'work'ing in'. the �noighbor oo� or t,o tiro general �'h+ealth 'Wel£a're and Safety Of the County, Tirade a it otian foar approval of pl,acemont -of +ollowing conditions the ,nob�.;,le subject to Cllr' following /1 y Peed to J:he Counto£ Butte 30 £ee"t of right* '6f—wav,- from i� t' the centerline of Baggett-Marysville Road and Baggett..pal.ermo Road.. Construct 'vertical curb, gutter, sideway 40 widen Bag$ett':: Ma; ysvjlle goad to RS -2A Road Standard' The one-half street section consists of ,an 18 -:Foot wide paved i"0440 with vertical curb (plaoed at 20 :deet to race of curb)) gutterf rind 5 -foot v.do aidewalky Minimum road atruct tal section to be 211 eophalt oonoxetet, 811 glass 2 aggregate base, dog sear$ prime eoaty and 95% relative compaction of o0gradea Of (covered by recorded covenant) 3. Provide a permanent solution for drainage, Submit constructipn and drainage plans to Department of Public Works f`6T approval and install the requared'fac lities. Applicant must also comply with all other State and local." statutes, ordinances and regulations R His motkqil was seconded ��y Commissioner 'Max , AIM : Cbmti s:'LoersB Wheeler, NOES. vlt , Max, tambort, Gilbert-o;Gilbert-o;, and CPQ , NOBS. No one AMM: No one. Motion carried. ITM,19 ON WHICH NECATIVE DECLARATION REQ IN fiI i -TM IMP, �riMpND n 1. Ryder Homes -, Use petMit to allow a subdiv.isiony sales tffice on: property zoned ��R,-111 (Single-laMily Resident all "locate on the southwest corner of Morseman Avenue and. Sandi Drive y approximately 1/4 mile north of Lassen Avenuo identified a:4, AP 441-581-01 (portion) , Chico,, 8t2�+31-2-235 BU Mi COUNTY PLANNING CON111ISSTON MINUTES - December 12, 197(E Mrs « 11it road s�a�� ��nd, JAgs. , ,There wwre n4 j 'that ��i 0,0 n c0 nateR MOICATsaa . y ipt.' rt4m:O'n !oun A , weree traffiic and part ling, and loth ok,,t,hose 'wo.old ba shoot -corm .and , minimal. 'r PO4), el, 131, Or Bioxwa Ony 1440 SOS ))rive lValnut Crook,, Cps: 4 sa:i d they a xt patc d no tr���iG" .pxob�e�t�e ppOnents s ' No one, ; The heara ng was closed; Co'Tiilnisioraer Betnott; fndri that the proposed pxooct 'could not have a significant e oot on the onvi."Onment, macho a motion that a. Negative Declaration be �Ilod. His motion was seconded by Commissioner Gilbert. AYi1s Comm ssi,onors Max, Lambort Gilbert, Bennett and Chairman 'Wheoler. Nast* No one, ABSENT No one I Motion carried: *Bennet, ..noxng o.r Negative ,D,eol arat gn is to,oal ed tinct n.dili that the proposed use of the 'property n074 3:mpa`lr the integrity and characer ,of the Zane in yh-ioh the llandl'' Iles and that the use world not be un easonabl- zncompa i� a �u�th or 3njux of s pers6ns residing or work g in the health and ;general welfare xo ntli�g r�x�,erties or dotri.mOnta.l to the heaith�aand general or to the general health, welfare and safety o, the county, made a motion for appr6vd] of the _Pioj eco Nabi eci to anclion. listed Motion lvs s000r�ried. h C�ertiinassr�n',..?or.._. AYF.8.* Commissioners Max; Lamti;- rt, Gilberto Bonnet and' Chairman Wheeler, Nots bio one AhS8NT t!ira ono Motion carrl,od Condit X cns ot'. Y.4ppr0va.,: -are ; w i The! s01, er it a. tova� i8 to he Pam w �" pp � '`or t�n.e ear, erioa°, Ari signs usod to identi gyy taxa slaos office or to g.'dtr'or�tige tho � aroo %c romovod after the u4e'permtr�sires or f su di is,ion t r 4 +:Y Y BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMM1;5SION �3a MINUTES -,December 12, 1979 after the sales office curios operation, whichovor occurs first, Applici�t. in,.u� a'�aom� with a.ry�ot) apnioa,�ila ��ta�r. local statutes, ordinances and regulations Cal if ern s Watbr serviqe Co. Use permit to sllgw ,.a pu�,lic Utility building pan property xonod nR-I ll (Sin,gle-Family osi (jentiall ldcated on the northwest corner .of Mdtscgraa AueVuo and Sandi Drive approximately 1/2 miles north of ha,`sseri ,Aiie;sue, identified as AP 44-38-01 (portion), Chico. 80-51-2-421 l l�ecla tion had becait recommended. Mrs., Iain react staff fiucli.n s: Dick Molcar said that; a Negative f'raponents mar's Moore, representing the applicant, said t1te building would be 14' x A 1 and mado of slumpstone Opponents No one. The heating was closed. Commissioner LaMheM finding that the 'proposed project could not hav'o a signif<i Baht effect on he environment, made a motion that a or Negative Declaration be filed. Her motion was secondo by Commission Gilbert. - - AYES Commissioners Max, Lambert, Gi.lbort., Bennet. and Chairman Wheeler NOBS: No one, ABMT No one, Motion carried, She then, noting that, a NegAtiVo Docl4ratlbh is to bo filed, and finding that the proposed use of the property will not impair the integrity andd character of the zone in aoh ,ch the land lies and a' that the use would not be unreasonably iaacompaiblo with or injurious to, surrounding propovtios or datrimenta.? to the h�a,lth and general welf:ar,o, of the persons residing or woTking-ln the ,neighborhood or motion general approval subject to the f0llk)W4g con6it�ions.�Ma�e a the Co,,►n`t`y; ma to the eneral health),welfare and sa�et o� tf � seconded, 1, ta all statutes, orda.riar�cmug t comply saaid,tiregulat��nsG�bi.e State and locali AYDS., Ch t,0_ssn nits a�. ,ilbert, Bennett and whooComm',ss�.onor� 1�1ax'� I,am�l.v�t FOBS No one I -� ITTh COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES December J.2, 1979 " ✓ /r ABSENT No one. r 3. .Ian Larson Usc permit to allo-w 'a sales � bract a�i�:�ce� an property zoned 1111.311 iei`14% Density Re0 ae;,►'tal) tIocat:od ,on the 1'1o>X'tll t5 .ctrner'a. l4anta�c�llo Lane,d.an4. Ddb, ed,0 Colarl.,� " .approximately 200 feet north ol+ tie indl of �4$t� $.hash► AvUe id.en�:i ied as r�'F 44-05 -70 lnoxt� �n� ��hica,. Mrs. Dlal,r road staff f-Indings Dick Molcar said that a Negative Declaration lead been recommended. it Proponents Douglas Cillandy,:manager for the complex, said there would be no 1)4r�- ;ng prubl,em5 Opponents., No one. The hearing !W,a§ ,- osed. ' Comm, iss ,onesLambert, fins n that g thO proposed. ;pray eco; , could not hhVe a, significabt effect on the envir,on4ont, m.a.de a mo'_ion tillat a NegativeUeclarat.ioii be filed, Her .motion Was secandod by Commissioner tax. AYES t Commissioners; Max, tanbert,i Gilbert, liselnntltt and ' Chairman Wheeler. NUNS: No one. 1j ABSNT No one. Motion carried t111�e1't L# not,iiig that a NeiAtiVe Decl.aratl,lbn I;F.� #o be fixed, and i inditi,, tixat the proposed use of the, proper»;ty Ssxj�l not impair the i`ite rit i t;hatgthe' uso�woulda'totrbe�W re yincompatible.irj o.so�na'bl. with ar zn'urxous zone an whrh flys ,hand leas end t'o, s`u,rrounding properties rsr;.detr�.monta7l- to the health and general WbIfar,o of the persons resifiiitg 04 working, in th.e neighborhood or to the genoral health, wolfa.re rind ;6afoty of tihO Countyo made: mot'on, for &pproval subject to the following �yo�t�iti or,s aXX seconded.) 1. U)Xe permit limited tti ,:, V� period of one yoaic. 2, Any 'signs used to �doAlflf , the sales office or to`ae"'Verti� � � i the deelopment to bre r and red Ithen, the perolt expires , 5e;' i Applicant must also ccimpl,y with all ot)+ r appl icabl.e _STate," BUTTE COUNTY"PLANNING COMMISSION' MINUTES } Dotember 12., 1975 and local lytat�4tes, ordinances and ogulations,. p1`.1^, + ,. • t + ' , " ns - ... sty - - t AY �.O+�mma SS.Lonors 'eta , tam b���, G I eit; -be'e�t a�i�� „ Charman Whoololl. NOLSZ No one. r ,ABSENT ' No o ne Motion carried., d', Paradise Grange - Use Permit to allow, a.meeting hall o property zoned "A,2 Ltd." located approxim to400 feet y north Of Pearson Riad, approximately so p;feet east of Academy Drive, identified as AP S4 -04X26 r Paradise. 80- 52-1-16 �s . Mrs. Blair read staff findings. Dick Moicor comnientod that Negative Declaration hadbeen recommended. proponents: Gary McCullock, t resenting the applicant, said that Academy YDrive is a pec vats road a,.:d that thoxe woro-,no plans;,!, to paire the parka.n lot. Opponents. No one. The hearing Was closed. C0141m,�ssj.oner tai -V4 finding that the proposed project cou].d not havo t j de a motion that villxsnmotxon bcn Negative a.xatcant g ,x, , _ ,. b tiled As seconded by' Comma ssz,onor Lambert a AYB ;y Commissionors Ma.x$ Lamhext, Gilbert, .Sennett anA Chairman .Wheeler NOS S : No one , ABMT No one. Motion cariied, Commissionern6ting Max, then n6ti,n that a No at,;iVe Declara�>zatY, xs' to be g tie �� , filed, and finding that the proposed d use of the rirapeywty �Vilf not impair tine integrity and chavacter of the tone in whiicl-h the, land, lies and that the U$b Would, not be onrea8onably i comjjatiblo t�t,it'h or injurious to surrounding properties or dotrimentat to the heSr+`Lth and geftC'val wa1fave Of the porsons residing, or worki—a in the rto e lfedsaile yo9 County, made amotion-Papplovalsubject the condi ilOns I. Deed to the County of Butte a dvainsge easement fo!r the crOkl BUTTE COUNTY PtANNYNG COMIAISkON: MINUTES - December 12, 10`79 On the east: property line, easement stall bo off' sufficient,r N :asc�t�o pravadf,io�r G]xa`o. an access; yraa.44 v S Z Provide a permanent solution for drainage, $abmit conal approval, and: installrequiredfacilities. � ks for structi,on and drainage plans to Department Of Public Works Applicant must also comply with all: other applicable State and local sItatutes, ordinances and. regulations, His motion was seconded by Commissioner Lambert, Commissioners Max, Latnl�rrt, Gilbert, Bennett and AWL'S. Chairman Wheeler. N(JhS ; No Ono. A1SLN1` No one. Motlpn ca.rrie,d► DorisMiller - Use permit to allow prof essli�ri€�l Offices on property y zoned '�Ii- C" (�Iig'�tvay- C;atnmex; c al ) 1�icat+ecl thegst corner of Foothill, Blvd, and 'Orovil,le- ',Bangor RlglWay, identified as AP 36-71-5, Oroville 80,52- ,,t260 read staf� l.n�.yn�st�m, Mrs We" rgpo�ted tfl.at a Negative n.�eclaratian had 'been reoiten-dod, J'oh saidthere' n Olit)onneli, 106 Oro Bangor Highway, next door to this proposal, d are 18 families in 'this little 8Ubd.iVision with 22 children, 750 of which are undar 8 years ol.tl *find that there is great concern about additional: tral+fi that tvc;uld be generated. He also saw:d that the Public deport made no menti,om of the H-�C zoning P and the homes in the subdivision ;fere purchased, by people who were )} under the impresseion that they were in aresidential zoning area,, He expressed concerns that aesthetics would deter6o7rate if this com- mercial ventUtre is allowed, IIo emphasized, the fact -that he was ,and f0f. bthers hue nabl,erto attende thetmoetiftgenc e against tiffs prod eot IGath O otrnei l 1.06 Oro Bangor Highways commented that the applIca.nt Owns: property, acT.oss� the sttOet that oT ce housed a real ost.ate office. use of the ,pt•opert will impair the iht, y . CoMmitsipher Gilbert finding that the proposed �arl.ng tvas closed The e }� egrxt and charact,ex of the tone in whiith the land,lies and. that the use would be unreasonably e! _l +` " _ , f BUTTE COUNT' PLANNING COMMISSION t` MINUTES W December 12, 197 incompatible with and injurious to surrounding; piropertie,n. and det- " xe�.meAt` 1 to thl 110,4 0 ac d ` or working in, the neighl)o�hoad and.. to. the general beat ,' welfare ani ��e faty of the Cqunty, made to inota on for den i a,l . His mo'ta on was seconded by Commxsslon' ov tbanett AM Commxgsioners 13ennett, Max, Lambert, Gilbert and Glaaix�mx?1 �+iheel;x: NOBS Na one. ABSENT No once Motion carried,- MHNTAL DOCrTEi�� ON `19HICH Ef3VYR0 HAVE NOT MMM��2 :1. Larry Featherston - Shelton Reale - U`se Realty permit to allow a 126 unit; mobile home park on pror'etty zoned #►A-211 (General) located approximately 700 feet vest ajEsplanade tend apProximatel . 800 feet north of Tanea Way, identified as AP 44-41-.31,, Gh�co. : Mrs. Mair explainedpt��`variartcesmustbe conat as a result sidered all W,Iicationause xmits/ `for by the Planning Commission within one'year, of the time of the receipt of the application o a.nd a�1od that this appla.ca:tion was �recexvecl on January 8, 1979. Tn the absence of communication front the applicant or presence of hili or his xepresentative at the meeting, Commissioner Lambe , 1 made a motion that this matter be continued until January-2s 1980 to give the applicant another opportunity to make his wishes known. Her motion,Wa,s seconded by Commissioner Bennett: AYES Commissioners Max, Bennett, Lambert Gilbert and Chairman Wheeler,' NOES; No one. At8E No orte Motion carried: 1 BUTTE COUNT` PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - December 1.2 1079 A. CONSIDER SETTING PUBLIC 'UtARXNG 'TO CONSIDER IZE CA ON OR OD `OF U II,.PEWIT 1, l�nthony William MaxCs Use permit to allow body sha0 on the north side -of ,Orovil.le Dam Blvd. Wdsto approxima Gly 400 ft. east of 12th St. Oroville, AP 50-195.14 .:. (CONTXNUED PROM NOVEMBER 28 MEETING); 80LL32w2�15 Motion was made by Commissioner Gilbert, seconded by Commissioner Bennett to instruct staffto sett a public hoarinB for the cow.tldera.tion emit, hearing of revacata,on or modification of this use pg Janu 2, 1980. AXES; Omlalss, overs Gilbert, Lamborn Maxi Sennett and Chairman Wheeler, NOES No one. ABSENT: No one, Motion carried. 2. Rev. K. O. BdCkstrartd - AP 5b-0$2-19 N Use permit for church .issued in Iuly 10,65 does not inal A scho:ol whiih he is Operating z_ 80w32-2�5�' MotionMotionwas made by Commissioner:' Max, seconded by CamDnis,4i on6� Gilbert, to instruct staff to .set a publ"' hearing dor J'vinizatry 16,; l $0 to cons de revocation or mod llcdtiun of thus use permit. AYES . Comm ss' oners 'Gilberto t 6illbert, Max, Dennett, and Chairman . _ ��heel.ex. NOES'. No one. ABMT No cine Motion carried'. Vx . ADT ITEMS i2� w BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COM1�1> SSIt i'1 M1N1.T1','5 - December 17 A. PARADISE IRRIGATION DISTRICT iZEZONg :REQttT?S"i' n A letter from C ',''1?hi�1�.�5 1Cellyo Jr ts: Paradise Irrigation 1)ist,rict, reciuest ng thatatl�eht� County rezone AP 50-11.�-25 from P�Q to RT -1 had boon submitted to tht) Comm .ss avers Motion Was made by Commiss=colter Gilbert, second --d by G"Oi11)Pi8sioner Bennett, th4t the request be denied. AYVS t Commissioners Bennett, C i.lbert, Lambert,, 1 x and Chairman Wheoler. NO88 No ore, B8riNT No one Motian carried, SATE OF COUNTY PROPERTY AP Mrs. Blair reported that there is a request :from the Publ�e Warks Department tii=jt the abovo—lefer� need parcel be dor�la and be sold byPublic bid, red surplus i + Motion was made b Cammiss�anor Gilbert, seed)zdod by Commissioner Bennett, that this Property's sake at publid bid Would tie in con- form * with the General P'-lan . AYES: Commissioner Gilbert Mdx Lambert, 011b Wheeler, � � ert and Chairman No ane ABUXTt No ane Motion carrieu. V'11. ADJOURNMENT' hero being no further business the meeting rias ad'ourned at 1(),03. TAPp , 80-51-1 �6