Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES & AGENDAS 3-3-77 -- 4-11-77
BUTTE COtWTY PLIA-N�;ING COMMISSION SPECIAL MEETING March= 3, 1977 Mi;NUTES 77-66-1-340 I- PLEDGE OF ALLEGIALTCE II. ROLL CALL: Present: Commissioners Camenzind, Gilbert, Moore,; Smith, Thebach and -Watson Absent: Commissioners Watters., Le Clerc and Chairirna;,. Hanford Also Present: Jim Lawson., Bail Gaiser, Rel Siemsen, Sim Sk,j eistad (Chico Enterprise Record) and Hazel Dallas TTI. IkPPROVAL OF YLUNUTES Minutes of February 24,; 1977were approved a4 submitted- Then Nr. Camenzind requested that the State Park boundaries be checked in connection; with the abandonment of the public roadway as req;zested by Continental out Company, Page 4 p Y., EV. PitBLIC HEARIvCS--GTTF COUNTY GEIERAh PLAN A. seismic Safety Element B. Safety Element G Noise Element, Its Scenic Hi'hways Element It was explained that this is a special meeting called by the Board of Supervisors in order to consider proposed changes recommended by the -Roard and by a committee composed of ? members of the 'Board and some private Citizens. fir. Gaiser presented to the Commission copies of proposed changes and minutes of the starch 1, 1971 Board m--eting as prepared by him. Commissioner Smith questioned (714) that it was possible for this Commission to realistically assess the impact of these changes,. 'at this tine,, when t ey had been, received just a; few minutes ago . Cont- - missioner Thebacb commented that it did not seem fair that the Commission is being used as a yo-yo,_ C647 After some discussion as to proper procedure, it was decided to review all changes mentioned above and attempt to make a compasit list of recommendations. 1 i r LI -PIANNING COMMIiSSION.RECOMMENDATIONS . MARCH 3, 1977 TOble II=2 SEISMIC SAFETY ELEMENT NPIDINGS hoLICY IMPLEMENTATION, 1. Butte Counter is in an area of known 1. Inform the public of current 1. Approve and oublisit this Man faults and recent seismic activity. estimates of seismic hazard in element. Keen the information w. all harts of the Countyi up-to-date, ?,r The only known active fault in butte 2. 'rake into account all known 2a. Consider the most rocnot information County is the Cleveland Hill fault seismic information in making on seismic hazard in all xanina and near Orovi lie. A number, of faults land use decisions. Avoid subdivision decisions, in or near the County should be locatino schools, hospitals, consi ,iered Ootentiall.v active. The -public buildinns and similar nroximity of the San Andreas fault uses in known fault areas. Sys tom 1s rienerally s. i q n i`ieant in ovaluatinn seismic risk in the `r b. Rdoui re an;Iaronri ate detailedsoi smi t> investticrations for all public and -.r• private oroject5 in locations Of kohown seismic risk. 3' The area around the Cleveland Hill' 1. Follow the policies and criteria 3. Exercise approval 'authority with rosrr.c atilt has been dhpi�tnated as a "' established by the State Mining to all real eStale Jc.velonnlent altl Soccial Studios 7nn* under the and Ceolonv I -turd witliin the structures for human occupancy within Alouist-Priolo Ac's, i:ffectiva Snocial Studies 7one. the S�iecial Studies 70no, a$ nrovird(!d Oonuaev 1 , 1977p (Chapter 7.5, by Stato Late, ,�Pi division 2, Citlifornia Coda. 4. Portions of the Satramcnto Vailley, 4, Considoi; linuefaction potential 4. Require Aoprol riato design of structon tS hAvr a rionerally hinh notontial in makiho to d use decisian5 suscootible to the effects of au Jnr 1irfun,faction duHnq a major liquo f8tt'ion U eaf`hnilake + r w }/fes BUTTE COUNTY PLANY.ING.MMUSSION SPECIAL NIEETI G - March �fI�L�'iE:S - B- SAFETY ELEMENT Motion was made -by Commissioner with,, seconder; by Commaisssi rf er . Thebac , to recornmend adoption of this element - ith changes aG shovin in Table III -1. GEOLOGIC HAZARD SU9-ELEt6MV'1' (Page S of these minutes AYES: Commissioners Ca-y-enzird, "Toore, Smith,. Thebac r,, Watson and acting chairman, Gilbert. NOES No, one AB T C'otp-miss:ioners Le Cl erc ,, Watters and. Chairman Hanford_ M6tion carried - 'Motion was trade by Commissioner Smith, seconded by Commissioner Moore, to recommend adoption of this element with changes as shown in Table III- -IRE HAZARD SUB�ELENMNM ' (Pages: 6 7 o,-1-7 these ?ikin-ute5) . AM: Corfzti•s%ioners ua?;eTl ii2d "•ioore, Swith, ThebaChy -"i son and acting chairman Gilbert.;' NOES: Na one. } ARSENT,T`: Commissioners he Clerc, Watters and. Chairman Hanford. Motion carried. x � x RECESS: -9:35 P. M. . MEETING RECONVENED 9;54 P . AM - Commissioner Thebach did not: return to the meeting after reds_ j I f L 1'Er ?1 rM „I 1141 GtOLootc tIAZ RQijfSuV, t4EMENT1113 rirfblmris POLICY _ 1M.PLCMlaPiTAT IOil 1� Tha idelit ification of geolortic I. Inform the nuiyl ±t of known 1, Approve and Publish the hazard hazards is in the Public ins geologic hazards, mans in this Mari elOment ter, st< recogi Wnn that thi;; mw) iss general and oath site mus tR be JudoO on its individual merit. hoep the information un-to-date, 2, naoiogic hozards limit^, lr,n w Consider neolooic hazards lkll' P. Oetermioe apnrojlriato uses f6r dovolonrront capabilities, development of Land Use, high haz;�tr+d arras. Cstablish Housi nri, Ci rein ation o C,onsor. limits on the density.Ind f v'rio, vation and Orwns Soace Llrment`. of development nort+tiirtod in hinh hazard areas. 3. The task of landslides is aJ-0at 3. Consider landOido notontial ih R,onuirr, inv(?5t;iqatio'4- of .lan�i,li,rr. es t in arera5 with s1 oons ovor rovi ew of ori vato delvol oomant notenti al for r)r,onosed )mont \ 15+', weak rock, and hiolt rain- and oublic facilitlr<.s in saris Present findings in ��r�,ir\cn;sl�it�r1 fall, rated 4 and r On HAD Illi-14 review and subiJiviotrrr rhevic,^O,t � ?hr re I o sitrfavc ma to al 4a Go aror,�on noto11tial 1n `� t,en uire ' 'investi�aa'r�, or r ri+r rain a11d water varies by review of nrivato dnveloornnnt notentia`l for ororio�,%, i r1c�d�1"nor>1,r,n t. Slane, $oil , voocto kicin, tlroci n,- and oulrl i c favi I i tr os in ar oaaq Prcrtvn t fl ndinnr, i n till i r oo"'cn tial -+ itati.oh and davcIommn1,: It is rated Mirth rind vory hioli (1n 1�ovieryr and subdivision 1*00",cr^ri r r"'; +greatest in ary tis of nran i to rock Mart III\-2 tJ ri\ 1,rntrrld �urf�Ccs call5it1k �11d a� j �rea," : � Ott agkliMS 9UbSidr:ncc i r s. Holl 111kinn tis �'tnrC'"ry c+rust 5'irrnifiotnt d,�r�l+l rte inarrttis �Irrytrndwivatcr 1vitlrClraural and' Require ilrve5t rlatioll of suet;id��olco -. 1'11h t.ra th0. v 1s nxtonsivr: 14ith 0 i I all qaq t-11thdrollo1. noterttitil ill review of ilerlowl'od dr+rwill Of rlrouitd W-itce, oil r .t the cr1,�sarvration o1 alithd'rot1rtl", Pros"nt, r`ir\r!intjr, ill - C +rr1Ci �'j75c - orounrr wator from doelr we11 s for i.,n4�71 1"�V"1�r'7v ,arr��rlrt grana onvi roar u " lust' within tho CtruniV6 , •, , orojeC l.s to br ina arrrfsic4 +^.7 r;i 1nb Butte rount'v 1-IllereevnV4 R,osr,ihle, 4° a q i h y 1111 rl+r i t\ 1� \ 'I110V arO'lG ri L clay C Pratett (10Yr-IOilrr0.nt in 110 lev C: lion i ttrr ,itrini;inrt and swel1 incl aa z, •.s.� rs Soi 1s have a hi+1h 110tonti trl arras with exP41151 vo ,oils. 110cotsdrv, itPolui ro mi ti oa ti+"'a r \. Htrr structural damatte+fot�rrr for s i j r N \ y ml�arr �rvrelnwrurrl.s �rnr1 .,nil :.hrinkin and srr411in1 foc�7ti�Jnett r nnt;onti+i1 for 5i(in i Picaht r+AMAno \ t. l�rtr orltor` it t. 't1(,ak I)or",inr'lx %. AlIFhn"t llr'rrrlOtit Of 't?'r't�►ii` OCPvOOon 7. r117oorr nroi;ti?l"'irr 41 { 1 r r v{ ca its es .,i ni f,jC'I11t r'roD foil t'rnri '' ckri�tra� hro��k!cts \�Itt w`i r�:.r;- �.. , , � n other roblz.ltts for vial Io farini'n to r, :I �• E:rr0l)l iata r�ethods+ �upportt r areas dam tir01dCt9 ill 1110Vtirorn Ca 11f01'11ia rrlriclr ar% � +rr+ticikj1 t:o r,r=rsitill ;. :. ap i.11.4 Delete spocial leq��nd and designation for Paradise. Indicate Paradise as ilicah hazard (1ight oranclo 0.0 o x h i b 1 ;fi Table 111"3i FT REQ IIAZA'RD SUD-ELS ENT OI NGS POLICY t„ Sr1wr11LNTAT 10IN f 1. 11o:it of the County has a natural fire hazard of at Make protection front fire hazards- a consideration in .1. Consider fire 115zards in x'11' land " least mode,•ate severity. Nearly Nearly all of the foothill all olannino reaulator,y,,. use and zonino decisions, environmental ruviewr subdivision and mnuntain areas Have and capital imnrovement programs, with soecial concern review and the nyovision of public servicer„ hazards of hiqlr or oxtreme for areas of ►"hi -oh° and Severity, "extreme" fir' hazard. Thenumber of fire r,es is alonqwithth� 2. Provide vfire tection sericos in � Identify epere It and future limits increasing numbers of visit)rs all areas _ of population nrowth and high afadequatcfirerlroi:ec'tian service 5, Guide, develonment to rind residents in the:' County. recreation use. those areas through zoninrl, and develoomr„fit review liroces,(21s, 3, Residential develonment is accurrinrt in the mtyuntailroua 3. Limit dovelonment where natural fire 3. Zone high end axrtrcmc natural fi'r0' t6w areas of the Countlt 1�rherr. hazards are high or extreme Until adenuate fire l roto ctith 11azards areas which are inadequately r.ro tented for l oj,) resi ciantial ”` natural fire haznrlis are hinh eKt1`0me and whare fire is nrov'ide'd. densities only, Provido no rjow nr�otection fac`I li tit:; are hublio faciIitieS ithai; c:r1�oClrar�r ;` w cirailth �r1 these ar,.��,, r,xcenU irhos� mostly inadequate anti di ffieul t to provide, essential to public safety. ; moi ' d': ' Venetat�on' is the crlt7cal factor in ii Q. w Use fuelhreaks alone the. dqe 4'. � +� r1°'C! f'K,aselal��+ Renuir•e foolbraaks .h re` srlread. of develonino ar"e�js 1t within "hi nh" and "extremoll firm, and "extreme" fire hazard areas. hazard areae,,, Enforce renulartir►rls ' 011 vegetation clearance around structures, u `�c� h i f+.1c11ities ►t re lire nrotr, end ryinal in some~ l�clr►nn or, mar Y.. Attarnnt to upgrade fere scryicc there r. Promote formiltion of vnluntar,, fil,r) '+1r% areas Of the County, eoohomicall ea Y feasible. ca mi)Anios in rtrnrote +ureas, C.6nstrucn Arldi ti onal foci l i ti es and servi cies as desired )bY arra rotidents and as rsrrsnnrnically feasible, Dr�vr:lryl1rrrrnt in rc5r.tavoir 1v�1ti�1"W si�lo�is leads. to fires, irl�ch G� L-init rlevelopllrehl; in' a r�eservair4 C, ,i C"�`opare zcrninrl �1t1rt far cl�tir;K11 ' z threateh community water supplies, WatOrsheds to a level that will not lead to degrodation of waters11e ar`CaS, COnsidew, Boa ill C? r 1 wateN sU01IY. danla � rater es to ► SI10d in OnvirQnll'lenta+l re vi errs SPECIAL �'-IEETINn' ;.;p to to E3 G .7 r'� Z:f- --.I : : :r. ' s r rl `. ::. Cs fit 0 ra - ►*+ _/• Wit. C T J'. - Cs :i Cfi'.r. - J`... r} 70 tF .9 "}.. i3C. ;t t= Q. C- �. ;� G'i: �: iy ;i. ri �.:. a^.+ = . ' r+ c-1'1.-0� it :f- CjZ7 rte: -C - i} �• �. �+ 'rn .r. (� >.: 3? . CT 0- 0 CL .. i .:. r".. is }: •' '.CS- _:.N �1 i,i .�, 1; - Q-' - Gx to Q /.L� r'. Li ,f• < -+x G _r, ra ra cfa LTi f,`..:1F ct rka, -=F, :ri h m - s -i T C3 Z. C i 'S. ur 1u tr Z iII =MO r3 cr a rz 4= n a Z CiQ co- Jt:. J -13. Q - Q C'!< cr' < !t' r3! ct iZ�, �:%: .�'. -:ay: trl1: �.-ir} aii. -aCi Q,. - Q rJ' S •. 'ice w - .� fJ L �! .3 rte+% .� i:�: 1 c rsr "rf r3 of -•> .Y Q : a ct- C" C+ Q < cr - t C7 S f- o r3 - +�` r. Q+ •.> CT �: Q Q .moi' -T i :s C =T �' ril �. i V Q. Y ifs o X10 :3 3: Ca CT LF S ii s tlY C3' iS fY L7`. L'1 .t -TL r'1 C! c i Q rr Y7' rls' M f _ t"t to j. - �s co -.s -- --z3 r3 zl--a o' es Q :D ja 1 CD aY C' C'!' s3 -+ C3 "S 0 Cin S+ « -s -,:) (n; -s: C a i3 - c, Q sem. = `: -• �J: ..J«-i ir+' Q'. �f:: J'. - .�f J. ., x^a �Y. �,j. 'y �.t.. �J' (jk. J. v. CD G -20, 0 rD r zx �, .�. ". rs r s .^•7 6 i"3' . vj' G'i en :Qck a n v r- _,'} il: C F ) 1,. Lm:, 0: ,.._ — v C7 C I r to ^J -x Ci'" G .`= rs i3 Q 1. c'r o - �. <-!, CJ :L'S 0 _s. cl- r7fi��-:S o-cvc�r� - .-. C. i':' ..� is <. moi' rr.•k rx __ s" Q. U7 th Ln CI- CK cj ��. -h rt- 3 vk e'ta U). Table IV-6. BOISE f:1.tMEN P O L C Y'., 1, 'Objectionable noise from trans- 7;, Maintain an acceptable nois4e en- 1 Adoot a County noise ordinance.- liortation facilities and vi`ronment n,,AlI areas of the County, C-onsider noise lovols in environ- stationary sources can have a I„ental rovieVl. Where possible, significant impact on public mainta11n noiso levels recommended health an.' welfare. b rigLIVO 1\1-7.'Land Comoa�ti-' unit�,Ilse Environments. 2. Some aspects of tronsportation 3, Where possible, cont-roll the Z.State and Federal reovidtions for eci noise can be controlled sources of transportation noise reducino transportation noise, y the County.to i�,, the b" maintain accel)tahle levels. Consider noise in the loeatioii rind design of Cnr unty roads. Locate fl i (Olt from ai rcraft oaths aviay develoned arc:as shore fea,gWew, 3. Tae'oIonment alongraiI roae and 3. Discow or., resid development, 3. Consider noise sources in revieet of hi gilways can cause a s'i gr w ant and o not se, oe acti Vi ti VS zoni lift and r, obdi vi s i oii nronns al s noir r7rb; lem, near i, loads a ;+z�,YS: Lacate noise s011fltivc= usr:s 0'117 t -+ frem rai 1 roads and 0 ohwa,ys r ;t d, Development ricar aircraft flight 4,. Plan for aA rnor_t devcl on nent and '4:Locate noise sensitive uses ,�t'ra+r tlati1 stii)iects i�tnsrlrx to01;iectit�nw clisr,auradr� nuisc�set51t7ve from airports, Pr`opare snecifi; able- noise tend thrc+ri tons future air., acti vi ties near a i rnort.�, Iii i"hart l:`,l�ri rens i�l ahs for Chico nort oncrations incl Cl'rovi'i le �tirllorts, Cn::r�uranr. Id ts compatible uses around al6rta, ' U .� '5 5, ,. omo tvpos of recroatlonal 5, Conf:iol retreat i oil lcti v7 ti rs 5. lel rice limit", on tine l ovcl s of acti vi ties mato oh,lectiona ile that havo the potential to cause amol i fi nd ,:rund and the time and �, nb1sc.; Oi),7or�iollc�hlo no1SC locatdon o!,' outdoor concert",) aULO .� ., and iliatorc"cle rare„,�i1ti similar noisy anti vi ties. Identify locatiolT �. for such acti vi ties that are comnctt — able with tho nublla hoalth, We fara and safet v, -c�� U G . Stryte lcr)�sation (ecru ros l G Provide un dD noise contours G, Develop 00 0 noise contours noise insulation of new multi- around all major sourcd54 oround major sourcesi';llere this fami l'v dwol I inns cons tructed information is not ornsen tl v '_ within the 0 r18 nOSO, exposure oval able, con tours 'iaFrl�c lV-6 ' N01ST ELEMENT (contin le 7. Noi ae pr.obloms boundaries, _trosA rIj ty .' ! 4 Coo crag S�ti th *he i ncorsiQrat^d p `' 7', "� nrla� �on�att f . . i►iro r�ta�1 on C,ti@5 to, r�'5ql,VC mlltUi�l ilgjS�' .change n015G CO ntj of � r hrq_�ert�. prUgr�m�COfl1(lai.ible T1s the County Brows and acti - 8, Keep the Noise Element current 8. M6ni for changes in noise l evkrl s. VitieS environment' wi se ll ha l toi chani t i With �;har, tinct conditions. Update noise Contour data; ol w � CJ tt1 I W V 6-3 t6 i V f i4TERPRETATION NORMALLY ACCEFT ABLE. Specified land use is sarisfactory, basrd' upon the assumption that anybuifdings tmol'ved are of normal cocventionaf corsrruction,without anyspecial noise insutation regr:irements. CONDITIONALLY .ACCEPTABLE New, coristruction or d_eveiopmmt,shocrl�t be undertaker ontya�era dr��sxitatvsis of ttee noise reduction rc,4u"rre eats is made <n3 pee4ed no€� m'asulatiott fatures included +!rL'='Z'oign_ Conventional construtavor,but with dossed. windows and fresh air supply systems or air conditioning. will:awmzlly sur.I= '. NORMALLY UNACCEPTABLE, New construction or development should: generally be discouraged_ If ere.. construction a: developtrent does proceed, a detailed -analy*- of the noise reduction requirements must be made and needed noise insulation features inc'l'uded in the design: CLEARLY UNACCEPTABLE New ca:tstruciiorror development should' generally not be undertaken. r CO:NSIDEftAT'iONS TM DETERMINATION OF '_BIOS-SE—COMPA'T€BLC LAND :USE A.NORIM L2EDNOISEEXPOSUREINFOXMATIONDESMED, munityNoise Exposure A.reas greater than 65d8`sbooldSediscour Wherest; ffC.ent4araexists,cvafu22eIY du-,c,—:abIitVwItkrr_prct [ CQ .MUMTk *,0€SE EXPOSURE to--v-m-Matired"value: ofCNEL.ar Len tarralz ;�aruesg..2 I Ldst OR CNEL, dE. LAND �'S€ CATEGORY � 55 1- 55 70 '!rS 80 RESID£ :TIAL— LOVA DE +SV # `..,,..,. SINGLE FA•SULY, DUPLFX, The ~bad Use n4:sr iampit='�Jliit� TCL6RtneTtt aliflr iSIWU!C ¢e YI[ti G� i. MOWLE HOMES able di Lance to a noise sourcm - - r - - t r t € Rt:SrOENTFAI.-!.IULTI_FA,+f v D s_CEt'TA£LECsi'i3C?ORE�Yint}ti�!��FTS feat~ Z> -ArlC noise Act USM - Y 65 d9 CN, LL g.3. tr Crit vo i _hk.S a 7 .- ^ " r rt f< g t +[ci t•: A rQ+tr.r=n4e Zito -S. saltich 4M 1 aI-z c rrr^j n1des it [on v`Si't"^� TRA.N$1ENT r 0DGSNG! :• �. is the-dC_i•Cv.r 3�-a{c[p'+:10c. ctl:doar in P�•r(.�-nett tnamtraftnoiSG. Flt older`rafac-,trr IFezu ansrsalt:r i.:t. CT -;)f M0TE1_5, HIOTELS rrhk!iis LUCnc",-JqC ra-Suscs-cc--nyat of W: t- ;hr-55ea CIVELi`rtiT j + sr`arer ors wher, toosa'air and irro.i'_..a .`a:«I �„c! r 1_'"4TV of p tccea:_^" ` �r -h`lt.and use !a baa as< 1 SCHOOLS, MBIZA RIES, f CHURCHES. HOSPITALS, NsRSING HOMES 6 �' AUDI T(fRCtpbSS„CONCERT v •'i�:r_'/;tri".�::� ••...f f Y:fAI LS-,AA'.PHITHEATRES i SPORTS' ARENA, OUTDOOR ,r�1 �,f ,z r�,.• 'l:Wl SPECTATOR SPORTS PLAYGROUNi1S, VEIGMEG. jODPARRS GULF COU9SES, FUDNNG l t: , t STABLES.`r4ATER RECREAT€ N+i t t CEME€ER?ES OFFICE SLI DWGS,.BUSINESS COMMERCIAL AND PROFESSIONAL INDUS E RtAL, NVANUFs C7•URING UTFL€ MS. AGRICULTURE i4TERPRETATION NORMALLY ACCEFT ABLE. Specified land use is sarisfactory, basrd' upon the assumption that anybuifdings tmol'ved are of normal cocventionaf corsrruction,without anyspecial noise insutation regr:irements. CONDITIONALLY .ACCEPTABLE New, coristruction or d_eveiopmmt,shocrl�t be undertaker ontya�era dr��sxitatvsis of ttee noise reduction rc,4u"rre eats is made <n3 pee4ed no€� m'asulatiott fatures included +!rL'='Z'oign_ Conventional construtavor,but with dossed. windows and fresh air supply systems or air conditioning. will:awmzlly sur.I= '. NORMALLY UNACCEPTABLE, New construction or development should: generally be discouraged_ If ere.. construction a: developtrent does proceed, a detailed -analy*- of the noise reduction requirements must be made and needed noise insulation features inc'l'uded in the design: CLEARLY UNACCEPTABLE New ca:tstruciiorror development should' generally not be undertaken. r CO:NSIDEftAT'iONS TM DETERMINATION OF '_BIOS-SE—COMPA'T€BLC LAND :USE A.NORIM L2EDNOISEEXPOSUREINFOXMATIONDESMED, munityNoise Exposure A.reas greater than 65d8`sbooldSediscour Wherest; ffC.ent4araexists,cvafu22eIY du-,c,—:abIitVwItkrr_prct aced and consderedlocated within normallyum,,zept2ble areas. to--v-m-Matired"value: ofCNEL.ar Len tarralz ;�aruesg..2 I nti:aincdbytcIsun: sdesccr e! l inTable I CySUITAS( F WTERIOR LtiklROHMEhT5 to tS;e Tcasuredof calccla•crtvarural CNEf or L`tr. i4TERPRETATION NORMALLY ACCEFT ABLE. Specified land use is sarisfactory, basrd' upon the assumption that anybuifdings tmol'ved are of normal cocventionaf corsrruction,without anyspecial noise insutation regr:irements. CONDITIONALLY .ACCEPTABLE New, coristruction or d_eveiopmmt,shocrl�t be undertaker ontya�era dr��sxitatvsis of ttee noise reduction rc,4u"rre eats is made <n3 pee4ed no€� m'asulatiott fatures included +!rL'='Z'oign_ Conventional construtavor,but with dossed. windows and fresh air supply systems or air conditioning. will:awmzlly sur.I= '. NORMALLY UNACCEPTABLE, New construction or development should: generally be discouraged_ If ere.. construction a: developtrent does proceed, a detailed -analy*- of the noise reduction requirements must be made and needed noise insulation features inc'l'uded in the design: CLEARLY UNACCEPTABLE New ca:tstruciiorror development should' generally not be undertaken. r CO:NSIDEftAT'iONS TM DETERMINATION OF '_BIOS-SE—COMPA'T€BLC LAND :USE A.NORIM L2EDNOISEEXPOSUREINFOXMATIONDESMED, munityNoise Exposure A.reas greater than 65d8`sbooldSediscour Wherest; ffC.ent4araexists,cvafu22eIY du-,c,—:abIitVwItkrr_prct aced and consderedlocated within normallyum,,zept2ble areas. to--v-m-Matired"value: ofCNEL.ar Len tarralz ;�aruesg..2 nti:aincdbytcIsun: sdesccr e! l inTable I CySUITAS( F WTERIOR LtiklROHMEhT5 to tS;e Tcasuredof calccla•crtvarural CNEf or L`tr. One o5iearre arlocatinS resident:af units relative to a kno-n noise , - - source is to maintain a suitable interior noise environment at no 8. NOISE SOURCE QJ4.% LI ERIST!CS- graterthan 4S eS CNEL of Ldn. This requirement; co Ved.nth The ~bad Use n4:sr iampit='�Jliit� TCL6RtneTtt aliflr iSIWU!C ¢e YI[ti G� the r�su� or gAtculared noise, reduction pCKa;; i of the type; O 1LrUC1Ltc under consideration. 1hould'ZovT n the lrtinfrnum accapr in fctaticrt tJ_ tli. SpeclfiiC s>1r:fCc 9f tl1t '*?:s.. r arrtampiz, alrctarr able di Lance to a noise sourcm - - a_'..! CaiifQad .fro}Se i$ nrrt 3'tyrtlde up oa higBCr strtjre' no'w evrm's - - ; t r arta traffic but or. +a trs rreque-WIN. "TherzfSre. different Saurtr<ytcidingthe sarse°co=posttens!ze4porue1anet necesFzt"Iy D s_CEt'TA£LECsi'i3C?ORE�Yint}ti�!��FTS feat~ Z> -ArlC noise Act USM - Y 65 d9 CN, LL g.3. tr Crit vo i _hk.S a 7 .- ^ " r rt f< g t +[ci t•: A rQ+tr.r=n4e Zito -S. saltich 4M 1 aI-z c rrr^j n1des it [on v`Si't"^� t"w.'t;it'tsrlltj,r^5A1....s3t.,C.^.lTf1C:2'G[sEC'r'Sar[. M.dt3�e YXr,`'aSti'e :• �. is the-dC_i•Cv.r 3�-a{c[p'+:10c. ctl:doar in P�•r(.�-nett tnamtraftnoiSG. Flt older`rafac-,trr IFezu ansrsalt:r i.:t. CT -;)f 4!!JM.t«.ig 11!be'case, rf;nr.:!K4 K sr.ndards .for fans uyer-tn- rrhk!iis LUCnc",-JqC ra-Suscs-cc--nyat of W: t- ;hr-55ea CIVELi`rtiT i'a}t E�!.j{ rJ.:?�v :IrG �a�r.T;i tII,^Y: Fled -rrcr.'�'-kr sr`arer ors wher, toosa'air and irro.i'_..a .`a:«I �„c! r 1_'"4TV of p tccea:_^" ` �r -h`lt.and use !a baa as< a:r tis- to,CaMplr x ihr XcY,.res•3cn,«t�uy[tta:at� .Cerz fj .,.e +, ., 1 a b,I e Y I t J Y� t{ ��t III 01114AY, L+�'�..r.�LN Tr .. . rI it nI NGS PPL I CY IL Mnl,RENTnT10N 1. Butte County has many areas of 1 Protoct V u 1e scenic, a.,r.ea%, 1. Consider develor�ment of a t'Vstem_, picturesque natural landscao6s4 for enjoyment by residents and of scenic highways, as indicated vi si tors. on man Val . ~ Consider addi'ti cnal designation of local streets in urban areas,. Ofelicia1 State designation of Z► Secure official Stato desig- i'ollow procedures in /lhrtend:ix E. scenic highways bettefits the nation of scenic hiollways local ,Gonia hi ghways proq' am adopted- in all or, Some of this and�renuires various County ._ element. act7onsr 3. Scenic corridor boundaries S Delineate scenic corridors with 3. Cr.ns der 5ta;to criteria, Survey should include areas visible from carefulconsideration of all scenic corridors. Soli ci t ci ti xen hinhways outstandinq natural factors, participation, Prepare "Scenic �. or man-made features, land where Ili ghway Report" for each corridor, development, ma-y affect views, and , oc feasible requlatory areas. r'n i 4. Ueveloliment of scenic highwav 4. Cons ider Iitv`' of visual 4. Rpr,u re Planning -,mmission annual riOhts-of-igav has siJ'nifican t impact landscape and driving ox- review of majuri `J nro,iocts to t on �aualit, � of vi,ual{landscarre and ode ence in desitln a'f' tlic include concern r,„r."�sccriic valur�s. Ult� drivinj experience, roadw4v and other features in the ri qhi-ofi-way. r. humorous vehicle access points S. Control acci ss to scaniC ✓. Utilize existing access whore along scenic hifillwava can impact I11011WAVs to maintain 'sc�;'ct)t feasible. 1.i111it encroachment driver safoty and comfort, and and quality of drivino nerinits for safety. roadside beauty, exncrience. w G. Ylir rrecr�7tive visual � of imnact G� . Locator and design utility G. Revie;v the location and desirin C) C) utility lines and StrUcturr«s ' structures str.JGtureS to ni7nirsi'ze i of major transmission lines, ,.40 can be mitigated by incoh- . _.i , visual impact. wheee Require the least conspicuous 1-41-4 snicuous siting Lind t}leasi'rtcl economically feasible, loctition of distribution lines, W '0 dos i on as feasi bid and where there i s 04ac c roasonahl choice. 7. Pr•otot.kiew or er-pnir, carridors 7, Maititain ccl'n►hatible land use 7, Amend Zorli nc► arrlira,,ince- to wnr►1ltinrr�rt1. it, laurel, dooviident on local PAtterns in scr:nic corridors. 1 County policy, lard use rehulations, .r. ` 0 N S, C9FIV%WAY LtM��i� v , U y , a, Official Statefrdesi,nation of � scenic highways requires de- 8. prepare snccif3c p1tins for each scerii c corridor, Survey corridors, prepare and.. tai 1'ed study and planriir�q of :. adont land W80 rehul ati ores, pl air scenti: corridors. development of ririht-of-t��av and other public fO,#-ilities.; w An effC.cti var s.cen7 � hi �htva,ys pro rain ti ui es +1 h r aliport 1t�ca1 9-, Invite citizen xen Marti ci pa -tion .� in 9. the scenic high, Indicate routes on public s _ maga ° i,yvolvement and suppor�, , wtys "rogrom, and plans n1aG,e '`nonpy" sinns on adopted routes, Encourage advertising by Chambers of Commerce and others, geek citizen parti ci na ti on in all asPects of Program, �..,,.. 1C pes lnation of a scenic h c�ht�ia!r `� cap affect the use and va,Ue�,cy+ 1p, Consider economic impacts on 10. In consideril7g any road designation ' . adjacent property.tray nronerty Pfecterl by a scenic c high- desivination, as a scenic hir�l1t�rav, a niIl7lic (tear- incl shall be hold and all ad,i,acent' property owners sha'11 be noui fi eu ; c of the public hoaring, by mail, in addition to general notices pub- ub- lished 1ished in a nrarsnaper of general circulation+ ca u ' �, Mw LU H U ZZ t BUTTE COUNTY PGAVNING' C©MIM SSIG -T SPECIAL MEETING March 3, I977 NIINUTES Tr.. Ga:iser called the Commission's attention to the recommended revisions to the text Portion of the Scenic Highways Element. � - Motion cvas made by Commissioner Smitn, seconded by Commissioner Watson, to iorrard this recommendation to Mr. GAiser and staff for V ein recommendations, if any, to the Board- AYES: oardAYES: Commissioners Moore, Smith., Matson and Acting Chairman Gilbert. NOES: C,=issioner Camehzind.. ABSENT: Commissioners he Clerc, Watters, Thehach, and Chairman Danford. lvTatson carried. V. ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 11:2 P. M. TAPE 77-66-1-340 2 tape fouled up 67 -1 -all 2 -all 69 -1 -all j Acting Chairman Gilbert 1311T` E COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION 11INUT1 S March Ill, 1977 77-68-2-00 Tiein * the only carryover from the pretriour Curitntission, Commissioner Gilbert ;*utned the 4uta,cs of� tamporory chairman 4nd asked for nominatia,ns for pormanonat chairman and vice chairman. Commissioner Bverhard l t 3iominat ion of George, or pprmapen,.t chairman was seconded by Commissioner Stuts. AYBS Commissioners Bennett, Trvorltc rj� Stuts and 111illiams NOES- Cotnan'.asianer GIlhert � ABSENT: No one �Jotio:n c.aj-'rind. Commissioner Stutz i:hon male ,a melt-jol�' xIaa o 0,or 3"ssioxer Bennett for vase chairman.. His m6tion tuns .otoconded ), �n,j� ,����°��no Ever'hnrcl AYES: commissioners Gilbert, Everhard, Stuts anal 1411', elf NOBS; Commissioner Bennett. ABSt3NT ! No One, Motion carried. I PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE, It.: ROLL CALL OR DULY CONSTITUTED COMMISSION Presentat Commissioners Bennett; Brorhft`Va StUts, Williams, and Chairman. Gilbert, Also presOnt: Jim Lawson, lel Siemsen, Hazel DallaLSL and Jim Skjclstad (Chico Lntorprise Rocord III, APPROVAL hnv Ml"Ni n Minutes for March 31 1,077 meo ting, avere appro}oed) as submitted) by, unanimous vote Chairman Gilbert introduced the Chairman oaf the Board of Supervisors Bernard Ri�htor, who read a statement welcoming the new Commissioners, outlining tihme duties facing v Commission and pledgang coperaonofthBoardofSuprvsors IV. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. APPEAL Olt BUTTE COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING ADJUSTMENT DECISION DBN INO V'AR CANC BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMM18SION MINUTES W March 10, 1977 1. Robort J. e, Jennie J DuBoso Rbquest -Variance to roar yard setback atb al.l,oai a building 2 feet ' from the property line on property zonod C-2 (Commercial) located on the sbuthW69t side Of State Highway 32, approx. 1/4 mile southeast of Linda Channel., identified as AP 42.14-13, C] icu Counsel cited Section 24-49 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance, reminding the Commission of the findings necessary in order to giant a variance Opponents: Robert DuBose, 2175 Nord Avenue, commented that without the requested variance the turning radius at the rear of the property in front of the building would be shortened from 67 to 42 feet, and `Tat the additional, 12 feet in the -rear would be useless. A A i s ', cussion regarding the placement of the buildings in any other place on the lot followed. In response to a ques;.ion.from Commissioner Shuts as to why the C-2 Ordinance called for a 1.2 ft. setback Mr. Lawson commented that it could serve as a buffer between the commercial and residential, uses and/or provide service access. Auer the ensuing disctassion regarding pronasions of the present Zonl-nm ssion'must:iactnon thervarianceeonthe theCbasisso;�n1awa the Com- mission ome law as it now stands Mri i10osp said 874 that the existing units had been buil a t � g t, when the ptopciAty was zoned A� 2, - than: the prbperty wag subsequently re- toned to S-9 and that when his request was made to rezone From S-R to C-2 th,-t he was not aware of the setback requirements in C-2, After furthor discuss.l,)n as to the possibility of recommending changes in the C-2 Ordinance, the hearing was closed. Commissionr Everhard being unable to make the necossary findings ;For approval of the vavi.ance request pursuant to the enabling ordinance, made a motion to deny it His motion was seconded bv Commissioner Stutz, AYBS: Commissionr es Bennett, Lverlia.ru Stwut�s, Williams and haiman NO;r8 No one, AB8MT 6 No one. Motion carried The applicant: was appraised of the appeal por od �2 B4 x�; COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - March 10 1977 V ADD ITEMS A. 'ROAD -NAME CHAN03S IN' PAHADTSI? Mr. Lawson reported that the Department of Public Works had requosred i commission review of the proposed changes for the Paradise area to enable the Board to seta public hearing on Tuesday, March:;l$$, f Supervisor Lemke suggested that the Commission hold a, public jiearing in Paradise prior to mating their recommendations to the Board. The Commission concurred and staff was asked to rc* quest that Bob,,Malquist of tbo Public Works Department be present at the next meeting of the Commission to melte a presentation concering these p-roposed changes . it -vas also suggested that the proposed list of ehanges be made available to local residents,. B. NORTHERN CALIPORNIA PLANNING COUNCIL It was announced that the next meeting of the council, `would iso in, Willows on Manch 18, Chairman Gilbert, a former President of the organization, made a -few comments concerning its objectives and said that lie would be most happy to introduce the entire Commission at next. Ft'idayis mooting. (Staff mailed details of the meeting to the 4 new-mumbors on Monday, ,i C. NAME PLATES Mr. Lawson said that name plates would be ordered and asked' if there were any special instructions as to first names) et(-,. None were :forthcoming. 1D. SPECIAL ZNMUCTIONS PROM COUNSEL Counsel snm would not beaComissiontvariance functi.onin thefutuappeal being the tonight heard t e new ordinance ,ends appeals direct to the Board of Supervisor;, fje cautioned tic Com#nissi on as to the necessity of making proper : findings regarding conformance with the General Plan and commented that thn, law allows 3 amendments per year to the Pian, He then read statutes setting forth the duties of -the Coinmissit n. f BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTE!") March 10 1977 Nn FI�QdF CI` Comm ss,ione Stutn recommended (953 the following projects .be �" ras 1. Rezone South, Orovillo, RehabAlittition Area 2 Rezone all Awl in last Chico-Veci.no Arca. 3 : Amend R4 oHinance to require �l fraternal, oxgani:za,,i.ons too ` acqu .rc a use permit 4. Amend R -2 -ordinance to allow singlo49tory apartments on a.usc permit, or create a new meditint- densIty, residential oard ndilce. 5, Amend 841 ordinance to make 3.t a truly $-14 Ordinance. Provide a time on our agenda .Cor business from the floor, 7. Initiate an amendment to County Cenoral Plan Land Us:e..Map:w 8. Amend Genoral Paan to provide that zoned developments outside designated urban areas be ;legal land uses. 9. Review and update' Circulation Element ofthe'General Plan.. to, Prepare hylar prints for Dopy'Makinr � of the five urban areas of the county --for maps. Il: Review and update the Butte County Regional Transportation plan 12. Review commercial ordinances. S4aI+f was asked to set a pTiority list for these accomplishments. There was discussion as to the need :dor special study sessions, but no formal action was taken. P. MINUTES There vas a short discussion as to the need for more details ;i'm the minutes of the 'CO mitsinn me0t ngs. No specific instructions issu''C is lti. C ifis �' lON BY-LAWS A copy of the 'pld" By -taws for the Planning Commission was dis, s� -4- b q .0 BUTTil COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MTNUTR�S W March XU, 1977 trabuted to each of t1Ce j, Commissioners. Chap -man Gilbert appoli ntod a committee composed of Commi.. ioners ST'Utz and Bennett to review the .By -haws with the idea Of proposing amondmetits a 1.1 RBIMBURSEWNT OF COMMIS81ONERS The possibility of -reimbursement of the Commissioners for mis- cellaneous expenses, such as dinners --after a study session and prior to a Planning Commission meeting the same evening—was q,uest,.oned. Staff was instructed to check to :see whoa would have to be done in order to accomplish this I ACTION OF Mr' J,1RITY OF COMMISSIONERS PRESENT CommiBoardsthatemadennett actio questioned the majorityrofhCommissi action re the sinners present a binding action applied to fUtu-.re actions of the Commission. Counsel Commentedthat this was now a part of the ordnance and action by the Board would be necessary to make any chango,a (1 V!, ADJOURNMENT There being no further`, jus nesss the meeting was adjourned at 9:32 P, M George Gil ert, Cha;irma 'TAPE; 77-68-2-005 65' -1 -Ai 69 -2; -All 4 f A , BUTTH, COUNTY PLANNING C OMMI SS t ON Chairman Gilbert t called t1io meeti.aig to order at 7:40 P. M. 77-72-2-710 II. RC LI, (AU Prasent Coton1 1 s si.anors Bennett Williams and, C:ha,i.ranan Gi.11�er�G` , Abs,ent,s Commi,ssioiier Evorltard wbo arrived at Comm lss'lon, ;r Stu,ts who arrived, at *;03 A,1so [}resent: Jim La.wsort, Dol Si omsen, Bob Gaisor J1.1n Skjotstad (Chico Lntorprise Recorci , Hazol Palla:, 111", APPROVAL iii{ MINITTl3 Minutos for March 10, 1:177 were na:pprovod as submitted. M ABANDONMENT - Cnnt nuad from Pebruary 24, 1.177 A. CONTINENTAL NOT COMPANY (File 77-48) - Roquest;: ahandonmont or tho r-01.101aia11, describod county bigbway of the County of 130 to Fdst Eleventh Pvenue �ro,m and ilicludinn the i n'torsection o' pl cancer and ta`st Eleventh, �Venuotho cast side 'of the `East Esplatti dd 'Road. East Linda Avenue from, wast side fit" LOurnam Avo;nue to tie Eatit F-NOIan•ade Dtive goad and includinra the Fast l.sp.14nade hrive ku6d to the north aide of L21.4 Eleventh 'Avenue, Subject to easements oisguGd to the eailroad and .: utility campanio'a. Mr. Parkor requostod that 3 ewiditiows bo addod to those oroglnally« pr;opo: Ced 1, on �a�se as public til idY d. storm drainagd easemdnt Resox�e a pul,�.3.e tnt�.�.�.t ea�'enaont �n y y p y� h j j ' M. t Abandoomortt 4o �.bo no l,.Io.s4i�4� ��i�.iCo 1 ft, from lit y 1 i A, BUTTE COUNTY PLANNTNG VONINITSSION i' r x t NINii`iEN March 24, 1 (077 to of the railroad,� � f�q Robort An 11g, ropresrnt lta Contlnen ;aa Nut Crrn7);y, in answer to a question from CoMmissioator Gilbert, statod that t.'we abandoned ,area I aloni1 Undo Cha.xanel could revert to the heirs of Bidwell and that the any; could requo.st that Ca-nt.in,cnta! Nutptai-chase tho _Dr 'perty, He called the C;omnra: ,s inn's attention to the signicsi Agreoinent Between Gant znonta i. Nut t:oiq)any anti ,Joe Va l onntawhielN fo i,, ,,knvs ,- I ACREEIM- ENT BETWELI CONTINENTAL NUT COITA't' NY, TIEREI NAtT"R, (,,A LCi; t CNC ? Abri:] TOE VANNBALLA , t"A.F*. QNAFT£R CA ,I.IaL) a�f�(� a' I. By mutual agreamo'nt, CN(L ARCH agree to abandon Ltndo Avenue startinq at Undo and rabur, . AvtlnOess and running 4frast,to end lnclud.- my abandonment of t+h4� Es) !e S'e'rvice Road ene- t.- on the north side: of East I lth Avenue and th,. , made. It is agreed that all of Lindo Chanoal abandonment •r 0l revert to exist-- rny; property lines of CNCC and. ARCO. 3 it is mutually agreed to abandon East 17th Avenue Vi CNICO with the exception of an easement granted by CNCO to ARCO to allow access tri ARC;C7's �peat6-nt or new 60 font frontage area entran4a, Ysuch entrance which will be provided as staffed in Paragraph a below► 4 CNCO will provide ARCO wwith an easement for the portidn of the, B'spla- node Service Road trarting at ARCO's property I[Ae on such rmd and ending at Last 11th Avthuu, thus proodirg ectiris t„± AltCO over the ont r,r Esplahatle Sbt'+tice Road, 6,. CI\iCrP will,remove Warchvusz No. One (60 ft. by 150 St.) pratontl,y located on the north side of East 11th Avenua. At tw ,,j"1 time when the building is removed, CNI CO will provldi6 to ARCO a v,.6 foot easement on the notch side of East 11th Avenue bordering ARCO's property. Stich easement will be located starting at the southwewt t,r,r ner of ARCO's i' 'property and runnikrg 60 feet east on the :i ar`th side of, Ea`6t l.lth Ave hut . +a In cons iderotion of the above provis Ilons, ARCM will ;Pro tide 0I\100 with ad easement on the toutheast port 6A of AROO-18 prbfs,frtyj which, is a, j 4 60 ,foot width bordering test 1lth Avenue and is $0 flet �jh depth. This easement will provide a thoroughfare for right of way said property by CNCCI. Should a 1.0 foot strip of ;aid property be required by CICO for ("'Onstructian, such 10 foot by 60 foot strip Will be deeded to MOO by ARCA. 4 BUiI1 j , C t�,j °i'S l'i�:ANNINC COMMISSION1 MINUTllS - Ma'tcl. 24, 1977 QItft. Atrig 'added thr,l his X'�rm haa no opposition to, the :iti,pulata�ns as ` set out by he �;�Sufat .' 048) C mn►3 siot� r 1�011n6tt commerxt d, that he bad. cantare area wi.tli A M6mb(ir of the Con.tl.7xeotal ''Nut f tm and that .t appeared to ,F the only roGasonable tray to go and that evarybody wouldbOnoCat. hip. 1143 4i 01 'Iker sd 4t the only thing that would; noel, to be done to elim- inate -tbe left t'Wti. O -U of-, IlttiAu'eni,4e i; to have t'.he. Road Department put Up "Ll ;1.1 gi1. The i�approveym�ett, seconded by Comna ss oner�Williamsliams to thxs4bandonmnt a � outiino:O vol jcc-tto t,lio 7 (.,ond.iti0ns as :f'ol.low.s < 1. Dedication of 20 -foot dr, a'ina j;e easement to Co�lnty wotIlin that portion, of Oleander Avenue abandoned recently. ". Rights of ;the publ l c_ut3lities in accordance with $o t<loo 959.7: of the Shoots Fa I -C l;hw.�jys CoZie. 3. Access *ow barnk mainte`aance along Lindo Channel. 4 Access for possible biking axed bike path. S. Reserve a po4 is utility easement and. storm dr"a,.lnage easement on hast 1 sp7.anede Drive, G. Aba.ndoment to be no closer than 10 ft. from the conte tiito a -f tho railroad. 7 detain fare across, AYM, C'om'mlssionet Bonnatt, 11111:.ams and, Chairtna.n Gilbert ABSTAINMICottimxsst.nnor hv'erhard, ABSANT Co)tI.missioner Stutz, Motion carried V. RUM.IC RARING A. RE20N8 77-73- 1.999+92 �ffjl - 1S 1 i)JTTfl ,,QQUNTY PLANNI'NO COMMISSION MINUT, March 24, 1977 Warren T. Ambrtrso Rotone from "A-R" (Apri cul tural-Resi.jenti al t and "A.R-MH" R.esiden�titial�-Mtr�i��u I�p�rps�,. tp.,,r►pq-0u (!landed Arna4'Iuster) property located on the north side 'of Mento Vista Ave. , approX . 800 fteats of Lnwe.r Wyandotte Road, 4deWfied as ACS 36-194-07, 36-58.34 and 36-6$-35, more pyarti Cul arty doscri bed at: K Common`,:-inq at the Sr corner of "14yarldotte Terrace .Uni t Two`" per Map'iof Record in flap Book 27 on i'aq�es 31 and 32 of tiro Butte County Recorder; thence N 090 1.2' 2111 W 30.11 ft, to zthe true point of beginnirm of heroin described parcel; thence N 890 30a B 832.13 ft ; the` .�A N 625.5 ft. y thence 5 850 30' W 1067.06 ft. •, the"Oe 5', 1,60 ft. ; thence S 806 300, 0001 6 31 .98 ft.; thence B 09° 12 1 21'" F 491 .24 ft to th,e centerline of Monte Vista Ave,; thence ea-, -1y along said dented ine to the true point of becrinnina. . ,Conta jino "5.29 iw ros, 'mare or less4 Oroville. Mr. Lawson read steff findings. s i hir. Ambrose commented that the location of the sewer line as, shoyi on the plan was only an approximate location, that there would be no permanent strv'.tur.e:,S in the easement and that he had talked, with members of tho North llu.�bank Utilities C)L trict and that they had no objection too his pr,jposel. Mr, ParRer of the public Works Department stated that the sewer line as shown on the P.A. , plan was in an approximate location and t, ,,d, exact location had not been cletermincd when the l ubdivisi.on Comm, ��tee reviewed the pla.Ix , Counsel Siemsen reminded the Commission (207) that the P.A.0 zoning requires approval of a specific plan and suggested continuance until 11 the exact location of the sewer line can be determined; Both Com- r' missioners Stutz and Gilbert expressed conc:eryr about having mobiles placed i.n the easement dor the seivor, parti culatl�y since tide lots' would be under ined' i idual ownership and not a mobile home park owhor. Chairman Gilbert no,,-ad that a 'egati ve Statement Regarding lInvi ronmentaI Impar.-t had been I'i od by the ,i, rd of 8uporvlsors on Fis.bruary° 8, 1977, Chairman Oilbert then, hearing no comments to the contrary, n caltlnued: this i�em tniti l the next neeting its order ,to onablo the Sut dlvisio Committee to confirm the location of the easement. The Subdivision is to come 'back O th a properly word.eri condition or a. ;redee ign to show Lots that will work. s. "4 B. SRAPLANC LANDING CN LAKlI O12OVILLI I. State Department of Parks 6 Ct1 Croat .on request; *4w r _ Itil'I"TE COUNTY PLANNING Cp1NMIS.SION MINUTES - March 24, 1,977 e staniti,shment or scap:lrane landing oil sake proville. 77*73-2-65,9. �1 Ross Henry, representing tiro JJepjTtinont of Parks and Rdcreation, s"id that in May 1974 the Scapl.aale. Pilots' Association, tv: th the perplissif,,fin of the Division of .Aexona.uties had held a e fl -in on La r (,} y � p ova.11.e and that 17 seaplanes 11,�i^ti.cip�.tod without a registered complaint'br, a Sunday whon a rega.ttu'and normal boating .Icti.viti.es were in , Yrobress. lie :�Fai d that tltore was no clesagnated. pass or strip recommended. in order > O allow more versa.til i.ty in larding. He added that he felt this'activi.ty would be conmiatible with boating. Bob Burns, California Division of Aeronautics, stated that there were orrl.y 2 fresh -water approved l.andi.ngspot$ in the state, both at H. e said that there were only At1 or i seaplanes in the entire state sand that the requested usa.l;e would, be very low key, Ile :further stated that the State tvotil, assume liability, He added that the butte County Board. Of Su'porvisors bad denied a request for a landing in 1978, Walter Wi.ndus a member of the tl° S. .Seaplane Pilot's Association �oiked nt andti=or�.f sl ng, Otc. Association belie 8a3 d there voreprmittod to use t3elake benef is a rest I benefits to be derived from this usage: 1. Opportunity for search alid rescue in rase of emorgency. 2. Chock and report boating hazards, and, 3. Aerating tater. No addod trip+ all pilots mast have a Federal license and that the members of the associau`ion are careful., considerate, and law abiditig, Charles Sanders, Orovill,e, and Loe pttorson, +Lol.usa, bc,Fth members of the Seaplane Pi ots► Association, spoke in i:avor. Persons a:rpoarlAg !11 opposi.tian ,vere Bob 8di er,, Chico, tvho stated that, there was an organized smil. at least every 2 wooks and, that the lake was, used therebhadany booniffarent problemssduring tilt last tfly-in)Mri buththatrthe were made. g o kllow to womur.li reports should ' beQt reportedecause noone concern that once started it W ul,, be 4iffxc.ul.t to Stop such a practice 7.f there should be a mishap, oeorgd Hook, also of Chiro, `cxpressod concerti., particularly about liability in case of an, accident. After cont�a dbscus.'ion, a. motion teas made by Commissioner Hverhara;, y mmi.ssioner Williams) to reer.mmo; d to the ;Board of, super- vis,o�{s second-ed th6 request; for, a seaplane landing on Lake Oroyille be g Gar. zed with the stipulation that the first mishap would rdL revocation. His motion tvas seconded by Commissioner Williams. It was xi,oted that a Negative Declaration Regarding Invironm6ntal; Impact had been tiled A�imay{. , i tS i+ Conimssi.oaiOrs I3onnr.t* l vc;rlaar°d, Stutz, Williams and , Chairman. Oil,bort M BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES March 24o 1977 No Hone , ABSENT No ono Motion ea,rrieat � Dr. Bonnet�j, voported zat he had reeeived .a Iotter ea; er in the oven' n rQa; Philp 'T ic;o, attor.nry in Chaco, expro .,�n� concerti regarding, this prot)G it The letter was not read ah . entirety but main poiircs :sere covered a comt:tints prior t this time the heari g was closed. V1. MT S 21 LLANW118 k. PROP OSBD NAME CHANGES IN 1-ARAnT8I (Pile 77-54 Gam, 1 Pursuant to the .197S excerpt from State Lav Re Lativig [_..y to Local Planning Title 7, Planning, Chapter .5, Local Planning Article 5, Authority for `and Scope of General Plans, Section 65392, Paragr4ph (b) 77-174-1-345 Mr. Lawson intvoduced the ' address and street: naming coordinator,. Mx. Malquist of ,the Pt1bl�.c Works Department, lie. Stated that there ha.8 been 16 public hoa.rings 1n the paradise area and that the riroject was the result of a comprehensive' study, tie stated that Crestmoore and a part of Wapta.ff were still under study. lie further stated. that the erateria used 1n, making name changes Weise the number cif peoplhg on thee road and the h tstoricel value of the read, and t h''at every of -Fort had goon made t6 ,,permlt the,a1cle�lts oil the, strep+t; to choose the names. Mr. Malquist explained 'a study''beitig; made for a new numboring system, stating that it wa.s planiidd that the new names MW numberlia would be dono at the Name tame -iii order to have as little confu iOft as possibie Mr. Lawson stated that there was yon, -6 discussion at a; recent Board ir:soting concersti.ng another public hearing !In paradise, Commissioner %ve�rhatd expressed the o�Y.ni�., that an �dvox�t�serl hear�i�� should b held. The 'other Commiss�oilers aprpod am stag was anstructea to sett such a hearing, on h Thursday nign,t. B. APPROVAL 0x' PLANS VOR CI�MAyT�IiCTAL COMPLEX : �,i BUTTrii COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES March 24, 1.977 3 alo,'17-55-For G"ehe .4m r, Lot S4) Paradise, 1>anas tYi ifi x) w , 7.7.74-1-80eJ -Mr., Lawson commented that tho pr0p0s0, d par'kislg. appeared to ho- adequate for the 5 I:J ,nfe;-slonal of,�,i+ces pl,annad: for construction. Motion was )nn,do by Conmm:i.ss"iondr Stutzs soconclod by C,ommxssibner Everhartl, t ,approvo the s1tc plan as prosonted AYES: Cc,1,mmi&,sionors Bonnott, 1vorhari� Stutz, Williams and Chairman Gilbert NOE$ No qne ABSSMI` No one. Motion carried. h ' lila HRRALS C , IICt�RIl OF SUI hR"V1SORS, 1. Planning Commission to cont`ti er amendment to G'enorai. - flan (File 77-56) bisect ' quote i" om 'boa.rd ol± .Supervisors' minutes for pebruar" 1, 1977: "On motion o� Supervisor Moseley, seconded seconded by Supervisor Madigan, and unanim.ously carried, the Planning Commission was reromto-'Aded to <, amend the General; Plan to state that whorever the t;Ise on the ground is more intensive than that on the plan, the land use could be interpreted to the use of the lancl, " 77-74-1-865 Mr Lawson commer t,od that he felt rovi ;ions to the plan should he consistent with the State Guf dell,nos and radd.ocl, that 'the small scale 1 County General Plan Map was never intended for'highl,y urbanized. atoa,s. �I Commissioner Stutz commented (99.9+61) that Tehama. County had ap„ ' parontly solved this problem and read the following statement 1;rom that plan: r� I; 1, BU'l"I't, COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTE'S - Morch 24$ 1,977 The plan As to be considered as Navin sufficient flexibility, to area..AccotacAndusuchocompatible compatible zoning shall be consideredeco +see consistent wi,f'�,4a'�i�#� f .a consistent with the plan. Also, carefully developed zoning vi,thi.n transition land classification areas, shall be deemed consistent. Such reasonable and workable flexibility is necessary to preserve the purpose of the long term guide plan, fund to prevent it from becoming a meani;aigless zoning duplicate 2 The p1rat has sufficient definition and detail to be used as a positive guide for land use and development,; but is to be usbu as a plan which contains flexibility to the extent the planning aahmi8a ton and, legislative - bodies ray, by the adoption of initial policy statements based on the intent and purpose of the plan further .define and interpri„t -plan features, develope criteria for findings of compatibility and otherwise provide for orderl,' plan administration. 3 'St is anticipated that some locations ons not shovin on the land use map may be round suitable for needed uses in the futureyin specific planned developments, at fremgay interchangos, at *highway and road interseti.ons and at other locations where the chahei.ng needs of people create a demand Por service,so 40 Approprite uses other than agricultural) open space and tUaber mountain. are to be determined by mating special findings on the bases oi' specific plans or precise toning. 5 When bkibtia'ig.uses - is an area are greater or more intensive than that shoVm tial the Land itse maps the plarinihe, commission and legislative bodies may make operiel. Andings to all.mr development that is, similar to the exiatinr a.m. Codnsol was:,aslred to give all opinion tcgra.rdAng any `[.egal problems involved with making a sivila-r change In the General 1'l.an text. Bob Gaiser playod the tape of the Board Minutes for pebruary 1., 1:977 regarding this issue--for clarification. g g Commissioner Bennett comtfierited that there were a lot of inquiries as to 'when the band Use Blement woul(t be revised and suggesto& malls on mylsr he made a,va .labae for such studies It was suggested (559) that the Commissioners study the statement presented by Commissioner Stutz and Pb preparod to mace seine recdmmenda- t.i.ons as to language , to be -used for proposed changes Mr. Lawson commented that due to Shari;` staHilii- in the Planning Depart- ment the General Plan Tovisi tan should maybe go to a Consultant, Commissioner Stutz commented that the out-of-date donsities in urban areas should be changed nri that the areas outside urban areas shoult! be studied, in conjunction with the removal of A42 zoning: This item will. be carried On the agenda for the next meeting.- . 8- s t 4 T3Urn, COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES A March 24, 1077 t l S`1IUDY LAND U$B MAIC Vile 77-57 - To consider rezoning to S-A, SR 1/2; SR -1 a.nd A -R, or, other compatible zoning, or property on the west 4ide of Ssplanade, `wost Of existing InteTIM, SR -1 zone 77-74-2-G4 Mr. Lawson, with the aid of a Land Use Map of the area gave a brief f..•'' history of the zoning proposals made in the past for this area and reeommeAdcd. A -R zoning contiguous to present A -R zoning, SR to the north, C-2 at the Lassor intersection with 11.4 for the remaining hspxa.nad.e frontage,. He stated that thi-,; area wAs under tti Interim $-2 zone and 'had been extendo4 for the :last time by the Board and would oxpire on 8/14/77: 11e added that the Sewer Committee had recommended this area be con- sidered for sowering,. Commissioner Stutz suggested that the ertire A42 area from the Els- planade outside the'urban boundary be considered in this proposal to .Ay R, SR$ $121, and that an area be considered for RT -1.. Staff was instructed to prepare a, map cov'et'ing the expanded areas and present it at the tient meeting. VII. ADD ITEMS A. AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION Mr. Lawson announced that a meeting had been arranged with the City of Chico Planning Commission and The Airport Land 'Use Commission. It will be a luncheon meeting to be at the Chico Airport at 12,00 Noon, on April 20. s; B. 17LANNIrI"i COMMISSION BY-LAWS, A copy of the proposed revised,, by-xa,:ts prepared by Dr. Bennett and his committee, was presented to thr; Commission memberk;. Dr.. Unnett asked that the other Commissioners review this proposal and be prepared to take action at the next meat ng, �eu o 1 BUTT13 COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTT38 March 24o 1077 C� NAM OV TKET;TI'NC DfiTTiS Atter sumo cHgrussion.; motion was made by Comtnisgioner Bonnott, seconded by Comm ssi.onor Everhard, and-unanimou.4`ly carried to chango the meeting nights to Mondays at 7.30 P. M yy r yyy Y t ITIO NT There heing no furthor business, the mooting was adjourned at 11s47 P:m "T"AIDE: 77-72-2-710 73-1-All, 2-Al 74-1-All 2-Al 75-t-7 u G�eatii•gC Cyilbert, Chai.rmaa `ems BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES APRIL 4, 1977 77-76-1-840 11 1?LUDGE 0,P ALLEGIANCE 11, ROLL CALLt Present Commissioners Bennett, l3vorl�ard, Stutz`,, Williams and Chairman Gilbert Absent! NO ono. Also Present: Jim Lawson, Del Siemsen, Clay Castleberry, Mac Parlor, Brad Bal.lingnt-Chico Enterprise Record, and Hazel Dallas xl'T. APPLE AL OP MINUTES POR MARCH 10, 1077 Approved as submitted. TV. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. JIB ZoNg rContinued 9 om March 24, '1.977) 1, Warren T, Ambrose . Rezone Prom "A-R11 (Agricultural— Residential) and "AR-MH" (Agricultural Residential- Mobile I40mds) to PA-C,11 ('Planned Area Cluster) property located on the north slap o1a'Monte Vista Ave., approx. Boo ft. east of Lower. Wyandotte toad, identified as AIS 36-194-07, Oroville Mr. Lawson reported that Mr: Ambrose had submitted a modified plan and that Aitc "i.tbd vision Committee had reviewed the plan adding two more con- Proponentst Warren T, Ambrose asked (947) that i. )ndit on No. 11 call- ing for the installation of vertical curb, gutter and sidewalks to be deleted, and that lie be partm.tted to install rolled curb instead of vortita.l. Curb 4s specified it the conditions, Opponents: No one. The hearing 'vas closed and after some cliscussi.on motion was made by Commissioner 'Bennett to •recommena approval of this xezoning subject to the 25 conditions as recommended by the Subdivision Committee and the revised. plan. (Condition 7 amended --change 7`6 & 77 to 75 4 76 and add "Along Monte Vista Ave," to Condition 12). fie found the proposal not to be in conflict with the General. Plan. ills motionwas seconded b Commissi.on.ra+ ;,r I, i BUTTE- COUNTY PLANNING CtOMMTS81ON MINUTES - April 4 ) 1977 AM: co3. mmis3. ioGers Bennott!�j Ev`erhard, Stutz. , W;iwl�liams and yt e NOES No one ABSENT: No one Motion carried, Conditions of approval are: 1. The main access be centrally located on the development plan, this access to be a minimum width of 0 ft,- x k The interior road developma;it be as the typical street section be limited to the interior of the development. 3. The access shown on tho southwesterly corner of the property be eliminated and. reserved for emergency exists only, 4, All lot coverage not to exceed that delineated on the approved development plan as an example of the exterior lot, and the typical niter ioT lot. S The perimeter of tha, parcel, excepting. the svtreet side which would be the south side o have a minimum of 10 ft. setback from. all coaches, development, etc, I 6 A redwood fence 6 int, in height composed of vedwo,,d with mason.a.ry pilaster at 3 ft. intervals to be Located on or adjacent to :the property line on the east, northy and west, 7, The south side of the fence should be located 50 ft from the centerline of Monte 'Vista Ave. easterly extension, the fence to terminate 1.00 ft: from the centerline intersection of main access approach between lot 75 4 76. The fende between the 100 ft. point atd the driveway not to exceed 42 inches 8. Submit road and drainage plans to the Dept of public Works for approval and install the required facilities. p. Street signs shall be provided by the developer at all street intersections per 'County requirements (Submit .5 alternate street names for each street to the County a&lross coordinator for it pp a rova:l. of street naltes,) 1`0. Deod 30 1 ft. from the centoriine, of Monte Vista Ave, extension., 11.. Construct half stroet section on Monte "Vista Ave, extension to 118.2 major road geometric standard, i.e., minimum struntu,ral _2 BUTTE COUNTY ,PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - April 4, T977 socti�r�nto he 2" AC and 611 At with £rag ,seal. end 05% relative conxp co Gr:cs S>x) m .t' dasign � to C6tinty+ i?opt - or , Vj�l � i� W6��t� der approval. Ilk" value determrnatioils tinct other^ data may be requi.reci to support section designs 12, Install curb, gutter, and siaowa.l,k along Monte Vista. Ave,. 13i Provide monumenta'txon as required by the Dept. of Public works in accordance with accepted standards ih. Street grades and other features shat comply with t Butte and oprher accephc County nrdinanres, design. resolution ted engineering sta.nde rds, 1S ► _ Provide road maintenance c•r homeowners agr, fl-simcPnt,. 16, All. casements of record to shown on °rheilial: vap, 17 Meet requirements of rutte County Dire Dept, or other -to- sponsMble agency. 18 Street lighting shall be provided in acc6rda.nce with Butto County requirements accepted design criteria and recommendations o PG&E. r 10. Submit 'Plan, to Dept, of public Works lour ap siteuevgIopanent p _ construct or install the required facilities, 20. Provide a. I ft. no access strap at east end of :Monte Vista Ave. extension 21. prow,de- a letter from Or-c+vil:I.e4Wya.nd.otte Irrigation District stating thati they will provide wator and a jotter, from tile' North Burbank Public Utility District that they Will Ptovide Seg for to the property. �. 22, 'l'i'e coach arca on lot 30 not encroach on the server oasemeait. 254 There must be a i ft, build. g sotba.ck 1`=0 and a 0 ft, fence setback Line -fromv th;e center of the road. V hit 8 LI NEOU A Consider letter and petition of Craig-Mooretown .property oignfArs .and residents requesting consideration of TR, 20ninr, x 7i -76-2-0A iwiT from Lose ScaC�o i4r Lawson read a lot't or i `ot-Arding zoning 01 BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES a April 4, 1977 certain parcels in, the area:, and a.dde(,.that this was not a zoning, ap y Icat ioax . te�i,d'01 haa, req /�yyy�y{� �(. a Aed that 00 AoIr xssxo cin s' Hetiatang`pro pos�,� Ile then stated that earlier today the Craig-Moorptown Association had presented a zoning petition for ;EHRR-2 (Foothill Rural Resi.- denti,ai.-2-4rro minimum) which would be a new zoning cl,"si:i:ication it tile, 'Cour ty. This petit on covers a large area- -including that mentioned iti the Stei.del letter, but excludi Ag 110 lain Of 'Forest Service and Southern Pacific Land Company. Sta,ff was instructed to determine the validity of this hew appli- cation and bringit back to the CommS.ssion as :kaon ?,s possible. i When, 'Brtlno Igoj ic1,., representing the Craig -Mooretown Association) expressed a desire to Speak, 'Cl airman Ci lber. t requested that lie make all information available to Staff. Rh CRSS : 8:10 P. M. MEETING RpCONVtNBD. 8-18 P. M. ' 13. DOW OF SUPtRVT.SORS r REFERRALS (Continued Erom March 24) 1. proposed amendment: to General; pian 77-�76-2-684 Counsel, Sil emson reported that he had not completed work on the wordali of the proposed chane in the 'General pian text. at re-- g y 'B and `of Supervisors , ' but would attempt to ha.v(-; it " p g �uo�ted 1a the Bo_ completed and back on the agenda for April l$. F tis 2. Consideration of rezoning proposal fot area west of Esplanade, north bf Past Avenue ,to Mud Creek 77-76-2-775 this with t the aid o:- a Map, presented a proposal to rezone thisthe hs,plaa�ade ..'dd bKl and Cwt. Lie said that part of the, area tw y SR`t-a along oetidoleted, and added. that the IC-," s � , `k rite south had also bi ;gin deleted beca.ttsct there has been an G FW icatiCaxl l7ur a zoning pxnpasa",! dor tlx: s property (styles p.ancltj. undc,,r consider at,*on for quite some time in ttae envir i tinr.ntal :review process. John L,uvaa.$) a. Chico attotno'y, representing the Priends of 'Butte County, cori�mentcd that this as at extremely controvdrsi�l area, and ,� .:4w BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - April 4 1977 that he- would ask that first the urban bpunclavios be stud od.and established i°,.the area, that l,' group ,-o 14 live with thom after they are' os tabl.xs ied, that he a,eco�,►��ri;.�1de .r�t1. y big brought, cl.o o ' to; tho , city, He stated lie would oppose ant proposal to move ,boundary Further out, His, recommendation was that a buffer be made between th(t more dense residential aroas and the agricultural, zones. (500.) Joo hllingscn> 420 West Lassen, expressed opposition to tape 5«R pxS}17osa1 .and, xerlucsted a hearing in Chico at the time a zoning is heard For this area. rQ n 'BlakOe 270 Oakva.1e Ave., Oroville) repror; enting People's Action r' Committee, recommended (482) maximum density for this area to enable lower and middle income people to afford a lot on, which to build a Dome John R. Dobson, Route 1, Box 41.1. (Bay Avenue), Chi said that his J . 63- acre parcel is survourded by sinal.l parcels, and speaking for himself, the Tiptons, the Cuttybacks, asked that their properties be zoned RT-1. He add6,1 that b wasmisinformed regarding the pro- posal when the area was interim zoned and he wished to have his name removed :from that petition for such zoning. Alan Buychett� an attorney from Chico, representing Stylos Ranch properties, requested (703) that his client's property not 1°e lumped in with another rezoning or .hither delayed Chuck Harvey Route 2, Box 130 Chico, made aft appeal: for the most „ \ restrictive, feasible zone, and added that agriLoi Lure can be made viable on sural l acreages by using easehol ds, ktc said that the community` of Chaco is enhance . by providing a green belt around it, in response to a question frc,: Comr►ussaozier Bennett, he said that he was speaking as a ci.tizon, not a property owner in the area, Jim Mikkelsen) 1319 Arbutus j Chico, riled for zoning to eticoura.ge maximum density Bob nutose, 2175 Nord Avenue, Chico, commented that the owners of these properties had a,lrea0l paid high'costs in the form of taxes and " drainage assessments and that the only way to peep these lands is agriculture is to assess the Lands as a.gri.cul.tural. Commissionr Stutz commented (990+19) that, even though this area had; boon under an interim zone for a long tithe, there were no petitions subMi.tted by the residents for p r s zoning, Shasta, e Drainage `�� Bit staff aro'vide a ma showingthe boundaries t onSha lie asked that g tinct, for thatdistrictto the south formed in 1971--this map to be wi.tI relation to the property under consideration for rezoning, He also asked what annexations to the • � were being prncess�ed, Ax!to'r additional discugsion4 it was ufta,nimously agreed to' have a sp"ecial mcatln.g on April 11 to consider this maItter in viewoi+ tho ,time frame within which the Commist,ion and Board mulst ►:ork in BUTTECOUNTY .PLANNING COMMISSTON APRIL 4, 1977 , MINUTE'S order tol accomplish perr4anont zonl g PTiorto t1l the int�:xxm. G, C. BOARD 0V SUP;1�It�i� St7RS' tW,PIRit�ILS No w) II ,I I. The hoard ` o :su ser ors asked the Plarn n g orrimiss° on to address the subs 6tt of effects on count7 roads of sand divisions being processed, or Proeessod in the ptast, that do not reallyprovide satisfactory access for resi- dential t1ovelopment 77-77-2-a Mr..Lawson introduced Mr. Clay 8astleborry, Director ox 'Public Wors Mr. "astleberry commented that theme were many reads in Butte I�ounty that' were marginal :dor access--Monwj a.r Road, Hurleton-Swede's Plat toad, Concow RoadHumbug Road,pa.rt o. f 14upp-Coutolenc- -just to name 4 few. tie stated that an increasing number of rosidents on t;liose road's had been appearing before the Hoard of Supervisors asking. that their roads be maintained, an(! that the hoard was asking for suggestions ars to how to handle the pvoblom Chairman, Gilbert commented that the Commission no longer has any jurisdiction in reviewing lot spA jtting and that, in the past, many times conditions for road impvov0ents on, pa:r.eel maps rocommo,hded by the ,Commission had beet" de'letod. ",Chore was further discission, but no formal a.otion was ta.km` Mr. Castleberry again asl;ed that -the Commission think about 11h is problom and give to the Board the benefit of their thougSats. 9q' it '}R �t 1 pid.A _88 x. 9;40 h • m, MEETING RLCONV51411D t '(9:47 P. M. 4 P. PLAWNG COMM1SSlag V-LAWS 4 . 77-77«2-42 Ibt rgo4on made by Cr>mriiss onor Everhardo srcondod by Commissioner Nilliams) by Laws 01 the Butte, County Planning Cemmiss�.�,n 44.0 tod as follow, , AABS; c:ommissit )nets Bennett, hverhard, Stuis, IV111ia.ts and Mt 'aUTTB COUNTY 'PLANNING CONIMISS10N MSNUI S - ApT l 4 a 1977 NOBS" : tr No 0" .ABSENT No one. BY --AWS OF THE BUTTS 00dNTY- PLM"AI0 . COM14ISSION ART lelk I Name Section 10 The name of this association sfi-:O 'be -the TMTE COUNTY°Pahl NTNG commzsszom AI�'fE a :SEL tlb�ect _ , Section l To prepare and adopt a.comprehensive., long terih, gctdrbl plan for the phys t4l develbpmnt of Butte .dountyy, a Seot4 ok 26 z ►ro develop a plan for the on ser�4gtion� dcvelopmernt and ecor;omle utilization of the netixraxµ r6sotYro )a of this oottnty. Seot3.ori �. general. self d P. w a health) si�fety and i�d rcenote the u%.�i.. Cex era . - t4�a coxtserve a ., DU`I TH COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION M:_NU' I-1 , April 4, 1977 Ths offioers of the %tte County P1811 irig Commission 811011 cin' ,. EQ'i t of a obalmn and Gice.�Cha�rmart. ,,���� r✓ � � a Sectioo 2. Tho ofjt�J.ogs of Cl.airmhn and Vice Chairman sha'l.l be electivo and thbp rJavtt3 so el1dcte O shall serve for a term of one �i} ",'or and uintil their ssuccesaors are 61oeted; sa,ia annual .esea-t-lpr,s shall, be set for the month of J+aM19Zy» goetich 3. The p ,aiticn of Secretary -T teaaurer shall be filled bythe Plan- ming Staff. 5dati Gi The duties of the officers of the planning Commission shall be as ` follows., it shall: be the d-,�ty of the Chairman to preside over all meet- ings of the Commission, to atapoint committees and to ss�rvz as ar nzt.offioio mbmber of all cMm3ittees so appointed lt- shall- be tj:e duty of the Vice -Chairman to pasi:st the Chairman ;4,n: the execution of the duties of his office and o act i1n" i3�;!! steed during his absencefrom conferwnces arsd to assume hie dutios inease of doath or retro ai it Shall be the duty of the Secretary -Treasurer to keep a com plete recded' of a11 conferences, and me?etings of the Pl,anni.mg Com mists ion» seet3.oq 5» It shall be the dutr of the ChOirm'an tp apooitt any app 'r, committees vi.ich may be riecossary. The comp0s3.ti6h of said cord mittets may altered by a maJoril ''#ote, ART IG VE . n" Cuorum ;eot�.btt i "tutr shall consist of threof�ta�mak, snoreommiaa�{Aeirtai' Scss A guts;! o bf guor�M. ries$ t►ay be entete'�d by a fru r3 ATZCi.E . ` ► it BUITt COUNTY ,:z LANNxNC COMMISSION WNUTEI S April 4 1977 n� Rs i r "' et�I let f the � F x��� �"i�i�fi�!lt��t�� �hk���` �►0 holo�+�..�e� month in the 041urthoasO at OrOYLU m 5mot�;oz� + r t a adjourn, ''and ,recOx .�n� 'no reef ar meet�n� �n � a Geonty an a majority of the �"arrrmiooia�a.. � t Sectyon 3.} Special Meetings May be held upon written notice to e 0 `,ch member of tix.e Commission and to the press, said m,eotiA s shall be hold at such timers and pl.acos:- as ordared 'by the Chairman of the Pla.nrf�.ng Commission. Said wtiften notice p p g ria state the purpose t�I' such speca,s.:t, meetings, ' �l9re�tt�nten'Fs _ ' i These- by-laws may be: amended,, revised or rep6AF. et acaQu�tar meetitng of the planning Caljtmi9sian by a roto of a via jai.^hy 01 the memWs of said ComMi.tl0ion t,, ARI1101E "J i _u ads r Se -,tion team L. 11 meet3n a of the Butte CoWdIty Plannii� vomm3��s3on sha t be �Iondueted in striet acobrdanee vith p�+rl3ah�nta t�� 1aW anal Ra���tr."s Ttile s aforder._ TM V=GOVG BY -W$ tb gdoptol by r ma jorit yr vr' ;e of the df%abning (:0%mJgiiJon of the Coilnity of tette this day of April. 1977. `THS BMTg Co=y PLA14_11gd 0(kDi 81:6N I ( ..j BUTTH COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - April 4, 1977 VI. APD ITEM,,, A. P-ARADISE ROAD 'JAMS GHANGIV�0 77 -77 -2270th 3v1r. Lawsa Mx*, Ma.lquist of 1?ubllc 16rl�s i)6,pa.rt, aunt, to tl s' effoct that it would not be necessary ..to have, a pbibl i.c hoarxng on this matter by the Planning Comm i.s sion, as or' would seta hearing.hearing.g%nally planned, but ttidt' the Bo�a:rcl �: ,. LANO USE C OMMITTFIB3 MEETING IN •0,1.11CO APRTL'2a Mr. Lowson announced that CI -12M 11;1.11, will iauV0 4 presontatzon to make at this meeting, It was later agireod that this meeting 'w6uld be combinerl wa.tb� �t .Irleld trip to view the Mutt Crock area proposed for rozoning. Apt i Lawson will provide transportation to leave the Oroville Office au J A M. and the County Office Building at Chico at 9a30 A. M: (77-77-2-999+43) b J H _ C. , COUNTY PbANNINC COMMISSIONERS ASSOCIATION M1 ETING Mir. LAwsota I's to check the dame `Par the, next- meeting end inform, the Commi ssio'ners Y D. PLANNING COMMISSION MPETtNG IN C11IC.t ` The following lettev was read, , a League of Women Voters of Butte Count pr.w. 1 ti,.ahn p,Gfy bis 799 Chrt�l Cnli�'orYt C � �?5��d March 25, 197' auttd County Manning owmn saion 7 County contd�r D�rivo 7 �II`pV 1.0� 0a. 76✓ BUTTE COUNTY 'PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES * April 4, 1977 Because of the l.aroo amount of land involved and the number of dhieo residents who v 4i, be affected directly or ;Lidireotl y the League of 1,4omcn Inters urges the �{founty to hold the publics hearing regarding tiro northwest Chico rezone in Chico. we 'also urgo that oxtxa e:ftort Me made in publicizing zing 'the hearing sc that all Interested citizens can be informed and prepared to offer input. The s gnifiOanco of this rozono is gar reaching and has implioations that must be consi.dpred 4n an atmosphere of fall and open debates Very sincerely, yours, Veva: Edson, President r. 1 , � � Barbara Dq�rl.e - Local. Action Director ca: Chico Planning impartment No formal action was take7i. 98ZONING DC; WNSTRtAM PROM LACE 1=RONL SAM The following 'Let`ker was ;read. by C;,ho.a.t tan 6.1-l;bert 41�.� BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION NIINIJ-63� Alttii l 4, 1977 k'A MINASIAN, MINASIAN, MINASIAN. SPRUANCE & SA,SE R A'1"`t'tJRNrCYS AT LAW Ifinl OIRO 5T14F,UT AT OAK STI'MIT P JACKSON MINAMAN •, P, b. 130X 'tfiY� Ti:1,.CPFICfP1C h��'8,09 DAVID HA` KIN$ MINASIAN ARCA: CODC JIC PAU4IiYAN M1NA51ACd OROVINIX, CAI..IF4DPNIA 00905 WILLIAM N, $11RSlANCE IN romoi.YINf.� nt: ea To wjt.LIAM H, III No, -.....°.-. March ;20 PALM R H. HATC" Planning Commi,ssitm Butte County 7 County Center Drive Crovil,l,e, Cal,ifor4a 95965 Rei Lake Madrone eater Distract Centl;crlen AS you may be tularo► the State of California, nivinion of- Data and Safety, Department cif 'Fater Resources has commenced a lawsuit in rejard to the safety of the dam forming Lake Madrone, County of Butte. it a,s the 60ntent on of the state of California that the data -does not have a proper ppil.l way and is, therefore, not safe during certaa.n condit ons e whether ar not the require -menu of the State of California are reasonable, the estimatts of the cosi: of' meet ng the state's demand far exceed any Am6ttnt which either the Coun:•byof Butte or the local parties can potentially beat. For that reason it has been suggested that it is Uhf ikel.y that any changes in the dam structure *ill occur for many years in light of the above circumstances it appears appropriate in the opinion of the Lakaa Madrone water District to ask for flood plain -Zoning dotunstteam of take Madkone t^ prevent the construction of any habitations or any improvements which would induce the presenoo of people within ' -trach area. This matter is corning to trial by September of 1:57 7. it is essential that we attempt tip provide this toning prier t0 that time, May we this xrefore sut►gest that your staff consider aha: neoessary ohAnges to be mane in regard to restricting the character and joatl.on of any iriprovements within this area to, that tf.Ntr1'1;.' 11�lF�a 1 4 a VY"? r, t'lill be: hat) ay to worlk v-I'th your staff ar d s&ms <01s.;; " watt ar „ xr trh you l ua�•%nq ones of your �x�►xi�11al �1metings ;�, L sit�ta �o deoira.' VII would alga Mquest to he %Opt:. vitt OrMOa as to the progress very frilly yours r PA L R. MXNRSTAN M'rM1 M 4y� ^Y•1:51F"�."fP31�FTi..wW�++�w.iW<M'4fnw'_--i> " y' w Oct M.C.il-I >:loydt P. C. i o:c 26I Relyy'"y Creeko OA 95916 Mr. Sheman Rinaman t Jr.# P. 0. BOX 365t CA 45948 Mr. 7aok wtiiaulk, 1045 iCwAirview Dr., Grj,dj.L_y, CA g594S Mr. Howard Scutt, 1.2 San tonito Court, Walnut Creek,, �C A 945961 St:,aff [Vfls lnstruZ."tecl to (10 a Jal1 l Inia` stil(l). of t:l1f:' ill (111e qt:t.oll taml report to the cojllmiss-j"' P. C-2 ORDINANCE Setbztck rpt u rc,mctlt 77-77-2-932 Mr, l;.lwson Was romindecl t0_ St;t1Lly fllr C-2 Ord-Ir,anco wirll refoi� vncc -t o rc eche.. ett)"1t,Rs . Commit.,; Ivory 111"Wo colic 4'rtljng, for t'11 �11t he#111° +llmjmCicy am -is �rticulI 1t " illythe iii,c Doprtmoiitlit, innuLtod lli;m� CmCf � Vlore tic i rll, nn f urtller llusillos , tlae 1i ve?t1nj> lv; 1 00 olil tle'el, al, . 10:23 P.M. 1dwl»111.1 46 r EOM— COUNTY PLA14NING COMMISSION MINt1TLS - APr11 11, 1977 .,.J(? P,1n',1wiY�n 7 ALy1ry{CI'A`NE IxROLL CALL: Present:CnmmzarssoandsCllaavnar iGallerrtxd, Stutz, Willi Absent: No one Also Present Jim Lawson, Del 5iemsen' Brad Ballinger - Chico Enterprise Record, anal, Hazel nallas Tlx ;APPROVAL OF MINUTL38 Minv--os for April 4 1.977 were approved wit..h Z co°vr4:ctlons s Page 1, add to the end ,Everhard" pale 5 4th line :front the bottom change "'City"to "districts"- r iV. REVIPW BY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION A. Acquisit-ion of Clear Zo11,e Croville Airport 77-78-1-300 - Mr. Lawson raPorted that there wag lllepartm�.ntnask ngs fort from Mr, Kroeger of the Orov il,lo Public Works postponement for one woek because of a conflicting meeting tohlght. Heating no comments to the con1,:rary, Chaa,rma.n, Gilbert granted his Toq test; Vw ABANDOMMliNT A. Parada se T'a ncs iln:it 15 Marry Tayl.ar otal Rec{tte�4t a�_s.;ldonmont, of P�ublicl ttility, easeMeln.t on thy► north proper ty line o:t Iot 77-7R-1-566 lair. Lawson said that letters were on file frOni the tdiff Brat ent public lztila �y compa'nias that work: 3n. the area stating no object onsi and that a, petition from Property owners in the area had been rece:�rred» s , . ,, tgted that those was a' hardship in this case Cotnml.�s�oner Everharcl sttr�g ested that tile�Commi.ss7.on �e ammo td abandonment r1ot3 on was Made by Coanm, ss loner Bennett ) seconded by Commis►sioner .......... 11UTTE COUNTY PLANNING CCMMISSIPM %lxNUTRS - April 11, 1977 ComTnl %s i. one r Stutz, to rec.omme nc]. the ,granting of 'the abandonment. AUS tiwrstrim3ssa t�nos an»e ,` Stza.nt: nd Cliam�n Ci1�ort , NQLS: tea one, ABSTAINED �aomm ssi,onor Bverhard. ABSENT No oito �,Otlon cairzed,. A (10 NTINUI-*D PROM APRIL 4. I.,R 7 7 y ConsIderati.on of rozori.ng roposal for area west of 1�splan4de, nortlioi; hast ;A�JOnue, to Wid Creek, Chico 77-78.1-602 Several ere -.Ire�aract by 'staff and another propared b Commissioner Stu zy w;Ttapsppred on the W911 for study. p !� Y ,_ lanade needs more study, rea along �,sp �CyTTTT11's1.ra�UIIC.';t �Stutz.a said that thoa tt' Was noted "U-hatth6 north Portion of the proposal: was comp Bed of Dvop arti.es in tho Wi llil amt,on Act, gnd it was suggested that. these be, deletect from this p„~tpers�k At tho request of JoIlli Brayton) Route 1Box 477, Chico, staff o - plainery. (999+119t]io diffo�.rences to the various zones proposed. Mr. Brayton them asked what theproposal was for the hrayton p=roperty on tile sofitli side of Shasta adjoining the Harrington i s p rop ertY s He h,11d no specific suggestions Barbara Copeland) 1501 Manche stol Road) Chico, asked (2-501) what the proposal was for the property between Cassick and Alamo and was c!onceri'Wd about Wiat, if any, protection owners hot wishing to sell: at this tamp' Would have Wit] regard fe the pt�essuro of higkier taxes► In answer to a, question from Mrs, Copeland) Mr. Lawson..stated that the sphores of influence oftho ci.t' es were not necess.a`ri 1y coordi na°ted with available str'V1C05 Joe Mli.ngsen, 4201 W. La. .- pan, Chico, asked •that the area. on the south side of Lassen, east oaf Cussi.c.k `tae zoned 5R-1. rather than A-TR as had brren proposed earlier. (900) Frd.nk Brate11., route l., Bob. 490Chaco, cited facts and figures ��a 1 BUTTP COUNTY PtANNINC COMMISSION MxNUTBS April Irl, 1977 regar da1a\ .,the S1�.asta ))�ainw&o D�s%rxCt and`.,�5kod �.h�t> the ��rcpdrty AXI thx.s _ ustri.ot be zoned to iti . greatest potential, c ting ha gh tra ces in the area 9 ; 30 P, N. L Cha.ir,man Gilbert declared a recess to onable tho Co'M- mission a.ha ,staff to prepare a comprehensive exhibit map for the zoning proposal. 0:41 P . M.-Meeting reconvened 1, Motion was made by Commissioner Bennett, seconded. by Commi'ssio,Ier Williams, to instruct staff to p-,eoceed towards setting public hear- ings on this zoning proposal as show: on Exhibit Map "A". and :Further that the first heaving be held in Shasta Awe School,-,i'n Chico . nazi l�;t° . 'V-Vp 7 Chaa rmari Gilbert. NOES** Stutz > Williams andAY]- Commissioners iiennett,. NOES: No one. AB$tNT F No one. Mr1tion carried,, 'VII, I41SCBLLANFOUS A PROPOSED S'T'REET NAME CHANCES IN PARADISE (77-54' 'tb b � x ' ' r�r. Lawson said that, even though a.t: was.announced last (aee�c that; it would not be necessary for the C omma.ssa.on. tL) hold a oubl c hear- 4 in Paradise tegardi'ng this project, as orig�:nal],y pi 'r�ned, that it would be : n order for the Commission to take some type of formai, a.ct'ion Motion was made by Commissioner Stutz, s,00nded. by Commissioner Evorhard, to tetommend to the Board that the proposed changes be made—excepting ('.restmoox`e and a past of Wagstaff 11h,iell were sta,ii under study. AYES: Commissioners Bennett, Evorhardl Stutz, IVillaams and Cha:iTman. Gilbert. NOVS1. No one. ,ABSENT No one, Motion carried., u y BUTTE COUNTY PLANNING cOMMISSION MINUj,R,S I%prll,ll, 1977 �S' QNINC� NEON iSTRVIO , FROM LAKB MAI�RON� n11M Commissioner Gilbert a$Loa if there had been any. 43 r�Gt�.az� �ratn the laarcl to tete Cowmis,sic"'l regarding this matter blot Caine,ur list weelcAw�}x the xead3.ng aI t;ter prem MnasJct7jMinas�an, Minasian, Spxua.n.eo And Do er) local:, attorneys. Mr. Lawson rePl led that rhoro had been,none The state Of litigation, mentioned in the ,letter, Could not be de- termined at this,time, and the mr,titer of just haw 'the C;ommiSSic.' should 'proceed Was re -C -,.red to Ooun.tty Counso'l r `C SPECIAL �EMIAARS pQR COMMISS:CONgRG c" Mr. Lawson CCiitTile tt t that lie 'would ga to the Boa;rd And ash that they app--ove oxper�d.iture of funds to cover rbargols,.as outlined on the brochure: given to the members earlier this evening—Provided there remal„ned enough money In the -,budget to coater the costs, Commissioners Bennett, Ev, and and Gilbert exPxessed a desire tO attend one or more of the meetings. The matter will be brought up again next week. TAPE: 77 -78 -1 -Al 2 -All 79-1,-,471) °-George Gilbert, Chairma -4-