Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout015-230-026C. ITEMS WITH PUBLIC HEARING 1. Bonnie Lamb, determination of ,consistency with the 2000 CLUP for the Chico Municipal Airport to review a proposed 4,696 square foot commercial building in the B-2 zone of the Chico Airport Land Use compatibility plan, Chico. The project is located at 968 East Avenue, on the north side of East Avenue, approximately 550 feet east of Cohasset Road, Chico. (CD) A 05-28. Mr. Durling gave a brief summary of the project and a power point presentation. He said this parcel is part of the Chico infill area that was approved by this Commission in May.He said that Chairperson Sherman made a suggestion to him before the meeting that the Commission might want to consider a condition for noise attenuation if the building is converted or cor_structed as an office building, the interior noise level should be 45 dBs or less. Commissioner Wheeler asked how the property will be accessed from East Avenue. He asked if people would cut through Chuck E. Cheese to get to this building. Mr. Durling said it is all one lot with access agreements for both parking and the Jriveway. The hearing was opened to the public. Joe Acquistapace noted that they have to meet the City of Chico's landscaping requirements. Commissioner Hennigan said if the building is converted to office space it would have to meet the noise attenuation condition discussed earlier. Mr. Acquistapace said that was fine. The hearing was closed and comments confined to the Commission and staff. Commissioner Hennigan pointed out that if the City of Chico had brought its General Plan into conformity with the CLUP and followed State law, the applicant would not have to come before this Commission or pay the fees to have them review this. It was moved by Commissioner Hennigan, seconded by Commissioner Rosen, and unanimously carried to find ALUC File A 05-28 for Bonnie Lamb is consistent with the infill development policy of Section 2.4.4 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan subject to the findings and conditions listed below; adding a new Condition 3 to read "If the pnoposed commercial building is converted or constructed as an office building, the interior sound attenuation shall be 45 dBs or less." SECTION 1: ENVIRONMENTAL FINDINGS A. No environmental documentation has been completed for this project by ALUC staff. The City of Chico staff will make a determination per the California Environmental Quality Act as part of their processing of the commercial building. SECTION 2: CONSISTENCY FINDINGS FOR PROPOSED PROJECT A. The proposal for the Bonnie Lamb commercial use will add an additional 4,696 square feet of commercial use, which is consistent with the infill development criteria of Section 2.4.4(a)(3) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan. SECTION 3: PROJECT FINDINGS: A. The project site meets the criteria for infill development of Section 2.4.4(a)(3) because: .1.The project site is 5 acres or less in size 2. The Commercial project qualifies as infill development pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act 3. The size of the project, at approximately 4,696 square fee-, would be less than the size of the highest density of existing commercial dev.;lopment within 500 feet of the project site, a 6,018 square foot commercial building. 4.. The project site is shown on the City of Chico's infill d--velopment map, as approved by the Butte County Airport Land Use Commission on March 16, 2005. B. No structures on the project site would extend into protected airspace. C. Commercial uses are exempt from noise requirements of Section x.1.5 (a) of the Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan.. SECTION 4: PROJECT CONDITIONS: 1. Airspace review by .the Airport Land Use Commission required for objects greater than, 70 feet tall. 2. Prior to.the issuance of building permits, record an Avigation Easement granting the right of continued use of the airspace above the proposed parcel by the Chico Municipal Airport, and acknowledging any and all existing,or potential airport operational impacts. ` 3. If the proposed commercial building is converted or constructed a an office building, the interior sound attenuation shall be 45 dBs or less. I tes of Me( WANK Butte County Department of Development Services Planning Division Airport Land Use Commission July 20, 2005, ALUC Meeting AGENDA ITEM — TO: Honorable Chair and Airport Land Use Commission FROM: Carl Durling, Associate Planner DATE: July 20, 2005 ITEM: ALUC File No. A 05-28 — Lamb, APN 015-230-026: A consistency review for the addition of a 4,656 square foot commercial building in an exisdng commercial complex. The project site pad is located on the north side of Eas.i Avenue, at the rear of the subject parcel, approximately 550 feet east of Cohasset Road, in area 13 • 4 of the Chico Airport infill map and in Airport Compatibility Zone B2, City of Chico. SUMMARY: Staff recommends that ALUC find the project consistent with the 2000 Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan for the Chico Municipal Airport.,' Consistency is based upon the recently - approved amendment to Section 2.4.4 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan and ALUC's approval of the City of Chico infill development map at the March 16, 2005 meeting. BACKGROUND:. • The property is within the incorporated limits of the City of Chico. The project site is designated Community Commercial on the City of Chico General Plan Diagram and is zoned CC (Community Commercial). • The subject property is a vacant building pad with parking already established, and is a portion of a 1.04 acre parcel. The development proposal is to build a 4,696 square foot commercial building for use as a restaurant. • The remaining portion of the 1.04 acre parcel is developed with an existing operating restaurant of 6,018 square feet, and a parking area. • Existing land uses within 500 feet of the project site include commercial uEes to the north east, west and south across East Avenue, single family residential dwellings to the north and south. across East Avenue, and an elementary school adjacent on the.east. • No open space is proposed on the project site. • The height of the tallest object on the project site is anticipated to be approximately 24 feet above ground level, which equates to approximately 225 feet above mean sea level. Q ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ,■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20,, 2005 ■ Page 1 of 10 ■ ANALYSIS: • This project is a major land use action as defined by Policy 1.5.3 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan (ALUCP). • The project site lies within Airport Compatibility Zone B2 (Extended Approach/Departure Zone). • The primary compatibility criteria for the B2 Airport Compatibility Zone a:e shown on the following table: Compatibility Zone Criteria Maximum Densities Req'd Other Development Zone Open Prohibited Uses •-onditions Residential Land du/ac 1 Children's schools, Minim7im NLR* of 25 day care center, dB in Psidences < 0.2 (average libraries, hospitals, (including mobile B2 (Extended parcel size > 5.0 o 20% nursing homes, homes: and buildings Approach/Departure acres) highly noise- with noise sensitive Zone) sensitive uses, issues, airspace review hazards to flight for objects >70 feet tall, deed notice required Extract from Table 2A of the 2000 ALUCP *NLR - Noise Level Reduction • The project site is approximately 0.6 miles west of the extended centerline of Runway 31R/13L of the Chico Municipal Airport, at a distance of 1.8 miles southwest of this runway. • Section 4.1.3 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan states that the maximum noise level for residential uses in the vicinity of an airport is 55 dB CNEL, except for the area south of the Chico Municipal Airport, where a 60 dB CNEL no=se maximum is acceptable. I • The project site is not within the 55 dB CNEL noise contour as shown on E>hibit 4E (Noise Impacts — Future Average Fire Season Day) but is within the 55dB CNEL noise contour as shown on Exhibits 4F (Noise Impacts — Expanded Forecast) and 4G (Noise Impacts — Peak Fire Attack Day) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility P!an. • Pursuant to Section 4.1.5(a) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan, staff - notes that commercial buildings and uses are excluded from the requirement of achieving a maximum interior noise level of 45 dB CNEL. • The proposed commercial restaurant development qualifies as infill development pursuant to Section 15332 (Class 32) of the California Environmental Quality Act Categorically Exempt status projects. In summary, a project qualifies if it is consistent with the G --,neral Plan and zoning; is within the City Limits; not a habitat for rare or endangered species; would not result in traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality impacts; and can be served by 'all required utilities and public services. ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 ■ Page 2 of 10 ■ o The project site also meets the criteria for infill development of Section 2.4.4(a)(3) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan. It is 5 acres or less in size (1.04 acres), qualifies as infill development pursuant to Section 15332 of the California Environmental Quality Act, and the density of the project (4,696 square feet) would be less than the highest density of the existing developments within 500 feet of the project site. The property already includes a 6,018 square foot commercial building. Amendment to Policy 2.4.4 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan • At the February 16, 2005, ALUC meeting the Commission approved an amendment to Section 2.4.4 (Special Conditions) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan. The amendment allows infill development that would otherwise be inconsistent with the B2 Airport Consistency Zone. • Section 2.4.4 now allows infill development on parcels that are 5 acres or less in size. If the proposed infill development meets the infill development requirements of Section 15332 (In - Fill Development Projects) of the California Environmental Quality Act, the infill development density may be equal to, but no greater than, the density that exists on the most densely developed property'that is located within 500 feet of the perimeter of the parcel. • The City of Chico provided a map to the ALUC that showed those parcels eligible for infill development in the B2 Airport Compatibility Zone south of the Chico Mlnicipal Airport:. ALUC formally adopted this map on March 16, 2005 as the infill development map. The project parcel is identified as parcel 13 on the City of Chico infill development map. ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTATION: No environmental documentation has been completed for this project by ALUC staff. The City of Chico staff will make a determination per the California Environmental Qual:_ty Act as part of their processing of the application for development review. It is expected that a Class 32 categorical exemption for in -fill development (Section 15332 of the CEQA GLidelines) will be the environmental determination for the new commercial use. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Butte County Airport Land Use Commission find ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) is consistent with the infill development policy of Sec -tion 2.4.4 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan. Exhibits: A: Findings B: List of References C: -Project Location. and Compatibility Zones Map D: Site Plan \\Ds-svr-14\Documents\Planning\ALUC\AL.UC Applications\2005 Files\A05-28 Lamb on East Ave. east of Cohasset\Agenda Report A0428 Lamb commercial on Nside of East Ave..doc ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A'05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20,' 2005 ■ Page 3 of 10 ■ EXHIBIT A BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION CONSISTENCY FINDINGS FOR ALUC File No. A 05-28 — Bonnie Lamb. APN 015-230- 026: The Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) has prepared the. following findings: based on data contained in the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan (ALUCP), as well as site specific information submitted by the applicant and ALUC staff. The following findings have been prepared at the direction of the ALUC and are for the consideration of the Lead Agency (City of Chico) when making a decision on the project. SECTION 1: ENVIRONMENTAL FINDINGS A. No environmental documentation has been completed for this project by ALUC staff. The City of Chico staff will make a determination per the California Environmental Quality Act as part of their processing of the commercial building. SECTION 2: CONSISTENCY FINDINGS FOR PROPOSED PROJECT A.'. The proposal for the Bonnie Lamb commercial use will add an additional 4,696 square feet of commercial use, which is consistent with the infill "development criteria of Section 2.4.4(a)(3) of the. 2000 Butte County Amort Land Use Compatibility .Plan. SECTION 3: PROJECT FINDINGS: A. The project site meets the criteria for infill development of Section 2.4.4(a)(3) because:. 1. The project site is 5 acres or less in size 2. The Commercial project qualifies as infill development pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act 3.. The size of the project, at approximately 4,696 square feet, would be less than the size of the highest density of. existing commercial development within 500 feet of the project site, a 6,018 square bot commercial building. 4'. The project site is shown on the City of Chico's infill development map, as approved by the Butte County Airport Land Use Commission on March . . 16-2005.. B. No structures on the project site would extend into protected airspace. C. Commercial uses are exempt from noise requirements. of Section 4.1.5 (a) of the Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan.. ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 ■ Page 4 of 10 ■ EXHIBIT B " List of References oKpnypl �p6B�eyigNydh6�006_ j _ _ •'._�. a•.t NOV '" A l j1:q: j A i X 15?C- _& Portion of Chico Airport Infill Map, Area 13 ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 m Page 8 of 10 ■ ' X3�'• d�. rA fi ' ���� • Y (y �W n4T.� ` . t .,.. Y Ej' �T i 4�( Y4 ' a^r ,�'fcy.Y�' 4. � §' �� �% �` • �- � r ����. � '" � f 3.&e ?"%,,. a �• �a tg ` . ' 2d'' � �qt ..(n�� £#����� 'YY' y'.1mi. �����f- 3�Ae � CS A7¢�.,i• G � q�.]y � s ., S_ t' � �` •,,Y: }y���g ,jc�'y��,^, Yom.+ , R 3 Bonnie Lamb .'• A 05-23 G JJ'� 'XW r• � `� '��- �t � i� ?�'T�' {q�.a'��.�a,� pfpJ}� d�`S1 � ''• J r �Wl_( gm ' Z1. - $ : yt — `r4;F•� w1`vTt>;a� RI f„'' �� �� '3 �.lY oli � � � ,l• y *� a - F N$•!1r("'(" « � 1 �4 4,'t L w���• � d �� Y� - '� .Z p' i �� f ty� tA ' ; � � i! I . J 5[ ` . ` 4 ,•* r � + \ � -e+ ` a " . i /"b n T Tµ � t � VP 1' "-®"Butte'County Airport�Land Use'Commission o A-LUC,F'ile'No."A 05-28'(Bonnte Lamb) ® July 20, 2005 m Page.9iof I ® r tt F ns i OLD r; (' I• ;ter—; � L... al ��� \,r. � r �� � . r y it c t I _RRev.osiD inlRnjaeE �a ._l1.RL,_B.AANLE_.L9 MB lit T�fT 1V •Y9L Lt t LAPACE _.. ® Butte County Airport, Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 ■ Page 10 of 10 ■ o �O T TF>o Brute ' County Department of Development Services www.buftecounty.net/dds o o ° 7 County Center Drive °�`' .° Oroville, CA 95965 o — ":: o . (530) 538-7601 Telephone C0IJ N'fjy (530) 538.7785 Facsimile ADMINISTRATION * BUILDING * GIS * PLANNING July 20, 2005 Bonnie Lamb 32 Quista Drive Chico, CA 95926 RE:. A 05-28, APN, 015-230-026 Dear Ms. Lamb: On Wednesday, July 20,•2005, the Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) found the referenced project to be consistent subject to the conditions listed below: 1. Airspace review by the Airport Land Use Commission required for objects greater than 70 . feet tal. 2. Prior to the issuance of building permits, record and Avigation Easement granting the right of continued use of the airspace above the proposed parcel by the Chico Municipal Airport,' and acknowledging any and all existing or potential airport operational impacts. 3. If the proposed commercial building is converted or constructed as an office building, the . interior sound attenuation shall be 45 dBs or less. Should you need additional information, please contact Carl Durling at (530) 53&7150. Thank you. Sincerely, Lynn Richardson . Commission Clerk cc: City of Chico Joe Acquistapace Butte County DeparLinent ofDevelopment Services %3T TF o PLANNING DIVISION o 7 County Center Drive c o Oroville, CA 95965 C- - - (530) 538-7601 Telephone o -`=�=�� J o " (530) 538-7785 Facsimile ADMINISTRATION * BUILDING *-GIS * PLANNING July 12, 2005 Bonnie Lamb _ - 32 Quista Drive Chico, CA 95926 Re: A 05-28, AP: 015-230-026 Dear Ms. Lamb: Enclosed is a copy of the Agenda Report concerning your application for consistency findings for the addition of a 4,656 square foot commercial building in an existing commercial building in an existing commercial complex. The project site pad is located on the north side of East Avenue, at the rear of the subject parcel; approximately 500 feet east of cohasset Road, in area 13 of the Chico airport infill map and in Airport, Compatibility Zone B2, City of Chico. Should you have any concerns with the report or conditions of approval, please contact us in advance of the meeting so that we may work together to resolve your concerns. A public hearing has been set for July 20, 2005, at 9:00 a.m. This meeting will be held in the Board of Supervisors' Room, 25 County Center Drive, Oroville, California. - The Airport Land Use'Commission recommends that the applicant or their authorized representative be present at the hearing to respond to any questions the Commission may have. Should.you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact Carl Durling of this office at 538-7150, between 8:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m., Monday through Friday. _ Sincerely, Lynn Richardson Commission Clerk Enc. y . cc: _ City of Chico Joe Acquistapace Ki\letters\merge letters\SCHEDULE.dot { r Butte County -Department of Development Services Planning Division "Airport Land Use Commission July 20, 2005, ALUC Meeting AGENDA ITEM — TO: Honorable Chair and Airport Land Use Commission FROM: Carl Durling, Associate Planner DATE: July 20, 2005 ITEM: ALUC File No. A 05-28 — Lamb, APN 015-230-026: A consis_ency review for the addition of a 4,656 square foot commercial building in an existing commercial complex.. The project site pad is located on the north side of East Avenue, at the rear of the subject parcel, approximately 550 feet east of Cohasset Road, in area 13 of the Chico Airport infill map and in Airport Compatibility Tine B2, City of ; Chico. SUMMARY: Staff recommends, that ALUC find the project consistent with the 2000 A-rport Land Use • Compatibility Plan for the Chico Municipal Airport. Consistency is based upon the recently-,. approved amendment to Section 2.4.4 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility ' Plan and ALUC's approval of the City of Chico infill development map at the March 16, 2005 meeting. BACKGROUND: T • The property is within the incorporated limits of the City of Chico. The project site iso designated Community Commercial on the City of Chico General Plan Diagram and is zoned CC (Community Commercial). ' • The subject property is a vacant building pad with parking already established, and is a' portion of a 1.04 acre parcel. The development proposal is to build a 4,696 square foot commercial building for use as a restaurant. • The remaining portion of the 1.04 acre parcel - is developed with an existing operating restaurant of 6,018 square feet, and a parking area. • Existing land uses within 500 feet of the project site include commercial uses to the north east, west and south across East Avenue, single family residential dwellings to the north and south across East Avenue, and an elementary school adjacent on the east. • No open space is proposed on the project site. • The height of the tallest object on the project site is anticipated to be approximately 24 feet'- above ground level, which equates to approximately 225 feet above mean sea level. t ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20,- 2005 m Page 1 of 10 ■ ANALYSIS: • This project is a major land use action as defined by Policy 1.5.3 of the .2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan (ALUCP). • The project site lies within Airport Compatibility Zone B2 (Extended Approach/Departure Zone). • The primary compatibility criteria for the B2 Airport Compatibility Zone are shown on the following table: Compatibility Zone Criteria Maximum Densities Req'd Other Development Zone Open Prohibited Uses Conditions Residential Land (du/ac)' Children's schools, Mininium NLR* of 25 day care center, dB in residences libraries, hospitals, (inclucing mobile B2 (Extended < 0.2 (average o 20% nursing homes, homesi and buildings Approach/Departure parcel size > 5.0 acres) highly noise- with noise sensitive Zone) sensitive uses, issues,, airspace review hazards to flight for obk-cts >70 feet tall, deed m3tice required Extract from Table 2A of the 2000 ALUCP {NLK - Noise Level Ke(luction • . The project site is approximately 0.6 miles west of the extended centerline of Runway. 31RJ13L of the.Chico Municipal Airport, at a distance of 1.8 miles southwest of this.runway. • Section 4.1.3 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan states that the maximum noise level for residential uses in the vicinity of an airport is 55 dB CNEL, except for the area south of the Chico Municipal Airport, where a 60 dB CNEL noise maximum is acceptable. • The project site is not within the 55 dB CNEL noise contour -as shown on Exhibit 4E (Noise Impacts — Future Average Fire Season Day) but is within the 55dB CNEL noise contour as shown on Exhibits 4F (Noise Impacts — Expanded Forecast) and 4G (Noise Impacts — Peak Fire Attack Day) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan. • Pursuant to Section. 4.1.5(a) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan, staff notes that commercial buildings and uses are excluded from the requirement of achieving a maximum interior noise level of 45 dB CNEL. • The proposed commercial restaurant development qualifies as infill development pursuant to Section 15332 (Class 32) of the California Environmental Quality Act Categorically Exempt status projects. In summary, a project qualifies if it is consistent with the General Plan and zoning;. is within the City Limits; not a habitat for rare or endangered species; would not result in traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality impacts; and can be served by all required utilities and public services. ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission m ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 ■ Page 2 of 10 ■ • The project site also meets the criteria for infill development of Section 2 4.4(a)(3) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan. It is 5 acres or less in size (1.04 acres), qualifies as infill development pursuant to Section 15332 of the California Environmental Quality Act, and the density of the project (4,696 square feet) would be less than the highest density of the existing developments within 500 feet of the project site. The property already includes a 6,018 square foot commercial building. Amendment to Policy 2.4.4 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan • At the February 16, 2005, ALUC meeting the Commission approved an amendment to Section 2.4.4 (Special Conditions) of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility, Plan. The amendment allows infill development that would otherwise be inconsistent with the B2 Airport Consistency Zone. • Section 2.4.4 now allows infill development on parcels that are 5 acres or less in size. If the proposed infill development meets the infill development requirements of Se:tion 15332 (In - Fill Development Projects) of the California' Environmental Quality -Act, the infill development density may be equal to, but no greater than, the density that exists on the most densely developed property that is located within 500 feet of the perimeter of the parcel. • The City of Chico provided a map to the ALUC that showed those parcels eligible for infill development in the B2 Airport Compatibility Zone south of the Chico Municipal Airport. ALUC formally adopted this map on March 16, 2005 as the infill development map. The project parcel is identified as parcel 13 on the City of Chico infill development map. ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTATION: No environmental documentation has been completed for this project by ALUC. staff. The City of Chico staff will make a determination per the California Environmental Qualiy Act as part of their processing of the application for development review. It- is expected that a Class 32 categorical exemption for in -fill development (Section 15332 of the CEQA Guidelines) will be, the environmental determination for the new commercial use. RECONIlVIENDATION: Staff recommends that the Butte County Airport Land Use Commission find ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) is .consistent with the infill development policy of Section 2.4.4 of the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan. Exhibits: A: Findings B: List of References C: Project Location and Compatibility Zones Map D: Site Plan , \\Ds-svr-14\Documents\Planning\ALDC\ALUC Applications\2005 Files\A05-28 Lamb on East Ave. east of Cohasset\Agenda Report A05-!8 Lamb commercial on Nside of East Ave..doc r ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005.m Page 3 of 10 ■ EXHIBIT A BUTTE COUNTY AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION CONSISTENCY FINDINGS FOR ALUC File No.A 05-28 - Bonnie Lamb, APN 015 -230- 026 - The Airport Land Use Commission (ALUC) has prepared the following findings based on data contained in the 2000 Butte County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan (ALUCP), as well as site specific information submitted by the applicant and ALUC staff. The following findings have been prepared at the direction of the ALUC and are for the. consideration of the Lead Agency (City of Chico), when making a decision on the project. " SECTION 1: ENVIRONMENTAL FINDINGS A. " No ,environmental documentation has been completed for this project by ALUC staff. The City of Chico staff will make a. determination pe- the California Environmental Quality Act as part of their processing of the commercial building. SECTION`2: CONSISTENCY FINDINGS FOR PROPOSED PROJECT A." The proposal for the Bonnie Lamb commercial use will add an additional 4,696 " square feet of commercial use, which is consistent with the infill" development criteria of Section 2.4.4(a)(3) of the 2000 Butte ,County Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan. SECTION 3: PROJECT FINDINGS: A. The project site meets the criteria for infill 'development of Section 2.4.4(a)(3) because: 1. The project site is 5 acres or less in size 2. The Commercial project qualifies as infill development pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act 3. The size of the project, at approximately 4,696 square feet, would be less than the size of the highest density of existing commerc_al development within 500 feet of the project site, a 6,018 square foot commercial building: ". 4.; The project site is shown on the City of Chico'.s infill development map, as approved by the Butte County Airport Land Use Commission on March 16, 2005. B. No structures on the project site would extend into protected airspace. `C: Commercial uses are exempt from noise requirements of Section 4.1.5 (a) of -the Butte County Airpoit Land Use Compatibility Plan.. ■ Butte County AirportLand Use Commission ■ ALUC File.No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 ■ Page 4 of 10 ■ . EXHIBIT B - List of References Data supporting the ALUC s findings have been generated from studies and repDrts prepared by recognized professionals and agencies with expertise in Airport Land Use Planning and land use compatibility. These include, but are not limited to: r Butte County 2000 Airport Land Use Compatibility Plan Chico Municipal Airport B2 Compatibility Zone — City of Chico Infill Map, adopted_ ; March 16, 2005. ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 ■ Page 6 of 10 ■ Portion of Chico Airport Infill Map, Area 13 ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 ■ Page 8 of 10 ■ r , ' ;ti �H �+X f %�^�i�4 ��'�'� . .; I��i � � ..L � \ °4 � �����. ��•� ,,t� 5 tsy M +h �t i t7 • � 4> � i 5 fQ W qa �t E(� A i 3 . ^ A'4b�sj "u -e >"Y '.`"3 t - '� y♦� ,y - - a k `Bonnie Lamb A 05-23 L Y 2 f ' � fi � 1� EM �Y ' • 1-. i �:�. S'%. �`L ''S'. 1 i^ :&��C `�i:. '��T'�,TKb4 t�£y7�..�tlaoic' 1 � T - 2 ::i p-7 .1'. I zr*" _ - 4, •') h. � :b%z`d' � A. 5 � J>S x "`� � ! F. .f. � ". _ '� `' x S w,,,„ yA�� v,R" �,�' � w:!1d}�,�ih N .,¢ .. :4 t 7 t .� °� •yas�i '��.g"t`S` r4tk r � rn h M�3• J GR ' t# RKv' -'1 C'i �l4 fi' � h 7.*4• `3 S . � i"` � �� � R � � 'az :`aye' �f?. ^} .9' . � t i f �.. ��: '�c <..iq..,.4. 3Y., �t •.$' i �' i r �' .� �� � _.� ���� ' x L Y � _ .t » � $ R�71`��fxa1'rY � ,� t. p •' .17 ., .1 1• y �1 i. 4 t r. S' y. •� %> � �!` .. r fir,' Y x •:,� ty a.- x � � !, ry, � i q�, a it yf t a} :5 •' r ,A in Biitte,County Airport Land Use Commission e ALUC File No. A 05-28. (Bonnie Lamb),® July, -20,--. r —2005 ■ Page 9 10 ■ of d t t i } i Ml II JOE. ACQUISTAPACEIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ARGHITECT - ■ Butte County Airport Land Use Commission ■ ALUC File No. A 05-28 (Bonnie: Lamb) ■ July 20, 2005 ■ Page 10 of 10 ■ Wednesday, May 25, 2005 Development Services PLANNING DIVISION Ver. Counter DDS Planning $0.00 (General Fund) Payment Date5/2 4/2005 (Land Development) 1430654 Receipt Number $0.00 'Lamb, Bonnie (UBS Received From / NOE 'financial) Applicant :Lamb, Bonnie Aunt Minnie A 5-28 I $1, 500 or $2,000 Application Number - or In Reference To $0.00 Parcel Number :015-230-026 1167-79107 Check Number/ Cash $1,531:00 $0.00 Total`Received $1,531.00 Total Fees I R DDS Planning $0.00 (General Fund) Public Works $0.00 (Land Development) Environmental $0.00 CDF (Fire De $0.00 / NOE $0.00 INOD (Recording Fee) Aunt Minnie $0.00 I $1, 500 or $2,000 Planning Review EIR $0.00 Fish/Game $0.00 $1,531.00 IALUC (Airport Land Use) Ii Non Sufficient $0.00 Funds ($25.00 Fee) Tower $0.00 1Cell ($2500.00) Public Sales $0.00 Other: $0.00 I R COUNTY OF BUTTE FIFICIAL RECEIPT 430654 OFFTIE OR DEPARTMENT ISSUING RECEIPT 5 - 20aS--' Received from &9.1 V 0" eti, 1-1 C Tht Sum ofd e 7�0 Forte !i_- 25 A : /2 ao- _-6 2 Received: Received By—/-, L5 _t;i � (fcl CASH Title CHECK By DAVrn RI I-qlKjr:QQ griou S . tn� n UBS FIN;NlbW_ -CERVICES INC.- KO 167 7 opUBS U 1058 MANGE Av8NUE, SUITE 2 CHICO, CA 95926-3595 62-35 J. 31.1 ACCT. 'NUMBER member of all principal security, commodity and option exchanges. L T C,i-f !�.JL Z_ C D: 1 This check is not negotiable after 180 days from date issued .'AMOUNT DATE. PAY TO THE ORDER OF _31i. -X� aXr E' cc The Bank of New York (Delaware)-. T. Newark, Delaware L I C3 7?910.?Ilm ' 1:03L10035Ii: u503009721141116 RECEIVED FROM COUNTY OF BUTTE AUDITOR'S CERTIFICATE AND TREASURER'S RECEIPT OROVILLE, CA ATR NO 84993 . PLANNING DAG # 316 DATE 5125/2005 FUND FUND DEPT ACCT CASH DESCRIPTION TITLE CODE CODE CODE CODE AMOUNT DEPOSIT DATE: 5125 RECEIPTS: 430554-9710 PLANNING APPL FEES GENL 0010 44.0Wl 4210M 101001 7,235.00 Project Number Amount of Fee APN 028-230-009; BANGOR ROC! QUARRY; ?.I 04N-05 $839 APN 030-1$0-017; GEORGIA NELSON; TPM 05-24 $3,198 APN 00010-03QRODGER NICHOLS;TPM 05-23 $3,198 LAND DEVELOPMENT ::. GENL 0010 440004 4611700 101001 Project Number Amount of Fee APN 030-160-017; GEORGIA NELSON: TPM 05-24 $491 ,4PN 064-010-030;RODGER NICHOLS;TPM 05-26 $491 ENVIRONMENTAL HLTH GENL 0010 540003 4614901 '109001 -' Prafe' d Number Amount of Fee >.:APN 030-180-017; GEORGIA NELSON; TPM 05-24 $378 `APN 064-010=030,RODGER NICh10LS;TPM.05-255 $9,049.50 FIRE PLNG APPL ;SEE FIRE PROTECT 0100 4517240 101001. F'rpg�ct Number Amount' of Fee APN 034 -160 -017; -GEORGIA NELSON; TP(bi 05-24 $283 APN 06401.0 030:RODGER NICHOLS;TPM 06-25 $283 NODINOE CLERK'S FILING FE GENL . 0010 47QCti.11 4612319 1010101 (am) Project Number Amount of Fee APN 030;160-017; GEORGIA NELSOP.JPM 05-24 $36 APN 064-010-030;RODGER NICHOLS;TPM 05-25 $36 AGRICULTURE AG FEE 0090 460001 4512100 101001 Project Number Amount of Fee APN 030-180-017: GEORGIA NELSON; TPM.05-24 $32.50 APN 064010-030.RODGER NICHOLS;TPM 05-25 $32.50 D-T.-ALUG PLANNING GENL 0010 440001 4617241 101001 Project Number Amount of Fee iAPN 0+5-23"2E-BrNNIE LAMB -A Q5-28 "DOCUMENT/COPY SALES _. "GENL i+10i 4400U1 4711910; -- 10,1001 TOTAL. $ APPROVED BY: RECEIVED BY: AUDITOR-CONFMOLLER TREASURER � BY white=treasurer, pin4r-,-auditorrr canarV--depositor Polden md=File 77 982.00 1,417.50 525.00 . 72.00 1,5.�1.OD 2.00 61 ,830.59 Durling, Carl From: Durling, Carl Sent: Thursday, June 02, 2005 7:09 AM To: Breedon, Dan Subject: RE: Lamb ALUC review Dan I received this application for processing on 31 May 2005. In no way could I prepare and get this application ready for the June ALUC meeting. It will be heard at the July meeting. I will call and let him know. Carl From: Breedon, Dan Sent: Wednesday, June 01, 2005 4:23 PM To: Durling, Carl Subject: Lamb ALUC review Carl, Please call Joe Aquistipace about this ALUC review. He wants to know the status and when he can go to ALUC (he sounded pretty anxious). 891-0916. Thanks. Dan Breedon, AICP, Principal Planner Butte County Department of Development Services 7 County Center Drive, Oroville, CA 95965 530-538-7629, FAX: 530-538-7785 , 1 r "DRAFT" LEAD IN. SHEET FILE NO: 1�~ d 577 .Z AP# G i575'0- 02,E APPLICANT: j' CCcv� �c9ulyl�r'e OWNER:w�Pi , r -REPRESENTATIVE: PROPOSED REQUEST:, (to be filled out by person taking in application) , 4? 11 ,-e..i. R -2 ��►,eriS rJiz ^t-lf�.s GH t r� /�t✓'Z % L✓.O cJlc Av.�r FINAL REQUEST: (to be filled out by project planner) SIZE: /. 6%. LOCATIOIy: ,' 8 mss' G(�l,`c� �� e r �o �f -we,7 SUPERVISORIAL DISTRICT '# EXISTING ZONING: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: C� ASSIGNED PLANNER: Date Application Received ' /7- y Date Proiect Assigned IDR Date 30 Day Complete Tentative Hearing Date KAPIanningTormsEead In Sheet.doc PLANNER's INITIALS REC EN �1 cv,.-L 4 0& f.li✓G MAY 2 7 2005 BUTTE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES AA nCOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT PLANNING 411 Main Street - 2nd Floor (530) 879-6800 CITYOFCHICO P.O. Box 3420 F* (530) 895-4726 INC. 187Z Chico, CA 95927 http://www.ci.chico.ca.us May 13, 2005 Butte County Airport Land Use Commission 7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965 Re: Request for ALUC Review - City of Chico Application: Development Review Committee Application 05-01 (Acquistapace/La><r-b) With this letter, the City of Chico Planning Division forwards a Butte County A=rport Land Use Commission (ALUC) application for consistency findings for the captioned proj--ct. Enclosed with the application are a check in the amount of $1,531.00, a project`site plan, znd 24 copies of a map showing the relationship of the project to the airport boundary and runways. The project site is within the boundary of Zone'B2 (and immediately adjacent to Zone D) fon the Chico Municipal Airport, and is one of the sites designated for infill development (Area. 13). The project consists of a proposal to construct a 4,696 square foot commercial building on a 1.04 acre site located at 968 East Avenue, which is intended for use by a restaurant (2,696 square feet) and office (2,000 square feet). The site is already developed with a commercial building 6,018 square feet in size, occupied by a restaurant and bar ("Quackers"). The property is identified as Assessor's Parcel No. 015-230-026, is designated Community Commercial on the City of Chico General Plan Diagram, and is located in a CC Community Commercial zoning d --strict. The project is consistent with the General Plan designation and zoning for the area. Pursuant to Table 2A of the 2000 ALUCP, a maximum density of 100 people/acre for a single acre is allowed in the B2 Compatibility Zone. Based upon a, parking analysis using the method described in Appendix D of the ALUCP, the calculated density for this project is. 98 people/acre. (68 required parking spaces multiplied by 1.5 occupants per vehicle = 102 occupants, divided by parcel size of 1.04 acres = 98 people/acre.) Please note that the density for this s_.te is less than the density for the Chuck E. Cheese property located immediately to the west. Because of the project's consistency with the provisions of Zone B2, we would appreciate a staff determination that it should not proceed to ALUC. In the event that staff determines otherwise, please schedule this item for the next available ALUC meeting. Your assistance in processing this application is greatly appreciated. Please feel fee to contact me at (530) 879-6810 or gredeker@ci.chico.ca.us if you have any questions. (a�� Made From Recycled Paper DRC 05-01 (Acquistapace/Lamb) May 13, 2005 Page 2 of 2 Sincerely, G g Redeker Assistant Planner Attachments: Application and Check. Site Plan , • Location Maps (24) cc: Joe Acquistapace, 32 Quista Drive, Chico, CA 95926 DRC 05-01 BE CoQ4nzL)e--r D K r` G 4-1CF—SE, •PRe1U` &.�ILDIVc x I Pn gl'IU Qi W5-r,uy' 4 cress' A1JV nrmau vA..T - . Icts m••ft+..•.nl leao m•!es 1 T,O fwt TQluuy POO e0f4 ILS i tc.Ta 2f.10 ewa+. ,- uGW�QPsrAmywuT PATS '7bTAl C•.la 0.6tpU.PtO Gd.49'CnAt._. • _. 't"_y w-- ^TA ZQ.�¢E.�roTAGE :- IrllaT+•..4 6UIlDlua �D Do. VT - - NOW QUILAtNQ 4V & 59. rf - • — 0... �.. • • \+ tp•e a. ' l !e fib' 1A off( b.• {`•' -- - {{{f�{ t4cwfmfc 1 F��"f-'F INTI I —� O • . vl 4 M1M1��.• OA4-'1 �7IIyI/7�.. ioim4�o K VV��..��V OC.4PAtT (.a fKMJIQJ PAmlt+l.y AP ---_ .- --- • ��"'� • , � S Iw re.w. �a�►�.r --�_ - ati� _ LAsr ^1/9$401 .. BUTTE COUNTY MAY 17.2005.. DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Mot r L4 �. B2 ' _ (1 , / X11 �"�` • �••. !• � , , t. . '•/ . ••'.. ' +. ( fir., .. ...1 • i .�=_7p.. _ -__•�� •'R ' /`- .' }�, �((�q�,7� <. . J•'�4. ice'' � � '..... - • j - i •i N• PLO Fl-cej, kv •�i 1/p_'1,' '� �f1� I� � i'�;�_� ' i I- i •, ii _�� i —. .' r • 1. • ,� '`• :tit ` � � � : � ; :-�_--�: it : ;l .. ... :; :.:,��' . � i ;.�•-�"...:r .� ., - .' �' -.: � ,� {�. •moi.. - =: =t . ,- ;- /C Parking analysis for 300 ft around 968 East Ave, Parking Places 1. Residence 2 2. Residence 2 I. Fairview Center 72 4. Hi Fy muffler , ' 1 5. Bombers grill 3 6. All The Best Video Tape sales 0 7. Child Care 4 8. Spiteri Deli /Reef conection 9 9. Taco Bell 38 10. Cathys / Dive shop 22 11. Randy Fowkes DDS 7 12. McManus School No -parking within 300 -ft zone.. 13. Dry Cleaning / Office space 17 14. Office space / parts storage 7 15. Riebes Parts store 23 16. Quakers / El Tamborazo Please refer to new parking diagram. 17. Chuck E Cheese Please refer to new parking diagram. 18. Burger King 44 ; 19. The Donut Nook / Music store 20 20. Courtesy Motors No parking within 300 -ft zine. Kim gill PROJECT SUMMARY SHEET FILE #: A 05-28 AP #: 015-230-026 APPLICANT: Bonnie Lamb ADDRESS: 32 Quista Drive, Chico, CA 95926 OWNER: Same REPRESENTATIVE: Joe Accluistapace ADDRESS: same PROJECT DESCRIPTION / LOCATION: Bonnie Lamb, determination of consistency with the 2000 CLUP for the Chico Municipal Airport to review a proposed new 4,696 square foot commercial building in the B-2 zone of the Chico Airport Land Use co,mpatibility plan, Chico. The project is located 968 East Avenue, east of Cohasset Road, approximately 550 feet on the north side of East Avenue, Chico. (CE). DESIGNATION: 1. Application submitted: 5/17/05 Amount: $1,531.00 Receipt # 430654 u Photocopy of deposit check received 2. Comments (sent to / received from): 3. Staff Report (date / prepared by): _ ❑ Staff Report in file 4. Published: (date / specify where) ❑ Hearing Notice, if published 5. ALUC Commission Hearing(s): Agenda Action taken: ❑ Found to be Consistent ❑ Found to be Inconsistent Notes/Special Conditions: 6. ❑ Minutes` - CLOSED FILES: ❑ Billed out date ❑ Received Check Amount: $ Receipt # Fj Sent them Refund or ❑ Check box if County-initiated—"Exempt from fees" K:\Planning\ALIJC\BILI..INGS\PROJEc,r SUMMARY.SHEET.dod Friday,.May 27, 2005 Check Number/ Cash $19'531.W' Total Recervecil ; Y ^ Total Fees4 s $1 531.00 Fish/Game ALUC (Airport Land Use) Non Sufficient Funds ($25.00 Fee) 1Cell Tower ($2500.00). Public Sales / Copies Other: $0.00 $1,531.00 $0.00 - $0.00 i $0.00 $0.00 • .....w� S ...•a:- '..dfl4Ml'rt7F`wI1R.�`e ti ..}' :H'.c i •wii4.4111.;1 _.y.1 id- ..� 1tT Y5y,4 - .i F ':'ik `f P: . . 'c i Pii"_ t - p.i :• "°"''' u3`y tau�aa�G+ "..st'.. , '. ?ML >2 ,!5, �a+` ��"y'7k�ry `rir �rt'.i, t�ry� �jVh�k2`XBY PROJECKT�'Lh�PR..OP,.ONpENT..(kTo BE COQ, PJ ETED BY0AP� ICAS.ORI �.,, �':=��„�F ��ti�}..� r� � r *7 ,�F,:•k.; • :x.: -.� . •::�•: ,• , »y..�, UU t�✓ j .i.:�$,,\I-,.•.��...�.,'h^' Yywt �' ..8 w.q +. �.��. .rz • ;e"- 'NUMNA, i6�rTT'�' }fw'�?i •� Fx: �� F•e$.•,dU%�4.;:-,�.,;; �h?our;. A`• b� y1 i5 '�r`i x� a i •• .� .dirr tt tt.{..t4".rq: l,,.3 �nV il{�a�i-Ma�as�s�uu_.67ci" K vFt.k a_�'f21.. r4n SiU? 5„ Date of Application Md�( I f 00'5 Property Owner C�IQS. Upt9U1EN S Phone Number 5$0 1 16 . ;. FTI 1 /3 3 Mailing Address:---',�. 1 Agent (if any)�� cq[ �1°S��pG� Phone Number. 530'•- -0�t 1� '� Mailing Address:.3Q:°� l5% `�PJ �J C.4-11 C ci 59 2G "1�'� �O� li�L"' •�,o�i a t®i � ��(® . -in .. �' ®I . r 4�P� : � o �i � I . t� .• - f t" � c 1! A;�t.��b.• �4 ac�c,�z�r�at�Z��.��'?,•.� r�?a � S r:�o.�"���'t-�i r �a�.;'.o.�n �'h.��,.�.�T.�i` at- �o � ��arr,�o,. ' oun'cla..�,�:,Q��,. ..,daY...� . Street Address��8 E •.5T" 4,VF-- C�l--�JCD'.'C�1.1.Fr c1::5ei:2$ Assessor's Parcel No. X15 •° 230 C7(o ! Parcel Size ��t�C• a2•-4ssc.�}g ;.� - .,(-c46, A c. T Subdivision•Name:r y ' r, 98vTTE �� 3 r -. COUNT. Zoning: G u MAY 17 2005 i DEVELOPMENT •y� 3 SERVICES Me i "'u RI ri� 'a 2 BMW; "jV water bodges, 940%. 190k o structures _and trees, znclude;additzona� ro,ect, de crz trop data as�neec�ed ; , ,::1 Existing Land Use (describe) Proposed Land Use, Vzs-rAyt2A4j-r,-/6t=FrtC'r_ 2EQUALE AEA For Residential Uses: Number of Parcels or Units on Site (including secondary units) For Other Land Uses: Hours of Use: 1! Z' T6 4- W Maximum number of people on.site., 0� b4se) or �� eib W'. Indicate the method used to determine this number (i.e. Church membership, number of parking spaces, etc.) A00 12F-00ceso + 6=ie�&Lxr rX2. 4CT, getcemi) Height Data: Height above Ground of Tallest Object (including antennas &.'6ies) W15- ft. Highest Elevation (above sea level) of Any Object or Terrain on Site Flight Hazards: Does the project involve any characteristics which could create Electrical interference, confusing lights, glare, smoke, or other Electrical or visual hazard's to aircraft Right? 0 Yes XNo Does the project have the potential for attracting birds? 0 Yes VNo If yes to either, explain below: _- _ :..s '.. � :U. � x i,.:S T>•.�'ll3 nwM':rvr C' CI hW'ti,4S'�<Q. S}_ 7.. �.t E�t �. � w - I•tr �isttr 1:,.1;. ... _... ;. ,>.,.. v., 5 ✓aft c tr,. i 1 . s „r.::.::n:�: A;...'L'.A;".<..'.t:.;'F, tq: 9 � iv ! i � 1 �' ti.. "scv:.; ::..:.� ..c� - t d � ,1� r ti i r . w✓. . -. r,,::` `r ..- :'z .. :! ..,.,:-.Y-`.: ;• -°' r � ,�aki'?�. _mis:.- •,.P, :kt,+a..•.:_�•:...a. ;� , v a.M i.. o, al...rt,o-, J.. Date Received s- - D Type of project: AgencyName G/ iw l vii tv, 0 General Plan Amendment 0 Zoning Amend,Variance,Rezone 0 Subdivision Approval Staff Contact s, AVU4f4l 0 Use Permit , 0 Public Facility Phone Number X30)". f 71- 6 Y'1 Other t Zt44/ Agency's Project No��L Signature Date 0.57 (Applicant or Agent) �'� r t " - ✓` s f� ��5�."-E { r�,3 MEN A K:1Planning\ALUC\FORMSAPPFORM. WPD x - ,e JOSEPH A. ACQUISTAPACE, ARCHITECT 32 QUISTA DRIVE, CHICO; CA 95926 (530) 891-0916 FEBUARY 4, 2004 GREG REDEKER COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PLANNING DEPARTMENT 411 MAIN STREET CHICO, CA 95926 SUBJECT: RESTAURANT & OF.FICE COMPLEX FOR BONNIE LAMB 968 EAST AVE., AP#015-230-026 CHICO, CA 95926 REASON FOR APPROVAL B ALUK - 1. THE TOTAL SQ. FT. OF THE (CHUCKY CHEESE RESTAURANT) .10,800 SQ. FT. (OCCUPANCY @ MAX. 300 BY CHICO FIRE DEPARTMENT). QUAKERS BUILDING (EXISTING) AND NEW CONSTRUCTION IS 8,250 SQ. FT. TOTAL. LESS THEN THE EXISTING BUILDING OF (CHUCKY CHEESE) @ 10,800 SQ. FT. TOTAL. 2. THE BUILDING TO BE CONSTRUCTED IS ON THE EDGE OF A B-2 ALUK ZONE @ EAST AVENUE. JOS PH A. ACQUISTAPACE CHITECT C-16688 '511:� I�le c-1o►.�h'iscno;��Gvtatc''x1S�i�t3)�' c��O,,rcx �a>»9'cC? 3 ° lin, t3t� gN-11 3�t,L x�ra►a ossa �b �� t°