The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About08-104 ~ ~ ` • : O' O ~ ~~ :~ :~~ ~. Q'• '~ G ~~~ % ~' ~ rC ~ OUN* ' ~~ARD 4F SL~PERV~S~~RS `C~"3U'NT1C OF BUTTE, STATE OF CAt~FO~NfA RI':~O[.(:`7'I[)N Of~' "flll? [3O~ARI) Oh' ~[-NH:R\~`ISOR5 {)I'' "I'iiF: ('O(IN'I'Y {)1~' i3U'[~~i'H:, I)I~:NYiN(: ;\1'PI~:\I,~ ()1'' IZ[('ll:\ItD ~91~;YF:Itti, I.l;t'Y ('()()I~H:\Ni)'I'lll+: ItH:~IU1~:N~1~~ O1~' B[~`I"I'1{: V;\l.[.1?l' :\Nl) 1'\R:V)ISF., GR;\N"1"IN(;'[ I[1^: ANI'la;Al, O1{ NOFt"1'lI ('ON"I'INh:N'I' 1.:\NU :\NU "I'lillli[?k, 111:\I~IN(: hIN[)I'V(:S :\N[) 1)1':"I'[<.IZ111I'V:\"I'I{)N~ \I~i''I12111N(:'I'IiF. \~\i,IDI"1'~' OI~' f1IININ(. ~\NU It>,:('[.\I~is\"LION PI+:R;~I["I-l31--13~, :\;VI) KI':~('INI)I:V(; l'l.:\VNIN(~ ('()~I11il~til()N ItlE:ti()I.l -1'I()N (}H-2=i ~\ND "f[[E: Rh:VISh:[) OIZi)1?Il'l'O ('O1II'I.Y' 1~'OIt'I'lii~; Nh:\\ I~:lt;\ 11i1'VF' 1G'l l[~.fZl':f'1~. the Nuu~ t':ra '~'[inc iti I(~catt(j (iil ,nsstss(~r's I'arccl \(,. f)41-[)~f}-fl?7 alt ~fl~)i I)r~~ C'reek Iloatl, Urovillc, (~alifornia; an(i 1~'III:EZI~.r~~. 11s5c5sur'ti Yarr~l Nu. (1:.}1-U~(1-U`?7 is ulvnc~i in hart h_y Runal(l anr.l }ictty [.u~~an ~ln(1 the Nel~ f~.rtl Mine is (~f~~rat~~l by North C'c~l~tincnt l.ancj ~L -[~ii~~bcr- lnc. ("~l(~ith ~VHE~.lZ1~.,~1~, the (lucumcnt hcrcinaltcr rcferrc~l t(7 as 'Vlinin~ an(1 Kcclam~ltiun Permit ~]- 1 > (E'~l~~cs 4-(7 ol-thc ;4 i hu~~c hin(I~r of'att~lclinlcnts, titlc~3 "llttachmri7t~, 5t~sf~l~l2clx~rt- Elcl'isccl (}rtlcr ~['(~ ('(~mpl~-. '~clv I~.ra Ylinc, =1{]~)~ Urv {'rcl'k Iloacl {)ro~'illc. C'~1, Ylarcl~ l ;, ?(}US f3uttc ('aunty f'lannin~~ C'un~missii~n 1[earin~~- '):[IU ,~1.M., ?> ('aunty ('enter ])rive. Orovillc, (';~.. her~cinal'tcr rcl'errc(l t(~ as tllc ":March 1 ~, ?t)~l~ Taff EZeh(~rt llttachn~cnls") c(~nstilulcs the Nel~~ 1':ra ~~tine t~linin~~ }permit an(l its ?~ c(m(litit~cls (sr~ sai([ h~srccL ani3 Vb'I [I':Itf:.~1~, the ~u~~tiestccl V1o(icl Rcclamatiol~ Plan hercinai~ter re#~crrc(1 to as the "Ilcclamatiun Plan" [Yaks 1? 1 ~ of the March 1 ;. ?f1U~ Taff Rcport ,~ttachmcnts) c(ulstitutcs the rcclanultion plan filr the Ncly f':ra Mine ahhruti~c(j Ivilll Minin~~ an(l lZcclamati(~n Permit ~l- l_ti~; an(l 1ti'l ll:Kf":n~, Vlin~r,~~ ,an({ l:eclanulti(~n I'crnlil ~1-1 ,~ an(l ils associatc(i lZcclamation flan 1i'Cr~ af)hr(i\'ell ~[)r tl1C NCIV lira Mlne (~~NC11' l',I~LI Mille"}, a placer `~(l~ll lllllllll`~ OhCralli)Il, lltilil`~ cut an(I cuter rcclattulliui7 tcclluiyur;, h~~ the Eiuttc ('aunt}' f'lanilin~~ ('nninii5tii(~n (~n ~'[a_y~ ~tl, F ~)ti?; an(l WIIE~:IZI'::~~, Nlinin~, an(l Ilcclanlalion Permit ~I-1.7i an(I its IZcclanlatinn flan arc t~olernecl icy the hrul~isioiis of f3uttc ('(s~lnty ('u(1c (l3('C'} ('hahtcr l ~, ~~rticlc [1 an(j the ~urlacc I'a~c 1 of 2~4 titinirt~~ ~u~tl ]Z~ci,sr~~~rti~}rt 1ct ul~ I~)7i, E'uhlic fZtti~~rrrc~•ti ('~~~lc, [)i~~itii~}ri ?. ('lt,t;~t~r ~). 5~~ti~~rs ?7III ~°~ ~~~~r~ ("SM:'11Z~1~~): and 1~~'I [I~;Kf~,;1~. Urparirn~nts ~~f [)c~~clohn7crtt ~cr~iccs anal 1'trhlic 1~VorkS stafi~hcrlorrncd an ins;~cction ol~ the Ne~~~ I~:ra ~1ine on [?eccmhcr ~, i(l[17 and lound ahhro~imatel~~ i? acres of benched and ~,r,ui~cl l,u~~l (r~~u~~hl~~ 1. ~U{1 ~ -~fl(1 I~~~~t). ,rn ~°stini,rt~ti li)fl,(lUr1 c~~i~ir ~~.rr~clti cif tic,il ciis;~iacal, fire process eater Fonds anti l~rc}~~titiin~~ n~u~•l~in~rv; and 1~'I[I~:IZE~.;~1~, iiurint~ the ;~criu~i Jruic l~)~? Octr~hcr ?f1f17 the {'aunty h,r~l nr~ rcc~~rds (~.~~., annual ;production rchorts, inshcction rc}x~rts, a;~datcd cast cstintates) ant iilc for the Nc~~~ I:ra Mlnc; and 4~'1Il:IZE~:i1~, a Notice ol~ Violation, l~cr 13utle {'~urniv ('o~ie ~ectiort 1 ;-I l(~(h), ~~~as sent to the o~~~ner anti operators of the Ne~~~ k~;ra 'Vlirtc on I)ccenther ?O, ?(t(17 rcyuirin~~ that they shoe lire curt'cnt Ne~~ f:ra ~,Y1inc operation has a valid permit. rccluntation plan anti lin~utcial assurttncc (l'~s_~cs l ~ ; l ~> of the March 1 ~, ?QOS ~tal~f~ fZcport ~~tt,rchntcnts}; and V4'lll~llf~:n`;, a Ilcviscd Order ~I~o {'ompl_y {1'a~cs ]s)4 ?(11 0l thr March 1 ~, ?f!})~ 5tal'I~ 1Zcport olttacluttcnts) ~~~as sent to lire o~~~nrr and operators on 1~chruary 1 1, ?f1~]ti; anti ~~'I ll:lZE~:~~ti, on March 13. ?Ofl~ the 1'iartrtin~~ ('ontntission held a hcarin~~ ~~n the issues raised in the 1~chruary 1 1, ~t)f)~ Ke~~ised {)rdcr to {'omply~ to the o~~~ner and operators of-the New fora Mine; artd Wlll:ftl~:~~ti, the V[arch l3, ?f}Uh hearit~~~ ~4~~rs a~ij~~tn'ne~i ~rnc{ continual cl~~sc~i t~~ A;aril io, ?f1{)S at which time the I'lannin~ {'ommission continued its deliberations re~~,u-tlin~~ said Ilcvised {)rdcr to {'ornply; and VdHE~:fZi~:~'1~, on ~~pril ? 1, ?Ut)~ rite E3utte (~ount_y' I'lannin~~ ('ou~niissi~~n aduhted Resolution fly-?~ and the fZc~'iscd Order ~I~o ('outply for the Nc~~~ I~.ra Minc, Etonald anti 13ctty [.o`~trn, {)«ncrs_ and North {'ontinent 6.and ~~, ~[ imher, [nc., Operators, rcduirin`~ sc~~cral items incl~r~lin~~ a re~isu~l utinin~ herutit ~tn~l reclant~r[iun plan [I'a~cs ~)-;5 ol~ihc .tune lfl, ?Of)S 13c~ar~i 01~ Supcr~~isors' ~taf~i~ Report for the ~lppcal ol~ Resolnt€on [}~-?4}; anti ~'~~'HE~,EZI~:r'1`;. Resolution Uti-?4 was appealed by Ury ('reek Road residents Richard Meyers and [.ucy Cooke, the Residents of E3utte Valley anti Paradise. ~rnd ;forth ('ontincnt [.and and 'I'imhcr, Inc. (Pa~cs 3f~-_5(r of the Jrmc lO, 2(lfli; Board of Su}~cr-~~isors' `;tai~l~ 1Zcport for the A}~pcal ol~ iZesolutiart UR-2~l) in a timely tuanncr with approl~riatc I~ccs; and 1~'EIE~.R1~:,~1~. at a duly noticed public hcat'in~~ held ou ,l~ntc lf}, ?Oily, the f3«ar~} 01~ Supervisors considered puhiic comments and a report From the E'lannin~~ 6)i~i,ic~n (I'a~~cs l-S cil~ the June I O, ?(}O5 [3oard ol~ Supervisors' Sta[f Report lor~ the ~'lppcal of~ Resolution (1~-?d), and then closctl suid hcarin~~ and he~~an dclihc;r~rtions rirt thu a}~]~~'als oi~ lire ~'1}~rii ? 1. ?UUS I'I~rnitnt~~ ('ommissiort fZcsolution t)~-?d and the issttcs raised by said appeals; and t>~>I~E~ z ~,ti~ z=~ ~1'E I f~.Kl'.,'1~- [h~ i3oar~l al ~upcr~isars resun3c~l sail ~lelihrratians an ,tune '-~ ~{}{J~ arr~l ~rPhra~~e~l .r !~~1atian ~~I- h~tcnt rlircctin~~ the [)ci~~rrtn~cnt ~~i~ 1)c~~~l~~hn~cnt ticr~~iccti try tir,rft ,r rtsalutian ~~ith tin~lin~~s that ~'linin~~ an~1 lZeclamati~~n !'cl~mit ~]-1 ~ an~1 its associated iZcclanrrtian flan are ~alici cr~titlen~cnts ~~itlr which the. c~n-rcnt ohcratian is in coltihliancc, ~~rantin~~ flit ~ri~ii~~rl c~f• ~Jr~rih ('c~ntin~r7t L~~ncl .~nci ~l~inlhcr, [nc. an~1 ~l~nyint~ the .riih4~rls ul lZicliarci ~1e~~•rs. I.uc~ {'aol:r- an~1 the EZcai~lctlts of l;uttc ~'alle~ anti !'ara~lisr: anti 1~~'E IE~.lZI~:f~S, un .lone ?-l, ?f)U~ the E3oarcl c71 ~uhrr~~iscn-s also statccl its intent to rrcluil~r that Nartll ('ontin~nt [.an~i anti 1-imi~cr, inc.: (l) si~~n anti ii~livcr tc~ the Uci~artnlcnl ul• [)c~~clahnrcrrt ~cr.~iccs, I'I~r»uin~~ l)i~'isi~~n ~nicl tlic Oi•ficc ~~i- viinc flccl~rm~rtic~n .r stat~:nt~iit ~~i- Ce51~aR5111111tV', (?~ an iI~~CC:Cn1Cnt IIl ~~'] ltln~~ ilC~nlll~'ll'llt~ln~~ tililt it Ilnill7Clill ilSSlll-iiRCC ]17CChilnlSlTl, accchlahlc to the 1)elru~imcnt oi~ l)c~~clohmcnt ~cr~~iccs, ol-~?(~7,~1 l i(~ f~~r the ctn-rent i~c~~~ I~:ra Mint oh~ratian ~~~ill he ~r-o~~iclc~l within ti~~c (5) wor~kin~~ clays of- this final action, (~) pmvi~lc lrsymcnt af~ ~~fl,f)(1i1 to 13uttc ('aunty [)ehartn~cr~t a! [)e~~elahnunt 5crviccs f~~r- the ('aunty's InCLf1~l-l'Cl CUSts IL']lhln II~'C ~~~ ~~'U[~~lnt~ iia~'S [)i tills llnal aCtlall, illlCi {~l Sl~~n ~9i1 lll(lCltllllllCatlllll ~t~~;r:ct»cnt salisl•act~~rv try E3trttc {•uunty; anal 1'4'EiE~:fZI~:.A~, the oheratars, North ('ontincnt l.an~l anal ~[imhcr, [nc., ha~~e l~rati~i~leci, as rccluirrcl by the .lone ?~_ ?[)f)<~ f3oarcl oi~ ~uher-~~isor-s Motion ol- Intent: (l) a si~~nr~1 ~tatcmcnt of Kcsln~nsihility, (`?) an a~rcertient in ~~~ritin~ to hro~~icic an accehtahlc financial asstn-arlcc ]11CChanlSlil OI ~~{)7,%~i i.?O IoC tI1C ~C1~ !'.I-a M1nC \Vlthlll hVl' ~b'U[~~Sllt~ ~~} CI~9L'S [l~ tills Ilnt11 action, (~} a si~~nccl cun7initr»cr7t I~~r tl7c;~aymcnt t~~ the Uci~~n-tn~cnt ~~i-I)c~~clapuienl ~~rviccs of '~>f),(lU!) f~~r the [)clrrrtment's incur-rcci casts within li'tc working (~) clays of-tl~is final action, anti (~] a si~nrei incicn~niiicatic~n a~~rccrz~cnt satisl-acte~rv to the County. NO~'4', ~I~EIE:RI:I~OIZ1:, E31~: !~I RI:S{)1:1']~:I) that the 13oartl of- ~uhcryisars r»akcs the I~~Ilc~~yin iinciin~s: %~. Vlinin~~ anti lZ~;clamatic~n i'crmit 81-1 7~ Multi its ass~~ci~riccl lZcclanlatic~n Elan ar-c valr(1 Cr1l1tICI1lCilts. r11i~~nt,~r u~trl kc°rlui~rulrr»1 1'c•rirrit ~5'l-l 37 cr~u! thr I~rrlcrnurtir»r l'lu~r rrrrc~ u~~~~~-«r•c'r( ht~ t{rr l3uttr ('~~rnrtr• 1'lutliri~r~> ('«ntj~ti,~~.~~in~1 u~1 ;11rrr~ '(l, I ~)~1'? (131rttc° ('r~trfltt~ 1'ht~ririir~~ ('oj~l~rl~.ccir~ti ;'lli~tr~l~•.e fr~r' ,19r~i' ?(1, I ~~4?, l'r~~~~•s l ~~(-1O u~~ !h~° r1~1~rt'~~lr 1 ~, ?U11~5' ,5'1rrJf IZc7~r~rt .~!ltrrr•Irrrtcirrsl ~~rrrs~rrrnrt 1r~ rr ~~rrlrr! ~~rrhlir~ rnr~l C'crlrJur~lru I~;~n~ir~~~rnrrirlul Ou~rlitr~ .~tr1 ("C'I.'U.~~ ") rc".°ic~rr hrr~c~c'.r.ti~. .1 1fili~rutrr! 1'~'r~,~rtrrr I)c°r~hrrrr~inir rr~cr.~~ cfrrh• urln~~trd u1u1 a r'~'nlrcc~ uJ~!)r1c~f•»riiurliu~r /ilrrl rr~itlr thc~ I~rrtlr ('rnrrtll' R~~~~~~~-th•r r~it rM1lul~ '(, 1 ~)~ti?. ,Sui~l lV'r~trr'~• u~ Ik~1~~ruti~~crlinn ~~t-nti•rrh~rl ~~uhlir' ~rnlir~t> hr~ lirrlt~° ('urr~ttr~ !]1rr! rr illrlr,~rr1~•r] ;~'~;~utri~r~ l)~•c~~rr~~rrlir~ii lrrrrl hc~~~ir ~~r~~~~rrj-~~rl fr~r 11t~• ~~rr~jrr! rrjrrl rr~~r.~~ ~n•rrrl~rhlr fr»- rc~rrrri~ art 111c• I~rr1~r C'rJU~dl1• !'luir~ti~t~r Ik~>uf•lirrc°~rt, ~r~tcf tl1«t 11,E• ~u~r~jrr! ri•nrrlcl ~rnl lirrti~c° c1 sr~r~liJic~~utl rJJc~c~t rrjrnir thc~ ~~~rr'iru~rn~~•~t! tr~r!/t lllr° iitrr~r~x~rulin~t ~~f~ljlili,~rrllolt Il1(~u.ctrl~(•.~~ ~tnlE•~~ rrs rr~~trr`ilrn~ls 1- •# rnr~l t 1 ? (sce~ 1'~{~'c•s 1 ? 3-! ?i rrJ~ 1h~• ,'llrrrrlr 1 ~, ~O11~Y .5'lrrf/~I~rj~r~rt ,111ur~lr~lr~•jtl.~~). Pale 3 oi' 2~ f3. Mit~in~~ ,~ncl I~ccl~~n~~iti~~n I'crnlit <5l-l 3> iti << ~~,~li~l nlinin~~ l~en7~it. i~suc~l hurtiu<<nt t~~ Eiultc ('utu~t~~ ('~~~It ('l~~i~~l~r I ~, .nrticl~• IE (Surf~~ir~• ~~liriir~~~ Or~linancc) <<n~l is \O~I~ << [ Ise I'crmit issu~cl uiiclrr 13uttc ('t»uity ('oclc ('l~ahtcr ?~ {L~~nin~~ (h-~linaticc). .~Le.~~c'.~~~~n~' .~~ l'u1'c~~'1 ;Vn. (1-11-(1~ti'(1-U_'7 ~~'rl.~ ~rr~lc'r( .~1 ~ _' ((;c'~1~'i'~r1J r(tf~'i~t~~ ilt~' f~~'~'~nrl hi~1~r~~~~~1 alrrt~ 1 ~J~S'1 urlrl 11rr~~ 1 ~)~S'' i~~Iu~11 ,M1Irllrrr~ rr1r~1 ]~rr~Irrnrulrr»r I'~~1~n1r1 h'I 1_i tti~«,~~ ~~~'r'~'~t~E'r(. ~~r~11si~1~'~'<'<1 rrlrrl c1~~/u~u~'c'~l. .~1 1fs~' ~~~'i'nlrr tr~r1.~~ 11r~1 r~'r/1rr1'c'~1 u1t t`u1r~l.e =r»u'rl .~1-_' ((;rlrrrrrll rutlr.~~.~~ r.r~~ln.~~iir.~~ u~rrr !n h<~ Ir.er'rl r1r lltr uJ~rrulrr~rt. 11r 11r,t~ Ju111ruri~ fi, 1 ~~5" 1r11rr In I~rr111~ C'nra~11~~ I'1cu11rc~1- .ti~l~~h11c~1r .5~lrrrtrr, 111r rr~~jllrrrrjl~ K(~11~11~1 t`.n~[!Il .efrllNr~: ~~;~~n, l~'(~ c~U17 .5~~'[' 11n t'['U.S~n17 c!! J~ll~~ 111)10 ~tN' r1 rl}~Jlulltif[° J~i~rnlil. " (l'rr~~~ 7-1 r~/~I11~~ rllrrr~~11 li, ?Ol1~S' .S'trrfJ~R~~~~nr! .}Ilur~hnr~~ill.e) 7h~~ lfsc' of ~'.~f~lrz~~li'c's >>xrs 111~'r~'Jr~r~' 11r~! ~1 /~rir! of !h~' ,'1~'c'i~~ l:rr1 ;11lir<' r~~~~~1'rrtrulr rrlrrl tir~r1,~~ I1uf irrrlrrrlrrl rrr ~lrr ~~rr~nril rr~~~~lir•~rrir~rr, urr~l 111c'rr°Ji,r~~ !ru rrsr hrrnrr< u~rr.~~ rrr~rrrrrrl rrrrrlc'r C'h~rjurr- '-~. ('. ,`1s ~i l~~rn~it issu~~l un~lci~ ('hahtcr ~3, .'lrticl~ [I, IVtiil~ii~~ ~ir~~j Il~cla~~lati~~n ]'~r~~iit 1- l ~ ~ ]~~~s tic~t laps~cl. I~rrlfr~ ('nrurtti~ C'nrfr~,S~c~rliurr 1?-If1~5 (LrrJ~~~r~ r~f~l'r'rnr!!l .~~1~r1~~~~~.~ "(~j~urr rr~~En~u~~rrl r,f~ rJrr nlrrrrrl,~ E~rriurl, rlrr r,~~rrrr~ur .~~Tr~rll r~ururrrr°rrr~r s~ur/rrc~r rrlrrrrrr,~r njx~rrrlir~rt.~~ tir~r!lrirr /i~~r (?1 ~~r~~rr.~~ Ji-unr ~{1(' rlrrlc~ r~J~i.~~slrrrrrrr u/~!l1r~ jx~rrrlrl. .S~hnrrl~! r~~x°r~rlinrls rrul rnrrlrurrrc~r ti,~r111irr s~rrrl J~i~r (?) 4•r~rrr.~~ rl1r~ ]~r~r-irtrl .clurll ~-r~~ir'~~ trot! h~~c~nrrlr ti~r~irl, ttrtlr•ss r~~t~~rrrlr~rl hi~ 1/r~° ~~Irrrrtrirr,~ rvrrlnlrs,~~rurr f~rlnr lu r~.~~~rr~rrlrurr. „ ~llf' !1~)['1'(l1CJ1'J' !rl[ll'(' .1'1f~7N1111['(!` Cl7(~C'll('r' !J~ 11111Cj1' r'nl)1131r'llr'r'1I1P111 C7~ l1r111117~~ r~~~r°rulrrut.~~ urlr! rrrr~llrrrllt' nlt~nilt,, rxirrirr~ rrrtiti'itic~.~~ u1 rlr~~ !ti~r°u~ Ft-rr ,~Irr1r~ hr~it~~°r~i1 ! r)~S" ~rurl tlrr ~~r-r~s~rlrt rir 1hr~ Jr~r-nr r~/~ rr/jirlrri~il.5~, rr11c.~~lrrlrr~rr.~~, ~~11c~tr,~=l-rrj~11,5~ ~rir~l rrti~uir•c~.~~ (srr° .•Ittrrr~hnrrrrr.~~ l/, l~ rrru! 13I~ llrrrrlr,~Ir l~f313 r~J~ll1r' IVurtlr C'urrtrrarrr~ Lrrrrrl trot! liruhr~r- rllrrrrlr l_i. 'O(1~1' l'I~rrrrrirt~ C'urrrrrrr.~~.5~ir~rr ;1~1ur11rrrrrl~.~~), rr.~~ 111r~.~~c~ rrrlri~rlirs crrr rlrjirrc°cl 1>>• ,~'a1.llt.~1 .5~rrlirur '7; ~ "'.S'1ri~/~rrc° nrrlrilr~ r~~~cr~rlirrlr.~~ ~ nrc~~rlr.~~ rrll, ~~1~ ujr~~ ~urr1 r~J; 111° ~~rr~rt°.~~s rrri~ul~~c~cl rrr !!r c' rrrrrrrrr~ uf~ rrrilrcrrrl.~ r~r1 I11111('(I I~rrrrl.~ ht' rrnrr~ti~ir1~ nti~c~r~luu-rlrrr rrlrrl nrrrtirr,~~ rtrl-rc•~h~ f -r~nr ~11r rrurlc~rrrl r(r~u~.ti~rLti•, r~~~rr1-~~r1 rlrirrrrr., r~J~ rrlirrc°rrrls rurlrrrrr111~ r_~~~u.~~rrl, nrirrirr,~ J~~• nc~~ urr,~c'r nrc~t/rnrl. rh-~~rhi~t~ rrlrrl ylr~rrr-l~irr„ nr .~~rn.Jirc~~~ irvr-l. rrtr~rrlr-rr~ rn rr~r rrurlr~r~rrnrrrrl nrrrrr~. ,S'rrrJrrr~~~ rrrflrilr,~~ r~1~r'rrr!lrjlrs .clrrrll rrrr~llrrl~~, hrr! rrrc~ rrr~l (rrrritr~rl try: (rr% Irr~~l~rc~r rlLc~ill~r~ir)11 nr rrlnrlrrr~r nr• Ir~rc~11ir1~. (1~) Ihr~~~r-urlrrr~~rr~rt rrrr~l rlrcj~u.~~rrl r~J~nrirrirr~~ lt~rrelr. (r~) I'r-vs~~r~r~lrrr,~ rrlrrl c.t7~lr~r-rrlr~r~~ rrr~ri+~i~rr°.5~. „ 111 uc~rr~rrlrrrlrr ~t~itlr Ilrr.ti~ rlr/irrrlinrr, urrrl ht~ ihr rrJJr~lui•i1s, rr!!r°.~~lrrriurr~~~, ~~11r~tr~~>1~rrC7l1.~~ urrrl irtti~nrc~c-.~~ slrf~rrl!!lrrl hr• 11tr n~x'I'rrtnl~s, nrlrtirt,~ nj~rl'rrlir~rt.e ra! !hc- iVr°tt~ l:rrr rllrrr~~ Na~;c 4 of 2~4 tr~c'1'<' lrfrrc~h~ ~v~ntntr~t~~~~rl ~r~i~l ~11iur11~ rrf~rl 1<<°rlunt~~tru~t 1'rrr~rtt ~~'I-1_i ~ hrr.~~ rrr~f Irr~~s~'rl. 1). ~Chc ~lcn~ E~:ra 11Tinc hay ncitl~er h~~•n in idle status nc>r ahanclonecl clurin~~ the ~~~rio~i hct~~~~~~n l~)~? anal the E~r4s4nt. as th~itic tcriliti art ~lcffil4~l by ~Y1;1fZi1. 5~~1L~1K.~1 .~'E'r!ln11 .~?'%. 1 r~t'fdJ7r'~' "irllr' ~. rl~~ Ji~lln~,.c.~ "'I~llr' ntrrr~~.~~ to rtrrrrul Jrr~- rr ~~rrrur( uJ~rr t~r~rr r,r nrurr ~~~rrrJrrr~r f~tr~tf~t r~~x~rr~lru~1~~ hi~ fat~~r~~ l1l~ria 4(1 ~~rrrc~li! uJ~llir r~~x~r~rrrulr ~.~~ ~~rrt•iulr.~~ nrrr.~inririrr tr~tirucrl j~li~tc~r~rl ~~rrxlrrrlir,il, rrr!{~ nc~° i~llrirl !r~ rc°s~rrirrc° 111n.~~c' ~~rri•Jirrr ifli~li~l~r (1~J('1"(iI!(J11.C (11 fl ~1711iI"C (j[lf('. ~~ "lY1c° r~~~~~rrrlnr.~~ lurti~r .errhnai~l~~~f ~~~~rrl~~s~r~~ rrf~ uit~n~rrllti~ r~tl~urll~~ n1i~~i~~t~ rrr~lr~~rlir.~~ hc~l4ti~rc~ir 195'_' rrrrcl 111r ~~rr.5~c~ir1 i~r llrr /~~rnr a/~rrJ/r~lui~il.~~, r~1tc~.~~lrr~rvji.i~, hhulr~~r~r~~h.ti~ u~t~l i~t~~nic~c~.r u1 tllc° lVc~7i• f:'ru ;1~lr~rc~ u.~~ 111ncc~ urlri~rlrc~.,~ urc° ~lrJi~rr~l hi~ .5'r11.111.~1 .5'~°rlru~t '7>> (.rr~~ .~tl~u~~la»i~~r11s Il, 1' ~ul~f KIi 111rntr~rll f~1313 r,J~11tc~ r~4~r11r (~njllr~rc~it! Lrrilrl ~r~t~l 2'inih~~r ;~Icrrc~{t Ii, ?l1Uh' l'lcail~trr~~~ (~r~nrnti.e.ein~t .~111urlttttc°ii1.~~). ft"~trlr i~rrrJirrl rrirlirrrrl~~I~r~~(r![~llv~1 ~~r~rrtrlilr~°.~~ Jrrn~~~ ~tr~! h~°~~tr /~f-r,rltrrc~~l hr 1h~~ u~~~~~-r~lr~rs Jr»- llrr~rrir,~~ ~rr~lii~rlrrs ut ~hr r~'~'titi~ l;ru ;1/i~rr hrnrrE°r1 I9~5'' rrir~l 'l1Ufi, 111r uJr~f-t'ittc'~rli~~itrrl rt~Jitlrrti'i1c, rt11t~.~~1r~t1u17s. ~~11ulr~~~'u~~l7,e ~t~rrl i~rti'uir'r~.~~ Flu ~»'ui~rrl~~ ~~ti~rcl~~arr~~ 111t~1 1hc~ .~Vc~tit~ I;r~r ~'lli~rr Iru.S~ irnr hr<~ir irllr rr.~~ rlc~Ji~rrrl h~~ .5'r11.11~.-1 .Sc~rlinjl i'? 7. 1. .5'in~ilrrrlti~. ~Itr rVrii~ l:~f-rr ;l~li~lr Itrr.e ~tr~i~r~r J~rr~t rrhrr~r~fn~trrl rr.~~ 1hu~ 1c~ri~t i.~~ rlrJiitrrl hl~ .5,11.~i1t.~~ ,S'c~rtr~ril ~'?7l1(hl(FJ: "U~tlr.~~.~~ r~~i~rru~ r~/~rrir rfuE~rint nr~rrrrr,~c°nrr~rl ~~Irrir 1.~~ j~rtlrlrir~ hrJr~t~r thr ic~~rrl ~r~rrirrti~, ~»• uir crhl3rrrl i.~~ ~x~~trlrit,~r hr~urr ~lu~ hurl ~r~~~~~jir~~'~~ ~~~ti~c~j-~ri~~~~ f~nrh~, u .rrrrJirr~~ nlilliit~~ r~f~r~-rrli~~i1 >>~hirlr rc°nirriil.~~ r~llr fr,r n~~rr r)Ji(' 1•('rrl- rrflc°r hrc~r»>ti~~~ r~fl~~ rrs CIE-fi~r~~~l rr~ .5'c~c~~ir~at ?7_'7.111•irllntrr r~ht~riirrta~ <<ir ~r~~~~rvti~~rl uf~ uir rim°rinr ~u~r~rrr~~°ntrtrl ~~lu~r .~~~urll hr rr~rtsrrh~r~~<< rrhrulrln~r~~rl rnr~l rh~~ uj~rrrrtur .~~Otrr(1 r~r~nrntc~jrr~~° rntrf (~r~~rd~~(c°tc~ rc~i~lunr~rlrr~tl i~r rr~~r~urrfrr~irr ti~~rlli ~hc~ rr~~hrr~ti~c°rl j-rc~Irrntrrtr~»t ~~lrr~1. " :Is niririit~ rrr~Ii~~iti~•.c u1 Ilrr ,V~-ti~~ Eru rlliuc• li~rrc~ lur~r crrr~ru~rllti~ r»t,~r~iit~, it lru.~~ ~rr~r 1~~°cil rrr ~rir r~llc ,5~lrrrrrs~ tiur rrh~ul~lo~r~~rl. I'hc Kcclamation Elan ap~rovct~ ~~~itl~ 'vtinin~ and EZccl~~m,ttion Ncrn~it ~1-135 is a ~~alicl reclamation Elan ap}~ro~~ecl by E3ullc ('aunty anti the Eirecleccssor oi~the State Officcc~f~Minc flcclamatian. 771c~ j~c~rurcl .ehui~•,~~ tlrrrl rhr llrrlrrru~rrir~ir l'Icr~r it7r.e ru~t.ci~/c~rc~~l ~r~r~l crj~~~rrrti~c°~l i~~r1{~ 111iitirt,~ rrttrl l~i~r~lrrmrrliu~r I'~~rnril <ti'1-1 ~? In~ ~{~r l'l~r~r~1i~1~ ('vfu~fti.5~.5~int1_ (~t1 ;'l~lrrti~ 'fJ, l J~5'?, ('~~nr»rrs,~~fvrrcr ~tlu.r niu~l~° rr t~lnlioil 1Iur1 ~t~~r.~~ .ec~ru~t~lc~~l h~~ ('~~nrnrissir~ir~°~~ .S'rhr~rr(rr ln: '~,-1, .-1~1r~~~t rr~r~l rrrlrJi~ rho- ~19ili~rrlrrl l'4'~;~rrliti~r 1)E°i ~ltrr-rrlir~r~, frirrliiw lhur r•r~ir~lili~,~r.c Irrrti~c~ h~~c~r rfrrnr~~nrrrti'rl lldlr) Ilrt~ rr~~~~rui~~rl of !Iris j~t~r~jrrl u~llrrla nrrli~~rrlr lhc~ .~~r~~irfrr~rr~11 rit~~iruir»tc•irtrrl r/Jc~r1s rr1~~~rliJrrrl rit lltr iirili~rl s1tr~17~ ~urr.ti~xcrirl rr~ rlrc~ C'rrliJr~r~tiu f:iri~irn~lnrr~~l~r1 (hr~rli~7•:~lrl; rr~rrl Page 5 of 24 f~. I~~rfu~ l~tu! l~t~° ~~1'njCC~l ilt~'~'ls l~t~~ (7'11t~l~lr! of lilrll~° ~'nlulll~ ~ r1~lc { ~huf~l~~r 1.~ ~rrrr(C ~rxl~ ~ .ti~rrlrnn ~-~--~%, crud ('. .~IJ~~~~•r~7•r' rr nr~lrr~r~~ hrrnril rrirrl ~-r~rlrrif~u~r~~ir ~~Irr~r r»r .~11' -~1-~1~5'-_'%, ~~rrl>~~°r! rr, rh~~ /i~Ilnrriit~r c~nia~lrlinir.~~... " (]~1l11~~ (~nrr~rrt• l'luir~ti~i<~ ('unrnll.eclu~t :1lrlttrl~~.e fr~r r11u~~ 'l). I ~J~S''. I'u,~~~ l(ri r~J11tt~ ;llrrf~~'h 1_i, 'l)ll~l' ~'1uJJ~ll~~~ur~l.lrlur~hi~rrii~~~l I'/tt' r(~r~n~~r1.~~llnlt~s tlt~1! 111c• 11tc'~r I)!~'~~rlnl' r,J~I'trhli~~ l[~nf'ks fni- Rtrlle~ ('nlutll~. (~/rrt~ ( ~~r.~~l~rhr~~r1~, .e1~rr~°rl rhrrl Ir~~ rri~i~~titi~rr! rrirrl ]irrrl "err, ~»~r,hlrnr " titi~rllr ~Irr ll~~i~(untrrlrr»t f'Irrir, u~u! tltrrl lrr tti~urrlrl .~~rtirl it !u 11rr .ti'lulr (irulr~~r.~~t. Junrrs !:. l)~ri'i.~~ (Jrrllr 1 ?, 1<l~~l I~r1~~~-rlr~urr~nrr~rrrr! ;llr~~iurrr~t~lrrnt j~~ntat ('lu~~ ('r r.~~Ilrh~~~~r7. 1r~ Ifrrli~c~ liluir, f'u~c~ '_' ~~J~thr ;11urrlr l 3, _'f)ll<5 .5'lujJ~Rc~x~rt .~llfrrrlr~rrr~lLc1. 1hr Krt~Iunrutrr,~r 1'Icr~r rs~ r~~ji~r~-~rr~~rl rfr rr ,11rrf-~~h '.~, 1{J~ti'~ Ir11~~r Ji-r~nt !)rti~Lsrr~ir r,f ,~11r~~r.~~ ~rlr~l (i~~r~Ir,~~~ Krrlrrntrrtrr,~r .Sj~~°r~irrlr.~~lil:~r,~rirc~rl~r~1~ (rculu,~i.~~t h~r~r ('r~lr~ try ,5'lrj~]ir~t ,5'lrrrlrr, ~~rr~f~r~liir~r ~~i~irlr•irr~r purr 11r~~ I)ii~r,~~insr r~/~;~llrirr.~~ rr~ul (;rulr~~~~ 11~rr1 rrti~rr>>~r~I thr ~~lrr~~ Lcr~~ l'rr~r I _'.i u/~ rlrr ,~1lrr~rlr l ;, ?U~l<5 .ti'!u/J~ Ilc~~wr~ .-lltrrc~lrnlc~irl.,~}. ~Chc° rc~~~nrtl rr~irtcritr.~~ ~ir~ uJ~jr'rli~,il~c 1u rhr IZc~rlu~~iulrn~l 1'Irria f -rrlu u~t t~ .~~lul~• u,~c~itca'. ~I~hc rcc~~r~j 5ho~~~s that the uE~~~ruvccl fZcclamati~~n flan auth~~riics a t~~tal nr.~.~imum ~~isturhanc~ ~~f~ u~~ t~~ ?if},llf}U cubic yar~js jeer ~~car. .~1,~~ .S~huu~tr rir rh~~ Ilcrlunlrrtrr~jr I'Iu1i Jilli~~I r,irt h~~ :~11~-, l.r~;~rr~i, 11~~~ri I f ~rllrnt~s 1Ir~~ rrh~~lirrr~r! 1u .~~c'Ic'c'1 1{tr rnuurnit u/~ if~rrtc°riul 1r, h~~ ~Ir.~~rrrrh~~rl h~~ rn! nj~ri~rrlru~t uc~c~nr~lri~~ ~r~ /lti~c° ru~t~~r.c: • U~r~lc~r ?, U(JlJ lnir.~~ c~u. l~~ls%~~f-. • S,l1Ul) SU,I)Uf) 1vjr.~~ ~~rr. i~rl.c'i~r. • 50,01)(1 ?5(1,Ol)(1 lr~I1s rtr. ti'~ls~"ti~~~ 'S(1,0(Jf1 ~,(1Ol1,(1(1(1lr~ji.~~ rrr t~rls;l~r • Os~r~r I,f)1J(1.11001n~1.e ~~1r_ ~~r1s/i~r. 511,00(1 '5(1,!)(1(1 1r»r.e rir. t~c(.e./~•r. ii•us the°rlu°~l 1>>• ihc~ rr~~j~lrc~trjll, .~~i~itiJi'iir,~ !hu! lh~~ linri! uJ rritttuul rlisltrrhrtitc~E' ut lltc° ~ti`~•titi~ L'~'u ~~Irttc• iit r~~~rrf-~(.5~ !n t-~~~~I~rntulrnii u~rr.~~ rr~~ 1u _'Sf1,OlJf1 lurrs~ r~r ~~lrhrr i~ur~l.~~ ~~c~r ti~~°~rr. (/'u,~~~~ IS a/~llrt~ r'll~rf~r~lr 1 3, 'l)11~5' .ti'~rrJJ~Ilr~~r~rt .•lttur•Irnrrri~.cl lhi~ K~~~'luntulru~r 1'I~1ir l1t~,t-i,/vr~• uulltr~J~i~(°.e lh~~ ~'~'~•titi~ f.ru 1llrir~~ ~~~~crulr~t- 1r~ ~(i.~~lirt~h ir~~ !r~ ' SO.f10(1 lu~~.e ur rrrhir~ i~rrr~L~~ ~~~°~~ l~ccrr (rr~r ui~c~rrr~c° uJ~~r~~~»-u.ri»rrrlr~h~ ~5'Ol1 1r»r.~~ ~~r rrrhrr~ ti~rrr~l.5~ ~~rf- titi~r~rk rlrrti~.Jui _; l? tti~urhrji~ rlu~~.e ~~rt- i~rrr~~, hrr.~~rrf r~ii .ti~r.~~ tir~urkrji~~ ~lut'.~~ ~~~~i' titi•c°~~f). 'lu itr.~'ir~~~' t{tut 1h~' Il~1ti! a/~_'S0,(10l) 1~~1~.~~ ui' ~'trlur• ~'u~'rl.e ~~~~~' 1'c~ui' r.ti~ j1u1 ~~.~~r~~c'rl~'rI, ~hc~ Ih~l~crrl~jlc'171 r~/~!)c'~~rluJrrllr~rl .5'c°r~•rc~c~.c shall rr»~rlrrc~l u~r ullirrrul ria.~~~~c°r1ru11 j~c~r f~trll~• (~ntf~rtl' (~~~tlc' ~ti'c'c•]ir~j1 ] i-II'(u1 r~~tcl .S'c't'irn11 X77-lfl>) nJ~ !h~' l'rrf>Iic~ Na~;c h of 24 IZ~~,~~ritu~r~~s ('uJ~° rr~trl r~~°rrJi~ rh~~ ~r~ifiirrrl rrf~rnrurl r~/ rlr.~~~rri~h~r~rr~~ h~~ nr~~rur.~~ rrJ rr t~ulti»ic~lr•ir' u.~~~~~~~c~~nlr~rl (<<~'c'r1 r~J~rli.~~lu~~f~rritr~~~ nttrlrf~~lt~'~1 hr~ i1.~~ rl~'~~llr1. (~ the rccur{l ~lluns th~rt '~linin~~ ~rncl fZr~•lanration I'cr-iTrit ~]-l;~ authc~rirr.5 tlr~ ri~inir~~~ c~l•tl~~ 1 ti-~rcr~ N~~~ I~:r,r '~~[in~ hrriF~~rty (!~E'i~~ l1-~1-Off}-fl?7). lllr :'V~~1ir~~ ~,J 1 k~lrri~irirrrltuir Jr~r llrr :b~rri I~:rrr ;1lrirr ~~rr,jrr~1, Jrlrr! ii~i11~ ~liE~ I~rrt~r ('r~rr~r1~~ Kr~~nr~lc'r n!t r11~rr• ~+i, ]rl<S'? rrirr(r~~ nc~~ (~rrliJr~~~itirr I~.'~tr~rrr»1ir1c°~r1~rl (hr~rlrtti~ .~lc~l, .~~1(tlE°.~~ !h~- /'~~njr~r! 1)r°.~~~~riJ>Iinlt rl.r: ~~l'luc~~-r nti~te~ It~il{t r~tt! rut~l t~rn~t•~~ rr.e r~°rlrrnrrrlrr~ti• 1 ~Y rr~~r~~s. " (;'~'r~tr[~[~ n/' 1)r1~°r1lrf~rrrrtulr, 1'rr~r 17_~ c~J~ 1hr ?~1urr~11 I_~. ~U11~5' ,S~!(! jjRchui•t .~111rrr~lanr~~irr~~~1 l~-nl• "I'rnj~~r! /h~,~~rr1~~lru~r, '• llar l ~~5'? 1'Irrrt~ri~r~r (•niuturs~ci~,~! ,ti~rmrnrrrrr• .S~hc~r1 .elrr<<-.,~. "l~`.~~c' 1'~~rr~rit Jr~~• ~~l~rc~~~r tuiir~~ rtii11~ cart ~r~1~1 ~~nt~c'r u.~~ r~~c~hr~rt~rlrr~il, l~5' rrc~r~~s. " (f'Irrir~~r~i~~ ('n~rrntr.esr~~~t ,ti'rn~rntur~' .5'!tc'~~1. I'rr~~~ _i uJ~llt~° Alurc~lt 1 ?. '(IU~S ,~'lrlff~l2<'~~r~1't .111rrr•hnt<'i11.5'l "Ilrr.lirlti~ t. 11~ti'1 1~~~lrr f-n~rt f:~~rrl 1).Vc°lsr~fr (13ir~t~~ (•utrstlt~ l:~rti~iru~tj~~r~urrl IZrt~irrr~ 1)rrrrl~~1-l 1r~ ;i'r~tr l:•r-u ,'llitrr r~rr~~~ri~ Iluirulrl l.r~~trjr ~~nr1c°.~~, "ltl:: 11i~ri~1,~~ u~rrl R~~c~Iutuulin~l 1'~~ri~ri( Jr~r (;nhl ~'lli~rr, c~i~lrlrril uc~rc° .erlr. .1I' -ll-(1~5'-'7 l:•!l~) l.n,~~ '~~'l-fly-"-lhl. '• ~l'~r~~- '7 r~~~lltt• Rlrrrrlr 1 ~, 'lJ(1A' .57rrJ/~ll~~~~u~•! .~lrrrrr~llirlc~~r1.~~J Ilr°nr ~S' of thr R~~r~Irrn~r~~rr~rr l'hr~r fur :~lrflr~l•~ rr~rrl R~~c•Irrnirrtr~~lr 1'rrnrr~ <ti'l-l ~ ? .~~lrrtr.~~ I~ti ~rrrc~.~~ ~rs• rlrc~ "c°.~tr~rr ~,J~1hr jfll~rrrl Irnr~l (1u hr) ijtrv~lr~c~~l hl~ lhi~~ u~~rrutrnrt... " IR~~rl~rnttrliuit I'luj1. /'~r~~• I=~ rr/~rl1c~ ,~lhrrc~lr I ~, _'!J(1~ti a5`rr~JJ~Il~~E~nrt :~ltt~u~h~~~c~irt.~~). l'11~~ .~l~~~x~~rrlr.~- 1.' f:'irr~rru~~~ji~~~llrr! l~1Jr~ri~irrlrr~ir /•'urnl .5~1rrt[~.~~ l~ti' rrr•rr~~~ Jr~r th~~ ~»•ujrc~r ~Ic'.~~rri~~lrr~it;'.ti~ltr~.~~r_c•. (l'rr~c~ rJ ~~J~tl1r ,1lrrrr~lt 1-i, ~U(h5 .5•trrJ/~Il<•~~r~j-! .~It~rrr~ltntr•rit.~~l I~r,~crr~lrrt~ lllr .~~i~c~ of tlrr ~~rnjrrl• thc~ r1l~rrc~lr ~, 19<S' I3tr1~c~ ('ntrilll~ 1'hriratiu•~ ( 1J1R111l.~'.5'!(Jll ;'~1*111!!/('.1' .Sl(It('. "r~lr. ,~'trc~c°tc~r crl.~~u c~.r~~lrri~rrrl Ixnt~ !hr l~~'7_~ rlliiri~~~ I,rrtt~.~~ rc~I~rlr~l tr, l11i.~~ ~~rujrc~l, ~ir~lr~i~~ tltrrt t{tr f-rlulru~r~~hi~~ /ltrrr rt~ru~ 1!~ 1 ur•rr .~~itc~~~, ur Ir~.ti~s, ~rrul thus thi.~~ Wile' ~thc~ rVc'u' I•;rcr ,~llilrc~J r.~~ ntr~rr thcr~r I~~' crrj•c~s. •' (1'rr,~r~' ]l1~) nj~ rhr.~llrrt-~~h 1.3. 'OlJ~S,~'tu%fKc°~r~~i•1:1tt~lr~hnr~~t~1.c.) Item '~lumhcr 1(i of the Ilcclamation 1']ai~ e~hressly i~lrntifics the maximum volume oi~~rll nritcria[s t{~ be cxcavatal. r~1r. 1.~~,~r~rit rrs~~rl rr rE~urlilt~ rri~rrrlrrhlr ,5•r~r~r fur•nr ~",5•rr,~r~.~~trrl :~l~lurh~l Krc•lrrnrrrtir»1 1'lu~! •'1 u~hc~ir rrc~rrtr~~~r 11rc~ ,Nrrr~ l-;j-u ~~Irrrc° Kr~rlu~riutru~! !'l~r~r. . fj~~~riulr.r ;I r~J~ nc~~ ('~rlr/urflru I)r7~L5~iun nJ~ ~lli~t~'.e ~r~rcl (;eulr~~rr~ 5~~~~rirrl I~trll~•Irrt it J~rr~r~r~l~~~l ~~r.~~lrrrr7ru~ls fr~r /il(rjr~~~ nrrt 1h~~ "~~rr~~~~~~~.~~1~°rl 191rxh°( IZ~~~~(rrnr~rlinjr 1'lu~r •~ Jr~rnt- T~I1c i1r.elrrrrliu~ts Jr~r Il~~nr l ~ .e~~~~rtf i~ 1{lrrr 1h~~ n~~c'rrrtur i~rc~hrrlr "rrlr` urn', t~ri~lrrcrL~~, nr~c°t-hrrrrlr~rr cr~rrl 1t~rr.clr rr.~~ u~rr lurrrl r~trrrjilil7~ •' 7-Irc~ rrui~~r r~hrrkc~rl hr~ ,'~Ir. l.rt•~urr, !'a~;c 7 cat' 2~1 ~(1.1J11U '?11,U11U !~rltc r~r r~rrhrr ~~rrr~l.e hi~r- r~~~rrr, rltrt.e rr~1~r~~~r~~atr.~~ 1h~~ lrrl~rl u~rrarrrrl rrrflr~rrrat uf~nrrrlr•r'irrl !r~ hc' rl~~~lrar'h~'r( rr~ lh~~ 'V~~ti~ 1•;rrr ;llrrrr. ~I~h~ 1Z~ckanustion f'l~tn and the rrcc~r~k clc~crihc a suhst.rntial mininti~ okieration. IYi~~ IZ<~r~l~rnru~rr~rt I'Irrra ~ti~1rr1~:~~ 11ru1: 111 nrrrrrrt~ u~rll rx~~~irr~ nat rrll l~1 ur~r~~s r~J~1hr I>>•n1~~-f~ti•: 1') aalirarrrrl.~~ to hr niiu~~rl rrt~~lrrrl~° ~~~~h1, ~ilti~r~-, I~Irrlirrarnr rr~rrl I~rrllrr~lirrnr (_~l 1hc~ ~~.~~rinurl~°~1 ]rJa~ r~/ rh~~ nlx~rrrlinat i.~~ iO-Ill(1 r~•rrr'.~~,~ (-1) 1h~- r~1~~-rirlir~rt trill Ix' rura~rrnrnrr~e; rrrtrl (?1 1h~~ rairr.~inrirrrr c1r1~1{a r~J~~~~r•rri~rrlir,n Still hr Illl1 jr~~1_ . f!( rrJ~lhr ul~rrrrriurarrl rlrlrril.t~ Iri 1hr Krc~l~rrarrrriurl 1'Irrra rrrr r•urr.~~r.~7t'rr! titi~rllr ura u1~rr~rrliurl ~~~rrh.~~ltrrl~rrrlli• ,~rrc°rrlra- rharra nrrr linrilrr( ~~~ '~l titbit ti~urrl.~~ hc'r rlrn~ ~~/~ 1u1rr1 rtLti~lru~hurlr~~ (sr~• 1'rr~~' 1 ? r~J~llar ;11ura~lr 1 ?, 'l1(1~1 .5'luJj~K~'j~nr7 .-111ut~lrntc'rtLrl. Ill ;111'. LU~ilil .1' .l(rrarrrrr:r~ ~, 1~~ti'~ 1rl'rll('ll i'('.5'17~JlI,S'(' lU .111'. ,~I1't'('/('!' .1' ;~~lT1'C1N1~['!' ~1. 1 aJ~51 Irlrrr- (irr ri~ltir•la :1h~. ,~'trc~rlrr ~r.~~lrrcl J~,r rl~rrijirrrriuat rc ~~rrrliu~ Ihr nlrrrrra hlcrrtl, ;11r. l,r~~>uir .~~tulc~cl: "!f'r rr~~~rrlrl.ti~lrrr~! hi~ hrrrlrlrri,~ rr hr~~c~i~.~~rtllrn~ hr~rrrl, rc°- ~~irc~arhrrirl~ rhr r~~utrr~...1~;clrrrluuc~ral ti~~ill irlc~lir~lr a rrrhhc~r•-1irc~rl Ir~rrrlc~r, rlr,-rr, ~~~rrrrrrfnr. I1trll1lzs, c~r» rti~c't•r» ~s, ~~r~rrc~l ri•rr.~~lairtt~ hlrrrl~ crrr~l.elrria~c° lu~.~~c~s. " (1'~r~>~~ (~~l ref ~Ih~' ;1lrrrr•h I ~, 'OU~Y .5'ruJ~~Kc°Ix~r1 .-klluc~ltllt~°rtLr./ l r.r~~ n~~u lr~url~~r-. ~In~~~r, I)tlntl).e. r~r~rri~~~i~r~r,~~, ~rrrr~c°( u~rrs~lurr,~~ hlarrar ~rnrl slirrrc~ hrzr~'.e i.~~ rr~rr.~~islrrrl >>~i11r lh~~ ?II,UUU ~~(1,fXlU tntas~ nr rrrhir~ t~urrls hE'r i~r~rr u1~c'rrrlturl rrrrllaurr~~°rl hti~ rlrr Il~~~~lrrnurrit,rr I'Irrra. .l. [~hc cur~rcnt l~'c~~ l:ra Mine c~k~crati~~n is ~r ~~l~rc~r n~inis~~~ c~k~crutic~n c~1~ nc~t n~c~r'c than l ~ ~tcres «~ith concurrent cut anck cover as a kart of its rccl,rnurtion k~roccss. 77u~ r•rrrrrnl ,N~~+~~ 1,'rrr ;llirrc r~1~~~r~rlir,rr i.e rx~i~arr~rirr,~ u~ilhi~r rh~° Iir~ril.~~ uJ~. (l'.r~' f1-ll- f1~5'~1-lJ'7, a hur-t•~~l of rr1~l~rn_rirurrlc~l~~ l~S' rrr•rc~.~~ irr .ci~r. I)rrrirl~ hi.~~ 1c~.~~lrrarurrti~ hc~Jr~r~r 1h~~ f3rr11c~ (~nrrarl~~ l'lararrairt~~ ('n»tnti.~~.ti~rr»t r~rr a~Irrrrlt 1.~, 'llU~1', I)r~rr OL~~rn, Il.('.I:'., u/ thr ~•ra~ri~rc~c°rir1~~ /rrnr r,/~ llnl~lrc~~rc° ct~ hall ~rrac( urrc~ nJ~ thc° r~1~c~rart~~r,~~' rra~~irarc~r~.t~, ~I~~sr'rih~~rl tla~° ~~arr urtrl ~~nti~~~r' nIx•r~rtir~rt u.c Ji~llurt•.~~: "rti'uu~, ,~rrllirr,~ hrrr~k ~r~ thr sinarrltrrrrc~urr.e rrrlrrraruriurt rrrr~! r~rr1 rrrr~! c~ur~rr n1x'1'rtli~)17, rrrr rrrul rr>i't'r ~ra.~'! rnr~rul.~' lhul tit'r°'rr ~~uirr~~ 1u c~.~r'uti'rrl~~ rrrar( st~~~'rc~ ~uira~ tea Irrr~ .~•tar/J~lurrlc ira. It rluc~srr'I n1~~rrr1 lhrrl ir',~~ ar hrr~c~ ~~.~~tc~rr.~~iti~c vlx~n hit lil~c~...th~°.~lrurrvrrrl~r ruiatr irr :1ri_nrru titi~hc~r-r rhr7~ rrrGr...arrlrl lrtrilrl a 11u,~r hit rn tlar rnrrrul rrrtrl harllrrr~~ ~.ti~ic~/ c~nlhrr~ ~rir1....1 racl the°aa rhe~ Irnlr i.~~ IrJi hrr~rrr.~~r the°i• rli-t' c~.r1~~~r1rn,~ rrll nfllaul r~JJ~1hr.~~i1r~. i~i'Itc°rru.ti~ he°rc° tt~r 'r~~ larkirr~~ thc~ ntarlrriul, hrnc•r.~~.eirr,~ i1 rratrl Jh he°rrrrat nf~th~° nrrrtrri~rl ~u~'s h~rrk iron thc~ hr~lc° irr thc~ ~>r~~rrrr~l. ,S'u ~r.~~ }~uir ~li~~, ~~uir 'rr rrr~ti~ hlurirt~ ~h~r1 nrrrlrr~irrl h~rrl~ irtlu 1hr hrrti~ir~tr.~~ hit Iorultnrt. " (1'~r~~~ ~>' r,J~111r Jau1c~ 1(1, ?(1(1<S Ruarrcl a/~,5'arl7c~a~ti~i.vur.~~' .S'IarjJ~ IZ~ ~x~r1) r11r-. OL~~rr~ rr1.5~r~ hr-r~ti~i~lc'rl I'usi~rrl'a~irr! .~~li~lr.e rhrr~irr~ 11i.e ;11rn~r~lt l.} t~~.ti~linrr~ral~ illarstrrrlirl~ hr~r,• ~hc~ c~ir1-arra~l-rui~rr hr~~rrss u~nrrlr( nc~rrrr crl Clad rrrrrrarl Nc~rr. fu-u Na;~c 8 ut' 2~ ;1Tr~1c'. IYr~- .~lirl~'.~~ slrntii'c'rl />r~lt~,~~n~t.~~ ~'~~~»'~°.~~~°rtlift~~ Ih~~ ~~_r~vrrrrllurt ~~ir~c u~tJ ~7~h.~~~~~jtrr~tl r~•rlunrrrlin~l rrrr~r~~ j~rr~rrc~rlrjt~ nt~~~r lrnr~° i~r a ~tr~rllr !r~ ~~r~rrlll j~rrllr u~rrx~~.~~ rlrr ~'~~~~°<<~ l;i~rr .~~ri~°_ ('ir~~r~°~r11~~, rrr~l~rnurlrr~ii Irrrs !ru! r~r~nlntrirr~E~rl hrr~rrir.~~r 1711 i1ri1~ r~/~1'r! ! Iru.~~ ~1u1 ~'~'! f~~~r'r1 ~'u~tl/~lrlrrl r11 1lti.~~ lrntr. f.ti'r'r~ ,5'ilr~ f'lulr~' r~u~lx~lc'rl r~r flnl~frr~'r <<~ f,~rr(1 ~s~ "l~~rizrritrrrrl .ls.~~iri~rltrrE° 1~:~7rnaurr I~~~~x,rl /nr ;V~-tii~ I:ru ;11r11~~ .. 111rrc~lttu~~~tt .~~ r~/~ lhr .~1Irr1'~~17 1_~, ~(Jll~~' ~1'nrlh ('nrtlrtr~•~r1 l.rrr~<< ur~cl 7'rr~rf~~~r ~11I1I('~lll!('11LS_1 7Y,r ~~rr! urr~l c~ni~rr r~~c~hili~jrrr r.~ ul.,~n ~lc~.,~c~rrhr~l iu 1{ar J~r~irr~ria• ~i, I ~J~S' ~ Ir!<<~r fr-n~ti R«~1rtl~l Lr~~~r~t to S'trt'c°i1 .ti~ll'r~~1~~1' lsr~• l'u,~~~s 7l %-~ nJ 1h~~ rllrrrc•{t I_i. ~Ul1~ti' ,S'1rrJJ Kt'~~nr1 .~(Ilrrr~Ittrr~°i11.e) "!hr i~arirr~r~r r~~u~r-rrlrulr u~rll ~~rr~rrr~! ht~ ~~.rc~ui~rrlr~r;~ gut iiai~rtrl c~rr1 (.~(r~~rr ,. 1 „l, u(~f»'n.~~intulc'11~ I11(1-'f11J jl. tii'i~l~' 1~ti~ 11111 lr~ -~(Jll Jl. lr~ir~ l~lE'j~~•~trli~t,~ nit ~~~'ct~'c'l.) Ilt~• 1r~lz5~n1! «~t~l nti~c~~'htrt'~lc~it ~t-ill hc~ r~-tftr~t~~~<<, ~~i-r~~~~~.e.c~~rl ~i~ r~ r~~u.~~hr~l~ ~~Itui1 u~trl ~~Iuc~e°~l rlt .~lr~~~k~~r1~~.5~. _~1 s~°~vritr~ '111) /!. ref ~i)trrrc' ~r~'c~rr 111 ur(jrrr~~tr! !r, !hr fir!lrrrl rrrrrr {.~1J titi~rl(hr ttiliic~r(rr.~~ rir 111r rirrli~r! urr~r, u~i111 lltr r~irrlrrrrrl.~~ rrjrrui~~'rl Ji~uif~ ur~~u (l3) ~~lrrr~r~l to Ji(1 i~~ ~rr~~rr (.~Il. "l'!rr rrrru tr~rll 1{tc'~t hr ,~~It~rj~rrl rrlrrl lu~~.euil 1't/~Irrr't'rl ~lilrl rc'~~lu~!!c'tl ~l~llii'c' !n trrru. " (1'~r,~rr.~~ 7l 7' ~~j~ll,c° :~llurrlr 1 ;, ?U11~S ,~7~rJJ~Rc'J~nl•1 .-111rrc~hirrc°~r1.~~1 aL~_ 1.~~~rril Ilr~~,t ~~rut'rll~'.c (r~lr ~~~~~~~.c 7' 7_i uf~lhr' ;11rn'r'1~ l?. _'1J11~4 ,ti'1rrJf~Nr'j~~~r1 .~~!lrr~'I~n~E'~11s1 rl Jlrrtti~ ,~~It~'~'1 .~~Itr~tti~i~t~ llrt~ r'ta~ rr~~~l r'rn~rt- ]»~ur'~~e.e 1~~ hr' c'nrhl~~i~c'rl cr! ~hc~ rVri~~ f:i•u r~li~rr. K. ~I~hc Ilcclan~ati~~n flan auth~~riratiun I~~r an c~~~cratiun ~~f u~~ to ?iU,[l{lf} tens ~~r cubic yards E~cr year is c~~nsistcnt with ('on~~i[ion ? l hccausc the Phase I amount of ?O cubic yards ~~c:r ciay relcrs to a conccntr~rte or a~~ro~luct that is ~~roccss~:~~ anal scEru~atc~l out from ~~ lar~,cr ~~ulun~c c~l~~ulrj-hcarin~~ i~~atcrial. ('r~jtrlrftnit 'I uJ~rllrjlr~r~ ~rfrrl Ilc~rl~rijirrlr~»r f'rrnlrl X5'1-! >> .~~lrrlc~.ti~: ";'llrin~r~ n~~rrrrlin~t In h~~ li~rlirrJ t~~ rr n~~r_rinttrnt nJ~?U rrrhr~~ ti~rrrrl.e ~~~~~- ~lrrl~ ~i~il~r .~~uhs~°~1rri~lr~ r~~~~r~°»~ h~~ 11~~~ !'l~ur~ti~l,~r ('ui~ri~rr,~~.t~rr~rr Jr~r ~u~u~~r~.ti~r~! r.~-~~~rjr.~~inir !r~ l'lr~rsr 11. " 7{~c' ~•c'c'n~'tl ,ehnii•,,' 111«1 'll rrrhrr i~urrl.e j~c'r ~l~rl' t'c'fc'~'.~~ !r~ ~t c~nltr~•itlrul~-rl r~trl~~rr! rc~.elrllill~ Ji~nn1 a j~rvc~c°.~~.~~ rjlr~nh~i11~ r11~~ nrc~c~lurlti~~rr1 s~~~~rrrrlrr»r r~J~ ,~~~alrl-hc~rrrrlr~ hl~r~~h srrlul.~~ Jrr~111 a I~rr,~c~r rnrrnrrlrl n/~nr~rtc~~-r~rl. Irr 11i~~ lc~.ti~linlr»n~ hrjr~rr ih~~ 13u1lr ('r~r~~r1i• 1'Iu1111i11~> ('~~111r11r,~~.~~rn11 n11 1llurc~ll 1.,. ?(1115', ('~1rI Gcrlc~.~~, ~r11 r11~rr11~~c~r /err r11~~ ~~~x°rutnt~.5~. rl~•.rr~-ih~~rl t{1r ~~lur~~~r nrr~rrrr~~ r~~u~rrrlrnlr ~r! !{1~~ a'ru~ F_r~r '11i11c: "~lY1c'1~c' L~~ hu.~~rc'ull~~ nil llrr.,' .~'!!c' i~'11~rt titi'c' c~~11c',~~ni-!~c' u.~~ t{1i•c•r ~li.~~liuc~l rlrilt.r ~{lcrt` 11•c° ~Ic°~rl u~rrll. rti'ru~1h~'r r~tri~. 1uj~sr~rl. T11~~ u~rr~~ titi~r rlc~rl i~~r111 lr,h,~~rrrl rrr ~nri~ u~~e~rrr~rr~lr i.~~ ti~u11 r'r1~'r%t~(lti~ l~rlu' ~Itt' lu~~.er~lt` uJf; l~ur1 .clr~c'kf~il~' h u11r1 ti~n1r rr~1r.~~r°rr~~ it hc~r•rrrr.~~c~ ti~utr 't-c~ ~niir~r 1r~ ~~rr1 t{trrt hu~~k u1r ~~~~~ ref cr~11~ ~~r! thu! ~~~~1r 111u~• ~li~. E'a~c 9 of 24 7Yrc- trc~_r1 nrtc~ i~~ ~Irc° ni~c°r!>rrrrlrrr. lh•rrhtrrclc~rr r~rur hr rrrrf~tlrirr~~ Ji•nrtr rlrrl. rr~rlc. n/ 111rr1 rtrrlru~c~, rrrr ti~rrltrc~ II Iru(cl.~~ ~! lrr~lrl.~~ Ilrr~ hr~~lr~nr r~J llrc' rru-!It rr~~c~lltc'r tit- lltc' hc'rlrur~lt rrtrc( llrr lr~h.~~url. ~ltrcl 1ltc~tr rhr llrircl 1lrirr~~ !]rrrr 7~~c~'rc° Ir~r~kirr~~ Jnr i~~ llrc~ ~>luc~c~r~ <~rur•c~ls. '1trltiti~, rrr llr1.~ hur'lrrrrlur' ~f1c~ Ilrr~rc' :~~ rrlurtr! 'i f~~c~t nJ~hlrrr~r~r ;~rrrtir~l~. ~llrr.~- r.~~ rrir nlrl urrr~rc~it! rlrrr~trrc'I t{ctrl rrnrs rrr~rn.~~s ~lrr.~~ srlc°. ;~`r~tir', itt lltn,~~c' ~t-rr~'c'1,~~ ,~~r~ntc'ft~hc'rr !!rc'rc' L~~ ~,e1c'~ sr~trtr~ hurl~r'lc'.~~ uf~,~'ulr( urrrl !!rrr! 's~ tti~lurr ti~r ~rc° rrJlc~r, 111rzec' Irlllr hru-11r1r.~~ r~/~~~nlcl. iVntir', ~i•c~ Irui'c' In ~~Irulrc' llti.~ Inn.~c', rtttrl llrc'rc' ~.~ ~~~L~~ irrr~lr rnc~l(s, llrc-rc~ :~~ f~rtn- rrtc~lt rnr~lts. !hc'rr~ '.5~ hr,trlrlrr'.~- Iltrr'r ~.~ .eurtrl urtrl llrrrc~ ~.~ .~i11.~~. l~t"c°'rc~ r~rrlti~ irrlrrc~.ti~lc~r/ rrr tlrr hc~rrti~i~.eurrrls crrrrl Ilrrrt '.~~ Itr,~lr ,~rurfr r~r-r. 1lrr hlrrr~lr ,~~rrrrrls. 7Yrul ~.~~ 1hr 1c°rtrrrrru(r~~~~ 1hu1 '.~~ rrr ~u(rl ntrrrrrl,~. " r`rllrrrr~h 1 i 7'r-rrrt.~~r~r-i!» of I't~r~r~rrrlirr,~.~~, l'u,~rr.5~ ~1'~i-~1'7 uJ~ 11rr Jtrrtr ll), _'(1111' ]~urrrrl of .S'rr~~rn~rsur.e ' ,S'lrrf/~Rr~~~nr-r J~~l- 1hc~ .~l~~j~r'rrl uJ~llc~.~~nlrrlir>rt 115-_'-~l lrr Iri.S~ rllurc~lr I ~, ~~111~5 tc~slinrntri J~rJrrrr 11tc~ I~rrllc~ ('nrurlt• 1'lrrruritr~ C -nnrnti.~~.elnrt. 1ltr~ r~~~c~rulnr~.~~ - c•rt~irtc~r~r I )nrt OL~rrr .riulc'rl.' "ltr urrlc'r lr~ hruclrrc'c' Ilrc' _'U r~trhir' ]~ur'rls uJ~ ,~r~lrl f~c'uJ'llr~ hlrrr'h srutrL~~, i~r~rr'rr ~~r~rrr~ In lurti~r lu ~rrrrrrrlr.-.rrhurrl, .ti~rr1~. ?1111 1r~ 71(1 c~rrhir i~ut-rl., rr clu7' !u r~rclc~r 1n ; rc~rrc°rulc~ t{rut. " (,l~lrrrrlr 1 ~ ~l rrrrr.~r~t~i!>r r~J~ l'r~r~c~crrlrrr<~s, 1'u~~c~ X1'9 r~/~Iltc~ .hrnc~ l t1. 'D~)<~' 13ncrrrl nJ~.S'tr~~<•rris~r~r.5' ' .ti'1rrfJ~ Rc~~~r~rt J~~r lltc~ .~lhhc~rrl uJ~Kc~,crrlrrlrurr l)~S'-'~1) f~'~tr~ rr 31? clue rrr~rk ~•rur, SUFI 1r~ 7(1(1 rrrhrc~ ~~urrls hrr rlui• rc~.err11,~~ err utr r~hr~rutrr,rr nj~ Ii(,(1011 ]r~ '1~1',-lUl1 rtrhic~ 1'ur'cl.~~ he°r t'o'ur'. 17tr.5~ rurt~c° Le tirrllrirr lltr rurr,~~r ref ~U,U(1(1 ~?U,(lUU-S~~Irr~rc~cl hl~ r'lfr. Lo~rrrr irr tlrc~ ftc~~~lcmrrrtrntr I'Icrrr. 7Yrc• Rrr~lrrtrrulrutr l'Irrtr rrrrllrr~rr_r.~~ cur uhrrrrlinrr uf~ ti11,11O111n ?~11,(1l1(llnrt.~~ rrr c•rrhir t~urcL~~ hrr iecrr-. C'urtrlilrr~rr ? n/~r1lrrrirr~~ curt! Rc°rlrrttrulrnrr !'c~r-nrrl ~1'I-l ~S Irrrrits 1lrc~ ltr~ru~s r~/~rlhrrulrrrrr ]rr (.1;~1 !n ~ I':~1, ;1lnrulu~~ llrrnu~~h .5'ulrrrrlut. ~'sir1~~ llrc- Irr~lac~r ./i~ru~c~ nJ~?i0,(1011, curt! hu.rc'rl r,rr a .~i_r rlrrt' ~i•nrl. tti•c°r1,, ~I? ~rr~rkirr~ rlut~.~~ hrr t~c~crr ti-r~rrlrl u11~1+r 1Iu~ r/rslrrrhrrrrrc~ n/~rrh try ~1'lHJ forts rrr c~rrhr~~ t~rrrrh~ her clrrl~ ('?(1,1111U clit°irlcrl ht' ?l ~), Jiu- hc>t~urrcl ?f) c~rrhrr° t~ru-cfs~ hc~r rlrrt~. !i`rrr ~lrc~ ?U rrrhic• t~ruxl.~~ 1n rr~rrc°.ti~c~rr! a ]t~lrll rlurlt~ Iitrrrt fu rlr.~~ltfr-hrrrrcc~, r! tti~urrlcl rrstrlf rrr rrrr rrrtrrrrcrl rr~ful cli,~~tru•luurc~c~ r~J~(r,?-~(J rrrhrr t~urcl.~• f~,r~ u ? 1.' rfrrt~ it~nr•Ic t~c~ur, f rr hc~luit• flrc~ ?(1,00(1 1n ~0, 000 uullrori~rr(ht- ]hc° IZc°r~lunrulivtr I'lurt. lhc~ Rrc•Icurrrrlinrt l'Icur'.~~ rrllntit~c'rl nrrr_rintrurr nhrt~rrlrr~rr nJ~_'?0,(lf1(1 lr~tr.~~ rrr rrrlrrr 1•urch~ hr~r• t~c°ur rrJ~~rs !r1 tlrr lnlrrl nrufc~r-rul cli.,~lrrrh~~cl clrrr~rit~ tlrr hrnc~c.~.~ oJ~~~rrrrt~rr,~ u~'c'c~s.~~ Io llrc~ ~olrl-I>c~ur-rrt~ rrrtiti nrulc~riul.~. Tltc~ ('r~rrclitrc~rr '1 f'lrus'c~ 1 Irntif oJ~'0 c~rrhir~ r~ru-rls hc~r c(rn~ rrhrc~srtrls 11rr rc~.~~rrllrrrrl urrrurnrl uJ~trre~c~Irrrtric~rrllt~ .~~c°hrrrcrlrrl, c•urrrrrrtr-rrlc~c! rrrulrrrul lr~ hr ntnt~rrl a/J.~~ifr Jut frrrlhc~r hrr~r~r~~~~.~~itr~r. I'a~c 11} of 2~ hrru 17 a/~tlr(~ K('rl(r»r(rtturr 1'lrtir rlrrtirihrti('s rr rurrrrurrrnr (!('htlr r~J~ 1 Ull /c'('t, rr rl('htlt r•urr,~~i~~t('rrt i~~itlr (rrr uh('r'(rtinrl a/~rrh to '?f1.11(lU lnrr~~~ ur~ r'rrhir t~(rr~(l.t~ hrr~ t'r'rrr Y~Irr tntrrl ~~~ttc° ti'r~lrrnr(~ i.~~ r(hhr~r>.~~irrrrrtc~l~~ _',(~U(1,O(ll1 rrrhrr ~~urrh~ (1<4 rr(•rc~.~~ .~~ l(1 (1 Jrr1 (lc'(~tlr _~~ -1i,i(~11 ~~~(/. /1. f~c'r- rrr•r'r' rliti'r(1('(l l>1' '' rrrfuc~ Jc'r11~(•r' ('trhi(' i'rrr'rll. [l~itlr rr '?U.UU(1 (~uhrr ~~rrr-(I h('r r(•ru~ r~hr•rrrlrr~rurl Irrrrtt. tlr(~ .S~nurr(~.~'t nrrrrirr,~ nhr'r~crtrnrr.~~ r'r~rrlrl hr rr,nrhl('t('(l nrr !Ir(' I ~ti' u('r~(' h(rr~r~('l ii'nzrlrl h(' I ~ ~~('rrr'.~~. f f ~(•r-(' t!t(' r~hrrrrtrr~rrrrl linrrt rr tntrrl of _'U rrrhir ~~rrr-rl.~~ hrr rlrr~~, rt tt~rrrrl(! t(tlti(~ rrhhr-rz~rnurtrlt' -f~, ~ ti'c°(rrs to r~nnrhlrtc' rrrrrrrrr~> rrt thc~ ~~rt(~ 1~(r.~~r(l. (r~~rr~rr, nrr ~ I ' u~nrkrrl~ (1(rt•.,~ hrr 1'c ~rrr. hr Iri.~~ ;1lrrrr~lr I ;, ?f111~4 t(~stinrurrt~ hc~/rrrr tlrr l~rrtt(~ ('ururtt~ 1'lrrrrrrirr~~ ('urrrnrr.~~.~~rurr, nn'rrrr- llr~rrrrlrl Lu~urr ,ctrrlr(I tlrrrt rr hc'r rl(ri~ uhrrrrtrnrrrrl littrrt a/_'(J rrrhir i'rrr(L~~ u/~ tntul rlistrrrhurrrr ~~~nrrlrl hr rrrJ~~(r.~~ihl(~: "Ilnti~~ rntrl(l ~~ntr rrrrir(• ~'(J ~•rn•(L~~:' Ij~t'ntr 7~~rr(• cr ntrrt(~r-, ~~ntr titi'nrrlrlrt't rti'rrr s(n~ th(rL l.rkr i~r,u r(rrr'I nrrrlti(~ rr Irrrr~~ urt(( ti~nr-k (rrr(l !t(ri'r rrlrrihnr(~rrt rrrr 'U ~~rrrrt.~~. 77rrrt 's rrrr~i~. " 1~11rrrrlr L3 7i-rrrrs(•rthl r~J~l'rr~rrrrlrtr,~s, 1'(r,~~r Il1-I n~~tlrr Jrrrr(' l11, _'(1(11' l~urrr'r(uj~,5'rrhrr'ti'f.eur•s' ,~'trrff~Kc'hnrt j~~r' tltr .•Ihhr(rl uJ K('ti•r~lrrtinrr (1~5-~-{} Lc stutr°rf rrhuti'c° frti. tlrr nhrrrrtnr's rrt•~irr(°('r ~Ir. OL~~('tr- ~lJU to 7f)11 rtrhi(' ti~rrrrLs r~j~ rrurtc~r-r(rl rrrr rr°(Irrrrr'(l to hrr~(Ir~rc~ 'U rrrhrr ~~rrr(1~~ r~J~ rnur•(~rrtrrrlc (rt th(~ ,'Vrtiti~ hrrr .~~rtr. 7Yrr ,~~ulrl-hr(rr-rrr~ (•nrrr•(~rrtrrrlr rs~ tlrrr.~' hr~tti~r(°rr ~ rrrrr! _'.~1't ftrrr•rtrt nJ~ thr (lr~~trrrhrr! nrrrtrrr(rl ('U rrrhrr i~urrl.~' (lrti'r(lc~(! h~~ i(1 (l urrrl 711(1 rrrhrr ~•urrLe). Ii'rrr tlrr r'Vc~rt• l':ru r,hc~r(rtrnrurl lrrrrit (r tntul nJ~ ?(1 r'rrhir r(rrrl.~~ h('r riot, tlr(~ t~(•.~~rrltrmt ,~r~lrl-hr°(rrrrtg rnrrrc~rrtrutc~ ti'r~rr(rl hr tlrrr.5~ hr~ U.~1' to (1- ~7 (•rrhrr ti~ur(ls her rlrr~~. Tlrr i11(rrr•Ir ~, 1 ~r1'? I'Irrrrrrrrr ('uttrnrrssrurr ;~Irrrrrtr.~~ strrtc~: "f~nrr l,n,,(ur .1'(!!(I...tlr(f! hr titi•urr!(1 Irkc~ to ~>r~nr,~ li~r»ra lri.5~ f~r-c~.~~c~trt prud~rctroir nJ~ 1 ? to 'll i•urrl,,' 1>rr~ (lut• to <SIJ.-. '~ (lirrttr ('nrurti• ,11ur~rlr 3, 1O~5'? 1'I(rrrrrrrl~ ('nrxnri.~~.~~inrr .~tlrtrrrtc~.~~, I'(r~c' lf1(J n/~ Iltc° r1lrrrc'Ir l,;- ?O{)~1' .S7(r//~ K(~hvr-t : ~ttrrrlrnrrrrl.~~) "I'rnr/rrr'trnrr " rr~ji~rs lu thr nrr(~]r(nrrr(rl .~~c°hrnxrtrr,rr rrrr(! rurrrrrrtrrrtiurr a/~~ul(1-Irr(rrirr,~~ hlrrrlt •5~(rrr(h~ /rnru utlrrr rrr(rtrrrrrls~, rrs rlc.~~rr-r1~r(1 ulun'r~ irr l~'rrr((irr~ .I rrrrrl irr tlrr t(°stinrnrri~ nf~c~rr,~rrtrc~rr.~~ I)urr OLsrtr caul ('(rrl (;ulc~.ti~. l'rnrlrrr'tinrr rr.~~rrlts rrr (r hrn(lrrr•1 tlrut cln(~.ti• rrr~t irrrlrrrlc~ c°-rrul'rrtc~(1 r~i~rrfrrrr(lc~rr, tr~hs•rril, rrrrcl/nr sti'cr.~•1c~ rnrk. Irr rrrr .~~hrrl J, 1(J~4? lrr,~~hc~rlinrt I~c~hr~rt Ji-r~rrr fire ('rrrlru! I~~(rllci' I~c;~rutr(rl 1~'rrt(~r Uurrlrlt' ('nrttr-nl l~n(rrrl, : Irtthr~rr~' J- l,rrrrrlr.~~ ~i rut(: "h- r1Tr. Lrl~rrrr (t,~r(-r'(l tltrrl Ire' u'urrlrl nrrh' p1•r~rr~s's rr/> In 'll r't(1>fr• t~urrL~~lrlut~ l]'Itrr.er 1 uhrrcrtlr,rr) fir t{rc' rrr.rl J~~ti,~ ~~rrrrs, rnrttl !rr rrrrr .~~nhr tilt nrttrr'.~ rrrrrr(rh' tir'rrtrr rrrrrtrrrtrnrrtrt hrnhlrnr.e. " (1'rr~r l a7 nJ~ tilt r~l(rrr•!r l ;, '(lfJ~1' .S'tcr/j~llc'hnrt :-lttrrrlrnrc~rrt.c.) .-1.~~ uvtc~rl rrhu~'(~ rrr 1~'rrrrlrr~~ .l, hlrr(•cr nrrrrrrr,~ rrt tilt ;V(~titi' 1:'r~r 11lrir(~ rrri•nlti'r.~~ rr hru(•r.~~.~~ of rrnrni'rr1~ ni'rrhrrr(lrrr rrrr(1 nrr~r'Irrrrrr(•rrlh~ .t~rhrrrrrtrrr,~r ~ulrl-hrrrrrtt~ hlrrrh Na~c 11 ut' 2=1 .~~raarrls Jr~~m rrurr~rur~liar~r ~~r~rrl~(~l~~ uaar! c~1lt~~r- mrrl~~rrcr! rrr rl~~~ ~~'~~11~ l~.i~rr Jru~naurlurr'.~~ fltri•frrlilr rl~~l~r~.~~rl.~~ (rtLsn si'c' llu~ 1)~~l~rrrlrrt~~at1 uJ ~llrur.~~ carrel (~r'r~lr~~ti~ ,~'l~~~r'rrrl 13rrllr~ira rr~car-rlrr~~ rlr(~ tl~`rll~ I~,~rrr Jr~rrriulrurt url 1'crt~r,~~ tr' ~i~ r~J~rlr~• ;llrrr-rlr l.i, _'(1(1~~' ,5'trr/J~Ilrlu~r-r .~11lrrr~hrrr~~rrl.5~l. 111 R~lili~atc~i h~~,ati~~ ])~•claraliull clici n(l~ illclu(~r C'(t~l(liti(~n N(t. ?1 ~ls a ('1~:(,)~'1 1111L]~~.9~2Un It1CL1tiL12~1'. 7'Irr C'l~:(~.~I J~r-r~rr.~~e l~rrrsirrarrl !r~ ll~hirh nc~~ ;1lirrirr~> crrrcl Ilrc~lcuucr~inrr I'c°rrrril ~5'I-! ~? li~ct.~ rr!>!»'nt•c'cl t~r,r1~'rclc'r•('cl !!tc' c'/fc'c~1s~ nJ~ rr'rrc~k lr'uJfic~. Iltc- rte°i~Itl~nr-.e c~tE~rc°.e.errl c•r»tc~c~r'rt 1rillr lrrr/jir ~rtc~r~rcl.rr.r nrt !>r,r (~rrc~l, 7tnu~! L~~('c'. /r~r- c'.r~ritrl~Ic'. !lrnr ' uJ~1hc l~~c°ht-rrnr~~ '(i. l~)~S'? !~(-~irrnrr /i-vrrl 1)f-l~ ('rr~~1~ Nurrrl rr.~~r<lrrrts~ 1u lhr f'lrrrrrlrrr,~ ('unrnu.~~.~~rurr, !'rr,~~r cJ-1 uJ~ tlrc~ :'llrrrr~h !_~, _'UO~4 .ti'1rrJJ~ Ilc~lrurl .~(~Irrr~larrrrrtl.~~1. llrn~~r~~rr, llauir~h ('r~rrrlrlrurr Nu. '! llrrs irtrlrrrlrc! Irt ,'llirrirr~ rarer! llrrlcrrraulir~rr I'r°rrrti! ~ti'!-!_i 7, r1 lti~rr.~~ rtr~! irlrrlri~rr°cl ra.~~ ur1 inrl~rrr! rrtrli~rutirrrr ntrcr.,~rn~(~ nl7 !!tr ,ti'rrlrrr c~f~])rlc~rrrrrrzulrc~ri (.cc°(~ Il(~rrr ? of llu~ ;~1~nlirc~ nJ~lh~lc~rnarrlulrnrl, !'cr~r !7, nj~ llac~ r1lur~c~11 I ;, 'U(l~ti' .1'1crjJ~Ile°lxrr•1 .-111uc~lrnrc~u~.,~). 1~1. I~IIC currrut i~~~~~ E~:r~l uE~cratiun h~ls nut ancj ~~~ill not result in a suhstalltial (l~~~satioll f~runl the a~~E~ro~~~cj Reclamation flan as that tcrlll is (jclinca3 by ~cctinu >(1?((l? of-the ~urfarc Mislin,~ an(l Rcclaltlahrnt llct ol~ li)7ti. Thc~ ralrlrrnti~c°cl llc~c~luraacatiurr 1'lurr (J>ca~~c~.r 1 '-!~5' nJ~ tlrc~ ,~1~lurrla 1 ~. 'UU~ti' 1'Icnrrurr~~ ('r~nrnris.~~rr~ra _~lrlcrc~lanrc~rrts) stcrlc~s llac~.Jr~llr~lrira~ rc°,~crr-clrrr,~r rc°r•lrrrnrrtrurr of !hc' ,r1~~~u~ l;rca ;~lrrar .~~i1r.~ ~ 7'hc~ !r~lcr! crr-c~rr Icy hc- rc~c'lurnac~c! r`llc°rrrs ~S' crrtr! ") l~~us !r~ !~c° I ~Y rr[v'c~.~~; crrtrl ~ 711 c' ('.ti~linlralc'c! Iifi' nf~!lac~ r~lx'r'ralrurr (11i~nr !-7J l1'rr~' S{) Cry 1!1(1 l~c'cu~.c; !!tc' crrlrrarcrl rrnlr~rrrrl uf~rrarrlrrrca! nrnl~rr! (lrrnr Ih/ ll~crs~ lu 1~(~ i(l,(lU(1 !n ?S(l,(111U tura.~~ rrr rarhir i'trr(!s lx~r: carol ~ 7lrc• nrrr_rirrttrnt rrrttirrl~crlc'r! rl(~!~llr (llc~nr !.') !.~ Il)l1 Ji'c'1; uru( • 71ar rrairaira~ nrrllanr! (ltc~nr IBS') tt~cr.ti~ !r~ hr ,ti~irr~,lr hc~„r1, tl~rllr lrrilrrr~r.ti~ lrcrarc! crrrrl ,rcrti~r! hrrr slurr~rrarra,; urrr( • 1lrc~ ar!linrutc~lrltt'.51c~rr! rurrclirinu cajlc°r- r•c~rlcunrrtrnrr tl~rrs ,~~trrlc~r! rrs~ "u~r ll~rrrlt !n l~rr! rlrc~ lrrrrr! hcrc~k rnrcl hlrrail rrrrfrl~r 1r~ rrrrra. " .11 tlrr ,~11cu•rlr !3, ?llll~ti' I~ncrrr! rrf~ ,S'rrl~rrl~r.ti~ur,~~' llc~urrrr~ thc~ rVrll• f:'ru ~'l~lrrlr c~rl~rrrrc~c°r~, lh~rr Ul.~~rra crJ~ llolclrc~~c~ urtr! h~rr11, ~c~.~~riJi(~rl Ilru1 Ilrc° c~rr1 cnrrl rnt~c~r rcc~lcrrracrlir~rr crl~l~rnrrr]i rl~r~trlcl 1~c~ rrlrli~c°rl !rr r-c~-cwntnrrr tlrc' .~~itc~ to ~Irc~ lrrr-ruirrr .~~lular /r~r c•rarlt rrrrrr rr.~~ nrirairr~~ is r~untlrl<~l~~rl: "alr•. ;'tlcrrirr: .~1rr tlrc~lx,rtrl~~ ~~nir1~ to hc~ hurkJilk~c!'' ;11r. (llsrrr: Ih(~ lwncL~~ 11•il! tlrc~rr hc~ uc~Itrrallt~ rc~,~rrrr!(°c!. 7hc~l~ u~rl] hc' hrac I~Ji(Ic~cl. I'a~;c 12 oi' 24 .lrlrl lhrt-r'.~~ 1hr Jitrrrl ~rrrrlit~~ 1'lrrtr. iJ~irr rrrti ~>rrll 117rr1 itlt ~rrJi•~-ritr<~ lr~ r! 1'r~rt~rrl'nitr! .~'lirlr'~. Il Innl~~~~ liter' 111is. ,S'n ~~r~rr rlr~tl '~ ,er'r' [1171' r'ivrlr'ttr~r' nJ !hr- /tr117r1~~. ,5~n u'r' '1'c' t'c'-r'.~~luf~li.~~17it7~r lhr~ nt'i~iltul ~rurlr.e. 7ltc' r~rtttlilttrnrts rtt- .~rtlirl Iittr's ul-c' tltc' I~rr~I~usc'rI JInr7/ ~rrtrlitr,~ l~/rrtt ~1-rrrlr',~~ rti7rl thr' r/rr.~~h lit7r's r71~r' a hr71 i~ u'r1.~~ hc'frtt-r' rt171 n7ittilr~ rrrlil'ilir.~~ 1ur~lt I~lrtrc'. .ti'n l n7! r~r117 .~'c'r' it '.~~ Jiril•ll' r~ln.~r~ /ht~c°- rrtrrl I~n.~~1-rrtittitt~ rthr~rrrlintr ~r~rrr/r°.~~~. 1J~l~nrr 1t~r~rr~ !n r~rttt7llrrl-r r'lr'ti'rtliutt r'nttlnirt- t~rfl7rrs, l~rt7r I~tlr~ti~, lllc'r~ r11'c' ~(1i1'll' ('lusC Ire tir'11r11 it ~t-r7s hE°~r~t"C- Ot7rr' lhi.~~ Iru.~~ hr'r'17 run7hlr'!r'll~ 1'r;~r~tr7lr~rl, ti rtit ltt-r~lurhll' rt~r~ttlr/tr ~! c'1'r'17 hr' rrhlr lu rrll rrtrrl phut lt~rr.c rr nritritt~r ul7c~rulir~l7. " (1'rr~~r~ r>? nJ~thc~,lrurr~ 111, '11U~5' 13r,r7rrl nJ~,~~tl/)r't'1'i~'r1i'.~~ ~ ,ti'luJJ~Kr'/tnrt Jrtt' !hr' .~Il1Ix•ul nJ~llr-.~~nlulirtlt U~ti'- '-Il Ilr-rr» rlurrt-itr~ nf~ lhr~ .~~ilr f~~llvtir~rrl hl~ tlrrrir~r~ hlrrtrritr,~ rti~ill hr rr~r/trirrr( hl~ ~hr 1)r~Ixtt'ln7r'tt! r~J~l>c'i'r'In/»uc'ttl ~ti'c't'r'ir'c'~~~ hr'1' 111 c' rrhl~!-ul'r•rl Kr~r'Irrnrrrlir117 f'/rr17 rrtul 1hr' rrr~Iruttulir~tt Il/rrtt rlnrtultrttl.c itrr~ltalrrl u~illt ~hr 1lrrrr~h 1 ;, ?(1115 rri~i~~c~rl /itrrrl7riul rr.c.~~rrrutrrr rrz~~l c~~~littautr~ Jrlr rrrlrrlurrlrrtt7 nJ~ Ihr ;ti4'u' I.rr1 ~ei1c~ nJ~ ~'fi?,-III. ?<i (.~1llrrr~I7tl7r~t7! .1~ nJ~ thc~ a'urt17 (Trtt71i17c°lrt l.rr17r1 rrlu! 7itulxr .1llrtrhlt7r171.~~ J~tr ~hr° ,1lrrtrl7 I_,. '(1U~1' I'/r7ttt7ilt~ ('uurntissir~lr hr~rn-iti~.) 7hi.~~ Jit7rrlrr~iul u.~~strl-ut7r•c° r~r~,~~! r.~~littrrrlr~, hl-r~/trrre~r( h~~ rhr~ c~ti,~=itrr~~°~~rtr,~ Jit-tti r~J~llulrlrc~,~r° rrtrrl h-trll rnrrl rr~~hrnr~r~rl ht~ hullr I~trrtr ('nrtt711~ rrtrrl 117r l)fJirr uJ~ ,1littr Kr~rlrrtttrrrir~l7, hrnl~irlr,e .c11r hlrrt7.~~ .~~hnlti~il7~~ I7rlrr rrrrl7 rrrru mill hr~ rr-rnt7tu7rrc~rl rrflr~r tttittit7,~ is r~ntt7/>lrtc~rl, rlrsrrihr.~- rc~lluntilr~ r»r ihr~ .~~itc', rrlntt~ lti•il`h a tr7r~17i~uriu~ Ilr~l-irul uJ~ltti~r~ ~~r~rtrs 1~~ itrsrtrc~ lhrrr rc~hlrrrrlilr~ is .~~rrr~~~r°.~~.~~Jirl. :Iltltl-~~l~rrl r~J~ thr~ r~r~,~~1 r~.~~littrrrtr~ ht' thc~ UJfir~r' uJ~ 1llitrr~ Rr~r•Irnurrliutr rrtrc( l3rrltr ('nrtltlt~ rut7.~~litrur.~~ ~hrir r/c~rrrtttittrrlint7 thrr~ nc~~ r'~'rlti~ F.ru silt rru7 hr t~r~rlrri117c'rl rrrrrlt-rlit~~ ru 1hr Krc~lrutu7tirltt l'lru7. ~l- ~I~ha currant uharatiun has nut rasuftacl irl a suh~tarllial ~lcviatiun li~um iha ~r}~l~ru~~c~4 lZeclamatic~r~ Plan trcc~~r~lin~~ t~~ tha suhstanti~rl cicviation rritcri~r f~~un~l in 1. ".A substantial increase in tf~e cfistrn-hanca ol- a surf~rcc arr~l ur in tha ma~inwn~ clchth ol`minin~.„ '4'r~ srrr~{r itrr~rr~rr.~~r~ teas nr~r~rrt-rr~rl. 77ir° Nr~r~/rrnrrrlir~l7 1'Irrt7 i,~~Jr~r 1hr' l~ti' ur~rr /trrt-r•rl (rr.~~ rrl.~~u .~~Irrlrrl itr thr Nutir•c~ of l)c~lc~rnril7rrlint7 jilrrl fnr nc~~ nrittitr~r nj~rrrrliut7). the llc~rlullurtint7 1'Irtt7 crllnu~s• !hr' clislru~hut7rc° rlj~ ?lJ,O(1O ~ ?~(l,l1(1(J ~ulr.~~ nt• r7rhic~ t~urrl.~~ /'r't. t'c°rrr to rr t17rr_ritt7ruu rlr~/lth nJ~ I (111 ji•c't. .~ti'rilhrl- nJ~lhrs~~ lin7il.~~ ltrrs hr°r~tr. rat- lti~ill hr~, r°.rrr°r~rlc'rl. 7'r~ ilrs7rrr~ that ll7c lrn7il of '?(1,UOll lutr.~~ rat- rrrhir~ l~rrrrl.~~ ~x~r 1'r°rrr is trr~! r.rr~r~rrlrrl, the' 1)rllrrr1117r1r1 r~J~l)r1~r~luluttrl7! ,ti'rt-l~irr~s .ehrr// rutlrl7rr~t rrtr rrl7trurrl i17s/x~c~lintr hrr I~rr11r° ('rlturll~ C'uc/r ,S'rr1in17 I i-l l '(rr) utrrl .5'c°c~tiutt '77-I(hJ r,J~ rhr~ 1'rrhlir llr~.~~rrurr~r's ('urlr rrtrrl l~r°riJi' rhr~ utrl7trrrl rrlt7lJrf17! r~J~rlis~rrrhrrl7r~r f~l~ nlr~rrlr.~~ rtJ~ u lv~lrutlc°lrir~ uc.~~r°.~~cntr~lll (rrrr~rr r~frli~clrrt-hrttrrr~ nrrr/fil~]ir~rl hl' il.~' rh~~llt). Yaffe 13 of 24 ?. ".~1 s~~hstanlia~ 4~tcusi~ui ~~f the t~rn~in~itinn ~iatc ~~f the n~iiiiii_.~ ~~~~criti~~n ati sit uut in tlic ~s~i~~r<~~~c~l r~cl~im~ji~nn ~~l~in... ;1~'n .,~rrrll ~-_~~rc'lt.r1n11 h~r.~~ r~rc~rr~~r~~~l. l~hc~ l2rt~lu~12tr1~n~t f'Irrir tr~1r~•Jrrr»r~• r.~~ ?l1 1r~ 1 Ull t~~°crr.~~ (Ili°nr 1~~1. ~~r~ltsr.57~-ir1 ti~rllr rh~° c~ru~f~~~jtl ~~~~e°r~rlrr~rt rr~rrl rru! r~r~it.~~i.~~l~~rr! >>~rlh ctrl l~ur~ j~rt~l~~lrr,~r r~J~ rr 1r,lrrl rlr~~lrrrhu~rr~~ r,J~ 'f) r~rrhrr~ t~~rrrl.~~ f,rr rlrr7~ (st~ltir~lt titi~urrlrl i-r.errl~ i~r rr~r n~~r°rrrli~~irrrl trjrir~Ji~rrjyrr r~J~rr~~~~~~r~.~rnrrrrrh~ ~(~? 7~~~cri:~~l. ~. ..{~I~ai~t~c~ th<<t ~t~c~tilcl suhst~inti~illy <<I~fcct tll~ ~~Ei~~r~~~~~~1 cr~cl tic ~~I~tl~~ site ,is cstah~ishui ii7 the rcclait~.~tiou E~lait." ?'~`~~ .~~rrrlr rlrrri~~r hrr.~~ rx~rrrrr~~~l. "l7rc~ r~r~l rrsr r~~jrr~rr~a.~~ 1hc~ r~~1u~-~t ~~/~ tltr .~~ilr !n i1.~~ ~~r~~-;tlriirjr~> urrrl Izrrluiricuru~r 1'rrnril ~5'I-l ~? c~~»r~lil~n~1 hs• rr-c~rr~llnrrrr~r~~ ~r~a~l rc~~l~rtrlitt,~< u~irlr rt~rlrrc~ 1~r~c~lulinil. .~(~rrr~t, a c~rr1 urt~l c~ni~~•f• t~~rlt~tir~trr tt~ill h~~ ~-itt~~lnt~~•~l ~~nllc~trl'I'~•I1! tti~rlll ilti11i11~. l~~Y~lrr~tlulinir /tcr.~~ trot 1~l'1 r~~~irtrue~itc~~°rl rr.c. rr! ~~r~~_~~~~irl, 1h~- r~ru-i~~-~l1 uj~~-rrrlrr~i! hrr.e i1r~I ~~r~nrj~It~l~~rl nrf~rfli,~ fir f'f! 1 L~~~'~' .5'rt~~ 1'I~rjt.e rrlr•lrr<lrrl r~r llul~lr~~,~~~ cl~ h~rrl! ~.~~ "1~7~rrr~rr~lrr! : tssrrru~r~~r l~.'.~~lintrrtr Krj~r~j~l Jr~r r1%c~u~ I~;j~rr 11i1r~~, " .111rrr•lrnrr~it! .1~ of lOtr ;~lrrrr~{r l ;, ?(Itl<5' :'~'nrlh ('n~rlr~rrit! l.rrirrl rriul 7innc~°~~ .•11lrrrlrjric°~rr.~•). ~. "~[ he c~ulsistcncy c~l~ anv E~rc~E~osccl cha~~~~~ tc~ the oE~~r<<ti~iil with the prc~i~~usly aclu4~tccl cn~~irunn~c~~tal dctcrmination5.„ 7Yrr~-c~ L~~ itr~ "j~ru~~n.~~c~c( r{i~ut~rr" /i~~~~fi tit~lrrrl r.r ~lrsc~rrh~~~l iit ;1lrirrir~ uj1~1 Rc°c~Iulu~rtirrfl l'rj~nrit <ti'1-1 >> ~rat~l tlrc° Krrhri~zulir~u f'Icr~t. Tlrr rlliti~u<<~r! ;V~;~rrlrti~r 1)~~~~Irn~rr~r~~ir ~rrl~~~~l[°~( u~r ;'L~/rr.r 'U. ]9~5" ii~rr.~~ /r~t~ rr i~rrirrir<~ nE~~~r~rlrn~l of l~ti' rrr•y~t~s. u~i1h u~r u~~r~-rrJru~url Irinrl uJ~'~O,l1UU tu~1,~~ ur rr~hrr 1~rlrc(.e ~'{'t- t~rrrr, rr rltrruliu~t n/ ~U-Ill(1 ti~rur.~~ rnt~! a ntu_rillrrrnr rl~•~~11i u~~ 1!)fJ frc~1. "IY,c° rir~~rc~itt r~~~rrcrfinia r.~~ c~~~il.cr.~~1ri11 titi~itl! 1{~r Llrti~rcrlc°rl r'4'c°~>~rtri~c~ !)rc~l~rru~rr,~i jr»~ t{1~rr n~~c°~~~rrin~r. >. "~1rw c~thcr chvl~~GS that tl~c l~ac3 a~~n~y cl~~ms suhst~-nti~il c[wi~~liu»s as ~l~finc~j in Ui~ suhsccti~~i7.., 7Yirr~~ i.~~ ~~n ~•hrn~~r fi~unr 1hr rr~~~~rn~•c~rl R~~rluniutru~r !'l~rir. r'4'~~1•tlr C'nrttr~trirt l,crjr~l rri1J Tri~rhrr, Int. r~~rll ru»t~~lc~rr rc~c~lcri~rcrlru~r rt1 r.l~rrc~llt• tllc° ~~rrx~rs.~~ ~lc~.~~rrrhrc! ht' th~~ Il~•rlcrntulin~t I'l~rrr. O. ~[~he current New E~.ra Mine ~~~~er<<ti~~n is in com~~liance ~F~ith the sco~c of il~tinin~~ anei fZeclamatie~n E'crmit 51-135, tllc Kcclanrition Ilan, the; Miti~attc~ Nc~ati~c Ucclaratic7n anti ~Ioticc ~~f~ [)ctcrminatioi~. ;'lliiti~t~ crncl Krr~lrrtl~crlin~t I'rri~tr! X4'1-I75 r~1trllc~` rr i~arfrr~r~r ~~/~rrcrlir~ir nj 1~5' crrrr.~•, ~,~r1h ~r~r r~hrrrrlinjiul Irnirl a/~'~f1,~11N1 tu~t.ti~ ~~i• rirhrc~ ti•rrrcJ.,~ ~~c°~~ t~c°rrj~, ~r ~lrrrulrn~r ~,J if)- I rJll t'~~rrr.c curl rr ~u~r_rrnrrrnr clc~~~rla nJ~ Il)lJ J~~c'1. "l~h~- ~~rrf~re~irt nj~~-ru~rr,r1 r.e i~nrt.~~rs~1~°tt1 t~~illt rhL~~ ~~r~~j~°rt ~h~sr~ri~~lrnu. Na~;c l~ of 24 Ilrr "~~f~ujrr~! ~~ rrrr~~ti~rrl hr ~Ii~~ I ~1~5'? ,11rlr~rrlr~rl :'1`r',~ulrr~~ 1)t~rlurrrtrurt 1.~~ llu~ .~~rrntr u~~[~rulrulr rnrrlrrrrrhr~r rrn~r~~lrlh~ rrl llrr ;1~rrt~ l:rrr ;tli~rr. 71rr .~~ru~,~' uJ~ rhr /~ruj~~~~1 ru~~.er~f~~f-r~l rat 1 ~J~S'_' r.~~ 1hr .~~ru~~~~ uJ~11~r h~~r.~~r~tr ~lriiriir~~ uj~c~~~rrlrr»r rat tt~hirh all nJ~lltc- ~~n1c'~11~~r1 ~~~ri•irniiirlr~rrrr! 1111f>rrt~l.~~ rrrr nc~~ s~rn7~~. 7~11c-r~~ lurt~r h~~~~jr ~1u ~~l1u~r~r.~~ ~rc~trrrrit~~ a ~suli.~~e~rjtrc~~t1. ~rtr~~~~l~~irir~rt~rl ur jr~ rti~ C'I~:O.1 r~~rrE~tr_ :~'u r~lt~rllrll~~rs !n lire' ;1`rrrrr~r r~J~ 1)rlrrnrr~ruliuir Jnr 11rr :11i1r~~crrc°r( Vc'~>~rlii'~' Ih~r~lrrrrrlru~r u~lu~~1~~r! tirilh nc~~ ~r~~~~rui~~rl uJ~:1lrirr~l~~ u11r1 Krc~lrrtu~rlrrrrl !'~~i•~ui1 ~ti'1-! u~rrc~ jil~~~f u~illr l~rrltc° {'nrr~rlt•, ih~-,5'1ut~' ('Irc~r~it~ltrllr.~~~°, ur ru rr~rr~ ~~uru-1 in I~J~1'?, i'. ~l~lte aphcal of E'l~rt~r~it~~~ ('ottti~iitisiun Ilcsoluti~»t O~-?-l by Kick~~tr~l Meyers (its cluute~i hclo~ti} is nut suhhortc~l h_v s~:hstantial c~~i~lencc in the rccunl hasccl un the fi~lluwin~~ linclitt`~s: E'c7it3t l c7f iVir. Mcvcrs~ ~thheal states: "I. f'lannin~ ('ommissiun mule nu ciecisinn un the hermit hcin~ `lahscci'. W'c have ~tr~~uccl, anti ~~~il] ar~uc. that the county stal-I~~t~~rs crirr~ct its their st~ttct~~cnt, its the ])cccmhcr ?O, ?Ut77 Notice oi~ \%iolatiotl `the cin-rcnt uher~ttiotl c.~cctds tl7c sc~~pc ul~ ~;1' ~1-1 ;~ an~k, t~wrc in~hortanil_y', l;f' til-1ij is nu l~~n~acr c~~nsicicrccl tt ~alicl hermit. It is uur~ieterminatiun that l.l' ~l-li> has lahseci."' ;11ri1rlr~ rrir~l Rc~r~hrnlrrlinsl 1'c~rr~rrt ~S'l-1 ~? ~r~~r.~~ i.~~srrc~rl ru~~lrr 1~'tr~rr C'rlrnrl~~ C'rnlr ('{ru~~lrr J;, ;l1-tirlr 1I ~uu! jtul rrjrrlc~r l~utlc~ ('ul~~rlt~ ('n~lc° C'lt~rj~lc~r ?~1. Ilrr Iu~~sr j~i•nt'L~~iu1r nJ~.S'c~rtruit _'-~-~l~.tl1 flu~~sc~ uJ~~~c~f'nti!) clues ttul rl/~~~It~ !~~ ;'llrtirji~ rrirrl Kc°rltr~uutiuir I'~~r»rr1 ~ti'I-I_,5. .~L~~.~~rutc~~l in f•-rfirlr~i~ ('rrhurr. rr~lrrrh !.e rirr~ur~~urrrl~~~l {i~°~'~°rir hr 1hrs~ rcfcre°irr~°, lh~~ u~~~~rrrtr»~.~~ Irur~t~ j~rut~rrlc'~f rr~rrlr~i~~~~ tlrrlt llar~rria~r u~~~~rrrrr~,~r,~~ rrl Ilrr ,ti'ru~ l:'rrr ;1liirr rti~c°r~° 1rirlrlt~ r~r»ui~rc°~trrrl [r~1rl lrrrti~r hrrir u~t~~r~ria~~ u~r rr~t rnt~turrl h~rsr.~~ f~rlsr~rr~t 1 t1~5'? rr~trl ?f1l17. 1~'rrj-lhc~r~rturr, rltr iti'c~u~ I~;~~cr ~'l7rit~~ uf~r~-crlruil hcr.~~ ulti~o itut lu~~.~~c~~l ~>c°r 13rr1rc° ('r~rr~ttt~ C'~xlc° .S~rrliuir 1 ~-]ll<5' hrc~~rtr.r~~, rr.~~ ~,~lrrrc°rl i~1 l~rir~li~r~ (~, c~rrclc°~1c~~~ rj1 tlrr Jnr1u uJ~tr/Jr~lrrt~rts, u!lr.rlulrr~rrs. E~hntu~rrr~~~ts~ rritrl rrtrur~~[~s (s~,i, .-~IllrrrltJlt~~rt1.~~ ll, i~ crit~I 1~f3 !ltrnrr~Ir I~I~Ii a/~11r~~ r1~'ur1~r ('u~rlr~rrtll l,rr~l~l rnrrl ~I'rnnc~'r rt~l~u-r~{z I.~, ~Oll~Y I'luriutit ('unrntissrwr .111rr~~1lnrc~~1~.5~), rr.ti~ lltr~.ti~r ~r<'1rt'rti~~.~~ rn'c' rlc'f~~~E.'rl ht~ ,~',II,IR,( .5'c~~'li~jjl 'i ~ ~, hers hc'r~r ~~rc'.~'c'~ilc'r1 sllntt~i~l,~r llltr! irriitiit,~~ u~~c°r~rlru~t.~~ rt•rrc~ ri~u~~lt' rr»rtific~nrr~l rt•i1{rrja Jit~r ti'c°~u~s uJ~ rhr i.~~sucritrr uJ r1li~ri~t~ rrjrcl Ilc~rlcn~rurrr»r !'c~r»rr! ~ti I - I ~ ?. Point ? of Mr. Meyers' ahhcal states: ?. [ he f'lat~nin~ ('(1n11ZllsslO[1's clccisiun ~~as huhclcssl}' ~ a`~uc in that: :. ~'1t ]cast one of-the cunnnissiuncrs was con~~incc~i thcv hail allo~~~cci the t~tinc to uhcratc at the a~~rcccl upon rate c~l~c~ir~tctii~n uf~ l1E' ~l-l~iti «I-?U cui~ic yards ol~ tutti~~c soil ~~ ~iav; in the intcrint hcf~uc thu amcncimcnt to the hermit ~~as al~hru~ecl. I'a;;e I S «f 2~4 h. ~I~I~e ciecisitnr eieic~~ nt~t snl•licientlti~ aelclr~~s tl~c iiiiti~~~rti~~iis rc~luircrl f~~r the ~n~ irunn~ent~rl imparts cif tllc incrt•~i~e in scale nl the nc~~ c~pcratic~n. r. ~I~hL clecisic~i7 allo~~~s I~~r iir~ staneiarei li~~~nr ~~hich the impact eau he elcteeirrineel.., ~1.~' slulrr~ frr l~1rr~Irrr,~,.~ ,I, h~ rrrr~l I, rrhr~ti'c', ~~~lrrr'{r ~rr-<' irrrur~~urure°rl Irrj-rirr l~i~ llrr~~ r'e'J<'r<•rtr'e', Il1e' .ti~tr1~.~~lrrrrTiul tt~ri~~lt! r~J~ 11~c' e'i'irlc'rtc~e' ~~~ !he' r~~'c'r~r-rl ,~'Irnrt•,~~ !lrul tlrc' (-r~rtelrlrr~rr _'1 1'hu.~'e° I linri! r~J~?(1 e~rrhie~ r~ur'eL~~ fu'r' ~lut~ r'rJ~~rs in rr r~nrrc~~~itU~ul~~rl ~'nltrltic' c~f~/~r'rx~e.e.~~c'rl nurl~•r•iul !n hr lrrr~~Ice•~l r~JJ srfe~.jr~r firrlh~~r j~rrx~['ssrlr~. 71,c~ "~~r~njr•r~1 " r~•~~re°rre°et h~~ ~I~r l e)h'' rllrrr,~ul~~el rti'e;~rrlti~r 1)re~lrrr-rrlrr»1 r.5~ t{~r .~~rrrur u~~e°rerrl~~rr rrrrrle°rr~rl~rrr i~irrre°rrl~t~ <r! 111r ;1~'rrr~ l~:r-rr ;~Irrrr, Jr~r rr~hrrh all raJ~ rlrr E~r~lrirtr~rl rrrt~rrurrrrrrrlrul rrrr~urrl.~~ rri~e' llre° .~~rurrr. I'hrrc° hrri•e~ hurt rru e~lrrrri,~e~.~~ rryrrirrrr, ~r .~~rrh.ti~rr~rre•rr1, .ti~rrh~~lc•rrrrril~rl ur rtc•rr (•I~;O.-1 rc°r~rrt~ . Perrot ~ e~l~N1r. iV3cycrs• appeal states: .,; ~[~hc E']~tr~nin~~ (`c~r»r>>issi~~iz clicl iiut r~~iuluct a th~~r~~u~~h rc~~ic~4~ ~~i the e~~i~lcncc suhn~ittccl. ~[~hcv acccptecl the asserti~rns of the pre~pen~ents e~l~ the mine as true ~iith no in~c5ti~~ati~~n «1~thcir- honaii~ics.,, ~IYre° 13rjrrr~l uf~ ,5'rrEr~•rr~i.~~urs {rrrs irtrh~~~rrtrlr~rttlr~ r~rt~ie•rr~rr( rrtrcl rr~rt.vr~fc•re•rl 11rc• rt~irlrrrr~r in t{re~ r-e~rurr! rrrt~l Jirrr(.~~ ihui: 111e° nj~rrulnr.~~ Irerr~~~ srrhnlrr~e~e1 t~rrlr<< c•t~irlc°rrc~c~ vJ~~rrrrtr~trllt• r,rr~r~irr, rrrrrrrrr,~ urlit~rlie~.e (us srrrlr rrrlit~ilre°.~~ rrre~ r(e°Jirie°el lrr~ .5'e~rlrr~n '7>> r~/'1~1r .Srrr/iri~e~ 1lirriu~ rrrrel Ile°rhrnrrrlrr»r .~lr~t r~J~ l17?) ill ~Ire• Jnrrrr nJ rrJ/l~lrr~~r1.~~, rrtte~srrrlruir.~~, ~~Irr~lr~~rrr~~h.~~ rrirr( i~n~r~rc•r.~~ rrt rhr ,'~~t~tt~ f:'rrr ~'4li~tr (.ti~c~r .~lttrrr•hn~c~rrt.~~ l!, 1~~ rrtrcl I~13 thrnrr,~~11 131~1~ r~/~1hr Nur11r C'nrltrrrc~rll r1lrrrr{z I?'. _'(N)tti' !'lurlrrrrrg ('r~rnrniti~s~i~~rr .-flrurhrrrc•rrr.,~/. Thc• ,Vc~n• I;r~r :11irr~~ 11u.~~ tllrre°%r~re~ he°~°fi e~~~e°rrrtrrl~~ urr cnr urrrrrrul f~u.ei.r Jrc~trr~e°rrt I JAS'? rnr<< ?lJU7 erirr( here Ilr~! he•e°~~ rrr frlle• .~~luttrs rrs efe~Jrrre~~l 1»~ S'~~rrrnir '?'7.l r~/~tlre• •S'rrr-f~ri~r fllrrrirr,~ uric! Krrl~rrrrrrlinrr .~1r7 r,/ J ~J 7_~. !'dint 4 0l- Mr- 'Vlcycrs- appal slags: "=~. ~l~hcrc is Wert sril•licicnt c~~iclcncc to s~thport the ~lccisi~rn ~~f• the f'lannin~~. (•c~mmissic~i}•„ "i'~re~ l~e~rrref u/~ .ti'rrhe°rrisr~rs bus irr<ft~~x°rrrh~ritlr~ re°r~r~~rr~e~el rrtrcl c•nrr.~~irle're~rl tltr~ rr~rrh~ne~e• irr rlre~ re~c~ur~! rrrl~l Ji~rc(.~~ t{rut Ilr~~ srrh.~~turrliul rr~e°r,lr1 n/~~{ze~ rrrefc~rle~e~ irr thr 1"e'('(ll-(tt .1'~l(Jt1'.1' ~~!(rC i1r<rllll7~r f111e1 ~~e'['ju1)IU11Ul1 ~'e'1'lllll <~1-rl;S u!1(~ !f5 ~~E'e'r'(!1N(rllOlt !'Irrrr ele°srrihr a .,~irh.~~rrrrrlierl e~~rrrulrr~rr nJ~ ~(1,f10(J ?~U.IJU(1 lr~rr.~~ r,r- r~rrlur r~rrrrLe ~rrr 1~e'ur-, e~ur'c'rirt•~ 1~5' u~'r-c'.c, e'rrlillc'~I !u rc'Ilfut'e' ufJ~,~rlr /r~r• frrr'lI1~'r'/rr'urr.~~.~~rrr•~ tr/~ !r~ 'O r•trhir~ t~urel.~~ ~re~r ~Irrt' uj~~rr~rc~sse•rl rrtrcl rrjru•rrrrrrrtrrl nru~rrrul. E'~rint ~ cif VIr. Mcycrs• appeal states: ~. 1~17c l~:n~ irc~nn7ental ]nrpacts c~l•ilris hrcrjert have not been aelclressecl: Pa~;c: >. ~~ ~~i• z~ a. l here is nc, hru~ isi~,n ii,r ('1:(~)1 1-l'l l~•1i. h. i ht it~i~~hhc,rs cc,nr~r-n fi,r tli~• ,hrin~s uticci I~ur ltc,uti~•itc,lci ~~ ,rt~•r It,r~ nc,t hl`Cn a~lclressc~l. ~] he rcyuest~~i tn~i~ntuilicati~,n as tr, the lc,ss ~,I~ this res~,urcc has n«t 1)l'l'll acl~iressc~i. r. 1~hc hcaltll {>f~ llry ('r~~k is n~,t ~ul~lresse~i either in iiuality c,r yu~sntity. cl. 1~~, i~rn~~isic,ns for nc,isc anal ~liist hc,lluti<ut. ~. ~[~ral•lir c,n tlic E'ri~~ate 1Zoac1 that is [)r}' ('reek Iz~,acl is nr,t aciclresse~i." II1~~ c~lu~r~~ll! rti`c•1,~ l~,~ru ~1lr~rc~ n~lc•rutinll r.~~ rr,lt~~~1.~~lrlt! r,~rlh thc~ ~'llilt,~ul~•rl :V~~~«Irt~~• Ik°c~lcrl~rrlrr»t urlr~~ltt'tl rr~i111 rr/,/»'ns~crl r~f~ ;'lli~rir~~ rui~l l~rrlrrluulrr»i 1'c~rnrrt ~ti']-l.i ~. ~h~° ?Vulir'E• r~f~l)~~l~~rll~rrrrrlrn~r Jilrrl ,r~r!!~ rh~~ I3is!!~~ ('rlrr~rl~~ llrr~r»'rlc~r r~lt ?~l~rr' 'f, I t~~ti''. rrlr~l u~rrlr 1lrr l ~)~Y? ('rrltJrlr~llrr l:'Irr~rru~rntrlrtrll Urrrrlirr~ .1 t~r. l7n• .~~r~rr~,r of 1lrr /~t'uj~'r'1 r~ultsirl~'~'~'rl !11 1 t)~S" i,~~ lhc' .~~rrntr rl.t~ lltc' .~~ruj~r uJ~ lhr' ~Irr.er~lt! ntiltilt,; njlrrrrlinll: a hlrrr~rr »tiitrir,~ rl~l~~rrrlirlll rur~hnrr_~~rl hr• its Itc~rl~rlltulrnlt 1'Icllt 1~1 ~lr.~~lrr1~J, hc~lu~rrlt ?(1,(X!(1 to '70,(100 1r)11.1~ ~,r rrlhrr r~urrl.e ~x•r t~rul~ u~ilhr~t thc~ l~5' uc~rr j>ul'c~~'l, ,r~rlh « cart trlt~l c~nl'c'1• ~Ij,/~l•nrlc~{~ jrll• ~'c'rltr~uulintt. 71t~~ jlnf~°Itlt~tl ('!11'!f"lJIII1I('lll(1~ Illlj)(!['I~e !J~ t~?(' ('!!1"!'E'll! ~)~7('1"(l~1I)!1 (!i"(' I1<7(' .1'(!111(' (l.~~ j~IU.S'(' CL111.1'I(~('f'1'(~ fit rhE~ rr~~~lrnt~tr! ~Ir~l~~~~.~~.~~ rli 1{)~ti'1-!I ~~1'?. ~lh~~r~~ lurr~~~ hc~r11 Ilu r~hrnl~~~.~~ r~~rjrrrrr~~~ u .~~trh.~~rc~trr~t~, .~~tr~lhlrntr~lttul nr Irrt,~ (~l.'O.~l rrr~rrr,~ rail{I r~;~urrl 1u lu°i~rhhrlrilt,~~ .~~~Irr~t~r.~~, 1)1•r• ('rc~c~lti ,rulrr yu~llrli~ t~llrl ~Inlltrlrult, ~lrr.,~l ~~nllu~~n~t, rr~rfJic~ nlr 1)1•t~ ('~'e~t'k K~~url, tu' Itnis~~. (,). 'Chc ahhca] c~f~l'lannin~ ('ommissic,n Ilcac,lutic,n US-?=~ by Lucy ('cn,ke (as yur,tcci hcio~w} is n~,t suplx~rtc~3 by substantial c~~iclcncc in the rcc~~rcl hasecl on the fpll(lwtn~~ i11lC11r7~~5; I'c,inl l ol~Ms. ('oc~kc's apheal slates: "1 . ~f~hc liftb `v~~ i [I•.iZI~:11S ~,n ha~c t,nc ~,f lzcs~,iutinn 'vii,. l},~-Z~ is a ntisstatcment. in actuality, the E'iannii~t~ ('t~mr~~issic~ners resc,l~etl in the March 1 } arul f'1i~ri] l[) discussion item G, lrt~c 1O, that tl~e Minim and EZcclamatitm f'crmit Sl-1 ,5 limitation of~ ?(? cubic var~ls rclcrs to ~~rc,ss total ~~c,luiz~c, that is tlati~~~ tt~aterial ~~r~tss, ec~cks, curt, nut a concctitratc~l final ~'c,lumc." i.c stulc~rl i~t 1~71r~(iu~~.~~ .l, h~ ~r~r~l 1, uhuir rr~lrr~~h rlr~~ r~tr~ur/I~~l~rrl~~r! h~~rt~r~r hr~ llrr.~~ rrf ~rr~trr, thr .~~rr11.~~1rllrtr~rl rt~ri,~~ht nJ~ t{I C' ri~irlc~lrr~r rlr rlrr rrr~~~r~f .~~h~lr,~s 11i~r! 111c~ ('nluliliult ?1 1'llu,~~r l lintrl rIJ~?0 rrrhrr t~cu•~1.~~ J~c~r ~lrrr~ I~~~J~~r,r r~l cl c~r,~tc~rlltrtrl~°~l t~nlru~r~• ufJll-r~t~t'.~~s~~rl nrulcriul. Point ? of~Ms. ('ookc's aphcal states: ••~. l he sLCtll ~~' 1 li'.EZI'.r'1S C,ll ha~e l,lle (7l lZl:ti(7llltl(}Il ~[). t)ij-~=~ is a 1tllsstatC[1lCllt. in actuality, the I)clrrrtmet~t ol~l)c~~~clohmcnt ~cr-yiccs (1)l)S) hcc~u~~c ~r~~~~ar-e r,f•tllc 1'a~c 17 ~3f 2~4 hotcntial f~~r r~nc~~ ed ntinint~ a~•li~ its ~~ It~n. in I~tl~ n irtt~r ~'{lft7 K~~[[ l.c~~~.rn c~tnt~ it7t{, I)1)~ t« ash ahuut his ht'rtnit status. ]t7 late Vla~ ?U{17, I)1)~ hcc,u~tL an~ar~• t~l rcnc~~cd activity when aec~i residents came into 1)1)~ t~~ alert UU~ to not just renen~cd activity. but extensive ~~radcd ]ands clcxsreil of vc~~etation. ~l~hrou~~h~utt the suttutter ?ilf}7 there were hhnnc calls to I)1)~ about the unusual and extensive I111IlIIl~~ activity and turbidity in the crc~l:. I h~'5~' dat~:s cc7nic f~r~~nt a It~~; crf- Kcccnt E•:vcnts and (~tn-rent ('ompliance l'rucess hrclru-c~l by 1)1)~ f~~r a n~cctint~ in late winter ~{lU<~ with Ur~~ ('reek (',uryon residettts." " l he date is intlx~rtant because had I)U~ beta hroacti~ c in dcaliti~~ ~~ ith the renewed minim activity, it is likely there would have been an earlier realisation that the ntinc uherators hart been ]resented with an interhrctation of~ l.o~an's hermit that was unreal and that the ohcrators wen intcndin~ an ohcration much ~~ICatel- than that hcrmlttcd h~` Mlillll~ and 1ZCC1al17atl1111 l~la~mlt til-1?S. f1nd, herhahs, the scale of~tl~e oh~rati~~n could have 4~ccn better n~ana~~ccL.. Ih~~ rrrrrrul n~)~•rulinll is c°~ltitl~~cl f>>• ;11r~tiit,~~ ~r~1~1 llc~c~l~r~rtrrli~~~r 1'rr~rrrl ~~' 1- I ; j uirrl r1.e IZ~~rlrrnir~lruir f'l~r~r. 71r~~ c lrrrc°~rr ;~'c•u~ l:'ru ,11i~r~~ r,~)rrrrltr» 7 r-~~ c•r~n1~>I~~rrlt' rr,il,~~rs~lrirl r~~r1h !]ir 111r11~~rr1~°~( :1%c;~rrtrt~r l)E~~•(urrrlrr~ir ~rrlr~~~lrr~ r~~rlh u~~~»~nrrrl ~~J ;lliiirjt•~ uirrl IZrr•lrnn~rlru~r !'rrif~rt ~5'I-I 3~• llrr l~rr•r`ut~rrrlrr~j~ 1'Irnr• <n1~1 u~rfll 1h~~ 1 t)~S'' ( •ultfr~r~tiu l:irt~rrr~~nuc~iatrrl Orrrrlilr~ ."1r•1. ~IYr~~ .~~ruJx~ nJ~ 11rr ~~rujrr! ru~t.~~rrlr~~rrl i~r 1 ~J~S'_' r.~~ t11~~ .~~~rnr~~ u.~~ tlrc~ .ec•n~~r nJ~1hc~ ~~rc~•srirl nti~ti~t,~r u~x~rulir~il: cr ~~lurrr ntitriir~r u~~~°rrrtir~jr ~rrr1{rnrr~i~r1 to rlLsltu-1~ hrttr~r~-~1 jl1.U(1(1 !u '~(1,(IUIJ 1nu.r nl' c•uhrc r•rrr~ls ~~~~i' t~~~rrr rti•i~lull llr~~ l~S' rrr~rt~ ~~rn•~~~~1, u~il{r rr ctrl rnrcl r•ui•~~r ~r~~jtt~r~rrrh /ur rc~rlrrnrulir~rr. Ih~~ j~ntrialr~rl r~tt•irnia»r~~it<<rl rnr~~rrr7s r~J~tltr r•rrrrr~al r~~x~rrrtrr~ir rrrr <<r~~ .~~~r~rrc° u.~~ lltusc~ c•r~ir•~•r~lc°rc~cl i~t thr u~~~~rrn•rrl ~~rr~c~r~•s.~~ in 19<5'l%]9~~?. 7Ytc~rr h~n•c~ h~'c°it Stu rh~ltr~~~s r~~yrri~~i~t,~ cr .ctrl>.~~c~yuc~~rr• ~~ir~~~~lr~nrc~fttul nr ir~~rr~ (•I:U.•1 rc~r•ic°r~• with r~~,~rtt'~l tv itc~i,~=Itha~-ltt,~~ .~'~~rijr,~.~~, 1)rt ('rE~~•k tti~u1~°r r~rrrrlilt~ rrfr~l ~~olltrlin~t. ~ltr.~~1 jir~lltrlrutr• rt•rrJjir• utr l)rt• C'r~~c°h llnrt~l, nr tt~~rsr. ll ~f~hc ahheal E'lat~nin~ ('~~ntmissiou EZesnluti~m t1~-24 by the 1Zrsidenis o1" E3utic Valley and E'aradise (as ~luoted hel~~w) is not suhh~~rtcc[ by substantial evidence in the rccctrd based on the follo~i~in~~ iin~lin~~s: Points 1, 2 and ~ ol~thc 1Zcsidcnts ot~ f3uttc Valle.v and E'aradise's ahhcals state: "l . 1lllowit7~~ the I'rojcct operators tc~ move nwre than ?tl cu. yds. of~ native soil per day fails to comply with ('I•:(1/1... " 2. EZesidcnts ol~ Butte Valley and Paradise who attended the ?fHlh ('ommission hearin~~s rc~ardin,~ the E'rojcci set f~,r[h a nt[mhcr uf~ Bair ar~un~cntti. ~~crhai and written, c~inccrnin~ potential si~nilicani impacts that n~inc oheratic~ns at a level of~ activity ~rcater than tl7e removal of~?f! cu. yds. of nati~~~e soilid~ty would imhosc inn the natural anti man-made cn~'irc}nmcnt of~ the: l)ry (`reek (`anyon area, i.c., streamheil .dtcration, etc. "['here was no reshonse to said lair ar~~un~cnts. I lcnce, k'a~;e 1 R of 24 the (•r~nmtissi~~n~s inth[ic~l cictcrntinaiic~n that an l~:ilZ i~ti nr~l ncccssar~~ try aclclrt'ss thr ~,ticl fair rtr~~rintcnl~ ~ir~l,rtcci ('].Orl.~~ ";. EZcSUltitiiut f}~-?~} clc~c~ nr~t accurately rcilcct the acti~~n tai:cit by the (~r~nuttissi~m rtn ~~hril I [I, ?fJf}ti ~~ .1 ~~ rli.crrr.~~.~~rrl irr !'rtrrliri~.e J• ~~ rrttrl l: rrhr~t~c' Ir~lrir~lr rrrr• irrrnthurrr~r~rl hc~rrirr ht• 1lri~~ rc•frrr•trr•r• lhr'.~~trh.~~irrrrlirr! tit c'1~>Ir! r~J~llrc' t•r'rr~t'rl.~~ltnti'~~ llrrll llrc' (•rlrr~lilirltr _'1 f'Itcr.~~c' 1 Iirtrir r~J 'f) r•uhir' rrrt~rls ~~rr rrtrr rr•/~•r.e 1rr rr r~r~trr~r•rtlrrrrr°rf t~nfrnrrr• ref ~trnr~r~.~•sr~rl nrrrtrrirrl 1u hr Irrrr•Iccr! r~Jf~.eilr. 77tc~ r~rrrrc~trr r~'c'tt' I:ru ~1lirrc° rtEtr~rrrlir~tr Lr r•rmrJ~fr~lr-lt~ r•ntr.cLslr~rrl tr~ith Iltr~ rllili~rrlc'rl :'1'c;~rrllt•c' /h~rlrrrrrriutr crrlr~l~lcrl trillr rrjt~~rr~rul uJ~,llitritr~ utrrl Krrlrrtrrrrlir~tt I'r~t~tttrl ~ti'1-1.;5, llrr .5'rr,~,~c~.~~1rr1 ;1lurlrl Kc°r•Iunrrrtir,rr I'frnr• rnrrl tti~i!!t ~Irc~ l~~1'? ('rrli/i,rttirr 1:rrl•irr~ttrttr~rr~rrl Urrrrlilt~ .~l r•~. l'Irr .~~r r~~~r r~J~ 11rr ~rrujrr 1 r•utr.~~irfrn'rl irr I r1~5? i.~~ llrr .,~rrtrrr~ rrs 1{tr~ .rr~rj~u' rtJ~ !hr• ~~rr.~•rttt nrirtirt,~~ u~~rrrrlir~tr: rr ~~lur~rr nritritr~~ r~~~r't~u!lrttr rrtrthr,ri~r~rl to cli.,~lrrt~l~ he°1rr•r°c~tr 7(1•(1(111 In '~lJ,~llJ(1 lrrrr•, nt• c•rrf7ic• t•rrrcl.5~ f~rr r•c'rrl~ rt~ilhitr llrr I ~S' rrrrr Jrurc•c'l, tr•ith rtrt rrttrl r•rn~r•t• uft/~r'nrrrlt j~tr t-rrlrrtrrrrlrorr. I hr ~~r~lc~rrliul c~tn'irr~rtntc~rrlrr] irrr~urr•Lc nJ~lhc~ r•urrc°rr! r~j~r~rrrlir~rr rrr-r~ thc~ suntr~ cr.~~ 1{tnsc° rutt.~~irJrrc'rl irr 11rr crl~ltrut•rrl ~~r-nrrss iu I r)~S'I/I )~5". l~Ircrc~ Irrrr~c~ he°c~tr ttr, rlrrrrr,~c~.~~ rrrirriritr•~ rr .~~rrh.t~rrjrrrttl, .~~trlthlrturtrlrr! ur trrtti~ C •I:~).~[ r<~t•iru~ tri~lr rr~,~~rrrrl 1u rrc°i~rlrhr~ritr,~ .,•l~ritr~~.ti~, 1)rt' ('rrr°k tt~rllc~r- yrrulilr• urrrl !>r~Ihrrintr• rlrr.~~l l~nllrrlirttr• rrrrJJir• r,tr 1)r-t~ {'r-r~r~l, Iluurl• r,r trni.,~r. Tlrc~ r•rrt•rr°tr1 n~~r~rrrlrutr i.~~ rulillr•rl ht~ t~Iirritr~ rrttrl Kr~r~Irrrrrrrtirtrr !'c~rtttit ~S'I-J 3? rrtrrl it.~~ Itc°r~I[rrrrrrlivtr !'!rrrr. ~. ~I~hc ahhcal cif I'l~rnitin~~ ('ctntntissic~tl Etcsoltrticitl U~-?=1• by Vc~r'tlt ('c~ntittcnt [.~Incl anti 'I~imher, [nc. (CIS yuc~tecl hclo~~~) is suhhortc~l h_v substantial eviclencc in the rec{u~cl haste! ctn the t~~llo~~~in~ finclil~~s: I'c~irtt 1 cif ~Jc~rth ('r~ntinent Last[ and ~I•imhcr, [nt.'s ahhcal states: "l. •I~hc ('«itunissi«it cr-rr~ncc~uslti' clctcr-ntinc~l that Miitint~ ~In~l ]Zcclam~ttion 1'Cl'nlll ~l). ~l-li5 al1C[ the aSSOClatel[ 1ZCCIilnlat[On I'lal~ r"CC[LIII"~' that Illlnln~~ at t11C Nc~'~~ I•:ra Mine he cc~ncluctecl as a hhascxi ol~eratic~n.,. YYrr .S~rrh,~~trrrtlirr! tr~r°i,~It1 uj~llrc~ ct~irlc~trrc° slrrnr•,~~ lltrr! llrrlthrr.~~itr,~ rlr.~~r•rihrrl irr r~littitt, utrrl Kr~rlruuulirjrr 1'c~rttti! ~ti'1-1 ;? t-r~lrrlr.~~ rtttlt• !n t•nlrrtrrrlric• ~~rr~rlrrc•~ir~tr tht-c~.ti•lrnlrl.~•• trnl tittrc°-lxr.rr°cl ur nrirrirr~r-rrrru llrrrshrrlc(.~~. Tlrr rrf7frrr,t•c'rl r1litrirr~ rrttrl Ilc~c~lunurlirttr I'c~rtrril BSI-I i ~ ~~rrrtrt.,~ rr ri,~hr 1rt ul~r°rcrlr cr j~lrrrc'r ~~nlrl trrirrc~ nir 1 ~5' rtr't-c~s n j~.~lssr°.~'_s'nr •.~• 1'rrrr'c~l r'~"r~. fJ-1 !-U~1'(J-f1?7. . L~ slrrlc~rf irr 1.7rrrlirr~s .I• ~~ rrtrrl I, rrhvt c° rr~lurh rrrc~ itrrr~r7~r~rcrfc~rf hc~rcitr ht• !lri.~ rc~lcv~c~rtr•c~, t1rc~ ('r~trrlilirtrr '1 I'ltrr.er I linril rrllnrr~s 11rr~ l~rrx•r~.~~.~•itr~ n/~rrh to ?fl c~trhir ~~rrr-rl.ti• Erc~r r(rrt' of c•ntrc•r~trtt•rrlc~rl trrutc~riul to hc° ~~Irii~~rrcl nJfi•itc~ jut• Jirrtlrrt• ltrr~rr~.e.~~irr~r irr r,~lric•Ir tlrc~ ~nlr! i.~~ tlrc~tt sr'fxn~rrtc'rl /i•ntrr tlrc° hlrrch .~~uttrls. IJ~ rlrr~ rlrrilt' f~rnrhrr•~rotr nJ rvtrrrc°rrlrrrlcr! ttrrrlr~r-irrl Ir-rrr•&rrl a%J-.cilr~ c°.~r•r~c°rls ~U r~rrhir~ t~urrlc tic-r rlrn'. tlrc~tr Na~c 19 of 24 1'l~rnairr~~> ('unlnai.~~.~~rnar r~~r~r~,ir- Ina- 1']irr.cc° I1 i,~~ rt~tfarirc~rl. 7'11~~ ,1~~t'ir I~:i-rr ;1/irtt~ i.~~ l1n1 ~,lrt~rti~raa,~~ r~r ~'rt~c's~~ nJ~rl~t° l'larr.,~r l '!1 rrahir ti~urtl lin~r~. I'uint _' o#~N~~rth ('tn~tincnt l.ancl anal I inrher, ]nc.'.5 appeal stat~5: ..~. ~I~h~• ('onin~ission erroncnusl~~ ~letcrminccl that ('oncliti«n ~ 1 0l~ th~• Minin~~ i~efm]L rrli:rs to a ~r~>ss total ~~~~lun~c ol~ clisturh~~i t>n--tiitc urrtcrial, nnl a e~~nccntrale~l ~~iilurtre ul~pr~~cesse~l s~;~~lcl-h~arirt~~ c~r~ t~~ he 5liihp~~l ~,11~it~ ~. ~~.~~ .~~Irrlrrl rar 1~'iirrlirr,~.e ,l, Iv rrnrl 1, uhni'c' rr'Irn'Ir tra~c' raat~nrhnrtalc~t( lrrrrraa 1>>• !{~r~~~ rrJ~~rt~fr~~r, rlrt~ 13urrf-r] nJ~,S'aal~c°rr~L~~na-,e JintL~~ lhrrl C'nartlrlrnn '1 1'hu.~~c° I linril n/~'~1 r'trl~rr t'ua'rls lu~~' tlrn' I't'J<'I'S 1~~ tr c'naat't'arla'ralt'r( i'nltantt~ nJ~~~a-nr'c~~~~'t'rl ~~nlrl-hc'ua-rat~> hltark .~~rtarrlti~ lu fx~ shi~~~~rr! uJJ.~~rtr Jnr /irr!]ic°r ~~rnrrssiat~r r1r ti•larrh 1hc° ~rnhl r.,~ ~~c'l>crrult~tl fi•niai rlac~ hlrrt~lr .~~trntl.~~. 7~hr a~'rrr~ I:r~r ,1lrarr Itc~rltraatrrlrnar 1'lrui .S~trrlr'.ti~ tlrrrr 1lrt~ aniariar~~ n~>rrulrnaa u~rll hr ~l),(1lJ(1 _'111, 1J{J(1 lrn~.~~ nr r~rrf~ir r~rrf-tl.v ~~rr ~ c~trr. rllraain~r trntl Kt~t~luaaaulrnir /'c-rnlil ~S'I-1 ~1 .,~ltrfr.~~ Ilarrl nlrnrn,~~ nhc°rtrrinaa.~~ rril! !~c° Irnarlc~tl 1n 'l1 t~aahrt~ r•trrtL~~ ~x°r rlur~. ~l~lat~.~~t• Iiauitulinaas urr ~tr~1 i~rrn~lsLrlt~itl, ra.e tltc° llt~rlunrutruaa !'(uaa rt°Ji~a-.~~ In 1n1uI tlrslrra-htnrrt~ trim( Alrnrai~ rrartl l~t~rlranarrlrraar !'t~rnur ~ti'1-1_~1 rrJi~i-.~~ !~, r~r~arr~c~~atrrrlt~rl nrtalrrrtrlln hr nrnr~rtl t,/J~;~rlr J~»' Jtn'~I1t'rhrnt~r.c.~~in~. Point ; of North ('ontir7ctlt land anti ~I~imhcr. [rte.'s ahhral states: "~. the ('ommission c:rroncously louncl that the current lc~cl of~ohcrution at the Neu E~:ra :~1inc cxccctis ?(1 cubic yarcls her clay total clisturhancc anti tl}c mint uE~cratar is thcrclorc in ~~ialation of('onclition 21 al-tile Uiininti~ Pcrntit." .~1.~~ .ti~ltrfrtl rrr 1~7aulrn~.~~ .I, A- rrntl 1, trhnt~r tirlrrch tu-c° rjirrn j~nrtrlrtl lac~a•c~nt h~~ 1lai.,~ rt~J~~rc~nrt~, ~lar .~~rah,,~lu~aliul rr•c~r~rh~ nJ~11ac~ ri~itlc~aac~c~ iaa tlrt~ rc•rnrtl th•ntnn.~~trrrtt-.~~ Iltrrl (-njttl~tintt :Vn. 'l a'c~j~~a•.~~ to l~a~nc~t~.r.et'cl crattl c~nnc~t~~tlrtrlt~rl nrult•rrul (~nlrl-hctariar~ f~lcrrh strntL,~/ !n 6c' atint~t~rl njJ=.c!!t' fnr./rra-llarr ~~ru[r_e.~~ln,~~, a1~'n ri~rr(t~arrc ]trrs he°t~it /~~'c'st'aalt'rl 11au1 ;y't'tr~ l;~'tr ;lltnc lrtrs~ c'1'c'1' u~x'a'tllt'rl rya c'.~~rt'.~~.~~ nJ~ rlrt~ _'(~ t'trhrr r~ui-rl.e ~x~r rlrn~ linairrrlinaa nf~l~rnc~c°.~~.~~rtl antrtc~rirrl (~•nnc•t~ialrrrtt~l rrnrnr~rrl Jinni thr .~~llc~, jrnr r(nc°.~~ rl .ti~ttrtc° rrar~~ jn-c~~~rart raatc°atlrn~i In al~~ .~~rr. Paint 4 of North ('ontinent [.anti anti 'l'imber, [nt.'s al}heal starts: "~k. "[~he Commission erroneously found the scope of-the current aheration at Ne~~~ E~:ra iVline has substantially ~lcviatccl fi-ot~r the ahhrc~~~c~l Ulinin~, Pcr-mit anti Rcclamatian Plan anti that, as a result, am~n~lmcnt oi~ the Ilcclamation i'lan ~~~as rc:cluirecl uncicr the ~urf~acc 1~inin~~ anti IZcclan~ation r'1ct ("~1~;1K:~1") anti i3uttc ('aunty (`otlc ('hahtcr 1 `~ „ lht~ rrj~ha-n~~rtf Ilc~r~Irmau~rnat 1'lrraa (hrt,~rr.c 1'-IBS' nJ~11tt° r1lrrrrh 1.;, ?(1~1~ti' 1'luiaaaiaa,r ('nnrnir.~~.~~in~r : fllrrr~lrn~r~rt.c1 .S~Ita1c°.~~ Clan f~~llnrr~rn~> j-c~~trrtfrjr~> rrrlcrnaurinir nJ~rlar Nc~rr• F.r~u ;'l~lrarr .citt~: Pa~;r 20 ~~f 24 • I'hr tulul crr-c~rr trl hr rrrlrtlntrcl (Itrnt~c ~~' rrrtrl _"J ircrc 1cr hc~ 1 ~5' rrr~rc~~~: crtrcl • 7Ytr <~~~tittrrrtrrl IrJr r~J~thr u~,rrrrtiutt (Itr°nt l-J1 rtcr.~~ ?fl try 1 U(1 1~rrrt:~~; thr crtttrucrl rrntrtrrttt uf~nrrrtrt~rrrl ntut~rrl ~Itrnt 1(1 tti~rr.~~ to Ix' ?~1,f1U(t try ~?(1,(1O(11c~tt.~~ car rrrhrr ~ crt•cl.~ l~rr; uttcl • I7tr tttu.tinrtrttt crtrtirij~rrtr~! clrlttlr (lrrtlt ! ~ l r.. lllfl J~~rt; ~rttcl • Thr turttitt~r ttrrtltr~cl (ltrttt I ~S') rr~u.,~ to hr sitr,~lc' l>rttrlr i~~rth turlirt,~~.~~ ~x~ttrl rrrtrl ~rrrti'rl hcrr .ti~lcintntitt,~. crtrcl ~ 'lYtr rrltrntcttr ~~ln~.~~irrrl r•uttclrtiutt rr~trt- rrrlcrntrrtrutr ii~rr.c .etcrtc'cl crs "ri~r u~uttt 1u ~~trt 1{tc~ Irrttrl lurk rrrtrl ~~lrrttt trrtti~~r trt rrrrrt. '~ ~Lr a~tcrtrcl uhor'r Ott l~-ittclitt,~r J ittrnt~~urcrtc•rl Itrt'rrttct/tc°r- 1>r~ thi.~~ t-~~/i~t-rttrc~, ul tlrc :~Ictrc~It 1.3. ?~1U~4 13ncrtzl rtJ~,S'u~~rrt~isot-s ' llruritt,~ Ihr :~1'rrr• l~:rcr tllirtc° rtt,~rttrc'r. l~r~tr U(.~~rtr of Ilr~lr(rc,~r crtrcl I`~rrll, trstrJirrl tltcrt 1hr c~rrt crtrcl rr~r~rr rrr]ctttlrrtrult crh~trr,rrrh ii~r~trlcl hr trtili_rrr` !u t~r-rut11u1fI' !!t c' .~~ilr to tOrr ~tt'r~ntrttr .~~(r~lx' Jrtt• rrrc'lt rtrrcr us tttrttrtt~~ r.~~ runt~~lrtrrl. ~l'r~ rusru•r that the' Irtttit nJ~?i(1,11U(J 1c~tt,,~ nr colic l~cn•cls ltrr 4•c'ctr i.5~ Jtnf r_~~rrrclrrl, tltr l k~~tut-tntrttt r~J~ l h•r'r!«hrttcttt .5'rrr'~rrs .~~Itull ruttclrtrt rrtt crtrtttrrrl itts~tc°rtrurt j~rr 13trttr ('rtrrtrtr ('nrlr ,S'rrtintt l3-ll?(cr1 crtrcl .S'rc~trutt ?77-JIh) uj~ t{rr l'rrhlrr IZr.~~nrrt~rr.~~ ('r~rlr crtrcl r~rrrJi~ tlrr rrtttrrrcr! rrtttutrttt uJ~ clr.~~tut~luntrr 1>>~ ntrrrtt.~~ rtJ~ rr i~c~lrrttrrtrrr crs.ec~~~stttrtrt (rrt-rrt clr.ti~trrrlrcl ntrrltrhlrrrl hr• rt.~~ r(rltthl. "17tr littrrttr~icrl rr.~~.~~trrutrrr rr~.~~t c'strturrtc~ nJ~,1'f 7,~1 !. ;~~, ~~rr~~rrt-rrl 1~~~ llulclrr~rc' rrrtrl h'trl! (.Ittcarlttttrtrt .1" rt/~thr ,'~`rtt-th t'ntrlrtrc'rtt !,crtrcl crtrcl 1 inrhrr crttcrrhtttc~ttt.~~ Jur thc~ 1lcrrrlt I ;, ?(JIJ~~ l'luttttitt,~~ (~nnttur.~~-,~lnlt hc'uritr~,t, {tu.~~ hc'c~tt crj~ltrc~rc~cl lt' lr,th I3trttr {'c~rrtrtl~ cntcf Ihr (~JJrrr nJ~~M1l~ur l~rrluntutrort crtrcl jtrut~ic(rs .~~itr ~~Icrtr.~~ shuic~rtt,~r {tcni~ rctc~h rrrrrr titi~111 hr rc°-rrttttnrrrrcl crJlrr nrrtritr~ i.~~ rr~ur~tlrtrrl. l'!tr Ilu]r(rc,~r rrrtrl h-rrll rest r.~7intrrtc• ul.~~u rlc~.~~rt•Ihr.~~ rc'1tlrrttUtl~ ntr tltr .S~itr rtltc! rr ntrtttrtrtt-rtt,~r jrrrirtcl uj~trr~ct r~rcrt•s trt itt.ti~trt-r tltcrt rrltlrrtttitr, i.~• srrc•rc's.,'lrrl. .-I~~~~rcn•crl r~J~thr rns~t rs~trttrcur crJjirttt.,~ tltcrt` thc~ rtrt•rc'trt c~ltc~rcrtiutt rr~rll hr rrr~lrtrrttc~c! rtt rrrrc~rclrrttrc° rti~ith tTtc~ Ilc~rlutttcrtrntr I'Icrtt. r1''r~ -5~trh.~tcrrttirr! clc°i~icrtic,tt /rtr-~~ nc~r~rrrrc~cl. -f-. E']annin~ ('os»missi~~n Resolution t)i3-?4 and the Ilc~~isetl On{cr '[~o ('omhl_v fZccluirin~ ,~ Revisal Minim Pcrn~it, Rcclamatic~n flan anti E~inancial I\ssurancc Mcchanisn~ [i~ -[hc Matter OI~~fi~c New t~ra Mine arc rnit suhhortccl by suhst~ultial c~~i+.lcncc i» the rccc~rcL Rcsalutiurl O5-?4 clctcrniincci that Minim and ReclarZ~ation Pcr'mit N~~. 51-135 must he amcndc~l lor- the f~~llowin~ reasons: "l. ('onclition ?l t~f Minin~~ anti IZecEam~rtic~n E'eriZ~it ~~l-1 ~~ states: `Minin~~ ohcratitm to he limitccl to a iz~a~imum ~~[-?O cubic yards her play «~ith suhscyucnt review hy' tllc Planninti~ ('c~mmissiun I~ir hrc~h~~sccl cxhaiisiun to Phase [1." 'Vo such suhsc~lucnt rcvic~~~ by the Planning ('ommissiou was cvcr hulci." Pa~;c 21 of 24 f.t~ ~~1(rl~~~I rfr 1~'ifrrlifr,~~~~ J, ~~ ~rfr~l 1, rrhut'(' tii~lri(~I1 rrr~- i!r(~nr~fnr(11('rl lr(~r(~ifr !>i tlti~ f•('J~'!~('frr(', lh(' .,~r1lz~~7(frrli(rl ti'('i,~rlfl nJ~11r(' ('r'irl(~ft(~(~ ~~1lnrti~~~~ lh~r! 1ir(- jilrrf.eift~ rl(~.e(~rif>~~r~ r!f 11ilrilr,~ clfrrl K(•rlruurrrinrr 1'(~f~flrif ,ti'1-l.i ~ r(~I(r1(~.~~ uult~ !u r~r,Irfnrr!!-i(' /lrrf((tl(~!!r»r !1!r('.~~{Irfl(ls, llrfl life('-hrrs('(l rff~ nlifuir,~~-x11'('(1 llrf'('.ti~lrnlrl.~~. ('flflrlilir~n ;b~n_ ~l rrJr1:~~ trf j~r~u~~~.e.errl lfrrrfrri~rl 1r, hr nrr~r(~r1 n~fti~l!(' Jru' Ji1f'lhf~f' /ff'ur'r,5~.~~ifr~. ;~~`n ('1'i(l('frr'(' hr1.~~ 1~(~rrr /~f~r°.S~r'lrfr'(I 1irul rti'('ii~ 1':f-rr ;1lifrr f'1(1.~~ ('i'('r u~~c~r(r1(~rl ifr c'.rc~('e.~~ rfJ~llr(' '~l rrrl7ir r'(rr(l.c nJ~7~rrx'r.,~~~(~(1 ftrrrlrriul7!(~r (lug' li»fiirrli(ffr, ftnl' (In(~s it s!(r!(' u1r4'~~!'(~.~~(~ftl i11Ic~Jtllnft fn (/n .~~n. .1 srrh~(~(jrr(~frl I'lufrfrifr~~ (~~,fului.~~.~~i~,fr r(~r~iru~ Jrff' rr ~frnjfns(~(1 rs~xursrr~u In I'Ircf.~~(~ ]I r.ti~ llrN ftr((~ssrlf'1' (1.~~ Ihr :~l~~~rr 7~:!•r1 ;~1rft(~ r~~x~rulrn!! 11u.~~ !ln1, (n1(I is lfr~l, c_r('(~(~(Irlt~ lIr(° l'hcf.~~(~ 1 ~(1 r~rfhr(' 1~(ff~r(c ~~(~r rlul~ Iinril JUf- nl(rlc~rrul !u f~(~ lf-rr('k(~(l r~J/,i'il(°. "~. l~hc scr,hc uf~ the current c~f~cratiurl has suhstai~tially (le~~i.rtcci, as ~icfirictl by {'ulif~~ruia ('cxi~ rii~ fZct~ulatirins (('('fZ) ~I~itl~; l4, ('htihicr ~~, llrticl~ I, ~ccti~~u ~~{1?(ci), fi-uru the ~~i~cr~rti~~n hcrrnitte~l by Viiniii~~ ~~ncl Itcclan~trtic~n f'cr'mit ~1-l?~ ar~(l is in ~~iolatinn ~~f E~utte ('~~uiity ('~x€c ~ccti~~n 1 3- l I i " "~. ~l he scc~pc cif the current c~hcratic~t7 has substantially clcviatc(i f-rc~n~ the ~~herati~~n i~crmittc~i by 1~~1inin~~ rnttj llccl~rmatir~n E'cr-ii~it <~ l - I ~5 an{l is iil ~~i~~l~rti~~i~ cif-('('1l Sccti~~n 35t1?(~l) " 7Yrr uh~~rn~~(~rl Krr~l(fffrulrufr f'i(ffr (Ifrr~rs~ 1_'-1~5' nJ~llrc~ ;11(frr{t i3. _'Oll<S f'lrrfrfrifr,~r C~nfllfrris'.~~ivff .-11tuc~lrflrc°frl.~~l .~1(ftc~.,' lIr(~ Jnllnrr~rfl~ rc~~ur(lifr~ r(-rl(nlrulinu rr/~th(~ 1~~(~tir~ ~ 711 c' lr~tul ol'e'o to hc' 1•c'('luiflt('(1 fllc'nr,,' ~5' (fful _'_') 1t~(1.~~ !n h(~ l~5' u('f'c'.~~: uftcl • Ih(~ (~slilrr(r1(°r~lffi~ of !Ir(~ a~~(°r(rlrr~fr (I!(~ftr 1-1} ir'rr~' ?111u IUII r'(~rrra',~ llr(~ (lftfrtrul (fnrr~ulrl of nrrllrrirr! nrvr~r(I (l1(°nr I ~) trus Jv hc~ 5U, l1Uf) to ?~l1,UllU !r~lr.~~ ur (~rrlu(' ~ rrr(l~~ ~~c~r; rrrr(I • 711c~ ffru.~~inrrufr (rfrlic'i~~(rlrc(c1c~~~111 fltc~ffr l7) is I OlJ jE~rt; ufr(! • 7Yr(' nrifrilr,~ !rf(~t~rrx( ~l1('!u IBS') tr(r.~~ !v lu' .~~lfr~l(° h(~fr('lr rr~rllr trrilili~,~~ ~~ufrrl (rfr(l til"(11'('j 7(11' .1'~ifl11N11ir~~: lUl(t `llrr rrltrnullc~ 7~Irr.~~irul rr~l1((ilrr~fr uJlc'r rrrl(rlrur1rn11 rr~(r.~~ .,~1urc~cl us~ "rr~c~ tir'ufrl !n 1>rr1 thr lufl(l Iur('1~ (r!r(1 ~~l(r!r! frutir~r t(~ urc~u. " ,~L~~ rJr.~~r'rf.~~.e(>(I rfr I~ifrJifr~ :r4~1 rrhur~(~. llrr r•rrrr(~!a! 1~`rrr' l~;rrr ;llrfrc~ (~J~c•rutrnrr tir~rll hr rrc'i(frnrr(( urrur(li1r~> !(~ 11rr u~~l3rr~ti~rrl .S'rr~>,~r.ti'!r(1 ;M1lur(c~l l~c~c~l(rnlrr1ru11 I'l(1f1: f'c°- c~(~frtollrifr,, rfJ~tlrr sil(~ rr~illr frutrr~e ~~l(nrlifr~. I'~rrrllrrr, 11rr Jifrufrrr(rl rr.ti~srrruftrr rusl r.~~lrffrrffr u/ ,5 ~(f7,-71 !. ?~, j~ry>urr(1 hr' ll~~l(lrr~>r (rful h'rrll (, trt(rc~lrfurlrt .1' u/~ ll1c~ r~~r~f•1lf ('nff~ilrc~rlr I,rrfrcl (rful 7~rnfhrl' ulluc'Irfu(~frts Jr,1- llfc~ ,'llrrrc'lf 1 ~, 'f1(1~1' l'1(r1rlrrfl~ ('nnr!lrissrolr 11(~rrriu~), hrr.~~ h(~(~fr rrjl~~rnt'(~rj hr' bulb I~rr!!(° ('r~rnfll' ufrrl lIr(° UjJir(~ n/~;11ifr(~ R(~r~lrrnrrrtivfl (rfrrl7~rr~ti~irlr°.~~ ,crtc ~~lrrfrs~ .~~Irr~rr~rfr,~ {Ir,u' (°ur•{r (rr(~(r mill hr rr-r•rffllurrrrrl rrJirr nrifrifr~ r.~~ ('r~nr~~lrtrrl, i'.~~;r 22 ui' 2~t rrrrc~ rl~~srf~lh~~s r~~~~l~r~rli~r~~ nfr lhr sr1e~ crud ~r nrrntrrnrr~t~~ ~~E°rirnl r~/ t;~~r~ r~E~crr.~~ lr~ 117.~~!!rC 11tU! f"['/~Irritff~t~ Le .ellr~r'C.~'.~'~tr]_ .~1~1~~rurYr~ rif i11~' l~n,~~i <'.~'11~f1rl1C r11~1~'~7i.~~ 1{h!! 1~1C rtrrir»r u~~rrulir~jl ~i~rll ix~ ~~E~r~lruntE~rl !i1 rrr~~r~~~rlrnrrr u~r111 ~/r~~ lzrrl~rntrrrin~t l'Jrrir. tiO~~1'. 1-IIl~1lE~:l~OIZf:. 1~1~ f~l~ Ezl~:~tiOI.Vl~if). hasc~l inn th~~ lin~lin~~s set f<~rth ah~,~~c. that the 13u,u-il cal-~uhcr~ isc~rs: I. I}cnius the ahhcals c~E- I'I,~nnin~~ ('untntis~i~>n lZ~sr~luti~~n tl~-?~ h_v fZich;~r~l i~t~~_~~rti, [.tic~_~ ('o~~kr ~rn~l the Ilcsicicnts ~~i~ Butte V~rllcv anal f';sra~lise. IL (;runts tl~c ahheal ~~I i'l;ritnirtt~ (~~~ntrni5si«it EZ~s~~lritinn {1~-?~ h~- i~c~rtl~ ('~~ittincni [,;~sr~l and l inther, Inc. 1[I. I)ctcrnriitcs that Vlinin<~ and Kcclantatic~n I'l'l~[ltlt ~]-l ;j ;uul the Eleclamaticm Plan arc ~ alicl entitlements. IV. I)etermincs th~st the crirrcnt i~'c~~~ E~.r;r Mine ~}hcratii~n is in c~~nthliancc ~~~itlt the sei~hc «I the Minin~~ ;rnci IZccl;un~rtion E'ermit ~l-l~ti, its IZeclant;rti~~n Nl,rn, ,rn~l their ~rtle~hlccl tilili~atecl l~~c~ati~~c Declaration anal Eilccl i~c~tice cal-Ihtcrmination. V. IZescincl5 E']aitnin~~ ('on~ntission Ilcsolutic~n t7ti-?~ ~rn~l the llc~~isecl Orcier ~I~~~ ('amply IZcyuirinti r~ IZc~isc~l tilinin~ Permit, EZeclaitu~tion Ilan sncl financial ~'lssuruncc '~Tcchanism ]n ~I~hc '~lattcr Of-~[-hc New f~:ra 'Vtinc. VL llirects the 13uttc ('~~unty Deharln~cnt of~ l)e~~elu}~ment ~er~~tces to eerily that :~Jc~ti l:ra '~}ine ~~her~~ti~~n continncs try he in compliance «~ith its hermit anal recl;rmati~~n hl~rn thron~lt the f~tllowins~: 1. Suhntissirm by the oher~rtors uf~ monthly truckin~~; ru<niiicsts t~~ the [)eh;rrtntent ref I)eti~clohmcnt ~er-~~ices cietailin~~ the number of h~n-rcls of- hrucessecl black sands in order to verif-y compliance Frith Minim and Reclamation I'crmit ('onclition 21, a ntaxintum uf~?(1 cubic y~rr~ls her clay oi-conc~ntratc~l itratcrial to he trrFCkccl ol~f=sitc- ?. "[~hc Department ol- Dc~~clopmcnt Services shall conduct annual inspcctirnts per 13uttc ('aunty C'o~lc Section l3-l k?(a) anc! SM,~1R;1 Section ??7~3(h) .utcl ~~erify, by mcaits of a ~oluntetric asscssmeitt (area clisturhecl multihlieel by its depth), that the annual limit c71 clisturhancc of ?Sf),[)fl(l tens or cubic yur~ls per year is not excec~iecl. P;3~e 23 of 24 ])1 ~I.l' k':1Stif~:I) :1V~I) :AI)OI'~I~f~:I) this ~~~' clay ~>I' ,1us'u~t. ?fx7ti. h~~ the I~«Il~ni~in~~ ~~r~tt: 1Y1~:~: ~ul~~r~itic~rti ('«iii7~~11~_ ~'~u~~.st~u~l~i. ~ui~j ('I7,iir~.fr~;ia~~~i1 \(}1~:5; ~uhcr~iti~rr'ti U~~I~u1 an~i kirk :~13ti1:\ 1 : '~c~i~c .113 l :\[\: \cit~~r r] ; { lrr"l .I(1.1]iL~SC'1~. ( ]loll' 13ull~ (~~~ui~t~ 13~~ar~l t~l ~uhcr~ i~nrti .\I II.~I: ('. Brian Eia~idix, ~'hi~i~\~in~ir~istrati~~~ Ol~~ic~r <~nd (']rrk ~~f`thc ~3~~ur~i'~rl~Suh~r'~ititu'~ F l~l'13~11~~ ! )I~ii~C Z-~ Ut ~~