Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout81-182~ Resolution No. R~SOLUTION RESCINING RESOLUTIONS 78-9a AND 78-I39, 'WHICF~ RESOLUTIONS ADOP'FED REVISED ENVIgONMENTAL REVIE[~7 GUID~L~NES, 12ESCINDING RESOLUTTON 79-209, W~iICH ~t~SOLUTION ESTASLISHED FILING FEES FOR ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW, ADOPT NEW ENVIRONMENTAL 12EVIE~d GUIDELINES AND ESTABLZSH NETn~ FILING FEES FOR ~NVIRONP2ENTAL REVIEt~~ WHEREAS, on r4ay 9, 1978, the Sut~e County Board of Super- visors adopted Resolution 78-90, which resolution adopted revised ~n.vironmental Review Guidelines; and WHEREAS, on August Z5, 1978, the Sutte County Board of Supervisors adopted Reso~ution 78-134 atnending Resolution 78-90; and WHEREAS, on October 2, 1979, the Butte County Board of Supervisors adopted Resolution 79-209, which resolution established £zl.ing fees for Environmental Review; and G7HER~,A.S, these revised Environmental Review Guidelines are mandated by State Law; and W~T~~AS, in order to provide for such increased sErvices and ta compensate fox cost increases due to inflation, it is necessary to establish new fees. NOW, TEiEREFORE, BE IT RF.SOLVED by the Board o~ Supervisors that the revised Environu~ental Review Guidelines, attached hereto as Exhibi~ "A", a~e hezeby adopted. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the filing fees as set forth in Exhibit "A" shall become effective two wee~Ec.s from the date of the adoption of this resolution. BE IT FURTI3ER RESOLVED Chat Resol.uti.on Nos. 78-90, 78-139 and 79-209 are he~eby ~'esci.nded. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Butte County Board of Supervisors this ~th day of August , Zg81, by tne ~nllowing vote: AYES: Supervisors Dolan, Saraceni, Wheeler and Chairman Moseley NOES : None ABSENT: Supervisor Lemke NOT VOTING: None ERTI~ M SEL , a' an o t Board of Supervisors ATTEST: CLARK A. NEL54N, County•Clerk/kZecorder and ex-officio erk of the Board By ~~p.~.dA~Q ~ ~ ~ (~ ° ~ ~ 2. COUNTY OF B~TTE PR~CED~RES ~OR IMP~EM~vTATION QF CALIFORi~IA ENVI~ONi~ENTAL ~~ALI~Y ACT OF 1970 ~ 1. O~JECTIVES The objectives of these p~oc~dures are ~a implement the Californaa Environ~en~al Qual~ty Act of I974 (CEQA) as am~nded and to ens~re that consi~eration is given to the environmental effects of projects which are s~bject ta CEQA. An Enviro~mental Impact Report (ETR) is an in~ormational documenC which, when fully prepared in accordance with CEQA and these Guidelines, wi11 inform ~~blic de~ision-makers and th~ gene~al public of the significant e~vironmen~al effects of projects t~ey propose to carry out or appra~e. The informatio~ in an EIR consritutes evidence that a public agency shall consider along with any other information which may be prasen~ed to the agency. While CEQA requi~es that major ~onsi~eration be gi~~n ta preventing environ- menCal damage, it is recognized tha~ public agencies have obliga- tions to balance other public objectives, including e~onomic and social factors Zn determining whether and how a project should be a~p~oved. ~conomic intormation maq be included in an EIR a~ may be p~esented in whatever form ~he agency desires. T~e County retains i~s exis~ing authority ta balance environmEntal objectives with economic and social objectives and to weigh the variaus long-term and shortWterm costs and benefi~s of a proj~ct in making the decision Co apprav~ ar disapprove it. 2. GENERAL PROVISIONS The reguiations contai~ed in Tit1e 1~, Division b, Chagte~ 3 of Che California Adminzstrative Code are hereby inco~porated by ~eference as if seC out in fu~l and snatl be ~~~L~~abi~, exc~p~ as modified herein, to thes~ p~ocedures. 3. E~ERGENCY PROJEC~S The followxng emergency projects are exempt ~rom the requirements of CEQA, and ~o ~~R is required. (a) Projects undertaken, carried o~t, or approved by a public agency to maintain, repair, r~store, demolish ar replace pro~er~y ar facilities aamaged ar destrayed as a result o£ a~isaster in a d~sast~r stricken area in which a state of emergency has b~~n proclaimed by the Governar p~rsuant to Chapter 7(com~encing with §$550) of Division 1, Title 2 of the Government Code. (b} Emergency repa~rs to public service fa~ili~ies necessary to maintazn serviCe. -2- (c) Projects ~ndertaken as immediate action necessa~y to gr~vent or mitigate an emergency. ~. PRIVA~E PR~~ECTS; E~VIR4NMENTAL REV~EW ~ROC~DURES Wh~n applicatian is made to the County of Butte, or any department rhereof, as Che Lead Agency, for a~proval of a private project (as defined in 1~ California Administrativ~ Code §15937(a} (2) and (3) and ~15062} the following praceaures sha~i be followed in accordan~e with the flow char~ attached hereta as Appendix M. The appli~ation sha~l be ac~ompanied by a fee as established pursuant to resolu~ion of the Board of 5upervisors. (Initial Action) A. The depar~ment with which ~he appiication has been f~le~ sha~l forward the application ~o ~he ERC (EnvironmenCal Review Coordinator) for a determination as to whether t~e application is for a ministerial activi~y or ~or an activity q~al~~y~ing for a ca~egorical exemption, which activ~ties and exemptians are listed on attached Appendix B. It the ap~lication is for a minis~erial activity or an ac~ivity whiC~ is ca~egoricaltiy exempC, no environmenta~ report (EIR) i~s required, and regular processing o~ Che ap~~icaCion may con~inu~ without fur~her environmen~al review p~rsuan~ to these procedures; the applicanC or department shal~ file a notice of ex~mption wi~h the County C1er~ in t~e form provid~d as Appendix A. B. If t~e p~oject is de~ermined na~ to be minis~erial or exempt, the ~xC shail candUCt an initial study to determ~ne if the projec~ may have a s~gnificant effect on ~he environmen~. In making such study, the ERC sha~1 prepare a written determinatian in the for~ attached as Ap~endix F. The ERC shall require the applicant ~o fi~e and sub~it data and information in the form attached as Appendix E, may request comm~nts fram aff~cted County departments ar other governm~n~ agencies and may make field inspections, as necessary, to make this d~termination. P~ior to de~ermining whether a Negative Declaratian or Environmental ~mpacr Report~is required for a praject, the Lead Agency shall consult with all Responsxble Agencies. This first step o~ consu~~ation may be ~o~e quick~y and informa~ly. i~ any of the effects of a p~oject may have substantial adverse impact on the environment, regardless of whether the overall effect of the project is adverse or beneficiaL, then an EIR must b~ prepared. C. If iC is de~ermined that the project could have a significant effect an t~e enviranment and an EIR is req~ired, ~he app~icant wil~ be notifi~d in writing. If the app~icant wishes to protest this d~~ermination, he may file a written pratest specifying the reasons therefor with ~he ERC wi~hin 15 days from the date the not~ice o~ the determination was gi~en or mailed to him. If no wtitten protest is t~mely filed, an EIR wil~ be required. -3- D. If a written prot~st is timely ~i~ed, a hearing regarding the determination shall be heLd in the same manner as pro~ided in Pa~agraph G by the decision-making bo~y. E. If the decision-making body determines tha~ the , project may have a signifiCant effect on the e~vironment, and an EIR is xequired, the de~ision becomes finaL. If the decision-making body determines that the project will not have a significant ef~ect on the environment, the ERC shali prepar~ a Negative Declara~ion in the form attac~ed hereCo as Appendix G. {Negative Declara~ion and ~rotests) ~. If a de~ermination ~s made tha~ ~he projec~ wiil not have a significant eftect on the environment, ~he ERC sha~l pzepare or have prepared, a Negative Dec~ara~ion in the form attached hereto as Appendix G. The Negative Declara~ion sha~1 be c~mpleted wit~in 30 days from ~he date of the d~termination by the EkC and ~n any cas~, adopted wiChin 1~5 days from the date of receipt of the compieted application. G. 1. Notice of the preparation o~ Che Negati~e DeclaraCion sha11 be provided to the public within a reasonable period of time prior to the fina~ adop~~on by the d~cisian-making bady of the Nega~ive Declaration. No~ice shal~ be given to a1~ arganizations and in~iv~duals who have previous~y reques~ed such notice and shall also be given bq at least ane of the fo~lowing procedures: a. Publication, no fewer time~ than r~quired by §6061 of the Government Code, by the ~ublic agency in a newspaper of general circulation in ~he area a~fected by t~e praposed project. b. Postzng of notice by ~he pub~ic agency an- and off-site in the area where the project is to be located. ~o the project. c. Direct mailing to owners of praperty contiguous 2. The alternatives for providing notic~ spe~~fied in Subsection {~) sha11 not preclude a public agency from providing additianal notice by other means i~ such agency so deszres, nor shal~ the requirements of this sec~ion preclude a public agency from providxng the public notice required herein at the same time and in the same manner as public notice otherwise required by I(a} for such praject. H. Copies of the Negative Dec~aratian snall be available for public ~nspection and copies ther~oi may be pro~ided to any person upon payment by him of a fee of $1.OQ for the ~irst page and $.10 for each addit~onal page. -4- Z. A hearing on t~e Negative Declaration shall ~be held by ~ne decision-makzng body. Notice o~ said hearing shall be given as provided in Paragraph G. If the decision-making body determines that the project may have a signi~icant effect on ~~e environment, it shall require that an EIR be prepared. ~f t~e decision-making body determines tha~ the project will not ~ave a significant effect on ~he env~ronment, i~ shall adopt the Negative Declaration. J. After a~inal determination has b~en made on a Negative Declaration and a decision is ma~e on th~ project, th~ ERC shal~ p~epare a Notice of Determination in the form attac~ed as Appendix H and til~ it with the County Clerk. . {Envira~me~tal Impact Re~ort Required) K. If it is determined that rhe projec~ may have a significant effect on t~e environment and an EIR is required, t~e applicant wil~ be notifzed in wri~ing that his application cannot be ac~ed upon until the EIR is prepared and reviewed. If the a~plicant wishes to pursue his pro~ect, the ERC shal~ prepare ar sha~l contrac~ to have ~he EIR prepared~~or shal~ request the applicant to submzt informa~~on ~n ~he form of a draft EIR ar in a form which can be used as the basis for preparation of a dratt EIR L. A Notice of Preparation sha11 be sent to each responsib~e agency. The ERC sha11 solicit input from the owners of property contiguo~s to th~ projsct site, regarding environmenCal concerns which should be covered in the d~afC ~IR. If t~e number of owners of contiguous property exceeds ~OQ, tnen the ~RC sha~~ solicit such information by publica~ion, no fewer tzmes than required by §6~61 0~ th~ Governm~nt Code, in a newspaper of general circ~~ation i~ the area affected by the proposed project. Said notices shall indica~e that ~h~ information shall be submitted to the ERC within th~ee weeks ~rom the date of mailing or of publication. I. ~ach elemenC listed in Paragraphs 2~hrough 14 be~ow must b~ coveted, and when these elemen~s are not separated into distinct sectio~s, ~he do~ument sha11 state w~ere in the documen~ ea~h e~~men~ is discussed. 2. Each ~eport shall contain a brief summary of Che proposed action and its consequences in language sufficienCly simple ~ha~ the issues can be understood by the average m~mber of the lay publ~c. ~he EIR shall also contain a table of conten~s or an index. 3. The information co~tained in an ~iR s~all include summarized teChnical daCa, maps, plot plans, diagrams and similar rel~vant information sufficien~ to permiC f~ll assessment of signi- ficant env~ronmental impacts by reviewing agencies and members o~ the pub~ic. -5- Placement of highly ~~chnical and specialized analyses.and data in ~he body of t~e EiR should be avoided through inclus~on of supporting information and analyses as appendi~es Co the main body o~ the EIR. A~pendices to the EIR may be prepared in vol~mes separaCe from Che basic EIR document, but sha11 be availabl~ for public exam~nation and shall be submitted to ail ~learinghous~s which assisC in public r~vi~w. 4. The EIR should be prepared using a systematic, interdiscip~inary approach. The inte~disciplinary analysis shall be conduct~d by ~ompetent individuals, bu~ no single discipline shall be designa~ed or required ta undertake ~his evalua~ion. Preparation of EIRs is dependent upon information from many souzces, including the engineering project report and many scientific docu- ments relati~g to environmenta~ fea~ures. T`ae ~IR shall ~eferen~e a11 documents used in iCs pxeparation including, where pos~ible, a citaCion ~o Che page and section number of any Cechnica~ reports which were used as ~he basis for any statements in the EXR. 5. The E~R should discuss enviranmentai effects in proportion to their severity and probabil~ty o€ occ~rr~nce. Ef~ec~s dismissed in an Initial Study as c~early insignificant and ~nlikely to ocC~r need not be disc~ss~d further in the ~IR unl~ss the ~ead Agencq subsequent~y receives information ~nconsis- t~nr wiCh Che finding in that ~naCia~ S~udy. A copy of the In~tial S~udy shali be at~ached to the E~R to provide the basis ~or l~miting the impacts d~scussed. 6. An E~R shali conCa~n a sta~ement brie£ly indicating the reasons fo~ deternining tha~ various effects af a projec~ that co~ld possibiy be considered significant were not discusse~ in detail in the EIR. 7. Drafring an EIR necessari~y involves some degree o~ forecas~ing. W~i1e fareseeing th~ unfareseeab~e ~s not possible, an agency must usa its besC e~forts to ~ind out and dzsc~ose a~l tl~at it reasonably can, 8. If, after Chorough investi~ation, a Lead Agency finds that a partic~Iar impacC zs tao speculative for evaluation, ~he agency should note its conclusion and term~nate discussion o~ t~e impact. 9. The description af the ~roject sha1~ contain ~he fo~lowzng information but shauld nat supply exCensive detail beyond thaC needed far evaluation and review of the environmenCal impac~. a. T~e precise Location and boundaries of the proposed proje~t shal~ be shown on a de~azled map, preterabl.y tapographic. The locaraon of the praject shall a~so appear on a regional map. -6~ b. A staCemen~ of the ob~ec~ives sough~ by ~he proposed project. c. A general description of fihe praje~~'s technica~, economic and environmenta~ characteristics, considering the pxincipal enginee~ing proposals and supporCing public service fa~ili~i~s. ~ 10. An EIR musC inc~ude a description of t~e environ- ment in ~he vicinity of the project, as iC exists b~fore commencement of the project, from both a 1oca1 and regional pers~ec~ive. Knowledge of the regional setting is criCical to the assessment of environmental impacts. Specia~ emp~asis should be pla~ed on environme~tal reso~rces that are rare or uniq~e to that region. Speci~ic reference to rela~ed projec~s, both p~blic and pxivate, bo~h existent and planned, in t~e region should aLso be in~~uded, for purposes of examining the possible cumula~ive impact of such projects. 1~, A11 p~ases of a pxoject must be considered when eval~ating its impaet on Che enviranment: planning, acquisition, deve~opment and opera~ion. The following su~bjects shall ~e discussed, prefezably in sEparate sections or paragraphs. ~f ~hey are not discussed separate~y, the EIR shall include a Cable showin~ where each of the subjects is discussed. a. Describe the direcC and indirec~ significan~ effects of t~e project on the envixanm~n~, gzving due consideration ro both th~ short-term a~d long-~erm effects. ~t should include relevant specifics of ~he a~ea, the resou~~es involve~, physical changes, alteratians to ecologica~ systems and changes induced in populataon distribution, pop~~ation concentration, the human use o~ the ~and (in~~udin~ cammercia~ and residential development) and other aspects of the resaurces base sUCh as wa~er, scenac qua~iry and pub~ic s~rvites. Cumula~ive effects sha~l also be discussed when found to be significanC. b. Describe any significant impacts, including those which can be reduced ~o an insig~if~cant level but not elimina~ed. Wher~ there are impacts that cannoC be alleviated witho~t imposing an alternative design, th~ir implications and the reasons why the project is being p~opas~d, notwi~hstanding their ef~ect, should be described. Describe significan~ impacts on any aesthetica~Iy valuable surroundings, or on h~man heaith. c. Describe signifiCant, avoidabLe, adverse impacts, including inefficient and unne~essary consu~ption of ~n~rgy, and measures to minimiz~ these impacts. The discussion nf mitigation measures sha11 distinguish between the measures which are praposed by proj~ct proponents to be inc~~ded in ~he -~- project and other ~easures that are not included bu~ could reasonably be expec~ed to reduce adverse impacts. This discussion s~all include an identification of ~he acceptable leve~s ~o w~ich such impac~s wiZl be reduced, and the basis upon w~ich levels are ~dentifie~. Where sev~ral meas~res are available to mitiga~e an impact, each shauld be d~scussad and the basis for selecting a par~icular meas~re should be identifie~. Energy conse~~ation measures, as w~~l as other appropriate m~tigation measures, shall be discussed when zel~vant. Examp~es of energy conservation measures are provided in Appendix C. d.' Descr~be a~l reasonab~e al~ernatives to the p~oject, or to the location of ~he project, which cou~d feasibly attain ~he basis obje~tives of the project, and why they were rejected in favor of the ul~ima~e choice. ~he sp~cific aiternative of "no project" must al.so aLways be evaluated, along wit~ the impact. Th~ discussion of a3.ternatives sha].1 include alternatives capab~~ af subs~anti.ai~y reducing or elimina~ing any signif~cant envaronmental effec~s ~ven if these alternativ~s wouid substantia~ly impede the at~ai.nment of the project objec~.ives, and would be more casCly. ' e. Describe the cumulative and long-term effects of the proposed projecC. which adversely affec~ the s~ate of the environment. Special aC.tention sho~ld b~ given ~o ~mpacts wi~ich narrow the range of beneficia~. uses of the environment or pose long-te~m risks to health or safety. Tn adciition, the reasons w~y t~e proposed pro,~ect is be3.ieved by the spansor to be ~us~ified now rather than reserving an aption for further a~ternatives, st~ould be exp~ained. f. i~ses of nonrenewable resou~ces durir~g the initia~. and continued p~ases o~ the project may be irre.versible since a large coFnmitment of such reso~arces makes removal of nonuse ~hereafter unlikely. Primary a.mpacts and, partic~larly, sacandary impacts (such as a highway improvement which provides access ~o a nonaccessible area} genera~ly commit future generata.ons to simi~ar uses. A1.so irxeversible damage can result f~om en~ironmen~al accic~ents associated with ~he project. Irr~trievable comznztmen~s of zesa~rces sho~ld be evaluated to assure that such current Consuu~ption is justi~ied. g. Discuss ~he ways in which the ~roposed project could fnster economic or population growth, either dzrectly or indirectly, ~n tl~e surrounding environment. Included in this are projects which would remove obstac~.es ~o popu~ation growth {a uiajor expansion o~ a waste water treatment plant might, for example, a3.low for more canstruction in ser~ice areas). Incr~ases in the popealation may furt~er tax exis~ing caa~t~nity servi~e facilities so consideration must be giv~n to tha.s ig,pac~. Al.so disc~ss the characteristic of some projects which _g_ may encourage and facil~tate other activi~ies that could signi~i- Cantly affect the en~ironment, either individually or cum~~atively. It musC not be assumed that growth in any area is nec~ssarily bene~icial, de~rimental, or of Iittle signif~cance ta the environment. 12. The in~armation requ~red by subsectio~s "e" and "f" of paragraph 11 need be included o~ly in EIRs prepared in connection wi~~ any of the following activi~ies: a. The adoption, amendmen~, ar ~na~tment of a p~an, poZ~cy o~ ordinance of a public agency. b. Th~ adopt~o~ by a local agency formation commission o~ resolution making de~ezminations. c. A project which will be su6ject to the req_uirement for pzegaring an environmen~a~ impact statement pursuant ~o the r~quirements o~ Che National Environ~ental Policy Act af 1969. 13. The identi~y of ai~ ~ederal, State or Ioca1 agen~ies, other arganizaCions and private i~dividuals cansu~te~ in preparing the EIR, by contract or other authorization musr be given. 14. Describe in Che environ~r~entati set~ing sec~ian, and other sections where applicable, water quality aspects of proposed proj~cts which have been previously certified by the appropriate StaCe or intets~ate organzzation as being in subs~an- ~ial compliance wi~h applicable water quality stan~ards. ~. 1. ~~e Final EIR sha~1 consis~ af: a. The Draft EIR or a revision of ~he draft. b Commen~s and recommendations received on the Dr a~t EIK, either verbatim or in summary. c. A list of persons, organiza~ions and public agencies cammenting on the Draft E~R. ' d. The responses of the Lead Agency to signifi- cant environmental points raised in the review and consultation process. 2. The respons~ of the Lead Agency ra commen~s received may tak~ the form of a re~ision of the Draft EIR or may be an attachment to the Draft ETR. ~he response shall be descr~bed in the disposition or significant environmenta~ iss~es raised (e.g., revisions ~o the praposed proje~t to mZ~igate an~icipated i~pacts or objec~ions). In partic~lar the major iss~es raised when the -9- Lead Agency's position is a~ variance with t~e recommendations and objecCions raised in the commen~s must be addressed in detail g~ving reasons why sp~cific comments an~ suggestions wer~ no~ acCepted, and factors of overriding importance warranting an override of ~he sugg~stians. N. The applicanr shall be required to pay to the.County ~~e cos~ far preparation of the EIR, as es~ablished pursuant Co resolution by the Board of Supervisors. 0. The ~RC or consultant, as app~icable, shall consul~ w~t~ ali ~esponsib~e agencies with respect to the project and may consult with any person or ag~ncy having special expertise wi~h respect to any environmental impact involved and may consul~ with any ci~y or other agency regarding the environmental impact of a project within i~s sphere of influence. (A c~art af governmen~a~ agencies with jurisdict~on and/ar expertise with resp~c~ to environmental matters is attac~ed as Appendix I for guida~ce in this regard. A chart of Sta~e Departments with jurisdiction in areas of en~ironmen~al concern is attach~d as Appen~zx B to th~ State Guid~lines ~or implementation of CEQA.) The comments of s~ch agencies and persons s~ouid be considered in preparation of the Draf~ ~IR, if possible, and shall be considere~ in preparation of the ~inal EIR. P. Whea the ~raf~ EIR is compl~t~d, a Notice o~ Comp~et~o~ in the form attached as Appendix J sha11 be prepared by the ERC and copies of it filed with ~he SecreCary of ~he California Resources Ag~ncy and Che Co~nty Clerk and given or mai~ed to the applicant. Public notice of th~ completion of a Draft EIR shall be made as provided in garagraph G. Q. The Dra~t EiR will be made availab~e for public review and any p~rson may obtain a copy of it by ~aying a fee of $~.00 for the first page and $.10 for each additiona~ page. In addition, the ERC sha~l prov~de all county and city public libraries with copies af a11 Draft EIRs. R. A hear~ng an ~he Draft EIR shall be held by the d~cision-making body. Notice of said hear~ng shall be given as provided in paragraph G. S. At the hearing on the Draf~ ETR, t~e decision-making body shall determine th~ sufficiency of the EIR in discu5sing possible impacts upon _the environment, ways in which adverse eftects might be minimized, and al~ernatives to the project, in ligh~ of the intent of the California Environmen~al Quaiity Act ~o provide decis~on-makers wi~h useful infor~ation about such factors. Any perso~ may ~omment verbally o~ in writing at the hearing regarding the suffic~ency of the Draft EIR. A copy or summary of such ~omments and comme~~s from other a~encies or persons with jurisdictian and/or expertise shal~ be a~~ached to the Final EIR. -~a- T. The ERC or consu~tant, as applicable, shall prepare recommend~d responses to such commen~s received pursuant to paragraphs 0 and S above by preparing an a~~achment to the Draft EIR. ~he attachment shali describe the dis~osztion of significant ~nvironmental issues raised {e.g,, revisions Co the proposed pro~ect to ~itigate anticipated i~pacts or objections). Major iSS~~S raised when approva~ of Che project would be at variance wit~ recomm~ndat~ons or objectians raised in svch commen~s must be addressed in detail in the attachment, wh~ch should give reasons why specific comments and suggestians were not accegted and list ~ac~o~s of overriding Zmpor~ance warran~ing an override of these suggestions. Notwiths~andzng th~ above pro~isions, if al~ such co~men~s or suggestions are adequately dealt with in the Draft EIR, the aCtachmen~ may simply so state and identify the applacab~e sections of t't~e Draft EIR. The Final ETR sha1~ consist of the Draf~ EIR, comments either verbatim or in s~mmary, responses as approved by t~e decis~on-making aody, and a list of the persons cammenting, received pursuant ~o paragraphs 0 and 5 above. The Final EIK shall be certi~ied within one year from t~e date o~ application. ~ U. The Fina1 E~R shall be reviewed and conszdered by the decision-making body prior to approving the praject. V. Findings. a. Th~ deCision-making body s~ail not apprave a praject for which an environmental impact report has been completed which identif~es one or more significan~ e~fects of the pro~ect ~aless the decision-ma~in~ body makes one or more of the fo~lowing writ~en findings for ea~h of those significant effec~s, accompanied by a statemenC. of ~he facts suppor~ing each finding. 1. Changes or a~terations have b~en required in, or zncorporated into, the project which mi~igate or avoid t~e significant environmental effects thereof as id~ntified in the Fina~ EIR. 2. Such changes or alt~raCions are within the zespons~bility and jurisdiction of anothex public agency and not the agency making ~he finding. S~ch changes have been adopted by sucn ottzer agency or can and snouLd be adopted by suc~ ot~er age~cy. 3. Specific economic, soCial or othe~ ~onsidera- tions make znfeasibl~ the mitigation measures or projecC alternatives identified in ~he Final EIR. b. ~he findings required in subseCtion "a" sha~l be supported by substantial evidence in the record. -11- ~. The finding in subsection a.2. shall na~ be made if the agency makang the finding has concurrent jurisdiction w~th ano~her agency ta deal with idenCified feasible mi~igation measures ox alternatives. ~he ERC shall be responsible for assisting the Board or any other reviewing body in the co~pletion of ~hese requiremen~s.. . ~ W. The decision-making body sha11 certify that the F~nal. ~Ik has been completed in co~pliance wi~h CEQA, the State EIR Guidelines, these guid~~ines and that decision-making body ar adminis~rative o~ficial having tinal a~t~ority over the project has reviewed a~d cansidered the information ~on~ained in ~he EIR. X. After approval o~ a de~ermination to carry out ~h~ projeC~ is made ~he ERC sha11 prepare a Not~ce of Ueterminatian in the form attached as Appendix H and file it wz~h ~he Co~nty Clerk, ~hich shal~ include a statemenC of overr~dxng ~onsiderations if adverse environmental impacts ~ave been iden~ified and not mit~gated. If the p~oj:ect req~ixes discretionary approval from a Sta~e agency, the Notice a~ Determina~ion shall also be filed with the Secretary for Resources. Y. ~he determination of the Lead Agency of whether to prepare an EIR ar a Negative Declaratio~ shall be fina~ and concl~- sive on a~l pe~sans, including Responsi~le Agencies, as provided by §210$0.1 of the Public Resourc~s Code, ~nless: 1. The deczs~on is chall~nged as p~ovided in §21167 of the Pub~ic Resources Cade, ar 2. Circumsta~ces change as prov~ded in §~5067 of the State G~idelines. Z. A time period may be extended for a reasonable period if due Co un~oreseen circumstances, additzanal time is justifi~d and ~he appl~cant consents to the ex~ension. 5. CO~NTY PK~J~CTS; ENVIKO~MBNTAL REVI~W PROC~~URES W~ien the County ot Sutte, or any depart~ent thereof, as the Lead Agency, cont~mplates anq activity resulti~g in physical c~ange in ~he a~vironment, inclu~ing bu~ not limited to Public Works construction and related activities, clearing ar grading of land, impravemen~s ~o existing public structures, enact~ent and am~ndmen~ of zoning ordinances ini~iated by the Planning Commission or the Board of Supervisors, an~ the amendment o~ th~ Butte County G~neral Plan or Elements thereaf, ~he fol~owing procedures sha11 be fo~lowed: Th~ departament w~xch contemplates ~he ac~iaity shall request ~he ~~vironmental Revi~w Coordinator to determ~ne w~erher the activity qualifies for a categorical ex~mption ~is~ed on attach~d Appendix B or in 14 Ca~ifornia Administrative Code §§I5~01 Chroug~ ~5112, 15114, ~5116, 15~17 and 1512Q. If the activity is -i2- categoricaliy exemp~, na Environmental Impact Report (EIR} is req~i~ed and regular processing of plans for the activity may con~in~e without further environmental review pursuan~ to these procedures. I~ the ac~ivity is not categoraca~ly exempt, ~he aepartment shal~ ~arward its plans and spe~ifica~ions to the ~RC. Upon receipt of ~he plans and specif~cations for ~he prajecC, the ERC shall condu~C an ini~ial study. to determine if the project may have a significant ~ffect on the enviro~ment. The environmen~al review process from that point on, inclu~ing determinations and filing o~ notices, will be con~ucted in tn~ same manner as specified above in the p~ocedutes ~or enviranmental r~view of private projects, wi~~ the d~partment proposing ta carry out the pr4~ect being treated as Che "a~PP1iCa~[]C" d~~artmen~ . AP~ENb~X A NOTICE OF EXEMPT~ON ~0: Q Secre~ary for Resaurces FROM: ~416 Ninth St~eet, Room i311 Sacramento, Califor~~a 95$1~ Q County C~erk Co~nty of Projec~ Ti~le Project Loeation - Spec~ zc Proje~t Lo~ation - City Project Location - Coun~y Description of Nature, Purpos~ and Beneficiaries af Project Name o Pu~ ic Agency Approving Project Name o Person or Agency Carrying Out Pra~ect Exempt Status: {Check One) Mi~is~erial (915073) Declared Emargency (§15071(a}) Emergency Pro~ec~ (§§15071(fl} and (c)) Categorical Exemption. State ~ype and section number: Reasans w y pro~ect 1s exempt: Contact Person Area Coc~e Telephone ~xrension If filed by appl.icant: 1. Atta~~ certified docum~n~. of exemption finding. 2. Has a notice of exemption been filed by the public agency approving the project? Yes 1Vo Date Receiv~ ~or ~'i1.~.ng Signature Tit e APPENDI~ B MINISTERIAL ACTIVITIES AND CA~EGORICAL ~XEM~TI~NS MINTSTER~AL PR0IECTS. Ministeriai pro~ects do not require the preparation o EnvironmentaZ Impact Reports. The following projects have been de~ermined by the Board of Sup~rvisors to be ministerial pro~ects, based upon an ana~ysis of County ordinances and procedures; 1. Issuance of building, plumbing, me~hanicaZ and electrica~ permits. 2. Approval of f~nal subdivzsion and parcel maps and records of survey. 3. App~o~al of individual utility se~vice connections and disconnections. 4. ~ssuance of retai~ faod markeC permits. 5. Issuance of highway transportation permits. 6. Business licenses. CATEGqRICAL ~XEMPTIONS. Certain c~asses of discretionary projects ave een eterm~ned by the Secretary of ~he R~sources Age~cy not ~o have a signif~can~ effect on the environment. These classes are exemp~ from the xequirement ~ar preparation o~ Environ- mental Impact Reports. As applicable ~nder Butte County ordinances and procedures the categorical exemptions are as follows: Class ~. Existin ~aci~itiss. Opera~ion, re~a~x, mainCenance or mi~o~r a~eraC~on o exis~ing gublic or priva~e str~ctures, facilities, mechanical equipment, or topographical features, xnvolving negligibLe at~ no Expansion of ~se beyond that ~revio~s~y exisCing, inc~uding ~ut not limited to: a. In~erior or ~xterior a~teration af County faci~ities involving such Chings as interior partxtions, plumbin~ and e~ectrical conv~yances; b. ~xistin~ facilities of both investor and publicly owned utiiities usEd to convey or dis~zibute elec~rica~ power, natural gas, sewage, etc.; ~. Existing highways and stree~s (within already established right-ot-way), sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian ttails, and similar ~aciliries sueh as drainage easemen~s and channels. (For purposes of Chis secrion, removal of dead ot hazardous trees ~rom such faci~ities sha11 be cansid~red to be ~repai~ and maintenance}; d. ResCorat~on, or rehabilitation of detetiorated or damaged Goun~y str~ctures, facilities or mechanical equip~ent to ' meet current standards of public health and safety, unless it is deCermined that the damage was substantial and ~es~l~e~ from an ~nvironmental hazard su~h as earthquake, landslzde or flood; e. Addi~ions to existing Coun~y structures pravid~d tha~ ~he addi~ion wi11 not res~lt in an increase of more ~han 50 percent of the flaor area af Che struc~ure befor~ the addition ar a~teration, ar 2,500 square fe~~, whichever is less; f. Addi~ion of safety or health p~otec~ion devic~s for use durxng construction of o~ ~n conju~c~ion with ~xis~ing structures, facili~~es or mechanical equipment, or topagraphical fea~ures (including naviga~ional devices) where ~~ese de~ices do not have or result in an adverse environmen~al impac~; g. New copy of existing on- and o~~-premi~es signs; h. Maintenanee of existin~ landscaping, native growth and water supply ~eservoirs (excluding Che use of ag~onomic poisons, as defined in ~ivis~on 7, Chapter 2, Califo~nia Agricultural Cade); i. Maintena~ce of ~ish sc~eens, fish ~adders, wildlife habi~at areas, ar~ificial wiLdli~e waterway devices, s~ream flows, sp~ings and waterholes, and stream channe~s (clearing of debris) ta protect fis~ and wildl~~e resources; j. Fish stocking by the But~e County Fis~ and Game Commiss~on; k. D~vision of exisring m~ltip~.e family rental un~.ts and/or co~mercial unit~ into condominiums; ~.. Demolition and removal o~ County bu~.ldings and related s~.ructures except wi~ere ~hey are o~ his~arical, archaeo- lagical o~ architectural consequer~ce as ot~;cially designated by Federal., State o~ Coun~y action; m. Opera~ion, repair, mai.n~.enance or minor alteration of sewage ~rea~me~~ and retuse di.sposal facilities; n. Conversion o~ a single family residence inCo office use; Class 2. Re ~.acement or ReconstruC~ion. Class 2 consists of replacement or reconstruction a existing structures and facil.iti~s w~ere the new structure will be located on ~he same si~e as the s~ructure rep~.a~ed and wi11 have substanCially the same purpose and capacity as t~e s~ructure replaced, includzng but not li.mited to: a. Repl,acement or reconstruc~.ion of existing schaols and hospita~s to provide earthquake resis~ant str~ctures whic~ do no~ increase capac~ty more than 50 percent; b. Replacement of a commercia~ s~ruCture with a new structure of substantially the same size, purpose and capacity; c. Replacement or r~construction of existzr~g utility systems and/ar ~aciliCies involving negligibie or na expansion af capaci~y; B-2 d. Conv~rsian of over~ead eiectric utiliCy distribu- tion system facilities into underground including connecCion to existing o~erhead electriC ~tility distributio~ lines where the sur~ace is restored to the condi~ion existing prior ~o the undergrounding. Class 3. New Construc~ion or Co~version o~ Sma11 Structures. Class consists o constxuction an location o zmi~e numbers of new, small facilities or struct~res; znstallation o sma new ~quipment and facilities in small str~ctures; and the ~anversion o~ existing sma11 structures from o~e use to another where only minor modifications are made in ~he exterior of the s~ructUre. The numbers of structvres described in this section are the maximum allowable within a two year period. Examples of this exemp~ion incxude, but are noC limited to: a. Singie-family residences no~ in Conjunction with the building of ~wo o~ more such ~nits. In urbanized areas, up to three single-family residences may be const~ucted under ~~is ~xemption. b. Apartments, duplexes and simi~ar structures wi~h not mare than four dwelling units if not in conjunction wzth the bui~d~ng of two or more such structures. In urbanizea a~eas, ~he exemption applies to s~ngle apartmen~s, duplexes and sim~lar small structures aesigned for not more than six dwelling ~nits if not constructed in conjunction wiCh th~ building of Cwo or more struc~~xes. c. Water ~azn, sewage, electrical, gas and a~~her utility extensions of reasonab~e Iength to serve su~n constr~ction. d. Accessory {appur~enant) stru~tures including garages, carports, patios, swi~ing pools and fences. e. Trailer Iiving permits. Class ~. Minor Altera~ions ~o Lan~. Minor public or pr~vate alterat~o~in the con it~on o an , water and/o~ vegetation which do not involve r~movaL of mature, scenic trees except for forestry and agric~ltural purposes, inc~Udzng bu~ not ~imiCed to: a. Grading on land with a slope of less than I~ percent, excep~ where zt is to be lacated in a waterway, in any we~land, in any offiCially designated (by Federal, StaCe or local governm~nt acCion} scenic area, o~ ~n officially mapped areas of severe geologic hazard. b. New gardening or ~a~dscaping but not intlu~ing tree ~emoval. c. Fil~ing of ~atth znto pre~iously excavated land witn materiai co~ipatible with the na~ural featu~e~ of the site. B-3 d. Minar altera~ions in land, wat~r and vegetatian on existing offzcially deszgnated wildlife manage~ent areas or fish praduction facilit~es which result in improvement of habita~ for fish and wild~~fe resources or greater ~ish production. e. Minor te~porary uses of lan~ having neg~igib~e or no permanent effect on the enviranment, incl~ding carnivals, sales of Chrxstmas trees, etc. f. Minor trenching and backfi~~ing where the surface is restored. g. Mai~tenan~e dredging where the spoil is de~oszted into a spoi~ area authorzzed ~y all app~icable State and ~ederal regulatory agencies. h. T~e creatian of bicycle lanes on exis~ing righ~s- of-way. i. Continuation af minzng ar aggregate ex~raction wi~hin an existing and cl~arly defined si~e. Class 5. Alteratia~s in Land ~se LimitaCions. Minor al~eration in 1an use limitations, except zonzng, including bu~ not Iimi~ed to: a. Minor ~ot line ad~~stments, side ya~d and se~ba~k varzances not resulting in the creation o~ any new parce~ nor i~ any change in ~and ~se or d~nsity. b. Issuance of minor encroachm~nC permzts. ~. Abandonment of pub~ic utility or road easeme~~s and ~ights-af-way. d. Reversion to acreage in accordance with the S~bdivision Map Act. Class b. Information Co~lection. C~ass b consists of basic data coll~ction, research, experimental management and resource evaluation activi~ies whi~h do not resuLt in a serious or major disturbance to a~ ~nvzronmental resource. These may be for strictly in~ormation ga~~ering purposes, or as part of a st~dy leading to an ac~io~ whi~h a public agency has not yet app~oved, adopted or funded. Glass 7. Ac~ions b Re ula~or A encies for Protection of Natural Re~ources. C1ass 7 consists of actions taken by reg~latory agenc~es as aut orized by State ~aw ar 1oca1 ordinance to ass~re ~he ~aintenan~e, restoration, or enhancement o~ a natural resource where the regu~atory process invo~ves pro~edure~ for proCectian of the e~vironment. Examples include bu~ are not limited ~o wi~d- ii~e preservation activities of the S~ate Department of Fish and Game. Constr~ctio~ activities are not zncluded in this exe~ption. B-4 C~ass 8. Actio~s b Re ulator A encies for Protee~ion af th~ Environment. C ass cansists o actions ~a en by regu atory agenc~es, as authorized by State or locai ordinance, ~o assure the maintenance, restorat~on, e~~ancement, or protection of t~e e~vironment wh~r~ the r~gulatory process invol~es procedures for pro~ection of the environment. Construction acti~ities are not inctiuded in this exemption. C~ass 9. Inspectians. Class 9 consists of activi~ies limite~ entirely ~o inspection, to check for performance of an operation, or quality, health or safety of a projecC, including ~elated activities such as ins~~c~ion fo~ possib~e mislabeling, misrepresenCaCio~s or a~ulteratian of products. CLass 10. Accessor S~rucC~res. C1ass 1~ consists af construction, or placement o minor str~ctures aCCessory to {a~purtenant ~o) existing commercia~, industrial, or instit~~ional faciZi~ies, inc~uding b~t not limited to: a. Qn-premises signs. b. Small parking Iots. C. Placement of seasonal or temporary use items such as iifeguard ~owers, mobile foad units, por~ab~e restrooms or similar items in genexal~y the same locations from ti~e to ti~e in publicly owned parks, stadiums, or other facalities des~gned for public use. C1ass 11. Sur ~us Co~n~ Pro ert Sa1es. Class 11 consists of saleis~ surpLus County praperty except for parce~s of land. Class ~2. tir~l~~n , Redrillin or Wel~s WiC in Esta is e Ons o~e Oi or consists o the dril~ing, re ri iing or ~or the purpose of estab~ished oil or g praductive limits of onshare o~l or gas ~he follo~ing cri~eria: Deepenin of Develo menC Gas Fie~~s. C~ass ~ deegening o~ wells as zones within the known £ields ~hat meet a11 of a. Zone pr~ssures are well documented and are at or below normal hydrostatic pressUre. b. Geolagic cond~tions are we11 doc~mented. c. More ~han 50 perc~nC of the deveLopment wells thaC can be expected to be ~ril~ed in the field ha~e been dri~~ed. Class 13. M~nor Additions to Sc~aols. Class 13 consists of minor a ztions to exxs~ing sc oa s w~t in exisCing schaol grounds where the addiCzon does not increase arigina~ student capacity by more ~han 25 percen~ or five classrooms, whichever is 1ess. The addition of portable c~assrooms is included in this exemptian. ~-5 Class ~4. Minor Land Divisions. Class 14 consists of the d~vision of property in ur anxze areas zoned for residential, commercial, or ~ndustrial ~se inta four ar fewer parce~s w~en the dzvision is in confarma~ce wit~ the G~neta~ P1an and zoning, no variances or exceptions are required, aIl services and access ~o the propased parcels to local standards are availab~e, the parc~l is no~ involved in a division of a~axger parcel with~n t~~ previous 2 years, and the parcel does no~ have a slope greate~ t~an 20 percent. Class 15. Transfer o~ Ownershi of ~and in Order ~o Create Parks. Class 15 cons~sts o t e acq~is~tion or sa e o lan in o~r3~e~r to establish a par~ where the Iand is in a na~ural condition or contains historic sites or ar~haeolagical sites and either: a. The manag~men~ plan for the park ~as not bee~ prepared, or b. The managemen~ plan proposed Co keep the area in a natural condx~ion or preserve the historic o~ ar~haeologica~ site. CEQA wilti apply when a managemen~ plan is praposed that wi~l change the area from its natural eondztian or significan~ly c~ange the historic ar archaeological si~e. C1ass 16. 0 en S ace Contracts or Easements. C1ass ti6 consis~~ ~he es~a lishment o agricu tural preserves, the making and renewing o~ open space contracts ~nder Cha Williamson AcC, ar the accepCance of easements or fee interests in order Co ~aintain ~he open spac~ character of thE area, ~he cancellation of such preserves, con~ract~, int~res~s or easements is not in~lUded. Class 17. Enforcement Actions. C1ass 17 consisCs of act~o~s to ~n or~ce or revoke a Iease, permit, license, certifacate or ather en~itlement for ~se issued, adopted or prescribed by Che County of Butte or law, genera~ rule, s~andard or obj~ctive, administered or adopted by the County of Butte. Su~h act~ons inc~ude, but are not ~imited to, Che ~o~lowin~: a. The dir~ct referral of a violat~on of lease, permit, license, ~er~ificate or en~itiement ~or use a~ or a generati rule, s~andard or objecCive ta the Dis~rict At~orney for ~udi~ial enfarcem~nt. b. The adoption of an administra~ive decision or ord~r ~nforcing or revoking the lease, per~i~, li~ense, certifica~e or entitlement ~or use or enforci~g the general ru~e, stan~ard or objec~ive. Construction activities undertaken by the pub~ic agency ~aking th~ enforcement or revocation action are no~ incl~ded in Chis exe~ption. B-5 Class 18. Educational or Traznin Pro rams In~olvin No Physica ~ G~ges. Class ~~ consists o t e aaoption, alteration or termination of ed~cational or training programs whz~h involve physical alteration i~ the area affected or whic~ invoLve physica~ changes only in the interior of existing school or training s~r~c~ures. Examples include, but are not limited to: a. DevelopmenC of o~ changes in curriculum or training methods. b. Changes in the grade structurE in a schooL which ~o not resul~ in changes in student transpo~tation. Cla~s 19. Norma~ 0 erations or Facilities for PUblic Gatherzn s. Class consists o the norma operat~ons o ~xistxng~acilities ~or public gath~~ings for wh~ch the facili~ies were designed, where there is a past history of t~e facility being used for t~e same kind of purpose. Facilities included wi~~in ~his exemp~ion include, but are not~limited to, racetracks, stadiums, canv~ntion centers, a~diCOriums, amphitheaters, swimming pools and amusement parks. C~ass 20. Re ulat~on of Workin Conditions. Class 2U consis~~ actzons to regu ate any o t e o owing: a. ~mployees` wages, b. Ho~rs of work, ar c, Working ~ondiCions where there wi1L be ~o demo~- strable physical changes outside the place of work. C~ass 21. ~rans~ers Qf Ownershi of In~erests ~n ~and ta Preserve 0 en S ace. C ass ' consis~s o~ e trans ers o awnership o~n~erests in land in order to preserve open space. Examples include, but are not limited to: a. Acq~isition of areas to prES~rv~ the existing natural canditions. b. Acq~isxtion of areas to a~~ow Continued agric~ltural us~ of the areas . condi~ions. c. Acquisition to all.ow restoration of natura~. d. Acquisition ta prevent encroachment of development into f~.ood plains. NO~E: Autharity: §2~0$3, ~ubl~c Resources Code; Reference: §21.084 an~ §21485, Publ~.c Resources Cocie. B-7 C1ass 22. Ac uisi~ion of Hou~in for Housin Assistance Programs. Class consists o actions by a re eve opmen~ agency, ~ho~sing authority, or o~her pubZi~ agency to implement an adopted Ho~sing Assistanc~ Plan by acquiring an inCeres~ in hou~sing units. xhe housing units may be either in exis~ence or poss~ssing all required permits far canstruction when the agen~y mak~s its final dec~sion to acq~ire ~he units. N~~E: Authority cited: §21083, PubLiC Resa~rc~s Code; Reference: §21D$4 and §21085, Public Resaurces Code. C1ass 23. Leasing New Facilities. a. Class 23 consists a~ the leasing of a new~y constru~~ed ox previously unoccupied private~y-owned ~acility by a iocal or s~ate agency where th~ Iocal governing au~hority determ~ned that ~he building was ex~mpt from CEQA. To be exempt u~der thi~ secCion, the proposed ~se of the facil~ty: 1. Shall be in conformace w~~h ~xis~ing Stat~ plans and poLicies and wi~h genera~, co~munity, and speci~ic plans for which an EIR or Negative D~c~aration has been prepar~d, 2. Shall be subs~an~ially the same as tha~ oziginally propos~d at the tim~ the building permiC was issued, 3. S~a~l not resul~ in a traffic increase of greater than 1~ perc~nt af front access road capacity, and 4. Sha~l incl~de the pravision of adequare employee and ~isiro~ par~ing fa~i~ities. b. Examp~es o~ C~ass 23 include, but are not Lamxted to: 1. Leasing of administra~ive o~fices in newly constructed affice space. 2. Leasing of client service o~fices in newly constructed retail space. 3. Leasing ot administrative and/or c~ienC service offices ~n newly construc~ed industrial parks. C~ass 24. Federa~ Financed Public Works Road Pro'ect. A separate review y the ERC sha e camp ete or Federa Y financed Public Works road projecCs, The ERC shall review the below section ~o determin~ whether the proposed project meets the "Major Action"or "No~w~lajox Action" designation. B-8 FOR PUBLIC WORKS USE ON~Y MAJOR AND NON-MAJOR ACTIONS a. A major action, which is an FHWA action, wi11 require either an ~zS o~ Negative De~laratian. A non-major actian, which is an FHWA action, will not require an EIS or a Nega~ive Declaratzon. b. Major actions are Chose o~ superior, large and considerab~e importance involving substantial pianning, time, resources or expenditures. Any ac~ion that is ~ikely to precipitate significan~ foreseeable alteratio~s in land use; planned grawth; dev~lopment patterns; traffic volumes; ~ravel patterns; Cranspartation services, including pubiic transpor~a~ion and natural and manmad~ resources would be considered a major action. ~he following are examples of ~ypes of actions wnich are ordina~ily considered ~o ~e major actions: 1. a new freeway or expressway, 2. a highway wh~ch provides new access to an area and is 1ikely ~o precipiCate significant changes in land use or development pa~~erns, 3. a new or re~onstructed ar~eria~ highway which provides subs~ant~ally im~roved access to an area and is likely to precipitate significant chan~es in iand use or development patterns, 4. a new ~irCUm~erential or belt highway w~ic~ bypasses a ca~unity. 5. a highway which provides new access to areas contain~ng significan~ amo~n~s of exploi~ab~e natural reso~rc~s. 5. add~d i~Cerchanges to a completed freeway ar expressway w~ich provide new or substantially improved aCCess to an area and are likely to precipi~a~e significant chang~s in land use or development patterns, and 7, a project that warrants a"major ac~ian" classification because it has ~been ga.~en national recognition by Congress even Chough it is not ~n~luded in the a~ove list. Such a projec~ wo~ld he one t~a~ fall.s ~nder 94(f} of Che DQT Act or §I06 of the National Historic Preservation Act. B-9 c. The follawing are exa~ples of types of acCions which are ordinarily considered to be no~-major acfiions: 1. construc~ion of a new ru.ra~ two-lane highway w~ich does not provide new access to an area and which would not likely ~o precipitate significant changes in land use or deveLopment patterns, 2. moderni~ation of an ~xisting ~ighway by ~esurfacing, widening tiess than a sing~e land w~dth, adding shoulders, adding auxilia~y lanes far locaLized purposes (weaving, climbing, speed cha~ge, etc.), and correc~ing substandard curves ana intersections, 3. -l~ghring, signing, pavement marking, signa~ization, f~eeway survei~lance and Control systems, and rail- road proCective devices, 4. safety projects suc~ as g~ooving, glare screen, safety barriers, e~ergy att~nuators, etc., 5. recons~ruc~ion of existing crossroad and raalroad separations and existin~ stream crossings, 6. ~~ghway landscaping and rest area proje~Cs, 7. canstr~ction of bus shelters and bays, $, alterations to existing buildings to provide tor , noise at~enua~ian and instal~a~ian of noise barrzers, 9. temporary replacement of a highway facility which is commenced immediately after the occurrence of a natural disaster or catastrophic failure to restore the highway for the health, welfare and safeCy of the public, I0, approval ot utili~q ~nstallations along oz across a highway or appro~al of graa~ separated crossings af highways by railroads or highways; and 11. appro~al of the tinn~al Highway SafeCy work Programs invo~ving the highway-rela~ed satety standards pursuanr to 23 U.S.C. 402. If the project is faund to meet ~he "Major" classzfication, ~he E~C may req~ire the Pub7.ic Works DepartmenC ~o prepare the appropriate document (E.I.S. or Negative Declaration) which ~he ERC estimat~s is needed. If the "Non-Major Actioni' ~~assification is fo~nd for a proposed projec~, ~~e fo~lawing checklist wi11 be reviewed and s~bmitted ~o ~he Public Works Depar~ment, with appropr.iate sections ~illed in. B-l~ ~NVIRONMENTAL ~VALUATION (Ini~ial StudY) District Road Name Local Agency State Rte. ~ Project Number County Raad # Bridge Name Bridge No. LIMiTS PROPOSED IM~ROVEMENT NET LENGTH MILES {p,0) (Gr. Surf. Drainag~, Srruc~ures, Etc. Po~en- Not tially Det~r- No Yes mined 1. Does it have the potential to deg~ade signzficantLy ~he quality o£, or ~urtai~ the range o~, the ~nvi~onment? 2. Wi11 it substantially affect rare endangered spe~ies of animal, plant, or habitat, or cause substantial znterferen~e with the movement of any resident or migra~ory fish or w~ldlife species? 3. WiLI i~ result in sign~ficant detrimental effect on: a. air quality b. water quality c. ambient noise levels d, public water supply system 4. Will ~t cause substant~al flooding, etosion, ar siltatzon? 5. rs the project subject to major geolagic hazards? b. Does it appear that any fearure of the project, includzng aes~he~ic, will generate major public controversy? 7. Is the action likely to be highly COntzoversial on environmental graunds? B-~1 ~o~en- No~ ~ia11y DEter- No Y~s mined 8. Will any archaeo~ogical, cultural, historica~, reCreational, 4r SCe~ic si~es be significantly affe~ted? 9. Wil~ the actzon hav~ more than minimal effect on properties protec~ed under §4(f) of the D0~ Act or ~lOb of the Hi~taric Preservation Act? 10. Is ~he aCtion ~nconsiste~t with any Federal, State or Local 1aw or regutiation re~ati~g ta ~he environmen~? I1. Wil~ i~ result in the need tor public services, inc~~ding utili~ies, beyond ~hos~ present~y available or proposed in the near future? 12. "wi11 it have a significan~ growth-induCing impact? 13. ~s any part of ~he praj~ct subject to inundation or located in or near a flood plain? 14. Is the proposed project within an ag~i- cultural preserve and/or under an agri- cultural cont~act with the Co~nCy? ~5. Does iC ap~ear to be controversial witn respect to the avai~abiliCy of adequate xelocat~on housing? 15. Will the project cause a significan~ increase in traf~ic congestion? 17. Will the project cause a signi£icant division or disrup~ion of an established communzty or disrup~ a~derly, planned development, ar is de~ermined to be sig~ificantly inconsistent with glans or gaaZs the project that have been adopted by t~e Community in which the project is ~ocated as determined by a respons~ble officiai.(s)? I.$, Will there be a cumul.ative impact by this project and successive projecCs of Che same class in the same place over time? 19. Wi11 the project affect rivers an th~ wi~.d and Scenxc Rivers Systems? B-12 Po~en- Not ~zally Deter~ No Yes mined 20. Wil~ a Fish and Game form "Notification of Remaval of Ma~erial and/or Alteration of Lake, River or Str~ambed Bottom or Margin" be ~riled? ~ased on t.his e~aluation, ir a.s con~luded tha~ one of the following is appropr~.ate. Q' ~~S/~IR P~3ay have significant eff~ct. ~ ND Wiil not nave significant etfect [~ OTHEk Proposal is a non-major ac~~.on as d~fined in FHPM 772, ~'aragraph 14e Signatur~ - Loca Agency flar~ NOTE: Classes 3, 4~, 5 and ~0 above are qualified by considerations of where ~he pro~ect is ta be located -- a project tt~at is o-~dinarily insignificant in its impact on ~he enuironmen~ may ~.n a par~icularly sensiCive environmen~ be significant. T~,er~fore, these c~.asses are considered to apply in al~. znstances, EXC~PT where the project may impact on an en~iron- mental resource, o~ hazard of criti~al conc~rn as may be hereaf~.er designa~ed, ptecisely mapped, and officzally adopCed pursuant to l.aw. Moreover, a7.1 exemptions for these c~asses are inappliCable when the cumu~ative impact af suCCes~ive projecCs of the same rype in the same place, over time is signifi~an~ -- for example, repeaCed issuance of permits ~or septzc tank systems on the wa~ersheds o~ streams, latces, domestic water teservoirs, etc. Discretionar 1'ro'ec~s. Dzscretionary projects, other than ~hose within the categorical exemptions iisted above, ~ay req~i.re Environmental Impact Repor~s. Discretionary projects whic~ may require Environmenal Impa~C Reports include but are not limited ~o the following: Enactment and amendment of zaning ordinance, issuance of zoning variances, issuance of conditional use p~rmits and the approval vf tentative subdi~isions and parcel maps. B-13 APFENDIX C ~NERGY CONSERVATION I. INTRODUCTION The goal of conserving energy imp~ies the wise and efficient use of energy. The means of achieving this goal include: A. decr~asing ov~rall pe~ capi~a energy consumption; B, decreasing reliance on natural gas and oil; and C. inczeasing reliance on renewable energy sources. In order ta assure that energy implications are considexed in p~aject dec~sions, ~he California Environ~ental Q~ality Act requires that EIRs include a discussion of the potential energy impacts of p~oposed projects, w~th particu~ar emphasis an avoiding o~ reducing inefficient, waste~ul and unnecessary cons~mption of energy. Enexgy conse~vation implies that a project's ~ost effe~ti~eness be rev~ewed no~ on~y in dollar~, but also in terms of energy req~ire- ments. Far many projects, lifetime costs may be determined more by energy effic~ency than by ini~ial dol~ar cost~. II. EIR CONTEN~S Po~entially signi~ican~ energy implications of a proje~t sho~Id be consid~red in an ~IR. The following list of energy impact possi- bi~ities and potential consezvation measures is designed to assist in ~he preparation of an EIR. In many instances specitic items may not apply or additional items may be needed. A. Projec~ Des~ription may include the follawing items: 1. Energy cons~min~ equipmen~ and processes w~ic~ wi11 be used during construction, operation and/or remova~ of the projec~. If approp~~a~e, this discussion should consider the energy intensiveness of ~ate~ia~s and equipment required for rhe project. ' 2. Total ener~y requir~menCs of the project by ~Uel type and end use. 3. ~nergy conse~vatio~ equipment and design ~eaCures. 4. Initial an~ Iife-cyc~e energy costs ox supplies. B. Envi.ronmental SetCing may include exis~ing energy supp~ies and energy use patterns in the region and locali~y. c-i APPENDIX D SIGNIFICANT E~FECTS A project w~ll normally ~ave a significanC effect on the environment if it will: a. Con~lic~ with adop~ed env~~onmental p~ans and goa~s of the community where it is located; b. Have a substantial, demonstrable negative aesthetic effect; c. S~bstan~ial~y aff~c~ a rare or endangered species of animal ox p~ant or ~he habitat of the species; d. Int~~fe~e s.~bs~antially with the movement of any residenC or migxatory fish or wildlife species; e. Breach published natural, s~ate, or local standards relating to solid waste or litter con~rol; t. Substantially degrade waCez qualaty; g. ConCaminate a publ~c water supply; h. Substantially degrade or deplete ground wa~er resour~es; i. ~nCerfere substantially wi~h ground wa~er r~charge; ~. Disrup~ or alter an arc~aeological site over 2Q0 qears old, an historic site or a paleo~tologica~ siCe except as part a~ a scien~ific s~udy of the site; k. Induce subs~antia~ growth or cancentration of pop~lation; 1. Cause an increase in ~ra~fic w~ich is substan~ial in relation to the existing traffic ~oad and capacity of ~he streeC system; m. Displace a large number of people; n. Encourage activit~~s which result in the use of large amaunts of fuel or energy; o. Use f~e~ or energy in a was~e~u~ manner; p. In~rease s~bstantially the ambient noise Ieve~s for adjoining a~eas; q. Cause substantia~ f~ooding, erosion or si~ta~ion; r. Expase people or structures to major geologic hazards; D ~-1 s. Ex~end a sewer trunk line wit~ capacity to ser~e ~ew developments; C. Substantial~y dimin'ish habitat for fish, wi~dlife or plan~s; u. C~eate a major dxsrup~ion or division of Che physical arrangement of an esta~lished comm~nity; v. Create a po~en~ial public h~al~h hazard or invo~~e the ~se, projec~ion or disposal of materia~s which pose a~azar~ ta people, animal or plan~ populations in the area affec~ed; w. Conflict wirh established recreational, educational, religious or scien~tific ~ses of the area; x. Violate any ambien~ air quality standards, cont~ibute substa~tia~.ly to an existing or projected air q~ality vio~ation, or expose sen~itive receptors to subs~antial pollutant concent-~ation; . y. Co~v~r~ prime agricul.~ural land to non-agricv~tural use or impair ~he agricu~tural produc~i.vity o~ prime agri.cultu~al land; ~. Int~rfere with emergency response plans or emergen~y evacua~zon plans. D-2 ~OR O~FiCE USE QNLY: Fees collecred: ERC Other Total Receipt No. ERC Log. No. Date Filed APPENDIX E ~nvi~o~menta~ ~nformatian Form (To be compleCed by applicant No~e: Careful Completian of ~his Form Will Facili~ate Pro'ect Praces~in ) A. GENERAL INFORMATION 1. Name and address of developer or project sponsor: 2. ~ocation of project: 3. ~ame, address and telephane number of person ta be conCa~~ed concerning this pro~e~t: 4. ~ype ot ptoje~t {i.e. rezon~ng, subdivision): 5. List and des~~ibe any other relat~d permits and ot~er p~blic approva~s requir~d for this project, including Chose required by city, r~gxonal, State and Federal agencies: b. Existing zoning district: 7. Existing But~e County Genera~ Plan Designation: 8. Propos~d use of si~~: B. PROJEGT DESCRiPTION 9. Si~e size: E ~-1 10. Square faotage of building(s): 11. Number of floors of construction: ~2. Amo~nt of of~-streeC parkin~ provided: 13. Propos~d scheduling of constrvction: 14. Associated projects: 15. An~icipated incremen~al develap~en~ (desc~ibe total develop- ment p~an envisioned, including f~~Ure plans): 16. Propose~ densi~y of development {units per acre) 17, Describe vehicle access: 18. Haw wil~ surface drainage be acco~modated? and location o~ off-site improvements.} ~9. WiII excavation or grading be necessary? Cubic yard (estima~e) 20. Wate~ so~rce: 2~, Proximi~y ot water for fire fighting purposes (hydrants, ponds, e~c.}: 22. ~roposed sewage disposa~ method: 23. Proxirni~y a~ power ~ines: Z4. ~f residential, indicate number and ~ype af units (i.e, one- bedroom, two-bedraom, detached, townhause, etc.): (Describe type E-2 2S. If commercial, indica~e the Cype, whether neighbor~ood, ci~y or regiona~ly oriented, sq~are footage o~ sa~es area, and loadin~ faci~ities: 26. zf ~ndustrial, indi~ate type, estimated emplayment p~r shzft, and loading faciiiti~s: 27. I~ i~sti~utional, indica~e the type, estimated emplo}rment per shi~~, estzmated occupancy and ~oading facitiities: C. ENVIRONMENTA~ IMPACTS Are the followin~ items applicable to t~e project or its effe~~s? Discuss below a11 times chec~ed yes {attach addiCional she~ts as necessary) . Xes Ma~ No - 28. Chan~e in existing featur.es of any beaci~es, lakes, hills, or substantial alteraCian of ground contours. 29. SignificanC change in ~cenic views or vistas from existing residential areas or public ~ands or roads. 30. Signi~icant~y change pattern, scale or c~arac~er of general area of projec~.. 31. Significanr amo~ints af solid waste or litter. 32. Change in dust, ash, smflke, fumes or odors in V~Gli7lty. 33. Significant change in ~ake, s~ream, or gro~nd waCer quality or quantity, or altera- tion of existing draznage patter~s. 34. Substan~ial change in ex~.sting noise or vibration ~evels in the vicinz~y. E-3 Yes Maybe No 35. Site on filled land or on sLope of 30 pe~Cent or ~ore. 36. ~se or disposal of potentially hazardous materials, such as toxic subsCanc~s, ~~ammabl~s or explosives. 37. Substant~a~ change in demand for mun~ci~a1 se~vices (police, fi~e, wa~er, sewage, etc.) 3$. Substantially increase ~assil fue~ consumption (e~ec~~icity, oi1, natural gas, etc.) 39. Relationship to part of a larger project or series a~ projec~s. 40. Remaval af a substantaal amount of natural vegetataan. D. MIT~GATION yEASURES 41. W~at proje~t d~sign ~eatures or spe~ia~ condztions of app~aval (mitigation measures} are proposed to a~leviate potential envitonmenCal impacts? E. ENVIRONMEN'FAL SET~ING 42. Desc-~il~e the pro~ect site as it exists before the pro~ec~, inc~.uding informat~on on ~apography, soil srability, plants and ani~nals, and any ~ultural, historical ar sCenic as~eCts. Describe any exis~ing st~euc~ures on ~he 51C2i and the use of the structures. ~-~ 43. Describe the surro~nding properties, including information on pian~s and anima~s and any cultural, historica~ ar scenic aspec~s. Indica~e the type of Zand use {residen~ial, co~mercia~, etc.), i~~ensity of land use (one-family, apar~ment ho~ses, shops, departV me~t s~ores, erc,), and scale of development {height, ~rontage, set- back, rear ya~d, etc.) . CERTIF~CA'~ION: Z hereby certify that the s~atements furnished above and in ~h~ atCached exhibits present the da~a and infarmation requi~ed for th~.s initia~. evaluation to the best of_my' abili~y, and that t~e facts, staCements and information prasente~ a~ee true and co~rect to the best of my knawledge and belief. Date Signature For E-5 APPEND~X ~ - ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKL~ST FORM (Ta be complete~ by Lead Agency) I. BACKGRO~ND ERC Log ~ ~. 2. Name of Address Propon~nt and Rhone Num er o Proponen~: 3. 4. 5. ~ate o~ Agency Na~e of Checkiist Requiring Proposal, Submitted Checklist i~ appLzca e II. ENVIRONMENTAL YM~ACTS ~Explanations of all "yes" an~ "maybe" answers are requared on attached sheets.) YES N3AYBE NO 1. Earth. Wil~ the propasal resul~ in significant: a. Unstabl~ ear~h conditians ot in changes in geoJ.o~ic sCructures? b. Disruptian, d~splacemer~t, com- paction or overcavering of the sail? c. Change in ~opography or ground surface relief fea~u~res or removal of topsoil? d. Destruc~ion, cavering or modi~ fication of any' unique~geologic or physical fea~ures? e. Increase in wi.nd or waCer erosian o~ soiLs, eit~er on- or off-site? f. Changes i.n depositio~ or erosion of beach sands, or c~anges in siltation, ~epo~ si~ion or erosion whach may modify the c~anne~ of a river or stream or the bed of ~he ocEan or any bay, iniet or lake? ~-1 YES MAYBE NO g. Loss of prime agricultura~ly prod~ctive soils outside designa~~d ~rban areas? h. Exposure o~ peop~e or property to geolo~ic hazards such as earthquakes, landslides, mud- slides, gxound failure, or similar hazard~? 2. Air. Wi11 th~ proposal result in: a. Substantial deterioration of ambient or ~o~a1 air quality? b. The Creation of objecCiona~le odoxs, smoke ox t~mes? c. Signi~icanC al~eration of air movement, moisture or tempera~ure or any change in climate, either locally or regionally? 3. Water. Wi~l the proposal resu~t in subs~antial: a. C~anges in currenrs, or ~he course or direction of wat~r movemen~s? b. Changes in absorption rates, drainage patterns, or the ra~e and amoun~ of surface watez runoff? c. N~ed fo~ aff-site surface dra~nage improvemenCs, incl~ding vegetatian removal,~channe~iza- tion or culvert insta~latian? d. A1Cerations ~o th~ course or flow of flood waters? e. Change in the amou~t of surface ~ water i.n any water body? f. Uischaxge inCO surtace waters, o-~ ~.n any al~eration of surface waCer qual.iCy, including bu~ not limited to temperature, dissol~ed oxygen or turbidity? F-2 YES MAYBE NO g. A1t~raCion of the directzon or rate a~ flow of ground waters? h. Change in the quantity or quality o€ gxound wate~s, either through direc~ additions or withdrawals, or through in~er- ception of an aquifer by cuts or excavaCionS? i. Reduction in the amounr of water atherwise ava~~ab~e ~or public or private water supplies? j. Exposure of peop~e or property to water re~atea hazards such as floading? 4. Pla~t Life Wil1 the proposal resul~ in subs~antia~: a. Loss af vegetaCion or change in the diversity of species or n~m~er of any specxes af plants (including ~rees, shrubs, grass, crops, mzcro- flora and aquatiC plants)? b. Reduction of the numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species o~ plants? c. Introductio~ of new species of plants into an area, ar in a ba~rier ta the narmal replenish- ment of exis~ing 5pecies? d. Reduction in acreage of any agricultura~ crop? 5. Animal Life. Will t~e prapasal -cesult a.n' su6~'stanCial.: a. Change in the diversity af s~ecies, or numbers of any species of animals (birds, land animals, ~.ncluding rep~zles, fish, and shellfish, bent~h~c o-cganisms, insects or microfauna)? b. ReducCian of ~he numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species of animals? F-3 YES MAYBE vU c. Introduc~ion of new species of an~ma~s into an area, or result in a barrier to the migration or movement of animals? d. Reduction of, encraachment upon, or deterioration ~o existing fish or w~ldlife habitat? 6. Naise. Will the proposal result in su stantia~: a. Increases ~n noise levels? b. Exposure of people to severe noise l~v~ls? 7. Li ht and Glare. wi~l the proposal pro uce sign~~can~ 1ighC or glare? 8. Land Use. wi11 t~e proposal result in a sign~ficant: a. Alteration of the planned ~and use of an area, ar establish a trend whic~ wi~l demonstrably ~~ad to such aite~ation? b. Conflict with uses on adjoining properties, or con- flict with established recrea- tional, educational, rel3gious or sc~entific uses of an area? 9. NaturaZ Reso~rces. Wi~l the proposal result zn s~ stantial: a. Demand for, or inCrease in the rate of use of any natural resources? b. Depletion of any non-renewable naCurati resource? lU. Risk o~ Upset. Does t~e praposal invo ve a risk of an exp~osion or _ the releas~ of hazardous substances (including, but not limited to, oil, pes~icides, chemicals or radiation) in the even~ of an accident or upset condi~ions? F-4 YES MAYB~ ~0 11. Po ulation. Will the proposal signi icant~y alter ~he ~ocation, distribution, densi~y, ar growth rar~ of the human pogulation of an area or physi.cally divic~e an established COmIDUnity or facilitate deve~.~p~nen~ of adjoinin~ propertzes? 12. Housrn . Wil~. th~ proposal s~gn~fi- can~affec~ existing t~ousing, or create a demand for adda.tzonal hous i.ng? 13. Transportat~on/Circula~~on. wi~.I. ~he proposal result in: ~ a. Generation of s~bstantial additional vehicular movement? b. 5igni~icant effects on existi~g parki.ng; facilities, or demand . for new parkin~? c. Subs~antia~ i~npact upon existing transporta~~.on systems? d. Si.gn~ficant altera~ions to present patterns of circulation or mvvement ot people and/or goods? e. A1te~ations to waCerborne, rail or air traffic? f. Increase in traffic congestion or hazards ~o motar vehi.cles, bicyclis~s or pedestrians? 14. Public Services. Wi11 the praposal ave an ~ ect upon, or res~al~ i.n a substantial need for new or alte~ed go~ernmental serv.ices in any o~ C~e fo~lawing a~eas: a. Fire protection? b. Police protection? c. Schoals? ~'-5 YES MAYBE NO d. Parks or other recreationa~ faci~iries? e. Ma~ntenance af public fa~~liti~s, including roads? f. O~hex governmental services?. 15. Ener~~. Wi11 the propasa~ resul~ in: a. Use of s~bstantial amounts of ~uel or energy? b. Subs~ant~al increase in demand : upon ex~sting sources of energy, or require the deve~opment of ~ew sources flf energy? 16. ^ti~ities. Will the ~rapasa~ resul~ in a~ ~or new systems, or sub- s~ant~al alterations to ~he ~ollowing utiliries: a. Power or natural gas? b. Co~munzcatzons systems? c. Wat~r? ~. Sewer (wi~l trunk ~ine be extended, providing capacity to serve new de~elopmen~}? e, Storm watez drainage? I7. Human Heal~h. Wi11 the proposa~ resu ~ in: a. Creation of any health hazard or potential hea~th hazard (exc~uding menta~ health)? ~ b. Exposure o~ peop~e to potential health hazards? 18. Solid Waste. wil~ the proposal resu t in any signi~ican~ impacts associa~ed with solid wasCe dis~osa~ or litter control? F-6 YES MAXBE NO 19. Aes~~etics. Will t~e proposal result in the obstruction of any pub~ic designated or r~cognized sceni~ vista open to the pub~ic? Will the proposal result in the creatio~ of an aesthetically offensive site op~en to pubiic view? ~ Wi1I the proposal significant~y a1Cer the character of ~he area? 2Q. Recreation. WiII the proposal. ~esu t ia an impact upon the quality or quan~ity of existing public re~reation fa~i~ities? 21. Archaeolo i.ca1/Historical. Will the proposa resu t in an alteratian of a ~igni£zcant a~chaeological or historical site, structure, object or buildzng? 22. Manc3a~or ~indin s of Si nificanCe. ~ a. Do~s ~he project ha~~ the potential ta degrade the quaii~y of the ~nva.ronment, subs~antially ret~uce the t~abitat of a~ish or wildlife species, caus~ a fish or wil~life po~ulation to drop be~.ow s~1f- sustainir~~ levels, threaten to el.imi.nate a p~.ant or an~.mal commur~ity, reduce Che nun~ber or restric~ Che ra~ge of a ra~e or _ endangered plant or animal or eliminate importan~ examples of ~he major peraods of California history o~c prehisCory? b. Does the p~oject have Che potential to aclnieve shorC-tern~ benefits to • the detrzment of publicly adopted long-~e~m environmenta~ goals? / F-7 YES MAYBE NQ c. Does the project have impac~s ~ w~ich are individually limiCed, but c~~ulative~y considerable? (A project may ~mpact on two o~ more separate resaurces where the impact on each resource is ~~1a~ively sma~l, b~t w~ere the effect ~af the total of Chose impac~s on ~he environment is si~nifi~ant.) d. Does the projec~ have ~nviron- menta~ effects wk~ich will cause subs~.antial adverse effects on human beings, either directly or indi~ectly? III. DISCUSSION 4F ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATI~N F-$ IV. DETERM~NAT~ON ~ {To be compLeted by the Lead Agency) On the basis of this initial evaluation: Q" I find the proposed project COULD NOT have a signi~icant effect on the environment, and a N~GATIVE DECLARATIUN is reca~mEnded. Q I find Cha~ a~thaugh the proposed project could have a signifzcan~ e~fect on the env~ronment, there will not be a significant effect in this case because the mitigation measures described on ~he aCta~hed sheet have been added to the pro~ec~. A NE~ATIVE DECLARAT~ON IS RECOMMENDED. ~ Q I find ~he proposed p~oject MAY have a significanC effecC on the environment, and an ENVIRONM~NTAL IMPACT REPOR~ is requi~ed. Dat~ Signature For: Planning Department Revzewed by: Environ~ental Review Coordina~or F-9 APP~NDIX G NEGA~IVE DECLARATION REGARDiNG ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT 1. NOTiCE zS HERESY GIVEN tha~ the praject described below has been re~iewed pursuant to the provisions of the California Envi~onme~ta~ Qua~ity Act of 1970'(Public Resouzces Code §§2I100; et se .} and a dete~~ination has been made.tha~ it wi1~ nor have a sig~icant effect upan the environment. 2. DESCRIPTION OF PRO%~EC~: 3. LOCA~~~N OF ~ROJECT: 4. NAME AND Al]URESS QF ~ROJECT APPLICANT: 5. MITIGATION ~iEASURBS: 6. A copy of the Env~ronmen~al kevi~w Coo~c~inator's ini~ial stuciy. regarding the environmental effe~t of this project is at~ached. Z'his study was Q Adop~ed as presen~ed. C7 AdopCed wit~ changes. Specific modifications and supporting ~easons are at~ached. 7. A pub~ic hearing on this Negative Declaration was held by the decasion-making body. Hearing Body Date of De~ermination G -- I Determination: On C~e basis of the Environmental Review Coordina~ar's initial s~udy~, the infarmation presented ar hearings, comments received on the proposal and our own knowledge and independent research: Q We find the proposed p~oject COULD NOT have a significant eftect on the enviranmen~, and a NEGATIVE DECLARATION is hereby adopted. ~ Cj We find that the project could have a signifi~ant e~fect an the enviranmen~ but wi,ll not in this case because of attached mitiga~i.on measures described in ztem 5 above which are by ~hz.s reference made.condi~ions of project appra~a7.. A candiCional N~GATIVE DECLARAT~O~ is hereby adopt~d. DATE: Si~nat~re ~ Name Tit e G- 2 APPEtiUIX H NOTICE ~F DETERMINAT~ON T0: Q Secretary ~or Resourc~s ~ 1416 Ninth Street, Room 1311 - Sacramento, CA 95814 Q County Clerk FKUM: (Lead Agency) ~ Co~nty of Si3B,7ECT: Filing of Not~ce of Determination in Complian~e with §2~108 or §21152 of Che Public Resources Code Pro~ect Titie ~ta~e C~.earing ause Num e~ I su mitte to 5~at~ C~.earing~ouse Cantact Person Telephone ~kum er Project Loca~ion Project Description: This is to advise that the Lea Agency or Responsible Agency as made t e ollowing etermir~ations tegarding ~he above-described project: l. ~he pro~~c~ Q wi~l Q wi11 noC have~ a signi~icanC. e~fect on the enviranment. 2. Q An Environmental ~mpac~ Repor~ was pr~pared for t'hzs projec~ pursuant to ~he proviszons of CEQA, and was certified as required by §15085(g), 14 California Administrative Code. H-I Q A Negative Declaration was prepared for this project pursuant Co ~he provisions of CEQA. A copy of the Negative -eclaratian may be examined a~ the Enviro~mental Review Department, 3 County Center Drive, Oroville, Ca~iforn~a 95965. ~ ~he EIR or Negative Declara~ion and record af project approva~ may be examined at: 3. ~ A Notice of Exemption was filed indica~ing this project is exempt from environme~ta~ review. 4. A statement of Overriding Consideration Q was ~ was not adop~ed for this projec~. 5. Mitigation measures adopt~d by the Lead Agency to reduce the impacts of the app~oved.project are: Signa~.ure T~t e Date H-2 _ ,, /"~ . ~r c o ~ f ~ ~ T ~ ~ -; ~r ^ ~ ~ ~ ~, ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~, _ ~ ~ ~ rn ~ ~ ,~ R ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ o z ~o ~ ~ ~, o a ~ ~, ~ ~ ~ ~ o u ~ o ~ ~ ~. ~ m s ~ `~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ n ~ - ~ Z ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ r -rt ci n ~ ~ ~ c r~ m ~ * N {A ... ~ " X i Air quali+y artd air callutian corttrol Ch4iniccl contamination x ~ crtd food prod~cts X x X ~ Caasial areas, wetiands, estuaries, waterfowi reiuges, and beaehes a Congestion in ur6an areas, hau~ing and 6uilding dispiaeament ~,' ea Oisaasa eantrol x ~ leetria ener4Y gene-arion and supp{y Ereviromnental aFieets wieh sqecial ~ irr~Qact in low-incame neigf~borhoods x x x ~ x, ~ ~ ~ ar Flood plains qnd walersFeds ~ Food additives and faod sanitarion X Y p h'ar~icides i Historic and ~'G 1 i Areheologica~ siTes ' X '` Mvman eealogy N rj h4icrokfeoiogical cantaminatian I x ~ ~IREfQ~ ~Cf7~ fCC~OTOflOf1 , • .~ . Natural gas energy dcve~apment ' ~ generqtian and svpp~y q~ t~lav;gabie nirwcys ' X V Naviga~la waterways ~ Noise'eontrof and abateme~} . ~ porks, fores's, srees and ovtdoar x ~ ~ rCGfeqTiOn afCp~ ;~ ;+~ o Past9cides ~ `~ j Radiation and redialogical healtE~ ~ Re~ionai eomgranensive pkanning `rC W Rodenl eontrok ~ ~ X a Sartirotion and wasre sysTems N ShellFis'n eanisatian cn ~ 'x ~ x ~' l ~ ~ 6 s ~ ~ i n d hyd rolag c cond an erosian ~ ~ '/. y To:ie inqierials ~ ~ ~ T~ansportatian and handling af hazcrdavs mafcrials ~ ~ x y ~ 1 r .~y 'Nqier Guaiify ar1~ iD warer ol~ufion controi y~ x ~! ~! ;/' ~ ~ o ~isl~ and +~ildtifa ~ A~tiv;ries wi!h speeial impnct on -w regional jurisdicr~ons ' yY % ~ i~ ;rC N '+~mrr ~rojact Eorm~iation ~ ~' I I I r„W,~ C'ieothermal energy • ' ~,y Qii and petroleum da~elopment, I - I A generation and svpA~y I ~ $rarewide land ~se parterr,s ~ ~^ ~pen $paer pokicy ~ 4 Vy Srotcwide averview-tumularive ~ ~ ~ im pact af seaerate pra{ects APPENDlX = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ @~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t!~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m~ ~ ~ Pg. ~: Of APPENDIX J NOTICE ~F COMPLETION (a~ Draft Environmen~a~ Impact Report) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY: D~~ART~E~T: Gounty of ~u~te ~lan~ing PROJECT T~TL~: ~ ADDR~SS: CITY: COUNTY: 7 Caunty Center Drive Orovi~le ~~-~~~ CONTACT PERSON: AREA COD~: PHONE: Environmental Review Coordinator 91b 534-~+6Q1 PROJECT DESCRIFTION OF NAT~JRE, 1'URPOSE AND BEtiEF~CIARIES: PRO.~ECT LOCATION CITY: PROJEGT LOCATION COUNTY: Bu~te TIME PERIQD PROVIDED FOR REVIEW: ADDR~SS,WH~RE COPY OF DR.AFT EIR IS AVAILAB~E: Planning Department aunty Center Drive, rov~ e, :~ - i ~NN~rr~ix x Qo not typa to th~ left of dottetl Ilne. CA- l 89 FEQERAL GRANT I.. ~CATEONIAWARR 11fOT~FICATIOf~t '. 1 naPUCATION DASE STAT~ aF CALI~ORNkA .. ,,.;TE CLEARII~GHQUS~ (916} 445-0613 v~ m~ tl•y 17L~75 1 31 TO BG CUMPLt7ESJ 4i1' APPL~C.~1f~17 19 ^~ 2 FEO£FIAL EMPLOY 3. APPLICANT - OrOmlxet~onal IJnst n. A~~RE55 - Street or P. O. Box EA ID NQ, 5. C~T~Y . , 6. COUNTY 7.STA7E e. ZrP CODE 9. PRDG TITLEIND. ICatakpg pl Fed Romrs[ic Assistance~ E OF ACTION 70. TY TYPE OF CHAkGE (COmplete ef 10b or lOc was checkatll 74. EXLSTiNG FE~ GRANY Ib ~a ~ IVew c ~ Madilicsi+On t~. 12, i3. • D lncr•~aed Oollan a D I ncreasatl OunciO~ e^ O~her $eoAf Chenp ~~Cantlnuation b ~~ecreesetl flotlers C ~Decreased O~rntion b~Csntalletipn ' y~ mo 19.APPL~CANTTYPE FuxASRFpUESTED1FwCMnPSSnowOnfrAmco~MCNforp.c,l~7.1 76. REQVE57H0 FVND STAHT 79_~ Enter Lot~er A. State F. Schaol ~is7nct z0. ffpExac ( 15 .DO 16. FU~1O5 DURA7iON _.._IMpnthq g, knier~tata G. Co+w*+uniiy Ae[ion Agene zi S~AYf ~ 1$ •~ yf m0 C. Sub StstO Dici ii, SPO~SOred 4•ge~~TaNo~ 12. COCAL ~~~ .~ P 77. ES'C. Pfi6J€CT START 1~,_,~, ~_ p, Councy i. Indian 7] OTFrER / 1 S .00 19. ESt. PAOJECT QVRATION _IManthsl E. C~tv J. Other ISoeci[y in RamarksS 74. TOT.at l20,7t,77,77~ ~~ S •~ A 25. BA~EF TlTLE OF q ~ APPL~CANT'$ PiiOJECT ~ i~ ~ 1 28. DE~GRIPTION OP APPLiCANT'S PpOJEGT (PUrposel 27. AR~A OF PqpJECT IMPACT fkndic~ve Ci[y, Coun[y,5ceta, e~c.1 Wi~E wIQE UL I- COVNTY ~ 5~.° ~ ° ~' 26. CO GRE5530NAL RISTRICT 29, Environmentel AeSessment Rrquiratl 3p. CLEARINGHOUSE[S1 70 WHICH 5UBM~TTEF] O~ Applicant ^estdcts Impecied By Prafect SY Sie7e/Fe6erol A9ency7 Q Ves ~~,' ~ C ] ^NO a:~5taee b ^Ar08Wid0 c^~VonC 31. 0 ry~`qME/1'ITLf OF CONTACT PERSON b ADORE55 - Strcet or P. O. Box c TELEPiiDNE NO. 37. d 1~ ENVLfidNMENTAI. pOCIiMEN7 REVIEW REQU]RED ti'£5 ~l NO [_] e Will [he project require reloca[ian? h If prpject is physi~l in natu*epr requires an {ist the V enwronmente3 document S ~} Yes [7 ~nvironmenta4 Imoaa Stetemen[ IReponl Attached ~20 wpiesl YE N~ , . . GeologicSurvey~vadranglemap~nwhlrhthe ~ DraftElR ~ Fina]EIR 8 Negative Declaration Atiaahed 12p cap~es} 1 Does your a~ency have a a fvmative civi~ nghts project is loceted. None a[rsahad - Dotumenr Will Be Forwarded On ~ ~ , action policvand pfan. Apprnxima[ely YES F"-i NO ~ sKOn oay vear g Ispr o ec[ cavered by ~t EV? A `~~ If No ^ Federal Program ~oes Not Require An Enwronmencal qocumem C'~ Project Exempt Under Stete Categoriol £xemption Ciass • . YES ~ NO , - ~ ]f yes. is 6A executed. Y E 5[~ n40 C i7@an532387p BE CO^.+~~E7t09r C~FnFinG~OUS'= MiILTI LE 32.CLEaRiNGHquSE iD I ~CLE~tRINGWOV5E i ~ , 33. a FSCTEON ~ASEO ON 33. ~ qC71btV TAKEfV ~ FIEVIEWOF STATEAPPL~C/7iON c~ «W i ~Wi hC a '~~' ~ A I I II III ~ ~ ~~NotHicatian ~ a e ommem a ve ~p~ryTIFiFR ISAl1 ~S_,..1,,. ___1._l 3_ A ti~Apolieetion h I~ Wiehove Commene. d~I UnlBVOrabiE 51h[C Numblr R ~ S747E WIDE County/ C~[y Covntv C~ey ~ Co~nty~ C~tv Co~nty Gtv P P~ A~ Coun=y C+ev p Coun~y L~:v Ar Pin 35. CLF~~IR~NGhSOUSE ~a PIn9 Area I ing A~ee I PI~g P.eae ~6 i~g 4•ee g ea T I IMPACT C017E ^ Yec ^ No I I I ~ , I ~ ~ , Z 3fi.57Y+TE PLAra AEOUiAEO 3~. i,E CE~vi~c~:~ U ~TC %' ^`~~ ~'•~~~ 3a. a SIGNATUAE OF CH QFFICIAL =.7 CLC:.F7~:~i~~+~:~i~Si. 19~~ _ ^ vec ^NO 38. FI~dAL CH ACTIO~V i74TE ~~ ^~a ^"~ 19~ .,,,,.^ ITEMS 39~42 TO BE C~~=YLE7L6 Fv ANri iC-', ;~[I ~~;~~.~. SEna~'::, ~~~r.'~' T:) ~ EOt aaE a~EuCr ~ T~e applfes~S CeRIliet Zhbi [o [he bBCS oF hiF knowlBtlg~ and bel~e! [hB above tla[e ere [ruu antl .Check 6ox if elearin house 39. CE#iTIFICATION - 9 i i ' eorreCt entltllingof thiiform hes heen tluly pueh4r i2ep ~y the gowerning potlv O~ ihe apAl~ca~t. .f¢SpOf15@ i58t[BCh~, L~ ' R AME IPrint or Typa) 4Q. a h TITLE c$lGNATLJRE ot Aoenonzetl Reare~ertietiue tl TE~EPnONE Nl1M8EA ~ 41. ~RTE MqILED TD FEDERqLISTAFE AGENCY V~ ~no dav ~2. t~tAlv1E OP FEOER~+L i 5TATE AGENCY 3 tg_ _~ I i TQ WH1CH THtS APPLICAT14N SU9iN[TTED ITEy5a3-SaTO$ECOMPLETE6BY~E~LK:.i.;i'rV~Ci. Lti+,t~_.Af~NC,PNDRIC~»."~:!`:l)~1~~:.CSiON~:*:7~s4 ~vrL~C~~~~}h 43. GFjANT APPLICATVON I ~ 52- 4noi~cauo~. ReCC. ~:_ e E.;~ .,..~.,~, ~,,,. ~ y[ ~. ~,.~ o, , e ~IAsiignetl bY Fetlera] ApencY) I ~ ~ ~ ~.~.~ .~.,. vr mr. o.n . . ~. .. ~~ ~ ~ qiwaVS ComA~e[e ~ ? 53.a OR b r~~ - - ~ "~ ~--» ---«- - 44. G' AlVTOR AGENCV 79 -~-~~ ~ - P y - {54.txP Pc1~on ~ i ...i ~, .~F~•s i~, I.~~! Amc~tladAf+t~l~[. i R I F~ . i ~ ~ Re~iee0 A ~i n ' R A . cx . ~cn ~ eu ecc•~~eu ' ~ E~ p as a~ E dS.OFfGAN12ATIONALU~IFT ~ V i V I V; R i 1 ~ ~~~ ~ m r m o I. ~~ ~ ~ i . „r ,..~~ v~ ~., ... Y o ~iaY o av ~ ~ f r ~! ~ i S ~ 4 t<~ ~ !~ 19 119 46.A,MINSST£RkPfGOFFeCE ~ ~ --- ~ ' '--"--' ---~ ~ ~ --- ~ F ~ 19 !f ~ 1B tf ~ S ~ ! i i9,~,T, - - ~ 5 - _ ' 19 --- $ ~'~~ ---~- -~... 5 ~ ---.~ 47. A~bflE55 - STreei or P. p. goa ~48. CtT Y ~' ~ eg.5T4TE ` - -- - -~J SO Z~p COflE 57 7ELEPrt6N@ NUMBfR ~l5 .`.'I:'. Sr~ li~ Tfs t5F C~11'li~•i ! 7! [1 i'.1 ~~.! 4 I ill ':.11 .'~~ 1~~1 :.S'i'~;.'~..',ti~ 1~~1 ..i:.1`:T .11'I'i IC:11 ~~~ti ~ Fi qLACTIOh FiNALOATES yr mo aar FUNOSAPPAdVEO(ForChangesShowOnlyAmr.oflnc.l+larAet.(-l.I A I ~ 55. a~ q,vardetl b u fle~ected ~ J Wnnara.vn T9 6D. FEDERAL AMOUNT !F Y_luntlsJ ! 1 5 .00 == J56. F~JNOS AVAILA6LE ~y ~..,. j 6L STATf SHaRE ( IS .a0 ~ ~57. ENDING DATE i9 ~~ I G2. LOCAL SNARE ( 1 S .OO T SB. F~p~RAL GRANT ID B.~.OTHER ( J$ .QO ~ ~ ~ ea. rorac rsn, st, sz, sa1 r fa .on ~ F OERAL FVN~ ACCOUNT NUMBEA 59 65. MULTIPLE PAOGRRM-LffUK ~ . A~PENDIX L NOT I C E 0~' PREPARAT I UN TQ: FROM: Responsi ~e Agency Lead Ag~ncy) (Address (Adaress) SU~JECT: Notice of Preparatzan a~ a Draft Environmental Impact Report. w~ll be the Lead Agency and will prepare an Env2ronm~nta ~mpact Report for the projec~ identified below. We need to know C.he views of your agency as to the scope and content of the environmental. information which is german~ to qour agency's statutory responsibilities in connectior~ with the proposed p-rojecC. Your agency will need ta use the ~IR prepared by our agency when consic~ering your permzt or other approval for the project. The proje~.t description, location and probable environm~nCai effects are ~ontained ~.n the attached materials. A copy' of the Initzal S~udy Q is, C] is not, a~tached. Due ta the time limits manda~ed by State l.aw, your ~esponse must be sen~ at ~ne ~arl~.es~ possible date ~bu~ not la~er than 45 days af~er receipt of tha.s notice. Please send your response to at the address shown above. We wi~l need the name for a cantact person in your agency. PROJECT T~~LE: PROJECT APPL~CANT, IF ANY: DATE 5 igna t ur e Title Telep~o~e L-1 ~.,_ _ . . . 3 ~ . t . . -:ti ~ ' ' . . - ` i . - ~ . . ~ - . . . , . . ~ . . - riL Z ~1VLiL\ 1'-..-Y -Tm~- ~ - . . '~-_-..~ . . . , ~ ; BUTT ` C4 U NTY ~ ~ ~; : - ENVIRON MENTAL REV1 EVY PRO CESS , ., . . ~ - P R I VAT E P~R 0 J E C T S APPLlCATION ~ . so ~ • bF.PARTMENT ~ CAT. ~ ~ YE . EX. OR IYIINIS. 7 ' HO ' . ~REPARATION OF ~~ ? HEARING 01~ NEGATIV~ DEC. SIGtIIF[CANT NEGATIVE pEG ~Y ERC ~ i IMPA . ~s d~G. D~G. N~ E. I. R. ' . ADOPTE~ 15 R80UIRED r~s ~?eC~.51.a31 . m2ka.ng b~ ~s - . ~~ APPEALER APPEAI. FEAR~NG p NO NO APP[.~ SUBIAI £G4TIV~ DE ~~~~ ~ ? OF ~IRAF~ ELR. YES E i.R ~ ~~SEJI.7ANT PR~+4RED BY ? E.R.C PREFARATIt3M OF FiHQL ~RAFT C~k5UL7ANT N~G4T'V~ SU9MITS ~~C. BY E R.G. ~~~pF~~~ tNF4RMATION ~ NEGAT}y~ C~RCtELA710fJ ~ ~ D E G. TO ADOP1'ED AGENCIES COiV:MENT5 ~ . AND ~ RESPON5ES SUBI~['~' HEAR!NG A~~I~IONAI. . INFORMAI'IdN ~ ~ ~ ~ ADOPTEO ~~ ? YES ~ ~ CERT~F1GATiON ; QF E3Ji. DE CISI01~ ON ~ROJECT NOTICE OF DETERM[NAT10N PREPAREp ~ AHD FILEG M~ITF! COUKYY Cl,£RK AN D. ~ `P L"A M~iJ3~F.3_r;DE~'AR T M~~~+1~.'f ~ ' 1 FI~ING FEES FOR ENV~RONMENTAL REVIEW Rezones and General ~1an Amendments Use Permits Varzances LAFC t-lnnexations Sewage 17isposa3. Permits Waiv~er o~ Farcel Maps Miscel~aneaus Land Divisians and Condomin~ums of four u~its or less Subdivisions, parce~ maps invol.ving more than fo€~r parcels a~~ Condomi~niums o~ mo~e tinan faur uni.ts Multiple project: $220 $22U $140 ~ZZa $220 $22(~ $~2U ~224 $22t7 + $5 per lat {or unit) the amount not to exceed a a ~ota1 of $5Q0 A multigLe project is where the same site is affect~d by two or more related project5 at the same location, if the application for each succeeding project is fi~ed within six months af the preceeding project. The fee for a m~ltiple project shal~ be compu~ed as rhe sum of the highest projecr fee plus 50 percent ot each additional p~oject fee. PRQCEDURES FOR DETERMI~IATION C1F COSTS FOR PREPARATION OF ~N~IIRONMENTAL ZMPACT REPORTS Pr~va~e and Publ.ic I'ro,~ects: The applicant sha~.l pay all costslincurr~d or admin~stratian and preparat~.on af an environinenCal impa~t report up to and including the fi.ling of all i~otices of Deter- mina~ion relat~d ro the project. The ~nvironmenCal Review Coordinator shall est~mate costs associa~ed with the preparation and administ~caC~on of the environ- men~al impact report. In pr~paring the estimate o~ costs for env~ronmenta~ impact reporC preparation ant3 administra~ian, th~ Environmenta~. Review Coordinator shall inclucie public h~aring attendance, printing costs, Consu3.tant`s fees, if any, and a.ny o,ther relevant expenses incurred by t~e County. In estima~ing the costs of personnel time, the Environm~n~al. Review Coordinato~ shall mul.tiply the hourlq salary rate of County employees involved in Che preparatinn and administration of the env~~onm~ntal impact repar~ by a factor of two.