HomeMy WebLinkAbout04.09.21 Public Works - Director's Report April 2021
From:Pack, Joshua
To:Alpert, Bruce;Bennett, Robin;Clerk of the Board;Connelly, Bill;Cook, Holly;Cook, Robin;Kimmelshue, Tod;
Lucero, Debra;Paulsen, Shaina;Pickett, Andy;Ring, Brian;Ritter, Tami;Rodas, Amalia;Sweeney, Kathleen;
Teeter, Doug
Cc:Ott, Radley;Nuzum, Danielle;Smith, Micah;Partain, Amanda;Bridgnell, Bill;Cissell, Craig;Hightower, Scott;
Cooper, Raymond;Edwards, Terry;McDowell, Felicia;Cambra, Brett
Subject:Public Works - Director"s Report April 2021
Date:Friday, April 9, 2021 12:52:16 PM
Attachments:April 2021 Public Works Director"s Report Final.pdf
Good afternoon Board members –
Please see my attached Director’s Report for April 2021. I hope that this monthly report will
provide valuable insight into key Public Works activities that you may not typically receive
through other more traditional settings. I have attempted to present this information in a
format that can easily be passed on to your constituents. With that said, I’m happy to revise
the style or format o this Report to better meet the Board’s needs.
Please feel free to contact me directly if you have any questions or would like to discuss items
in greater detail.
I look forward to seeing you all on Tuesday!
Josh
Joshua Pack
Director of Public Works
7 County Center Drive Oroville, CA 95965
530.538.7681 Phone
530-538-7171 Fax
jpack@buttecounty.net
PUBLIC WORKS
DIRECTOR’S REPORT
April2021
Butte County Public Works
Joshua Pack, Director
Department of Public Works
530-538-7681
7 County Center Drive
jpack@buttecounty.net
Oroville, CA 95965
CSA 172 Retention Pond Vegetation Removal
March 16, 2021
0
1
INTRODUCTION
This update focuses on recent major activities and provides the Board of Supervisors a summary of Public
Works projects and operations. Additional information is always available by contacting me directly.
FACTS OF THE MONTH
Did you know?
Public Works maintains approximately 1,300 miles of roadways, over 500 bridges and drainage
structures, and more than 18,000 road signs.
If all Butte County Roads were lined up one by one, we would be able to travel from San Diego to
Austin, Texas.
The Butte County Pavement Condition Index - or condition of all publicly maintained roadways
including cities–was 60 in 2018. The represents a 10-point drop over the past ten years.This
condition includes both county- and city-maintained roads. Butte County roads are rated at a 53.
Overall, Butte County Public Roads are considerably worse than the Statewide average of 65 and
considered “at-risk” by a 2018 California Statewide Local Streets and Roads Needs Assessment.
SUPERVISOR DISTRICT UPDATES
District 1
Beginning April 12th, the Las Plumas Avenue and Lincoln Boulevard Safe Routes to School Project will
construct road and sidewalk improvements on portions of both roads. Spring work will begin on Lincoln
Boulevard from Monte Vista Avenue to Arnold Avenue. Las Plumas Avenue improvements are scheduled
to start after schools adjourn for summer break to minimize impacts to school traffic. Public Works plans
to complete repairs to guardrail damaged by the North Lightning Complex Fire along portions of Bald Rock
Road and Lumpkin Road in the coming months. This work is eligible for reimbursement through the Federal
Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Disaster Assistance Program. The Engineers Estimate for the
damaged guardrail repairs on Bald Rock Road and Lumpkin road is approximately $150,000. Road crews
recently replaced damaged and rotted boards and painted areas of need on the Oregon Gulch Covered
Bridge. Road crews also rehung the Oregon Gulch sign refurbished by a local community member.
District 2
A recent meeting with County Service Area 172 residents resulted in various action items for Public Works
that include a follow-up field meeting in May to discuss the potential removal of street trees impacting
surrounding public and private infrastructure. Action on a proposed landscaping maintenance agreement
previously scheduled for late April has been delayed until the May meeting occurs. Road crews also recently
completed vegetation removal in the CSA’s retention pond and plans to investigate adjacent drainage
culverts this summer. Sierra Moon Subdivision Phase 4 has requested approval of their Final Subdivision
Map. The project is comprised of 14 lots and is in conformance with the Tentative Map and Butte County
Code. The applicant wishes to defer construction of remaining on-site improvements until after the Final
Map is recorded. This is allowable per the Subdivision Map Act, and the applicant has providedthe
appropriate securities to guarantee completion of the required remaining Phase 4 improvements. The item
will be brought to the April 13, 2021 Board meeting for consideration. We recognize the sensitivity to
th
development activity in the North Chico area and will be prepared to answer any questions on the 13.
2
District 3
Caltrans recently completed its annual preemergent program along Highway 32. Caltrans applies
preemergent along fire strips about 4-8 feet wide depending on the location. Due to various protocols on
herbicide usage, Caltrans does not spray preemergent beyond fire strips.Caltrans has allocated additional
resources to perform follow-up spraying once CalFire has completed work and includes a post-emergent
application to treat shrub and stump resprout. The post applications typically follow quickly behind CalFire
pruning efforts to control to be effective to minimize resprouting. Soil stabilization and dust suppression
efforts began earlier this week on various roads in Butte County. Roads targeted for treatment in District 3
include Mud Creek Road (Cohasset Road to Vilas Road in Cohasset), Garland Road (Highway 32 to the
end of county-maintained in Forest Ranch), and Doe Mill Road / Schott Road (end of pavement to end of
county-maintained in Forest Ranch).
District 4
Later this summer, Public Works plans to remove and replace 4 inches of existing asphalt pavement with a
new polymer modified hot mix asphalt along 4.6 miles of road of Midway from Durham Dayton Highway
to Hegan Lane. Additional improvements include pavement shoulder backing, modifications to the concrete
bridge rail, guardrail improvements at the railroad overpass, replacement of traffic signal loops, and new
thermoplastic striping and pavement markings. The engineer's estimate for construction is $2,520,000 and
is funded with Senate Bill 1 (SB 1) revenues. Public Works continues to make progress on the construction
of improvements on the Midway Bridge. Recent work has resulted in modest contract unit price increases
for various items in the contract. A contract change order will be brought to the Board in April for these
changes. Please note that these contract change orders are different than the recent contract change orders
approved by the Board for consultant services. Contract change orders during construction are
commonplace, and most California municipalities utilize Public Contract Code statutes that allow minor
construction change orders without the need for the Board of Supervisors' approval. It’s unclear why Butte
County Public Works has not utilized State law in the past, as the need for Board approval for each minor
construction contract change order results in considerable effort and cost. I plan to revise future construction
contract language permitting Public Works to be consistent with State law.
District 5
Significant efforts have been focused on portions of Skyway over the past month. Hazard trees were
removed through multiple efforts that involved Butte County Public Works road crews, the Alliance
Workforce Development crews, Alternative Custody Supervised (ACS) inmate crews, and CalRecycle.
Public Works also recently coordinated with the ACS crews to complete litter removal along Skyway from
the City of Chico to the Paradise town limits. These efforts typically occur each spring. Significant disaster
recovery currently scheduled for work in 2022 under the Federal Highways Administration Emergency
Relief (FHWA-ER) program includes road rehabilitation and repair efforts on Skyway, New Skyway, and
Pentz Road. Preliminary estimates target the costs for these projects at approximately $23 million that
includes $2.5 million in local matching funds. Due to federal funding delays, any repair efforts will require
the County to use local funding and seek reimbursement once the project is completed. Additional
discussion on this topic is included in this report. Efforts to manage both the FWHA and FEMA federal
disaster reimbursement process have been difficult and time-consuming and continue to affect our ability
to deliver both disaster recovery and other standard infrastructure projects.
3
Board of Supervisor Meetings – April 2021
Key items scheduled for the Board this month include:
Sierra Moon Phase 4 Final Map
Improvement Standards Discussion
Midway Roadway Rehabilitation Project
FEMA Guardrail Replacement – North Complex Fire
On January 12, 2021, the Board of Supervisors requested staff to schedule an educational item for future
discussion on the County's Improvement Standards. These Standards help provide minimum design and
construction criteria that apply to various site improvements and help regulate the design and preparation
of plans for the construction of streets, drainage, fire protection, and other related improvements. On April
th
13, I will provide the Board with a presentation onthese Standards. Public Works and Development
Services staff will be available to answer questions from the Board.
2021 CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULE
The following table outlines routine (non-disaster) Public Works construction activity for 2021. The
construction end dates are approximate and will be updated in future reports.
2021 Construction Program
Capital Improvement Projects
Approx. Const. Approx. Const.
Project NameProject DescriptionStartEnd
Replacement of bridge across Butte Creek on
Midway Bridge at Butte Creek8/3/202012/31/2021
Midway
Las Plumas Ave and Lincoln Blvd. SRTS ProjectSidewalks, draiange and roadway rehab.4/12/20218/13/2021
Midway RehabilitationMill existing AC surface and place HMA Overlay6/14/20217/30/2021
Rehab. Existing road from Oroville C.L. to
Foothill Blvd. Rehabilitation9/1/202110/29/2021
Oro Bangor Hwy.
Neal Road Recycling and Waste Facility Projects
Approx. Const. Approx. Const.
Project NameProject DescriptionStartEnd
LFG Well Expansion Install landfill gas wells within Module 45/24/20218/27/2021
Encroachment Permit / Land Development Inspection
Approx. Const. Approx. Const.
Project NameProject DescriptionStartEnd
West Biggs Gridley Water DistrictBridge Replacement on Afton RoadComplete
PG&EUnderground gas on Via Canella,Autry Ln11/6/20205/30/2021
PG&EBald Rock Road Underground Electric Phase 11/6/20215/15/2021
PG&EBald Rock Road Underground Electric Phase 23/1/20217/1/2021
Sierra Moon Phase IVConstruction of next phase of subdivision1/11/20216/1/2021
South Feather Water and PowerUnderground water main Foothill Blvd
Complete
PG&EOro Quincy Hwy Underground Electric6/1/2021unknown
DISASTER RECOVERY
Butte County received a $252 million settlement from PG&E to compensate the County for the impacts of
the Camp Fire, which wascaused by PG&E's criminal negligence. The County’s net settlement revenue
after attorney fees was $204.4 million. In recent months, the Board has heard updates from Administration
th
on potential uses and will be considering action on various items on April 13. Part of this action may
include consideration of a PG&E Settlement Fund Policy so the Board can consider stability, recovery, and
4
hazard mitigation initiatives and projects.The Board of Supervisors also expects that departments will
pursue potential funding alternatives, including Community Development Block Grants or other similar
funds before considering the use of PG&E funds.
Recent feedback from the Board of Supervisors and the community reflects an interest in the restoration
and rehabilitation of roads and infrastructure impacted by the Camp Fire. In response, Public Works has
begun efforts to prepare a Butte County Infrastructure Rehabilitation and Restoration Plan. This Plan will
reflect efforts to develop a comprehensive accounting of impacts to public roads and infrastructure resulting
from the Camp Fire and other disasters over the past five years that focuses on drainage and flood protection;
pavement repairs and rehabilitation; roadside tree, vegetation, and brush removal; guardrail repairs; signage
and striping rehabilitation; unpaved road stabilization; hillside slope stability and erosion concerns; and
other unmet needs.
Specifically, the Plan will focus on four areas of concern:
Federal disaster recovery projects typically require Butte County to complete the projects utilizing
local funding and submit reimbursement requests to FEMA for the completed work. This process
may take months or years to complete. The sheer size and number of projects identified under these
programs far exceed Public Works’ ability to finance and requires consideration of short-term
financing.
Despite federal and state funding for various disaster projects, Butte County is required to provide
a local funding match. For road infrastructure projects that have qualified for disaster assistance, the
local funding match has been provided by the road fund (gas taxes). The use of local road funds for
disaster recovery efforts has impacted our ability to fund other much-needed infrastructure repair
and rehabilitation projects, including preventative pavement and infrastructure treatments.
There are many other roads within disaster areas or providing access to disaster areas where
combined disaster and disaster recovery efforts have impacted that have not qualified for federal
disaster recovery funds but are deteriorating at an accelerated rate.
Over the past half-decade, road crews have disproportionately allocated time and resources to
infrastructure impacted by various disasters. Other roads and infrastructure in Butte County – and
western portions of the County in particular – have not received the attention necessary to adequately
maintain and are at risk of deteriorating at an accelerated rate.
The proposed Plan will represent a comprehensive effort to identify the needs for restoration and
rehabilitation of county roads and infrastructure affected by various disasters. Public Works looks forward
to preparing this Plan and hopes to bring a draft to the Board of Supervisors later this spring.
SPECIAL DEPARTMENT FOCUS – NEAL ROAD LANDFILL
Public Works has approximately 150 employees serving different divisions that include Road Maintenance,
Landfill Operations, Fleet Services, Engineering, Surveying, the County Surveyor, Land Development, and
Fiscal and Administrative Services. Each month, I will provide a more in-depth look at one of our Divisions
within Public Works. For this month, I’ve provided more detailed insight into the operations of our Neal
Road Landfill Operations.
5
The Neal Road Recycling and Waste Facility (NRRWF) recently received a haul truck used for delivering
the daily cover material such as dirt, green waste, and gravel for building access roads; anexcavator used
for loading the haul truck with daily cover materials such as dirt, green waste, and gravel for building access
roads; and a skid steer used for site maintenance such as mowing, and repairing landfill side-slopes from
minor storm damage.
The Module 4 Landfill Gas Collection System was developed to capture, collect, and remove landfill gas
(methane) from the landfill. Recent testing has demonstrated ambient and below-ground methane readings
have exceeded permitted limits for the level of gas allowed to migrate off-site. To bring the system into
compliance with permit conditions, a project to expand the gas collection and control system to capture
excess gas escaping into the atmosphere and migrating off-site is progressing. The project involves drilling
and installing twelve additional landfill gas wells, abandoning and decommissioning a damaged extraction
well, installing vertical and horizontal landfill gas wellheads, installing various pipes fitting and fixtures,
and restoring soil erosion cover. The work will help NRRWF comply with existing federal and state air
emissions requirements.
The NRRWF has been serving the public for over 50 years, 7 days a week, 360 days a year, with the public
and franchise haulers bringing in approximately 200,000 tons of solid waste for disposal into the facility
annually, and served 125,000 vehicles The current landfill footprint is projected to run out of storage space
at some point in the 2050s. Public Works has identified to develop an NRRWF Master Plan to better account
for emerging trends in landfill operations. This process will involve a robust program and policy analysis
to address long-term capital and operating needs for the facility. Public Works anticipated engaging a large
group of stakeholders that includes
profit organizations engaged in diversion programs, and various County departments. The Public Works
Department also plans to utilize the Butte County Solid Waste Local Task Force, which comprises various
stakeholders to address various solid waste planning and management issues.
Efforts to develop a site-specific Master Plan will also better inform the County of future property needs
and necessary property acquisitions that result in the greatest public benefit for the least private impact.
Public Works plans to delay the property acquisition and eminent domain process for the Nance Canyon
parcel until these efforts are completed and the County can complete the necessary environmental
assessment and approval processes.
For more information on Solid Waste and the NRRWF, please click HERE.
OTHER PUBLIC WORKS NEWS
Butte County Service Request System
Public Works received 73 service requests last month – an 11% drop in service requests from the prior
month. Primary complaints for this past month include Potholes and Other Road Issues, Trees and
Vegetation, and Illegal Dumping. Over the past few weeks, I have worked with our Maintenance Division
to greatly increase the number of specificity of categories available for the public to submit service requests.
This should better align citizen service requests with the resources available to address those requests. New
6
categories recently made available to the public include levee issues and concerns, sidewalk safety, snow
removal, graffiti removal, and other general questions. Public Works also created separate categories to
better separate minor and routine road maintenance requests with major requests that may not be reasonable
or feasible with current resources. We believe these changes will better serve residents and improve our
ability to accurately respond to constituent concerns in the future.
Public Works Employee Survey Results
As we recently passed the one-year mark of COVID, we recognize that this past year has been incredibly
difficult on so many levels. If there is one thing we have all learned is that “business as usual” hasbecome
anything but usual. We have all had to adjust to the loss of friends and loved ones, separation from our
family and friends, sheltering-in-place, working remotely, homeschooling, and a variety of other life
challenges both professionally and personally. In response to these challenges, I issued an employee survey
in mid-March to checkin with employees and explore areas of improvement. A 10-question survey was
issued and available to all employees both online and offline. Irecognize that these difficult times have had
impacts on all of us, and I hope that this survey can help give us some insight and feedback that can improve
our ability to support our employees and even help us revisit and revise the way we do business moving
forward.
In total, we received 74 responses. That represents about half of our department, and many of the employee
responses were honest, candid, and thoughtful. We are in the process of reviewing the results, including
reading every written response, and I plan to share the results of this survey with the employees in the
coming days. Employee recognition and engagement, training and certification programs, development of
permanent remote and flexible work policies, and improved communication and collaboration were some
of the key areas of focus identified by Public Works staff, and I’m excited about the opportunity to focus
on these and other areas in the coming months.
COVID-19 Response
Staff continues to follow the protocols outlined by the CDC, CDPH, and Butte County. We are coordinating
with Development Services to provide limited counter service to the public as we progress through the
orange and yellow COVID-19 tiers. We arealso in the beginning stages of developing a permanent return-
to-work policy that utilizes the tools, skills, resources, and lessons learned during the pandemic to reimagine
the delivery of services in a post-pandemic environment. We hope to have a policy in place by this summer.