HomeMy WebLinkAbout06.19.21 FW_ Emergency Groundwater Program_Redacted
From:Gosselin, Paul
To:Alpert, Bruce;Bennett, Robin;Clerk of the Board;Connelly, Bill;Cook, Holly;Cook, Robin;Hironimus, Patrizia;
Kimmelshue, Tod;Lucero, Debra;Paulsen, Shaina;Pickett, Andy;Reaster, Kayla;Ring, Brian;Ritter, Tami;
Sweeney, Kathleen;Teeter, Doug;Pickett, Andy
Cc:Buck, Christina;Jessee, Meegan
Subject:FW: Emergency Groundwater Program
Date:Saturday, June 19, 2021 9:49:32 AM
Attachments:image001.png
2021_06_18 GCID Emergency Groundwater Production Program Map.pdf
DWRUSBR JUNE 4 2021 F1.docx
GCID Billou Response.pdf
Board Members
I am forwarding information provided by the Glenn Colusa Irrigation District regarding their
Emergency Groundwater Program.
Thank you.
Paul
Paul Gosselin, Director
Department of Water and Resource Conservation
308 Nelson Ave
Oroville, CA 95965
530-552-3590 office
mobile
From: Thad Bettner <tbettner@gcid.net>
Sent: Friday, June 18, 2021 4:09 PM
To: Lisa Hunter <lhunter@countyofglenn.net>; Mary Fahey <mfahey@countyofcolusa.com>; 'Ryan
Teubert' <rteubert@tcpw.ca.gov>; Gosselin, Paul <PGosselin@buttecounty.net>; Buck, Christina
<CBuck@buttecounty.net>
Cc: Jered Shipley <jshipley@gcid.net>; Louis Jarvis <ljarvis@gcid.net>; Zac Dickens
<zdickens@gcid.net>
Subject: Emergency Groundwater Program
ATTENTION: This message originated from outside Butte County. Please exercise judgment before opening
..
attachments, clicking on links, or replying.
All,
Pleasefindattachedthefirstofourweeklyupdatesofouremergencygroundwater
program.Todate,wehavepumped1,811AFandarecontinuingtoaddnewwells
whichwillbeonnextweeksupdate.
Also,IhaveincludedaresponsetoalocallandownerMichaelBilliouwhohasmade
inaccuratestatementstotheStateandReclamation,I’mincludingthisforreferencein
caseyouhaveheardthesameconcernthroughothervenues.
Thanks,
Thad
_________________________________
ThaddeusLBettnerPE,GeneralManager
Glenn-ColusaIrrigationDistrict
POBox150
Willows,CA95988
530.934.8881(office)
530.588.3450(cell)
109.17 AF
Legend
Program Production Well (quantity: 26)
168.323 AF
Program Monitoring Well (quantity: 28)
107.78 AF
GCID Service Area
96 AF
19.12 AF
34.748 AF
115.34 AF
191.791 AF
78.697 AF
42.584 AF
21.921 AF
48.991 AF
13.893 AF
19.971 AF
29.309 AF
44.23 AF
15.465 AF
170.341 AF
1.117 AF
99.956 AF
95.18 AF
85.283 AF
87.036 AF
12.927 AF
51.475 AF
02.5510
50.702 AF
Miles
±
Service Layer Credits: Source: Esri,
DigitalGlobe, GeoEye, Earthstar Geographics,
CNES/Airbus DS, USDA, USGS, AeroGRID,
IGN, and the GIS User Community
GCID 2021 Emergency Groundwater Production Program (Program) as of 06/15/2021
Preliminary Area Map - Program Production Wells & Monitoring Wells
June 4, 2021
State Water Resources Control BoardDepartment of Water Resources
c/o Erin Foresman and Chris Carrc/o James Mizell
P.O. Box 2000 P.O. Box 942836
Sacramento, CA 95812-2000Sacramento, CA 94236-0001
Erin.Foresman@waterboards.ca.govJames.Mizell@water.ca.gov
Chris.Carr@waterboards.ca.gov
RegionalSolicitor’s OfficeU.S. Bureau of Reclamation
c/o Amy AufdembergeKristin White
2800 Cottage Way, Rm. E-17123310 El Camino Ave., Rm. 300
Sacramento, CA 95825 Sacramento, CA 95821
Amy.Aufdemberge@sol.doi.govknwhite@usbr.gov
Re: Department of Water Resourcesand the United States Bureau of Reclamation Temporary
Urgency Change Petition (TUCP)
To all recipients noted above,
My name is Michael Billiou. I am a fourth generation California farmer. My ranch
headquarters is located ½ mile south of Hamilton City, at 4290 State Route 45, Glenn
County. I believe that the State Water Resources Control Board would benefit from the
information I have regarding existing groundwater conditionswhere I live and farmas it
considers the petition filed by the Department of Water Resources (“DWR”) and the United
States Bureau of Reclamation (“Reclamation”)fora Temporary Urgency Change.
I heard about the TUCP one day ago from AquAlliance of which I am a member.There is great
potential for injuryto numerousgroundwater dependent homes and farms who don’t even know
this is taking place.
To date I am aware of Glenn Colusa Irrigation District plans to export 20,000 af to Tehama
Colusa Canal Authority half of which is available by crop idling/substitution and half by
1
groundwater substitutionand then additionally pump 25,000 af of groundwater under a so-
2
called Emergency Groundwater Production Program.I don’t understand how GCIDhas 70,000
af of surface water to sell outside the region yet claims to need 25,000 af of groundwater as an
emergency use, which will strain an already overtaxed basin.
1
GCID, 2021. GLENN-COLUSA IRRIGATION DISTRICT RESOLUTION NO. 2021-08. p. 2.
2
GCID, 2021. GLENN-COLUSA IRRIGATION DISTRICT RESOLUTION NO. 2021-09 for the Emergency
Groundwater Production Program. p.1.
Even more problematic, is the fact that we do not seem to have anyone to fairly represent
us and our interests. The State, and Glenn County have allowed GCID to become the lead for
our local groundwater management area, even though this is a major conflict of interest.
Their stated goals include the pumping and exporting of groundwater. This is a worst case
example of the fox guarding the hen house, and should not be allowed.
Past experience reporting conflicts with GCID well operations has beenconfrontational and
seems to justhavebeenignored. Due to this past experience, I believe that DWR and
Reclamation must ensure the posting of the 2021 GCID mitigation plan required in the Draft
Technical Information for Preparing Water Transfer Proposals(December 2019)on GCID’s
web site with public notification of the posting. There must also be one or more individuals at
each agency, SWRCB, DWR, and Reclamation, for the public to contact if conflict resolution on
a local level is avoided or unreasonable. You must understand, however, that there is no
mitigation that can compensate for the devaluation of my 160 year old ranch.
The land that GCID production wells 2 and 3 are sited on has no history of being irrigated,
or having any other use, other than as a right-of-way for the canal banks. The extraction of
this water, and its removal from the area of recharge, will amount to Grand Theft, in the
enormity of its damages to the local economy and environment .
Damages that we believe GCID has no legal right to impose on us. It is especially frustrating
to continually hear about their “senior water rights”, when they disregard the locals’ many
decades of historic use of these groundwater aquifers. We all overlie, live, farm, and have a
history of true beneficial use of this water. Until recently it has stayed in the area, and
helped with recharge.
My neighbors and I urge you to provide some meaningful oversight to this process. Right
now we have none. We need an unbiased arbiter in the regulation of the sale, pumping, and
export of the water that we rely on.
Historyof Problems
The ranches I operate for my family and friends rely on 19 groundwater wells. Since
around 2012 several of these wells have been showing abnormal and erratic behavior. In
2014 three important wells became unusable for several weeks. Our ag pump 19 went
completely dry on July 19, 2014. Following GCID pumping from 2011 to 2015 we had to
replace our main well #2 at a cost of nearly $200,000.
This year our area has received about 7 inches of rainfall, where we average an amount in
the mid 20s. The ±100’ and 300’ upper aquifer levels that many of the homes, farms, and
ranches have used for multiple decades, has started to show its stress several months
earlier than the last time we had a serious drawdown.
In the past week, our area has had 3 domestic wells, and an equal number of ag wells,
become un-useable due to a drop in the water table.
Yesterday, I had to have the first of 3 domestic pumps lowered. The other two will have to
be drilled deeper, and I fear what will happen while we are all waiting.
Our ag pumps 19 and 20 have gone dry as of this morning. I have not yet checked in with
all my neighbors, but I am sure there are more.
Each day, the situation seems to become worse, and it appears we are headed into very dire
straits.
GCID’s engineers reported that each of the GCID production wells affect other private
pumpers up to a four mile radius. The graphic I produced is more generous and shows
what a three mile radius encompasses: 48,900 acres less a little GCID land. As stated above,
these areas are already experiencing problems in 2021.
The effects of this large scale water export out of the local recharge area, will likely be very
damaging to my family and neighbors that live and work here. We urge you to stand up for
us in this matter
Michael Billiou