HomeMy WebLinkAbout08.25.2020 Paul Gosslin - Water Resources Report - August 25, 2020 AT0
Water andResource Conservation Paul Gosselin, Director
buttecounty.net/waterresourceconservation
308 Nelson Avenue T: 530.552.3595
Oroville, California 95965 F: 530.538.3807
bcwater@buttecounty.net
MEMORANDUM
DATE: August 25, 2020
TO: Butte County Board of Supervisors
FROM: Paul Gosselin, Director
RE: Water Resources Update
The following is an update of significant water resource issues from the Department of
Water and Resource Conservation.
Sustainable Groundwater Management Act
Request for an Extension to Submit Groundwater Sustainability Plans (GSP) - Public
engagement is a critical requirement of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act
(SGMA). The Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSA) in the three subbasins have
gone to great lengths to establish advisory structures to engage the public. With the
COVID-19 pandemic, the ability to hold meetings has been delayed and compromised.
The schedule to develop and submit the GSP remains on schedule. The Vina
Stakeholder Advisory Committee voted to recommend that the Vina GSA Board submit
a letter to the Governor and the Legislature requesting an extension of the January 31,
2022 GSP submission deadline. An extension would likely require legislation or a
Governors Executive Order. The issue will be brought before the Wyandotte Creek
th
GSA Board on August 27 as part of the GSP Status. The Butte County Water
nd
Commission will discuss the issue at their September 2 meeting and may make a
recommendation to the Board of Supervisors. If a recommendation is made by the
Water Commission, it will come to the Board in October. In the meantime, I will
investigate whether other subbasins are seeking an extension.
Groundwater Pumper Advisory Committee
The Groundwater Pumper Advisory Committee (GPAC) was formed in 2016 to advise
the Board of Supervisors on SGMA implementation, governance and groundwater
sustainability plan development. The GPAC is comprised two agricultural groundwater
pumpers from the four subbasins that were established at that time and an
environmental representative. With the establishment of governance structures in Vina
and Wyandotte Creek, Butte County is only a GSA in a small portion of the Butte
subbasin. The GPAC had previously discussed disbanding but decided to wait until the
governance structure in the Butte subbasin was finalized. The GPAC has not met since
th
2019. A GPAC meeting was held on August 19 to discuss recommending to the Board
to disband the GPAC. The GPAC voted to recommend continuing to meet as needed
nd
and not disband. The item will be discussed at the September 2 Water Commission
th
agenda as a continuation of the August 5 discussion. I will inform the Water
Commission of the GPACs intent. For the GPAC to continue, the members will need to
be reappointed. I will begin the process of having them submit applications for
appointment and solicit other potential candidates.
PG&E Issues
1. Poe Relicensing
As part of the order to issue the license to PG&E for the Poe facility issued by the
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), PG&E is required to enhance
recreational activities at Bardees Bar. The order required that PG&E conduct a
feasibility study on a hiking trail between the Poe Power Plant and Bardees Bar. The
Butte County Resource Conservation District conducted a feasibility study. PG&E
subsequently sent a letter to FERC requesting to remove the requirement to construct a
hiking trail. The action by PG&E is inconsistent with the FERC order and removes a
potential recreational opportunity for Butte County. The Coordinating Committee met on
th
August 18 and voted to recommend that a joint letter be drafted with Butte County and
American Whitewater directed to FERC objecting to the PG&E request. Butte County
Counsel and American Whitewater have previously collaborated on issues on the Poe
relicensing. The Paradise Parks and Recreation Commission is considering sending a
letter to FERC. An item requesting that the Board approve sending a joint letter with
American Whitewater will come before the Board in October.
2. DeSalba/Centerville Project and Butte Creek
The sale of the DeSalba/Centerville project by PG&E raised concerns about the
potential impact to flows in Butte Creek. PG&E is in negotiations with Toll House Energy
about acquiring the DeSalba/Centerville project. The Miocene Canal is not part of the
negotiations or part of the DeSalba/Centerville project. An informal group called the
Centerville Schoolhouse Group began meeting to discuss opportunities to increase
flows in Butte Creek to better support salmon population and other species. The group
is made up of a broad coalition including the CA Sportfishing Alliance, Metropolitan
Water District, American Whitewater, NOAA, and the State Water Resources Control
Board. The Centerville Schoolhouse Group reached out to the Department to better
understand how the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act and Miocene Canal
nd
issues could relate to their efforts. On September 2, a presentation by American
Whitewater will be made at the Water Commission about the opportunities to repurpose
hydroelectric facilities for environmental benefit. A report will be brought to the Board
based on the discussion at the Water Commission.
3. Miocene Canal
In June, PG&E plead guilty to 84 felony counts of involuntary manslaughter and
causing the 2018 Camp Fire. As part of the plea agreement with the Butte County
restore water to the Miocene Canal.
PG&E has agreed to provide up to $15 million over the next five years towards restoring
water to the Miocene Canal. The Department is continuing to facilitate discussion
among PG&E, stakeholder and local partners. The immediate effort involves securing a
short-term solution that could be implemented this summer. PG&E is planning to have a
temporary outtake at Lime Saddle that would deliver water to the Middle Miocene.
There are a number of permits, agreements and approvals required to achieve this goal
including approval from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). The FERC
approval could take 8 months or longer. Given the uncertainty of the temporary outtake,
other more viable alternatives are going to be pursued by PG&E. One alternative
involves connecting the existing DOWC outtake into the Miocene Canal at Lime Saddle.
This could be accomplished in 3-4 months. The second option involves supplying
Kunkel Reservoir with dechlorinated water from DOWC tank. This could be
accomplished in 3-4 months. The DOWC would be supplied by PID through the
PID/DOWC intertie. The third alternative involves upsizing the current Del Oro Water
Company outtake at Lime Saddle and using the increase capacity to put a sufficient
amount of water into the Middle Miocene. This option would compliment the first two
options. An engineering study on these alternatives is expected to be completed in two
th
weeks. A Miocene Canal Workgroup meeting will be held on August 18 from 11:00-
12:30. Board members should have gotten a meeting announcement. Please contact
me if you had not received the notice.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.