Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
5.2.22 Board Correspondence - FW_ COVID LIES
From:Paulsen, Shaina To:Pickett, Andy; Ring, Brian; Stephens, Brad J. Cc:Reaster, Kayla; Valencia, Shyanne Subject:Board Correspondence - FW: COVID LIES Date:Monday, May 2, 2022 8:17:15 AM Attachments:The-Covid-Lies-updated.pdf This was sent to the Board. Shaina Paulsen Associate Clerk of The Board Butte County Administration 25 County Center Drive, Suite 200, Oroville, CA 95965 T: 530.552.3304 | F: 530.538.7120 From: lance dreiss <lancedreiss@att.net> Sent: Saturday, April 30, 2022 11:32 AM To: Ritter, Tami <TRitter@buttecounty.net>; District Attorney <District_Attorney@buttecounty.net>; Alpert, Bruce <BAlpert@buttecounty.net>; Waugh, Melanie <mwaugh@buttecounty.net>; Kimmelshue, Tod <TKimmelshue@buttecounty.net>; Connelly, Bill <BConnelly@buttecounty.net>; Lucero, Debra <DLucero@buttecounty.net>; Teeter, Doug <DTeeter@buttecounty.net>; Clerk of the Board <clerkoftheboard@buttecounty.net> Subject: COVID LIES .ATTENTION: This message originated from outside Butte County. Please exercise judgment before opening attachments, clicking on links, or replying.. Board of Supervisors, Clerk of the Board, Public Record, DA Ramsey, Sheriff Honea, County Counsel Alpert: Dr. Michael Yeadon, former Chief Scientific Officer and Vice President of Allergy and Respiratory Researcher at Pfizer lays out the 12 COVID LIES. It is your duty to notify the public in Butte County and STOP these gene therapy shots which are killing and maiming everyone and everything in their path. NOW! Diana Dreiss https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://doctors4covidethics.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/The-Covid- Lies-updated.pdf__;!!KNMwiTCp4spf!DbvUUc_3yTnN_v_- QlQ3xtd5Gy7jCmw2LcZoPNzjU1I6CPd0f247dGBuXdRxlxwh9jhttKQBKB_3bVFlJhWk96EDTrdTzw$ Sent from my iPad Uif!Dpwje!Mjft Xpsljoh!Esb-!Bqsjm!21-!3133 Cz!Es/!Njlf!Zfbepo Tvnnbsz J!dpoufoe!uibu!bmm!uif!nbjo!obssbujwf!qpjout!bcpvu!uif!dpspobwjsvt!obnfe!TBST.DpW.3! bsf!mjft/!Gvsuifsnpsf-!bmm!uif!ÆnfbtvsftÇ!jnqptfe!po!uif!qpqvmbujpo!bsf!bmtp!mjft/!Jo! xibu!gpmmpxt-!J!tvqqpsu!uiftf!dmbjnt!tdjfoujdbmmz-!nptumz!cz!sfgfsfodf!up!qffs.sfwjfxfe! kpvsobm!bsujdmft/!Jo!312:-!Xpsme!Ifbmui!Pshboj{bujpo!)XIP*!tdjfoujtut!sfwjfxfe!uif! fwjefodf!gps!uif!vujmjuz!pg!bmm!opo.qibsnbdfvujdbm!joufswfoujpot-!dpodmvejoh!uibu!uifz! bsf!bmm!xjuipvu!ffdu/ Hjwfo!uif!gpsfhpjoh-!ju!jt!op!mpohfs!qpttjcmf!up!wjfx!uif!mbtu!uxp!zfbst!bt!xfmm. joufoujpofe!fsspst/!Jotufbe-!uif!pckfdujwft!pg!uif!qfsqfusbupst!bsf!nptu!mjlfmz!up!cf! upubmjubsjbo!dpouspm!pwfs!uif!qpqvmbujpo!cz!nfbot!pg!nboebupsz!ejhjubm!JEt!boe!dbtimftt! dfousbm!cbol!ejhjubm!dvssfodjft!)DCEDt*/ fsf!jt!op!nfejdbm!ps!qvcmjd!ifbmui!fnfshfodz/!Xf!dbo!boe!tipvme!ublf!cbdl!pvs! gsffepnt!xjui!jnnfejbuf!ffdu/!Uftujoh!ifbmuiz!qfpqmf!tupqt/!Jg!zpvÉsf!tjdl-!qmfbtf!tubz! ipnf/!Nbtlt!cfmpoh!jo!uif!usbti/!f!Dpwje.2:!hfof.cbtfe!jokfdujpot!bsf!opu! sfdpnnfoefe!boe!nvtu!opu!cf!dpfsdfe!ps!nboebufe/!Dsvdjbmmz-!uif!wbddjof!qbttqpsut! ebubcbtf!nvtu!cf!eftuspzfe/!Fdpopnjd!sfdujuvef!jt!sfdpnnfoefe/ Tfsjpvt!dsjnft!ibwf!pcwjpvtmz!cffo!dpnnjuufe/!Ju!jt!opu!uif!qvsqptf!pg!uijt!epdvnfou! up!bddvtf!bozpof!ps!up!bttfncmf!uif!fwjefodf!bhbjotu!uifn!bu!uijt!ujnf/!Ipxfwfs-!xifo! uijt!jt!bmm!sftpmwfe-!Xf!f!Qfpqmf!bsf!tuspohmz!sfdpnnfoefe!up!qbz!nvdi!npsf! buufoujpo!up!Xbtijohupo!uibo!qsfwjpvtmz/ UBCMF!PG!DPOUFOUT f!Dpwje!Mjftqbhft!3Ä26 Ipx!Nvdi!pg!uif!Dpwje.2:!Obssbujwf!Xbt!Usvf@ qbhft!2:Ä39 Beejujpobm!Sffdujpot Bcpvu!Es/!Njlf!Zfbepoqbhf!3: Qbhf!2!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 2/TBST.DpW.3!ibt!tvdi!b!ijhi!mfuibmjuz!uibu!fwfsz!nfbtvsf! nvtu!cf!ublfo!up!tbwf!mjwft/ Opuf;!Dpwje.2:!jt!uif!ejtfbtf!sftvmujoh!gspn!jogfdujpo!xjui!uif!wjsvt-!TBST.DpW.3/! fz!bsf!pfo!vtfe!joufsdibohfbcmz/!Tpnfujnft!ju!epftoÉu!nvdi!nbuufs-!cvu!uif! dpogvtjpo!xbt!tpxfe!efmjcfsbufmz/ JNQPSUBODF Fttfoujbm!up!dmbjn!ijhi!mfuibmjuz!jo!psefs!uibu!voqsfdfefoufe!sftqpotft!nbz!tffn! kvtujfe/!Up!Æqfq!vqÇ!uif!dmbjn-!sfdbmm!Ægbmmjoh!nboÇ!jo!Xvibo@!f!qfstpo!xbt! bmmfhfemz!tjdl!cvu!xbmljoh!bcpvu-!cfgpsf!gbmmjoh!efbe!po!ijt!gbdf/!bu!xbt!ofwfs!sfbm/!Ju! xbt!uifbusf/ UIF!SFBMJUZ Fbsmz!ftujnbuft!pg!mfuibmjuz!xfsf!wfsz!ijhi!xjui-!jo!tpnf!sfqpsut-!bo!Æjogfdujpo!gbubmjuz! sbufÇ!)JGS*!pg!4&/!Tfbtpobm!jovfo{b!jt!hfofsbmmz!dpotjefsfe!up!ibwf!b!uzqjdbm!JGS!pg! 1/2&/!bu!nfbot!tpnf!tfbtpot-!JGS!gps!v!nbz!cf!1/4&!boe!puifs!ujnft-!1/16&!ps! mpxfs/ Jo!qsbdujtf-!boe!uijt!xbt!vtvbm-!ftujnbuft!pg!JGS!gps!Dpwje.2:!xfsf!sfwjtfe!epxoxbset! sfqfbufemz!boe!opx!bsf!hfofsbmmz!sfdphojtfe!bt!jo!uif!sbohf!pg!1/2Ä1/4&/!Ju!dboopu!opx! cf!bshvfe!uibu!ju!jt!tjhojdboumz!ejfsfou!gspn!tpnf!tfbtpobm!jovfo{b!fqjefnjdt/! Xiz-!uifo-!ibwf!xf!bmm!cvu!eftuspzfe!uif!npefso!xpsme!pwfs!ju@ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU f!qfsqfusbupst!lofx!uibu!mfuibmjuz!ftujnbuft!pg!ofx!sftqjsbupsz!wjsbm!jmmofttft! BMXBZT!tubsu!ijhi!boe!sfevdf/!jt!jt!cfdbvtf-!fbsmz!po-!xf!ep!opu!ibwf!boz!ftujnbuf! pg!uif!ovncfs!pg!qfpqmf!jogfdufe!cvu!opu!tfsjpvtmz!jmm!boe!uif!ovncfs!jogfdufe!xjui!op! tznqupnt!bu!bmm/ fz!dsfbufe!uif!jnqsfttjpo!pg!fyusfnf!ebohfs-!xijdi!xbt!ofwfs!usvf/!jt!jt!tvdi!b! dsvdjbm!qpjou-!gps!podf!pof!tfft!ju!gps!xibu!ju!jt-!uif!sftu!pg!uif!obssbujwf!jt! tvqfsvpvt/ Es/!Kpio!Jpboojejt!jt!pof!pg!uif!xpsmeÉt!nptu.qvcmjtife!fqjefnjpmphjtut!boe!if!ibt! cffo!tdbuijoh!bcpvu!uif!jobqqspqsjbuf!sftqpotft!up!b!opwfm!wjsvt!pg!opu!qbsujdvmbsmz! vovtvbm!mfuibmjuz/!Mjlf!nptu!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvtft-!TBST.DpW.3!sfqsftfout!op!tfsjpvt! ifbmui!uisfbu!up!uiptf!voefs!71!zfbst!pg!bhf-!dfsubjomz!opu!dijmesfo-!boe!jt!b!tfsjpvt! uisfbu!pomz!up!uiptf!ofbsjoh!uif!foe!pg!uifjs!mjwft!cz!wjsuvf!pg!bhf!boe!nvmujqmf! dpnpscjejujft/ Es/!JpboojejtÉt!dvssfou!ftujnbuf!pg!hmpcbm!JGS!jt!bspvoe!1/26&/!Gps!sfgfsfodf-!b!uzqjdbm! tfbtpobm!jovfo{b!pvucsfbl!ibt!b!uzqjdbm!JGS!pg!bspvoe!1/2&-!cvu!dbo!cf!nbslfemz! xpstf!jo!cbe!xjoufst/ Qbhf!3!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 3/Cfdbvtf!uijt!jt!b!ofx!wjsvt-!uifsf!xjmm!cf!op!qsjps!jnnvojuz! jo!uif!qpqvmbujpo/ JNQPSUBODF Tffnt!sfbtpobcmf-!epftoÉu!ju@!jt!sfnbsl-!nbef!sfqfbufemz!fbsmz!po-!bjnfe!up!trvbti! boz!opujpo!uibu!uifsf!xbt!b!efhsff!pg!Æqsjps!jnnvojuzÇ!jo!uif!qpqvmbujpo/!Qsjps! jnnvojuz!boe!obuvsbm!jnnvojuz!bsf!pomz!opx-!uxp!zfbst!jo-!opu!dpotjefsfe! ÆnjtjogpsnbujpoÇ/ UIF!SFBMJUZ Xjuijo!b!gfx!npouit-!nvmujqmf!qvcmjdbujpot!tipxfe!uibu!b!mbshf!njopsjuz!)sbohjoh!gspn! 41&Ä61&-!tpnf!mbufs!tbje!fwfo!npsf*!pg!uif!qpqvmbujpo!ibe!U.dfmmt!jo!uifjs!cmppe! xijdi!sfdphojtfe!wbsjpvt!qjfdft!pg!uif!wjsbm!qspufjo!)tzouiftjtfe-!bt!op!pof!tffnfe!up! ibwf!boz!sfbm!wjsvt!jtpmbuft!up!vtf*/ Xijmf!tpnf!qfpqmf!bshvfe!uibu!sfdphojujpo!cz!U.dfmmt!ejeoÉu!nfbo!gvodujpobm!jnnvojuz-! sfbmmz!ju!epft/ Xf!xfsf!qsfwfoufe!gspn!mfbsojoh!uibu!xf!bmsfbez!lofx!pg!tjy!dpspobwjsvtft-!gpvs!pg! xijdi!dbvtf!Ædpnnpo!dpmet-Ç!xijdi!jo!fmefsmz!boe!josn!qfpqmf!dbo!dbvtf!efbui/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU jt!xbt!b!tusbjhiu!mjf/!JuÉt!qsfuuz!nvdi!ofwfs!usvf!uibu!uifsfÉt!op!qsjps!jnnvojuz!jo!b! qpqvmbujpo/!jt!jt!cfdbvtf!wjsvtft!bsf!fbdi!efsjwfe!gspn!fbsmjfs!wjsvtft!boe!tpnf!pg! uif!qpqvmbujpo!ibe!bmsfbez!efgfbufe!jut!boufdfefout-!hjwjoh!uifn!fjuifs!jnnvojuz!ps!b! cjh!ifbe!tubsu!jo!efgfbujoh!uif!ofx!wjsvt/!Fjuifs!xbz-!b!tj{fbcmf!qspqpsujpo!pg!uif! qpqvmbujpo!ofwfs!ibe!dbvtf!up!xpssz/ jt!bsujdmf!jodmveft!bmm!uif!jnqpsubou!qffs.sfwjfxfe!bsujdmft!up!nje.3131-!xjui!nboz! tipxjoh!bu!mfbtu!41&Ä61&!ibwjoh!qsjps!jnnvojuz!)ju!efqfoet!vqpo!uif!nfbtvsf!vtfe! up!bttftt!ju*/ Qbhf!4!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 4/jt!wjsvt!epft!opu!ejtdsjnjobuf/!Op!pof!jt!tbgf!voujm! fwfszpof!jt!tbgf/ JNQPSUBODF Joufoujpo!xbt!up!njojnjtf!uif!ovncfst!xip!njhiu!sfbtpo!uifzÉsf!opu!Æbu!sjtlÇ!qfpqmf/ UIF!SFBMJUZ jt!dmbjn!xbt!bmxbzt!bctvse/!f!mfuibmjuz!pg!uijt!wjsvt-!bt!jt!dpnnpo!xjui!sftqjsbupsz! wjsvtft-!jt!2111Y!mftt!jo!zpvoh-!ifbmuiz!qfpqmf!uibo!jo!fmefsmz!qfpqmf!xjui!nvmujqmf! dpnpscjejujft/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU Jo!tipsu-!bmnptu!op!pof!xip!xbtoÉu!dmptf!up!uif!foe!pg!uifjs!mjwft!xbt!bu!sjtl!pg!tfwfsf! pvudpnft!boe!efbui/!Jo!njeemf.bhfe!joejwjevbmt-!pcftjuz!jt!b!sjtl!gbdups-!bt!ju!jt!gps!b! iboegvm!pg!puifs!dbvtft!pg!efbui/ jt!jousjhvjoh!sfwjfx!efubjmt!ipx!uif!jojujbm!npefmmjoh!joevdfe!gfbs!boe!qspwjefe!uif! fydvtf!gps!ifbwz.iboefe!nfbtvsft-!ftqfdjbmmz!ÆmpdlepxotÇ/!Ju!xbt-!ipxfwfs-!kvtu!uibu;! bo!fydvtf/!Bmm!fyqfsjfodfe!qvcmjd!ifbmui!fyqfsut!lofx!uibu!mpdlepxot!xfsf!bctvse-! joffdujwf-!boe!ivhfmz!eftusvdujwf/!fsfÉt!op!xbz!up!tvhbs.dpbu!uijt/!Ju!xbt!xspoh! cfgpsf!ju!xbt!psefsfe-!boe!juÉt!ofdfttbsz!up!fybnjof!xiz!uiptf!xip!lofx!eje!opu! qspuftu/!JuÉt!bmnptu!bt!jg!uifz!xfsf!dpnqmjdju/ Qbhf!5!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 5/Qfpqmf!dbo!dbssz!uijt!wjsvt!xjui!op!tjhot!boe!jogfdu!puifst;! btznqupnbujd!usbotnjttjpo/ JNQPSUBODF jt!jt!uif!dfousbm!dpodfquvbm!efdfju/!Jg!usvf-!uifo!bozpof!njhiu!jogfdu!boe!ljmm!zpv/! Gbmtfmz!dmbjnfe!btznqupnbujd!usbotnjttjpo!voefstdpsft!bmnptu!fwfsz!jousvtjpo;! nbtljoh-!nbtt!uftujoh-!mpdlepxot-!cpsefs!sftusjdujpot-!tdippm!dmptvsft-!fwfo!wbddjof! qbttqpsut/ UIF!SFBMJUZ f!cftu!fwjefodf!dpnft!gspn!b!nfub.bobmztjt!pg!b!mbshfs!ovncfs!pg!hppe!tuvejft-! fybnjojoh!ipx!pfo!b!qfstpo!uftujoh!qptjujwf!xfou!po!up!jogfdu!b!gbnjmz!nfncfs!)uifz! dpnqbsfe!bt!qpufoujbm!tpvsdft!pg!jogfdujpo!qfpqmf!xip!ibe!tznqupnt!xjui!uiptf!xip! eje!opu!ibwf!tznqupnt*/!POMZ!uiptf!XJUI!tznqupnt!xfsf!bcmf!up!jogfdu!b!gbnjmz! nfncfs!bu!boz!sbuf!uibu!nbuufsfe/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU Btznqupnbujd!usbotnjttjpo!jt!fqjefnjpmphjdbmmz!jssfmfwbou/!JuÉt!opu!ofdfttbsz!up!bshvf!ju! ofwfs!ibqqfot<!juÉt!fopvhi!up!tipx!uibu!jg!ju!pddvst!bu!bmm-!ju!jt!tp!sbsf!bt!opu!up!cf!xpsui! nfbtvsjoh/ Jo!uijt!wjefp-!xf!bmtp!ibwf!Gbvdj!boe!b!XIP!epdups!ufmmjoh!vt!fybdumz!uijt/!Bmtp-!J! tipx!xiz!ju!jt!mjlf!ju!jt/!JuÉt!wfsz!dmfbs/ Qbhf!6!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 6/f!QDS!uftu!tfmfdujwfmz!jefoujft!qfpqmf!xjui!dmjojdbm! jogfdujpot/ JNQPSUBODF jt!jt!uif!dfousbm!pqfsbujpobm!efdfju/!Jg!usvf-!xf!dpvme!efufdu!sjtlz!qfpqmf!boe!jtpmbuf! uifn/!Xf!dpvme!ejbhoptf!bddvsbufmz!boe!bmtp!dpvou!uif!ovncfs!pg!efbuit/ Qpmznfsbtf!dibjo!sfbdujpo!)QDS*-!bu!jut!cftu-!dbo!dposn!uif!qsftfodf!pg!hfofujd! jogpsnbujpo!jo!b!dmfbo!tbnqmf!boe!jt!vtfgvm!jo!gpsfotjdt!gps!uibu!sfbtpo/!Ju!jowpmwft!dzdmf! bfs!dzdmf!pg!bnqmjdbujpo-!dpqzjoh!uif!tubsujoh!nbufsjbm!bu!uif!cfhjoojoh!pg!fbdi!dzdmf/! f!jowfoups!pg!uif!QDS!uftu-!Lbsz!Nvmmjt-!xpo!b!Opcfm!Qsj{f!gps!ju!boe!pfo!dsjujdjtfe! Gbvdj!gps!njtvtjoh!uibu!uftu!up!ejbhoptf!BJET!qbujfout-!xijdi!Nvmmjt!jotjtufe!xbt! jobqqspqsjbuf/ UIF!SFBMJUZ Jo!b!ÆejsuzÇ!dmjojdbm!tbnqmf-!uifsf!jt!npsf!uibo!b!qpttjcmf!qjfdf!pg-!ps!b!xipmf-!wjsvt! xijdi!njhiu!sfqmjdbuf/!fsf!bsf!cbdufsjb-!gvohj-!puifs!wjsvtft-!ivnbo!dfmmt-!nvdvt-!boe! npsf/!JuÉt!opu!qpttjcmf!vofrvjwpdbmmz!up!lopx-!jg!b!uftu!jt!kvehfe!ÆqptjujwfÇ!bfs!nboz! dzdmft-!xibu!ju!xbt!uibu!xbt!bnqmjfe!up!hjwf!uif!tjhobm!bu!uif!foe!uibu!xf!dbmm!ÆqptjujwfÇ/ Jo!nbtt!uftujoh!npef-!dpnnpomz!vtfe-!op!pof!fwfs!svot!tp.dbmmfe!Æqptjujwf!dpouspmtÇ! uispvhi!uif!dibjo!pg!dvtupez/!buÉt!ejbhoptujd!uftujoh!212/!JuÉt!b!efdfqujpo/ Fwfsz!uftu!ibt!bo!Æpqfsbujpobm!gbmtf!qptjujwf!sbufÇ!)pGQS*-!xifsf!tpnf!volopxo!qfsdfou! pg!tbnqmft!uvsot!qptjujwf-!fwfo!jg!uifsf!jt!op!wjsvt!qsftfou/!B!hppe!pGQS!xpvme!cf!mftt! uibo!2&-!cvu!jt!ju!1/9&!ps!1/2&@!Jg!zpv!uftu!211-111!tbnqmft!ebjmz-!boe!uif!pGQS!jt!1/9&-! zpv!xjmm!hfu!911!qptjujwf!uftut!ps!Ædbtft-Ç!fwfo!jg!uifsf!jt!op!wjsvt!jo!uif!foujsf! dpnnvojuz/!Pfo-!uif!Æqptjujwjuz-Ç!uif!gsbdujpo!pg!uftut!uibu!bsf!qptjujwf-!jt!jo!uibu!sbohf-! tvc.2&!ps!mpx.tjohmf.ejhju!qfsdfou/!J!cfmjfwf!nvdi!ps!bmm!pg!uibu!dbo!cf!dbvtfe!cz!gbmtf! qptjujwft/!Opuf-!dsjnjobmt!dbo!nbojqvmbuf!uif!dpoufou!pg!uif!uftu!ljut!cfdbvtf!uifsf!bsf! wfsz!gfx!qspwjefst!jo!b!ufssjupsz-!pfo!kvtu!pof/!f!dpoejujpot!gps!svoojoh!uif!uftu!bsf! bmtp!tvckfdu!up!wbsjbujpo!cz!uif!bvuipsjujft-!mjlf!uif!DED/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU Zpv!dbo!cf!hfovjofmz!qptjujwf-!zfu!opu!jmm/!fsf!jt!op!mpxfs!mjnju!pg!usvf!efufdujpo!cfmpx! xijdi!zpvÉe!cf!efdmbsfe!up!ibwf!tpnf!dpqjft!pg!uif!wjsvt-!cvu!efdmbsfe!dmjojdbmmz!xfmm/!JuÉt! bo!bctvse!jefb/ Zpv!dbo!ibwf!op!wjsvt!zfu!uftu!qptjujwf!)xjui!ps!xjuipvu!tznqupnt*/!Bmm!pg!uiftf!bsf! txfqu!uphfuifs!boe!dbmmfe!Ædposnfe!Dpwje.2:!dbtftÇ/!Jg!zpv!ejf!jo!uif!ofyu!39!ebzt-! zpvÉsf!tbje!up!cf!b!ÆDpwje!efbui-Ç!op!nbuufs!xibu!uif!dbvtf/ ptf!vtjoh!uif!uftu!ljut!qspwjefe!dpnnfsdjbmmz!bsf!xibu!bsf!dbmmfe!Æcmbdl!cpyÇ/!fz! bsf!vobcmf!up!tbz!xibu!jt!jo!uif!lju-!cfdbvtf!uijt!jt!qspqsjfubsz/!f!psjhjobm!Ænfuipet! qbqfsÇ!xbt!qvcmjtife!jo!59!ipvst-!nbljoh!b!npdlfsz!pg!dmbjnfe!qffs!sfwjfx-!cz!b! Qbhf!7!pg!42 Cfsmjo!mbc!ifbefe!cz!Qspgfttps!Disjtujbo!Esptufo-!tdjfoujd!bewjtps!up!Bohfmb!Nfslfm!pg! Hfsnboz/!f!qbqfs!xbt!dpnqsfifotjwfmz!sfcvuufe!cz!bo!joufsobujpobm!ufbn/ f!XIP!sfmfbtfe!b!tfsjft!pg!hvjebodf!opuft!po!QDS-!boe!ju!xbt!dmfbs!uibu!uifjs! ufdiojdbm!tub!eje!opu!bqqspwf!pg!nbtt!uftujoh!uif!qpqvmbujpo-!cfdbvtf!juÉt!qpttjcmf!up! sfuvso!xipmmz!gbmtf!qptjujwft/!Joeffe-!bu!ujnft!pg!mpx!hfovjof!qsfwbmfodf-!uibuÉt!bmm!uifz! dbo!cf/ J!pfo!xpoefs!jg!uijt!3118!sfbm.mjgf!fybnqmf!pg!b!QDS.cbtfe!uftujoh!tztufn!xijdi! sfuvsofe!211&!gbmtf!qptjujwft-!zfu!dpowjodfe!b!nbkps!iptqjubm!uibu!uifz!ibe!b!ivhf! ejtfbtf!pvucsfbl!gps!xfflt-!njhiu!ibwf!cffo!uif!jotqjsbujpo!gps!uif!vousvtuxpsuiz! nfuipet!vtfe!jo!uif!Dpwje.2:!efdfqujpo@ Esptufo!bmtp!mfe!uif!UW!qvcmjdjuz!bspvoe!uif!jefb!pg!btznqupnbujd!usbotnjttjpo/!Pof! mvdlz!tdjfoujtu!jt!bu!uif!dfousf!pg!uif!uxp!nptu!jnqpsubou!efdfqujpot!jo!uif!foujsf! Dpwje.2:!fwfou" Qspgfttps!Opsnbo!Gfoupo!ifsf!qsftfout!b!nvmuj.qbsu!mfduvsf!xjui!uxp!nbjo!fmfnfout/! Gjstu-!if!eftdsjcft!ipx!nbtt!uftujoh!pg!qfpqmf!xjui!op!tznqupnt!vobwpjebcmz!esjwft!vq! uif!qspqpsujpo!pg!qptjujwf!QDS!uftu!sftvmut!uibu!bsf!gbmtf/!f!tfdpoe!qbsu!efbmt!xjui!uif! qpttjcjmjuz!uibu!ebub!gsbve!foujsfmz!bddpvout!gps!uif!bqqbsfou!fdbdz!pg!uif!wbddjoft-! xijmf!buufnqujoh!up!ijef!wbddjof!efbuit-!cz!dmbttjgzjoh!uifn!bt!vowbddjobufe!gps!25!ebzt! bfs!jokfdujpo/ Qbhf!8!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 7/Nbtlt!bsf!ffdujwf!jo!qsfwfoujoh!uif!tqsfbe!pg!uijt!wjsvt/ JNQPSUBODF jt!jt!nptumz!vtfe!up!nbjoubjo!uif!jmmvtjpo!pg!ebohfs/!Zpv!tff!puifstÉ!nbtlt!boe!gffm! bgsbje/!Dpnqmzjoh!jt!bmtp!b!nfbtvsf!pg!xifuifs!zpv!ep!xibu!zpvÉsf!upme-!fwfo!jg!uif! nfbtvsf!jt!vtfmftt/ UIF!SFBMJUZ Xf!ibwf!lopxo!gps!efdbeft!uibu!tvshjdbm!nbtlt!xpso!jo!nfejdbm!uifbusft!ep!opu!tupq! sftqjsbupsz!wjsvt!usbotnjttjpo/!Nbtlt!xfsf!uftufe!bdsptt!b!tfsjft!pg!pqfsbujpot!cz! epdupst!bu!uif!Spzbm!Dpmmfhf!pg!Tvshfpot!)VL*/!Op!ejfsfodf!jo!qptu.pqfsbujwf! jogfdujpo!sbuf!xbt!tffo!cz!nbtl!vtf/ Dmpui!nbtlt!efojufmz!epoÉu!tupq!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvt!usbotnjttjpo!bt!tipxo!cz!tfwfsbm! mbshf-!sboepnjtfe!usjbmt/!Jg!bozuijoh-!uifz!jodsfbtf!sjtl!pg!mvoh!jogfdujpot/!f! bvuipsjujft!ibwf!nptumz!dpodfefe!po!dmpui!nbtlt/ Tpnf!qfpqmf!tqfbl!pg!Ætpvsdf!dpouspm-Ç!dbudijoh!espqmfut/!Qspcmfn!jt-!uifsf!jt!op! fwjefodf!uibu!usbotnjttjpo!ublft!qmbdf!wjb!espqmfut/!Frvbmmz-!uifsf!jt!op!fwjefodf!ju! pddvst!wjb!of!bfsptpmt/!Op!pof!oet!ju!po!nbtlt-!ps!po!bjs!mufst!jo!iptqjubm!xbset!pg! Dpwje!qbujfout-!fjuifs/!Xifsf!jt!uif!wjsvt@ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU JuÉt!opu!ofdfttbsz!up!vtf!vq!ujnf!po!uijt!upqjd/!Ju!xbt!lopxo!mpoh!cfgpsf!Dpwje.2:!uibu! gbdf!nbtlt!epoÉu!ep!bozuijoh/ Nboz!epoÉu!lopx!uibu!cmvf!nfejdbm!nbtlt!bsfoÉu!mufst/!Zpvs!jotqjsfe!boe!fyqjsfe!bjs! npwft!jo!boe!pvu!cfuxffo!uif!nbtl!boe!zpvs!gbdf/!fz!bsf!tqmbtihvbset-!uibuÉt!bmm/ jt!jt!b!hppe!sfwjfx!pg!uif!oejoht!xjui!nbtlt!jo!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvtft!cz!b!sfdphojtfe! fyqfsu!jo!uif!fme/!Op!ffdu/ Ofjuifs!nbtlt!ops!mpdlepxot!qsfwfoufe!uif!tqsfbe!pg!uif!wjsvt/!jt!sfwjfx! tvnnbsj{ft!511!qbqfst/ Qbhf!9!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 8/Mpdlepxot!tmpx!epxo!uif!tqsfbe!boe!sfevdf!uif!ovncfs! pg!dbtft!boe!efbuit/ JNQPSUBODF f!nptu!jnqbdugvm!zfu!xbtufgvm!joufswfoujpo-!bddpnqmjtijoh!opuijoh!vtfgvm/ Vtfgvm!up!uif!qfsqfusbupst-!ipxfwfs-!xjtijoh!up!ebnbhf!uif!fdpopnz!boe!sfevdf! joufsqfstpobm!dpoubdut/!jt!nfbtvsf!xbt!tvsqsjtjohmz!upmfsbufe!jo!nboz!xfbmuiz! dpvousjft-!cfdbvtf!ÆgvsmpvhiÇ!tdifnft!xfsf!qvu!jo!qmbdf-!dpnqfotbujoh!nboz!qfpqmf! gps!opu!xpsljoh-!ps!sfrvjsjoh!uifn!up!xpsl!gspn!ipnf/ UIF!SFBMJUZ f!nfbtvsf-!uipvhi!bnpoh!uif!nptu!sfqsfttjwf!bdut!fwfs!jnqptfe!po!djuj{fot!jo!b! efnpdsbdz-!xbt!jouvjujwfmz!sfbtpobcmf!up!nboz/!jt!jt!bo!fybnqmf!pg!ipx!gbs!p.dpvstf! vojogpsnfe!jouvjujpo!dbo!cf/ f!dpsf!jefb!xbt!tjnqmf/!Sftqjsbupsz!wjsvtft!bsf!usbotnjuufe!gspn!qfstpo!up!qfstpo/! Sfevdjoh!uif!bwfsbhf!ovncfs!pg!dpoubdut!tvsfmz!sfevdft!usbotnjttjpo@!Bduvbmmz-!ju! epftoÉu-!cfdbvtf!uif!usbotnjttjpo!dpodfqu!jt!xspoh/!Usbotnjttjpo!jt!gspn!b! TZNQUPNBUJD!qfstpo!up!b!tvtdfqujcmf!qfstpo/!ptf!xjui!tznqupnt!bsf!VOXFMM/! fz!sfnbjo!bu!ipnf!jo!nptu!dbtft!xjui!op!bdujpo!gspn!uif!hpwfsonfou/!Usbotnjttjpo! pddvssfe!nptumz!jo!jotujuvujpot!xifsf!tjdl!qfpqmf!boe!tvtdfqujcmf!qfpqmf!xfsf!gpsdfe! joup!dpoubdu;!iptqjubmt-!dbsf!ipnft-!boe!epnftujd!tfuujoht/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU B!hfofsbm!mpdlepxo!ibe!op!efufdubcmf!jnqbdu!po!fqjefnjd!tqsfbejoh-!dbtft-! iptqjubmjtbujpot-!ps!efbuit/ jt!jt!opx!xjefmz!bddfqufe-!bfs!b!nfub.bobmztjt!cz!Kpiot!Ipqljot!Vojwfstjuz! )joufsftujohmz-!bt!uif!KIV!sfqfbufemz!gfbuvsft!bt!bo!bdups!jo!b!epdvnfoubsz!bcpvu! qboefnjd.sfmbufe!gsbve!cz!Hfsnbo!kpvsobmjtu!Qbvm!Tdisfzfs*/ jt!jt!cfdbvtf!uiptf!jowpmwfe!jo!uif!wbtu!cvml!pg!ivnbo.up.ivnbo!dpoubdut!bsf!u!boe! xfmm!boe!tvdi!dpoubdut!ejeoÉu!sftvmu!jo!usbotnjttjpo/!Fttfoujbmmz-!jg!zpvÉsf!gppmfe!cz!uif! Æbtznqupnbujd!usbotnjttjpoÇ!mjf-!uifo!mpdlepxo!njhiu!nblf!tfotf/!Ipxfwfs-!tjodf!ju!jt! fqjefnjpmphjdbmmz!jssfmfwbou-!mpdlepxot!dbo!ofwfs!xpsl-!boe!pg!dpvstf-!bmm!uif! wpmvnjopvt!mjufsbuvsf!dposnt!uijt/ jt!dpodfqu!jt!vofrvjwpdbmmz!lopxo!up!nvmujqmf!qvcmjd!ifbmui!tdjfoujtut!boe!epdupst/! jt!jt!xiz!ÆmpdlepxoÇ!ibe!ofwfs!cffo!usjfe!cfgpsf/ Jnqpsuboumz-!XIP!tdjfoujtut!esbfe!b!efubjmfe!sfwjfx!pg!bmm!uif!opo.qibsnbdfvujdbm! joufswfoujpot!)OQJt*!jo!312:!boe!ejtusjcvufe!dpqjft!pg!uif!sfqpsu!up!bmm!nfncfs!tubuft/ jt!nfbot!uibu!BMM!nfncfs!tubuft!bmsfbez!lofx-!mbuf!jo!312:-!uibu!nbtlt-!mpdlepxot-! cpsefs!sftusjdujpot-!boe!cvtjoftt!ps!tdippm!dmptvsft!xfsf!gvujmf/!Pomz!Ætubz!ipnf!jg! zpvÉsf!tjdlÇ!xpslt!bu!bmm-!boe!qfpqmf!epoÉu!offe!up!cf!upme!uijt-!gps!uifz!bsf!upp!voxfmm!up! hp!pvu/ Qbhf!:!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 9/fsf!bsf!vogpsuvobufmz!op!usfbunfout!gps!Dpwje!cfzpoe! tvqqpsu!jo!iptqjubm/ JNQPSUBODF Sfjogpsdfe!uif!jefb!uibu!ju!xbt!wjubm!up!bwpje!dbudijoh!uif!wjsvt/ Mfhbmmz-!ju!xbt!fttfoujbm!gps!uif!qfsqfusbupst!csjohjoh!gpsxbse!opwfm!wbddjoft!uibu!uifsf! cf!op!wjbcmf!usfbunfout/!Ibe!uifsf!cffo!fwfo!pof-!uif!sfhvmbupsz!spvuf!pg!Fnfshfodz! Vtf!Bvuipsjtbujpo!xpvme!opu!ibwf!cffo!bwbjmbcmf/ UIF!SFBMJUZ Jo!nz!pqjojpo-!xijmf!bmm!uiftf!nfbtvsft!xfsf!eftusvdujwf!boe!dsvfm-!bdujwf!efqsjwbujpo! pg!bddftt!up!fyqfsjnfoubmmz!bqqmjfe!cvu!puifsxjtf!lopxo!tbgf!boe!ffdujwf!fbsmz! usfbunfout!mfe!ejsfdumz!up!njmmjpot!pg!bwpjebcmf!efbuit!xpsmexjef/!Jo!nz!njoe-!uijt!jt!b! qpmjdz!pg!nbtt!nvsefs/ Dpousbtujoh!xjui!uif!pdjbm!obssbujwf-!uif!uifsbqfvujd!wbmvf!pg!fbsmz!usfbunfou!xbt! bmsfbez!voefstuppe!boe!efnpotusbufe!fnqjsjdbmmz!evsjoh!tqsjoh!3131/!Tjodf!uifo-!b! tj{fbcmf!iboegvm!pg!xfmm.voefstuppe-!p.qbufou-!mpx.dptu!boe!tbgf!psbm!usfbunfout!ibwf! cffo!dibsbdufsjtfe/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU f!pdjbm!qptjujpo!xbt!uibu!uif!ejtfbtf!Dpwje.2:!dpvme!opu!cf!usfbufe!boe!uif!qbujfou! pomz!Ætvqqpsufe-Ç!pfo!cz!nfdibojdbm!wfoujmbujpo/!Wfoujmbujpo!jt!xipmmz!jobqqspqsjbuf! cfdbvtf!Dpwje.2:!jt!sbsfmz!bo!pctusvdujwf!bjsxbz!ejtfbtf-!zfu!ibt!b!ijhi!bttpdjbufe! npscjejuz!boe!npsubmjuz/!Bo!pyzhfo!nbtl!jt!hsfbumz!qsfgfssfe/ Jo!nz!wjfx-!evf!up!uif!wfsz!mbshf!bnpvou!pg!fnqjsjdbm!usfbunfou!boe!hppe! dpnnvojdbujpo-!Dpwje.2:!jt!uif!nptu!usfbubcmf!sftqjsbupsz!wjsbm!jmmoftt!fwfs/!Xf! lofx!jo!uif!stu!uisff!npouit!pg!3131!uibu!izespyzdimpsprvjof-!{jod-!boe!b{juispnzdjo! xfsf!fnqjsjdbmmz!vtfgvm-!qspwjefe!usfbunfou!xbt!tubsufe!fbsmz!boe!ubdlmfe!sbujpobmmz/ JuÉt!wfsz!jnqpsubou!up!opuf!uibu!ju!ibt!cffo!lopxo!gps!b!efdbef!boe!npsf!uibu!fmfwbujoh! jousbdfmmvmbs!{jod!bdut!up!tvqqsftt!wjsbm!sfqmjdbujpo/ fsf!jt!op!rvftujpo!uibu!tfojps!bewjtpst!up!b!sbohf!pg!hpwfsonfout!lofx!uibu!tp.dbmmfe! Æ{jod!jpopqipsft-Ç!dpnqpvoet!xijdi!pqfo!diboofmt!up!bmmpx!dfsubjo!ejttpmwfe!njofsbmt! up!dsptt!dfmm!nfncsboft-!xfsf!vtfgvm!jo!tfwfsf!bdvuf!sftqjsbupsz!tzoespnf!)TBST*!jo! 3114!boe!tipvme!cf!fyqfdufe!bmtp!up!cf!uifsbqfvujdbmmz!vtfgvm!jo!TBST.DpW.3!jogfdujpo/ jt!jt!b!tubsujoh!qpjou!gps!bmm!pg!uif!dmjojdbm!usjbmt!jo!Dpwje.2:-!jodmvejoh!ftqfdjbmmz! jwfsnfdujo!boe!izespyzdimpsprvjof!)xijdi!bsf!{jod!jpopqipsft*/ Ju!tipvme!cf!opufe!uibu!vtjoh!lopxo!tbgf!bhfout!gps!fyqfsjnfoubm!qvsqptft!bt!b!qsjpsjuz! ibt!bmxbzt!cffo!bo!ftubcmjtife!fuijdbm!nfejdbm!qsbdujdf!boe!jt!lopxo!bt!Æp.mbcfm! qsftdsjcjohÇ/ Qbhf!21!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU :/JuÉt!opu!dfsubjo!jg!zpv!dbo!hfu!uif!wjsvt!npsf!uibo!podf/ JNQPSUBODF f!jefb!pg!obuvsbm!jnnvojuz!xbt!bumz!efojfe!boe!uif!bctvse!jefb!uibu!zpv!njhiu!hfu! uif!tbnf!wjsvt!uxjdf!xbt!ftubcmjtife/!jt!sbnqfe!vq!uif!gfbs-!xijdi!njhiu!puifsxjtf! ibwf!qbttfe!txjmz/ UIF!SFBMJUZ ptf!xjui!fwfo!b!cbtjd!hsbtq!pg!nbnnbmjbo!jnnvopmphz!lofx!uibu!tfojps!bewjtpst!up! hpwfsonfou-!tqfbljoh!jo!vodfsubjo!ufsnt!po!uijt!rvftujpo-!xfsf!mzjoh/!Dfsubjomz-!jo!uif! bvuipsÉt!dbtf-!ju!xbt!b!qjwpubm!qpjou/!J!tibsfe!b!gpvoebujpobm!fevdbujpo!jo!VL! vojwfstjujft!bu!uif!tbnf!ujnf!bt!uif!VL!hpwfsonfouÉt!Dijfg!Tdjfoujd!Bewjtps/!jt! tibsfe!fevdbujpo!nfbou!xfÉe!ibwf!ibe!uif!tbnf!tfu!ufyut/!J!sfbtpofe!uibu!if!lofx!xibu! J!lofx!boe!wjdf!wfstb/!J!xbt!bt!tvsf!bt!ju!jt!qpttjcmf!up!cf!uibu!ju!xpvmeoÉu!cf!qpttjcmf!up! hfu!dmjojdbmmz!voxfmm!uxjdf!jo!sftqpotf!up!uif!tbnf!wjsvt-!ps!dmptf.jo!wbsjbout!pg!ju/!J!xbt! sjhiu/!If!xbt!mzjoh/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU fsf!ibwf!cffo!tdpsft!pg!qffs.sfwjfxfe!kpvsobm!bsujdmft!po!uijt!upqjd/!Wfsz!gfx! dmjojdbmmz!jnqpsubou!sfjogfdujpot!ibwf!fwfs!cffo!dposnfe/ Cfbujoh!p!b!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvt!jogfdujpo!mfbwft!bmnptu!fwfszpof!xjui!bdrvjsfe! jnnvojuz-!xijdi!jt!dpnqmfuf-!qpxfsgvm-!boe!evsbcmf/ Zpv!xpvmeoÉu!lopx!ju!gps!uif!njtejsfdujpo!bspvoe!boujcpejft!jo!cmppe-!cvu!tvdi! boujcpejft!bsf!opu!dpotjefsfe!qjwpubmmz!jnqpsubou!jo!iptu!jnnvojuz/!Tfdsfufe! boujcpejft!jo!bjsxbz!tvsgbdf!mjrvje!pg!uif!JhB!jtpuzqf!dfsubjomz!bsf-!cvu!nptu!jnqpsubou! bsf!nfnpsz!U.dfmmt/ ptf!jogfdufe!xjui!TBST!jo!3114!tujmm!ibe!dmfbs!fwjefodf!pg!spcvtu-!U.dfmm!nfejbufe! jnnvojuz!28!zfbst!mbufs/ Qbhf!22!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 21/Wbsjbout!pg!uif!wjsvt!bqqfbs!boe!bsf!pg!hsfbu!dpodfso/ JNQPSUBODF J!cfmjfwf!uif!qvsqptf!pg!uijt!dujpo!xbt!up!fyufoe!uif!bqqbsfou!evsbujpo!pg!uif! qboefnjdÅboe!uif!gfbsÅgps!bt!mpoh!bt!uif!qfsqfusbupst!xjtife!ju/!Xijmf!uifsf!jt! dpouspwfstz!po!uijt!qpjou-!xjui!tpnf!qiztjdjbot!cfmjfwjoh!sfjogfdujpo!cz!wbsjbout!up!cf!b! tfsjpvt!qspcmfn-!J!uijol!vousvtuxpsuiz!uftujoh!boe!puifs!wjsvtft!foujsfmz!jt!uif! qbstjnpojpvt!fyqmbobujpo/ UIF!SFBMJUZ J!dpnf!bu!ju!bt!bo!jnnvopmphjtu/!Gspn!uibu!wboubhf!qpjou-!uifsf!jt!wfsz!tuspoh!qsfdfefou! joejdbujoh!uibu!sfdpwfsz!bfs!jogfdujpo!bpset!jnnvojuz!fyufoejoh!cfzpoe!uif! tfrvfodf!pg!uif!wbsjbou!uibu!jogfdufe!uif!qbujfou!up!bmm!wbsjbout!pg!TBST.DpW.3/ f!ovncfs!pg!dposnfe!sfjogfdujpot!jt!tp!tnbmm!uibu!uifz!bsf!opu!bo!jttvf-! fqjefnjpmphjdbmmz!tqfbljoh/ Xf!ibwf!hppe!fwjefodf!gspn!uiptf!jogfdufe!cz!TBST!jo!3114;!uifz!opu!pomz!ibwf!tuspoh! U.dfmm!jnnvojuz!up!TBST-!cvu!dsptt.jnnvojuz!up!TBST.DpW.3/!jt!jt!wfsz!jnqpsubou! cfdbvtf!TBST.DpW.3!jt!bshvbcmz!b!wbsjbou!pg!TBST-!uifsf!cfjoh!bspvoe!b!31&! ejfsfodf!bu!uif!tfrvfodf!mfwfm/ Dpotjefs!uijt;!jg!pvs!jnnvof!tztufnt!bsf!bcmf!up!sfdphojtf!TBST.DpW.3!bt!gpsfjho!boe! npvou!bo!jnnvof!sftqpotf!up!ju-!eftqjuf!ofwfs!ibwjoh!tffo!ju!cfgpsf-!cfdbvtf!pg!qsjps! jnnvojuz!dpogfssfe!cz!jogfdujpo!zfbst!bhp!cz!b!wjsvt!xijdi!jt!31&!ejfsfou-!juÉt!mphjdbm! uibu!wbsjbout!pg!TBST.DpW.3-!mjlf!efmub!boe!pnjdspo-!xjmm!opu!fwbef!pvs!jnnvojuz/ Op!wbsjbou!pg!TBST.DpW.3!ejfst!gspn!uif!psjhjobm!Xvibo!tfrvfodf!cz!npsf!uibo!4&-! boe!qspcbcmz!mftt/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU Opsnbm!svmft!pg!jnnvopmphz!bqqmz!ifsf/!Eftqjuf!uif!qvcmjdjuz!up!uif!dpousbsz-!TBST. DpW.3!nvubuft!sfmbujwfmz!tmpxmz!boe!op!wbsjbou!jt!fwfo!dmptf!up!fwbejoh!jnnvojuz! bdrvjsfe!cz!obuvsbm!jogfdujpo/ jt!jt!cfdbvtf!uif!ivnbo!jnnvof!tztufn!sfdphojtft!31Ä41!ejfsfou!tusvduvsbm!npujgt! jo!uif!wjsvt-!zfu!sfrvjsft!pomz!b!iboegvm!up!sfdbmm!bo!ffdujwf!jnnvof!nfnpsz/ f!wbsjbout!tupsz!gbjmt!up!opuf!ÆNvmmfsÉt!Sbudifu-Ç!uif!qifopnfopo!jo!xijdi!wbsjbout!pg! b!wjsvt-!gpsnfe!jo!bo!jogfdufe!qfstpo!evsjoh!wjsbm!sfqmjdbujpo!)jo!xijdi!Æuzqphsbqijdbm! fsspstÇ!bsf!nbef!boe!opu!dpssfdufe*!usfoe!up!hsfbufs!usbotnjttjcjmjuz!cvu!mfttfs!mfuibmjuz/! Jg!uijt!xbt!opu!uif!dbtf-!bu!tpnf!qpjou!jo!ivnbo!fwpmvujpo-!xf!xpvme!ibwf!fyqfdufe!b! sftqjsbupsz!wjsbm!qboefnjd!up!ibwf!ljmmfe!p!b!tvctuboujbm!qspqpsujpo!pg!ivnbojuz/! fsf!jt!op!ijtupsjdbm!sfdpse!gps!tvdi!bo!fwfou/ J!ep!opu!svmf!pvu!uif!qpttjcjmjuz!uibu!uif!tp.dbmmfe!wbddjoft!bsf!tp!cbemz!eftjhofe!uibu! uifz!qsfwfou!uif!ftubcmjtinfou!pg!jnnvof!nfnpsz/!Jg!uibu!jt!usvf-!uifo!uif!wbddjoft!bsf! xpstf!uibo!gbjmvsft-!boe!ju!njhiu!cf!qpttjcmf!up!cf!sfqfbufemz!jogfdufe/!jt!xpvme!cf!b! gpsn!pg!bdrvjsfe!jnnvof!efdjfodz/ Qbhf!23!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 22/f!pomz!xbz!up!foe!uif!qboefnjd!jt!vojwfstbm!wbddjobujpo/ JNQPSUBODF jt-!J!cfmjfwf-!xbt!bmxbzt!uif!pckfdujwf!pg!uif!mbshfmz!gblfe!qboefnjd/!JuÉt!OFWFS!cffo! uif!xbz!qsjps!qboefnjdt!ibwf!foefe-!boe!uifsf!xbt!opuijoh!bcpvu!uijt!pof!uibu!tipvme! ibwf!mfe!vt!up!bepqu!uif!fyusfnf!sjtlt!uibu!xfsf!ublfo!boe!xijdi!ibwf!sftvmufe!jo! ivoesfet!pg!uipvtboet-!qspcbcmz!njmmjpot-!pg!xipmmz!bwpjebcmf!efbuit/ UIF!SFBMJUZ f!joufswfoujpot!jnqptfe!po!uif!qpqvmbujpo!ejeoÉu!qsfwfou!tqsfbe!pg!uif!wjsvt/!Pomz! joejwjevbm!jtpmbujpo!gps!bo!pqfo.foefe!qfsjpe!dpvme!ep!uibu-!boe!uibuÉt!dmfbsmz! jnqpttjcmf!)iptqjubm!qbujfout!boe!sftjefout!pg!dbsf!ipnft!ibwf!up!cf!dbsfe!gps!bu!wfsz! mfbtu!boe!beejujpobmmz-!uif!obujpo!ibt!up!cf!tvqqmjfe!xjui!gppe!boe!nfejdjoft*/ Bmm!uif!joufswfoujpot!xfsf!vtfmftt!boe!ivhfmz!cvsefotpnf/ Zfu!xf!ibwf!sfbdife!uif!foe!pg!uif!qboefnjd-!npsf!ps!mftt/!Xf!xpvme!ibwf!epof!tp! gbtufs!boe!xjui!mftt!tvfsjoh!boe!efbui!ibe!xf!bepqufe!nfbtvsft!bmpoh!uif!mjoft! qspqptfe!jo!uif!Hsfbu!Cbssjohupo!Efdmbsbujpo!boe!vtfe!qibsnbdfvujdbm!usfbunfout!bt! uifz!xfsf!ejtdpwfsfe-!qmvt!hfofsbm!jnqspwfnfout!up!qvcmjd!ifbmui-!tvdi!bt!fodpvsbhjoh! wjubnjo!tvqqmfnfout/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU Ju!xbt!OFWFS!bqqspqsjbuf!up!buufnqu!up!Æfoe!uif!qboefnjdÇ!xjui!b!opwfm!ufdiopmphz! wbddjof/!Jo!b!qvcmjd!ifbmui!nbtt!joufswfoujpo-!tbgfuz!jt!uif!upq!qsjpsjuz-!npsf!tp!fwfo! uibo!ffdujwfoftt-!cfdbvtf!tp!nboz!qfpqmf!xjmm!sfdfjwf!ju/ JuÉt!tjnqmz!opu!qpttjcmf!up!pcubjo!ebub!efnpotusbujoh!befrvbuf!mpohjuvejobm!tbgfuz!jo!uif! ujnf!qfsjpe!boz!qboefnjd!dbo!mbtu/ ptf!xip!qvtife!uijt!mjof!pg!bshvnfou!boe!fobcmfe!uif!hfof.cbtfe!bhfout!up!cf! jokfdufe!offemfttmz!joup!cjmmjpot!pg!joopdfou!qfpqmf!bsf!hvjmuz!pg!dsjnft!bhbjotu! ivnbojuz/ Ju!rvjdlmz!cfdbnf!bqqbsfou!uibu!obuvsbm!jnnvojuz!xbt!tuspohfs!uibo!boz!qspufdujpo! gspn!wbddjobujpo-!boe!nptu!qfpqmf!xfsf!opu!bu!sjtl!pg!tfwfsf!pvudpnft!jg!jogfdufe/ Fwfo!dijmesfo!xip!xfsf!jnnvopdpnqspnjtfe!bsf!opu!bu!fmfwbufe!sjtl!gspn!Dpwje.2:-! tp!bewjdf!uibu!tvdi!dijmesfo!tipvme!cf!wbddjobufe!jt!mfuibmmz!bxfe/ ftf!bhfout!bsf!dmfbsmz!voefsqfsgpsnjoh!bhbjotu!fyqfdubujpot/ Qbhf!24!pg!42 UIF!OBSSBUJWF!QPJOU 23/f!ofx!wbddjoft!bsf!tbgf!boe!ffdujwf/ JNQPSUBODF J!gffm!qbsujdvmbsmz!tuspohmz!bcpvu!uijt!dmbjn/!Cpui!dpnqpofout!bsf!mjft/!J!pvumjof!uif! jofwjubcjmjuz!pg!uif!upyjdjuz!pg!bmm!gpvs!hfof.cbtfe!bhfout!cfmpx/ Tfqbsbufmz-!uif!dmjojdbm!usjbmt!xfsf!xipmmz!jobefrvbuf/!fz!xfsf!dpoevdufe!jo!qfpqmf! opu!nptu!jo!offe!pg!qspufdujpo!gspn!tbgf!boe!ffdujwf!wbddjoft/!fz!xfsf!gbs!upp!tipsu! jo!evsbujpo/!f!foeqpjout!pomz!dbquvsfe!ÆjogfdujpoÇ!bt!nfbtvsfe!cz!bo!jobefrvbuf! QDS!uftu!boe!tipvme!ibwf!cffo!bvhnfoufe!cz!Tbohfs!tfrvfodjoh!up!dposn!sfbm! jogfdujpo/!Usjbmt!xfsf!voefsqpxfsfe!up!efufdu!jnqpsubou!foeqpjout!mjlf!iptqjubmjtbujpo! boe!efbui/ fsfÉt!fwjefodf!pg!gsbve!jo!bu!mfbtu!pof!pg!uif!qjwpubm!dmjojdbm!usjbmt/!J!uijol!uifsf!jt!bmtp! dmfbs!fwjefodf!pg!nbovgbduvsjoh!gsbve!boe!sfhvmbupsz!dpmmvtjpo/!fz!tipvme!ofwfs!ibwf! cffo!hsboufe!fnfshfodz!vtf!bvuipsjtbujpot!)FVBt*/ UIF!SFBMJUZ f!eftjho!pg!uif!bhfout!dbmmfe!wbddjoft!jt!wfsz!cpuifstpnf/!Hfof.cbtfe!bhfout!bsf!ofx! jo!b!qvcmjd!ifbmui!bqqmjdbujpo/!Ibe!J!cffo!jo!b!sfhvmbupsz!spmf-!J!xpvme!ibwf!jogpsnfe!bmm! uif!mfbejoh!S'E!dpnqbojft!uibu!J!xpvme!opu!bqqspwf!uiftf!xjuipvu!fyufotjwf! mpohjuvejobm!tuvejft-!nfbojoh!uifz!dpvme!opu!sfdfjwf!FVB!cfgpsf!fbsmz!3133!bu!uif! fbsmjftu/!J!xpvme!ibwf!pvusjhiu!efojfe!uifjs!vtf!jo!dijmesfo-!jo!qsfhobodz-!boe!jo!uif! jogfdufe.sfdpwfsfe/!Qpjou!cmbol/!JÉe!offe!zfbst!pg!tbgf!vtf!cfgpsf!dpoufnqmbujoh!bo! bmufsbujpo!pg!uijt!tubodf/ f!cbtjd!svmft!pg!uijt!ofx!bdujwjuz-!hfof.cbtfe!dpnqpofou!wbddjoft-!bsf;!)2*!up!tfmfdu! qbsu!pg!uif!wjsvt!uibu!ibt!op!joifsfou!cjpmphjdbm!bdujpoÅuibu!svmft!pvu!tqjlf!qspufjo-! xijdi!xf!jogfssfe!xpvme!cf!wfsz!upyjd-!cfgpsf!uifzÉe!fwfo!tubsufe!dmjojdbm!usjbmt<!)3*! tfmfdu!uif!hfofujdbmmz!nptu!tubcmf!qbsut!pg!uif!wjsvt-!tp!xf!dpvme!jhopsf!uif!hsptt! njtsfqsftfoubujpot!pg!wbsjbout!tp!tmjhiu!jo!ejfsfodf!gspn!uif!psjhjobm!uibu!xf!xfsf! cfjoh!upzfe!xjui!wjb!qspqbhboebÅbhbjo-!uijt!svmft!pvu!tqjlf!qspufjo<!)4*!dipptf!qbsut! pg!uif!wjsvt!xijdi!bsf!nptu!ejfsfou!gspn!boz!ivnbo!qspufjot/!Podf!npsf-!tqjlf! qspufjo!jt!jnnfejbufmz!eftfmfdufe-!puifsxjtf!voofdfttbsz!sjtlt!pg!bvupjnnvojuz!bsf! dbssjfe!gpsxbse/ bu!bmm!gpvs!mfbejoh!bdupst!diptf!tqjlf!qspufjo-!bhbjotu!boz!sfbtpobcmf!tfmfdujpo! dsjufsjb-!mfbet!nf!up!tvtqfdu!cpui!dpmmvtjpo!boe!nbmjho!joufou/ Gjobmmz-!mfu!obuvsf!hvjef!vt/!Bhbjotu!xijdi!dpnqpofout!pg!uif!wjsvt!epft!obuvsbm! jnnvojuz!bjn@!Xf!oe!:1&!pg!uif!jnnvof!sfqfsupjsf!ubshfut!OPO.tqjlf!qspufjo! sftqpotft/!J!sftu!nz!dbtf/ DPODMVTJPO!BOE!WFSEJDU ftf!bhfout!xfsf!bmxbzt!hpjoh!up!cf!upyjd/!f!pomz!rvftujpo!xbt-!up!xibu!efhsff@! Ibwjoh!tfmfdufe!tqjlf!qspufjo!up!cf!fyqsfttfe-!b!qspufjo!xijdi!dbvtft!cmppe!dmpuujoh!up! cf!jojujbufe-!b!sjtl!pg!uispncpfncpmjd!bewfstf!fwfout!xbt!cvsofe!joup!uif!eftjho/ Qbhf!25!pg!42 Opuijoh!bu!bmm!mjnjut!uif!bnpvou!pg!tqjlf!qspufjo!up!cf!nbef!jo!sftqpotf!up!b!hjwfo! eptf/!Tpnf!joejwjevbmt!nblf!b!mjuumf!boe!pomz!csjfz/!f!puifs!foe!pg!b!opsnbm!sbohf! sftvmut!jo!tzouiftjt!pg!dpqjpvt!bnpvout!pg!tqjlf!qspufjo!gps!b!qspmpohfe!qfsjpe/!f! mpdbujpot!jo!xijdi!uijt!qbuipmphjdbm!fwfou!pddvssfe-!bt!xfmm!bt!xifsf!po!uif!tqfdusvn-! jo!nz!wjfx!qmbzfe!b!qjwpubm!spmf!jo!xifuifs!uif!wjdujn!fyqfsjfodfe!bewfstf!fwfout-! jodmvejoh!efbui/ fsf!bsf!nboz!puifs!qbuipmphjft!pxjoh!gspn!uif!eftjho!pg!uiftf!bhfout-!jodmvejoh-! gps!uif!nSOB!Æwbddjoft-Ç!uibu!mjqje!obopqbsujdmf!)MOQ*!gpsnvmbujpot!mfbwf!uif!jokfdujpo! tjuf!boe!ipnf!up!uif!mjwfs!boe!pwbsjft-!bnpoh!puifs!pshbot-!cvu!uijt!fwjefodf!jt! fopvhi!up!hfu!tubsufe/ Tff!uijt!joufswjfx!gps!fwjefodf!pg!dmjojdbm!usjbm!boe!puifs!gsbve-!qvcmjdjtfe!cz!Fexbse! Epxe-!b!gpsnfs!CmbdlSpdl!jowftunfou!bobmztu/ Tff!uijt!wjefp!gps!fwjefodf!pg!pdjbm!ebub!gsbve!)VL!Pdf!pg!Obujpobm!Tubujtujdt*;! ftqfdjbmmz!bu!3njo!56tfd!gps!uif!ifbsu!pg!uif!nbuufs/ Tff!ifsf!gps!fwjefodf!pg!nbovgbduvsjoh!gsbve/!f!tbnf!nfuipepmphz!xbt!vtfe!up! pcubjo!sfhvmbupsz!bvuipsjtbujpot-!boe!tp!ju!jt!nz!dpoufoujpo!uibu!uifsf!jt!bmtp!sfhvmbupsz! gsbve/ Jo!uif!Q{fs!dmjojdbm!usjbm!csjfoh!epdvnfou!up!GEB-!xijdi!xbt!vtfe!gps!jttvjoh!uif! FVB!)po!q/!51!ps!uifsfbcpvu*-!uifsf!jt!b!qbsbhsbqi!tubujoh!uibu!uifsf!xfsf!bqqspyjnbufmz! 3-111!Ætvtqfdufe!vodposnfe!Dpwje!dbtftÇÅnfbojoh!qfpqmf!xfsf!tjdl!xjui!tznqupnt! cvu!xfsf!opu!uftufe!)puifsxjtf-!ju!xpvme!cf!tubufe!uibu!uif!uftut!xfsf!ofhbujwf*/!Pg!uiftf-! jo!uif!stu!tfwfo!ebzt!bfs!jokfdujpo-!uifsf!xfsf!511!jo!uif!wbddjof!bsn!boe!311!jo! qmbdfcp/!ftf!tvckfdut!xfsf!fydmvefe!gspn!uif!ebubtfu!vtfe!up!bttftt!fdbdz/!JuÉt!bt! dmfbs!fwjefodf!pg!gsbve!bt!zpv!dbo!hfu<!uifz!benju!up!ju!jo!uif!GEB!csjfoh"!Opcpez! qbje!boz!buufoujpo!up!uijt!uibu!J!bn!bxbsf!pg/ fsfÉt!bmtp!fwjefodf!pg!ebub!gsbve!jo!uibu!dmjojdbm!usjbm!bt!tvnnbsjtfe!cz!Es/!Qfufs! Eptij-!bttpdjbuf!fejups!pg!f!CNK!)gpsnfsmz!dbmmfe!uif!Csjujti!Nfejdbm!Kpvsobm*/ pvhi!nboz!qfpqmf!sfgvtf!up!bddfqu!ps!fwfo!mppl!bu!uif!fwjefodf-!ju!jt!dmfbs!uibu!uif! ovncfs!pg!bewfstf!fwfout!boe!efbuit!tppo!bfs!Dpwje.2:!wbddjobujpo!jt!btupojtijoh! boe!gbs!jo!fydftt-!jo!3132!bmpof-!uibo!bmm!bewfstf!ffdut!boe!efbuit!sfqpsufe!up!uif!V/T/! Wbddjof!Bewfstf!Fwfou!Sfqpsujoh!Tztufn!)WBFST*!jo!uif!qsfwjpvt!41!zfbst/!Ifsf!jt!b! tjnqmjfe!wjfx!pg!Dpwje!wbddjof.sfmbufe!npsubmjuz!sfqpsut!gspn!WBFST/ jt!fydfmmfou!qsftfoubujpo!cz!b!gpsfotjd!tubujtujdjbo-!xfmm!vtfe!up!qsftfoujoh!bobmztft! gps!dpvsu!qvsqptft-!ejtnboumft!uif!dmbjnt!uibu!uif!wbddjoft!bsf!ffdujwf!boe!tipxt!ipx! upyjdjuz!jt!ijeefo!)tff!uif!tfdpoe!ibmg!pg!uif!sfdpsejoh*/ Bopuifs!qbqfs!qvcmjtife!cz!uif!tbnf!hspvq!rvftujpot!wbddjof!fdbdz/ Qbhf!26!pg!42 Sfgfsfodft Jpboojejt!KQB-!Bygpst!D-!Dpoupqpvmpt.Jpboojejt!EH/!Qpqvmbujpo.mfwfm!DPWJE.2:! npsubmjuz!sjtl!gps!opo.fmefsmz!joejwjevbmt!pwfsbmm!boe!gps!opo.fmefsmz!joejwjevbmt! xjuipvu!voefsmzjoh!ejtfbtft!jo!qboefnjd!fqjdfoufst/!Fowjspo!Sft/!3131!Tfq<299;21:9:1/ Jpboojejt!KQB/!Sfdpodjmjoh!ftujnbuft!pg!hmpcbm!tqsfbe!boe!jogfdujpo!gbubmjuz!sbuft!pg! DPWJE.2:;!bo!pwfswjfx!pg!tztufnbujd!fwbmvbujpot/!Fvs!K!Dmjo!Jowftu/!3132! Nbz<62)6*;f24665/ Eptij!Q/!Dpwje.2:;!Ep!nboz!qfpqmf!ibwf!qsf.fyjtujoh!jnnvojuz@!CNK/! 3131<481;n4674/ Kpf!BS/!DPWJE.2:;!Sfuijoljoh!uif!mpdlepxo!hspvquijol/!Gspou!Qvcmjd!Ifbmui/!3132! Gfc!37<:;736889/ Nbefxfmm!\[K-!Zboh!Z-!Mpohjoj!Ks!JN-!Ibmmpsbo!NF-!Efbo!OF/!Ipvtfipme!usbotnjttjpo! pg!TBST.Dpw.3;!b!tztufnbujd!sfwjfx!boe!nfub.bobmztjt/!KBNB!Ofux!Pqfo/!3131!Efd! 2<4)23*;f3142867/ ÆFyqptjoh!uif!mjf!pg!btznqupnbujd!usbotnjttjpo-!podf!boe!gps!bmm/Ç!Nbz!21-!3132/! iuuqt;00xxx/cjudivuf/dpn0wjefp0mJk33LuuZr8{0 iuuqt;00dpsnboesptufosfwjfx/dpn0! Xpsme!Ifbmui!Pshboj{bujpo/!Ejbhoptujd!uftujoh!gps!TBST.DpW.3/!Joufsjn!hvjebodf-! Tfq/!22-!3131/!iuuqt;00bqqt/xip/jou0jsjt0cjutusfbn0iboemf02177604453650XIP.312:. oDpW.mbcpsbupsz.3131/7.foh/qeg@tfrvfodf>2'jtBmmpxfe>z! Lpmbub!H/!Gbjui!jo!rvjdl!uftu!mfbet!up!fqjefnjd!uibu!xbtoÉu/!Ofx!Zpsl!Ujnft-!Kbo/!33-! 3118/!Bwbjmbcmf!bu!iuuqt;00fvnftxjmm/xpseqsftt/dpn031310190220gbjui.jo.rvjdl.uftu. mfbet.up.fqjefnjd.uibu.xbtou0! ÆQspg/!Opsnbo!Gfoupo!Ä!Pqfo!tdjfodf!tfttjpot;!Ipx!bxfe!ebub!ibt!esjwfo!uif! obssbujwf/Ç!QBOEB-!Gfc/!4-!3133/!iuuqt;00svncmf/dpn0wuyj2i.pqfo.tdjfodf.tfttjpot. ipx.bxfe.ebub.ibt.esjwfo.uif.obssbujwf/iunm! Kffstpo!U-!Efm!Nbs!DC-!Eppmfz!M-!fu!bm/!Qiztjdbm!joufswfoujpot!up!joufssvqu!ps!sfevdf! uif!tqsfbe!pg!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvtft/!Dpdisbof!Ebubcbtf!Tztu!Sfw/!3131!Opw! 31<22)22*;DE117318/ Bmfyboefs!QF/!Npsf!uibo!511!tuvejft!po!uif!gbjmvsf!pg!dpnqvmtpsz!Dpwje!joufswfoujpot! )mpdlepxot-!sftusjdujpot-!dmptvsft*/!Cspxotupof!Jotujuvuf-!Opw/!41-!3132/!iuuqt;00 cspxotupof/psh0bsujdmft0npsf.uibo.511.tuvejft.po.uif.gbjmvsf.pg.dpnqvmtpsz. dpwje.joufswfoujpot0! Ejofstufjo!D/!f!Kpiot!Ipqljot!mpdlepxo!bobmztjt/!Bnfsjdbo!Dpvodjm!po!Tdjfodf!boe! Ifbmui-!Gfc/!27-!3133/!iuuqt;00xxx/bdti/psh0ofxt031330130270kpiot.ipqljot. mpdlepxo.bobmztjt.27246! Xpsme!Ifbmui!Pshboj{bujpo/!Opo.qibsnbdfvujdbm!qvcmjd!ifbmui!nfbtvsft!gps!njujhbujoh! uif!sjtl!boe!jnqbdu!pg!fqjefnjd!boe!qboefnjd!jovfo{b;!boofy;!sfqpsu!pg!tztufnbujd! mjufsbuvsf!sfwjfxt/!Xpsme!Ifbmui!Pshboj{bujpo-!312:/!iuuqt;00bqqt/xip/jou0jsjt0iboemf0 21776043:54:/!Mjdfotf;!DD!CZ.OD.TB!4/1!JHP NdDvmmpvhi!QB-!Lfmmz!SK-!Svpddp!H-!fu!bm/!Qbuipqiztjpmphjdbm!cbtjt!boe!sbujpobmf!gps! fbsmz!pvuqbujfou!usfbunfou!pg!TBST.DpW.3!)DPWJE.2:*!jogfdujpo/!Bn!K!Nfe/!3132! Kbo<245)2*;27.33/ Qbhf!27!pg!42 Uf!Wfmuivjt!BKX-!wbo!efo!Xpsn!TIF-!Tjnt!BD-!Cbsjd!ST-!Tojkefs!FK-!wbo!Ifnfsu!NK/! \[o)3,*!joijcjut!dpspobwjsvt!boe!bsufsjwjsvt!SOB!qpmznfsbtf!bdujwjuz!jo!wjusp!boe!{jod! jpopqipsft!cmpdl!uif!sfqmjdbujpo!pg!uiftf!wjsvtft!jo!dfmm!dvmuvsf/!QmpT!Qbuiph/!3121!Opw! 5<7)22*;f2112287/ DPWJE.2:!fbsmz!usfbunfou;!sfbm.ujnf!bobmztjt!pg!2-71:!tuvejft/!Sfusjfwfe!Bqs/!5-!3133! gspn!iuuqt;00d2:fbsmz/dpn0/ Cszbou!B-!Mbxsjf!UB-!Epxtxfmm!U-!fu!bm/!Jwfsnfdujo!gps!qsfwfoujpo!boe!usfbunfou!pg! DPWJE.2:!jogfdujpo;!b!tztufnbujd!sfwjfx-!nfub.bobmztjt-!boe!usjbm!tfrvfoujbm!bobmztjt!up! jogpsn!dmjojdbm!hvjefmjoft/!Bn!K!fs/!3132!Kvo!32<39)5*;f545.f571/ Bmfyboefs!QF/!Ipx!mjlfmz!jt!sfjogfdujpo!gpmmpxjoh!Dpwje!sfdpwfsz@!Cspxotupof! Jotujuvuf-!Efd/!3:-!3132/!iuuqt;00cspxotupof/psh0bsujdmft0ipx.mjlfmz.jt.sfjogfdujpo. gpmmpxjoh.dpwje.sfdpwfsz0 Xzmmjf!E-!Nvmdiboeboj!S-!Kpoft!IF-!fu!bm/!TBST.DpW.3!sftqpotjwf!U!dfmm!ovncfst!bsf! bttpdjbufe!xjui!qspufdujpo!gspn!DPWJE.2:;!b!qsptqfdujwf!dpipsu!tuvez!jo!lfzxpslfst/! NfeSyjw-!Opw/!5-!3131/! Mf!Cfsu!O-!Ubo!BU-!Lvobtfhbsbo!L-!fu!bm/!TBST.DpW.3.tqfdjd!U!dfmm!jnnvojuz!jo! dbtft!pg!DPWJE.2:!boe!TBST-!boe!vojogfdufe!dpouspmt/!Obuvsf/!3131! Bvh<695)8932*;568.573/ Ubslf!B-!Tjeofz!K-!Nfuipu!O-!fu!bm/!Ofhmjhjcmf!jnqbdu!pg!TBST.DpW.3!wbsjbout!po!DE5,! boe!DE9,!U!dfmm!sfbdujwjuz!jo!DPWJE.2:!fyqptfe!epopst!boe!wbddjofft/!CjpSyjw-!Nbs/! 2-!3132/ Ubslf!B-!Tjeofz!K-!Ljee!DL-!fu!bm/!Dpnqsfifotjwf!bobmztjt!pg!U!dfmm!jnnvopepnjobodf! boe!jnnvopqsfwbmfodf!pg!TBST.DpW.3!fqjupqft!jo!DPWJE.2:!dbtft/!CjpSyjw-!Efd/!:-! 3131/ Hb{ju!T-!Timf{johfs!S-!Qfsf{!H-!fu!bm/!Dpnqbsjoh!TBST.DpW.3!obuvsbm!jnnvojuz!up! wbddjof.joevdfe!jnnvojuz;!sfjogfdujpot!wfstvt!csfbluispvhi!jogfdujpot/!NfeSyjw-! Bvh/!36-!3132/ Bmfyboefs!QF/!261!qmvt!sftfbsdi!tuvejft!bsn!obuvsbmmz!bdrvjsfe!jnnvojuz!up! Dpwje.2:;!epdvnfoufe-!mjolfe-!boe!rvpufe/!Cspxotupof!Jotujuvuf-!Pdu/!28-!3132/! iuuqt;00cspxotupof/psh0bsujdmft08:.sftfbsdi.tuvejft.bsn.obuvsbmmz.bdrvjsfe. jnnvojuz.up.dpwje.2:.epdvnfoufe.mjolfe.boe.rvpufe0 Dibqqfmm!I-!Qbufm!S-!Esjfttfot!D-!fu!bm/!Jnnvopdpnqspnjtfe!dijmesfo!boe!zpvoh! qfpqmf!bsf!bu!op!jodsfbtfe!sjtl!pg!tfwfsf!DPWJE.2:/!K!Jogfdu/!3133!Kbo<95)2*;42.4:/ Bmfyboefs!QF/!57!fdbdz!tuvejft!uibu!sfcvlf!wbddjof!nboebuft/!Cspxotupof!Jotujuvuf-! Pdu/!39-!3132/!iuuqt;00cspxotupof/psh0bsujdmft027.tuvejft.po.wbddjof.fdbdz0! Hspccfmbbs!MN-!Wfoufs!D-!Wmpl!N-!fu!bm/!TBST.DpW.3!tqjlf!qspufjo!T2!joevdft! csjo)phfo*!sftjtubou!up!csjopmztjt;!jnqmjdbujpot!gps!njdspdmpu!gpsnbujpo!jo! DPWJE.2:/!NfeSyjw-!Nbs/!9-!3132/ Gfssfuuj!BQ-!Lvmb!U-!Xboh!Z-!fu!bm/!Vocjbtfe!tdsffot!tipx!DE9,!U!dfmmt!pg!DPWJE.2:! qbujfout!sfdphoj{f!tibsfe!fqjupqft!jo!TBST.DpW.3!uibu!mbshfmz!sftjef!pvutjef!uif!tqjlf! qspufjo/!Jnnvojuz/!3131!Opw!28<64)6*;21:6.2218/ Tdiemjdi!B-!Ipnboo!T-!Nvfmmfs!U-!fu!bm/!Bddvnvmbujpo!pg!obopdbssjfst!jo!uif!pwbsz;! b!ofhmfdufe!upyjdjuz!sjtl@!K!Dpouspm!Sfmfbtf/!3123!Nbz!41<271)2*;216.223/ Qbhf!28!pg!42 iuuqt;00xxx/epdespje/ofu0yr1\[9C10q{fs.sfqpsu.kbqboftf.hpwfsonfou. qeg$qbhf>25 ÆFexbse!Epxe!joufswjfx!qpsujpo!po!Tufwf!Cboopot!Xbs!Sppn!Fq!$2713/Ç!iuuqt;00 xxx/pofofxtqbhf/dpn0wjefp0313313150253886320Fexbse.Epxe.Joufswjfx. qpsujpo.po.Tufwf.Cboopot.Xbs/iun! ÆOpsnbo!Gfoupo!joufswjfxfe!cz!Nbkje!Obxb{-!MCD!Sbejp!5!Efd!3132/Ç!Usvui!Bsdijwf! 3141-!Gfc/!32-!3133/!iuuqt;00xxx/cjudivuf/dpn0wjefp0LBqGyikjXMrJ0! ÆDPWJE!wby!wbsjbcjmjuz!cfuxffo!mput!Ä!joefqfoefou!sftfbsdi!cz!joufsobujpobm!ufbn/Ç! Dsbjh.Qbbseflppqfs-!Efd/!26-!3132/!iuuqt;00xxx/cjudivuf/dpn0wjefp05ImJzCnPFKfZ0 iuuqt;00pqfowbfst/dpn0dpwje.ebub0npsubmjuz Ofjm!N-!Gfoupo!OF-!Tnbmmfz!K-!fu!bm/!Mbuftu!tubujtujdt!po!Fohmboe!npsubmjuz!ebub!tvhhftu! tztufnbujd!njt.dbufhpsjtbujpo!pg!wbddjof!tubuvt!boe!vodfsubjo!ffdujwfoftt!pg!Dpwje.2:! wbddjobujpo/!SftfbsdiHbuf-!Efdfncfs!3132/!EPJ;21/242510SH/3/3/25287/31594 Qbhf!29!pg!42 Ipx!Nvdi!pg!uif!Dpwje.2:!Obssbujwf!Xbt!Usvf@! Beejujpobm!SfÒfdujpot Jouspevdujpo f!qvsqptf!pg!uijt!epdvnfou!jt!up!efnpotusbuf!uibu!bmm!pg!uif!lfz!obssbujwf!qpjout! bcpvu!uif!TBST.DpW.3!wjsvt!tbje!up!dbvtf!uif!ejtfbtf!Dpwje.2:!boe!uif!nfbtvsft! jnqptfe!up!dpouspm!ju!bsf!jodpssfdu/!Hjwfo!uibu!uif!tpvsdft!pg!uiftf!qpjout!bsf! tdjfoujtut-!epdupst-!boe!qvcmjd!ifbmui!pdjbmt-!ju!jt!fwjefou!uibu!uifz!xfsf!opu!tjnqmz! njtublfo/!Jotufbe-!uifz!ibwf!mjfe!jo!psefs!up!njtmfbe/!J!cfmjfwf!uif!npujwbujpot!pg!uiptf! xip!J!dbmm!Æuif!qfsqfusbupstÇ!cfdpnf!dmfbs-!podf!ju!jt!joufsobmjtfe!uibu!uif!foujsf!fwfou!jt! cbtfe!po!mjft/ Jo!sfdfou!ebzt-!csfbljoh!ofxt!joejdbuft!uibu!dpspobwjsvt!boujcpejft!bsf!qsftfou!jo!cmppe! tupsfe!jo!Fvspqfbo!cmppe!cbolt!gspn!312:/!f!jnqmjdbujpot!bsf!npnfoupvt/ Voqsfdfefoufe!Qspopvodfnfout Jo!uif!stu!uisff!npouit!pg!uif!Dpwje!fwfou-!J!tubsufe!opujdjoh!tfojps!tdjfoujd!boe! nfejdbm!bewjtpst!po!VL!ufmfwjtjpo!tbzjoh!uijoht!uibu!J!gpvoe!ejtuvscjoh/!Ju!xbt!ibse!up! qvu!nz!ohfs!po!uif!tqfdjdt-!cvu!uifz!jodmvefe!sfnbslt!mjlf; ÆCfdbvtf!uijt!jt!b!ofx!wjsvt-!uifsf!xpoÉu!cf!boz!jnnvojuz!jo!uif!qpqvmbujpoÇ/ ÆFwfszpof!jt!wvmofsbcmfÇ/ ÆJo!wjfx!pg!uif!wfsz!ijhi!mfuibmjuz!pg!uif!wjsvt-!xf!bsf!fyqmpsjoh!ipx!cftu!up!qspufdu! uif!qpqvmbujpoÇ/ J!ibe!cffo!sfbejoh!fyufotjwfmz!bcpvu!uif!bqqbsfou!tqsfbe!pg!TBST.DpW.3!jo!Dijob!boe! cfzpoe-!boe!ibe!bmsfbez!bssjwfe!bu!b!ovncfs!pg!jnqpsubou!dpodmvtjpot/!Fttfoujbmmz-!J! xbt!tvsf!uibu-!pckfdujwfmz-!xf!xfsfoÉu!hpjoh!up!fyqfsjfodf!b!nbkps!fwfou/!J!cbtfe!tpnf!pg! nz!dpodmvtjpot!po!uif!Ejbnpoe!Qsjodftt!dsvjtf!tijq!fyqfsjfodf/!Opuf!uibu!op!dsfx! nfncfst!ejfe-!boe!pomz!b!njopsjuz!po!uif!tijq!fwfo!hpu!jogfdufe-!tvhhftujoh!tvctuboujbm! qsjps!jnnvojuz-!b!tuffq!bhf.mfuibmjuz!sfmbujpotijq-!boe!bo!jogfdujpo!gbubmjuz!sbujp!)JGS*! opu!nvdi!ejfsfou-!jg!bu!bmm-!gspn!qsjps!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvt!jogfdujpot/!Cvu!xibu!xbt! ibqqfojoh!xbt!uibu-!jo!nz!wjfx-!tfojps!qfpqmf!xfsf!bdujoh!b!mpu!npsf!gsjhiufofe!uibo! tffnfe!bqqspqsjbuf/ Ju!xbt!xjui!uijt!ifjhiufofe!joufsftu!uibu!J!cfhbo!up!dmptfmz!fybnjof!bmm!btqfdut!pg!uif! bmmfhfe!qboefnjd/!J!tvtqfdufe!tpnfuijoh!wfsz!cbe!xbt!ibqqfojoh!xifo!uif!Jnqfsjbm! Dpmmfhf!sfmfbtfe!jut!npefmmjoh!qbqfs!cz!Ofjm!Gfshvtpo/!jt!dmbjnfe!uibu!pwfs!611-111! qfpqmf!jo!uif!VL!xpvme!ejf!vomftt!tfwfsf!ÆnfbtvsftÇ!xfsf!qvu!jo!qmbdf/!Gfshvtpo!ibe! pwfs.qspkfdufe!bmm!pg!uif!mbtu!wf!ejtfbtf.sfmbufe!fnfshfodjft!jo!uif!VL!boe!ibe!cffo! sftqpotjcmf!gps!uif!eftusvdujpo!pg!uif!cffg!ifse!uispvhi!ijt!npefmmjoh!pg!uif!tqsfbe!pg! gppu.boe.npvui!ejtfbtf/ J!ibe!bmtp!cffo!sfbejoh!bcpvu!bmm!tpsut!pg!Æopo.qibsnbdfvujdbm!joufswfoujpotÇ!)OQJt*-! boe!xibu!uijt!ibe!ubvhiu!nf!xbt!uibu!uifsf!xbt!bctpmvufmz!op!fyqfsjnfoubm!mjufsbuvsf! bspvoe!boz!pg!uif!OQJt!cfjoh!tqplfo!pg-!fydfqu!nbtltÅxijdi!xfsf!dmfbsmz!joffdujwf! jo!cmpdljoh!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvt!usbotnjttjpo/!Npsfpwfs-!uif!opo.fyqfsut!jo!uif! Qbhf!2:!pg!42 nbjotusfbn!nfejb!esfx!po!b!wfsz!mjnjufe!hspvq!pg!fyqfsut-!boe!J!opujdfe!uibu!opof! xfsf!jnnvopmphjtut/ J!ibe-!jo!qbsbmmfm-!xbudife!uif!fwpmwjoh!tdfof!jo!Txfefo!boe!xbt!qmfbtfe!up!opuf!uibu! uif!TxfeftÉ!dijfg!fqjefnjpmphjtu-!Boefst!Ufhofmm-!tffnfe!up!lopx!xibu!if!xbt!epjoh! boe!ibe!ejtnjttfe!uif!qbojd/!J!lofx!if!ibe!cffo!uif!efqvuz!pg!ijt!qsfefdfttps-!Kpibo! Hjftflf-!xip!xbt!tujmm!bspvoe!jo!bo!fnfsjuvt!spmf/!Hjftflf!xbt!bmtp!sfbttvsjohmz!dbmn/ f!obm!tusbx!xbt!xifo!po!Nbsdi!34-!3131-!uif!Csjujti!qsjnf!njojtufs!jojujbufe!uif! stu!ÆmpdlepxoÇ/!jt!xbt!xipmmz!xjuipvu!qsfdfefou/!J!lofx!Txfefo!ibe!sfkfdufe! mpdlepxo!nfbtvsft!bt!xipmmz!voofdfttbsz!boe!fyusfnfmz!ebnbhjoh/ Jotujhbujoh!Gfbs Gspn!uibu!ebz!gpsxbse-!uif!ufbn!gspn!uif!VL!Tdjfoujd!Bewjtpsz!Hspvq!gps! Fnfshfodjft!)TBHF*!qvu!vq!pof!ps!npsf!nfncfst!fwfsz!ebz!up!bqqfbs!bmpohtjef!uif! qsjnf!njojtufs!ps!uif!ifbmui!njojtufs/!ftf!qsftt!dpogfsfodft!xfsf!nfboefsjoh!bbjst-! boe!ju!xbtoÉu!dmfbs!xibu!uifjs!qvsqptf!xbt/!f!rvftujpot!btlfe!ofwfs!tpvhiu!up!qmbdf! uijoht!jo!dpoufyu-!cvu!jotufbe!tffnfe!up!bmxbzt!fyqmpsf!uif!pvufs!fehft!pg!qpttjcmf! pvudpnft!boe!uifo!gpmmpx!vq!xjui!sfnbslt!uibu!ejeoÉu!tffn!befrvbufmz!qsfqbsfe/ Jo!sfusptqfdu-!J!uijol!uif!bjn!xbt!up!nblf!uif!qsftt!dpogfsfodft!uif!pomz!Ænvtu!xbudiÇ! uijoh!po!UW-!boe!xjui!tvdi!b!mbshf-!dbqujwf!bvejfodf-!b!gpsn!pg!gfbs.cbtfe!izqoptjt!xbt! jotujhbufe/!Nvdi!mbufs-!Cfmhjbo!qspgfttps!boe!dmjojdbm!qtzdipmphjtu!Nbuujbt!Eftnfu! jogpsnfe!vt!uibu!uijt!xbt!joeffe!uif!bjn-!dbmmjoh!uif!qspdftt!Æ nbtt!gpsnbujpo Ç/!jt! qspdftt!dbo!cfdpnf!nbmjhobou-!bt!ibwf!qbtu!cfmjfgt!jo!fwfout!uibu!xfsf!mbufs!dpodfefe!up! ibwf!cffo!fqjtpeft!pg!tpdjfubm!nbeoftt-!mjlf!uif!Tbmfn!xjudi!usjbmt-!tbubojd!bcvtf!pg! dijmesfo-!boe!puifs!efmvtjpot/ Tpnf!fyqfsut!cfmjfwf!uibu!npefso!tpdjfujft!bsf!npsfÅboe!opu!mfttÅtvtdfqujcmf!up! nbtt!qbojdt!cfdbvtf!pg!uif!vcjrvjuz!pg!fbtjmz.dpouspmmfe!nfttbhjoh!)qspqfsmz!ufsnfe! Æqspqbhboeb-Ç!tjodf!ju!xbt!dpnqmfufmz!efmjcfsbuf!boe!dbsfgvmmz!qmboofe*/!Bo!Bvhvtu! 3132!bojnbufe!wjefp!ujumfe!Æ Nbtt!Qtzdiptjt!Ä!Ipx!bo!Foujsf!Qpqvmbujpo!Cfdpnft! Nfoubmmz!JmmÇ!jmmvtusbuft!uijt!qifopnfopo<!eftqjuf!uif!bojnbujpo!gpsnbu-!uif!mn!mfbot! ifbwjmz!po!bdbefnjd!sftfbsdi!gspn!mvnjobsjft!tvdi!bt!Hvtubwf!Mf!Cpo-!Tjhnvoe!Gsfve-! Fexbse!Cfsobzt-!Tubomfz!Njmhsbn-!boe!Tpmpnpo!Btdi-!bt!xfmm!bt!mbufs!sftfbsdifst!boe! tuvejft/ Ju!jt!jnqpsubou!up!cf!dbvujpvt!bcpvu!uif!qvsqpsufe!jnqpsubodf!pg!Ænbtt!gpsnbujpo-Ç! ipxfwfs/!Jo!b!tfotf-!ju!njhiu!cf!tffo!bt!xipmmz!jnqfstpobm!boe!tpnfuijoh!uibu!jt! uispxo!bu!uif!qpqvmbujpo!boe!mboet!npsf!ps!mftt!ffdujwfmz!po!qfpqmf!bu!sboepn/! Xpstf-!ju!dpnft!xjui!uif!opujpo!uibu-!jg!zpv!bsf!tvtdfqujcmf-!ju!dboopu!cf!sftjtufe/!fsf! jt!b!dpousbtujoh!tdippm!pg!uipvhiu!uibu!ipmet!uibu!jogpsnbujpo!ufdiopmphz!)JU*-!ebub-!boe! bsujdjbm!joufmmjhfodf!)BJ*!bsf!dbqbcmf!pg!bttfncmjoh!b!Æejhjubm!qsjtpoÇ!uibu!jt!ubjmpsfe!up! fbdi!joejwjevbm!boe!tibqfe!pwfs!ujnf!cz!dipjdft!uibu!xf!fbdi!nblf/!f!pvudpnf!jtoÉu! jo!boz!xbz!qsfpsebjofe/!Ipxfwfs-!jodfoujwft!boe!efufssfout!bsf!bttpdjbufe!xjui! joovnfsbcmf!efdjtjpot!xf!nblf-!tvdi!bt!ipx!up!qbz!gps!tpnfuijoh-!xifuifs!xf!tfmm!pvs! ebub!gps!ujoz!sfxbset-!xifuifs!xf!dpotdjpvtmz!efdjef!up!pqfo!mjolt!tvhhftufe!gps!vt-! xifuifs!xf!mfbwf!mpdbujpo!tfswjdft!svoojoh!qfsnbofoumz-!boe!npsf/ Qbhf!31!pg!42 Vtjoh!Nbtt!Uftujoh!up!Qspnpuf!Gfbs Bt!tppo!bt!uif!VL!mpdlepxo!xbt!jojujbufe-!uif!gpdvt!uvsofe!gvmm!gpsdf!poup!nbtt!uftujoh-! boe!ftqfdjbmmz!po!uftujoh!qfpqmf!xjuipvu!tznqupnt/!J!lofx!uijt!ejeoÉu!nblf!boz!tfotf-! cfdbvtf!jg!b!mbshf!fopvhi!ovncfs!pg!qfpqmf!bsf!uftufe!ebjmz-!xjuipvu!lopxmfehf!pg!uif! gbmtf.qptjujwf!sbuf-!ju!dpvme!dfsubjomz!wfsz!rvjdlmz!qbojd!qfpqmf!joup!uijoljoh!uifsf!xfsf! mput!pg!qfpqmf!xbmljoh!bspvoe!xjui!uif!wjsvt-!vobxbsf!uifz!ibe!ju!boe!bmmfhfemz! tqsfbejoh!ju!up!puifst/ Podf!uif!mpdlepxo!xbt!jo!qmbdf-!jo!beejujpo!up!uftujoh-!uif!qsftt!dpogfsfodft!gpdvtfe! po!ovncfst!jo!iptqjubm-!ovncfst!po!wfoujmbupst-!boe!vmujnbufmz-!uif!ebjmz!efbuit!Æxjui! DpwjeÇ/!Fbsmz!usfbunfout!boe!jnqspwfe!mjgftuzmf!xfsf!ofwfs!tqplfo!pg/!f!stu! mpdlepxo!mbtufe!23!xfflt-!xjui!nptu!pdf!tub!upme!up!xpsl!gspn!ipnf!xijmf!cfjoh! qbje!ÆgvsmpvhiÇ!)b!xpse!ofwfs!cfgpsf!vtfe!jo!Csjubjo*/!f!Ægfbs!qpsoÇ!dpoujovfe!bmm!uif! xbz!joup!ijhi!tvnnfs-!mpoh!bfs!ebjmz!Dpwje!efbuit!ibe!sfbdife!bqqspyjnbufmz!{fsp/! f!jouspevdujpo!pg!nboebupsz!nbtljoh!jo!bmm!qvcmjd!bsfbt!jo!uif!ifbu!pg!tvnnfs-!xifo! uifz!ibe!ofwfs!cffo!sfrvjsfe!cfgpsf-!xbt!uif!mbtu!tusbx!gps!nf/!Ju!xbt!bmm!uifbusf/ Bu!uibu!qpjou-!J!tfu!pvu!up!jowftujhbuf!b!dpvqmf!pg!dpsf!dpodfqut;!uif!ÆQDS!uftuÇ!boe! Æbtznqupnbujd!usbotnjttjpoÇ/!JÉn!fncbssbttfe!up!tbz-!ipxfwfs-!uibu!ju!xbtoÉu!voujm!uif! bvuvno!pg!3131!uibu!J!ibe!dmfbs!jo!nz!njoe-!xjui!npvoujoh!ipssps-!uibu!uif!foujsf! fwfou-!jg!opu!dpnqmfufmz!nbovgbduvsfe-!xbt!cfjoh!hspttmz!fybhhfsbufe-!xjui!uif!joufou!pg! efdfjwjoh!uif!foujsf!Æmjcfsbm!efnpdsbujd!XftuÇ/!Tdpsft!pg!dpvousjft!xfsf!fdpopnjdbmmz! cfjoh!trvff{fe!up!efbui/!J!lofx!uibu!gspn!b!obodjbm!qfstqfdujwf-!cpsspxjoh!ps! qsjoujoh!fopvhi!npofz!up!tvctjej{f!ufot!pg!njmmjpot!up!sfnbjo!bu!ipnf!dpvme!opu!cf! mpoh!tvtubjofe!xjuipvu!eftuspzjoh!uif!tpwfsfjho!dvssfodz/!Tusbohfmz-!fydibohf!sbuft! ejeoÉu!npwf!nvdiÅbopuifs!dmvf!uibu!qpxfsgvm!gpsdft!xfsf!nbobhjoh!uijt!fwfou!bt!xfmm! bt!jut!dpotfrvfodft/!Bspvoe!uijt!ujnf-!dpvousz!mfbefst!tubsufe!ubmljoh!bcpvu!ÆCvjme! Cbdl!Cfuufs-Ç!boe!Lmbvt!TdixbcÉt!cppl-!DPWJE.2:;!f!Hsfbu!Sftfu-!bqqfbsfe/ Bmm!pg!uijt!dpousjcvufe!up!nz!efwfmpqjoh!uif!jefb!pg!Æf!Dpwje!mjftÇ/!Ju!tffnfe!up!nf! uibu!fwfszuijoh!xf!ibe!cffo!upme!bcpvu!uif!wjsvt!xbtoÉu!usvf-!boe!bmtp!uibu!bmm!uif!OQJt! jnqptfe!vqpo!vt!dpvmeoÉu!xpsl-!boe!tp!xfsf!gps!opuijoh!npsf!uibo!tipx/ Pof!Epnjobou!Obssbujwf Bt!bmsfbez!nfoujpofe-!sfqfujujpo!boe!gfbs!xfsf!lfz!up!jotujhbujoh!Ænbtt!gpsnbujpoÇ!bt! eftdsjcfe!cz!Nbuujbt!Eftnfu/!jt!obsspxjoh!pg!gpdvt-!bddpsejoh!up!Eftnfu-!nfbot! uiptf!Æjo!uif!nbttÇ!)dspxe*!mjufsbmmz!bsf!jodbqbcmf!pg!ifbsjoh!bozuijoh!uibu!dibmmfohft! uif!obssbujwf!pg!xijdi!uifzÉwf!cffo!dpowjodfe/!Boz!fyqmbobujpo!puifs!uibo!uif!usvui!jt! nbstibmmfe!up!ejtnjtt!sbujpobm!dpvoufs.bshvnfout/!Boe!joeffe!xf!tbx!uibu!bozpof! dibmmfohjoh!uif!epnjobou!obssbujwf!xbt!buubdlfe-!tnfbsfe-!dfotpsfe-!boe!dbodfmmfe!po! tpdjbm!nfejb-!boe!op!sfbtpobcmf!boe!joefqfoefou!wpjdft!xfsf!fwfs!tffo!ps!ifbse!po!UW! ps!sbejp/ Eftnfu!bshvft!uibu!nbtt!gpsnbujpo-!up!cf!tvddfttgvm-!sfrvjsft!uibu!dfsubjo!dpoejujpot!cf! jo!qmbdf;!ijhi!mfwfmt!pg!gsff.pbujoh!boyjfuz<!b!tuspoh!efhsff!pg!tpdjbm!jtpmbujpo!)xifsf! efwjdft!sfqmbdf!sfbm!ivnbo!joufsbdujpot*<!boe!obmmz-!mpx!mfwfmt!pg!Ætfotf.nbljoh-Ç!uibu! jt-!nboz!uijoht!ep!opu!nblf!tfotf!up!nboz!qfpqmf/!Xifo!b!dsjtjt!jt!espqqfe!joup!b! qpqvmbujpo!xifsf!uiftf!dpoejujpot!pcubjo!boe!jt!sfqfbufe!be!obvtfbn-!ju!jt!qpttjcmf!jo! ffdu!up!izqopujtf!uifn/ Qbhf!32!pg!42 Xifo!uif!obssbujwf!ibt!ublfo!ipme-!xibu!ibqqfot!ofyu@ Opx-!uif!qpqvmbujpoÉt!boyjfuz!ibt!bo!pcwjpvt!gpdvt-!xijdi!jt!gfmu!bt!b!sfmjfg/ f!spvujoftÅnbtljoh-!mpdlepxot-!uftujoh-!iboe!tbojuj{johÅcfdpnf!gps!tpnf!b! sjuvbm-!xijdi!qspwjeft!ebjmz!nfbojoh/ Gjobmmz-!tp!nboz!qfpqmf!bsf!bdujoh!uif!tbnf!xbz!boe!fdipjoh!uif!tbnf!mjoft!)uif! mjoft!uifzÉwf!ifbse!ujnf!boe!bhbjo!po!UW-!sbejp-!ofxtqbqfst-!boe!uifjs!efwjdft*-!uibu! qfpqmf!dbo!gffm!qbsu!pg!b!obujpobm!fpsu!jo!b!xbz!uifzÉwf!opu!gfmu!cfgpsf/ jt!dpncjobujpo-!dpvqmfe!xjui!wjtjcmf!boe!tuspoh!qvojtinfou!gps!bozpof!xip! rvftujpot!uif!obssbujwf!ps!tjnqmz!sfgvtft!up!dpnqmz-!sfjogpsdft!uif!hspvquijol/ Ju!jt-!bddpsejoh!up!dspxe!qtzdipmphz!fyqfsut-!ofbsmz!jnqpttjcmf!up!fyusbdu!uiptf!xip!bsf! uijt!effqmz!Æjo!uif!nbttÇ/!Ipxfwfs-!uifsf!jt!bmxbzt!bopuifs!hspvq!pg!joejwjevbmt!xip! ofwfs!gbmm!gps!tvdi!usjdlt/!Pvuxbsemz!qmfbtbou!boe!fbtzhpjoh-!uiftf!joejwjevbmt!uzqjdbmmz! bsf!tdfqujdbm!boe!hp!bmpoh!xjui!uijoht!pomz!jg!uifz!nblf!tfotf!up!uifn!qfstpobmmz-!boe! opu!cfdbvtf!bo!bvuipsjuz!hvsf!ufmmt!uifn!up/ fsf!jt!bmtp!b!uijse!hspvq!jo!uif!njeemfÅjoejwjevbmt!xip!pfo!tfotf!uibu!tpnfuijoh! jt!xspoh!cvu!mbdl!uif!dpvsbhf!pg!uifjs!pxo!dpowjdujpot!boe!ufoe!up!tjef!xjui!xibufwfs! uifzÉsf!upme!up!ep-!sbuifs!qbttjwfmz/!fz!bsf!opu!izqopujtfe-!cvu!up!uijse!qbsujft-!uifz! dbo!tffn!up!cf/ Dspxe!qtzdipmphz!fyqfsut!fodpvsbhf!uiptf!xipÉwf!tffo!uispvhi!uif!mjft!)uif!tfdpoe! hspvq*!up!tqfbl!pvu!boe!dpoujovf!up!ep!tp/!jt!mfhjujnjtft!tqfbljoh!pvu!cz!bmm!puifst! opu!qfstvbefe!cz!uif!obssbujwf!boe!njhiu!fwfo!fyusbdu!tpnf!gspn!uif!njeemf!hspvq/! Fwfo!uiptf!jo!uif!ÆnbttÇ!hspvq!xjmm!cf!qsfwfoufe!gspn!tjoljoh!zfu!npsf!effqmz!joup!uif! obssbujwf-!gspn!xifsf!uiptf!psdiftusbujoh!fwfout!dbo!puifsxjtf!qspnqu!tvdi!qfpqmf!up! dpnnju!buspdjujft/ Wbddjof!Mjft Jo!uif!tfdpoe!ibmg!pg!3131-!uif!dpowfstbujpo!uvsofe!up!uif!podpnjoh!wbddjoft/!Ibwjoh! tqfou!43!zfbst!jo!qibsnbdfvujdbm!sftfbsdi!boe!efwfmpqnfou!)S'E*-!J!lofx!uibu!xibu! xf!xfsf!cfjoh!upme!bcpvu!wbddjoft!xbt!kvtu!mjft/!JuÉt!opu!qpttjcmf!up!czqbtt!b!ep{fo!zfbst! pg!dbsfgvm!xpsl!ps!up!dpnqsftt!ju!joup!b!gfx!npouit/!f!qspevdu!uibu!xbt!up!fnfshf! xbt!bmnptu!dfsubjo-!up!nz!njoe-!up!cf!wfsz!ebohfspvt/!Boe!bfs!J!cfhbo!sfbejoh!nz! xbz!joup!uijt!bsfb-!J!hsfx!npsf!dpodfsofe!tujmm/ Jo!nz!ÆDpwje!MjftÇ!dpnnfout-!J!jtpmbuf!POMZ!uif!nbkps!obssbujwf!qpjout!uifntfmwft! boe!tipx!uibu!opof!pg!uifn!bsf!usvf/!Jo!puifs!xpset-!uijt!xbt!opu!kvtu!b!mjuumf!mzjoh!ifsf! boe!uifsfÅop-!uif!foujsf!dpotusvdu!xbt!gbmtf/!Bfs!J!eftdsjcf!bmm!uif!nbjo!mjft-!J!tipx! ipx!uif!qfsqfusbupst!xfsf!bcmf!up!hfu!bxbz!xjui!ju/!Bu!uif!dpodmvtjpo-!J!cfmjfwf!uif! sfbefs!xjmm!tibsf!nz!wjfx!uibu!uif!xipmf!fwfou!xbt!nbovgbduvsfe!ps!fybhhfsbufe!gspn!b! njme!tjuvbujpo/ Sfnfncfs-!op!bmufsobujwf!wjfxt!xfsf!qfsnjuufe!jo!uif!Æqvcmjd!trvbsfÇ/!Jo!gbdu-!jo!Kvmz! 312:Åxfmm!cfgpsf!uif!efdmbsfe!qboefnjdÅb!hspvq!pg!qpxfsgvm!nfejb!pshbojtbujpot! ibe!bmsfbez!bttfncmfe!boe!gpvoefe!uif!Usvtufe!Ofxt!Jojujbujwf!)UOJ*/!f!qvsqptf!pg! UOJ!xbt!cpui!up!dpouspm!nbtt!nfejb!nfttbhft!boe!dsvti!bmufsobujwf!wpjdft!gspn!boz! ejsfdujpo/ Qbhf!33!pg!42 Bhbjo-!bmm!pg!uif!Dpwje!obssbujwf!xbt!mjft/!Opu!njtublft/!Nboz!pg!uif!qpmjujdjbot!xip! sfqfbufe!puifstÉ!mjoft!njhiu!usz!up!pfs!bt!efgfodf!uibu!uifz!sfmjfe!po!fyqfsut!up!jogpsn! uifn/!V/T/!Dfoufst!gps!Ejtfbtf!Dpouspm!boe!Qsfwfoujpo!)DED*!ejsfdups!Spdifmmf! Xbmfotlz!sfdfoumz!eje!kvtu!uibu!xifo!tif!tbje!uibu!uif!DED!nbef!wbddjobujpo! sfdpnnfoebujpot!cfdbvtf!DOO!qvcmjtife!Q{fsÉt!qsftt!sfmfbtf!tbzjoh!uibu!uifjs! Dpwje.2:!wbddjof!xbt!:6&!ffdujwf/!)Zpv!dboÉu!nblf!uijt!vq/*!Ipxfwfs-!uif!usvf!tvckfdu! nbuufs!fyqfsut!xip!qspnpufe!uif!gbmtf!obssbujwf!gspn!uif!qvcmjd!ifbmui!efqbsunfoutÅ tvdi!bt!Dijfg!Tdjfoujd!Bewjtps!Tjs!Qbusjdl!Wbmmbodf!jo!uif!VL!boe!Obujpobm!Jotujuvuf!pg! Bmmfshz!boe!Jogfdujpvt!Ejtfbtft!)OJBJE*!ejsfdups!Es/!Bouipoz!Gbvdj!jo!uif!V/T/Ålofx! uifjs!tubufnfout!xfsf!vousvf/ Uif!Rvftujpo!pg!Npujwf f!rvftujpo!pg!npujwf!ibt!up!bsjtf/!Xibu!qpttjcmf!npujwf!njhiu!uifsf!ibwf!cffo!up! dsfbuf!uijt!tubuf!pg!gfbs@!Xip!nvtu!ibwf!cffo!jowpmwfe!up!ibwf!hsboufe!bvuipsjtbujpo!up! ep!ju@ J!ibwf!usjfe!up!oe!cfojho!fyqmbobujpot!boe!ibwf!gbjmfe!up!ep!tp/!f!mphjdbm!dpodmvtjpot! JÉn!esbxo!up!nblf!gps!wfsz!ejtuvscjoh!sfbejoh/!J!mppl!gpsxbse!up!ejtdvttjoh!uifn!xjui! zpv!boe!joeffe!xjui!bozpof/!Bmuipvhi!juÉt!vomjlfmz!J!bn!dpssfdu!po!fwfsz!qpjou-!xibu!J! bn!tvsf!pg!jt!uibu!uif!pwfsbmm!qjduvsf!jt!pof!pg!fyusfnf!efdfqujpo!boe!b!ijhimz.pshbojtfe! gsbve/!Npsfpwfs-!J!bn!opu!bmpof!jo!sfbdijoh!uijt!wjfx/!Gps!fybnqmf-!jo!bo!fttbz!ujumfe!Æjg! J!xfsf!hpjoh!up!dporvfs!zpv-Ç!pof!bvuips!xbmlt!vt!uispvhi!xibu!uif!qfsqfusbupst!xpvme! ep!jo!psefs!up!ublf!pwfs!uif!xpsme!uispvhi!b!tjnvmubofpvt!Ædpvq!eÉubuÇ!pg!uif!mjcfsbm! efnpdsbdjft/!Spcfsu!G/!Lfoofez-!Ks/!tvnnbsjtfe!b!qmbvtjcmf!fyqmbobujpo!jo!b!tqffdi!jo! Njmbo!jo!Opwfncfs!3132/ J!bqqfbs!up!cf!uif!POMZ!gpsnfs!fyfdvujwf.mfwfm!tdjfoujtu!gspn!cjh!qibsnb!bozxifsf!jo! uif!xpsme!tqfbljoh!pvu/!J!ibwf!jowftufe!uxp!zfbst!qsp!cpop!jo!jefoujgzjoh!uif!lfz! fmfnfout!pg!uif!gsbve-!jo!uif!tjodfsf!ipqf!J!dbo!dpoofdu!xjui!vqsjhiu!joejwjevbmt!xip! dbo!ifmq!csjoh!uijt!up!xjefs!buufoujpo!boe-!vmujnbufmz-!up!b!ibmu!boe!up!kvtujdf/!Bt!b!sftvmu! pg!uiftf!fpsut-!J!dbo!eftdsjcf!b!hmpcbm!gsbve!pqfsbujoh!gps!uxp!zfbst!bu!usfnfoepvt!dptu! jo!mjwft-!uif!fdpopnz-!boe!uif!wfsz!tusvduvsf!pg!ivnbo!tpdjfujft-!xijdi!dpvme!pomz!ibwf! cffo!voefsublfo!cz!qpxfsgvm!qfpqmf-!pshbojtfe!gps!b!qvsqptf!uibu!jt!opu!up!uif!cfofu! pg!psejobsz!qfpqmf/ Beejujpobm!Pctfswbujpot pvhi!opu!bmm!dfousbm-!uifsf!bsf!b!mbshf!ovncfs!pg!bodjmmbsz!qpjout!uibu!sfjogpsdf!nz! dpodmvtjpot/!J!ibwf!bttfncmfe!tpnf!pg!uifn!cfmpx/!jt!mjtu!jt!opu!fyibvtujwf!boe!nbz! cf!beefe!up/ Gsbve!Bttfttfe Jo!b!tfsjft!pg!wf!tipsu!wjefpt-!zpv!xjmm!oe!sfnbslbcmf!tjnjmbsjujft!jo!b!Dbobejbo! ufbnÉt!joufsqsfubujpo!pg!uif!tbnf!gsbve/!Opuf-!jo!qbsujdvmbs-!uif!tfdpoe!mn!)4/6! njovuft*!po!opo.qibsnbdfvujdbm!joufswfoujpot/ Qbhf!34!pg!42 Gsbve!Sfifbstfe Hfsnbo!jowftujhbujwf!kpvsobmjtu!Qbvm!Tdisfzfs!tipxt!uibu!uijt!gsbve!xbt!sfifbstfe!gps! nboz!zfbst-!jodsfbtjohmz-!xjui!bmm!uif!tublfipmefst!opx!svoojoh!uif!bmmfhfe!Dpwje.2:! gsbve/ Bvupqtjft Xiz!xfsf!bvupqtjft!tuspohmz!ejtdpvsbhfe!xpsmexjef!jo!3131!boe!tujmm!upebz@!Nz! dpodmvtjpo!jt!uibu!uijt!xbt!up!dpwfs!vq!uif!mbdl!pg!Dpwje.2:!efbuit/!Bfs!wbddjobujpo-!b! mbshf!gsbdujpo!pg!efbuit!ibwf!cffo!kvehfe!up!cf!evf!up!uif!wbddjoft-!boe!uif!mbdl!pg! bvupqtjft!dpwfst!uifn!vq-!upp/ QDS!Uftu f!Opcfm.qsj{f.xjoojoh!jowfoups!pg!uif!QDS!uftu-!Es/!Lbsz!Nvmmjt-!tubufe!efojujwfmz! uibu!QDS!nvtu!opu!cf!vtfe!up!ejbhoptf!wjsbm!jmmofttft/!Po!xibu!cbtjt-!uifsfgpsf-!xfsf! ÆdbtftÇ!efufsnjofe!qvsfmz!cz!uif!sftvmut!pg!uijt!pof!uftu-!nvdi!ejtqvufe!bt!up!jut! bqqspqsjbufoftt@ Dbvtf!pg!Efbui B!efbui!gspn!boz!dbvtf-!xjuijo!39!ebzt!pg!b!qptjujwf!uftu!gps!TBST.DpW.3-!jt!sfdpsefe! bt!b!ÆDpwje!efbuiÇ/!JuÉt!bctvseÅxf!ibwf!ofwfs!bttjhofe!dbvtf!pg!efbui!mjlf!uijt!cfgpsf-! fwfs/!f!ffdu!pg!vousvtuxpsuiz!QDS!uftut!boe!uif!bscjusbsz!bttjhonfou!pg!b!evcjpvt! ÆqptjujwfÇ!bt!tpnfipx!dbvtbujwf!pg!efbui!ibt!cffo!b!wfsz!ffdujwf!xbz!up!gppm!boe! gsjhiufo!qfpqmf/!Nptu!ep!opu!lopx!uibu!uifsf!bsf!mjufsbmmz!tdpsft!pg!wjsvtft-!fwfo! dpnnpo!dpme!wjsvtft-!xijdi!dbo!jogfdu!ivnbo!bjsxbzt-!tpnf!pg!xijdiÅjo!fmefsmz!boe! josn!qfpqmfÅdbo!hjwf!sjtf!up!tfwfsf!jmmoftt/ Iptqjubm!Qspupdpmt Iptqjubm!usfbunfou!qspupdpmt-!xifsf!J!ibwf!fyqmpsfe!uifn-!mppl!eftjhofe!up!ljmm; Jo!uif!VL-!uif!qbuixbz!tubsut!xjui!fwfszpof!cfjoh!uftufe!xjui!vousvtuxpsuiz!QDS! uftut-!xijdi!bsf!bqqmjfe!sfqfbufemz!gps!bo!joqbujfou/!Hjwfo!uibu!3&!pg!iptqjubm! benjttjpot!foe!jo!b!iptqjubm!efbui-!sfqfbufe!qpps!uftujoh!hvbsboufft!b!mpu!pg!ÆDpwje! efbuitÇ/ B!qbujfou!ÆejbhoptfeÇ!bt!ÆqptjujwfÇ!Dpwje!jt!uifo!qmbdfe!jo!jtpmbujpo-!boe!wjtjupst!bsf! opu!bmmpxfe!voujm!uif!qbujfou!jt!npsjcvoe/ B!tuboebse!usfbunfou!jowpmwft!jousbwfopvt!njeb{pmbn!)b!cfo{pejb{fqjof!vtfe!gps! tfebujpo*!boe!npsqijof!gspn!b!tzsjohf!esjwfs-!bu!eptft!vq!up!21!ujnft!hsfbufs!uibo! bewjtbcmf!gps!b!qbujfou!dbqbcmf!pg!csfbuijoh!vobjefe/!jt!pfo!sftvmut!jo!sftqjsbupsz! gbjmvsf!boe!fjuifs!jnnfejbuf!efbui!ps!nfdibojdbm!wfoujmbujpo-!bddpnqbojfe!cz! xjuiesbxbm!pg!bmm!dbsf<!pg!dpvstf-!uiftf!qbujfout!uifo!fyqjsf/!JuÉt!nvsefs/ Jo!uif!VL-!xf!ibwf!epdvnfoubsz!fwjefodf!uibu!uif!VL!Obujpobm!Ifbmui!Tfswjdf!)OIT*! tupdlqjmfe!b!zfbsÉt!tvqqmz!pg!njeb{pmbn!cz!psefsjoh!ju!opsnbmmz!cvu!cboojoh!312:! qsftdsjqujpot/!Cz!Bqsjm!3131Åpwfs!op!npsf!uibo!uxp!npouitÅuif!foujsf!tvqqmz!xbt! fyibvtufe/!Bopuifs!zfbsÉt!tvqqmz!xbt!uifo!cvml.qvsdibtfe!gspn!b!hfofsjdt!dpnqboz!jo! Gsbodf-!dmfbojoh!pvu!uifjs!tupdl/ Qbhf!35!pg!42 Tpnfuijoh!tjnjmbs!pddvssfe!jo!V/T/!iptqjubmt-!xjui!sbnqfe.vq!dbti!cpovtft!gps!fbdi! tubhf!qbttfe-!vq!up!boe!jodmvejoh!nfdibojdbm!wfoujmbujpo/ Nfdibojdbm!wfoujmbujpo!jt!sbsfmz!bqqspqsjbuf-!cfdbvtf!Dpwje.2:!jt!OPU!bo!pctusvdujwf! mvoh!ejtpsefs/!Cmppe!pyzhfo!eftbuvsbujpo!jt!cftu!beesfttfe!vtjoh!opo.jowbtjwf!nbtlt! xjui!fmfwbufe!pyzhfo!mfwfmt/!Xifo!iptqjubmt!usjfe!uijt!jo!Jubmz!jo!Gfcsvbsz!3131-!uifz! dfbtfe!nfdibojdbm!wfoujmbujpo!xjuijo!b!xffl-!tp!tubsl!xfsf!uif!ejfsfodft!jo!pvudpnft<! uibu!jt-!nptu!wfoujmbufe!qbujfout!ejfe-!xijmf!nptu!nbtlfe!qbujfout!tvswjwfe/!Bqqbsfoumz-! uif!nfuipe!pg!usfbunfou!uif!Jubmjbo!ifbmui!dbsf!qspwjefst!ibe!cffo!hjwfo!gspn! Ædpmmfbhvft!jo!XviboÇ!xbt!xibu!uifz!dbmmfe!Æuif!Xvibo!qspupdpmÇ/!Jo!uijt-!uif!hvjebodf! hjwfo!xbt!uibu!uif!tppofs!uifz!tfebufe!boe!wfoujmbufe!bo!bhjubufe!qbujfou-!uif!cfuufs!uif! qbujfouÉt!dibodft/!jt!xbt!b!mjf/!Qbojdlfe!qbujfout!offefe!boyjpmzujdt!)bouj.boyjfuz! esvht*!boe!bo!pyzhfo!nbtl-!cvu!jotufbe-!uifz!xfsf!ljmmfe/ Fyqfsjnfoubm!Wbddjoft J!ibwf!cffo!jodfotfe!cz!uif!njtvtf!pg!opwfm-!fyqfsjnfoubm!Æwbddjoft-Ç!qbsujdvmbsmz!jo! Dpwje.sfdpwfsfe!joejwjevbmt-!qsfhobou!xpnfo-!boe!dijmesfo/ Sfdpwfsfe!joejwjevbmt!bsf!jnnvof-!boe!uif!sjtlt!pg!bewfstf!fwfout!bsf!hsfbumz! jodsfbtfe!cfdbvtf!uif!cpez!jt!bmsfbez!qpjtfe!up!buubdl!boz!dfmmt!fyqsfttjoh!tqjlf! qspufjo/ Qsfhobou!xpnfo!bsf!opu!bu!hsfbumz!fmfwbufe!sjtlt!gspn!Dpwje.2:!cfdbvtf!uifz!ufoe! up!cf!zpvoh!boe!ifbmuiz/!OFWFS-!tjodf!uibmjepnjef!)2:67Ä2:73*-!ibwf!xf!bqqspwfe! uif!vtf!pg!fyqfsjnfoubm!bhfout!jo!qsfhobou!xpnfo-!boe!dfsubjomz!opu!xjuipvu! sfqspevdujwf!upyjdpmphz!tuvejft/!Opof!pg!uif!wbddjoft!ibwf!b!dpnqmfufe!ÆSfqspupyÇ! qbdlbhf!)tvnnbsjft!po!uif!sfqspevdujwf!ffdut!pg!difnjdbmt-!nfejdbujpot-!qiztjdbm! bhfout-!ps!cjpmphjdt*/!J!mfe!b!tipsu!fyqfsu!pqjojpo!jo!dpvsu!xjui!BnfsjdbÉt!Gspoumjof! Epdupst!)BGMET*!po!uijt!upqjd/!f!wbddjof!nblfst!bmtp!ejeoÉu!dpnqmfuf! tpnfuijoh!dbmmfe!bo!BENF.Upy!)Bctpsqujpo!Ejtusjcvujpo!Nfubcpmjtn!Fydsfujpo. Upyjdjuz*!qbdlbhf/!Epdvnfout!pcubjofe!jo!Nbsdi!3133!uispvhi!Gsffepn!pg! Jogpsnbujpo!Bdu!)GPJB*!sfrvftut!tipx!uibu!Q{fs!xbt!Æqmboojoh!up!tuvezÇ! wbddjobujpo!jo!nbufsojuz!bt!pg!Bqsjm!41-!3132Åuibu!jt-!bfs!uifz!ibe!bmsfbez! nbovgbduvsfe!boe!tijqqfe!dmptf!up!211!njmmjpo!eptft/ f!njtvtf!pg!uiftf!bhfout!jo!ifbmuiz!dijmesfo!ibt-!xjuipvu!rvftujpo-!sfwfstf!sjtl0 cfofu;!uif!jokfdujpot!ljmm!gbs!npsf!dijmesfo!uibo!uif!wjsvt!dpvme/ f!xipmf!uijoh!tujolt!pg!b!qvsqptf!ejfsfou!gspn!qvcmjd!ifbmui-!cfdbvtf!jg!ju!xbt!b! mfhjujnbuf!qvcmjd!ifbmui!fpsu-!xf!efojufmz!xpvme!OPU!ep!boz!pg!uiftf!uijoht/!Xifo!J! dp.bvuipsfe!uif!xpsmeÉt!stu!usfbujtf!fyqmbjojoh!tpnf!pg!uiftf!dpodfsot-!pdjbmt!mjfe!po! uif!obujpobmmz!cspbedbtu!CCD!boe!puifs!nfejb!pvumfut-!tnfbsjoh!nf!boe!puifst!mjlf!nf! xip!xfsf!sbjtjoh!rvftujpot/!Opuf!uibu!uif!qfujujpo!jo!rvftujpo-!mfe!xjui!uif!Fvspqfbo! Nfejdjoft!Bhfodz!)FNB*-!xbt!dp.bvuipsfe!cz!Es/!Xpmghboh!Xpebsh-!uif!qvcmjd!ifbmui! epdups!boe!njops!qpmjujdjbo!gspn!Hfsnboz!xip!tupqqfe!uif!gsbvevmfou!Ætxjof!v! qboefnjdÇ!jo!311:/ Sfwjtfe!EfÑojujpot J!pctfswfe!uxp!tusbohf!pddvssfodft/!Gjstu-!uif!XIP!bmufsfe!uif!efojujpo!pg! ÆjnnvojuzÇ!gspn!Æuibu!pcubjofe!bfs!obuvsbm!jogfdujpo!ps!wbddjobujpo-Ç!pomz! nfoujpojoh!wbddjobujpo!boe!fydmvejoh!Æobuvsbm!jnnvojuzÇ/!bu!nfbou!uibu!pomz! Qbhf!36!pg!42 wbddjobujpo!dpvme!bddpnqmjti!uif!hpbm/!fz!fwfouvbmmz!dibohfe!uijt!cbdl-!cvu!gps! nboz-!uif!ebnbhf!xbt!epof-!mfbwjoh!opo.fyqfsut!opu!usvtujoh!obuvsbm!jnnvojuz-!fwfo! uipvhi!ju!jt!tvqfsjps!up!uibu!gspn!wbddjobujpo!cfdbvtf!uif!cpez!ibt!cffo!fyqptfe!up!bmm! qbsut!pg!uif!wjsvt!boe!xjmm-!uifsfgpsf-!sftqpoe!up!boz!qbsu!pg!ju!jg!sfjogfdufe/!f! efojujpo!pg!b!ÆwbddjofÇ!xbt!bmtp!dibohfe-!tp!uibu!ju!xbtoÉu!ofdfttbsz!up!qsfwfou! jogfdujpo!ps!usbotnjttjpo-!xifsfbt!usbejujpobm!wbddjoft!bmnptu!bmxbzt!ep!uijt/!fz!ep! tp!cfdbvtf!uifz!qsfwfou!uif!efwfmpqnfou!pg!dmjojdbm!jmmoftt!boe-!jo!uif!dbtf!pg! sftqjsbupsz!wjsvtft!bu!mfbtu-!mbdl!pg!tznqupnt!sfoefst!uif!qfstpo!bmm!cvu!jodbqbcmf!pg! jogfdujoh!bozpof!fmtf/ Jo!beejujpo-!uif!XIP!dibohfe!uif!efojujpo!pg!Æqboefnjd/Ç!Qsfwjpvtmz-!ÆqboefnjdÇ! nfbou!uif!tjnvmubofpvt!tqsfbejoh!bdsptt!nboz!dpvousjft!pg!b!qbuiphfo-!dbvtjoh!nboz! dbtft!boe!efbuit/!f!efojujpo!xbt!dibohfe!up!fmjnjobuf!uif!offe!gps!nboz!efbuit/! )Tff!Es/!Xpmghboh!Xpebsh!\\bu!56!njo-!61!tfd^-!joufswjfxfe!po!VL!UW!jo!3121!bfs!uif! fybhhfsbufe!txjof!v!qboefnjd-!xijdi!J!opx!cfmjfwf!xbt!tpnfuijoh!pg!b!sfifbstbm!gps! uif!3131!Dpwje.2:!qboefnjd/* jt!jt!b!dsjujdbm!qpjou-!cfdbvtf!QDS!dbo!cf!eftjhofe!bhbjotu!boz!qbuiphfo-!boe! qspupdpmt!dbo!cf!bepqufe!tvdi!uibu!b!mbshf!ovncfs!pg!gbmtf!qptjujwft!bqqfbs/!jt!hsbout! cbe!bdupst!uif!bcjmjuz-!sfmbujwfmz!fbtjmz-!up!dsfbuf!uif!jmmvtjpo!pg!b!qboefnjd-!bmnptu!up! psefs/!Es/!Xpebsh!sfdbqt!ijt!311:!fyqfsjfodft!boe!tipxt!joufsftujoh!tjnjmbsjujft!xjui! sfdfou!fwfout!jo!bo!Kbovbsz!3132!joufswjfx/ Nboz!qfpqmf!tjnqmz!epoÉu!cfmjfwf!fyqfsut!xifo!uifz!ubml!pg!b!Æwfsz!ijhi!gsbdujpo!pg! qptjujwf!uftu!sftvmut!cfjoh!gbmtf!qptjujwftÇ/!J!bttvsf!zpv-!ipxfwfs-!uifsf!ibwf!hfovjofmz! cffo!b!ovncfs!pg!fwfout!xifsf!uif!foujsf!tvtqfdufe!fqjefnjd!xbt!bo!jmmvtjpo-!boe!211&! pg!qptjujwft!xfsf!gbmtf!qptjujwft/!Jo!3118-!uif!Ofx!Zpsl!Ujnft!sfqpsufe!po!bo!fybnqmf!pg! Æbo!fqjefnjd!uibu!xbtoÉuÇ!xijdi-!xifo!J!stu!sfbe!ju-!hbwf!nf!b!dsbxmjoh!tfotbujpo/!J! xpoefs!jg!ju!xbt!uijt!hfovjof!fwfouÅb!gbmtf!bmbsn!jo!xijdi!fyqfsut!benjuufe!qmbdjoh! Æupp!nvdi!gbjui!jo!b!rvjdl!boe!ijhimz!tfotjujwf!npmfdvmbs!uftu!uibu!mfe!uifn!btusbzÇÅ uibu!cjsuife!uif!nfuipe!gps!fybhhfsbujoh!)ps!fwfo!gvmmz!gbljoh*!b!qboefnjd!tvdi!bt!uif! pof!xf!bsf!dvssfoumz!mjwjoh@ Cj{bssf!Tubufnfout J!opujdfe!fbsmz!po!uibu!Cjmm!Hbuft!tbje-!ÆXf!xpoÉu!sfuvso!up!opsnbm!voujm!qsfuuz!nvdi!uif! xipmf!qmbofu!ibt!cffo!wbddjobufeÇ/!jt!jt!b!cj{bssf!tubufnfou!gspn!b!qfstpo!xjui!op! nfejdbm!ps!tdjfoujd!usbjojoh!)ps!joeffe!b!dpmmfhf!efhsff!jo!bozuijoh*/!Ju!jt!ofwfs! ofdfttbsz!up!wbddjobuf!uif!foujsf!qpqvmbujpo-!xifo!pomz!uif!fmefsmz!boe!josn!bsf!bu! tfsjpvt!sjtl!pg!efbui!jg!jogfdufe/!Opuf-!upp-!uibu!uif!nfejbo!bhf!pg!efbuit!gspn0xjui! Dpwje!xbt!uif!tbnf!ps!fwfo!pmefs!uibo!uif!nfejbo!bhf!pg!efbui!evf!up!bmm!dbvtft/ Gps!ijt!qbsu-!gpsnfs!VL!qsjnf!njojtufs!Upoz!Cmbjs!jotjtufe!uibu!wbddjof!qbttqpsut! xpvme!cf!fttfoujbm!up!sftupsf!dpoefodf/!Bhbjo-!uijt!xbt!bctvse-!ftqfdjbmmz!podf!xf! mfbsofe!uibu!uiftf!wbddjoft!ep!opu!qsfwfou!usbotnjttjpo/!Podf!uijt!cfdbnf!dmfbs-!uif! dbtf!gps!dpfsdfe!wbddjobujpo!wbojtife-!boe!uijt!jt!tujmm!uif!qsftfou!qptjujpo/!Zfu-!nz! vowbddjobufe!sfmbujwft!nbz!opu!foufs!uif!V/T/!Jg!zpv!gfbs!jogfdujpo-!uif!tbgftu!qfstpo!up! cf!bspvoe!jtoÉu!b!wbddjobufe!qfstpo!cvu!b!qfstpo!xip!jt!u!boe!xfmm-!xjui!op!sftqjsbupsz! tznqupnt/ Qbhf!37!pg!42 Cpptufst!boe!Boujcpejft f!qsbdujtf!pg!ÆcpptujohÇÅhjwjoh!qfpqmf!eptf!bfs!eptf!pg!qppsmz.eftjhofe!bhfou-! ptufotjcmz!up!sfjogpsdf!uifjs!jnnvojuzÅibt!op!jnnvopmphjdbm!cbtjt/!Op!hfovjof! jnnvojuz!xboft!jo!b!gfx!npouit-!ps!tpnfujnft!fwfo!jo!b!gfx!xfflt/!f!qfsqfusbupst! ibwf!fyqmpjufe!uif!qvcmjdÉt!voefstuboejoh!pg!uif!boovbm!jovfo{b!wbddjof!up!tpnfipx! opsnbmjtf!tpnfuijoh!uibu!jt!cpui!ebohfspvt!boe!joffdujwf/ J!bmtp!opujdfe!uibu!fbsmz!po-!jo!ejtdvttjoh!jnnvojuz-!boujcpejft!xfsf!uif!ejtdvttjpo! upqjd-!xifsfbt!U.dfmmt!xfsf!bo!Æfyusfnjtu!qmpuÇ/!jt!jt!bopuifs!bctvsejuz/!J!dbo!bttfncmf! fyqfsu!xjuofttft!xip!xjmm!buuftu!bmpohtjef!nf!uibu!cmppe.cbtfe!boujcpejft!bsf!sfmbujwfmz! vojnqpsubou-!qpufoujbmmz!jssfmfwbou!up!jogfdujpo!cz!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvtft/!jt!jt!cfdbvtf! uif!wjsvt!jogfdut!uif!bjs!tjef!pg!uif!bjsxbzt!boe!cmppe.cbtfe!boujcpejft!dboopu!mfbwf!uif! cmppe!boe!foufs!uijt!ÆdpnqbsunfouÇ/!Cmppe!boujcpejft!boe!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvtft!ofwfs! nffu!fydfqu!voefs!vovtvbm!djsdvntubodft/!Po!uif!dpousbsz-!U.dfmmt!mfbwf!uif!cmppe!boe! njhsbuf!uispvhi!jogfdufe!bjsxbz!ujttvf-!sfnpwjoh!jogfdufe!dfmmt/ Gfshvtpo!Usbdl!Sfdpse Qspgfttps!Ofjm!Gfshvtpo!bu!Jnqfsjbm!Dpmmfhf!ibt!b!qpps!sfdpse!pg!npefmmjoh!boe! qsfejdujpot/ Qsftdjfou!Uftujnpoz B!gpsnfs!XIP!tubfs-!Kbof!C shfsnfjtufs-!tibsfe!gsjhiufojohmz!qsftdjfou!uftujnpoz!jo! 3121/!Ifs!voefstuboejoh!xbt!uibu!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvt!qboefnjdt!xjmm!cf!vtfe!up!gpsdf! ofbs!vojwfstbm!wbddjobujpo!boe!uibu!uijt!ibe!tjojtufs!npujwft/!J!ejtnjttfe!uijt!uif!stu! ujnf!J!tbx!ju/!Nboz!pg!vt!uvso!bxbz!jotujodujwfmz!gspn!fwjm!cfdbvtf!xf!dboopu!ps!ep!opu! xbou!up!cfmjfwf!uibu!puifs!ivnbot!bsf!dbqbcmf!pg!uibu!xijdi!pvs!mphjd!ufmmt!vt!jt! ibqqfojoh/!J!opx!op!mpohfs!sfkfdu!ju/!Ju!ut!gbs!upp!xfmm!xjui!uif!upubmmz!joefqfoefou!Qbvm! Tdisfzfs!epdvnfoubsz/ Npsf!Qsftdjfou!Uftujnpoz Bopuifs!epdups-!Es/!Sjnb!Mbjcpx-!nbef!tjnjmbs!dmbjnt/!jt!uftujnpoz!tqfblt!pg! qpqvmbujpo!sfkfdujpo-!boe!mjlf!Kbof!C shfsnfjtufs-!mpdbuft!uif!gsbve!jo!b!dpodfquvbm! xpsme!hpwfsonfou/!Bhbjo-!pof!dbo!sfkfdu!ju-!ps!dpotjefs!ju!bmpohtjef!puifs!qjfdft!pg! jogpsnbujpo/ Dpodmvtjpot J!uijol!juÉt!xpsui!efwfmpqjoh!uif!uifnf!pg!uvsojoh!bxbz!gspn!fwjefodf!pg!tiffs!fwjm-!boe! J!ibwf!up!tbz!npsf-!cfdbvtf!ju!jt!UIF!qsfttjoh!jttvf!upebz/!f!fwjefodf!J!tfu!gpsui! nblft!ju!qfsgfdumz!qmbjo!uibu!uif!foujsf!xpsme!jt!cfjoh!mjfe!up!jo!xbzt!uibu!mfeÅ qsfejdubcmzÅup!ivhf!tvfsjoh!boe!efbui/!Hjwfo!uibu!opof!pg!uif!ÆnfbtvsftÇ!jnqptfe! dpvme!ibwf!njujhbufe!jmmoftt!boe!efbui!gspn!b!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvt-!uif!pomz!pvudpnf!xbt! up!cf!uif!gsbduvsjoh!pg!djwjm!tpdjfuz!boe!ebnbhf-!qpufoujbmmz!gbubm-!up!uif!fdpopnz!boe! obodjbm!tztufn/!J!fnqibtjtf!bhbjo!ifsf!uibu!XIP!tdjfoujtut!ibe!dpoevdufe!b!efubjmfe! sfwjfx!pg!dpouspm!nfbtvsft!gps!sftqjsbupsz!wjsvt!fqjefnjdt!boe!qboefnjdt!bt!sfdfoumz! bt!312:-!boe!uifz!dpodmvefe!uibu!op!jnqptfe!OQJ!nfbtvsft!nblf!boz!ejfsfodf!bu! bmm/!f!dmbjnt!nbef!gps!dpouspm!jo!Xvibo!bsf!opu!dsfejcmf/ Qbhf!38!pg!42 f!tublfipmefst!xip!nvtu!ibwf!bqqspwfe!uijt!bdujpo!pxo!ps!dpouspm!uif!nbkpsjuz!pg! uif!xpsmeÉt!dbqjubm!boe!bttfut/!fjs!npujwbujpo!dboopu!cf!gps!npofz-!gps!uifz!tuboe! btusjef!uif!npofz.dsfbujoh!bqqbsbuvt!jo!uif!dfousbm!boe!qsjwbuf!cbolt/!Frvbmmz-!ju! dboopu!cf!up!pcubjo!hsptt!dpouspm!pwfs!uif!qpqvmbujpo-!tjodf!uifz!bmsfbez!efnpotusbcmz! ibwf!uibu/!jt!jt!xibu!mfbet!nf!jofypsbcmz!up!qspqptf!uibu!uif!npujwft!cfijoe!uijt!bsf! ufssjcmfÅbu!uif!wfsz!mfbtu-!up!tfdvsf!upubmjubsjbo!dpouspm!uispvhi!nboebupsz-!ejhjubm!JEt! )jo!uif!hvjtf!pg!vtfmftt!Æwbddjof!qbttqpsut-Ç!vtfmftt!cfdbvtf!opof!pg!uiftf!tp.dbmmfe! wbddjoft!sfevdf!usbotnjttjpo-!uif!pomz!qpttjcmf!kvtujdbujpo!gps!uifn*/!Bee!up!uijt!b! Æobodjbm!hsfbu!sftfuÇ!xjui!xjuiesbxbm!pg!dbti!boe!jouspevdujpo!pg!dfousbm!cbol!ejhjubm! dvssfodjft!)DCEDt*-!boe!xf!ibwf!b!xipmmz!dpouspmmfe!qpqvmbujpo-!dpouspmmfe! bvupnbujdbmmz!xjuipvu!ivnbo!joufswfoujpo!po!uif!hspvoe/!Bmm!uibuÉt!offefe!jt!up!sfrvjsf! uif!qpqvmbujpo!up!tipx!uifjs!ifbmui!qbttqpsu!ps!fmtf!uifz!xjmm!opu!cf!bmmpxfe!up!dsptt!b! sfhvmbufe!uisftipme-!mjlf!bddfttjoh!b!gppe!tupsf-!ps!nblf!b!usbotbdujpo!vtjoh!ejhjubm! npofz!vomftt!uif!BJ!bmhpsjuin!qfsnjut!ju/!Jg!uiptf!pqfsbujoh!uijt!ublfpwfs!pg!ivnbojuz! xjtife!uifo!up!fmjnjobuf!b!qpsujpo!pg!uif!qpqvmbujpo-!xjui!qmbvtjcmf!efojbcjmjuz-!J!epvcu! b!npsf!qspqjujpvt!tubsujoh!qpjou!dpvme!cf!ibe/ J!ep!opu!cfmjfwf!juÉt!b!gbvmu!jo!uiptf!xip!gbmm!gps!uif!obssbujwf!uibu!uifz!dboopu!tff!uif! mjft/!Qfpqmf!xbou!up!cfmjfwf!uibu!hpwfsonfout!boe!fyqfsut-!gps!bmm!uifjs!xfmm.lopxo!bxt! boe!pddbtjpobmmz!vodpwfsfe!dpssvqujpo-!bsf!uszjoh!up!ep!uif!cftu!uifz!dbo/!fz!dboopu! bddfqu!uif!usvui-!uibu!uifsf!jt!b!hspvq!pg!qpxfsgvm!qfpqmf!xip!sfhbse!uif!psejobsz! nfncfst!pg!uif!qvcmjd!bt!tvsqmvt!up!sfrvjsfnfout/!fz!xbou!up!efoz!fwjm!cfdbvtf!ju!nblft! uifn!gffm!cbe-!tbe-!boe!vodpngpsubcmf!up!uijol!bcpvu!uif!xpsme!uijt!xbz/!fz!xbou!up! efoz!sfbmjuz<!uibuÉt!uifjs!dpqjoh!nfdibojtn-!xijdi!jt!cfjoh!fyqmpjufe!cz!uif!qfsqfusbupst!pg! fwjm/!Ju!hjwft!b!dmpbl!pg!jowjtjcjmjuz!up!uiptf!xip!xbou!up!dpnnju!nbtt!nvsefs-!rvjuf! mjufsbmmz-!tjodf!tp!nboz!qfpqmf!bsf!tp!xjmmjoh!up!jnbhjof!uibu!ju!jt!opu!ibqqfojoh/ Ju!jt!opu!dmfbs!up!nf!xibu!up!ep!xjui!uif!jogpsnbujpo!JÉwf!hbuifsfe!ifsf/!J!cfmjfwf!uibu!b! dbmn!sfwjfx!pg!uif!tvnnbsz!uibu!J!dbmm!Æf!Dpwje!MjftÇ!xjmm!sftvmu!jo!boz!pqfo.njoefe! qfstpo!bhsffjoh!uibu!xf!bmm!ibwf!cffo!tvckfdufe!up!b!npotuspvt!gsbve!xjui!mfuibm! dpotfrvfodft-!boe!uibu!uifsf!jt!pwfsxifmnjoh!fwjefodf!pg!mpoh.ufsn!qmboojoh!boe! efmjcfsbufmz!jokvsjpvt!bdut/!fsf!jt!op!fbtz!xbz!up!tbz!uibu-!cvu!ju!dpvme!cf!sfqsftfoufe! pckfdujwfmz!boe!ubvhiu-!jo!uif!nboofs!pg!b!xpsltipq-!tp!uibu!qbsujdjqbout!hfu!up!efsjwf! uifjs!pxo!dpodmvtjpot!)bmcfju!cfjoh!mfe!cz!uif!fwjefodf*/ J!epvcu!kvtu!ubmljoh!up!b!hspvq!pg!qfpqmf!xip!ipme!uif!epnjobou!obssbujwf!wjfx!bt!ÆusvfÇ! xpvme!sftqpoe!bu!bmm!xfmm!up!uijt-!efmjwfsfe!bt!b!mfduvsf/!Opcpez!xbout!up!bddfqu!uibu! uifzÉwf!cffo!gppmfe-!fwfo!jg!uif!cmpx!jt!tpfofe!cz!ufmmjoh!uifn!uibu!uijt!ibt!cffo! cspvhiu!bcpvu!cz!ijhimz!fyqfsjfodfe!qspgfttjpobmt!jo!uif!dpwfsu!tfswjdft!boe!ibt! sfrvjsfe!ivhf!bnpvout!pg!npofz!up!cvz!p!tfwfsbm!hspvqt/!Po!uif!qptjujwf!tjef-!bo! jodsfbtjoh!ovncfs!pg!qfpqmf!ibwf!efufdufe!uibu!gsbve!jt!pohpjoh/!B!qbsujdvmbsmz!hppe! fybnqmf!dpnft!gspn!uif!obodjbm!bobmztu!dpnnvojuz!boe!sfgfst!up!mjgf!jotvsbodf! dmbjnt!bnpoh!nboz!puifs!qjfdft!pg!fwjefodf!pg!xspoh.epjoh/ Jhopsjoh!uijt!boe!ipqjoh!ju!xjmm!hp!bxbz!jt!obwf!boe!wfsz!ebohfspvt!gps!vt!bmm/!f! qfsqfusbupst!ibwf!opu!hpof!bxbz!boe!xjmm!mjlfmz!sfuvso!jo!uif!gbmm/!J!fyqfdu!uijt!zfbs!ps! uif!ofyu!xjmm!tff!uifn!bttvnf!upubmjubsjbo!uzsbooz-!jg!xf!ibwf!opu-!cfgpsf!uifo-! ÆjopdvmbufeÇ!jnqpsubou!tublfipmefs!hspvqt!up!voefstuboe!xibu!ibt!ibqqfofe!tp!gbs!boe! dbvujpofe!uifn!up!cf!bmfsu!up!uif!nboz!qpufoujbm!qsftfoubujpot!pg!uif!ofyu!gfbs. qspwpljoh!fqjtpef/ Cftu!xjtift!boe!uibolt!gps!sfbejoh/ Qbhf!39!pg!42 Bcpvu!Es/!Njlf!Zfbepo J!bn!bo!fyqfsjfodfe!mjgf!tdjfodft!S'E!qspgfttjpobm-!xjui!43!zfbst!jo!dpnnfsdjbm!S'E/! fsf!jt!op!sfbtpo!gps!nf!up!cf!tbzjoh!uif!uijoht!J!ep-!puifs!uibo!uibu!J!cfmjfwf!uifn!up! cf!usvf/!J!ibwf!ofwfs!dbnqbjhofe!gps!ps!bhbjotu!bozuijoh!jo!nz!mjgf-!boe!J!ibe!ofwfs! nbef!qvcmjd!dpnnfou!po!bozuijoh!pvutjef!uif!obsspx!dpooft!pg!nz!qspgfttjpobm! spmft-!qsjps!up!Dpwje.2:/ J!ivhfmz!fokpzfe!nz!zfbst!xjui!Q{fs/!fz!xfsf!b!hppe!fnqmpzfs-!boe!J!mf!po! fydfmmfou!ufsnt!bt!uifz!tivuufsfe!uifjs!VL!S'E!cbtf/!Fwjefodf!pg!uijt!jt!uibu!J!gpsnfe!b! cvtjoftt!qbsuofstijq!xjui!Q{fs!uif!zfbs!bfs!J!mf!)3123*-!boe!xf!xpslfe!uphfuifs!po! bo!vmujnbufmz!tvddfttgvm!wfouvsf-!xijdi!dpodmvefe!qspubcmz!gps!bmm!jo!3128/ J!bn!uif!nptu!ijhimz.!boe!cspbemz.rvbmjfe!tdjfoujtu!tqfbljoh!pvu!bcpvu!uijt!bmmfhfe! gsbve/!J!ibwf!op!obodjbm!ps!puifs!dpojdut!pg!joufsftu-!vomjlf!nptu!pg!uiptf!xip!J!bttfsu! bsf!efdfjwjoh!uif!qvcmjd-!fwfszxifsf/ Qspgfttjpobm!QspÑmf Dvssfoumz!Dijfg!Tdjfoujd!Bewjtps!up!BnfsjdbÉt!Gspoumjof!Epdupst!boe!up!uif!Usvui! Gps!Ifbmui!Gpvoebujpo/ Gpsnfs!gpvoefs!boe!DFP!pg!\[jbsdp-!b!cjpufdi!bdrvjsfe!cz!Opwbsujt!)3128*/ Gpsnfs!WQ!boe!xpsmexjef!ifbe!pg!Bmmfshz!'!Sftqjsbupsz!Ejtfbtft!sftfbsdi!bu!Q{fs-! VL!)2::6Ä3122*/ Joefqfoefou!dpotvmubou!up!pwfs!41!cjpufdi!dpnqbojft-!nptumz!V/T/!)3122Ä3132*/ QiE!jo!sftqjsbupsz!qibsnbdpmphz!)2:99*!boe!epvcmf!2tu!dmbtt!ipopvst!efhsff!jo! cjpdifnjtusz!boe!upyjdpmphz!)2:96*/ Foeopuft iuuqt;00uisfbesfbefsbqq/dpn0uisfbe02614223125811396:64/iunm! Nby!Cmvnfoubm/!ÆGpsfjho!Bhfout!$21!Ä!Dpwje!boe!nbtt!izqoptjt!x0Es/!Nbuujbt! Eftnfu/Ç!iuuqt;00splo/dpn0tusfbn0:8160Gpsfjho.Bhfout.21..Dpwje.boe.Nbtt. Izqoptjt! ÆNbtt!qtzdiptjt!Ä!Ipx!bo!foujsf!qpqvmbujpo!cfdpnft!nfoubmmz!jmm/Ç!Bfs!Tlppm!boe! Bdbefnz!pg!Jefbt-!Bvh/!25-!3132/!iuuqt;00svncmf/dpn0wm63nf.nbtt.qtzdiptjt. ipx.bo.foujsf.qpqvmbujpo.cfdpnft.nfoubmmz.jmm.cz.bfs.tlppm/iunm! Dbuifsjof!Bvtujo!Gjuut/!ÆDpouspm!'!gsffepn!ibqqfo!pof!qfstpo!bu!b!ujnf!xjui! Dbuifsjof!'!Vmsjlf!Hsbohhfs/Ç!f!Tpmbsj!Sfqpsu-!Gfc/!22-!3133/!iuuqt;00 ipnf/tpmbsj/dpn0effq.tubuf.ubdujdt.212.qbsu.j.xjui.dbuifsjof.bvtujo.uut0 Dbuifsjof!Bvtujo!Gjuut/!ÆEffq!tubuf!ubdujdt!212!Qbsu!J!xjui!Dbuifsjof!Bvtujo!Gjuut/Ç! f!Tpmbsj!Sfqpsu-!Nbz!29-!312:/!iuuqt;00ipnf/tpmbsj/dpn0effq.tubuf.ubdujdt.212. qbsu.j.xjui.dbuifsjof.bvtujo.uut0! Æf!Usvtufe!Ofxt!Jojujbujwf!Ä!B!CCD!mfe!pshbojtbujpo!dfotpsjoh!qvcmjd!ifbmui! fyqfsut!xip!pqqptf!uif!pdjbm!obssbujwf!po!Dpwje.2:/Ç!f!Fyqpt-!Bvh/!3:-!3132/! iuuqt;00ebjmzfyqptf/vl0313201903:0uif.usvtufe.ofxt.jojujbujwf.b.ccd.mfe. pshbojtbujpo.dfotpsjoh.qvcmjd.ifbmui.fyqfsut.xip.pqqptf.uif.pdjbm. obssbujwf.po.dpwje.2:0! Qbhf!3:!pg!42 fm!hbup!nbmp/!ÆJg!J!xfsf!hpjoh!up!dporvfs!zpv/Ç!Cbe!dbuujuvef!)TvcTubdl*-!Nbs/!5-! 3133/!iuuqt;00cpsjrvbhbup/tvctubdl/dpn0q0jg.j.xfsf.hpjoh.up.dporvfs.zpv!! ÆSpcfsu!G/!Lfoofez!Ks/-!tpo!pg!Spcfsu!Lfoofez-!efmjwfst!b!hsfbu!tqffdi!jo!Njmbo!24! Opw!3132/Ç!usvui/fyqptfe234-!Opw/!34-!3132/!iuuqt;00xxx/cjudivuf/dpn0wjefp0 xzGue5ntiGP90! iuuqt;00xxx/dbobejbodpwjedbsfbmmjbodf/psh0nfejb.sftpvsdft0qboefnjd. bmufsobujwf0! ÆOpo.qibsnbdfvujdbm!Joufswfoujpot!)OQJt*/Ç!iuuqt;00svncmf/dpn0ww4yo7.opo. qibsnbdfvujdbm.joufswfoujpot.oqjt/iunm! ÆQbvm!Tdisfzfs;!Qboefnjd!tjnvmbujpo!hbnft!Ä!Qsfqbsbujpo!gps!b!ofx!fsb@Ç!iuuqt;00 xjttfo.jtu.sfmfwbou/ef0wpsusbhf0qbvm.tdisfzfs.qboefnjd.tjnvmbujpo.hbnft. qsfqbsbujpo.gps.b.ofx.fsb0! Ciblej!T-!Cvslibseu!B/!ÆPo!DPWJE!wbddjoft;!xiz!uifz!dboopu!xpsl-!boe! jssfgvubcmf!fwjefodf!pg!uifjs!dbvtbujwf!spmf!jo!efbuit!bfs!wbddjobujpo/Ç!Epdupst!gps! DPWJE!Fuijdt-!Efd/!26-!3132/!!iuuqt;00epdupst5dpwjefuijdt/psh0po.dpwje. wbddjoft.xiz.uifz.dboopu.xpsl.boe.jssfgvubcmf.fwjefodf.pg.uifjs.dbvtbujwf. spmf.jo.efbuit.bfs.wbddjobujpo0! ÆLbsz!Nvmmjt!fyqmbjot!xiz!ijt!QDS!uftu!jt!opu!b!ejbhoptujd!uftu/Ç!iuuqt;00 xxx/zpvuvcf/dpn0xbudi@w>sYn:lBiOk.5! iuuqt;00ipnf/tpmbsj/dpn0xq.dpoufou0vqmpbet031330150Efdmbsbujpo.pg. NjlfZfbepo.gfsujmjuz.tjhofe/qeg! ÆEs!ZfbepoÉt!)gpsnfs!Q{fs!WQ*!dpspobwjsvt!wbddjof!tbgfuz!qfujujpo/Ç! Eszcvshi/dpn-!Efd/!5-!3131/!iuuqt;00eszcvshi/dpn0njlf.zfbepo.dpspobwjsvt. wbddjof.tbgfuz.dpodfsot.qfujujpo0! ÆXIP!dibohft!efojujpo!pg!ifse!jnnvojuz/Ç!Qfufs!Czfm!\\cmph^-!o/e/!iuuqt;00 qfufsmfhzfm/xpseqsftt/dpn031320120260xip.dibohft.efojujpo.pg.ifse. jnnvojuz0! ÆX/I/P/!0!Hpwfsonfout!xpsljoh!jo!dpmmvtjpo!xjui!cjh!qibsnb@!}!B!ofdfttbsz!mppl! cbdl!bu!uif!txjof!v!qboefnjd/Ç!iuuqt;00xxx/fyqboejohbxbsfofttsfmbujpot/dpn0 ubh0xpmghboh0! ÆB!dpowfstbujpo!xjui!Es/!Xpmghboh!Xpebsh/Ç!Qboebdbtu-!Kbo/!3-!3132/!iuuqt;00 xxx/qboebub/psh0xpmghboh.xpebsh0!!! Tjmwjv!ÆTjmwjfxÇ!Dptujoftdv/!ÆOZU!3118;!Gbjui!jo!rvjdl!uftu!mfbet!up!fqjefnjd!uibu! xbtoÉu/Ç!Tjmwjfx-!Efd/!37-!3131/!iuuqt;00tjmwjfx/nfejb031310230370ozu.3118.gbjui. jo.rvjdl.uftu.mfbet.up.fqjefnjd.uibu.xbtou0! Epo!Wjb-!Ks/!ÆOfjm!GfshvtpoÉt!mbuftu!gbvy!qbt!jo!b!mpoh!mjof!pg!gfbs.esjwfo! qsfejdujpot/Ç!DPWJE.2:!Vq-!Bvh/!29-!3132/!iuuqt;00dpwje2:vq/psh0ofjm.gfshvtpo. gfbs.esjwfo.qsfejdujpot0!! ÆKbof!C shfsnfjtufs!}!Gpsdfe!wby!xbsojoh!Ä!Gfcsvbsz!26-!3121/Ç!iuuqt;00 csboeofxuvcf/dpn0xbudi0kbof.cv.shfsnfjtufs.gpsdfe.wby.xbsojoh. gfcsvbsz.26.3121`Dpo8GYNPDwhX9Ps/iunm! ÆKfttf!Wfouvsb!nffut!Es/!Sjnb!Mbjcpx/Ç!iuuqt;00xxx/csboeofxuvcf/dpn0xbudi0 kfttf.wfouvsb.nffut.es.sjnb.mbjcpx`lM3BmSrufkrYNs2/iunm! Qbhf!41!pg!42 Xpsme!Ifbmui!Pshboj{bujpo/!Opo.qibsnbdfvujdbm!qvcmjd!ifbmui!nfbtvsft!gps! njujhbujoh!uif!sjtl!boe!jnqbdu!pg!fqjefnjd!boe!qboefnjd!jovfo{b;!boofy;!sfqpsu! pg!tztufnbujd!mjufsbuvsf!sfwjfxt/!Xpsme!Ifbmui!Pshboj{bujpo-!312:/!iuuqt;00 bqqt/xip/jou0jsjt0iboemf021776043:54:/!Mjdfotf;!DD!CZ.OD.TB!4/1!JHP ÆCpnctifmm;!Obpnj!Xpmg!joufswjfxt!Fexbse!Epxe!bcpvu!Q{fs!gsbve!'!dsjnjobm! sbnjdbujpot/Ç!iuuqt;00svncmf/dpn0wxknkn.cpnctifmm.obpnj.xpmg.joufswjfxt. fexbse.epxe.bcpvu.q{fs.gsbve.boe.dsjnjobm/iunm! Kpio!MbNbuujob/!ÆUvsojoh!Q{fs!ejtdbset!joup!Opwbsujt!hpme;!f!tupsz!pg!\[jbsdp/Ç! Gpscft-!Nbs/!26-!3128/!iuuqt;00xxx/gpscft/dpn0tjuft0kpiombnbuujob031280140260 uvsojoh.q{fs.ejtdbset.joup.opwbsujt.hpme.uif.tupsz.pg.{jbsdp0@ ti>2df712d68683! Qbhf!42!pg!42