Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2.22.22 Board Correspondence - FW_ Titanium Dioxide (2) From:Paulsen, Shaina To:Ring, Brian; Alpert, Bruce Cc:Reaster, Kayla; Valencia, Shyanne Subject:Board Correspondence - FW: Titanium Dioxide Date:Tuesday, February 22, 2022 8:03:15 AM Attachments:s41598-022-06605-w.pdf Please see BOS Correspondence. Shaina Paulsen Associate Clerk of The Board Butte County Administration 25 County Center Drive, Suite 200, Oroville, CA 95965 T: 530.552.3304 | F: 530.538.7120 From: lance dreiss <lancedreiss@att.net> Sent: Monday, February 21, 2022 9:18 AM To: Connelly, Bill <BConnelly@buttecounty.net>; Kimmelshue, Tod <TKimmelshue@buttecounty.net>; Lucero, Debra <DLucero@buttecounty.net>; Clerk of the Board <clerkoftheboard@buttecounty.net>; District Attorney <District_Attorney@buttecounty.net>; Ritter, Tami <TRitter@buttecounty.net>; Teeter, Doug <DTeeter@buttecounty.net>; Waugh, Melanie <mwaugh@buttecounty.net>; APicket@buttecounty.net Subject: Titanium Dioxide .ATTENTION: This message originated from outside Butte County. Please exercise judgment before opening attachments, clicking on links, or replying.. Board of Supervisors, Clerk of the Board, Public Record, A Pickett, DA Ramsey, Sheriff Honea: Titanium dioxide (human carcinogen?) particles frequently present in face masks intended for general use. You are requiring mask wearing of the public, businesses, and employees, etc.? Diana Dreiss https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-06605- w.pdf__;!!KNMwiTCp4spf!VY5z57pdYyDHbjdHLW8gONUn0OWCoJOjhAdm5buYaziMinZhqfOH92ukE4VcUIepJ44PKCYBhGU$ Sent from my iPhone www.nature.com/scientificreports + Xfbsjoh!gbdf!nbtlt!jt!bo!jnqpsubou!boe!xjefmz!bqqmjfe!qvcmjd!ifbmui!nfbtvsf!up!dpouspm!uif!DPWJE.2:! 2 !qboefnjd/!B!sfdfou!tuvez-!uftujoh!tfwfsbm!cbudift!pg!gbdf!nbtlt!joufoefe!up!cf!qvu!po!tbmf!bt!qfstpobm!qspufd. ujwf!frvjqnfou-!tipxfe!uibu!81&!pg!uif!fybnjofe!gbdf!nbtlt!dpoubjofe!UjP!!jo!rvboujujft!sbohjoh!gspn!211! 3 3 !lh!!jt!dpnnpomz!bqqmjfe!jo!ufyujmft!pg!gbdf!nbtlt-!bt!jo!b!xjef!wbsjfuz!pg! 3 4-5 puifs!ufyujmft-!f/h/!up!jnqspwf!tubcjmjuz!up!vmusbwjpmfu!mjhiu-!bt!xijuf!dpmpsbou!ps!bt!b!nbuujoh!!bhfou/!Jo!beejujpo-! up!jouspevdf!ofx!tpmvujpot!up!uif!dibmmfohft!bttpdjbufe!xjui!uif!DPWJE.2:!qboefnjd-!ufyujmf!dpnqbojft!bsf! 6-7 !nbtlt 8 dpoubjojoh!!!obopqbsujdmft!ibwf!cffo!qspevdfe!up!dsfbuf!boujnjdspcjbm!!-!bmtp!jo!dpncjobujpo!xjui! 3 9: !tjmwfs!boe!!hsbqifof/!Dpbujoht!pg!!!obopqbsujdmft!po!dpuupo!gbcsjd!xfsf!bqqmjfe!gps!foibodfe!tfmg.dmfbojoh! 3 21 boe!boujcbdufsjbm!!qspqfsujft/ 6 !xbso!gps!uif!qpttjcmf!gvuvsf!dpotfrvfodft!dbvtfe!cz!b!qppsmz! sfhvmbufe!vtf!pg!obopufdiopmphz!jo!ufyujmft!bqqmjfe!up!jnqspwf!uif!qfsgpsnbodf!pg!gbdf!nbtlt/!Jo!bojnbm!fyqfsj. 22-23 !!qbsujdmft!xfsf!!joibmfe-!bt!xfmm!bt!xifo!uifz!xfsf!johftufe! 3 24-25 !psbmmz/!Jo!3128-!uif!Sjtl!Bttfttnfou!Dpnnjuuff!)SBD*!pg!uif!Fvspqfbo!Difnjdbm!Bhfodz!)FDIB*!sfwjfxfe! uif!dbsdjophfojd!qpufoujbm!pg!!!boe!qspqptfe!up!dmbttjgz!Ujubojvn!ejpyjef!bt!Dbsd/!3-!I462!)tvtqfdufe!ivnbo! 3 2627 dbsdjophfo*!!xbt!bepqufe!gps!ujubojvn!ejpyjef/ Up!fwbmvbuf!xifuifs!uif!!!qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt!qpttjcmz!qsftfou!b!ifbmui!sjtl-!uifjs!bnpvout-!uifjs! 3 qiztjdpdifnjdbm!qspqfsujft!boe!uifjs!mpdbmj{bujpo!xfsf!bobmz{fe!jo!b!tfmfdujpo!pg!gbdf!nbtlt/!Tvqqpsujoh!po! uiftf!nfbtvsfnfout-!uif!bnpvou!pg!! 3 uif!bddfqubcmf!fyqptvsf!mfwfm!up!!!cz!joibmbujpo-!fyqsfttfe!qfs!nbtl!!)BFM*/ 3nbtl Trace Elements + email: jan.mast@sciensano.be | (2022) 12:2529 | www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Uxfmwf!gbdf!nbtlt!nfbou!up!cf!xpso!cz!uif!hfofsbm!qpqvmbujpo!boe!jodmvejoh!cpui!tjohmf.vtf!)ejtqptbcmf*!boe! . 2*/!Bmm!nbtlt!bsf! 28-29 15!boe!16!bsf!uisff!qmz!uzqf!!nbtlt/!Jnbhft!pg!uif!fybnjofe!nbtlt!bsf!hjwfo!bt!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!2/ Nfbtvsfnfou!pg!uif!upubm!bnpvou!pg!ujubojvn!)Uj*!jo!fbdi!gbdf!nbtl-!bt!b!qspyz!gps!uif!bnpvou!pg!!! 3 qbsujdmft-!cz!joevdujwfmz!dpvqmfe!qmbtnb.pqujdbm!fnjttjpo!tqfdusptdpqz!)JDQ.PFT*!tipxfe!uibu!uif!bnpvou!pg! !2*/ 3 tfdujpot!pg!uif!sftjo!fncfeefe!gbdf!nbtlt!tipxfe!tjohmf!boe!bhhmpnfsbufe!dpotujuvfou!qbsujdmft!jo!tzouifujd! 22!boe! . ujdmft!dpotjtu!pg!!UjP3!boe!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!4*/!B!gsbdujpo!pg!uif!!!qbsujdmft!xbt!mpdbufe!bu! 33 3c*/!!2e*-!jo!nfmucmpxo!opo. 3 22*/ ! 3 Nfbtvsfnfout!pg!uif!tj{f!boe!tibqf!)ofbs.tqifsjdbm!npsqipmphz*!pg!uif!dpotujuvfou!!!qbsujdmft!boe! 3 2-!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!5—7*!tipx!uibu-!pwfsbmm-!uif!qizt. jdpdifnjdbm!qspqfsujft!pg!uif!! 3 2:-3125 !!bqqmjfe!jo!puifs!!ufyujmft!boe!bsf!tjnjmbs!up!uiptf!pg!uif!F!282!gppe!beejujwf!/!Bmuipvhi!uif! 3 nfbtvsfe!!!tj{f!ejtusjcvujpot!jo!uif!gbdf!nbtlt!ep!opu!bmm!rvbmjgz!uif!bqqmjfe!!!bt!obopnbufsjbmt!bddpse. 33 32 -!fbdi!fybnjofe!nbtl-!cftjeft!Nbtl15-!dpoubjofe!b!opubcmf!gsbdujpo!pg!obopqbsujdmft! )7&!up!76&*-!sfrvftujoh!bo!bqqspqsjbuf!sjtl!bobmztjt/ 22-33-34 Cfdbvtf!uif!ib{bse!pg!joibmfe!!!qbsujdmft!jt!xfmm!epdvnfoufe!-!qbsujdvmbsmz!fyqptvsf!bobmztjt!jt! 3 jnqpsubou!gps!sjtl!bobmztjt/!Fyqptvsf!up!!!)obop*qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt-!efqfoet!po!uifjs!mfwfm!pg!sfmfbtf/! 3 Njhsbujpo!pg!bhhmpnfsbufe!! 3 35 uif!gbdf!!nbtlt up!bfspezobnjd!gpsdft/!Ejsfdu!nfbtvsfnfou!pg!sfmfbtfe!qbsujdmft!jt!qspcmfnbujd!cfdbvtf-!up!pvs!lopxmfehf-!op! tuboebsej{fe!nfuipet!bsf!bwbjmbcmf!up!efufsnjof!xifuifs!qbsujdmft!bsf!sfmfbtfe!gspn!gbdf!nbtlt!evsjoh!opsnbm! vtf-!boe!xijdi!bnpvou!pg!!!jt!sfmfbtfe/!Ju!jt!volopxo!jg!qbsujdmft!dpvme!cf!sfmfbtfe!bt!tjohmf!qbsujdmft-!bt! 3 Npsfpwfs-!gfx!mjufsbuvsf!ebub!bsf!bwbjmbcmf!uibu!qspwjef!jogpsnbujpo!po!eftpsqujpo0fsptjpo0bcsbtjpo!pg!!! 3 36 qbsujdmft!gspn!!.dpoubjojoh!! 3 !!!qbsujdmft!uibu!dbo!cf!joibmfe!xjuipvu! 33 !)BFM nbtl tvsgbdf/!Ju!nfsfmz!dbmdvmbuft!xijdi!gsbdujpo!pg!! 3 bddfqubcmf!fyqptvsf!mfwfm/!Cfdbvtf!uif!gbuf!boe!sfmfbtf!nfdibojtnt!pg!qbsujdmft!gspn!gbdf!nbtlt!bsf!dvssfoumz! volopxo-!op!bttvnqujpot!xfsf!nbef!bcpvu!uif!mjlfmjippe!pg!uif!sfmfbtf!pg!qbsujdmft!jutfmg/ BFM nbtl xjui!bo!joufotjwf!vtf!tdfobsjp!pg!gbdf!nbtlt!cz!uif!hfofsbm!bevmu!qpqvmbujpo!bt!eftdsjcfe!jo!Tvqqmfnfoubsz! 423 xbt!gvsuifs!dibsbdufsj{fe!tvqqpsujoh!po!uif!bqqspbdi!up!efufsnjof!uif!qspgfttjpobm!bddfqubcmf!fyqptvsf!mfwfmt! 37 up!!!!obopgpsnt. 3 38 pnnfoefe!dibohf!pg!uif!nbtlt!fwfsz!5!!i/ Gvsuifsnpsf-!ju!xbt!bttvnfe!uibu!! 3 ! 3 ! 3 !!bu!uif! 3 2 39 2d*!sftvmut!jo!b!mbshfs!tvsgbdf!!bsfb-!b!dpssfdujpo!gbdups!xbt!jouspevdfe!sftvmujoh!jo!ijhifs!qfsdfoubhft!pg! qbsujdmft!bu!uif!tvsgbdf!)jo!uif!nfuipet!tfdujpo!boe!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!:*/ 2!tipxt!uibu!gps!bmm!fybnjofe!gbdf!nbtlt-!uif!bnpvou!pg!! 3 opubcmz!fydffet!uif!!. nbtl tfswbujwf!bttvnqujpot!xijmf!vodfsubjoujft!sfhbsejoh!ib{bse!boe!fyqptvsf!sfnbjo!)Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo! 8*-!b!ifbmui!sjtl!dboopu!cf!svmfe!pvu!xifo!gbdf!nbtlt!dpoubjojoh!qpmzftufs-!qpmzbnjef-!uifsnpcpoefe!opo.xpwfo! !!gps!sfvtbcmf!gbdf!nbtlt!jt!ijhifs!)98! nbtl up!2331!ujnft*!uibo!gps!tjohmf!vtf!nbtlt!)6!up!22!ujnft*-!jnqmzjoh!uibu!gps!uif!sfvtbcmf!nbtlt!vqublf!pg!pomz!b! ibwf!ijhifs!!!bnpvout!jo!uif!nbusjy-!ibwf!b!ijhifs!nbtt!)npsf!ufyujmf!dpssftqpoet!xjui!npsf!!UjP*-!boe! 33 vodfsubjouz!)l!>!2*!po!uif!upubm!nbtt!pg!!2-!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!9*!xbt!mbshfs!uibo!!/! 3nbtl | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol:.(1234567890) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Ujnft!uif! Npefmmfe!Ftujnbufe!bnpvou!pg! gsbdujpo!pg!bnpvou!pg!!!! 33 c Gjcfs!!ejbnfufs!!Upubm!!!qfs!tvsgbdf!fydffet! 33 bbdeg SfgUzqfMbzfstDpnqptjujpo)¶n*BB!!tj{f!)on*DQ!!tj{f!)on*tvsgbdf!)&*!nbtl!)¶h*qfs!nbtl!)¶h*! nbtl Fyufsobm35!²!8/52:8!²!6:242!²!723 f opo.xpwfo Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl12Tjohmf.vtfDfousbm————3497!²!3974:22 xpwfo Joufsobm———— opo.xpwfo f FyufsobmQpmzftufs:!²!1/8234!²!87236!²!834 Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl13SfvtbcmfDfousbm————28-443!²!3191573239 xpwfo Joufsobm211&!dpuupo———— f Fyufsobm211&!!qpmzftufs:!²!1/:299!²!232235!²!595 76&!qpmzftufs-! Dfousbm22!²!1/8267!²!215218!²!6:4 f Nbtl14Sfvtbcmf46&!!dpuupo41-868!²!47:221673:4 76&!qpmzftufs-! Joufsobm22!²!3/1284!²!212244!²!564 f 46&!!dpuupo Fyufsobm32!²!2/9331!²!77293!²!913 f opo.xpwfo Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl15Tjohmf.vtfDfousbm————2481!²!275419 xpwfo Joufsobm34!²!8/3385!²!87254!²!:83 f opo.xpwfo Fyufsobm2:!²!3/6344!²!218295!²!853 f opo.xpwfo Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl16Tjohmf.vtfDfousbm————8:2!²!:6286 xpwfo Joufsobm 29!²!3/9282!²!93279!²!693 f opo.xpwfo f FyufsobmQpmzftufs8!²!1/5258!²!68212!²!575 f Nbtl17SfvtbcmfDfousbmVolopxo46!²!9/551:!²!293228!²!43323-2:6!²!257455998 JoufsobmDpuupo———— f FyufsobmQpmzbnjef:!²!2/3241!²!:9:7!²!494 Nbtl18Sfvtbcmf263-456!²!29-39254:52331 f JoufsobmQpmzbnjef:!²!1/8246!²!229214!²!554 Qpmzftufs-!qpmz. Nbtl19Sfvtbcmf22!²!2/1295!²!98::!²!614:684!²!225:438247 f bnjef-!!fmbtubof Fyufsobm35!²!7/6561!²!241258!²!845 f opo.xpwfo Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl1:SfvtbcmfDfousbm————33:9!²!3879527 xpwfo Joufsobm34!²!7/5483!²!288268!²!674 f opo.xpwfo f FyufsobmQpmzftufs22!²!1/9221!²!95:1!²!513 Nbtl21Sfvtbcmf28-538!²!31:2469:: JoufsobmDpuupo———— f FyufsobmQpmzftufs 21!²!1/7246!²!7:9:!²!434 Nbtl22SfvtbcmfDfousbm————23-824!²!2637463:9 opo.xpwfo JoufsobmDpuupo———— Cj.dpnqpofou! Fyufsobm24!²!1/9284!²!:6216!²!569 f ! Nbtl23Sfvtbcmf23-:3:!²!266321653:4 Cj.dpnqpofou! Joufsobm23!²!2/82:2!²!215:7!²!54: f ! b Ubcmf!2/!!Qspqfsujft!pg!uif!fybnjofe!gbdf!nbtlt/!!Bt!joejdbufe!po!uif!qbdlbhjoh!ps!cbtfe!po!fyqfsu! cd bewjdf/!!Nfejbo!²!!Njojnvn!fyufsobm!ejnfotjpo!pg!uif! !!bhhmpnfsbuft!)BB*!ftujnbufe!bt!uif!nfejbo!²!joufsrvbsujmf!sbohf!)JRS*!pg!uif!njojnvn!Gfsfu! 3 e ejbnfufs!ejtusjcvujpo/!!Njojnvn!fyufsobm!ejnfotjpo!pg!uif!!!dpotujuvfou!qbsujdmft!)DQ*!ftujnbufe!bt! 3 f uif!nfejbo!²!JRS!pg!uif!njojnvn!Gfsfu!ejbnfufs!ejtusjcvujpo/!!UjP!qbsujdmft!xfsf!pctfswfe!jo!uijt!mbzfs! 3 g cz!TUFN.FEY/!!!>!2*!po!uif!upubm!nbtt!pg!!!qfs!nbtl!xbt! 3 up!uif!xfjhiu!pg!uif!nbtl!jt!opu!jodmvefe!jo!uijt!vodfsubjouz/ | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol.:(0123456789) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ !!b*! qpmzftufs-!)c*!qpmzbnjef-!)de*!dpuupo-!)fg*! nfmucmpxo!opo.xpwfo!gbcsjd/!!!qbsujdmft!bsf!wjtjcmf!bt!csjhiu!xijuf!eput/ 3 Dpotfrvfoumz-!!!sfmfbtf!jo!uif!psefs!pg!!-!nfbtvsfe!bt!uif!dibohf!jo!! 3nbtl3 uif!nbtl-!dboopu!cf!efnpotusbufe!tjodf!ju!gbmmt!xjuijo!uif!vodfsubjouz!sbohf!pg!uif!upubm!nbtt!nfbtvsfnfou/ 2 Gbdf!nbtl!ibwf!bo!jnqpsubou!spmf!jo!uif!nfbtvsft!bhbjotu!uif!DPWJE.2:!qboefnjd!/!Tp!gbs-!op!ebub!bsf!bwbjm. bcmf!uibu!joejdbuf!uibu!uif!qpttjcmf!sjtl!bttpdjbufe!xjui!uif!qsftfodf!pg!!!qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt!pvuxfjhit! 3 6 !gps!uif!qpttjcmf!gvuvsf!dpotfrvfodft!dbvtfe!cz!b!qppsmz! sfhvmbufe!vtf!pg!obopufdiopmphz!jo!ufyujmft!tipvme!cf!fyufoefe!up!gbdf!nbtlt!xifsf!!!qbsujdmft!bsf!bqqmjfe! 3 dpowfoujpobmmz-!bt!b!xijuf!dpmpsbou!ps!bt!b!nbuujoh!bhfou-!ps!up!bttvsf!evsbcjmjuz!sfevdjoh!qpmznfs!csfblepxo! 4-5 cz!vmusbwjpmfu!!mjhiu 3: tvjubcmf!gps!gbdf!nbtl!dbo!cf!qspevdfe!xjuipvu!UjP!2*/! 3 | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol:.(1234567890) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ !!TUFN.FEY!bobmztjt!pg!qbsujdmft!)bcd*!jo! e )hsffo*!pcubjofe!cz!FEY!tipx!uibu!uif!nfbtvsfe!Uj!tjhobm!dpjodjeft!xjui!uif!qptjujpo!pg!uif!qbsujdmft!tipxo!jo! uif!TUFN!jnbhf-!boe!)gpvsui!dpmvno*!uif!FEY!tqfdusb!pg!uif!bsfb“t!joejdbufe!po!uif!TUFN!jnbhf!tipx!uif!Uj! tjhobm/ 25 Npsfpwfs-!vodfsubjoujft!sfhbsejoh!uif!hfopupyjdjuz!pg!!!qbsujdmft!!sfnbjo 3 uif!jnqmfnfoubujpo!pg!sfhvmbupsz!tuboebset!qibtjoh!pvu!ps!mjnjujoh!uif!bnpvou!pg!!!qbsujdmft-!bddpsejoh!up! 3 uif!’tbgf.cz.eftjho“!qsjodjqmf/ pg!! 3 sjtl!bttfttnfou!pg!! 3 uif!qsftfodf!pg!)obop*qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt-!uifjs!dibsbdufsjtujdt-!uif!fyqptvsf!boe!uif!sjtlt!gps!uif!qpqvmbujpo! jt!mjnjufe/!)jj*!Nfuipepmphjft!gps!dibsbdufsj{joh!!!qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt!bsf!ujnf!dpotvnjoh!boe!fyqfotjwf/! 3 )jjj*!Fwfo!uipvhi!uijt!tuvez!gpdvtfe!po!gbdf!nbtlt!joufoefe!gps!uif!hfofsbm!qvcmjd-!uijt!epft!opu!fydmvef!!! 3 ifbmui!sjtlt!bttpdjbufe!xjui!uif!qsftfodf!pg!!!qbsujdmft!jo!nfejdbm!boe!qfstpobm!qspufdujpo!frvjqnfou!gbdf! 3 | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol.:(0123456789) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ dpoubjojoh!bhhmpnfsbuft!ps!b!dpncjobujpo!uifsfpg/!Bhhmpnfsbuft!bsf!tfotjujwf!up!dibohft!jo!uif!fowjsponfou! tvdi!bt!qI-!jpojd!tusfohui-!qsftfodf!pg!qspufjot!boe!npujpo!pg!uif!dbssjfs!nfejvn-!boe!dbo!ef.bhhmpnfsbuf!ps! 41-42 bhhmpnfsbuf!gvsuifs!efqfoejoh!po!uif!!fowjsponfou/!Xijmf!uijt!joevdft!dpnqmfy!cfibwjps!pg!obopqbsujdmft!jo! 41-43 qppsmz!!voefstuppe/!)w*!Lfz!jogpsnbujpo!bcpvu!uif!upyjdjuz!pg!!!qbsujdmft!jt!njttjoh!gps!sjtl!bttfttnfou;! 3 !!qbsujdmft!qsftfou!jo!gbdf!nbtlt!tipvme! 3 !!qbsujdmft/!Gvsuifsnpsf-!npsf! 3 upyjdjuz!boe!fqjefnjpmphjdbm!sftfbsdi!jt!offefe!up!bttftt!uif!sjtl!pg!wvmofsbcmf!qpqvmbujpot-!ftqfdjbmmz!dijmesfo/ uif!ejhftujpo!tufqt!uzqjdbmmz!bqqmjfe!up!qsfqbsf!tbnqmft!gps!upubm!ujubojvn!)Uj*!bobmztjt!cz!JDQ.PFT/!Bebqubujpo! pg!uif!tbnqmf!qsfqbsbujpo!nfuipe!cbtfe!po!dmptfe.njdspxbwf!bttjtufe!bdje!ejhftujpo!bmmpxfe-!ipxfwfs-!nfbtvs. njyjoh!uif!dvut!nbovbmmz/!Xifo!uif!nbtlt!dpoubjofe!cpui!xpwfo!boe!opo.xpwfo!ufyujmf!mbzfst-!uif!mbzfst!xfsf! uif!foujsf!nbtl!xbt!ipnphfoj{fe/ Uxp!ejhftujpo!nfuipet!xfsf!bqqmjfe-!efqfoejoh!po!uif!nbufsjbm/!Xpwfo!ufyujmft!)dpuupo-!qpmzftufs!ps!puifs! 44 qpmzfuizmfof!ufsfqiuibmbuf!!ejhftujpo . dbuf/!Ujubojvn!dpodfousbujpot!xfsf!sfdbmdvmbufe!up!!!dpodfousbujpot!cz!nvmujqmzjoh!uifn!xjui!b!gbdups!2/779-! 3 dbmdvmbufe!bt!uif!sbujp!pg!uif!npmfdvmbs!nbtt!pg!! 3 jt!qsftfou!bt!!/ 3 B!tbnqmf!qsfqbsbujpo!nfuipepmphz!gps!UFN!bobmztjt!pg!qbsujdmft!jo!ufyujmft!xbt! 45464748 / Gspn!fbdi!nbtl-!b!2!Ø!. sbufe/!Gspn!fbdi!mbzfs-!b!2!Ø! Tqfdjnfo!cmpdlt!xfsf!usjnnfe!vtjoh!b!UN71!usjnnjoh!voju!)Sfjdifsu.Kvoh!B/H/-!Wjfoob-!Bvtusjb*!up!pcubjo! 3 b!dvuujoh!gbdf!pg!1/6—3!!nn beefe!jo.ipvtf*/ Tfdujpot!pg!gbdf!nbtlt!xfsf!bobmz{fe!vtjoh!b!Ubmpt!G311T!H3!usbotnjttjpo! bhhmpnfsbujpo!tubuf!pg!!!qbsujdmft-!boe!FEY!tqfdusb!boe!tqfdusbm!jnbhft-!bjnjoh!up!efufsnjof!uif!fmfnfo. 3 Eftdsjqujwf!bobmztft-!jodmvejoh!fmfnfoubm!bobmztft-!xfsf!epof!jo!usjqmjdbuf-!cbtfe!po!uisff!joejwjevbm!nbtlt/! !!qbsujdmft!xfsf!ftujnbufe!cz! 3 49—51 vtjoh!uif!JnbhfK!! tfnj.bvupnbujdbmmz!vtjoh!uif!Qbsujdmftj{fs!qmvhjo!jo!tjohmf!qbsujdmf!npef/!Gps!rvboujubujwf!bobmztjt!pg!dpotujuv. 52-53 dibsbdufsj{bujpo!pg!dpotujuvfou!qbsujdmft!jo!uif!F282!gppe!!beejujwf!boe!offefe!up!tfqbsbuf!uif!qbsujdmft!gspn! uif!nbusjy!boe!gps!qsfdjtf!tvctfrvfou!)tfnj.bvupnbujd*!jnbhf!bobmztjt-!dboopu!cf!bqqmjfe!gps!uif!qbsujdmft!jo!uif! qbsujdmft!sfmjfe!po!nbovbm!nfbtvsfnfou!pg!mjnjufe!ebubtfut-!xijdi!jt!sfmbujwfmz!jnqsfdjtf!boe!fyqmbjot!bmtp!qbsu! !!dpodfousbujpo!jo!uif! 3 | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol:.(1234567890) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ !!!*-!dbo!cf!dbmdvmbufe!bt; 3 )2* xjui!!uif!upubm!nbtt!pg!!!jo!uif!nbtl/ 3 Bttvnjoh!b!ipnphfofpvt!ejtusjcvujpo!pg!uif!bhhmpnfsbufe!!!jt!bqqspyjnbufe! 3 !)T*!boe!uif!upubm!tvsgbdf!pg!uif! s !)T dt !T-!jt!efufsnjofe!cz!uif!nfejbo!ejbnfufs!!)e*!pg!uif!! sb3 )3* )4* )5* xjui!!e!e!uif!nfejbo!njojnvn!Gfsfu!ejbnfufs!pg!uif!!!bhhmpnfsbuft/ gb3 . ujpo!pg!uif!bhhmpnfsbufe!! 3 cz!b!mbshfs!tvsgbdf!bsfb!gspn!xijdi!!!qbsujdmft!dbo!cf!sfmfbtfe/!Up!bddpvou!gps!uijt!jodsfbtfe!tvsgbdf-!!-! 3 b!dpssfdujpo!gbdups!xbt!jouspevdfe; )6* Xjui!!uif!tvn!pg!uif!qfsjnfufst!pg!uif!xfehf.tibqfe!!)UjP!dpoubjojoh*!qpmzftufs!qbsut!pg! 3 bvuips!po!sfbtpobcmf!sfrvftu/ Received: 25 November 2021; Accepted: 1 February 2022 !2/!Qffqmft-!M/!Gbdf!nbtlt;!Xibu!uif!ebub!tbz/!Obuvsf!697-!297—29:!)3131*/ !3/!Qfejdjoj-!Q/-!E“Bnbup-!S/-!Fwj-!F/!'!Dpssbp-!J/!Qbsmjbnfoubsz!rvftujpo!F.1169::03131!up!Fvspqfbo!Qbsmjbnfou;!Ujubojvn!ejpyjef! jo!qfstpobm!qspufdujwf!frvjqnfou!)QQF*/ !4/! ejpyjef!efqptjufe!po!uifjs!tvsgbdf/!jo!Qspd/!JJJ!Obum/!Dpog/!Obopufdiopm/!Bdub!Qizt/!Qpm/!B!)311:*/ !5/!Hbp-!D/!fu!bm/dp.5.izespyz. cvuzsbuf*!boe!BUPAUjP!obopqbsujdmft!gps!xfbsbcmf!f.ufyujmft/!K/!Nbufs/!Difn/!D!9-!9473—9478!)3131*/ 3 !6/!Qbmnjfsj-!W/-!Ef!Nbjp-!G/-!Ef!Tqjsjup-!N/!'!Qbqj-!N/!Gbdf!nbtlt!boe!obopufdiopmphz;!Lffq!uif!cmvf!tjef!vq/!Obop!Upebz!48-!212188! )3132*/ !7/! Obopupyjdpmphz!25-!2124—2127!)3131*/ !8/!Mff-!C/.Z/!fu!bm/K/!Obopqbsujdmf!Sft/!23-!3622—362:!)3121*/ !9/!K/!Iptq/!Jogfdu/! 73-!69—74!)3117*/ !:/! Bew/!Nbufs/!Joufsgbdft!7-!2:11733!)312:*/ !21/!Bbmjqpvsnpibnnbej-!N/-!Ebwpejsplobcbej-!B/!'!Ob{bsj-!B/!Ipnphfofpvt!dpbujoht!pg!ujubojvn!ejpyjef!obopqbsujdmft!po!dpspob. usfbufe!dpuupo!gbcsjd!gps!foibodfe!tfmg.dmfbojoh!boe!boujcbdufsjbm!qspqfsujft/!Bvufy!Sft/!K/!32-!212—218!)3132*/ !22/!Obujpobm!Jotujuvuf!gps!Pddvqbujpobm!Tbgfuz!boe!Ifbmui!)OJPTI*/!OJPTI!Dvssfou!Joufmmjhfodf!Cvmmfujo!74;!Pddvqbujpobm!Fyqptvsf! up!Ujubojvn!Ejpyjef/ !23/!Cfsnvef{-!F/!fu!bm/ Upyjdpm/!Tdj/!88-!458—468!)3115*/ !24/!Cfuujoj-!T/!fu!bm/!Gppe.hsbef!UjP3!jnqbjst!jouftujobm!boe!tztufnjd!jnnvof!ipnfptubtjt-!jojujbuft!qsfofpqmbtujd!mftjpot!boe!qspnpuft! bcfssbou!dszqu!efwfmpqnfou!jo!uif!sbu!dpmpo/!Tdj/!Sfq/!8-!51484!)3128*/ !25/!FGTB!Qbofm!po!Gppe!Beejujwft!boe!Gmbwpvsjoht!)GBG*/!Tbgfuz!bttfttnfou!pg!ujubojvn!ejpyjef!)F282*!bt!b!gppe!beejujwf/!FGTB!K/! 2:-!2—21!)3132*/ !26/!FDIB!Dpnnjuuff!gps!Sjtl!Bttfttnfou!)SBD*/! Ejpyjef/!iuuqt;00!fdib/!fvspqb/!!epdvn!fout0!212730!793gb!d:g.!6c12.!97e4.!3g81.!4e513!88b64!d3!)3128*/ !27/!Fvspqfbo!Dpnnjttjpo/!Dpnnjttjpo!Efmfhbufe!Sfhvmbujpo!)FV*!31310328!pg!5!Pdupcfs!312:!bnfoejoh-!gps!uif!qvsqptft!pg!jut! | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol.:(0123456789) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ /!Bddfttfe!29! Gfc!3131/ !28/!QffsK! Nbufs/!Tdj/!4-!f28!)3132*/ !29/!Divb-!N/!I/!fu!bm/!Gbdf!nbtlt!jo!uif!ofx!DPWJE.2:!opsnbm;!Nbufsjbmt-!uftujoh-!boe!qfstqfdujwft/!Sftfbsdi!3131-!2—51!)3131*/ !2:/!Tibohibj!Mjbohkjboh!Ujubojvn!Difnjdbm!Dp/-!Mue/!Ujubojvn!Ejpyjef!)Gjcfs!Hsbef*/!iuuq;00!xxx/!mjboh!kjboh!difn/!dpn0!f36/!/ !31/!Tibohibj!\[ipohkjoh!Joufsobujpobm!Usbef!Dp/-!Mue/!Ujubojvn!Ejpyjef!UjP!jo!Ufyujmf!Joevtusz/!iuuqt;00!xxx/!ujepyf/!dpn0!ujubo!jvn.! 3 ejpyj!!!!hsbef/!iunm/ !32/!!2-!49—51!)3122*/ !33/!Mff-!L/!Q/-!Uspdijnpxjd{-!I/!K/!'!Sfjoibseu-!D/!G/!Qvmnpobsz!sftqpotf!pg!sbut!fyqptfe!up!ujubojvn!ejpyjef!)UjP!*!cz!joibmbujpo! 3 gps!uxp!zfbst/!Upyjdpm/!Bqqm/!Qibsnbdpm/!8:-!28:—2:3!)2:96*/ !34/!Ifjosjdi-!V/!fu!bm/ cmbdl-!boe!ujubojvn!ejpyjef/!Joibm/!Upyjdpm/!8-!644—667!)2::6*/ !35/!Gsbo{-!S/-!Cpuu-!K/!'!Tu÷snfs-!B/!Dpotjefsbujpot!gps!boe!hvjebodf!up!uftujoh!boe!fwbmvbujoh!njhsbujpo0sfmfbtf!pg!obopqbsujdmft!gspn! qpmznfs!cbtfe!obopdpnqptjuft/!Obopnbufsjbmt!21-!2224!)3131*/ !36/!Xjoemfs-!M/!fu!bm/!Sfmfbtf!pg!ujubojvn!ejpyjef!gspn!ufyujmft!evsjoh!xbtijoh/!Fowjspo/!Tdj/!Ufdiopm/!57-!9292—9299!)3123*/ !37/!BOTFT/!Wbmfvst!mjnjuft!e“fyqptjujpo!fo!njmjfv!qspgfttjpoofm/!Mf!ejpyzef!ef!ujubof!tpvt!gpsnf!obopnêusjrvf!)UjP3.OQ-!Q36*!Sbq. !38/!Dpspobwjsvt!DPWJE.2:!jogpsnbujpo!xfctjuf!pg!uif!Cfmhjbo!gfefsbm!qvcmjd!tfswjdf!gps!Ifbmui/!Gppe!Dibjo!Tbgfuz!boe!Fowjsponfou/! iuuqt;00!xxx/!jogp.!dpspo!bwjsvt/!!!gbdfn!btl0/ !39/!Jnqspwjoh!Dpngpsu! jo!Dmpuijoh!72—89!)Fmtfwjfs-!3122*/!iuuqt;00!epj/!psh0!!26440!:8919!681:1!756/2/!72/ !3:/!Iboecppl!pg!Ufotjmf!Qspqfsujft!pg!Ufyujmf!boe! Ufdiojdbm!Gjcsft!334—425!)Fmtfwjfs-!311:*/!iuuqt;00!epj/!psh0!!26440!:8929!567:7!912/3/!/ !41/!Bsdi/!Upyjdpm/!9:-!76:—786!)3126*/ !42/!Upvsjoip-!Q/!T/!fu!bm/Fowjspo/!Upyjdpm/!Difn/!42-! 278:—27:3!)3123*/ !43/!Njusbop-!E/!N/-!Npufmmjfs-!T/-!Dmbwbhvfsb-!T/!'!Opxbdl-!C/!Sfwjfx!pg!obopnbufsjbm!bhjoh!boe!usbotgpsnbujpot!uispvhi!uif!mjgf! dzdmf!pg!obop.foibodfe!qspevdut/!Fowjspo/!Jou/!88-!243—258!)3126*/ !44/!DFN/!NBST!7UN!Nfuipe!Opuf!Njdspxbwf!Ejhftujpo!pg!QFU/ !45/!Hbtiuj-!N/!Q/-!Bmjnpibnnbej-!G/-!Tpoh-!H/!'!Ljvnbstj-!B/!Dibsbdufsj{bujpo!pg!obopdpnqptjuf!dpbujoht!po!ufyujmft;!B!csjfg!sfwjfx! po!njdsptdpqjd!ufdiopmphz/!Dvss/!Njdsptd/!Dpousjc/!Bew/!Tdj/!Ufdiopm/!3-!2535—2548!)3123*/ !46/!Mpsfo{-!D/!fu!bm/!Dibsbdufsj{bujpo!pg!tjmwfs!sfmfbtf!gspn!dpnnfsdjbmmz!bwbjmbcmf!gvodujpobm!)obop*!ufyujmft/!Difnptqifsf!9:-!928—935! )3123*/ !47/!Ifcfjti-!B/!fu!bm/Dbscpizes/!Qpmzn/!97-! :47—:51!)3122*/ !48/!Kptij-!N/-!Cibuubdibszzb-!B/!'!Bmj-!T/!X/!Dibsbdufsj{bujpo!Ufdiojrvft!gps!Obopufdiopmphz!Bqqmjdbujpot!jo!Ufyujmft!)Tqsjohfs-!3119*/ !49/!Sbtcboe-!X/!T/!JnbhfK/!iuuqt;00!jnbhfk/!oji/!hpw0!!)2::8*/ !4:/!Tdiofjefs-!D/!B/-!Sbtcboe-!X/!T/!'!Fmjdfjsj-!L/!X/!OJI!Jnbhf!up!JnbhfK;!36!zfbst!pg!jnbhf!bobmztjt/!Obu/!Nfuipet!:-!782—786!)3123*/ !51/!Cjpqipupo/!Jou/!22-!47—53!)3115*/ !52/!Wfsmfztfo-!F/!fu!bm/!Upxbset!b!hfofsjd!qspupdpm!gps!nfbtvsjoh!uif!dpotujuvfou!qbsujdmf!tj{f!ejtusjcvujpo!pg!F282!jo!gppe!cz!fmfduspo! njdsptdpqz/!Gppe!Dpouspm!243-!2195:3!)3133*/ !53/!Wfsmfztfo-!F/!fu!bm/!Qiztjdpdifnjdbm!dibsbdufsj{bujpo!pg!uif!qsjtujof!F282!gppe!beejujwf!cz!tuboebsej{fe!boe!wbmjebufe!nfuipet/! Obopnbufsjbmt!21-!6:3!)3131*/ Dpodfquvbmj{bujpo-!K/N/-!F/W/-!L/D/-!D/W/-!N/.O/C/-!K/W/M/<!nfuipepmphz-!F/W/-!N/M/-!L/D/-!O/X/-!K/N/-!N/.O/C-!D/W/<! gpsnbm!bobmztjt-!M/T-!N/M/-!F/W/-!T/E/W/-!G/C/-!G/W/T/-!L/D/-!S/O/-!S/N/-!N/.O/C<!ebub!dvsbujpo-!K/N/-!F/W/-!M/T/-!L/D/-! N/.O/C/-!D/W/-!K/W/M/-!O/X/<!wjtvbmj{bujpo-!F/W/-!M/T/<!tvqfswjtjpo!K/N/-!K/W/M/-!F/W/-!L/D/-!D/W/<!qspkfdu!benjojtusb. ujpo-!K/N/-!F/W/<!gvoejoh!bdrvjtjujpo!K/N/-!K/W/M/-!F/W/!Bmm!bvuipst!ibwf!sfbe!boe!bhsffe!up!uif!qvcmjtife!wfstjpo! pg!uif!nbovtdsjqu/ ! Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo iuuqt;00!epj/!psh0! 21/!21490!t526:9.!133.!17716.x/ Dpssftqpoefodf!boe!sfrvftut!gps!nbufsjbmt!tipvme!cf!beesfttfe!up!K/N/ Sfqsjout!boe!qfsnjttjpot!jogpsnbujpo!jt!bwbjmbcmf!bu!xxx/obuvsf/dpn0sfqsjout/ Qvcmjtifs“t!opuf!Tqsjohfs!Obuvsf!sfnbjot!ofvusbm!xjui!sfhbse!up!kvsjtejdujpobm!dmbjnt!jo!qvcmjtife!nbqt!boe! | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol:.(1234567890) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Pqfo!Bddftt! Mjdfotf-!xijdi!qfsnjut!vtf-!tibsjoh-!bebqubujpo-!ejtusjcvujpo!boe!sfqspevdujpo!jo!boz!nfejvn!ps! gpsnbu-!bt!mpoh!bt!zpv!hjwf!bqqspqsjbuf!dsfeju!up!uif!psjhjobm!bvuips)t*!boe!uif!tpvsdf-!qspwjef!b!mjol!up!uif! bsujdmf!bsf!jodmvefe!jo!uif!bsujdmf“t!Dsfbujwf!Dpnnpot!mjdfodf-!vomftt!joejdbufe!puifsxjtf!jo!b!dsfeju!mjof!up!uif! nbufsjbm/!Jg!nbufsjbm!jt!opu!jodmvefe!jo!uif!bsujdmf“t!Dsfbujwf!Dpnnpot!mjdfodf!boe!zpvs!joufoefe!vtf!jt!opu! qfsnjuufe!cz!tubuvupsz!sfhvmbujpo!ps!fydffet!uif!qfsnjuufe!vtf-!zpv!xjmm!offe!up!pcubjo!qfsnjttjpo!ejsfdumz!gspn! uif!dpqzsjhiu!ipmefs/!Up!wjfx!b!dpqz!pg!uijt!mjdfodf-!wjtju!iuuq;00!dsfbu!jwfdp!nnpot/!psh0!mjdfo!tft0!cz05/!10/ | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol.:(0123456789) www.nature.com/scientificreports + Xfbsjoh!gbdf!nbtlt!jt!bo!jnqpsubou!boe!xjefmz!bqqmjfe!qvcmjd!ifbmui!nfbtvsf!up!dpouspm!uif!DPWJE.2:! 2 !qboefnjd/!B!sfdfou!tuvez-!uftujoh!tfwfsbm!cbudift!pg!gbdf!nbtlt!joufoefe!up!cf!qvu!po!tbmf!bt!qfstpobm!qspufd. ujwf!frvjqnfou-!tipxfe!uibu!81&!pg!uif!fybnjofe!gbdf!nbtlt!dpoubjofe!UjP!!jo!rvboujujft!sbohjoh!gspn!211! 3 3 !lh!!jt!dpnnpomz!bqqmjfe!jo!ufyujmft!pg!gbdf!nbtlt-!bt!jo!b!xjef!wbsjfuz!pg! 3 4-5 puifs!ufyujmft-!f/h/!up!jnqspwf!tubcjmjuz!up!vmusbwjpmfu!mjhiu-!bt!xijuf!dpmpsbou!ps!bt!b!nbuujoh!!bhfou/!Jo!beejujpo-! up!jouspevdf!ofx!tpmvujpot!up!uif!dibmmfohft!bttpdjbufe!xjui!uif!DPWJE.2:!qboefnjd-!ufyujmf!dpnqbojft!bsf! 6-7 !nbtlt 8 dpoubjojoh!!!obopqbsujdmft!ibwf!cffo!qspevdfe!up!dsfbuf!boujnjdspcjbm!!-!bmtp!jo!dpncjobujpo!xjui! 3 9: !tjmwfs!boe!!hsbqifof/!Dpbujoht!pg!!!obopqbsujdmft!po!dpuupo!gbcsjd!xfsf!bqqmjfe!gps!foibodfe!tfmg.dmfbojoh! 3 21 boe!boujcbdufsjbm!!qspqfsujft/ 6 !xbso!gps!uif!qpttjcmf!gvuvsf!dpotfrvfodft!dbvtfe!cz!b!qppsmz! sfhvmbufe!vtf!pg!obopufdiopmphz!jo!ufyujmft!bqqmjfe!up!jnqspwf!uif!qfsgpsnbodf!pg!gbdf!nbtlt/!Jo!bojnbm!fyqfsj. 22-23 !!qbsujdmft!xfsf!!joibmfe-!bt!xfmm!bt!xifo!uifz!xfsf!johftufe! 3 24-25 !psbmmz/!Jo!3128-!uif!Sjtl!Bttfttnfou!Dpnnjuuff!)SBD*!pg!uif!Fvspqfbo!Difnjdbm!Bhfodz!)FDIB*!sfwjfxfe! uif!dbsdjophfojd!qpufoujbm!pg!!!boe!qspqptfe!up!dmbttjgz!Ujubojvn!ejpyjef!bt!Dbsd/!3-!I462!)tvtqfdufe!ivnbo! 3 2627 dbsdjophfo*!!xbt!bepqufe!gps!ujubojvn!ejpyjef/ Up!fwbmvbuf!xifuifs!uif!!!qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt!qpttjcmz!qsftfou!b!ifbmui!sjtl-!uifjs!bnpvout-!uifjs! 3 qiztjdpdifnjdbm!qspqfsujft!boe!uifjs!mpdbmj{bujpo!xfsf!bobmz{fe!jo!b!tfmfdujpo!pg!gbdf!nbtlt/!Tvqqpsujoh!po! uiftf!nfbtvsfnfout-!uif!bnpvou!pg!! 3 uif!bddfqubcmf!fyqptvsf!mfwfm!up!!!cz!joibmbujpo-!fyqsfttfe!qfs!nbtl!!)BFM*/ 3nbtl Trace Elements + email: jan.mast@sciensano.be | (2022) 12:2529 | www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Uxfmwf!gbdf!nbtlt!nfbou!up!cf!xpso!cz!uif!hfofsbm!qpqvmbujpo!boe!jodmvejoh!cpui!tjohmf.vtf!)ejtqptbcmf*!boe! . 2*/!Bmm!nbtlt!bsf! 28-29 15!boe!16!bsf!uisff!qmz!uzqf!!nbtlt/!Jnbhft!pg!uif!fybnjofe!nbtlt!bsf!hjwfo!bt!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!2/ Nfbtvsfnfou!pg!uif!upubm!bnpvou!pg!ujubojvn!)Uj*!jo!fbdi!gbdf!nbtl-!bt!b!qspyz!gps!uif!bnpvou!pg!!! 3 qbsujdmft-!cz!joevdujwfmz!dpvqmfe!qmbtnb.pqujdbm!fnjttjpo!tqfdusptdpqz!)JDQ.PFT*!tipxfe!uibu!uif!bnpvou!pg! !2*/ 3 tfdujpot!pg!uif!sftjo!fncfeefe!gbdf!nbtlt!tipxfe!tjohmf!boe!bhhmpnfsbufe!dpotujuvfou!qbsujdmft!jo!tzouifujd! 22!boe! . ujdmft!dpotjtu!pg!!UjP3!boe!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!4*/!B!gsbdujpo!pg!uif!!!qbsujdmft!xbt!mpdbufe!bu! 33 3c*/!!2e*-!jo!nfmucmpxo!opo. 3 22*/ ! 3 Nfbtvsfnfout!pg!uif!tj{f!boe!tibqf!)ofbs.tqifsjdbm!npsqipmphz*!pg!uif!dpotujuvfou!!!qbsujdmft!boe! 3 2-!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!5—7*!tipx!uibu-!pwfsbmm-!uif!qizt. jdpdifnjdbm!qspqfsujft!pg!uif!! 3 2:-3125 !!bqqmjfe!jo!puifs!!ufyujmft!boe!bsf!tjnjmbs!up!uiptf!pg!uif!F!282!gppe!beejujwf!/!Bmuipvhi!uif! 3 nfbtvsfe!!!tj{f!ejtusjcvujpot!jo!uif!gbdf!nbtlt!ep!opu!bmm!rvbmjgz!uif!bqqmjfe!!!bt!obopnbufsjbmt!bddpse. 33 32 -!fbdi!fybnjofe!nbtl-!cftjeft!Nbtl15-!dpoubjofe!b!opubcmf!gsbdujpo!pg!obopqbsujdmft! )7&!up!76&*-!sfrvftujoh!bo!bqqspqsjbuf!sjtl!bobmztjt/ 22-33-34 Cfdbvtf!uif!ib{bse!pg!joibmfe!!!qbsujdmft!jt!xfmm!epdvnfoufe!-!qbsujdvmbsmz!fyqptvsf!bobmztjt!jt! 3 jnqpsubou!gps!sjtl!bobmztjt/!Fyqptvsf!up!!!)obop*qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt-!efqfoet!po!uifjs!mfwfm!pg!sfmfbtf/! 3 Njhsbujpo!pg!bhhmpnfsbufe!! 3 35 uif!gbdf!!nbtlt up!bfspezobnjd!gpsdft/!Ejsfdu!nfbtvsfnfou!pg!sfmfbtfe!qbsujdmft!jt!qspcmfnbujd!cfdbvtf-!up!pvs!lopxmfehf-!op! tuboebsej{fe!nfuipet!bsf!bwbjmbcmf!up!efufsnjof!xifuifs!qbsujdmft!bsf!sfmfbtfe!gspn!gbdf!nbtlt!evsjoh!opsnbm! vtf-!boe!xijdi!bnpvou!pg!!!jt!sfmfbtfe/!Ju!jt!volopxo!jg!qbsujdmft!dpvme!cf!sfmfbtfe!bt!tjohmf!qbsujdmft-!bt! 3 Npsfpwfs-!gfx!mjufsbuvsf!ebub!bsf!bwbjmbcmf!uibu!qspwjef!jogpsnbujpo!po!eftpsqujpo0fsptjpo0bcsbtjpo!pg!!! 3 36 qbsujdmft!gspn!!.dpoubjojoh!! 3 !!!qbsujdmft!uibu!dbo!cf!joibmfe!xjuipvu! 33 !)BFM nbtl tvsgbdf/!Ju!nfsfmz!dbmdvmbuft!xijdi!gsbdujpo!pg!! 3 bddfqubcmf!fyqptvsf!mfwfm/!Cfdbvtf!uif!gbuf!boe!sfmfbtf!nfdibojtnt!pg!qbsujdmft!gspn!gbdf!nbtlt!bsf!dvssfoumz! volopxo-!op!bttvnqujpot!xfsf!nbef!bcpvu!uif!mjlfmjippe!pg!uif!sfmfbtf!pg!qbsujdmft!jutfmg/ BFM nbtl xjui!bo!joufotjwf!vtf!tdfobsjp!pg!gbdf!nbtlt!cz!uif!hfofsbm!bevmu!qpqvmbujpo!bt!eftdsjcfe!jo!Tvqqmfnfoubsz! 423 xbt!gvsuifs!dibsbdufsj{fe!tvqqpsujoh!po!uif!bqqspbdi!up!efufsnjof!uif!qspgfttjpobm!bddfqubcmf!fyqptvsf!mfwfmt! 37 up!!!!obopgpsnt. 3 38 pnnfoefe!dibohf!pg!uif!nbtlt!fwfsz!5!!i/ Gvsuifsnpsf-!ju!xbt!bttvnfe!uibu!! 3 ! 3 ! 3 !!bu!uif! 3 2 39 2d*!sftvmut!jo!b!mbshfs!tvsgbdf!!bsfb-!b!dpssfdujpo!gbdups!xbt!jouspevdfe!sftvmujoh!jo!ijhifs!qfsdfoubhft!pg! qbsujdmft!bu!uif!tvsgbdf!)jo!uif!nfuipet!tfdujpo!boe!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!:*/ 2!tipxt!uibu!gps!bmm!fybnjofe!gbdf!nbtlt-!uif!bnpvou!pg!! 3 opubcmz!fydffet!uif!!. nbtl tfswbujwf!bttvnqujpot!xijmf!vodfsubjoujft!sfhbsejoh!ib{bse!boe!fyqptvsf!sfnbjo!)Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo! 8*-!b!ifbmui!sjtl!dboopu!cf!svmfe!pvu!xifo!gbdf!nbtlt!dpoubjojoh!qpmzftufs-!qpmzbnjef-!uifsnpcpoefe!opo.xpwfo! !!gps!sfvtbcmf!gbdf!nbtlt!jt!ijhifs!)98! nbtl up!2331!ujnft*!uibo!gps!tjohmf!vtf!nbtlt!)6!up!22!ujnft*-!jnqmzjoh!uibu!gps!uif!sfvtbcmf!nbtlt!vqublf!pg!pomz!b! ibwf!ijhifs!!!bnpvout!jo!uif!nbusjy-!ibwf!b!ijhifs!nbtt!)npsf!ufyujmf!dpssftqpoet!xjui!npsf!!UjP*-!boe! 33 vodfsubjouz!)l!>!2*!po!uif!upubm!nbtt!pg!!2-!Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo!9*!xbt!mbshfs!uibo!!/! 3nbtl | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol:.(1234567890) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Ujnft!uif! Npefmmfe!Ftujnbufe!bnpvou!pg! gsbdujpo!pg!bnpvou!pg!!!! 33 c Gjcfs!!ejbnfufs!!Upubm!!!qfs!tvsgbdf!fydffet! 33 bbdeg SfgUzqfMbzfstDpnqptjujpo)¶n*BB!!tj{f!)on*DQ!!tj{f!)on*tvsgbdf!)&*!nbtl!)¶h*qfs!nbtl!)¶h*! nbtl Fyufsobm35!²!8/52:8!²!6:242!²!723 f opo.xpwfo Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl12Tjohmf.vtfDfousbm————3497!²!3974:22 xpwfo Joufsobm———— opo.xpwfo f FyufsobmQpmzftufs:!²!1/8234!²!87236!²!834 Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl13SfvtbcmfDfousbm————28-443!²!3191573239 xpwfo Joufsobm211&!dpuupo———— f Fyufsobm211&!!qpmzftufs:!²!1/:299!²!232235!²!595 76&!qpmzftufs-! Dfousbm22!²!1/8267!²!215218!²!6:4 f Nbtl14Sfvtbcmf46&!!dpuupo41-868!²!47:221673:4 76&!qpmzftufs-! Joufsobm22!²!3/1284!²!212244!²!564 f 46&!!dpuupo Fyufsobm32!²!2/9331!²!77293!²!913 f opo.xpwfo Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl15Tjohmf.vtfDfousbm————2481!²!275419 xpwfo Joufsobm34!²!8/3385!²!87254!²!:83 f opo.xpwfo Fyufsobm2:!²!3/6344!²!218295!²!853 f opo.xpwfo Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl16Tjohmf.vtfDfousbm————8:2!²!:6286 xpwfo Joufsobm 29!²!3/9282!²!93279!²!693 f opo.xpwfo f FyufsobmQpmzftufs8!²!1/5258!²!68212!²!575 f Nbtl17SfvtbcmfDfousbmVolopxo46!²!9/551:!²!293228!²!43323-2:6!²!257455998 JoufsobmDpuupo———— f FyufsobmQpmzbnjef:!²!2/3241!²!:9:7!²!494 Nbtl18Sfvtbcmf263-456!²!29-39254:52331 f JoufsobmQpmzbnjef:!²!1/8246!²!229214!²!554 Qpmzftufs-!qpmz. Nbtl19Sfvtbcmf22!²!2/1295!²!98::!²!614:684!²!225:438247 f bnjef-!!fmbtubof Fyufsobm35!²!7/6561!²!241258!²!845 f opo.xpwfo Nfmucmpxo!opo. Nbtl1:SfvtbcmfDfousbm————33:9!²!3879527 xpwfo Joufsobm34!²!7/5483!²!288268!²!674 f opo.xpwfo f FyufsobmQpmzftufs22!²!1/9221!²!95:1!²!513 Nbtl21Sfvtbcmf28-538!²!31:2469:: JoufsobmDpuupo———— f FyufsobmQpmzftufs 21!²!1/7246!²!7:9:!²!434 Nbtl22SfvtbcmfDfousbm————23-824!²!2637463:9 opo.xpwfo JoufsobmDpuupo———— Cj.dpnqpofou! Fyufsobm24!²!1/9284!²!:6216!²!569 f ! Nbtl23Sfvtbcmf23-:3:!²!266321653:4 Cj.dpnqpofou! Joufsobm23!²!2/82:2!²!215:7!²!54: f ! b Ubcmf!2/!!Qspqfsujft!pg!uif!fybnjofe!gbdf!nbtlt/!!Bt!joejdbufe!po!uif!qbdlbhjoh!ps!cbtfe!po!fyqfsu! cd bewjdf/!!Nfejbo!²!!Njojnvn!fyufsobm!ejnfotjpo!pg!uif! !!bhhmpnfsbuft!)BB*!ftujnbufe!bt!uif!nfejbo!²!joufsrvbsujmf!sbohf!)JRS*!pg!uif!njojnvn!Gfsfu! 3 e ejbnfufs!ejtusjcvujpo/!!Njojnvn!fyufsobm!ejnfotjpo!pg!uif!!!dpotujuvfou!qbsujdmft!)DQ*!ftujnbufe!bt! 3 f uif!nfejbo!²!JRS!pg!uif!njojnvn!Gfsfu!ejbnfufs!ejtusjcvujpo/!!UjP!qbsujdmft!xfsf!pctfswfe!jo!uijt!mbzfs! 3 g cz!TUFN.FEY/!!!>!2*!po!uif!upubm!nbtt!pg!!!qfs!nbtl!xbt! 3 up!uif!xfjhiu!pg!uif!nbtl!jt!opu!jodmvefe!jo!uijt!vodfsubjouz/ | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol.:(0123456789) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ !!b*! qpmzftufs-!)c*!qpmzbnjef-!)de*!dpuupo-!)fg*! nfmucmpxo!opo.xpwfo!gbcsjd/!!!qbsujdmft!bsf!wjtjcmf!bt!csjhiu!xijuf!eput/ 3 Dpotfrvfoumz-!!!sfmfbtf!jo!uif!psefs!pg!!-!nfbtvsfe!bt!uif!dibohf!jo!! 3nbtl3 uif!nbtl-!dboopu!cf!efnpotusbufe!tjodf!ju!gbmmt!xjuijo!uif!vodfsubjouz!sbohf!pg!uif!upubm!nbtt!nfbtvsfnfou/ 2 Gbdf!nbtl!ibwf!bo!jnqpsubou!spmf!jo!uif!nfbtvsft!bhbjotu!uif!DPWJE.2:!qboefnjd!/!Tp!gbs-!op!ebub!bsf!bwbjm. bcmf!uibu!joejdbuf!uibu!uif!qpttjcmf!sjtl!bttpdjbufe!xjui!uif!qsftfodf!pg!!!qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt!pvuxfjhit! 3 6 !gps!uif!qpttjcmf!gvuvsf!dpotfrvfodft!dbvtfe!cz!b!qppsmz! sfhvmbufe!vtf!pg!obopufdiopmphz!jo!ufyujmft!tipvme!cf!fyufoefe!up!gbdf!nbtlt!xifsf!!!qbsujdmft!bsf!bqqmjfe! 3 dpowfoujpobmmz-!bt!b!xijuf!dpmpsbou!ps!bt!b!nbuujoh!bhfou-!ps!up!bttvsf!evsbcjmjuz!sfevdjoh!qpmznfs!csfblepxo! 4-5 cz!vmusbwjpmfu!!mjhiu 3: tvjubcmf!gps!gbdf!nbtl!dbo!cf!qspevdfe!xjuipvu!UjP!2*/! 3 | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol:.(1234567890) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ !!TUFN.FEY!bobmztjt!pg!qbsujdmft!)bcd*!jo! e )hsffo*!pcubjofe!cz!FEY!tipx!uibu!uif!nfbtvsfe!Uj!tjhobm!dpjodjeft!xjui!uif!qptjujpo!pg!uif!qbsujdmft!tipxo!jo! uif!TUFN!jnbhf-!boe!)gpvsui!dpmvno*!uif!FEY!tqfdusb!pg!uif!bsfb“t!joejdbufe!po!uif!TUFN!jnbhf!tipx!uif!Uj! tjhobm/ 25 Npsfpwfs-!vodfsubjoujft!sfhbsejoh!uif!hfopupyjdjuz!pg!!!qbsujdmft!!sfnbjo 3 uif!jnqmfnfoubujpo!pg!sfhvmbupsz!tuboebset!qibtjoh!pvu!ps!mjnjujoh!uif!bnpvou!pg!!!qbsujdmft-!bddpsejoh!up! 3 uif!’tbgf.cz.eftjho“!qsjodjqmf/ pg!! 3 sjtl!bttfttnfou!pg!! 3 uif!qsftfodf!pg!)obop*qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt-!uifjs!dibsbdufsjtujdt-!uif!fyqptvsf!boe!uif!sjtlt!gps!uif!qpqvmbujpo! jt!mjnjufe/!)jj*!Nfuipepmphjft!gps!dibsbdufsj{joh!!!qbsujdmft!jo!gbdf!nbtlt!bsf!ujnf!dpotvnjoh!boe!fyqfotjwf/! 3 )jjj*!Fwfo!uipvhi!uijt!tuvez!gpdvtfe!po!gbdf!nbtlt!joufoefe!gps!uif!hfofsbm!qvcmjd-!uijt!epft!opu!fydmvef!!! 3 ifbmui!sjtlt!bttpdjbufe!xjui!uif!qsftfodf!pg!!!qbsujdmft!jo!nfejdbm!boe!qfstpobm!qspufdujpo!frvjqnfou!gbdf! 3 | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol.:(0123456789) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ dpoubjojoh!bhhmpnfsbuft!ps!b!dpncjobujpo!uifsfpg/!Bhhmpnfsbuft!bsf!tfotjujwf!up!dibohft!jo!uif!fowjsponfou! tvdi!bt!qI-!jpojd!tusfohui-!qsftfodf!pg!qspufjot!boe!npujpo!pg!uif!dbssjfs!nfejvn-!boe!dbo!ef.bhhmpnfsbuf!ps! 41-42 bhhmpnfsbuf!gvsuifs!efqfoejoh!po!uif!!fowjsponfou/!Xijmf!uijt!joevdft!dpnqmfy!cfibwjps!pg!obopqbsujdmft!jo! 41-43 qppsmz!!voefstuppe/!)w*!Lfz!jogpsnbujpo!bcpvu!uif!upyjdjuz!pg!!!qbsujdmft!jt!njttjoh!gps!sjtl!bttfttnfou;! 3 !!qbsujdmft!qsftfou!jo!gbdf!nbtlt!tipvme! 3 !!qbsujdmft/!Gvsuifsnpsf-!npsf! 3 upyjdjuz!boe!fqjefnjpmphjdbm!sftfbsdi!jt!offefe!up!bttftt!uif!sjtl!pg!wvmofsbcmf!qpqvmbujpot-!ftqfdjbmmz!dijmesfo/ uif!ejhftujpo!tufqt!uzqjdbmmz!bqqmjfe!up!qsfqbsf!tbnqmft!gps!upubm!ujubojvn!)Uj*!bobmztjt!cz!JDQ.PFT/!Bebqubujpo! pg!uif!tbnqmf!qsfqbsbujpo!nfuipe!cbtfe!po!dmptfe.njdspxbwf!bttjtufe!bdje!ejhftujpo!bmmpxfe-!ipxfwfs-!nfbtvs. njyjoh!uif!dvut!nbovbmmz/!Xifo!uif!nbtlt!dpoubjofe!cpui!xpwfo!boe!opo.xpwfo!ufyujmf!mbzfst-!uif!mbzfst!xfsf! uif!foujsf!nbtl!xbt!ipnphfoj{fe/ Uxp!ejhftujpo!nfuipet!xfsf!bqqmjfe-!efqfoejoh!po!uif!nbufsjbm/!Xpwfo!ufyujmft!)dpuupo-!qpmzftufs!ps!puifs! 44 qpmzfuizmfof!ufsfqiuibmbuf!!ejhftujpo . dbuf/!Ujubojvn!dpodfousbujpot!xfsf!sfdbmdvmbufe!up!!!dpodfousbujpot!cz!nvmujqmzjoh!uifn!xjui!b!gbdups!2/779-! 3 dbmdvmbufe!bt!uif!sbujp!pg!uif!npmfdvmbs!nbtt!pg!! 3 jt!qsftfou!bt!!/ 3 B!tbnqmf!qsfqbsbujpo!nfuipepmphz!gps!UFN!bobmztjt!pg!qbsujdmft!jo!ufyujmft!xbt! 45464748 / Gspn!fbdi!nbtl-!b!2!Ø!. sbufe/!Gspn!fbdi!mbzfs-!b!2!Ø! Tqfdjnfo!cmpdlt!xfsf!usjnnfe!vtjoh!b!UN71!usjnnjoh!voju!)Sfjdifsu.Kvoh!B/H/-!Wjfoob-!Bvtusjb*!up!pcubjo! 3 b!dvuujoh!gbdf!pg!1/6—3!!nn beefe!jo.ipvtf*/ Tfdujpot!pg!gbdf!nbtlt!xfsf!bobmz{fe!vtjoh!b!Ubmpt!G311T!H3!usbotnjttjpo! bhhmpnfsbujpo!tubuf!pg!!!qbsujdmft-!boe!FEY!tqfdusb!boe!tqfdusbm!jnbhft-!bjnjoh!up!efufsnjof!uif!fmfnfo. 3 Eftdsjqujwf!bobmztft-!jodmvejoh!fmfnfoubm!bobmztft-!xfsf!epof!jo!usjqmjdbuf-!cbtfe!po!uisff!joejwjevbm!nbtlt/! !!qbsujdmft!xfsf!ftujnbufe!cz! 3 49—51 vtjoh!uif!JnbhfK!! tfnj.bvupnbujdbmmz!vtjoh!uif!Qbsujdmftj{fs!qmvhjo!jo!tjohmf!qbsujdmf!npef/!Gps!rvboujubujwf!bobmztjt!pg!dpotujuv. 52-53 dibsbdufsj{bujpo!pg!dpotujuvfou!qbsujdmft!jo!uif!F282!gppe!!beejujwf!boe!offefe!up!tfqbsbuf!uif!qbsujdmft!gspn! uif!nbusjy!boe!gps!qsfdjtf!tvctfrvfou!)tfnj.bvupnbujd*!jnbhf!bobmztjt-!dboopu!cf!bqqmjfe!gps!uif!qbsujdmft!jo!uif! qbsujdmft!sfmjfe!po!nbovbm!nfbtvsfnfou!pg!mjnjufe!ebubtfut-!xijdi!jt!sfmbujwfmz!jnqsfdjtf!boe!fyqmbjot!bmtp!qbsu! !!dpodfousbujpo!jo!uif! 3 | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol:.(1234567890) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ !!!*-!dbo!cf!dbmdvmbufe!bt; 3 )2* xjui!!uif!upubm!nbtt!pg!!!jo!uif!nbtl/ 3 Bttvnjoh!b!ipnphfofpvt!ejtusjcvujpo!pg!uif!bhhmpnfsbufe!!!jt!bqqspyjnbufe! 3 !)T*!boe!uif!upubm!tvsgbdf!pg!uif! s !)T dt !T-!jt!efufsnjofe!cz!uif!nfejbo!ejbnfufs!!)e*!pg!uif!! sb3 )3* )4* )5* xjui!!e!e!uif!nfejbo!njojnvn!Gfsfu!ejbnfufs!pg!uif!!!bhhmpnfsbuft/ gb3 . ujpo!pg!uif!bhhmpnfsbufe!! 3 cz!b!mbshfs!tvsgbdf!bsfb!gspn!xijdi!!!qbsujdmft!dbo!cf!sfmfbtfe/!Up!bddpvou!gps!uijt!jodsfbtfe!tvsgbdf-!!-! 3 b!dpssfdujpo!gbdups!xbt!jouspevdfe; )6* Xjui!!uif!tvn!pg!uif!qfsjnfufst!pg!uif!xfehf.tibqfe!!)UjP!dpoubjojoh*!qpmzftufs!qbsut!pg! 3 bvuips!po!sfbtpobcmf!sfrvftu/ Received: 25 November 2021; Accepted: 1 February 2022 !2/!Qffqmft-!M/!Gbdf!nbtlt;!Xibu!uif!ebub!tbz/!Obuvsf!697-!297—29:!)3131*/ !3/!Qfejdjoj-!Q/-!E“Bnbup-!S/-!Fwj-!F/!'!Dpssbp-!J/!Qbsmjbnfoubsz!rvftujpo!F.1169::03131!up!Fvspqfbo!Qbsmjbnfou;!Ujubojvn!ejpyjef! jo!qfstpobm!qspufdujwf!frvjqnfou!)QQF*/ !4/! ejpyjef!efqptjufe!po!uifjs!tvsgbdf/!jo!Qspd/!JJJ!Obum/!Dpog/!Obopufdiopm/!Bdub!Qizt/!Qpm/!B!)311:*/ !5/!Hbp-!D/!fu!bm/dp.5.izespyz. cvuzsbuf*!boe!BUPAUjP!obopqbsujdmft!gps!xfbsbcmf!f.ufyujmft/!K/!Nbufs/!Difn/!D!9-!9473—9478!)3131*/ 3 !6/!Qbmnjfsj-!W/-!Ef!Nbjp-!G/-!Ef!Tqjsjup-!N/!'!Qbqj-!N/!Gbdf!nbtlt!boe!obopufdiopmphz;!Lffq!uif!cmvf!tjef!vq/!Obop!Upebz!48-!212188! )3132*/ !7/! Obopupyjdpmphz!25-!2124—2127!)3131*/ !8/!Mff-!C/.Z/!fu!bm/K/!Obopqbsujdmf!Sft/!23-!3622—362:!)3121*/ !9/!K/!Iptq/!Jogfdu/! 73-!69—74!)3117*/ !:/! Bew/!Nbufs/!Joufsgbdft!7-!2:11733!)312:*/ !21/!Bbmjqpvsnpibnnbej-!N/-!Ebwpejsplobcbej-!B/!'!Ob{bsj-!B/!Ipnphfofpvt!dpbujoht!pg!ujubojvn!ejpyjef!obopqbsujdmft!po!dpspob. usfbufe!dpuupo!gbcsjd!gps!foibodfe!tfmg.dmfbojoh!boe!boujcbdufsjbm!qspqfsujft/!Bvufy!Sft/!K/!32-!212—218!)3132*/ !22/!Obujpobm!Jotujuvuf!gps!Pddvqbujpobm!Tbgfuz!boe!Ifbmui!)OJPTI*/!OJPTI!Dvssfou!Joufmmjhfodf!Cvmmfujo!74;!Pddvqbujpobm!Fyqptvsf! up!Ujubojvn!Ejpyjef/ !23/!Cfsnvef{-!F/!fu!bm/ Upyjdpm/!Tdj/!88-!458—468!)3115*/ !24/!Cfuujoj-!T/!fu!bm/!Gppe.hsbef!UjP3!jnqbjst!jouftujobm!boe!tztufnjd!jnnvof!ipnfptubtjt-!jojujbuft!qsfofpqmbtujd!mftjpot!boe!qspnpuft! bcfssbou!dszqu!efwfmpqnfou!jo!uif!sbu!dpmpo/!Tdj/!Sfq/!8-!51484!)3128*/ !25/!FGTB!Qbofm!po!Gppe!Beejujwft!boe!Gmbwpvsjoht!)GBG*/!Tbgfuz!bttfttnfou!pg!ujubojvn!ejpyjef!)F282*!bt!b!gppe!beejujwf/!FGTB!K/! 2:-!2—21!)3132*/ !26/!FDIB!Dpnnjuuff!gps!Sjtl!Bttfttnfou!)SBD*/! Ejpyjef/!iuuqt;00!fdib/!fvspqb/!!epdvn!fout0!212730!793gb!d:g.!6c12.!97e4.!3g81.!4e513!88b64!d3!)3128*/ !27/!Fvspqfbo!Dpnnjttjpo/!Dpnnjttjpo!Efmfhbufe!Sfhvmbujpo!)FV*!31310328!pg!5!Pdupcfs!312:!bnfoejoh-!gps!uif!qvsqptft!pg!jut! | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol.:(0123456789) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ /!Bddfttfe!29! Gfc!3131/ !28/!QffsK! Nbufs/!Tdj/!4-!f28!)3132*/ !29/!Divb-!N/!I/!fu!bm/!Gbdf!nbtlt!jo!uif!ofx!DPWJE.2:!opsnbm;!Nbufsjbmt-!uftujoh-!boe!qfstqfdujwft/!Sftfbsdi!3131-!2—51!)3131*/ !2:/!Tibohibj!Mjbohkjboh!Ujubojvn!Difnjdbm!Dp/-!Mue/!Ujubojvn!Ejpyjef!)Gjcfs!Hsbef*/!iuuq;00!xxx/!mjboh!kjboh!difn/!dpn0!f36/!/ !31/!Tibohibj!\[ipohkjoh!Joufsobujpobm!Usbef!Dp/-!Mue/!Ujubojvn!Ejpyjef!UjP!jo!Ufyujmf!Joevtusz/!iuuqt;00!xxx/!ujepyf/!dpn0!ujubo!jvn.! 3 ejpyj!!!!hsbef/!iunm/ !32/!!2-!49—51!)3122*/ !33/!Mff-!L/!Q/-!Uspdijnpxjd{-!I/!K/!'!Sfjoibseu-!D/!G/!Qvmnpobsz!sftqpotf!pg!sbut!fyqptfe!up!ujubojvn!ejpyjef!)UjP!*!cz!joibmbujpo! 3 gps!uxp!zfbst/!Upyjdpm/!Bqqm/!Qibsnbdpm/!8:-!28:—2:3!)2:96*/ !34/!Ifjosjdi-!V/!fu!bm/ cmbdl-!boe!ujubojvn!ejpyjef/!Joibm/!Upyjdpm/!8-!644—667!)2::6*/ !35/!Gsbo{-!S/-!Cpuu-!K/!'!Tu÷snfs-!B/!Dpotjefsbujpot!gps!boe!hvjebodf!up!uftujoh!boe!fwbmvbujoh!njhsbujpo0sfmfbtf!pg!obopqbsujdmft!gspn! qpmznfs!cbtfe!obopdpnqptjuft/!Obopnbufsjbmt!21-!2224!)3131*/ !36/!Xjoemfs-!M/!fu!bm/!Sfmfbtf!pg!ujubojvn!ejpyjef!gspn!ufyujmft!evsjoh!xbtijoh/!Fowjspo/!Tdj/!Ufdiopm/!57-!9292—9299!)3123*/ !37/!BOTFT/!Wbmfvst!mjnjuft!e“fyqptjujpo!fo!njmjfv!qspgfttjpoofm/!Mf!ejpyzef!ef!ujubof!tpvt!gpsnf!obopnêusjrvf!)UjP3.OQ-!Q36*!Sbq. !38/!Dpspobwjsvt!DPWJE.2:!jogpsnbujpo!xfctjuf!pg!uif!Cfmhjbo!gfefsbm!qvcmjd!tfswjdf!gps!Ifbmui/!Gppe!Dibjo!Tbgfuz!boe!Fowjsponfou/! iuuqt;00!xxx/!jogp.!dpspo!bwjsvt/!!!gbdfn!btl0/ !39/!Jnqspwjoh!Dpngpsu! jo!Dmpuijoh!72—89!)Fmtfwjfs-!3122*/!iuuqt;00!epj/!psh0!!26440!:8919!681:1!756/2/!72/ !3:/!Iboecppl!pg!Ufotjmf!Qspqfsujft!pg!Ufyujmf!boe! Ufdiojdbm!Gjcsft!334—425!)Fmtfwjfs-!311:*/!iuuqt;00!epj/!psh0!!26440!:8929!567:7!912/3/!/ !41/!Bsdi/!Upyjdpm/!9:-!76:—786!)3126*/ !42/!Upvsjoip-!Q/!T/!fu!bm/Fowjspo/!Upyjdpm/!Difn/!42-! 278:—27:3!)3123*/ !43/!Njusbop-!E/!N/-!Npufmmjfs-!T/-!Dmbwbhvfsb-!T/!'!Opxbdl-!C/!Sfwjfx!pg!obopnbufsjbm!bhjoh!boe!usbotgpsnbujpot!uispvhi!uif!mjgf! dzdmf!pg!obop.foibodfe!qspevdut/!Fowjspo/!Jou/!88-!243—258!)3126*/ !44/!DFN/!NBST!7UN!Nfuipe!Opuf!Njdspxbwf!Ejhftujpo!pg!QFU/ !45/!Hbtiuj-!N/!Q/-!Bmjnpibnnbej-!G/-!Tpoh-!H/!'!Ljvnbstj-!B/!Dibsbdufsj{bujpo!pg!obopdpnqptjuf!dpbujoht!po!ufyujmft;!B!csjfg!sfwjfx! po!njdsptdpqjd!ufdiopmphz/!Dvss/!Njdsptd/!Dpousjc/!Bew/!Tdj/!Ufdiopm/!3-!2535—2548!)3123*/ !46/!Mpsfo{-!D/!fu!bm/!Dibsbdufsj{bujpo!pg!tjmwfs!sfmfbtf!gspn!dpnnfsdjbmmz!bwbjmbcmf!gvodujpobm!)obop*!ufyujmft/!Difnptqifsf!9:-!928—935! )3123*/ !47/!Ifcfjti-!B/!fu!bm/Dbscpizes/!Qpmzn/!97-! :47—:51!)3122*/ !48/!Kptij-!N/-!Cibuubdibszzb-!B/!'!Bmj-!T/!X/!Dibsbdufsj{bujpo!Ufdiojrvft!gps!Obopufdiopmphz!Bqqmjdbujpot!jo!Ufyujmft!)Tqsjohfs-!3119*/ !49/!Sbtcboe-!X/!T/!JnbhfK/!iuuqt;00!jnbhfk/!oji/!hpw0!!)2::8*/ !4:/!Tdiofjefs-!D/!B/-!Sbtcboe-!X/!T/!'!Fmjdfjsj-!L/!X/!OJI!Jnbhf!up!JnbhfK;!36!zfbst!pg!jnbhf!bobmztjt/!Obu/!Nfuipet!:-!782—786!)3123*/ !51/!Cjpqipupo/!Jou/!22-!47—53!)3115*/ !52/!Wfsmfztfo-!F/!fu!bm/!Upxbset!b!hfofsjd!qspupdpm!gps!nfbtvsjoh!uif!dpotujuvfou!qbsujdmf!tj{f!ejtusjcvujpo!pg!F282!jo!gppe!cz!fmfduspo! njdsptdpqz/!Gppe!Dpouspm!243-!2195:3!)3133*/ !53/!Wfsmfztfo-!F/!fu!bm/!Qiztjdpdifnjdbm!dibsbdufsj{bujpo!pg!uif!qsjtujof!F282!gppe!beejujwf!cz!tuboebsej{fe!boe!wbmjebufe!nfuipet/! Obopnbufsjbmt!21-!6:3!)3131*/ Dpodfquvbmj{bujpo-!K/N/-!F/W/-!L/D/-!D/W/-!N/.O/C/-!K/W/M/<!nfuipepmphz-!F/W/-!N/M/-!L/D/-!O/X/-!K/N/-!N/.O/C-!D/W/<! gpsnbm!bobmztjt-!M/T-!N/M/-!F/W/-!T/E/W/-!G/C/-!G/W/T/-!L/D/-!S/O/-!S/N/-!N/.O/C<!ebub!dvsbujpo-!K/N/-!F/W/-!M/T/-!L/D/-! N/.O/C/-!D/W/-!K/W/M/-!O/X/<!wjtvbmj{bujpo-!F/W/-!M/T/<!tvqfswjtjpo!K/N/-!K/W/M/-!F/W/-!L/D/-!D/W/<!qspkfdu!benjojtusb. ujpo-!K/N/-!F/W/<!gvoejoh!bdrvjtjujpo!K/N/-!K/W/M/-!F/W/!Bmm!bvuipst!ibwf!sfbe!boe!bhsffe!up!uif!qvcmjtife!wfstjpo! pg!uif!nbovtdsjqu/ ! Tvqqmfnfoubsz!Jogpsnbujpo iuuqt;00!epj/!psh0! 21/!21490!t526:9.!133.!17716.x/ Dpssftqpoefodf!boe!sfrvftut!gps!nbufsjbmt!tipvme!cf!beesfttfe!up!K/N/ Sfqsjout!boe!qfsnjttjpot!jogpsnbujpo!jt!bwbjmbcmf!bu!xxx/obuvsf/dpn0sfqsjout/ Qvcmjtifs“t!opuf!Tqsjohfs!Obuvsf!sfnbjot!ofvusbm!xjui!sfhbse!up!kvsjtejdujpobm!dmbjnt!jo!qvcmjtife!nbqt!boe! | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol:.(1234567890) www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Pqfo!Bddftt! Mjdfotf-!xijdi!qfsnjut!vtf-!tibsjoh-!bebqubujpo-!ejtusjcvujpo!boe!sfqspevdujpo!jo!boz!nfejvn!ps! gpsnbu-!bt!mpoh!bt!zpv!hjwf!bqqspqsjbuf!dsfeju!up!uif!psjhjobm!bvuips)t*!boe!uif!tpvsdf-!qspwjef!b!mjol!up!uif! bsujdmf!bsf!jodmvefe!jo!uif!bsujdmf“t!Dsfbujwf!Dpnnpot!mjdfodf-!vomftt!joejdbufe!puifsxjtf!jo!b!dsfeju!mjof!up!uif! nbufsjbm/!Jg!nbufsjbm!jt!opu!jodmvefe!jo!uif!bsujdmf“t!Dsfbujwf!Dpnnpot!mjdfodf!boe!zpvs!joufoefe!vtf!jt!opu! qfsnjuufe!cz!tubuvupsz!sfhvmbujpo!ps!fydffet!uif!qfsnjuufe!vtf-!zpv!xjmm!offe!up!pcubjo!qfsnjttjpo!ejsfdumz!gspn! uif!dpqzsjhiu!ipmefs/!Up!wjfx!b!dpqz!pg!uijt!mjdfodf-!wjtju!iuuq;00!dsfbu!jwfdp!nnpot/!psh0!mjdfo!tft0!cz05/!10/ | (2022) 12:2529 | Vol.:(0123456789)