HomeMy WebLinkAbout23-143►OARD OF SUPERVISORS
AUNTY OF BUTTE, STATE OF CALIFORNIA
Resolution No. 23-143
A RESOLUTION OF THE BUTTE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AMENDING THE LAND USE MAP OF THE COUNTY'S
GENERAL PLAN FROM RURAL RESIDENTIAL TO PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT AT CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY OFF
CRANE AVENUE, 500 FEET EAST OF MELROSE DRIVE, IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF BUTTE COUNTY, ONE MILE
SOUTHEAST OF THE CITY OF OROVILLE; ASSESSOR PARCEL NUMBER 079-150-001
WHEREAS, Estom Yumeka Maidu Indians of the Enterprise Rancheria (Applicant) proposes a General Plan Amendment,
Rezone, and Development Plan (PUD21-0002) to develop twelve single-family residential dwellings, site improvements,
and access road on 64.1 acres at a certain real property off Crane Avenue, 500 feet east of Melrose Drive, in an
unincorporated area of Butte County, approximately one mile southeast of the City of Oroville; Assessor Parcel Number:
079-150-001; and
WHEREAS, the proposed General Plan Amendment encompasses the entire 64.1-acre parcel and would amend the
County's General Plan land use map from Rural Residential (RR) to Planned Unit Development (PUD); and
WHEREAS, the General Plan Amendment was filed in accordance with Butte County Code Chapter 24, Article VI, Division
5 (General Plan Amendments); and
WHEREAS, an Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration were completed for the project in compliance with the
California Environmental Quality Act and circulated for public review and comment for 30 days starting May 25, 2023,
through June 23, 2023; and
WHEREAS, said applications were referred to various affected public and private agencies, County departments, and
referral agencies for review and comments; and
WHEREAS, at a noticed public hearing on September 28, 2023, the Planning Commission recommended that the Board of
Supervisors adopt the Mitigated Negative Declaration and approve this General Plan Amendment (Resolution No. PC23-
17); and
WHEREAS, the Board of Supervisors held a duly noticed public hearing on November 7, 2023, and has considered public
comments received and a report from the Planning Division.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Butte County Board of Supervisors hereby:
Adopts the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program with the
following findings:
1. The Initial Study was completed in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act. Said Study
identified significant environmental effects and included mitigation measures to mitigate such effects
below significant levels.
2. The Board of Supervisors has considered the Mitigated Negative Declaration, together with comments
received during the review process.
3. On the basis of the whole record before the Board of Supervisors, including the environmental document
and any comments received, there is no substantial evidence that the project, with mitigations here
attached as Exhibit A, would have a significant effect on the environment. The custodian of the record is
the Department of Development Services. The location of the record is 7 County Center Drive, Oroville,
CA 95965.
4. The Mitigated Negative Declaration reflects the independent judgment and analysis of the County, which
is the Lead Agency.
II. Adopts the General Plan Amendment, as shown in Exhibit B, with the following findings in Butte County Code
Article VI, Division 5, section 24-275:
1. The proposed General Plan Amendment is in the public interest.
2. The proposed General Plan Amendment is consistent and compatible with the rest of the General Plan.
3. The potential effects of the proposed General Plan Amendment have been evaluated and have been
determined not to be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare.
4. The proposed General Plan Amendment has been processed in accordance with the applicable provisions
of the California Government Code and CEQA.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Butte County Board of Supervisors this 71h day of November 2023 by the following vote:
AYES: Supervisor Connelly, Durfee, Ritter, Teeter and Chair Kimmelshue
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
NOT VOTING: None
Tod Kimmelshue, Chair
Butte Coun Board of Supervisors
ATTEST:
Andy Pickett, Chief Administrative Officer
and Clerk of the Board of Supervisors
Deputy
EXHIBIT A
Mitigation Monitoring and
Reporting Program
Enterprise Rancheria Housing Project Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program
MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING
PROGRAM
In accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), Butte County
(County) prepared a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) that identifies adverse
impacts related to the Enterprise Rancheria Housing Project (Project). The MND also
identifies mitigation measures that would reduce or eliminate these impacts.
Section 21081.6 of the California Public Resources Code (PRC) (§ 15091(d) and 15097 of
the State CEQA Guidelines) requires public agencies "to adopt a reporting and
monitoring program for changes to the project which it has adopted or made a condition
of project approval in order to mitigate or avoid significant effects on the environment."
A mitigation monitoring and reporting program (MMRP) is required for the Project
because the MND for the project identified potentially significant adverse impacts related
to construction and implementation activities, and mitigation measures have been
identified to mitigate those impacts.
PURPOSE OF MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM
This MMRP has been prepared to ensure that all required mitigation measures are
implemented and completed according to schedule and maintained satisfactorily during
project implementation as adopted by the County, as required. The MMRP may be
modified by the County during Project implementation, as necessary, in response to
changing conditions or other refinements. The attached Mitigation Monitoring and
Reporting table has been prepared to assist the responsible parties in implementing and
documenting required mitigation measures. The table identifies individual mitigation
measures, implementation timing/schedule, responsible person/agency for
implementing the measure, implementation, and verification action, and provides space
to confirm implementation of the mitigation measures. The numbering of mitigation
measures follows the numbering sequence of the MND.
ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
Unless otherwise specified herein, the County is ultimately responsible for ensuring that
mitigation measures are implemented according to the specifications provided for each
measure and for demonstrating that the action has been successfully completed. At its
discretion, the County may delegate implementation responsibility or portions thereof to
a licensed contractor or professional. In most instances, the applicant is responsible for
funding and implementing the measures.
The County will be responsible for the overall administration of the MMRP and for
1
ENTERPRISE RANCHERIA HOUSING PROJECT MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM
verifying that County staff and/or the construction contractor has completed the
necessary actions for each measure. The County will designate a project manager to
oversee the MMRP during construction. The County project manager is responsible for
the following duties:
• Ensure that routine inspections of the project site are conducted by appropriate
County staff; check plans, reports, and other documents required by the MMRP;
and conduct report activities.
• Serve as a liaison between the County and the site manager regarding mitigation
monitoring issues.
• Complete forms and maintain reports and other records and documents generated
by the MMRP.
• Coordinate and ensure corrective actions or enforcement measures are taken, if
necessary.
MITIGATION MONITORING PLAN TABLE
The column categories identified in the MMRP table are described below:
• Mitigation Measure: This column lists the mitigation measures by number and
provides the text of the mitigation measures identified in the MND.
• Timing/Schedule: This column lists the time frame in which the mitigation will
take place.
• Implementation Responsible Party: This column identifies the party responsible
for complying with the requirements of the mitigation measure.
• Monitoring Responsible Party: This column identifies the party responsible for
verifying the implementation of mitigation actions.
• Date Completed/Name of County Staff Verifying Completion: This column is
to be dated and signed by the County project manager or their designee based on
the documentation provided by the applicant, its agents (qualified individuals),
and/or through visual inspection.
2
a
CD
0
Of
a
(D
Z
F-
w
O
a
W
ry
0
z
a
Z
Of
0
z
0
2
z
0
r
a
O
I=
U
W
0
Of
a -
CD
z
U)
Z)
0
2
a
W
x
U
z
W
d'
a-
W
z
Z
W
w
J
m
a
H
Q
z
O
a
w
z
Q
l7
z
E
O
H
Z
O
2
z
O
Q
l7
2
U
w
0
w
a
z
G
Z)
O
2
a
w
u
Z
Q
w
Ln
a
w
z
w
o
0-0
�j
•
O
u
O O
U U
y
bb u
tn
M
di°)
y tt
as
Ln
+,
G
u
d
d
cn
U)
751
u
+u
o °
c
0
0
Q
G
a) �
u
O
v
O > o >
O O
o
pp
O O
P-1
Q
"Cl
c
v
>
v
o
(U
a�, -0
b�
Ckc
v c
v
N U
V) �=
..
N
u
fC
X
o
N
oz
d. r
v Q (uv
c
a
3
v
.X
c
v
E
°
u
v
oA
3
0
�
°�' v
�_
3 v
-X
m
Q. 0
3 .c
cn
eu o U°
c v
o
u v
s'
a�
u$
°
u
�
-
,c,
° °
3
o
�
o
^ a
>
W
w°°
H
V
ul °
V
V
0 0
_
C
Qv�
•
t0
v Q
O
m 'p d �CC v
v
y
ou O
.G
cC i
,�
�O
G
O
NG
cu
a)
a)o
O
a a.oa
v
'0
i
a)CJ r
°
o o
'
.
a
.
Gl
wO
.
u
°o
4Q�
Z:�
o
O 41
cr
O
W.)
�O
a)i.
�-a
°
aHuc�.
m
U
W
0
Of
0-
0
z
I
D
0
w
x
U
z
W
d
w
z
w
4
Q
tt c
u
U L
cz v
cz
V
O
p+
S]
�
Sri
o
O O
u
cn
cu
o
3 u
o
U o
m
ca
G x.
4
U �b o
bA v°
o
r. v
o
v
} >
v }
O°
vCC
ar
p
�"
N
+, cC
m
'�
O .x
+'
m m m 3 o-
° 'm o w
e
u p
;w; `� 4
a°
a� -0w � can
� w � 3 a
.r �
'>
ai
o.
o v
v
r
¢ o oA
�. �.
cu
G
N 3
v U
w
w
u
m u
a,
v o M
u >, 4cu
•
6"
°'
X
ar
'"
N X
�?
°'
v
a
co ..
v � °
0) o �' °'
3
v°
'3
•�
o
O
CU
o> o
o
o
O
aC1
G m
+
v
0
ri
0 v
YJ
�.
cn
ai G,
'„
p
3 G
b
y G
O
v
U
3 w
° u
o
v
m°
t�
°
o p.
°
w 'J
Q. r>
o
�
O
U
v
•
G
tO
'a
w .v van-0-
(u
Gl
°
p
o v
d°
U v
m
Q-
Q".
•
G
a
O
a
c�
z
O
CL
w
0
z
a
cD
z
O
H
z
O
2
z
O
a
2
F-
L)
w
O
a
z
Z)
O
a
w
2
U
z
w
a_
Ir
w
z
w
4
G
m
o
E
•
Q
o
G
°
ca v =•
•
U•�
aJ
o
G � v
U "" o
•
S�
C
v
'U
jF v
y
G U� V
� a)
+' O
s.
0J O
vO
G
O O
is
°
N
Q a
+' + d
.�
bA
G 's.
G
a�i
ct"a U)
ai .w] G
u •�
v
a�
+� G
v
G
� u `� +,
G G v
o a)
aJ
ca
U
fN
G
a
s°
p
C
aJ u �?
W
m
•�
�, W
G G
N v
0
G 0
cu
p
U
.C�
v
p O
N
M .-
.- •�
C
N
O
N
E. G
O
+, v
U
+,
y
Q.
v ar
o m
o
s.
U
U
o
M-
U
v .0
O
r v u
d
v
G° p 'u
° a, o a) oa °
r Q
v
o o
bA
oAa,p.Q"O�
S] G
O N
aJ
N • O
Q. a)
"
°
o
U G
G W d o
0
p
O
G
pG
0(1) ^�
sG.
GO
bA +
^
) G
C8 CG
p O
p�
u B U
G
OO
v G
G
m
0 n G C O
O
(uGp
Q
° 0
p
9
v ��.
O
G
V U
C 7
m
.O
o�
-�
d°
`� v
H
o v
v
w
G
m
o
cGa
G v
`�
o d
°
V
a
o. v n u
6A
+
x°°
a1
C S]
u v
G w
a
U7
ot°D
v
v a+
o .G �.
+� pcn
v
v°
'+� W U
v
bA ,
c`c
U u
U C,
m G p.
G
° U
Q
CU7
cn
Ln
a
cD
0
w
a
c�
z
w
O
IL
w
0-1
z
O
Z
O
z
O
2
z
0
a
c�
p
2
U
w
O
a
U
z
0
g
w
2
O
z
w
S2
of
n.
w
w
H
z
w
°
'o0
°
v
o
Q
w
G
Q
O
U
,z
U .
°
°
•
CU
as
U Q
v ~
U b�
P.
o ° ° °
bra
O
v V v ,
u
v Z >
o
v
Q
C
:
bo'A ¢ p
v
m
u
G
Q o o
o
G
m
a)
�; 0
v
p
o
Q. m bA Q, . ~
Q,
u�
p v
w
m y
� v
p>
bA
CO +�
°
N M
O
v
Q
>
.� G
m M m
.
CO
bA
"
s.
bA r
N
+�
O
+ 30
Cf)4
�
+�
�
O a) 9
��-
z
v
m v >,
'�
v �
�.
a21i
u Q.~
O
_
"�r
O
,..• �. +..
O
o Off„
N
O O
O
O
V
b
ON
OO
Id
as
'G
v, it
O •.>-�
O
4: �. .�
O
Q ° vOi a1
, s. G n5
3
u>
o
U
I' 3 v v
bD N
U
Q
U O p
p -
z
•o
a
a
°�
o
+,
Z
z
v
O .y
u Z�
o
PQ
u
a)
v
pO
;z
G
:;p
GOmU)U
a,
o
O
GboU
N
a,QQ,
�
O
w
V
Ln
m .�
+O,
o O u
ar'
co
V
O
O
o
0)
3
u s
Q a1
o
v
'"
°�'
'A v> v
o
Id u
a o
o
a
°
o
" >
o
o—
o (n o
t
�w v�u�a)
>
(U
cV
n n
Q,
* %
a! aJ
O aJ
N �.
td
O
73
w~
N o
bA O
V
�, �~ .v
u
sr
O O
u
td �*'. O
'
s0 V
bA
u
�
o
a,
'o � •�
0 �
o°
.,
c 0
�
� m m
� � o
a�
�
Eel
a
c�
O
z
F-
O
a
W
w
0
z
¢
c�
z
E
0
z
O
2
z
O
c�
F-
2
O
W
O
a
c�
z
U)
D
0
W
U
zz
1.
LU
Of
d
W
F
z
W
v
v
O
cC aJ
y. a1
0)o
•d
p
O
°
O s. N w
'� >
a)
�.
aJ
U
v
ca
� m .�
cC
4!
p
> Q CZ
"
w
U.
v U
p >
w '�
,1
+ �,
w of
O
w CU
OD
O
r
o
., >
o m
N
u} d
aJ
o
o
u°
D.
m
wo o
s o
v
R .v
u
s,
y
u>
w N
O
r
a)¢
•
cr
o '�
*�
�
d
v '� o 4
r. z
v C14
m
W o a
° �,
-0°A
0
3
o w
v
a� .
+j
Ej
O
O
n >
>O cC bA
•�
.x
CZ M
O > O
•�
En
cC
"
W w r
N O M
bA • v O
p w
> n a)
'. v
7S
a1 v S]
.�
_
vO
51
._�
9 +
- 6_ v
u p
M
J n
n
°0)
.�
`) ' u v
cu t� cC Q.'
�i
w
w v
s0
C)
v
a) p
E
6<
O"
5 m Q •G
ti
U
W
O
d
CD
z
U)
Z)
O
2
Q
W
2
C)
z
W
W
F-
z
W
x a v is
v m y v o u u Tf v u o
En
CU
f—v C1 v n O 4., +n n
O O N v � •., N
W a) v o '� H(z U) u Q. o�¢ Q �cn v '� v m 'u
uN U c.r `�
a1 u bA o E" v p C
• c p r. G N C �� s ib N u n m VO
4J
ca
N M +� 5 w n � v w
.G a)o o o v'I > N
z vCa > m �' O c0. O O o u>> o v o v °� � +� v
R v o m bA +, �v 3 v m a G o o m G
as
O a G 'o R, O c0. ou O A w
Q N N N ++ +� U s•, �, w
a+
Ef
F
U
w
O
Of
0-
(D
z
U)
D
0
a
w
S
U
z
Q
w
d
w
F-
z
W
0
o
G)
��
aa�
UCl
o
0
a�
u
•O
•� N
-u
�
O
O �
�4 v
vi
v
lull)
b
v
o
3
O
'
o
O
"3
U�
, a�
3
t+G r•.
cn
p
v
%
O
v G
V
rr
N fC
Q. +
cC 7� Uui
O
¢'
°' >
x
v
v
3
o
o
o
y
w0
O 0
o
v°
v
v
.° o
O
o
m
3
v
•
'"
Q.
u m
Q C
�'
M
�
�'
)
o
cC
�
CQ
Q
C)
�-'
Y
1
p i,
Ou
r
OV :n
p M
cC
�
�
n
M
C!
N
'�
-O
•�
cn "G
N
p v O
Qch
O�W
Z
cu
-d
m
U
3 o
o�
N
ea
bA Cn
v
Q. v
' i
u
7
n 0
E-
O U")
O
J
•
•
•
U
•2
Q
0
O
CD
z
F
w
O
d
W
z
Q
C7
z_
E
O
H
z
O
2
z
O
Q
cD
H
2
F-
U
W
O
d
U
z
O
2
Q
w
U
z
w
Of
d
W
z
z
w
>.
w
O
o
•�
u
u
v v
u
w
�
u
v
N
0
w
o � O
.0
cA�
U o�xP,
z ozcn
zxu
�
a
o
°
v
6"
u
m
U
s.
�
O
G
bi
bA O
z '
>
G
m
�.
u
Q v
• O
•p N
o-Ti
O O
�' '�
N
O
'�
>�.
u
bA
>
�
cap
E o
m
ai
b�A a O
U°
3
O,)
0
>
ca
v
a,
u G
o 0
R
v
O
o v
0
v
u
j
O
v
�a),
�v,O
Oa.
O
G
bjD
>, O
�
U
pJ OU
+�>
7
�
v
CA
a)'9
O
N
N
n
?O
w
u O
�
xu
(n �.
N
�i
�-'
�.:'
u
E u
U
a) v
N
�
0)
U
0;
u U
+ >
v bA
v 9
o
b0
G
p
o
ca
p
Q m
u
o
O v
CZ
�'�
U
O O
4J N
,u
cz�
C
v N
M M U
O 4
*O'
:
(UG
a�
3°
u
o
v
v
a"lu i
o o
x
v �'
�"~°t
m"
o
c
U
O
UO
NIz
p dI
O
mO
6+ v
°u N 0
9
O
v
O
v
'(—
bA
v i�. n
C CS
u
F
V +�
u
n
.. y
o
D
(Ucedn
a, w
Lq
4
3
ri
� s� U
o
rn
Ci
r-
� r*� o
m
�rwp
O
F-
U
LLI
O
a
c�
z
O
Q
Lu
2
U
z
w
U
a
LLJ
r
z
W
r.
O
o
"
CZ CU
v
3
_ o :E�
o
v o
M
.°
p4
' aJ
u w0
a1
���.z
o0
u
U
iC
N
Ln
G n of
�
O r-14 s.
O
v
rl).�.
O
aJ r).
° b0
0
0 �'
v
aJ,
O ¢
ti °�'
u
O�
°�'
�+
° bD O O
•
o
Q
°
Q
G
bz
U
��
u
zxu
" bb
v o
v
6" u
au
u
Q)
o `z
bj 0
bD o
J
V
Q a)
b0 r~ W CU r, G v -d Ocu
C
�.
O ' Ou u Qn
m w O +
v m aJ 0 A u v
V
a,
A 0 .� y y o v o
CA
pm 3 C W
ed n CY Q � O `C° U Q
�. w r.w co v Z v �O
VN° CD�" N O OTC
cu� .� u r v v °�+ J Q
m u a C. 3cu
0 sr C
r v .O � u +J+ N M c: bD O V v
u P"
G 0
..
°V c%i m -0 -0 0
u �f u m can S
H
U
W
O
Z
O
2
Q
LU
W
2
U
Z
W
a_
of
W
H
Z
LLI
i
I
G
o
o
G
v
v .°
m
v
�
m
o
au
u
U)
v
v
'j
G
�
i
O
u
N
U
i-i
O
*'
G
C
V
O
'G
Q
�
v°
cn
v
v
v
G
O
aG� m
hG" u
cu
os
Gcvu,1-4O
4.
cn
v
~
>
p s
s r,-
ca
G
+ 7
> o N
>
o
o
Q
G
p
v •°u Q p
G
M
0
o
G
ocz
o
� v
b
y
G Q
u
•�
y
U
Opn
VfLLJ
.�'- p+
v O
as O
n
m M a)
V
U O G
Q
Q G
• N
/x
Q .� (n
7-1
¢�°
(n
�'� N
v
•Q
v
G
;
S), C
LAJ
G
m u
N
rn
cC
td
�+
N G
G c
Q
BUG
O
N
p
.�
'n J
ii v-
bO w
°
p cn
_�
'Q. N 'o
U
v
O O '�
i V
O a1 G
"''
�
'� N
U cu
Nr
C
L1
Q
U�
C
p u
c3
v
0bo
G
5bA
`m
w0
N
V-
EXHIBIT B
16
Legend
® Project Site
Parcels
Land Use Designations
GP
_ MDR
_ P
_ RC
_ ROW
RR
Butte County General Plan Land Uses
0 220 440 880 1320 1,760 2,200
Feet
Applicant: Enterprise Rancheria (Designation: RR to Planned Unit Development (PUD)
(Request: General Plan Amendment I Assessor Parcel No: 079-150-001
Supervisorial
District #1
File: PUD21-0002